AB 242: Critical access hospitals: employment.
- Session Year: 2023-2024
- House: Assembly
- Latest Version Date: 2023-10-10
Current Status:
Passed
(2023-10-10: Chaptered by Secretary of State - Chapter 641, Statutes of 2023.)
Introduced
In Committee
First Chamber
In Committee
Second Chamber
Enacted
Existing law, the Medical Practice Act, authorizes the Medical Board of California to grant approval of the employment of licensees on a salary basis by licensed charitable institutions, foundations, or clinics if no charge for professional services is made, in accordance with specified requirements. Existing law provides an exception to the prohibition on charging for professional services for a federally certified critical access hospital that employs licensees and charges for professional services rendered by those licensees to patients under specified conditions, including that the medical staff concur by an affirmative vote that the licensees employment is in the best interest of the communities served by the hospital. Existing law makes that exception operative only until January 1, 2024.
This bill would delete the provision making the above-specified exception inoperative on January 1, 2024. The bill would make nonsubstantive changes by deleting inoperative reporting requirements.
Existing law, the Medical Practice Act, authorizes the Medical Board of California to grant approval of the employment of licensees on a salary basis by licensed charitable institutions, foundations, or clinics if no charge for professional services is made, in accordance with specified requirements. Existing law provides an exception to the prohibition on charging for professional services for a federally certified critical access hospital that employs licensees and charges for professional services rendered by those licensees to patients under specified conditions, including that the medical staff concur by an affirmative vote that the licensees employment is in the best interest of the communities served by the hospital. Existing law makes that exception operative only until January 1, 2024.
This bill would delete the provision making the above-specified exception inoperative on January 1, 2024. The bill would make nonsubstantive changes by deleting inoperative reporting requirements.
Existing law, the Medical Practice Act, authorizes the Medical Board of California to grant approval of the employment of licensees on a salary basis by licensed charitable institutions, foundations, or clinics if no charge for professional services is made, in accordance with specified requirements. Existing law provides an exception to the prohibition on charging for professional services for a federally certified critical access hospital that employs licensees and charges for professional services rendered by those licensees to patients under specified conditions, including that the medical staff concur by an affirmative vote that the licensees employment is in the best interest of the communities served by the hospital. Existing law makes that exception operative only until January 1, 2024.
This bill would delete the provision making the above-specified exception inoperative on January 1, 2024. The bill would make nonsubstantive changes by deleting inoperative reporting requirements.
(a)Notwithstanding Section 2400, a clinic operated primarily for the purpose of medical education by a public or private nonprofit university medical school, which is approved by the board or the Osteopathic Medical Board of California, may charge for professional services rendered to teaching patients by licensees who hold academic appointments on the faculty of the university, if the charges are approved by the physician and surgeon in whose name the charges are made.
(b)Notwithstanding Section 2400, a clinic operated under subdivision (p) of Section 1206 of the Health and Safety Code may employ licensees and charge for professional services rendered by those licensees. However, the clinic shall not interfere with, control, or otherwise direct the professional judgment of a physician and surgeon in a manner prohibited by Section 2400 or any other law.
(c)Notwithstanding Section 2400, a narcotic treatment program operated under Section 11876 of the Health and Safety Code and regulated by the State Department of Health Care Services, may employ licensees and charge for professional services rendered by those licensees. However, the narcotic treatment program shall not interfere with, control, or otherwise direct the professional judgment of a physician and surgeon in a manner prohibited by Section 2400 or any other law.
(d)Notwithstanding Section 2400, a hospital that is owned and operated by a licensed charitable organization, that offers only pediatric subspecialty care, that, before January 1, 2013, employed licensees on a salary basis, and that has not charged for professional services rendered to patients may, commencing January 1, 2013, charge for professional services rendered to patients, provided the following conditions are met:
(1)The hospital does not increase the number of salaried licensees by more than five licensees each year.
(2)The hospital does not expand its scope of services beyond pediatric subspecialty care.
(3)The hospital accepts each patient needing its scope of services regardless of the patients ability to pay, including whether the patient has any form of health care coverage.
(4)The medical staff concur by an affirmative vote that the licensees employment is in the best interest of the communities served by the hospital.
(5)The hospital does not interfere with, control, or otherwise direct a physician and surgeons professional judgment in a manner prohibited by Section 2400 or any other law.
(e)Notwithstanding Section 2400, a federally certified critical access hospital may employ licensees and charge for professional services rendered by those licensees to patients, provided both of the following conditions are met:
(1)The medical staff concur by an affirmative vote that the licensees employment is in the best interest of the communities served by the hospital.
(2)The hospital does not interfere with, control, or otherwise direct a physician and surgeons professional judgment in a manner prohibited by Section 2400 or any other law.
(a)Notwithstanding Section 2400, a clinic operated primarily for the purpose of medical education by a public or private nonprofit university medical school, which is approved by the board or the Osteopathic Medical Board of California, may charge for professional services rendered to teaching patients by licensees who hold academic appointments on the faculty of the university, if the charges are approved by the physician and surgeon in whose name the charges are made.
(b)Notwithstanding Section 2400, a clinic operated under subdivision (p) of Section 1206 of the Health and Safety Code may employ licensees and charge for professional services rendered by those licensees. However, the clinic shall not interfere with, control, or otherwise direct the professional judgment of a physician and surgeon in a manner prohibited by Section 2400 or any other law.
(c)Notwithstanding Section 2400, a narcotic treatment program operated under Section 11876 of the Health and Safety Code and regulated by the State Department of Health Care Services, may employ licensees and charge for professional services rendered by those licensees. However, the narcotic treatment program shall not interfere with, control, or otherwise direct the professional judgment of a physician and surgeon in a manner prohibited by Section 2400 or any other law.
(d)Notwithstanding Section 2400, a hospital that is owned and operated by a licensed charitable organization, that offers only pediatric subspecialty care, that, before January 1, 2013, employed licensees on a salary basis, and that has not charged for professional services rendered to patients may, commencing January 1, 2013, charge for professional services rendered to patients, provided the following conditions are met:
(1)The hospital does not increase the number of salaried licensees by more than five licensees each year.
(2)The hospital does not expand its scope of services beyond pediatric subspecialty care.
(3)The hospital accepts each patient needing its scope of services regardless of the patients ability to pay, including whether the patient has any form of health care coverage.
(4)The medical staff concur by an affirmative vote that the licensees employment is in the best interest of the communities served by the hospital.
(5)The hospital does not interfere with, control, or otherwise direct a physician and surgeons professional judgment in a manner prohibited by Section 2400 or any other law.
(e)Notwithstanding Section 2400, a federally certified critical access hospital may employ licensees and charge for professional services rendered by those licensees to patients, provided both of the following conditions are met:
(1)The medical staff concur by an affirmative vote that the licensees employment is in the best interest of the communities served by the hospital.
(2)The hospital does not interfere with, control, or otherwise direct a physician and surgeons professional judgment in a manner prohibited by Section 2400 or any other law.
(a)Notwithstanding Section 2400, a clinic operated primarily for the purpose of medical education by a public or private nonprofit university medical school, which is approved by the board or the Osteopathic Medical Board of California, may charge for professional services rendered to teaching patients by licensees who hold academic appointments on the faculty of the university, if the charges are approved by the physician and surgeon in whose name the charges are made.
(b)Notwithstanding Section 2400, a clinic operated under subdivision (p) of Section 1206 of the Health and Safety Code may employ licensees and charge for professional services rendered by those licensees. However, the clinic shall not interfere with, control, or otherwise direct the professional judgment of a physician and surgeon in a manner prohibited by Section 2400 or any other law.
(c)Notwithstanding Section 2400, a narcotic treatment program operated under Section 11876 of the Health and Safety Code and regulated by the State Department of Health Care Services, may employ licensees and charge for professional services rendered by those licensees. However, the narcotic treatment program shall not interfere with, control, or otherwise direct the professional judgment of a physician and surgeon in a manner prohibited by Section 2400 or any other law.
(d)Notwithstanding Section 2400, a hospital that is owned and operated by a licensed charitable organization, that offers only pediatric subspecialty care, that, before January 1, 2013, employed licensees on a salary basis, and that has not charged for professional services rendered to patients may, commencing January 1, 2013, charge for professional services rendered to patients, provided the following conditions are met:
(1)The hospital does not increase the number of salaried licensees by more than five licensees each year.
(2)The hospital does not expand its scope of services beyond pediatric subspecialty care.
(3)The hospital accepts each patient needing its scope of services regardless of the patients ability to pay, including whether the patient has any form of health care coverage.
(4)The medical staff concur by an affirmative vote that the licensees employment is in the best interest of the communities served by the hospital.
(5)The hospital does not interfere with, control, or otherwise direct a physician and surgeons professional judgment in a manner prohibited by Section 2400 or any other law.
(e)(1)Notwithstanding Section 2400, until January 1, 2024, a federally certified critical access hospital may employ licensees and charge for professional services rendered by those licensees to patients, provided both of the following conditions are met:
(A)(1)The medical staff concur by an affirmative vote that the licensees employment is in the best interest of the communities served by the hospital.
(B)(2)The hospital does not interfere with, control, or otherwise direct a physician and surgeons professional judgment in a manner prohibited by Section 2400 or any other law.
