AB 2125: Judicial officers: disqualification.
- Session Year: 2023-2024
- House: Assembly
- Latest Version Date: 2024-05-16
Current Status:
Failed
(2024-08-15: In committee: Held under submission.)
Introduced
In Committee
First Chamber
In Committee
Second Chamber
Enacted
Existing law authorizes a party or attorney in an action or proceeding to move to disqualify a judge, court commissioner, or referee for prejudice against a party or attorney or the interest of a party or attorney, as specified. Prejudice may be established by an oral or written motion without notice supported by affidavit or declaration under penalty of perjury, or an oral statement under oath, that the judge, court commissioner, or referee is prejudiced against a party or attorney, or the interest of the party or attorney, so that the party or attorney cannot, or believes that they cannot, have a fair and impartial trial or hearing. Existing law requires, in specified circumstances, the Chair of the Judicial Council to assign some other judge, court commissioner, or referee to try the cause or hear the matter as promptly as possible. Existing law specifies that these provisions do not apply to a judge designated or assigned to serve on the appellate division of a superior court in the judges capacity as a judge in that division.
This bill, from January 1, 2025, to January 1, 2031, would repeal that exclusion and would extend these provisions to authorize a party or attorney to disqualify a justice or justices of an appellate court for prejudice against a party or attorney, or the interest of a party or attorney, as specified. The bill would authorize the motion directed to one or more justices of a court of appeal to only be made following reversal by the California Supreme Court of a court of appeals decision, and may only be directed to the justice or justices who authored or concurred in the prior decision and who is or are assigned to further consider the matter. The bill would authorize the party who obtained the reversal of a decision of a court of appeal to make that motion regardless of whether that party or side has previously done so. The bill would require, for cases reversed on or after January 1, 2025, the motion to be made within 30 days after the party or the partys attorney has been notified of the assignment. The bill would require, for cases reversed before January 1, 2025, and remaining pending as of the effective date of this act, the motion to be made on or before January 31, 2025. The bill would require, if the motion is duly presented and the affidavit or declaration under penalty of perjury is duly filed or an oral statement under oath is duly made, that the presiding justice assign other justice or justices or transfer the case to another panel of justices. The bill would also require, in specified circumstances, the Chair of the Judicial Council to assign some other justice or justices to hear the matter as promptly as possible.The bill would require the California Law Revision Commission to deliver, on or before September 30, 2027, a study regarding the recusal of judicial officers for prejudice and conflict of interest, as specified. The bill would require the California Law Revision Commission to consult with the Commission on Judicial Performance in developing the study. This bill would make these provisions inoperative on September 30, 2031, and would repeal it as of January 1, 2032.
Existing law authorizes a party or attorney in an action or proceeding to move to disqualify a judge, court commissioner, or referee for prejudice against a party or attorney or the interest of a party or attorney, as specified. Prejudice may be established by an oral or written motion without notice supported by affidavit or declaration under penalty of perjury, or an oral statement under oath, that the judge, court commissioner, or referee is prejudiced against a party or attorney, or the interest of the party or attorney, so that the party or attorney cannot, or believes that they cannot, have a fair and impartial trial or hearing. Existing law requires, in specified circumstances, the Chair of the Judicial Council to assign some other judge, court commissioner, or referee to try the cause or hear the matter as promptly as possible. Existing law specifies that these provisions do not apply to a judge designated or assigned to serve on the appellate division of a superior court in the judges capacity as a judge in that division.
This bill bill, from January 1, 2025, to January 1, 2031, would repeal that exclusion and would extend these provisions to authorize a party or attorney to disqualify a justice or justices of an appellate court for prejudice against a party or attorney, or the interest of a party or attorney, as specified. The bill would authorize the motion directed to one or more justices of a court of appeal to only be made following reversal by the California Supreme Court of a court of appeals decision, and may only be directed to the justice or justices who authored or concurred in the prior decision and who is or are assigned to further consider the matter. The bill would authorize the party who obtained the reversal of a decision of a court of appeal to make that motion regardless of whether that party or side has previously done so. The bill would require, for cases reversed on or after January 1, 2025, the motion to be made within 30 days after the party or the partys attorney has been notified of the assignment. The bill would require, for cases reversed before January 1, 2025, and remaining pending as of the effective date of this act, the motion to be made on or before January 31, 2025. The bill would require, if the motion is duly presented and the affidavit or declaration under penalty of perjury is duly filed or an oral statement under oath is duly made, that the presiding justice assign other justice or justices or transfer the case to another panel of justices. The bill would also require, in specified circumstances, the Chair of the Judicial Council to assign some other justice or justices to hear the matter as promptly as possible.
The bill would require the California Law Revision Commission to deliver, on or before September 30, 2027, a study regarding the recusal of judicial officers for prejudice and conflict of interest, as specified. The bill would require the California Law Revision Commission to consult with the Commission on Judicial Performance in developing the study. This bill would make these provisions inoperative on September 30, 2031, and would repeal it as of January 1, 2032.
Existing law authorizes a party or attorney in an action or proceeding to move to disqualify a judge, court commissioner, or referee for prejudice against a party or attorney or the interest of a party or attorney, as specified. Prejudice may be established by an oral or written motion without notice supported by affidavit or declaration under penalty of perjury, or an oral statement under oath, that the judge, court commissioner, or referee is prejudiced against a party or attorney, or the interest of the party or attorney, so that the party or attorney cannot, or believes that they cannot, have a fair and impartial trial or hearing. Existing law requires, in specified circumstances, the Chair of the Judicial Council to assign some other judge, court commissioner, or referee to try the cause or hear the matter as promptly as possible. Existing law specifies that these provisions do not apply to a judge designated or assigned to serve on the appellate division of a superior court in the judges capacity as a judge in that division.
This bill would repeal that exclusion and would extend these provisions to authorize a party or attorney to disqualify a justice or justices of an appellate court for prejudice against a party or attorney, or the interest of a party or attorney, as specified. The bill would authorize the motion directed to one or more justices of a court of appeal to only be made following reversal by the California Supreme Court of a court of appeals decision, and may only be directed to the justice or justices who authored or concurred in the prior decision and who is or are assigned to further consider the matter. The bill would authorize the party who obtained the reversal of a decision of a court of appeal to make that motion regardless of whether that party or side has previously done so. The bill would require, for cases reversed on or after January 1, 2025, the motion to be made within 30 days after the party or the partys attorney has been notified of the assignment. The bill would require, for cases reversed before January 1, 2025, and remaining pending as of the effective date of this act, the motion to be made on or before January 31, 2025. The bill would require, if the motion is duly presented and the affidavit or declaration under penalty of perjury is duly filed or an oral statement under oath is duly made, that the presiding justice assign other justice or justices or transfer the case to another panel of justices. The bill would also require, in specified circumstances, the Chair of the Judicial Council to assign some other justice or justices to hear the matter as promptly as possible.
Existing law vests the State Air Resources Board with regulatory jurisdiction over matters related to air pollution and emissions of greenhouse gases. Existing law requires the state board to convene various advisory committees to provide advice to the state board in the exercise of its regulatory jurisdiction.This bill would require the state board to convene a youth advisory council consisting of 35 members between 16 and 21 years of age with, to the extent feasible, at least one member representing each air quality management district and air pollution control district. The bill would require the council to advise the state board on air pollution issues that impact youth throughout the state and authorize the council to take certain actions.Existing law vests the State Air Resources Board with regulatory jurisdiction over matters related to air pollution and emissions of greenhouse gases. Existing law requires the state board to convene various advisory committees to provide advice to the state board in the exercise of its regulatory jurisdiction.
This bill would require the state board to convene a youth advisory council consisting of 35 members between 16 and 21 years of age with, to the extent feasible, at least one member representing each air quality management district and air pollution control district. The bill would require the council to advise the state board on air pollution issues that impact youth throughout the state and authorize the council to take certain actions.
Existing law establishes the Clean Cars 4 All Program, which is administered by the State Air Resources Board, to focus on achieving reductions in the emissions of greenhouse gases, improvements in air quality, and benefits to low-income state residents through the replacement of high-polluter motor vehicles with cleaner and more efficient motor vehicles or a mobility option. Existing law requires the state board to set goals for the replacement of trucks and passenger vehicles that are high polluters.This bill would make nonsubstantive changes to this provision.Existing law establishes the Clean Cars 4 All Program, which is administered by the State Air Resources Board, to focus on achieving reductions in the emissions of greenhouse gases, improvements in air quality, and benefits to low-income state residents through the replacement of high-polluter motor vehicles with cleaner and more efficient motor vehicles or a mobility option. Existing law requires the state board to set goals for the replacement of trucks and passenger vehicles that are high polluters.
This bill would make nonsubstantive changes to this provision.
(a)On or before September 30, 2027, the California Law Revision Commission shall deliver to the Legislature a study regarding recusal of judicial officers for prejudice and conflict of interest.
(b)In developing the study required by this section, the California Law Revision Commission shall consult with the Commission on Judicial Performance.
(c)The study shall, at minimum, include a discussion of the following:
(1)The effectiveness of Section 170.6 and other existing mechanisms in eliminating bias in judicial proceedings.
(2)The prevalence of judicial officers hearing matters in which the canons of judicial ethics should have warranted a recusal.
(3)The impact on case hearing times of judicial recusals.
(4)The costs to the courts and to litigants of judicial recusals.
(d)A report submitted pursuant to subdivision (a) shall be submitted in compliance with Section 9795 of the Government Code.
(e)Pursuant to Section 10231.5 of the Government Code, this section shall become inoperative on September 30, 2031, and, as of January 1, 2032, is repealed.
SEC. 4.Section 170.7 of the Code of Civil Procedure is repealed.SEC. 5.Section 170.7 is added to the Code of Civil Procedure, to read:170.7.(a)Section 170.6 does not apply to a judge designated or assigned to serve on the appellate division of a superior court in the judges capacity as a judge of that division.(b)This section shall become operative January 1, 2031.(a)(1)A judge, court commissioner, or referee of a superior court of the State of California, or justice of a court of appeal of the State of California, shall not try a civil or criminal action or special proceeding of any kind or character nor hear any matter therein that involves a contested issue of law or fact when it is established as provided in this section that the judge, justice, or court commissioner is prejudiced against a party or attorney or the interest of a party or attorney appearing in the action or proceeding.
(2)A party to, or an attorney appearing in, an action or proceeding may establish this prejudice by an oral or written motion without prior notice supported by affidavit or declaration under penalty of perjury, or an oral statement under oath, that the judge, justice, court commissioner, or referee before whom the action or proceeding is pending, or to whom it is assigned, is prejudiced against a party or attorney, or the interest of the party or attorney, so that the party or attorney cannot, or believes that they cannot, have a fair and impartial trial or hearing before the judge, justice, court commissioner, or referee.
