AB 1757: Accessibility: internet websites.
- Session Year: 2023-2024
- House: Assembly
- Latest Version Date: 2024-06-12
Current Status:
Failed
(2024-08-15: In committee: Held under submission.)
Introduced
In Committee
First Chamber
In Committee
Second Chamber
Enacted
The Unruh Civil Rights Act (Unruh Act) requires persons within the jurisdiction of the state to be free and equal and, regardless of the persons sex, race, color, religion, ancestry, national origin, disability, medical condition, genetic information, marital status, sexual orientation, citizenship, primary language, or immigration status to be entitled to the full and equal accommodations, advantages, facilities, privileges, or services in all business establishments, as prescribed, and makes a violation of the federal Americans with Disabilities Act of 1990 (ADA) a violation of the act.
Existing law imposes liability upon a person who denies, aids, or incites a denial of, or makes any discrimination or distinction contrary to, rights afforded by law for actual damages suffered, exemplary damages, a civil penalty, and attorneys fees, as specified, to any person who was denied the specified rights. Existing law also imposes liability upon a person, firm, or corporation that denies or interferes with admittance to, or enjoyment of, public facilities or otherwise interferes with the rights of an individual with a disability, as specified, for damages and attorneys fees to a person who was denied those rights.
This bill would provide that statutory damages based upon the inaccessibility of on the basis of a specific accessibility barrier on an internet website under these provisions shall only be recovered against an entity, as defined, if the internet website fails to provide equally effective communication or facilitate full and equal enjoyment of the entitys goods and services to all members of the public. is not accessible, as defined. The bill would require, in order for a plaintiff to be entitled to statutory damages for internet website inaccessibility, on the basis of a specific accessibility barrier that constitutes a violation of the Unruh Act by violating the ADA, the plaintiff to prove either that the plaintiff personally encountered a specific barrier that caused the plaintiff to experience a difference in the plaintiffs access to, or use of, the internet website as compared to other users, as specified, users because the internet website was not accessible or that the plaintiff was deterred from accessing or using all or part of the internet website or the content of the internet website because of the internet websites failure to provide equally effective communication or to facilitate full and equal enjoyment of the entitys goods and services offered to the public. The bill would provide that an entitys internet website is presumed to provide equally effective communication and to facilitate full and equal enjoyment of the entitys goods and services to all members of the public for the purpose of determining whether an award of statutory damages is warranted, as specified, if the internet website has a certain certification by a professional reviewer, as defined, that, among other things, the internet website is designed and intended to conform to the internet website-related accessibility standard, as defined. the internet website was not accessible. The bill would prohibit, in a civil action seeking statutory damages under the Unruh Act and the other provisions described above therewith on the basis of a specific accessibility barrier, as defined, on an entitys internet website that is a violation of the ADA, the entity from being liable for those damages if the entity establishes, as an affirmative defense to the claim, certain elements, including that the entity identified the specific accessibility barrier in a digital accessibility report posted on the accessibility page, as specified, of its internet website.
This bill would make it unlawful for a resource service provider, as defined, in exchange for remuneration, to intentionally, negligently, recklessly, or knowingly construct, license, distribute, or maintain for online use an internet website that fails to provide equally effective communication or fails to facilitate full and equal enjoyment of the entitys goods and services to all members of the public, including any member of the public who is a person with a disability. is not accessible or any resource or part of an internet website that, when used by the entity in accordance with any instructions provided by the resource provider, causes an entitys internet website to be inaccessible. The bill would also make it unlawful for a resource provider to intentionally, negligently, knowingly, or recklessly make certain false representations, including that the resource provider is a professional reviewer or otherwise qualified to assess the accessibility of an internet website. internet website is accessible or conforms to the internet website accessibility standard, as defined. The bill would authorize a civil action by a person by, among others, an individual or entity that pays, compensates, or contracts with a resource service provider to construct, license, distribute, or maintain an internet website for the purpose of providing equally effective communication or facilitating full and equal enjoyment of the person or entitys goods and services to all members of the public, including any member of the public who is a person with a disability, that is accessible who is injured as a result of the defendants violation of the bill and reasonably relied upon the resource provider to ensure that the internet website, or a part of the internet website, is accessible, with remedies as prescribed. The bill would also authorize the Attorney General, the Civil Rights Department, or a district attorney, county counsel, or city attorney to bring an action to obtain injunctive or declaratory relief and attorneys fees and costs. The bill would provide provide, subject to an exception, that a provision within a contract between a person an individual or entity and a resource service provider that seeks to waive liability under these provisions, or otherwise shift liability to a person or entity that pays, compensates, or contracts with the resource provider, as provided, is void as a matter of public policy and subject to specified provisions of the Ralph Civil Rights Act of 1976 relating to waiver of rights.
Existing law imposes liability upon a person who denies, aids aids, or incites a denial, denial of, or makes any discrimination or distinction contrary to to, rights afforded by law, law for actual damages suffered, exemplary damages, a civil penalty, and attorneys fees, as specified, to any person who was denied the specified rights. Existing law also imposes liability upon a person, firm, or corporation that denies or interferes with admittance to to, or enjoyment of of, public facilities or otherwise interferes with the rights of an individual with a disability, as specified, for damages and attorneys fees to a person who was denied those rights.
This bill would specify provide that statutory damages based upon the inaccessibility of an internet website under these provisions shall only be recovered against an entity, as defined, if the internet website fails to provide equally effective communication or facilitate full and equal enjoyment of the entitys goods and services to all members of the public. The bill would require, in order for a plaintiff to be entitled to statutory damages for internet website inaccessibility, the plaintiff to prove either that they the plaintiff personally encountered a specific barrier that caused them the plaintiff to experience a difference in their the plaintiffs access to, or use of, the internet website as compared to other users, as specified, or that they were the plaintiff was deterred from accessing all or part of the internet website or the content of the internet website because of the internet websites failure to provide equally effective communication or to facilitate full and equal enjoyment of the entitys goods and services offered to the public. The bill would specify provide that an entitys internet website is presumed to provide equally effective communication and to facilitate full and equal enjoyment of the entitys goods and services to all members of the public for the purpose of determining whether an award of statutory damages is warranted, as specified, if the internet website, taking into account the variety of conforming implementations that may be used to meet the internet website-related accessibility standard, conforms to an internet website-related accessibility standard, as defined. the internet website has a certain certification by a professional reviewer, as defined, that, among other things, the internet website is designed and intended to conform to the internet website-related accessibility standard, as defined.
This bill would make it unlawful for any a resource service provider, as defined, in exchange for remuneration, to intentionally, negligently, recklessly, or knowingly construct, license, distribute, or maintain for online use, use an internet website that fails to conform to the internet website-related accessibility standard or provide equally effective communication or fails to facilitate full and equal enjoyment of the entitys goods and services to all members of the public, including any member of the public who is a person with a disability. The bill would also make it unlawful for a resource provider to intentionally, negligently, knowingly, or recklessly make a certain false representation that an internet website conforms to the internet website-related accessibility standard. representations, including that the resource provider is a professional reviewer or otherwise qualified to assess the accessibility of an internet website. The bill would authorize a civil action by a person who is unable to obtain equally effective communication or full and equal enjoyment of an internet website, the content of an internet website, or goods and services offered to the public on an internet website, as a result of that violation, with remedies as prescribed. The bill would further authorize a civil action by a person or entity that pays, compensates, or contracts with a resource service provider to construct, license, distribute, or maintain an internet website for the purpose of providing equally effective communication or facilitating full and equal enjoyment of the person or entitys goods and services to all members of the public, including any member of the public who is a person with a disability, with remedies as prescribed. The bill would also authorize the Attorney General General, the Civil Rights Department, or a district attorney, county counsel, or city attorney to bring an action to obtain injunctive or declaratory relief and attorneys fees and costs. The bill would provide that a provision within a contract between a person or entity and a resource service provider that seeks to waive liability under these provisions, or otherwise shift liability to a person or entity that pays, compensates, or contracts with the resource provider, as provided, is void as a matter of public policy and subject to specified provisions of the Ralph Civil Rights Act of 1976 relating to waiver of rights.
Existing law imposes liability upon a person who denies, aids or incites a denial, or makes any discrimination or distinction contrary to rights afforded by law, for actual damages suffered, exemplary damages, a civil penalty, and attorneys fees, as specified, to any person who was denied the specified rights. Existing law also imposes liability upon a person, firm, or corporation that denies or interferes with admittance to or enjoyment of public facilities or otherwise interferes with the rights of an individual with a disability, as specified, for damages and attorneys fees to a person who was denied those rights.
This bill would specify that statutory damages based upon the inaccessibility of an internet website under these provisions shall only be recovered against an entity, as defined, if the internet website fails to provide equally effective communication or facilitate full and equal enjoyment of the entitys goods and services to all members of the public. The bill would require, in order for a plaintiff to be entitled to statutory damages for internet website inaccessibility, the plaintiff to prove either that they personally encountered a barrier that caused them to experience a difference in their access to, or use of, the website as compared to other users, as specified, or that they were deterred from accessing all or part of the internet website or the content of the website because of the websites failure to provide equally effective communication or to facilitate full and equal enjoyment of the entitys goods and services offered to the public. The bill would specify that an internet website is presumed to provide equally effective communication for the purpose of determining whether an award of statutory damages is warranted, as specified, if the internet website, taking into account the variety of conforming implementations that may be used to meet the internet website-related accessibility standard, conforms to an internet website-related accessibility standard, as defined.
This bill would make it unlawful for any resource service provider, in exchange for remuneration, to intentionally, negligently, or knowingly construct, license, distribute, or maintain for online use, an internet website that fails to conform to the internet website-related accessibility standard or to intentionally, negligently, or recklessly make a false representation that an internet website conforms to the internet website-related accessibility standard. The bill would authorize a civil action by a person who is unable to obtain equally effective communication or full and equal enjoyment of an internet website, the content of an internet website, or goods and services offered to the public on an internet website, as a result of that violation, with remedies as prescribed. The bill would further authorize a civil action by a person or entity that pays, compensates, or contracts with a resource service provider to construct, license, distribute, or maintain an internet website for the purpose of providing equally effective communication or facilitating full and equal enjoyment of the person or entitys goods and services to all members of the public, including any member of the public who is a person with a disability, with remedies as prescribed. The bill would also authorize the Attorney General or a district attorney, county counsel, or city attorney to bring an action to obtain injunctive or declaratory relief and attorneys fees and costs. The bill would provide that a provision within a contract between a person or entity and a resource service provider that seeks to waive liability under these provisions, or otherwise shift liability to a person or entity that pays, compensates, or contracts with the resource provider, as provided, is void as a matter of public policy and subject to specified provisions of the Ralph Civil Rights Act of 1976 relating to waiver of rights.
Existing law imposes liability upon a person who denies, aids or incites a denial, or makes any discrimination or distinction contrary to rights afforded by law, for actual damages suffered, exemplary damages, a civil penalty, and attorneys fees, as specified, to any person who was denied the specified rights. Existing law also imposes liability upon a person, firm, or corporation that denies or interferes with admittance to or enjoyment of public facilities or otherwise interferes with the rights of an individual with a disability, as specified, for damages and attorneys fees to a person who was denied those rights.
This bill would specify that statutory damages based upon the inaccessibility of an internet website under these provisions shall only be recovered against an entity, as defined, if the internet website fails to provide equally effective communication or facilitate full and equal enjoyment of the entitys goods and services to all members of the public. The bill would require, in order for a plaintiff to be entitled to statutory damages for internet website inaccessibility, the plaintiff to prove either that they personally encountered a barrier that caused them to experience a difference in their access to, or use of, the website as compared to other users, as specified, or that they were deterred from accessing all or part of the internet website or the content of the website because of the websites failure to provide equally effective communication or to facilitate full and equal enjoyment of the entitys goods and services offered to the public. The bill would specify that an internet website is presumed to provide equally effective communication for the purpose of determining whether an award of minimum statutory damages is warranted, as specified, if the internet website, taking into account the variety of conforming implementations that may be used to meet the internet website-related accessibility standard, complies with conforms to an internet website-related accessibility standard, as defined.
This bill would make it unlawful for any resource service provider, in exchange for remuneration, to intentionally intentionally, negligently, or knowingly construct, license, distribute, or maintain for online use, an internet website that fails to comply with conform to the internet website-related accessibility standard. standard or to intentionally, negligently, or recklessly make a false representation that an internet website conforms to the internet website-related accessibility standard. The bill would authorize a civil action by a person who is unable to obtain equally effective communication or full and equal enjoyment of an internet website, the content of an internet website, or goods and services offered to the public on an internet website, as a result of the failure of an internet website to meet the internet website-related accessibility standard, that violation, with remedies as prescribed. The bill would further authorize a civil action by a person or entity that pays, compensates, or contracts with a resource service provider to construct, license, distribute, or maintain an internet website for the purpose of providing equally effective communication or facilitating full and equal enjoyment of the person or entitys goods and services to all members of the public, including any member of the public who is disabled, a person with a disability, with remedies as prescribed. The bill would also authorize the Attorney General or a district attorney, county counsel, or city attorney to bring an action to obtain injunctive or declaratory relief and attorneys fees and costs. The bill would provide that a provision within a contract between a person or entity and a resource service provider that seeks to waive liability under these provisions provisions, or otherwise shift liability to a person or entity that pays, compensates, or contracts with the resource provider, as provided, is void as a matter of public policy and subject to specified provisions of the Ralph Civil Rights Act of 1976 relating to waiver of rights.
Existing law imposes liability upon a person who denies, aids or incites a denial, or makes any discrimination or distinction contrary to rights afforded by law, for actual damages suffered, exemplary damages, a civil penalty, and attorneys fees, as specified, to any person who was denied the specified rights. Existing law also imposes liability upon a person, firm, or corporation that denies or interferes with admittance to or enjoyment of public facilities or otherwise interferes with the rights of an individual with a disability, as specified, for damages and attorneys fees to a person who was denied those rights.
This bill would specify that statutory damages based upon the inaccessibility of an internet website under these provisions shall only be recovered against an entity, as defined, if the internet website fails to provide equally effective communication or facilitate full and equal enjoyment of the entitys goods and services to all members of the public. The bill would require, in order for a plaintiff to be entitled to statutory damages for internet website inaccessibility, the plaintiff to prove either that they personally encountered a barrier that caused them to experience a difference in their access to, or use of, the website as compared to other users, as specified, or that they were deterred from accessing all or part of the internet website or the content of the website because of the websites failure to provide equally effective communication or to facilitate full and equal enjoyment of the entitys goods and services offered to the public. The bill would specify that an internet website is presumed to provide equally effective communication for the purpose of determining whether an award of minimum statutory damages is warranted, as specified, if the internet website, taking into account the variety of conforming implementations that may be used to meet the internet website-related accessibility standard, complies with an internet website-related accessibility standard, as defined.
This bill would make it unlawful for any resource service provider, in exchange for remuneration, to intentionally or knowingly construct, license, distribute, or maintain for online use, an internet website that fails to comply with the internet website-related accessibility standard. The bill would authorize a civil action by a person who is unable to obtain equally effective communication or full and equal enjoyment of an internet website, the content of an internet website, or goods and services offered to the public on an internet website, as a result of the failure of an internet website to meet the internet website-related accessibility standard, with remedies as prescribed. The bill would further authorize a civil action by a person or entity that pays, compensates, or contracts with a resource service provider to construct, license, distribute, or maintain an internet website for the purpose of providing equally effective communication or facilitating full and equal enjoyment of the person or entitys goods and services to all members of the public, including any member of the public who is disabled, with remedies as prescribed. The bill would also authorize the Attorney General or a district attorney, county counsel, or city attorney to bring an action to obtain injunctive or declaratory relief and attorneys fees and costs. The bill would provide that a provision within a contract between a person or entity and a resource service provider that seeks to waive liability under these provisions is subject to specified provisions of the Ralph Civil Rights Act of 1976 relating to waiver of rights.
(1)Existing law, upon request of any judge of the superior or municipal court, requires the district attorney to appear for and represent the court or judge if the court or judge in their official capacity is a party defendant in any action. Existing law, if requested to do so by the superior court of the county of the county counsel, or by any judge thereof, and insofar as those duties are not in conflict with, and do not interfere with, other duties, with specified exceptions, authorizes the county counsel to represent any such court or judge thereof in all matters and questions of law pertaining to any of the judges duties. Existing law specifies that if, because of a declared conflict of interest, any judge, who is otherwise entitled to representation, is required to retain their own counsel, the judge is entitled to recover from the appropriate public entity the reasonable attorneys fees, costs, and expenses as were necessarily incurred thereby.Existing law, the Government Claims Act, requires the Judicial Council to provide for representation, defense, and indemnification of judges, subordinate judicial officers, court executive officers of the superior courts, and the court. The act authorizes a county to insure any officer or attache of its superior and municipal courts against all or any part of the officer or attaches liability for injury resulting from any act or omission in the scope of the officer or attaches employment.Existing law, the State Bar Act, requires the State Bar to, among other things, notify specified individuals and entities of a lawyers involuntary enrollment as an inactive licensee and termination of that enrollment, or any suspension or disbarment, and the reinstatement to active license of a suspended or disbarred attorney.Existing law prescribes the salaries and compensation for judges and establishes the Trial Court Employment Protection and Governance Act, which, among other things, governs the authority to regulate court employee classification and compensation, labor relations, employment protection, and retirement. Existing law provides county-specific requirements with respect to the benefits and compensation of municipal court judges and organization of certain municipal courts, and requires parity of benefits between municipal court judges and superior court judges.Proposition 220, approved by voters at the June 2, 1998, statewide primary election, consolidated the superior and municipal courts, as specified. This bill would amend these provisions to conform with the unification of municipal and superior courts and would make related changes with respect to employees of superior courts in specified counties and to judicial officers and their duties, including insuring judicial officers and the representation and indemnification of judicial officers and related expenses. This bill would, effective January 1, 2074, repeal those provisions relating to judicial compensation and benefits for specified municipal courts.(2)Existing law subjects certain property to forfeiture, including controlled substances and equipment used to process controlled substances, and requires a petition of forfeiture to be filed with the superior court of the county in which a defendant has been charged with the underlying criminal offense. A person with an interest in the seized property may file a claim with that court stating their interest.This bill would specify that these petitions and claims are unlimited civil cases.(3)The bill also makes technical, conforming, and nonsubstantive changes to various provisions.(1)Existing law, upon request of any judge of the superior or municipal court, requires the district attorney to appear for and represent the court or judge if the court or judge in their official capacity is a party defendant in any action. Existing law, if requested to do so by the superior court of the county of the county counsel, or by any judge thereof, and insofar as those duties are not in conflict with, and do not interfere with, other duties, with specified exceptions, authorizes the county counsel to represent any such court or judge thereof in all matters and questions of law pertaining to any of the judges duties. Existing law specifies that if, because of a declared conflict of interest, any judge, who is otherwise entitled to representation, is required to retain their own counsel, the judge is entitled to recover from the appropriate public entity the reasonable attorneys fees, costs, and expenses as were necessarily incurred thereby.
Existing law, the Government Claims Act, requires the Judicial Council to provide for representation, defense, and indemnification of judges, subordinate judicial officers, court executive officers of the superior courts, and the court. The act authorizes a county to insure any officer or attache of its superior and municipal courts against all or any part of the officer or attaches liability for injury resulting from any act or omission in the scope of the officer or attaches employment.
Existing law, the State Bar Act, requires the State Bar to, among other things, notify specified individuals and entities of a lawyers involuntary enrollment as an inactive licensee and termination of that enrollment, or any suspension or disbarment, and the reinstatement to active license of a suspended or disbarred attorney.
Existing law prescribes the salaries and compensation for judges and establishes the Trial Court Employment Protection and Governance Act, which, among other things, governs the authority to regulate court employee classification and compensation, labor relations, employment protection, and retirement. Existing law provides county-specific requirements with respect to the benefits and compensation of municipal court judges and organization of certain municipal courts, and requires parity of benefits between municipal court judges and superior court judges.
Proposition 220, approved by voters at the June 2, 1998, statewide primary election, consolidated the superior and municipal courts, as specified.
This bill would amend these provisions to conform with the unification of municipal and superior courts and would make related changes with respect to employees of superior courts in specified counties and to judicial officers and their duties, including insuring judicial officers and the representation and indemnification of judicial officers and related expenses. This bill would, effective January 1, 2074, repeal those provisions relating to judicial compensation and benefits for specified municipal courts.
(2)Existing law subjects certain property to forfeiture, including controlled substances and equipment used to process controlled substances, and requires a petition of forfeiture to be filed with the superior court of the county in which a defendant has been charged with the underlying criminal offense. A person with an interest in the seized property may file a claim with that court stating their interest.
This bill would specify that these petitions and claims are unlimited civil cases.
(3)The bill also makes technical, conforming, and nonsubstantive changes to various provisions.
