SB 632: Civil discovery: depositions.
- Session Year: 2017-2018
- House: Senate
- Latest Version Date: 2017-09-05
Existing law authorizes any party to obtain discovery in civil actions by taking the oral deposition of any person, including any party to the action. Under existing law, a deposition examination of the witness by all counsel, other than the witness counsel of record, is generally limited to 7 hours of total testimony. Existing law provides an exception to the 7-hour limitation for depositions taken in cases designated as complex. In such cases, the deposition examination of a witness by all counsel other than the witness counsel of record is limited to 2 days of no more than 7 hours of total testimony each day, or 14 hours of total testimony, unless a licensed physician attests that the deponent suffers from an illness or condition that raises substantial medical doubt of the deponents survival beyond 6 months.
This bill would require that, in any civil action for injury or illness that results in mesothelioma, a deposition examination of the witness by counsel other than the witness counsel of record be limited to 7 hours of total testimony if a licensed physician attests in a declaration that the deponent suffers from mesothelioma and is either (1) over 70 years of age and his or her health is such that a deposition of more than 7 hours will prejudice the deponents well-being, or (2) without regard to age of the deponent, the deponents mesothelioma raises mesothelioma, raising substantial medical doubt of the survival of the deponent beyond 6 months. A party would be authorized by this bill to seek up to 7 hours of additional deposition testimony for no more than 14 hours of total testimony. The bill would prohibit authorize a court to grant an extension from being granted unless a beyond 7 hours if the court makes a factual finding supporting the finds that an extension beyond 7 hours, is in the interest of fairness, and determines that the health of the deponent does not appear to be endangered by the grant of additional time.
Existing law authorizes any party to obtain discovery in civil actions by taking the oral deposition of any person, including any party to the action. Under existing law, a deposition examination of the witness by all counsel, other than the witness counsel of record, is generally limited to 7 hours of total testimony. Existing law provides an exception to the 7-hour limitation for depositions taken in cases designated as complex. In such cases, the deposition examination of a witness by all counsel other than the witness counsel of record is limited to 2 days of no more than 7 hours of total testimony each day, or 14 hours of total testimony, unless a licensed physician attests that the deponent suffers from an illness or condition that raises substantial medical doubt of the deponents survival beyond 6 months.
This bill would require that, in any civil action for injury or illness based upon exposure to asbestos, that results in mesothelioma, a deposition examination of the witness by counsel other than the witness counsel of record be limited to 7 hours of total testimony if a licensed physician attests in a declaration that the deponent suffers from mesothelioma and is either (1) over 70 years of age and his or her health is such that a deposition of more than 7 hours will prejudice the deponents well-being, or that, (2) without regard to age of the deponent, the deponent suffers from an illness or condition that deponents mesothelioma raises substantial medical doubt of the survival of the deponent beyond 6 months. A party would be authorized by this bill to seek up to 7 hours of additional deposition testimony for no more than 14 hours of total testimony. The bill would prohibit an extension from being granted unless a court makes a factual finding supporting the extension beyond 7 hours, and determines that the health of the deponent does not appear to be endangered by the grant of additional time.
Existing law authorizes any party to obtain discovery in civil actions by taking the oral deposition of any person, including any party to the action. Under existing law, a deposition examination of the witness by all counsel, other than the witness counsel of record, is generally limited to 7 hours of total testimony. Existing law provides an exception to the 7-hour limitation for depositions taken in cases designated as complex. In such cases, the deposition examination of a witness by all counsel other than the witness counsel of record is limited to 2 days of no more than 7 hours of total testimony each day, or 14 hours of total testimony, unless a licensed physician attests that the deponent suffers from an illness or condition that raises substantial medical doubt of the deponents survival beyond 6 months.
This bill would require that, in any civil action for injury or illness based upon exposure to asbestos, a deposition examination of the witness by counsel other than the witness counsel of record be limited to 7 hours of total testimony if a licensed physician attests in a declaration that the deponent is either over 70 years of age and his or her health is such that a deposition of more than 7 hours will prejudice the deponents well-being, or that, without regard to age of the deponent, the deponent suffers from an illness or condition that raises substantial medical doubt of the survival of the deponent beyond 6 months. A party would be authorized by this bill to seek up to 7 hours of additional deposition testimony for no more than 14 hours of total testimony. If a court grants an extension, the court would be required to include in its order The bill would prohibit an extension from being granted unless a court makes a factual finding supporting the extension beyond 7 hours, and a statement determines that the health of the deponent does not appear to be endangered by the grant of additional time.
Existing law authorizes any party to obtain discovery in civil actions by taking the oral deposition of any person, including any party to the action. Under existing law, a deposition examination of the witness by all counsel, other than the witness counsel of record, is generally limited to 7 hours of total testimony. Existing law provides an exception to the 7-hour limitation for depositions taken in cases designated as complex. In such cases, the deposition examination of a witness by all counsel other than the witness counsel of record is limited to 2 days of no more than 7 hours of total testimony each day, or 14 hours of total testimony, unless a licensed physician attests that the deponent suffers from an illness or condition that raises substantial medical doubt of the deponents survival beyond 6 months.
This bill would require that, in any civil action for injury or illness based upon exposure to asbestos, a deposition examination of the witness by counsel other than the witness counsel of record be limited to 7 hours of total testimony if a licensed physician attests in a declaration that the deponent is either over 70 years of age and his or her health is such that a deposition of more than 7 hours will prejudice the deponents interest in the litigation well-being, or that, without regard to age of the deponent, the deponent suffers from an illness or condition that raises substantial medical doubt of the survival of the deponent beyond 6 months. A party would be authorized by this bill to seek up to 7 hours of additional deposition testimony for no more than 14 hours of total testimony. If a court grants an extension, the court would be required to include in its order a factual finding supporting the extension beyond 7 hours, and a statement that the health of the deponent does not appear to be endangered by the grant of additional time.
Existing law authorizes any party to obtain discovery in civil actions by taking the oral deposition of any person, including any party to the action. Under existing law, a deposition examination of the witness by all counsel, other than the witness counsel of record, is generally limited to 7 hours of total testimony. Existing law provides an exception to the 7-hour limitation for depositions taken in cases designated as complex. In such cases, the deposition examination of a witness by all counsel other than the witness counsel of record is limited to 2 days of no more than 7 hours of total testimony each day, or 14 hours of total testimony, unless a licensed physician attests that the deponent suffers from an illness or condition that raises substantial medical doubt of the deponents survival beyond 6 months.
This bill would require that, in any civil action for injury or illness based upon exposure to asbestos, a deposition examination of the witness by counsel other than the witness counsel of record be limited to 7 hours of total testimony if a licensed physician attests in a declaration that the deponent is either over 70 years of age and his or her health is such that a deposition of more than 7 hours will prejudice the deponents interest in the litigation, or that, without regard to age of the deponent, the deponent suffers from an illness or condition that raises substantial medical doubt of the survival of the deponent beyond 6 months.
(a)Notwithstanding Section 2025.290, in any civil action for injury or illness that results in mesothelioma, a deposition examination of the witness by all counsel, other than the witness counsel of record, shall be limited to seven hours of total testimony if a licensed physician attests in a declaration served on the parties that either: the deponent suffers from mesothelioma, raising substantial medical doubt of the survival of the deponent beyond six months.
(1)The deponent suffers from mesothelioma, is over 70 years of age, and his or her health is such that a deposition of more than seven hours will prejudice the deponents well-being.(2)Without regard to the age of the deponent, the deponent suffers from mesothelioma, which raises substantial medical doubt of the survival of the deponent beyond six months.(b)A party may seek up to seven hours of additional deposition testimony for no more than 14 hours of total testimony. An extension shall not be granted unless a court makes a factual finding supporting the extension beyond seven hours, and determines that the health of the deponent does not appear to be endangered by the grant of additional time.(b)Notwithstanding subdivision (a), upon request by a party, a court may, in its discretion, grant an additional seven hours of deposition testimony for no more than 14 hours of total testimony. The court may grant an extension if it finds that an extension is in the interest of fairness, and determines that the health of the deponent does not appear to be endangered by the grant of additional time.
(c)This section does not affect the existing right of any party to move for a protective order or the courts discretion to make any order that justice requires to limit a deposition in order to protect any party, deponent, or other natural person or organization from unwarranted annoyance, embarrassment, oppression, undue burden, or expense.
(a)Notwithstanding Section 2025.290, in any civil action for injury or illness based upon exposure to asbestos, that results in mesothelioma, a deposition examination of the witness by all counsel, other than the witness counsel of record, shall be limited to seven hours of total testimony if a licensed physician attests in a declaration served on the parties that either:
(1)The deponent suffers from mesothelioma, is over 70 years of age age, and his or her health is such that a deposition of more than seven hours will prejudice the deponents well-being.
(2)Without regard to the age of the deponent, the deponent suffers from an illness or condition that mesothelioma, which raises substantial medical doubt of the survival of the deponent beyond six months.
(b)A party may seek up to seven hours of additional deposition testimony for no more than 14 hours of total testimony. An extension shall not be granted unless a court makes a factual finding supporting the extension beyond seven hours, and determines that the health of the deponent does not appear to be endangered by the grant of additional time.
(c)This section does not affect the existing right of any party to move for a protective order or the courts discretion to make any order that justice requires to limit a deposition in order to protect any party, deponent, or other natural person or organization from unwarranted annoyance, embarrassment, oppression, undue burden, or expense.
(a)Notwithstanding Section 2025.290, in any civil action for injury or illness based upon exposure to asbestos, a deposition examination of the witness by all counsel, other than the witness counsel of record, shall be limited to seven hours of total testimony if a licensed physician attests in a declaration served on the parties that either:
(1)The deponent is over 70 years of age and his or her health is such that a deposition of more than seven hours will prejudice the deponents well-being.
(2)Without regard to the age of the deponent, the deponent suffers from an illness or condition that raises substantial medical doubt of the survival of the deponent beyond six months.
(b)A party may seek up to seven hours of additional deposition testimony for no more than 14 hours of total testimony. If a court grants an extension, the court shall include in its order a factual finding supporting the extension beyond seven hours, and a statement that the health of the deponent does not appear to be endangered by the grant of additional time. An extension shall not be granted unless a court makes a factual finding supporting the extension beyond seven hours, and determines that the health of the deponent does not appear to be endangered by the grant of additional time.
(c)This section does not affect the existing right of any party to move for a protective order or the courts discretion to make any order that justice requires to limit a deposition in order to protect any party, deponent, or other natural person or organization from unwarranted annoyance, embarrassment, oppression, undue burden, or expense.
(a)Notwithstanding Section 2025.290, in any civil action for injury or illness based upon exposure to asbestos, a deposition examination of the witness by all counsel, other than the witness counsel of record, shall be limited to seven hours of total testimony if a licensed physician attests in a declaration served on the parties that either:
(a)(1)The deponent is over 70 years of age and his or her health is such that a deposition of more than seven hours will prejudice the deponents interest in the litigation. well-being.
(b)(2)Without regard to the age of the deponent, the deponent suffers from an illness or condition that raises substantial medical doubt of the survival of the deponent beyond six months.
(b)A party may seek up to seven hours of additional deposition testimony for no more than 14 hours of total testimony. If a court grants an extension, the court shall include in its order a factual finding supporting the extension beyond seven hours, and a statement that the health of the deponent does not appear to be endangered by the grant of additional time.
