SB 481: Successor agencies: assets: disposal.
- Session Year: 2017-2018
- House: Senate
- Latest Version Date: 2018-09-18
Existing law dissolved redevelopment agencies and community development agencies as of February 1, 2012, and provides for the designation of successor agencies to wind down the affairs of the dissolved redevelopment agencies and to, among other things, dispose of assets and properties of the former redevelopment agency as directed by the oversight board of the successor agency. Existing law requires a successor agency to dispose of specified assets and properties of the former redevelopment expeditiously and in a manner aimed at maximizing value.
This bill would, until January 1, 2022, authorize the successor agency to the Redevelopment Agency of the County of Sacramento to dispose of a specified property previously used as the San Juan Hotel and Mobile Home Park for an amount less than fair market value, provided that the agency require that the property be used for housing affordable to, and occupied by, persons and families of low or moderate income and very low income and extremely low income households and include an enforceable covenant to that effect.
This bill would make legislative findings and declarations regarding the public purpose served by the bill.
This bill would make legislative findings and declarations as to the necessity of a special statute for the successor agency to the Redevelopment Agency of the County of Sacramento.
Existing law dissolved redevelopment agencies and community development agencies as of February 1, 2012, and provides for the designation of successor agencies to wind down the affairs of the dissolved redevelopment agencies and to, among other things, dispose of assets and properties of the former redevelopment agency as directed by the oversight board of the successor agency. Existing law requires a successor agency to dispose of specified assets and properties of the former redevelopment expeditiously and in a manner aimed at maximizing value.
This bill would, until January 1, 2022, authorize the successor agency to the Redevelopment Agency of the County of Sacramento to dispose of a specified property previously used as the San Juan Hotel and Mobile Home Park for an amount less than fair market value, provided that the agency require that the property be used for housing affordable to, and occupied by, persons and families of low or moderate income and very low income and extremely low income households and include an enforceable covenant to that effect.
This bill would make legislative findings and declarations regarding the public purpose served by the bill.
This bill would make legislative findings and declarations as to the necessity of a special statute for the successor agency to the Redevelopment Agency of the County of Sacramento.
Existing law dissolved redevelopment agencies and community development agencies as of February 1, 2012, and provides for the designation of successor agencies to wind down the affairs of the dissolved redevelopment agencies and to, among other things, dispose of assets and properties of the former redevelopment agency as directed by the oversight board of the successor agency. Existing law requires a successor agency to dispose of specified assets and properties of the former redevelopment expeditiously and in a manner aimed at maximizing value.
This bill would, until January 1, 2022, authorize the successor agency to the Redevelopment Agency of the County of Sacramento to dispose of a specified property previously used as the San Juan Hotel and Mobile Home Park for an amount less than fair market value, provided that the agency require that the property be used for housing affordable to, and occupied by, persons and families of low or moderate income and very low income and extremely low income households and include an enforceable covenant to that effect.
This bill would make legislative findings and declarations regarding the public purpose served by the bill.
This bill would make legislative findings and declarations as to the necessity of a special statute for the Successor Agency to the Redevelopment Agency of the County of Sacramento.
Existing law dissolved redevelopment agencies and community development agencies as of February 1, 2012, and provides for the designation of successor agencies to wind down the affairs of the dissolved redevelopment agencies and to, among other things, dispose of assets and properties of the former redevelopment agency as directed by the oversight board of the successor agency. Existing law requires a successor agency to dispose of specified assets and properties of the former redevelopment expeditiously and in a manner aimed at maximizing value.
This bill would, until January 1, 2022, authorize the successor agency to the Redevelopment Agency of the County of Sacramento to dispose of a specified property previously used as the San Juan Hotel and Mobile Home Park for an amount less than fair market value, provided that the agency require that the property be used for housing affordable to, and occupied by, persons and families of low or moderate income and very low income and extremely low income households and include an enforceable covenant to that effect.
This bill would make legislative findings and declarations regarding the public purpose served by the bill.
This bill would make legislative findings and declarations as to the necessity of a special statute for Successor Agency to the Redevelopment Agency of the County of Sacramento.
Existing law requires the attending physician of a resident in a skilled nursing facility or intermediate care facility who prescribes or orders a medical intervention of a resident that requires the informed consent of a patient who lacks the capacity to provide that consent, as specified, to inform the skilled nursing facility or intermediate care facility. Existing law requires the facility to conduct an interdisciplinary team review of the prescribed medical intervention prior to the administration of the medical intervention, subject to specified proceedings. Existing law authorizes a medical intervention prior to the facility convening an interdisciplinary team review in the case of an emergency, under specified circumstances. Existing law imposes civil penalties for a violation of these provisions.This bill would, before implementing a medical intervention that requires informed consent for a resident who lacks capacity to make health care decisions and there is no person with legal authority able and willing to make those decisions, require the physician, skilled nursing facility, or intermediate care facility, to promptly notify the resident, orally and in writing, that it has been determined that the resident lacks capacity, and other information, as specified.Existing law requires the attending physician of a resident in a skilled nursing facility or intermediate care facility who prescribes or orders a medical intervention of a resident that requires the informed consent of a patient who lacks the capacity to provide that consent, as specified, to inform the skilled nursing facility or intermediate care facility. Existing law requires the facility to conduct an interdisciplinary team review of the prescribed medical intervention prior to the administration of the medical intervention, subject to specified proceedings. Existing law authorizes a medical intervention prior to the facility convening an interdisciplinary team review in the case of an emergency, under specified circumstances. Existing law imposes civil penalties for a violation of these provisions.
This bill would, before implementing a medical intervention that requires informed consent for a resident who lacks capacity to make health care decisions and there is no person with legal authority able and willing to make those decisions, require the physician, skilled nursing facility, or intermediate care facility, to promptly notify the resident, orally and in writing, that it has been determined that the resident lacks capacity, and other information, as specified.
Existing law requires the attending physician of a resident in a skilled nursing facility or intermediate care facility that who prescribes or orders a medical intervention of a resident that requires the informed consent of a patient who lacks the capacity to provide that consent, as specified, to inform the skilled nursing facility or intermediate care facility. Existing law requires the facility to conduct an interdisciplinary team review of the prescribed medical intervention prior to the administration of the medical intervention, subject to specified proceedings. Existing law authorizes a medical intervention prior to the facility convening an interdisciplinary team review in the case of an emergency, under specified circumstances. Existing law imposes civil penalties for a violation of these provisions.
This bill would, before implementing a medical intervention that requires informed consent for a resident that who lacks capacity to make health care decisions and there is no person with legal authority able and willing to make those decisions, require the physician, skilled nursing facility, or intermediate care facility, to promptly notify the resident, orally and in writing, that it has been determined that the resident lacks capacity. capacity, and other information, as specified.
Existing law requires the attending physician of a resident in a skilled nursing facility or intermediate care facility that prescribes or orders a medical intervention of a resident that requires the informed consent of a patient who lacks the capacity to provide that consent, as specified, to inform the skilled nursing facility or intermediate care facility. Existing law requires the facility to conduct an interdisciplinary team review of the prescribed medical intervention prior to the administration of the medical intervention, subject to specified proceedings. Existing law authorizes a medical intervention prior to the facility convening an interdisciplinary team review in the case of an emergency, under specified circumstances. Existing law imposes civil penalties for a violation of these provisions.
This bill would, before implementing a medical intervention that requires informed consent for a resident that lacks capacity to make health care decisions and there is no person with legal authority able and willing to make those decisions, require the physician, skilled nursing facility, or intermediate care facility, to promptly notify the resident, orally and in writing, that it has been determined that the resident lacks capacity.
(a)Notwithstanding subdivision (e) of Section 34177, and subdivision (a) of Section 34181, the successor agency to the Redevelopment Agency of the County of Sacramento may dispose of assets previously used as the San Juan Hotel and Mobile Home Park for an amount less than fair market value provided that the agency require that the property be used for housing affordable to, and occupied by, persons and families of low or moderate income and very low income and extremely low income households and include an enforceable covenant to that effect that meets the requirements of subdivision (f) of Section 33334.3.
(b)For purposes of this section, assets previously used as the San Juan Hotel and Mobile Home Park means a property, consisting of 2.55 acres, formerly known as the San Juan Hotel and Mobile Home Park located at 5700 Stockton Boulevard in Sacramento County.
(c)For purposes of this section, dispose of means to transfer or sell the property described in subdivision (b) to the City of Sacramento or to the housing successor to the Redevelopment Agency of the City of Sacramento.
(d)This section shall remain in effect only until January 1, 2022, and as of that date is repealed.
SEC. 2.The Legislature finds and declares that the addition of Section 34177.8 to the Health and Safety Code by this act serves a public purpose of encouraging the construction of affordable housing in Sacramento County, and does not constitute a gift of public funds within the meaning of Section 6 of Article XVI of the California Constitution.
SEC. 3.The Legislature finds and declares that a special statute is necessary and that a general statute cannot be made applicable within the meaning of Section 16 of Article IV of the California Constitution because of the unique need of the Successor Agency to the Redevelopment Agency of the County of Sacramento to ensure that the assets of the former redevelopment agency are disposed of in a way that provides the maximum benefit to the community.
(a)Notwithstanding subdivision (e) of Section 34177, and subdivision (a) of Section 34181, the successor agency to the Redevelopment Agency of the County of Sacramento may dispose of assets previously used as the San Juan Hotel and Mobile Home Park for an amount less than fair market value provided that the agency require that the property be used for housing affordable to, and occupied by, persons and families of low or moderate income and very low income and extremely low income households and include an enforceable covenant to that effect that meets the requirements of subdivision (f) of Section 33334.3.
(b)For purposes of this section, assets previously used as the San Juan Hotel and Mobile Home Park means a property, consisting of 2.55 acres, formerly known as the San Juan Hotel and Mobile Home Park located at 5700 Stockton Boulevard in Sacramento County.
(c)For purposes of this section, dispose of means to transfer or sell the property described in subdivision (b) to the City of Sacramento or to the housing successor to the Redevelopment Agency of the City of Sacramento.
(d)This section shall remain in effect only until January 1, 2022, and as of that date is repealed.
SEC. 2.The Legislature finds and declares that the addition of Section 34177.8 to the Health and Safety Code by this act serves a public purpose of encouraging the construction of affordable housing in Sacramento County, and does not constitute a gift of public funds within the meaning of Section 6 of Article XVI of the California Constitution.
SEC. 3.The Legislature finds and declares that a special statute is necessary and that a general statute cannot be made applicable within the meaning of Section 16 of Article IV of the California Constitution because of the unique need of the Successor Agency to the Redevelopment Agency of the County of Sacramento to ensure that the assets of the former redevelopment agency are disposed of in a way that provides the maximum benefit to the community.
(a)Notwithstanding subdivision (e) of Section 34177, and subdivision (a) of Section 34181, the successor agency to the Redevelopment Agency of the County of Sacramento may dispose of assets previously used as the San Juan Hotel and Mobile Home Park for an amount less than fair market value provided that the agency require that the property be used for housing affordable to, and occupied by, persons and families of low or moderate income and very low income and extremely low income households and include an enforceable covenant to that effect that meets the requirements of subdivision (f) of Section 33334.3.
(b)For purposes of this section, assets previously used as the San Juan Hotel and Mobile Home Park means a property, consisting of 2.55 acres, formerly known as the San Juan Hotel and Mobile Home Park located at 5700 Stockton Boulevard in Sacramento County.
(c)For purposes of this section, dispose of means to transfer or sell the property described in subdivision (b) to the City of Sacramento or to the housing successor to the Redevelopment Agency of the City of Sacramento.
(c)(d)This section shall remain in effect only until January 1, 2022, and as of that date is repealed.
SEC. 2.The Legislature finds and declares that the addition of Section 34177.8 to the Health and Safety Code by this act serves a public purpose of encouraging the construction of affordable housing in Sacramento County, and does not constitute a gift of public funds within the meaning of Section 6 of Article XVI of the California Constitution.
SEC. 3.The Legislature finds and declares that a special statute is necessary and that a general statute cannot be made applicable within the meaning of Section 16 of Article IV of the California Constitution because of the unique need of the Successor Agency to the Redevelopment Agency of the County of Sacramento to ensure that the assets of the former redevelopment agency are disposed of in a way that provides the maximum benefit to the community.
(a)Notwithstanding subdivision (e) of Section 34177, and subdivision (a) of Section 34181, the successor agency to the Redevelopment Agency of the County of Sacramento may dispose of assets previously used as the San Juan Hotel and Mobile Home Park for an amount less than fair market value provided that the agency require that the property be used for housing affordable to, and occupied by, persons and families of low or moderate income and very low income and extremely low income households and include an enforceable covenant to that effect that meets the requirements of subdivision (f) of Section 33334.3.
(b)For purposes of this section, assets previously used as the San Juan Hotel and Mobile Home Park means a property, consisting of 2.55 acres, formerly known as the San Juan Hotel and Mobile Home Park located at 5700 Stockton Boulevard in Sacramento County.
(c)This section shall remain in effect only until January 1, 2022, and as of that date is repealed.
SEC. 2.The Legislature finds and declares that the addition of Section 34177.8 to the Health and Safety Code by this act serves a public purpose of encouraging the construction of affordable housing in Sacramento County, and does not constitute a gift of public funds within the meaning of Section 6 of Article XVI of the California Constitution.
SEC. 3.The Legislature finds and declares that a special statute is necessary and that a general statute cannot be made applicable within the meaning of Section 16 of Article IV of the California Constitution because of the unique need of the Successor Agency to the Redevelopment Agency of the County of Sacramento to ensure that the assets of the former redevelopment agency are disposed of in a way that provides the maximum benefit to the community.
SECTION 1.Section 1418.8 of the Health and Safety Code is amended to read:1418.8.(a)If the attending physician of a resident in a skilled nursing facility or intermediate care facility prescribes or orders a medical intervention that requires that informed consent be obtained prior to administration of the medical intervention, but is unable to obtain informed consent because the physician determines that the resident lacks capacity to make decisions concerning his or her health care and that there is no person with legal authority able and willing to make those decisions on behalf of the resident, the physician shall inform the skilled nursing facility or intermediate care facility.(b)For purposes of subdivision (a), a resident lacks capacity to make a decision regarding his or her health care if the resident is unable to understand the nature and consequences of the proposed medical intervention, including its risks and benefits, or is unable to express a preference regarding the intervention. To make the determination regarding capacity, the physician shall interview the resident, review the residents medical records, and consult with skilled nursing facility or intermediate care facility staff, as appropriate, and family members and friends of the resident, if any have been identified.(c)For purposes of subdivision (a), a person with legal authority to make medical treatment decisions on behalf of a resident is a person designated pursuant to Division 4.7 of the Probate Code, a guardian, a conservator, or next of kin. To determine the existence of a person with legal authority, the physician shall interview the resident, review the medical records of the resident, and consult with skilled nursing facility or intermediate care facility staff, as appropriate, and with family members and friends of the resident, if any have been identified.(d)The attending physician and the skilled nursing facility or intermediate care facility may initiate a medical intervention that requires informed consent pursuant to subdivision (e) in accordance with acceptable standards of practice. Before implementing a health care decision about a medical intervention that requires informed consent, if the resident lacks capacity to make health care decisions and there is no person with legal authority able and willing to make those decisions on behalf of the resident, the physician, skilled nursing facility, or intermediate care facility shall promptly communicate to the resident, orally and in writing, the following information:(1)The residents attending physician has determined that the resident lacks capacity to make health care decisions.(2)The facility has been unable to locate a person with legal authority to make medical treatment decisions on behalf of the resident pursuant to Division 4.7 of the Probate Code, a guardian, conservator, or next of kin who is able and willing to make health care decisions on behalf of the resident.(3)The medical intervention recommended or prescribed that requires informed consent and the identity of the person recommending or prescribing the medical intervention.(4)The interdisciplinary team will review or has reviewed the physicians determinations, and will continue to oversee any additional recommended or prescribed interventions unless or until a person with legal authority able and willing to make health care decisions on behalf of the resident is identified, or the attending physician or a court determines that the resident has regained the capacity to make health care decisions.(5)The right of the resident to challenge the determinations made pursuant to this section, in a judicial proceeding.(e)If a resident of a skilled nursing facility or intermediate care facility has been prescribed a medical intervention by a physician that requires informed consent and the physician has determined that the resident lacks capacity to make health care decisions and there is no person with legal authority able and willing to make those decisions on behalf of the resident, the facility shall, except as provided in subdivision (h), conduct an interdisciplinary team review of the prescribed medical intervention prior to the administration of the medical intervention. The interdisciplinary team shall oversee the care of the resident utilizing a team approach to assessment and care planning, and shall include the residents attending physician, a registered professional nurse with responsibility for the resident, other appropriate staff in disciplines as determined by the residents needs, and, if practicable, a resident representative, in accordance with applicable federal and state requirements. The review shall include all of the following:(1)A review of the physicians assessment of the residents condition.(2)The reason for the proposed use of the medical intervention.(3)A discussion of the desires of the resident, if known. To determine the desires of the resident, the interdisciplinary team shall interview the resident, review the residents medical records, and consult with family members or friends, if any have been identified.(4)The type of medical intervention to be used in the residents care, including its probable frequency and duration.(5)The probable impact on the residents condition, with and without the use of the medical intervention.(6)Reasonable alternative medical interventions considered or utilized and reasons for their discontinuance or inappropriateness.(f)A resident representative may include a family member or friend of the resident who is unable to take full responsibility for the health care decisions of the resident, but who has agreed to serve on the interdisciplinary team, or other person authorized by state or federal law.(g)The interdisciplinary team shall periodically evaluate the use of the prescribed medical intervention at least quarterly or upon a significant change in the residents medical condition.(h)In case of an emergency, after obtaining a physicians order under subdivision (a), as necessary, a skilled nursing facility or intermediate care facility may administer a medical intervention that requires informed consent prior to the facility convening an interdisciplinary team review. If the emergency results in the application of physical or chemical restraints, the interdisciplinary team shall meet within one week of the emergency for an evaluation of the medical intervention.(i)Physicians, skilled nursing facilities, and intermediate care facilities shall not be required to obtain a court order pursuant to Section 3201 of the Probate Code prior to administering a medical intervention that requires informed consent if the requirements of this section are met.(j)Nothing in this section shall in any way affect the right of a resident of a skilled nursing facility or intermediate care facility for whom medical intervention has been prescribed, ordered, or administered pursuant to this section to seek appropriate judicial relief to review the decision to provide the medical intervention.(k)No physician or other health care provider, whose action under this section is in accordance with reasonable medical standards, is subject to administrative sanction if the physician or health care provider believes in good faith that the action is consistent with this section and the desires of the resident, or if unknown, the best interests of the resident.(l)The determinations required to be made pursuant to subdivisions (a), (e), and (g), and the basis for those determinations shall be documented in the residents medical record and shall be made available to the residents representative for review.(a)If the attending physician of a resident in a skilled nursing facility or intermediate care facility prescribes or orders a medical intervention that requires that informed consent be obtained prior to administration of the medical intervention, but is unable to obtain informed consent because the physician determines that the resident lacks capacity to make decisions concerning his or her health care and that there is no person with legal authority able and willing to make those decisions on behalf of the resident, the physician shall inform the skilled nursing facility or intermediate care facility.