(a)Statutory damages under subdivision (a) of either Section 52 or Section 54.3 shall only be recovered against an entity based upon the inaccessibility of on the basis of a specific accessibility barrier on an internet website that is developed, procured, maintained, or used by that entity if the internet website fails to provide equally effective communication or facilitate full and equal enjoyment of the entitys goods and services to all members of the public, including any member of the public who is a person with a disability. is not accessible.
(b)To be entitled to statutory damages for internet website inaccessibility, on the basis of a specific accessibility barrier that constitutes a violation of subdivision (f) of Section 51, a plaintiff shall prove one either of the following:
(1)That the plaintiff personally encountered a specific barrier that caused the plaintiff to experience a difference in the plaintiffs ability to access or use the internet website as compared to other users such that the plaintiff was unable to acquire the same information, engage in the same interactions, or enjoy the same services with substantially equivalent ease of use, or to have the same level of privacy and independence as other users who are not persons with a disability. because the internet website was not accessible.
(2)That the plaintiff was deterred from accessing or using all or part of the internet website or the content of the internet website because of the because the internet websites failure to provide equally effective communication or to facilitate full and equal enjoyment of the entitys goods and services offered to the public. website was not accessible.
(c)(1)An entitys internet website is presumed to provide equally effective communication and to facilitate full and equal enjoyment of the entitys goods and services to all members of the public for the purpose of determining whether an award of statutory damages is warranted under subdivision (a) of Section 52 or 54.3 if both of the following criteria are satisfied:(A)The internet website has a certification by a professional reviewer that all of the following are true:(i)The internet website is designed and intended to conform to the internet website-related accessibility standard.(ii)The internet website has been tested, in both an automated manner and a manual manner by qualified users, and has been determined to conform to the internet website-related accessibility standard.(iii)All third-party content that is available on the entitys internet website by means of a link from the internet website and that allows members of the public to access, view, utilize, conduct transactions with respect to, or in any other way interact with, the entity or the entitys goods, services, or presentations, has been tested, in both an automated and manual manner, and has been determined to conform to the internet website-related accessibility standard.(B)The certification described in subparagraph (A) meets all of the following requirements:(i)The certification is made within the prior 12 months or after revisions to the internet website that impact accessibility, whichever is more recent, and is based on a review that includes testing by qualified users.(ii)The certification is posted, or available by means of a clearly marked link, on the home page of the entitys internet website.(iii)The certification includes a statement from the professional reviewer explaining how that person qualifies to be a professional reviewer. If the professional reviewer is not a Certified Professional in Web Accessibility (CPWA) with a certificate issued by the International Association of Accessibility Professionals (IAAP), the professional reviewer shall list the type of certification that person has obtained from another source of professional training for front-end internet website developers, as well as the criteria for issuance of that certificate, in order to demonstrate that the criteria are equivalent to, or higher than, the requirements for the issuance of a CPWA certificate.(2)The presumption set forth in paragraph (1) affects the plaintiffs burden of proof. Upon the defendant establishing by a preponderance of the evidence that the criteria set forth in paragraph (1) are satisfied and that the entitys internet website is therefore presumed to provide equally effective communication and to facilitate full and equal enjoyment of the entitys goods and services to all members of the public, the plaintiff may rebut the presumption with clear and convincing evidence, showing that, notwithstanding the presumption set forth in paragraph (1), the elements of one of the violations set forth in subdivision (b) are established.(c)(1)For purposes of this section, judgment shall not be entered in favor of any party solely based on evidence of an automated scan of an internet website.
(2)(A)An entitys internet website may be found to be accessible notwithstanding that content on the internet website that is described in subparagraph (B) is not accessible if a user of the internet website is not required to utilize the content in order to access, view, utilize, conduct transactions, or interact with the entity or the entitys goods, services, or presentations via the internet, and the entity promptly makes the content available, upon request, to the requester in a format that is accessible to the requester.
(B)The content referenced in subparagraph (A) is either of the following:
(i)Data that has been archived as of January 1, 2025, and all of the following criteria are satisfied:
(I)The data are organized and stored in a dedicated area clearly identified as being archived.
(II)The data reproduce paper documents created before January 1, 2025, or reproduce the contents of other physical media created before that date.
(III)The data are retained exclusively for reference, research, or recordkeeping.
(IV)The data are not altered or updated after the date of archiving.
(V)The data may include conventional electronic documents posted and made available on the internet website before January 1, 2025, in word processing, presentation, PDF, or spreadsheet files.
(ii)Content that is posted by a third party and not developed, procured, used, funded, or otherwise controlled by the entity, including by means of a contractual, licensing, or other arrangement between the third party and the entity.
(3)In a civil action alleging that an internet website is not accessible, the party who asserts that an entitys internet website meets the requirements to be deemed accessible pursuant to paragraph (2) has the burden of proving both of the following:
(A)Any content that is not accessible is content that is described in subparagraph (B) of paragraph (2).
(B)Upon request, the entity promptly made the content available to the requester in a format that was accessible to the requester.
(d)(1)In a civil action seeking statutory damages under subdivision (a) of Section 52 or 54.3 on the basis of a specific accessibility barrier on an entitys internet website that is a violation of subdivision (f) of Section 51, the entity shall not be liable for those damages if the entity establishes, as an affirmative defense to the claim, that all of the following apply:
(A)The entity identified the specific accessibility barrier in a digital accessibility report posted on the accessibility page, described in subparagraph (H), of its internet website.
(B)Before the date when the entity identified the specific accessibility barrier pursuant to subparagraph (A), both of the following were true:
(i)A complaint had not been filed against the entity alleging the specific accessibility barrier identified in the digital accessibility report and seeking damages under subdivision (a) of Section 52 or Section 54.3.
(ii)The entity had not been notified that a user of the internet website intended to file a complaint described in clause (i) or otherwise make a claim for damages, including through structured negotiation or other nonjudicial, nongovernmental process, against the entity on the basis of the specific accessibility barrier identified in the digital accessibility report.
(C)Within 90 days of identifying a specific accessibility barrier in a digital accessibility report on the accessibility page, described in subparagraph (H), of its internet website, the entity remediated the specific accessibility barrier and updated its accessibility page to reflect the fact and date of the remediation of that specific accessibility barrier.
(D)The entity reasonably believes that the entitys internet website is accessible.
(E)The entity uses automated and manual testing mechanisms to regularly monitor the internet website to ensure that the internet website is accessible, and the entity remediates any specific accessibility barrier that it identifies.
(F)(i)The entity has posted on its accessibility page described in subparagraph (H) its policy and general practices for ensuring that the entitys internet website is accessible, including the frequency of reviewing or monitoring and testing content on the internet website.
(ii)The post described in clause (i) specifies the extent to which the entity relies on manual testing by users with disabilities and the extent to which the entity uses automated testing mechanisms.
(G)The entity ensures that if a user of the internet website is required to utilize either a link to third-party content, or a resource developed or controlled by a third party, in order to access, view, utilize, conduct transactions, or interact with the entity or the entitys goods, services, or presentations via the internet, that the required third-party content or resource is accessible.
(H)The entity constructed an accessibility page labeled accessibility that is displayed and linked to from the primary domain directory and home page of its internet website and used the term accessibility for any linked text or text descriptions leading to that page, and all of the following criteria are satisfied:
(i)The accessibility page and all content available on that page conformed to the internet website accessibility standard when created and continues to conform to the standard whenever it is updated.
(ii)The accessibility page contains the following statement:
On this page, you can download our Digital Accessibility Report. The Digital Accessibility Report has information about specific accessibility barriers that we know about on our website or app, along with the date by which we expect each barrier to be fixed. We will update the Digital Accessibility Report any time that a barrier listed in the report is fixed.
We may not be liable for certain kinds of damages under California law if a specific accessibility barrier is listed on our Digital Accessibility Report, and we fix that specific accessibility barrier within 90 days of that listing, unless you have filed a lawsuit about that specific accessibility barrier or told us that you intended to make a claim for damages about that specific accessibility barrier before we list it in our Digital Accessibility Report. If we do not fix a specific accessibility barrier within 90 days of the barrier being listed in our Digital Accessibility Report, we will not have protection from damages. For more information about the scope of our protection from damages, you can look at Section 55.565 of the California Civil Code. You can download our Digital Accessibility Report here [link to digital accessibility report].
(iii)(I)If the entity restricts access to the digital accessibility report, the entity shall provide access to the report to a requester within 10 days of receiving a request for the report.
(II)If the entitys digital accessibility report is protected from public view, the entity shall add the following statement immediately following the statement in clause (ii):
When you download this file, you will not be able to read it right away because you will need a password. You can request a password by emailing us at [insert email address], and we will send you the password within 10 days of receiving your request. Once you have the password, you will be able to look at the information in the Digital Accessibility Report.
(I)On the accessibility page described in subparagraph (H), the entity provides a process for users of the internet website, including users with disabilities, to contact the entity to do both of the following:
(i)Obtain assistance with the internet website or to otherwise access, view, utilize, or conduct transactions with respect to the entity or the entitys goods, services, or presentations.
(ii)Report specific accessibility barriers the users encounter on the internet website.
(J)The entitys process for a user of the internet website to report a specific accessibility barrier the user encounters on the internet website described in clause (ii) of subparagraph (I) shall satisfy all of the following criteria:
(i)The entity reviews each report within five business days in order to determine whether it identifies a specific accessibility barrier.
(ii)The entity responds to the person making the report within 48 hours of receiving the report by acknowledging its receipt and providing a copy of the report.
(iii)No later than 90 days after the date of the submission of a report, the entity remediates each specific accessibility barrier and notifies the reporting party of its determination and remediation, as applicable.
(iv)The entity retains all records related to each report for at least three years after the date on which the report is submitted to the entity.
(2)An entity shall not claim the affirmative defense specified in paragraph (1) for a specific accessibility barrier that previously was identified by the entity in a digital accessibility report or that is so similar to a previously identified specific accessibility barrier that it has the same effect on a user as the previously identified specific accessibility barrier.
(3)After qualifying for the affirmative defense described in paragraph (1) as applicable to a specific accessibility barrier identified and remediated pursuant to this subdivision, the entity shall not make any additional alteration to the identifiable location on its internet website where the specific accessibility barrier was remediated if the alteration would create a new specific accessibility barrier. If the entity does so, it shall identify the new specific accessibility barrier in a new digital accessibility report and meet all of the requirements of paragraph (1) in order to qualify for the affirmative defense described in paragraph (1) as applicable to that newly created specific accessibility barrier.
(3)(4)A defendant who qualifies for the presumption affirmative defense set forth in paragraph (1) is entitled to seek a court stay and early evaluation conference, as described in Section 55.54.
(4)(5)The Judicial Council may adopt a form, or modify its existing forms, to implement this section. Before the Judicial Council promulgates a modified form, an entity covered by this part and served with an action regarding an internet website may use or adapt the existing form implementing Section 55.54.
(d)(e)This section does not do any of the following:
(1)Limit the rights and remedies available to persons with a disability under federal law, or any other state law.
(2)Affect whether an entity is responsible under either Section 51 or 51.5 for making its premises accessible to all members of the public, including persons with a disability and including by means of accessing and using the entitys internet website.
(3)Resolve, or otherwise address, whether an internet website that is a standalone internet website-only business and not associated with a business that has a physical location in California is subject to liability under Sections 51, 54, and 54.1.
(4)Establish a presumption of liability, affect the burden of proof, or otherwise impact a courts determination of liability if the presumption established in paragraph (1) of subdivision (c) does not apply or if a plaintiff does not seek statutory damages.(5)(A)Subject to subparagraph (B), require an entity to conform to the internet website-related accessibility standard or impose liability upon the entity for the inaccessibility of an internet website or resource that is accessed by any links that navigate the user from the entitys internet website to a third-party internet website.(B)An entity shall comply with both of the following:(i)An entity shall not unduly rely on links to third-party resources as a means of evading its responsibility to provide an internet website that provides equally effective communication and facilitates full and equal enjoyment of the entitys goods and services to all members of the public, including any member of the public who is a person with a disability.(ii)If a user is required, in order to access, view, utilize, conduct transactions with respect to, or in any other way interact with the business of the entity or the entitys goods, services, or presentations via the internet, to utilize a link to third-party content, the entity shall ensure that the third-party content complies with the internet website-related accessibility standard.(6)(4)Demonstrate an intent by the Legislature, in enacting this section, to deprive or limit the exercise of jurisdiction by federal courts over state law claims brought in conjunction with any federal claim under the Americans with Disabilities Act (42 U.S.C. Sec. 12101 et seq.) or other federal law.
(5)Affect whether a defendant may assert defenses that may otherwise be applicable, including, but not limited to, a defense that the plaintiff does not have standing to bring the claim or that remediation of an accessibility barrier would be an undue burden.
(6)Impose liability on a distributor of video programming for a specific accessibility barrier with respect to the closed captioning or audio description of the video programming if all of the following apply:
(A)The video programming is subject to the 21st Century Communications and Video Accessibility Act of 2010 (Public Law 111-260) and the implementing Federal Communications Commission regulations.
(B)The video programming, including the closed captioning and audio description of the video programming, complies with the accessibility requirements of the 21st Century Communications and Video Accessibility Act of 2010 (Public Law 111-260) and the implementing Federal Communications Commission regulations.
(C)Individuals have the right to obtain a decision from the Enforcement Bureau of the Federal Communications Commission regarding the accessibility of the video programming, including the closed captioning and audio description of the video programming.
(e)(f)For purposes of this section:
(1)Conform means that the entitys internet website, taking into account the variety of conforming implementations, meets the criteria specified by the applicable internet website-related accessibility standard. For purposes of the Web Content Accessibility Guidelines (WCAG) 2.1 Level AA standard for the accessibility of internet websites established by the World Wide Web Consortium (W3C) Accessibility Guidelines Working Group on June 5, 2018, an entity conforms to that standard if the entitys internet website meets all of the Success Criteria set forth in the standard, except if conformance to the standard is either not necessary or not possible due to the nature of the data sought to be presented on the internet website, and any instance of nonconformance does not impact the ability of a person with a disability to acquire information, engage in interactions, and enjoy the services of the entitys internet website with an ease of use and level of privacy that is substantially equivalent to the experience of other users who are not persons with a disability.(1)Accessibility means the quality of an internet website being accessible and useable, particularly to people with disabilities.
(2)Accessible means that an internet website is usable because it provides equally effective communication and facilitates full and equal enjoyment of the entitys goods and services such that individuals with disabilities can do all of the following with substantially equivalent timeliness, privacy, independence, and ease of use as individuals without disabilities:
(A)Access the same information as individuals without disabilities.
(B)Engage in the same interactions as individuals without disabilities.
(C)Conduct the same transactions as individuals without disabilities.
(D)Otherwise participate in or benefit from the same services, programs, and activities as individuals without disabilities.
(3)Conform means, with respect to an internet website, to become accessible and, taking into account the variety of possible implementations, to meet the criteria specified by the applicable internet website accessibility standard, except if conforming to the standard is not necessary, or not possible, due to the nature of the data sought to be presented on the internet website or the lack of conformity with the internet website accessibility standard has such a minimal impact on a user of the internet website that it would not affect the accessibility of the internet website.
(4)(A)Digital accessibility report means a report that contains all of the following information in an accessible, nonproprietary tabular format about a specific accessibility barrier identified in the report:
(i)The identifiable location on the internet website where a user of the internet website would encounter the specific accessibility barrier and the function or component of the internet website at that location.
(ii)A short description of the specific accessibility barrier and how it affects the ability of a user, particularly a user who is a person with a disability, to access or use the internet website and, if applicable, the provisions and success criteria of the internet website accessibility standard to which the location, function, or component of the internet website fails to conform.
(iii)The names of either the entity or resource service provider that the entity believes to be responsible for the specific accessibility barrier or a list of all resource providers who contributed to or developed the inaccessible content identified in the report.
(iv)The date when the digital accessibility report about the specific accessibility barrier is first displayed on the entitys accessibility page.
(v)The date when the specific accessibility barrier is expected to be remediated that is within 90 days of the violation first being displayed on the entitys accessibility page.
(vi)Upon remediation of the specific accessibility barrier, the date when the specific accessibility barrier was remediated.
(2)(5)Entity means a business establishment that is open to the public, a public place, or a place of public accommodation or any other business or place that is subject to the provisions of Sections 51, 54, or 54.1.
(3)(6)Internet website includes all internet web-based technology, including, but not limited to, a mobile site or application, or an app, that can be accessed by a mobile device or other electronic device.
(4)(7)Internet website-related accessibility standard means the Web Content Accessibility Guidelines (WCAG) 2.1 2.2 Level AA standard for the accessibility of internet websites established by the World Wide Web Consortium (W3C) Accessibility Guidelines Working Group on June 5, 2018, or the accessibility standards for Section 508 of the federal Rehabilitation Act of 1973 (29 U.S.C. Sec. 794d) in Part 1194 of Title 36 of the Code of Federal Regulations. To the extent that there is a difference or conflict between the applicable standards for internet websites under WCAG 2.1 2.2 Level AA and standards for information or communication technology under Section 508 of the federal Rehabilitation Act of 1973, the more recent WCAG 2.1 Level AA standard shall apply, unless a more stringent update, revision, or replacement to the accessibility standards for Section 508 of the federal Rehabilitation Act of 1973 (29 U.S.C. Sec. 794d) in Part 1194 of Title 36 of the Code of Federal Regulations is adopted by any final rule of the federal United States Architectural and Transportation Barriers Compliance Board after the date of the enactment of this section, in which case, that final rule federal law, the more stringent standard shall apply to this section.
(5)Professional reviewer means an expert in internet website design and accessibility who has a professional certificate in internet website accessibility issued by the World Wide Web Consortium (W3C), a certificate as a Certified Professional in Web Accessibility (CPWA) issued by the International Association of Accessibility Professionals (IAAP), or a certification issued by another source of professional training for front-end internet website developers with criteria for issuance that are equivalent to, or higher than, the requirements for the issuance of a CPWA certificate.(8)Resource service provider has the same meaning as defined in Section 55.566.
(9)Specific accessibility barrier means the specific aspect of an internet websites content design, functionality, or behavior that causes the internet website to be not accessible to users of the website, particularly users who are people with disabilities.
(f)(g)This section applies to any civil action filed on or after January 1, 2024. 2025.
SEC. 3.Section 55.566 is added to the Civil Code, to read:55.566.(a)It is unlawful for a resource service provider, in exchange for money or any other form of remuneration, to intentionally, negligently, recklessly, or knowingly do either any of the following:
(1)Intentionally, negligently, recklessly, or knowingly construct, Construct, license, distribute, or maintain for online use an internet website that fails to provide equally effective communication or fails to facilitate full and equal enjoyment of the entitys goods and services to all members of the public, including any member of the public who is a person with a disability. is not accessible.
(2)Construct, license, distribute, or maintain for online use any resource or part of an internet website that, when used by the entity in accordance with any instructions provided by the resource provider, causes an entitys internet website to be inaccessible.
(2)Intentionally, negligently, knowingly, or recklessly make(3)Make a false representation of any of the following:
(A)An internet website provides equally effective communication and facilitates full and equal enjoyment of the entitys goods and services to all members of the public, including any member of the public who is a person with a disability.(B)An internet website qualifies for the certification described in subdivision (c) of Section 55.565.(C)The resource provider is a professional reviewer or otherwise qualified to assess the accessibility of an internet website.(A)An internet website is accessible or conforms to the internet website accessibility standard.
(B)An internet website qualifies for the affirmative defense described in subdivision (d) of Section 55.565.
(C)The resource service provider is qualified to assess the accessibility of an internet website.
(D)A specific accessibility barrier has been remediated.
(E)A digital accessibility report is true and accurate.
(b)The following parties may bring a civil action pursuant to subdivision (a): for a violation of this section:
(1)(A)A person (i)An individual or entity that pays, compensates, or contracts with, with the resource service provider to construct, license, distribute, or maintain an internet website for the purpose of providing equally effective communication or facilitating full and equal enjoyment of the person or entitys goods and services to all members of the public, including any member of the public who is a person with a disability. that is accessible who is injured as a result of the defendants violation of subdivision (a) and reasonably relied upon the resource provider to ensure that the internet website, or a part of the internet website, is accessible.
(ii)For purposes of this subparagraph, an individuals or entitys reliance is not reasonable if a resource service provider, before the individual or entity is served with a complaint alleging a violation of this section or being notified that a user of the entitys internet website intends to file such a complaint or otherwise make a claim for damages, including through structured negotiation or other nonjudicial, nongovernmental process, did both of the following:
(I)Disclosed in writing to the individual or entity all known specific accessibility barriers on the entitys internet website.
(II)Described in writing to the individual or entity either of the following, as applicable:
(ia)If the resource service provider had the ability to remediate a specific accessibility barrier, how each specific accessibility barrier identified by the resource provider could be remediated, including by providing an estimate for the cost and time required for that remediation if the resource provider was able to perform the remediation or a referral to a third party who was able to perform the remediation, as applicable.
