SB 472: Public postsecondary education: Campus Free Expression Act.
- Session Year: 2017-2018
- House: Senate
- Latest Version Date: 2017-05-03
(1)Under existing law, the 3 segments of public postsecondary education in this state are the University of California, under the administration of the Regents of the University of California, the California State University, under the administration of the Trustees of the California State University, and the California Community Colleges, under the administration of the Board of Governors of the California Community Colleges. Existing law, known as the Donahoe Higher Education Act, sets forth, among other things, the missions and functions of these 3 public postsecondary educational segments. No provision of the Donahoe Higher Education Act is applicable to the University of California except to the extent that the regents act, by appropriate resolution, to make that provision applicable.
Existing law prohibits the Regents of the University of California, the Trustees of the California State University, and the governing board of a community college district from making or enforcing a rule subjecting a student to disciplinary sanction solely on the basis of conduct that is speech or other communication that is protected by specified provisions of the United States Constitution and the California Constitution.
This bill would enact the Campus Free Expression Act. The bill would declare that the outdoor areas of public postsecondary institutions are traditional public forums. The bill would provide that a public postsecondary institution may maintain and enforce reasonable time, place, and manner restrictions only when those restrictions are narrowly tailored in service of a significant institutional interest, employ clear, published, content-neutral content-neutral, and viewpoint-neutral criteria, and provide for ample alternative means of expression. The bill would require these restrictions to allow for members of the campus community to spontaneously and contemporaneously distribute literature and assemble. The bill would further require that a person who wishes to engage in expressive activity on the campus of a public postsecondary institution be permitted to do so freely, as long as that persons conduct is not unlawful and does not materially and substantially disrupt the functioning of the institution.
TheThis bill would authorize the Attorney General and a person whose right to engage in expressive activity was infringed through a violation of these provisions to bring an action in a court of competent jurisdiction within one year after the date that a cause of action accrues, as specified. The bill would require a court that finds a violation of these provisions to award aggrieved persons damages of no less than $500 for an initial violation, plus $50 for each day the violation remains ongoing, which shall accrue starting on the day after the complaint is served on the institution. The bill would set the maximum damages that an aggrieved person, or set of aggrieved persons, may receive in a case or cases stemming from a single controversy at $250,000. $5,000.
To the extent that this bill would impose new duties on community college districts for implementation of its provisions, the bill would constitute a state-mandated local program.
(2)The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.
This bill would provide that, if the Commission on State Mandates determines that the bill contains costs mandated by the state, reimbursement for those costs shall be made pursuant to the statutory provisions noted above.
(1)Under existing law, the 3 segments of public postsecondary education in this state are the University of California, under the administration of the Regents of the University of California, the California State University, under the administration of the Trustees of the California State University, and the California Community Colleges, under the administration of the Board of Governors of the California Community Colleges. Existing law, known as the Donahoe Higher Education Act, sets forth, among other things, the missions and functions of these 3 public postsecondary educational segments. No provision of the Donahoe Higher Education Act is applicable to the University of California except to the extent that the regents act, by appropriate resolution, to make that provision applicable.
Existing law prohibits the Regents of the University of California, the Trustees of the California State University, and the governing board of a community college district from making or enforcing a rule subjecting a student to disciplinary sanction solely on the basis of conduct that is speech or other communication that is protected by specified provisions of the United States Constitution and the California Constitution.
This bill would enact the Campus Free Expression Act. The bill would declare that the outdoor areas of public postsecondary institutions are traditional public forums. The bill would provide that a public postsecondary institution may maintain and enforce reasonable time, place, and manner restrictions only when those restrictions are narrowly tailored in service of a significant institutional interest only when those restrictions interest, employ clear, published, content-neutral and viewpoint-neutral criteria, and provide for ample alternative means of expression. The bill would require these restrictions to allow for members of the campus community to spontaneously and contemporaneously distribute literature and assemble. The bill would further require that a person who wishes to engage in expressive activity on the campus of a public postsecondary institution be permitted to do so freely, as long as that persons conduct is not unlawful and does not materially and substantially disrupt the functioning of the institution.
The bill would authorize the Attorney General and a person whose right to engage in expressive activity was infringed through a violation of these provisions to bring an action in a court of competent jurisdiction within one year after the date that a cause of action accrues, as specified. The bill would require a court that finds a violation of these provisions to award aggrieved persons damages of no less than $500 for an initial violation, plus $50 for each day the violation remains ongoing. ongoing, which shall accrue starting on the day after the complaint is served on the institution. The bill would set the maximum damages that an aggrieved person, or set of aggrieved persons, may receive in a case or cases stemming from a single controversy at $250,000.
To the extent that this bill would impose new duties on community college districts for implementation of its provisions, the bill would constitute a state-mandated local program.
(2)The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.
This bill would provide that, if the Commission on State Mandates determines that the bill contains costs mandated by the state, reimbursement for those costs shall be made pursuant to the statutory provisions noted above.
(1)Under existing law, the 3 segments of public postsecondary education in this state are the University of California, under the administration of the Regents of the University of California, the California State University, under the administration of the Trustees of the California State University, and the California Community Colleges, under the administration of the Board of Governors of the California Community Colleges. Existing law, known as the Donahoe Higher Education Act, sets forth, among other things, the missions and functions of these 3 public postsecondary educational segments. No provision of the Donahoe Higher Education Act is applicable to the University of California except to the extent that the regents act, by appropriate resolution, to make that provision applicable.
Existing law prohibits the Regents of the University of California, the Trustees of the California State University, and the governing board of a community college district from making or enforcing a rule subjecting a student to disciplinary sanction solely on the basis of conduct that is speech or other communication that is protected by specified provisions of the United States Constitution and the California Constitution.
This bill would enact the Campus Free Expression Act. The bill would declare that the outdoor areas of public postsecondary institutions are traditional public forums. The bill would provide that a public postsecondary institution may maintain and enforce reasonable time, place, and manner restrictions in service of a significant institutional interest only when those restrictions employ clear, published, content-neutral and viewpoint-neutral criteria, and provide for ample alternative means of expression. The bill would require these restrictions to allow for members of the campus community to spontaneously and contemporaneously assemble. The bill would further require that a person who wishes to engage in expressive activity on the campus of a public postsecondary institution be permitted to do so freely, as long as that persons conduct is not unlawful and does not materially and substantially disrupt the functioning of the institution.
The bill would authorize the Attorney General and a person whose right to engage in expressive activity was infringed through a violation of these provisions to bring an action in a court of competent jurisdiction within one year after the date that a cause of action accrues, as specified. The bill would require a court that finds a violation of these provisions to award aggrieved persons damages of no less than $500 for an initial violation, plus $50 for each day the violation remains ongoing.
To the extent that this bill would impose new duties on community college districts for implementation of its provisions, the bill would constitute a state-mandated local program.
(2)The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.
This bill would provide that, if the Commission on State Mandates determines that the bill contains costs mandated by the state, reimbursement for those costs shall be made pursuant to the statutory provisions noted above.
Existing law establishes the California State University, the California Community Colleges, and the University of California as the 3 segments of public postsecondary education in this state.This bill would express the intent of the Legislature to enact legislation discouraging the restriction of freedom of speech, freedom of assembly, and other rights protected under the First Amendment to the United States Constitution at public colleges and universities.Existing law establishes the California State University, the California Community Colleges, and the University of California as the 3 segments of public postsecondary education in this state.
This bill would express the intent of the Legislature to enact legislation discouraging the restriction of freedom of speech, freedom of assembly, and other rights protected under the First Amendment to the United States Constitution at public colleges and universities.
(a)This chapter shall be known, and may be cited, as the Campus Free Expression Act.
(b)The First Amendment to the United States Constitution and Sections 2 and 3 of Article I of the California Constitution protect expressive activities, including, but not limited to, all forms of peaceful assembly, protests, speeches, distribution of literature, carrying of signs, and circulation of petitions.
