SB 337: Repatriation Infrastructure Fund.
- Session Year: 2017-2018
- House: Senate
- Latest Version Date: 2017-02-13
Existing law provides various sources of funding for transportation purposes, including funding for the state highway system, the local street and road system, and public transportation.
This bill, until July 1, 2025, would require the Department of Finance, in consultation with the Franchise Tax Board, to estimate, on an annual basis by November 1 of each year, the amount of revenue to be received from state taxes in the next fiscal year as a consequence of enactment of a federal corporate repatriation statute pursuant to which foreign earnings of United States-based corporations that are currently invested abroad are moved to the United States.
The bill, until July 1, 2025, after reservation of appropriate amounts required to be allocated by the California Constitution for Proposition 98 education funding requirements and the Budget Stabilization Account, would require the remaining repatriation revenues to be transferred to the Repatriation Infrastructure Fund in the State Transportation Fund, which the bill would create. The bill would continuously appropriate the revenues in the Repatriation Infrastructure Fund to the California Transportation Commission. The bill would require 65% of available revenues to be allocated by the commission to trade corridor improvement projects, and would require the Controller to apportion 30% of available revenues to cities and counties for local street and roads and 5% of available revenues to public transportation, as specified.
The Repatriation Infrastructure Fund is hereby created in the State Transportation Fund.
14561.The moneys in the fund, notwithstanding Section 13340, are hereby continuously appropriated without regard to fiscal years to the California Transportation Commission for the purposes of this chapter, and shall be allocated annually as follows:
(a)Sixty-five percent to be allocated by the commission to trade corridor improvement projects.
(b)Thirty percent for apportionment by the Controller to cities and counties for local streets and roads, pursuant to the formulas in subparagraph (C) of paragraph (3) of subdivision (a) of Section 2103 of the Streets and Highways Code.
(c)Five percent for apportionment by the Controller to transportation planning agencies for allocation to transit operators for public transportation, pursuant to the formulas in Section 99312.1 of the Public Utilities Code.
14562.This chapter shall become inoperative on July 1, 2025, and, as of January 1, 2026, is repealed.
SEC. 2.Section 16342 is added to the Government Code, to read:16342.(a)The Department of Finance, in consultation with the Franchise Tax Board, shall estimate, on an annual basis on or before November 1 of each year, the amount of revenue to be received from state taxes in the next fiscal year as a consequence of enactment of a federal corporate repatriation statute pursuant to which foreign earnings of United States-based corporations that are currently invested abroad are moved to the United States. For the 201819 fiscal year, the estimate shall be completed as soon as practicable after January 1, 2018.
(b)In each fiscal year beginning with the 201819 fiscal year, after reservation of appropriate amounts from the total revenues available pursuant to subdivision (a) for purposes of Section 8 of Article XVI of the California Constitution (Proposition 98) and Section 20 of Article XVI of the California Constitution (Budget Stabilization Account), the remaining revenues, notwithstanding any other provision of law, shall be transferred to the Repatriation Infrastructure Fund in the State Transportation Fund created pursuant to Section 14560. The amounts reserved for purposes of Proposition 98 and the Budget Stabilization Account in each fiscal year and included in each Budget Act, and the amounts transferred to the Repatriation Infrastructure Fund, shall be based on the revenue estimates made by the Department of Finance pursuant to subdivision (a), and shall be subject to adjustment in future fiscal years based on actual revenues received during the budget year.
(c)This section shall become inoperative on July 1, 2025, and, as of January 1, 2026, is repealed.
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Feb 1, 2018 | Returned to Secretary of Senate pursuant to Joint Rule 56. |
| Jan 10, 2018 | January 10 hearing: Heard for testimony only. |
| Jan 9, 2018 | Set for hearing January 11 in T. & H. pending receipt. |
| Jan 4, 2018 | Set for hearing January 10. |
| Apr 5, 2017 | April 5 hearing: Testimony taken. Hearing postponed by committee. |
| Mar 8, 2017 | Set for hearing April 5. |
| Feb 23, 2017 | Referred to Coms. on GOV. & F. and T. & H. |
| Feb 14, 2017 | From printer. May be acted upon on or after March 16. |
| Feb 13, 2017 | Introduced. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. To print. |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
SENATE COMMITTEE ON GOVERNANCE AND FINANCE
Senator Mike McGuire, Chair
2017 - 2018 Regular
Bill No: | SB 337 | Hearing Date: | 1/10/18 |
Author: | Bates | Tax Levy: | No |
Version: | 2/13/17 | Fiscal: | Yes |
Consultant: | Grinnell | ||
Repatriation Infrastructure Fund
Shifts any increase in estimated state tax revenue resulting from a federal repatriation statute to specified transportation purposes.
