AB 2878: Attorneys: State Bar: board of trustees.
- Session Year: 2015-2016
- House: Assembly
- Latest Version Date: 2016-08-31
The State Bar Act provides for the licensure and regulation of attorneys by the State Bar of California, a public corporation governed by a board of trustees. That act requires 6 members of the 19-member board to be attorneys elected from State Bar Districts. That act requires protection of the public to be the highest priority for the State Bar and the board of trustees in exercising their licensing, regulatory, and disciplinary functions and requires protection of the public to be paramount whenever the protection of the public is inconsistent with any other interest sought to be promoted. That act provides that the State Bar is subject to the Bagley-Keene Open Meeting Act and the California Public Records Act, as specified. That act, until January 1, 2017, requires the board to charge an annual membership fee for active members of up to $315 for 2016. The act requires the board of trustees to elect or select the president, vice president, and treasurer of the State Bar, as specified. Existing law prohibits the Legislature, when the board of trustees places a charge upon or otherwise makes available all or any portion of the income or revenue from membership fees for the payment of security of an obligation of the State Bar and so long as any obligation remains unpaid, from reducing the maximum membership fee below the maximum in effect at the time the obligation is created or incurred and provides that this provision constitutes a covenant to the holder of such an obligation. The act requires the board of trustees to contract with the California State Auditors Office to conduct a performance audit of the State Bars operations, as specified. That act establishes the State Bar Court to act in the place of the board of trustees in the determination of disciplinary proceedings, as specified. That act requires the board to appoint a lawyer admitted to practice in California to serve as chief trial counsel, as specified. That act authorizes the State Bar to raise additional revenue by any lawful means, including, but not limited to, the creation of foundations or not-for-profit corporations. That act requires the board to establish and administer a Client Security Fund to relieve or mitigate pecuniary losses caused by dishonest conduct of active members of the State Bar, as specified.
This bill would provide that the board of trustees consist of no more than 19 members and no fewer than 13 members and would require the board to transition to a 13-member board, as specified. The bill would remove from the board attorney members elected from State Bar Districts and would make conforming changes. The bill would provide that each appointing body, when making appointments to the board after December 31, 2016, should consider appointing members who have education or experience, or both, in one of 6 specified areas, including public finance. The bill would require that a maximum of 6 members of the board be public members, as appointed by specified entities, and would require members of the board to serve a term of 4 years. The bill would require the California Supreme Court to select from the members of the board a chair and vice chair instead of the board of trustees electing a president and vice president. The bill would require members of the executive committee of the board to include at least one member of the board appointed by each appointing authority.
This bill would provide that protection of the public requires that professional legal services are provided in a competent, accessible, and ethical manner, and that the judicial system functions in a fair, impartial, and just manner. The bill would define protection of the public, for purposes of staffing and resource allocations, as specified core functions of the State Bar, including, administration of the bar admissions and law school accreditation processes. The bill would provide that any decision of the board raising antitrust concerns is subject to review, modification, veto, or other appropriate action by the California Supreme Court.
The bill would require the Office of Chief Trial Counsel to open a nonattorney complaint against a person when the office becomes aware of an allegation that a person not licensed to practice law in California has practiced or held himself or herself out as practicing law or entitled to practice law in the state and would require the complaint to be evaluated and processed, as specified.
This bill would require the Attorney General to appoint a State Bar enforcement program monitor prior to March 31, 2017, and would require the program enforcement monitor to evaluate the disciplinary system and procedures of the State Bar, as specified. The bill would require the program enforcement monitor to submit an initial report no later than October 1, 2019, and to issue a final report before March 31, 2020. The bill would make these provisions inoperative on March 31, 2020, and would repeal the provision as of January 1, 2021.
The bill would require the board of trustees to engage the services of an independent national or regional public accounting firm with at least 5 years of experience in governmental auditing for an audit of its revenues, expenditures, reserves, and financial statements for each fiscal year and would require the California State Auditor, for the performance audit due in January 2017, to review all of the State Bars expenses, including, but not limited to, executive salaries. The bill would also require California State Auditor to conduct a performance audit evaluating the State Bars progress in certain areas, including correcting any issues raised in prior California State Auditor audits, and would require the California State Auditor to report its findings and recommendations, as specified.
This bill would provide that access to records of the State Bar Court is subject to the rules and laws applicable to the judiciary instead of the California Public Records Act and would exempt the State Bar Court from the Bagley-Keene Open Meeting Act.
This bill, until January 1, 2018, would require the board to charge an annual membership fee in a specified amount for 2017. The bill would repeal the provision prohibiting the Legislature from reducing the maximum membership fee and would prohibit the State Bar from creating any foundation or nonprofit corporations, as specified. The bill would require the State Bar to conduct a thorough analysis of the Client Security Fund and to submit a report to the Legislature on its analysis of that fund by March 15, 2017, as specified.
Existing constitutional provisions require that a statute that limits the right of access to the meetings of public bodies or the writings of public officials and agencies be adopted with findings demonstrating the interest protected by the limitation and the need for protecting that interest.
This bill would make legislative findings to that effect.
The State Bar Act provides for the licensure and regulation of attorneys by the State Bar of California, a public corporation governed by a board of trustees. That act requires 6 members of the 19-member board to be attorneys elected from State Bar Districts. That act requires protection of the public to be the highest priority for the State Bar and the board of trustees in exercising their licensing, regulatory, and disciplinary functions and requires protection of the public to be paramount whenever the protection of the public is inconsistent with any other interest sought to be promoted. That act provides that the State Bar is subject to the Bagley-Keene Open Meeting Act and the California Public Records Act, as specified. That act, until January 1, 2017, requires the board to charge an annual membership fee for active members of up to $315 for 2016. The act requires the board of trustees to elect or select the president, vice president, and treasurer of the State Bar, as specified. Existing law prohibits the Legislature, when the board of trustees places a charge upon or otherwise makes available all or any portion of the income or revenue from membership fees for the payment of security of an obligation of the State Bar and so long as any obligation remains unpaid, from reducing the maximum membership fee below the maximum in effect at the time the obligation is created or incurred and provides that this provision constitutes a covenant to the holder of such an obligation. The act requires the board of trustees to contract with the California State Auditors Office to conduct a performance audit of the State Bars operations, as specified. That act establishes the State Bar Court to act in the place of the board of trustees in the determination of disciplinary proceedings, as specified. That act requires the board to appoint a lawyer admitted to practice in California to serve as chief trial counsel, as specified. That act authorizes the State Bar to raise additional revenue by any lawful means, including, but not limited to, the creation of foundations or not-for-profit corporations. That act requires the board to establish and administer a Client Security Fund to relieve or mitigate pecuniary losses caused by dishonest conduct of active members of the State Bar, as specified.
This bill would provide that the board of trustees consist of no more than 19 members and no fewer than 13 members and would require the board to transition to a 13-member board, as specified. The bill would remove from the board attorney members elected from State Bar Districts and would make conforming changes. The bill would require provide that each member of appointing body, when making appointments to the board appointed after December 31, 2016, to should consider appointing members who have demonstrated educational or experience expertise, education or experience, or both, in one of 5 6 specified areas, including public finance. The bill would require that a minimum of 7 maximum of 6 members of the board be public members, as appointed by specified entities, and would provide that no motion of the board can be approved unless a majority of the public members approve the motion. require members of the board to serve a term of 4 years. The bill would require the Supreme Court to select from its appointed members a president and vice president of the State Bar the members of the board a chair and vice chair instead of the board of trustees electing a president and vice president. The bill would require members of the executive committee of the board to include at least one member of the board appointed by each appointing authority.
This bill would provide that protection of the public requires that professional legal services are provided in a competent, accessible, and ethical manner, and that the judicial system functions in a fair, impartial, and just manner. The bill would define protection of the public, for purposes of staffing and resource allocations, as specified core functions of the State Bar, including, administration of the bar admissions and law school accreditation processes. The bill would provide that any decision of the board raising antitrust concerns is subject to review, modification, veto, or other appropriate action by the California Supreme Court.
The bill would require the Office of Chief Trial Counsel to open a nonattorney complaint against a person when the office becomes aware of an allegation that a person not licensed to practice law in California has practiced or held himself or herself out as practicing law or entitled to practice law in the state and would require the complaint to be evaluated and processed, as specified.
This bill would create the California State Bar Governance Commission and would provide that it consists of 9 members to be appointed as specified. The bill would require the commission to evaluate all issues of governance of the State Bar, including, but not limited to, a full review of other states with attorney regulatory structures that are different than the State Bar, in order to recommend the best governance structure for the State Bar and to ensure that protection of the public is the highest priority of the State Bar in its regulatory duties. The bill would require the commission to provide a report to the Governor, the Chief Justice of the California Supreme Court, and the Senate and Assembly Committees on Judiciary by April 30, 2017. The bill would repeal these provisions as of January 1, 2018.
This bill would require the Chief Justice of the California Supreme Court Attorney General to appoint a State Bar enforcement program monitor prior to March 31, 2017, and would require the program enforcement monitor to evaluate the disciplinary system and procedures of the State Bar, as specified. The bill would require the program enforcement monitor to submit an initial report no later than October 1, 2019, and to issue a final report before March 31, 2020. The bill would make these provisions inoperative on March 31, 2020, and would repeal the provision as of January 1, 2021.
The bill would require the board of trustees to contract with the California State Auditors Office engage the services of an independent national or regional public accounting firm with at least 5 years of experience in governmental auditing for an audit of its revenues, expenditures, reserves, and its financial statements for each fiscal year and would require the California State Auditor, for the performance audit due in January 2017, to review all of the State Bars expenses, including, but not limited to, executive salaries. The bill would also require California State Auditor to conduct a performance audit evaluating the State Bars progress in certain areas, including correcting any issues raised in prior California State Auditor audits, and would require the California State Auditor to report its findings and recommendations, as specified.
This bill would provide that access to records of the State Bar Court is subject to the rules and laws applicable to the judiciary instead of the California Public Records Act and would exempt the State Bar Court from the Bagley-Keene Open Meeting Act.
This bill, until January 1, 2018, would require the board to charge an annual membership fee in a specified amount for 2017. The bill would repeal the provision prohibiting the Legislature from reducing the maximum membership fee and the provision authorizing the State Bar to raise additional revenue by any lawful means. The bill would specify that the State Bar is empowered to raise additional revenue by any lawful means and would prohibit the State Bar from creating any foundation or nonprofit corporations, as specified. The bill would require the State Bar to conduct a thorough analysis of the Client Security Fund and to submit a report to the Legislature on its analysis of that fund by March 15, 2017, as specified. The bill would state various findings and declarations of the Legislature.
Existing constitutional provisions require that a statute that limits the right of access to the meetings of public bodies or the writings of public officials and agencies be adopted with findings demonstrating the interest protected by the limitation and the need for protecting that interest.
This bill would make legislative findings to that effect.
The State Bar Act provides for the licensure and regulation of attorneys by the State Bar of California, a public corporation governed by a board of trustees. That act requires 6 members of the 19-member board to be attorneys elected from State Bar Districts. That act provides that the State Bar is subject to the Bagley-Keene Open Meeting Act and the California Public Records Act, as specified. That act, until January 1, 2017, requires the board to charge an annual membership fee for active members of up to $315 for 2016. The act requires the board of trustees to elect or select the president, vice president, and treasurer of the State Bar, as specified. Existing law prohibits the Legislature, when the board of trustees places a charge upon or otherwise makes available all or any portion of the income or revenue from membership fees for the payment of security of an obligation of the State Bar and so long as any obligation remains unpaid, from reducing the maximum membership fee below the maximum in effect at the time the obligation is created or incurred and provides that this provision constitutes a covenant to the holder of such an obligation. The act requires the board of trustees to contract with the California State Auditors Office to conduct a performance audit of the State Bars operations, as specified. That act establishes the State Bar Court to act in the place of the board of trustees in the determination of disciplinary proceedings, as specified. That act authorizes the State Bar to raise additional revenue by any lawful means, including, but not limited to, the creation of foundations or not-for-profit corporations. That act requires the board to establish and administer a Client Security Fund to relieve or mitigate pecuniary losses caused by dishonest conduct of active members of the State Bar, as specified.
This bill would provide that the board of trustees consist of no more than 19 members and no fewer than 13 members and would require the board to transition to a 13-member board, as specified. The bill would remove from the board attorney members elected from State Bar Districts and would make conforming changes. The bill would require each member of the board appointed after December 31, 2016, to have demonstrated educational or experience expertise, or both, in one of 5 specified areas, including public finance. This The bill would require that a minimum of 7 members of the board be public members, as appointed by specified entities, and would provide that no motion of the board can be approved unless a majority of the public members approve the motion. The bill would require the Supreme Court to select from its appointed members a president and vice president of the State Bar instead of the board of trustees electing a president and vice president.
This bill would create the California State Bar Governance Commission and would provide that it consists of 9 members to be appointed as specified. The bill would require the commission to evaluate all issues of governance of the State Bar, including, but not limited to, a full review of other states with attorney regulatory structures that are different than the State Bar, in order to recommend the best governance structure for the State Bar and to ensure that protection of the public is the highest priority of the State Bar in its regulatory duties. The bill would require the commission to provide a report to the Governor, the Chief Justice of the California Supreme Court, and the Senate and Assembly Committees on Judiciary by April 30, 2017. The bill would repeal these provisions as of January 1, 2018.
This bill would require the Chief Justice of the California Supreme Court to appoint a State Bar enforcement program monitor prior to March 31, 2017, and would require the program enforcement monitor to evaluate the disciplinary system and procedures of the State Bar, as specified. The bill would require the program enforcement monitor to submit an initial report no later than October 1, 2019, and to issue a final report before March 31, 2020. The bill would make these provisions inoperative on March 31, 2020, and would repeal the provision as of January 1, 2021.
The bill would require the board of trustees to contract with the California State Auditors Office for an audit of its revenues, expenditures, reserves, and its financial statements for each fiscal year and would require the California State Auditor, for the performance audit due in January 2017, to review all of the State Bars expenses, including, but not limited to, executive salaries.
This bill would provide that access to records of the State Bar Court is subject to the rules and laws applicable to the judiciary instead of the California Public Records Act and would exempt the State Bar Court from the Bagley-Keene Open Meeting Act.
This bill, until January 1, 2018, would require the board to charge an annual membership fee in a specified amount for 2017. The bill would repeal the provision prohibiting the Legislature from reducing the maximum membership fee and the provision authorizing the State Bar to raise additional revenue by any lawful means. The bill would specify that the State Bar is empowered to raise additional revenue by any lawful means and would prohibit the State Bar from creating any foundation or nonprofit corporations, as specified. The bill would require the State Bar to conduct a thorough analysis of the Client Security Fund and to submit a report to the Legislature on its analysis of that fund by March 15, 2017, as specified. The bill would state various findings and declarations of the Legislature.
Existing constitutional provisions require that a statute that limits the right of access to the meetings of public bodies or the writings of public officials and agencies be adopted with findings demonstrating the interest protected by the limitation and the need for protecting that interest.
This bill would make legislative findings to that effect.
The State Bar Act provides for the licensure and regulation of attorneys by the State Bar of California, a public corporation governed by a board of trustees. Existing law, That act requires 6 members of the 19-member board to be attorneys elected from State Bar Districts. That act provides that the State Bar is subject to the Bagley-Keene Open Meeting Act and the California Public Records Act, as specified. That act, until January 1, 2017, requires the board to charge an annual membership fee for active members of up to $315 for 2016. Existing law prohibits the Legislature, when the board of trustees places a charge upon or otherwise makes available all or any portion of the income or revenue from membership fees for the payment of security of an obligation of the State Bar and so long as any obligation remains unpaid, from reducing the maximum membership fee below the maximum in effect at the time the obligation is created or incurred and provides that this provision constitutes a covenant to the holder of such an obligation. That act establishes the State Bar Court to act in the place of the board of trustees in the determination of disciplinary proceedings, as specified. That act authorizes the State Bar to raise additional revenue by any lawful means, including, but not limited to, the creation of foundations or not-for-profit corporations. That act requires the board to establish and administer a Client Security Fund to relieve or mitigate pecuniary losses caused by dishonest conduct of active members of the State Bar, as specified.
This bill would provide that the board of trustees consist of no more than 19 members and no fewer than 13 members and would require the board to transition to a 13-member board, as specified. The bill would remove from the board attorney members elected from State Bar Districts and would make conforming changes. The bill would require each member of the board appointed after December 31, 2016, to have demonstrated educational or experience expertise, or both, in one of 5 specified areas, including public finance. This bill would provide that access to records of the State Bar Court is subject to the rules and laws applicable to the judiciary instead of the California Public Records Act and would exempt the State Bar Court from the Bagley-Keene Open Meeting Act.
This bill would, bill, until January 1, 2018, would require the board to charge an annual membership fee in the same a specified amount for 2017. The bill would repeal the above provision prohibiting the Legislature from reducing the maximum membership fee and the provision authorizing the State Bar to raise additional revenue by any lawful means. The bill would require the State Bar to conduct a thorough analysis of the Client Security Fund and to submit a report to the Legislature on its analysis of that fund by March 15, 2017, as specified. The bill would state various findings and declarations of the Legislature.
Existing constitutional provisions require that a statute that limits the right of access to the meetings of public bodies or the writings of public officials and agencies be adopted with findings demonstrating the interest protected by the limitation and the need for protecting that interest.
This bill would make legislative findings to that effect.
The State Bar Act provides for the licensure and regulation of attorneys by the State Bar of California, a public corporation governed by a board of trustees. Existing law, until January 1, 2017, requires the board to charge an annual membership fee for active members of up to $315 for 2016. Existing law prohibits the Legislature, when the board of trustees places a charge upon or otherwise makes available all or any portion of the income or revenue from membership fees for the payment of security of an obligation of the State Bar and so long as any obligation remains unpaid, from reducing the maximum membership fee below the maximum in effect at the time the obligation is created or incurred and provides that this provision constitutes a covenant to the holder of such an obligation.
This bill would, until January 1, 2018, require the board to charge an annual membership fee in the same amount for 2017. The bill would repeal the above provision prohibiting the Legislature from reducing the maximum membership fee and would state various findings and declarations of the Legislature.
The State Bar Act provides for the licensure and regulation of attorneys by the State Bar of California, a public corporation governed by a board of trustees. Existing law, until January 1, 2017, requires the board to charge an annual membership fee for active members of up to $315 for 2016.
This bill would, until January 1, 2018, require the board to charge an annual membership fee in the same amount for 2017.
The State Bar of California is a public corporation. It is hereinafter designated as the State Bar.
The State Bar has perpetual succession and a seal and it may sue and be sued. It may, for the purpose of carrying into effect and promoting its objectives:
(a)Make contracts.
(b)Borrow money, contract debts, issue bonds, notes, and debentures and secure the payment or performance of its obligations.
(c)Own, hold, use, manage, and deal in and with real and personal property.
(d)Construct, alter, maintain, and repair buildings and other improvements to real property.
(e)Purchase, lease, obtain options upon, acquire by gift, bequest, devise, or otherwise, any real or personal property or any interest therein.
(f)Sell, lease, exchange, convey, transfer, assign, encumber, pledge, dispose of any of its real or personal property or any interest therein, including without limitation all or any portion of its income or revenues from membership fees paid or payable by members.
(g)Do all other acts incidental to the foregoing or necessary or expedient for the administration of its affairs and the attainment of its purposes.
Pursuant to those powers enumerated in subdivisions (a) to (g), inclusive, it is recognized that the State Bar has authority to raise revenue in addition to that provided for in Section 6140 and other statutory provisions. The State Bar is empowered to raise that additional revenue by any lawful means. However, as of December 31, 2016, the State Bar shall not create any foundations or nonprofit corporations.
The State Bar shall conspicuously publicize to its members in the annual dues statement and other appropriate communications, including its Web site and electronic communications, that its members have the right to limit the sale or disclosure of member information not reasonably related to regulatory purposes. In those communications the State Bar shall note the location of the State Bars privacy policy, and shall also note the simple procedure by which a member may exercise his or her right to prohibit or restrict, at the members option, the sale or disclosure of member information not reasonably related to regulatory purposes. On or before May 1, 2005, the State Bar shall report to the Assembly and Senate Committees on Judiciary regarding the procedures that it has in place to ensure that members can appropriately limit the use of their member information not reasonably related to regulatory purposes, and the number of members choosing to utilize these procedures.
No law of this state restricting, or prescribing a mode of procedure for the exercise of powers of state public bodies or state agencies, or classes thereof, including, but not by way of limitation, the provisions contained in Division 3 (commencing with Section 11000), Division 4 (commencing with Section 16100), and Part 1 (commencing with Section 18000) and Part 2 (commencing with Section 18500) of Division 5, of Title 2 of the Government Code, shall be applicable to the State Bar, unless the Legislature expressly so declares. Notwithstanding the foregoing or any other law, pursuant to Sections 6026.7 and 6026.11, the State Bar is subject to the California Public Records Act (Chapter 3.5 (commencing with Section 6250) of Division 7 of Title 1 of the Government Code) and, commencing April 1, 2016, the Bagley-Keene Open Meeting Act (Article 9 (commencing with Section 11120) of Chapter 1 of Part 1 of Division 3 of Title 2 of the Government Code).
SEC. 2.Section 6001.1 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:6001.1.(a)Protection of the public shall be the highest priority for the State Bar of California and the board of trustees in exercising their licensing, regulatory, and disciplinary functions. Whenever the protection of the public is inconsistent with other interests sought to be promoted, the protection of the public shall be paramount.
(b)Protection of the public requires that professional legal services are provided in a competent, accessible, and ethical manner and that the judicial system functions in a fair, impartial, and just manner. For purposes of staffing and resource allocations, protection of the public is defined as the following core functions of the State Bar in the following order of priority:
(1)Administration of the bar admissions and law school accreditation processes, recordkeeping and licensing functions, and the lawyer discipline system.
(2)Administration of programs that advance professional competence and ethics, support the prevention of discipline problems before they occur, address the unlawful practice of law, and support the judicial selection process.
(3)Administration of programs that support the fair and equal administration of justice, effective functioning of the legal system, and diversity of the profession.
SEC. 3.SEC. 2.Section 6008.5 of the Business and Professions Code is repealed.SEC. 3.Section 6008.6 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:6008.6.(a)The State Bar shall award no contract for goods, services, or both, for an aggregate amount in excess of fifty thousand dollars ($50,000), or for information technology goods, services, or both, for an aggregate amount in excess of one hundred thousand dollars ($100,000), except pursuant to the standards established in Article 4 (commencing with Section 10335) of Chapter 2 of Part 2 of Division 2 of the Public Contract Code. Code and approval of the board of trustees. The State Bar shall establish a request for proposal procedure by rule, pursuant to the general standards established in Article 4 (commencing with Section 10335) of Chapter 2 of Part 2 of Division 2 of the Public Contract Code. For the purposes of this section, information technology includes, but is not limited to, all electronic technology systems and services, automated information handling, system design and analysis, conversion voice, video, and data communications, network systems, requisite facilities, equipment, system controls, stimulation, electronic commerce, and all related interactions between people and machines.
(b)The board of trustees shall adopt policies and procedures to require board approval of any contract that could impact the State Bars ability to carry out its paramount duty to protect the public.
SEC. 4.Section 6009.7 of the Business and Professions Code is repealed.SEC. 5.Section 6011 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:6011.(a)The board shall consist of no more than 19 members and no fewer than 13 members.
(b)It is the intent of the Legislature that the board consist of no more than 19 members and no fewer than 13 members during the period of transition from a 19-member board to a 13-member board. It is the intent of the Legislature that the board decrease its size without shortening, lengthening, or abolishing terms commencing prior to December 31, 2016, with the ultimate goal of instituting a 13-member board no later than October 31, 2019. It is the intent of the Legislature that this transition occur by the expiration of the terms of the elected members who are serving on the board as of December 31, 2016.
(c)When making appointments to the board on and after December 31, 2016, each appointing body should consider appointing members with education or experience, or both, in at least one of the following:
(1)Public finance.
(2)Public administration.
(3)Business or financial management.
(4)State government, particularly prior regulatory experience.
(5)Legal ethics.
(6)Immigration law.
SEC. 6.Section 6012 of the Business and Professions Code is repealed.SEC. 7.Section 6013.1 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:6013.1.(a)The Supreme Court shall appoint five attorney members of the board pursuant to a process that the Supreme Court may prescribe. These attorney members shall serve for a term of four years and may be reappointed by the Supreme Court for one additional term only.
(b)An attorney member elected pursuant to Section 6013.2 may be appointed by the Supreme Court pursuant to this section to a term as an appointed attorney member.
(c)The Supreme Court shall fill any vacancy in the term of, and make any reappointment of, any appointed attorney member.
(d)When making appointments to the board, the Supreme Court should consider appointing attorneys that represent the following categories: legal services; small firm or solo practitioners; historically underrepresented groups, including consideration of race, ethnicity, gender, and sexual orientation; and legal academics. In making appointments to the board, the Supreme Court should also consider geographic distribution, years of practice, particularly attorneys who are within the first five years of practice or 36 years of age and under, and participation in voluntary local or state bar activities.
(e)The State Bar shall be responsible for carrying out the administrative responsibilities related to the appointment process described in subdivision (a).
SEC. 8.Section 6013.2 of the Business and Professions Code is repealed.SEC. 9.Section 6013.3 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:6013.3.(a)One attorney member of the board shall be appointed by the Senate Committee on Rules and one attorney member of the board shall be appointed by the Speaker of the Assembly.
(b)An attorney member appointed pursuant to this section shall serve for a term of four years. Vacancies shall be filled for the remainder of the term. An appointed attorney member may be reappointed pursuant to this section.
SEC. 10.Section 6013.5 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:6013.5.(a)Effective January 1, 2017, a maximum of six members of the board shall be members of the public who have never been members of the State Bar or admitted to practice before any court in the United States.
(b)Each of these members shall serve for a term of four years. Vacancies shall be filled for the remainder of the term.
(c)Effective January 1, 2017, one public member shall be appointed by the Senate Committee on Rules and one public member shall be appointed by the Speaker of the Assembly.
(d)Four public members shall be appointed by the Governor, subject to the confirmation of the Senate.
(e)Each respective appointing authority shall fill any vacancy in and make any reappointment to each respective office.
SEC. 11.Section 6015 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:6015.No person is eligible for attorney membership on the board unless both of the following conditions are satisfied:
(a)He or she is an active member of the State Bar.
(b)Either:
(1)Prior to October 31, 2019, if elected, he or she maintains his or her principal office for the practice of law within the State Bar district from which he or she is elected.
(2)If appointed by the Supreme Court or the Legislature, he or she maintains his or her principal office for the practice of law within the State of California.
SEC. 12.Section 6016 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:6016.The term of office of each attorney member of the board shall be four years and he or she shall hold office until his or her successor is appointed and qualified. Vacancies shall be filled for the remainder of the term.
The board of trustees may provide by rule for an interim board to act in the place and stead of the board when because of vacancies during terms of office there is less than a quorum of the board.
SEC. 13.Section 6018 of the Business and Professions Code is repealed.SEC. 14.Section 6019 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:6019.Each place upon the board for which a member is to be appointed shall for the purposes of the appointment be deemed a separate office.
SEC. 15.Section 6021 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:6021.(a)(1)The California Supreme Court shall select from the members of the board a chair and a vice chair to serve in the absence of the chair.
(2)The chair and vice chair shall assume the duties of their respective offices at the conclusion of the annual meeting following their appointment.
(b)The term of the board chair and vice chair shall be one year.
SEC. 16.Section 6022 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:6022.The secretary and treasurer of the State Bar shall be selected annually by the board and need not be members of the State Bar.
SEC. 17.Section 6026.5 of the Business and Professions Code, as added by Section 3 of Chapter 537 of the Statutes of 2015, is repealed.SEC. 18.Section 6026.7 of the Business and Professions Code, as added by Section 5 of Chapter 537 of the Statutes of 2015, is amended to read:6026.7.(a)The State Bar is subject to the Bagley-Keene Open Meeting Act (Article 9 (commencing with Section 11120) of Chapter 1 of Part 1 of Division 3 of Title 2 of the Government Code) and all meetings of the State Bar are subject to the Bagley-Keene Open Meeting Act.
(b)Notwithstanding any other law, the Bagley-Keene Open Meeting Act shall not apply to the Judicial Nominees Evaluation Commission, the Committee of Bar Examiners, or the State Bar Court.
(c)In addition to the grounds authorized in the Bagley-Keene Open Meeting Act, a closed session may be held for those meetings, or portions thereof, relating to both of the following:
(1)Appeals from decisions of the Board of Legal Specialization refusing to certify or recertify an applicant or suspending or revoking a specialists certificate.
(2)The preparation, approval, grading, or administration of examinations for certification of a specialist.
SEC. 19.Section 6029 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:6029.(a)The board may appoint such committees, officers and employees as it deems necessary or proper, and fix and pay salaries and necessary expenses.
(b)The members of the executive committee of the board shall include at least one board member appointed by each of the following appointing authorities:
(1)The Supreme Court.
(2)The Governor.
(3)The Speaker of the Assembly.
(4)The Senate Committee on Rules.
SEC. 20.Section 6030 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:6030.(a)The board shall be charged with the executive function of the State Bar and the enforcement of the provisions of this chapter.
(b)The violation or threatened violation of any provision of Articles 7 (commencing with Section 6125) and 9 (commencing with Section 6150) of this chapter may be enjoined in a civil action brought in the superior court by the State Bar and no undertaking shall be required of the State Bar.
(c)Any decision of the board raising antitrust concerns is subject to review, modification, veto, or other appropriate action by the California Supreme Court.
SEC. 21.Section 6060.2 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:6060.2.(a)All investigations or proceedings conducted by the State Bar concerning the moral character of an applicant shall be confidential and shall not be disclosed pursuant to any state law, including, but not limited to, the California Public Records Act (Chapter 3.5 (commencing with Section 6250) of Division 7 of Title 1 of the Government Code) unless the applicant, in writing, waives the confidentiality.
(b)Notwithstanding subdivision (a), the records of the proceeding may be disclosed in response to either of the following:
(1)A lawfully issued subpoena.
(2)A written request from a government agency responsible for either the enforcement of civil or criminal laws or the professional licensing of individuals that is conducting an investigation about the applicant.
SEC. 22.Section 6060.25 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:6060.25.(a)Notwithstanding any other law, any identifying information submitted by an applicant to the State Bar for admission and a license to practice law and all State Bar admission records, including, but not limited to, bar examination scores, law school grade point average (GPA), undergraduate GPA, Law School Admission Test scores, race or ethnicity, and any information contained within the State Bar Admissions database or any file or other data created by the State Bar with information submitted by the applicant that may identify an individual applicant, other than information described in subdivision (b), shall be confidential and shall not be disclosed pursuant to any state law, including, but not limited to, the California Public Records Act (Chapter 3.5 (commencing with Section 6250) of Division 7 of Title 1 of the Government Code).
(b)(1)This section does not prohibit the disclosure of any of the following:
(A)The names of applicants who have passed any examination administered, given, or prescribed by the Committee of Bar Examiners.
(B)Information that is provided at the request of an applicant to another jurisdiction where the applicant is seeking admission to the practice of law.
(C)Information provided to a law school that is necessary for the purpose of the law schools compliance with accreditation or regulatory requirements.
(D)Information provided to the National Conference of Bar Examiners or a successor nonprofit organization in connection to the State Bars administration of any examination.
(2)This subdivision shall apply retroactively to January 1, 2016.
(c)Disclosure of any of the information in subparagraphs (B) to (D), inclusive, of paragraph (1) of subdivision (b) shall not constitute a waiver under Section 6254.5 of the Government Code of the exemption from disclosure provided for in subdivision (a) of this section.
SEC. 23.Section 6075.6 is added to the Business and Professions Code, to read:6075.6.(a)(1)The Attorney General shall appoint a State Bar enforcement program monitor prior to March 31, 2017. The applicant for the position shall have investigative experience, shall be familiar with California laws and procedures, and, preferably, shall be familiar with the rules and procedures of the State Bar lawyer discipline system and relevant administrative procedures. The monitor may be a state employee or his or her services may be provided pursuant to contract.
(2)The Attorney General shall supervise the monitor and may terminate or dismiss him or her from this position.
(b)(1)The enforcement program monitor shall monitor and evaluate the disciplinary system and procedures of the State Bar. The enforcement program monitor shall make his or her highest priority the reform and reengineering of the State Bars enforcement program and operations and the improvement of the overall efficiency of the State Bars disciplinary system so that the State Bar is successfully and consistently protecting the public.
(2)This monitoring duty shall include, but not be limited to, the prioritization of cases most impacting public protection, improving the timeframe for the handling of complaints and in the rendering of initial decisions on complaints, the efficiency of the system, the fairness and courtesy given to complainants, the adequacy of the staffing and the budget allocated to the discipline section of the State Bar, the reduction of the complaint backlog, the consistency in the application of sanctions or discipline imposed, the implementation of laws affecting discipline and the State Bars operations, disciplinary standards and rules, staff concerns regarding disciplinary matters or procedures, and the State Bars cooperation with other governmental entities charged with enforcing related laws and regulations that affect members of the State Bar.
(3)The monitor shall exercise no authority over the State Bars discipline operations or staff, however, the State Bar and its staff shall cooperate with the program enforcement monitor, and the State Bar shall provide data, information, and case files as requested by the enforcement program monitor to perform all of his or her duties.
(c)The enforcement program monitor shall submit an initial written report of his or her findings and conclusions to the State Bar, the California Supreme Court, and the Legislature no later than October 1, 2019, and be available to make oral reports to each if requested to do so. The initial report shall include an analysis of the sources of information that resulted in each disciplinary action imposed since January 1, 2016. The monitor may also provide additional information to either the California Supreme Court, the State Bar, or the Legislature at his or her discretion or at the request of the California Supreme Court, the State Bar, or the Legislature. The program enforcement monitor shall make his or her reports available to the public or the media. The monitor shall make every effort to provide the State Bar with an opportunity to reply to any facts, findings, issues, or conclusions in his or her reports with which the State Bar may disagree.
(d)The enforcement program monitor shall issue a final report prior to March 31, 2020.
(e)This section shall become inoperative on March 31, 2020, and as of January 1, 2021, shall be repealed.
SEC. 24.Section 6086.5 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:6086.5.The board of trustees shall establish a State Bar Court, to act in its place and stead in the determination of disciplinary and reinstatement proceedings and proceedings pursuant to subdivisions (b) and (c) of Section 6007 to the extent provided by rules adopted by the board of trustees pursuant to this chapter. In these proceedings the State Bar Court may exercise the powers and authority vested in the board of trustees by this chapter, including those powers and that authority vested in committees of, or established by, the board, except as limited by rules of the board of trustees within the scope of this chapter.
Access to records of the State Bar Court shall be governed by court rules and laws applicable to records of the judiciary and not the California Public Records Act (Chapter 3.5 (commencing with Section 6250) of Division 7 of Title 1 of the Government Code).
For the purposes of Sections 6007, 6043, 6049, 6049.2, 6050, 6051, 6052, 6077 (excluding the first sentence), 6078, 6080, 6081, and 6082, board includes the State Bar Court.
Nothing in this section shall authorize the State Bar Court to adopt rules of professional conduct or rules of procedure.
The Executive Committee of the State Bar Court may adopt rules of practice for the conduct of all proceedings within its jurisdiction. These rules may not conflict with the rules of procedure adopted by the board, unless approved by the California Supreme Court.
SEC. 25.Section 6134 is added to the Business and Professions Code, to read:6134.(a)When the Office of the Chief Trial Counsel becomes aware of an allegation that a person not licensed to practice law in California has practiced or held himself or herself out as practicing law or entitled to practice law in the state, the offices intake unit shall open a nonattorney complaint against that person for evaluation and processing.
(b)The intake unit shall open a case record in the offices case management system with the complaint form received date. The complaint form received date shall be the date the State Bar first received the complaint. Evaluation and processing of the nonattorney complaint shall include, but not be limited to, all of the following:
(1)Creation of a summary of the allegation or allegations in the case record and assignment to staff, including inputting staff assignment codes into the case management system.
(2)Identifying the source of the complaint.
(3)Identifying the relevant practice area of law, such as immigration, loan modification, or debt resolution, and recording the relevant practice area of law in the case record.
(4)Identifying whether the allegations include potential identity theft of a licensed attorneys identity and, if so, contacting the potential victim attorney to verify whether the attorney is aware of the potential identify theft and whether he or she has notified law enforcement.
(5)Evaluating the nonattorney complaint for unauthorized practice of law allegations, which includes opening a corresponding attorney complaint case record, if appropriate, such as in the case in which the nonattorney complaint also identifies a licensed California attorney potentially aiding or abetting the person in the unauthorized practice of law.
(6)Seeking additional information from the complainant or other sources, such as the Internet, when the nonattorney complaint does not provide specific or sufficient facts to establish that the unauthorized practice of law may have occurred.
(7)Determining whether to forward the complaint to the enforcement unit for investigation.
(c)If the nonattorney complaint sufficiently alleges an unauthorized practice of law violation, the intake unit shall do both of the following:
(1)Forward the nonattorney complaint to the enforcement unit for further action.
(2)Refer the matter to law enforcement or other appropriate agency for consideration of criminal or other enforcement action, as specified in subdivisions (f) and (g).
(d)If the nonattorney complaint sufficiently alleges the use of notario, notario publico, or other words or phrases in violation of Section 6126.7 or there is other evidence of a violation of Section 6126.7, the intake unit shall forward the complaint to the enforcement unit for further action.
(e)If the nonattorney complaint does not sufficiently allege an unauthorized practice of law violation or a violation of Section 6126.7, the intake unit shall do all of the following:
(1)Notify the complainant in writing of the determination.
(2)Advise the complainant in writing of the opportunity to seek reconsideration of the determination.
(3)Process the case for closure, including updating the case record.
