SB 460: Communications: broadband Internet access service: state agencies.
- Session Year: 2017-2018
- House: Senate
- Latest Version Date: 2018-08-28
(1)Existing law generally governs the state procurement of materials, supplies, equipment, and services, and the acquisition of electronic data-processing and telecommunications goods and services.
This bill would prohibit a state agency from contracting with an Internet service provider for the provision of broadband Internet access service unless that provider certifies require an Internet service provider that submits a bid or proposal to, or that otherwise proposes to enter into or renew a contract with, a state agency with respect to any contract in the amount of $100,000 or more for the provision of broadband Internet access service to certify that it is in full compliance with, and renders broadband Internet access service to the state agency consistent with, specified provisions of SB 822 of the 201718 Regular Session concerning the treatment of Internet traffic, as provided. The bill would authorize a state agency to waive these provisions under specified conditions.
(2)The bill would make its operation contingent on the enactment of SB 822 of the 201718 Regular Session.
(1)Existing law generally governs the state procurement of materials, supplies, equipment, and services, and the acquisition of electronic data-processing and telecommunications goods and services.
This bill would prohibit a state agency from contracting with an Internet service provider for the provision of broadband Internet access service unless that provider certifies under penalty of perjury that it will not engage in specified activities. Because the bill would expand the crime of perjury, the bill would impose a state-mandated local program. that it is in full compliance with, and renders broadband Internet access service to the state agency consistent with, specified provisions of SB 822 of the 201718 Regular Session concerning the treatment of Internet traffic, as provided.
(3)This bill would include legislative findings and declarations and be known as the California Internet Consumer Protection and Net Neutrality Act of 2018.(4)The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.This bill would provide that no reimbursement is required by this act for a specified reason.(2)The bill would make its operation contingent on the enactment of SB 822 of the 201718 Regular Session.
(1)Existing law, the Consumers Legal Remedies Act, makes unlawful certain unfair methods of competition and unfair or deceptive acts or practices undertaken by any person in a transaction intended to result or which results in the sale or lease of goods or services to any consumer. Existing law authorizes any consumer who suffers damages as a result of the use or employment by any person of a method, act, or practice declared to be unlawful, as described above, to bring an action against that person to recover or obtain damages, restitution, an order enjoining the methods, acts, or practice, or any other relief the court deems proper.
This bill would revise the act to prohibit specified actions by an Internet service provider, as defined, that provides broadband Internet access service, as defined, and make a violation of those prohibitions subject to the remedies available pursuant to the act.
(2)Existing law generally governs the state procurement of materials, supplies, equipment, and services, and the acquisition of electronic data-processing and telecommunications goods and services.
This bill would prohibit a state agency from contracting with an Internet service provider for the provision of broadband Internet access service unless that provider certifies under penalty of perjury that it will not engage in specified activities. Because the bill would expand the crime of perjury, the bill would impose a state-mandated local program.
(3)This bill would include legislative findings and declarations and be known as the California Internet Consumer Protection and Net Neutrality Act of 2018.
(4)The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.
This bill would provide that no reimbursement is required by this act for a specified reason.
(1)Under existing law, the Public Utilities Commission has regulatory authority over public utilities, including telephone corporations. Pursuant to its existing authority, the commission supervises administration of the states telecommunications universal service programs. The Digital Infrastructure and Video Competition Act of 2006 establishes a procedure for the issuance of state franchises for the provision of video service, defined to include cable service and open-video systems, administered by the commission.This bill would, except as provided, prohibit Internet service providers in the state from taking certain actions regarding the accessing of content on the Internet by end users. The bill would require the commission to adopt an order that, among other things, identifies and specifies this state governments role as an Internet customer and uses that customer power to ensure implementation of the bills provisions, establishes statewide consumer protection rules, ensures that public purpose program funding is expended in a manner that will maximize Internet neutrality and ensure the fair distribution of services to low-income individuals and communities, and establishes a process whereby an Internet service provider in California is required to certify to the commission that it is providing broadband Internet access service in accordance with the provisions of the bill.(2)Under existing law, a violation of the Public Utilities Act or any order, decision, rule, direction, demand, or requirement of the commission is a crime.Because a violation of an order or decision of the commission implementing this acts requirements would be a crime, this bill would impose a state-mandated local program by creating a new crime.The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.This bill would provide that no reimbursement is required by this act for a specified reason.(3)This bill would declare that it is to take effect immediately as an urgency statute.(1)Under existing law, the Public Utilities Commission has regulatory authority over public utilities, including telephone corporations. Pursuant to its existing authority, the commission supervises administration of the states telecommunications universal service programs. The Digital Infrastructure and Video Competition Act of 2006 establishes a procedure for the issuance of state franchises for the provision of video service, defined to include cable service and open-video systems, administered by the commission.
This bill would, except as provided, prohibit Internet service providers in the state from taking certain actions regarding the accessing of content on the Internet by customers. end users. The bill would require the commission to adopt an order that, among other things, identifies and specifies this state governments role as an Internet customer and uses that customer power to ensure implementation of the bills provisions, establishes statewide consumer protection rules, ensures that public purpose program funding is expended in a manner that will maximize Internet neutrality and ensure the fair distribution of services to low-income individuals and communities, and establishes a process whereby an Internet service provider in California is required to certify to the commission that it is providing broadband Internet access service in accordance with the provisions of the bill.
(2)Under existing law, a violation of the Public Utilities Act or any order, decision, rule, direction, demand, or requirement of the commission is a crime.
Because a violation of an order or decision of the commission implementing this acts requirements would be a crime, this bill would impose a state-mandated local program by creating a new crime.
The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.
This bill would provide that no reimbursement is required by this act for a specified reason.
(3)This bill would declare that it is to take effect immediately as an urgency statute.
(1)Under existing law, the Public Utilities Commission has regulatory authority over public utilities, including telephone corporations. Pursuant to its existing authority, the commission supervises administration of the states telecommunications universal service programs. The Digital Infrastructure and Video Competition Act of 2006 establishes a procedure for the issuance of state franchises for the provision of video service, defined to include cable service and open-video systems, administered by the commission.
This bill would, except as provided, prohibit Internet service providers in the state from taking certain actions regarding the accessing of content on the Internet by customers. The bill would require the commission to adopt an order that, among other things, identifies and specifies this state governments role as an Internet customer and uses that customer power to ensure implementation of the bills provisions, establishes statewide consumer protection rules, ensures that public purpose program funding is expended in a manner that will maximize Internet neutrality and ensure the fair distribution of services to low-income individuals and communities, and establishes a process whereby an Internet service provider in California is required to certify to the commission that it is providing broadband Internet access service in accordance with the provisions of the bill.
(2)Under existing law, a violation of the Public Utilities Act or any order, decision, rule, direction, demand, or requirement of the commission is a crime.
Because a violation of an order or decision of the commission implementing this acts requirements would be a crime, this bill would impose a state-mandated local program by creating a new crime.
The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.
This bill would provide that no reimbursement is required by this act for a specified reason.
(3)This bill would declare that it is to take effect immediately as an urgency statute.
Under existing law, the Public Utilities Commission has regulatory authority over public utilities, including telephone corporations. Existing law establishes, among other funds related to telecommunications, the California Advanced Services Fund (CASF) in the State Treasury. Existing law requires the commission to develop, implement, and administer the CASF to encourage the deployment of high-quality advanced communications services to all Californians that will promote economic growth, job creation, and the substantial social benefits of advanced information and communications technologies, as provided in specified decisions of the commission and in the CASF statute. Existing law requires the commission to give priority to projects that provide last-mile broadband access to households that are unserved by an existing facilities-based broadband provider. Existing law authorizes the commission to collect a surcharge for deposit into the CASF not to exceed $315,000,000 in total and authorizes the surcharge through 2020. Existing law establishes that the goal of the program is, no later than December 31, 2015, to approve funding for infrastructure projects that will provide broadband access to no less than 98% of California households. This bill would postpone the deadline for meeting that goal until December 31, 2020.Under existing law, the Public Utilities Commission has regulatory authority over public utilities, including telephone corporations. Existing law establishes, among other funds related to telecommunications, the California Advanced Services Fund (CASF) in the State Treasury. Existing law requires the commission to develop, implement, and administer the CASF to encourage the deployment of high-quality advanced communications services to all Californians that will promote economic growth, job creation, and the substantial social benefits of advanced information and communications technologies, as provided in specified decisions of the commission and in the CASF statute. Existing law requires the commission to give priority to projects that provide last-mile broadband access to households that are unserved by an existing facilities-based broadband provider. Existing law authorizes the commission to collect a surcharge for deposit into the CASF not to exceed $315,000,000 in total and authorizes the surcharge through 2020. Existing law establishes that the goal of the program is, no later than December 31, 2015, to approve funding for infrastructure projects that will provide broadband access to no less than 98% of California households.
This bill would postpone the deadline for meeting that goal until December 31, 2020.
(a)An Internet service provider that submits a bid or proposal to, or that otherwise proposes to enter into or renew a contract with, a state agency with respect to any contract in the amount of one hundred thousand dollars ($100,000) or more for the provision of broadband Internet access service shall certify in writing that both of the following conditions are met:
(1)The Internet service provider is in full compliance with Title 15 (commencing with Section 3100) of Part 4 of Division 3 of the Civil Code.
(2)The broadband Internet access service provided to the state agency by the Internet service provider is rendered consistent with the requirements of Title 15 (commencing with Section 3100) of Part 4 of Division 3 of the Civil Code.
(b)After taking all reasonable measures to find a contractor that complies with the requirements of this section, as determined by the state agency, the requirements of this section may be waived under any of the following circumstances:
(1)Whenever there is only one prospective contractor willing to enter into a specific contract with the state agency and that contractor is unable to provide either of the certifications required pursuant to subdivision (a).
(2)If the contract is necessary to respond to an emergency, as determined by the state agency, that endangers the public health, welfare, or safety, or the contract is necessary for the provision of essential services, and no entity that complies with the requirements of this section capable of responding to the emergency is immediately available.
(3)If the agency specifically requests broadband Internet access service that would not be rendered consistent with the requirements of Title 15 (commencing with Section 3100) of Part 4 of Division 3 of the Civil Code, as provided in paragraph (2) of subdivision (a).
(c)For purposes of this section, broadband Internet access service and Internet service provider have the same meanings as defined in Section 3100 of the Civil Code, except that broadband Internet access service shall include enterprise service offerings, as defined in Section 3100 of the Civil Code.
SEC. 2.The provisions of this act are severable. If any provision of this act or its application is held invalid, that invalidity shall not affect other provisions or applications that can be given effect without the invalid provision or application.
SEC. 3.This act shall become operative only if Senate Bill 822 of the 201718 Regular Session is enacted and becomes effective.
For purposes of this chapter, broadband Internet access service and Internet service provider have the same meanings as defined in Section 3100 of the Civil Code.
12122.No state agency shall contract with an Internet service provider for the provision of broadband Internet access service unless that provider certifies in writing that both of the following conditions are met:
(a)The Internet service provider is in full compliance with Title 15 (commencing with Section 3100) of Part 4 of Division 3 of the Civil Code.
(b)The broadband Internet access service provided to the state agency by the Internet service provider is rendered consistent with the requirements of Title 15 (commencing with Section 3100) of Part 4 of Division 3 of the Civil Code.
SEC. 2.The provisions of this act are severable. If any provision of this act or its application is held invalid, that invalidity shall not affect other provisions or applications that can be given effect without the invalid provision or application.
SEC. 3.This act shall become operative only if Senate Bill 822 of the 201718 Regular Session is enacted and becomes effective.
SECTION 1.(a)The Legislature finds and declares that the Federal Communications Commission has repealed net neutrality rules intended to protect consumers and to ensure fair and reasonable access to the Internet.(b)It is the intent of this act to ensure that corporations do not impede competition or engage in deceptive consumer practices, and that they offer service to residential broadband Internet customers on a nondiscriminatory basis.(c)This act shall be known, and may be cited, as the California Internet Consumer Protection and Net Neutrality Act of 2018. SEC. 2.Chapter 3.5 (commencing with Section 1775) is added to Title 1.5 of Part 4 of Division 3 of the Civil Code, to read:3.5.Internet Neutrality1775.For purposes of this chapter, the following definitions apply:(a)Broadband Internet access service means a mass-market retail service by wire or radio in California that provides the capability to transmit data to and receive data from all or substantially all Internet endpoints, including any capabilities that are incidental to and enable the operation of the communications service, but excluding dial-up Internet access service. Broadband Internet access service also encompasses any service in California that provides a functional equivalent of that service or that is used to evade the protections set forth in this chapter.(b)Edge provider means any individual or entity in California that provides any content, application, or service over the Internet, and any individual or entity in California that provides a device used for accessing any content, application, or service over the Internet.(c)Internet service provider means a business that provides broadband Internet access service to an individual, corporation, government, or other customer in California.(d)Paid prioritization means the management of an Internet service providers network to directly or indirectly favor some traffic over other traffic, including through the use of techniques such as traffic shaping, prioritization, resource reservation, or other forms of preferential traffic management, either (1) in exchange for consideration, monetary or otherwise, from a third party, or (2) to benefit an affiliated entity.1776.It shall be unlawful for an Internet service provider that provides broadband Internet access service to engage in any of the following activities:(a)Blocking lawful content, applications, services, or nonharmful devices, subject to reasonable network management practices.(b)Impairing or degrading lawful Internet traffic on the basis of Internet content, application, or service, or use of a nonharmful device, subject to reasonable network management practices.(c)Engaging in paid prioritization, or providing preferential treatment of some Internet traffic to any Internet customer.(d)Unreasonably interfering with, or unreasonably disadvantaging, either a customers ability to select, access, and use broadband Internet access service or lawful Internet content, applications, services, or devices of the customers choice, or an edge providers ability to make lawful content, applications, services, or devices available to a customer.(e)Engaging in deceptive or misleading marketing practices that misrepresent the treatment of Internet traffic or content to its customers.(f)Advertising, offering for sale, or selling broadband Internet access service without prominently disclosing with specificity all aspects of the service advertised, offered for sale, or sold.1777.(a)A violation of this chapter shall be subject to the remedies and procedures established pursuant to Chapter 4 (commencing with Section 1780).(b)This chapter does not preclude enforcement of the rights specified herein under Chapter 5 (commencing with Section 17200) of Part 2 of, or Article 1 (commencing with Section 17500) of Chapter 1 of Part 3 of, Division 7 of the Business and Professions Code.SEC. 3.Chapter 3.51 (commencing with Section 12121) is added to Part 2 of Division 2 of the Public Contract Code, to read:3.51.Internet Neutrality12121.For purposes of this chapter, the following definitions apply:(a)Broadband Internet access service means a mass-market retail service by wire or radio in California that provides the capability to transmit data to and receive data from all or substantially all Internet endpoints, including any capabilities that are incidental to and enable the operation of the communications service, but excluding dial-up Internet access service. Broadband Internet access service also encompasses any service in California that provides a functional equivalent of that service or that is used to evade the protections set forth in this chapter.(b)Edge provider means any individual or entity in California that provides any content, application, or service over the Internet, and any individual or entity in California that provides a device used for accessing any content, application, or service over the Internet.(c)Internet service provider means a business that provides broadband Internet access service to an individual, corporation, government, or other customer in California.(d)Paid prioritization means the management of an Internet service providers network to directly or indirectly favor some traffic over other traffic, including through the use of techniques such as traffic shaping, prioritization, resource reservation, or other forms of preferential traffic management, either (1) in exchange for consideration, monetary or otherwise, from a third party, or (2) to benefit an affiliated entity.12122.No state agency may contract with an Internet service provider for the provision of broadband internet access service unless that provider certifies, under penalty of perjury, that it will not engage in any of the following activities:(a)Blocking lawful content, applications, services, or nonharmful devices for any customer, subject to reasonable network management practices.(b)Impairing or degrading lawful Internet traffic on the basis of Internet content, application, or service for, or use of a nonharmful device by, any customer, subject to reasonable network management practices.(c)Engaging in paid prioritization, or providing preferential treatment of some Internet traffic to any Internet customer.(d)Unreasonably interfering with, or unreasonably disadvantaging, either a customers ability to select, access, and use broadband Internet access service or lawful Internet content, applications, services, or devices of the customers choice, or an edge providers ability to make lawful content, applications, services, or devices available to a customer.(e)Engaging in deceptive or misleading marketing practices that misrepresent the treatment of Internet traffic or content to its customers.(f)Advertising, offering for sale, or selling broadband Internet access service to any customer without prominently disclosing with specificity all aspects of the service advertised, offered for sale, or sold.SEC. 4.The provisions of this act are severable. If any provision of this act or its application is held invalid, that invalidity shall not affect other provisions or applications that can be given effect without the invalid provision or application.SEC. 5.No reimbursement is required by this act pursuant to Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution because the only costs that may be incurred by a local agency or school district will be incurred because this act creates a new crime or infraction, eliminates a crime or infraction, or changes the penalty for a crime or infraction, within the meaning of Section 17556 of the Government Code, or changes the definition of a crime within the meaning of Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution.(a)The Legislature finds and declares that the Federal Communications Commission has repealed net neutrality rules intended to protect consumers and to ensure fair and reasonable access to the Internet.
(b)It is the intent of this act to ensure that corporations do not impede competition or engage in deceptive consumer practices, and that they offer service to residential broadband Internet customers on a nondiscriminatory basis.
(c)This act shall be known, and may be cited, as the California Internet Consumer Protection and Net Neutrality Act of 2018.
SEC. 2.Chapter 3.5 (commencing with Section 1775) is added to Title 1.5 of Part 4 of Division 3 of the Civil Code, to read:3.5.Internet Neutrality1775.For purposes of this chapter, the following definitions apply:
(a)Broadband Internet access service means a mass-market retail service by wire or radio in California that provides the capability to transmit data to and receive data from all or substantially all Internet endpoints, including any capabilities that are incidental to and enable the operation of the communications service, but excluding dial-up Internet access service. Broadband Internet access service also encompasses any service in California that provides a functional equivalent of that service or that is used to evade the protections set forth in this chapter.
(b)Edge provider means any individual or entity in California that provides any content, application, or service over the Internet, and any individual or entity in California that provides a device used for accessing any content, application, or service over the Internet.
(c)Internet service provider means a business that provides broadband Internet access service to an individual, corporation, government, or other customer in California.
(d)Paid prioritization means the management of an Internet service providers network to directly or indirectly favor some traffic over other traffic, including through the use of techniques such as traffic shaping, prioritization, resource reservation, or other forms of preferential traffic management, either (1) in exchange for consideration, monetary or otherwise, from a third party, or (2) to benefit an affiliated entity.
1776.It shall be unlawful for an Internet service provider that provides broadband Internet access service to engage in any of the following activities:
(a)Blocking lawful content, applications, services, or nonharmful devices, subject to reasonable network management practices.
(b)Impairing or degrading lawful Internet traffic on the basis of Internet content, application, or service, or use of a nonharmful device, subject to reasonable network management practices.
(c)Engaging in paid prioritization, or providing preferential treatment of some Internet traffic to any Internet customer.
(d)Unreasonably interfering with, or unreasonably disadvantaging, either a customers ability to select, access, and use broadband Internet access service or lawful Internet content, applications, services, or devices of the customers choice, or an edge providers ability to make lawful content, applications, services, or devices available to a customer.
(e)Engaging in deceptive or misleading marketing practices that misrepresent the treatment of Internet traffic or content to its customers.
(f)Advertising, offering for sale, or selling broadband Internet access service without prominently disclosing with specificity all aspects of the service advertised, offered for sale, or sold.
1777.(a)A violation of this chapter shall be subject to the remedies and procedures established pursuant to Chapter 4 (commencing with Section 1780).
(b)This chapter does not preclude enforcement of the rights specified herein under Chapter 5 (commencing with Section 17200) of Part 2 of, or Article 1 (commencing with Section 17500) of Chapter 1 of Part 3 of, Division 7 of the Business and Professions Code.
SEC. 3.Chapter 3.51 (commencing with Section 12121) is added to Part 2 of Division 2 of the Public Contract Code, to read:3.51.Internet Neutrality12121.For purposes of this chapter, the following definitions apply:
(a)Broadband Internet access service means a mass-market retail service by wire or radio in California that provides the capability to transmit data to and receive data from all or substantially all Internet endpoints, including any capabilities that are incidental to and enable the operation of the communications service, but excluding dial-up Internet access service. Broadband Internet access service also encompasses any service in California that provides a functional equivalent of that service or that is used to evade the protections set forth in this chapter.
(b)Edge provider means any individual or entity in California that provides any content, application, or service over the Internet, and any individual or entity in California that provides a device used for accessing any content, application, or service over the Internet.
(c)Internet service provider means a business that provides broadband Internet access service to an individual, corporation, government, or other customer in California.
(d)Paid prioritization means the management of an Internet service providers network to directly or indirectly favor some traffic over other traffic, including through the use of techniques such as traffic shaping, prioritization, resource reservation, or other forms of preferential traffic management, either (1) in exchange for consideration, monetary or otherwise, from a third party, or (2) to benefit an affiliated entity.
12122.No state agency may contract with an Internet service provider for the provision of broadband internet access service unless that provider certifies, under penalty of perjury, that it will not engage in any of the following activities:
(a)Blocking lawful content, applications, services, or nonharmful devices for any customer, subject to reasonable network management practices.
(b)Impairing or degrading lawful Internet traffic on the basis of Internet content, application, or service for, or use of a nonharmful device by, any customer, subject to reasonable network management practices.
(c)Engaging in paid prioritization, or providing preferential treatment of some Internet traffic to any Internet customer.
(d)Unreasonably interfering with, or unreasonably disadvantaging, either a customers ability to select, access, and use broadband Internet access service or lawful Internet content, applications, services, or devices of the customers choice, or an edge providers ability to make lawful content, applications, services, or devices available to a customer.
(e)Engaging in deceptive or misleading marketing practices that misrepresent the treatment of Internet traffic or content to its customers.
(f)Advertising, offering for sale, or selling broadband Internet access service to any customer without prominently disclosing with specificity all aspects of the service advertised, offered for sale, or sold.
SEC. 4.The provisions of this act are severable. If any provision of this act or its application is held invalid, that invalidity shall not affect other provisions or applications that can be given effect without the invalid provision or application.
SEC. 5.No reimbursement is required by this act pursuant to Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution because the only costs that may be incurred by a local agency or school district will be incurred because this act creates a new crime or infraction, eliminates a crime or infraction, or changes the penalty for a crime or infraction, within the meaning of Section 17556 of the Government Code, or changes the definition of a crime within the meaning of Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution.
SECTION 1.Division 2.6 (commencing with Section 5980) is added to the Public Utilities Code, to read:2.6.California Internet Consumer Protection and Net Neutrality5980.(a)The Legislature finds and declares that the Federal Communications Commission has repealed net neutrality rules intended to protect consumers and to ensure fair and reasonable access to the Internet.(b)It is the intent of this division to ensure that corporations do not impede competition or engage in deceptive consumer practices, and that they offer service to residential broadband Internet customers on a nondiscriminatory basis.(c)This act shall be known, and may be cited, as the California Internet Consumer Protection and Net Neutrality Act of 2018.(d)It is the intent of the Legislature to ensure that all of the following principles, as established in Section 709, are met:(1)The development and deployment of new technologies and the equitable provision of services in a way that efficiently meets consumer need and encourages the ubiquitous availability of a wide choice of state-of-the-art services.(2)The promotion of lower prices, broader consumer choice, and avoidance of anticompetitive conduct.(3)The removal of the barriers to open and competitive markets and the promotion of fair product and price competition in a way that encourages greater efficiency, lower prices, and more consumer choice.5981.For purposes of this division, the following definitions apply:(a)Broadband Internet access service means a mass-market retail service by wire or radio in California that provides the capability to transmit data to, and receive data from, all or substantially all Internet endpoints, including any capabilities that are incidental to, and enable the operation of, the communications service, but excluding dial-up Internet access service. Broadband Internet access service also encompasses any service in California that provides a functional equivalent of that service or that is used to evade the protections set forth in this division, as determined by the commission.(b)Edge provider means any individual or entity in California that provides any content, application, or service over the Internet, and any individual or entity in California that provides a device used for accessing any content, application, or service over the Internet.(c)End user means an individual or entity that uses a broadband Internet access service.(d)Internet service provider means a business that provides broadband Internet access service to an individual, corporation, government, or other end user in California.(e)Paid prioritization means the management of an Internet service providers network to directly or indirectly favor some traffic over other traffic, including through the use of techniques such as traffic shaping, prioritization, resource reservation, or other forms of preferential traffic management, either (1) in exchange for consideration, monetary or otherwise, from a third party, or (2) to benefit an affiliated entity.(f)Reasonable network management means a network management practice that has a primarily technical network management justification, but does not include other business practices. A network management practice is reasonable if it is primarily used for, and tailored to, achieving a legitimate network management purpose, taking into account the particular network architecture and technology of the broadband Internet access service.5982.An Internet service provider shall not engage in any of the following activities:(a)Blocking lawful content, applications, services, or nonharmful devices, subject to reasonable network management, as determined by the commission.(b)Impairing or degrading lawful Internet traffic on the basis of Internet content, application, or service, or use of a nonharmful device, subject to reasonable network management, as determined by the commission.(c)(1)Engaging in paid prioritization, or providing preferential treatment of some Internet traffic to any end user.(2)The commission may waive the ban on paid prioritization only if the petitioner demonstrates that the practice would provide some significant public interest benefit and would not harm the open nature of the Internet.(d)Except for reasonable network management, unreasonably interfering with, or unreasonably disadvantaging, either an end users ability to select, access, and use broadband Internet access service or lawful Internet content, applications, services, or devices of the end users choice, or an edge providers ability to make lawful content, applications, services, or devices available to an end user.(e)Engaging in deceptive or misleading marketing practices that misrepresent the treatment of Internet traffic or content to an end user.5982.5.In addition to the authority granted herein, any violation of this division may be enforced by the Attorney General, a district attorney, or a city attorney pursuant to Chapter 5 (commencing with Section 17200) of Part 2 of, and Chapter 1 (commencing with Section 17500) of Part 3 of, Division 7 of the Business and Professions Code.5983.On or before December 31, 2018, the commission shall adopt an order that does all of the following:(a)Establishes rules implementing Section 5982, by which the commission shall enforce this division. Nothing in this subdivision shall affect the authority of the Attorney General, a district attorney, or a city attorney to enforce this division pursuant to the authority described in Section 5982.5.(b)Identifies and specifies this state governments role as an Internet customer, uses that customer power to ensure implementation of this division, and establishes sample master contracts for public entities to be used as an incentive for California companies to comply with net neutrality principles.(c)Establishes statewide consumer protection rules and guidelines that can be easily accessed by the public and that include ground truth testing for broadband Internet speeds to create a single objective statewide Internet speed test, which permits end users to test their own broadband Internet speed and submit its results to the commission to determine what Internet speeds they are receiving and where Internet service providers may be blocking, impairing, or degrading Internet traffic or content.(d)Ensures that public purpose program funding, such as funding under the lifeline service program, California Advanced Services Fund program, California Teleconnect Fund program, or other similar publicly funded programs, is expended in a manner that will maximize Internet neutrality and ensure the fair distribution of services to low-income individuals and communities.(e)Amends or modifies commission rules pertaining to eligible telecommunications carrier status, which is necessary to participate as a provider in the lifeline service program and to receive other federal funding, to ensure compliance with consumer protection and Internet neutrality standards provided under this division.(f)Establishes a process whereby an Internet service provider shall certify to the commission that it is providing broadband Internet access service in accordance with the requirements set forth in this division.5989.The provisions of this division are severable. If any provision of this division or its application is held invalid, that invalidity shall not affect other provisions or applications that can be given effect without the invalid provision or application.SEC. 2.No reimbursement is required by this act pursuant to Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution because the only costs that may be incurred by a local agency or school district will be incurred because this act creates a new crime or infraction, eliminates a crime or infraction, or changes the penalty for a crime or infraction, within the meaning of Section 17556 of the Government Code, or changes the definition of a crime within the meaning of Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution.SEC. 3.This act is an urgency statute necessary for the immediate preservation of the public peace, health, or safety within the meaning of Article IV of the California Constitution and shall go into immediate effect. The facts constituting the necessity are:The Federal Communications Commission has vacated an earlier order establishing consumer protections and Internet neutrality. It is necessary for this bill to take effect immediately to ensure those protections are continued.(a)The Legislature finds and declares that the Federal Communications Commission has repealed net neutrality rules intended to protect consumers and to ensure fair and reasonable access to the Internet.
(b)It is the intent of this division to ensure that corporations do not impede competition or engage in deceptive consumer practices, and that they offer service to residential broadband Internet customers on a nondiscriminatory basis.
(c)This act shall be known, and may be cited, as the California Internet Consumer Protection and Net Neutrality Act of 2018.
(d)It is the intent of the Legislature to ensure that all of the following principles, as established in Section 709, are met:
(1)The development and deployment of new technologies and the equitable provision of services in a way that efficiently meets consumer need and encourages the ubiquitous availability of a wide choice of state-of-the-art services.
(2)The promotion of lower prices, broader consumer choice, and avoidance of anticompetitive conduct.
(3)The removal of the barriers to open and competitive markets and the promotion of fair product and price competition in a way that encourages greater efficiency, lower prices, and more consumer choice.
5981.For purposes of this division, the following definitions apply:
(a)Broadband Internet access service means a mass-market retail service by wire or radio in California that provides the capability to transmit data to to, and receive data from from, all or substantially all Internet endpoints, including any capabilities that are incidental to to, and enable the operation of of, the communications service, but excluding dial-up Internet access service. Broadband Internet access service also encompasses any service in California that provides a functional equivalent of that service or that is used to evade the protections set forth in this division, as determined by the commission.
(b)Edge provider means any individual or entity in California that provides any content, application, or service over the Internet, and any individual or entity in California that provides a device used for accessing any content, application, or service over the Internet.
