SB 29: Law enforcement: immigration.
- Session Year: 2017-2018
- House: Senate
- Latest Version Date: 2017-10-05
Existing law generally regulates formation and enforcement of contracts, including what constitutes an unlawful contract. Under existing law, a contract is unlawful if it is contrary to an express provision of law, contrary to the policy of express law, though not expressly prohibited, or otherwise contrary to good morals.
Existing law authorizes a county board of supervisors on behalf of its sheriff, and a legislative body of a city on behalf of its chief of police, to contract to provide supplemental law enforcement services to private individuals, private entities, and private corporations in specified circumstances and subject to certain conditions.
This bill would, commencing on January 1, 2018, prohibit a city, county, city and county, or a local law enforcement agency that does not, as of that date, have a contract with the federal government or any federal agency or a private corporation to detain noncitizens for the purposes of civil immigration custody from entering into a contract with those entities to house or detain in a locked detention facility noncitizens for purposes of civil immigration custody. The bill would further prohibit a city, county, city and county, or local law enforcement agency that, as of January 1, 2018, has an existing contract with the federal government or any federal agency or a private corporation to house or detain noncitizens for purposes of civil immigration custody, from renewing or modifying that contract, on and after that date, in a manner that would expand the maximum number of contract beds that may be utilized to house or detain, in a locked detention facility, noncitizens for purposes of civil immigration custody. This bill would prohibit, on and after January 1, 2018, a city, county, city and county, or a public agency from approving or signing a deed, instrument, or other document related to a conveyance of land or issuing a permit for the building or reuse of existing buildings by a private corporation, contractor, or vendor to house or detain noncitizens for the purposes of civil immigration proceedings unless the city, county, city and county, or public agency has provided specified notice to the public and solicited and heard public comments regarding the action.
The California Public Records Act requires state and local agencies to make their records available for public inspection and to make copies available upon request and payment of a fee unless the records are exempt from disclosure.
This bill would specify that any facility that detains a noncitizen pursuant to a contract with a city, county, city and county, or a local law enforcement agency is subject to the California Public Records Act.
The bill would provide that its provisions are severable.
Existing law generally regulates formation and enforcement of contracts, including what constitutes an unlawful contract. Under existing law, a contract is unlawful if it is contrary to an express provision of law, contrary to the policy of express law, though not expressly prohibited, or otherwise contrary to good morals.
Existing law authorizes a county board of supervisors on behalf of its sheriff, and a legislative body of a city on behalf of its chief of police, to contract to provide supplemental law enforcement services to private individuals, private entities, and private corporations in specified circumstances and subject to certain conditions.
This bill would, commencing on January 1, 2018, prohibit a city, county, city and county, or a local law enforcement agency that does not, as of that date, have a contract with the federal government or any federal agency or a private corporation to detain noncitizens for the purposes of civil immigration custody from entering into a contract with those entities to house or detain in a locked detention facility noncitizens for purposes of civil immigration custody. The bill would further prohibit a city, county, city and county, or local law enforcement agency that, as of January 1, 2018, has an existing contract with the federal government or any federal agency or a private corporation to house or detain noncitizens for purposes of civil immigration custody, from renewing or modifying that contract, on and after that date, in a manner that would expand the maximum number of contract beds that may be utilized to house or detain, in a locked detention facility, noncitizens for purposes of civil immigration custody. This bill would prohibit, on and after January 1, 2018, a city, county, city and county, or a public agency from approving or signing a deed, instrument, or other document related to a conveyance of land or issuing a permit for the building or reuse of existing buildings by a private corporation, contractor, or vendor to house or detain noncitizens for the purposes of civil immigration proceedings unless the city, county, city and county, or public agency has provided specified notice to the public and solicited and heard public comments regarding the action.
The California Public Records Act requires state and local agencies to make their records available for public inspection and to make copies available upon request and payment of a fee unless the records are exempt from disclosure.
This bill would specify that any facility that detains a noncitizen pursuant to a contract with a city, county, city and county, or a local law enforcement agency is subject to the California Public Records Act.
The bill would provide that its provisions are severable.
Existing law generally regulates formation and enforcement of contracts, including what constitutes an unlawful contract. Under existing law, a contract is unlawful if it is contrary to an express provision of law, contrary to the policy of express law, though not expressly prohibited, or otherwise contrary to good morals.
Existing law authorizes a county board of supervisors on behalf of its sheriff, and a legislative body of a city on behalf of its chief of police, to contract to provide supplemental law enforcement services to private individuals, private entities, and private corporations in specified circumstances and subject to certain conditions.
This bill would, commencing on January 1, 2019, 2018, prohibit a city, county, or city and county, or a local law enforcement agency that does not, as of that date, have a contract with the federal government or any federal agency or a private corporation to detain noncitizens for the purposes of civil immigration custody from entering into, renewing, or extending the length of a contract with a private corporation, contractor, or vendor to detain immigrants in civil immigration proceedings for profit. into a contract with those entities to house or detain in a locked detention facility noncitizens for purposes of civil immigration custody. The bill would further prohibit a city, county, city and county, or local law enforcement agency that, as of January 1, 2018, has an existing contract with the federal government or any federal agency or a private corporation to house or detain noncitizens for purposes of civil immigration custody, from renewing or modifying that contract, on and after that date, in a manner that would expand the maximum number of contract beds that may be utilized to house or detain, in a locked detention facility, noncitizens for purposes of civil immigration custody. This bill would prohibit, on and after January 1, 2018, a city, county, city and county, or a public agency from approving or signing a deed, instrument, or other document related to a conveyance of land or issuing a permit for the building or reuse of existing buildings by a private corporation, contractor, or vendor to house or detain noncitizens for the purposes of civil immigration proceedings unless the city, county, city and county, or public agency has provided specified notice to the public and solicited and heard public comments regarding the action.
Existing law requires the Board of State and Community Corrections to establish minimum standards for local correctional facilities, as specified.This bill would require a city, county, or city and county, or a local law enforcement agency that chooses to enter into, renew, or extend a contract to detain immigrants in civil immigration proceedings to detain immigrants only pursuant to a contract that requires the immigration detention facility operator to adhere to specified standards.The California Public Records Act requires state and local agencies to make their records available for public inspection and to make copies available upon request and payment of a fee unless the records are exempt from disclosure.
This bill would specify that any facility that detains an immigrant a noncitizen pursuant to a contract with a city, county, city and county, or a local law enforcement agency is subject to the California Public Records Act.
Existing law, the Unruh Civil Rights Act, provides that all persons within the jurisdiction of California are free and equal no matter their national origin, citizenship, or immigration status and are entitled to full and equal accommodations, facilities, and privileges in all business establishments of every kind. Persons denied their rights under this act may obtain specified remedies, including treble damages.This bill would provide that an immigration detention facility operator, as defined, an agent thereof, or a person acting on its behalf, shall not deprive an immigrant detainee in civil immigration proceedings of specified rights, including access to an attorney or other authorized person, medical care, freedom from harm or harassment, or privacy. The bill would prohibit an immigration detention facility from involuntarily placing a detainee in segregated housing because of his or her actual or perceived gender, gender identity, gender expression, or sexual orientation.This bill would authorize the Attorney General or any district attorney or city attorney to bring a civil action against an immigration detention facility, an agent thereof, or a person acting on its behalf that violates a detainees rights, as specified.The bill would provide that its provisions are severable.
Existing law generally regulates formation and enforcement of contracts, including what constitutes an unlawful contract. Under existing law, a contract is unlawful if it is contrary to an express provision of law, contrary to the policy of express law, though not expressly prohibited, or otherwise contrary to good morals.
Existing law authorizes a county board of supervisors on behalf of its sheriff, and a legislative body of a city on behalf of its chief of police, to contract to provide supplemental law enforcement services to private individuals, private entities, and private corporations in specified circumstances and subject to certain conditions.
This bill would, commencing on January 1, 2019, prohibit a city, county, or city and county, or a local law enforcement agency from entering into, renewing, or extending the length of a contract with a private corporation, contractor, or vendor to detain immigrants in civil immigration proceedings for profit.
Existing law requires the Board of State and Community Corrections to establish minimum standards for local correctional facilities, as specified.
This bill would require a city, county, or city and county, or a local law enforcement agency that chooses to enter into, renew, or extend a contract to detain immigrants in civil immigration proceedings to detain immigrants only pursuant to a contract that requires the immigration detention facility operator to adhere to specified standards.
The California Public Records Act requires state and local agencies to make their records available for public inspection and to make copies available upon request and payment of a fee unless the records are exempt from disclosure.
This bill would specify that any facility that detains an immigrant pursuant to a contract with a city, county, city and county, or a local law enforcement agency is subject to the California Public Records Act.
Existing law, the Unruh Civil Rights Act, provides that all persons within the jurisdiction of California are free and equal no matter their national origin, citizenship, or immigration status and are entitled to full and equal accommodations, facilities, and privileges in all business establishments of every kind. Persons denied their rights under this act may obtain specified remedies, including treble damages.
This bill would provide that an immigration detention facility operator, as defined, an agent thereof, or a person acting on its behalf, shall not deprive an immigrant detainee in civil immigration proceedings of specified rights, including access to an attorney or other authorized person, medical care, freedom from harm or harassment, or privacy. The bill would prohibit an immigration detention facility from involuntarily placing a detainee in segregated housing because of his or her actual or perceived gender, gender identity, gender expression, or sexual orientation.
This bill would authorize the Attorney General or any district attorney or city attorney to bring a civil action against an immigration detention facility, an agent thereof, or a person acting on its behalf that violates a detainees rights, as specified.
The bill would provide that its provisions are severable.
The Legislature finds and declares the following:
(a)In keeping with its obligation to safeguard the humane and just treatment of all individuals located in California, it is the intent of the Legislature that this bill declare that the state does not tolerate profiting from the incarceration of Californians held in immigration detention and the states desire to ensure the just and humane treatment of our most vulnerable populations.
(b)It is the further intent of the Legislature to ensure the uniform treatment of individuals detained within immigration detention facilities, operating in California, in a manner that meets or exceeds the federal national standards and other applicable legal requirements.
SEC. 2.Section 1670.9 is added to the Civil Code, to read:1670.9.(a)A city, county, city and county, or local law enforcement agency that does not, as of January 1, 2018, have a contract with the federal government or any federal agency or a private corporation to house or detain noncitizens for purposes of civil immigration custody, shall not, on and after January 1, 2018, enter into a contract with the federal government or any federal agency or a private corporation, to house or detain in a locked detention facility noncitizens for purposes of civil immigration custody.
(b)A city, county, city and county, or local law enforcement agency that, as of January 1, 2018, has an existing contract with the federal government or any federal agency or a private corporation to detain noncitizens for purposes of civil immigration custody, shall not, on and after January 1, 2018, renew or modify that contract in a manner that would expand the maximum number of contract beds that may be utilized to house or detain in a locked detention facility noncitizens for purposes of civil immigration custody.
(c)Any facility that detains a noncitizen pursuant to a contract with a city, county, city and county, or a local law enforcement agency is subject to the California Public Records Act (Chapter 3.5 (commencing with Section 6250) of Division 7 of Title 1 of the Government Code).
(d)A city, county, city and county, or public agency shall not, on and after January 1, 2018, approve or sign a deed, instrument, or other document related to a conveyance of land or issue a permit for the building or reuse of existing buildings by any private corporation, contractor, or vendor to house or detain noncitizens for purposes of civil immigration proceedings unless the city, county, city and county, or public agency has done both of the following:
(1)Provided notice to the public of the proposed conveyance or permitting action at least 180 days before execution of the conveyance or permit.
(2)Solicited and heard public comments on the proposed conveyance or permit action in at least two separate meetings open to the public.
SEC. 3.The provisions of this act are severable. If any provision of this act or its application is held invalid, that invalidity shall not affect other provisions or applications that can be given effect without the invalid provision or application.
The Legislature finds and declares the following:
(a)In keeping with its obligation to safeguard the humane and just treatment of all individuals located in California, it is the intent of the Legislature that this bill declare that the state does not tolerate profiting from the incarceration of Californians held in immigration detention and the states desire to ensure the just and humane treatment of our most vulnerable populations.
(b)It is the further intent of the Legislature to ensure the uniform treatment of individuals detained within immigration detention facilities, operating in California, in a manner that meets or exceeds the federal national standards and other applicable legal requirements.
SEC. 2.Section 1670.9 is added to the Civil Code, to read:1670.9.(a)A city, county, city and county, or local law enforcement agency that does not, as of January 1, 2018, have a contract with the federal government or any federal agency or a private corporation to house or detain noncitizens for purposes of civil immigration custody, shall not, on and after January 1, 2018, enter into a contract with the federal government or any federal agency or a private corporation, to house or detain in a locked detention facility noncitizens for purposes of civil immigration custody.
(b)A city, county, city and county, or local law enforcement agency that, as of January 1, 2018, has an existing contract with the federal government or any federal agency or a private corporation to detain noncitizens for purposes of civil immigration custody, shall not, on and after January 1, 2018, renew or modify that contract in a manner that would expand the maximum number of contract beds that may be utilized to house or detain in a locked detention facility noncitizens for purposes of civil immigration custody.
(c)Any facility that detains a noncitizen pursuant to a contract with a city, county, city and county, or a local law enforcement agency is subject to the California Public Records Act (Chapter 3.5 (commencing with Section 6250) of Division 7 of Title 1 of the Government Code).
(d)A city, county, city and county, or public agency shall not, on and after January 1, 2018, approve or sign a deed, instrument, or other document related to a conveyance of land or issue a permit for the building or reuse of existing buildings by any private corporation, contractor, or vendor to house or detain noncitizens for purposes of civil immigration proceedings unless the city, county, city and county, or public agency has done both of the following:
(1)Provided notice to the public of the proposed conveyance or permitting action at least 180 days before execution of the conveyance or permit.
(2)Solicited and heard public comments on the proposed conveyance or permit action in at least two separate meetings open to the public.
SEC. 3.The provisions of this act are severable. If any provision of this act or its application is held invalid, that invalidity shall not affect other provisions or applications that can be given effect without the invalid provision or application.
The Legislature finds and declares the following:
(a)In keeping with its obligation to safeguard the humane and just treatment of all individuals located in California, it is the intent of the Legislature that this bill declare that the state does not tolerate profiting from the incarceration of Californians held in immigration detention and the states desire to ensure the just and humane treatment of our most vulnerable populations.
(b)It is the further intent of the Legislature to ensure the uniform treatment of individuals detained within immigration detention facilities, operating in California, in a manner that meets or exceeds the federal national standards and other applicable legal requirements.
SEC. 2.Section 1670.9 is added to the Civil Code, to read:1670.9.(a)On or after January 1, 2019, city, county, city and county, or a local law enforcement agency shall not enter into or renew a contract, or modify a contract to extend the length of the contract, with a private corporation, contractor, or vendor to detain immigrants in civil immigration proceedings for profit.(b)If a city, county, city and county, or a local law enforcement agency chooses to enter into a contract, renews a contract, or modifies a contract to extend the length of the contract, to detain immigrants in civil immigration proceedings, it shall detain immigrants only pursuant to a contract that requires the immigration detention facility operator to adhere to the standards for detaining those individuals described in the 2011 Operations Manual ICE Performance-Based National Detention Standards as corrected and clarified in February 2013 and ICE Directive 11065.1 (Review of the Use of Segregation for ICE Detainees).1670.9.(a)A city, county, city and county, or local law enforcement agency that does not, as of January 1, 2018, have a contract with the federal government or any federal agency or a private corporation to house or detain noncitizens for purposes of civil immigration custody, shall not, on and after January 1, 2018, enter into a contract with the federal government or any federal agency or a private corporation, to house or detain in a locked detention facility noncitizens for purposes of civil immigration custody.
(b)A city, county, city and county, or local law enforcement agency that, as of January 1, 2018, has an existing contract with the federal government or any federal agency or a private corporation to detain noncitizens for purposes of civil immigration custody, shall not, on and after January 1, 2018, renew or modify that contract in a manner that would expand the maximum number of contract beds that may be utilized to house or detain in a locked detention facility noncitizens for purposes of civil immigration custody.
(c)Any facility that detains an immigrant a noncitizen pursuant to a contract with a city, county, city and county, or a local law enforcement agency is subject to the California Public Records Act (Chapter 3.5 (commencing with Section 6250) of Division 7 of Title 1 of the Government Code).