Background
Corporate taxes at the federal and state level apply to different bases. Until recently, the Internal Revenue Code generally applied a graduated tax rate schedule, with a top rate of 35%, on the total worldwide income of United States-headquartered companies, including its foreign subsidiaries. The Code allows taxes on income derived by U.S. corporations from foreign subsidiaries to be deferred in some cases, but not in others. For example, tax on foreign subsidiaries’ operating income is generally deferred until “repatriated” in the form of a dividend paid to the U.S. parent corporation (less a credit for any foreign taxes paid on that income).
Most foreign subsidiaries are considered Controlled Foreign Corporations (CFCs) under the Code. A CFC is a corporate entity that is registered and conducts business in a different country, such as Ireland, than the residency of its U.S. owners. CFCs pay tax in the current taxable year on any U.S. income, as well as specified sources of passive, highly mobile non-operating income, such as dividends, royalties, interest, and rents, regardless of whether the subsidiary has paid a dividend. Subpart F of the Code specifies the forms of a CFC’s income which are taxable on a current basis.
On December 22nd, 2017, President Trump signed HR 1, which enacted fundamental changes to the federal corporate income tax. Among other changes, the measure:
- Eliminates the graduated rate schedule for corporate income with a top rate of 35%, and replaces it with a single rate of 21%, effective in the 2018 taxable year.
- Enacts a “forced repatriation” that requires U.S. taxpayers to include in income in the last taxable year any deferred foreign income not previously taxed, with some exceptions. Corporate taxpayers can partially offset the repatriation with a deduction, the amount of which depends on whether the income is held in the form of liquid or illiquid assets. The net effect is a 15.5-percent tax rate on foreign earnings held in the form of cash or cash equivalents, and an 8-percent tax rate on all other earnings. Taxpayers can pay the tax on repatriated earnings in equal installments over eight years. HR 1 accomplishes the forced repatriation by increasing a CFC’s Subpart F income for the last taxable year.
- Limits significantly taxation of a U.S. taxpayer’s foreign source income by adopting a “territorial system,” which allows a 100% deduction for the foreign-source portion of dividends received from its 10% owned foreign corporations, including CFCs, beginning in the 2018 taxable year. Only “C” Corporations can claim the dividend.
California instead taxes at a rate of 8.84% the net business income and allocated net nonbusiness income of a multistate or multinational corporation doing business in California apportioned by its sales factor, or imposes the $800 minimum tax, whichever is greater, with some exceptions. Business income generally includes any income derived from the taxpayer’s trade or business, while nonbusiness income typically includes rents, royalties, interest and dividends not connected to the taxpayer’s trade or business. California also applies the combined report method of corporate taxation, where the income and expenses of a firm’s unitary subsidiaries and affiliates must be included as a group on a single tax return. While determining unity for purposes of a combined report has been subject to disputes, this method generally allows for the cancellation of any intercompany transactions, such as dividends paid from a foreign subsidiary to a domestic parent. However, taxpaying corporations can elect to exclude the income and expenses of its foreign subsidiaries from the combined report, called the “water’s edge” election. Despite the water’s edge election, state law requires taxpayers to include specified income of certain foreign subsidiaries and affiliates in the combined report, including CFCs. California requires taxpayers making the water’s edge election to include a specified portion of its CFC’s Subpart F income, plus its apportionment factors, based on an inclusion ratio, on a current basis.
Seeking additional funds for transportation purposes, the author wants to shift any additional state tax revenue resulting from HR 1 to transportation purposes.
Proposed Law
Senate Bill (SB) 337 creates the Repatriation Investment Fund in the State Transportation Fund, which is continuously appropriated without regard to fiscal year to the California Transportation Commission, as follows:
- 65% to trade corridor improvement projects,
- 30% by the Controller to cities and counties for local streets and roads pursuant to current formulas specified in the bill,
- 5% by the Controller to transportation planning agencies for allocation to transit operators for public transportation pursuant to current formulas specified in the bill.