(2)(A)On or before July 1, 2023, the Department of Health Care Access and Information shall provide a report to the Legislature containing data about the impact of paragraph (1) on federally certified critical access hospitals and their ability to recruit and retain physicians and surgeons between January 1, 2017, and January 1, 2023, inclusive. This report shall be submitted in compliance with Section 9795 of the Government Code. The requirement for submitting a report imposed under this subparagraph is inoperative on July 1, 2027.(B)The Department of Health Care Access and Information shall determine the format of the report, as well as the methods and data elements to be utilized in the development of the report.(C)On and after July 1, 2017, a federally certified critical access hospital that is employing licensees and charging for professional services rendered by those licensees to patients under this section shall submit to the office, on or before July 1 of each year, a report for any year in which that hospital has employed or is employing licensees and charging for professional services rendered by those licensees to patients. The report shall include data elements as required by the office and shall be submitted in a format as required by the Department of Health Care Access and Information. The requirement for submitting reports imposed under this subparagraph shall be inoperative on July 1, 2023.|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Oct 10, 2023 | Chaptered by Secretary of State - Chapter 641, Statutes of 2023. |
| Oct 10, 2023 | Approved by the Governor. |
| Sep 12, 2023 | Enrolled and presented to the Governor at 2 p.m. |
| Sep 5, 2023 | In Assembly. Ordered to Engrossing and Enrolling. |
| Sep 5, 2023 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Assembly. (Ayes 38. Noes 0. Page 2357.). |
| Aug 15, 2023 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| Aug 14, 2023 | From committee: Be ordered to second reading pursuant to Senate Rule 28.8. |
| Jun 29, 2023 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 12. Noes 0.) (June 28). Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Jun 5, 2023 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on HEALTH. (Ayes 13. Noes 0.) (June 5). Re-referred to Com. on HEALTH. |
| May 3, 2023 | Referred to Coms. on B., P. & E. D. and HEALTH. |
| Apr 18, 2023 | In Senate. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. |
| Apr 17, 2023 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Senate. (Ayes 79. Noes 0. Page 1178.) |
| Mar 30, 2023 | Read second time. Ordered to Consent Calendar. |
| Mar 29, 2023 | From committee: Do pass. To Consent Calendar. (Ayes 14. Noes 0.) (March 29). |
| Mar 15, 2023 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 13. Noes 0.) (March 14). Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Feb 2, 2023 | Referred to Com. on HEALTH. |
| Jan 14, 2023 | From printer. May be heard in committee February 13. |
| Jan 13, 2023 | Read first time. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sep 5, 2023 | Assembly 3rd Reading AB242 Wood By Roth | Senate Floor |
Passed |
|
| Jun 28, 2023 | Do pass, but first be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Senate Standing Committee on Health |
Passed |
|
| Jun 5, 2023 | Do pass, but first be re-referred to the Committee on [Health] | Senate Standing Committee on Business, Professions and Economic Development |
Passed |
|
| Apr 17, 2023 | AB 242 Wood Consent Calendar Second Day Regular Session | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| Mar 29, 2023 | Do pass. To Consent Calendar. | Assembly Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Mar 14, 2023 | Do pass and be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Assembly Standing Committee on Health |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
|
Organization
|
Position
|
Date
|
|---|---|---|
| Adventist Health | ** Support | |
| Association of California Healthcare Districts | ** Support | |
| Association Of California Healthcare Districts The | ** Support | |
| Avalon Medical Development Corporation | ** Support | |
| Banner Lassen Medical Center | ** Support | |
| California Hospital Association | ** Support | |
| California Medical Association | ** Against | |
| California Resident | * Against | Jun 28, 2023 |
| California Special Districts Association | ** Support | |
| Catalina Island Medical Center | ** Support | |
| Cottage Health | ** Support | |
| Dignity Health | ** Support | |
| District Hospital Leadership Forum | ** Support | |
| Fairchild Medical Center | ** Support | |
| Kern Valley Healthcare District | ** Support | |
| Mee Memorial Healthcare System | ** Support | |
| Mountain Communities Healthcare District | ** Support | |
| Providence | ** Support | |
| Providence Health | * Support | Mar 14, 2023 |
| Providence, Northern California Region | ** Support | |
| Ridgecrest Regional Hospital | ** Support | |
| Rural County Representatives of California | ** Support | |
| Sohum Health | ** Support | |
| Sutter Health | ** Support | |
| Tahoe Forest Hospital District | ** Support | |
| Trinity Hospital | ** Support |
SENATE RULES COMMITTEE Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | AB 242 |
THIRD READING
Bill No: AB 242
Author: Wood (D)
Introduced: 1/13/23
Vote: 21
SENATE BUS., PROF. & ECON. DEV. COMMITTEE: 13-0, 6/5/23
AYES: Roth, Nguyen, Alvarado-Gil, Archuleta, Ashby, Becker, Dodd, Eggman, Glazer, Niello, Smallwood-Cuevas, Wahab, Wilk
SENATE HEALTH COMMITTEE: 12-0, 6/28/23
AYES: Eggman, Nguyen, Glazer, Gonzalez, Grove, Hurtado, Limón, Menjivar, Roth, Rubio, Wahab, Wiener
SENATE APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE: Senate Rule 28.8
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 79-0, 4/17/23 (Consent) - See last page for vote
SUBJECT: Critical access hospitals: employment
SOURCE: Author
DIGEST:
This bill permanently authorizes a federally certified critical access hospital (CAH) to employ physicians and charge for their services.
ANALYSIS:
Existing law:
- Provides for the licensure and regulation of physicians and surgeons by the Medical Board of California (MBC) pursuant to the Medical Practice Act (Act) and Osteopathic Medical Board of California pursuant to the Osteopathic Act. (Business and Professions Code (BPC) § 2000 et seq and BPC § 2450-2459.7.)
- States that corporations and other artificial legal entities shall have no professional rights, privileges, or powers. Provides that the MBC may in its discretion, and under regulations adopted by it, grant approval of the employment of licensees on a salary basis by licensed charitable institutions, foundations, or clinics, if no charge for professional services rendered patients is made by any such institution, foundation, or clinic. (BPC § 2400)
- Establishes exceptions to the ban on the corporate practice of medicine (CPM), thereby allowing certain types of facilities to employ physicians, including:
- Clinics operated primarily for the purpose of medical education by a public or private nonprofit university medical school, to charge for professional services rendered to teaching patients by licensed physicians who hold academic appointments on the faculty of the university, if the charges are approved by the physician in whose name the charges are made;
- Certain nonprofit clinics organized and operated exclusively for scientific and charitable purposes, that have been conducting research since before 1982, and that meet other specified requirements, to employ physicians and charge for professional services. Prohibits, however, these clinics from interfering with, controlling, or otherwise directing a physician’s professional judgment in a manner prohibited by the CPM prohibition or any other provision of law;
- A narcotic treatment program regulated by the Department of Alcohol and Drug Programs to employ physicians and charge for professional services rendered by those physicians. Prohibits, however, the narcotic clinic from interfering with, controlling, or otherwise directing a physician’s professional judgment in a manner that is prohibited by the CPM prohibition or any other provision of law;
- A hospital that is owned and operated by a licensed charitable organization that offers only pediatric subspecialty care, as specified; and,
- A CAH, until January 1, 2024, if the medical staff concur by an affirmative vote that the licensee’s employment is in the best interest of the communities served by the hospital and if the hospital does not interfere with, control, or otherwise direct a physician and surgeon’s professional judgment. (BPC § 2401)
- Requires the Department of Health Care Access and Information (HCAI), on or before July 1, 2023, to provide a report to the Legislature containing data about the impact of e) above on CAHs and their ability to recruit and retain physicians and surgeons between January 1, 2017, and January 1, 2023.
- Establishes various protections against retaliation for health care practitioners who advocate for appropriate health care for their patients pursuant to Wickline v. State of California (192 Cal. App. 3d 1630).
- Under the Knox-Keene Health Care Service Plan Act of 1975, authorizes licensed health care service plans to employ or contract with health care professionals, including physicians, to deliver professional services, and requires health plans to demonstrate that medical decisions are rendered by qualified medical providers unhindered by fiscal and administrative management. Provides in regulation that the organization of a health plan must include separation of medical services from fiscal and administrative management. (Health and Safety Code §§ 1340 et seq.)
This bill permanently authorizes a federally certified CAH to directly employ physicians and charge for their services by deleting the sunset date and eliminates reporting requirements related to this activity.
Background
- Ban on the Corporate Practice of Medicine (CPM). CPM is usually referred to in the context of a prohibition, banning hospitals from employing physicians. The ban on CPM evolved in the early 20th century when mining companies had to hire physicians directly to provide care for their employees in remote areas. However, problems arose when physicians' loyalty to the mining companies conflicted with patients' needs. Eventually, physicians, courts, and legislatures prohibited CPM in an effort to preserve physicians’ autonomy and improve patient care.
Over the years, various state and federal statutes have weakened the CPM prohibition. According to a 2007 California Research Bureau (CRB) report, “California’s CPM doctrine has been defined largely through lawsuits and Attorney General opinions over decades, and then riddled by HMO and other legislation; its power and meaning are now inconsistent…. Although some non-profit clinics may employ physicians, California applies the CPM doctrine to most other entities.... Teaching hospitals may employ physicians, but other hospitals, including most public and non-profit hospitals, may not employ physicians. Professional medical corporations are expressly permitted to engage in the practice of medicine, and may employ physicians. [However, t]hese medical corporations may operate on a for-profit basis, although the profit motive was one of the original rationales of the CPM prohibition.”
A 2016 CRB report notes that “since 2007, the provision of healthcare has undergone changes in California. The Affordable Care Act is responsible for an increase in insured patients across the state. In 2016-2017, 13.5 million Californians are expected to have enrolled in Medi-Cal, up from 7.9 million in 2012-2013, and 1.5 million people will be enrolled in Covered California at the end of 2015-2016. As a result, more insured patients than ever are accessing healthcare services without a commensurate increase in healthcare practitioners.” The report suggested assessing changing financial incentives; considering whether other methods of protecting physician autonomy are sufficient; increasing patient access to data about physician-hospital relationships and hospital metrics; determining whether the current alignment strategies used by physicians and hospitals are more costly than direct employment models; and collecting additional data to better understand the impact of CPM.
California is one of only a small handful of states remaining states that adhere to some form of the ban. The American Medical Association (AMA), historically the driving force behind the CPM prohibition, no longer views physician employment as a violation of medical ethics and has removed the doctrine from its ethical code.