(f)The intake units staff shall resolve nonattorney complaints by either:
(1)Forwarding the nonattorney complaint to the offices enforcement unit.
(2)Closing the nonattorney complaint in the intake unit.
(g)(1)A nonattorney complaint alleging the unauthorized practice of law shall be presumed to warrant a law enforcement referral to federal, state, or local authorities, such as the United States Attorney, the Attorney General, the local district attorney, local county counsel, or local city attorney, for criminal or other enforcement action.
(2)After the intake unit forwards a nonattorney complaint, the offices enforcement unit shall make the referral required under paragraph (1), where appropriate, and shall coordinate with law enforcement, as appropriate, throughout the offices investigation of the nonattorney complaint.
(3)The intake unit may, where warranted, refer nonattorney complaints that do not allege the unauthorized practice of law to another regulatory agency, such as the Bureau of Real Estate, the Department of Consumer Affairs, the United States Securities and Exchange Commission, the Federal Trade Commission, and the United States Patent and Trademark Office.
(h)Staff of the intake unit shall evaluate nonattorney complaints and strive to meet all of the following in at least 90 percent of nonattorney complaints filed:
(1)Open a nonattorney complaint case record within five days from the complaint form received date, as defined in subdivision (b).
(2)Complete the initial legal review of the nonattorney complaint within 20 days from the complaint form received date.
(3)Process the nonattorney complaint to resolution, which means closing the case or forwarding the case for investigation, within 60 days from the complaint form received date.
(i)Staff of the intake unit shall maintain processing activities in the nonattorney complaint case record, including the recording and tracking of other regulatory agency referrals made in connection with a nonattorney complaint.
(j)All nonattorney complaints forwarded by the intake unit to the offices enforcement unit shall be investigated to determine whether there is evidence of the unauthorized practice of law or any violation of Section 6126.7. There shall be an appropriate law enforcement referral upon assignment to a staff member of the enforcement unit. Assigned enforcement unit staff shall update any law enforcement agency to which the complaint was referred with the status and findings of the investigation as it proceeds. Upon completion of an investigation, the assigned staff of the enforcement unit shall analyze the evidence to determine whether the evidence is sufficient to support formal proceedings in superior court.
(k)Enforcement unit staff shall complete nonattorney complaint investigations to resolution by one of the following:
(1)Filing enforcement proceedings in superior court.
(2)Issuing a cease and desist letter. Enforcement unit staff may issue a cease and desist letter where the unauthorized practice of law activity appears isolated in nature and unlikely to recur or where it otherwise appears that a cease and desist warning will sufficiently address and stop the activity at issue.
(3)Closing the complaint with no further action.
(l)Enforcement unit staff shall investigate nonattorney complaints adhering to the same backlog time standard applicable to attorney discipline complaints and shall resolve the complaint within six months from the complaint form received date.
(m)Intake unit staff and enforcement unit staff shall, as appropriate, maintain and update processing activities in the nonattorney case record, as follows:
(1)Record and track the number of superior court proceedings initiated pursuant to Section 6126.3.
(2)Record and track the number of superior court proceedings initiated pursuant to Section 6126.4.
(3)Record and track the number of superior court proceedings initiated pursuant to Section 6126.7.
(4)Record and track the number of superior court proceedings initiated pursuant to Section 6127.
(5)Record and track the number of law enforcement referrals made in connection with nonattorney complaints.
(6)Record and track the number of other agency referrals made in connection with nonattorney complaints.
(7)Record and track the number of cease and desist letters issued in connection with nonattorney complaints.
(n)The Office of Chief Trial Counsel shall hire at least one supervising attorney with the following experience:
(1)At least three years of experience handling asylum, T-Visa, U-Visa, or special immigrant juvenile status cases and has represented at least 25 individuals in these matters.
(2)Experience in representing individuals in removal proceedings and asylum applications.
SEC. 26.Section 6140 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:6140.(a)The board shall fix the annual membership fee for active members for 2017 at a sum not exceeding three hundred fifteen dollars ($315).
(b)The annual membership fee for active members is payable on or before the first day of February of each year. If the board finds it appropriate and feasible, it may provide by rule for payment of fees on an installment basis with interest, by credit card, or other means, and may charge members choosing any alternative method of payment an additional fee to defray costs incurred by that election.
(c)This section shall remain in effect only until January 1, 2018, and, as of that date, is repealed, unless a later enacted statute, that is enacted before January 1, 2018, deletes or extends that date.
SEC. 27.Section 6140.56 is added to the Business and Professions Code, to read:6140.56.(a)To ensure that the Client Security Fund can adequately protect the public and relieve or mitigate financial losses caused by the dishonest conduct of members of the State Bar by paying claims in a timely manner, the State Bar shall conduct a thorough analysis of the Client Security Fund, including a review of the governance structure of the Client Security Fund to ensure that the structure provides for the most effective and efficient operation of the fund, a determination of the ongoing needs of the fund to satisfy claims in a timely manner, a review of additional efforts that can be taken to increase the collection of payments from the responsible attorneys, and a review of other State Bar expenditures to determine whether other expenditures that do not directly impact the State Bars public protection functions, including, but not limited to, executive salaries and benefits, can be reduced or redirected in order to better fund the Client Security Fund through existing revenue, and, whether, after all other options have been fully and thoroughly exhausted, an increase in membership dues is necessary to ensure that the Client Security Fund can timely pay claims.
(b)The State Bar shall submit a report on its analysis of the Client Security Fund to the Legislature by March 15, 2017, so that the plans can be reviewed in conjunction with the bill that would authorize the imposition of the State Bars membership fee. The report shall be submitted in compliance with Section 9795 of the Government Code.
(c)For purposes of this section, timely manner means within 12 months from the later of the time the claim is received by the State Bar and upon the resolution of the underlying discipline case involving an attorney member, which is a prerequisite to paying the claim.
SEC. 28.Section 6145 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:6145.(a)The board shall engage the services of an independent national or regional public accounting firm with at least five years of experience in governmental auditing for an audit of its revenues, expenditures, reserves, and its financial statement for each fiscal year. The financial statement shall be promptly certified under oath by the Treasurer of the State Bar, and a copy of the audit and financial statement shall be submitted within 120 days of the close of the fiscal year to the board, to the Chief Justice of California, and to the Assembly and Senate Committees on Judiciary.
The audit shall examine the receipts and expenditures of the State Bar and the State Bar sections to ensure that the receipts of the sections are being applied, and their expenditures are being made, in compliance with subdivision (a) of Section 6031.5, and that the receipts of the sections are applied only to the work of the sections.
The audit also shall examine the receipts and expenditures of the State Bar to ensure that the funds collected on behalf of the Conference of Delegates of California Bar Associations as the independent successor entity to the former Conference of Delegates of the State Bar are conveyed to that entity, that the State Bar has been paid or reimbursed for the full cost of any administrative and support services provided to the successor entity, including the collection of fees or donations on its behalf, and that no mandatory dues are being used to fund the activities of the successor entity.
In selecting the accounting firm, the board shall consider the value of continuity, along with the risk that continued long-term engagements of an accounting firm may affect the independence of that firm.
(b)The board shall contract with the California State Auditors Office to conduct a performance audit of the State Bars operations from July 1, 2000, to December 31, 2000, inclusive. A copy of the performance audit shall be submitted by May 1, 2001, to the board, to the Chief Justice of California, and to the Assembly and Senate Committees on Judiciary.
Every two years thereafter, the board shall contract with the California State Auditors Office to conduct a performance audit of the State Bars operations for the respective fiscal year, commencing with January 1, 2002, to December 31, 2002, inclusive. A copy of the performance audit shall be submitted within 120 days of the close of the fiscal year for which the audit was performed to the board, to the Chief Justice of California, and to the Assembly and Senate Committees on Judiciary.
For the performance audit due to the board, to the Chief Justice of the California Supreme Court, and to the Assembly and Senate Committees on Judiciary in 2017, the California State Auditor shall review all of the State Bars expenses, including, but not limited to, executive salaries and benefits, outside contracts, and real estate holdings, to determine the expenses that are appropriate and necessary to protect the public and what the appropriate level of member dues should be.
For the purposes of this subdivision, the California State Auditors Office may contract with a third party to conduct the performance audit. This subdivision is not intended to reduce the number of audits the California State Auditors Office may otherwise be able to conduct.
(c)(1)In addition to the audits required in subdivision (b), the California State Auditor shall conduct a performance audit evaluating the State Bars progress in:
(A)Reviewing any changes in the State Bars expenses made as a result of prior audits by the California State Auditor.
(B)Correcting any issues raised in prior audits by the California State Auditor.
(C)Increasing operational effectiveness and efficiency.
(2)The California State Auditor shall report its findings and recommendations to the board, to the Chief Justice of California, to the Assembly Committee on Judiciary, and to the Senate Committee on Judiciary, no later than June 15, 2018.
SEC. 29.The Legislature finds and declares that Sections 18 and 24 of this act, which amend Sections 6026.7 and 6086.5 of the Business and Professions Code, impose a limitation on the publics right of access to the meetings of public bodies or the writings of public officials and agencies within the meaning of Section 3 of Article I of the California Constitution. Pursuant to that constitutional provision, the Legislature makes the following findings to demonstrate the interest protected by this limitation and the need for protecting that interest:
In order to protect the decisionmaking process of the State Bar Court in a manner that is similar to the deliberative functions of other courts and in order to ensure that personal or sensitive information regarding discipline by the State Bar Court is kept confidential, including for persons participating in discussions and offers of settlement pursuant to arbitration or mediation, it is necessary to exempt the State Bar Court from the provision of the Bagley-Keene Open Meeting Act and the California Public Records Act.
The Legislature finds and declares all of the following:
(a)The protection of the public is required, by statute, to be the highest priority of the State Bar of California and must be the paramount focus of the State Bar, its employees, and, most importantly, its board of trustees. All other duties and activities of the State Bar are ancillary to its regulatory oversight of the states more than 250,000 attorneys, over 185,000 of whom are active members.
(b)Throughout its history, the State Bar has been the subject of substantial controversies, including allegations of serious fiscal and management improprieties, and most recently failure to properly protect the public against the unauthorized practice of law, including allowing hundreds of complaints to languish in a drawer.
(c)In May 2015, the California State Auditor released its biannual performance audit of the State Bar, reviewing the State Bars backlog of discipline cases and its recent $75,000,000 purchase and renovation of a building in Los Angeles at three times the cost originally estimated and requiring a loan against the Public Protection Fund, which is designed to be an emergency fund to protect the public in the event of a financial emergency. The audit uncovered significant, questionable decisions made by the State Bar in the handling of both matters, including that the State Bar had not fully or consistently reported its backlog of discipline cases and that, in order to reduce its backlog of discipline cases, the State Bar made questionable choices, potentially causing significant risk to the public.
(d)Most recently and without consultation with the Legislature, the State Bar chose to replace the loan on the Los Angeles building, along with a brand new loan for updating its San Francisco building, with a securitization on future members dues, potentially tying the hands of the Legislature in setting future dues amounts.
(e)As a result of the troubling findings of the audit, the Legislature, as part of the 2015 State Bar dues legislation, imposed important new preliminary reforms on the State Bar. First, the Legislature mandated that the State Bar be subject to both the California Public Records Act and the Bagley-Keene Open Meetings Act. These good government reforms help ensure the integrity, transparency, and accountability of the State Bar. Second, the Legislature directed the California State Auditor to conduct a full financial audit of the State Bar, which is due on May 15, 2016. Finally, the State Bar must develop a workforce plan for its attorney discipline system and a spending plan to determine the level for dues to recommend to the Legislature, which are both due on May 15, 2016. These reports should help inform the Legislature regarding the appropriate actions to take in its oversight responsibility of the State Bar and its own determination of the proper dues amount.
(f)In 2011, the Legislature directed the State Bar to establish a Governance in the Public Interest Task Force to make recommendations to the Governor, the Supreme Court, and the Legislature every three years, beginning May 15, 2014, for, among other things, enhancing the protection of the public and ensuring that protection of the public is the highest priority in the licensing, regulation, and discipline of attorneys, to be reviewed by the Assembly and Senate Committees on Judiciary in their regular consideration of the annual State Bar dues measure. That first report is now two years overdue and, although the Governance in the Public Interest Task Force finally began holding meetings this year, it appears that this already long overdue report will not be completed during this legislative session.
(g)It is the intent of the Legislature, in fulfilling its important oversight responsibility over the State Bar and the proper amount State Bar members must pay in annual dues, that this bill serve as the vehicle to implement possible recommendations for substantially improving the operations, effectiveness, and efficiency of the State Bar based on the 2016 California State Auditors audit of the State Bar, along with the State Bars discipline workforce and spending plans and any draft Governance Task Force report or other information, in order to ensure that the dues are the appropriate amount, that the State Bar becomes more accountable to the public, and that public protection is, and remains, the State Bars top priority.
SEC. 2.SECTION 1.Section 6001 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:6001.The State Bar of California is a public corporation. It is hereinafter designated as the State Bar.
The State Bar has perpetual succession and a seal and it may sue and be sued. It may, for the purpose of carrying into effect and promoting its objectives:
(a)Make contracts.
(b)Borrow money, contract debts, issue bonds, notes notes, and debentures and secure the payment or performance of its obligations.
(c)Own, hold, use, manage manage, and deal in and with real and personal property.
(d)Construct, alter, maintain maintain, and repair buildings and other improvements to real property.
(e)Purchase, lease, obtain options upon, acquire by gift, bequest, devise devise, or otherwise, any real or personal property or any interest therein.
(f)Sell, lease, exchange, convey, transfer, assign, encumber, pledge, dispose of any of its real or personal property or any interest therein, including without limitation all or any portion of its income or revenues from membership fees paid or payable by members.
(g)Do all other acts incidental to the foregoing or necessary or expedient for the administration of its affairs and the attainment of its purposes.
Pursuant to those powers enumerated in subdivisions (a) to (g), inclusive, it is recognized that the State Bar has authority to raise revenue in addition to that provided for in Section 6140 and other statutory provisions. The State Bar is empowered to raise that additional revenue by any lawful means. However, as of December 31, 2016, the State Bar shall not create any foundations or nonprofit corporations.
The State Bar shall conspicuously publicize to its members in the annual dues statement and other appropriate communications, including its Web site and electronic communications, that its members have the right to limit the sale or disclosure of member information not reasonably related to regulatory purposes. In those communications the State Bar shall note the location of the State Bars privacy policy, and shall also note the simple procedure by which a member may exercise his or her right to prohibit or restrict, at the members option, the sale or disclosure of member information not reasonably related to regulatory purposes. On or before May 1, 2005, the State Bar shall report to the Assembly and Senate Committees on Judiciary regarding the procedures that it has in place to ensure that members can appropriately limit the use of their member information not reasonably related to regulatory purposes, and the number of members choosing to utilize these procedures.
No law of this state restricting, or prescribing a mode of procedure for the exercise of powers of state public bodies or state agencies, or classes thereof, including, but not by way of limitation, the provisions contained in Division 3 (commencing with Section 11000), Division 4 (commencing with Section 16100), and Part 1 (commencing with Section 18000) and Part 2 (commencing with Section 18500) of Division 5, of Title 2 of the Government Code, shall be applicable to the State Bar, unless the Legislature expressly so declares. Notwithstanding the foregoing or any other law, pursuant to Sections 6026.7 and 6026.11, the State Bar is subject to the California Public Records Act (Chapter 3.5 (commencing with Section 6250) of Division 7 of Title 1 of the Government Code) and, commencing April 1, 2016, the Bagley-Keene Open Meeting Act (Article 9 (commencing with Section 11120) of Chapter 1 of Part 1 of Division 3 of Title 2 of the Government Code).
SEC. 3.Section 6001.3 is added to the Business and Professions Code, to read:6001.3.(a)There is hereby created, as of January 1, 2017, the California State Bar Governance Commission, consisting of nine members, who shall be appointed by February 1, 2017, and selected as follows:
(1)Two members appointed by the Governor.
(2)Three members appointed by the Chief Justice of the California Supreme Court.
(3)Two members appointed by the Speaker of the Assembly.
(4)Two members appointed by the Senate Committee on Rules.
(b)The chairperson of the commission shall be elected by the members of the commission and shall preside at meetings of the commission.
(c)Appointed members of the commission shall not receive a salary, but shall be entitled to a per diem allowance of fifty dollars ($50) for each days attendance at a meeting of the commission, not to exceed three hundred dollars ($300) in any month, and reimbursement for expenses incurred in the performance of their duties under this chapter, including travel and other necessary expenses.
(d)The commission may adopt bylaws for the regulation of its affairs and the conduct of its business.
(e)The commission shall meet on the call of the chairperson, at the request of a majority of the members, or at the request of the California Chief Justice of the Supreme Court. A majority of all members of the commission constitutes a quorum for the transaction of business.
(f)The State Bar shall furnish all administrative assistance required by the commission.
(g)The commission shall evaluate all issues of governance of the State Bar, including, but not limited to, a full review of other states with attorney regulatory structures that are different than the State Bar and a possible separation of the State Bars regulatory and trade association functions, in order to recommend the best governance structure for the State Bar to ensure that the protection of the public is the highest priority in the licensing, regulation, and discipline of attorneys and that the State Bar appropriately functions as a government agency subject to laws that apply to similar regulatory bodies. The commission shall, by April 30, 2017, provide a report to the Governor, the Chief Justice of the California Supreme Court, and the Senate and Assembly Committees on Judiciary on its recommendations, along with an implementation plan for those recommendations. If the commission does not reach a consensus on all of the recommendations in its report, the dissenting members of the commission may prepare and submit a dissenting report to the same entities described in this subdivision.
SEC. 2.Section 6001.1 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:6001.1.(a)Protection of the public shall be the highest priority for the State Bar of California and the board of trustees in exercising their licensing, regulatory, and disciplinary functions. Whenever the protection of the public is inconsistent with other interests sought to be promoted, the protection of the public shall be paramount.
(b)Protection of the public requires that professional legal services are provided in a competent, accessible, and ethical manner and that the judicial system functions in a fair, impartial, and just manner. For purposes of staffing and resource allocations, protection of the public is defined as the following core functions of the State Bar in the following order of priority:
(1)Administration of the bar admissions and law school accreditation processes, recordkeeping and licensing functions, and the lawyer discipline system.
(2)Administration of programs that advance professional competence and ethics, support the prevention of discipline problems before they occur, address the unlawful practice of law, and support the judicial selection process.
(3)Administration of programs that support the fair and equal administration of justice, effective functioning of the legal system, and diversity of the profession.
SEC. 4.SEC. 3.Section 6008.5 of the Business and Professions Code is repealed.SEC. 5.SEC. 4.Section 6009.7 of the Business and Professions Code is repealed.SEC. 6.SEC. 5.Section 6011 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:6011.(a)The board shall consist of no more than 19 members and no fewer than 13 members.
(b)It is the intent of the Legislature that the board consist of no more than 19 members and no fewer than 13 members during the period of transition from a 19-member board to a 13-member board. It is the intent of the Legislature that the board decrease its size without shortening, lengthening, or abolishing terms commencing prior to December 31, 2016, with the ultimate goal of instituting a 13-member board no later than October 31, 2019. It is the intent of the Legislature that this transition occur by the expiration of the terms of the elected members who are serving on the board as of December 31, 2016.
(c)Each member appointed after December 31, 2016, shall have demonstrated educational or experience expertise, When making appointments to the board on and after December 31, 2016, each appointing body should consider appointing members with education or experience, or both, in at least one of the following:
(1)Public finance.
(2)Public administration.
(3)Business or financial management.
(4)State government, particularly prior regulatory experience.
(5)Legal ethics.
(6)Immigration law.
SEC. 7.SEC. 6.Section 6012 of the Business and Professions Code is repealed.SEC. 7.Section 6013.1 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:6013.1.(a)The Supreme Court shall appoint five attorney members of the board pursuant to a process that the Supreme Court may prescribe. These attorney members shall serve for a term of three four years and may be reappointed by the Supreme Court for one additional term only.
(b)An attorney member elected pursuant to Section 6013.2 may be appointed by the Supreme Court pursuant to this section to a term as an appointed attorney member.
(c)The Supreme Court shall fill any vacancy in the term of, and make any reappointment of, any appointed attorney member.
(d)When making appointments to the board, the Supreme Court should consider appointing attorneys that represent the following categories: legal services; small firm or solo practitioners; historically underrepresented groups, including consideration of race, ethnicity, gender, and sexual orientation; and legal academics. In making appointments to the board, the Supreme Court should also consider geographic distribution, years of practice, particularly attorneys who are within the first five years of practice or 36 years of age and under, and participation in voluntary local or state bar activities.
(e)The State Bar shall be responsible for carrying out the administrative responsibilities related to the appointment process described in subdivision (a).
SEC. 8.Section 6013.2 of the Business and Professions Code is repealed.SEC. 9.Section 6013.3 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:6013.3.(a)One attorney member of the board shall be appointed by the Senate Committee on Rules. Rules and one attorney member of the board shall be appointed by the Speaker of the Assembly.
(b)An attorney member appointed pursuant to this section shall serve for a term of three four years. Vacancies shall be filled for the remainder of the term. An appointed attorney member may be reappointed pursuant to this section.
SEC. 10.Section 6013.5 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:6013.5.(a)Effective January 1, 2017, a minimum of seven maximum of six members of the board shall be members of the public who have never been members of the State Bar or admitted to practice before any court in the United States.
(b)Each of these members shall serve for a term of three years, commencing at the conclusion of the annual meeting next succeeding his or her appointment. four years. Vacancies shall be filled for the remainder of the term.
(c)Effective January 1, 2017, one public member shall be appointed by the Senate Committee on Rules and two one public members member shall be appointed by the Speaker of the Assembly.
(d)Four public members shall be appointed by the Governor, subject to the confirmation of the Senate.
(e)Each respective appointing authority shall fill any vacancy in and make any reappointment to each respective office.
(f)It is the intent of the Legislature that the increase of public members appointed by the Speaker of the Assembly, from one to two, as required by this measure adding this subdivision, occur at the expiration of the terms of the attorney members who are appointed by the Speaker of the Assembly and serving on the board as of December 31, 2016.
SEC. 11.Section 6015 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:6015.No person is eligible for attorney membership on the board unless all both of the following conditions are satisfied:
(a)He or she is an active member of the State Bar.
(b)Either:
(1)Prior to October 31, 2019, if elected, he or she maintains his or her principal office for the practice of law within the State Bar district from which he or she is elected.
(2)If appointed by the Supreme Court or the Legislature, he or she maintains his or her principal office for the practice of law within the State of California.
(c)If newly appointed after December 31, 2016, he or she satisfies the requirements of subdivision (c) of Section 6011.
SEC. 12.Section 6016 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:6016.The term of office of each attorney member of the board shall commence at the conclusion of the annual meeting next succeeding his or her election or appointment, be four years and he or she shall hold office until his or her successor is elected or appointed and qualified. For the purposes of this section, the time intervening between any two successive annual meetings shall be deemed to be one year. Vacancies shall be filled for the remainder of the term.
The board of trustees may provide by rule for an interim board to act in the place and stead of the board when because of vacancies during terms of office there is less than a quorum of the board.
SEC. 13.Section 6018 of the Business and Professions Code is repealed.SEC. 14.Section 6019 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:6019.Each place upon the board for which a member is to be appointed shall for the purposes of the appointment be deemed a separate office.
SEC. 15.Section 6021 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:6021.(a)(1)The Supreme Court shall select from its appointed the members a president and a vice president of the board a chair and a vice chair to serve in the absence of the president. chair.
(2)Within the period of 90 days next preceding the annual meeting, the board, at a meeting called for that purpose, shall select the treasurer for the ensuing year.
(3)
(2)The president, vice president, and treasurer chair and vice chair shall assume the duties of their respective offices at the conclusion of the annual meeting following their appointment or selection. appointment.
(b)The term of the board president chair and vice chair shall be one year, except that he or she may be reappointed to a second one-year term as the board president. year.
(c)Notwithstanding the provisions of Section 6011 regarding a 13-member board, if the president is elected from among those members of the board whose terms on the board expire by that year and has not been reappointed to another term under Section 6013.1 or 6013.5, the president shall serve as a 14th member of the board during his or her one-year term, and he or she may vote.
SEC. 16.Section 6022 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:6022.The officers secretary and treasurer of the State Bar shall be selected annually by the board and need not be a member members of the State Bar.
SEC. 17.Section 6026.5 of the Business and Professions Code, as added by Section 3 of Chapter 537 of the Statutes of 2015, is repealed.SEC. 18.Section 6026.7 of the Business and Professions Code, as added by Section 5 of Chapter 537 of the Statutes of 2015, is amended to read:6026.7.(a)The State Bar is subject to the Bagley-Keene Open Meeting Act (Article 9 (commencing with Section 11120) of Chapter 1 of Part 1 of Division 3 of Title 2 of the Government Code) and all meetings of the State Bar are subject to the Bagley-Keene Open Meeting Act.
(b)Notwithstanding any other law, the Bagley-Keene Open Meeting Act shall not apply to the Judicial Nominees Evaluation Commission, the Committee of Bar Examiners, or the State Bar Court.
(c)In addition to the grounds authorized in the Bagley-Keene Open Meeting Act, a closed session may be held for those meetings, or portions thereof, relating to both of the following:
(1)Appeals to the board from decisions of the Board of Legal Specialization refusing to certify or recertify an applicant or suspending or revoking a specialists certificate.
(2)The preparation, approval, grading, or administration of examinations for certification of a specialist.
SEC. 19.Section 6029 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:6029.(a)The board may appoint such committees, officers and employees as it deems necessary or proper, and fix and pay salaries and necessary expenses.
(b)The members of the executive committee of the board shall include at least one board member appointed by each of the following appointing authorities:
(1)The Supreme Court.
(2)The Governor.
(3)The Speaker of the Assembly.
(4)The Senate Committee on Rules.
SEC. 19.SEC. 20.Section 6030 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:6030.(a)The board shall be charged with the executive function of the State Bar and the enforcement of the provisions of this chapter.
(b)The violation or threatened violation of any provision of Articles 7 (commencing with Section 6125) and 9 (commencing with Section 6150) of this chapter may be enjoined in a civil action brought in the superior court by the State Bar and no undertaking shall be required of the State Bar.
(c)No motion of the board can be approved unless a majority of the public members approve the motion.
(c)Any decision of the board raising antitrust concerns is subject to review, modification, veto, or other appropriate action by the California Supreme Court.
SEC. 20.SEC. 21.Section 6060.2 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:6060.2.(a)All investigations or proceedings conducted by the State Bar concerning the moral character of an applicant shall be confidential and shall not be disclosed pursuant to any state law, including, but not limited to, the California Public Records Act (Chapter 3.5 (commencing with Section 6250) of Division 7 of Title 1 of the Government Code) unless the applicant, in writing, waives the confidentiality.
(b)Notwithstanding subdivision (a), the records of the proceeding may be disclosed in response to either of the following:
(1)A lawfully issued subpoena.
(2)A written request from a government agency responsible for either the enforcement of civil or criminal laws or the professional licensing of individuals that is conducting an investigation about the applicant.
SEC. 21.SEC. 22.Section 6060.25 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:6060.25.(a)Notwithstanding any other law, any identifying information submitted by an applicant to the State Bar for admission and a license to practice law and all State Bar admission records, including, but not limited to, bar examination scores, law school grade point average (GPA), undergraduate GPA, Law School Admission Test scores, race or ethnicity, and any information contained within the State Bar Admissions database or any file or other data created by the State Bar with information submitted by the applicant that may identify an individual applicant, other than information described in subdivision (b), shall be confidential and shall not be disclosed pursuant to any state law, including, but not limited to, the California Public Records Act (Chapter 3.5 (commencing with Section 6250) of Division 7 of Title 1 of the Government Code).
(b)(1)This section does not prohibit the disclosure of any of the following:
(1)
(A)The names of applicants who have passed any examination administered, given, or prescribed by the Committee of Bar Examiners.
(2)
(B)Information that is provided at the request of an applicant to another jurisdiction where the applicant is seeking admission to the practice of law.
(3)
(C)Information provided to a law school that is necessary for the purpose of the law schools compliance with accreditation or regulatory requirements.
(4)
(D)Information provided to the National Conference of Bar Examiners or a successor nonprofit organization in connection to the State Bars administration of any examination.
(2)This subdivision shall apply retroactively to January 1, 2016.
(c)Disclosure of any of the information in paragraphs (2) subparagraphs (B) to (4), (D), inclusive, of paragraph (1) of subdivision (b) shall not constitute a waiver under Section 6254.5 of the Government Code of the exemption from disclosure provided for in subdivision (a) of this section.
SEC. 22.SEC. 23.Section 6075.6 is added to the Business and Professions Code, to read:6075.6.(a)(1)The Chief Justice of the California Supreme Court Attorney General shall appoint a State Bar enforcement program monitor prior to March 31, 2017. The Chief Justice of the California Supreme Court shall advertise the availability of the position and conduct interviews of candidates for the position. The applicant for the position shall have investigative experience, shall be familiar with California laws and procedures, and, preferably, shall be familiar with the rules and procedures of the State Bar lawyer discipline system and relevant administrative procedures. The monitor may be a state employee or his or her services may be provided pursuant to contract.
(2)The Chief Justice of the California Supreme Court Attorney General shall supervise the monitor and may terminate or dismiss him or her from this position.
(b)(1)The enforcement program monitor shall monitor and evaluate the disciplinary system and procedures of the State Bar. The enforcement program monitor shall make his or her highest priority the reform and reengineering of the State Bars enforcement program and operations and the improvement of the overall efficiency of the State Bars disciplinary system so that the State Bar is successfully and consistently protecting the public.
(2)This monitoring duty shall include, but not be limited to, the prioritization of cases most impacting public protection, improving the timeframe for the handling of complaints and in the rendering of initial decisions on complaints, the efficiency of the system, the fairness and courtesy given to complainants, the adequacy of the staffing and the budget allocated to the discipline section of the State Bar, the reduction of the complaint backlog, the consistency in the application of sanctions or discipline imposed, the implementation of laws affecting discipline and the State Bars operations, disciplinary standards and rules, staff concerns regarding disciplinary matters or procedures, and the State Bars cooperation with other governmental entities charged with enforcing related laws and regulations that affect members of the State Bar.
(3)The monitor shall exercise no authority over the State Bars discipline operations or staff, however, the State Bar and its staff shall cooperate with the program enforcement monitor, and the Bar shall provide data, information, and case files as requested by the enforcement program monitor to perform all of his or her duties. The enforcement program monitor shall have the same access to documents as the Chief Justice of the California Supreme Court.
(c)The enforcement program monitor shall submit an initial written report of his or her findings and conclusions to the State Bar, the Supreme Court, and the Legislature no later than October 1, 2019, and be available to make oral reports to each if requested to do so. The initial report shall include an analysis of the sources of information that resulted in each disciplinary action imposed since January 1, 2016. The monitor may also provide additional information to either the Supreme Court, the State Bar, or the Legislature at his or her discretion or at the request of the Supreme Court, the State Bar, or the Legislature. The program enforcement monitor shall make his or her reports available to the public or the media. The monitor shall make every effort to provide the State Bar with an opportunity to reply to any facts, findings, issues, or conclusions in his or her reports with which the State Bar may disagree.
(d)The enforcement program monitor shall issue a final report prior to March 31, 2020.
(e)This section shall become inoperative on March 31, 2020, and as of January 1, 2020, 2021, shall be repealed.
SEC. 23.SEC. 24.Section 6086.5 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:6086.5.The board of trustees shall establish a State Bar Court, to act in its place and stead in the determination of disciplinary and reinstatement proceedings and proceedings pursuant to subdivisions (b) and (c) of Section 6007 to the extent provided by rules adopted by the board of trustees pursuant to this chapter. In these proceedings the State Bar Court may exercise the powers and authority vested in the board of trustees by this chapter, including those powers and that authority vested in committees of, or established by, the board, except as limited by rules of the board of trustees within the scope of this chapter.
Access to records of the State Bar Court shall be governed by court rules and laws applicable to records of the judiciary and not the California Public Records Act (Chapter 3.5 (commencing with Section 6250) of Division 7 of Title 1 of the Government Code).
For the purposes of Sections 6007, 6043, 6049, 6049.2, 6050, 6051, 6052, 6077 (excluding the first sentence), 6078, 6080, 6081, and 6082, board includes the State Bar Court.
Nothing in this section shall authorize the State Bar Court to adopt rules of professional conduct or rules of procedure.
The Executive Committee of the State Bar Court may adopt rules of practice for the conduct of all proceedings within its jurisdiction. These rules may not conflict with the rules of procedure adopted by the board, unless approved by the Supreme Court.
SEC. 24.SEC. 25.Section 6134 is added to the Business and Professions Code, to read:6134.(a)When the Office of the Chief Trial Counsel becomes aware of an allegation that a person not licensed to practice law in California has practiced or held himself or herself out as practicing law or entitled to practice law in the state, the offices intake unit shall open a nonattorney complaint against that person for evaluation and processing.
(b)The intake unit shall open a case record in the offices case management system with the complaint form received date. The complaint form received date shall be the date the State Bar first received the complaint. Evaluation and processing of the nonattorney complaint shall include, but not be limited to, all of the following:
(1)Creation of a summary of the allegation or allegations in the case record and assignment to staff, including inputting staff assignment codes into the case management system.
(2)Identifying the source of the complaint.
(3)Identifying the relevant practice area of law, such as immigration, loan modification, or debt resolution, and recording the relevant practice area of law in the case record.
(4)Identifying whether the allegations include potential identity theft of a licensed attorneys identity and, if so, contacting the potential victim attorney to verify whether the attorney is aware of the potential identify theft and whether he or she has notified law enforcement.
(5)Evaluating the nonattorney complaint for unauthorized practice of law allegations, which includes opening a corresponding attorney complaint case record, if appropriate, such as in the case in which the nonattorney complaint also identifies a licensed California attorney potentially aiding or abetting the person in the unauthorized practice of law.
(6)Seeking additional information from the complainant or other sources, such as the Internet, when the nonattorney complaint does not provide specific or sufficient facts to establish that the unauthorized practice of law may have occurred.
(7)Determining whether to forward the complaint to the enforcement unit for investigation.
(c)If the nonattorney complaint sufficiently alleges an unauthorized practice of law violation, the intake unit shall do both of the following:
(1)Forward the nonattorney complaint to the enforcement unit for further action.
(2)Refer the matter to law enforcement or other appropriate agency for consideration of criminal or other enforcement action, as specified in subdivisions (f) and (g).
(d)If the nonattorney complaint sufficiently alleges the use of notario, notario publico, or other words or phrases in violation of Section 6126.7 or there is other evidence of a violation of Section 6126.7, the intake unit shall forward the complaint to the enforcement unit for further action.
(e)If the nonattorney complaint does not sufficiently allege an unauthorized practice of law violation or a violation of Section 6126.7, the intake unit shall do all of the following:
(1)Notify the complainant in writing of the determination.
(2)Advise the complainant in writing of the opportunity to seek reconsideration of the determination.
(3)Process the case for closure, including updating the case record.
(f)The intake units staff shall resolve nonattorney complaints by either:
(1)Forwarding the nonattorney complaint to the offices enforcement unit.
(2)Closing the nonattorney complaint in the intake unit.
(g)(1)A nonattorney complaint alleging the unauthorized practice of law shall be presumed to warrant a law enforcement referral to federal, state, or local authorities, such as the United States Attorney, the Attorney General, the local district attorney, local county counsel, or local city attorney, for criminal or other enforcement action.
(2)After the intake unit forwards a nonattorney complaint, the offices enforcement unit shall make the referral required under paragraph (1), where appropriate, and shall coordinate with law enforcement, as appropriate, throughout the offices investigation of the nonattorney complaint.
(3)The intake unit may, where warranted, refer nonattorney complaints that do not allege the unauthorized practice of law to another regulatory agency, such as the Bureau of Real Estate, the Department of Consumer Affairs, the United States Securities and Exchange Commission, the Federal Trade Commission, and the United States Patent and Trademark Office.
(h)Staff of the intake unit shall evaluate nonattorney complaints and strive to meet all of the following in at least 90 percent of nonattorney complaints filed:
(1)Open a nonattorney complaint case record within five days from the complaint form received date, as defined in subdivision (b).
(2)Complete the initial legal review of the nonattorney complaint within 20 days from the complaint form received date.
(3)Process the nonattorney complaint to resolution, which means closing the case or forwarding the case for investigation, within 60 days from the complaint form received date.
(i)Staff of the intake unit shall maintain processing activities in the nonattorney complaint case record, including the recording and tracking of other regulatory agency referrals made in connection with a nonattorney complaint.
(j)All nonattorney complaints forwarded by the intake unit to the offices enforcement unit shall be investigated to determine whether there is evidence of the unauthorized practice of law or any violation of Section 6126.7. There shall be an appropriate law enforcement referral upon assignment to a staff member of the enforcement unit. Assigned enforcement unit staff shall update any law enforcement agency to which the complaint was referred with the status and findings of the investigation as it proceeds. Upon completion of an investigation, the assigned staff of the enforcement unit shall analyze the evidence to determine whether the evidence is sufficient to support formal proceedings in superior court.
(k)Enforcement unit staff shall complete nonattorney complaint investigations to resolution by one of the following:
(1)Filing enforcement proceedings in superior court.
(2)Issuing a cease and desist letter. Enforcement unit staff may issue a cease and desist letter where the unauthorized practice of law activity appears isolated in nature and unlikely to recur or where it otherwise appears that a cease and desist warning will sufficiently address and stop the activity at issue.
(3)Closing the complaint with no further action.
(l)Enforcement unit staff shall investigate nonattorney complaints adhering to the same backlog time standard applicable to attorney discipline complaints and shall resolve the complaint within six months from the complaint form received date.
(m)Intake unit staff and enforcement unit staff shall, as appropriate, maintain and update processing activities in the nonattorney case record, as follows:
(1)Record and track the number of superior court proceedings initiated pursuant to Section 6126.3.