(b)For purposes of subdivision (a), a resident lacks capacity to make a decision regarding his or her health care if the resident is unable to understand the nature and consequences of the proposed medical intervention, including its risks and benefits, or is unable to express a preference regarding the intervention. To make the determination regarding capacity, the physician shall interview the resident, review the residents medical records, and consult with skilled nursing facility or intermediate care facility staff, as appropriate, and family members and friends of the resident, if any have been identified.
(c)For purposes of subdivision (a), a person with legal authority to make medical treatment decisions on behalf of a resident is a person designated pursuant to Division 4.7 of the Probate Code, a guardian, a conservator, or next of kin. To determine the existence of a person with legal authority, the physician shall interview the resident, review the medical records of the resident, and consult with skilled nursing facility or intermediate care facility staff, as appropriate, and with family members and friends of the resident, if any have been identified.
(d)The attending physician and the skilled nursing facility or intermediate care facility may initiate a medical intervention that requires informed consent pursuant to subdivision (e) in accordance with acceptable standards of practice. Before implementing a health care decision about a medical intervention that requires informed consent, if the resident lacks capacity to make health care decisions and there is no person with legal authority able and willing to make those decisions on behalf of the resident, the physician, skilled nursing facility, or intermediate care facility shall promptly communicate to the resident, orally and in writing, the following information:
(1)The residents attending physician has determined that the resident lacks capacity to make health care decisions.
(2)The facility has been unable to locate a person with legal authority to make medical treatment decisions on behalf of the resident pursuant to Division 4.7 of the Probate Code, a guardian, conservator, or next of kin who is able and willing to make health care decisions on behalf of the resident.
(3)The medical intervention recommended or prescribed that requires informed consent and the identity of the person recommending or prescribing the medical intervention.
(4)The interdisciplinary team will review or has reviewed the physicians determinations, and will continue to oversee any additional recommended or prescribed interventions unless or until a person with legal authority able and willing to make health care decisions on behalf of the resident is identified, or the attending physician or a court determines that the resident has regained the capacity to make health care decisions.
(5)The right of the resident to challenge the determinations made pursuant to this section, in a judicial proceeding.
(e)If a resident of a skilled nursing facility or intermediate care facility has been prescribed a medical intervention by a physician that requires informed consent and the physician has determined that the resident lacks capacity to make health care decisions and there is no person with legal authority able and willing to make those decisions on behalf of the resident, the facility shall, except as provided in subdivision (h), conduct an interdisciplinary team review of the prescribed medical intervention prior to the administration of the medical intervention. The interdisciplinary team shall oversee the care of the resident utilizing a team approach to assessment and care planning, and shall include the residents attending physician, a registered professional nurse with responsibility for the resident, other appropriate staff in disciplines as determined by the residents needs, and, if practicable, a resident representative, in accordance with applicable federal and state requirements. The review shall include all of the following:
(1)A review of the physicians assessment of the residents condition.
(2)The reason for the proposed use of the medical intervention.
(3)A discussion of the desires of the resident, if known. To determine the desires of the resident, the interdisciplinary team shall interview the resident, review the residents medical records, and consult with family members or friends, if any have been identified.
(4)The type of medical intervention to be used in the residents care, including its probable frequency and duration.
(5)The probable impact on the residents condition, with and without the use of the medical intervention.
(6)Reasonable alternative medical interventions considered or utilized and reasons for their discontinuance or inappropriateness.
(f)A resident representative may include a family member or friend of the resident who is unable to take full responsibility for the health care decisions of the resident, but who has agreed to serve on the interdisciplinary team, or other person authorized by state or federal law.
(g)The interdisciplinary team shall periodically evaluate the use of the prescribed medical intervention at least quarterly or upon a significant change in the residents medical condition.
(h)In case of an emergency, after obtaining a physicians order under subdivision (a), as necessary, a skilled nursing facility or intermediate care facility may administer a medical intervention that requires informed consent prior to the facility convening an interdisciplinary team review. If the emergency results in the application of physical or chemical restraints, the interdisciplinary team shall meet within one week of the emergency for an evaluation of the medical intervention.
(i)Physicians, skilled nursing facilities, and intermediate care facilities shall not be required to obtain a court order pursuant to Section 3201 of the Probate Code prior to administering a medical intervention that requires informed consent if the requirements of this section are met.
(j)Nothing in this section shall in any way affect the right of a resident of a skilled nursing facility or intermediate care facility for whom medical intervention has been prescribed, ordered, or administered pursuant to this section to seek appropriate judicial relief to review the decision to provide the medical intervention.
(k)No physician or other health care provider, whose action under this section is in accordance with reasonable medical standards, is subject to administrative sanction if the physician or health care provider believes in good faith that the action is consistent with this section and the desires of the resident, or if unknown, the best interests of the resident.
(l)The determinations required to be made pursuant to subdivisions (a), (e), and (g), and the basis for those determinations shall be documented in the residents medical record and shall be made available to the residents representative for review.
(a)If the attending physician of a resident in a skilled nursing facility or intermediate care facility prescribes or orders a medical intervention that requires that informed consent be obtained prior to administration of the medical intervention, but is unable to obtain informed consent because the physician determines that the resident lacks capacity to make decisions concerning his or her health care and that there is no person with legal authority able and willing to make those decisions on behalf of the resident, the physician shall inform the skilled nursing facility or intermediate care facility.
(b)For purposes of subdivision (a), a resident lacks capacity to make a decision regarding his or her health care if the resident is unable to understand the nature and consequences of the proposed medical intervention, including its risks and benefits, or is unable to express a preference regarding the intervention. To make the determination regarding capacity, the physician shall interview the resident, review the residents medical records, and consult with skilled nursing facility or intermediate care facility staff, as appropriate, and family members and friends of the resident, if any have been identified.
(c)For purposes of subdivision (a), a person with legal authority to make medical treatment decisions on behalf of a resident is a person designated under a valid Durable Power of Attorney for Health Care, pursuant to Division 4.7 of the Probate Code, a guardian, a conservator, or next of kin. To determine the existence of a person with legal authority, the physician shall interview the resident, review the medical records of the resident, and consult with skilled nursing facility or intermediate care facility staff, as appropriate, and with family members and friends of the resident, if any have been identified.
(d)The attending physician and the skilled nursing facility or intermediate care facility may initiate a medical intervention that requires informed consent pursuant to subdivision (e) in accordance with acceptable standards of practice. Before implementing a health care decision about a medical intervention that requires informed consent, if the resident lacks capacity to make health care decisions and there is no person with legal authority able and willing to make those decisions on behalf of the resident, the physician, skilled nursing facility, or intermediate care facility shall promptly notify the resident, orally and in writing, that it has been determined that the resident lacks capacity. communicate to the resident, orally and in writing, the following information:
(1)The residents attending physician has determined that the resident lacks capacity to make health care decisions.
(2)The facility has been unable to locate a person with legal authority to make medical treatment decisions on behalf of the resident pursuant to Division 4.7 of the Probate Code, a guardian, conservator, or next of kin who is able and willing to make health care decisions on behalf of the resident.
(3)The medical intervention recommended or prescribed that requires informed consent and the identity of the person recommending or prescribing the medical intervention.
(4)The interdisciplinary team has reviewed the physicians determinations, and will continue to oversee any additional recommended or prescribed interventions unless or until a person with legal authority able and willing to make health care decisions on behalf of the resident is identified, or the attending physician or a court determines that the resident has regained the capacity to make health care decisions.
(5)The right of the resident to challenge the determinations made pursuant to this section, in a judicial proceeding.
(e)If a resident of a skilled nursing facility or intermediate care facility has been prescribed a medical intervention by a physician that requires informed consent and the physician has determined that the resident lacks capacity to make health care decisions and there is no person with legal authority able and willing to make those decisions on behalf of the resident, the facility shall, except as provided in subdivision (h), conduct an interdisciplinary team review of the prescribed medical intervention prior to the administration of the medical intervention. The interdisciplinary team shall oversee the care of the resident utilizing a team approach to assessment and care planning, and shall include the residents attending physician, a registered professional nurse with responsibility for the resident, other appropriate staff in disciplines as determined by the residents needs, and, if practicable, a resident representative, in accordance with applicable federal and state requirements. The review shall include all of the following:
(1)A review of the physicians assessment of the residents condition.
(2)The reason for the proposed use of the medical intervention.
(3)A discussion of the desires of the resident, if known. To determine the desires of the resident, the interdisciplinary team shall interview the resident, review the residents medical records, and consult with family members or friends, if any have been identified.
(4)The type of medical intervention to be used in the residents care, including its probable frequency and duration.
(5)The probable impact on the residents condition, with and without the use of the medical intervention.
(6)Reasonable alternative medical interventions considered or utilized and reasons for their discontinuance or inappropriateness.
(f)A resident representative may include a family member or friend of the resident who is unable to take full responsibility for the health care decisions of the resident, but who has agreed to serve on the interdisciplinary team, or other person authorized by state or federal law.
(g)The interdisciplinary team shall periodically evaluate the use of the prescribed medical intervention at least quarterly or upon a significant change in the residents medical condition.
(h)In case of an emergency, after obtaining a physicians order under subdivision (a), as necessary, a skilled nursing facility or intermediate care facility may administer a medical intervention that requires informed consent prior to the facility convening an interdisciplinary team review. If the emergency results in the application of physical or chemical restraints, the interdisciplinary team shall meet within one week of the emergency for an evaluation of the medical intervention.
(i)Physicians, skilled nursing facilities, and intermediate care facilities shall not be required to obtain a court order pursuant to Section 3201 of the Probate Code prior to administering a medical intervention that requires informed consent if the requirements of this section are met.
(j)Nothing in this section shall in any way affect the right of a resident of a skilled nursing facility or intermediate care facility for whom medical intervention has been prescribed, ordered, or administered pursuant to this section to seek appropriate judicial relief to review the decision to provide the medical intervention.
(k)No physician or other health care provider, whose action under this section is in accordance with reasonable medical standards, is subject to administrative sanction if the physician or health care provider believes in good faith that the action is consistent with this section and the desires of the resident, or if unknown, the best interests of the resident.
(l)The determinations required to be made pursuant to subdivisions (a), (e), and (g), and the basis for those determinations shall be documented in the residents medical record and shall be made available to the residents representative for review.
(a)If the attending physician and surgeon of a resident in a skilled nursing facility or intermediate care facility prescribes or orders a medical intervention that requires that informed consent be obtained prior to administration of the medical intervention, but is unable to obtain informed consent because the physician and surgeon determines that the resident lacks capacity to make decisions concerning his or her health care and that there is no person with legal authority to make those decisions on behalf of the resident, the physician and surgeon shall inform the skilled nursing facility or intermediate care facility.
(b)For purposes of subdivision (a), a resident lacks capacity to make a decision regarding his or her health care if the resident is unable to understand the nature and consequences of the proposed medical intervention, including its risks and benefits, or is unable to express a preference regarding the intervention. To make the determination regarding capacity, the physician shall interview the patient, resident, review the patients residents medical records, and consult with skilled nursing facility or intermediate care facility staff, as appropriate, and family members and friends of the resident, if any have been identified.
(c)For purposes of subdivision (a), a person with legal authority to make medical treatment decisions on behalf of a patient resident is a person designated under a valid Durable Power of Attorney for Health Care, a guardian, a conservator, or next of kin. To determine the existence of a person with legal authority, the physician shall interview the patient, resident, review the medical records of the patient, resident, and consult with skilled nursing facility or intermediate care facility staff, as appropriate, and with family members and friends of the resident, if any have been identified.
(d)The attending physician and the skilled nursing facility or intermediate care facility may initiate a medical intervention that requires informed consent pursuant to subdivision (e) in accordance with acceptable standards of practice. Before implementing a medical intervention that requires informed consent, if the resident lacks capacity to make health care decisions and there is no person with legal authority able and willing to make those decisions on behalf of the resident, the physician, skilled nursing facility, or intermediate care facility shall promptly notify the resident, orally and in writing, that it has been determined that the resident lacks capacity.
(e)Where If a resident of a skilled nursing facility or intermediate care facility has been prescribed a medical intervention by a physician and surgeon that requires informed consent and the physician has determined that the resident lacks capacity to make health care decisions and there is no person with legal authority to make those decisions on behalf of the resident, the facility shall, except as provided in subdivision (h), conduct an interdisciplinary team review of the prescribed medical intervention prior to the administration of the medical intervention. The interdisciplinary team shall oversee the care of the resident utilizing a team approach to assessment and care planning, and shall include the residents attending physician, a registered professional nurse with responsibility for the resident, other appropriate staff in disciplines as determined by the residents needs, and, where if practicable, a patient resident representative, in accordance with applicable federal and state requirements. The review shall include all of the following:
(1)A review of the physicians assessment of the residents condition.
(2)The reason for the proposed use of the medical intervention.
(3)A discussion of the desires of the patient, where resident, if known. To determine the desires of the resident, the interdisciplinary team shall interview the patient, resident, review the patients residents medical records, and consult with family members or friends, if any have been identified.
(4)The type of medical intervention to be used in the residents care, including its probable frequency and duration.
(5)The probable impact on the residents condition, with and without the use of the medical intervention.
(6)Reasonable alternative medical interventions considered or utilized and reasons for their discontinuance or inappropriateness.
(f)A patient resident representative may include a family member or friend of the resident who is unable to take full responsibility for the health care decisions of the resident, but who has agreed to serve on the interdisciplinary team, or other person authorized by state or federal law.
(g)The interdisciplinary team shall periodically evaluate the use of the prescribed medical intervention at least quarterly or upon a significant change in the residents medical condition.
(h)In case of an emergency, after obtaining a physician and surgeons physicians order under subdivision (a), as necessary, a skilled nursing facility or intermediate care facility may administer a medical intervention that requires informed consent prior to the facility convening an interdisciplinary team review. If the emergency results in the application of physical or chemical restraints, the interdisciplinary team shall meet within one week of the emergency for an evaluation of the medical intervention.
(i)Physicians and surgeons and Physicians, skilled nursing facilities, and intermediate care facilities shall not be required to obtain a court order pursuant to Section 3201 of the Probate Code prior to administering a medical intervention which that requires informed consent if the requirements of this section are met.
(j)Nothing in this section shall in any way affect the right of a resident of a skilled nursing facility or intermediate care facility for whom medical intervention has been prescribed, ordered, or administered pursuant to this section to seek appropriate judicial relief to review the decision to provide the medical intervention.
(k)No physician or other health care provider, whose action under this section is in accordance with reasonable medical standards, is subject to administrative sanction if the physician or health care provider believes in good faith that the action is consistent with this section and the desires of the resident, or if unknown, the best interests of the resident.
(l)The determinations required to be made pursuant to subdivisions (a), (e), and (g), and the basis for those determinations shall be documented in the patients residents medical record and shall be made available to the patients residents representative for review.
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Sep 18, 2018 | Chaptered by Secretary of State. Chapter 506, Statutes of 2018. |
| Sep 18, 2018 | Approved by the Governor. |
| Aug 28, 2018 | Enrolled and presented to the Governor at 3:30 p.m. |
| Aug 21, 2018 | Assembly amendments concurred in. (Ayes 31. Noes 6.) Ordered to engrossing and enrolling. |
| Aug 15, 2018 | From committee: That the Assembly amendments be concurred in. (Ayes 6. Noes 0.) |
| Aug 9, 2018 | From committee: Be re-referred to Com. on GOV. & F. pursuant to Senate Rule 29.10(d). (Ayes 5. Noes 0.) Re-referred to Com. on GOV. & F. |
| Aug 9, 2018 | Re-referred to Com. on RLS. pursuant to Senate Rule 29.10(d). |
| Aug 6, 2018 | In Senate. Concurrence in Assembly amendments pending. |
| Aug 6, 2018 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Senate. |
| Jun 28, 2018 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| Jun 27, 2018 | From committee: Do pass. (Ayes 5. Noes 1.) (June 27). |
| Jun 21, 2018 | From committee with author's amendments. Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on H. & C.D. |
| Jun 21, 2018 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on H. & C.D. (Ayes 6. Noes 1.) (June 20). Re-referred to Com. on H. & C.D. |
| Jun 14, 2018 | From committee: Be re-referred to Coms. on L. GOV. and H. & C.D. (Ayes 7. Noes 0.) (June 14). Re-referred to Com. on L. GOV. |
| Jun 7, 2018 | Re-referred to Com. on RLS. pursuant to Assembly Rule 96. |
| Jun 6, 2018 | From committee with author's amendments. Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on JUD. |
| Jul 10, 2017 | July 11 set for first hearing canceled at the request of author. |
| Jun 29, 2017 | Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on JUD. |
| Jun 28, 2017 | From committee: Do pass as amended and re-refer to Com. on JUD. (Ayes 15. Noes 0.) (June 27). |
| Jun 8, 2017 | Referred to Coms. on HEALTH and JUD. |
| May 31, 2017 | In Assembly. Read first time. Held at Desk. |
| May 30, 2017 | Read third time. Passed. (Ayes 27. Noes 12. Page 1247.) Ordered to the Assembly. |
| May 16, 2017 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| May 15, 2017 | From committee: Do pass. (Ayes 7. Noes 0. Page 1080.) (May 15). |
| May 4, 2017 | Set for hearing May 15. |
| Apr 26, 2017 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 7. Noes 0. Page 852.) (April 25). Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Apr 21, 2017 | Set for hearing April 25. |
| Apr 20, 2017 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on JUD. (Ayes 9. Noes 0. Page 808.) (April 19). Re-referred to Com. on JUD. |
| Apr 6, 2017 | From committee with author's amendments. Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on HEALTH. |
| Apr 4, 2017 | Set for hearing April 19. |
| Mar 2, 2017 | Referred to Coms. on HEALTH and JUD. |
| Feb 17, 2017 | From printer. May be acted upon on or after March 19. |
| Feb 16, 2017 | Introduced. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Aug 21, 2018 | Unfinished Business SB481 Pan Concurrence | Senate Floor |
Passed |
|
| Aug 15, 2018 | That the Assembly amendments be concurred in | Senate Standing Committee on Governance and Finance |
Passed |
|
| Aug 6, 2018 | SB 481 Pan Senate Third Reading By MCCARTY | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| Jun 27, 2018 | Do pass. | Assembly Standing Committee on Housing and Community Development |
Passed |
|
| Jun 20, 2018 | Do pass and be re-referred to the Committee on [Housing and Community Development] | Assembly Standing Committee on Local Government |
Passed |
|
| Jun 14, 2018 | Be re-referred to the Committees on [Local Government] and [Housing and Community Development] | Assembly Standing Committee on Rules |
Passed |
|
| Jun 27, 2017 | Do pass as amended and be re-referred to the Committee on [Judiciary] | Assembly Standing Committee on Health |
Passed |
|
| May 30, 2017 | Senate 3rd Reading SB481 Pan | Senate Floor |
Passed |
|
| May 15, 2017 | Do pass | Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Apr 25, 2017 | Do pass, but first be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Senate Standing Committee on Judiciary |
Passed |
|
| Apr 19, 2017 | Do pass, but first be re-referred to the Committee on [Judiciary] | Senate Standing Committee on Health |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | SB |
UNFINISHED BUSINESS
Bill No: SB 481
:
PRIOR VOTES NOT RELEVANT
SENATE GOVERNANCE & FIN. COMMITTEE: 6-0, 8/15/18 (Pursuant to Senate Rule 29.10)
AYES: McGuire, Nguyen, Beall, Hernandez, Hertzberg, Lara
NO VOTE RECORDED: Moorlach
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 53-22, 8/6/18 - See last page for vote
DIGEST:
This bill allows the County of Sacramento to dispose of a parcel to the City of Sacramento for an amount less than fair market value provided that the property is used for affordable housing purposes.
