SB 1129: Spousal support award: convictions.
- Session Year: 2017-2018
- House: Senate
- Latest Version Date: 2018-09-27
Existing law requires that in any proceeding for dissolution of marriage where one spouse has been convicted of an act of domestic violence against the other spouse within a specific time period, there is a rebuttable presumption affecting the burden of proof that any award of temporary or permanent spousal support to the abusive spouse should not be made. In a similar spousal support proceeding where one spouse has been convicted of a violent sexual felony perpetrated against the other spouse within a specific time period, existing law prohibits an award of spousal support to the convicted spouse from the injured spouse, requires the court to order attorneys fees to be paid from community assets, authorizes the date of legal separation to be the date of the incident giving rise to the conviction or earlier, and entitles the injured spouse to 100% of the community interest in the injured spouses retirement and pension.
This bill would modify the rebuttable presumption against making an award of temporary or permanent spousal support that is applicable to all criminal convictions for an act of domestic violence by distinguishing between a criminal conviction for a domestic violence felony and a domestic violence misdemeanor, and would define these 2 types of convictions. Under the bill, a criminal conviction for a domestic violence felony would prohibit awards relating to spousal support, attorneys fees, setting the date of separation, and retirement and pension benefits in a manner similar to a criminal conviction for a violent sexual felony. The bill would authorize the court to determine, based on the facts of the particular case, that one or more of these limitations on awards do not apply, if the convicted spouse presents documented evidence that he or she has been the victim of a violent sexual offense or domestic violence by the other spouse.
Under the bill, a criminal conviction for a domestic violence misdemeanor or a misdemeanor that results in a term of probation that is based on domestic violence, as specified, would require a rebuttable presumption against making the same awards that are prohibited in cases of a criminal conviction for a violent sexual felony or domestic violence felony, except that there would not be a rebuttable presumption that the injured spouse is entitled to 100% of the community property interest in his or her retirement or pension benefits. The bill would authorize the court to determine, based on the facts of a particular case, that the injured spouse is entitled to up to 100% of the community property interest in his or her retirement and pension benefits based on specified factors, including the duration of the marriage and when, based on documented evidence, incidents of domestic violence occurred.
This bill would establish different time periods for the effectiveness of the prohibition in cases of a criminal conviction for a violent sexual felony or domestic violence felony and the effectiveness of the rebuttable presumption in cases of a domestic violence misdemeanor or probationary term, as specified. The bill would make the above changes applicable to convictions that occurred on or after January 1, 2019. The bill would also define terms for its purposes, and would make technical changes to these provisions.
Existing law requires that in any proceeding for dissolution of marriage where one spouse has been convicted of an act of domestic violence against the other spouse within a specific time period, there is a rebuttable presumption affecting the burden of proof that any award of temporary or permanent spousal support to the abusive spouse should not be made. In a similar spousal support proceeding where one spouse has been convicted of a violent sexual felony perpetrated against the other spouse within a specific time period, existing law prohibits an award of spousal support to the convicted spouse from the injured spouse, requires the court to order attorneys fees to be paid from community assets, authorizes the date of legal separation to be the date of the incident giving rise to the conviction or earlier, and entitles the injured spouse to 100% of the community interest in the injured spouses retirement and pension.
This bill would modify the rebuttable presumption against making an award of temporary or permanent spousal support that is applicable to all criminal convictions for an act of domestic violence by distinguishing between a criminal conviction for a domestic violence felony and a domestic violence misdemeanor, and would define these 2 types of convictions. Under the bill, a criminal conviction for a domestic violence felony would prohibit awards relating to spousal support, attorneys fees, setting the date of separation, and retirement and pension benefits in a manner similar to a criminal conviction for a violent sexual felony. The bill would authorize the court to determine, based on the facts of the particular case, that one or more of these limitations on awards do not apply, if the convicted spouse presents documented evidence that he or she has been the victim of a violent sexual offense or domestic violence by the other spouse.
Under the bill, a criminal conviction for a domestic violence misdemeanor or a misdemeanor that results in a term of probation that is based on domestic violence, as specified, would require a rebuttable presumption against making the same awards that are prohibited in cases of a criminal conviction for a violent sexual felony or domestic violence felony, except that there would not be a rebuttable presumption that the injured spouse is entitled to 100% of the community property interest in his or her retirement or pension benefits. The bill would authorize the court to determine, based on the facts of a particular case, that the injured spouse is entitled to up to 100% of the community property interest in his or her retirement and pension benefits based on specified factors, including the duration of the marriage and when, based on documented evidence, incidents of domestic violence occurred.
This bill would establish different time periods for the effectiveness of the prohibition in cases of a criminal conviction for a violent sexual felony or domestic violence felony and the effectiveness of the rebuttable presumption in cases of a domestic violence misdemeanor or probationary term, as specified. The bill would make the above changes applicable to convictions that occurred on or after January 1, 2019. The bill would also define terms for its purposes, and would make technical changes to these provisions.
Existing law requires that in any proceeding for dissolution of marriage where one spouse has been convicted of an act of domestic violence against the other spouse within a specific time period, there is a rebuttable presumption affecting the burden of proof that any award of temporary or permanent spousal support to the abusive spouse should not be made. In a similar spousal support proceeding where one spouse has been convicted of a violent sexual felony perpetrated against the other spouse within a specific time period, existing law prohibits an award of spousal support to the convicted spouse from the injured spouse, requires the court to order attorneys fees to be paid from community assets, authorizes the date of legal separation to be the date of the incident giving rise to the conviction or earlier, and entitles the injured spouse to 100% of the community interest in the injured spouses retirement and pension.
This bill would modify the rebuttable presumption against making an award of temporary or permanent spousal support that is applicable to all criminal convictions for an act of domestic violence by distinguishing between a criminal conviction for a domestic violence felony and a domestic violence misdemeanor, and would define these 2 types of convictions. Under the bill, a criminal conviction for a domestic violence felony would prohibit awards relating to spousal support, attorneys fees, setting the date of separation, and retirement and pension benefits in a manner similar to a criminal conviction for a violent sexual felony. Under The bill would authorize the court to determine, based on the facts of the particular case, that one or more of these limitations on awards do not apply, if the convicted spouse presents documented evidence that he or she has been the victim of a violent sexual offense or domestic violence by the other spouse.
Under the bill, a criminal conviction for a domestic violence misdemeanor or a misdemeanor that results in a term of probation that is based on domestic violence, as specified, would require a rebuttable presumption against making the same awards that are prohibited in cases of a criminal conviction for a violent sexual felony or domestic violence felony, except that there would not be a rebuttable presumption that the injured spouse is entitled to 100% of the community property interest in his or her retirement or pension benefits. The bill would authorize the court to determine, based on the facts of a particular case, that the injured spouse is entitled to up to 100% of the community property interest in his or her retirement and pension benefits based on specified factors, including the duration of the marriage and when, based on documented evidence, incidents of domestic violence occurred.
This bill would establish different time periods for the effectiveness of the prohibition in cases of a criminal conviction for a violent sexual felony or domestic violence felony and the effectiveness of the rebuttable presumption in cases of a domestic violence misdemeanor or probationary term, as specified. The bill would make the above changes applicable to convictions that occurred on or after January 1, 2019. The bill would also define terms for its purposes, and would make technical changes to these provisions.
Existing law requires that in any proceeding for dissolution of marriage where one spouse has been convicted of an act of domestic violence against the other spouse within a specific time period, there is a rebuttable presumption affecting the burden of proof that any award of temporary or permanent spousal support to the abusive spouse should not be made. In a similar spousal support proceeding where one spouse has been convicted of a violent sexual felony perpetrated against the other spouse within a specific time period, existing law prohibits an award of spousal support to the convicted spouse from the injured spouse, requires the court to order attorneys fees to be paid from community assets, authorizes the date of legal separation to be the date of the incident giving rise to the conviction or earlier, and entitles the injured spouse to 100 percent 100% of the community interest in the injured spouses retirement and pension.
This bill would modify the rebuttable presumption against making an award of temporary or permanent spousal support that is applicable to all criminal convictions for an act of domestic violence by distinguishing between a criminal conviction for a domestic violence felony and a domestic violence misdemeanor, and would define these two 2 types of convictions. Under the bill, a criminal conviction for a domestic violence felony would prohibit awards relating to spousal support, attorneys fees, setting the date of separation, and retirement and pension benefits in a manner similar to a criminal conviction for a violent sexual felony. Under the bill, a criminal conviction for a domestic violence misdemeanor or a misdemeanor that results in a term of probation that is based on domestic violence, as specified, would require a rebuttable presumption against making the same awards that are prohibited in cases of a criminal conviction for a violent sexual felony or domestic violence felony. felony, except that there would not be a rebuttable presumption that the injured spouse is entitled to 100% of the community property interest in his or her retirement or pension benefits. The bill would authorize the court to determine, based on the facts of a particular case, that the injured spouse is entitled to up to 100% of the community property interest in his or her retirement and pension benefits based on specified factors, including the duration of the marriage and when, based on documented evidence, incidents of domestic violence occurred.
This bill would establish different time periods for the effectiveness of the prohibition in cases of a criminal conviction for a violent sexual felony or domestic violence felony and the effectiveness of the rebuttable presumption in cases of a domestic violence misdemeanor or probationary term, as specified. The bill would make the above changes applicable to convictions that occurred on or after January 1, 2019. The bill would also define terms for its purposes, and would make technical changes to these provisions.
Existing law requires that in any proceeding for dissolution of marriage where one spouse has been convicted of an act of domestic violence against the other spouse within a specific time period, there is a rebuttable presumption affecting the burden of proof that any award of temporary or permanent spousal support to the abusive spouse should not be made. In a similar spousal support proceeding where one spouse has been convicted for of a violent sexual felony perpetrated against the other spouse within a specific time period, existing law prohibits an award of spousal support to the convicted spouse from the injured spouse, requires the court to order attorneys fees to be paid from community assets, authorizes the legal date of legal separation to be the date of the incident giving rise to the conviction or earlier, and entitles the injured spouse to 100 percent of the community interest in the injured spouses retirement and pension.
This bill would delete the provisions relating to the rebuttable presumption in a proceeding for dissolution of marriage where one spouse has been convicted of an act of domestic violence against the other spouse, and instead award spousal support under these circumstances in a manner similar to when one spouse has been convicted of a violent sexual felony against the other spouse.This bill would modify the rebuttable presumption against making an award of temporary or permanent spousal support that is applicable to all criminal convictions for an act of domestic violence by distinguishing between a criminal conviction for a domestic violence felony and a domestic violence misdemeanor, and would define these two types of convictions. Under the bill, a criminal conviction for a domestic violence felony would prohibit awards relating to spousal support, attorneys fees, setting the date of separation, and retirement and pension benefits in a manner similar to a criminal conviction for a violent sexual felony. Under the bill, a criminal conviction for a domestic violence misdemeanor or a misdemeanor that results in a term of probation that is based on domestic violence, as specified, would require a rebuttable presumption against making the same awards that are prohibited in cases of a criminal conviction for a violent sexual felony or domestic violence felony.
This bill would establish different time periods for the effectiveness of the prohibition in cases of a criminal conviction for a violent sexual felony or domestic violence felony and the effectiveness of the rebuttable presumption in cases of a domestic violence misdemeanor or probationary term, as specified. The bill would define terms for its purposes, and would make technical changes to these provisions.
Existing law requires that in any proceeding for dissolution of marriage where one spouse has been convicted of an act of domestic violence against the other spouse within a specific time period, there is a rebuttable presumption affecting the burden of proof that any award of temporary or permanent spousal support to the abusive spouse should not be made. In a similar spousal support proceeding where one spouse has been convicted for a violent sexual felony perpetrated against the other spouse within a specific time period, existing law prohibits an award of spousal support to the convicted spouse from the injured spouse, requires the court to order attorneys fees to be paid from community assets, authorizes the legal date of separation to be the date of the incident giving rise to the conviction or earlier, and entitles the injured spouse to 100 percent of the community interest in the injured spouses retirement and pension.
This bill would delete the provisions relating to the rebuttable presumption in a proceeding for dissolution of marriage where one spouse has been convicted of an act of domestic violence against the other spouse, and instead award spousal support under these circumstances in a manner similar to when one spouse has been convicted of a violent sexual felony against the other spouse.
(a)In any proceeding for dissolution of marriage where there is a criminal conviction for a violent sexual felony or a domestic violence felony perpetrated by one spouse against the other spouse and the petition for dissolution is filed before five years following the conviction and any time served in custody, on probation, or on parole, the following shall apply:
(1)An award of spousal support to the convicted spouse from the injured spouse is prohibited.
(2)If economic circumstances warrant, the court shall order the attorneys fees and costs incurred by the parties to be paid from the community assets. The injured spouse shall not be required to pay any attorneys fees of the convicted spouse out of the injured spouses separate property.
(3)At the request of the injured spouse, the date of separation, as defined in Section 70, shall be the date of the incident giving rise to the conviction, or earlier, if the court finds circumstances that justify an earlier date.
(4)The injured spouse shall be entitled to 100 percent of the community property interest in the retirement and pension benefits of the injured spouse.
(b)As used in this section, the following definitions apply:
(1)Domestic violence felony means a felony offense for an act of abuse, as described in Section 6203, perpetrated by one spouse against the other spouse.
(2)Injured spouse means the spouse who has been the subject of the violent sexual felony or domestic violence felony for which the other spouse was convicted.
(3)Violent sexual felony means those offenses described in paragraphs (3), (4), (5), (11), and (18) of subdivision (c) of Section 667.5 of the Penal Code.
(c)If a convicted spouse presents documented evidence of the convicted spouses history as a victim of a violent sexual offense, as described in paragraphs (3), (4), (5), (11), and (18) of subdivision (c) of Section 667.5 of the Penal Code, or domestic violence, as defined in Section 6211, perpetrated by the other spouse, the court may determine, based on the facts of the particular case, that one or more of paragraphs (1) to (4), inclusive, of subdivision (a) do not apply.
(d)The changes made to this section by the bill that added this subdivision shall only apply to convictions that occur on or after January 1, 2019.
SEC. 2.Section 4325 of the Family Code is amended to read:4325.(a)In any proceeding for dissolution of marriage where there is a criminal conviction for a domestic violence misdemeanor or a criminal conviction for a misdemeanor that results in a term of probation pursuant to Section 1203.097 of the Penal Code perpetrated by one spouse against the other spouse entered by the court within five years prior to the filing of the dissolution proceeding or during the course of the dissolution proceeding, there shall be a rebuttable presumption that the following shall apply:
(1)An award of spousal support to the convicted spouse from the injured spouse is prohibited.
(2)If economic circumstances warrant, the court shall order the attorneys fees and costs incurred by the parties to be paid from the community assets. The injured spouse shall not be required to pay any attorneys fees of the convicted spouse out of the injured spouses separate property.
(3)At the request of the injured spouse, the date of separation, as defined in Section 70, shall be the date of the incident giving rise to the conviction, or earlier, if the court finds circumstances that justify an earlier date.
(b)The court may consider documented evidence of a convicted spouses history as a victim of domestic violence, as defined in Section 6211, perpetrated by the other spouse, or any other factors the court deems just and equitable, as conditions for rebutting this presumption.