The bill requires the Department of Finance (DOF) in consultation with the Franchise Tax Board (FTB) to estimate on an annual basis on or before November 1st the amount of revenue to be received by state taxes in the next fiscal year as a consequence of enactment of a federal corporation repatriation statute pursuant to which foreign earnings of United States-based corporations that are currently invested abroad are moved to the United States. The estimate must be completed as soon as practicable after January 1, 2018 for the 2018-19 fiscal year.
The measure provides that after reserving amounts from the total estimate calculated above for Proposition 98 and the Budget Stabilization Amount, remaining revenues must be transferred to the Repatriation Investment Fund. Each amount reserved in each fiscal year and included in each Budget Act, as well as transfers to the Fund, must be based on the estimate, which is subject to adjustment based on actual revenues received during the budget year.
The measure becomes inoperative on July 1, 2025, and is repealed as of January 1, 2026.
State Revenue Impact
No estimate.
Comments
1. Purpose of the bill. According to the author, “SB 337 establishes the Repatriation Infrastructure Fund to collect California tax windfall from businesses bringing money back to California to repair our roads. Essentially, this bill would ‘Repatriate, Rebuild and Repave.’ For California to have a vibrant economy, one that creates jobs and financial security for all, we must maintain, rebuild and repair the vital infrastructure that keeps everything and everyone moving. In recent years, local streets and roads have faced an estimated shortfall of $73 billion in deferred maintenance. Caltrans estimates that 55% of the state’s pavement is in either fair or poor condition. Additionally, of the 13,100 bridges and structures in the State Highway System, approximately 3,275 bridges are in fair or poor condition. Requiring the state to use any tax proceeds from repatriated foreign earnings to fund transportation would help supplement our efforts to re-establish California’s commitment to transportation infrastructure. The amount of revenue that could be generated in California taxes is uncertain. However, this would be new funding for the state, generated by corporate earnings, after requirements have been met for Proposition 98 and the Rainy Day Fund. While the recent gas tax increase has supplemented state and local funding for our streets and highways, this additional funding would relieve the pressure on locals to produce more funding for transportation. The gas tax and DMV fee increase are regressive taxes that dramatically affect the bottom-line of low- and middle-income families. According to the U.S. Congress Joint Committee on Taxation, the total of “undistributed” and ‘not previously taxed’ foreign earnings of American companies amounted to $2.6 trillion as of 2015. The amount of repatriated dollars could be tremendous for our state. SB 337 ensures that any windfall from a federal repatriation deal is allocated towards transportation. There’s no better place to invest the revenue windfall than in fixing California’s deteriorating roads and bridges.
2. Appropriate? Revenue from the state’s general taxes are generally not dedicated to specific purposes, except for the California Constitution’s requirement that proceeds from both the excise tax and the sales tax on gasoline are dedicated to transportation purposes. Instead, the Legislature and the Governor set the state’s spending priorities each year when they enact the State Budget. SB 337 sets a precedent by transferring revenues resulting from one act of Congress for specific purposes outside the budget process, at the cost of other funding priorities, albeit only after reserving amounts for Proposition 98’s education funding guarantee and Proposition 2’s budgetary reserve. As a result, SB 337 would reduce the funds available for the Legislature to appropriate any additional revenues as part of the Budget, thereby reducing its flexibility to meet other needs or maintain current program funding in the event of reductions in federal funding or an economic recession. Because the bill continuously appropriates funds, the Legislature would have to enact a new statute to undo its transfer. Last year, the Legislature enacted AB 1499 (Gray), which required the Governor to include in the proposed and revised budgets amounts for capital outlay projects at state fairs; however, that bill did not automatically transfer revenue. Instead, the measure provided that the Legislature must appropriate any funds for that purpose. The Committee may wish to consider the precedent established by SB 337, and whether the measure may limit the Legislature’s flexibility to respond to a budget shortfall.
3. Accurate? Any estimate that compels shifting funds away from health and human services, corrections, and other parts of the state’s budget outside the Budget Act should be as accurate as possible. However, completing an exact estimate of any incremental funding from HR 1’s international tax provisions will be difficult. While firms’ consolidated financial reports show more than $2.6 trillion in untaxed earnings, revenue estimators may have to make assumptions to implement SB 337, including:
- The share of repatriated income taxable in California.
- Whether the taxable income will be considered apportioned business income, or allocated nonbusiness income.
- Whether firms repatriating income make the water’s edge election, or file under the worldwide combined method, in which case any repatriated funds will be cancelled out.
- The effect of importing factors from CFCs.
