AB 2099: Crimes: reproductive health services.
- Session Year: 2023-2024
- House: Assembly
- Latest Version Date: 2024-09-28
Current Status:
Passed
(2024-09-28: Chaptered by Secretary of State - Chapter 821, Statutes of 2024.)
Introduced
In Committee
First Chamber
In Committee
Second Chamber
Enacted
Existing law makes it a crime to post personal information or an image of a reproductive health care services patient, provider, or assistant, or other individuals residing at the same home address with the intent that another person imminently use that information to commit a crime involving violence or a threat of violence against the reproductive health care services patient, provider, or assistant, or other individuals residing at the same home address. Existing law makes a violation of this provision punishable as a misdemeanor. If the violation leads to bodily injury of the person, existing law makes it a misdemeanor punishable by up to one year in a county jail, a fine of up to $50,000, or both that fine and imprisonment.
This bill would make a violation of these provisions punishable as either a misdemeanor or as a felony, and would make a violation a felony if bodily injury occurs. By increasing the punishment for a crime, this bill would impose a state-mandated local program.
Existing law makes it a misdemeanor to, by force or threat of force, willfully injure, intimidate, interfere with, oppress, or threaten another person in the free exercise or enjoyment of a right or privilege secured by the Constitution or laws of this state or by the Constitution or laws of the United States in whole or in part because of one or more of specified actual or perceived characteristics of the victim, including disability, gender, religion, race, or sexual orientation.
This bill would make a violation of this provision punishable either as a misdemeanor or as a felony. By increasing the punishment for a crime, this bill would impose a state-mandated local program.
Existing law, the California Freedom of Access to Clinic and Church Entrances Act (the Act), prohibits specified actions that, by force, threat of force, or physical obstruction, impede access to reproductive health services facilities, as defined. Existing law specifies the penalties for a violation of the Act, including imprisonment as a misdemeanor and specified fines.
This bill would increase the penalties for violations of the Act, including making specified violations punishable as either a misdemeanor or as a felony. By increasing the punishment for a crime, this bill would impose a state-mandated local program.
The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.
This bill would provide that no reimbursement is required by this act for a specified reason.
Existing law makes it a crime to post personal information or an image of a reproductive health care services patient, provider, or assistant, or other individuals residing at the same home address with the intent that another person imminently use that information to commit a crime involving violence or a threat of violence against the reproductive health care services patient, provider, or assistant, or other individuals residing at the same home address. Existing law makes a violation of this provision punishable as a misdemeanor. If the violation leads to bodily injury of the person, existing law makes it a misdemeanor punishable by up to one year in a county jail, a fine of up to $50,000, or both that fine and imprisonment.
This bill would make a violation of these provisions punishable as either a misdemeanor or as a felony, and would make a violation a felony if bodily injury occurs. By increasing the punishment for a crime, this bill would impose a state-mandated local program.
Existing law makes it a misdemeanor to, by force or threat of force, willfully injure, intimidate, interfere with, oppress, or threaten another person in the free exercise or enjoyment of a right or privilege secured by the Constitution or laws of this state or by the Constitution or laws of the United States in whole or in part because of one or more of specified actual or perceived characteristics of the victim, including disability, gender, religion, race, or sexual orientation.
This bill would make a violation of this provision punishable either as a misdemeanor or as a felony. By increasing the punishment for a crime, this bill would impose a state-mandated local program.
Existing law, the California Freedom of Access to Clinic and Church Entrances Act (the Act), prohibits specified actions that, by force, threat of force, or physical obstruction, impede access to reproductive health services facilities, as defined. Existing law specifies the penalties for a violation of the Act, including imprisonment as a misdemeanor and specified fines.
This bill would increase the penalties for violations of the Act, including making specified violations punishable as either a misdemeanor or as a felony. By increasing the punishment for a crime, this bill would impose a state-mandated local program.
The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.
This bill would provide that no reimbursement is required by this act for a specified reason.
Existing law makes it a crime to post personal information or an image of a reproductive health care services patient, provider, or assistant, or other individuals residing at the same home address with the intent that another person imminently use that information to commit a crime involving violence or a threat of violence against the reproductive health care services patient, provider, or assistant, or other individuals residing at the same home address. Existing law makes a violation of this provision punishable as a misdemeanor. If the violation leads to bodily injury of the person, existing law makes it a misdemeanor punishable by up to one year in a county jail, a fine of up to $50,000, or both that fine and imprisonment.
This bill would make a violation of these provisions punishable as either a misdemeanor or as a felony, and would make a violation a felony if bodily injury occurs. By increasing the punishment for a crime, this bill would impose a state-mandated local program.
Existing law makes it a misdemeanor to, by force or threat of force, willfully injure, intimidate, interfere with, oppress, or threaten another person in the free exercise or enjoyment of a right or privilege secured by the Constitution or laws of this state or by the Constitution or laws of the United States in whole or in part because of one or more of specified actual or perceived characteristics of the victim, including disability, gender, religion, race, or sexual orientation.
This bill would make a violation of this provision punishable either as a misdemeanor or as a felony. By increasing the punishment for a crime, this bill would impose a state-mandated local program.
Existing law, the California Freedom of Access to Clinic and Church Entrances Act (the Act), prohibits specified actions that, by force, threat of force, or physical obstruction, impede access to reproductive health services facilities, as defined. Existing law specifies the penalties for a violation of the Act, including imprisonment as a misdemeanor and specified fines.
This bill would increase the penalties for violations of the Act, including making specified violations punishable as either a misdemeanor or as a felony. By increasing the punishment for a crime, this bill would impose a state-mandated local program.
The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.
This bill would provide that no reimbursement is required by this act for a specified reason.
Existing law makes it a crime to post personal information or an image of a reproductive health care services patient, provider, or assistant, or other individuals residing at the same home address with the intent that another person imminently use that information to commit a crime involving violence or a threat of violence against the reproductive health care services patient, provider, or assistant, or other individuals residing at the same home address. Existing law makes a violation of this provision punishable as a misdemeanor. If the violation leads to bodily injury of the person, existing law makes it a misdemeanor punishable by up to one year in a county jail, a fine of up to $50,000, or both that fine and imprisonment.
This bill would make a violation of these provisions punishable as either a misdemeanor or as a felony, and would make a violation a felony if bodily injury occurs. By increasing the punishment for a crime, this bill would impose a state-mandated local program.
Existing law makes it a misdemeanor to, by force or threat of force, willfully injure, intimidate, interfere with, oppress, or threaten another person in the free exercise or enjoyment of a right or privilege secured by the Constitution or laws of this state or by the Constitution or laws of the United States in whole or in part because of one or more of specified actual or perceived characteristics of the victim, including disability, gender, religion, race, or sexual orientation.
This bill would make a violation of this provision punishable either as a misdemeanor or as a felony. By increasing the punishment for a crime, this bill would impose a state-mandated local program.
Existing law, the California Freedom of Access to Clinic and Church Entrances Act (the Act), prohibits specified actions that, by force, threat of force, or physical obstruction, impede access to reproductive health services facilities, as defined. Existing law specifies the penalties for a violation of the Act, including imprisonment as a misdemeanor and specified fines.
This bill would increase the penalties for violations of the Act, including making specified violations punishable as either a misdemeanor or as a felony. By increasing the punishment for a crime, this bill would impose a state-mandated local program.
The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.
This bill would provide that no reimbursement is required by this act for a specified reason.
(a)(1)A person shall not post on the internet or social media, with the intent that another person imminently use that information to commit a crime involving violence or a threat of violence against a reproductive health care services patient, provider, or assistant, or other individuals residing at the same home address, the personal information or image of a reproductive health care services patient, provider, or assistant, or other individuals residing at the same home address.
(2)A violation of this subdivision is punishable by a fine of up to ten thousand dollars ($10,000) per violation, imprisonment of either up to one year in a county jail or pursuant to subdivision (h) of Section 1170 of the Penal Code, or by both that fine and imprisonment.
(3)A violation of this subdivision that leads to the bodily injury of a reproductive health care services patient, provider, or assistant, or other individuals residing at the same home address, is a felony punishable by a fine of up to fifty thousand dollars ($50,000), imprisonment pursuant to subdivision (h) of Section 1170 of the Penal Code, or by both that fine and imprisonment.
(b)Nothing in this section shall preclude prosecution under any other provision of law.
SEC. 2.Section 422.6 of the Penal Code is amended to read:422.6.(a)A person, whether or not acting under color of law, shall not, by force or threat of force, willfully injure, intimidate, interfere with, oppress, or threaten any other person in the free exercise or enjoyment of a right or privilege secured by the Constitution or laws of this state or by the Constitution or laws of the United States in whole or in part because of one or more of the actual or perceived characteristics of the victim listed in subdivision (a) of Section 422.55.
(b)A person, whether or not acting under color of law, shall not knowingly deface, damage, or destroy the real or personal property of any other person for the purpose of intimidating or interfering with the free exercise or enjoyment of a right or privilege secured by the Constitution or laws of this state or by the Constitution or laws of the United States, in whole or in part because of one or more of the actual or perceived characteristics of the victim listed in subdivision (a) of Section 422.55.
(c)A person convicted of violating subdivision (a) or (b) shall be punished either by imprisonment in a county jail not to exceed one year, or by a fine not to exceed five thousand dollars ($5,000), or by both the above imprisonment and fine, or pursuant to subdivision (h) of Section 1170. In addition to that punishment, the court shall order the defendant to perform a minimum of community service, not to exceed 400 hours, to be performed over a period not to exceed 350 days, during a time other than the persons hours of employment or school attendance. However, a person shall not be convicted of violating subdivision (a) based upon speech alone, except upon a showing that the speech itself threatened violence against a specific person or group of persons and that the defendant had the apparent ability to carry out the threat.
(d)Conduct that violates this and any other law, including, but not limited to, an offense described in Article 4.5 (commencing with Section 11410) of Chapter 3 of Title 1 of Part 4, may be charged under all applicable provisions. However, an act or omission punishable in different ways by this section and another law shall not be punished under more than one law, and the penalty to be imposed shall be determined as set forth in Section 654.
SEC. 3.Section 423.3 of the Penal Code is amended to read:423.3.(a)A first violation of subdivision (c), (d), (g), or (h) of Section 423.2 is a misdemeanor, punishable by imprisonment in a county jail for a period of not more than one year, or a fine not to exceed ten thousand dollars ($10,000), or by both that fine and imprisonment.
(b)A second or subsequent violation of subdivision (c), (d), (g), or (h) of Section 423.2 is punishable by imprisonment in a county jail for a period of not more than one year, or by imprisonment pursuant to subdivision (h) of Section 1170, or a fine not to exceed twenty-five thousand dollars ($25,000), or by both that fine and imprisonment.
(c)A first violation of subdivision (e) or (f) of Section 423.2 is a felony, punishable by imprisonment pursuant to subdivision (h) of Section 1170, or a fine not to exceed twenty-five thousand dollars ($25,000), or by both that fine and imprisonment.
(d)A first violation of subdivision (a) or (b) of Section 423.2 is a misdemeanor, punishable by imprisonment in a county jail for a period of not more than one year, or a fine not to exceed twenty-five thousand dollars ($25,000), or by both that fine and imprisonment.
(e)A second or subsequent violation of subdivision (a), (b), (e), or (f) of Section 423.2 is a felony, punishable by imprisonment pursuant to subdivision (h) of Section 1170, or a fine not to exceed fifty thousand dollars ($50,000), or by both that fine and imprisonment.
(f)In imposing fines pursuant to this section, the court shall consider applicable factors in aggravation and mitigation set out in Rules 4.421 and 4.423 of the California Rules of Court, and shall consider a prior violation of the federal Freedom of Access to Clinic Entrances Act of 1994 (18 U.S.C. Sec. 248), or a prior violation of a statute of another jurisdiction that would constitute a violation of Section 423.2 or of the federal Freedom of Access to Clinic Entrances Act of 1994, to be a prior violation of Section 423.2.
(g)This title establishes concurrent state jurisdiction over conduct that is also prohibited by the federal Freedom of Access to Clinic Entrances Act of 1994 (18 U.S.C. Sec. 248), which provides for misdemeanor penalties for first violations and felony-misdemeanor penalties for second and subsequent violations. State law enforcement agencies and prosecutors shall cooperate with federal authorities in the prevention, apprehension, and prosecution of these crimes, and shall seek federal prosecutions when appropriate.
(h)No person shall be convicted under this article for conduct in violation of Section 423.2 that was done on a particular occasion where the identical conduct on that occasion was the basis for a conviction of that person under the federal Freedom of Access to Clinic Entrances Act of 1994 (18 U.S.C. Sec. 248).
SEC. 4.No reimbursement is required by this act pursuant to Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution because the only costs that may be incurred by a local agency or school district will be incurred because this act creates a new crime or infraction, eliminates a crime or infraction, or changes the penalty for a crime or infraction, within the meaning of Section 17556 of the Government Code, or changes the definition of a crime within the meaning of Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution.
(a)(1)A person shall not post on the internet or social media, with the intent that another person imminently use that information to commit a crime involving violence or a threat of violence against a reproductive health care services patient, provider, or assistant, or other individuals residing at the same home address, the personal information or image of a reproductive health care services patient, provider, or assistant, or other individuals residing at the same home address.
(2)A violation of this subdivision is punishable by a fine of up to ten thousand dollars ($10,000) per violation, imprisonment of either up to one year in a county jail or pursuant to subdivision (h) of Section 1170 of the Penal Code, or by both that fine and imprisonment.
(3)A violation of this subdivision that leads to the bodily injury of a reproductive health care services patient, provider, or assistant, or other individuals residing at the same home address, is a felony punishable by a fine of up to fifty thousand dollars ($50,000), imprisonment pursuant to subdivision (h) of Section 1170 of the Penal Code, or by both that fine and imprisonment.
(b)Nothing in this section shall preclude prosecution under any other provision of law.
SEC. 2.Section 422.6 of the Penal Code is amended to read:422.6.(a)A person, whether or not acting under color of law, shall not, by force or threat of force, willfully injure, intimidate, interfere with, oppress, or threaten any other person in the free exercise or enjoyment of a right or privilege secured by the Constitution or laws of this state or by the Constitution or laws of the United States in whole or in part because of one or more of the actual or perceived characteristics of the victim listed in subdivision (a) of Section 422.55.
(b)A person, whether or not acting under color of law, shall not knowingly deface, damage, or destroy the real or personal property of any other person for the purpose of intimidating or interfering with the free exercise or enjoyment of a right or privilege secured by the Constitution or laws of this state or by the Constitution or laws of the United States, in whole or in part because of one or more of the actual or perceived characteristics of the victim listed in subdivision (a) of Section 422.55.
(c)A person convicted of violating subdivision (a) or (b) shall be punished either by imprisonment in a county jail not to exceed one year, or by a fine not to exceed five thousand dollars ($5,000), or by both the above imprisonment and fine, or pursuant to subdivision (h) of Section 1170. In addition to that punishment, the court shall order the defendant to perform a minimum of community service, not to exceed 400 hours, to be performed over a period not to exceed 350 days, during a time other than the persons hours of employment or school attendance. However, a person shall not be convicted of violating subdivision (a) based upon speech alone, except upon a showing that the speech itself threatened violence against a specific person or group of persons and that the defendant had the apparent ability to carry out the threat.
(d)Conduct that violates this and any other law, including, but not limited to, an offense described in Article 4.5 (commencing with Section 11410) of Chapter 3 of Title 1 of Part 4, may be charged under all applicable provisions. However, an act or omission punishable in different ways by this section and another law shall not be punished under more than one law, and the penalty to be imposed shall be determined as set forth in Section 654.
SEC. 3.Section 423.3 of the Penal Code is amended to read:423.3.(a)A first violation of subdivision (c), (d), (g), or (h) of Section 423.2 is a misdemeanor, punishable by imprisonment in a county jail for a period of not more than one year, or a fine not to exceed ten thousand dollars ($10,000), or by both that fine and imprisonment.
(b)A second or subsequent violation of subdivision (c), (d), (g), or (h) of Section 423.2 is punishable by imprisonment in a county jail for a period of not more than one year, or by imprisonment pursuant to subdivision (h) of Section 1170, or a fine not to exceed twenty-five thousand dollars ($25,000), or by both that fine and imprisonment.
(c)A first violation of subdivision (e) or (f) of Section 423.2 is a felony, punishable by imprisonment pursuant to subdivision (h) of Section 1170, or a fine not to exceed twenty-five thousand dollars ($25,000), or by both that fine and imprisonment.
(d)A first violation of subdivision (a) or (b) of Section 423.2 is a misdemeanor, punishable by imprisonment in a county jail for a period of not more than one year, or a fine not to exceed twenty-five thousand dollars ($25,000), or by both that fine and imprisonment.
(e)A second or subsequent violation of subdivision (a), (b), (e), or (f) of Section 423.2 is a felony, punishable by imprisonment pursuant to subdivision (h) of Section 1170, or a fine not to exceed fifty thousand dollars ($50,000), or by both that fine and imprisonment.
(f)In imposing fines pursuant to this section, the court shall consider applicable factors in aggravation and mitigation set out in Rules 4.421 and 4.423 of the California Rules of Court, and shall consider a prior violation of the federal Freedom of Access to Clinic Entrances Act of 1994 (18 U.S.C. Sec. 248), or a prior violation of a statute of another jurisdiction that would constitute a violation of Section 423.2 or of the federal Freedom of Access to Clinic Entrances Act of 1994, to be a prior violation of Section 423.2.