(A)If the judge, other than a judge assigned to the case for all purposes, court commissioner, or referee assigned to, or who is scheduled to try, the cause or hear the matter is known at least 10 days before the date set for trial or hearing, the motion shall be made at least 5 days before that date. If directed to the trial of a cause with a master calendar, the motion shall be made to the judge supervising the master calendar not later than the time the cause is assigned for trial. If directed to the trial of a criminal cause that has been assigned to a judge for all purposes, the motion shall be made to the assigned judge or to the presiding judge by a party within 10 days after notice of the all purpose assignment, or if the party has not yet appeared in the action, then within 10 days after the appearance. If directed to the trial of a civil cause that has been assigned to a judge for all purposes, the motion shall be made to the assigned judge or to the presiding judge by a party within 15 days after notice of the all purpose assignment, or if the party has not yet appeared in the action, then within 15 days after the appearance. If the court in which the action is pending is authorized to have no more than one judge, and the motion claims that the duly elected or appointed judge of that court is prejudiced, the motion shall be made before the expiration of 30 days from the date of the first appearance in the action of the party who is making the motion or whose attorney is making the motion. In no event shall a judge, court commissioner, or referee entertain the motion if it is made after the drawing of the name of the first juror, or if there is no jury, after the making of an opening statement by counsel for plaintiff, or if there is no opening statement by counsel for plaintiff, then after swearing in the first witness or the giving of any evidence or after trial of the cause has otherwise commenced. If the motion is directed to a hearing, other than the trial of a cause, the motion shall be made not later than the commencement of the hearing. In the case of trials or hearings not specifically provided for in this paragraph, the procedure specified herein shall be followed as nearly as possible. The fact that a judge, court commissioner, or referee has presided at, or acted in connection with, a pretrial conference or other hearing, proceeding, or motion prior to trial, and not involving a determination of contested fact issues relating to the merits, shall not preclude the later making of the motion provided for in this paragraph at the time and in the manner herein provided.
A motion under this paragraph directed to a judge, court commissioner, or referee of a superior court may be made following reversal on appeal of a trial courts decision, or following reversal on appeal of a trial courts final judgment, if the trial judge in the prior proceeding is assigned to conduct a new trial on the matter. Notwithstanding paragraph (4), the party who filed the appeal that resulted in the reversal of a final judgment of a trial court may make a motion under this section regardless of whether that party or side has previously done so. The motion shall be made within 60 days after the party or the partys attorney has been notified of the assignment.
(B)A motion under this paragraph directed to one or more justices of a court of appeal may only be made following reversal by the California Supreme Court of a court of appeals decision, and may only be directed to the justice or justices who authored or concurred in the prior decision and is or are assigned to further consider the matter. Notwithstanding paragraph (4), the party who obtained the reversal of a decision of a court of appeal may make a motion under this section regardless of whether that party or side has previously done so. For cases reversed on or after January 1, 2025, the motion shall be made within 30 days after the party or the partys attorney has been notified of the assignment. For cases reversed before January 1, 2025, and remaining pending as of the effective date of the act adding this subparagraph, the motion shall be made on or before January 31, 2025.
(3)A party to a civil action making that motion under this section shall serve notice on all parties no later than five days after making the motion.
(4)If the motion is duly presented, and the affidavit or declaration under penalty of perjury is duly filed or an oral statement under oath is duly made, thereupon and without any further act or proof, the judge supervising the master calendar, if any, or presiding justice shall assign some other judge, justice or justices, court commissioner, or referee to try the cause or hear the matter. In other cases, the trial of the cause or the hearing of the matter shall be assigned or transferred to another judge, panel of justices, court commissioner, or referee of the court in which the trial or matter is pending or, if there is no other judge, panel of justices, court commissioner, or referee of the court in which the trial or matter is pending, the Chair of the Judicial Council shall assign some other judge, justice or justices, court commissioner, or referee to try the cause or hear the matter as promptly as possible. Except as provided in this section, no party or attorney shall be permitted to make more than one such motion in any one action or special proceeding pursuant to this section. In actions or special proceedings where there may be more than one plaintiff or similar party or more than one defendant or similar party appearing in the action or special proceeding, only one motion for each side may be made in any one action or special proceeding.
(5)Unless required for the convenience of the court or unless good cause is shown, a continuance of the trial or hearing shall not be granted by reason of the making of a motion under this section. If a continuance is granted, the cause or matter shall be continued from day to day or for other limited periods upon the trial or other calendar and shall be reassigned or transferred for trial or hearing as promptly as possible.
(6)Any affidavit filed pursuant to this section shall be in substantially the following form:
(Here set forth court and cause) | |||
State of California, | ss. | PEREMPTORY CHALLENGE | |
| County of | |||
| ____, being duly sworn, deposes and says: That they are a party (or attorney for a party) to the within action (or special proceeding). That ____ the judge, justice, court commissioner, or referee before whom the trial of the (or a hearing in the) action (or special proceeding) is pending (or to whom it is assigned) is prejudiced against the party (or their attorney) or the interest of the party (or their attorney) so that affiant cannot or believes that they cannot have a fair and impartial trial or hearing before the judge, justice, court commissioner, or referee. | ||
Subscribed and sworn to before me this | ||
______ day of ______, 20__. | ||
(Clerk or notary public or other | ||
officer administering oath) |
(7)Any oral statement under oath or declaration under penalty of perjury made pursuant to this section shall include substantially the same contents as the affidavit above.
(b)Nothing in this section shall affect or limit Section 170 or Title 4 (commencing with Section 392) of Part 2, and this section shall be construed as cumulative thereto.
(c)If any provision of this section or the application to any person or circumstance is held invalid, that invalidity shall not affect other provisions or applications of the section that can be given effect without the invalid provision or application and, to this end, the provisions of this section are declared to be severable.
(d)This section shall remain in effect only until January 1, 2031, and as of that date is repealed.
SEC. 2.Section 170.6 is added to the Code of Civil Procedure, to read:170.6.(a)(1)A judge, court commissioner, or referee of a superior court of the State of California shall not try a civil or criminal action or special proceeding of any kind or character nor hear any matter therein that involves a contested issue of law or fact when it is established as provided in this section that the judge or court commissioner is prejudiced against a party or attorney or the interest of a party or attorney appearing in the action or proceeding.
(2)A party to, or an attorney appearing in, an action or proceeding may establish this prejudice by an oral or written motion without prior notice supported by affidavit or declaration under penalty of perjury, or an oral statement under oath, that the judge, court commissioner, or referee before whom the action or proceeding is pending, or to whom it is assigned, is prejudiced against a party or attorney, or the interest of the party or attorney, so that the party or attorney cannot, or believes that they cannot, have a fair and impartial trial or hearing before the judge, court commissioner, or referee. If the judge, other than a judge assigned to the case for all purposes, court commissioner, or referee assigned to, or who is scheduled to try, the cause or hear the matter is known at least 10 days before the date set for trial or hearing, the motion shall be made at least 5 days before that date. If directed to the trial of a cause with a master calendar, the motion shall be made to the judge supervising the master calendar not later than the time the cause is assigned for trial. If directed to the trial of a criminal cause that has been assigned to a judge for all purposes, the motion shall be made to the assigned judge or to the presiding judge by a party within 10 days after notice of the all purpose assignment, or if the party has not yet appeared in the action, then within 10 days after the appearance. If directed to the trial of a civil cause that has been assigned to a judge for all purposes, the motion shall be made to the assigned judge or to the presiding judge by a party within 15 days after notice of the all purpose assignment, or if the party has not yet appeared in the action, then within 15 days after the appearance. If the court in which the action is pending is authorized to have no more than one judge, and the motion claims that the duly elected or appointed judge of that court is prejudiced, the motion shall be made before the expiration of 30 days from the date of the first appearance in the action of the party who is making the motion or whose attorney is making the motion. In no event shall a judge, court commissioner, or referee entertain the motion if it is made after the drawing of the name of the first juror, or if there is no jury, after the making of an opening statement by counsel for plaintiff, or if there is no opening statement by counsel for plaintiff, then after swearing in the first witness or the giving of any evidence or after trial of the cause has otherwise commenced. If the motion is directed to a hearing, other than the trial of a cause, the motion shall be made not later than the commencement of the hearing. In the case of trials or hearings not specifically provided for in this paragraph, the procedure specified herein shall be followed as nearly as possible. The fact that a judge, court commissioner, or referee has presided at, or acted in connection with, a pretrial conference or other hearing, proceeding, or motion prior to trial, and not involving a determination of contested fact issues relating to the merits, shall not preclude the later making of the motion provided for in this paragraph at the time and in the manner herein provided.
A motion under this paragraph may be made following reversal on appeal of a trial courts decision, or following reversal on appeal of a trial courts final judgment, if the trial judge in the prior proceeding is assigned to conduct a new trial on the matter. Notwithstanding paragraph (4), the party who filed the appeal that resulted in the reversal of a final judgment of a trial court may make a motion under this section regardless of whether that party or side has previously done so. The motion shall be made within 60 days after the party or the partys attorney has been notified of the assignment.
(3)A party to a civil action making that motion under this section shall serve notice on all parties no later than five days after making the motion.
(4)If the motion is duly presented, and the affidavit or declaration under penalty of perjury is duly filed or an oral statement under oath is duly made, thereupon and without any further act or proof, the judge supervising the master calendar, if any, shall assign some other judge, court commissioner, or referee to try the cause or hear the matter. In other cases, the trial of the cause or the hearing of the matter shall be assigned or transferred to another judge, court commissioner, or referee of the court in which the trial or matter is pending or, if there is no other judge, court commissioner, or referee of the court in which the trial or matter is pending, the Chair of the Judicial Council shall assign some other judge, court commissioner, or referee to try the cause or hear the matter as promptly as possible. Except as provided in this section, no party or attorney shall be permitted to make more than one such motion in any one action or special proceeding pursuant to this section. In actions or special proceedings where there may be more than one plaintiff or similar party or more than one defendant or similar party appearing in the action or special proceeding, only one motion for each side may be made in any one action or special proceeding.
(5)Unless required for the convenience of the court or unless good cause is shown, a continuance of the trial or hearing shall not be granted by reason of the making of a motion under this section. If a continuance is granted, the cause or matter shall be continued from day to day or for other limited periods upon the trial or other calendar and shall be reassigned or transferred for trial or hearing as promptly as possible.
(6)Any affidavit filed pursuant to this section shall be in substantially the following form:
(Here set forth court and cause) | |||
State of California, | ss. | PEREMPTORY CHALLENGE | |
| County of | |||
| ____, being duly sworn, deposes and says: That they are a party (or attorney for a party) to the within action (or special proceeding). That ____ the judge, court commissioner, or referee before whom the trial of the (or a hearing in the) action (or special proceeding) is pending (or to whom it is assigned) is prejudiced against the party (or their attorney) or the interest of the party (or their attorney) so that affiant cannot or believes that they cannot have a fair and impartial trial or hearing before the judge, court commissioner, or referee. | ||
Subscribed and sworn to before me this | ||
______ day of ______, 20__. | ||
(Clerk or notary public or other | ||
officer administering oath) |
(7)Any oral statement under oath or declaration under penalty of perjury made pursuant to this section shall include substantially the same contents as the affidavit above.
(b)Nothing in this section shall affect or limit Section 170 or Title 4 (commencing with Section 392) of Part 2, and this section shall be construed as cumulative thereto.
(c)If any provision of this section or the application to any person or circumstance is held invalid, that invalidity shall not affect other provisions or applications of the section that can be given effect without the invalid provision or application and, to this end, the provisions of this section are declared to be severable.
(d)This section shall become operative January 1, 2031.
SEC. 3.Section 170.6.1 is added to the Code of Civil Procedure, to read:170.6.1.(a)On or before September 30, 2027, the California Law Revision Commission shall deliver to the Legislature a study regarding recusal of judicial officers for prejudice and conflict of interest.
(b)In developing the study required by this section, the California Law Revision Commission shall consult with the Commission on Judicial Performance.