(c)As used in this chapter, public postsecondary institution means a campus of the University of California, the California State University, or the California Community Colleges.
66321.(a)The outdoor areas of public postsecondary institutions are traditional public forums. A public postsecondary institution may maintain and enforce reasonable time, place, and manner restrictions only when those restrictions are narrowly tailored in service of a significant institutional interest, employ clear, published, content-neutral content-neutral, and viewpoint-neutral criteria, and provide for ample alternative means of expression. These restrictions shall allow for members of the campus community to spontaneously and contemporaneously distribute literature and assemble.
(b)A person who wishes to engage in expressive activity on the campus of a public postsecondary institution shall be permitted to do so freely, as long as that persons conduct is not unlawful and does not materially and substantially disrupt the functioning of the institution.
(c)Nothing in this chapter shall be interpreted as doing any of the following:
(1)Altering the protections for expressive activity provided by the First Amendment to the United States Constitution and Sections 2 and 3 of Article I of the California Constitution.
(2)Limiting the right of student expression in other areas of public postsecondary institutions.
(3)Granting any person the right to materially disrupt scheduled or reserved activities in a portion or section of the campus at the scheduled time.
66322.(a)Either of the following persons may bring an action in a court of competent jurisdiction, in accordance with the limitation set forth in Section 66323, to enjoin a violation of this chapter, or to recover compensatory damages, court costs, and reasonable attorneys fees, or all of these:
(1)The Attorney General.
(2)A person whose right to engage in expressive activity was infringed through a violation of this chapter.
(b)In an action brought pursuant to subdivision (a), if the court finds a violation of this chapter, the court shall award an aggrieved person damages of no less than five hundred dollars ($500) for the initial violation, plus fifty dollars ($50) for each day the violation remains ongoing, which shall accrue starting on the day after the complaint is served on the institution. The total damages, excluding court costs and attorneys fees, available to a plaintiff, or multiple plaintiffs, in a case or cases stemming from a single controversy shall not exceed two hundred fifty five thousand dollars ($250,000) ($5,000) in total. If the court that finds a violation of this chapter has harmed multiple plaintiffs, the court shall divide damages, which shall not exceed two hundred fifty five thousand dollars ($250,000) ($5,000) in total, equally among those plaintiffs.
(c)A violation of this chapter is established by the Attorney General or a person described in paragraph (2) of subdivision (a) demonstrating in an action brought in a court of competent jurisdiction either of the following:
(1)That a public postsecondary educational institution has a policy that does not conform with the requirements of this chapter.
(2)That a public postsecondary educational institution, by an act or actions of one of its employees, administrators, or any person contracted to perform a service at the institution or by the enforcement of an institutional policy, violated the requirements of this chapter.
66323.(a)A person shall bring an action alleging a violation of this chapter no later than one year after the date the cause of action accrues.
(b)For purposes of calculating the one-year limitation period imposed by subdivision (a), each day that a violation of this chapter persists, and each day that a policy that violates this chapter remains in effect, constitutes a new violation of this chapter and is, therefore, a new day on which a cause of action has accrued.
SEC. 2.If the Commission on State Mandates determines that this act contains costs mandated by the state, reimbursement to local agencies and school districts for those costs shall be made pursuant to Part 7 (commencing with Section 17500) of Division 4 of Title 2 of the Government Code.
(a)This chapter shall be known, and may be cited, as the Campus Free Expression Act.
(b)The First Amendment to the United States Constitution and Sections 2 and 3 of Article I of the California Constitution protect expressive activities, including, but not limited to, all forms of peaceful assembly, protests, speeches, distribution of literature, carrying of signs, and circulation of petitions.
(c)As used in this chapter, public postsecondary institution means a campus of the University of California, the California State University, or the California Community Colleges.
66321.(a)The outdoor areas of public postsecondary institutions are traditional public forums. A public postsecondary institution may maintain and enforce reasonable time, place, and manner restrictions only when those restrictions are narrowly tailored in service of a significant institutional interest only when those restrictions interest, employ clear, published, content-neutral and viewpoint-neutral criteria, and provide for ample alternative means of expression. These restrictions shall allow for members of the campus community to spontaneously and contemporaneously distribute literature and assemble.
(b)A person who wishes to engage in expressive activity on the campus of a public postsecondary institution shall be permitted to do so freely, as long as that persons conduct is not unlawful and does not materially and substantially disrupt the functioning of the institution.
(c)Nothing in this chapter shall be interpreted as limiting the right of student expression in other areas of public postsecondary institutions. as doing any of the following:
(d)Nothing in this chapter shall be interpreted to alter(1)Altering the protections for expressive activity provided by the First Amendment to the United States Constitution and Sections 2 and 3 of Article I of the California Constitution.
(2)Limiting the right of student expression in other areas of public postsecondary institutions.
(3)Granting any person the right to materially disrupt scheduled or reserved activities in a portion or section of the campus at the scheduled time.
66322.(a)Either of the following persons may bring an action in a court of competent jurisdiction, in accordance with the limitation set forth in Section 66323, to enjoin a violation of this chapter, or to recover compensatory damages, court costs, and reasonable attorneys fees, or all of these:
(1)The Attorney General.
(2)A person whose right to engage in expressive activity was infringed through a violation of this chapter.
(b)In an action brought pursuant to subdivision (a), if the court finds a violation of this chapter, the court shall award an aggrieved person damages of no less than five hundred dollars ($500) for the initial violation, plus fifty dollars ($50) for each day the violation remains ongoing. ongoing, which shall accrue starting on the day after the complaint is served on the institution. The total damages, excluding court costs and attorneys fees, available to a plaintiff, or multiple plaintiffs, in a case or cases stemming from a single controversy shall not exceed two hundred fifty thousand dollars ($250,000) in total. If the court that finds a violation of this chapter has harmed multiple plaintiffs, the court shall divide damages, which shall not exceed two hundred fifty thousand dollars ($250,000) in total, equally among those plaintiffs.
(c)A violation of this chapter is established by the Attorney General or a person described in paragraph (2) of subdivision (a) demonstrating in an action brought in a court of competent jurisdiction either of the following:
(1)That a public postsecondary educational institution has a policy that does not conform with the requirements of this chapter.
(2)That a public postsecondary educational institution, by an act or actions of one of its employees, administrators, or any person contracted to perform a service at the institution or by the enforcement of an institutional policy, violated the requirements of this chapter.
66323.(a)A person shall bring an action alleging a violation of this chapter no later than one year after the date the cause of action accrues.
(b)For purposes of calculating the one-year limitation period imposed by subdivision (a), each day that a violation of this chapter persists, and each day that a policy that violates this chapter remains in effect, constitutes a new violation of this chapter and is, therefore, a new day on which a cause of action has accrued.
SEC. 2.If the Commission on State Mandates determines that this act contains costs mandated by the state, reimbursement to local agencies and school districts for those costs shall be made pursuant to Part 7 (commencing with Section 17500) of Division 4 of Title 2 of the Government Code.
(a)This chapter shall be known, and may be cited, as the Campus Free Expression Act.
(b)The First Amendment to the United States Constitution and Sections 2 and 3 of Article I of the California Constitution protect expressive activities, including, but not limited to, all forms of peaceful assembly, protests, speeches, distribution of literature, carrying of signs, and circulation of petitions.
(c)As used in this chapter, public postsecondary institution means a campus of the University of California, the California State University, or the California Community Colleges.
66321.(a)The outdoor areas of public postsecondary institutions are traditional public forums. A public postsecondary institution may maintain and enforce reasonable time, place, and manner restrictions in service of a significant institutional interest only when those restrictions employ clear, published, content-neutral and viewpoint-neutral criteria, and provide for ample alternative means of expression. These restrictions shall allow for members of the campus community to spontaneously and contemporaneously assemble.