(2)Record and track the number of superior court proceedings initiated pursuant to Section 6126.4.
(3)Record and track the number of superior court proceedings initiated pursuant to Section 6126.7.
(4)Record and track the number of superior court proceedings initiated pursuant to Section 6127.
(5)Record and track the number of law enforcement referrals made in connection with nonattorney complaints.
(6)Record and track the number of other agency referrals made in connection with nonattorney complaints.
(7)Record and track the number of cease and desist letters issued in connection with nonattorney complaints.
(n)The Office of Chief Trial Counsel shall hire at least one supervising attorney with the following experience:
(1)At least three years of experience handling asylum, T-Visa, U-Visa, or special immigrant juvenile status cases and has represented at least 25 individuals in these matters.
(2)Experience in representing individuals in removal proceedings and asylum applications.
SEC. 25.SEC. 26.Section 6140 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:6140.(a)The board shall fix the annual membership fee for active members for 2017 at a sum not exceeding three hundred fifteen dollars ($315).
(b)The annual membership fee for active members is payable on or before the first day of February of each year. If the board finds it appropriate and feasible, it may provide by rule for payment of fees on an installment basis with interest, by credit card, or other means, and may charge members choosing any alternative method of payment an additional fee to defray costs incurred by that election.
(c)This section shall remain in effect only until January 1, 2018, and, as of that date, is repealed, unless a later enacted statute, that is enacted before January 1, 2018, deletes or extends that date.
SEC. 26.SEC. 27.Section 6140.56 is added to the Business and Professions Code, to read:6140.56.(a)To ensure that the Client Security Fund can adequately protect the public and relieve or mitigate financial losses caused by the dishonest conduct of members of the State Bar by paying claims in a timely manner, the State Bar shall conduct a thorough analysis of the Client Security Fund, including a review of the governance structure of the Client Security Fund to ensure that the structure provides for the most effective and efficient operation of the fund, a determination of the ongoing needs of the fund to satisfy claims in a timely manner, a review of additional efforts that can be taken to increase the collection of payments from the responsible attorneys, and a review of other State Bar expenditures to determine whether other expenditures that do not directly impact the State Bars public protection functions, including, but not limited to, executive salaries and benefits, can be reduced or redirected in order to better fund the Client Security Fund through existing revenue, and, whether, after all other options have been fully and thoroughly exhausted, an increase in membership dues is necessary to ensure that the Client Security Fund can timely pay claims.
(b)The State Bar shall submit a report on its analysis of the Client Security Fund to the Legislature by March 15, 2017, so that the plans can be reviewed in conjunction with the bill that would authorize the imposition of the State Bars membership fee. The report shall be submitted in compliance with Section 9795 of the Government Code.
(c)For purposes of this section, timely manner means within 12 months from the later of the time the claim is received by the State Bar. Bar and upon the resolution of the underlying discipline case involving an attorney member, which is a prerequisite to paying the claim.
SEC. 27.SEC. 28.Section 6145 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:6145.(a)The board shall contract with the California State Auditors Office engage the services of an independent national or regional public accounting firm with at least five years of experience in governmental auditing for an audit of its revenues, expenditures, reserves, and its financial statement for each fiscal year. The financial statement shall be promptly certified under oath by the Treasurer of the State Bar, and a copy of the audit and financial statement shall be submitted within 120 days of the close of the fiscal year to the board, to the Chief Justice of the Supreme Court, California, and to the Assembly and Senate Committees on Judiciary.
The audit shall examine the receipts and expenditures of the State Bar and the State Bar sections to ensure that the receipts of the sections are being applied, and their expenditures are being made, in compliance with subdivision (a) of Section 6031.5, and that the receipts of the sections are applied only to the work of the sections.
The audit also shall examine the receipts and expenditures of the State Bar to ensure that the funds collected on behalf of the Conference of Delegates of California Bar Associations as the independent successor entity to the former Conference of Delegates of the State Bar are conveyed to that entity, that the State Bar has been paid or reimbursed for the full cost of any administrative and support services provided to the successor entity, including the collection of fees or donations on its behalf, and that no mandatory dues are being used to fund the activities of the successor entity.
This subdivision is not intended to reduce the number of audits the California State Auditors Office may otherwise be able to conduct.
In selecting the accounting firm, the board shall consider the value of continuity, along with the risk that continued long-term engagements of an accounting firm may affect the independence of that firm.
(b)The board shall contract with the California State Auditors Office to conduct a performance audit of the State Bars operations from July 1, 2000, to December 31, 2000, inclusive. A copy of the performance audit shall be submitted by May 1, 2001, to the board, to the Chief Justice of the Supreme Court, California, and to the Assembly and Senate Committees on Judiciary.
Every two years thereafter, the board shall contract with the California State Auditors Office to conduct a performance audit of the State Bars operations for the respective fiscal year, commencing with January 1, 2002, to December 31, 2002, inclusive. A copy of the performance audit shall be submitted within 120 days of the close of the fiscal year for which the audit was performed to the board, to the Chief Justice of the Supreme Court, California, and to the Assembly and Senate Committees on Judiciary.
For the performance audit due to the board, to the Chief Justice of the California Supreme Court, and to the Assembly and Senate Committees on Judiciary in 2017, the California State Auditor shall review all of the State Bars expenses, including, but not limited to, executive salaries and benefits, outside contracts, and real estate holdings, to determine the expenses that are appropriate and necessary to protect the public and what the appropriate level of member dues should be.
For the purposes of this subdivision, the California State Auditors Office may contract with a third party to conduct the performance audit. This subdivision is not intended to reduce the number of audits the California State Auditors Office may otherwise be able to conduct.
(c)This section shall become inoperative on January 1, 2021, and as of that date is repealed.
(c)(1)In addition to the audits required in subdivision (b), the California State Auditor shall conduct a performance audit evaluating the State Bars progress in:
(A)Reviewing any changes in the State Bars expenses made as a result of prior audits by the California State Auditor.
(B)Correcting any issues raised in prior audits by the California State Auditor.
(C)Increasing operational effectiveness and efficiency.
(2)The California State Auditor shall report its findings and recommendations to the board, to the Chief Justice of California, to the Assembly Committee on Judiciary, and to the Senate Committee on Judiciary, no later than June 15, 2018.
SEC. 28.Section 6145 is added to the Business and Professions Code, to read:6145.(a)The board shall engage the services of an independent national or regional public accounting firm with at least five years of experience in governmental auditing for an audit of its financial statement for each fiscal year. The financial statement shall be promptly certified under oath by the Treasurer of the State Bar, and a copy of the audit and financial statement shall be submitted within 120 days of the close of the fiscal year to the board, to the Chief Justice of the California Supreme Court, and to the Assembly and Senate Committees on Judiciary.
The audit shall examine the receipts and expenditures of the State Bar and the State Bar sections to ensure that the receipts of the sections are being applied, and their expenditures are being made, in compliance with subdivision (a) of Section 6031.5, and that the receipts of the sections are applied only to the work of the sections.
The audit also shall examine the receipts and expenditures of the State Bar to ensure that the funds collected on behalf of the Conference of Delegates of California Bar Associations as the independent successor entity to the former Conference of Delegates of the State Bar are conveyed to that entity, that the State Bar has been paid or reimbursed for the full cost of any administrative and support services provided to the successor entity, including the collection of fees or donations on its behalf, and that no mandatory dues are being used to fund the activities of the successor entity.
In selecting the accounting firm, the board shall consider the value of continuity, along with the risk that continued long-term engagements of an accounting firm may affect the independence of that firm.
(b)The board shall contract with the California State Auditors Office to conduct a performance audit of the State Bars operations from July 1, 2000, to December 31, 2000, inclusive. A copy of the performance audit shall be submitted by May 1, 2001, to the board, to the Chief Justice of the California Supreme Court, and to the Assembly and Senate Committees on Judiciary.
Every two years thereafter, the board shall contract with the California State Auditors Office to conduct a performance audit of the State Bars operations for the respective fiscal year, commencing with January 1, 2002, to December 31, 2002, inclusive. A copy of the performance audit shall be submitted within 120 days of the close of the fiscal year for which the audit was performed to the board, to the Chief Justice of the Supreme Court, and to the Assembly and Senate Committees on Judiciary.
For the purposes of this subdivision, the California State Auditors Office may contract with a third party to conduct the performance audit. This subdivision is not intended to reduce the number of audits the California State Auditors Office may otherwise be able to conduct.
SEC. 29.SEC. 29.The Legislature finds and declares that Sections 17 18 and 20 24 of this act, which amend Sections 6026.7 and 6086.5 of the Business and Professions Code, impose a limitation on the publics right of access to the meetings of public bodies or the writings of public officials and agencies within the meaning of Section 3 of Article I of the California Constitution. Pursuant to that constitutional provision, the Legislature makes the following findings to demonstrate the interest protected by this limitation and the need for protecting that interest:
In order to protect the decisionmaking process of the State Bar Court in a manner that is similar to the deliberative functions of other courts and in order to ensure that personal or sensitive information regarding discipline by the State Bar Court is kept confidential, including for persons participating in discussions and offers of settlement pursuant to arbitration or mediation, it is necessary to exempt the State Bar Court from the provision of the Bagley-Keene Open Meeting Act and the California Public Records Act.
The Legislature finds and declares all of the following:
(a)The protection of the public is required, by statute, to be the highest priority of the State Bar of California and must be the paramount focus of the State Bar, its employees, and, most importantly, its board of trustees. All other duties and activities of the State Bar are ancillary to its regulatory oversight of the states more than 250,000 attorneys, over 185,000 of whom are active members.
(b)Throughout its history, the State Bar has been the subject of substantial controversies, including allegations of serious fiscal and management improprieties, and most recently failure to properly protect the public against the unauthorized practice of law, including allowing hundreds of complaints to languish in a drawer.
(c)In May 2015, the California State Auditor released its biannual performance audit of the State Bar, reviewing the State Bars backlog of discipline cases and its recent $75,000,000 purchase and renovation of a building in Los Angeles at three times the cost originally estimated and requiring a loan against the Public Protection Fund, which is designed to be an emergency fund to protect the public in the event of a financial emergency. The audit uncovered significant, questionable decisions made by the State Bar in the handling of both matters, including that the State Bar had not fully or consistently reported its backlog of discipline cases and that, in order to reduce its backlog of discipline cases, the State Bar made questionable choices, potentially causing significant risk to the public.
(d)Most recently and without consultation with the Legislature, the State Bar chose to replace the loan on the Los Angeles building, along with a brand new loan for updating its San Francisco building, with a securitization on future members dues, potentially tying the hands of the Legislature in setting future dues amounts.
(e)As a result of the troubling findings of the audit, the Legislature, as part of the 2015 State Bar dues legislation, imposed important new preliminary reforms on the State Bar. First, the Legislature mandated that the State Bar be subject to both the California Public Records Act and the Bagley-Keene Open Meetings Act. These good government reforms help ensure the integrity, transparency, and accountability of the State Bar. Second, the Legislature directed the California State Auditor to conduct a full financial audit of the State Bar, which is due on May 15, 2016. Finally, the State Bar must develop a workforce plan for its attorney discipline system and a spending plan to determine the level for dues to recommend to the Legislature, which are both due on May 15, 2016. These reports should help inform the Legislature regarding the appropriate actions to take in its oversight responsibility of the State Bar and its own determination of the proper dues amount.
(f)In 2011, the Legislature directed the State Bar to establish a Governance in the Public Interest Task Force to make recommendations to the Governor, the Supreme Court, and the Legislature every three years, beginning May 15, 2014, for, among other things, enhancing the protection of the public and ensuring that protection of the public is the highest priority in the licensing, regulation, and discipline of attorneys, to be reviewed by the Assembly and Senate Committees on Judiciary in their regular consideration of the annual State Bar dues measure. That first report is now two years overdue and, although the Governance in the Public Interest Task Force finally began holding meetings this year, it appears that this already long overdue report will not be completed during this legislative session.
(g)It is the intent of the Legislature, in fulfilling its important oversight responsibility over the State Bar and the proper amount State Bar members must pay in annual dues, that this bill serve as the vehicle to implement possible recommendations for substantially improving the operations, effectiveness, and efficiency of the State Bar based on the 2016 California State Auditors audit of the State Bar, along with the State Bars discipline workforce and spending plans and any draft Governance Task Force report or other information, in order to ensure that the dues are the appropriate amount, that the State Bar becomes more accountable to the public, and that public protection is, and remains, the State Bars top priority.
SEC. 2.Section 6001 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:6001.The State Bar of California is a public corporation. It is hereinafter designated as the State Bar.
The State Bar has perpetual succession and a seal and it may sue and be sued. It may, for the purpose of carrying into effect and promoting its objectives:
(a)Make contracts.
(b)Borrow money, contract debts, issue bonds, notes and debentures and secure the payment or performance of its obligations.
(c)Own, hold, use, manage and deal in and with real and personal property.
(d)Construct, alter, maintain and repair buildings and other improvements to real property.
(e)Purchase, lease, obtain options upon, acquire by gift, bequest, devise or otherwise, any real or personal property or any interest therein.
(f)Sell, lease, exchange, convey, transfer, assign, encumber, pledge, dispose of any of its real or personal property or any interest therein, including without limitation all or any portion of its income or revenues from membership fees paid or payable by members.
(g)Do all other acts incidental to the foregoing or necessary or expedient for the administration of its affairs and the attainment of its purposes.
Pursuant to those powers enumerated in subdivisions (a) to (g), inclusive, it is recognized that the State Bar has authority to raise revenue in addition to that provided for in Section 6140 and other statutory provisions. The State Bar is empowered to raise that additional revenue by any lawful means. However, as of December 31, 2016, the State Bar shall not create any foundations or nonprofit corporations.
The State Bar shall conspicuously publicize to its members in the annual dues statement and other appropriate communications, including its Web site and electronic communications, that its members have the right to limit the sale or disclosure of member information not reasonably related to regulatory purposes. In those communications the State Bar shall note the location of the State Bars privacy policy, and shall also note the simple procedure by which a member may exercise his or her right to prohibit or restrict, at the members option, the sale or disclosure of member information not reasonably related to regulatory purposes. On or before May 1, 2005, the State Bar shall report to the Assembly and Senate Committees on Judiciary regarding the procedures that it has in place to ensure that members can appropriately limit the use of their member information not reasonably related to regulatory purposes, and the number of members choosing to utilize these procedures.
No law of this state restricting, or prescribing a mode of procedure for the exercise of powers of state public bodies or state agencies, or classes thereof, including, but not by way of limitation, the provisions contained in Division 3 (commencing with Section 11000), Division 4 (commencing with Section 16100), and Part 1 (commencing with Section 18000) and Part 2 (commencing with Section 18500) of Division 5, of Title 2 of the Government Code, shall be applicable to the State Bar, unless the Legislature expressly so declares. Notwithstanding the foregoing or any other law, pursuant to Sections 6026.7 and 6026.11, the State Bar is subject to the California Public Records Act (Chapter 3.5 (commencing with Section 6250) of Division 7 of Title 1 of the Government Code) and, commencing April 1, 2016, the Bagley-Keene Open Meeting Act (Article 9 (commencing with Section 11120) of Chapter 1 of Part 1 of Division 3 of Title 2 of the Government Code).
SEC. 3.Section 6001.3 is added to the Business and Professions Code, to read:6001.3.(a)There is hereby created, as of January 1, 2017, the California State Bar Governance Commission, consisting of nine members, who shall be appointed by February 1, 2017, and selected as follows:
(1)Two members appointed by the Governor.
(2)Three members appointed by the Chief Justice of the California Supreme Court.
(3)Two members appointed by the Speaker of the Assembly.
(4)Two members appointed by the Senate Committee on Rules.
(b)The chairperson of the commission shall be elected by the members of the commission and shall preside at meetings of the commission.
(c)Appointed members of the commission shall not receive a salary, but shall be entitled to a per diem allowance of fifty dollars ($50) for each days attendance at a meeting of the commission, not to exceed three hundred dollars ($300) in any month, and reimbursement for expenses incurred in the performance of their duties under this chapter, including travel and other necessary expenses.
(d)The commission may adopt bylaws for the regulation of its affairs and the conduct of its business.
(e)The commission shall meet on the call of the chairperson, at the request of a majority of the members, or at the request of the California Chief Justice of the Supreme Court. A majority of all members of the commission constitutes a quorum for the transaction of business.
(f)The State Bar shall furnish all administrative assistance required by the commission.
(g)The commission shall evaluate all issues of governance of the State Bar, including, but not limited to, a full review of other states with attorney regulatory structures that are different than the State Bar and a possible separation of the State Bars regulatory and trade association functions, in order to recommend the best governance structure for the State Bar to ensure that the protection of the public is the highest priority in the licensing, regulation, and discipline of attorneys and that the State Bar appropriately functions as a government agency subject to laws that apply to similar regulatory bodies. The commission shall, by April 30, 2017, provide a report to the Governor, the Chief Justice of the California Supreme Court, and the Senate and Assembly Committees on Judiciary on its recommendations, along with an implementation plan for those recommendations. If the commission does not reach a consensus on all of the recommendations in its report, the dissenting members of the commission may prepare and submit a dissenting report to the same entities described in this subdivision.
SEC. 3.SEC. 4.Section 6008.5 of the Business and Professions Code is repealed.SEC. 4.SEC. 5.Section 6009.7 of the Business and Professions Code is repealed.SEC. 5.SEC. 6.Section 6011 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:6011.(a)The board shall consist of no more than 19 members and no fewer than 13 members.
(b)It is the intent of the Legislature that the board consist of no more than 19 members and no fewer than 13 members during the period of transition from a 19-member board to a 13-member board. It is the intent of the Legislature that the board decrease its size without shortening, lengthening, or abolishing terms commencing prior to December 31, 2016, with the ultimate goal of instituting a 13-member board no later than October 31, 2019. It is the intent of the Legislature that this transition occur by the expiration of the terms of the elected members who are serving on the board as of December 31, 2016.
(c)Each member appointed after December 31, 2016, shall have demonstrated educational or experience expertise, or both, in at least one of the following:
(1)Public finance.
(2)Public administration.
(3)Business or financial management.
(4)State government, particularly prior regulatory experience.
(5)Legal ethics.
SEC. 6.SEC. 7.Section 6012 of the Business and Professions Code is repealed.SEC. 7.SEC. 8.Section 6013.2 of the Business and Professions Code is repealed.SEC. 9.Section 6013.3 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:6013.3.(a)One attorney member of the board shall be appointed by the Senate Committee on Rules and one attorney member shall be appointed by the Speaker of the Assembly. Rules.
(b)An attorney member appointed pursuant to this section shall serve for a term of three years. An appointed attorney member may be reappointed pursuant to this section.
SEC. 10.Section 6013.5 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:6013.5.Notwithstanding any other provision of law, six (a)Effective January 1, 2017, a minimum of seven members of the board shall be members of the public who have never been members of the State Bar or admitted to practice before any court in the United States. They shall be appointed through 1982 by the Governor, subject to the confirmation of the Senate.
Each
(b)Each of such these members shall serve for a term of three years, commencing at the conclusion of the annual meeting next succeeding his appointment, except that for the initial term after enactment of this section, two shall serve for one year, two for two years, and the other two for three years, as determined by lot. or her appointment.
In 1983
(c)Effective January 1, 2017, one public member shall be appointed by the Senate Committee on Rules and one two public member members shall be appointed by the Speaker of the Assembly.
For each of the years, 1984 and 1985, two
(d)Four public members shall be appointed by the Governor, subject to the confirmation of the Senate.
Each
(e)Each respective appointing authority shall fill any vacancy in and make any reappointment to each respective office.
(f)It is the intent of the Legislature that the increase of public members appointed by the Speaker of the Assembly, from one to two, as required by this measure adding this subdivision, occur at the expiration of the terms of the attorney members who are appointed by the Speaker of the Assembly and serving on the board as of December 31, 2016.
SEC. 8.SEC. 11.Section 6015 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:6015.No person is eligible for attorney membership on the board unless all of the following conditions are satisfied:
(a)He or she is an active member of the State Bar.
(b)Either:
(1)Prior to October 31, 2019, if elected, he or she maintains his or her principal office for the practice of law within the State Bar district from which he or she is elected.
(2)If appointed by the Supreme Court or the Legislature, he or she maintains his or her principal office for the practice of law within the State of California.
(c)If newly appointed after December 31, 2016, he or she satisfies the requirements of subdivision (c) of Section 6011.
SEC. 9.SEC. 12.Section 6016 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:6016.The term of office of each attorney member of the board shall commence at the conclusion of the annual meeting next succeeding his or her election or appointment, and he or she shall hold office until his or her successor is elected or appointed and qualified. For the purposes of this section, the time intervening between any two successive annual meetings shall be deemed to be one year.
The board of trustees may provide by rule for an interim board to act in the place and stead of the board when because of vacancies during terms of office there is less than a quorum of the board.
SEC. 10.SEC. 13.Section 6018 of the Business and Professions Code is repealed.SEC. 11.SEC. 14.Section 6019 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:6019.Each place upon the board for which a member is to be appointed shall for the purposes of the appointment be deemed a separate office.
SEC. 12.SEC. 15.Section 6021 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:6021.(a)(1)Within The Supreme Court shall select from its appointed members a president and a vice president to serve in the absence of the president.
(2)Within the period of 90 days next preceding the annual meeting, the board, at a meeting called for that purpose, shall elect the president, vice president, and select the treasurer for the ensuing year. The president, the vice president, and the treasurer shall be elected from among all members of the board.
(2)
(3)The newly elected president, vice president, and treasurer shall assume the duties of their respective offices at the conclusion of the annual meeting following their election. appointment or selection.
(b)The term of the board president shall be one year, except that he or she may be reelected reappointed to a second one-year term as the board president.
(c)Notwithstanding the provisions of Section 6011 regarding a 13-member board, if the president is elected from among those members of the board whose terms on the board expire by that year and has not been reappointed to another term under Section 6013.1 or 6013.5, the president shall serve as a 14th member of the board during his or her one-year term, and he or she may vote.
SEC. 13.SEC. 16.Section 6022 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:6022.The officers of the State Bar shall be selected annually by the board and need not be a member of the State Bar.
SEC. 14.SEC. 17.Section 6026.5 of the Business and Professions Code, as added by Section 3 of Chapter 537 of the Statutes of 2015, is repealed.SEC. 15.SEC. 18.Section 6026.7 of the Business and Professions Code, as added by Section 5 of Chapter 537 of the Statutes of 2015, is amended to read:6026.7.(a)The State Bar is subject to the Bagley-Keene Open Meeting Act (Article 9 (commencing with Section 11120) of Chapter 1 of Part 1 of Division 3 of Title 2 of the Government Code) and all meetings of the State Bar are subject to the Bagley-Keene Open Meeting Act.
(b)Notwithstanding any other law, the Bagley-Keene Open Meeting Act shall not apply to the Judicial Nominees Evaluation Commission, the Committee of Bar Examiners, or the State Bar Court.
(c)In addition to the grounds authorized in the Bagley-Keene Open Meeting Act, a closed session may be held for those meetings, or portions thereof, relating to both of the following:
(1)Appeals to the board from decisions of the Board of Legal Specialization refusing to certify or recertify an applicant or suspending or revoking a specialists certificate.
(2)The preparation, approval, grading, or administration of examinations for certification of a specialist.
SEC. 19.Section 6030 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:6030.(a)The board shall be charged with the executive function of the State Bar and the enforcement of the provisions of this chapter. The
(b)The violation or threatened violation of any provision of Articles 7 (commencing with Section 6125) and 9 (commencing with Section 6150) of this chapter may be enjoined in a civil action brought in the superior court by the State Bar and no undertaking shall be required of the State Bar.
(c)No motion of the board can be approved unless a majority of the public members approve the motion.
SEC. 16.SEC. 20.Section 6060.2 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:6060.2.(a)All investigations or proceedings conducted by the State Bar concerning the moral character of an applicant shall be confidential and shall not be disclosed pursuant to any state law, including, but not limited to, the California Public Records Act (Chapter 3.5 (commencing with Section 6250) of Division 7 of Title 1 of the Government Code) unless the applicant, in writing, waives the confidentiality.
(b)Notwithstanding subdivision (a), the records of the proceeding may be disclosed in response to either of the following:
(1)A lawfully issued subpoena.
(2)A written request from a government agency responsible for either the enforcement of civil or criminal laws or the professional licensing of individuals that is conducting an investigation about the applicant.
SEC. 17.SEC. 21.Section 6060.25 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:6060.25.(a)Notwithstanding any other law, any identifying information submitted by an applicant to the State Bar for admission and a license to practice law and all State Bar admission records, including, but not limited to, bar examination scores, law school grade point average (GPA), undergraduate GPA, Law School Admission Test scores, race or ethnicity, and any information contained within the State Bar Admissions database or any file or other data created by the State Bar with information submitted by the applicant that may identify an individual applicant, other than information described in subdivision (b), shall be confidential and shall not be disclosed pursuant to any state law, including, but not limited to, the California Public Records Act (Chapter 3.5 (commencing with Section 6250) of Division 7 of Title 1 of the Government Code).
(b)This section does not prohibit the disclosure of any of the following:
(1)The names of applicants who have passed any examination administered, given, or prescribed by the Committee of Bar Examiners.
(2)Information that is provided at the request of an applicant to another jurisdiction where the applicant is seeking admission to the practice of law.
(3)Information provided to a law school that is necessary for the purpose of the law schools compliance with accreditation or regulatory requirements.
(4)Information provided to the National Conference of Bar Examiners or a successor nonprofit organization in connection to the State Bars administration of any examination.
(c)Disclosure of any of the information in paragraphs (2) to (4), inclusive, of subdivision (b) shall not constitute a waiver under Section 6254.5 of the Government Code of the exemption from disclosure provided for in subdivision (a) of this section.
SEC. 22.Section 6075.6 is added to the Business and Professions Code, to read:6075.6.(a)(1)The Chief Justice of the California Supreme Court shall appoint a State Bar enforcement program monitor prior to March 31, 2017. The Chief Justice of the California Supreme Court shall advertise the availability of the position and conduct interviews of candidates for the position. The applicant for the position shall have investigative experience, shall be familiar with California laws and procedures, and, preferably, shall be familiar with the rules and procedures of the State Bar lawyer discipline system and relevant administrative procedures. The monitor may be a state employee or his or her services may be provided pursuant to contract.
(2)The Chief Justice of the California Supreme Court shall supervise the monitor and may terminate or dismiss him or her from this position.
(b)(1)The enforcement program monitor shall monitor and evaluate the disciplinary system and procedures of the State Bar. The enforcement program monitor shall make his or her highest priority the reform and reengineering of the State Bars enforcement program and operations and the improvement of the overall efficiency of the State Bars disciplinary system so that the State Bar is successfully and consistently protecting the public.
(2)This monitoring duty shall include, but not be limited to, the prioritization of cases most impacting public protection, improving the timeframe for the handling of complaints and in the rendering of initial decisions on complaints, the efficiency of the system, the fairness and courtesy given to complainants, the adequacy of the staffing and the budget allocated to the discipline section of the State Bar, the reduction of the complaint backlog, the consistency in the application of sanctions or discipline imposed, the implementation of laws affecting discipline and the State Bars operations, disciplinary standards and rules, staff concerns regarding disciplinary matters or procedures, and the State Bars cooperation with other governmental entities charged with enforcing related laws and regulations that affect members of the State Bar.
(3)The monitor shall exercise no authority over the State Bars discipline operations or staff, however, the State Bar and its staff shall cooperate with the program enforcement monitor, and the Bar shall provide data, information, and case files as requested by the enforcement program monitor to perform all of his or her duties. The enforcement program monitor shall have the same access to documents as the Chief Justice of the California Supreme Court.
(c)The enforcement program monitor shall submit an initial written report of his or her findings and conclusions to the State Bar, the Supreme Court, and the Legislature no later than October 1, 2019, and be available to make oral reports to each if requested to do so. The initial report shall include an analysis of the sources of information that resulted in each disciplinary action imposed since January 1, 2016. The monitor may also provide additional information to either the Supreme Court, the State Bar, or the Legislature at his or her discretion or at the request of the Supreme Court, the State Bar, or the Legislature. The program enforcement monitor shall make his or her reports available to the public or the media. The monitor shall make every effort to provide the State Bar with an opportunity to reply to any facts, findings, issues, or conclusions in his or her reports with which the State Bar may disagree.
(d)The enforcement program monitor shall issue a final report prior to March 31, 2020.
(e)This section shall become inoperative on March 31, 2020, and as of January 1, 2020, shall be repealed.
SEC. 18.SEC. 23.Section 6086.5 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:6086.5.The board of trustees shall establish a State Bar Court, to act in its place and stead in the determination of disciplinary and reinstatement proceedings and proceedings pursuant to subdivisions (b) and (c) of Section 6007 to the extent provided by rules adopted by the board of trustees pursuant to this chapter. In these proceedings the State Bar Court may exercise the powers and authority vested in the board of trustees by this chapter, including those powers and that authority vested in committees of, or established by, the board, except as limited by rules of the board of trustees within the scope of this chapter.
Access to records of the State Bar Court shall be governed by court rules and laws applicable to records of the judiciary and not the California Public Records Act (Chapter 3.5 (commencing with Section 6250) of Division 7 of Title 1 of the Government Code).
For the purposes of Sections 6007, 6043, 6049, 6049.2, 6050, 6051, 6052, 6077 (excluding the first sentence), 6078, 6080, 6081, and 6082, board includes the State Bar Court.
Nothing in this section shall authorize the State Bar Court to adopt rules of professional conduct or rules of procedure.
The Executive Committee of the State Bar Court may adopt rules of practice for the conduct of all proceedings within its jurisdiction. These rules may not conflict with the rules of procedure adopted by the board, unless approved by the Supreme Court.
SEC. 24.Section 6134 is added to the Business and Professions Code, to read:6134.(a)When the Office of the Chief Trial Counsel becomes aware of an allegation that a person not licensed to practice law in California has practiced or held himself or herself out as practicing law or entitled to practice law in the state, the offices intake unit shall open a nonattorney complaint against that person for evaluation and processing.
(b)The intake unit shall open a case record in the offices case management system with the complaint form received date. The complaint form received date shall be the date the State Bar first received the complaint. Evaluation and processing of the nonattorney complaint shall include, but not be limited to, all of the following:
(1)Creation of a summary of the allegation or allegations in the case record and assignment to staff, including inputting staff assignment codes into the case management system.
(2)Identifying the source of the complaint.
(3)Identifying the relevant practice area of law, such as immigration, loan modification, or debt resolution, and recording the relevant practice area of law in the case record.
(4)Identifying whether the allegations include potential identity theft of a licensed attorneys identity and, if so, contacting the potential victim attorney to verify whether the attorney is aware of the potential identify theft and whether he or she has notified law enforcement.
(5)Evaluating the nonattorney complaint for unauthorized practice of law allegations, which includes opening a corresponding attorney complaint case record, if appropriate, such as in the case in which the nonattorney complaint also identifies a licensed California attorney potentially aiding or abetting the person in the unauthorized practice of law.
(6)Seeking additional information from the complainant or other sources, such as the Internet, when the nonattorney complaint does not provide specific or sufficient facts to establish that the unauthorized practice of law may have occurred.
(7)Determining whether to forward the complaint to the enforcement unit for investigation.
(c)If the nonattorney complaint sufficiently alleges an unauthorized practice of law violation, the intake unit shall do both of the following:
(1)Forward the nonattorney complaint to the enforcement unit for further action.
(2)Refer the matter to law enforcement or other appropriate agency for consideration of criminal or other enforcement action, as specified in subdivisions (f) and (g).
(d)If the nonattorney complaint sufficiently alleges the use of notario, notario publico, or other words or phrases in violation of Section 6126.7 or there is other evidence of a violation of Section 6126.7, the intake unit shall forward the complaint to the enforcement unit for further action.
(e)If the nonattorney complaint does not sufficiently allege an unauthorized practice of law violation or a violation of Section 6126.7, the intake unit shall do all of the following:
(1)Notify the complainant in writing of the determination.
(2)Advise the complainant in writing of the opportunity to seek reconsideration of the determination.
(3)Process the case for closure, including updating the case record.
(f)The intake units staff shall resolve nonattorney complaints by either:
(1)Forwarding the nonattorney complaint to the offices enforcement unit.
(2)Closing the nonattorney complaint in the intake unit.
(g)(1)A nonattorney complaint alleging the unauthorized practice of law shall be presumed to warrant a law enforcement referral to federal, state, or local authorities, such as the United States Attorney, the Attorney General, the local district attorney, local county counsel, or local city attorney, for criminal or other enforcement action.
(2)After the intake unit forwards a nonattorney complaint, the offices enforcement unit shall make the referral required under paragraph (1), where appropriate, and shall coordinate with law enforcement, as appropriate, throughout the offices investigation of the nonattorney complaint.
(3)The intake unit may, where warranted, refer nonattorney complaints that do not allege the unauthorized practice of law to another regulatory agency, such as the Bureau of Real Estate, the Department of Consumer Affairs, the United States Securities and Exchange Commission, the Federal Trade Commission, and the United States Patent and Trademark Office.
(h)Staff of the intake unit shall evaluate nonattorney complaints and strive to meet all of the following in at least 90 percent of nonattorney complaints filed:
(1)Open a nonattorney complaint case record within five days from the complaint form received date, as defined in subdivision (b).
(2)Complete the initial legal review of the nonattorney complaint within 20 days from the complaint form received date.
(3)Process the nonattorney complaint to resolution, which means closing the case or forwarding the case for investigation, within 60 days from the complaint form received date.
(i)Staff of the intake unit shall maintain processing activities in the nonattorney complaint case record, including the recording and tracking of other regulatory agency referrals made in connection with a nonattorney complaint.
(j)All nonattorney complaints forwarded by the intake unit to the offices enforcement unit shall be investigated to determine whether there is evidence of the unauthorized practice of law or any violation of Section 6126.7. There shall be an appropriate law enforcement referral upon assignment to a staff member of the enforcement unit. Assigned enforcement unit staff shall update any law enforcement agency to which the complaint was referred with the status and findings of the investigation as it proceeds. Upon completion of an investigation, the assigned staff of the enforcement unit shall analyze the evidence to determine whether the evidence is sufficient to support formal proceedings in superior court.
(k)Enforcement unit staff shall complete nonattorney complaint investigations to resolution by one of the following:
(1)Filing enforcement proceedings in superior court.
(2)Issuing a cease and desist letter. Enforcement unit staff may issue a cease and desist letter where the unauthorized practice of law activity appears isolated in nature and unlikely to recur or where it otherwise appears that a cease and desist warning will sufficiently address and stop the activity at issue.
(3)Closing the complaint with no further action.
(l)Enforcement unit staff shall investigate nonattorney complaints adhering to the same backlog time standard applicable to attorney discipline complaints and shall resolve the complaint within six months from the complaint form received date.
(m)Intake unit staff and enforcement unit staff shall, as appropriate, maintain and update processing activities in the nonattorney case record, as follows:
(1)Record and track the number of superior court proceedings initiated pursuant to Section 6126.3.
(2)Record and track the number of superior court proceedings initiated pursuant to Section 6126.4.
(3)Record and track the number of superior court proceedings initiated pursuant to Section 6126.7.
(4)Record and track the number of superior court proceedings initiated pursuant to Section 6127.
(5)Record and track the number of law enforcement referrals made in connection with nonattorney complaints.
(6)Record and track the number of other agency referrals made in connection with nonattorney complaints.
(7)Record and track the number of cease and desist letters issued in connection with nonattorney complaints.
SEC. 19.SEC. 25.Section 6140 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:6140.(a)The board shall fix the annual membership fee for active members for 2017 at a sum not exceeding three hundred fifteen dollars ($315).
(b)The annual membership fee for active members is payable on or before the first day of February of each year. If the board finds it appropriate and feasible, it may provide by rule for payment of fees on an installment basis with interest, by credit card, or other means, and may charge members choosing any alternative method of payment an additional fee to defray costs incurred by that election.
(c)This section shall remain in effect only until January 1, 2018, and, as of that date, is repealed, unless a later enacted statute, that is enacted before January 1, 2018, deletes or extends that date.
SEC. 20.SEC. 26.Section 6140.56 is added to the Business and Professions Code, to read:6140.56.(a)To ensure that the Client Security Fund can adequately protect the public and relieve or mitigate financial losses caused by the dishonest conduct of members of the State Bar by paying claims in a timely manner, the State Bar shall conduct a thorough analysis of the Client Security Fund, including a determination of the ongoing needs of the fund to satisfy claims in a timely manner, a review of additional efforts that can be taken to increase the collection of payments from the responsible attorneys, and a review of other State Bar expenditures to determine whether other expenditures that do not directly impact the State Bars public protection functions, including, but not limited to, executive salaries and benefits, can be reduced or redirected in order to better fund the Client Security Fund through existing revenue, and, whether, after all other options have been fully and thoroughly exhausted, an increase in membership dues is necessary to ensure that the Client Security Fund can timely pay claims.
(b)The State Bar shall submit a report on its analysis of the Client Security Fund to the Legislature by March 15, 2017, so that the plans can be reviewed in conjunction with the bill that would authorize the imposition of the State Bars membership fee. The report shall be submitted in compliance with Section 9795 of the Government Code.
(c)For purposes of this section, timely manner means within 12 months from the time the claim is received by the State Bar.
SEC. 27.Section 6145 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:6145.(a)The board shall engage the services of an independent national or regional public accounting firm with at least five years of experience in governmental auditing contract with the California State Auditors Office for an audit of its revenues, expenditures, reserves, and its financial statement for each fiscal year. The financial statement shall be promptly certified under oath by the Treasurer of the State Bar, and a copy of the audit and financial statement shall be submitted within 120 days of the close of the fiscal year to the board, to the Chief Justice of the Supreme Court, and to the Assembly and Senate Committees on Judiciary.