(g)This title establishes concurrent state jurisdiction over conduct that is also prohibited by the federal Freedom of Access to Clinic Entrances Act of 1994 (18 U.S.C. Sec. 248), which provides for misdemeanor penalties for first violations and felony-misdemeanor penalties for second and subsequent violations. State law enforcement agencies and prosecutors shall cooperate with federal authorities in the prevention, apprehension, and prosecution of these crimes, and shall seek federal prosecutions when appropriate.
(h)No person shall be convicted under this article for conduct in violation of Section 423.2 that was done on a particular occasion where the identical conduct on that occasion was the basis for a conviction of that person under the federal Freedom of Access to Clinic Entrances Act of 1994 (18 U.S.C. Sec. 248).
SEC. 4.No reimbursement is required by this act pursuant to Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution because the only costs that may be incurred by a local agency or school district will be incurred because this act creates a new crime or infraction, eliminates a crime or infraction, or changes the penalty for a crime or infraction, within the meaning of Section 17556 of the Government Code, or changes the definition of a crime within the meaning of Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution.
(a)(1)A person shall not post on the internet or social media, with the intent that another person imminently use that information to commit a crime involving violence or a threat of violence against a reproductive health care services patient, provider, or assistant, or other individuals residing at the same home address, the personal information or image of a reproductive health care services patient, provider, or assistant, or other individuals residing at the same home address.
(2)A violation of this subdivision is punishable by a fine of up to ten thousand dollars ($10,000) per violation, imprisonment of either up to one year in a county jail or pursuant to subdivision (h) of Section 1170 of the Penal Code, or by both that fine and imprisonment.
(3)A violation of this subdivision that leads to the bodily injury of a reproductive health care services patient, provider, or assistant, or other individuals residing at the same home address, is a felony punishable by a fine of up to fifty thousand dollars ($50,000), imprisonment pursuant to subdivision (h) of Section 1170 of the Penal Code, or by both that fine and imprisonment.
(b)Nothing in this section shall preclude prosecution under any other provision of law.
SEC. 2.Section 422.6 of the Penal Code is amended to read:422.6.(a)A person, whether or not acting under color of law, shall not, by force or threat of force, willfully injure, intimidate, interfere with, oppress, or threaten any other person in the free exercise or enjoyment of a right or privilege secured by the Constitution or laws of this state or by the Constitution or laws of the United States in whole or in part because of one or more of the actual or perceived characteristics of the victim listed in subdivision (a) of Section 422.55.
(b)A person, whether or not acting under color of law, shall not knowingly deface, damage, or destroy the real or personal property of any other person for the purpose of intimidating or interfering with the free exercise or enjoyment of a right or privilege secured by the Constitution or laws of this state or by the Constitution or laws of the United States, in whole or in part because of one or more of the actual or perceived characteristics of the victim listed in subdivision (a) of Section 422.55.
(c)A person convicted of violating subdivision (a) or (b) shall be punished either by imprisonment in a county jail not to exceed one year, or by a fine not to exceed five thousand dollars ($5,000), or by both the above imprisonment and fine, or pursuant to subdivision (h) of Section 1170. In addition to that punishment, the court shall order the defendant to perform a minimum of community service, not to exceed 400 hours, to be performed over a period not to exceed 350 days, during a time other than the persons hours of employment or school attendance. However, a person shall not be convicted of violating subdivision (a) based upon speech alone, except upon a showing that the speech itself threatened violence against a specific person or group of persons and that the defendant had the apparent ability to carry out the threat.
(d)Conduct that violates this and any other law, including, but not limited to, an offense described in Article 4.5 (commencing with Section 11410) of Chapter 3 of Title 1 of Part 4, may be charged under all applicable provisions. However, an act or omission punishable in different ways by this section and another law shall not be punished under more than one law, and the penalty to be imposed shall be determined as set forth in Section 654.
SEC. 3.Section 423.3 of the Penal Code is amended to read:423.3.(a)A first violation of subdivision (c), (d), (g), or (h) of Section 423.2 is, is a misdemeanor, punishable by imprisonment in a county jail for a period of not more than one year or by imprisonment pursuant to subdivision (h) of Section 1170, year, or a fine not to exceed ten thousand dollars ($10,000), or by both that fine and imprisonment.
(b)A second or subsequent violation of subdivision (c), (d), (g), or (h) of Section 423.2 is a felony, punishable by imprisonment in a county jail for a period of not more than one year, or by imprisonment pursuant to subdivision (h) of Section 1170, or a fine not to exceed twenty-five thousand dollars ($25,000), or by both that fine and imprisonment.
(c)A first violation of subdivision (e) or (f) of Section 423.2 is a felony, punishable by imprisonment pursuant to subdivision (h) of Section 1170, or a fine not to exceed twenty-five thousand dollars ($25,000), or by both that fine and imprisonment.
(d)A first violation of subdivision (a) or (b) of Section 423.2 is a misdemeanor, punishable by imprisonment in a county jail for a period of not more than one year, or a fine not to exceed twenty-five thousand dollars ($25,000), or by both that fine and imprisonment.
(e)A second or subsequent violation of subdivision (a), (b), (e), or (f) of Section 423.2 is a felony, punishable by imprisonment pursuant to subdivision (h) of Section 1170, or a fine not to exceed fifty thousand dollars ($50,000), or by both that fine and imprisonment.
(f)In imposing fines pursuant to this section, the court shall consider applicable factors in aggravation and mitigation set out in Rules 4.421 and 4.423 of the California Rules of Court, and shall consider a prior violation of the federal Freedom of Access to Clinic Entrances Act of 1994 (18 U.S.C. Sec. 248), or a prior violation of a statute of another jurisdiction that would constitute a violation of Section 423.2 or of the federal Freedom of Access to Clinic Entrances Act of 1994, to be a prior violation of Section 423.2.
(g)This title establishes concurrent state jurisdiction over conduct that is also prohibited by the federal Freedom of Access to Clinic Entrances Act of 1994 (18 U.S.C. Sec. 248), which provides for misdemeanor penalties for first violations and felony-misdemeanor penalties for second and subsequent violations. State law enforcement agencies and prosecutors shall cooperate with federal authorities in the prevention, apprehension, and prosecution of these crimes, and shall seek federal prosecutions when appropriate.
(h)No person shall be convicted under this article for conduct in violation of Section 423.2 that was done on a particular occasion where the identical conduct on that occasion was the basis for a conviction of that person under the federal Freedom of Access to Clinic Entrances Act of 1994 (18 U.S.C. Sec. 248).
SEC. 4.No reimbursement is required by this act pursuant to Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution because the only costs that may be incurred by a local agency or school district will be incurred because this act creates a new crime or infraction, eliminates a crime or infraction, or changes the penalty for a crime or infraction, within the meaning of Section 17556 of the Government Code, or changes the definition of a crime within the meaning of Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution.
(a)(1)A person shall not post on the internet or social media, with the intent that another person imminently use that information to commit a crime involving violence or a threat of violence against a reproductive health care services patient, provider, or assistant, or other individuals residing at the same home address, the personal information or image of a reproductive health care services patient, provider, or assistant, or other individuals residing at the same home address.
(2)A violation of this subdivision is a misdemeanor punishable by a fine of up to ten thousand dollars ($10,000) per violation, imprisonment of either up to one year in a county jail, jail or pursuant to subdivision (h) of Section 1170 of the Penal Code, or by both that fine and imprisonment.
(3)A violation of this subdivision that leads to the bodily injury of a reproductive health care services patient, provider, or assistant, or other individuals residing at the same home address, is a misdemeanor felony punishable by a fine of up to fifty thousand dollars ($50,000), imprisonment in a county jail not exceeding one year, pursuant to subdivision (h) of Section 1170 of the Penal Code, or by both that fine and imprisonment.
(b)Nothing in this section shall preclude prosecution under any other provision of law.
SEC. 2.Section 422.6 of the Penal Code is amended to read:422.6.(a)No A person, whether or not acting under color of law, shall not, by force or threat of force, willfully injure, intimidate, interfere with, oppress, or threaten any other person in the free exercise or enjoyment of any a right or privilege secured to him or her by the Constitution or laws of this state or by the Constitution or laws of the United States in whole or in part because of one or more of the actual or perceived characteristics of the victim listed in subdivision (a) of Section 422.55.
(b)No A person, whether or not acting under color of law, shall not knowingly deface, damage, or destroy the real or personal property of any other person for the purpose of intimidating or interfering with the free exercise or enjoyment of any a right or privilege secured to the other person by the Constitution or laws of this state or by the Constitution or laws of the United States, in whole or in part because of one or more of the actual or perceived characteristics of the victim listed in subdivision (a) of Section 422.55.
(c)Any A person convicted of violating subdivision (a) or (b) shall be punished either by imprisonment in a county jail not to exceed one year, or by a fine not to exceed five thousand dollars ($5,000), or by both the above imprisonment and fine, and or pursuant to subdivision (h) of Section 1170. In addition to that punishment, the court shall order the defendant to perform a minimum of community service, not to exceed 400 hours, to be performed over a period not to exceed 350 days, during a time other than his or her the persons hours of employment or school attendance. However, no a person may shall not be convicted of violating subdivision (a) based upon speech alone, except upon a showing that the speech itself threatened violence against a specific person or group of persons and that the defendant had the apparent ability to carry out the threat.
(d)Conduct that violates this and any other provision of law, including, but not limited to, an offense described in Article 4.5 (commencing with Section 11410) of Chapter 3 of Title 1 of Part 4, may be charged under all applicable provisions. However, an act or omission punishable in different ways by this section and other provisions of another law shall not be punished under more than one provision, law, and the penalty to be imposed shall be determined as set forth in Section 654.
SEC. 3.Section 423.3 of the Penal Code is amended to read:423.3.(a)A first violation of subdivision (c), (d), (g), or (h) of Section 423.2 is a misdemeanor, punishable by imprisonment in a county jail for a period of not more than one year, year or by imprisonment pursuant to subdivision (h) of Section 1170, or a fine not to exceed ten thousand dollars ($10,000), or both that fine and imprisonment.
(b)A second or subsequent violation of subdivision (c), (d), (g), or (h) of Section 423.2 is a misdemeanor, felony, punishable by imprisonment in a county jail for a period of not more than one year, pursuant to subdivision (h) of Section 1170, or a fine not to exceed twenty-five thousand dollars ($25,000), or by both that fine and imprisonment.
(c)A first violation of subdivision (e) or (f) of Section 423.2 is a misdemeanor, felony, punishable by imprisonment in a county jail for a period of not more than one year, pursuant to subdivision (h) of Section 1170, or a fine not to exceed twenty-five thousand dollars ($25,000), or by both that fine and imprisonment.
(d)A first violation of subdivision (a) or (b) of Section 432.2 423.2 is a misdemeanor, punishable by imprisonment in a county jail for a period of not more than one year, or a fine not to exceed twenty-five thousand dollars ($25,000), or by both that fine and imprisonment.
(e)A second or subsequent violation of subdivision (a), (b), (e), or (f) of Section 423.2 is a misdemeanor, felony, punishable by imprisonment in a county jail for a period of not more than one year, pursuant to subdivision (h) of Section 1170, or a fine not to exceed fifty thousand dollars ($50,000), or by both that fine and imprisonment.
(f)In imposing fines pursuant to this section, the court shall consider applicable factors in aggravation and mitigation set out in Rules 4.421 and 4.423 of the California Rules of Court, and shall consider a prior violation of the federal Freedom of Access to Clinic Entrances Act of 1994 (18 U.S.C. Sec. 248), or a prior violation of a statute of another jurisdiction that would constitute a violation of Section 423.2 or of the federal Freedom of Access to Clinic Entrances Act of 1994, to be a prior violation of Section 423.2.
(g)This title establishes concurrent state jurisdiction over conduct that is also prohibited by the federal Freedom of Access to Clinic Entrances Act of 1994 (18 U.S.C. Sec. 248), which provides for misdemeanor penalties for first violations and felony-misdemeanor penalties for second and subsequent violations. State law enforcement agencies and prosecutors shall cooperate with federal authorities in the prevention, apprehension, and prosecution of these crimes, and shall seek federal prosecutions when appropriate.
(h)No person shall be convicted under this article for conduct in violation of Section 423.2 that was done on a particular occasion where the identical conduct on that occasion was the basis for a conviction of that person under the federal Freedom of Access to Clinic Entrances Act of 1994 (18 U.S.C. Sec. 248).
SEC. 4.No reimbursement is required by this act pursuant to Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution because the only costs that may be incurred by a local agency or school district will be incurred because this act creates a new crime or infraction, eliminates a crime or infraction, or changes the penalty for a crime or infraction, within the meaning of Section 17556 of the Government Code, or changes the definition of a crime within the meaning of Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution.
REVISIONS: HeadingLine 2. CORRECTIONS: HeadingLine 2.|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Sep 28, 2024 | Chaptered by Secretary of State - Chapter 821, Statutes of 2024. |
| Sep 28, 2024 | Approved by the Governor. |
| Sep 10, 2024 | Enrolled and presented to the Governor at 4:30 p.m. |
| Aug 28, 2024 | Senate amendments concurred in. To Engrossing and Enrolling. (Ayes 68. Noes 0.). |
| Aug 28, 2024 | In Assembly. Concurrence in Senate amendments pending. May be considered on or after August 30 pursuant to Assembly Rule 77. |
| Aug 28, 2024 | Assembly Rule 77 suspended. |
| Aug 27, 2024 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Assembly. (Ayes 31. Noes 9.). |
| Aug 19, 2024 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| Aug 15, 2024 | From committee: Do pass. (Ayes 5. Noes 2.) (August 15). |
| Aug 5, 2024 | In committee: Referred to APPR suspense file. |
| Jul 3, 2024 | Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Jul 2, 2024 | From committee: Amend, and do pass as amended and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 4. Noes 0.) (July 2). |
| Jun 19, 2024 | In committee: Hearing postponed by committee. |
| Jun 5, 2024 | Referred to Com. on PUB S. |
| May 24, 2024 | In Senate. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. |
| May 23, 2024 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Senate. (Ayes 63. Noes 0. Page 5623.) |
| May 20, 2024 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| May 17, 2024 | Introduced measure version corrected. |
| May 16, 2024 | From committee: Do pass. (Ayes 13. Noes 0.) (May 16). |
| May 16, 2024 | Coauthors revised. |
| Apr 17, 2024 | In committee: Set, first hearing. Referred to APPR. suspense file. |
| Apr 3, 2024 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 8. Noes 0.) (April 2). Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Feb 20, 2024 | Referred to Com. on PUB. S. |
| Feb 6, 2024 | From printer. May be heard in committee March 7. |
| Feb 5, 2024 | Read first time. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Aug 28, 2024 | AB 2099 Bauer-Kahan Concurrence in Senate Amendments | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| Aug 27, 2024 | Assembly 3rd Reading AB2099 Bauer-Kahan et al. By Skinner | Senate Floor |
Passed |
|
| Aug 15, 2024 | Do pass | Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Aug 5, 2024 | Placed on suspense file | Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Jul 2, 2024 | Do pass as amended, but first amend, and re-refer to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Senate Standing Committee on Public Safety |
Passed |
|
| May 23, 2024 | AB 2099 Bauer-Kahan Assembly Third Reading | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| May 16, 2024 | Do pass. | Assembly Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Apr 2, 2024 | Do pass and be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Assembly Standing Committee on Public Safety |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
|
Organization
|
Position
|
Date
|
|---|---|---|
| Aclu California Action | ** Against | |
| American Association Of University Women - California | ** Support | |
| American College Of Obstetricians And Gynecologists District Ix | ** Support | |
| California Academy Of Family Physicians | ** Support | |
| California Chapter of the American College of Emergency Physicians | ** Support | |
| California Commission on the Status of Women and Girls | * Support | Jul 2, 2024 |
| Los Angeles County District Attorney'S Office | ** Support | |
| Office of Lieutenant Governor Eleni Kounalakis | ** Support | |
| Planned Parenthood Affiliates Of California | ** Support | |
| Reproductive Freedom for All | ** Support |
CONCURRENCE IN SENATE AMENDMENTS
CSA1 Bill Id:AB 2099
Author:(Bauer-Kahan and McCarty)
As Amended Ver:July 3, 2024
Majority vote
SUMMARY
Increases penalties for violations of the California Freedom of Access to Clinics and Church Entrances ("FACCE") Act.
Senate Amendments
- Eliminate the proposed penalty increase from misdemeanor to an alternate misdemeanor-felony for a first violation of the following offenses:
- Nonviolent physical obstruction, or where a person intentionally injures, intimidates, or interferes with, or attempts to injure, intimidate, or interfere with, any person or entity because that person or entity is a reproductive health services patient, provider, or assistant, or in order to intimidate any person or entity, or any class of persons or entities, from becoming or remaining a reproductive health services patient, provider, or assistant.
- Nonviolent physical obstruction, or where a person intentionally injures, intimidates, or interferes with, or attempts to injure, intimidate, or interfere with, a person lawfully exercising or seeking to exercise the First Amendment right of religious freedom at a place of religious worship.
- Within 100 feet of the entrance to, or within, a reproductive health services facility, intentionally videotapes, films, photographs, or records by electronic means, a reproductive health services patient, provider, or assistant without that person's consent with specific intent to intimidate the person from becoming or remaining a reproductive health services patient, provider, or assistant, and thereby causes the person to be intimidated.
- Intentionally discloses or distributes a videotape, film, photograph, or recording knowing it was obtained unlawfully with the specific intent to intimidate the person from becoming or remaining a reproductive health services patient, provider, or assistant, and thereby causes the person to be intimidated.
