AB 3207: California Financing Law.
- Session Year: 2017-2018
- House: Assembly
- Latest Version Date: 2018-07-05
(1)Existing law, the California Financing Law (CFL), provides for the licensure and regulation of finance lenders and brokers, and, beginning on January 1, 2019, program administrators, by the Commissioner of Business Oversight. The CFL prohibits anyone from engaging in the business of a finance lender or broker without obtaining a license. A willful violation of the CFL is a crime, except as specified. The CFL defines a broker to include anyone who is engaged in the business of negotiating or performing any act as a broker in connection with loans made by a finance lender.
This bill would revise the definition of a broker to include anyone who, among other things, transmits confidential data about a prospective borrower to a finance lender with the expectation of compensation in connection with making a referral unless a specified exception applies, makes a referral under an agreement with a finance lender that meets certain requirements with the expectation of compensation if the finance lender enters into the loan with the prospective borrower unless a specified exception applies, participates in any loan negotiation between a finance lender and prospective borrower, participates in the preparation of loan documents, communicates lending decisions or inquiries to a borrower, or charges a fee to a prospective borrower for any services related to an application for a loan from a finance lender. The bill would exempt specified persons from the definition of broker, including the operator of an Internet search engine or social media platform. Because the bill would expand the definition of an existing crime by broadening the definition of a broker for purposes of the CFL, the bill would impose a state-mandated local program.
The bill would prohibit a licensed broker from performing an act that falls within the definition of a broker without first obtaining the borrowers express consent.
(2)Existing law exempts specified entities from the CFL. Under existing federal law, a federally recognized Indian tribe is immune from suit on the basis of tribal sovereign immunity, and the California Supreme Court held in People ex rel. Owen v. Miami Nation Enterprises (2016) 2 Cal.5th 222 that tribal sovereign immunity can extend to an entity that is acting as an arm of the tribe provided the entity meets 5 factors articulated in that case.
The bill would state that the provisions of the CFL should not be interpreted to impose licensing or regulatory obligations on federally recognized Indian tribes or business entities that are considered arms of the tribe, under the test articulated in the California Supreme Court case described above and any superseding case law.
The bill would clarify that a licensed broker is not prohibited from performing any act that falls within the definition of broker in connection with loans made by a person not required to be licensed as a finance lender under this division.
(3)Existing law prohibits a finance lender, broker, or mortgage loan originator licensee from paying any commission, fee, or other compensation to an unlicensed individual for conducting activities related to a consumer loan that require a license, unless that unlicensed individual is exempt from licensure. Existing law authorizes a licensed finance lender to compensate an unlicensed person in connection with the referral of one or more prospective borrowers to the licensee for a commercial loan if certain requirements are met.
This bill would prohibit a finance lender from compensating a person for any of the acts that fall within the definition of a broker, as described above, unless that person is a licensed broker, is not required to be licensed as a broker under the CFL, or if that compensation is made in connection with the referral of one or more prospective borrowers when specified conditions are met. The bill would prohibit an unlicensed person who receives compensation pursuant to that exception from collecting a prospective borrowers confidential data for the purpose of making a referral without first obtaining the borrowers express consent, and would also require that person to provide a written disclosure to the prospective borrower before making the referral that shows the method of compensation to the licensed broker. The bill would prohibit a licensed finance lender from compensating a broker for specified acts that fall within the definition of broker if the finance lender has actual knowledge at the time the compensation is to be made that the broker has committed any violation of the CFL. CFL or any rule or order adopted under the CFL in connection with that loan. The bill would prohibit a licensed finance lender who enters into a loan with a prospective borrower in which the finance lender paid or would pay a referral fee from passing through an additional fee attributable to the referral fee, but would authorize a licensed finance lender to charge additional fees or costs attributable to the performance of other acts that fall within the definition of a broker if the finance lender pays another person for performing any of those acts for a consumer loan made under the CFL.
The bill would require a licensed broker who compensates unlicensed persons for referrals as described above to develop, implement, and enforce policies and procedures to ensure that the unlicensed person does not engage in acts that would have been a violation of the CFL had those acts been committed by a licensee. The bill would provide that a licensed broker who is in violation of this provision is in violation of this chapter to the same extent as the unlicensed person would have been had that person been a licensed broker. The bill would provide, however, that a licensed broker is not in violation of these provisions solely for the reason that an unlicensed person that the broker compensated commits isolated acts that are in violation of the CFL. The bill would require a broker who compensates unlicensed persons for referrals to maintain books and records documenting the identities of all unlicensed persons that the broker compensates for referrals and all unlicensed persons that broker severs a relationship with due to the unlicensed persons failure to adhere to the brokers policies and procedures adopted pursuant to these provisions. By expanding the scope of an existing crime with respect to violations of the CFL, this bill would impose a state-mandated local program.
(4)Existing law requires a licensed finance lender to provide a borrower with respect to a consumer loan a statement that contains, among other things, the terms of the loan, and to obtain a signed statement from the borrower as to whether any person has performed any act as a broker in connection with the making of the loan.
The bill would make clarifying changes to that provision, and would require a licensed finance lender, in lieu of the requirement to obtain a signed statement from the borrower described above, making a consumer loan to a prospective borrower who was referred by a licensed broker as described above or before the prospective borrowers express consent for such a borrower is obligated on the loan, to provide to the prospective borrower a statement that provides specified information relating to the arrangement in a clear and conspicuous manner.
(5)Existing law requires a licensed broker to comply with certain duties with respect to a consumer loan, including delivering the borrower a signed statement that contains the terms of the agreement with the broker, and when the borrower pays the loan in full, ensure that the finance lender fully complies with a provision of the CFL that requires a licensed finance lender, upon repayment of any loan in full, to take specified actions related to that loan, including releasing all security for the loan and marking it as paid.
This bill would, with respect to acts that fall within the definition of broker other than transmitting confidential data and making a referral as described above, no longer require a licensed broker to ensure that a finance lender fully complies with the provision of the CFL governing repayment described above. The bill would require a licensed broker before making a referral in connection with a consumer loan to provide to the prospective borrower a statement that provides specified information relating to the arrangement in a clear and conspicuous manner and to then obtain the prospective borrowers express consent.
(6)The CFL authorizes the commissioner to examine specified records of every person engaged in the business of a finance lender, broker, or, beginning on January 1, 2019, program administrator, for the purpose of discovering violations of the CFL or securing information otherwise required in the administration and enforcement of this division.
This bill would require the commissioner to examine the affairs of each finance lender licensee for compliance at least once every 48 months. The bill would authorize the commissioner to conduct the examination under oath. By expanding the crime of perjury, this bill would impose a state-mandated local program. The bill would require the commissioner to provide a written statement of the findings of the examination, to issue a copy of that statement to the licensees principals, officers, or directors, and to take appropriate steps to ensure correction of any violations.
(7)The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.
This bill would provide that no reimbursement is required by this act for a specified reason.
(1)Existing law, the California Financing Law (CFL), provides for the licensure and regulation of finance lenders and brokers, and, beginning on January 1, 2019, program administrators, by the Commissioner of Business Oversight. The CFL prohibits anyone from engaging in the business of a finance lender or broker without obtaining a license. A willful violation of the CFL is a crime, except as specified. The CFL defines a broker to include anyone who is engaged in the business of negotiating or performing any act as a broker in connection with loans made by a finance lender.
This bill would revise the definition of a broker to include anyone who, among other things, transmits confidential data about a prospective borrower to a finance lender with the expectation of compensation in connection with making a referral unless a specified exception applies, makes a referral under an agreement with a finance lender that meets certain requirements with the expectation of compensation if the finance lender enters into the loan with the prospective borrower unless a specified exception applies, participates in any loan negotiation between a finance lender and prospective borrower, participates in the preparation of loan documents, communicates lending decisions or inquiries to a borrower, or charges a fee to a prospective borrower for any services related to an application for a loan from a finance lender. Because the bill would expand the definition of an existing crime by broadening the definition of a broker for purposes of the CFL, the bill would impose a state-mandated local program.
The bill would prohibit a licensed broker from collecting confidential data for the purpose of performing an act that falls within the definition of a broker without first obtaining the borrowers affirmative authorization. express consent.
(2)Existing law exempts specified entities from the CFL. Under existing federal law, a federally recognized Indian tribe is immune from suit on the basis of tribal sovereign immunity, and the California Supreme Court held in People ex rel. Owen v. Miami Nation Enterprises (2016) 2 Cal.5th 222 that tribal sovereign immunity can extend to an entity that is acting as an arm of the tribe provided the entity meets 5 factors articulated in that case.
The bill would state that the provisions of the CFL should not be interpreted to impose licensing or regulatory obligations on federally recognized Indian tribes or business entities that are considered arms of the tribe, under the test articulated in the California Supreme Court case described above and any superseding case law.
(3)Existing law prohibits a finance lender, broker, or mortgage loan originator licensee from paying any commission, fee, or other compensation to an unlicensed individual for conducting activities related to a consumer loan that require a license, unless that unlicensed individual is exempt from licensure. Existing law authorizes a licensed finance lender to compensate an unlicensed person in connection with the referral of one or more prospective borrowers to the licensee for a commercial loan if certain requirements are met.
This bill would prohibit a finance lender from compensating a person for any of the acts that fall within the definition of a broker, as described above, unless that person is a licensed broker broker, is not required to be licensed as a broker under the CFL, or if that compensation is made in connection with the referral of one or more prospective borrowers when specified conditions are met, including that the finance lender is prohibited from doing so if the finance lender has actual knowledge at the time that the compensation is to be made that the broker has committed any violation of a provision of the CFL that prohibits a licensee from making false or misleading statements or from knowingly misrepresenting any material information regarding a transaction and committing any act that constitutes fraud or dishonest dealings. met. The bill would prohibit an unlicensed person who receives compensation pursuant to that exception from collecting a prospective borrowers confidential data for the purpose of making a referral without first obtaining the borrowers affirmative authorization, express consent, and would also require that person to provide a written disclosure to the prospective borrower before making the referral that shows the method of compensation to the licensed broker. The bill would prohibit a licensed finance lender from compensating a broker for specified acts that fall within the definition of broker if the finance lender has actual knowledge at the time the compensation is to be made that the broker has committed any violation of the CFL. The bill would prohibit a licensed finance lender who enters into a loan with a prospective borrower in which the finance lender paid or would pay a referral fee from charging the borrower more for the loan than the finance lender would have if the finance lender had not agreed to pay the referral fee. passing through an additional fee attributable to the referral fee, but would authorize a licensed finance lender to charge additional fees or costs attributable to the performance of other acts that fall within the definition of a broker if the finance lender pays another person for performing any of those acts for a consumer loan made under the CFL.
The bill would require a licensed broker who compensates unlicensed persons for referrals as described above to develop, implement, and enforce policies and procedures to ensure that the unlicensed person does not engage in acts that would have been a violation of the CFL had those acts been committed by a licensee. The bill would provide that a licensed broker who is in violation of this provision is in violation of this chapter to the same extent as the unlicensed person would have been had that person been a licensed broker. The bill would provide, however, that a licensed broker is not in violation of these provisions solely for the reason that an unlicensed person commits isolated acts that are in violation of the CFL. By expanding the scope of an existing crime with respect to violations of the CFL, this bill would impose a state-mandated local program.
(4)Existing law requires a licensed finance lender to provide a borrower with respect to a consumer loan a statement that contains, among other things, the terms of the loan, and to obtain a signed statement from the borrower as to whether any person has performed any act as a broker in connection with the making of the loan.
The bill would make clarifying changes to that provision, and would require a licensed finance lender, in lieu of the requirement to obtain a signed statement from the borrower described above, after receiving a referral from a broker for a consumer loan as described above, but before the prospective borrower affirmatively assents to the loan, making a consumer loan to a prospective borrower who was referred by a licensed broker as described above or before the prospective borrowers express consent for such a loan, to provide to the prospective borrower a statement that provides specified information relating to the arrangement in a clear and conspicuous manner.
(5)Existing law requires a licensed broker to comply with certain duties with respect to a consumer loan, including delivering the borrower a signed statement that contains the terms of the agreement with the broker. broker, and when the borrower pays the loan in full, ensure that the finance lender fully complies with a provision of the CFL that requires a licensed finance lender, upon repayment of any loan in full, to take specified actions related to that loan, including releasing all security for the loan and marking it as paid.
This bill would, instead, would, with respect to acts that fall within the definition of broker other than transmitting confidential data and making a referral as described above, no longer require a licensed broker to ensure that a finance lender fully complies with the provision of the CFL governing repayment described above. The bill would require a licensed broker before collecting the borrowers confidential data for the purpose of making a referral in connection with a consumer loan to provide to the prospective borrower a statement that provides specified information relating to the arrangement in a clear and conspicuous manner and to then obtain the prospective borrowers affirmative authorization. express consent.
(6)The CFL authorizes the commissioner to examine specified records of every person engaged in the business of a finance lender, broker, or, beginning on January 1, 2019, program administrator, for the purpose of discovering violations of the CFL or securing information otherwise required in the administration and enforcement of this division.
This bill would require the commissioner to examine the affairs of each finance lender licensee for compliance at least once every 48 months. The bill would authorize the commissioner to conduct the examination under oath. By expanding the crime of perjury, this bill would impose a state-mandated local program. The bill would require the commissioner to provide a written statement of the findings of the examination, to issue a copy of that statement to the licensees principals, officers, or directors, and to take appropriate steps to ensure correction of any violations.
(6)(7)The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.
This bill would provide that no reimbursement is required by this act for a specified reason.
(1)Existing law, the California Financing Law (CFL), provides for the licensure and regulation of finance lenders and brokers, and, beginning on January 1, 2019, program administrators, by the Commissioner of Business Oversight. The CFL prohibits anyone from engaging in the business of a finance lender or broker without obtaining a license. A willful violation of the CFL is a crime, except as specified. The CFL defines a broker to include anyone who is engaged in the business of negotiating or performing any act as a broker in connection with loans made by a finance lender.
This bill would revise the definition of a broker to include anyone who, among other things, transmits confidential data about a prospective borrower to a finance lender with the expectation of compensation in connection with making a referral unless a specified exception applies, makes a referral under an agreement with a finance lender that meets certain requirements with the expectation of compensation if the finance lender enters into the loan with the prospective borrower unless a specified exception applies, participates in any loan negotiation between a finance lender and prospective borrower, participates in the preparation of loan documents, communicates lending decisions or inquiries to a borrower, or charges a fee to a prospective borrower for any services related to an application for a loan from a finance lender. Because the bill would expand the definition of an existing crime by broadening the definition of a broker for purposes of the CFL, the bill would impose a state-mandated local program.
The bill would prohibit a licensed broker from collecting confidential data for the purpose of performing an act that falls within the definition of a broker without first obtaining the borrowers affirmative authorization.
(2)Existing law exempts specified entities from the CFL. Under existing federal law, a federally recognized Indian tribe is immune from suit on the basis of tribal sovereign immunity, and the California Supreme Court held in People ex rel. Owen v. Miami Nation Enterprises (2016) 2 Cal.5th 222 that tribal sovereign immunity can extend to an entity that is acting as an arm of the tribe provided the entity meets 5 factors articulated in that case.
The bill would state that the provisions of the CFL should not be interpreted to impose licensing or regulatory obligations on federally recognized Indian tribes or business entities that are considered arms of the tribe, under the test articulated in the California Supreme Court case described above and any superseding case law.
(2)(3)Existing law prohibits a finance lender, broker, or mortgage loan originator licensee from paying any commission, fee, or other compensation to an unlicensed individual for conducting activities related to a consumer loan that require a license, unless that unlicensed individual is exempt from licensure. Existing law authorizes a licensed finance lender to compensate an unlicensed person in connection with the referral of one or more prospective borrowers to the licensee for a commercial loan if certain requirements are met.
This bill would prohibit a finance lender from compensating a person for any of the acts that fall within the definition of a broker, as described above, unless that person is a licensed broker or if that compensation is made in connection with the referral of one or more prospective borrowers when specified conditions are met, including that the finance lender is prohibited from doing so if the finance lender knows has actual knowledge at the time that the compensation is to be made that the broker has committed any violation of a provision of the CFL that prohibits a licensee from making false or misleading statements or from knowingly misrepresenting any material information regarding a transaction and committing any act that constitutes fraud or dishonest dealings. The bill would prohibit an unlicensed person who receives compensation pursuant to that exception from collecting a prospective borrowers confidential data for the purpose of making a referral without first obtaining the borrowers affirmative authorization, and would also require that person to provide a written disclosure to the prospective borrower before making the referral that shows the method of compensation to the licensed broker. The bill would prohibit a licensed finance lender who enters into a loan with a prospective borrower in which the finance lender paid or would pay a referral fee from charging the borrower more for the loan than the finance lender would have if the finance lender had not agreed to pay the referral fee.
The bill would require a licensed broker who compensates unlicensed persons for referrals as described above to develop, implement, and enforce policies and procedures to ensure that the unlicensed person does not engage in acts that would have been a violation of the CFL had those acts been committed by a licensee. The bill would provide that a licensed broker who is in violation of this provision is in violation of this chapter to the same extent as the unlicensed person would have been had that person been a licensed broker. By expanding the scope of an existing crime with respect to violations of the CFL, this bill would impose a state-mandated local program.
(3)(4)Existing law requires a licensed finance lender to provide a borrower with respect to a consumer loan a statement that contains, among other things, the terms of the loan, and to obtain a signed statement from the borrower as to whether any person has performed any act as a broker in connection with the making of the loan.
The bill would require a licensed finance lender, in lieu of the requirement to obtain a signed statement from the borrower described above, after receiving a referral from a broker for a consumer loan as described above above, but before accepting an application from the prospective borrower referred by the broker, affirmatively assents to the loan, to provide to the prospective borrower a statement that provides specified information relating to the arrangement in a clear and conspicuous manner.
(4)(5)Existing law requires a licensed broker to comply with certain duties with respect to a consumer loan, including delivering the borrower a signed statement that contains the terms of the agreement with the broker.
This bill would, instead, require a licensed broker before collecting the borrowers confidential data for the purpose of making a referral in connection with a consumer loan to provide to the prospective borrower a statement that provides specified information relating to the arrangement in a clear and conspicuous manner and to then obtain the prospective borrowers affirmative authorization.
(5)(6)The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.
This bill would provide that no reimbursement is required by this act for a specified reason.
(1)Existing law, the California Financing Law (CFL), provides for the licensure and regulation of finance lenders and brokers, and, beginning on January 1, 2019, program administrators, by the Commissioner of Business Oversight. The CFL prohibits anyone from engaging in the business of a finance lender or broker without obtaining a license. A willful violation of the CFL is a crime, except as specified. The CFL defines a broker to include anyone who is engaged in the business of negotiating or performing any act as a broker in connection with loans made by a finance lender.
This bill would revise the definition of a broker to include anyone who, among other things, receives compensation for providing a referral or a lead if the referral or lead conveys confidential information, as defined, transmits confidential data about a prospective borrower to a finance lender with the expectation of compensation in connection with making a referral unless a specified exception applies, makes a referral under an agreement with a finance lender that meets certain requirements with the expectation of compensation if the finance lender enters into the loan with the prospective borrower unless a specified exception applies, participates in any loan negotiation between a finance lender and prospective borrower, participates in the preparation of loan documents, communicates lending decisions or inquiries to a borrower, or charges any fees a fee to a prospective borrower or applicant for any services related to an application for a loan from a finance lenders. lender. Because the bill would expand the definition of an existing crime by broadening the definition of a broker for purposes of the CFL, the bill would impose a state-mandated local program.
The bill would prohibit a licensed broker from soliciting or collecting confidential data, unless that information is reasonably necessary to perform the acts that fall within the definition of a broker. data for the purpose of performing an act that falls within the definition of a broker without first obtaining the borrowers affirmative authorization.
(2)Existing law prohibits a finance lender, broker, or mortgage loan originator licensee from paying any commission, fee, or other compensation to an unlicensed individual for conducting activities related to a consumer loan that require a license, unless that unlicensed individual is exempt from licensure. Existing law authorizes a licensed finance lender to compensate an unlicensed person in connection with the referral of one or more prospective borrowers to the licensee for a commercial loan if certain requirements are met.
This bill would prohibit a finance lender from compensating a person for any of the acts that fall within the definition of a broker, as described above, unless that person is a licensed broker or if that compensation is made in connection with the referral of one or more prospective borrowers when specified conditions are met. met, including that the finance lender is prohibited from doing so if the finance lender knows at the time that the compensation is to be made that the broker has committed any violation of a provision of the CFL that prohibits a licensee from making false or misleading statements or from knowingly misrepresenting any material information regarding a transaction and committing any act that constitutes fraud or dishonest dealings. The bill would prohibit an unlicensed person who receives compensation pursuant to that exception from collecting confidential data, as specified, a prospective borrowers confidential data for the purpose of making a referral without first obtaining the borrowers affirmative authorization, and would also require that person to provide a written disclosure to the prospective borrower before making the referral or lead that shows the method of compensation to the licensed broker. The bill would prohibit a licensee from compensating a broker for services related to a loan subject to the CFL if the broker has committed any violation of a provision prohibiting false and misleading statements. The bill would prohibit a licensee from passing through to a borrower the licensees cost of compensating a broker. The bill would prohibit a licensed finance lender who enters into a loan with a prospective borrower in which the finance lender paid or would pay a referral fee from charging the borrower more for the loan than the finance lender would have if the finance lender had not agreed to pay the referral fee.
(3)Existing law prohibits a licensee from making a materially false or misleading statement to a borrower about the terms or conditions of the borrowers loan.The bill would require a licensed broker who compensates unlicensed persons for referrals as described above to develop, implement, and enforce policies and procedures to ensure that the unlicensed person does not engage in acts that would have been a violation of the CFL had those acts been committed by a licensee. The bill would provide that a licensed broker who is in violation of this provision is in violation of this chapter to the same extent as the unlicensed person would have been had that person been a licensed broker. By expanding the scope of an existing crime with respect to violations of the CFL, this bill would impose a state-mandated local program.
(3)Existing law requires a licensed finance lender to provide a borrower with respect to a consumer loan a statement that contains, among other things, the terms of the loan, and to obtain a signed statement from the borrower as to whether any person has performed any act as a broker in connection with the making of the loan.
The bill would require a licensed broker, before making a referral or lead in connection with a loan subject to the CFL, to provide the prospective borrower a written disclosure of the method of compensation used. The bill would require a licensed finance lender, before consummating a loan subject to the CFL, to provide the prospective borrower a written disclosure that shows the amount paid to any broker in connection with the loan and how the compensation was determined. finance lender, in lieu of the requirement to obtain a signed statement from the borrower described above, after receiving a referral from a broker for a consumer loan as described above but before accepting an application from the prospective borrower referred by the broker, to provide to the prospective borrower a statement that provides specified information relating to the arrangement in a clear and conspicuous manner.
(4)Existing law requires a licensed broker to comply with certain duties with respect to a consumer loan, including delivering the borrower a signed statement that contains the terms of the agreement with the broker.
This bill would, instead, require a licensed broker before collecting the borrowers confidential data for the purpose of making a referral in connection with a consumer loan to provide to the prospective borrower a statement that provides specified information relating to the arrangement in a clear and conspicuous manner and to then obtain the prospective borrowers affirmative authorization.
(4)(5)The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.
This bill would provide that no reimbursement is required by this act for a specified reason.
(1)Existing law, the California Financing Law (CFL), provides for the licensure and regulation of finance lenders and brokers, and, beginning on January 1, 2019, program administrators, by the Commissioner of Business Oversight. The CFL prohibits anyone from engaging in the business of a finance lender or broker without obtaining a license. A willful violation of the CFL is a crime, except as specified. The CFL defines a broker to include anyone who is engaged in the business of negotiating or performing any act as a broker in connection with loans made by a finance lender.
This bill would revise the definition of a broker to include anyone who, among other things, receives compensation for providing a referral or a lead if the referral or lead conveys confidential information, as defined, participates in any loan negotiation between a finance lender and prospective borrower, participates in the preparation of loan documents, communicates lending decisions or inquiries to a borrower, or charges any fees to a prospective borrower or applicant for any services related to an application for a loan from a finance lenders. Because the bill would expand the definition of an existing crime by broadening the definition of a broker for purposes of the CFL, the bill would impose a state-mandated local program.
The bill would prohibit a licensed broker from soliciting or collecting confidential data, unless that information is reasonably necessary to perform the acts that fall within the definition of a broker.
(2)Existing law prohibits a finance lender, broker, or mortgage loan originator licensee from paying any commission, fee, or other compensation to an unlicensed individual for conducting activities related to a consumer loan that require a license, unless that unlicensed individual is exempt from licensure. Existing law authorizes a licensed finance lender to compensate an unlicensed person in connection with the referral of one or more prospective borrowers to the licensee for a commercial loan if certain requirements are met.
This bill would prohibit a finance lender from compensating a person for any of the acts that fall within the definition of a broker, as described above, unless that person is a licensed broker or if that compensation is made in connection with the referral of one or more prospective borrowers when specified conditions are met. The bill would require prohibit an unlicensed person who receives compensation pursuant to that exception to, among other things, from collecting confidential data, as specified, and would also require that person to provide a written disclosure to the prospective borrower before making the referral or lead that shows the method of compensation to the licensed broker. The bill would prohibit a licensee from compensating a broker for services related to a loan subject to the CFL if the broker has committed any violation of a provision prohibiting false and misleading statements. The bill would prohibit a licensee from passing through to a borrower the licensees cost of compensating a broker.
(3)Existing law prohibits a licensee from making a materially false or misleading statement to a borrower about the terms or conditions of the borrowers loan.
The bill would require a licensed broker, before making a referral or lead in connection with a loan subject to the CFL, to provide the prospective borrower a written disclosure of the method of compensation used. The bill would require a licensed finance lender, before consummating a loan subject to the CFL, to provide the prospective borrower a written disclosure that shows the amount paid to any broker in connection with the loan and how the compensation was determined.
(4)The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.
This bill would provide that no reimbursement is required by this act for a specified reason.
(1)Existing law, the California Financing Law (CFL), provides for the licensure and regulation of finance lenders and brokers, and, beginning on January 1, 2019, program administrators, by the Commissioner of Business Oversight. The CFL prohibits anyone from engaging in the business of a finance lender or broker without obtaining a license. A willful violation of the CFL is a crime, except as specified. The CFL defines a broker to include anyone who is engaged in the business of negotiating or performing any act as a broker in connection with loans made by a finance lender.
This bill would revise the definition of a broker to include anyone who, among other things, receives compensation for providing a referral or a lead if the referral or lead conveys confidential information, as defined, participates in any loan negotiation between a finance lender and prospective borrower, participates in the preparation of loan documents, communicates lending decisions or inquiries to a borrower, or charges any fees to a prospective borrower or applicant for any services related to an application for a loan from a finance lenders. Because the bill would expand the definition of an existing crime by broadening the definition of a broker for purposes of the CFL, the bill would impose a state-mandated local program.
The bill would prohibit a licensed broker from soliciting or collecting confidential data, unless that information is reasonably necessary to perform the acts that fall within the definition of a broker.
(2)Existing law prohibits a finance lender, broker, or mortgage loan originator licensee from paying any commission, fee, or other compensation to an unlicensed individual for conducting activities related to a consumer loan that require a license, unless that unlicensed individual is exempt from licensure. Existing law authorizes a licensed finance lender to compensate an unlicensed person in connection with the referral of one or more prospective borrowers to the licensee for a commercial loan if certain requirements are met.
This bill would prohibit a finance lender from compensating a person for any of the acts that fall within the definition of a broker, as described above, unless that person is a licensed broker or if that compensation is made in connection with the referral of one or more prospective borrowers when specified conditions are met. The bill would require an unlicensed person who receives compensation pursuant to that exception to, among other things, provide a written disclosure to the prospective borrower before making the referral or lead that shows the method of compensation to the licensed broker. The bill would prohibit a licensee from compensating a broker for services related to a loan subject to the CFL if the broker has committed any violation of a provision prohibiting false and misleading statements. The bill would prohibit a licensee from passing through to a borrower the licensees cost of compensating a broker.
(3)Existing law prohibits a licensee from making a materially false or misleading statement to a borrower about the terms or conditions of the borrowers loan.
The bill would require a licensed broker, before making a referral or lead in connection with a loan subject to the CFL, to provide the prospective borrower a written disclosure of the method of compensation used. The bill would require a licensed finance lender, before consummating a loan subject to the CFL, to provide the prospective borrower a written disclosure that shows the amount paid to any broker in connection with the loan and how the compensation was determined.
(4)The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.
This bill would provide that no reimbursement is required by this act for a specified reason.
The California Credit Union Law regulates the formation and operation of credit unions. Existing law sets forth various defined terms for purposes of the California Credit Union Law. This bill would make a nonsubstantive change to these provisions.The California Credit Union Law regulates the formation and operation of credit unions. Existing law sets forth various defined terms for purposes of the California Credit Union Law.
This bill would make a nonsubstantive change to these provisions.
(a)Broker includes any person who is engaged in the business of performing any of the following acts in connection with loans made by a finance lender, unless that person is otherwise exempt from this division pursuant to Section 22050:
(1)Transmitting confidential data about a prospective borrower to a finance lender with the expectation of compensation, in connection with making a referral. However, a licensed finance lender that transmits confidential data to another licensed finance lender as described in this paragraph in connection with the denial of a loan application shall be deemed to not be a broker within the meaning of this paragraph if the licensee does both of the following before transmitting the confidential data:
(A)Provides the prospective borrower a clear and conspicuous written statement that discloses that the licensee either may be compensated by the finance lender for transmitting the confidential data, or, if applicable, will be compensated by the finance lender if the transmittal results in a funded loan. The licensee shall have the prospective borrower acknowledge receipt of the statement. The form of the statement shall comply with paragraph (1) of subdivision (c) of Section 22337.5.
(B)After the prospective borrower acknowledges receipt of the written disclosure statement, obtains the prospective borrowers express consent to transmit the confidential data.
(2)Making a referral to a finance lender under an agreement with the finance lender that any prospective borrower referred by the person to the finance lender meet certain criteria involving confidential data and with the expectation that the person making the referral will be compensated if the finance lender and the prospective borrower enter into a loan agreement. However, a licensed finance lender that makes a referral to another licensed finance lender as described in this paragraph in connection with the denial of a loan application shall be deemed to not be a broker within the meaning of this paragraph if the licensee does both of the following before making the referral:
(A)Provides the prospective borrower a clear and conspicuous written statement that discloses that the licensee either may be compensated by the finance lender for making the referral, or, if applicable, will be compensated by the finance lender if the referral results in a funded loan. The licensee shall have the prospective borrower acknowledge receipt of the statement. The form of the statement shall comply with paragraph (1) of subdivision (c) of Section 22337.5.
(B)After the prospective borrower acknowledges receipt of the written disclosure statement, obtains the prospective borrowers express consent to make the referral.
(3)Participating in any loan negotiation between a finance lender and prospective borrower.
(4)Counseling, advising, or making recommendations to a prospective borrower about a loan based on the prospective borrowers confidential data.
(5)Participating in the preparation of any loan documents, including loan applications, other than providing a prospective borrower blank copies of loan documents. Transmitting information that is not confidential data to a finance lender at the request of a prospective borrower shall not, by itself, constitute participation in the preparation of loan documents.
(6)Communicating to a prospective borrower a finance lenders loan approval decisions involving confidential data.
(7)Charging a fee to a prospective borrower for any services related to a prospective borrowers application for a loan from a finance lender.
(b)(1)For purposes of this section, confidential data means the following:
(A)Bank account number.
(B)Bank statement.
(C)Credit or debit card account number.
(D)Credit score, as defined in subdivision (b) of Section 1785.15.1 of the Civil Code, either self-reported by the person it relates to, or received from a credit reporting agency as part of an official request.
(E)Social security number, including both a persons full social security number or a partial number.
(F)Personal or business income information, including information self-reported by the person.
(G)Government-issued identification number.
(H)Personal employment data or history.
(I)Date of birth.
(J)Mothers maiden name.
(K)Medical information.
(L)Health insurance information.
(M)Insurance policy number.
(N)Taxpayer or employer identification number.
