SB 1392: Criminal procedure: competence to stand trial.
- Session Year: 2023-2024
- House: Senate
- Latest Version Date: 2024-02-16
Current Status:
Failed
(2024-04-18: April 23 set for second hearing canceled at the request of author.)
Introduced
In Committee
First Chamber
In Committee
Second Chamber
Enacted
Existing law prohibits a person who is found to be mentally incompetent to stand trial. Existing law requires a court, if a question is raised as to a defendants mental competence, to hold a hearing into the defendants mental competence. Existing law, if a defendant is found incompetent, requires the court to order the defendant to treatment for the restoration of competence. Under existing law, if the defendants competence is restored, the defendant is returned to the court with a certificate of restoration. Under existing law, if a defendants competence is not restored within 2 years of being declared incompetent, the defendant is either subject to conservatorship proceedings or released.
This bill would make the issuance of a certificate of restoration toll the running of that 2-year period. The bill would additionally establish procedures for a trial by court on the question of mental competence of a defendant after a defendant has been issued a certificate of restoration, including, among other things, that the defendant shall be presumed restored to competence unless it is proved by a preponderance of the evidence that the defendant is mentally incompetent.
(a)(1)(A)If the defendant is found mentally competent, the criminal process shall resume, the trial on the offense charged or hearing on the alleged violation shall proceed, and judgment may be pronounced.
(B)If the defendant is found mentally incompetent, the trial, the hearing on the alleged violation, or the judgment shall be suspended until the person becomes mentally competent.
(i)The court shall order that the mentally incompetent defendant be delivered by the sheriff to a State Department of State Hospitals facility, as defined in Section 4100 of the Welfare and Institutions Code, as directed by the State Department of State Hospitals, or to any other available public or private treatment facility, including a community-based residential treatment system approved by the community program director, or their designee, that will promote the defendants speedy restoration to mental competence, or placed on outpatient status as specified in Section 1600.
(ii)However, if the action against the defendant who has been found mentally incompetent is on a complaint charging a felony offense specified in Section 290, the prosecutor shall determine whether the defendant previously has been found mentally incompetent to stand trial pursuant to this chapter on a charge of a Section 290 offense, or whether the defendant is currently the subject of a pending Section 1368 proceeding arising out of a charge of a Section 290 offense. If either determination is made, the prosecutor shall notify the court and defendant in writing. After this notification, and opportunity for hearing, the court shall order that the defendant be delivered by the sheriff to a State Department of State Hospitals facility, as directed by the State Department of State Hospitals, or other secure treatment facility for the care and treatment of persons with a mental health disorder, unless the court makes specific findings on the record that an alternative placement would provide more appropriate treatment for the defendant and would not pose a danger to the health and safety of others.
(iii)If the action against the defendant who has been found mentally incompetent is on a complaint charging a felony offense specified in Section 290 and the defendant has been denied bail pursuant to subdivision (b) of Section 12 of Article I of the California Constitution because the court has found, based upon clear and convincing evidence, a substantial likelihood that the persons release would result in great bodily harm to others, the court shall order that the defendant be delivered by the sheriff to a State Department of State Hospitals facility, as directed by the State Department of State Hospitals, unless the court makes specific findings on the record that an alternative placement would provide more appropriate treatment for the defendant and would not pose a danger to the health and safety of others.
(iv)(I)If, at any time after the court finds that the defendant is mentally incompetent and before the defendant is transported to a facility pursuant to this section, the court is provided with any information that the defendant may benefit from diversion pursuant to Chapter 2.8A (commencing with Section 1001.35) of Title 6, the court may make a finding that the defendant is an appropriate candidate for diversion.
(II)Notwithstanding subclause (I), if a defendant is found mentally incompetent and is transferred to a facility described in Section 4361.6 of the Welfare and Institutions Code, the court may, at any time upon receiving any information that the defendant may benefit from diversion pursuant to Chapter 2.8A (commencing with Section 1001.35) of Title 6, make a finding that the defendant is an appropriate candidate for diversion.
(v)If a defendant is found by the court to be an appropriate candidate for diversion pursuant to clause (iv), the defendants eligibility shall be determined pursuant to Section 1001.36. A defendant granted diversion may participate for the lesser of the period specified in paragraph (1) of subdivision (c) or the applicable period described in subparagraph (C) of paragraph (1) of subdivision (f) of Section 1001.36. If, during that period, the court determines that criminal proceedings should be reinstated pursuant to subdivision (g) of Section 1001.36, the court shall, pursuant to Section 1369, appoint a psychiatrist, licensed psychologist, or any other expert the court may deem appropriate, to determine the defendants competence to stand trial.
(vi)Upon the dismissal of charges at the conclusion of the period of diversion, pursuant to subdivision (h) of Section 1001.36, a defendant shall no longer be deemed incompetent to stand trial pursuant to this section.
(vii)The clerk of the court shall notify the Department of Justice, in writing, of a finding of mental incompetence with respect to a defendant who is subject to clause (ii) or (iii) for inclusion in the defendants state summary criminal history information.
(C)Upon the filing of a certificate of restoration to competence, the court shall order that the defendant be returned to court in accordance with Section 1372. The court shall transmit a copy of its order to the community program director or a designee.
(D)A defendant charged with a violent felony may not be delivered to a State Department of State Hospitals facility or treatment facility pursuant to this subdivision unless the State Department of State Hospitals facility or treatment facility has a secured perimeter or a locked and controlled treatment facility, and the judge determines that the public safety will be protected.
(E)For purposes of this paragraph, violent felony means an offense specified in subdivision (c) of Section 667.5.
(F)A defendant charged with a violent felony may be placed on outpatient status, as specified in Section 1600, only if the court finds that the placement will not pose a danger to the health or safety of others. If the court places a defendant charged with a violent felony on outpatient status, as specified in Section 1600, the court shall serve copies of the placement order on defense counsel, the sheriff in the county where the defendant will be placed, and the district attorney for the county in which the violent felony charges are pending against the defendant.
(G)If, at any time after the court has declared a defendant incompetent to stand trial pursuant to this section, counsel for the defendant or a jail medical or mental health staff provider provides the court with substantial evidence that the defendants psychiatric symptoms have changed to such a degree as to create a doubt in the mind of the judge as to the defendants current mental incompetence, the court may appoint a psychiatrist or a licensed psychologist to opine as to whether the defendant has regained competence. If, in the opinion of that expert, the defendant has regained competence, the court shall proceed as if a certificate of restoration of competence has been returned pursuant to paragraph (1) of subdivision (a) of Section 1372.
(H)(i)The State Department of State Hospitals may, pursuant to Section 4335.2 of the Welfare and Institutions Code, conduct an evaluation of the defendant in county custody to determine any of the following:
(I)The defendant has regained competence.
(II)There is no substantial likelihood that the defendant will regain competence in the foreseeable future.
(III)The defendant should be referred to the county for further evaluation for potential participation in a county diversion program, if one exists, or to another outpatient treatment program.
(ii)If, in the opinion of the departments expert, the defendant has regained competence, the court shall proceed as if a certificate of restoration of competence has been returned pursuant to paragraph (1) of subdivision (a) of Section 1372.
(iii)If, in the opinion of the departments expert, there is no substantial likelihood that the defendant will regain mental competence in the foreseeable future, the committing court shall proceed pursuant to paragraph (2) of subdivision (c) no later than 10 days following receipt of the report.
(2)Prior to making the order directing that the defendant be committed to the State Department of State Hospitals or other treatment facility or placed on outpatient status, the court shall proceed as follows:
(A)(i)The court shall order the community program director or a designee to evaluate the defendant and to submit to the court within 15 judicial days of the order a written recommendation as to whether the defendant should be required to undergo outpatient treatment, or be committed to the State Department of State Hospitals or to any other treatment facility. A person shall not be admitted to a State Department of State Hospitals facility or other treatment facility or placed on outpatient status under this section without having been evaluated by the community program director or a designee. The community program director or designee shall evaluate the appropriate placement for the defendant between a State Department of State Hospitals facility or the community-based residential treatment system based upon guidelines provided by the State Department of State Hospitals.
(ii)Commencing on July 1, 2023, a defendant shall first be considered for placement in an outpatient treatment program, a community treatment program, or a diversion program, if any such program is available, unless a court, based upon the recommendation of the community program director or their designee, finds that either the clinical needs of the defendant or the risk to community safety, warrant placement in a State Department of State Hospitals facility.