- Change the proposed penalty increase for a second or subsequent violation of the above offenses from a straight felony to an alternate misdemeanor-felony.
COMMENTS
As Passed by the Assembly, this bill:
- Increased the penalty for a misdemeanor offense of posting on the internet or social media, threats of violence with the intent that another person imminently use that information to commit a violent crime against a reproductive health care worker to an alternate misdemeanor-felony[1] punishable by up to one year in the county jail or three years in the county jail.
- Increased the penalty for posting on the internet or social media threats of violence against a reproductive healthcare worker where it leads to bodily injury from a misdemeanor to a felony punishable by up to three years in the county jail.
- Increased the penalty from a misdemeanor to an alternate misdemeanor-felony punishably by up to one year in county jail, or up to three years in county jail, for willfully interfering with, injuring, intimidating, oppressing, or threatening, by use of force or threat of force, any person's ability in the free exercise of any right or privilege, ensured by the state and federal constitutional law or statutes because of one or more actual or perceived characteristics.
- Mandated the court order a defendant to perform a minimum of community service in addition to any criminal sentence for violations of specified crimes related to interference with the exercise of constitutional rights.
- Increased the penalties for the existing crimes under the FACCE Act, as follows:
- Punishes the first violation of the following offenses as an alternate-misdemeanor-felony subject to a penalty of one year in county jail or up to three years in county jail, a fine of up to $10,000, or by both imprisonment and fine:
- nonviolent physical obstruction, or where a person intentionally injures, intimidates, or interferes with, or attempts to injure, intimidate, or interfere with, any person or entity because that person or entity is a reproductive health services patient, provider, or assistant, or in order to intimidate any person or entity, or any class of persons or entities, from becoming or remaining a reproductive health services patient, provider, or assistant.
- By nonviolent physical obstruction, or where a person intentionally injures, intimidates, or interferes with, or attempts to injure, intimidate, or interfere with, a person lawfully exercising or seeking to exercise the First Amendment right of religious freedom at a place of religious worship.
- Within 100 feet of the entrance to, or within, a reproductive health services facility, intentionally videotape, film, photograph, or record by electronic means, a reproductive health services patient, provider, or assistant without that person's consent with specific intent to intimidate the person from becoming or remaining a reproductive health services patient, provider, or assistant, and thereby causes the person to be intimidated.
- Intentionally disclose or distribute a videotape, film, photograph, or recording knowing it was obtained unlawfully with the specific intent to intimidate the person from becoming or remaining a reproductive health services patient, provider, or assistant, and thereby causes the person to be intimidated.
- Increases the penalty for a second or subsequent violation of the offenses listed above in 5 (a) (i-iv), from an alternate misdemeanor-felony to a straight felony punishable by up to three years in county jail.
- Increases the penalties for a first violation of the following offenses from a misdemeanor to a straight felony punishable by up to three years in county jail:
- Intentionally damages or destroys the property of a person, entity, or facility, or attempts to do so, because the person, entity, or facility is a reproductive health services patient, provider, assistant, or facility.
- Intentionally damages or destroys the property of a place of religious worship.
- Punishes a second or subsequent violation of the following offenses as a felony subject to a penalty of up to three years in county jail, a fine of not more than $50,000, or by both imprisonment and fine:
- Using force, threat of force, or physical obstruction of violence, to intentionally injure, intimidate, interfere with, or attempt to injure, intimidate, or interfere with, any person or entity because that person or entity is a reproductive health services patient, provider, or assistant, or in order to intimidate a person or entity, or a class of persons or entities, or from becoming or remaining a reproductive health services patient, provider, or assistant.
- Using force, threat of force, or physical obstruction of violence, to intentionally injure, intimidate, interfere with, or attempt to injure, intimidate, or interfere with a person lawfully exercising or seeking to exercise the First Amendment right of religious freedom at a place of religious worship.
- Intentionally damaging or destroying the property of a person, entity, or facility, or attempts to do so, because the person, entity, or facility is a reproductive health services patient, provider, assistant, or facility.
- Intentionally damages or destroys the property of a person, entity, or facility, or attempts to do so, because the person, entity, or facility is a reproductive health services patient, provider, assistant, or facility.
- Intentionally damages or destroys the property of a place of religious worship.
According to the Author
"Since the overturning of Roe vs. Wade, reproductive health clinics like Planned Parenthood have become the very last line for women seeking critical reproductive health care. These vulnerable patients and providers are facing an onslaught of organized harassment, being attacked online and in person. Current penalties are insufficient to deter extremist anti-abortion groups from attacking clinics and providers. AB 2099 updates our state penalties to protect the essential right to reproductive healthcare."
Arguments in Support
According to Planned Parenthood Affiliates of California, "In California, while we continue to work to expand and protect access to sexual and reproductive health care, we still witness the consequences of the national attack on abortion. Extremist lawmakers and their supporters have been transforming incredibly personal health care choices into political battlegrounds, creating dangerous consequences for people across the country. Attacks on reproductive health care, including abortion, contraception, gender-affirming care, and IVF have resulted in patients being denied care, forced to travel out-of-their home states in difficult circumstances, and endangering their health and well-being. These attacks have emboldened anti-abortion extremists.
"Since the Dobbs decision, there has been an increase in violence in abortion protective states like California. According to the National Abortion Federation, there was a disproportionate increase of anti-reproductive health incidents in protective states – stalking increased by 913%, assault and battery increased by 29%, bomb threats increased by 133% and obstruction of clinics increased by 538%.
"While California has existing protections in place under the Freedom to Access Clinic Entrances (FACE) Act, offenses are not always taken seriously and health centers face challenges with enforcement. Acts of violence and harassment have persisted for decades as anti-abortion extremists have faced little retribution for their escalating tactics and cultural complacency has normalized their activity. Violations of the FACE Act include intentionally injuring, intimidating, or obstructing access to a health center, vandalism, and modern forms of harassment such as posting personal information online with the intent to cause harm. According to a Feminist Majority Foundation survey of providers over half of providers face targeted threats and intimidation – often coming from highly organized and well-funded groups. Targeted threats and intimidation includes twelve variables: death threats, stalking, tracking of activities, vandalism of home or personal property, harassing phone calls, harassing emails/social media posts, pamphlets/leaflets targeting staff and physicians, personal information/pictures posted online, frivolous lawsuits, and threats to family members of staff or physicians.
"Attacks at clinics do not just have a negative impact on the staff and patients, but also contribute to a culture of fear. As more states criminalize reproductive health care, increasing not just safety in accessing care but also stigma, it is more crucial than ever that patients feel safe when seeking care in California. AB 2099 will strengthen the enforcement mechanisms for violations of the FACE Act in California and ensure that patients and providers can access the care they need, provide essential health care, and do so without fearing their safety".
Arguments in Opposition
According to The American Civil Liberties Union California Action, "[w]hile we share and prioritize your goal of protecting and enhancing access to reproductive health care, we do not believe that expanding criminal penalties for those who seek to block such access will adequately curb such behavior. California is grappling with a fiscal deficit and cannot afford to absorb the increased carceral costs associated with this bill.
"The code sections addressed by the bill already provide significant penalties for those who seek to impede access to reproductive health care. Government Code section 6218.01 and Penal Code sections 422.6 and 423.3 allow for up to a year in jail and fines ranging from $5,000 to $50,000. In addition to the code sections addressed by the bill, anyone who makes criminal threats against another person can be punished by up to three years in state prison. (Penal Code § 422.) Likewise, a person who aids and abets another in committing a crime involving violence against a reproductive healthcare patient, provider, employee, or volunteer – or any other person – can be convicted of the underlying crime as though they themself had directly committed it. (Penal Code Section 31.) Assault by means of force likely to produce great bodily injury can be punished by up to four years in state prison (Penal Code Section 245, subd. (a)(4)); and if the felony assault is committed because of a protected characteristic, the person can be punished by up to an additional three years in state prison (Penal Code Section 422.75).
"To the extent existing laws are not being enforced or prioritized to curb the harmful behavior contemplated by AB 2099, we encourage the Legislature to focus its attention on holding law enforcement agencies accountable. Simply increasing penalties will not result in greater accountability for those who seek to do harm."
FISCAL COMMENTS
According to the Senate Appropriations Committee, "Costs (local funds, General Fund) to the counties and the California Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation (CDCR) to incarcerate people who must serve longer sentences due to this bill. Costs may be in the hundreds of thousands to millions of dollars annually, depending on prosecutorial discretion in charging, the number of convictions, and defendants' criminal histories. The Legislative Analyst's Office (LAO) estimates the average annual cost to incarcerate one person in CDCR is $133,000. The average annual cost to incarcerate one person in county jail is approximately $29,000. Overcrowding in county jails creates cost pressure on the General Fund because the state has historically granted new funding to counties to offset overcrowding after the 2011 Realignment Act."
VOTES:
ASM PUBLIC SAFETY: 8-0-0
YES: McCarty, Alanis, Lackey, Stephanie Nguyen, Reyes, Ting, Wilson, Zbur
ASM APPROPRIATIONS: 13-0-2
YES: Wicks, Sanchez, Arambula, Bryan, Calderon, Wendy Carrillo, Mike Fong, Grayson, Haney, Hart, Jim Patterson, Pellerin, Villapudua
ABS, ABST OR NV: Dixon, Ta
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 63-0-17
YES: Addis, Aguiar-Curry, Alanis, Alvarez, Arambula, Bains, Bauer-Kahan, Bennett, Berman, Boerner, Bonta, Bryan, Calderon, Juan Carrillo, Wendy Carrillo, Chen, Connolly, Davies, Mike Fong, Friedman, Gabriel, Garcia, Gipson, Grayson, Haney, Hart, Hoover, Irwin, Jackson, Jones-Sawyer, Kalra, Lee, Low, Lowenthal, Maienschein, McCarty, McKinnor, Muratsuchi, Stephanie Nguyen, Ortega, Pacheco, Papan, Pellerin, Petrie-Norris, Quirk-Silva, Ramos, Rendon, Reyes, Rodriguez, Santiago, Schiavo, Soria, Ting, Valencia, Villapudua, Waldron, Wallis, Ward, Weber, Wilson, Wood, Zbur, Robert Rivas
ABS, ABST OR NV: Cervantes, Megan Dahle, Dixon, Essayli, Flora, Vince Fong, Gallagher, Holden, Lackey, Mathis, Jim Patterson, Joe Patterson, Luz Rivas, Blanca Rubio, Sanchez, Ta, Wicks
SENATE FLOOR: 31-9-0
YES: Allen, Archuleta, Ashby, Atkins, Becker, Blakespear, Bradford, Caballero, Cortese, Dodd, Durazo, Eggman, Glazer, Gonzalez, Hurtado, Laird, Limón, McGuire, Menjivar, Min, Newman, Padilla, Portantino, Roth, Rubio, Skinner, Smallwood-Cuevas, Stern, Umberg, Wahab, Wiener
NO: Alvarado-Gil, Dahle, Grove, Jones, Nguyen, Niello, Ochoa Bogh, Seyarto, Wilk
UPDATED
VERSION: July 3, 2024
CONSULTANT: Ilan Zur / PUB. S. / (916) 319-3744 FN: 0004843
See fn. 2, infra, at p. 6. ↑
SENATE RULES COMMITTEE Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | AB 2099 |
THIRD READING
Bill No: AB 2099
Author: Bauer-Kahan (D) and McCarty (D), et al.
Amended: 7/3/24 in Senate
Vote: 21
SENATE PUBLIC SAFETY COMMITTEE: 4-0, 7/2/24
AYES: Wahab, Bradford, Skinner, Wiener
NO VOTE RECORDED: Seyarto
SENATE APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE: 5-2, 8/15/24
AYES: Caballero, Ashby, Becker, Bradford, Wahab
NOES: Jones, Seyarto
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 63-0, 5/23/24 - See last page for vote
SUBJECT: Crimes: reproductive health services
SOURCE: Planned Parenthood Affiliates of California
DIGEST:
This bill increases penalties for violations of the California Freedom of Access to Clinics and Church Entrances (FACCE) Act.
ANALYSIS:
Existing law:
- Provides that any reproductive health service provider, employee, volunteer, or patient who is placed in reasonable fear by the posting of their home address and phone number on an Internet website may make a written demand that such information be removed from the website, so long as the demand includes a sworn statement describing the reasonable fear and attesting that the person is a member of the group protected by the statute. Provides injunctive relief. (Govt. Code § 6281 (b).)
- Makes it a misdemeanor, punishable by up to 6 months in a county jail, a fine of not more than $2,500, or both that fine and imprisonment, to post the home address, telephone number, or personally identifying information about a provider, employee, volunteer, or patient of a reproductive health service facility or other individuals residing at the same home address with the intent that another person imminently use that information to commit a crime involving violence or a threat of violence against that person or entity. If the violation leads to bodily injury of the person, it is a misdemeanor punishable by up to one year in a county jail, a fine of up to $5,000, or both that fine and imprisonment. (Govt. Code § 6218.01.)
- Defines “reproductive health care services” to mean health care services relating to the termination of a pregnancy in a reproductive health care services facility. (Govt. Code § 6218.05. (a).)
- Defines “reproductive health care services provider, employee, volunteer, or patient” means a person who obtains, provides, or assists, at the request of another person, in obtaining or providing reproductive health care services, or a person who owns or operates a reproductive health care services facility. (Govt. Code § 6218.05 (b).)
- Defines “reproductive health care services facility” includes a hospital, an office operated by a licensed physician and surgeon, a licensed clinic or a clinic exempt from licensure, or other licensed health care facility that provides reproductive health care services and includes only the building or structure in which the reproductive health care services are actually provided. (Govt. Code § 6218.05 (c).)
- Defines “public post” or “publicly display” as meaning to intentionally communicate or otherwise make available to the general public. (Govt. Code § 6218.05 (d).)
- Defines “image” as including, but not limited to, any photograph, video footage, sketch, or computer-generated image that provides a means to visually identify the person depicted. (Govt. Code § 6218.05 (e).)
- Defines “crime of violence” as an offense that has as an element the use, attempted use, or threatened use of physical force against the person or property of another. (Penal Code § 423.1 (a).)
- Defines “interfere with” as meaning to restrict a person’s freedom of movement. (Penal Code § 423.1 (b).)
- Defines “intimidate” as meaning to place a person in reasonable apprehension of bodily harm to herself or himself or to another. (Penal Code, § 423.1 (c).)
- Defines “nonviolent” as meaning to conduct that would not constitute a crime of violence. (Pen. Code § 423.1 (d).)
- Defines “physical obstruction” as rendering ingress to or egress from a reproductive health services facility or to or from a place of religious worship impassable to another person, or rendering passage to or from a reproductive health services facility or a place of religious worship unreasonably difficult or hazardous to another person. (Penal Code § 423.1 (e).)
- Defines “reproductive health services” as meaning reproductive health services provided in a hospital, clinic, physician’s office, or other facility and includes medical, surgical, counseling, or referral services relating to the human reproductive system, including services relating to pregnancy or the termination of a pregnancy. (Penal Code § 423.1 (f).)
- Defines “reproductive health services client, provider, or assistant” as a person or entity that is or was involved in obtaining, seeking to obtain, providing, seeking to provide, or assisting or seeking to assist another person, at that other person’s request, to obtain or provide any services in a reproductive health services facility, or a person or entity that is or was involved in owning or operating or seeking to own or operate, a reproductive health services facility. (Penal Code § 423.1 (g).)
- States “reproductive health services facility” includes a hospital, clinic, physician’s office, or other facility that provides or seeks to provide reproductive health services and includes the building or structure in which the facility is located. (Penal Code § 423.1 (h).)
- Provides that every person who, except a parent or guardian acting towards his or her minor child or ward, commits any of the following acts shall be subject to the punishment, as specified (Penal Code § 423.2 (a)-(f)):
- By force, threat of force, or physical obstruction that is a crime of violence, intentionally injures, intimidates, interferes with, or attempts to injure, intimidate, or interfere with, any person or entity because that person or entity is a reproductive health services client, provider, or assistant, or in order to intimidate any person or entity, or any class of persons or entities, from becoming or remaining a reproductive health services client, provider, or assistant; or
- By force, threat of force, or physical obstruction that is a crime of violence, intentionally injures, intimidates, interferes with, or attempts to injure, intimidate, or interfere with any person lawfully exercising or seeking to exercise the First Amendment right of religious freedom at a place of religious worship; or
- By nonviolent physical obstruction, intentionally injures, intimidates, or interferes with, or attempts to injure, intimidate, or interfere with, any person or entity because that person or entity is a reproductive health services client, provider, or assistant, or in order to intimidate any person or entity, or any class of persons or entities, from becoming or remaining a reproductive health services client, provider, or assistant; or
- By nonviolent physical obstruction, intentionally injures, intimidates, or interferes with, or attempts to injure, intimidate, or interfere with, any person lawfully exercising or seeking to exercise the First Amendment right of religious freedom at a place of religious worship; or
- Intentionally damages or destroys the property of a person, entity, or facility, or attempts to do so, because the person, entity, or facility is a reproductive health services client, provider, assistant, or facility; or
- Intentionally damages or destroys the property of a place of religious worship. (Penal Code § 423.2.)
- Makes a first violation involving nonviolent physical obstruction a misdemeanor, punishable by imprisonment in a county jail for a period of not more than six months and a fine not to exceed two thousand dollars ($2,000). (Penal Code § 423.3 (a).)
- Makes a second or subsequent violation involving nonviolent physical obstruction a misdemeanor, punishable by imprisonment in a county jail for a period of not more than six months and a fine not to exceed five thousand dollars ($5,000). (Penal Code § 423.3 (b).)
