AB 1006: Prisoners: mental health treatment.
- Session Year: 2015-2016
- House: Assembly
- Latest Version Date: 2015-04-21
Existing law prohibits a person from being tried, adjudged to punishment, or having his or her probation, mandatory supervision, postrelease community supervision, or parole revoked while that person is mentally incompetent. Existing law establishes a process by which a defendants mental competency is evaluated and by which the defendant receives treatment, including, if applicable, antipsychotic medication, with the goal of returning the defendant to competency. Existing law credits time spent by a defendant in a state hospital or other facility as a result of commitment during the process toward the term of any imprisonment for which the defendant is sentenced. Existing law, as added by Proposition 184, adopted November 8, 1994, and amended by Proposition 36, adopted November 6, 2012, commonly known as the Three Strikes Law, prohibits certain recidivist offenders from being committed to any facility other than a state prison.
This bill would authorize, if a defendant has pled guilty or nolo contendere to, or been convicted of, an offense that will result in a sentence to state prison, prison or county jail, the defendant or the prosecutor to file a petition for a hearing to determine if submit evidence that the defendant suffers from a diagnosable mental condition and would authorize the court, on its own motion, to order that hearing. that was a substantial factor that contributed to the defendants criminal conduct. The bill would require that petition to the evidence be filed submitted after the defendants conviction, but before his or her sentencing, and to allege that the defendant suffers from a diagnosable mental illness and requests mental health treatment. sentencing. The bill would require the court, after a hearing on the matter, and if the court finds by a preponderance of the evidence that the defendant suffers from a diagnosable mental illness, to make one or more specified orders, including, among others, an order that court to consider any evidence submitted as described above in conjunction with the defendants sentencing, and would authorize the court to order the Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation or county jail authority, as applicable, to place the defendant in a residential mental health program within the state prison. treatment facility. This placement would not be available to a defendant who is subject to the Three Strikes Law. The bill would also authorize the court to order the department or jail authority to place the defendant in a mental health program within the state prison or county jail, respectively. The bill would provide that the defendant has the right to counsel for these proceedings.
By imposing additional duties upon county jail authorities, this bill would create a state-mandated local program.
The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.
This bill would provide that, if the Commission on State Mandates determines that the bill contains costs mandated by the state, reimbursement for those costs shall be made pursuant to these statutory provisions.
Existing law prohibits a person from being tried, adjudged to punishment, or having his or her probation, mandatory supervision, postrelease community supervision, or parole revoked while that person is mentally incompetent. Existing law establishes a process by which a defendants mental competency is evaluated and by which the defendant receives treatment, including, if applicable, antipsychotic medication, with the goal of returning the defendant to competency. Existing law credits time spent by a defendant in a state hospital or other facility as a result of commitment during the process toward the term of any imprisonment for which the defendant is sentenced.
This bill would authorize, if a defendant has pled guilty or nolo contendere to, or been convicted of, an offense that will result in a sentence to state prison, the defendant or the prosecutor to file a petition for a hearing to determine if the defendant suffers from a diagnosable mental condition and would authorize the court, on its own motion, to order that hearing. The bill would require that petition to be filed after the defendants conviction, but before his or her sentencing, and to allege that the defendant suffers from a diagnosable mental illness and requests mental health treatment. The bill would require the court, after a hearing on the matter, and if the court finds by a preponderance of the evidence that the defendant suffers from a diagnosable mental illness, to make one or more specified orders, including, among others, an order that the Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation place the defendant in a mental health program within the state prison. The bill would provide that the defendant has the right to counsel for these proceedings.
This act shall be known and may be cited as the Mental Health Justice Act.
SEC. 2.Chapter 16 (commencing with Section 1425) is added to Title 10 of Part 2 of the Penal Code, to read:16.Mental Health Treatment1425.(a)(1)If a defendant has pled guilty or nolo contendere to, or been convicted of, an offense that will result in a sentence to state prison, prison or county jail, the defendant or the prosecutor may file a petition for a hearing to determine if submit evidence that the defendant suffers from a diagnosable mental illness. illness that was a substantial factor that contributed to the defendants criminal conduct. The petition evidence shall be filed after the defendants plea or conviction, but before his or her sentencing.
(2)If a defendant has pled guilty or nolo contendere to, or been convicted of, an offense that will result in a sentence to state prison, the court, on its own motion, may order the hearing described in paragraph (1).
(b)A petition filed pursuant to paragraph (1) of subdivision (a) shall allege that the defendant suffers from a diagnosable mental illness and requests mental health treatment.
(c)Upon the filing of a petition pursuant to paragraph (1) of subdivision (a), or upon its own motion pursuant to paragraph (2) of subdivision (a), the court shall set an evidentiary hearing, to be heard in conjunction with the defendants sentencing, to determine whether the defendant suffers from a diagnosable mental illness.