(c)End user means an individual or entity that uses a broadband Internet access service.
(c)(d)Internet service provider means a business that provides broadband Internet access service to an individual, corporation, government, or other customer end user in California.
(d)(e)Paid prioritization means the management of an Internet service providers network to directly or indirectly favor some traffic over other traffic, including through the use of techniques such as traffic shaping, prioritization, resource reservation, or other forms of preferential traffic management, either (1) in exchange for consideration, monetary or otherwise, from a third party, or (2) to benefit an affiliated entity.
(f)Reasonable network management means a network management practice that has a primarily technical network management justification, but does not include other business practices. A network management practice is reasonable if it is primarily used for, and tailored to, achieving a legitimate network management purpose, taking into account the particular network architecture and technology of the broadband Internet access service.
5982.An Internet service provider shall not engage in any of the following activities:
(a)Blocking lawful content, applications, services, or nonharmful devices, subject to reasonable network management practices management, as determined by the commission.
(b)Impairing or degrading lawful Internet traffic on the basis of Internet content, application, or service, or use of a nonharmful device, subject to reasonable network management practices management, as determined by the commission.
(c)(1)Engaging in paid prioritization, or providing preferential treatment of some Internet traffic to any Internet customer. end user.
(2)The commission may waive the ban on paid prioritization only if the petitioner demonstrates that the practice would provide some significant public interest benefit and would not harm the open nature of the Internet.
(d)Unreasonably Except for reasonable network management, unreasonably interfering with, or unreasonably disadvantaging, either a customers an end users ability to select, access, and use broadband Internet access service or lawful Internet content, applications, services, or devices of the customers end users choice, or an edge providers ability to make lawful content, applications, services, or devices available to a customer. an end user.
(e)Engaging in deceptive or misleading marketing practices that misrepresent the treatment of Internet traffic or content to its customers. an end user.
5982.5.In addition to the authority granted herein, any violation of this division may be enforced by the Attorney General, a district attorney, or a city attorney pursuant to Chapter 5 (commencing with Section 17200) of Part 2 of, and Chapter 1 (commencing with Section 17500) of Part 3 of, Division 7 of the Business and Professions Code.
5983.On or before July 1, December 31, 2018, the commission shall adopt an order that does all of the following:
(a)Establishes rules implementing Section 5982, and by which the commission shall enforce this division. Nothing in this subdivision shall affect the authority of the Attorney General, a district attorney, or a city attorney to enforce this division pursuant to the authority described in Section 5982.5.
(b)Identifies and specifies this state governments role as an Internet customer, uses that customer power to ensure implementation of this division, and establishes sample master contracts for public entities to be used as an incentive for California companies to comply with net neutrality principles.
(c)Establishes statewide consumer protection rules and guidelines that can be easily accessed by the public and that include ground truth testing for broadband Internet speeds to create a single objective statewide Internet speed test, which permits customers end users to test their own broadband Internet speed and submit its results to the commission to determine what Internet speeds consumers they are receiving and where Internet service providers may be blocking, impairing, or degrading Internet traffic or content.
(d)Ensures that public purpose program funding, such as funding under the lifeline service program, California Advanced Services Fund program, California Teleconnect Fund program, or other similar publicly funded programs, is expended in a manner that will maximize Internet neutrality and ensure the fair distribution of services to low-income individuals and communities.
(e)Amends or modifies commission rules pertaining to eligible telecommunications carrier status, which is necessary to participate as a provider in the lifeline service program and to receive other federal funding, to ensure compliance with consumer protection and Internet neutrality standards provided under this division.
(f)Establishes a process whereby an Internet service provider shall certify to the commission that it is providing broadband Internet access service in accordance with the requirements set forth in this division.
5989.The provisions of this division are severable. If any provision of this division or its application is held invalid, that invalidity shall not affect other provisions or applications that can be given effect without the invalid provision or application.
SEC. 2.No reimbursement is required by this act pursuant to Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution because the only costs that may be incurred by a local agency or school district will be incurred because this act creates a new crime or infraction, eliminates a crime or infraction, or changes the penalty for a crime or infraction, within the meaning of Section 17556 of the Government Code, or changes the definition of a crime within the meaning of Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution.
SEC. 3.This act is an urgency statute necessary for the immediate preservation of the public peace, health, or safety within the meaning of Article IV of the California Constitution and shall go into immediate effect. The facts constituting the necessity are:
The Federal Communications Commission has vacated an earlier order establishing consumer protections and network Internet neutrality. It is necessary for this bill to take effect immediately to ensure those protections are continued.
(a)The Legislature finds and declares that the Federal Communications Commission has repealed net neutrality rules intended to protect consumers and to ensure fair and reasonable access to the Internet.
(b)It is the intent of this division to ensure that corporations do not impede competition or engage in deceptive consumer practices, and that they offer service to residential broadband Internet customers on a nondiscriminatory basis.
(c)This act shall be known, and may be cited, as the California Internet Consumer Protection and Net Neutrality Act of 2018.
(d)It is the intent of the Legislature to ensure that all of the following principles, as established in Section 709, are met:
(1)The development and deployment of new technologies and the equitable provision of services in a way that efficiently meets consumer need and encourages the ubiquitous availability of a wide choice of state-of-the-art services.
(2)The promotion of lower prices, broader consumer choice, and avoidance of anticompetitive conduct.
(3)The removal of the barriers to open and competitive markets and the promotion of fair product and price competition in a way that encourages greater efficiency, lower prices, and more consumer choice.
5981.For purposes of this division, the following definitions apply:
(a)Broadband Internet access service means a mass-market retail service by wire or radio in California that provides the capability to transmit data to and receive data from all or substantially all Internet endpoints, including any capabilities that are incidental to and enable the operation of the communications service, but excluding dial-up Internet access service. Broadband Internet access service also encompasses any service in California that provides a functional equivalent of that service or that is used to evade the protections set forth in this division, as determined by the commission.
(b)Edge provider means any individual or entity in California that provides any content, application, or service over the Internet, and any individual or entity in California that provides a device used for accessing any content, application, or service over the Internet.
(c)Internet service provider means a business that provides broadband Internet access service to an individual, corporation, government, or other customer in California.
(d)Paid prioritization means the management of an Internet service providers network to directly or indirectly favor some traffic over other traffic, including through the use of techniques such as traffic shaping, prioritization, resource reservation, or other forms of preferential traffic management, either (1) in exchange for consideration, monetary or otherwise, from a third party, or (2) to benefit an affiliated entity.
5982.An Internet service provider shall not engage in any of the following activities:
(a)Blocking lawful content, applications, services, or nonharmful devices, subject to reasonable network management practices as determined by the commission.
(b)Impairing or degrading lawful Internet traffic on the basis of Internet content, application, or service, or use of a nonharmful device, subject to reasonable network management practices as determined by the commission.
(c)Engaging in paid prioritization, or providing preferential treatment of some Internet traffic to any Internet customer.
(d)Unreasonably interfering with, or unreasonably disadvantaging, either a customers ability to select, access, and use broadband Internet access service or lawful Internet content, applications, services, or devices of the customers choice, or an edge providers ability to make lawful content, applications, services, or devices available to a customer.
(e)Engaging in deceptive or misleading marketing practices that misrepresent the treatment of Internet traffic or content to its customers.
5982.5.In addition to the authority granted herein, any violation of this division may be enforced by the Attorney General, a district attorney, or a city attorney pursuant to Chapter 5 (commencing with Section 17200) of Part 2 of, and Chapter 1 (commencing with Section 17500) of Part 3 of, Division 7 of the Business and Professions Code.
5983.On or before July 1, 2018, the commission shall adopt an order that does all of the following:
(a)Establishes rules implementing Section 5982, and by which the commission shall enforce this division. Nothing in this subdivision shall affect the authority of the Attorney General, a district attorney, or a city attorney to enforce this division pursuant to the authority described in Section 5982.5.
(b)Identifies and specifies this state governments role as an Internet customer, uses that customer power to ensure implementation of this division, and establishes sample master contracts for public entities to be used as an incentive for California companies to comply with net neutrality principles.
(c)Establishes statewide consumer protection rules and guidelines that can be easily accessed by the public and that include ground truth testing for broadband Internet speeds to create a single objective statewide Internet speed test, which permits customers to test their own broadband Internet speed and submit its results to the commission to determine what Internet speeds consumers are receiving and where Internet service providers may be blocking, impairing, or degrading Internet traffic or content.
(d)Ensures that public purpose program funding, such as funding under the lifeline service program, California Advanced Services Fund program, California Teleconnect Fund program, or other similar publicly funded programs, is expended in a manner that will maximize Internet neutrality and ensure the fair distribution of services to low-income individuals and communities.
(e)Amends or modifies commission rules pertaining to eligible telecommunications carrier status, which is necessary to participate as a provider in the lifeline service program and to receive other federal funding, to ensure compliance with consumer protection and Internet neutrality standards provided under this division.
(f)Establishes a process whereby an Internet service provider shall certify to the commission that it is providing broadband Internet access service in accordance with the requirements set forth in this division.
5989.The provisions of this division are severable. If any provision of this division or its application is held invalid, that invalidity shall not affect other provisions or applications that can be given effect without the invalid provision or application.
SEC. 2.No reimbursement is required by this act pursuant to Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution because the only costs that may be incurred by a local agency or school district will be incurred because this act creates a new crime or infraction, eliminates a crime or infraction, or changes the penalty for a crime or infraction, within the meaning of Section 17556 of the Government Code, or changes the definition of a crime within the meaning of Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution.
SEC. 3.This act is an urgency statute necessary for the immediate preservation of the public peace, health, or safety within the meaning of Article IV of the California Constitution and shall go into immediate effect. The facts constituting the necessity are:
The Federal Communications Commission has vacated an earlier order establishing consumer protections and network neutrality. It is necessary for this bill to take effect immediately to ensure those protections are continued.
All matter omitted in this version of the bill appears in the bill as introduced in the Senate, February 16, 2017. (JR11)(a)The commission shall develop, implement, and administer the California Advanced Services Fund program to encourage deployment of high-quality advanced communications services to all Californians that will promote economic growth, job creation, and the substantial social benefits of advanced information and communications technologies, consistent with this section.
(b)(1)The goal of the program is, no later than December 31, 2015, 2020, to approve funding for infrastructure projects that will provide broadband access to no less than 98 percent of California households.
(2)In approving infrastructure projects, the commission shall give priority to projects that provide last-mile broadband access to households that are unserved by an existing facilities-based broadband provider. The commission shall provide each applicant, and any party challenging an application, the opportunity to demonstrate actual levels of broadband service in the project area, which the commission shall consider in reviewing the application.
(c)The commission shall establish the following accounts within the fund:
(1)The Broadband Infrastructure Grant Account.
(2)The Rural and Urban Regional Broadband Consortia Grant Account.
(3)The Broadband Infrastructure Revolving Loan Account.
(4)The Broadband Public Housing Account.
(d)(1)All moneys collected by the surcharge authorized by the commission pursuant to Decision 07-12-054 shall be transmitted to the commission pursuant to a schedule established by the commission. The commission shall transfer the moneys received to the Controller for deposit in the California Advanced Services Fund. Moneys collected on and after January 1, 2011, shall be deposited in the following amounts in the following accounts:
(A)One hundred ninety million dollars ($190,000,000) into the Broadband Infrastructure Grant Account.
(B)Fifteen million dollars ($15,000,000) into the Rural and Urban Regional Broadband Consortia Grant Account.
(C)Ten million dollars ($10,000,000) into the Broadband Infrastructure Revolving Loan Account.
(2)All interest earned on moneys in the fund shall be deposited in the fund.
(3)The commission shall not collect moneys, by imposing the surcharge described in paragraph (1) for deposit in the fund, in an amount that exceeds one hundred million dollars ($100,000,000) before January 1, 2011. On and after January 1, 2011, the commission may collect an additional sum not to exceed two hundred fifteen million dollars ($215,000,000), for a sum total of moneys collected by imposing the surcharge described in paragraph (1) not to exceed three hundred fifteen million dollars ($315,000,000). The commission may collect the additional sum beginning with the calendar year starting on January 1, 2011, and continuing through the 2020 calendar year, in an amount not to exceed twenty-five million dollars ($25,000,000) per year, unless the commission determines that collecting a higher amount in any year will not result in an increase in the total amount of all surcharges collected from telephone customers that year.
(e)(1)All moneys in the California Advanced Services Fund shall be available, upon appropriation by the Legislature, to the commission for the program administered by the commission pursuant to this section, including the costs incurred by the commission in developing, implementing, and administering the program and the fund.
(2)Notwithstanding any other law and for the sole purpose of providing matching funds pursuant to the federal American Recovery and Reinvestment Act of 2009 (Public Law 111-5), any entity eligible for funding pursuant to that act shall be eligible to apply to participate in the program administered by the commission pursuant to this section, if that entity otherwise satisfies the eligibility requirements under that program. Nothing in this section shall impede the ability of an incumbent local exchange carrier, as defined by subsection (h) of Section 251 of Title 47 of the United States Code, that is regulated under a rate of return regulatory structure, to recover, in rate base, California infrastructure investment not provided through federal or state grant funds for facilities that provide broadband service and California intrastate voice service.
(3)Notwithstanding subdivision (b) of Section 270, an entity that is not a telephone corporation shall be eligible to apply to participate in the program administered by the commission pursuant to this section to provide access to broadband service to an unserved or underserved household, as defined in commission Decision 12-02-015, if the entity otherwise meets the eligibility requirements and complies with program requirements established by the commission. These requirements shall include all of the following:
(A)That projects under this paragraph provide last-mile broadband access to households that are unserved by an existing facilities-based broadband provider and only receive funding to provide broadband access to households that are unserved or underserved, as defined in commission Decision 12-02-015.
(B)That funding for a project providing broadband access to an underserved household shall not be approved until after any existing facilities-based provider has an opportunity to demonstrate to the commission that it will, within a reasonable timeframe, upgrade existing service. An existing facilities-based provider may, but is not required to, apply for funding under this section to make that upgrade.
(C)That the commission shall provide each applicant, and any party challenging an application, the opportunity to demonstrate actual levels of broadband service in the project area, which the commission shall consider in reviewing the application.
(D)That a local governmental agency may be eligible for an infrastructure grant only if the infrastructure project is for an unserved household or business, the commission has conducted an open application process, and no other eligible entity applied.
(E)That the commission shall establish a service list of interested parties to be notified of California Advanced Services Fund applications.
(f)Moneys in the Rural and Urban Regional Broadband Consortia Grant Account shall be available for grants to eligible consortia to fund the cost of broadband deployment activities other than the capital cost of facilities, as specified by the commission. An eligible consortium may include, as specified by the commission, representatives of organizations, including, but not limited to, local and regional government, public safety, elementary and secondary education, health care, libraries, postsecondary education, community-based organizations, tourism, parks and recreation, agricultural, business, workforce organizations, and air pollution control or air quality management districts, and is not required to have as its lead fiscal agent an entity with a certificate of public convenience and necessity.
(g)Moneys in the Broadband Infrastructure Revolving Loan Account shall be available to finance capital costs of broadband facilities not funded by a grant from the Broadband Infrastructure Grant Account. The commission shall periodically set interest rates on the loans based on surveys of existing financial markets.
(h)(1)For purposes of this subdivision, the following terms have the following meanings:
(A)Publicly subsidized means either that the housing development receives financial assistance from the United States Department of Housing and Urban Development pursuant to an annual contribution contract or is financed with low-income housing tax credits, tax-exempt mortgage revenue bonds, general obligation bonds, or local, state, or federal loans or grants and the rents of the occupants, who are lower income households, do not exceed those prescribed by deed restrictions or regulatory agreements pursuant to the terms of the financing or financial assistance.
(B)Publicly supported community means a publicly subsidized multifamily housing development that is wholly owned by either of the following:
(i)A public housing agency that has been chartered by the state, or by any city or county in the state, and has been determined to be an eligible public housing agency by the United States Department of Housing and Urban Development.
(ii)An incorporated nonprofit organization as described in Section 501(c)(3) of the Internal Revenue Code (26 U.S.C. Sec. 501(c)(3)) that is exempt from taxation under Section 501(a) of that code (26 U.S.C. Sec. 501(a)), and that has received public funding to subsidize the construction or maintenance of housing occupied by residents whose annual income qualifies as low or very low income according to federal poverty guidelines.
(2)Notwithstanding subdivision (b) of Section 270, moneys in the Broadband Public Housing Account shall be available for the commission to award grants and loans pursuant to this subdivision to an eligible publicly supported community if that entity otherwise meets eligibility requirements and complies with program requirements established by the commission.
(3)(A)Not more than twenty million dollars ($20,000,000) shall be available for grants and loans to a publicly supported community to finance a project to connect a broadband network to that publicly supported community. A publicly supported community may be an eligible applicant only if the publicly supported community can verify to the commission that the publicly supported community has not denied a right of access to any broadband provider that is willing to connect a broadband network to the facility for which the grant or loan is sought and the publically supported community is unserved.
(B)(i)In its review of applications received pursuant to subparagraph (A), the commission shall award grants only to unserved housing developments.
(ii)For purposes of this subparagraph, a housing development is unserved when at least one housing unit within the housing development is not offered broadband Internet service.
(4)(A)Not more than five million dollars ($5,000,000) shall be available for grants and loans to a publicly supported community to support programs designed to increase adoption rates for broadband services for residents of that publicly supported community. A publicly supported community may be eligible for funding for a broadband adoption program only if the residential units in the facility to be served have access to broadband services or will have access to broadband services at the time the funding for adoption is implemented.
(B)A publicly supported community may contract with other nonprofit or public agencies to assist in implementation of a broadband adoption program.
(5)To the extent feasible, the commission shall approve projects for funding from the Broadband Public Housing Account in a manner that reflects the statewide distribution of publicly supported communities.
(6)In reviewing a project application under this subdivision, the commission shall consider the availability of other funding sources for that project, any financial contribution from the broadband service provider to the project, the availability of any other public or private broadband adoption or deployment program, including tax credits and other incentives, and whether the applicant has sought funding from, or participated in, any reasonably available program. The commission may require an applicant to provide match funding, and shall not deny funding for a project solely because the applicant is receiving funding from another source.
(7)(A)To provide funding for the purposes of this subdivision, the commission shall transfer to the Broadband Public Housing Account twenty million dollars ($20,000,000) from the Broadband Infrastructure Grant Account and five million dollars ($5,000,000) from the Broadband Infrastructure Revolving Loan Account. Any moneys in the Broadband Public Housing Account that have not been awarded pursuant to this subdivision by December 31, 2020, shall be transferred back to the Broadband Infrastructure Grant Account and Broadband Infrastructure Revolving Loan Account in proportion to the amount transferred from the respective accounts.
(B)The commission shall transfer funds pursuant to subparagraph (A) only if the commission is otherwise authorized to collect funds for purposes of this section in excess of the total amount authorized pursuant to paragraph (3) of subdivision (d).
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Aug 31, 2018 | From Assembly without further action. |
| Aug 31, 2018 | Read third time. Refused passage. |
| Aug 29, 2018 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| Aug 28, 2018 | Read second time and amended. Ordered to second reading. |
| Aug 27, 2018 | From committee: Do pass as amended. (Ayes 11. Noes 5.) (August 27). |
| Aug 24, 2018 | Joint Rule 62(a) suspended. |
| Aug 23, 2018 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 7. Noes 2.) (August 23). Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Aug 22, 2018 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on P. & C.P. (Ayes 9. Noes 3.) (August 22). Re-referred to Com. on P. & C.P. |
| Aug 20, 2018 | Assembly Rule 56 suspended. |
| Aug 16, 2018 | Joint Rule 61(b)(13,14,15,16) suspended. |
| Aug 7, 2018 | From committee with author's amendments. Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on C. & C. |
| Aug 6, 2018 | From committee with author's amendments. Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on C. & C. |
| Jun 11, 2018 | June 13 hearing postponed by committee. |
| May 31, 2018 | Referred to Coms. on C. & C. and P. & C.P. |
| Jan 30, 2018 | In Assembly. Read first time. Held at Desk. |
| Jan 29, 2018 | Read third time. Passed. (Ayes 21. Noes 12.) Ordered to the Assembly. |
| Jan 24, 2018 | From committee: That the measure be returned to the Senate Floor for consideration. (Ayes 5. Noes 2.) (January 24). |
| Jan 23, 2018 | Set for hearing January 24. |
| Jan 22, 2018 | From committee: Be re-referred to Com. on JUD. pursuant to Senate Rule 29.10(b). (Ayes 5. Noes 0.) Re-referred to Com. on JUD. |
| Jan 22, 2018 | Read third time and amended. |
| Jan 22, 2018 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| Jan 18, 2018 | From committee: Do pass. (Ayes 5. Noes 2.) (January 18). |
| Jan 17, 2018 | Set for hearing January 18. |
| Jan 16, 2018 | January 16 hearing: Placed on APPR. suspense file. |
| Jan 12, 2018 | Set for hearing January 16. |
| Jan 12, 2018 | From committee with author's amendments. Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Jan 11, 2018 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 7. Noes 2.) (January 11). Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Jan 5, 2018 | Set for hearing January 11. |
| Jan 3, 2018 | From committee with author's amendments. Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on E., U. & C. |
| Apr 6, 2017 | April 18 hearing postponed by committee. |
| Mar 23, 2017 | Set for hearing April 18. |
| Mar 9, 2017 | April 4 hearing postponed by committee. |
| Mar 9, 2017 | Set for hearing April 4. |
| Mar 2, 2017 | Referred to Com. on E., U. & C. |
| Feb 17, 2017 | From printer. May be acted upon on or after March 19. |
| Feb 16, 2017 | Introduced. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Aug 31, 2018 | SB 460 De León Senate Third Reading By BONTA | Assembly Floor |
Failed |
|
| Aug 27, 2018 | Do pass as amended. | Assembly Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Aug 23, 2018 | Do pass and be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Assembly Standing Committee on Privacy and Consumer Protection |
Passed |
|
| Aug 22, 2018 | Do pass and be re-referred to the Committee on [Privacy and Consumer Protection] | Assembly Standing Committee on Communications and Conveyance |
Passed |
|
| Jan 29, 2018 | Senate 3rd Reading SB460 De León | Senate Floor |
Passed |
|
| Jan 24, 2018 | That the measure be returned to Senate Floor for consideration. Ordered to third reading. | Senate Standing Committee on Judiciary |
Passed |
|
| Jan 18, 2018 | Do pass | Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Jan 16, 2018 | Placed on suspense file | Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Jan 11, 2018 | Do pass, but first be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Senate Standing Committee on Energy, Utilities and Communications |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
SENATE THIRD READING
STR Bill Id:SB 460
Author:(De León and Wiener)
As Amended Ver:August 28, 2018
Majority vote
SENATE VOTE: 21-12
Committee | Votes | Ayes | Noes |
Communications | 9-3 | Santiago, Bonta, Cervantes, Eduardo Garcia, Holden, Kamlager-Dove, Low, Quirk-Silva, Rodriguez | Obernolte, Mathis, Patterson |
Privacy | 7-2 | Chau, Berman, Calderon, Gabriel, Irwin, Mullin, Reyes | Kiley, Obernolte |
Appropriations | 11-5 | Gonzalez Fletcher, Bloom, Bonta, Calderon, Carrillo, Chau, Eggman, Friedman, Nazarian, Quirk, Reyes | Bigelow, Brough, Fong, Gallagher, Obernolte |
SUMMARY: Requires an Internet service provider (ISP) that bids to contract with a state agency for broadband Internet access service (BIAS) to certify it complies with specified net neutrality rules. Specifically, this bill:
- Requires an ISP that submits a bid or proposal to, or that otherwise proposes to enter into or renew a contract with, a state agency with respect to any contract in the amount of $100,000 or more for the provision of BIAS to certify in writing that both of the following conditions are met:
- The ISP is in full compliance with specified net neutrality rules; and,
- The BIAS provided to the state agency by the ISP is rendered consistent with specified net neutrality rules.
- Specifies that after taking all reasonable measures to find a contractor that complies with the specified requirements, as determined by the state agency, the specified requirements may be waived under any of the following circumstances:
- Whenever there is only one prospective contractor willing to enter into a specific contract with the state agency and that contractor is unable to provide either of the specified certifications;
- If the contract is necessary to respond to an emergency, as determined by the state agency, that endangers the public health, welfare, or safety, or the contract is necessary for the provision of essential services, and no entity that complies with the specified requirements capable of responding to the emergency is immediately available; or,
- If the agency specifically requests BIAS that would not be rendered consistent with specified net neutrality rules.
- Defines "broadband Internet access service" and "Internet service provider" for purposes of the bill, except that BIAS shall include enterprise service offerings, as specified.
- Provides that this bill shall become operative only if SB 822 (Wiener) of the current legislative session is enacted and becomes effective.
FISCAL EFFECT: According to the Assembly Appropriations Committee, this bill would have the following costs:
- Costs to the California Department of Technology (CDT) of an unknown, but presumably significant amount – in the hundreds of thousands of dollars annually – to ensure state agency contracting for BIAS, which CDT oversees, complies with the requirements of this bill.
- Cost to other state agencies of an unknown, but presumably minor amount—in the tens of thousands of dollars annually—to ensure their own compliance with the requirements of this bill.
COMMENTS:
- Authors Statement: According to the author, "In today's world, open access to the internet is critical to free expression, free speech, and democracy […] That's why the [Federal Communications Commission] (FCC's) partisan decision to repeal net neutrality rules is so dangerous. The FCC's action directly contradicts the will of the vast majority of Americans. It gives [ISPs] unfettered power to sabotage the competition by throttling the internet speeds for competing content. The FCC action lets companies pay for priority to gain an unfair advantage in the race for our time, attention, and business. That's also why this bill is so important."
- Background: Net neutrality is the principle that ISPs should not discriminate against legal content and applications, by charging edge providers different delivery speeds to deliver their content. Hence, ISPs should not block, throttle, or create special "fast lanes" for certain content. Net neutrality rules serve the purpose of maintaining open access to the internet and promoting greater competition by limiting the degree to which ISPs can interfere with a customer's ability to access legal content on the internet, and the degree in which better resourced companies can pay to have their content prioritized and distributed to consumers at optimal speeds.
- 2015 Open Internet Order and Repeal: In February 2015, the FCC adopted the Open Internet Order which established three "bright-line" rules, prohibiting ISPs from blocking, throttling, or engaging in paid prioritization. The Order also included an Internet Conduct Standard which prohibits practices that unreasonably interferes with, or unreasonably disadvantages, an end users ability to access, or an edge provider's ability to deliver, content over the internet.
Following the election of President Trump, in December 2017, the FCC adopted the Restoring Internet Freedom Order which repealed the 2015 Open Internet Order. The new FCC argued that net neutrality rules were unnecessary because ISPs have publicly stated their opposition to violating such principles, and if an ISP were to engage in such activities, consumer expectations, market incentives, and the deterrent threat of enforcement actions by antitrust and consumer protection agencies will constrain such practices ex ante.
- Public Policy & Procurement: California has many public policies in place that it supports by ensuring that public funds are not spent in a manner that contravenes those exact same public policies. The State has previously used its contracting power on numerous occasions to discourage vendors from violating various laws such as the Unruh Civil Rights Act and the California Fair Employment and Housing Act. By doing so, the State is able to leverage its purchasing power to ensure that public funds are not inappropriately invested in companies that violate public policies passed by the State of California, which sends inconsistent messages to the public and vendor community.
This bill requires an ISP that bids to contract with a state agency for BIAS to certify it complies with specified net neutrality rules. As such, should the Legislature elect to enforce net neutrality rules in California, it arguably should not spend millions of taxpayer dollars on information technology and telecommunications contracts with companies that violate those laws. In addition, given that not all states have similar net neutrality rules, this bill will also arguably help ensure that out-of-state vendors who wish to do business with the state adhere to the same rules that in-state vendors must adhere to.
Analysis Prepared by: Edmond Cheung / C. & C. / (916) 319-2637 FN: 0005098
Date of Hearing: August 27, 2018
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Lorena Gonzalez Fletcher, Chair
SBPCA Bill Id:SB 460
Author:(De León) – As Amended Ver:August 7, 2018
Policy Committee: | Communications and Conveyance | Vote: | 9 - 3 |
Privacy and Consumer Protection | 7 - 2 | ||
|
|
Urgency: No State Mandated Local Program: No Reimbursable: No
SUMMARY:
This bill requires an internet service provider (ISP) that bids to contract with a state agency for broadband internet access service (BIAS) to certify it complies with state law regarding “net neutrality.” The Assembly Committee on Privacy and Consumer Protection recently heard and passed this bill, with amendments to be made in this committee. This analysis reflects those amendments.
Specifically, this bill requires an ISP that bids to provide BIAS to a state agency via a contract in the amount of $100,000 or more to certify, in writing, that the ISP and the BIAS provided to the state agency by the ISP are both in compliance with state law regarding “net neutrality.” The bill authorizes a state agency to waive the certification requirements if the state agency determines it has taken all reasonable measures to find an ISP that complies with state law regarding “net neutrality,” provided any of the following circumstances exist: (a) there is only one prospective contractor willing to contract with the state agency and the prospective contractor is unable to provide either certification, (b) the contract is necessary to respond to an emergency, as determined by the state agency, or (c) the agency specifically requests BIAS that would be inconsistent with the state law regarding “net neutrality.”
State law regarding “net neutrality” with which this bill requires an ISP to certify compliance is created by SB 822 (Wiener), to which enactment of this bill is contingent.
FISCAL EFFECT:
- Costs to the California Department of Technology (CDT) of an unknown, but presumably significant amount—in the hundreds of thousands of dollars annually—to ensure state agency contracting for BIAS, which CDT oversees, complies with the requirements of this bill.
- Cost to other state agencies of an unknown, but presumably minor amount—in the tens of thousands of dollars annually—to ensure their own compliance with the requirements of this bill.
COMMENTS:
- Purpose. According to the author, this bill is to ensure ISPs that enter into state contracts adhere to net neutrality principles.