- SB 376 Pilot Program. In 2003, the Legislature established a pilot project to allow qualified hospital districts to directly employ physicians (SB 376, Chesbro, Chapter 411, Statutes of 2003). SB 376 was sponsored by the Association of California Healthcare Districts, which argued that authorizing the employment of physicians could improve the ability of district hospitals to attract the physicians required to meet the needs of the communities and ensure the continued survival of district hospitals. As the 2016 CRB report notes, hospital districts were established in California in 1945 in an attempt to give rural, low income areas without ready access to hospital facilities a source of tax dollars that could be used to construct and operate community hospitals and healthcare institutions, and, in medically underserved areas, to recruit physicians and support their practices. SB 376 allowed each hospital district to hire two physicians, for a total of 20 physicians throughout the state. To qualify for the pilot project, a hospital district was required to meet certain criteria, including population numbers and numbers of uninsured patients. During the pilot project, five participating hospital districts recruited and hired six physicians, whose employment contract periods ran three to four years.
SB 376 required MBC to report to the Legislature on the evaluation of the effectiveness of the pilot project in improving access to health care in rural and medically underserved areas and the project’s impact on consumer protection as it relates to intrusions into the practice of medicine. In the report, MBC estimated that a total of 20 physician participants were needed to conduct a valid analysis of the project. Only six physicians were hired by eligible hospitals. Further, MBC had difficulty gathering information from the participants on the success of the plan. Only three of the five participating hospitals and five of the six participating doctors responded to MBC’s inquires. MBC stated that it regrets the lack of participation in the project.
Efforts have been undertaken since 2003 to further address this issue and allow for direct employment, which is seen as having a number of benefits, including, but not limited to relief from administrative responsibilities, especially those relating to insurance billing; malpractice insurance; greater access and support for healthcare IT tools, facilities, and medical equipment; a predictable work week and; economic stability.
In 2016, AB 2024 (Wood, Chapter 496, Statutes of 2016) authorized a CAH to employ physicians and charge for professional services rendered by those physicians. The measure also required CAHs to report certain information to the former Office of Statewide Health Planning and Development, now HCAI. HCAI is mandated to provide a report to the Legislature by July 1, 2023, containing data about the impact of employing licensees and charging professional services on CAHs, and their ability to recruit and retain physicians and surgeons between January 1, 2017, and January 1, 2023. This bill extends permanently the authority for a CAH to employ physicians directly, as initially authorized by AB 2024.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: Yes Local: No
SUPPORT: (Verified 8/16/23)
Adventist Health
Association of California Healthcare Districts
Avalon Medical Development Corporation
Banner Lassen Medical Center
California Hospital Association
California Special Districts Association
Cottage Health
Dignity Health
District Hospital Leadership Forum
Fairchild Medical Center
Kern Valley Healthcare District
Mee Memorial Healthcare System
Mountain Communities Healthcare District
Ridgecrest Regional Hospital
Rural County Representatives of California
Sohum Health
Sutter Health
Tahoe Forest Hospital District
OPPOSITION: (Verified 8/16/23)
California Medical Association
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: Numerous CAHs write that they have benefited greatly from the direct hire of primary care and specialty physicians and making this employment provision permanent for will ensure access to high-quality health care is equitable across the state.
According to the California Hospital Association, “CAHs serve as the centerpiece of economic viability, providing jobs for their community’s residents and resources for its development. The ability to directly hire physicians directly impacts recruitment and retention, stabilizing access to care. Making this option permanent for CAHs helps ensure access to high quality health care in our most rural and remote communities — with little to no cost to the state.”
The Association of California Healthcare Districts writes in support: “There are 33 district hospitals in the state of California, 17 of which have critical access designation. Since the enactment of the pilot program under AB 2024 (Wood, 2016), several of these hospitals have successfully used this tool to recruit and retain physicians to underserved areas of the state. Those that have not yet utilized this ability, have long awaited its permanency to ensure they would not lose valuable providers once they were employed. California is facing a severe workforce shortage, of both primary and specialty care providers. The ability to employ physicians allow CAHs to offer benefits and guaranteed salaries, making serving these areas more financially attractive. AB 242 is essential to closing provider gaps, ensuring Californians continue to receive care in rural and remote communities. If the pilot is allowed to sunset on January 1, 2024, hospitals throughout the state will no longer be able to employ doctors currently serving their facilities. This would be devastating to the patients that these hospitals serve and the doctors who enjoy employment at these facilities.”
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION: The California Medical Association notes that the HCAI report is due in July 2023 and states that “until HCAI publishes its report regarding the impact the program has had on patient care, we would request that the sunset on the program be extended for 5 years and not made permanent.”
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 79-0, 4/17/23
AYES: Addis, Aguiar-Curry, Alanis, Alvarez, Arambula, Bains, Bauer-Kahan, Bennett, Berman, Boerner Horvath, Bonta, Bryan, Calderon, Juan Carrillo, Wendy Carrillo, Cervantes, Chen, Connolly, Megan Dahle, Davies, Dixon, Essayli, Flora, Mike Fong, Vince Fong, Friedman, Gabriel, Gallagher, Garcia, Gipson, Grayson, Hart, Holden, Hoover, Irwin, Jackson, Jones-Sawyer, Kalra, Lackey, Lee, Low, Lowenthal, Maienschein, Mathis, McCarty, McKinnor, Muratsuchi, Stephanie Nguyen, Ortega, Pacheco, Papan, Jim Patterson, Joe Patterson, Pellerin, Petrie-Norris, Quirk-Silva, Ramos, Reyes, Luz Rivas, Robert Rivas, Rodriguez, Blanca Rubio, Sanchez, Santiago, Schiavo, Soria, Ta, Ting, Valencia, Villapudua, Waldron, Wallis, Ward, Weber, Wicks, Wilson, Wood, Zbur, Rendon
NO VOTE RECORDED: Haney
Prepared by: Sarah Mason / B., P. & E.D. /
8/16/23 16:20:12
**** END ****
SENATE COMMITTEE ON HEALTH
Senator Dr. Susan Talamantes Eggman, Chair
BILL NO: AB 242
AUTHOR: | Wood | ||
VERSION: | January 13, 2023 | ||
HEARING DATE: | June 28, 2023 | ||
CONSULTANT: | Vincent D. Marchand | ||
SUBJECT: Critical access hospitals: employment
SUMMARY:
Deletes the January 1, 2024 sunset date, and thereby makes permanent, on a provision of law permitting a critical access hospital to employ physicians.
Existing law:
- Prohibits, within the Medical Practice Act, corporations and other artificial legal entities from having any professional rights, privileges, or powers. However, permits the Medical Board of California (MBC), in its discretion, to grant approval of the employment of physicians on a salary basis by licensed charitable institutions, foundation, or clinics, if no charge for professional services rendered to patients is made by any such institution, foundation, or clinic. This is known as the ban on the corporate practice of medicine (CPM). [BPC §2400]
- Establishes certain exemptions from the ban on the CPM, including the following:
- Clinics operated primarily for the purpose of medical education by a public or private nonprofit university medical school, are permitted to charge for professional services rendered to teaching patients by licensed physicians who hold academic appointments on the faculty of the university, if the charges are approved by the physician in whose name the charges are made; [BPC §2401(a)]
- Certain nonprofit clinics organized and operated exclusively for scientific and charitable purposes, that have been conducting research since before 1982, and that meet other specified requirements, are permitted to employ physicians and charge for professional services, but are prohibited from interfering with or directing a physician’s professional judgment; [BPC §2401(b)]
- A narcotic treatment program regulated by the Department of Alcohol and Drug Programs is permitted to employ physicians and charge for professional services rendered by those physicians, but is prohibited from interfering with or directing a physician’s professional judgment; [BPC §2401(c)]
- A hospital that is owned and operated by a licensed charitable organization that offers only pediatric subspecialty care, and that employed physicians prior to January 1, 2013, is permitted to charge for professional services, under certain specified conditions; and, [BPC §2401(d)]
- Although not in statute, existing case law establishes an exemption from the ban on the CPM for county hospitals to employ physicians.
- Exempts from the ban on the CPM, until January 1, 2024, a federally certified critical access hospital, to enable critical access hospitals to employ physicians, provided the medical staff concur by an affirmative vote that the licensee’s employment is in the best interest of the communities served by the hospital, and the hospital does not interfere with, control, or otherwise direct a physician’s judgment. [BPC §2401(e)]
- Requires the Department of Health Care Access and Information (HCAI) to provide a report to the Legislature by July 1, 2023, containing data about the impact of the CPM exemption for critical access hospitals s as described in 3) above on these hospitals ability to recruit and retain physicians. Requires critical access hospitals that are employing physicians to submit data on to HCAI as specified. [BPC §2401(e)]
- Establishes “The Local Health Care District Law,” under which a local hospital district may be organized, incorporated and managed. Permits a district to include incorporated or unincorporated territory, or both, in any one or more counties. Requires health care districts to be governed by an elected board of five members, who are required to live within the healthcare district. [HSC §32000 et seq., §32001, §32100]
- Provides local health care districts with certain powers, including establishing and operating health facilities or other health care programs, and to establish and operate, or provide assistance in the operation of, free clinics, diagnostic and testing centers, health education programs, wellness and prevention programs, rehabilitation, aftercare, and any other health care services providers, groups, and organizations that are necessary for the maintenance of good physical and mental health in the communities served by the district. [HSC §32121]
This bill:
- Deletes the January 1, 2024 sunset date, and thereby makes permanent, on a provision of law permitting a certified critical access hospital to employ physicians and charge for services rendered by those physicians.
- Deletes related provisions requiring critical access hospitals to submit reports to HCAI on their employment of physicians, and requiring HCAI to provide a report about the impact on critical access hospitals and their ability to recruit and retain physicians.