(d)If, after the hearing described in subdivision (c), the court determines by a preponderance of evidence that the defendant suffers from a diagnosable mental illness, the court shall order one or more of the following:
(b)If evidence is submitted pursuant to subdivision (a), the court shall consider that evidence in conjunction with the defendants sentencing.
(c)Upon consideration of the evidence submitted pursuant to subdivision (a), notwithstanding any other law, if the court determines that it is in the best interests of public safety, the court may order one or more of the following:
(1)Order that (A)That the defendant serve serve, if the defendant agrees, all or a part of his or her sentence in a residential mental health treatment facility instead of in the state prison, prison or county jail, unless that placement would pose an unreasonable risk of danger to public safety.
(B)This paragraph does not apply to a defendant subject to Section 1170.12.
(2)Order the The Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation or county jail authority, as applicable, to place the defendant in a mental health program within the state prison, prison or county jail system, respectively, at a level of care determined to be appropriate by the departments mental health staff or county mental health staff, within 30 days days, of the defendants placement in the state prison, or sooner upon order of the court. prison or county jail.
(3)Order the The Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation or the county jail authority, as applicable, regardless of the type of crime committed to prepare a post-release postrelease mental health treatment plan six months prior to the defendants release from custody. to parole or postrelease community supervision. The treatment plan shall specify the manner in which the defendant will receive mental health treatment services following release from custody, that release, and shall address, if applicable and in the discretion of the court, medication management, housing, and substance abuse treatment.
(e)
(d)(1)(A)The defendant or prosecutor may, at any time, petition the court for approval to transfer the defendant from a residential mental health treatment facility to a mental health program within the state prison or county jail for the remainder of the defendants sentence.
(B)
(2)The defendant, prosecutor, or Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation or county jail authority, as applicable, may, at any time, petition the court for permission to remove the defendant from a mental health program within the state prison. prison or county jail system, respectively.
(C)
(3)The defendant, prosecutor, or Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation or county jail authority, as applicable, may, at any time, petition the court for dismissal of the requirement that the Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation or county jail authority, respectively, prepare a post-release postrelease mental health treatment plan.
(2)The court shall approve a petition described in paragraph (1) only if the court determines by a preponderance of the evidence that approving the petition is in the best interest of the defendant.
(f)
(e)The defendant shall have the right to counsel for all proceedings under this section.
SEC. 3.If the Commission on State Mandates determines that this act contains costs mandated by the state, reimbursement to local agencies and school districts for those costs shall be made pursuant to Part 7 (commencing with Section 17500) of Division 4 of Title 2 of the Government Code.
(a)(1)If a defendant has pled guilty or nolo contendere to, or been convicted of, an offense that will result in a sentence to state prison, the defendant or the prosecutor may file a petition for a hearing to determine if the defendant suffers from a diagnosable mental illness. The petition shall be filed after the defendants plea or conviction, but before his or her sentencing.
(2)If a defendant has pled guilty or nolo contendere to, or been convicted of, an offense that will result in a sentence to state prison, the court, on its own motion, may order the hearing described in paragraph (1).
(b)A petition filed pursuant to paragraph (1) of subdivision (a) shall allege that the defendant suffers from a diagnosable mental illness and requests mental health treatment.
(c)Upon the filing of a petition pursuant to paragraph (1) of subdivision (a), or upon its own motion pursuant to paragraph (2) of subdivision (a), the court shall set an evidentiary hearing, to be heard in conjunction with the defendants sentencing, to determine whether the defendant suffers from a diagnosable mental illness.
(d)If, after the hearing described in subdivision (c), the court determines by a preponderance of evidence that the defendant suffers from a diagnosable mental illness, the court shall order one or more of the following:
(1)Order that the defendant serve all or a part of his or her sentence in a residential mental health treatment facility instead of in the state prison, unless that placement would pose an unreasonable risk of danger to public safety.
(2)Order the Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation to place the defendant in a mental health program within the state prison, at a level of care determined to be appropriate by the departments mental health staff within 30 days of the defendants placement in the state prison, or sooner upon order of the court.
(3)Order the Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation to prepare a post-release mental health treatment plan six months prior to the defendants release from custody. The treatment plan shall specify the manner in which the defendant will receive mental health treatment services following release from custody, and shall address, if applicable and in the discretion of the court, medication management, housing, and substance abuse treatment.
(e)(1)(A)The defendant or prosecutor may, at any time, petition the court for approval to transfer the defendant from a residential mental health treatment facility to a mental health program within the state prison for the remainder of the defendants sentence.
(B)The defendant, prosecutor, or Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation may, at any time, petition the court for permission to remove the defendant from a mental health program within the state prison.
(C)The defendant, prosecutor, or Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation may, at any time, petition the court for dismissal of the requirement that the Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation prepare a post-release mental health treatment plan.