(d)An immigration detention facility operator, an agent of an immigration detention facility, or a person acting on behalf of an immigration detention facility shall not deprive any immigrant detainee in civil immigration proceedings access to an attorney or any other person authorized by the Board of Immigration Appeals under Section 292.2 of Title 8 of the Code of Federal Regulations, or access to a translator or interpretation services, medical care, freedom from harm or harassment, or privacy.(e)An immigrant detainee shall not be involuntarily placed in segregated housing in an immigration detention facility because of his or her actual or perceived gender, gender identity, gender expression, or sexual orientation, as defined in Section 422.56 of the Penal Code. Transgender and gender nonconforming immigrant detainees shall be given the option to choose a housing placement consistent with their gender identity.(f)Nothing in this section shall prohibit an immigration detention facility operator from exceeding the 2011 Operations Manual ICE Performance-Based National Detention Standards as corrected and clarified in February 2013 or ICE Directive 11065.1 (Review of the Use of Segregation for ICE Detainees).(g)If an immigration detention facility operator, or agent of an immigration detention facility, or person acting on behalf of an immigration detention facility violates subdivision (d) or (e), the 2011 Operations Manual ICE Performance-Based National Detention Standards as corrected and clarified in February 2013, or ICE Directive 11065.1 (Review of the Use of Segregation for ICE Detainees), the Attorney General, or any district attorney or city attorney, may bring a civil action for injunctive and other appropriate equitable relief in the name of the people of the State of California. An action brought by the Attorney General, any district attorney, or any city attorney may also seek a civil penalty of twenty-five thousand dollars ($25,000). If this civil penalty is requested, it shall be assessed individually against each person who is determined to have violated this section, and the penalty shall be awarded to each individual who has been injured under this section.(h)For purposes of this section, the following definitions shall apply:(1)Immigration detention facility means a facility where immigrants are detained for civil immigration proceedings pursuant to an agreement between a city, county, or city and county, or a law enforcement agency and either of the following:(A)The United States Department of Homeland Security or other federal agency.(B)A private corporation, contractor, or private vendor.(2)Immigration detention facility operator means an individual, firm, corporation, association, partnership, joint venture, commercial entity, municipality, commission, or political division of the State of California that operates or owns an immigration detention facility.(3)Segregated housing means administrative segregation or disciplinary segregation, as defined in the 2011 Operations Manual ICE Performance-Based National Detention Standards as corrected and clarified in February 2013, or any other act resulting in an individual being segregated from the general population through prolonged physical or social isolation for hours, days, weeks, or years.(d)A city, county, city and county, or public agency shall not, on and after January 1, 2018, approve or sign a deed, instrument, or other document related to a conveyance of land or issue a permit for the building or reuse of existing buildings by any private corporation, contractor, or vendor to house or detain noncitizens for purposes of civil immigration proceedings unless the city, county, city and county, or public agency has done both of the following:
(1)Provided notice to the public of the proposed conveyance or permitting action at least 180 days before execution of the conveyance or permit.
(2)Solicited and heard public comments on the proposed conveyance or permit action in at least two separate meetings open to the public.
SEC. 3.The provisions of this act are severable. If any provision of this act or its application is held invalid, that invalidity shall not affect other provisions or applications that can be given effect without the invalid provision or application.
The Legislature finds and declares the following:
(a)In keeping with its obligation to safeguard the humane and just treatment of all individuals located in California, it is the intent of the Legislature that this bill declare that the state does not tolerate profiting from the incarceration of Californians held in immigration detention and the states desire to ensure the just and humane treatment of our most vulnerable populations.
(b)It is the further intent of the Legislature to ensure the uniform treatment of individuals detained within immigration detention facilities, operating in California, in a manner that meets or exceeds the federal national standards and other applicable legal requirements.
SEC. 2.Section 1670.9 is added to the Civil Code, to read:1670.9.(a)On or after January 1, 2019, city, county, city and county, or a local law enforcement agency shall not enter into or renew a contract, or modify a contract to extend the length of the contract, with a private corporation, contractor, or vendor to detain immigrants in civil immigration proceedings for profit.
(b)If a city, county, city and county, or a local law enforcement agency chooses to enter into a contract, renews a contract, or modifies a contract to extend the length of the contract, to detain immigrants in civil immigration proceedings, it shall detain immigrants only pursuant to a contract that requires the immigration detention facility operator to adhere to the standards for detaining those individuals described in the 2011 Operations Manual ICE Performance-Based National Detention Standards as corrected and clarified in February 2013 and ICE Directive 11065.1 (Review of the Use of Segregation for ICE Detainees).
(c)Any facility that detains an immigrant pursuant to a contract with a city, county, city and county, or a local law enforcement agency is subject to the California Public Records Act (Chapter 3.5 (commencing with Section 6250) of Division 7 of Title 1 of the Government Code).
(d)An immigration detention facility operator, an agent of an immigration detention facility, or a person acting on behalf of an immigration detention facility shall not deprive any immigrant detainee in civil immigration proceedings access to an attorney or any other person authorized by the Board of Immigration Appeals under Section 292.2 of Title 8 of the Code of Federal Regulations, or access to a translator or interpretation services, medical care, freedom from harm or harassment, or privacy.
(e)An immigrant detainee shall not be involuntarily placed in segregated housing in an immigration detention facility because of his or her actual or perceived gender, gender identity, gender expression, or sexual orientation, as defined in Section 422.56 of the Penal Code. Transgender and gender nonconforming immigrant detainees shall be given the option to choose a housing placement consistent with their gender identity.
(f)Nothing in this section shall prohibit an immigration detention facility operator from exceeding the 2011 Operations Manual ICE Performance-Based National Detention Standards as corrected and clarified in February 2013 or ICE Directive 11065.1 (Review of the Use of Segregation for ICE Detainees).
(g)If an immigration detention facility operator, or agent of an immigration detention facility, or person acting on behalf of an immigration detention facility violates subdivision (d) or (e), the 2011 Operations Manual ICE Performance-Based National Detention Standards as corrected and clarified in February 2013, or ICE Directive 11065.1 (Review of the Use of Segregation for ICE Detainees), the Attorney General, or any district attorney or city attorney, may bring a civil action for injunctive and other appropriate equitable relief in the name of the people of the State of California. An action brought by the Attorney General, any district attorney, or any city attorney may also seek a civil penalty of twenty-five thousand dollars ($25,000). If this civil penalty is requested, it shall be assessed individually against each person who is determined to have violated this section, and the penalty shall be awarded to each individual who has been injured under this section.
(h)For purposes of this section, the following definitions shall apply:
(1)Immigration detention facility means a facility where immigrants are detained for civil immigration proceedings pursuant to an agreement between a city, county, or city and county, or a law enforcement agency and either of the following:
(A)The United States Department of Homeland Security or other federal agency.
(B)A private corporation, contractor, or private vendor.
(2)Immigration detention facility operator means an individual, firm, corporation, association, partnership, joint venture, commercial entity, municipality, commission, or political division of the State of California that operates or owns an immigration detention facility.
(3)Segregated housing means administrative segregation or disciplinary segregation, as defined in the 2011 Operations Manual ICE Performance-Based National Detention Standards as corrected and clarified in February 2013, or any other act resulting in an individual being segregated from the general population through prolonged physical or social isolation for hours, days, weeks, or years.
SEC. 3.The provisions of this act are severable. If any provision of this act or its application is held invalid, that invalidity shall not affect other provisions or applications that can be given effect without the invalid provision or application.
REVISIONS: HeadingLine 2.|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Oct 5, 2017 | Chaptered by Secretary of State. Chapter 494, Statutes of 2017. |
| Oct 5, 2017 | Approved by the Governor. |
| Sep 19, 2017 | Enrolled and presented to the Governor at 4 p.m. |
| Sep 13, 2017 | Assembly amendments concurred in. (Ayes 27. Noes 13.) Ordered to engrossing and enrolling. |
| Sep 11, 2017 | In Senate. Concurrence in Assembly amendments pending. |
| Sep 11, 2017 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Senate. |
| Sep 8, 2017 | Read third time and amended. |
| Sep 5, 2017 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| Sep 1, 2017 | Coauthors revised. |
| Jul 19, 2017 | July 19 set for first hearing. Placed on APPR. suspense file. |
| Jun 28, 2017 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 7. Noes 2.) (June 27). Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Jun 8, 2017 | Referred to Com. on JUD. |
| May 31, 2017 | In Assembly. Read first time. Held at Desk. |
| May 30, 2017 | Read third time. Passed. (Ayes 26. Noes 13. Page 1276.) Ordered to the Assembly. |
| May 26, 2017 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| May 25, 2017 | From committee: Do pass. (Ayes 5. Noes 2. Page 1176.) (May 25). |
| May 19, 2017 | Set for hearing May 25. |
| Apr 17, 2017 | April 17 hearing: Placed on APPR. suspense file. |
| Apr 5, 2017 | Set for hearing April 17. |
| Mar 29, 2017 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 5. Noes 2. Page 538.) (March 28). Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Mar 14, 2017 | Set for hearing March 28. |
| Jan 12, 2017 | Referred to Com. on JUD. |
| Dec 6, 2016 | From printer. May be acted upon on or after January 5. |
| Dec 5, 2016 | Introduced. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sep 13, 2017 | Unfinished Business SB29 Lara et al. Concurrence | Senate Floor |
Passed |
|
| Sep 11, 2017 | SB 29 Lara Senate Third Reading By REYES | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| Sep 8, 2017 | SB 29 Lara Senate Third Reading By REYES Amendment Set #1 | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| Sep 1, 2017 | Do pass. | Assembly Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Jun 27, 2017 | Do pass and be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Assembly Standing Committee on Judiciary |
Passed |
|
| May 30, 2017 | Senate 3rd Reading SB29 Lara | Senate Floor |
Passed |
|
| May 25, 2017 | Do pass | Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Apr 17, 2017 | Placed on suspense file | Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Mar 28, 2017 | Do pass, but first be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Senate Standing Committee on Judiciary |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | SB |
UNFINISHED BUSINESS
Bill No: SB 29
:
SENATE JUDICIARY COMMITTEE: 5-2, 3/28/17
AYES: Jackson, Hertzberg, Monning, Stern, Wieckowski
NOES: Moorlach, Anderson
SENATE APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE: 5-2, 5/25/17
AYES: Lara, Beall, Bradford, Hill, Wiener
NOES: Bates, Nielsen
SENATE FLOOR: 26-13, 5/30/17
AYES: Allen, Atkins, Beall, Bradford, De León, Dodd, Galgiani, Glazer, Hernandez, Hill, Hueso, Jackson, Lara, Leyva, McGuire, Mendoza, Mitchell, Monning, Newman, Pan, Portantino, Roth, Skinner, Stern, Wieckowski, Wiener
NOES: Anderson, Bates, Berryhill, Cannella, Fuller, Gaines, Moorlach, Morrell, Nguyen, Nielsen, Stone, Vidak, Wilk
NO VOTE RECORDED: Hertzberg
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 52-24, 9/11/17 - See last page for vote
DIGEST:
This bill establishes, after January 1, 2018, contracting restrictions and new notice and public hearing requirements, as specified, upon local governments and local law enforcement agencies with respect to contracts, building permits, and other official actions involving the federal government, federal agencies, or private corporations seeking to house or detain noncitizens for purposes of civil immigration custody.
Assembly Amendments
narrow the scope of this bill by deleting the provisions regarding federal detention standards, deleting provisions granting specified rights to detainees, and deleting the civil penalty and injunctive relief provisions.
ANALYSIS:
Existing law:
- Provides that everyone has the right to seek and to enjoy in other countries asylum from persecution.
- Protects asylum seekers by prohibiting the federal government from returning to their home countries people who have fled persecution on account of race, religion, nationality, political opinion, or membership in a social group.
- Provides that victims of certain crimes may obtain immigration relief through a Victim of Crime Visa (U-Visa) and victims of human trafficking may obtain immigration relief through a Victim of Human Trafficking Visa (T-Visa).
- Provides immigration relief that relies on a state’s interest in the welfare of children and provides for Special Immigrant Juvenile Status where a state determines that reunification with one or both of the immigrant’s parents is not viable due to abuse, neglect, abandonment, or similar basis found under state law and that it would not be in the child’s best interest to return to their home country.
- Establishes that the care and custody of unaccompanied minors is the responsibility of the Office of Refugee Resettlement in the Department of Health and Human Services instead of the Department of Homeland Security.
- Holds that immigrant detainees with mental disabilities who are facing deportation and who are unable to adequately represent themselves are entitled to qualified legal representatives provided by the federal government for representation during all phases of their immigration proceedings, including appeals and custody hearings.
This bill:
- Prohibits a city, county, city and county, or local law enforcement agency from entering into a contract with the federal government or any federal agency or a private corporation, to house or detain in a locked detention facility noncitizens for purposes of civil immigration custody if that local government or local law enforcement agency does not have an existing contract to do so as of January 1, 2018.
- Prohibits a city, county, city and county, or local law enforcement agency from renewing or modifying a contract in a manner that would expand the maximum number of contract beds that may be utilized to house or detain in a locked detention facility noncitizens for purposes of civil immigration custody when the local government or local law enforcement agency has an existing contract with the federal government or any federal agency or a private corporation to detain noncitizens for purposes of civil immigration custody as of January 1, 2018.
- Prohibits a city, county, city and county, or public agency from approving or signing a deed, instrument or other document related to a conveyance of land or issue a permit for the building or reuse of existing buildings by any private corporation, contractor, or vendor to house or detain noncitizens for purposes of civil immigration proceedings unless the local government or law enforcement agency has: provided notice to the public of the proposed conveyance or permitting action at least 180 days before execution of the conveyance or permit; and solicited and heard public comments on the proposed conveyance or permit action in at least two separate meetings open to the public.
- Subjects any facility that detains a noncitizen pursuant to a contract with a city, county, city and county, or a local law enforcement agency to the California Public Records Act.
- Makes related legislative findings and declarations, and includes a severability clause.
Background
In California, and around the country, for-profit detention facilities are increasingly relied upon to detain immigrants who are oftentimes eligible for Asylum, Special Immigrant Juvenile Status immigration relief, U-Visas, T-Visas, or other forms of immigration relief. Additionally, a few local government and local law enforcement entities choose to enter into agreements with federal immigration authorities to detain immigrants in their county or city jails on behalf of the federal immigration authorities.
For-profit detention facilities are accountable to their shareholders and not the people of the State of California. Oftentimes, immigrants in immigrant detention facilities are escaping persecution in their countries of origin and in need of special care due to their persecution or because they have suffered arduous journeys as unaccompanied children. Ensuring that immigrants are provided with the services they need to heal oftentimes is in contrast to corporate interests. Because these facilities are private, they routinely claim exemptions to the California’s Public Records Act and the federal Freedom of Information Act. Despite the lack of access to records through these acts, there have been reports of inadequate medical care, suicide attempts, sexual assault, and even deaths at for-profit immigrant detention facilities. Somewhat perversely, because immigration detention is technically a civil form of confinement, immigrants in immigrant detention facilities lack many of the safeguards of the criminal justice system, including access to counsel.
Many detainees have reported experiencing deplorable conditions at city and county immigrant detention facilities in violation of the national standards. Various reports indicate that the rights of Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual, and Transgender (LGBT) detained immigrants have been extensively violated at for-profit detention facilities and those run by local governmental agencies.
Last year, the Legislature passed SB 1289 (Lara), a bill similar to SB 29, but the Governor vetoed the bill. In his veto message the Governor wrote:
I have been troubled by recent reports detailing unsatisfactory conditions and limited access to counsel in private immigration detention facilities. The Department of Homeland Security, however, is now considering whether private contracting should continue for immigrant detention, and if so under what conditions. Their recommendations are expected in November. These actions indicate that a more permanent solution to this issue may be at hand. I urge the federal authorities to act swiftly.
Since the veto of SB 1289, a new President was elected who has made it clear in his executive orders and his administration’s enforcement guidelines that every undocumented immigrant could be a target of deportation. President Donald Trump has also made it clear that he intends to detain more immigrants and expand private for profit detention facility use.
Comments
The author writes:
SB 29 will stop local governments from entering into new contracts and place a moratorium on the expansion of existing contracts that local governments have with private for-profit immigration detention facilities in California. Additionally, the bill will require private detention facilities in California to adhere to the Public Records Act and require public notice before a local government issues approval of any permit or land use conveyance for a profit detention center.
With the new administration’s commitment to deport millions, it is even more crucial now than ever before, that California insists on humane and just treatment for all immigrants in our state.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: Fiscal Com.: Local:
According to the Senate Appropriations Committee, and based on a more expansive version of this bill, there are potential fiscal impacts on the Attorney General, local prosecutors, and local governments. There are potentially significant workload increases (General Fund) should the Attorney General choose to bring civil actions for injunctive and other equitable relief, offset in part by civil penalty revenues. To the extent the number and complexity of cases brought forward is significant, costs could rise into the hundreds of thousands of dollars annually. There are potentially significant non-reimbursable local costs (Local Funds) for local prosecutors to bring civil actions for injunctive and other equitable relief, offset in part by civil penalty revenues. There are also potentially significant losses of future revenue (Local Funds) due to the inability of local governments/ agencies to contract with for-profit entities for immigrant detention services. To the extent a local law enforcement agency opts to detain immigrants in its facilities through a direct contract with the federal government, the agency could incur potentially significant non-reimbursable costs (Local Funds) to ensure immigrant detainee rights as prescribed are met. There are also unknown and potentially major costs (private funds) for private contracts and vendors to adhere to the specified standards and processes for detainee transfers and rights to counsel, translators, interpreters, and medical care as outlined in this bill.