Assembly Amendments
delete the initial contents of SB 481 and insert the current language relating to redevelopment successor agencies.
Existing law:
- Dissolved redevelopment agencies (RDAs) and community development agencies as of February 1, 2012, and provides for the designation of successor agencies to wind down the affairs of the dissolved RDAs and to, among other things, dispose of assets and properties of the former RDA as directed by the oversight board of the successor agency.
- Requires a successor agency to dispose of specified assets and properties of the former redevelopment expeditiously and in a manner aimed at maximizing value.
This bill:
- Allows the successor agency to the Redevelopment Agency of the County of Sacramento, until January 1, 2022, to dispose of assets previously used as the San Juan Hotel and Mobile Home Park to the City of Sacramento or its housing successor agency for an amount less than fair market value provided that the successor agency requires that the property be used for housing affordable to, and occupied by, persons and families of low and moderate income, and very low-income and extremely low-income households, and include an enforceable covenant, as specified.
- Defines “assets previously used as the San Juan Hotel and Mobile Home Park” to mean a property, consisting of 2.55 acres, formerly known as the San Juan Hotel and Mobile Home Park located at 5700 Stockton Boulevard in Sacramento County.
- Finds and declares that this bill serves a public purpose of encouraging the construction of affordable housing in Sacramento County, and does not constitute a gift of public funds within the meaning of Section 6 of Article XVI of the California Constitution.
Background
Tax increment financing. Generally, property tax increment financing requires a local government to form a tax increment financing district to issue bonds and use the bond proceeds to pay project costs within the boundaries of a specified project area. To repay the bonds, the district captures increased property tax revenues that are generated when projects financed by the bonds increase assessed property values within the project area. To calculate the increased property tax revenues captured by the district, the amount of property tax revenues received by any local government participating in the district, referred to as taxing entities, is “frozen” at the amount it received from property within a project area prior to the project area’s formation. In future years, as the project area's assessed valuation grows above the frozen base, the resulting additional property tax revenues—the so-called property tax “increment” revenues—flow to the tax increment financing district instead of other local governments.
Redevelopment agencies. From the early 1950s until they were dissolved in 2011, the Community Redevelopment Law allowed local officials to create RDAs, prepare and adopt redevelopment plans, and finance redevelopment activities. RDAs used property tax increment financing to pay for economic development projects in “blighted” areas. As part of the 2011 Budget Act, and to protect funding for core public services at the local level, the Legislature approved the dissolution of the state’s more than 400 RDAs. After a period of litigation, RDAs were officially dissolved as of February 1, 2012. One of the successor agencies’ primary responsibilities is to make payments for enforceable obligations entered into by former RDAs, supported by property tax revenues that would have gone to RDAs. Any remaining property tax revenues that exceed these enforceable obligations return to cities, counties, special districts, and school and community college districts to support core public services. Successor agencies also manage redevelopment projects already underway and dispose of assets and properties owned by the now dissolved RDAs. Successor agencies can dispose of assets by selling them to other governments or interested parties provided that they are disposed of expeditiously and in a manner that maximizes value to the taxing entities.
County of Sacramento RDA dissolution. Sacramento County elected to serve as the successor agency to the county’s RDA for its non-housing assets and functions, while Sacramento Housing and Redevelopment Agency (SHRA) elected to serve as the successor agency for housing assets and functions. One of the county successor agency’s properties is the former San Juan Motel and Mobile Home Park located at 5700 Stockton Boulevard with an estimated fair market value of $442,400 according to an October 2015 appraisal. The property is adjacent to other properties managed by the SHRA. The City of Sacramento wants the Legislature to allow the Sacramento County Redevelopment Successor Agency to sell the San Juan Motel property to the City of Sacramento or its housing successor agency, at below market value. According to the City of Sacramento, since these properties are not owned by the same entity, neither the county’s successor agency nor the SHRA has been able to group these properties together to maximize their potential for development. This bill allows SHRA to develop a plan to group these properties together for development as affordable housing, which is in short supply in Sacramento and across California.
Comments
Purpose of the bill. According to the author, “SB 481 will provide the City of Sacramento with the much-needed opportunity to provide affordable housing at the site of the former San Juan Motel along Stockton Boulevard. Our city is in the midst of a housing crisis – the parcels in question are the only site in District 6 that can directly be used to provide affordable housing, and they are ideally situated along a convenient transportation corridor. Currently, the site is an unused empty lot which contributed to neighborhood blight due to the crime and illegal dumping which take place. By allowing the County’s Redevelopment Agency Successor Agency to dispose of the property for below market value, the City of Sacramento’s Housing Authority Successor Agency will be able to assume control of the former San Juan Motel property and aggregate it with adjacent parcels. Aggregating the parcels is the optimum strategy for ensuring that the future development will achieve its full potential to remove neighborhood blight and provide quality affordable housing to low-income residents.”
Setting a precedent. SB 481 provides legislative authorization for the transfer of a single piece of property at below market value without compensating taxing entities for any revenue lost by disposing of the property below market value. According to the City of Sacramento, purchasing the property at fair market value would make developing the property more challenging. However, successor agencies across the state have disposed of many properties without similar exceptions to current law.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: Fiscal Com.: Local:
City of Sacramento (source)
County of Sacramento
Sacramento Housing and Redevelopment Agency
Stockton Boulevard Partnership
30 individuals
OPPOSITION: (Verified 8/15/18)
None received
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 53-22, 8/6/18
AYES: Aguiar-Curry, Arambula, Berman, Bloom, Bonta, Burke, Caballero, Calderon, Cervantes, Chau, Chiu, Chu, Cooley, Cooper, Daly, Eggman, Frazier, Friedman, Gabriel, Cristina Garcia, Eduardo Garcia, Gipson, Gloria, Gonzalez Fletcher, Gray, Grayson, Holden, Irwin, Jones-Sawyer, Kalra, Kamlager-Dove, Levine, Limón, Low, McCarty, Medina, Mullin, Muratsuchi, Nazarian, O'Donnell, Quirk, Quirk-Silva, Reyes, Rodriguez, Rubio, Salas, Santiago, Mark Stone, Thurmond, Ting, Weber, Wood, Rendon
NOES: Acosta, Travis Allen, Baker, Bigelow, Brough, Chávez, Chen, Choi, Cunningham, Dahle, Fong, Gallagher, Harper, Kiley, Lackey, Maienschein, Mathis, Mayes, Obernolte, Patterson, Steinorth, Voepel
NO VOTE RECORDED: Carrillo, Flora, Melendez, Rivas, Waldron
8/15/18 14:14:58
**** END ****
SENATE COMMITTEE ON GOVERNANCE AND FINANCE
Senator Mike McGuire, Chair
2017 - 2018 Regular
Bill No: | SB 481 | Hearing Date: | 8/15/18 |
Author: | Pan | Tax Levy: | No |
Version: | 6/21/18 | Fiscal: | No |
Consultant: | Peterson | ||
Successor agencies: assets: disposal
Authorizes the successor agency to the Redevelopment Agency of the County of Sacramento to dispose of a specified property previously used as the San Juan Hotel and Mobile Home Park for an amount less than fair market value.
Background
Tax increment financing. Generally, property tax increment financing requires a local government to form a tax increment financing district to issue bonds and use the bond proceeds to pay project costs within the boundaries of a specified project area. To repay the bonds, the district captures increased property tax revenues that are generated when projects financed by the bonds increase assessed property values within the project area. To calculate the increased property tax revenues captured by the district, the amount of property tax revenues received by any local government participating in the district, referred to as taxing entities, is “frozen” at the amount it received from property within a project area prior to the project area’s formation. In future years, as the project area's assessed valuation grows above the frozen base, the resulting additional property tax revenues—the so-called property tax “increment” revenues—flow to the tax increment financing district instead of other local governments. After the bonds have been fully repaid using the property tax increment revenues, the district is dissolved, ending the diversion of property tax increment revenues from participating local governments.
Redevelopment agencies. From the early 1950s until they were dissolved in 2011, the Community Redevelopment Law allowed local officials to create redevelopment agencies (RDAs), prepare and adopt redevelopment plans, and finance redevelopment activities. RDAs used property tax increment financing to pay for economic development projects in “blighted” areas. Citing a significant State General Fund deficit, Governor Brown’s 2011-12 budget proposed eliminating RDAs and returning billions of dollars of property tax revenues to schools, cities, and counties to fund core services. Among the statutory changes that the Legislature adopted to implement the 2011-12 budget, AB X1 26 (Blumenfield, 2011) dissolved all RDAs. The California Supreme Court's 2011 ruling in California Redevelopment Association v. Matosantos upheld AB X1 26, but invalidated AB X1 27 (Blumenfield, 2011), which would have allowed most RDAs to avoid dissolution.
RDA dissolution. As part of the 2011 Budget Act, and to protect funding for core public services at the local level, the Legislature approved the dissolution of the state’s more than 400 RDAs. After a period of litigation, RDAs were officially dissolved as of February 1, 2012. AB X1 26 established successor agencies to manage the process of unwinding former RDAs’ affairs. With the exception of seven cities that chose not to serve as successor agencies, the city or county that created each former RDA now serves as that RDA’s successor agency. One of the successor agencies’ primary responsibilities is to make payments for enforceable obligations entered into by former RDAs, supported by property tax revenues that would have gone to RDAs. The statutory definition of an enforceable obligation includes bonds, specified bond-related payments, some loans, payments required by the federal government, obligations to the state, obligations imposed by state law, legally required payments related to RDA employees, judgments or settlements, and other legally binding and enforceable agreements or contracts that are not otherwise void. Any remaining property tax revenues that exceed these enforceable obligations return to cities, counties, special districts, and school and community college districts to support core public services. Successor agencies also manage redevelopment projects already underway and dispose of assets and properties owned by the now dissolved RDAs. Each successor agency has an oversight board that is responsible for both supervising and approving its actions. The Department of Finance (DOF) can review and request reconsideration of an oversight board’s decisions. Initially, once a successor agency took over for an RDA, it reviewed the RDA’s outstanding assets and obligations, and developed a plan to resolve those obligations. If DOF agreed with the plan, it issued a Finding of Completion. Within six months of receiving a Finding of Completion from DOF, successor agencies submitted a Long-Range Property Management Plan (LRPMP) to their oversight board and DOF for approval. These plans address how successor agencies plan to use or dispose of former RDAs’ real properties.
Disposal of Assets. Successor agencies can dispose of assets by selling them to other governments or interested parties, with both oversight board and DOF approval, provided that they are disposed of expeditiously and in a manner that maximizes value to the taxing entities. Maximizing value has generally been interpreted to mean the 2011 fair market value of the asset or property. The successor agency can also transfer ownership of assets that were constructed and used for a governmental purpose, such as police and fire stations, to the appropriate public jurisdiction. However, Community Redevelopment Law does not explicitly allow successor agencies to transfer ownership of assets that were constructed for non-governmental purposes, such as a motel or mobile home park. Rather than dispose of assets, a city, county, or city and county can retain a property currently owned by a successor agency for future redevelopment activities if it reaches compensation agreements with the taxing entities that stand to benefit from selling the property. These compensation agreements provide some revenue for these taxing entities that would not otherwise receive any if the property was retained and not sold. Current law does not require DOF or another entity to verify whether assets were disposed of in a manner that maximizes value to taxing entities once approved by the respective oversight board.
County of Sacramento RDA dissolution. Sacramento County elected to serve as the successor agency to the county’s RDA for its non-housing assets and functions, while Sacramento Housing and Redevelopment Agency (SHRA) elected to serve as the successor agency for housing assets and functions. The SHRA, which is a joint powers authority for both the county and the city, staffs and manages the housing assets and properties transferred to the city and county housing authorities.
The county’s successor agency assumed responsibility for the non-housing assets beginning on February 1, 2012. Sacramento County received notice of its Finding of Completion by DOF on July 16, 2013, and received its Oversight Board’s approval for the revised LRPMP on January 27, 2014, which was subsequently approved by DOF. One of the properties listed in the county successor agency’s LRPMP is the former San Juan Motel and Mobile Home Park located at 5700 Stockton Boulevard with an estimated fair market value of $442,400 according to an October 2015 appraisal. According to the 2014 LRPMP, the agency planned to sell the property. In fact, it is the last remaining property owned by the county’s successor agency and once it is sold and the successor agency’s remaining loans are paid off, the agency can be dissolved. The property is adjacent to other properties managed by the SHRA.
The City of Sacramento wants the Legislature to allow the Sacramento County Redevelopment Successor Agency to sell the San Juan Motel property to the City of Sacramento or its housing successor agency, at below market value. According to the City of Sacramento, since these properties are not owned by the same entity, neither the county’s successor agency nor the SHRA has been able to group these properties together to maximize their potential for development. This bill would allow SHRA to develop a plan to group these properties together for development as affordable housing, which is in short supply in Sacramento and across California.
Proposed Law
Senate Bill 481 allows, until January 1, 2022, the successor agency to Sacramento County’s RDA to dispose of the San Juan Hotel and Mobile Home Park property at below market value, notwithstanding the requirement in existing law that assets and properties are to be disposed of expeditiously and in a manner that maximizes value to the taxing entities. To do so, the successor agency must require, through an enforceable covenant, the property to be used for housing affordable to, and occupied by, low or moderate income, very low income, and extremely low income households. The bill authorizes the agency to dispose of the property only to the City of Sacramento or the housing successor agency to the City of Sacramento’s RDA. The bill also makes findings and declarations that the transfer of the property does not constitute a gift of public funds.
State Revenue Impact
No estimate.
Comments
1. Purpose of the bill. According to the author, “SB 481 will provide the City of Sacramento with the much-needed opportunity to provide affordable housing at the site of the former San Juan Motel along Stockton Boulevard. Our city is in the midst of a housing crisis – the parcels in question are the only site in District 6 that can directly be used to provide affordable housing, and they are ideally situated along a convenient transportation corridor. Currently, the site is an unused empty lot which contributed to neighborhood blight due to the crime and illegal dumping which take place. By allowing the County’s Redevelopment Agency Successor Agency to dispose of the property for below market value, the City of Sacramento’s Housing Authority Successor Agency will be able to assume control of the former San Juan Motel property and aggregate it with adjacent parcels. Aggregating the parcels is the optimum strategy for ensuring that the future development will achieve its full potential to remove neighborhood blight and provide quality affordable housing to low-income residents.”
2. Setting a precedent. SB 481 provides legislative authorization for the transfer of a single piece of property at below market value without compensating taxing entities for any revenue lost by disposing of the property below market value. According to the City of Sacramento, purchasing the property at fair market value would make developing the property more challenging. However, successor agencies across the state have disposed of many properties without similar exceptions to current law. The Committee may wish to consider whether granting an exception for Sacramento could set a precedent for other successor agencies to request permission to dispose of assets below market value.
3. Unknown unknowns. Current law requires successor agencies to dispose of assets expeditiously and in a manner that maximizes value. However, once an oversight board approves a transaction, there is not oversight to determine whether that transaction did in fact maximize value for taxing entities. On the one hand, without any statewide oversight over the disposal of these assets, it is unclear whether other properties throughout the state may have been disposed of below market value without special legislation. On the other hand, there may be additional properties throughout the state that remain undeveloped due to the limited ability for successor agencies to transfer assets between successor agencies for particular purposes, such as affordable housing. To the extent other projects are in a similar situation to this property, the development of certain projects and the dissolution of RDAs may be unnecessarily delayed. The Committee may wish to consider whether future changes to Community Redevelopment Law could be made to remove obstacles for prospective developments and streamline the dissolution process without considering special legislation for each property or asset.
4. Special legislation. The California Constitution prohibits special legislation when a general law can apply (Article IV, §16). SB 481 contains findings and declarations explaining the need for legislation that applies only to the property located at 5700 Stockton Boulevard in Sacramento County.
5. Gut and amend. As introduced and approved by the Senate, SB 481 contained provisions relating to patient consent in long-term health facilities. Amendments taken in the Assembly deleted the initial contents of SB 481 and inserted the current language relating to redevelopment successor agencies. Because this topic was never heard in the Senate, the Senate Rules Committee referred the amended bill under Senate Rule 29.10 to the Senate Governance and Finance Committee for a hearing on the Assembly’s amendments. At its August 15th hearing, the Committee has two choices:
- Hold the bill, or
- Return the bill to the Senate Floor.
Assembly Actions
Assembly Local Government Committee 6-1
Assembly Housing and Community Development Committee 5-1
Assembly Floor 53-22
Support and Opposition
(8/8/2018)
Support: City of Sacramento (sponsor); County of Sacramento; Sacramento Housing and Redevelopment Agency (SHRA); Stockton Boulevard Partnership; Thirty Individuals.
Opposition: Unknown.
-- END --
SENATE THIRD READING
STR Bill Id:SB 481
Author:(Pan)
As Amended Ver:June 21, 2018
Majority vote
SENATE VOTE: 27-12
Committee | Votes | Ayes | Noes |
Health | 15-0 | Wood, Maienschein, Bonta, Kalra, Gallagher, Limón, McCarty, Nazarian, Patterson, Ridley-Thomas, Rodriguez, Santiago, Thurmond, Waldron, Chau | |
Rules | 7-0 | Cooley, Cunningham, Carrillo, Cervantes, Gallagher, Nazarian, Salas | |
Local Government | 6-1 | Aguiar-Curry, Waldron, Bloom, Caballero, Gabriel, Rivas | Voepel |
Housing | 5-1 | Chiu, Chau, Gloria, Limón, Wood | Choi |
SUMMARY: Allows the County of Sacramento to dispose of a parcel for an amount less than fair market value provided that the property is used for affordable housing purposes. Specifically, this bill:
- Allows the successor agency to the Redevelopment Agency of the County of Sacramento, until January 1, 2022, to dispose of assets previously used as the San Juan Hotel and Mobile Home Park for an amount less than fair market value provided that the successor agency requires that the property be used for housing affordable to, and occupied by, persons and families of low and moderate income, and very low-income and extremely low-income households, and include an enforceable covenant, as specified.
- Defines the following terms:
- "Assets previously used as the San Juan Hotel and Mobile Home Park" to mean a property, consisting of 2.55 acres, formerly known as the San Juan Hotel and Mobile Home Park located at 5700 Stockton Boulevard in Sacramento County; and,
- "Dispose of" to mean to transfer or sell the property to the City of Sacramento or to the housing successor to the Redevelopment Agency of the City of Sacramento.
- Finds and declares that the bill serves a public purpose of encouraging the construction of affordable housing in Sacramento County, and does not constitute a gift of public funds within the meaning of the California Constitution Article XVI Section 6.
- Finds and declares that a special statute is necessary and that a general statute cannot be made applicable within the meaning of the California Constitution Article IV Section 16 because of the unique need of the successor agency to ensure that the assets of the former redevelopment agency are disposed of in a way that provides the maximum benefit to the community.
FISCAL EFFECT: None
COMMENTS:
- Redevelopment Agency (RDA) Dissolution. As part of the 2011 Budget Act, and in order to protect funding for core public services at the local level, the Legislature approved the dissolution of the state's 400 plus RDAs. After a period of litigation, RDAs were officially dissolved as of February 1, 2012. As a result of the elimination of the RDAs, property tax revenues are now being used to pay required payments on existing bonds, other obligations, and pass-through payments to local governments. The remaining property tax revenues that exceed the enforceable obligations are now being allocated to cities, counties, special districts, and school and community college districts, thereby providing critical resources to preserve core public services.
