AB 570: Workers’ compensation: permanent disability apportionment.
- Session Year: 2017-2018
- House: Assembly
- Latest Version Date: 2017-09-08
Existing workers compensation law generally requires employers to secure payment of workers compensation, including medical treatment, for injuries incurred by their employees that arise out of, or in the course of, employment. An employer is liable only for the percentage of the permanent disability directly caused by the injury arising out of, and occurring in the course of, employment.
Existing law requires apportionment of permanent disability to be based on causation, and a physician who prepares a report addressing the issue of permanent disability due to a claimed industrial injury is required to address the issue of causation of the permanent disability. Existing law requires the physician to make an apportionment determination by finding the approximate percentage of the permanent disability that was caused by the direct result of injury arising out of and occurring in the course of employment, and the approximate percentage of the permanent disability that was caused by other factors both before and subsequent to the industrial injury, including prior industrial injuries.
This bill would prohibit apportionment, in the case of a physical injury occurring on or after January 1, 2018, from being based on pregnancy, childbirth, or other medical conditions related to pregnancy or childbirth.
Existing workers compensation law generally requires employers to secure payment of workers compensation, including medical treatment, for injuries incurred by their employees that arise out of, or in the course of, employment. An employer is liable only for the percentage of the permanent disability directly caused by the injury arising out of, and occurring in the course of, employment.
Existing law requires apportionment of permanent disability to be based on causation, and a physician who prepares a report addressing the issue of permanent disability due to a claimed industrial injury is required to address the issue of causation of the permanent disability. Existing law requires the physician to make an apportionment determination by finding the approximate percentage of the permanent disability that was caused by the direct result of injury arising out of and occurring in the course of employment, and the approximate percentage of the permanent disability that was caused by other factors both before and subsequent to the industrial injury, including prior industrial injuries.
This bill would prohibit apportionment, in the case of a physical injury occurring on or after January 1, 2018, from being based on pregnancy, childbirth, or other medical conditions related to pregnancy or childbirth.
(a)Apportionment of permanent disability shall be based on causation.
(b)A physician who prepares a report addressing the issue of permanent disability due to a claimed industrial injury shall address in that report the issue of causation of the permanent disability.
(c)(1)In order for a physicians report to be considered complete on the issue of permanent disability, the report must include an apportionment determination.
(2)(A)A physician shall make an apportionment determination by finding what approximate percentage of the permanent disability was caused by the direct result of injury arising out of and occurring in the course of employment and what approximate percentage of the permanent disability was caused by other factors both before and subsequent to the industrial injury, including prior industrial injuries.
(B)No percentage of an apportionment in the case of a physical injury occurring on or after January 1, 2018, shall be based on pregnancy, childbirth, or other medical conditions related to pregnancy or childbirth.
(3)If the physician is unable to include an apportionment determination in his or her report, the physician shall state the specific reasons why the physician could not make a determination of the effect of that prior condition on the permanent disability arising from the injury. The physician shall then consult with other physicians or refer the employee to another physician from whom the employee is authorized to seek treatment or evaluation in accordance with this division in order to make the final determination.
(d)An employee who claims an industrial injury shall, upon request, disclose all previous permanent disabilities or physical impairments.
(e)Subdivisions (a), (b), and (c) do not apply to injuries or illnesses covered under Sections 3212, 3212.1, 3212.2, 3212.3, 3212.4, 3212.5, 3212.6, 3212.7, 3212.8, 3212.85, 3212.9, 3212.10, 3212.11, 3212.12, 3213, and 3213.2.
(a)Apportionment of permanent disability shall be based on causation.
(b)A physician who prepares a report addressing the issue of permanent disability due to a claimed industrial injury shall address in that report the issue of causation of the permanent disability.
(c)(1)In order for a physicians report to be considered complete on the issue of permanent disability, the report must include an apportionment determination. A
(2)(A)A physician shall make an apportionment determination by finding what approximate percentage of the permanent disability was caused by the direct result of injury arising out of and occurring in the course of employment and what approximate percentage of the permanent disability was caused by other factors both before and subsequent to the industrial injury, including prior industrial injuries. If
(B)No percentage of an apportionment in the case of a physical injury occurring on or after January 1, 2018, shall be based on pregnancy, childbirth, or other medical conditions related to pregnancy or childbirth.
(3)If the physician is unable to include an apportionment determination in his or her report, the physician shall state the specific reasons why the physician could not make a determination of the effect of that prior condition on the permanent disability arising from the injury. The physician shall then consult with other physicians or refer the employee to another physician from whom the employee is authorized to seek treatment or evaluation in accordance with this division in order to make the final determination.
(d)An employee who claims an industrial injury shall, upon request, disclose all previous permanent disabilities or physical impairments.
(e)Subdivisions (a), (b), and (c) do not apply to injuries or illnesses covered under Sections 3212, 3212.1, 3212.2, 3212.3, 3212.4, 3212.5, 3212.6, 3212.7, 3212.8, 3212.85, 3212.9, 3212.10, 3212.11, 3212.12, 3213, and 3213.2.
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Jan 12, 2018 | Stricken from file. |
| Jan 3, 2018 | Consideration of Governor's veto pending. |
| Oct 13, 2017 | Vetoed by Governor. |
| Sep 13, 2017 | Enrolled and presented to the Governor at 4 p.m. |
| Sep 7, 2017 | In Assembly. Ordered to Engrossing and Enrolling. |
| Sep 7, 2017 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Assembly. |
| Sep 5, 2017 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| Sep 1, 2017 | From committee: Do pass. (Ayes 5. Noes 2.) (September 1). |
| Aug 21, 2017 | In committee: Referred to APPR. suspense file. |
| Jul 12, 2017 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 4. Noes 1.) (July 12). Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Jun 14, 2017 | Referred to Coms. on L. & I.R. and APPR. |
| Jun 1, 2017 | In Senate. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. |
| May 31, 2017 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Senate. (Ayes 61. Noes 15. Page 1909.) |
| May 30, 2017 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| May 26, 2017 | From committee: Do pass. (Ayes 13. Noes 3.) (May 26). |
| May 17, 2017 | In committee: Set, first hearing. Referred to APPR. suspense file. |
| May 3, 2017 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 12. Noes 1.) (May 3). Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Feb 27, 2017 | Referred to Com. on INS. |
| Feb 15, 2017 | From printer. May be heard in committee March 17. |
| Feb 14, 2017 | Read first time. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sep 7, 2017 | Assembly 3rd Reading AB570 Gonzalez Fletcher By Hueso | Senate Floor |
Passed |
|
| Sep 1, 2017 | Do pass | Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Aug 21, 2017 | Placed on suspense file | Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Jul 12, 2017 | Do pass, but first be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Senate Standing Committee on Labor and Industrial Relations |
Passed |
|
| May 31, 2017 | AB 570 GONZALEZ FLETCHER Assembly Third Reading | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| May 26, 2017 | Do pass. | Assembly Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| May 3, 2017 | Do pass and be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Assembly Standing Committee on Insurance |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
|
Organization
|
Position
|
Date
|
|---|---|---|
| Acclamation Insurance Management Services | ** Against | May 1, 2017 |
| Acclimation Insurance Management Services | * Against | May 3, 2017 |
| American Insurance Association | ** Against | Sep 3, 2017 |
| Association For Los Angeles Deputy Sheriffs | * Support | May 3, 2017 |
| Association of California Healthcare Districts | ** Against | Sep 3, 2017 |
| Association Of California Insurance Companies | ** Against | Sep 3, 2017 |
| BizFed | ** Against | Sep 3, 2017 |
| California Applicants' Attorneys Association | ** Support | Sep 3, 2017 |
| California Association Of Joint Powers Authorities | ** Against | Sep 3, 2017 |
| California Chamber Of Commerce | ** Against | Sep 3, 2017 |
| California Coalition on Workers' Compensation | ** Against | Sep 3, 2017 |
| California Conference Board Of The Amalgamated Transit Union | ** Support | Sep 3, 2017 |
| California Conference Of Machinists | ** Support | Sep 3, 2017 |
| California Federation Of Teachers | ** Support | Sep 3, 2017 |
| California Grocers Association | ** Against | Sep 3, 2017 |
| California Manufacturers & Technology Association | ** Against | Sep 3, 2017 |
| California Society Of Industrial Medicine And Surgery | * Support | May 3, 2017 |
| California Special Districts Association | ** Against | Sep 3, 2017 |
| California State Association Of Counties | ** Against | Sep 3, 2017 |
| California Teamsters Public Affairs Council | ** Support | Sep 3, 2017 |
| Csac Excess Insurance Authority | ** Against | Sep 3, 2017 |
| International Longshore and Warehouse Union | ** Support | Sep 3, 2017 |
| Los Angeles County Professional Peace Officers Association | ** Support | Sep 3, 2017 |
| National Federation Of Independent Business | ** Against | Sep 3, 2017 |
| Professional & Technical Engineers, IFPTE Local 21, AFL-CIO | ** Support | Sep 3, 2017 |
| Riverside Sheriffs' Association | ** Support | Sep 3, 2017 |
| UNITE-HERE, AFL-CIO | ** Support | Sep 3, 2017 |
| Utility Workers Union of America | ** Support | Sep 3, 2017 |
| Western Occupational and Environmental Medical Association | ** Against | Sep 3, 2017 |
GOVERNOR'S VETO
GV Bill Id:AB 570
Author:(Gonzalez Fletcher)
As Enrolled Ver:September 8, 2017
2/3 vote
Committee | Votes | Ayes | Noes |
Insurance | 12-1 | Daly, Melendez, Bigelow, Caballero, Calderon, Chu, Cooley, Cooper, Dababneh, Dahle, Frazier, Gipson | Voepel |
Appropriations | 13-3 | Gonzalez Fletcher, Bloom, Bocanegra, Bonta, Calderon, McCarty, Quirk, Fong, Friedman, Eduardo Garcia, Gray, Muratsuchi, Reyes | Bigelow, Brough, Obernolte |
ASSEMBLY: | 61-15 | (May 31, 2017) | SENATE: | 25-11 | (September 7, 2017) |
SUMMARY: Prohibits the use of pregnancy, childbirth, or other medical conditions related to pregnancy or childbirth, in the calculation of permanent disability benefits for injuries occurring on or after January 1, 2018.