(b)A person who wishes to engage in expressive activity on the campus of a public postsecondary institution shall be permitted to do so freely, as long as that persons conduct is not unlawful and does not materially and substantially disrupt the functioning of the institution.
(c)Nothing in this chapter shall be interpreted as limiting the right of student expression in other areas of public postsecondary institutions.
(d)Nothing in this chapter shall be interpreted to alter the protections for expressive activity provided by the First Amendment to the United States Constitution and Sections 2 and 3 of Article I of the California Constitution.
66322.(a)Either of the following persons may bring an action in a court of competent jurisdiction, in accordance with the limitation set forth in Section 66323, to enjoin a violation of this chapter, or to recover compensatory damages, court costs, and reasonable attorneys fees, or all of these:
(1)The Attorney General.
(2)A person whose right to engage in expressive activity was infringed through a violation of this chapter.
(b)In an action brought pursuant to subdivision (a), if the court finds a violation of this chapter, the court shall award an aggrieved person damages of no less than five hundred dollars ($500) for the initial violation, plus fifty dollars ($50) for each day the violation remains ongoing.
66323.(a)A person shall bring an action alleging a violation of this chapter no later than one year after the date the cause of action accrues.
(b)For purposes of calculating the one-year limitation period imposed by subdivision (a), each day that a violation of this chapter persists, and each day that a policy that violates this chapter remains in effect, constitutes a new violation of this chapter and is, therefore, a new day on which a cause of action has accrued.
SEC. 2.If the Commission on State Mandates determines that this act contains costs mandated by the state, reimbursement to local agencies and school districts for those costs shall be made pursuant to Part 7 (commencing with Section 17500) of Division 4 of Title 2 of the Government Code.
SECTION 1.It is the intent of the Legislature to enact legislation discouraging the restriction of freedom of speech, freedom of assembly, and other rights protected under the First Amendment to the United States Constitution at public colleges and universities.It is the intent of the Legislature to enact legislation discouraging the restriction of freedom of speech, freedom of assembly, and other rights protected under the First Amendment to the United States Constitution at public colleges and universities.
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Feb 1, 2018 | Returned to Secretary of Senate pursuant to Joint Rule 56. |
| May 25, 2017 | May 25 hearing: Held in committee and under submission. |
| May 19, 2017 | Set for hearing May 25. |
| May 15, 2017 | May 15 hearing: Placed on APPR. suspense file. |
| May 5, 2017 | Set for hearing May 15. |
| May 3, 2017 | Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| May 2, 2017 | From committee: Do pass as amended and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 7. Noes 0. Page 852.) (April 25). |
| Apr 21, 2017 | Set for hearing April 25. |
| Apr 20, 2017 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on JUD. (Ayes 7. Noes 0. Page 783.) (April 19). Re-referred to Com. on JUD. |
| Apr 7, 2017 | Set for hearing April 19. |
| Apr 6, 2017 | From committee with author's amendments. Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on ED. |
| Apr 5, 2017 | Re-referred to Coms. on ED. and JUD. |
| Mar 28, 2017 | From committee with author's amendments. Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on RLS. |
| Mar 2, 2017 | Referred to Com. on RLS. |
| Feb 17, 2017 | From printer. May be acted upon on or after March 19. |
| Feb 16, 2017 | Introduced. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| May 15, 2017 | Placed on suspense file | Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Apr 25, 2017 | Do pass as amended, but first amend, and re-refer to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Senate Standing Committee on Judiciary |
Passed |
|
| Apr 19, 2017 | Do pass, but first be re-referred to the Committee on [Judiciary] | Senate Standing Committee on Education |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
SENATE COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Senator Ricardo Lara, Chair
2017 - 2018 Regular Session
SB 472 (Nielsen) - Public postsecondary education: Campus Free Expression Act
Version: May 3, 2017 | Policy Vote: ED. 7 - 0, JUD. 7 - 0 |
Urgency: No | Mandate: Yes |
Hearing Date: May 15, 2017 | Consultant: Lenin Del Castillo |
This bill meets the criteria for referral to the Suspense File.
Bill Summary:
This bill requires a person who wishes to engage in expressive activity on the campus of a public postsecondary institution to be permitted to do so freely, as long as that person’s conduct is not unlawful and does not materially and substantially disrupt the functioning of the institution.
Fiscal Impact:
- The exact costs for the institutions to comply with this measure are unknown, but the UC estimates that its systemwide implementation costs could be in the millions of dollars annually.
- Unknown General Fund costs, potentially in the low hundreds of thousands of dollars per year, for the Attorney General to bring legal action against public postsecondary institutions that violate the bill's provisions.
Background:
Existing law prohibits the Regents of the University of California, the Trustees of the California State University, the governing board of a community college district, and an administrator of any campus of those institutions, from making or enforcing a rule subjecting a student to disciplinary sanction solely on the basis of conduct that is speech or other communication that, when engaged in outside a campus of those institutions, is protected from governmental restriction.
These institutions are not prohibited from adopting rules and regulations that are designed to prevent hate violence from being directed at students in a manner that denies them their full participation in the educational process, if the rules and regulations conform to standards established by the First Amendment to the United States Constitution and Section 2 of Article I of the California Constitution for citizens generally.
Further, existing law requires the governing board of a community college district to adopt rules and regulations relating to the exercise of free expression by students upon the premises of each community college maintained by the district, which shall include reasonable provisions for the time, place, and manner of conducting such activities. Existing law provides that such rules and regulations shall not prohibit the right of students to exercise free expression, except that expression which is obscene, libelous or slanderous according to current legal standards, or which so incites students as to create a clear and present danger of the commission of unlawful acts on community college premises, or the violation of lawful community college regulations, or the substantial disruption of the orderly operation of the community college, shall be prohibited.
Students are authorized to commence a civil action to obtain appropriate injunctive and declaratory relief as determined by the court. Upon a motion, a court may award attorney’s fees to a prevailing plaintiff in a civil action pursuant to this section.
Proposed Law:
This bill requires a person who wishes to engage in expressive activity on the campus of a public postsecondary institution to be permitted to do so freely, as long as that person’s conduct is not unlawful and does not materially and substantially disrupt the functioning of the institution.
Further, the bill provides that outdoor areas of public postsecondary institutions are traditional public forums.
This bill authorizes a public postsecondary institution to maintain and enforce reasonable time, place, and manner restrictions only when those restrictions are narrowly tailored in service of a significant institutional interest, employ clear, published, content-neutral, and viewpoint-neutral criteria, and provide for ample alternative means of expression. This bill requires these restrictions to allow for members of the campus community to spontaneously and contemporaneously distribute literature and assemble.
This bill also authorizes either of the following people to bring an action in a court of competent jurisdiction to enjoin a violation of this bill, or to recover compensatory damages, court costs, and reasonable attorney’s fees, or all of these: the Attorney General or a person whose right to engage in expressive activity was infringed through a violation of this bill.
This bill requires the court, if the court finds a violation of this bill, to award an aggrieved person damages of no less than $500 for the initial violation, plus $50 for each day the violation remains ongoing which is to accrue starting on the day after the complaint is served on the institution. This bill prohibits the total damages, excluding court costs and attorney’s fees, available to a plaintiff, or multiple plaintiffs, in a case or cases stemming from a single controversy from exceeding $5,000 in total. This bill requires the court, if the court that finds a violation of this bill has harmed multiple plaintiffs, to divide damages, which shall not exceed $5,000 in total, equally among those plaintiffs.
The bill provides that a violation of this bill is established by a person, as specified, demonstrating in an action brought in a court of competent jurisdiction either of the following: that a public postsecondary educational institution has a policy that does not conform with the requirements of this bill; or that a public postsecondary educational institution, by an act or actions of one of its employees, administrators, or any person contracted to perform a service at the institution or by the enforcement of an institutional policy, violated the requirements of this bill.