(c)The study shall, at minimum, include a discussion of the following:
(1)The effectiveness of Section 170.6 in eliminating bias in judicial proceedings.
(2)The prevalence of judicial officers hearing matters in which the canons of judicial ethics should have warranted a recusal.
(3)The impact on case hearing times of judicial recusals.
(4)The costs to the courts and to litigants of judicial recusals.
(d)A report submitted pursuant to subdivision (a) shall be submitted in compliance with Section 9795 of the Government Code.
(e)Pursuant to Section 10231.5 of the Government Code, this section shall become inoperative on September 30, 2031, and, as of January 1, 2032, is repealed.
SEC. 2.SEC. 4.Section 170.7 of the Code of Civil Procedure is repealed.SEC. 5.Section 170.7 is added to the Code of Civil Procedure, to read:170.7.(a)Section 170.6 does not apply to a judge designated or assigned to serve on the appellate division of a superior court in the judges capacity as a judge of that division.
(b)This section shall become operative January 1, 2031.
(a)(1)A judge, court commissioner, or referee of a superior court of the State of California California, or justice of a court of appeal of the State of California, shall not try a civil or criminal action or special proceeding of any kind or character nor hear any matter therein that involves a contested issue of law or fact when it is established as provided in this section that the judge judge, justice, or court commissioner is prejudiced against a party or attorney or the interest of a party or attorney appearing in the action or proceeding.
(2)A party to, or an attorney appearing in, an action or proceeding may establish this prejudice by an oral or written motion without prior notice supported by affidavit or declaration under penalty of perjury, or an oral statement under oath, that the judge, justice, court commissioner, or referee before whom the action or proceeding is pending, or to whom it is assigned, is prejudiced against a party or attorney, or the interest of the party or attorney, so that the party or attorney cannot, or believes that he or she they cannot, have a fair and impartial trial or hearing before the judge, justice, court commissioner, or referee. If
(A)If the judge, other than a judge assigned to the case for all purposes, court commissioner, or referee assigned to, or who is scheduled to try, the cause or hear the matter is known at least 10 days before the date set for trial or hearing, the motion shall be made at least 5 days before that date. If directed to the trial of a cause with a master calendar, the motion shall be made to the judge supervising the master calendar not later than the time the cause is assigned for trial. If directed to the trial of a criminal cause that has been assigned to a judge for all purposes, the motion shall be made to the assigned judge or to the presiding judge by a party within 10 days after notice of the all purpose assignment, or if the party has not yet appeared in the action, then within 10 days after the appearance. If directed to the trial of a civil cause that has been assigned to a judge for all purposes, the motion shall be made to the assigned judge or to the presiding judge by a party within 15 days after notice of the all purpose assignment, or if the party has not yet appeared in the action, then within 15 days after the appearance. If the court in which the action is pending is authorized to have no more than one judge, and the motion claims that the duly elected or appointed judge of that court is prejudiced, the motion shall be made before the expiration of 30 days from the date of the first appearance in the action of the party who is making the motion or whose attorney is making the motion. In no event shall a judge, court commissioner, or referee entertain the motion if it is made after the drawing of the name of the first juror, or if there is no jury, after the making of an opening statement by counsel for plaintiff, or if there is no opening statement by counsel for plaintiff, then after swearing in the first witness or the giving of any evidence or after trial of the cause has otherwise commenced. If the motion is directed to a hearing, other than the trial of a cause, the motion shall be made not later than the commencement of the hearing. In the case of trials or hearings not specifically provided for in this paragraph, the procedure specified herein shall be followed as nearly as possible. The fact that a judge, court commissioner, or referee has presided at, or acted in connection with, a pretrial conference or other hearing, proceeding, or motion prior to trial, and not involving a determination of contested fact issues relating to the merits, shall not preclude the later making of the motion provided for in this paragraph at the time and in the manner herein provided.
A motion under this paragraph directed to a judge, court commissioner, or referee of a superior court may be made following reversal on appeal of a trial courts decision, or following reversal on appeal of a trial courts final judgment, if the trial judge in the prior proceeding is assigned to conduct a new trial on the matter. Notwithstanding paragraph (4), the party who filed the appeal that resulted in the reversal of a final judgment of a trial court may make a motion under this section regardless of whether that party or side has previously done so. The motion shall be made within 60 days after the party or the partys attorney has been notified of the assignment.
(B)A motion under this paragraph directed to one or more justices of a court of appeal may only be made following reversal by the California Supreme Court of a court of appeals decision, and may only be directed to the justice or justices who authored or concurred in the prior decision and is or are assigned to further consider the matter. Notwithstanding paragraph (4), the party who obtained the reversal of a decision of a court of appeal may make a motion under this section regardless of whether that party or side has previously done so. For cases reversed on or after January 1, 2025, the motion shall be made within 30 days after the party or the partys attorney has been notified of the assignment. For cases reversed before January 1, 2025, and remaining pending as of the effective date of the act adding this subparagraph, the motion shall be made on or before January 31, 2025.
(3)A party to a civil action making that motion under this section shall serve notice on all parties no later than five days after making the motion.
(4)If the motion is duly presented, and the affidavit or declaration under penalty of perjury is duly filed or an oral statement under oath is duly made, thereupon and without any further act or proof, the judge supervising the master calendar, if any, or presiding justice shall assign some other judge, justice or justices, court commissioner, or referee to try the cause or hear the matter. In other cases, the trial of the cause or the hearing of the matter shall be assigned or transferred to another judge, panel of justices, court commissioner, or referee of the court in which the trial or matter is pending or, if there is no other judge, panel of justices, court commissioner, or referee of the court in which the trial or matter is pending, the Chair of the Judicial Council shall assign some other judge, justice or justices, court commissioner, or referee to try the cause or hear the matter as promptly as possible. Except as provided in this section, no party or attorney shall be permitted to make more than one such motion in any one action or special proceeding pursuant to this section. In actions or special proceedings where there may be more than one plaintiff or similar party or more than one defendant or similar party appearing in the action or special proceeding, only one motion for each side may be made in any one action or special proceeding.
(5)Unless required for the convenience of the court or unless good cause is shown, a continuance of the trial or hearing shall not be granted by reason of the making of a motion under this section. If a continuance is granted, the cause or matter shall be continued from day to day or for other limited periods upon the trial or other calendar and shall be reassigned or transferred for trial or hearing as promptly as possible.
(6)Any affidavit filed pursuant to this section shall be in substantially the following form:
(Here set forth court and cause) | |||
State of California, | ss. | PEREMPTORY CHALLENGE | |
| County of | |||
| ____, being duly sworn,
deposes and says: That he or she is
they are a party (or attorney for a party) to the within action (or special proceeding). That ____ the judge, justice, court commissioner, or referee before whom the trial of the (or a hearing in the) action (or special proceeding) is pending (or to whom it is assigned) is prejudiced against the party (or his or her their attorney) or the interest of the party (or his or her their attorney) so that affiant cannot or believes that he or she they cannot have a fair and impartial trial or hearing before the judge, justice, court commissioner, or referee. | ||
Subscribed and sworn to before me this | ||
______ day of ______, 20__. | ||
(Clerk or notary public or other | ||
officer administering oath) |
(7)Any oral statement under oath or declaration under penalty of perjury made pursuant to this section shall include substantially the same contents as the affidavit above.
(b)Nothing in this section shall affect or limit Section 170 or Title 4 (commencing with Section 392) of Part 2, and this section shall be construed as cumulative thereto.
(c)If any provision of this section or the application to any person or circumstance is held invalid, that invalidity shall not affect other provisions or applications of the section that can be given effect without the invalid provision or application and, to this end, the provisions of this section are declared to be severable.
SEC. 2.Section 170.7 of the Code of Civil Procedure is repealed.170.7.Section 170.6 does not apply to a judge designated or assigned to serve on the appellate division of a superior court in the judges capacity as a judge of that division. All matter omitted in this version of the bill appears in the bill as amended in the Assembly, February 26, 2024. (JR11)(a)(1)The state board shall convene a youth advisory council consisting of 35 members with, to the extent feasible, at least one member representing each district.
(2)The members of the council shall be between 16 and 21 years of age.
(3)The state board shall conduct public outreach to encourage the submission of membership applications and shall make additional outreach efforts in communities that are disproportionately impacted by pollution in each district.
(4)The state board shall select members of the council with preference given to applicants from communities that are disproportionately impacted by pollution burdens.
(b)The youth advisory council shall advise the state board on air pollution issues that impact youth throughout the state and may do any of the following:
(1)Research, assessment, and evaluation of youth and community programs related to air pollution and environmental justice issues.
(2)Hold open panel discussions with the state board.
(3)Inform the public and nonprofit entities about their work.
(4)Serve on speaker panels in which the state board is represented or hosted.
(c)The state board shall provide administrative support to the youth advisory council.
All matter omitted in this version of the bill appears in the bill as introduced in the Assembly February 6, 2024. (JR11)(a)The Clean Cars 4 All Program is hereby established and is to be administered by the state board to focus on achieving reductions in the emissions of greenhouse gases, improvements in air quality, and benefits to low-income state residents through the replacement of high-polluter motor vehicles with cleaner and more efficient motor vehicles or a mobility option.
(b)Beginning in the 201819 fiscal year, and every fiscal year thereafter, the state board shall set specific, measurable goals for the replacement of passenger vehicles and light- and medium-duty trucks and passenger vehicles that are high polluters.
(c)The state board shall take steps to meet the goals set forth pursuant to subdivision (b). The steps shall include, but need not be limited to, updating the guidelines for Clean Cars 4 All no later than January 1, 2019.
(d)The regulation implementing this section shall ensure all of the following:
(1)Where applicable, there is improved coordination, integration, and partnerships with other programs that target disadvantaged communities and receive moneys from the Greenhouse Gas Reduction Fund, created pursuant to Section 16428.8 of the Government Code.
(2)The state board shall coordinate with districts and local nonprofit and community organizations, prioritizing those organizations that have a strong and ongoing local presence in areas within the district, to identify barriers to accessing Clean Cars 4 All and to develop outreach protocols and metrics to assess the success of outreach across the districts.
(3)The replacement or a mobility option is consistent with paragraph (6) of subdivision (d) of Section 44125.
(4)Provisions enhance the prescreening of applicants to Clean Cars 4 All, if determined by the state board to be appropriate.
(5)By January 1, 2025, all hybrid vehicles purchased using an incentive are capable of plug-in charging.
(e)The state board shall ensure that incentives awarded under the Clean Cars 4 All Program are awarded in accordance with Section 44258.7.