- Whether amounts stated on original returns will be subsequently subject to refund claims, especially given the incentive for larger firms to file conservative original returns due to California’s Large Corporate Understatement Penalty.
- Whether California conforms provisions of its corporate income tax to conform with HR1.
- The degree in which California’s foreign dividend deduction (R&T §24411) applies to any dividends.
- The impact of any litigation or subsequent technical cleanup legislation.
SB 337 does allow subsequent adjustments to estimates, which could offset uncertainty. However, any subsequent adjustments would make the measure’s revenue source less stable, which could make planning, constructing, and completing transportation projects more difficult. The Committee may wish to consider whether it’s desirable to require shifting funds from needed purposes given the potential uncertainties in developing an estimate.
5. SB 1. After several years of consideration, last year the Legislature enacted SB 1 (Beall), which increased several taxes and fees to raise roughly $52.4 billion over ten years in new transportation revenues, and makes adjustments for inflation every year; directs the funding to be used towards deferred maintenance on the state highways and local streets and roads; and to improve the state's trade corridors, transit, and active transportation facilities. That bill increased the excise tax on gasoline by $0.12 per gallon, the excise tax on diesel fuel by $0.20 per gallon, and the sales tax on diesel fuels by an additional 4% increment, commencing November 1, 2017. The measure also created a new annual Transportation Improvement Fee, starting January 1, 2018, based on the market value of the vehicle, and imposed the Road Improvement Fee of $100 per vehicle for zero emission vehicles, starting in 2020 for model year 2020 and later.
6. Double referred. The Senate Rules Committee ordered a double referral for SB 337, first to the Committee on Governance and Finance to consider the measure’s tax implications, and to the Committee on Transportation and Housing to assess its effect on transportation funding.
7. Technicals. Committee staff recommends the following technical amendments:
- Replacing the phrase “consequence of enactment of a federal corporate repatriation statute pursuant to which foreign earnings of United States-based corporations that are currently invested abroad are moved to the United States,” with “result of the enactment of HR 1’s international tax provisions.”
- Replacing references to the 2018-19 fiscal year, and the estimate deadline date of January 1, 2018, with the 2019-20 fiscal year and January 1, 2019.
Support and Opposition
(1/3/18)
Support: None received.
Opposition: None received.
-- END --
SENATE COMMITTEE ON GOVERNANCE AND FINANCE
Senator Mike McGuire, Chair
2017 - 2018 Regular
Bill No: | SB 337 | Hearing Date: | 4/5/17 |
Author: | Bates | Tax Levy: | No |
Version: | 2/13/17 | Fiscal: | Yes |
Consultant: | Grinnell | ||
Repatriation Infrastructure Fund
Shifts any increase in estimated state tax revenue resulting from a federal repatriation statute to specified transportation purposes.
Background
Corporation taxes at the federal and state level apply to very different bases. Generally, federal tax applies a 35 percent rate to the total income of United States-headquartered companies. When U.S.-headquartered companies operate in foreign countries, they generally do so as Controlled Foreign Corporations (CFCs), defined as entities where more than 50 percent of voting stock is held by U.S. shareholders. CFCs are taxable on U.S. income, as well as their foreign income subject to Subpart F of the Internal Revenue, which applies only to specific sources of foreign income such as dividends, royalties, interest, and rents, among others. The U.S. parent is usually not taxed on its CFCs’ operating income until “repatriated” in the form of a dividend, in which case the firm can apply a credit for foreign taxes paid. Corporations usually report their foreign earnings as part of their consolidated financial reports, which presumes that the earnings will be “repatriated” eventually. Congress enacted the American Jobs Creation Act of 2004 to provide a temporary repatriation holiday, and may again soon: according to a November 25, 2016, Wall Street Journal article, over the past decade, the total undistributed foreign earnings of U.S. companies have risen from about $500 billion to more than $2.5 trillion, a sum equal to nearly 14 percent of U.S. gross domestic product.