- Background. As a general concept, net neutrality refers to the principle that the internet should be accessible to all and that no content should be prioritized. In recent years, the Federal Communications Commission (FCC) had moved to ensure adherence to certain net neutrality principles. Specifically, in 2015, the FCC issued its “Open Internet Order,” which, very generally, prohibited three practices the FCC deemed contrary to net neutrality—blocking, throttling, and paid prioritization—and reclassified internet service as a common carrier service subject to the jurisdiction of the FCC.
In 2017, under new leadership appointed by President Trump, the FCC rescinded the Open Internet Order. The gist of the rescission is to reclassify internet service as an information service—not a common carrier service—and to allow blocking, throttling, and paid prioritization, so long as an ISP disclosed its engagement in those practices. The FCC also generally preempted state regulation of internet service.
Despite the FCC’s declaration of preemption, several states have passed laws enacting some version of “net neutrality.” This legislature is considering the same, in the form of SB 822 (Wiener), on which this bill functionally relies and to which its enactment is conditioned. As described by the policy analysis, SB 822:
Seeks to codify the prescribed rules and provide additional clarity by establishing additional bright-line rules that prohibit preferential treatment to some services but not others, including prohibiting ISPs from charging website fees for access to users and incorporating net-neutrality protections at the point of interconnection. The bill seeks to capture the intent of the Order by prescribing additional provisions based on the narratives that were debated and the FCC’s assertions and expectations.
This bill relies on SB 822, in that the bill requires an ISP contracting with a state agency to provide BIAS to certify that the ISP and the services it provides are both in compliance with the net neutrality principles of SB 822.
Some have objected to this bill as unnecessary, in that the provisions of SB 822 establish legal requirements with which an ISP must comply, regardless of its self-certification of compliance. However, as noted a policy analysis of this bill, existing statute requires entities doing business with the state to affirm their compliance with certain laws, such as the Unruh Civil Rights Act and the California Fair Employment and Housing Act. Therefore, this bill is not unique in requiring those seeking to do business with the state to attest to their compliance with state law.
Analysis Prepared by: Jay Dickenson / APPR. / (916) 319-2081
Date of Hearing: August 23, 2018
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON PRIVACY AND CONSUMER PROTECTION
Ed Chau, Chair
SBPCA Bill Id:SB 460
Author:(De León and Wiener) – As Amended Ver:August 7, 2018
SENATE VOTE: 21-12
SUBJECT: Communications: broadband Internet access service: state agencies
SUMMARY: This bill would prohibit a state agency from contracting with an internet service provider (ISP) for the provision of broadband internet access service (BIAS) unless that provider provides written certification that it is in full compliance with provisions that would be added to the Civil Code by SB 822 (Wiener), as specified. Specifically, this bill would:
- Add a new chapter to the Public Contract Code prohibiting any state agency from contracting with an ISP for the provision of BIAS unless that provider certifies in writing that both of the following conditions are met:
- The ISP is in full compliance with net neutrality-related laws in the Civil Code, as specified.
- The BIAS provided to the state agency by the ISP is rendered consistent with the requirements of net neutrality-related laws in the Civil Code, as specified.
- Define, for purposes of this new chapter, “BIAS” and “ISP” to have the same meanings as defined in the Civil Code, as specified.
- Provide that the provisions of this act are severable. If any provision of this act or its application is held invalid, that invalidity shall not affect other provisions or applications that can be given effect without the invalid provision or application.
- Provide that this bill shall become operative only if SB 822 of this session is enacted and becomes effective.
EXISTING LAW:
- Establishes in the state government, the Government Operations (GovOps) Agency, among other agencies. (Gov. Code Sec. 12800(a).)
- Establishes the California Department of Technology (CDT) within the GovOps Agency. (Gov. Code Sec. 11545(a)(1).) Also establishes the Department of General Services (DGS) within the GovOps Agency. (Gov. Code Sec. 14601.)
- Authorizes and generally governs the acquisition of goods and services from private contractors by state agencies under the supervision of DGS pursuant to Chapter 2 of the Public Contract Code. (Pub. Contract Code Sec. 10290 et seq.)
- Authorizes and generally governs the acquisition of information technology (IT) goods and services from private contractors by state agencies under the shared supervision of DGS and CDT, as specified pursuant to Chapter 3 of the Public Contract Code. (Pub. Contract Code Sec. 12100 et seq.) Generally, contracts for the acquisition of IT goods and services related to IT projects are to be made by or under the supervision of CDT, and other IT goods and services contracts, whether by lease or purchase, are to be made by or under the supervision of DGS. (Pub. Contract Code Sec. 12100.)
- Authorizes and generally governs the acquisition of telecommunications goods and services from private contractors by state agencies under the supervision of CDT pursuant to Chapter 3.5 of the Public Contract Code. Specifically, any contract for the acquisition of telecommunications services and any contract for the acquisition of telecommunications goods, whether by lease or purchase, shall be made by, or under the supervision of, CDT. (Pub. Contract Code Sec. 12120.)
- Provides that the Office of Technology Services (OTech), which is established within CDT, may acquire, install, equip, maintain, and operate new or existing business telecommunications systems and services. Acquisitions for IT goods and services shall be made pursuant to Chapter 3 of the Public Contract Code. To accomplish that purpose, OTech may enter into contracts, obtain licenses, acquire personal property, install necessary equipment and facilities, and do other acts that will provide adequate and efficient business telecommunications systems and services. Any system established shall be made available to all public agencies in the state on terms that may be agreed upon by the agency and the OTech. (Gov. Code Secs. 11543, 11541.)
- Requires, as a matter of California’s Public Contract Code, that bidders or persons entering into contracts with the state to sign various statements or certify various matters under penalty of perjury. For example, existing code requires:
- A person that submits a bid or proposal to, or otherwise proposes to enter into or renew a contract with, a state agency with respect to any contract in the amount of $100,000 or more to certify, under penalty of perjury, at the time the bid or proposal is submitted or the contract is renewed, all of the following:
- that they are in compliance with the Unruh Civil Rights Act (Unruh);
- that they are in compliance with the California Fair Employment and Housing Act (FEHA); and
- that any policy that they have against any sovereign nation or peoples recognized by the government of the United States, including, but not limited to, the nation and people of Israel, is not used to discriminate in violation of the Unruh or the FEHA, as specified. (Pub. Contract Code Sec. 2010.)
- Specified departments under the Public Contract Code to require from all prospective bidders the completion, under penalty of perjury, of a standard form of questionnaire inquiring whether such prospective bidder, any officer of such bidder, or any employee of such bidder who has a proprietary interest in such bidder, has ever been disqualified, removed, or otherwise prevented from bidding on, or completing a federal, state, or local government project because of a violation of law or a safety regulation, and if so to explain the circumstances. (Pub. Contract Code Sec. 10162.)
- Similarly provides, as a matter of Public Contract Code, that state agencies must require a company that submits a bid or proposal with respect to a contract for goods or services, that currently or within the previous three years has had business activities or other operations outside of the United States, to certify that the company is not a “scrutinized company” as otherwise defined under specified law. (Pub. Contract Code Sec. 10478(a).) Scrutinized companies are ineligible to, and shall not, bid on or submit a proposal for a contract with a state agency for goods or services related to products or services that are the reason the company must comply with specified federal Securities Exchange Act of 1934 provisions. (Pub. Contract Code Sec. 10490(a).) For purposes of this section, goods or services also includes IT goods and services and telecommunications goods and services, subject to Chapters 3 and 3.5 of the Public Contract Code, respectively. (Pub. Contract Code Sec. 10490(e).)
- Generally protects consumers under the state’s Unfair Competition Law, from unlawful, unfair and fraudulent business acts or practices, and from unfair, deceptive, untrue, or misleading advertising and any act prohibited under the state’s False Advertising Law, as specified. (Bus. & Prof. Code Sec. 17200 et seq.)
- Generally protects consumers and competitors, under the state’s False Advertising Law, against false or misleading advertising by any person, firm, corporation or association selling a product or service, as specified. (Bus. & Prof. Code Sec. 17500 et seq.)
FISCAL EFFECT: Unknown
COMMENTS:
- Purpose of this bill: This bill seeks to ensure that public moneys are not used to procure BIAS from ISPs that violate the net neutrality principles set forth in SB 822 (Wiener) by requiring ISPs to self-certify to state agencies they seek to contract with that they: (1) are in full compliance with the net neutrality laws sought to be enacted by SB 822; and (2) will provide BIAS to the state agency consistent with those same net neutrality laws. This is an author-sponsored bill.
- Author’s statement: According to the author, “In December 2017, the Trump Administration Federal Communications Commission (FCC) on a split, partisan vote, repealed strong consumer protection rules for internet neutrality enacted by the Obama Administration. These rules were intended to protect consumers from unscrupulous business practices and usurious charges for broadband internet service. This bill focuses on requiring ISPs that enter into state contracts adhere to net neutrality principles. This provision ensures that public entities only expend taxpayer funds on contracts with ISPs that comply with California’s comprehensive net neutrality protections. This bill also prohibits state agencies from contracting with such providers unless they commit to not engage in the prohibited practices.”
- General background on the internet: Of relevance to this discussion on SB 460 and the topic of net neutrality (discussed further below) is a basic understanding of the internet through what are known as backbone networks, ISPs, edge providers, and end users (the customers). Backbone networks, as described a federal court in Verizon v. FCC (D.C. Cir. 2014) 740 F.3d 623 are “interconnected, long-haul fiber-optic links and high-speed routers capable of transmitting vast amounts of data.” End users wishing to access the internet generally connect to backbone networks by way of the ISPs. In that sense, ISPs are said to provide the “on-ramp” to the internet. Stated another way, “users generally connect to these networks—and, ultimately, to one another—through local access providers like petitioner Verizon, who operate the ‘last-mile’ transmission lines.” (Verizon at 628-629.)
Examples of ISPs are AT&T, Verizon, and Comcast. Today, these ISPs provide that on-ramp through a faster, high speed connection known as “broadband internet access services” (BIAS) or “broadband” for short, compared to prior “dial up” connections used over telephone lines in prior years. In contrast, “edge providers” are companies such as YouTube, Facebook, and Google, which provide content, services, and applications over the internet that are consumed by the end users.
- Net neutrality: The term “net neutrality” refers to “internet openness”; the concept that the internet highways should be open and equally available to all, and that no internet “traffic” should be given preference or prioritized over other traffic. A widely cited example of a violation of net neutrality principles was Comcast’s throttling (i.e., secret slowing) of uploads from peer-to-peer file sharing applications. (Svensson, MSNBC, Comcast blocks some Internet traffic: Tests confirm data discrimination by number 2 U.S. service provider (Oct. 19, 2007).) Comcast did not stop blocking these protocols, like BitTorrent, until the FCC ordered them to stop, “marking the first time that any U.S. broadband provider has ever been found to violate Net neutrality rules.” (McCullagh, CNET, FCC formally rules Comcast's throttling of BitTorrent was illegal (Aug. 20, 2008).) The FCC’s decision was ultimately appealed by Comcast on the basis that the order fell outside the scope of the of commission’s authority under the Communications Act of 1934 (Comcast Corp. v. FCC (2010) 600 F.3d 642.) The U.S. Court of Appeal for the District of Columbia agreed, vacating the decision.
Over the last decade, the FCC has issued several orders relating to such net neutrality-related practices, including the 2015 Open Internet Order, which reclassified internet access as a common carrier telecommunications service (in other words, a public utility), and the partial repeal of that order on December 14, 2017, whereby the FCC, under new leadership, once again reclassified internet access as an information service and under the purview of the Federal Trade Commission (FTC), instead.
- Background on FCC’s 2010 conduct rules against blocking and unreasonable discrimination, the 2015 Open Internet Order, and the 2017 Restoring Internet Freedom Order: In 2009, the FCC began “a public process to determine whether and what actions might be necessary to preserve the characteristics that have allowed the Internet to grow into an indispensable platform supporting our nation’s economy and civic life, and to foster continued investment in the physical networks that enable the Internet.” As a result of that process, in 2010, the commission issued a set of regulations to move towards the establishment of the internet neutrality, or net neutrality, concept. A 2014 federal appeals court ruling, however, ultimately struck down those 2010 rules. (See Verizon.)
Immediately after the 2010 rules pertaining to net neutrality were struck down, the FCC issued a new order, noting that “[t]hreats to Internet openness remain today. The record reflects that broadband providers hold all the tools necessary to deceive consumers, degrade content, or disfavor the content that they don’t like. The 2010 rules helped to deter such conduct while they were in effect. But, as Verizon frankly told the court at oral argument, but for the 2010 rules, it would be exploring agreements to charge certain content providers for priority service.” (FCC, Report and Order on Remand, Declaratory Ruling, and Order, Protecting and Promoting the Open Internet (Mar. 12, 2015) GN Docket No. 14-28, FCC 15-24, pp. 4-5 <https://docs.fcc.gov/public/ attachments/FCC-15-24A1_Rcd.pdf> [as of Jun. 20, 2018], internal citations omitted) (hereinafter “2015 Open Internet Order”).).
As stated by the FCC in the 2015 Open Internet Order:
…the overwhelming consensus on the record, is that carefully-tailored rules to protect Internet openness will allow investment and innovation to continue to flourish. Consistent with that experience and the record built in this proceeding, today we adopt carefully-tailored rules that would prevent specific practices we know are harmful to Internet openness— blocking, throttling, and paid prioritization—as well as a strong standard of conduct designed to prevent the deployment of new practices that would harm Internet openness. We also enhance our transparency rule to ensure that consumers are fully informed as to whether the services they purchase are delivering what they expect. (Id. at p. 3.) To that end, the FCC issued rules, which included “practices which invariably harm the open Internet—Blocking, Throttling, and Paid Prioritization […].” (Id. at p. 7.)
No blocking is the principle that consumers who subscribe to a retail BIAS must get what they have paid for—access to all (lawful) destinations on the internet. No throttling guards against degradation targeted at specific uses of a customer’s broadband connection based on source, destination, or content. […] No paid prioritization prohibits “fast lanes” on the internet highways whereby a broadband provider accepts payment (monetary or otherwise) to manage its network in a way that benefits particular content, applications, services, or devices. (Id.)
On December 14, 2017, the FCC, under the new leadership of the Trump administration, repealed the Obama-era net neutrality protections in the 2015 Open Internet Order and preempted any conflicting state laws. This put ISPs and technology companies back on the same national regulatory playing field as they were before 2015: the FTC. Effectively, the repeal removed FCC restrictions on blocking, throttling, and prioritization, as long as such practices are publicly disclosed.
As a result, any power to take action has reverted back to the FTC. However, unlike the FCC, the FTC is not able to create hard-and-fast rules that ISPs must follow, though the FTC does have authority to prevent deceptive and unfair practices so that it can force companies to live up to the promises they place in their terms of service. In other words, if an ISP promises a “neutral” network and then fails to deliver, the FTC could presumably take action. Stated another way, the actions available to the FTC are more limited to when a broadband provider deceives the public.
- Net neutrality is a consumer protection issue: As stated by the Verizon court, “[p]roponents of net neutrality worry about the relationship between broadband providers and edge providers. They fear that broadband providers might prevent their end-user subscribers from accessing certain edge providers altogether, or might degrade the quality of their end-user subscribers' access to certain edge providers, either as a means of favoring their own competing content or services or to enable them to collect fees from certain edge providers. Thus, for example, a broadband provider like Comcast might limit its end-user subscribers’ ability to access the New York Times website if it wanted to spike traffic to its own news website, or it might degrade the quality of the connection to a search website like Bing if a competitor like Google paid for prioritized access.” (Verizon 740 F.3d at 629.) In that regard, the individuals who suffer from the loss of net neutrality are not limited to the edge providers; it affects the end user customers as well. Indeed, the consequences of creating fast lanes that users can access for a fee is that it will disproportionately impact some people over others, and impact their ability to find jobs, get health care, do well in school, go on to higher education, get better paying jobs, start businesses, and so forth. Rural areas will likely be hit harder than urban areas, but again, even in urban areas, accessibility issues will remain. Poor and working class people, and communities of color reportedly have a far more disproportionate lack of access to the internet than affluent communities.
Arguably, the repeal of net neutrality will aggravate such systematic divides/issues. On the heels of the FCC’s decision to repeal the net neutrality protections in 2017, it was warned that this deregulation could “force working class people to pay for internet access twice: once for basic access, and again for equitable access. That’s a direct challenge to social mobility. Not only would that complicate the process of applying for jobs or for college admission, it would also put an obstacle in the path of people trying to start their own businesses.” (Jones, The New Republic, Who Loses in the War Against Net Neutrality? (Dec. 15, 2017).)
Ultimately, offering different levels of services or different quality of service (such as through throttling or blocking lawful content) without clearly advertising that the services will come with such speed changes or content regulations and when promising neutral and open networks, is arguably a form of false and deceptive business practice in violation of California law.
This Legislature has had two primary net neutrality-related bills presented for consideration that seek to build protections for such principles into state law: SB 822 (Wiener) and this bill. This Committee previously heard and approved SB 822, which has been subsequently amended and set to be reheard in the Assembly Communications and Conveyance Committee on August 22, 2018. Because it was never previously heard in policy committee, SB 460 has been double-referred to both Assembly Communications and Conveyance Committee (where it is set to be heard on August 22, 2018), and this Committee.
Both bills include contingent enactment language, ensuring that they will only take effect if the other bill is also enacted into law. For SB 460, this contingent enactment language is critical, given its fundamental reliance on the SB 822 changes to existing law. SB 822 includes the proposed changes to the Civil Code which require companies to comply with various net neutrality concepts, based upon the 2015 Open Internet Order which has since been repealed on the federal level. This bill, SB 460, seeks to ensure that state agencies do not enter into contracts with private companies that are in violation of SB 822’s net neutrality principles through a self-certification process used in state procurement in other instances, such as where the state requires that vendors self-certify that they are in compliance with the state’s anti-discrimination laws, such as Unruh and FEHA. This, arguably, helps ensure that public funds are not inappropriately invested in companies that violate public policies passed by the State of California, which sends inconsistent messages to the public and vendor community. Moreover, within the vendor community itself, given that not all states have similar net neutrality laws, this bill will also arguably help ensure that out-of-state vendors who wish to do business with the state adhere to the same rules that in-state vendors must adhere to—thus evening the playing field among competitors.
- Bill ensures that BIAS provided to state agencies also adheres to the net neutrality principles of SB 822: This bill seeks to prohibit any state agency from contracting with an ISP for the provision of BIAS unless that provider certifies in writing that both of the following conditions are met:
- The ISP is in full compliance with net neutrality-related laws in the Civil Code, as specified.
- The BIAS provided to the state agency by the ISP is rendered consistent with the requirements of net neutrality-related laws in the Civil Code, as specified.
Read together with the severability clause in Section 2 of this bill, it appears that the distinction between the two enumerated conditions above has been drawn in part out of concern that a court might determine that state agencies cannot legally require ISPs to comply with the SB 822 net neutrality principles as a condition of procurement, but that they may require ISPs to comply with SB 822 in the provision of the services to the state agency itself. That being said, the State has been able to use its contracting power on numerous occasions to discourage vendors from violating various laws if they wish to be rewarded by a contract with the State. (See Comment 9 for more.)
Staff notes that while at first glance it may appear that the second condition appears to be redundant of the first (an ISP cannot be in full compliance with net neutrality laws in the Civil Code if it does not render BIAS consistent with the net neutrality-related laws in the Civil Code), it is not for two reasons. First, the provision states that the ISP must render BIAS to the state agency (as opposed to residential consumers) consistent with the Civil Code’s net neutrality requirements. Second, and related, under the Civil Code, BIAS does not include “enterprise service offerings.” Stated another way, without the second statement, an ISP technically does not have to provide BIAS to the state agency in a net neutral manner because of limitations in how SB 822 (enacting the relevant Civil Code provisions) is drafted.
Specifically, SB 822 defines the relevant terms for purposes of this bill. Key is the term “BIAS” which SB 822 defines to mean, in relevant part: a mass-market retail service by wire or radio provided to customers in California that provides the capability to transmit data to, and receive data from, all or substantially all internet endpoints, including, but not limited to, any capabilities that are incidental to and enable the operation of the communications service, but excluding dial-up internet access service. (Emphasis added). Mass market, in turn, under SB 822 excludes enterprise service offerings, which it defines as an offering to larger organizations through customized or individually negotiated arrangements or special access services. In other words, under SB 822, vendors’ enterprise service offerings, as usually made to state agencies, would not have to adhere to the net neutrality principles of SB 822, absent the language in SB 460 that suggests otherwise. Now, vendors will have to certify that any BIAS they provide to the state agency is also compliant with those same net neutrality laws.
That being said, SB 460 defines “BIAS” to have the same meaning as in SB 822—which excludes enterprise service offerings. To ensure the bill has the effect intended, the following clarifying amendment is suggested to clearly state that for purposes of SB 460, BIAS does not inherently exclude mass market services that include enterprise service offerings.
Suggested amendment:
On page 3, lines 4-6, after “For purposes of this chapter, “broadband Internet access service” and “Internet service provider” have the same meanings as defined in Section 3100 of the Civil Code” insert “, except that broadband Internet access services shall not necessarily exclude enterprise service offerings as defined in that section.”
- Suggested amendments to narrow the bill and ensure that the responsibility for certification rests on the bidder--not the state agency: Staff notes that this bill applies to contracts of all sizes and the smaller the contract, the more likely it will be conducted by smaller state agencies (which includes departments and offices) with smaller procurement departments with less experience than CDT and DGS in conducting acquisitions for goods and services (ranging from non-IT, to IT, to telecommunications). In many similar instances where certification has been required of vendors entering into contracts with the state, such as in the case of self-certification of compliance with anti-discrimination policies, the focus of the law has been on contracts of $100,000 or more. (See e.g. Pub. Contract Code Sec. 2010; see also Pub. Contract Code Sec. 10295.3 prohibiting state agencies entering into any contract for the acquisition of goods or services in the amount of $100,000 or more with a contractor who, in the provision of benefits, discriminates between employees with spouses and employees with domestic partners, or between employees with same sex as opposed to employees with different sex spouses or domestic partners.)
While under the current language of the bill a state agency can arguably rely on representations made by the contractor, more recent iterations of those laws have more clearly placed the responsibility to provide the certification of compliance with state laws on the contractor/vendor, and not on the state agency. This is critical when dealing with contracts with smaller state departments with less experienced procurement departments to navigate complex procurement laws. Recently, in 2016, when seeking to ensure that all state contractors comply with California’s primary anti-discrimination laws, Unruh and FEHA, and that they do not engage in certain boycott activities in a manner that would violate either of those laws, AB 2844 (Bloom, Ch. 581, Stats. 2016) affirmatively required “[a] person that submits a bid or proposal to, or otherwise proposes to enter into or renew a contract with, a state agency with respect to any contract in the amount of $100,000 or more [to] certify, under penalty of perjury, at the time the bid or proposal is submitted or the contract is renewed,” that they are in compliance with such laws – as opposed to prohibiting a state agency from contracting with persons that violate those laws.
Following the example set by AB 2844, the following amendment is suggested to restate the certification requirement of the bill to ensure that the responsibility clearly rests with the vendor and ensure that the bill applies to larger contracts, which also has the added benefit of increasing the likelihood that the contract will be conducted by or with the assistance of the state agencies with procurement expertise (CDT and/or DGS), to ensure that proper certification is provided and avoid the need to invalidate contracts after the fact. Specifically, it would require that an ISP that submits a bid or proposal, or that otherwise proposes to enter into or renew a contract, to a state agency with respect to any contract in the amount of $100,000 or more for the provision of BIAS, provide written certification that it is in compliance with the bill’s contracting conditions.
Suggested amendment:
On page 3, starting on line 7, strike “No state agency shall contract with an Internet service provider for the provision of broadband Internet access service unless that provider certifies in writing that both of the following conditions are met” and insert, “An Internet service provider that submits a bid or proposal to, or that otherwise proposes to enter into or renew a contract, a state agency with respect to any contract in the amount of $100,000 or more for the provision of broadband Internet access service shall certify in writing that both of the following conditions are met”
Notably, such a procurement provision, as proposed to be amended, would clearly avoid placing any onerous requirements on state agencies to make determinations about the compliance of vendors with the law. As a practical matter, it would merely require vendors to self-certify on a single document, which would be included as part of their bid, that they are in compliance, similar to how they have provided certification of their compliance with FEHA and Unruh since the enactment of AB 2844. Alternatively, such language could feasibly be added to standard State terms and conditions that must be agreed to by vendors as part of a bid and any resulting contract, as done, for example, with the Sweat Free Code of Conduct and Drug Free Workplace Certification provisions included in the State’s general terms and conditions as part of every IT contract. (See GSPD 401-IT, available at <https://www.documents.dgs.ca.gov/pd/poliproc/gspd401it14_0905.pdf> [as of Aug. 21, 2018].) Because this bill applies only to contracts between the State and ISPs for BIAS (as opposed to contracts between the State and all contractors, or the State and ISPs for any service, including but not limited to BIAS), such terms and conditions would have to be part of special terms and conditions and not the GSPD 401-IT, which the State uses for every contract as general terms and conditions.
Lastly, staff notes that unlike with the procurement language previously contained in SB 822, this bill does not require the certification to be made under penalty of perjury on the document itself. That being said, as a bidding document, it would be subject to severe repercussions should the certification prove false – at the very least, potentially including termination of the contract.
- Procurement provision and claims that bill goes beyond 2015 Open Internet Order: The concept that vendors must certify that they are compliance with proposed net neutrality standards before entering into contracts with state agencies has been previously approved by this Committee when it heard SB 822 on June 26, 2018. During the passage of SB 822 by this Committee, it was argued by various opponents that the procurement provisions go beyond the 2015 Open Internet Order. As noted in this Committee’s analysis at that time, “[w]hile it is true that the 2015 Open Internet Order did not contain a similar provision on government procurement, that does not mean that this bill cannot justifiably include those additional requirements.”
Relevant to both that prior version of SB 822 and to this bill, this State has many public policies in place that it simultaneously supports by ensuring that public funds are not spent in a manner that contravenes those exact same public policies. As discussed in Comments above, the State prohibits discrimination under both Unruh and FEHA. It also requires vendors who contract with the State to self-certify that they are in compliance with those laws and do not engage in other protected activities (such as the right to boycott) in a manner that would be discriminatory in violation of those laws. (See AB 2844 (Bloom, Ch. 581, Stats. 2016.) While these types of “good government” procurement laws often follow years after the underlying public policy is enacted, such a waiting period is not a requirement. Nor is it a requirement that the procurement provisions be part of the 2015 Open Internet Order in order to be an appropriate public policy for the State of California, should this Legislature choose to enact the net neutrality regulations of that Order in SB 822. Indeed, as a matter of public policy, should the Legislature elect to enforce net neutrality rules in California, it arguably should not spend millions of taxpayer dollars on IT and telecommunications contracts with companies that violate those laws.
The Utility Reform Network writes in support, “Customers should have the right to know whether their broadband access provider engages in practices that affect the treatment of content available to them. California is an economic powerhouse. By requiring public entities to contract with [ISPs] who comply with net neutrality rules, SB 460 would create an environment that rewards broadband providers for treating all content equally.”
That being said, because this provision effectively limits the ability of state agencies to contract with ISPs, it arguably does not require a new chapter, but rather belongs under the existing Chapter 3 of the Public Contract Code wherein CDT and DGS have authority to make or supervise IT contracts between state agencies and private companies. Chapter 3 is also appropriate as it applies when CDT’s OTech engages in acquisitions for business telecommunications systems and services, which it in turn makes available to other public agencies on the terms agreed to by OTech. Accordingly, the following amendment would recast Section 1 of the bill (which currently creates a new Chapter 3.51 on Internet Neutrality) to become Section 12119, at the end of Chapter 3, and immediately preceding Chapter 3.5, which expressly designates CDT as having authority over telecommunications-related acquisitions under Section 12120. (Note: the technical amendment below for this renumbering purpose also reflects the suggested clarifying amendments from Comments 7 and 8.)
Suggested amendment:
Strike Section 1 of the bill, adding a new Chapter 3.51 on Internet Neutrality and, instead, insert into Chapter 3 of the Public Contract Code as follows:
12119. (a) An Internet service provider that submits a bid or proposal to, or that otherwise proposes to enter into or renew a contract, a state agency with respect to any contract in the amount of $100,000 or more for the provision of broadband Internet access service shall certify in writing that both of the following conditions are met:
(1) The Internet service provider is in full compliance with Title 15 (commencing with Section 3100) of Part 4 of Division 3 of the Civil Code.
(2) The broadband Internet access service provided to the state agency by the Internet service provider is rendered consistent with the requirements of Title 15 (commencing with Section 3100) of Part 4 of Division 3 of the Civil Code.
(b) For purposes of this section, “broadband Internet access service” and “Internet service provider” have the same meanings as defined in Section 3100 of the Civil Code, except that broadband Internet access services shall not necessarily exclude enterprise service offerings as defined in that section.
- Arguments in Support: According to the ACLU of California, “Strong, enforceable net neutrality provisions ensure an open Internet for all Californians, free from interference by ISPs that would otherwise be empowered to hinder competition and limit choices. Net neutrality is the simple principle that ISP customers, not the ISP itself, should choose what apps, services, and websites they want to use. It enables competition by ensuring that small start-ups have a level playing field with incumbent services with deep pockets. It prevents ISPs from choosing winners and losers online based on their own interests. And it allows marginalized voices, who often have the fewest resources to ‘pay to play,’ to leverage the Internet to build communities and create societal change. […] SB 822 would restore those protections to Californians, while SB 460 would ensure that state agencies employ their contracting authority to the same ends.”