(ib)If the resource service provider did not have the ability to remediate a specific accessibility barrier, an explanation for why the resource service provider was unable to remediate the specific barrier, including as a result of a specific accessibility barrier that was created by a third partys resource that the resource service provider did not control and was unable to modify.
(B)A plaintiff who prevails under this paragraph shall be entitled to collect all damages, including, but not limited to, any statutory damages and attorneys fees and costs paid by the person or entity as a result of a lawsuit against the person or entity pursuant to Sections 51, 54, and 54.1, based upon the inaccessibility of the person or entitys internet website, and all costs of bringing their internet website into conformance to the internet website-related accessibility standard.
(2)The Attorney General, the Civil Rights Department, or a district attorney, county counsel, or city attorney to obtain the following:
(A)Injunctive or declaratory relief.
(B)Attorneys fees and costs.
(3)(A)A person harmed as a result of a violation of this section if the resource service provider caused the same specific accessibility barrier on multiple internet websites or caused specific accessibility barriers on multiple internet websites that are so similar that they have the same effect on a user of the internet websites. If the person is a prevailing plaintiff, the person may obtain both of the following:
(i)Injunctive or declaratory relief.
(ii)Attorneys fees and costs.
(B)For purposes of this paragraph, person means any of the following:
(i)An individual with a disability that is harmed as a result of a violation of this section.
(ii)An organization that is comprised of, or that represents, individuals with disabilities, at least one of which was harmed as a result of a violation of this section.
(iii)An organization that is injured by a violation of this section due to diversion of resources or frustration of purpose.
(C)For purposes of this paragraph, a person is a prevailing plaintiff if the person obtains a judgment in a civil action pursuant to this section or if that action is a catalyst for, or otherwise results in, the remediation of one or more specific accessibility barriers or other violations of this section while the action is pending resolution.
(c)A (1)Subject to paragraph (2), a provision within a contract between a person an individual or entity and a resource service provider that seeks to waive liability under this section, or otherwise shift the liability to a person or entity that pays, compensates, or contracts with the resource service provider, as described under paragraph (2) (1) of subdivision (b), is void as a matter of public policy and subject to subdivision (c) of Section 51.7.
(2)A contract or other agreement, including a settlement of claims under subdivision (a) or subdivision (a) of Section 55.566, between a person or entity and a resource provider may be valid and enforceable if any of the following apply:
(A)The entity is a large entity.
(B)The contract or other agreement expressly does both of the following:
(i)Obligates an entity to remediate any accessibility barrier corresponding to the released claim.
(ii)Provides the releasor a right to enforce this obligation.
(d)This section does not limit or alter the application of other laws, including, but not limited to, Sections 51, 54, 54.1, and 55, or the ability of a plaintiff to bring a civil action under any other theory of the law, including, but not limited to, breach of contract, implied warranty of merchantability, or false or deceptive advertising.
(e)(1)For purposes of this section, the following terms have the same meanings as defined in Section 55.565:
(A)Accessibility.
(B)Accessible.
(A)(C)Conform.
(D)Digital accessibility report.
(B)(E)Entity.
(C)(F)Internet website.
(D)(G)Internet website-related website accessibility standard.
(E)Professional reviewer.(H)Specific accessibility barrier.
(2)For purposes of this section, large entity means an entity that meets all of the following criteria:
(A)The entity employs more than 50 full-time employees.
(B)The entity earns more than ten million dollars ($10,000,000) in annual revenue, and more than 50 percent of its annual revenue is generated by sales conducted by means of its internet website.
(C)The entity is publicly traded on a stock exchange.
(2)(3)(A)For purposes of this section, resource service provider means a person or entity that, in exchange for money or any other form of remuneration, constructs, licenses, distributes, or maintains for online use any internet website or resource to be used within or in conjunction with an internet website.
(B)Resource service provider does not mean either of the following:
(i)A person or entity that provides hosting or hardware support to an internet website, but does not design, construct, or control the internet website, or resource to be used within or in conjunction with an internet website, in any manner that affects the ability of the internet website or resource to provide equally effective communication and facilitates full and equal enjoyment of an entitys goods and services to all members of the public, including any member of the public who is a person with a disability.
(ii)An individual who is hired by a resource service provider, but does not have a contract directly with the entity who owns the internet website, including a manual accessibility tester.
(f)This section does not do any of the following:
(1)Limit the rights and remedies available to a person with disabilities under the federal law or any other state law.
(2)Affect whether an entity is responsible under either Section 51 or 51.5 for making its premises accessible to all members of the public, including persons with a disability and including by means of accessing and using the entitys internet website.
(3)Resolve, or otherwise address, whether an internet website that is a standalone internet website-only business and not associated with a business that has a physical location in California is subject to liability under Sections 51, 54, and 54.1.
(4)Establish a presumption of liability, affect the burden of proof, or otherwise impact a courts determination of liability if an internet website does not conform to the internet website-related website accessibility standard.
(5)(A)Subject to subparagraph (B), require Require an entity to conform to the internet website-related website accessibility standard if the internet website is otherwise accessible or impose liability upon the entity for the inaccessibility of an a specific accessibility barrier on a third-partys internet website or resource that is accessed by any links that navigate the user from the entitys internet website to a the third-party internet website. website if a user of the internet website is not required to utilize the third-party internet website in order to access, view, utilize, conduct transactions, or interact with the entity or the entitys goods, services, or presentations via the internet.
(B)An entity shall comply with both of the following:(i)An entity shall not unduly rely on links to third-party resources as a means of evading its responsibility to provide an internet website that provides equally effective communication or facilitates full and equal enjoyment of the entitys goods and services to all members of the public, including any member of the public who is a person with a disability.(ii)If a user is required, in order to access, view, utilize, conduct transactions with respect to, or in any other way interact with the business of the entity or the entitys goods, services, or presentations via the internet, to utilize a link to third-party content, the entity shall ensure that the third-party content complies with the internet website-related accessibility standard.(6)Demonstrate an intent by the Legislature, in enacting this section, to deprive or limit the exercise of jurisdiction by federal courts over state law claims brought in conjunction with any federal claim under the Americans with Disabilities Act (42 U.S.C. Sec. 12101 et seq.) or other federal law.
(7)Establish liability under subdivision (a) if a resource service provider establishes that, after the date when the resource service provider constructed, licensed, distributed, or maintained for online use an internet website or resource to be used within, or in conjunction with, an internet website, or issued the certification described in subdivision (c) of Section 55.565, an entity other than the resource service provider, without the knowledge or permission of the resource service provider, altered the internet website or resource in a manner that directly resulted in the internet website or resource no longer providing equally effective communication and facilitating full and equal enjoyment of the entitys goods and services to all members of the public, including any member of the public who is a person with a disability. does either of the following:
(A)Establishes that, after the date when the resource service provider constructed, licensed, distributed, or maintained for online use an internet website or resource to be used within, or in conjunction with, an internet website that is accessible, an entity other than the resource service provider, without the knowledge or permission of the resource service provider, altered the internet website or resource in a manner that directly resulted in the internet website or resource no longer being accessible.
(B)(i)Notifies the entity that a resource the resource service provider has constructed, licensed, or distributed to the entity is responsible for causing a specific accessibility barrier on the entitys internet website and provides the entity with an updated resource to remediate the specific accessibility barrier on the entitys internet website.
(ii)This subparagraph does not apply if the notification by the resource provider occurs on or after the date on which either of the following occurs:
(I)The entity is served with a complaint alleging a violation of Section 55.565 or any other claim for damages alleging that the entitys internet website is not accessible because of the specific accessibility barrier identified in the resource service providers notice.
(II)The entity is notified that a user of the entitys internet website intends to file a complaint described in subclause (I) or otherwise make a claim for damages, including through structured negotiation or other nonjudicial, nongovernmental process, on the basis that the entitys internet website is not accessible because of the specific accessibility barrier identified in the resource service providers notice.
(a)Statutory damages under subdivision (a) of either Section 52 or Section 54.3 shall only be recovered against an entity based upon the inaccessibility of an internet website developed, procured, maintained, or used by that entity if the internet website fails to provide equally effective communication or facilitate full and equal enjoyment of the entitys goods and services to all members of the public, including any member of the public who is a person with a disability.
(b)To be entitled to statutory damages for internet website inaccessibility, a plaintiff must shall prove one of the following:
(1)That the plaintiff personally encountered a specific barrier that caused the plaintiff to experience a difference in their the plaintiffs ability to access or use the internet website as compared to other users such that the plaintiff was unable to acquire the same information, engage in the same interactions, or enjoy the same services with substantially equivalent ease of use, or to have the same level of privacy and independence as other users who are not persons with a disability.
(2)That the plaintiff was deterred from accessing all or part of the internet website or the content of the internet website because of the internet websites failure to provide equally effective communication or to facilitate full and equal enjoyment of the entitys goods and services offered to the public.
(c)(1)An entitys internet website is presumed to provide equally effective communication and to facilitate full and equal enjoyment of the entitys goods and services to all members of the public for the purpose of determining whether an award of statutory damages is warranted under subdivision (a) of Section 52 or 54.3, if the internet website, taking into account the variety of conforming implementations that may be used to meet the internet website-related accessibility standard, conforms to the internet website-related accessibility standard. 54.3 if both of the following criteria are satisfied:
(A)The internet website has a certification by a professional reviewer that all of the following are true:
(i)The internet website is designed and intended to conform to the internet website-related accessibility standard.
(ii)The internet website has been tested, in both an automated manner and a manual manner by qualified users, and has been determined to conform to the internet website-related accessibility standard.
(iii)All third-party content that is available on the entitys internet website by means of a link from the internet website and that allows members of the public to access, view, utilize, conduct transactions with respect to, or in any other way interact with, the entity or the entitys goods, services, or presentations, has been tested, in both an automated and manual manner, and has been determined to conform to the internet website-related accessibility standard.
(B)The certification described in subparagraph (A) meets all of the following requirements:
(i)The certification is made within the prior 12 months or after revisions to the internet website that impact accessibility, whichever is more recent, and is based on a review that includes testing by qualified users.
(ii)The certification is posted, or available by means of a clearly marked link, on the home page of the entitys internet website.
(iii)The certification includes a statement from the professional reviewer explaining how that person qualifies to be a professional reviewer. If the professional reviewer is not a Certified Professional in Web Accessibility (CPWA) with a certificate issued by the International Association of Accessibility Professionals (IAAP), the professional reviewer shall list the type of certification that person has obtained from another source of professional training for front-end internet website developers, as well as the criteria for issuance of that certificate, in order to demonstrate that the criteria are equivalent to, or higher than, the requirements for the issuance of a CPWA certificate.
(2)The presumption set forth in paragraph (1) affects the plaintiffs burden of proof. Upon the defendant establishing by a preponderance of the evidence that the internet website conforms to the internet website-related accessibility standard, criteria set forth in paragraph (1) are satisfied and that the entitys internet website is therefore presumed to provide equally effective communication and to facilitate full and equal enjoyment of the entitys goods and services to all members of the public, the plaintiff may rebut the presumption with clear and convincing evidence, showing that, notwithstanding the internet websites conformance to the standard, presumption set forth in paragraph (1), the elements of one of the violations set forth in subdivision (b) are established.
(3)A defendant who qualifies for the presumption set forth in paragraph (1) is entitled to seek a court stay and early evaluation conference, as described in Section 55.54.
(4)The Judicial Council may adopt a form, or modify its existing forms, to implement this section. Before the Judicial Council promulgates a modified form, an entity covered by this part and served with an action regarding an internet website may use or adapt the existing form implementing Section 55.54.
(d)This section is not intended to does not do any of the following:
(1)Limit the rights and remedies available to persons with a disability under federal law, or any other state law.
(2)Affect whether an entity is responsible under either Section 51 or 51.5 for making its premises accessible to all members of the public, including persons with a disability and including by means of accessing and using the entitys internet website.
(3)Resolve, or otherwise address, whether an internet website that is a standalone website-only business and not associated with a business that has a physical location in California is subject to liability under Sections 51, 54, and 54.1.
(4)Establish a presumption of liability, affect the burden of proof, or otherwise impact a courts determination of liability when an internet website does not conform to the internet website-related accessibility standard and in which case if the presumption established in paragraph (1) of subdivision (c) therefore would does not apply. apply or if a plaintiff does not seek statutory damages.
(5)Require (A)Subject to subparagraph (B), require an entity to conform to the internet website-related accessibility standard. standard or impose liability upon the entity for the inaccessibility of an internet website or resource that is accessed by any links that navigate the user from the entitys internet website to a third-party internet website.
(B)An entity shall comply with both of the following:
(i)An entity shall not unduly rely on links to third-party resources as a means of evading its responsibility to provide an internet website that provides equally effective communication and facilitates full and equal enjoyment of the entitys goods and services to all members of the public, including any member of the public who is a person with a disability.
(ii)If a user is required, in order to access, view, utilize, conduct transactions with respect to, or in any other way interact with the business of the entity or the entitys goods, services, or presentations via the internet, to utilize a link to third-party content, the entity shall ensure that the third-party content complies with the internet website-related accessibility standard.
(6)Demonstrate an intent by the Legislature, in enacting this section, to deprive or limit the exercise of jurisdiction by federal courts over state law claims brought in conjunction with any federal claim under the Americans with Disabilities Act (42 U.S.C. Sec. 12101 et seq.) or other federal law.
(e)For purposes of this section, the following definitions apply: section:
(1)Conform means that the entitys internet website website, taking into account the variety of conforming implementations, meets the criteria specified by the applicable internet website-related accessibility standard, as defined in paragraph (4). standard. For purposes of the Web Content Accessibility Guidelines (WCAG) 2.1 Level AA standard for the accessibility of internet websites established by the World Wide Web Consortium (W3C) Accessibility Guidelines Working Group on June 5, 2018, an entity conforms to that standard when if the entitys internet website meets all of the Success Criteria set forth in the standard. standard, except if conformance to the standard is either not necessary or not possible due to the nature of the data sought to be presented on the internet website, and any instance of nonconformance does not impact the ability of a person with a disability to acquire information, engage in interactions, and enjoy the services of the entitys internet website with an ease of use and level of privacy that is substantially equivalent to the experience of other users who are not persons with a disability.
(2)Entity means a business establishment that is open to the public, a public place, or a place of public accommodation or any other business or place that is subject to the provisions of Sections 51, 54, or 54.1.
(3)Internet website includes all internet web-based technology, including, but not limited to, a mobile site or application, or an app, that can be accessed by a mobile device or other electronic device.
(4)Internet website-related accessibility standard means the Web Content Accessibility Guidelines (WCAG) 2.1 Level AA standard for the accessibility of internet websites established by the World Wide Web Consortium (W3C) Accessibility Guidelines Working Group on June 5, 2018, or the accessibility standards for Section 508 of the federal Rehabilitation Act of 1973 (29 U.S.C. Sec. 794d) in Part 1194 of Title 36 of the Code of Federal Regulations. To the extent that there is a difference or conflict between the applicable standards for internet websites under WCAG 2.1 Level AA and standards for information or communication technology under Section 508 of the federal Rehabilitation Act of 1973, the more recent WCAG 2.1 Level AA standard shall apply, unless a more stringent update, revision, or replacement to the accessibility standards for Section 508 of the federal Rehabilitation Act of 1973 (29 U.S.C. Sec. 794d) in Part 1194 of Title 36 of the Code of Federal Regulations is adopted by any final rule of the federal Access Board United States Architectural and Transportation Barriers Compliance Board after the date of the enactment of this section, in which case case, that final rule shall apply to this section.
(5)Professional reviewer means an expert in internet website design and accessibility who has a professional certificate in internet website accessibility issued by the World Wide Web Consortium (W3C), a certificate as a Certified Professional in Web Accessibility (CPWA) issued by the International Association of Accessibility Professionals (IAAP), or a certification issued by another source of professional training for front-end internet website developers with criteria for issuance that are equivalent to, or higher than, the requirements for the issuance of a CPWA certificate.
(f)This section applies to any civil action filed on or after January 1, 2024.
SEC. 3.Section 55.566 is added to the Civil Code, to read:55.566.(a)It is unlawful for any a resource service provider, in exchange for money or any other form of remuneration, to do either of the following:
(1)Intentionally, negligently, recklessly, or knowingly construct, license, distribute, or maintain for online use, use an internet website that fails to conform to the internet website-related accessibility standard. provide equally effective communication or fails to facilitate full and equal enjoyment of the entitys goods and services to all members of the public, including any member of the public who is a person with a disability.
(2)Intentionally, negligently, knowingly, or recklessly make a false representation that an internet website conforms to the internet website-related accessibility standard. of any of the following:
(A)An internet website provides equally effective communication and facilitates full and equal enjoyment of the entitys goods and services to all members of the public, including any member of the public who is a person with a disability.
(B)An internet website qualifies for the certification described in subdivision (c) of Section 55.565.
(C)The resource provider is a professional reviewer or otherwise qualified to assess the accessibility of an internet website.
(b)The following parties may bring a civil action pursuant to subdivision (a):
(1)(A)A person who is unable to obtain equally effective communication or full and equal enjoyment of an internet website, the content of an internet website, or goods and services offered to the public on an internet website, as a result of the violation.(B)The remedies for a violation of this section pursuant to this paragraph are the remedies provided in subdivision (a) of Section 52.(2)(1)(A)A person or entity that pays, compensates, or contracts with, the resource service provider to construct, license, distribute, or maintain an internet website for the purpose of providing equally effective communication or facilitating full and equal enjoyment of the person or entitys goods and services to all members of the public, including any member of the public who is a person with a disability.
(B)A plaintiff who prevails under this paragraph shall be entitled to collect all damages, including, but not limited to, any statutory damages and attorneys fees paid by the person or entity as a result of a lawsuit against the person or entity pursuant to Sections 51, 54, and 54.1, based upon the inaccessibility of the person or entitys website, and all costs of bringing their internet website into conformance to the internet website-related accessibility standard.
(c)Notwithstanding subdivision (b), the Attorney General(2)The Attorney General, the Civil Rights Department, or a district attorney, county counsel, or city attorney may bring an action under this section to obtain the following:
(1)(A)Injunctive or declaratory relief.
(2)(B)Attorneys fees and costs.
(d)(c)A provision within a contract between a person or entity and a resource service provider that seeks to waive liability under this section, or otherwise shift the liability to a person or entity that pays, compensates, or contracts with the resource service provider, as described under paragraph (2) of subdivision (b), is void as a matter of public policy and subject to subdivision (c) of Section 51.7.
(e)(d)This section does not limit or alter the application of other laws, including, but not limited to, Sections 51, 54, and 54.1, and 55, or the ability of a plaintiff to bring a civil action under any other theory of the law, including, but not limited to, breach of contract, implied warranty of merchantability, or false or deceptive advertising.
(f)(e)(1)For purposes of this section, the following terms have the same meanings as provided in subdivision (e) of defined in Section 55.565:
(A)Conform.
(B)Entity.
(C)Internet website.
(D)Internet website-related accessibility standard.
(E)Professional reviewer.
(2)(A)For purposes of this section, resource service provider means a person or entity that, in exchange for money or any other form of remuneration, constructs, licenses, distributes, or maintains for online use any internet website or resource to be used within or in conjunction with an internet website.
(B)Resource service provider does not mean either of the following:
(i)A person or entity that provides hosting or hardware support to an internet website, but does not design, construct, or control the internet website, or resource to be used within or in conjunction with an internet website, in any manner that affects the ability of the website or resource to provide equally effective communication and facilitates full and equal enjoyment of an entitys goods and services to all members of the public, including any member of the public who is a person with a disability.
(ii)An individual who is hired by a resource service provider, but does not have a contract directly with the entity who owns the website, including a manual accessibility tester.
(g)(f)This section is not intended to does not do any of the following:
(1)Limit the rights and remedies available to a person with disabilities under the federal law or any other state law.
(2)Affect whether an entity is responsible under either Section 51 or 51.5 for making its premises accessible to all members of the public, including persons with a disability and including by means of accessing and using the entitys internet website.
(3)Resolve, or otherwise address, whether an internet website that is a standalone website-only business and not associated with a business that has a physical location in California is subject to liability under Sections 51, 54, and 54.1.
(4)Establish a presumption of liability, affect the burden of proof, or otherwise impact a courts determination of liability when if an internet website does not conform to the internet website-related accessibility standard.
(5)Require (A)Subject to subparagraph (B), require an entity to conform to the internet website-related accessibility standard. standard or impose liability upon the entity for the inaccessibility of an internet website or resource that is accessed by any links that navigate the user from the entitys internet website to a third-party internet website.
(B)An entity shall comply with both of the following:
(i)An entity shall not unduly rely on links to third-party resources as a means of evading its responsibility to provide an internet website that provides equally effective communication or facilitates full and equal enjoyment of the entitys goods and services to all members of the public, including any member of the public who is a person with a disability.