(B)The court shall hear and determine whether the defendant lacks capacity to make decisions regarding the administration of antipsychotic medication. The court shall consider opinions in the reports prepared pursuant to subdivision (a) of Section 1369, as applicable to the issue of whether the defendant lacks capacity to make decisions regarding the administration of antipsychotic medication, and shall proceed as follows:
(i)The court shall hear and determine whether any of the following is true:
(I)Based upon the opinion of the psychiatrist or licensed psychologist offered to the court pursuant to subparagraph (A) of paragraph (2) of subdivision (a) of Section 1369, the defendant lacks capacity to make decisions regarding antipsychotic medication, the defendants mental disorder requires medical treatment with antipsychotic medication, and, if the defendants mental disorder is not treated with antipsychotic medication, it is probable that serious harm to the physical or mental health of the defendant will result. Probability of serious harm to the physical or mental health of the defendant requires evidence that the defendant is presently suffering adverse effects to their physical or mental health, or the defendant has previously suffered these effects as a result of a mental disorder and their condition is substantially deteriorating. The fact that a defendant has a diagnosis of a mental disorder does not alone establish probability of serious harm to the physical or mental health of the defendant.
(II)Based upon the opinion of the psychiatrist or licensed psychologist offered to the court pursuant to subparagraph (A) of paragraph (2) of subdivision (a) of Section 1369, the defendant is a danger to others, in that the defendant has inflicted, attempted to inflict, or made a serious threat of inflicting substantial physical harm on another while in custody, or the defendant had inflicted, attempted to inflict, or made a serious threat of inflicting substantial physical harm on another that resulted in the defendant being taken into custody, and the defendant presents, as a result of mental disorder or mental defect, a demonstrated danger of inflicting substantial physical harm on others. Demonstrated danger may be based on an assessment of the defendants present mental condition, including a consideration of past behavior of the defendant within six years prior to the time the defendant last attempted to inflict, inflicted, or threatened to inflict substantial physical harm on another, and other relevant evidence.
(III)The people have charged the defendant with a serious crime against the person or property, and based upon the opinion of the psychiatrist offered to the court pursuant to subparagraph (C) of paragraph (2) of subdivision (a) of Section 1369, the involuntary administration of antipsychotic medication is substantially likely to render the defendant competent to stand trial, the medication is unlikely to have side effects that interfere with the defendants ability to understand the nature of the criminal proceedings or to assist counsel in the conduct of a defense in a reasonable manner, less intrusive treatments are unlikely to have substantially the same results, and antipsychotic medication is medically necessary and appropriate in light of their medical condition.
(ii)(I)If the court finds the conditions described in subclause (I) or (II) of clause (i) to be true, and if pursuant to the opinion offered to the court pursuant to paragraph (2) of subdivision (a) of Section 1369, a psychiatrist has opined that treatment with antipsychotic medications is appropriate for the defendant, the court shall issue an order authorizing the administration of antipsychotic medication as needed, including on an involuntary basis, to be administered under the direction and supervision of a licensed psychiatrist.
(II)If the court finds the conditions described in subclause (I) or (II) of clause (i) to be true, and if pursuant to the opinion offered to the court pursuant to paragraph (2) of subdivision (a) of Section 1369, a licensed psychologist has opined that treatment with antipsychotic medication may be appropriate for the defendant, the court shall issue an order authorizing treatment by a licensed psychiatrist on an involuntary basis. That treatment may include the administration of antipsychotic medication as needed, to be administered under the direction and supervision of a licensed psychiatrist.
(III)If the court finds the conditions described in subclause (III) of clause (i) to be true, and if pursuant to the opinion offered to the court pursuant to paragraph (2) of subdivision (a) of Section 1369, a psychiatrist has opined that it is appropriate to treat the defendant with antipsychotic medication, the court shall issue an order authorizing the administration of antipsychotic medication as needed, including on an involuntary basis, to be administered under the direction and supervision of a licensed psychiatrist.
(iii)An order authorizing involuntary administration of antipsychotic medication to the defendant when and as prescribed by the defendants treating psychiatrist at any facility housing the defendant for purposes of this chapter, including a county jail, shall remain in effect when the defendant returns to county custody pursuant to subparagraph (A) of paragraph (1) of subdivision (b) or paragraph (1) of subdivision (c), or pursuant to subparagraph (C) of paragraph (3) of subdivision (a) of Section 1372, but shall be valid for no more than one year, pursuant to subparagraph (A) of paragraph (7). The court shall not order involuntary administration of psychotropic medication under subclause (III) of clause (i) unless the court has first found that the defendant does not meet the criteria for involuntary administration of psychotropic medication under subclause (I) of clause (i) and does not meet the criteria under subclause (II) of clause (i).
(iv)In all cases, the treating hospital, county jail, facility, or program may administer medically appropriate antipsychotic medication prescribed by a psychiatrist in an emergency as described in subdivision (m) of Section 5008 of the Welfare and Institutions Code.
(v)If the court has determined that the defendant has the capacity to make decisions regarding antipsychotic medication, and if the defendant, with advice of their counsel, consents, the court order of commitment shall include confirmation that antipsychotic medication may be given to the defendant as prescribed by a treating psychiatrist pursuant to the defendants consent. The commitment order shall also indicate that, if the defendant withdraws consent for antipsychotic medication, after the treating psychiatrist complies with the provisions of subparagraph (C), the defendant shall be returned to court for a hearing in accordance with subparagraphs (C) and (D) regarding whether antipsychotic medication shall be administered involuntarily.
(vi)If the court has determined that the defendant has the capacity to make decisions regarding antipsychotic medication and if the defendant, with advice from their counsel, does not consent, the court order for commitment shall indicate that, after the treating psychiatrist complies with the provisions of subparagraph (C), the defendant shall be returned to court for a hearing in accordance with subparagraphs (C) and (D) regarding whether antipsychotic medication shall be administered involuntarily.
(vii)A report made pursuant to paragraph (1) of subdivision (b) shall include a description of antipsychotic medication administered to the defendant and its effects and side effects, including effects on the defendants appearance or behavior that would affect the defendants ability to understand the nature of the criminal proceedings or to assist counsel in the conduct of a defense in a reasonable manner. During the time the defendant is confined in a State Department of State Hospitals facility or other treatment facility or placed on outpatient status, either the defendant or the people may request that the court review any order made pursuant to this subdivision. The defendant, to the same extent enjoyed by other patients in the State Department of State Hospitals facility or other treatment facility, shall have the right to contact the patients rights advocate regarding the defendants rights under this section.
(C)If the defendant consented to antipsychotic medication as described in clause (iv) of subparagraph (B), but subsequently withdraws their consent, or, if involuntary antipsychotic medication was not ordered pursuant to clause (v) of subparagraph (B), and the treating psychiatrist determines that antipsychotic medication has become medically necessary and appropriate, the treating psychiatrist shall make efforts to obtain informed consent from the defendant for antipsychotic medication. If informed consent is not obtained from the defendant, and the treating psychiatrist is of the opinion that the defendant lacks capacity to make decisions regarding antipsychotic medication based on the conditions described in subclause (I) or (II) of clause (i) of subparagraph (B), the treating psychiatrist shall certify whether the lack of capacity and any applicable conditions described above exist. That certification shall contain an assessment of the current mental status of the defendant and the opinion of the treating psychiatrist that involuntary antipsychotic medication has become medically necessary and appropriate.
(D)(i)If the treating psychiatrist certifies that antipsychotic medication has become medically necessary and appropriate pursuant to subparagraph (C), antipsychotic medication may be administered to the defendant for not more than 21 days, provided, however, that, within 72 hours of the certification, the defendant is provided a medication review hearing before an administrative law judge to be conducted at the facility where the defendant is receiving treatment. The treating psychiatrist shall present the case for the certification for involuntary treatment and the defendant shall be represented by an attorney or a patients rights advocate. The attorney or patients rights advocate shall be appointed to meet with the defendant no later than one day prior to the medication review hearing to review the defendants rights at the medication review hearing, discuss the process, answer questions or concerns regarding involuntary medication or the hearing, assist the defendant in preparing for the hearing and advocating for the defendants interests at the hearing, review the panels final determination following the hearing, advise the defendant of their right to judicial review of the panels decision, and provide the defendant with referral information for legal advice on the subject. The defendant shall also have the following rights with respect to the medication review hearing:
(I)To be given timely access to the defendants records.
(II)To be present at the hearing, unless the defendant waives that right.
(III)To present evidence at the hearing.