(2)The court shall approve a petition described in paragraph (1) only if the court determines by a preponderance of the evidence that approving the petition is in the best interest of the defendant.
(f)The defendant shall have the right to counsel for all proceedings under this section.
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Feb 1, 2016 | From committee: Filed with the Chief Clerk pursuant to Joint Rule 56. |
| Jan 31, 2016 | Died pursuant to Article IV, Sec. 10(c) of the Constitution. |
| May 28, 2015 | In committee: Held under submission. |
| May 20, 2015 | In committee: Set, first hearing. Referred to APPR. suspense file. |
| May 20, 2015 | In committee: Set, first hearing. Referred to suspense file. |
| Apr 28, 2015 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 5. Noes 2.) (April 28). Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Apr 22, 2015 | Re-referred to Com. on PUB. S. |
| Apr 21, 2015 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to Com. on PUB. S. Read second time and amended. |
| Apr 21, 2015 | In committee: Set, first hearing. Hearing canceled at the request of author. |
| Mar 19, 2015 | Referred to Com. on PUB. S. |
| Feb 27, 2015 | From printer. May be heard in committee March 29. |
| Feb 26, 2015 | Read first time. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Apr 28, 2015 | Do pass and be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Assembly Standing Committee on Public Safety |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
AB 1006
Page 3
Date of Hearing: May 20, 2015
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Jimmy Gomez, Chair
AB 1006
(Levine) – As Amended April 21, 2015
Policy Committee: |
Public Safety |
Vote: |
5 - 2 |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Urgency: No State Mandated Local Program: Yes Reimbursable: No
SUMMARY:
This bill allows the defendant or the prosecutor to submit evidence that the defendant suffers from a diagnosable mental illness that was a substantial factor that contributed to the defendant’s criminal conduct, when a defendant has pled guilty or no contest to, or has been convicted of, an offense that will result in a sentence to state prison or county jail. The court may use that evidence to order the defendant to serve part of his or her sentence in a residential mental health treatment facility, order the defendant placed in a mental health program in the state prison or county jail, or order the detention facility to prepare a post release mental health treatment plan. Allows the defendant, prosecutor, or the Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation (CDCR) or county jail authority, as applicable, to at any time, petition the court for permission to remove the defendant from a mental health program within the state prison or county jail authority.
FISCAL EFFECT:
Potential ongoing annual costs in excess of $1.5 million (GF) to the trial courts for the additional evidentiary hearings that may be requested. Even if a small percentage of the 40,000-plus felons committed to state prison or the 25,000-plus felons and misdemeanants committed to county jail are impacted, the numbers are significant. Also, the assumption is the prosecutor will probably object to a number of requests.
CDCR costs will be several million dollars (GF). This bill could result in a significant increase in inmates designated for mental health programs. This bill would also result in the need for additional legal staff for CDCR to petition the removal of inmates from the mental health program. In addition, it should be noted that any inmate with a mental health condition in CDCR is part of a current class action lawsuit that is a significant cost driver in the CDCR budget.
Significant nonreimbursable state mandated costs in the millions to counties to provide additional mental health services to current inmates in county jails.
Moderate costs to the Department of Justice (DOJ) in those cases where the DOJ represents the State of California.
COMMENTS:
Purpose. According to the author, "Jails and prisons have become California’s de facto mental health facilities, with those who are mentally ill being far more likely to be incarcerated than to be in a psychiatric hospital. Incarcerating those with mental illness does not make sense from an outcomes or a fiscal stand point. Studies have found that individuals who participate in mental health courts reoffend one third of the time than those who do not and that participant’s show significant improvement in quality of life."
Background. In 2009, the Division of Correctional Health Care Services for the CDCR estimated that 23 percent of California’s prison inmates have a serious mental illness. According to the Berkeley Center for Criminal Justice, an estimated “40 to 70 percent of youth in the California juvenile justice system have some mental health disorder or illness,” with 15 to 25 percent considered severely mentally ill. Based on these numbers, youth in California’s juvenile justice system are two to four times more likely to be in need of mental health care than California youth generally. The Bureau of Justice Statistics reported in 2006 that 74 percent of mentally ill state prisoners and 76 percent of mentally ill local jail inmates also met the criteria for substance dependence or abuse indicating a larger issue with co-occurring disorders among mentally ill offenders
CDCR data shows higher rates of recidivism in inmates identified with mental health issues when compared to those without. Upon release, inmates exhibiting mental health problems are assigned one of two mental health services designations: Enhanced Outpatient Program (EOP) or Correctional Clinical Case Management System (CCCMS). Inmates with severe mental illness expected to experience difficulty transitioning out of corrections are designated as EOP and receive treatment at a level similar to day treatment services in the community, while inmates receiving CCCMS services are housed within the general population and participate on an outpatient basis. In the 2012 CDCR Outcome Evaluation Report, 76.7 percent of first-release inmates with an EOP designation recidivated after three years, compared to lower rates found in CCCMS designees (70.6 percent) and those without a designation (62 percent).