- Arguments in Opposition: According to a coalition of industry groups, “SB 460 requires ISPs that contract with state agencies to certify in writing they are in ‘full’ compliance with [specified] net neutrality requirements […] The uncertainty created by SB 460 will lead to procurement delays as claims of noncompliance will be easy to make and difficult to disprove – and cause the state to engage in protracted and expensive litigation. SB 460 […] will not promote or protect an open Internet. Instead, it opens the door to a patchwork of unworkable state regulations that will stymie innovation, and potentially undermine the backbone of California’s Internet economy.”
- Amendments to be taken in Appropriations Committee: Due to procedural timing issues, the amendments suggested in this analysis, should this bill be approved by this Committee, will need to be processed by the Assembly Appropriations Committee, as this bill has been keyed fiscal by the Legislative Counsel and is due to be heard in that committee next.
- Related legislation: SB 822 (Wiener) see Comments 6, 7, and 9.
- Double-referral: This bill was double-referred to the Assembly Committee on Communications on Conveyance where it is scheduled to be heard on August 22, 2018.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support (pursuant to Assembly Communications & Conveyance Committee analysis)
Access Humboldt
ACLU of California
ADT Security Services
California Association of Realtors
California Clean Money Campaign
California Common Cause
CallFire
CALPIRG
Center for Media Justice
Color of Change
Communications Workers of America, District 9
Consumer Federation of California
Consumer Union
Contextly
Electronic Frontier Foundation
Engine
Etsy
Eventbrite
Expa
Fight for the Future
Founder Academy
Foursquare
GitHub
Greenlining Institute
Gusto
Hellosign
Indivisible CA: StateStrong
Mapbox
Media Alliance
Medium
New America’s Open Technology Institute
NextGen California
Oakland Privacy
Patreon
Placer Independent Resource Services
Public Knowledge
Sonos
The Utility Reform Network
Twilio
Vimeo
Vivid Seats
Voices for Progress
Numerous Individuals
Opposition (pursuant to Assembly Communications & Conveyance Committee analysis)
100 Black Men of Long Beach
Affordable Living for the Aging
African American Male Education Network and Development Organization
Alhambra Chamber of Commerce
American Legion Post 290
Asian Pacific Islander American Public Affairs Association – Greater Sacramento
Asian Pacific Islander American Public Affairs Association – Solano County
Asian Resources Inc.
AT&T
Athletes and Entertainers for Change
Brotherhood Crusade
Burbank Chamber of Commerce
CalCom
California Asian Pacific Chamber of Commerce
California Cable & Telecommunications Association
California Chamber of Commerce
California Hispanic Chamber of Commerce
California League of United Latin American Citizens
California Manufacturers & Technology Association
California State Conference of the NAACP
CenturyLink
Chinese American Association of Solano County
Civil Justice Association of California
Community Women Vital Voices
CompTIA
Concerned Citizens Community Involvement
Congress of California Seniors
CONNECT
Consolidated Communications Inc.
CTIA
Frontier Communications
Gamma Zeta Boule Foundation
Greater Coachella Valley Chamber of Commerce
Greater Los Angeles African American Chamber of Commerce
Greater Riverside Chamber of Commerce
Inglewood / South Bay NAACP
Inland Empire Economic Partnership
Janet Goeske Foundation
Korean American Central Chamber of Commerce
Korean American Seniors Association of Orange County
La Canada Flintridge Chamber of Commerce and Community Association
Los Angeles African American Women’s Public Policy Institute
Los Angeles NAACP
Marjaree Mason Center
Monterey County Business Council
Monterey County Hospitality Association
Mother Lode Rehabilitation Enterprises Inc.
Music Changing Lives
NAACP – Venture County
Oceanside Chamber of Commerce
Orange County Business Council
Organization of Chinese Americans – Sacramento
Organization of Chinese Americans – San Mateo County
Organization of Chinese Americans – Silicon Valley
PulsePoint Foundation
Sacramento Asian Pacific Chamber of Commerce
Sacramento Black Chamber of Commerce
Sacramento Metro Chamber
San Diego Regional Chamber of Commerce
San Gabriel Valley Economic Partnership
San Marcos Chamber of Commerce
San Ysidro Chamber of Commerce
Solano Community College Educational Foundation
Sprint
T-Mobile
Tracefone
Tulare Kings Hispanic Chamber of Commerce
Valley Industry and Commerce Association
Verizon
Vietnamese American Chamber of Commerce
Analysis Prepared by: Ronak Daylami / P. & C.P. / (916) 319-2200
Date of Hearing: August 22, 2018
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON COMMUNICATIONS AND CONVEYANCE
Miguel Santiago, Chair
SBPCA Bill Id:SB 460
Author:(De León) – As Amended Ver:August 7, 2018
SENATE VOTE: 21-12
SUBJECT: Communications: broadband Internet access service: state agencies
SUMMARY: Prohibits a state agency from contracting with an Internet service provider (ISP) for the provision of broadband Internet access service unless the ISP certifies in writing that it is in full compliance with, and the service provided to the state agency is rendered consistent with, specified net neutrality rules.
EXISTING LAW:
- Specifies policies for telecommunications in California including; to promote lower prices, broader consumer choice, and avoidance of anticompetitive conduct; to remove the barriers to open and competitive markets and promote fair product and price competition in a way that encourages greater efficiency, lower prices, and more consumer choice; and to encourage fair treatment of consumers through provision of sufficient information for making informed choices, establishment of reasonable service quality standards, and establishment of processes for equitable resolution of billing and service problems. (Public Utilities Code (PUC) Section 709)
- Prohibits the California Public Utilities Commission (CPUC) from exercising regulatory jurisdiction or control over Voice over Internet Protocol and Internet Protocol enabled services except as required or expressly delegated by federal law or expressly directed to do so by statute, as specified. (PUC Section 710)
- Establishes the Digital Infrastructure and Video Compeition Act of 2006 which specifies that the CPUC is the sole franchising authority for a state franchise to provide video service, as specified. (PUC Section 5800 et seq.)
- Requires specified State departments to require from all prospective bidders the completion, under penalty of perjury, of a standard form of questionnaire inquiring whether such prospective bidder, any officer of such bidder, or any employee of such bidder who has a proprietary interest in such bidder, has ever been disqualified, removed, or otherwise prevented from bidding on, or completing a federal, state, or local government project because of a violation of law or a safety regulation, and if so to explain the circumstances. (Public Contract Code (PCC) Section 10162)
- Specifies that a specified bid may be rejected on the basis of a bidder, any officer of such bidder, or any employee of such bidder who has a proprietary interest in such bidder, having been disqualified, removed, or otherwise prevented from bidding on, or completing a federal, state, or local project because of a violation of law or a safety regulation. (PCC Section 10162)
- Prohibits the use of untrue or misleading advertisements by any person, firm, corporation or association selling a product or service, as specified. (Business and Professions Code Section 17500)
FISCAL EFFECT: Unknown. This bill is keyed fiscal by the Legislative Counsel.
COMMENTS:
- Authors Statement: According to the author, “In today’s world, open access to the internet is critical to free expression, free speech, and democracy. Americans of every income level and of political persuasion depend on the internet. That’s why the [Federal Communications commission] (FCC’s) partisan decision to repeal net neutrality rules is so dangerous. The FCC’s action directly contradicts the will of the vast majority of Americans. It gives [ISPs] unfettered power to sabotage the competition by throttling the internet speeds for competing content. The FCC action lets companies pay for priority to gain an unfair advantage in the race for our time, attention, and business. That’s also why this bill is so important.”
- Background: There are a number of federal and state agencies that play a role in the regulation and enforcement of communications-related services including the FCC, the Federal Trade Commission (FTC), and the CPUC. The FCC is an independent federal agency overseen by Congress to regulate interstate and international communications by radio, television, wire, satellite and cable in the United States. The FCC is tasked with promoting the development of competitive networks, as well as ensuring universal service, consumer protection, public safety, and national security.
In addition, the FTC is an independent federal agency tasked with promoting consumer protection and preventing anticompetitive business practices. The FTC enforces antitrust laws, and protects consumers by stopping unfair, deceptive or fraudulent practices in the marketplace. In California, the CPUC regulates the telecommunications industry by developing and implementing policies to ensure fair, affordable universal access to necessary services, developing rules and regulatory tools, removing barriers that prevent a competitive market, and reducing or eliminating burdensome regulations.
- Net Neutrality & the Internet: There are several major players in the operation of the Internet for data to be delivered from one point to another. Edge providers, such as Amazon, Google, and Facebook, develop and provide content, services, and applications over the Internet. End users are internet customers that consume content from edge providers. In order for products to be delivered from an edge provider to an end user, the product travels through backbone networks which are capable of transmitting vast amounts of data. End users and edge providers typically connect to these backbone networks through local ISPs, such as AT&T, Comcast, or Verizon. Such ISPs serve as the gatekeepers and provide the “on-ramp” to the internet.
Net neutrality is the principle that ISPs should not discriminate against legal content and applications, by charging edge providers different delivery speeds to deliver their content. Hence, ISPs cannot block, throttle, or create special “fast lanes” for certain content. Net neutrality rules serve the purpose of maintaining open access to the internet and limited the degree to which ISPs can interfere with a customer’s ability to access legal content on the internet. It can also serve to promote greater competition between content providers by limiting the degree in which better resourced companies can pay to have their content prioritized and distributed to consumers at optimal speeds. Maintaining competition in the internet marketplace provides greater choices and reduced cost to consumers and new services entering the marketplace.
- Bright-line Rules and the 2015 Open Internet Order: After a series of court cases in which the FCC attempted to enforce net neutrality rules were overturned, in May 2014 the FCC began a rulemaking to respond to the lack of conduct-based rules to protect and promote an open internet. In February 2015, the FCC adopted the Open Internet Order which established three “bright-line” rules banning certain practices that the FCC considers to harm open access to the Internet. The bright-line rules include:
- No Blocking: ISPs may not block access to legal content, applications, services, or non-harmful devices;
- No Throttling: ISPs may not impair or degrade lawful Internet traffic on the basis of content, applications, services, or non-harmful devices; and,
- No Paid Prioritization: ISPs may not favor some lawful Internet traffic over other lawful traffic in exchange for consideration of any kind.
In addition, recognizing that there may exist other current or future practices that cause the type of harms the bright-line rules are intended to address, the 2015 Open Internet Order also included a no unreasonable interference or unreasonable disadvantage Standard for Internet Conduct rule. The Internet Conduct Standard servers as a catch-all by prohibiting practices that unreasonably interferes with, or unreasonably disadvantages, an end users ability to access, or an edge providers ability to deliver, content over the internet. Furthermore, the Order also reaffirmed the importance of ensuring transparency and adopted enhanced transparency rules so that consumers would have accurate information sufficient for them to make informed choices of available services.
Within the FCC’s 2015 Open Internet rules included provisions to reclassify ISPs from an “information service” under Title I of the Telecommunications Act of 1996 (the Act), to a “telecommunications service” under Title II of the Act. This would allow the FCC to regulate ISPs similar to traditional public utilities, which may include rate of return regulation. However, when the FCC adopted the 2015 Open Internet rules it specified that certain provisions of Title II would not apply to broadband services. Proponents of net neutrality argue that the FCC needs to reclassify ISPs as common carriers (e.g. a private company that is required to sell their services to everyone under the same terms) under Title II of the Act, in order to prevent anticompetitive behaviors. While opponents argue that the FTC already has the authority to prevent anticompetitive business practices and that Title II is an archaic provision created to regulate telecommunications services long before the Internet existed.
- 2017 Restoring Internet Freedom Order & State Response: In December 2017, following the election of President Trump, the FCC adopted the Restoring Internet Freedom Order which repealed the 2015 Open Internet order. The new FCC argued that net neutrality rules were unnecessary because ISPs have publicly stated their opposition to violating such principles, and if an ISP were to engage in such activities, consumer expectations, market incentives, and the deterrent threat of enforcement actions by antitrust and consumer protection agencies, such as the FTC, will constrain such practices ex ante. To enact such changes the FCC reclassified ISPs under Title I of the Act and asserted significant preemption over state and local regulations, and laws. In June 2018, the repeal took effect.
In response to the 2017 Restoring Internet Freedom Order, Legislators in 29 states have introduced over 65 bills requiring ISPs to ensure various net neutrality principles. In 13 states and the District of Columbia, 23 resolutions have been introduced expressing opposition to the FCCs repeal of net neutrality rules and urging the U.S. Congress to reinstate and preserve net neutrality. In California, the Legislature passed AJR 7 (Mullin) Chapter 151, Statutes of 2017, which urged the President and Members of Congress to continue to protect net neutrality, open Internet access, the federal Lifeline program, and the E-rate program.
Currently, Governors in six states have signed executive orders and three states have enacted net neutrality legislation, including Oregon, Vermont, and Washington. Legislation introduced typically includes one or more of the following:
- Prohibiting blocking, throttling and paid prioritization of internet traffic, usually by invoking state consumer protection laws;
- Requiring ISPs to be transparent about their network management practices; or,
- Requiring state contractors for ISP service to abide by net neutrality rules.
This bill seeks to follow a similar approach by prohibiting state agencies from contracting with an ISP for services unless the provider certifies that it is in full compliance with, and the service provided to the state agency is rendered consistent with, specified net neutrality rules.
- Arguments in Support: According to the ACLU of California, “Strong, enforceable net neutrality provisions ensure an open Internet for all Californians, free from interference by ISPs that would otherwise be empowered to hinder competition and limit choices. Net neutrality is the simple principle that ISP customers, not the ISP itself, should choose what apps, services, and websites they want to use. It enables competition by ensuring that small start-ups have a level playing field with incumbent services with deep pockets. It prevents ISPs from choosing winners and losers online based on their own interests. And it allows marginalized voices, who often have the fewest resources to ‘pay to play,’ to leverage the Internet to build communities and create societal change.”
- Arguments in Opposition: According to a coalition of industry groups, “SB 460 requires ISPs that contract with state agencies to certify in writing they are in ‘full’ compliance with [specified] net neutrality requirements […] The uncertainty created by SB 460 will lead to procurement delays as claims of noncompliance will be easy to make and difficult to disprove – and cause the state to engage in protracted and expensive litigation. SB 460 […] will not promote or protect an open Internet. Instead, it opens the door to a patchwork of unworkable state regulations that will stymie innovation, and potentially undermine the backbone of California’s Internet economy.”
- Related Legislation: AB 1999 (Chau) of 2018 establishes net neutrality rules for local agencies that provide broadband services and expands the types of local agencies that may provide broadband infrastructure and/or services. Status: Pending on the Senate Floor.
SB 822 (Wiener) of 2018 establishes net neutrality rules by prohibiting ISPs from engaging in activities that interfere with a user’s ability to access content on the internet. Status: Pending in the Assembly Communications and Conveyance Committee.
- Previous Legislation: AJR 7 (Mullin) of 2017 urged the President of the United States and Members of the United States Congress to continue to protect net neutrality, open Internet access, the federal Lifeline program, and the E-rate program. Status: Chaptered by the Secretary of State, Resolution Chapter 151, Statutes of 2017.
- Double-referral: This bill is double referred, and if passed by this Committee, will be referred to the Assembly Committee on Privacy and Consumer Protection.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
Access Humboldt
ACLU of California
ADT Security Services
California Association of Realtors
California Clean Money Campaign
California Common Cause
CallFire
CALPIRG
Center for Media Justice
Color of Change
Communications Workers of America, District 9
Consumer Federation of California
Consumer Union
Contextly
Electronic Frontier Foundation
Engine
Etsy
Eventbrite
Expa
Fight for the Future
Founder Academy
Foursquare
GitHub
Greenlining Institute
Gusto
Hellosign
Indivisible CA: StateStrong
Mapbox
Media Alliance
Medium
New America’s Open Technology Institute
NextGen California
Oakland Privacy
Patreon
Placer Independent Resource Services
Public Knowledge
Sonos
The Utility Reform Network
Twilio
Vimeo
Vivid Seats
Voices for Progress
Numerous Individuals
Opposition
100 Black Men of Long Beach
Affordable Living for the Aging
African American Male Education Network and Development Organization
Alhambra Chamber of Commerce
American Legion Post 290
Asian Pacific Islander American Public Affairs Association – Greater Sacramento
Asian Pacific Islander American Public Affairs Association – Solano County
Asian Resources Inc.
AT&T
Athletes and Entertainers for Change
Brotherhood Crusade
Burbank Chamber of Commerce
CalCom
California Asian Pacific Chamber of Commerce
California Cable & Telecommunications Association
California Chamber of Commerce
California Hispanic Chamber of Commerce
California League of United Latin American Citizens
California Manufacturers & Technology Association
California State Conference of the NAACP
CenturyLink
Chinese American Association of Solano County
Civil Justice Association of California
Community Women Vital Voices
CompTIA
Concerned Citizens Community Involvement
Congress of California Seniors
CONNECT
Consolidated Communications Inc.
CTIA
Frontier Communications
Gamma Zeta Boule Foundation
Greater Coachella Valley Chamber of Commerce
Greater Los Angeles African American Chamber of Commerce
Greater Riverside Chamber of Commerce
Inglewood / South Bay NAACP
Inland Empire Economic Partnership
Janet Goeske Foundation
Korean American Central Chamber of Commerce
Korean American Seniors Association of Orange County
La Canada Flintridge Chamber of Commerce and Community Association
Los Angeles African American Women’s Public Policy Institute
Los Angeles NAACP
Marjaree Mason Center
Monterey County Business Council
Monterey County Hospitality Association
Mother Lode Rehabilitation Enterprises Inc.
Music Changing Lives
NAACP – Venture County
Oceanside Chamber of Commerce
Orange County Business Council
Organization of Chinese Americans – Sacramento
Organization of Chinese Americans – San Mateo County
Organization of Chinese Americans – Silicon Valley
PulsePoint Foundation
Sacramento Asian Pacific Chamber of Commerce
Sacramento Black Chamber of Commerce
Sacramento Metro Chamber
San Diego Regional Chamber of Commerce
San Gabriel Valley Economic Partnership
San Marcos Chamber of Commerce
San Ysidro Chamber of Commerce
Solano Community College Educational Foundation
Sprint
T-Mobile
Tracefone
Tulare Kings Hispanic Chamber of Commerce
Valley Industry and Commerce Association
Verizon
Vietnamese American Chamber of Commerce
Analysis Prepared by: Edmond Cheung / C. & C. / (916) 319-2637
Date of Hearing: June 20, 2018
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON COMMUNICATIONS AND CONVEYANCE
Miguel Santiago, Chair
SBPCA Bill Id:SB 460
Author:(De León) – As Amended Ver:January 22, 2018
SENATE VOTE: 21-12
SUBJECT: Communications: broadband Internet access service
SUMMARY: Establishes net neutrality rules by prohibiting Internet Service providers (ISPs) from engaging in activities that interfere with a user’s ability to access content on the internet. Specifically, this bill:
Specifies that it shall be unlawful for an ISP that provides broadband Internet access service (BIAS) to engage in any of the following activities:
- Blocking lawful content, applications, services, or nonharmful devices, subject to reasonable network management practices;
- Impairing or degrading lawful Internet traffic on the basis of Internet content, application, or service, or use of a nonharmful device, subject to reasonable network management practices;
- Engaging in paid prioritization, or providing preferential treatment of some Internet traffic to any Internet customer;
- Unreasonably interfering with, or unreasonably disadvantaging, either a customer’s ability to select, access, and use BIAS or lawful Internet content, applications, services, or devices of the customer’s choice, or an edge provider’s ability to make lawful content, applications, services, or devices available to a customer;
- Engaging in deceptive or misleading marketing practices that misrepresent the treatment of Internet traffic or content to its customers; or,
- Advertising, offering for sale, or selling BIAS service without prominently disclosing with specificity all aspects of the service advertised, offered for sale, or sold.
- Specifies that a specified violation shall be subject to the remedies and procedures established under the Consumer Legal Remedies Act.
- Prohibits a state agency from contracting with an ISP for the provision of BIAS unless that provider certifies, under penalty of perjury, that it will not engage in any of the following activities:
- Blocking lawful content, applications, services, or nonharmful devices for any customer, subject to reasonable network management practices;
- Impairing or degrading lawful Internet traffic on the basis of Internet content, application, or service for, or use of a nonharmful device by, any customer, subject to reasonable network management practices;
- Engaging in paid prioritization, or providing preferential treatment of some Internet traffic to any Internet customer;
- Unreasonably interfering with, or unreasonably disadvantaging, either a customer’s ability to select, access, and use BIAS or lawful Internet content, applications, services, or devices of the customer’s choice, or an edge provider’s ability to make lawful content, applications, services, or devices available to a customer;
- Engaging in deceptive or misleading marketing practices that misrepresent the treatment of Internet traffic or content to its customers; or,
- Advertising, offering for sale, or selling BIAS to any customer without prominently disclosing with specificity all aspects of the service advertised, offered for sale, or sold.
- Defines “Broadband Internet access service” to mean a mass-market retail service by wire or radio in California that provides the capability to transmit data to and receive data from all or substantially all Internet endpoints, including any capabilities that are incidental to and enable the operation of the communications service, but excluding dial-up Internet access service. “Broadband Internet access service” also encompasses any service in California that provides a functional equivalent of that service or that is used to evade the protections as specified.
- Defines “Edge provider” to mean any individual or entity in California that provides any content, application, or service over the Internet, and any individual or entity in California that provides a device used for accessing any content, application, or service over the Internet.
- Defines “Internet service provider” to mean a business that provides BIAS to an individual, corporation, government, or other customer in California.
- Defines “Paid prioritization” to mean the management of an ISP’s network to directly or indirectly favor some traffic over other traffic, including through the use of techniques such as traffic shaping, prioritization, resource reservation, or other forms of preferential traffic management, either (1) in exchange for consideration, monetary or otherwise, from a third party, or (2) to benefit an affiliated entity.
- Specifies that the Legislature finds and declares that the Federal Communications Commission (FCC) has repealed net neutrality rules intended to protect consumers and to ensure fair and reasonable access to the Internet.
- Specifies that is the intent of this act to ensure that corporations do not impede competition or engage in deceptive consumer practices, and that they offer service to residential broadband Internet customers on a nondiscriminatory basis.
EXISTING LAW:
- Specifies policies for telecommunications in California including; to promote lower prices, broader consumer choice, and avoidance of anticompetitive conduct; to remove the barriers to open and competitive markets and promote fair product and price competition in a way that encourages greater efficiency, lower prices, and more consumer choice; and to encourage fair treatment of consumers through provision of sufficient information for making informed choices, establishment of reasonable service quality standards, and establishment of processes for equitable resolution of billing and service problems. (Public Utilities Code (PUC) Section 709)
- Prohibits the California Public Utilities Commission (CPUC) from exercising regulatory jurisdiction or control over Voice over Internet Protocol and Internet Protocol enabled services except as required or expressly delegated by federal law or expressly directed to do so by statute, as specified. (PUC Section 710)
- Establishes the Digital Infrastructure and Video Compeition Act of 2006 which specifies that the CPUC is the sole franchising authority for a state franchise to provide video service, as specified. (PUC Section 5800 et seq.)
- Defines unfair competition to mean and include any unlawful, unfair or fraudulent business act or practice and unfair, deceptive, untrue or misleading advertising and any act prohibited, as specified. (Business and Professions Code (BPC) Section 17200)
- Specifies that any person who engages, has engaged, or proposes to engage in unfair competition may be enjoined in any court of competent jurisdiction, as specified. (BPC Section 17203)
- Authorizes actions for relief provisions to be prosecuted exclusively in a court of competent jurisdiction by the Attorney General or a district attorney or by a county, as specified, as a result of the unfair completion. (BPC Section 17204)
- Prohibits the use of untrue or misleading advertisements by any person, firm, corporation or association selling a product or service, as specified. (BPC Section 17500)
- Establishes the Consumers Legal Remedies Act to protect consumers against unfair and deceptive business paratices and provies procedures to secure such protections. (Civil Code Section 1750 et seq.)
- Requires specified State department to require from all prospective bidders the completion, under penalty of perjury, of a standard form of questionnaire inquiring whether such prospective bidder, any officer of such bidder, or any employee of such bidder who has a proprietary interest in such bidder, has ever been disqualified, removed, or otherwise prevented from bidding on, or completing a federal, state, or local government project because of a violation of law or a safety regulation, and if so to explain the circumstances. (Public Contract Code (PCC) Section 10162)
- Specifies that a specified bid may be rejected on the basis of a bidder, any officer of such bidder, or any employee of such bidder who has a proprietary interest in such bidder, having been disqualified, removed, or otherwise prevented from bidding on, or completing a federal, state, or local project because of a violation of law or a safety regulation. (PCC Section 10162)
FISCAL EFFECT: Unknown. This bill is keyed fiscal by the Legislative Counsel.
COMMENTS:
- Authors Statement: According to the author, “In today’s world, open access to the internet is critical to free expression, free speech, and democracy. Americans of every income level and of political persuasion depend on the internet. That’s why the FCC’s partisan decision to repeal net neutrality rules is so dangerous. The FCC’s action directly contradicts the will of the vast majority of Americans. It gives internet service providers unfettered power to sabotage the competition by throttling the internet speeds for competing content. The FCC action lets companies pay for priority to gain an unfair advantage in the race for our time, attention, and business. That’s also why this bill is so important. SB 460 prevents ISP’s from using deceptive, discriminatory or anti-competitive business practices related to the internet. It preserves the heart of the FCC’s net neutrality rules and prohibits ISP’s from blocking, throttling, and paid prioritization. SB 460 also makes net neutrality violations subject to enforcement under the consumer protection and unfair business practices laws. It also prohibits state agencies from contracting with ISPs unless the ISPs certify under penalty of perjury that they are abiding by net neutrality rules.
- Background: There are a number of federal and state agencies that play a role in the regulation and enforcement of communications-related services including the FCC, the Federal Trade Commission (FTC), and the CPUC. The FCC is an independent federal agency overseen by Congress to regulate interstate and international communications by radio, television, wire, satellite and cable in the United States. The agency is directed by five commissioners who are appointed by the President of the United States and confirmed by the United State Senate. The FCC is tasked with promoting the development of competitive networks, as well as ensuring universal service, consumer protection, public safety, and national security.
In addition, the FTC is an independent federal agency tasked with promoting consumer protection and preventing anticompetitive business practices. The FTC enforces antitrust laws, and protects consumers by stopping unfair, deceptive or fraudulent practices in the marketplace. In California, the CPUC regulates the telecommunications industry by developing and implementing policies to ensure fair, affordable universal access to necessary services, developing rules and regulatory tools, removing barriers that prevent a competitive market, and reducing or eliminating burdensome regulations. Furthermore, the Attorney General and local district attorneys can take enforcement actions against corporations for deceptive and misleading advertisement and other unfair business competition violations.
- Net Neutrality & the Internet: There are several major players in the operation of the Internet for information and data to be delivered from one point to another. Edge providers, such as Amazon, Google, and Facebook, develop and provide content, services and applications over the Internet. End users are internet customers that consume content from edge providers. In order for products to be delivered from an edge provider to an end user, the product travels through backbone networks which are capable of transmitting vast amounts of data. End users and edge providers typically connect to these backbone networks through local ISPs, such as AT&T, Comcast, or Verizon. Such ISPs serve as the gatekeepers and provide the “on-ramp” to the internet.
Net neutrality is the principle that ISPs should not discriminate against legal content and applications, by charging edge providers different delivery speeds to deliver their content. Hence, ISPs cannot block, throttle, or create special “fast lanes” for certain content. Net neutrality rules serve the purpose of maintaining open access to the internet and limited the degree to which ISPs can interfere with a customer’s ability to access legal content on the internet. It can also serve to promote greater competition between content providers by limiting the degree in which better resourced companies can pay to have their content prioritized and distributed to consumers at optimal speeds. Maintaining competition in the internet marketplace provides greater choices and reduced cost to consumers and new services entering the marketplace.
- Bright-line Rules and the 2015 Open Internet Order: After a series of court cases in which the FCC attempted to enforce net neutrality rules but were overturned, in May 2014 the FCC began a rulemaking to respond to the lack of conduct-based rules to protect and promote an open internet. After receiving over 3 million comments, in February 2015, the FCC adopted the Open Internet Order which established three “bright-line” rules banning certain practices that the FCC considers to harm open access to the Internet. The bright-line rules include:
- No Block: ISPs may not block access to legal content, applications, services, or non-harmful devices;
- No Throttling: ISPs may not impair or degrade lawful Internet traffic on the basis of content, applications, services, or non-harmful devices; and,
- No Paid Prioritization: ISPs may not favor some lawful Internet traffic over other lawful traffic in exchange for consideration of any kind.
In addition, recognizing that there may exist other current or future practices that cause the type of harms the bright-line rules are intended to address, the 2015 Open Internet Order also included a no unreasonable interference or unreasonable disadvantage Standard for Internet Conduct rule. The Internet Conduct Standard servers as a catch-all for consumers and edge providers by prohibiting practices that would unreasonably interfere with or unreasonably disadvantages to access or deliver products over the internet. Furthermore, the Order also reaffirmed the importance of ensuring transparency and adopted enhanced transparency rules so that consumers would have accurate information sufficient for them to make informed choices of available services.
Within the FCC’s 2015 Open Internet rules included provisions to reclassify ISPs from an “information service” under Title I of the Telecommunications Act of 1996 (the Act), to a “telecommunications service” under Title II of the Act. This would allow FCC to regulate ISPs similar to traditional public utilities, which may include rate of return regulation. However, when the FCC adopted the 2015 Open Internet rules it specified that certain provisions of Title II would not apply to broadband services. Proponents of net neutrality argue that FCC needs to reclassify ISPs as common carriers (e.g. a private company that is required to sell their services to everyone under the same terms) under Title II of the Act, in order to prevent anticompetitive behaviors. While opponents argue that the FTC already has the authority to prevent anticompetitive business practices and that Title II is an archaic provision created to regulate telecommunications services long before the Internet existed.