(IV)To question persons presenting evidence supporting involuntary medication.
(V)To make reasonable requests for attendance of witnesses on the defendants behalf.
(VI)To a hearing conducted in an impartial and informal manner.
(ii)If the administrative law judge determines that the defendant either meets the criteria specified in subclause (I) of clause (i) of subparagraph (B), or meets the criteria specified in subclause (II) of clause (i) of subparagraph (B), antipsychotic medication may continue to be administered to the defendant for the 21-day certification period. Concurrently with the treating psychiatrists certification, the treating psychiatrist shall file a copy of the certification and a petition with the court for issuance of an order to administer antipsychotic medication beyond the 21-day certification period. For purposes of this subparagraph, the treating psychiatrist shall not be required to pay or deposit any fee for the filing of the petition or other document or paper related to the petition.
(iii)If the administrative law judge disagrees with the certification, medication may not be administered involuntarily until the court determines that antipsychotic medication should be administered pursuant to this section.
(iv)The court shall provide notice to the prosecuting attorney and to the attorney representing the defendant, and shall hold a hearing, no later than 18 days from the date of the certification, to determine whether antipsychotic medication should be ordered beyond the certification period.
(v)If, as a result of the hearing, the court determines that antipsychotic medication should be administered beyond the certification period, the court shall issue an order authorizing the administration of that medication.
(vi)The court shall render its decision on the petition and issue its order no later than three calendar days after the hearing and, in any event, no later than the expiration of the 21-day certification period.
(vii)If the administrative law judge upholds the certification pursuant to clause (ii), the court may, for a period not to exceed 14 days, extend the certification and continue the hearing pursuant to stipulation between the parties or upon a finding of good cause. In determining good cause, the court may review the petition filed with the court, the administrative law judges order, and any additional testimony needed by the court to determine if it is appropriate to continue medication beyond the 21-day certification and for a period of up to 14 days.
(viii)The district attorney, county counsel, or representative of a facility where a defendant found incompetent to stand trial is committed may petition the court for an order to administer involuntary medication pursuant to the criteria set forth in subclauses (II) and (III) of clause (i) of subparagraph (B). The order is reviewable as provided in paragraph (7).
(3)When the court orders that the defendant be committed to a State Department of State Hospitals facility or other public or private treatment facility, the court shall provide copies of the following documents prior to the admission of the defendant to the State Department of State Hospitals or other treatment facility where the defendant is to be committed:
(A)The commitment order, which shall include a specification of the charges, an assessment of whether involuntary treatment with antipsychotic medications is warranted, and any orders by the court, pursuant to subparagraph (B) of paragraph (2), authorizing involuntary treatment with antipsychotic medications.
(B)A computation or statement setting forth the maximum term of commitment in accordance with subdivision (c).
(C)(i)A computation or statement setting forth the amount of credit for time served, if any, to be deducted from the maximum term of commitment.
(ii)If a certificate of restoration of competency was filed with the court pursuant to Section 1372 and the court subsequently rejected the certification, a copy of the court order or minute order rejecting the certification shall be provided. The court order shall include a new computation or statement setting forth the amount of credit for time served, if any, to be deducted from the defendants maximum term of commitment based on the courts rejection of the certification.(D)State summary criminal history information.
(E)Jail classification records for the defendants current incarceration.
(F)Arrest reports prepared by the police department or other law enforcement agency.
(G)Court-ordered psychiatric examination or evaluation reports.
(H)The community program directors placement recommendation report.
(I)Records of a finding of mental incompetence pursuant to this chapter arising out of a complaint charging a felony offense specified in Section 290 or a pending Section 1368 proceeding arising out of a charge of a Section 290 offense.
(J)Medical records, including jail mental health records.
(4)When the defendant is committed to a treatment facility pursuant to clause (i) of subparagraph (B) of paragraph (1) or the court makes the findings specified in clause (ii) or (iii) of subparagraph (B) of paragraph (1) to assign the defendant to a treatment facility other than a State Department of State Hospitals facility or other secure treatment facility, the court shall order that notice be given to the appropriate law enforcement agency or agencies having local jurisdiction at the placement facility of a finding of mental incompetence pursuant to this chapter arising out of a charge of a Section 290 offense.
(5)When directing that the defendant be confined in a State Department of State Hospitals facility pursuant to this subdivision, the court shall commit the defendant to the State Department of State Hospitals.
(6)(A)If the defendant is committed or transferred to the State Department of State Hospitals pursuant to this section, the court may, upon receiving the written recommendation of the medical director of the State Department of State Hospitals facility and the community program director that the defendant be transferred to a public or private treatment facility approved by the community program director, order the defendant transferred to that facility. If the defendant is committed or transferred to a public or private treatment facility approved by the community program director, the court may, upon receiving the written recommendation of the community program director, transfer the defendant to the State Department of State Hospitals or to another public or private treatment facility approved by the community program director. In the event of dismissal of the criminal charges before the defendant recovers competence, the person shall be subject to the applicable provisions of the Lanterman-Petris-Short Act (Part 1 (commencing with Section 5000) of Division 5 of the Welfare and Institutions Code). If either the defendant or the prosecutor chooses to contest either kind of order of transfer, a petition may be filed in the court for a hearing, which shall be held if the court determines that sufficient grounds exist. At the hearing, the prosecuting attorney or the defendant may present evidence bearing on the order of transfer. The court shall use the same standards as are used in conducting probation revocation hearings pursuant to Section 1203.2.
Prior to making an order for transfer under this section, the court shall notify the defendant, the attorney of record for the defendant, the prosecuting attorney, and the community program director or a designee.
(B)If the defendant is initially committed to a State Department of State Hospitals facility or secure treatment facility pursuant to clause (ii) or (iii) of subparagraph (B) of paragraph (1) and is subsequently transferred to any other facility, copies of the documents specified in paragraph (3) shall be electronically transferred or taken with the defendant to each subsequent facility to which the defendant is transferred. The transferring facility shall also notify the appropriate law enforcement agency or agencies having local jurisdiction at the site of the new facility that the defendant is a person subject to clause (ii) or (iii) of subparagraph (B) of paragraph (1).
(7)(A)An order by the court authorizing involuntary medication of the defendant shall be valid for no more than one year. The court shall review the order at the time of the review of the initial report and the six-month progress reports pursuant to paragraph (1) of subdivision (b) to determine if the grounds for the authorization remain. In the review, the court shall consider the reports of the treating psychiatrist or psychiatrists and the defendants patients rights advocate or attorney. The court may require testimony from the treating psychiatrist and the patients rights advocate or attorney, if necessary. The court may continue the order authorizing involuntary medication for up to another six months, or vacate the order, or make any other appropriate order.
(B)Within 60 days before the expiration of the one-year involuntary medication order, the district attorney, county counsel, or representative of any facility where a defendant found incompetent to stand trial is committed may petition the committing court for a renewal, subject to the same conditions and requirements as in subparagraph (A). The petition shall include the basis for involuntary medication set forth in clause (i) of subparagraph (B) of paragraph (2). Notice of the petition shall be provided to the defendant, the defendants attorney, and the district attorney. The court shall hear and determine whether the defendant continues to meet the criteria set forth in clause (i) of subparagraph (B) of paragraph (2). The hearing on a petition to renew an order for involuntary medication shall be conducted prior to the expiration of the current order.
(8)For purposes of subparagraph (D) of paragraph (2) and paragraph (7), if the treating psychiatrist determines that there is a need, based on preserving their rapport with the defendant or preventing harm, the treating psychiatrist may request that the facility medical director designate another psychiatrist to act in the place of the treating psychiatrist. If the medical director of the facility designates another psychiatrist to act pursuant to this paragraph, the treating psychiatrist shall brief the acting psychiatrist of the relevant facts of the case and the acting psychiatrist shall examine the defendant prior to the hearing.
(b)(1)Within 90 days after a commitment made pursuant to subdivision (a), the medical director of the State Department of State Hospitals facility or other treatment facility to which the defendant is confined shall make a written report to the court and the community program director for the county or region of commitment, or a designee, concerning the defendants progress toward recovery of mental competence and whether the administration of antipsychotic medication remains necessary.