California instead taxes at a rate of 8.84 percent the net business income of a multistate or multinational corporation doing business in California apportioned by its sales factor, or imposes the $800 minimum tax, whichever is greater, with some exceptions. Business income generally includes any income derived from the taxpayer’s trade or business operations. California requires any firm to include in the state of the taxpayer’s commercial domicile any nonbusiness income, or income derived from rents, royalties, interest and dividends not connected to the taxpayer’s trade or business, with several exceptions for property sales and royalties, among others. The distinction between business and nonbusiness income can be unclear in some cases, and has often been subject to disputes and litigation. California also applies the combined report method of corporate taxation, where the income and expenses of a firm’s unitary subsidiaries and affiliates must be included as a group on a single tax return. While determining unity for purposes of a combined report has often been subject to disputes and litigation, this method generally allows for the cancellation of any intercompany transactions, such as dividends paid within the group. However, the taxpayer can elect to exclude the income and expenses of its foreign subsidiaries from the combined report, called the “water’s edge” election; however, in specific cases, certain foreign subsidiaries and affiliates must be included within the water’s edge, such as CFCs. California requires CFCs to include in the combined report certain kinds of Subpart F income, plus apportionment factors, based on an inclusion ratio. Foreign corporations with less than 20 percent of activities in the United States and foreign banks must be included in the combined report too to the extent that they have U.S. Income.
Seeking additional funds for transportation purposes, the author wants to shift any additional state tax revenue from a repatriation holiday to transportation purposes.
Proposed Law
Senate Bill 337 creates the Repatriation Investment Fund in the State Transportation Fund, which is continuously appropriated without regard to fiscal year to the California Transportation Commission as follows:
- 65 percent to trade corridor improvement projects,
- 30 percent by the Controller to cities and counties for local streets and roads pursuant to current formulas specified in the bill,
- 5 percent by the Controller to transportation planning agencies for allocation to transit operators for public transportation pursuant to current formulas specified in the bill.
The bill requires the Department of Finance (DOF) in consultation with the Franchise Tax Board (FTB) to estimate on annual basis on or before November 1st the amount of revenue to be received by state taxes in the next fiscal year as a consequence of enactment of a federal corporation repatriation statute pursuant to which foreign earnings of United States-based corporations that are currently invested abroad are moved to the United States. The estimate must be completed as soon as practicable after January 1, 2018 for the 2018-19 fiscal year.
The measure provides that after reserving amounts from the total estimate calculated above for Proposition 98 and the Budget Stabilization Amount, remaining revenues must be transferred to the Repatriation Investment Fund. Each amount reserved in each fiscal year and included in each Budget Act, as well as transfers to the Fund, must be based on the estimate, which is subject to adjustment based on actual revenues received during the budget year.
The measure becomes inoperative on July 1, 2025, and is repealed as of January 1, 2026.
State Revenue Impact
No estimate.
Comments
1. Purpose of the bill. According to the author, “SB 337 establishes the Repatriation Infrastructure Fund to collect California tax windfall from businesses bringing money back to California to repair our roads. Essentially, this bill would ‘Repatriate, Rebuild and Repave.’ For California to have a vibrant economy, one that creates jobs and financial security for all, we must maintain, rebuild and repair the vital infrastructure that keeps everything and everyone moving.
Local streets and roads face an estimated shortfall of $73 billion in deferred maintenance. CalTrans faces a $59 billion backlog in deferred maintenance. Caltrans estimates that 55 percent of the state’s pavement is in either fair or poor condition. Additionally, of the 13,100 bridges and structures in the State Highway System, approximately 3,275 bridges are in fair or poor condition. Our transportation system is in dire shape and the state must change the tide. Requiring the state to use any tax proceeds from repatriated foreign earnings to fund transportation would help supplement our efforts to re-establish California’s commitment to transportation infrastructure; a priority that has sadly taken a backseat to other programs. The amount of revenue that could be generated in California taxes is uncertain. However, this would be new funding for the state, generated by corporate earnings, after requirements have been met for Proposition 98 and the Rainy Day Fund. According to the U.S. Congress Joint Committee on Taxation, the total of ‘undistributed’ and ‘not previously taxed’ foreign earnings of American companies amounted to $2.6 trillion as of 2015. Although the legislation for addressing repatriation is still being developed at the federal level, SB 337 steps ahead of the curve to ensure that the unexpected windfall from a federal repatriation deal is allocated towards transportation. There’s no better place to invest the revenue windfall than in fixing California’s deteriorating roads and bridges.”