SUPPORT: (Verified 9/11/17)
Alliance for Boys and Men of Color
American Academy of Pediatrics, California
AFSCME, AFL-CIO
AFSCME, Local 685
Antelope Valley League of United Latin American Citizens
Association for Los Angles Deputy Sheriffs
Association of Deputy District Attorneys
California Catholic Conference
California Environmental Justice Alliance
California Health+ Advocates
California Immigrant Policy Center
California Latinas for Reproductive Justice
Community Clinic Association of Los Angeles County
Council on American-Islamic Relations
Equality California
Harvey Milk LGBT Democratic Club
Human Rights Defense Center
Immigrant Legal Resource Center
In the Public Interest
Inland Coalition for Immigrant Rights
Jewish Public Affairs Committee of California
Latino Coalition for a Healthy California
League of United Latin American Citizens
League of Women Voters of California
Los Angeles County Probation Officers’ Union
Los Angeles County Professional Peace Officers Association
Los Angeles LGBT Center
Los Angeles Police Protective League
Mixteco/Indigena Community Organizing Project
National Association of Social Workers, California Chapter
Pangea Legal Services
Riverside Sheriffs’ Association
San José Evergreen Community College District
Service Employees International Union
Services, Immigrant Rights and Education Network
Transgender Law Center
United Farm Workers
OPPOSITION: (Verified 9/11/17)
California State Sheriffs’ Association
Imperial County Board of Supervisors
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 52-24, 9/11/17
AYES: Aguiar-Curry, Arambula, Baker, Berman, Bloom, Bocanegra, Bonta, Burke, Caballero, Calderon, Cervantes, Chau, Chiu, Chu, Cooley, Cooper, Dababneh, Daly, Eggman, Friedman, Cristina Garcia, Gipson, Gloria, Gonzalez Fletcher, Gray, Holden, Irwin, Jones-Sawyer, Kalra, Levine, Limón, Low, McCarty, Medina, Mullin, Muratsuchi, Nazarian, O'Donnell, Quirk, Quirk-Silva, Reyes, Ridley-Thomas, Rodriguez, Rubio, Salas, Santiago, Mark Stone, Thurmond, Ting, Weber, Wood, Rendon
NOES: Acosta, Travis Allen, Bigelow, Chávez, Chen, Choi, Cunningham, Dahle, Flora, Fong, Frazier, Gallagher, Harper, Kiley, Lackey, Maienschein, Mathis, Mayes, Melendez, Obernolte, Patterson, Steinorth, Voepel, Waldron
NO VOTE RECORDED: Brough, Eduardo Garcia, Grayson
9/11/17 21:38:24
**** END ****
SENATE THIRD READING
STR Bill Id:SB 29
Author:(Lara)
As Amended Ver:September 8, 2017
Majority vote
SENATE VOTE: 26-13
Committee | Votes | Ayes | Noes |
Judiciary | 7-2 | Mark Stone, Chau, Chiu, Cristina Garcia, Kalra, Reyes, Ting | Kiley, Maienschein |
Appropriations | 11-5 | Gonzalez Fletcher, Bloom, Bocanegra, Bonta, Calderon, Chau, Eggman, Friedman, Eduardo Garcia, Jones-Sawyer, Reyes | Bigelow, Brough, Fong, Gallagher, Obernolte |
SUMMARY: Establishes, after January 1, 2018, contracting restrictions and new notice and public hearing requirements, as specified, upon local governments and local law enforcement agencies with respect to contracts, building permits, and other official actions involving the federal government, federal agencies, or private corporations seeking to house or detain noncitizens for purposes of civil immigration custody. Specifically, this bill:
- Prohibits any city, county, city and county, or local law enforcement agency from entering into any new contract with the federal government, any federal agency, or a private corporation to house or detain noncitizens for purposes of civil immigration custody if that entity does not already have such a contract for those purposes as of January 1, 2018.
- Prohibits any city, county, city and county, or local law enforcement agency that, as of January 1, 2018, has an existing contract with the federal government, any federal agency, or a private corporation to detain noncitizens for purposes of civil immigration custody, from renewing or modifying that contract, on or after January 1, 2018, in a manner that would expand the maximum number of contract beds that may be utilized to house or detain noncitizens in a locked detention facility for purposes of civil immigration custody.
- Provides that any facility that detains a noncitizen pursuant to a contract with a city, county, city and county, or a local law enforcement agency is subject to the California Public Records Act (Chapter 3.5 (commencing with Section 6250) of Division 7 of Title 1 of the Government Code).
- Prohibits any city, county, city and county, or public agency from (a) approving or signing a deed, instrument, or other document related to a conveyance of land; or (b) issuing permits for the building or reuse of existing buildings by any private corporation, contractor, or vendor to house or detain noncitizens for purposes of civil immigration proceedings unless that entity had done both of the following:
- Provided notice to the public of the proposed conveyance or permitting action at least 180 days before execution of the conveyance or permit; and
- Solicited and heard public comments on the proposed conveyance or permit action in at least two separate meetings open to the public.
FISCAL EFFECT: According to the Assembly Appropriations Committee:
- GF costs to the Department of Justice (DOJ) of $454,000 in 2018-19 and $767,000 in 2019-20 and ongoing for DOJ's civil rights enforcement division to handle increased workload from civil filings for alleged violations of the standards established in this bill. These costs could be offset, at least partially, by civil penalty revenues.
- Potential non-reimbursable local costs for local prosecutors to bring civil actions pursuant to this bill. These costs could be offset, at least partially by civil penalty revenues.
COMMENTS: According to the author: "With the new administration's commitment to deport millions, it is even more crucial now than ever before that California insists on humane and just treatment for all immigrants in our state. There have been consistent reports of human rights abuses in private detention facilities, including physical and sexual abuse, poor access to healthcare, little access to legal counsel, and overuse of solitary confinement, and even death."
Immigration detention facilities in California. Local governments and local law enforcement entities are not required to detain immigrants on behalf of federal immigration authorities. The ones in California that decide to detain immigrants do so by choice. Federal immigration authorities, either Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) or the United States (U.S.) Marshals, enter into Intergovernmental Service Agreements (IGSAs) with local governments or local law enforcement whereby the local entity agrees to detain immigrants on behalf of the federal government. Local governments or local law enforcement can then choose to detain the immigrants in their own facilities or subcontract with for-profit detention facilities instead.
According to figures provided by CIVIC, 62% of all ICE immigration detention beds in the U.S. are operated by for-profit prison corporations, up from 49% in 2009. They contend that operators of these private detention facilities make billions in profit each year from holding undocumented persons, while the California county and city partners in these intergovernmental service agreements experience little economic gain. There are currently four for-profit detention facilities in California, located in the cities of Adelanto, Bakersfield, Calexico, and San Diego. According to the author, these four privately run facilities hold almost 85% of detainees statewide, approximately 3,700 people, with the rest held in city and county jail facilities that contract with federal immigration authorities for the detention of immigrants, including the Yuba County Jail (Marysville), Rio Consumnes Correctional Center (Elk Grove), West County Detention Facility (Richmond), James Musick Facility (Irvine), Theo Lacy Facility (Orange), and the Santa Ana City Jail.
Reported patterns of widespread abuse of immigrants held in private detention facilities. Immigrant advocates, watchdog organizations, and human rights advocates have documented widespread incidents of abuse and mistreatment of immigrants held in private detention facilities in California, as well as in facilities in other states operated by the same companies that operate facilities in California. In its report "Abuse in Adelanto: An Investigation into a California Town's Immigration Jail," CIVIC details a number of disturbing examples of prolonged detention, medical abuse and neglect, violations of religious freedom, attempted suicides, and the negligent deaths of detainees—just at the Adelanto facility alone. The National Immigrant Justice Center reports that among Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual, and Transgender (LGBT) individuals in the detained population, there are higher accounts of the use of solitary confinement, sexual abuse, and poor medical care in immigration detention facilities. (See National Immigrant Justice Center, Stop Abuse of Detained LGBT Immigrants; available at: http://www.immigrantjustice.org/stop-abuse-detained-lgbt-immigrants)
Accordingly, as recently amended, this bill establishes a moratorium on new contracts, after January 1, 2018, between local governments and federal agencies or private contractors to house or detain noncitizens for purposes of civil immigration custody. More specifically, the bill prohibits any city, county, city and county, or local law enforcement agency from entering into any new contract with the federal government, any federal agency, or a private corporation to house or detain noncitizens for purposes of civil immigration custody if that entity does not already have such a contract for those purposes as of January 1, 2018. Furthermore, the bill provides that any city, county, city and county, or local law enforcement agency that, as of January 1, 2018, already contracts with the federal government or a private corporation for such purposes is prohibited from subsequently renewing or modifying that contract after that date in a manner that would expand the maximum number of contract beds that may be utilized to house or detain noncitizens for purposes of civil immigration custody. It should be noted that the Legislature lacks the authority to prohibit private facility operators from contracting directly with ICE or federal authorities to detain persons, and this bill does not overstep that authority and attempt to preclude such contracting.
Private immigration detention facilities operate with no mechanism for public oversight. The author contends that because private for-profit detention facilities operate with little to no oversight, they are essentially accountable only to their shareholders and not the people of the state of California. For-profit detention facilities claim exemptions to the public disclosure requirements under the Freedom of Information Act (FOIA) (5 United States Code Section 552) because they are private corporations, which makes the potentially unlawful conduct occurring within the facility hidden from discovery. For example, a 2013 article in Forbes noted that "if serious questions arise about…the 16,500 federal immigration detainees held in privately-operated facilities under contracts with the U.S. Department of Homeland Security, there's no legal remedy in place forcing those questions to be answered." (Matt Stroud, Private Prisons Are Exempted From Federal Disclosure Laws; Advocates Say that Should Change, (Feb. 7, 2013) Forbes.)
As a result, abuse and inhumane treatment of detainees is reportedly tolerated and persists in these facilities because the public has no dependable mechanism for getting information about what is going on behind closed doors. Journalists and advocacy groups are occasionally able to document problems and incidents of mistreatment at these facilities, but only with the cooperation of the facilities themselves. In order to establish greater transparency and oversight over what goes on within these facilities, this bill provides that any facility that detains a noncitizen pursuant to a contract with a city, county, city and county, or a local law enforcement agency is subject to the California Public Records Act (Chapter 3.5 (commencing with Section 6250) of Division 7 of Title 1 of the Government Code).
Increasing transparency of local government actions involving detention facilities. According to the author, more public transparency is also needed at the local government level when cities, counties, or public agencies take official actions that enable or otherwise involve the operation of detention facilities, because many of these decisions (for example, conveyance of real property or issuance of building permits) are done with little public awareness. Thus, recent amendments to the bill prohibit local governments from approving or signing a deed, instrument, or other document related to a conveyance of land, or issuing permits for the building or reuse of existing buildings by any private corporation, contractor, or vendor to house or detain noncitizens for purposes of civil immigration proceedings, unless that local government or agency has done both of the following: 1) provided notice to the public of the proposed conveyance or permitting action at least 180 days before execution of the conveyance or permit; and 2) solicited and heard public comments on the proposed conveyance or permit action in at least two separate public meetings.
Analysis Prepared by: Anthony Lew / JUD. / (916) 319-2334 FN: 0002145
SENATE THIRD READING
STR Bill Id:SB 29
Author:(Lara)
As Introduced Ver:December 5, 2016
Majority vote
SENATE VOTE: 26-13
Committee | Votes | Ayes | Noes |
Judiciary | 7-2 | Mark Stone, Chau, Chiu, Cristina Garcia, Kalra, Reyes, Ting | Kiley, Maienschein |
Appropriations | 11-5 | Gonzalez Fletcher, Bloom, Bocanegra, Bonta, Calderon, Chau, Eggman, Friedman, Eduardo Garcia, Jones-Sawyer, Reyes | Bigelow, Brough, Fong, Gallagher, Obernolte |
SUMMARY: Prohibits local governments and law enforcement from contracting with companies that operate for-profit immigration detention facilities, and requires these facilities to uphold national standards for humane treatment of detainees. Specifically, this bill:
- Prohibits a city, county, city and county, or a local law enforcement agency from entering into or renewing a contract, or modifying a contract to extend the length of the contract, with a private corporation, contractor, or vendor to detain immigrants in civil immigration proceedings for profit.
- Provides that when an immigration detention facility chooses to enter into a contract to detain immigrants in civil immigration proceedings, it shall detain immigrants only pursuant to a contract that requires the entity contracting with the Department of Homeland Security (DHS) or other federal agency to adhere to the standards for detaining those individuals described in the 2011 Operations Manual Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) Performance-Based National Detention Standards as corrected and clarified in February 2013 and ICE Directive 11065.1 (Review of the Use of Segregation for ICE Detainees).
- Prohibits immigration detention facilities, their agents, or those acting on their behalf from depriving immigrant detainees from: (a) access to an attorney or other authorized legal representative; (b) access to translation or interpreters; (c) medical care; (d) freedom from harm or harassment; and (e) privacy.
- Prohibits the involuntary placement of immigrant detainees in segregated housing because of the detainee's actual or perceived gender, gender identity, gender expression, or sexual orientation.
- Clarifies that an immigration detention facility can provide more rights than are required under the 2011 Operations Manual ICE Performance-Based National Detention Standards as corrected and clarified in February 2013 or ICE Directive 11065.1 (Review of the Use of Segregation for ICE Detainees).
- Authorizes the Attorney General, any district attorney, or city attorney to bring a civil action for injunctive and other appropriate equitable relief in the name of the people of the State of California and seek a civil penalty of $25,000, as specified, when an immigration detention facility, or its agent or person acting on its behalf deprives an immigrant detainee of their rights created under this bill or rights under the 2011 Operations Manual ICE Performance-Based National Detention Standards as corrected and clarified in February 2013, or ICE Directive 11065.1 (Review of the Use of Segregation for ICE Detainees).
- Requires that if a civil penalty is requested by the Attorney General, a district attorney, or city attorney, the civil penalty shall be assessed individually against each person who is determined to have violated the legal rights of a detained immigrant and awarded to each individual who has been injured under these provisions.
FISCAL EFFECT: According to the Assembly Appropriations Committee:
- GF costs to the Department of Justice (DOJ) of $454,000 in 2018-19 and $767,000 in 2019-20 and ongoing for DOJ's civil rights enforcement division to handle increased workload from civil filings for alleged violations of the standards established in this bill. These costs could be offset, at least partially, by civil penalty revenues.
- Potential non-reimbursable local costs for local prosecutors to bring civil actions pursuant to this bill. These costs could be offset, at least partially by civil penalty revenues.
COMMENTS: This bill, co-sponsored by Community Initiatives for Visiting Immigrants in Confinement (CIVIC) and the Immigrant Legal Resource Center, seeks to prohibit local governments and law enforcement from contracting with companies that operate for-profit immigration detention facilities, and requires these facilities to uphold national standards for humane treatment of detainees. According to the author: "With the new administration's commitment to deport millions, it is even more crucial now than ever before that California insists on humane and just treatment for all immigrants in our state. There have been consistent reports of human rights abuses in private detention facilities, including physical and sexual abuse, poor access to healthcare, little access to legal counsel, and overuse of solitary confinement, and even death. Ultimately, SB 29 will ensure that immigrants who are being detained do not face abuse or neglect in detention."
Immigration detention facilities in California. Local governments and local law enforcement entities are not required to detain immigrants on behalf of federal immigration authorities. The ones in California that decide to detain immigrants do so by choice. Federal immigration authorities, either ICE or the U.S. Marshals, enter into Intergovernmental Service Agreements (IGSAs) with local governments or local law enforcement whereby the local entity agrees to detain immigrants on behalf of the federal government. Local governments or local law enforcement can then choose to detain the immigrants in their own facilities or subcontract with for-profit detention facilities instead.
According to figures provided by CIVIC, 62% of all ICE immigration detention beds in the U.S. are operated by for-profit prison corporations, up from 49% in 2009. They contend that operators of these private detention facilities make billions in profit each year from holding undocumented persons, while the California county and city partners in these intergovernmental service agreements experience little economic gain. There are currently four for-profit detention facilities in California, located in the cities of Adelanto, Bakersfield, Calexico, and San Diego. According to the author, these four privately run facilities hold almost 85% of detainees statewide, approximately 3,700 people, with the rest held in city and county jail facilities that contract with federal immigration authorities for the detention of immigrants, including the Yuba County Jail (Marysville), Rio Consumnes Correctional Center (Elk Grove), West County Detention Facility (Richmond), James Musick Facility (Irvine), Theo Lacy Facility (Orange), and the Santa Ana City Jail.
Private immigration detention facilities operate with no mechanism for public oversight. The author contends that because private for-profit detention facilities operate with little to no oversight, they are essentially accountable only to their shareholders and not the people of the state of California. For-profit detention facilities claim exemptions to the public disclosure requirements under the Freedom of Information Act (FOIA) (5 United States Code Section 552) because they are private corporations, which makes the potentially unlawful conduct occurring within the facility hidden from discovery. For example, a 2013 article in Forbes noted that "if serious questions arise about…the 16,500 federal immigration detainees held in privately-operated facilities under contracts with the U.S. Department of Homeland Security, there's no legal remedy in place forcing those questions to be answered." (Matt Stroud, Private Prisons Are Exempted From Federal Disclosure Laws; Advocates Say that Should Change, (Feb. 7, 2013) Forbes.)
As a result, abuse and inhumane treatment of detainees is reportedly tolerated and persists in these facilities because the public has no dependable mechanism for getting information about what is going on behind closed doors. Journalists and advocacy groups like CIVIC are occasionally able to document problems and incidents of mistreatment at these facilities, but only with the cooperation of the facilities themselves. The public policy of California is certainly not to allow the abuse of people who are detained by the government in facilities where there is no transparency or oversight. Accordingly, starting January 1, 2019, this bill would prohibit local governments and law enforcement from contracting with companies that operate for-profit immigration detention facilities to detain immigrants. Although the Legislature lacks authority to prohibit private immigration detention facility operators from contracting directly with ICE or federal authorities to hold immigrants, this bill does not attempt to preclude such contracting.