(c)The rebuttable presumption created in this section may be rebutted by a preponderance of the evidence.
(d)The court may determine, based on the facts of a particular case, that the injured spouse is entitled to up to 100 percent of the community property interest in his or her retirement and pension benefits. In determining whether and how to apportion the community property interest in the retirement and pension benefits of the injured spouse, the court shall consider all of the following factors:
(1)The misdemeanor domestic violence conviction, as well as documented evidence of other instances of domestic violence, as defined in Section 6211, between the parties or perpetrated by either party against either partys child, including, but not limited to, consideration of emotional distress resulting from domestic violence. The court shall also consider documented evidence of a convicted spouses history as a victim of domestic violence, as defined in Section 6211, perpetrated by the other spouse.
(2)The duration of the marriage and when, based on documented evidence, incidents of domestic violence, as defined in Section 6211, occurred.
(3)The extent to which the convicted spouses present or future earning capacity is impaired by periods of unemployment that were incurred during the marriage to permit the convicted spouse to devote time to domestic duties.
(4)The extent to which the convicted spouse contributed to the attainment of an education, training, a career position, or a license by the injured spouse.
(5)The balance of the hardships to each party.
(6)Any other factors the court determines are just and equitable.
(e)As used in this section, the following definitions apply:
(1)Domestic violence misdemeanor means a misdemeanor offense for an act of abuse, as described in paragraphs (1) to (3), inclusive, of subdivision (a) of Section 6203, perpetrated by one spouse against the other spouse.
(2)Injured spouse means the spouse who has been the subject of the domestic violence misdemeanor for which the other spouse was convicted.
(f)The changes made to this section by the bill that added this subdivision shall only apply to convictions that occur on or after January 1, 2019.
(a)In any proceeding for dissolution of marriage where there is a criminal conviction for a violent sexual felony or a domestic violence felony perpetrated by one spouse against the other spouse and the petition for dissolution is filed before five years following the conviction and any time served in custody, on probation, or on parole, the following shall apply:
(1)An award of spousal support to the convicted spouse from the injured spouse is prohibited.
(2)If economic circumstances warrant, the court shall order the attorneys fees and costs incurred by the parties to be paid from the community assets. The injured spouse shall not be required to pay any attorneys fees of the convicted spouse out of the injured spouses separate property.
(3)At the request of the injured spouse, the date of separation, as defined in Section 70, shall be the date of the incident giving rise to the conviction, or earlier, if the court finds circumstances that justify an earlier date.
(4)The injured spouse shall be entitled to 100 percent of the community property interest in the retirement and pension benefits of the injured spouse.
(b)As used in this section, the following definitions apply:
(1)Domestic violence felony means a felony offense for an act of abuse, as described in Section 6203, perpetrated by one spouse against the other spouse.
(2)Injured spouse means the spouse who has been the subject of the violent sexual felony or domestic violence felony for which the other spouse was convicted.
(3)Violent sexual felony means those offenses described in paragraphs (3), (4), (5), (11), and (18) of subdivision (c) of Section 667.5 of the Penal Code.
(c)If a convicted spouse presents documented evidence of the convicted spouses history as a victim of a violent sexual offense, as described in paragraphs (3), (4), (5), (11), and (18) of subdivision (c) of Section 667.5 of the Penal Code, or domestic violence, as defined in Section 6211, perpetrated by the other spouse, the court may determine, based on the facts of the particular case, that one or more of paragraphs (1) to (4), inclusive, of subdivision (a) do not apply.
(d)The changes made to this section by the bill that added this subdivision shall only apply to convictions that occur on or after January 1, 2019.
SEC. 2.Section 4325 of the Family Code is amended to read:4325.(a)In any proceeding for dissolution of marriage where there is a criminal conviction for a domestic violence misdemeanor or a criminal conviction for a misdemeanor that results in a term of probation pursuant to Section 1203.097 of the Penal Code perpetrated by one spouse against the other spouse entered by the court within five years prior to the filing of the dissolution proceeding or during the course of the dissolution proceeding, there shall be a rebuttable presumption that the following shall apply:
(1)An award of spousal support to the convicted spouse from the injured spouse is prohibited.
(2)If economic circumstances warrant, the court shall order the attorneys fees and costs incurred by the parties to be paid from the community assets. The injured spouse shall not be required to pay any attorneys fees of the convicted spouse out of the injured spouses separate property.
(3)At the request of the injured spouse, the date of separation, as defined in Section 70, shall be the date of the incident giving rise to the conviction, or earlier, if the court finds circumstances that justify an earlier date.
(b)The court may consider documented evidence of a convicted spouses history as a victim of domestic violence, as defined in Section 6211, perpetrated by the other spouse, or any other factors the court deems just and equitable, as conditions for rebutting this presumption.
(c)The rebuttable presumption created in this section may be rebutted by a preponderance of the evidence.
(d)The court may determine, based on the facts of a particular case, that the injured spouse is entitled to up to 100 percent of the community property interest in his or her retirement and pension benefits. In determining whether and how to apportion the community property interest in the retirement and pension benefits of the injured spouse, the court shall consider all of the following factors:
(1)The misdemeanor domestic violence conviction, as well as documented evidence of other instances of domestic violence, as defined in Section 6211, between the parties or perpetrated by either party against either partys child, including, but not limited to, consideration of emotional distress resulting from domestic violence. The court shall also consider documented evidence of a convicted spouses history as a victim of domestic violence, as defined in Section 6211, perpetrated by the other spouse.
(2)The duration of the marriage and when, based on documented evidence, incidents of domestic violence, as defined in Section 6211, occurred.
(3)The extent to which the convicted spouses present or future earning capacity is impaired by periods of unemployment that were incurred during the marriage to permit the convicted spouse to devote time to domestic duties.
(4)The extent to which the convicted spouse contributed to the attainment of an education, training, a career position, or a license by the injured spouse.
(5)The balance of the hardships to each party.
(6)Any other factors the court determines are just and equitable.
(e)As used in this section, the following definitions apply:
(1)Domestic violence misdemeanor means a misdemeanor offense for an act of abuse, as described in paragraphs (1) to (3), inclusive, of subdivision (a) of Section 6203, perpetrated by one spouse against the other spouse.
(2)Injured spouse means the spouse who has been the subject of the domestic violence misdemeanor for which the other spouse was convicted.
(f)The changes made to this section by the bill that added this subdivision shall only apply to convictions that occur on or after January 1, 2019.
(a)In any proceeding for dissolution of marriage where there is a criminal conviction for a violent sexual felony or a domestic violence felony perpetrated by one spouse against the other spouse and the petition for dissolution is filed before five years following the conviction and any time served in custody, on probation, or on parole, the following shall apply:
(1)An award of spousal support to the convicted spouse from the injured spouse is prohibited.
(2)If economic circumstances warrant, the court shall order the attorneys fees and costs incurred by the parties to be paid from the community assets. The injured spouse shall not be required to pay any attorneys fees of the convicted spouse out of the injured spouses separate property.
(3)At the request of the injured spouse, the date of separation, as defined in Section 70, shall be the date of the incident giving rise to the conviction, or earlier, if the court finds circumstances that justify an earlier date.
(4)The injured spouse shall be entitled to 100 percent of the community property interest in the retirement and pension benefits of the injured spouse.
(b)As used in this section, the following definitions apply:
(1)Domestic violence felony means a felony offense for an act of abuse, as described in Section 6203, perpetrated by one spouse against the other spouse.
(2)Injured spouse means the spouse who has been the subject of the violent sexual felony or domestic violence felony for which the other spouse was convicted.
(3)Violent sexual felony means those offenses described in paragraphs (3), (4), (5), (11), and (18) of subdivision (c) of Section 667.5 of the Penal Code.
(c)If a convicted spouse presents documented evidence of the convicted spouses history as a victim of a violent sexual offense, as described in paragraphs (3), (4), (5), (11), and (18) of subdivision (c) of Section 667.5 of the Penal Code, or domestic violence, as defined in Section 6211, perpetrated by the other spouse, the court may determine, based on the facts of the particular case, that one or more of paragraphs (1) to (4), inclusive, of subdivision (a) do not apply.
(c)(d)The changes made to this section by the bill that added this subdivision shall only apply to convictions that occur on or after January 1, 2019.
SEC. 2.Section 4325 of the Family Code is amended to read:4325.(a)In any proceeding for dissolution of marriage where there is a criminal conviction for a domestic violence misdemeanor or a criminal conviction for a misdemeanor that results in a term of probation pursuant to Section 1203.097 of the Penal Code perpetrated by one spouse against the other spouse entered by the court within five years prior to the filing of the dissolution proceeding or during the course of the dissolution proceeding, there shall be a rebuttable presumption that the following shall apply:
(1)An award of spousal support to the convicted spouse from the injured spouse is prohibited.
(2)If economic circumstances warrant, the court shall order the attorneys fees and costs incurred by the parties to be paid from the community assets. The injured spouse shall not be required to pay any attorneys fees of the convicted spouse out of the injured spouses separate property.
(3)At the request of the injured spouse, the date of separation, as defined in Section 70, shall be the date of the incident giving rise to the conviction, or earlier, if the court finds circumstances that justify an earlier date.
(b)The court may consider documented evidence of a convicted spouses history as a victim of domestic violence, as defined in Section 6211, perpetrated by the other spouse, or any other factors the court deems just and equitable, as conditions for rebutting this presumption.
(c)The rebuttable presumption created in this section may be rebutted by a preponderance of the evidence.
(d)The court may determine, based on the facts of a particular case, that the injured spouse is entitled to up to 100 percent of the community property interest in his or her retirement and pension benefits. In determining whether and how to apportion the community property interest in the retirement and pension benefits of the injured spouse, the court shall consider all of the following factors:
(1)The misdemeanor domestic violence conviction, as well as documented evidence of other instances of domestic violence, as defined in Section 6211, between the parties or perpetrated by either party against either partys child, including, but not limited to, consideration of emotional distress resulting from domestic violence. The court shall also consider documented evidence of a convicted spouses history as a victim of domestic violence, as defined in Section 6211, perpetrated by the other spouse.
(2)The duration of the marriage and when, based on documented evidence, incidents of domestic violence, as defined in Section 6211, occurred.
(3)The extent to which the convicted spouses present or future earning capacity is impaired by periods of unemployment that were incurred during the marriage to permit the convicted spouse to devote time to domestic duties.
(4)The extent to which the convicted spouse contributed to the attainment of an education, training, a career position, or a license by the injured spouse.
(5)The balance of the hardships to each party.
(6)Any other factors the court determines are just and equitable.
(e)As used in this section, the following definitions apply:
(1)Domestic violence misdemeanor means a misdemeanor offense for an act of abuse, as described in paragraphs (1) to (3), inclusive, of subdivision (a) of Section 6203, perpetrated by one spouse against the other spouse.
(2)Injured spouse means the spouse who has been the subject of the domestic violence misdemeanor for which the other spouse was convicted.
(f)The changes made to this section by the bill that added this subdivision shall only apply to convictions that occur on or after January 1, 2019.
(a)In any proceeding for dissolution of marriage where there is a criminal conviction for a violent sexual felony or a domestic violence felony perpetrated by one spouse against the other spouse and the petition for dissolution is filed before five years following the conviction and any time served in custody, on probation, or on parole, the following shall apply:
(1)An award of spousal support to the convicted spouse from the injured spouse is prohibited.
(2)If economic circumstances warrant, the court shall order the attorneys fees and costs incurred by the parties to be paid from the community assets. The injured spouse shall not be required to pay any attorneys fees of the convicted spouse out of the injured spouses separate property.
(3)At the request of the injured spouse, the date of separation, as defined in Section 70, shall be the date of the incident giving rise to the conviction, or earlier, if the court finds circumstances that justify an earlier date.
(4)The injured spouse shall be entitled to 100 percent of the community property interest in the retirement and pension benefits of the injured spouse.
(b)As used in this section, the following definitions apply:
(1)Domestic violence felony means a felony offense for an act of abuse, as described in Section 6203, perpetrated by one spouse against the other spouse.
(2)Injured spouse means the spouse who has been the subject of the violent sexual felony or domestic violence felony for which the other spouse was convicted.
(3)Violent sexual felony means those offenses described in paragraphs (3), (4), (5), (11), and (18) of subdivision (c) of Section 667.5 of the Penal Code.
(c)The changes made to this section by the bill that added this subdivision shall only apply to convictions that occur on or after January 1, 2019.
SEC. 2.Section 4325 of the Family Code is amended to read:4325.(a)In any proceeding for dissolution of marriage where there is a criminal conviction for a domestic violence misdemeanor or a criminal conviction for a misdemeanor that results in a term of probation pursuant to Section 1203.097 of the Penal Code perpetrated by one spouse against the other spouse entered by the court within five years prior to the filing of the dissolution proceeding or during the course of the dissolution proceeding, there shall be a rebuttable presumption that the following shall apply:
(1)An award of spousal support to the convicted spouse from the injured spouse is prohibited.
(2)If economic circumstances warrant, the court shall order the attorneys fees and costs incurred by the parties to be paid from the community assets. The injured spouse shall not be required to pay any attorneys fees of the convicted spouse out of the injured spouses separate property.
(3)At the request of the injured spouse, the date of separation, as defined in Section 70, shall be the date of the incident giving rise to the conviction, or earlier, if the court finds circumstances that justify an earlier date.
(4)The injured spouse shall be entitled to 100 percent of the community property interest in the retirement and pension benefits of the injured spouse.(b)The court may consider documented evidence of a convicted spouses history as a victim of domestic violence, as defined in Section 6211, perpetrated by the other spouse, or any other factors the court deems just and equitable, as conditions for rebutting this presumption.
(c)The rebuttable presumption created in this section may be rebutted by a preponderance of the evidence.
(d)The court may determine, based on the facts of a particular case, that the injured spouse is entitled to up to 100 percent of the community property interest in his or her retirement and pension benefits. In determining whether and how to apportion the community property interest in the retirement and pension benefits of the injured spouse, the court shall consider all of the following factors:
(1)The misdemeanor domestic violence conviction, as well as documented evidence of other instances of domestic violence, as defined in Section 6211, between the parties or perpetrated by either party against either partys child, including, but not limited to, consideration of emotional distress resulting from domestic violence. The court shall also consider documented evidence of a convicted spouses history as a victim of domestic violence, as defined in Section 6211, perpetrated by the other spouse.
(2)The duration of the marriage and when, based on documented evidence, incidents of domestic violence, as defined in Section 6211, occurred.
(3)The extent to which the convicted spouses present or future earning capacity is impaired by periods of unemployment that were incurred during the marriage to permit the convicted spouse to devote time to domestic duties.
(4)The extent to which the convicted spouse contributed to the attainment of an education, training, a career position, or a license by the injured spouse.
(5)The balance of the hardships to each party.
(6)Any other factors the court determines are just and equitable.
(d)(e)As used in this section, the following definitions apply:
(1)Domestic violence misdemeanor means a misdemeanor offense for an act of abuse, as described in paragraphs (1) to (3), inclusive, of subdivision (a) of Section 6203, perpetrated by one spouse against the other spouse.
(2)Injured spouse means the spouse who has been the subject of the violent sexual felony or domestic violence felony misdemeanor for which the other spouse was convicted.