If the defendant is in county custody, the county jail shall provide access to the defendant for purposes of the State Department of State Hospitals conducting an evaluation of the defendant pursuant to Section 4335.2 of the Welfare and Institutions Code. Based upon this evaluation, the State Department of State Hospitals may make a written report to the court within 90 days of a commitment made pursuant to subdivision (a) concerning the defendants progress toward recovery of mental incompetence and whether the administration of antipsychotic medication is necessary. If the defendant remains in county custody after the initial 90-day report, the State Department of State Hospitals may conduct an evaluation of the defendant pursuant to Section 4335.2 of the Welfare and Institutions Code and make a written report to the court concerning the defendants progress toward recovery of mental incompetence and whether the administration of antipsychotic medication is necessary.
If the defendant is on outpatient status, the outpatient treatment staff shall make a written report to the community program director concerning the defendants progress toward recovery of mental competence. Within 90 days of placement on outpatient status, the community program director shall report to the court on this matter. If the defendant has not recovered mental competence, but the report discloses a substantial likelihood that the defendant will regain mental competence in the foreseeable future, the defendant shall remain in the State Department of State Hospitals facility or other treatment facility or on outpatient status. Thereafter, at six-month intervals or until the defendant becomes mentally competent, if the defendant is confined in a treatment facility, the medical director of the State Department of State Hospitals facility or person in charge of the facility shall report, in writing, to the court and the community program director or a designee regarding the defendants progress toward recovery of mental competence and whether the administration of antipsychotic medication remains necessary. If the defendant is on outpatient status, after the initial 90-day report, the outpatient treatment staff shall report to the community program director on the defendants progress toward recovery, and the community program director shall report to the court on this matter at six-month intervals. A copy of these reports shall be provided to the prosecutor and defense counsel by the court.
(A)If the report indicates that there is no substantial likelihood that the defendant will regain mental competence in the foreseeable future, custody of the defendant shall be transferred without delay to the committing county and shall remain with the county until further order of the court. The defendant shall be returned to the court for proceedings pursuant to paragraph (2) of subdivision (c) no later than 10 days following receipt of the report. The court shall not order the defendant returned to the custody of the State Department of State Hospitals under the same commitment. The court shall transmit a copy of its order to the community program director or a designee.
(B)If the report indicates that there is no substantial likelihood that the defendant will regain mental competence in the foreseeable future, the medical director of the State Department of State Hospitals facility or other treatment facility to which the defendant is confined shall do both of the following:
(i)Promptly notify and provide a copy of the report to the defense counsel and the district attorney.
(ii)Provide a separate notification, in compliance with applicable privacy laws, to the committing countys sheriff that immediate transportation will be needed for the defendant pursuant to subparagraph (A).
(C)If a county does not take custody of a defendant committed to the State Department of State Hospitals within 10 calendar days following notification made pursuant to clause (ii) of subparagraph (B), the county shall be charged the daily rate for a state hospital bed, as established by the State Department of State Hospitals.
(2)The reports made pursuant to paragraph (1) concerning the defendants progress toward regaining competency shall also consider the issue of involuntary medication. Each report shall include, but not be limited to, all of the following:
(A)Whether or not the defendant has the capacity to make decisions concerning antipsychotic medication.
(B)If the defendant lacks capacity to make decisions concerning antipsychotic medication, whether the defendant risks serious harm to their physical or mental health if not treated with antipsychotic medication.
(C)Whether or not the defendant presents a danger to others if the defendant is not treated with antipsychotic medication.
(D)Whether the defendant has a mental disorder for which medications are the only effective treatment.
(E)Whether there are any side effects from the medication currently being experienced by the defendant that would interfere with the defendants ability to collaborate with counsel.
(F)Whether there are any effective alternatives to medication.
(G)How quickly the medication is likely to bring the defendant to competency.
(H)Whether the treatment plan includes methods other than medication to restore the defendant to competency.
(I)A statement, if applicable, that no medication is likely to restore the defendant to competency.
(3)After reviewing the reports, the court shall determine if grounds for the involuntary administration of antipsychotic medication exist, whether or not an order was issued at the time of commitment, and shall do one of the following:
(A)If the original grounds for involuntary medication still exist, any order authorizing the treating facility to involuntarily administer antipsychotic medication to the defendant shall remain in effect.
(B)If the original grounds for involuntary medication no longer exist, and there is no other basis for involuntary administration of antipsychotic medication, any order for the involuntary administration of antipsychotic medication shall be vacated.
(C)If the original grounds for involuntary medication no longer exist, and the report states that there is another basis for involuntary administration of antipsychotic medication, the court shall determine whether to vacate the order or issue a new order for the involuntary administration of antipsychotic medication. The court shall consider the opinions in reports submitted pursuant to paragraph (1) of subdivision (b), including any opinions rendered pursuant to Section 4335.2 of the Welfare and Institutions Code. The court may, upon a showing of good cause, set a hearing within 21 days to determine whether the order for the involuntary administration of antipsychotic medication shall be vacated or whether a new order for the involuntary administration of antipsychotic medication shall be issued. The hearing shall proceed as set forth in subparagraph (B) of paragraph (2) of subdivision (a). The court shall require witness testimony to occur remotely, including clinical testimony pursuant to subdivision (d) of Section 4335.2 of the Welfare and Institutions Code. In-person witness testimony shall only be allowed upon a courts finding of good cause.
(D)If the report states a basis for involuntary administration of antipsychotic medication and the court did not issue such order at the time of commitment, the court shall determine whether to issue an order for the involuntary administration of antipsychotic medication. The court shall consider the opinions in reports submitted pursuant to paragraph (1) of subdivision (b), including any opinions rendered pursuant to Section 4335.2 of the Welfare and Institutions Code. The court may, upon a finding of good cause, set a hearing within 21 days to determine whether an order for the involuntary administration of antipsychotic medication shall be issued. The hearing shall proceed as set forth in subparagraph (B) of paragraph (2) of subdivision (a). The court shall require witness testimony to occur remotely, including clinical testimony pursuant to subdivision (d) of Section 4335.2 of the Welfare and Institutions Code. In-person witness testimony shall only be allowed upon a courts finding of good cause.
(4)If it is determined by the court that treatment for the defendants mental impairment is not being conducted, the defendant shall be returned to the committing court, and, if the defendant is not in county custody, returned to the custody of the county. The court shall transmit a copy of its order to the community program director or a designee.
(5)At each review by the court specified in this subdivision, the court shall determine if the security level of housing and treatment is appropriate and may make an order in accordance with its determination. If the court determines that the defendant shall continue to be treated in the State Department of State Hospitals facility or on an outpatient basis, the court shall determine issues concerning administration of antipsychotic medication, as set forth in subparagraph (B) of paragraph (2) of subdivision (a).
(c)(1)At the end of two years from the date of commitment or a period of commitment equal to the maximum term of imprisonment provided by law for the most serious offense charged in the information, indictment, or complaint, or the maximum term of imprisonment provided by law for a violation of probation or mandatory supervision, whichever is shorter, but no later than 90 days prior to the expiration of the defendants term of commitment, a defendant who has not recovered mental competence shall be returned to the committing court, and custody of the defendant shall be transferred without delay to the committing county and shall remain with the county until further order of the court. The court shall not order the defendant returned to the custody of the State Department of State Hospitals under the same commitment. The court shall notify the community program director or a designee of the return and of any resulting court orders.
(2)(A)The medical director of the State Department of State Hospitals facility or other treatment facility to which the defendant is confined shall provide notification, in compliance with applicable privacy laws, to the committing countys sheriff that immediate transportation will be needed for the defendant pursuant to paragraph (1).
(B)If a county does not take custody of a defendant committed to the State Department of State Hospitals within 10 calendar days following notification pursuant to subparagraph (A), the county shall be charged the daily rate for a state hospital bed, as established by the State Department of State Hospitals.
(3)Whenever a defendant is returned to the court pursuant to paragraph (1) or (4) of subdivision (b) or paragraph (1) of this subdivision and it appears to the court that the defendant is gravely disabled, as defined in subparagraph (A) or (B) of paragraph (1) of subdivision (h) of Section 5008 of the Welfare and Institutions Code, the court shall order the conservatorship investigator of the county of commitment of the defendant to initiate conservatorship proceedings for the defendant pursuant to Chapter 3 (commencing with Section 5350) of Part 1 of Division 5 of the Welfare and Institutions Code. Hearings required in the conservatorship proceedings shall be held in the superior court in the county that ordered the commitment. The court shall transmit a copy of the order directing initiation of conservatorship proceedings to the community program director or a designee, the sheriff and the district attorney of the county in which criminal charges are pending, and the defendants counsel of record. The court shall notify the community program director or a designee, the sheriff and district attorney of the county in which criminal charges are pending, and the defendants counsel of record of the outcome of the conservatorship proceedings.