Despite lack of transparency, advocates have documented patterns of widespread abuse of immigrants held in private detention facilities. The Committee has received a number of reports and letters in support of this bill from immigrant advocates, watchdog organizations, and human rights advocates describing widespread incidents of abuse and mistreatment of immigrants held in private detention facilities in California, as well as in facilities in other states operated by the same companies that operate facilities in California. In its report "Abuse in Adelanto: An Investigation into a California Town's Immigration Jail," CIVIC details a number of disturbing examples of prolonged detention, medical abuse and neglect, violations of religious freedom, attempted suicides, and the negligent deaths of detainees—just at the Adelanto facility alone. The National Immigrant Justice Center reports that among Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual, and Transgender (LGBT) individuals in the detained population, there are higher accounts of the use of solitary confinement, sexual abuse, and poor medical care in immigration detention facilities. (See National Immigrant Justice Center, Stop Abuse of Detained LGBT Immigrants; available at: http://www.immigrantjustice.org/stop-abuse-detained-lgbt-immigrants) To address these issues, the bill prohibits immigration detention facilities, their agents, or those acting on their behalf, from depriving immigrant detainees of medical care, freedom from harm or harassment, and privacy. The bill also prohibits the involuntary placement of immigrant detainees in segregated housing because of the detainee’s actual or perceived gender, gender identity, gender expression, or sexual orientation.
Lack of access to legal representation and telephone communication. Because immigration proceedings are civil, not criminal, detainees have fewer rights than criminal defendants, including the right to an attorney. CIVIC reports, for example, that of the 89 people detained at ADF that it monitored over a six-month period, only 12.3% had legal representation—below the already low national average of 16% (Abuse in Adelanto: An Investigation into a California Town's Immigration Jail (October 2015); CIVIC and Detention Watch Network.) Because most detainees go completely without legal representation, it is essential that they have access to a law library or telephone communications where they can communicate with advocates or family members outside the center who can arrange assistance. Even where detainees at Adelanto had legal representation, CIVIC reported the difficulties that these people experienced due to obstructive actions taken by facility staff. The lack of access to legal representation is even more tragic because many detainees in custody may, in fact, qualify to remain in the U.S., but are instead deported because they were never able to obtain the assistance of legal counsel. Accordingly, this bill specifically prohibits immigration detention facilities from depriving immigrant detainees access to an attorney or other authorized legal representative, and access to translation or interpreters.
Codifying the national standards for basic care in immigration detention facilities, promulgated by ICE for facilities it contracts with. ICE has promulgated a series of national standards laying out the requirements for basic care in immigration detention facilities, known as the Performance-Based National Detention Standards 2011 as corrected and clarified in February 2013 (Hereafter, PBNDS 2011). ICE uses national detention standards to govern conditions of confinement in its detention facilitates established through contracts with those facilities. (United States Government Accountability Office, "Immigration Detention" Additional Actions Could Strengthen DHS Efforts to Address Sexual Abuse, p. 12 (Nov. 2013), Available at: http://www.gao.gov/assets/660/659145.pdf) Immigration detention facilities agree to follow these standards pursuant to the Inter-governmental Service Agreements (IGSAs) between the federal government and the local governments, including when the local entities contract out with for-profit corporations.
This bill is necessary, proponents contend, to address the fact that although the PBNDS 2011 standards may be agreed to under the contract, the standards are unenforceable because adherence is not required under any federal or state law. They contend that many of the abuses documented in California violate the PBNDS 2011, but because the standards are not legally binding and have only been implemented at select facilities that have voluntarily elected to modify their operating agreements with ICE, there is virtually no recourse for detainees under existing law when the detention facilities violate these standards.
Accordingly, this bill seeks to create enforceable rights for immigrant detainees centered on the national standards described above. The bill provides that when an immigration detention facility chooses to enter into a contract to detain immigrants in civil immigration proceedings, it shall detain immigrants only pursuant to a contract that requires the entity contracting with DHS or other federal agency to adhere to the PBNDS 2011 standards, as well as ICE Directive 11065.1. The bill makes clear that, as a policy matter, every immigration detention facility in California should be subject to the same national standards for the detention of immigrants, including private detention facilities contracted with local governments. Mandating that private immigration detention facilities in California meet national standards is intended to prevent and reduce patterns of abuse that have been documented in these facilities.
Enforcement provisions. This bill would require that immigration detention facilities adhere to the PBNDS 2011 standards, ICE Directive 11065.1, and other rights granted by this bill. Unlike its predecessor legislation, SB 1289 (Lara) of 2016, vetoed by the Governor, there is no private right of action to enable detainees to sue on their own behalf. Instead, enforcement of these provisions is much more limited; the Attorney General, or any district attorney or city attorney may bring a civil action for injunctive and other appropriate equitable relief in the name of the people of the State of California. The prosecuting attorney may also seek a civil penalty of $25,000, as specified, when an immigration detention facility deprives an immigrant detainee of their rights created under this bill, or their rights under the PBNDS 2011 standards or ICE Directive 11065.1.
The bill is opposed by the California State Sheriffs' Association (CSSA), who believe that the bill "inappropriately inserts the state into matters that are appropriately governed by federal authorities" and that "it is certainly possible that this measure would be preempted by federal law." According to Judiciary Committee staff, however, it should be noted that this bill merely restricts the ability of local government and law enforcement to contract with private companies, and imposes certain standards of treatment to be upheld in private detention facilities. Neither of these actions interfere or conflict with the federal government's ability to enforce federal immigration laws, and thus are unlikely to cause this bill to be preempted by federal law if challenged in court.
Analysis Prepared by: Anthony Lew / JUD. / (916) 319-2334 FN: 0001645
Date of Hearing: July 19, 2017
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Lorena Gonzalez Fletcher, Chair
SBPCA Bill Id:SB 29
Author:(Lara) – As Introduced Ver:December 5, 2016
Policy Committee: | Judiciary | Vote: | 7 - 2 |
|
| ||
|
|
Urgency: No State Mandated Local Program: No Reimbursable: No
SUMMARY:
This bill prohibits local governments and law enforcement from contracting with companies that operate for-profit immigration detention facilities, and requires these facilities to uphold national standards for humane treatment of detainees. Specifically, this bill:
- Prohibits a city, county, city and county, or a local law enforcement agency from entering into or renewing a contract, or modifying a contract to extend the length of the contract, with a private corporation, contractor, or vendor to detain immigrants in civil immigration proceedings for profit.
- Requires a city, county, city and county, or local law enforcement agency that chooses to enter into a contract to detain immigrants in civil immigration proceedings, to detain immigrants only pursuant to a contract that requires immigration detention facility to adhere to the standards for detaining those individuals described in the 2011 Operations Manual Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) Performance-Based National Detention Standards as corrected and clarified in February 2013 and ICE Directive 11065.1 (Review of the Use of Segregation for ICE Detainees).
- Prohibits immigration detention facilities, their agents, or those acting on their behalf from depriving immigrant detainees from: (a) access to an attorney or other authorized legal representative; (b) access to translation or interpreters; (c) medical care; (d) freedom from harm or harassment; and (e) privacy.
- Prohibits the involuntary placement of immigrant detainees in segregated housing because of the detainee’s actual or perceived gender, gender identity, gender expression, or sexual orientation.
- Authorizes the Attorney General, any district attorney, or city attorney to bring a civil action for injunctive and other appropriate equitable relief in the name of the people of the State of California and seek a civil penalty of $25,000, as specified, when an immigration detention facility, or its agent or person acting on its behalf deprives an immigrant detainee of their rights created under this bill or rights under the 2011 Operations Manual ICE Performance-Based National Detention Standards as corrected and clarified in February 2013, or ICE Directive 11065.1 (Review of the Use of Segregation for ICE Detainees).
FISCAL EFFECT:
- GF costs to the Department of Justice (DOJ) of $454,000 in 2018-19 and $767,000 in 2019-20 and ongoing for DOJ’s civil rights enforcement division to handle increased workload from civil filings for alleged violations of the standards established in this bill. These costs could be offset, at least partially, by civil penalty revenues.
- Potential non-reimbursable local costs for local prosecutors to bring civil actions pursuant to this bill. These costs could be offset, at least partially by civil penalty revenues.
COMMENTS:
- Background. Local governments and local law enforcement entities are not required to detain immigrants on behalf of federal immigration authorities. However, these entities can choose to detain immigrants. Federal immigration authorities, either U.S. Immigration & Customs Enforcement (ICE) or the U.S. Marshals, can enter into Intergovernmental Service Agreements (IGSAs) with local governments or local law enforcement for the detention of immigrants on behalf of the federal government. Local governments or local law enforcement can then choose to detain the immigrants in their own facilities or subcontract with for-profit detention facilities instead.
- Purpose. According to the author, these privately run facilities hold almost 85% of detainees statewide, approximately 3,700 people, with the rest held in county jail facilities that contract with federal immigration authorities. The author contends that because private for-profit detention facilities operate with little to no oversight, they are essentially accountable only to their shareholders and not the people of the state of California. For-profit detention facilities claim exemptions to the public disclosure requirements under the Freedom of Information Act (FOIA) because they are private corporations. This lack of transparency makes the potentially unlawful conduct occurring within the facility hidden from discovery.
According to the author, ‘With the new administration's commitment to deport millions, it is even more crucial now than ever before that California insists on humane and just treatment for all immigrants in our state. There have been consistent reports of human rights abuses in private detention facilities, including physical and sexual abuse, poor access to healthcare, little access to legal counsel, and overuse of solitary confinement, and even death. SB 29 will prohibit local governments from contracting with private companies to detain immigrants for profit. This bill will also require detention facilities to meet the basic standards laid out by ICE’s 2011 Performance-Based National Detention Standards. Ultimately, SB 29 will ensure that immigrants who are being detained do not face abuse or neglect in detention.”
Analysis Prepared by: Jessica Peters / APPR. / (916) 319-2081
Date of Hearing: June 27, 2017
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON JUDICIARY
Mark Stone, Chair
SBPCA Bill Id:SB 29
Author:(Lara) – As Introduced Ver:December 5, 2016
SENATE VOTE: 26-13
SUBJECT: LAW ENFORCEMENT: IMMIGRATION DETENTION FACILITIES
KEY ISSUES:
- BECAUSE OF THE LACK OF PUBLIC OVERSIGHT AND ACCOUNTABILITY IN PRIVATE FACILitIES, SHOULD local governments and law enforcement agencies be prohibITed from contracting with companies that operate PRIVATE facilIties for profit to detain immigrants in civil immigration proceedings?
- IN LIGHT OF REPORTED ABUSE OF IMMIGRANTS DETAINED IN SUCH FACILITIES, should immigration detention facilities in california that are operated by for-profit companies be required to uphold national minimum standards for the humane treatment of detainees?
SYNOPSIS
Federal immigration authorities, namely the U.S. Immigration & Customs Enforcement (ICE) or the U.S. Marshals, enter into Intergovernmental Service Agreements (IGSAs) with local governments or local law enforcement whereby the local entity agrees to detain immigrants on behalf of the federal government. Local governments or local law enforcement can then choose to detain the immigrants in their own publicly-run facilities (i.e. county jails) or to subcontract with for-profit operators of private detention facilities instead. The author contends that because these private detention facilities operate with little to no public oversight and are not subject to public disclosure laws, such as the Freedom of Information Act, they are essentially accountable only to their shareholders and not the people of the State of California. As a result, abuse and inhumane treatment of detainees is reportedly tolerated and persists in these facilities because the public has no dependable mechanism for getting information about what is going on behind closed doors. To corroborate these claims, the Committee has received a number of reports and letters from immigrant advocates, watchdog organizations, and human rights advocates describing investigations that have uncovered widespread incidents of abuse and mistreatment of immigrants who are held in private detention facilities in California.
This bill, co-sponsored by Community Initiatives for Visiting Immigrants in Confinement (CIVIC) and the Immigrant Legal Resource Center, seeks to prohibit local governments and law enforcement from contracting with companies that operate for-profit immigration detention facilities, and requires these facilities to uphold national standards for humane treatment of detainees. These national standards are promulgated by ICE itself to govern conditions of confinement in its detention facilitates established through contracts with those facility operators, and are known as the Performance-Based National Detention Standards 2011 (aka "PBNDS 2011"). Among the standards codified by this bill are provisions that prohibit immigrant detainees from being deprived of access to an attorney or other authorized legal representative; access to translation or interpreters; medical care; freedom from harm or harassment; and privacy. The bill also creates a number of other protections and rights for immigrant detainees that would be enforceable under the bill.
This bill is needed, proponents contend, to address the fact that although the PBNDS 2011 standards may apply under contracts between ICE and detention facilities, the standards are ultimately unenforceable because neither federal nor state law requires adherence to them. Accordingly, this bill would require that immigrant detention facilities adhere to the PBNDS 2011 standards and ICE Directive 11065.1, and protect other rights granted by this bill. The Attorney General, district attorneys, and city attorneys are empowered to enforce these provisions on behalf of the people, although there is no private right of action. This bill is a follow-up to AB 1289 (Lara) of 2016, which was approved by this Committee last year, but ultimately vetoed by Governor Brown, who stated he wanted to wait to see possible new federal regulations from the Obama administration before signing the bill. In light of the changed circumstances in the White House, this bill was introduced in December and is supported by a broad coalition of immigrant advocates, labor organizations, human rights advocates, and some local public safety groups. The bill is opposed by the California State Sheriffs Association and Imperial County, who contend, among other things, that their authority to contract with private detention facilities should not be limited, and that there is already sufficient oversight under federally-created standards and minimum standards provided by state regulations.
SUMMARY: Prohibits local governments and law enforcement from contracting with companies that operate for-profit immigration detention facilities, and requires these facilities to uphold national standards for humane treatment of detainees. Specifically, this bill:
- Prohibits a city, county, city and county, or a local law enforcement agency from entering into or renewing a contract, or modifying a contract to extend the length of the contract, with a private corporation, contractor, or vendor to detain immigrants in civil immigration proceedings for profit.
- Provides that when an immigration detention facility chooses to enter into a contract to detain immigrants in civil immigration proceedings, it shall detain immigrants only pursuant to a contract that requires the entity contracting with DHS or other federal agency to adhere to the standards for detaining those individuals described in the 2011 Operations Manual Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) Performance-Based National Detention Standards as corrected and clarified in February 2013 and ICE Directive 11065.1 (Review of the Use of Segregation for ICE Detainees).
- Prohibits immigration detention facilities, their agents, or those acting on their behalf from depriving immigrant detainees from: (a) access to an attorney or other authorized legal representative; (b) access to translation or interpreters; (c) medical care; (d) freedom from harm or harassment; and (e) privacy.
- Prohibits the involuntary placement of immigrant detainees in segregated housing because of the detainee’s actual or perceived gender, gender identity, gender expression, or sexual orientation.
- Clarifies that an immigration detention facility can provide more rights than are required under the 2011 Operations Manual ICE Performance-Based National Detention Standards as corrected and clarified in February 2013 or ICE Directive 11065.1 (Review of the Use of Segregation for ICE Detainees).
- Authorizes the Attorney General, any district attorney, or city attorney to bring a civil action for injunctive and other appropriate equitable relief in the name of the people of the State of California and seek a civil penalty of $25,000, as specified, when an immigration detention facility, or its agent or person acting on its behalf deprives an immigrant detainee of their rights created under this bill or rights under the 2011 Operations Manual ICE Performance-Based National Detention Standards as corrected and clarified in February 2013, or ICE Directive 11065.1 (Review of the Use of Segregation for ICE Detainees).
- Requires that if a civil penalty is requested by the Attorney General, a district attorney, or city attorney, the civil penalty shall be assessed individually against each person who is determined to have violated the legal rights of a detained immigrant and awarded to each individual who has been injured under these provisions.
- Defines the key terms "immigration detention facility," "immigration detention facility operator," and "segregated housing."
EXISTING STATE LAW:
- Permits the board of supervisors of any county to contract on behalf of the sheriff of that county, and the legislative body of any city may contract on behalf of the chief of police of that city, to provide supplemental law enforcement services to specified entities under certain conditions, including to private individuals or private entities to preserve the peace at special events or occurrences that happen on an occasional basis. (Government Code 53069.8 (a).)
- Requires the Board of State and Community Corrections to establish minimum standards for local correctional facilities, which standards shall include, but not be limited to, the following areas: health and sanitary conditions, fire and life safety, security, rehabilitation programs, recreation, treatment of persons confined in local correctional facilities, and personnel training. (Penal Code Section 6030.)
- Pursuant to the Unruh Civil Rights Act, provides that all persons within the jurisdiction of California are free and equal no matter their national origin, citizenship, or immigration status and are entitled to full and equal accommodations, facilities, and privileges in all business establishments of every kind. (Civil Code Section 51.)
EXISTING FEDERAL LAW:
- Pursuant to the Immigration and Naturalization Act, protects all asylum seekers by prohibiting the federal government from returning to their home countries people who have fled persecution on account of race, religion, nationality, political opinion, or membership in a particular social group. (8 U.S.C. Sec. 1101 (a)(42)(A).)
- Pursuant to the Immigration and Naturalization Act, provides that victims of certain crimes may obtain immigration relief through a Victim of Crime Visa (U-Visa) and victims of human trafficking may obtain immigration relief through a Victim of Trafficking Visa (T-Visa). (8 U.S.C. Sec. 1101 (a)(15)(U); 8 U.S.C. Sec. 1101 (a)(15)(T).)
- Pursuant to case law, establishes that immigrant detainees with mental disabilities who are facing deportation and who are unable to adequately represent themselves are entitled to qualified legal representatives provided by the federal government for representation during all phases of their immigration proceedings, including appeals and custody hearings. (Franco-Gonzalez v. Holder, CV 10-02211-DMG.)
FISCAL EFFECT: As currently in print this bill is keyed fiscal.