This bill limits a person’s ability to bring an action alleging a violation of this bill to no later than one year after the date the cause of action accrues. This bill provides that each day that a violation persists, and each day that a policy that violates this bill remains in effect, constitutes a new violation of this bill and is, therefore, a new day on which a cause of action has accrued.
Further, it provides that nothing in this bill is to be interpreted as doing any of the following: altering the protections for expressive activity provided by the First Amendment, limiting the right of student expression in other areas of public postsecondary institutions, or granting any person the right to materially disrupt scheduled or reserved activities in a portion or section of the campus at the scheduled time.
Related Legislation:
ACR 21 (Kiley) urges all private and public universities in California, to the extent that they do not already have free speech statements consistent with the principles articulated by the Chancellor of the University of California at Irvine, or the Free Speech Statement formally adopted by the University of Chicago, to consider such statements as a model for developing similar free speech statements. ACR 21 is pending on the Assembly Floor.
Staff Comments:
Currently, freedom of speech on public postsecondary educational institutions is allowed within the confines of codes of conduct and time, place and manner restrictions. Postsecondary educational institutions maintain time, place, and manner restrictions to ensure safety, security, and order. This bill requires a person who wishes to engage in expressive activity on the campus of a public postsecondary institution to be permitted to do so freely, as long as that person’s conduct is not unlawful and does not materially and substantially disrupt the functioning of the institution. Additionally, the bill authorizes a public postsecondary institution to maintain and enforce reasonable time, place, and manner restrictions only when those restrictions are narrowly tailored in service of a significant institutional interest, employ clear, published, content-neutral, and viewpoint-neutral criteria, and provide for ample alternative means of expression.
The bill essentially eliminates the ability of postsecondary educational institutions to limit free speech activities to “free speech zones” and prohibit free speech activities in “safe spaces” unless the conduct is unlawful or disrupts the functioning of the institution. To comply with this measure, the institutions would likely need to revise their campus policies and procedures and train staff accordingly. There could also be an increase in law enforcement activity to the extent that the institutions are currently employing more stringent restrictions and the bill leads to more expressive demonstrations requiring the attention of campus law enforcement. Further, there could be an increase in legal costs for the institutions to defend themselves against possible legal action taken against the institutions for violations. The exact costs for the institutions are unknown, but the UC estimates that systemwide implementation costs could be in the millions of dollars annually.
The bill’s authorization of the Attorney General or a person whose rights were infringed to sue for compensatory damages, court costs, and reasonable attorneys’ fees could result in additional General Fund costs, potentially in the low hundreds of thousands of dollars per year, for the Attorney General to bring legal action against public postsecondary institutions that violate the bill's provisions.
-- END --
Senator Hannah-Beth Jackson, Chair
2017-2018 Regular Session
Bill No: SB 472 (Author:Nielsen)
Version: April 6, 2017
Hearing Date: April 25, 2017
Fiscal: Yes
Urgency: No
Consultant: TSG
SUBJECT
Public postsecondary education: Campus Free Expression Act
DESCRIPTION
This bill, which would be known as the Campus Free Expression Act, would declare that the outdoor areas of the Universities of California, the California State Universities, and California Community Colleges are traditional public forums for the purposes of First Amendment law. In those outdoor areas, California’s public postsecondary institutions would only be able to make and enforce reasonable restrictions related to the time, place, and manner of speech, and any such restriction would have to be narrowly tailored to serve a significant institutional interest. In addition, such restrictions would have to be content neutral and viewpoint neutral. Finally, any restrictions on campus speech would have to allow for ample alternative means of expression and for the ability of campus community members to spontaneously and contemporaneously distribute literature and assemble.
To help enforce compliance with its mandate, this bill would create a corresponding civil right of action with a one year statute of limitations. The Attorney General and the person whose right to engage in free expression on campus is infringed by a violation of this bill’s provisions would be able to file a lawsuit seeking injunctive relief, compensatory damages, court costs, reasonable attorney’s fees and liquidated damages of at least $500, plus $50 for each day the violation continues. The total damages available to a plaintiff or multiple plaintiffs, excluding court costs and attorney’s fees, would be $5,000.
[NOTE: This analysis reflects amendments to be accepted in Committee. See Comment 8, below for details on the amendments.]
BACKGROUND
The intellectual and academic purpose of public colleges and universities, together with the open, publicly accessible nature of their physical layouts suggest that public colleges and universities are traditional or designated public forums. If that is the case, then the institutions may only impose time, place, and manner restrictions on campus speech, and only so long as the restrictions are narrowly tailored to serve a clear government interest, the restrictions are content and viewpoint neutral, and they provide for an ample alternative means of expression. (Perry Education Association v. Perry Local Educators’ Association (1983) 460 U.S. 37, 44.)
Despite this, several colleges and universities around the country confine expressive activity, such as leafleting, making speeches, and protests, to “free speech zones” on campus. In these limited, sometimes rather small locations on the campus, people can engage in expressive activities. Anyone engaging in expressive activities outside of these zones violates the policy. Some colleges and universities also require people to get advance permits for expressive activities. In some cases both restrictions apply: free expression is only permitted within the “free speech zones” and only after obtaining prior authorization. The colleges and universities that employ these policies justify them by asserting either that they are permissible time, place, and manner restrictions on speech or that the campus is not a public forum.
The sponsors of this bill have made a practice of challenging such college and university policies on the grounds that they violate the First Amendment. According to the sponsors, these arguments have met with quite a bit of success. Either through settlement or loss in court, the sponsors have forced a number of these colleges and universities to change their policies, removing requirements that students obtain advance approval for demonstrations, leafleting or other expressive activities and eliminating rules that confine these expressive activities to “free speech zones.”
This bill would codify the viewpoint that the outdoor areas of California’s public colleges and universities are traditional public forums. As such, they would be open to all forms of free speech, subject only to reasonable content and viewpoint limitations on the time, place, and manner of that speech that are narrowly tailored to serve significant institutional interests. The outdoor areas would also have to available for spontaneous and contemporaneous assembly and the distribution of literature. Additionally, the bill provides that any person wishing to engage in expressive activity on the campus of a public postsecondary institution must be permitted to do so freely, so long as that person’s conduct is not unlawful and does not substantially disrupt the function of the school. To help ensure compliance, this bill would also create a private right of action to enforce its terms, including a provision for liquidated damages.
CHANGES TO EXISTING LAW
Existing law provides that “Congress shall make no law… abridging the freedom of speech...” (U.S. Const., Amend. 1.)
Existing law applies the First Amendment to the states through operation of the Fourteenth Amendment. (Gitlow v. New York (1925) 268 U.S. 652; NAACP v. Alabama (1925) 357 U.S. 449.)
Existing law establishes that the First Amendment applies in full force on public college and university campuses. (Healy v. James (1972) 408 U.S. 169, 180.)
Existing law provides that every person may freely speak, write and publish his or her sentiments on all subjects, being responsible for the abuse of this right. (Cal. Const., art. I, Sec. 2)
Existing law defines traditional public forums as places “which by long tradition or by government fiat have been devoted to assembly and debate… [such as] streets and parks....” (Perry Education Association v. Perry Local Educators’ Association (1983) 460 U.S. 37, 44.) In such traditional public forums, the government may only impose time, place, and manner restrictions on speech, and only so long as the restrictions are narrowly tailored to serve a clear government interest, the restrictions are content and viewpoint neutral, and they provide for an ample alternative means of expression. (Ibid.)
Existing law defines designated public forums as “public property which the state has voluntarily opened for its use by the public as place for expressive activity.” (Perry, supra, 460 U.S. 37, 45.) The government is not constitutionally required to maintain the open character of these places, but once it does, any restrictions it imposes on speech therein must meet the same standard as in a traditional public forum. (Id.)
Existing law defines limited public forums as public property “not by tradition or designation a forum for public communication.” (Perry, supra, 460 U.S. 37, 46.) In such places, the government can place restrictions on speech so long as they are reasonable and viewpoint neutral. (Id.)