To help facilitate the wind-down process at the local level, successor agencies were established to manage redevelopment projects currently underway, make payments on enforceable obligations, and dispose of redevelopment assets and properties. Each successor agency had an Oversight Board that supervised its work. Oversight Board members have a fiduciary responsibility to holders of enforceable obligations, as well as to the local agencies that would benefit from property tax distributions from the former redevelopment project area.
Within six months after receiving a Finding of Completion from Department of Finance (DOF), successor agencies were required to submit for approval to their Oversight Boards and to DOF a Long-Range Property Management Plan (LRPMP) that addresses the disposition and use of the real properties of the former redevelopment agency. Existing law requires the disposal of property pursuant to the LRPMP to be done expeditiously and in a manner aimed at maximizing value, so that distribution of income to taxing entities is property to their property tax share.
- County of Sacramento RDA Dissolution. The County of Sacramento elected to serve as the successor agency to the Redevelopment Agency of the County of Sacramento for its non-housing assets and functions, which began on February 1, 2012. Sacramento County received notice of its Finding of Completion by DOF on July 16, 2013, and received Oversight Board approval of its revised LRPMP on January 27, 2014. The LRPMP addresses the disposition and use of the real properties of the former RDA, and was transmitted to DOF.
The property that is the subject of this bill is listed on that LRPMP, with an estimated fair market value of $900,000. The LRPMP from 2014 shows that the County plans to sell the property.
- Bill Summary. This bill allows the successor agency to the Redevelopment Agency of the County of Sacramento, until January 1, 2022, to dispose of assets previously used as the San Juan Hotel and Mobile Home Park for an amount less than fair market value, provided that the successor agency requires that the property be used for housing affordable to, and occupied by, persons and families of low and moderate income, and very low-income and extremely low-income households, and include an enforceable covenant, as specified. This bill also finds and declares that this does not constitute a gift of public funds.
This bill is sponsored by the City of Sacramento.
- Author's Statement. According to the author, "SB 481 will provide the City of Sacramento with the much-needed opportunity to provide affordable housing at the site of the former San Juan Motel along Stockton Boulevard. Our city is in the midst of a housing crisis – the parcels in question are the only site in District 6 that can directly be used to provide affordable housing, and they are ideally situated along a convenient transportation corridor. Currently, the site is an unused empty lot which contributed to neighborhood blight due to the crime and illegal dumping which take place.
"By allowing the County's Redevelopment Agency Successor Agency to dispose of the property for below market value, the City of Sacramento's Housing Authority Successor Agency will be able to assume control of the former San Juan Motel property and aggregate it with adjacent parcels. Aggregating the parcels is the optimum strategy for ensuring that the future development will achieve its full potential to remove neighborhood blight and provide quality affordable housing to low-income residents.
"We must act now to address the technicality that is standing in the way of the development of affordable housing at this site. Each month that we delay the aggregation of these parcels, and postpone further development, more Sacramento residents fall victim to the housing crisis as they are removed from their homes."
- Arguments in Support. Supporters argue that this bill will help revitalize a blighted area in the Stockton Boulevard Corridor and that this parcel that was housing is now locked in a bureaucratic situation that has prevented any progress.
- Arguments in Opposition. None on file.
Analysis Prepared by: Debbie Michel / L. GOV. / (916) 319-3958 FN: 0003664
Date of Hearing: June 27, 2018
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON HOUSING AND COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT
David Chiu, Chair
SBPCA Bill Id:SB 481
Author:(Pan) – As Amended Ver:June 21, 2018
SENATE VOTE: Not relevant
SUBJECT: Successor agencies: assets: disposal
SUMMARY: Allows the County of Sacramento to dispose of a parcel for an amount less
than fair market value provided that the property is used for affordable housing purposes. Specifically, this bill:
- Allows the successor agency to the Redevelopment Agency of the County of Sacramento, until January 1, 2022, to dispose of assets previously used as the San Juan Hotel and Mobile Home Park for an amount less than fair market value provided that the successor agency requires that the property be used for housing affordable to, and occupied by, persons and families of low and moderate income, and very low-income and extremely low-income households, and include an enforceable covenant, as specified.
- Defines “assets previously used as the San Juan Hotel and Mobile Home Park” to mean a property, consisting of 2.55 acres, formerly known as the San Juan Hotel and Mobile Home Park located at 5700 Stockton Boulevard in Sacramento County.
- Defines "dispose of" to mean to transfer or sell the San Juan Hotel and Mobile Home Park to the City of Sacramento or to the housing successor to the Redevelopment Agency of the City of Sacramento.
- Finds and declares that the bill serves a public purpose of encouraging the construction
of affordable housing in Sacramento County, and does not constitute a gift of public funds within the meaning of Section 6 of Article XVI of the California Constitution. - Finds and declares that a special statute is necessary and that a general statute cannot be made applicable within the meaning of Section 16 of Article IV of the California Constitution because of the unique need of the successor agency to ensure that the assets
of the former redevelopment agency are disposed of in a way that provides the maximum benefit to the community.
FISCAL EFFECT: None
COMMENTS:
RDA Dissolution: As part of the 2011 Budget Act, and in order to protect funding for core public services at the local level, the Legislature approved the dissolution of the state’s 400 plus RDAs. After a period of litigation, RDAs were officially dissolved as of February 1, 2012. As a result of the elimination of the RDAs, property tax revenues are now being used to pay required payments on existing bonds, other obligations, and pass-through payments to local governments. The remaining property tax revenues that exceed the enforceable obligations are now being allocated to cities, counties, special districts, and school and community college districts, thereby providing critical resources to preserve core public services.
To help facilitate the wind-down process at the local level, successor agencies were established to manage redevelopment projects currently underway, make payments on enforceable obligations, and dispose of redevelopment assets and properties. Each successor agency had an Oversight Board that supervised its work. Oversight Board members have a fiduciary responsibility to holders of enforceable obligations, as well as to the local agencies that would benefit from property tax distributions from the former redevelopment project area.
Within six months after receiving a Finding of Completion from DOF, successor agencies were required to submit for approval to their Oversight Boards and to DOF a Long-Range Property Management Plan (LRPMP) that addresses the disposition and use of the real properties of the former redevelopment agency. Existing law requires the disposal of property pursuant to the LRPMP to be done expeditiously and in a manner aimed at maximizing value, so that distribution of income to taxing entities is property to their property tax share.
County of Sacramento RDA Dissolution. The County of Sacramento elected to serve as the successor agency to the Redevelopment Agency of the County of Sacramento for its non-housing assets and functions, which began on February 1, 2012. Sacramento County received notice of its Finding of Completion by DOF on July 16, 2013, and received Oversight Board approval of its revised LRPMP on January 27, 2014. The LRPMP addresses the disposition and use of the real properties of the former RDA, and was transmitted to DOF.
The property that is the subject of this bill is listed on that LRPMP, with an estimated fair market value of $900,000. The LRPMP from 2014 shows that the County plans to sell the property.
This bill allows the successor agency to the Redevelopment Agency of the County of Sacramento, until January 1, 2022, to dispose of assets previously used as the San Juan Hotel and Mobile Home Park for an amount less than fair market value, provided that the successor agency requires that the property be used for housing affordable to, and occupied by, persons and families of low and moderate income, and very low-income and extremely low-income households, and include an enforceable covenant, as specified. This bill also finds and declares that this does not constitute a gift of public funds.
Purpose of this bill: According to the author, “SB 481 will provide the City of Sacramento with the much-needed opportunity to provide affordable housing at the site of the former San Juan Motel along Stockton Boulevard. Our city is in the midst of a housing crisis – the parcels in question are the only site in District 6 that can directly be used to provide affordable housing, and they are ideally situated along a convenient transportation corridor. Currently, the site is an unused empty lot which contributed to neighborhood blight due to the crime and illegal dumping which take place.
“By allowing the County’s Redevelopment Agency Successor Agency to dispose of the property for below market value, the City of Sacramento’s Housing Authority Successor Agency will be able to assume control of the former San Juan Motel property and aggregate it with adjacent parcels. Aggregating the parcels is the optimum strategy for ensuring that the future development will achieve its full potential to remove neighborhood blight and provide quality affordable housing to low-income residents.
“We must act now to address the technicality that is standing in the way of the development of affordable housing at this site. Each month that we delay the aggregation of these parcels, and postpone further development, more Sacramento residents fall victim to the housing crisis as they are removed from their homes.”
Double referred: This bill is double referred. It was heard in the Assembly Committee on Local Government and passed out on a vote of 6-1 on June 20, 2018.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
City of Sacramento (sponsor)
Eric Guerra, Councilmember, City of Sacramento
Patrick D. Kennedy, Sacramento County Supervisor, District 2
Sacramento Housing and Redevelopment Agency
Stockton Boulevard Partnership
Opposition
None on file
Analysis Prepared by: Lisa Engel / H. & C.D. / (916) 319-2085
Date of Hearing: June 20, 2018
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON LOCAL GOVERNMENT
Cecilia Aguiar-Curry, Chair
SBPCA Bill Id:SB 481
Author:(Pan) – As Amended Ver:June 6, 2018
SENATE VOTE: Not relevant
SUBJECT: Successor agencies: assets: disposal.
SUMMARY: Allows the County of Sacramento to dispose of a parcel for an amount less
than fair market value provided that the property is used for affordable housing purposes. Specifically, this bill:
- Allows the successor agency to the Redevelopment Agency of the County of Sacramento, until January 1, 2022, to dispose of assets previously used as the San Juan Hotel and Mobile Home Park for an amount less than fair market value provided that the successor agency requires that the property be used for housing affordable to, and occupied by, persons and families of low and moderate income, and very low-income and extremely low-income households, and include an enforceable covenant, as specified.
- Defines “assets previously used as the San Juan Hotel and Mobile Home Park” to mean a property, consisting of 2.55 acres, formerly known as the San Juan Hotel and Mobile Home Park located at 5700 Stockton Boulevard in Sacramento County.
- Finds and declares that the bill serves a public purpose of encouraging the construction
of affordable housing in Sacramento County, and does not constitute a gift of public funds within the meaning of Section 6 of Article XVI of the California Constitution. - Finds and declares that a special statute is necessary and that a general statute cannot be made applicable within the meaning of Section 16 of Article IV of the California Constitution because of the unique need of the successor agency to ensure that the assets
of the former redevelopment agency are disposed of in a way that provides the maximum benefit to the community.
FISCAL EFFECT: None
COMMENTS:
- RDA Dissolution. As part of the 2011 Budget Act, and in order to protect funding for core public services at the local level, the Legislature approved the dissolution of the state’s 400 plus RDAs. After a period of litigation, RDAs were officially dissolved as of February 1, 2012. As a result of the elimination of the RDAs, property tax revenues are now being used to pay required payments on existing bonds, other obligations, and pass-through payments to local governments. The remaining property tax revenues that exceed the enforceable obligations are now being allocated to cities, counties, special districts, and school and community college districts, thereby providing critical resources to preserve core public services.
To help facilitate the wind-down process at the local level, successor agencies were established to manage redevelopment projects currently underway, make payments on enforceable obligations, and dispose of redevelopment assets and properties. Each successor agency had an Oversight Board that supervised its work. Oversight Board members have a fiduciary responsibility to holders of enforceable obligations, as well as to the local agencies that would benefit from property tax distributions from the former redevelopment project area.
Within six months after receiving a Finding of Completion from DOF, successor agencies were required to submit for approval to their Oversight Boards and to DOF a Long-Range Property Management Plan (LRPMP) that addresses the disposition and use of the real properties of the former redevelopment agency. Existing law requires the disposal of property pursuant to the LRPMP to be done expeditiously and in a manner aimed at maximizing value, so that distribution of income to taxing entities is property to their property tax share.
- County of Sacramento RDA Dissolution. The County of Sacramento elected to serve as the successor agency to the Redevelopment Agency of the County of Sacramento for its non-housing assets and functions, which began on February 1, 2012. Sacramento County received notice of its Finding of Completion by DOF on July 16, 2013, and received Oversight Board approval of its revised LRPMP on January 27, 2014. The LRPMP addresses the disposition and use of the real properties of the former RDA, and was transmitted to DOF.
The property that is the subject of this bill is listed on that LRPMP, with an estimated fair market value of $900,000. The LRPMP from 2014 shows that the County plans to sell the property.
- Bill Summary. This bill allows the successor agency to the Redevelopment Agency of the County of Sacramento, until January 1, 2022, to dispose of assets previously used as the San Juan Hotel and Mobile Home Park for an amount less than fair market value, provided that the successor agency requires that the property be used for housing affordable to, and occupied by, persons and families of low and moderate income, and very low-income and extremely low-income households, and include an enforceable covenant, as specified. This bill also finds and declares that this does not constitute a gift of public funds.
This bill is sponsored by the City of Sacramento.
- Author’s Statement. According to the author, “SB 481 will provide the City of Sacramento with the much-needed opportunity to provide affordable housing at the site of the former San Juan Motel along Stockton Boulevard. Our city is in the midst of a housing crisis – the parcels in question are the only site in District 6 that can directly be used to provide affordable housing, and they are ideally situated along a convenient transportation corridor. Currently, the site is an unused empty lot which contributed to neighborhood blight due to the crime and illegal dumping which take place.
“By allowing the County’s Redevelopment Agency Successor Agency to dispose of the property for below market value, the City of Sacramento’s Housing Authority Successor Agency will be able to assume control of the former San Juan Motel property and aggregate it with adjacent parcels. Aggregating the parcels is the optimum strategy for ensuring that the future development will achieve its full potential to remove neighborhood blight and provide quality affordable housing to low-income residents.
“We must act now to address the technicality that is standing in the way of the development of affordable housing at this site. Each month that we delay the aggregation of these parcels, and postpone further development, more Sacramento residents fall victim to the housing crisis as they are removed from their homes.”
- Policy Considerations. The Committee may wish to consider the following:
- Fulfilling the Intent. The author and sponsor indicate that the bill is intended to allow the County Successor Agency to sell the property, at less than market value, to the City
of Sacramento, so that the property can be aggregated with other surrounding parcels already owned by the Sacramento Housing and Redevelopment Agency (SHRA). However, there is nothing in the bill that requires the County to sell to the City or SHRA (which serves as the housing successor), and instead, leaves the issue of who the County can sell to unaddressed.
- Fulfilling the Intent. The author and sponsor indicate that the bill is intended to allow the County Successor Agency to sell the property, at less than market value, to the City
- Committee Amendments. To address the concern raised above, the Committee may wish to consider amending the bill to specifically require the County to sell the property to the City or to the City of Sacramento’s housing successor. Due to timing with the double-referral, amendments will be taken in the Housing and Community Development Committee.
- Arguments in Support. Supporters argue that this bill will help revitalize a blighted area in the Stockton Boulevard Corridor and that this parcel that was housing is now locked in a bureaucratic situation that has prevented any progress.
- Arguments in Opposition. None on file.
- Double-referral. This bill was gutted and amended on June 6, 2018, and is double-referred to the Housing and Community Development Committee.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
City of Sacramento [SPONSOR]
Eric Guerra, Councilmember, City of Sacramento
Sacramento Housing and Redevelopment Agency
Opposition
None on file
Analysis Prepared by: Debbie Michel / L. GOV. / (916) 319-3958
Date of Hearing: July 11, 2017
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON JUDICIARY
Mark Stone, Chair
SBPCA Bill Id:SB 481
Author:(Pan) – As Amended Ver:June 29, 2017
SENATE VOTE: 27-12
SUBJECT: LONG-TERM HEALTH FACILITIES: INFORMED CONSENT
KEY ISSUE: IN ORDER TO TEMPORarily address the apparent constitutional shortcomings of existing law without affecting pending litigation about that law, should the legislature create a process for notifying residents of skilled nursing facilities or intermediate care facilitIes about the intent of those facilities to prescribe or administer a medical intervention when the person lacks capacity to consent to such an intervention?
SYNOPSIS
This bill seeks, in order to address apparent constitutional shortcomings in existing law, to create a process for notifying a person about the intent of a skilled nursing facility (SNF), or intermediate care facility (ICF), to prescribe or administer a medical intervention when the person lacks capacity to consent to such an intervention. It seeks to amend a provision of existing law found to be unconstitutional by an Alameda County court in 2015. In June of 2015, the Alameda County Superior Court ruled, in CANHR v. Chapman, that Section 1418.8 is unconstitutional as applied because of the following: 1) it does not require that the resident be adequately notified of the determination of incapacity, the determination of the absence of a legal substitute decision maker, the prescribed medical intervention, and the right to seek judicial review; 2) it cannot be used for the administration of antipsychotic drugs to residents, except in emergency situations; and, 3) it cannot be the basis to make end of life decisions regarding the withholding or withdrawal of life-sustaining treatment for residents. Both parties have appealed: The decision has been stayed, pending appeal, and thus the Section 1418.8 process is allowed to continue pending resolution of the case on appeal. As a result of the trial court ruling, parties are in the difficult position of either not providing medical care, delaying care until a court order is obtained, or waiting until the need for medical care is acute so that it can be provided in an emergency room setting.
When an adult is incapacitated, certain third parties have legal authority to make health care decisions on behalf of that individual. The third party may be a court-appointed conservator authorized to make health care decisions on behalf of the adult pursuant to Probate Code Section 2355. It may also be one of the following: (1) a person designated by the individual as an “agent” in a power of attorney for health care to make a health care decision for the individual (or “principal”), regardless of whether the person is known as an agent, attorney in fact, or by some other term (Probate Code Section 4607); (2) a person identified by way of a written or oral designation (including a surrogate designation); or (3) a person identified in a Physician Order for Life Sustaining Treatment (POLST) form. All of these designations require that the adult needing assistance from a third party for health care decisions either makes the designation when he or she still has the capacity to do so, has the assistance of the Probate Court, or has a family member or close friend who can be designated to make health care decisions. This bill seeks to address situations where a person is a resident of a SNF or ICF, lacks the capacity to make his or her own health care decisions, and has none of these legally recognized third parties to make medical decisions on his or her behalf.
In order to address the apparent constitutional deficiencies of Section 1418.8 in a manner that respects the rights of residents and ensures that the changes to Section 1418.8 do not affect the outcome of pending litigation and are in effect on a temporary basis until the resolution of the litigation, the Committee proposes the following amendments in concept:
- A statement of legislative intent, indicating that the Legislature is aware of the CANHR case and it is the express intent of the Legislature that no party in that pending litigation be in any way prejudiced by the passage of this act, and that this bill shall not be indicative of any legislative intent concerning any issues before the courts in that litigation.
- Further clarification about the notice that must be provided by the skilled nursing facility or intermediate care facility to the resident, stating that the notice must meet specified requirements.
- Further clarification about the procedure to follow if the resident objects to the recommended medical intervention.
- A requirement for the facility to provide to the resident information on the availability of advocacy assistance and contact information for groups that can provide advocacy and assistance, including the Long-Term Care Ombudsman.
- A prohibition on initiation of medical intervention that requires informed consent in accordance with acceptable standards of practice until after the notice has been provided to the resident and any relevant court proceedings initiated by the resident or his or her representative have been exhausted.
- A sunset provision on the section amended by the bill indicating that it shall be repealed on December 31, 2019, unless a later enacted statute deletes or extends that date.