COMMENTS: In one of his first interviews after being elected President, the current occupant of the White House echoed his campaign promises and told "60 Minutes" he intended to deport "millions and millions of undocumented immigrants" after his inauguration in January, focusing on those "who have criminal records" and promising to later "make a determination" on possible deportation of remaining undocumented immigrants. (Amy Wang, "Donald Trump plans to immediately deport 2 million to 3 million undocumented immigrants." Washington Post, Nov. 14, 2016. Available at: https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/the-fix/wp/2016/11/13/donald-trump-plans-to-immediately-deport-2-to-3-million-undocumented-immigrants). According to the Washington Post writer: "What would be new is the speed and scale with which Trump has vowed to remove undocumented immigrants with criminal records. His proposal to deport '2 to 3 million' people would be roughly equivalent to the number of people removed over the course of about six years under Obama's presidency. It is unclear how Trump would feasibly implement such a plan immediately after inauguration, as promised, without monumental expense and potentially exposing Americans to all kinds of disruptions." (Id.)
On January 25, 2017, the president issued Executive Order 13767 (82 FR 8793), titled "Border Security and Immigration Enforcement Improvements," which, among other things, calls for the immediate detainment and deportation of illegal immigrants and directs the U.S. Customs and Border Protection to hire 5,000 additional border patrol agents. EO 13767 clearly places a large number of California residents at greater risk of being deported. According to the author, Department of Homeland Security (DHS) figures show that over 400,000 people nationally are held each year awaiting a civil deportation proceeding, even though nothing in the law requires immigrants to be detained as immigration proceedings are civil, not criminal matters. Furthermore, the data indicate that today over 50% of detainees are held in private immigration detention facilities (i.e. run by private companies who contract with ICE), up from a rate of just 25% only ten years ago. According to the author:
With the new administration's commitment to deport millions, it is even more crucial now than ever before that California insists on humane and just treatment for all immigrants in our state.
There have been consistent reports of human rights abuses in private detention facilities, including physical and sexual abuse, poor access to healthcare, little access to legal counsel, and overuse of solitary confinement, and even death. SB 29 will prohibit local governments from contracting with private companies to detain immigrants for profit. This bill will also require detention facilities to meet the basic standards laid out by ICE’s 2011 Performance-Based National Detention Standards. Ultimately, SB 29 will ensure that immigrants who are being detained do not face abuse or neglect in detention.
Immigration detention facilities in California. Local governments and local law enforcement entities are not required to detain immigrants on behalf of federal immigration authorities. The ones in California that decide to detain immigrants do so by choice. Federal immigration authorities, either U.S. Immigration & Customs Enforcement (ICE) or the U.S. Marshals, enter into Intergovernmental Service Agreements (IGSAs) with local governments or local law enforcement whereby the local entity agrees to detain immigrants on behalf of the federal government. Local governments or local law enforcement can then choose to detain the immigrants in their own facilities or subcontract with for-profit detention facilities instead.
According to figures provided by CIVIC, 62% of all ICE immigration detention beds in the U.S. are operated by for-profit prison corporations, up from 49% in 2009. They contend that operators of these private detention facilities make billions in profit each year from holding undocumented persons, while the California county and city partners in these intergovernmental service agreements experience little economic gain. There are currently four for-profit detention facilities in California:
(1) ICE contracts with the City of Adelanto, who in turn contracts with GEO Group to detain immigrants at the Adelanto Detention Facility (Adelanto).
(2) ICE contracts with the City of McFarland, who in turn contracts with GEO Group to detain immigrants at the Mesa Verde Detention Facility (Bakersfield).
(3) ICE contract with the City of Holtville, who in turn contracts with Management & Training Corp. (MTC) to detain immigrants at the Imperial Regional Detention Facility. (Calexico).
(4) U.S. Marshals contract with Corrections Corporation of America (CCA) to detain immigrants at the Otay Detention Facility (San Diego).
According to the author, these four privately run facilities hold almost 85% of detainees statewide, approximately 3,700 people, with the rest held in county jail facilities that contract with federal immigration authorities. Specifically, ICE and the U.S. Marshals have intergovernmental service agreements with five counties, for the detention of immigrants at the Yuba County Jail (Marysville), Rio Consumnes Correctional Center (Elk Grove), the West County Detention Facility (Richmond), James Musick Facility (Irvine), and the Theo Lacy Facility (Orange). Lastly, they contract with the City of Santa Ana to detain immigrants at the Santa Ana City Jail. Altogether, CIVIC reports that a total of approximately 6,276 immigrants per day are held in civil confinement in these facilities. Proponents contend that many of these facilities operate under a perverse contractual incentive where they are guaranteed a minimum number of detainees in their facility at all times, thus ensuring their profits. For example, according to CIVIC, at the Adelanto Detention Facility (ADF), ICE is guaranteed 975 detainees at all times with a per diem rate of $111 per bed per day.
Private immigration detention facilities operate with no mechanism for public oversight. The author contends that because private for-profit detention facilities operate with little to no oversight, they are essentially accountable only to their shareholders and not the people of the state of California. For-profit detention facilities claim exemptions to the public disclosure requirements under the Freedom of Information Act (FOIA) (5 U.S.C. Sec. 552) because they are private corporations, which makes the potentially unlawful conduct occurring within the facility hidden from discovery. For example, a 2013 article in Forbes noted that “if serious questions arise about…the 16,500 federal immigration detainees held in privately-operated facilities under contracts with the U.S. Department of Homeland Security, there’s no legal remedy in place forcing those questions to be answered.” (Matt Stroud, Private Prisons Are Exempted From Federal Disclosure Laws; Advocates Say that Should Change, (Feb. 7, 2013) Forbes.)
Private detention facilities similarly claim exemptions to the California Public Records Act (CPRA) (Gov. Code Sec 6250 et seq). CIVIC notes that despite numerous reports of inadequate medical care, suicide attempts, sexual assault, and even deaths at for profit immigration detention facilities, it is difficult to obtain information about these facilities. CIVIC explains the process for obtaining information about private, for-profit immigration detention facilities as follows:
[A] person can FOIA the IGSA between ICE and the private prison. When this occurs, ICE is required to ask the corporation if they are OK with the government disclosing it. If the corporation is OK, then it will be disclosed. However, it is completely in the discretion of the private prison corporation whether any document pertaining to the IGSA or any other aspect of the business is disclosed through a FOIA request.
As a result, abuse and inhumane treatment of detainees is reportedly tolerated and persists in these facilities because the public has no dependable mechanism for getting information about what is going on behind closed doors. Journalists and advocacy groups like CIVIC are occasionally able to document problems and incidents of mistreatment at these facilities, but only with the cooperation of the facilities themselves. The public policy of California is certainly not to allow the abuse of people who are detained by the government in facilities where there is no transparency or oversight. Accordingly, this bill would prohibit local governments and law enforcement from contracting with companies that operate for-profit immigration detention facilities to detain immigrants. While the Legislature lacks authority to prohibit private immigration detention facility operators from contracting directly with ICE or federal authorities to hold immigrants, this bill does not attempt to preclude those contracting practices. Rather, this bill attempts to bring more transparency to the operation of these facilities by making any facility that detains an immigrant pursuant to a contract with a city, county, city and county, or a local law enforcement agency subject to the California Public Records Act.
Despite lack of transparency, advocates have documented patterns of widespread abuse of immigrants held in private detention facilities. The Committee has received a number of reports and letters in support of this bill from immigrant advocates, watchdog organizations, and human rights advocates describing widespread incidents of abuse and mistreatment of immigrants held in private detention facilities in California, as well as in facilities in other states operated by the same companies that operate facilities in California. In its report "Abuse in Adelanto: An Investigation into a California Town's Immigration Jail," CIVIC details a number of disturbing examples of prolonged detention, medical abuse and neglect, violations of religious freedom, attempted suicides, and the negligent deaths of detainees—just at the Adelanto facility alone. The National Immigrant Justice Center reports that among LGBT individuals in the detained population, there are higher accounts of the use of solitary confinement, sexual abuse, and poor medical care in immigration detention facilities. (See National Immigrant Justice Center, Stop Abuse of Detained LGBT Immigrants; available at: http://www.immigrantjustice. org/stop-abuse-detained-lgbt-immigrants.) Human Rights Watch reports that it interviewed many transgender women in immigration detention who report being subjected to sexual assault and regular strip searches by male guards, including at the Santa Ana City jail, and others who report being held in abusive conditions of indefinite solitary confinement that are justified by prison authorities as a measure for transgender detainees’ protection. Finally, CIVIC summarizes cases from several other states where the same private detention companies (namely, Geo Group, CCA, and MTC) have faced lawsuits (and in some cases been held civilly liable) for acts of sexual harassment, wrongful death, and medical neglect, among other things.
To address these issues, the bill prohibits immigration detention facilities, their agents, or those acting on their behalf, from depriving immigrant detainees of medical care, freedom from harm or harassment, and privacy. The bill also prohibits the involuntary placement of immigrant detainees in segregated housing because of the detainee’s actual or perceived gender, gender identity, gender expression, or sexual orientation.
Lack of access to legal representation and telephone communication. Because immigration proceedings are civil, not criminal, detainees have fewer rights than criminal defendants, including the right to an attorney. CIVIC reports, for example, that of the 89 people detained at ADF that it monitored over a six-month period, only 12.3 percent had legal representation—below the already low national average of 16 percent (Abuse in Adelanto: An Investigation into a California Town's Immigration Jail (October 2015); CIVIC and Detention Watch Network.) Because most detainees go completely without legal representation, it is essential that they have access to a law library or telephone communications where they can communicate with advocates or family members outside the center who can arrange assistance. Even where detainees at Adelanto had legal representation, CIVIC reported the difficulties that these people experienced due to obstructive actions taken by facility staff. The lack of access to legal representation is even more tragic because many detainees in custody may, in fact, qualify to remain in the U.S., but are instead deported because they were never able to obtain the assistance of legal counsel. Accordingly, this bill specifically prohibits immigration detention facilities from depriving immigrant detainees access to an attorney or other authorized legal representative, and access to translation or interpreters.
Codifying the national standards for basic care in immigration detention facilities, promulgated by ICE for facilities it contracts with. ICE has promulgated a series of national standards laying out the requirements for basic care in immigration detention facilities, known as the Performance-Based National Detention Standards 2011 as corrected and clarified in February 2013 (Hereafter, PBNDS 2011). ICE uses national detention standards to govern conditions of confinement in its detention facilitates established through contracts with those facilities. (United States Government Accountability Office, “Immigration Detention” Additional Actions Could Strengthen DHS Efforts to Address Sexual Abuse, p. 12 (Nov. 2013), Available at: http://www.gao.gov/assets/660/659145.pdf) Immigration detention facilities agree to follow these standards pursuant to the Inter-governmental Service Agreements (IGSAs) between the federal government and the local governments, including when the local entities contract out with for-profit corporations. (See e.g. Mesa Verde IGSA pp. 4, 7, 19; available at http://www. documentcloud.org/ documents/ 2631228-Mesa-Verde-CA-IGSA-Contract.html.)
An additional federal policy, ICE Directive 11065.1 (Review of the Use of Segregation for ICE Detainees), was created to govern the placement of immigrant detainees in solitary confinement. The directive was created after a joint study by two human rights organizations revealed that immigrant detainees were increasingly placed in solitary confinement due to mental illness, sexual orientation, or not speaking English. (See Invisible in Isolation: The Use of Segregation and Solitary Confinement in Immigration Detention (Sept. 2012), Heartland Alliance and Physicians for Human Rights.) Unfortunately, this policy directive is equally unenforceable as there is no law requiring it to be followed.
This bill is necessary, proponents contend, to address the fact that although the PBNDS 2011 standards may be agreed to under the contract, the standards are unenforceable because adherence is not required under any federal or state law. They contend that many of the abuses documented in California violate the PBNDS 2011, but because the standards are not legally binding and have only been implemented at select facilities that have voluntarily elected to modify their operating agreements with ICE, there is virtually no recourse for detainees under existing law when the detention facilities violate these standards.
Accordingly, this bill seeks to create enforceable rights for immigrant detainees centered on the national standards described above. The bill provides that when an immigration detention facility chooses to enter into a contract to detain immigrants in civil immigration proceedings, it shall detain immigrants only pursuant to a contract that requires the entity contracting with DHS or other federal agency to adhere to the PBNDS 2011 standards, as well as ICE Directive 11065.1. The bill makes clear that, as a policy matter, every immigration detention facility in California should be subject to the same national standards for the detention of immigrants, including private detention facilities contracted with local governments. Mandating that private immigration detention facilities in California meet national standards is intended to prevent and reduce patterns of abuse that have been documented in these facilities.
Enforcement provisions. This bill would require that immigration detention facilities adhere to the PBNDS 2011 standards, ICE Directive 11065.1, and other rights granted by this bill. Unlike its predecessor legislation, SB 1289 (2016), there is no private right of action to enable detainees to sue on their own behalf. Instead, enforcement of these provisions is much more limited; the Attorney General, or any district attorney or city attorney may bring a civil action for injunctive and other appropriate equitable relief in the name of the people of the State of California. The prosecuting attorney may also seek a civil penalty of $25,000, as specified, when an immigration detention facility deprives an immigrant detainee of their rights created under this bill, or their rights under the PBNDS 2011 standards or ICE Directive 11065.1.
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: In addition to immigrant advocates and human rights groups, the bill is supported by some law enforcement organizations, including the Los Angeles Professional Peace Officers Association and the Riverside Sheriffs Association (RSA). RSA writes in support:
Numerous studies have demonstrated that main objective of these Wall Street private prison cash-cows is to maximize profits for their shareholders. For-profit private prison companies accomplish this goal by implementing relaxed hiring standards, reduced staffing levels, inadequate employee training and by paying their workers substantially less in wages and benefits when compared to professional, public correctional peace officers.
Stocks for the out-of-state prison corporations are traded on the New York Stock Exchange and must meet the financial goals of the institutional investors. As the CEO of the largest for-profit private prison company, Corrections Corporation of America, once stated, “Inmates are a commodity in our line of work.”
Private, for-profit prisons continue to treat their charges as “commodities” and “lower the bar” when it comes to the entire corrections profession. While we in the public sector are constantly trying to improve operations, the private, for-profit corporations seek only to improve profits. The 4,000-plus members of the RSA support efforts that improve public safety and save precious tax dollars. SB 29 accomplishes both of these objectives. Private prison companies make all of us in local, state or federal corrections look bad.
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION: The bill is opposed by the California State Sheriffs' Association, who state:
We believe SB 29 inappropriately inserts the state into matters that are appropriately governed by federal authorities. [I]t is certainly possible that this measure would be preempted by federal law. Additionally, by creating a public right of action for alleged violations . . . SB 29 exposes local governments to state civil liability despite federal oversight and enforcement. The costs of litigation resulting from this bill are likely to be significant. We are also concerned that the ban on contracting with private entities could result in overcrowded local facilities being left as the only viable option for immigration detention.
Committee staff notes that this bill merely restricts the ability of local government and law enforcement to contract with private companies, and imposes certain standards of treatment to be upheld in private detention facilities. Neither of these actions interfere or conflict with the federal government's ability to enforce federal immigration laws, and thus are not likely to cause this bill to be preempted by federal law if challenged in court.
Previously related legislation. SB 1289 (Lara) of 2016 is substantially similar to this bill, and would have prohibited local governments and law enforcement from contracting with companies that operate for-profit immigration detention facilities. The bill also would have required these facilities to uphold national standards for humane treatment of detainees, enforceable by a private right of action. In his September 2016 veto message of SB 1289, the Governor reasoned that Department of Homeland Security regulations under the Obama administration may shortly resolve the issue of whether private contracting for immigration detention should continue, and if so, under what conditions. After the November presidential election, however, no additional regulations on the issue are expected, and for reasons described earlier, greater use of private detention facilities is anticipated, not less.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
Community Initiatives for Visiting Immigrants in Confinement (CIVIC) (co-sponsor)
Immigrant Legal Resource Center (co-sponsor)
AFSCME
Alliance for Boys and Men of Color
American Academy of Pediatrics
Antelope Valley League of United Latin American Citizens
California Catholic Conference
California Environmental Justice Alliance
California Federation of Teachers
California Health+ Advocates
California Latinas for Reproductive Justice
California Immigrant Policy Center
Council on American-Islamic Relations, California
Equality California
Harvey Milk LGBT Democratic Club
Human Rights Defense Center
Immigrant Legal Resource Center
Inland Coalition for Immigrant Justice
In the Public Interest (ITPI)
Jewish Public Affairs Committee of California
Latino Coalition for a Healthy California
League of Women Voters of California
Los Angeles LGBT Center
Los Angeles Professional Peace Officers Association
Mixteco Idigena Community Organizing Project
National Association of Social Workers
Pangea Legal Services
Riverside Sheriffs Association
SEIU California
Services, Immigrant Rights, Education Network (SIREN)
Transgender Law Center
The United Farm Workers
Opposition
California State Sheriffs Association
County of Imperial
Analysis Prepared by: Anthony Lew / JUD. / (916) 319-2334
Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | SB |
THIRD READING
Bill No: SB 29
:
SENATE JUDICIARY COMMITTEE: 5-2, 3/28/17
AYES: Jackson, Hertzberg, Monning, Stern, Wieckowski
NOES: Moorlach, Anderson
SENATE APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE: 5-2, 5/25/17
AYES: Lara, Beall, Bradford, Hill, Wiener
NOES: Bates, Nielsen
SOURCE: Community Initiatives for Visiting Immigrants in Confinement
Immigrant Legal Resource Center
DIGEST:
This bill prohibits local law enforcement agencies and local governments from contracting with for-profit entities to detain immigrants on behalf of federal immigration authorities. This bill requires that immigrant detention facilities adhere to national immigration standards for the detention of immigrants. This bill further requires that immigrants in detention be provided other legal rights, as specified. This bill authorizes suits against detention facilities for violations of the national detention standards or violations of other legal rights created by this bill.