Existing law prohibits the Regents of the University of California, the Trustees of the California State University, the governing board of a community college district, and an administrator of any campus of those institutions, from making or enforcing a rule subjecting a student to disciplinary sanction solely on the basis of conduct that is speech or other communication that, when engaged in outside a campus of those institutions, is protected from governmental restriction. A student may commence a civil action to obtain appropriate injunctive and declaratory relief, as determined by the court, to enforce these provisions. Upon a motion, a court may award attorney’s fees to a prevailing plaintiff in a civil action pursuant to this section. (Ed. Code Secs. 66301 and 94367.)
Existing law does not prohibit an institution from adopting rules and regulations that are designed to prevent hate violence from being directed at students in a manner that denies them their full participation in the educational process, if the rules and regulations conform to standards established by the First Amendment to the United States Constitution and Section 2 of Article I of the California Constitution for citizens generally. (Ed. Code Secs. 66301 and 94367.)
This bill would declare that the outdoor areas of public universities and colleges in California are traditional public forums for First Amendment analysis purposes. Institutions would only be able to make and enforce restrictions related to the time, place and manner of speech in those areas. Such restrictions would have to be narrowly tailored to serve a significant institutional interest. Furthermore, any such restriction would have to be content neutral, viewpoint neutral, and allow for ample alternative means of expression. Finally, the restriction would have to allow members of the campus community to spontaneously and contemporaneously distribute literature and assemble.
This bill would permit people who wish to engage in expressive activity on the campus of a public postsecondary institution to do so freely, so long as their conduct is not unlawful and does not materially and substantially disrupt the function of the institution.
Existing law permits aggrieved individuals to bring a lawsuit for the deprivation of any rights, privileges, or immunities secured by the Constitution and laws. (42 U.S. 1983.)
Existing law allows a court to award attorney’s fees to a party that prevails in a civil action to enforce his or her rights under the Constitution. (42 U.S. 1988.)
This bill would permit the Attorney General or a person aggrieved by a violation of its terms to bring a lawsuit and obtain injunctive relief, compensatory damages, courts costs, attorney’s fees and liquidated damages in the amount of at least $500 plus $50 for each day the violation continues, up to a maximum, excluding attorney’s fees and court costs, of $5,000.
COMMENT
1. Stated need for the bill
According to the author:
Unfortunately, the latest research shows that roughly 1 in 10 colleges and universities stifle expression on campus with policies that quarantine speech into misleadingly labeled free speech zones. Even more colleges require students to obtain permission or permits before simply distributing literature on campus … Too many public institutions in California are among those schools….
Most importantly, the bill would advance free expression at California’s public colleges by prohibiting the maintenance of “free speech zones” statewide.
At present, bringing legal challenges to unconstitutional free speech zone policies pose particular difficulties for potential student-plaintiffs, who may be unaware of the fact that these policies violate their First Amendment rights, may worry about risking punishment to secure standing for a legal challenge, or may have difficulty securing counsel to pursue legal action. By codifying the existing doctrinal standard, the bill removes uncertainty for all parties: students, counsel, and university administrators. Further, at present, student claims may avoid review because students’ cases can be rendered moot as they graduate. SB 472 closes the loophole that allows for these policies to evade judicial review by liquidating damages….
In support, the Foundation for Individual Rights in Education writes:
One of the most common ways that institutions infringe on their students’ rights to freedom of expression is through policies that restrict the locations on campuses where students can engage in expressive activities protected by the First Amendment. These policies often quarantine student expression into misleadingly labeled “free speech zones” or require students to obtain prior approval from administrators before speaking their minds.
Across the country, similar policies have been used to silence student speech on gun rights, veganism, and the National Security Agency. They have even prohibited distribution of copies of the U.S. Constitution….
In recent years, several institutions in California have been sued over their free speech zones… If SB 472 were passed, further unfortunate incidents could be avoided in California.
The continued maintenance of free speech zones at California’s public institutions benefits no one. Institutions risk losing lawsuits. Students risk punishment for protected speech and learn the wrong lesson about their expressive rights, concluding that self-censorship is safer than risking discipline for speaking their mind. Establishing that outdoor areas on public campuses are public forums… will ensure that our public universities continue to be a traditional space for debate aptly and memorably recognized by the Supreme Court as “peculiarly the ‘marketplace of ideas.’”
In further support, the American Civil Liberties Union of California writes:
…Unfortunately, some schools have enacted overly-restrictive policies effectively precluding full enjoyment of these fundamental rights.
Consistent with constitutional principles, this bill would recognize that outdoor areas of public postsecondary institutions are traditional public forums… Expressive activity would be permitted, as long as that person’s conduct is not unlawful and does not materially or substantially disrupt the functioning of the institution.
We believe this bill strikes an appropriate balance between the right to free expression and the interests of public universities to maintain appropriate safety and decorum.
In further support, Leadership and Advocacy Development writes:
SB 472 does not alter existing law or change legal rulings affecting student free speech, but simply removes bureaucratic barriers that inhibit student speech and discourage dialogue.
SB 472 … prevents public colleges and universities from restricting student free speech to campus “free speech” areas. Too often, these areas are comprised of a very small remote space in a location that limits interactions with the general student population. Many colleges and universities require prior permission from campus administrators to use this finite space; permission that may also require the prior approval of literature that students wish to distribute….
[…]
Such campus bureaucracy discourages free speech and restricts the free expression of ideas – founding principles of our public colleges and universities. A bureaucratic bias shouldn’t be allowed that restricts speech to one particular viewpoint, and exercising the 1st Amendment shouldn’t be confined by the conservative or liberal ideology of campus administrators. SB 472 ensures the safeguard of these principles by removing obstructive barriers.
2. Campus incidents that illustrate the issue
- A student at Pierce College in Woodland Hills, California, alleges that campus administrators told him to stop handing out Spanish-language copies of the U.S. Constitution outside the campus “free speech zone,” a 616 square foot space on a 426 acre campus.[1]
- A student at Georgia Gwinnet College in Lawrenceville, Georgia alleges that campus administrators sought to discipline him for passing out religious materials in front of the library, telling him that he needed to get a permit and stay inside one of the campus’ two small free speech zones.[2]
- A group of students at the University of South Carolina in Columbia, South Carolina, alleges that even after getting permission to hold a “free speech event” on campus, they were called in for questioning over a possible violation of the school’s speech code when the event included displays of a swastika, use of the slur “wetback,” and anti-Israeli sentiment.[3]
3. Court decisions addressing free speech zones
Federal courts have struck down or enjoined enforcement of free speech zone policies. For example, in University of Cincinnati Chapter of Young Americans for Liberty v. Williams ((S.D. Ohio June 12, 2012) No. 1:12-cv-155, 2012 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 80967), the court held that open, outdoor areas of public campus are designated public forums as to students, and enjoined enforcement of a free speech area policy and advance notice requirement for public expression. In Roberts v. Haragan, (N.D. Tex. 2004) 346 F. Supp. 2d 853, 861, the court held that a prior permission requirement for expression outside campus free speech areas was unconstitutional, finding that “to the extent the campus has park areas, sidewalks, streets, or other similar common areas, these areas are public forums, at least for the University’s students, irrespective of whether the University has so designated them or not.”
4. Pending lawsuits on this issue
There are at least several active lawsuits pending on this issue, including one in California. The California case pits Kevin Shaw, who is represented by the sponsors of this bill, against Pierce College, part of the Los Angeles Community College District. Shaw alleges that college administrators told him he could not distribute Spanish-language copies of the U.S. Constitution and recruit new members for his student group outside the campus free speech zone.[4] The lawsuit, pending in the United States District Court for the Central District of California, challenges the free speech zones in place at the campuses of the Los Angeles Community College District, which is the largest community college district in the United States.