(f)The changes made to this section by the bill that added this subdivision shall only apply to convictions that occur on or after January 1, 2019.
(a)In any proceeding for dissolution of marriage where there is a criminal conviction for a violent sexual felony or a domestic violence felony perpetrated by one spouse against the other spouse and the petition for dissolution is filed before five years following the conviction and any time served in custody, on probation, or on parole, the following shall apply:
(1)An award of spousal support to the convicted spouse from the injured spouse is prohibited.
(2)Where If economic circumstances warrant, the court shall order the attorneys fees and costs incurred by the parties to be paid from the community assets. The injured spouse shall not be required to pay any attorneys fees of the convicted spouse out of the injured spouses separate property.
(3)At the request of the injured spouse, the date of legal separation separation, as defined in Section 70, shall be the date of the incident giving rise to the conviction, or earlier, if the court finds circumstances that justify an earlier date.
(4)The injured spouse shall be entitled to 100 percent of the community property interest in the retirement and pension benefits of the injured spouse.
(b)As used in this section, violent sexual felony means those offenses described in paragraphs (3), (4), (5), (11), and (18) of subdivision (c) of Section 667.5 of the Penal Code.(c)As used in this section, injured spouse means the spouse who has been the subject of the violent sexual felony for which the other spouse was convicted.(b)As used in this section, the following definitions apply:
(1)Domestic violence felony means a felony offense for an act of abuse, as described in Section 6203, perpetrated by one spouse against the other spouse.
(2)Injured spouse means the spouse who has been the subject of the violent sexual felony or domestic violence felony for which the other spouse was convicted.
(3)Violent sexual felony means those offenses described in paragraphs (3), (4), (5), (11), and (18) of subdivision (c) of Section 667.5 of the Penal Code.
SECTION 1.Section 4325 of the Family Code is amended to read:4325.In any proceeding for dissolution of marriage where there is a criminal conviction for an act of domestic violence perpetrated by one spouse against the other spouse entered by the court within five years prior to the filing of the dissolution proceeding, or at any time thereafter, the following shall apply:(a)An award of spousal support to the convicted spouse from the injured spouse is prohibited.(b)Where economic circumstances warrant, the court shall order the attorneys fees and costs incurred by the parties to be paid from the community assets. The injured spouse shall not be required to pay any attorneys fees of the convicted spouse out of the injured spouses separate property.(c)At the request of the injured spouse, the date of legal separation shall be the date of the incident giving rise to the conviction, or earlier, if the court finds circumstances that justify an earlier date.(d)The injured spouse shall be entitled to 100 percent of the community property interest in the retirement and pension benefits of the injured spouse.SEC. 2.Section 4325 of the Family Code is amended to read:4325.(a)In any proceeding for dissolution of marriage where there is a criminal conviction for an act of a domestic violence misdemeanor or a criminal conviction for a misdemeanor that results in a term of probation pursuant to Section 1203.097 of the Penal Code perpetrated by one spouse against the other spouse entered by the court within five years prior to the filing of the dissolution proceeding, or at any time thereafter, proceeding or during the course of the dissolution proceeding, there shall be a rebuttable presumption affecting the burden of proof that any award of temporary or permanent spousal support to the abusive spouse otherwise awardable pursuant to the standards of this part should not be made. that the following shall apply:
(1)An award of spousal support to the convicted spouse from the injured spouse is prohibited.
(2)If economic circumstances warrant, the court shall order the attorneys fees and costs incurred by the parties to be paid from the community assets. The injured spouse shall not be required to pay any attorneys fees of the convicted spouse out of the injured spouses separate property.
(3)At the request of the injured spouse, the date of separation, as defined in Section 70, shall be the date of the incident giving rise to the conviction, or earlier, if the court finds circumstances that justify an earlier date.
(4)The injured spouse shall be entitled to 100 percent of the community property interest in the retirement and pension benefits of the injured spouse.
(b)The court may consider documented evidence of a convicted spouses history as a victim of domestic violence, as defined in Section 6211, perpetrated by the other spouse, or any other factors the court deems just and equitable, as conditions for rebutting this presumption.
(c)The rebuttable presumption created in this section may be rebutted by a preponderance of the evidence.
(d)As used in this section, the following definitions apply:
(1)Domestic violence misdemeanor means a misdemeanor offense for an act of abuse, as described in Section 6203, perpetrated by one spouse against the other spouse.
(2)Injured spouse means the spouse who has been the subject of the violent sexual felony or domestic violence felony for which the other spouse was convicted.
(a)In any proceeding for dissolution of marriage where there is a criminal conviction for an act of domestic violence perpetrated by one spouse against the other spouse entered by the court within five years prior to the filing of the dissolution proceeding, or at any time thereafter, there shall be a rebuttable presumption affecting the burden of proof that any award of temporary or permanent spousal support to the abusive spouse otherwise awardable pursuant to the standards of this part should not be made. thereafter, the following shall apply:
(b)The court may consider documented evidence of a convicted spouses history as a victim of domestic violence, as defined in Section 6211, perpetrated by the other spouse, or any other factors the court deems just and equitable, as conditions for rebutting this presumption.(c)The rebuttable presumption created in this section may be rebutted by a preponderance of the evidence.(a)An award of spousal support to the convicted spouse from the injured spouse is prohibited.
(b)Where economic circumstances warrant, the court shall order the attorneys fees and costs incurred by the parties to be paid from the community assets. The injured spouse shall not be required to pay any attorneys fees of the convicted spouse out of the injured spouses separate property.
(c)At the request of the injured spouse, the date of legal separation shall be the date of the incident giving rise to the conviction, or earlier, if the court finds circumstances that justify an earlier date.
(d)The injured spouse shall be entitled to 100 percent of the community property interest in the retirement and pension benefits of the injured spouse.
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Sep 27, 2018 | Chaptered by Secretary of State. Chapter 850, Statutes of 2018. |
| Sep 27, 2018 | Approved by the Governor. |
| Sep 6, 2018 | Enrolled and presented to the Governor at 4 p.m. |
| Aug 29, 2018 | Assembly amendments concurred in. (Ayes 31. Noes 7.) Ordered to engrossing and enrolling. |
| Aug 28, 2018 | In Senate. Concurrence in Assembly amendments pending. |
| Aug 28, 2018 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Senate. |
| Aug 24, 2018 | Read third time and amended. |
| Aug 6, 2018 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| Jul 5, 2018 | Read second time and amended. Ordered to second reading. |
| Jul 3, 2018 | From committee: Do pass as amended. (Ayes 9. Noes 0.) (July 3). |
| May 31, 2018 | Referred to Com. on JUD. |
| May 21, 2018 | In Assembly. Read first time. Held at Desk. |
| May 21, 2018 | Read third time. Passed. (Ayes 30. Noes 7.) Ordered to the Assembly. |
| May 15, 2018 | Read second time and amended. Ordered to third reading. |
| May 14, 2018 | From committee: Do pass as amended. (Ayes 5. Noes 1.) (May 8). |
| Apr 18, 2018 | Set for hearing May 8. |
| Feb 22, 2018 | Referred to Com. on JUD. |
| Feb 14, 2018 | From printer. May be acted upon on or after March 16. |
| Feb 13, 2018 | Introduced. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Aug 29, 2018 | Unfinished Business SB1129 Monning Concurrence | Senate Floor |
Passed |
|
| Aug 28, 2018 | SB 1129 Monning Senate Third Reading By CHIU | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| Jul 3, 2018 | Do pass as amended. | Assembly Standing Committee on Judiciary |
Passed |
|
| May 21, 2018 | Senate 3rd Reading SB1129 Monning | Senate Floor |
Passed |
|
| May 8, 2018 | Do pass as amended | Senate Standing Committee on Judiciary |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
|
Organization
|
Position
|
Date
|
|---|---|---|
| Association of Certified Family Law Specialists | ** Against | Aug 28, 2018 |
| California Judges Association | * Indeterminate | May 8, 2018 |
| Congressman Sam Farr | ** Support | Aug 28, 2018 |
| Democratic Party Of Santa Cruz | ** Support | Jul 1, 2018 |
| Democratic Women's Club of Santa Cruz County | ** Support | Jul 1, 2018 |
| Family Law Section Of The California Lawyers Association | ** Against | Jul 1, 2018 |
| Family Violence Appellate Project | ** Against | Aug 28, 2018 |
| Judicial Council | ** Against | Jul 1, 2018 |
| Over 10 Individuals | ** Support | Aug 28, 2018 |
| Santa Cruz County Supervisor Ryan Coonerty | ** Support | Jul 1, 2018 |
| Santa Cruz County Supervisor Zach Friend | ** Support | Jul 1, 2018 |
| Santa Cruz Mayor Davis Terrazas | ** Support | Jul 1, 2018 |
| Several individuals | ** Support | May 16, 2018 |
| Thirteen Individuals | ** Support | Jul 1, 2018 |
| walnut avenue family & women's center | ** Support | Aug 28, 2018 |
| Women Sv | ** Support | Aug 28, 2018 |
| Writing In Support, Former Congressman Sam Farr States: | ** Against | Aug 28, 2018 |
Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | SB |
UNFINISHED BUSINESS
Bill No: SB 1129
:
SENATE JUDICIARY COMMITTEE: 5-1, 5/8/18
AYES: Jackson, Hertzberg, Monning, Stern, Wieckowski
NOES: Anderson
NO VOTE RECORDED: Moorlach
SENATE FLOOR: 30-7, 5/21/18
AYES: Allen, Atkins, Bates, Beall, Bradford, De León, Dodd, Galgiani, Glazer, Hernandez, Hertzberg, Hill, Hueso, Jackson, Lara, Leyva, McGuire, Mitchell, Monning, Newman, Nguyen, Pan, Portantino, Roth, Skinner, Stern, Stone, Wieckowski, Wiener, Wilk
NOES: Anderson, Berryhill, Gaines, Moorlach, Morrell, Nielsen, Vidak
NO VOTE RECORDED: Cannella, Fuller
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 68-0, 8/28/18 - See last page for vote
SUBJECT: Spousal support award: convictions
DIGEST:
This bill prohibits awards of spousal support, attorney fees, and community property interest in retirement benefits to individuals convicted of felony domestic violence against their spouses, and creates a presumption against an award of similar benefits to those spouses convicted of misdemeanor domestic violence.
Assembly Amendments augment judicial discretion to (1) protect spouses who were convicted of felony domestic violence but were actually the abused spouse in the relationship, and (2) decide, in cases involving domestic violence misdemeanors, the extent to which the injured spouse should receive the community property interest in retirement benefits.
Existing law:
- Provides that when parties in a divorce proceeding request spousal support, the court may order either spouse to pay for the support of the other party an amount, for a period of time, that the court determines is just and reasonable, based on the standard of living established during the marriage, taking into consideration the specified circumstances. (Fam. Code Sec. 4330(a).)
- Requires a court, in ordering spousal support, to take many factors into consideration, including: the marketable skills of the supported party; the extent to which the supported party contributed to the earning capacity of the supporting party; the needs of each party; the obligations and assets of each party; evidence of any history of domestic violence between the two parties; and the criminal conviction of an abusive spouse. (Fam. Code Sec. 4320.)
- Provides, in addition to any other remedy, that when a spouse is convicted of attempting to murder the other spouse, or soliciting the murder of the other spouse, the convicted spouse is prohibited from receiving any temporary or permanent award of spousal, medical, life or other insurance benefits or payments from the injured spouse. (Fam. Code Sec. 4324.)
- Provides, in addition to any other remedy authorized by law, that when a spouse is convicted of attempting to murder the other spouse, or of soliciting the murder of that spouse, the injured spouse is entitled to all the community property interest in the retirement and pension benefits of the injured spouse. (Fam. Code Sec. 782.5.)
- Provides that in any proceeding for dissolution of a marriage, where there is a criminal conviction for a violent sexual felony perpetrated by one spouse against the other, an award of spousal support to the convicted spouse is prohibited. Existing law further authorizes a court, when one spouse is convicted of a violent sexual felony against the other, to order attorney fees be covered out of community property assets, set the date of separation at the point at which the incident giving rise to the conviction occurred, and award the injured spouse 100 percent of their interest in pension or retirement benefits. (Fam. Code Sec. 4324.5.)
- Creates a rebuttable presumption against an award for temporary or permanent spousal support to a spouse convicted of domestic violence against the other spouse within five years before filing for a dissolution of the marriage, or any time thereafter. (Fam. Code Sec. 4325.)
This bill:
- Provides that in any proceeding for dissolution of a marriage where one spouse has been convicted of a domestic violence felony against the other spouse, filed before five years following the conviction and any time served in custody, on probation, or on parole:
- Prohibits an award of spousal support to the convicted spouse.
- Requires the court, where economic circumstances warrant, to order attorney fees and costs incurred by the parties to be paid from the community assets. Prohibits the injured spouse from being required to pay any attorney fees of the convicted spouse out of the injured spouse's separate property.
- At the request of the injured spouse, requires the date of legal separation to be the date of the incident giving rise to the conviction, or earlier, if the court finds circumstances that justify an earlier date.
- Requires the injured spouse to receive 100% of the community property interest in the retirement and pension benefits of the injured spouse.
- Provides that if a convicted spouse presents documented evidence of that spouse’s history as a victim of violent sexual offenses or domestic violence perpetrated by the other spouse, the court may determine, based on the facts of the particular case, that one or more of the restrictions in 1) above do not apply.
- Provides that in any proceeding for dissolution of a marriage where one spouse has been convicted, within five years prior to filing of the dissolution or during the course of the dissolution proceeding, of a domestic violence misdemeanor against the other spouse, as provided, there is a rebuttable presumption, rebuttable by a preponderance of evidence, for all of the following:
- Prohibits an award of spousal support to the convicted spouse.
- Requires the court, where economic circumstances warrant, to order attorney fees and costs incurred by the parties to be paid from the community assets. Prohibits the injured spouse from being required to pay any attorney fees of the convicted spouse out of the injured spouse's separate property.
- At the request of the injured spouse, requires the date of legal separation to be the date of the incident giving rise to the conviction, or earlier, if the court finds circumstances that justify an earlier date.
- Allows the court, in considering whether to rebut the presumption in 3) above, to consider any documented evidence that the convicted spouse was a victim of domestic violence by the injured spouse or any other factors the court deems just and reasonable.
- Allows the court, in the situation in 3) above, based on the facts of the particular dissolution case, to provide the injured spouse up to 100% of the community property interest in the retirement and pension benefits of the injured spouse. Requires the court, in determining whether and how to apportion the community property interest in the retirement and pension benefits of the injured spouse, to consider all of the following factors:
- The misdemeanor domestic violence conviction, as well as documented evidence of other instances of domestic violence between the parties or perpetrated by either party against either party's child, including, but not limited to, consideration of emotional distress resulting from domestic violence. The court shall also consider documented evidence of a convicted spouse's history as a victim of domestic violence perpetrated by the other spouse.
- The duration of the marriage and when, based on documented evidence, incidents of domestic violence occurred.
- The extent to which the convicted spouse's present or future earning capacity is impaired by periods of unemployment that were incurred during the marriage to permit the convicted spouse to devote time to domestic duties.
- The extent to which the convicted spouse contributed to the attainment of an education, training, a career position, or a license by the injured spouse.
- The balance of the hardships to each party.
- Any other factors the court determines are just and equitable.