In its current form, the bill is supported by the Association of California Healthcare Districts; California Association of Health Facilities; California Hospital Association; California Medical Association; San Diego Regional Chamber of Commerce. California Advocates for Nursing Home Reform and Disability Rights California (DRC) oppose the bill in its current form (unless amended in the case of DRC). It is unknown how the Committee’s proposed amendments would affect the support and opposition of all the above groups, but the amendments appear to address concerns raised by the groups in opposition to the bill. In addition, at the time of this writing it was not clear if the author would accept those amendments.
SUMMARY: Provides a process for a physician, skilled nursing facility (SNF), or intermediate care facility (ICF), before implementing a health care decision about a medical intervention that requires informed consent, to notify a resident that the resident's attending physician has determined that the resident lacks capacity. Specifically, this bill:
- Requires a physician, SNF, or ICF to promptly notify a resident, before implementing a healthcare decision about a medical intervention that requires informed consent, if the resident lacks the capacity to make health care decisions and there is no person with legal authority able and willing to make decisions on behalf of the patient, both orally and in writing, of the following information:
- The resident's attending physician has determined that the resident lacks capacity to make health care decisions;
- The facility has been unable to locate a person with legal authority to make medical treatment decisions on behalf of the resident, a guardian, conservator, or next of kin who is able and willing to make health care decisions on behalf of the resident;
- The medical intervention recommended or prescribed that requires informed consent and the identity of the person recommending or prescribing the medical intervention;
- That an interdisciplinary team will review or has reviewed the physician's determinations, and will continue to oversee any additional recommended or prescribed interventions, unless or until a person with legal authority is able and willing to make health care decisions on behalf of the resident is identified, or the attending physician or a court determines that the resident has regained the capacity to make health care decisions; and,
- The right of the resident to challenge these determinations in a judicial proceeding.
- Makes technical and clarifying changes regarding who has legal authority to make medical treatment decisions on behalf of a resident of a SNF or ICF.
EXISTING LAW:
- Licenses and regulates SNFs and ICFs by the Department of Public Health (DPH). Defines SNFs as health facilities that provide skilled nursing care and supportive care to patients whose primary need is for availability of skilled nursing care on an extended basis. ICFs are defined as health facilities that provide inpatient care to ambulatory or non-ambulatory patients who have recurring need for skilled nursing supervision and need supportive care, but who do not require the availability of continuous skilled nursing care.
- Permits an attending physician and a SNF or ICF to initiate a medical intervention for a resident of a SNF or ICF that requires informed consent, when the physician has determined the resident lacks the capacity to make health care decisions and there is no person with legal authority to make those decisions on behalf of the resident, in accordance with acceptable standards of practice. (Health & Safety Code Section 1418.8 (a). All further statutory references are to this code, unless otherwise indicated.)
- Provides for the physician to interview the patient, review the resident’s medical records, consult with SNF or ICF staff as appropriate, and identified family members or friends when determining the resident’s capacity to consent. (Section 1418.8 (b).)
- Allows the attending physician and SNF or ICF to initiate medical intervention that requires informed consent pursuant to interdisciplinary team review and in accordance with acceptable standards and practice. (Section 1418.8 (d).)
- Requires, when a patient of an SNF or ICF who has been prescribed a medical intervention by a physician and surgeon that requires informed consent and the physician has determined that the resident lacks capacity to make health care decisions and there is no person with legal authority to make those decisions, the facility to conduct an interdisciplinary team review of the prescribed medical intervention prior to the administration of the medical intervention or treatment; requires the interdisciplinary team to oversee the care of the resident utilizing a team approach to assessment and care planning, and shall include the resident’s attending physician, a registered professional nurse with responsibility for the resident, other appropriate staff in disciplines as determined by the resident’s needs, and, where practicable, a patient representative, in accordance with applicable state and federal requirements. (Section 1418.8 (e).)
- Allows a family member or friend of the resident who is unable to take full responsibility for the health care decisions of the resident, but who has agreed to serve on the interdisciplinary team, or the other person authorized by state or federal law, to serve as a patient representative on the interdisciplinary team. (Section 1418.8 (f).)
- Requires an interdisciplinary team to periodically evaluate the use of the prescribed medical intervention at least quarterly or upon significant change in the resident’s medical condition. (Section 1418.8 (g).)
- Provides that in case of an emergency, after obtaining a physician and surgeon’s order as necessary, a skilled nursing or intermediate care facility may administer a medical intervention that requires informed consent prior to the facility convening an interdisciplinary team review; requires that, if the emergency results in the application of physical or chemical restraints, the interdisciplinary team must meet within one week of the emergency for an evaluation of the medical intervention. (Section 1418.8 (h).)
- Specifies that physicians, surgeons, SNFs, and ICFs are not required to obtain a court order pursuant to Section 3201 of the Probate Code prior to administering a medication intervention which requires informed consent if the requirements of this section are met. (Section 1418.8 (i).)
- Allows a resident of a SNF or ICF for whom medical intervention has been prescribed, ordered, or administered to seek appropriate judicial relief to review the decision to provide the medical intervention. (Section 1418.8 (j).)
- Protects a physician or other health care provider, whose action is in accordance with reasonable medical standards, from being subject to administrative sanction if the physician or health care provider believes in good faith that the action is consistent with this section and the desires of the resident, or if unknown, the best interest of the resident. (Section 1418.8 (k).)
- Requires the determinations required to be made when a patient is determined to lack capacity to make a decision regarding his or her health care and an interdisciplinary team review is conducted, and the basis for those determinations to be documented in the patient’s medical record and shall be made available to the patient’s representative for review. (Section 1418.8 (l).)
- Allows a person designated by the individual as an “agent” in a power of attorney for health care to make a health care decision for the individual (or “principal”), regardless of whether the person is known as an agent, attorney in fact, or by some other term. (Probate Code Section 4607.)
- Allows a person identified in a Physician Order for Life Sustaining Treatment (POLST) to make end of life health care decisions for a person who designates them to do so in the POLST form, which is generally filled out by an individual or a third party (usually a family member or close friend) with the individual’s physician, and is generally used to guide actions by emergency medical personnel or other health care providers near the end of the patient’s life. (Probate Code Section 4780 et seq.)
- Provides that if a court has adjudicated that a conservatee lacks capacity to make health care decisions, the conservator has exclusive authority to make health care decisions in accordance with the conservatee’s health care instructions and other wishes to the extent known, and if unknown, then in accordance with the conservatee’s best interest. (Probate Code Section 2355.)
FISCAL EFFECT: As currently in print this bill is keyed fiscal.
COMMENTS: This bill seeks, in order to address apparent constitutional shortcomings in existing law, to create a process for notifying a person about the intent of a skilled nursing facility (SNF), or intermediate care facility (ICF), to prescribe or administer a medical intervention when the person lacks capacity to consent to such an intervention. It seeks to amend a provision of existing law found to be unconstitutional by an Alameda County court in 2015. As a result, parties are in the difficult position of either not providing medical care, delaying care until a court order is obtained, or waiting until the need for medical care is acute so that it can be provided in an emergency room setting. Even Disability Rights California, which opposes the bill (unless amended) acknowledges the difficulty:
However, the sponsors of the bill present the legitimate concern that judicial action upholding the trial court’s decision in the Chapman litigation invalidating the notice provisions in section 1418.8 would leave no process in place until such time as the Legislature can act.
At the same time, the Legislature in general and this Committee in particular are reluctant to intervene in, or change the outcome of, pending litigation.
Third parties authorized to make health care decisions on behalf of an incapacitated adult. When an adult is incapacitated, certain third parties have legal authority to make health care decisions on behalf of that individual. The third party may be a court-appointed conservator authorized to make health care decisions on behalf of the adult pursuant to Probate Code Section 2355. It may also be one of the following: (1) a person designated by the individual as an “agent” in a power of attorney for health care to make a health care decision for the individual (or “principal”), regardless of whether the person is known as an agent, attorney in fact, or by some other term (Probate Code Section 4607); (2) a person identified by way of a written or oral designation (including a surrogate designation); or (3) a person identified in a Physician Order for Life Sustaining Treatment (POLST) form.
If a court has adjudicated that a conservatee lacks capacity to make health care decisions, the conservator has exclusive authority to make health care decisions in accordance with the conservatee’s health care instructions and other wishes to the extent known, and if unknown, then in accordance with the conservatee’s best interest. (Probate Code Section 2355.) An agent effectively makes health care decisions with the same authority as the individual when the individual becomes incapacitated, unless otherwise specified. (Section 4678.) A surrogate is an adult, other than an individual’s agent or conservator, authorized to make health care decisions for the individual. (Probate Code Section 4643.) An individual designates a surrogate to make health care decisions by personally informing a supervising health care provider of the surrogate. (Probate Code Section 4711 (a).) A surrogate designation is only effective for the course of treatment or illness or during the stay at a health care institution when the individual designated the surrogate, or for a period of 60 days, whichever is shorter. (Probate Code Section 4711 (b).)
A POLST form is different than an advanced health care directive (AHCD) in that it is generally filled out by an individual or a third party (usually a family member or close friend) with the individual’s physician, and is generally used to guide actions by emergency medical personnel or other health care providers near the end of the patient’s life. (Probate Code Section 4780 et seq.) The POLST form allows a broader group of individuals to act as decision makers on behalf of an individual, including that person’s spouse, registered domestic partner, closest available relative, or person whom the individual’s medical professional signing the order believes best knows what is in the individual’s best interest and will make decisions in accordance with the individual’s expressed wishes and values to the extent known. Unlike an AHCD, this broader group of medical decision makers can execute a POLST on behalf of an incapacitated individual and in this way may make health care decisions for the individual.
All of these designations require that the adult needing assistance from a third party for health care decisions either makes the designation when he or she still has the capacity to do so, has the assistance of the Probate Court, or has a family member or close friend who can be designated to make health care decisions. This bill seeks to address situations where a person is a resident of a SNF or ICF, lacks the capacity to make his or her own health care decisions, and has none of these legally recognized third parties to make medical decisions on his or her behalf.
Estimated number of adults who would be affected by the bill. As explained above, only adults who do not have capacity to make their own health care decisions and who do not have a third party designated to act on their behalf would be affected by the provisions of this bill. How many such adults are in such situations? Estimates vary. The California Association of Health Facilities estimates the number at somewhere between 6,000 to 12,000 residents in the state, while other estimates put the number at 3% to 4% of all SNF and ICF residents (roughly 3,000 to 4,000 people). These are rough estimates of the number of SNF and ICF residents who could be affected by the bill, but certainly not all residents would necessarily require a medical intervention in any given year. And while these numbers are not huge, the impact on patients, medical providers, and care facilities—as explained below--is significant.
Background about the Epple Bill and CANHR v. Chapman. In 1992, the Legislature enacted Health and Safety Code Section 1418.8 in AB 3209 (Epple), Chapter 1303, Statutes of 1992, to address the problem of providing nonemergency medical treatment to nursing home patients who lack the capacity to consent to such treatment and who have no legally authorized decision makers to consent to treatment on their behalf. Prior to AB 3209, a medical provider or facility could file a petition seeking court authorization for treatment under the Probate Code, but this process could take up to six months. AB 3209 (known as the “Epple Bill”) established the process that is sought to be modified by this bill. It allows a physician to make a determination that a resident lacks capacity to provide informed consent, and to prescribe a medical intervention subject to review by an interdisciplinary team (IDT) at the facility.
The Epple Bill was immediately challenged as an unconstitutional violation of due process and privacy rights, but was initially found constitutional in Raines vs. Belshe (1995) 32 Cal. App. 4th 157. More than 15 years later, California Advocates for Nursing Home Reform (CANHR) filed a civil action against the Department of Public Health (DPH), CANHR v. Ronald Chapman, M.D. (Case No. RG13700100), alleging that Health and Safety Code Section 1418.8 was constitutionally deficient on its face for the following reasons:
- The right to due process regarding the right to notice and opportunity to oppose: (1) determination of decisional incapacity, (2) the determination of the absence of a legal substitute decision maker, (3) the hearing or review as to medical treatment, and, (4) the administration or withdrawal of medical treatment.
- The right to due process by failing to require adequate representation at the determination of incapacity.
- The right to privacy by permitting physician to make legal adjudications as to decisional incapacity.
- The right to due process by failing to require neutral decision makers at the adjudications as to decisional incapacity.
- The violation of the right to due process by failing to require a neutral decision maker at the review and approval or rejection of the treatment.
CANHR also alleged that Section 1418.8 was unconstitutional as applied by DPH for the following reasons:
- DPH fails to require a patient representative at the review to determine treatment.
- DPH failed to apply the statute to antipsychotic drugs, or in the alternative, failed to provide adequate notice, counsel, evidence and a judicial hearing as to incapacity, necessity and the least intrusive alternative.
- DPH precluded the use of statute for treatments or discontinuation thereof which would result in death, such as, but not limited to, do not resuscitate, comfort care or discontinuation of treatment, or for Physician Order for Life Sustaining Treatment orders.
In June of 2015, the Alameda County Superior Court agreed with CANHR that Section 1418.8 is unconstitutional as applied because of the following: 1) it does not require that the resident be adequately notified of the determination of incapacity, the determination of the absence of a legal substitute decision maker, the prescribed medical intervention, and the right to seek judicial review; 2) it cannot be used for the administration of antipsychotic drugs to residents, except in emergency situations; and, 3) it cannot be the basis to make end of life decisions regarding the withholding or withdrawal of life-sustaining treatment for residents. Both parties have appealed: The decision has been stayed, pending appeal, and thus the Section 1418.8 process is allowed to continue pending resolution of the case on appeal.
This bill seeks to address only the first cause of action that the court found unconstitutional: the need for the resident to be notified of the facility’s determination that he or she lacks capacity and has no legally authorized decision maker, a prescribed medical intervention is needed, and the right of the person to seek judicial review of these determinations.
The impact of CANHR v. Chapman on incapacitated adults without third party medical decisionmakers, their medical providers, and the facilities where they live. As mentioned above, the decision in CANHR v. Chapman that found Section 1418.8 to be constitutionally flawed is currently stayed pending appeal of the case. In other words, health facilities and medical providers may rely on a statute that has been found, at least by one court, to be unconstitutional and may be ultimately be held unconstitutional by a court of appeal.
According to the California Association of Health Facilities, facilities have a number of less than ideal options for how to proceed:
The court’s order is stayed pending appeal, meaning SNFs are still allowed to utilize the invaluable care to residents under Section 1418.8. If the order becomes effective, it will negatively affect thousands of SNF patients throughout the state who lack capacity and surrogate decision makers, forcing SNFs to choose one of the following options (1) leave the patients untreated; (2) transfer patients to an acute care hospital, which is known to cause transfer trauma to these patients; or (3) treat the patients illegally, resulting in expensive litigation and penalties.
Californians for Nursing Home Reform, plaintiff in CANHR v. Chapman, writes that the bill in print is an inadequate response to the constitutional defects in Section 1418.8:
Regarding the issue of notice, SB 481 fails to require the notice be in advance of the critical acts in Section 1418.8. The bill permits after-the-fact notifications (“the interdisciplinary team will review or [already] has reviewed the physician’s determinations”) that a physician assessed a resident’s capacity and was searching for possible surrogates and that an inter-disciplinary team (IDT) has met to review the physician’s assessments and proposed treatment. A central tenet of due process is notice be given in a way that provides a meaningful opportunity to be heard and influence outcomes. Notice after-the-fact is more worthless than meaningful.
Disability Rights California, which opposes the bill (unless amended), suggests a number of amendments to address its concerns:
[I]n order to ensure that a notice provision remains in place before a medical intervention that requires informed consent is taken DRC proposes these amendments.
First, there should be a provision that SB 481 is not intended to alter, impact or influence the appellate courts’ review of the Chapman case and that the provisions contained in the bill are intended as an interim provision until such time as there is a final decision from the courts.
Second, the bill should sunset within a reasonable period of time after a final judicial decision to allow the Legislature to act following the judicial decision. This would permit the Legislature to fully consider the conclusions of the courts on the constitutionality of the various provisions of section 1418.8. It would also permit the Legislature to then consider as a whole the issues presented in this bill in the context of the other intertwined issues presented in the litigation.
Finally, even though the bill would be an interim measure it should ensure some basic components of effective notice. Those components include: oral and written notice to the resident or person with legal authority to make decisions on behalf of the resident as soon as possible after the facility has been informed by the physician of the need for a medical intervention but no later than forty-eight hours; the notice be in plain language and in the resident’s preferred language; in the event the resident objects to the medical intervention and intends to challenge in a judicial proceeding the determination the medical intervention should be delayed for a reasonable period as long as the delay does not present an immediate risk to the resident; the notice advise the resident of advocacy assistance and contact information for the protection and advocacy agency; that any medical intervention that requires informed consent not proceed until notice is provided and exhaustion of judicial proceedings, if any, have been exhausted; and, that if the resident does not challenge the determination of capacity of the proposed medical intervention or the court has authorized the proposed intervention the medical decision should be made in accordance with any wishes of the resident, if known.
Amendments proposed by the Committee. In order to address the apparent constitutional deficiencies of Section 1418.8 in a manner that respects the rights of residents and ensures that the changes to Section 1418.8 do not affect the outcome of pending litigation and are in effect on a temporary basis until the resolution of the litigation, the Committee proposes the following amendments in concept:
- A statement of legislative intent, indicating that the Legislature is aware of California Advocates for Nursing Home Reform v. Smith, Court of Appeal Case No. A147987, which is pending litigation and indicating (1) that it is the express intent of the Legislature that no party in that pending litigation be in any way prejudiced by the passage of this act, and (2) that this bill shall not be indicative of any legislative intent concerning any issues before the courts in that litigation, and no provision of this act shall be relied upon in any way regarding the issues pending before the courts in that litigation.
- Further clarification about the notice that must be provided by the skilled nursing facility or intermediate care facility to the resident, stating that the notice must meet the following requirements:
- It shall be given orally and in writing.
- It shall be given to the resident, any known relative of the resident, and any person with legal authority to make decisions on behalf of the resident who has declined to make the medical decision, if applicable, about the determinations of the physician.
- It shall be made as soon as possible after the physician has informed the facility of the determinations, but no later than 48 hours after such determinations.
- It shall be in the resident’s preferred language.
- It shall be expressed in plain language in a manner that is easily understandable to the resident.
- Further clarification about the procedure to follow if the resident objects to the recommended medical intervention, including the ability of the resident to challenge the planned intervention in a judicial proceeding and a requirement that the skilled nursing or intermediate care facility must delay the medical intervention for a reasonable period of time as long as such delay does not present an immediate risk of harm to the patient.
- A requirement for the facility to provide to the resident information on the availability of advocacy assistance and contact information for groups that can provide advocacy and assistance, including the Long-Term Care Ombudsman.
- A prohibition on initiation of medical intervention that requires informed consent in accordance with acceptable standards of practice until after the notice has been provided to the resident and any relevant court proceedings initiated by the resident or his or her representative have been exhausted, as well as a provision that if the resident does not indicate that he or she intends to challenge the determination of capacity or the proposed medical intervention or the court has authorized the proposed medical intervention, the attending physician and the skilled nursing facility or intermediate care facility shall make medical decisions in accordance with any wishes of the resident, if known.
- A sunset provision on the section amended by the bill indicating that it shall be repealed on December 31, 2019, unless a later enacted statute deletes or extends that date.