(ii)If a user is required, in order to access, view, utilize, conduct transactions with respect to, or in any other way interact with the business of the entity or the entitys goods, services, or presentations via the internet, to utilize a link to third-party content, the entity shall ensure that the third-party content complies with the internet website-related accessibility standard.
(6)Demonstrate an intent by the Legislature, in enacting this section, to deprive or limit the exercise of jurisdiction by federal courts over state law claims brought in conjunction with any federal claim under the Americans with Disabilities Act (42 U.S.C. Sec. 12101 et seq.) or other federal law.
(7)Establish liability under subdivision (a) when if a resource service provider constructs, licenses, distributes, or maintains establishes that, after the date when the resource service provider constructed, licensed, distributed, or maintained for online use an internet website that fails to conform to the internet website-related accessibility standard, but the internet website provides website or resource to be used within, or in conjunction with, an internet website, or issued the certification described in subdivision (c) of Section 55.565, an entity other than the resource service provider, without the knowledge or permission of the resource service provider, altered the internet website or resource in a manner that directly resulted in the internet website or resource no longer providing equally effective communication and facilitates facilitating full and equal enjoyment of the entitys goods and services to all members of the public, including any member of the public who is a person with a disability.
(a)Statutory damages under subdivision (a) of either Section 52 or Section 54.3 shall only be recovered against an entity based upon the inaccessibility of an internet website developed, procured, maintained, or used by that entity if the internet website fails to provide equally effective communication or facilitate full and equal enjoyment of the entitys goods and services to all members of the public, including any member of the public who is a person with a disability.
(b)To be entitled to statutory damages for internet website inaccessibility, a plaintiff must prove one of the following:
(1)That the plaintiff personally encountered a barrier that caused the plaintiff to experience a difference in their ability to access or use the website as compared to other users such that the plaintiff was unable to acquire the same information, engage in the same interactions, or enjoy the same services with substantially equivalent ease of use, or to have the same level of privacy and independence as other users who are not persons with a disability.
(2)That the plaintiff was deterred from accessing all or part of the internet website or the content of the website because of the websites failure to provide equally effective communication or to facilitate full and equal enjoyment of the entitys goods and services offered to the public.
(c)(1)An internet website is presumed to provide equally effective communication for the purpose of determining whether an award of statutory damages is warranted under subdivision (a) of Section 52 or 54.3, if the internet website, taking into account the variety of conforming implementations that may be used to meet the internet website-related accessibility standard, conforms to the internet website-related accessibility standard.
(2)The presumption set forth in paragraph (1) affects the plaintiffs burden of proof. Upon the defendant establishing by a preponderance of the evidence that the internet website conforms to the internet website-related accessibility standard, the plaintiff may rebut the presumption with clear and convincing evidence, showing that, notwithstanding the internet websites conformance to the standard, the elements of one of the violations set forth in subdivision (b) are established.
(d)This section is not intended to do any of the following:
(1)Limit the rights and remedies available to persons with a disability under federal law, or any other state law.
(2)Affect whether an entity is responsible under either Section 51 or 51.5 for making its premises accessible to all members of the public, including persons with a disability and including by means of accessing and using the entitys internet website.
(3)Resolve, or otherwise address, whether an internet website that is a standalone website-only business and not associated with a business that has a physical location in California is subject to liability under Sections 51, 54, and 54.1.
(4)Establish a presumption of liability, affect the burden of proof, or otherwise impact a courts determination of liability when an internet website does not conform to the internet website-related accessibility standard and in which case the presumption established in paragraph (1) of subdivision (c) therefore would not apply.
(5)Require an entity to conform to the internet website-related accessibility standard.
(6)Demonstrate an intent by the Legislature, in enacting this section, to deprive or limit the exercise of jurisdiction by federal courts over state law claims brought in conjunction with any federal claim under the Americans with Disabilities Act (42 U.S.C. Sec. 12101 et seq.) or other federal law.
(e)For purposes of this section, the following definitions apply:
(1)Conform means that the entitys internet website meets the criteria specified by the applicable internet website-related accessibility standard, as defined in paragraph (4). For purposes of the Web Content Accessibility Guidelines (WCAG) 2.1 Level AA standard for the accessibility of internet websites established by the World Wide Web Consortium (W3C) Accessibility Guidelines Working Group on June 5, 2018, an entity conforms to that standard when the entitys internet website meets all of the Success Criteria set forth in the standard.
(2)Entity means a business establishment that is open to the public, a public place, or a place of public accommodation or any other business or place that is subject to the provisions of Sections 51, 54, or 54.1.
(3)Internet website includes all internet web-based technology, including, but not limited to, a mobile site or application, or an app, that can be accessed by a mobile device or other electronic device.
(4)Internet website-related accessibility standard means the Web Content Accessibility Guidelines (WCAG) 2.1 Level AA standard for the accessibility of internet websites established by the World Wide Web Consortium (W3C) Accessibility Guidelines Working Group on June 5, 2018, or the accessibility standards for Section 508 of the federal Rehabilitation Act of 1973 (29 U.S.C. Sec. 794d) in Part 1194 of Title 36 of the Code of Federal Regulations. To the extent that there is a difference or conflict between the applicable standards for internet websites under WCAG 2.1 Level AA and standards for information or communication technology under Section 508 of the federal Rehabilitation Act of 1973, the more recent WCAG 2.1 Level AA standard shall apply, unless a more stringent update, revision, or replacement to the accessibility standards for Section 508 of the federal Rehabilitation Act of 1973 (29 U.S.C. Sec. 794d) in Part 1194 of Title 36 of the Code of Federal Regulations is adopted by any final rule of the federal Access Board after the date of the enactment of this section, in which case that final rule shall apply to this section.
(f)This section applies to any civil action filed on or after January 1, 2024.
SEC. 3.Section 55.566 is added to the Civil Code, to read:55.566.(a)It is unlawful for any resource service provider, in exchange for money or any other form of remuneration, to do either of the following:
(1)Intentionally, negligently, or knowingly construct, license, distribute, or maintain for online use, an internet website that fails to conform to the internet website-related accessibility standard.
(2)Intentionally, negligently, or recklessly make a false representation that an internet website conforms to the internet website-related accessibility standard.
(b)The following parties may bring a civil action pursuant to subdivision (a):
(1)(A)A person who is unable to obtain equally effective communication or full and equal enjoyment of an internet website, the content of an internet website, or goods and services offered to the public on an internet website, as a result of the violation.
(B)The remedies for a violation of this section pursuant to this paragraph are the remedies provided in subdivision (a) of Section 52.
(2)(A)A person or entity that pays, compensates, or contracts with, the resource service provider to construct, license, distribute, or maintain an internet website for the purpose of providing equally effective communication or facilitating full and equal enjoyment of the person or entitys goods and services to all members of the public, including any member of the public who is a person with a disability.
(B)A plaintiff who prevails under this paragraph shall be entitled to collect all damages, including, but not limited to, any statutory damages and attorneys fees paid by the person or entity as a result of a lawsuit against the person or entity pursuant to Sections 51, 54, and 54.1, based upon the inaccessibility of the person or entitys website, and all costs of bringing their internet website into conformance to the internet website-related accessibility standard.
(c)Notwithstanding subdivision (b), the Attorney General or a district attorney, county counsel, or city attorney may bring an action under this section to obtain the following:
(1)Injunctive or declaratory relief.
(2)Attorneys fees and costs.
(d)A provision within a contract between a person or entity and a resource service provider that seeks to waive liability under this section, or otherwise shift the liability to a person or entity that pays, compensates, or contracts with the resource service provider, as described under paragraph (2) of subdivision (b), is void as a matter of public policy and subject to subdivision (c) of Section 51.7.
(e)This section does not limit or alter the application of other laws, including, but not limited to, Sections 51, 54, and 54.1, or the ability of a plaintiff to bring a civil action under any other theory of the law, including, but not limited to, breach of contract, implied warranty of merchantability, or false or deceptive advertising.
(f)(1)For purposes of this section, the following terms have the same meanings as provided in subdivision (e) of Section 55.565:
(A)Conform.
(B)Entity.
(C)Internet website.
(D)Internet website-related accessibility standard.
(2)For purposes of this section, resource service provider means a person or entity that, in exchange for money or any other form of remuneration, constructs, licenses, distributes, or maintains for online use any internet website or resource to be used within or in conjunction with an internet website.
(g)This section is not intended to do any of the following:
(1)Limit the rights and remedies available to a person with disabilities under the federal law or any other state law.
(2)Affect whether an entity is responsible under either Section 51 or 51.5 for making its premises accessible to all members of the public, including persons with a disability and including by means of accessing and using the entitys internet website.
(3)Resolve, or otherwise address, whether an internet website that is a standalone website-only business and not associated with a business that has a physical location in California is subject to liability under Sections 51, 54, and 54.1.
(4)Establish a presumption of liability, affect the burden of proof, or otherwise impact a courts determination of liability when an internet website does not conform to the internet website-related accessibility standard.
(5)Require an entity to conform to the internet website-related accessibility standard.
(6)Demonstrate an intent by the Legislature, in enacting this section, to deprive or limit the exercise of jurisdiction by federal courts over state law claims brought in conjunction with any federal claim under the Americans with Disabilities Act (42 U.S.C. Sec. 12101 et seq.) or other federal law.
(7)Establish liability under subdivision (a) when a resource service provider constructs, licenses, distributes, or maintains for online use an internet website that fails to conform to the internet website-related accessibility standard, but the internet website provides equally effective communication and facilitates full and equal enjoyment of the entitys goods and services to all members of the public, including any member of the public who is a person with a disability.
(a)Statutory damages under subdivision (a) of either Section 52 or Section 54.3 shall only be recovered against an entity based upon the inaccessibility of an internet website developed, procured, maintained, or used by that entity if the internet website fails to provide equally effective communication or facilitate full and equal enjoyment of the entitys goods and services to all members of the public, including any member of the public who is disabled. a person with a disability.
(b)To be entitled to statutory damages for internet website inaccessibility, a plaintiff must prove one of the following:
(1)That the plaintiff personally encountered a barrier that caused the plaintiff to experience a difference in their ability to access or use the website as compared to other users such that the plaintiff was unable to acquire the same information, engage in the same interactions, or enjoy the same services with substantially equivalent ease of use, or to have the same level of privacy and independence as other users who are not disabled. persons with a disability.
(2)That the plaintiff was deterred from accessing all or part of the internet website or the content of the website because of the websites failure to provide equally effective communication or to facilitate full and equal enjoyment of the entitys goods and services offered to the public.
(c)(1)An internet website is presumed to provide equally effective communication for the purpose of determining whether an award of minimum statutory damages is warranted under subdivision (a) of Section 52 or 54.3, if the internet website, taking into account the variety of conforming implementations that may be used to meet the internet website-related accessibility standard, complies with conforms to the internet website-related accessibility standard.
(2)The presumption set forth in paragraph (1) affects the plaintiffs burden of proof. Upon the defendant establishing by a preponderance of the evidence that the internet website complies with conforms to the internet website-related accessibility standard, the plaintiff may rebut the presumption with clear and convincing evidence, showing that, notwithstanding the internet websites compliance with conformance to the standard, the elements of one of the violations set forth in subdivision (b) are established.
(d)This section is not intended to do any of the following:
(1)Limit the rights and remedies available to disabled persons with a disability under federal law, or any other state law.
(2)Affect whether an entity is responsible under either Section 51 or 51.5 for making its premises accessible to all members of the public, including the disabled persons with a disability and including by means of accessing and using the entitys internet website.
(3)Resolve, or otherwise address, whether an internet website that is a standalone website-only business and not associated with a business that has a physical location in California is subject to liability under Sections 51, 54, and 54.1.
(4)Establish a presumption of liability, affect the burden of proof, or otherwise impact a courts determination of liability when an internet website does not conform to the internet website-related accessibility standard and in which case the presumption established in paragraph (1) of subdivision (c) therefore would not apply.
(5)Require an entity to conform to the internet website-related accessibility standard.
(6)Demonstrate an intent by the Legislature, in enacting this section, to deprive or limit the exercise of jurisdiction by federal courts over state law claims brought in conjunction with any federal claim under the Americans with Disabilities Act (42 U.S.C. Sec. 12101 et seq.) or other federal law.
(e)For purposes of this section, the following definitions apply:
(1)Conform means that the entitys internet website meets the criteria specified by the applicable internet website-related accessibility standard, as defined in paragraph (4). For purposes of the Web Content Accessibility Guidelines (WCAG) 2.1 Level AA standard for the accessibility of internet websites established by the World Wide Web Consortium (W3C) Accessibility Guidelines Working Group on June 5, 2018, an entity conforms to that standard when the entitys internet website meets all of the Success Criteria set forth in the standard.
(1)(2)Entity means a business establishment that is open to the public, a public place, or a place of public accommodation. accommodation or any other business or place that is subject to the provisions of Sections 51, 54, or 54.1.
(2)(3)Internet website includes all internet web-based technology, including, but not limited to, a mobile application site or application, or app an app, that can be accessed by a mobile device. device or other electronic device.
(3)(4)Internet website-related accessibility standard means the Web Content Accessibility Guidelines (WCAG) 2.1 Level AA standard for the accessibility of internet websites established by the World Wide Web Consortium (W3C) Accessibility Guidelines Working Group on June 5, 2018, or the accessibility standards for Section 508 of the federal Rehabilitation Act of 1973 (29 U.S.C. Sec. 794d) in Part 1194 of Title 36 of the Code of Federal Regulations. To the extent that there is an overlap a difference or conflict between the applicable standards for internet websites under WCAG 2.1 Level AA and standards for information or communication technology under Section 508 of the federal Rehabilitation Act of 1973, the more recent WCAG 2.1 Level AA standard shall apply. Any subsequent apply, unless a more stringent update, revision, or replacement to either standard adopted by any final rule of the U.S. Access Board the accessibility standards for Section 508 of the federal Rehabilitation Act of 1973 (29 U.S.C. Sec. 794d) in Part 1194 of Title 36 of the Code of Federal Regulations is adopted by any final rule of the federal Access Board after the date of the enactment of this section, in which case that final rule shall apply to this section.
(f)This section applies to any civil action filed on or after January 1, 2024.
SEC. 3.Section 55.566 is added to the Civil Code, to read:55.566.(a)It is unlawful for any resource service provider, in exchange for money or any other form of remuneration, to intentionally do either of the following:
(1)Intentionally, negligently, or knowingly construct, license, distribute, or maintain for online use, an internet website that fails to comply with conform to the internet website-related accessibility standard.
(2)Intentionally, negligently, or recklessly make a false representation that an internet website conforms to the internet website-related accessibility standard.
(b)The following parties may bring a civil action pursuant to this subdivision: subdivision (a):
(1)(A)A person who is unable to obtain equally effective communication or full and equal enjoyment of an internet website, the content of an internet website, or goods and services offered to the public on an internet website, as a result of the failure of an internet website to meet the internet website-related accessibility standard. violation.
(B)The remedies for a violation of this section pursuant to this paragraph are the remedies provided in subdivision (a) of Section 52.
(2)(A)A person or entity that pays, compensates, or contracts with, the resource service provider to construct, license, distribute, or maintain an internet website for the purpose of providing equally effective communication or facilitating full and equal enjoyment of the person or entitys goods and services to all members of the public, including any member of the public who is disabled. a person with a disability.
(B)A party plaintiff who prevails under this paragraph shall be entitled to collect all damages, including, but not limited to, any statutory damages and attorneys fees paid by the person or entity as a result of a lawsuit against the person or entity pursuant to Sections 51, 54, and 54.1, based upon the inaccessibility of the person or entitys website, and all costs of bringing their internet website into compliance with conformance to the internet website-related accessibility standard.
(c)Notwithstanding subdivision (b), the Attorney General or a district attorney, county counsel, or city attorney may bring an action under this section to obtain the following:
(1)Injunctive or declaratory relief.
(2)Attorneys fees and costs.
(d)A provision within a contract between a person or entity and a resource service provider that seeks to waive liability under this section section, or otherwise shift the liability to a person or entity that pays, compensates, or contracts with the resource service provider, as described under paragraph (2) of subdivision (b), is void as a matter of public policy and subject to subdivision (c) of Section 51.7.
(e)This section does not limit or alter the application of other laws, including, but not limited to, Sections 51, 54, and 54.1, or the ability of a plaintiff to bring a civil action under any other theory of the law, including, but not limited to, breach of contract, implied warranty of merchantability, or false or deceptive advertising.
(f)(1)For purposes of this section, the following terms have the following meanings: same meanings as provided in subdivision (e) of Section 55.565:
(1)Entity has the same meaning as provided in subdivision (e) of Section 55.565.(2) Internet website has the same meaning as provided in subdivision (e) of Section 55.565.(A)Conform.
(B)Entity.
(C)Internet website.
(3)(D)Internet website-related accessibility standard has the same meaning as provided in subdivision (e) of Section 55.565. standard.
(4)Resource(2)For purposes of this section, resource service provider means a person or entity that, in exchange for money or any other form of remuneration, constructs, licenses, distributes, or maintains for online use any internet website or resource to be used within or in conjunction with an internet website.
(g)This section is not intended to do any of the following:
(1)Limit the rights and remedies available to a person with disabilities under the federal law or any other state law.
(2)Affect whether an entity is responsible under either Section 51 or 51.5 for making its premises accessible to all members of the public, including persons with a disability and including by means of accessing and using the entitys internet website.
(3)Resolve, or otherwise address, whether an internet website that is a standalone website-only business and not associated with a business that has a physical location in California is subject to liability under Sections 51, 54, and 54.1.
(4)Establish a presumption of liability, affect the burden of proof, or otherwise impact a courts determination of liability when an internet website does not conform to the internet website-related accessibility standard.
(5)Require an entity to conform to the internet website-related accessibility standard.
(6)Demonstrate an intent by the Legislature, in enacting this section, to deprive or limit the exercise of jurisdiction by federal courts over state law claims brought in conjunction with any federal claim under the Americans with Disabilities Act (42 U.S.C. Sec. 12101 et seq.) or other federal law.
(a)Statutory damages under subdivision (a) of either Section 52 or Section 54.3 shall only be recovered against an entity based upon the inaccessibility of an internet website developed, procured, maintained, or used by that entity if the internet website fails to provide equally effective communication or facilitate full and equal enjoyment of the entitys goods and services to all members of the public, including any member of the public who is disabled.
(b)To be entitled to statutory damages for internet website inaccessibility, a plaintiff must prove one of the following:
(1)That the plaintiff personally encountered a barrier that caused the plaintiff to experience a difference in their ability to access or use the website as compared to other users such that the plaintiff was unable to acquire the same information, engage in the same interactions, or enjoy the same services with substantially equivalent ease of use, or to have the same level of privacy and independence as other users who are not disabled.
(2)That the plaintiff was deterred from accessing all or part of the website or the content of the website because of the websites failure to provide equally effective communication or to facilitate full and equal enjoyment of the entitys goods and services offered to the public.
(c)(1)An internet website is presumed to provide equally effective communication for the purpose of determining whether an award of minimum statutory damages is warranted under subdivision (a) of Section 52 or 54.3, if the internet website, taking into account the variety of conforming implementations that may be used to meet the internet website-related accessibility standard, complies with the internet website-related accessibility standard.
(2)The presumption set forth in paragraph (1) affects the plaintiffs burden of proof. Upon the defendant establishing by a preponderance of the evidence that the internet website complies with the internet website-related accessibility standard, the plaintiff may rebut the presumption with clear and convincing evidence, showing that, notwithstanding the internet websites compliance with the standard, the elements of one of the violations set forth in subdivision (b) are established.
(d)This section is not intended to do any of the following:
(1)Limit the rights and remedies available to disabled persons under federal law, or any other state law.
(2)Affect whether an entity is responsible under either Section 51 or 51.5 for making its premises accessible to all members of the public, including the disabled and including by means of accessing and using the entitys internet website.
(3)Resolve, or otherwise address, whether an internet website that is a standalone website-only business and not associated with a business that has a physical location in California is subject to liability under Sections 51, 54, and 54.1.
(e)For purposes of this section, the following definitions apply:
(1)Entity means a business establishment that is open to the public, a public place, or a place of public accommodation.
(2)Internet website includes all internet web-based technology, including, but not limited to, a mobile application or app that can be accessed by a mobile device.
(3)Internet website-related accessibility standard means the Web Content Accessibility Guidelines (WCAG) 2.1 Level AA standard for the accessibility of internet websites established by the World Wide Web Consortium (W3C) Accessibility Guidelines Working Group on June 5, 2018, or the accessibility standards for Section 508 of the federal Rehabilitation Act of 1973 (29 U.S.C. Sec. 794d) in Part 1194 of Title 36 of the Code of Federal Regulations. To the extent that there is an overlap between the applicable standards for internet websites under WCAG 2.1 and standards for information or communication technology under Section 508 of the federal Rehabilitation Act of 1973, the more recent WCAG 2.1 standard shall apply. Any subsequent more stringent update, revision, or replacement to either standard adopted by any final rule of the U.S. Access Board shall apply to this section.