- Applies 1), 3), and 5) above, prospectively to convictions that occur after the effective date of this bill.
Comments
Purpose of the bill. This bill arises from cases in which courts in divorce proceedings ruled that spouses who were convicted of criminal acts of domestic violence were still entitled to a community property interest in the injured spouse’s retirement or pension benefits.
This result has occurred because existing law generally does not enable a court, in dividing assets and awarding spousal support, to take into account one spouse’s wrongdoing against the other, such as having an affair. However, in recent years, the Legislature has carved out exceptions to this general policy when the wrongdoing is especially harmful. In particular, for a divorce proceeding in which a spouse was, within five years of the divorce filing, convicted of a violent sexual felony perpetrated against the other spouse, all of the following apply: (1) the convicted spouse cannot receive spousal support; (2) the court may order that attorney fees be covered out of community property assets; (3) the injured spouse may elect to set the date of the legal separation to the point at which the incident giving rise to the conviction occurred, or earlier, if the court finds that circumstances justify an earlier date; and (4) the injured spouse is entitled to 100 percent of the community property interest in the spouse’s pension or retirement benefits. (Fam. Code Sec. 4324.5.)
Assembly amendments augment judicial discretion to prevent unintended consequences. This bill, as it passed the Senate, sought to put victims of domestic violence on the same footing as victims of sexually violent felonies. With regard to domestic violence felonies, the forfeiture of the covered marital assets and interests applied as a matter of course. With regard to domestic violence misdemeanors, these consequences were subject to a rebuttable presumption.
The Assembly amendments introduce more judicial discretion to prevent potentially unjust, unintended applications of this bill’s provisions. As amended by the Assembly, this bill now provides that if a spouse convicted of a sexually violent or domestic violence felony presents documented evidence of their history as a victim of abuse perpetrated by the other spouse, as specified, the court may decline to apply the provisions mandating the forfeiture of the covered assets and interests.
Additionally, with regard to spouses convicted of domestic violence misdemeanors, the Assembly amendments give the court complete discretion to determine if the injured spouse is entitled to 100 percent of the community property interest in the retirement and pension benefits of the injured spouse, based on specified factors. These amendments retain the protective framework passed by the Senate, while ensuring that courts have flexibility to account for extenuating circumstances and fashion appropriate remedies.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: Fiscal Com.: Local:
Congressman Sam Farr
Walnut Avenue Family & Women’s Center
Women SV
Over 10 individuals
OPPOSITION: (Verified 8/28/18)
Association of Certified Family Law Specialists
Executive Committee of the Family Law Section of the State Bar
Family Violence Appellate Project
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: According to the author:
California is currently a “No-Fault Divorce” state, where existing law protects a spouse from having to show fault in their partner’s actions in order to end a marriage. California law, however, recognizes the unique need to protect the financial security of an individual who seeks a divorce because they are a victim of spousal abuse.
Current law gives a family court judge the discretion to consider a spouse’s history of domestic violence when determining spousal support, and provides for a rebuttal presumption against the awarding of spousal support to those who receive a conviction for domestic violence.
These protections, however, do not explicitly restrict a court’s ability to re-victimize a spouse by ordering them to financially support their domestic abuser; cover the cost of their domestic abuser’s attorney fees; or force them to give half of their pension and retirement savings to their abusive spouse.
Assembly Bill (AB) 1522 (Chapter 718, Statutes of 2012), took the first step in protecting abused spouses from being re-victimized by their former partners by prohibiting the courts from awarding spousal support, medical benefits, attorney’s fees, or any community property interest to a person that is convicted of a violent sexual felony against their spouse.
AB 1522 falls short, however, in protecting the vast majority of those who suffer domestic violence in a marriage, and creates an imbalance where victims of a “sexually” violent act by their spouse receive far greater protections from their abuser in divorce proceedings, than victims of all other acts of domestic violence.
SB 1129 will correct this shortcoming in the existing law, and will create parity in the laws protecting victims of violence by expanding the existing protections for victims of a violent sexual felony to all victims of domestic violence at the hands of their spouse.
Writing in support, former Congressman Sam Farr states:
California has provided leadership for many years on the issues of domestic violence. This bill represents another step in helping break the cycle of domestic violence and support the victim. With passage of this bill, the victim would have one less obstacle in leaving the abusive relationship and after they do, critical help in rebuilding their life. […] SB 1129 is seeking to address this same issue in a different way; allowing the victim to have the retirement security that they worked for throughout their careers while enduring the abuse. Equally important in this bill is the ability of the victim to seek an earlier date of separation; a date that recognizes that the true date of the ‘break in the marital relationship’ occurs when domestic violence is present. By acknowledging that domestic violence and the normal conduct of a marital relationship are not consistent, the bill provides another tool to aid the victims.
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION: Writing in opposition, the Association of Certified Family Law Specialists states as follows:
SB 1129 is not only unnecessary and attempts to reintroduce fault into a no-fault divorce state, it will likely have the adverse effect of actually harming victims of domestic violence. It will take away judicial discretion in awarding spousal support to true victims of domestic violence and will end up forcing victims of domestic violence to testify in every domestic violence case, as no alleged abuser will plead guilty to a lesser offense of domestic violence, due to a loss of property rights and support.
Additionally, the Family Violence Appellate Project, which supports some provisions of this bill and opposes others, has expressed concerns over the removal of judicial discretion, the reintroduction of fault into divorces, and potential
unintended consequences, including the possibility that this bill could harm convicted spouses who are in actuality the abused spouse in the relationship.
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 68-0, 8/28/18
AYES: Acosta, Aguiar-Curry, Arambula, Baker, Berman, Bloom, Bonta, Brough, Burke, Caballero, Calderon, Carrillo, Cervantes, Chau, Chávez, Chen, Chiu, Choi, Chu, Cooley, Cunningham, Daly, Eggman, Fong, Frazier, Friedman, Gabriel, Cristina Garcia, Eduardo Garcia, Gipson, Gloria, Gonzalez Fletcher, Gray, Holden, Irwin, Jones-Sawyer, Kalra, Kamlager-Dove, Kiley, Lackey, Levine, Limón, Low, Maienschein, Mayes, McCarty, Medina, Melendez, Mullin, Muratsuchi, Nazarian, O'Donnell, Quirk, Quirk-Silva, Reyes, Rivas, Rodriguez, Rubio, Salas, Santiago, Steinorth, Mark Stone, Thurmond, Ting, Waldron, Weber, Wood, Rendon
NO VOTE RECORDED: Travis Allen, Bigelow, Cooper, Dahle, Flora, Gallagher, Grayson, Harper, Mathis, Obernolte, Patterson, Voepel
8/28/18 21:35:58
**** END ****
SENATE THIRD READING
STR Bill Id:SB 1129
Author:(Monning)
As Amended Ver:August 24, 2018
Majority vote
SENATE VOTE: 30-7
Committee | Votes | Ayes | Noes |
Judiciary | 9-0 | Mark Stone, Chau, Chiu, Holden, Kalra, Kiley, Maienschein, Reyes, Gonzalez Fletcher |
SUMMARY: Prohibits awards of spousal support, attorney fees, and community property interest in retirement, pension, or insurance benefits to individuals convicted of felony domestic violence against their spouses and creates a presumption against an award of similar benefits to those spouses convicted of misdemeanor domestic violence. Specifically, this bill:
- In any proceeding for dissolution of a marriage where one spouse has been convicted of a domestic violence felony against the other spouse, filed before five years following the conviction and any time served in custody, on probation, or on parole:
- Prohibits an award of spousal support to the convicted spouse.
- Requires the court, where economic circumstances warrant, to order attorney fees and costs incurred by the parties to be paid from the community assets. Prohibits the injured spouse from being required to pay any attorney fees of the convicted spouse out of the injured spouse's separate property.
- At the request of the injured spouse, requires the date of legal separation to be the date of the incident giving rise to the conviction, or earlier, if the court finds circumstances that justify an earlier date.
- Requires the injured spouse to receive 100% of the community property interest in the retirement and pension benefits of the injured spouse.
- Provides that if a convicted spouse presents documented evidence of that spouse’s history as a victim of violent sexual offenses or domestic violence perpetrated by the other spouse, the court may determine, based on the facts of the particular case, that one or more of the restrictions in 1)a) to d) do not apply.
- In any proceeding for dissolution of a marriage where one spouse has been convicted, within five years prior to filing of the dissolution or during the course of the dissolution proceeding, of a domestic violence misdemeanor against the other spouse, as provided, provides that there is a rebuttable presumption, rebuttable by a preponderance of evidence, for all of the following:
- Prohibits an award of spousal support to the convicted spouse.
- Requires the court, where economic circumstances warrant, to order attorney fees and costs incurred by the parties to be paid from the community assets. Prohibits the injured spouse from being required to pay any attorney fees of the convicted spouse out of the injured spouse's separate property.
- At the request of the injured spouse, requires the date of legal separation to be the date of the incident giving rise to the conviction, or earlier, if the court finds circumstances that justify an earlier date.
- In considering whether to rebut the presumption in 3), allows the court to consider any documented evidence that the convicted spouse was a victim of domestic violence by the injured spouse or any other factors the court deems just and reasonable.
- Allows the court, in the situation in 3), above, based on the facts of the particular dissolution case, to provide the injured spouse up to 100% of the community property interest in the retirement and pension benefits of the injured spouse. Requires the court, in determining whether and how to apportion the community property interest in the retirement and pension benefits of the injured spouse, to consider all of the following factors:
- The misdemeanor domestic violence conviction, as well as documented evidence of other instances of domestic violence between the parties or perpetrated by either party against either party's child, including, but not limited to, consideration of emotional distress resulting from domestic violence. The court shall also consider documented evidence of a convicted spouse's history as a victim of domestic violence perpetrated by the other spouse.
- The duration of the marriage and when, based on documented evidence, incidents of domestic violence occurred.
- The extent to which the convicted spouse's present or future earning capacity is impaired by periods of unemployment that were incurred during the marriage to permit the convicted spouse to devote time to domestic duties.
- The extent to which the convicted spouse contributed to the attainment of an education, training, a career position, or a license by the injured spouse.
- The balance of the hardships to each party.
- Any other factors the court determines are just and equitable.
- Applies 1), 3), and 5), above, prospectively to convictions that occur after the effective date of the bill.
EXISTING LAW:
- Prohibits a person who feloniously and intentionally kills another from inheriting from that person, either through a will or by intestate succession, and includes quasi-community property. (Probate Code Section 250.)
- Provides that all property, real or personal, wherever situated, acquired by a married person during the marriage while domiciled in California is community property, except as otherwise provided by statute. Provides that property acquired before the marriage and property acquired by gift or inheritance during the marriage is separate property. (Family Code Sections 760, 770. Unless stated otherwise, all further references are to the Family Code.)
- Defines, for purposes of a dissolution, the "date of separation" to be the date that a complete and final break in the marital relationship has occurred, as evidenced by a spouse's expression to the other spouse of his or her intent to end the marriage and conduct that is consistent with that intent. (Section 70.)
- Provides that, in addition to any other remedy authorized by law, when a spouse is convicted of attempting to murder the other spouse, or of soliciting the murder of that spouse, the injured spouse is entitled to all the community property interest in the retirement and pension benefits of the injured spouse. (Section 782.5.)
- In a proceeding for dissolution of marriage, requires the court to ensure that each party has access to legal representation, including access early in the proceedings, to preserve each party's rights by ordering, if necessary based on the income and needs assessments, one party to pay to the other party, or to the other party's attorney, whatever amount is reasonably necessary for attorney fees and for the cost of maintaining or defending the proceeding during the pendency of the proceeding. Provides that the court should make an order for attorney fees where the making of the award, and the amount of the award, are just and reasonable under the relative circumstances of the respective parties. (Section 2030 et seq.)
- Provides, in addition to any other remedy, when a spouse is convicted of attempting to murder the other spouse or of soliciting the murder of the other spouse, the convicted spouse is prohibited from receiving any temporary or permanent award of spousal support or medical, life, or other insurance benefits or payments from the injured spouse. (Section 4324.)
- Provides that if an injured spouse is entitled to a remedy under 6), above, the injured spouse is entitled to an award of reasonable attorney fees and costs as a sanction. (Section 274.)
- In any proceeding for dissolution of a marriage where one spouse has been convicted of a violent sexual felony against the other spouse within the previous five years, as provided:
- Prohibits an award of spousal support to the convicted spouse.
- Requires the court, where economic circumstances warrant, to order attorney fees and costs incurred by the parties to be paid from the community assets. Prohibits the injured spouse from being required to pay any attorney fees of the convicted spouse out of the injured spouse's separate property.
- At the request of the injured spouse, requires the date of legal separation to be the date of the incident giving rise to the conviction, or earlier, if the court finds circumstances that justify an earlier date.
- Requires that the injured spouse receive 100% of the community property interest in the retirement and pension benefits of the injured spouse. (Section 4324.5.)
- Creates a rebuttable presumption against an award for temporary or permanent spousal support to a spouse convicted of domestic violence against the other spouse within five years before filing for a dissolution of the marriage, or any time thereafter. Allows the court to consider documented evidence of a convicted spouse's history as a victim of domestic violence perpetrated by the other spouse, or any other factors the court deems just and equitable, as conditions for rebutting the presumption. (Section 4325.)
- When determining whether to award spousal support, requires the court to consider a documented history of domestic violence and a criminal conviction of an abusive spouse. (Section 4320(i).)
FISCAL EFFECT: None
COMMENTS: This bill arises from instances in certain divorce proceedings where spouses who were convicted of criminal acts of domestic violence were still entitled to various benefits, including their community property interest in the injured spouse's retirement or pension benefits. While those spouses were punished in the criminal court, this bill seeks to limit what share of the community property to which they might otherwise be entitled in their divorce.
California is a no-fault divorce state, and existing law generally does not allow a court, in dividing assets and awarding spousal support, to take into account one spouse's wrongdoing against the other. However, in recent years, the Legislature has carved out exceptions to this general policy when the wrongdoing is especially heinous. In particular, for a divorce proceeding in which a spouse was, within five years of the divorce filing, convicted of a violent sexual felony against the other spouse, all of the following apply: 1) the convicted spouse cannot receive spousal support; 2) the court may limit an order for attorney fees; 3) the injured spouse may elect to set the date of the legal separation to the point at which the incident giving rise to the conviction occurred, or earlier; and 4) the injured spouse is entitled to all of the community property interest in the spouse's pension or retirement benefits. (Section 4324.5.) This bill would expand that exception and treat victims of domestic violence felonies the same as victims of sexually violent felonies and would create a presumption for the same protections for victims of domestic violence misdemeanors.
This bill is supported by many individuals, politicians, and political entities, who believe that current law allows victims of domestic violence to be re-victimized in divorce and keeps many victims with their abusers to avoid becoming destitute in their later years. This bill is opposed by family law practitioners who believe the law already has sufficient safeguards and procedures to protect victims of domestic violence and this bill will have unintended consequences that will actually result in harm to domestic violence victims, and will increase workload and limit pleas in criminal court.