FISCAL EFFECT:
According to the Assembly Appropriations Committee, no state costs.
PRIOR VOTES:
Senate Business, Professions, and Economic Development Committee: | 13 - 0 |
Assembly Floor: | 79 - 0 |
Assembly Appropriations Committee: | 14 - 0 |
Assembly Health Committee: | 13 - 0 |
COMMENTS:
- Author’s statement. According to the author, while he is sympathetic to the concerns about interference with the clinical judgment of any health care provider, the ban on the CPM is not necessarily the best or only tool to assure physician autonomy in clinical decision-making. The number of exceptions allowed, combined with the growth of medical groups, independent practice associations and medical foundations, all represent the larger medical communities’ response to pressures within the delivery system to reduce costs, improve patient outcomes and increase access. The author states that the private practice of medicine is a valuable component in our communities and should be preserved but preserving it to the exclusion of other modes of practice seems shortsighted. If younger physicians prefer or are comfortable in an employment setting, California should not limit it as an option for them. By doing so, California law may also be inadvertently limiting access in rural communities when it may not be financially viable to maintain a private practice. Rural hospitals struggle with many health care challenges, particularly as they relate to workforce and financial payer mix, which tends to be disproportionately Medi-Cal and Medicare. The author concludes that this bill provides an additional tool to rural, critical access hospitals by providing them some workforce flexibility.
- Background on the CPM and California Research Bureau (CRB) reports. The ban on the CPM has historically prevented corporations from practicing medicine, which includes the employment of physicians. From the late 1920s, California courts have staunchly protected the right of physicians to practice without being subject to potential interference by corporate employers. Since that time, California has created a number of exemptions to the ban on the CPM. Where exemptions do not exist, physicians and hospitals work together without creating employment relationships.
In 2007, the CRB published a report examining the status of the ban on the CPM, and it argued that exemptions had created a doctrine whose “power and meaning are now inconsistent.” The CRB also raised the idea that the many exemptions to the ban may “signal a change in public opinion.” The CRB report noted that although the CPM doctrine is generally not believed to be extremely detrimental, its present utility seems limited, as the evolution and erosion of the CPM prohibition over many decades has resulted in a doctrine that is far removed from its origin and lacks coherence and relevance in today’s health care landscape. On April 12, 2016 the CRB released a new report, "The Corporate Practice of Medicine in a Changing Healthcare Environment," which reviewed the current status of the ban in California and key policy issues associated with it. In the 2016 report, the CRB pointed out that there are a variety of issues within the healthcare environment that cause conflicts of interest, though not necessarily wrongdoing, within the healthcare field, including self-referrals for office services and physician-owned centers, reimbursement models and bonuses, and pharmaceutical promotions and drug samples, among others. With respect to physician autonomy, the CRB states that recent survey research indicates that physicians’ status as salaried employees in large organizations is not associated with decreased reports by physicians of freedom in making clinical decisions. The CRB notes that as discussions about the ban on the CPM continue, it is important that public policy discussions consider it within the context of conflicts of interest and autonomy in the modern healthcare environment. - Pilot project for Critical Access Hospitals. AB 2024 (Wood, Chapter 496, Statutes of 2016) created a new pilot project that allowed federal certified critical access hospitals to employ physicians until January 1, 2024. This bill is making this permanent. Critical access hospitals are licensed general acute care hospitals that are certified to receive cost-based reimbursement from Medicare in order to reduce hospital closures in rural areas. To be certified as a critical access hospital, a hospital can have no more than 25 beds, must be located in a rural area, and cannot be close to another hospital. There are 36 federally certified critical access hospitals in California. Unlike the pilot program for district hospitals created by SB 376 in 2003 (see the “limited pilot project” description in 4) below), the critical access hospital exemption did not limit the number of physicians that a hospital could employ, and there is no statewide cap. AB 2024 required HCAI to provide a report to the Legislature, by July 1, 2023, on this pilot program and critical access hospitals ability to recruit and retain physicians between January 1, 2017 and January 1, 2023. While this report has not yet been submitted, HCAI has provided data on the number of physicians hired under the pilot program so far. According to HCAI, of the 36 critical access hospitals, 18 have hired at least one physician, for a total of 123 physicians employed by critical access hospitals at some point during the pilot program. One hospital (Tahoe Forest Hospital District in Truckee) employed the most at 54 physicians. Mark Twain Medical Center in San Andreas hired 16 physicians, Healdsburg Hospital hired ten physicians, and Ridgecrest Regional Hospital hired six physicians, with most of the remaining hospitals hiring one to two physicians.
- Limited pilot project for some district hospitals from 2004-2010. SB 376 (Chesbro, Chapter 411, Statutes of 2003) created a limited exemption from the ban on the CPM for some health care district hospitals. Health care districts are a form of special district. Special districts are local governments that are legally separate from counties and cities, and they have the authority to build public works projects and run programs, and the power to impose taxes to raise funds to pay for these services. Each health care district is governed by a locally elected five-member board of directors, and are subject to state policies and regulations as applied by each county’s Local Agency Formation Commission. There are currently 77 health care districts, but of these, only 33 own and operate hospitals, while a handful of others own either the hospital or the land and lease the hospital to another entity to operate the hospital. Under the SB 376 pilot program, a district hospital that was located in a county with less than 750,000 people, that had net losses in a previous year, and that served a high proportion of Medi-Cal and Medicare patients could directly employ up to two physicians for a maximum of four years, with the maximum number of employed physicians statewide capped at 20. The pilot program required a report from the MBC to be provided to the Legislature by October 1, 2008, and pilot project sunset was January 1, 2011. According to the MBC’s report, unexpectedly, only six physicians were hired by five eligible hospitals during the years the pilot was operational. The MBC stated that such a low number would not offer a significant, quantifiable improvement in access to healthcare nor would such a low number offer much information to MBC in preparing a valid and useful analysis of the pilot. Only four of the six participating physicians, and three of the five participating hospitals, responded for requests for input. The MBC stated that there may be justification to extend the pilot so that a better evaluation of the direct employment of physicians could be made. While several bills sought to either extend or expand the pilot project, these bills did not pass and the pilot project expired.
- Double referral. This bill was heard in the Senate Business, Professions and Economic Development Committee on June 5, 2023, and passed on a 13-0 vote.
- Related legislation. SB 784 (Becker) exempts health care district hospitals from the ban on the CPM, enabling these hospitals to directly employ physicians. SB 784 has not been heard in the Senate Appropriations Committee.
- Prior legislation. AB 2024 (Wood, Chapter 496, Statutes of 2016) established an exemption, until January 1, 2024, from the ban on the CPM in order to allow federally certified critical access hospitals to employ physicians and charge for those services.
SB 1274 (Wolk, Chapter 793, Statutes of 2012), permits a hospital that is owned and operated by a charitable organization and offers only pediatric subspecialty care to begin billing health carriers for physician services rendered, notwithstanding the ban on the CPM if specified conditions are met.
AB 648 (Chesbro of 2009) would have established a demonstration project to permit rural hospitals, as defined, whose service area includes a medically underserved or federally designated shortage area and which meet certain specified requirements, to directly employ physicians and surgeons. AB 648 failed passage in the Senate Business, Professions and Economic Development Committee.
AB 646 (Swanson of 2009) would have permitted health care districts and certain public hospitals, independent community nonprofit hospitals, and clinics, as specified, to directly employ physicians and surgeons. AB 646 failed passage in the Senate Business, Professions and Economic Development Committee.
SB 726 (Ashburn of 2009) would have revised and extended the MBC pilot project that allows qualified district hospitals, as defined, to employ a physician, if the hospital does not interfere with, control, or otherwise direct the professional judgment of the physician. SB 726 failed passage in the Senate Business, Professions and Economic Development Committee.
AB 1944 (Swanson of 2008) would have allowed health care districts to employ a physician. AB 1944 failed passage in the Senate Committee on Health.
SB 1294 (Ducheny of 2008) would have expanded the pilot project enabling health care districts to directly employ physicians. SB 1294 failed passage in the Assembly Appropriations Committee.
SB 376 (Chesbro, Chapter 411, Statutes of 2003) authorized, until January 1, 2011, a hospital owned and operated by a health care district meeting specified criteria to employ a physician, and to charge for professional services rendered by the physician if the physician approves the charges. - Support. The California Hospital Association, the Association of California Healthcare Districts, the District Hospital Leadership Forum, the Rural County Representatives of California, as well as numerous individual hospitals, all support this bill. The Association of California Healthcare Districts states that 17 of the 33 district hospitals have critical access designation. Since the enactment of the pilot program under AB 2024, several of these hospitals have successfully used this tool to recruit and retain physicians to underserved areas of the state. Those that have not yet utilized this ability have long awaited its permanency to ensure they would not lose valuable providers once they were employed. Tahoe Forest Hospital District supports this bill and states that since the enactment of AB 2024, critical access hospitals, including Tahoe Forest Hospital, have benefited greatly from the direct hire of primary care and specialty physicians, and this bill will ensure access to high-quality health care is equitable at Tahoe Forest Hospital and hospitals across the state. The Rural County Representatives of California, more than 25% of the population lives in rural areas, yet less than 10% of the country’s physicians practice there. Rural communities are facing dire workforce shortages, which are putting additional pressure on the strained service delivery systems, and this bill is essential to close provider gaps and ensure Californians continue to receive care in rural and remote communities.
- Oppose unless amended. The California Medical Association (CMA) states it is opposed to this bill because the original legislation required a report by HCAI on this program that is due in July of 2023, and that report has not been released. CMA states that until HCAI publishes its report regarding the impact the program has had on patient care, it requests that the sunset date be extended for five years rather than made permanent.