(f)This section applies to any civil action filed on or after January 1, 2024.
SEC. 3.Section 55.566 is added to the Civil Code, to read:55.566.(a)It is unlawful for any resource service provider, in exchange for money or any other form of remuneration, to intentionally or knowingly construct, license, distribute, or maintain for online use, an internet website that fails to comply with the internet website-related accessibility standard.
(b)The following parties may bring a civil action pursuant to this subdivision:
(1)(A)A person who is unable to obtain equally effective communication or full and equal enjoyment of an internet website, the content of an internet website, or goods and services offered to the public on an internet website, as a result of the failure of an internet website to meet the internet website-related accessibility standard.
(B)The remedies for a violation of this section pursuant to this paragraph are the remedies provided in subdivision (a) of Section 52.
(2)(A)A person or entity that pays, compensates, or contracts with, the resource service provider to construct, license, distribute, or maintain an internet website for the purpose of providing equally effective communication or facilitating full and equal enjoyment of the person or entitys goods and services to all members of the public, including any member of the public who is disabled.
(B)A party who prevails under this paragraph shall be entitled to collect all damages, including, but not limited to, any statutory damages and attorneys fees paid by the person or entity as a result of a lawsuit against the person or entity pursuant to Sections 51, 54, and 54.1, based upon the inaccessibility of the person or entitys website, and all costs of bringing their internet website into compliance with the internet website-related accessibility standard.
(c)Notwithstanding subdivision (b), the Attorney General or a district attorney, county counsel, or city attorney may bring an action under this section to obtain the following:
(1)Injunctive or declaratory relief.
(2)Attorneys fees and costs.
(d)A provision within a contract between a person or entity and a resource service provider that seeks to waive liability under this section is subject to subdivision (c) of Section 51.7.
(e)This section does not limit or alter the application of other laws, including, but not limited to, Sections 51, 54, and 54.1, or the ability of a plaintiff to bring a civil action under any other theory of the law, including, but not limited to, breach of contract, implied warranty of merchantability, or false or deceptive advertising.
(f)For purposes of this section, the following terms have the following meanings:
(1)Entity has the same meaning as provided in subdivision (e) of Section 55.565.
(2)Internet website has the same meaning as provided in subdivision (e) of Section 55.565.
(3)Internet website-related accessibility standard has the same meaning as provided in subdivision (e) of Section 55.565.
(4)Resource service provider means a person or entity that, in exchange for money or any other form of remuneration, constructs, licenses, distributes, or maintains for online use any internet website or resource to be used within or in conjunction with an internet website.
All matter omitted in this version of the bill appears in the bill as introduced in the Assembly, March 2, 2023. (JR11)In addition to any other duties specified by law, the State Bar shall do all of the following:
(a)Promptly notify the complainant of the disposition of each matter.
(b)Notify all of the following of a lawyers involuntary enrollment as an inactive licensee and termination of that enrollment, or any suspension or disbarment, and the reinstatement to active license of a suspended or disbarred attorney:
(1)The presiding judge of the superior court in the county where the attorney most recently maintained an office for the practice of law, with a request that the judge notify the courts and judges in the county.
(2)The local bar association, if there is one, in the county or area where the attorney most recently maintained an office for the practice of law.
(3)The appropriate disciplinary authority in any other jurisdiction where the attorney is admitted to practice.
(c)Upon receipt of the certified copy of the record of conviction of a lawyer, as provided by subdivision (c) of Section 6101, promptly forward a certified copy of the judgment of conviction to the disciplinary agency in each jurisdiction in which the lawyer is admitted.
(d)Maintain permanent records of discipline and other matters within its jurisdiction, and compile statistics to aid in the administration of the system, including, but not limited to, a single log of all complaints received, investigative files, statistical summaries of docket processing and case dispositions, transcripts of all proceedings which have been transcribed, and other records as the State Bar or court require to be maintained.
(e)Expunge records of the State Bar as directed by the California Supreme Court.
(f)Pursuant to directions from the California Supreme Court, undertake whatever investigations are assigned to it.
(g)Provide information to prospective complainants regarding the nature and procedures of the disciplinary system, the criteria for prosecution of disciplinary complaints, the client security fund, and fee arbitration procedures.
(h)Inform the public, local bar associations and other organizations, and any other interested parties about the work of the State Bar and the right of all persons to make a complaint.
(i)Make agreements with respondents in lieu of disciplinary proceedings, regarding conditions of practice, further legal education, or other matters. These agreements may be used by the State Bar in any subsequent proceeding involving the lawyer.
SEC. 2.Section 811.9 of the Government Code is amended to read:811.9.(a)Notwithstanding any other provision of law, judges, subordinate judicial officers, and court executive officers of the superior courts are state officers for purposes of Part 1 (commencing with Section 810) to Part 7 (commencing with Section 995), inclusive, and trial court employees are employees of the trial court for purposes of Part 1 (commencing with Section 810) to Part 7 (commencing with Section 995), inclusive. The Judicial Council shall provide for representation, defense, and indemnification of those individuals and the court pursuant to Part 1 (commencing with Section 810) to Part 7 (commencing with Section 995), inclusive. The Judicial Council shall provide for that representation or defense through the county counsel, the Attorney General, or other counsel. The county counsel and the Attorney General may, but are not required to, provide representation or defense for the Judicial Council. a trial court, judge, subordinate judicial officer, court executive officer, or trial court employee if the Judicial Council requests that assistance to fulfill its duties under this section. The fact that a justice, judge, subordinate judicial officer, court executive officer, court employee, the court, the Judicial Council, or the Administrative Office of the Courts staff of the Judicial Council is or was represented or defended by the county counsel, the Attorney General, or other counsel shall not be the sole basis for a judicial determination of disqualification of a justice, judge, subordinate judicial officer, the county counsel, the Attorney General, or other counsel in unrelated actions.
(b)To promote the cost-effective, prompt, and fair resolution of actions, proceedings, and claims affecting the trial courts, the Judicial Council shall adopt rules of court requiring the Administrative Office of the Courts its staff to manage actions, proceedings, and claims that affect the trial courts and involve superior courts, superior court judges, subordinate judicial officers, court executive officers, or trial court employees in consultation with the affected courts and individuals. The Administrative Office of the Courts staffs management of these actions, proceedings, and claims shall include, but not be limited to, case management and administrative responsibilities such as selection of counsel and making strategic and settlement decisions.
(c)Nothing in this section shall be construed to affect the employment status of subordinate judicial officers, court executive officers, and trial court employees related to any matters not covered by subdivision (a).
SEC. 3.Section 990.2 of the Government Code is amended to read:990.2.A county The Judicial Council may insure any officer or attache of its superior and municipal courts against all or any part of the officer or attaches liability for injury resulting from any act or omission in the scope of the officer or attaches employment, and also may insure against the expense of defending any claim against such the officer or attache, whether or not liability exists on such that claim.
SEC. 4.Section 26524 of the Government Code is repealed.26524.Upon request of any judge of the superior or municipal court, the district attorney shall appear for and represent the court or judge if the court or judge in his or her official capacity is a party defendant in any action.SEC. 5.Section 26529 of the Government Code is amended to read:26529.(a)In counties that have a county counsel, the county counsel shall discharge all the duties vested in the district attorney by Sections 26520, 26522, 26523, 26524, and 26526. The county counsel shall defend or prosecute all civil actions and proceedings in which the county or any of its officers is concerned or is a party in his or her the officers official capacity. Except where the county provides other counsel, the county counsel shall defend as provided in Part 7 (commencing with Section 995) of Division 3.6 of Title 1 of the Government Code any action or proceeding brought against an officer, employee, or servant of the county.
(b)Notwithstanding any other provision of law, the County Counsel of the County of Solano may, and when directed by the board of supervisors of that county shall, bring a civil action when the county, or any of its officers, has a cause of action to abate a public nuisance in the county. The County Counsel and the District Attorney of Solano County have the concurrent right to bring an action to abate a public nuisance pursuant to this subdivision.
SEC. 6.Section 27647 of the Government Code is amended to read:27647.(a)If requested to do so by the superior court of the county of the county counsel, or by any judge thereof, Judicial Council, and insofar as such these duties are not in conflict with, and do not interfere with, other duties, the county counsel may represent any such the superior court or a judge thereof in all matters and questions of law pertaining to any of such the judges duties, including any representation authorized by Section 68111 and representation in all civil actions and proceedings in any court in which with respect to the courts or judges official capacity, such the court or judge is concerned or is a party.
(b)This section does not apply to any of the following:
(1)Any criminal proceedings in which a judge is a defendant.
(2)Any grand jury proceedings.
(3)Any proceeding before the Commission on Judicial Qualifications. Performance.
(4)Any civil action or proceeding arising out of facts under which the judge was convicted of a criminal offense in a criminal proceeding.
SEC. 7.Section 27648 of the Government Code is repealed.27648.If, because of a declared conflict of interest, any judge, who is otherwise entitled to representation pursuant to Section 825, 995, or 27647, is required to retain his own counsel, such judge is entitled to recover from the appropriate public entity such reasonable attorneys fees, costs, and expenses as were necessarily incurred thereby.SEC. 8.Section 53214.5 of the Government Code is amended to read:53214.5.A county or city and county which that pays the salaries, either in whole or in part, of judges of the superior and municipal courts and the officers and attaches of those courts may allow the judges, officers, and attaches to participate in any deferred compensation plan established pursuant to this article. Any county or city and county is hereby authorized to enter into a written agreement with the judges, officers, and attaches providing for deferral of a portion of their wages. The judges, officers, and attaches may authorize deductions to be made from their wages for the purpose of participating in the deferred compensation plan.
SEC. 9.Section 68111 of the Government Code is amended to read:68111.(a)Whenever any judge of any court of this state is a witness in his an official capacity as judge in any action or proceeding, such the judge shall be entitled to be represented at such the action or proceeding by counsel of his choice. the judges choice, at the judges own expense.
(b)Representation of a judge at public expense is governed by the Government Claims Act (Division 3.6 (commencing with Section 810) of Title 1), including, but not limited to, Section 995.9.
SEC. 10.Section 69894.3 of the Government Code is amended to read:69894.3.Employees of the superior court in each county having a population of over 2,000,000 of the first class shall be entitled to step advancement, vacation, sick leave, holiday benefits and other leaves of absence and other benefits as may be directed by rules of the court. Where statutes require implementation by local ordinances for the extension of benefits to local officers and employees, these may be made applicable by rule to court personnel, including including, but not limited to jurors, to, jurors and judges.
These benefits shall also include the same lump sum payments for sick leave and vacation for the superior court employees when they are separated from the service as are made to county employees of the county; except that lump-sum payments to court commissioners when separated from the service of the superior court shall be limited to accrued vacation if any, as is provided by local rule of court, exclusive of accrued sick leave.
Court employees under this section shall have the right to transfer to other departments in the county government, subject to the approval of the board of supervisors, the county charter, and other usual conditions that may be placed upon the transfer, including, but not limited to, a requirement that the transferee successfully complete an appropriate civil service examination. The right of transfer shall not give any employee any additional rights by reason of his their employment with the court, other than those to which he they would have been entitled if the employment had been with a different department of the county government.
Employment by the court shall be deemed to be employment by the county, if approved by rule of court, for the purpose of determining a court employees rights with respect to a countys ordinances providing for salary step advancements and other employee benefits and rights, including, but not limited to, amount of compensation, vacations, sick leave, and accumulated sick leave.
In any such county county, attaches may be voluntarily transferred from a position in one judicial district to a position in another within the county and promoted or voluntarily demoted from a position in one judicial district to a position in another within the county in substantially the same manner as transfers, demotions and promotions are authorized generally in county departments or between departments of the county.
Rules of the court may include other matters pertaining to the general administration of the court, including conditions of employment of court personnel, including including, but not limited to to, jurors and judges. When rules are adopted by a majority of the judges and filed with the Judicial Council Council, they shall have the same status as other rules of court adopted pursuant to Section 68070.
When requested to do so by the court court, the county shall shall, through the county civil service commission commission, furnish to the court services as may be required in connection with the recruitment and employment of court officers and employees.
SEC. 11.Section 69894.4 of the Government Code is repealed.69894.4.All of the employees provided for in Section 69894.1 and judges of the superior court in each county having a population of over 2,000,000 shall be allowed actual traveling and necessary expenses incurred while engaged in the duties of their office, which shall be the same as allowed to officers and employees of such county. Any expenses for travel outside of the county shall require the prior approval of the board of supervisors.Whenever, because of the nature of the duties of any judge or officer of the court, the board of supervisors determines that the best interest of the county and the court would be served, it may assign an automobile in lieu of allowing travel expenses.The salaries provided for in said Section 69894.1 shall be paid by the county out of such fund as other salary demands against the county are paid. The expenses provided for in this section shall be paid in monthly installments out of the general fund. Salaries and expenses shall be audited in the same manner as the law requires for other demands against the county.SEC. 12.Section 69894.4 is added to the Government Code, to read:69894.4.In each county of the first class, whenever, because of the nature of the duties of any judge or officer of the court, the court determines that the best interest of the court would be served, it may assign an automobile in lieu of allowing traveling expenses.
SEC. 13.Section 73643 is added to the Government Code, immediately following Section 73642, to read:73643.(a)This article shall remain in effect only until January 1, 2074, and as of that date is repealed.
(b)The repeal of this article does not affect any right or benefit to which a person was entitled on the date of repeal.
SEC. 14.Section 73953 is added to the Government Code, immediately following Section 73952, to read:73953.(a)This article shall remain in effect only until January 1, 2074, and as of that date is repealed.
(b)The repeal of this article does not affect any right or benefit to which a person was entitled on the date of repeal.
SEC. 15.Section 74146 is added to the Government Code, immediately following Section 74145, to read:74146.(a)This article shall remain in effect only until January 1, 2074, and as of that date is repealed.
(b)The repeal of this article does not affect any right or benefit to which a person was entitled on the date of repeal.
SEC. 16.Section 74343 is added to the Government Code, immediately following Section 74342, to read:74343.(a)This article shall remain in effect only until January 1, 2074, and as of that date is repealed.
(b)The repeal of this article does not affect any right or benefit to which a person was entitled on the date of repeal.
SEC. 17.Section 74743 is added to the Government Code, immediately following Section 74742, to read:74743.(a)This article shall remain in effect only until January 1, 2074, and as of that date is repealed.
(b)The repeal of this article does not affect any right or benefit to which a person was entitled on the date of repeal.
SEC. 18.Section 77210 of the Government Code is amended to read:77210.(a)The state shall provide municipal court judges retired under the Judges Retirement System with retiree health, dental, and vision care plans equal to and in the same manner as the health, dental, and vision benefits provided to retired superior court judges.
(b)No judge shall have any salary or benefits reduced solely by reason of the enactment of this section.
(c)This section shall remain in effect only until January 1, 2074, and as of that date is repealed.
(d)The repeal of this section does not affect any right or benefit to which a person was entitled on the date of repeal.
SEC. 19.Section 11488.4 of the Health and Safety Code is amended to read:11488.4.(a)(1)Except as provided in subdivision (j), if the Department of Justice or the local governmental entity determines that the factual circumstances do warrant that the moneys, negotiable instruments, securities, or other things of value seized or subject to forfeiture come within the provisions of subdivisions (a) to (g), inclusive, of Section 11470, and are not automatically made forfeitable or subject to court order of forfeiture or destruction by another provision of this chapter, the Attorney General or district attorney shall file a petition of forfeiture with the superior court of the county in which the defendant has been charged with the underlying criminal offense or in which the property subject to forfeiture has been seized or, if no seizure has occurred, in the county in which the property subject to forfeiture is located. A petition under this section is an unlimited civil case, regardless of the value of the seized property. If the petition alleges that real property is forfeitable, the prosecuting attorney shall cause a lis pendens to be recorded in the office of the county recorder of each county in which the real property is located.
(2)A petition of forfeiture under this subdivision shall be filed as soon as practicable, but in any case within one year of the seizure of the property which that is subject to forfeiture, or as soon as practicable, but in any case within one year of the filing by the Attorney General or district attorney of a lis pendens or other process against the property, whichever is earlier.
(b)Physical seizure of assets shall not be necessary in order to have that particular asset alleged to be forfeitable in a petition under this section. The prosecuting attorney may seek protective orders for any asset pursuant to Section 11492.
(c)The Attorney General or district attorney shall make service of process regarding this petition upon every individual designated in a receipt issued for the property seized. In addition, the Attorney General or district attorney shall cause a notice of the seizure, if any, and of the intended forfeiture proceeding, as well as a notice stating that any interested party may file a verified claim with the superior court of the county in which the property was seized or if the property was not seized, a notice of the initiation of forfeiture proceedings with respect to any interest in the property seized or subject to forfeiture, to be served by personal delivery or by registered mail upon any person who has an interest in the seized property or property subject to forfeiture other than persons designated in a receipt issued for the property seized. Whenever a notice is delivered pursuant to this section, it shall be accompanied by a claim form as described in Section 11488.5 and directions for the filing and service of a claim.
(d)An investigation shall be made by the law enforcement agency as to any claimant to a vehicle, boat, or airplane whose right, title, interest, or lien is of record in the Department of Motor Vehicles or appropriate federal agency. If the law enforcement agency finds that any person, other than the registered owner, is the legal owner thereof, and that ownership did not arise subsequent to the date and time of arrest or notification of the forfeiture proceedings or seizure of the vehicle, boat, or airplane, it shall forthwith send a notice to the legal owner at his or her the owners address appearing on the records of the Department of Motor Vehicles or appropriate federal agency.
(e)When a forfeiture action is filed, the notices shall be published once a week for three successive weeks in a newspaper of general circulation in the county where the seizure was made or where the property subject to forfeiture is located.
(f)All notices shall set forth the time within which a claim of interest in the property seized or subject to forfeiture is required to be filed pursuant to Section 11488.5. The notices shall explain, in plain language, what an interested party must do and the time in which the person must act to contest the forfeiture in a hearing. The notices shall state what rights the interested party has at a hearing. The notices shall also state the legal consequences for failing to respond to the forfeiture notice.
(g)Nothing contained in this chapter shall preclude a person, other than a defendant, claiming an interest in property actually seized from moving for a return of property if that person can show standing by proving an interest in the property not assigned subsequent to the seizure or filing of the forfeiture petition.
(h)(1)If there is an underlying or related criminal action, a defendant may move for the return of the property on the grounds that there is not probable cause to believe that the property is forfeitable pursuant to subdivisions (a) to (g), inclusive, of Section 11470 and is not automatically made forfeitable or subject to court order of forfeiture or destruction by another provision of this chapter. The motion may be made prior to, during, or subsequent to the preliminary examination. If made subsequent to the preliminary examination, the Attorney General or district attorney may submit the record of the preliminary hearing as evidence that probable cause exists to believe that the underlying or related criminal violations have occurred.
(2)Within 15 days after a defendants motion is granted, the people may file a petition for a writ of mandate or prohibition seeking appellate review of the ruling.
(i)(1)With respect to property described in subdivisions (e) and (g) of Section 11470 for which forfeiture is sought and as to which forfeiture is contested, the state or local governmental entity shall have the burden of proving beyond a reasonable doubt that the property for which forfeiture is sought was used, or intended to be used, to facilitate a violation of one of the offenses enumerated in subdivision (f) or (g) of Section 11470.
(2)In the case of property described in subdivision (f) of Section 11470, except cash, negotiable instruments, or other cash equivalents of a value of not less than forty thousand dollars ($40,000), for which forfeiture is sought and as to which forfeiture is contested, the state or local governmental entity shall have the burden of proving beyond a reasonable doubt that the property for which forfeiture is sought meets the criteria for forfeiture described in subdivision (f) of Section 11470.
(3)In the case of property described in paragraphs (1) and (2), where forfeiture is contested, a judgment of forfeiture requires as a condition precedent thereto, that a defendant be convicted in an underlying or related criminal action of an offense specified in subdivision (f) or (g) of Section 11470 which offense occurred within five years of the seizure of the property subject to forfeiture or within five years of the notification of intention to seek forfeiture. If the defendant is found guilty of the underlying or related criminal offense, the issue of forfeiture shall be tried before the same jury, if the trial was by jury, or tried before the same court, if trial was by court, unless waived by all parties. The issue of forfeiture shall be bifurcated from the criminal trial and tried after conviction unless waived by all the parties.
(4)In the case of property described in subdivision (f) of Section 11470 that is cash or negotiable instruments of a value of not less than forty thousand dollars ($40,000), the state or local governmental entity shall have the burden of proving by clear and convincing evidence that the property for which forfeiture is sought is such as is described in subdivision (f) of Section 11470. There is no requirement for forfeiture thereof that a criminal conviction be obtained in an underlying or related criminal offense.
(5)If there is an underlying or related criminal action, and a criminal conviction is required before a judgment of forfeiture may be entered, the issue of forfeiture shall be tried in conjunction therewith. In such a case, the issue of forfeiture shall be bifurcated from the criminal trial and tried after conviction unless waived by the parties. Trial shall be by jury unless waived by all parties. If there is no underlying or related criminal action, the presiding judge of the superior court shall assign the action brought pursuant to this chapter for trial.