- Makes a first violation involving force, threat of force, or physical obstruction that is a crime of violence or intentional property damage a misdemeanor, punishable by imprisonment in a county jail for a period of not more than one year and a fine not to exceed twenty-five thousand dollars ($25,000). (Penal Code § 423.3 (c).)
- Makes a second or subsequent violation involving force, threat of force, or physical obstruction that is a crime of violence or intentional property damage a misdemeanor, punishable by imprisonment in a county jail for a period of not more than one year and a fine not to exceed fifty thousand dollars ($50,000). (Penal Code § 423.3 (d).)
- States that this title establishes concurrent state jurisdiction over conduct that is also prohibited by the federal Freedom of Access to Clinic Entrances Act of 1994 (18 U.S.C. Sec. 248), which provides for more severe misdemeanor penalties for first violations and felony-misdemeanor penalties for second and subsequent violations. State law enforcement agencies and prosecutors shall cooperate with federal authorities in the prevention, apprehension, and prosecution of these crimes, and shall seek federal prosecutions when appropriate. (Penal Code, § 423.3 (f).)
- Makes it a misdemeanor to, by force or threat of force, willfully injure, intimidate, interfere with, oppress, or threaten another person in the free exercise or enjoyment of a right or privilege secured by the Constitution or laws of this state or by the Constitution or laws of the United States, in whole or in part, because of one or more of specified actual or perceived characteristics of the victim, including disability, gender, religion, race, or sexual orientation. (Penal Code, §§ 422.6 (a) & 422.55 (a).)
- Makes it a misdemeanor to knowingly deface, damage, or destroy the real or personal property of another person for the purpose of intimidating or interfering with the free exercise or enjoyment of a right or privilege secured by the Constitution or laws of this state or by the Constitution or laws of the United States, in whole or in part, because of one or more of the same actual or perceived characteristics of the victim. (Penal Code §§ 422.6 (b) & 422.55 (a).)
This bill:
- Increases the penalty for a misdemeanor offense of posting on the internet or social media, threats of violence with the intent that another person imminently use that information to commit a violent crime against a reproductive health care worker to an alternate misdemeanor-felony punishable by up to one year in the county jail or sixteen months, 2 or three years in addition to the existing $10,000 fine plus penalty assessments.
- Increases the penalty for posting on the internet or social media threats of violence against a reproductive healthcare worker where it leads to bodily injury from a misdemeanor to a felony punishable by 16 months, 2 or 3 years in county jail in addition to the existing $50,000 plus penalty assessments and existing community service.
- Increases the penalty for willfully interfering with, injuring, intimidating, oppressing, or threatening, by use of force or threat of force, any person’s ability in the free exercise of any right or privilege, ensured by the state and federal constitutional law or statutes because of one or more actual or perceived characteristics. from a misdemeanor to an alternate misdemeanor-felony punishably by up to one year in county jail, or 16 months, 2 or 3 years in county jail, plus the existing $5,000 fine plus penalty assessments and the existing mandatory community service
- Increases the penalties for the existing crimes under the FACCE Act, as follows:
- Punishes the second violation of the following offenses as an alternate-misdemeanor-felony subject to a penalty of one year in county jail or 16 months two or three years in county jail, in addition to the existing fine of up to $10,000 plus penalty assessments, or by both imprisonment and fine:
- nonviolent physical obstruction, or where a person intentionally injures, intimidates, or interferes with, or attempts to injure, intimidate, or interfere with, any person or entity because that person or entity is a reproductive health services patient, provider, or assistant, or in order to intimidate any person or entity, or any class of persons or entities, from becoming or remaining a reproductive health services patient, provider, or assistant.
- By nonviolent physical obstruction, or where a person intentionally injures, intimidates, or interferes with, or attempts to injure, intimidate, or interfere with, a person lawfully exercising or seeking to exercise the First Amendment right of religious freedom at a place of religious worship.
- Within 100 feet of the entrance to, or within, a reproductive health services facility, intentionally videotape, film, photograph, or record by electronic means, a reproductive health services patient, provider, or assistant without that person’s consent with specific intent to intimidate the person from becoming or remaining a reproductive health services patient, provider, or assistant, and thereby causes the person to be intimidated.
- Intentionally disclose or distribute a videotape, film, photograph, or recording knowing it was obtained unlawfully with the specific intent to intimidate the person from becoming or remaining a reproductive health services patient, provider, or assistant, and thereby causes the person to be intimidated.
- nonviolent physical obstruction, or where a person intentionally injures, intimidates, or interferes with, or attempts to injure, intimidate, or interfere with, any person or entity because that person or entity is a reproductive health services patient, provider, or assistant, or in order to intimidate any person or entity, or any class of persons or entities, from becoming or remaining a reproductive health services patient, provider, or assistant.
- Increases the penalties for a first violation of the following offenses from a misdemeanor to a straight felony punishable by 16 months, two, or three years in county jail and the existing fine of not more than $25,000 plus penalty assessments:
- Intentionally damages or destroys the property of a person, entity, or facility, or attempts to do so, because the person, entity, or facility is a reproductive health services patient, provider, assistant, or facility.
- Intentionally damages or destroys the property of a place of religious worship.
- Intentionally damages or destroys the property of a person, entity, or facility, or attempts to do so, because the person, entity, or facility is a reproductive health services patient, provider, assistant, or facility.
- Punishes a second or subsequent violation of the following offenses as an alternate-misdemeanor-felony subject to a penalty of one year in county jail or 16 months, two or three years in county jail, in addition to the existing fine of not more than $50,000, or by both imprisonment and fine:
- Using force, threat of force, or physical obstruction of violence, to intentionally injure, intimidate, interfere with, or attempt to injure, intimidate, or interfere with, any person or entity because that person or entity is a reproductive health services patient, provider, or assistant, or in order to intimidate a person or entity, or a class of persons or entities, or from becoming or remaining a reproductive health services patient, provider, or assistant.
- Using force, threat of force, or physical obstruction of violence, to intentionally injure, intimidate, interfere with, or attempt to injure, intimidate, or interfere with a person lawfully exercising or seeking to exercise the First Amendment right of religious freedom at a place of religious worship.
- Intentionally damaging or destroying the property of a person, entity, or facility, or attempts to do so, because the person, entity, or facility is a reproductive health services patient, provider, assistant, or facility.
- Intentionally damages or destroys the property of a person, entity, or facility, or attempts to do so, because the person, entity, or facility is a reproductive health services patient, provider, assistant, or facility.
- Intentionally damages or destroys the property of a place of religious worship.
- Using force, threat of force, or physical obstruction of violence, to intentionally injure, intimidate, interfere with, or attempt to injure, intimidate, or interfere with, any person or entity because that person or entity is a reproductive health services patient, provider, or assistant, or in order to intimidate a person or entity, or a class of persons or entities, or from becoming or remaining a reproductive health services patient, provider, or assistant.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: Yes Local: Yes
According to the Senate Appropriations Committee:
Costs (local funds, General Fund) to the counties and the California Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation (CDCR) to incarcerate people who must serve longer sentences due to this bill. Costs may be in the hundreds of thousands to millions of dollars annually, depending on prosecutorial discretion in charging, the number of convictions, and defendants’ criminal histories. The Legislative Analyst’s Office (LAO) estimates the average annual cost to incarcerate one person in CDCR is $133,000. The average annual cost to incarcerate one person in county jail is approximately $29,000. Overcrowding in county jails creates cost pressure on the General Fund because the state has historically granted new funding to counties to offset overcrowding after the 2011 Realignment Act. (See staff comments)
SUPPORT: (Verified 8/15/24)
Planned Parenthood Affiliates of California (source)
American Association of University Women - California
American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists District IX
California Academy of Family Physicians
California Chapter of The American College of Emergency Physicians
Los Angeles County District Attorney's Office
Office of Lieutenant Governor Eleni Kounalakis
Reproductive Freedom for All
OPPOSITION: (Verified 8/15/24)
ACLU California Action
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: Planned Parenthood Affiliates of California:
In California, while we continue to work to expand and protect access to sexual and reproductive health care, we still witness the consequences of the national attack on abortion. Extremist lawmakers and their supporters have been transforming incredibly personal health care choices into political battlegrounds, creating dangerous consequences for people across the country. Attacks on reproductive health care, including abortion, contraception, gender-affirming care, and IVF have resulted in patients being denied care, forced to travel out-of-their home states in difficult circumstances, and endangering their health and well-being. These attacks have emboldened anti-abortion extremists.
Since the Dobbs decision, there has been an increase in violence in abortion protective states like California. According to the National Abortion Federation, there was a disproportionate increase of anti-reproductive health incidents in protective states – stalking increased by 913%, assault and battery increased by 29%, bomb threats increased by 133% and obstruction of clinics increased by 538%. While California has existing protections in place under the Freedom to Access Clinic Entrances (FACE) Act, offenses are not always taken seriously and health centers face challenges with enforcement. Acts of violence and harassment have persisted for decades as anti-abortion extremists have faced little retribution for their escalating tactics and cultural complacency has normalized their activity.
Violations of the FACE Act include intentionally injuring, intimidating, or obstructing access to a health center, vandalism, and modern forms of harassment such as posting personal information online with the intent to cause harm. According to a Feminist Majority Foundation survey of providers over half of providers face targeted threats and intimidation – often coming from highly organized and well-funded groups. Targeted threats and intimidation includes twelve variables: death threats, stalking, tracking of activities, vandalism of home or personal property, harassing phone calls, harassing emails/social media posts, pamphlets/leaflets targeting staff and physicians, personal information/pictures posted online, frivolous lawsuits, and threats to family members of staff or physicians.
Attacks at clinics do not just have a negative impact on the staff and patients, but also contribute to a culture of fear. As more states criminalize reproductive health care, increasing not just safety in accessing care but also stigma, it is more crucial than ever that patients feel safe when seeking care in California. AB 2099 will strengthen the enforcement mechanisms for violations of the FACE Act in California and ensure that patients and providers can access the care they need, provide essential health care, and do so without fearing their safety. For these reasons, PPAC is proud to sponsor AB 2099 and respectfully urge your “Aye” vote when it’s before you in Committee.
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION: ACLU California Action opposes this bill stating:
The code sections addressed by the bill already provide significant penalties for those who seek to impede access to reproductive health care. Government Code section 6218.01 and Penal Code sections 422.6 and 423.3 allow for up to a year in jail and fines ranging from $5,000 to $50,000. In addition to the code sections addressed by the bill, anyone who makes criminal threats against another person can be punished by up to three years in state prison. (Penal Code § 422.) Likewise, a person who aids and abets another in committing a crime involving violence against a reproductive healthcare patient, provider, employee, or volunteer – or any other person – can be convicted of the underlying crime as though they themselves had directly committed it. (Penal Code § 31.) Assault by means of force likely to produce great bodily injury can be punished by up to four years in state prison (Penal Code § 245, subd. (a)(4)); and if the felony assault is committed because of a protected characteristic, the person can be punished by up to an additional three years in state prison (Penal Code § 422.75).
To the extent existing laws are not being enforced or prioritized to curb the harmful behavior contemplated by AB 2099, we encourage the Legislature to focus its attention on holding law enforcement agencies accountable. Simply increasing penalties will not result in greater accountability for those who seek to do harm.
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 63-0, 5/23/24
AYES: Addis, Aguiar-Curry, Alanis, Alvarez, Arambula, Bains, Bauer-Kahan, Bennett, Berman, Boerner, Bonta, Bryan, Calderon, Juan Carrillo, Wendy Carrillo, Chen, Connolly, Davies, Mike Fong, Friedman, Gabriel, Garcia, Gipson, Grayson, Haney, Hart, Hoover, Irwin, Jackson, Jones-Sawyer, Kalra, Lee, Low, Lowenthal, Maienschein, McCarty, McKinnor, Muratsuchi, Stephanie Nguyen, Ortega, Pacheco, Papan, Pellerin, Petrie-Norris, Quirk-Silva, Ramos, Rendon, Reyes, Rodriguez, Santiago, Schiavo, Soria, Ting, Valencia, Villapudua, Waldron, Wallis, Ward, Weber, Wilson, Wood, Zbur, Robert Rivas
NO VOTE RECORDED: Cervantes, Megan Dahle, Dixon, Essayli, Flora, Vince Fong, Gallagher, Holden, Lackey, Mathis, Jim Patterson, Joe Patterson, Luz Rivas, Blanca Rubio, Sanchez, Ta, Wicks
Prepared by: Mary Kennedy / PUB. S. /
8/18/24 8:51:27
**** END ****
SENATE COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Senator Anna Caballero, Chair
2023 - 2024 Regular Session
AB 2099 (Bauer-Kahan) - Crimes: reproductive health services
Version: July 3, 2024 | Policy Vote: PUB. S. 4 - 0 |
Urgency: No | Mandate: Yes |
Hearing Date: August 5, 2024 | Consultant: Liah Burnley |
Bill Summary:
AB 2099 increases penalties for criminal offenses related to reproductive health care clinic safety, including violations of the California Freedom of Access to Clinics and Church Entrances (“FACE”) Act.
Fiscal Impact:
Costs (local funds, General Fund) to the counties and the California Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation (CDCR) to incarcerate people who must serve longer sentences due to this bill. Costs may be in the hundreds of thousands to millions of dollars annually, depending on prosecutorial discretion in charging, the number of convictions, and defendants’ criminal histories. The Legislative Analyst’s Office (LAO) estimates the average annual cost to incarcerate one person in CDCR is $133,000. The average annual cost to incarcerate one person in county jail is approximately $29,000. Overcrowding in county jails creates cost pressure on the General Fund because the state has historically granted new funding to counties to offset overcrowding after the 2011 Realignment Act. (See staff comments)
Background:
The California FACE Act, enacted in 2001, provides criminal and civil penalties for interference with rights to reproductive health services and religious worship. In 2021, California enacted AB 1356 (Bauer-Kahan), Chapter 191, Statutes of 2021, which provided more protections for people seeking reproductive health care assistance and service providers. Specifically, AB 1356 created new crimes under the FACE Act for videotaping, photographing, or recording patients or providers within 100 feet of an applicable facility or disclosing or distributing those images. It also increased misdemeanor penalties for violations of the FACE Act and expanded online privacy laws and peace officer trainings relative to anti-reproduction-rights offenses.
Proposed Law:
This bill further increases the penalties for criminal violations of the FACE Act, as follows:
- Punishes the second violation of the following offenses as an alternate-misdemeanor-felony subject to a penalty of one year in county jail or 16 months two or three years in county jail, in addition to the existing fine of up to $10,000 plus penalty assessments, or by both imprisonment and fine:
- Nonviolent physical obstruction, or where a person intentionally injures, intimidates, or interferes with, or attempts to injure, intimidate, or interfere with, any person or entity because that person or entity is a reproductive health services patient, provider, or assistant, or in order to intimidate any person or entity, or any class of persons or entities, from becoming or remaining a reproductive health services patient, provider, or assistant.
- By nonviolent physical obstruction, or where a person intentionally injures, intimidates, or interferes with, or attempts to injure, intimidate, or interfere with, a person lawfully exercising or seeking to exercise the First Amendment right of religious freedom at a place of religious worship.
- Within 100 feet of the entrance to, or within, a reproductive health services facility, intentionally videotape, film, photograph, or record by electronic means, a reproductive health services patient, provider, or assistant without that person’s consent with specific intent to intimidate the person from becoming or remaining a reproductive health services patient, provider, or assistant, and thereby causes the person to be intimidated.
- Intentionally disclose or distribute a videotape, film, photograph, or recording knowing it was obtained unlawfully with the specific intent to intimidate the person from becoming or remaining a reproductive health services patient, provider, or assistant, and thereby causes the person to be intimidated.
- Increases the penalties for a first violation of the following offenses from a misdemeanor to a straight felony punishable by 16 months, two, or three years in county jail and the existing fine of not more than $25,000 plus penalty assessments:
- Intentionally damages or destroys the property of a person, entity, or facility, or attempts to do so, because the person, entity, or facility is a reproductive health services patient, provider, assistant, or facility.
- Intentionally damages or destroys the property of a place of religious worship.
- Punishes a second or subsequent violation of the following offenses as an alternate-misdemeanor-felony subject to a penalty of one year in county jail or 16 months, two or three years in county jail, in addition to the existing fine of not more than $50,000, or by both imprisonment and fine:
- Using force, threat of force, or physical obstruction of violence, to intentionally injure, intimidate, interfere with, or attempt to injure, intimidate, or interfere with, any person or entity because that person or entity is a reproductive health services patient, provider, or assistant, or in order to intimidate a person or entity, or a class of persons or entities, or from becoming or remaining a reproductive health services patient, provider, or assistant.
- Using force, threat of force, or physical obstruction of violence, to intentionally injure, intimidate, interfere with, or attempt to injure, intimidate, or interfere with a person lawfully exercising or seeking to exercise the First Amendment right of religious freedom at a place of religious worship.
- Intentionally damaging or destroying the property of a person, entity, or facility, or attempts to do so, because the person, entity, or facility is a reproductive health services patient, provider, assistant, or facility.
- Intentionally damages or destroys the property of a person, entity, or facility, or attempts to do so, because the person, entity, or facility is a reproductive health services patient, provider, assistant, or facility.
- Intentionally damages or destroys the property of a place of religious worship.