The audit shall examine the receipts and expenditures of the State Bar and the State Bar sections to ensure that the receipts of the sections are being applied, and their expenditures are being made, in compliance with subdivision (a) of Section 6031.5, and that the receipts of the sections are applied only to the work of the sections.
The audit also shall examine the receipts and expenditures of the State Bar to ensure that the funds collected on behalf of the Conference of Delegates of California Bar Associations as the independent successor entity to the former Conference of Delegates of the State Bar are conveyed to that entity, that the State Bar has been paid or reimbursed for the full cost of any administrative and support services provided to the successor entity, including the collection of fees or donations on its behalf, and that no mandatory dues are being used to fund the activities of the successor entity.
In selecting the accounting firm, the board shall consider the value of continuity, along with the risk that continued long-term engagements of an accounting firm may affect the independence of that firm.
This subdivision is not intended to reduce the number of audits the California State Auditors Office may otherwise be able to conduct.
(b)The board shall contract with the California State Auditors Office to conduct a performance audit of the State Bars operations from July 1, 2000, to December 31, 2000, inclusive. A copy of the performance audit shall be submitted by May 1, 2001, to the board, to the Chief Justice of the Supreme Court, and to the Assembly and Senate Committees on Judiciary.
Every two years thereafter, the board shall contract with the California State Auditors Office to conduct a performance audit of the State Bars operations for the respective fiscal year, commencing with January 1, 2002, to December 31, 2002, inclusive. A copy of the performance audit shall be submitted within 120 days of the close of the fiscal year for which the audit was performed to the board, to the Chief Justice of the Supreme Court, and to the Assembly and Senate Committees on Judiciary.
For the performance audit due to the board, to the Chief Justice of the California Supreme Court, and to the Assembly and Senate Committees on Judiciary in 2017, the California State Auditor shall review all of the State Bars expenses, including, but not limited to, executive salaries and benefits, outside contracts, and real estate holdings, to determine the expenses that are appropriate and necessary to protect the public and what the appropriate level of member dues should be.
For the purposes of this subdivision, the California State Auditors Office may contract with a third party to conduct the performance audit. This subdivision is not intended to reduce the number of audits the California State Auditors Office may otherwise be able to conduct.
(c)Effective January 1, 2016, the board shall contract with the California State Auditors Office to conduct an in-depth financial audit of the State Bar, including an audit of its financial statement, internal controls, and relevant management practices. The contract shall include reimbursement for the California State Auditors Office for the costs of conducting the audit. The audit shall, at a minimum, examine the revenues, expenditures, and reserves of the State Bar, including all fund transfers. The California State Auditors Office shall commence the audit no later than January 1, 2016, and a copy of the audit shall be submitted by May 15, 2016, to the board, the Chief Justice of the Supreme Court, and to the Assembly and Senate Committees on Judiciary. The audit shall be submitted in compliance with Section 9795 of the Government Code. This subdivision shall cease to be operative January 1, 2017.
(c)This section shall become inoperative on January 1, 2021, and as of that date is repealed.
SEC. 28.Section 6145 is added to the Business and Professions Code, to read:6145.(a)The board shall engage the services of an independent national or regional public accounting firm with at least five years of experience in governmental auditing for an audit of its financial statement for each fiscal year. The financial statement shall be promptly certified under oath by the Treasurer of the State Bar, and a copy of the audit and financial statement shall be submitted within 120 days of the close of the fiscal year to the board, to the Chief Justice of the California Supreme Court, and to the Assembly and Senate Committees on Judiciary.
The audit shall examine the receipts and expenditures of the State Bar and the State Bar sections to ensure that the receipts of the sections are being applied, and their expenditures are being made, in compliance with subdivision (a) of Section 6031.5, and that the receipts of the sections are applied only to the work of the sections.
The audit also shall examine the receipts and expenditures of the State Bar to ensure that the funds collected on behalf of the Conference of Delegates of California Bar Associations as the independent successor entity to the former Conference of Delegates of the State Bar are conveyed to that entity, that the State Bar has been paid or reimbursed for the full cost of any administrative and support services provided to the successor entity, including the collection of fees or donations on its behalf, and that no mandatory dues are being used to fund the activities of the successor entity.
In selecting the accounting firm, the board shall consider the value of continuity, along with the risk that continued long-term engagements of an accounting firm may affect the independence of that firm.
(b)The board shall contract with the California State Auditors Office to conduct a performance audit of the State Bars operations from July 1, 2000, to December 31, 2000, inclusive. A copy of the performance audit shall be submitted by May 1, 2001, to the board, to the Chief Justice of the California Supreme Court, and to the Assembly and Senate Committees on Judiciary.
Every two years thereafter, the board shall contract with the California State Auditors Office to conduct a performance audit of the State Bars operations for the respective fiscal year, commencing with January 1, 2002, to December 31, 2002, inclusive. A copy of the performance audit shall be submitted within 120 days of the close of the fiscal year for which the audit was performed to the board, to the Chief Justice of the Supreme Court, and to the Assembly and Senate Committees on Judiciary.
For the purposes of this subdivision, the California State Auditors Office may contract with a third party to conduct the performance audit. This subdivision is not intended to reduce the number of audits the California State Auditors Office may otherwise be able to conduct.
SEC. 21.SEC. 29.The Legislature finds and declares that Sections 17 and 20 of this act, which amend Sections 6026.7 and 6086.5 of the Business and Professions Code, impose a limitation on the publics right of access to the meetings of public bodies or the writings of public officials and agencies within the meaning of Section 3 of Article I of the California Constitution. Pursuant to that constitutional provision, the Legislature makes the following findings to demonstrate the interest protected by this limitation and the need for protecting that interest:
In order to protect the decisionmaking process of the State Bar Court in a manner that is similar to the deliberative functions of other courts and in order to ensure that personal or sensitive information regarding discipline by the State Bar Court is kept confidential, including for persons participating in discussions and offers of settlement pursuant to arbitration or mediation, it is necessary to exempt the State Bar Court from the provision of the Bagley-Keene Open Meeting Act and the California Public Records Act.
The Legislature finds and declares all of the following:
(a)The protection of the public is required, by statute, to be the highest priority of the State Bar of California and must be the paramount focus of the State Bar, its employees, and, most importantly, its board of trustees. All other duties and activities of the State Bar are ancillary to its regulatory oversight of the states more than 250,000 attorneys, over 185,000 of whom are active members.
(b)Throughout its history, the State Bar has been the subject of substantial controversies, including allegations of serious fiscal and management improprieties, and most recently failure to properly protect the public against the unauthorized practice of law, including allowing hundreds of complaints to languish in a drawer.
(c)In May 2015, the California State Auditor released its biannual performance audit of the State Bar, reviewing the State Bars backlog of discipline cases and its recent $75,000,000 purchase and renovation of a building in Los Angeles at three times the cost originally estimated and requiring a loan against the Public Protection Fund, which is designed to be an emergency fund to protect the public in the event of a financial emergency. The audit uncovered significant, questionable decisions made by the State Bar in the handling of both matters, including that the State Bar had not fully or consistently reported its backlog of discipline cases and that, in order to reduce its backlog of discipline cases, the State Bar made questionable choices, potentially causing significant risk to the public.
(d)Most recently and without consultation with the Legislature, the State Bar chose to replace the loan on the Los Angeles building, along with a brand new loan for updating its San Francisco building, with a securitization on future members dues, potentially tying the hands of the Legislature in setting future dues amounts.
(e)As a result of the troubling findings of the audit, the Legislature, as part of the 2015 State Bar dues legislation, imposed important new preliminary reforms on the State Bar. First, the Legislature mandated that the State Bar be subject to both the California Public Records Act and the Bagley-Keene Open Meetings Act. These good government reforms help ensure the integrity, transparency, and accountability of the State Bar. Second, the Legislature directed the California State Auditor to conduct a full financial audit of the State Bar, which is due on May 15, 2016. Finally, the State Bar must develop a workforce plan for its attorney discipline system and a spending plan to determine the level for dues to recommend to the Legislature, which are both due on May 15, 2016. These reports should help inform the Legislature regarding the appropriate actions to take in its oversight responsibility of the State Bar and its own determination of the proper dues amount.
(f)In 2011, the Legislature directed the State Bar to establish a Governance in the Public Interest Task Force to make recommendations to the Governor, the Supreme Court, and the Legislature every three years, beginning May 15, 2014, for, among other things, enhancing the protection of the public and ensuring that protection of the public is the highest priority in the licensing, regulation, and discipline of attorneys, to be reviewed by the Assembly and Senate Committees on Judiciary in their regular consideration of the annual State Bar dues measure. That first report is now two years overdue and, although the Governance in the Public Interest Task Force finally began holding meetings this year, it appears that this already long overdue report will not be completed during this legislative session.
(g)It is the intent of the Legislature, in fulfilling its important oversight responsibility over the State Bar and the proper amount State Bar members must pay in annual dues, that this bill serve as the vehicle to implement possible recommendations for substantially improving the operations, effectiveness, and efficiency of the State Bar based on the 2016 California State Auditors audit of the State Bar, along with the State Bars discipline workforce and spending plans and any draft Governance Task Force report or other information, in order to ensure that the dues are the appropriate amount, that the State Bar becomes more accountable to the public, and that public protection is, and remains, the State Bars top priority.
SEC. 2.Section 6001 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:6001.The State Bar of California is a public corporation. It is hereinafter designated as the State Bar.
The State Bar has perpetual succession and a seal and it may sue and be sued. It may, for the purpose of carrying into effect and promoting its objectives:
(a)Make contracts.
(b)Borrow money, contract debts, issue bonds, notes and debentures and secure the payment or performance of its obligations.
(c)Own, hold, use, manage and deal in and with real and personal property.
(d)Construct, alter, maintain and repair buildings and other improvements to real property.
(e)Purchase, lease, obtain options upon, acquire by gift, bequest, devise or otherwise, any real or personal property or any interest therein.
(f)Sell, lease, exchange, convey, transfer, assign, encumber, pledge, dispose of any of its real or personal property or any interest therein, including without limitation all or any portion of its income or revenues from membership fees paid or payable by members.
(g)Do all other acts incidental to the foregoing or necessary or expedient for the administration of its affairs and the attainment of its purposes.
Pursuant to those powers enumerated in subdivisions (a) to (g), inclusive, it is recognized that the State Bar has authority to raise revenue in addition to that provided for in Section 6140 and other statutory provisions. The State Bar is empowered to raise that additional revenue by any lawful means, including, but not limited to, the creation of foundations or not-for-profit corporations.
The State Bar shall conspicuously publicize to its members in the annual dues statement and other appropriate communications, including its Web site and electronic communications, that its members have the right to limit the sale or disclosure of member information not reasonably related to regulatory purposes. In those communications the State Bar shall note the location of the State Bars privacy policy, and shall also note the simple procedure by which a member may exercise his or her right to prohibit or restrict, at the members option, the sale or disclosure of member information not reasonably related to regulatory purposes. On or before May 1, 2005, the State Bar shall report to the Assembly and Senate Committees on Judiciary regarding the procedures that it has in place to ensure that members can appropriately limit the use of their member information not reasonably related to regulatory purposes, and the number of members choosing to utilize these procedures.
No law of this state restricting, or prescribing a mode of procedure for the exercise of powers of state public bodies or state agencies, or classes thereof, including, but not by way of limitation, the provisions contained in Division 3 (commencing with Section 11000), Division 4 (commencing with Section 16100), and Part 1 (commencing with Section 18000) and Part 2 (commencing with Section 18500) of Division 5, of Title 2 of the Government Code, shall be applicable to the State Bar, unless the Legislature expressly so declares. Notwithstanding the foregoing or any other law, pursuant to Sections 6026.7 and 6026.11, the State Bar is subject to the California Public Records Act (Chapter 3.5 (commencing with Section 6250) of Division 7 of Title 1 of the Government Code) and, commencing April 1, 2016, the Bagley-Keene Open Meeting Act (Article 9 (commencing with Section 11120) of Chapter 1 of Part 1 of Division 3 of Title 2 of the Government Code).
SEC. 2.SEC. 3.Section 6008.5 of the Business and Professions Code is repealed.SEC. 4.Section 6009.7 of the Business and Professions Code is repealed.6009.7.(a)(1)The State Bar shall determine the manner by which to reduce the board of trustees from 23 members to 19 members, as described in Section 6011, pursuant to the election and appointment processes specified in Sections 6012, 6013.1, 6013.2, and 6013.3.
(2)The State Bar shall develop a plan for implementing the transition to a 19-member board by January 31, 2012.
(3)By January 31, 2012, the State Bar shall submit a written report to the Senate and Assembly Committees on Judiciary that includes, but is not limited to, the implementation plan described in paragraph (2).
(b)The State Bar shall complete the transition to a 19-member board no later than October 31, 2014.
(c)The State Bar shall not change, reduce, shorten, lengthen, or abolish the terms of board members commencing prior to December 31, 2011, or force any board member to resign in order to institute a 19-member board pursuant to this section.
(d)The State Bar shall report annually to the Senate and Assembly Committees on Judiciary on its progress toward implementing the transition to a 19-member board.
SEC. 5.Section 6011 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:6011.(a)The board shall consist of no more than 23 19 members and no less fewer than 19 13 members.
(b)It is the intent of the Legislature that the board consist of no more than 23 19 members and no less fewer than 19 13 members during the period of transition from a 23-member 19-member board to a 19-member board, as described in Section 6009.7. 13-member board. It is the intent of the Legislature that the board, pursuant to the plan developed by the State Bar as described in Section 6009.7, gradually board decrease its size without shortening, lengthening, or abolishing terms commencing prior to December 31, 2011, 2016, with the ultimate goal of instituting a 19-member 13-member board no later than October 31, 2014, pursuant to Section 6009.7. 2019. It is the intent of the Legislature that this transition occur by the expiration of the terms of the elected members who are serving on the board as of December 31, 2016.
(c)Each member appointed after December 31, 2016, shall have demonstrated educational or experience expertise, or both, in at least one of the following:
(1)Public finance.
(2)Public administration.
(3)Business or financial management.
(4)State government, particularly prior regulatory experience.
(5)Legal ethics.
SEC. 6.Section 6012 of the Business and Professions Code is repealed.6012.(a)State Bar Districts, as they existed on December 31, 2011, pursuant to Section 6012.5, as added by Chapter 1223 of the Statutes of 1989, shall cease, pursuant to the act that added this section, for purposes of the election of attorney members of the board. However, attorney members who were elected in 2009, 2010, or 2011 to serve for a three-year term commencing at the conclusion of the annual meeting held in those years shall be eligible to serve their full three-year terms.
(b)Commencing on January 1, 2012, State Bar Districts shall be based on the six court of appeal districts as constituted pursuant to Section 69100 of the Government Code, as they existed on December 31, 2011. The board shall provide for the election of six attorney members of the board from these six State Bar Districts as specified in Section 6013.2.
SEC. 7.Section 6013.2 of the Business and Professions Code is repealed.6013.2.(a)Six members of the board shall be attorneys elected from the State Bar Districts created by the board pursuant to Section 6012.
(b)An attorney member elected pursuant to this section shall serve for a term of three years. An elected attorney member may run for reelection, but may be reelected to only serve one additional term.
SEC. 8.Section 6015 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:6015.No person is eligible for attorney membership on the board unless both all of the following conditions are satisfied:
(a)He or she is an active member of the State Bar.
(b)Either:
(1)If Prior to October 31, 2019, if elected, he or she maintains his or her principal office for the practice of law within the State Bar district from which he or she is elected.
(2)If appointed by the Supreme Court or the Legislature, he or she maintains his or her principal office for the practice of law within the State of California.
(c)If newly appointed after December 31, 2016, he or she satisfies the requirements of subdivision (c) of Section 6011.
SEC. 9.Section 6016 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:6016.The term of office of each attorney member of the board shall commence at the conclusion of the annual meeting next succeeding his or her election or appointment, and he or she shall hold office until his or her successor is elected or appointed and qualified. For the purposes of this section, the time intervening between any two successive annual meetings shall be deemed to be one year.
Except as specified in Section 6013.1, vacancies in the board of trustees shall be filled by the board by special election or by appointment for the unexpired term.
The board of trustees may provide by rule for an interim board to act in the place and stead of the board when because of vacancies during terms of office there is less than a quorum of the board.
SEC. 10.Section 6018 of the Business and Professions Code is repealed.6018.Nominations of elected members of the board shall be by petition signed by at least 20 persons entitled to vote for such nominees.
Only active members of the State Bar maintaining their principal offices for the practice of the law in the respective State Bar districts shall be entitled to vote for the member or members of the board therefrom.
SEC. 11.Section 6019 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:6019.Each place upon the board for which a member is to be elected or appointed shall for the purposes of the election or appointment be deemed a separate office.
If only one member seeks election to an office, the member is deemed elected. If two or more members seek election to the same office, the election shall be by ballot. The ballots shall be distributed to those entitled to vote at least twenty days prior to the date of canvassing the ballots and shall be returned to a site or sites designated by the State Bar, where they shall be canvassed at least five days prior to the ensuing annual meeting. At the annual meeting, the count shall be certified and the result officially declared.
In all other respects the elections shall be as the board may by rule direct.
SEC. 12.Section 6021 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:6021.(a)(1)Within the period of 90 days next preceding the annual meeting, the board, at a meeting called for that purpose, shall elect the president, vice president, and treasurer for the ensuing year. The president, the vice president, and the treasurer shall be elected from among all members of the board.
(2)The newly elected president, vice president, and treasurer shall assume the duties of their respective offices at the conclusion of the annual meeting following their election.
(b)The term of the board president shall be one year, except that he or she may be reelected to a second one-year term as the board president.
(c)Notwithstanding the provisions of Sections 6009.7 and Section 6011 regarding a 19-member 13-member board, if the president is elected from among those members of the board whose terms on the board expire by that year and has not been reelected or reappointed to another term under Section 6013.1, 6013.2, 6013.3, 6013.1 or 6013.5, the president shall serve as a 20th 14th member of the board during his or her one-year term, and he or she may vote.
SEC. 13.Section 6022 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:6022.The secretary officers of the State Bar shall be selected annually by the board and need not be a member of the State Bar.
SEC. 14.Section 6026.5 of the Business and Professions Code, as added by Section 3 of Chapter 537 of the Statutes of 2015, is repealed.6026.5.(a)Pursuant to Section 6026.7, every meeting of the board shall be open to the public except those meetings, or portions thereof, relating to:
(1)Consultation with counsel concerning pending or prospective litigation.
(2)Involuntary enrollment of active members as inactive members due to mental infirmity or illness or addiction to intoxicants or drugs.
(3)The qualifications of judicial appointees, nominees, or candidates.
(4)The appointment, employment, or dismissal of an employee, consultant, or officer of the State Bar or to hear complaints or charges brought against such employee, consultant, or officer, unless such person requests a public hearing.
(5)Disciplinary investigations and proceedings, including resignations with disciplinary investigations or proceedings pending, and reinstatement proceedings.
(6)Appeals to the board from decisions of the Board of Legal Specialization refusing to certify or recertify an applicant or suspending or revoking a specialists certificate.
(7)Appointments to or removals from committees, boards, or other entities.
(8)Joint meetings with agencies provided in Article VI of the California Constitution.
(b)This section shall become operative on April 1, 2016.
SEC. 15.Section 6026.7 of the Business and Professions Code, as added by Section 5 of Chapter 537 of the Statutes of 2015, is amended to read:6026.7.(a)The State Bar is subject to the Bagley-Keene Open Meeting Act (Article 9 (commencing with Section 11120) of Chapter 1 of Part 1 of Division 3 of Title 2 of the Government Code) and all meetings of the State Bar are subject to the Bagley-Keene Open Meeting Act.
(b)Notwithstanding any other law, the Bagley-Keene Open Meeting Act shall not apply to the Judicial Nominees Evaluation Commission or Commission, the Committee of Bar Examiners. Examiners, or the State Bar Court.
(c)This section shall become operative on April 1, 2016.
(c)In addition to the grounds authorized in the Bagley-Keene Open Meeting Act, a closed session may be held for those meetings, or portions thereof, relating to both of the following:
(1)Appeals to the board from decisions of the Board of Legal Specialization refusing to certify or recertify an applicant or suspending or revoking a specialists certificate.
(2)The preparation, approval, grading, or administration of examinations for certification of a specialist.
SEC. 16.Section 6060.2 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:6060.2.(a)All investigations or proceedings conducted by the State Bar concerning the moral character of an applicant shall be confidential and shall not be disclosed pursuant to any state law, including, but not limited to, the California Public Records Act (Chapter 3.5 (commencing with Section 6250) of Division 7 of Title 1 of the Government Code) unless the applicant, in writing, waives the confidentiality. However, the
(b)Notwithstanding subdivision (a), the records of the proceeding may be subject disclosed in response to lawfully either of the following:
(1)A lawfully issued subpoenas. subpoena.
(2)A written request from a government agency responsible for either the enforcement of civil or criminal laws or the professional licensing of individuals that is conducting an investigation about the applicant.
SEC. 17.Section 6060.25 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:6060.25.(a)Notwithstanding any other law, any identifying information submitted by an applicant to the State Bar for admission and a license to practice law and all State Bar admission records, including, but not limited to, bar examination scores, law school grade point average (GPA), undergraduate GPA, Law School Admission Test scores, race or ethnicity, and any information contained within the State Bar Admissions database or any file or other data created by the State Bar with information submitted by the applicant that may identify an individual applicant, other than information described in subdivision (b), shall be confidential and shall not be disclosed pursuant to any state law, including, but not limited to, the California Public Records Act (Chapter 3.5 (commencing with Section 6250) of Division 7 of Title 1 of the Government Code).
(b)This section does not prohibit the disclosure of any of the following:
(1)The names of applicants who have passed any examination administered, given, or prescribed by the Committee of Bar Examiners.
(2)Information that is provided at the request of an applicant to another jurisdiction where the applicant is seeking admission to the practice of law.
(3)Information provided to a law school that is necessary for the purpose of the law schools compliance with accreditation or regulatory requirements.
(4)Information provided to the National Conference of Bar Examiners or a successor nonprofit organization in connection to the State Bars administration of any examination.
(c)Disclosure of any of the information in paragraphs (2) to (4), inclusive, of subdivision (b) shall not constitute a waiver under Section 6254.5 of the Government Code of the exemption from disclosure provided for in subdivision (a) of this section.
SEC. 18.Section 6086.5 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:6086.5.The board of trustees shall establish a State Bar Court, to act in its place and stead in the determination of disciplinary and reinstatement proceedings and proceedings pursuant to subdivisions (b) and (c) of Section 6007 to the extent provided by rules adopted by the board of trustees pursuant to this chapter. In these proceedings the State Bar Court may exercise the powers and authority vested in the board of trustees by this chapter, including those powers and that authority vested in committees of, or established by, the board, except as limited by rules of the board of trustees within the scope of this chapter.
Access to records of the State Bar Court shall be governed by court rules and laws applicable to records of the judiciary and not the California Public Records Act (Chapter 3.5 (commencing with Section 6250) of Division 7 of Title 1 of the Government Code).
For the purposes of Sections 6007, 6043, 6049, 6049.2, 6050, 6051, 6052, 6077 (excluding the first sentence), 6078, 6080, 6081, and 6082, board includes the State Bar Court.
Nothing in this section shall authorize the State Bar Court to adopt rules of professional conduct or rules of procedure.
The Executive Committee of the State Bar Court may adopt rules of practice for the conduct of all proceedings within its jurisdiction. These rules may not conflict with the rules of procedure adopted by the board, unless approved by the Supreme Court.
SEC. 3.SEC. 19.Section 6140 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:6140.(a)The board shall fix the annual membership fee for active members for 2017 at a sum not exceeding three hundred fifteen dollars ($315).
(b)The annual membership fee for active members is payable on or before the first day of February of each year. If the board finds it appropriate and feasible, it may provide by rule for payment of fees on an installment basis with interest, by credit card, or other means, and may charge members choosing any alternative method of payment an additional fee to defray costs incurred by that election.
(c)This section shall remain in effect only until January 1, 2018, and, as of that date, is repealed, unless a later enacted statute, that is enacted before January 1, 2018, deletes or extends that date.
SEC. 20.Section 6140.56 is added to the Business and Professions Code, to read:6140.56.(a)To ensure that the Client Security Fund can adequately protect the public and relieve or mitigate financial losses caused by the dishonest conduct of members of the State Bar by paying claims in a timely manner, the State Bar shall conduct a thorough analysis of the Client Security Fund, including a determination of the ongoing needs of the fund to satisfy claims in a timely manner, a review of additional efforts that can be taken to increase the collection of payments from the responsible attorneys, and a review of other State Bar expenditures to determine whether other expenditures that do not directly impact the State Bars public protection functions, including, but not limited to, executive salaries and benefits, can be reduced or redirected in order to better fund the Client Security Fund through existing revenue, and, whether, after all other options have been fully and thoroughly exhausted, an increase in membership dues is necessary to ensure that the Client Security Fund can timely pay claims.
(b)The State Bar shall submit a report on its analysis of the Client Security Fund to the Legislature by March 15, 2017, so that the plans can be reviewed in conjunction with the bill that would authorize the imposition of the State Bars membership fee. The report shall be submitted in compliance with Section 9795 of the Government Code.
(c)For purposes of this section, timely manner means within 12 months from the time the claim is received by the State Bar.
SEC. 21.The Legislature finds and declares that Sections 17 and 20 of this act, which amend Sections 6026.7 and 6086.5 of the Business and Professions Code, impose a limitation on the publics right of access to the meetings of public bodies or the writings of public officials and agencies within the meaning of Section 3 of Article I of the California Constitution. Pursuant to that constitutional provision, the Legislature makes the following findings to demonstrate the interest protected by this limitation and the need for protecting that interest:
In order to protect the decisionmaking process of the State Bar Court in a manner that is similar to the deliberative functions of other courts and in order to ensure that personal or sensitive information regarding discipline by the State Bar Court is kept confidential, including for persons participating in discussions and offers of settlement pursuant to arbitration or mediation, it is necessary to exempt the State Bar Court from the provision of the Bagley-Keene Open Meeting Act and the California Public Records Act.
The Legislature finds and declares all of the following:
(a)The protection of the public is required, by statute, to be the highest priority of the State Bar of California and must be the paramount focus of the State Bar, its employees, and, most importantly, its board of trustees. All other duties and activities of the State Bar are ancillary to its regulatory oversight of the states more than 250,000 attorneys, over 185,000 of whom are active members.
(b)Throughout its history, the State Bar has been the subject of substantial controversies, including allegations of serious fiscal and management improprieties, and most recently failure to properly protect the public against the unauthorized practice of law, including allowing hundreds of complaints to languish in a drawer.
(c)In May 2015, the California State Auditor released its biannual performance audit of the State Bar, reviewing the State Bars backlog of discipline cases and its recent $75,000,000 purchase and renovation of a building in Los Angeles at three times the cost originally estimated and requiring a loan against the Public Protection Fund, which is designed to be an emergency fund to protect the public in the event of a financial emergency. The audit uncovered significant, questionable decisions made by the State Bar in the handling of both matters, including that the State Bar had not fully or consistently reported its backlog of discipline cases and that, in order to reduce its backlog of discipline cases, the State Bar made questionable choices, potentially causing significant risk to the public.
(d)Most recently and without consultation with the Legislature, the State Bar chose to replace the loan on the Los Angeles building, along with a brand new loan for updating its San Francisco building, with a securitization on future members dues, potentially tying the hands of the Legislature in setting future dues amounts.
(e)As a result of the troubling findings of the audit, the Legislature, as part of the 2015 State Bar dues legislation, imposed important new preliminary reforms on the State Bar. First, the Legislature mandated that the State Bar be subject to both the California Public Records Act and the Bagley-Keene Open Meetings Act. These good government reforms help ensure the integrity, transparency, and accountability of the State Bar. Second, the Legislature directed the California State Auditor to conduct a full financial audit of the State Bar, which is due on May 15, 2016. Finally, the State Bar must develop a workforce plan for its attorney discipline system and a spending plan to determine the level for dues to recommend to the Legislature, which are both due on May 15, 2016. These reports should help inform the Legislature regarding the appropriate actions to take in its oversight responsibility of the State Bar and its own determination of the proper dues amount.
(f)In 2011, the Legislature directed the State Bar to establish a Governance in the Public Interest Task Force to make recommendations to the Governor, the Supreme Court, and the Legislature every three years, beginning May 15, 2014, for, among other things, enhancing the protection of the public and ensuring that protection of the public is the highest priority in the licensing, regulation, and discipline of attorneys, to be reviewed by the Assembly and Senate Committees on Judiciary in their regular consideration of the annual State Bar dues measure. That first report is now two years overdue and, although the Governance in the Public Interest Task Force finally began holding meetings this year, it appears that this already long overdue report will not be completed during this legislative session.
(g)It is the intent of the Legislature, in fulfilling its important oversight responsibility over the State Bar and the proper amount State Bar members must pay in annual dues, that this bill serve as the vehicle to implement possible recommendations for substantially improving the operations, effectiveness, and efficiency of the State Bar based on the 2016 California State Auditors audit of the State Bar, along with the State Bars discipline workforce and spending plans and any draft Governance Task Force report or other information, in order to ensure that the dues are the appropriate amount, that the State Bar becomes more accountable to the public, and that public protection is, and remains, the State Bars top priority.
SEC. 2.Section 6008.5 of the Business and Professions Code is repealed.6008.5.Whenever the board has pledged, placed a charge upon, or otherwise made available all or any portion of the income or revenue from membership fees for the payment of security of an obligation of the State Bar or any interest thereon, and so long as any such obligation or any interest thereon remains unpaid, the Legislature shall not reduce the maximum membership fee below the maximum in effect at the time such obligation is created or incurred, and the provisions of this section shall constitute a covenant to the holder or holders of any such obligation.
SECTION 1.SEC. 3.Section 6140 of the Business and Professions Code is amended to read:6140.(a)The board shall fix the annual membership fee for active members for 2017 at a sum not exceeding three hundred fifteen dollars ($315).
(b)The annual membership fee for active members is payable on or before the first day of February of each year. If the board finds it appropriate and feasible, it may provide by rule for payment of fees on an installment basis with interest, by credit card, or other means, and may charge members choosing any alternative method of payment an additional fee to defray costs incurred by that election.
(c)This section shall remain in effect only until January 1, 2018, and, as of that date, is repealed, unless a later enacted statute, that is enacted before January 1, 2018, deletes or extends that date.
(a)The board shall fix the annual membership fee for active members for 2016 2017 at a sum not exceeding three hundred fifteen dollars ($315).
(b)The annual membership fee for active members is payable on or before the first day of February of each year. If the board finds it appropriate and feasible, it may provide by rule for payment of fees on an installment basis with interest, by credit card, or other means, and may charge members choosing any alternative method of payment an additional fee to defray costs incurred by that election.
(c)This section shall remain in effect only until January 1, 2017, 2018, and, as of that date, is repealed, unless a later enacted statute, that is enacted before January 1, 2017, 2018, deletes or extends that date.
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Aug 31, 2016 | (Ayes 26. Noes 13. Page 5586.) |
| Jun 2, 2016 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Senate. (Ayes 79. Noes 0.) |
| Jun 2, 2016 | Reconsideration granted. |
| Jun 2, 2016 | Reconsideration granted. (Page 5168.) |
| Jun 6, 2016 | In Senate. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. |
| Jun 9, 2016 | Referred to Com. on JUD. |
| Jun 28, 2016 | In committee: Set, first hearing. Hearing canceled at the request of author. |
| Aug 19, 2016 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to committee. Read second time, amended, and re-referred to Com. on JUD. |
| Aug 22, 2016 | Re-referred to Com. on RLS. |
| Aug 22, 2016 | Withdrawn from committee. |
| Jun 2, 2016 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Senate. (Ayes 79. Noes 0. Page 5205.) |
| Aug 31, 2016 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to committee. Read second time, amended, and re-referred to Com. on RLS. |
| Aug 31, 2016 | In Assembly. Concurrence in Senate amendments pending. |
| Aug 31, 2016 | Ordered to third reading. |
| Aug 31, 2016 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Assembly. |
| Aug 31, 2016 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Assembly. (Ayes 25. Noes 13. Page 5599.). |
| Aug 31, 2016 | Senate Rule 29.3 (b) suspended. (Ayes 26. Noes 10. Page 5583.) |
| Aug 31, 2016 | Senate Rule 29.3 (b) suspended. (Ayes 26. Noes 10.) |
| Aug 31, 2016 | Withdrawn from committee. |
| May 31, 2016 | Motion to reconsider made by Assembly Member Mark Stone. |
| Feb 26, 2016 | From printer. May be heard in committee March 27. |
| Mar 28, 2016 | Referred to Com. on JUD. |
| Apr 18, 2016 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to Com. on JUD. Read second time and amended. |
| Apr 19, 2016 | Re-referred to Com. on JUD. |
| Apr 26, 2016 | From committee: Do pass. (Ayes 10. Noes 0.) (April 26). |
| Apr 27, 2016 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| May 27, 2016 | Read third time and amended. Ordered to third reading. |
| May 27, 2016 | Read third time and amended. Ordered to third reading. (Page 4944.) |
| Feb 25, 2016 | Read first time. To print. |
| May 31, 2016 | Read third time. Refused passage. |
| May 31, 2016 | Read third time. Refused passage. (Ayes 10. Noes 50. Page 5008.). |
| May 31, 2016 | Read third time. Refused passage. (Ayes 10. Noes 50.). |
| Jun 2, 2016 | Assembly Rule 63 suspended. |
| Jun 2, 2016 | Assembly Rule 69 suspended. |
| Jun 2, 2016 | Read third time and amended. Ordered to third reading. |
| Jun 2, 2016 | Read third time and amended. Ordered to third reading. (Page 5205.) |
| Jun 2, 2016 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Senate. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Aug 31, 2016 | W/O REF. TO FILE AB2878 Committee on JUD. By Jackson | Senate Floor |
Passed |
|
| Jun 2, 2016 | AB 2878 JUD. Assembly Third Reading By STONE | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| May 31, 2016 | AB 2878 JUD. Assembly Third Reading By STONE | Assembly Floor |
Failed |
|
| Apr 26, 2016 | Do pass. | Assembly Standing Committee on Judiciary |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
|
Organization
|
Position
|
Date
|
|---|---|---|
| Bar Trustee Dennis Mangers | ** Support | Apr 26, 2016 |
| Bar Trustee Glenda Corcoran | ** Support | Apr 26, 2016 |
| Bar Trustee Joanna Mendoza | ** Support | Apr 26, 2016 |
| California Lawyer Guild | * Support | Apr 26, 2016 |
| California Lawyers Guild | * For If Amend | Apr 26, 2016 |
| Center for Public Interest Law | ** Against | Apr 26, 2016 |
| Former Bar Trustee Heather Linn Rosing | ** Support | Apr 26, 2016 |
| The State Bar Of California | * Support | Apr 26, 2016 |
Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | AB |
THIRD READING
Bill No: AB 2878
:
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 10-50, 5/31/16 - See last page for vote (FAIL)
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 79-0, 6/2/16 - See last page for vote
DIGEST: This bill authorizes the State Bar of California (State Bar) to collect annual membership dues for 2017 and, among other things:
- Reconstitutes the membership of the State Bar Board of Trustees (Board) from a 19-member Board consisting of a supermajority of attorneys (13) as compared to non-attorneys (six), to a 13-member Board consisting of seven attorneys and six non-attorney members, by eliminating the six attorneys elected to the Board;
- Provides that the President and Vice-President of the Board are to be renamed as the Chair and Vice-Chair and to be appointed by the Supreme Court instead of elected by the Board;
- Provides that each appointing body should consider appointing members with education or experience in one of six specified areas, including immigration law;
- Provides that members of the Board serve four year terms instead of three;
- Codifies new specific requirements for the handling of unlawful practice of law complaints (including specific timeframes for processing those complaints; specified, acceptable resolutions for those complaints; and requiring that those complaints be forwarded to law enforcement);
- Requires the Office of Chief Trial Counsel at the State Bar to employ at least one supervising attorney with significant immigration law experience;
- Requires the Executive Committee to include at least one Board member appointed by the Governor, Senate, Assembly, and Supreme Court to ensure oversight and participation by all appointing entities in the most crucial decisions made by the Board;
- Provides that access to records of the State Bar Court are subject to the rules and laws applicable to the judiciary instead of the California Public Records Act (CPRA) or Bagley-Keene Open Meeting Act;
- Enhances the annual financial audits of the State Bar and requires an additional performance audit of the State Bar by the State Auditor;
- Requires the Attorney General to appoint a temporary State Bar enforcement program monitor to evaluate the disciplinary system, make recommendations, and report findings, as specified;
- Eliminates the ability of the State Bar to prevent future Legislatures from reducing future membership dues;
- Requires Board approval of contracts for goods, services, or both for an aggregate amount in excess of $50,000 as well as of contracts for information technology, goods, services, or both, for an aggregate amount in excess of $100,000, as specified;
- Requires the Board to adopt policies and procedures to require Board approval of any contract that could impact the State Bar’s ability to carry out its paramount duty to protect the public;
- Prohibits the State Bar from creating foundations or nonprofits, as specified; and
- Requires the State Bar to conduct an analysis of the Client Security Fund (CSF), as specified.
Existing law:
- Establishes that protection of the public shall be the highest priority for the State Bar of California and the Board of Trustees in exercising their licensing, regulatory, and disciplinary functions. Whenever the protection of the public is inconsistent with other interests sought to be promoted, the protection of the public shall be paramount.
- Requires all attorneys who practice law in California to be members of the State Bar, establishes that the State Bar is a public corporation established for the purpose of regulating the legal profession.
- Authorizes the State Bar to collect $315 in annual membership fees from active members for a total annual dues bill of $390 for the year 2016. The other $75 is pursuant to statutory authorization to assess annually the following fees: $40 for the CSF; $25 for disciplinary activities; and $10 to fund the Lawyer Assistance Program (LAP).