(4)If a change in placement is proposed for a defendant who is committed pursuant to subparagraph (A) or (B) of paragraph (1) of subdivision (h) of Section 5008 of the Welfare and Institutions Code, the court shall provide notice and an opportunity to be heard with respect to the proposed placement of the defendant to the sheriff and the district attorney of the county in which the criminal charges or revocation proceedings are pending.
(5)If the defendant is confined in a treatment facility, a copy of any report to the committing court regarding the defendants progress toward recovery of mental competence shall be provided by the committing court to the prosecutor and to the defense counsel.
(d)With the exception of proceedings alleging a violation of mandatory supervision, the criminal action remains subject to dismissal pursuant to Section 1385. If the criminal action is dismissed, the court shall transmit a copy of the order of dismissal to the community program director or a designee. In a proceeding alleging a violation of mandatory supervision, if the person is not placed under a conservatorship as described in paragraph (3) of subdivision (c), or if a conservatorship is terminated, the court shall reinstate mandatory supervision and may modify the terms and conditions of supervision to include appropriate mental health treatment or refer the matter to a local mental health court, reentry court, or other collaborative justice court available for improving the mental health of the defendant.
(e)If the criminal action against the defendant is dismissed, the defendant shall be released from commitment ordered under this section, but without prejudice to the initiation of proceedings that may be appropriate under the Lanterman-Petris-Short Act (Part 1 (commencing with Section 5000) of Division 5 of the Welfare and Institutions Code).
(f)As used in this chapter, community program director means the person, agency, or entity designated by the State Department of State Hospitals pursuant to Section 1605 of this code and Section 4360 of the Welfare and Institutions Code.
(g)For the purpose of this section, secure treatment facility does not include, except for State Department of State Hospitals facilities, state developmental centers, and correctional treatment facilities, any facility licensed pursuant to Chapter 2 (commencing with Section 1250) of, Chapter 3 (commencing with Section 1500) of, or Chapter 3.2 (commencing with Section 1569) of, Division 2 of the Health and Safety Code, or any community board and care facility.
(h)This section does not preclude a defendant from filing a petition for habeas corpus to challenge the continuing validity of an order authorizing a treatment facility or outpatient program to involuntarily administer antipsychotic medication to a person being treated as incompetent to stand trial.
SEC. 2.Section 1372 of the Penal Code is amended to read:1372.(a)(1)If the medical director of a state hospital, a person designated by the State Department of State Hospitals at an entity contracted by the department to provide services to a defendant prior to placement in a treatment program or other facility to which the defendant is committed, or the community program director, county mental health director, or regional center director providing outpatient services, determines that the defendant has regained mental competence, the director or designee shall immediately certify that fact to the court by filing a certificate of restoration with the court by certified mail, return receipt requested, or by confidential electronic transmission. This shall include any certificate of restoration filed by the State Department of State Hospitals based on an evaluation conducted pursuant to Section 4335.2 of the Welfare and Institutions Code. For purposes of this section, the date of filing shall be the date on the return receipt.
(2)The courts order committing an individual to a State Department of State Hospitals facility or other treatment facility pursuant to Section 1370 shall include direction that the sheriff shall redeliver the patient to the court without any further order from the court upon receiving from the state hospital or treatment facility a copy of the certificate of restoration.
(3)The defendant shall be returned to the committing court in the following manner, except that a defendant in county custody that the State Department of State Hospitals has evaluated pursuant to Section 4335.2 of the Welfare and Institutions Code and filed a certificate of restoration with the court shall remain in county custody:
(A)A patient who remains confined in a state hospital or other treatment facility shall be redelivered to the sheriff of the county from which the patient was committed. The sheriff shall immediately return the person from the state hospital or other treatment facility to the court for further proceedings.
(B)The patient who is on outpatient status shall be returned by the sheriff to court through arrangements made by the outpatient treatment supervisor.
(C)In all cases, the patient shall be returned to the committing court no later than 10 days following the filing of a certificate of restoration. The state shall only pay for 10 hospital days for patients following the filing of a certificate of restoration of competency. The State Department of State Hospitals shall report to the fiscal and appropriate policy committees of the Legislature on an annual basis in February, on the number of days that exceed the 10-day limit prescribed in this subparagraph. This report shall include, but not be limited to, a data sheet that itemizes by county the number of days that exceed this 10-day limit during the preceding year.
(b)If the defendant becomes mentally competent after a conservatorship has been established pursuant to the applicable provisions of the Lanterman-Petris-Short Act, Part 1 (commencing with Section 5000) of Division 5 of the Welfare and Institutions Code, and Section 1370, the conservator shall certify that fact to the sheriff and district attorney of the county in which the defendants case is pending, defendants attorney of record, and the committing court.
(c) (1) When a defendant is returned to court with a certification that competence has been regained, including a certification of restoration provided pursuant to Section 4335.2 of the Welfare and Institutions Code, the court shall notify either the community program director, the county mental health director, the State Department of State Hospitals, or the regional center director and the Director of Developmental Services, as appropriate, of the date of any hearing on the defendants competence and whether or not the defendant was found by the court to have recovered competence.
(2)If the court rejects a certificate of restoration, the court shall base its rejection on a written report of an evaluation, conducted by a licensed psychologist or psychiatrist, that the defendant is not competent. The evaluation shall be conducted after the certificate of restoration is filed with the committing court and in compliance with Section 1369. A copy of the written report shall be provided to the department pursuant to paragraph (3) of subdivision (a) of Section 1370. The court shall also provide a copy of the court order or minute order rejecting the certification of restoration to the department, pursuant to clause (ii) of subparagraph (C) of paragraph (3) of subdivision (a) of Section 1370, including any minute orders continuing the hearing for the courts determination.
(d)If the committing court approves the certificate of restoration to competence as to a person in custody, the court shall notify the State Department of State Hospitals by providing the State Department of State Hospitals with a copy of the court order or minute order approving the certificate of restoration to competence. The court shall hold a hearing to determine whether the person is entitled to be admitted to bail or released on own recognizance status pending conclusion of the proceedings. If the superior court approves the certificate of restoration to competence regarding a person on outpatient status, unless it appears that the person has refused to come to court, that person shall remain released either on own recognizance status, or, in the case of a developmentally disabled person, either on the defendants promise or on the promise of a responsible adult to secure the persons appearance in court for further proceedings. If the person has refused to come to court, the court shall set bail and may place the person in custody until bail is posted.
(e)A defendant subject to either subdivision (a) or (b) who is not admitted to bail or released under subdivision (d) may, at the discretion of the court, upon recommendation of the director of the facility where the defendant is receiving treatment, be returned to the hospital or facility of their original commitment or other appropriate secure facility approved by the community program director, the county mental health director, or the regional center director. The recommendation submitted to the court shall be based on the opinion that the person will need continued treatment in a hospital or treatment facility in order to maintain competence to stand trial or that placing the person in a jail environment would create a substantial risk that the person would again become incompetent to stand trial before criminal proceedings could be resumed.
(f)Notwithstanding subdivision (e), if a defendant is returned by the court to a hospital or other facility for the purpose of maintaining competency to stand trial and that defendant is already under civil commitment to that hospital or facility from another county pursuant to the Lanterman-Petris-Short Act (Part 1 (commencing with Section 5000) of Division 5 of the Welfare and Institutions Code) or as a developmentally disabled person committed pursuant to Article 2 (commencing with Section 6500) of Chapter 2 of Part 2 of Division 6 of the Welfare and Institutions Code, the costs of housing and treating the defendant in that facility following return pursuant to subdivision (e) shall be the responsibility of the original county of civil commitment.
(g)The issuance of a certificate of restoration of competence shall toll the running of the period of commitment.
(h)Section 1372.1 shall govern the procedure for the defendants restoration of competency hearing after the issuance of a certificate of restoration.
SEC. 3.Section 1372.1 is added to the Penal Code, to read:1372.1.A trial by court of the question of mental competence after a defendant has been issued a certificate of restoration shall proceed in the following order:
(a)(1)If the defendants counsel informs the court that the defense is not seeking a finding of mental incompetence, the court may approve a certificate of restoration filed in accordance with subdivision (d) of Section 1372.