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Aug 15, 2024 | In committee: Held under submission. |
| Aug 5, 2024 | In committee: Referred to APPR suspense file. |
| Jun 26, 2024 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 11. Noes 0.) (June 25). Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Jun 5, 2024 | Referred to Com. on JUD. |
| May 23, 2024 | In Senate. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. |
| May 22, 2024 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Senate. (Ayes 66. Noes 0. Page 5566.) |
| May 20, 2024 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| May 16, 2024 | Read second time and amended. Ordered returned to second reading. |
| May 16, 2024 | From committee: Amend, and do pass as amended. (Ayes 11. Noes 3.) (May 16). |
| May 16, 2024 | Assembly Rule 63 suspended. |
| May 1, 2024 | In committee: Set, first hearing. Referred to APPR. suspense file. |
| Apr 11, 2024 | Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Apr 10, 2024 | Read second time and amended. |
| Apr 9, 2024 | From committee: Amend, and do pass as amended and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 9. Noes 2.) (April 9). |
| Mar 27, 2024 | In committee: Hearing postponed by committee. |
| Mar 14, 2024 | Re-referred to Com. on JUD. pursuant to Assembly Rule 96. |
| Mar 7, 2024 | Re-referred to Com. on NAT. RES. |
| Mar 6, 2024 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to Com. on NAT. RES. Read second time and amended. |
| Feb 27, 2024 | Re-referred to Com. on NAT. RES. |
| Feb 26, 2024 | Referred to Com. on NAT. RES. |
| Feb 26, 2024 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to Com. on NAT. RES. Read second time and amended. |
| Feb 7, 2024 | From printer. May be heard in committee March 8. |
| Feb 6, 2024 | Read first time. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Aug 5, 2024 | Placed on suspense file | Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Jun 25, 2024 | Do pass, but first be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Senate Standing Committee on Judiciary |
Passed |
|
| May 22, 2024 | AB 2125 Garcia Assembly Third Reading | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| May 16, 2024 | Do pass as amended. | Assembly Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Apr 9, 2024 | Do pass as amended and be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Assembly Standing Committee on Judiciary |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
|
Organization
|
Position
|
Date
|
|---|---|---|
| AB 2125 | * Support | Apr 9, 2024 |
| AB 2125 | * Support | Apr 9, 2024 |
| AB 2125 | * Against | Apr 9, 2024 |
| AB 2125 | * Against | Apr 9, 2024 |
| AB 2125 | * Support | Apr 9, 2024 |
| Asian Americans Advancing Justice - Asian Law Caucus | ** Support | |
| Asian Law Alliance | * Support | Jun 25, 2024 |
| California Judges Association | ** Against | |
| Central Valley Opportunity Center | * Support | Jun 25, 2024 |
| First Aid Foundation | * Support | Jun 25, 2024 |
| First Day Foundation | ** Support | |
| Inland Coalition for Immigrant Justice | * Support | Jun 25, 2024 |
| Judicial Council of California | ** Against | |
| La Cooperativa Campesina De California | * Support | Jun 25, 2024 |
| Lawyers' Committee for Civil Rights of the San Francisco Bay Area | ** Support | |
| Los Amigos de la Comunidad | * Support | Jun 25, 2024 |
| Proteus Inc. | ** Support | |
| William C. Velasquez Institute | ** Support | |
| William C. Velasquez Institute | * Support | Jun 25, 2024 |
SENATE COMMITTEE ON
Senator Anna Caballero, Chair
2023 - 2024 Regular Session
AB 2125 (Garcia) - Judicial officers: disqualification
Version: | Policy Vote: |
Urgency: | Mandate: |
Hearing Date: | Consultant: |
Bill Summary:
AB 2125 would require the California Law Review Commission (CLRC) to conduct a study for the Legislature about recusal of judicial officers for prejudice and conflict of interest.
Fiscal Impact:
Onetime costs (General Fund) to CLRC in the hundreds of thousands of dollars for additional staffing. CLRC reports it will need to hire a consultant to gather the data needed to complete the required study, which it estimates to range from $319,550-$473,550.
Background:
Existing law and judicial procedures generally require a superior court judge, appellate justice, or Supreme Court justice (“judicial officers”) to voluntarily remove themselves from presiding over a case if the judicial officer has a conflict of interest or bias relating to the case. Outside of voluntary recusal, the Code of Civil Procedure also allows a litigant to make a motion seeking removal of a superior court judge for potential bias. The law allows a litigant to make such a motion before the judge hears the matter or after the judge is reversed on appeal and the case is remanded back to the same judge for further action.
CLRC is responsible for studying California’s statutory and decisional law, identifying defects an anachronisms in the law, and making recommendations on how to remedy issues identified. Under CLRC’s enabling statute, a topic for study may originate from CLRC itself or may be assigned to CLRC by the Legislature.
Proposed Law:
This bill requires, on or before September 30, 2027, CLRC to complete a study for the Legislature on judicial disqualification. The study must cover the effectiveness of current removal procedures in eliminating bias, the prevalence of judicial officers hearing matters where recusal was warranted, the impact of judicial recusals on case hearing times, and the costs to the court and litigants of judicial recusals. In developing the study required by this section, the CLRC shall consult with the Commission on Judicial Performance.
-- END --
Senator Thomas Umberg, Chair
2023-2024 Regular Session
Bill No: AB 2125 (Author:Garcia)
Version: May 16, 2024
Hearing Date: June 25, 2024
Fiscal: Yes
Urgency: No
Consultant: ME
SUBJECT
Judicial officers: disqualification
DIGEST
This bill requires that on or before September 30, 2027, the California Law Revision Commission (CLRC) shall deliver to the Legislature, as specified, a study regarding recusal of judicial officers for prejudice and conflict of interest. The bill requires that the CLRC consult with the Commission on Judicial Performance in developing the study and that the study include a discussion of specified issues.
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
The California Law Revision Commission (CLRC) was created in 1953 and tasked with the responsibility for a continuing substantive review of California statutory and decisional law. The CLRC studies the law in order to discover defects and make related recommendations to the Legislature for needed reforms.
The CLRC’s enabling statute recognizes two types of topics the CLRC is authorized to study: (1) those that the CLRC identifies for study and lists in the Calendar of Topics that it reports to the Legislature; and (2) those that the Legislature assigns to the CLRC directly, by statute or concurrent resolution. Once the CLRC identifies a topic for study, it cannot begin to work on the topic until the Legislature, by concurrent resolution, authorizes the CLRC to conduct the study. Direct legislative assignments have become much more common in recent years, and many of the CLRC’s recent studies were directly assigned by the Legislature.
The CLRC is governed by Government Code Section 8293 which sets out the broad list of topics it is authorized to study. This authorization must be renewed in a concurrent resolution at least once per two-year legislative session. The most recent reauthorization was through ACR 24 (Chau, 2021). ACR 169 (Kalra, 2024) reauthorizes the CLRC to study the 14 topics that were authorized by ACR 24. ACR 169 is currently pending in the Senate Judiciary Committee.
AB 2125 adds a topic for the CLRC to study. Specifically, this bill requires that on or before September 30, 2027, the CLRC shall deliver to the Legislature a study regarding recusal of judicial officers for prejudice and conflict of interest. The bill requires that the CLRC consult with the Commission on Judicial Performance in developing the study.
This bill is sponsored by the Asian Law Alliance and the William C. Velasquez Institute, and is supported by a coalition of legal aid organizations and advocates for the rights of immigrants. The bill is opposed by the California Academy of Appellate Lawyers and the California Judges Association, who had issues with a prior version of the bill.
PROPOSED CHANGES TO THE LAW
Existing law:
- Provides that every judge has a duty to decide any proceeding in which they are not disqualified. (Code Civ. Proc. § 170.)
- Requires a judge to be disqualified if any of the following are true:
- the judge has personal knowledge of disputed evidentiary facts concerning the proceeding, as specified;
- the judge served as a lawyer in the proceeding, or in any other proceeding involving the same issues they served as a lawyer for a party in the present proceeding or gave advice to a party in the present proceeding upon a matter involved in the action or proceeding, as specified;
- the judge has a financial interest in the subject matter in a proceeding or in a party to the proceeding, as specified;
- the judge, or the spouse of the judge, or a person within the third degree of relationship to either of them, or the spouse of such a person is a party to the proceeding or an officer, director, or trustee of a party;
- a lawyer or a spouse of a lawyer in the proceeding is the spouse, former spouse, child, sibling, or parent of the judge or the judge’s spouse or if such a person is associated in the private practice of law with a lawyer in the proceeding;
- by reason of permanent or temporary physical impairment, the judge is unable to properly perceive the evidence or is unable to properly conduct the proceeding;
- the judge has a current arrangement concerning prospective employment or other compensated service as a dispute resolution neutral or is participating in, or, within the last two years has participated in, discussions regarding prospective employment or service as a dispute resolution neutral, or has been engaged in that employment or service, as specified;
- the judge has received a contribution in excess of one thousand five hundred dollars ($1500) from a party or lawyer in the proceeding, as specified; or
- the judge believes their recusal would further the interests of justice, the judge believes there is a substantial doubt as to their capacity to be impartial, or the judge believes a person aware of the facts might reasonably entertain a doubt that the judge would be able to be impartial. (Code Civ. Proc. § 170.1 (a).)
- Requires a judge who determines themselves to be disqualified to notify the presiding judge of the court of their recusal and not further participate in the proceeding, except as provided, unless their disqualification is waived by the parties, as specified. (Code Civ. Proc. § 170.3 (a).)
- Provides that if a judge who should disqualify themselves refuses or fails to do so, any party may file with the clerk a written verified statement objecting to the hearing or trial before the judge and setting forth the facts constituting the grounds for disqualification of the judge at the earliest practicable opportunity after discovery of the facts constituting the ground for disqualification. (Code Civ. Proc. § 170.3 (c)(1).)
- Prohibits a judge, court commissioner, or referee of a superior court of the State of California from trying a civil or criminal action or special proceeding of any kind or character or hear any matter therein that involves a contested issue of law or fact when it is established that the judge or court commissioner is prejudiced against a party or attorney or the interest of a party or attorney appearing in the action or proceeding. (Code Civ. Proc. § 170.6 (a)(1).)
- Provides that a party to, or an attorney appearing in, an action or proceeding may establish the prejudice required by 5) by an oral or written motion without prior notice supported by affidavit or declaration under penalty of perjury, or an oral statement under oath, that the judge, court commissioner, or referee before whom the action or proceeding is pending, or to whom it is assigned, is prejudiced against a party or attorney, or the interest of the party or attorney, so that the party or attorney cannot, or believes that they cannot, have a fair and impartial trial or hearing before the judge, court commissioner, or referee. (Code Civ. Proc. § 170.6 (a)(2).)
- Provides that if the motion prepared pursuant to 6) is duly presented, and the affidavit or declaration under penalty of perjury is duly filed or an oral statement under oath is duly made, thereupon and without any further act or proof, the judge supervising the master calendar, if any, must assign some other judge, court commissioner, or referee to try the cause or hear the matter, and in other cases, the trial of the cause or the hearing of the matter must be assigned or transferred to another judge, court commissioner, or referee of the court in which the trial or matter is pending or, if there is no other judge, court commissioner, or referee of the court in which the trial or matter is pending, the Chair of the Judicial Council must assign some other judge, court commissioner, or referee to try the cause or hear the matter as promptly as possible. (Code Civ. Proc. § 170.6 (a)(4).)
- Provides that the provisions of 5) through 7) do not apply to a judge designated or assigned to serve on the appellate division of a superior court in the judge’s capacity as a judge of that division. (Code Civ. Proc. § 170.7.)
- Provides that: the CLRC shall file a report at each regular session of the Legislature that shall contain a calendar of topics selected by it for study, including a list of the studies in progress and a list of topics intended for future consideration; the CLRC shall confine its studies to those topics set forth in the calendar contained in its last preceding report that have been or are thereafter approved for its study by concurrent resolution of the Legislature; and that the CLRC shall also study any topic that the Legislature, by concurrent resolution or statute, refers to it for study. (Gov. Code § 8293 (a).)