Staff Comments:
Studies have shown that, in most circumstances, lengthy criminal sentences do not effectively deter crime. According to the Committee on Revision of the Penal Code, a “major analysis of more than 100 studies concluded that it was a ‘criminological fact’ that incarceration is no better at reducing reoffending than noncustodial sanctions such as probation.” (Committee on Revision of the Penal Code, “Annual Report and Recommendations,” 2021.) In light of the growing cost of incarceration and its limited utility in deterring crime, both the Little Hoover Commission and the Committee on Revision of the Penal Code have encouraged sentencing reform in California.
-- END --
SENATE COMMITTEE ON PUBLIC SAFETY
Senator Aisha Wahab, Chair
2023 - 2024 Regular
Bill No: AB 2099 Hearing Date: July 2, 2024
Author: | Bauer-Kahan | ||
Version: | February 5, 2024 | ||
Urgency: | No | Fiscal: | Yes |
Consultant: | MK | ||
Subject: Crimes: reproductive health services
HISTORY
Source: Planned Parenthood Affiliates of California
Prior Legislation: AB 1356 (Bauer-Kahan), Chapter 191, Stats. 2021
AB 3140 (Bauer-Kahan), 2020 not heard in ACoPS
SB 1770 (Padilla), Chapter 206, Statutes of 2008
AB 2251 (Evans), Chapter 486, Statutes of 2006
SB 603 (Ortiz), Chapter 481, Statutes of 2006
Support: American Association of University Women – California; American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists District IX; California Academy of Family Physicians; California Chapter of The American College of Emergency Physicians; Office of Lieutenant Governor Eleni Kounalakis
Opposition: ACLU California Action
Assembly Floor Vote: 63 - 0
This analysis reflects amendments to be taken in Committee.
PURPOSE
The purpose of this bill to increase penalties for violations of the California Freedom of Access to Clinics and Church Entrances (“FACCE”) Act.
Existing law provides that any reproductive health service provider, employee, volunteer, or patient who is placed in reasonable fear by the posting of their home address and phone number on an Internet website may make a written demand that such information be removed from the website, so long as the demand includes a sworn statement describing the reasonable fear and attesting that the person is a member of the group protected by the statute. Provides injunctive relief. (Govt. Code § 6281 (b).)
Existing law makes it a misdemeanor, punishable by up to 6 months in a county jail, a fine of not more than $2,500, or both that fine and imprisonment, to post the home address, telephone number, or personally identifying information about a provider, employee, volunteer, or patient of a reproductive health service facility or other individuals residing at the same home address with the intent that another person imminently use that information to commit a crime involving violence or a threat of violence against that person or entity. If the violation leads to bodily injury of the person, it is a misdemeanor punishable by up to one year in a county jail, a fine of up to $5,000, or both that fine and imprisonment. (Govt. Code § 6218.01.)
Existing law defines “reproductive health care services” to mean health care services relating to the termination of a pregnancy in a reproductive health care services facility. (Govt. Code § 6218.05. (a).)
Existing law defines “reproductive health care services provider, employee, volunteer, or patient” means a person who obtains, provides, or assists, at the request of another person, in obtaining or providing reproductive health care services, or a person who owns or operates a reproductive health care services facility. (Govt. Code § 6218.05 (b).)
Existing law defines “reproductive health care services facility” includes a hospital, an office operated by a licensed physician and surgeon, a licensed clinic or a clinic exempt from licensure, or other licensed health care facility that provides reproductive health care services and includes only the building or structure in which the reproductive health care services are actually provided. (Govt. Code § 6218.05 (c).)
Existing law defines “public post” or “publicly display” as meaning to intentionally communicate or otherwise make available to the general public. (Govt. Code § 6218.05 (d).)
Existing law defines “image” as including, but not limited to, any photograph, video footage, sketch, or computer-generated image that provides a means to visually identify the person depicted. (Govt. Code § 6218.05 (e).)
Existing law defines “crime of violence” as an offense that has as an element the use, attempted use, or threatened use of physical force against the person or property of another. (Penal Code § 423.1 (a).)
Existing law defines “interfere with” as meaning to restrict a person’s freedom of movement. (Penal Code § 423.1 (b).)
Existing law defines “intimidate” as meaning to place a person in reasonable apprehension of bodily harm to herself or himself or to another. (Penal Code, § 423.1 (c).)
Existing law defines “nonviolent” as meaning to conduct that would not constitute a crime of violence. (Pen. Code § 423.1 (d).)
Existing law defines “physical obstruction” as rendering ingress to or egress from a reproductive health services facility or to or from a place of religious worship impassable to another person, or rendering passage to or from a reproductive health services facility or a place of religious worship unreasonably difficult or hazardous to another person. (Penal Code § 423.1 (e).)
Existing law defines “reproductive health services” as meaning reproductive health services provided in a hospital, clinic, physician’s office, or other facility and includes medical, surgical, counseling, or referral services relating to the human reproductive system, including services relating to pregnancy or the termination of a pregnancy. (Penal Code § 423.1 (f).)
Existing law defines “reproductive health services client, provider, or assistant” as a person or entity that is or was involved in obtaining, seeking to obtain, providing, seeking to provide, or assisting or seeking to assist another person, at that other person’s request, to obtain or provide any services in a reproductive health services facility, or a person or entity that is or was involved in owning or operating or seeking to own or operate, a reproductive health services facility. (Penal Code § 423.1 (g).)
Existing law states “reproductive health services facility” includes a hospital, clinic, physician’s office, or other facility that provides or seeks to provide reproductive health services and includes the building or structure in which the facility is located. (Penal Code § 423.1 (h).)
Existing provides that every person who, except a parent or guardian acting towards his or her minor child or ward, commits any of the following acts shall be subject to the punishment, as specified (Penal Code § 423.2 (a)-(f)):
- By force, threat of force, or physical obstruction that is a crime of violence, intentionally injures, intimidates, interferes with, or attempts to injure, intimidate, or interfere with, any person or entity because that person or entity is a reproductive health services client, provider, or assistant, or in order to intimidate any person or entity, or any class of persons or entities, from becoming or remaining a reproductive health services client, provider, or assistant; or
- By force, threat of force, or physical obstruction that is a crime of violence, intentionally injures, intimidates, interferes with, or attempts to injure, intimidate, or interfere with any person lawfully exercising or seeking to exercise the First Amendment right of religious freedom at a place of religious worship; or
- By nonviolent physical obstruction, intentionally injures, intimidates, or interferes with, or attempts to injure, intimidate, or interfere with, any person or entity because that person or entity is a reproductive health services client, provider, or assistant, or in order to intimidate any person or entity, or any class of persons or entities, from becoming or remaining a reproductive health services client, provider, or assistant; or
- By nonviolent physical obstruction, intentionally injures, intimidates, or interferes with, or attempts to injure, intimidate, or interfere with, any person lawfully exercising or seeking to exercise the First Amendment right of religious freedom at a place of religious worship; or
- Intentionally damages or destroys the property of a person, entity, or facility, or attempts to do so, because the person, entity, or facility is a reproductive health services client, provider, assistant, or facility; or
- Intentionally damages or destroys the property of a place of religious worship. (Penal Code § 423.2.)
Existing law makes a first violation involving nonviolent physical obstruction a misdemeanor, punishable by imprisonment in a county jail for a period of not more than six months and a fine not to exceed two thousand dollars ($2,000). (Penal Code § 423.3 (a).)
Existing law makes a second or subsequent violation involving nonviolent physical obstruction a misdemeanor, punishable by imprisonment in a county jail for a period of not more than six months and a fine not to exceed five thousand dollars ($5,000). (Penal Code § 423.3 (b).)
Existing law makes a first violation involving force, threat of force, or physical obstruction that is a crime of violence or intentional property damage a misdemeanor, punishable by imprisonment in a county jail for a period of not more than one year and a fine not to exceed twenty-five thousand dollars ($25,000). (Penal Code § 423.3 (c).)
Existing law makes a second or subsequent violation involving force, threat of force, or physical obstruction that is a crime of violence or intentional property damage a misdemeanor, punishable by imprisonment in a county jail for a period of not more than one year and a fine not to exceed fifty thousand dollars ($50,000). (Penal Code § 423.3 (d).)
Existing law states that this title establishes concurrent state jurisdiction over conduct that is also prohibited by the federal Freedom of Access to Clinic Entrances Act of 1994 (18 U.S.C. Sec. 248), which provides for more severe misdemeanor penalties for first violations and felony-misdemeanor penalties for second and subsequent violations. State law enforcement agencies and prosecutors shall cooperate with federal authorities in the prevention, apprehension, and prosecution of these crimes, and shall seek federal prosecutions when appropriate. (Penal Code, § 423.3 (f).)
Existing law makes it a misdemeanor to, by force or threat of force, willfully injure, intimidate, interfere with, oppress, or threaten another person in the free exercise or enjoyment of a right or privilege secured by the Constitution or laws of this state or by the Constitution or laws of the United States, in whole or in part, because of one or more of specified actual or perceived characteristics of the victim, including disability, gender, religion, race, or sexual orientation. (Penal Code, §§ 422.6 (a) & 422.55 (a).)
Existing law makes it a misdemeanor to knowingly deface, damage, or destroy the real or personal property of another person for the purpose of intimidating or interfering with the free exercise or enjoyment of a right or privilege secured by the Constitution or laws of this state or by the Constitution or laws of the United States, in whole or in part, because of one or more of the same actual or perceived characteristics of the victim. (Penal Code §§ 422.6 (b) & 422.55 (a).)
This bill increases the penalty for a misdemeanor offense of posting on the internet or social media, threats of violence with the intent that another person imminently use that information to commit a violent crime against a reproductive health care worker to an alternate misdemeanor-felony punishable by up to one year in the county jail or sixteen months, 2 or three years in addition to the existing $10,000 fine plus penalty assessments.
This bill increases the penalty for posting on the internet or social media threats of violence against a reproductive healthcare worker where it leads to bodily injury from a misdemeanor to a felony punishable by 16 months, 2 or 3 years in county jail in addition to the existing $50,000 plus penalty assessments and existing community service.
This bill increases the penalty for willfully interfering with, injuring, intimidating, oppressing, or threatening, by use of force or threat of force, any person’s ability in the free exercise of any right or privilege, ensured by the state and federal constitutional law or statutes because of one or more actual or perceived characteristics. from a misdemeanor to an alternate misdemeanor-felony punishably by up to one year in county jail, or 16 months, 2 or 3 years in county jail, plus the existing $5,000 fine plus penalty assessments and the existing mandatory community service,
This bill, as proposed to be amended in Committee, increases the penalties for the existing crimes under the FACCE Act, as follows:
- Punishes the second violation of the following offenses as an alternate-misdemeanor-felony subject to a penalty of one year in county jail or 16 months two or three years in county jail, in addition to the existing fine of up to $10,000 plus penalty assessments, or by both imprisonment and fine:
- nonviolent physical obstruction, or where a person intentionally injures, intimidates, or interferes with, or attempts to injure, intimidate, or interfere with, any person or entity because that person or entity is a reproductive health services patient, provider, or assistant, or in order to intimidate any person or entity, or any class of persons or entities, from becoming or remaining a reproductive health services patient, provider, or assistant.
- By nonviolent physical obstruction, or where a person intentionally injures, intimidates, or interferes with, or attempts to injure, intimidate, or interfere with, a person lawfully exercising or seeking to exercise the First Amendment right of religious freedom at a place of religious worship.
- Within 100 feet of the entrance to, or within, a reproductive health services facility, intentionally videotape, film, photograph, or record by electronic means, a reproductive health services patient, provider, or assistant without that person’s consent with specific intent to intimidate the person from becoming or remaining a reproductive health services patient, provider, or assistant, and thereby causes the person to be intimidated.
- Intentionally disclose or distribute a videotape, film, photograph, or recording knowing it was obtained unlawfully with the specific intent to intimidate the person from becoming or remaining a reproductive health services patient, provider, or assistant, and thereby causes the person to be intimidated.
- nonviolent physical obstruction, or where a person intentionally injures, intimidates, or interferes with, or attempts to injure, intimidate, or interfere with, any person or entity because that person or entity is a reproductive health services patient, provider, or assistant, or in order to intimidate any person or entity, or any class of persons or entities, from becoming or remaining a reproductive health services patient, provider, or assistant.
- Increases the penalties for a first violation of the following offenses from a misdemeanor to a straight felony punishable by 16 months, two, or three years in county jail and the existing fine of not more than $25,000 plus penalty assessments:
- Intentionally damages or destroys the property of a person, entity, or facility, or attempts to do so, because the person, entity, or facility is a reproductive health services patient, provider, assistant, or facility.
- Intentionally damages or destroys the property of a place of religious worship.
- Intentionally damages or destroys the property of a person, entity, or facility, or attempts to do so, because the person, entity, or facility is a reproductive health services patient, provider, assistant, or facility.
- As proposed to be amended, punishes a second or subsequent violation of the following offenses as an alternate-misdemeanor-felony subject to a penalty of one year in county jail or 16 months, two or three years in county jail, in addition to the existing fine of not more than $50,000, or by both imprisonment and fine:
- Using force, threat of force, or physical obstruction of violence, to intentionally injure, intimidate, interfere with, or attempt to injure, intimidate, or interfere with, any person or entity because that person or entity is a reproductive health services patient, provider, or assistant, or in order to intimidate a person or entity, or a class of persons or entities, or from becoming or remaining a reproductive health services patient, provider, or assistant.
- Using force, threat of force, or physical obstruction of violence, to intentionally injure, intimidate, interfere with, or attempt to injure, intimidate, or interfere with a person lawfully exercising or seeking to exercise the First Amendment right of religious freedom at a place of religious worship.
- Intentionally damaging or destroying the property of a person, entity, or facility, or attempts to do so, because the person, entity, or facility is a reproductive health services patient, provider, assistant, or facility.
- Intentionally damages or destroys the property of a person, entity, or facility, or attempts to do so, because the person, entity, or facility is a reproductive health services patient, provider, assistant, or facility.
- Intentionally damages or destroys the property of a place of religious worship.
- Using force, threat of force, or physical obstruction of violence, to intentionally injure, intimidate, interfere with, or attempt to injure, intimidate, or interfere with, any person or entity because that person or entity is a reproductive health services patient, provider, or assistant, or in order to intimidate a person or entity, or a class of persons or entities, or from becoming or remaining a reproductive health services patient, provider, or assistant.
COMMENTS
1. Need for This Bill
According to the author:
Since the overturning of Roe vs. Wade, reproductive health clinics like Planned Parenthood have become the very last line for women seeking critical reproductive health care. These vulnerable patients and providers are facing an onslaught of organized harassment, being attacked online and in person. Current penalties are insufficient to deter extremist anti-abortion groups from attacking clinics and providers. AB 2099 updates our state penalties to protect the essential right to reproductive healthcare.
2. AB 1356 (Bauer-Kahan), Chapter 191, Statutes of 2021
AB 1356 was enacted in 2021 and provided more protections for those seeking reproductive healthcare assistance and people that provide those services. Specifically, as enacted, it created new crimes under FACCE Act directed at videotaping, photographing, or recording patients or providers within 100 feet of the facility (i.e., the "buffer" zone) or disclosing or distributing those images. It also increased misdemeanor penalties for violations of the FACCE Act and expanded online privacy laws and peace officer trainings relative to anti-reproduction-rights offenses. In this Committee the felony penalties were removed but the greatly increased fines remained – before the bill was signed into law. This bill creates several new wobblers or felonies. Has there been an increase in attacks on reproductive clinics or people seeking reproductive services since AB 1356 was enacted? Given that we just increased penalties for these offenses, does it make sense to consider alternate solutions?
3. First Amendment
First Amendment provides that “Congress shall make no law . . . abridging the freedom of speech.” (U.S. Const. Amend. I, Section 1.) The California Constitution also protects free speech. “Every person may freely speak, write and publish his or her sentiments on all subjects, being responsible for the abuse of this right. A law may not restrain or abridge liberty of speech or press.” (Cal. Const. Art. I, § 2.) “[A]s a general matter, the First Amendment means that government has no power to restrict expression because of its message, its ideas, its subject matter, or its content.” (Ashcroft v. American Civil Liberties Union (2002) 535 U.S. 564, 573.)
“To achieve First Amendment protection, a plaintiff must show that [t]he[y] possessed: (1) a message to be communicated; and (2) an audience to receive that message, regardless of the medium in which the message is to be expressed.” (Hurley v. Irish-American Gay, Lesbian & Bisexual Group (1995) 515 U.S. 557.) With personal filming devices being commonplace, more and more “news” is being gathered and disseminated by members of the public. The courts have
found that freedom of the press applies to citizen journalists and documentarians, not just formal members of the press. (See, e.g., Glik v. Cunniffe,(1st Cir. 2011) 655 F.3d 78 [“plaintiff was exercising clearly-established First Amendment rights in filming the officers in a public space”].)
Legislation that regulates the content of protected speech is subject to strict scrutiny, sometimes referred to by the courts as “exacting scrutiny” in this context. (Reed v. Town of Gilbert, Ariz. (2015) 135 S.Ct. 2218, 2226.) To survive strict scrutiny, state action must be narrowly tailored to address a compelling government interest. (Ibid.)
4. The California FACCE Act
In 2001, the Legislature enacted the California FACCE Act, mirroring the federal Freedom of Access to Clinic Entrances (FACE) Act. California’s FACCE Act provides state criminal and civil penalties for interference with rights to reproductive health services and religious worship. As stated above, AB 1356 added a 100 ft., buffer zone around reproductive healthcare facilities wherein it is unlawful to “intentionally videotape, film, photograph, or records by electronic means, any reproductive health services patient, provider, or assistant without that person’s consent, with specific intent to intimidate the person from becoming or remaining a reproductive health services patient, provider, or assistant, and thereby causes the person to be intimidated.”