Existing law:
- Provides that everyone has the right to seek and to enjoy in other countries asylum from persecution.
- Protects asylum seekers by prohibiting the federal government from returning to their home countries people who have fled persecution on account of race, religion, nationality, political opinion, or membership in a social group.
- Provides that victims of certain crimes may obtain immigration relief through a Victim of Crime Visa (U-Visa) and victims of human trafficking may obtain immigration relief through a Victim of Human Trafficking Visa (T-Visa).
- Provides immigration relief that relies on a state’s interest in the welfare of children and provides for Special Immigrant Juvenile Status where a state determines that reunification with one or both of the immigrant’s parents is not viable due to abuse, neglect, abandonment, or similar basis found under state law and that it would not be in the child’s best interest to return to their home country.
- Establishes that the care and custody of unaccompanied minors is the responsibility of the Office of Refugee Resettlement in the Department of Health and Human Services instead of the Department of Homeland Security.
- Holds that immigrant detainees with mental disabilities who are facing deportation and who are unable to adequately represent themselves are entitled to qualified legal representatives provided by the federal government for representation during all phases of their immigration proceedings, including appeals and custody hearings.
This bill:
- Prohibits, as of January 1, 2019, local governments or local law enforcement from entering into or renewing a contract, or modifying a contract to extend the length of the contract, with a private corporation, contractor or vendor to detain immigrants in civil immigration proceedings for profit.
- Provides that a city, county, city and county, or a local law enforcement agency that chooses to enter into a contract, renews a contract, or modifies a contract to extend the length of the contract, to detain immigrants in civil immigration proceedings, shall detain immigrants only pursuant to a contract that requires the immigration detention facility operator to adhere to the standards for detaining those individuals described in the 2011 Operations Manual Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) Performance-Based National Detention Standards as corrected and clarified in February 2013 and ICE Directive 11065.1 (Review of the Use of Segregation for ICE Detainees).
- Makes clear that an immigration detention facility can exceed the 2011 Operations Manual ICE Performance-Based National Detention Standards as corrected and clarified in February 2013 or ICE Directive 11065.1 (Review of the Use of Segregation for ICE Detainees).
- Prohibits immigrant detention facilities, agents of immigration detention facility operators, or those acting on their behalf from depriving immigrant detainees: (a) access to legal representatives; (b) access to translation or interpreters; (c) medical care (which would still include, and not be limited to, HIV medication and transition-related health care, and would still need to be provided even if an immigrant is likely to be released or deported); (d) freedom from harm or harassment; and (e) privacy.
- Prohibits the involuntary placement of immigration detainees in segregated housing because of the detainee’s actual or perceived gender, gender identity, gender expression, or sexual orientation. This bill also requires that transgender and gender non-conforming immigration detainees be given the option to choose a housing placement consistent with their gender identity.
- Authorizes civil actions for injunctive and other appropriate equitable relief and a civil penalty of $25,000, as specified, when an immigrant detention facility operator, or its agent or person acting on its behalf violates rights created under this bill or the 2011 Operations Manual ICE Performance-Based National Detention Standards as corrected and clarified in February 2013, or ICE Directive 11065.1 (Review of the Use of Segregation for ICE Detainees).
- Requires that if a civil penalty is requested, the civil penalty shall be assessed individually against each person who is determined to have violated the legal rights of a detained immigrant and awarded to each individual who has been injured.
- Subjects any facility that detains an immigrant pursuant to a contract with a city, county, city and county, or a local law enforcement agency to the California Public Records Act.
- Makes related legislative findings and declarations, and includes definitions.
Background
In California, and around the country, for-profit detention facilities are increasingly relied upon to detain immigrants who are oftentimes eligible for Asylum, Special Immigrant Juvenile Status immigration relief, U-Visas, T-Visas, or other forms of immigration relief. Additionally, a few local government and local law enforcement entities choose to enter into agreements with federal immigration authorities to detain immigrants in their county or city jails on behalf of the federal immigration authorities.
For-profit detention facilities are accountable to their shareholders and not the people of the State of California. Oftentimes, immigrants in immigrant detention facilities are escaping persecution in their countries of origin and in need of special care due to their persecution or because they have suffered arduous journeys as unaccompanied children. Ensuring that immigrants are provided with the services they need to heal oftentimes is in contrast to corporate interests. Because these facilities are private, they routinely claim exemptions to the California’s Public Records Act and the federal Freedom of Information Act. Despite the lack of access to records through these acts, there have been reports of inadequate medical care, suicide attempts, sexual assault, and even deaths at for-profit immigrant detention facilities. Somewhat perversely, because immigration detention is technically a civil form of confinement, immigrants in immigrant detention facilities lack many of the safeguards of the criminal justice system, including access to counsel.
Local government and law enforcement entities that choose to contract with immigration authorities to detain immigrants are supposed to adhere to national immigration detention standards, promulgated by ICE regardless of whether they detain the immigrants in their local jails or contract their immigrant detention duties out to private for-profit corporations. But many detainees have reported experiencing deplorable conditions at city and county immigrant detention facilities in violation of the national standards. No meaningful enforcement mechanism currently exists to hold immigration detention facilities accountable, whether for-profit or run by local governmental agency, when they violate immigrant detainee’s rights. Various reports indicate that the rights of Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual, and Transgender (LGBT) detained immigrants have been extensively violated at both types of detention facilities.
Last year, the Legislature passed SB 1289 (Lara), a bill identical to SB 29, but the Governor vetoed the bill. In his veto message the Governor wrote:
I have been troubled by recent reports detailing unsatisfactory conditions and limited access to counsel in private immigration detention facilities. The Department of Homeland Security, however, is now considering whether private contracting should continue for immigrant detention, and if so under what conditions. Their recommendations are expected in November. These actions indicate that a more permanent solution to this issue may be at hand. I urge the federal authorities to act swiftly.
Since the veto of SB 1289, a new President was elected who has made it clear in his executive orders and his administration’s enforcement guidelines that every undocumented immigrant could be a target of deportation. President Donald Trump has also made it clear that he intends to detain more immigrants and expand private for profit detention facility use. This bill would protect immigrants held in immigrant detention in California.
Comments
The author writes:
In 2011 ICE developed the Operations Performance-Based National Detention Standards, which lays out the basic health and safety standards detainees should receive while in detention. However, these standards are not codified and are unenforceable. There have been widespread reports of human right’s abuses in detention facilities, including physical and sexual abuse, poor access to healthcare, little access to legal counsel, overuse of solitary confinement, and even death. LGBT detainees have reported facing discrimination, harassment, and abuse due to their sexual orientation. In many of these instances, even the Department of Homeland Security has found these deaths were preventable. Tragically, the incidents often go unaddressed and victims have no recourse.
Private, for-profit immigration detention facilities present a host of problems. The facilities are not subject to the Freedom of Information Act and operate with little to no oversight. Many also operate under a perverse incentive, where they are guaranteed a minimum number of detainees in their facility at all times, ensuring their profits. For example in Adelanto Detention Facility in Adelanto, California, ICE is guaranteed 975 detainees at all times with a per diem rate of $111 per bed per day. The private detention contracts are designed to incentivize filling the most beds at all times, regardless of public safety or their destructive effects on communities. Private companies make billions in profits every year from incarcerating mothers, fathers, children, and others in our broken immigration system.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: Fiscal Com.: Local:
According to the Senate Appropriations Committee:
- Department of Justice: Potentially significant workload increase (General Fund) should the Attorney General choose to bring civil actions for injunctive and other equitable relief, offset in part by civil penalty revenues. To the extent the number and complexity of cases brought forward is significant, costs could rise into the hundreds of thousands of dollars annually.
- Local prosecutors: Potentially significant non-reimbursable local costs (local funds) to bring civil actions for injunctive and other equitable relief, offset in part by civil penalty revenues.
- Local governments/agencies: Potentially significant loss of future revenue (local funds) due to the inability to contract with for-profit entities for immigrant detention services. To the extent a local law enforcement agency opts to detain immigrants in its facilities through a direct contract with the federal government, the agency could incur potentially significant non-reimbursable costs (local funds) to ensure immigrant detainee rights as prescribed are met.
- Private contractors/vendors: Unknown, potentially major costs (private funds) to adhere to the specified standards and processes for detainee transfers and rights to counsel, translators, interpreters, and medical care and comply with public record requests as outlined in the bill.
Community Initiatives for Visiting Immigrants in Confinement (co-source)
Immigrant Legal Resource Center (co-source)
AFSCME, AFL-CIO
AFSCME, Local 685
Alliance for Boys and Men of Color
American Academy of Pediatrics, California
Antelope Valley League of United Latin American Citizens
Association for Los Angles Deputy Sheriffs
Association of Deputy District Attorneys
California Catholic Conference
California Environmental Justice Alliance
California Health+ Advocates
California Immigrant Policy Center
California Latinas for Reproductive Justice
Community Clinic Association of Los Angeles County
Council on American-Islamic Relations
Equality California
Harvey Milk LGBT Democratic Club
Human Rights Defense Center
Inland Coalition for Immigrant Rights
Jewish Public Affairs Committee of California
Latino Coalition for a Healthy California
League of Women Voters of California
Los Angeles County Probation Officers’ Union
Los Angeles County Professional Peace Officers Association
Los Angeles LGBT Center
Los Angeles Police Protective League
Mixteco/Indigena Community Organizing Project
National Association of Social Workers, California Chapter
Pangea Legal Services
Riverside Sheriffs’ Association
Service Employees International Union
Services, Immigrant Rights and Education Network
Transgender Law Center
United Farm Workers
OPPOSITION: (Verified 5/25/17)
California State Sheriffs’ Association
Imperial County Board of Supervisors
5/27/17 18:32:27
**** END ****
SENATE COMMITTEE ON
Senator Ricardo Lara, Chair
2017 - 2018 Regular Session
SB 29 (Lara) - Law enforcement: immigration
Version: | Policy Vote: |
Urgency: | Mandate: |
Hearing Date: | Consultant: |
This bill meets the criteria for referral to the Suspense File.
Bill Summary:
SB 29 would prohibit local governments from contracting with for-profit entities to detain immigrants on behalf of federal immigration authorities and requires that local detention facilities that house immigrant detainees adhere to the most recent federal standards.
Fiscal Impact:
- Department of Justice: Potentially significant workload increase (General Fund) should the Attorney General choose to bring civil actions for injunctive and other equitable relief, offset in part by civil penalty revenues. To the extent the number and complexity of cases brought forward is significant, costs could rise into the hundreds of thousands of dollars annually.
- Local prosecutors: Potentially significant non-reimbursable local costs (local funds) to bring civil actions for injunctive and other equitable relief, offset in part by civil penalty revenues.
- Local governments/agencies: Potentially significant loss of future revenue (local funds) due to the inability to contract with for-profit entities for immigrant detention services. To the extent a local law enforcement agency opts to detain immigrants in its facilities through a direct contract with the federal government, the agency could incur potentially significant non-reimbursable costs (local funds) to ensure immigrant detainee rights as prescribed are met.
- Private contractors/vendors: Unknown, potentially major costs (private funds) to adhere to the specified standards and processes for detainee transfers and rights to counsel, translators, interpreters, and medical care and comply with public record requests as outlined in the bill.
Background:
Existing law authorizes a county board of supervisors on behalf of its sheriff, and the governing body of a city on behalf of its chief of police, to contract to provide supplemental law enforcement services to private individuals, private entities, and private corporations in specified circumstances and subject to certain conditions.
As stated in the Senate Committee on Judiciary analysis of this measure: In California, and around the country, for-profit detention facilities are increasingly relied upon to detain immigrants who are oftentimes eligible for Asylum, Special Immigrant Juvenile Status immigration relief, Victims of Crime Visas (U-Visas), Victims of Human Trafficking Visas (T-Visas), or other forms of immigration relief. Additionally, a few local government and local law enforcement entities choose to enter into agreements with federal immigration authorities to detain immigrants in their county or city jails on behalf of the federal immigration authorities. Even children, who have not been charged with crimes, including a child who was granted asylum, are held in county juvenile criminal detention facilities on behalf of federal immigration authorities.
For-profit detention facilities are accountable to their shareholders and not the people of the State of California. Oftentimes, immigrants in immigrant detention facilities are escaping persecution in their countries of origin and in need of special care due to their persecution or because they have suffered arduous journeys as unaccompanied children. Ensuring that immigrants are provided with the services they need to heal oftentimes is in contrast to corporate interests. Because these facilities are private, they routinely claim exemptions to the California’s Public Records Act and the federal Freedom of Information Act. Despite the lack of access to records through these acts, there have been reports of inadequate medical care, suicide attempts, sexual assault, and even deaths at for-profit immigrant detention facilities. Because immigration detention is technically a civil form of confinement, immigrants in immigrant detention facilities lack many of the safeguards of the criminal justice system, including access to counsel.
Local government and law enforcement entities that choose to contract with immigration authorities to detain immigrants are supposed to adhere to national immigration detention standards, promulgated by Immigration Customs and Enforcement (ICE) regardless of whether they detain the immigrants in their local jails or contract their immigrant detention duties out to private for-profit corporations. But many detainees have reported experiencing deplorable conditions at city and county immigrant detention facilities in violation of the national standards. No meaningful enforcement mechanism currently exists to hold immigration detention facilities accountable, whether for-profit or run by a local governmental agency, when they violate immigrant detainee’s rights.
Proposed Law:
This bill would:
- Prohibit, as of January 1, 2019, local governments or local law enforcement from entering into or renewing a contract, or modifying a contract to extend the length of the contract, with a private corporation, contractor, or vendor to detain immigrants in civil immigration proceedings for profit.
- Provide that a city, county, city and county, or a local law enforcement agency that chooses to enter into a contract, renews a contract, or modifies a contract to extend the length of the contract, to detain immigrants in civil immigration proceedings, shall detain immigrants only pursuant to a contract that requires the immigration detention facility operator to adhere to the standards for detaining those individuals described in the 2011 Operations Manual ICE Performance-Based National Detention Standards as corrected and clarified in February 2013 and ICE Directive 11065.1 (Review of the Use of Segregation for ICE Detainees).
- Clarifies that an immigration detention facility can exceed the 2011 Operations Manual ICE Performance-Based National Detention Standards as corrected and clarified in February 2013 or ICE Directive 11065.1 (Review of the Use of Segregation for ICE Detainees).
- Prohibit immigrant detention facilities, agents of immigration detention facility operators, or those acting on their behalf from depriving immigrant detainees: access to legal representatives; access to translation or interpreters; medical care; freedom from harm or harassment; and privacy.
- Prohibit the involuntary placement of immigration detainees in segregated housing because of the detainee’s actual or perceived gender, gender identity, gender expression, or sexual orientation.
- Require that transgender and gender non-conforming immigration detainees be given the option to choose a housing placement consistent with their gender identity.
- Allow the Attorney General, any district attorney, or city attorney to bring a civil action for injunctive and other appropriate equitable relief in the name of the people of the State of California and seek a civil penalty of $25,000, as specified, when an immigrant detention facility operator, or its agent or person acting on its behalf violates rights created under this bill or the 2011 Operations Manual ICE Performance-Based National Detention Standards as corrected and clarified in February 2013, or ICE Directive 11065.1 (Review of the Use of Segregation for ICE Detainees).
- Require that if a civil penalty is requested by the Attorney General, a district attorney, or city attorney, the civil penalty shall be assessed individually against each person who is determined to have violated the legal rights of a detained immigrant and awarded to each individual who has been injured.
- Clarify that any facility that detains an immigrant pursuant to a contract with a city, county, city and county, or a local law enforcement agency is subject to the California Public Records Act.
Prior Legislation:
SB 1289 (Lara, 2016) was identical to this bill. It was vetoed by the Governor with the following message:
I have been troubled by recent reports detailing unsatisfactory conditions and limited access to counsel in private immigration detention facilities. The Department of Homeland Security, however, is now considering whether private contracting should continue for immigrant detention, and if so under what conditions. Their recommendations are expected in November.
Staff Comments:
The Department of Justice has indicated potentially significant costs to address an increase in workload should be bill be enacted. Additional workload would include the cost of additional staffing to complete the drafting of pleadings, discovery, and extensive legal research required for these cases.
By prohibiting local governments and law enforcement agencies from contracting with for-profit entities to detain immigrants on behalf of federal immigration authorities, this bill could result in some degree of lost revenue to local entities. For example, based on information reported by the Community Initiatives for Visiting Immigrants in Confinement (CIVIC), an intergovernmental service agreement (IGSA) that utilizes the City of Adelanto for a contract between the GEO Group and ICE for immigrant detention at the Adelanto Detention Facility, could potentially result in lost revenue to the City of nearly $228,000 (based on a flat administrative fee of $50,000 per year for the facility and a reimbursement rate of $0.75 per person per day for 650 persons).