This bill:
- Requires that on or before September 30, 2027, the CLRC shall deliver to the Legislature, as specified, a study regarding recusal of judicial officers for prejudice and conflict of interest.
- Provides that in developing the study the CLRC shall consult with the Commission on Judicial Performance.
- Requires that the study include, at minimum, a discussion of the following:
- the effectiveness of Section 170.6 and other existing mechanisms in eliminating bias in judicial proceedings;
- the prevalence of judicial officers hearing matters in which the canons of judicial ethics should have warranted a recusal;
- the impact on case hearing times of judicial recusals; and
- the costs to the courts and to litigants of judicial recusals.
- Provides that the provisions of this bill shall become inoperative on September 30, 2031, and, as of January 1, 2032, are repealed.
COMMENTS
- Stated need for the bill
According to the author:
AB 2125 mandates a comprehensive study by the California Law Revision Commission, in collaboration with the Commission on Judicial Performance, to thoroughly examine the recusal practices of judicial officers. This study will assess the effectiveness of current mechanisms in eliminating bias, the prevalence of judges presiding over cases where ethical standards suggest they should have recused themselves, and the consequent impact on case hearing times and the costs incurred by both the courts and litigants. Public confidence in the judiciary is at an all-time low, and it is imperative that we take concrete actions to restore faith in our legal system. By investigating and addressing the roots of perceived and actual biases, this bill aims to ensure that all individuals receive fair and impartial treatment in our courts. The findings and recommendations of the study will guide future legislative and judicial reforms, helping to build a more transparent, accountable, and trustworthy judiciary. This bill not only addresses current concerns but also lays the groundwork for long-term improvements in the administration of justice in California.
2. CLRC would be required to study the issue of recusal of judicial officers for prejudice and conflict of interest
As explained in the Assembly Judiciary Committee analysis for this bill:
[ . . . ] Typically, the judicial branch of government had been held in higher esteem than more politicized branches of the government. However, likely as a result of a series of scandals and stories of questionable ethical activities at the United States Supreme Court, the public’s confidence in the judiciary has fallen. From Justice Clarence Thomas’s multiple indiscretions (questionable loans, free travel, and unreported gifts) to Justice Samuel Alito’s penchant for taking expensive fishing trips with corporate lobbyists, to Justice Sonya Sotomayor pressuring public institutions where the justice was speaking to buy copies of her book, the Supreme Court’s behavior has significantly harmed the public faith in the justice’s neutrality and ability to fairly render legal decisions. (Alison Durkee, Here Are All The Supreme Court Controversies That Led To Adopting An Ethics Code, Forbes (Nov. 14, 2023) available at: https://www.forbes.com/sites/alisondurkee/2023/11/14/here-are-all-the-supreme-court-controversies-that-led-to-adopting-an-ethics-code/?sh=136ad0ab64ca.)
Unfortunately, questionable decision making and eroding public trust is not limited to the federal judiciary. In 2017, following a scandal regarding the purchase of a $32,000 sofa for his chambers, the Chief Justice of the West Virginia Supreme Court was indicted on 22 felony charges. (Carol Funk, Public Confidence and the Courts: Pillars of the Rule of Law, ABA Magazine (Feb. 17, 2023).) In 2022, the Montana Legislature issued subpoenas to the judicial branch after allegations surfaced that court computers and other public resources had been used by judges to assist their trade association in mounting a challenge to a proposed statute. (Ibid.) As a result of these and similar scandals, a study by the National Judicial College noted that 63 percent of judges believed their esteem in the eyes of the public was falling. (Ibid.) Other public polling mimics these results. A 2023 study by the National Center for State Courts noted that only 61 percent of Americans surveyed had “confidence” in state courts. (https://www.ncsc.org/consulting-and-research/areas-of-expertise/court-leadership/state-of-the-state-courts.) Furthermore, the percentage of Americans stating that state courts do not provide equal justice to all increased by 7 percentage points over the last decade and the number of Americans who stated they have faith in the court’s ability to provide equal justice declined by nearly ten percent. (Ibid.)
Whether or not this data is fair to the majority of judges, in California and nationally, the above described data paints a troubling picture of the degradation of public faith in the judiciary. Given that the same survey by the National Center for State Courts noted that the public holds an equally skeptical views of state legislatures, any actions by this Committee that may be perceived as shielding judges from public scrutiny, including for potential conflicts or bias, must be carefully evaluated.
Accordingly, this bill requires that on or before September 30, 2027, the CLRC shall deliver to the Legislature a study regarding recusal of judicial officers for prejudice and conflict of interest and requires that the CLRC consult with the Commission on Judicial Performance in developing the study.
The Inland Coalition for Immigrant Justice writes the following in support of the bill:
[ . . . ] Judicial impartiality is a cornerstone of our legal system. When parties involved in legal actions believe that they cannot receive a fair and impartial hearing due to perceived prejudice or conflicts of interest from judicial officers, it undermines public trust in the judiciary. AB 2125 seeks to address these concerns in Superior Courts by commissioning comprehensive research and analysis on the current state of affairs in the Superior Courts. [ . . . ]
Opposition letters focus on provisions that were amended out of the bill in the Assembly.
SUPPORT
Asian Law Alliance (sponsor)
William C. Velasquez Institute (sponsor)
Central Valley Opportunity Center
First Day Foundation
Inland Coalition for Immigrant Justice
La Cooperativa Campesina de California
Lawyers’ Committee for Civil Rights of the San Francisco Bay Area
Proteus, Inc.
OPPOSITION
California Academy of Appellate Lawyers
California Judges Association
RELATED LEGISLATION
Pending Legislation:
AB 1906 (Gipson, 2024) requires the CLRC, with input from stakeholders, to complete and submit a study to the Legislature on how to remove the terms “dependent adult” and “dependent person” from existing code sections. The bill requires the CLRC to convene a working group that includes the protection and advocacy agency, persons described by those terms, and groups representing those persons. The bill requires the study to include recommendations on how to replace the terms with new terminology that would respectfully describe those persons and preserves the legal rights and protections of those and other persons. AB 1906 is currently in the Senate Appropriations Committee.
ACR 169 (Kalra, 2024) grants approval to the CLRC to continue its study of 14 designated topics that the Legislature previously authorized or directed the CLRC to study. The measure is currently in the Senate Appropriations Committee.
Prior Legislation:
ACR 24 (Chau, Res. Ch. 108, Stats. 2021) authorized the CLRC to continue its study of 13 topics and added an additional topic of study regarding states of disaster or emergencies.
ACR 173 (Gallagher, Res. Ch. 26, Stats. 2020) authorized the CLRC to continue its study of 13 topics.
SCR 91 (Roth, Res. Ch. 158, Stats. 2018) granted approval to the CLRC to continue its study of designated topics that the Legislature previously authorized or directed the CLRC to study; authorized and requested the CLRC to study and report on topics relating to hazardous waste control and hazardous substances; provided that before commencing work on any project within the list of topics authorized for study by the Legislature, the CLRC shall submit a detailed description of the scope of work to the Senate and Assembly Committees on Judiciary and any legislative policy committee with jurisdiction over the study’s subject matter; and expressly allowed the CLRC to provide copies of its recommendations to members of a legislative policy committee and invited CLRC staff to hearings for the purpose of explaining recommendations and answering questions from committee members.
ACR 148 (Chau, Res. Ch. 150, Stats. 2016) authorized the CLRC to continue its studies on whether specified laws should be revised; authorized an additional study of the California Public Records Act; provided that before commencing work on any project within the list of topics authorized for study by the Legislature, the CLRC shall submit a detailed description of the scope of work to the Senate and Assembly Committees on Judiciary and any legislative policy committee with jurisdiction over the study’s subject matter; and expressly allowed the CLRC to provide copies of its recommendations to members of a legislative policy committee and invite CLRC staff to hearings for the purpose of explaining recommendations and answering questions from committee members.
SCR 54 (Padilla, Res. Ch. 115, Stats. 2013) authorized the CLRC report on and prepare recommended legislation concerning statutes governing access by state and local government agencies to customer information from communications service providers.
AB 567 (Wagner, Res. Ch. 15, Stats. 2013) repealed the requirement that the CLRC make the decennial recommendations, and retained the CLRC’s general authority to study, review, and make recommendations regarding the enforcement of judgments law.
ACR 125 (Papan, Res. Ch. 167, Stats. 2002) authorized the CLRC to study, report on, and prepare recommended legislation concerning the issue of financial privacy to address protection and control of a consumer’s personal information and provide both administrative and civil penalties.
PRIOR VOTES:
Assembly Floor (Ayes 66, Noes 0)
Assembly Appropriations Committee (Ayes 11, Noes 3)
Assembly Judiciary Committee (Ayes 9, Noes 2)
**************
ASSEMBLY THIRD READING
ATR Bill Id:AB 2125
Author:(Garcia)
As Amended Ver:May 16, 2024
Majority vote
SUMMARY
Requires the California Law Revision Commission to study the existing statutes related to judicial recusal and removal related to conflicts of interest.
Major Provisions
- Requires on or before September 30, 2027 the California Law Revision Commission to deliver to the Legislature a study regarding recusal of judicial officers for prejudice and conflict of interest.
- Requires the study mandated pursuant to 1) to include the following:
- The effectiveness of Section 170.6 of the Code of Civil Procedure in eliminating bias in judicial proceedings;
- The prevalence of judicial officers hearing matters in which the cannons of judicial ethics should have warranted a recusal;
- The impact on case hearing times of judicial recusals; and
- The costs to the courts and to litigants of judicial recusals.
- Requires the California Law Revision Commission to consult with the Commission on Judicial Performance in creating the study.
COMMENTS
In 1957, the Legislature first authorized the disqualification of judges, via motion practice, on the basis of a judge's bias or prejudice against a party to a case. These provisions were expanded to include removal of a trial judge if a case were remanded back to the trial court after reversal on appeal on the basis that the trial judge may harbor resentment against the prevailing appellant. These provisions have never been applied to any appellate level judge or justice. The author and proponents of this measure contend that similar biases may be harbored by justices of the Court of Appeal whose decisions are reversed by the California Supreme Court. Recognizing that these biases or grievances may very well exist, as simply being an appellate justice rather than a trial court judge does not remove basic human emotions that could cause bias, this bill tasks the California Law Revision and Commission on Judicial Performance with reviewing the totality of California's judicial removal and recusal statutes to determine whether modernization is necessary.
Existing law provides several avenues for judges to be removed from a case due to conflicts of interest or bias. While many of the recusal statutes are predicated on the judicial officer voluntarily removing themselves in the event of a conflict, Code of Civil Procedure Section 170.6 is unique in that it enables a party to move to have a judge removed from a case for potential bias. Generally, Code of Civil Procedure Section 170.6 requires a party to move to have a judge dismissed from a case prior to the judge hearing the matter on the merits. However, amendments to that section added a provision authorizing the removal of a judge after a case was remanded back to the trial court after an appeal. SB 690 (Dills) Chapter 537, Statutes of 1989. Unfortunately, there is little available legislative history outlining the intent of the 1989 amendments regarding post-appeal removal of trial judges. The proponents of this measure appear to argue, and common sense would follow, that those amendments were made as a result of trial judges demonstrating bias against parties who appealed the trial judge’s ruling. Nonetheless, the ability for attorneys to remove judges for bias following an appeal has been the law of the state for nearly 40 years and the trial courts appear to have been able to handle reassigning matters, upon request, without significant difficulty.