- 2017 Restoring Internet Freedom Order & State Response: In December 2017, following the election of President Trump, the FCC voted to repeal the 2015 Open Internet order. The new FCC argued that net neutrality rules were unnecessary because ISPs have publicly stated their opposition to violating such principles, and if an ISP were to engage in such activities, consumer expectations, market incentives, and the deterrent threat of enforcement actions by antitrust and consumer protection agencies, such as the FTC, will constrain such practices ex ante. To enact such changes the FCC reclassified ISPs under Title I of the Act and asserted significant preemption over state and local regulations, and laws. In June 2018, the repeal took effect.
In response to the 2017 Restoring Internet Freedom Order, Legislators in 29 states have introduced over 65 bills requiring ISPs to ensure various net neutrality principles. In 13 states and the District of Columbia, 23 resolutions have been introduced expressing opposition to the FCCs repeal of net neutrality rules and urging the U.S. Congress to reinstate and preserve net neutrality. In California, the Legislature passed AJR 7 (Mullin) Chapter 151, Statutes of 2017, which urged the President and Members of Congress to continue to protect net neutrality, open Internet access, the federal Lifeline program, and the E-rate program.
Currently, Governors in six states have signed executive orders and three states have enacted net neutrality legislation, including Oregon, Vermont, and Washington. Legislation introduced typically includes one or more of the following:
- Prohibiting blocking, throttling and paid prioritization of internet traffic, usually by invoking state consumer protection laws;
- Requiring that ISPs are transparent about there network management practices; or,
- Requiring state contractors for ISP service to abide by net neutrality principles.
This bill seeks to follow a similar approach by establishing net neutrality rules prohibiting ISPs from engaging in activities that interfere with a user’s ability to access content on the internet, similar to the Final Rules in the 2015 Open Internet Order. The bill prohibits a state agency from contracting with an ISP for service unless that provider certifies, under penalty of perjury, that it will not violate the specified net neutrality rules.
The author may wish to consider an amendment to better maintain consistency with the 2015 Open Internet Order’s Final Rules.
- Arguments in Support: According to The Utility Reform Network, “Recent action by the FCC to rescind the Obama era rules on net neutrality have led state legislatures from New York to Washington to consider state laws on this issue. Most big city mayors and local government officials have publicly opposed the recent FCC action and urged their states to respond. SB 460 is built on the same or similar platform as other state legislation in this area. California must act on net neutrality and ensure that there are comprehensive consumer protections that prohibit broadband [ISPs] from restrict access to the internet, imposing discriminatory charges for internet access, or otherwise inhibiting open access to internet services.”
- Arguments in Opposition: According to a coalition of industry groups, “SB 460 would create regulations that will disrupt the function of the Internet, make network management untenable, and ultimately harm consumers […] SB 460 will not promote or protect an open Internet, Instead, it opens the door to a patchwork of unworkable state regulations that will stymie innovation, and potentially undermine the backbone of California’s Internet economy. Despite virtually no showing of harms or violations of any rules, and regardless of the strong federal and state regulatory and enforcement safeguards currently in place, SB 460 goes beyond the previous 2015 Net Neutrality Rules, including creation of untenable procurement requirements, and enforcement by multiple forums.”
- Suggested Amendments:
SECTION 1. The Legislature finds and declares all of the following:
(x) This bill is adopted pursuant to the police power inherent in the State of California to protect and promote the safety, life, public health, public convenience, general prosperity, and well-being of society, and the welfare of the state’s population and economy, that are increasingly dependent on an open and neutral Internet.
(x) Almost every sector of California’s economy, democracy, and society is dependent on the open and neutral Internet that supports vital functions regulated under the police power of the state, including, but not limited to, each of the following:
(1) Police and emergency services.
(2) Health and safety services and infrastructure.
(3) Utility services and infrastructure.
(4) Transportation infrastructure and services, and the expansion of zero- and low-emission transportation options.
(5) Government services, voting, and democratic decisionmaking processes.
(6) Education.
(7) Business and economic activity.
(8) Environmental monitoring and protection, and achievement of state environmental goals.
(9) Land use regulation.
(a) The Legislature finds and declares that the Federal Communications Commission has repealed net neutrality rules intended to protect consumers and to ensure fair and reasonable access to the Internet.
(b) It is the intent of this act to ensure that corporations do not impede competition or engage in deceptive consumer practices, and that they offer service to residential broadband Internet customers on a nondiscriminatory basis.
(x) It is the intent of this act to protect and promote the Internet as an open platform enabling consumer choice, freedom of expression, end-user control, competition, and the freedom to innovate without permission, and thereby to encourage the deployment of advanced telecommunications capability and remove barriers to infrastructure investment.
(c) This act shall be known, and may be cited, as the California Internet Consumer Protection and Net Neutrality Act of 2018.
1775. For purposes of this chapter, the following definitions apply:
(x) “End user” means any individual or entity that uses a broadband Internet access service.
(x) Reasonable network management” means a network management practice is a practice that has a primarily technical network management justification, but does not include other business practices. A network management practice is reasonable if it is primarily used for and tailored to achieving a legitimate network management purpose, taking into account the particular network architecture and technology of the broadband Internet access service.
1776. It shall be unlawful for an Internet service provider, insofar as the provider is engaged in providing that provides broadband Internet access service, to engage in any of the following activities:
(a) Blocking lawful content, applications, services, or non-harmful devices, subject to reasonable network management practices.
(b) Impairing or degrading lawful Internet traffic on the basis of Internet content, application, or service, or use of a non-harmful device, subject to reasonable network management practices.
(c) Engaging in paid prioritization, or providing preferential treatment of some Internet traffic to any Internet customer.
(d) Unreasonably interfering with, or unreasonably disadvantaging, either an end users’ customer’s ability to select, access, and use broadband Internet access service or the lawful Internet content, applications, services, or devices of the customer’s their choice, or an edge providers’ ability to make lawful content, applications, services, or devices available to a end users. Reasonable network management shall not be considered a violation of this paragraph.
(e) Engaging in deceptive or misleading marketing practices that misrepresent the treatment of Internet traffic or content to its customers.
(f) Advertising, offering for sale, or selling broadband Internet access service without prominently disclosing with specificity all aspects of the service advertised, offered for sale, or sold.
(x) A Internet service provider engaged in the provision of broadband Internet access service shall publicly disclose accurate information regarding the network management practices, performance, and commercial terms of its broadband internet access services sufficient for consumers to make informed choices regarding uses of such services and for content, application, service, and device providers to develop, market, and maintain internet offerings.
(x) Nothing in this Section supersedes any obligation or authorization a provider of broadband Internet access service may have to address the needs of emergency communications or law enforcement, public safety, or national security authorities, consistent with or as permitted by applicable law, or limits the provider’s ability to do so.
(x) Nothing in this Section prohibits reasonable efforts by an Internet service provider of broadband Internet access service to address copyright infringement or other unlawful activity.
1777. (a) A violation of this chapter shall be subject to the remedies and procedures established pursuant to Chapter 4 (commencing with Section 1780).
(b) This chapter does not preclude enforcement of the rights specified herein under Chapter 5 (commencing with Section 17200) of Part 2 of, or Article 1 (commencing with Section 17500) of Chapter 1 of Part 3 of, Division 7 of the Business and Professions Code.
12121. For purposes of this chapter, the following definitions apply:
“Broadband Internet access service” means a mass-market retail service by wire or radio in California that provides the capability to transmit data to and receive data from all or substantially all Internet endpoints, including any capabilities that are incidental to and enable the operation of the communications service, but excluding dial-up Internet access service. “Broadband Internet access service” also encompasses any service in California that provides a functional equivalent of that service or that is used to evade the protections set forth in this chapter.“Edge provider” means any individual or entity in California that provides any content, application, or service over the Internet, and any individual or entity in California that provides a device used for accessing any content, application, or service over the Internet.“Internet service provider” means a business that provides broadband Internet access service to an individual, corporation, government, or other customer in California.“Paid prioritization” means the management of an Internet service provider’s network to directly or indirectly favor some traffic over other traffic, including through the use of techniques such as traffic shaping, prioritization, resource reservation, or other forms of preferential traffic management, either (1) in exchange for consideration, monetary or otherwise, from a third party, or (2) to benefit an affiliated entity.
12122. No state agency may contract with an Internet service provider for the provision of broadband internet access service unless that provider certifies, under penalty of perjury, that it is in full compliance with Civil Code Section 1775 and 1776 will not engage in any of the following activities.
Blocking lawful content, applications, services, or nonharmful devices for any customer, subject to reasonable network management practices.Impairing or degrading lawful Internet traffic on the basis of Internet content, application, or service for, or use of a nonharmful device by, any customer, subject to reasonable network management practices.Engaging in paid prioritization, or providing preferential treatment of some Internet traffic to any Internet customer.Unreasonably interfering with, or unreasonably disadvantaging, either a customer’s ability to select, access, and use broadband Internet access service or lawful Internet content, applications, services, or devices of the customer’s choice, or an edge provider’s ability to make lawful content, applications, services, or devices available to a customer.Engaging in deceptive or misleading marketing practices that misrepresent the treatment of Internet traffic or content to its customers.Advertising, offering for sale, or selling broadband Internet access service to any customer without prominently disclosing with specificity all aspects of the service advertised, offered for sale, or sold.- Related Legislation: AB 1999 (Chau) of 2018 establishes net neutrality rules for local agencies that provide broadband services and expands the types of local agencies that may provide broadband infrastructure and/or services. Status: Pending in the Senate Committee on Governance and Finance.
SB 822 (Wiener) of 2018 establishes net neutrality rules by prohibiting ISPs from engaging in activities that interfere with a user’s ability to access content on the internet. Status: Pending in the Assembly Communications and Conveyance Committee.
- Previous Legislation: AJR 7 (Mullin) of 2017 urged the President of the United States and Members of the United States Congress to continue to protect net neutrality, open Internet access, the federal Lifeline program, and the E-rate program. Status: Chaptered by the Secretary of State, Resolution Chapter 151, Statutes of 2017.
- Double-referral: This bill is double referred, and if passed by this Committee, will be referred to the Assembly Committee on Privacy and Consumer Protection.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
California Association of Realtors
City of Santa Monica
Media Alliance
Office of Ratepayer Advocates – CPUC
Sierra Business Council
The Utility Reform Network
Opposition
AT&T
BizFed
California Cable & Telecommunications Association
California Chamber of Commerce
California Communications Association
California Manufacturers & Technology Association
CenturyLink
Civil Justice Association of California
CompTIA
Consolidated Communications
CTIA
Frontier Communications
Greater Coachella Valley Chamber of Commerce
Los Angeles Area Chamber of Commerce
Orange County Business Council
San Diego Regional Chamber of Commerce
San Gabriel Valley Economic Partnership
Sprint
T-Mobile
Tracfone
USTelecom
Verizon
Analysis Prepared by: Edmond Cheung / C. & C. / (916) 319-2637
Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | SB |
THIRD READING
Bill No: SB 460
:
SENATE ENERGY, U. & C. COMMITTEE: 7-2, 1/11/18
AYES: Hueso, Bradford, Hertzberg, Hill, McGuire, Skinner, Wiener
NOES: Morrell, Vidak
NO VOTE RECORDED: Cannella, Stern
SENATE APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE: 5-2, 1/18/18
AYES: Lara, Beall, Bradford, Hill, Wiener
NOES: Bates, Nielsen
SENATE JUDICIARY COMMITTEE: 5-2, 1/24/18 (Pursuant to Senate Rule 29.10)
AYES: Jackson, Hertzberg, Monning, Stern, Wieckowski
NOES: Moorlach, Anderson
DIGEST:
This bill adopts the main components of the “net neutrality rules” – rules that prohibit Internet service providers (ISPs) from taking actions to interfere with a customer’s ability to access content on the Internet and which were repealed by a vote of the Federal Communications Commission (FCC) in December 2017. This bill provides persons damaged by violations of these rules access to the robust enforcement mechanisms laid out in the Consumer Legal Remedies Act. This bill also prohibits state agencies from contracting with such providers unless they commit to not engage in the prohibited practices.
Existing law:
- Defines “information service,” “telecommunications,” and “telecommunications carrier.” (47 United States Code §153)
- Authorizes the FCC, with some exceptions, to forbear from applying any regulation to a telecommunications carrier if the FCC makes specified determinations. States that a state commission may not continue to apply or enforce any provision that the FCC has determined to forbear. (47 United States Code §160)
- Requires that all charges, practices, classifications, and regulations for and in connection with common carrier interstate communication service by wire or radio be just and reasonable, and any such charge, practice, classification, or regulation that is unjust or unreasonable is declared to be unlawful. (47 United States Code §§201 and 202)
- Establishes duties on telecommunications carriers regarding interconnection to other telecommunications carriers, among other duties and responsibilities. (47 United States Code §251)
- Establishes procedures for negotiation, arbitration, and approval of interconnection agreements among telecommunications carriers. (47 United States Code §252)
- Requires the FCC and each state commission with regulatory jurisdiction over telecommunications services to encourage the deployment on a reasonable and timely basis of advanced telecommunications capability to all Americans by utilizing, in a manner consistent with the public interest, convenience, and necessity, price cap regulation, regulatory forbearance, measures that promote competition in the local telecommunications market, or other regulating methods that remove barriers to infrastructure investment. (47 United States Code §§706 and 1302)
- Empowers the Federal Trade Commission (FTC) to prevent persons, partnerships or corporations, except common carriers, and specified others, from using unfair methods of competition in or affecting commerce and unfair or deceptive acts of practices in or affecting commerce which give rise to a claim. (15 United States Code §45 (a)(1))
- Finds and declares the policies for telecommunications in California include, among others, universal service commitment by assuring the continued affordability and widespread availability of high-quality telecommunications services to all Californians. (California Public Utilities Code §709)
- Prohibits the California Public Utilities Commission (CPUC) from exercising regulatory jurisdiction or control over Voice over Internet Protocol and Internet Protocol-enabled services, except as required or expressly delegated by federal law or expressly directed to do so by statute or as set forth in statute. (Public Utilities Code §710)
- Establishes the Consumers Legal Remedies Act (CLRA), protects consumers against unfair and deceptive business practices and provides procedures to secure such protection. (Civil Code §1750 et seq.)
- Prohibits certain unfair methods of competition and unfair or deceptive acts or practices undertaken by any person in a transaction that are intended to result or that result in the sale or lease of goods or services to any consumer, including misrepresentations of the person’s products or those of competitors and false or misleading advertising. (Civil Code §1770)
- Provides that any consumer who suffers any damage as a result of the use or employment by any person of a method, act, or practice declared to be unlawful by Section 1770 of the Civil Code may bring an action against that person to recover or obtain any of the following: actual damages, but in no case shall the total award of damages in a class action be less than one thousand dollars ($1,000); an order enjoining the methods, acts, or practices; restitution of property; punitive damages; and any other relief that the court deems proper. (Civil Code §1780(a))
- Authorizes the State Attorney General to prosecute for unfair business competition, false advertising, or fraudulent business practices any business that violates any of California’s false advertising laws. (Business & Professions Code §§17200 and 17204)
- Establishes laws prohibiting the use of untrue or misleading in advertisements by any person, firm, corporation or association selling a product or service. (Business & Professions Code §17500 et seq.)
This bill:
- Establishes the California Internet Consumer Protection and Net Neutrality Act of 2018 and state its intent is to ensure that corporations do not impede competition or engage in deceptive consumer practices, and that they offer service to residential broadband Internet customers on a nondiscriminatory basis.
- Prohibits an ISP from engaging in the following activities:
- Blocking lawful content.
- Impairing or degrading lawful Internet traffic.
- Engaging in paid prioritization.
- Unreasonably interfering with, or unreasonably disadvantaging, either a customer’s ability to select, access, and use broadband Internet access service or lawful Internet content.
- Engaging in deceptive or misleading marketing practices that misrepresent the treatment of Internet traffic or content to its customers.
- Advertising, offering for sale, or selling BIAS without prominently disclosing with specificity all aspects of the service advertised, offered for sale, or sold.
- Makes the remedies and procedures of the CLRA available for violations of its provisions. This bill would also make clear that it does not preclude enforcement of the rights granted therein pursuant to the Unfair Competition Law (Business & Professions Code §17200 et seq.) and the False Advertising Law (Business & Professions Code §17500 et seq.).
- Prohibits state agencies from contracting with an ISP unless that ISP certifies, under penalty of perjury, that it will not engage in the activities made unlawful by this bill.
- States that the provisions of the division are severable.
- States this is an urgency statute necessary for the immediate preservation of the public peace, health, or safety and shall go into immediate effect.
[NOTE: See Senate Energy, Utilities and Communications Committee and Judiciary Committee Analyses for more detail.]
Background
Net Neutrality & Open Internet Access. Net neutrality, also known as an open internet, is the principle that ISPs should not discriminate against lawful content and should, instead, treat all Internet traffic the same regardless of source. Proponents of Internet openness and net neutrality principles generally express concerns that ISPs will limit, block, or degrade the quality of the content being transmitted to the end-user. Under net neutrality principles, ISPs cannot block, impair or degrade access, or create special “fast lanes” for the ISP’s preferred content. For example, net neutrality runs counter to an ISP blocking or slowing down traffic of TV shows streamed by a competitor video company over its broadband service as compared to TV shows from one of its own content companies.
To be a common carrier,
or not to be a common carrier?
That is the question.
The net neutrality debate. The crux of the national debate on net neutrality (also known as open internet) is whether broadband internet access service should be classified as a “telecommunications service,” under Title II of the Telecommunications Act, or as an “information service” under Title I. A Title II classification subjects the service to common carrier regulation (as a utility) and authorizes the government to mandate that the companies provide the same service to everyone without discrimination – much like electricity and gas services. A Title I classification would not subject the service to common carrier (utility) regulation. Proponents of net neutrality argue that the FCC needs to reclassify ISPs as a “telecommunications service” – a common carrier that is required to sell their services to everyone under the same terms – under Title II of the Telecommunications Act in order to prevent anticompetitive behaviors. Opponents of the Title II “telecommunication service” classification argue that although they are not opposed to the general principles of net neutrality, however, they believe the FTC already has the authority to prevent anticompetitive business practices and that Title II telecommunications service classification is an archaic framework created to regulate telecommunications services long before the internet existed. Opponents of the Open Internet Order also argue that regulating ISPs under Title II would have the opposite effect of impeding innovation and investment. Those against a Title II classification, including the current majority of the FCC, argue for a “light-touch regulatory framework.”
Obama Administration 2015 Open Internet Order. In February 2015, the FCC adopted, in a partisan vote, Open Internet rules (based on previous Open Internet rules) which established three “bright-line” rules banning certain practices that the FCC considers to harm open access to the internet. In adopting the Open Internet Order, the FCC classified ISPs as “telecommunications service providers” subject to Title II of the Telecommunications Act of 1996, instead of “information service” under Title I, as they had historically been classified. The classification under Title II provides the FCC with authority to regulate the service as a common carrier, as they might with telephone service. When the FCC adopted the 2015 Open Internet rules it established a “Title II tailored for the 21st Century,” whereby the FCC exercised its authority to forbear provisions of law, specifying that many provisions of Title II would not apply to broadband services, including those related to rate regulation. The Order also included additional transparency requirements beyond those required in the 2010 Open Internet Order.
The bright-line rules include:
- No Blocking: Broadband providers may not block access to legal content, applications, services, or non-harmful devices.
- No Throttling: Broadband providers may not impair or degrade lawful internet traffic on the basis of content, applications, services, or non-harmful devices.
- No Paid Prioritization: Broadband providers may not favor some lawful internet traffic over other lawful traffic in exchange for consideration of any kind.
Court cases promulgate FCC action. Previous court cases have limited the FCC’s regulation of the issues related to unfair blocking and discrimination when broadband internet service has been classified under Title I as an “information service,” even as the courts have acknowledged the merits of preventing discriminatory actions by broadband service providers. The court decisions made clear that if the FCC wished to adopt net neutrality rules, the FCC would need to classify the service as a Title II “telecommunications service” subject to common carrier regulation, as opposed to Title I “information service” which can not be regulated as a common carrier and can not be subject to FCC regulation of net neutrality rules related to no blocking and no unreasonable discrimination. Therefore, the lack of success in the courts promulgated the FCC to classify the service under Title II as a “telecommunications service.” Most notably, in Verizon v. FCC (D.C. Circuit 2014) the court ruled that the FCC did not have the authority to impose the 2010 Open Internet Order in its entirety because the FCC had classified broadband providers under Title I and, therefore, could not regulate them like common carriers. The case was largely viewed as a loss for open internet supporters and a victory for the cable broadband industry. However, the court sustained the FCC’s findings that “absent rules such as those set forth in the Open Internet Order, the broadband providers represent a threat to internet openness and could act in ways that would ultimately inhibit the speed and extent of the future broadband deployment.” The Verizon v. FCC court decision laid the foundation for the 2015 Open Internet Order and the classification of broadband service as a Title II telecommunications service.
Voted, ordered, but not, yet, taken effect. In December 2017, the Trump FCC voted, in another partisan vote, on a framework to repeal the 2015 rules. The FCC argued for a “light-touch framework” for broadband service, support for FTC oversight of anti-trust and anti-competitive behavior instead of FCC common carrier regulation, and largely revert to the 2010 Open Internet transparency rules with some modifications. On January 4th, the FCC issued the full order, however, it is pending a required review by the Office of Management and Budget and the publishing in the Federal Register, at which time it would then officially take effect. The future legal obligations of ISPs remain in flux at the federal level as it is highly expected the courts will be asked to weigh-in on the merits of the order and assess whether the action meets the standard for agency review or whether the action is “capricious and arbitrary.” Already the New York state attorney general has filed a lawsuit challenging the integrity of the public comment process. A few days ago, the California Attorney General, along with several other Attorney Generals, filed a lawsuit challenging whether the FCC’s recent repeal is arbitrary and capricious. More lawsuits are expected once the order takes official effect, including potential challenges to the preemption provisions. Perhaps less likely, although possible, is a Congressional repeal of the new order via the Congressional Review Act that authorizes Congress to overrule actions taken by federal agencies by a simple majority in the Senate and House within 60 legislative days of the order going into effect and requires a signature by the President.
Preemption. This bill adopts the main components of the FCC’s 2015 Open Internet rules, which were repealed by a vote of the Trump FCC in December 2017 and apply the rules to California intrastate internet traffic. The language of this bill largely reflects the rules adopted in the 2015 Open Internet Order concerning no blocking, no throttling, and no paid prioritization, as well as, conduct rules. In repealing the 2015 rules, the new FCC order states that they “preempt any state or local measures that would effectively impose rules or requirements that we have repealed or decided to refrain from imposing in this order.” As such, the success of implementing some of the provisions of this bill is largely hinged on the recent order being repealed or rejected, in whole or in part. Considering the high likelihood that the courts will be asked to weigh in, it seems within the realm of possibilities that the new order may not withstand a court challenge.
Enforcement. In addition to prohibiting certain practices by ISPs, this bill would make the remedies and procedures of the CLRA available for violations of its provisions. These “strong remedial provisions” would now be extended to Internet consumers in California when ISPs run afoul of this bill’s bright line rules. Consumers who suffer any damage as a result of the unlawful practices specified in this bill would have a right of action under the CLRA to recover damages and other remedies, including actual damages; an order to enjoin the unlawful practices; restitution; punitive damages; or any other relief that the court deems proper. Additionally, under this bill, mechanisms for securing remedies on a class wide basis would be provided to consumers, and courts would be authorized to award attorney’s fees to prevailing plaintiffs. This bill goes further and would also make clear that it does not preclude enforcement of the rights granted in this bill pursuant to the Unfair Competition and the False Advertising Law. The Unfair Competition Law provides that a court “may make such orders or judgments . . . as may be necessary to restore to any person in interest any money or property, real or personal, which may have been acquired by means of such unfair competition.” The law also permits courts to award injunctive relief and, in certain cases, to assess civil penalties against a violator. By making paid prioritization, throttling or blocking Internet traffic, or otherwise unreasonably interfering with a customer’s ability to utilize the full benefits of ISPs unlawful, the remedies afforded under the Unfair Competition Law would also be available to address any violations. Violations of the Unfair Competition Law can be prosecuted by all of the following:
- the Attorney General;
- a district attorney;
- a county counsel authorized by agreement with the district attorney in actions involving violation of a county ordinance;
- a city attorney of a city having a population in excess of 750,000;
- a city attorney in a city and county;
- a city prosecutor in a city having a full-time city prosecutor in the name of the people of the State of California upon their own complaint or upon the complaint of a board, officer, person, corporation, or association with the consent of the district attorney; or
- a person who has suffered injury in fact and has lost money or property as a result of the unfair competition.
The state government as customers of ISPs. Courts have repeatedly recognized a distinction between states acting as market regulators and states operating as market participants, recognizing the states’ ability to themselves operate freely in the free market. This bill would prohibit state agencies from contracting with an ISP for the provision of broadband service unless that ISP certifies, under penalty of perjury, that it will not engage in the net neutrality rules. This provision of the bill would harness the state’s power as a market participant to decide the terms upon which it will enter into a contract in order to protect the principles of net neutrality. Several other states are looking to implement similar rules for state government contracts. In addition, on January 22, 2018, Governor Steve Bullock of Montana signed an executive order declaring that any ISP with a state government contract cannot block or charge more for faster delivery of websites. States generally have control over their decisions when contracting for goods and services. Because this bill would make clear that its provisions are severable, even if Section two were struck down as preempted, California could still protect net neutrality through its role as a market participant.
CPUC role. Rules related to common carrier regulation are consistent with the CPUC’s role in regulating utility-style services. A previous version of this bill which would have expanded the CPUC’s existing telecommunications-related responsibilities was amended out.
Patchwork of regulation. One of the criticisms of this bill by the opponents is that this bill would create a patchwork of regulation that could stymie the marketplace since California would have rules that are different from other states and the federal government. Due to the nature of Internet traffic traveling across state lines, it would be ideal to have one national rule to address the issue of net neutrality. However, the FCC’s vote in December has resulted in other states also proposing action to institute their own net neutrality rules via statute or executive orders. In this regard, California may not be alone in adopting its own rules.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: Fiscal Com.: Local:
Unknown fiscal impact with recent amendments.
ADT Security Services
Center for Accessible Technology
City of Santa Monica
The Greenlining Institute
The Utility Reform Network
OPPOSITION: (Verified 1/24/18)
Asian Pacific Islander American Public Affairs Association
Asian Pacific Islander American Public Affairs Association Bay Area Region
AT&T
Black Business Association
Black Chamber of Orange County
California Cable & Telecommunications Association
California Chamber of Commerce
California Manufacturers & Technology Association
Carmel Valley Chamber of Commerce
Central City Association of Los Angeles
Chambers of Commerce Alliance of Ventura and Santa Barbara Counties
Coalition for Responsible Community Development
Community Youth Center of San Francisco
Congregations Organized for Prophetic Engagement
CONNECT
Consolidated Communications
CTIA
Escondido Chamber of Commerce
Exceptional Parents Unlimited
Fresno Chamber of commerce
Frontier Communications
Greater Coachella Valley Chamber of Commerce
Greater Los Angeles African American Chamber of Commerce
Hacker Lab
Imperial Valley LGBT Resource Center
Inland Empire Economic Partnership
Innovation Tri-Valley Leadership Group
International Leadership Foundation
International Leadership Foundation Orange County Chapter
Janet Goeske Foundation
Jobs and Housing Coalition
KoBE Government Contracting Alliance
LEAD Projects/NetRoots
Lighthouse Counseling and Family Resource Center
Monterey County Business Council
Monterey Hospitality Benefits Group
Music Changing Lives
OCA Silicon Valley
Oceanside Chamber of Commerce
Organization of Chinese Americans Sacramento Chapter
Orange County Business Council
Orange County Hispanic Chamber of Commerce
Pacific Grove Chamber of Commerce
San Diego North Economic Development Council
San Diego Regional Chamber
San Gabriel Valley Economic Partnership
San Marcos Chamber of Commerce
Santa Ana Chamber of Commerce
Sprint
T Mobile
TechNet
The Fresno Center
The RightWay Foundation
Tracfone
UFCW Local 648
Valley Industry & Commerce Association
Verizon
Young Visionaries Youth Leadership Academy
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: The author states:
We cannot allow the profits and political interests of Internet service providers to outweigh the public interest in a free and open Internet – it’s too important to our economy and our way of life. And if the Trump Administration won’t protect consumers, the State of California will. SB 460 will prevent ISP’s from using deceptive, discriminatory or anti-competitive business practices. It preserves the heart of the FCC’s net neutrality rules and prohibits ISP’s from blocking, throttling, and paid prioritization. And it gives consumers greater transparency about the services we all depend on in everyday life. Net Neutrality is just common sense. It’s good for consumers and protects a level playing field for Internet companies.
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION: Opponents generally express concerns that this bill would result in a patchwork of state regulations that will stymie innovation. Many of the opponents also express concerns that this bill is inconsistent with the federal regulatory framework governing ISPs, is federally preempted, and will likely result in costly litigation.
ISPs, including CCTA, AT&T, Frontier Communications, generally express support for net neutrality principles, but share the concerns stated above and, therefore, oppose the bill. Additionally, CCTA states that “ISPs are required to keep consumers clearly informed of their open Internet practices and will be held accountable for any harmful conduct.” Some of the opponents state their concerns that the bill is being rushed through the legislative process.
1/24/18 17:07:15
**** END ****
Senator Hannah-Beth Jackson, Chair
2017-2018 Regular Session
Bill No: SB 460 (Author:De León)
Version: January 22, 2018
Hearing Date: January 24, 2018
Fiscal: Yes
Urgency: No
Consultant: CK
SUBJECT
Communications: broadband Internet access service
DESCRIPTION
This bill would codify portions of the recently-rescinded Federal Communications Commission rules protecting “net neutrality.” This bill would prohibit broadband Internet access service providers from engaging in certain practices, including impairing or degrading lawful Internet traffic, engaging in “paid prioritization,” and engaging in deceptive or misleading marketing practices. It would also provide persons damaged by violations of this bill access to the robust enforcement mechanisms laid out in the Consumer Legal Remedies Act. This bill would also prohibit state agencies from contracting with such providers unless they commit to not engage in the prohibited practices.