(c)This section does not affect the existing right of any party to move for a protective order or the courts discretion to make any order that justice requires to limit a deposition in order to protect any party, deponent, or other natural person or organization from unwarranted annoyance, embarrassment, oppression, undue burden, or expense.
Notwithstanding Section 2025.290, in any civil action for injury or illness based upon exposure to asbestos, a deposition examination of the witness by all counsel, other than the witness counsel of record, shall be limited to seven hours of total testimony if a licensed physician attests in a declaration served on the parties that either:
(a)The deponent is over 70 years of age and his or her health is such that a deposition of more than seven hours will prejudice the deponents interest in the litigation.
(b)Without regard to the age of the deponent, the deponent suffers from an illness or condition that raises substantial medical doubt of the survival of the deponent beyond six months.
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Sep 11, 2017 | Ordered to inactive file on request of Assembly Member Calderon. |
| Sep 5, 2017 | Read third time and amended. |
| Jul 10, 2017 | Read third time and amended. |
| Jun 26, 2017 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| Jun 22, 2017 | Read second time and amended. Ordered to second reading. |
| Jun 21, 2017 | From committee: Do pass as amended. (Ayes 8. Noes 1.) (June 20). |
| Jun 12, 2017 | June 13 set for first hearing canceled at the request of author. |
| May 26, 2017 | Referred to Com. on JUD. |
| May 9, 2017 | In Assembly. Read first time. Held at Desk. |
| May 8, 2017 | Read third time. Passed. (Ayes 29. Noes 9. Page 989.) Ordered to the Assembly. |
| May 4, 2017 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| May 3, 2017 | From committee: Do pass. (Ayes 5. Noes 1. Page 945.) (May 2). |
| Apr 17, 2017 | From committee with author's amendments. Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on JUD. |
| Apr 13, 2017 | Set for hearing May 2. |
| Mar 2, 2017 | Referred to Com. on JUD. |
| Feb 21, 2017 | From printer. May be acted upon on or after March 23. |
| Feb 17, 2017 | Introduced. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Jun 20, 2017 | Do pass as amended. | Assembly Standing Committee on Judiciary |
Passed |
|
| May 8, 2017 | Senate 3rd Reading SB632 Monning | Senate Floor |
Passed |
|
| May 2, 2017 | Do pass | Senate Standing Committee on Judiciary |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
SENATE THIRD READING
STR Bill Id:SB 632
Author:(Monning)
As Amended Ver:September 5, 2017
Majority vote
SENATE VOTE: 29-9
Committee | Votes | Ayes | Noes |
Judiciary | 8-1 | Mark Stone, Chau, Chiu, Cristina Garcia, Holden, Kalra, Reyes, Ting | Kiley |
SUMMARY: Limits the deposition in a civil action for injury or illness that results in mesothelioma to seven hours for a deponent who suffers from mesothelioma. Allows the court, in its discretion, to grant an additional seven hours of deposition if the court finds that the extension is in the interest of fairness, and determines that the health of the deponent does not appear to be endangered by the grant of additional time. Specifically, this bill:
- Provides that in any civil action for injury or illness that results in mesothelioma, a deposition examination of the witness by all counsel, other than the witness' counsel of record, shall be limited to seven hours of total testimony if a licensed physician attests in a declaration served on the parties that the deponent suffers from mesothelioma, raising substantial medical doubt of the survival of the deponent beyond six months.
- Allows a court, in its discretion, to grant a party up to additional seven hours of deposition testimony for no more than 14 hours of total testimony if the court finds that the extension is in the interest of fairness, and determines that the health of the deponent does not appear to be endangered by the grant of additional time.
- Clarifies that this bill's provisions do not affect the existing right of any party to move for a protective order or the court's discretion to make any order that justice requires to limit a deposition in order to protect any party, deponent, or other natural person or organization from unwarranted annoyance, embarrassment, oppression, undue burden, or expense.
FISCAL EFFECT: None
COMMENTS: In 2012, the Legislature enacted AB 1875 (Gatto), Chapter 346, Statutes of 2012, which creates a presumption that a deposition examination of any person shall not exceed seven hours of total testimony except in specific circumstances. One policy reason behind this seven-hour deposition limit was to protect parties against "needlessly long and repetitious questioning that allegedly serves no other purposes than to harass the deponent or delay the proceeding." (Assembly Judiciary Committee analysis of AB 1875; April 24, 2012.) Another policy reason for the deposition limit was to protect vulnerably ill or elderly plaintiffs, and workers suffering from injuries or exposure to workplace chemicals from litigation tactics. (Ibid.)
Existing law provides a series of the exceptions to the seven-hour rule. Despite the seven-hour presumption, the law allows a court to grant additional time if additional time is needed to "fairly examine the deponent" or if "the deponent, another person, or any other circumstance impedes or delays the examination." Furthermore, the seven-hour rule does not apply if the parties stipulate to longer depositions, or the deponent is an expert. Relevant to this bill, the seven-hour rule does not apply in cases governed by a case management order or designated by the court as complex – in order words, cases involving many parties, multiple witnesses, or coordination between several courts. Generally, a case involving environmental or toxic tort claims involving many parties are provisionally designated as a complex case. (California Rules of Court, Rule 3.400.)
There is also an exception to the exception. Even in matters that have been deemed to be complex, the deposition may be limited if a physician provides a declaration attesting that a "deponent suffers from an illness or condition that raises substantial medical doubt of survival of the deponent beyond six months." (Code of Civil Procedure (CCP) Section 2025.290.) In those circumstances, the deposition is limited to two days of no more than seven hours of total testimony each day, or 14 hours of total testimony. (Ibid.)
Summary of this bill. This bill limits the deposition of a deponent in a civil action for illness or injury that results in mesothelioma to seven hours of total testimony if a physician provides a declaration, attesting that the deponent suffers from mesothelioma, raising substantial medical doubt of the survival of the deponent beyond six months.
In order to streamline asbestos litigation, several courts have issued case management orders in asbestos cases. Given the complexity of asbestos cases, several California courts have issued case management orders that govern personal injury cases arising from asbestos exposure. In other words, in several courts, all asbestos litigation in those courts must follow specific rules on various procedures including designation of counsel, discovery requests, settlement conferences, and trial management. In those courts, the case management orders will establish a deposition limit at twenty hours.
The deposition limits under this bill only apply to cases involving a civil action for injury or illness that results in mesothelioma. This bill – upon a physician's declaration – will create a deposition limit for specified deponents in any civil action for injury or illness that results in mesothelioma. Originally, this bill was limited only to asbestos litigation because several asbestos case management orders issued after the enactment of AB 1875 are inconsistent with existing law. Under the deposition "exception to the exception," the duration of a deposition is limited in complex matters if there is evidence that a deponent suffers from an illness or condition that raises substantial medical doubt of survival of the deponent beyond six months. The author contends that courts overseeing asbestos cases have ignored this "exception to the exception" and allow depositions to go beyond the statutory limit. Accordingly, the author contends that these orders subject dying asbestos plaintiffs to unnecessary lengthy – and sometimes fatal – depositions. The recent amendments narrow the cases to only those that involve an injury or illness that results in mesothelioma.
This bill creates a seven hour deposition limit for certain deponents, consistent with existing law. Existing law creates a presumption that depositions are limited to seven hours of total testimony unless an exception or other rule applies. Those exceptions include cases governed by a court order (including a case management order) and in complex cases. Additionally, there is a broad rule in existing law that requires the court to grant additional time "beyond any limits imposed by this section, if needed to fairly examine the deponent or if the deponent, another person, or any other circumstance impedes or delays the examination." (CCP Section 2025.290.) This bill provides that, notwithstanding those exceptions and the broad rule, a deposition is limited to seven hours for those who suffer from mesothelioma, where there is substantial medical doubt about whether the deponent is going to survive beyond six months.
If additional time is needed, this bill authorizes judicial discretion to extend the deposition beyond seven hours, not to exceed 14 hours, if the health of the deponent does not appear to be endangered by the grant of additional time. To provide the court discretion to raise the deposition limit in certain situations, this bill provides that the deposition may be extended for another seven hours if the court finds that it is in the interest of fairness and the health of the deponent does not appear to be endangered by the grant of additional time.
Although civil discovery rules are not generally meant to be limited so that truth and efficient information sharing can be promoted, the limits under this bill appear to be narrow in order to promote the laudable goal of protecting injured victims suffering from mesothelioma from grueling questioning where answers could be ascertained from other sources like written interrogatories. The deponents who would benefit from this bill are in a uniquely vulnerable position. According to data from the Center for Disease Control and Prevention, the median survival after a diagnosis of malignant mesothelioma is approximately one year. Often in these types of cases, by the time victims are diagnosed and file suit, their health is dramatically impaired. Given the limitations on what damages can be recovered in survival actions after a victim has died, there is a perverse incentive for defendants to prolong litigation as much as possible.
It has been suggested that this bill prevents due process because (it is argued) that this bill would infringe upon a defendant's ability to gain information during litigation, particularly when there are a lot of defendants. While this bill limits a deposition in mesothelioma cases where a plaintiff is not likely to survive beyond six months, this bill does nothing to limit the use of other litigation tools such as written questions (known as interrogatories) or medical exams. Accordingly, the due process arguments appear unavailing. For example, in Los Angeles Superior Court, the asbestos case management order requires the plaintiff to answer over 72 written interrogatories with over 300 sub-questions. Generally, the interrogatories will ask the plaintiff to tell the defendants about everything they did across the decades of their life, their family's medical history, as well as the products and jobsites where plaintiff may have contracted mesothelioma. Furthermore, when considering the factors for why a court may limit discovery ("unreasonably cumulative or duplicative"…"obtainable from some other source that is more convenient, less burdensome, or less expensive"), this bill appears to fit those standards when weighing the victims who would benefit, and the alternatives in obtaining information.
Analysis Prepared by: Eric Dang / JUD. / (916) 319-2334 FN: 0001610
SENATE THIRD READING
STR Bill Id:SB 632
Author:(Monning)
As Amended Ver:July 10, 2017
Majority vote
SENATE VOTE: 29-9
Committee | Votes | Ayes | Noes |
Judiciary | 8-1 | Mark Stone, Chau, Chiu, Cristina Garcia, Holden, Kalra, Reyes, Ting | Kiley |
SUMMARY: Limits the deposition in a civil action for injury or illness that results in mesothelioma to seven hours for a deponent who either suffers from mesothelioma and is unlikely to survive beyond six months, or who is over 70 years of age, or suffers from mesothelioma and whose health or well-being would be prejudiced by a deposition beyond seven hours. Allows an additional seven hours of deposition if the court finds that the health of the deponent does not appear to be endangered by the grant of additional time. Specifically, this bill:
- Provides that in any civil action for injury or illness that results in mesothelioma, a deposition examination of the witness by all counsel, other than the witness' counsel of record, shall be limited to seven hours of total testimony if a licensed physician attests in a declaration served on the parties that either:
- The deponent suffers from mesothelioma, is over 70 years of age and his or her health is such that a deposition of more than seven hours will prejudice the deponent's well-being.
- Without regard to the age of the deponent, the deponent suffers from mesothelioma, which raises substantial medical doubt of the survival of the deponent beyond six months.
- Allows a party to seek up to seven hours of additional deposition testimony for no more than 14 hours of total testimony. The extension shall not be granted unless the court makes a factual finding supporting the extension beyond seven hours, and determines that the health of the deponent does not appear to be endangered by the grant of additional time.