Several stakeholders noted discontent with the existing law regarding removal of potentially biased judges. There is general agreement that reform of judicial recusal statutes and lessening delays in the court system are necessary. Accordingly, this bill tasks the California Law Revision Commission, by September 2027 and in consultation with the Commission on Judicial Performance, with studying the existing statutory framework for judicial recusal and removal for bias. The study must examine the effectiveness of existing statutes and the cost pressures that judicial removal procedures would place on the court.
According to the Author
[This bill] fills the hole remaining in Code of Civil Procedure section 170.6, to ensure appeals are decided by an unbiased appellate judge or panel. The legislation will ensure that decision made by the California Supreme Court are not negatively impacted by an appellate justice that is overturned. The legislation closes a loophole to ensure that voting rights, immigration rights, and environmental rights are not negatively impacted by an appellate judge.
Arguments in Support
This measure is sponsored by a coalition of legal aid organizations, who contend that justices who are angry about being overturned on appeal are purposefully and needlessly delaying litigation. Representative of the opinion of these supporters, the Inland Coalition for Immigrant Justice writes:
When the California Supreme Court reverses the decision of an intermediate appellate court, it generally remands the case back to the intermediate appellate court, and the same appellate justices who were reversed are again tasked with deciding the case. Where those appellate justices are hostile to the party prevailing in the Supreme Court, and decide the case against that party again, the result can be serial reviews by the California Supreme Court, with corresponding delays as the case bounces between the courts illustrating the maxim "justice delayed justice denied."
Additionally, the Asian Law Alliance writes:
While the California Supreme Court decides far fewer cases than the intermediate appellate courts, the cases it chooses to decide are often the most important, and receive more attention than cases decided by the intermediate appellate courts. Thus, the risk of bias against the party who successfully reversed the justice's erroneous ruling is even greater when the reversal is by the California Supreme Court.
Arguments in Opposition
A prior version of the bill was opposed by the Judicial Council of California, who contended the bill would place significant hardships on the courts, resulting in litigation delays and unnecessary costs. The Council writes:
Appellate court justices are required to disqualify themselves when they have any reason to believe that they cannot be impartial, or when they have any specific financial or personal conflicts as set forth in Canons 3E(4) and (5) of the California Code of Judicial Ethics. These conflicts are assessed at the outset when the panel is being assigned to prevent any appearance of bias or prejudice. By contrast, disqualification of a whole panel or majority of a panel after a reversal would result in significant delays in implementing the holding of the Supreme Court because the newly assigned justices and their attorneys would need to duplicate the work done by the prior panel and a second oral argument would need to be extended. This would also create significant logistical challenges in the courts that have been divided into divisions by the Legislature as provided by Article VI, Section 3 of the California Constitution because those courts only have three to four justices assigned and thus would need to request that the Chief Justice reassign the case to a different division within their district. This result would cause substantial delays in resolving cases and make it difficult for the courts to manage their existing caseloads in a timely manner.
Additionally, the California Judges Association writes:
Past legislative attempts to clean up Section 170.6, by eliminating the allegation of bias, have run into separation of powers problems based upon a 1938 decision of the California Supreme Court, Austin v. Lambert. Thus, for at least 86 years, the statute has required lawyers to essentially commit perjury, alleging bias when they know that no bias exists. Applying Section 170.6 to the fundamentally different structure and purpose of the appellate courts is unnecessary, will bring forum shopping to the appellate process, and cause delay in the administration of justice.
The problems with Section 170.6 calls out for a thoughtful evaluation, such as might be provided by the California Law Revision Commission, not expanding the flawed statute beyond the trial courts to the appellate process.
FISCAL COMMENTS
According to the Assembly Appropriations Committee, costs (General Fund) to CLRC of an unknown amount to complete the required study. CLRC reports it will likely need to hire a consultant to gather the data needed for the study.
VOTES
ASM JUDICIARY: 9-2-1
YES: Kalra, Ting, Bryan, Connolly, Haney, Maienschein, McKinnor, Pacheco, Reyes
NO: Sanchez, Waldron
ABS, ABST OR NV: Dixon
ASM APPROPRIATIONS: 11-3-1
YES: Wicks, Arambula, Bryan, Calderon, Wendy Carrillo, Mike Fong, Grayson, Haney, Hart, Pellerin, Villapudua
NO: Sanchez, Jim Patterson, Ta
ABS, ABST OR NV: Dixon
UPDATED
VERSION: May 16, 2024
CONSULTANT: Nicholas Liedtke / JUD. / (916) 319-2334 FN: 0003179
Date of Hearing: May 1, 2024
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Buffy Wicks, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 2125
Author:(Garcia) – As Amended Ver:April 10, 2024
Policy Committee: | Judiciary | Vote: | 9 - 2 |
|
| ||
|
|
Urgency: No State Mandated Local Program: No Reimbursable: No
SUMMARY:
This bill expands existing judicial officer removal rules to apply to certain appellate justices and requires the California Law Review Commission (CLRC) to conduct a study for the Legislature about recusal of judicial officers for prejudice and conflict of interest.
Specifically, among other provisions, this bill:
- Prohibits an appellate justice from trying a civil or criminal action or special proceeding, or hearing any matter therein, that involves a contested issue of law or fact when it is established that the justice is prejudiced against a party or attorney or the interest of a party or attorney appearing in the action or proceeding.
- Permits a party to make an oral or written motion, as specified, that the justice before whom the action or proceeding is pending, or to whom it is assigned, is prejudiced against a party or attorney, or their interest, so that the party or attorney cannot, or believes they cannot, have a fair and impartial trial or hearing before the justice.
- Specifies that such a motion directed to an appellate justice may be made only following reversal by the California Supreme Court of a court of appeal’s decision, and may be directed only to a justice who authored or concurred in the prior decision and is assigned to further consider the matter.
- Requires CLRC to deliver to the Legislature a study regarding recusal of judicial officers for prejudice and conflict of interest. CLRC must consult with the Commission on Judicial Performance and include information about the effectiveness, cost, and other impacts of judicial recusals.
FISCAL EFFECT:
- Cost pressures (Trial Court Trust Fund, General Fund) to the courts of an unknown but significant amount to adjudicate motions alleging judicial prejudice of appellate justices and reassign cases if justices are disqualified. Judicial Council estimates ongoing workload cost pressures of approximately $10 million annually to the appellate courts, with unknown additional impacts to the workload at the superior court level. The Governor’s 2024-25 budget proposes $83.1 million ongoing from the General Fund to backfill declining revenue to the Trial Court Trust Fund.
- Costs (General Fund) to CLRC of an unknown amount for additional staffing. CLRC reports it will likely need to hire a consultant to gather the data needed to complete the required study.
According to the Legislative Analyst’s Office, the General Fund faces a structural deficit in the tens of billions of dollars over the next several fiscal years.
COMMENTS:
- Purpose. According to the author:
AB 2125 fills the hole remaining in Code of Civil Procedure section 170.6, to ensure appeals are decided by an unbiased appellate judge or panel. The legislation will ensure that decision made by the California Supreme Court are not negatively impacted by an appellate justice that is overturned. The legislation closes a loophole to ensure that voting rights, immigration rights, and environmental rights are not negatively impacted by an appellate judge.
- Background. Judicial Disqualification. Existing law and judicial procedures generally require a superior court judge, appellate justice, or Supreme Court justice (“judicial officers”) to voluntarily remove themselves from presiding over a case if the judicial officer has a conflict of interest or bias relating to the case. Outside of voluntary recusal, the Code of Civil Procedure also allows a litigant to make a motion seeking removal of a superior court judge for potential bias. The law allows a litigant to make such a motion before the judge hears the matter or after the judge is reversed on appeal and the case is remanded back to the same judge for further action.
This bill expands existing judicial disqualification statutes to include appellate justices, allowing a litigant to move for removal of a justice based on bias or conflict of interest. The bill allows such motions only when a decision by an appellate justice (or multiple justices) is overturned by the California Supreme Court and the case has been remanded back to the appellate panel for further action. The bill would also make a superior court judge serving on an appellate panel subject to disqualification. The bill sunsets this provision in 2031.
California Law Review Commission. CLRC is responsible for studying California’s statutory and decisional law, identifying defects an anachronisms in the law, and making recommendations on how to remedy issues identified. Under CLRC’s enabling statute, a topic for study may originate from CLRC itself or may be assigned to CLRC by the Legislature.
This bill requires CLRC to complete a study for the Legislature on judicial disqualification. The study must cover the effectiveness of current removal procedures in eliminating bias, the prevalence of judicial officers hearing matters where recusal was warranted, the impact of judicial recusals on case hearing times, and the costs to the court and litigants of judicial recusals. As noted in the analysis of this bill by the Assembly Committee on Judiciary, the existing judicial disqualification laws seem unpopular with a variety of stakeholders, and public confidence in the judiciary is currently at an all-time low. Accordingly, it seems to make sense to study the effectiveness of the current system and consider alternative ways to handle judicial bias.
- Support and Opposition. In support of the bill, the League of Latino American Citizens and William C. Velasquez Institute writes:
Historically, and recently, we have seen the need for AB 2125. Following reversal by the California Supreme Court, intermediate appellate courts have, at best, reluctantly followed the instruction of the California Supreme Court, and, at worst, strained to avoid the outcome that would otherwise result from a faithful application of the high court’s decision. While the State of California has enacted several laws over several decades to promote the prompt resolution of cases, these post-reversal actions of the intermediate appellate courts can, and have, resulted in extreme delay – with cases bouncing between the three levels of courts for a decade or more. In cases where the rights of marginalized communities are at stake, that delay is harm in itself.
Writing in opposition, Judicial Council argues the current system – in which appellate justices must voluntarily recuse themselves if they believe they cannot be impartial, each appellate panel includes multiple justices who balance each other, and the Supreme Court provides oversight – is sufficient, and the bill “would result in significant delays in appellate proceedings without any real benefit to appellate litigants or the public.” Judicial Council continues:
These significant disruptions and delays might be justified if there was evidence of pervasive bias on appellate panels, but no such evidence has been provided. The council has not been made aware of instances in which a litigant believed that an appellate court justice was prejudiced against them after reversal by the Supreme Court, nor of cases that returned to the Supreme Court a second time because the intermediate appellate court misapplied the holding of the Supreme Court.
Analysis Prepared by: Annika Carlson / APPR. / (916) 319-2081
Date of Hearing: April 9, 2024
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON JUDICIARY
Ash Kalra, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 2125
Author:(Garcia) – As Amended Ver:March 6, 2024
As Proposed to be Amended
SUBJECT: Judicial officers: disqualification
KEY ISSUES:
- should a party obtaining a California supreme court decision that reverses the decision of a court of appeal be able to move to remove one or more justices of the court of appeal if the matter were remanded to the court of appeal for further action?
- should the calIfornia law revision commission, in conjunction with the commission on judicial performance, study and recommend to the legislature potential updates to the statutes regarding judicial recusal and removal?