(2)The term confidential data does not include any of the following:
(A)Name.
(B)Phone number.
(C)Physical address.
(D)Email address.
(E)Desired loan or financing amount.
(F)Prospective borrowers stated purpose for a loan.
(G)Prospective borrowers self-reported range of credit scores or range of incomes.
(H)Information that is knowingly made publicly available by a prospective borrower.
(H)(I)In connection with a commercial loan, confidential data does not include a businesss name, address, phone number, email address, self-reported income, self-reported credit score of a business owner, or a businesss desired loan or financing amount, in addition to the other information listed in this paragraph.
(c)A person shall not be deemed a broker if both of the following are met:
(1)The person distributes or otherwise disseminates to a prospective borrower a finance lenders marketing materials or factual information about the finance lender, its lending activities, or its loan products, such as the finance lenders interest rates, minimum or maximum loan amounts or loan periods, or a general description of the finance lenders underwriting criteria.
(2)The person does not perform any of the acts specified in subdivision (a).
(d)This section does not apply to any person of the following:
(1)A person who performs the acts described in subdivision (a) five or fewer times in a calendar year.
(2)A person who performs only administrative or clerical tasks.
(3)A consumer credit reporting agency, as defined in Section 1785.3 of the Civil Code, which furnishes a consumer credit report to a finance lender.
(4)The operator of an Internet search engine, when providing general search results to the public, whether or not based on paid advertising, provided that the operator of the Internet search engine does not engage in any brokering activities beyond providing search results. For purposes of this paragraph, Internet search engine means an Internet Web site that provides the user a method, either via a query search or any other means, to search the Internet.
(5)The operator of a social media platform, whether or not compensated in connection with paid advertising, provided that the operator of the social media platform does not engage in any brokering activities that are unrelated to the primary purpose of the social media platform. For purposes of this paragraph, social media means an electronic service or account, or electronic content, including, but not limited to, videos, still photographs, blogs, video blogs, podcasts, instant and text messages, email, online services or accounts, or Internet Web site profiles or locations.
SEC. 2.Section 22005.5 is added to the Financial Code, to read:22005.5.For purposes of this division, express consent means an affirmative action taken by a person to authorize one or more specific acts by others in connection with that persons confidential data. Express consent cannot be implied or inferred.
SEC. 2.SEC. 3.Section 22010.5 is added to the Financial Code, to read:22010.5.Referral means the introduction of a prospective borrower to a finance lender or the delivery of a prospective borrowers contact information to a finance lender for the purposes of making an introduction.
SEC. 3.SEC. 4.Section 22050.1 is added to the Financial Code, to read:22050.1.Nothing in this division shall be interpreted to impose licensing or regulatory obligations on federally recognized Indian tribes or business entities that are considered arms of a tribe, tribe, under the test articulated in People ex rel. Owen v. Miami Nation Enterprises (2016) 2 Cal.5th 222 and any superseding case law.
SEC. 5.Section 22059 of the Financial Code is amended to read:22059.(a)A license to act as a broker under this division does not authorize the licensee to negotiate or perform any act as a broker in connection with loans made or to be made by a lender not licensed as a finance lender under this division.
(b)Notwithstanding subdivision (a), a license to act as a broker under this division does not prohibit the licensee from performing any of the acts described in subdivision (a) of Section 22004 in connection with loans made or to be made by a person not required to be licensed as a finance lender under this division.
SEC. 4.SEC. 6.Section 22100 of the Financial Code is amended to read:22100.(a)A person shall not engage in the business of a finance lender or broker without obtaining a license from the commissioner.
(b)Every licensee engaging in the business of making or brokering residential mortgage loans shall require that every mortgage loan originator employed or compensated by that licensee obtains and maintains a mortgage loan originator license from the commissioner under this division or Division 20 (commencing with Section 50000), or has first obtained a license endorsement from the Commissioner of Real Estate pursuant to Article 2.1 (commencing with Section 10166.01) of Chapter 3 of Part 1 of Division 4 of the Business and Professions Code.
(c)Except as provided in subdivisions (a), (b), and (e) of Section 22602, a finance lender shall not compensate a person for any of the acts described in subdivision (a) of Section 22004 unless that person is a licensed broker or is not required to be licensed as a broker pursuant to this division.
(d)A licensed broker shall not perform an act described in subdivision (a) of Section 22004 without first obtaining the prospective borrowers express consent for that purpose. A licensed broker shall be deemed to be in compliance with this subdivision if the broker obtained the consent of the prospective borrower before the operative date of the act adding this subdivision and that consent was not revoked.
(e)A licensed finance lender shall not compensate a broker for an act described in subdivision (a) of Section 22004 if the finance lender has actual knowledge at the time the compensation is to be made that the broker has committed any violation of this division or any rule or order adopted pursuant to this division in connection with that loan.
(f)A licensed finance lender shall not, in connection with any loan subject to this division for which the finance lender paid or would pay a referral fee, pass through an additional fee attributable to the referral fee. However, a licensed finance lender may charge a borrower additional fees or costs attributable to the performance of any of the acts described in paragraphs (3) to (7), inclusive, of subdivision (a) of Section 22004 if the finance lender pays another person or entity for performing any of those acts for a loan made pursuant to this division.
(g)A finance lender or broker shall not employ a mortgage loan originator whose license or license endorsement has lapsed.
(h)A finance lender or broker may not make or broker a residential mortgage loan unless that loan is offered by, negotiated by, or applied for through a licensed mortgage loan originator.
(i)Every licensee engaged in the business of making or brokering residential mortgage loans and every mortgage loan originator licensed under this division shall register with and maintain a valid unique identifier issued by the Nationwide Mortgage Licensing System and Registry.
(j)An individual shall not engage in the business of a mortgage loan originator with respect to any dwelling located in this state without first obtaining and maintaining annually a license in accordance with the requirements of this division and any rules promulgated by the commissioner under this chapter.
(k)A registered mortgage loan originator, as defined in subdivision (c) of Section 22013, is exempt from licensure under this section when he or she is employed by:
(1)A depository institution.
(2)A subsidiary of a depository institution that is owned and controlled by a depository institution and regulated by a federal banking agency.
(3)An institution regulated by the Farm Credit Administration.
SEC. 5.SEC. 7.Section 22337 of the Financial Code is amended to read:22337.Each licensed finance lender shall:
(a)Deliver or cause to be delivered to the borrower, or any one thereof, at the time the loan is made, a statement showing in clear and distinct terms the name, address, and license number of the finance lender and the broker, if any. The statement shall show the date, amount, and maturity of the loan contract, how and when repayable, the nature of the security for the loan, if any, and the agreed rate of charge or the annual percentage rate pursuant to Regulation Z promulgated by the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (12 C.F.R. 1026).
(b)Except in connection with an act described in paragraph (1) or (2) of subdivision (a) of Section 22004, obtain from the borrower a signed statement as to whether any person has performed any act as a broker in connection with the making of the loan. If the statement discloses that a broker or other person has participated, then the finance lender shall obtain a full statement of all sums paid or payable to the broker or other person by the borrower, if any. The finance lender shall keep these statements for a period of three years from and after the date the loan has been paid in full, or has matured according to its terms, or has been charged off.
(c)Permit payment to be made in advance in any amount on any contract of loan at any time. The licensee may apply the payment first to any agreed prepayment penalty, then to all charges due, including charges at the agreed rate or rates up to the date of payment, not to exceed the applicable maximum rate permitted by this article.
(d)Deliver or cause to be delivered to the person making any cash payment, or to the person who requests a receipt at the time of making any payment, at the time payment is made on account of any loan, a plain and complete receipt showing the total amount received and identifying the loan contract upon which the payment is applied.
(e)Upon repayment of any loan in full, release all security for the loan, endorse and return any certificate of ownership, and cancel or plainly mark paid and return to the borrower or person making final payment, any note, mortgage, security agreement, trust deed, assignment, or order signed by the borrower, or an optical image reproduction thereof, except those documents that are a part of the court record in any action, or that have been delivered to a third person for the purpose of carrying out their terms, or a security agreement that secures any other indebtedness of a borrower to the licensee, or original documents otherwise required by law. When a trust deed on real property has been taken as security for a loan that has been subsequently paid in full, a duly executed request for reconveyance shall be delivered to the trustor or trustee for the purpose of recording a reconveyance. A termination statement, furnished to the borrower as provided for in Sections 9512 and 9513 of the Commercial Code, shall be deemed a release of the security when a financing statement has been filed pursuant to Section 9501 of the Commercial Code.
For purposes of this subdivision, an optical image reproduction shall meet all of the following requirements:
(1)The optical image storage media used to store the document shall be nonerasable write once, read many (WORM) optical image media that does not allow changes to the stored document.
(2)The optical image reproduction shall be made consistent with the minimum standards of quality approved by either the National Institute of Standards and Technology or the Association for Information and Image Management.
(3)Written authentication identifying the optical image reproduction as an exact unaltered copy of the note, trust deed, mortgage, security agreement, assignment, or order shall be stamped or printed on the optical image reproduction.
(f)Deliver or cause to be delivered to the potential borrower, or any one thereof, at the time the licensee first requires or accepts any signed instrument or the payment of any fee, a statement showing in clear and distinct terms the name, address, and license number of the finance lender and the broker, if any.
SEC. 6.SEC. 8.Section 22337.5 is added to the Financial Code, to read:22337.5.(a)Before making a loan to a prospective borrower who was referred by a licensed broker through an act described in paragraph (1) or (2) of subdivision (a) of Section 22004, and before the prospective borrowers express consent to borrower is obligated on the loan, the licensed finance lender shall provide to the prospective borrower a statement in a clear and conspicuous manner that provides all of the following:
(1)Identifies the name and license number of the broker who referred the prospective borrower.
(2)Discloses that the finance lender may pay a fee to the broker who referred the prospective borrower for the referral.
(3)Affirms that, if the licensed finance lender pays a fee for a referral, the licensed finance lender will not pass through to the prospective borrower an additional fee attributable to the referral fee. However, the licensed finance lender may charge a borrower additional fees or costs as described in subdivision (f) of Section 22100.
(4)Affirms that the prospective borrower should not be charged a fee by the broker who referred the prospective borrower to the licensed finance lender for a referral described in paragraph (1) or (2) of subdivision (a) of Section 22004.
(5)Affirms that the finance lender, not the broker who referred the prospective borrower, is the party authorized to make a loan to the prospective borrower.
(6)Provides a statement substantially similar to the following:
If you wish to report a complaint about the manner in which you were referred to us, you may contact the Department of Business Oversight at 866-275-2677 or file a complaint online at www.dbo.ca.gov.
(b)A licensed finance lender who provides the statement described in subdivision (a) shall have prospective borrowers acknowledge receipt of the statement.
(c)For purposes of this section, clear and conspicuous means either of the following:
(1)If the statement is provided in text, that the text is at least 10-point size, is not obscured by techniques such as graphical displays, shading, coloration, or other devices, and is displayed in a manner that allows a prospective borrower to read the text.
(2)If the statement is an oral statement, whether provided by telephone or other medium, that the statement is given at a speed and volume sufficient for a prospective borrower to hear and comprehend the disclosure.
SEC. 7.SEC. 9.Section 22338 of the Financial Code is amended to read:22338.In connection with any of the acts described in paragraphs (3) to (7), inclusive, of subdivision (a) of Section 22004, each licensed broker shall:
(a)Deliver to the borrower, or any one thereof, at the time the final negotiation or arrangement is made, a statement showing in clear and distinct terms the name, address, and license number of the broker and the finance lender. The statement shall show the date, amount, and terms of the agreement with the broker, and all amounts paid or to be paid to the broker by the prospective borrower and to any person other than the finance lender.
(b)Deliver to the finance lender making the loan a copy of the statement referred to and described in subdivision (a).
(c)Deliver to the person making any payment to the broker to be retained by the broker, a plain and complete receipt for each payment made, at the time it is made, showing the total amount received, and identifying the brokerage agreement and the loan contract upon which the payment is applied. If the payment is made by a person other than the finance lender, a copy of the receipt shall be delivered to the finance lender.
(d)Deliver to the potential borrower or borrowers, at the time the licensee first requires or accepts any signed instrument or the payment of any fee, a statement showing in clear and distinct terms the name, address, and license number of the broker and finance lender.
SEC. 8.SEC. 10.Section 22338.5 is added to the Financial Code, to read:22338.5.(a)A licensed broker shall obtain a prospective borrowers express consent before performing an act described in paragraph (1) or (2) of subdivision (a) of Section 22004. A licensed broker shall be deemed to be in compliance with this subdivision if the broker obtained the consent of the prospective borrower before the operative date of the act adding this section and that consent was not revoked.
(b)Before obtaining a prospective borrowers express consent under subdivision (a), each licensed broker shall provide to the prospective borrower a statement in a clear and conspicuous manner that provides all of the following:
(1)Identifies the name and license number of each finance lender to whom the prospective borrower may be referred by the licensed broker.
(2)Identifies the name and contact information of any person who is not a finance lender to whom the prospective borrower may be referred by the licensed broker.
(3)Discloses whether the compensation that would be paid by each finance lender to whom the prospective borrower is referred by the licensed broker is contingent on the making of a loan to the prospective borrower and whether the compensation varies based on the principal amount of the loan or the charges provided by the loan agreement.
(4)Discloses that lenders to whom the prospective borrower is referred are not necessarily the best lending options available to the prospective borrower.
(5)Discloses that lenders to whom the prospective borrower is referred may separately contact the prospective borrower.
(6)Provides a statement substantially similar to the following:
If you wish to report a complaint about our services, the services of any entity with which you interacted in connection with this loan, you may contact the Department of Business Oversight at 866-275-2677 or file a complaint online at www.dbo.ca.gov.
(7)Affirms that the licensed broker will not charge the prospective borrower a fee for the referral.
(c)A licensed broker who provides the statement described in subdivision (b) shall have prospective borrowers acknowledge receipt of the statement.
(d)For purposes of this section:
(1)Clear and conspicuous means the following:
(A)If the statement is provided in text, that the text is at least 10-point size, is not obscured by techniques such as graphical displays, shading, coloration, or other devices, and is not displayed in a manner that impedes the prospective borrowers ability to notice and comprehend the text.
(B)If the statement is an oral statement, whether provided by telephone or other medium, that the statement is given at a speed and volume sufficient for a prospective borrower to hear and comprehend the disclosure.
(2)Confidential data has the same meaning as defined in subdivision (b) of Section 22004.
SEC. 9.SEC. 11.Section 22348 is added to the Financial Code, to read:22348.(a)A licensed broker who compensates unlicensed persons for referrals that would have required the unlicensed person to obtain a license under paragraph (1) or (2) of subdivision (a) of Section 22004 had those referrals been made to a licensed finance lender shall develop, implement, and enforce policies and procedures intended to:
(1)Identify and correct any business practices maintained by those unlicensed persons that would violate this division if those business practices were maintained by the licensed broker.
(2)Identify and correct any statements, representations, or acts made by those unlicensed persons that would violate Section 22161 if those statements, representations, or acts were made by the licensed broker.
(3)Ensure that the licensed broker receives and monitors complaints by prospective borrowers regarding those unlicensed persons.
(4)Ensure that those unlicensed persons provide to prospective borrowers the unlicensed person that collects confidential data directly from a prospective borrower provides the prospective borrower a disclosure that includes the following:
(A)An explanation of the process for how the confidential data of a prospective borrower may be viewed by, used by, or transferred between other unlicensed persons and that the confidential data may ultimately be provided to a licensed broker for the purpose of making a referral to a finance lender.
(B)An explanation of how the unlicensed person engages in the process described in subparagraph (A).
(C)An explanation of how the unlicensed person will and other unlicensed persons that may view, use, or transfer the prospective borrowers confidential data may use the prospective borrowers confidential data of a prospective borrower to identify a finance lender that may offer a loan to the prospective borrower.
(5)Ensure that those unlicensed persons shall not collect confidential data directly from a prospective borrower for the purpose of referring a prospective borrower to the licensed broker without first obtaining the prospective borrowers express consent for that purpose. Express consent provided by a prospective borrower to one unlicensed person may be used to satisfy the requirement that another unlicensed person or persons obtain that prospective borrowers express consent for purposes of this paragraph, if both of the following conditions are met:
(A)The prospective borrower authorizes the use of his or her confidential data by multiple persons.
(B)The persons who rely on that express consent engage only in the specific acts authorized by the prospective borrower when he or she provides his or her express consent.
(6)Ensure that the licensed broker does not pay compensation to any of those unlicensed persons for referrals made in a manner that would have violated this division if the licensed broker had made the referral to a finance lender. However, a licensed broker is not required to ensure that an unlicensed person provide the disclosure required pursuant to Section 22338.5.
(7)Ensure that the broker ceases any relationship with those unlicensed persons who demonstrate repeated, uncorrected failures to adhere to the brokers policies and procedures.
(b)A licensed broker that violates subdivision (a) on the basis that the licensed broker failed to develop, implement, and enforce policies and procedures that would prevent an unlicensed person from engaging in acts that would be a violation of this division if that person was licensed shall be deemed to be in violation of any provision of this division or any regulation rule or order adopted pursuant to this division to the same extent as the unlicensed person would have been in violation had that person been a licensed broker.
(c)A licensed broker is not in violation of subdivision (a) or (b) solely for the reason that an unlicensed person commits isolated acts that are in violation of this chapter.
(c)(d)A licensed broker shall conspicuously post the policies and procedures required by subdivision (a) in the place of business authorized by the license. If a licensed broker conducts activity under its broker license on an Internet Web site, the licensed broker shall conspicuously post the policies and procedures on its Internet Web site.
(d)A licensed broker is not in violation of subdivision (a) or (b) solely for the reason that an unlicensed person commits isolated acts that are in violation of this chapter.(e)A licensed broker who compensates unlicensed persons described in subdivision (a) shall maintain books and records documenting the identities of both of the following:
(1)All unlicensed persons the broker compensates for referrals.
(2)All unlicensed persons with whom the broker severs a business relationship due to the repeated, uncorrected failure of the unlicensed person to adhere to the brokers policies and procedures.
SEC. 10.SEC. 12.Section 22602 of the Financial Code is amended to read:22602.(a)Notwithstanding subdivision (c) of Section 22100, a licensed finance lender may pay compensation to a person that is not licensed pursuant to this division in connection with a referral as described in paragraphs (1) and (2) of subdivision (a) of Section 22004 of one or more prospective borrowers to the licensee, when all of the following conditions are met:
(1)The referral by the unlicensed person leads to the consummation of a commercial loan, as defined in Section 22502, between the licensee and the prospective borrower referred by the unlicensed person.
(2)The commercial loan contract provides for an annual percentage rate that does not exceed 36 percent.
(3)Before approving the commercial loan, the licensee does both of the following:
(A)Obtains documentation from the prospective borrower documenting the borrowers commercial status. Examples of acceptable forms of documentation include, but are not limited to, a sellers permit, business license, articles of incorporation, income tax returns showing business income, or bank account statements showing business income.
(B)Performs underwriting and obtains documentation to ensure that the prospective borrower will have sufficient monthly gross revenue with which to repay the loan pursuant to the loan terms, and does not make a loan if it determines through its underwriting that the prospective borrowers total monthly expenses, including debt service payments on the loan for which the prospective borrower is being considered, will exceed the prospective borrowers monthly gross revenue. Examples of acceptable forms of documentation for verifying current and projected gross monthly revenue and monthly expenses include, but are not limited to, tax returns, bank statements, merchant financial statements, business plans, business history, and industry-specific knowledge and experience. If the prospective borrower is a sole proprietor or a corporation and the loan will be secured by a personal guarantee provided by the owner of the corporation, a credit report from at least one consumer credit reporting agency that compiles and maintains files on consumers on a nationwide basis shall also be considered.
(4)The licensee maintains records of all compensation paid to unlicensed persons in connection with the referral of borrowers for a period of at least four years.
(5)The licensee annually submits information requested by the commissioner regarding the payment of compensation in the report required pursuant to Section 22159.
(b)This section does not authorize an unlicensed person to perform any of the activities described in paragraphs (3) to (7), inclusive, of subdivision (a) of Section 22004, unless the person meets one or more of the following criteria:
(1)Is exempt from licensure under this division.
(2)Is exempt from federal income taxes under Section 501(c)(3) of the Internal Revenue Code.
(3)Is a business assistance organization recognized by the United States Small Business Administration.
(4)Is engaged in one or more of the activities described in paragraphs (3) to (7), inclusive, of subdivision (a) of Section 22004 in connection with five or fewer commercial loans in a calendar year made by persons licensed under this division.
(c)The commissioner may adopt regulations under this section to impose conditions on the referral activity authorized under this section. The commissioner may classify persons, loans, loan terms, referral methods, and other matters within his or her jurisdiction, and may prescribe different requirements for different classes of loans.
(d)Nothing in this section shall authorize the payment of a referral or lead fee to an unlicensed person for a residential mortgage loan, nor the payment of a referral or lead fee to a person required to be licensed under Section 10131 or 10131.1 of the Business and Professions Code, unless that person is licensed by the Bureau of Real Estate pursuant to Division 4 (commencing with Section 10000) of the Business and Professions Code.
(e)Notwithstanding subdivision (c) of Section 22100, a licensed finance lender may, pursuant to this section, pay compensation to an unlicensed person to provide services described in subdivision (c) of Section 22004. A licensed finance lender that pays compensation pursuant to this subdivision shall not be subject to the requirements of paragraphs (1) through (5), inclusive, of subdivision (a).
SEC. 11.SEC. 13.Section 22604 of the Financial Code is amended to read:22604.(a)Any person that receives compensation pursuant to subdivision (a) or (e) of Section 22602 shall not do any of the following:
(1)Make a materially false or misleading statement or representation to a prospective borrower about the terms or conditions of a prospective loan.
(2)Advertise, print, display, publish, distribute, or broadcast any statement or representation with regard to the conditions for making or negotiating a loan that is false, misleading, or deceptive, or that omits material information that is necessary to make the statements made not false, misleading, or deceptive.
(3)Engage in any act in violation of Section 17200 of the Business and Professions Code.
(4)Commit an act that constitutes fraud or dishonest dealings.
(5)Fail to safeguard a prospective borrowers confidential data, as defined in subdivision (b) of Section 22004.
(b)In addition to the prohibitions set forth in subdivision (a), a person who receives compensation pursuant to subdivision (a) of Section 22602 shall comply with both of the following:
(1)Shall not collect a prospective borrowers confidential data, as defined in subdivision (b) of Section 22004, for the purpose of performing an act described in paragraph (1) or (2) of subdivision (a) of Section 22004 without first obtaining the prospective borrowers express consent for that purpose.
(2)Shall, before making the referral, provide the prospective borrower with a written disclosure that shows in clear and distinct terms, the method of compensation provided by the licensed finance lender to that person, including whether the compensation is based on the size of the loan or contingent upon the referral or lead resulting in a consummated loan.
(c)Whenever, in the opinion of the commissioner, any person who receives compensation pursuant to subdivision (a) or (e) of Section 22602, violates this section or any other provision of this division authorizing such activity or exempting the person from this division, the commissioner may order the person to desist and to refrain from engaging in the business or further violating this division.
SEC. 12.SEC. 14.Section 22701 of the Financial Code, as added by Section 75 of Chapter 475 of the Statutes of 2017, is amended to read:22701.(a)(1)The commissioner shall, at least once every 48 months, and as often as the commissioner deems necessary and appropriate, examine the affairs of each finance lender, broker, or program administrator licensee for compliance with this division. The commissioner may, as often as the commissioner deems necessary and appropriate, examine the books, accounts, records, and files used in the business of every person engaged in the business of a finance lender, broker, or program administrator, whether the person acts or claims to act as principal or agent, or under or without the authority of this division in order to discover violations of this division or to secure information required in order to enforce the division. The commissioner shall appoint suitable persons to perform the examination. For the purpose of examination, the commissioner and his or her representatives shall have free access to the offices and places of business, books, accounts, papers, records, documents, files, safes, and vaults of all these persons, and may examine the officers, directors, and employees of the person being examined, under oath, regarding the persons operations.
(2)In conducting the examination described in paragraph (1), the commissioner may cooperate with any agency of the state or federal government. The commissioner may accept an examination conducted by a state or federal agency in place of the mandatory 48-month examination required by paragraph (1), unless the commissioner determines that the examination conducted by the state or federal agency does not provide information necessary to enable the commissioner to fulfill his or her responsibilities under this division.
(b)After conducting an examination described in subdivision (a), the commissioner shall do all the following:
(1)Provide Prepare a written statement of the findings of the examination.
(2)Issue a copy of that statement to each licensees principals, officers, or directors.
(3)Take appropriate steps to ensure correction of any violations of this division.
(c)The commissioner may subject an affiliate of a licensee to examination on the same terms as the licensee, but only when reports from, or examination of, a licensee provides documented evidence of unlawful activity between a licensee and the affiliate benefiting, affecting, benefitting or affecting the licensee or the affiliate or arising from the activities regulated by this division.
(d)This section shall become operative on January 1, 2019.
SEC. 13.SEC. 15.No reimbursement is required by this act pursuant to Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution because the only costs that may be incurred by a local agency or school district will be incurred because this act creates a new crime or infraction, eliminates a crime or infraction, or changes the penalty for a crime or infraction, within the meaning of Section 17556 of the Government Code, or changes the definition of a crime within the meaning of Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution.
(a)Broker includes any person who is engaged in the business of performing any of the following acts in connection with loans made by a finance lender, unless that person is otherwise exempt from this division pursuant to Section 22050:
(1)Transmitting confidential data about a prospective borrower to a finance lender with the expectation of compensation, in connection with making a referral. However, a licensed finance lender that transmits confidential data to another licensed finance lender as described in this paragraph in connection with the denial of a loan application shall be deemed to not be a broker within the meaning of this paragraph if the licensee does both of the following before transmitting the confidential data:
(A)Provides the prospective borrower a clear and conspicuous written statement that discloses that the licensee either may be compensated by the finance lender for transmitting the confidential data, or, if applicable, will be compensated by the finance lender if the transmittal results in a funded loan. The licensee shall have the prospective borrower acknowledge receipt of the statement. The form of the statement shall comply with paragraph (1) of subdivision (c) of Section 22337.5.
(B)After the prospective borrower acknowledges receipt of the written disclosure statement, obtains the prospective borrowers affirmative approval express consent to transmit the confidential data.
(2)Making a referral to a finance lender under an agreement with the finance lender that any prospective borrower referred by the person to the finance lender meet certain criteria involving confidential data and with the expectation that the person making the referral will be compensated if the finance lender and the prospective borrower enter into a loan agreement. However, a licensed finance lender that makes a referral to another licensed finance lender as described in this paragraph in connection with the denial of a loan application shall be deemed to not be a broker within the meaning of this paragraph if the licensee does both of the following before making the referral:
(A)Provides the prospective borrower a clear and conspicuous written statement that discloses that the licensee either may be compensated by the finance lender for making the referral, or, if applicable, will be compensated by the finance lender if the referral results in a funded loan. The licensee shall have the prospective borrower acknowledge receipt of the statement. The form of the statement shall comply with paragraph (1) of subdivision (c) of Section 22337.5.
(B)After the prospective borrower acknowledges receipt of the written disclosure statement, obtains the prospective borrowers affirmative approval express consent to make the referral.
(3)Participating in any loan negotiation between a finance lender and prospective borrower.
(4)Counseling, advising, or making recommendations to a prospective borrower about a loan based on the prospective borrowers confidential data.
(5)Participating in the preparation of any loan documents, including loan applications, other than providing a prospective borrower blank copies of loan documents. Transmitting information that is not confidential data to a finance lender at the request of a prospective borrower shall not, by itself, constitute participation in the preparation of loan documents.
(6)Communicating to a prospective borrower a finance lenders loan approval decisions involving confidential data.
(7)Charging a fee to a prospective borrower for any services related to a prospective borrowers application for a loan from a finance lender.
(b)(1)For purposes of this section, confidential data includes any of means the following:
(A)Bank account number.
(B)Bank statement.
(C)Credit or debit card account number.
(D)Credit score, as defined in subdivision (b) of Section 1785.15.1 of the Civil Code, either self-reported by the person it relates to, or received from a credit reporting agency as part of an official request.
(E)Social security number, including both a persons full social security number or a partial number.
(F)Personal or business income information, including information self-reported by the person.
(G)Drivers license number or government-issued Government-issued identification number.
(H)Passport number.(I)(H)Personal employment data or history.
(J)(I)Date of birth.
(K)(J)Mothers maiden name.
(L)(K)Medical information.
(M)(L)Health insurance information.
(N)(M)Insurance policy number.
(O)(N)Taxpayer or employer identification number.
(2)The term confidential data does not include any of the following:
(A)Name.
(B)Phone number.
(C)Physical address.
(D)Email address.
(E)Desired loan or financing amount.
(F)Borrowers Prospective borrowers stated purpose for a loan.
(G)Prospective borrowers self-reported range of credit scores or range of incomes.
(G)(H)In connection with a commercial loan, confidential data does not include a businesss name, address, phone number, email address, self-reported income, self-reported credit score of a business owner, or a businesss desired loan or financing amount, in addition to the other information listed in this paragraph.
(c)A person shall not be deemed a broker if both of the following are met:
(1)The person distributes or otherwise disseminates to a prospective borrower a finance lenders marketing materials or factual information about the finance lender, its lending activities, or its loan products, such as the finance lenders interest rates, minimum or maximum loan amounts or loan periods, or a general description of the finance lenders underwriting criteria.
(2)The person does not perform any of the acts specified in subdivision (a).
(d)This section does not apply to any person who performs the acts described in subdivision (a) five or fewer times in a calendar year.
SEC. 2.Section 22010.5 is added to the Financial Code, to read:22010.5.Referral means the introduction of a prospective borrower to a licensee finance lender or the delivery of a prospective borrowers contact information to a finance lender for the purposes of making an introduction.
SEC. 3.Section 22050.1 is added to the Financial Code, to read:22050.1.Nothing in this division shall be interpreted to impose licensing or regulatory obligations on federally recognized Indian tribes or business entities that are considered arms of a tribe, under the test articulated in People ex rel. Owen v. Miami Nation Enterprises (2016) 2 Cal.5th 222 and any superseding case law.
SEC. 4.Section 22100 of the Financial Code is amended to read:22100.(a)A person shall not engage in the business of a finance lender or broker without obtaining a license from the commissioner.
(b)Every licensee engaging in the business of making or brokering residential mortgage loans shall require that every mortgage loan originator employed or compensated by that licensee obtains and maintains a mortgage loan originator license from the commissioner under this division or Division 20 (commencing with Section 50000), or has first obtained a license endorsement from the Commissioner of Real Estate pursuant to Article 2.1 (commencing with Section 10166.01) of Chapter 3 of Part 1 of Division 4 of the Business and Professions Code.
(c)Except as provided in subdivisions (a), (b), and (e) of Section 22602, a finance lender shall not compensate a person for any of the acts described in subdivision (a) of Section 22004 unless that person is a licensed broker or is not required to be licensed as a broker pursuant to this division.
(d)A licensed broker shall not collect confidential data, as defined in subdivision (b) of Section 22004, for the purpose of performing perform an act described in subdivision (a) of Section 22004 without first obtaining the prospective borrowers affirmative authorization express consent for that purpose. A licensed broker shall be deemed to be in compliance with this subdivision if the broker obtained the consent of the prospective borrower before the operative date of the act adding this subdivision and that consent was not revoked.
(e)A licensed finance lender shall not compensate a broker for an act described in paragraph (1) or (2) of subdivision (a) of Section 22004 if the finance lender has actual knowledge at the time the compensation is to be made that the broker has committed any violation of Section 22161 this division in connection with that loan.
(f)A licensed finance lender shall not, in connection with any loan subject to this division for which the finance lender paid or would pay a referral fee, charge a borrower more for the loan than the finance lender would have charged the borrower if the finance lender did not pay or would not be paying a referral fee. pass through an additional fee attributable to the referral fee. However, a licensed finance lender may charge a borrower additional fees or costs attributable to the performance of any of the acts described in paragraphs (3) to (7), inclusive, of subdivision (a) of Section 22004 if the finance lender pays another person or entity for performing any of those acts for a loan made pursuant to this division.