- Clarifies that this bill's provisions do not affect the existing right of any party to move for a protective order or the court's discretion to make any order that justice requires to limit a deposition in order to protect any party, deponent, or other natural person or organization from unwarranted annoyance, embarrassment, oppression, undue burden, or expense.
FISCAL EFFECT: None
COMMENTS: In 2012, the Legislature enacted AB 1875 (Gatto), Chapter 346, Statutes of 2012, which creates a presumption that a deposition examination of any person shall not exceed seven hours of total testimony except in specific circumstances. One policy reason behind this seven-hour deposition limit was to protect parties against "needlessly long and repetitious questioning that allegedly serves no other purposes than to harass the deponent or delay the proceeding." (Assembly Judiciary Committee analysis of AB 1875; April 24, 2012.) Another policy reason for the deposition limit was to protect vulnerably ill or elderly plaintiffs, and workers suffering from injuries or exposure to workplace chemicals from litigation tactics. (Ibid.)
Existing law provides a series of the exceptions to the seven-hour rule. Despite the seven-hour presumption, the law allows a court to grant additional time if additional time is needed to "fairly examine the deponent" or if "the deponent, another person, or any other circumstance impedes or delays the examination." Furthermore, the seven-hour rule does not apply if the parties stipulate to longer depositions, or the deponent is an expert. Relevant to this bill, the seven-hour rule does not apply in cases governed by a case management order or designated by the court as complex – in order words, cases involving many parties, multiple witnesses, or coordination between several courts. Generally, a case involving environmental or toxic tort claims involving many parties are provisionally designated as a complex case. (Cal. Rules of Court, Rule 3.400.)
There is also an exception to the exception. Even in matters that have been deemed to be complex, the deposition may be limited if a physician provides a declaration attesting that a "deponent suffers from an illness or condition that raises substantial medical doubt of survival of the deponent beyond six months." (Code of Civil Procedure (CCP) Section 2025.290.) In those circumstances, the deposition is limited to two days of no more than seven hours of total testimony each day, or 14 hours of total testimony. (Ibid.)
Summary of this bill. This bill limits the deposition of a deponent in a civil action for illness or injury that results in mesothelioma to seven hours of total testimony if a physician provides a declaration, attesting to either of the following: 1) the deponent, regardless of age, suffers from mesothelioma, which raises substantial medical doubt of the survival of the deponent beyond six months; or 2) the deponent is over 70 years of age, and suffers from mesothelioma, whose health is such that a deposition of more than seven hours would prejudice the deponent's well-being. This bill allows an additional seven hours of deposition if the court makes a factual finding supporting the extension, and determines that the health of the deponent does not appear to be endangered by the grant of additional time.
In order to streamline asbestos litigation, several courts have issued case management orders in asbestos cases. Given the complexity of asbestos cases, several California courts have issued case management orders that govern personal injury cases arising from asbestos exposure. In other words, in several courts, all asbestos litigation in those courts must follow specific rules on various procedures including designation of counsel, discovery requests, settlement conferences, and trial management.
The deposition limits under this bill only apply to cases involving a civil action for injury or illness that results in mesothelioma. This bill – upon a physician's declaration – will create a deposition limit for specified deponents in any civil action for injury or illness that results in mesothelioma. Originally, this bill was limited only to asbestos litigation because several asbestos case management orders issued after the enactment of AB 1875 are inconsistent with existing law. Under the deposition "exception to the exception," the duration of a deposition is limited in complex matters if there is evidence that a deponent suffers from an illness or condition that raises substantial medical doubt of survival of the deponent beyond six months. The author contends that courts overseeing asbestos cases have ignored this "exception to the exception" and allow depositions to go beyond the statutory limit. Accordingly, the author contends that these orders subject dying asbestos plaintiffs to unnecessary lengthy – and sometimes fatal – depositions. The recent amendments narrow the cases to only those that involve an injury or illness that results in mesothelioma.
This bill creates a seven hour deposition limit for certain deponents, consistent with existing law. Existing law creates a presumption that depositions are limited to seven hours of total testimony unless an exception or other rule applies. Those exceptions include cases governed by a court order (including a case management order) and in complex cases. Additionally, there is a broad rule in existing law that requires the court to grant additional time "beyond any limits imposed by this section, if needed to fairly examine the deponent or if the deponent, another person, or any other circumstance impedes or delays the examination." (CCP Section 2025.290.) This bill provides that, notwithstanding those exceptions and the broad rule, a deposition is limited to seven hours for those who suffer from mesothelioma and who are either elderly or severely-ill.
If additional time is needed, this bill authorizes judicial discretion to extend the deposition beyond seven hours, not to exceed 14 hours, if the health of the deponent does not appear to be endangered by the grant of additional time. To provide some flexibility for the court and the parties to extend the deposition beyond the initial seven hour limit, the bill provides that the deposition may be extended for another seven hours if the court finds that the health of the deponent does not appear to be endangered by the grant of additional time.
Although civil discovery rules are not generally meant to be limited so that truth and efficient information sharing can be promoted, the limits under this bill appear to be narrow in order to promote the laudable goal of protecting injured victims suffering from mesothelioma from grueling questioning where answers could be ascertained from other sources like written interrogatories. The deponents who would benefit from this bill are in a uniquely vulnerable position. According to data from the Center for Disease Control and Prevention, the median survival after a diagnosis of malignant mesothelioma is approximately one year. Often in these types of cases, by the time victims are diagnosed and file suit, their health is dramatically impaired. Given the limitations on what damages can be recovered in survival actions after a victim has died, there is a perverse incentive for defendants to prolong litigation as much as possible.
Moreover, it appears that many of the answers that a defendant seeks to obtain from the asbestos victim could be provided through written interrogatories. For example, in Los Angeles Superior Court, the asbestos case management order requires the plaintiff to answer over 72 written interrogatories with over 300 sub-questions. Generally, the interrogatories will ask the plaintiff to tell the defendants about everything they did across the decades of their life, their family's medical history, as well as the products and jobsites where plaintiff may have contracted mesothelioma. Furthermore, when considering the factors for why a court may limit discovery ("unreasonably cumulative or duplicative"…"obtainable from some other source that is more convenient, less burdensome, or less expensive"), this bill appears to fit those standards when weighing the victims who would benefit, and the alternatives in obtaining information.
Analysis Prepared by: Eric Dang / JUD. / (916) 319-2334 FN: 0001111
SENATE THIRD READING
STR Bill Id:SB 632
Author:(Monning)
As Amended Ver:June 22, 2017
Majority vote
SENATE VOTE: 29-9
Committee | Votes | Ayes | Noes |
Judiciary | 8-1 | Mark Stone, Chau, Chiu, Cristina Garcia, Holden, Kalra, Reyes, Ting |
|
SUMMARY: Limits the deposition in asbestos litigation to seven hours for a deponent who is unlikely to survive beyond six months, or who is over 70 years of age and whose health or well-being would be prejudiced by a deposition beyond seven hours. Allows an additional seven hours of deposition if the court finds that the health of the deponent does not appear to be endangered by the grant of additional time. Specifically, this bill:
- Provides that in any civil action for injury or illness based upon exposure to asbestos, a deposition examination of the witness by all counsel, other than the witness' counsel of record, shall be limited to seven hours of total testimony if a licensed physician attests in a declaration served on the parties that either:
- The deponent is over 70 years of age and his or her health is such that a deposition of more than seven hours will prejudice the deponent's well-being.
- Without regard to the age of the deponent, the deponent suffers from an illness or condition that raises substantial medical doubt of the survival of the deponent beyond six months.
- Allows a party to seek up to seven hours of additional deposition testimony for no more than 14 hours of total testimony. The extension shall not be granted unless the court makes a factual finding supporting the extension beyond seven hours, and determines that the health of the deponent does not appear to be endangered by the grant of additional time.
- Clarifies that this bill's provisions do not affect the existing right of any party to move for a protective order or the court's discretion to make any order that justice requires to limit a deposition in order to protect any party, deponent, or other natural person or organization from unwarranted annoyance, embarrassment, oppression, undue burden, or expense.
FISCAL EFFECT: None
COMMENTS: In 2012, the Legislature enacted AB 1875 (Gatto), Chapter 346, Statutes of 2012, which creates a presumption that a deposition examination of any person shall not exceed seven hours of total testimony except in specific circumstances. One policy reason behind this seven-hour deposition limit was to protect parties against "needlessly long and repetitious questioning that allegedly serves no other purposes than to harass the deponent or delay the proceeding." (Assembly Judiciary Committee analysis of AB 1875; April 24, 2012.) Another policy reason for the deposition limit was to protect vulnerably ill or elderly plaintiffs, and workers suffering from injuries or exposure to workplace chemicals from litigation tactics. (Ibid.)
Existing law provides a series of the exceptions to the seven-hour rule. Despite the seven-hour presumption, the law allows a court to grant additional time if additional time is needed to "fairly examine the deponent" or if "the deponent, another person, or any other circumstance impedes or delays the examination." Furthermore, the seven-hour rule does not apply if the parties stipulate to longer depositions, or the deponent is an expert. Relevant to this bill, the seven-hour rule does not apply in cases governed by a case management order or designated by the court as complex — in order words, cases involving many parties, multiple witnesses, or coordination between several courts. Generally, a case involving environmental or toxic tort claims involving many parties are provisionally designated as a complex case. (Cal. Rules of Court, Rule 3.400.)
There is also an exception to the exception. Even in matters that have been deemed to be complex, the deposition may be limited if a physician provides a declaration attesting that a "deponent suffers from an illness or condition that raises substantial medical doubt of survival of the deponent beyond six months." (Code of Civil Procedure (CCP) Section 2025.290.) In those circumstances, the deposition is limited to two days of no more than seven hours of total testimony each day, or 14 hours of total testimony. (Ibid.)
Summary of this bill. This bill limits the deposition of a deponent in asbestos litigation to seven hours of total testimony if a physician provides a declaration, attesting to either of the following: 1) the deponent, regardless of age, suffers from an illness or condition that raises substantial medical doubt of the survival of the deponent beyond six months; or 2) the deponent is over 70 years of age whose health is such that a deposition of more than seven hours would prejudice the deponent's well-being. This bill allows an additional seven hours of deposition if the court makes a factual finding supporting the extension, and determines that the health of the deponent does not appear to be endangered by the grant of additional time.
In order to streamline asbestos litigation, several courts have issued case management orders in asbestos cases. Given the complexity of asbestos cases, several California courts have issued case management orders that govern personal injury cases arising from asbestos exposure. In other words, in several courts, all asbestos litigation in those courts must follow specific rules on various procedures including designation of counsel, discovery requests, settlement conferences, and trial management.
The deposition limits under this bill only apply to asbestos cases. This bill — upon a physician's declaration — will create a deposition limit for specified deponents in any civil action for injury or illness based upon exposure to asbestos. According to the author, this bill is limited only to asbestos litigation because several asbestos case management orders issued after the enactment of AB 1875 are inconsistent with existing law. Under the deposition "exception to the exception," the duration of a deposition is limited in complex matters if there is evidence that a deponent suffers from an illness or condition that raises substantial medical doubt of survival of the deponent beyond six months. The author contends that courts overseeing asbestos cases have ignored this "exception to the exception" and allow depositions to go beyond the statutory limit. Accordingly, the author contends that these orders subject dying asbestos plaintiffs to unnecessary lengthy—and sometimes fatal—depositions.