Argument in Support: According to David Mills (Chairman) and Michael Romano(Director), of the Stanford Law School Three Strikes and Justice Advocacy Project, “The Mental Health Justice Act (AB 1006) is the embodiment of the first reform proposed in our report. The bill is critically important because it will—for the first time—empower Superior Court Judges discretionary authority to order psychiatric treatment for criminal offenders who commit crimes as a result of mental illness. The bill does not require courts to do anything and protects public safety by forbidding judges from departing from traditional sentencing if doing so would endanger the public. Involving the courts in the identification and treatment of mentally ill offenders is a crucial step in addressing the massive problem of mental ill offenders in the justice system. We believe the measure will also save tax dollars and reduce recidivism by providing earlier interruption in the cycle of mental illness and incarceration.
“According to a recent report from the national Sheriff’s Association and Treatment Advocacy Center, ten times as many mentally ill people are in prison and jail in the United States than there are in mental health treatment facilities. In California, 45% of the state’s prison population is estimated to be mentally ill. In the last fifteen years the number of mentally ill people in prison has almost doubled.
Analysis Prepared by: Pedro R. Reyes / APPR. / (916) 319-2081
AB 1006
Page 9
Date of Hearing: April 28, 2015
Counsel: David Billingsley
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON PUBLIC SAFETY
Bill Quirk, Chair
AB 1006
(Levine) – As Amended April 21, 2015
SUMMARY:
Where a defendant has been convicted of an offense that will result in sentence to state prison sentence or county jail, the defendant or the prosecutor may submit evidence that the defendant suffers from a diagnosable mental illness that contributed to the defendant’s crime. The court may use that evidence to order the defendant to serve part of his or her sentence in a residential mental health treatment facility, order the defendant placed in a mental health program in the state prison or county jail, or order the detention facility to prepare a post release mental health treatment plan. Specifically, this bill:
Allows the defendant or the prosecutor to submit evidence that the defendant suffers from a diagnosable mental illness that was a substantial factor that contributed to the defendant’s criminal conduct, when a defendant has pled guilty or no contest to, or been convicted of, an offense that will result in a sentence to state prison or county jail.
Requires the evidence of diagnosable mental illness, be filed after the defendant’s plea or conviction, but before his or her sentencing.
Requires that the court consider evidence that the defendant suffers from a diagnosable mental illness that was a substantial factor that contributed to the defendant’s criminal conduct in conjunction with the defendant’s sentencing.
Allows the court upon consideration of the evidence of mental illness, if the court determines that it is in the best interests of public safety, the court to order one or more of the following:
That the defendant serve, if the defendant agrees, all or a part of his or her sentence in a residential mental health treatment facility instead of in the state prison or county jail, unless that placement would pose an unreasonable risk of danger to public safety. This does not apply to a defendant has a prior conviction for a serious or violent felony;
The Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation or county jail authority to the place the defendant in a mental health program within the state prison or county jail system, respectively, at a level of care determined to be appropriate by the department’s mental staff or county mental health staff, within 30
sdays, of the defendant’s placement in the state prison or county jail; and
The Department of Correction and Rehabilitation or the county jail authority, as applicable, regardless of the type of crime committed to prepare postrelease mental health treatment plan six months prior to the defendant’s release to parole or postrelease community supervision. The treatment plan shall specify the manner in which the defendant will receive mental health treatment services following that release, and shall address, if applicable and in the discretion of the court, medication management, housing, and substance abuse treatment.
Allows the defendant or prosecutor to, at any time, petition the court for approval to transfer the defendant from a residential mental health treatment facility to a mental health program within the state prison or county jail for the remainder of the defendant’s sentence.
Allows the defendant, prosecutor, or Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation or county jail authority, as applicable, to at any time, petition the court for permission to remove the defendant from a mental health program within the state prison or county jail authority.
Permits the defendant, prosecutor, or Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation or county jail authority, as applicable, to at any time, petition the court for dismissal of the requirement that the Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation or county jail authority, as applicable prepare a postrelease mental health treatment plan.
Requires that the defendant have the right to counsel for all proceedings under this section.
EXISTING LAW:
Finds and declares that the provision of probation services is an essential element in the administration of criminal justice. The safety of the public, which shall be a primary goal through the enforcement of court-ordered conditions of probation; the nature of the offense; the interests of justice, including punishment, reintegration of the offender into the community, and enforcement of conditions of probation; the loss to the victim; and the needs of the defendant shall be the primary considerations in the granting of probation. (Pen. Code, § 1202.7.)