SUPPORT AND OPPOSITION:
Support: Association of California Healthcare Districts
Banner Lassen Medical Center
California Hospital Association
California Special Districts Association
Catalina Island Medical Center
Dignity Health
District Hospital Leadership Forum
Fairchild Medical Center
Kern Valley Healthcare District
Mee Memorial Healthcare System
Providence, Northern California Region
Ridgecrest Regional Hospital
Rural County Representatives of California
Sutter Health
Tahoe Forest Hospital District
Trinity Hospital
Oppose: California Medical Association (unless amended)
-- END --
SENATE COMMITTEE ON
BUSINESS, PROFESSIONS AND ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT
Senator Richard Roth, Chair
2023 - 2024 Regular
Bill No: Hearing Date: June 5, 2023
Author: | |||
Version: | January 13, 2023 | ||
Urgency: | No | Fiscal: | Yes |
Consultant: | Sarah Mason | ||
Subject:
SUMMARY: Permanently authorizes a federally certified critical access hospital (CAH) to employ physicians and charge for their services.
NOTE:
This measure is double-referred to the Senate Committee on Health, second.
Existing law:
- Provides for the licensure and regulation of physicians and surgeons by the Medical Board of California (MBC) pursuant to the Medical Practice Act (Act) and Osteopathic Medical Board of California pursuant to the Osteopathic Act. (Business and Professions Code (BPC) § 2000 et seq and BPC § 2450-2459.7.)
- States that corporations and other artificial legal entities shall have no professional rights, privileges, or powers. Provides that the MBC may in its discretion, and under regulations adopted by it, grant approval of the employment of licensees on a salary basis by licensed charitable institutions, foundations, or clinics, if no charge for professional services rendered patients is made by any such institution, foundation, or clinic. (BPC § 2400)
- Establishes exceptions to the ban on the corporate practice of medicine (CPM), thereby allowing certain types of facilities to employ physicians, including:
- Clinics operated primarily for the purpose of medical education by a public or private nonprofit university medical school, to charge for professional services rendered to teaching patients by licensed physicians who hold academic appointments on the faculty of the university, if the charges are approved by the physician in whose name the charges are made;
- Certain nonprofit clinics organized and operated exclusively for scientific and charitable purposes, that have been conducting research since before 1982, and that meet other specified requirements, to employ physicians and charge for professional services. Prohibits, however, these clinics from interfering with, controlling, or otherwise directing a physician’s professional judgment in a manner prohibited by the CPM prohibition or any other provision of law;
- A narcotic treatment program regulated by the Department of Alcohol and Drug Programs to employ physicians and charge for professional services rendered by those physicians. Prohibits, however, the narcotic clinic from interfering with, controlling, or otherwise directing a physician’s professional judgment in a manner that is prohibited by the CPM prohibition or any other provision of law; and,
- A hospital that is owned and operated by a licensed charitable organization that offers only pediatric subspecialty care, as specified.
- A CAH, until January 1, 2024, if the medical staff concur by an affirmative vote that the licensee’s employment is in the best interest of the communities served by the hospital and if the hospital does not interfere with, control, or otherwise direct a physician and surgeon’s professional judgment. (BPC § 2401)
- Requires the Department of Health Care Access and Information (HCAI), on or before July 1, 2023, to provide a report to the Legislature containing data about the impact of (e) above on CAHs and their ability to recruit and retain physicians and surgeons between January 1, 2017, and January 1, 2023..
- (C) On and after July 1, 2017, a federally certified critical access hospital that is employing licensees and charging for professional services rendered by those licensees to patients under this section shall submit to the office, on or before July 1 of each year, a report for any year in which that hospital has employed or is employing licensees and charging for professional services rendered by those licensees to patients. The report shall include data elements as required by the office and shall be submitted in a format as required by the Department of Health Care Access and Information. The requirement for submitting reports imposed under this subparagraph shall be inoperative on July 1, 2023.
- Establishes the following protections against retaliation for health care practitioners who advocate for appropriate health care for their patients pursuant to Wickline v. State of California (192 Cal. App. 3d 1630):
- It is the public policy of the State of California that a health care practitioner be encouraged to advocate for appropriate health care for his or her patients. For purposes of this section, “to advocate for appropriate health care” means to appeal a payer’s decision to deny payment for a service pursuant to the reasonable grievance or appeal procedure established by a medical group, independent practice association, preferred provider organization, foundation, hospital medical staff and governing body, or payer, or to protest a decision, policy, or practice that the health care practitioner, consistent with that degree of learning and skill ordinarily possessed by reputable health care practitioners with the same license or certification and practicing according to the applicable legal standard of care, reasonably believes impairs the health care practitioner’s ability to provide appropriate health care to his or her patients.
- The application and rendering by any individual, partnership, corporation, or other organization of a decision to terminate an employment or other contractual relationship with or otherwise penalize a health care practitioner principally for advocating for appropriate health care consistent with that degree of learning and skill ordinarily possessed by reputable health care practitioners with the same license or certification and practicing according to the applicable legal standard of care violates the public policy of this state.
- This law shall not be construed to prohibit a payer from making a determination not to pay for a particular medical treatment or service, or the services of a type of health care practitioner, or to prohibit a medical group, independent practice association, preferred provider organization, foundation, hospital medical staff, hospital governing body, or payer from enforcing reasonable peer review or utilization review protocols or determining whether a health care practitioner has complied with those protocols. (BPC § 510)
- Under the Knox-Keene Health Care Service Plan Act of 1975, authorizes licensed health care service plans to employ or contract with health care professionals, including physicians, to deliver professional services, and requires health plans to demonstrate that medical decisions are rendered by qualified medical providers unhindered by fiscal and administrative management. Provides in regulation that the organization of a health plan must include separation of medical services from fiscal and administrative management. (Health and Safety Code §§ 1340 et seq.)
This bill permanently authorizes a federally certified CAH to directly employ physicians and charge for their services by deleting the sunset date and eliminates reporting requirements related to this activity.
FISCAL EFFECT:
This bill is keyed fiscal. According to the Assembly Committee on Appropriations, the measure will not result in state costs.
COMMENTS:
- Purpose. The Author is the Sponsor of this bill. According to the Author, “It is difficult for small rural, critical access hospitals to hire physicians. Of the more than 7,200 federally designated health professional shortage areas, three out of five are in rural regions. According to the National Rural Health Association, more than 25% of the U.S. population lives in rural areas, yet less than 10% of the country’s physicians practice there. This could be because of the many obstacles they face in a rural setting, including a lack of access to resources and medical technology, the absence of a defined work schedule, a lower salary than their urban counterparts and the challenges of owning and operating a financially viable sole private practice in smaller communities.”
The Author cites a 2020 American Medical Association survey which found that fewer physicians are opting to own and operate a private practice, with more seeking a career as an employee of a hospital or larger medical group. The survey also noted that many recent graduates of medical schools have significant debt and are more likely to choose employment, which offers financial stability and better work-life balance.
According to the Author, “All CAHs need the ability to hire physicians for their rural communities, without a sunset on the length of employment.”
- Background. Prior to 1968, the common practice in California was that professional services could be provided only pursuant to a license and could not be rendered by a professional business organized as a corporation in California. Discussions began in the early 1960's to allow the formation of professional corporations, for a limited number of regulated professions, in order to provide those individuals with some of the same benefits that general corporations received including, tax benefits, health plan benefits, and reduction of personal liability exposure. However, a major underlying concern for the proponents of continuing the prohibition against the corporate practice of licensed professions was that lay shareholders and directors may not be bound by the same ethical standards that professional licensees are, and instead may focus on financial gains rather than consumer protection and professional standards.
A professional corporation is an organization made up of individuals of the same trade or profession. In 1968, the California Legislature enacted the Moscone-Knox Professional Corporation Act (Act), which established the requirements for the practice of professional services in corporate form. When the Act was passed in 1968, some personal service professions already had the legal authority to form corporations. Physicians, attorneys and dentists were not included, and were authorized to establish professional corporations at that time. By 1973, the Act had extended corporate practice to chiropractors, physical therapists, psychologists, optometrists, accountants, and shorthand reporters.
However, as noted in historical information provided by the California Research Bureau (CRB), at the time of the Act, the Department of Finance opposed the legislation, because other professions would want similar authorization, as the Act provided an economic benefit that "allows physicians, lawyers, and dentists to reduce their taxes in a manner that self-employed persons and wage-earners cannot."
Current law specifies which healing arts licensees may be shareholders, officers, directors or professional employees of professional corporations controlled, including by a differing profession so long as the sum of all shares owned by those licensed persons does not exceed 49 percent of the total number of shares of the professional corporation. Corporations Code Section 13401.5 authorizes the formation of various healing arts professional corporations and establishes which healing arts licensees who are not of the same license type as the corporation may be shareholders, officers, and directors of that corporation. Any person licensed under the BPC, the Chiropractic Act, or the Osteopathic Act may be employed by these professional corporations. Thus, the services of professional corporations are not limited to the named profession. For example, a nursing corporation may have a director who is a chiropractor, a shareholder who is an acupuncturist, and employ an accountant, podiatrist, and a marriage and family therapist, none of which would traditionally be seen as providing the professional services of nursing. Current law authorizes a medical corporation to have a number of health licensees as officers, directors, and shareholders.
License holders in a variety of other health professions can also serve as shareholders. Provisions of the Act requiring corporations to be owned by licensees are reflected in the various practice acts within the BPC that govern the licensure and regulation of a number of professions.
Ban on the Corporate Practice of Medicine (CPM). CPM is usually referred to in the context of a prohibition, banning hospitals from employing physicians. The ban on CPM evolved in the early 20th century when mining companies had to hire physicians directly to provide care for their employees in remote areas. However, problems arose when physicians' loyalty to the mining companies conflicted with patients' needs. Eventually, physicians, courts, and legislatures prohibited CPM in an effort to preserve physicians’ autonomy and improve patient care.