This bill creates a seven hour deposition limit for certain asbestos deponents, consistent with existing law. Existing law creates a presumption that depositions are limited to seven hours of total testimony unless an exception or other rule applies. Those exceptions include cases governed by a court order (including a case management order) and in complex cases. Additionally, there is a broad rule in existing law that requires the court to grant additional time "beyond any limits imposed by this section, if needed to fairly examine the deponent or if the deponent, another person, or any other circumstance impedes or delays the examination." (CCP Section 2025.290.) This bill provides that, notwithstanding those exceptions and the broad rule, a deposition in an asbestos case is limited to seven hours for those who are either elderly or severely-ill.
If additional time is needed, this bill authorizes judicial discretion to extend the deposition beyond seven hours, not to exceed 14 hours, if the health of the deponent does not appear to be endangered by the grant of additional time. To provide some flexibility for the court and the parties to extend the deposition beyond the initial seven hour limit, the bill provides that the deposition may be extended for another seven hours if the court finds that the health of the deponent does not appear to be endangered by the grant of additional time.
Although civil discovery rules are not generally meant to be limited so that truth and efficient information sharing can be promoted, the limits under this bill appear to be narrow in order to promote the laudable goal of protecting injured asbestos victims from grueling questioning where answers could be ascertained from other sources like written interrogatories. The deponents who would benefit from this bill are in a uniquely vulnerable position. According to data from the Center for Disease Control and Prevention, the median survival after a diagnosis of malignant mesothelioma is approximately one year. Despite regulatory action curtailing the use of asbestos, the number of deaths due to asbestos exposure annually continues to increase. Often in these types of cases, by the time victims are diagnosed and file suit, their health is dramatically impaired. Given the limitations on what damages can be recovered in survival actions after a victim has died, there is a perverse incentive for defendants to prolong litigation as much as possible.
Moreover, it appears that many of the answers that a defendant seeks to obtain from the asbestos victim could be provided through written interrogatories. For example, in Los Angeles Superior Court, the asbestos case management order requires the plaintiff to answer over 72 written interrogatories with over 300 sub-questions. Generally, the interrogatories will ask the plaintiff to tell the defendants about everything they did across the decades of their life, their family's medical history, as well as the products and jobsites where plaintiff may have been exposed to asbestos. Furthermore, when considering the factors for why a court may limit discovery ("unreasonably cumulative or duplicative"…"obtainable from some other source that is more convenient, less burdensome, or less expensive"), this bill appears to fit those standards when weighing the victims who would benefit, and the alternatives in obtaining information.
Analysis Prepared by: Eric Dang / JUD. / (916) 319-2334 FN: 0001033
Date of Hearing: June 20, 2017
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON JUDICIARY
Mark Stone, Chair
SBPCA Bill Id:SB 632
Author:(Monning) – As Amended Ver:April 17, 2017
As Proposed to be Amended
SENATE VOTE: 29-9
SUBJECT: CIVIL DISCOVERY: DEPOSITIONS
KEY ISSUE: IN ORDER TO ENSURE THAT VICTIMS SUFFERING and dying from ASBESTOS EXPOSURE ARE NOT REQUIRED TO SUBMIT TO UNNECESSARILY LENGTHY DEPOSITIONS—WHERE THEIR ANSWERS CAN BE PROVIDED BY OTHER WRITTEN DISCOVERY—SHOULD DEPOSITIONS of such victims BE LIMITED TO SEVEN HOURS, with ANOTHER SEVEN HOURS authorized IF THE additional TIME DOES NOT HARM THE HEALTH OF THE DEPONENT?
SYNOPSIS
The Civil Discovery Act (the Act) provides the manner in which a party to a civil action may engage in discovery. The Act authorizes parties to use depositions, interrogatories, document inspection, physical and mental examinations, requests for admissions, and to exchange expert witness information during discovery. In 2012, the Legislature enacted AB 1875 (Gatto, Chap. 346, Stats. 2012) which limits depositions to seven hours to protect vulnerable parties from abusive litigation tactics. However, this rule provides a series of exceptions—including when a court needs additional time to fairly examine the deponent, and when the case is governed by a case management order or is designated as complex. However, current law provides that even if a case is complex, if a deponent is unlikely to survive beyond six months, the deposition is limited to 14 hours.
According to the author, despite this legislative intent, courts have ignored this time limit and have allowed dying asbestos plaintiffs to be subjected to unnecessarily lengthy—and sometimes fatal—depositions. Accordingly, this bill limits a deposition to seven hours for elderly or gravely ill deponents in a civil action for injury based upon exposure to asbestos. The bill allows the court to extend the time limit for another seven hours if the health of the deponent is not endangered by the additional extension.
The bill is sponsored by the Consumer Attorneys of California and is supported by multiple labor organizations, including the California Labor Federation, State Building and Construction Trades Council, California Conference of Machinists, Heat & Frost Insulators & Allied Workers, SEIU California, and the California Professional Firefighters. The opponents of the bill—a coalition of the civil defense bar and business interests led by the Civil Justice Association of California that includes the American Insurance Association, the Association of California Insurance Companies, the California Association of Joint Powers Authorities, and California Defense Counsel—argue that this bill overturns AB 1875, limits judicial discretion, and interferes with a defendant’s due process rights during litigation. The author plans to adopt a clarifying and technical amendment in Committee relating to the findings required of a court in extending the deposition. This analysis reflects those amendments.
SUMMARY: Limits the deposition in asbestos litigation to seven hours for a deponent who is unlikely to survive beyond six months, or who is over 70 years of age and whose health or well-being would be prejudiced by a deposition beyond seven hours. Allows an additional seven hours of deposition if the court finds that the health of the deponent does not appear to be endangered by the grant of additional time. Specifically, this bill:
- Provides that in any civil action for injury or illness based upon exposure to asbestos, a deposition examination of the witness by all counsel, other than the witness’ counsel of record, shall be limited to seven hours of total testimony if a licensed physician attests in a declaration served on the parties that either:
- The deponent is over 70 years of age and his or her health is such that a deposition of more than seven hours will prejudice the deponent’s well-being.
- Without regard to the age of the deponent, the deponent suffers from an illness or condition that raises substantial medical doubt of the survival of the deponent beyond six months.
- Allows a party to seek up to seven hours of additional deposition testimony for no more than 14 hours of total testimony. The extension shall not be granted unless the court makes a factual finding supporting the extension beyond seven hours, and determines that the health of the deponent does not appear to be endangered by the grant of additional time.
- Clarifies that this bill’s provisions do not affect the existing right of any party to move for a protective order or the court’s discretion to make any order that justice requires to limit a deposition in order to protect any party, deponent, or other natural person or organization from unwarranted annoyance, embarrassment, oppression, undue burden, or expense.
EXISTING LAW:
- Establishes the Civil Discovery Act, which provides the manner in which parties may engage in discovery. (Code of Civil Procedure Section 2016.010 et seq. Unless provided otherwise, all further statutory references are to this Code.)
- Allows a party to a civil action to obtain discovery by, among other methods, oral and written depositions, interrogatories, inspection of documents, and requests for admissions. (Section 2019.010.)
- Limits a deposition examination of the witness by all counsel, other than the witness’ counsel of record, to seven hours of total testimony except as provided. (Section 2025.290 (a).)
- Requires the court to allow additional time, beyond any limits imposed as provided, if needed to fairly examine the deponent or if the deponent, another person, or any other circumstance impedes or delays the examination. (Section 2025.290 (a).)
- Provides that the seven hour of total testimony limit does not apply under any of the following circumstances:
- If the parties have stipulated that the limit will not apply to a specific deposition or to the entire proceeding.
- To any deposition of a witness designated as an expert as defined.
- To any case designated as complex by the court pursuant to Rule 3.400 of the California Rules of Court, unless a licensed physician attests in a declaration served on the parties that the deponent suffers from an illness or condition that raises substantial medical doubt of survival of the deponent beyond six months, in which case the deposition examination of the witness by all counsel, other than the witness’ counsel of record, shall be limited to two days of no more than seven hours of total testimony each day, or 14 hours of total testimony.
- To any case brought by an employee or applicant for employment against an employer for acts or omissions arising out of or relating to the employment relationship.
- To any deposition of a person who is designated as the most qualified person to be deposed as defined.
- To any party who appeared in the action after the deposition has concluded, in which case the new party may notice another deposition, as provided. (Section 2025.290 (b).)
- Pursuant to Federal Rules of Civil Procedure, a deposition is limited to one day of seven hours unless otherwise stipulated or ordered by the court. The court must allow additional time consistent with Rule 26(b)(1) and (2) if needed to fairly examine the deponent or if the deponent, another person, or any other circumstance impedes or delays the examination. (Fed. Rules Civ. Proc., rule 30(d)(1), 28 U.S.C.)
- Defines a complex case and provides factors that the court considers in determining whether an action is considered complex. (Cal. Rules of Court, rules 3.400.)
- Requires the court, in deciding whether an action is a complex case, to consider whether the action is likely to involve any of the following factors:
- Numerous pretrial motions raising difficult or novel legal issues that will be time-consuming to resolve;
- Management of a large number of witnesses or a substantial amount of documentary evidence;
- Management of a large number of separately represented parties;
- Coordination with related actions pending in one or more courts in other counties, states, or countries, or in a federal court; or
- Substantial postjudgment judicial supervision. (Ibid.)
- Specifies that an action is provisionally a complex case if it involves one or more of the following types of claims:
- Antitrust or trade regulation claims;
- Construction defect claims involving many parties or structures;
- Securities claims or investment losses involving many parties;
- Environmental or toxic tort claims involving many parties;
- Claims involving mass torts;
- Claims involving class actions; or
- Insurance coverage claims as provided. (Ibid.)
FISCAL EFFECT: As currently in print this bill is keyed non-fiscal.
COMMENTS: The Civil Discovery Act (the Act) provides the manner in which a party to a civil action may engage in discovery. Generally, California’s discovery rules are liberally construed in favor of disclosure in order to promote the following policy goals:
(1) to give greater assistance to the parties in ascertaining the truth and in checking and preventing perjury; (2) to provide an effective means of detecting and exposing false, fraudulent and sham claims and defenses; (3) to make available, in a simple, convenient and inexpensive way, facts which otherwise could not be proved except with great difficulty; (4) to educate the parties in advance of trial as to the real value of their claims and defenses, thereby encouraging settlements; (5) to expedite litigation; (6) to safeguard against surprise; (7) to prevent delay; (8) to simplify and narrow the issues; and, (9) to expedite and facilitate both preparation and trial. (Greyhound Corp. v. Superior Court (1961) 56 Cal.2d 355, 376.)
To that end, the Civil Discovery Act authorizes parties to use depositions, interrogatories, document inspection, physical and mental examinations, requests for admissions, and the exchange of expert witness information during discovery.
There are limited circumstances under which a court may narrow discovery. Generally, a court will only restrict or limit discovery in specific instances. For example, a court is required to limit discovery if it determines that the discovery being sought is “unreasonably cumulative or duplicative.” (Section 2019.030.) Additionally, the court may limit discovery if the information “is obtainable from some other source that is more convenient, less burdensome, or less expensive.” (Ibid.) Generally speaking, the court may also limit discovery after considering the needs of a case, the amount in controversy, and the importance of the issues in the case. (Ibid.)