(2)If the defendants counsel informs the court that the defense is seeking a finding of mental incompetence, the court shall appoint a licensed psychologist or psychiatrist to examine the defendant. The examining licensed psychologist or psychiatrist shall evaluate the nature of the defendants mental disorder, if any, the defendants ability or inability to understand the nature of the criminal proceedings, and the defendants ability to assist counsel in the conduct of a defense in a rational manner as a result of a mental disorder. This evaluation shall be a prerequisite to the court approving or rejecting a certificate of restoration pursuant to paragraph (2) of subdivision (c) of, or subdivision (d) of, Section 1372.
(3)If the court, in its discretion, believes that the defendant may not be competent, regardless of whether the defense is seeking a finding of mental incompetence, the court shall appoint a licensed psychologist or psychiatrist to examine the defendant consistent with the provisions of subdivision (b). This evaluation shall be a prerequisite to the court rejecting a certificate of restoration pursuant to paragraph (2) of subdivision (c) of Section 1372.
(4)Any licensed psychologist or psychiatrist appointed pursuant to this section shall meet the guidelines established pursuant to subdivision (h) of Section 1369.
(b)The counsel for the defendant shall offer evidence in support of the allegation of mental incompetence.
(c)The prosecution may present its case regarding the issue of the defendants present mental competence. The prosecution may submit on the certificate of restoration or may present additional evidence.
(d)Each party may offer rebutting testimony, unless the court, for good cause in the furtherance of justice, also permits other evidence in support of the original contention.
(e)When the evidence is concluded, unless the case is submitted without final argument, the prosecution shall make its final argument and the defense shall conclude with its final argument to the court.
(f)It shall be presumed that the defendant has been restored to competence unless it is proved by a preponderance of the evidence that the defendant is mentally incompetent.
(g)This section does not preclude the defense and prosecution from submitting on the certificate of restoration.
(h)This section does not preclude the parties from privately retaining an evaluator at their own expense.
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Apr 18, 2024 | April 23 set for second hearing canceled at the request of author. |
| Apr 11, 2024 | Set for hearing April 23. |
| Apr 9, 2024 | April 9 set for first hearing canceled at the request of author. |
| Mar 13, 2024 | Set for hearing April 9. |
| Feb 29, 2024 | Referred to Com. on PUB S. |
| Feb 20, 2024 | From printer. May be acted upon on or after March 18. |
| Feb 16, 2024 | Introduced. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. To print. |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
SENATE COMMITTEE ON PUBLIC SAFETY
Senator Aisha Wahab, Chair
2023 - 2024 Regular
Bill No: SB 1392 Hearing Date: April 9, 2024
Author: | Stern | ||
Version: | February 16, 2024 | ||
Urgency: | No | Fiscal: | Yes |
Consultant: | SC | ||
Subject: Criminal procedure: competence to stand trial
HISTORY
Source: Author
Prior Legislation: SB 349 (Roth), held Assem. Public Safety, 2023
SB 1187 (Beall), Ch. 1008, Stats. 2018
AB 1529 (Murphy), Ch. 1511, Stats. 1974
Support: California District Attorney Association
Opposition: Disability Rights California
PURPOSE
The purpose of this bill is to toll the running of the maximum term of commitment for defendants found to be incompetent to stand trial upon the issuance of a certificate of restoration of competency.
Existing law states that a person cannot be tried or adjudged to punishment or have his or her probation, mandatory supervision, postrelease community supervision, or parole revoked while that person is mentally incompetent. (Pen. Code § 1367, subd. (a).)
Existing law requires, when counsel has declared a doubt as to the defendant’s competence, the court to hold a hearing determine whether the defendant is incompetent to stand trial (IST). (Pen. Code § 1368, subd. (b).)
Existing law provides that, except as provided, when an order for a hearing into the present mental competence of the defendant has been issued, all proceedings in the criminal prosecution shall be suspended until the question of whether the defendant is IST is determined. (Pen. Code § 1368, subd. (c).)
Existing law states that a person who has been found to be IST may be eligible for mental health diversion. (Pen. Code, § 1001.36, subd. (b)(1)(D).)
Existing law specifies how the trial on the issue of mental competency shall proceed. (Pen. Code § 1369.)
Existing law requires the court to appoint a psychiatrist or licensed psychologist, and any other expert the court may deem appropriate, to examine the defendant. (Pen. Code, § 1369, subd. (a)(1).)
Existing law provides that if the defendant or defendant’s counsel informs the court that the defendant is not seeking a finding of mental incompetence, the court shall appoint two psychiatrists, licensed psychologists, or a combination thereof. One of the psychiatrists or licensed psychologists may be named by the defense and one may be named by the prosecution. (Pen. Code, § 1369, subd. (a)(1).)
Existing law states that in a jury trial, the court shall charge the jury, instructing them on all matters of law necessary for the rendering of a verdict. It shall be presumed that the defendant is mentally competent unless it is proved by a preponderance of the evidence that the defendant is mentally incompetent. The verdict of the jury shall be unanimous. (Pen. Code, §1369, subd. (f).)
Existing law states that only a court trial is required to determine competency in a proceeding for a violation of probation, mandatory supervision, postrelease community supervision, or parole. (Pen Code, § 1369, subd. (g).)
Existing law provides that if the defendant is found mentally competent, the criminal process shall resume. If the defendant has been found mentally incompetent, the trial, the hearing on the alleged violation, or the judgment shall be suspended until the person becomes mentally competent. (Pen. Code § 1370, subd. (a).)
Existing law requires the court to order an IST defendant to be delivered by the sheriff to a State Department of State Hospitals (DSH), or to any other available public or private treatment facility, including a community based residential treatment system approved by the community program director, or their designee, that will promote the defendant’s speedy restoration to mental competence, or placed on outpatient status. (Pen. Code § 1370, subd. (a)(1)(B)(i).)
Existing law provides that if, at any time after the court finds that the defendant is IST and before the defendant is transported to a facility, the court is provided with any information that the defendant may benefit from mental health diversion, the court may make a finding that the defendant is an appropriate candidate for diversion. (Pen. Code § 1370, subd. (a)(1)(B)(iv).)
Existing law states that upon a filing of a certificate of restoration to competence, the court shall order the defendant to be returned to court in accordance with Penal Code section 1372. (Pen. Code § 1370, subd. (a)(1)(C).)
Existing law states that when the court orders the defendant to be committed to DSH or other public or private treatment facility, the court shall provide copies of the following documents prior to the admission of the defendant:
- The commitment order, which shall include specification of charges, an assessment of whether involuntary treatment with antipsychotic medications is warranted, and any other orders by the court authorizing involuntary treatment with antipsychotic medications;
- A computation or statement setting forth the maximum term of commitment;
- A computation or statement setting forth the amount of credit for time served, if any, to be deducted from the maximum term of commitment. (Pen. Code § 1370, subd. (a)(3).)
Existing law provides that if a certificate of restoration of competency was filed with the court and the court subsequently rejected the certification, a copy of the court order or minute order rejecting the certification shall be provided. The court order shall include a new computation or statement setting forth the amount of credit for time served, if any, to be deducted from the defendant’s maximum term of commitment based on the court’s rejection of the certification. (Pen. Code § 1370, subd. (a)(3)(C)(ii).)
This bill deletes the above provision.
Existing law states that at the end of two years from the date of commitment or a period of commitment equal to the maximum term of imprisonment provided by law for the most serious offense charged, whichever is shorter, but no later than 90 days prior to the expiration of the defendant’s term of commitment, a defendant who has not recovered mental competence shall be returned to the committing court, and custody of the defendant shall be transferred without delay to the committing county. The court shall not order the defendant returned to the custody of DSH. (Pen. Code, §1370, subd. (c)(1).)
Existing law states that if the medical director of a state hospital or designated person at an entity contracted by DSH to provide services to a defendant prior to placement in a treatment program or other facility to which the defendant is committed, or the community program director, county mental health director, or regional center director providing outpatient services, determines that the defendant has regained mental competence, the director or designee shall immediately certify that fact to the court by filing a certificate of restoration with the court by certified mail, return receipt requested, or by confidential electronic transmission. (Pen. Code, § 1372, subd. (a)(1).)
Existing law provides that the court’s order committing an individual to a DSH facility or other treatment facility shall include direction that the sheriff shall redeliver the patient to the court without any further order from the court upon receiving from the state hospital or treatment facility a copy of the certificate of restoration. (Pen. Code, § 1372, subd. (a)(2).)
Existing law states that the defendant shall be returned to the committing court no later than 10 days after the filing of a certificate of restoration of competency as follows:
- A patient who remains confined in a state hospital or other treatment facility shall be redelivered to the sheriff of the county from which the patient was committed. The sheriff shall immediately return the person from the state hospital or other treatment facility to the court for further proceedings.