EXISTING LAW:
- Provides for a comprehensive system to provide workers' compensation benefits for workers whose injuries arise out of or in the course of employment, including medical treatment and financial compensation if the injury or condition has a permanently disabling effect.
- Establishes a Permanent Disability Rating Schedule (PDRS), a methodology for calculating impairment through the use of the American Medical Association Guides to the Evaluation of Permanent Impairment (AMA Guides), and other tools that are used to determine the extent of an injured worker's permanent disability (PD).
- Allows for the "apportionment" of PD determinations to prior industrial causes, to prior non-industrial causes, or to subsequent causes, and reduces the amount of the injured worker's PD award to the extent these causes have contributed to the extent of the disability.
- Requires the physician who is making a recommendation on the extent of disability that has followed from an industrial injury to identify, and quantify, causation of the disability that is either prior to or subsequent to the industrial injury.
FISCAL EFFECT:
- Increased administrative costs to the Division of Workers' Compensation and the Workers' Compensation Appeals Board (WCAB) within the Department of Industrial Relations. Because of the exception to the apportionment standard created by this bill, disputes concerning causation of permanent disability between employers and female workers' compensation applicants are likely to increase substantially. This could lead to significantly more filings, hearings and trials within the workers' compensation system on apportionment issues, which could in turn lead to significant increases in the costs of administration. This total cost is unknown, but could be well in excess of $1 million (Workers Compensation Administration Revolving Fund).
- Increased costs to the state as an employer. The state could incur unknown, likely significantly increased workers' compensation costs for higher permanent partial disability compensation as a result of fewer allowable apportionments (various funds).
COMMENTS:
- Purpose. The purpose of the bill is to eliminate elements of what the author believes is gender bias in the workers' compensation system. According to the author, women can receive disproportionately low compensation amounts for work-related permanent disability because of the gender-specific conditions of pregnancy and childbirth. The author points to specific examples where the evaluating physician has pointed to pre-existing conditions that have involved pregnancy or childbirth in apportioning the causation of subsequent industrial injuries, and argues that this constitutes an inappropriate discrimination, since male injured workers can never have their disability apportioned in this manner.
- Case Law. In an unpublished appellate decision, Vaira v. WCAB, the Court of Appeal returned a case to the Workers' Compensation Appeals Board (WCAB) because the record was insufficient to determine whether the physician had based his apportionment decision on medical facts that showed the older female claimant suffered from osteoporosis, or on the basis that the risk factor (older women face a high risk of suffering from osteoporosis) alone was sufficient to assign a percentage of the causation to osteoporosis. This decision has been broadly applied in the workers' compensation courts as establishing the following rule: a risk characteristic such as older women having a high incidence of osteoporosis, or older African American men having a high incidence of hypertension, cannot be used as a basis to apportion a permanent disability award. However, a woman diagnosed with osteoporosis that contributes to her disability resulting from the subsequent industrial injury, or an African American man diagnosed with hypertension that contributes to his disability resulting from the subsequent industrial injury, can have the disability award apportioned based on the prior nonindustrial causation.
- Scope of problem. There is substantial disagreement as between supporters of this bill and opponents of this bill on whether or not there is a serious problem of gender-based unfairness in the workers' compensation system. Some supporters have asserted that "we see it every day" while some opponents assert that the wrongs complained of simply do not occur in the workers' compensation courts.
This issue has been presented to, and debated in, the Legislature in one form or another for at least eight years, and there is a paucity of concrete evidence, either academic or anecdotal, to show that there is pervasive discrimination based on gender, or other protected classes. Proponents cite several examples of cases where women are alleged to have suffered unfair treatment by the system. In these examples it is claimed that the evaluating physician has pointed to the offending apportionment factor. Despite requests for any information indicating that workers' compensation judges have accepted these apportionment factors, proponents have been unable to do so.
- Apportionment. Apportionment applies to PD determinations when the disabling effect of an industrial injury has some percentage of causation that either predates or occurs subsequent to the industrial injury. Apportionment does not apply to medical treatment. For example, no matter how much the old football injury is making an industrial knee injury more complicated or extensive, the workers' compensation system provides medical treatment for the industrial knee injury fully and comprehensively. The fact that there is pre-industrial injury causation that affects the seriousness of the injury does not limit the extent of medical treatment. But causation of the disability is treated differently from causation of the injury.
There are at least three policy rationales underpinning the apportionment rule. First, it has been deemed unfair to require an employer to pay for disability that was not caused by the employment. Second, if the prior causation was a previous industrial injury that resulted in a PD award, the injured worker would have already been compensated for that portion of the disabling condition. Third, if an employer knew that a job candidate suffered a previous injury that might lead to more expense if he should re-injure himself, the employer might opt to hire someone else who does not pose that financial risk.
Apportionment as a policy is not without its critics. On a "but for" causation rationale, the injured worker would not be suffering the current disability to any extent but for the current industrial injury. And if the injury were being compensated in the tort system, the person who acted negligently to cause an injury would be responsible for the full extent of the disability, because in tort the "victim's" preconditions do not operate to diminish the consequences of the acts that cause injury. However, apportionment is the rule in workers' compensation, and this bill proposes exceptions to the normal rules of apportionment.
- Does case law result in gender discrimination? Proponents strongly argue that it is inappropriate gender discrimination to use even factual conditions that contribute to disability causation if those factors are uniquely attributable to being a woman. In the proponents view, even the Vaira decision endorses gender discrimination, because Vaira merely rejected use of risk factors, but allowed use of factual pre-existing conditions, including some of the factors that the bill would prohibit. Thus, the policy argument is that the uniquely female gender factors addressed by the bill should simply not be used to reduce permanent disability awards. Opponents counter that the workers' compensation system is designed to require employers to pay to injured workers what the job itself caused, not what non-job factors caused.
- Pregnancy and child birth. It is difficult to argue that permanent disabilities ought to be apportioned due to pregnancy or child birth. Indeed, many employers and insurers argue that this is not done, nor is it allowed in the workers' compensation system. However, they point out that adding these characteristics to the statute poses problems. First, they argue that it confuses the idea of causation to injury with causation to disability. They suggest that pregnancy can contribute to injury, but it is hard to understand how it is a condition that causes permanent disability. However, by adding pregnancy and child birth to the apportionment statute, uncertainties are created that will cause extended litigation to determine the precise meaning of the statutory change.
- "or other medical conditions". Unlike previous bills on this subject (see below), this bill expressly adds language that brings in other medical conditions that are related to the gender-based condition. Thus, the bill appears to expressly prohibit apportionment not merely to pregnancy or childbirth, but to any other medical condition that pre-dates the industrial injury if that prior condition can be shown to have been related to a pregnancy or child birth. For example, if a pregnancy causes back problems, and those back problems persist as a chronic problem, the bill appears to preclude using that pre-existing condition as a basis to apportion a subsequent industrial back injury. Opponents are concerned about the scope of this provision, and the amount of litigation it would create. They also note the underlying principle that employers should pay for what the job caused, but not pre-existing conditions.
- Prior legislation. In 2008, SB 1115 (Migden), and in 2011, AB 1155 (Alejo), addressed the apportionment discrimination issue in virtually the same language. Unlike this bill, those bills would have broadly prohibited the use of the protected classes defined in the Unruh Civil Rights Act as a basis to apportion permanent disability awards. Each was vetoed by the Governor.
AB 1643 (Gonzalez) of 2016, and AB 305 (Gonzalez) of 2015, take a different approach to the issue. Rather than addressing the use of protected characteristics, these bills proposed to prohibit precisely what the AB 1155 Veto Message notes that courts currently recognize: that apportionment to actual, factual prior industrial or non-industrial causation is acceptable. AB 305 was substantially similar to AB 1643. The Governor vetoed both AB 305 and AB 1643. The Veto Message to AB 1643 provided, in part:
I am returning Assembly Bill 1643 without my signature.
On the issue of apportionment, this bill creates broad, gender-based exceptions to the rule that employers are liable only for the percentage of permanent disability directly caused by a work-related injury. As written, the bill would prohibit apportionment to, and thus require employers to pay for, a permanent disability that actually resulted from pregnancy or menopause, or from osteoporosis or carpal tunnel syndrome where these are preexisting conditions or unrelated to work.