Past Similar Legislation: SB 503 (Hernández, 2015-16) was amended to incorporate substantial changes to the Epple Bill statute in an attempt to address the court’s findings in CANHR v. Chapman. SB 503, as amended on June 30, 2016, was sponsored by DPH, and attempted to address the adequate notice requirement, as this bill proposes to do. However, SB 503 also contained language intended to address the court’s findings on the other two causes of action relating to the use of antipsychotic medications and end-of-life decisions. SB 503 was opposed by CANHR as not being sufficiently protective of resident rights, and was also opposed by the long-term care facilities and hospitals as creating an overly cumbersome procedure. Faced with opposition from both sides, the author and DPH determined not to move forward with SB 503, which was never heard in a policy committee.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support (to the bill in print)
Association of California Healthcare Districts
California Association of Health Facilities
California Hospital Association
California Medical Association
San Diego Regional Chamber of Commerce
Opposition (to the bill in print)
California Advocates for Nursing Home Reform
Disability Rights California (unless amended)
Analysis Prepared by: Alison Merrilees / JUD. / (916) 319-2334
Date of Hearing: June 27, 2017
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON HEALTH
Jim Wood, Chair
SBPCA Bill Id:SB 481
Author:(Pan) – As Amended Ver:April 6, 2017
SENATE VOTE: 27-12
SUBJECT: Long-term health facilities: informed consent.
SUMMARY: Requires a physician, skilled nursing facility (SNF), or intermediate care facility (ICF) before implementing a health care decision about a medical intervention that requires informed consent, to promptly communicate to a resident that the resident's attending physician has determined that the resident lacks capacity to make health care decisions. Specifically, this bill:
- Requires a physician, SNF, or ICF to promptly communicate to a resident, before implementing a healthcare decision about a medical intervention that requires informed consent, if there is no person with legal authority able and willing to make decisions on behalf of the patient, orally and in writing, the following information:
- The resident's attending physician has determined that the resident lacks capacity to make health care decisions;
- The facility has been unable to locate a person with legal authority to make medical treatment decisions on behalf of the resident, a guardian, conservator, or next of kin who is able and willing to make health care decisions on behalf of the resident;
- The medical intervention recommended or prescribed that requires informed consent and the identity of the person recommending or prescribing the medical intervention;
- That an interdisciplinary team has reviewed the physician's determinations, and will continue to oversee any additional recommended or prescribed interventions, unless or until a person with legal authority is able and willing to make health care decisions on behalf of the resident is identified, or the attending physician or a court determines that the resident has regained the capacity to make health care decisions; and,
- The right of the resident to challenge these determinations in a judicial proceeding.
- Makes technical and clarifying changes regarding who has legal authority to make medical treatment decisions on behalf of a resident of a SNF or ICF.
EXISTING LAW:
- Licenses and regulates SNFs and ICFs by the Department of Public Health (DPH). Defines SNFs as health facilities that provide skilled nursing care and supportive care to patients whose primary need is for availability of skilled nursing care on an extended basis. ICFs are defined as health facilities that provide inpatient care to ambulatory or non-ambulatory patients who have recurring need for skilled nursing supervision and need supportive care, but who do not require the availability of continuous skilled nursing care.
- Permits an attending physician and a SNF or ICF to initiate a medical intervention for a resident of a SNF or ICF that requires informed consent, when the physician has determined the resident lacks the capacity to make health care decisions and there is no person with legal authority to makes those decisions on behalf of the resident, in accordance with acceptable standards of practice.
- Specifies that a resident lacks capacity to make a decision regarding his or her health care if the resident is unable to understand the nature and consequences of the proposed medical intervention, or is unable to express a preference regarding the intervention. Requires the physician, in making this determination regarding capacity, to interview the resident, review the resident’s medical records, and consult with SNF or ICF staff, and family members and friends of the resident, if any have been identified.
- Specifies that a person with legal authority to make medical decisions on behalf of a resident is a person designated under a valid Durable Power of Attorney for Health Care, a guardian, a conservator, or next of kin. Requires a physician to interview the resident, review medical records, and consult with SNF or ICF staff, and with family members and friends, if identified, in order to determine the existence of a person with legal authority.
- Requires the SNF or ICF, where a resident who has been determined to lack capacity has been prescribed a medical intervention that requires informed consent, to conduct an interdisciplinary team (IDT) review of the prescribed intervention prior to the administration of the medical intervention. Requires the IDT to oversee the care of the resident utilizing a team approach to assessment and care planning, and to include the attending physician, a registered nurse, other appropriate staff as determined by the resident’s needs, and where practicable, a resident representative. Requires the IDT review to include, among other things, a discussion of the desires of the resident, if known, the probable impact on the resident’s condition, and reasonable alternative medical interventions considered.
- Permits a SNF or ICF, in case of an emergency and after obtaining a physician’s order, to administer a medical intervention that requires informed consent prior to convening an IDT review, and if the emergency results in the application of physical or chemical restraints, requires the IDT to meet within one week of the emergency for an evaluation of the medical intervention.
- Exempts physicians, SNFs, and ICFs from being required to obtain a court order pursuant to specified provisions of the Probate Code, which establish a procedure for filing a petition in superior court to designate a person to make health care decisions on behalf of a patient who lacks capacity, if the requirements outlined in 2) through 6) above are met.
FISCAL EFFECT: According to the Senate Appropriations Committee one-time costs of $115,000 over two years for DPH to adopt regulations to implement this bill (Licensing and Certification Fund). No significant ongoing licensing or enforcement costs are anticipated by DPH.
COMMENTS:
- PURPOSE OF THIS BILL. According to the author, on January 27, 2016, an Alameda County superior court judge issued a decision holding that Health & Safety Code § (HSC) 1418.8, the portion of existing law being amended by this bill, was unconstitutional, in part because it did not require patient notification.
The author states that the court’s order also held the statute unconstitutional in allowing an IDT to provide informed consent to the administration of antipsychotic medications to a SNF patient who lacks capacity and has no friends/family, and that the court held that an independent physician review or court approval is required. The court also limited decisions by an IDT that would allow a patient to receive hospice care.
The author notes that the court’s order is stayed pending appeal, and if the order becomes effective, it will negatively affect thousands of SNF patients throughout the state who lack capacity and surrogate decision makers, forcing SNFs to choose one of the following options: a) leave the patients untreated; b) transfer patients to an acute care hospital, which is known to cause transfer trauma to these patients; or, c) treat the patients illegally, resulting in expensive litigation and penalties.
The author concludes that this bill will address the deficiencies in HSC 1418.8 identified by the Alameda County superior court and protect patients who lack capacity. - BACKGROUND.
- The Epple Bill. In 1992, AB 3209 (Epple), Chapter 1303, Statutes of 1992 was enacted to address the problem of how to provide nonemergency medical treatment to nursing home patients who lack capacity to consent, and who have no legally authorized decision maker who can consent for them. Prior to the Epple bill, a medical provider or facility could file a petition authorizing treatment under the Probate Code, but this process could take up to six months. Known as the “Epple Bill,” AB 3209 established the process being amended by this bill, which permits a physician to make a determination that a resident lacks capacity to provide informed consent, and to prescribe a medical intervention subject to review by an IDT at the facility. The Epple Bill was immediately challenged as an unconstitutional violation of due process and privacy rights, but was initially found constitutional in Raines vs. Belshe, 32 Cal. App. 4th 157 (Cal. Ct. App. 1995).
However, on October 22, 2013, the California Advocates for Nursing Home Reform (CANHR) filed a lawsuit against DPH, known as CANHR v. Ronald Chapman, M.D. (Case No. RG13700100), alleging that HSC 1418.8 (the Epple Bill) was unconstitutional, raising eight separate causes of action. The first five causes of action alleged that the statute is facially unconstitutional and that HSC 1418.8 is a violation of the California Constitution as follows:- The right to due process regarding the right to notice and opportunity to oppose: (1) determination of decisional incapacity, (2) the determination of the absence of a legal substitute decision maker, (3) the hearing or review as to medical treatment, and, (4) the administration or withdrawal of medical treatment.
- The right to due process by failing to require adequate representation at the determination of incapacity.
- The right to privacy by permitting physician to make legal adjudications as to decisional incapacity.
- The right to due process by failing to require neutral decision makers at the adjudications as to decisional incapacity.
- The violation of the right to due process by failing to require a neutral decision maker at the review and approval or rejection of the treatment.
- The Epple Bill. In 1992, AB 3209 (Epple), Chapter 1303, Statutes of 1992 was enacted to address the problem of how to provide nonemergency medical treatment to nursing home patients who lack capacity to consent, and who have no legally authorized decision maker who can consent for them. Prior to the Epple bill, a medical provider or facility could file a petition authorizing treatment under the Probate Code, but this process could take up to six months. Known as the “Epple Bill,” AB 3209 established the process being amended by this bill, which permits a physician to make a determination that a resident lacks capacity to provide informed consent, and to prescribe a medical intervention subject to review by an IDT at the facility. The Epple Bill was immediately challenged as an unconstitutional violation of due process and privacy rights, but was initially found constitutional in Raines vs. Belshe, 32 Cal. App. 4th 157 (Cal. Ct. App. 1995).
The remaining three causes of action allege that the statute is unconstitutional as applied by DPH by failing to comply with judicial precedent as follows:
- Failing to require a patient representative at the review to determine treatment.
- Precluding use as to antipsychotic drugs, or in the alternative, providing adequate notice, counsel, evidence and a judicial hearing as to incapacity, necessity and the least intrusive alternative.
- Precluding use of statute for treatments or discontinuation thereof which would result in death, such as, but not limited to, do not resuscitate, comfort care or discontinuation of treatment, or for Physician Order for Life Sustaining Treatment orders.
In June of 2015, the Alameda County Superior Court agreed on three of the eight. The court ruled that the use of HSC 1418.8 is prohibited to the extent that: i) it does not require that the resident be adequately notified of the determination of incapacity, the determination of the absence of a legal substitute decision maker, the prescribed medical intervention, and the right to seek judicial review; ii) that it cannot be used for the administration of antipsychotic drugs to residents except in emergency situations; and, iii) that it cannot be the basis to make end of life decisions regarding the withholding or withdrawal of life-sustaining treatment for residents. Both parties have appealed: DPH has appealed the decision to invalidate the use of HSC 1418.8, and CANHR has appealed on the five causes of action that the court did not find unconstitutional. The decision by the court has been stayed, pending appeal, and the use of the Epple Bill process is allowed to continue.
This bill seeks to address only the first cause of action that the court found unconstitutional: the need for the resident to be notified of the determinations of incapacity and lack of a legal substitute decision maker, the prescribed medical intervention, and the right to seek judicial review.
- Attempt to address CANHR last year. In June of last year, SB 503 (Hernandez) was amended to incorporate substantial changes to the Epple Bill statute in an attempt to address the court’s findings in CANHR v. Chapman. SB 503, as amended on June 30, 2016, was sponsored by DPH, and attempted to address the adequate notice requirement, as this bill is proposing to do, though the language was different from this bill. However, SB 503 also contained language intended to address the court’s findings on the other two causes of action relating to the use of antipsychotic medications and end-of-life decisions. SB 503 was opposed by CANHR as not being sufficiently protective of resident rights, and was also opposed by the long-term care facilities and hospitals as creating an overly cumbersome procedure. Faced with opposition from both sides, the author and DPH determined not to move forward with SB 503, and it was never heard in a committee.
- Estimates regarding unrepresented, incapacitated residents. According to DPH, there are 1,244 licensed SNFs, and 1,183 licensed ICFs. According to the California Association of Health Facilities (CAHF), there are at least 100,000 residents in SNFs. As to how many are both determined to be incapacitated and also do not have a legally authorized representative to make decisions on their behalf, and are therefore subject to the Epple Bill process, estimates vary. CAHF estimates the number at somewhere between 6,000 to 12,000 residents, while other estimates put the number at 3% to 4% of residents (roughly 3,000 to 4,000 people). These are rough estimates and not all of these residents will necessarily require a medical intervention in a given year.
- Attempt to address CANHR last year. In June of last year, SB 503 (Hernandez) was amended to incorporate substantial changes to the Epple Bill statute in an attempt to address the court’s findings in CANHR v. Chapman. SB 503, as amended on June 30, 2016, was sponsored by DPH, and attempted to address the adequate notice requirement, as this bill is proposing to do, though the language was different from this bill. However, SB 503 also contained language intended to address the court’s findings on the other two causes of action relating to the use of antipsychotic medications and end-of-life decisions. SB 503 was opposed by CANHR as not being sufficiently protective of resident rights, and was also opposed by the long-term care facilities and hospitals as creating an overly cumbersome procedure. Faced with opposition from both sides, the author and DPH determined not to move forward with SB 503, and it was never heard in a committee.
- SUPPORT. The California Hospital Association (CHA) is the sponsor of this bill and states in support that this bill will address the notification deficiencies in HSC 1418.8 identified by the Alameda County superior court by requiring a SNF's IDT to notify a patient who lacks capacity to make health care decisions, and who has no family and friends to make those decisions, that the patient has been determined by his or her attending physician to lack the capacity to make health care decisions, the SNF is unable to locate family, the medical intervention or procedure that has been recommended, and, the patient's right to legally challenge these determinations. CHA states these changes are necessary to ensure that residents in SNFs have timely access to medical care and to avoid unnecessary and costly hospitalizations.
The California Commission on Aging (CCoA) supports this bill and states that CCoA believes the bill provides an opportunity for facility residents who have been improperly medicated or suffering delirium to refute a capacity determination in the courts in order to re-establish their autonomy. CCoA concludes, knowing that over-medication and delirium are fairly common among institutionalized individuals; this bill provides a safety valve to ensure that those who have capacity are able to challenge an improper determination in court.
The Arc and United Cerebral Palsy California Collaboration support this bill stating that it protects residents of long-term care facilities by better assuring their right to control their own treatment through informed consent. - OPPOSITION. CANHR opposes this bill noting that CANHR, along with two nursing home residents, filed a lawsuit against the State challenging HSC 1418.8. CANHR points out that in 2015, the court ruled that section was unconstitutional on three separate grounds. CANHR states that, aside from the completely disconcerting fact that HSC 1418.8 is regularly used to make end-of-life-decisions for unwitting nursing home residents and to chemically restrain them and deprive them of other fundamental liberties, its process is insufficiently protective of residents' basic rights for routine, nonintrusive care. CANHR concludes by recommending the Legislature avoid a piecemeal approach and wait until the opinion of the Court of Appeal is rendered to guide it going forward.
Disability Rights California (DRC) states in opposition that this bill will result in an inconsistent solution to the complex myriad of issues of informed consent that are inextricably linked, and that this bill should be held pending the resolution of the litigation. - SUGGESTED AMENDMENT. As currently drafted this bill requires oral and written notice to be provided to a resident prior to the implementation of a health care decision about a medical intervention that requires informed consent; however, it is vague as to the timing of the notice with regards to the IDT review. In order to clarify that the IDT review will continue to occur after the physician has made a determination of lack of capacity, the Committee may wish to amend the bill as follows:
(4) The interdisciplinary team will review or has reviewed the physician’s determinations, and will continue to oversee any additional recommended or prescribed interventions unless or until a person with legal authority able and willing to make health care decisions on behalf of the resident is identified, or the attending physician or a court determines that the resident has regained the capacity to make health care decisions. - DOUBLE REFERRAL. This bill is double referred; upon passage in this Committee, this bill will be referred to the Assembly Judiciary Committee.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
California Hospital Association (sponsor)
Alliance of Catholic Health Care
Association of California Healthcare Districts
California Association of Health Facilities
California Commission on Aging
California Medical Association
LeadingAge California
The Arc and United Cerebral Palsy California Collaboration
Opposition
California Advocates for Nursing Home Reform
California Right to Life Committee, Inc.
Disability Rights California
Analysis Prepared by: Lara Flynn / HEALTH / (916) 319-2097
Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | SB |
THIRD READING
Bill No: SB 481
:
SENATE HEALTH COMMITTEE: 9-0, 4/19/17
AYES: Hernandez, Nguyen, Atkins, Leyva, Mitchell, Monning, Newman, Nielsen, Roth
SENATE JUDICIARY COMMITTEE: 7-0, 4/25/17
AYES: Jackson, Moorlach, Anderson, Hertzberg, Monning, Stern, Wieckowski
SENATE APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE: 7-0, 5/15/17
AYES: Lara, Bates, Beall, Bradford, Hill, Nielsen, Wiener
SOURCE: California Hospital Association
This bill requires that a resident of a long term care facility who has been determined to lack capacity to make health care decisions and there is no person with legal authority to make those decisions on the resident’s behalf, to be notified prior to implementing a medical intervention, of this lack of capacity determination, of the medical intervention that has been prescribed, and of the right of the resident to challenge these determinations in a judicial proceeding.
Existing law:
- Licenses and regulates skilled nursing facilities (SNFs) and intermediate care facilities (ICFs) by the Department of Public Health (DPH). SNFs are defined as health facilities that provide skilled nursing care and supportive care to patients whose primary need is for availability of skilled nursing care on an extended basis, and ICFs are defined as health facilities that provide inpatient care to ambulatory or non-ambulatory patients who have recurring need for skilled nursing supervision and need supportive care, but who do not require the availability of continuous skilled nursing care.
- Permits an attending physician and a SNF or ICF to initiate a medical intervention for a resident of a SNF or ICF that requires informed consent, when the physician has determined the resident lacks the capacity to make health care decisions and there is no person with legal authority to makes those decisions on behalf of the resident, in accordance with acceptable standards of practice.
- Specifies that a resident lacks capacity to make a decision regarding his or her health care if the resident is unable to understand the nature and consequences of the proposed medical intervention, or is unable to express a preference regarding the intervention. Requires the physician, in making this determination regarding capacity, to interview the resident, review the resident’s medical records, and consult with SNF or ICF staff, and family members and friends of the resident, if any have been identified.
- Specifies that a person with legal authority to make medical decisions on behalf of a resident is a person designated under a valid Durable Power of Attorney for Health Care, a guardian, a conservator, or next of kin. Requires a physician to interview the resident, review medical records, and consult with SNF or ICF staff, and with family members and friends, if identified, in order to determine the existence of a person with legal authority.
- Requires the SNF or ICF, where a resident who has been determined to lack capacity has been prescribed a medical intervention that requires informed consent, to conduct an interdisciplinary team (IDT) review of the prescribed intervention prior to the administration of the medical intervention. Requires the IDT to oversee the care of the resident utilizing a team approach to assessment and care planning, and to include the attending physician, a registered nurse, other appropriate staff as determined by the resident’s needs, and where practicable, a resident representative. Requires the IDT review to include, among other things, a discussion of the desires of the resident, if known, the probable impact on the resident’s condition, and reasonable alternative medical interventions considered.
- Permits a SNF or ICF, in case of an emergency and after obtaining a physician’s order, to administer a medical intervention that requires informed consent prior to convening an IDT review, and if the emergency results in the application of physical or chemical restraints, requires the IDT to meet within one week of the emergency for an evaluation of the medical intervention.
- Exempts physicians, SNFs, and ICFs from being required to obtain a court order pursuant to specified provisions of the Probate Code, which establish a procedure for filing a petition in superior court to designate a person to make health care decisions on behalf of a patient who lacks capacity, if the requirements outlined in 2) through 6) above are met.