Analysis Prepared by: Leora Gershenzon / JUD. / (916) 319-2334 FN: 0004752
SENATE THIRD READING
STR Bill Id:SB 1129
Author:(Monning)
As Amended Ver:July 5, 2018
Majority vote
SENATE VOTE: 30-7
Committee | Votes | Ayes | Noes |
Judiciary | 9-0 | Mark Stone, Chau, Chiu, Holden, Kalra, Kiley, Maienschein, Reyes, Gonzalez Fletcher |
|
SUMMARY: Prohibits awards of spousal support, attorney fees, and community property interest in retirement, pension, or insurance benefits to individuals convicted of felony domestic violence against their spouses and creates a presumption against an award of similar benefits to those spouses convicted of misdemeanor domestic violence. Specifically, this bill:
- In any proceeding for dissolution of a marriage where one spouse has been convicted of a domestic violence felony against the other spouse, filed before five years following the conviction and any time served in custody, on probation, or on parole:
- Prohibits an award of spousal support to the convicted spouse.
- Requires the court, where economic circumstances warrant, to order attorney fees and costs incurred by the parties to be paid from the community assets. Prohibits the injured spouse from being required to pay any attorney fees of the convicted spouse out of the injured spouse's separate property.
- At the request of the injured spouse, requires the date of legal separation to be the date of the incident giving rise to the conviction, or earlier, if the court finds circumstances that justify an earlier date.
- Requires the injured spouse to receive 100% of the community property interest in the retirement and pension benefits of the injured spouse.
- In any proceeding for dissolution of a marriage where one spouse has been convicted, within five years prior to filing of the dissolution or during the course of the dissolution proceeding, of a domestic violence misdemeanor against the other spouse, as provided, provides that there is a rebuttable presumption, rebuttable by a preponderance of evidence, for all of the following:
- Prohibits an award of spousal support to the convicted spouse.
- Requires the court, where economic circumstances warrant, to order attorney fees and costs incurred by the parties to be paid from the community assets. Prohibits the injured spouse from being required to pay any attorney fees of the convicted spouse out of the injured spouse's separate property.
- At the request of the injured spouse, requires the date of legal separation to be the date of the incident giving rise to the conviction, or earlier, if the court finds circumstances that justify an earlier date.
- In considering whether to rebut the presumption in 2), allows the court to consider any documented evidence that the convicted spouse was a victim of domestic violence by the injured spouse or any other factors the court deems just and reasonable.
- Allows the court, in the situation in 2), above, based on the facts of the particular dissolution case, to provide the injured spouse up to 100% of the community property interest in the retirement and pension benefits of the injured spouse. Requires the court, in determining whether and how to apportion the community property interest in the retirement and pension benefits of the injured spouse, to consider all of the following factors:
- The misdemeanor domestic violence conviction, as well as documented evidence of other instances of domestic violence between the parties or perpetrated by either party against either party's child, including, but not limited to, consideration of emotional distress resulting from domestic violence. The court shall also consider documented evidence of a convicted spouse's history as a victim of domestic violence perpetrated by the other spouse.
- The duration of the marriage and when, based on documented evidence, incidents of domestic violence occurred.
- The extent to which the convicted spouse's present or future earning capacity is impaired by periods of unemployment that were incurred during the marriage to permit the convicted spouse to devote time to domestic duties.
- The extent to which the convicted spouse contributed to the attainment of an education, training, a career position, or a license by the injured spouse.
- The balance of the hardships to each party.
- Any other factors the court determines are just and equitable.
- Applies 1), 2), and 4), above, prospectively to convictions that occur after the effective date of the bill.
EXISTING LAW:
- Prohibits a person who feloniously and intentionally kills another from inheriting from that person, either through a will or by intestate succession, and includes quasi-community property. (Probate Code Section 250.)
- Provides that all property, real or personal, wherever situated, acquired by a married person during the marriage while domiciled in California is community property, except as otherwise provided by statute. Provides that property acquired before the marriage and property acquired by gift or inheritance during the marriage is separate property. (Family Code Sections 760, 770. Unless stated otherwise, all further references are to the Family Code.)
- Defines, for purposes of a dissolution, the "date of separation" to be the date that a complete and final break in the marital relationship has occurred, as evidenced by a spouse's expression to the other spouse of his or her intent to end the marriage and conduct that is consistent with that intent. (Section 70.)
- Provides that, in addition to any other remedy authorized by law, when a spouse is convicted of attempting to murder the other spouse, or of soliciting the murder of that spouse, the injured spouse is entitled to all the community property interest in the retirement and pension benefits of the injured spouse. (Section 782.5.)
- In a proceeding for dissolution of marriage, requires the court to ensure that each party has access to legal representation, including access early in the proceedings, to preserve each party's rights by ordering, if necessary based on the income and needs assessments, one party to pay to the other party, or to the other party's attorney, whatever amount is reasonably necessary for attorney fees and for the cost of maintaining or defending the proceeding during the pendency of the proceeding. Provides that the court should make an order for attorney fees where the making of the award, and the amount of the award, are just and reasonable under the relative circumstances of the respective parties. (Section 2030 et seq.)
- Provides, in addition to any other remedy, when a spouse is convicted of attempting to murder the other spouse or of soliciting the murder of the other spouse, the convicted spouse is prohibited from receiving any temporary or permanent award of spousal support or medical, life, or other insurance benefits or payments from the injured spouse. (Section 4324.)
- Provides that if an injured spouse is entitled to a remedy under 6), above, the injured spouse is entitled to an award of reasonable attorney fees and costs as a sanction. (Section 274.)
- In any proceeding for dissolution of a marriage where one spouse has been convicted of a violent sexual felony against the other spouse within the previous five years, as provided:
- Prohibits an award of spousal support to the convicted spouse.
- Requires the court, where economic circumstances warrant, to order attorney fees and costs incurred by the parties to be paid from the community assets. Prohibits the injured spouse from being required to pay any attorney fees of the convicted spouse out of the injured spouse's separate property.
- At the request of the injured spouse, requires the date of legal separation to be the date of the incident giving rise to the conviction, or earlier, if the court finds circumstances that justify an earlier date.
- Requires that the injured spouse receive 100% of the community property interest in the retirement and pension benefits of the injured spouse. (Section 4324.5.)
- Creates a rebuttable presumption against an award for temporary or permanent spousal support to a spouse convicted of domestic violence against the other spouse within five years before filing for a dissolution of the marriage, or any time thereafter. Allows the court to consider documented evidence of a convicted spouse's history as a victim of domestic violence perpetrated by the other spouse, or any other factors the court deems just and equitable, as conditions for rebutting the presumption. (Section 4325.)
- When determining whether to award spousal support, requires the court to consider a documented history of domestic violence and a criminal conviction of an abusive spouse. (Section 4320 (i).)
FISCAL EFFECT: None
COMMENTS: This bill arises from instances in certain divorce proceedings where spouses who were convicted of criminal acts of domestic violence were still entitled to various benefits, including their community property interest in the injured spouse's retirement or pension benefits. While those spouses were punished in the criminal court, this bill seeks to limit what share of the community property to which they might otherwise be entitled in their divorce.
California is a no-fault divorce state, and existing law generally does not allow a court, in dividing assets and awarding spousal support, to take into account one spouse's wrongdoing against the other. However, in recent years, the Legislature has carved out exceptions to this general policy when the wrongdoing is especially heinous. In particular, for a divorce proceeding in which a spouse was, within five years of the divorce filing, convicted of a violent sexual felony against the other spouse, all of the following apply: (1) the convicted spouse cannot receive spousal support; (2) the court may limit an order for attorney fees; (3) the injured spouse may elect to set the date of the legal separation to the point at which the incident giving rise to the conviction occurred, or earlier; and (4) the injured spouse is entitled to all of the community property interest in the spouse's pension or retirement benefits. (Section 4324.5.) This bill would expand that exception and treat victims of domestic violence felonies the same as victims of sexually violent felonies and would create a presumption for the same protections for victims of domestic violence misdemeanors.
This bill is supported by many individuals, politicians, and political entities, who believe that current law allows victims of domestic violence to be re-victimized in divorce and keeps many victims with their abusers to avoid becoming destitute in their later years. This bill is opposed, or opposed unless amended, by family law practitioners and the Judicial Council who believe the law already has sufficient safeguards and procedures to protect victims of domestic violence and this bill will have unintended consequences that will actually result in harm to domestic violence victims, and will increase workload and limit pleas in criminal court.
Analysis Prepared by: Leora Gershenzon / JUD. / (916) 319-2334 FN: 0003711
Date of Hearing: July 3, 2018
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON
, Chair
SBPCA Bill Id:
Author:() – As Ver:
As Proposed to be Amended
SENATE VOTE:
SUBJECT: DOMESTIC VIOLENCE : forfeiture of spousal sUPPORT, ATTORNEY FEES, and retirement benefits
KEY ISSUES:
- should an individual WHO IS convicted of felony DOMESTIC VIOLENCE against THEIR spouse forfeit ALL rightS to SPOUSAL SUPPORT, attorney fees, AND their COMMUNITY PROPERTY INTEREST in THE INJURED SPOUSE’S retirement and pension benefits?
- should an individual WHO IS convicted of misdemeanor DOMESTIC VIOLENCE against THEIR spouse PRESUMPTIVELY forfeit ALL rightS to SPOUSAL SUPPORT and attorney fees, AND should the court have discretion to take away their COMMUNITY PROPERTY INTEREST in THE INJURED SPOUSE’S retirement and pension benefits?
SYNOPSIS
This bill arises from instances in certain divorce proceedings where spouses who were convicted of criminal acts of domestic violence were still entitled to various benefits, including their community property interest in the injured spouse’s retirement or pension benefits. While those spouses were punished in the criminal court, this bill seeks to limit what share of the community property to which they might otherwise be entitled to in their divorce. California is a no-fault divorce state, and existing law generally does not allow a court, in dividing assets and awarding spousal support, to take into account one spouse’s wrongdoing against the other spouse. However, in recent years, the Legislature has carved out exceptions to this general policy when the wrongdoing is especially heinous. In particular, for a divorce proceeding in which a spouse was, within five years of the divorce filing, convicted of a violent sexual felony against the other spouse, all of the following apply: (1) the convicted spouse cannot receive spousal support; (2) the court may limit an order for attorney fees; (3) the injured spouse may elect to set the date of the legal separation to the point at which the incident giving rise to the conviction occurred, or earlier; and (4) the injured spouse is entitled to all of the community property interest in the spouse’s pension or retirement benefits. (SB 1522 (Atkins), Chap. 718, Stats. 2012.) This bill would expand that exception and treat victims of domestic violence felonies the same as victims of sexually violent felonies, and would also create a presumption for the same protections for victims of domestic violence misdemeanors.
This bill is supported by many individuals, politicians, and political entities, who believe that current law allows victims of domestic violence to be re-victimized in divorce and keeps many victims with their abusers to avoid becoming destitute in their later years. The bill is opposed, or opposed unless amended, by family law practitioners and the Judicial Council who believe the law already has sufficient safeguards and procedures to protect victims of domestic violence and this bill will have unintended consequences that will actually result in harm to domestic violence victims, and will increase workload and limit pleas in criminal court.
SUMMARY: Prohibits awards of spousal support, attorney fees, and community property interest in retirement, pension, or insurance benefits to individuals convicted of felony domestic violence against their spouses and creates a presumption against an award of similar benefits to those spouses convicted of misdemeanor domestic violence. Specifically, this bill:
- In any proceeding for dissolution of a marriage where one spouse has been convicted of a domestic violence felony against the other spouse, filed before five years following the conviction and any time served in custody, on probation, or on parole:
- Prohibits an award of spousal support to the convicted spouse.
- Requires the court, where economic circumstances warrant, to order attorney fees and costs incurred by the parties to be paid from the community assets. Prohibits the injured spouse from being required to pay any attorney fees of the convicted spouse out of the injured spouse’s separate property.
- At the request of the injured spouse, requires the date of legal separation to be the date of the incident giving rise to the conviction, or earlier, if the court finds circumstances that justify an earlier date.
- Requires the injured spouse to receive 100 percent of the community property interest in the retirement and pension benefits of the injured spouse.
- In any proceeding for dissolution of a marriage where one spouse has been convicted, within five years prior to filing of the dissolution or during the course of the dissolution proceeding, of a domestic violence misdemeanor against the other spouse, as provided, provides that there is a rebuttable presumption, rebuttable by a preponderance of evidence, for all of the following:
- Prohibits an award of spousal support to the convicted spouse.
- Requires the court, where economic circumstances warrant, to order attorney fees and costs incurred by the parties to be paid from the community assets. Prohibits the injured spouse from being required to pay any attorney fees of the convicted spouse out of the injured spouse’s separate property.
- At the request of the injured spouse, requires the date of legal separation to be the date of the incident giving rise to the conviction, or earlier, if the court finds circumstances that justify an earlier date.
- In considering whether to rebut the presumption in 2), allows the court to consider any documented evidence that the convicted spouse was a victim of domestic violence by the injured spouse or any other factors the court deems just and reasonable.
- Allows the court, in the situation in 2), above, based on the facts of the particular dissolution case, to provide the injured spouse up to 100 percent of the community property interest in the retirement and pension benefits of the injured spouse. Requires the court, in determining whether and how to apportion the community property interest in the retirement and pension benefits of the injured spouse, to consider all of the following factors:
- The misdemeanor domestic violence conviction, as well as documented evidence of other instances of domestic violence between the parties or perpetrated by either party against either party’s child, including, but not limited to, consideration of emotional distress resulting from domestic violence. The court shall also consider documented evidence of a convicted spouse’s history as a victim of domestic violence perpetrated by the other spouse.
- The duration of the marriage and when, based on documented evidence, incidents of domestic violence occurred.
- The extent to which the convicted spouse's present or future earning capacity is impaired by periods of unemployment that were incurred during the marriage to permit the convicted spouse to devote time to domestic duties.
- The extent to which the convicted spouse contributed to the attainment of an education, training, a career position, or a license by the injured spouse.
- The balance of the hardships to each party.
- Any other factors the court determines are just and equitable.
- Applies 1), 2), and 4), above, prospectively to convictions that occur after the effective date of the bill.
EXISTING LAW:
- Prohibits a person who feloniously and intentionally kills another from inheriting from that person, either through a will or by intestate succession, and includes quasi-community property. (Probate Code Section 250.)
- Provides that all property, real or personal, wherever situated, acquired by a married person during the marriage while domiciled in California is community property, except as otherwise provided by statute. Provides that property acquired before the marriage and property acquired by gift or inheritance during the marriage is separate property. (Family Code Sections 760, 770. Unless stated otherwise, all further references are to the Family Code.)
- Defines, for purposes of a dissolution, the “date of separation” to be the date that a complete and final break in the marital relationship has occurred, as evidenced by a spouse’s expression to the other spouse of his or her intent to end the marriage and conduct that is consistent with that intent. (Section 70.)
- Provides that, in addition to any other remedy authorized by law, when a spouse is convicted of attempting to murder the other spouse, or of soliciting the murder of that spouse, the injured spouse is entitled to all the community property interest in the retirement and pension benefits of the injured spouse. (Section 782.5.)
- In a proceeding for dissolution of marriage, requires the court to ensure that each party has access to legal representation, including access early in the proceedings, to preserve each party’s rights by ordering, if necessary based on the income and needs assessments, one party to pay to the other party, or to the other party’s attorney, whatever amount is reasonably necessary for attorney fees and for the cost of maintaining or defending the proceeding during the pendency of the proceeding. Provides that the court should make an order for attorney fees where the making of the award, and the amount of the award, are just and reasonable under the relative circumstances of the respective parties. (Section 2030 et seq.)