BACKGROUND
Overview of the Internet: Understanding the Series of Tubes
There are four major participants in the operation of the Internet marketplace that are relevant herein: backbone networks, Internet service providers (ISPs), edge providers, and end users--the customers. Backbone networks are interconnected, long-haul fiber-optic links, high-speed routers, and data centers capable of transmitting vast amounts of data. These networks are operated by many independent companies from around the world. Customers wishing to access the Internet generally connect to these networks through local ISPs, such as Verizon or Comcast. ISPs are said to provide the “on-ramp” to the Internet. Whereas users previously relied on dial-up connection over telephone lines, most customers now generally access the Internet through much faster “broadband,” high-speed communication technologies such as cable modem service. ISPs that provide these broadband Internet access services are referred to as BIAS providers. Edge providers provide content, services, and applications over the Internet that are consumed by the end users. Companies like Amazon, Google, and Facebook are examples of edge providers.
One federal court provided a simplified example of how this all works together:
when an edge provider such as YouTube transmits some sort of content—say, a video of a cat—to an end user, that content is broken down into packets of information, which are carried by the edge provider’s local [ISP] to the backbone network, which transmits these packets to the end user’s local [ISP], which, in turn, transmits the information to the end user, who then views and hopefully enjoys the cat.
These categories of entities are not necessarily mutually exclusive. For example, end users may often act as edge providers by creating and sharing content that is consumed by other end users, for instance by posting photos on Facebook. Similarly, broadband providers may offer content, applications, and services that compete with those furnished by edge providers.
(Verizon v. FCC (D.C. Cir. 2014) 740 F.3d at 645-647.)
It should be noted that some edge providers can bypass or take shortcuts along the backbone networks and provide their content more directly to ISPs through “peering connections” and “content delivery networks” (CDNs). For example, Netflix has built its own CDN to deliver all of its video traffic, including 90 percent of it being delivered through direct connections between its CDN and local ISPs. (See Netflix Media Center, How Netflix Works With ISPs Around the Globe to Deliver a Great Viewing Experience (Mar. 17, 2018) <https://media.netflix.com/en/ company-blog/how-netflix-works-with-isps-around-the-globe-to-deliver-a-great viewing-experience> [as of Jan. 22, 2018].)
“Net Neutrality”
Net neutrality is the concept that the Internet should be an open and level playing field. The theory is that ISPs should not discriminate against lawful content, but treat all Internet traffic the same regardless of source and whether the content is in competition with that of the ISP. There is reasonable concern, explained in further detail below, that without rules against it, ISPs will limit, block, or degrade the quality of the content being transmitted to the end user, or create special “fast lanes” for the ISP’s preferred content. Another troubling practice is known as “paid prioritization” in which BIAS providers will offer to prioritize Internet traffic for some edge providers for compensation and at the detriment of other edge providers and end users. Under commonly-accepted net neutrality principles, these practices are anathema to an open Internet.
As discussed in more detail below, these are not simply speculative concerns. One major BIAS provider admitted to a federal appellate court that without FCC rules prohibiting accepting fees from edge providers in return for either excluding their competitors or for granting prioritized access to end users, it “would be exploring those commercial arrangements.” (Verizon v. FCC (D.C. Cir. 2014) 740 F.3d 623, 645-646.) There is also extensive evidence that major BIAS providers have intentionally interfered with customers’ access to certain Internet content and have threatened to withhold the free flow of traffic from certain edge providers unless compensated. (See Comcast Corp. v. FCC (D.C. Cir. 2010) 600 F.3d 642; Peter Svensson, Comcast Blocks Some Internet Traffic (Oct. 19, 2007) <http://www.washingtonpost.com/wpdyn/content/article/2007/10 /19/AR2007101900842.html> [as of Jan. 22, 2018]; Timothy Lee, Five big US Internet providers are slowing down Internet access until they get more cash (May 5, 2014) Vox <https://www.vox.com/2014/5/5/5683642/five-big-internet-providers-are-slowing-down-internet-access-until> [as of Jan. 22, 2018]; Sam Thielman, Major Internet providers slowing traffic speeds for thousands across US (June 22, 2015) The Guardian < https:// www.theguardian.com/technology/2015/jun/22/major-internet-providers-slowing-traffic-speeds> [as of Jan. 22, 2018]; Timothy Karr, Net Neutrality Violations: A Brief History (Apr. 25, 2017) < https://www.freepress.net/blog/2017/04/25/net-neutrality-violations-brief-history> [as of Jan. 22, 2018].)
The Federal Communications Commission under President Obama implemented robust net neutrality rules in a 2015 Open Internet Order that included prohibitions on blocking access to legal content, applications, and services; impairing or degrading lawful Internet traffic; and favoring some Internet traffic over other traffic in exchange for consideration (paid prioritization). However, the FCC under the current President recently released its order rescinding these rules and again exposing end users and edge providers to these troubling practices.
In response, several states have introduced their own legislation to protect net neutrality. This bill would implement the net neutrality rules established in the 2015 Open Internet Order for ISPs providing BIAS within California and would prohibit state agencies from contracting with ISPs unless they commit to net neutral practices. This bill would also provide enforcement mechanisms to ensure those harmed by violations are able to seek redress.
CHANGES TO EXISTING LAW
Existing federal law, the Communications Act of 1934 (the Act), as amended, establishes the Federal Communications Commission (FCC) for the purpose of regulating interstate and foreign communication by various means. (47 U.S.C. Sec. 151 et seq.)
Existing federal law defines “information service” to mean the offering of a capability for generating, acquiring, storing, transforming, processing, retrieving, utilizing, or making available information via telecommunications, and includes electronic publishing, but does not include any use of any such capability for the management, control, or operation of a telecommunications system or the management of a telecommunications service. Federal law defines “telecommunications” to mean the transmission, between or among points specified by the user, of information of the user’s choosing, without change in the form or content of the information as sent and received and defines “telecommunications carrier” to mean any provider of telecommunications services, except that such term does not include aggregators of telecommunications services, as defined. A telecommunications carrier is treated as a common carrier only to the extent that it is engaged in providing telecommunications services, except that the FCC shall determine whether the provision of fixed and mobile satellite service shall be treated as common carriage. (47 U.S.C. Sec. 153.)
Existing federal law states that it is the policy of the United States to preserve the vibrant and competitive free market that presently exists for the Internet and other interactive computer services, unfettered by federal or state regulation and to encourage the development of technologies which maximize user control over what information is received by individuals, families, and schools who use the Internet and other interactive computer services. (47 U.S.C. Sec. 230.)
Existing federal law authorizes the FCC, with some exceptions, to forbear from applying any regulation or any provision of the Act to a telecommunications carrier or telecommunications service, or class of telecommunications carriers or telecommunications services if the FCC makes specified determinations. It requires the FCC in making such a determination to consider whether the forbearance from enforcing the provision or regulation will promote competitive market conditions, including the extent to which such forbearance will enhance competition among providers of telecommunications services. It also states that a state commission may not continue to apply or enforce any provision of this chapter that the FCC has determined to forbear from applying under this section. (47 U.S.C. Sec. 160.)
Existing federal law requires that all charges, practices, classifications, and regulations for and in connection with common carrier interstate communication service by wire or radio be just and reasonable, and any such charge, practice, classification, or regulation that is unjust or unreasonable is declared to be unlawful. Existing law authorizes the FCC to prescribe such rules and regulations as may be necessary in the public interest to carry out the provisions of the Act. (47 U.S.C. Sec. 201.)
Existing federal law prohibits any common carrier from making any unjust or unreasonable discrimination in charges, practices, classifications, regulations, facilities, or services for or in connection with like communication service, directly or indirectly, by any means or device, or to make or give any undue or unreasonable preference or advantage to any particular person, class of persons, or locality, or to subject any particular person, class of persons, or locality to any undue or unreasonable prejudice or disadvantage. (47 U.S.C. Sec. 202.)
Existing federal law requires every telecommunications carrier to protect the confidentiality of proprietary information of its customers, with some specified exemptions. (47 U.S.C. Sec. 222.)
Existing federal law establishes duties on telecommunications carriers regarding interconnectivity, including an obligation to interconnect directly or indirectly with the facilities and equipment of other telecommunications carriers. (47 U.S.C. Secs. 251, 256.)
Existing federal law establishes procedures for negotiation, arbitration, and approval of interconnection agreements among telecommunications carriers. (47 U.S.C. Sec. 252.)
Existing federal law requires every telecommunications carrier that provides interstate telecommunications services to contribute, on an equitable and nondiscriminatory basis, to the specific, predictable, and sufficient mechanisms established by the FCC to preserve and advance universal service. Existing federal law states that only eligible telecommunications carriers, as provided, shall be eligible to receive specific federal universal service support. Federal law authorizes a state to adopt regulations to provide for additional definitions and standards to preserve and advance universal service within that state. (47 U.S.C. Sec. 254.)
Existing federal law requires the FCC and each state commission with regulatory jurisdiction over telecommunications services to encourage the deployment on a reasonable and timely basis of advanced telecommunications capability to all Americans (including, in particular, elementary and secondary schools and classrooms) by utilizing, in a manner consistent with the public interest, convenience, and necessity, price cap regulation, regulatory forbearance, measures that promote competition in the local telecommunications market, or other regulating methods that remove barriers to infrastructure investment. (47 U.S.C. Sec. 1302.)
Existing federal law empowers the Federal Trade Commission (FTC) to prevent persons, partnerships or corporations, except common carriers, and specified others, from using unfair methods of competition in or affecting commerce and unfair or deceptive acts of practices in or affecting commerce. (15 U.S.C. Sec. 45(a).)
Existing California law, the Consumers Legal Remedies Act (CLRA), protects consumers against unfair and deceptive business practices and provides procedures to secure such protection. (Civ. Code Sec. 1750 et seq.)
Existing California law makes unlawful certain unfair methods of competition and unfair or deceptive acts or practices undertaken by any person in a transaction that are intended to result or that result in the sale or lease of goods or services to any consumer, including misrepresentations of the person’s products or those of competitors and false or misleading advertising. (Civ. Code Sec. 1770.)
Existing California law provides that any consumer who suffers any damage as a result of the use or employment by any person of a method, act, or practice declared to be unlawful by Section 1770 of the Civil Code may bring an action against that person to recover or obtain any of the following:
- actual damages, but in no case shall the total award of damages in a class action be less than one thousand dollars ($1,000);
- an order enjoining the methods, acts, or practices;
- restitution of property;
- punitive damages; and
- any other relief that the court deems proper. (Civ. Code Sec. 1780(a).)
Existing California law additionally provides that consumers who are senior citizens or disabled persons, as defined, may seek and be awarded, in actions pursuant to Section 1780(a) of the Civil Code (CLRA actions), in addition to the remedies specified therein, up to five thousand dollars ($5,000) where the trier of fact makes certain findings. (Civ. Code Sec. 1780(b).)
Existing California law provides that CLRA actions may be commenced in the county in which the person against whom it is brought resides, has the person’s principal place of business, or is doing business, or in the county where the transaction or any substantial portion thereof occurred. Courts are required to award court costs and attorney’s fees to a prevailing plaintiff in such actions. Reasonable attorney’s fees may be awarded to a prevailing defendant upon a finding by the court that the plaintiff’s prosecution of the action was not in good faith. (Civ. Code Sec. 1780(d)-(e).)
Existing California law provides that any consumer entitled to bring a CLRA action may, if the unlawful method, act, or practice has caused damage to other consumers similarly situated, bring an action on behalf of the consumer and such other similarly situated consumers to recover damages or obtain other relief as provided. (Civ. Code Sec. 1781.)
Existing California law defines “unfair competition” to mean and include any unlawful, unfair or fraudulent business act or practice and unfair, deceptive, untrue, or misleading advertising and any act prohibited by Chapter 1 (commencing with Section 17500) of Part 3 of Division 7 of the Business and Professions Code (False Advertising Law). (Bus. & Prof. Code Sec. 17200 (Unfair Competition Law).)
Existing California law, the False Advertising Law, makes it unlawful to engage in false or misleading advertising and requires certain disclosures, including in direct customer solicitations. (Bus. & Prof. Code Sec. 17500 et seq.)
Existing California law, the False Advertising law, makes it unlawful for any person, firm, corporation or association, or any employee thereof with intent directly or indirectly to dispose of real or personal property or to perform services, professional or otherwise, or anything of any nature whatsoever or to induce the public to enter into any obligation relating thereto, to make or disseminate or cause to be made or disseminated before the public in this state, or to make or disseminate or cause to be made or disseminated from this state before the public in any state, in any newspaper or other publication, or any advertising device, or by public outcry or proclamation, or in any other manner or means whatever, including over the Internet, any statement, concerning that real or personal property or those services, professional or otherwise, or concerning any circumstance or matter of fact connected with the proposed performance or disposition thereof, which is untrue or misleading, and which is known, or which by the exercise of reasonable care should be known, to be untrue or misleading, or for any person, firm, or corporation to so make or disseminate or cause to be so made or disseminated any such statement as part of a plan or scheme with the intent not to sell that personal property or those services, professional or otherwise, so advertised at the price stated therein, or as so advertised. Existing law makes any violation of these provisions a misdemeanor punishable by imprisonment in the county jail not exceeding six months, or by a fine not exceeding two thousand five hundred dollars ($2,500), or by both imprisonment and fine. (Bus. & Prof. Code Sec. 17500.)
Existing California law provides that any person who engages, has engaged, or proposes to engage in unfair competition may be enjoined in any court of competent jurisdiction. The court may make such orders or judgments, including the appointment of a receiver, as may be necessary to prevent the use or employment by any person of any practice which constitutes unfair competition or as may be necessary to restore to any person in interest any money or property, real or personal, which may have been acquired by means of such unfair competition. Any person may pursue representative claims or relief on behalf of others only if the claimant meets the standing requirements of Business and Professions Code Section 17204 and complies with Section 382 of the Code of Civil Procedure, but these limitations do not apply to claims brought under this chapter by the Attorney General, or any district attorney, county counsel, city attorney, or city prosecutor in this state. (Bus. & Prof. Code Sec. 17203.)
Existing California law requires actions for relief pursuant to the Unfair Competition Law be prosecuted exclusively in a court of competent jurisdiction and only by the following:
- the Attorney General;
- a district attorney;
- a county counsel authorized by agreement with the district attorney in actions involving violation of a county ordinance;
- a city attorney of a city having a population in excess of 750,000;
- a city attorney in a city and county;
- a city prosecutor in a city having a full-time city prosecutor in the name of the people of the State of California upon their own complaint or upon the complaint of a board, officer, person, corporation, or association with the consent of the district attorney; or
- a person who has suffered injury in fact and has lost money or property as a result of the unfair competition. (Bus. & Prof. Code Sec. 17204.)
Existing California law, the Public Contract Code, requires that bidders or persons entering into contracts with the state to sign various statements or certify various matters under penalty of perjury. For example, the existing code:
- authorizes a state entity to require, in lieu of specified verification of a contractor’s license before entering into a contract for work to be performed by a contractor, that the person seeking the contract provide a signed statement which swears, under penalty of perjury, that the pocket license or certificate of licensure presented is his or hers, is current and valid, and is in a classification appropriate to the work to be undertaken. (Pub. Contract Code Sec. 6100(b).)
- requires specified departments under the State Contract Code to require from all prospective bidders the completion, under penalty of perjury, of a standard form of questionnaire inquiring whether such prospective bidder, any officer of such bidder, or any employee of such bidder who has a proprietary interest in such bidder, has ever been disqualified, removed, or otherwise prevented from bidding on, or completing a federal, state, or local government project because of a violation of law or a safety regulation, and if so to explain the circumstances. (Pub. Contract Code Sec. 10162.)
- requires every bid on every public works contract of a public entity to include a noncollusion declaration under penalty of perjury under the laws of the State of California, as specified. (Pub. Contract Code Sec. 7106.)
- requires every contract entered into by a state agency for the procurement of equipment, materials, supplies, apparel, garments and accessories and the laundering thereof, excluding public works contracts, to require a contractor to certify that no such items provided under the contract are produced by sweatshop labor, forced labor, convict labor, indentured labor under penal sanction, abusive forms of child labor, or exploitation of children in child labor. The law further requires contractors ensure that their subcontractors comply with the Sweat Free Code of Conduct, under penalty of perjury. (Pub. Contract Code Sec. 6108.)
This bill would establish the California Internet Consumer Protection and Net Neutrality Act of 2018 and state its intent is to ensure that corporations do not impede competition or engage in deceptive consumer practices, and that they offer service to residential broadband Internet customers on a nondiscriminatory basis.
This bill would define “broadband Internet access service” (BIAS) to mean a mass-market retail service by wire or radio in California that provides the capability to transmit data to and receive data from all or substantially all Internet endpoints, including any capabilities that are incidental to and enable the operation of the communications service, but excluding dial-up Internet access service. It would also encompass any service in California that provides a functional equivalent of that service or that is used to evade the protections set forth in this chapter. “Edge provider” would be defined to mean any individual or entity in California that provides any content, application, or service over the Internet, and any individual or entity in California that provides a device used for accessing any content, application, or service over the Internet. “Internet service provider” (ISP) would be defined to mean a business that provides BIAS to an individual, corporation, government, or other customer in California. This bill would define “paid prioritization” to mean the management of an ISP’s network to directly or indirectly favor some traffic over other traffic, including through the use of techniques such as traffic shaping, prioritization, resource reservation, or other forms of preferential traffic management, either (1) in exchange for consideration from a third party, or (2) to benefit an affiliated entity.
This bill would make it unlawful for an ISP that provides BIAS to engage in any of the following activities:
- blocking lawful content, applications, services, or nonharmful devices, subject to reasonable network management practices;
- impairing or degrading lawful Internet traffic on the basis of Internet content, application, or service, or use of a nonharmful device, subject to reasonable network management practices;
- engaging in paid prioritization, or providing preferential treatment of some Internet traffic to any Internet customer;
- unreasonably interfering with, or unreasonably disadvantaging, either a customer’s ability to select, access, and use BIAS or lawful Internet content, applications, services, or devices of the customer’s choice, or an edge provider’s ability to make lawful content, applications, services, or devices available to a customer;
- engaging in deceptive or misleading marketing practices that misrepresent the treatment of Internet traffic or content to its customers;
- advertising, offering for sale, or selling BIAS without prominently disclosing with specificity all aspects of the service advertised, offered for sale, or sold.
This bill would make the remedies and procedures of the CLRA available for violations of its provisions. This bill would also make clear that it does not preclude enforcement of the rights granted therein pursuant to the Unfair Competition Law (Business & Professions Code Section 17200 et seq.) and the False Advertising Law (Business & Professions Code Section 17500 et seq.).
This bill would prohibit state agencies from contracting with an ISP for the provision of BIAS unless that ISP certifies, under penalty of perjury, that it will not engage in the activities made unlawful by this bill.
This bill would make its provisions severable.
COMMENT
1. Stated need for the bill
According to the author:
Last month, the Trump Administration Federal Communications Commission (FCC) on a split, partisan vote, repealed strong consumer protection rules for Internet neutrality enacted by the Obama Administration. These rules were intended to protect consumers from unscrupulous business practices and usurious charges for broadband Internet service. States like Washington, New York, and New Jersey have announced efforts to enact state laws to protect consumers by establishing their own net neutrality laws.
SB 460 will preserve the heart of the FCC’s net neutrality rules. It will prevent Internet service providers from engaging in deceptive, discriminatory, or anti-competitive business practices. This bill sets clear, reasonable standards for Internet service providers and offers necessary protections for both online businesses and consumers.
2. Evolution of BIAS oversight
The Federal Communications Commission (FCC) is a federal agency created by the Communications Act of 1934, which was later amended by the Telecommunications Act of 1996. The enabling statute and those providing the FCC’s mission and operation are found in Chapter 5 of Title 47 of the United States Code. The purpose of the FCC is to regulate interstate and international communications by radio, television, wire, satellite and cable in the United States. The agency is directed by five commissioners appointed by the President of the United States and confirmed by the United States Senate, with no more than three commissioners from the same political party. The FCC is tasked with promoting the development of competitive networks, as well as ensuring universal service, consumer protection, public safety, and national security.
The FCC’s authority to regulate Broadband Internet Access services (BIAS) has hinged on the official classification of such services as either “information services” or as “telecommunications services,” as those terms are understood by the Communications Act of 1934, as amended (the Act). The importance of the classification to the role of the FCC is paramount:
The Act, as amended by the Telecommunications Act of 1996, 110 Stat. 56, defines two categories of regulated entities relevant to these cases: telecommunications carriers and information-service providers. The Act regulates telecommunications carriers, but not information-service providers, as common carriers. Telecommunications carriers, for example, must charge just and reasonable, nondiscriminatory rates to their customers, 47 U.S.C. §§ 201-209, design their systems so that other carriers can interconnect with their communications networks, § 251(a)(1), and contribute to the federal “universal service” fund, § 254(d). These provisions are mandatory, but the Commission must forbear from applying them if it determines that the public interest requires it. §§ 160(a), (b). Information-service providers, by contrast, are not subject to mandatory common-carrier regulation under Title II, though the Commission has jurisdiction to impose additional regulatory obligations under its Title I ancillary jurisdiction to regulate interstate and foreign communications, see §§ 151-161.
(Nat’l Cable & Telecomms. Ass’n v. Brand X Internet Servs. (2005) 545 U.S. 967, 975-976.)
Guided by the principles of open access, competition, and consumer choice, the FCC, in 2005, adopted the “Internet Policy Statement.” The Internet Policy Statement detailed four guiding principles designed to carry out the policy of the United States as stated in the Act, namely the preservation of the competitive free market for the Internet and the fostering of widespread deployment of advanced telecommunications capability to all Americans. The adopted principles were:
- to encourage broadband deployment and preserve and promote the open and interconnected nature of the public Internet, consumers are entitled to access the lawful Internet content of their choice;
- to encourage broadband deployment and preserve and promote the open and interconnected nature of the public Internet, consumers are entitled to run applications and use services of their choice, subject to the needs of law enforcement;
- to encourage broadband deployment and preserve and promote the open and interconnected nature of the public Internet, consumers are entitled to connect their choice of legal devices that do not harm the network; and,
- to encourage broadband deployment and preserve and promote the open and interconnected nature of the public Internet, consumers are entitled to competition among network providers, application and service providers, and content providers.
The Internet Policy Statement guided the FCC’s subsequent handling of Broadband Internet Access services (BIAS). In fact, the principles espoused therein were incorporated into several merger orders and licensing agreements. The FCC conditioned its approval of these transactions on compliance with the Internet Policy Statement. However, BIAS was classified as an “information service” at that time, limiting the basis for FCC oversight to its ancillary authority pursuant to Title I of the Act.
In 2010, the FCC, in furtherance of Internet Policy Statement principles, took action against Comcast for interfering with its customers’ use of peer-to-peer networking applications, and Comcast brought suit, contending the FCC acted outside of the authority vested in it by the Act. (See Comcast Corp. v. FCC (D.C. Cir. 2010) 600 F.3d 642.) The FCC argued it had authority to so regulate Comcast, then classified as an information service provider, under its Title I ancillary authority. The D.C. Circuit Court disagreed and found the agency’s actions were outside the parameters of its authority. It found the general statements of policy upon which the FCC relied did not create the “statutorily mandated responsibilities” that would justify the agency’s action against Comcast.
In response, the FCC issued a “Notice of Inquiry,” which, among other things, contemplated the possible reclassification of BIAS. The FCC received written feedback from over 100,000 commenters, held public workshops, and convened a “Technological Advisory Process with experts from industry, academia, and consumer advocacy groups.” As a result of that process, the FCC issued the “2010 Open Internet Order.” In that order, the FCC found that “the Internet has thrived because of its freedom and openness—the absence of any gatekeeper blocking lawful uses of the network or picking winners and losers online.” While the 2010 Open Internet Order maintained BIAS as an information service, it codified the principles laid out in the Internet Policy Statement in order to provide “greater clarity and certainty regarding the continued freedom and openness of the Internet.” The order established three rules:
- Transparency. Fixed and mobile broadband providers must disclose the network management practices, performance characteristics, and terms and conditions of their broadband services;
- No blocking. Fixed broadband providers may not block lawful content, applications, services, or non-harmful devices; mobile broadband providers may not block lawful websites, or block applications that compete with their voice or video telephony services; and
- No unreasonable discrimination. Fixed broadband providers may not unreasonably discriminate in transmitting lawful network traffic.
The 2010 Open Internet Order made the case for these rules by laying out the real and present danger to an open Internet, arguing that “broadband providers endanger the Internet’s openness by blocking or degrading content and applications without disclosing their practices to end users and edge providers, notwithstanding the Commission’s adoption of open Internet principles in 2005.” The FCC pointed to the financial incentives for ISPs to engage in these activities and the limited choices most consumers have for the provision of BIAS.
However, Verizon challenged the 2010 Open Internet Order in the D.C. Circuit Court, again with an argument that the FCC had exceeded its regulatory authority and violated the Act. (See Verizon v. FCC (D.C. Cir. 2014) 740 F.3d 623.) The D.C. Circuit vacated the no-blocking and antidiscrimination rules because it found that they impermissibly regulated broadband providers as common carriers, which conflicted with the FCC’s prior classification of BIAS as an “information service” rather than a telecommunications service, again exceeding their ancillary authority. However, the court upheld the transparency rule as within the FCC’s Title I authority. It also ruled that the FCC reasonably interpreted the Act to empower the FCC “to promulgate rules governing broadband providers’ treatment of Internet traffic.” Particularly relevant here, the D.C. Circuit Court also found the FCC provided ample justification for the rules in the 2010 Open Internet Order and that the need for them was supported by substantial evidence:
Equally important, the Commission has adequately supported and explained its conclusion that, absent rules such as those set forth in the Open Internet Order, broadband providers represent a threat to Internet openness and could act in ways that would ultimately inhibit the speed and extent of future broadband deployment. First, nothing in the record gives us any reason to doubt the Commission’s determination that broadband providers may be motivated to discriminate against and among edge providers. The Commission observed that broadband providers—often the same entities that furnish end users with telephone and television services—”have incentives to interfere with the operation of third-party Internet-based services that compete with the providers’ revenue-generating telephone and/or pay-television services.”. . . Broadband providers also have powerful incentives to accept fees from edge providers, either in return for excluding their competitors or for granting them prioritized access to end users. Indeed, at oral argument Verizon’s counsel announced that “but for [the Open Internet Order] rules we would be exploring those commercial arrangements.” . . . Although Verizon dismisses the Commission’s assertions regarding broadband providers’ incentives as “pure speculation,” . . . those assertions are, at the very least, speculation based firmly in common sense and economic reality.
Moreover, as the Commission found, broadband providers have the technical and economic ability to impose such restrictions. Verizon does not seriously contend otherwise. In fact, there appears little dispute that broadband providers have the technological ability to distinguish between and discriminate against certain types of Internet traffic. . . . The Commission also convincingly detailed how broadband providers’ position in the market gives them the economic power to restrict edge-provider traffic and charge for the services they furnish edge providers. Because all end users generally access the Internet through a single broadband provider, that provider functions as a “‘terminating monopolist’” with power to act as a “gatekeeper” with respect to edge providers that might seek to reach its end-user subscribers. As the Commission reasonably explained, this ability to act as a “gatekeeper” distinguishes broadband providers from other participants in the Internet marketplace—including prominent and potentially powerful edge providers such as Google and Apple—who have no similar “control [over] access to the Internet for their subscribers and for anyone wishing to reach those subscribers.”
To be sure, if end users could immediately respond to any given broadband provider’s attempt to impose restrictions on edge providers by switching broadband providers, this gatekeeper power might well disappear. . . . For example, a broadband provider like Comcast would be unable to threaten Netflix that it would slow Netflix traffic if all Comcast subscribers would then immediately switch to a competing broadband provider. But we see no basis for questioning the Commission’s conclusion that end users are unlikely to react in this fashion. . . . Moreover, the Commission emphasized, many end users may have no option to switch, or at least face very limited options: “[a]s of December 2009, nearly 70 percent of households lived in census tracts where only one or two wireline or fixed wireless firms provided” broadband service.
(Verizon v. FCC, 740 F.3d at 645-647 (internal citations omitted; emphasis added).)
Following this ruling, the FCC issued a Notice of Proposed Rulemaking in May 2014, to respond to the lack of conduct-based rules to protect and promote an open Internet. The FCC took proactive steps to facilitate public engagement in response to the Notice, including the establishment of a dedicated email address to receive comments, a mechanism for submitting large numbers of comments in bulk, and the release of the entire record of comments and reply comments in a machine-readable format, so that researchers, journalists, and other parties could analyze and create visualizations of the record. The FCC also hosted a series of roundtables covering a variety of topics related to the open Internet proceeding, including events focused on different policy approaches to protecting the open Internet, mobile broadband, enforcement issues, technology, broadband economics, and the legal issues surrounding the Commission’s proposals. The result of this process was the “2015 Open Internet Order.”
The FCC hailed the order as putting into place “strong, sustainable rules, grounded in multiple sources of our legal authority, to ensure that Americans reap the economic, social, and civic benefits of an open Internet today and into the future.” As discussed above, these rules made clear that BIAS providers could not block or throttle lawful Internet traffic or engage in paid prioritization.
However, just five months into the Trump Administration, the FCC, led by the newly appointed Commissioner Ajit Pai, issued another notice of proposed rulemaking, starting the process for overturning the carefully crafted provisions of the 2015 Open Internet Order. In December 2017, in a break from the decade of working to ensure an open Internet free from discrimination and interference, the FCC voted to reclassify BIAS back to an information service and roll back the net neutrality protections. The official order, the dubiously entitled “Restoring Internet Freedom Order,” was published on January 4, 2018. It will take official effect when published in the Federal Register, which is expected to happen shortly.