The enactment of “buffer zones” around reproductive health care facilities were designed to protect reproductive health care services patients and providers from being harassed, photographed, or threatened just for walking in and out of a reproductive health care facility. According to Guttmacher Institute, a leading research and policy organization working to advance sexual and reproductive health and rights worldwide, there are numerous protections around the U.S. for people working at, or seeking the services of, a reproductive healthcare facility.
States have taken two approaches designed to protect abortion providers. Some states have enacted laws similar to the federal FACE Act that prohibit specific activities such as vandalism or obstruction at clinics. Other states have limited protests aimed at clinic patients by either creating “buffer” zones around clinics that bar protestors entirely or establishing floating “bubble zones” of several feet around a person who is within a specific distance of a clinic; protesters are prohibited from crossing into that “bubble zone” without the person’s consent.
In 2014, the U.S. Supreme Court struck down the Massachusetts law that placed a 35-foot buffer zone around clinic entrances. The impact of this ruling on the New Hampshire law is still to be determined, but the decision did not immediately affect the Court’s 2000 ruling that upheld Colorado’s floating ‘bubble [or buffer] zone’ law.
15 states and the District of Columbia prohibit certain specified actions aimed at abortion providers: 13 of the states and the District of Columbia prohibit blocking the entrance to and egress from clinic facilities; seven of the states and the District of Columbia prohibit threatening or intimidating staff who provide reproductive health services and/or patients entering the clinic; four of the states prohibit property damage to facilities providing reproductive health services; two of the states and the District of Columbia prohibit telephone harassment of staff who provide reproductive health services; six of the states and the District of Columbia prohibit other specified actions, such as creating excessive noise outside the clinic, possessing or having access to a weapon during a demonstration at a medical facility, trespassing, or releasing a substance that produces noxious odor on clinic premises; and four states have established a “bubble zone” around a person within a specific distance of a clinic’s entrance or driveway. (Guttmacher Institute (August 31, 2023) Public Policy Office, Protecting Access to Clinics, Background.) [1]
The Massachusetts “buffer” zone made it a “crime to knowingly stand on a ‘public way or sidewalk’ within 35 feet of an entrance or driveway to any ‘reproductive health care facility,’ defined as ‘a place, other than within or upon the grounds of a hospital, where abortions are offered or performed.’” (McCullen v. Cookley (2014) 573 U.S. 474.) The U.S. Supreme Court held the law violated the First Amendment. (Ibid. [state law creating 35-foot buffer zones around all abortion clinics was not justified by congestion in front of one clinic on Saturday mornings].)
However, the Supreme Court declined to hear two challenges to two other buffer zones: in Harrisburg, Pennsylvania and Chicago, Illinois. In those cases, the buffer zone at issue was much lower than 100 feet, and were, at least, tacitly approved by the Court when it denied certiorari. According to one article in the national press coverage,
On Thursday, one of the two cases the court declined to take up involved an ordinance passed by the city council in Harrisburg, Pennsylvania’s capital, in 2012 that made it illegal to “congregate, patrol, picket or demonstrate” in a zone 20 feet from a health care facility. Anti-abortion activists sued, arguing that the ordinance violates their free speech rights. Lower courts have upheld the ordinance, however, ruling it doesn’t apply to “sidewalk counseling,” where individuals who oppose abortion offer assistance and information about alternatives to abortion to those entering a clinic.
The second case the court turned away on Thursday involved a Chicago ordinance that regulates the space 50 feet from the entrance of any abortion clinic or other medical facility. In that space, a person cannot come within 8 feet of another person without their consent to hand them information or engage in “oral protest, education, or counseling.” The ordinance was modeled on a statute upheld by the Supreme Court in 2000. (Jessica Gresko (July 2, 2020) “Higher Court won’t hear abortion clinic ‘buffer zone’ cases,” Associated News Press.)[2]
5. Increased Penalties
As outlined in detail in the Purpose section, this bill increase penalties for a number of offenses. It increases from a misdemeanor with a $10,000 fine (approximately $41,000 with penalty assessments)[3] to a wobbler with the same fine for a posting a home address of a clinic worker on the internet with the intent for another to imminently use the information to commit a crime. If that action results in great bodily injury to someone at that posted address then this bill also makes the existing misdemeanor with a $50,000 fine (approximately $205,000 with penalty assessments) a wobbler with the same fine.
This bill as proposed to be amended, makes a second violation of a number of non-violent violations of the FACE act that are currently a misdemeanor with a $10,000 fine (approximately $41,000 with penalty assessments) a wobbler with a $25,000 fine (approximately $102,500) a straight felony.
As proposed to be amended, existing offenses that involve some force or physical obstruction that are a misdemeanor with a $25,000 fine for a first and a misdemeanor with a $50,000 fine for second become a wobbler for a second offense.
Finally this bill makes the existing misdemeanor with a $25,000 fine for intentionally destroying the property of a reproductive clinic or house of worship a straight felony.
The fines were increased in these sections in 2021, and as noted, with penalty assessments are quite high. Should these misdemeanors become wobblers? Or in the case of destroying property a straight felony.
6. Argument in Support
Planned Parenthood Affiliates of California:
In California, while we continue to work to expand and protect access to sexual and reproductive health care, we still witness the consequences of the national attack on abortion. Extremist lawmakers and their supporters have been transforming incredibly personal health care choices into political battlegrounds, creating dangerous consequences for people across the country. Attacks on reproductive health care, including abortion, contraception, gender-affirming care, and IVF have resulted in patients being denied care, forced to travel out-of-their home states in difficult circumstances, and endangering their health and well-being. These attacks have emboldened anti-abortion extremists.
Since the Dobbs decision, there has been an increase in violence in abortion protective states like California. According to the National Abortion Federation, there was a disproportionate increase of anti-reproductive health incidents in protective states – stalking increased by 913%, assault and battery increased by 29%, bomb threats increased by 133% and obstruction of clinics increased by 538%. While California has existing protections in place under the Freedom to Access Clinic Entrances (FACE) Act, offenses are not always taken seriously and health centers face challenges with enforcement. Acts of violence and harassment have persisted for decades as anti-abortion extremists have faced little retribution for their escalating tactics and cultural complacency has normalized their activity.
Violations of the FACE Act include intentionally injuring, intimidating, or obstructing access to a health center, vandalism, and modern forms of harassment such as posting personal information online with the intent to cause harm. According to a Feminist Majority Foundation survey of providers over half of providers face targeted threats and intimidation – often coming from highly organized and well-funded groups. Targeted threats and intimidation includes twelve variables: death threats, stalking, tracking of activities, vandalism of home or personal property, harassing phone calls, harassing emails/social media posts, pamphlets/leaflets targeting staff and physicians, personal information/pictures posted online, frivolous lawsuits, and threats to family members of staff or physicians.
Attacks at clinics do not just have a negative impact on the staff and patients, but also contribute to a culture of fear. As more states criminalize reproductive health care, increasing not just safety in accessing care but also stigma, it is more crucial than ever that patients feel safe when seeking care in California. AB 2099 will strengthen the enforcement mechanisms for violations of the FACE Act in California and ensure that patients and providers can access the care they need, provide essential health care, and do so without fearing their safety. For these reasons, PPAC is proud to sponsor AB 2099 and respectfully urge your “Aye” vote when it’s before you in Committee.
7. Argument in Opposition
ACLU California Action opposes this bill stating:
The code sections addressed by the bill already provide significant penalties for those who seek to impede access to reproductive health care. Government Code section 6218.01 and Penal Code sections 422.6 and 423.3 allow for up to a year in jail and fines ranging from $5,000 to $50,000. In addition to the code sections addressed by the bill, anyone who makes criminal threats against another person can be punished by up to three years in state prison. (Penal Code § 422.) Likewise, a person who aids and abets another in committing a crime involving violence against a reproductive healthcare patient, provider, employee, or volunteer – or any other person – can be convicted of the underlying crime as though they themselves had directly committed it. (Penal Code § 31.) Assault by means of force likely to produce great bodily injury can be punished by up to four years in state prison (Penal Code § 245, subd. (a)(4)); and if the felony assault is committed because of a protected characteristic, the person can be punished by up to an additional three years in state prison (Penal Code § 422.75).
To the extent existing laws are not being enforced or prioritized to curb the harmful behavior contemplated by AB 2099, we encourage the Legislature to focus its attention on holding law enforcement agencies accountable. Simply increasing penalties will not result in greater accountability for those who seek to do harm.
-- END –
Located at https://www.guttmacher.org/state-policy/explore/protecting-access-clinics last visited March 26, 2024. ↑
Located at https://apnews.com/article/31d02c9336e9f3c2a5d9dea4a883e72c ↑
Until the budget year 2002-2003, there was 170% in penalty assessments applied to every fine, the current penalty assessments are approximately 310% plus a flat fee of $79. (See Penal Code § 1464; Penal Code § 1465.7; Penal Code § 1465.8 Government Code § 70373; Government Code § 7600.5; Government Code § 76000 et seq; Government Code §76000.10 Government Code § 76104.6; Government Code §76104,7) ↑
ASSEMBLY THIRD READING
ATR Bill Id:AB 2099
Author:(Bauer-Kahan and McCarty)
As Introduced Ver:February 5, 2024
Majority vote
SUMMARY
Increases penalties for violations of the California Freedom of Access to Clinics and Church Entrances ("FACCE") Act.
Major Provisions
- Increases the penalty for a misdemeanor offense of posting on the internet or social media, threats of violence with the intent that another person imminently use that information to commit a violent crime against a reproductive health care worker to an alternate misdemeanor-felony[1] punishable by up to one year in the county jail or three years in the county jail.
- Increases the penalty for posting on the internet or social media threats of violence against a reproductive healthcare worker where it leads to bodily injury from a misdemeanor to a felony punishable by up to three years in the county jail.
- Increases the penalty from a misdemeanor to an alternate misdemeanor-felony punishably by up to one year in county jail, or up to three years in county jail, for willfully interfering with, injuring, intimidating, oppressing, or threatening, by use of force or threat of force, any person's ability in the free exercise of any right or privilege, ensured by the state and federal constitutional law or statutes because of one or more actual or perceived characteristics.
- Mandates the court order a defendant to perform a minimum of community service in addition to any criminal sentence for violations of specified crimes related to interference with the exercise of constitutional rights.
- Increases the penalties for the existing crimes under the FACCE Act, as follows:
- Punishes the first violation of the following offenses as an alternate-misdemeanor-felony subject to a penalty of one year in county jail or up to three years in county jail, a fine of up to $10,000, or by both imprisonment and fine:
- nonviolent physical obstruction, or where a person intentionally injures, intimidates, or interferes with, or attempts to injure, intimidate, or interfere with, any person or entity because that person or entity is a reproductive health services patient, provider, or assistant, or in order to intimidate any person or entity, or any class of persons or entities, from becoming or remaining a reproductive health services patient, provider, or assistant.
- By nonviolent physical obstruction, or where a person intentionally injures, intimidates, or interferes with, or attempts to injure, intimidate, or interfere with, a person lawfully exercising or seeking to exercise the First Amendment right of religious freedom at a place of religious worship.
- Within 100 feet of the entrance to, or within, a reproductive health services facility, intentionally videotape, film, photograph, or record by electronic means, a reproductive health services patient, provider, or assistant without that person's consent with specific intent to intimidate the person from becoming or remaining a reproductive health services patient, provider, or assistant, and thereby causes the person to be intimidated.
- Intentionally disclose or distribute a videotape, film, photograph, or recording knowing it was obtained unlawfully with the specific intent to intimidate the person from becoming or remaining a reproductive health services patient, provider, or assistant, and thereby causes the person to be intimidated.
- Increases the penalty for a second or subsequent violation of the offenses listed above in 5 (a) (i-iv), from an alternate misdemeanor-felony to a straight felony punishable by up to three years in county jail.
- Increases the penalties for a first violation of the following offenses from a misdemeanor to a straight felony punishable by up to three years in county jail:
- Intentionally damages or destroys the property of a person, entity, or facility, or attempts to do so, because the person, entity, or facility is a reproductive health services patient, provider, assistant, or facility.
- Intentionally damages or destroys the property of a place of religious worship.
- Punishes a second or subsequent violation of the following offenses as a felony subject to a penalty of up to three years in county jail, a fine of not more than $50,000, or by both imprisonment and fine:
- Using force, threat of force, or physical obstruction of violence, to intentionally injure, intimidate, interfere with, or attempt to injure, intimidate, or interfere with, any person or entity because that person or entity is a reproductive health services patient, provider, or assistant, or in order to intimidate a person or entity, or a class of persons or entities, or from becoming or remaining a reproductive health services patient, provider, or assistant.
- Using force, threat of force, or physical obstruction of violence, to intentionally injure, intimidate, interfere with, or attempt to injure, intimidate, or interfere with a person lawfully exercising or seeking to exercise the First Amendment right of religious freedom at a place of religious worship.
- Intentionally damaging or destroying the property of a person, entity, or facility, or attempts to do so, because the person, entity, or facility is a reproductive health services patient, provider, assistant, or facility.
- Intentionally damages or destroys the property of a person, entity, or facility, or attempts to do so, because the person, entity, or facility is a reproductive health services patient, provider, assistant, or facility.
- Intentionally damages or destroys the property of a place of religious worship.
COMMENTS
According to the Author
"Since the overturning of Roe vs. Wade, reproductive health clinics like Planned Parenthood have become the very last line for women seeking critical reproductive health care. These vulnerable patients and providers are facing an onslaught of organized harassment, being attacked online and in person. Current penalties are insufficient to deter extremist anti-abortion groups from attacking clinics and providers. AB 2099 updates our state penalties to protect the essential right to reproductive healthcare."
Arguments in Support
According to Planned Parenthood Affiliates of California, "In California, while we continue to work to expand and protect access to sexual and reproductive health care, we still witness the consequences of the national attack on abortion. Extremist lawmakers and their supporters have been transforming incredibly personal health care choices into political battlegrounds, creating dangerous consequences for people across the country. Attacks on reproductive health care, including abortion, contraception, gender-affirming care, and IVF have resulted in patients being denied care, forced to travel out-of-their home states in difficult circumstances, and endangering their health and well-being. These attacks have emboldened anti-abortion extremists.
"Since the Dobbs decision, there has been an increase in violence in abortion protective states like California. According to the National Abortion Federation, there was a disproportionate increase of anti-reproductive health incidents in protective states – stalking increased by 913%, assault and battery increased by 29%, bomb threats increased by 133% and obstruction of clinics increased by 538%.
"While California has existing protections in place under the Freedom to Access Clinic Entrances (FACE) Act, offenses are not always taken seriously and health centers face challenges with enforcement. Acts of violence and harassment have persisted for decades as anti-abortion extremists have faced little retribution for their escalating tactics and cultural complacency has normalized their activity. Violations of the FACE Act include intentionally injuring, intimidating, or obstructing access to a health center, vandalism, and modern forms of harassment such as posting personal information online with the intent to cause harm. According to a Feminist Majority Foundation survey of providers over half of providers face targeted threats and intimidation – often coming from highly organized and well-funded groups. Targeted threats and intimidation includes twelve variables: death threats, stalking, tracking of activities, vandalism of home or personal property, harassing phone calls, harassing emails/social media posts, pamphlets/leaflets targeting staff and physicians, personal information/pictures posted online, frivolous lawsuits, and threats to family members of staff or physicians.
"Attacks at clinics do not just have a negative impact on the staff and patients, but also contribute to a culture of fear. As more states criminalize reproductive health care, increasing not just safety in accessing care but also stigma, it is more crucial than ever that patients feel safe when seeking care in California. AB 2099 will strengthen the enforcement mechanisms for violations of the FACE Act in California and ensure that patients and providers can access the care they need, provide essential health care, and do so without fearing their safety".
Arguments in Opposition
None on file.
FISCAL COMMENTS
According to the Assembly Appropriations Committee, "Costs (local funds, General Fund) to the counties and the California Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation (CDCR) to incarcerate people who must serve longer sentences due to this bill. Costs may be in the hundreds of thousands to millions of dollars annually, depending on prosecutorial discretion in charging, the number of convictions, and defendants' criminal histories. The Legislative Analyst's Office (LAO) estimates the average annual cost to incarcerate one person in CDCR is $133,000. The average annual cost to incarcerate one person in county jail is approximately $29,000. Overcrowding in county jails creates cost pressure on the General Fund because the state has historically granted new funding to counties to offset overcrowding after the 2011 Realignment Act.
"According to the LAO, the General Fund faces a structural deficit in the tens of billions of dollars over the next several fiscal years."
VOTES
ASM PUBLIC SAFETY: 8-0-0
YES: McCarty, Alanis, Lackey, Stephanie Nguyen, Reyes, Ting, Wilson, Zbur
ASM APPROPRIATIONS: 13-0-2
YES: Wicks, Sanchez, Arambula, Bryan, Calderon, Wendy Carrillo, Mike Fong, Grayson, Haney, Hart, Jim Patterson, Pellerin, Villapudua
ABS, ABST OR NV: Dixon, Ta
UPDATED
VERSION: February 5, 2024
CONSULTANT: Kimberly Horiuchi / PUB. S. / (916) 319-3744 FN: 0003111
See fn. 2, infra, at p. 6. ↑
Date of Hearing: April 17, 2024
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Buffy Wicks, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 2099
Author:(Bauer-Kahan) – As Introduced Ver:February 5, 2024
Policy Committee: | Public Safety | Vote: | 8 - 0 |
|
| ||
|
|
Urgency: No State Mandated Local Program: Yes Reimbursable: No
SUMMARY:
This bill increases penalties for criminal offenses related to reproductive health care clinic safety, including violations of the California Freedom of Access to Clinics and Church Entrances (“FACE”) Act.