In any case in which it appears to the person in charge of a county jail, city jail, or juvenile detention facility, or to any judge of a court in the county in which the jail or juvenile detention facility is located, that a person in custody in that jail or juvenile detention facility may be mentally disordered, he or she may cause the prisoner to be taken to a facility for 72-hour treatment and evaluation pursuant and he or she shall inform the facility in writing, which shall be confidential, of the reasons that the person is being taken to the facility. The local mental health director or his or her designee may examine the prisoner prior to transfer to a facility for treatment and evaluation. (Pen. Code, § 4011.6.)
Where the court causes the prisoner to be transferred to a 72-hour facility, the court shall forthwith notify the local mental health director or his or her designee, the prosecuting attorney, and counsel for the prisoner in the criminal or juvenile proceedings about that transfer. Where the person in charge of the jail or juvenile detention facility causes the transfer of the prisoner to a 72-hour facility the person shall immediately notify the local mental health director or his or her designee and each court within the county where the prisoner has a pending proceeding about the transfer. Upon notification by the person in charge of the jail or juvenile detention facility the court shall forthwith notify counsel for the prisoner and the prosecuting attorney in the criminal or juvenile proceedings about that transfer. (Pen. Code, § 4011.6.)
If a prisoner is detained in, or remanded to, a mental health facility pursuant, the facility shall transmit a report, which shall be confidential, to the person in charge of the jail or juvenile detention facility or judge of the court who caused the prisoner to be taken to the facility and to the local mental health director or his or her designee, concerning the condition of the prisoner. A new report shall be transmitted at the end of each period of confinement as specified, upon conversion to voluntary status, and upon filing of temporary letters of conservatorship. (Pen. Code, § 4011.6.)
A prisoner who has been transferred to an inpatient facility pursuant to this section may convert to voluntary inpatient status without obtaining the consent of the court, the person in charge of the jail or juvenile detention facility, or the local mental health director. At the beginning of that conversion to voluntary status, the person in charge of the facility shall transmit a report to the person in charge of the jail or juvenile detention facility or judge of the court who caused the prisoner to be taken to the facility, counsel for the prisoner, prosecuting attorney, and local mental health director or his or her designee. (Pen. Code, § 4011.6.)
If the prisoner is detained in, or remanded to, a mental health facility, the time passed in the facility shall count as part of the prisoner's sentence. When the prisoner is detained in, or remanded to, the facility, the person in charge of the jail or juvenile detention facility shall advise the professional person in charge of the facility of the expiration date of the prisoner's sentence. If the prisoner is to be released from the facility before the expiration date, the professional person in charge shall notify the local mental health director or his or her designee, counsel for the prisoner, the prosecuting attorney, and the person in charge of the jail or juvenile detention facility, who shall send for, take, and receive the prisoner back into the jail or juvenile detention facility. (Pen. Code, § 4011.6.)
A defendant, either charged with or convicted of a criminal offense, or a minor alleged to be within the jurisdiction of the juvenile court, may be concurrently subject to mental health detention as specified by law under the Welfare and Institutions Code. (Pen. Code, § 4011.6.)
If a prisoner is detained in a mental health facility pursuant to the Welfare and Institutions Code and if the person in charge of the facility determines that arraignment or trial would be detrimental to the well-being of the prisoner, the time spent in the facility shall not be computed in any statutory time requirements for arraignment or trial in any pending criminal or juvenile proceedings. Otherwise, this section shall not affect any statutory time requirements for arraignment or trial in any pending criminal or juvenile proceedings. (Pen. Code, § 4011.6.)
States that upon conviction of any felony in which the defendant is sentenced to state prison, and the court makes any of the findings listed below, a court shall, in addition to any other terms of imprisonment, fine, and conditions, recommend in writing that the defendant participate in a counseling or education program having a substance abuse component while imprisoned:
That the defendant at the time of the commission of the offense was under the influence of any alcoholic beverages; (Pen. Code, § 1203.096, subd. (b)(1).)
That the defendant at the time of the commission of the offense was under the influence of any controlled substance; (Pen. Code, § 1203.096, subd. (b)(2).)
That the defendant has a demonstrated history of substance abuse; and (Pen. Code, § 1203.096, subd. (b)(3).)
That the offense or offenses for which the defendant was convicted are drug related. (Pen. Code, § 1203.096, subd. (b)(4).)
FISCAL EFFECT:
Unknown
COMMENTS:
Author's Statement: According to the author, "Jails and prisons have become California’s de facto mental health facilities with those who are mentally ill being far more likely to be incarcerated than to be in a psychiatric hospital. Incarcerating those with mental illness does not make sense from an outcomes or a fiscal stand point. Studies have found that individuals who participate in mental health courts reoffend one third of the time than those who do not and that participant’s show significant improvement in quality of life. Furthermore, mental health courts have been demonstrated to save $7 in costs for every $1 spent. It costs $51,000 a year to house an inmate, and $20,412 to house and treat a person with mental illness. AB 1006 gives the court the ability to consider the presence of a mental illness in criminal sentencing.”