Over the years, various state and federal statutes have weakened the CPM prohibition. According to a 2007 California Research Bureau (CRB) report, “California’s CPM doctrine has been defined largely through lawsuits and Attorney General opinions over decades, and then riddled by HMO and other legislation; its power and meaning are now inconsistent…. Although some non-profit clinics may employ physicians, California applies the CPM doctrine to most other entities.... Teaching hospitals may employ physicians, but other hospitals, including most public and non-profit hospitals, may not employ physicians. Professional medical corporations are expressly permitted to engage in the practice of medicine, and may employ physicians. [However, t]hese medical corporations may operate on a for-profit basis, although the profit motive was one of the original rationales of the CPM prohibition.”
A 2016 CRB report notes that “since 2007, the provision of healthcare has undergone changes in California. The Affordable Care Act is responsible for an increase in insured patients across the state. In 2016-2017, 13.5 million Californians are expected to have enrolled in Medi-Cal, up from 7.9 million in 2012-2013, and 1.5 million people will be enrolled in Covered California at the end of 2015-2016. As a result, more insured patients than ever are accessing healthcare services without a commensurate increase in healthcare practitioners.” The report suggested assessing changing financial incentives; considering whether other methods of protecting physician autonomy are sufficient; increasing patient access to data about physician-hospital relationships and hospital metrics; determining whether the current alignment strategies used by physicians and hospitals are more costly than direct employment models; and collecting additional data to better understand the impact of CPM.
California is one of only a small handful of states remaining states that adhere to some form of the ban. The American Medical Association (AMA), historically the driving force behind the CPM prohibition, no longer views physician employment as a violation of medical ethics and has removed the doctrine from its ethical code.
SB 376 Pilot Program. In 2003, the Legislature established a pilot project to allow qualified hospital districts to directly employ physicians (SB 376, Chesbro, Chapter 411, Statutes of 2003). SB 376 was sponsored by the Association of California Healthcare Districts, the Sponsor of this bill, which argued that authorizing the employment of physicians could improve the ability of district hospitals to attract the physicians required to meet the needs of the communities and ensure the continued survival of district hospitals. As the 2016 CRB report notes, hospital districts were established in California in 1945 in an attempt to give rural, low income areas without ready access to hospital facilities a source of tax dollars that could be used to construct and operate community hospitals and healthcare institutions, and, in medically underserved areas, to recruit physicians and support their practices.
SB 376 allowed each hospital district to hire two physicians, for a total of 20 physicians throughout the state. To qualify for the pilot project, a hospital district was required to meet certain criteria, including population numbers and numbers of uninsured patients. During the pilot project, five participating hospital districts recruited and hired six physicians, whose employment contract periods ran three to four years.
SB 376 required MBC to report to the Legislature on the evaluation of the effectiveness of the pilot project in improving access to health care in rural and medically underserved areas and the project’s impact on consumer protection as it relates to intrusions into the practice of medicine. In the report, MBC estimated that a total of 20 physician participants were needed to conduct a valid analysis of the project. Only six physicians were hired by eligible hospitals. Further, MBC had difficulty gathering information from the participants on the success of the plan. Only three of the five participating hospitals and five of the six participating doctors responded to MBC’s inquires. MBC stated that it regrets the lack of participation in the project.
According to the report, MBC held discussions with numerous interested parties, even beyond those participating in the project and found widespread concern over the lack of physicians in rural areas. MBC stated that due to the “limited extent” of participation, it was unable to fully evaluate the project. In the report, MBC stated that it does not support the complete removal of the limitations on the corporate practice of medicine, but concluded that there may be justification to continue the project. MBC stated that it might be appropriate to expand the pilot project to allow more hospitals to participate; but until more information is available it does not recommend amending the statues that govern the corporate practice of medicine.
Efforts have been undertaken since 2003 to further address this issue and allow for direct employment, which is seen as having a number of benefits, including, but not limited to relief from administrative responsibilities, especially those relating to insurance billing; malpractice insurance; greater access and support for healthcare IT tools, facilities, and medical equipment; a predictable work week and; economic stability. The Legislature considered:
- AB 824 (Chesbro, 2011) which was similar language in AB 648 of 2009 below which would have extended the SB 376 pilot project to January 1, 2022. The bill failed passage in the Assembly Committee on Health.
- AB 926 (Hayashi, 2011) would have reenacted SB 376 pilot project but would have allowed all qualified district hospitals to employ not more than 50 physicians and surgeons until January 1, 2022. The bill failed passage in the Assembly Committee on Business, Professions and Consumer Protection.
- AB 1360 (Swanson, 2011) would have authorized a new pilot project that allowed a healthcare district and a clinic owned or operated by a healthcare district to employ physicians and surgeons if the service area included a medically underserved area or a medically underserved population or had been federally designated as a health professional shortage area. The bill would have provided that a district could extend any employee contracts up to 10 years and would have required a study of the program’s effectiveness and a sunset date of January 1, 2022. The bill failed passage in the Assembly Committee on Health.
- SB 726 (Ashburn, 2009) would have extended the SB 376 pilot project to 2018 and would have revised the pilot to authorize the direct employment by qualified healthcare districts and qualified rural hospitals of an unlimited number of physicians and surgeons, and authorized such hospitals to employ up to five physicians and surgeons at a time with a term of contract not to exceed 10 years. The bill failed passage in this committee.
- AB 646 (Swanson, 2009) was almost identical to AB 1360. The bill failed passage in this committee.
- AB 648 (Chesbro, 2009) would have established a new pilot project that extended the scope of the first pilot and would have authorized a rural hospital to employ up to 10 physicians and surgeons at one time and to retain all or part of the income generated for medical services billed and collected, provided the physician and surgeon in whose name the charges are made approved the charges. The bill would have required a rural hospital to develop and implement a policy regarding the independent medical judgment of the physician and surgeon. This pilot would have expired January 1, 2020. The bill failed passage in this committee.
- SB 1294 (Ducheny, 2008) would have extended the SB 376 pilot project to January 1, 2017 and would have allowed district hospitals to hire an unlimited number of physicians and surgeons, subject to board approval. It would also have changed the definition of a qualified district hospital to a hospital that, among other things, is located in a medically underserved area or a rural hospital that had net losses in the most recent fiscal year. The bill failed passage in the Assembly Appropriations Committee.)
- SB 1640 (Ashburn, 2008) would have extended the SB 376 pilot project to January 1, 2016 and revised it to authorize “general acute care hospitals” in rural or underserved areas, to employ an unlimited number of physicians and surgeons and to charge for professional services rendered by those physicians. The bill failed passage in this committee
- AB 1944 (Swanson, 2008) would have eliminated the SB 376 pilot project and instead would have permanently authorized healthcare districts to employ physicians to primarily treat Medi-Cal patients and bill for the physicians’ services with their approval. It would have prohibited the hospital from interfering with the professional judgment of physicians and surgeons. The bill failed passage in the Senate Committee on Health.
AB 242 and HCAI report. In 2016, AB 2024 (Wood, Chapter 496, Statutes of 2016) authorized a CAH to employ physicians and charge for professional services rendered by those physicians. The measure also required CAHs to report certain information to the former Office of Statewide Health Planning and Development, now the Department of Health Care Access and Information (HCAI). HCAI is mandated to provide a report to the Legislature by July 1, 2023 containing data about the impact of employing licensees and charging professional services on CAHs, and their ability to recruit and retain physicians and surgeons between January 1, 2017, and January 1, 2023. This bill would permanently extend the authority for a CAH to employ physicians directly, as initially authorized by AB 2024.
- Related Legislation. SB 784 (Becker) authorizes a health care district that owns or controls a general acute care hospital to employ physicians and charge for their services and prohibits a health care district from interfering with, controlling, or otherwise directing the professional judgment of a physician and surgeon. (Status: This bill is pending in the Senate Committee on Appropriations.)
- Arguments in Support. Numerous CAHs write that they have benefited greatly from the direct hire of primary care and specialty physicians and making this employment provision permanent for will ensure access to high-quality health care is equitable across the state.
According to the California Hospital Association, “CAHs serve as the centerpiece of economic viability, providing jobs for their community’s residents and resources for its development. The ability to directly hire physicians directly impacts recruitment and retention, stabilizing access to care. Making this option permanent for CAHs helps ensure access to high quality health care in our most rural and remote communities — with little to no cost to the state.”
The Association of California Healthcare Districts writes in and support: “There are 33 district hospitals in the state of California, 17 of which have critical access designation. Since the enactment of the pilot program under AB 2024 (Wood, 2016), several of these hospitals have successfully used this tool to recruit and retain physicians to underserved areas of the state. Those that have not yet utilized this ability, have long awaited its permanency to ensure they would not lose valuable providers once they were employed. California is facing a severe workforce shortage, of both primary and specialty care providers. The ability to employ physicians allow CAHs to offer benefits and guaranteed salaries, making serving these areas more financially attractive. AB 242 is essential to closing provider gaps, ensuring Californians continue to receive care in rural and remote communities. If the pilot is allowed to sunset on January 1, 2024, hospitals throughout the state will no longer be able to employ doctors currently serving their facilities. This would be devastating to the patients that these hospitals serve and the doctors who enjoy employment at these facilities.”
- Arguments in Opposition. The California Medical Association notes that the HCAI report is due in July 2023 and states that “until HCAI publishes its report regarding the impact the program has had on patient care, we would request that the sunset on the program be extended for 5 years and not made permanent.”
SUPPORT AND OPPOSITION:
Support:
Adventist Health
Association of California Healthcare Districts
Avalon Medical Development Corporation
Banner Lassen Medical Center
California Hospital Association
Cottage Health
Dignity Health
District Hospital Leadership Forum
Fairchild Medical Center
Kern Valley Healthcare District
Mee Memorial Healthcare System
Mountain Communities Healthcare District
Ridgecrest Regional Hospital
Rural County Representatives of California
Sohum Health
Tahoe Forest Hospital District
Opposition:
California Medical Association
-- END --
Date of Hearing: March 29, 2023
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Chris Holden, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 242
Author:(Wood) – As Introduced Ver:January 13, 2023
Policy Committee: | Health | Vote: | 13 - 0 |
|
| ||
|
|
Urgency: No State Mandated Local Program: No Reimbursable: No
SUMMARY:
This bill deletes the prohibition on federally certified critical access hospitals (CAHs) employing physicians.