Existing law limits depositions to seven hours to protect vulnerable parties from abusive litigation tactics. In 2012, the Legislature enacted AB 1875 (Gatto, Chap. 346, Stats. 2012) which creates a presumption that a deposition examination of any person shall not exceed seven hours of total testimony except in specific circumstances. One policy reason behind this seven-hour deposition limit was to protect parties against “needlessly long and repetitious questioning that allegedly serves no other purposes than to harass the deponent or delay the proceeding.” (Assembly Judiciary Committee analysis of AB 1875; April 24, 2012.) Another policy reason for the deposition limit was to protect vulnerably ill or elderly plaintiffs, and workers suffering from injuries or exposure to workplace chemicals from litigation tactics. (Ibid.)
Existing law provides a series of the exceptions to the seven-hour rule. Despite the seven-hour presumption, the law allows a court to grant additional time if additional time is needed to “fairly examine the deponent” or if “the deponent, another person, or any other circumstance impedes or delays the examination.” Furthermore, the seven-hour rule does not apply if the parties stipulate to longer depositions, or the deponent is an expert. Relevant to this bill, the seven-hour rule does not apply in cases governed by a case management order or designated by the court as complex—in order words, cases involving many parties, multiple witnesses, or coordination between several courts. Generally, a case involving environmental or toxic tort claims involving many parties are provisionally designated as a complex case. (Cal. Rules of Court, Rule 3.400.)
There is also an exception to the exception. Even in matters that have been deemed to be complex, the deposition may be limited if a physician provides a declaration attesting that a “deponent suffers from an illness or condition that raises substantial medical doubt of survival of the deponent beyond six months.” (Section 2025.290.) In those circumstances, the deposition is limited to two days of no more than seven hours of total testimony each day, or 14 hours of total testimony.” (Ibid.)
Problem this bill seeks to address. According to the author:
Despite the clear intent of the California Legislature in 2012 to protect dying victims from abusive depositions, courts overseeing asbestos cases have ignored the 14-hour presumption, relying on broad language in the Code of Civil Procedure permitting judicial discretion in determining the length of a deposition. As a result, courts are ignoring the presumptive time limit altogether, and dying asbestos plaintiffs continue to be subjected to unnecessary lengthy—and sometimes fatal—depositions.
Summary of this bill. This bill limits the deposition of a deponent in asbestos litigation to seven hours of total testimony if a physician provides a declaration, attesting to either of the following: (1) the deponent, regardless of age, suffers from an illness or condition that raises substantial medical doubt of the survival of the deponent beyond six months; or (2) the deponent is over 70 years of age whose health is such that a deposition of more than seven hours would prejudice the deponent’s well-being. This bill allows an additional seven hours of deposition if the court makes a factual finding supporting the extension, and determines that the health of the deponent does not appear to be endangered by the grant of additional time.
Background on asbestos and asbestos litigation. As many know, asbestos is a naturally occurring fibrous mineral. Because asbestos was once viewed as a “miracle mineral” for its heat- and fire-resistant and flexible properties, it was once incorporated into many commercial household and building products (even though many people have known asbestos to be a health hazard.) (Kaminsky and Campbell, The Lawyer’s Guide to Lead Paint, Asbestos, and Chinese Drywall (2010) pp. 87- 90.) Indeed, according to the Office of Environmental Health Hazard Assessment (OEHHA), asbestos is classified as a known human carcinogen by state, federal, and international agencies and was identified in 1986 as a Toxic Air Contaminant by the California Air Resources Board.
Naturally, asbestos fibers can cause health problems if they are inhaled. For instance, asbestos exposure can result in pleural disease (pleural thickening in the lungs), asbestosis (scarring of the lung tissue), lung cancer, and mesothelioma—a fatal cancer in the lining of the chest or abdomen. (Kaminsky and Campbell, supra, pp. 93-95.) However, given the long latency period between the initial asbestos exposure and the first onset of disease, oftentimes, civil tort and product liability claims may not occur until long after exposure, resulting in actions that likely involve multiple plaintiffs, defendants, experts, and witnesses. Troublingly, many victims of asbestos exposure—often industrial, commercial, and residential construction workers—are in significant pain and do not survive the litigation. Given these various issues, courts designate asbestos cases as complex, and manage asbestos claims differently than other cases.
In order to streamline asbestos litigation, several courts have issued case management orders in asbestos cases. Given the complexity of asbestos cases, several California courts have issued case management orders that govern personal injury cases arising from asbestos exposure. In other words, in several courts, all asbestos litigation in those courts must follow specific rules on various procedures including designation of counsel, discovery requests, settlement conferences, and trial management. For example, in San Francisco Superior Court, all parties in complex asbestos litigation are required to participate in informal discovery conferences with the court’s asbestos judge or designee. The Committee has learned that at least three courts have issued asbestos case management orders: Alameda, San Francisco, and Los Angeles. Presumably, one reason behind the streamlining of these cases is to promote court efficiency; another reason for the expedience is likely to ensure that plaintiffs survive the litigation process.
The deposition limits under this bill only apply to asbestos cases. As stated, this bill—upon a physician’s declaration—will create a deposition limit for specified deponents in any civil action for injury or illness based upon exposure to asbestos. According to the author, this bill is limited only to asbestos litigation because several asbestos case management orders issued after the enactment of AB 1875 are inconsistent with existing law. Under the deposition “exception to the exception,” the duration of a deposition is limited in complex matters if there is evidence that a deponent suffers from an illness or condition that raises substantial medical doubt of survival of the deponent beyond six months. The author contends that courts overseeing asbestos cases have ignored this “exception to the exception” and allow depositions to go beyond the statutory limit. Accordingly, the author contends that these orders subject dying asbestos plaintiffs to unnecessary lengthy—and sometimes fatal—depositions.
This bill creates a seven hour deposition limit for certain asbestos deponents, consistent with existing law. As previously mentioned, existing law creates a presumption that depositions are limited to seven hours of total testimony unless an exception or other rule applies. Those exceptions include cases governed by a court order (including a case management order) and in complex cases. Additionally, there is a broad rule in existing law that requires the court to grant additional time “beyond any limits imposed by this section, if needed to fairly examine the deponent or if the deponent, another person, or any other circumstance impedes or delays the examination.” (Section 2025.290.) (It is believed that this broad rule has allowed courts and parties to ignore the “exception to the exception.”)
This bill provides that, notwithstanding those exceptions and the broad rule, a deposition in an asbestos case is limited to seven hours for those who are either elderly or severely-ill. Specifically, this bill establishes a seven-hour limit if a licensed physician provides a declaration, attesting to either of the following: (1) the deponent is over 70 years of age and his or her health is such that a deposition of more than seven hours will prejudice the deponent’s well-being; or (2) without regard to the age of the deponent, the deponent suffers from an illness or condition that raises substantial medical doubt of the survival of the deponent beyond six months.
If additional time is needed, this bill authorizes judicial discretion to extend the deposition beyond 7 hours, not to exceed 14 hours, if the health of the deponent does not appear to be endangered by the grant of additional time. To provide some flexibility for the court and the parties to extend the deposition beyond the initial seven hour limit, the bill provides that the deposition may be extended for another seven hours if the court finds that the health of the deponent does not appear to be endangered by the grant of additional time.
The opponents of the bill—made up of a coalition of the business and insurances interests, and the civil defense bar—believe that this bill does not provide sufficient judicial discretion. They write: “[Under this bill], judges are given the authority to order more time if they make specified findings, but only up to 14 hours. This obviously limits the discretion of a judge to order a deposition longer than 14 hours, but it also overrules decisions which judges have made in crafting local case management orders….These orders were crafted by judges who presided over asbestos cases on a daily basis, and we object to provisions of a bill which overrule their reasoned decisions.”
In response, the author and sponsor note the following: “SB 632 creates a balance—it protects the remaining life of dying asbestos victims, and their right to finish their depositions while they are still alive. It also protects the rights of defendants to ask a judge for more time if the specific facts of that specific case make more time necessary. Right now, the burden is on victims to prove that a ‘one size fits all,’ generic standard does not fit their case, and this is backwards.”
Notably, both the Judicial Council of California and the California Judges Association continue to monitor this bill and do not express a position on the bill.
Although civil discovery rules are not generally meant to be limited so that truth and efficient information sharing can be promoted, the limits under this bill appear to be narrow in order to promote the laudable goal of protecting injured asbestos victims from grueling questioning where answers could be ascertained from other sources like written interrogatories. The deponents who would benefit from this bill are in a uniquely vulnerable position. According to data from the Center for Disease Control and Prevention, the median survival after a diagnosis of malignant mesothelioma is approximately one year. Despite regulatory action curtailing the use of asbestos, the number of deaths due to asbestos exposure annually continues to increase. Often in these types of cases, by the time victims are diagnosed and file suit, their health is dramatically impaired. Given the limitations on what damages can be recovered in survival actions after a victim has died, there is a perverse incentive for defendants to prolong litigation as much as possible.
Moreover, it appears that many of the answers that a defendant seeks to obtain from the asbestos victim could be provided through written interrogatories. For example, in Los Angeles Superior Court, the asbestos case management order requires the plaintiff to answer over 72 written interrogatories with over 300 sub-questions. Generally, the interrogatories will ask the plaintiff to tell the defendants about everything they did across the decades of their life, their family’s medical history, as well as the products and jobsites where plaintiff may have been exposed to asbestos. Furthermore, when considering the factors for why a court may limit discovery (“unreasonably cumulative or duplicative”…“obtainable from some other source that is more convenient, less burdensome, or less expensive”), this bill appears to fit those standards when weighing the victims who would benefit, and the alternatives in obtaining information.
Testimony during a deposition is not required for a defendant to succeed on a motion for summary judgment. The opponents of the bill cite Scheidling v. Dinwiddie Construction Co. (1999) 69 Cal.App.4th 64, for the proposition that each defendant must specifically ask the plaintiff about potential exposure to the defendant’s products in order to support a motion for summary judgment. In other words, the opponents are essentially arguing that a time limit on depositions would curb their ability to seek a motion for summary judgment. While Committee staff notes that it is true that a party must present affirmative evidence to support a motion for summary judgment, the Scheidling case does not hold that the defendant is required to obtain affirmative evidence from a deposition. The defendant can still obtain affirmative evidence from written discovery under interrogatories or a request for admissions to support a motion for summary judgment.
Some argue that this bill is merely reaffirming the intent behind AB 1875 (Gatto). Some argue that this bill is merely re-establishing the “exception to the exception” under existing law. As previously stated, the exception which applies to complex cases does not apply to deponents who suffer from an illness or condition that raises substantial medical doubt of survival of the deponent beyond six months. In those instances, the deposition is limited to 14 hours. This bill essentially reinforces the “exception to the exception” under existing law by creating an absolute deposition limit of 14 hours for individuals who are elderly or gravely ill so that other exceptions available under the law do not apply.
Technical amendment. To provide some clarity about the findings that must be presented to the court, the author proposes to adopt the following technical and clarifying amendment in Committee:
On page 2, in line 18, strike out “If a court”, strike out lines 19 to 22, inclusive, and insert:
The extension shall not be granted unless the court makes a factual finding supporting the extension beyond seven hours, and determines that the health of the deponent does not appear to be endangered by the grant of additional time.