- The patient who is on outpatient status shall be returned by the sheriff to court through arrangements made by the outpatient treatment supervisor. (Pen. Code, § 1372, subd. (a)(3).)
Existing law states that when a defendant is returned to court with a certification that competence has been regained, including upon reevaluation by DSH, the court shall notify either the community program director, the county mental health director, DSH, or the regional center director and the Director of Developmental Services, as appropriate, of the date of any hearing on the defendant’s competence and whether or not the defendant was found by the court to have recovered competence. (Pen. Code, § 1372, subd. (c)(1).)
Existing law states that if the court rejects a certificate of restoration, the court shall base its rejection on a written report of an evaluation, conducted by a licensed psychologist or psychiatrist, that the defendant is not competent. The evaluation shall be conducted after the certificate of restoration is filed with the committing court as specified. A copy of the report as well as a copy of the court order or minute order rejecting the certificate of restoration to DSH, including any order continuing the hearing for the court’s determination. (Pen. Code, § 1372, subd. (c)(2).)
Existing law provides that if the committing court approves the certificate of restoration to competency as to a person in custody, the court shall notify DSH by providing a copy of the court order or minute order approving the certificate of restoration to competence. The court shall hold a hearing to determine whether the person is entitled to be admitted to bail or released on own recognizance pending conclusion of the proceedings. (Pen. Code, § 1372, subd. (d).)
Existing law states that if the court approves the certificate of restoration to competency on outpatient status, unless it appears that the person has refused to come to court, that person shall remain on outpatient status, or, in the case of a developmentally disabled person, either on the defendant’s promise or on the promise of a responsible adult to secure the person’s appearance in court for further proceedings. If the person has refused to come to court, the court shall set bail and may place the person in custody until bail is posted. (Pen. Code, § 1372, subd. (d).)
Existing law states that a person who has been restored to competence who is not admitted to bail or released on own recognizance may, at the discretion of the court, upon recommendation of the director of the facility where the defendant is receiving treatment, be returned to the hospital or facility of their original commitment in order to receive continued treatment to maintain competence to stand trial. (Pen. Code, § 1372, subd. (e).)
This bill states that the issuance of a certificate of restoration of competence shall toll the running of the period of commitment.
This bill provides that the procedure for defendant’s restoration of competency hearing after the issuance of a certificate of restoration shall proceed as follows:
- The question of defendant’s mental competence shall be determined by a court trial;
- If the defendant’s counsel informs the court that the defense is not seeking a finding of mental incompetence, the court may approve a certificate of restoration;
- If the defendant’s counsel informs the court that the defense is seeking a finding of mental incompetence, the court shall appoint a licensed psychologist or psychiatrist to examine the defendant. The examining licensed psychologist or psychiatrist shall evaluate: 1) the nature of the defendant’s mental disorder, if any, 2) the defendant’s ability or inability to understand the nature of the criminal proceedings, and 3) the defendant’s ability to assist counsel in the conduct of a defense in a rational manner as a result of a mental disorder. This evaluation shall be a prerequisite to the court approving or rejecting a certificate of restoration.
- If the court, in its discretion, believes that the defendant may not be competent, regardless of whether the defense is seeking a finding of mental incompetence, the court shall appoint a licensed psychologist or psychiatrist to examine the defendant. This evaluation shall be a prerequisite to the court rejecting a certificate of restoration.
- Any licensed psychologist or psychiatrist appointed pursuant to this section shall meet the existing established guidelines.
- The defense shall offer evidence in support of the allegation of mental competence;
- The prosecution may present its case or may submit on the certificate of restoration or present additional evidence;
- Each party may offer rebutting testimony, unless the court, for good cause in the furtherance of justice, also permits other evidence in support of the original contention;
- When the evidence is concluded, unless the case is submitted without final argument, the prosecution shall make its final argument and the defense shall conclude with its final argument to the court;
- It shall be presumed that the defendant has been restored to competence unless it is proved by a preponderance of the evidence that the defendant is mentally incompetent.
This bill provides that the procedure described above does not preclude the defense and prosecution from submitting on the certificate of restoration nor does it preclude the parties from privately retaining an evaluator at their own expense.
COMMENTS
- Need for This Bill
According to the author of this bill:
SB 1392 ensures that incompetent defendants receive the full two years of mental health and competency treatment they are entitled to under the law. By creating a tolling provision for restoration of competency proceedings, SB 1392 provides that any hearings after the issuance of a certificate of restoration do not chip away at this two-year treatment period. The bill also codifies the procedure by which restoration hearings are conducted, consistent with existing statutes and case law. This change will benefit criminal defendants and society at large by ensuring incompetent defendants get as much help as possible.
- Background: Mental Competency in Criminal Proceedings
The Due Process Clause of the United States Constitution prohibits the criminal prosecution of a defendant who is not mentally competent to stand trial. Existing law provides that if a person has been charged with a crime and is not able to understand the nature of the criminal proceedings and/or is not able to assist counsel in his or her defense, the court may determine that the offender is IST. (Pen. Code § 1367.) When the court issues an order for a hearing into the present mental competence of the defendant, all proceedings in the criminal prosecution are suspended until the question of present mental competence has been determined. (Pen. Code, §1368, subd. (c).)
In order to determine mental competence, the court must appoint a psychiatrist or licensed psychologist to examine the defendant. If defense counsel opposes a finding on incompetence, the court must appoint two experts: one chosen by the defense, one by the prosecution. (Pen. Code, § 11369, subd. (a).) The examining expert(s) must evaluate the defendant’s alleged mental disorder and the defendant’s ability to understand the proceedings and assist counsel, as well as address whether antipsychotic medication is medically appropriate. (Pen. Code, § 1369, subd. (a).)
Both parties have a right to a jury trial to decide competency. (Pen. Code, § 1369.) A formal trial is not required when jury trial has been waived. (People v. Harris (1993) 14 Cal.App.4th 984.) The burden of proof is on the party seeking a finding of incompetence. (People v. Skeirik (1991) 229 Cal.App.3d 444, 459-460.) In order to be competent to stand trial, “a defendant must have sufficient present ability to consult with his or her lawyer with a reasonable degree of rational understanding and a rational as well as factual understanding of the proceedings against him or her.” (People v. Oglesby (2008) 158 Cal.App.4th 818, 827 citing People v. Ramos (2004) 34 Cal.4th 494, 507.) Because a defendant is initially considered competent to stand trial (Medina v. California (1992) 505 U.S. 437), usually this means that the defense bears the burden of proof to establish incompetence. Therefore, defense counsel must first present evidence to support mental incompetence. However, if defense counsel does not want to offer evidence to have the defendant declared incompetent, the prosecution may. Each party may offer rebuttal evidence. Final arguments are presented to the court or jury, with the prosecution going first, followed by defense counsel. (Pen. Code, § 1369, subds. (b)-(e).)
If after an examination and hearing the defendant is found IST, the criminal proceedings are suspended and the court shall order the defendant to be referred to DSH, or to any other available public or private treatment facility, including a community-based residential treatment system if the facility has a secured perimeter or a locked and controlled treatment facility, approved by the community program director that will promote the defendant’s speedy restoration to mental competence, or placed on outpatient status, except as specified. (Pen. Code § 1368, subd. (c) and 1370, subd. (a)(1)(B).) The court may also make a determination as to whether the defendant is an appropriate candidate for mental health diversion pursuant to Penal Code section 1001.36.
The maximum term of commitment for an IST defendant charged with a felony is two-years, however, no later than 90 days prior to the expiration of the defendant’s term of commitment, if the defendant has not regained mental competence shall be returned to the committing court and the court shall not order the defendant returned to the custody of DSH. (Pen. Code, § 1370, subd. (c)(1).) With the exception of proceedings alleging a violation of mandatory supervision, the criminal action may be dismissed in the interests of justice. (Pen. Code, § 1370, subd. (d).)
If the defendant is determined to have regained mental competence after receiving treatment, the treatment provider is required to certify that fact to the court by filing a certificate of restoration with the court. (Pen. Code, § 1372, subd. (a)(1).) The court’s order committing the defendant to the treatment facility shall include direction that the sheriff shall redeliver the patient to the court without any further order from the court upon receiving the copy of the certificate of restoration. (Pen. Code, § 1372, subd. (a)(2).) The defendant shall be returned to the committing court no later than 10 days following the filing of a certificate of restoration. (Pen. Code, § 1372, subd. (a)(3)(C).)