SYNOPSIS
The level of the public’s confidence in the judiciary is at a near-record low. Much of the public’s distrust of the judicial branch can likely be traced to the numerous scandals involving United States Supreme Court justices and their acceptance of gifts and trips from parties with matters before the court. Regardless of the cause, numerous surveys show that the trustworthiness of all state and federal court judges is being harmed by these issues. Symptomatic of this distrust, the proponents of this bill contend that appellate justices are demonstrating bias against litigants involved in cases in which the justice’s decision was overturned by the California Supreme Court. Seeking to remedy this perceived bias, this bill would expand the existing law’s provisions providing for the removal of a judge for bias, at the request of a party to the matter, to apply to appellate justices and judges serving on a superior court’s appellate division. In response to opposition concerns, as proposed to be amended, this bill would sunset this expansion in 2030. Furthermore, acknowledging that several stakeholders have noted that the existing law regarding judicial officer recusal and removal needs updating, this bill would task the California Law Revision Commission, in consultation with the Commission on Judicial Performance, to study and recommend changes to the state’s existing laws on the topic.
This measure is supported by a coalition of legal aid organizations who argue that appellate justices are needlessly delaying or otherwise displaying bias in matters in which a justice has been reversed by California Supreme Court. The proponents argue that this bill is necessary to ensure that justice for their clients is not delayed by a bitter appellate court justice. The bill is vehemently opposed by the Judicial Council of California, which argues that three-justice appellate court panels are sufficient to remedy any judicial bias and that this bill would be too onerous for the judicial branch to implement successfully. This measure is also opposed by the California Judges Association, who contend that the existing law related to judicial removal is flawed, should not be expanded as proposed by this bill, and that the whole statutory scheme needs to be revisited. It is the Committee’s hope that by making this measure temporary and adopting a public process to reevaluate the existing law related to judicial bias, recusal, and removal, that this measure will begin to restore the public’s faith in the integrity of the judiciary.
SUMMARY: Expands existing judicial officer removal rules to apply to appellate justices whose decisions are reversed by the California Supreme Court if the case were remanded to the appellate court for additional action. Specifically, this bill:
- Prohibits, in addition to those judges identified by existing law, a justice of a court of appeal of the State of California from trying a civil or criminal action or special proceeding of any kind or character or hear any matter therein that involves a contested issue of law or fact when it is established that the judge or court commissioner is prejudiced against a party or attorney or the interest of a party or attorney appearing in the action or proceeding.
- Permits a party to, or an attorney appearing in, an action or proceeding may establish the prejudice required by 1) by an oral or written motion without prior notice supported by affidavit or declaration under penalty of perjury, or an oral statement under oath, that the justice before whom the action or proceeding is pending, or to whom it is assigned, is prejudiced against a party or attorney, or the interest of the party or attorney, so that the party or attorney cannot, or believes that they cannot, have a fair and impartial trial or hearing before the justice.
- Specifies that a motion made in accordance with 2) that is directed to one or more justices of a court of appeal may only be made following reversal by the California Supreme Court of a court of appeal’s decision, and may only be directed to the justice or justices who authored or concurred in the prior decision and is assigned to further consider the matter.
- Provides that the party who obtained the reversal of a decision of a court of appeal may make a motion pursuant to 2) regardless of whether that party or side has previously done so.
- Provides that for cases reversed on or after January 1, 2025, the motion made pursuant to 2) must be made within 30 days after the party or the party’s attorney has been notified of the assignment, and that for cases reversed before January 1, 2025, and remaining pending as of the effective date this bill the motion must be made on or before January 31, 2025.
- Deletes provisions of existing law exempting judges serving on the appellate division of a superior court from the judicial disqualification by motion provisions of this bill and provided for in existing law.
- Repeals the provisions of 1) though 6) on December 31, 2030 and reverts back to existing law related to judicial removal.
- Requires on or before September 30, 2027 the California Law Revision Commission to deliver to the Legislature a study regarding recusal of judicial officers for prejudice and conflict of interest.
- Requires the study mandated pursuant to 8) to include the following:
- The effectiveness of Section 170.6 of the Code of Civil Procedure in eliminating bias in judicial proceedings;
- The prevalence of judicial officers hearing matters in which the cannons of judicial ethics should have warranted a recusal;
- The impact on case hearing times of judicial recusals; and
- The costs to the courts and to litigants of judicial recusals.
- Requires the California Law Revision Commission to consult with the Commission on Judicial Performance in creating the study mandated by 8).
EXISTING LAW:
- Provides that every judge has a duty to decide any proceeding in which they are not disqualified. (Code of Civil Procedure Section 170.)
- Requires a judge to be disqualified if any of the following are true:
- The judge has personal knowledge of disputed evidentiary facts concerning the proceeding, as specified;
- The judge served as a lawyer in the proceeding, or in any other proceeding involving the same issues he or she served as a lawyer for a party in the present proceeding or gave advice to a party in the present proceeding upon a matter involved in the action or proceeding, as specified;
- The judge has a financial interest in the subject matter in a proceeding or in a party to the proceeding, as specified;
- The judge, or the spouse of the judge, or a person within the third degree of relationship to either of them, or the spouse of such a person is a party to the proceeding or an officer, director, or trustee of a party;
- A lawyer or a spouse of a lawyer in the proceeding is the spouse, former spouse, child, sibling, or parent of the judge or the judge’s spouse or if such a person is associated in the private practice of law with a lawyer in the proceeding;
- By reason of permanent or temporary physical impairment, the judge is unable to properly perceive the evidence or is unable to properly conduct the proceeding;
- The judge has a current arrangement concerning prospective employment or other compensated service as a dispute resolution neutral or is participating in, or, within the last two years has participated in, discussions regarding prospective employment or service as a dispute resolution neutral, or has been engaged in that employment or service, as specified;
- The judge has received a contribution in excess of one thousand five hundred dollars ($1500) from a party or lawyer in the proceeding, as specified; or
- The judge believes their recusal would further the interests of justice, the judge believes there is a substantial doubt as to their capacity to be impartial, or the judge believes a person aware of the facts might reasonably entertain a doubt that the judge would be able to be impartial. (Code of Civil Procedure Section 170.1 (a).)
- Requires a judge who determines themselves to be disqualified to notify the presiding judge of the court of their recusal and not further participate in the proceeding, except as provided, unless their disqualification is waived by the parties, as specified. (Code of Civil Procedure Section 170.3 (a).)
- Provides that if a judge who should disqualify themselves refuses or fails to do so, any party may file with the clerk a written verified statement objecting to the hearing or trial before the judge and setting forth the facts constituting the grounds for disqualification of the judge at the earliest practicable opportunity after discovery of the facts constituting the ground for disqualification. (Code of Civil Procedure Section 170.3 (c)(1).)
- Prohibits a judge, court commissioner, or referee of a superior court of the State of California from trying a civil or criminal action or special proceeding of any kind or character or hear any matter therein that involves a contested issue of law or fact when it is established that the judge or court commissioner is prejudiced against a party or attorney or the interest of a party or attorney appearing in the action or proceeding. (Code of Civil Procedure Section 170.6 (a)(1).)
- Provides that a party to, or an attorney appearing in, an action or proceeding may establish the prejudice required by 5) by an oral or written motion without prior notice supported by affidavit or declaration under penalty of perjury, or an oral statement under oath, that the judge, court commissioner, or referee before whom the action or proceeding is pending, or to whom it is assigned, is prejudiced against a party or attorney, or the interest of the party or attorney, so that the party or attorney cannot, or believes that they cannot, have a fair and impartial trial or hearing before the judge, court commissioner, or referee. (Code of Civil Procedure Section 170.6 (a)(2).)
- Provides that if the motion prepared pursuant to 6) is duly presented, and the affidavit or declaration under penalty of perjury is duly filed or an oral statement under oath is duly made, thereupon and without any further act or proof, the judge supervising the master calendar, if any, must assign some other judge, court commissioner, or referee to try the cause or hear the matter, and in other cases, the trial of the cause or the hearing of the matter must be assigned or transferred to another judge, court commissioner, or referee of the court in which the trial or matter is pending or, if there is no other judge, court commissioner, or referee of the court in which the trial or matter is pending, the Chair of the Judicial Council must assign some other judge, court commissioner, or referee to try the cause or hear the matter as promptly as possible. (Code of Civil Procedure Section 170.6 (a)(4).)
- Provides that the provisions of 5) through 7) does not apply to a judge designated or assigned to serve on the appellate division of a superior court in the judge’s capacity as a judge of that division. (Code of Civil Procedure Section 170.7.)
FISCAL EFFECT: As currently in print this bill is keyed fiscal.
COMMENTS: In 1957, the Legislature first authorized the disqualification of judges, via motion practice, on the basis of a judge’s bias or prejudice against a party to a case. These provisions were expanded to include removal of a trial judge if a case were remanded back to the trial court after reversal on appeal on the basis that the trial judge may harbor resentment against the prevailing appellant. These provisions have never been applied to any appellate level judge or justice. The author and proponents of this measure contend that similar biases may be harbored by justices of the Court of Appeal whose decisions are reversed by the California Supreme Court. Recognizing that these biases or grievances may very well exist, as simply being an appellate justice rather than a trial court judge does not remove basic human emotions that could cause bias, this bill seeks to temporarily expand the existing judicial removal statute to apply to appellate justices while the California Law Revision and Commission on Judicial Performance review the totality of California’s judicial removal and recusal statutes to determine whether modernization is necessary. In support of this bill, the author states:
AB 2125 fills the hole remaining in Code of Civil Procedure section 170.6, to ensure appeals are decided by an unbiased appellate judge or panel. The legislation will ensure that decision made by the California Supreme Court are not negatively impacted by an appellate justice that is overturned. The legislation closes a loophole to ensure that voting rights, immigration rights, and environmental rights are not negatively impacted by an appellate judge.
Although largely a result of the politicization of the United States Supreme Court, Americans confidence in the judicial branch of government is at an all-time low. The trust of Americans in institutions is at record lows. Typically, the judicial branch of government had been held in higher esteem than more politicized branches of the government. However, likely as a result of a series of scandals and stories of questionable ethical activities at the United States Supreme Court, the public’s confidence in the judiciary has fallen. From Justice Clarence Thomas’s multiple indiscretions (questionable loans, free travel, and unreported gifts) to Justice Samuel Alito’s penchant for taking expensive fishing trips with corporate lobbyists, to Justice Sonya Sotomayor pressuring public institutions where the justice was speaking to buy copies of her book, the Supreme Court’s behavior has significantly harmed the public faith in the justice’s neutrality and ability to fairly render legal decisions. (Alison Durkee, Here Are All The Supreme Court Controversies That Led To Adopting An Ethics Code, Forbes (Nov. 14, 2023) available at: https://www.forbes.com/sites/alisondurkee/2023/11/14/here-are-all-the-supreme-court-controversies-that-led-to-adopting-an-ethics-code/?sh=136ad0ab64ca.)
Unfortunately, questionable decision making and eroding public trust is not limited to the federal judiciary. In 2017, following a scandal regarding the purchase of a $32,000 sofa for his chambers, the Chief Justice of the West Virginia Supreme Court was indicted on 22 felony charges. (Carol Funk, Public Confidence and the Courts: Pillars of the Rule of Law, ABA Magazine (Feb. 17, 2023).) In 2022, the Montana Legislature issued subpoenas to the judicial branch after allegations surfaced that court computers and other public resources had been used by judges to assist their trade association in mounting a challenge to a proposed statute. (Ibid.) As a result of these and similar scandals, a study by the National Judicial College noted that 63 percent of judges believed their esteem in the eyes of the public was falling. (Ibid.) Other public polling mimics these results. A 2023 study by the National Center for State Courts noted that only 61 percent of Americans surveyed had “confidence” in state courts. (https://www.ncsc.org/consulting-and-research/areas-of-expertise/court-leadership/state-of-the-state-courts.) Furthermore, the percentage of Americans stating that state courts do not provide equal justice to all increased by 7 percentage points over the last decade and the number of Americans who stated they have faith in the court’s ability to provide equal justice declined by nearly ten percent. (Ibid.)