(g)A finance lender or broker shall not employ a mortgage loan originator whose license or license endorsement has lapsed.
(h)A finance lender or broker may not make or broker a residential mortgage loan unless that loan is offered by, negotiated by, or applied for through a licensed mortgage loan originator.
(i)Every licensee engaged in the business of making or brokering residential mortgage loans and every mortgage loan originator licensed under this division shall register with and maintain a valid unique identifier issued by the Nationwide Mortgage Licensing System and Registry.
(j)An individual shall not engage in the business of a mortgage loan originator with respect to any dwelling located in this state without first obtaining and maintaining annually a license in accordance with the requirements of this division and any rules promulgated by the commissioner under this chapter.
(k)A registered mortgage loan originator, as defined in subdivision (c) of Section 22013, is exempt from licensure under this section when he or she is employed by:
(1)A depository institution.
(2)A subsidiary of a depository institution that is owned and controlled by a depository institution and regulated by a federal banking agency.
(3)An institution regulated by the Farm Credit Administration.
SEC. 5.Section 22337 of the Financial Code is amended to read:22337.Each licensed finance lender shall:
(a)Deliver or cause to be delivered to the borrower, or any one thereof, at the time the loan is made, a statement showing in clear and distinct terms the name, address, and license number of the finance lender and the broker, if any. The statement shall show the date, amount, and maturity of the loan contract, how and when repayable, the nature of the security for the loan, if any, and the agreed rate of charge or the annual percentage rate pursuant to Regulation Z promulgated by the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (12 C.F.R. 1026).
(b)Except in connection with an act described in paragraph (1) or (2) of subdivision (a) of Section 22004, obtain from the borrower a signed statement as to whether any person has performed any act as a broker in connection with the making of the loan. If the statement discloses that a broker or other person has participated, then the finance lender shall obtain a full statement of all sums paid or payable to the broker or other person. person by the borrower, if any. The finance lender shall keep these statements for a period of three years from and after the date the loan has been paid in full, or has matured according to its terms, or has been charged off.
(c)Permit payment to be made in advance in any amount on any contract of loan at any time. The licensee may apply the payment first to any agreed prepayment penalty, then to all charges due, including charges at the agreed rate or rates up to the date of payment, not to exceed the applicable maximum rate permitted by this article.
(d)Deliver or cause to be delivered to the person making any cash payment, or to the person who requests a receipt at the time of making any payment, at the time payment is made on account of any loan, a plain and complete receipt showing the total amount received and identifying the loan contract upon which the payment is applied.
(e)Upon repayment of any loan in full, release all security for the loan, endorse and return any certificate of ownership, and cancel or plainly mark paid and return to the borrower or person making final payment, any note, mortgage, security agreement, trust deed, assignment, or order signed by the borrower, or an optical image reproduction thereof, except those documents that are a part of the court record in any action, or that have been delivered to a third person for the purpose of carrying out their terms, or a security agreement that secures any other indebtedness of a borrower to the licensee, or original documents otherwise required by law. When a trust deed on real property has been taken as security for a loan that has been subsequently paid in full, a duly executed request for reconveyance shall be delivered to the trustor or trustee for the purpose of recording a reconveyance. A termination statement, furnished to the borrower as provided for in Sections 9512 and 9513 of the Commercial Code, shall be deemed a release of the security when a financing statement has been filed pursuant to Section 9501 of the Commercial Code.
For purposes of this subdivision, an optical image reproduction shall meet all of the following requirements:
(1)The optical image storage media used to store the document shall be nonerasable write once, read many (WORM) optical image media that does not allow changes to the stored document.
(2)The optical image reproduction shall be made consistent with the minimum standards of quality approved by either the National Institute of Standards and Technology or the Association for Information and Image Management.
(3)Written authentication identifying the optical image reproduction as an exact unaltered copy of the note, trust deed, mortgage, security agreement, assignment, or order shall be stamped or printed on the optical image reproduction.
(f)Deliver or cause to be delivered to the potential borrower, or any one thereof, at the time the licensee first requires or accepts any signed instrument or the payment of any fee, a statement showing in clear and distinct terms the name, address, and license number of the finance lender and the broker, if any.
SEC. 6.Section 22337.5 is added to the Financial Code, to read:22337.5.(a)A licensed finance lender, after receiving a referral from a broker as described in paragraph (1) or (2) of subdivision (a) of Section 22004 and before the prospective borrower affirmatively assents to the loan, Before making a loan to a prospective borrower who was referred by a licensed broker through an act described in paragraph (1) or (2) of subdivision (a) of Section 22004, and before the prospective borrowers express consent to the loan, the licensed finance lender shall provide to the prospective borrower a statement in a clear and conspicuous manner that provides all of the following:
(1)Identifies the name and license number of the broker who referred the prospective borrower.
(2)Discloses that the finance lender may pay a fee to the broker who referred the prospective borrower for the referral.
(3)Affirms that the prospective borrower will not be charged more for a loan by the finance lender because of the fact that the finance lender may pay a fee to the broker who referred the prospective borrower for the referral.(3)Affirms that, if the licensed finance lender pays a fee for a referral, the licensed finance lender will not pass through to the prospective borrower an additional fee attributable to the referral fee. However, the licensed finance lender may charge a borrower additional fees or costs as described in subdivision (f) of Section 22100.
(4)Affirms that the prospective borrower should not be charged a fee by the broker who referred the prospective borrower to the licensed finance lender. lender for a referral described in paragraph (1) or (2) of subdivision (a) of Section 22004.
(5)Affirms that the finance lender, not the broker who referred the prospective borrower, is the party authorized to make a loan to the prospective borrower.
(6)Provides a statement substantially similar to the following:
If you wish to report a complaint about the manner in which you were referred to us, you may contact the Department of Business Oversight at 866-275-2677 or file a complaint online at www.dbo.ca.gov.
(b)A licensed finance lender who provides the statement described in subdivision (a) shall have prospective borrowers acknowledge receipt of the statement.
(c)For purposes of this section, clear and conspicuous means either of the following:
(1)If the statement is provided in text, that the text is at least 10-point size, is not obscured by techniques such as graphical displays, shading, coloration, or other devices, and is displayed in a manner that allows a prospective borrower to read the text.
(2)If the statement is an oral statement, whether provided by telephone or other medium, that the statement is given at a speed and volume sufficient for a prospective borrower to hear and comprehend the disclosure.
SEC. 7.Section 22338 of the Financial Code is amended to read:22338.Except in connection with an act described in paragraph (1) or (2) of subdivision (a) of Section 22004, In connection with any of the acts described in paragraphs (3) to (7), inclusive, of subdivision (a) of Section 22004, each licensed broker shall:
(a)Deliver to the borrower, or any one thereof, at the time the final negotiation or arrangement is made, a statement showing in clear and distinct terms the name, address, and license number of the broker and the finance lender. The statement shall show the date, amount, and terms of the agreement with the broker, and all amounts paid or to be paid to the broker by the prospective borrower and to any person other than the finance lender.
(b)Deliver to the finance lender making the loan a copy of the statement referred to and described in subdivision (a).
(c)Deliver to the person making any payment to the broker to be retained by the broker, a plain and complete receipt for each payment made, at the time it is made, showing the total amount received, and identifying the brokerage agreement and the loan contract upon which the payment is applied. If the payment is made by a person other than the finance lender, a copy of the receipt shall be delivered to the finance lender.
(d)When the borrower pays the loan in full, ensure that the finance lender fully complies with subdivision (e) of Section 22337.(e)(d)Deliver to the potential borrower or borrowers, at the time the licensee first requires or accepts any signed instrument or the payment of any fee, a statement showing in clear and distinct terms the name, address, and license number of the broker and finance lender.
SEC. 8.Section 22338.5 is added to the Financial Code, to read:22338.5.(a)A licensed broker shall obtain a prospective borrowers affirmative authorization express consent before collecting the prospective borrowers confidential data for the purpose of performing an act described in paragraph (1) or (2) of subdivision (a) of Section 22004 that does not also constitute any of the acts described in paragraphs (3) to (7), inclusive, of subdivision (a) of Section 22004. 22004. A licensed broker shall be deemed to be in compliance with this subdivision if the broker obtained the consent of the prospective borrower before the operative date of the act adding this section and that consent was not revoked.
(b)Before obtaining a prospective borrowers authorization express consent under subdivision (a), each licensed broker shall provide to the prospective borrower a statement in a clear and conspicuous manner that provides all of the following:
(1)Identifies the name and license number of each finance lender to whom the prospective borrower may be referred by the licensed broker.
(2)Identifies the name and contact information of any person who is not a finance lender to whom the prospective borrower may be referred by the licensed broker.
(3)Discloses the method by which whether the compensation that would be paid by each finance lender to whom the prospective borrower is referred by the licensed broker will compute the compensation paid to the licensed broker for a referral, including whether the compensation varies based on the loan amount and whether the compensation is contingent on the making of a loan to the prospective borrower. borrower and whether the compensation varies based on the principal amount of the loan or the charges provided by the loan agreement.
(4)Discloses that lenders to whom the prospective borrower is referred are not necessarily the best lending options available to the prospective borrower.
(5)Discloses that lenders to whom the prospective borrower is referred may separately contact the prospective borrower.
(6)Provides a statement substantially similar to the following:
If you wish to report a complaint about our services, you may contact the Department of Business Oversight at 866-275-2677 or file a complaint online at www.dbo.ca.gov.
(7)Affirms that the licensed broker will not charge the prospective borrower a fee for the referral.
(c)A licensed broker who provides the statement described in subdivision (b) shall have prospective borrowers acknowledge receipt of the statement.
(d)For purposes of this section:
(1)Clear and conspicuous means the following:
(A)If the statement is provided in text, that the text is at least 10-point size, is not obscured by techniques such as graphical displays, shading, coloration, or other devices, and is not displayed in a manner that allows a prospective borrower to read the text. impedes the prospective borrowers ability to notice and comprehend the text.
(B)If the statement is an oral statement, whether provided by telephone or other medium, that the statement is given at a speed and volume sufficient for a prospective borrower to hear and comprehend the disclosure.
(2)Confidential data has the same meaning as defined in subdivision (b) of Section 22004.
SEC. 9.Section 22348 is added to the Financial Code, to read:22348.(a)A licensed broker who compensates unlicensed persons for referrals that would have required the unlicensed person to obtain a license under paragraph (1) or (2) of subdivision (a) of Section 22004 had those referrals been made to a licensed finance lender shall develop, implement, and enforce policies and procedures intended to:
(1)Identify and correct any business practices maintained by those unlicensed persons that would violate this division if those business practices were maintained by the licensed broker.
(2)Identify and correct any statements, representations, or acts made by those unlicensed persons that would violate Section 22161 if those statements, representations, or acts were made by the licensed broker.
(3)Ensure that the licensed broker receives and monitors complaints by prospective borrowers regarding those unlicensed persons.
(4)Ensure that those unlicensed persons provide to prospective borrowers a disclosure that includes the following:
(A)An explanation of the process for how the confidential data of a prospective borrower may be viewed by, used by, or transferred between other unlicensed persons and that the confidential data may ultimately be provided to a licensed broker for the purpose of making a referral to a finance lender.
(B)An explanation of how the unlicensed person engages in the process described in subparagraph (A).
(C)An explanation of how the unlicensed person will use the confidential data of a prospective borrower to identify a finance lender that may offer a loan to the prospective borrower.
(4)(5)Ensure that those unlicensed persons shall not collect a prospective borrowers confidential data, as defined in subdivision (b) of Section 22004, data directly from a prospective borrower for the purpose of referring a prospective borrower to the licensed broker without first obtaining the prospective borrowers affirmative authorization express consent for that purpose.
(5)(6)Ensure that the licensed broker does not pay compensation to any of those unlicensed persons for referrals made in a manner that would have violated this division if the licensed broker had made the referral to a finance lender. However, a licensed broker is not required to ensure that an unlicensed person provide the disclosure required pursuant to Section 22338.5.
(6)(7)Ensure that the broker ceases any relationship with those unlicensed persons who demonstrate repeated, uncorrected failures to adhere to the brokers policies and procedures.
(b)A licensed broker that violates subdivision (a) on the basis that the licensed broker failed to develop, implement, and enforce policies and procedures that would prevent an unlicensed person from engaging in acts that would be a violation of this division if that person was licensed shall be deemed to be in violation of any provision of this division or any regulation adopted pursuant to this division to the same extent as the unlicensed person would have been in violation had that person been a licensed broker.
(c)A licensed broker shall conspicuously post the policies and procedures required by subdivision (a) in the place of business authorized by the license. If a licensed broker conducts activity under its broker license on an Internet Web site, the licensed broker shall conspicuously post the policies and procedures on its Internet Web site.
(d)A licensed broker is not in violation of subdivision (a) or (b) solely for the reason that an unlicensed person commits isolated acts that are in violation of this chapter.
SEC. 10.Section 22602 of the Financial Code is amended to read:22602.(a)Notwithstanding subdivision (c) of Section 22100, a licensed finance lender may pay compensation to a person that is not licensed pursuant to this division in connection with a referral as described in paragraphs (1) and (2) of subdivision (a) of Section 22004 of one or more prospective borrowers to the licensee, when all of the following conditions are met:
(1)The referral by the unlicensed person leads to the consummation of a commercial loan, as defined in Section 22502, between the licensee and the prospective borrower referred by the unlicensed person.
(2)The commercial loan contract provides for an annual percentage rate that does not exceed 36 percent.
(3)Before approving the commercial loan, the licensee does both of the following:
(A)Obtains documentation from the prospective borrower documenting the borrowers commercial status. Examples of acceptable forms of documentation include, but are not limited to, a sellers permit, business license, articles of incorporation, income tax returns showing business income, or bank account statements showing business income.
(B)Performs underwriting and obtains documentation to ensure that the prospective borrower will have sufficient monthly gross revenue with which to repay the loan pursuant to the loan terms, and does not make a loan if it determines through its underwriting that the prospective borrowers total monthly expenses, including debt service payments on the loan for which the prospective borrower is being considered, will exceed the prospective borrowers monthly gross revenue. Examples of acceptable forms of documentation for verifying current and projected gross monthly revenue and monthly expenses include, but are not limited to, tax returns, bank statements, merchant financial statements, business plans, business history, and industry-specific knowledge and experience. If the prospective borrower is a sole proprietor or a corporation and the loan will be secured by a personal guarantee provided by the owner of the corporation, a credit report from at least one consumer credit reporting agency that compiles and maintains files on consumers on a nationwide basis shall also be considered.
(4)The licensee maintains records of all compensation paid to unlicensed persons in connection with the referral of borrowers for a period of at least four years.
(5)The licensee annually submits information requested by the commissioner regarding the payment of compensation in the report required pursuant to Section 22159.
(b)This section does not authorize an unlicensed person to perform any of the activities described in paragraphs (3) to (7), inclusive, of subdivision (a) of Section 22004, unless the person meets one or more of the following criteria:
(1)Is exempt from licensure under this division.
(2)Is exempt from federal income taxes under Section 501(c)(3) of the Internal Revenue Code.
(3)Is a business assistance organization recognized by the United States Small Business Administration.
(4)Is engaged in one or more of the activities described in paragraphs (3) to (7), inclusive, of subdivision (a) of Section 22004 in connection with five or fewer commercial loans in a calendar year made by persons licensed under this division.
(c)The commissioner may adopt regulations under this section to impose conditions on the referral activity authorized under this section. The commissioner may classify persons, loans, loan terms, referral methods, and other matters within his or her jurisdiction, and may prescribe different requirements for different classes of loans.
(d)Nothing in this section shall authorize the payment of a referral or lead fee to an unlicensed person for a residential mortgage loan, nor the payment of a referral or lead fee to a person required to be licensed under Section 10131 or 10131.1 of the Business and Professions Code, unless that person is licensed by the Bureau of Real Estate pursuant to Division 4 (commencing with Section 10000) of the Business and Professions Code.
(e)Notwithstanding subdivision (c) of Section 22100, a licensed finance lender may, pursuant to this section, pay compensation to an unlicensed person to provide services described in subdivision (c) of Section 22004. A licensed finance lender that pays compensation pursuant to this subdivision shall not be subject to the requirements of paragraphs (1) through (5), inclusive, of subdivision (a).
SEC. 11.Section 22604 of the Financial Code is amended to read:22604.(a)Any person that receives compensation pursuant to subdivision (a) or (e) of Section 22602 shall not do any of the following:
(1)Make a materially false or misleading statement or representation to a prospective borrower about the terms or conditions of a prospective loan.
(2)Advertise, print, display, publish, distribute, or broadcast any statement or representation with regard to the conditions for making or negotiating a loan that is false, misleading, or deceptive, or that omits material information that is necessary to make the statements made not false, misleading, or deceptive.
(3)Engage in any act in violation of Section 17200 of the Business and Professions Code.
(4)Commit an act that constitutes fraud or dishonest dealings.
(5)Fail to safeguard a prospective borrowers confidential data, as defined in subdivision (b) of Section 22004.
(b)In addition to the prohibitions set forth in subdivision (a), a person who receives compensation pursuant to subdivision (a) of Section 22602 shall comply with both of the following:
(1)Shall not collect a prospective borrowers confidential data, as defined in subdivision (b) of Section 22004, for the purpose of performing an act described in paragraph (1) or (2) of subdivision (a) of Section 22004 without first obtaining the prospective borrowers affirmative authorization express consent for that purpose.
(2)Shall, before making the referral, provide the prospective borrower with a written disclosure that shows in clear and distinct terms, the method of compensation provided by the licensed finance lender to that person, including whether the compensation is based on the size of the loan or contingent upon the referral or lead resulting in a consummated loan.
(c)Whenever, in the opinion of the commissioner, any person who receives compensation pursuant to subdivision (a) or (e) of Section 22602, violates this section or any other provision of this division authorizing such activity or exempting the person from this division, the commissioner may order the person to desist and to refrain from engaging in the business or further violating this division.
SEC. 12.Section 22701 of the Financial Code, as added by Section 75 of Chapter 475 of the Statutes of 2017, is amended to read:22701.(a)For the purpose of discovering violations of this division or securing information required by him or her in the administration and enforcement of this division, the commissioner may at any time investigate the loans, assessment contracts, and business, and (1)The commissioner shall, at least once every 48 months, and as often as the commissioner deems necessary and appropriate, examine the affairs of each finance lender, broker, or program administrator licensee for compliance with this division. The commissioner may, as often as the commissioner deems necessary and appropriate, examine the books, accounts, records, and files used in the business, business of every person engaged in the business of a finance lender, broker, or program administrator, whether the person acts or claims to act as principal or agent, or under or without the authority of this division. division in order to discover violations of this division or to secure information required in order to enforce the division. The commissioner shall appoint suitable persons to perform the examination. For the purpose of examination, the commissioner and his or her representatives shall have free access to the offices and places of business, books, accounts, papers, records, documents, files, safes, and vaults of all these persons. persons, and may examine the officers, directors, and employees of the person being examined, under oath, regarding the persons operations.
(2)In conducting the examination described in paragraph (1), the commissioner may cooperate with any agency of the state or federal government. The commissioner may accept an examination conducted by a state or federal agency in place of the mandatory 48-month examination required by paragraph (1), unless the commissioner determines that the examination conducted by the state or federal agency does not provide information necessary to enable the commissioner to fulfill his or her responsibilities under this division.
(b)After conducting an examination described in subdivision (a), the commissioner shall do all the following:
(1)Provide a written statement of the findings of the examination.
(2)Issue a copy of that statement to each licensees principals, officers, or directors.
(3)Take appropriate steps to ensure correction of any violations of this division.
(c)The commissioner may subject an affiliate of a licensee to examination on the same terms as the licensee, but only when reports from, or examination of, a licensee provides documented evidence of unlawful activity between a licensee and the affiliate benefiting, affecting, or arising from the activities regulated by this division.
(b)(d)This section shall become operative on January 1, 2019.
SEC. 12.SEC. 13.No reimbursement is required by this act pursuant to Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution because the only costs that may be incurred by a local agency or school district will be incurred because this act creates a new crime or infraction, eliminates a crime or infraction, or changes the penalty for a crime or infraction, within the meaning of Section 17556 of the Government Code, or changes the definition of a crime within the meaning of Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution.
(a)Broker includes any person who is engaged in the business of performing any of the following acts in connection with loans made by a finance lender, unless that person is otherwise exempt from this division pursuant to Section 22050:
(1)Transmitting confidential data about a prospective borrower to a finance lender with the expectation of compensation, in connection with making a referral. However, a licensed finance lender that transmits confidential data to another licensed finance lender as described in this paragraph in connection with the denial of a loan application shall be deemed to not be a broker within the meaning of this paragraph if the licensee does both of the following before transmitting the confidential data:
(A)Provides the prospective borrower a clear and conspicuous written statement that discloses that the licensee either may be compensated by the finance lender for transmitting the confidential data, or, if applicable, will be compensated by the finance lender if the transmittal results in a funded loan. The licensee shall have the prospective borrower acknowledge receipt of the statement. The form of the statement shall comply with paragraph (1) of subdivision (c) of Section 22337.5.
(B)After the prospective borrower acknowledges receipt of the written disclosure statement, obtains the prospective borrowers affirmative approval to transmit the confidential data.
(2)Making a referral to a finance lender under an agreement with the finance lender that any prospective borrower referred by the person to the finance lender meet certain criteria involving confidential data and with the expectation that the person making the referral will be compensated if the finance lender and the prospective borrower enter into a loan agreement. However, a licensed finance lender that makes a referral to another licensed finance lender as described in this paragraph in connection with the denial of a loan application shall be deemed to not be a broker within the meaning of this paragraph if the licensee does both of the following before making the referral:
(A)Provides the prospective borrower a clear and conspicuous written statement that discloses that the licensee either may be compensated by the finance lender for making the referral, or, if applicable, will be compensated by the finance lender if the referral results in a funded loan. The licensee shall have the prospective borrower acknowledge receipt of the statement. The form of the statement shall comply with paragraph (1) of subdivision (c) of Section 22337.5.
(B)After the prospective borrower acknowledges receipt of the written disclosure statement, obtains the prospective borrowers affirmative approval to make the referral.
(3)Participating in any loan negotiation between a finance lender and prospective borrower.
(4)Counseling, advising, or making recommendations to a prospective borrower about a loan based on the prospective borrowers confidential data.
(5)Participating in the preparation of any loan documents, including loan applications, other than providing a prospective borrower blank copies of loan documents. Transmitting information that is not confidential data to a finance lender at the request of a prospective borrower shall not, by itself, constitute participation in the preparation of loan documents.
(6)Communicating to a prospective borrower a finance lenders decisions or inquiries loan approval decisions involving confidential data.
(7)Charging a fee to a prospective borrower for any services related to a prospective borrowers application for a loan from a finance lender.
(b)(1)For purposes of this section, confidential data includes, but is not limited to, includes any of the following:
(A)Bank account number.
(B)Bank statement.
(C)Credit or debit card account number.
(D)Credit score, as defined in subdivision (b) of Section 1785.15.1 of the Civil Code, either self-reported by the person it relates to, or received from a credit reporting agency as part of an official request.
(E)Social security number, including both a persons full social security number or a partial number.
(F)Personal or business income information, including information self-reported by the person.
(G)Drivers license number or government-issued identification number.
(H)Passport number.
(I)Personal employment data or history.
(J)Date of birth.
(K)Mothers maiden name.
(L)Medical information.
(M)Health insurance information.
(N)Insurance policy number.
(O)Taxpayer or employer identification number.
(2)The term confidential data does not include any of the following:
(A)Name.
(B)Phone number.
(C)Physical address.
(D)Email address.
(E)Desired loan or financing amount.
(F)Borrowers stated purpose for a loan.
(G)In connection with a commercial loan, confidential data does not include a businesss name, address, phone number, email address, self-reported income, self-reported credit score of a business owner, or a businesss desired loan or financing amount, in addition to the other information listed in this paragraph.
(c)A person shall not be deemed a broker if both of the following are met:
(1)The person distributes or otherwise disseminates to a prospective borrower a finance lenders marketing materials or factual information about the finance lender, its lending activities, or its loan products, such as the finance lenders interest rates, minimum or maximum loan amounts or loan periods, or a general description of the finance lenders underwriting criteria.
(2)The person does not perform any of the acts specified in subdivision (a).
(d)This section does not apply to any person who performs the acts described in subdivision (a) five or fewer times in a calendar year.
SEC. 2.Section 22010.5 is added to the Financial Code, to read:22010.5.Referral means the introduction of a prospective borrower to a licensee or the delivery of a prospective borrowers contact information to a finance lender for the purposes of making an introduction.
SEC. 3.Section 22050.1 is added to the Financial Code, to read:22050.1.Nothing in this division shall be interpreted to impose licensing or regulatory obligations on federally recognized Indian tribes or business entities that are considered arms of a tribe, under the test articulated in People ex rel. Owen v. Miami Nation Enterprises (2016) 2 Cal.5th 222 and any superseding case law.
SEC. 3.SEC. 4.Section 22100 of the Financial Code is amended to read:22100.(a)A person shall not engage in the business of a finance lender or broker without obtaining a license from the commissioner.
(b)Every licensee engaging in the business of making or brokering residential mortgage loans shall require that every mortgage loan originator employed or compensated by that licensee obtains and maintains a mortgage loan originator license from the commissioner under this division or Division 20 (commencing with Section 50000), or has first obtained a license endorsement from the Commissioner of Real Estate pursuant to Article 2.1 (commencing with Section 10166.01) of Chapter 3 of Part 1 of Division 4 of the Business and Professions Code.
(c)Except as provided in subdivisions (a), (b), and (e) of Section 22602, a finance lender shall not compensate a person for any of the acts described in subdivision (a) of Section 22004 unless that person is a licensed broker pursuant to this division.
(d)A licensed broker shall not collect confidential data, as defined in subdivision (b) of Section 22004, for the purpose of performing an act described in subdivision (a) of Section 22004 without first obtaining the prospective borrowers affirmative authorization for that purpose.
(e)A licensed finance lender shall not compensate a broker for an act described in paragraph (1) or (2) of subdivision (a) of Section 22004 if the finance lender knows has actual knowledge at the time the compensation is to be made that the broker has committed any violation of Section 22161 in connection with that loan.
(f)A licensed finance lender shall not, in connection with any loan subject to this division for which the finance lender paid or would pay a referral fee, charge a borrower more for the loan than the finance lender would have charged the borrower if the finance lender did not pay or would not be paying a referral fee.
(g)A finance lender or broker shall not employ a mortgage loan originator whose license or license endorsement has lapsed.
(h)A finance lender or broker may not make or broker a residential mortgage loan unless that loan is offered by, negotiated by, or applied for through a licensed mortgage loan originator.
(i)Every licensee engaged in the business of making or brokering residential mortgage loans and every mortgage loan originator licensed under this division shall register with and maintain a valid unique identifier issued by the Nationwide Mortgage Licensing System and Registry.
(j)An individual shall not engage in the business of a mortgage loan originator with respect to any dwelling located in this state without first obtaining and maintaining annually a license in accordance with the requirements of this division and any rules promulgated by the commissioner under this chapter.
(k)A registered mortgage loan originator, as defined in subdivision (c) of Section 22013, is exempt from licensure under this section when he or she is employed by:
(1)A depository institution.
(2)A subsidiary of a depository institution that is owned and controlled by a depository institution and regulated by a federal banking agency.
(3)An institution regulated by the Farm Credit Administration.
SEC. 4.SEC. 5.Section 22337 of the Financial Code is amended to read:22337.Each licensed finance lender shall:
(a)Deliver or cause to be delivered to the borrower, or any one thereof, at the time the loan is made, a statement showing in clear and distinct terms the name, address, and license number of the finance lender and the broker, if any. The statement shall show the date, amount, and maturity of the loan contract, how and when repayable, the nature of the security for the loan, if any, and the agreed rate of charge or the annual percentage rate pursuant to Regulation Z promulgated by the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (12 C.F.R. 1026).
(b)Except in connection with an act described in paragraph (1) or (2) of subdivision (a) of Section 22004, obtain from the borrower a signed statement as to whether any person has performed any act as a broker in connection with the making of the loan. If the statement discloses that a broker or other person has participated, then the finance lender shall obtain a full statement of all sums paid or payable to the broker or other person. The finance lender shall keep these statements for a period of three years from and after the date the loan has been paid in full, or has matured according to its terms, or has been charged off.
(c)Permit payment to be made in advance in any amount on any contract of loan at any time. The licensee may apply the payment first to any agreed prepayment penalty, then to all charges due, including charges at the agreed rate or rates up to the date of payment, not to exceed the applicable maximum rate permitted by this article.
(d)Deliver or cause to be delivered to the person making any cash payment, or to the person who requests a receipt at the time of making any payment, at the time payment is made on account of any loan, a plain and complete receipt showing the total amount received and identifying the loan contract upon which the payment is applied.
(e)Upon repayment of any loan in full, release all security for the loan, endorse and return any certificate of ownership, and cancel or plainly mark paid and return to the borrower or person making final payment, any note, mortgage, security agreement, trust deed, assignment, or order signed by the borrower, or an optical image reproduction thereof, except those documents that are a part of the court record in any action, or that have been delivered to a third person for the purpose of carrying out their terms, or a security agreement that secures any other indebtedness of a borrower to the licensee, or original documents otherwise required by law. When a trust deed on real property has been taken as security for a loan that has been subsequently paid in full, a duly executed request for reconveyance shall be delivered to the trustor or trustee for the purpose of recording a reconveyance. A termination statement, furnished to the borrower as provided for in Sections 9512 and 9513 of the Commercial Code, shall be deemed a release of the security when a financing statement has been filed pursuant to Section 9501 of the Commercial Code.
For purposes of this subdivision, an optical image reproduction shall meet all of the following requirements:
(1)The optical image storage media used to store the document shall be nonerasable write once, read many (WORM) optical image media that does not allow changes to the stored document.
(2)The optical image reproduction shall be made consistent with the minimum standards of quality approved by either the National Institute of Standards and Technology or the Association for Information and Image Management.
(3)Written authentication identifying the optical image reproduction as an exact unaltered copy of the note, trust deed, mortgage, security agreement, assignment assignment, or order shall be stamped or printed on the optical image reproduction.
(f)Deliver or cause to be delivered to the potential borrower, or any one thereof, at the time the licensee first requires or accepts any signed instrument or the payment of any fee, a statement showing in clear and distinct terms the name, address, and license number of the finance lender and the broker, if any.
SEC. 5.SEC. 6.Section 22337.5 is added to the Financial Code, to read:22337.5.(a)A licensed finance lender, after receiving a referral from a broker as described in paragraph (1) or (2) of subdivision (a) of Section 22004 and before accepting an application from the prospective borrower referred by the broker, the prospective borrower affirmatively assents to the loan, shall provide to the prospective borrower a statement in a clear and conspicuous manner that provides all of the following:
(1)Identifies the name and license number of the broker who referred the prospective borrower.
(2)Discloses that the finance lender may pay a fee to the broker who referred the prospective borrower for the referral.
(3)Affirms that the prospective borrower will not be charged more for a loan by the finance lender because of the fact that the finance lender may pay a fee to the broker who referred the prospective borrower for the referral.
(4)Affirms that the prospective borrower should not be charged a fee by the broker who referred the prospective borrower to the licensed finance lender.
(5)Affirms that the finance lender, not the broker who referred the prospective borrower, is the party authorized to make a loan to the prospective borrower.
(6)Provides a statement substantially similar to the following:
If you wish to report a complaint about the manner in which you were referred to us, you may contact the Department of Business Oversight at 866-275-2677 or file a complaint online at www.dbo.ca.gov.
(b)A licensed finance lender who provides the statement described in subdivision (a) shall have prospective borrowers acknowledge receipt of the statement.
(c)For purposes of this section, clear and conspicuous means either of the following:
(1)If the statement is provided in text, that the text is at least 10-point size, is not obscured by techniques such as graphical displays, shading, coloration, or other devices, and is displayed in a manner that allows a prospective borrower to read the text.