The court shall notify the treatment provider of the date of any hearing on the defendant’s competence and whether or not the defendant was found by the court to have recovered competence. (Pen. Code, § 1372, subd. (c)(1).) If the court rejects a certificate of restoration, the court shall base its rejection on a written report of an evaluation conducted by a licensed psychologist or psychiatrist that the defendant is not competent. The evaluation shall be conducted after the certificate of restoration is filed with the committing court. (Pen. Code, § 1372, subd. (c)(2).)
This bill states that the issuance of a certificate of restoration of competency shall toll the running of the maximum period of commitment and deletes an existing provision that requires the court, after rejecting a certificate of restoration, to include within the court order a new computation of the amount of credit for time served deducted from the defendant’s maximum term of commitment. Currently, Penal Code section 1372 does not specify that tolling is permitted, however, recent case law which will be discussed in Note 3 ruled that the issuance of the certificate and any determination by the court on the certificate is included within the maximum term of commitment.
This bill also specifies the process by which a court trial on the question of defendant’s competency is to proceed which is similar to the process by which a court can find that a person is IST, except there is not a guarantee of a jury trial. Currently, there is not a specified procedure for how the court should determine a defendant’s competency after the filing of a certificate of restoration.
- Tolling of Maximum Period of Commitment
The maximum period of commitment due to incompetency for a defendant charged with a felony is no more than 2 years. (Pen. Code, § 1370, subd. (c)(1).) If the treatment provider determines that the defendant has regained mental competence after receiving treatment, the treatment provider is required to certify that fact to the court by filing a certificate of restoration with the court. . (Pen. Code, § 1372, subd. (a)(1).) The sheriff is then required to deliver the defendant back to court no later than 10 days after filing of the certificate and the court is required to have a hearing to determine whether to approve the certificate.
The California Supreme Court recently ruled that the filing of the certificate of competency and the court’s ruling on the certificate is included in the two-year maximum term of commitment. (Rodriguez v. Superior Court of Santa Clara County (2023) 15 Cal.5th 472, 487.) In Rodriguez, the defendant who was charged with multiple felonies was found to be IST and ordered to be committed to the state hospital. The maximum term of his commitment was 2 years, which statutorily requires the defendant to be returned to court no later than 90 days from when the commitment term is set to expire. After a few months of commitment, a certificate of restoration was filed and the defendant was returned to court. However, the court subsequently declared a new doubt as to the defendant’s competency and he was again found IST and returned to the state hospital. After another period of commitment at the state hospital, the medical director certified that the defendant was restored to competency and he was returned to court. The court set a hearing date to determine whether to approve the certificate, but due to COVID-19 the court suspended almost all of its operations and the competency hearing did not take place until after the two-year maximum period of commitment had expired. The defendant filed a motion to dismiss which was denied by the trial court and the Court of Appeal rejected his claim as well. The California Supreme Court disagreed with the Court of Appeal.
In coming to its conclusion, the Rodriguez court first reviewed the history of the IST process: Prior to 1974, California law provided that persons charged with criminal conduct but found IST were committed to state hospitals until they became competent. Because attainment of competence was the sole standard for release the commitments could be indefinite, even permanent, so long as incompetence persisted. In 1972, the United States Supreme Court held that “indefinite commitment of a criminal defendant solely on account of his incompetency to stand trial” offends constitutional guarantees of equal protection and due process. (Rodriguez, supra, 15 Cal.5th at p. 491, citing Jackson v. Indiana (1972) 406 U.S. 715, 731.) In 1973, the California Supreme Court adopted the rule in Jackson, and delegated to trial courts the discretion to decide whether sufficient progress is being made to justify continued commitment and held that “if there exists no o reasonable likelihood that the person will recover his competence to stand trial in the foreseeable future, then the court should either order him released from confinement or initiate appropriate alternative commitment proceedings under the Lanterman-Petris-Short Act. (Id., citing In re Davis (1973) 8 Cal. 3d 798, 801.)
In 1974, the Legislature specified that an IST defendant could not be committed for more than three years and imposed an obligation by the state hospitals and other treatment facilities to report to the court within 90 days of commitment, and at six-month intervals, the defendant’s progress towards recovery of competence. If any report indicated that there was not a substantial likelihood that the defendant would regain his mental competence in the foreseeable future, the committing court was required to order the defendant to be returned to court. However, the law also provided that if the defendant was still IST after 18 months, the defendant must be returned to determine competency. The law also created a new type of conservatorship, referred to as a “Murphy” conservatorship after the author of the 1974 law, allowing for a one-year renewable commitment of IST defendants charged with violent felonies who have reached their maximum term of commitment. These provisions “resolve the conflicting concerns of protecting society from dangerous individuals who are not subject to criminal prosecution … and safeguarding the freedom of incompetent criminal defendants who present no threat to the public.” (Rodriguez, supra, 15 Cal.5th at p. 492, citing Parker, California's New Scheme for the Commitment of Individuals Found Incompetent to Stand Trial (1975) 6 Pacific L.J. 484, 485.)
In 1980, the Legislature extended the courts' role in overseeing competency procedures by making them responsible for determining whether a defendant has regained competency when the defendant is returned to court following the filing of a certificate of restoration. In 2018, the Legislature shortened the maximum commitment term from three years to two years. As part of the same bill, the Legislature eliminated the requirement that a defendant who remains committed for 18 months be returned to court for a redetermination of competency. (Rodriguez, supra, 15 Cal.5th at pp. 492-493.)
The Rodriguez court concluded that this history shows that the Legislature intended for the court to play a central role in making competency assessments, before and after the filing of the certificate of restoration, thus ending the period of commitment when the certificate is filed is inconsistent with this scheme. (Id. at p. 497.) The statutory procedures suggest that the two-year time frame does not end with the filing of the certificate. The defendant is required to be returned to court no later than 90 days prior to the expiration of the term of commitment which would allow the time for necessary subsequent judicial proceedings to be completed before reaching the maximum period of commitment. (Id. at p. 498.)
Additionally, from a fairness standpoint, the Court pointed out that a defendant who has been certified as competent, is ineligible for bail consideration until the court determines the defendant has regained competency and cannot otherwise challenge the underlying charges because the criminal proceedings remain suspended. (Id. at p. 506, see also § 1372, subd. (d) and 1370, subd. (a)(1).) This state of limbo is contrary to the entire statutory scheme and would eliminate any urgency in reaching a determination of competency. (Ibid.)
The Court rejected the People’s contention that their conclusion allows defendants to evade prosecution. Such individuals may be civilly committed, including long-term conservatorships, including a Murphy conservatorship (discussed above), or may have their charges dismissed which the People may refile even if the defendant was previously committed for the maximum period of commitment. (Id. at p. 516.)
As noted by the Court in Rodriguez, the delay in that particular case was due to COVID-19. DSH acknowledges that the average time for treatment to restore competency is well within the two-year maximum period, usually sometime between 6 to 9 months. (Rodriguez, supra, 15 Cal. 5th at p. 515.) The tolling of the time period is also not necessary to continue treatment of a defendant when they are returned to court after the filing of a certificate of restoration. A defendant may continue to receive treatment if necessary which may include involuntary administration of antipsychotic medication. (Pen. Code Section § 1370, subd. (a)(2)(B)(iii).)
- Argument in Support
According to California District Attorneys Association:
Often, the certificate of restoration is disputed by defense counsel upon the defendant’s return to court. Upon such a dispute, defense counsel will hire experts to review the defendant’s records and examine the defendant, and the court will hold a contested hearing, often several months later. In a recent California Supreme Court ruling in Rodriguez v. Superior Court of Santa Clara County (2023) 15 Cal.5th 472, the court held that the period between when the doctor tells the court a defendant is competent and the court’s ruling on competency is part of the two-year time limit. This means that the period of delay for the contested hearing, where a potentially incompetent defendant is not receiving appropriate treatment, counts towards the two-year period of mental health treatment provided by law. Given this situation, courts have been placed in the untenable situation of choosing between a defendant’s right to effective counsel and his (and society’s) interest in ensuring he receives the full period of treatment with every opportunity to regain competence. The Rodriguez opinion was the Court’s attempt to fill in the blanks where current statutes remained silent.
- Argument in Opposition
According to Disability Rights California:
SB 1392 tolls the two-year maximum commitment period for competency. This could create an indefinite period of detention as a defendant challenges their certificate of restoration of competency.
-- END –
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):