(j)The Attorney General or the district attorney of the county in which property is subject to forfeiture under Section 11470 may, pursuant to this subdivision, order forfeiture of personal property not exceeding twenty-five thousand dollars ($25,000) in value. The Attorney General or district attorney shall provide notice of proceedings under this subdivision pursuant to subdivisions (c), (d), (e), and (f), including:
(1)A description of the property.
(2)The appraised value of the property.
(3)The date and place of seizure or location of any property not seized but subject to forfeiture.
(4)The violation of law alleged with respect to forfeiture of the property.
(5)(A)The instructions for filing and serving a claim with the Attorney General or the district attorney pursuant to Section 11488.5 and time limits for filing a claim and claim form.
(B)If no claims are timely filed, the Attorney General or the district attorney shall prepare a written declaration of forfeiture of the subject property to the state and dispose of the property in accordance with Section 11489. A written declaration of forfeiture signed by the Attorney General or district attorney under this subdivision shall be deemed to provide good and sufficient title to the forfeited property. The prosecuting agency ordering forfeiture pursuant to this subdivision shall provide a copy of the declaration of forfeiture to any person listed in the receipt given at the time of seizure and to any person personally served notice of the forfeiture proceedings.
(C)If a claim is timely filed, then the Attorney General or district attorney shall file a petition of forfeiture pursuant to this section within 30 days of the receipt of the claim. The petition of forfeiture shall then proceed pursuant to other provisions of this chapter, except that no additional notice need be given and no additional claim need be filed.
(k)If in any underlying or related criminal action or proceeding, in which a petition for forfeiture has been filed pursuant to this section, and a criminal conviction is required before a judgment of forfeiture may be entered, the defendant willfully fails to appear as required, there shall be no requirement of a criminal conviction as a prerequisite to the forfeiture. In these cases, forfeiture shall be ordered as against the defendant and judgment entered upon default, upon application of the state or local governmental entity. In its application for default, the state or local governmental entity shall be required to give notice to the defendants attorney of record, if any, in the underlying or related criminal action, and to make a showing of due diligence to locate the defendant. In moving for a default judgment pursuant to this subdivision, the state or local governmental entity shall be required to establish a prima facie case in support of its petition for forfeiture.
SEC. 20.Section 11488.5 of the Health and Safety Code is amended to read:11488.5.(a)(1)Any person claiming an interest in the property seized pursuant to Section 11488 may, unless for good cause shown the court extends the time for filing, at any time within 30 days from the date of the last publication of the notice of seizure, if that person was not personally served or served by mail, or within 30 days after receipt of actual notice, file with the superior court of the county in which the defendant has been charged with the underlying or related criminal offense or in which the property was seized or, if there was no seizure, in which the property is located, a claim, verified in accordance with Section 446 of the Code of Civil Procedure, stating his or her the claimants interest in the property. An endorsed copy of the claim shall be served by the claimant on the Attorney General or district attorney, as appropriate, within 30 days of the filing of the claim. The Judicial Council shall develop and approve official forms for the verified claim that is to be filed pursuant to this section. The official forms shall be drafted in nontechnical language, in English and in Spanish, and shall be made available through the office of the clerk of the appropriate court. A claim under this section is an unlimited civil case, regardless of the value of the seized property.
(2)Any person who claims that the property was assigned to him or to her that person prior to the seizure or notification of pending forfeiture of the property under this chapter, whichever occurs last, shall file a claim with the court and prosecuting agency pursuant to Section 11488.5 declaring an interest in that property and that interest shall be adjudicated at the forfeiture hearing. The property shall remain under control of the law enforcement or prosecutorial agency until the adjudication of the forfeiture hearing. Seized property shall be protected and its value shall be preserved pending the outcome of the forfeiture proceedings.
(3)The Notwithstanding any other law, the clerk of the court shall not charge or collect a fee for the filing of a claim in any case in which the value of the respondent property as specified in the notice is five thousand dollars ($5,000) or less. If the value of the property, as specified in the notice, is more than five thousand dollars ($5,000), the clerk of the court shall charge the filing fee specified in Section 70611 of the Government Code.
(4)The claim of a law enforcement agency to property seized pursuant to Section 11488 or subject to forfeiture shall have priority over a claim to the seized or forfeitable property made by the Franchise Tax Board in a notice to withhold issued pursuant to Section 18817 or 26132 18669 or 18670 of the Revenue and Taxation Code.
(b)(1)If at the end of the time set forth in subdivision (a) there is no claim on file, the court, upon motion, shall declare the property seized or subject to forfeiture pursuant to subdivisions (a) to (g), inclusive, of Section 11470 forfeited to the state. In moving for a default judgment pursuant to this subdivision, the state or local governmental entity shall be required to establish a prima facie case in support of its petition for forfeiture. There is no requirement for forfeiture thereof that a criminal conviction be obtained in an underlying or related criminal offense.
(2)The court shall order the money forfeited or the proceeds of the sale of property to be distributed as set forth in Section 11489.
(c)(1)If a verified claim is filed, the forfeiture proceeding shall be set for hearing on a day not less than 30 days therefrom, and the proceeding shall have priority over other civil cases. Notice of the hearing shall be given in the same manner as provided in Section 11488.4. Such a verified claim or a claim filed pursuant to subdivision (j) of Section 11488.4 shall not be admissible in the proceedings regarding the underlying or related criminal offense set forth in subdivision (a) of Section 11488.
(2)The hearing shall be by jury, unless waived by consent of all parties.
(3)The provisions of the Code of Civil Procedure shall apply to proceedings under this chapter unless otherwise inconsistent with the provisions or procedures set forth in this chapter. However, in proceedings under this chapter, there shall be no joinder of actions, coordination of actions, except for forfeiture proceedings, or cross-complaints, and the issues shall be limited strictly to the questions related to this chapter.
(d)(1)At the hearing, the state or local governmental entity shall have the burden of establishing, pursuant to subdivision (i) of Section 11488.4, that the owner of any interest in the seized property consented to the use of the property with knowledge that it would be or was used for a purpose for which forfeiture is permitted, in accordance with the burden of proof set forth in subdivision (i) of Section 11488.4.
(2)No interest in the seized property shall be affected by a forfeiture decree under this section unless the state or local governmental entity has proven that the owner of that interest consented to the use of the property with knowledge that it would be or was used for the purpose charged. Forfeiture shall be ordered when, at the hearing, the state or local governmental entity has shown that the assets in question are subject to forfeiture pursuant to Section 11470, in accordance with the burden of proof set forth in subdivision (i) of Section 11488.4.
(e)The forfeiture hearing shall be continued upon motion of the prosecution or the defendant until after a verdict of guilty on any criminal charges specified in this chapter and pending against the defendant have been decided. The forfeiture hearing shall be conducted in accordance with Sections 190 to 222.5, inclusive, Sections 224 to 234, inclusive, Section 237, and Sections 607 to 630, inclusive, of the Code of Civil Procedure if a trial by jury, and by Sections 631 to 636, inclusive, of the Code of Civil Procedure if by the court. Unless the court or jury finds that the seized property was used for a purpose for which forfeiture is permitted, the court shall order the seized property released to the person it determines is entitled thereto.
If the court or jury finds that the seized property was used for a purpose for which forfeiture is permitted, but does not find that a person claiming an interest therein, to which the court has determined he or she the claimant is entitled, had actual knowledge that the seized property would be or was used for a purpose for which forfeiture is permitted and consented to that use, the court shall order the seized property released to the claimant.
(f)All seized property which that was the subject of a contested forfeiture hearing and which was not released by the court to a claimant shall be declared by the court to be forfeited to the state, provided the burden of proof required pursuant to subdivision (i) of Section 11488.4 has been met. The court shall order the forfeited property to be distributed as set forth in Section 11489.
(g)All seized property which that was the subject of the forfeiture hearing and which was not forfeited shall remain subject to any order to withhold issued with respect to the property by the Franchise Tax Board.
SEC. 21.Section 2620 of the Penal Code is amended to read:2620.(a)When it is necessary to have a person imprisoned in the state prison brought before any court to be tried for a felony, or for an examination before a grand jury or magistrate preliminary to such trial, trial for a felony, or for the purpose of hearing a motion or other proceeding, to vacate a judgment, an order for the prisoners temporary removal from said prison, and for the prisoners production before such the court, grand jury or magistrate, must be made by the superior court of the county in which said the action, motion, or examination is pending or by a judge thereof; such of that court. The order shall be made only upon the affidavit of the district attorney or defense attorney, stating the purpose for which said that person is to be brought before the court, grand jury or magistrate or upon the courts own motion. The order shall be executed by the sheriff of the county in which it shall be made, whose duty it shall be to bring the prisoner before the proper court, grand jury or magistrate, to safely keep the prisoner, and when the prisoners presence is no longer required to return the prisoner to the prison from whence the prisoner was taken; the taken. The expense of executing such that order shall be a proper charge against, and shall be paid by, the county in which the order shall be made.
Such order(b)An order pursuant to subdivision (a) shall recite the purposes for which said that person is to be brought before the court, grand jury or magistrate, and shall be signed by the judge making the order and sealed with the seal of the court. The order must be to the following effect:
County of ____ (as the case may be).
The people of the State of California to the warden of ____:
An order having been made this day by me, that A.B. be produced in the ____ court (or before the grand jury, as the case may be) to be prosecuted or examined for the crime of ____, a felony (or to have said that motion heard), you are commanded to deliver the prisoner into the custody of ____ for the purpose of (recite purposes).
Dated this ____ day of ____, 19__. 20__.
When
(c)When a prisoner is removed from a state prison under this section section, the prisoner shall remain in the constructive custody of the warden thereof. During the prisoners absence from the prison, the prisoner may be ordered to appear in other felony proceedings as a defendant or witness in the courts superior court of the county from which the original order directing removal issued. A copy of the written order directing the prisoner to appear before any such that court shall be forwarded by the district attorney to the warden of the prison having protective custody of the prisoner.
SEC. 22.If a right, privilege, duty, authority, or status, including, but not limited to, a qualification for office, salary range, or employment benefit, is based on a provision of law repealed by this act, and if a statute, order, rule of court, memorandum of understanding, or other legally effective instrument provides that the right, duty, authority, or status continues for a period beyond the effective date of the repeal, that provision of law continues in effect for that purpose, notwithstanding its repeal by this act.
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Aug 15, 2024 | In committee: Held under submission. |
| Jun 24, 2024 | In committee: Referred to suspense file. |
| Jun 12, 2024 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to committee. Read second time, amended, and re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Aug 21, 2023 | In committee: Set, second hearing. Hearing canceled at the request of author. |
| Aug 15, 2023 | In committee: Set, first hearing. Hearing canceled at the request of author. |
| Aug 15, 2023 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to committee. Read second time, amended, and re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Aug 2, 2023 | In committee: Hearing postponed by committee. |
| Jul 13, 2023 | Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Jul 13, 2023 | From committee: Amend, and do pass as amended and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 9. Noes 1.) (July 11). |
| Jul 3, 2023 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to committee. Read second time, amended, and re-referred to Com. on JUD. |
| Jun 13, 2023 | In committee: Set, first hearing. Hearing canceled at the request of author. |
| Jun 12, 2023 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to committee. Read second time, amended, and re-referred to Com. on JUD. |
| May 3, 2023 | Referred to Com. on JUD. |
| Apr 18, 2023 | In Senate. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. |
| Apr 17, 2023 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Senate. (Ayes 79. Noes 0. Page 1181.) |
| Apr 12, 2023 | Read second time. Ordered to Consent Calendar. |
| Apr 11, 2023 | From committee: Do pass. To Consent Calendar. (Ayes 11. Noes 0.) (April 11). |
| Mar 16, 2023 | Referred to Com. on JUD. |
| Mar 3, 2023 | From printer. May be heard in committee April 2. |
| Mar 2, 2023 | Read first time. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Jun 24, 2024 | Placed on suspense file | Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Jul 11, 2023 | Do pass as amended, but first amend, and re-refer to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Senate Standing Committee on Judiciary |
Passed |
|
| Apr 17, 2023 | AB 1757 Judiciary Consent Calendar Second Day Regular Session | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| Apr 11, 2023 | Do pass. To Consent Calendar. | Assembly Standing Committee on Judiciary |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
|
Organization
|
Position
|
Date
|
|---|---|---|
| American Property Casualty Insurance Association | ** Support | |
| Balboa Village Merchants Association | ** Against | |
| California Apartment Association | ** Support | |
| California Association Of Realtors | ** Support | |
| California Business Properties Association | ** Support | |
| California Council Of The Blind | ** Support | |
| California Credit Union League | ** Support | |
| California Foundation For Independent Living Centers | * Support | Jul 11, 2023 |
| California Resident | * Against | Jul 11, 2023 |
| California Restaurant Association | * Support | Jul 11, 2023 |
| California Retailers Association | * Support | Jul 11, 2023 |
| Chinatown Merchants Association | ** Against | |
| City of Belmont | * Against | Jul 11, 2023 |
| City Of Burlingame | * Against | Jul 11, 2023 |
| City of San Francisco | * Against | Jul 11, 2023 |
| Civil Justice Association Of California | * Support | Jul 11, 2023 |
| Coalition for Fair Access | ** Against | |
| Consumer Attorneys Of California | ** Support | |
| Cooperative of American Physicians | ** Support | |
| County Of Los Angeles | * Against | Jul 11, 2023 |
| Daly City | * Against | Jul 11, 2023 |
| Disability Rights Advocates | ** Support | |
| Disability Rights California | * Support | Jul 11, 2023 |
| Disability Rights Education and Defense Fund | ** Support | |
| EcomBack | ** Against | |
| eMainStreet Alliance | * Against | Jul 11, 2023 |
| Falafel Inc | * Against | Jul 11, 2023 |
| Fillmore Merchants Association | ** Against | |
| Goodman’s | ** Against | |
| Hop Wo Benevolent Association | ** Against | |
| Jack Sen Benevolent Association | ** Against | |
| Karlin Law Firm | ** Against | |
| Los Angeles Area Chamber Of Commerce | * Support | Jul 11, 2023 |
| Los Angeles County | * Against | Jul 11, 2023 |
| National Federation Of The Blind Of California | ** Support | |
| Potrero Dogpatch Merchants Association | ** Against | |
| Quong Fook Tong Association | ** Against | |
| RespectAbility | * Support | Jul 11, 2023 |
| San Diego County | * Against | Jul 11, 2023 |
| San Fernando Valley | * Against | Jul 11, 2023 |
| San Mateo County | * Against | Jul 11, 2023 |
| State of New Jersey | * Against | Jul 11, 2023 |
| Trimex reality and Loan | ** Against | |
| Valencia Corridor Merchants Association | ** Against | |
| World Wide Web Consortium | * Against | Jul 11, 2023 |
| Yee Fung Toy Family Association | ** Against |
SENATE COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Senator Anna Caballero, Chair
2023 - 2024 Regular Session
AB 1757 (Kalra) - Accessibility: internet websites
Version: June 12, 2024 | Policy Vote: JUD. 9 - 1 |
Urgency: No | Mandate: No |
Hearing Date: June 24, 2024 | Consultant: Liah Burnley |
Bill Summary:
AB 1757 would create a presumption in state law that if a website of a business entity meets a specified standard, the business entity complies with state accessibility requirements and therefore is not liable for damages. AB 1757 would also authorize attorney’s fees and statutory damages for civil cases related to website accessibility standards.
Fiscal Impact:
- The Department of Justice (DOJ) indicates significant costs (General Fund) of $1,000,000 or less to enforce the provisions of this bill. According to the DOJ, the Civil Rights Enforcement Section (CRES) within the Public Rights Division will be authorized to monitor, investigate and enforce AB 1757. This bill would create the expectation that the DOJ would investigate and bring actions to enforce disability access laws by authorizing the Attorney General and other public prosecutors to bring an action to obtain injunctive or declaratory relief and attorney’s fees and costs to redress inaccessible websites. Enforcement of AB 1757 will require the addition of 1.0 Senior Legal Analyst to evaluate and review websites and claims of violations, analyze them, and make a recommendation for further handling of potential violators. To address the increase in workload, CRES will require 1.0 Senior Legal Analyst and 1.0 Legal Secretary (Legal Complement) beginning in January 1, 2024 and ongoing:
- The Civil Rights Division (CRD) anticipates costs of an unknown but potentially significant amount (General Fund) because to enforce the changes made to the Unruh Act that would result from the bill, as well as litigation costs to the extent that CRD seeks to enforce the bill through civil actions.
- Potentially significant costs (local funds, General Fund) of an unknown amount to cities and counties. This bill would authorize a district attorney, county counsel, or city attorney to enforce its provisions, by bringing a civil action for injunctive or declaratory relief, attorney’s fees and costs. General Fund costs will depend on whether the duties imposed by this bill constitute a reimbursable state mandate, as determined by the Commission on State Mandates.
- Potentially significant costs (Trial Court Trust Fund, General Fund) to the courts to adjudicate cases brought under the new private right of action created by this bill. One eight-hour day of court time has an estimated cost of $8,000. If 50 plaintiffs or public prosecutors bring suits under this bill and each lawsuit take two days of court time to resolve, the resulting cost would be $800,000. Although courts are not funded on the basis of workload, increased pressure on the Trial Court Trust Fund may create a need for increased funding for courts from the General Fund. If funding is not provided for the new workload created by this bill, it may result in delays and prioritization of court cases. For illustrative purposes, the Governor’s 2024-25 state budget proposes $83.1 million ongoing General Fund to continue to backfill the Trial Court Trust Fund for expected revenue declines.
Background:
A business that is a public accommodation is prohibited from discriminating on the basis of disability if its operations affect interstate commerce under the federal Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA). Any business that provides goods or services to the public, such as restaurants, hotels, retail stores, movie theaters, private schools (including housing), theaters, doctors' offices and hospitals, day care centers, gyms, and more are public accommodations. The ADA also applies to websites and apps of public accommodations. Pursuant to the Unruh Civil Rights Act, all persons, regardless of disability or medical condition, are entitled to the full and equal accommodations, advantages, facilities, privileges, or services in all business establishments of every kind. The Unruh Civil Rights Act provides that a violation of the ADA also constitutes a violation of Unruh and subjects a person or entity in violation to actual damages incurred by an injured party, but not less than $4,000, and any attorney’s fees as the court may determine to be proper. There is no specific standard for website compliance with disability law and this has created uncertainty for businesses seeking to comply with law.
As explained by the Senate Judiciary Committee in their analysis of a prior version of this bill:
In the absence of a specific standard for website compliance, courts and government entities sometimes rely on private standards developed by technology and accessibility experts, including the World Wide Web Consortium (W3C), the main international standards organization for the Internet. As part of their Web Accessibility Initiative, W3C has promulgated a series of web accessibility guidelines, including the Web Content Accessibility Guidelines (WCAG). WCAG standards are a set of recommendations for making Web content more accessible, particularly for people with disabilities. The first set of accessibility guidelines, called WCAG 1.0 became a W3C recommendation in May of 1999. The guidelines have been updated since then. WCAG 2.0 was published in December 2008 and became an ISO standard in October 2012. WCAG 2.1 became a W3C Recommendation in June of 2018. WCAG 2.2 is in the process of being developed and could be released this year.
WCAG 2.1 retains WCAG 2.0 in its entirety, but adds 17 additional success criteria to the 2.0 standard. The new success criteria are intended to address viewing of content on mobile devices and provide additional success criteria to improve the experience of individuals with low vision and cognitive impairments. W3C’s overview of the additional success criteria in version 2.1 can be accessed at the WCAG website: https://www.w3.org/WAI/standards-guidelines/wcag/new-in-21/. Regarding the level of compliance within each version of the standard, “Level A is a subset of Level AA. There are 25 criteria that you have to meet to reach Level A. To reach Level AA you have to meet 13 more criteria in addition to the 25 for Level A.”
Courts and government entities have relied upon WCAG standards in addressing accessibility issues and compliance, particularly in settlement agreements and consent decrees.
Proposed Law:
- Authorizes statutory damages for claims against an entity relating to specific accessibility barriers on their internet websites.
- Defines “Entity” as a business establishment that is open to the public, a public place, or a place of public accommodation, as specified.
- Provides that, to recover statutory damages on the basis that an accessibility barrier is a violation of the Unruh Civil Rights Act, a plaintiff must prove, either:
- That they personally encountered a specific barrier that caused them to experience a difference in their ability to access or use the internet website as compared to other users because the internet website was not accessible; or,
- That they were deterred from accessing or using all or part of the internet website or the content of the internet website because the website was not accessible.
- Provides that, in a civil action alleging that an internet website is not accessible, the party who asserts that an entity’s internet website is accessible, as specified, has the burden of proving both:
- That any content that is not accessible is specified exempted content; and,
- Upon request, the entity promptly made the content available to the requester in a format that was accessible to the requester.