As I said last year, there is no place for gender discrimination in the workers' compensation system. Current law, however, already prohibits apportionment to risk factors, including gender, age, and family history. There is ample opportunity within the workers' compensation adjudicatory process for workers, their counsel, and others to raise any concerns or allegations of improper and impermissible gender discrimination in the medical evaluation or apportionment process.
California's workers' compensation system strives to treat all injured workers fairly and to ensure that all workers, regardless of gender, are adequately compensated for any permanent disability directly caused by work-related injuries. Rather than promoting equality, the statutory changes proposed by this measure would create new gender-based classifications and spur additional and costly litigation, undermining the successful reforms enacted in 2012 and the sustainability of the system.
GOVERNOR'S VETO MESSAGE. Consistent with his prior vetoes of similar bills, the Governor's veto message provides:
This bill would prohibit apportionment of permanent disability, in the case of a physical injury occurring on or after January 1, 2018, from being based on pregnancy, childbirth, or other medical conditions related to pregnancy or childbirth. I am vetoing this bill for the same reasons that I vetoed similar measures Assembly Bill 1643 in 2016 and Assembly Bill 305 in 2015.
The California Constitution provides that the Legislature shall create a complete system of Workers' Compensation so that employers compensate employees for injuries sustained in the course of their employment. To that end, Labor Code Section 4663 provides that the employer shall only be liable for the percentage of permanent disability directly caused by the injury. AB 570 is in direct contradiction to this Constitutional mandate and legislative scheme because it requires employers to be liable for non-work related injuries. This measure would extend the scope of the workers' compensation system well beyond what it is meant to do: compensate injured workers who suffer a work related injury.
I agree with the Author that there is no place for gender discrimination in the workers' compensation system. However, it is not discrimination to have a gender-neutral system in which only permanent disability that results directly from work injuries is compensable. The creation of a broad exception to the apportionment statutes for medical conditions that affect only women would create a gender-based classification and would not be likely to withstand constitutional challenge.
I am committed to ensuring that California's workers' compensation policy treats all injured workers fairly and that every worker, regardless of gender, is adequately compensated for their injury. I encourage proponents of this bill to support continuing efforts to educate medical evaluators on current laws prohibiting gender bias.
Analysis Prepared by: Mark Rakich / INS. / (916) 319-2086 FN: 0002484
Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | AB |
THIRD READING
Bill No: AB 570
:
SENATE LABOR & IND. REL. COMMITTEE: 4-1, 7/12/17
AYES: Bradford, Atkins, Jackson, Mitchell
NOES: Stone
SENATE APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE: 5-2, 9/1/17
AYES: Lara, Beall, Bradford, Hill, Wiener
NOES: Bates, Nielsen
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 61-15, 5/31/17 - See last page for vote
SOURCE: California Applicants’ Attorneys Association
DIGEST:
This bill prohibits apportionment in cases of physical injury based on pregnancy, childbirth, or other medical conditions related to pregnancy or childbirth.
Existing law:
- Establishes a workers’ compensation system that provides benefits to an employee who suffers from an injury or illness that arises out of and in the course of employment, irrespective of fault. This system requires all employers to secure payment of benefits by either securing the consent of the Department of Industrial Relations to self-insure or by securing insurance against liability from an insurance company duly authorized by the state.
- Requires that, if an occupational injury results in a permanent disability, the percentage of disability to total disability shall be determined, and the disability payment computed on the basis of the percentage of disability to total disability. (Labor Code §4658)
- Requires that, when doctors are determining the nature and severity of an occupational injury, the American Medical Association (AMA) Guides to the Evaluation of Permanent Impairment (5th Edition) must be used to measure physical impairment and determine an injured worker’s whole person impairment (WPI). (Labor Code §4660.1)
- Creates the Permanent Disability Ratings Schedule (PDRS), which increases the WPI by 40% and adjusts for occupation and age to calculate a percentage of permanent disability (PD), also known as a PD rating.
(Labor Code §4660.1) - Requires that any physician who prepares a report addressing the issue of permanent disability include an apportionment determination, where the physician determines what approximate percentage of the permanent disability was caused by other factors, including prior industrial injuries. (Labor Code §4663)
- Requires workers’ compensation law to be liberally construed by the courts with the purpose of extending their benefits for the protection of persons injured in the course of their employment. (Labor Code §3202)
This bill prohibits apportionment in the case of a physical injury occurring on or after January 1, 2018, based on pregnancy, childbirth, or other medical conditions related to pregnancy or childbirth.
Comments
- A Brief Word on Apportionment: Under existing law, every time a doctor prepares a report on if a claimed workplace injury is permanently disabling, the physician must determine causation AND what percentage of the injury is due to non-occupational issues, including prior workplace injuries. An injured worker’s PD award is then adjusted down by this percentage. Only a physician can determine if apportionment is appropriate and to what degree.
This makes apportionment a uniquely provocative policy. On one hand, it would be difficult to defend requiring an employer to provide PD awards for an injury that is unrelated to work or occurred at another place of employment. This is why language limiting PD awards to only cover the consequences of a workplace injury has been in law since 1917. While the current apportionment statute dates back to 2004, the idea behind it is nearly a century old.
On the other hand, determining what percentage of an injury is or is not occupational is highly dependent on the judgment of the physician. Workers’ Compensation Appeals Board (WCAB) case law provides that an apportionment finding is only valid if the physician’s medical opinion:
- Framed in terms of reasonable medical probability;
- Not speculative;
- Based on pertinent facts and on an adequate examination;
- Sets forth the reasoning in support of its conclusion; and
- Explains how and why the apportionable factor is responsible for the disability. (See Escobedo v. Marshalls, (2005) 70 Cal. Comp. Cases 604)
Despite this case law, sometimes physicians fail to meet these requirements when making an apportionment determination.
For example, in Rice v. City of Jackson, ADJ8701916 (2015), an injured worker’s PD award was apportioned by 49% due to “family history”, or the injured worker’s father’s history of hip and back issues. The physician cited several journal articles, but did not evaluate the injured worker’s family or connect the “how and why” such family history led to the injured worker’s level of permanent disability. The WCAB ruled that apportioning on the basis of genetic predisposition was inappropriate, noted that apportioning on the basis of immutable factors is impermissible, and returned the case to the local board for a new unapportioned award of permanent disability. While litigation continues on this case, it is unlikely that apportionment based on speculative research/information could sustain judicial scrutiny.
Proponents have brought forward several examples of apportionment that, like Rice, appear to fall into the arena of Qualified Medical Evaluator (QME) failure. Each example is troubling. However, they are a small sample; thousands of apportionment decisions are issued each year and have been for over a decade. Staff notes that it is currently unclear if such a small sample of apportionment examples demonstrates systemic inequality towards women or notable examples of physician error.
One final note on apportionment: the apportioning of a PD award has no impact on the ability of an injured worker to receive medical care. Even in the event that a PD award is apportioned to 0%, the worker has a right to medical care if the injury arises or occurs in the course of employment (See Employers Mutual Liability Ins. Co. of Wisconsin v. Industrial Acc. Com. (Gideon) (1953) 41 Cal.2d 676 and Reyes v. Hart Plastering (2005) 70 Cal.Comp.Cases 223).
- Apportionment and AB 570. As discussed above, employers are already liable for medical treatment for an industrial injury, even if the injury is eventually apportioned to 0%. AB 570 will make employer additionally liable for increased indemnity benefits by prohibiting apportionment due to pregnancy, childbirth, or other medical conditions related to pregnancy or childbirth. So, it is clear that AB 570 will increase the amount of indemnity benefits paid by employers to injured workers. But to what degree and by how much?
The full impact of this legislation, unfortunately, is highly difficult to predict. For one, the impact of apportionment in the workers’ compensation system hasn’t been studied since 2008. Much has happened in the 9 years that has passed, and it is likely that the full systemic impact of apportionment is no longer captured by that study. As has been discussed before in previous analyses, apportionment cries out as a topic that requires additional, comprehensive research.
Additionally, it is also difficult to predict how litigation around this apportionment and pregnancy will develop. AB 570 references “medical conditions related to pregnancy or childbirth”. As pregnancy and childbirth can impact virtually every biological system, it is hard to know where this language begins and ends. Moreover, if AB 570 became law, it would be the first time a statute was passed to shape apportionment determinations on the basis of gender, rather than factual medical findings.
Labor Code §3202 requires a liberal construction of workers’ compensation law by the WCAB “with the purpose of extending their benefits for the protection of persons injured in the course of their employment.” It is almost certain that this will eventually grow to encompass medical conditions that were not originally considered by the Legislature. To what degree and in what cases, however, is largely unknowable.
With that said, at least in the short run, AB 570 will likely encourage litigation to push the boundaries of what medical conditions are considered related to pregnancy or childbirth. It is unlikely that this increased litigation will improve outcomes for either workers or employers.
- Areas for Further Discussion and Reform. As was discussed above and in prior analyses, the issues raised by AB 570 appear to be related to QMEs unlawfully apportioning injured worker’s PD ratings. This sort of error is simply unacceptable, and it adds to the perception that California’s workers’ compensation system does not appropriately serve injured workers.