FISCAL EFFECT:
No state costs.
COMMENTS:
- Purpose. According to the author:
By [limiting employment as an option for younger physicians], California law may…be inadvertently limiting access in rural communities… Rural hospitals struggle with many health care challenges, particularly as they relate to workforce and financial payer mix, which tends to be disproportionately Medi-Cal and Medicare…This bill provides an additional tool to rural, CAHs by providing them some workforce flexibility.
- Background.
- CAHs. CAHs are licensed general acute care hospitals that are certified to receive cost-based reimbursement from Medicare, which is intended to reduce hospital closures in rural areas. To be certified as a CAH, a hospital may have no more than 25 beds and must be located in a rural area and be either (i) more than 35 miles from another hospital or (ii) 15 miles from another hospital in mountainous terrain or an area with only secondary roads. Other requirements include operating an emergency department and having an annual average length of stay of 96 hours or less per patient.
- Corporate Practice of Medicine (CPM). CPM commonly refers to the employment of physicians by hospitals, for-profit and non-profit corporate entities, and government. CPM was banned to prevent interference with a physician’s professional judgment, based on concerns that CPM would lead to commercial exploitation of physicians and lower professional standards, divide a physician’s loyalty between patient and employer, and give lay persons control over a professional.
- Exceptions to the Ban on CPM. The Medical Practice Act, within Business and Professions Code § 2400, prohibits corporations and other artificial legal entities from having any professional rights, privileges, or powers, and gives the Medical Board of California (MBC) discretion to grant approval of the employment of physicians on a salary basis by licensed charitable institutions, foundations, or clinics if patients are not charged for professional services. There are numerous other exemptions from the ban on CPM, such as physician employment by teaching hospitals, certain nonprofit clinics, narcotic treatment programs regulated by the Department of Alcohol and Drug Programs, and county hospitals. In addition, under the Knox-Keene Health Care Service Plan Act of 1975 (Health and Safety Code § 1340 et seq.), licensed health plans may employ or contract with physicians to deliver professional services under specified conditions, including that qualified medical providers’ medical decisions are unhindered by fiscal and administrative management.
- SB 376 (Chesbro), Chapter 411, Statutes of 2003. SB 376 established a pilot project to allow each of ten qualified hospital districts to directly employ two physicians. The Association of California Healthcare Districts, the sponsor of SB 376, argued authorizing the employment of physicians could improve the ability of district hospitals to attract the physicians required to meet the needs of the communities and ensure the survival of district hospitals. Proponents hoped direct employment would provide economic security and encourage physicians to choose rural communities. During the pilot project, participating hospital districts recruited and hired six physicians, whose employment contract periods ran three to four years. The MBC reported all six participating physicians were positive about the employment experience, and administrators believed it would have been more difficult to recruit the physicians without the employment opportunity.
- AB 2024 (Wood), Chapter 496, Statutes of 2016. The provisions of SB 376 expired in 2011. AB 2024 established an exemption from the prohibition on CPM to allow federally certified CAHs to employ physicians and charge for those services. According to the Department of Health Care Access and Information (HCAI), of the 36 CAHs in California, half hired physicians between 2017 and 2023. The provisions of AB 2024 will expire January 1, 2024, if this bill is not enacted.
- CAHs. CAHs are licensed general acute care hospitals that are certified to receive cost-based reimbursement from Medicare, which is intended to reduce hospital closures in rural areas. To be certified as a CAH, a hospital may have no more than 25 beds and must be located in a rural area and be either (i) more than 35 miles from another hospital or (ii) 15 miles from another hospital in mountainous terrain or an area with only secondary roads. Other requirements include operating an emergency department and having an annual average length of stay of 96 hours or less per patient.
Analysis Prepared by: Allegra Kim / APPR. / (916) 319-2081
Date of Hearing: March 14, 2023
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON HEALTH
Jim Wood, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 242
Author:(Wood) – As Introduced Ver:January 13, 2023
SUBJECT: Critical access hospitals: employment.
SUMMARY: Deletes the prohibition on the corporate practice of medicine (CPM) for federally certified critical access hospitals (CAHs) and the reporting requirements related to CAHs employing physicians.
EXISTING LAW:
- Establishes an exemption, until January 1, 2024, from the prohibition on the CPM in order to allow federally certified CAHs to employ physicians and charge for those services. [Business and Professions Code (BPC) § 2401]
- Prohibits, within the Medical Practice Act, corporations and other artificial legal entities from having any professional rights, privileges, or powers. Gives the Medical Board of California (MBC), discretion, to grant approval of the employment of physicians on a salary basis by licensed charitable institutions, foundations, or clinics, if no charge for professional services rendered to patients is made by any such institution, foundation, or clinic. This is known as the ban on the CPM. [BPC § 2400]
- Establishes certain exemptions from the ban on the CPM, including the following:
- Clinics and hospitals operated primarily for the purpose of medical education by a public or private nonprofit university medical school, are permitted to charge for professional services rendered to teaching patients by licensed physicians who hold academic appointments on the faculty of the university, if the charges are approved by the physician in whose name the charges are made;
- Certain nonprofit clinics organized and operated exclusively for scientific and charitable purposes, that have been conducting research since before 1982, and that meet other specified requirements, are permitted to employ physicians and charge for professional services, but are prohibited from interfering with or directing a physician’s professional judgment;
- A narcotic treatment program regulated by the Department of Alcohol and Drug Programs is permitted to employ physicians and charge for professional services rendered by those physicians, but is prohibited from interfering with or directing a physician’s professional judgment;
- A hospital that is owned and operated by a licensed charitable organization that offers only pediatric subspecialty care, and that employed physicians prior to January 1, 2013, is permitted to charge for professional services, under certain specified conditions; and, [BPC § 2401]
- Establishes in case law, an exemption from the ban on the CPM for county hospitals to employ physicians. [Wickline v. State of California (192 Cal. App. 3d 1630)]
- Permits, under the Knox-Keene Health Care Service Plan Act of 1975, licensed health plans to employ or contract with health care professionals, including physicians, to deliver professional services, and requires health plans to demonstrate that medical decisions are rendered by qualified medical providers unhindered by fiscal and administrative management. Provides in regulation that the organization of a health plan must include separation of medical services from fiscal and administrative management. (HSC § 1340 et seq.]
FISCAL EFFECT: Unknown. This bill has not yet been analyzed by a fiscal committee.
COMMENTS:
- PURPOSE OF THIS BILL. According to the author, while he is sympathetic to the concerns about interference with the clinical judgment of any health care provider, the ban on the CPM is not necessarily the best or only tool to assure physician autonomy in clinical decision-making. The number of exceptions allowed, combined with the growth of medical groups, independent practice associations and medical foundations, all represent the larger medical communities’ response to pressures within the delivery system to reduce costs, improve patient outcomes and increase access. The author states that the private practice of medicine is a valuable component in our communities and should be preserved but preserving it to the exclusion of other modes of practice seems shortsighted. If younger physicians prefer or are comfortable in an employment setting, California should not limit it as an option for them. By doing so, California law may also be inadvertently limiting access in rural communities when it may not be financially viable to maintain a private practice. Rural hospitals struggle with many health care challenges, particularly as they relate to workforce and financial payer mix, which tends to be disproportionately Medi-Cal and Medicare. The author concludes that this bill provides an additional tool to rural, CAHs by providing them some workforce flexibility.
- BACKGROUND.
- Health Professional Shortage Areas (HPSAs). Of the more than 7,200 federally designated HPSAs, which is defined as a geographic area, population, or facility with a shortage of primary care, dental, or mental health providers and services), three out of five are in rural regions. According to the National Rural Health Association, more than 25% of the U.S. population lives in rural areas, yet less than 10% of the country’s physicians practice there. This could be because of the many obstacles they face in a rural setting, including a lack of access to resources and medical technology, the absence of a defined work schedule, a lower salary than their urban counterparts and the challenges of owning and operating a financially viable sole private practice in smaller communities.
- Physician employment preferences. A 2020 American Medical Association survey found that fewer physicians are opting to own and operate a private practice, with more seeking a career as an employee of a hospital or larger medical group. The survey also noted that many recent graduates of medical schools have significant debt and are more likely to choose employment, which offers financial stability and better work-life balance.
- CAHs. CAHs are licensed general acute care hospitals that are certified to receive cost-based reimbursement from Medicare, which is intended to reduce hospital closures in rural areas. To be certified as a CAH, a hospital can have no more than 25 beds and must be located in a rural area and: i) more than 35 miles from another hospital; or, ii) 15 miles from another hospital in mountainous terrain or an area with only secondary roads. Other requirements include operating an emergency department, and having an annual average length of stay of 96 hours or less per patient.
- California Research Bureau (CRB) reports. In 2007, the CRB published a report examining the status of the ban on the CPM, and it argued that exemptions had created a doctrine whose “power and meaning are now inconsistent.” The CRB also raised the idea that the many exemptions to the ban may “signal a change in public opinion.” The CRB report notes that although the CPM doctrine is generally not believed to be extremely detrimental, its present utility seems limited, as the evolution and erosion of the CPM prohibition over many decades has resulted in a doctrine that is far removed from its origin and lacks coherence and relevance in today’s health care landscape. Because the policy concerns that the CPM prohibition was meant to address are still important and have been raised in other contexts, California’s statutes and regulations now address these concerns more directly. The existence of these more focused safeguards, and the ability to enact others if needed, raise the question of whether maintaining the CPM doctrine still makes sense.