(2)If the statement is an oral statement, whether provided by telephone or other medium, that the statement is given at a speed and volume sufficient for a prospective borrower to hear and comprehend the disclosure.
SEC. 6.SEC. 7.Section 22338 of the Financial Code is amended to read:22338.Except in connection with an act described in paragraph (1) or (2) of subdivision (a) of Section 22004, each licensed broker shall:
(a)Deliver to the borrower, or any one thereof, at the time the final negotiation or arrangement is made, a statement showing in clear and distinct terms the name, address, and license number of the broker and the finance lender. The statement shall show the date, amount, and terms of the agreement with the broker, and all amounts paid or to be paid to the broker by the prospective borrower and to any person other than the finance lender.
(b)Deliver to the finance lender making the loan a copy of the statement referred to and described in subdivision (a).
(c)Deliver to the person making any payment to the broker to be retained by the broker, a plain and complete receipt for each payment made, at the time it is made, showing the total amount received, and identifying the brokerage agreement and the loan contract upon which the payment is applied. If the payment is made by a person other than the finance lender, a copy of the receipt shall be delivered to the finance lender.
(d)When the borrower pays the loan in full, ensure that the finance lender fully complies with subdivision (e) of Section 22337.
(e)Deliver to the potential borrower or borrowers, at the time the licensee first requires or accepts any signed instrument or the payment of any fee, a statement showing in clear and distinct terms the name, address, and license number of the broker and finance lender.
SEC. 7.SEC. 8.Section 22338.5 is added to the Financial Code, to read:22338.5.(a)A licensed broker shall obtain a prospective borrowers affirmative authorization before collecting the prospective borrowers confidential data for the purpose of performing an act described in paragraph (1) or (2) of subdivision (a) of Section 22004 that does not also constitute any of the acts described in paragraphs (3) to (7), inclusive, of subdivision (a) of Section 22004.
(b)Before obtaining a prospective borrowers authorization under subdivision (a), each licensed broker shall provide to the prospective borrower a statement in a clear and conspicuous manner that provides all of the following:
(1)Identifies the name and license number of each finance lender to whom the prospective borrower may be referred by the licensed broker.
(2)Identifies the name and contact information of any person who is not a finance lender to whom the prospective borrower may be referred by the licensed broker.
(3)Discloses the method by which each finance lender to whom the prospective borrower is referred by the licensed broker will compute the compensation paid to the licensed broker for a referral, including whether the compensation varies based on the loan amount and whether the compensation is contingent on the making of a loan to the prospective borrower.
(4)Discloses that lenders to whom the prospective borrower is referred are not necessarily the best lending options available to the prospective borrower.
(5)Discloses that lenders to whom the prospective borrower is referred may separately contact the prospective borrower.
(6)Provides a statement substantially similar to the following:
If you wish to report a complaint about our services, you may contact the Department of Business Oversight at 866-275-2677 or file a complaint online at www.dbo.ca.gov.
(7)Affirms that the licensed broker will not charge the prospective borrower a fee for the referral.
(c)A licensed broker who provides the statement described in subdivision (b) shall have prospective borrowers acknowledge receipt of the statement.
(d)For purposes of this section:
(1)Clear and conspicuous means the following:
(A)If the statement is provided in text, that the text is at least 10-point size, is not obscured by techniques such as graphical displays, shading, coloration, or other devices, and is displayed in a manner that allows a prospective borrower to read the text.
(B)If the statement is an oral statement, whether provided by telephone or other medium, that the statement is given at a speed and volume sufficient for a prospective borrower to hear and comprehend the disclosure.
(2)Confidential data has the same meaning as defined in subdivision (b) of Section 22004.
SEC. 8.SEC. 9.Section 22348 is added to the Financial Code, to read:22348.(a)A licensed broker who compensates unlicensed persons for referrals that would have required the unlicensed person to obtain a license under paragraph (1) or (2) of subdivision (a) of Section 22004 had those referrals been made to a licensed finance lender shall develop, implement, and enforce policies and procedures intended to:
(1)Identify and correct any business practices maintained by those unlicensed persons that would violate this division if those business practices were maintained by the licensed broker.
(2)Identify and correct any statements, representations, or acts made by those unlicensed persons that would violate Section 22161 if those statements, representations, or acts were made by the licensed broker.
(3)Ensure that the licensed broker receives and monitors complaints by prospective borrowers regarding those unlicensed persons.
(4)Ensure that those unlicensed persons shall not collect a prospective borrowers confidential data, as defined in subdivision (b) of Section 22004, for the purpose of referring a prospective borrower to the licensed broker without first obtaining the prospective borrowers affirmative authorization for that purpose.
(5)Ensure that the licensed broker does not pay compensation to any of those unlicensed persons for referrals made in a manner that would have violated this division if the licensed broker had made the referral to a finance lender.
(6)Ensure that the broker ceases any relationship with those unlicensed persons who demonstrate repeated, uncorrected failures to adhere to the brokers policies and procedures.
(b)A licensed broker that violates subdivision (a) on the basis that the licensed broker failed to develop, implement, and enforce policies and procedures that would prevent an unlicensed person from engaging in acts that would be a violation of this division if that person was licensed shall be deemed to be in violation of any provision of this division or any regulation adopted pursuant to this division to the same extent as the unlicensed person would have been in violation had that person been a licensed broker.
(c)A licensed broker shall conspicuously post the policies and procedures required by subdivision (a) in the place of business authorized by the license.
SEC. 9.SEC. 10.Section 22602 of the Financial Code is amended to read:22602.(a)Notwithstanding subdivision (c) of Section 22100, a licensed finance lender may pay compensation to a person that is not licensed pursuant to this division in connection with a referral as described in paragraphs (1) and (2) of subdivision (a) of Section 22004 of one or more prospective borrowers to the licensee, when all of the following conditions are met:
(1)The referral by the unlicensed person leads to the consummation of a commercial loan, as defined in Section 22502, between the licensee and the prospective borrower referred by the unlicensed person.
(2)The commercial loan contract provides for an annual percentage rate that does not exceed 36 percent.
(3)Before approving the commercial loan, the licensee does both of the following:
(A)Obtains documentation from the prospective borrower documenting the borrowers commercial status. Examples of acceptable forms of documentation include, but are not limited to, a sellers permit, business license, articles of incorporation, income tax returns showing business income, or bank account statements showing business income.
(B)Performs underwriting and obtains documentation to ensure that the prospective borrower will have sufficient monthly gross revenue with which to repay the loan pursuant to the loan terms, and does not make a loan if it determines through its underwriting that the prospective borrowers total monthly expenses, including debt service payments on the loan for which the prospective borrower is being considered, will exceed the prospective borrowers monthly gross revenue. Examples of acceptable forms of documentation for verifying current and projected gross monthly revenue and monthly expenses include, but are not limited to, tax returns, bank statements, merchant financial statements, business plans, business history, and industry-specific knowledge and experience. If the prospective borrower is a sole proprietor or a corporation and the loan will be secured by a personal guarantee provided by the owner of the corporation, a credit report from at least one consumer credit reporting agency that compiles and maintains files on consumers on a nationwide basis shall also be considered.
(4)The licensee maintains records of all compensation paid to unlicensed persons in connection with the referral of borrowers for a period of at least four years.
(5)The licensee annually submits information requested by the commissioner regarding the payment of compensation in the report required pursuant to Section 22159.
(b)This section does not authorize an unlicensed person to perform any of the activities described in paragraphs (3) to (7), inclusive, of subdivision (a) of Section 22004, unless the person meets one or more of the following criteria:
(1)Is exempt from licensure under this division.
(2)Is exempt from federal income taxes under Section 501(c)(3) of the Internal Revenue Code.
(3)Is a business assistance organization recognized by the United States Small Business Administration.
(4)Is engaged in one or more of the activities described in paragraphs (3) to (7), inclusive, of subdivision (a) of Section 22004 in connection with five or fewer commercial loans in a calendar year made by persons licensed under this division.
(c)The commissioner may adopt regulations under this section to impose conditions on the referral activity authorized under this section. The commissioner may classify persons, loans, loan terms, referral methods, and other matters within his or her jurisdiction, and may prescribe different requirements for different classes of loans.
(d)Nothing in this section shall authorize the payment of a referral or lead fee to an unlicensed person for a residential mortgage loan, nor the payment of a referral or lead fee to a person required to be licensed under Section 10131 or 10131.1 of the Business and Professions Code, unless that person is licensed by the Bureau of Real Estate pursuant to Division 4 (commencing with Section 10000) of the Business and Professions Code.
(e)Notwithstanding subdivision (c) of Section 22100, a licensed finance lender may, pursuant to this section, pay compensation to an unlicensed person to provide services described in subdivision (c) of Section 22004. A licensed finance lender that pays compensation pursuant to this subdivision shall not be subject to the requirements of paragraphs (1) through (5), inclusive, of subdivision (a).
SEC. 10.SEC. 11.Section 22604 of the Financial Code is amended to read:22604.(a)Any person that receives compensation pursuant to subdivision (a) or (e) of Section 22602 shall not do any of the following:
(1)Make a materially false or misleading statement or representation to a prospective borrower about the terms or conditions of a prospective loan.
(2)Advertise, print, display, publish, distribute, or broadcast any statement or representation with regard to the conditions for making or negotiating a loan that is false, misleading, or deceptive, or that omits material information that is necessary to make the statements made not false, misleading, or deceptive.
(3)Engage in any act in violation of Section 17200 of the Business and Professions Code.
(4)Commit an act that constitutes fraud or dishonest dealings.
(5)Fail to safeguard a prospective borrowers confidential data, as defined in subdivision (b) of Section 22004.
(b)In addition to the prohibitions set forth in subdivision (a), a person who receives compensation pursuant to subdivision (a) of Section 22602 shall comply with both of the following:
(1)Shall not collect a prospective borrowers confidential data, as defined in subdivision (b) of Section 22004, for the purpose of performing an act described in paragraph (1) or (2) of subdivision (a) of Section 22004 without first obtaining the prospective borrowers affirmative authorization for that purpose.
(2)Shall, before making the referral, provide the prospective borrower with a written disclosure that shows in clear and distinct terms, the method of compensation provided by the licensed finance lender to that person, including whether the compensation is based on the size of the loan or contingent upon the referral or lead resulting in a consummated loan.
(c)Whenever, in the opinion of the commissioner, any person who receives compensation pursuant to subdivision (a) or (e) of Section 22602, violates this section or any other provision of this division authorizing such activity or exempting the person from this division, the commissioner may order the person to desist and to refrain from engaging in the business or further violating this division.
SEC. 11.SEC. 12.No reimbursement is required by this act pursuant to Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution because the only costs that may be incurred by a local agency or school district will be incurred because this act creates a new crime or infraction, eliminates a crime or infraction, or changes the penalty for a crime or infraction, within the meaning of Section 17556 of the Government Code, or changes the definition of a crime within the meaning of Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution.
(a)Broker includes any person who is engaged in the business of negotiating or performing any act as broker in connection with loans made by a finance lender, unless otherwise exempt pursuant to Section 22050, including, but not limited to, any of the following acts: performing any of the following acts in connection with loans made by a finance lender, unless that person is otherwise exempt from this division pursuant to Section 22050:
(1)Providing a referral or a lead to one or more finance lenders for compensation or expected compensation if the referral or lead conveys confidential data. For the purposes of this subdivision, a referral or lead is considered to convey confidential data when either of the following occurs:(A)Confidential data about a referral or lead is transmitted to the finance lender.(B)The referral or lead is provided pursuant to an agreement under which a finance lender only compensates the referral or lead provider for a referral or lead that both:(i)Meets certain, agreed-upon criteria involving confidential data.(ii)Leads to a person obtaining a loan from the finance lender.(1)Transmitting confidential data about a prospective borrower to a finance lender with the expectation of compensation, in connection with making a referral. However, a licensed finance lender that transmits confidential data to another licensed finance lender as described in this paragraph in connection with the denial of a loan application shall be deemed to not be a broker within the meaning of this paragraph if the licensee does both of the following before transmitting the confidential data:
(A)Provides the prospective borrower a clear and conspicuous written statement that discloses that the licensee either may be compensated by the finance lender for transmitting the confidential data, or, if applicable, will be compensated by the finance lender if the transmittal results in a funded loan. The licensee shall have the prospective borrower acknowledge receipt of the statement. The form of the statement shall comply with paragraph (1) of subdivision (c) of Section 22337.5.
(B)After the prospective borrower acknowledges receipt of the written disclosure statement, obtains the prospective borrowers affirmative approval to transmit the confidential data.
(2)Making a referral to a finance lender under an agreement with the finance lender that any prospective borrower referred by the person to the finance lender meet certain criteria involving confidential data and with the expectation that the person making the referral will be compensated if the finance lender and the prospective borrower enter into a loan agreement. However, a licensed finance lender that makes a referral to another licensed finance lender as described in this paragraph in connection with the denial of a loan application shall be deemed to not be a broker within the meaning of this paragraph if the licensee does both of the following before making the referral:
(A)Provides the prospective borrower a clear and conspicuous written statement that discloses that the licensee either may be compensated by the finance lender for making the referral, or, if applicable, will be compensated by the finance lender if the referral results in a funded loan. The licensee shall have the prospective borrower acknowledge receipt of the statement. The form of the statement shall comply with paragraph (1) of subdivision (c) of Section 22337.5.
(B)After the prospective borrower acknowledges receipt of the written disclosure statement, obtains the prospective borrowers affirmative approval to make the referral.
(2)(3)Participating in any loan negotiation between a finance lender and prospective borrower.
(3)(4)Counseling, advising, or making recommendations to a prospective borrower about a loan based on a the prospective borrowers confidential data.
(4)(5)Participating in the preparation of any loan documents, including loan applications, other than providing a prospective borrower blank copies of loan documents. Transmitting information that is not confidential data to a finance lender at the request of a prospective borrower or loan applicant shall not, by itself, constitute participation in the preparation of loan documents.
(5)(6)Communicating lending to a prospective borrower a finance lenders decisions or inquiries between a finance lender and a borrower. involving confidential data.
(6)(7)Charging any fees a fee to a prospective borrower or applicant for any services related to a prospective borrowers or applicants application for a loan from a finance lender.
(b)(1)For purposes of this section, confidential data means information about a borrower, prospective borrower, or applicant that is nonpublic and sensitive. The term confidential data includes, but is not limited to, any of the following:
(A)Bank account number or routing number. number.
(B)Bank statement.
(C)Credit or debit card account number.
(D)Credit score, as defined in subdivision (b) of Section 1785.15.1 of the Civil Code, either self-reported by the person it relates to, or received from a credit reporting agency as part of an official request.
(E)Social security number, including both a persons full social security number or a partial number.
(F)Personal or business income information, including information self-reported by the person.
(G)Drivers license number or government-issued identification number.
(H)Passport number.
(I)Personal employment data or history.
(J)Date of birth.
(K)Mothers maiden name.
(L)Medical information.
(M)Health insurance information.
(N)Insurance policy number.
(O)Taxpayer or employer identification number.
(2)The term confidential data does not include any of the following:
(A)Name.
(B)Phone number.
(C)Physical address.
(D)Email address.
(E)Desired loan or financing amount.
(F)Borrowers stated purpose for a loan.
(G)In connection with a commercial loan, confidential data does not include business name, business address, business phone number, or a businesss self-reported range of income, a businesss name, address, phone number, email address, self-reported income, self-reported credit score of a business owner, or a businesss desired loan or financing amount, in addition to the other information listed in this paragraph.
(c)A person shall not be deemed a broker if both of the following are met:
(1)The person only distributes or otherwise disseminates to a prospective borrower or applicant a finance lenders marketing materials or factual information about the finance lender and lender, its lending activities, or its loan products, such as the finance lenders interest rates, minimum or maximum loan amounts or loan periods, or a general description of the finance lenders underwriting criteria.
(2)The person does not engage in any of the other perform any of the acts specified in subdivision (a).
(d)This section does not apply to any person who performs the acts described in subdivision (a) five or fewer times in a calendar year.
SEC. 2.Section 22010.5 is added to the Financial Code, to read:22010.5.Referral means the introduction of a prospective borrower to a licensee or the delivery of a prospective borrowers contact information to a finance lender for the purposes of making an introduction.
SEC. 2.SEC. 3.Section 22100 of the Financial Code is amended to read:22100.(a)A person shall not engage in the business of a finance lender or broker without obtaining a license from the commissioner.
(b)Every licensee engaging in the business of making or brokering residential mortgage loans shall require that every mortgage loan originator employed or compensated by that licensee obtains and maintains a mortgage loan originator license from the commissioner under this division or Division 20 (commencing with Section 50000), or has first obtained a license endorsement from the Commissioner of Real Estate pursuant to Article 2.1 (commencing with Section 10166.01) of Chapter 3 of Part 1 of Division 4 of the Business and Professions Code.
(c)Except as provided in subdivisions (a) and (b) (a), (b), and (e) of Section 22602, a finance lender shall not compensate a person for any of the acts described in subdivision (a) of Section 22004 unless that person is a licensed broker pursuant to this division.
(d)A licensee shall not compensate a broker for services related to a loan subject to this division if the broker is known to have committed any violation of Section 22161 in connection with that loan.(e)A licensee shall not, in connection with any loan subject to this division, directly or indirectly pass through to a borrower the licensees cost of compensating a broker.(f)(d)A licensed broker shall not solicit or collect confidential data, as defined in subdivision (b) of Section 22004, unless that information is reasonably necessary to perform the acts described in subdivision (a) of Section 22004. for the purpose of performing an act described in subdivision (a) of Section 22004 without first obtaining the prospective borrowers affirmative authorization for that purpose.
(g)Before making a referral or lead as described in paragraph (1) of subdivision (a) of Section 22004 in connection with any loan subject to this division, a licensed broker shall provide the prospective borrower a written disclosure that shows in clear and distinct terms the method of compensation provided to the licensed broker, including whether the compensation is based on the size of a loan or contingent on the referral or lead resulting in a consummated loan.(h)Before consummating a loan subject to this division, a licensed finance lender shall provide the prospective borrower a written disclosure that shows in clear and distinct terms the amount paid to any broker in connection with the loan, and how the compensation was determined, including whether the compensation was based on the size of a loan or contingent on the referral or lead resulting in a consummated loan.(e)A licensed finance lender shall not compensate a broker for an act described in paragraph (1) or (2) of subdivision (a) of Section 22004 if the finance lender knows at the time the compensation is to be made that the broker has committed any violation of Section 22161 in connection with that loan.
(f)A licensed finance lender shall not, in connection with any loan subject to this division for which the finance lender paid or would pay a referral fee, charge a borrower more for the loan than the finance lender would have charged the borrower if the finance lender did not pay or would not be paying a referral fee.
(i)(g)A finance lender or broker shall not employ a mortgage loan originator whose license or license endorsement has lapsed.
(j)(h)A finance lender or broker may not make or broker a residential mortgage loan unless that loan is offered by, negotiated by, or applied for through a licensed mortgage loan originator.
(k)(i)Every licensee engaged in the business of making or brokering residential mortgage loans and every mortgage loan originator licensed under this division shall register with and maintain a valid unique identifier issued by the Nationwide Mortgage Licensing System and Registry.
(l)(j)An individual shall not engage in the business of a mortgage loan originator with respect to any dwelling located in this state without first obtaining and maintaining annually a license in accordance with the requirements of this division and any rules promulgated by the commissioner under this chapter.
(m)(k)A registered mortgage loan originator, as defined in subdivision (c) of Section 22013, is exempt from licensure under this section when he or she is employed by:
(1)A depository institution.
(2)A subsidiary of a depository institution that is owned and controlled by a depository institution and regulated by a federal banking agency.
(3)An institution regulated by the Farm Credit Administration.
SEC. 4.Section 22337 of the Financial Code is amended to read:22337.Each licensed finance lender shall:
(a)Deliver or cause to be delivered to the borrower, or any one thereof, at the time the loan is made, a statement showing in clear and distinct terms the name, address, and license number of the finance lender and the broker, if any. The statement shall show the date, amount, and maturity of the loan contract, how and when repayable, the nature of the security for the loan, if any, and the agreed rate of charge or the annual percentage rate pursuant to Regulation Z promulgated by the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (12 C.F.R. 1026).
(b)Obtain Except in connection with an act described in paragraph (1) or (2) of subdivision (a) of Section 22004, obtain from the borrower a signed statement as to whether any person has performed any act as a broker in connection with the making of the loan. If the statement discloses that a broker or other person has participated, then the finance lender shall obtain a full statement of all sums paid or payable to the broker or other person. The finance lender shall keep these statements for a period of three years from and after the date the loan has been paid in full, or has matured according to its terms, or has been charged off.
(c)Permit payment to be made in advance in any amount on any contract of loan at any time. The licensee may apply the payment first to any agreed prepayment penalty, then to all charges due, including charges at the agreed rate or rates up to the date of payment, not to exceed the applicable maximum rate permitted by this article.
(d)Deliver or cause to be delivered to the person making any cash payment, or to the person who requests a receipt at the time of making any payment, at the time payment is made on account of any loan, a plain and complete receipt showing the total amount received and identifying the loan contract upon which the payment is applied.
(e)Upon repayment of any loan in full, release all security for the loan, endorse and return any certificate of ownership, and cancel or plainly mark paid and return to the borrower or person making final payment, any note, mortgage, security agreement, trust deed, assignment, or order signed by the borrower, or an optical image reproduction thereof, except those documents that are a part of the court record in any action, or that have been delivered to a third person for the purpose of carrying out their terms, or a security agreement that secures any other indebtedness of a borrower to the licensee, or original documents otherwise required by law. When a trust deed on real property has been taken as security for a loan that has been subsequently paid in full, a duly executed request for reconveyance shall be delivered to the trustor or trustee for the purpose of recording a reconveyance. A termination statement, furnished to the borrower as provided for in Sections 9512 and 9513 of the Commercial Code, shall be deemed a release of the security when a financing statement has been filed pursuant to Section 9501 of the Commercial Code.
For purposes of this subdivision, an optical image reproduction shall meet all of the following requirements:
(1)The optical image storage media used to store the document shall be nonerasable write once, read many (WORM) optical image media that does not allow changes to the stored document.
(2)The optical image reproduction shall be made consistent with the minimum standards of quality approved by either the National Institute of Standards and Technology or the Association for Information and Image Management.
(3)Written authentication identifying the optical image reproduction as an exact unaltered copy of the note, trust deed, mortgage, security agreement, assignment or order shall be stamped or printed on the optical image reproduction.
(f)Deliver or cause to be delivered to the potential borrower, or any one thereof, at the time the licensee first requires or accepts any signed instrument or the payment of any fee, a statement showing in clear and distinct terms the name, address, and license number of the finance lender and the broker, if any.
SEC. 5.Section 22337.5 is added to the Financial Code, to read:22337.5.(a)A licensed finance lender, after receiving a referral from a broker as described in paragraph (1) or (2) of subdivision (a) of Section 22004 and before accepting an application from the prospective borrower referred by the broker, shall provide to the prospective borrower a statement in a clear and conspicuous manner that provides all of the following:
(1)Identifies the name and license number of the broker who referred the prospective borrower.
(2)Discloses that the finance lender may pay a fee to the broker who referred the prospective borrower for the referral.
(3)Affirms that the prospective borrower will not be charged more for a loan by the finance lender because of the fact that the finance lender may pay a fee to the broker who referred the prospective borrower for the referral.
(4)Affirms that the prospective borrower should not be charged a fee by the broker who referred the prospective borrower to the licensed finance lender.
(5)Affirms that the finance lender, not the broker who referred the prospective borrower, is the party authorized to make a loan to the prospective borrower.
(6)Provides a statement substantially similar to the following:
If you wish to report a complaint about the manner in which you were referred to us, you may contact the Department of Business Oversight at 866-275-2677 or file a complaint online at www.dbo.ca.gov.
(b)A licensed finance lender who provides the statement described in subdivision (a) shall have prospective borrowers acknowledge receipt of the statement.
(c)For purposes of this section, clear and conspicuous means either of the following:
(1)If the statement is provided in text, that the text is at least 10-point size, is not obscured by techniques such as graphical displays, shading, coloration, or other devices, and is displayed in a manner that allows a prospective borrower to read the text.
(2)If the statement is an oral statement, whether provided by telephone or other medium, that the statement is given at a speed and volume sufficient for a prospective borrower to hear and comprehend the disclosure.
SEC. 6.Section 22338 of the Financial Code is amended to read:22338.Each Except in connection with an act described in paragraph (1) or (2) of subdivision (a) of Section 22004, each licensed broker shall:
(a)Deliver to the borrower, or any one thereof, at the time the final negotiation or arrangement is made, a statement showing in clear and distinct terms the name, address, and license number of the broker and the finance lender. The statement shall show the date, amount, and terms of the agreement with the broker, and all amounts paid or to be paid to the broker and to any person other than the finance lender.
(b)Deliver to the finance lender making the loan a copy of the statement referred to and described in subdivision (a).
(c)Deliver to the person making any payment to the broker to be retained by the broker, a plain and complete receipt for each payment made, at the time it is made, showing the total amount received, and identifying the brokerage agreement and the loan contract upon which the payment is applied. If the payment is made by a person other than the finance lender, a copy of the receipt shall be delivered to the finance lender.
(d)When the borrower pays the loan in full, ensure that the finance lender fully complies with subdivision (e) of Section 22337.
(e)Deliver to the potential borrower or borrowers, at the time the licensee first requires or accepts any signed instrument or the payment of any fee, a statement showing in clear and distinct terms the name, address, and license number of the broker and finance lender.
SEC. 7.Section 22338.5 is added to the Financial Code, to read:22338.5.(a)A licensed broker shall obtain a prospective borrowers affirmative authorization before collecting the prospective borrowers confidential data for the purpose of performing an act described in paragraph (1) or (2) of subdivision (a) of Section 22004 that does not also constitute any of the acts described in paragraphs (3) to (7), inclusive, of subdivision (a) of Section 22004.
(b)Before obtaining a prospective borrowers authorization under subdivision (a), each licensed broker shall provide to the prospective borrower a statement in a clear and conspicuous manner that provides all of the following:
(1)Identifies the name and license number of each finance lender to whom the prospective borrower may be referred by the licensed broker.
(2)Identifies the name and contact information of any person who is not a finance lender to whom the prospective borrower may be referred by the licensed broker.
(3)Discloses the method by which each finance lender to whom the prospective borrower is referred by the licensed broker will compute the compensation paid to the licensed broker for a referral, including whether the compensation varies based on the loan amount and whether the compensation is contingent on the making of a loan to the prospective borrower.
(4)Discloses that lenders to whom the prospective borrower is referred are not necessarily the best lending options available to the prospective borrower.
(5)Discloses that lenders to whom the prospective borrower is referred may separately contact the prospective borrower.
(6)Provides a statement substantially similar to the following:
If you wish to report a complaint about our services, you may contact the Department of Business Oversight at 866-275-2677 or file a complaint online at www.dbo.ca.gov.
(7)Affirms that the licensed broker will not charge the prospective borrower a fee for the referral.
(c)A licensed broker who provides the statement described in subdivision (b) shall have prospective borrowers acknowledge receipt of the statement.
(d)For purposes of this section:
(1)Clear and conspicuous means the following:
(A)If the statement is provided in text, that the text is at least 10-point size, is not obscured by techniques such as graphical displays, shading, coloration, or other devices, and is displayed in a manner that allows a prospective borrower to read the text.
(B)If the statement is an oral statement, whether provided by telephone or other medium, that the statement is given at a speed and volume sufficient for a prospective borrower to hear and comprehend the disclosure.
(2)Confidential data has the same meaning as defined in subdivision (b) of Section 22004.
SEC. 8.Section 22348 is added to the Financial Code, to read:22348.(a)A licensed broker who compensates unlicensed persons for referrals that would have required the unlicensed person to obtain a license under paragraph (1) or (2) of subdivision (a) of Section 22004 had those referrals been made to a licensed finance lender shall develop, implement, and enforce policies and procedures intended to:
(1)Identify and correct any business practices maintained by those unlicensed persons that would violate this division if those business practices were maintained by the licensed broker.
(2)Identify and correct any statements, representations, or acts made by those unlicensed persons that would violate Section 22161 if those statements, representations, or acts were made by the licensed broker.
(3)Ensure that the licensed broker receives and monitors complaints by prospective borrowers regarding those unlicensed persons.
(4)Ensure that those unlicensed persons shall not collect a prospective borrowers confidential data, as defined in subdivision (b) of Section 22004, for the purpose of referring a prospective borrower to the licensed broker without first obtaining the prospective borrowers affirmative authorization for that purpose.
(5)Ensure that the licensed broker does not pay compensation to any of those unlicensed persons for referrals made in a manner that would have violated this division if the licensed broker had made the referral to a finance lender.
(6)Ensure that the broker ceases any relationship with those unlicensed persons who demonstrate repeated, uncorrected failures to adhere to the brokers policies and procedures.
(b)A licensed broker that violates subdivision (a) on the basis that the licensed broker failed to develop, implement, and enforce policies and procedures that would prevent an unlicensed person from engaging in acts that would be a violation of this division if that person was licensed shall be deemed to be in violation of any provision of this division or any regulation adopted pursuant to this division to the same extent as the unlicensed person would have been in violation had that person been a licensed broker.
(c)A licensed broker shall conspicuously post the policies and procedures required by subdivision (a) in the place of business authorized by the license.
SEC. 3.SEC. 9.Section 22602 of the Financial Code is amended to read:22602.(a)Notwithstanding subdivision (c) of Section 22100, a licensed finance lender may pay compensation to a person that is not licensed pursuant to this division in connection with a referral or lead as described in paragraph (1) paragraphs (1) and (2) of subdivision (a) of Section 22004 of one or more prospective borrowers to the licensee, when all of the following conditions are met:
(1)The referral or lead by the unlicensed person leads to the consummation of a commercial loan, as defined in Section 22502, between the licensee and the prospective borrower referred or lead by the unlicensed person.
(2)The commercial loan contract provides for an annual percentage rate that does not exceed 36 percent.
(3)Before approving the commercial loan, the licensee does both of the following:
(A)Obtains documentation from the prospective borrower documenting the borrowers commercial status. Examples of acceptable forms of documentation include, but are not limited to, a sellers permit, business license, articles of incorporation, income tax returns showing business income, or bank account statements showing business income.
(B)Performs underwriting and obtains documentation to ensure that the prospective borrower will have sufficient monthly gross revenue with which to repay the loan pursuant to the loan terms, and does not make a loan if it determines through its underwriting that the prospective borrowers total monthly expenses, including debt service payments on the loan for which the prospective borrower is being considered, will exceed the prospective borrowers monthly gross revenue. Examples of acceptable forms of documentation for verifying current and projected gross monthly revenue and monthly expenses include, but are not limited to, tax returns, bank statements, merchant financial statements, business plans, business history, and industry-specific knowledge and experience. If the prospective borrower is a sole proprietor or a corporation and the loan will be secured by a personal guarantee provided by the owner of the corporation, a credit report from at least one consumer credit reporting agency that compiles and maintains files on consumers on a nationwide basis shall also be considered.
(4)The licensee maintains records of all compensation paid to unlicensed persons in connection with the referral or lead of borrowers for a period of at least four years.
(5)The licensee annually submits information requested by the commissioner regarding the payment of compensation in the report required pursuant to Section 22159.
(b)This section does not authorize an unlicensed person to perform any of the activities described in paragraphs (2) to (6), (3) to (7), inclusive, of subdivision (a) of Section 22004, unless the person meets one or more of the following criteria:
(1)Is exempt from licensure under this division.
(2)Is exempt from federal income taxes under Section 501(c)(3) of the Internal Revenue Code.
(3)Is a business assistance organization recognized by the United States Small Business Administration.
(4)Is engaged in one or more of the activities described in paragraphs (2) to (6), (3) to (7), inclusive, of subdivision (a) of Section 22004 in connection with five or fewer commercial loans in a calendar year made by persons licensed under this division.
(c)The commissioner may adopt regulations under this section to impose conditions on the referral or lead activity authorized under this section. The commissioner may classify persons, loans, loan terms, referral or lead methods, and other matters within his or her jurisdiction, and may prescribe different requirements for different classes of loans.