Staff notes that the provisions of this measure do not prohibit an IGSA between a local entity and the federal government, should a local government entity, such as a law enforcement agency, choose to detain immigrants on behalf of the federal government. By prohibiting the practice of subcontracting with for-profit entities for use of its facilities, a direct contract between a law enforcement agency and the federal government to detain immigrants in its own local facilities could result in significant costs to local agencies to ensure immigrant detainee rights as prescribed in the bill are met. It is unclear to what degree the existing pressure on the capacity of local jails would be impacted by this bill, but as previously noted, the detention of immigrants on behalf of the federal immigration authorities is optional. To the extent local agencies do not have sufficient capacity or resources, local agencies could choose not to enter into such agreements.
-- END --
Senator Hannah-Beth Jackson, Chair
2017-2018 Regular Session
Bill No: SB 29 (Author:Lara)
Version: December 5, 2016
Hearing Date: March 28, 2017
Fiscal: Yes
Urgency: No
Consultant: MEC
SUBJECT
Law enforcement: immigration
DESCRIPTION
This bill would prohibit local law enforcement agencies and local governments from contracting with for-profit entities to detain immigrants on behalf of federal immigration authorities. This bill would require that immigrant detention facilities adhere to national immigration standards for the detention of immigrants. This bill further would require that immigrants in detention be provided other legal rights, as specified. This bill would authorize the Attorney General, district attorneys, and city attorneys to bring suits against detention facilities for violations of the national detention standards or violations of other legal rights created by this bill.
BACKGROUND
In California, and around the country, for-profit detention facilities are increasingly relied upon to detain immigrants who are oftentimes eligible for Asylum, Special Immigrant Juvenile Status immigration relief, Victims of Crime Visas (U-Visas), Victims of Human Trafficking Visas (T-Visas), or other forms of immigration relief. Additionally, a few local government and local law enforcement entities choose to enter into agreements with federal immigration authorities to detain immigrants in their county or city jails on behalf of the federal immigration authorities. Even children, who have not been charged with crimes, including a child who was granted asylum, are held in county juvenile criminal detention facilities on behalf of federal immigration authorities.
For-profit detention facilities are accountable to their shareholders and not the people of the State of California. Oftentimes, immigrants in immigrant detention facilities are escaping persecution in their countries of origin and in need of special care due to their persecution or because they have suffered arduous journeys as unaccompanied children. Ensuring that immigrants are provided with the services they need to heal oftentimes is in contrast to corporate interests. Because these facilities are private, they routinely claim exemptions to the California’s Public Records Act and the federal Freedom of Information Act. Despite the lack of access to records through these acts, there have been reports of inadequate medical care, suicide attempts, sexual assault, and even deaths at for-profit immigrant detention facilities. Because immigration detention is technically a civil form of confinement, immigrants in immigrant detention facilities lack many of the safeguards of the criminal justice system, including access to counsel.
Local government and law enforcement entities that choose to contract with immigration authorities to detain immigrants are supposed to adhere to national immigration detention standards, promulgated by Immigration Customs and Enforcement (ICE) regardless of whether they detain the immigrants in their local jails or contract their immigrant detention duties out to private for-profit corporations. But many detainees have reported experiencing deplorable conditions at city and county immigrant detention facilities in violation of the national standards. No meaningful enforcement mechanism currently exists to hold immigration detention facilities accountable, whether for-profit or run by a local governmental agency, when they violate immigrant detainee’s rights. Various reports indicate that the rights of Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual, and Transgender (LGBT) detained immigrants have been extensively violated at both types of detention facilities.
Last year the Legislature passed Senate Bill 1289 (Lara), a bill identical to SB 29. In his veto message the Governor wrote:
I have been troubled by recent reports detailing unsatisfactory conditions and limited access to counsel in private immigration detention facilities. The Department of Homeland Security, however, is now considering whether private contracting should continue for immigrant detention, and if so under what conditions. Their recommendations are expected in November. These actions indicate that a more permanent solution to this issue may be at hand. I urge the federal authorities to act swiftly.
Since the veto of SB 1289, a new President was elected who has made it clear in his executive orders and his administration’s enforcement guidelines that every undocumented immigrant could be a target of deportation. President Donald Trump has also made it clear that he intends to detain more immigrants and expand private for profit detention facility use. This bill would protect immigrants held in immigrant detention in California.
CHANGES TO EXISTING LAW
Existing international law provides for the protection of people who have fled persecution on account of race, religion, nationality, political opinion, or membership in a particular social group. (UN General Assembly, Universal Declaration of Human Rights, Dec. 10, 1948, 217A(III), Art. 14.)
Existing law prohibits the federal government from returning to their home countries people whose life or freedom would be threatened because of the alien’s race, religion, nationality, membership in a particular social group, or political opinion. (8 U.S.C. Sec. 1231(b)(3).)
Existing law protects all asylum seekers by prohibiting the federal government from returning to their home countries people who have fled persecution on account of race, religion, nationality, political opinion, or membership in a particular social group. (8 U.S.C. Sec. 1101(a)(42)(A).)
Existing law provides that victims of certain crimes may obtain immigration relief through a Victim of Crime Visa (U-Visa) and victims of human trafficking may obtain immigration relief through a Victim of Trafficking Visa (T-Visa). (8 U.S.C. Sec. 1101(a)(15)(U); 8 U.S.C. Sec. 1101(a)(15)(T).)
Existing law provides immigration relief that relies on a state’s interest in the welfare of children by providing for Special Immigrant Juvenile Status where a state determines that reunification with one or both of the immigrant’s parents is not viable due to abuse, neglect, abandonment, or similar basis found under state law and that it would not be in the child’s best interest to return to their home country. (8 U.S.C. Sec. 1101 (a)(27)(J).)
Existing law establishes that the care and custody of unaccompanied minors is the responsibility of the Office of Refugee Resettlement (ORR) in the Department of Health and Human Services instead of the Department of Homeland Security (DHS). (Homeland Security Act of 2002; P.L. 107-296, Sec. 462)
Existing law provides, under the Fifth Amendment to the U.S. Constitution, that a person shall not be deprived of life, liberty, or property without due process of law. (U.S. Const., 5th Amend.)
Existing law holds that once an alien enters the country, the legal circumstance changes, for the Due Process Clause applies to all persons within the United States, including aliens, whether their presence here is lawful, unlawful, temporary, or permanent. (Zadvydas v. Davis, 533 U.S. 678 (2001).)
Existing case law holds that immigrant detainees with mental disabilities who are facing deportation and who are unable to adequately represent themselves are entitled to qualified legal representatives provided by the federal government for representation during all phases of their immigration proceedings, including appeals and custody hearings. (Franco-Gonzalez v. Holder, 2015 U.S. Dist. Lexis 179622.)
Existing law permits the board of supervisors of any county to contract on behalf of the sheriff of that county, and the legislative body of any city may contract on behalf of the chief of police of that city, to provide supplemental law enforcement services to specified entities under certain conditions, including to private individuals or private entities to preserve the peace at special events or occurrences that happen on an occasional basis. (Government Code Section 53069.8 (a).)
Existing law requires the Board of State and Community Corrections to establish minimum standards for local correctional facilities, which standards shall include, but not be limited to, the following areas: health and sanitary conditions, fire and life safety, security, rehabilitation programs, recreation, treatment of persons confined in local correctional facilities, and personnel training. (Penal Code Section 6030.)
Existing law provides that all persons within the jurisdiction of California are free and equal no matter their national origin, citizenship, or immigration status and are entitled to full and equal accommodations, facilities, and privileges in all business establishments of every kind. (Civil Code Section 51.)
This bill would prohibit, as of January 1, 2019, local governments or local law enforcement from entering into or renewing a contract, or modifying a contract to extend the length of the contract, with a private corporation, contractor, or vendor to detain immigrants in civil immigration proceedings for profit.
This bill would provide that a city, county, city and county, or a local law enforcement agency that chooses to enter into a contract, renews a contract, or modifies a contract to extend the length of the contract, to detain immigrants in civil immigration proceedings, shall detain immigrants only pursuant to a contract that requires the immigration detention facility operator to adhere to the standards for detaining those individuals described in the 2011 Operations Manual Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) Performance-Based National Detention Standards as corrected and clarified in February 2013 and ICE Directive 11065.1 (Review of the Use of Segregation for ICE Detainees).
This bill would make clear that an immigration detention facility can exceed the 2011 Operations Manual ICE Performance-Based National Detention Standards as corrected and clarified in February 2013 or ICE Directive 11065.1 (Review of the Use of Segregation for ICE Detainees).
This bill would prohibit immigrant detention facilities, agents of immigration detention facility operators, or those acting on their behalf from depriving immigrant detainees: access to legal representatives; access to translation or interpreters; medical care; freedom from harm or harassment; and privacy.
This bill would prohibit the involuntary placement of immigration detainees in segregated housing because of the detainee’s actual or perceived gender, gender identity, gender expression, or sexual orientation.
This bill would require that transgender and gender non-conforming immigration detainees be given the option to choose a housing placement consistent with their gender identity.
This bill would authorize the Attorney General, any district attorney, or city attorney to bring a civil action for injunctive and other appropriate equitable relief in the name of the people of the State of California and seek a civil penalty of $25,000, as specified, when an immigrant detention facility operator, or its agent or person acting on its behalf violates rights created under this bill or the 2011 Operations Manual ICE Performance-Based National Detention Standards as corrected and clarified in February 2013, or ICE Directive 11065.1 (Review of the Use of Segregation for ICE Detainees).
This bill would require that if a civil penalty is requested by the Attorney General, a district attorney, or city attorney, the civil penalty shall be assessed individually against each person who is determined to have violated the legal rights of a detained immigrant and awarded to each individual who has been injured.
This bill would make clear that any facility that detains an immigrant pursuant to a contract with a city, county, city and county, or a local law enforcement agency is subject to the California Public Records Act.
This bill would: make related legislative findings and declarations; include a severability clause; and definitions.
COMMENT
1. Stated need for the bill
According to the author:
In 2011 ICE developed the Operations Performance-Based National Detention Standards, which lays out the basic health and safety standards detainees should receive while in detention. However, these standards are not codified and are unenforceable. There have been widespread reports of human right’s abuses in detention facilities, including physical and sexual abuse, poor access to healthcare, little access to legal counsel, overuse of solitary confinement, and even death. LGBT detainees have reported facing discrimination, harassment, and abuse due to their sexual orientation. In many of these instances, even the Department of Homeland Security has found these deaths were preventable. Tragically, the incidents often go unaddressed and victims have no recourse.
Private, for-profit immigration detention facilities present a host of problems. The facilities are not subject to the Freedom of Information Act and operate with little to no oversight. Many also operate under a perverse incentive, where they are guaranteed a minimum number of detainees in their facility at all times, ensuring their profits. For example in Adelanto Detention Facility in Adelanto, California, ICE is guaranteed 975 detainees at all times with a per diem rate of $111 per bed per day. The private detention contracts are designed to incentivize filling the most beds at all times, regardless of public safety or their destructive effects on communities. Private companies make billions in profits every year from incarcerating mothers, fathers, children, and others in our broken immigration system.
2. Immigration detention is civil and immigrants are denied appointed counsel
Immigration detention is civil in nature and deportation unlike in criminal proceedings is not punitive. (Wong Wing v. United States, (1896) 163 U.S. 228.) Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) states that they detain people for no purpose other than to secure their presence both for immigration proceedings and their removal. (U.S. Customs and Immigration Service, Performance Based National Detention Standards (2011), See <https://www.ice.gov/doclib/detention-standards/2011/pbnds2011.pdf >[as of March 23, 2017].) “Unlike criminal incarceration, immigration detention is not to be punitive…ICE is to confine detainees for the administrative purpose of holding, processing, and preparing them for removal.” (United States Government Accountability Office, “Immigration Detention” Additional Actions Could Strengthen DHS Efforts to Address Sexual Abuse (Nov. 2013), p.8, <http://www.gao.gov/assets/660/659145.pdf> [as of March 23, 2017].)
Immigrants in civil detention are not provided with the same protections as individuals in the criminal justice system, such as appointed legal counsel. Even California immigrants with mental disabilities were deprived of counsel until a federal district judge in the Central District of California ordered that detained immigrants with mental disabilities are entitled to qualified legal representatives provided by the federal government for representation during all phases of their immigration proceedings, including appeals and custody hearings. (Franco-Gonzalez v. Holder, No. CV 10-02211 DMG (DTBx), 2013 WL 3674492, *8 (C.D. Cal Apr. 23, 2013).)
A nationwide class action lawsuit was filed in the U.S. District Court for the Western District of Washington in July 2014 on behalf of thousands of children who challenged the federal government’s failure to provide them with legal representation in deportation hearings. (J.E.F.M. v. Lynch, 837 F3d. 1026 (9th Cir. 2016).) These children argued that the failure of the United States government to provide them with lawyers, even though they face the threat of deportation to countries where they may face persecution, violence, or even death, violates their basic rights under international law and is a violation of their due process rights under the Fifth Amendment of the United States Constitution. (“No person shall be…deprived of life, liberty, or property without due process of law” U.S. Const., 5th Amend.). Indeed, at least 83 deportees, including children, were reported murdered upon their return to Central America since January 2014. (Sibylla Brodzinsky & Ed Pilkington, US Government Deporting Central American Migrants to Their Deaths (Oct. 12, 2015), The Guardian <http://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2015/oct/12/obama-immigration-deportations-central-america> [as of March 23, 2017].) In J.E.F.M., a panel of Ninth circuit justices declined the petitioners request that the Ninth Circuit mandate the provision of attorneys for children in immigration court, ruling that the federal courts lacked jurisdiction given the particular way that the case was brought. (837 F3d. 1026 (9th Cir. 2016). But the justices urged other branches of government to act:
I cannot let the occasion pass without highlighting the plight of unrepresented children who find themselves in immigration proceeding[s]… [T]housands of children are left to thread their way alone through the labyrinth maze of immigration law…Additional policy and funding initiatives aimed at securing representation for minors are important to ensure the smooth functioning of our immigration system and the fair and proper application of our immigration laws. (Id. at 1039-40)
Some unaccompanied minors who have fled violence in Central America are being detained in California on behalf of the Office of Refugee Resettlement for months and in some cases years. (The California Report, Hundreds of Migrant Teens Are Being Held Indefinitely in Locked Detention (March 23, 2017) KQED <http://audio.californiareport.org./archive/R201604081630/a> [as of March 23, 2017]) In Yolo County, for example, a vulnerable and abused child was granted asylum and still held in immigrant detention in the county criminal juvenile facility even though he has no criminal record. (Karen de Sá, Honduran Boy, 14, Wins U.S. Asylum but Remains in Jail (March 23, 2017), San Francisco Chronicle <http://www.sfchronicle.com/bayarea/article/Honduran-boy-14-wins-U-S-asylum-but-remains-in-10977616.php> [as of March 23, 2017]; Fabian Garcia, County Approves Probation Department to House More Unaccompanied Children (Oct. 23, 2015), Daily Democrat <http://www.dailydemocrat.com/article/NI/20151023/NEWS/151029943> [March 23, 2017].)
Without procedural protections, such as access to appointed counsel, immigrants, including children, in immigration detention facilities are arguably more vulnerable to abuse and in need of additional protections and safeguards. Mandating that immigrant detention facilities adhere to national immigration detention standards and affording immigrants an enforcement mechanism against the detention facility when the immigrant’s legal rights are violated will lead to more accountability and less abuse.
3. Immigrant detention facilities in California
Local governments and local law enforcement entities are not required to detain immigrants on behalf of federal immigration authorities. The ones in California that decide to detain immigrants do so by choice. Federal immigration authorities enter into Intergovernmental Service Agreements (IGSAs) with local governments or local law enforcement whereby the local entity agrees to detain immigrants on behalf of the federal government. Local governments or local law enforcement can then choose to detain the immigrants in their own facilities or subcontract with for-profit detention facilities instead. There are currently four for-profit detention facilities in California. They are located in Adelanto, Bakersfield, Calexico, and San Diego.
Ensuring that immigrants, who are oftentimes in need of special care due to persecution in their country of escape or who have suffered arduous journeys, are provided with the services they need to thrive mentally and physically often conflicts with corporate profit objectives. For-profit detention facilities are accountable to their shareholders and not the people of the State of California. For example, for-profit detention facilities claim exemptions to the public disclosure requirements under the Freedom of Information Act (FOIA) (5 U.S.C. Sec. 552) because they are private corporations, which makes the potentially unlawful conduct occurring within the facility hidden from discovery. A 2012 article in Forbes noted that “if serious questions arise about…the 16,500 federal immigration detainees held in privately-operated facilities under contracts with the U.S. Department of Homeland Security, there’s no legal remedy in place forcing those questions to be answered.” (Matt Stroud, Private Prisons Are Exempted From Federal Disclosure Laws; Advocates Say that Should Change, (Feb. 7, 2013) Forbes, <http://www.forbes.com/sites/mattstroud/2013/02/07/private-prisons-are-exempted-from-federal-disclosure-laws-advocates-say-that-should-change/#234489614d0d> [as of March 23, 2017].) The private detention facilities similarly claim an exemption to California’s State counterpart, the California Public Records Act (CPRA) (Gov. Code Sec 6250 et seq). Community Initiatives for Visiting Immigrants in Confinement (CIVIC), a sponsor of this bill, notes that despite numerous reports of inadequate medical care, suicide attempts, sexual assault, and even deaths at for profit immigrant detention facilities, it is difficult to obtain information about these facilities. CIVIC explains the process for obtaining information about private for profit immigrant detention facilities as follows:
[A] person can FOIA the IGSA between ICE and the private prison. When this occurs, ICE is required to ask the corporation if they are OK with the government disclosing it. If the corporation is OK, then it will be disclosed. However, it is completely in the discretion of the private prison corporation whether any document pertaining to the IGSA or any other aspect of the business is disclosed through a FOIA request.