- Exempts from liability, any entity that establishes, as an affirmative defense to the claim, as specified.
- Defines “resource service provider” as a person or entity that, in exchange for money or any other form of remuneration, constructs, licenses, distributes, or maintains for online use any internet website or resource to be used within or in conjunction with an internet website.
- Prohibits a resource service provider from doing any of the following:
- Constructing, licensing, distributing, or maintaining for online use an internet website that is not accessible;
- Constructing, licensing, distributing, or maintaining for online use an internet website that, when used by the entity in accordance with any instructions provided by the resource provider, causes an entity’s internet website to be inaccessible; and,
- Making a false representation about a website’s accessibility, as specified.
- Authorizes any individual or entity that pays or contracts with the resources provider to construct, license, distribute, or maintain an internet website that is accessible, to bring a civil lawsuit for any of the above-listed violations.
- Provides that a plaintiff who prevails under these provisions shall be entitled to collect all damages, including, but not limited to, any statutory damages and attorney’s fees and costs paid by the person or entity as a result of a lawsuit against the person or entity, and all costs of bringing their internet website into conformance to the internet website-related accessibility standard.
- Defines internet website-related accessibility standard as the Web Content Accessibility Guidelines (WCAG) 2.2 Level AA standard for the accessibility of internet websites established by the World Wide Web Consortium (W3C) Accessibility Guidelines Working Group on June 5, 2018, or the accessibility standards for Section 508 of the federal Rehabilitation Act of 1973 (29 U.S.C. Sec. 794d) in Part 1194 of Title 36 of the Code of Federal Regulations. To the extent that there is a difference or conflict between the applicable standards for internet websites under WCAG 2.2 Level AA and standards for information or communication technology under federal law, the more stringent standard shall apply.
- Authorizes the Attorney General, the CRD, or a district attorney, county counsel, or city attorney to enforce these provisions, by bringing an action for injunctive or declaratory relief, attorney’s fees and costs.
- Authorizes any individual with a disability that is harmed as a result of a violation, and any organization that represents individuals with disabilities, to bring a civil action for a violation of these provisions, and allows the plaintiff to obtain injunctive or declaratory relief, attorney’s fees and costs.
- Prohibits contract provisions between an individual or entity and a resource service provider that seek to waive liability for violations specified in this bill and makes such contract provisions void as a matter of public policy.
Related Legislation:
- AB 1404 (W. Carrillo), Chapter 842, Statues of 2023, requires plaintiff who serves lawsuits alleging inaccessibility of an internet website to provide the defendant a standard notice about the defendant’s rights and obligations regarding internet website accessibility.
- AB 950 (Maienschein), of the 2023-2024 Legislative Session, was substantially similar to this bill. AB 950 was held under submission in Assembly Appropriations Committee.
-- END --
Senator Thomas Umberg, Chair
2023-2024 Regular Session
Bill No: AB 1757 (Author:Committee on Judiciary)
Version: July 3, 2023
Hearing Date: July 11, 2023
Fiscal: Yes
Urgency: No
Consultant: ME
SUBJECT
Accessibility: internet websites
DIGEST
This bill creates a presumption in state law that a website that meets a specified standard complies with state accessibility requirements.
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
A business that is a public accommodation is prohibited from discriminating on the basis of disability if its operations affect interstate commerce under the federal Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA). The ADA also applies to websites and apps of public accommodations. Pursuant to the Unruh Civil Rights Act, all persons, regardless of disability or medical condition, are entitled to the full and equal accommodations, advantages, facilities, privileges, or services in all business establishments of every kind. The Unruh Civil Rights Act provides that a violation of the ADA also constitutes a violation of Unruh and subjects a person or entity in violation to actual damages incurred by an injured party, but not less than $4,000, and any attorney’s fees as the court may determine to be proper. There is no specific standard for website compliance with disability law and this has created uncertainty for businesses seeking to comply with law. Some reports indicate that threats of litigation and actual litigation are on the rise with regard to internet website compliance under disability law. The Assembly Committee on Judiciary introduced this bill in response to reports to the Committee of increased website accessibility litigation, especially with regard to small businesses.
In an effort to help small businesses comply with the law regarding website disability access and to ensure more websites are accessible, this bill seeks to encourage businesses to create websites that comply with a specified website standard. Under this bill, if the business’ website complies with a specified standard then there is a rebuttable presumption that the business complies with state accessibility requirements and therefore the business is not liable for damages available under the ADA and Unruh Civil Rights Act. Specifically, this bill creates a presumption in state law that a website of a business entity that meets the WCAG 12.1 Level AA standard and avails itself of the rebuttable presumption described above. This bill allows a person who is denied access to a website to bring a civil cause of action against a person who negligently, intentionally or knowingly built an inaccessible website. Additionally, the bill allows a business that hires such a website designer to recover any statutory damages and attorney’s fees paid to website users; and allows public prosecutors to enforce the law by obtaining injunctive relief.
This bill is supported by the Civil Justice Association of California, the California Apartment Association, the California Restaurant Association, and other organizations that support and advocate for businesses. The bill is also supported by a coalition of advocates for disability rights, including the National Federation of the Blind of California, the California Council of the Blind, Disability Rights California, and others. It is opposed by the Karlin Law Firm, a website development business, some merchants associations, some benevolent associations, a few businesses, and 8 individual opponents. The bill is nearly identical to AB 950 (Committee on Judiciary, 2023), which was held in the Assembly Appropriations Committee because of the fiscal portion of AB 950 that is not in AB 1757. AB 950 passed out of the Assembly Judiciary Committee with a vote of 11 to 0.
PROPOSED CHANGES TO THE LAW
Existing law:
- Provides, pursuant to the federal Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA), that no individual shall be discriminated against on the basis of disability in the full and equal enjoyment of the goods, services, facilities, privileges, advantages, or accommodations of any place of public accommodation by any person who owns, leases, or leases to, or operates a place of public accommodation. (42 U.S.C. § 12182.)
- Pursuant to Section 508 of the federal Rehabilitation Act, all federal agencies, when they develop, procure, maintain, or use electronic and information technology, must give disabled employees and members of the public access to information that is comparable to access available to others. (29 U.S.C. § 794 d.)
- Holds, pursuant to case law, that the websites and apps of businesses that are public places or places of public accommodation are governed by the ADA, which "applies to the services of a place of public accommodation, not services in a place of public accommodation.” (Nat'l Fed'n of the Blind v. Target Corp. (N.D. Cal. 2006) 452 F. Supp. 2d 946, 953.)
- Pursuant to the Unruh Civil Rights Act, provides that all persons, regardless of sex, race, color, religion, ancestry, national origin, disability or medical condition, are entitled to the full and equal accommodations, advantages, facilities, privileges, or services in all business establishments of every kind; provides that a violation of the ADA also constitutes a violation of Unruh; and subjects a person or entity in violation to actual damages incurred by an injured party, treble actual damages but not less than $4,000, and any attorney’s fees as the court may determine to be proper. (Civ. Code § 51 et seq.)
- Provides, pursuant to the Disabled Persons Act, that individuals with disabilities or medical conditions have the same right as the general public to the full and free use of the streets, highways, sidewalks, walkways, public buildings, medical facilities, including hospitals, clinics and physicians’ offices, public facilities and other public places, and also provides that a violation of an individual’s rights under the ADA constitutes a violation of state law. (Civ. Code § 54.)
- Entitles individuals with disabilities to full and equal access to public accommodations, subject only to the conditions and limitations established by law, or state or federal regulation, and applicable alike to all persons. (Civ. Code § 54.1.)
This bill:
- Defines “Internet website-related accessibility standard” as the Web Content Accessibility Guidelines (WCAG) 2.1 Level AA standard for the accessibility of internet websites established by the World Wide Web Consortium (W3C) Accessibility Guidelines Working Group on June 5, 2018, or the accessibility standards for Section 508 of the federal Rehabilitation Act of 1973 (29 U.S.C. Sec. 794d) in Part 1194 of Title 36 of the Code of Federal Regulations. To the extent that there is a difference or conflict between the applicable standards for internet websites under WCAG 2.1 Level AA and standards for information or communication technology under Section 508 of the federal Rehabilitation Act of 1973, the more recent WCAG 2.1 Level AA standard shall apply, unless a more stringent update, revision, or replacement to the accessibility standards for Section 508 of the federal Rehabilitation Act of 1973 (29 U.S.C. Sec. 794d) in Part 1194 of Title 36 of the Code of Federal Regulations is adopted by any final rule of the federal Access Board after the date of the enactment of this section, in which case that final rule shall apply to this section.
- Defines “resource service provider” as a person or entity that, in exchange for money or any other form of remuneration, constructs, licenses, distributes, or maintains for online use any internet website or resource to be used within or in conjunction with an internet website.
- Defines “entity” as a business establishment that is open to the public, a public place, or a place of public accommodation or any other business or place that is subject to the provisions of Sections 51, 54, or 54.1.
- Defines “conform” to mean that the entity’s internet website meets the criteria specified by the applicable internet website-related accessibility standard, as defined in paragraph (4). For purposes of the Web Content Accessibility Guidelines (WCAG) 2.1 Level AA standard for the accessibility of internet websites established by the World Wide Web Consortium (W3C) Accessibility Guidelines Working Group on June 5, 2018, an entity conforms to that standard when the entity’s internet website meets all of the Success Criteria set forth in the standard.
- Provides that the term “Internet website” includes all internet web-based technology, including, but not limited to, a mobile site or application, or an app, that can be accessed by a mobile device or other electronic devise.
- Provides that statutory damages under subdivision (a) of either Section 52 or Section 54.3 shall only be recovered against an entity based upon the inaccessibility of an internet website developed, procured, maintained, or used by that entity if the internet website fails to provide equally effective communication or facilitate full and equal enjoyment of the entity’s goods and services to all members of the public, including any member of the public who is a person with a disability.
- Provides that a plaintiff must prove one of the following in order to be entitled to statutory damages for internet website inaccessibility: that the plaintiff personally encountered a barrier that caused the plaintiff to experience a difference in their ability to access or use the website as compared to other users such that the plaintiff was unable to acquire the same information, engage in the same interactions, or enjoy the same services with substantially equivalent ease of use, or to have the same level of privacy and independence as other users who are not persons with a disability; or that the plaintiff was deterred from accessing all or part of the website or the content of the website because of the website’s failure to provide equally effective communication or to facilitate full and equal enjoyment of the entity’s goods and services offered to the public.
- Provides that an internet website is presumed to provide equally effective communication for the purpose of determining whether an award of statutory damages is warranted under subdivision (a) of Section 52 or 54.3, if the internet website, taking into account the variety of conforming implementations that may be used to meet the internet website-related accessibility standard, conforms to the internet website-related accessibility standard.
- Specifies that the presumption set forth in 8) affects the plaintiff’s burden of proof. Specifies that upon the defendant establishing by a preponderance of the evidence that the internet website conforms to the internet website-related accessibility standard, the plaintiff may rebut the presumption with clear and convincing evidence, showing that, notwithstanding the internet website’s compliance with the standard, the elements of one of the violations set forth in 7) are established.
- Specifies that this bill is not intended to: limit the rights and remedies available to persons with a disability under federal law, or any other state law; affect whether an entity is responsible under either Section 51 or 51.5 for making its premises accessible to all members of the public, including persons with a disability and including by means of accessing and using the entity’s internet website; resolve, or otherwise address, whether an internet website that is a standalone website-only business and not associated with a business that has a physical location in California is subject to liability under Sections 51, 54, and 54.1; establish a presumption of liability, affect the burden of proof, or otherwise impact a court’s determination of liability when an internet website does not conform to the internet website-related accessibility standard and in which case the presumption established in 8) therefore would not apply; require an entity to conform to the internet website-related accessibility standard; or demonstrate an intent by the Legislature, in enacting this section, to deprive or limit the exercise of jurisdiction by federal courts over state law claims brought in conjunction with any federal claim under the Americans with Disabilities Act (42 U.S.C. Sec. 12101 et seq.) or other federal law.
- Provides that the above provisions apply to civil actions filed on or after January 1, 2024.
- Provides that it is unlawful for any resource service provider, in exchange for money or any other form of remuneration, to do either of the following: intentionally, negligently, or knowingly construct, license, distribute, or maintain for online use, an internet website that fails to conform to the internet website-related accessibility standard; or intentionally, negligently, or recklessly make a false representation that an internet website conforms to the internet website-related accessibility standard.
- Provides that a person who is unable to obtain equally effective communication or full and equal enjoyment of an internet website, the content of an internet website, or goods and services offered to the public on an internet website, as a result of the violation, may bring a civil action against a resource service provider for violating 12). The remedies for this violation are the remedies provided in subdivision (a) of Section 52.
- Provides that a person or entity that pays, compensates, or contracts with, the resource service provider to construct, license, distribute, or maintain an internet website for the purpose of providing equally effective communication or facilitating full and equal enjoyment of the person or entity’s goods and services to all members of the public, including any member of the public who is a person with a disability, may bring a civil action against a resource service provider for violating 12).
- Provides that if a plaintiff prevails under 14) then the plaintiff shall be entitled to collect all damages, including, but not limited to, any statutory damages and attorney’s fees paid by the person or entity as a result of a lawsuit against the person or entity pursuant to Sections 51, 54, and 54.1, based upon the inaccessibility of the person or entity’s website, and all costs of bringing their internet website into conformance to the internet website-related accessibility standard.
- Provides that the Attorney General or a district attorney, county counsel, or city attorney may bring an action against a resource service provider to obtain injunctive or declaratory relief and attorney’s fees and costs.
- Provides that a provision within a contract between a person or entity and a resource service provider that seeks to waive liability under this section, or otherwise shift the liability to a person or entity that pays, compensates, or contracts with the resource service provider, as described, is void as a matter of public policy and subject to subdivision (c) of Section 51.7.
- Provides that this section does not limit or alter the application of other laws, including, but not limited to, Sections 51, 54, and 54.1, or the ability of a plaintiff to bring a civil action under any other theory of the law, including, but not limited to, breach of contract, implied warranty of merchantability, or false or deceptive advertising.
- Provides that the provisions regarding resource service providers in this bill are not intended to do any of the following: limit the rights and remedies available to a person with disabilities under the federal law or any other state law; affect whether an entity is responsible under either Section 51 or 51.5 for making its premises accessible to all members of the public, including persons with a disability and including by means of accessing and using the entity’s internet website; resolve, or otherwise address, whether an internet website that is a standalone website-only business and not associated with a business that has a physical location in California is subject to liability under Sections 51, 54, and 54.1; establish a presumption of liability, affect the burden of proof, or otherwise impact a court’s determination of liability when an internet website does not conform to the internet website-related accessibility standard; require an entity to conform to the internet website-related accessibility standard; or demonstrate an intent by the Legislature, in enacting this section, to deprive or limit the exercise of jurisdiction by federal courts over state law claims brought in conjunction with any federal claim under the Americans with Disabilities Act (42 U.S.C. Sec. 12101 et seq.) or other federal law.
COMMENTS
- Stated need for the bill
According to the author:
[AB 1757] would help address internet website accessibility for persons with disabilities by creating presumption in state law that if the website of a business meets WCAG standards developed by the World Wide Web Consortium (W3C), it complies with California’s Unruh Civil Rights Act and Disabled Persons Act. By creating this rebuttable presumption, the bill would reduce litigation over whether business’ websites are ADA compliant.
By providing appropriate liability protections for ensuring accessible websites and providing a clear standard for being in compliance, AB 950 would result in greater accessibility and reduced litigation regarding the accessibility of websites.
The California Apartment Association, in support of the bill writes:
I am writing to extend CAA’s support for AB 1757, your bill that would create a legal presumption that a business website that meets the existing compliance standard developed by the World Wide Web Consortium (W3C Standard) complies with accessibility requirements for business websites in California. Unfortunately, litigious attorneys are abusing the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) by suing businesses with claims of ADA violations for failure to make their websites accessible to the public. AB 1757 would curtail this activity by codifying a widely used compliance standard for businesses to follow. The W3C Standard was adopted in 2018 and has been the compliance standard for state websites for the past five years. By applying an objective standard for businesses to follow, AB 1757 strikes a balance between business interests and consumer protection in a commonsense manner.
A coalition of advocates for disability rights, including the National Federation of the Blind of California, the California Council of the Blind, and others, writes the following in support of this bill:
This bill is the result of negotiation between disability advocates and the business community. It presents a balanced, reasoned approach to website accessibility litigation that promotes access for people with disabilities while also protecting businesses from frivolous litigation and unscrupulous providers of website products and services.
The undersigned organizations envision a world where all disabled people have power and are treated with dignity and respect. Such a world is only possible when people with disabilities have equal access to the information, resources, services, and products that are available to others. In today’s world, website accessibility is a critical component of equal access.
AB 1757 advances the goals of the Americans with Disabilities Act and California’s civil rights laws. Equity, inclusion, and access are key principles that disability advocates continue to hold as central to our work. Ensuring that websites are accessible to people with disabilities—and that aggrieved individuals have an avenue for recourse when they are not—advances these principles.
AB 1757 brings us closer to the world we seek to bring into fruition. In this world, people with disabilities are supported, valued, included in their communities, afforded the same opportunities as people without disabilities, and make their own decisions.
The Civil Justice Association of California, California Restaurant Association, in a coalition with other groups, writes the following in support of AB 1757:
A growing trend in ADA lawsuits is in website accessibility; in California alone, we saw a 23% spike in lawsuits from 2019 to 2020.1 The absence of clear standards in the digital space has spawned this wave of litigation. While there are a few recent California court decisions that helped provide guidance and mitigate some lawsuit filings, many businesses continue to get hit with suits and demand letters. These lawsuits not only harm small business owners but also undermine the original intent of the ADA.
AB 1757 attempts to address these shakedown lawsuits by giving businesses guidelines for how a website can be accessible to those with communication disabilities. We appreciate the Assembly Judiciary Committee for their efforts to help businesses that are trying to ensure website accessibility for their customers and to protect themselves against lawsuits.
CJAC and other business groups have argued for years that we need federal guidelines that give businesses clear direction on website accessibility so they can avoid needless lawsuits and those with communication barriers can have full and fair access to website content. We believe in reforms that make the ADA more accessible and effective for those it was designed to protect, while also reducing the number of frivolous lawsuits that only serve to hurt businesses and consumers.
2. Expands legislative efforts to provide relief to small businesses
California’s disability access laws have long operated to ensure that people with disabilities can utilize businesses and places of public accommodation in this state. In spite of their important civil rights functions, these laws have sometimes generated controversy due to a high-volume of claims made by a relatively small group of litigants and law firms. One way the Legislature has addressed this issue is through the California Certified Access Specialist Program. Under this program businesses can request a trained inspector to examine their establishment and point out any changes that are needed to ensure compliance with disability access standards. If the business proceeds to undertake necessary upgrades, the business receives temporary immunity from disability access lawsuits.
SB 269 (Roth, Ch. 13, Stats. 2016), was enacted to protect businesses with 50 or fewer employees from liability for minimum statutory damages in a construction-related accessibility claim for the 120-day period after the business has obtained an inspection of its premises by a CASp, allowing the business to identify and correct violations during that period. SB 269 also established a presumption that certain “technical violations” of construction-related accessibility standards (such as faded paint on parking spaces or missing signage) do not constitute grounds for a complaint under Unruh as long as those violations are corrected within 15 days of the business owner being notified about them. AB 2093 (Steinorth, Ch. 379, Stats. 2016), was enacted to require a commercial property owner to disclose on every lease form or rental agreement, whether or not the property being leased has undergone inspection by a CASp. AB 1521 (Committee on Judiciary, Ch. 755, Stat. 2015) was enacted to provide additional information and legal resources to small business owners to help them minimize their liability for ADA violations. It also limited the practice of high-volume lawsuits motivated by quick settlement with business owners, rather than correction of ADA violations.
As stated above, existing law provides certain protections to businesses who actively seek out a CASp inspection prior to being sued for construction-related accessibility violations. These small businesses are entitled to a 90-day stay and an early evaluation conference. They also qualify for reduced minimum statutory damages of $1000 per violation if the violations are corrected within 120 days. In addition, existing law extends similar protections to small businesses that have not had a CASp inspection. These small businesses qualify for minimum statutory damages of $2000 per violation if the violations are cured within 30 days.
In an effort to help small businesses comply with the law regarding website disability access and to ensure more websites are accessible, this bill creates a rebuttable presumption in state law that a website of a business entity that meets a specific standard (WCAG 12.1 Level AA) conforms to state accessibility requirements and therefore is not liable for damages. Additionally, a civil cause of action can be brought by a business or a public prosecutor against a person who intentionally, negligently, or knowingly builds an inaccessible website. These provisions will ensure that a business that takes steps under the statute to make their websites accessible will be able to operate without being under threat of litigation.