Prevalence of Mentally Ill Offenders: The Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation’s (CDCR) Council on Mentally Ill Offenders (COMIO) regards the growing number of inmates suffering from mental health issues as a pressing concern.1
Nationally, a 2009 American Psychiatric Association study “found that 14.5% of male and 31.0% of female inmates recently admitted to jail have a serious mental illness” which is three to six times higher than rates found in the general population. “A serious mental illness” included major depressive disorder, depressive disorder not otherwise specified, schizophrenia spectrum disorder, schizoaffective disorder, schizophreniform disorder, brief psychotic disorder, delusional disorder, and psychotic disorder not otherwise specified.2
In 2009, the Division of Correctional Health Care Services for the CDCR estimated that 23 percent of California’s prison inmates have a serious mental illness.3 According to the Berkeley Center for Criminal Justice, an estimated “40 to 70 percent of youth in the California juvenile justice system have some mental health disorder or illness,” with 15 to 25 percent considered severely mentally ill. Based on these numbers, youth in California’s juvenile justice system are two to four times more likely to be in need of mental health care than California youth generally.4 The Bureau of Justice Statistics reported in 2006 that 74 percent of mentally ill state prisoners and 76 percent of mentally ill local jail inmates also met the criteria for substance dependence or abuse indicating a larger issue with co-occurring disorders among mentally ill offenders.5
Increased Rates of Recidivism Among Mentally Ill Offenders: A 2012 review conducted by the Utah Criminal Justice Center found that released inmates with serious mental illness experience poorer outcomes overall as they are “twice as likely to have their probation or parole revoked, are at an elevated risk for rearrest, incarceration, and homelessness, lack skills to obtain and sustain employment, and have higher rates of medical problems.” 6
In 2009, the Council of State Governors Justice Center released a report entitled Improving Outcomes for People with Mental Illnesses under Community Corrections Supervision, which stated that the reasons for increased recidivism among mental ill offenders may be multifaceted:
Once people with mental illnesses are finally released, it is often extremely difficult for them to successfully transition from incarceration to the community. Their mental illnesses may be linked to community corrections supervision failure in a number of ways. Skeem and Loudon have characterized these links as being direct, indirect, or spurious.
First, mental illnesses may directly result in probation or parole revocation. For example, an individual may not access treatment, leading him or her to decompensate, behave in a bizarre or dangerous manner in public, get arrested for this behavior, and have his or her probation revoked.
Second, mental illnesses may indirectly result in revocation. For example, an individual with clinical depression may have impaired functioning that prevents him or her from maintaining employment and paying court ordered fines, which are standard conditions of release. Notably, many people with mental illnesses returning to the community from jail or prison lack financial or social supports. Some were receiving Medicaid and other forms of public assistance at the time of their arrest, and these benefits are typically terminated rather than suspended during incarceration, and rarely reinstated immediately upon release. In short, there is often no safety net to compensate for functional impairments that may place individuals with mental illnesses at risk for revocation.
Third, mental illnesses may not result in revocation. Instead, the relationship between the two may be spurious—that is, more apparent than real—because a third variable associated with mental illness causes revocation. For example, an individual with bipolar disorder may be at risk of committing a new offense not because of his or her mental illness, but because of criminogenic attitudes or affiliation with antisocial peers. Alternatively, an individual with psychosis may be monitored exceptionally closely and revoked readily by his or her probation officer, given that traditional supervision strategies often reflect misconceptions about (and stigma associated with) mental illness.7
CDCR data shows higher rates of recidivism in inmates identified with mental health issues when compared to those without. Upon release, inmates exhibiting mental health problems are assigned one of two mental health services designations: Enhanced Outpatient Program (EOP) or Correctional Clinical Case Management System (CCCMS). Inmates with severe mental illness expected to experience difficulty transitioning out of corrections are designated as EOP and receive treatment at a level similar to day treatment services in the community, while inmates receiving CCCMS services are housed within the general population and participate on an outpatient basis. In the 2012 CDCR Outcome Evaluation Report, 76.7 percent of first-release inmates with an EOP designation recidivated after three years, compared to lower rates found in CCCMS designees (70.6 percent) and those without a designation (62 percent).8
According to a 2005 CDCR report, mental health issues “comprised the single most critical gap in juvenile justice services. ... According to those surveyed, the number of at-risk youth and youthful offenders with mental health problems continues to increase as does the seriousness of their mental illnesses. The only thing not increasing is the resources to treat and confine these troubled and troubling youth.” Even if juvenile offenders receive assistance, absence of treatment after release may contribute to a path of behavior that includes continued delinquency and adult criminality.9
Under Existing Law, Judges Have Discretion to Impose Conditions on Felony or Misdemeanor Cases When a Defendant is Placed on Probation: Probation is the suspension of the imposition or execution of a sentence and the conditional release of a defendant into the community under the direction of a probation officer. “Probation is generally reserved for convicted criminals whose conditional release into society poses minimal risk to public safety and promotes rehabilitation.” People v. Carbajal (1995) 10 Cal.4th 1114,1120. Probation can be conditioned on serving a period of incarceration in county jail and on conditions reasonably related to the offense. Certain convicted felons are not eligible for probation. Other felons are presumptively ineligible for probation, but may be granted probation in an unusual case.