- Provides, in addition to any other remedy, when a spouse is convicted of attempting to murder the other spouse or of soliciting the murder of the other spouse, the convicted spouse is prohibited from receiving any temporary or permanent award of spousal support or medical, life, or other insurance benefits or payments from the injured spouse. (Section 4324.)
- Provides that if an injured spouse is entitled to a remedy under 6), above, the injured spouse is entitled to an award of reasonable attorney fees and costs as a sanction. (Section 274.)
- In any proceeding for dissolution of a marriage where one spouse has been convicted of a violent sexual felony against the other spouse within the previous five years, as provided:
- Prohibits an award of spousal support to the convicted spouse.
- Requires the court, where economic circumstances warrant, to order attorney fees and costs incurred by the parties to be paid from the community assets. Prohibits the injured spouse from being required to pay any attorney fees of the convicted spouse out of the injured spouse’s separate property.
- At the request of the injured spouse, requires the date of legal separation to be the date of the incident giving rise to the conviction, or earlier, if the court finds circumstances that justify an earlier date.
- Requires that the injured spouse receive 100 percent of the community property interest in the retirement and pension benefits of the injured spouse. (Section 4324.5.)
- Creates a rebuttable presumption against an award for temporary or permanent spousal support to a spouse convicted of domestic violence against the other spouse within five years before filing for a dissolution of the marriage, or any time thereafter. Allows the court to consider documented evidence of a convicted spouse’s history as a victim of domestic violence perpetrated by the other spouse, or any other factors the court deems just and equitable, as conditions for rebutting the presumption. (Section 4325.)
- When determining whether to award spousal support, requires the court to consider a documented history of domestic violence and a criminal conviction of an abusive spouse. (Section 4320 (i).)
FISCAL EFFECT: As currently in print this bill is keyed non-fiscal.
COMMENTS: This bill arises from instances in certain divorce proceedings where spouses who were convicted of criminal acts of domestic violence were still entitled to various benefits, including their community property interest in the injured spouse’s retirement or pension benefits. While those spouses were punished in the criminal court, this bill seeks to limit what share of the community property to which they might otherwise be entitled in their divorce.
California is a no-fault divorce state, and existing law generally does not allow a court, in dividing assets and awarding spousal support, to take into account one spouse’s wrongdoing against the other. However, in recent years, the Legislature has carved out exceptions to this general policy when the wrongdoing is especially heinous. In particular, for a divorce proceeding in which a spouse was, within five years of the divorce filing, convicted of a violent sexual felony against the other spouse, all of the following apply: (1) the convicted spouse cannot receive spousal support; (2) the court may limit an order for attorney fees; (3) the injured spouse may elect to set the date of the legal separation to the point at which the incident giving rise to the conviction occurred, or earlier; and (4) the injured spouse is entitled to all of the community property interest in the spouse’s pension or retirement benefits. (Section 4324.5.) This bill would expand that exception and treat victims of domestic violence felonies the same as victims of sexually violent felonies and would create a presumption for the same protections for victims of domestic violence misdemeanors.
In support of the bill, the author writes:
Current law is insufficient in protecting victims of domestic violence from having to financially support their abusers at the conclusion of a marriage. California’s long standing “no-fault” divorce status has protected countless spouses who want to end a marriage from having to prove any wrongdoing by their spouse, and can do so knowing that their spouse will have to provide some support. The protections of “no fault” and the existing laws around spousal support are important in providing a spouse who may not be the primary breadwinner in a marriage the financial security to seek dissolution of their marriage, without fear of ending up destitute. . . .
The legislature established a precedent that there certain heinous crimes that fall outside of the “no-fault” rule, and in doing so, created an imbalanced system where one victim whose abuse was sexual in nature receives far greater protections in divorce than a victim [of] non-sexual domestic violence. This imbalance in the law is unjust, and deserves to be corrected by the Legislature.
SB 1129 will prevent the injustice of forcing victims of domestic violence to financially support their abusive spouses after ending their marriage. It will create parity in the laws currently protecting victims of violence by applying the financial protections that victims of a violent sexual felony receive, to all victims of domestic violence.
“No-fault” Divorce System in California. By limiting the financial support a victim spouse must provide to a spouse convicted of domestic violence, this bill creates an exception to the general policy of “no-fault” divorce in California. A no-fault divorce policy allows either party to file for dissolution without the need to prove fault by the other spouse. An article from the Cincinnati Law Review describes the importance of the no-fault divorce system for women:
Having to prove grounds in order to obtain a divorce was traditionally mired with rigid hierarchical notions of male and female gender roles, and divorce has too often been awarded in a discriminatory fashion. Moreover, feminists aspiring to formal equality and fighting women’s traditional dependence on men have supported allowing either party to a marriage to exit if they so choose without having to prove or contrive the existence of fault. (Laufer-Ukeles, Pamela, Reconstructing Fault: the Case for Spousal Torts, 79 U. Cin. L. Rev. 207, 209-10 (2010) (footnotes omitted).)
No-fault divorce laws are also designed to protect children. To obtain a divorce under California law, a party is not required to show wrongdoing by the other party, such as an affair. Likewise, spousal support is awardable without regard to the merits or procedural posture of the case, and torts and criminal acts are dealt with in their respective courts. (See Marriage of Askmo (2000) 85 Cal.App.4th 1032.) The general principle that a court does not look to the relative culpability of the parties in a divorce proceeding generally applies to the division of marital assets and debts, as well as to the awarding of attorney fees. However, there are exceptions to these rules which this bill seeks to expand.
Background on community property and the legal date of separation. California is a community property state. Community property is generally defined as all property acquired by a married person during the marriage while living in California. (Section 760.) Under California's community property system, one-half of the earnings of each spouse is owned by the other spouse. Separate property is property acquired before marriage, by gift or inheritance during the marriage, or after the spouses are living “separate and apart,” and is the separate property of each spouse. (Sections 770-771.) Community property interest in a pension or retirement account attaches when it is earned. Thus, even if a couple divorces years before the spouses are eligible for their retirement, each former spouse still has a one-half interest in the other former spouse's retirement account or pension accrued during the marriage.
Absent prior agreement, upon dissolution, the court must divide the community estate equally. (Section 2550.) Unlike a determination of spousal support where courts are given a certain amount of discretion to create a fair award based on the circumstances of the parties, as discussed below, the disposition of separate and community property is strictly governed by statute. There is no discretion. This policy was established to recognize the equal contributions of both spouses to the family unit, and historically has provided for an arguably more just division of property for families where one spouse may earn more income than the other, but the other may contribute more time to the household and the children.
Community property ceases to accrue on the "date of separation," defined as the date that a complete and final break in the marital relationship has occurred, as evidenced by a spouse’s expression to the other spouse of his or her intent to end the marriage and conduct that is consistent with that intent. (Section 70.) Thus, as of the legal date of separation, spouses keep all of their own earnings and any retirement or pension benefits accrued after that date.
Attorney fees in family law actions. The Judicial Council has reported that 90 percent of petitioners in domestic violence cases are unrepresented, and 85 percent of petitioners in child support cases appear in court without legal assistance. Courts report a similar lack of representation in child custody and dissolution cases, with at least one party unrepresented in more than 70 percent of family law cases. Unrepresented litigants in family law cases often find themselves dealing with issues in court that can be legally as well as factually complex. Individuals who start out with attorneys at the beginning of their cases often run out of money and become unrepresented before their cases are over. Unfortunately, our judicial system is based on parties being represented by counsel and when one or both parties is unrepresented, it is far more difficult for justice to be served. And while contested family law matters where both parties are unrepresented can be extremely difficult for the parties and the judge, cases where one party is represented and the other is not tend to be the most problematic cases in terms of fair access to justice.
While most civil cases require that parties pay for their own attorneys, family law is different. To address the situation where one spouse may have been the main breadwinner, the court, in any dissolution proceeding where one party has requested that the other party pay attorney fees, is required to make findings on whether an award of attorney fees is appropriate, whether there is a disparity in access to retain counsel, and whether one party is able to pay for legal representation for both parties. If the court determines that there is need, disparity in access and ability to pay, the court is required to award attorney fees. (Sections 2030-32.) And attorney fees may be requested upfront, to ensure that a spouse has sufficient resources to pay for an attorney throughout the proceeding. This attempts to level the playing field between spouses and helps ensure a just result.
Unlike community property and attorney fees, determination of spousal support is discretionary and based on a variety of factors, including domestic violence. In California, the court may order spousal support in an amount, and for a period of time, that the court determines is just and reasonable, based on the standard of living established during the marriage. (Section 4330.) In making spousal support awards, the court is required to consider, among other factors, the marketable skills of each party, the parties’ ability to pay spousal support, the needs of each party, the assets of each party, the ability of each party to engage in employment considering the interests of dependent children, and any other factors that the court determines are just and equitable. Of particular relevance here, the court is also required to consider documented evidence of any history of domestic violence between the parties. (Section 4320.) As a result of the complexity of the factors that the court must consider and the individual circumstances of the parties and families involved, courts are given broad discretion in determining spousal support awards.
Limitations on awarding spousal support, attorney fees and community property in dissolution proceedings based on spouse’s fault. While California is a no-fault divorce state, there are instances when fault is considered in dissolution proceedings.
Attempted murder or solicitation for murder. If one spouse attempts to murder the other spouse, or solicits a third party for the murder of their spouse, current law limits what the convicted spouse may receive in a divorce. These rules help ensure that the spouse convicted of attempting to murder the other spouse does not in any way benefit from that action. When a spouse is convicted of attempting to murder the other spouse, or of soliciting the murder of that spouse, the injured spouse is entitled to all the community property interest in the retirement and pension benefits of the injured spouse. (Section 782.5.) The convicted spouse is also prohibited from receiving spousal support or medical, life, or other insurance benefits or payments from the injured spouse. (Section 4324.) The injured spouse is also entitled to an award of reasonable attorney fees and costs as a sanction. (Section 274.)
Violent sexual felony. In 2012, in response to a very troubling case from San Diego in which a husband, who was convicted of a violent sexual felony against his wife and was serving a six-year prison sentence, was still awarded spousal support and attorney fees in the couple’s subsequent divorce, the Legislature enacted AB 1522 (Atkins), Chap. 718, Stats. 2012. That bill established that, in any proceeding for dissolution of a marriage where one spouse has been convicted of a violent sexual felony against the other spouse within five years:
- An award of spousal support to the convicted spouse is prohibited.
- The court, where economic circumstances warrant, is required to order attorney fees and costs incurred by the parties to be paid from the community assets. The injured spouse is prohibited from paying any attorney fees of the convicted spouse out of the injured spouse’s separate property.
- At the request of the injured spouse, the date of legal separation must be the date of the incident giving rise to the conviction, or earlier, if the court finds circumstances that justify an earlier date.
- The injured spouse must receive all of the community property interest in the retirement and pension benefits of the injured spouse. (Section 4324.5.)
Domestic violence. As discussed above, spousal support is, for the most part, discretionary. However, there are instances that restrict a court’s ability to award spousal support. When a spouse is convicted of domestic violence against the other spouse, there is a presumption against an award of spousal support to the convicted spouse, though that presumption may be overcome by a preponderance of the evidence. (Section 4325.) When ordering a spousal support award, a court must consider documented history of domestic violence, including but not limited to consideration of emotional distress or violence, committed by one spouse against the other or by one spouse against the children of the other spouse. (Section 4320.) It is important to note that, until this bill, domestic violence could limit spousal support, but had no other financial consequences in a subsequent divorce.
This bill seeks to extend the 2012 limitations applicable to felony sexual assault to domestic violence. This bill seeks to extend AB 1522’s limitations on what a spouse convicted of a violent sexual felony against the other spouse may receive in a subsequent divorce to a spouse convicted of felony domestic violence against the other spouse. Thus, under the bill, the convicted spouse would be prohibited from receiving any spousal support or any of their community property interest in the retirement and pension benefits of the injured spouse. In addition, the court would be required to limit attorney fees so that, where economic circumstances warrant, any order for attorney fees and costs incurred by the parties would have to be paid from the community assets, and the injured spouse’s separate property would be protected from any claim for attorney fees by the convicted spouse. Finally, at the request of the injured spouse, the date of separation – the date that community property ceases and separate property begins – would be the date of the incident giving rise to the conviction, or earlier, if the court finds circumstances that justify an earlier date. This would allow the injured spouse, if they were the higher earner, to protect their income and retirement benefits from that "date of separation."
For a conviction for misdemeanor domestic violence within five years prior to filing of the dissolution or during the course of the dissolution proceeding, by one spouse against the other spouse, this bill, as proposed to be amended, creates a rebuttable presumption against an award of spousal support to the convicted spouse and against an award of spousal support from the injured spouse’s separate property. The court could, where economic circumstances warrant, order attorney fees and costs incurred by the spouses to be paid from the community assets. In addition, the bill creates a presumption that, at the request of the injured spouse, the date of legal separation is the date of the incident giving rise to the conviction, or earlier, if the court finds circumstances that justify an earlier date.
The presumption can be rebutted by a preponderance of the evidence. In considering whether to rebut the presumption the court may consider any documented evidence that the convicted spouse was a victim of domestic violence by the injured spouse or any other factors the court deems just and reasonable. This is designed to help limit possible unintended consequences as a result of the bill and help limit the possible manipulation of this bill by a perpetrator of domestic violence who may try to use its provisions to further oppress the victim-spouse.
The bill, as proposed to be amended, also allows the court, without creating a presumption, to provide the injured spouse up to all of the community property interest in their retirement and pension benefits. In determining whether and how to apportion the community property interest in the injured spouse’s retirement and pension benefits, the court is required to consider all of the following factors:
- The misdemeanor domestic violence conviction, as well as documented evidence of other instances of domestic violence between the parties or perpetrated by either party against either party’s child, including, but not limited to, consideration of emotional distress resulting from domestic violence. The court must also consider documented evidence of a convicted spouse’s history as a victim of domestic violence perpetrated by the other spouse.
- The duration of the marriage and when, based on documented evidence, incidents of domestic violence occurred.
- The extent to which the convicted spouse's present or future earning capacity is impaired by periods of unemployment that were incurred during the marriage to permit the convicted spouse to devote time to domestic duties.
- The extent to which the convicted spouse contributed to the attainment of an education, training, a career position, or a license by the injured spouse.
- The balance of the hardships to each party.
- Any other factors the court determines are just and equitable.
These are similar to the factors that a court must consider when deciding on spousal support, but specifically tailored to domestic violence and other relevant issues to prevent an unjust result. These factors plus the fact that any adjustment of distribution of retirement benefits is not the result of a presumption, but up to the court to decide, on a case-by-case basis, should help limit the possible unintended consequences of the bill.
In addition, the bill, as proposed to be amended, is prospective only, so that spouses will be on notice that a conviction for domestic violence could cause them to lose certain rights and property that they would otherwise receive in a dissolution before any potential guilty plea or conviction.