(d)Nothing in this section shall authorize the payment of a referral or lead fee to an unlicensed person for a residential mortgage loan, nor the payment of a referral or lead fee to a person required to be licensed under Section 10131 or 10131.1 of the Business and Professions Code, unless that person is licensed by the Bureau of Real Estate pursuant to Division 4 (commencing with Section 10000) of the Business and Professions Code.
(e)A Notwithstanding subdivision (c) of Section 22100, a licensed finance lender may, pursuant to this section, pay compensation to an unlicensed person to provide services described in subdivision (c) of Section 22004. A licensed finance lender that pays compensation pursuant to this subdivision shall not be subject to the requirements of paragraphs (1) through (5), inclusive, of subdivision (a).
SEC. 4.SEC. 10.Section 22604 of the Financial Code is amended to read:22604.(a)Any person that receives compensation pursuant to subdivision (a) or (e) of Section 22602 shall not do any of the following:
(1)Make a materially false or misleading statement or representation to a prospective borrower about the terms or conditions of a prospective loan.
(2)Advertise, print, display, publish, distribute, or broadcast any statement or representation with regard to the conditions for making or negotiating a loan that is false, misleading, or deceptive, or that omits material information that is necessary to make the statements made not false, misleading, or deceptive.
(3)Engage in any act in violation of Section 17200 of the Business and Professions Code.
(4)Commit an act that constitutes fraud or dishonest dealings.
(5)Fail to safeguard a prospective borrowers confidential data, as defined in subdivision (b) of Section 22004.
(b)In addition to the prohibitions set forth in subdivision (a), a person who receives compensation pursuant to subdivision (a) of Section 22602 shall comply with both of the following:
(1)Shall not solicit or collect collect a prospective borrowers confidential data, as defined in subdivision (b) of Section 22004, unless that information is reasonably necessary to make the referral or lead. for the purpose of performing an act described in paragraph (1) or (2) of subdivision (a) of Section 22004 without first obtaining the prospective borrowers affirmative authorization for that purpose.
(2)Shall, prior to making the referral or lead, before making the referral, provide the prospective buyer borrower with a written disclosure that shows in clear and distinct terms, the method of compensation provided by the licensed lender, finance lender to that person, including whether the compensation is based on the size of the loan or contingent upon the referral or lead resulting in a consummated loan.
(c)Whenever, in the opinion of the commissioner, any person who receives compensation pursuant to subdivision (a) or (e) of Section 22602, violates this section or any other provision of this division authorizing such activity or exempting the person from this division, the commissioner may order the person to desist and to refrain from engaging in the business or further violating this division.
SEC. 5.SEC. 11.No reimbursement is required by this act pursuant to Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution because the only costs that may be incurred by a local agency or school district will be incurred because this act creates a new crime or infraction, eliminates a crime or infraction, or changes the penalty for a crime or infraction, within the meaning of Section 17556 of the Government Code, or changes the definition of a crime within the meaning of Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution.
(a)Broker includes any person who is engaged in the business of negotiating or performing any act as broker in connection with loans made by a finance lender, unless otherwise exempt pursuant to Section 22050, including, but not limited to, any of the following acts:
(1)Providing a referral or a lead to one or more finance lenders for compensation or expected compensation if the referral or lead conveys confidential data. For the purposes of this subdivision, a referral or lead is considered to convey confidential data when either of the following occurs:
(A)Confidential data about a referral or lead is transmitted to the finance lender.
(B)The referral or lead is provided pursuant to an agreement under which a finance lender only compensates the referral or lead provider for a referral or lead that both:
(i)Meets certain, agreed-upon criteria involving confidential data.
(ii)Leads to a person obtaining a loan from the finance lender.
(2)Participating in any loan negotiation between a finance lender and prospective borrower.
(3)Counseling, advising, or making recommendations to a borrower about a loan based on a borrowers confidential data.
(4)Participating in the preparation of any loan documents, including loan applications, other than providing a borrower blank copies of loan documents. Transmitting information that is not confidential data at the request of a prospective borrower or loan applicant shall not, by itself, constitute participation in the preparation of loan documents.
(5)Communicating lending decisions or inquiries between a finance lender and a borrower.
(6)Charging any fees to a prospective borrower or applicant for any services related to a prospective borrowers or applicants application for a loan from a finance lender.
(b)(1)For purposes of this section, confidential data means information about a borrower, prospective borrower, or applicant that is nonpublic and sensitive. The term confidential data includes, but is not limited to, any of the following:
(A)Bank account number or routing number.
(B)Bank statement.
(C)Credit or debit card account number.
(D)Credit score, as defined in subdivision (b) of Section 1785.15.1 of the Civil Code, either self-reported by the person it relates to, or received from a credit reporting agency as part of an official request.
(E)Social security number, including both a persons full social security number or a partial number.
(F)Personal or business income information, including information self-reported by the person.
(G)Drivers license number or government-issued identification number.
(H)Passport number.
(I)Personal employment data or history.
(J)Date of birth.
(K)Mothers maiden name.
(L)Medical information.
(M)Health insurance information.
(N)Insurance policy number.
(O)Taxpayer or employer identification number.
(2)The term confidential data does not include any of the following:
(A)Name.
(B)Phone number.
(C)Physical address.
(D)Email address.
(E)Desired loan or financing amount.
(F)Borrowers stated purpose for a loan.
(G)In connection with a commercial loan, confidential data does not include business name, business address, business phone number, or a businesss self-reported range of income, in addition to the other information listed in this paragraph.
(c)A person shall not be deemed a broker if both of the following are met:
(1)The person only distributes or otherwise disseminates to a prospective borrower or applicant a finance lenders marketing materials or factual information about the finance lender and its loan products, such as the finance lenders interest rates, minimum or maximum loan amounts or loan periods, or a general description of the finance lenders underwriting criteria.
(2)The person does not engage in any of the other acts specified in subdivision (a).
(d)This section does not apply to any person who performs the acts described in subdivision (a) five or fewer times in a calendar year.
SEC. 2.Section 22100 of the Financial Code is amended to read:22100.(a)A person shall not engage in the business of a finance lender or broker without obtaining a license from the commissioner.
(b)Every licensee engaging in the business of making or brokering residential mortgage loans shall require that every mortgage loan originator employed or compensated by that licensee obtains and maintains a mortgage loan originator license from the commissioner under this division or Division 20 (commencing with Section 50000), or has first obtained a license endorsement from the Commissioner of Real Estate pursuant to Article 2.1 (commencing with Section 10166.01) of Chapter 3 of Part 1 of Division 4 of the Business and Professions Code.
(c)Except as provided in subdivision (a) subdivisions (a) and (b) of Section 22602, a finance lender shall not compensate a person for any of the acts described in subdivision (a) of Section 22004 unless that person is a licensed broker pursuant to this division.
(d)A licensee shall not compensate a broker for services related to a loan subject to this division if the broker is known to have committed any violation of Section 22161 in connection with that loan.
(e)A licensee shall not, in connection with any loan subject to this division, directly or indirectly pass through to a borrower the licensees cost of compensating a broker.
(f)A licensed broker shall not solicit or collect confidential data, as defined in subdivision (b) of Section 22004, unless that information is reasonably necessary to perform the acts described in subdivision (a) of Section 22004.
(g)Before making a referral or lead as described in paragraph (1) of subdivision (a) of Section 22004 in connection with any loan subject to this division, a licensed broker shall provide the prospective borrower a written disclosure that shows in clear and distinct terms the method of compensation provided to the licensed broker, including whether the compensation is based on the size of a loan or contingent on the referral or lead resulting in a consummated loan.
(h)Before consummating a loan subject to this division, a licensed finance lender shall provide the prospective borrower a written disclosure that shows in clear and distinct terms the amount paid to any broker in connection with the loan, and how the compensation was determined, including whether the compensation was based on the size of a loan or contingent on the referral or lead resulting in a consummated loan.
(i)A finance lender or broker shall not employ a mortgage loan originator whose license or license endorsement has lapsed.
(j)A finance lender or broker may not make or broker a residential mortgage loan unless that loan is offered by, negotiated by, or applied for through a licensed mortgage loan originator.
(k)Every licensee engaged in the business of making or brokering residential mortgage loans and every mortgage loan originator licensed under this division shall register with and maintain a valid unique identifier issued by the Nationwide Mortgage Licensing System and Registry.
(l)An individual shall not engage in the business of a mortgage loan originator with respect to any dwelling located in this state without first obtaining and maintaining annually a license in accordance with the requirements of this division and any rules promulgated by the commissioner under this chapter.
(m)A registered mortgage loan originator, as defined in subdivision (c) of Section 22013, is exempt from licensure under this section when he or she is employed by:
(1)A depository institution.
(2)A subsidiary of a depository institution that is owned and controlled by a depository institution and regulated by a federal banking agency.
(3)An institution regulated by the Farm Credit Administration.
SEC. 3.Section 22602 of the Financial Code is amended to read:22602.(a)Notwithstanding subdivision (c) of Section 22100, a licensed finance lender may pay compensation to a person that is not licensed pursuant to this division in connection with a referral or lead as described in paragraph (1) of subdivision (a) of Section 22004 of one or more prospective borrowers to the licensee, when all of the following conditions are met:
(1)The referral or lead by the unlicensed person leads to the consummation of a commercial loan, as defined in Section 22502, between the licensee and the prospective borrower referred or lead by the unlicensed person.
(2)The commercial loan contract provides for an annual percentage rate that does not exceed 36 percent.
(3)Before approving the commercial loan, the licensee does both of the following:
(A)Obtains documentation from the prospective borrower documenting the borrowers commercial status. Examples of acceptable forms of documentation include, but are not limited to, a sellers permit, business license, articles of incorporation, income tax returns showing business income, or bank account statements showing business income.
(B)Performs underwriting and obtains documentation to ensure that the prospective borrower will have sufficient monthly gross revenue with which to repay the loan pursuant to the loan terms, and does not make a loan if it determines through its underwriting that the prospective borrowers total monthly expenses, including debt service payments on the loan for which the prospective borrower is being considered, will exceed the prospective borrowers monthly gross revenue. Examples of acceptable forms of documentation for verifying current and projected gross monthly revenue and monthly expenses include, but are not limited to, tax returns, bank statements, merchant financial statements, business plans, business history, and industry-specific knowledge and experience. If the prospective borrower is a sole proprietor or a corporation and the loan will be secured by a personal guarantee provided by the owner of the corporation, a credit report from at least one consumer credit reporting agency that compiles and maintains files on consumers on a nationwide basis shall also be considered.
(4)The licensee maintains records of all compensation paid to unlicensed persons in connection with the referral or lead of borrowers for a period of at least four years.
(5)The licensee annually submits information requested by the commissioner regarding the payment of compensation in the report required pursuant to Section 22159.
(b)An unlicensed person that is paid compensation pursuant to this section shall do the following:(1)Comply with Section 22161.(2)Not solicit or collect confidential data, as defined in subdivision (b) of Section 22004 unless that information is reasonably necessary to perform the acts described in subdivision (a) of Section 22004.(3)Before making a referral or lead as described in paragraph (1) of subdivision (a) of Section 22004 in connection with any loan subject to this division, provide the prospective borrower a written disclosure that shows in clear and distinct terms the method of compensation provided to the licensed broker, including whether the compensation is based on the size of a loan or contingent on the referral or lead resulting in a consummated loan.(c)A licensee that pays compensation to an unlicensed person pursuant to this section shall be liable for any known violation of that compensated person of paragraphs (1) to (3), inclusive, of subdivision (b). (d)(b)This section does not authorize an unlicensed person to perform any of the activities described in paragraphs (2) to (6), inclusive, of subdivision (a) of Section 22004. 22004, unless the person meets one or more of the following criteria:
(e)The prohibition in subdivision (d) does not apply if the unlicensed person meets one or more of the following criteria:(1)Is exempt from licensure under this division.
(2)Is exempt from federal income taxes under Section 501(c)(3) of the Internal Revenue Code.
(3)Is a business assistance organization recognized by the United States Small Business Administration.
(4)Is engaged in one or more of the activities described in paragraphs (2) to (6), inclusive, of subdivision (a) of Section 22004 in connection with five or fewer commercial loans in a calendar year made by persons licensed under this division.
(f)(c)The commissioner may adopt regulations under this section to impose conditions on the referral or lead activity authorized under this section. The commissioner may classify persons, loans, loan terms, referral or lead methods, and other matters within his or her jurisdiction, and may prescribe different requirements for different classes of loans.
(g)(d)Nothing in this section shall authorize the payment of a referral or lead fee to an unlicensed person for a residential mortgage loan, nor the payment of a referral or lead fee to a person required to be licensed under Section 10131 or 10131.1 of the Business and Professions Code, unless that person is licensed by the Bureau of Real Estate pursuant to Division 4 (commencing with Section 10000) of the Business and Professions Code.
(h)(e)A licensed finance lender may, pursuant to this section, pay compensation to an unlicensed person to provide services described in subdivision (c) of Section 22004. A licensed finance lender that pays compensation pursuant to this subdivision shall not be subject to the requirements of paragraphs (1) through (5), inclusive, of subdivision (a).
SEC. 4.Section 22604 of the Financial Code is amended to read:22604.(a)Any person that receives compensation in connection with a referral, as described in Section 22602, that leads to the consummation of a commercial loan under this division may pursuant to subdivision (a) or (e) of Section 22602 shall not do any of the following:
(1)Make a materially false or misleading statement or representation to a prospective borrower about the terms or conditions of a prospective loan.
(2)Advertise, print, display, publish, distribute, or broadcast any statement or representation with regard to the conditions for making or negotiating a loan that is false, misleading, or deceptive, or that omits material information that is necessary to make the statements made not false, misleading, or deceptive.
(3)Engage in any act in violation of Section 17200 of the Business and Professions Code.
(4)Commit an act that constitutes fraud or dishonest dealings.
(5)Fail to safeguard a prospective borrowers personally identifiable information. confidential data, as defined in subdivision (b) of Section 22004.
(b)For purposes of this section, personally identifiable information means information that is not publicly available, that a prospective borrower provides for the purpose of obtaining a loan or other financial product. Personally identifiable information includes information a prospective borrower provides on an application to obtain a loan, credit card, or other financial product or service.(b)In addition to the prohibitions set forth in subdivision (a), a person who receives compensation pursuant to subdivision (a) of Section 22602 shall comply with both of the following:
(1)Shall not solicit or collect confidential data, as defined in subdivision (b) of Section 22004, unless that information is reasonably necessary to make the referral or lead.
(2)Shall, prior to making the referral or lead, provide the prospective buyer with a written disclosure that shows in clear and distinct terms, the method of compensation provided by the licensed lender, including whether the compensation is based on the size of the loan or contingent upon the referral or lead resulting in a consummated loan.
(c)Whenever, in the opinion of the commissioner, any person is engaged in the business of soliciting borrowers for a loan to be made by a licensee under this division, and the person is not in compliance with this section, Section 22602, Section 22603, who receives compensation pursuant to subdivision (a) or (e) of Section 22602, violates this section or any other provision of this division authorizing such activity or exempting the person from this division, the commissioner may order the person to desist and to refrain from engaging in the business or further violating this division.
SEC. 4.SEC. 5.No reimbursement is required by this act pursuant to Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution because the only costs that may be incurred by a local agency or school district will be incurred because this act creates a new crime or infraction, eliminates a crime or infraction, or changes the penalty for a crime or infraction, within the meaning of Section 17556 of the Government Code, or changes the definition of a crime within the meaning of Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution.
(a)Broker includes any person who is engaged in the business of negotiating or performing any act as broker in connection with loans made by a finance lender. lender, unless otherwise exempt pursuant to Section 22050, including, but not limited to, any of the following acts:
(1)Providing a referral or a lead to one or more finance lenders for compensation or expected compensation if the referral or lead conveys confidential data. For the purposes of this subdivision, a referral or lead is considered to convey confidential data when either of the following occurs:
(A)Confidential data about a referral or lead is transmitted to the finance lender.
(B)The referral or lead is provided pursuant to an agreement under which a finance lender only compensates the referral or lead provider for a referral or lead that both:
(i)Meets certain, agreed-upon criteria involving confidential data.
(ii)Leads to a person obtaining a loan from the finance lender.
(2)Participating in any loan negotiation between a finance lender and prospective borrower.
(3)Counseling, advising, or making recommendations to a borrower about a loan based on a borrowers confidential data.
(4)Participating in the preparation of any loan documents, including loan applications, other than providing a borrower blank copies of loan documents. Transmitting information that is not confidential data at the request of a prospective borrower or loan applicant shall not, by itself, constitute participation in the preparation of loan documents.
(5)Communicating lending decisions or inquiries between a finance lender and a borrower.
(6)Charging any fees to a prospective borrower or applicant for any services related to a prospective borrowers or applicants application for a loan from a finance lender.
(b)(1)For purposes of this section, confidential data means information about a borrower, prospective borrower, or applicant that is nonpublic and sensitive. The term confidential data includes, but is not limited to, any of the following:
(A)Bank account number or routing number.
(B)Bank statement.
(C)Credit or debit card account number.
(D)Credit score, as defined in subdivision (b) of Section 1785.15.1 of the Civil Code, either self-reported by the person it relates to, or received from a credit reporting agency as part of an official request.
(E)Social security number, including both a persons full social security number or a partial number.
(F)Personal or business income information, including information self-reported by the person.
(G)Drivers license number or government-issued identification number.
(H)Passport number.
(I)Personal employment data or history.
(J)Date of birth.
(K)Mothers maiden name.
(L)Medical information.
(M)Health insurance information.
(N)Insurance policy number.
(O)Taxpayer or employer identification number.
(2)The term confidential data does not include any of the following:
(A)Name.
(B)Phone number.
(C)Physical address.
(D)Email address.
(E)Desired loan or financing amount.
(F)Borrowers stated purpose for a loan.
(G)In connection with a commercial loan, confidential data does not include business name, business address, business phone number, or a businesss self-reported range of income, in addition to the other information listed in this paragraph.
(c)A person shall not be deemed a broker if both of the following are met:
(1)The person only distributes or otherwise disseminates to a prospective borrower or applicant a finance lenders marketing materials or factual information about the finance lender and its loan products, such as the finance lenders interest rates, minimum or maximum loan amounts or loan periods, or a general description of the finance lenders underwriting criteria.
(2)The person does not engage in any of the other acts specified in subdivision (a).
(d)This section does not apply to any person who performs the acts described in subdivision (a) five or fewer times in a calendar year.
SEC. 2.Section 22100 of the Financial Code is amended to read:22100.(a)No A person shall not engage in the business of a finance lender or broker without obtaining a license from the commissioner.
(b)Every licensee engaging in the business of making or brokering residential mortgage loans shall require that every mortgage loan originator employed or compensated by that licensee obtains and maintains a mortgage loan originator license from the commissioner under this division or Division 20 (commencing with Section 50000), or has first obtained a license endorsement from the Commissioner of Real Estate pursuant to Article 2.1 (commencing with Section 10166.01) of Chapter 3 of Part 1 of Division 4 of the Business and Professions Code.
(c)Except as provided in subdivision (a) of Section 22602, a finance lender shall not compensate a person for any of the acts described in subdivision (a) of Section 22004 unless that person is a licensed broker pursuant to this division.
(d)A licensee shall not compensate a broker for services related to a loan subject to this division if the broker is known to have committed any violation of Section 22161 in connection with that loan.
(e)A licensee shall not, in connection with any loan subject to this division, directly or indirectly pass through to a borrower the licensees cost of compensating a broker.
(f)A licensed broker shall not solicit or collect confidential data, as defined in subdivision (b) of Section 22004, unless that information is reasonably necessary to perform the acts described in subdivision (a) of Section 22004.
(g)Before making a referral or lead as described in paragraph (1) of subdivision (a) of Section 22004 in connection with any loan subject to this division, a licensed broker shall provide the prospective borrower a written disclosure that shows in clear and distinct terms the method of compensation provided to the licensed broker, including whether the compensation is based on the size of a loan or contingent on the referral or lead resulting in a consummated loan.
(h)Before consummating a loan subject to this division, a licensed finance lender shall provide the prospective borrower a written disclosure that shows in clear and distinct terms the amount paid to any broker in connection with the loan, and how the compensation was determined, including whether the compensation was based on the size of a loan or contingent on the referral or lead resulting in a consummated loan.
(c)(i)A finance lender or broker shall not employ a mortgage loan originator whose license or license endorsement has lapsed.
(d)(j)A finance lender or broker may not make or broker a residential mortgage loan unless that loan is offered by, negotiated by, or applied for through a licensed mortgage loan originator.
(e)(k)Every licensee engaged in the business of making or brokering residential mortgage loans and every mortgage loan originator licensed under this division shall register with and maintain a valid unique identifier issued by the Nationwide Mortgage Licensing System and Registry.
(f)(l)An individual shall not engage in the business of a mortgage loan originator with respect to any dwelling located in this state without first obtaining and maintaining annually a license in accordance with the requirements of this division and any rules promulgated by the commissioner under this chapter.
(g)(m)A registered mortgage loan originator, as defined in subdivision (c) of Section 22013, is exempt from licensure under this section when he or she is employed by:
(1)A depository institution.
(2)A subsidiary of a depository institution that is owned and controlled by a depository institution and regulated by a federal banking agency.
(3)An institution regulated by the Farm Credit Administration.
SEC. 3.Section 22602 of the Financial Code is amended to read:22602.(a)A licensee that is a finance lender Notwithstanding subdivision (c) of Section 22100, a licensed finance lender may pay compensation to a person that is not licensed pursuant to this division in connection with the a referral or lead as described in paragraph (1) of subdivision (a) of Section 22004 of one or more prospective borrowers to the licensee, when all of the following conditions are met:
(1)The referral or lead by the unlicensed person leads to the consummation of a commercial loan, as defined in Section 22502, between the licensee and the prospective borrower referred or lead by the unlicensed person.
(2)The commercial loan contract provides for an annual percentage rate that does not exceed 36 percent.
(3)Before approving the commercial loan, the licensee does both of the following:
(A)Obtains documentation from the prospective borrower documenting the borrowers commercial status. Examples of acceptable forms of documentation include, but are not limited to, a sellers permit, business license, articles of incorporation, income tax returns showing business income, or bank account statements showing business income.
(B)Performs underwriting and obtains documentation to ensure that the prospective borrower will have sufficient monthly gross revenue with which to repay the loan pursuant to the loan terms, and does not make a loan if it determines through its underwriting that the prospective borrowers total monthly expenses, including debt service payments on the loan for which the prospective borrower is being considered, will exceed the prospective borrowers monthly gross revenue. Examples of acceptable forms of documentation for verifying current and projected gross monthly revenue and monthly expenses include, but are not limited to, tax returns, bank statements, merchant financial statements, business plans, business history, and industry-specific knowledge and experience. If the prospective borrower is a sole proprietor or a corporation and the loan will be secured by a personal guarantee provided by the owner of the corporation, a credit report from at least one consumer credit reporting agency that compiles and maintains files on consumers on a nationwide basis shall also be considered.
(4)The licensee maintains records of all compensation paid to unlicensed persons in connection with the referral or lead of borrowers for a period of at least four years.
(5)The licensee annually submits information requested by the commissioner regarding the payment of compensation in the report required pursuant to Section 22159.
(b)An unlicensed person that is paid compensation pursuant to this section shall do the following:
(b)(1)Comply with Section 22161.
(2)Not solicit or collect confidential data, as defined in subdivision (b) of Section 22004 unless that information is reasonably necessary to perform the acts described in subdivision (a) of Section 22004.
(3)Before making a referral or lead as described in paragraph (1) of subdivision (a) of Section 22004 in connection with any loan subject to this division, provide the prospective borrower a written disclosure that shows in clear and distinct terms the method of compensation provided to the licensed broker, including whether the compensation is based on the size of a loan or contingent on the referral or lead resulting in a consummated loan.
(c)A licensee that pays compensation to a an unlicensed person that is not licensed pursuant to this division in connection with a referral for a commercial loan made by that licensee to a borrower pursuant to this section shall be liable for any misrepresentation made to that borrower in connection with that loan. known violation of that compensated person of paragraphs (1) to (3), inclusive, of subdivision (b).
(c)The following activities by an unlicensed person are not authorized by this section:(1)Participating in any loan negotiation.(2)Counseling or advising the borrower about a loan.(3)Participating in the preparation of any loan documents, including credit applications.(4)Contacting the licensee on behalf of the borrower other than to refer the borrower.(5)Gathering loan documentation from the borrower or delivering the documentation to the licensee.(6)Communicating lending decisions or inquiries to the borrower.(7)Participating in establishing any sales literature or marketing materials.(8)Obtaining the borrowers signature on documents.(d)This section does not authorize an unlicensed person to perform any of the activities described in paragraphs (2) to (6), inclusive, of subdivision (a) of Section 22004.
(d)(e)The prohibitions prohibition in subdivision (c) do (d) does not apply if the unlicensed person meets one or more of the following criteria:
(1)Is exempt from licensure under this division.
(2)Is exempt from federal income taxes under Section 501(c)(3) of the Internal Revenue Code.
(3)Is a business assistance organization recognized by the United States Small Business Administration.
(4)Is engaged in one or more of the activities described in paragraphs (1) to (8), inclusive, of subdivision (c) paragraphs (2) to (6), inclusive, of subdivision (a) of Section 22004 in connection with five or fewer commercial loans in a 12-month period calendar year made by persons licensed under this division.
(e)(f)The commissioner may adopt regulations under this section to impose conditions on the referral or lead activity authorized under this section. The commissioner may classify persons, loans, loan terms, referral or lead methods, and other matters within his or her jurisdiction, and may prescribe different requirements for different classes of loans.
(f)(g)Nothing in this section shall authorize the payment of a referral or lead fee to an unlicensed person for a residential mortgage loan, nor the payment of a referral or lead fee to a person required to be licensed under Section 10131 or 10131.1 of the Business and Professions Code, unless such that person is licensed by the Bureau of Real Estate pursuant to Division 4 (commencing with Section 10000) of the Business and Professions Code.
(g)For the purposes of this section, referral means either the introduction of the borrower and the finance lender or the delivery to the finance lender of the borrowers contact information.(h)A licensed finance lender may, pursuant to this section, pay compensation to an unlicensed person to provide services described in subdivision (c) of Section 22004. A licensed finance lender that pays compensation pursuant to this subdivision shall not be subject to the requirements of paragraphs (1) through (5), inclusive, of subdivision (a).
SEC. 4.No reimbursement is required by this act pursuant to Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution because the only costs that may be incurred by a local agency or school district will be incurred because this act creates a new crime or infraction, eliminates a crime or infraction, or changes the penalty for a crime or infraction, within the meaning of Section 17556 of the Government Code, or changes the definition of a crime within the meaning of Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution.
SECTION 1.Section 14001 of the Financial Code is amended to read:14001.The definitions provided in this division govern the construction of this division unless the context otherwise requires.The definitions given provided in this division govern the construction of this division unless the context otherwise requires.
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Aug 16, 2018 | In committee: Held under submission. |
| Aug 6, 2018 | In committee: Referred to APPR. suspense file. |
| Jul 5, 2018 | Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Jul 3, 2018 | From committee: Amend, and do pass as amended and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 5. Noes 1.) (June 27). |
| Jun 18, 2018 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to committee. Read second time, amended, and re-referred to Com. on B. & F.I. |
| Jun 14, 2018 | In committee: Set, first hearing. Hearing canceled at the request of author. |
| Jun 13, 2018 | Referred to Com. on B. & F.I. |
| Jun 4, 2018 | In Senate. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. |
| May 31, 2018 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Senate. |
| May 29, 2018 | Read third time and amended. Ordered to third reading. |
| May 25, 2018 | From committee: Do pass. (Ayes 12. Noes 4.) (May 25). |
| May 16, 2018 | In committee: Set, first hearing. Referred to APPR. suspense file. |
| May 14, 2018 | Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| May 10, 2018 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to Com. on APPR. Read second time and amended. |
| Apr 24, 2018 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 8. Noes 2.) (April 23). Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Apr 18, 2018 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on B. & F. (Ayes 7. Noes 3.) (April 17). Re-referred to Com. on B. & F. |
| Apr 5, 2018 | Re-referred to Com. on P. & C.P. |
| Apr 4, 2018 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to Com. on P. & C.P. Read second time and amended. |
| Apr 2, 2018 | Re-referred to Com. on B. & F. |
| Mar 22, 2018 | Referred to Coms. on B. & F. and P. & C.P. |
| Feb 17, 2018 | From printer. May be heard in committee March 19. |
| Feb 16, 2018 | Read first time. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Aug 6, 2018 | Placed on suspense file | Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Jun 27, 2018 | Do pass as amended, but first amend, and re-refer to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Senate Standing Committee on Banking and Financial Institutions |
Passed |
|
| May 31, 2018 | AB 3207 LIMÓN Assembly Third Reading | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| May 25, 2018 | Do pass. | Assembly Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Apr 23, 2018 | Do pass and be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Assembly Standing Committee on Banking and Finance |
Passed |
|
| Apr 17, 2018 | Do pass and be re-referred to the Committee on [Banking and Finance] | Assembly Standing Committee on Privacy and Consumer Protection |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
|
Organization
|
Position
|
Date
|
|---|---|---|
| Avenue Link | ** Against | Jun 25, 2018 |
| California Financial Service Providers | * Against | Jun 27, 2018 |
| California Financial Services Association | ** Support | Jun 25, 2018 |
| California Low-Income Consumer Coalition | * Support | Jun 27, 2018 |
| Center For Responsible Lending | * Support | Jun 27, 2018 |
| City and County of San Francisco | ** Support | Apr 20, 2018 |
| Clergy & Laity United for Economic Justice | ** Support | Jun 25, 2018 |
| Commercial Finance Coalition | ** Against | Jun 25, 2018 |
| Consumers For Auto Reliability And Safety | ** Support | Jun 25, 2018 |
| Consumers Union | * Support | Jun 27, 2018 |
| Credit Karma | * Neutral | Jun 27, 2018 |
| Curo | ** Against | Jun 25, 2018 |
| Department Of Business Oversight | ** Support | Jun 25, 2018 |
| Dot818 | ** Against | Jun 25, 2018 |
| Electronic Transactions Association | ** Against | Jun 25, 2018 |
| Elevate | * Against | Jun 27, 2018 |
| Enova | ** Against | Jun 25, 2018 |
| Equipment Leasing And Financing Association | ** Against | Apr 25, 2018 |
| Equipment Leasing and Financing Association | * Indeterminate | Apr 23, 2018 |
| Lead Economy | ** Against | Jun 25, 2018 |
| Lead Flash | ** Against | Jun 25, 2018 |
| Lead Flash | * Against | Jun 27, 2018 |
| LeadsCon | * Against | Jun 27, 2018 |
| Leadsmarket | ** Against | Jun 25, 2018 |
| Lendingtree | ** Against | Jun 25, 2018 |
| LendingTree | * Neutral | Jun 27, 2018 |
| Nerd Wallet | * Neutral | Jun 27, 2018 |
| New Economics for Women | ** Support | Jun 25, 2018 |
| On Deck | ** Support | Jun 25, 2018 |
| OnDeck Capital | * Support | Jun 27, 2018 |
| Online Lenders Alliance | ** Against | Jun 25, 2018 |
| Online Lending Alliance | * Against | Jun 27, 2018 |
| Quinstreet | ** Against | Jun 25, 2018 |
| San Francisco Office Of Economic Empowerment | ** Support | Jun 25, 2018 |
| Small Business Finance Association | * Against | Jun 27, 2018 |
| The Lead Group | ** Against | Jun 25, 2018 |
| TMX Finance | * Against | Jun 27, 2018 |
| Unova | * Against | Jun 27, 2018 |
| western center on law and poverty | ** Support | Jun 25, 2018 |
| Zero Parallel | ** Against | Jun 25, 2018 |
SENATE COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Senator Anthony Portantino, Chair
2017 - 2018 Regular Session
AB 3207 (Limón) - California Financing Law
Version: July 5, 2018 | Policy Vote: B. & F.I. 5 - 1 |
Urgency: No | Mandate: Yes |
Hearing Date: August 6, 2018 | Consultant: Debra Cooper |
This bill meets the criteria for referral to the Suspense File.