- Health Professional Shortage Areas (HPSAs). Of the more than 7,200 federally designated HPSAs, which is defined as a geographic area, population, or facility with a shortage of primary care, dental, or mental health providers and services), three out of five are in rural regions. According to the National Rural Health Association, more than 25% of the U.S. population lives in rural areas, yet less than 10% of the country’s physicians practice there. This could be because of the many obstacles they face in a rural setting, including a lack of access to resources and medical technology, the absence of a defined work schedule, a lower salary than their urban counterparts and the challenges of owning and operating a financially viable sole private practice in smaller communities.
On April 12, 2016, the CRB released a new report, "The Corporate Practice of Medicine in a Changing Healthcare Environment," which reviewed the status of the ban in California and key policy issues associated with it, one of them being the effect of the ban on rural areas.
As the 2016 CRB report notes, attempting to address the rural healthcare gap, SB 376 (Chesbro), Chapter 411, Statutes of 2003, established a pilot project to allow qualified hospital districts to directly employ physicians. The pilot allowed each hospital district to hire two physicians, for a total of 20 physicians throughout the state. To qualify for the pilot project, a hospital district was required to have: been in a county with population of 750,000 or less; reported net losses in 2000-01; and, had at least 50% of combined patient days from Medicare, Medi-Cal, and uninsured patients.
SB 376 was sponsored by the Association of California Healthcare Districts, which argued that authorizing the employment of physicians could improve the ability of district hospitals to attract the physicians required to meet the needs of the communities and ensure the continued survival of district hospitals. Proponents hoped direct employment would provide the kind of economic security that might encourage physicians to choose a rural community, just as the State of California is able to offer when it directly hires physicians and staffs its rural prisons.
During the pilot project, five participating hospital districts recruited and hired six physicians, whose employment contract periods ran three to four years. The MBC sent letters to participating physicians, participating administrators, and also administrators in nonparticipating hospital districts to get their views on the project. All six participating physicians were positive about the employment experience. Responding administrators acknowledged it would have been more difficult to recruit the physicians without the employment opportunity, and expressed support of the project. Responding nonparticipating administrators also generally supported the project as a means of recruiting physicians into rural areas. The MBC, in its assessment, stated there was not enough evidence to draw conclusions about the effectiveness of the program, but believed there might be justification to extend the pilot so a comprehensive analysis could be made. The MBC also noted that, “[f]rom the responses received to the Board’s queries about the pilot, there seems to be a universal belief that many physicians hesitate settling in California, especially rural areas of the state, because of the disincentive created by the laws governing the corporate practice of medicine – most physicians in California work as contractors, not employees.”
- AB 2024 (Wood), Chapter 496, Statutes of 2016. The provisions of SB 376 expired in 2011. AB 2024 established an exemption, until January 1, 2024, from the prohibition on CPM in order to allow federally certified CAHs to employ physicians and charge for those services. According to the Department of Health Care Access and Information (HCAI), of the 36 CAHs in California, half have hired physicians between 2017 and 2023, as follows:
- AB 2024 (Wood), Chapter 496, Statutes of 2016. The provisions of SB 376 expired in 2011. AB 2024 established an exemption, until January 1, 2024, from the prohibition on CPM in order to allow federally certified CAHs to employ physicians and charge for those services. According to the Department of Health Care Access and Information (HCAI), of the 36 CAHs in California, half have hired physicians between 2017 and 2023, as follows:
Hospital Name | Total Physician Hires from 2017-23 |
Adventist Health Clearlake (St. Helena Hospital) | 0 |
Adventist Health Mendocino Coast (Mendocino Coast District Hospital) | 0 |
Adventist Health Howard Memorial (Willits Hospital) | 1 |
Adventist Health Tehachapi Valley | 0 |
Bear Valley Healthcare System | 0 |
Banner Hospital | 0 |
Catalina Island Medical Center | 1 |
Colorado River Medical Center | 0 |
Eastern Plumas District Hospital | 2 |
Fairchild Medical Center | 0 |
Glenn Medical Center | 1 |
Hazel Hawkins Memorial Hospital | 0 |
Healdsburg Hospital (North Sonoma Healthcare) | 10 |
Jerold Phelps Community Hospital | 0 |
John C. Fremont Healthcare District | 0 |
Kern Valley Hospital District | 0 |
Mammoth Hospital | 0 |
Mark Twain St. Joseph’s Hospital | 16 |
Mayers Memorial Hospital | 3 |
Mercy Medical Center, Mt. Shasta | 4 |
Modoc Medical Center | 4 |
Northern Inyo Hospital | 0 |
Ojai Valley Community Hospital (Community Memorial Health System) | 2 |
Orchard Hospital | 5 |
Plumas District Hospital | 0 |
Redwood Memorial Hospital | 0 |
Ridgecrest Regional Hospital | 6 |
San Bernardino Mountains Community Hospital District | 1 |
Santa Ynez Valley Cottage Hospital | 3 |
Seneca Healthcare District | 0 |
Southern Inyo Healthcare District | 0 |
Surprise Valley Community Hospital | 0 |
Sutter Lakeside Hospital | 6 |
Tahoe Forest Hospital District | 54 |
Trinity Hospital (Formally Mountain Communities) | 2 |
George L. Mee Memorial Hospital | 2 |
123 |
- SUPPORT. The California Hospital Association (CHA) supports this bill and states that, California continues to face serious challenges meeting the physician needs of its population, particularly in primary care. This challenge is even more pronounced in parts of the state known as HPSAs, which is defined as a geographic area, population, or facility with a shortage of primary care, dental, or mental health providers and services. CHA notes that it is estimated that 28% of California’s population lives in an HPSA and concludes, with this in mind, the CHA strongly supports this bill.
The Association of California Healthcare Districts (ACHD) supports this bill and states that
there are 33 district hospitals in the state of California, 17 of which have critical access designation. Since the enactment of the pilot program under AB 2024, several of these hospitals have successfully used this tool to recruit and retain physicians to underserved areas of the state. Those that have not yet utilized this ability have long awaited its permanency to ensure they would not lose valuable providers once they were employed. ACHD notes that California is facing a severe workforce shortage, of both primary and specialty care providers. The ability to employ physicians allow CAHs to offer benefits and guaranteed salaries, making serving these areas more financially attractive. ACHD concludes that it is essential to closing provider gaps, ensuring Californians continue to receive care in rural and remote communities.
Tahoe Forest Hospital District supports this bill and states that since the enactment of AB 2024, CAHs, including Tahoe Forest Hospital have benefited greatly from the direct hire of primary care and specialty physicians, and this bill will ensure access to high-quality health care is equitable at Tahoe Forest Hospital and hospitals across the state.
- OPPOSE UNLESS AMENDED. The California Medical Association (CMA) is opposed to this bill unless it is amended. CMA notes that in 2016, the author’s bill, AB 2024, established the pilot program and required a report to be created by HCAI to determine the usage and efficacy of the program and its impact on patient care. That report is due in July 2023. CMA states that until HCAI publishes its report regarding the impact the program has had on patient care, they would request that the sunset on the program be extended for five years and not made permanent.
- PREVIOUS LEGISLATION.
- AB 2024 established an exemption, until January 1, 2024, from the prohibition on the CPM in order to allow federally certified critical access hospitals to employ physicians and charge for those services.
- SB 1274 (Wolk), Chapter 793, Statutes of 2012, permits a hospital that is owned and operated by a charitable organization and offers only pediatric subspecialty care to begin billing health carriers for physician services rendered, notwithstanding the prohibition in the CPM if specified conditions are met.
- AB 824 (Chesbro) of 2012 would have established a pilot project to permit certain rural hospitals to directly employ physicians and surgeons. AB 824 was never heard in Assembly Health Committee.
- AB 648 (Chesbro) of 2009 would have established a demonstration project to permit rural hospitals, as defined, whose service area includes a medically underserved or federally designated shortage area and which meet certain specified requirements, to directly employ physicians and surgeons. AB 648 failed passage in the Senate Business, Professions and Economic Development Committee.
- AB 646 (Swanson) of 2009 would have permitted health care districts and certain public hospitals, independent community nonprofit hospitals, and clinics, as specified, to directly employ physicians and surgeons. AB 646 failed passage in the Senate Business, Professions and Economic Development Committee.
- SB 726 (Ashburn) of 2009 would have revised and extended the MBC pilot project that allows qualified district hospitals, as defined, to employ a physician, if the hospital does not interfere with, control, or otherwise direct the professional judgment of the physician. SB 726 failed passage in the Senate Business, Professions and Economic Development Committee.
- AB 1944 (Swanson) of 2008 would have allowed health care districts to employ a physician. AB 1944 failed passage in the Senate Committee on Health.
- SB 1294 (Ducheny) of 2008 would have expanded the pilot project enabling health care districts to directly employ physicians. SB 1294 failed passage in the Assembly Appropriations Committee.
- SB 376 authorized, until January 1, 2011, a hospital owned and operated by a health care district meeting specified criteria to employ a physician, and to charge for professional services rendered by the physician if the physician approves the charges.
- AB 2024 established an exemption, until January 1, 2024, from the prohibition on the CPM in order to allow federally certified critical access hospitals to employ physicians and charge for those services.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
Adventist Health
Association of California Healthcare Districts; the
Avalon Medical Development Corporation
Banner Lassen Medical Center
California Hospital Association
Cottage Health
Dignity Health
District Hospital Leadership Forum
Fairchild Medical Center
Kern Valley Healthcare District
Mee Memorial Healthcare System
Mountain Communities Healthcare District
Providence
Rural County Representatives of California (RCRC)
Sohum Health
Tahoe Forest Hospital District
Opposition
None on file.
Analysis Prepared by: Lara Flynn / HEALTH / (916) 319-2097
Discussed in Hearing
Senate Floor
Senate Standing Committee on Health
Senate Standing Committee on Business, Professions and Economic Development
Assembly Standing Committee on Health
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):