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: In support of this bill, the State Building and Construction Trades Council, AFL-CIO, writes:
Victims of mesothelioma, a disease caused only by exposure to asbestos that predominately afflicts construction workers and their families, commonly survive less than a year after diagnosis. This is a very painful disease and extended depositions are already hard on individuals who are healthy, but can be fatal to those who are in excruciating pain from this illness. This bill is important to workers because it will help protect persons who are dying from mesothelioma from being subjected to abusive depositions. By limiting the time allowed for a person’s deposition to one day of seven hours, similar to federal law, it will make a big difference for our members and their families should either one contract this horrible disease.
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION: In its coalition opposition letter, the Civil Justice Association, the American Insurance Association, the Association of California Insurance Companies, the California Defense Counsel, and the California Association of Joint Powers Authorities writes:
In 2012, the California Legislature enacted Code of Civil Procedure Section 2025.290, which limited the length of depositions in civil actions. The statute was the result of exacting negotiations over many months that included CJAC and CDC. This joint effort to protect plaintiffs’ interests while also ensuring due process rights for defendants created a broad rule limiting depositions to seven hours of total testimony, with very specific exceptions which were negotiated by stakeholders. Among those exceptions were cases designated as complex by the California Rules of Court, unless the deponent presents a declaration from a physician that raises substantial doubt of the deponent’s survival beyond six months, and cases subject to case management orders issued by local courts. Thus, there were exceptions to the seven-hour deposition limit, but also “exceptions to the exceptions” if a doctor declares that the survival of the plaintiff is in substantial doubt. This system gives all parties clear rules for depositions but also the ability for judges to exercise discretion in appropriate circumstances. Again, this construct was negotiated by and between stakeholders for plaintiffs, defendants, and the courts.
SB 632 proposes to overturn this carefully negotiated statute for plaintiffs alleging injury from asbestos exposure. The bill actually overrides not one, but two exceptions to the general rule created in CCP Section 2025.290: the exception for cases designated as “complex” pursuant to statewide Rules of Court, and the exception for cases subject to case management orders by local courts.
Author’s statement. In support of this bill, the author writes:
Many workers, especially in the trades, suffered exposure to asbestos in their workplace. Asbestos poisoning can result in terrible diseases, including mesothelioma. The manufacturers of products containing asbestos knew of the dangers for many years yet did not remove asbestos from products that exposed workers. As a result, workers and their families have the right to pursue a civil action against those manufacturers to seek compensation for their injuries….The bill sets sensible limits on depositions for dying asbestos victims.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
Consumer Attorneys of California (sponsor)
Asbestos Disease Awareness Organization
Asbestos Workers Local 16 Retirees Club
California Conference Board of the Amalgamated Transit Union
California Conference of Machinists
California Labor Federation
California Teamsters Public Affairs Council
California Professional Firefighters
Communication Workers of America, District 9, AFL-CIO
Communication Workers of America, Local 9421
Contra Costa Building and Construction Trades Council, AFL-CIO
District Council of Iron Workers of the State of California and Vicinity
Engineers and Scientists of California, IFPTE Local 20, AFL-CIO
Heat & Frost Insulators & Allied Workers Local 5
International Longshore & Warehouse Union
Labor & Employment Committee of the National Lawyers Guild
Northern California District Council of the International Longshore and Warehouse Union
Professional and Technical Engineers, IFPTE Local 21, AFL-CIO
San Francisco Bay Area Physicians for Social Responsibility
Service Employees International Union California
State Building and Construction Trades Council of California
UNITE-HERE, AFL-CIO
Utility Workers of America
Worksafe
Opposition
American Insurance Association
Association of California Insurance Companies
California Association of Joint Powers Authorities
California Defense Counsel
Civil Justice Association of California
Analysis Prepared by: Eric Dang / JUD. / (916) 319-2334
Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | SB |
THIRD READING
Bill No: SB 632
:
SENATE JUDICIARY COMMITTEE: 5-1, 5/2/17
AYES: Jackson, Moorlach, Monning, Stern, Wieckowski
NOES: Anderson
NO VOTE RECORDED: Hertzberg
SOURCE: Consumer Attorneys of California
DIGEST: This bill limits the deposition of a deponent in asbestos litigation to seven hours of total testimony when a physician attests that the deponent is either over 70 years of age and the deponent’s health is such that a deposition of more than seven hours will prejudice the deponent’s well-being, or that, without regard to age of the deponent, the deponent suffers from an illness or condition that raises substantial medical doubt of the survival of the deponent beyond six months. An additional seven hours of deposition testimony can be authorized if it is found that it does not endanger the health of the deponent.
Existing law:
- Provides procedures by which parties to a civil action conduct and obtain “discovery,” including by, among other things, depositions. (Code Civ. Proc. Sec. 2017.010 et seq.)
- Permits a party to a civil action to take an oral deposition of any person upon service of a proper notice indicating the date, time, and location of the deposition, as well as notice of any materials that must be produced at the deposition. The person deposed may be a natural person, an organization such as a public or private corporation, a partnership, an association, or a governmental agency. (Code Civ. Proc. Sec. 2025.010 et seq.)
- Permits any party or deponent, at any time before, during, or after a deposition, to seek a protective order from the court, as specified. (Code Civ. Proc. Sec. 2025.420.)
- Authorizes a deposition officer to suspend the taking of testimony to enable the party or deponent to move for such protective order on the ground that the examination is being conducted in bad faith or in a manner that unreasonably annoys, embarrasses, or oppresses that deponent or party. (Code Civ. Proc. Sec. 2025.470.)
- Governs, through the Rules of Court, complex cases, and defines them as an action that requires exceptional judicial management to avoid placing unnecessary burdens on the court or the litigants and to expedite the case, keep costs reasonable, and promote effective decision making by the court, the parties, and counsel. (Cal. Rules of Court, rule 3.400.)
- Provides that a deposition is limited to seven hours of total testimony, except as provided or as ordered by the court. The court is required to allow additional time if needed to fairly examine the deponent or if the deponent, another person, or any other circumstance impedes or delays the examination. (Code Civ. Proc. Sec. 2025.290(a).)
- Exempts the following circumstances from the presumptive limit of seven hours of deposition testimony:
- if the parties have stipulated that this section will not apply to a specific deposition or to the entire proceeding;
- to any deposition of an expert witness, as specified;
- to any case designated as a complex case, as specified, unless a licensed physician attests in a declaration served on the parties that the deponent suffers from an illness or condition raising substantial medical doubt of survival of the deponent beyond six months, in which case the deposition shall be limited to two days of no more than seven hours of total testimony each day, or 14 hours of total testimony;
- to any case brought by an employee or applicant for employment against an employer for acts or omissions arising out of the employment relationship;
- to any deposition of a person designated as the most qualified person to be deposed, as specified; and
- to any party who appeared in the action after the deposition has concluded, in which case the new party may notice another deposition subject to the requirements of this section. (Code Civ. Proc. Sec. 2025.290(b).)
- Provides that nothing in the section described above shall be construed to affect the existing right of any party to move for a protective order or the court's discretion to make any order that justice requires to limit a deposition in order to protect any party, deponent, or other natural person or organization from unwarranted annoyance, embarrassment, oppression, undue burden, or expense. (Code Civ. Proc. Sec. 2025.290(c).)
- Provides that a cause of action that survives the death of the person entitled to commence an action or proceeding (decedent) passes to the decedent's successor in interest, as specified, and an action may be commenced by the decedent's personal representative or, if none, by the decedent's successor in interest. (Code Civ. Proc. Sec. 377.30.) In such an action or proceeding by a decedent's personal representative or successor in interest on the decedent's cause of action, the damages recoverable are limited to the loss or damage that the decedent sustained or incurred before death, including any penalties or punitive or exemplary damages that the decedent would have been entitled to recover had the decedent lived, and do not include damages for pain, suffering, or disfigurement. (Code Civ. Proc. Sec. 377.34.)
This bill:
- Provides, notwithstanding Section 2025.290 of the Code of Civil Procedure, in any civil action for injury or illness based upon exposure to asbestos, a deposition examination of the witness by all counsel, other than the witness’ counsel of record, must be limited to seven hours of total testimony if a licensed physician attests in a declaration served on the parties that either:
- the deponent is over 70 years of age and the deponent’s health is such that a deposition of more than seven hours will prejudice the deponent’s well-being; or
- the deponent suffers from an illness or condition that raises substantial medical doubt of the survival of the deponent beyond six months.
- Allows a party to seek up to seven hours of additional deposition testimony for no more than 14 hours of total testimony. If a court grants such an extension, the court is required to include in its order a factual finding supporting the extension beyond seven hours, and a statement that the health of the deponent does not appear to be endangered by the grant of additional time.
- Specifies that it does not affect the existing right of any party to move for a protective order or the court’s discretion to make any order that justice requires to limit a deposition in order to protect any party, deponent, or other natural person or organization from unwarranted annoyance, embarrassment, oppression, undue burden, or expense.
Background
A deposition is a witness’ out-of-court testimony reduced to writing for later use in a court proceeding. The Civil Discovery Act applies to every civil action and special proceeding of a civil nature, unless there is a statutory exception. Prior to 2012, California law did not provide for any statutory limit on the length of depositions. In response to abuses of the system, AB 1875 (Gatto, Chapter 346, Statutes 2012) was enacted into law. It requires deposition testimony to be limited to seven hours, except as provided or as ordered by the court. The law requires that the court allow additional time if needed to fairly examine the deponent or if the deponent, another person, or any other circumstance impedes or delays the examination. Certain exceptions were also put into place to the presumptive seven-hour limit.
One of the enumerated exceptions is the exception for complex cases, as specified under rule 3.400 of the California Rules of Court. However, an exception to the exception also exists. The exception for complex cases specifies that it does not apply if a licensed physician attests in a declaration served on all parties that the deponent suffers from an illness or condition raising substantial medical doubt of survival of the deponent beyond six months. In that instance, the deposition examination of the deponent by all counsel, other than the deponent’s counsel of record, must be limited to two days of no more than seven hours of total testimony each day, or 14 hours of total testimony. This “exception to the exception” was intended to address the problems posed by asbestos litigation cases, which often involve extremely sick plaintiffs and numerous defendants.
However, since that time, the statute has been interpreted such that the seven- to 14-hour limit on depositions for deponents in complex cases with an illness or condition raising substantial medical doubt of survival of the deponent beyond six months to be subject to the broad discretion vested in the courts by the preceding section. This bill explicitly provides that for deponents in asbestos litigation a deposition examination must be limited to seven hours of total testimony if a licensed physician attests in a declaration that the deponent is either: (1) over 70 years of age and the deponent’s health is such that a deposition of more than seven hours will prejudice the deponent’s well-being; or (2) suffers from an illness or condition that raises substantial medical doubt of the survival of the deponent beyond six months. An additional seven hours of deposition testimony can be authorized for a total of no more than 14 hours of testimony. If a court were to grant such an extension, the order is required to include a factual finding supporting the extension and a statement that the health of the deponent does not appear to be endangered by the grant of additional time.
Comments
The author writes:
Many workers, especially in the trades, suffered exposure to asbestos in their workplace. Asbestos poisoning can result in terrible diseases, including mesothelioma. The manufacturers of products containing asbestos knew of the dangers for many years yet did not remove asbestos from products that exposed workers. As a result, workers and their families have the right to pursue a civil action against those manufacturers to seek compensation for their injuries.