Bill Summary:
AB 3207 would modify the definition of a broker under the California Financing Law (CFL) and modify the rules applicable to finance brokers and to finance lenders that use the services of brokers, as specified. This bill would also require the Department of Business (DBO) to examine the CFL licensees at least once every 48 months.
Fiscal Impact:
DBO would require additional examiners to examine each CFL licensee at least once every four years. The number of additional examiners would be dependent on the specific needs of DBO. If DBO were to hire an additional two personnel, the department would incur costs of approximately $325,000. If their needs are greater the cost for additional personnel would increase. These costs would be recouped from fees charged on the licensees.
Background:
CFL requires licensing and regulation of finance lenders and brokers making and brokering consumer and commercial loans. CFL (previously California Finance Lenders Law) was created before the prevalence of the internet and activities that are common in today’s online consumer and business lending marketplaces. Introducing prospective borrowers to prospective lenders online without helping to negotiate the terms of the loan is colloquially known as lead generation, and online lead generation is becoming increasingly prevalent. While lead generation can be beneficial to borrowers and lenders, it can also be predatory and harm borrowers.
CFL and its predecessor laws have lacked a robust definition of personal loan brokering. The CFL currently defines a broker as any person who is engaged in the business of negotiating or performing any act as a broker in connection with loans made by a finance lender. This bill aims to provide a more distinct definition of a finance broker to cover lead generation and traditional brokering.
DBO currently has a mandatory cycle of examination for many of the license types that they oversee; however, there is no statutory frequency for examining CFL licensees. DBO also currently lacks express authority to examine affiliates of CFL licensees. Additionally, DBO does not have express authority to substitute an exam of one of its CFL licensees that was conducted by another state or federal agency. This bill would require DBO to perform examinations on CFL licensees at least once every four years and would grant DBO the authority to examine CFL licensee affiliates and substitute an exam from another agency.
Proposed Law:
Among other things, this bill would:
- Specify the definition of broker and the authorized and prohibited actions of a broker;
- Specify the definitions of a referral and confidential data;
- Specify the required and prohibited actions of a finance lender;
- Require the commissioner of DBO to examine every finance lender, finance broker, and program administrator licensee at least once every 48 months and as often as the commissioner deems necessary and appropriate. This bill would also authorize the commissioner to cooperate with any agency of the state or federal government and may accept an examination conducted by a state or federal agency;
- Require the commissioner, after conducting an examination, to provide a copy of the written statement of findings of the examination; issue a copy to each licensee’s principals, officers, or directors; and take appropriate steps to ensure correction of any violations of the CFL;
- Authorize the commissioner to subject an affiliate of a licensee to examination on the same terms as the licensee, but only when reports from, or examination of, a licensee provides documented evidence of unlawful activity between a licensee and the affiliate benefitting or affecting the licensee or the affiliate or arising from the activities regulated by the CFL.
Related Legislation:
AB 2984 (Limon, 2018) among other things, would have required commissioner of DBO to examine the affairs of each finance lender licensee for compliance at least once every 48 months. It was held on the Assembly Appropriations Committee Suspense File.
SB 297 (Dodd, 2017) would have required lead generators, as defined, to register with DBO, provide specified disclosures, adhere to specified rules, and refrain from engaging in prohibited activity, and would have given the Commissioner of DBO regulatory and enforcement authority over lead generators, as specified. It was held on the Senate Appropriations Committee Suspense File.
-- END --
SENATE COMMITTEE ON
BANKING AND FINANCIAL INSTITUTIONS
Senator Steven Bradford, Chair
2017 - 2018 Regular
Bill No: AB 3207 Hearing Date: June 27, 2018
Author: | Limón | ||
Version: | June 18, 2018 Amended | ||
Urgency: | No | Fiscal: | Yes |
Consultant: | Eileen Newhall | ||
Subject: California Financing Law.
SUMMARY
This bill modifies the definition of a broker under the California Financing Law and modifies the rules applicable to finance brokers and to finance lenders that use the services of brokers, as specified. This bill also requires the Department of Business Oversight to examine California Financing Law licensees at least once every 48 months, as specified.
EXISTING LAW
- Provides for the California Financing Law (CFL; Financial Code Section 22000 et seq.), administered by the Department of Business Oversight (DBO). The CFL regulates secured and unsecured, consumer-purpose and commercial-purpose loans made by nondepository institutions and Property Assessed Clean Energy financing arranged by program administrators, as specified.
- Defines a broker, pursuant to the CFL, as any person who is engaged in the business of negotiating or performing any act as broker in connection with loans made by a finance lender (Financial Code Section 22004).
- Provides that no person shall engage in the business of a finance lender or finance broker without obtaining a license from the Commissioner of Business Oversight (commissioner; Financial Code Section 22100).
- Authorizes a licensed finance lender to act as a finance broker at its licensed place of business without obtaining an additional license as a broker, provided the lender notifies the commissioner in writing (Financial Code Section 22167).
- Prohibits a finance lender from paying any compensation to an unlicensed person or company for soliciting or accepting applications for loans. This prohibition does not apply to the payment of compensation to an employee of the lender or to a real estate broker, or to compensation paid for any brokerage service provided by a bank, savings and loan association, or other financial institution exempted from the CFL (10 California Code of Regulations, Title 10, Section 1451).
- Contains two limited exceptions to the prohibition against compensating unlicensed persons in connection with the solicitation or acceptance of applications for loans made by a finance lender:
- Lenders accepted to participate in the Pilot Program for Increased Access to Responsible Small-Dollar Loans (pilot program) may use the services of one or more unlicensed finders, as specified (Financial Code Sections 22371 through 22376).
- CFL licensees that make commercial loans may compensate unlicensed persons in connection with the referral of one or more prospective borrowers, when all of the following occur: the referral leads to a consummated loan, the loan contract provides for an annual percentage rate that does not exceed 36%, the licensee follows specified requirements when underwriting the loan, the licensee maintains records of all compensation paid to unlicensed persons, and the licensee annually submits information to the commissioner (Financial Code Sections 22602 through 22604).
- Lenders accepted to participate in the Pilot Program for Increased Access to Responsible Small-Dollar Loans (pilot program) may use the services of one or more unlicensed finders, as specified (Financial Code Sections 22371 through 22376).
- Defines a mortgage loan originator as an individual who, for compensation or gain, or in the expectation of compensation or gain, takes a residential mortgage loan application or offers or negotiates terms of a residential mortgage loan (Financial Code Section 22013). Provides that a mortgage loan originator does not include an individual who performs purely administrative or clerical tasks on behalf of a person meeting the definition of a mortgage loan originator, and provides that the term “administrative or clerical tasks” means the receipt, collection, and distribution of information common for the processing or underwriting of a loan in the mortgage industry and communication with a consumer to obtain information necessary for the processing or underwriting of a residential mortgage loan, to the extent that the communication does not include offering or negotiating loan rates or terms, or counseling consumers about residential mortgage loan rates or terms.
CFL EXAMINATION POLICIES
- Provides that, for the purpose of discovering violations of the CFL or securing information required by the commissioner to administer and enforce the CFL, the commissioner may, at any time, investigate the loans, assessment contracts, and business and the books, accounts, records, and files used in the business of every person engaged in the business of a finance lender, broker, or program administrator (Financial Code Section 22701).
THIS BILL
LEAD GENERATION AND BROKERING PROVISIONS
- Defines a referral as the introduction of a prospective borrower to a finance lender or the delivery of a prospective borrower’s contact information to a finance lender for the purposes of making an introduction.
- Defines a broker as any person not otherwise exempt from the CFL, who is engaged in the business of performing any of the following acts more than five times in a calendar year in connection with loans made by a finance lender. Activities described in 2a and 2b will be described as lead generation activities in the remainder of this analysis, and activities described in 2c through 2g will be described as non-lead generation brokering activities in the remainder of this analysis.
- Transmitting confidential data about a prospective borrower to a finance lender with the expectation of compensation, in connection with making a referral.
- Making a referral to a finance lender under an agreement with the finance lender that any prospective borrower referred by the person to the finance lender meet certain criteria involving confidential data and with the expectation that the person making the referral will be compensated if the finance lender and the prospective borrower enter into a loan agreement.
- Participating in any loan negotiation between a finance lender and a prospective borrower.
- Counseling, advising, or making recommendations to a prospective borrower about a loan based on the prospective borrower’s confidential data.
- Participating in the preparation of any loan documents, including loan applications, other than providing a prospective borrower blank copies of loan documents. However, transmitting information that does not constitute confidential data to a finance lender at the request of a prospective borrower does not, in and of itself, constitute preparation of loan documents.
- Communicating to a prospective borrower a finance lender’s loan approval decisions or inquiries involving confidential data.
- Charging a fee to a prospective borrower for any services related to a prospective borrower’s application for a loan from a finance lender.
- Transmitting confidential data about a prospective borrower to a finance lender with the expectation of compensation, in connection with making a referral.
- Provides that a person is not a broker if he or she distributes or disseminates a finance lender’s marketing materials or factual information about the finance lender, its lending activities, its loan products, or a general description of its underwriting criteria, as long as he or she does not perform any of the acts that require a broker’s license.
- Defines confidential data as any of the following: bank account number or bank statement; credit or debit card number; credit score, whether self-reported or received from a credit reporting agency; partial or full social security number; personal or business income information, whether self-reported or received from an official source; government-issued identification number; personal employment data or history; date of birth; mother’s maiden name; medical information; health insurance information; insurance policy number; and taxpayer or employer identification number.
- Provides that confidential data does not include any of the following in connection with a consumer loan: name, phone number, physical address, e-mail address, desired loan or financing amount, prospective borrower’s stated purpose for a loan, or prospective borrower’s self-reported range of credit scores or range of incomes.
- Provides that confidential data does not include any of the following in connection with a commercial loan: information that is considered not to be confidential when provided in connection with a consumer loan; business name, phone number, physical address, e-mail address; desired loan or financing amount; self-reported income; and self-reported credit score of a business owner.
- Prohibits a finance broker from performing an act that represents brokering without first obtaining the prospective borrower’s express consent for that purpose. Clarifies that a licensed broker who obtained the consent of a prospective borrower before the operative date of this bill is deemed to be in compliance with this requirement, as long as that consent was not revoked.
- Prohibits a finance lender from compensating a person who is required to hold a broker’s license, unless that person is licensed as a broker.
- Prohibits a finance lender from compensating a broker for an act that requires a broker’s license if the finance lender has actual knowledge, at the time compensation is to be made, that the broker has violated any provision of the CFL in connection with that loan.
- Prohibits a finance lender from passing an additional fee on to a borrower that is attributable to a referral fee the finance lender paid or will pay, but clarifies that a finance lender may charge a borrower additional fees or costs attributable to non-lead generation brokering activities, if the finance lender pays another person or entity for performing any of those acts for a loan made pursuant to the CFL.
- Deletes the requirement that brokers who engage in non-lead generation brokering activities ensure that a finance lender complies with specified requirements, when a borrower fully pays off his or her loan.
- Requires a finance lender that uses the services of a lead generation broker to provide a specified disclosure to each prospective borrower referred to that lender by a lead generation broker, and have the prospective borrower acknowledge receipt of that disclosure, before the prospective borrower expressly consents to a loan.
- Requires a licensed lead generation broker to provide a specified disclosure to each prospective borrower and to obtain that prospective borrower’s express consent, before performing lead generation activities. Requires the disclosure to be provided before the broker may obtain express consent. Requires the following information to be contained in that disclosure:
- The name and license number of each finance lender to whom the prospective borrower may be referred by the licensed broker.
- The name and contact information of any person who is not a finance lender to whom the prospective borrower may be referred by the licensed broker.
- Whether the compensation that would be paid by each finance lender to whom the prospective borrower is referred by the licensed broker is contingent on the making of a loan to the prospective borrower, and whether the compensation varies based on the principal amount of the loan or the charges provided by the loan agreement.
- A statement that lenders to whom the prospective borrower is referred are not necessarily the best lending options available to the prospective borrower and that lenders to whom the prospective borrower is referred may separately contact the prospective borrower.
- A statement instructing the prospective borrower about how to report a complaint to DBO.
- A statement that the licensed broker will not charge the prospective borrower a fee for the referral.
- The name and license number of each finance lender to whom the prospective borrower may be referred by the licensed broker.
- Imposes a series of requirements on brokers who compensate unlicensed persons for referrals that would have constituted lead generation activities requiring a broker’s license, if those referrals had been made to a licensed finance lender, and requires these brokers to develop, implement, and enforce policies and procedures intended to ensure compliance with those requirements, as specified. Among these requirements is a provision intended to ensure that unlicensed persons do not collect confidential data directly from a prospective borrower for the purpose of referring that borrower to a licensed broker, without first obtaining the prospective borrower’s express consent for that purpose.
- Imposes a disclosure requirement on the unlicensed persons who engage in activities that would have required those unlicensed persons to obtain broker’s licenses for engaging in lead generation activities if they had been making referrals to finance lenders. Those unlicensed persons are required to provide prospective borrowers with all of the following:
- An explanation of the process by which the borrower’s confidential data may be viewed, used by, or transferred between other unlicensed persons, and how the unlicensed person engages in that process.
- A statement that the borrower’s confidential data may ultimately be provided to a licensed broker for the purpose of making a referral to a finance lender and an explanation of how that will occur.
- An explanation of how the unlicensed person will use the confidential data of a prospective borrower to identify a finance lender that may offer a loan to the prospective borrower.
- An explanation of the process by which the borrower’s confidential data may be viewed, used by, or transferred between other unlicensed persons, and how the unlicensed person engages in that process.
- Provides that nothing in the CFL shall be interpreted to impose licensing or regulatory obligations on federally-recognized Indian tribes or business entities that are considered “arms of a tribe” under the test articulated in People ex rel. Owen v. Miami Nation Enterprises (2016) 2 Cal. 5th 222 and any superseding case law.
CFL EXAMINATION POLICIES
- Requires the commissioner to examine every finance lender, finance broker, and program administrator licensee at least once every 48 months and as often as the commissioner deems necessary and appropriate. Provides that the commissioner may, as often as the commissioner deems necessary and appropriate, examine the books, accounts, records, and files used in the licensee’s business, in order to discover violations of the CFL or to secure information required to enforce the CFL. Clarifies that the commissioner may cooperate with any agency of the state or federal government and may (but need not) accept an examination conducted by a state or federal agency in place of the “once every 48-month” examination.
- Requires the commissioner, after conducting an examination of a licensee, to do all of the following: provide a copy of the written statement of findings of the examination; provide a copy to each licensee’s principals, officers, or directors; and take appropriate steps to ensure correction of any violations of the CFL.
- Authorizes the commissioner to subject an affiliate of a licensee to examination on the same terms as the licensee, but only when reports from or examination of a licensee provides documented evidence of unlawful activity between a licensee and the affiliate that benefits, affects, or arises from the activities regulated by the CFL.
COMMENTS
- Purpose: This bill is sponsored by the author to update the definition of broker in the CFL and specify which activities require a broker’s license. The author expects that this clarification will increase the number of licensed brokers. Codifying a required examination cycle for CFL licensees is intended to ensure that these new licensees are conducting business according to the new law.
- Background: This bill contains two different sets of provisions. The first, related to licensing lead generators as brokers, was heard and passed by the Assembly, albeit in a different form than the version before this Committee. The second, related to CFL examinations, was amended into this bill on June 18th. This provision was previously contained in AB 2984 (Limon), a measure that was held on the Assembly Appropriations Committee Suspense File in May, 2018.
- What is Lead Generation? Lead generation is a marketing tool that introduces consumers who are interested in goods or services with merchants or providers who can offer them. As is clear to anyone who searches for a good or a service on the Internet, online lead generation websites are extremely common. Anyone who has ever searched for a plane ticket on Expedia.com or Travelocity.com, for a handyman on Homeadvisor.com, or has researched assisted living facilities on APlaceForMom.com has used the services of a lead generation website.
Within the lending context, lead generators collect information from consumers and small businesses seeking loans and sell that information to lenders seeking to extend credit to these groups. Borrowers who use lead generators to help them obtain loans can often compare different lenders and loan terms, before selecting the combination in which they are most interested. Lead generators may also help connect consumers with lenders they might not have readily found on their own. Lenders can use lead generators to cost-effectively and efficiently identify prospective borrowers who are interested in and eligible for the loans they are offering and, in doing so, can reduce their borrower acquisition costs. Because of its targeted nature, lead generation is often more cost-effective than other, less-targeted forms of direct marketing.
However, as is the case with other forms of marketing, lead generation can be performed in unscrupulous ways that confuse and mislead borrowers via aggressive or potentially deceptive advertising claims. Unscrupulous lead generators can also harm prospective borrowers by misusing their confidential information.
Increasingly, lead generation that is performed in connection with lending is receiving scrutiny from state and federal regulators. Calling lead generation “the most pervasive industry that nobody knows about,” the Federal Trade Commission (FTC) sponsored a workshop and published a white paper in 2016 to call attention to the consumer protection implications of lead generation (https://www.ftc.gov/news-events/blogs/business-blog/2016/09/ftc-staff-perspective-lead-generation); see discussion below.
DBO has also begun applying increased scrutiny to CFL lenders that use the services of lead generators, out of concern for the consumers who use lead generation websites to help find loans online. However, because the CFL was written long before the Internet was developed, that law is silent on several activities that are now common, including the act of introducing prospective borrowers to prospective lenders online, without helping to negotiate the terms of the loan. This bill is an attempt to modernize the CFL to add a regulatory framework designed to protect persons who use lead generators to obtain installment loans. - FTC White Paper on Lead Generation: To date, the FTC is the only government agency that has studied lead generation in detail and issued a public report summarizing its findings. In its September, 2016 “Follow the Lead” white paper, the FTC stated,
Online lead generation is nearly ubiquitous in the modern marketplace, connecting consumers who are interested in goods or services with the merchants or providers who can offer them. But because lead generators often operate behind the scenes in complex ways, consumers and many businesses may know little about what they do and how to do it. The process of collecting, preparing, and selling consumer leads can be quite complex, and the roles played by different entities in the lead ecosystem can vary and overlap significantly. Although the mechanics defy simple generalizations, some relatively common elements of lead generation are worth highlighting.
Generally speaking, consumers’ first interaction with online lead generators starts with a website or sites operated by a publisher or affiliate. Publishers are the consumer-facing marketers in the lead generation ecosystem that promote products or services online....A publisher’s website typically contains marketing claims and a web form requesting consumer information. While these websites sometimes expressly identify the merchant brands to which they sell consumer leads, others do not – and instead make more generic marketing claims. Often, publishers are small companies that simply collect consumer information and pass it on to larger, more sophisticated actors in the lead ecosystem. Adding complexity to the process, however, some publishers oversee networks of sub-publishers or sub-affiliates that feed them leads, and with which they contract to create marketing websites and web forms....Once publishers have collected consumer leads (whether directly or through sub-publishers), they frequently send them to aggregators.
Aggregators, generally speaking, are intermediaries that take in leads collected by multiple website publishers and prepare them for sale to their clients – merchants or other aggregators...Unless an aggregator chooses to operate its own websites or engage in consumer-facing marketing, its role may be largely invisible to consumers who fill out online forms. Once an aggregator has processed a batch of leads, it may sell those leads directly to an end-buyer merchant that can offer products and services. Alternatively, it may sell that batch to yet another aggregator – adding more layers to the lead ecosystem....Ultimately, the leads that publishers collect, and that aggregators frequently prepare, are sold to end-buyer merchants or advertisers that can sell consumers the products and services they are seeking. With the leads in hand, merchants will frequently contact consumers directly to provide additional marketing materials and more specific information about a potential transaction.
Between the time consumers first fill out online web forms and the time they are contacted by a merchant (often only a matter of seconds), their personal information can pass through a number of hands and undergo supplementation.
AB 3207 proposes to license the entities that are the final link in the lead generation chain (i.e., the entities that sell leads to lenders). It does not propose to license or give DBO other direct regulatory oversight over the other entities in the lead generation ecosystem, which collect consumers’ confidential data but do not market that data directly to lenders (e.g., sub-publishers, publishers that sell to aggregators, and aggregators that sell to other aggregators).
- Unique Broker Definition: California’s CFL and its predecessor laws have lacked a robust definition of personal loan brokering since their creation in the early 1900s. The CFL currently defines a broker in a circular manner, as any person who is engaged in the business of negotiating or performing any act as broker in connection with loans made by a finance lender.
This bill amends the definition of a finance broker to cover two different types of activities: a) lead generation (described in paragraphs 1 and 2 of proposed Section 22004(a) and b) traditional brokering (described in paragraphs 3 through 7 of proposed Section 22004(a)). In doing so, this bill proposes a definition of loan brokering that is unique in the United States.
Earlier this year, in expectation that the Legislature would be debating the definition of brokering activity under the CFL, Committee staff reached out to the National Conference of State Legislatures (NCSL) to ask how other states define brokering under their consumer lending laws. According to NCSL, 21 states other than California have adopted definitions for consumer-purpose loan brokering.[1] Although the exact wording of the definitions varies by state, virtually all of the definitions are quite similar and cover persons who, for compensation or in expectation of compensation, arrange or attempt to arrange loans; negotiate the terms of loans; act for or on behalf of loan brokers to solicit borrowers; or hold themselves out as loan brokers. In practice, while other states’ definitions do include helping to arrange loans within their brokering definitions, those states do not require lead generators to obtain broker’s licenses. Only one state (North Dakota) includes the act of advertising on behalf of lenders as brokering.
This bill’s definition of loan brokering differs from other states’ definitions in two key ways: a) it includes lead generation activities and b) it includes the ministerial acts of helping a prospective borrower fill out a loan application and communicating a finance lender’s loan approval decision to a prospective borrower. - Should California Adopt a Lead Generator Definition Separate From Brokering? This bill’s bifurcated definition of brokering is not only unique among the 50 states; it also creates drafting challenges. In essence, even though this bill includes lead generation activities within the definition of brokering, the bill envisions two different regulatory schemes for brokers: one applicable to brokers who engage in lead generation activities and one applicable to brokers who engage in more traditional brokering activities. This bill also applies two different sets of rules to lenders who use brokers: one that applies to lenders who use brokers that engage in lead generation activities and one that applies to lenders who use brokers that engage in more traditional brokering activities.
Some of the drafting challenges described above would be mitigated if California adopted a lead generation definition and licensing requirement separate from the definition and licensing requirement applicable to brokers. If separate definitions and licensing requirements are adopted, entities engaging in lead generation would be called lead generators and would require lead generator’s licenses, while entities engaging in more traditional forms of brokering would be called brokers and would require broker’s licenses. Entities engaging in both types of activities would require both types of licenses. If separate definitions are adopted, California’s broker definition would be in closer alignment with the definitions adopted by other states, and California would not equate the targeted introduction of prospective borrowers to lenders with the act of actively negotiating loan terms.
- Will This Bill Place Finance Lenders At a Competitive Disadvantage To Other Lenders? As described in more detail below, several of this bill’s provisions impose unclear requirements on entities that meet this bill’s definition of broker as a result of their lead generation activities. Other provisions impose significant liability on these entities. Liability concerns flow not only from lead generators’ potential failure to accurately infer the meaning of this bill’s unclear language, but also from this bill’s decision to call lead generators brokers and, in doing so, subject them to possible litigation over the extent to which that title carries a heightened duty to prospective borrowers. Other provisions impose burdensome disclosure requirements on lead generators, which include a requirement to release proprietary information about their compensation models.
For all of the aforementioned reasons and others discussed in the opposition and amendments sections below, this bill has the potential to encourage lead generators that currently serve California licensed finance lenders to cease engaging in lead generation activities in California on behalf of those lenders, in order to avoid the licensure requirement imposed by this bill. Some companies that would be required to obtain licenses may change their business practices to avoid this bill’s licensing requirement. Other companies that currently hold finance broker licenses may relinquish those licenses or change their business practices to avoid the liability they will incur by holding them.
It is unlikely that lead generators currently serving licensed finance lenders will stop doing business entirely; they will simply stop selling leads to licensed finance lenders, in order to avoid a California licensing requirement. In doing so, they are likely to increase finance lenders’ costs of customer acquisition by depriving those lenders of access to cost-effective lead generation. - CFL Examination Policies: As noted above, this bill contains two distinct provisions: one applicable to lead generators and brokers, and another applicable to CFL examinations. Although the bulk of this analysis focuses on the former provision, a brief discussion of the latter provision is warranted.
The provision of this bill that proposes a 48-month examination cycle for CFL licensees is patterned on a similar section within the California Residential Mortgage Lending Act (CRMLA) and is intended to accomplish three key goals. First, although DBO currently attempts to examine each of its CFL licensees once every four years, it lacks sufficient examination staff to meet this self-imposed requirement. Adding a four-year examination frequency requirement to the CFL will help the department justify a budget request for the additional examiners necessary to achieve its statutorily required exam frequency.
Second, DBO currently lacks express authority to examine affiliates of CFL licensees, if it has evidence to believe that there is unlawful activity occurring between a CFL licensee and its affiliate. This bill would provide the department with that authority.
Third, DBO currently lacks express statutory authority to substitute an exam of one of its CFL licensees that was conducted by another state or federal agency for the requirement to perform its own exam. This bill would give DBO that authority, without requiring the commissioner to use an exam she feels fails to provide the information necessary for her to fulfil his or her responsibilities under the CFL.
Finally, it is important to note that although Section 22701, as proposed to be amended by this bill, is based on a related section in the CRMLA (Financial Code Section 50302), there is one key difference between the two sections. Section 50302 contains language stating, “The statement of the findings of an examination shall belong to the commissioner and shall not be disclosed to anyone other than the licensee, law enforcement officials, or other state or federal regulatory agencies for further investigation and enforcement. Reports required of licensees by the commissioner under this division and results of examinations performed by the commissioner under this division are the property of the commissioner.” This bill does not propose similar language for inclusion in proposed Section 22701, because DBO believes that express statutory language of this sort is unnecessary. The department already has the ability to keep reports of examination confidential pursuant to the Public Records Act (Government Code Section 6254(d)(2)). - Support:
- DBO supports AB 3207 on grounds that it “would help strengthen consumer protections for the millions of Californians who obtain loans from lenders licensed under the CFL by bringing needed clarity to the definition of brokering activity.” By differentiating between acts that are and are not considered brokering under the CFL, AB 3207 “would require lead generators to obtain a CFL broker’s license, bringing lead generation within the confines of the CFL’s brokering provisions. This change will help ensure that consumers gain the protections and safeguards provided by the CFL’s prohibitions against unfair and deceptive business practices. This targeted approach will also modernize the CFL to reflect current market realities without adding additional complexity to the law.”
- A coalition of consumer advocacy groups support the bill on the basis that it will “give DBO, finance lenders, and consumers a clear picture of who can legally provide lead generation services and how those firms are conducting their business.”
- On Deck Capital writes, “AB 3207 recognizes the important differences among conventional brokering activities where the broker actively manages the customer relationship, referral activities where the broker and lender exchange confidential customer data, and passive referral activities where the referral partner simply provides marketing information to potential borrowers along with a link to the lender’s website. These activities present entirely different risks for small business borrowers, and the level of regulatory oversight should be calibrated to match those risks. We support the tailored regulatory approach taken in AB 3207.”
- DBO supports AB 3207 on grounds that it “would help strengthen consumer protections for the millions of Californians who obtain loans from lenders licensed under the CFL by bringing needed clarity to the definition of brokering activity.” By differentiating between acts that are and are not considered brokering under the CFL, AB 3207 “would require lead generators to obtain a CFL broker’s license, bringing lead generation within the confines of the CFL’s brokering provisions. This change will help ensure that consumers gain the protections and safeguards provided by the CFL’s prohibitions against unfair and deceptive business practices. This targeted approach will also modernize the CFL to reflect current market realities without adding additional complexity to the law.”
- Opposition:
- LeadsMarket.com, a lead generator based in California, writes, “AB 3207 fails to understand and respect the way good lead generators work, which is why its good intentions would decimate the industry, leaving only criminals and bad players to interact with consumers. There are several critical (albeit nuanced) flaws with AB 3207, but two that stand out most include: (1) impossible disclosure requirements and (2) an open invite to class action lawyers to run good lead generators out of business. The impossible disclosure requirements are embodied in 22337.5 and 22338.5...the required disclosures simply cannot be made without violating the proposed legislation. Lead generators will risk criminal liability by continuing to do business in California. Lead generators doing business in California will pull out of the state to focus in other more reasonable jurisdictions. Lead generators headquartered in California (already a very challenging jurisdiction for business) will relocate to other states and well-paid IT employees will lose their jobs...if compliance with the law is factually and literally impossible, what other choice is there?”
LeadsMarket.com also takes issue with this bill’s treatment of lead generators as brokers. “Lead generation is not brokering. The two activities are fundamentally different. Tweaking an antiquated law written before modern technology and trying to force lead generation into the CFL’s definition of “broker” without respecting these differences, is a recipe for disaster. Furthermore, how does a convoluted definition of “broker” help consumers understand the distinction between brokering and lead generation?” - Several other lead generators expressed lengthy concerns with provisions of the bill and focused primarily (but not exclusively) on Sections 22337.5 and 22338.5 and on the bill’s treatment of lead generators as brokers. Among the comments: “The author’s outright refusal to create a separate definition for “lead generator” versus “broker” is unjustified and harms the consumer...Separate labels that reflect what consumers already know make it easier for lenders, brokers and lead generators to communicate with consumers. Consumer education should be an integral part of the DBO’s consumer protection activity. It is difficult to imagine how the DBO (or anyone else) would communicate effectively with consumers if such diverse activities are given the same label.”
“The bill blatantly disregards commercially established and accepted business models by inappropriately including lead generation in its definition of brokering activities, instead of defining and treating each business activity separately. A broker is compensated when, and only when, a consumer successfully obtains a loan. Accordingly, brokers are incentivized to restrict their services to only those most likely to qualify. Conversely, lead generation services are available to all, and lead generators are only compensated for connecting interested parties, regardless of the outcome of said introduction.” Further, “the bill drafters fail to consider and address the impact that enacting AB 3207 in its current form would have on similar statutory language and existing case law, insofar that the term “broker” under California law, would impart an unnecessary fiduciary duty on lead generators, exposing them to countless potential lawsuits that will further restrict good actors from the marketplace.”
Proposed Section 22338.5(b)(2) “is very difficult to interpret because a ‘referral’ is defined as an introduction to a finance lender.” ...Under the definition of “referral,” a 22004(a)(1)-(2) broker cannot refer a consumer to someone not a finance lender...Even if the assumption is made that 22004(a)(1)-(2) brokers might provide consumer information to non-lenders, it is inconceivable to expect the disclosure of every person who “may” be provided the consumer’s information. This enormous overreach will result in terrible consumer confusion. Furthermore, the DBO does not have authority over non-lenders, so this particular section may be void or unenforceable.” - CURO and Enova (both lenders), and the Online Lenders Alliance oppose the bill on grounds that the language is confusing and not reflective of the role that lead generators serve in the lending process. “Through a virtual marketplace, lead generators help prospective customers find established, responsible lenders. Without this virtual marketplace, consumers would spend hours searching numerous websites and repeatedly exposing their highly sensitive personal data. Additionally, through the use of innovative tools and technology, lead generators also reduce consumers’ exposure to the many scams prevalent on the Internet. Unfortunately, much of the innovation that has enabled consumers’ greater access to safe, reliable lending options online would be significantly impacted should AB 3207 be signed into law.”
- The Electronic Transactions Association (ETA) is seeking an exemption from this bill’s broker requirement for persons acting as third-party service providers for banks that are exempt from the CFL. “Given the increased convergence between state- and federally-chartered banks and non-bank service providers and the overlapping regulatory requirements, ETA urges the inclusion of an exemption from the broker requirement for third-party service providers already subject to regulation and examination by a federal banking agency.