Outside of California, a student group at Michigan’s Grand Valley State University is suing to overturn the school’s restrictive free speech zone.[5] The plaintiffs in that case claim that campus police and administrators threatened them with arrest when they tried to take their “Free Speech Ball” — a large beach ball students can write on — outside the designated free speech zone on campus. In another case, a Georgia Gwinnett College student alleges that he was prevented from handing out religious literature and peacefully talking with others about his faith outside the school’s tiny free speech zones.[6] Finally, University of South Carolina students and student organizations have sued the school seeking to abolish its free speech zone.[7]
In the past, this Committee has raised concerns about bills which interfere with pending litigation. In this case, however, although the bill addresses subject matter which is at issue in pending litigation, there are arguably sound reasons to proceed. First, the bill largely restates the current state of the law. Second, despite the apparently settled nature of the law in this area, the issue of “free speech zones” seems to be persistent. Thus, guidance from the legislature could be helpful and might have the positive effect of eliminating the need to address each campus one-by-one in individual litigation.
5. Related legislation in other states
At present, the following states have enacted statutes similar to this bill: Arizona (HB 2615, HB 2548, 2016); Colorado (SB 17-062, 2017), Kentucky (SB 17, 2017), Missouri (SB 93, 2015), Utah (HB 54, 2017), and Virginia (HB 258, 2013).
Legislation that would prohibit the confinement of expressive activities on campus to “free speech zones” (sometimes as one piece of broader policy initiatives) is pending in New York (a-4066), Texas (HB 2527), North Carolina (HB 527), Illinois (HB 2939), Tennessee (HB 538 and SB 723), and Texas (SB 1151).
6. Campus free speech and the importance of ensuring inclusive learning environments
This bill would codify what is arguably the law anyway: that outdoor areas on public university and college campuses are public forums, with the attendant limitations on regulation of free expression. One way to view this bill, therefore, is as a simple and straightforward vindication of constitutional rights on campus.
Yet it is also a reality that free speech does not impact all individuals equally. Epithets and symbols of hate are but speech and expression, yet they are easier to dismiss as such for those who have not experienced, directly or by association, the very real violence and oppression behind those words and symbols. (See Richard Delgado, Words That Wound: A Tort Action for Racial Insults, Epithets, and Name-Calling (1982) 17 Har. C.R.-C.L. L. Rev., 133, 143-149.)
Speech need not be intended hatefully to be hurtful, either. For instance, the classroom assertion “we ought to get rid of birthright citizenship,” may be just intellectual jousting to the student who casually and confidently traces his or her ancestry in the U.S. back to the Mayflower. For the first generation immigrant at the next desk, however, that same statement may represent an existential threat, in as much as it is saying “you don’t belong here” to that student. The two students do not emerge from this marketplace of ideas equally enriched; in fact one may come out poorer, especially if that student is surrounded by a campus with only a few classmates, professors, and administrators who can relate to this experience and provide the counter arguments and affirmations that help ensure that a clash of ideas is enlightening and not delegitimizing.
This bill would prohibit California’s public colleges and universities from confining campus free speech or placing certain restrictions on it. This bill would not prohibit the institutions from taking proactive steps to encourage a campus environment that is inclusive and genuinely diverse. A robust marketplace of ideas is best served not only by maximum freedom of expression, but also a forum in which everyone feels welcome and valued and in which the voices heard come from a true range of viewpoints and experiences, reflective of our society more broadly.
7. Necessity of the bill?
(a) Necessity to codify this law?
If, as the proponents of this bill assert, it is reasonably well settled law that the outdoor parts of public university and college campuses are public forums, then the question arises: why is it necessary to codify it? The proponents state that:
[a]t present, bringing legal challenges to unconstitutional free speech zone policies pose particular difficulties for potential student-plaintiffs, who may be unaware of the fact that these policies violate their First Amendment rights, may worry about risking punishment to secure standing for a legal challenge, or may have difficulty securing counsel to pursue legal action. By codifying the existing doctrinal standard, the bill removes uncertainty for all parties: students, counsel, and university administrators.
In at least one sense, the bill arguably does not perfectly match “existing doctrinal standard.” The bill would declare that public college and university campuses are traditional public forums whereas most courts analyzing the situation have concluded that college campuses and universities are designated public forums. (See, e.g., McGlone v. Bell (6th Cir. Apr. 23, 2012) 2012 WL 1403233 (holding that the open areas of Tennessee Technical University's campus are designated public fora); Hays Cnty Guardian v. Supple (5th Cir. 1992) 969 F.2d 111, 116 (holding that the university campus is a designated public forum)). However, the distinction makes no difference for purposes of what restrictions on speech can be imposed. Moreover, even if the bill were to declare public college and university campuses to be designated public forums, as most case law does, the public colleges and universities would not be in a position to “redesignate” their campus to be some other type of forum, since the forum designation would come from state law, which the public universities and colleges do not have the authority to supersede.
(b) Necessity of the private right of action?
Under existing law, affected individuals can sue for First Amendment violations. (42 U.S. 1983.) The relief available includes injunctive relief, compensatory damages, court costs, and attorney’s fees. (42 U.S. 1988.) Existing state law also provides for a private right of action to challenge campus restrictions on free speech. (Ed. Code Secs. 66301(b) and 94367(b).) The question therefore arises why it is necessary to include a private right of action in this bill. The sponsor of the bill asserts that:
[a]t present, student claims may avoid review because students’ cases can be rendered moot as they graduate. SB 472 closes the loophole that allows for these policies to evade judicial review by liquidating damages, as the bill fines colleges for $500 for the initial violation that the court will have to impose even if the student graduates while the case is pending.
Arguably, however, this concern is already covered by the exception to the mootness doctrine that allows claims to survive when they are “capable of repetition yet evading review.” (Spencer v. Kemna (1998) 523 U.S. 1, 17.) However, that exception applies “only in exceptional situations,” where (1) “the challenged action [is] in its duration too short to be fully litigated prior to cessation or expiration,” and (2) “there [is] a reasonable expectation that the same complaining party [will] be subject to the same action again.” (Ibid.) The bill’s proponents asset that, as to cases involving campus “free speech zones,” this exception to the “capable of repetition yet evading review” standard has acted as a practical barrier against obtaining a conclusion to these lawsuits.
8. Amendments
To allow potential lawsuits under this bill to continue after a student plaintiff graduates, to avoid exposing public colleges and universities to excessive liability risk, and to ensure that free speech, rather than financial interests, motivate any lawsuits under this bill, the author proposes to accept the following amendments in Committee:
Amendment 1
On page 4, line 22, strike two hundred fifty and insert:
five
Amendment 2
On page 4, line 23, strike $250,000 and insert:
$5,000
Amendment 3
On page 4, line 25, strike two hundred fifty and insert:
Five
Amendment 4
On page 4, line 26, strike $250,000 and insert:
$5,000
Support: American Civil Liberties Union of California; Foundation for Individual Rights in Education; Leadership Education and Advocacy Development
Opposition: None known
HISTORY
Source: Foundation for Individual Rights in Education
Related Pending Legislation: ACR 21 (Kiley, 2017) would urge all private and public universities in California, to the extent that they have not adopted free speech statements consistent with the principles articulated by the Chancellor of the University of California at Irvine, and the Free Expression Statement formally adopted by the University of Chicago, to consider such statements as a model for developing and adopting free speech statements. ACR 21 has been adopted in the Assembly and ordered to the Senate.
Prior Legislation:
ACR 76 (Lowenthal, 2013) would have recognized the importance of the right of freedom of speech, would have condemned biased, hurtful, and dangerous speech intended to stoke fear and intimidation in its listeners, and would have encouraged public postsecondary educational institutions to ensure that they provide a safe, encouraging environment for exercising the right of freedom of speech. ACR 76 died on the Assembly Floor.