Fortunately, existing law provides a remedy. Under Labor Code §139.2(k), the administrative director may suspend or discipline a QME for a limited list of reasons, including failing to meet minimum requirements set by the administrative director. While consistently apportioning on the basis of gender, race, or supposed genetic characteristics almost certainly falls into such a category, clarifying this would almost certainly reduce its frequency.
Related/Prior Legislation
AB 1643 (Gonzalez) of 2016 would have prohibited apportionment in cases of physical injury based on pregnancy, menopause, osteoporosis, and carpal tunnel syndrome. AB 1643 was vetoed by Governor Brown. His veto message read:
"I am returning Assembly Bill 1643 without my signature.
On the issue of apportionment, this bill creates broad, gender-based exceptions to the rule that employers are liable only for the percentage of permanent disability directly caused by a work-related injury. As written, the bill would prohibit apportionment to, and thus require employers to pay for, a permanent disability that actually resulted from pregnancy or menopause, or from osteoporosis or carpal tunnel syndrome where these are preexisting conditions or unrelated to work.
As I said last year, there is no place for gender discrimination in the workers' compensation system. Current law, however, already prohibits apportionment to risk factors, including gender, age, and family history. There is ample opportunity within the workers' compensation adjudicatory process for workers, their counsel, and others to raise any concerns or allegations of improper and impermissible gender discrimination in the medical evaluation or apportionment process.
California's workers' compensation system strives to treat all injured workers fairly and to ensure that all workers, regardless of gender, are adequately compensated for any permanent disability directly caused by work-related injuries. Rather than promoting equality, the statutory changes proposed by this measure would create new gender-based classifications and spur additional and costly litigation, undermining the successful reforms enacted in 2012 and the sustainability of the system."
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: Fiscal Com.: Local:
California Applicants’ Attorneys Association (source)
American Federation of State, County and Municipal Employees, AFL-CIO
California Conference Board of the Amalgamated Transit Union
California Conference of Machinists
California Federation of Teachers
California Teamsters Public Affairs Council
Engineers & Scientists of California, IFPTE Local 20, AFL-CIO
International Longshore and Warehouse Union
Los Angeles County Professional Peace Officers Association
Professional & Technical Engineers, IFPTE Local 21, AFL-CIO
Riverside Sheriffs’ Association
UNITE-HERE, AFL-CIO
Utility Workers Union of America
American Insurance Association
Association of California Healthcare Districts
Association of California Insurance Companies
BizFed
California Association of Joint Powers Authorities
California Chamber of Commerce
California Coalition on Workers’ Compensation
California Grocers Association
California Manufacturers & Technology Association
California Special Districts Association
California State Association of Counties
CSAC Excess Insurance Authority
National Federation of Independent Business
Western Occupational and Environmental Medical Association
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: Proponents, noting the Governor’s veto message of last year’s AB 1643 (see below), argue that AB 570 address the Governor’s veto message and fight gender discrimination in the California workers’ compensation system. Specifically, proponents note that AB 570 will prohibit apportionment based on pregnancy, childbirth, or other medical conditions related to pregnancy or childbirth. Proponents argue that apportionment on this basis is fundamentally discriminatory, and that AB 570 is an important first step towards achieving gender equality in California’s workers’ compensation system.
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION: Opponents to AB 570, which include the California Coalition on Workers’ Compensation, the California Association of Joint Powers Authorities, and the California Chamber of Commerce, argue the following:
We oppose AB 570 because it is a violation of the fundamental agreement between workers and their employers that establishes the foundation of our workers’ compensation system. That agreement holds that employers will accept responsibility for all injuries and illnesses that occur in the course and scope of employment, even when they would otherwise have no legal liability. The workers, in exchange for the guaranteed coverage, relinquish the right to sue their employers in civil court. AB 570 violates that agreement by requiring employers to compensate injured workers for disability that has not, with medical certainty, resulted from a workplace injury.
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 61-15, 5/31/17
AYES: Acosta, Aguiar-Curry, Arambula, Baker, Berman, Bloom, Bocanegra, Bonta, Burke, Caballero, Calderon, Cervantes, Chau, Chiu, Chu, Cooley, Cooper, Cunningham, Dababneh, Daly, Fong, Frazier, Friedman, Cristina Garcia, Eduardo Garcia, Gipson, Gloria, Gomez, Gonzalez Fletcher, Gray, Grayson, Holden, Irwin, Jones-Sawyer, Kalra, Lackey, Levine, Limón, Low, Maienschein, McCarty, Medina, Mullin, Muratsuchi, Nazarian, O'Donnell, Quirk, Quirk-Silva, Reyes, Ridley-Thomas, Rodriguez, Rubio, Salas, Santiago, Steinorth, Mark Stone, Thurmond, Ting, Weber, Wood, Rendon
NOES: Bigelow, Brough, Chávez, Chen, Dahle, Flora, Gallagher, Harper, Kiley, Mathis, Mayes, Obernolte, Patterson, Voepel, Waldron
NO VOTE RECORDED: Travis Allen, Choi, Eggman, Melendez
9/3/17 17:48:59
**** END ****
SENATE COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Senator Ricardo Lara, Chair
2017 - 2018 Regular Session
AB 570 (Gonzalez Fletcher) - Workers’ compensation: permanent disability apportionment
Version: February 14, 2017 | Policy Vote: L. & I.R. 4 - 1 |
Urgency: No | Mandate: No |
Hearing Date: August 21, 2017 | Consultant: Robert Ingenito |
This bill meets the criteria for referral to the Suspense File.
Bill Summary:
AB 570 would prohibit apportionment in cases of physical injury based on pregnancy, childbirth, or other medical conditions related to pregnancy or childbirth.
Fiscal Impact:
This bill would lead to increased costs for the Division of Workers' Compensation (DWC) and the Workers' Compensation Appeals Board (WCAB) within the Department of Industrial Relations (DIR), resulting from an increased number of disputes concerning causation of permanent disability between employers and female workers’ compensation applicants. This could lead to significantly more filings, hearings and trials within the workers’ compensation system on apportionment issues, which could in turn lead to significant increases in the costs of administration. DIR estimates that the total cost could be several million dollars (Workers Compensation Administration Revolving Fund, See Staff Comments).
Additionally the State would experience increased costs as a direct employer as a result of the bill. The magnitude is unknown, but potentially significant (General Fund, special funds, See staff Comments).
Background:
Current law establishes a workers’ compensation system that provides benefits to an employee who suffers from an injury or illness that occurs during the course of employment, irrespective of fault. This system requires all employers to secure payment of benefits by either (1) securing the consent of DIR to self-insure, or (2) securing insurance against liability from an insurance company authorized by the State.
Under current law, when doctors are determining the nature and severity of an occupational injury, the American Medical Association (AMA) Guides to the Evaluation of Permanent Impairment (5th Edition) must be used to measure physical impairment and determine an injured worker’s whole person impairment (WPI).
When physicians prepare a report regarding whether a claimed workplace injury is permanently disabling, the physician must determine both (1) causation, and (2) what percentage of the injury is due to non-occupational issues, including prior workplace injuries. An injured worker’s permanent disability (PD) award is then adjusted down by this percentage, referred to as an apportionment determination. Only a physician can make the determination whether and to what extent if apportionment is appropriate.
Proposed Law:
This bill would prohibit apportionment in the case of a physical injury occurring on or after January 1, 2018, based on pregnancy, childbirth, or other medical conditions related to pregnancy or childbirth.
Related Legislation:
AB 1643 (Gonzalez) of 2016 would have prohibited apportionment in cases of physical injury based on pregnancy, menopause, osteoporosis, and carpal tunnel syndrome. The bill was vetoed by the Governor.
Staff Comments:
The Office of the Legislative Counsel has keyed this bill “non-fiscal.” However, the purview of this Committee, pursuant to Joint Rule 10.5, is to review and analyze bills that would, among other things, result in a substantial expenditure of state money. Thus, even though AB 570 was keyed “non-fiscal,” the Committee requested the bill to examine the extent to which it might potentially increase both workload and state costs.
As noted above, under current workers compensation law, an employer is only liable for the percentage of permanent disability directly caused by the injury arising out of and occurring in the course of employment. This bill would instead make employers liable for disability caused by specified non-work related medical conditions. The result would be a substantial increases in the cost of workers’ compensation insurance for employers in in California, including the State itself as a direct employer. DIR data indicate that there are more than 600,000 workers’ compensation claims filed in California annually, and approximately 43 percent of those are filed by women. Consequently, DIR estimates that the increase in costs to the workers compensation system from making employers liable for disability that may be caused by pregnancy and childbirth-related medical conditions, rather than by work injuries, would likely be, a minimum, in the tens of millions of dollars annually. The State’s share of this increase as a direct employer is unknown, but potentially significant.
Moreover, the exception to the apportionment standard created by the bill would lead to more filings, hearings and trials within the workers’ compensation system on apportionment issues, which would in turn lead to significant administrative costs to DIR. Specifically, DIR indicates that it would likely require several million dollars in additional staff resources for DWC to administer the increased workload.