Accordingly, this bill would clarify that any facility that detains an immigrant pursuant to a contract with a city, county, city and county, or a local law enforcement agency is subject to the California Public Records Act. Additionally, this bill would prohibit local governments and local law enforcement from contracting with private for profit immigrant detention facilities to fulfill the commitment local governments and local law enforcement voluntarily make to the federal government to hold immigrants in civil detention on behalf of the federal government.
4. Reports of abuses in immigration detention facilities:
Staff notes that there are numerous reports detailing abuses of immigrant detainees in immigration detention facilities in California.[1]
a. LGBT abuse
Human Rights Watch has uncovered widespread abuse against transgender women in immigration detention. In immigration detention, those belonging to the lesbian, gay, bisexual, and transgender (LGBT) community are among the most vulnerable and reported to be subject to denial of hormones and other medications, forced into long stays in solitary confinement, and subject to sexual assault, and other abuses. (Matt Schiavenza, LGBT Activists Are Still Fighting (June 28, 2015) <http://www.theatlantic.com/national/archive/2015/06/ice-transgender-lgbt-immigrants/397046/> [as of March 23, 2017]; “Do You See How Much I’m Suffering Here?” Abuse Against Transgender Women in US Immigration Detention, (March 2016) Human Rights Watch.) LGBT immigrants in detention are oftentimes seeking asylum due to persecution in their country of origin and are eligible for asylum because of being persecuted as LGBT. Studies note that in the LGBT detained population there are higher accounts of the use of solitary confinement, sexual abuse, and poor medical care in immigration detention facilities. (See National Immigrant Justice Center, Stop Abuse of Detained LGBT Immigrants, <http://www.immigrantjustice.org/stop-abuse-detained-lgbt-immigrants> [as of March 23, 2017].) Human Rights Watch detailed abuses against transgender women as follows:
In our recent research on abuse against transgender women in immigration detention, many of the women we interviewed had been subjected to sexual assault and ill-treatment in detention, and others had been held in abusive conditions of indefinite solitary confinement that are justified by prison authorities as a measure for transgender detainees’ protection. Many of the cases of abuse of transgender women we documented occurred in California. As part of its transgender detention policy, ICE now detains a majority of transgender women in a segregated unit at the Santa Ana City Jail, in Santa Ana, California.
All of the transgender women who had been at Santa Ana and were interviewed by Human Rights Watch said that they were consistently subjected to strip searches by male guards. Many of these women were repeatedly sexually assaulted prior to fleeing their home countries and described the experience of being required to strip nude and undergo full cavity searches by male guards as painfully reminiscent of prior sexual assaults…
Several of the transgender women who had been at Santa Ana and were interviewed by Human Rights Watch said they had been subjected to arbitrary “lockdowns,” raising concerns that the facility is overusing lockdowns and solitary confinement in ways that violate the rights of the individuals held there and that potentially subject vulnerable detainees to additional trauma. [. . . ]
Several transgender women told Human Rights Watch that they were unable to access their HIV medications for periods ranging from two to three months after entering detention, including one transgender woman who was held in the segregated unit at Santa Ana.
b. Pregnant women are held in detention facilities
CIVIC, a sponsor of this bill, detailed abuse of a pregnant woman in a for-profit detention facility in California as follows:
[The for profit detention facility] staff fully shackled [the pregnant woman] while she was transported to a hospital to receive urgent medical care related to her pregnancy. While in transit, she tripped on the shackles and fell on her stomach. She suffered a miscarriage the next day. After a doctor confirmed she had suffered a miscarriage, [the woman] did not receive any follow-up gynecological care to ensure she had not contracted an infection or continued hemorrhaging, despite the fact that [the woman] was experiencing ongoing bleeding and vaginal irritation. This shackling violated the [2011 Operations Manual ICE Performance-Based National Detention Standards], which bars the restraint of pregnant women absent “extraordinary circumstances that render restraints absolutely necessary.”
c. In an attempt to effectuate change in for-profit immigrant detention facilities, immigrant detainees use their bodies to protest through hunger strikes
Reports document poor conditions and treatment in immigration detention facilities, including deaths allegedly due to substandard medical care. (See e.g. Fatal Neglect How Ice Ignores Death in Detention (February 2016) American Civil Liberties Union, Detention Watch Network, and Heartland Alliance’s National Immigrant Justice Center; Abuse in Adelanto: An Investigation into a California Town’s Immigration Jail, CIVIC & Detention Watch Network, p. 16.) Frontline reported that immigrants held in immigration detention facilities lack effective recourse if they are victims of crime, including sexual abuse and assault, and sometimes the government deports them before an investigation is completed. (Sarah Childress, Why Immigrant Detainees Still Aren’t Safe from Abuse (Nov. 20, 2013) Frontline <http://www.pbs.org/wgbh/frontline/article/why-immigrant-detainees-still-arent-safe-from-abuse/> [As of March 23, 2017]; Catherine Rentz, How Much Sexual Abuse Gets “Lost in Detention”? (October 19, 2011) Frontline <http://www.pbs.org/wgbh/frontline/article/how-much-sexual-abuse-gets-lost-in-detention/> [As of March 23, 2017].)
With no ability to fight against poor detention conditions, detainees have turned to hunger strikes to protest poor conditions in immigrant detention facilities. It was reported that hundreds launched a hunger strike at the private for-profit immigrant detention facility in Adelanto, California. (Katie Linthicum, Hundreds launch hunger strike at immigrant detention center in Adelanto, Calif. (Nov. 6, 2015) Los Angeles Times <http://www.latimes.com/local/lanow/la-me-ln-immigrant-hunger-strike-20151106-story.html> [as of March 23, 2017].) More than 300 men were reported to have stopped eating to protest conditions including poor medical care. Id. Hunger strikers included an asylum seeker from Ghana who had been in immigration detention for 11 months since he asked for asylum at the border. Id.
5. Codifying minimum standards for immigrant detention facilities to follow in the treatment of immigrants held in civil detention on behalf of federal immigration authorities
Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) promulgated a series of national standards laying out the requirements for basic care in immigrant detention facilities. The most recent are the Performance-Based National Detention Standards 2011 (PBNDS 2011). ICE uses national detention standards to govern conditions of confinement in its detention facilities established through contracts with those facilities. (United States Government Accountability Office, “Immigration Detention” Additional Actions Could Strengthen DHS Efforts to Address Sexual Abuse, p. 12 (Nov. 2013), <http://www.gao.gov/assets/660/659145.pdf> [as of March 23, 2017].) Immigration detention facilities already agree to follow these standards pursuant to the Intergovernmental Service Agreements (IGSAs) between the federal government and the local governments, including when the local entities contract out with for-profit corporations. (See e.g. Mesa Verde IGSA pp. 4, 7, 19 <http://www.documentcloud.org/documents/2631228-Mesa-Verde-CA-IGSA-Contract.html> [as of March 23, 2017].)
However, these standards are not required to be adhered to under any federal or state law. And, there is no recourse for individuals when the facilities fail to follow the standards. Human Rights Watch explains:
Many of [the abuses documented in California] violate the 2011 Performance-Based National Detention Standards (PBNDS) promulgated by US Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) in 2011. The PBNDS establish concrete standards on access to counsel, visitation, medical and mental health care, solitary confinement, and sexual assault prevention. Unfortunately, the measures are not legally binding and have only been implemented at select facilities that have voluntarily elected to modify their operating agreements with ICE. Without a mechanism to ensure compliance with these standards by all facilities, [. . . ], too many immigrant detainees suffer basic rights abuses.
An additional federal policy, ICE Directive 11065.1 (Review of the Use of Segregation for ICE Detainees), was created to govern the placement of immigrant detainees in solitary confinement. The directive was created after a joint study by two human rights organizations revealed that immigrant detainees were increasingly placed in solitary confinement due to mental illness, sexual orientation, or not speaking English. (See Heartland Alliance and Physicians for Human Rights (Sept. 2012) Invisible in Isolation: The Use of Segregation and Solitary Confinement in Immigration Detention.) This policy directive is equally unenforceable by immigrant detainees.
This bill makes it clear that every immigrant detention facility in California must, at a minimum, meet the same objective national standards for the detention of immigrants. Mandating that all immigrant detention facilities in California must meet the same minimum standards will arguably lead to uniformity of treatment of immigrant detainees across the state and will diminish abuse in the immigrant detention facilities.
6. Enforcement mechanism
This bill would require that immigrant detention facilities adhere to the 2011 Operations Manual ICE Performance-Based National Detention Standards as corrected and clarified in February 2013, ICE Directive 11065.1 (Review of the Use of Segregation for ICE Detainees), and other rights granted by this bill. This bill would provide an enforcement mechanism whereby the Attorney General, any district attorney, or city attorney may bring a civil action for injunctive and other appropriate equitable relief in the name of the people of the State of California and may also seek a civil penalty of $25,000, as specified, when an immigrant detention facility, or its agent or person acting on its behalf deprives an immigrant detainee of their rights created under this bill or rights under the 2011 Operations Manual ICE Performance-Based National Detention Standards as corrected and clarified in February 2013 or ICE Directive 11065.1 (Review of the Use of Segregation for ICE Detainees).
7. Opposition Arguments
The California State Sheriffs’ Association writes the following in opposition:
When local correctional facilities house detained immigrants, they do so in coordination with the federal government, according to the laws and standards created by federal authorities. Additionally, state regulations provide minimum standards for all public detention facilities. We believe SB 29 inappropriately inserts the state into matters that are appropriately governed by federal authorities. Given the fact that the federal government has occupied the field of immigration enforcement, it is certainly possible that this measure would be preempted by federal law.
Additionally, by creating a public right of action for alleged violations of the federal guidelines and the bill’s standards, SB 29 exposes local governments to state civil liability despite federal oversight and enforcement. The costs of litigation resulting from this bill are likely to be significant. We are also concerned that the bill’s ban on contracting with private entities could result in overcrowded local facilities being left as the only viable option for immigrant detention, assuming the federal government does not decide to move detainees out of state and away from their families, which is also a possible outcome.
In response to the California State Sheriffs’ Association’s opposition to immigrant detainees being able to enforce their rights to be free from abuse, the author states:
The standards in SB 29 are already included in all immigration detention contracts in California, but are currently not being upheld in large part because there is no consequence if facilities fall below these standards. In fact, there have been many accounts documenting repeated failures to adhere to these standards, resulting in poor medical treatment and other substandard care. (See e.g., Fatal Neglect, How ICE ignores Deaths in Detention (Feb. 2016) American Civil Liberties Union, Detention Watch Network, and Heartland Alliance’s National Immigrant Justice Center; Congressional letter to ICE about Adelanto conditions, (July 14, 2015), https://www.documentcloud.org/documents/2165708-adelanto-letter.html.)
There has to be a consequence for facilities that do not uphold the standards, otherwise abuse and neglect will continue. And, despite numerous reports of facilities falling below the detention standards, historically there has been little to no action even when facilities fall below the federal standards. Further, immigration detention is civil in nature. It is thus important that we provide protections to this especially vulnerable population, especially since these individuals are not afforded some of the protections built into the criminal justice system, such as the right to government-appointed counsel.
In response to the California State Sheriffs’ Association’s assertion that “SB 29 inappropriately inserts the state into matters that are appropriately governed by federal authorities…it is certainly possible that this measure would be preempted by federal law,” the author responds:
Immigration is federally regulated. However, this bill is not about immigration enforcement, this is about ensuring state standards for treating people humanely. The state is fully within its jurisdiction to assert higher standards of care for detainees being held in our state. Regardless, the facilities in California are contracting with local governments, which the state has purview over.
Staff notes that local governments and local law enforcement entities in California are choosing to enter into contracts with federal immigration authorities. They are not mandated to enter into contracts to detain immigrants on behalf of federal immigration authorities. In fact, less than 20 local government or local law enforcement entities out of the hundreds of cities, counties, police departments, and Sheriffs offices have made the choice to get paid by the federal government to detain immigrants. The state would not regulate the federal government through any provision in this bill. The state would only regulate the local governments and local law enforcement entities. These are entities the state has clear authority to regulate.
In response to California State Sheriffs’ Association’s concern that the bill’s ban on contracting out with private for-profit detention facilities “could result in overcrowded local facilities being left as the only viable option for immigrant detention,” the author responds:
There are alternatives to detention that exist for immigrants that are not being utilized because the private for-profit detention facilities are guaranteed they will be paid for certain numbers of detainees every day. These alternatives include releasing immigrants on bond or through other alternatives to bond. (See Mills Legal Clinic Stanford Law School Immigrants’ Rights Clinic and Detention Watch Network (Aug. 2010) Community-based Alternatives to Immigration Detention); Mark Noferi, Esq., A Human Approach Can Work: The Effectiveness of Alternatives to Detention for Asylum Seekers (July 2015) American Immigration Council.) Again, local government entities and local law enforcement entities do not have to participate in detaining immigrants in their county or city jails. In fact, if there is jail overcrowding, the county or city or law enforcement entity should be using their jail facilities to hold criminal detainees, not to choose to make extra money holding immigrants in civil detention.
Detaining immigrants on behalf of the federal immigration authorities is optional. Local governments can avoid any issues of exacerbated overcrowding at jail facilities by choosing not to engage in civilly detaining immigrants. Contra Costa County has recently been criticized for requesting $70 million in state funds to expand capacity in their West County Detention Facility while receiving $3 million annually from the federal government for holding immigration detainees on behalf of ICE in their detention facility. (Otis R. Taylor Jr., Contra Costa Sheriff’s Tie to ICE Riles Immigrants’ Advocates (Feb. 8, 2017), San Francisco Chronicle <http://www.sfchronicle.com/news/article/Contra-Costa-sheriff-s-tie-to-ICE-riles-10915704.php> [March 23, 2017]; Karina Ioffee, Richmond: Contra Costa Supes Move Forward with Controversial New Jail Project (Feb. 2, 2017), East Bay Times <http://www.eastbaytimes.com/2017/02/07/richmond-contra-costa-supes-move-forward-with-controversial-new-jail-project/>[March 23, 2017].) Moreover, any concerns regarding a local government’s liability due to right of action can equally be eliminated if the entities choose not to contract to detain immigrants. However, the bill makes it clear that if California’s local governments or local law enforcement entities make the choice to detain immigrants as civil immigration detainees, the immigrants will be held under uniform humane standards and will be afforded a mechanism to enforce their legal rights.
In support of this bill, the Association for Los Angeles Deputy Sheriffs, the Association of Deputy District Attorneys, the Los Angeles County Probation Officers’ Union, AFSCME, Local 685, the Los Angeles Police Protective League, and the Riverside Sheriffs’ Association write:
Such private, for-profit immigration detention facilities present a list of problems. The facilities can operate with little to no oversight. Often they will operate under an incentive, where they are guaranteed a minimum number of detainees in their facility at all times, thus ensuring their profits. Private detention contracts are designed to incentivize filing the most beds at all times, regardless of public safety or their destructive effects on communities. Private companies make billions in profits every year from incarcerating mothers, fathers, children and others in our broken immigration system.
Support: Alliance for Boys and Men of Color; American Academy of Pediatrics, California; American Federation of State, County and Municipal Employees (AFSCME), AFL-CIO; AFSCME, Local 685; Association for Los Angles Deputy Sheriffs; Association of Deputy District Attorneys; California Catholic Conference; California Environmental Justice Alliance; California Immigrant Policy Center; Community Clinic Association of Los Angeles County; Council on American-Islamic Relations; Equality California; Human Rights Defense Center; Inland Coalition for Immigrant Rights; Jewish Public Affairs Committee of California; Los Angeles County Probation Officers’ Union; Los Angeles County Professional Peace Officers Association; Los Angeles LGBT Center; Los Angeles Police Protective League; Pangea Legal Services; Riverside Sheriffs’ Association; Service Employees International Union; Transgender Law Center
Opposition: California State Sheriffs’ Association
HISTORY
Source: Immigrant Legal Resource Center (ILRC); Community Initiatives for Visiting Immigrants in Confinement (CIVIC)
Related Pending Legislation:
SB 6 (Hueso) would create a program within the Department of Social Services to fund immigration attorneys to represent Californians in immigration removal defense. This bill is currently on the Senate Floor.
SB 54 (De León) would limit state and local law enforcement agencies involvement in immigration enforcement and ensure that eligible individuals are able to seek services from and engage with state agencies without regard to their immigration status. This bill is currently on the Senate Floor.
AB 3 (Bonta) would create a state program to support county offices of the public defender and other specified entities in the provision of services related to fulfilling obligations under Padilla v. Kentucky, 559 U.S. 356 (2010) to provide advisals to immigrants regarding immigration consequences of criminal convictions. This bill is currently in the Assembly Appropriations Committee.
Prior Legislation:
SB 1289 (Lara, 2016) was identical to the bill now before this committee and was vetoed by the Governor. See Background.
*************
See e.g. American Civil Liberties Union, Detention Watch Network, and Heartland Alliance’s National Immigrant Justice Center Fatal Neglect How Ice Ignores Death in Detention (February 2016); “Do You See How Much I’m Suffering Here?” Abuse Against Transgender Women in US Immigration Detention, (March 2016) Human Rights Watch. ↑
Discussed in Hearing
Senate Floor
Assembly Floor
Assembly Floor
Assembly Standing Committee on Appropriations
Assembly Standing Committee on Judiciary
Senate Floor
Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations
Senate Standing Committee on Judiciary
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):