Supporters, including many individuals, politicians, and political entities, believe that current law allows victims of domestic violence to be re-victimized. Santa Cruz County Supervisors Ryan Coonerty and Zach Friend write that the law today:
[F]unctions to financially disincentive victims from leaving abusive relationships even in instances where the abuser has been convicted of domestic violence. Although men are also victims, the data reflects that the vast majority of victims of domestic violence are women. As more and more women are earners and in fact the main breadwinners, it seems that it is time for the state to update its statutes to protect women and not put them in a position of being financial hostages to their abusive spouses. SB 1129 will go a long way towards solving this inequity and would open the door to freedom for untold numbers of women suffering in abusive relationships who are unable to leave because of very real and severe financial disincentives.
The Democratic Women’s Club of Santa Cruz County thinks that this bill could have a broader impact on domestic violence in general:
This bill serves not only to extend protections in existing law to a broader pool of domestic violence victims, but it also serves as an important vehicle to shine a light on the seriousness and pervasiveness of domestic violence at all levels of our society. Domestic violence is not an issue that is contained in subsets of economic and cultural niches but is one that is insidious and hides behind closed doors in homes across the state and nation. This bill is designed to help victims stand up, be heard, and escape abusive situations without jeopardizing their financial security in their twilight years.
Opponents are concerned that the bill will have unintended consequences and result in unwarranted hardships, even to victims of domestic violence. This bill is opposed, or opposed unless amended, by family law practitioners and the Judicial Council. The Family Law Section of the newly established California Lawyers Association (CLA) notes that the law already provides substantial protections for victims of domestic violence with regards to spousal support and attorney fees and believes that the felony mandate will have unintended consequences. CLA writes of a case of a woman who had experienced years of domestic abuse but never sought any protections from the law:
After enduring years of abuse, she finally broke down and threw a vase at her husband. Her husband sustained a minor injury, and immediately called law enforcement. He was issued a permanent restraining order and the wife was criminally prosecuted.
Under this or similar fact patterns, we believe a judicial officer should have discretion in not imposing the draconian effect of stripping the wife of her interest in husband’s pension plan. However, if a spouse is convicted of a felony as a result of a single incident of domestic abuse following years of provocation, that is exactly what would occur if SB 1129 is enacted as currently worded.
CLA also argue, as does the Judicial Council, below, that this bill will reduce the number of plea bargains in domestic violence cases – because of the financial impact of such a conviction – requiring victims to have to testify against their abusers in court (which many victims may well choose not to do). Additionally, CLA argues that forfeiture of community property as a deterrent to domestic violence could, depending on the facts of the case, be an unreasonable financial punishment that would violate the 14th Amendment’s due process protections. (See BMW of North America v. Gore (1996) 517 U.S. 559.) Finally, CLA notes that a victim of domestic violence has a tort claim against the abuser and could seek the same basic financial protections envisioned in this bill through an action in civil court, without disturbing California’s no-fault divorce system or causing other unintended consequences.
The Association of Certified Family Law Specialists echoes the concerns raised by CLA, writing: “SB 1129 is not only unnecessary and attempts to reintroduce fault into a no-fault divorce state, it will likely have the adverse effect of actually harming victims of domestic violence. . . . The bill could also lead a true abuser to bate a victim into an act of ‘retaliatory domestic violence’ in an attempt to ensure he did not have to pay spousal support in a long-term marriage or share his pension with his spouse.”
It should be noted that changes to the bill in the Senate Judiciary Committee, and as proposed to be amended in this Committee, should limit some of the bill’s possible unintended consequences by giving courts more discretion to make just and appropriate decisions that protects the parties, but these changes certainly cannot eliminate all such risks. Should this bill become law, it is hoped that judges exercise the discretion they are given to minimize any unintended consequences.
The Judicial Council opposes the bill, unless the misdemeanor provisions are removed. The Judicial Council is concerned about “the breath and lack of clarity” of those provisions, particularly with the types of misdemeanors included in the bill and how the five-year timeframe for the bill’s application is calculated. Court workload is also likely to increase, argues the Judicial Council, because there will be an increase in trials requested by domestic violence defendants and appeals for claims of ineffective assistance of counsel for those who failed to tell defendants about the financial risks, in an ensuing divorce, associated with entering a guilty or no contest plea.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
Congressman Sam Farr
Democratic Party of Santa Cruz
Democratic Women's Club of Santa Cruz County
Santa Cruz County Supervisor Ryan Coonerty
Santa Cruz County Supervisor Zach Friend
Santa Cruz Mayor Davis Terrazas
Walnut Avenue Family & Women’s Center
Women SV
Thirteen individuals
Opposition
Association of Certified Family Law Specialists
Family Law Section of the California Lawyers Association (unless amended)
Judicial Council (unless amended)
Analysis Prepared by:
Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | SB |
THIRD READING
Bill No: SB 1129
:
SENATE JUDICIARY COMMITTEE: 5-1, 5/8/18
AYES: Jackson, Hertzberg, Monning, Stern, Wieckowski
NOES: Anderson
NO VOTE RECORDED: Moorlach
DIGEST:
This bill reduces the scope of marital assets available to a spouse convicted of an act of domestic violence perpetrated against the other spouse within five years of a divorce proceeding. If the conviction was a felony, these reductions automatically apply. If the conviction was a misdemeanor, the reductions presumptively apply. This presumption may be rebutted with a showing of mitigating circumstances.
Existing law:
- Provides that when parties in a divorce proceeding request spousal support, the court may order either spouse to pay for the support of the other party an amount, for a period of time, that the court determines is just and reasonable, based on the standard of living established during the marriage, taking into consideration the specified circumstances. (Fam. Code Sec. 4330(a).)
- Requires a court, in ordering spousal support, to take many factors into consideration, including: the marketable skills of the supported party; the extent to which the supported party contributed to the earning capacity of the supporting party; the needs of each party; the obligations and assets of each party; evidence of any history of domestic violence between the two parties; and the criminal conviction of an abusive spouse. (Fam. Code Sec. 4320.)
- Provides, in addition to any other remedy, that when a spouse is convicted of attempting to murder the other spouse, or soliciting the murder of the other spouse, the convicted spouse is prohibited from receiving any temporary or permanent award of spousal, medical, life or other insurance benefits or payments from the injured spouse. (Fam. Code Sec. 4324.)
- Provides, in addition to any other remedy authorized by law, that when a spouse is convicted of attempting to murder the other spouse, or of soliciting the murder of that spouse, the injured spouse is entitled to all the community property interest in the retirement and pension benefits of the injured spouse. (Fam. Code Sec. 782.5.)
- Provides that in any proceeding for dissolution of a marriage, where there is a criminal conviction for a violent sexual felony perpetrated by one spouse against the other, an award of spousal support to the convicted spouse is prohibited. Existing law further authorizes a court, when one spouse is convicted of a violent sexual felony against the other, to order attorney fees be covered out of community property assets, set the date of separation at the point at which the incident giving rise to the conviction occurred, and award the injured spouse 100% of their interest in pension or retirement benefits. (Fam. Code Sec. 4324.5.)
- Creates a rebuttable presumption against an award for temporary or permanent spousal support to a spouse convicted of domestic violence against the other spouse within five years before filing for a dissolution of the marriage, or any time thereafter. (Fam. Code Sec. 4325.)
This bill:
- States that for a spouse who, within five years before a divorce proceeding, perpetrated a domestic violence felony against the other spouse, automatically imposes, in the ensuing divorce proceeding the following consequences:
- The court cannot award spousal support to the convicted spouse.
- If economic circumstances warrant, the court must order attorney’s fees and costs incurred by the parties to be paid from the community assets.
- At the election of the injured spouse, the court may set the date of legal separation at the date of the incident giving rise to the conviction, or earlier, if the court finds that circumstances justify an earlier date.
- The injured spouse is entitled to 100% of the community property interest in the retirement and pension benefits of the injured spouse.
- Provides that for a spouse who, within five years before a divorce proceeding, perpetrated a domestic violence misdemeanor against the other spouse, presumptively imposes, in the ensuing divorce proceeding, the same consequences described above, unless the court finds that imposing the consequences would not be just and equitable in light of the particular circumstances of the convicted spouse.
Background
This bill arises from cases in which courts in divorce proceedings ruled that spouses who were convicted of criminal acts of domestic violence were still entitled to a community property interest in the injured spouse’s retirement or pension benefits.
This result has occurred because existing law generally does not enable a court, in dividing assets and awarding spousal support, to take into account one spouse’s wrongdoing against the other, such as having an affair. However, in recent years, the Legislature has carved out exceptions to this general policy when the wrongdoing is especially harmful. In particular, for a divorce proceeding in which a spouse was, within five years of the divorce filing, convicted of a violent sexual felony perpetrated against the other spouse, all of the following apply: (1) the convicted spouse cannot receive spousal support; (2) the court may order that attorney fees be covered out of community property assets; (3) the injured spouse may elect to set the date of the legal separation to the point at which the incident giving rise to the conviction occurred, or earlier, if the court finds that circumstances justify an earlier date; and (4) the injured spouse is entitled to 100% of the community property interest in the spouse’s pension or retirement benefits. (Fam. Code Sec. 4324.5.)
This bill, with regard to the division of marital assets and awarding of spousal support, puts victims of domestic violence on the same footing as victims of sexually violent felonies. With regard to domestic violence felonies, these consequences apply as a matter of course. With regard to domestic violence misdemeanors, these consequences are subject to a rebuttable presumption.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: Fiscal Com.: Local:
Congressman Sam Farr
Walnut Avenue Family & Women’s Center
Women SV
Several individuals
OPPOSITION: (Verified 5/16/18)
Association of Certified Family Law Specialists
Family Violence Appellate Project
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: According to the author:
California is currently a “No-Fault Divorce” state, where existing law protects a spouse from having to show fault in their partner’s actions in order to end a marriage. California law, however, recognizes the unique need to protect the financial security of an individual who seeks a divorce because they are a victim of spousal abuse.
Current law gives a family court judge the discretion to consider a spouse’s history of domestic violence when determining spousal support, and provides for a rebuttal presumption against the awarding of spousal support to those who receive a conviction for domestic violence.
These protections, however, do not explicitly restrict a court’s ability to re-victimize a spouse by ordering them to financially support their domestic abuser; cover the cost of their domestic abuser’s attorney fees; or force them to give half of their pension and retirement savings to their abusive spouse.
Assembly Bill (AB) 1522 (Chapter 718, Statutes of 2012), took the first step in protecting abused spouses from being re-victimized by their former partners by prohibiting the courts from awarding spousal support, medical benefits, attorney’s fees, or any community property interest to a person that is convicted of a violent sexual felony against their spouse.
AB 1522 falls short, however, in protecting the vast majority of those who suffer domestic violence in a marriage, and creates an imbalance where victims of a “sexually” violent act by their spouse receive far greater protections from their abuser in divorce proceedings, than victims of all other acts of domestic violence.
SB 1129 will correct this shortcoming in the existing law, and will create parity in the laws protecting victims of violence by expanding the existing protections for victims of a violent sexual felony to all victims of domestic violence at the hands of their spouse.
Writing in support, former Congressman Sam Farr states:
California has provided leadership for many years on the issues of domestic violence. This bill represents another step in helping break the cycle of domestic violence and support the victim. With passage of this bill, the victim would have one less obstacle in leaving the abusive relationship and after they do, critical help in rebuilding their life. […] SB 1129 is seeking to address this same issue in a different way; allowing the victim to have the retirement security that they worked for throughout their careers while enduring the abuse. Equally important in this bill is the ability of the victim to seek an earlier date of separation; a date that recognizes that the true date of the ‘break in the marital relationship’ occurs when domestic violence is present. By acknowledging that domestic violence and the normal conduct of a marital relationship are not consistent, the bill provides another tool to aid the victims.
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION: Writing in opposition, the Association of Certified Family Law Specialists states as follows:
SB 1129 is not only unnecessary and attempts to reintroduce fault into a no-fault divorce state, it will likely have the adverse effect of actually harming victims of domestic violence. It will take away judicial discretion in awarding spousal support to true victims of domestic violence and will end up forcing victims of domestic violence to testify in every domestic violence case, as no alleged abuser will plead guilty to a lesser offense of domestic violence, due to a loss of property rights and support.
Additionally, the Family Violence Appellate Project, which supports some provisions of this bill and opposes others, has expressed concerns over the removal of judicial discretion, the reintroduction of fault into divorces, and potential unintended consequences, including the possibility that this bill could harm convicted spouses who are in actuality the abused spouse in the relationship
Prepared by: Josh Tosney / JUD. / (916) 651-4113
5/16/18 10:26:22
**** END ****
Senator Hannah-Beth Jackson, Chair
2017-2018 Regular Session
Bill No: SB 1129 (Author:Monning)
Version: February 13, 2018
Hearing Date: May 8, 2018
Fiscal: No
Urgency: No
Consultant: JDT
SUBJECT
Spousal support award: conviction for act of domestic violence
DESCRIPTION
Existing law requires that in any proceeding for dissolution of marriage where there is a criminal conviction for an act of domestic violence that occurred within five years before the filing of the dissolution, or at any time thereafter, there is a rebuttable presumption that any award of spousal support to the abusive spouse should not be made. This bill would: (1) eliminate the rebuttable presumption and altogether prohibit an award of spousal support to the abusive spouse; (2) require a court, if economic circumstances warrant, to order the attorney’s fees and costs incurred by the parties to be paid from the community assets; (3) provide that the date of legal separation is the date of the incident giving rise to the conviction, or earlier, if a court finds circumstances that justify an earlier date; and (4) provide that the injured spouse is entitled to 100 percent of the community property interest in the retirement and pension benefits of the injured spouse.
BACKGROUND
This bill arises from cases in which courts in divorce proceedings ruled that spouses who were convicted of criminal acts of domestic violence were still entitled to a community property interest in the injured spouse’s retirement or pension benefits.
This result has occurred because existing law generally does not enable a court, in dividing assets and awarding spousal support, to take into account one spouse’s wrongdoing against the other, such as having an affair. However, in recent years, the Legislature has carved out exceptions to this general policy when the wrongdoing is especially harmful. In particular, for a divorce proceeding in which a spouse was, within five years of the divorce filing, convicted of a violent sexual felony perpetrated against the other spouse, all of the following apply: (1) the convicted spouse cannot receive spousal support; (2) the court may order that attorney fees be covered out of community property assets; (3) the injured spouse may elect to set the date of the legal separation to the point at which the incident giving rise to the conviction occurred, or earlier, if the court finds that circumstances justify an earlier date; and (4) the injured spouse is entitled to 100 percent of the community property interest in the spouse’s pension or retirement benefits. (Fam. Code Sec. 4324.5.) This bill would, with regard to the division of marital assets and awarding of spousal support, put victims of domestic violence on the same footing as victims of sexually violent felonies.
CHANGES TO EXISTING LAW
Existing law provides that when parties in a divorce proceeding request spousal support, the court may order either spouse to pay for the support of the other party an amount, for a period of time, that the court determines is just and reasonable, based on the standard of living established during the marriage, taking into consideration the specified circumstances. (Fam. Code Sec. 4330(a).)
Existing law requires a court, in ordering spousal support, to take many factors into consideration, including: the marketable skills of the supported party; the extent to which the supported party contributed to the earning capacity of the supporting party; the needs of each party; the obligations and assets of each party; evidence of any history of domestic violence between the two parties; and the criminal conviction of an abusive spouse. (Fam. Code Sec. 4320.)