-- END --
SENATE COMMITTEE ON LABOR AND INDUSTRIAL RELATIONS
Senator Steven Bradford, Chair
2017 - 2018 Regular
Bill No: AB 570 Hearing Date: July 12, 2017
Author: | Gonzalez Fletcher | ||
Version: | February 14, 2017 | ||
Urgency: | No | Fiscal: | No |
Consultant: | Gideon L. Baum | ||
Subject: Workers’ compensation: permanent disability apportionment
KEY ISSUE
Should the Legislature prohibit apportionment in cases of physical injury based on pregnancy, childbirth, or other medical conditions related to pregnancy or childbirth?
ANALYSIS
Existing law:
- Establishes a workers’ compensation system that provides benefits to an employee who suffers from an injury or illness that arises out of and in the course of employment, irrespective of fault. This system requires all employers to secure payment of benefits by either securing the consent of the Department of Industrial Relations to self-insure or by securing insurance against liability from an insurance company duly authorized by the state.
- Requires that, if an occupational injury results in a permanent disability, the percentage of disability to total disability shall be determined, and the disability payment computed on the basis of the percentage of disability to total disability. (Labor Code §4658)
- Requires that, when doctors are determining the nature and severity of an occupational injury, the American Medical Association (AMA) Guides to the Evaluation of Permanent Impairment (5th Edition) must be used to measure physical impairment and determine an injured worker’s whole person impairment (WPI). (Labor Code §4660.1)
- Creates the Permanent Disability Ratings Schedule (PDRS), which increases the WPI by 40% and adjusts for occupation and age to calculate a percentage of permanent disability (PD), also known as a PD rating. (Labor Code §4660.1)
- Requires that any physician who prepares a report addressing the issue of permanent disability include an apportionment determination, where the physician determines what approximate percentage of the permanent disability was caused by other factors, including prior industrial injuries. (Labor Code §4663)
- Requires workers’ compensation law to be liberally construed by the courts with the purpose of extending their benefits for the protection of persons injured in the course of their employment. (Labor Code §3202)
This bill prohibits apportionment in the case of a physical injury occurring on or after January 1, 2018, based on pregnancy, childbirth, or other medical conditions related to pregnancy or childbirth.
COMMENTS
1. A Brief Word on Apportionment:
Under existing law, every time a doctor prepares a report on if a claimed workplace injury is permanently disabling, the physician must determine causation AND what percentage of the injury is due to non-occupational issues, including prior workplace injuries. An injured worker’s PD award is then adjusted down by this percentage. Only a physician can determine if apportionment is appropriate and to what degree.
This makes apportionment a uniquely provocative policy. On one hand, it would be difficult to defend requiring an employer to provide PD awards for an injury that is unrelated to work or occurred at another place of employment. This is why language limiting PD awards to only cover the consequences of a workplace injury has been in law since 1917. While the current apportionment statute dates back to 2004, the idea behind it is nearly a century old.
On the other hand, determining what percentage of an injury is or is not occupational is highly dependent on the judgment of the physician. Workers’ Compensation Appeals Board (WCAB) case law provides that an apportionment finding is only valid if the physician’s medical opinion:
- Framed in terms of reasonable medical probability;
- Not speculative;
- Based on pertinent facts and on an adequate examination;
- Sets forth the reasoning in support of its conclusion; and
- Explains how and why the apportionable factor is responsible for the disability.
(See Escobedo v. Marshalls, (2005) 70 Cal. Comp. Cases 604)
Despite this case law, sometimes physicians fail to meet these requirements when making an apportionment determination.
For example, in Rice v. City of Jackson, ADJ8701916 (2015), an injured worker’s PD award was apportioned by 49% due to “family history”, or the injured worker’s father’s history of hip and back issues. The physician cited several journal articles, but did not evaluate the injured worker’s family or connect the “how and why” such family history led to the injured worker’s level of permanent disability. The WCAB ruled that apportioning on the basis of genetic predisposition was inappropriate, noted that apportioning on the basis of immutable factors is impermissible, and returned the case to the local board for a new unapportioned award of permanent disability. While litigation continues on this case, it is unlikely that apportionment based on speculative research/information could sustain judicial scrutiny.
Proponents have brought forward several examples of apportionment that, like Rice, appear to fall into the arena of Qualified Medical Evaluator (QME) failure. Each example is troubling. However, they are a small sample; thousands of apportionment decisions are issued each year and have been for over a decade. Staff notes that it is currently unclear if such a small sample of apportionment examples demonstrates systemic inequality towards women or notable examples of physician error.
One final note on apportionment: the apportioning of a PD award has no impact on the ability of an injured worker to receive medical care. Even in the event that a PD award is apportioned to 0%, the worker has a right to medical care if the injury arises or occurs in the course of employment (See Employers Mutual Liability Ins. Co. of Wisconsin v. Industrial Acc. Com. (Gideon) (1953) 41 Cal.2d 676 and Reyes v. Hart Plastering (2005) 70 Cal.Comp.Cases 223).
2. Staff Comments:
Apportionment and AB 570
As discussed above, employers are already liable for medical treatment for an industrial injury, even if the injury is eventually apportioned to 0%. AB 570 will make employer additionally liable for increased indemnity benefits by prohibiting apportionment due to pregnancy, childbirth, or other medical conditions related to pregnancy or childbirth. So, it is clear that AB 570 will increase the amount of indemnity benefits paid by employers to injured workers. But to what degree and by how much?
The full impact of this legislation, unfortunately, is highly difficult to predict. For one, the impact of apportionment in the workers’ compensation system hasn’t been studied since 2008. Much has happened in the 9 years that has passed, and it is likely that the full systemic impact of apportionment is no longer captured by that study. As has been discussed before in previous analyses, apportionment cries out as a topic that requires additional, comprehensive research.
Additionally, it is also difficult to predict how litigation around this apportionment and pregnancy will develop. AB 570 references “medical conditions related to pregnancy or childbirth”. As pregnancy and childbirth can impact virtually every biological system, it is hard to know where this language begins and ends. Moreover, if AB 570 became law, it would be the first time a statute was passed to shape apportionment determinations on the basis of gender, rather than factual medical findings.
Labor Code §3202 requires a liberal construction of workers’ compensation law by the WCAB “with the purpose of extending their benefits for the protection of persons injured in the course of their employment.” It is almost certain that this will eventually grow to encompass medical conditions that were not originally considered by the Legislature. To what degree and in what cases, however, is largely unknowable.
With that said, at least in the short run, AB 570 will likely encourage litigation to push the boundaries of what medical conditions are considered related to pregnancy or childbirth. It is unlikely that this increased litigation will improve outcomes for either workers or employers.
Areas for Further Discussion and Reform
As was discussed above and in prior analyses, the issues raised by AB 570 appear to be related to QMEs unlawfully apportioning injured worker’s PD ratings. This sort of error is simply unacceptable, and it adds to the perception that California’s workers’ compensation system does not appropriately serve injured workers.
Fortunately, existing law provides a remedy. Under Labor Code §139.2(k), the administrative director may suspend or discipline a QME for a limited list of reasons, including failing to meet minimum requirements set by the administrative director. While consistently apportioning on the basis of gender, race, or supposed genetic characteristics almost certainly falls into such a category, clarifying this would almost certainly reduce its frequency. This may be a topic of reform that the author and/or Committee may wish to consider.
3. Proponent Arguments:
Proponents, noting the Governor’s veto message of last year’s AB 1643 (see below), argue that AB 570 address the Governor’s veto message and fight gender discrimination in the California workers’ compensation system. Specifically, proponents note that AB 570 will prohibit apportionment based on pregnancy, childbirth, or other medical conditions related to pregnancy or childbirth. Proponents argue that apportionment on this basis is fundamentally discriminatory, and that AB 570 is an important first step towards achieving gender equality in California’s workers’ compensation system.
4. Opponent Arguments:
Opponents to AB 570, which include the California Coalition on Workers’ Compensation (CCWC), the California Association of Joint Powers Authorities (CAJPA), and the California Chamber of Commerce, argue the following:
“We oppose AB 570 because it is a violation of the fundamental agreement between workers and their employers that establishes the foundation of our workers’ compensation system. That agreement holds that employers will accept responsibility for all injuries and illnesses that occur in the course and scope of employment, even when they would otherwise have no legal liability. The workers, in exchange for the guaranteed coverage, relinquish the right to sue their employers in civil court. AB 570 violates that agreement by requiring employers to compensate injured workers for disability that has not, with medical certainty, resulted from a workplace injury.”
5. Prior Legislation:
AB 1643 (Gonzalez) of 2016 would have prohibited apportionment in cases of physical injury based on pregnancy, menopause, osteoporosis, and carpal tunnel syndrome. AB 1643 was vetoed by Governor Brown. His veto message read:
"I am returning Assembly Bill 1643 without my signature.
On the issue of apportionment, this bill creates broad, gender-based exceptions to the rule that employers are liable only for the percentage of permanent disability directly caused by a work-related injury. As written, the bill would prohibit apportionment to, and thus require employers to pay for, a permanent disability that actually resulted from pregnancy or menopause, or from osteoporosis or carpal tunnel syndrome where these are preexisting conditions or unrelated to work.