- Authorizes the State Bar to collect $75 in annual membership fees from inactive members for a total annual dues bill of $115 for the year 2016. The other $40 is pursuant to statutory authorization to assess annually the following fees: $10 for the CSF; $25 for disciplinary activities; $5 to fund the LAP.
- Authorizes the State Bar to increase the annual membership fees by an additional $40, to be allocated only for purposes of providing voluntary support for nonprofit organizations that provide free legal services to persons of limited means. Members may deduct the $40 from the annual membership fee if they elect not to have the amount allocated for the purposes of legal services.
- Subjects the State Bar to the CPRA and provides that all public records and writings of the State Bar are subject to the CPRA with exceptions, as specified. Identifying information submitted by applicants to the State Bar for admission to practice law and State Bar admissions records, as specified, are confidential and may not be disclosed pursuant to any law, including the CPRA.
- Subjects the State Bar to the Bagley-Keene Open Meeting Act, except that the Act shall not apply to the Judicial Nominees Evaluation Commission or the Committee of Bar Examiners.
- Requires the Board to engage the services of an independent national or regional public accounting firm with at least five years of experience in governmental auditing for an audit of its financial statement for each fiscal year, as specified.
- Requires, in relevant part, that every two years, the Board contract with the California State Auditor’s Office to conduct a performance audit of the State Bar’s operations, as specified.
- Establishes that the State Bar is governed by a 19-member Board of Trustees consisting of six board members who are not attorneys (public members) and 13 members who are attorneys. Six of the 13 attorney board members are elected by other licensed attorneys to represent districts throughout the state. Five attorneys are appointed by the Supreme Court. One attorney and one public member is appointed by the Senate Committee on Rules. One attorney and one public member is appointed by the Speaker of the Assembly. Four of the six public members are appointed by the Governor.
- Provides that the State Bar officers are a president, vice president, secretary, and treasurer, elected by the Board.
- Requires the State Bar to annually report on the performance and condition of its discipline system, including the backlog of discipline cases that are six months old and case processing times, as provided.
- Creates the Governance in the Public Interest Task Force, effective February 1, 2013, and requires that the task force report to the Supreme Court, the Governor and the Assembly and Senate Committees on Judiciary by May 15, 2014, and every three years thereafter, its recommendations for enhancing public protection and ensuring that public protection is the State Bar’s highest priority.
- Permits the State Bar, for the purpose of carrying into effect and promoting its objectives, to sell, lease, exchange, convey, transfer, assign, encumber, pledge, or dispose of any of its real or personal property or any interest therein, including without limitation all or any portion of its income or revenues from membership fees paid or payable by members.
- Provides that whenever the Board secures an obligation of the State Bar on all or any portion of the fees from membership dues the Legislature may not, until the obligation is repaid in full, reduce membership dues below the maximum amount in effect when the obligation was created and provides that this constitutes a covenant to the holder of the obligation.
- Authorizes the State Bar to raise additional revenue by any lawful means, including, but not limited to, the creation of foundations or not-for-profit corporations.
- Requires the Board to establish and administer a CSF to relieve or mitigate pecuniary losses caused by dishonest conduct of active members of the State Bar, as specified.
- Prohibits a person from practicing law in California unless the person is an active member of the State Bar, and provides for the fine and imprisonment of persons who engage in the unauthorized practice of law, as specified.
- Provides that in addition to any criminal penalties or contempt proceedings, the courts of this state shall have specified jurisdiction when a person advertises or holds himself or herself out as practicing or entitled to practice, or otherwise practices law, without being an active member of the State Bar or otherwise authorized pursuant to statute or court rule to practice law in this state at the time of doing so (the “unauthorized practice of law”). The State Bar, or superior court on its own motion, may make application for assumption by the court of jurisdiction over the practice, as specified. In any proceeding related to the unauthorized practice of law, the State Bar is permitted to intervene and assume primary responsibility for conducting the action.
- Requires that the court provide a copy of any order issued on the unauthorized practice of law to the Office of the Trial Counsel of the State Bar.
This bill:
- Requires, until January 1, 2018, the Board to charge an annual membership fee for 2017 of $390 for active members.
- Provides that access to records of the State Bar Court is subject to the rules and laws applicable to the judiciary instead of the CPRA and exempts the State Bar Court from the Bagley-Keene Open Meeting Act.
- Requires the California State Auditor’s Office to conduct an additional performance audit evaluating the State Bar’s progress in certain areas, including correcting any issues raised in prior California State Auditor audits.
- Requires the Board to expand the scope of its annual independent financial statement audit to also include an audit of its revenues, expenditures, and reserves.
- Requires the California State Auditor, for the performance audit due in January 2017, to review all of the State Bar’s expenses, including, but not limited to, executive salaries and benefits, outside contracts and real estate holdings, to determine the appropriate and necessary expenses of the State Bar and the appropriate member dues level.
- Requires the Board to transition from a 19 member Board to a 13 member Board, as specified.
- Removes from the Board the six attorney members who are elected from State Bar Districts and would make conforming changes.
- Requires that a maximum of six members of the Board be non-attorney members appointed as follows: four by the Governor, one by the Assembly Speaker, one by the Senate Rules Committee, and none by the Supreme Court.
- Provides that each appointing body should consider appointing members with education or experience, in one of six specified areas, including immigration law.
- Requires the Supreme Court to select a Chair and Vice-chair of the State Bar.
- Requires the Attorney General to appoint a State Bar enforcement program monitor prior to March 31, 2017, and requires the monitor to evaluate the disciplinary system and procedures of the State Bar, as specified.
- Requires the program enforcement monitor to submit an initial report no later than October 1, 2019 and to issue a final report before March 31, 2020. This provision sunsets on January 1, 2021.
- Deletes the provision in law that prohibits the Legislature from reducing membership dues if the Board secures an obligation of the State Bar on membership dues.
- Eliminates the ability of the State Bar to prevent future Legislatures from reducing future membership dues.
- Requires Board approval of contracts for goods, services, or both for an aggregate amount in excess of $50,000 as well as of contracts for information technology, goods, services, or both, for an aggregate amount in excess of $100,000, as specified.
- Requires the Board to adopt policies and procedures to require Board approval of any contract that could impact the State Bar’s ability to carry out its paramount duty to protect the public.
- Prohibits the State Bar from creating any foundation or nonprofit corporations, as specified.
- Requires the State Bar to conduct a thorough analysis of the CSF and to submit a report to the Legislature on its analysis of that fund by March 15, 2017, as specified.
- Sets forth specific requirements for the handling of unlawful practice of law complaints, including: specific timeframes for processing those complaints; specified, acceptable resolutions for those complaints; and requiring that those complaints be forwarded to law enforcement.
- Requires the Bar’s Office of Chief Trial Counsel to employ a supervising attorney with significant immigration law experience, including representing individuals in removal proceedings and asylum applications.
Background
The State Bar is a public corporation. Attorneys who wish to practice law in California generally must be admitted and licensed in this state and must be a member of the State Bar. (Cal. Const., art. VI, Sec. 9.) The State Auditor and media have reported extensively in the last year regarding the State Bar’s lack of transparency and problems with the discipline system, including the mishandling of over 300 complaints alleging the unauthorized practice of law. The power to regulate the practice of law, including the power to admit and to discipline attorneys, is among the inherent powers of the Supreme Court. The State Bar functions as the administrative arm of the Supreme Court for the purpose of assisting in attorney admissions and discipline, with the Court retaining its inherent judicial authority to disbar or suspend attorneys.
The State Bar of California is the largest state bar in the country. As of March 2016, the State Bar had 186,152 active members and 56,929 inactive members, which represents a slight annual increase in both active members and inactive members. Total State Bar membership is listed at 257,788, which includes 2,162 judge members and 12,544 members who are “Not Eligible to Practice Law.” The State Bar’s programs are financed mostly by annual membership dues paid by attorneys, as well as other fees paid by applicants seeking to practice law. The Legislature has required the Board to establish and administer a CSF to relieve or mitigate pecuniary losses caused by dishonest conduct of active attorneys. Among the criticisms of the State Bar in a recent State Auditor report was that the State Bar failed to be transparent with the Legislature and that it now takes 18 to 36 months for a victim to be paid from the CSF. Ultimately, if the Bar dues bill fails to pass or is vetoed, the Supreme Court can exercise its inherent constitutional power over regulation of the legal profession and order a special regulatory assessment to fund the State Bar’s discipline-related functions.
This bill authorizes the State Bar to collect the annual membership dues for 2017 and makes various substantive changes to the State Bar Act designed to increase transparency, protect victims of unscrupulous non-attorneys, remove politics from the Board, reform the discipline system, and make various other changes in response to the findings in the State Auditor’s audit of the State Bar and various media reports.
Comments
- Stated need for the bill. The author writes the following:
This bill continues the Legislature’s important oversight of the State Bar through the annual dues authorization bill, which is part of our general oversight role over agencies in the executive and judicial branches of government. As the Supreme Court itself acknowledged in In re Garcia (2014) 58 Cal.4th 440, the Legislature may establish reasonable rules regulating the Bar, despite the fact that the Supreme Court has ultimate responsibility for admissions and discipline. This bill seeks to exercise the Legislature’s oversight role over the State Bar after yet another year of extensive and publicly reported turmoil involving the Bar, some of which has only come to light because of new open government laws that we approved last year and which took effect just months ago. [. . . ] This bill takes critical steps to make the Bar, once and for all, an effective regulator of attorneys and a protector of the public[.]
- The State Bar functions as the administrative arm of the Supreme Court. As a constitutional matter, the judicial power of California is vested in the Supreme Court, Courts of Appeal, and superior courts. (Cal. Const., art. VI, Sec. 1.) The power to regulate the practice of law, including the power to admit and to discipline attorneys, is among the inherent powers of the Supreme Court. (In re Attorney Discipline System (1998) 19 Cal.4th 582, 592; Obrien v. Jones (2000) 23 Cal.4th 40, 48.) In addressing this inherent authority, the Supreme Court has explained: “The important difference between regulation of the legal profession and regulation of other professions is this: Admission to the bar is a judicial function, and members of the bar are officers of the court, subject to discipline by the court. Hence, under the constitutional doctrine of separation of powers, the court has inherent and primary regulatory power.” (In re Attorney Discipline System, supra, 19 Cal.4th at 593.)
Although originally a creature of statute, the State Bar is now “a constitutional entity within the judicial article of the California Constitution.” (Obrien, supra, 23 Cal.4th at 48; see Cal. Const., art. VI, Sec. 9; Bus. & Prof. Code, Sec. 6001.) The State Bar functions as the administrative arm of the Supreme Court for the purpose of assisting in attorney admissions and discipline, with the court retaining its inherent judicial authority to disbar or suspend attorneys. (In re Attorney Discipline System, supra, 19 Cal.4th at 599-600; see Keller v. State Bar of California (1990) 496 U.S. 1, 11.) The State Bar’s regulatory assistance is an integral part of the judicial function. (Obrien, supra, 23 Cal.4th at 48.) Emphasizing the sui generis nature of the State Bar as its administrative arm, the Supreme Court has made clear that “express legislative recognition of reserved judicial power over admission and discipline is critical to the constitutionality of the State Bar Act.” (In re Attorney Discipline System, supra, 19 Cal.4th at 600, citing Bus. & Prof. Code Sec. 6087.)
In addition, the Legislature’s exercise, under the police power, of a reasonable degree of regulation and control over the profession and practice of law in California, is well established. (Obrien, supra, 23 Cal.4th at 48.) The Legislature also exercises regulatory authority pursuant to the State Bar Act and has authority to set the amount of membership fees necessary to fund the disciplinary system. The Legislature has enacted statutes making protection of the public the highest priority of the State Bar (Bus. & Prof. Code Sec. 6001.1) and empowering the Bar to promote improvement of the administration of justice (Bus. & Prof. Code Sec. 6031(a).) And, while the Board has statutory authority to formulate rule proposals, they only take effect if the State Supreme Court approves them.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: Fiscal Com.: Local:
None received
OPPOSITION: (Verified 8/31/16)
None received
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 10-50, 5/31/16 (FAIL)
AYES: Atkins, Cooley, Dodd, Gordon, Jones-Sawyer, O'Donnell, Quirk, Santiago, Mark Stone, Rendon
NOES: Alejo, Travis Allen, Arambula, Baker, Bigelow, Bonta, Brough, Brown, Burke, Calderon, Campos, Chang, Chávez, Chiu, Chu, Cooper, Dababneh, Gallagher, Cristina Garcia, Gatto, Gipson, Gonzalez, Gray, Grove, Harper, Roger Hernández, Holden, Irwin, Jones, Lackey, Levine, Lopez, Low, Maienschein, Mathis, Mayes, McCarty, Medina, Obernolte, Olsen, Patterson, Rodriguez, Salas, Steinorth, Ting, Wagner, Waldron, Weber, Wilk, Wood
NO VOTE RECORDED: Achadjian, Bloom, Bonilla, Chau, Dahle, Daly, Eggman, Frazier, Beth Gaines, Eduardo Garcia, Gomez, Hadley, Kim, Linder, Melendez, Mullin, Nazarian, Ridley-Thomas, Thurmond, Williams
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 79-0, 6/2/16
AYES: Achadjian, Alejo, Travis Allen, Arambula, Atkins, Baker, Bloom, Bonilla, Bonta, Brough, Brown, Burke, Calderon, Campos, Chang, Chau, Chávez, Chiu, Chu, Cooley, Cooper, Dababneh, Dahle, Daly, Dodd, Eggman, Frazier, Beth Gaines, Gallagher, Cristina Garcia, Eduardo Garcia, Gatto, Gipson, Gomez, Gonzalez, Gordon, Gray, Grove, Hadley, Harper, Roger Hernández, Holden, Irwin, Jones, Jones-Sawyer, Kim, Lackey, Levine, Linder, Lopez, Low, Maienschein, Mathis, Mayes, McCarty, Medina, Melendez, Mullin, Nazarian, Obernolte, O'Donnell, Olsen, Patterson, Quirk, Ridley-Thomas, Rodriguez, Salas, Santiago, Steinorth, Mark Stone, Thurmond, Ting, Wagner, Waldron, Weber, Wilk, Williams, Wood, Rendon
NO VOTE RECORDED: Bigelow
8/31/16 21:22:44
**** END ****
Senator Hannah-Beth Jackson, Chair
2015-2016 Regular Session
Bill No: AB 2878 (Author:Committee on Judiciary)
Version: June 2, 2016
Hearing Date: June 28, 2016
Fiscal: No
Urgency: No
Consultant: ME
SUBJECT
Attorneys: State Bar: board of trustees
DESCRIPTION
This bill would authorize the State Bar of California (State Bar) to collect annual membership dues for 2017 and would, among other things:
- codify a protocol for handling unlawful practice of law complaints;
- provide that access to records of State Bar Court are subject to the rules and laws applicable to the judiciary instead of the California Public Records Act or Bagley-Keene Open Meeting Act;
- require various additional audits of the State Bar by the State Auditor;
- require the Board of Trustees (Board) to transition from a 19 member Board to a 13 member board and comprised of a majority of public members;
- provide that no motion of the Board can be approved unless a majority of the public members approve the motion;
- create a Commission of nine appointed members to evaluate issues of State Bar governance and report findings, as specified;
- require the Chief Justice to appoint a temporary State Bar enforcement program monitor to evaluate the disciplinary system, make recommendations, and report findings, as specified;
- prohibit the State Bar from creating foundations or nonprofits, as specified; and
- require the State Bar to conduct an analysis of the Client Security Fund, as specified.
BACKGROUND
The State Bar of California is a public corporation. Attorneys who wish to practice law in California generally must be admitted and licensed in this state and must be a member of the State Bar. (Cal. Const., art. VI, Sec. 9.) The State Auditor and media have reported extensively in the last year regarding the State Bar’s lack of transparency and problems with the discipline system, including the mishandling of over 300 complaints alleging the unauthorized practice of law. The power to regulate the practice of law, including the power to admit and to discipline attorneys, is among the inherent powers of the Supreme Court. The State Bar functions as the administrative arm of the Supreme Court for the purpose of assisting in attorney admissions and discipline, with the Court retaining its inherent judicial authority to disbar or suspend attorneys.
The State Bar of California is the largest state bar in the country. As of March 2016, the State Bar had 186,152 active members and 56,929 inactive members, which represents a slight annual increase in both active members and inactive members. Total State Bar membership is listed at 257,788, which includes 2,162 judge members and 12,544 members who are “Not Eligible to Practice Law.” The State Bar’s programs are financed mostly by annual membership dues paid by attorneys as well as other fees paid by applicants seeking to practice law. The Legislature has required the Board to establish and administer a Client Security Fund (CSF) to relieve or mitigate pecuniary losses caused by dishonest conduct of active attorneys. Among the criticisms of the State Bar in a recent State Auditor report was that the State Bar failed to be transparent with the Legislature and that it now takes 18 to 36 months for a victim to be paid from the CSF. If the Bar dues bill fails to pass or be signed by the Governor, the Supreme Court will be able to exercise its inherent constitutional power over regulation of the legal profession and may order a special regulator assessment to fund the State Bar’s discipline-related functions.
This bill would authorize the State Bar to collect the annual membership dues for 2017 and make various substantive changes to the State Bar Act designed to increase transparency, protect victims of unscrupulous non-attorneys, remove politics from the Board, reform the discipline system, and make various other changes in response to the findings in the State Auditor’s audit of the State Bar and various media reports.
CHANGES TO EXISTING LAW
- Existing law establishes that protection of the public shall be the highest priority for the State Bar of California and the Board of Trustees in exercising their licensing, regulatory, and disciplinary functions. Whenever the protection of the public is inconsistent with other interests sought to be promoted, the protection of the public shall be paramount. (Bus. & Prof. Code Sec. 6001.1.)
Existing law requires all attorneys who practice law in California to be members of the State Bar and establishes the State Bar for the purpose of regulating the legal profession. Pursuant to the State Bar Act, the annual mandatory membership fee set by the State Bar’s Board of Trustees to pay for discipline and other functions must be ratified by the Legislature. (Bus. & Prof. Code Sec. 6000 et seq.)
Existing law authorizes the State Bar to collect $315 in annual membership fees from active members for a total annual dues bill of $390 for the year 2015. (Bus. & Prof. Code Sec. 6140.) The other $75 is pursuant to statutory authorization to assess annually the following fees: $40 for the Client Security Fund (Bus. & Prof. Code Sec. 6140.55); $25 for disciplinary activities (Bus. & Prof. Code Sec. 6140.6); and $10 to fund the Lawyer Assistance Program (Bus. & Prof. Code Sec. 6140.9).
Existing law authorizes the State Bar to collect $75 in annual membership fees from inactive members for a total annual dues bill of $115 for the year 2015. (Bus. & Prof. Code Sec. 6141.) The other $40 is pursuant to statutory authorization to assess annually the following fees: $10 for the Client Security Fund (Bus. & Prof. Code Sec. 6140.55); $25 for disciplinary activities (Bus. & Prof. Code Sec. 6140.6); $5 to fund the Lawyer Assistance Program (Bus. & Prof. Code Sec. 6140.9.)
Existing law authorizes the State Bar to increase the annual membership fees by an additional $40, to be allocated only for purposes of providing voluntary support for nonprofit organizations that provide free legal services to persons of limited means. Members have the option of deducting the $40 from the annual membership fee if they elect not to have the amount allocated for the purposes of legal services. (Bus. & Prof. Code Secs. 6033, 6140.03.)
This bill, until January 1, 2018, would require the board to charge an annual membership fee for 2017 of $390 for active members.
- Existing law subjects the State Bar to the California Public Records Act (CPRA) and provides that all public records and writings of the State Bar are subject to the CPRA with exceptions, as specified. Identifying information submitted by applicants to the State Bar for admission to practice law and State Bar admissions records, as specified, are confidential and may not be disclosed pursuant to any law, including the CPRA. (Bus. & Prof. Code Secs. 6001(g), 6026.11, 6060.25, 6086.1(b), 6168, 6200(h), 6232(d), 6234.)
Existing law subjects the State Bar to the Bagley-Keene Open Meeting Act, except that the Act shall not apply to the Judicial Nominees Evaluation Commission or the Committee of Bar Examiners. (Bus. & Prof. Code Secs. 6001(g), 6026.5, 6026.7; Gov. Code Sec. 11121.)
This bill would provide that access to records of the State Bar Court is subject to the rules and laws applicable to the judiciary instead of the CPRA and would exempt the State Bar Court from the Bagley-Keene Open Meeting Act.
- Existing law provides that the Board shall engage the services of an independent national or regional public accounting firm with at least five years of experience in governmental auditing for an audit of its financial statement for each fiscal year. The financial statement must be promptly certified and a copy of the audit and financial statement must be submitted, as specified, to the Chief Justice of the Supreme Court, and to the Assembly and Senate Committees on Judiciary. Existing law requires that the audit examine both:
- the receipts and expenditures of the State Bar and the State Bar sections to ensure that the receipts of the sections are being applied, and their expenditures are being made, in compliance with specified law, and that the receipts of the sections are applied only to the work of the sections; and
- the receipts and expenditures of the State Bar to ensure that the funds collected on behalf of the Conference of Delegates of the California Bar Associations are conveyed to that entity, as specified. (Bus. & Prof. Code Sec. 6145(a).)
Existing law, in relevant part, requires that every two years, the Board shall contract with the California State Auditor’s Office to conduct a performance audit of the State Bar’s operations for the respective fiscal year. A copy of the performance audit must be submitted as specified, to the board, to the Chief Justice of the Supreme Court, and to the Assembly and Senate Committees on Judiciary. For these purposes, the California State Auditor’s Office may contract with a third party to conduct the performance audit. This, however, is not intended to reduce the number of audits the California State Auditor’s office may otherwise be able to conduct. (Bus. & Prof. Code Sec. 6145(b).)
This bill would require the board to contract with the California State Auditor’s Office for an audit of its revenues, expenditures, reserves, and its financial statements for each fiscal year through 2020.
This bill would require the California State Auditor, for the performance audit due in January 2017, to review all of the State Bar’s expenses, including, but not limited to, executive salaries and benefits, outside contracts and real estate holdings, to determine the appropriate and necessary expenses of the State Bar and the appropriate member dues level.
- Existing law establishes that the State Bar is governed by a 19-member Board of Trustees consisting of 6 board members who are not attorneys (public members) and 13 members who are attorneys. Six of the 13 attorney board members are elected by other licensed attorneys to represent districts throughout the state. Five attorneys are appointed by the Supreme Court. One attorney is appointed by the Senate Committee on Rules. One attorney is appointed by the Speaker of the Assembly. Four of the six public members are appointed by the Governor. And, the Senate Rules Committee and Assembly Speaker appoint one public member each. (Bus. & Prof. Code Secs. 6011-6019.)
This bill would require the Board to transition from a 19 member board to a 13 member board, as specified.
This bill would remove from the Board attorney members elected from State Bar Districts and would make conforming changes.
This bill would require that a minimum of seven members of the Board be public members appointed as follows: four by the Governor, two by the Assembly, one by the Senate Rules Committee, and none by the Supreme Court.
This bill would provide that no motion of the Board can be approved unless a majority of the public members approve the motion.
This bill would require each member of the Board appointed after December 31, 2016, to have demonstrated educational or experience expertise, or both, in one of five specified areas, including public finance.
- Existing law provides that the State Bar officers are a president, vice president, secretary, and treasurer, elected by the Board. (Bus. & Prof. Code Secs. 6020, 6021.)
This bill would require the Supreme Court to instead select from its appointed members a president and vice president of the State Bar.
This bill would create a Commission of nine appointed members and require the Commission to evaluate all issues of governance of the State Bar, including, but not limited to, a full review of other states with attorney regulatory structures that are different than the State Bar, in order to recommend the best governance structure for the State Bar and to ensure that protection of the public is the highest priority of the State Bar in its regulatory duties.
This bill would require the Commission to provide a report to the Governor, the Chief Justice of the California Supreme Court, and the Senate and Assembly Committees on Judiciary by April 30, 2017.
This bill would require the Chief Justice to appoint a State Bar enforcement program monitor prior to March 31, 2017, and would require the program enforcement monitor to evaluate the disciplinary system and procedures of the State Bar, as specified.
This bill would require the program enforcement monitor to submit an initial report no later than October 1, 2019, to issue a final report before March 31, 2020. This provision would sunset on January 1, 2020.
- Existing law requires the State Bar to annually report on the performance and condition of its discipline system, including the backlog of discipline cases that are six months old and case processing times, as provided. (Bus. & Prof. Code Sec. 6086.15.)
Existing law creates the Governance in the Public Interest Task Force, effective February 1, 2013, and requires that the task force report to the Supreme Court, the Governor and the Assembly and Senate Judiciary Committees on Judiciary by May 15, 2014, and every three years thereafter, its recommendations for enhancing public protection and ensuring that public protection is the State Bar's highest priority. (The task force has yet to submit its first report.) (Bus. & Prof. Code Sec. 6001.2.)
Existing law permits the State Bar, for the purpose of carrying into effect and promoting its objectives, to sell, lease, exchange, convey, transfer, assign, encumber, pledge, or dispose of any of its real or personal property or any interest therein, including without limitation all or any portion of its income or revenues from membership fees paid or payable by members. (Bus. & Prof. Code Sec. 6001.)
Existing law provides that whenever the Board secures an obligation of the State Bar on all or any portion of the fees from membership dues the Legislature may not, until the obligation is repaid in full, reduce membership dues below the maximum amount in effect when the obligation was created and provides that this constitutes a covenant to the holder of the obligation. (Bus. & Prof. Code Sec. 6008.5.)
This bill would delete the provision in law that prohibits the Legislature from reducing membership dues if the Board secures an obligation of the State Bar on membership dues.
- Existing law authorizes the State Bar to raise additional revenue by any lawful means, including, but not limited to, the creation of foundations or not-for-profit corporations. (Bus. & Prof. Code Sec. 6001.)
This bill would prohibit the State Bar from creating any foundation or nonprofit corporations, as specified.
- Existing law requires the board to establish and administer a Client Security Fund to relieve or mitigate pecuniary losses caused by dishonest conduct of active members of the State Bar, as specified. (Bus. & Prof. Code Sec. 6140.5.)
This bill would require the State Bar to conduct a thorough analysis of the Client Security Fund and to submit a report to the Legislature on its analysis of that fund by March 15, 2017, as specified.
- Existing law prohibits a person from practicing law in California unless the person is an active member of the State Bar. (Bus. & Prof. Code Sec. 6125.)
Existing law provides for the fine and imprisonment of persons who engage in the unauthorized practice of law, as specified. (Bus. & Prof. Code Sec. 6126(a), (b).)
Existing law, in relevant part, provides that the following acts or omissions in respect to the practice of law are contempts of the authority of the courts:
- assuming to be an officer or attorney of a court and acting as such, without authority; and
- advertising or holding oneself out as practicing or entitled to practice law or otherwise practicing law in any court, without being an active member of the State Bar. (Bus. & Prof. Code Sec. 6127.)
Existing law provides that in addition to any criminal penalties or contempt proceedings, above, the courts of this state shall have specified jurisdiction when a person advertises or holds himself or herself out as practicing or entitled to practice, or otherwise practices law, without being an active member of the State Bar or otherwise authorized pursuant to statute or court rule to practice law in this state at the time of doing so (hereinafter referred to as the “unauthorized practice of law”). The State Bar, or superior court on its own motion, may make application, as specified, for assumption by the court of jurisdiction over the practice to the extent provided in this section. In any proceeding under this section, the State Bar is permitted to intervene and assume primary responsibility for conducting the action. (Bus. & Prof. Code Sec. 6126.3(a)-(c).)
Existing law authorizes the court, if it finds that the facts set forth regarding the unauthorized practice of law have occurred, and that the interests of a client or an interested person or entity will be prejudiced if the proceeding provided herein is not maintained, to make an order assuming jurisdiction over the person’s practice, as specified. If the person to whom the order to show cause is directed does not appear, existing law authorizes the court to make its order upon the verified application or upon such proof it may require. Thereupon, the court must appoint one or more active members of the State Bar to act under its direction to mail a notice of cessation of practice, as specified, and may appoint those appointed attorneys to do one or more of the following, among other things:
- examine the files and records of the practice and obtain information as to any pending matters that may require attention;
- notify persons or entities who appear to be clients in connection to the event or events stated in relation to the unauthorized practice of law, and inform them that it may be in their best interest to obtain other legal counsel;
- with the consent of the client, file notices, motions, and pleadings on behalf of the client where jurisdictional time limits are involved and other legal counsel has not yet been obtained; and
- do any other acts that the court may direct to carry out for the purposes of this section. (Bus. & Prof. Code Sec. 6126.3(e).)
Existing law requires that the court provide a copy of any order issued pursuant to this section on the unauthorized practice of law to the Office of the Trial Counsel of the State Bar. (Bus. & Prof. Code Sec. 6126.3(e).)
Existing law provides that upon a finding by the court that it is more likely than not that the application will be granted and that delay in making orders described above will result in substantial injury to clients or to others, the court, without notice or upon notice as it shall prescribe, may make interim orders containing any provisions that the court deems appropriate under the circumstances. Such an interim order shall be served, as specified. (Bus. & Prof. Code Sec. 6126.3(j).)
Existing law provides that an order pursuant to this section on the unauthorized practice of law is not appealable and shall not be stayed by petition for a writ, except as ordered by the superior or appellate court. (Bus. & Prof. Code Sec. 6126.3(l).)
Existing law provides that a member of the State Bar appointed pursuant to this section on the unauthorized practice of law shall serve without compensation, except as specified. (Bus. & Prof. Code Sec. 6126.3(m).)
This bill sets forth specific requirements for the handling of unlawful practice of law complaints, including: specific timeframes for processing those complaints; specified, acceptable resolutions for those complaints; and requiring that those complaints be forwarded to law enforcement.
COMMENT
- Stated need for the bill
According to the author:
This bill continues the Legislature’s important oversight of the State Bar through the annual dues authorization bill, which is part of our general oversight role over agencies in the executive and judicial branches of government. As the Supreme Court itself acknowledged in In re Garcia (2014) 58 Cal.4th 440, the Legislature may establish reasonable rules regulating the Bar, despite the fact that the Supreme Court has ultimate responsibility for admissions and discipline. This bill seeks to exercise the Legislature’s oversight role over the State Bar after yet another year of extensive and publically reported turmoil involving the Bar, some of which has only come to light because of new open government laws that we approved last year and which took effect just months ago.
The State Bar was created to license and regulate attorneys, with the protection of the public as its highest priority. [ . . . ] Unfortunately, in just this last year alone, far too many instances have come to light that illustrate how far the Bar has strayed from its paramount mission to protect the public. Hundreds of complaints from the public about the unauthorized practice of law were thrown into a drawer and forgotten for months and even years; an audit of the Bar’s discipline system showed that the Bar imposed inappropriately light sanctions on attorneys in an effort to clear its backlog of such cases; the Bar’s discipline system has focused on minor abuses that do not threaten the public without properly prioritizing more serious discipline cases; the Bar refinanced a $25 million loan on its property in Los Angeles and took out a new $10 million loan on its property in San Francisco by pledging future bar dues as collateral and tied the hands of the Legislature in the process, all without notice to the Legislature; [ . . . ] it was revealed that the Executive Director (and about a dozen member of her executive team) earn a salary far higher than Governor Brown; the Bar recently hired a public relations professional who makes more money than the White House Press Secretary; the Bar’s executive staff receives far greater benefits than the rest of the staff; the Bar unlawfully transferred money between its funds; the Bar held at least one meeting in violation of the Bagley-Keene Open Meetings Law; and the Bar is involved in ongoing litigation with five former Bar employees. And the list of wrong doing goes on and on. Too often today, the Bar behaves more like a law firm than a regulator and this has resulted in attorney discipline and public protection receiving short shrift.
This bill takes critical steps to make the Bar, once and for all, an effective regulator of attorneys and a protector of the public[.]
- The Supreme Court
The Supreme Court is not the State Bar Board of Trustees (Board). However, in the frustration surrounding the Board, its former Chief Trial Council, and Executive team, the Board and the Supreme Court are being conflated by some critics. This Supreme Court is arguably the most diverse state Supreme Court in the nation and reflects the new California, in terms of racial, gender, and age diversity. While change is needed with the Board, arguably, this newer Court should be given a reasonable opportunity to address issues within its own branch of government. The Supreme Court is entrusted as the final adjudicator of State laws. While actions of the State Bar, including by the Board, the former Chief Trial Counsel, and Executive team have generated dozens of critical media reports as well as criticism by the State Auditor, this Committee is not aware of any criticism of the State Bar Court, the Supreme Court, or the Chief Justice regarding their respective roles in licensing and disciplining attorneys.
- The State Bar functions as the administrative arm of the Supreme Court for the purpose of assisting in attorney admissions and discipline, with the Court retaining its inherent judicial authority to disbar or suspend attorneys
As a constitutional matter, the judicial power of California is vested in the Supreme Court, Courts of Appeal, and superior courts. (Cal. Const., art. VI, Sec. 1.) The power to regulate the practice of law, including the power to admit and to discipline attorneys, is among the inherent powers of the Supreme Court. (In re Attorney Discipline System (1998) 19 Cal.4th 582, 592; Obrien v. Jones (2000) 23 Cal.4th 40, 48.) In addressing this inherent authority, the Supreme Court has explained: “‘The important difference between regulation of the legal profession and regulation of other professions is this: Admission to the bar is a judicial function, and members of the bar are officers of the court, subject to discipline by the court. Hence, under the constitutional doctrine of separation of powers, the court has inherent and primary regulatory power.’” (In re Attorney Discipline System, supra, 19 Cal.4th at 593.)
Although originally a creature of statute, the State Bar of California is now “a constitutional entity within the judicial article of the California Constitution.” (Obrien, supra, 23 Cal.4th at 48; see Cal. Const., art. VI, Sec. 9; Bus. & Prof. Code, Sec. 6001.) The State Bar functions as the administrative arm of the Supreme Court for the purpose of assisting in attorney admissions and discipline, with the court retaining its inherent judicial authority to disbar or suspend attorneys. (In re Attorney Discipline System, supra, 19 Cal.4th at 599-600; see Keller v. State Bar of California (1990) 496 U.S. 1, 11.) The State Bar’s regulatory assistance is an integral part of the judicial function. (Obrien, supra, 23 Cal.4th at 48.) Emphasizing the sui generis nature of the State Bar as its administrative arm, the Supreme Court has made clear that “express legislative recognition of reserved judicial power over admission and discipline is critical to the constitutionality of the State Bar Act.” (In re Attorney Discipline System, supra, 19 Cal.4th at 600, citing Bus. & Prof. Code Sec. 6087.)
In addition, the Legislature’s exercise, under the police power, of a reasonable degree of regulation and control over the profession and practice of law in California, is well established. (Obrien, supra, 23 Cal.4th at 48.) The Legislature also exercises regulatory authority pursuant to the State Bar Act and has authority to set the amount of membership fees necessary to fund the disciplinary system. The Legislature has enacted statutes making protection of the public the highest priority of the State Bar (Bus. & Prof. Code Sec. 6001.1) and empowering the Bar to promote improvement of the administration of justice (Bus. & Prof. Code Sec. 6031(a).) And, while the Board has statutory authority to formulate rule proposals, they only take effect if the State Supreme Court approves them.[1]
- This bill would marginalize a co-equal branch of government even though the State Bar functions as the administrative arm of the Supreme Court
This bill would provide that no motion of the Board can be approved unless a majority of the public members approve the motion. While these provisions are seemingly intended to increase transparency and fairly distribute authority, as drafted this bill would disproportionately favor certain branches of government over others. Specifically, pursuant to this bill, the Supreme Court continues to appoint no public members, the Assembly Speaker appoints two, the Governor continues to appoint four, and the Senate Rules Committee continues to appoint one. Accordingly, the Governor’s appointees could control every motion, whereas the Supreme Court would have no power on the Board, and the Assembly would have double the power of the Senate. The following amendment is suggested to remove this inequitable consequence, by striking the requirement that a majority of the public members approve every motion.
Suggested Amendment:
On page 13, strike out lines 19 and 20.
- The Chief Justice requests the authority to appoint a Special Master to review issues of governance of the State Bar instead of the creation of a Commission
As discussed in Comment 3, above, the power to regulate the practice of law, including the power to admit and to discipline attorneys, is among the inherent powers of the Supreme Court. This bill would provide for the creation of the California State Bar Governance Commission (Commission) to study the best governance structure for the State Bar to fulfill its core function of public protection. Specifically, this Commission would be comprised of nine volunteer Commission members. The Commission members would be appointed by the same entities that currently appoint the Board Members of the State Bar—i.e. the Governor, Chief Justice, Speaker of the Assembly, and Senate Committee on Rules. The Commission would be tasked with “evaluating all issues of governance of the State Bar, including, but not limited to, a full review of other states with attorney regulatory structures that are different than the State Bar and a possible separation of the State Bar’s regulatory and trade association functions [. . .].”
The Chief Justice of the California Supreme Court, as the leader of the Court, requests that instead of creating this new commission, she be given the statutory authority to appoint a Special Master. Under her proposal, the Supreme Court would assess whether changes to the governing board or overall structure of the State Bar would better support regulation of the legal profession, protection of the public, and effective administration of justice. To aid in its assessment, the Supreme Court would be statutorily required to appoint a Special Master on or before March 1, 2017. The Special Master would be tasked with reviewing issues of governance of the State Bar, including, but not limited to, a full review of other states with attorney regulatory structures that are similar to or different than the State Bar, possible changes to the composition and operation of the Board, and a possible restructuring of the regulatory and non-regulatory functions of the State Bar. To aid the Special Master in fulfilling his or her duties, the Supreme Court would be required to provide a public list of questions pertaining to governance, regulatory, and other areas perceived as aiding in or interfering with regulation of the legal profession, protection of the public, or the effective administration of justice. The Supreme Court would also be required to consult with the Administration, the Assembly Committee on Judiciary, and the Senate Committee on Judiciary, all of which would be invited to contribute questions to this list.