Specifically, among other provisions, this bill:
- Increases, from a misdemeanor to an alternate misdemeanor-felony (“wobbler”), the penalty for posting on the internet or social media, threats of violence with the intent that another person imminently use that information to commit a violent crime against a reproductive health care worker.
- Increases, from a misdemeanor to a wobbler, the penalty for posting on the internet or social media threats of violence against a reproductive healthcare worker where it leads to bodily injury.
- Increases, from a misdemeanor to a wobbler, the penalty for willfully interfering with, injuring, intimidating, oppressing, or threatening, by use of force or threat of force, any person’s ability in the free exercise of any right or privilege, ensured by the state and federal constitutional law or statutes because of one or more actual or perceived characteristics.
- Increases, from a misdemeanor to a felony, the penalty for both a first and subsequent violation for intentionally damaging or destroying property of a reproductive health care patient or provider, or intentionally damaging or destroying a place of worship.
- Increases, from a misdemeanor to a wobbler, the penalty for a first violation for using nonviolent obstruction to intentionally injure, intimidate, or interfere with reproductive health care workers or religious worship, and for filming a reproductive health care worker or patient within 100 feet of a reproductive health care facility, and for distributing such footage with intent to intimidate and causing intimidation.
- Increases, from a misdemeanor to a felony, the penalty for a subsequent violation of the offenses described in 5, above.
- Increases, from a misdemeanor to a felony, the penalty for a subsequent violation of using force, threat of force, or physical obstruction to intentionally injury, intimidate, or interfere with a person who is a reproductive health services patient or provider in order to intimidate them from becoming or remaining a patient or provider, or a person exercising or seeking to exercise their right of religious freedom at a place of worship.
FISCAL EFFECT:
Costs (local funds, General Fund) to the counties and the California Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation (CDCR) to incarcerate people who must serve longer sentences due to this bill. Costs may be in the hundreds of thousands to millions of dollars annually, depending on prosecutorial discretion in charging, the number of convictions, and defendants’ criminal histories. The Legislative Analyst’s Office (LAO) estimates the average annual cost to incarcerate one person in CDCR is $133,000. The average annual cost to incarcerate one person in county jail is approximately $29,000. Overcrowding in county jails creates cost pressure on the General Fund because the state has historically granted new funding to counties to offset overcrowding after the 2011 Realignment Act.
According to the LAO, the General Fund faces a structural deficit in the tens of billions of dollars over the next several fiscal years.
COMMENTS:
- Purpose. According to the author:
Since the overturning of Roe vs. Wade, reproductive health clinics like Planned Parenthood have become the very last line for women seeking critical reproductive health care. These vulnerable patients and providers are facing an onslaught of organized harassment, being attacked online and in person. Current penalties are insufficient to deter extremist anti-abortion groups from attacking clinics and providers. AB 2099 updates our state penalties to protect the essential right to reproductive healthcare.
- Background. The California FACE Act, enacted in 2001, provides criminal and civil penalties for interference with rights to reproductive health services and religious worship. In 2021, California enacted AB 1356 (Bauer-Kahan), Chapter 191, Statutes of 2021, which provided more protections for people seeking reproductive health care assistance and service providers. Specifically, AB 1356 created new crimes under the FACE Act for videotaping, photographing, or recording patients or providers within 100 feet of an applicable facility or disclosing or distributing those images. It also increased misdemeanor penalties for violations of the FACE Act and expanded online privacy laws and peace officer trainings relative to anti-reproduction-rights offenses.
This bill further increases the penalties for criminal violations of the FACE Act, as described briefly above and in more detail in the policy committee analysis of this bill. The bill increases several existing misdemeanors to wobblers and other existing misdemeanors to felonies. A wobbler is a criminal offense that may be charged either as a misdemeanor or a felony. By increasing the maximum jail sentences for these offenses and making them punishable, in some circumstances, by incarceration in state prison, this bill will result in significant incarceration costs to the counties and the state. Depending on the number of convictions affected by this bill, those costs may be in the millions of dollars annually.
Studies have shown that, in most circumstances, lengthy criminal sentences do not effectively deter crime. According to the Committee on Revision of the Penal Code, a “major analysis of more than 100 studies concluded that it was a ‘criminological fact’ that incarceration is no better at reducing reoffending than noncustodial sanctions such as probation.” (Committee on Revision of the Penal Code, “Annual Report and Recommendations,” 2021.) In light of the growing cost of incarceration and its limited utility in deterring crime, both the Little Hoover Commission and the Committee on Revision of the Penal Code have encouraged sentencing reform in California.
Analysis Prepared by: Annika Carlson / APPR. / (916) 319-2081
Date of Hearing: April 2, 2024
Counsel: Kimberly Horiuchi
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON
Kevin McCarty, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:
Author:() – As Ver:
SUMMARY:
Increases penalties for violations of the California Freedom of Access to Clinics and Church Entrances (“FACCE”) Act. Specifically, this bill:
- Increases the penalty for a misdemeanor offense of posting on the internet or social media, threats of violence with the intent that another person imminently use that information to commit a violent crime against a reproductive health care worker to an alternate misdemeanor-felony[1] punishable by up to one year in the county jail or three years in the county jail.
- Increases the penalty for posting on the internet or social media threats of violence against a reproductive healthcare worker where it leads to bodily injury from a misdemeanor to a felony punishable by up to three years in the county jail.
- Increases the penalty from a misdemeanor to an alternate misdemeanor-felony punishably by up to one year in county jail, or up to three years in county jail, for willfully interfering with, injuring, intimidating, oppressing, or threatening, by use of force or threat of force, any person’s ability in the free exercise of any right or privilege, ensured by the state and federal constitutional law or statutes because of one or more actual or perceived characteristics.
- Mandates the court order a defendant to perform a minimum of community service in addition to any criminal sentence for violations of specified crimes related to interference with the exercise of constitutional rights.
- Increases the penalties for the existing crimes under the FACCE Act, as follows:
- Punishes the first violation of the following offenses as an alternate-misdemeanor-felony subject to a penalty of one year in county jail or up to three years in county jail, a fine of up to $10,000, or by both imprisonment and fine:
- nonviolent physical obstruction, or where a person intentionally injures, intimidates, or interferes with, or attempts to injure, intimidate, or interfere with, any person or entity because that person or entity is a reproductive health services patient, provider, or assistant, or in order to intimidate any person or entity, or any class of persons or entities, from becoming or remaining a reproductive health services patient, provider, or assistant.
- By nonviolent physical obstruction, or where a person intentionally injures, intimidates, or interferes with, or attempts to injure, intimidate, or interfere with, a person lawfully exercising or seeking to exercise the First Amendment right of religious freedom at a place of religious worship.
- Within 100 feet of the entrance to, or within, a reproductive health services facility, intentionally videotape, film, photograph, or record by electronic means, a reproductive health services patient, provider, or assistant without that person’s consent with specific intent to intimidate the person from becoming or remaining a reproductive health services patient, provider, or assistant, and thereby causes the person to be intimidated.
- Intentionally disclose or distribute a videotape, film, photograph, or recording knowing it was obtained unlawfully with the specific intent to intimidate the person from becoming or remaining a reproductive health services patient, provider, or assistant, and thereby causes the person to be intimidated.
- nonviolent physical obstruction, or where a person intentionally injures, intimidates, or interferes with, or attempts to injure, intimidate, or interfere with, any person or entity because that person or entity is a reproductive health services patient, provider, or assistant, or in order to intimidate any person or entity, or any class of persons or entities, from becoming or remaining a reproductive health services patient, provider, or assistant.
- Increases the penalty for a second or subsequent violation of the offenses listed above in 5 (a) (i-iv), from an alternate misdemeanor-felony to a straight felony punishable by up to three years in county jail.
- Increases the penalties for a first violation of the following offenses from a misdemeanor to a straight felony punishable by up to three years in county jail:
- Intentionally damages or destroys the property of a person, entity, or facility, or attempts to do so, because the person, entity, or facility is a reproductive health services patient, provider, assistant, or facility.
- Intentionally damages or destroys the property of a place of religious worship.
- Intentionally damages or destroys the property of a person, entity, or facility, or attempts to do so, because the person, entity, or facility is a reproductive health services patient, provider, assistant, or facility.
- Punishes a second or subsequent violation of the following offenses as a felony subject to a penalty of up to three years in county jail, a fine of not more than $50,000, or by both imprisonment and fine:
- Using force, threat of force, or physical obstruction of violence, to intentionally injure, intimidate, interfere with, or attempt to injure, intimidate, or interfere with, any person or entity because that person or entity is a reproductive health services patient, provider, or assistant, or in order to intimidate a person or entity, or a class of persons or entities, or from becoming or remaining a reproductive health services patient, provider, or assistant.
- Using force, threat of force, or physical obstruction of violence, to intentionally injure, intimidate, interfere with, or attempt to injure, intimidate, or interfere with a person lawfully exercising or seeking to exercise the First Amendment right of religious freedom at a place of religious worship.
- Intentionally damaging or destroying the property of a person, entity, or facility, or attempts to do so, because the person, entity, or facility is a reproductive health services patient, provider, assistant, or facility.
- Intentionally damages or destroys the property of a person, entity, or facility, or attempts to do so, because the person, entity, or facility is a reproductive health services patient, provider, assistant, or facility.
- Intentionally damages or destroys the property of a place of religious worship.
- Using force, threat of force, or physical obstruction of violence, to intentionally injure, intimidate, interfere with, or attempt to injure, intimidate, or interfere with, any person or entity because that person or entity is a reproductive health services patient, provider, or assistant, or in order to intimidate a person or entity, or a class of persons or entities, or from becoming or remaining a reproductive health services patient, provider, or assistant.
EXISTING LAW:
- Provides that any reproductive health service provider, employee, volunteer, or patient who is placed in reasonable fear by the posting of their home address and phone number on an Internet website may make a written demand that such information be removed from the website, so long as the demand includes a sworn statement describing the reasonable fear and attesting that the person is a member of the group protected by the statute. Provides injunctive relief. (Govt. Code, § 6281, subd. (b).)
- Makes it a misdemeanor, punishable by up to 6 months in a county jail, a fine of not more than $2,500, or both that fine and imprisonment, to post the home address, telephone number, or personally identifying information about a provider, employee, volunteer, or patient of a reproductive health service facility or other individuals residing at the same home address with the intent that another person imminently use that information to commit a crime involving violence or a threat of violence against that person or entity. If the violation leads to bodily injury of the person, it is a misdemeanor punishable by up to one year in a county jail, a fine of up to $5,000, or both that fine and imprisonment. (Govt. Code, § 6218.01.)
- Defines “reproductive health care services” to mean health care services relating to the termination of a pregnancy in a reproductive health care services facility. (Govt. Code, § 6218.05, subd. (a).)
- Defines “reproductive health care services provider, employee, volunteer, or patient” means a person who obtains, provides, or assists, at the request of another person, in obtaining or providing reproductive health care services, or a person who owns or operates a reproductive health care services facility. (Govt. Code, § 6218.05, subd. (b).)
- Defines “reproductive health care services facility” includes a hospital, an office operated by a licensed physician and surgeon, a licensed clinic or a clinic exempt from licensure, or other licensed health care facility that provides reproductive health care services and includes only the building or structure in which the reproductive health care services are actually provided. (Govt. Code, § 6218.05, subd. (c).)
- Defines “public post” or “publicly display” as meaning to intentionally communicate or otherwise make available to the general public. (Govt. Code, § 6218.05, subd. (d).)
- Defines “image” as including, but not limited to, any photograph, video footage, sketch, or computer-generated image that provides a means to visually identify the person depicted. (Govt. Code, § 6218.05, subd. (e).)
- Defines “crime of violence” as an offense that has as an element the use, attempted use, or threatened use of physical force against the person or property of another. (Pen. Code, § 423.1, subd. (a).)
- Defines “interfere with” as meaning to restrict a person’s freedom of movement. (Pen. Code, § 423.1, subd. (b).)
- Defines “intimidate” as meaning to place a person in reasonable apprehension of bodily harm to herself or himself or to another. (Pen. Code, § 423.1, subd. (c).)
- Defines “nonviolent” as meaning to conduct that would not constitute a crime of violence. (Pen. Code, § 423.1, subd. (d).)
- Defines “physical obstruction” as rendering ingress to or egress from a reproductive health services facility or to or from a place of religious worship impassable to another person, or rendering passage to or from a reproductive health services facility or a place of religious worship unreasonably difficult or hazardous to another person. (Pen. Code, § 423.1, subd. (e).)
- Defines “reproductive health services” as meaning reproductive health services provided in a hospital, clinic, physician’s office, or other facility and includes medical, surgical, counseling, or referral services relating to the human reproductive system, including services relating to pregnancy or the termination of a pregnancy. (Pen. Code, § 423.1, subd. (f).)
- Defines “reproductive health services client, provider, or assistant” as a person or entity that is or was involved in obtaining, seeking to obtain, providing, seeking to provide, or assisting or seeking to assist another person, at that other person’s request, to obtain or provide any services in a reproductive health services facility, or a person or entity that is or was involved in owning or operating or seeking to own or operate, a reproductive health services facility. (Pen. Code, § 423.1, subd. (g).)
- States “reproductive health services facility” includes a hospital, clinic, physician’s office, or other facility that provides or seeks to provide reproductive health services and includes the building or structure in which the facility is located. (Pen. Code, § 423.1, subd. (h).)
- Provides that every person who, except a parent or guardian acting towards his or her minor child or ward, commits any of the following acts shall be subject to the punishment, as specified (Pen. Code, § 423.2, subds. (a)-(f)):
- By force, threat of force, or physical obstruction that is a crime of violence, intentionally injures, intimidates, interferes with, or attempts to injure, intimidate, or interfere with, any person or entity because that person or entity is a reproductive health services client, provider, or assistant, or in order to intimidate any person or entity, or any class of persons or entities, from becoming or remaining a reproductive health services client, provider, or assistant; or
- By force, threat of force, or physical obstruction that is a crime of violence, intentionally injures, intimidates, interferes with, or attempts to injure, intimidate, or interfere with any person lawfully exercising or seeking to exercise the First Amendment right of religious freedom at a place of religious worship; or
- By nonviolent physical obstruction, intentionally injures, intimidates, or interferes with, or attempts to injure, intimidate, or interfere with, any person or entity because that person or entity is a reproductive health services client, provider, or assistant, or in order to intimidate any person or entity, or any class of persons or entities, from becoming or remaining a reproductive health services client, provider, or assistant; or
- By nonviolent physical obstruction, intentionally injures, intimidates, or interferes with, or attempts to injure, intimidate, or interfere with, any person lawfully exercising or seeking to exercise the First Amendment right of religious freedom at a place of religious worship; or
- Intentionally damages or destroys the property of a person, entity, or facility, or attempts to do so, because the person, entity, or facility is a reproductive health services client, provider, assistant, or facility; or
- Intentionally damages or destroys the property of a place of religious worship. (Pen. Code, § 423.2.)
- By force, threat of force, or physical obstruction that is a crime of violence, intentionally injures, intimidates, interferes with, or attempts to injure, intimidate, or interfere with, any person or entity because that person or entity is a reproductive health services client, provider, or assistant, or in order to intimidate any person or entity, or any class of persons or entities, from becoming or remaining a reproductive health services client, provider, or assistant; or
- Makes a first violation involving nonviolent physical obstruction a misdemeanor, punishable by imprisonment in a county jail for a period of not more than six months and a fine not to exceed two thousand dollars ($2,000). (Pen. Code, § 423.3, subd. (a).)
- Makes a second or subsequent violation involving violation involving nonviolent physical obstruction a misdemeanor, punishable by imprisonment in a county jail for a period of not more than six months and a fine not to exceed five thousand dollars ($5,000). (Pen. Code, § 423.3, subd. (b).)
- Makes a first violation involving force, threat of force, or physical obstruction that is a crime of violence or intentional property damage a misdemeanor, punishable by imprisonment in a county jail for a period of not more than one year and a fine not to exceed twenty-five thousand dollars ($25,000). (Pen. Code, § 423.3, subd. (c).)
- Makes a second or subsequent violation involving force, threat of force, or physical obstruction that is a crime of violence or intentional property damage a misdemeanor, punishable by imprisonment in a county jail for a period of not more than one year and a fine not to exceed fifty thousand dollars ($50,000). (Pen. Code, § 423.3, subd. (d).)
- States that this title establishes concurrent state jurisdiction over conduct that is also prohibited by the federal Freedom of Access to Clinic Entrances Act of 1994 (18 U.S.C. Sec. 248), which provides for more severe misdemeanor penalties for first violations and felony-misdemeanor penalties for second and subsequent violations. State law enforcement agencies and prosecutors shall cooperate with federal authorities in the prevention, apprehension, and prosecution of these crimes, and shall seek federal prosecutions when appropriate. (Pen. Code, § 423.3, subd. (f).)
- Makes it a misdemeanor to, by force or threat of force, willfully injure, intimidate, interfere with, oppress, or threaten another person in the free exercise or enjoyment of a right or privilege secured by the Constitution or laws of this state or by the Constitution or laws of the United States, in whole or in part, because of one or more of specified actual or perceived characteristics of the victim, including disability, gender, religion, race, or sexual orientation. (Pen. Code, §§ 422.6, subd. (a) & 422.55, subd. (a).)