The primary considerations in granting probation are: (1) Public safety; (2) the nature of the offense; (3) the interests of justice; (4) the victim’s loss; and (5) the defendant’s needs. (Pen. Code, § 1202.7.)
Courts have broad general discretion to fashion and impose additional probation conditions that are particularized to the defendants. People v. Smith (2007) 152. Cal.App.4th 1245, 1249. Courts may impose any “reasonable” conditions necessary to secure justice and assist the rehabilitation of the probationer. Under existing law, a judge can impose a condition of probation that a defendant spend a certain amount of time in a residential mental health facility in conjunction with a jail sentence, or as an alternative to a jail sentence. In imposing probation conditions related to mental health, the court is not limited to ordering residential mental health treatment. The court can order outpatient mental health treatment, or other mental health directives the court finds appropriate. When a defendant is placed on probation the court retains jurisdiction over the case to ensure the defendant complies with probation. The court has the power to impose further punishment if the defendant does not comply with probation.
California’s Current Sentencing Scheme Does Not Provide an Option for a Judge to Impose a Split Prison Sentence: Under California’s sentencing scheme, if a person is sent to state prison, they are sentenced for a determinate amount of time. Once an individual is sentenced to State Prison they are committed to the custody of CDCR. Once CDCR has custody of a defendant, CDCR, not the court, decides where and in what type of custodial setting the defendant serves their state prison term.
When a court sentences a defendant to state prison, the court loses jurisdiction over the individual.
“If the judgment is for imprisonment, ‘the defendant must forthwith be committed to the custody of the proper officer and by him or her detained until the judgment is complied with.’ The sheriff, upon receipt of the certified abstract of judgment "or minute order thereof," is required to deliver the defendant to the warden of the state prison together with the certified abstract of judgment or minute order. ‘It is clear then that at least upon the receipt of the abstract of the judgment by the sheriff, the execution of the judgment is in progress.’
“Thus, for example, in People v. Banks, we considered the effect of a stay of execution in the context of the trial court's authority to grant probation for certain offenses. We observed that upon entry of a guilty plea, if the trial court chooses to retain jurisdiction under the statutes dealing with probation, it may pronounce judgment and suspend its execution by refraining from issuing a commitment of the defendant to the prison authority. We stated: "The critical requirement for control over the defendant and the res of the action is that the court shall not have surrendered its jurisdiction in the premises by committing and delivering the defendant to the prison authority." People v. Karaman, (1992) 4 Cal.4th 335,345 (citation omitted)(italics added.)
Because the court loses jurisdiction over a defendant when they are sentenced to state prison, it is unclear who would have the authority to enforce transfer of a defendant from a mental health facility to a state prison if treatment in a residential mental health treatment was ordered for a portion of the defendant’s sentence at the beginning of the sentence. The same problem would exist if the court sentenced the defendant to begin their term with state prison, but directed the later part of the state prison term to be served in a mental health facility.
For the same jurisdictional reasons, it is unclear what remedies would be available if a defendant left a residential mental health treatment facility after being sentenced to such a facility for a portion of, or all of, a state prison sentence.
Logistical Difficulties of Post Sentencing Procedures to Petition the Court to Change the Defendant’s Status Regarding Their Mental Health Treatment: The proposed legislation allows for the defendant or prosecutor to petition the court to transfer the defendant from a residential mental health facility to a state prison or county jail, and provides that defendants have a right to counsel for those proceedings. From a practical standpoint, appointing counsel for an individual who is in a residential mental health treatment facility presents challenges for a system where most of the defendants are represented by Public Defender Offices. Public Defender Offices are accustomed to visiting and representing clients in custody at the local county jail. To see and represent clients placed in a variety of mental health facilities that can be in disparate geographic regions would present substantial obstacles to such representation. The same obstacles are present if a defendant in state prison required representation, in the sentencing court, on a petition to remove the defendant from a mental health program in the state prison.