- LeadsMarket.com, a lead generator based in California, writes, “AB 3207 fails to understand and respect the way good lead generators work, which is why its good intentions would decimate the industry, leaving only criminals and bad players to interact with consumers. There are several critical (albeit nuanced) flaws with AB 3207, but two that stand out most include: (1) impossible disclosure requirements and (2) an open invite to class action lawyers to run good lead generators out of business. The impossible disclosure requirements are embodied in 22337.5 and 22338.5...the required disclosures simply cannot be made without violating the proposed legislation. Lead generators will risk criminal liability by continuing to do business in California. Lead generators doing business in California will pull out of the state to focus in other more reasonable jurisdictions. Lead generators headquartered in California (already a very challenging jurisdiction for business) will relocate to other states and well-paid IT employees will lose their jobs...if compliance with the law is factually and literally impossible, what other choice is there?”
- Amendments:
LEAD GENERATION PROVISIONS
- Several sections of this bill require lead generators to obtain a borrower’s “express consent” before undertaking certain actions. However, the term “express consent” is undefined. For this reason, lead generators subject to this bill will be forced to make reasonable guesses as to what this term means. Those who guess wrong risk enforcement actions by DBO.
According to the author’s office, use of the word “express” is intended to clarify that consent cannot be implied, simply because a prospective borrower provides their confidential data. The term is intended to require a prospective borrower to take an action to provide consent, such as clicking an “I Agree” box or signing a disclosure. At a minimum, staff recommends that the bill be amended to define the term “express consent.”
In addition, as discussed in more detail below, amendments are recommended to clarify the circumstances under which express consent provided by a prospective borrower to one party can be considered to have been provided to all parties to whom that prospective borrower’s confidential data are sold. The current wording of the bill is unclear in this regard in several places, a lack of clarity that could impose very significant liability on persons subject to this bill’s lead generation rules. - This bill’s broker definition includes several activities that may be warrant exemptions. For example, as drafted, there is no exemption for individuals who perform purely administrative or clerical tasks in connection with loan applications. California’s mortgage loan originator definition (Financial Code Section 22013) contains language that may provide a useful model in this regard. Consistent with that section, the term “administrative or clerical tasks” would mean the receipt, collection, and distribution of information common for the processing or underwriting of a loan and communication with a consumer to obtain information necessary for the processing or underwriting of a loan, to the extent that the communication does not include offering or negotiating loan rates or terms, or counseling consumers about loan rates or terms.
- Several sections of this bill require lead generators to obtain a borrower’s “express consent” before undertaking certain actions. However, the term “express consent” is undefined. For this reason, lead generators subject to this bill will be forced to make reasonable guesses as to what this term means. Those who guess wrong risk enforcement actions by DBO.
This bill also lacks exemptions for credit bureaus, Internet search engines, and social media platforms such as Facebook and LinkedIn. Unless this bill’s author wants to require these entities to obtain finance broker’s licenses (a requirement that DBO would likely have a very difficult time enforcing), staff suggests amendments to expressly exclude these entities from this bill’s broker definition. If the author chooses to exempt these entities, staff recommends an amendment to clarify that this exemption applies, regardless of whether these entities provide search results or other choices to a consumer based on paid advertising.
A related amendment is also recommended to this bill’s definition of confidential data to clarify that, notwithstanding the items included in the definition, this term does not include publicly available data about a prospective borrower.
- Section 22100(e) may benefit from amendments to increase consumer protection. As drafted, that subdivision prohibits a finance lender from compensating a broker for performing lead generation activities, if the finance lender has actual knowledge that the finance broker has committed any act in violation of “this division.” At a minimum, staff suggests expanding this reference to “any act in violation of this division or any rule or order adopted pursuant to this division.” Such language will better track language in other areas of the CFL and the Financial Code.
However, staff also questions whether the standard of “actual knowledge” that this bill applies to lenders with respect to the acts of brokers whose services they use is sufficiently protective of consumers. An “actual knowledge” standard is less protective of consumers than a “knew or should have known” standard and far less protective than a standard which makes lenders liable for the acts of brokers working on their behalf. Notably, the “actual knowledge” standard that this bill applies to lenders with respect to the brokers they use differs from and is weaker than the standard this bill applied to brokers for the acts of unlicensed persons from whom they purchase confidential information. - Financial Code Section 22337.5(a) uses the term “express consent” in a manner that appears to equate this term with a borrower accepting a specific loan offer extended by a lender. As noted above, this bill would benefit from an amendment to define the term “express consent.” However, given the desire of this bill’s author to equate “express consent” with checking a box on a Web form, staff suggests that Section 22337.5(a) be amended to replace the term “express consent” with language that more closely tracks the action of committing one’s self on a loan agreement (e.g., providing a signature).
The disclosure requirement of this section should also be considered alongside the disclosure requirements of Section 22338.5 and 22348. At some point, one must question whether a prospective borrower really needs three different lead generation-specific disclosures, in addition to the Truth in Lending Act disclosures and other contractual disclosures consumer finance lenders are required to provide their borrowers. - As described in additional detail by several of this bill’s opponents, Section 22338.5 raises multiple problematic issues.
- Section 22100(e) may benefit from amendments to increase consumer protection. As drafted, that subdivision prohibits a finance lender from compensating a broker for performing lead generation activities, if the finance lender has actual knowledge that the finance broker has committed any act in violation of “this division.” At a minimum, staff suggests expanding this reference to “any act in violation of this division or any rule or order adopted pursuant to this division.” Such language will better track language in other areas of the CFL and the Financial Code.
- The first issue relates to process. It is unclear, as this section and Section 22348 are currently written, how they are supposed to work together. For example, Section 22338.5(a) requires a broker engaging in lead generation activities to obtain a prospective borrower’s express consent before transmitting that prospective borrower’s confidential data to a finance lender or making a referral to a finance lender based on confidential data. Section 22338.5(b) requires a broker engaging in lead generation activities to provide a disclosure to a prospective borrower before obtaining that prospective borrower’s express consent. Sections 22348(a)(4) and (a)(5) require brokers to ensure that the unlicensed persons from whom they purchase confidential data do not collect confidential data directly from a prospective borrower without providing that prospective borrower with a specified disclosure and obtaining that prospective borrower’s express consent.
Taken together, the bill’s language appears to envision the following: A prospective borrower goes online seeking a loan and navigates to a web site operated by a publisher or sub-publisher that is not required to be licensed. This unlicensed person provides the prospective borrower with the disclosure required by Section 22348(a)(4), obtains the prospective borrower’s express consent pursuant to Section 22348(a)(5), collects that prospective borrower’s confidential data, and sells that data to an unlicensed entity, which may sell the data to a different unlicensed entity, and so on, until the confidential data is sold to a broker.
Section 22338.5(b) requires the broker who purchases that prospective borrower’s confidential data to provide a different disclosure to the prospective borrower and have the prospective borrower acknowledge receipt of that disclosure before obtaining the prospective borrower’s express consent. Only after the broker has obtained the prospective borrower’s express consent may that broker transmit that prospective borrower’s confidential data to a finance lender or make a referral to a finance lender based on the prospective borrower’s confidential data.
In the example above, it appears that the prospective borrower is receiving two different disclosures (one from the unlicensed entity to which he or she is providing their confidential data and one from the broker who is selling that data to a finance lender) and is providing express consent at least twice (once to the unlicensed person to whom he or she provides his or her confidential data, and once to the broker). Depending on the manner in which express consent is clarified, this bill may require each unlicensed entity that wishes to purchase a borrower’s confidential data to provide the disclosure required by Section 22348, and to obtain a prospective borrower’s express consent. This would add additional disclosures and consent requirements to the two described above.
Requiring multiple disclosures and requiring express consent to be obtained multiple times is likely to inject delays into a process that now occurs almost instantaneously. It is unknown how many prospective borrowers will close their browsers or click away from lead generators’ web sites, if they are asked to review multiple disclosures and opt in to multiple consents. - Concerns have also been expressed about the contents of the disclosure required to be provided to prospective borrowers by brokers pursuant to Section 22338.5. That disclosure requires:
- The name and license number of each finance lender to whom the prospective borrower may be referred by the licensed broker.
According to some lead generators, this list changes regularly and may include several hundred or more lenders. It is unclear whether borrowers will benefit from being provided access to a long list of lenders in a lead generator’s network. It is also unclear to what extent prospective borrowers will think that they qualify for a loan from all of the lenders on the list, when that may not be the case. - The name and contact information of any person who is not a finance lender to whom the prospective borrower may be referred by the broker.
This information is outside the scope of the CFL and thus potentially outside the scope of information DBO may require a CFL licensee to provide to a prospective borrower. Technically, the CFL only regulates licensed activity, and the licensed activity that is the subject of this bill involves making referrals, as defined, to licensed finance lenders. Thus, any sale of confidential data to an entity that is not required to be licensed under the CFL or any introduction of a prospective borrower to an entity that is not required to be licensed under the CFL is outside the scope of DBO’s regulatory authority under the CFL. Requiring CFL brokers engaging in lead generation activities to provide information to prospective borrowers about their relationships with persons who are not subject to licensure under the CFL muddies the scope of the bill and the extent to which the author is trying to regulate CFL brokers’ relationships with these entities.
Several organizations opposed to this bill are seeking clarification about the extent to which this bill is intended to regulate a licensed lead generator’s ability to sell leads to entities that are not required to be licensed under the CFL. - The extent to which the compensation paid by each finance lender to whom the prospective borrower is referred by the licensed broker is contingent on the making of a loan to the prospective borrower and whether the compensation varies based on the principal amount of the loan or the charges provided by the loan agreement.
This information is proprietary and is information that, if released, could place the broker at a competitive disadvantage relative to his or her competitors. It is also unclear why it would be helpful to inform a borrower about the method by which a broker will be compensated by a lender, if the prospective borrower will not be responsible for paying that compensation, and if the lender is not allowed to charge that prospective borrower more for a loan it makes following a referral from a broker than for a loan it makes without such a referral. If this requirement remains in the disclosure, it may be helpful to add a sentence to the disclosure helping prospective borrowers understand the significance of this information and how they may wish to use it.
Furthermore, according to some of this bill’s opponents, this information is extremely dynamic. It not only varies by lender, but can also vary for the same lender, depending on the time of day and other factors. It may be extremely difficult, if not impossible, for a broker to provide a prospective borrower with accurate, up-to-date information that is specific to the compensation practices of each of the lenders in its network at the specific time it is seeking the prospective borrower’s express consent to refer that borrower to lenders in its network. This requirement may also lead to provision of different information to different prospective borrowers, depending on when during the day those prospective borrowers seek loans. - A statement informing the prospective borrower how to report a complaint about “our” services.
This statement would benefit from an amendment to include a reference not only to the broker, but also to any unlicensed persons to whom the prospective borrower may have provided their confidential data, before that data was sold to the broker.
- The name and license number of each finance lender to whom the prospective borrower may be referred by the licensed broker.
- Section 22348 also raises a number of questions and concerns that would benefit from clarification and possible amendments.
- For example, by requiring brokers to develop, implement and enforce policies and procedures intended to ensure compliance by unlicensed persons, this section appears to place finance brokers in a pseudo-regulatory position relative to unlicensed persons they compensate for referrals involving confidential data. However, this bill appears to impose a different, higher standard on brokers with respect to their liability for the acts of unlicensed persons they compensate for leads than lenders are held to with respect to the acts of brokers they compensate for leads.
While lenders are liable only if they have “actual knowledge at the time compensation is to be made that the broker has committed any violation of this division in connection with that loan,” the broker is liable if it fails “to develop, implement, and enforce policies and procedures that would prevent an unlicensed person from engaging in acts that would be a violation of this division if that person was licensed” and “shall be deemed to be in violation of any provision of this division or any regulation adopted pursuant to this division to the same extent as the unlicensed person would have been in violation had that person been a licensed broker.” This liability is then limited with language that provides “a licensed broker is not in violation...solely for the reason that an unlicensed person commits isolated acts that are in violation of this chapter.”
The combination of this language appears to place significant responsibility on the broker (to develop, implement, and enforce policies), and to make brokers liable for anything other than isolated bad acts by the unlicensed persons they compensate. This standard is far higher than the “actual knowledge” standard applied to lenders and is likely to serve as a strong disincentive for entities who meet the definition of “lead generation” brokers to become licensed. - Section 22348(a)(3) requires brokers to monitor complaints by prospective borrowers regarding unlicensed persons. Yet, unless the disclosure in Section 22338.5(b)(6) is amended to instruct prospective borrowers to report complaints about both brokers and unlicensed entities with whom they have interacted, it is unclear how a prospective borrower would know to complain to a broker about an unlicensed person.
- Section 22348(a)(4) requires unlicensed persons to provide prospective borrowers with a specified disclosure. The bill fails to specify which unlicensed person must provide this disclosure, if multiple unlicensed persons are involved in handling a prospective borrower’s data. Staff suggests an amendment intended to clarify that this disclosure should be provided by the unlicensed person that initially seeks to collect a prospective borrower’s confidential data.
- Section 22348(a)(5) requires brokers to ensure that unlicensed persons do not collect a prospective borrower’s confidential data for the purpose of referring a prospective borrower to a licensed broker without first obtaining the prospective borrower’s express consent for that purpose. It is unclear whether the author intends for express consent obtained by one unlicensed entity to be “passed on” to another unlicensed entity to which the first entity sells the data. In some lead generation contexts, several unlicensed entities can “touch” a borrower’s data (e.g., a subpublisher that sells to a publisher, which sells to a lead aggregator, which may sell to another lead aggregator, which may sell to the lead aggregator that requires a broker’s license). If the author intends that an initial express consent provided to the first unlicensed entity can absolve other unlicensed entities of the requirement to collect express consent, an amendment would be helpful to clarify this point.
However, it will be important to clarify that the express consent a prospective borrower provides to an unlicensed person cannot substitute for the express consent that a licensed broker is required to obtain from that prospective borrower, because a substitution of this sort would be in direct conflict with the requirements of Section 22338.5(a) and 22338.5(b). - Section 22348(a)(7) requires brokers to cease any relationship with those unlicensed persons who demonstrate repeated, uncorrected failures to adhere to the broker’s policies and procedures. However, the bill lacks any tracking mechanism for use by DBO to learn the identities of unlicensed persons whose business relationships with brokers are severed by those brokers because the unlicensed persons engaged in repeated, uncorrected failures to adhere to the brokers’ policies and procedures.
- For example, by requiring brokers to develop, implement and enforce policies and procedures intended to ensure compliance by unlicensed persons, this section appears to place finance brokers in a pseudo-regulatory position relative to unlicensed persons they compensate for referrals involving confidential data. However, this bill appears to impose a different, higher standard on brokers with respect to their liability for the acts of unlicensed persons they compensate for leads than lenders are held to with respect to the acts of brokers they compensate for leads.
More generally, Section 22348 also fails to require brokers to maintain books and records documenting the identities of the unlicensed entities they compensate for leads. A requirement of this sort would go hand in hand with a requirement that brokers keep records, for review by DBO, of the unlicensed persons with whom they have severed business relationships due to those persons’ repeated, uncorrected failures to adhere to the brokers’ policies and procedures.
CFL EXAMINATION PROVISIONS
j) While recognizing that the language of proposed Section 22701 is based on Section 50302 of the Financial Code, staff suggests the following amendments to clarify intent:
Page 21, line 39, strike “provide” and insert: Prepare
Page 21, strike lines 9 and 10 and insert: benefitting or affecting the licensee or the affiliate or arising from the activities regulated by this division.
- Prior and Related Legislation:
- SB 297 (Dodd), 2017 -18 Legislative Session, would have required lead generators, as defined, to register with DBO, provide specified disclosures, adhere to specified rules, and refrain from engaging in prohibited activity, and would have given the Commissioner of Business Oversight regulatory and enforcement authority over lead generators, as specified. Held on the Senate Appropriations Committee Suspense File.
- AB 2984 (Limon), 2017-2018 Legislative Session, included among its provisions the CFL examination provision recently added to AB 3207. Held on the Assembly Appropriations Committee Suspense File.
- SB 297 (Dodd), 2017 -18 Legislative Session, would have required lead generators, as defined, to register with DBO, provide specified disclosures, adhere to specified rules, and refrain from engaging in prohibited activity, and would have given the Commissioner of Business Oversight regulatory and enforcement authority over lead generators, as specified. Held on the Senate Appropriations Committee Suspense File.
LIST OF REGISTERED SUPPORT/OPPOSITION
Support
California Financial Services Association
California Low-Income Consumer Coalition
Center for Responsible Lending
Clergy & Laity United for Economic Justice
Consumers for Auto Reliability and Safety
Consumers Union
Department of Business Oversight
New Economics for Women
On Deck
San Francisco Office of Economic Empowerment
Western Center on Law and Poverty
Opposition
Avenue Link
California Financial Service Providers Association
Commercial Finance Coalition
CURO
Dot818
Electronic Transactions Association
Enova
Lead Economy
Lead Flash
LeadsMarket
LendingTree
Online Lenders Alliance
QuinStreet
The Lead Group
Zero Parallel
-- END --
NCSL’s review did not cover residential mortgage loan brokering activity, because real estate brokering definitions are fairly uniform across the United States following enactment of the federal Secure and Fair Enforcement for Mortgage Licensing Act of 2008 (Title V of HR 3221; Public Law 110-289), and because mortgage loan broker definitions typically differ from the definitions applied to brokers of non-real estate-secured lending. For example, California’s definition of a mortgage loan originator, contained in Financial Code Sections 22013 and 50003.5 and in Business and Professions Code Section 10166.01 is virtually identical to the mortgage loan originator definitions adopted by the other states but very different from the consumer loan brokering definition contained in Financial Code Section 22004. ↑
ASSEMBLY THIRD READING
ATR Bill Id:AB 3207
Author:(Limón)
As Amended Ver:May 29, 2018
Majority vote
Committee | Votes | Ayes | Noes |
Privacy | 7-3 | Chau, Berman, Calderon, Irwin, Mullin, Reyes, Ting | Kiley, Baker, Obernolte |
Banking | 8-2 | Limón, Burke, Calderon, Cervantes, Gonzalez Fletcher, Grayson, Mark Stone, Weber | Acosta, Choi |
Appropriations | 12-4 | Gonzalez Fletcher, Bloom, Bonta, Calderon, Carrillo, Chau, Eggman, Friedman, Eduardo Garcia, Nazarian, Quirk, Reyes | Bigelow, Fong, Gallagher, Obernolte |
SUMMARY: This bill revises the definition of "broker" under California Financing Law (CFL) and adds additional requirements for lenders when using a broker. Specifically, this bill:
- Defines a broker to be any person who negotiates or performs specified actions in connection with loans made by a finance lender, including transmitting confidential data, as defined, about a borrower to a finance lender with the expectation of compensation (except in specified cases when a licensed lender transmits confidential data to another licensed lender) or participating in any loan negotiation between a finance lender and borrower.
- Prohibits a lender from: compensating a person who is engaging in brokering activities without a license; compensating a broker for specified activities when the lender knows the broker has committed certain violations, including making a false statement or committed fraud; and charging a borrower more for the loan than the lender would have charged the borrower if the lender did not pay a referral fee.
- Requires a lender to provide a borrower a written disclosure that shows the amounts paid to any broker in connection with the loan, among other information.
- Requires a licensed broker who compensates an unlicensed person for a referral to develop, implement, and enforce policies and procedures related to business practices and activities prohibited for that person if they were a licensed broker.
FISCAL EFFECT: Additional ongoing administrative and enforcement costs to the Department of Business Oversight (DBO) in excess of $250,000. Additional enforcement staff may be needed as a result of the expanded universe of possible CFL licensees and the additional requirements around information accessibility and brokering activities. These costs may be offset by fees paid by licensees.
COMMENTS: Under existing law, a CFL lender is prohibited from paying any compensation to an unlicensed person or company for soliciting or accepting applications loans. This prohibition does not apply to an employee, a real estate broker, or to compensation paid for by any brokerage service provided by a bank or other financial institution not part of the CFL. There are some limited exceptions to this prohibition. First, CFL lenders that make commercial loans may compensate unlicensed persons in connection with the referral of one or more prospective borrowers, but only when certain conditions occur. Second, lenders participating in the Pilot Program for Increased Access to Responsible Small-Dollar Loans may use the services of one or more "finders" who are authorized under the program.
Many of CFL's provisions were drafted decades before the internet was developed. In recent years, consumers looking for personal loans have increasingly used the Internet to search for lenders, and companies have developed online lead generation practices to respond to this consumer demand. While lead generators can serve a valuable role in the market by lowering search costs for consumers and by providing value information to consumers, there remain significant consumer protection concerns around these modern practices. As the Assembly Committee on Banking and Finance notes, lead generators get paid whether or not a consumer is placed in a loan that fits their needs and that they have the ability to repay. This transactional nature of the relationship between consumers and lead generators poses significant consumer protection risks.
According to the author, this bill will address the issue of unlicensed third parties that solicit confidential information from consumers and provide this information to lenders. The author asserts this bill will require the licensure of lead generations that serve the nonbank lending market, such as CFL lenders.
In support, a coalition of consumer advocates, including the Western Center on Law and Poverty, Consumers Union, and the Center for Responsible Lending write:
This bill would require online lead generators to be licensed as brokers under the CFL if they provide confidential consumer data to finance lenders for compensation. The requirement for licensure gives DBO authority to conduct background checks on the owners and officers of lead generation firms and gives DBO access to examine the business records of these companies. The bill would also require that lead generators and finance lenders provide disclosures to consumers about how lead generators are compensated for providing leads.
Additionally, finance lenders would not be allowed to compensate unlicensed entities for lead generation services.
The requirements imposed by AB 3207 will give DBO, finance lenders, and consumers a clear picture of who can legally provide lead generation services and how those firms are conducting their business. The bill would bar lead generators from conducting any unlawful, unfair, or fraudulent business practice or from conducting any unfair, deceptive, false, or misleading advertising. And if companies violate any of the laws, DBO can suspend or revoke their license, cutting them off from receiving compensation from licensed finance lenders.
Recent amendments which provide that provisions of the CFL should not be interpreted to impose licensing or regulatory obligations on federally recognized Indian tribes or business entities that are considered "arms of the tribe," as specified, removed the opposition of the Habematolel Pomo of Upper Lake.
The Electronic Transactions Association (ETA) opposes this bill unless amended to address specific concerns. At the time of this writing it appears as though some concerns expressed in their letter have been addressed by amendments. ETA writes that they continue to have "significant concerns with a number of specific provisions of this bill as written and [look] forward to working with Assembly Member Limon and the committee on this important issue."
Analysis Prepared by: Nichole Rapier / P. & C.P. / (916) 319-2200 FN: 0003415
ASSEMBLY THIRD READING
ATR Bill Id:AB 3207
Author:(Limón)
As Amended Ver:May 10, 2018
Majority vote
Committee | Votes | Ayes | Noes |
Privacy | 7-3 | Chau, Berman, Calderon, Irwin, Mullin, Reyes, Ting | Kiley, Baker, Obernolte |
Banking | 8-2 | Limón, Burke, Calderon, Cervantes, Gonzalez Fletcher, Grayson, Mark Stone, Weber | Acosta, Choi |
Appropriations | 12-4 | Gonzalez Fletcher, Bloom, Bonta, Calderon, Carrillo, Chau, Eggman, Friedman, Eduardo Garcia, Nazarian, Quirk, Reyes | Bigelow, Fong, Gallagher, Obernolte |
SUMMARY: This bill revises the definition of "broker" under California Financing Law (CFL) and adds additional requirements for lenders when using a broker. Specifically, this bill:
- Defines a broker to be any person who negotiates or performs specified actions in connection with loans made by a finance lender, including transmitting confidential data, as defined, about a borrower to a finance lender with the expectation of compensation (except in specified cases when a licensed lender transmits confidential data to another licensed lender) or participating in any loan negotiation between a finance lender and borrower.
- Prohibits a lender from: compensating a person who is engaging in brokering activities without a license; compensating a broker for specified activities when the lender knows the broker has committed certain violations, including making a false statement or committed fraud; and charging a borrower more for the loan than the lender would have charged the borrower if the lender did not pay a referral fee.
- Requires a lender to provide a borrower a written disclosure that shows the amounts paid to any broker in connection with the loan, among other information.
- Requires a licensed broker who compensates an unlicensed person for a referral to develop, implement, and enforce policies and procedures related to business practices and activities prohibited for that person if they were a licensed broker.
FISCAL EFFECT:
Additional ongoing administrative and enforcement costs to the Department of Business Oversight (DBO) in excess of $250,000. Additional enforcement staff may be needed as a result of the expanded universe of possible CFL licensees and the additional requirements around information accessibility and brokering activities. These costs may be offset by fees paid by licensees.
COMMENTS: Under existing law, a CFL lender is prohibited from paying any compensation to an unlicensed person or company for soliciting or accepting applications loans. This prohibition does not apply to an employee, a real estate broker, or to compensation paid for by any brokerage service provided by a bank or other financial institution not part of the CFL. There are some limited exceptions to this prohibition. First, CFL lenders that make commercial loans may compensate unlicensed persons in connection with the referral of one or more prospective borrowers, but only when certain conditions occur. Second, lenders participating in the Pilot Program for Increased Access to Responsible Small-Dollar Loans may use the services of one or more "finders" who are authorized under the program.
Many of CFL's provisions were drafted decades before the internet was developed. In recent years, consumers looking for personal loans have increasingly used the Internet to search for lenders, and companies have developed online lead generation practices to respond to this consumer demand. While lead generators can serve a valuable role in the market by lowering search costs for consumers and by providing value information to consumers, there remain significant consumer protection concerns around these modern practices. As the Assembly Committee on Banking and Finance notes, lead generators get paid whether or not a consumer is placed in a loan that fits their needs and that they have the ability to repay. This transactional nature of the relationship between consumers and lead generators poses significant consumer protection risks.
According to the author, this bill will address the issue of unlicensed third parties that solicit confidential information from consumers and provide this information to lenders. The author asserts this bill will require the licensure of lead generations that serve the nonbank lending market, such as CFL lenders.
In opposition, the Equipment Leasing and Finance Association (ELFA) writes that this bill:
[R]equires that licensed brokers provide the prospective borrower a written disclosure that shows the method of compensation provided to the licensed broker but then counters this mandate by stating "22100 (e) A licensee shall not, in connection with any loan subject to this division, directly or indirectly pass through to a borrower the licensee's cost of compensating a broker."
As an initial matter, this provision generally contravenes basic principles of economics (i.e., to some degree, all costs are passed through to consumers, if not directly than indirectly). More importantly, why should a broker provide a disclosure to the borrower if the lender was not permitted to pass through the cost to the borrower? AB 3207 will entrap brokers and lenders engaged in sincere efforts to comply. This prohibition on passing through the broker fee appears designed to generate violations with almost every transaction. (Emphasis in original.)
Analysis Prepared by: Nichole Rapier / P. & C.P. / (916) 319-2200 FN: 0003147
Date of Hearing: May 16, 2018
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Lorena Gonzalez Fletcher, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 3207
Author:(Limón) – As Amended Ver:May 10, 2018
Policy Committee: | Privacy and Consumer Protection | Vote: | 7 - 3 |
Banking and Finance | 8 - 2 | ||
|
|
Urgency: No State Mandated Local Program: Yes Reimbursable: No
SUMMARY:
This bill revises the definition of “broker” under California Financing Law (CFL) and adds additional requirements for lenders when using a broker. Specifically, this bill:
- Defines a broker to be any person who negotiates or performs specified actions in connection with loans made by a finance lender, including transmitting confidential data, as defined, about a borrower to a finance lender with the expectation of compensation (except in specified cases when a licensed lender transmits confidential data to another licensed lender) or participating in any loan negotiation between a finance lender and borrower.
- Prohibits a lender from: compensating a person who is engaging in brokering activities without a license; compensating a broker for specified activities when the lender knows the broker has committed certain violations, including making a false statement or committed fraud; and charging a borrower more for the loan than the lender would have charged the borrower if the lender did not pay a referral fee.
- Requires a lender to provide a borrower a written disclosure that shows the amounts paid to any broker in connection with the loan, among other information.
- Requires a licensed broker who compensates an unlicensed person for a referral to develop, implement, and enforce policies and procedures related to business practices and activities prohibited for that person if they were a licensed broker.
FISCAL EFFECT:
Additional ongoing administrative and enforcement costs to the Department of Business Oversight (DBO) in excess of $250,000. Additional enforcement staff may be needed as a result of the expanded universe of possible CFL licensees and the additional requirements around information accessibility and brokering activities. These costs may be offset by fees paid by licensees.
COMMENTS:
- Background. Under existing law, a CFL lender is prohibited from paying any compensation to an unlicensed person or company for soliciting or accepting applications loans. This prohibition does not apply to an employee, a real estate broker, or to compensation paid for by any brokerage service provided by a bank or other financial institution not part of the CFL. There are some limited exceptions to this prohibition. First, CFL lenders that make commercial loans may compensate unlicensed persons in connection with the referral of one or more prospective borrowers, but only when certain conditions occur. Second, lenders participating in the Pilot Program for Increased Access to Responsible Small-Dollar Loans may use the services of one or more “finders” who are authorized under the program.
- Lead generators. Many of CFL’s provisions were drafted decades before the internet was developed. In recent years, consumers looking for personal loans have increasingly used the Internet to search for lenders, and companies have developed online lead generation practices to respond to this consumer demand. While lead generators can serve a valuable role in the market by lowering search costs for consumers and by providing value information to consumers, there remain significant consumer protection concerns around these modern practices. As the Assembly Committee on Banking and Finance notes, lead generators get paid whether or not a consumer is placed in a loan that fits their needs and that they have the ability to repay. This transactional nature of the relationship between consumers and lead generators poses significant consumer protection risks.
- Purpose. According to the author, AB 3207 will address the issue of unlicensed third parties that solicit confidential information from consumers and provide this information to lenders. The author asserts this bill will require the licensure of lead generations that serve the nonbank lending market, such as CFL lenders.
- Recent amendments. AB 3207 was recently amended to clarify the definition of a broker, among other changes. Significant changes include a requirement that brokers and lenders provide additional disclosures to prospective borrowers in connection with referrals for consumer loans and a requirement that brokers who compensate unlicensed persons for referrals must implement and enforce policies to correct unfair business practices.
- Recent legislation. SB 297 (Dodd), of the 2017-18 Legislative Session, which redefines broker under CFL and gives DBO the authority to regulate lead generators, was held on the Senate Appropriations Committee’s Suspense File.
Analysis Prepared by: Luke Reidenbach / APPR. / (916) 319-2081
Date of Hearing: April 23, 2018
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON BANKING AND FINANCE
Monique Limón, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 3207 (
Author:Limón) – As Amended Ver:April 4, 2018
SUBJECT: California Financing Law
SUMMARY: Revises the definition of “broker” under the California Financing Law (CFL) to include anyone who, among other things, receives compensation for providing a referral or a lead if the referral or lead conveys confidential information, participates in any loan negotiation between a finance lender and prospective borrower, participates in the preparation of loan documents, communicates lending decisions or inquiries to a borrower, or charges any fees to a prospective borrower or applicant for any services related to an application for a loan from a finance lenders.
Specifically, this bill:
- Defines a “broker” to mean any person who is engaged in the business of negotiating or performing any act as broker in connection with loans made by a finance lender, including, but not limited to, any of the following acts:
- Providing a referral or a lead to one or more finance lenders for compensation or expected compensation if the referral or lead conveys confidential data, as specified.
- Participating in any loan negotiation between a finance lender and prospective borrower.
- Counseling, advising, or making recommendations to a borrower about a loan based on a borrower’s confidential data.
- Participating in the preparation of any loan documents, including loan applications, other than providing a borrower blank copies of loan documents. Transmitting information that is not confidential data at the request of a prospective borrower or loan applicant shall not, by itself, constitute participation in the preparation of loan documents.
- Communicating lending decisions or inquiries between a finance lender and a borrower.
- Charging any fees to a prospective borrower or applicant for any services related to a prospective borrower’s or applicant’s application for a loan from a finance lender.
- Defines “confidential data” to mean information about a borrower, prospective borrower, or applicant that is nonpublic and sensitive, including but not limited to, the following:
- Bank account number or routing number, bank statement, or credit or debit card account number.
- Credit score, whether self-reported by the person it relates to, or received from a credit reporting agency as part of an official request.
- Social Security number (SSN), part of an SSN, driver’s license number or government-issued identification number, or passport number.