Despite the FCC’s commitment over the last decade and a half to maintaining an open and free Internet, the recent order removes the rules that protect edge providers and end users from discriminatory practices by BIAS providers. As the D.C. Circuit Court found, without these rules, “broadband providers represent a threat to Internet openness.” This bill would fill the void in order to respond to that threat. This bill would make it unlawful to engage in any of the following activities:
- blocking lawful content, applications, services, or nonharmful devices, subject to reasonable network management practices;
- impairing or degrading lawful Internet traffic on the basis of Internet content, application, or service, or use of a nonharmful device, subject to reasonable network management practices;
- engaging in paid prioritization, or providing preferential treatment of some Internet traffic to any Internet customer;
- unreasonably interfering with, or unreasonably disadvantaging, either a customer’s ability to select, access, and use BIAS or lawful Internet content, applications, services, or devices of the customer’s choice, or an edge provider’s ability to make lawful content, applications, services, or devices available to a customer;
- engaging in deceptive or misleading marketing practices that misrepresent the treatment of Internet traffic or content to its customers; or
- advertising, offering for sale, or selling BIAS without prominently disclosing with specificity all aspects of the service advertised, offered for sale, or sold.
These protections are central to preserving net neutrality and maintaining an open and free Internet. They ensure that everyone is given the ability to communicate and access information on a level playing field.
Staff notes that under the 2015 Open Internet Order the bright line rules prohibiting throttling or blocking Internet content and traffic were subject to “reasonable network management.” The order provided the following definition:
A network management practice is a practice that has a primarily technical network management justification, but does not include other business practices. A network management practice is reasonable if it is primarily used for and tailored to achieving a legitimate network management purpose, taking into account the particular network architecture and technology of the broadband Internet access service.
For the paid prioritization rule, the 2015 Open Internet Order included an exception when the BIAS provider could prove that the practice “would provide some significant public interest benefit and would not harm the open nature of the Internet.” The BIAS provider was required to seek a waiver for such an exception from the FCC, which would seek public comment and conduct its own investigation.
In order to maintain consistency with the 2015 Open Internet Order, the author may wish to amend the bill to include language that: (1) provides a clear definition of “reasonable network management”; (2) extends the reasonable network management exception to Section 1776(d) and Section 12122(d); and (3) provides for the “public interest benefit” exception as it relates to paid prioritization.
3. Enforcement mechanisms
In addition to prohibiting certain practices by BIAS providers, this bill would make the remedies and procedures of the Consumer Legal Remedies Act (CLRA) available for violations of its provisions. The CLRA was enacted “to protect the statute’s beneficiaries from deceptive and unfair business practices,” and to provide aggrieved consumers with “strong remedial provisions for violations of the statute.” (Am. Online, Inc. v. Superior Court (2001) 90 Cal.App.4th 1, 11.) These “strong remedial provisions” would now be extended to Internet consumers in California when BIAS providers run afoul of this bill’s bright line rules. Consumers who suffer any damage as a result of the unlawful practices specified in this bill would have a right of action under the CLRA to recover damages and other remedies, including actual damages; an order to enjoin the unlawful practices; restitution; punitive damages; or any other relief that the court deems proper. (Civ. Code Sec. 1780.) Additionally, under this bill, mechanisms for securing remedies on a class wide basis would be provided to consumers, and courts would be authorized to award attorney’s fees to prevailing plaintiffs. (Civ. Code Secs. 1780, 1781.) This bill would therefore place power in the hands of consumers, and even edge providers, to hold BIAS providers responsible for violations of net neutrality.
This bill goes further and would also make clear that it does not preclude enforcement of the rights granted in this bill pursuant to the Unfair Competition Law (Business & Professions Code Section 17200 et seq.) and the False Advertising Law (Business & Professions Code Section 17500 et seq). These laws have a broad scope. The Unfair Competition Law provides remedies against defendants who engage in “unfair competition,” which is broadly defined to mean and include any unlawful, unfair or fraudulent business act or practice and unfair, deceptive, untrue, or misleading advertising. (Bus. & Prof. Code Sec. 17200.) Unfair competition also includes any act prohibited by the False Advertising Law, which makes it unlawful to engage in false or misleading advertising and requires certain disclosures, including in direct customer solicitations. (Bus. & Prof. Code Secs. 17200, 17500 et seq.)
The Unfair Competition Law provides that a court “may make such orders or judgments . . . as may be necessary to restore to any person in interest any money or property, real or personal, which may have been acquired by means of such unfair competition.” (Bus. & Prof. Code Sec. 17203; see also Korea Supply Co. v. Lockheed Martin Corp. (2003) 29 Cal.4th 1134, 1146.) The law also permits courts to award injunctive relief and, in certain cases, to assess civil penalties against a violator. (Bus. & Prof. Code Sec. 17203; 17206.) By making paid prioritization, throttling or blocking Internet traffic, or otherwise unreasonably interfering with a customer’s ability to utilize the full benefits of BIAS unlawful, the remedies afforded under the Unfair Competition Law would also be available to address any violations. These laws would extend the power to enforce this bill’s provisions by not only allowing harmed customers or edge providers the right to bring action, but places enforcement power in the hands of state and local government entities. Violations of the Unfair Competition Law can be prosecuted by all of the following:
- the Attorney General;
- a district attorney;
- a county counsel authorized by agreement with the district attorney in actions involving violation of a county ordinance;
- a city attorney of a city having a population in excess of 750,000;
- a city attorney in a city and county;
- a city prosecutor in a city having a full-time city prosecutor in the name of the people of the State of California upon their own complaint or upon the complaint of a board, officer, person, corporation, or association with the consent of the district attorney; or
- a person who has suffered injury in fact and has lost money or property as a result of the unfair competition. (Bus. & Prof. Code Sec. 17204.)
4. Preemption
The supremacy clause of the United States Constitution provides:
This Constitution, and the Laws of the United States which shall be made in Pursuance thereof; and all Treaties made, or which shall be made, under the Authority of the United States, shall be the supreme Law of the Land; and the Judges in every State shall be bound thereby, any Thing in the Constitution or Laws of any State to the Contrary notwithstanding.
(U.S. Const., art. VI, cl. 2.) This provision forms the basis of Congress’ authority to preempt state laws. There are several forms such preemption may take.
The simplest form is “express preemption,” which occurs when Congress explicitly preempts state law in its enactment of federal law. Congress can also preempt state law implicitly. Field preemption exists when federal law creates “a scheme of federal regulation ‘so pervasive as to make reasonable the inference that Congress left no room for the States to supplement it.’” (Barnett Bank, N.A. v. Nelson (1996) 517 U.S. 25, 31 (quoting Rice v. Santa Fe Elevator Corp. (1947) 331 U.S. 218, 230).) “Conflict preemption” exists where federal law actually conflicts with state law and compliance with both state and federal law is impossible or where the state law impedes the realization of the full purposes and objectives of Congress. (California v. ARC America Corp. (1989) 490 U. S. 93, 100.)
Federal preemption is not limited to federal statutes, as federal regulations may also supersede state law. (Washington Mutual Bank v. Superior Court (2002) 95 Cal.App.4th 606, 612.) However, an agency may only preempt state law when the relevant regulations are within the scope of the agency’s statutory authority and are not arbitrary. (Id.; see also Smith v. Wells Fargo Bank, N.A. (2005) 135 Cal.App.4th 1463, 1475, fn. 6.)
As part of the Restoring Internet Freedom Order, the FCC included a provision concerning preemption:
[W]e conclude that we should exercise our authority to preempt any state or local requirements that are inconsistent with the federal deregulatory approach we adopt today.
We therefore preempt any state or local measures that would effectively impose rules or requirements that we have repealed or decided to refrain from imposing in this order or that would impose more stringent requirements for any aspect of broadband service that we address in this order. Among other things, we thereby preempt any so-called “economic” or “public utility-type” regulations, including common-carriage requirements akin to those found in Title II of the Act and its implementing rules, as well as other rules or requirements that we repeal or refrain from imposing today because they could pose an obstacle to or place an undue burden on the provision of broadband Internet access service and conflict with the deregulatory approach we adopt today.
Clearly this provision represents an attempt by the FCC to explicitly preempt state attempts to restore net neutrality, such as this bill. If the Restoring Internet Freedom Order goes into effect, litigation would likely result from any attempt to enforce the provisions of this bill. However, as indicated above, an agency may only preempt state law when the relevant regulations are within the scope of the agency’s statutory authority and are not arbitrary. (Id.; see also Smith v. Wells Fargo Bank, N.A. (2005) 135 Cal.App.4th 1463, 1475, fn. 6.) Courts are required to hold unlawful and set aside agency action, findings, and conclusions that are “found to be arbitrary, capricious, an abuse of discretion, or otherwise not in accordance with law,” or “contrary to constitutional right, power, privilege, or immunity.” (5 U.S.C. Sec. 706.)[1]
The Ninth Circuit has made clear that although the FCC has “broad discretionary authority to change its regulatory mind,” the FCC cannot expect the courts “simply to rubberstamp its change in policy.” (California v. FCC (9th Cir. 1990) 905 F.2d 1217, 1230.) The Ninth Circuit made clear that a reviewing court cannot accept an agency’s change of course uncritically, but rather it must “set aside agency action if it is arbitrary, capricious, an abuse of discretion, or otherwise not in accordance with law.” (Ibid.)
The policy goals set for the FCC by statute are “to preserve the vibrant and competitive free market that presently exists for the Internet” and “to encourage the development of technologies which maximize user control over what information is received by individuals, families, and schools who use the Internet and other interactive computer services.” (47 U.S.C. Sec. 230.) As seen above, these policy goals have guided the FCC for years. These principles are supported by the 2005 Internet Policy Statement, the 2010 Open Internet Order, and the 2015 Open Internet Order. In contrast, the recent Restoring Internet Freedom Order arguably breaks from these policy goals in clear ways. Rather than maximizing user control over what information is received, the order strips away the protections of an open Internet and allows BIAS providers to be “terminating monopolists” acting as the “gatekeepers” of the Internet without any rules to check their unique power. (Verizon v. FCC, 740 F.3d at 645-647.) As the D.C. Circuit Court of Appeals has indicated, without net neutrality rules, “broadband providers represent a threat to Internet openness.”
Concerns about these new rules and their legality are shared by many across the country. On January 16, 2018, the Attorneys General for the District of Columbia, the States of California, New York, Connecticut, Delaware, Hawaii, Illinois, Iowa, Maine, Maryland, Minnesota, Mississippi, New Mexico, North Carolina, Oregon, Rhode Island, Vermont, Washington, and the Commonwealths of Kentucky, Massachusetts, Pennsylvania, and Virginia, filed a protective petition for review in the United States Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit, initiating the states’ legal battle against the FCC and the recent Order. A host of public interest organizations have also filed suits challenging the recent FCC order. Underlying these legal challenges is the contention that the FCC’s decision to rescind the 2015 Open Internet Order was unlawful and must be overturned. Specifically, the States’ Attorneys General allege the order was:
arbitrary, capricious and an abuse of discretion within the meaning of the Administrative Procedure Act, 5 U.S.C. Sec. 701 et seq.; violates federal law, including but not limited to, the Constitution, the Communications Act of 1934, as amended, and FCC regulations promulgated thereunder; conflicts with the notice-and-comment rulemaking requirements of 5 U.S.C. Sec. 553; and is otherwise contrary to law.
Certain issues with the FCC’s process in implementing the Restoring Internet Freedom Order may also make it susceptible to legal challenge and repeal. There have been reports, including statements from FCC commissioners, that the public comment system was compromised. In addition, the preemption provision may be particularly vulnerable because the required notice of proposed rulemaking that the FCC put out did not seek public comment on preemption of state action.
Given these robust legal challenges and the incongruence between the FCC’s recent order and the policies set forth in the Act, there is a reasonable chance the Restoring Internet Freedom Order will be struck down, in whole or in part. Such an outcome will undercut any challenges to this bill based on federal preemption.
5. State contracting with BIAS providers
The Public Contract Code places various requirements on bidders or persons entering into contracts with the state. These usually entail entities signing various statements or certifying various matters under penalty of perjury. For example, the Public Contract Code currently:
- authorizes a state entity to require, in lieu of specified verification of a contractor’s license before entering into a contract for work to be performed by a contractor, that the person seeking the contract provide a signed statement which swears, under penalty of perjury, that the pocket license or certificate of licensure presented is his or hers, is current and valid, and is in a classification appropriate to the work to be undertaken. (Pub. Contract Code Sec. 6100(b).)
- requires specified departments under the State Contract Code to require from all prospective bidders the completion, under penalty of perjury, of a standard form of questionnaire inquiring whether such prospective bidder, any officer of such bidder, or any employee of such bidder who has a proprietary interest in such bidder, has ever been disqualified, removed, or otherwise prevented from bidding on, or completing a federal, state, or local government project because of a violation of law or a safety regulation, and if so to explain the circumstances. (Pub. Contract Code Sec. 10162.)
- requires every bid on every public works contract of a public entity to include a noncollusion declaration under penalty of perjury under the laws of the State of California, as specified. (Pub. Contract Code Sec. 7106.)
- requires every contract entered into by a state agency for the procurement of equipment, materials, supplies, apparel, garments and accessories and the laundering thereof, excluding public works contracts, to require a contractor to certify that no such items provided under the contract are produced by sweatshop labor, forced labor, convict labor, indentured labor under penal sanction, abusive forms of child labor, or exploitation of children in child labor. The law further requires contractors ensure that their subcontractors comply with the Sweat Free Code of Conduct, under penalty of perjury. (Pub. Contract Code Sec. 6108.)
Courts have repeatedly recognized a distinction between states acting as market regulators and states operating as market participants, recognizing the states’ ability to themselves operate freely in the free market. (Dep’t of Revenue v. Davis (2008) 553 U.S. 328, 339.)
This bill would prohibit state agencies from contracting with an ISP for the provision of BIAS unless that ISP certifies, under penalty of perjury, that it will not engage in certain activities, including interfering with customers’ access to Internet content or favoring some traffic over other traffic in exchange for compensation. This provision of the bill would harness the state’s power as a market participant to decide the terms upon which it will enter into a contract in order to protect the principles of net neutrality. Several other states are looking to implement similar rules for state government contracts. In addition, on January 22, 2018, Governor Steve Bullock of Montana signed an executive order declaring that any ISP with a state government contract cannot block or charge more for faster delivery of websites. (Cecilia Kang, Montana Governor Signs Order to Force Net Neutrality (Jan. 22, 2018) New York Times <https://www.nytimes.com/2018 /01/22/technology/montana-net-neutrality.html> [as of Jan. 22, 2018]. In response to concerns about the legality of such an action, a former enforcement chief for the FCC stated: “There is a long history of government using its procurement power to get companies to adopt requirements, and this is no different. This action by Governor Bullock will provide immediate relief.”
While the section of this bill that provides a right of action against BIAS providers for engaging in unlawful practices (Section two) directly conflicts with the preemption clause of the Restoring Internet Freedom Order and would therefore be fairly susceptible to arguments regarding federal preemption, the section governing government contracts with BIAS providers (Section three) would be more insulated from such challenges. States generally have control over their decisions when contracting for goods and services. Because this bill would make clear that its provisions are severable, even if Section two were struck down as preempted, California could still protect net neutrality through its role as a market participant.
“In general, Congress intends to preempt only state regulation, and not actions a state takes as a market participant. (Johnson v. Rancho Santiago Cmty. College Dist. (9th Cir. 2010) 623 F.3d 1011, 1022.) Federal law ordinarily preempts only state regulation of a defined field. Not all state law constitutes regulation. There may be no regulation and hence no preemption in circumstances when the state is acting in the marketplace in a proprietary rather than regulatory mode. (Friends of the Eel River v. North Coast Railroad Authority (2017) 3 Cal.5th 677, 705.) This section of the bill would specifically target state contracts for the “provision of broadband internet access service.” This provision would not regulate the industry, but simply place parameters for agencies contracting for these services.
6. Arguments for and against net neutrality in California
A number of groups submitted letters to the Senate Energy, Utilities, and Communications Committee in response to a prior version of the bill. The Greenlining Institute wrote in support of the bill:
Net neutrality ensures that people of color can tell their stories without fear of censorship, it ensures that they can access the resources and online networks necessary to overcome decades of discriminatory redlining. For communities of color, net neutrality is also essential [] for closing the digital divide. Without net neutrality, prices for open internet access will rise and media companies will invest less in diverse content and more in paying large broadband providers for priority access – resulting in an even wider digital divide.
The Utility Reform Network stated its belief that “California must act on net neutrality and ensure that there are comprehensive consumer protections that prohibit broadband internet service providers from restricting access to the internet, imposing discriminatory charges for internet access, or otherwise inhibiting open access to internet services.”
However, a number of technology associations and BIAS providers wrote in opposition to the bill. AT&T argued that the bill is “unnecessary to maintain an open Internet.” It stated that it is committed to the principles of net neutrality as indicated by its Web site. A coalition of business and industry groups wrote that they do not believe the bill “will operate to promote or protect an open Internet. Rather, the bill opens the door to the creation of a patchwork of state regulations that will stymie innovation, as well as have the potential to undermine the backbone of California’s Internet economy.”
Support: ADT Security Services; The Greenlining Institute; The Utility Reform Network
Opposition: Asian Pacific Islander American Public Affairs Association; AT&T; Black Business Association; California Cable & Telecommunications Association; California Chamber of Commerce; California Manufacturers & Technology Association; Carmel Valley Chamber of Commerce; Central City Association of Los Angeles; Coalition for Responsible Community Development; Consolidated Communications; CTIA; Frontier Communications; Greater Coachella Valley Chamber of Commerce; Greater Los Angeles African American Chamber of Commerce; Imperial Valley LGBT Resource Center; Inland Empire Economic Partnership; Jobs and Housing Coalition; LEAD Netroots; Monterey Hospitality Benefits Group, Inc.; Music Changing Lives; Oceanside Chamber of Commerce; Orange County Business Council; Orange County Hispanic Chamber of Commerce; Pacific Grove Chamber of Commerce; RightWay Foundation; Santa Ana Chamber of Commerce; Sprint; T Mobile; TechNet; Tracfone; Valley Industry & Commerce Association; Verizon; Young Visionaries Youth Leadership Academy
HISTORY
Source: Author
Related Pending Legislation: SB 822 (Wiener, 2018) would state it is the intent of the Legislature to enact legislation to effectuate net neutrality in California utilizing the state’s regulatory powers and to prevent Internet service providers from engaging in practices inconsistent with net neutrality. This bill is currently in the Senate Rules Committee.
Prior Legislation: None Known
Prior Vote:
Senate Appropriations Committee (Ayes 5, Noes 2)
Senate Appropriations Committee (Ayes 7, Noes 0)
Senate Energy, Utilities and Communications Committee (Ayes 7, Noes 2)
**************
An example of this is found in a Sixth Circuit case from February 2015 in which the court overturned the FCC’s attempt to preempt state laws restricting the growth of municipal broadband networks as outside of their statutory authority. (Tennessee v. FCC (6th Cir. 2016) 832 F.3d 597.) ↑
SENATE COMMITTEE ON
Senator Ricardo Lara, Chair
2017 - 2018 Regular Session
SB 460 (De León) - Guidelines: Broadband Internet access service
Version: | Policy Vote: |
Urgency: | Mandate: |
Hearing Date: | Consultant: |
This bill meets the criteria for referral to the Suspense File.
Bill Summary: SB 460 adopts the main components of the federal net neutrality rules repealed by a vote of the Federal Communications Commission (FCC) in December 2017.
Fiscal Impact: Unknown, likely significant costs to implement the bill. (See staff comments)
- Approximately $5.5 million (Utilities Reimbursement Account, General Fund) for the California Public Utilities Commission (CPUC) to establish rules and guidelines as required by the bill.
- Unknown potentially significant costs for the Attorney General to enforce the provisions of the bill and to defend against legal challenges of the bill.
Background:
Communications Services Oversight. Several federal and state organizations regulate and enforce communications-related services.
- The FCC is an independent federal agency that regulates interstate and international communications by radio, television, wire, satellite and cable in the United States.
- The FTC is a bipartisan federal agency with a dual mission to protect consumers and promote competition.
- In California, the CPUC oversees and regulates the telecommunications industry to: (1) ensure fair, affordable universal access to necessary services; develop rules and regulatory tools, remove barriers that prevent a competitive market, and reduce or eliminate burdensome regulations, as authorized by federal statute and rules, or authorized by the California Constitution or directed by state statutes.
- The Attorney General and local district attorney (as specified in statutes) can take enforcement action against corporations for deceptive and misleading advertisement and other violations of unfair business competition statutes.
Broadband Internet Access Service (BIAS). BIAS is generally high-speed internet access that is faster than the traditional “dial-up” service. This service includes transmission over digital subscriber line, cable modem, and fiber. The companies that provide the access are known as Internet Service Providers (ISP). ISPs range in size from well-known companies like AT&T, Comcast, Frontier and Verizon to smaller, regional firms like Pacific Internet and Sonic. ISP companies provide the “on-ramp” to the internet, usually with a required monthly subscription fee for the service.
Net Neutrality & Open Internet Access. Net neutrality, also known as an open internet, is the principle that ISPs should not discriminate against lawful content and should, instead, treat all internet traffic the same regardless of source. Proponents of internet openness and net neutrality principles worry about the relationship between broadband providers and edge providers. These proponents generally express concerns that ISPs will limit, block, or degrade the quality of the content being transmitted to the end-user. Under net neutrality principles, ISPs cannot block, impair or degrade access, or create special “fast lanes” for the ISP’s preferred content. For example, net neutrality runs counter to an ISP blocking or slowing down traffic of TV shows streamed by a competitor video company over its broadband service as compared to TV shows from one of its own content companies.
Obama Administration 2015 Open Internet Order. In February 2015, the FCC adopted Open Internet rules which established three “bright-line” rules banning certain practices that the FCC considers to harm open access to the internet. The bright-line rules include:
a) No Blocking: Broadband providers may not block access to legal content, applications, services, or non-harmful devices.
b) No Throttling: Broadband providers may not impair or degrade lawful internet traffic on the basis of content, applications, services, or non-harmful devices.
c) No Paid Prioritization: Broadband providers may not favor some lawful internet traffic over other lawful traffic in exchange for consideration of any kind.
In adopting the Open Internet Order, the FCC classified ISPs as “telecommunications service providers” subject to Title II of the Telecommunications Act of 1996, instead of “information service” under Title I, as they had historically been classified. The classification under Title II of the Telecommunications Act provides the FCC with authority to regulate the service as a common carrier, as they might with telephone service. However, when the FCC adopted the 2015 Open Internet rules it exercised its authority to forbear provisions of law, specifying that many provisions of Title II would not apply to broadband services, these included those related to rate regulation. The Order also included additional transparency requirements.
Proposed Law: The bill:
1) Prohibits an ISP from engaging in the following activities:
a) Blocking lawful content.
b) Impairing or degrading lawful internet traffic.
c) Engaging in paid prioritization.
d) Unreasonably interfering with, or unreasonably disadvantaging, either a customer’s ability to select, access, and use BIAS or lawful internet content.
e) Engaging in deceptive or misleading marketing practices that misrepresent the treatment of internet traffic or content to its customers.
2) Authorizes the Attorney General, a district attorney, or a city attorney to enforce any violation of this division.
3) Requires the CPUC to adopt an order on or before July 1, 2018, with specified requirements, including:
a) Establishing rules to implement this bill and by which the CPUC shall enforce the provisions of this bill.
b) Identifying this state government’s role as an internet customer and uses that customer power to ensure implementation of this division.
c) Establishing statewide consumer protection rules and guidelines that can be easily accessed by the public and that include “ground truth” testing for broadband internet speeds to create a single objective statewide internet speed test, which permits customers to test their own broadband internet speed and submit its results to the CPUC.
d) Ensuring that public purpose program funding, such as funding under the lifeline service program, California Advanced Services Fund, and others, is expended in a manner that will maximize internet neutrality and ensure the fair distribution of service to low-income individuals and communities.
e) Amending CPUC rules pertaining to eligible telecommunications carrier status which is necessary to participate as a provider in the lifeline service program and to receive other federal funding, to ensure compliance with consumer protection and internet neutrality standards provided by this bill.
f) Establishing a process whereby an ISP shall certify to the CPUC that it is providing BIAS in accordance with the requirements set forth in this division.
4) Adds language from FCC rules related to Reasonable Network Management (FCC Open Internet Rule Section 8.2 Definitions (f)).Add the exception provided in the FCC rules to authorize the CPUC to waive the ban on paid prioritization “only if the petitioner demonstrates that the practice would provide some significant public interest benefit and would not harm the open nature of the Internet.” (FCC Open Internet Rules Section 8.9 No paid prioritization (c)) - Add to SB 460. Section 5982 (c).
5) Adds “Reasonable network management shall not be considered a violation of this rule.” Per FCC Open Internet Rules Section 8.11. Add to SB 460 Section 5982 (d)
6) Changes the date by which the CPUC must implement the required order from July 1, 2018 to December 31, 2018.
7) States legislative intents, makes findings and declarations and Makes technical changes, and defines terms for the purposes of the bill.
8) States that the provisions of the division are severable, so that if any provision or its application is held invalid, that invalidity shall not affect other provisions or applications that can be given effect without the invalid provision or application.
9) States that the bill is an urgency statute necessary for the immediate preservation of the public peace, health, or safety and shall go into immediate effect.
Related Legislation:
SB 822 (Wiener, 2018) the bill would state the intent of the Legislature to enact legislation to effectuate net neutrality in California utilizing the state’s regulatory powers and to prevent ISPs from engaging in practices inconsistent with net neutrality, including through four specified means. The bill was introduced on January 4, 2018 and is awaiting referral.
AJR 7 (Mullin, Chapter 151, Statutes of 2017) urged the President of the United States and Members of the United States Congress to protect specified broadband communications-related policies and rules, including: net neutrality and open internet access, however, with no reference to Title II regulation. The resolution also calls on the President to support the Federal Lifeline Program that provides discounted telephone service for qualifying low-income consumers, and the E-Rate program’s discounted telecommunication and internet access services for schools and libraries.
Staff Comments:
CPUC Costs. According to the CPUC, a multi-phased Rulemaking would be required to implement SB 460. Phase 1 would address the statutory requirements; Phase 2 would address changes to the Public Programs to provide incentives as adopted in the legislation, and any changes necessary to Eligible Telecommunication Carrier regulations. The CPUC would also adopt the certification process and would develop the Ground Truth Testing and Master Contract Agreements. The CPUC would monitor compliance and adjudicate complaints on an ongoing basis.
Recent occurrences have left many policymakers and the public questioning whether the CPUC’s purview is too broad or its workload too great to effectively achieve its mandate. Last year, the legislature passed SB 19 (Hill, 2017) which transferred some of the transportation-related functions away from the CPUC to other agencies. This bill would expand to the CPUC’s existing responsibilities.
While it is not immediately clear whether it is feasible for the CPUC to take on these responsibilities, in terms of staff and resources, the responsibilities are potentially consistent with the CPUC’s role in regulating utility-style services. While existing statute, Public Utilities Code §710, prohibits the CPUC from exercising regulatory jurisdiction or control over Internet Protocol-enabled services, it only does so in so far as not directed by federal or state statute. Therefore, the Legislature retains the opportunity to pass statute to direct the CPUC in this space, granted such statutes are able to withstand any legal challenges, particularly those regarding federal preemption.
Feasibility. This bill requires the CPUC to adopt rules to ensure that public purpose program funding is expended in a manner that will maximize internet neutrality and ensure the fair distribution of services to low-income individuals and communities. Many of these programs already include criteria directing funding to low-income individuals and communities, such as the Lifeline Program and California Advanced Services Fund. According to the Senate Energy Committee, “efforts to leverage these funds in order to incentivize ISPs to commit to net neutrality rules seems very reasonable and an important leveraging opportunity for the state.” The Committee may wish to consider if, and the extent to which, it supports the leveraging of public purpose program funding for net neutrality.
Attorney General Costs. The fiscal impact resulting from the provision allowing the Attorney General to enforce this bill cannot be known with certainty, as the actual impact will be dependent on numerous factors. These include the number and frequency of violations enforced by the AG, the complexity of alleged violations, if parties settle matters prior to litigation, and the factors unique to each case. Each courtroom day costs about $7,010 so if this bill led to more than nineteen new cases or a case that took longer than seven days that otherwise would not have been brought, the cost pressures of this bill to the court would surpass the Suspense File threshold.
Litigation Costs and Preemption. The fiscal analysis does not consider potential legal challenges or federal preemption. As indicated in the Senate Energy Committee Analysis, this bill has a longstanding and highly litigious history. Staff notes that the state will likely incur significant costs due to legal challenges and notes the potential for one or more provisions of the bill to be held invalid by the courts due to the Surpremecy clause.
-- END --
SENATE COMMITTEE ON ENERGY, UTILITIES AND COMMUNICATIONS
Senator Ben Hueso, Chair
2017 - 2018 Regular
Bill No: Hearing Date: 1/11/2018
Author: | |||
Version: | As Amended | ||
Urgency: | Fiscal: | ||
Consultant: | |||
SUBJECT:
DIGEST: This bill adopts the main components of the net neutrality rules repealed by a vote of the Federal Communications Commission (FCC) in December 2017. This bill would prohibit internet service providers (ISPs) in the state from taking certain actions to interfere with a customer’s ability to access content on the internet, namely actions such as impairing or degrading, blocking, or paid prioritization, of lawful internet traffic. This bill requires the California Public Utilities Commission (CPUC) to adopt an order by July 1, 2018 to implement the provisions of this bill.
ANALYSIS:
Existing law:
- Defines “information service” to mean the offering of a capability for generating, acquiring, storing, transforming, processing, retrieving, utilizing, or making available information via telecommunications, and includes electronic publishing, but does not include any use of any such capability for the management, control, or operation of a telecommunications system or the management of a telecommunications service.
Defines “telecommunications” to mean the transmission, between or among points specified by the user, of information of the user’s choosing, without change in the form or content of the information as sent and received.