SB 1412 (Morrow, 2006) would have called upon the University of California, California State University, and California Community Colleges to develop a student bill of rights, including provisions regarding free speech on campus. SB 1412 died in the Senate Education Committee.
SB 5 (Morrow, 2005) was similar to SB 1412. SB 5 failed passage in the Senate Education Committee.
SB 1335 (Morrow, 2004) was nearly identical to SB 5. SB 1335 failed passage in the Senate Education Committee.
Prior Vote: Senate Education Committee (Ayes 7, Noes 0)
**************
Editorial Board, Don’t Squeeze Free Speech on College Campuses (Apr. 5, 2017) Los Angeles Times <http://www.latimes.com/opinion/editorials/la-ed-college-freespeech-20170405-story.html> (as of Apr. 17, 2017). ↑
Farner, Student Sues Georgia Gwinnett College for Censoring Speech (Dec. 20, 2016) Gwinnett Daily Post < http://www.gwinnettdailypost.com/local/student-sues-georgia-gwinnett-college-for-censoring-speech/article_35894ec2-7d27-55f5-8277-f3ed34fcee47.html> (as of Apr. 17, 2017). ↑
LeBlanc, USC Sued By Student Over Speech Code (Feb. 23, 2016) The State <http://www.thestate.com/news/local/article62037887.html> (as of Apr. 17, 2017). ↑
Complaint for Injunctive and Declaratory Relief and Damages, Shaw v. Burke (C.D. Cal. Mar. 28, 2017) No. CV-17-2386, <https://www.thefire.org/complaint-shaw-v-burke> (as of Apr. 17, 2017). ↑
Complaint and Demand for Jury Trial, Turning Point USA at Grand Valley State Univ. v. Trustees of Grand Valley State Univ. (W.D. Mich. Dec. 7, 2016) No. 1:16-cv-1407, <http://courthousenews.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/12/GrandValley.pdf> (as of Apr. 17, 2017). ↑
Complaint and Demand for Jury Trial, Uzuegbunam v. Preczewski (N.D. Ga. Dec. 19, 2016) No. 1:16-cv-04658 <https://adflegal.blob.core.windows.net/web-content-dev/docs/default-source/documents/case-documents/uzuegbunam-v.-preczewski/uzuegbunam-v-preczewski---complaint.pdf?sfvrsn=6> (as of Apr. 17, 2017). ↑
Complaint for Injunctive and Declaratory Relief and Damages, Abbott v. Pastides, et al. (D.S.C. Feb. 23, 2016) No. 3:16-538-MBS (D.S.C. Feb. 23, 2016), available at <https://www.thefire.org/complaint-and-exhibits-a-t-in-abbott-v-pastides-et-al> (as of Apr. 18. 2017). ↑
SENATE COMMITTEE ON EDUCATION
Senator Benjamin Allen, Chair
2017 - 2018 Regular
Bill No: SB 472 Hearing Date: April 19, 2017
Author: | |||
Version: | April 6, 2017 | ||
Urgency: | No | Fiscal: | Yes |
Consultant: | Lynn Lorber | ||
Subject: Public postsecondary education: Campus Free Expression Act
NOTE: This bill has been referred to the Committees on Education and Judiciary. A "do pass" motion should include referral to the Committee on Judiciary.
SUMMARY
This bill requires a person who wishes to engage in expressive activity on the campus of a public postsecondary institution to be permitted to do so freely, as long as that person’s conduct is not unlawful and does not materially and substantially disrupt the functioning of the institution.
BACKGROUND
Existing federal law prohibits Congress from making any law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof; or abridging the freedom of speech, or of the press; or the right of the people peaceably to assemble, and to petition the government for a redress of grievances. (First Amendment to the United States Constitution)
Existing state law:
- Provides that every person may freely speak, write and publish his or her sentiments on all subjects, being responsible for the abuse of this right. Existing law prohibits a law from restraining or abridging liberty of speech or press. (California Constitution, Article I, Section 2)
- Prohibits the Regents of the University of California, the Trustees of the California State University, the governing board of a community college district, and an administrator of any campus of those institutions, from making or enforcing a rule subjecting a student to disciplinary sanction solely on the basis of conduct that is speech or other communication that, when engaged in outside a campus of those institutions, is protected from governmental restriction. (Education Code § 66301)
- Provides that #2 and 3 do not prohibit an institution from adopting rules and regulations that are designed to prevent hate violence from being directed at students in a manner that denies them their full participation in the educational process, if the rules and regulations conform to standards established by the
First Amendment to the United States Constitution and Section 2 of Article I of the California Constitution for citizens generally. (EC § 66301 and § 94367) - Requires the governing board of a community college district to adopt rules and regulations relating to the exercise of free expression by students upon the premises of each community college maintained by the district, which shall include reasonable provisions for the time, place, and manner of conducting such activities. Existing law provides that such rules and regulations shall not prohibit the right of students to exercise free expression, except that expression which is obscene, libelous or slanderous according to current legal standards, or which so incites students as to create a clear and present danger of the commission of unlawful acts on community college premises, or the violation of lawful community college regulations, or the substantial disruption of the orderly operation of the community college, shall be prohibited. (EC § 76120)
- Authorizes a student to commence a civil action to obtain appropriate injunctive and declaratory relief as determined by the court. Upon a motion, a court may award attorney’s fees to a prevailing plaintiff in a civil action pursuant to this section. (EC § 66301 and § 94367)
ANALYSIS
This bill requires a person who wishes to engage in expressive activity on the campus of a public postsecondary institution to be permitted to do so freely, as long as that person’s conduct is not unlawful and does not materially and substantially disrupt the functioning of the institution. Specifically, this bill:
- Requires a person who wishes to engage in expressive activity on the campus of a public postsecondary institution to be permitted to do so freely, as long as that person’s conduct is not unlawful and does not materially and substantially disrupt the functioning of the institution.
- Provides that outdoor areas of public postsecondary institutions are traditional public forums.
- Authorizes a public postsecondary institution to maintain and enforce reasonable time, place, and manner restrictions only when those restrictions are narrowly tailored in service of a significant institutional interest, employ clear, published, content-neutral and viewpoint-neutral criteria, and provide for ample alternative means of expression. This bill requires these restrictions to allow for members of the campus community to spontaneously and contemporaneously distribute literature and assemble.
- Authorizes either of the following people to bring an action in a court of competent jurisdiction to enjoin a violation of this bill, or to recover compensatory damages, court costs, and reasonable attorney’s fees, or all of these:
- The Attorney General.
- A person whose right to engage in expressive activity was infringed through a violation of this bill.
- The Attorney General.
- Requires the court, if the court finds a violation of this bill, to award an aggrieved person damages of no less than $500 for the initial violation, plus $50 for each day the violation remains ongoing which is to accrue starting on the day after the complaint is served on the institution. This bill prohibits the total damages, excluding court costs and attorney’s fees, available to a plaintiff, or multiple plaintiffs, in a case or cases stemming from a single controversy from exceeding $250,000 in total. This bill requires the court, if the court that finds a violation of this bill has harmed multiple plaintiffs, to divide damages, which shall not exceed $250,000 in total, equally among those plaintiffs.
- Provides that a violation of this bill is established by a person described in #4 demonstrating in an action brought in a court of competent jurisdiction either of the following:
- That a public postsecondary educational institution has a policy that does not conform with the requirements of this bill.
- That a public postsecondary educational institution, by an act or actions of one of its employees, administrators, or any person contracted to perform a service at the institution or by the enforcement of an institutional policy, violated the requirements of this bill.
- That a public postsecondary educational institution has a policy that does not conform with the requirements of this bill.
- Limits a person’s ability to bring an action alleging a violation of this bill to no later than one year after the date the cause of action accrues. This bill provides that each day that a violation persists, and each day that a policy that violates this bill remains in effect, constitutes a new violation of this bill and is, therefore, a new day on which a cause of action has accrued.