A Special Master, sometimes called a referee, typically is a lawyer or retired judge who is appointed by a court to hear a case or consider matters involving difficult or specialized issues. The appointing court may specify or limit the powers of the Special Master and limit the issues considered. Depending on the court’s order, the Special Master will take evidence and file a report that may contain findings of fact and conclusions of law. Once a Special Master’s report is filed, the court will ordinarily accept findings of fact unless they are clearly erroneous, but the court may always determine questions of law de novo. In California, Special Masters have been appointed in a variety of cases. In 1998 when the State Bar fee bill was vetoed, the Supreme Court appointed a Special Master to supervise and oversee the collection, disbursement, and allocation of the collected court-imposed regulatory fees on active members of the Bar.
Given that the Supreme Court has the authority over the admission and practice of law in the State of California, it is arguably appropriate that the Supreme Court take the leading role in assessing how the State Bar, as its administrative arm, is best structured and governed to support adequate regulation of the legal profession, protection of the public, and the effective administration of justice. In recognition of the Supreme Court’s primary authority over the admission and practice of law and in deference to the Chief Justice, the following amendment is suggested to remove the Commission that would study governance and replace it with the Chief Justice’s language whereby the Special Master would review issues of governance of the State Bar.
Suggested Amendments:
On page 6, in line 4, strike out “SEC. 2.” and insert “SEC. 1.”
On page 7, strike out lines 29 through 39.
On page 8, strike out lines 1 through 37 and insert:
SEC. 2. Section 6001.3 is added to the Business and Professions Code, to read:
(a) In exercise of its oversight role over the State Bar, the Supreme Court shall assess whether changes to the governing board or overall structure of the State Bar would better support regulation of the legal profession, protection of the public, and effective administration of justice.
(b) To aid in its assessment, the Supreme Court shall appoint a special master on or before March 1, 2017.
(c) The special master shall review issues of governance of the State Bar, including, but not limited to, a full review of other states with attorney regulatory structures that are similar to or different than the State Bar, possible changes to the composition and operation of the Board of Trustees, and a possible restructuring of the regulatory and non-regulatory functions of the State Bar.
(d) To aid the special master in fulfilling his or her duties, the Supreme Court shall provide a list of questions pertaining to governance, regulatory, and other areas perceived as aiding in or interfering with regulation of the legal profession, protection of the public, or effective administration of justice. The Supreme Court shall consult with the Administration, the Assembly Committee on Judiciary, and the Senate Committee on Judiciary, who will be invited to contribute questions to this list. The Supreme Court shall provide written guidelines to the special master for the conduct of his or her duties. The list of questions and written guidelines shall be made available to the public.
(e) The special master shall engage in fact-finding to identify:
(1) Those functions of the State Bar that are regulatory, those functions that are non-regulatory but which reasonably serve to protect the public or improve the administration of justice, and those functions that are non-regulatory and provide little or no value to public protection or the administration of justice.
(2) All areas that relate to the State Bar’s governance structure and interfere with the competent performance of its regulatory and public protection functions and its efforts to improve the administration of justice.
(3) All changes and refinements in the structure or governance of the State Bar that reasonably should be considered by the Supreme Court as potentially effective in addressing the areas identified in subdivision (f)(2). In ascertaining which changes reasonably should be considered, the special master shall identify the fiscal and operational implications of the changes. For each change identified, the special master shall provide a proposed implementation plan that includes specification of all modifications to statutory law, Rules of Court, and Rules of the State Bar that will be necessary to accomplish such change.
(f) To aid in the fact-finding process, the special master shall hold public hearings to accept written and transcribed oral comments from the public and interested stakeholders, including the authorized State Bar employee bargaining unit representatives. The special master shall also receive the transcribed and other written comments and information previously taken during the public hearings conducted in 2016 by the State Bar’s Governance in the Public Interest Task Force. The special master shall provide bi-monthly written reports of updates on his or her work to the Supreme Court, the Administration, the Assembly Committee on Judiciary, and the Senate Committee on Judiciary.
(g) On or before October 1, 2017, the special master shall deliver a written report to the Supreme Court, the Administration, the Assembly Committee on Judiciary, and the Senate Committee on Judiciary. The report shall set forth the special master’s findings of fact as required in this section, and may include other observations made by the special master, if related to the performance or functioning of the State Bar and supported by substantial and credible information.
(h) Based on its review of the special master’s report, and after consultation with the Administration, the Assembly Committee on Judiciary, and the Senate Committee on Judiciary, the Supreme Court shall make its assessment of how the State Bar, as its administrative arm, is best structured and governed to support adequate regulation of the legal profession, protection of the public, and the effective administration of justice. The Supreme Court’s written report of its assessments shall be delivered to the Administration, the Assembly Committee on Judiciary, and the Senate Committee on Judiciary on or before March 1, 2018. It is contemplated that the Legislature will evaluate the Supreme Court’s report in exercising its regulatory authority pursuant to the State Bar Act.
(i) The State Bar shall furnish the special master with all reasonable assistance as necessary. To pay for the services and expenses of the special master, a per-member fee shall be assessed for all active members at a sum not exceeding ($ ).
- Alternative when State Bar due bills fail to be signed into law
If no State Bar dues bill is enacted by January 1, 2017, attorney bar dues may increase. In last year’s State Bar dues bill, the Legislature required that the State Bar develop and implement a workforce plan for its discipline system and conduct a public sector compensation and benefits study, including a recommendation for an appropriate backlog goal and an assessment of staffing needed to achieve that goal. The Legislature further required the State Bar to conduct a thorough analysis of its operating costs and develop a spending plan to determine a reasonable amount for its annual dues. The workforce plan and the spending plan, which could arguably justify increased dues, were submitted to the Legislature in May 2016.
In the event that AB 2878 does not pass or is vetoed, the Supreme Court, in the exercise of its inherent constitutional power over regulation of the legal profession, may order a special regulatory assessment to fund the State Bar’s discipline-related functions. In the case of In re Attorney Discipline System (1998) 19 Cal.4th 582, the Supreme Court considered information provided by the State Bar in ordering that each active member of the State Bar pay a mandatory regulatory fee of $171.44. The Court also appointed a Special Master to supervise and oversee the collection, disbursement, and allocation of the collected fees, and imposed an additional fee of $1.56 upon each active member of the State Bar to pay for the fees and expenses related to the Special Master and his activities. If AB 2878 fails, it is likely that the Supreme Court will act in a similar fashion if AB 2878 fails.
- Codifying a protocol to protect immigrants from the unauthorized practice of law
In January of this year, the Daily Journal revealed that the State Bar had ignored 59 complaints of unauthorized practice of law dating back to 2007. (Lyle Moran, State Bar Admits Ignoring Dozens of Complaints Against People Practicing Law Without a License, Daily Journal (Jan. 29, 2016).) In response, the State Bar acknowledged that “[c]omplaints against non-attorneys often come from immigrants who have been exploited by unscrupulous businesses, and it is important to [the State Bar] to root out this fraud and safeguard the public’s interests[.]” Less than two months later, the Daily Journal reported that the State Bar allowed an additional 270 complaints alleging the unauthorized practice of law to sit idle without assignment to an investigator for months. (Lyle Moran, State Bar Let Hundreds of Complaints Against Non-Attorneys Sit Idle, Daily Journal (March 4, 2016).)
At a recent Summit organized by the State Bar regarding the Unauthorized Practice of Law, immigration law practitioners shared stories about the State Bar not following through on complaints they filed on behalf of immigrants against those engaged in the unauthorized practice of law and attorneys licensed in other states who practice immigration law in California. At that Summit, the State Bar revealed new protocols they were developing to handle unauthorized practice of law complaints. Correctly recognizing that failure to immediately investigate allegations of unauthorized practice of law leaves future victims vulnerable to the perpetrators, and in the interest of protecting the public, this bill would codify those protocols.
Also at the Summit, it was clear that the OCTC lacks meaningful experience in immigration law. The OCTC would arguably benefit from employing an attorney with significant immigration law experience. Accordingly, the author may wish to consider the following amendment to require the OCTC to employ a supervising attorney with significant immigration experience:
Suggested amendment:
On page 20, in line 23 insert: “(n) the Office of Chief Trial Counsel shall hire at least one supervising attorney with the following experience: (1) Have at least three years of experience handling asylum, T-Visa, U-Visa, or special immigrant juvenile status cases and have represented at least 25 individuals in these matters. (2) Have experience in representing individuals in removal proceedings and asylum applications.
- The State Bar Enforcement Monitor
Audits by the State Auditor’s Office and media accounts have demonstrated that the discipline system at the State Bar in the Office of Chief Trial Counsel (OCTC) is broken. The 2015 State Auditor’s performance audit of the State Bar revealed that the State Bar did not fully and consistently report its backlog of discipline cases or its case processing times to the Legislature. The Auditor asserted that the manner in which the State Bar reduced its backlog of discipline cases may have caused significant risk to the public. According to the Auditor, “…to reduce its backlog, the State Bar allowed some attorneys whom it otherwise might have disciplined more severely—or even disbarred—to continue practicing law, at significant risk to the public.”
In an effort to improve the processing of complaints from intake to resolution in the OCTC, this bill would require the Chief Justice to appoint a temporary State Bar enforcement program monitor (Monitor) prior to March 31, 2017. The Monitor would be given various duties, including, monitoring and evaluating the State Bar’s disciplinary system and procedures. The Monitor would be charged with making his or her highest priority the reform and reengineering of the State Bar’s enforcement program and operations, and the improvement of the overall efficiency of the State Bar’s disciplinary system so that the State Bar may successfully and consistently protect the public. The Monitor would be required to submit an initial report to the Assembly and Senate Committees on Judiciary and others no later than October 1, 2019, and to issue a final report before March 31, 2020. Statutory authorization for the Monitor would cease on January 1, 2021. The strong evidence of a broken discipline system in the OCTC arguably warrants the imposition of an independent Monitor. That being said, staff notes that this Committee has received no complaints regarding the State Bar Court or the Supreme Court regarding their respective roles in State Bar discipline. Because the Chief Justice is part of the Supreme Court, it would arguably be more appropriate for another person to appoint the Monitor. Accordingly, the author’s office suggests giving that authority to the California Attorney General instead. The following author’s amendments would make that change and also correct an inadvertent error in the bill regarding the year the Monitor provisions sunset.
Author’s Amendments:
On page 14, in line 35, strike out “Chief Justice of the California Supreme” and insert “Attorney General”
On page 14, in line 36, strike out “Court
On page 14, in line 37, strike out “the Chief Justice of the California”
On page 14, strike out line 38
On page 14, in line 39, strike out “conduct interviews of candidates for the position.”
On page 15, in line 6, remove “Chief Justice” and insert “Attorney General”
On page 15, strike out line 35 and insert “duties.”
On page 15, strike out lines 36 and 37.
On page 16, in line 16, strike out “2020,” and insert “2021,”
- Respecting the victims of dishonest attorneys
The Legislature required the Board to establish and administer a Client Security Fund to relieve or mitigate pecuniary losses caused by dishonest conduct of active members of the State Bar. In the May 2016 audit of the State Bar, the State Auditor noted:
The State Bar has not clearly informed stakeholders of the amounts it estimates it will pay to reimburse members of the public who suffer financial losses because of dishonest attorneys. By the end of 2015, the State Bar estimated it would pay about $18.9 million from its Client Security Fund for such reimbursements. Unfortunately, the Client Security Fund had approximately $2.2 million available by that time, severely limiting the State Bar’s ability to pay these claims. However, beginning in 2012, the State Bar eliminated from its financial statements any disclosure of Client Security Fund claims it expected to pay, reporting instead that the fund’s balance had improved. This impeded stakeholders’ ability to assess the financial condition of the Client Security Fund. After we discussed this issue with the State Bar, it revised its 2015 financial statements to disclose the amount of the Client Security Fund’s estimated payouts. (California State Auditor, State Bar of California: Its Lack of Transparency Has Undermined Its Communications With Decision Makers and Stakeholders, Report 2015-047 (May 2016).)
The State Auditor further reported that by the end of 2015, the State Bar had about 5,500 applications that the State Bar estimated would cost $18.9 million. However, the Client Security fund balance had dropped to $2.2 million, thus reducing the State Bar’s ability to pay claims in a timely manner. Because “the State Bar lacked the funds necessary to pay claims, it slowed its claims processing from about 18 months to about 36 months…”
In response to the State Auditor’s report that the State Bar has lacked transparency around providing the Legislature with an ability to accurately assess the financial condition of the Client Security Fund, and in response to claims now taking about 36 months to process, this bill would require the State Bar to conduct a thorough analysis of the Client Security Fund and to submit a report to the Legislature on its analysis of that fund by March 15, 2017. The analysis is intended to help ensure that the Client Security Fund can adequately protect the public and relieve or mitigate financial losses caused by the dishonest conduct of members of the State Bar by paying claims in a timely manner. The author offers the following amendment to clarify what is meant by paying claims in a timely manner and to allow for a review of the governance structure of the Client Security Fund to ensure that the structure provides for the most effective and efficient operation of the Fund.
Author’s amendment:
On page 21, on line 8, after ”including” insert “a review of the governance structure of Client Security Fund to ensure that the structure provides for the most effective and efficient operation of the Fund,”
On page 21, on line 27, after “from the” insert “later of the”
On page 21, on line 27, after “Bar” insert “and upon the resolution of underlying discipline case involving an attorney member, which is a prerequisite to paying the claim”
- Correcting problems identified by the State Auditor in the most recent audit of the State Bar and the authorization of further audits
Last year’s State Bar dues bill required the Board to contract with the California State Auditor to conduct an in-depth financial audit of the State Bar, including an audit of its financial statement, internal controls, and relevant management practices. The audit was required to, at a minimum, examine the revenues, expenditures, and reserves of the State Bar, including all fund transfers. The Auditor submitted the audit in May of 2016 and noted the following:
We identified other instances in which the State Bar’s reports lacked transparency. For example, the State Bar reported the balance in two of its funds as unrestricted—or available for general use—when, in fact, that money could only be used for specific purposes. The State Bar also has not clearly reported its budget assumptions to the Legislature, despite the fact that the Legislature relies on that budget to ensure the reasonableness of the State Bar’s fees. In addition, the State Bar recently pledged its member fee revenue when it entered into a loan agreement without informing the Legislature, even though the pledge might have restricted the Legislature’s ability to lower the State Bar’s fees. After we discussed our concern regarding this loan provision with the State Bar, it replaced this provision with a $7 million debt service reserve. The State Bar also created and used a nonprofit foundation without sufficient oversight of its Board of Trustees, and recently used almost $14,800 from its general fund to eliminate the foundation’s fund deficit without its board’s knowledge or approval. (California State Auditor, State Bar of California: Its Lack of Transparency Has Undermined Its Communications With Decision Makers and Stakeholders, Report 2015-047 (May 2016).
In response to the State Auditor’s report that the State Bar continues to lack transparency in its reports to the Legislature, this bill would require the Board to contract with the California State Auditor’s Office for an audit of its revenues, expenditures, reserves, and its financial statements for each fiscal year through 2020. This would be in addition to the biannual performance audit that the State Bar is required to contract with the State Auditor to perform and the annual audit of the Bar’s financial statement that is required to be performed by an independent accounting entity. Accordingly, in the next few years, the Board would have to contract with the State Auditor for two types of audits and also would have to contract with an additional independent auditor for an audit of their financial statement. SEIU 1000, an authorized State Bar employee bargaining unit representative, writing with a support with amendments position, states:
The current language of the bill also sets out a series of reports and audits on top of existing reports and audits. The timing of these reports creates a hardship for our members and, we believe, sets up the State Bar to fail in its regulatory reforms. We believe that the Legislature, when requiring reports or audits must set reasonable timelines to plan, report, and implement the recommendations in such a way that is productive.
The author offers the following amendments in an effort to streamline the audits:
Author’s amendments:
On page 21, in line 38, strike out “the Supreme Court,” and insert “California,”
On page 22, after line 15, insert: “The State Auditor shall develop a methodology for auditing the State Bar’s revenues, expenditures, reserves, and its financial statement for the audit due to the board, to the Chief Justice of California, and to the Assembly and Senate Committees on Judiciary in 2018, and may, for all financial audits performed subsequently to that audit, contract with a third party to conduct the financial audit following the methodology developed by the State Auditor in this paragraph and subject to State Auditor review.
On page 22, in line 27, strike out “the Supreme Court,” and insert “California,”
On page 22, in line 35, strike out “the Supreme” and insert “California,”
On page 22, in line 36, strike out “Court,”
On page 22, in line 38, strike out “the California Supreme Court,” and insert “California,”
On page 23, between lines 4 and 5 insert “The performance audits due to the board, to the Chief Justice of California, and to the Assembly and Senate Committees on Judiciary in 2017 and in 2019 may be combined with the financial audit required in subdivision (a).”
On page 23, in line 35, strike out “the California Supreme Court,” and insert “California,”
On page 24, in line 20, strike out “the California Supreme Court,” and insert “California,”
On page 24, in line 28, strike out “the Supreme Court,” and insert “California,”
Additionally, in response to State Auditor’s finding that the State Bar recently pledged its member fee revenue when it entered into a loan agreement without informing the Legislature, even though the pledge might have restricted the Legislature’s ability to lower the State Bar’s fees, this bill would delete the provision in law that provides that the Legislature may not reduce membership dues if the Board secures an obligation of the State Bar on membership dues.
Further, in response to the State Auditor’s report that the State Bar also created and used a nonprofit foundation without sufficient oversight of its Board, and recently used almost $14,800 from its general fund to eliminate the foundation’s fund deficit without its Board’s knowledge or approval, this bill would prohibit the State Bar from creating any foundation or nonprofit corporations as of December 31, 2016.
- Removing politics from governance, streamlining the State Bar Board of Trustees, and being more inclusive of appointees from all appointing authorities
The State Bar Board (Board) consists of 19 Board Member positions. Of those 19 positions, 6 are public member positions (non-attorneys) and 13 are attorneys. Of the 6 public members, 4 are appointees of the Governor, one is an appointee of the Senate Committee on Rules, and one is an appointee of the Assembly Speaker. Of the 13 Attorney appointees, 6 represent districts within California and are elected by attorneys, 5 are appointed by the Supreme Court, one is appointed by the Senate Committee on Rules, and one is appointed by the Assembly Speaker.
This bill would require the Board to transition from a 19 member board to a 13 member board through the gradual elimination of the 6 elected attorney positions. The bill also removes the attorney appointee from the Speaker of the Assembly and allows the Speaker instead to appoint a public member. Accordingly, the new Board would consist of 7 public members and 6 attorney members. This bill would further require each member of the Board appointed after December 31, 2016, to have demonstrated educational or experience expertise, or both, in one of 5 specified areas, including public finance.
While current law provides that the officers of the State Bar are the president, vice president, secretary, and treasurer, and are elected by the Board, this bill would instead require the Supreme Court to select from its appointed members a president and vice president of the State Bar. These robust changes to the board structure would arguably lead to a more focused, efficient, and less political Board. The author seeks the following amendments to further reform the Board structure.
The following author’s amendments would: (1) allow rather than require the appointing bodies to consider appointees with educational or experience in six areas, including immigration law; (2) would allow the appointees of the Supreme Court and the appointees of the Governor, Senate Committee on Rules and Speaker of the Assembly to serve for a term of four years instead of three; and (3) change the title of Board President and Vice President to Board Chair and Vice-Chair, to allow the Supreme Court to appoint both the Chair and Vice-Chair, and to allow their terms to be two years as Chair and Vice-Chair instead of one year terms, which will arguably allow for more consistency on the Board.
Author’s amendments:
- On page 9, in line 19, strike out “Each member appointed” and insert “When making appointments to the Board”
On page 9, in line 19, strike out “shall have” and insert “each appointing body should consider appointing members with”
On page 9, in line 20, strike out “educational” and insert “education”
On page 9, in line 20, strike out “experience expertise,” and insert “experience,”
On page 9, after line 26, insert “(6) Immigration law”
- On page 9, in line 39, strike out “three” and insert “four”
On page 10, in line 10, strike out “three” and insert “four”
On page 11, in line 14, insert “be four years” before “and he”
Amend Section 6013.1 of the Business and Profession Code to reflect a term of four years, instead of three, for Supreme Court appointments to the Board.
.
- On page 11, in line 34, strike out “its”
On page 11, in line 35, strike out “appointed” and insert “the”
On page 11, in line 35, strike out ”a president and a vice president” and insert “of the board a chair and a vice-chair”
On page 11, in line 36, strike out “president.” And insert “chair.”
On page 11, strike out lines 37 through 39
On page 12, in line 1, strike out “year.”
On page 12, in line 4, strike out “president, vice president, and treasurer” and insert “chair and vice-chair”
On page 12, in line 6, strike out “appointment or” and insert “appointment.”
On page 12, strike out line 7.
On page 12, in line 8, strike out “president” and insert “chair and vice-chair”
On page 12, in line 8, strike out “one-year, except” and insert “two-years,”
On page 12, strike out lines 9 through 16
On page 12, in line 20, strike out “officers” and insert “secretary and treasurer”
Staff notes, under current law, the 19-member Board consists of a supermajority of attorneys (13) as compared to public members (6). This bill creates a public member majority Board consisting of seven public members and six attorney members. The arguments offered by proponents of a public member majority board appear to rely on the premise that attorneys would be inherently self-interested and more likely to render decisions as Board members that would advantage attorneys to the detriment of the public. Proponents also argue that the State needs to preserve anti-trust immunity[2] through changing the composition of the Board from a supermajority attorney Board to a majority public member Board.
Some letters received by the Committee point to the Supreme Court decision of North Carolina State Board of Dental Examiners v. FTC (2015) 135 S. Ct. 1101 as necessitating a need for a public majority Board with each vote controlled only by the public members. Staff notes, however, that the Court in the North Carolina State Board of Dental Examiners case in no way held that market participant majority boards would inherently eviscerate the state’s anti-trust immunity. Having a majority public member controlled Boards would not ensure anti-trust immunity with respect to every single decision or action taken by the Board. They key for a State to receive anti-trust immunity is for a Board to receive active supervision by the State when it is engaging in decisions regarding market participation. For example in the North Carolina case, the state could not invoke anti-trust immunity because the state was not actively supervising the Board when it determined that teeth whitening could only be performed by dentists and issued cease-and-desist letters to non-dentist teeth whiteners. Notwithstanding the fact that the state had a Dental Practice Act that did not address teeth whitening, the dental board decided that teeth whitening was solely within dentists’ scope of practice.
Accordingly, it is unclear as to why the very fact specific decision in the North Carolina case should have any impact on how California decides the best composition of its State Bar Board. The Bar makes suggestions about what rules practicing lawyers should be subject to through their recommendations regarding the Rules of Professional Conduct. The Supreme Court ultimately determines whether to accept or reject those rules. The State Bar’s Office of Chief Trial Counsel makes determinations regarding the discipline of lawyers. But, the Supreme Court has final say in matters of discipline. It is the Legislature and Supreme Court who make determinations about criteria for becoming attorneys and what is within the scope of practice of an attorney. There is nothing to suggest that the State Bar Board has been engaging in the same kind of activity that made the state of North Carolina lose their anti-trust immunity in that specific circumstance.
Indeed, the Committee has not been made aware of any instances in which our supermajority attorney Bar Board has been sued for anti-competitive/anti-trust activity. Staff further notes that other state professional boards, such as the Medical Board, are comprised of a majority of members of the profession. Notably, the Court in the North Carolina case actually noted that having market participant controlled boards could be beneficial. As stated by the Court, “[t]he States have a sovereign interest in structuring their governments and may conclude that there are substantial benefits to staffing their agencies with experts in complex and technical subjects. There is, moreover, a long tradition of citizens esteemed by their professional colleagues devoting time, energy, and talent to enhancing the dignity of their calling.” (Id. At 1115 (internal citations omitted).) An effective way for the state to preserve its anti-trust immunity is to ensure that appointees are ethical, balanced, and fair. Each of the four appointing authorities have the obligation to ensure their appointees, whether attorneys or non-attorneys, possess high ethical standards. Doing away with attorney-elected appointees, as this bill does, will ensure that the Assembly, Senate, Governor, and Supreme Court maintain all control over the caliber of appointees to the Board.
The following amendments are suggested to change the board composition to consist of 6 public members and 7 attorney members.
Suggested amendment:
On page 9, in line 37, strike out “Rules.” and insert “Rules, and one by the Speaker of the Assembly.”
On page 10, in line 4, strike out “minimum of seven” and insert “maximum of six”
On page 10, in line 18, strike “two” and insert “one”
On page 10, in line 19, strike “members” and insert “member”
On page 10, strike out lines 27 through 32
The following suggested author’s amendment would require that members of the Executive Committee include at least one appointee by each of the appointing entities. This will allow for oversight and parity in participation by all appointing entities in the most crucial decisions made by the Board.
Author’s amendment:
Add a new section to the bill amending Section 6029 of the Business and Professions Code to read:
(a) The board may appoint such committees, officers and employees as it deems necessary or proper, and fix and pay salaries and necessary expenses.
(b) The members of the Executive committee shall include at least one member appointed by each of the Supreme Court, the Governor, the Senate Committee on Rules and the Speaker of the Assembly.
The following amendments are suggested to: (1) remove unnecessary provisions due to the removal of elected attorneys and allow the appointing entities to appoint for unexpired terms when vacancies occur; and (2) remove the bill’s findings and declarations as this bill is now substantive:
Suggested amendment:
- On page 9, in line 39, after “years.” insert “Vacancies shall be filled for the remainder of the term.”
On page 10, strike out lines 11 through 15, and insert “years. Vacancies shall be filled for the remainder of the term.”
On page 11, in line 13, strike out “commence at the conclusion of the annual meeting”
On page 11, in line 14, strike out “Succeeding his or her election or appointment,”
On page 11, in line 15, strike out “elected or”
On page 11, strike out lines 16 through 18 and insert “qualified. Vacancies shall be filled for the remainder of the term.”
- On page 4, strike out lines 1 through 31.
On page 5, strike out lines 1 through 40.
On page 6, strike out lines 1 through 3.
- Refinements to Bagley-Keene and the California Public Records Act
This bill would provide that access to records of the State Bar Court is subject to the rules and laws applicable to the judiciary instead of the California Public Records Act and would exempt the State Bar Court from the Bagley-Keene Open Meeting Act. Out of an abundance of caution to ensure that the statutory exception to California Public Records Act enacted last year, that prohibited sharing identifying information submitted by an applicant to the State Bar, would not be construed to be violated in the event of sharing information for purposes such as announcing applicants who have passed the bar examination, the author proposes the following amendments.
Author’s amendments:
On page 13, in line 4, strike out “to the board”
On page 14, after line 28, insert “This subdivision shall apply retroactively to January 1, 2016.”
- Push for removing the sections of the State Bar from the State Bar
This Committee received letters urging it to amend the bill to, at the very least, remove the sections from the State Bar. Proponents of de-unifying the State Bar assert that the structure is inherently infirm and results in a distracted State Bar that spends too much time on “trade association” matters and not enough time on discipline.
In support of decoupling, the Center for Public Interest Law writes the following:
It is time for action. It is completely improper for a government agency to mix regulatory duties with trade association activities that are promotional and protective of the profession the agency is supposed to regulate. That creates a conflict of interest, and has resulted in time-consuming and bureaucratic calculations of expenditures which may be funded with compulsory Bar licensing fees and those that may not be so funding. No other California occupational licensing agency is structured as such; no other agency has a ‘Hudson deduction’ by which licensees can opt out of paying for trade association activities they choose not to support.
Also, in support of decoupling, a group of Board Members, including both Senate appointees, assert the following:
The Board of Trustees is a distracted regulator. It spends much of its energy on professional association matters such as appointments of attorneys to positions of prestige, providing continuing legal education in competition with voluntary bars and for-profit providers while also regulating those providers, conducting an annual conference that draws fewer attendees and requires greater subsidy each year, publishing legal content, selling insurance, etc. [. . .] over that past two years, the Board has spent far more time in closed session addressing personnel, litigation and real estate issues than it has devoted in open session to regulation [. . .]. [T]he aspirations of attorney Trustees to attain the coveted tile of president of the California State Bar have very destructive consequences. Would-be Presidents often identify themselves from the moment they are seated and begin to compete for an election to be held three years later. The election season is perpetual.
Although this bill does not provide for the removal of the sections from the State Bar, it arguably addresses many of the issues raised by those who wish to decouple the State Bar. For example, this bill substantially revises the State Bar Act so as to reduce the politics on the Board, shine light on State Bar finances, provide victims of unauthorized practice of law a better opportunity to be heard, and increases the likelihood that victims of nefarious attorneys are able get restitution from the Client Security Fund.
Support: California Lawyers Guild; Responsive Law; SEIU Local 1000 (support if amended); State Bar Board of Trustees Denny Mangers, Heather Linn Rosing, Glenda Corcoran, and Joanna Mendoza (support if amended); several individuals (support if amended)
Opposition: Center for Public Interest Law (CPIL) (oppose unless amended); several individuals (oppose unless amended)
HISTORY
Source: Assembly Committee on Judiciary
Related Pending Legislation: None Known
Prior Legislation: SB 387 (Jackson, Ch. 5, Stats. 2015) authorized the State Bar of California to collect active membership dues of up to $390 for the year 2016; required the State Bar to develop and implement a specified workforce plan for its discipline system; required the State Bar to conduct a public sector compensation and benefits study, conduct a thorough analysis of its operating costs and develop a spending plan to determine a reasonable amount for the annual membership fee, as specified; required the State Bar to contract with the California State Auditor’s Office to conduct an in-depth financial audit of the State Bar; and made the State Bar subject to the Bagley-Keene Open Meeting Act and the California Public Records Act, as specified.
Prior Vote:
Assembly Floor (Ayes 79, Noes 0)
Assembly Floor (Ayes 10, Noes 50)
Assembly Judiciary Committee (Ayes 10, Noes 0)
**************
The Rules of Professional Conduct are the professional standards to which California attorneys must adhere. Violation of the rules may subject an attorney to discipline. ↑
The United States Supreme Court in Parker v. Brown (1942) 317 U.S. 341 interpreted antitrust laws to confer immunity on anticompetitive conduct by the States when acting in their own sovereign capacity. ↑
(Without Reference to File)
ASSEMBLY THIRD READING
ATR Bill Id:AB 2878
Author:(Committee on Judiciary)
As Amended Ver:June 2, 2016
Majority vote
Committee | Votes | Ayes | Noes |
Judiciary | 10-0 | Mark Stone, Wagner, Alejo, Chau, Chiu, Gallagher, Cristina Garcia, Holden, Maienschein, Ting |
SUMMARY: Reauthorizes attorney license fees at the same level as the current year. Specifically, this bill:
- Reauthorizes the State Bar to collect up to $390 for active membership dues for 2017.
- Eliminates the ability of the State Bar to prevent future Legislatures from reducing future membership dues by securing all or any portion of an obligation of the State Bar on future dues.
- Eliminates the State Bar's ability to create foundations or non-profit corporations as a means to raise additional revenue.
- Eliminates the six elected State Bar Board of Trustees members, and reduces the membership of the State Bar Board of Trustees from 19 members to 13 members. States the intent of the Legislature that this reduction of members occur through the expiration of the terms of the elected members who are serving as of December 31, 2016.
- Requires that each Board of Trustees member appointed after December 31, 2016 have specified, demonstrated expertise.
- Increases the number of public members appointed to the State Bar Board of Trustees by changing the Assembly's attorney appointee to a public member appointee at the expiration of the current attorney member's term.
- Provides that no motion of the Board of Trustees can be approved unless a majority of public members approve the motion.
- Provides that the president and vice president of the Board of Trustees be appointed by the Supreme Court instead of elected by the Board.
- Requires the Chief Justice of the Supreme Court to appoint an enforcement program monitor, through March 31, 2020, to monitor and evaluate the State Bar's disciplinary system to ensure the Bar is successfully and consistently protecting the public. Sets forth the duties of the enforcement monitor, including submitting an initial report to the Supreme Court and the Legislature by October 1, 2019, and a final report by March 31, 2020.
- Sets forth specific requirements for the handling of unlawful practice of law complaints, including specific timeframes for processing those complaints; specified, acceptable resolutions for those complaints; and requiring that those complaints be forwarded to law enforcement.
- Creates the California Bar Governance Commission, consisting of appointees of the Governor, the Chief Justice of the Supreme Court, the Assembly and the Senate Committee on Rules. Requires the Commission, by April 30, 2017, to evaluate all issues of governance of the State Bar, including but not limited to possible separation of the State Bar's regulatory and trade association functions, in order to recommend the best governance structure for the State Bar to ensure that the protection of the public is the highest priority in the licensing, regulation, and discipline of attorneys and that the State Bar appropriately functions as a government agency subject to laws that apply to similar regulatory bodies.
- Requires the State Auditor to conduct the State Bar's existing, annual financial audit through 2020. Requires the State Auditor, for its existing 2017 bi-annual performance audit of the State Bar, to review the State Bar's expenses, including executive salaries and benefits, outside contracts and real estate holding, to determine the appropriate and necessary expenses of the State Bar and the appropriate member dues level.
- Eliminates certain State Bar exceptions to the Bagley-Keene Open Meeting Act, and adds an exception from both the Bagley-Keene Open Meeting Act and the California Public Records Act for the State Bar Court. Provides that access to records of the State Bar Court shall be governed by the laws applicable to the records of the judiciary.
- Provides several exceptions to confidentiality of State Bar admission applications and records, including the names of applicants who passed the Bar examination.
- Requires the State Bar to conduct an analysis of the funds necessary to timely satisfy claims against the Client Security Fund (CSF), including possible additional efforts to increase collection from responsible attorneys, a review of other non-public protection expenditures, including executive salaries and benefits, that can be redirected to better fund the CSF, and after exhausting all other options, whether a dues increase is necessary to ensure timely payment of claims against the CSF. The report is due to the Legislature by March 15, 2017.
- Makes various findings concerning events at the State Bar and states the intent of the Legislature that this bill serves as a vehicle to implement possible recommendations for substantially improving the operations, effectiveness and efficiency of the State Bar, based in part on reports to be submitted to the Legislature in the coming months.
EXISTING LAW:
- Requires all attorneys who practice law in California to be members of the State Bar and establishes the State Bar for the purpose of regulating the legal profession. Pursuant to the State Bar Act, requires the annual mandatory membership fee set by the State Bar's Board of Trustees (Board) to pay for discipline and other functions to be ratified by the Legislature. (Business and Professions Code Section 6000 et seq. Unless stated otherwise, all further statutory references refer to that code.)
- Authorizes the State Bar to collect $315 in annual membership fees from active members for a total annual dues bill of $390 for the year 2016. Provides that the other $75 is pursuant to statutory authorization to assess annually the following fees: $40 for the Client Security Fund; $25 for the disciplinary system; and $10 for the Lawyer Assistance Program. (Sections 6140, 6140.55, 6140.6, 6140.9.)
- Authorizes the State Bar to collect $75 in annual membership fees from inactive members for a total annual dues bill of $115. Provides that the other $40 is pursuant to statutory authorization to assess annually the following fees: $10 for the Client Security Fund; $25 for the disciplinary system; and $5 for the Lawyer Assistance Program. (Sections 6141, 6140.55, 6140.6, 6140.9.)
- Directs $40 of membership dues to legal services purposes unless a member elects not to support those activities. (Section 6140.03.)
- Provides that protection of the public is the highest priority of the State Bar and its Board in exercising their licensing, regulatory and disciplinary functions. Whenever the protection of the public is inconsistent with other interests sought to be promoted, provides that the protection of the public shall be paramount. (Section 6001.1.)
- Creates the Governance in the Public Interest Task Force, effective February 1, 2013, and requires that the task force report to the Supreme Court, the Governor and the Assembly and Senate Judiciary Committees by May 15, 2014, and every three years thereafter, its recommendations for enhancing public protection and ensuring that public protection is the State Bar's highest priority. (The task force has yet to submit its first report.) (Section 6001.2.)
- Permits the State Bar, for purpose of carrying into effect and promoting its objectives (of which public protection is its highest priority), to sell, lease, exchange, convey, transfer, assign, encumber, pledge, dispose of any of its real or personal property or any interest therein, including without limitation all or any portion of its income or revenues from membership fees paid or payable by members. (Section 6001.)
- Provides, pursuant to a 1950's statute, that whenever the Board secures an obligation of the State Bar on all or any portion of the fees from membership dues the Legislature may not, until the obligation is repaid in full, reduce membership dues below the maximum amount in effect when the obligation was created and provides that this constitutes a covenant to the holder of the obligation. (Section 6008.5.)
- Requires the State Bar to annually report on the performance and condition of its discipline system, including the backlog of discipline cases that are six months old and case processing times, as provided. (Section 6086.15.)
- Requires the State Bar to develop and implement a workforce plan for its discipline system and conduct a public sector compensation and benefits study, including a recommendation for an appropriate backlog goal and an assessment of staffing needed to achieve that goal. Requires the State Bar to conduct a thorough analysis of its operating costs and develop a spending plan to determine a reasonable amount for its annual dues. Requires that the workforce plan and the spending plan be submitted to the Legislature by May 15, 2016, and be implemented by December 31, 2016. (Section 6140.16.)
- Requires the State Bar's Board to contract with the California State Auditor to conduct a financial audit of the State Bar, including an audit of its financial statement, internal controls and practices, and requires that the audit be submitted to the Board, the Chief Justice of the California Supreme Court, and the Assembly and Senate Judiciary Committees by May 15, 2016. Requires the audit to examine revenues, expenditures, reserves and fund transfers. (Section 6145(c).)