This bill:
- Requires an attending physician, a SNF, or an ICF, before implementing a health care decision about a medical intervention for a resident who has been determined to lack capacity to make health care decisions and there is no person with legal authority to make those decisions on behalf of the resident, to promptly communicate to the resident, orally and in writing, the following information:
- The resident’s attending physician has determined that the resident lacks capacity to make health care decisions;
- The facility has been unable to locate a person with legal authority to make medical treatment decisions on behalf of the resident, as specified, a guardian, conservator, or next of kin who is able and willing to make health care decisions on behalf of the resident;
- The medical intervention recommended or prescribed that requires informed consent and the identity of the person recommending or prescribing the medical intervention;
- The IDT has reviewed the physician’s determinations, and will continue to oversee any additional recommended or prescribed interventions unless or until a person with legal authority able and willing to make health care decisions on behalf of the resident is identified, or the attending physician or a court determines that the resident has regained the capacity to make health care decisions; and,
- The right of the resident to challenge the determinations made in a judicial proceeding.
- Makes technical and clarifying changes regarding who has legal authority to make medical treatment decisions on behalf of a resident.
Comments
- Author’s statement. According to the author, on January 27, 2016, an Alameda County superior court judge issued an order holding that Health and Safety Code Section 1418.8 was unconstitutional, in part because it did not require the patient notification. The court’s order also held the statute unconstitutional in allowing an IDT to provide informed consent to the administration of antipsychotic medications to a SNF patient who lacks capacity and has no friends or family. The court held that an independent physician review or court approval is required. The court also limited decisions by an IDT that would allow a patient to receive hospice care. The court’s order is stayed pending appeal. If the order becomes effective, it will negatively affect thousands of SNF patients throughout the state who lack capacity and surrogate decision makers, forcing SNFs to choose one of the following options (a) leave the patients untreated; (b) transfer patients to an acute care hospital, which is known to cause transfer trauma to these patients; or (c) treat the patients illegally, resulting in expensive litigation and penalties. This bill will address the deficiencies in Health and Safety Code Section 1418.8 identified by the Alameda County superior court and to protect these patients who lack capacity.
- Epple Bill. In 1992, AB 3209 (Epple, Chapter 1303, Statutes of 1992) was enacted to address the problem of how to provide nonemergency medical treatment to nursing home patients who lack capacity to consent, and who have no legally authorized decision maker who can consent for them. Prior to the Epple bill, a medical provider or facility could file a petition authorizing treatment under the Probate Code, but this process could take up to six months. Known as the “Epple Bill,” AB 3209 established the process being amended by this bill, which permits a physician to make a determination that a resident lacks capacity to provide informed consent, and to prescribe a medical intervention subject to review by an IDT at the facility. The Epple Bill was immediately challenged as an unconstitutional violation of due process and privacy rights, but was initially found constitutional in Raines vs. Belshe in 1995.
However, on October 22, 2013, California Advocates for Nursing Home Reform (CANHR) filed a lawsuit against DPH, known as CANHR v. Ronald Chapman, M.D., alleging that Health and Safety Code Section 1418.8 (the Epple Bill) was unconstitutional, raising eight separate causes of action. In June of 2015, the Alameda County Superior Court agreed on three of the eight. The judgment states that the use of Health and Safety Code Section 1418.8 is prohibited to the extent that: a) the section does not require that the resident be adequately notified of the determination of incapacity, the determination of the absence of a legal substitute decision maker, the prescribed medical intervention, and the right to seek judicial review; b) that it is prohibited for the administration of antipsychotic drugs to residents except in emergency situations; and c) that it is prohibited to make end of life decisions regarding the withholding or withdrawal of life-sustaining treatment for residents. Both sides have appealed: DPH has appealed the decision to invalidate the use of Section 1418.8, and CANHR has appealed on the five causes of action that the court did not find unconstitutional. Because of the ongoing appeal, the decision by the court has been stayed, and the use of the Epple Bill process is allowed to continue pending the appeal. This bill seeks to address only the first cause of action that the court found unconstitutional: the need for the resident to be notified of the determinations of incapacity and lack of a legal substitute decision maker, the prescribed medical intervention, and the right to seek judicial review.
- Attempt to address CANHR last year. In June of last year, SB 503 (Hernandez, 2016) was amended to incorporate substantial changes to the Epple Bill statute in an attempt to address the court’s findings in CANHR v. Chapman. SB 503, as amended on June 30, 2016, was sponsored by DPH, attempted to address the adequate notice requirement, as this bill is proposing to do, though the language was different from this bill. However, SB 503 also contained language intended to address the court’s findings on the other two causes of action relating to the use of antipsychotic medications and end-of-life decisions. SB 503 was opposed by CANHR as not being sufficiently protective of resident rights, and was also opposed by the long-term care facilities and hospitals as creating an overly cumbersome procedure. Faced with opposition from both sides, the author and DPH determined not to move forward with the legislation, and it was never heard in a committee.
- How many people are we talking about? According to DPH, there are 1,244 licensed SNFs, and 1,183 licensed ICFs. According to the California Association of Health Facilities (CAHF), there are at least 100,000 residents in SNFs. As to how many are both determined to be incapacitated and also do not have a legally authorized representative to make decisions on their behalf, and are therefore subject to the Epple Bill process, estimates vary. CAHF estimates the number at somewhere between 6,000 to 12,000 residents, while other estimates put the number at 3% to 4% of residents (roughly 3,000 to 4,000 people). Of course, these are rough estimates of the number of people for whom the Epple Bill process is required if a medical intervention requiring informed consent is ordered. Not all of these residents will necessary require a medical intervention in a given year.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: Fiscal Com.: Local:
According to the Senate Appropriations Committee, one-time costs of $115,000 over two years for the DPH to adopt regulations to implement this bill (Licensing and Certification Fund). No significant ongoing licensing or enforcement costs are anticipated by the DPH.
California Hospital Association (source)
California Association of Health Facilities
California Commission on Aging
California Medical Association
LeadingAge California
OPPOSITION: (Verified 5/17/17)
California Advocates for Nursing Home Reform
California ProLife Council
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: This bill is sponsored by the California Hospital Association (CHA), which states in support that this bill will update existing law to improve and strengthen protections for some of California’s most vulnerable patients residing in SNFs. CHA states that these changes are necessary to ensure that residents in SNFs have timely access to medical care and to avoid unnecessary and costly hospitalizations. According to CHA, this bill will address the notification deficiencies in the law identified by the Alameda County superior court. The California Association of Health Facilities (CAHF) states in support that the providers and physicians who care for this very vulnerable population are very concerned about the judgment issued by the court and its ramifications for some of the most vulnerable individuals requiring skilled nursing services. According to CAHF, while the order is stayed pending appeal, if the order becomes effective it will negatively affect thousands of SNF patients throughout the state, forcing SNFs to choose between leaving the patient untreated, transferring patients to an acute care hospital, or treat the patients illegally, resulting in penalties and litigation. LeadingAge California states in support that it believes the notification process outlined in this bill addresses the concerns of the court decision and will enable facilities to provide medically necessary care.
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION: The California ProLife Council states in opposition that “informed consent” for those lacking capacity cannot be fulfilled by merely presenting a note or otherwise communicating that such a declaration has been made. The California ProLife Council states that the new change in medical ethics allowing medicine to be used as a lethal implement against a patient’s very life requires the utmost consideration be given to protecting dependent and vulnerable patients, and that this bill does the opposite. The California ProLife Council argues that this bill should explicitly prohibit any “terminal medicine” or the removal of life-sustaining treatment and at a minimum the Long-Term Care Ombudsman and County Adult Protective Services should be noticed of such a decision of incompetency.
CANHR opposes this bill unless amended. CANHR states that this bill is intended to partially address the seriously constitutionally defective Health and Safety Code Section 1418.8. CANHR notes that it filed a lawsuit against DPH, and that the court held, with regard to notice, that resident must be told (1) that a medical intervention requiring informed consent has been prescribed or ordered; (2) the resident has been determined by a physician to lack capacity; (3) there is no person with legal authority to make decisions on the behalf of the resident; (4) an IDT will review the physician’s determinations; (5) any further prescribed interventions will continue to be oversee using this team approach; and, (6) the resident may challenge, in a judicial proceeding, all of the above determinations. According to CANHR, while recent amendments to this bill have vastly improved it, there is one remaining significant concern: the notice might be given too late for it to be meaningful to the resident. CANHR states that while this bill requires the notice prior to implementing the medical intervention, the notice is required to inform the resident that the IDT “has reviewed the physician’s determinations, and will continue to oversee any additional recommended or prescribed interventions….” CANHR states that this indicates the notice could be provided after the physician has made the determinations and after the IDT has met and performed its review. CANHR states that without clarifying that the notice be provided in advance of the physician’s determination and the IDT meeting, this bill does not satisfy constitutional notice requirements.
5/17/17 15:55:50
SENATE COMMITTEE ON
Senator Ricardo Lara, Chair
2017 - 2018 Regular Session
SB 481 (Pan) - Long-term health facilities: informed consent
Version: | Policy Vote: |
Urgency: | Mandate: |
Hearing Date: | Consultant: |
This bill does not meet the criteria for referral to the Suspense File.
Bill Summary:
SB 481 would require a resident of a long-term care facility, who has been determined to lack the capacity to make health care decisions, to be provided certain notifications prior to the implementation of a medical intervention.
Fiscal Impact:
One-time costs of $115,000 over two years for the Department of Public Health to adopt regulations to implement the bill (Licensing and Certification Fund). No significant ongoing licensing or enforcement costs are anticipated by the Department.
Background:
Under current law (AB 3209, Epple, Statutes of 1992, referred to as the “Epple bill”), there is a process in law authorizing a physician to make a determination that a resident of a long-term care facility lacks the capacity to provide informed consent for health care treatments. In that case, current law allows a physician to prescribe a medical intervention, subject to review by an interdisciplinary team at the facility.
In 2015, a superior court found this law to be unconstitutional on several grounds. First, the court ruled that current law does not provide for adequate notification to the patient about the finding that the patient lacks capacity to make medical decisions, the nature of the proposed medical intervention, and the patient’s right to judicial review. Second, the court ruled that current law cannot be used to administer antipsychotic drugs, except in emergency situations. Third, the court ruled that current law cannot be used to make end-of-life decisions. The superior court ruling has been appealed by both the plaintiffs and the Department of Public Health. The superior court ruling has been stayed pending the appeal process.
Proposed Law:
SB 481 would require a resident of a long-term care facility, who has been determined to lack the capacity to make health care decisions, to be provided certain notifications prior to the implementation of a medical intervention.
Related Legislation:
SB 503 (Hernandez, 2015) was amended to incorporate several changes to the Epple bill statute, in response to the superior court ruling, including the issue of resident notification. That bill, in that form, was never heard in a policy committee.
Staff Comments:
This bill, as currently drafted, only addresses one of the issues addressed in the superior court ruling. As noted above, because the superior court ruling is currently stayed, the existing statutes in this area are still in effect.
Proponents of the bill have raised concerns that the superior court ruling could have significant impacts on patient care for those patients who lack the ability to provide informed consent. To the extent that there is not some process in law to govern those situations, proponents are concerned that long-term care facilities will need to transfer patients to hospitals for treatment that can no longer be provided in long-term care facilities. Given the uncertainty about future court rulings on this issue, it is difficult to determine the long-term potential for that to occur.
-- END --
Senator Hannah-Beth Jackson, Chair
2017-2018 Regular Session
Bill No: SB 481 (Author:Pan)
Version: April 6, 2017
Hearing Date: Apr. 25, 2017
Fiscal: Yes
Urgency: No
Consultant: MS
SUBJECT
Long-term health facilities: informed consent
DESCRIPTION
This bill would require the physician, a skilled nursing facility (SNF), or an intermediate care facility (ICF), to promptly notify the resident, orally and in writing, that it has been determined that the resident lacks capacity, and other information, as specified. This bill would require this notification be provided before implementing a medical intervention that requires informed consent for a resident who lacks capacity to make health care decisions and for whom there is no person with legal authority able and willing to make those decisions.
BACKGROUND
In 1992, the Legislature passed AB 3209 (Epple, Ch. 1303, Stats. 1992), which created Section 1418.8 of the Health & Safety Code. AB 3209 was aimed at addressing situations where a resident of an SNF or ICF was determined to need nonemergency medical care, but the patient was unable to consent and a surrogate decisionmaker could not be found. AB 3209 contained legislative findings and declarations regarding the inadequacy of the existing system “to address the legal, ethical, and practical issues involved in making health care decisions for incapacitated skilled nursing facility residents or intermediate care facility residents who lack surrogate decisionmakers.” (AB 3209, Epple, Ch. 1303, Stats 1992.) In these declarations, the Legislature expressed a belief that existing procedures included within the Probate Code did not adequately address these concerns. Thus, Section 1418.8 was being added to the Health & Safety Code to create a procedure for ensuring a decision could be made regarding these health care needs for residents who lack capacity and a surrogate health care decisionmaker. (Id.)
In 1995, Section 1418.8 was determined by the California Court of Appeals to not violate a patient’s privacy rights under the California Constitution, nor to violate a patient’s due process rights under either the state or federal Constitution. (Rains v. Belshe, 32 Cal.App.4th 157 (1995).) In 2016, an Alameda County Superior Court Judge issued an order holding this code section unconstitutional. The Superior Court Judge felt the notification provided to the resident by this Code Section needed to go further. Specifically, the order states that use of this section is prohibited to the extent that it does not require the resident be adequately notified in writing, that the use of this code section to prescribe antipsychotic drugs is prohibited, and it’s use to make end of life decisions regarding withholding or withdrawal of life-sustaining treatment for residents is prohibited.
This Alameda Superior Court order is currently stayed pending appeal. This means the decision of the Superior Court Judge has not yet impacted how care is provided to residents deemed to be incapacitated in California’s SNFs or ICFs. According to the California Hospital Association (CHA), the sponsor of this bill, this legislation is needed to implement the Superior Court’s findings so that SNFs and ICFs can continue to have access to a legally-sanctioned process for making medical treatment decisions for incapacitated residents who have no identified surrogate decisionmaker.
This bill would add notice requirements to Section 1418.8 of the Health and Safety Code based on requirements contained in the Alameda Superior Court’s order. It does not address the Superior Court’s prohibition from this section being used to prescribe antipsychotic medication, or the withholding or withdrawal of life-sustaining treatment to residents.
CHANGES TO EXISTING LAW
Existing law provides for an attending physician of a resident in an SNF or ICF to inform the SNF or ICF if the physician or surgeon prescribes or orders a medical intervention that requires informed consent, but is unable to be obtained from the resident because the physician or surgeon determines the resident lacks the capacity to make decisions concerning her or his health care and there is no person with legal authority to make those decisions on behalf of the resident. (Health & Saf. Code Sec. 1418.8(a).)
Existing law provides that a patient of an SNF or ICF lacks capacity to make a decision regarding his or her health care if the resident is unable to understand the nature and consequences of the proposed medical intervention, including its risks and benefits, or is unable to express a preference regarding the intervention. (Health & Saf. Code Sec. 1418.8(a).)
Existing law provides for the physician to interview the patient, review the resident’s medical records, consult with SNF or ICF staff as appropriate, and identified family members or friends when determining the resident’s capacity to consent. (Health & Saf. Code Sec. 1418.8(b).)
Existing law provides for a physician to interview the patient, review the medical records of the patient, and consult with SNF or ICF staff to determine if a person with legal authority to make medical treatment decisions on behalf of a patient exists. (Health & Saf. Code Sec. 1418.8(b).)
Existing law provides for the purposes of this subdivision, a person with legal authority to make medical treatment decisions is a person designated under a valid Durable Power of Attorney for Health Care, a guardian, a conservator, or next of kin. (Health & Saf. Code Sec. 1418.8(c).)
Existing law provides for the attending physician and SNF or ICF to initiate medical intervention that requires informed consent pursuant to interdisciplinary team review and in accordance with acceptable standards and practice. (Health & Saf. Code Sec. 1418.8(d).)
Existing law provides for a patient of an SNF or ICF who has been prescribed a medical intervention by a physician and surgeon that requires informed consent and the physician has determined that the resident lacks capacity to make health care decisions and there is no person with legal authority to make those decisions, the facility shall conduct an interdisciplinary team review of the prescribed medical intervention prior to the administration of the medical intervention or treatment. The interdisciplinary team shall oversee the care of the resident utilizing a team approach to assessment and care planning, and shall include the resident’s attending physician, a registered professional nurse with responsibility for the resident, other appropriate staff in disciplines as determined by the resident’s needs, and, where practicable, a patient representative, in accordance with applicable state and federal requirements. (Health & Saf. Code Sec. 1418.8(e).)
Existing law provides for the interdisciplinary team review to include all of the following:
- a review of the physician’s assessment of the resident’s condition;
- the reason for the proposed use of the medical intervention;
- a discussion of the desires of the patient, where known, which shall be determined by an interview with the patient, review of the patient’s medical records, and consult with family members or friends, if any have been identified;
- the type of medical intervention to be used in the resident’s care, including its probable frequency and duration;
- the probable impact on the resident’s condition, with and without the use of the medical intervention; and
- reasonable alternative medical interventions considered or utilized and reasons for their discontinuance or inappropriateness. (Health & Saf. Code Sec. 1418.8(e).)
Existing law provides a patient representative may include a family member or friend of the resident who is unable to take full responsibility for the health care decisions of the resident, but who has agreed to serve on the interdisciplinary team, or the other person authorized by state or federal law. (Health & Saf. Code Sec. 1418.8(f).)
Existing law requires an interdisciplinary team to periodically evaluate the use of the prescribed medical intervention at least quarterly or upon significant change in the resident’s medical condition. (Health & Saf. Code Sec. 1418.8(g).)
Existing law provides that in case of an emergency, after obtaining a physician and surgeon’s order as necessary, a skilled nursing or intermediate care facility may administer a medical intervention that requires informed consent prior to the facility convening an interdisciplinary team review. If the emergency results in the application of physical or chemical restraints, the interdisciplinary team shall meet within one week of the emergency for an evaluation of the medical intervention. (Health & Saf. Code Sec. 1418.8(h).)
Existing law provides that physicians, surgeons, SNFs, and ICFs shall not be required to obtain a court order pursuant to Section 3201 of the Probate Code prior to administering a medication intervention which requires informed consent if the requirements of this section are met. (Health & Saf. Code Sec. 1418.8(i).)
Existing law provides for a resident of an SNF or ICF for whom medical intervention has been prescribed, ordered, or administered pursuant to this section to seek appropriate judicial relief to review the decision to provide the medical intervention. (Health & Saf. Code Sec. 1418.8(j).)
Existing law prevents a physician or other health care provider, whose action under this section is in accordance with reasonable medical standards from being subject to administrative sanction if the physician or health care provider believes in good faith that the action is consistent with this section and the desires of the resident, or if unknown, the best interest of the resident. (Health & Saf. Code Sec. 1418.8(k).)
Existing law provides the determinations required to be made when a patient is determined to lack capacity to make a decision regarding his or her health care and an interdisciplinary team review is conducted, and the basis for those determinations shall be documented in the patient’s medical record and shall be made available to the patient’s representative for review. (Health & Saf. Code Sec. 1418.8(l).)
This bill would require the physician, SNF, or ICF, before implementing a health care decision about a medical intervention that requires informed consent, to promptly communicate to the resident, orally and in writing, the following information if making a determination that a medical intervention is needed but the resident is unable to provide consent:
- the resident’s attending physician has determined that the resident lacks capacity to make health care decisions;
- the facility has been unable to locate a person with legal authority to make medical treatment decisions on behalf of the resident pursuant to Division 4.7 of the Probate Code, a guardian, conservator, or next of kin who is able and willing to make health care decisions on behalf of the resident;
- the medical intervention recommended or prescribed that requires informed consent and the identity of the person recommending or prescribing the medical intervention;
- the interdisciplinary team has reviewed the physician’s determinations, and will continue to oversee any additional recommended or prescribed interventions unless or until a person with legal authority is able and willing to make health care decisions on behalf of the resident is identified, or the attending physician or court determines that the resident has regained the capacity to make health care decisions; and
- the right of the resident to challenge the determinations made pursuant to this section, in a judicial proceeding.