2. Appropriate? Revenue from the state’s general taxes are generally not dedicated to specific purposes, except for the California Constitution’s requirement that proceeds from the gasoline excise tax and the sales tax on gasoline are dedicated to transportation purposes. The Legislature and the Governor set the state’s spending priorities each year when they enact the State Budget. SB 337 sets a precedent by setting aside revenue from one possible act of Congress for specific purposes outside the budget process, at the cost of other funding priorities normally subject to the Legislature’s annual budget deliberations. Additionally, the Legislature has invested substantial energy considering legislation seeking additional revenue for transportation purposes in recent years, such as SB 1 (Beall, 2017), so much so that the Governor called a special session for that purpose last year. The Committee may wish to consider the precedent established by SB 337, and whether either current transportation funding proposals or the Budget process is a better way to enhance transportation funding.
3. Possible? The question presented by SB 337 is not whether a preferential rate on repatriated foreign earning is desirable public policy; instead the measure asks whether California should continuously appropriate revenues from non-Proposition 98 purposes to transportation based on DOF’s estimate of any additional state taxes resulting from repatriation. Any estimate that compels shifting funds away from health and human services, corrections, and other parts of the state’s budget outside the Budget Act should be as accurate as possible. However, completing an estimate of any incremental funding from repatriation, a reliable, timely estimate is highly unlikely due to the following:
- A bill may not be enacted soon, if ever. Congress is soon expected to debate the most significant change in the history of federal business taxation by moving from a net corporate income tax to a destination based cash flow tax. Any repatriation legislation will likely result from the outcome of that debate, which is far from certain. The first bill in the current Congress that fits SB 337’s definition was introduced by Rep. John Delaney on March 23rd (H.R. 1670, the Infrastructure 2.0 Act).
- Proposals for the preferential treatment of deferred foreign earnings vary. Both President Trump’s plan and the House blueprint would impose a one-time reduced tax rate on U.S. companies' deferred foreign earnings that have not been repatriated. Under the House blueprint, an 8.75 percent tax would be imposed on accumulated foreign earnings held in cash or cash equivalents, and a 3.5 percent tax would be imposed on all other accumulated earnings. Companies could pay the tax on repatriated earnings over an eight-year period. Under the Trump plan, accumulated offshore earnings would be subject to a one-time 10 percent tax. Firms’ response will be highly dependent on the specific proposal enacted.
- Assuming a bill is enacted, DOF and FTB would have to make an estimate without knowing:
- The amount of foreign earnings firms in the aggregate will repatriate. While firms’ consolidated financial reports show more than $2.6 trillion, both the Joint Committee on Taxation and the Federal Reserve Bank of Atlanta warn that these amounts may be overstated because a considerable amount has already been permanently invested in the taxpayer’s business outside the U.S.
- DOF is unlikely to know which firms will repatriate how much, because they do not have access to the future financial decisions of potentially affected firms.
- Whether any repatriated income would be considered apportionable business income, or allocated nonbusiness income. Presumably, a federal bill could provide some guidance, but the distinction depends on the function the funds serve in the taxpayer’s trade or business, which is information DOF is unlikely to have at the time the estimate is required (FTB Legal Ruling 2005-02).
- Whether firms repatriated funds are from CFCs, or whether the firm files under the worldwide combined method, in which case any repatriated funds will be cancelled out, or water’s edge, in which case California’s 75 percent or 100 percent foreign divided exclusion would apply.
- Whether amounts stated on original returns will be subsequently subject to refund claims, especially given the incentive for larger firms to file conservative original returns due to California’s Large Corporate Understatement Penalty. SB 337 does allow subsequent adjustments to estimates, which could offset this uncertainty. However, any subsequent adjustments would make the measure’s revenue source less stable.
The difficulty of developing an estimate of sufficient accuracy to justify shifting funds is considerable. The Committee may wish to consider whether it’s desirable to require shifting funds from needed purposes based on a highly uncertain revenue estimate.
4. Buyer beware. While likely a revenue raiser for the federal government, no clear evidence exists that federal repatriation legislation will be a revenue boon to the states given the significant differences in tax bases. Many foreign subsidiaries’ earnings are held in tax havens where little to no tax applies, so even a preferential federal rate may not spur a change in behavior. As mentioned above, firms may have already permanently reinvested these earnings in foreign subsidiaries’ business operations. Two advisors with accounting firm KPMG recently told the Multistate Tax Commission’s Litigation Committee that it’s too soon to determine the revenue effect to states of federal tax reform, and that it could be revenue negative in aggregate.
Support and Opposition
(3/30/17)
Support: None r4eceived.
Opposition: None received.
-- END --
Discussed in Hearing
Senate Standing Committee on Governance and Finance
Senate Standing Committee on Governance and Finance
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):