- Subjects the State Bar to the Public Records Act, with specified exceptions. Provides that identifying information submitted by applicants to the State Bar for admission to practice law and State Bar admissions records, as specified, are confidential and may not be disclosed pursuant to any state law including the Public Records Act. (Sections 6001, 6026.11.)
- Effective April 1, 2016, subjects the State Bar to the Bagley-Keene Open Meeting Act, as provided, with exemptions for the Judicial Nominees Evaluation Commission and the Committee of Bar Examiners. (Sections 6001 6026.7; Government Code Section 11121.)
FISCAL EFFECT: None
COMMENTS: This bill continues the decades-long tradition of oversight of the Bar by the Assembly and Senate Judiciary Committees via review of the annual dues authorization bill, as part of general oversight role of the Legislature over the agencies in the executive and judicial branches of government. Last year's bar dues bill required the State Bar to comply with important government transparency and accountability laws by way of the Bagley-Keene Open Meeting Act and the California Public Records Act. (SB 387 (Jackson), Chapter 537, Statutes of 2015.) Also last year, in response to significant and troubling audit findings and other concerns, the Legislature required the State Auditor to perform an in-depth financial audit of the Bar. That audit, The State Bar of California: Its Lack of Transparency Has Undermined its Communications with Decision Makers and Stakeholders (May 2016), found that the State Bar's financial reports "contained errors and lacked transparency;" in the absence of oversight, the State Bar has made "questionable or inappropriate financial decisions;" it has failed to take steps to minimize a years' long backlog in compensating victims of dishonest lawyers; and it provides executives with "significantly more generous salaries and benefits than other executives in comparable positions in state government." (Id. at 1-3.)
This bill comes to the Assembly after yet another year of extensive and publically reported turmoil involving the State Bar, some of which has come to light because of new open government laws. Given the ongoing turmoil at the State Bar and the Legislature's very strong desire to make this state agency, once and for all, an effective regulator of attorneys and protector of the public, the Legislature has two options: Continue to attempt to micromanage the State Bar through ongoing studies, reports and ever tightening legislative oversight, or fundamentally reform the structure of the State Bar so that it runs much more effectively and efficiently with protection of the public as its one clear directive. This bill, as recently amended, does a bit of both.
At this point, this bill authorizes the State Bar to collect active membership dues of up to $390 for 2017, the same rate as this year. The State Bar's programs are financed almost exclusively by annual membership dues paid by attorneys, as well as other fees paid by applicants who are seeking to practice law. The State Bar also uses its name and membership lists to sell items such as malpractice insurance and car rentals, and receives payment for those activities. The State Bar currently has complete discretion over how funds from this latter activity, which amount to approximately $2 million per year, are used. The State Bar's total revenue for 2016 is $118 million, excluding funds from interest on lawyer trust accounts that pass-through the State Bar and fund legal services, with $74.3 million coming from mandatory dues.
The bill also eliminates an anachronistic 1950's era statute that prohibits future Legislatures, if the State Bar uses any portion of membership dues as security for an obligation, from reducing membership dues below the amount in effect when the obligation was created by the State Bar, until the obligation is paid in full. While it is highly questionable whether this provision is constitutional, it is clear that it reduces the important oversight role of the Legislature over the State Bar which is needed to ensure that public protection is and remains the paramount concern of the State Bar. Therefore, this bill rightly deletes that provision.
As recently amended, this bill seeks to improve governance of the State Bar by eliminating the six Board of Trustee elected member position, reducing the Board from 19 members to 13 members as the terms of existing elected members expire, switching the board from a majority active members to a majority public members, thus eliminating antitrust concerns and potentially significant state liability, and requiring the president and vice president be appointed by the Supreme Court. The amendments also codify requirements for handling unlawful practice of law complaints to ensure that these complaints, particularly those involving vulnerable immigrant clients, do not sit in a drawer unprocessed for months or years. In addition the amendments create a short-term discipline monitor, to review and improve overall the Bar's discipline system, and the California Bar Governance Commission, to evaluate all issues of governance of the State Bar, including but not limited to possible separation of the State Bar's regulatory and trade association functions, in order to recommend the best governance structure for the State Bar to ensure that the protection of the public is the highest priority in the licensing, regulation, and discipline of attorneys and that the State Bar appropriately functions as a government agency subject to laws that apply to similar regulatory bodies. Finally, the recent amendments require the State Auditor to review the State Bar's expenses, including executive salaries and benefits, outside contracts and real estate holding, to determine the appropriate and necessary expenses of the State Bar and the appropriate member dues level. These amendments go a long way to making this state agency, once and for all, an effective regulator of attorneys and a protector of the public.
Analysis Prepared by: Leora Gershenzon / JUD. / (916) 319-2334 FN: 0003398
ASSEMBLY THIRD READING
ATR Bill Id:AB 2878
Author:(Committee on Judiciary)
As Amended Ver:May 27, 2016
Majority vote
Committee | Votes | Ayes | Noes |
Judiciary | 10-0 | Mark Stone, Wagner, Alejo, Chau, Chiu, Gallagher, Cristina Garcia, Holden, Maienschein, Ting |
SUMMARY: Reauthorizes attorney license fees at the same level as the current year. Specifically, this bill:
- Reauthorizes the State Bar to collect up to $390 for active membership dues for 2017.
- Eliminates the ability of the State Bar to prevent future Legislatures from reducing future membership dues by securing all or any portion of an obligation of the State Bar on future dues.
- Eliminates the State Bar's ability to create foundations or non-profit corporations as a means to raise additional revenue.
- Eliminates the six elected State Bar Board of Trustees members, and reduces the membership of the State Bar Board of Trustees from 19 members to 13 members. States the intent of the Legislature that this reduction of members occur through the expiration of the terms of the elected members who are serving as of December 31, 2016.
- Requires that each Board of Trustees member appointed after December 31, 2016 have demonstrated expertise in at least one of the following:
- Public finance;
- Public administration;
- Business or financial management;
- State government, particularly prior regulatory experience; and
- Legal ethics.
- Eliminates certain State Bar exceptions to the Bagley-Keene Open Meeting Act, and adds an exception from both the Bagley-Keene Open Meeting Act and the California Public Records Act for the State Bar Court. Provides that access to records of the State Bar Court shall be governed by the laws applicable to the records of the judiciary.
- Provides several exceptions to confidentiality of State Bar admission applications and records, including the names of applicants who passed the Bar examination.
- Requires the State Bar to conduct an analysis of the funds necessary to timely satisfy claims against the Client Security Fund (CSF), including possible additional efforts to increase collection from responsible attorneys, a review of other non-public protection expenditures, including executive salaries and benefits, that can be redirected to better fund the CSF, and after exhausting all other options, whether a dues increase is necessary to ensure timely payment of claims against the CSF. The report is due to the Legislature by March 15, 2017.
- Makes various findings concerning events at the State Bar and states the intent of the Legislature that this bill serves as a vehicle to implement possible recommendations for substantially improving the operations, effectiveness and efficiency of the State Bar, based in part on reports to be submitted to the Legislature in the coming months.
EXISTING LAW:
- Requires all attorneys who practice law in California to be members of the State Bar and establishes the State Bar for the purpose of regulating the legal profession. Pursuant to the State Bar Act, requires the annual mandatory membership fee set by the State Bar's Board of Trustees (Board) to pay for discipline and other functions to be ratified by the Legislature. (Business and Professions Code Section 6000 et seq. Unless stated otherwise, all further statutory references refer to that code.)
- Authorizes the State Bar to collect $315 in annual membership fees from active members for a total annual dues bill of $390 for the year 2016. Provides that the other $75 is pursuant to statutory authorization to assess annually the following fees: $40 for the Client Security Fund; $25 for the disciplinary system; and $10 for the Lawyer Assistance Program. (Sections 6140, 6140.55, 6140.6, 6140.9.)
- Authorizes the State Bar to collect $75 in annual membership fees from inactive members for a total annual dues bill of $115. Provides that the other $40 is pursuant to statutory authorization to assess annually the following fees: $10 for the Client Security Fund; $25 for the disciplinary system; and $5 for the Lawyer Assistance Program. (Sections 6141, 6140.55, 6140.6, 6140.9.)
- Directs $40 of membership dues to legal services purposes unless a member elects not to support those activities. (Section 6140.03.)
- Provides that protection of the public is the highest priority of the State Bar and its Board in exercising their licensing, regulatory and disciplinary functions. Whenever the protection of the public is inconsistent with other interests sought to be promoted, provides that the protection of the public shall be paramount. (Section 6001.1.)
- Creates the Governance in the Public Interest Task Force, effective February 1, 2013, and requires that the task force report to the Supreme Court, the Governor and the Assembly and Senate Judiciary Committees by May 15, 2014, and every three years thereafter, its recommendations for enhancing public protection and ensuring that public protection is the State Bar's highest priority. (The task force has yet to submit its first report.) (Section 6001.2.)
- Permits the State Bar, for purpose of carrying into effect and promoting its objectives (of which public protection is its highest priority), to sell, lease, exchange, convey, transfer, assign, encumber, pledge, dispose of any of its real or personal property or any interest therein, including without limitation all or any portion of its income or revenues from membership fees paid or payable by members. (Section 6001.)
- Provides, pursuant to a 1950's statute, that whenever the Board secures an obligation of the State Bar on all or any portion of the fees from membership dues the Legislature may not, until the obligation is repaid in full, reduce membership dues below the maximum amount in effect when the obligation was created and provides that this constitutes a covenant to the holder of the obligation. (Section 6008.5.)
- Requires the State Bar to annually report on the performance and condition of its discipline system, including the backlog of discipline cases that are six months old and case processing times, as provided. (Section 6086.15.)
- Requires the State Bar to develop and implement a workforce plan for its discipline system and conduct a public sector compensation and benefits study, including a recommendation for an appropriate backlog goal and an assessment of staffing needed to achieve that goal. Requires the State Bar to conduct a thorough analysis of its operating costs and develop a spending plan to determine a reasonable amount for its annual dues. Requires that the workforce plan and the spending plan be submitted to the Legislature by May 15, 2016, and be implemented by December 31, 2016. (Section 6140.16.)
- Requires the State Bar's Board to contract with the California State Auditor to conduct a financial audit of the State Bar, including an audit of its financial statement, internal controls and practices, and requires that the audit be submitted to the Board, the Chief Justice of the California Supreme Court, and the Assembly and Senate Judiciary Committees by May 15, 2016. Requires the audit to examine revenues, expenditures, reserves and fund transfers. (Section 6145(c).)
- Subjects the State Bar to the Public Records Act, with specified exceptions. Provides that identifying information submitted by applicants to the State Bar for admission to practice law and State Bar admissions records, as specified, are confidential and may not be disclosed pursuant to any state law including the Public Records Act. (Sections 6001, 6026.11.)
- Effective April 1, 2016, subjects the State Bar to the Bagley-Keene Open Meeting Act, as provided, with exemptions for the Judicial Nominees Evaluation Commission and the Committee of Bar Examiners. (Sections 6001 6026.7; Government Code Section 11121.)
FISCAL EFFECT: None
COMMENTS: This bill continues the decades-long tradition of oversight of the Bar by the Assembly and Senate Judiciary Committees via review of the annual dues authorization bill, as part of general oversight role of the Legislature over the agencies in the executive and judicial branches of government. Last year's bar dues bill required the State Bar to comply with important government transparency and accountability laws by way of the Bagley-Keene Open Meeting Act and the California Public Records Act. (SB 387 (Jackson), Chapter 537, Statutes of 2015.) Also last year, in response to significant and troubling audit findings and other concerns, the Legislature required the State Auditor to perform an in-depth financial audit of the Bar. That audit, The State Bar of California: Its Lack of Transparency Has Undermined its Communications with Decision Makers and Stakeholders (May 2016), found that the State Bar's financial reports "contained errors and lacked transparency;" in the absence of oversight, the State Bar has made "questionable or inappropriate financial decisions;" it has failed to take steps to minimize a years' long backlog in compensating victims of dishonest lawyers; and it provides executives with "significantly more generous salaries and benefits than other executives in comparable positions in state government." (Id. at 1-3.)
This bill comes to this Committee after yet another year of extensive and publically reported turmoil involving the State Bar, some of which has come to light because of new open government laws. Given the ongoing turmoil at the State Bar and the Legislature's very strong desire to make this state agency, once and for all, an effective regulator of attorneys and protector of the public, the Legislature has two options: Continue to attempt to micromanage the State Bar through ongoing studies, reports and ever tightening legislative oversight, or fundamentally reform the structure of the State Bar so that it runs much more effectively and efficiently with protection of the public as its one clear directive.
At this point, this bill authorizes the State Bar to collect active membership dues of up to $390 for 2017, the same rate as this year. The State Bar's programs are financed almost exclusively by annual membership dues paid by attorneys, as well as other fees paid by applicants who are seeking to practice law. The State Bar also uses its name and membership lists to sell items such as malpractice insurance and car rentals, and receives payment for those activities. The State Bar currently has complete discretion over how funds from this latter activity, which amount to approximately $2 million per year, are used. The State Bar's total revenue for 2016 is $118 million, excluding funds from interest on lawyer trust accounts that pass-through the State Bar and fund legal services, with $74.3 million coming from mandatory dues.
The bill also eliminates an anachronistic 1950's era statute that prohibits future Legislatures, if the State Bar uses any portion of membership dues as security for an obligation, from reducing membership dues below the amount in effect when the obligation was created by the State Bar, until the obligation is paid in full. While it is highly questionable whether this provision is constitutional, it is clear that it reduces the important oversight role of the Legislature over the State Bar which is needed to ensure that public protection is and remains the paramount concern of the State Bar. Therefore, this bill rightly deletes that provision.
As recently amended, this bill seeks to improve governance of the State Bar by eliminating the six Board of Trustee elected member position, reducing the Board from 19 members to 13 members as the terms of existing elected members expire. This bill also requires that new Board members, appointed after December 31, 2016, demonstrate oversight in public administration, financial management or regulatory oversight. The latest amendments also implement some of the recommendations of the State Auditor from the most recent audit and make some minor changes in the transparency laws passed last year.
However, even as recently amended, this bill, does not fully address critical governance or oversight issues, including whether the Board of Trustees, which is comprised of a supermajority of active market participants, can legally regulate attorneys and still avoid antitrust liability. Nor does it address whether the State Bar's primary regulatory and public protection functions should be de-coupled from its professional association functions, as some, including current State Bar trustees, have suggested. These additional issues should be considered along with the State Bar's Governance in the Public Interest Task Force report, which was due May 15, 2014, and which is supposed to offer its recommendations for enhancing public protection and ensuring that public protection is the State Bar's highest priority. It is anticipated that further, significant amendments are necessary to overcome the State Bar's ongoing and long-standing governance and oversight shortfalls.
Analysis Prepared by: Leora Gershenzon / JUD. / (916) 319-2334 FN: 0003074
ASSEMBLY THIRD READING
ATR Bill Id:AB 2878
Author:(Committee on Judiciary)
As Amended Ver:April 18, 2016
Majority vote
Committee | Votes | Ayes | Noes |
Judiciary | 10-0 | Mark Stone, Wagner, Alejo, Chau, Chiu, Gallagher, Cristina Garcia, Holden, Maienschein, Ting |
|
SUMMARY: Reauthorizes attorney license fees at the same level as the current year. Specifically, this bill:
- Reauthorizes the State Bar to collect up to $390 for active membership dues for 2017.
- Eliminates the ability of the State Bar to prevent future Legislatures from reducing future membership dues by securing all or any portion of an obligation of the State Bar on future dues.
- Makes various findings concerning events at the State Bar and states the intent of the Legislature that this bill serves as a vehicle to implement possible recommendations for substantially improving the operations, effectiveness and efficiency of the State Bar, based in part on reports to be submitted to the Legislature in the coming months.
EXISTING LAW:
- Requires all attorneys who practice law in California to be members of the State Bar and establishes the State Bar for the purpose of regulating the legal profession. Pursuant to the State Bar Act, requires the annual mandatory membership fee set by the State Bar's Board of Trustees (Board) to pay for discipline and other functions to be ratified by the Legislature. (Business and Professions Code Section 6000 et seq. Unless stated otherwise, all further statutory references refer to that code.)
- Authorizes the State Bar to collect $315 in annual membership fees from active members for a total annual dues bill of $390 for the year 2016. Provides that the other $75 is pursuant to statutory authorization to assess annually the following fees: $40 for the Client Security Fund; $25 for the disciplinary system; and $10 for the Lawyer Assistance Program. (Sections 6140, 6140.55, 6140.6, 6140.9.)
- Authorizes the State Bar to collect $75 in annual membership fees from inactive members for a total annual dues bill of $115. Provides that the other $40 is pursuant to statutory authorization to assess annually the following fees: $10 for the Client Security Fund; $25 for the disciplinary system; and $5 for the Lawyer Assistance Program. (Sections 6141, 6140.55, 6140.6, 6140.9.)
- Directs $40 of membership dues to legal services purposes unless a member elects not to support those activities. (Section 6140.03.)
- Provides that protection of the public is the highest priority of the State Bar and its Board in exercising their licensing, regulatory and disciplinary functions. Whenever the protection of the public is inconsistent with other interests sought to be promoted, provides that the protection of the public shall be paramount. (Section 6001.1.)
- Creates the Governance in the Public Interest Task Force, effective February 1, 2013, and requires that the task force report to the Supreme Court, the Governor and the Assembly and Senate Judiciary Committees by May 15, 2014, and every three years thereafter, its recommendations for enhancing public protection and ensuring that public protection is the State Bar's highest priority. (The task force has yet to submit its first report.) (Section 6001.2.)
- Permits the State Bar, for purpose of carrying into effect and promoting its objectives (of which public protection is its highest priority), to sell, lease, exchange, convey, transfer, assign, encumber, pledge, dispose of any of its real or personal property or any interest therein, including without limitation all or any portion of its income or revenues from membership fees paid or payable by members. (Section 6001.)
- Provides, pursuant to a 1950's statute, that whenever the Board secures an obligation of the State Bar on all or any portion of the fees from membership dues the Legislature may not, until the obligation is repaid in full, reduce membership dues below the maximum amount in effect when the obligation was created and provides that this constitutes a covenant to the holder of the obligation. (Section 6008.5.)
- Requires the State Bar to annually report on the performance and condition of its discipline system, including the backlog of discipline cases that are six months old and case processing times, as provided. (Section 6086.15.)
- Requires the State Bar to develop and implement a workforce plan for its discipline system and conduct a public sector compensation and benefits study, including a recommendation for an appropriate backlog goal and an assessment of staffing needed to achieve that goal. Requires the State Bar to conduct a thorough analysis of its operating costs and develop a spending plan to determine a reasonable amount for its annual dues. Requires that the workforce plan and the spending plan be submitted to the Legislature by May 15, 2016, and be implemented by December 31, 2016. (Section 6140.16.)
- Requires the State Bar's Board to contract with the California State Auditor to conduct a financial audit of the State Bar, including an audit of its financial statement, internal controls and practices, and requires that the audit be submitted to the Board, the Chief Justice of the California Supreme Court, and the Assembly and Senate Judiciary Committees by May 15, 2016. Requires the audit to examine revenues, expenditures, reserves and fund transfers. (Section 6145 (c).)
- Subjects the State Bar to the Public Records Act, with specified exceptions. Provides that identifying information submitted by applicants to the State Bar for admission to practice law and State Bar admissions records, as specified, are confidential and may not be disclosed pursuant to any state law including the Public Records Act. (Sections 6001, 6026.11.)
- Effective April 1, 2016, subjects the State Bar to the Bagley-Keene Open Meeting Act, as provided, with exemptions for the Judicial Nominees Evaluation Commission and the Committee of Bar Examiners. (Sections 6001 6026.7; Government Code Section 11121.)
FISCAL EFFECT: None
COMMENTS: This bill continues the decades-long tradition of oversight of the Bar by the Assembly and Senate Judiciary Committees via review of the annual dues authorization bill, as part of general oversight role of the Legislature over the agencies in the executive and judicial branches of government. Last year, in response to significant and troubling audit findings and other concerns, the Legislature required the State Auditor to perform an in-depth financial audit of the Bar, due May 15, 2016. Last year's bar dues bill also required the State Bar to comply with important government transparency and accountability laws by way of the Bagley-Keene Open Meeting Act and the California Public Records Act. (SB 387 (Jackson), Chapter 537, Statutes of 2015.) This bill comes to this Committee after another year of extensive and publically reported turmoil involving the State Bar, some of which has come to light because of new open government laws.
At this point, this bill merely authorizes the State Bar to collect active membership dues of up to $390 for 2017, the same rate as this year. The State Bar's programs are financed almost exclusively by annual membership dues paid by attorneys, as well as other fees paid by applicants who are seeking to practice law. The State Bar also uses its name and membership lists to sell items such as malpractice insurance and car rentals, and receives payment for those activities. The State Bar currently has complete discretion over how funds from this latter activity, which amount to approximately $2 million per year, are used. The State Bar's total revenue for 2016 is $118 million, excluding funds from interest on lawyer trust accounts that pass-through the State Bar and fund legal services, with $74.3 million coming from mandatory dues.
As required by last year's State Bar dues bill, the State Bar is conducting an analysis of its operating costs and developing a spending plan to determine a proposed amount to report to the Legislature for its annual dues. The spending plan must be submitted to the Legislature by May 15, 2016. Once that report is submitted, along with an audit from the State Auditor on the State Bar's finances that was also mandated in last year's dues bill and is also due by May 15, 2016, and the Legislature has thoroughly reviewed both reports, the State Bar dues amount in this bill could either increase or decrease, as the Legislature deems appropriate, based on the actual needs of the State Bar to effectively and efficiently protect the public.
The bill also eliminates an anachronistic 1950's era statute that prohibits future Legislatures, if the State Bar uses any portion of membership dues as security for an obligation, from reducing membership dues below the amount in effect when the obligation was created by the State Bar, until the obligation is paid in full. While it is highly questionable whether this provision is constitutional, it is clear that it reduces the important oversight role of the Legislature over the State Bar which is needed to ensure that public protection is and remains the paramount concern of the State Bar. Therefore, this bill rightly deletes that provision.
This bill in its current form does not address any other governance or oversight issues, including whether the Board of Trustees, which is comprised of a supermajority of active market participants, can legally regulate attorneys and still avoid antitrust liability. Nor does it address whether the State Bar's primary regulatory and public protection functions should be de-coupled from its professional association functions, as some including current State Bar trustees have suggested. These additional issues will be considered along with the State Bar's Governance in the Public Interest Task Force report, which was due May 15, 2014, and which is supposed to offer its recommendations for enhancing public protection and ensuring that public protection is the State Bar's highest priority
Analysis Prepared by: Leora Gershenzon / JUD. / (916) 319-2334 FN: 0002793
Date of Hearing: April 26, 2016
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON JUDICIARY
Mark Stone, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 2878
Author:(Committee on Judiciary) – As Amended Ver:April 18, 2016
SUBJECT: STATE BAR DUES: ANNUAL AUTHORIZATION OF MEMBER DUES, OVERSIGHT AND PUBLIC PROTECTION
KEY ISSUES:
- SHOULD THE LEGISLATURE AUTHORIZE THE STATE BAR TO assess MEMBERSHIP dues for active bar members in 2017 AT $390, THE SAME RATE AS THIS YEAR?
- SHOULD THE BAR'S ABILITY TO TIE THE HANDS OF FUTURE LEGISLATURE IN SETTING PROPER DUES, ENACTED IN THE 1950's, be ELIMINATED?
- as part of THE LEGISLATURE'S annual oversight OF THE BAR, CONDUCTED THROUGH THE DUES BILL, AND IN LIGHT OF THE MOST RECENT and ongoing FINANCIAL AND ADMINISTRATIVE CONCERNS, should the legislature consider SUBSTANTIAL CHANGES TO bar GOVERNANCE AND accountability CONSISTENT WITH THE BAR’S PARAMOUNT DUTY TO PROTECT THE PUBLIC?
SYNOPSIS
This bill continues the decades-long tradition of Judiciary Committee oversight of the Bar via review of the annual dues authorization bill, as part of general legislative oversight of agencies within the executive and judicial branches of government. Last year, in response to troubling audit findings as well as other problems in state bar governance, the Legislature required that the State Auditor perform an in-depth financial audit of the Bar, and that the Bar complete both a workforce plan for its discipline system and a spending plan to determine a reasonable amount for its annual dues. These critically important evaluations are all due to the Legislature by May 15, 2016. In addition, last year's legislation required the Bar, as a state agency, to comply with normal government transparency and accountability laws pursuant to the Bagley-Keene Open Meeting Act and the California Public Records Act.
This bill comes to this Committee after yet another year of extensive and publically reported turmoil involving the Bar, some of the information likely coming to light by way of the open government laws applied to the Bar last year. First, the media reported that the Bar had failed to investigate over 300 complaints about the unauthorized practice of law, some awaiting assignment to an investigator for years before any action was taken. According to the Bar, many of those complaints were filed by immigrants seeking legal assistance with, among other things, their legal status in this country. It goes without saying that failure to immediately investigate and, when appropriate, take action to stop the unauthorized practice of law puts the public at substantial risk and the longer the delays are, the more the public is put at risk. The Bar now asserts that these cases are being assigned to an attorney immediately upon receipt and the backlog has finally been addressed, but when this matter was first made public, over 300 cases were still awaiting intake. Had this issue not been made public, it is unclear whether such swift corrective action would have been taken. Second, the Bar, without input from or approval by the Legislature, and apparently without fully following its own newly established procedures, took out a $10 million loan for tenant improvements to its San Francisco facility and attempted to secure the loan with future member bar dues payments, which could have tied the hands of future Legislatures in the setting of dues based on a 1950's era statute. This apparently only came to light as a result of the State Auditor's recent audit of the Bar. Other issues of concern are discussed more fully below.
As now in print, this bill maintains member bar dues for 2017 at their same level as this year, while awaiting the results of the workforce and spending plans, as well as the 2016 State Auditor audit. The bill also appropriately eliminates the 1950's era statute that potentially allowed the Bar to tie the Legislature's hands in the future, interfering with its statutory duty to set member bar dues.
The bill in its current form does not address other broad governance and oversight issues discussed in more detail in the analysis, including whether the Board of Trustees, comprised of a supermajority of active market participants, can legally regulate attorneys and still avoid antitrust liability. Nor does it address whether the Bar's primary regulatory and public protection functions should be de-coupled from its trade association functions, as some, including a number of current Bar trustees, have suggested. However, both issues are discussed in the analysis.
The bill is supported, if amended, by some Bar Board trustees who argue that the bill should begin the process of de-coupling the Bar's regulatory functions from its trade association role. This bill is opposed, unless amended, by the Center for Public Interest Law which argues that it should address not only the governance and de-unification issues discussed above, but also a number of other concerns, including the need for an outside investigator to help ensure that the Bar better focuses on its paramount responsibility: protecting the public from harm. Given the forthcoming audit to be released by the State Auditor and the State Bar’s workforce and operational cost spending plans that are all due in mid-May, it is likely that this bill will be substantially amended in the near future to address issues raised and reforms that may be suggested by the Auditor, the Bar, and the Legislature.
SUMMARY: Reauthorizes attorney license fees at the same level as the current year. Specifically, this bill:
- Reauthorizes the State Bar to collect up to $390 for active membership dues for 2017.
- Eliminates the ability of the State Bar to prevent future Legislatures from reducing future membership dues by securing all or any portion of an obligation of the State Bar on future dues.
- Makes various findings concerning events at the State Bar and states the intent of the Legislature that this bill serve as a vehicle to implement possible recommendations for substantially improving the operations, effectiveness and efficiency of the State Bar, based in part on reports to be submitted to the Legislature in the coming months.
EXISTING LAW:
- Requires all attorneys who practice law in California to be members of the State Bar and establishes the State Bar for the purpose of regulating the legal profession. Pursuant to the State Bar Act, requires the annual mandatory membership fee set by the State Bar’s Board of Trustees (Board) to pay for discipline and other functions to be ratified by the Legislature. (Business & Professions Code Section 6000 et seq. Unless stated otherwise, all further statutory references refer to that code.)
- Authorizes the State Bar to collect $315 in annual membership fees from active members for a total annual dues bill of $390 for the year 2016. Provides that the other $75 is pursuant to statutory authorization to assess annually the following fees: $40 for the Client Security Fund; $25 for the disciplinary system; and $10 for the Lawyer Assistance Program. (Sections 6140, 6140.55, 6140.6, 6140.9.)
- Authorizes the State Bar to collect $75 in annual membership fees from inactive members for a total annual dues bill of $115. Provides that the other $40 is pursuant to statutory authorization to assess annually the following fees: $10 for the Client Security Fund; $25 for the disciplinary system; and $5 for the Lawyer Assistance Program. (Sections 6141, 6140.55, 6140.6, 6140.9.)
- Directs $40 of membership dues to legal services purposes unless a member elects not to support those activities. (Section 6140.03.)
- Provides that protection of the public is the highest priority of the State Bar and its Board in exercising their licensing, regulatory and disciplinary functions. Whenever the protection of the public is inconsistent with other interests sought to be promoted, provides that the protection of the public shall be paramount. (Section 6001.1.)
- Creates the Governance in the Public Interest Task Force, effective February 1, 2013, and requires that the task force report to the Supreme Court, the Governor and the Assembly and Senate Judiciary Committees by May 15, 2014, and every three years thereafter, its recommendations for enhancing public protection and ensuring that public protection is the State Bar's highest priority. (The task force has yet to submit its first report.) (Section 6001.2.)
- Permits the State Bar, for purpose of carrying into effect and promoting its objectives (of which public protection is its highest priority), to sell, lease, exchange, convey, transfer, assign, encumber, pledge, dispose of any of its real or personal property or any interest therein, including without limitation all or any portion of its income or revenues from membership fees paid or payable by members. (Section 6001.)
- Provides, pursuant to a 1950's statute, that whenever the Board secures an obligation of the State Bar on all or any portion of the fees from membership dues the Legislature may not, until the obligation is repaid in full, reduce membership dues below the maximum amount in effect when the obligation was created and provides that this constitutes a covenant to the holder of the obligation. (Section 6008.5.)
- Requires the State Bar to annually report on the performance and condition of its discipline system, including the backlog of discipline cases that are six months old and case processing times, as provided. (Section 6086.15.)
- Requires the State Bar to develop and implement a workforce plan for its discipline system and conduct a public sector compensation and benefits study, including a recommendation for an appropriate backlog goal and an assessment of staffing needed to achieve that goal. Requires the State Bar to conduct a thorough analysis of its operating costs and develop a spending plan to determine a reasonable amount for its annual dues. Requires that the workforce plan and the spending plan be submitted to the Legislature by May 15, 2016, and be implemented by December 31, 2016. (Section 6140.16.)
- Requires the State Bar's Board to contract with the California State Auditor to conduct a financial audit of the State Bar, including an audit of its financial statement, internal controls and practices, and requires that the audit be submitted to the Board, the Chief Justice of the California Supreme Court, and the Assembly and Senate Judiciary Committees by May 15, 2016. Requires the audit to examine revenues, expenditures, reserves and fund transfers. (Section 6145 (c).)
- Subjects the State Bar to the Public Records Act, with specified exceptions. Provides that identifying information submitted by applicants to the State Bar for admission to practice law and State Bar admissions records, as specified, are confidential and may not be disclosed pursuant to any state law including the Public Records Act. (Sections 6001, 6026.11.)
- Effective April 1, 2016, subjects the State Bar to the Bagley-Keene Open Meeting Act, as provided, with exemptions for the Judicial Nominees Evaluation Commission and the Committee of Bar Examiners. (Sections 6001 6026.7; Government Code Section 11121.)
FISCAL EFFECT: As currently in print this bill is keyed non-fiscal.
COMMENTS: This bill continues the decades-long tradition of oversight of the Bar by the Assembly and Senate Judiciary Committees via review of the annual dues authorization bill, as part of general oversight role of the Legislature over the agencies in the executive and judicial branches of government. Last year, in response to significant and troubling audit findings and other concerns, the Legislature required the State Auditor to perform an in-depth financial audit of the Bar, due May 15, 2016. Last year’s bar dues bill also required the Bar to comply with important government transparency and accountability laws by way of the Bagley-Keene Open Meeting Act and the California Public Records Act. (SB 387 (Jackson), Chap. 537, Stats. 2015.) This bill comes to this Committee after another year of extensive and publically reported turmoil involving the Bar, some of which has come to light because of new open government laws.
Background on the Bar. Attorneys who wish to practice law in California generally must be admitted and licensed in this State and must be members of the State Bar. (Cal. Const., Art. VI, Sec. 9.) The State Bar of California is the largest state bar in the country. As of March 2016, the State Bar had 186,152 active members and 56,929 inactive members. Total State Bar membership is listed at 257,788, which includes 2,162 judge members and 12,544 members who are “not eligible to practice law.”
The Bar is governed by a 19-member board of trustees, which is made up of 13 active lawyer members (6 lawyers elected by other licensed attorneys in the state; 5 lawyers appointed by the Supreme Court; and 2 lawyers appointed by the Legislature) and 6 public (non-lawyer) members (4 public members appointed by the Governor and 2 public members appointed by the Legislature). Currently, two public member positions, awaiting appointment by the Governor, are vacant. By statute, the Bar's highest priority, as necessary and appropriate, is protection of the public. (Section 6001.1.)
The Bill Maintains Dues at Current Rates and Eliminates a Provision That Could Tie the Hands of Future Legislatures and Reduce Legislative Oversight of the State Bar. At this point, this bill merely authorizes the State Bar to collect active membership dues of up to $390 for 2017, the same rate as this year. The Bar’s programs are financed almost exclusively by annual membership dues paid by attorneys, as well as other fees paid by applicants who are seeking to practice law. The Bar also uses its name and membership lists to sell items such as malpractice insurance and car rentals, and receives payment for those activities. The Bar currently has complete discretion over how funds from this latter activity, which amount to approximately $2 million per year, are used. The Bar's total revenue for 2016 is $118 million, excluding funds from interest on lawyer trust accounts that pass-through the State Bar and fund legal services, with $74.3 million coming from mandatory dues.
As required by last year's Bar dues bill, the Bar is currently conducting an analysis of its operating costs and developing a spending plan to determine a proposed amount to report to the Legislature for its annual dues. The spending plan must be submitted to the Legislature by May 15, 2016. Once that report is submitted, along with an audit from the State Auditor on the Bar's finances that was also mandated in last year's dues bill and is also due by May 15, 2016, and the Legislature has thoroughly reviewed both reports, the Bar dues amount in this bill could either increase or decrease, as the Legislature deems appropriate, based on the actual needs of the Bar to effectively and efficiently protect the public.
As discussed in more detail below, the bill also eliminates an anachronistic 1950's era statute that prohibits future Legislatures, if the Bar uses any portion of membership dues as security for an obligation, from reducing membership dues below the amount in effect when the obligation was created by the Bar, until the obligation is paid in full. While it is highly questionable whether this provision is constitutional, it is clear that it reduces the important oversight role of the Legislature over the Bar which is needed to ensure that public protection is and remains the paramount concern of the Bar. Therefore, this bill rightly deletes that provision.
Bar Report on its Progress This Past Year: The State Bar has provided a list of its accomplishments over the past year, including its hiring of its new management team last Fall: executive director Elizabeth Parker, chief operating officer Leah Wilson, and general counsel Vanessa Holton. The Bar also states that it is "well on its way to completing" all of the recommendations from the State Auditor in the 2015 audit, discussed in more detail below, including revising its discipline report to the Legislature, scheduled to be submitted at the end of this month, to ensure that it is consistent, clear and reliable; improving the quality of the discipline process; requiring a cost-benefit analysis for all contracts above $2 million; streamlining its organizational structure to more efficiently use existing staff resources; and beginning the development of a new case management system.
In an effort to address questionable management and budget practices, the Bar has reduced its overall budget for 2016 by 6.2 percent and reduced budgets for temporary help, travel and catering even more. The Bar states that it has eliminated all business expense accounts and the president’s once secret $30,000 discretionary expense account, something that has been of substantial concern to this Committee for years. It has also cancelled numerous contracts with outside counsel, seeking to bring more of that work in-house. The Bar also states that it is beginning an effort to use zero-based operational costs for assessment of fees charged by its Admissions division, as well as a review of other fees charged. The Bar has also re-established its Governance in the Public Interest Task Force and is expected to submit a report to the Board in July of 2016, although this report was actually due to the Legislature in 2014. Finally, after media reports that the Bar has not properly addressed unauthorized practice of law complaints, discussed more fully below, the Bar now states that it is developing a protocol for handling these cases and has adopted a referral policy to allow Bar investigators and criminal prosecutors to simultaneously investigate cases.
Well Reported, Disconcerting and Longstanding Problems at The Bar Continue to Raise Very Troubling Questions About Public Protection, Discipline, Governance, Expenditures and Oversight. The State Bar has been in the news throughout much of the past year primarily due to troubling management, oversight and governance problems, as well as questions about whether the Bar has focused sufficiently on its primary duty, public protection.
Bar Has Admitted Ignoring Unlawful Practice of Law Complaints, Many of Which are From Immigrants, Thus Allowing the Unlawful Practice of Law to Endanger the Public: The Bar operates an investigatory and discipline process to protect the public from unscrupulous attorneys, with possible disciplinary actions ranging from letters of warning and private reproval, to disbarment. The Bar's investigatory and regulatory duties include protecting the public from the unauthorized practice of law by non-attorneys and attorneys not licensed in this State. Although public protection is the Bar's highest statutory priority, the Bar reportedly allowed hundreds of complaints alleging the unauthorized practice of law to sit idle for months or even years without taking action. Many of the complaints are against "notaries," who offer to assist immigrants in securing legal status or performing other legal work, but whose efforts can result in denial of protective status or even deportation.