As I said last year, there is no place for gender discrimination in the workers' compensation system. Current law, however, already prohibits apportionment to risk factors, including gender, age, and family history. There is ample opportunity within the workers' compensation adjudicatory process for workers, their counsel, and others to raise any concerns or allegations of improper and impermissible gender discrimination in the medical evaluation or apportionment process.
California's workers' compensation system strives to treat all injured workers fairly and to ensure that all workers, regardless of gender, are adequately compensated for any permanent disability directly caused by work-related injuries. Rather than promoting equality, the statutory changes proposed by this measure would create new gender-based classifications and spur additional and costly litigation, undermining the successful reforms enacted in 2012 and the sustainability of the system."
SUPPORT
California Applicants’ Attorneys Association (Sponsor)
American Federation of State, County and Municipal Employees, AFL-CIO
California Conference Board of the Amalgamated Transit Union
California Conference of Machinists
California Federation of Teachers
California Teamsters Public Affairs Council
Engineers & Scientists of California, IFPTE Local 20, AFL-CIO
International Longshore and Warehouse Union
Los Angeles County Professional Peace Officers Association
Professional & Technical Engineers, IFPTE Local 21, AFL-CIO
Riverside Sheriffs’ Association
UNITE-HERE, AFL-CIO
Utility Workers Union of America
OPPOSITION
American Insurance Association
Association of California Healthcare Districts
Association of California Insurance Companies
BizFed
California Association of Joint Powers Authorities
California Chamber of Commerce
California Coalition on Workers’ Compensation
California Grocers Association
California Manufacturers & Technology Association
California Special Districts Association
California State Association of Counties
CSAC Excess Insurance Authority
National Federation of Independent Business
Western Occupational and Environmental Medical Association
-- END --
ASSEMBLY THIRD READING
ATR Bill Id:AB 570
Author:(Gonzalez Fletcher)
As Introduced Ver:February 14, 2017
Majority vote
Committee | Votes | Ayes | Noes |
Insurance | 12-1 | Daly, Melendez, Bigelow, Caballero, Calderon, Chu, Cooley, Cooper, Dababneh, Dahle, Frazier, Gipson | Voepel |
Appropriations | 13-3 | Gonzalez Fletcher, Bloom, Bocanegra, Bonta, Calderon, McCarty, Quirk, Fong, Friedman, Eduardo Garcia, Gray, Muratsuchi, Reyes | Bigelow, Brough, Obernolte |
SUMMARY: Prohibits the use of pregnancy, childbirth, or other medical conditions related to pregnancy or childbirth, in the calculation of permanent disability benefits for injuries occurring on or after January 1, 2018.
EXISTING LAW:
- Provides for a comprehensive system to provide workers' compensation benefits for workers whose injuries arise out of or in the course of employment, including medical treatment and financial compensation if the injury or condition has a permanently disabling effect.
- Establishes a Permanent Disability Rating Schedule (PDRS), a methodology for calculating impairment through the use of the American Medical Association Guides to the Evaluation of Permanent Impairment (AMA Guides), and other tools that are used to determine the extent of an injured worker's permanent disability (PD).
- Allows for the "apportionment" of PD determinations to prior industrial causes, to prior non-industrial causes, or to subsequent causes, and reduces the amount of the injured worker's PD award to the extent these causes have contributed to the extent of the disability.
- Requires the physician who is making a recommendation on the extent of disability that has followed from an industrial injury to identify, and quantify, causation of the disability that is either prior to or subsequent to the industrial injury.
FISCAL EFFECT: According the Assembly Appropriations Committee:
- Increased administrative costs to the Division of Workers' Compensation and the Workers' Compensation Appeals Board (WCAB) within the Department of Industrial Relations. Because of the exception to the apportionment standard created by this bill, disputes concerning causation of permanent disability between employers and female workers’ compensation applicants are likely to increase substantially. This could lead to significantly more filings, hearings and trials within the workers' compensation system on apportionment issues, which could in turn lead to significant increases in the costs of administration. This total cost is unknown, but could be well in excess of $1 million (Workers Compensation Administration Revolving Fund).
- Increased costs to the state as an employer. The state could incur unknown, likely significantly increased workers' compensation costs for higher permanent partial disability compensation as a result of fewer allowable apportionments (various funds).
COMMENTS:
- Purpose. The purpose of the bill is to eliminate elements of what the author believes is gender bias in the workers' compensation system. According to the author, women can receive disproportionately low compensation amounts for work-related permanent disability because of the gender-specific conditions of pregnancy and childbirth. The author points to specific examples where the evaluating physician has pointed to pre-existing conditions that have involved pregnancy or childbirth in apportioning the causation of subsequent industrial injuries, and argues that this constitutes an inappropriate discrimination, since male injured workers can never have their disability apportioned in this manner.
- Case Law. In an unpublished appellate decision, Vaira v. WCAB, the Court of Appeal returned a case to the Workers' Compensation Appeals Board (WCAB) because the record was insufficient to determine whether the physician had based his apportionment decision on medical facts that showed the older female claimant suffered from osteoporosis, or on the basis that the risk factor (older women face a high risk of suffering from osteoporosis) alone was sufficient to assign a percentage of the causation to osteoporosis. This decision has been broadly applied in the workers' compensation courts as establishing the following rule: a risk characteristic such as older women having a high incidence of osteoporosis, or older African American men having a high incidence of hypertension, cannot be used as a basis to apportion a permanent disability award. However, a woman diagnosed with osteoporosis that contributes to her disability resulting from the subsequent industrial injury, or an African American man diagnosed with hypertension that contributes to his disability resulting from the subsequent industrial injury, can have the disability award apportioned based on the prior nonindustrial causation.
- Scope of problem. There is substantial disagreement as between supporters of this bill and opponents of this bill on whether or not there is a serious problem of gender-based unfairness in the workers' compensation system. Some supporters have asserted that "we see it every day" while some opponents assert that the wrongs complained of simply do not occur in the workers' compensation courts.
This issue has been presented to, and debated in, the Legislature in one form or another for at least eight years, and there is a paucity of concrete evidence, either academic or anecdotal, to show that there is pervasive discrimination based on gender, or other protected classes. Proponents cite several examples of cases where women are alleged to have suffered unfair treatment by the system. In these examples it is claimed that the evaluating physician has pointed to the offending apportionment factor. Despite requests for any information indicating that workers' compensation judges have accepted these apportionment factors, proponents have been unable to do so.
- Apportionment. Apportionment applies to PD determinations when the disabling effect of an industrial injury has some percentage of causation that either predates or occurs subsequent to the industrial injury. Apportionment does not apply to medical treatment. For example, no matter how much the old football injury is making an industrial knee injury more complicated or extensive, the workers' compensation system provides medical treatment for the industrial knee injury fully and comprehensively. The fact that there is pre-industrial injury causation that affects the seriousness of the injury does not limit the extent of medical treatment. But causation of the disability is treated differently from causation of the injury.
There are at least three policy rationales underpinning the apportionment rule. First, it has been deemed unfair to require an employer to pay for disability that was not caused by the employment. Second, if the prior causation was a previous industrial injury that resulted in a PD award, the injured worker would have already been compensated for that portion of the disabling condition. Third, if an employer knew that a job candidate suffered a previous injury that might lead to more expense if he should re-injure himself, the employer might opt to hire someone else who does not pose that financial risk.
Apportionment as a policy is not without its critics. On a "but for" causation rationale, the injured worker would not be suffering the current disability to any extent but for the current industrial injury. And if the injury were being compensated in the tort system, the person who acted negligently to cause an injury would be responsible for the full extent of the disability, because in tort the "victim's" preconditions do not operate to diminish the consequences of the acts that cause injury. However, apportionment is the rule in workers' compensation, and this bill proposes exceptions to the normal rules of apportionment.
- Does case law result in gender discrimination? Proponents strongly argue that it is inappropriate gender discrimination to use even factual conditions that contribute to disability causation if those factors are uniquely attributable to being a woman. In the proponents view, even the Vaira decision endorses gender discrimination, because Vaira merely rejected use of risk factors, but allowed use of factual pre-existing conditions, including some of the factors that the bill would prohibit. Thus, the policy argument is that the uniquely female gender factors addressed by the bill should simply not be used to reduce permanent disability awards. Opponents counter that the workers' compensation system is designed to require employers to pay to injured workers what the job itself caused, not what non-job factors caused.
- Pregnancy and child birth. It is difficult to argue that permanent disabilities ought to be apportioned due to pregnancy or child birth. Indeed, many employers and insurers argue that this is not done, nor is it allowed in the workers' compensation system. However, they point out that adding these characteristics to the statute poses problems. First, they argue that it confuses the idea of causation to injury with causation to disability. They suggest that pregnancy can contribute to injury, but it is hard to understand how it is a condition that causes permanent disability. However, by adding pregnancy and child birth to the apportionment statute, uncertainties are created that will cause extended litigation to determine the precise meaning of the statutory change.
- "or other medical conditions". Unlike previous bills on this subject (see below), this bill expressly adds language that brings in other medical conditions that are related to the gender-based condition. Thus, the bill appears to expressly prohibit apportionment not merely to pregnancy or childbirth, but to any other medical condition that pre-dates the industrial injury if that prior condition can be shown to have been related to a pregnancy or child birth. For example, if a pregnancy causes back problems, and those back problems persist as a chronic problem, the bill appears to preclude using that pre-existing condition as a basis to apportion a subsequent industrial back injury. Opponents are concerned about the scope of this provision, and the amount of litigation it would create. They also note the underlying principle that employers should pay for what the job caused, but not pre-existing conditions.