Defines “telecommunications carrier” to mean any provider of telecommunications services, except that such term does not include aggregators of telecommunications services (as defined in section 226 of this title). A telecommunications carrier shall be treated as a common carrier under this chapter only to the extent that it is engaged in providing telecommunications services, except that the FCC shall determine whether the provision of fixed and mobile satellite service shall be treated as common carriage.
(47 United States Code §153)
- Authorizes the FCC, with some exceptions, to forbear from applying any regulation or any provision of this chapter to a telecommunications carrier or telecommunications service, or class of telecommunications carriers or telecommunications services, in any or some of its or their geographic markets, if the FCC makes specified determinations. Requires the FCC in making such a determination to consider whether the forbearance from enforcing the provision or regulation will promote competitive market conditions, including the extent to which such forbearance will enhance competition among providers of telecommunications services. States that a state commission may not continue to apply or enforce any provision of this chapter that the FCC has determined to forbear from applying under subsection. (47 United States Code §160)
- Requires that all charges, practices, classifications, and regulations for and in connection with such common carrier interstate communication service by wire or radio be just and reasonable, and any such charge, practice, classification, or regulation that is unjust or unreasonable is declared to be unlawful. Authorizes the FCC to prescribe such rules and regulations as may be necessary in the public interest to carry out the provisions of this chapter. (47 United States Code §201) 332(c)(1)(A))
- Prohibits any common carrier to make any unjust or unreasonable discrimination in charges, practices, classifications, regulations, facilities, or services for or in connection with like communication service, directly or indirectly, by any means or device, or to make or give any undue or unreasonable preference or advantage to any particular person, class of persons, or locality, or to subject any particular person, class of persons, or locality to any undue or unreasonable prejudice or disadvantage. (47 United States Code §202)
- Requires every telecommunications carrier to protect the confidentiality of proprietary information of its customers, with some specified exemptions. (47 United States Code §222)
- Requires the FCC to ensure that, with respect to common carriers, interstate and intrastate telecommunications relay services are available, to the extent possible and in the most efficient manner, to hearing-impaired and speech-impaired individuals in the United States. Provides that any state desiring to establish a state program under this section shall submit documentation to the FCC that makes available to hearing-impaired and speech-impaired individuals, either directly, through designees, through a competitively selected vendor, or through regulation of intrastate common carriers, intrastate telecommunications relay services in such state in a manner that meets or exceeds the requirements of regulations prescribed by the FCC. (47 United States Code §225)
- Requires a utility to provide a cable television system or any telecommunications carrier with nondiscriminatory access to any pole, duct, conduit, or right-of-way owned or controlled by it. Authorizes, with some exceptions, a utility providing electric service to deny a cable television system or any telecommunications carrier access to its poles, ducts, conduits, or rights-of-way, on a non-discriminatory basis where there is insufficient capacity and for reasons of safety, reliability and generally applicable engineering purposes. (47 United States Code §226)
- States it is the policy of the United States to preserve the vibrant and competitive free market that presently exists for the internet and other interactive computer services, unfettered by federal or state regulation. (47 United States Code §230)
- Establishes duties on telecommunications carriers regarding interconnection to other telecommunications carriers, among other duties and responsibilities. (47 United States Code §251)
- Establishes procedures for negotiation, arbitration, and approval of interconnection agreements among telecommunications carriers. (47 United States Code §252)
- Requires every telecommunications carrier that provides interstate telecommunications services to contribute, on an equitable and nondiscriminatory basis, to the specific, predictable, and sufficient mechanisms established by the FCC to preserve and advance universal service. States that only an eligible telecommunications carrier designated under section 214(e) of this title shall be eligible to receive specific federal universal service support. Authorizes a state to adopt regulations to provide for additional definitions and standards to preserve and advance universal service within that state. (47 United States Code §254)
- Requires the FCC and each state commission with regulatory jurisdiction over telecommunications services to encourage the deployment on a reasonable and timely basis of advanced telecommunications capability to all Americans (including, in particular, elementary and secondary schools and classrooms) by utilizing, in a manner consistent with the public interest, convenience, and necessity, price cap regulation, regulatory forbearance, measures that promote competition in the local telecommunications market, or other regulating methods that remove barriers to infrastructure investment. (47 United States Code §1302 (§706 of the 1996 Federal Telecommunications Act)
- Finds and declares that the policies for telecommunications in California include, among others: universal service commitment by assuring the continued affordability and widespread availability of high-quality telecommunications services to all Californians; encouraging the development and deployment of new technologies and the equitable provision of services in a way that efficiently meets consumer need and encourages the ubiquitous availability of a wide choice of state-of-the-art services; assisting in bridging the “digital divide” by encouraging expanded access to state-of-the-art technologies for rural, inner-city, low-income, and disabled Californians; promoting lower prices, broader consumer choice, and avoidance of anticompetitive conduct; encouraging fair treatment of consumers through provision of sufficient information for making informed choices, establishment of reasonable service quality standards, and establishment of processes for equitable resolution of billing and service problems. (California Public Utilities Code §709)
- Prohibits the CPUC from exercising regulatory jurisdiction or control over Voice over Internet Protocol and Internet Protocol-enabled services, except as required or expressly delegated by federal law or expressly directed to do so by statute or as set forth in statute, including enforcement of 47 United States Code §§251 and 252, and several other requirements. (Public Utilities Code §710)
- States the CPUC is the sole franchising authority for a state franchise to provide video service under this division. Neither the CPUC nor any local franchising entity or other local entity of the state may require the holder of a state franchise to obtain a separate franchise or otherwise impose any requirement on any holder of a state franchise except as expressly provided in this division. Sections 53066, 53066.01, 53066.2, and 53066.3 of the Government Code shall not apply to holders of a state franchise. (Public Utilities Code §5840 (a))
- Authorizes the State Attorney General to prosecute for unfair business competition, false advertising, or fraudulent business practices any business that violates any of California’s privacy protection laws. (Business & Professions Code §17200)
- Authorizes actions for relief provisions to be prosecuted exclusively in a court of competent jurisdiction by the Attorney General or a district attorney or by a county, as specified, as a result of the unfair competition. (Business and Professions §17204)
- Establishes laws prohibiting the use of untrue or misleading in advertisements by any person, firm, corporation or association selling a product or service. (Business & Professions Code §17500)
- Empowers the Federal Trade Commission (FTC) to prevent persons, partnerships or corporations, except common carriers, and specified others, from using unfair methods of competition in or affecting commerce and unfair or deceptive acts of practices in or affecting commerce which give rise to a claim, as set forth. (15 United States Code §45 (a)(1))
This bill:
- Finds and declares that the FCC has repealed net neutrality rules intended to protect consumers and to ensure fair and reasonable access to the internet.
- States the intent of this bill to ensure that corporations do not impede competition or engage in deceptive consumer practices, and that they offer service to residential broadband internet customers on a nondiscriminatory basis.
- States the intent of the Legislature to ensure the specified principles are met regarding the deployment of new technologies and equitable provisions of service, among others.
- Defines “broadband Internet access service (BIAS)” to mean a mass-market retail service by wire or radio in California that provides the capability to transmit data to and receive data from all or substantially all internet endpoints, including any capabilities that are incidental to and enable the operation of the communications service, but excluding dial-up internet access service. Provides that the definition encompass any service in California that provides a functional equivalent of that service or is used to evade the protections set forth in this division, as determined by the CPUC.
- Defines “edge provider” to mean any individual or entity in California that provides any content, application, or service over the internet, and any individual or entity in California that provides a device used for accessing any content, application, or service over the internet.
- Defines “Internet service provider” to mean a business that provides BIAS to an individual, corporation, government, or other customer in California.
- Defines “paid prioritization” to mean the management of an ISP’s network to directly or indirectly favor some traffic over other traffic, including through the use of techniques such as traffic shaping, prioritization, resource reservation, or other forms of preferential traffic management, either (1) in exchange for consideration, monetary or otherwise, from a third party, or (2) to benefit an affiliated entity.
- Prohibits an ISP from engaging in the following activities:
- Blocking lawful content.
- Impairing or degrading lawful internet traffic.
- Engaging in paid prioritization.
- Unreasonably interfering with, or unreasonably disadvantaging, either a customer’s ability to select, access, and use BIAS or lawful internet content.
- Engaging in deceptive or misleading marketing practices that misrepresent the treatment of internet traffic or content to its customers.
- Authorizes the Attorney General, a district attorney, or a city attorney to enforce any violation of this division.
- Requires the CPUC to adopt an order on or before July 1, 2018, with specified requirements, including:
- Establishing rules to implement this bill and by which the CPUC shall enforce the provisions of this bill.
- Identifying this state government’s role as an internet customer and uses that customer power to ensure implementation of this division.
- Establishing statewide consumer protection rules and guidelines that can be easily accessed by the public and that include “ground truth” testing for broadband internet speeds to create a single objective statewide internet speed test, which permits customers to test their own broadband internet speed and submit its results to the CPUC.
- Ensuring that public purpose program funding, such as funding under the lifeline service program, California Advanced Services Fund, and others, is expended in a manner that will maximize internet neutrality and ensure the fair distribution of service to low-income individuals and communities.
- Amending CPUC rules pertaining to eligible telecommunications carrier status which is necessary to participate as a provider in the lifeline service program and to receive other federal funding, to ensure compliance with consumer protection and internet neutrality standards provided by this bill.
- Establishing a process whereby an ISP shall certify to the CPUC that it is providing BIAS in accordance with the requirements set forth in this division.
- States that the provisions of the division are severable, so that if any provision or its application is held invalid, that invalidity shall not affect other provisions or applications that can be given effect without the invalid provision or application.
- States this is an urgency statute necessary for the immediate preservation of the public peace, health, or safety and shall go into immediate effect.
Background
This bill adopts the main components of the FCC’s 2015 Open Internet rules which have been subsequently repealed by a vote of the FCC in December 2017.
Oversight of Communications Service: To inform the discussion, below is an overview of the government agencies with roles related to regulation and enforcement of communications-related service.
The FCC is an independent federal agency overseen by Congress to regulate interstate and international communications by radio, television, wire, satellite and cable in the United States. The agency is directed by five commissioners who are appointed by the President of the United States and confirmed by the United States Senate, with no more than three commissioners from the same political party. The FCC is tasked with promoting the development of competitive networks, as well as ensuring universal service, consumer protection, public safety, and national security. Among its duties, the FCC regulates all interstate and foreign communications by wire and radio, with nearly exclusive authority, in combination with state commissions, communications services that are classified as common carriers under Title II of the Federal Telecommunications Act, specifically those classified as “telecommunication services.”
The FTC is a bipartisan federal agency with a dual mission to protect consumers and promote competition. The agency is directed by five commissioners who are appointed by the President of the United States and confirmed by the United States Senate, with no more than three commissioners from the same political party. The FTC protects consumers by stopping unfair, deceptive or fraudulent practices in the marketplace. By enforcing antitrust laws, the FTC helps ensure markets are open and free. Federal law empowers the FTC to prevent corporations from using unfair methods of competition and unfair or deceptive acts of practices affecting commerce. However, federal law explicitly exempts the FTC’s authority as it relates to various classes of businesses, including common carriers, which telecommunications services. FTC can only take enforcement action once harm has occurred and been demonstrated.
In California, the CPUC is the main state agency responsible for oversight and regulation of the telecommunications industry by developing and implementing policies to ensure fair, affordable universal access to necessary services, developing rules and regulatory tools, removing barriers that prevent a competitive market, and reducing or eliminating burdensome regulations, as authorized by federal statute and rules, or authorized by the California Constitution or directed by state statutes.
The Attorney General and local district attorney (as specified in statutes) can take enforcement action against corporations for deceptive and misleading advertisement and other violations of unfair business competition statutes.
Broadband Internet Access Service (BIAS). BIAS is generally high-speed internet access that is faster than the traditional “dial-up” service. This service includes transmission over digital subscriber line, cable modem, and fiber. The companies that provide the access are known as ISPs (also BIAS providers). ISPs range in size from well-known companies like AT&T, Comcast, Frontier and Verizon to smaller, regional firms like Pacific Internet and Sonic. ISP companies provide the “on-ramp” to the internet, usually with a required monthly subscription fee for the service.
About the Internet. As explained in U.S. Telecom v. FCC:
The internet has four major participants: end users, broadband providers, backbone networks, and edge providers. Most end users connect to the internet through a broadband provider, which delivers high-speed internet access using technologies such as cable modem service, digital subscriber line (DSL) service, and fiber optics. Broadband providers interconnect with backbone networks – “long haul fiber-optic links and high speed routers capable of transmitting vast amounts of data.” Edge providers, such as Netflix and Google, “provide content, services, and applications over the Internet.” To bring this all together, when an end user wishes to check last night’s baseball scores on ESPN.com, his computer sends a signal to his broadband provider, which in turn transmits it across the backbone to ESPN’s broadband provider, which transmit the signal to ESPN’s computer. Having received the scores into packets of information which travel back across ESPN’s broadband provider network to the backbone and then across the end user’s broadband provider network to the end user. In recent years, some edge providers, such as Netflix and Google, have begun connecting directly to broadband provider’s networks, thus avoiding the need to interconnect with the backbone, and some providers, such as Comcast and AT&T have begun developing their own backbone networks.
Net Neutrality & Open Internet Access. Net neutrality, also known as an open internet, is the principle that ISPs should not discriminate against lawful content and should, instead, treat all internet traffic the same regardless of source. Proponents of internet openness and net neutrality principles worry about the relationship between broadband providers and edge providers. These proponents generally express concerns that ISPs will limit, block, or degrade the quality of the content being transmitted to the end-user. Under net neutrality principles, ISPs cannot block, impair or degrade access, or create special “fast lanes” for the ISP’s preferred content. For example, net neutrality runs counter to an ISP blocking or slowing down traffic of TV shows streamed by a competitor video company over its broadband service as compared to TV shows from one of its own content companies.
Obama Administration 2015 Open Internet Order. In February 2015, the FCC adopted Open Internet rules which established three “bright-line” rules banning certain practices that the FCC considers to harm open access to the internet. The bright-line rules include:
- No Blocking: Broadband providers may not block access to legal content, applications, services, or non-harmful devices.
- No Throttling: Broadband providers may not impair or degrade lawful internet traffic on the basis of content, applications, services, or non-harmful devices.
- No Paid Prioritization: Broadband providers may not favor some lawful internet traffic over other lawful traffic in exchange for consideration of any kind.
In adopting the Open Internet Order, the FCC classified ISPs as “telecommunications service providers” subject to Title II of the Telecommunications Act of 1996, instead of “information service” under Title I, as they had historically been classified. The classification under Title II of the Telecommunications Act provides the FCC with authority to regulate the service as a common carrier, as they might with telephone service. However, when the FCC adopted the 2015 Open Internet rules it exercised its authority to forbear provisions of law, specifying that many provisions of Title II would not apply to broadband services, these included those related to rate regulation. The Order also included additional transparency requirements.
A Brief History: Classification of Broadband Service. ISPs have historically, mostly, been classified as “information services” and, therefore, subject to Title I of the Communications Act.
1996 Telecommunications Act. In enacting the 1996 Telecommunications Act, Congress borrowed heavily from the 1980 Computer II Order which distinguished between “basic services” and “enhanced services.” Basic services, such as telephone service, offered “pure transmission capability over a communication path that is virtually transparent in terms of its interaction with customer supplied information.” Enhanced services consisted of any offering over the telecommunications network which is more than a basic transmission service. The rules subjected basic services, but not enhanced services, to common carrier treatment under Title II of the Communications Act. The rules also recognized a third category of services, adjunct-to-basic services, such as speed-dialing, that facilitated use of basic services. The FCC treated them as basic because of their role in facilitating basic services.[1] Under the Telecommunications Act, “basic service” was now succeeded by “telecommunications service” as a common carrier regulated service and “enhanced service” was succeeded by “information service” not subject to common carrier Title II.
FCC Takes Varied Approaches. In subsequent years, the FCC took varied action on adjunct-to-basic service, in 1998 it classified a portion of DSL service as a telecommunications service and in 2002 the FCC classified cable modem service as solely an information service. The FCC’s classification of cable modem service as an information service was upheld by the Supreme Court in National Cable & Telecommunications Association v. Brand X Internet Services, 545 U.S. 967, 986 (2005). In that decision, the court stated the FCC would need to define what the word “offering” means in the definition of telecommunications service, whether the information service and telecommunications components are functionally equivalent or separate. The court, utilizing Chevron v. NRDC, deferred to the FCC to resolve the question based on the FCC’s investigation of the factual particulars of who the technology works.
Open Internet Principles. In the following years, the FCC generally spared broadband providers from Title II common carrier obligations. However, the FCC made clear it would seek to preserve principles of internet openness. These principles, embodied in the Internet Policy Statement, were incorporated as conditions by the FCC into several merger orders and a key 700MHz license, including the SBC/AT&T, Verizon/MCI, and Comcast/NBCU mergers where FCC approval of these transactions was expressly conditioned on compliance with the Internet Policy Statement. [Open Internet Order 2015, p. 20]
Comcast v. FCC. In 2007, customers accused Comcast of interfering with their ability to access certain content. The FCC took action against Comcast for violating the open internet polices. Comcast subsequently filed suit. The Circuit decision invalidated the FCC’s exercise of ancillary authority to provide consumers basic protections in using broadband internet services. The Court noted the FCC failed to tie its assertion of ancillary authority to any statutory mandated responsibility.
2010 Notice of Inquiry. Following the D.C. Circuit decision, the FCC initiated a Notice of Inquiry to seek comment on the framework for broadband internet service. The Notice of Inquiry recognized that the “current legal classification of broadband internet service is based on a record that was gathered a decade ago.” It sought comment on three separate alternative legal frameworks for classifying and regulating broadband internet service: (1) as an information service, (2) as a telecommunications service “to which all the requirements of Title II of the Communications Act would apply,” and (3) solely as to the “Internet connectivity service,” as a telecommunication service with forbearance from most Title II obligations.
2010 Open Internet Order. In December 2010, the FCC adopted the 2010 Open Internet Order, a codification of the policy principles contained in the Internet Policy Statement. The Order adopted three fundamental rules governing ISPs: (1) no blocking; (2) no unreasonable discrimination; and (3) transparency. The anti-discrimination rule operated on a case-by-case basis. The order did not entirely rule out the possibility of paid prioritization arrangements. However, it made clear that such pay for priority deals were likely to be problematic in a number of respects. The Order maintained BIAS under the classification of information service.
Verizon v. FCC. A 2014 U.S. Court of Appeals for the D.C. Circuit case vacating portions of the FCC Open Internet Order 2010 that the court determined could only be applied to common carriers. The court ruled that the FCC did not have the authority to impose the order in its entirety. Since the FCC had previously classified broadband providers under Title I of the Communications Act of 1934, the court ruled that the FCC had relinquished its right to regulate them like common carriers. Of the three orders that make up the FCC Open Internet Order 2010, two were vacated (no blocking and no unreasonable discrimination) and one was upheld (transparency). The case was largely viewed as a loss for network neutrality supporters and a victory for the cable broadband industry. However, the court sustained the FCC’s findings that “absent rules such as those set forth in the Open Internet Order, the broadband providers represent a threat to internet openness and could act in ways that would ultimately inhibit the speed and extent of the future broadband deployment.”
2015 Open Internet Order. Following the D.C. Circuit’s ruling, in May 2014, the FCC issued a Notice of Proposed Rulemaking (2014 Open Internet NPRM) to respond to the lack of conduct-based rules to protect and promote an open internet. The public submitted an unprecedented 3.7 million comments by the close of the reply comment period in September 2014. In February 2015, the FCC voted to adopt the 2015 Open Internet Order and reclassified ISPs as “common carriers” – much like other utilities – subject to Title II of the Telecommunications Act, but with forbearance of many common carrier requirements, including those related to tariffs and rate regulation. The 2015 Open Internet rules were challenged and upheld by the courts in United States Telecommunications v. FCC.
2016 Presidential Election. During the Presidential election campaign, then-candidate Donald Trump commented on his desire to do away with Obama-era net neutrality rules. As such, after the 2016 Presidential election, the tide quickly shifted on the issue of net neutrality and most experts believed the privacy rules adopted in late 2016, and the Open Internet Order, were vulnerable to a repeal by the Trump Presidential Administration. In March of 2017, the process for repealing the privacy rules began with the introduction of Senate Joint Resolution (SJR) 34 introduced by Senator Jeff Flake pursuant to the Congressional Review Act (CRA), which gives Congress an expedited means to review and overrule new federal regulations. The CRA also prohibits agencies from issuing a new rule substantially similar to the revoked one unless specifically authorized by Congress – which has highly significant implications for ongoing FCC authority in this area. By the end of March, SJR 34 had been passed, and on April 3, 2017 the measure was signed by President Trump – revoking the FCC ISP privacy rules and preventing the FCC from regulating further on the matter.
Restoring Internet Freedom Order. In May 2017, the FCC issued a notice of proposed rulemaking to repeal the 2015 Open Internet rules that classified ISPs under Title II and revert the classification of the service back to an “information service” under Title I of the Telecommunications Act. In December 2017, the FCC voted, in another partisan vote, on a framework to repeal the rules. The FCC argued for a “light-touch framework” for broadband service, support for FTC oversight of anti-trust and anti-competitive behavior instead of FCC common carrier regulation, and largely revert to the 2010 Open Internet transparency rules with some modifications.
Voted, ordered, but not, yet, taken effect. Just last week, on January 4th, the FCC issued the full order – 200+ pages. However, the new order is pending review by the Office of Management and Budget and pending final publishing of the order in the Federal Register at which time it would then officially take effect. The future legal obligations of ISPs remain in flux at the federal level as it is highly expected the courts will be asked to weigh-in on the merits of the order and assess whether the action meets the standard for agency review or whether the action is “capricious and arbitrary.” Already the New York state attorney general has filed a lawsuit challenging the integrity of the public comment process. There have been news reports and statements by FCC Commissioners that the public comment system may have been compromised. More lawsuits are expected once the order takes official effect, including potential challenges to the preemption provisions. Perhaps less likely, although possible, is a Congressional repeal of the new order via the Congressional Review Act that authorizes Congress to overrule actions taken by federal agencies by a simple majority in the Senate and House within 60 legislative days of the order going into effect.
The Net Neutrality Debate. Proponents of net neutrality argue that the FCC needs to reclassify ISPs as common carriers (e.g. a private company that is required to sell their services to everyone under the same terms) under Title II of the Act in order to prevent anticompetitive behaviors. As noted above, previous court cases have limited the FCC’s regulation of the issues related to unfair blocking and discrimination when the internet service has been classified under Title I as an “information service.” The lack of success in those court cases promulgated the FCC to reclassify the service under Title II as a telecommunications service. Opponents of the FCC’s decision argue that although they are not opposed to the general principles of net neutrality, they believe the FTC already has the authority to prevent anticompetitive business practices and that Title II is an archaic provision created to regulate telecommunications services long before the internet existed. Opponents of the Open Internet rules also argue that regulating ISPs under Title II would have the opposite effect of impeding innovation and investment. Those against a Title II classification, including the current majority of the FCC, argue for a “light-touch regulatory framework.”
Not likely to be resolved. This bill proposes to adopt the net neutrality rules for California intrastate internet traffic. The language of this bill largely reflects the rules adopted in the 2015 Open Internet Order concerning no blocking, no throttling, and no paid prioritization, as well as, conduct rules, which were repealed by the Trump FCC in December. Under the Order that was just issued, the FCC states they “preempt any state or local measures that would effectively impose rules or requirements that we have repealed or decided to refrain from imposing in this order.” As such, the success of implementing this bill is largely hinged on the new order being repealed or rejected, in whole or in part. Considering the high likelihood that the courts will be asked to weigh in, it seems within the realm of possibilities that the new order may not withstand a court challenge. However, the issue is not resolved prior to this committee hearing this bill.
CPUC: Spread too thin? This bill proposes to have the CPUC adopt rules by July 1, 2018 that include new responsibilities for the agency. As this committee knows, in recent years there have been questions raised concerning whether the CPUC is spread too thin and handling too many varied areas. Just last year, the legislature passed SB 19 (Hill, 2017) which removed some of the transportation-related functions away from the CPUC to other agencies. This bill would expand to the CPUC’s existing responsibilities. While it is not immediately clear whether it is feasible for the CPUC to take on these responsibilities, in terms of staff and resources, the responsibilities are potentially consistent with the CPUC’s role in regulating utility-style services. While existing statute, Public Utilities Code §710, prohibits the CPUC from exercising regulatory jurisdiction or control over Internet Protocol-enabled services, it only does so in so far as not directed by federal or state statute. Therefore, the Legislature retains the opportunity to pass statute to direct the CPUC in this space, granted such statutes are able to withstand any legal challenges, particularly those regarding federal preemption.
Patchwork of regulation. One of the criticisms of this bill by the opponents is that this bill would create a patchwork of regulation that could stymie the marketplace since California would have rules that are different from other states and the federal government. Due to the nature of the internet traffic traveling across state lines, it would be ideal to have one rule to address the issue of net neutrality. However, the FCC’s vote in December has resulted in other states also proposing action to institute their own net neutrality rules, including Washington State. In this case, California may not be alone in adopting its own net neutrality rules.
Feasibility. This bill requires a uniform and customer-accessible internet speed test. Currently, the CPUC utilizes CalSpeed testing at nearly 2000 points in the state to test mobile broadband internet speeds. Conceivably, this test might satisfy the requirements of this bill for one uniform test. However, the CPUC would need to ensure the test can be utilized for fixed broadband service and ensure the integrity of the test can not be manipulated by providers. This bill also requires the CPUC to adopt rules to ensure that public purpose program funding is expended in a manner that will maximize internet neutrality and ensure the fair distribution of services to low-income individuals and communities. Many of these programs already include criteria directing funding to low-income individuals and communities, such as the Lifeline Program and California Advanced Services Fund. This bill’s efforts to leverage these funds in order to incentivize ISPs to commit to net neutrality rules seems very reasonable and an important leveraging opportunity for the state.
Amendments needed. In order to maintain consistency with the Open Internet Order, the bill needs some clarifying amendments, including some related to reasonable network management. Additionally, in order to establish a more realistic timeline for CPUC action, the deadline by which the CPUC would adopt the rules required by this bill should be moved to no earlier than December 31, 2018.
- Replace “customer” with “end-user” throughout as noted in the original FCC rules.
- Add language from FCC rules related to Reasonable Network Management (FCC Open Internet Rule Section 8.2 Definitions (f)).
- Add the exception provided in the FCC rules to authorize the CPUC to waive the ban on paid prioritization “only if the petitioner demonstrates that the practice would provide some significant public interest benefit and would not harm the open nature of the Internet.” (FCC Open Internet Rules Section 8.9 No paid prioritization (c)) - Add to SB 460. Section 5982 (c).
- Add “Reasonable network management shall not be considered a violation of this rule.” Per FCC Open Internet Rules Section 8.11. Add to SB 460 Section 5982 (d)
- Move the date from July 1, 2018 to December 31, 2018.
- Technical clean-up replacing “network” with “internet” in the urgency section and other technical clean-up
Prior/Related Legislation
SB 822 (Wiener, 2018) the bill would state the intent of the Legislature to enact legislation to effectuate net neutrality in California utilizing the state’s regulatory powers and to prevent ISPs from engaging in practices inconsistent with net neutrality, including through four specified means. The bill was introduced on January 4, 2018 and is awaiting referral.
AJR 7 (Mullin, Chapter 151, Statutes of 2017) urged the President of the United States and Members of the United States Congress to protect specified broadband communications-related policies and rules, including: net neutrality and open internet access, however, with no reference to Title II regulation. The resolution also calls on the President to support the Federal Lifeline Program that provides discounted telephone service for qualifying low-income consumers, and the E-Rate program’s discounted telecommunication and internet access services for schools and libraries.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: Fiscal Com.: Local:
SUPPORT:
ADT Security Services
The Greenlining Institute
The Utility Reform Network
OPPOSITION:
AT&T
Black Business Association
California Cable & Telecommunications Association
California Chamber of Commerce
California Manufacturers & Technology Association
Central City Association of Los Angeles
Consolidated Communications
CTIA
Greater Los Angeles African American Chamber of Commerce
Frontier Communications
Sprint
T Mobile
TechNet
Tracfone
Valley Industry & Commerce Association
Verizon
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: The author states:
We cannot allow the profits and political interests of internet service providers to outweigh the public interest in a free and open internet – it’s too important to our economy and our way of life. And if the Trump Administration won’t protect consumers, the State of California will. SB 460 will prevent ISP’s from using deceptive, discriminatory or anti-competitive business practices. It preserves the heart of the FCC’s net neutrality rules and prohibits ISP’s from blocking, throttling, and paid prioritization. And it gives consumers greater transparency about the services we all depend on in everyday life. Net Neutrality is just common sense. It’s good for consumers and protects a level playing field for internet companies.
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION: Opponents generally express concerns that this bill would result in a patchwork of state regulations that will stymie innovation. Many express concerns about the appropriateness of placing the responsibility to implement this bill on the CPUC. Many of the opponents also express concerns that this bill is inconsistent with the federal regulatory framework governing ISPs, is federally preempted, and will likely result in costly litigation.
ISPs, including CCTA, AT&T, Frontier Communications, generally express support for net neutrality principles, but share the concerns stated above and, therefore, oppose the bill. Additionally, CCTA states that “ISPs are required to keep consumers clearly informed of their open internet practices and will be held accountable for any harmful conduct.” Some of the opponents state their concerns that the bill is being rushed through the legislative process.
-- END --
United States Telecom Association v. FCC, 825 F.3d 674 (D.C. Cir. 2016) reh’g denied, 855 F.3d 381 ↑
Discussed in Hearing
Assembly Floor
Assembly Standing Committee on Appropriations
Assembly Standing Committee on Privacy and Consumer Protection
Assembly Standing Committee on Communications and Conveyance
Senate Floor
Senate Standing Committee on Judiciary
Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations
Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):