- Personal or business income information, including information self-reported by the person, personal employment data or history, or taxpayer or employer identification number.
- Date of birth, mother’s maiden name.
- Medical information, health insurance information, including an insurance policy number.
- Provides that “confidential data” does not include: name, phone number, physical address, email address, financing amount, or stated purpose for a loan. In connection with a commercial loan, “confidential data” does not include business name, business address, business phone number, or a business’s self-reported range of income, in addition to the other information listed in this paragraph.
- Provides that a person shall not be deemed a broker if both of the following are met:
- The person only distributes or otherwise disseminates to a prospective borrower or applicant a finance lender’s marketing materials or factual information about the finance lender and its loan products, such as the finance lender’s interest rates, minimum or maximum loan amounts or loan periods, or a general description of the finance lender’s underwriting criteria.
- The person does not engage in any of the other acts specified above.
- Provides that a person is not considered a “broker” if that person performs the acts described in #1 above five or fewer times in a calendar year.
- Prohibits, subject to certain exceptions, a finance lender from compensating a unlicensed person for performing brokering services, as defined in #1 above. Additionally, prohibits a licensee from compensating a broker for services if the broker is known to have committed any violation of Section 22161 of the Financial Code (related to misleading behavior and fraud) in connection with that loan, and prohibits a licensee from passing through to a borrower the licensee’s cost of compensating a broker.
- Prohibits a licensed broker from soliciting or collecting confidential data, unless that information is reasonably necessary to perform the brokering acts described above.
- Requires that a broker, prior to making a referral in connection with a loan, provide the prospective borrower a written disclosure that shows in clear and distinct terms the method of compensation provided to the licensed broker, including whether the compensation is based on the size of a loan or contingent on the referral or lead resulting in a consummated loan.
- Requires that a finance lender, prior to consummating a loan, provide the prospective borrower a written disclosure that shows in clear and distinct terms the amount paid to any broker in connection with the loan, and how the compensation was determined, including whether the compensation was based on the size of a loan or contingent on the referral or lead resulting in a consummated loan.
EXISTING LAW:
- Defines a “broker” under the CFL as a person who is engaged in the business of negotiating or performing any act as a broker in connection with loans made by a finance lender (Financial Code Section 22004). Prohibits any person from engaging in the business of a broker without obtaining a license from the commissioner of the Department of Business Oversight (Section 22100).
- Prohibits a finance lender from paying any compensation to an unlicensed person or company for soliciting or accepting applications for loans. This prohibition does not apply to the payment of compensation to an employee of the lender, a real estate broker, or to compensation paid for any brokerage service provided by a bank, savings and loan association, or other financial institution that is exempted from the CFL. (Title 10 California Code of Regulations Section 1451)
- Contains two limited exceptions to the prohibition against compensating unlicensed persons in connection with the solicitation or acceptance of applications for loans:
- Lenders accepted to participate in the Pilot Program for Increased Access to Responsible Small-Dollar Loans (pilot program) may use the services of one or more finders, as defined. Finders authorized under the pilot program need not be licensed, if they engage in one or more of eight activities that generally involve helping borrowers fill out loan applications and communicating with lenders about the status of and final decision on borrowers’ loan applications. Pilot program finders may also engage in one or more of three additional activities (disbursing loan proceeds, accepting loan payments, and providing borrower disclosures) if they hold specified licenses. The ability of pilot program lenders to compensate finders is subject to several limitations. The commissioner has examination and disciplinary authority over pilot program finders. (Financial Code Sections 22371 – 22376)
- CFLL licensees that make commercial loans may compensate unlicensed persons in connection with the referral of one or more prospective borrowers, when all of the following occur: the referral leads to a consummated loan, the loan contract provides for an annual percentage rate that does not exceed 36 percent, the licensee follows specified requirements when underwriting the loan, the licensee maintains records of all compensation paid to unlicensed persons, and the licensee annually submits information to the commissioner. Unlicensed persons that receive compensation may not engage in one or more of eight specific activities involving loans, except as specified. (Financial Code Section 22602)
FISCAL EFFECT: Unknown
COMMENTS:
- PURPOSE
The author states:
“There are currently unlicensed third parties (aka lead generators) that solicit confidential financial information from consumers and provide this information to lenders for compensation. These third parties provide advice or recommendations to consumers that may not be in the best interest of the consumer. For example, an unlicensed third party may steer consumers into loans with higher costs because the lender is willing to pay more to the third party than a lender with lower cost loans for the referral is willing to pay.
DBO currently has 46 open cases related to unlicensed broker activities. These cases can be difficult for the department to enforce due to the poor construction of Financial Code Section 22004. Through consumer complaints and routine examinations, DBO has become aware of consumer harm due to the activities of lead generators. Without clearer statutory authority, DBO cannot prevent this harm from continuing.”
- BACKGROUND
Many provisions of the California Financing Law (CFL), including the definition of “broker,” were drafted decades before the Internet was developed. In recent years, consumers looking for personal loans have increasingly used the Internet to search for lenders. Companies have developed sophisticated online lead generation practices to respond to this consumer demand, including highly-targeted online advertisements and automated, real-time auction houses for consumer data.
Online lead generators serve a variety of industries, including hotels, for-profit education providers, insurance, and loans. This bill requires licensure of lead generators that serve the nonbank lending market in California (i.e., provide leads to CFL finance lenders). Lead generators that serve the CFL loan market play an important role in bringing borrowers and lenders together based on a borrower’s confidential information and the general underwriting characteristics of a lender. When serving this intermediary role and receiving compensation for this activity, the incentives of lead generators may be misaligned with the best interests of the consumer who provides their confidential data. For this reason, the state can protect consumers by regulating how lead generators represent their services and requiring them to disclose their financial interests to consumers.
Loan products offered by CFL lenders have also changed significantly in recent years. In 2006, CFL lenders originated only 57 loans with a principal amount of $2,500 to $10,000 and interest rates exceeding 100%. In 2016, CFL lenders originated 346,501 loans with triple-digit interest rates, representing an aggregate principal amount of $1.1 billion. The data are clear: lenders are marketing far riskier products to a much broader segment of consumers than ever before.
During the mortgage crisis of the 2000s, unlicensed third parties played a significant role in getting consumers into mortgages that they could not afford. Currently, lead generators act as unlicensed third parties in the CFL marketplace. As third parties, lead generators get paid whether or not a consumer is placed in a loan that fits their needs and that they have the ability to repay. The transactional nature of the relationship between consumers and lead generators poses risk of consumer harm, a risk that is exacerbated by the financially vulnerable situations that lead consumers to seek out high cost loans in the first place.
- RISKS TO CONSUMERS IN THE MARKET TODAY
Lead generators that serve the lending industry can serve a valuable role in the market by lowering search costs for consumers and lowering customer acquisition costs for lenders. Lead generators that provide unbiased information to consumers, adequately protect consumers’ confidential data, and disclose potential conflicts of interest should be allowed to flourish in the CFL marketplace. Unfortunately, not all lead generators maintain such standards.
The Federal Trade Commission (FTC) outlines the following consumer protection concerns in its paper on lead generation (https://www.ftc.gov/news-events/blogs/business-blog/2016/09/ftc-staff-perspective-lead-generation).
- Lack of transparency: Consumers may not understand that online web forms are operated by lead generators and instead assume that they are submitting information directly to a lender. Even when consumers know they are submitting their information to a lead generator, they may not know that their information can be sold and re-sold multiple times. Consumers may also not be aware that lead generators may sell their information to the highest bidder, rather than to a lender that could offer them a loan that better fits their needs.
- Deceptive marketing: The lead generation ecosystem can be complex with many lead generators buying and selling an individual consumer’s confidential data before the data is ultimately transmitted to a lender. Because of the many steps that can separate the entity that makes marketing claims to consumers from the lender who ultimately uses the confidential data to originate a loan, lead generators can use this lack of transparency to make misleading claims about their services, such as “we will connect you with the best loan” or “we will approve you for a loan.”
- Misuse of confidential information: Some lead generators fail to ensure that companies that buy their leads are using that information for authorized purposes. The FTC has filed several law enforcement actions alleging that bad actors have been able to obtain payday loan leads for nefarious purposes, such as making fake debt collection calls or charging consumers’ financial accounts without authorization.
In addition to the risks outlined by the FTC, online lead generators may act in their own self-interest, rather than in the interest of the consumer, when connecting a consumer with a lender. When a consumer submits their bank account number, credit score, social security number, desired loan amount, and/or income information to a lead generator, that consumer may reasonably assume that the lead generator will connect them with a lender that offers a loan product that meets the consumer’s needs and credit profile. However, lead generators may connect the consumer with whichever lender is willing to pay the highest amount, regardless of whether that lender offers products that fit the consumer’s needs.
- HOW THIS BILL ADDRESSES RISKS TO CONSUMERS
This bill aims to address the risks to consumers discussed in the preceding section. All code sections referenced below are from the Financial Code.
Lack of transparency and conflicts of interest
Subdivisions (g) and (h) of Section 22100 require brokers and finance lenders, respectively, to disclose in clear and distinct terms the amount paid to a broker in connection with a loan, including whether the compensation is based on the size of a loan or contingent on the consummation of a loan. Consumers can use this information to identify potential conflicts of interest. For example, a consumer may request a loan with a principal amount of $1,000, but the lead generator refers them to a lender that only offers loans above $2,500 (because the lender does not offer loans subject to the CFL rate caps on loans below $2,500). If the disclosure clearly indicates that the lead generator is compensated for sending such a lead to the lender despite the difference between the consumer’s desired loan amount and the loans that lender offers, a consumer may have second thoughts about consummating a loan with that lender.
Deceptive marketing
Subdivision (d) of Section 22100 prohibits a CFL licensee from compensating a broker who is known to have committed any violation of the CFL related to false, deceptive, or misleading advertising, fraudulent business practices, or dishonest dealings. Pursuant to Section 22161, CFL licensees are also prohibited from causing or permitting any false, misleading, or deceptive advertising to be displayed or distributed, which would extend the prohibition on false advertising to third parties that a lead generator may contract with.
Misuse of confidential information
Subdivision (f) of Section 22100 prohibits a broker from soliciting or collecting confidential information unless that information is reasonably necessary to perform the acts of a broker specified in the Section 22004 (a) (see #1 on page 1 of this analysis). This prohibition will minimize the amount of consumers’ sensitive information that is collected and available to be bought and sold by potentially nefarious actors.
- LICENSURE IS NECESSARY FOR ADEQUATE ENFORCEMENT
The enforcement mechanisms provided by the CFL are predicated on the premise that regulated entities are licensed by the DBO. Generally, licensure provides DBO with the tools to conduct three important functions that protect consumers: upfront vetting, market monitoring and examination, and providing punishment for violations of the law.
Upfront vetting
The requirement to be licensed prior to engaging in brokering activities permits the DBO to evaluate license candidates’ fitness for providing financial services. In order to obtain a license, a licensure candidate must submit an application, including the names and fingerprints of principal officers, directors, managers, and owners (aka applicants). THE DBO is required to conduct a background check on these persons, and the Commissioner of DBO may deny an application for a license if the applicant has been convicted of a crime or committed an act involving dishonesty, fraud, or deceit within the past ten years, or if the applicant has violated the CFL. The applicant is also required to have a minimum net worth of $25,000 and maintain a surety bond of $25,000. These requirements establish a minimum standard for companies that are permitted to handle consumers’ sensitive financial data and facilitate access to credit in the nonbank lending market in California.
Market monitoring and examination
CFL licensees are required to report their activities and make their books and records open to inspection by the DBO. Licensees are required to annually report to DBO relevant information concerning the business and operations conducted by the licensee, including the licensees annual financial statements. Importantly, licensees must maintain and provide DBO access to books and records which enable DBO to evaluate the licensee’s compliance with the requirements of the CFL. If DBO receives a complaint from a consumer, the ability to access books and records is pivotal to investigate the complaint, identify violations, and take enforcement actions to stop the violation from occurring. The CFL also requires licensees to maintain records related to a loan for three years after the final entry on any loan recorded in the records and to maintain advertising copy for two years after the last date of its use. These record retention requirements ensure that licensees cannot legally destroy evidence of a violation shortly after committing the violation.
Punishment for violations
A CFL license is a prerequisite for any company to receive compensation for making a loan or acting as a broker, subject to specified exceptions in the CFL. If a licensee violates any provision of the CFL, DBO has the authority to take a variety of enforcement actions, up to suspension or revocation of a license, which essentially puts the company out of business. The CFL authorizes DBO to pursue the following enforcement actions based on the gravity of the violation and other factors: desist and refrain from engaging in specific activities, issue a citation containing an order to correct violations and assess an administrative fine not to exceed $2,500, bring a civil action seeking an injunction and ancillary relief, suspend a license, and revoke a license.
- CONSIDERATIONS FOR THE AUTHOR
Based on meetings with stakeholders in support, neutral, and opposition positions, the author has identified several issues that will be addressed in future iterations of the bill. While the following is not an exhaustive list, the following issues have been raised by multiple parties and the author commits to continue working towards agreement on outstanding items if the bill moves through this committee.
- Section 22004(a): Delete “including, but not limited to” phrase in the definition of broker. Instead of an open-ended definition subject to interpretation by the regulator, the author may consider adding language that would require DBO to conduct a formal rulemaking if the regulator needs to clarify acts that constitute brokering activities.
- Section 22004(a)(5): Add “based on a borrower’s confidential data” after “inquiries” to clarify that general requests for information do not constitute brokering activities.
- Section 22004(b)(2)(G): Add “business’s email address, or a business’s desired loan or financing amount” to the list of exceptions to confidential data in connection with a commercial loan. Delete “range of” before “income.”
- Section 22100(c): Add subdivision (c) of Section 22602 to the list of exceptions.
- Section 22100(d): Clarify that a licensee shall not knowingly pay compensation to any broker who has violated the CFL prohibition against false or misleading advertising.
- Section 22100(e): Delete “or indirectly” related to passing through the cost of compensating a broker. Language should be clarified to reflect author’s intent that a lender charge a borrower the same amount for a loan facilitated through a broker as the lender would charge the same borrower for a loan that is not facilitated through a broker.
- Sections 22100(f) and 22604(b)(1): Delete “unless that information is reasonably necessary to perform the acts in subdivision (a) of Section 22004. Clarify that a licensed broker shall not solicit, collect, or convey a person’s confidential data without the person’s affirmative approval.
- Section 22100 (g) and (h): Regarding disclosures from brokers and lenders, determine if a duplicate disclosure provides meaningful consumer protections and determine the appropriate information to be disclosed.
- Determine if a separate definition of “lead generator” should be established under the CFL based on the activities described in Section 22004(a)(1). If a separate definition is established, all requirements of “broker” or “licensee” under the CFL shall apply to “lead generator” except for specific exceptions that are determined to have no negative impact on DBO’s ability to enforce the consumer protections of the law.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
California Low-Income Consumer Coalition
Center for Responsible Lending
Consumers Union
Department of Business Oversight
New Economics for Women
Office of Financial Empowerment, City and County of San Francisco
Western Center on Law and Poverty
Opposition
California Financial Services Association
Electronic Transactions Association (unless amended)
Equipment Leasing and Financing Association
Analysis Prepared by: Michael Burdick / B. & F. / (916) 319-3081
Date of Hearing: April 17, 2018
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON PRIVACY AND CONSUMER PROTECTION
Ed Chau, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 3207 (
Author:Limón) – As Amended Ver:April 4, 2018
SUBJECT: California Financing Law
SUMMARY: This bill, among other things, would revise the definition of “broker” under California’s Finance Lending Law (CFLL) to include anyone who, among other things, receives compensation for providing a referral or a lead if the referral or lead conveys confidential information, participates in any loan negotiation between a finance lender and prospective borrower, participates in the preparation of loan documents, communicates lending decisions or inquiries to a borrower, or charges any fees to a prospective borrower or applicant for any services related to an application for a loan from a finance lenders. Specifically, this bill would:
- Define a “broker” to mean any person who is engaged in the business of negotiating or performing any act as broker in connection with loans made by a finance including, but not limited to, any of the following acts:
- Providing a referral or a lead to one or more finance lenders for compensation or expected compensation if the referral or lead conveys confidential data, as specified.
- Participating in any loan negotiation between a finance lender and prospective borrower.
- Counseling, advising, or making recommendations to a borrower about a loan based on a borrower’s confidential data.
- Participating in the preparation of any loan documents, including loan applications, other than providing a borrower blank copies of loan documents. Transmitting information that is not confidential data at the request of a prospective borrower or loan applicant shall not, by itself, constitute participation in the preparation of loan documents.
- Communicating lending decisions or inquiries between a finance lender and a borrower.
- Charging any fees to a prospective borrower or applicant for any services related to a prospective borrower’s or applicant’s application for a loan from a finance lender.
- Define, for the purposes of this bill, “confidential data” to mean information about a borrower, prospective borrower, or applicant that is nonpublic and sensitive, including but not limited to, the following:
- Bank account number or routing number, bank statement, or credit or debit card account number.
- Credit score, whether self-reported by the person it relates to, or received from a credit reporting agency as part of an official request.
- Social Security number (SSN), part of an SSN, driver’s license number or government-issued identification number, or passport number.
- Personal or business income information, including information self-reported by the person, personal employment data or history, or taxpayer or employer identification number.
- Date of birth, mother’s maiden name.
- Medical information, health insurance information, including an insurance policy number.
- Provide that “confidential data” does not include: name, phone number, physical address, email address, financing amount, or stated purpose for a loan. In connection with a commercial loan, “confidential data” does not include business name, business address, business phone number, or a business’s self-reported range of income, in addition to the other information listed in this paragraph.
- Provide that a person shall not be deemed a broker if both of the following are met:
- The person only distributes or otherwise disseminates to a prospective borrower or applicant a finance lender’s marketing materials or factual information about the finance lender and its loan products, such as the finance lender’s interest rates, minimum or maximum loan amounts or loan periods, or a general description of the finance lender’s underwriting criteria.
- The person does not engage in any of the other acts specified above.
- Provide that these provisions do not apply to any person who performs the acts described above five or fewer times in a calendar year.
- Prohibit, subject to certain exceptions, a finance lender from compensating a unlicensed person for performing brokering services, as defined above. Additionally, prohibit a licensee from compensating a broker for services if the broker is known to have committed any violation of Section 22161 (related to misleading behavior and fraud) in connection with that loan, and prohibit a licensee from passing through to a borrower the licensee’s cost of compensating a broker.
- Prohibit a licensed broker from soliciting or collecting confidential data, unless that information is reasonably necessary to perform the brokering acts described above.
- Require that a broker, prior to making a referral in connection with a loan, provide the prospective borrower a written disclosure that shows in clear and distinct terms the method of compensation provided to the licensed broker, including whether the compensation is based on the size of a loan or contingent on the referral or lead resulting in a consummated loan.
- Require that a finance lender, prior to consummating a loan, provide the prospective borrower a written disclosure that shows in clear and distinct terms the amount paid to any broker in connection with the loan, and how the compensation was determined, including whether the compensation was based on the size of a loan or contingent on the referral or lead resulting in a consummated loan.
EXISTING LAW:
- Defines a broker, pursuant to the CFLL, as any person who is engaged in the business of negotiating or performing any act as broker in connection with loans made by a finance lender. (Fin. Code Sec. 22004.) Provides that no person shall engage in the business of a finance broker without obtaining a license from the commissioner. (Fin. Code Sec. 22100.)
- Prohibits a finance lender from paying any compensation to an unlicensed person or company for soliciting or accepting applications for loans. This prohibition does not apply to the payment of compensation to an employee of the lender, a real estate broker, or to compensation paid for any brokerage service provided by a bank, savings and loan association, or other financial institution that is exempted from the CFLL. (10 C.C.R. Sec. 1451.)
- Contains two limited exceptions to the prohibition against compensating unlicensed persons in connection with the solicitation or acceptance of applications for loans:
- Lenders accepted to participate in the Pilot Program for Increased Access to Responsible Small-Dollar Loans (pilot program) may use the services of one or more finders, as defined. Finders authorized under the pilot program need not be licensed, if they engage in one or more of eight activities that generally involve helping borrowers fill out loan applications and communicating with lenders about the status of and final decision on borrowers’ loan applications. Pilot program finders may also engage in one or more of three additional activities (disbursing loan proceeds, accepting loan payments, and providing borrower disclosures) if they hold specified licenses. The ability of pilot program lenders to compensate finders is subject to several limitations. The commissioner has examination and disciplinary authority over pilot program finders. (Fin. Code Secs. 22371 – 22376.)
- CFLL licensees that make commercial loans may compensate unlicensed persons in connection with the referral of one or more prospective borrowers, when all of the following occur: the referral leads to a consummated loan, the loan contract provides for an annual percentage rate that does not exceed 36 percent, the licensee follows specified requirements when underwriting the loan, the licensee maintains records of all compensation paid to unlicensed persons, and the licensee annually submits information to the commissioner. Unlicensed persons that receive compensation may not engage in one or more of eight specific activities involving loans, except as specified. (Fin. Code Sec. 22602.)
FISCAL EFFECT: Unknown
COMMENTS:
- Purpose of the bill: This bill seeks to require lead generators to be licensed as brokers under the CFLL. This is an author-sponsored bill.
- Author’s statement: According to the author, “There are currently unlicensed third parties (aka lead generators) that solicit confidential financial information from consumers and provide this information to lenders. These third parties provide advice or recommendations to consumers that may not be in the best interest of the consumer. For example, an unlicensed third party may steer consumers into loans with higher costs because the lender is willing to pay the third party more than a lender with lower cost loans for the referral.
DBO currently has 46 open cases related to unlicensed broker activities. These cases can be difficult for the department to enforce due to the poor construction of Financial Code Section 22004. Through consumer complaints and routine examinations, DBO has become aware of consumer harm due to the activities of lead generators. Without clearer statutory authority, DBO cannot prevent this harm from continuing.”
- Background: The CFLL was written long before the internet was developed. For that reason, the law is silent on several activities that are common in today’s consumer and business lending marketplaces, including the act of introducing prospective borrowers to prospective lenders online, without helping to negotiate the terms of the loan. The persons who perform these introductions are known as finders or, lead generators.
Lead generation websites are increasingly common. Consumers can use these platforms to quickly and easily shop for hotels, cars, home repair, etc. In the financial lead generation context, lead generators collect information from consumers and small businesses seeking loans and sell that information to lenders seeking to extend credit to these groups. Lead generators can benefit both borrowers and lenders. Borrowers who use lead generators to help them obtain loans can often compare different lenders and loan terms, before selecting the combination in which they are most interested. Lenders can use lead generators to cost-effectively and efficiently identify prospective borrowers who are interested in and eligible for the loans they are offering.
However, as described in more detail below, lead generation can also be performed in ways that have the potential to harm borrowers and prospective borrowers. Yet, despite these potential harms, California currently lacks a regulatory framework designed to protect persons who use lead generators to obtain installment loans. This bill proposes such a regulatory framework and proposes to give California’s primary lending regulator, the Commissioner of Business Oversight, clear statutory authority to regulate the behavior of lead generators operating in California. - Finance broker vs. lead generator: Last year SB 297 (Dodd, 2017) was introduced to similarly address the issue of the definition of “broker” under CFLL, and give the DBO the clear authority to regulate lead generators. That bill defined the terms “finance broker” and “finder” under the CFLL; required finders to register with the DBO, provide specified disclosures, adhere to specified rules, and refrain from engaging in prohibited activity; and gave the Commissioner of Business Oversight (commissioner) regulatory and enforcement authority over finders, as specified. That bill passed out policy committee (the Senate Banking and Financial Institutions Committee) unanimously, but was ultimately placed on suspense in the Senate Appropriations Committee.
This bill, by contrast, attempts to include both traditional brokers and lead generators under a single definition of “broker.” That definition would define a broker as a person who engages specified practices in connection with a loan made by a finance lender, including, but not limited to:
- providing a referral or a lead to one or more finance lenders for compensation or expected compensation if the referral or lead conveys confidential data;
- participating in any loan negotiation between a finance lender and prospective borrower;
- counseling, advising, or making recommendations to a borrower about a loan based on a borrower’s confidential data;
- participating in the preparation of any loan documents, including loan applications, other than providing a borrower blank copies of loan documents. Transmitting information that is not confidential data at the request of a prospective borrower or loan applicant shall not, by itself, constitute participation in the preparation of loan documents;
- communicating lending decisions or inquiries between a finance lender and a borrower; or
- charging any fees to a prospective borrower or applicant for any services related to a prospective borrower’s or applicant’s application for a loan from a finance lender.
This definition would certainly include “traditional” brokers, who negotiate loan terms with a lender on behalf of a borrower, participate in the preparation of loan documents, and are paid by the borrower. Also included in this definition would be lead generators, who provide a referral to one or more finance lenders for compensation or expected compensation, and that lead can include confidential data. Lead generators, though, are arguably distinct from traditional brokers in that lead generators do not have the authority to act on behalf of another person, and are paid by the lender, not the borrower.
Lead generation, as described by the Federal Trade Commission (FTC), is “the process of identifying and cultivating individual consumers who are potentially interested in purchasing a product or service. The goal of lead generation is to connect companies with those consumers so that they can convert ‘leads’ into sales.” (Federal Trade Commission, “Follow the Lead” Workshop, Staff Perspective (Sept. 2016) <https://www.ftc.gov/system/ files/documents/reports/staff-perspective-follow lead/staff_perspective_follow_the_ lead_ workshop.pdf> [as of April 11, 2018].) Lead generation, therefore, seems more akin to a a marketing tool than traditional brokering. Lenders, who do not specialize in marketing, are increasingly turning to the targeted, and more efficient advertising methods employed by lead generators.
DBO, who would be charged with regulating lead generators under this bill writes that “under current law, the CFLL defines a broker as ‘any person who is engaged in the business of negotiating or performing any act as a broker in connection with loans made by a finance lender.’ This circular definition provides insufficient guidance on the activities that constitute brokering and hinders the DBO’s ability to enforce the law and protect consumers. The vagueness of the brokering definition also creates compliance uncertainty for the CFLL licensees it regulates and allows much of the lead generation activity in California to go unregulated. […] AB 3207 would fix this problem by differentiating between the acts that are brokering and acts that are not brokering. In addition, this bill would require lead generators to obtain a CFLL broker’s license, bringing lead generation within the confines of the CFLL’s brokering provisions. This change will help ensure that consumers gain the protections and safeguards provided by the CFLL’s prohibitions against unfair and deceptive business practices.”
On Deck Capital, Inc., one of the largest online small business lending platforms in the United States, states that it appreciates the intent of the author, but expresses concern about the daunting task of creating a regulatory framework for a relatively new and complicated industry. Similarly, SoFi, taking no position on this bill, expresses optimism that this bill could provide “some needed precision to otherwise ambiguous provisions in the existing [CFL] regarding persons who provide referrals or leads for potential loans.” SoFi also “looks forward to participating in the process to further refine the measure as it progresses. In particular, we want to make certain that there is a level playing field for all market participants. We are also mindful of certain duplicative disclosure requirements that could, as a practical matter, create operational challenges.”
Staff notes that the definition of “broker” under this bill is open-ended in that the six activities which would bring a person or business under the definition of broker, are qualified by the phrase “including, but not limited to.” Therefore, businesses who do not participate in any of the six specified activities under that definition, could very well still be considered “brokers” and subject to regulation and/or discipline by the DBO. Accordingly, this definition arguably provides no real certainty to the industry.
Additionally, regulating traditional brokers and lead generators under a single statute or framework may ultimately prove unworkable given their different functions. Many requirements imposed on brokers (and lenders in their dealings with brokers) make no sense if applied to lead generators. For example, Financial Code Section 22337(a) requires lenders to provide to borrowers with a statement identifying the broker that was involved. In the event that there were multiple lead generators, how much information is useful to the customer and how can this information be provided clearly? Similarly, Section 22337(b) requires that lenders obtain a statement from the borrower indicating whether a broker was involved and how much was paid to that broker. Lead generators, however, are paid by lenders, so they would be unable to comply with this provision. A quick search of “broker” turns up other examples which would need to be amended to accommodate this bill’s definition. Given the different functions and accompanying risks of brokers and lead generators (discussed below in Comment 5), the author should consider whether separating out the definitions of “broker” and “lead generator” would create a more workable system under which lead generators could be properly regulated.
- Consumer protections should be targeted to the risks associated with the practice of lead generation: This bill would set out a framework for brokers (including lead generators under the bill) to follow when dealing with borrowers and potential borrowers in the CFLL. Among other things, the bill would prohibit brokers from soliciting confidential information, as defined, from borrowers, unless that information is reasonably necessary to make the referral or lead. The bill would also require that brokers safeguard prospective borrower’s confidential data, and would provide parameters for payment of lead generators and required disclosures. In support, a coalition of consumer advocates, including the Western Center on Law and Poverty, Consumers Union, and the Center for Responsible Lending write:
This bill would require online lead generators to be licensed as brokers under the CFL if they provide confidential consumer data to finance lenders for compensation. The requirement for licensure gives DBO authority to conduct background checks on the owners and officers of lead generation firms and gives DBO access to examine the business records of these companies. The bill would also require that lead generators and finance lenders provide disclosures to consumers about how lead generators are compensated for providing leads.
Additionally, finance lenders would not be allowed to compensate unlicensed entities for lead generation services.
The requirements imposed by AB 3207 will give DBO, finance lenders, and consumers a clear picture of who can legally provide lead generation services and how those firms are conducting their business. The bill would bar lead generators from conducting any unlawful, unfair, or fraudulent business practice or from conducting any unfair, deceptive, false, or misleading advertising. And if companies violate any of the laws, DBO can suspend or revoke their license, cutting them off from receiving compensation from licensed finance lenders.
There is little debate that lead generators who fail to abide by best practices can cause real harm by connecting borrowers with unauthorized lenders, misusing borrower data, and otherwise misleading consumers. Both industry and consumer advocates express interest in the regulation of this field. The question is how to regulate this industry in a meaningful way that will ensure consumer protection and industry certainty. Lead generation involves many different actions by many different participants. To be effective and helpful to consumers, any regulatory scheme will have to recognize that complexity and account for it. The consumer protections noted above are largely based off of the protections built into existing code with regard to the current definition of “broker.” Applied in the context of lead generation, while arguably not harmful or overly burdensome, those protections fail to provide consumers with the information they would need to make a meaningful decision, and also fail to provide lead generators with certainty as to their actual practices.
Accordingly, as this bill moves through the legislative process, the author may wish to consider what information and practices would be truly in the regulation of this particular industry, including: (1) how should lead generators vet their lenders; (2) should lead generators be required to disclose which lenders they work with; (3) is the data held by lead generators encrypted; (4) how long is borrower data retained; and (5) how many times is borrower data is being sold.
- Prior legislation: SB 297 (Dodd, 2017) See Comment 3.
AB 784 (Dababneh, 2017) Would have expanded the pilot program under CFL to include loans of up to $5,000, rename finders as referral partners when used in connection with pilot program loans, allow for the use of online referral partners, and provide greater flexibility to pilot program lenders with respect to their compensation of finders.
SB 235 (Block, Ch. 505, Stats. 2015) Increased the types of activities in which pilot program finders may engage and provided greater flexibility to pilot program lenders with respect to their compensation of finders.
SB 197 (Block, Ch. 761, Stats. 2015) Authorized the payment of referral fees to unlicensed persons in connection with commercial loans made under the CFLL, subject to several limitations specified in the bill.
- Double-referral: This bill is double-referred with the Assembly Committee on Banking and Finance, where it will be heard if passed by this Committee.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
California Low-Income Consumer Coalition
Center for Responsible Lending
City and County of San Francisco
Consumers Union
Department of Business Oversight
New Economics for Women
Western Center on Law and Poverty
Opposition
California Financial Services Association
Electronic Transactions Association (unless amended)
Analysis Prepared by: Nichole Rapier / P. & C.P. / (916) 319-2200
Discussed in Hearing
Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations
Senate Standing Committee on Banking and Financial Institutions
Assembly Floor
Assembly Standing Committee on Banking and Finance
Assembly Standing Committee on Privacy and Consumer Protection
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):