According to media reports, the Bar initially identified 59 complaints of unauthorized practice of law that were uninvestigated for years, with some complaints dating as far back as 2007. (Lyle Moran, State Bar admits ignoring dozens of complaints against people practicing law without a license, Daily Journal (Jan. 29, 2016).) At the time, the Bar called its failure to investigate complaints "unacceptable," and blamed a fired investigator. (Ibid.) The Daily Journal later learned that the Bar actually had more than 270 additional complaints alleging unauthorized practice of law that were allowed to sit idle, awaiting assignment to an investigator. These additional complaints were reportedly left in a drawer for more than two months or, in some cases, six months and more. (Lyle Moran, State Bar let hundreds of complaints against non-attorneys sit idle, Daily Journal (March 4, 2016).) These cases were reportedly assigned to an attorney, addressing the backlog, but when this matter was first made public, over 300 cases were still awaiting intake. Had this matter not been made public, likely as the result of a public records request, it is unclear if and when corrective action would have been taken.
It goes without saying that failure to immediately investigate and, when appropriate, take action to stop the unauthorized practice of law leaves the public at serious risk. If legal action is not taken, the unauthorized practice will likely continue, unnecessarily jeopardizing vulnerable individuals who are seeking legal assistance. When the failure to investigate lasts months or even years, the risk increases significantly. The failure to investigate in a timely manner is even more disturbing when many of the victims are immigrants, for whom negative consequences may include deportation. Those harmed, particularly those who have been deported, may not have the opportunity for a second chance to obtain actual legal assistance.
The Bar has acknowledged its mishandling of these complaints and is seeking to improve its procedures by not only working through the backlog swiftly, but also bringing together legal service providers and other stakeholders for a one-day summit next month, entitled "Strategies for Effective Investigation & Enforcement: UPL & Immigration Attorney Misconduct." According to the Bar, the "summit discussion is intended to identify what is working under the current structure and what is not, and to generate ideas for improvement." It is hoped that the summit produces real and immediate improvement in the Bar's handling of these critically important complaints.
Last Year's State Audit Substantially Faulted the Bar for Not Consistently Protecting the Public and For Lacking Accountability: As required by statute, the State Auditor completes a performance audit (covering one part of the Bar’s functions) of the Bar every two years. The 2015 audit reviewed the Bar's discipline process; in particular its backlog of discipline cases, and the Bar's 2012 $75 million purchase and renovation of a building in Los Angeles. The audit uncovered significant, troubling decisions made by the Bar in the handling of both matters. (California State Auditor, State Bar of California: It Has Not Consistently Protected the Public Through its Attorney Discipline Process and Lacks Accountability (June 2015).)
Discipline: To operate its discipline system effectively and maximize public protection, the Bar must minimize its backlog (cases not processed within six months) in order to prevent wayward attorneys and non-attorneys from continuing to practice law in a manner that endangers the public. The Bar is required to report annually to the Legislature, the Governor, and the Chief Justice on the discipline process and any backlog. (Section 6086.15.) Unfortunately, the State Auditor discovered that the Bar did not fully and consistently report its backlog or its case processing times to the Legislature or the Governor, and, when taking steps to reduce the backlog, did not adequately protect the public. Of particular importance, according to the Auditor, was the manner in which the Bar reduced its backlog of discipline cases, which may have caused "significant risk to the public":
[A]s the State Bar reduced its excessive backlog of disciplinary cases, the severity of the discipline it imposed on attorneys who failed to fulfill their professional responsibilities decreased. In other words, to reduce its backlog, the State Bar allowed some attorneys whom it otherwise might have disciplined more severely—or even disbarred—to continue practicing law, at significant risk to the public. . . . The chief trial counsel confirmed that she believes . . . that insufficient quality control was a key factor that enabled the State Bar to decrease its backlog. (Id. at 1 (emphasis added).)
As a result of the audit findings, the Legislature, in last year's dues bill, SB 387 (Jackson), Chap. 537, Stats. 2015, directed the Bar to develop and implement a workforce plan for its discipline system and to conduct a public sector compensation and benefits study, including a recommendation for an appropriate backlog goal and an assessment of staffing needed to achieve that goal. The workforce plan and the spending plan are to be submitted to the Legislature by May 15, 2016, and implemented by December 31, 2016. It is anticipated that this bill will be amended to address the Bar's discipline system after those plans are submitted.
Building Purchase: The State Auditor also determined that, when purchasing a building in Los Angeles in 2012, the Bar did not perform any cost-benefit analysis to determine if the purchase was appropriate and warranted before receiving approval from its Board to purchase the building. The Bar, according to the Auditor, did not fully inform the Legislature of its plans, thereby potentially risking public safety by not prioritizing other areas, such as attorney discipline:
The State Bar of California’s … primary mission is the protection of the public through its attorney discipline system. However, the State Bar’s financial priorities over the past six years did not consistently reflect that mission: Rather than using its financial resources to improve its attorney discipline system, the State Bar dedicated a significant portion of its funds to purchase and renovate a building in Los Angeles in 2012. Although the Legislature approved $10.3 million for this building, the State Bar ultimately spent approximately $76.6 million on it. Facilitating this purchase required the State Bar to transfer $12 million between its various funds, some of which its Board of Trustees (board) had set aside for other purposes.
The ultimate responsibility for ensuring that the State Bar spends funds prudently rests with the board, which should have ensured that the State Bar’s decision to purchase the Los Angeles building was justified and financially beneficial. However, the State Bar did not fully communicate its questionable financial decisions regarding this new building to the board because it never presented its board with comprehensive cost estimates of purchasing versus leasing a building. Moreover, only four months before it purchased the Los Angeles building, the State Bar informed the Legislature in an annual report that a building would cost $26 million—a third of the $76.6 million the State Bar ultimately paid. In addition, the State Bar could offer no evidence that it informed the Legislature of its final decision to purchase the Los Angeles building even though state law required it to do so. As a result, key decision makers and stakeholders lacked the information necessary to make informed financial decisions related to the purchase of the Los Angeles building or to understand its impact on the State Bar’s other financial priorities. (Id. at 43.)
The Auditor thereby found that the decision to purchase the Los Angles building jeopardized the State Bar’s core function to protect public safety: "Rather than using its financial resources to improve its attorney discipline system, the State Bar dedicated a significant portion of its funds to purchase and renovate a building in Los Angeles in 2012." (Ibid.)
Even more troubling was the fact that the Bar chose to secure the additional funding for the Los Angeles building, in part, through a loan that required the Bar to use $4.6 million of its Public Protection Fund as collateral for the loan. The sole purpose of the Public Protection Fund, which the Bar itself established in 2001, was to protect the public in the event of a financial emergency – and that emergency is generally regarded as a veto of the Bar’s annual dues bill, which has happened twice in the last 20 years: once in 1997 and most recently in 2009. (SB 1145 (Burton), 1997; SB 641 (Corbett), 2009.) However, without any notification to its members or the Legislature, the Bar decided, unilaterally, to tie up over 70 percent of its Public Protection Fund – $4.6 million of the $6.5 million fund – for the 15-year life of the loan. The Bar may not access those Public Protection funds for any reason during that time, or it will default on the loan for the Los Angeles building. This completely negates the purpose of the fund – public protection. If, the Bar Board determined that the Public Protection Fund is actually not necessary, the Board, in consultation with the Legislature, could have decided that the remaining unsecured funds, as well as the $4.5 million that is securing the Los Angeles building loan after the loan is paid off, could be used for other purposes, such as improving the discipline system, reducing the legal services “justice gap” or refunding unnecessary dues to members.
The use of the Public Protection Fund to secure the loan on the L.A. building is, according to the State Auditor, part of a larger pattern in which the Bar transfers money between its various funds and uses the money on unrelated items. The Auditor found that, from 2009 through 2012, the Bar made approximately 50 transfers between funds involving over $64 million. (Id. at 13.) Given the concerns about the Bar's lack of transparency and accountability, and the resulting potential risk to public protection, last year's dues bill, SB 387, directed the Auditor to do an in-depth financial audit of the Bar, including a review of the Bar’s internal controls. As noted, that report is due by May 15, 2016.
S.F. Building Loan and Restructuring of L.A. Building Loan: In spite of last year's audit that questioned the cost of the Los Angeles building and its impact on public protection, and without waiting for the results of the legislatively-required discipline workplan due next month (which could show that the Bar requires significant additional spending to meet its public protection mandate), the State Bar decided, without input or approval from the Legislature, to take out a new $10 million loan for updates and tenant improvements on three floors of its San Francisco building.
In order to use some of the loan as security for repayment, the Bar, again without consultation with the Legislature, chose to secure the loan and refinance the original $25 million loan on the Los Angeles building, discussed above, through a security interest in future member dues. The loan, secured on future Bar dues, was entered on March 1, 2016 for a term of ten years. Before receiving approval from the Board, the Bar requested an opinion from its staff on the legality of the revenue pledge. While finding the loan legally permissible, legal staff appropriately warned the Bar of the following:
Such a pledge, which has the potential to impact the Bar's regulatory functions, could additionally be deemed inconsistent with the later adoption of Business & Professions Code, section 6001.1, which provides that the Bar must place public protection as its highest priority and additionally states, "[w]henever the protection of the public is inconsistent with other interest sought to be promoted, the protection of the public shall be paramount." . . . [S]uch a pledge could subject the Bar to criticism on the basis that it could place funds that govern its core regulatory activities at what may be deemed to be unnecessary risk.
These risks were not mentioned in the materials presented by the Bar to its Board when it requested approval for the loan. Nor was the Board apparently provided with a cost-benefit analysis that included both a recommended course of action and alternatives, as the Bar's list of accomplishments states is required, beginning July, 2015, for all expenditures reasonably expected to exceed $2 million. Clearly, this loan met that $2 million threshold. Moreover, the decision to proceed with the loan came less than one year after the State Auditor questioned the Bar's decision to purchase the Los Angeles building on the basis that the Bar had not considered whether the resources to repay the loan might be better spent on improving the Bar's discipline system.
Even more troubling, Business & Professions Code Section 6008.5 provides that whenever the Board secures a Bar obligation with all or any portion of the fees from membership dues, the Legislature may not, until the obligation is repaid in full, reduce membership dues below the maximum amount in effect when the obligation was created, providing a covenant to the holder of the obligation. Thus, at least on its face, this statute, which has been on the books since 1957, appears to provide that, as a result of the loan, the Legislature cannot lower Bar dues by even a single penny. The annual legislative setting of the amount of the Bar's dues is the Legislature’s chief mechanism for oversight of the Bar. Without the ability to annually establish Bar fees, including the ability to lower fees, the Legislature would lose a key oversight tool to ensure that the Bar is properly carrying out its mission and protecting the public. It appears that this issue was never presented to the Board when it approved of the loan. Nor was there apparently any consultation with the Legislature before restricting future legislative authority.
It is highly unlikely that this statute, the policy merits of which are questionable, was ever constitutional. A legislature cannot restrict the powers of a subsequent legislature by enacting a statute that appears to be nonrepealable. (County Mobilehome Positive Action Committee v. County of San Diego (1998) 62 Cal. App. 4th 727, 734.) "An act of one legislature is not binding upon, and does not tie the hands of future legislatures [citations omitted]." (Ibid.) This provision may also run afoul of the constitutional prohibition against delegation of legislative power, which prevents the Legislature from, among other things, delegating rate setting ability to members of the industry that is regulated. (See State Bd. of Dry Cleaners v. Thrift-D-Lux Cleaners (1953) 40 C.2d 436, 447.) This statute appears to delegate to the Bar, should it choose to secure a loan with future dues, the ability to fix the minimum price of future dues for as long of a loan period as the Bar chooses.
At the request of the chairs of this Committee and the Senate Judiciary Committee, the Bar and the lender have agreed to restructure the loan so that it is no longer secured by future member dues. However, until the loan is repaid in full, the obligation still exists and still reduces the amount of Bar's resources available to protect the public. This bill, quite appropriately, therefore eliminates this anachronistic statute and, with it, the Bar's ability to lock in a dues rate for years, even if the Bar has no need for the funding generated by those dues.
Firing of Executive Director and Ensuing Litigation/Arbitration: In November 2014, the State Bar terminated its then-executive director, Joe Dunn. In response to that termination, the executive director filed suit against the State Bar, alleging whistleblower status and charging the bar with engaging in "egregious" fiscal improprieties. Bar officials reportedly responded with accusations against him, including criticism of his lavish expense accounts.
After spending months litigating the matter, the court ordered the parties to arbitrate their dispute, as required in the executive director's employment contract. The arbitration, which has apparently been open to the public, included release of the $359,000 internal investigation of the former executive director in 2014, which concluded that although "certain other deficiencies in Dunn's performance would warrant counseling or reprimand only (such as his inattention to proper allocation of expenses between mandatory and voluntary fees), Dunn's repeated failure to provide adequate or truthful information to the Board plainly provides an adequate basis to terminate his at will employment." (Mark Helm and Bart Williams, Independent Investigation for the State Bar of California: Summary of Findings and Recommendations, p.27-28 (Munger Tolles Report).)
Just this month, the arbitrator dismissed all of the former executive director's claims against the Bar and its Board, its prior president, and a former attorney to the California Supreme Court Chief Justice, with leave to amend some of those claims. Mr. Dunn has until May 1, 2016 to amend those claims.
Additional Firings and Ensuing Litigation: In and around the time of the firing of the executive director, the Bar also fired its general counsel, who was hired by the executive director, as well as the Bar’s chief financial officer, and an administrative specialist, who brought a $15 million wrongful termination suit against the Bar this past February. At roughly the same time, the Bar laid off its public information officer. On February 25, 2016, the Public Employment Relations Board issued a complaint against the Bar for that termination, alleging the Bar fired the public information officer as retaliation for his filing a grievance against the organization. This past winter, the Bar fired its managing director of investigations after he filed a whistleblower complaint against the Chief Trial Counsel. While it is difficult to determine what precisely occurred in each of these cases and whether any of the firings were justified, the number and frequency of these incidents does raise concerns about management at the State Bar. And according to media reports, the State Bar had spent over $530,000 on attorney's fees for the wrongful termination litigation of its former executive director and the others (as of February 2016), of which less than $400,000 was covered by insurance. (Lyle Moran, State Bar spent $413K investigating Dunn, leak of report, Daily Journal (Feb. 24, 2016).) It is reasonable to assume that those figures have risen substantially since then.
Ongoing Concerns About the Chief Trial Counsel, Still Awaiting Senate Confirmation: The Bar's chief trial counsel, Jayne Kim, has also been the subject of controversy. She filed an internal complaint against the former-executive director, which ultimately led to his firing. Last October, her subordinate employees in the Office of Chief Trial Counsel, members of SEIU, issued a 76 percent "no confidence" vote in her leadership, alleging that she misled the Board, grossly mismanaged her office, and failed to protect the public. Despite that vote, the Board on December 21, 2016, at the recommendation of current executive director Elizabeth Parker, voted 14-1 to seek another term for the chief trial counsel, although Ms. Parker did promise to address concerns regarding her management style. The additional term requires Senate approval. The Senate has yet to hold hearings on her re-appointment. In the meantime, she continues to serve in the position.
Troubling Expenses Cause Bar to Finally Cut its Travel and Catering Budget: This Committee has long raised concerns with the Bar’s expenses for travel, business expenses and other special allowances, when limited dues funds are required by law to first and foremost support public protection and the discipline system; non-dues funds could go to support woefully underfunded legal services programs or potentially to reduce mandatory bar dues. According to a media report from earlier this year, likely based on a public records request, the Bar had a number of questionable expenses and exercised limited oversight of how Bar members' funds were spent:
In late January 2014, a group of six executives and trustees from the State Bar of California embarked on a mission to protect the public from unscrupulous lawyers—by traveling to El Salvador.
While there, the bar president, the executive director and a bar employee classified as a public information officer signed an "accord" with the nation's foreign affairs minister pledging to work together to educate Salvadorans living in California about available legal resources. The two-page agreement carried no legal weight; it's unclear if the American signatories had any authority to sign an international pact anyway.
Outside the signing ceremony, the trip was unremarkable—except for the costs. Expenses for hotel rooms, airfare, meals, a driver's services and cellphone bills submitted to the bar by just four of the travelers—the only ones readily accessed through the bar's convoluted accounting system—totaled more than $6,600.
This international trip was not an isolated occurrence. Between 2013 and 2014, bar executives led by then-CEO Joe Dunn and, occasionally, trustees submitted thousands of dollars in expenses associated with trips to El Salvador, Mexico, Guatemala, Nicaragua, Peru and Mongolia, according to documents compiled by The Recorder.
The trips were paid out of bar funds. Just how much the costs for these trips added up to is difficult to say. The bar does not code expense reports by foreign trips, so determining who went where when and for how much requires some guesswork and manual calculations. For years, the bar refused to make public such records, arguing that the quasi-judicial agency was not subject to state sunshine-in-government laws. . . .
Hundreds of pages of bar records reveal numerous expenses and activities that appear to have a tenuous connection to the agency's mission of pursuing bad lawyers and protecting the public—the California public, at least. (Cheryl Miller, Joe Dunn, Bar Officials Spent Freely on Foreign Travel, The Recorder (Jan. 25, 2016).)
More recently, the Bar asserts that it has begun to reduce unnecessary spending. The 2016 budget reduces spending on travel by 29 percent, from $3.4 million to $2.4 million, and on catering by 24 percent, from $2.1 million to $1.6 million. These line items were reduced because, according to Chief Operating Officer Leah Wilson, these “were areas of “extraordinary costs’ for the bar.” (Lyle Moran, State bar cuts annual budget by 6 percent, Daily Journal (Feb. 2, 2016).) It is worth noting that, prior to seeking a financial audit by the State Auditor last year, Committee staff had asked the Bar for, among other things, information on Bar travel outside the country and was informed (incorrectly, as is now clear) that the only such trip was to Mongolia.
Legislative Oversight Role: While the above events and reported claims and allegations may be fully understood, enough is known about them to trigger legislative and public concern about how the Bar is governed and overseen, particularly given that public protection is required to be the Bar's paramount duty. Nevertheless, at least one member of the Board has remarkably and ironically questioned whether the Legislature should have oversight over the Bar. According to media reports, the Governance in the Public Interest Task Force has asked to be provided with "any cases in other states touching on the propriety of a Legislature setting licensing fees for lawyers or reviewing the appointment of a chief trial counsel." (Lyle Moran, State Bar panel may review legislative oversight of agency, Daily Journal (Feb. 29, 2016).) The current Bar President is reported to have said that the final Governance Task Force report "could include recommendations pertaining to lawmakers' oversight of the agency. 'It is an issue,' he said in an interview." (Ibid.)
Given the reported mismanagement by this state agency, it would certainly appear that greater oversight, and possible reform, of the State Bar is needed and that a call by some trustees for less oversight under such circumstances indicates reason to question whether the Bar can fully carry out its paramount duty to protect the public.
Can the Bar's Board of Trustees Continue to Oversee Attorneys When the Vast Majority of Board Members Are Practicing Attorneys? Under earlier governance reforms enacted by the Legislature in 2011 in an effort to begin to address significant concerns about the Bar's governance (SB 163 (Evans), Chap. 417, Stats. 2011), the State Bar is governed by a Board of Trustees, made up of 19 members, down from 23 in 2011 (though the Board President may remain on the Board for one year after his or her term is completed and be the 20th member, as is the case today), with a substantial component of attorney members selected by the Supreme Court. (Section 6010 et seq.) Under that legislation, due to Bar insistence, the Legislature agreed to allow the Bar to retain a supermajority majority of lawyer-members, or active market participants, following assurances from the Bar that the increased percentage of public members would completely address prior Board governance problems. Thus, of the current 20 possible members, 14 are lawyer members -- 6 of whom are elected by bar members in districts across the state -- and 6 are public members. Currently, there are two vacant public member seats, both of which are gubernatorial appointees, so the Board is currently composed of 18 members, 14 of whom are active members of the State Bar and 4 of whom are public members.
A recent U.S. Supreme Court case, which found that if a state licensing board has a majority of members who are active market participants then the board can only invoke antitrust immunity if it is subject to active state supervision, has raised serious questions about the Bar's immunity from federal antitrust laws. In that case, North Carolina State Board of Dental Examiners v. Federal Trade Commission (2015) 135 S. Ct. 1101, the Supreme Court held, in a 6-3 decision, that the North Carolina Dental Board (composed of eight members, six of whom were practicing dentists) did not have state immunity to an antitrust action brought by the Federal Trade Commission to stop the dental board from preventing non-dentists from offering teeth whitening services. The Court held that the dental board, since it was controlled by "market participants" who pose a risk of self-dealing, could only invoke state immunity to an antitrust action if the board is "actively supervised" by state officials. It is important to note that 75 percent of the North Carolina dental board members were active dentists, while currently fully 78 percent of the State Bar Board is composed of active Bar members. Even when all public members are appointed, the Bar's Board will still be composed of a supermajority of active Bar members – 68 to 70 percent (depending on whether the Board has 19 or 20 members) active Bar members.
To better understand if the Bar (and hence the State) might be subject to antitrust liability in its current configuration, this Committee asked Legislative Counsel for its opinion as to the risk of liability after the North Carolina State Board of Dental Examiners decision. Legislative Counsel opined that the Bar is indeed controlled by active market participants and, if the Bar is found to be in violation of antitrust laws by not being actively supervised by state officials, the State would generally be responsible for defending the Bar and paying any judgments against the Bar or its employees (including not only fines and treble damages, but also imprisonment for up to 10 years for individual board members). (Ops. Cal. Legis. Counsel, No. 1602135, State Bar of California: State-Action Immunity, pp. 5, 13 (April 18, 2016).) What is less clear is what is required for “active state supervision.” Legislative Counsel opines "that a court would analyze the presence of active supervision on a case-by-case basis . . . [I]t is our opinion that an anticompetitive action of the State Bar would be actively supervised by the state for purposes of state-action immunity if the California Supreme Court retains strict supervisory powers and ultimate full authority over the State Bar’s actions by laying out specific rules and serving as the ultimate decision maker." (Id. at 9 (citations omitted).)
Thus, as long as the Bar’s Board of Trustees is controlled by active market participants, as it is today, there will be a significant risk that the State could be subject to liability for the Board’s actions.
The Center for Public Interest Law (CPIL), which opposes this bill unless amended, believes that the best course of action is for the Board to be restructured in order to eliminate active market participant control: "The simplest way to avoid antitrust liability (and ensure the interest of the public is properly considered) in light of North Carolina is to convert the Board of Trustees’ composition to a supermajority of public members, with the added provision that no vote may be taken where those voting are not public members in the majority." (CPIL adds that, at a minimum, the Legislature should eliminate the six elected positions.) However, if the Board is not restructured to eliminate the Board's active market participant supermajority, CPIL writes that the Legislature must establish true active state supervision, which does not exist today:
The term “active” is critical. It cannot be simply the presence of a supervening entity. The fact there is a state Supreme Court at the zenith of the organizational chart does not provide compliance. . . .
At present, neither the California Supreme Court, nor any other entity, provides the requisite independent and “active” supervision for anticompetitive effect as required by North Carolina. This Legislature should add to this bill the clear authority of the California Supreme Court to engage in “active state supervision” of the Bar, and any part of it controlled by “active market participants” in the profession, as commanded by the U.S. Supreme Court. That authority should include the power and resources to fashion, in its own manner, a system for filtering decisions to focus on those with anticompetitive effect; and, for those, to examine their substantive anticompetitive effect and alternatives, using relevant economic, antitrust, and other expertise separate from practicing attorneys.
Given all of the oversight, governance and management concerns that continue to be raised about the State Bar, as well as the possibility of antitrust liability, can the Bar effectively continue to be both a government regulatory agency and a trade association? Since its inception, the Bar has worn two hats -- regulatory agency and professional trade association. California, like 31 other states, including Florida, Idaho, Louisiana, Michigan, Mississippi and Texas, has a unified bar, which means that the State Bar is both the regulatory arm of the state, as well as a mandatory attorney trade association. Attorneys who wish to practice law in this State must join the Bar and their dues cover both the regulatory arm and the trade association. This arrangement is unique among professions licensed by the State of California. For all other professions, the government entity regulates the profession and disciplines wayward practitioners, while a private trade association provides education and advocacy for members of the profession. (See for example, physicians, who are licensed and regulated by the Medical Board of California within the Department of Consumer Affairs, but who may voluntarily join the California Medical Association, their trade group, which provides "legislative, legal, regulatory, economic and social advocacy." (http://www.cmanet.org/about/).)
Eighteen states, generally including larger states such as Colorado, Illinois, Massachusetts, Minnesota, New Jersey, New York, Ohio and Pennsylvania, have non-unified bars. In those states, attorneys are only required to join the regulatory arm of the bar and not the trade association. These states have private trade associations, but those associations are not regulated by the state. Private bar associations are free to govern themselves as they see fit and are not subject to government oversight or transparency laws. Dues payments required by unified bars are, typically, considerably higher that dues payments required by non-unified bars. According to data from the State Bar, approximately 52 percent of active, resident attorneys are members of voluntary trade associations, although there is a range (Colorado - 84%; Illinois - 47%; Massachusetts - 25%; Minnesota - 61%; New Jersey - 44%; New York - 43%; Ohio - 58%; and Pennsylvania - 57%). If California were to have a voluntary bar and follow the average of the large states listed above, nearly 100,000 California active members would potentially join a voluntary bar association.
Governance in the Public Interest Task Force to Consider De-Coupling: The Bar's Governance in the Public Interest Task Force, created as part of the legislative reforms of SB 163 in 2011, is required to report to the Supreme Court, the Governor and the Assembly and Senate Judiciary Committees by May 15, 2014, and every three years thereafter, its recommendations for enhancing public protection and ensuring that public protection is the State Bar's highest priority. (Section 6001.2.) The task force has yet to submit its first report, but is now reported to be doing so and expected to complete by July of this year. Among other issues, the task force is considering whether the Bar should separate into a government entity charged with regulating attorneys and a private trade association.
Several Bar Trustees, Most Notably two Legislative Appointees, and at Least One Bar Section Are Publically Calling for De-Unification or De-Coupling as a Solution to Long-Term, Structural Problems with the Bar: Three current and one former Bar Board trustee write to support the annual dues assessment, but to request "substantial amendments to address systemic weaknesses in bar governance." These trustees (two of whom are legislative appointees to the Board) first note that the Bar's current controversies are part of a "long history of cyclical crisis, reform, neglect, and renewed crisis":
Nearly every Executive Director of the State Bar over the past few decades has ended his or her service in controversy. Each is replaced by a new leader, charged to be "a new sheriff in town." A show of effort at change is made; the attention of the press, bar and public turn elsewhere; and the Bar slides back into mismanagement, failure to protect Californians, and general dysfunction until a new controversy soon restarts the cycle. This systemic dysfunction derives from the dual mission of the Bar and its short-term, diffuse, volunteer leadership.
The trustees go on to note that unlike "every other profession in our State and unlike an apparent trend in sister states of comparable size and diversity toward decoupling legal regulatory and professional organizations, California attorneys have been granted the privilege of self-regulation." That self-regulation has resulted in allegations, according to the trustees, that "the Bar more vigorously prosecutes attorneys with less money and influence" which have "never been seriously addressed. These tend to be solo practitioners, small-town lawyers, and lawyers of color. The Bar can and should assure Californians that the justice it dispenses is even-handed as well as efficient."
These trustees state that their years of service reveal the Board to be "a distracted regulator. It spends much of its energy on professional association matters such as appointments of attorneys to positions of prestige, providing continuing legal education in competition with voluntary bars and for-profit providers while also regulating those providers, conducting an annual conference that draws fewer attendees and requires greater subsidy each year, publishing legal content, selling insurance, etc. . . . Over the past two years, the Board has spent far more time in closed session addressing personnel, litigation and real estate issues than it has devoted in open session to regulation."
The trustees argue that based on antitrust concerns after the North Carolina case, California should follow several of the largest states that have separate judicial branch regulation of attorneys and "thriving voluntary State Bar Associations." They argue that this will allow a statewide professional association to advocate more effectively for a well-funded judiciary and for legal services than "a state agency hemmed in by the most conservative perspective on what and how it can advocate." They further argue that Proposition 209's "prohibition on state-funded affirmative action has hampered the Bar’s ability to advocate for diversity in the profession and for full and fair access to justice for communities of color."
Their proposal involves a three-year process, led by the Bar, with input from the Supreme Court and the Governor, to first study the issue and determine which Bar functions "belong in government and which can be more effectively performed by a private entity" and then make recommendations to the Legislature at the end of 2017 for 2018 restructuring legislation. The Legislature should explicitly mandate, state the trustees, that there be no job losses from the separation, especially since the regulatory functions are currently understaffed, and that there be a larger role for the Supreme Court. These proponents of restructure see the end result as creating "a more effective regulator of legal services to Californians and a more potent and less costly professional association for lawyers." The trustee group's proposal is also supported by the Executive Committee of the Business Law Section of the State Bar.
The California Lawyers Guild, a statewide voluntary bar association, newly formed by former leaders of the Business Law Section of the State Bar, also support de-unification:
We believe that the attention currently focused on the State Bar offers all relevant constituencies – and particularly the Legislature – an opportunity to reflect on and revisit the manner in which the State Bar and its Sections are organized, and specifically to conclude that each organization would be stronger and more focused were they to be separated. . . .[W]e believe that the continued operation of the Sections under the umbrella of the State Bar is neither sustainable nor advisable. The strictures placed on lawyers (who are not compensated at all) for providing hundreds, often thousands, of hours giving back to the practice of law are wholly inappropriate, especially given that the work of these volunteers has nothing to do with why the State Bar is in crisis. . . . Given the problems that have festered and grown over time, we can no longer envision a paradigm in which the Sections and their Standing Committees are forced to have their functions degraded by strictures appropriate only for a governmental agency.
The Center for Public Interest Law likewise supports de-unification, arguing that the "State Bar must — once and for all — sever off its trade association functions and engage only in regulatory agency activities which may be funded with compulsory Bar dues." CPIL even sets out its recommendations as to how the Bar's current functions should be divided:
CPIL believes that the following regulatory agency functions may properly stay with the State Bar (which can continue to be housed in the judicial branch of state government) and may be lawfully funded with compulsory licensing fees: (1) licensing of attorneys; its legal specialization program; (3) adoption of ethical standards for the legal profession; (4) attorney discipline; (5) administration of the Client Security Fund; and (6) access to justice activities, including IOLTA funding of legal services for the poor and the Commission on Access to Justice. The following “trade association” activities should be severed off: (1) the sections; (2) lobbying and legislative activity on issues unrelated to the regulation of the legal profession and/or improving access to the justice system; (3) the annual meeting; (4) insurance programs and services; (5) the regulation of legal referral services; and (6) continuing legal education. (To the extent continuing legal education assures competence, particularly if subject to testing in areas of actual practice, it may also serve a regulatory function.)
Other Individuals, Sections Disagree: Other individuals and Bar sections vehemently disagree with separating the Bar. The Executive Committees of the Family Law and Trusts & Estates Sections of the State Bar have voted overwhelmingly in support of the Bar remaining unified. These sections argue that the geographic and practice diversities of their statewide organizations provide for the broadest and most objective possible representation that could well be lost if the sections become part of a private trade organization, particularly if over time membership drops. They are concerned that the well-respected educational materials they prepare and disperse would end up becoming glossy trade magazines used more for marketing than educating other professionals and the public on matters of significant. They believe that remaining part of the regulatory agency allows them to stay within their purview and be perceived by the Legislature as unbiased and objective experts in their respective fields. A trade association, they argue, would not have the clout that the State Bar has today.
The Executive Director of UC Berkeley School of Law's California Constitution Center, along with two associates, also oppose any rush to de-unify the Bar. In an op-ed published in the Daily Journal these experts first note that the Governance in the Public Interest Task Force is now looking at this issue and should be given a chance to complete its study. Second, they argue that the motivation for quicker action -- the Bar's ongoing crises -- has been negated by the Bar's new leadership team and an arbitrator's demurrer to all the former's executive director's claims against the Bar. They are concerned that the trustees' proposal discussed above, which leaves the regulatory system in the judicial branch, but suggests that the Governor and the Legislature appoint more Board trustees than the Supreme Court, could raise separation of powers issues and could be unconstitutional. They write that because "the admission and discipline of attorneys is a core judicial branch power, the judiciary is the ultimate authority over regulating the practice of law in California. The core judicial power over officers of the court is subject to only reasonable legislative regulation. At some point 'regulation' becomes 'destruction' and unconstitutionally invades the judiciary's power." (David Carrillo et al, Why the rush to dissolve the bar?, Daily Journal (April 13, 2016).) They go on to argue that, rather than enhancing public protection, de-unification will actually harm the public:
Returning to the question of motivation, consider this: who benefits? It is clear who will not benefit: the public. Proponents of the proposal have justified it by comparing it favorably to regulatory schemes for other professions and the bar[s] in other states. There are some superficial similarities between this profession and others - medicine, for example. But the law is unique, and the bar's work is crucial to our government and to society itself. Although doctors perform an important public service (saving lives), that is substantively distinct from the public role the bar plays: maintaining the integrity of the legal system and ensuring access to justice. For example, the bar has a major role in vetting judicial candidates. Will the new entity have the resources to continue operating the Judicial Nominees Evaluation Commission? And if some other states regulate their bars differently, so what? California should take pride in doing things differently - and better. (Id.)
While the issue of de-unification has been debated for years, it is clear that there is a renewed and growing interest in it as a possible solution to some of the most troubling issues impacting the Bar today and it warrants further consideration by all stakeholders.
This Bill Does Not Increase Modest Assistance to Legal Aid Organizations, Although Much More is Needed to Begin to Close the "Justice Gap." As this Committee has highlighted for many years, there has long been a dire need for civil legal services for poor Californians – especially underserved groups, such as elderly, disabled, children and people needing assistance with English. By many measures, California suffers from an overwhelming "justice gap" between the legal needs of low-income people and the legal help they receive. It has been estimated that the cost of closing the gap would amount to $400 million. Even in the best of times, legal aid providers have been able to address only a fraction of the demand for help. Because of insufficient resources, legal services programs can offer assistance in only a few types of cases; many poor and moderate-income Californians do not qualify for services; and most of those who meet the strict eligibility limits and seek assistance regarding problems for which a legal services office provides service are nevertheless turned away, simply for lack of staff. Even those who receive services are frequently under-served with brief advice and consultation, rather than full and fair representation.
As this Committee knows well, for over 30 years, interest on lawyer trust accounts (IOLTA) has been the primary mechanism on which the State has relied to fund legal aid programs. It seems likely that when the IOLTA program was instituted in 1981, no one anticipated that bank interest rates would be virtually zero, as the federal funds rate has been since the 2009-10 IOLTA grant cycle. The historic plunge in interest rates continues to pose an unprecedented challenge to the premise that legal aid programs can rely on IOLTA funding to help maintain their essential mission. Absent a substantial increase in interest rates, which may be undesirable in macro-economic terms, it has become painfully clear that IOLTA alone will never adequately address the needs of those less fortunate who require legal assistance.
As this Committee has frequently discussed and sought to ameliorate, funding for legal aid organizations that provide essential legal help for extremely impoverished individuals has been decimated in recent years. The Legislature has for years worked with the Bar to come up with alternative funding sources, in the past using non-mandatory dues, but that sunsetted several years ago diminishing state funding for legal aid even further, despite significantly greater needs for legal services by those who cannot afford them, and dramatically lower funding from other sources. Current law provides an optional legal aid fee by which members who choose to do so can help defray the cost of ensuring that legal services are available without regard to ability to pay market rates, consistently with each lawyer's professional responsibility, at the rate of $40. These voluntary contributions make up for some, but by no means all, of those lost non-mandatory contributions. Unfortunately, this year's bill does not provide any new funding for legal services programs.
The Bar’s leadership has, in the past, stated its commitment to this Committee to find other non-mandatory sources of funds as soon as possible to not just bridge this continuing crisis but to try finally to overcome it. A resolution adopted by the State Bar last May details the funding crisis in legal services and finds that "due to inadequate funding legal services must turn away eligible clients who are left to navigate complex legal situations on their own – and risk losing their families, homes and livelihoods in the process." The resolution ends with the Bar and its Board supporting "increased stable funding for legal services through an increased Equal Access Fund [limited state General Fund support of legal services] and otherwise to provide critically needed legal help to low-income and vulnerable residents of California." It is hoped that going forward, and in addition to a vitally needed increase in the Equal Access Fund itself, the Bar and its Board will be able to find additional, ongoing funding for legal services from the Bar's unrestricted sources of funding, funding that today may be used for discretionary expenses, including travel, catering, the annual meeting fund and other nonessential and non-public protection funds, that might be better invested in helping California's most vulnerable residents who seek legal assistance to avoid, among other things, domestic violence, unemployment and homelessness.
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION: CPIL opposes this bill, unless it is amended to make the changes discussed above regarding restructuring the Bar. In addition, CPIL proposes the following changes:
- Eliminate the attorney elections that today select six of the Board trustees, so the trustees are "selected by public officials, not by professional colleagues."
- Subject the Bar to an independent monitor: "It is in the best interest of the Bar – and the public – to hire an independent expert (outside of the politics, lawsuits, union votes, and finger pointing) who can study the disciplinary system as it exists today, and make recommendations to strengthen it, make it more efficient, ensure public protection, and ensure accurate reporting to the Legislature."
- Improve access to justice by implementing or seeking approval to implement recommendations in the Bar's Civil Justice Strategies Task Force and develop a statewide law school loan repayment program for lawyers who serve underrepresented communities.
- Fine-tune application of the California Public Records Act so that law schools can receive notification whether their students passed or failed the Bar exam.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
Bar Trustee Dennis Mangers (if amended)
Bar Trustee Joanna Mendoza (if amended)
Bar Trustee Glenda Corcoran (if amended)
California Lawyer Guild
Former Bar Trustee Heather Linn Rosing (if amended)
Opposition
Center for Public Interest Law (unless amended)
Analysis Prepared by: Leora Gershenzon / JUD. / (916) 319-2334
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):