This bill would replace the term “patient” with the term “resident,” as provided.
This bill would remove the term surgeon from the applicable subdivisions of Section 1418.8 of the Health and Safety Code.
This bill would reference Division 4.7 of the Probate Code for making a determination that someone has been designated under a valid Durable Power of Attorney for Health Care.
This bill would change the standard that there is no person with legal authority to make the medical intervention decisions on behalf of the resident, to no person with legal authority able and willing to make those decisions.
COMMENT
1. Stated need for this bill
According to the Author:
Current law, Health & Safety Code 1418.8, permits an interdisciplinary care team in a skilled nursing facility to make a health care decision on behalf of a patient who lacks the capacity to make his or her own health care decisions and who does not have any family member or friends to act on his or her behalf. This statute was enacted in 1992 by the California Legislature so that these vulnerable patients could still receive timely, medically necessary care. A recent trial court decision has found Health & Safety Code 1418.8 deficient because it does not require the physician to give the patient specified information. This bill would amend existing law to address the deficiencies identified by the court. Specifically, this law would modify the notification given to the patient/resident.
In support, the California Hospital Association (CHA) writes:
The lack of a legally-sanctioned process to make decisions for unrepresented patients restricts access to timely, medically necessary services and undermines the long term outcomes for our most vulnerable patients. SNFs that are legally unable to provide treatment that requires informed consent will be forced to send patients to nearby hospitals to receive the exact same care. This is very disruptive to SNF patients, particularly those that have dementia, for whom these transfers often result in “transfer trauma.” In addition, this practice has exacerbated overcrowding in hospital emergency departments, leading to longer wait times and delayed care. Hospital inpatient units, as well as emergency departments, stay crowded as SNFs decline to admit unrepresented patients lacking capacity, for fear the SNF may not be able to provide needed care to the patient due to a legal technicality.
2. Updated notice requirements
The Alameda Superior Court’s order states that use of Health & Safety Code Section 1418.8 is unconstitutional in that the section does not require the resident be notified of set requirements, as provided, in writing. The order specifies the resident should be notified in writing of the following:
- a medical intervention requiring informed consent has been prescribed or ordered by the resident’s attending physician;
- the resident has been determined by the attending physician to lack the capacity required to consent to the medical intervention as provided in this Section;
- there is no person with legal authority to make medical decisions on behalf of the resident;
- an interdisciplinary team has been assembled to review the physician’s determinations regarding the prescribed medical intervention and will continue to oversee any further prescribed interventions; and
- the resident may challenge, in a judicial proceeding, any of the above determinations or decision to provide a medical intervention.
Existing law simply states the attending physician and SNF or ICF may initiate medical intervention that requires informed consent pursuant to interdisciplinary team review and in accordance with acceptable standards and practice. (Health & Saf. Code Sec. 1418.8(d).) There is nothing within this statute that requires the Physician or the SNF to notify the patient that they have determined the patient is incapacitated and needs medical care that requires consent. This bill would change this by adding that before the physician and the SNF or ICF may implement a health care decision about a medical intervention that requires a resident who lacks capacity and does not have an identified surrogate with the legal authority able and willing to make those decisions, the physician, SNF, or ICF shall promptly communicate to the resident, orally and in writing, specified information relating to the notice requirements highlighted in the Superior Court’s order.
This bill would codify a portion of the Superior Court’s order regarding the constitutionality of Section 1418.8 of the Health and Safety Code.
In opposition, California Advocates for Nursing Home Reform (CANHR) writes:
The recent amendments to SB 481 have vastly improved its original barebones notice requirement. However, we have one remaining significant concern: the notice might be given too late for it to be meaningful for the resident. The bill rightfully proposes an advance notice (“before implementing...”) but proposed section (d)(4) indicates the notice could be provided after the physician has made her determinations and after the inter-disciplinary team (IDT) has met and performed its review. Such a notice, after the fact, does not give the resident a reasonable opportunity to participate in the team-decision process or a chance to object other than by going to court.
SB 481 appears to have been written to partially satisfy the court’s findings in our CANHR v. Chapman case, which found Health and Safety Code Section 1418.8 lacking constitutional due process protections. The bill would adopt the court’s requirements for notice but does not clearly require the notice be in advance of the physician’s determinations and the IDT meeting. Without that clarification, SB 481 does not satisfy constitutional notice requirements.
Disability Rights California (DRC), writing in their statement of concern, states:
DRC has several concerns with this bill in its timing and that it is not addressing all of the issues that have been invalidated in the pending litigation. We are concerned that the piecemeal approach will result in an inconsistent solution to the complex myriad of issues of informed consent. We believe that the better course for resolving the issues pending in the litigation, and are partly addressed by this bill, is to wait for a decision from the Court of Appeal so that a comprehensive solution can be found between the sponsor, representatives of residents, other stakeholders and the California Department of Public Health. Additionally, we believe that the notices provisions in this bill do not yet provide full and meaningful notice to the resident. We share the continuing concerns expressed by California Advocates for Nursing Home Reform as well as other regarding the clarity of the proposed notice provisions.
3. Concern regarding pending litigation
This bill codifies the order’s provisions regarding the notice provided to patients under Section 1418.8 of the Health and Safety code. The Court’s order has never impacted how Section 1418.8 is implemented, because of a stay following the immediate appeal of the Alameda Superior Court’s decision. According to the Author, the appeal appears to touch all parts of the Superior Court’s order. In the past, this Committee has raised concerns about bills which interfere with pending litigation. Any such interference could result in a direct financial windfall to a private party, prevent a court from deciding an action based upon the laws in place at the time the cause of action accrued, or create a situation where the Legislative branch is used to circumvent the discretion and independence of the Judicial branch.
As a result, this Committee’s policy with regard to pending court cases has been to hold bills that would effect pending litigation until resolution is reached by the Court, unless the legislation is tailored in such a way that it would not interfere with the pending litigation.
In this instance, the bill codifies the Superior Court’s decision only with respect to the notice. This bill makes no impact on the Superior Court’s decisions regarding Section 1418.8 and psychotropic medications or Section 1418.8 and the withholding or withdrawing of life sustaining treatments for residents. Therefore, this bill should have no impact on the pending litigation as it relates to psychotropic medications or the withholding or withdrawing of life sustaining treatments.
To ensure this bill is not intended as impacting the Alameda Superior Court’s order, this Committee suggests an amendment to clarify that nothing in this bill is intended to impact pending litigation arising out of CANHR v. Chapman (2016).
Support: Association of California Healthcare Districts; California Association of Health Facilities; LeadingAge California; The Arc and United Cerebral Palsy California Collaboration
Opposition: California Advocates for Nursing Home Reform
HISTORY
Source: California Hospital Association
Related Pending Legislation: None Known
Prior Legislation: AB 3209 (Epple, Ch. 1303, Stats. 1992) See Background.
Prior Vote: Senate Health Committee (Ayes 9, Noes 0)
**************
SENATE COMMITTEE ON HEALTH
Senator Ed Hernandez, O.D., Chair
BILL NO: SB 481
AUTHOR: | Pan | ||
VERSION: | April 6, 2017 | ||
HEARING DATE: | April 19, 2017 | ||
CONSULTANT: | Vince Marchand | ||
SUBJECT: Long-term health facilities: informed consent
SUMMARY:
Requires that a resident of a long term care facility who has been determined to lack capacity to make health care decisions and there is no person with legal authority to make those decisions on the resident’s behalf, to be notified prior to implementing a medical intervention, of this lack of capacity determination, of the medical intervention that has been prescribed, and of the right of the resident to challenge these determinations in a judicial proceeding.
Existing law:
- Licenses and regulates skilled nursing facilities (SNFs) and intermediate care facilities (ICFs) by the Department of Public Health (DPH). SNFs are defined as health facilities that provide skilled nursing care and supportive care to patients whose primary need is for availability of skilled nursing care on an extended basis, and ICFs are defined as health facilities that provide inpatient care to ambulatory or non-ambulatory patients who have recurring need for skilled nursing supervision and need supportive care, but who do not require the availability of continuous skilled nursing care.
- Permits an attending physician and a SNF or ICF to initiate a medical intervention for a resident of a SNF or ICF that requires informed consent, when the physician has determined the resident lacks the capacity to make health care decisions and there is no person with legal authority to makes those decisions on behalf of the resident, in accordance with acceptable standards of practice.
- Specifies that a resident lacks capacity to make a decision regarding his or her health care if the resident is unable to understand the nature and consequences of the proposed medical intervention, or is unable to express a preference regarding the intervention. Requires the physician, in making this determination regarding capacity, to interview the resident, review the resident’s medical records, and consult with SNF or ICF staff, and family members and friends of the resident, if any have been identified.
- Specifies that a person with legal authority to make medical decisions on behalf of a resident is a person designated under a valid Durable Power of Attorney for Health Care, a guardian, a conservator, or next of kin. Requires a physician to interview the resident, review medical records, and consult with SNF or ICF staff, and with family members and friends, if identified, in order to determine the existence of a person with legal authority.
- Requires the SNF or ICF, where a resident who has been determined to lack capacity has been prescribed a medical intervention that requires informed consent, to conduct an interdisciplinary team (IDT) review of the prescribed intervention prior to the administration of the medical intervention. Requires the IDT to oversee the care of the resident utilizing a team approach to assessment and care planning, and to include the attending physician, a registered nurse, other appropriate staff as determined by the resident’s needs, and where practicable, a resident representative. Requires the IDT review to include, among other things, a discussion of the desires of the resident, if known, the probable impact on the resident’s condition, and reasonable alternative medical interventions considered.
- Permits a SNF or ICF, in case of an emergency and after obtaining a physician’s order, to administer a medical intervention that requires informed consent prior to convening an IDT review, and if the emergency results in the application of physical or chemical restraints, requires the IDT to meet within one week of the emergency for an evaluation of the medical intervention.
- Exempts physicians, SNFs, and ICFs from being required to obtain a court order pursuant to specified provisions of the Probate Code, which establish a procedure for filing a petition in superior court to designate a person to make health care decisions on behalf of a patient who lacks capacity, if the requirements outlined in 2) through 6) above are met.
This bill:
- Requires an attending physician, a SNF, or an ICF, before implementing a health care decision about a medical intervention for a resident who has been determined to lack capacity to make health care decisions and there is no person with legal authority to make those decisions on behalf of the resident, to promptly communicate to the resident, orally and in writing, the following information:
- The resident’s attending physician has determined that the resident lacks capacity to make health care decisions;
- The facility has been unable to locate a person with legal authority to make medical treatment decisions on behalf of the resident, as specified, a guardian, conservator, or next of kin who is able and willing to make health care decisions on behalf of the resident;
- The medical intervention recommended or prescribed that requires informed consent and the identity of the person recommending or prescribing the medical intervention;
- The IDT has reviewed the physician’s determinations, and will continue to oversee any additional recommended or prescribed interventions unless or until a person with legal authority able and willing to make health care decisions on behalf of the resident is identified, or the attending physician or a court determines that the resident has regained the capacity to make health care decisions; and,
- The right of the resident to challenge the determinations made in a judicial proceeding.
- Makes technical and clarifying changes regarding who has legal authority to make medical treatment decisions on behalf of a resident.
FISCAL EFFECT:
This bill has not been analyzed by a fiscal committee.
COMMENTS:
- Author’s statement. According to the author, on January 27, 2016, an Alameda County superior court judge issued an order holding that Health & Safety Code Section 1418.8 was unconstitutional, in part because it did not require the patient notification. The court’s order also held the statute unconstitutional in allowing an IDT to provide informed consent to the administration of antipsychotic medications to a SNF patient who lacks capacity and has no friends or family. The court held that an independent physician review or court approval is required. The court also limited decisions by an IDT that would allow a patient to receive hospice care. The court’s order is stayed pending appeal. If the order becomes effective, it will negatively affect thousands of SNF patients throughout the state who lack capacity and surrogate decision makers, forcing SNFs to choose one of the following options (1) leave the patients untreated; (2) transfer patients to an acute care hospital, which is known to cause transfer trauma to these patients; or (3) treat the patients illegally, resulting in expensive litigation and penalties. This bill will address the deficiencies in Health & Safety Code Section 1418.8 identified by the Alameda County superior court and to protect these patients who lack capacity.
- Background on the Epple Bill. In 1992, AB 3209 (Epple, Chapter 1303, Statutes of 1992) was enacted to address the problem of how to provide nonemergency medical treatment to nursing home patients who lack capacity to consent, and who have no legally authorized decision maker who can consent for them. Prior to the Epple bill, a medical provider or facility could file a petition authorizing treatment under the Probate Code, but this process could take up to six months. Known as the “Epple Bill,” AB 3209 established the process being amended by this bill, which permits a physician to make a determination that a resident lacks capacity to provide informed consent, and to prescribe a medical intervention subject to review by an IDT at the facility. The Epple Bill was immediately challenged as an unconstitutional violation of due process and privacy rights, but was initially found constitutional in Raines vs. Belshe in 1995.
However, on October 22, 2013, California Advocates for Nursing Home Reform (CANHR) filed a lawsuit against DPH, known as CANHR v. Ronald Chapman, M.D., alleging that H&S 1418.8 (the Epple Bill) was unconstitutional, raising eight separate causes of action. In June of 2015, the Alameda County Superior Court agreed on three of the eight. The judgment states that the use of H&S 1418.8 is prohibited to the extent that: 1) the section does not require that the resident be adequately notified of the determination of incapacity, the determination of the absence of a legal substitute decision maker, the prescribed medical intervention, and the right to seek judicial review; 2) that it is prohibited for the administration of antipsychotic drugs to residents except in emergency situations; and 3) that it is prohibited to make end of life decisions regarding the withholding or withdrawal of life-sustaining treatment for residents. Both sides have appealed: DPH has appealed the decision to invalidate the use of Section 1418.8, and CANHR has appealed on the five causes of action that the court did not find unconstitutional. Because of the ongoing appeal, the decision by the court has been stayed, and the use of the Epple Bill process is allowed to continue pending the appeal. This bill seeks to address only the first cause of action that the court found unconstitutional: the need for the resident to be notified of the determinations of incapacity and lack of a legal substitute decision maker, the prescribed medical intervention, and the right to seek judicial review. - Attempt to address CANHR last year. In June of last year, SB 503 (Hernandez) was amended to incorporate substantial changes to the Epple Bill statute in an attempt to address the court’s findings in CANHR v. Chapman. SB 503, as amended on June 30, 2016, was sponsored by DPH, attempted to address the adequate notice requirement, as this bill is proposing to do, though the language was different from this bill. However, SB 503 also contained language intended to address the court’s findings on the other two causes of action relating to the use of antipsychotic medications and end-of-life decisions. SB 503 was opposed by CANHR as not being sufficiently protective of resident rights, and was also opposed by the long-term care facilities and hospitals as creating an overly cumbersome procedure. Faced with opposition from both sides, the author and DPH determined not to move forward with the legislation, and it was never heard in a committee.
- How many people are we talking about? According to DPH, there are 1,244 licensed SNFs, and 1,183 licensed ICFs. According to the California Association of Health Facilities (CAHF), there are at least 100,000 residents in SNFs. As to how many are both determined to be incapacitated and also do not have a legally authorized representative to make decisions on their behalf, and are therefore subject to the Epple Bill process, estimates vary. CAHF estimates the number at somewhere between 6,000 to 12,000 residents, while other estimates put the number at 3% to 4% of residents (roughly 3,000 to 4,000 people). Of course, these are rough estimates of the number of people for whom the Epple Bill process is required if a medical intervention requiring informed consent is ordered. Not all of these residents will necessary require a medical intervention in a given year.
- Double referral. This bill is double-referred. Should it pass out of this committee, it will be referred to the Senate Judiciary Committee.
- Support. This bill is sponsored by the California Hospital Association (CHA), which states in support that this bill will update existing law to improve and strengthen protections for some of California’s most vulnerable patients residing in SNFs. CHA states that these changes are necessary to ensure that residents in SNFs have timely access to medical care and to avoid unnecessary and costly hospitalizations. According to CHA, this bill will address the notification deficiencies in the law identified by the Alameda County superior court. The California Association of Health Facilities (CAHF) states in support that the providers and physicians who care for this very vulnerable population are very concerned about the judgment issued by the court and its ramifications for some of the most vulnerable individuals requiring skilled nursing services. According to CAHF, while the order is stayed pending appeal, if the order becomes effective it will negatively affect thousands of SNF patients throughout the state, forcing SNFs to choose between leaving the patient untreated, transferring patients to an acute care hospital, or treat the patients illegally, resulting in penalties and litigation. Leading Age California states in support that it believes the notification process outlined in this bill addresses the concerns of the court decision and will enable facilities to provide medically necessary care.
- Oppose unless amended. CANHR opposes this bill unless amended. CANHR states that this bill is intended to partially address the seriously constitutionally defective Health and Safety Code Section 1418.8. CANHR notes that it filed a lawsuit against DPH, and that the court held, with regard to notice, that resident must be told (1) that a medical intervention requiring informed consent has been prescribed or ordered; (2) the resident has been determined by a physician to lack capacity; (3) there is no person with legal authority to make decisions on the behalf of the resident; (4) an IDT will review the physician’s determinations; (5) any further prescribed interventions will continue to be oversee using this team approach; and, (6) the resident may challenge, in a judicial proceeding, all of the above determinations. According to CANHR, while recent amendments to this bill have vastly improved it, there is one remaining significant concern: the notice might be given too late for it to be meaningful to the resident. CANHR states that while this bill requires the notice prior to implementing the medical intervention, the notice is required to inform the resident that the IDT “has reviewed the physician’s determinations, and will continue to oversee any additional recommended or prescribed interventions….” CANHR states that this indicates the notice could be provided after the physician has made the determinations and after the IDT has met and performed its review. CANHR states that without clarifying that the notice be provided in advance of the physician’s determination and the IDT meeting, this bill does not satisfy constitutional notice requirements.
- Oppose. The California ProLife Council states in opposition that “informed consent” for those lacking capacity cannot be fulfilled by merely presenting a note or otherwise communicating that such a declaration has been made. The California ProLife Council states that the new change in medical ethics allowing medicine to be used as a lethal implement against a patient’s very life requires the utmost consideration be given to protecting dependent and vulnerable patients, and that this bill does the opposite. The California ProLife Council argues that this bill should explicitly prohibit any “terminal medicine” or the removal of life-sustaining treatment and at a minimum the Long-Term Care Ombudsman and County Adult Protective Services should be noticed of such a decision of incompetency.
SUPPORT AND OPPOSITION:
Support: California Hospital Association (sponsor)
California Association of Health Facilities
California Commission on Aging
California Medical Association
LeadingAge California
Oppose: California Advocates for Nursing Home Reform (unless amended)
California ProLife Council
-- END --
Discussed in Hearing
Senate Floor
Senate Standing Committee on Governance and Finance
Assembly Floor
Assembly Standing Committee on Local Government
Assembly Standing Committee on Health
Senate Floor
Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations
Senate Standing Committee on Judiciary
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):