Michigan: The state of Michigan passed Senate Bill 558 in 2014. That law requires county law enforcement and community mental health service programs, in coordination with courts and other key local partners, to create policies and practices that would provide mental health treatment and assistance to individuals with mental illness. Specifically, the policies and practices created would focus on individuals who are considered at risk of entering the criminal justice system; who not receiving needed mental health services during incarceration in a county jail or state prison; and who are not receiving needed mental health treatment services upon release or discharge from a county jail.
http://michigan.gov/snyder/0,4668,7-277-57577-323279--,00.html
Argument in Support: According to David Mills (Chairman) and Michael Romano(Director), of the Stanford Law School Three Strikes and Justice Advocacy Project, “The Mental Health Justice Act (AB 1006) is the embodiment of the first reform proposed in our report. The bill is critically important because it will—for the first time—empower Superior Court Judges discretionary authority to order psychiatric treatment for criminal offenders who commit crimes as a result of mental illness. The bill does not require courts to do anything and protects public safety by forbidding judges from departing from traditional sentencing if doing so would endanger the public. Involving the courts in the identification and treatment of mentally ill offenders is a crucial step in addressing the massive problem of mental ill offenders in the justice system. We believe the measure will also save tax dollars and reduce recidivism by providing earlier interruption in the cycle of mental illness and incarceration.
“According to a recent report from the national Sheriff’s Association and Treatment Advocacy Center, ten times as many mentally ill people are in prison and jail in the United States than there are in mental health treatment facilities. In California, 45% of the state’s prison population is estimated to be mentally ill. In the last fifteen years the number of mentally ill people in prison has almost doubled.
“Furthermore, there are five times the numbers of seriously mental ill prisoners confined in state prison than there are patients in psychiatric hospitals, making the California Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation the de facto mental health treatment provider in the state.
“This
bill will reform the way California sentences the mentally ill by
allowing a court do determine if the mental illness is a substantial
factor in the crime and give the court the ability to order treatment
for that illness.”
Prior Legislation:
SB 1054 (Steinberg), Chapter 436, Statutes of 2014, clarifies that mental health grants be divided equally between adult and juvenile mentally ill offender crime reduction grants and streamline the grant process.
SB 1323 (Cedillo), of the 2005-06 Legislative Session, would have appropriated $350,000 from the General Fund to the department for allocation, over 5 years, to the County of Los Angeles, at the consent of the county, for the purpose of funding one position to work, in conjunction with the Los Angeles County Superior Court, on a 5‑year Prototype Court Pilot Program for nonviolent felony offenders in the state who have been identified as having both serious mental health and substance abuse problems. SB 1323 was held in the Senate Appropriations Committee.
SB 643 (Ortiz), of the 2001-02 Legislative Session, would have enacted the Mental Health Enhancement and Crime Prevention Act of 2001, which would require the board to reimburse counties meeting specified requirements for the excess cost of providing more effective psychotropic medications to inmates in county correctional facilities during their incarceration and after release. SB 643 was held in the Assembly Appropriations Committee.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
Steinberg Institute (Sponsor)
California Council of Community Mental Health Agencies
Mental Health America of California
Chairman and Director of the Stanford Law School Three Strikes and Justice Advocacy Project
Legal Services for Prisoners with Children
Opposition
California District Attorneys Association
Analysis Prepared by:
David Billingsley / PUB. S. / (916) 319-3744
1 http://www.cdcr.ca.gov/comio/Legislation.html
2 Steadman, H., Osher, F. C., Robbins, P. C., Case, B., & Samuels, S. (2009). Prevalence of serious mental illness among jail inmates. Psychiatric Services, 60(6), 761-765. <http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/19487344>.
3 Administrative Office of the Courts, Center for Families, Children & the Courts. (2011). Task Force for Criminal Justice Collaboration on Mental Health Issues: Final Report. <http://www.mentalcompetency.org/resources/guides-standards/files/California%20Mental%20Health%20Task%20Force%20Report.pdf>.
4 Berkeley Center for Criminal Justice. (2010). Juvenile Justice Policy Brief Series: Mental Health Issues in California’s Juvenile Justice System. <https://www.law.berkeley.edu/img/BCCJ_Mental_Health_Policy_Brief_May_2010.pdf>
5 Treatment Advocacy Center & National Sheriffs’ Association. (2010). More Mentally Ill Persons Are in Jails and Prisons Than Hospitals: A Survey of States. <http://www.treatmentadvocacycenter.org/storage/documents/final_jails_v_hospitals_study.pdf>
6 University of Utah, Utah Criminal Justice Center. (2012). Treating Offenders with Mental Illness: A Review of the Literature. <http://ucjc.utah.edu/wp-content/uploads/MIO-butters-6-30-12-FINAL.pdf>.
7 https://s3.amazonaws.com/static.nicic.gov/Library/023634.pdf.
8 http://www.cdcr.ca.gov/adult_research_branch/Research_Documents/ARB_FY_0708_Recidivism_Report_10.23.12.pdf.
9 California Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation. (2005). Status Report on Juvenile Justice Reform.
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):