Existing law provides, in addition to any other remedy, that when a spouse is convicted of attempting to murder the other spouse, or soliciting the murder of the other spouse, the convicted spouse is prohibited from receiving any temporary or permanent award of spousal, medical, life or other insurance benefits or payments from the injured spouse. (Fam. Code Sec. 4324.)
Existing law provides, in addition to any other remedy authorized by law, that when a spouse is convicted of attempting to murder the other spouse, or of soliciting the murder of that spouse, the injured spouse is entitled to all the community property interest in the retirement and pension benefits of the injured spouse. (Fam. Code Sec. 782.5.)
Existing law provides that in any proceeding for dissolution of a marriage, where there is a criminal conviction for a violent sexual felony perpetrated by one spouse against the other, an award of spousal support to the convicted spouse is prohibited. Existing law further authorizes a court, when one spouse is convicted of a violent sexual felony against the other, to order attorney fees be covered out of community property assets, set the date of separation at the point at which the incident giving rise to the conviction occurred, and award the injured spouse 100 percent of their interest in pension or retirement benefits. (Fam. Code Sec. 4324.5.)
Existing law creates a rebuttable presumption against an award for temporary or permanent spousal support to a spouse convicted of domestic violence against the other spouse within five years before filing for a dissolution of the marriage, or any time thereafter. (Fam. Code Sec. 4325.)
This bill would additionally: (1) eliminate the rebuttable presumption and altogether prohibit an award of spousal support to the abusive spouse; (2) require a court, if economic circumstances warrant, to order the attorney’s fees and costs incurred by the parties to be paid from the community assets; (3) provide that the date of legal separation may be, at the election of the injured spouse, the date of the incident giving rise to the conviction, or earlier, if the court finds that circumstances justify an earlier date; and (4) provide that the injured spouse is entitled to 100 percent of the community property interest in the retirement and pension benefits of the injured spouse.
COMMENT
- Stated need for the bill
According to the author:
California is currently a “No-Fault Divorce” state, where existing law protects a spouse from having to show fault in their partner’s actions in order to end a marriage. California law, however, recognizes the unique need to protect the financial security of an individual who seeks a divorce because they are a victim of spousal abuse.
Current law gives a family court judge the discretion to consider a spouse’s history of domestic violence when determining spousal support, and provides for a rebuttal presumption against the awarding of spousal support to those who receive a conviction for domestic violence.
These protections, however, do not explicitly restrict a court’s ability to re-victimize a spouse by ordering them to financially support their domestic abuser; cover the cost of their domestic abuser’s attorney fees; or force them to give half of their pension and retirement savings to their abusive spouse.
Assembly Bill (AB) 1522 (Chapter 718, Statutes of 2012), took the first step in protecting abused spouses from being re-victimized by their former partners by prohibiting the courts from awarding spousal support, medical benefits, attorney’s fees, or any community property interest to a person that is convicted of a violent sexual felony against their spouse.
AB 1522 falls short, however, in protecting the vast majority of those who suffer domestic violence in a marriage, and creates an imbalance where victims of a “sexually” violent act by their spouse receive far greater protections from their abuser in divorce proceedings, than victims of all other acts of domestic violence.
SB 1129 will correct this shortcoming in the existing law, and will create parity in the laws protecting victims of violence by expanding the existing protections for victims of a violent sexual felony to all victims of domestic violence at the hands of their spouse.
Writing in further support, former Congressman Sam Farr states:
California has provided leadership for many years on the issues of domestic violence. This bill represents another step in helping break the cycle of domestic violence and support the victim. With passage of this bill, the victim would have one less obstacle in leaving the abusive relationship and after they do, critical help in rebuilding their life. […] SB 1129 is seeking to address this same issue in a different way; allowing the victim to have the retirement security that they worked for throughout their careers while enduring the abuse. Equally important in this bill is the ability of the victim to seek an earlier date of separation; a date that recognizes that the true date of the ‘break in the marital relationship’ occurs when domestic violence is present. By acknowledging that domestic violence and the normal conduct of a marital relationship are not consistent, the bill provides another tool to aid the victims.
- “No-fault” divorce system in California
By limiting the financial support a victim spouse must provide to a spouse convicted of domestic violence, this bill would create yet another exception to the general policy of “no-fault” divorce in California. A no-fault divorce policy allows either party to file for dissolution without the need to prove fault by the other spouse. An article from the Cincinnati Law Review describes the importance of the no-fault divorce system for women:
Having to prove grounds in order to obtain a divorce was traditionally mired with rigid hierarchical notions of male and female gender roles, and divorce has too often been awarded in a discriminatory fashion. Moreover, feminists aspiring to formal equality and fighting women’s traditional dependence on men have supported allowing either party to a marriage to exit if they so choose without having to prove or contrive the existence of fault. (Laufer-Ukeles, Pamela, Reconstructing Fault: the Case for Spousal Torts, (2010) 79 U. Cin. L. Rev. 207.)
Thus, to obtain a divorce under California law, a party is not required to show wrongdoing by the other party, such as an affair. Such wrongdoing may be remedied in civil or criminal courts. (See Marriage of Askmo (2000) 85 Cal.4th 1032.)
The principle that a court does not look to the relative culpability of the parties in a divorce proceeding generally applies to the division of marital assets and debts, as well as to the provision of spousal support. Existing law provides that all property, whether real or personal, acquired by a married person during the marriage while domiciled in this state is community property. (Fam. Code Sec. 760.) Existing law also provides that the community estate is liable for a debt incurred by either spouse, as specified. (Fam. Code Sec. 910.) Existing law further provides that absent prior agreement, upon dissolution, the court must divide the community estate equally. (Fam. Code Sec. 2550.) This policy was established to recognize the equal contributions of both spouses to the family unit, and historically has provided for an arguably more just division of property for families where one spouse earns more income than the other.
Likewise, courts are required to order spousal support in an amount and for a period of time that the court determines is just and reasonable, based on the standard of living established during the marriage. (Fam. Code Sec. 4330(a).) In making spousal support awards, the court is required to consider, among other factors, the marketable skills of each party, the parties’ ability to pay spousal support, the needs of each party, the assets of each party, and the ability of each party to engage in employment considering the interests of dependent children. (Fam. Code Sec. 4320.)
However, in some cases, existing law apportions community assets and spousal support based on the wrongdoing of one spouse against the other. For instance, a spouse convicted of attempted murder of the other spouse cannot receive spousal, medical, life, or other insurance benefits from the injured spouse (Fam. Code Sec. 4324), and the injured spouse is entitled to all community property interest in the retirement and pension benefits of the injured spouse (Fam. Code Sec. 782.5). For a divorce proceeding in which a spouse was convicted of a violent sexual felony perpetrated against the other spouse, all of the following apply: (1) the convicted spouse cannot receive spousal support; (2) the court may order that attorney fees be covered out of community property assets; (3) the injured spouse may elect to set the date of the legal separation to the point at which the incident giving rise to the conviction occurred, or earlier, if the court finds that circumstances justify an earlier date; and (4) the injured spouse is entitled to 100 percent of the community property interest in the spouse’s pension or retirement benefits. (Fam. Code Sec. 4324.5.) And in making spousal support awards, courts are also required to consider any evidence of any history of domestic violence between the two parties, as well as the criminal conviction of an abusive spouse. (Fam. Code Sec. 4320.) Finally, a spouse convicted of domestic violence presumptively forfeits the right to spousal support. (Fam. Code Sec. 4325.) These exceptions recognize that the “no-fault” system can be especially injurious to victims of violence, particularly those who are the higher earner in the relationship, by forcing the victim to provide continued financial support for the abuser.
- Reducing the convicted spouse’s community property interests
Existing law protects a spouse that is the victim of domestic violence from providing spousal support to the spouse convicted of domestic violence, unless the court finds that the unique circumstances justify awarding spousal support, as specified. (Fam. Code Sec. 4320.) However, under existing law, the convicted spouse is still entitled to their share of community property, including a community property interest in the retirement or pension of the victim spouse.
This bill would reduce the community property interests that the convicted spouse is entitled to. First, the bill would enable the injured spouse to request that the date of separation be deemed to be the date at which the incident giving rise to the conviction, or earlier if the court finds that doing so is justified. This means that assets and debts acquired after that date would not be community property, if the injured spouse so chooses. As a result, the injured spouse would be entitled to choose to avoid certain debts of the convicted spouse, and to keep the injured spouse’s earnings, investments, and other property acquired after the incident giving rise to the conviction, if dissolution is filed within the specified time period. Second, the bill would provide that the injured spouse is entitled to 100 percent of the injured spouse’s retirement or pension benefits, denying the convicted spouse access to property interests that could have begun accruing well before the separation date.
These reductions in a spouse’s community property interests mirror the reductions in existing law applicable to spouses convicted of violent sexual felonies perpetrated against their spouse. Arguably, such provisions offer further protections for an injured spouse and promote independence from the convicted spouse by enabling the injured spouse to choose to classify all property acquired after the date of the violent sexual felony as separate property.
It is important to note that a court would apply the bill’s changes prospectively, as there is a presumption against retroactive application of a statute unless the Legislature has clearly directed otherwise. (Quarry v. Doe I (2012) 53 Cal.4th 945, 955.) Furthermore, a retroactive reallocation of property interests implicates due process concerns, and courts, must construe statute in manner that preserves their constitutionality. (See e.g. Kunde v. Seiler (2011) 197 Cal.App.4th 518, 530.)
- Judicial discretion
Because of the complexity of factors and the unique circumstance of parties and families involved in divorce proceedings, several existing laws afford courts discretion to fashion equitable results that fit the facts of a given case. With regard to dissolutions in which one spouse was convicted of domestic violence within five years of the filing, existing law establishes a presumption that spousal support should not be awarded. (Fam. Code Sec. 4325(a).) This presumption may be rebutted if, by a preponderance of evidence, the convicted spouse shows factors that persuade the court that awarding spousal support would be just and equitable. (Fam. Code Sec. 4325(a).) Existing law expressly recognizes that one such factor may be the convicted spouse’s history as a victim of domestic violence. (Fam. Code Sec. 4325(b).) Thus, if a spouse who had repeatedly been a victim of domestic abuse retaliated against the abusive spouse and was convicted of an act of domestic violence for that retaliation, a court has the flexibility to account for those mitigating circumstances by awarding spousal support to the convicted spouse. By building in flexibility for a judge to take into account unforeseeable circumstances, the Legislature may reduce the risk of being overly prescriptive in a manner that yields unintended and undesirable consequences.
This bill would, however, eliminate the rebuttable presumption applicable to spousal support awards to spouses convicted of domestic violence, thus requiring a court to deny spousal support, and enabling the injured spouse to reduce the scope of community property, regardless of the circumstances. This mirrors the approach the Legislature has adopted with regard to dissolutions involving a spouse who has perpetrated a violent sexual felony against the other spouse. Some actions are so heinous that they always warrant such treatment.
But criminal acts of domestic violence span a broad range of conduct that, in some cases, may not justify the harsh result that this bill would impose. The example above of a spouse who was convicted for retaliating against an abusive spouse may be one such example. By restricting a court’s discretion to consider the parties’ unique situations, this bill could create unintended and undesirable consequences.
- Opposition
Writing in opposition, the Association of Certified Family Law Specialists states as follows:
SB 1129 is not only unnecessary and attempts to reintroduce fault into a no-fault divorce state, it will likely have the adverse effect of actually harming victims of domestic violence. It will take away judicial discretion in awarding spousal support to true victims of domestic violence and will end up forcing victims of domestic violence to testify in every domestic violence case, as no alleged abuser will plead guilty to a lesser offense of domestic violence, due to a loss of property rights and support.
Additionally, the Family Violence Appellate Project, which supports some provisions of the bill and opposes others, has expressed concerns over the removal of judicial discretion, the reintroduction of fault into divorces, and potential unintended consequences, including the possibility that the bill could harm convicted spouses who are in actuality the abused spouse in the relationship.
- Amendments
To avoid the potential unintended, inequitable results discussed in Comment 4, and to address some of the concerns expressed by the opposition, the author has agreed to amend the bill to distinguish between the most severe forms of domestic violence and the less severe forms. This change would treat the former the same as sexually violent felonies, while preserving judicial discretion with regard to the latter. Under these amendments, felony convictions for acts of domestic violence would be integrated into the existing framework applicable to sexually violent felonies. Meanwhile, for misdemeanor convictions for acts of domestic violence, or for other misdemeanors for which probation was granted where the victim was a victim of domestic violence, the rebuttable presumption would be restored in order to enable a court to arrive to a just and equitable result that fits the unique circumstances that may arise.
Thus, under these amendments, if one spouse, within five years before a divorce filing, perpetrated a domestic violence felony against the other, then, in the ensuing proceeding, all of the following would automatically apply: (1) a court could not award spousal support to the abusive spouse; (2) the court would be required, if economic circumstances warrant, to order the attorney’s fees and costs incurred by the parties to be paid from the community assets; (3) the date of legal separation would be set, at the election of the injured spouse, at the date of the incident giving rise to the conviction, or earlier, if the court finds that circumstances justify an earlier date; and (4) the injured spouse would be entitled to 100 percent of the community property interest in the retirement and pension benefits of the injured spouse. Domestic violence felonies would thus be treated the same as sexually violent felonies in the context of divorces.
If, however, one spouse perpetrates a domestic violence misdemeanor against the other, then, in a dissolution proceeding, the same consequences would presumptively apply, unless the court finds that imposing the consequences would not be just and equitable in light of the particular circumstances of a convicted spouse.
Finally, to avoid potential confusion about the application of Section 4325, the author has agreed to strike the phrase “or at any time thereafter” beginning on line 7 of page 2.
Support: Congressman Sam Farr; Walnut Avenue Family & Women’s Center; Women SV; over 10 individuals
Opposition: Association of Certified Family Law Specialists; Family Violence Appellate Project
HISTORY
Source: Author
Related Pending Legislation: AB 929 (Rubio, 2017) would require a court, in determining an award of spousal support, to consider all documented evidence of any history of domestic violence.
Prior Legislation:
SB 28 (Wieckowski, Ch. 137, Stats. 2015) included, among documented evidence of domestic violence a court must consider in awarding spousal support, a plea of nolo contendere.
AB 681 (Melendez and Skinner, Ch. 455, Stats. 2013) required the court to consider domestic violence perpetrated by either party against either party’s child when determining spousal support.
AB 1522 (Atkins, Ch. 718, Stats. 2012) prohibited an award of spousal support to a spouse convicted of a violent sexual felony against the other spouse, as specified.
AB 2674 (Block, Ch. 65, Stats. 2010) prohibits an award of spousal support to a spouse convicted of soliciting the murder of the other spouse, as specified.
AB 16 (Rainey, Ch. 364, Stats. of 1995) provides that when a spouse is convicted of attempting to murder the other spouse, as specified, the injured spouse shall be entitled to 100 percent of the community property interest in the injured spouse’s retirement and pension benefits, and a prohibition of specified support or insurance benefits from the injured spouse to the other spouse, as specified.
**************
Discussed in Hearing
Senate Floor
Assembly Floor
Senate Floor
Senate Standing Committee on Judiciary
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):