- Makes it a misdemeanor to knowingly deface, damage, or destroy the real or personal property of another person for the purpose of intimidating or interfering with the free exercise or enjoyment of a right or privilege secured by the Constitution or laws of this state or by the Constitution or laws of the United States, in whole or in part, because of one or more of the same actual or perceived characteristics of the victim. (Pen. Code, §§ 422.6, subd. (b) & 422.55, subd. (a).)
FISCAL EFFECT:
Unknown
COMMENTS:
- Author’s Statement: According to the author: Since the overturning of Roe vs. Wade, reproductive health clinics like Planned Parenthood have become the very last line for women seeking critical reproductive health care. These vulnerable patients and providers are facing an onslaught of organized harassment, being attacked online and in person. Current penalties are insufficient to deter extremist anti-abortion groups from attacking clinics and providers. AB 2099 updates our state penalties to protect the essential right to reproductive healthcare.”
- AB 1356 (Bauer-Kahan), Chapter 191, Statutes of 2021: AB 1356 was enacted in 2021 and provided more protections for those seeking reproductive healthcare assistance and people that provide those services. Specifically, as enacted, it created new crimes under FACCE Act directed at videotaping, photographing, or recording patients or providers within 100 feet of the facility (i.e., the "buffer" zone) or disclosing or distributing those images. It also increased misdemeanor penalties for violations of the FACCE Act and expanded online privacy laws and peace officer trainings relative to anti-reproduction-rights offenses. However, the felony penalties appear to have been removed in the Senate – before the bill was signed into law. This bill creates several new felonies requiring commitment in county jail for up to three years or state prison depending[2] on the defendant’s criminal history. (See Pen. Code, § 1170, subd. (h)(3).) Has there been an increase in attacks on reproductive clinics or people seeking reproductive services since AB 1356 was enacted? Given that we just increased penalties for these offenses, does it make sense to consider alternate solutions?
- First Amendment: First Amendment provides that “Congress shall make no law . . . abridging the freedom of speech.” (U.S. Const, Amend. I, Section 1.) The California Constitution also protects free speech. “Every person may freely speak, write and publish his or her sentiments on all subjects, being responsible for the abuse of this right. A law may not restrain or abridge liberty of speech or press.” (Cal. Const. Art. I, § 2.) “[A]s a general matter, the First Amendment means that government has no power to restrict expression because of its message, its ideas, its subject matter, or its content.” (Ashcroft v. American Civil Liberties Union (2002) 535 U.S. 564, 573.)
“To achieve First Amendment protection, a plaintiff must show that [t]he[y] possessed: (1) a message to be communicated; and (2) an audience to receive that message, regardless of the medium in which the message is to be expressed.” (Hurley v. Irish-American Gay, Lesbian & Bisexual Group (1995) 515 U.S. 557.)
With personal filming devices being commonplace, more and more “news” is being gathered and disseminated by members of the public. The courts have found that freedom of the press applies to citizen journalists and documentarians, not just formal members of the press. (See, e.g., Glik v. Cunniffe (1st Cir. 2011) 655 F.3d 78 [“plaintiff was exercising clearly-established First Amendment rights in filming the officers in a public space”].)
Legislation that regulates the content of protected speech is subject to strict scrutiny, sometimes referred to by the courts as “exacting scrutiny” in this context. (Reed v. Town of Gilbert, Ariz. (2015) 135 S.Ct. 2218, 2226.) To survive strict scrutiny, state action must be narrowly tailored to address a compelling government interest. (Ibid.) However, restrictions on speech around reproductive health care centers have passed constitutional muster as explained below.
- The California FACCE Act: In 2001, the Legislature enacted the California FACCE Act, mirroring the federal Freedom of Access to Clinic Entrances (FACE) Act. California’s FACCE Act provides state criminal and civil penalties for interference with rights to reproductive health services and religious worship. As stated above, AB 1356 added a 100 ft., buffer zone around reproductive healthcare facilities wherein it is unlawful to “intentionally videotape, film, photograph, or records by electronic means, any reproductive health services patient, provider, or assistant without that person’s consent, with specific intent to intimidate the person from becoming or remaining a reproductive health services patient, provider, or assistant, and thereby causes the person to be intimidated.”
The enactment of “buffer zones” around reproductive health care facilities were designed to protect reproductive health care services patients and providers from being harassed, photographed, or threatened just for walking in and out of a reproductive health care facility. According to Guttmacher Institute, a leading research and policy organization working to advance sexual and reproductive health and rights worldwide, there are numerous protections around the U.S. for people working at, or seeking the services of, a reproductive healthcare facility.
States have taken two approaches designed to protect abortion providers. Some states have enacted laws similar to the federal FACE Act that prohibit specific activities such as vandalism or obstruction at clinics. Other states have limited protests aimed at clinic patients by either creating “buffer” zones around clinics that bar protestors entirely or establishing floating “bubble zones” of several feet around a person who is within a specific distance of a clinic; protesters are prohibited from crossing into that “bubble zone” without the person’s consent.
In 2014, the U.S. Supreme Court struck down the Massachusetts law that placed a 35-foot buffer zone around clinic entrances. The impact of this ruling on the New Hampshire law is still to be determined, but the decision did not immediately affect the Court’s 2000 ruling that upheld Colorado’s floating ‘bubble [or buffer] zone’ law.
15 states and the District of Columbia prohibit certain specified actions aimed at abortion providers: 13 of the states and the District of Columbia prohibit blocking the entrance to and egress from clinic facilities; seven of the states and the District of Columbia prohibit threatening or intimidating staff who provide reproductive health services and/or patients entering the clinic; four of the states prohibit property damage to facilities providing reproductive health services; two of the states and the District of Columbia prohibit telephone harassment of staff who provide reproductive health services; six of the states and the District of Columbia prohibit other specified actions, such as creating excessive noise outside the clinic, possessing or having access to a weapon during a demonstration at a medical facility, trespassing, or releasing a substance that produces noxious odor on clinic premises; and four states have established a “bubble zone” around a person within a specific distance of a clinic’s entrance or driveway. (Guttmacher Institute (August 31, 2023) Public Policy Office, Protecting Access to Clinics, Background.) [3]
The Massachusetts “buffer” zone made it a “crime to knowingly stand on a ‘public way or sidewalk’ within 35 feet of an entrance or driveway to any ‘reproductive health care facility,’ defined as ‘a place, other than within or upon the grounds of a hospital, where abortions are offered or performed.’” (McCullen v. Cookley (2014) 573 U.S. 474.) The U.S. Supreme Court held the law violated the First Amendment. (Ibid. [state law creating 35-foot buffer zones around all abortion clinics was not justified by congestion in front of one clinic on Saturday mornings].)
However, the Supreme Court declined to hear two challenges to two other buffer zones: in Harrisburg, Pennsylvania and Chicago, Illinois. In those cases, the buffer zone at issue was much lower than 100 feet, and were, at least, tacitly approved by the Court when it denied certiorari. According to one article in the national press coverage,
On Thursday, one of the two cases the court declined to take up involved an ordinance passed by the city counsel in Harrisburg, Pennsylvania’s capital, in 2012 that made it illegal to “congregate, patrol, picket or demonstrate” in a zone 20 feet from a health care facility. Anti-abortion activists sued, arguing that the ordinance violates their free speech rights. Lower courts have upheld the ordinance, however, ruling it doesn’t apply to “sidewalk counseling,” where individuals who oppose abortion offer assistance and information about alternatives to abortion to those entering a clinic.
The second case the court turned away on Thursday involved a Chicago ordinance that regulates the space 50 feet from the entrance of any abortion clinic or other medical facility. In that space, a person cannot come within 8 feet of another person without their consent to hand them information or engage in “oral protest, education, or counseling.” The ordinance was modeled on a statute upheld by the Supreme Court in 2000. (Jessica Gresko (July 2, 2020) “Higher Court won’t hear abortion clinic ‘buffer zone’ cases,” Associated News Press.)[4]
- Jail Operations: In January 2010, a three-judge panel issued a ruling ordering the State of California to reduce its prison population to 137.5% of design capacity because overcrowding was the primary reason that CDCR was unable to provide inmates with constitutionally adequate healthcare. (Coleman/Plata v. Schwarzenegger (2010) No. Civ S-90-0520 LKK JFM P/NO. C01-1351 THE.) The United State Supreme Court upheld the decision, declaring that “without a reduction in overcrowding, there will be no efficacious remedy for the unconstitutional care of the sick and mentally ill” inmates in California’s prisons. (Brown v. Plata (2011) 131 S.Ct. 1910, 1939; 179 L.Ed.2d 969, 999.)
AB 109, The Criminal Justice Realignment Act, was implemented in 2011 in response to prison overcrowding. In part, it shifted to county jails the responsibility for incarcerating lower-level offenders previously incarcerated in state prison. (Pen. Code, § 1170, subd. (h).) This, however, increased the pressure on county jails to house larger populations and to make difficult decisions about how to manage their growing jail populations. These pressures manifest differently by county based on a number of factors including jail capacity and whether the county jail system is operating under a court-mandated population cap. Such caps have been in place in some counties long before Brown v. Plata addressed state prison overcrowding. (Sarah Lawrence, Court-Ordered Population Caps in California County Jails (Dec. 2014).)[5]
Recently, CalMatters published an article explaining that jails are facing increasing death rates even as the population may be declining. As the article explains, most of the people who died were pre-trial inmates – meaning they have not been convicted. Aside from natural causes, the two major causes of death for inmates in county jail were suicide, followed by overdoses, particularly fentanyl. The Board of State and Community Corrections (“BSCC”) have repeatedly warned about failures in the county jails and refusal by locals to adhere to required state standards. Until recently, BSCC was not even notified about deaths inside the county-run lockups. Nor was the pandemic the driving factor: California in 2022 had the smallest share of deaths due to natural causes in the past four decades. A surge in overdoses drove the trend of increasing deaths. And almost every person who died was waiting to be tried. A previous CalMatters investigation found that three-quarters of those held in county jails had not been convicted or sentenced, with many awaiting trial more than three years. (Duara and Kimelman, “California jails are holding thousands fewer people but far more people are dying in them,” Cal Matters (March 25, 2024).)[6]
While the numbers of incarcerated people may have declined, the amount of death and harm befalling incarcerated people has increased. Increasing the total number of people sentenced to jail will only exacerbate this problem. Is increasing criminal penalties the best way to prevent harassment or violence against those working at, or seeking assistance from, a reproductive healthcare services provider? Given the complications of a First Amendment defense, it is not clear how many people will actually be prosecuted for these crimes. If this does not solve the problem identified by the author, will progressively more severe penalties be proposed? The Legislature enacted AB 1356 in 2021 – is there any evidence that these changes have not stemmed the tide of alleged attacks against those seeking or providing reproductive services? This is, most certainly, an extremely important law to enforce – how aggressively is the FACCE Act enforced by law enforcement? If law enforcement does not arrest anyone for these offenses, escalating penalties may not make a lot of difference.
- Argument in Support: According to Planned Parenthood Affiliates of California, “In California, while we continue to work to expand and protect access to sexual and reproductive health care, we still witness the consequences of the national attack on abortion. Extremist lawmakers and their supporters have been transforming incredibly personal health care choices into political battlegrounds, creating dangerous consequences for people across the country. Attacks on reproductive health care, including abortion, contraception, gender-affirming care, and IVF have resulted in patients being denied care, forced to travel out-of-their home states in difficult circumstances, and endangering their health and well-being. These attacks have emboldened anti-abortion extremists.
“Since the Dobbs decision, there has been an increase in violence in abortion protective states like California. According to the National Abortion Federation, there was a disproportionate increase of anti-reproductive health incidents in protective states – stalking increased by 913%, assault and battery increased by 29%, bomb threats increased by 133% and obstruction of clinics increased by 538%.
“While California has existing protections in place under the Freedom to Access Clinic Entrances (FACE) Act, offenses are not always taken seriously and health centers face challenges with enforcement. Acts of violence and harassment have persisted for decades as anti-abortion extremists have faced little retribution for their escalating tactics and cultural complacency has normalized their activity. Violations of the FACE Act include intentionally injuring, intimidating, or obstructing access to a health center, vandalism, and modern forms of harassment such as posting personal information online with the intent to cause harm. According to a Feminist Majority Foundation survey of providers over half of providers face targeted threats and intimidation – often coming from highly organized and well-funded groups. Targeted threats and intimidation includes twelve variables: death threats, stalking, tracking of activities, vandalism of home or personal property, harassing phone calls, harassing emails/social media posts, pamphlets/leaflets targeting staff and physicians, personal information/pictures posted online, frivolous lawsuits, and threats to family members of staff or physicians.
“Attacks at clinics do not just have a negative impact on the staff and patients, but also contribute to a culture of fear. As more states criminalize reproductive health care, increasing not just safety in accessing care but also stigma, it is more crucial than ever that patients feel safe when seeking care in California. AB 2099 will strengthen the enforcement mechanisms for violations of the FACE Act in California and ensure that patients and providers can access the care they need, provide essential health care, and do so without fearing their safety”.
- Argument in Opposition: None on file.
- Related Legislation:
- AB 254 (Bauer-Kahan), Chapter 254, Statutes of 2023, revises the Confidentiality of Medical Information Act (CMIA) to include reproductive or sexual health application information into the definition of medical information.
- SB 36 (Skinner) prohibits the issuance of warrants for persons who have violated the laws of another state relating to abortion, contraception, reproductive care, and gender-affirming care that are legally protected in California. SB 36 was held on the Senate Committee on Appropriations suspense file.
- SB 848 (Rubio), Chapter 724, Statutes of 2023 requires employers, of five or more employees, to provide eligible employees with up to five days of reproductive loss leave following a reproductive loss event defined as a failed adoption, failed surrogacy, miscarriage, stillbirth or an unsuccessful assisted reproduction.
- AB 254 (Bauer-Kahan), Chapter 254, Statutes of 2023, revises the Confidentiality of Medical Information Act (CMIA) to include reproductive or sexual health application information into the definition of medical information.
- Prior Legislation:
- AB 1356 (Bauer-Kahan), Chapter 191, Statutes of 2021, created crimes under the California Freedom of Access to Clinic Act (Act) directed at videotaping, photographing, or recording patients or providers within 100 feet of the facility ("buffer" zone) or disclosing or distributing those images; increases misdemeanor penalties for violations of the Act; and updates and expands online privacy laws and peace officer trainings relative to anti-reproduction-rights offenses.
- AB 3140 (Bauer-Kahan), of the 2019-2020 Legislative Session, would have created additional crimes under the Act and increased penalties. AB 3140 was not heard in this committee.
- AB 2330 (Olsen), of the 2011-2012 Legislative Session, would have abolished the Commission on the Status of Women. AB 2330 failed passage in the Assembly Business, Professions, and Consumer Protection Committee.
- SB 1770 (Padilla), Chapter 206, Statutes of 2008, (1) extended the sunset on the Reproductive Rights Law Enforcement Act from January 1, 2009 to January 1, 2014, (2) required the Advisory Committee responsible for reporting on the implementation of, and the effectiveness of, the Attorney General plan for Reproductive Rights Law Enforcement Act to submit a second report to the Legislature by December 31, 2011, (3) required POST to prepare guidelines for law enforcement response to anti-reproductive rights crimes, as specified, and (4) amended the existing specifications for law enforcement training on anti-reproductive rights crimes to require that POST distribute training bulletins to law enforcement agencies on this topic, as specified.
- AB 2251 (Evans), Chapter 486, Statutes of 2006, sought to protect the personal safety of reproductive health care providers, employees, volunteers, and patients by prohibiting the posting of such people's personal information on the Internet under specified circumstances.
- SB 603 (Ortiz), Chapter 481, Statutes of 2006, required the Commission on the Status of Women to convene an advisory committee that would be responsible for reporting, as specified, to the Legislature and specified agencies on the implementation of the Reproductive Rights Law Enforcement Act and the effectiveness of the plan developed by the Attorney General.
- SB 780 (Ortiz), Chapter 899, Statutes of 2001, created the California FACCE Act, which provided state criminal and civil penalties for interference with rights to reproductive health services and religious worship
- AB 1356 (Bauer-Kahan), Chapter 191, Statutes of 2021, created crimes under the California Freedom of Access to Clinic Act (Act) directed at videotaping, photographing, or recording patients or providers within 100 feet of the facility ("buffer" zone) or disclosing or distributing those images; increases misdemeanor penalties for violations of the Act; and updates and expands online privacy laws and peace officer trainings relative to anti-reproduction-rights offenses.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists District Ix
Planned Parenthood Affiliates of California
Reproductive Freedom for All
Opposition
None Submitted.
Analysis Prepared by:
See fn. 2, infra, at p. 6. ↑
Any defendant who has a prior conviction for a serious or non-violent felony, or any offense required to register as a sex offender, shall be incarcerated in state prison – not county jail – even where the penalty in the statute cites to Penal Code section 1170, subdivision (h), which generally requires commitment in county jail. (Pen. Code, § 1170, subd. (h)(3).) ↑
Located at https://www.guttmacher.org/state-policy/explore/protecting-access-clinics last visited March 26, 2024. ↑
Located at https://apnews.com/article/31d02c9336e9f3c2a5d9dea4a883e72c ↑
Located at https://law.stanford.edu/search-sls/?q_as=california%20county%20jails [last visited March 26, 2024]. ↑
Located at https://calmatters.org/justice/2024/03/death-in-california-jails/ [last visited March 16, 2024.] ↑
Discussed in Hearing
Assembly Floor
Senate Floor
Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations
Senate Standing Committee on Public Safety
Assembly Floor
Assembly Standing Committee on Public Safety
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):