Whether or not this data is fair to the majority of judges, in California and nationally, the above described data paints a troubling picture of the degradation of public faith in the judiciary. Given that the same survey by the National Center for State Courts noted that the public holds an equally skeptical views of state legislatures, any actions by this Committee that may be perceived as shielding judges from public scrutiny, including for potential conflicts or bias, must be carefully evaluated.
Existing law enables parties to unilaterally remove a judge. Existing law provides several avenues for judges to be removed from a case due to conflicts of interest or bias. While many of the recusal statutes are predicated on the judicial officer voluntarily removing themselves in the event of a conflict, Code of Civil Procedure Section 170.6 is unique in that it enables a party to move to have a judge removed from a case for potential bias. Generally, Section 170.6 requires a party to move to have a judge dismissed from a case prior to the judge hearing the matter on the merits. However, amendments to that section added a provision authorizing the removal of a judge after a case was remanded back to the trial court after an appeal. (SB 690 (Dills) Chap. 537, Stats. 1989.) Unfortunately, there is little available legislative history outlining the intent of the 1989 amendments regarding post-appeal removal of trial judges. The proponents of this measure appear to argue, and common sense would follow, that those amendments were made as a result of trial judges demonstrating bias against parties who appealed the trial judge’s ruling. Nonetheless, the ability for attorneys to remove judges for bias following an appeal has been the law of the state for nearly 40 years and the trial courts appear to have been able to handle reassigning matters, upon request, without significant difficulty.
This bill seeks to eliminate actual and perceived bias at the Court of Appeal. This measure seeks to build on the existing law providing for the removal of trial judges following an appeal. Seeking to boost the faith of Californians, particularly communities of color, in the judiciary, this bill would extend the post-reversal right to remove a judge to apply to justices of California’s courts of appeal. The bill would similarly specify that the mandatory removal statute applies to superior court judges serving in the court’s appellate division. Recognizing that there may be logistical challenges to mandating the removal of appellate judges, this bill would sunset those provisions after five years and revert to the existing law regarding judicial removal, unless the Legislature acts to keep these new provisions in effect.
Further, recognizing that several of the stakeholders weighing in on this measure have noted to this Committee that the existing law is generally unpopular and functions as a blunt instrument for the unilateral removal of a judge, the bill also tasks the California Law Revision Commission to work with the Commission on Judicial Performance to study all of California’s judicial recusal statutes, both voluntary and involuntary, and report back to the Legislature on how these statutes could be made stronger for the public and more efficient for courts. In light of the above described data underscoring the public’s lack of faith in institutions of government, including the courts, the public will be able to provide feedback and comment on any California Law Revision Commission proposals. Thus, the comprehensive study is designed to improve everyday Californian’s faith in judicial branch decision making.
Despite calls to respect judicial decision-making, the courts are vehemently opposed to a measure that may increase public confidence in judicial outcomes. As discussed above, the public’s confidence in the judicial branch is eroding. While much of this is the result of high-profile conflicts of interest at the United States Supreme Court, the impact is clearly being felt in California. Indeed, in the 2024 State of the Judiciary address, the Chief Justice of the California Supreme Court lamented, “unnecessary and unproductive partisan attacks on court decisions.” (Cheryl Miller, California Chief Justice Calls on Lawmakers to Embrace Court Technology, Reject Attacks on Rulings, The Recorder (Mar. 19, 2024).) However, while not necessarily partisan, the proponents of this measure argue that appellate justices are making biased decisions after being overturned on appeal to punish litigants. They contend that this bill is necessary to preserve justice for their clients and to improve public confidence in court outcomes, especially within communities of color.
While this bill may increase confidence in court decision-making, the Judicial Council of California nevertheless oppose this measures. They contend:
Appellate courts have historically been exempted from the disqualification provisions in the Code of Civil Procedure because they have a different role in the process than the trial courts, and they include built in mechanisms to minimize judicial bias. The appellate process is structured to protect against individual bias by requiring a three-judge panel to decide each case, both at the appellate division of the Superior Court and at the intermediate courts of appeal.
Thus, the judicial branch is essentially asking this Committee to trust that any bias one justice may have in a case would be outweighed by having two other justices on a panel. These comments are unlikely to help the public’s perception of the courts, and in asking this Committee to oppose this measure, places the Legislature in the difficult position of appearing to protect potentially biased judges.
More compellingly, the courts also contend that, “AB 2125 would unnecessarily delay cases and interfere with the work of the appellate courts without providing any real benefit to the litigants or the public.” The author and proponents of this measure acknowledge that the bill may pose some logistical challenges for appellate courts, particularly in smaller districts. While the proponents believe that the study component of this measure, addressed in greater detail below, may ultimately produce a more workable statute for all parties, they also contend that the removal for bias statute is in need of immediate repair. Seeking to balance the needs of the courts with the needs of litigants, the author is proposing to sunset the provisions of this bill extending the removal for bias provisions of existing law to appellate judges in 2030. The author contends this provides immediate relief to litigants, while allowing for a thorough study of judicial recusal laws and evaluation the study by the Legislature.
Proposed amendments recognize that all stakeholders to this measure express some measure of displeasure with existing judicial recusal and removal statutes. Several stakeholders have written to this Committee, expressing discontent with the existing law regarding removal of potentially biased judges. The California Judges Association, writing in opposition to this measure, for example, succinctly summarize stakeholder’s thoughts on existing law by noting that this bill, “takes a bad statutory procedure and makes it worse.” While not all stakeholders would contend that this bill makes the statute worse, there is general agreement that reform of judicial recusal statutes and lessening delays in the court system are necessary. Accordingly, the author is proposing to have the California Law Revision Commission, in consultation with the Commission on Judicial Performance, study the existing statutory framework for judicial recusal and removal for bias. The amendments authorizing the study will read:
(a) On or before September 30, 2027 the California Law Revision Commission shall deliver to the Legislature a study regarding recusal of judicial officers for prejudice and conflict of interest.
(b) In developing the study required by this section, the California Law Revision Commission shall consult with the Commission on Judicial Performance.
(c) The study shall, at a minimum, include a discussion of the following:
(1) The effectiveness of Section 170.6 of the Code of Civil Procedure in eliminating bias in judicial proceedings.
(2)The prevalence of judicial officers hearing matters in which the cannons of judicial ethics should have warranted a recusal.
(3) The impact on case hearing times of judicial recusals.
(4) The costs to the courts and to litigants of judicial recusals.
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: This measure is sponsored by a coalition of legal aid organizations, who contend that justices who are angry about being overturned on appeal are purposefully and needlessly delaying litigation. Representative of the opinion of these supporters, the Inland Coalition for Immigrant Justice writes:
When the California Supreme Court reverses the decision of an intermediate appellate court, it generally remands the case back to the intermediate appellate court, and the same appellate justices who were reversed are again tasked with deciding the case. Where those appellate justices are hostile to the party prevailing in the Supreme Court, and decide the case against that party again, the result can be serial reviews by the California Supreme Court, with corresponding delays as the case bounces between the courts illustrating the maxim “justice delayed justice denied.”
Additionally, the Asian Law Alliance writes:
While the California Supreme Court decides far fewer cases than the intermediate appellate courts, the cases it chooses to decide are often the most important, and receive more attention than cases decided by the intermediate appellate courts. Thus, the risk of bias against the party who successfully reversed the justice’s erroneous ruling is even greater when the reversal is by the California Supreme Court.
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION: As noted above, this bill is opposed by the Judicial Council of California, who contend the bill will place significant hardships on the courts, resulting in litigation delays and unnecessary costs. The Council writes:
Appellate court justices are required to disqualify themselves when they have any reason to believe that they cannot be impartial, or when they have any specific financial or personal conflicts as set forth in Canons 3E(4) and (5) of the California Code of Judicial Ethics. These conflicts are assessed at the outset when the panel is being assigned to prevent any appearance of bias or prejudice. By contrast, disqualification of a whole panel or majority of a panel after a reversal would result in significant delays in implementing the holding of the Supreme Court because the newly assigned justices and their attorneys would need to duplicate the work done by the prior panel and a second oral argument would need to be extended. This would also create significant logistical challenges in the courts that have been divided into divisions by the Legislature as provided by Article VI, Section 3 of the California Constitution because those courts only have three to four justices assigned and thus would need to request that the Chief Justice reassign the case to a different division within their district. This result would cause substantial delays in resolving cases and make it difficult for the courts to manage their existing caseloads in a timely manner.
The council also has significant concerns about the impact of making Superior Court appellate division judges subject to disqualification pursuant to section 170.6 when they are serving in an appellate role. Currently they are subject to disqualification pursuant to Code of Civil Procedure section 170.3 which allows a party to object if they believe that a judge inappropriately refused to recuse themselves, but they are not subject to the more peremptory disqualification in section 170.6. Appellate division panels also consist of three judges who must be assigned by the Chief Justice. In small courts with only two judges, they must rely on the assignment of judges from neighboring counties, and in larger courts there may be only four judges assigned to the appellate division. If these appellate division judges were subject to disqualification pursuant to section 170.6, it would require many more judges to be assigned to serve on these panels and cause delays for the other cases and calendars that those trial judges would typically be assigned to hear.
These significant disruptions and delays might be justified if there was evidence of pervasive bias on appellate panels, but no such evidence has been provided. The council has not been made aware of instances in which a litigant believed that an appellate court justice was prejudiced against them after reversal by the Supreme Court, nor of cases that returned to the Supreme Court a second time because the intermediate appellate court misapplied the holding of the Supreme Court. In support of AB 2125 the author and sponsor cite the maxim that “justice delayed is justice denied.” While the process of fair and effective appellate review is one that takes time, it is clear that AB 2125 will not expedite the resolution of cases, but rather cause delay with no concomitant benefit to the parties or the public.
Additionally, the California Judges Association writes:
Past legislative attempts to clean up Section 170.6, by eliminating the allegation of bias, have run into separation of powers problems based upon a 1938 decision of the California Supreme Court, Austin v. Lambert. Thus, for at least 86 years, the statute has required lawyers to essentially commit perjury, alleging bias when they know that no bias exists. Applying Section 170.6 to the fundamentally different structure and purpose of the appellate courts is unnecessary, will bring forum shopping to the appellate process, and cause delay in the administration of justice.
The problems with Section 170.6 calls out for a thoughtful evaluation, such as might be provided by the California Law Revision Commission, not expanding the flawed statute beyond the trial courts to the appellate process.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
Asian Americans Advancing Justice - Asian Law Caucus
Asian Law Alliance
Central Valley Opportunity Center
First Day Foundation
Inland Coalition for Immigrant Justice
LA Cooperativa Campesina De California
Lawyers' Committee for Civil Rights of The San Francisco Bay Area
Los Amigos De LA Comunidad, INC.
Proteus INC.
William C. Velasquez Institute
Opposition
California Judges Association
Judicial Council of California
Analysis Prepared by: Nicholas Liedtke / JUD. / (916) 319-2334
Discussed in Hearing
Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations
Senate Standing Committee on Judiciary
Assembly Floor
Assembly Standing Committee on Judiciary
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):