- Prior legislation. In 2008, SB 1115 (Migden), and in 2011, AB 1155, addressed the apportionment discrimination issue in virtually the same language. Unlike this bill, those bills would have broadly prohibited the use of the protected classes defined in the Unruh Civil Rights Act as a basis to apportion permanent disability awards. Each was vetoed by the Governor.
AB 1643 (Gonzalez) of 2016, and AB 305 (Gonzalez) of 2015, take a different approach to the issue. Rather than addressing the use of protected characteristics, these bills proposed to prohibit precisely what the AB 1155 Veto Message notes that courts currently recognize: that apportionment to actual, factual prior industrial or non-industrial causation is acceptable. AB 305 was substantially similar to AB 1643. The Governor vetoed both AB 305 and AB 1643. The Veto Message to AB 1643 provided, in part:
"I am returning Assembly Bill 1643 without my signature.
"On the issue of apportionment, this bill creates broad, gender-based exceptions to the rule that employers are liable only for the percentage of permanent disability directly caused by a work-related injury. As written, the bill would prohibit apportionment to, and thus require employers to pay for, a permanent disability that actually resulted from pregnancy or menopause, or from osteoporosis or carpal tunnel syndrome where these are preexisting conditions or unrelated to work.
"As I said last year, there is no place for gender discrimination in the workers' compensation system. Current law, however, already prohibits apportionment to risk factors, including gender, age, and family history. There is ample opportunity within the workers' compensation adjudicatory process for workers, their counsel, and others to raise any concerns or allegations of improper and impermissible gender discrimination in the medical evaluation or apportionment process.
"California's workers' compensation system strives to treat all injured workers fairly and to ensure that all workers, regardless of gender, are adequately compensated for any permanent disability directly caused by work-related injuries. Rather than promoting equality, the statutory changes proposed by this measure would create new gender-based classifications and spur additional and costly litigation, undermining the successful reforms enacted in 2012 and the sustainability of the system."
Analysis Prepared by: Mark Rakich / INS. / (916) 319-2086 FN: 0000802
Date of Hearing: May 17, 2017
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Lorena Gonzalez Fletcher, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 570
Author:(Gonzalez Fletcher) – As Introduced Ver:February 14, 2017
Policy Committee: | Insurance | Vote: | 12 - 1 |
Urgency: No State Mandated Local Program: No Reimbursable: No
SUMMARY:
This bill prohibits the use of pregnancy, childbirth, or other medical conditions related to pregnancy or childbirth, in the calculation of permanent disability benefits for injuries occurring on or after January 1, 2018.
FISCAL EFFECT:
This bill would have two separate fiscal effects, as follows:
- Increased administrative costs to the Division of Workers' Compensation and the Workers' Compensation Appeals Board (WCAB) within the Department of Industrial Relations. Because of the exception to the apportionment standard created by this bill, disputes concerning causation of permanent disability between employers and female workers’ compensation applicants are likely to increase substantially. This could lead to significantly more filings, hearings and trials within the workers’ compensation system on apportionment issues, which could in turn lead to significant increases in the costs of administration. This total cost is unknown, but could be well in excess of $1 million (Workers Compensation Administration Revolving Fund).
- Increased costs to the state as an employer. The state could incur unknown, likely significantly increased workers' compensation costs for higher permanent partial disability compensation as a result of fewer allowable apportionments (various funds).
COMMENTS:
- Purpose. The purpose of the bill is to eliminate elements of what is perceived as gender bias in the workers' compensation system. According to the author, women can receive disproportionately low compensation amounts for work-related permanent disability because of the gender-specific conditions of pregnancy and childbirth. The author argues this constitutes inappropriate discrimination, since male injured workers can never have their disability apportioned in this manner.
- Background. Current law establishes a workers’ compensation system that provides benefits to an employee who suffers from an injury or illness that occurs during the course of employment, irrespective of fault. Workers' compensation benefits include medical treatment and indemnity benefits, including temporary and permanent disability benefits. Gender bias in workers' compensation was the subject of an informational hearing by the Assembly Select Committee on Women in the Workplace on February 23, 2016. In general, there is significant disagreement about whether there is gender bias in the workers' compensation system.
- Determining PD Awards. Once an individual's condition is permanent and stationary, they can be evaluated for PD benefits.
- Impairment. Impairment refers to how the injury affects one's ability to do normal life activities. Most people receiving PD benefits are not 100% disabled, but instead receive permanent partial disability based on a partial loss of function. Under current law, when doctors are determining the nature and severity of an occupational injury, the American Medical Association (AMA) Guides to the Evaluation of Permanent Impairment, 5th Edition must be used to measure physical impairment and determine an injured worker’s whole person impairment (WPI), which is expressed as a percentage of impairment. A treating physician issues a report that provides a WPI value and an apportionment determination.
- Apportionment. Physician's reports must include an apportionment determination, which is a determination that some percentage of a disability is not work-related. Apportioning a percentage of the injury to a preexisting condition, if applicable, attempts to ensure employers are only responsible to provide permanent disability compensation for a disability that is work-related. This bill bars apportionment based on pregnancy, childbirth, or other medical conditions related to pregnancy or childbirth, regardless of whether the condition is work-related.
- Disability evaluation. Disability means how impairment affects one's ability to work. A disability rating is issued, which is expressed as a percentage. The rating is based on the WPI value, applicable apportionment, and other relevant factors such as age and occupation. After the amount of PD in a claim is determined, there is usually a settlement, or award for benefits, which the claims administrator or the injured party's attorney can assist to obtain.
- Appeals and litigation. There are a number of avenues for appeals if the injured party disagrees with a medical report on impairment or an apportionment determination, or a disability rating. The process depends on whether he or she is represented by an attorney. He or she can appeal to a DWC to have the rating reconsidered, and/or present the case to a workers' compensation administrative law judge at the WCAB. If there is a dispute about impairment and apportionment determinations, an injured worker can request a qualified medical examiner (QME), who is selected from a panel, or an agreed medical examiner (AME) to provide a new report.
As explained in the fiscal comments, this bill would tend to raise the PD awards for women by eliminating apportionment, and could also raise administrative costs through more appeals and more litigation.
- Support. The California Applicants Attorneys and various labor groups support this bill, arguing women should not be punished through lower permanent disability ratings for conditions related to childbirth and pregnancy.
- Opposition. Groups representing private employers, local public employers, insurance companies, and the California Coalition for Workers' Compensation are opposed to this bill. Opponents contend this bill directly contradicts a core principle in workers' compensation: that the employer is responsible only for the percentage of permanent disability directly caused by the work-related injuries.
- Prior Legislation. AB 305 (Gonzalez) and AB 1643 (Gonzalez), both of the 2015-16 Legislative Session, were similar to this bill in that they prohibited apportionment based on several conditions more likely in to occur in females, among other provisions. Both bills were vetoed. As it relates to apportionment, the veto message to AB 1643 stated, in part:
"I am vetoing this bill for many of the same reasons that I returned a similar measure, AB 305, last year. This bill is poorly drafted and reflects a seriously flawed understanding of both the workers' compensation system and the nature of physical disability that may result from a work-related injury…. It would also create broad gender-based exceptions to the core principle of apportionment: that employers are liable only for the permanent disability directly caused by their employee's work-related injury…. Rather than promoting equality, the statutory changes proposed by this measure would create new gender-based classifications and spur additional and costly litigation, undermining the successful reforms enacted in 2012 and the sustainability of the system."
This bill does not appear to address the veto message, as it prohibits apportionment to conditions that are not work-related, making employers liable for disability caused by the specified non-work-related conditions.
Analysis Prepared by: Lisa Murawski / APPR. / (916) 319-2081
Date of Hearing: May 3, 2017
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON INSURANCE
Tom Daly, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 570 (
Author:Gonzalez Fletcher) – As Introduced Ver:February 14, 2017
SUBJECT: Workers’ compensation: permanent disability apportionment
SUMMARY: Prohibits the use of pregnancy, childbirth, or other medical conditions related to pregnancy or childbirth, in the calculation of permanent disability benefits for injuries occurring on or after January 1, 2018.
EXISTING LAW:
- Provides for a comprehensive system to provide workers' compensation benefits for workers whose injuries arise out of or in the course of employment, including medical treatment and financial compensation if the injury or condition has a permanently disabling effect.
- Establishes a Permanent Disability Rating Schedule (PDRS), a methodology for calculating impairment through the use of the American Medical Association Guides to the Evaluation of Permanent Impairment (AMA Guides), and other tools that are used to determine the extent of an injured worker's permanent disability (PD).
- Allows for the "apportionment" of PD determinations to prior industrial causes, to prior non-industrial causes, or to subsequent causes, and reduces the amount of the injured worker's PD award to the extent these causes have contributed to the extent of the disability.
- Requires the physician who is making a recommendation on the extent of disability that has followed from an industrial injury to identify, and quantify, causation of the disability that is either prior to or subsequent to the industrial injury.