There is no specific standard for website compliance with disability law and this has created uncertainty for businesses seeking to comply with law. Some reports indicate that threats of litigation and actual litigation are on the rise with regard to internet website compliance under disability law. The Assembly Committee on Judiciary introduced this bill in response to reports to the Committee of increased website accessibility litigation, especially with regard to small businesses.
3. WCAG
As explained by the Assembly Judiciary Committee in their analysis of AB 950 (Committee on Judiciary, 2023):
In the absence of a specific standard for website compliance, courts and government entities sometimes rely on private standards developed by technology and accessibility experts, including the World Wide Web Consortium (W3C), the main international standards organization for the Internet. As part of their Web Accessibility Initiative, W3C has promulgated a series of web accessibility guidelines, including the Web Content Accessibility Guidelines (WCAG). WCAG standards are a set of recommendations for making Web content more accessible, particularly for people with disabilities. The first set of accessibility guidelines, called WCAG 1.0 became a W3C recommendation in May of 1999. The guidelines have been updated since then. WCAG 2.0 was published in December 2008 and became an ISO standard in October 2012. WCAG 2.1 became a W3C Recommendation in June of 2018. WCAG 2.2 is in the process of being developed and could be released this year.
WCAG 2.1 retains WCAG 2.0 in its entirety, but adds 17 additional success criteria to the 2.0 standard. The new success criteria are intended to address viewing of content on mobile devices and provide additional success criteria to improve the experience of individuals with low vision and cognitive impairments. W3C’s overview of the additional success criteria in version 2.1 can be accessed at the WCAG website: https://www.w3.org/WAI/standards-guidelines/wcag/new-in-21/. Regarding the level of compliance within each version of the standard, “Level A is a subset of Level AA. There are 25 criteria that you have to meet to reach Level A. To reach Level AA you have to meet 13 more criteria in addition to the 25 for Level A.” (https://myaccessible.website/blog/wcaglevels/wcag-levels-a-aa-aaa-difference.)
Courts and government entities have relied upon WCAG standards in addressing accessibility issues and compliance, particularly in settlement agreements and consent decrees. For example:
- In 2013, DOJ entered into a settlement agreement with Louisiana Tech University that encompassed not only the University’s website, but also all electronic and information technology, instructional materials and online courses. (See Settlement Agreement with Louisiana Tech University, DJ #204-33-116 (July 22, 2013), available at https://www.ada.gov/louisiana-tech.htm.)
- In 2014, the National Federal of the Blind and DOJ entered into a consent decree with HRB Digital LLC and HRB Tax Group, Inc., agreeing that H&R Block’s website and apps would comply with the WCAG 2.0 AA standards by January 1, 2016. (National Federation of the Blind, et al v. HRB Digital LLC and HRB Tax Group, Inc., Civil Action No. 1:13-cv-10799-GAO, United States District Court for the State of Massachusetts, Boston Division, Consent Decree – available at https://www.ada.gov/hrb-cd.htm.)
- In August of 2016, DOJ notified the University of California, Berkeley, that large segments of its free, publicly available audio and video content (including its YouTube channel, iTunes U platform, and Open Online Courses) were not accessible to individuals with hearing, vision, or manual disabilities. The letter observed that, “While the University of California’s Information Technology Accessibility Policy adopts the WCAG 2.0 AA technical standard, which provides clear parameters for ensuring online content is accessible to individuals with disabilities, UC Berkeley has not ensured compliance with its policy.” (See Letter dated August 30, 2016 to University of California, Berkeley, available at https://www.ada.gov/briefs/uc_berkley_lof.pdf.)
- In November of 2018, the National Federation of the Blind announced a settlement agreement with Alameda County, California, in which the county agreed to utilize WCAG 2.1 AA in making its election website accessible. (See https://www.nfb.org/about-us/press-room/alameda-county-will-make-voting-more-accessible-blind.)
- In January of 2019, the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals observed in Robles that “the district court can order compliance with WCAG 2.0 as an equitable remedy if, after discovery, the website and app fail to satisfy the ADA.” (Robles, supra, 913 F.3d at p. 907.)
4. Opposition
In opposition, the Karlin Law Firm writes:
The bill, while laudable in its attempt to address the problem of a lack of standards and safe harbors in this critical area, not only falls short, but it has the complete opposite effect by indirectly suggesting that the WCAG guidelines are somehow objective, testable, standards that are easily measured. They are not by any stretch of the imagination. The proponents of the bill seem to believe that compliance with any version of WCAG can be measured by some simple test. It cannot. The WCAG was not designed to be a testable, measurable standard, but instead was designed only as a set of “guidelines,” with the understanding that compliance with “guidelines” is often, if not always, a matter of opinion. In short, the so-called “safe harbor” contained in the bill is none at all, but in fact, is a dangerous bay filled with hidden reefs that will destroy any vessel that enters. [ . . . ]
Assembly Bill 1757 (“AB 1757”), in part, would indirectly elevate Web Content Accessibility Guidelines 2.1 (“WCAG 2.1”) as some type of safe harbor and thereby suggesting by implication that it is one “standard” for determining website accessibility. The “G” in WCAG refers not to any type of objective or measurable standard, but rather to set of “Guidelines.”
In opposition, EcomBack writes:
On behalf of EcomBack, a website accessibility development firm that helps small businesses build and remediate website accessibility, I write to express our deep concerns regarding Assembly Bill 1757 (“AB 1757”), which would codify Web Content Accessibility Guidelines 2.1 AA (“WCAG 2.1”) as the standard for determining website accessibility. We have helped over 75 businesses make their websites accessible over the past year and understand the nuances and technicalities of website accessibility. We find it appalling that AB 1757 is a Gut & Amend of AB 950 which was put in the suspense file, and all costs that were associated with the bill were gutted from the text.
WCAG 2.1 has never been approved as a set of workable standards or guidelines for determining a website’s compliance with the ADA, has been rejected as a minimum standard of compliance by the Ninth Circuit in Robles v. Domino's Pizza, LLC, 913 F.3d 898, 905 (9th Cir. 2019), and is directly contrary to the standard set by Robles (“impedes access to the goods and services of the physical [location]”) for determining whether a website complies with the Americans with Disabilities Act (“ADA”). By adopting WCAG 2.1 as the standard for website accessibility which almost no websites actually meet and permitting statutory damages of $4,000 for each “visit” to a website and specifically permitting lawsuits against website designers and others, this amendment will open the floodgates for Unruh Act litigation in California against businesses, especially small and micro businesses still recovering from the COVID-19 pandemic.
In response, the author asserts:
It is inaccurate to say—as EcomBack alleges-- that WCAG guidelines have “never been approved as a set of workable standards or guidelines for determining a website’s compliance with the ADA.” In fact, courts and government entities repeatedly have relied upon WCAG guidelines as standards for compliance, including in consent decrees and court settlements. The history of reliance upon WCAG guidelines as a standard for website accessibility is discussed in detail in the Assembly Judiciary Committee’s analysis of AB 950 (Maienschein), this bill’s predecessor. Furthermore, for the past five years, the State of California has relied upon WCAG guidelines to verify that websites of its agencies are accessible, requiring each agency to certify their compliance with WCAG guidelines.
It also is inaccurate to say —as EcomBack alleges-- that WCAG guidelines were “rejected as a minimum standard of compliance by the Ninth Circuit in Robles v. Domino's Pizza, LLC, 913 F.3d 898, 905 (9th Cir. 2019).” In fact, the Ninth Circuit observed in a footnote of its decision in that case that, “WCAG 2.0 guidelines have been widely adopted, including by federal agencies, which conform their public-facing, electronic content to WCAG 2.0 level A and level AA Success Criteria.” (Robles, supra, at p. 902, fn. 1.) The Ninth Circuit reversed the district court’s dismissal of the plaintiff’s complaint against Domino’s, alleging a violation of the ADA based upon accessibility issues with Domino’s website and app based in part on non-compliance with WCAG guidelines; sent the case back to the district court; expressed no opinion about whether or not Domino's website or app complied with the ADA; and observed that “the district court can order compliance with WCAG 2.0 as an equitable remedy if, after discovery, the website and app fail to satisfy the ADA.” (Robles, supra, 913 F.3d at p. 907 [emphasis added].)
It seems clear that the aspect of AB 1757 that EcomBack, a website development firm, really objects to is its provision imposing liability on website development firms when they “intentionally or knowingly” design websites which do not comply with WCAG guidelines. Yet this provision will demonstrably help small businesses that now face sole liability for access violations. It is a fair way to spread liability and costs, especially after a small business hires a website design company to make its website accessible. As a whole, this bill will assist virtually all businesses (except perhaps website design firms like EcomBack) by clarifying the law and providing an important presumption against liability for those businesses that choose to design websites in compliance with WCAG 2.0 guidelines.
SUPPORT
American Property Casualty Insurance Association
California Apartment Association
California Association of Realtors
California Business Properties Association
California Council of the Blind
California Credit Union League
Californians for Disability Rights, Inc.
California Foundation for Independent Living Centers
California Restaurant Association
Civil Justice Association of California
Consumer Attorneys of California
Cooperative of American Physicians
Disability Rights Advocates
Disability Rights California
Disability Rights Education and Defense Fund
Los Angeles Area Chamber of Commerce
National Federation of the Blind of California
OPPOSITION
Balboa Village Merchants Association
Chinatown Merchants Association
Coalition for Fair Access
EcomBack[1]
Fillmore Merchants Association
Goodman’s
Hop Wo Benevolent Association
Jack Sen Benevolent Association
Karlin Law Firm
Potrero Dogpatch Merchants Association
Quong Fook Tong Association
Trimex reality and Loan
Valencia Corridor Merchants Association
Yee Fung Toy Family Association
8 Individuals who own or manage small businesses
RELATED LEGISLATION
Pending Legislation:
AB 950 (Committee on Judiciary, 2023) is substantially similar to this bill and was held on suspense in the Assembly Appropriations Committee.
AB 1404 (Carrillo, 2023) is a companion bill to AB 1757 and requires specified notice to be provided in website accessibility demand letters. AB 1404 is scheduled to heard on the same day as this bill.
Prior Legislation:
AB 2123 (Chau, 2019) was similar to AB 1757. The bill would have created a presumption in state law that a website of a business that meets WCAG 2.1 Level A and AA standards complies with state accessibility requirements. The bill was not heard at the author’s request and died without a hearing in the Assembly Judiciary Committee.
AB 434 (Baker, Ch. 780, Stats. 2017) requires the director of each state agency or entity and the chief information officer of that state agency or entity to biennially post on the home page of the agency’s or entity’s Internet Web site a signed certification that the agency’s or entity’s Internet Web site is in compliance with specified accessibility standards. The signed certification must specify that the director and chief information officer have determined that the Internet Web site is in compliance with Sections 7405 and 11135, and the Web Content Accessibility Guidelines 2.0, or a subsequent version, published by the Web Accessibility Initiative of the World Wide Web Consortium at a minimum Level AA success criteria.
PRIOR VOTES:
This bill was gut and amended on June 12, 2023 to address a different topic, thus all prior votes are irrelevant.
**************
The Committee received a letter from the President of EcomBack listing forty-one organizations and businesses that the President asserts are in opposition to AB 1757. These 41 entities are not listed as opposition in the analysis because the Committee was not provided with individual names or signatures affiliated with the entities. A copy of this letter is on file with the Committee. ↑
Date of Hearing: April 11, 2023
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON JUDICIARY
Brian Maienschein, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 1757
Author:(Committee on Judiciary) – As Introduced Ver:March 2, 2023
proposed consent
SUBJECT: Court consolidation
KEY ISSUE: SHOULD THE LEGISLATURE MAKE SEVERAL NON-SUBSTANTIVE AND CONFORMING UPDATES TO VARIOUS CODES AFFECTED BY TRIAL COURT CONSOLIDATION?
SYNOPSIS
California’s trial court system was extensively restructured slightly more than twenty years ago. As a result, hundreds of provisions throughout the codes became obsolete, in whole or in part. In 2001, the Legislature directed the California Law Revision Commission to review the codes and make recommendations about how to remove the obsolete provisions. The Commission has been working on this vast code clean-up project ever since. For various reasons, a few projects remain unfinished. This straightforward and uncontroversial bill would make the remaining non-substantive revisions in a handful of key areas: (1) statutes relating to judicial benefits; (2) statutes relating to representation and indemnification of trial courts and court personnel; and (3) statutes relating to the jurisdictional classification of drug forfeiture cases.
This bill contains proposals from the California Law Revision Commission, an independent state agency that assists the Legislature and the Governor by examining California law and recommending needed reforms. This bill has no support or opposition on file.
SUMMARY: Makes numerous non-substantive and non-controversial changes to existing statutes affected by trial court unification. Specifically, this bill:
- Removes outdated references to the, now nonexistent, municipal courts and municipal court personnel.
- Removes provisions concerning travel expenses of certain large county court personnel, in lieu of new provisions on business-related travel expenses of trial court judges and employees.
- Establishes that in Los Angeles County (“county of the first class”), where a court determines that the best interests of the court would be served, it may assign an automobile in lieu of allowing travel expenses.
- Establishes the automatic repeal of certain provisions specifying benefits for municipal judges in 50 years, in order to ensure that obsolete provisions are removed, without disrupting any existing rights of former municipal court judges and their beneficiaries.
- Establishes that the Judicial Council is permitted to insure courts and its personnel from liability for claims resulting from any act or omission in the scope of employment, and to insure against the expense of defending such a claim.
- Repeals as obsolete a provision requiring a district attorney to defend a court or judge, if named as a defendant in their official capacity.
- Establishes that a county counsel may, at the request of Judicial Counsel, represent a superior court judge in matters concerning the judge or the court’s official capacity.
- Repeals as obsolete a provision that entitles a judge who is entitled to district attorney representation, but has a conflict of interest, to recover reasonable attorney’s fees and expenses from the appropriate public entity.
- Makes non-substantive clarifications to statutes governing representation and indemnification of trial courts and trial personnel.
- Revises provisions relating to drug forfeiture cases to clarify that such cases are unlimited civil cases, regardless of the value of the seized property.
- Clarifies that the filing fees in drug forfeiture cases apply notwithstanding any other law.
- Eliminates several out of date and erroneous cross references.
EXISTING LAW:
- Authorizes a county, in specified circumstances, to permit superior and municipal court personnel to participate in a deferred compensation plan and authorizes deductions from their wages for that purpose. (Government Code Section 53214.5. All further statutory references are to the Government Code, unless otherwise specified.)
- Allows for reimbursement of necessary travel expenses of certain court personnel “in each county having a population over 2,000,000.” (Section 69894.4.)
- Allows the board of supervisors in a county having a population over 2,000,000 to assign an automobile in lieu of allowing travel expenses. (Ibid.)
- Establishes certain benefits for municipal court judges. (Sections 73640, 73642, 73950, 73952, 74130, 74145, 74340, 74342, 74740, 74742.)
- Establishes certain benefits to municipal court judges retired under the Judges’ Retirement System. (Section 77210.)
- Permits a county to insure superior and municipal court personnel against liability resulting from any act or omission in the scope of their employment, and to insure against the expense of defending such a claim. (Section 990.2.)
- Requires a district attorney to represent a superior or a municipal court, or a judge of such a court, upon request by such a judge, if the court or judge in official capacity is a defendant in any action. (Section 26524.)
- Requires a county counsel, in counties that have a county counsel, to discharge certain duties relating to representation that are otherwise vested in the district attorney. (Section 26529.)
- Permits a county counsel to represent the local superior court or a judge of that court in specified circumstances. (Section 27647.)
- Entitles a judge, who has a conflict of interest, but is otherwise entitled to representation, to recover from the appropriate public entity any reasonably incurred attorney’s fees, costs, and expenses. (Section 27648.)
- Permits the county counsel and the Attorney General to provide representation of defense for the Judicial Council. (Section 811.9.)
- Provides that whenever any judge of any court of the state is a witness in his official capacity as judge in any action or proceeding, he is entitled to be represented by a counsel of his choice. (Section 68111.)
- Directs the Attorney General or district attorney to file a petition of forfeiture with the superior court. (Health and Safety Code Section 11488.4.)
- Directs a person claiming seized property to file a claim with the superior court. (Health and Safety Code Section 11488.5.)
- Establishes that there is no fee for filing a claim for seized property valued at or less than $5,000, and that a fee applies for filing a claim for seized property valued at more than $5,000 (Ibid.)
FISCAL EFFECT: As currently in print this bill is keyed non-fiscal.
COMMENTS: Makes several non-substantive and non-controversial reforms to California’s statutes to reflect the restructuring of trial courts.
According to the Chair of the Judiciary Committee, author of this bill:
AB 1757 updates California’s statutes to remove obsolete references to municipal courts that no longer exist following the court unification process. It also clarifies that jurisdictional classification of a drug asset forfeiture proceeding is an unlimited civil case, regardless of the value of the seized property. Previously, classification of these cases occurred based on different factors, which resulted in misclassifications and confusion. This would not make a substantive change, nor endorse or condemn the existing drug asset forfeiture statute – it would just provide clarification to avoid jurisdictional mistakes.
History of trial court restructuring. California’s trial court system underwent significant restructuring around the turn of the century. In the late 1990s, each county had one superior court and one or more municipal courts. The municipal courts were courts of limited jurisdiction, which was specified by statute as constitutionally required. In a municipal court case, the maximum amount in controversy was $25,000 and there were also other limitations on the types of relief that could be awarded. Each county also had a superior court, which had original jurisdiction in all types of causes except those given by statute to the municipal courts. There was no maximum amount in controversy in the superior court, nor was the superior court subject to the limitations on types of relief that applied in the municipal courts. These courts were county-operated and funded. In the following few years, the county-oriented system was reformed, with the goal of improving efficiency, decreasing costs, and enhancing equity.
Trial court unification. In 1998, California voters passed a constitutional amendment that permitted the municipal and superior courts in each county to unify their operations in the superior court upon a vote of a majority of the county’s municipal court judges and a majority of the county’s superior court judges. By early 2001, the trial courts in all of California’s counties had unified. Each county now has a unified superior court, which handles all trial court operations in that county.
Through unification, the original jurisdiction of the superior courts expanded to include both (1) the types of civil cases traditionally brought in municipal court; and (2) the types of civil cases traditionally brought in superior court. Superior courts maintained procedural distinctions between those types of cases, by creating limited civil cases, those where the amount in controversy is less than $25,000, and unlimited civil cases, which involved claims in excess of $25,000.
Judicial benefits. When the Law Revision Commission began its recommendations concerning trial court restructuring, it proposed several revisions to statutes on judicial benefits. Those were withdrawn after it was determined that the area was unsettled and warranted further study. In the past two decades, there have been many developments in the area, including in particular work by a Judicial Council advisory committee on judicial service, a series of lawsuits over supplemental judicial benefits (extra benefits that some counties provide to local trial court judges in addition to their state compensation), a Judicial Council study on disparities in judicial benefits across the state, and related legislation. It was determined on the basis of those developments that the substance of those statutes did not need to be reformed. Thus, this bill does not make any substantive amendments to the provisions dealing with judicial benefits; it makes amendments to remove obsolete references to the municipal courts and ensure that benefits of municipal personnel are not interrupted in retirement.
Representation and indemnification. Trial court restructuring also included switching trial court operations from county-funding to state-funding. This meant that provisions relating to legal representation of court employees and reimbursement of costs associated with providing representation needed to be amended. Many of these areas of law remained unsettled during the initial restructuring. Since then, there have been extensive developments, such as amending the Government Claims Act, which specifically addresses these issues of representation and indemnification. Although the Government Claims Act has already been extensively and repeatedly revised to account for trial court restructuring, this bill makes further statutory revisions necessary to fully conform the codes to the current approach concerning representation and indemnification of trial courts and trial court employees.
Drug asset forfeiture proceedings. Pursuant to Health and Safety Code Sections 11469 to 11495, in some circumstances, a law enforcement officer is permitted to seize certain property connected with an unlawful drug activity (such as equipment used in manufacturing an unlawful drug, a vehicle used in transporting an unlawful drug, or the unlawful drug itself). The seized property may thereafter be subject to forfeiture to the state or local government. Proceeds from forfeited property are typically used to support state and local law enforcement. Health and Safety Code Sections 11469 to 11495 do not expressly say whether a drug asset forfeiture proceeding is a limited civil case or an unlimited civil case. But the statutes authorizing these drug seizures do expressly refer to filing of a petition in superior court. These statutory references predate the unification of the municipal and superior courts, and thus it follows that drug seizure petitions should be treated as an unlimited civil case and the procedures for an unlimited civil case apply, unless specifically stated otherwise. This bill does not address the substantive merits of California’s existing approach to drug asset seizures and forfeitures; it merely clarifies that these petitions should be treated as unlimited civil cases. This will reduce confusion, prevent misclassifications, and minimize waste of judicial resources in remedying these wasteful and preventable misclassifications.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
None on file
Opposition
None on file
Analysis Prepared by: Shiran Zohar / JUD. / (916) 319-2334
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):