Once these civil actions are filed, defendants are entitled to seek information from the plaintiff through both written discovery (interrogatories and request for admission) and oral discovery (depositions). Unfortunately, once a person is diagnosed with mesothelioma, they are locked into a painful death spiral. Many of these people are older and will die quickly due to the nature of the disease.
In [California], if a plaintiff dies before the resolution of their case, their general damages (pain and suffering) die with them. So any chance at justice is denied. Defendants often subject the dying asbestos victims to lengthy depositions, at times so long that the plaintiff dies before the depositions are complete. Their claims die with them.
Despite the clear intent of the California Legislature in 2012 to protect dying victims from abusive depositions, courts overseeing asbestos cases have ignored the 14-hour presumption, relying on broad language in Code of Civil Procedure 2025.290 (a) permitting “judicial discretion” in determining the length of a deposition. As a result, courts are ignoring the presumptive time limit altogether, and dying asbestos plaintiffs continue to be subjected to unnecessary lengthy – and sometimes fatal – depositions. The bill sets sensible limits on depositions for dying asbestos victims. The bill would enact a limit of 7 hours on depositions of asbestos plaintiffs.
Limited circumstances
Generally, a party may take the deposition of any person, including any other party in the action. (Code Civ. Proc. Sec. 2025.010.) Added in 2012, California Code of Civil Procedure 2025.290(a) establishes a presumptive time limit of seven hours of total deposition testimony but grants discretion to the court to allow additional time for testimony “if needed to fairly examine the deponent or if the deponent, another person, or any other circumstances impedes or delays the examination.”
Subdivision (b) of Section 2025.290 lays out exceptions to the presumption. Paragraph (3) excepts complex cases. The statute provides, however, that this exception does not apply if a physician attests in a declaration that the deponent suffers from an illness that raises substantial medical doubt of survival beyond six months. When this declaration is provided, the deposition examination of the deponent described shall be limited to two days of no more than seven hours of total testimony each day, or 14 hours of total testimony.
The issue that has arisen, and that has motivated this legislation, is whether and how the clause in subdivision (a) providing the court discretion to grant additional time for a deposition applies to the “exception to the exception” where a deponent in a complex case provides documentation that there is substantial medical doubt of survival beyond six months. The relevant question is how courts should apply the two-day, 14-hour limitation provided in paragraph (3) of subdivision (b).
The sponsor asserts that the clear intent of AB 1875 (Gatto, Chapter 346, Statutes 2012) was to protect dying victims from abusive depositions, but that courts are systematically ignoring the 14-hour presumption by relying on the broad language in subdivision (a). The sponsor states this has resulted in dying asbestos plaintiffs continuing to be subjected to unnecessarily lengthy depositions.
A review of the committee analyses of AB 1875 supports the contention that the 14-hour limit was primarily intended for asbestos plaintiffs: “This ‘exception to the exception’ is aimed, in many respects, at problems posed by asbestos litigation cases, which often involve extremely sick plaintiffs and numerous defendants.”
This bill makes clear that in complex asbestos litigation, a deposition examination is limited to seven hours when the deponent has certain serious health concerns that are documented by a licensed physician. If the court is presented with sufficient evidence to support an extension and it is clear that the health of the deponent does not appear to be endangered by such an extension, an order can extend the deposition testimony up to a total of 14 hours. This bill provides additional protections to the intended targets of the initial legislation; however, it also places strict constraints on the ability of defendants or the court to extend the deposition testimony.
Protections for a narrow and vulnerable group of plaintiffs
This bill provides a cap on the deposition testimony of deponents in asbestos litigation who have severe health issues. The deponents that benefit are in a uniquely vulnerable position. According to data from the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, the median survival after a diagnosis of malignant mesothelioma (a disease caused by asbestos exposure) is approximately one year. Despite regulatory action curtailing the use of asbestos, the number of deaths due to asbestos exposure annually is increasing. Often in these types of cases, by the time victims are diagnosed and have time to file suit, their health is dramatically impaired. Given the limitations on what damages can be recovered in survival actions after a victim has died, there is a perverse incentive for defendants to prolong litigation as much as possible. This bill provides a reasonable limitation on deposition testimony in a narrow subset of cases based on documented health concerns.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: Fiscal Com.: Local:
Consumer Attorneys of California (source)
Asbestos Disease Awareness Organization
Asbestos Workers Local 16 Retirees Club
California Conference Board of the Amalgamated Transit Union
California Conference of Machinists
California Labor Federation
California Professional Firefighters
California Teamsters Public Affairs Council
District Council of Iron Workers of the State of California and Vicinity
Engineers and Scientists of California, IFPTE Local 20, AFL-CIO
Heat & Frost Insulators & Allied Workers Local 5
International Longshore & Warehouse Union
Labor & Employment Committee of the National Lawyers Guild
Professional and Technical Engineers, IFPTE Local 21, AFL-CIO
Service Employees International Union
State Building and Construction Trades Council, AFL-CIO
UNITE-HERE, AFL-CIO
Utility Workers of America
American Insurance Association
Association of California Insurance Companies
California Association of Joint Powers Authorities
California Defense Counsel
Civil Justice Association of California
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: The California Teamsters Public Affairs Council writes in support that this bill puts a stop to “overly long, abusive depositions of dying victims where they are sometimes harassed for multiple days.”
The District Council of Iron Workers of the State of California and Vicinity explain their support: “When our members or their family are ill and dying from asbestos, they may use state courts to hold accountable the manufacturers, premises owners, and others who knew, since the 1930s about the horrendous dangers of asbestos but failed to warn or provide protection from this deadly toxin. . . . [Mesothelioma] is a very painful disease and extended depositions are hard enough on individuals who are healthy, but can be fatal to those who are in excruciating pain from this illness.”
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION: The Civil Justice Association of California and a group of others in opposition write: “SB 632 would upend California discovery law by limiting depositions length for asbestos plaintiffs who are over 70 years old and in bad health. Although we are of course sympathetic to asbestos plaintiffs, this overly restrictive bill would unduly prejudice asbestos defendants.
Asbestos cases are large and complex. The plaintiff may have been exposed to asbestos at multiple work sites over decades of work – usually many decades ago. Asbestos lawsuits often involve dozens or more defendants. A common practice by the plaintiffs’ bar involves naming multiple defendants and then many of those defendants conduct discovery to support a motion to dismiss, with evidence as to why they should have never been sued in the first place. The remaining defendants then are left to argue proper apportionment of liability.”
5/5/17 13:56:34
Senator Hannah-Beth Jackson, Chair
2017-2018 Regular Session
Bill No: SB 632 (Author:Monning)
Version: April 17, 2017
Hearing Date: May 2, 2017
Fiscal: No
Urgency: No
Consultant: CK
SUBJECT
Civil discovery: depositions
DESCRIPTION
This bill limits the deposition of a deponent in asbestos litigation to seven hours of total testimony when a physician attests that the deponent is either over 70 years of age and the deponent’s health is such that a deposition of more than seven hours will prejudice the deponent’s well-being, or that, without regard to age of the deponent, the deponent suffers from an illness or condition that raises substantial medical doubt of the survival of the deponent beyond six months. An additional seven hours of deposition testimony could be authorized if it is found that it would not endanger the health of the deponent.
BACKGROUND
A deposition is a witness’ out-of-court testimony reduced to writing for later use in a
court proceeding. Under Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 30(d)(1), oral depositions generally must be limited to one day of seven hours in duration. Likewise, several states similarly provide for presumptive limits to depositions. For example, Texas generally provides each party no more than six hours in total to examine and cross-examine all witnesses in oral depositions in suits involving $50,000 or less. (See Tex. Rule Civ. Proc. Rule 190.2.) Arizona provides that the oral deposition of any party or witness, including expert witnesses, whenever taken, shall not exceed four hours in length, except pursuant to stipulation of the parties, or, upon motion and a showing of good cause. (See Ariz. Rule Civ. Proc. Rule 30(d).)
The Civil Discovery Act applies to every civil action and special proceeding of a civil nature, unless there is a statutory exception. The intention of California’s broad discovery statutes is to make discovery a “simple, convenient, and inexpensive” means of revealing the truth and exposing false claims, to “educate the parties concerning their claims and defenses so as to encourage settlements and to expedite and facilitate trial,” and eliminate surprise. Moreover, California courts have reiterated that discovery provisions are to be liberally construed in favor of disclosure.
Prior to 2012, California law did not provide for any statutory limit on the length of depositions, even though the modern discovery methods in California can be traced to the Civil Discovery Act of 1957 which, with minor changes, was patterned on the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure. Because California law did not provide for any statutory limit on the length of depositions, so long as counsel continued the deposition, they could have continued over any number of days and hours, leading up to the 30th day before the date initially set for a trial (or even longer if a court order or written agreement extends the statutory cut-off). In response to abuses of the system and to harmonize with the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure, AB 1875 (Gatto, Chapter 346, Statutes 2012) was enacted into law. It requires deposition testimony to be limited to seven hours, except as provided or as ordered by the court. The law requires that the court allow additional time if needed to fairly examine the deponent or if the deponent, another person, or any other circumstance impedes or delays the examination. Certain exceptions were also put into place to the presumptive seven-hour limit.
One of the enumerated exceptions to the general rule is the exception for complex cases, as specified under rule 3.400 of the California Rules of Court. However, an exception to the exception also exists. The exception for complex cases specifies that it does not apply if a licensed physician attests in a declaration served on all parties that the deponent suffers from an illness or condition raising substantial medical doubt of survival of the deponent beyond six months. In that instance, the deposition examination of the deponent by all counsel, other than the deponent’s counsel of record, must be limited to two days of no more than seven hours of total testimony each day, or 14 hours of total testimony. Committee analysis of AB 1875 reveals that this “exception to the exception” was intended to address the problems posed by asbestos litigation cases, which often involve extremely sick plaintiffs and numerous defendants. Some courts had been limiting oral depositions in asbestos cases, locally, but this sought to make such limitations universal.
However, since that time, the statute has been interpreted such that the seven to 14 hour limit on depositions for deponents in complex cases with an illness or condition raising substantial medical doubt of survival of the deponent beyond six months to be subject to the broad discretion vested in the courts by the preceding section. This bill would explicitly provide that for deponents in asbestos litigation a deposition examination must be limited to seven hours of total testimony if a licensed physician attests in a declaration that the deponent is either: (1) over 70 years of age and the deponent’s health is such that a deposition of more than seven hours will prejudice the deponent’s well-being; or (2) suffers from an illness or condition that raises substantial medical doubt of the survival of the deponent beyond six months. An additional seven hours of deposition testimony could be authorized for a total of no more than 14 hours of testimony. If a court were to grant such an extension, the order would be required to include a factual finding supporting the extension and a statement that the health of the deponent does not appear to be endangered by the grant of additional time.
CHANGES TO EXISTING LAW
Existing Federal Rules of Civil Procedure provide that unless otherwise stipulated or ordered by the court, a deposition is limited to one day of seven hours and provides that a federal court may allow additional time, as specified, if needed to either fairly examine the deponent or if the deponent, another person, or any other circumstance impedes or delays the examination. (Fed. Rules of Civ. Proc. rule 30(d)(1).)