FISCAL EFFECT: Undetermined.
COMMENTS:
- Purpose. The purpose of the bill is to eliminate elements of what the author believes is gender bias in the workers' compensation system. According to the author, women can receive disproportionately low compensation amounts for work-related permanent disability because of the gender-specific conditions of pregnancy and childbirth. The author points to specific examples where the evaluating physician has pointed to pre-existing conditions that have involved pregnancy or childbirth in apportioning the causation of subsequent industrial injuries, and argues that this constitutes an inappropriate discrimination, since male injured workers can never have their disability apportioned in this manner.
- Case Law. In an unpublished appellate decision, Vaira v. WCAB, the Court of Appeal returned a case to the Workers' Compensation Appeals Board (WCAB) because the record was insufficient to determine whether the physician had based his apportionment decision on medical facts that showed the older female claimant suffered from osteoporosis, or on the basis that the risk factor (older women face a high risk of suffering from osteoporosis) alone was sufficient to assign a percentage of the causation to osteoporosis. This decision has been broadly applied in the workers' compensation courts as establishing the following rule: a risk characteristic such as older women having a high incidence of osteoporosis, or older African American men having a high incidence of hypertension, cannot be used as a basis to apportion a permanent disability award. However, a woman diagnosed with osteoporosis that contributes to her disability resulting from the subsequent industrial injury, or an African American man diagnosed with hypertension that contributes to his disability resulting from the subsequent industrial injury, can have the disability award apportioned based on the prior nonindustrial causation. This is the rule Governor Brown alluded to in his Veto Message on AB 1155 (Alejo) of 2011, (see below).
- Scope of problem. There is substantial disagreement as between supporters of this bill and opponents of this bill on whether or not there is a serious problem of gender-based unfairness in the workers' compensation system. Some supporters have asserted that "we see it every day" while some opponents assert that the wrongs complained of simply do not occur in the workers' compensation courts.
This issue has been presented to, and debated in, the Legislature in one form or another for at least eight years, and there is a paucity of concrete evidence, either academic or anecdotal, to show that there is pervasive discrimination based on gender, or other protected classes. Proponents cite several examples of cases where women are alleged to have suffered unfair treatment by the system. In these examples it is claimed that the evaluating physician has pointed to the offending apportionment factor. Despite requests for any information indicating that workers' compensation judges have accepted these apportionment factors, proponents have been unable to do so.
- Apportionment. Apportionment applies to PD determinations when the disabling effect of an industrial injury has some percentage of causation that either predates or occurs subsequent to the industrial injury. Apportionment does not apply to medical treatment. For example, no matter how much the old football injury is making an industrial knee injury more complicated or extensive, the workers' compensation system provides medical treatment for the industrial knee injury fully and comprehensively. The fact that there is pre-industrial injury causation that affects the seriousness of the injury does not limit the extent of medical treatment. But causation of the disability is treated differently from causation of the injury.
There are at least three policy rationales underpinning the apportionment rule. First, it has been deemed unfair to require an employer to pay for disability that was not caused by the employment. Second, if the prior causation was a previous industrial injury that resulted in a PD award, the injured worker would have already been compensated for that portion of the disabling condition. Third, if an employer knew that a job candidate suffered a previous injury that might lead to more expense if he should re-injure himself, the employer might opt to hire someone else who does not pose that financial risk.
Apportionment as a policy is not without its critics. On a "but for" causation rationale, the injured worker would not be suffering the current disability to any extent but for the current industrial injury. And if the injury were being compensated in the tort system, the person who acted negligently to cause an injury would be responsible for the full extent of the disability, because in tort the "victim's" preconditions do not operate to diminish the consequences of the acts that cause injury. However, apportionment is the rule in workers' compensation, and this bill proposes exceptions to the normal rules of apportionment. - Does case law result in gender discrimination? Proponents strongly argue that it is inappropriate gender discrimination to use even factual conditions that contribute to disability causation if those factors are uniquely attributable to being a woman. In the proponents view, even the Vaira decision endorses gender discrimination, because Vaira merely rejected use of risk factors, but allowed use of factual pre-existing conditions, including some of the factors that the bill would prohibit. Thus, the policy argument is that the uniquely female gender factors addressed by the bill should simply not be used to reduce permanent disability awards. Opponents counter that the workers' compensation system is designed to require employers to pay to injured workers what the job itself caused, not what non-job factors caused.
- Pregnancy and child birth. It is difficult to argue that permanent disabilities ought to be apportioned due to pregnancy or child birth. Indeed, many employers and insurers argue that this is not done, nor is it allowed in the workers' compensation system. However, they point out that adding these characteristics to the statute poses problems. First, they argue that it confuses the idea of causation to injury with causation to disability. They suggest that pregnancy can contribute to injury, but it is hard to understand how it is a condition that causes permanent disability. However, by adding pregnancy and child birth to the apportionment statute, uncertainties are created that will cause extended litigation to determine the precise meaning of the statutory change.
- “or other medical conditions”. Unlike previous bills on this subject (see below), AB 570 expressly adds language that brings in other medical conditions that are related to the gender-based condition. Thus, the bill appears to expressly prohibit apportionment not merely to pregnancy or childbirth, but to any other medical condition that pre-dates the industrial injury if that prior condition can be shown to have been related to a pregnancy or child birth. For example, if a pregnancy causes back problems, and those back problems persist as a chronic problem, the bill appears to preclude using that pre-existing condition as a basis to apportion a subsequent industrial back injury. Opponents are concerned about the scope of this provision, and the amount of litigation it would create. They also note the underlying principle that employers should pay for what the job caused, but not pre-existing conditions.
- Prior legislation. In 2008, SB 1115 (Migden), and in 2011, AB 1155, addressed the apportionment discrimination issue in virtually the same language. Unlike this bill, those bills would have broadly prohibited the use of the protected classes defined in the Unruh Civil Rights Act as a basis to apportion permanent disability awards. Each was vetoed by the Governor. The Veto Message to AB 1155 provided:
This bill would state that workers' compensation injury determinations shall not include consideration of race, religious creed, color, national origin, age, gender, marital status, sex, sexual orientation, or genetic characteristics.
The courts already recognize that apportioning a disability award to any of these classifications is antithetical to our states' non-discrimination policies. The courts also recognize that apportioning to an actual non-industrial condition that contributes to causing a disability is permissible and required by the principle that apportionment is based on causation.
This bill would not change existing law as interpreted by the courts to date. This bill would, however, generate new litigation over questions of whether it is intended to change existing interpretations. At best, that additional litigation would add to employers' costs for workers' compensation. At worst, this bill could disturb the appropriate interpretation of existing law that is already taking shape in the courts.
AB 1643 (Gonzalez) of 2016, and AB 305 (Gonzalez) of 2015, take a different approach to the issue. Rather than addressing the use of protected characteristics, these bills proposed to prohibit precisely what the AB 1155 Veto Message notes that courts currently recognize: that apportionment to actual, factual prior industrial or non-industrial causation is acceptable. AB 305 was substantially similar to AB 1643. The Governor vetoed both AB 305 and AB 1643. The Veto Message to AB 1643 provided, in part:
"I am returning Assembly Bill 1643 without my signature.
On the issue of apportionment, this bill creates broad, gender-based exceptions to the rule that employers are liable only for the percentage of permanent disability directly caused by a work-related injury. As written, the bill would prohibit apportionment to, and thus require employers to pay for, a permanent disability that actually resulted from pregnancy or menopause, or from osteoporosis or carpal tunnel syndrome where these are preexisting conditions or unrelated to work.
As I said last year, there is no place for gender discrimination in the workers' compensation system. Current law, however, already prohibits apportionment to risk factors, including gender, age, and family history. There is ample opportunity within the workers' compensation adjudicatory process for workers, their counsel, and others to raise any concerns or allegations of improper and impermissible gender discrimination in the medical evaluation or apportionment process.
California's workers' compensation system strives to treat all injured workers fairly and to ensure that all workers, regardless of gender, are adequately compensated for any permanent disability directly caused by work-related injuries. Rather than promoting equality, the statutory changes proposed by this measure would create new gender-based classifications and spur additional and costly litigation, undermining the successful reforms enacted in 2012 and the sustainability of the system."
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
CA Conference Board of the Amalgamated Transit Union
CA Conference of Machinists
California Applicants' Attorneys Association (CAAA) (sponsor)
California Federation of Teachers, AFT, AFL-CIO
Engineers & Scientists of CA, IFPTE Local 20, AFL-CIO
International Longshore and Warehouse Union
Los Angeles County Professional Peace Officers Association
Professional & Technical Engineers, IFPTE Local 21, AFL-CIO
The Teamsters
UNITE-HERE, AFL-CIO
Utility Workers Union of America
Opposition
Acclamation Insurance Management Services (AIMS)
American Insurance Association
Association of California Healthcare Districts
Association of California Insurance Companies
California Association of Joint Powers Authorities
California Chamber of Commerce
California Coalition on Workers' Compensation
California Grocers Association
California Manufacturers & Technology Association
California Special Districts Association
California State Association of Counties
CSAC Excess Insurance Authority
National Federation of Independent Business
Analysis Prepared by: Mark Rakich / INS. /
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):