- Provides that nothing in this bill is to be interpreted as doing any of the following:
- Alter the protections for expressive activity provided by the First Amendment.
- Limiting the right of student expression in other areas of public postsecondary institutions.
- Granting any person the right to materially disrupt scheduled or reserved activities in a portion or section of the campus at the scheduled time.
- Alter the protections for expressive activity provided by the First Amendment.
STAFF COMMENTS
- Need for the bill. According to the author, “Despite decades of legal precedent establishing that the First Amendment applies in full for students on public university campuses, many public institutions of higher education in California dramatically limit the areas on campus available for expressive activity to tiny designated areas – so call ‘free speech zones.’ This bill would guarantee that open areas at California’s public campuses are what they have always been intended to be: public forums where expressive activity may flourish subject only to content- and viewpoint-neutral reasonable, time, place, and manner restrictions. Quarantining student speech to tiny free speech zones violates the First Amendment and diminishes the quality of debate and discussion on campus by preventing expression from reaching its target audience. Moreover, many of the institutions that maintain these restrictive policies also employ burdensome permitting schemes that require students to obtain administrative and law enforcement permission days or even weeks before being allowed to speak their minds. Making matters worse, many of these policies grant campus administrators unfettered discretion to deny applications based on the viewpoint or content of the speakers’ intended message.”
- Protected speech. This bill does not alter what is considered protected or unprotected speech. This bill requires public postsecondary institutions’ policies to be reasonable, narrowly tailored, and use viewpoint-neutral criteria; requires policies to be applied evenly; requires institutions’ policies to be consistent with the requirements of this bill; and authorizes a person to bring an action in court for violations.
- Materially and substantially disrupt the functioning of the institution. This bill requires a person who wishes to engage in expressive activity on the campus of a public postsecondary institution to be permitted to do so freely, as long as that person’s conduct is not unlawful and does not materially and substantially disrupt the functioning of the institution. This bill does not define “materially and substantially disrupt”; existing law includes several references to the disruption of the orderly operation of institutions. The determination as to whether an action is a disruption is left to postsecondary institutions through their policies and codes of conduct.
Freedom of speech on public postsecondary educational institutions is allowed within the confines of codes of conduct and time, place and manner restrictions. Institutions cannot discipline a student for engaging in a free speech activity, but can discipline a student if the free speech activity crosses into unlawful behavior, or otherwise violates the institution’s time, place and manner restrictions. - Existing time, place, and manner restrictions. This bill authorizes a public postsecondary institution to maintain and enforce reasonable time, place, and manner restrictions only when those restrictions are narrowly tailored in service of a significant institutional interest, employ clear, published, content-neutral and viewpoint-neutral criteria, and provide for ample alternative means of expression.
Postsecondary educational institutions maintain time, place, and manner restrictions to ensure safety, security, and order. As an example, California State University, Sacramento’s policy states:
“A. Overview: All activities set forth in this policy are subject to these general time, place, and manner restrictions in addition to any other time, place, and manner restrictions specified below.
B. TIME: At all times, except for non-University affiliated organizations and individuals, who are limited to normal operating hours.
C. PLACE: Freedom of expression activities may take place anywhere on campus with the following exceptions: inside parking lots and structures, inside University buildings, and near any location in which instructional, educational, and/or official business activities are being conducted (generally within 20 feet). Popular locations for freedom of expression activities are the Library Quad, Main Quad, and South Green.
D. MANNER:
- Freedom of expression, which includes marches and/or moving protests, must be conducted in a manner that (1) shall not interfere with or obstruct the free flow of pedestrian or vehicular traffic; (2) shall not interfere with or disrupt the conduct of University business; (3) shall be carried out without creating excessive noise by use of a device; (4) shall not unreasonably interfere with classes in session or other scheduled academic, educational, co-curricular, and/or cultural/arts programs; (5) shall not promote an unlawful end, such as promoting actual violence or bodily or property harms, terrorist threats, defamation, obscenity, and false advertising; and (6) shall not violate any federal, state, or local safety code, such as regulations set by the State Fire Marshal, or University policy.
- For any public meeting, demonstration, rally, etc., held on University grounds, advance reservations are advised to avoid conflict with previously reserved activities. Use of space shall not conflict with prior reservation of that space for another use. (Casual or unscheduled users will not be allowed to interfere with scheduled, organized, or traditional use). Use of any campus buildings for this purpose requires advance reservations and is restricted to non-profit organizations or student organizations, and faculty-, staff- or administration-sponsored events. To maintain access and safety, the use of ramps, entrances, breezeways, hallways, and other pedestrian pathways is not authorized for such purposes.
- The scheduling process will ensure order and adequate preparation for the event and a suitable space for the intended use and expected attendance. Policies and procedures for reserving campus facilities are available in the Student Organizations & Leadership office and the Office of Space Management. Requests for student organization-sponsored events shall be directed to the Student Organizations & Leadership office. Requests for faculty-, staff- and administration-sponsored, and community events shall be directed to the Office of Space Management or the office that oversees reservations for that particular venue (e.g., requests for University Union space must be made through the University Union Events Services Office). Please consult the University’s Office of Space Management’s website for information relating to the appropriate office to contact to make reservations for a particular location on the University’s campus.” http://www.csus.edu/umanual/student/stu-0125.htm
This policy appears to meet the requirements of this bill. This bill provides that a violation is established in an action brought in a court of competent jurisdiction in either of the following scenarios:
a) A public postsecondary educational institution has a policy that does not conform with the requirements of this bill.
- A public postsecondary educational institution, by an act or actions of one of its employees, administrators, or any person contracted to perform a service at the institution or by the enforcement of an institutional policy, violated the requirements of this bill.
- Free speech zones and safe spaces. This bill essentially eliminates the ability of postsecondary educational institutions to limit free speech activities to “free speech zones” and prohibit free speech activities in “safe spaces” (when safe spaces are the entire campus, or based on a certain viewpoint). This bill could limit the ability of institutions to require students to get a permit prior to holding free speech activities, as it requires the time, place and manner restrictions to allow for members of the campus community to spontaneously and contemporaneously distribute literature and assemble.
Consistent with existing law, this bill allows people to protest:- A speech being given by an outside speaker, but does not allow people to disrupt that speech.
- An increase in tuition, but does not allow people to block the doors to a building on campus.
- A speech being given by an outside speaker, but does not allow people to disrupt that speech.
The author cites incidents related to free speech activities on California campuses that resulted in lawsuits against those institutions:
- A lawsuit was recently filed against Pierce College in the Los Angeles Community College District, related to the college’s designation of an area for free speech activities, while all other areas of campus are considered non-public forums.
- California State Polytechnic University, Pomona settled a lawsuit in 2015 related to the college’s designation of an area for free speech activities and the requirement that a permit be obtained prior to engaging in free speech activities.
- Citrus Community College District settled a lawsuit in 2014, related to the college’s designation of an area for free speech activities, while all other areas of campus are considered non-public forums. According to a news article that cited a post-settlement statement from Citrus College, "As part of the settlement, the District will be implementing new procedures that will expand its current free speech area to include most open spaces on campus, enhance the District’s co-curricular program by streamlining internal procedures that apply to activities of recognized student clubs and organizations, and help to ensure the safety and security of students involved in such activities."
- Related legislation. ACR 21 (Kiley) urges all private and public universities in California, to the extent that they do not already have free speech statements consistent with the principles articulated by the Chancellor of the University of California at Irvine, or the Free Speech Statement formally adopted by the University of Chicago, to consider such statements as a model for developing similar free speech statements. ACR 21 is pending on the Assembly Floor.
SUPPORT
Foundation for Individual Rights in Education (sponsor)
American Civil Liberties Union of California
Leadership Education and Advocacy Development Program
OPPOSITION
None received
-- END --
Discussed in Hearing
Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations
Senate Standing Committee on Judiciary
Senate Standing Committee on Education
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):