Existing Federal Rules of Civil Procedure permits a deponent or party, at any time during a deposition, to move to terminate or limit the deposition, as specified, on the ground that it is being conducted in bad faith or in a manner that unreasonably annoys, embarrasses, or oppresses the deponent or party. (Fed. Rules of Civ. Proc. rule 30(d)(3)(A).)
Existing law, the Civil Discovery Act, provides procedures by which parties to a civil action conduct and obtain “discovery,” including by, among other things, depositions. (Code Civ. Proc. Sec. 2017.010 et seq.)
Existing law permits a party to a civil action to take an oral deposition of any person upon service of a proper notice indicating the date, time, and location of the deposition, as well as notice of any materials that must be produced at the deposition. The person deposed may be a natural person, an organization such as a public or private corporation, a partnership, an association, or a governmental agency. (Code Civ. Proc. Sec. 2025.010 et seq.)
Existing law permits any party or deponent, at any time before, during, or after a deposition, to seek a protective order from the court, as specified. Existing law permits a court to make an order that justice requires to protect any party, the deponent, or other natural person or organization from unwarranted annoyance, embarrassment, or oppression, or undue burden or expense, and specifies some of the conditions or limitations that the order may impose on the deposition, including, among other things, that the deposition be terminated or not taken at all. (Code Civ. Proc. Sec. 2025.420.)
Existing law authorizes a deposition officer to suspend the taking of testimony to enable the party or deponent to move for such protective order on the ground that the examination is being conducted in bad faith or in a manner that unreasonably annoys, embarrasses, or oppresses that deponent or party. (Code Civ. Proc. Sec. 2025.470.)
Existing rule of court governs complex cases, and defines them as an action that requires exceptional judicial management to avoid placing unnecessary burdens on the court or the litigants and to expedite the case, keep costs reasonable, and promote effective decision making by the court, the parties, and counsel. (Cal. Rules of Court, rule 3.400.)
Existing law provides that a deposition is limited to seven hours of total testimony, except as provided or as ordered by the court. The court is required to allow additional time if needed to fairly examine the deponent or if the deponent, another person, or any other circumstance impedes or delays the examination. (Code Civ. Proc. Sec. 2025.290(a).)
Existing law exempts the following circumstances from the presumptive limit of seven hours of deposition testimony:
- if the parties have stipulated that this section will not apply to a specific deposition or to the entire proceeding;
- to any deposition of an expert witness, as specified;
- to any case designated as a complex case, as specified, unless a licensed physician attests in a declaration served on the parties that the deponent suffers from an illness or condition raising substantial medical doubt of survival of the deponent beyond six months, in which case the deposition shall be limited to two days of no more than seven hours of total testimony each day, or 14 hours of total testimony;
- to any case brought by an employee or applicant for employment against an employer for acts or omissions arising out of the employment relationship;
- to any deposition of a person designated as the most qualified person to be deposed, as specified; and
- to any party who appeared in the action after the deposition has concluded, in which case the new party may notice another deposition subject to the requirements of this section.
(Code Civ. Proc. Sec. 2025.290(b).)
Existing law provides that nothing in the section described above shall be construed to affect the existing right of any party to move for a protective order or the court's discretion to make any order that justice requires to limit a deposition in order to protect any party, deponent, or other natural person or organization from unwarranted annoyance, embarrassment, oppression, undue burden, or expense. (Code Civ. Proc. Sec. 2025.290(c).)
Existing law provides that a cause of action that survives the death of the person entitled to commence an action or proceeding (decedent) passes to the decedent's successor in interest, as specified, and an action may be commenced by the decedent's personal representative or, if none, by the decedent's successor in interest. (Code Civ. Proc. Sec. 377.30.) In such an action or proceeding by a decedent's personal representative or successor in interest on the decedent's cause of action, the damages recoverable are limited to the loss or damage that the decedent sustained or incurred before death, including any penalties or punitive or exemplary damages that the decedent would have been entitled to recover had the decedent lived, and do not include damages for pain, suffering, or disfigurement. (Code Civ. Proc. Sec. 377.34.)
This bill would provide, notwithstanding Section 2025.290 of the Code of Civil Procedure, in any civil action for injury or illness based upon exposure to asbestos, a deposition examination of the witness by all counsel, other than the witness’ counsel of record, must be limited to seven hours of total testimony if a licensed physician attests in a declaration served on the parties that either:
- the deponent is over 70 years of age and the deponent’s health is such that a deposition of more than seven hours will prejudice the deponent’s well-being; or
- the deponent suffers from an illness or condition that raises substantial medical doubt of the survival of the deponent beyond six months.
This bill would allow a party to seek up to seven hours of additional deposition testimony for no more than 14 hours of total testimony. If a court were to grant such an extension, the court would be required to include in its order a factual finding supporting the extension beyond seven hours, and a statement that the health of the deponent does not appear to be endangered by the grant of additional time.
This bill would specify that it does not affect the existing right of any party to move for a protective order or the court’s discretion to make any order that justice requires to limit a deposition in order to protect any party, deponent, or other natural person or organization from unwarranted annoyance, embarrassment, oppression, undue burden, or expense.
COMMENT
1. Stated need for the bill
According to the author:
Many workers, especially in the trades, suffered exposure to asbestos in their workplace. Asbestos poisoning can result in terrible diseases, including mesothelioma. The manufacturers of products containing asbestos knew of the dangers for many years yet did not remove asbestos from products that exposed workers. As a result, workers and their families have the right to pursue a civil action against those manufacturers to seek compensation for their injuries.
Once these civil actions are filed, defendants are entitled to seek information from the plaintiff through both written discovery (interrogatories and request for admission) and oral discovery (depositions). Unfortunately, once a person is diagnosed with mesothelioma, they are locked into a painful death spiral. Many of these people are older and will die quickly due to the nature of the disease.
In [California], if a plaintiff dies before the resolution of their case, their general damages (pain and suffering) die with them. So any chance at justice is denied. Defendants often subject the dying asbestos victims to lengthy depositions, at times so long that the plaintiff dies before the depositions are complete. Their claims die with them.
Despite the clear intent of the California Legislature in 2012 to protect dying victims from abusive depositions, courts overseeing asbestos cases have ignored the 14-hour presumption, relying on broad language in Code of Civil Procedure 2025.290 (a) permitting “judicial discretion” in determining the length of a deposition. As a result, courts are ignoring the presumptive time limit altogether, and dying asbestos plaintiffs continue to be subjected to unnecessary lengthy – and sometimes fatal – depositions. The bill sets sensible limits on depositions for dying asbestos victims. The bill would enact a limit of 7 hours on depositions of asbestos plaintiffs.
2. Limited circumstances
Generally, a party may take the deposition of any person, including any other party in the action. (Code Civ. Proc. Sec. 2025.010.) Added in 2012, California Code of Civil Procedure 2025.290(a) establishes a presumptive time limit of seven hours of total deposition testimony for each witness. This subdivision contains a sentence granting discretion to the court to allow additional time for testimony “if needed to fairly examine the deponent or if the deponent, another person, or any other circumstances impedes or delays the examination.”
Subdivision (b) of Section 2025.290 of the Code of Civil Procedure lays out the exceptions to the seven-hour presumption. Paragraph (3) excepts cases declared complex pursuant to Rule 3.400 of the California Rules of Court. The statute provides, however, that this exception does not apply if a licensed physician attests in a declaration that the deponent suffers from an illness that raises substantial medical doubt of survival beyond six months. The statute goes on to provide that when this declaration is provided, the deposition examination of the deponent described shall be limited to two days of no more than seven hours of total testimony each day, or 14 hours of total testimony.
The issue that has arisen, and that has motivated this legislation, is whether and how the clause in subdivision (a) providing the court discretion to grant additional time for a deposition applies to the “exception to the exception” where a deponent in a complex case provides documentation that there is substantial medical doubt of survival beyond six months. The relevant question is how courts should apply the two-day, 14-hour limitation provided in paragraph (3) of subdivision (b).
The sponsor asserts that the clear intent of AB 1875 (Gatto, Chapter 346, Statutes 2012) was to protect dying victims from abusive depositions, but that courts are systematically ignoring the 14-hour presumption by relying on the broad language in subdivision (a). The sponsor states this has resulted in dying asbestos plaintiffs continuing to be subjected to unnecessarily lengthy depositions.
A review of the committee analyses of AB 1875 supports the contention that the 14-hour limit was primarily intended for asbestos plaintiffs: “This ‘exception to the exception’ is aimed, in many respects, at problems posed by asbestos litigation cases, which often involve extremely sick plaintiffs and numerous defendants.”
This bill would make clear that in complex asbestos litigation, a deposition examination would be limited to seven hours when the deponent has certain serious health concerns that are documented by a licensed physician. If the court is presented with sufficient evidence to support an extension and it is clear that the health of the deponent does not appear to be endangered by such an extension, an order can extend the deposition testimony up to a total of 14 hours. This bill provides additional protections to the intended targets of the initial legislation; however, it also places strict constraints on the ability of defendants or the court to extend the deposition testimony.
3. Protections for a narrow and vulnerable group of plaintiffs
This bill would provide a cap on the deposition testimony of deponents in asbestos litigation who have severe health issues. The deponents that would benefit from this legislation are in a uniquely vulnerable position. According to data from the Center for Disease Control and Prevention, the median survival after a diagnosis of malignant mesothelioma (a disease caused by asbestos exposure) is approximately one year. Despite regulatory action curtailing the use of asbestos, the number of deaths due to asbestos exposure annually is increasing. Often in these types of cases, by the time victims are diagnosed and have time to file suit, their health is dramatically impaired. Given the limitations on what damages can be recovered in survival actions after a victim has died, there is a perverse incentive for defendants to prolong litigation as much as possible. The author, sponsor, and the various organizations in support present examples of how the discovery process is abused in these cases and the effects it has on victims.
The California Teamsters Public Affairs Council writes in support that this bill would put a stop to “overly long, abusive depositions of dying victims where they are sometimes harassed for multiple days.”
The District Council of Iron Workers of the State of California and Vicinity explain their support: “When our members or their family are ill and dying from asbestos, they may use state courts to hold accountable the manufacturers, premises owners, and others who knew, since the 1930s about the horrendous dangers of asbestos but failed to warn or provide protection from this deadly toxin. . . . [Mesothelioma] is a very painful disease and extended depositions are hard enough on individuals who are healthy, but can be fatal to those who are in excruciating pain from this illness.”
This bill would provide a reasonable limitation on deposition testimony in a narrow subset of cases based on documented health concerns.
Support: California Conference Board of the Amalgamated Transit Union; California Conference of Machinists; California Labor Federation; California Professional Firefighters; California Teamsters Public Affairs Council; District Council of Iron Workers of the State of California and Vicinity; Engineers and Scientists of California, IFPTE Local 20, AFL-CIO; Heat & Frost Insulators & Allied Workers Local 5; International Longshore & Warehouse Union; Labor & Employment Committee of the National Lawyers Guild; Professional and Technical Engineers, IFPTE Local 21, AFL-CIO; Service Employees International Union; State Building and Construction Trades Council, AFL-CIO; UNITE-HERE, AFL-CIO; Utility Workers of America
Opposition: American Insurance Association; Association of California Insurance Companies; California Association of Joint Powers Authorities; California Defense Counsel; Civil Justice Association of California
HISTORY
Source: Consumer Attorneys of California
Related Pending Legislation: None Known
Prior Legislation: AB 1875 (Gatto, Chapter 346, Statutes 2012) See Background.
**************
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):