SB 792: Homeless Coordinating and Financing Council.
- Session Year: 2017-2018
- House: Senate
- Latest Version Date: 2018-07-03
Existing law establishes various programs, including, among others, the Emergency Housing and Assistance Program, to provide assistance to homeless persons. Existing law requires a state agency or department that funds, implements, or administers a state program that provides housing or housing-related services to people experiencing homelessness or at risk of homelessness, except as specified, to revise or adopt guidelines and regulations to include enumerated Housing First policies. Existing law establishes the Homeless Coordinating and Financing Council to oversee the implementation of the Housing First guidelines and regulations and, among other things, to identify resources, benefits, and services that can be accessed to prevent and end homelessness in California.
This bill would require the Homeless Coordinating and Financing Council to develop and implement a statewide strategic plan for addressing homelessness in the state, as specified. The bill would require, by January 1, 2020, the council to implement 2 strategic plans to assist federal Housing and Urban Development Continuum of Care lead agencies in either or both better implementing Housing and Urban Development recommended activities and meeting Housing and Urban Development requirements.
Existing law establishes various programs, including, among others, the Emergency Housing and Assistance Program, to provide assistance to homeless persons. Existing law requires a state agency or department that funds, implements, or administers a state program that provides housing or housing-related services to people experiencing homelessness or at risk of homelessness, except as specified, to revise or adopt guidelines and regulations to include enumerated Housing First policies. Existing law establishes the Homeless Coordinating and Financing Council to oversee the implementation of the Housing First guidelines and regulations and, among other things, to identify resources, benefits, and services that can be accessed to prevent and end homelessness in California.
This bill would require the Homeless Coordinating and Financing Council to develop and implement a statewide strategic plan for addressing homelessness in the state, as specified. The bill would require, by January 1, 2020, the council to implement 2 strategic plans to assist federal Housing and Urban Development Continuum of Care lead agencies in either or both better implementing Housing and Urban Development recommended activities and meeting Housing and Urban Development requirements.
Existing law authorizes counties to impose various taxes, including a special tax that is required to be applied uniformly to all taxpayers or real property within the county, as specified.This bill would require the County of Los Angeles to establish the Measure B Oversight Commission and would require the commission to submit reports to the Legislature, as specified, regarding the County of Los Angeles trauma network and Measure B, defined by the bill to mean the special tax levied on all improved parcels in the County of Los Angeles, as specified, approved by the voters of the County of Los Angeles on November 5, 2002, to provide funding for the Countywide System of Trauma Centers, Emergency Medical Services, and Bioterrorism Response. The bill would require the County of Los Angeles to post on the countys Internet Web site information regarding allocations of Measure B funds, as specified. By establishing additional duties of local government, this bill would impose a state-mandated local program.This bill would make legislative findings and declarations as to the necessity of a special statute for County of Los Angeles.The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.This bill would provide that, if the Commission on State Mandates determines that the bill contains costs mandated by the state, reimbursement for those costs shall be made pursuant to the statutory provisions noted above.Existing law authorizes counties to impose various taxes, including a special tax that is required to be applied uniformly to all taxpayers or real property within the county, as specified. By establishing additional duties of local government, this bill would impose a state-mandated local program.
This bill would create require the County of Los Angeles to establish the Measure B Oversight Commission and would require the commission to submit reports to the Legislature, as specified, regarding the County of Los Angeles trauma network and Measure B, defined by the bill to mean the special tax levied on all improved parcels in the County of Los Angeles, as specified, approved by the voters of the County of Los Angeles on November 5, 2002, to provide funding for the Countywide System of Trauma Centers, Emergency Medical Services, and Bioterrorism Response. The bill would require the County of Los Angeles to post on the countys Internet Web site information regarding allocations of Measure B funds, as specified. By establishing additional duties of local government, this bill would impose a state-mandated local program.
This bill would make legislative findings and declarations as to the necessity of a special statute for County of Los Angeles.
The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.
This bill would provide that, if the Commission on State Mandates determines that the bill contains costs mandated by the state, reimbursement for those costs shall be made pursuant to the statutory provisions noted above.
Existing law authorizes counties to impose various taxes, including a special tax that is required to be applied uniformly to all taxpayers or real property within the county, as specified. By establishing additional duties of local government, this bill would impose a state-mandated local program.
This bill would create the Measure B Oversight Commission and would require the commission to submit reports to the Legislature, as specified, regarding the County of Los Angeles trauma network and Measure B, defined by the bill to mean the special tax levied on all improved parcels in the County of Los Angeles, as specified, approved by the voters of the County of Los Angeles on November 5, 2002, to provide funding for the Countywide System of Trauma Centers, Emergency Medical Services, and Bioterrorism Response. The bill would require the County of Los Angeles to post on the countys Internet Web site information regarding allocations of Measure B funds, as specified.
This bill would make legislative findings and declarations as to the necessity of a special statute for County of Los Angeles.
The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.
This bill would provide that, if the Commission on State Mandates determines that the bill contains costs mandated by the state, reimbursement for those costs shall be made pursuant to the statutory provisions noted above.
In addition to the other duties described in this chapter, the coordinating council shall do all of the following:
(a)By July 1, 2019, 2020, develop and implement a statewide strategic plan for addressing homelessness in the state. This plan shall include goals and objectives and timelines for achieving them, and metrics for measuring their achievements. Included among the goals and objectives shall be the identification of additional funding sources that state and local agencies can use to better address homelessness issues in the state.
(b)By January 1, 2020, implement strategic plans to assist HUD Continuum of Care lead agencies to do either or both of the following:
(1)Better implement federal Housing and Urban Development recommended activities, including conducting annual counts of the unsheltered homeless population, raising nonfederal funding, and coordinating with other agencies.
(2)Better meet federal Housing and Urban Development requirements, including implementation of the Homeless Management Information System (HMIS) and entry systems. The state homeless council shall include among its considerations the establishment of a balance of state Continuum of Care areas to help alleviate the administrative burdens imposed on Continuum of Care lead agencies, especially in rural areas.
In addition to the other duties described in this chapter, the coordinating council shall do all of the following:
(a)By July 1, 2019, develop and implement a statewide strategic plan for addressing homelessness in the state. This plan shall include goals and objectives and timelines for achieving them, and metrics for measuring their achievements. Included among the goals and objectives shall be the identification of additional funding sources that state and local agencies can use to better address homelessness issues in the state.
(b)By January 1, 2020, implement strategic plans to assist HUD Continuum of Care lead agencies to do either or both of the following:
(1)Better implement federal Housing and Urban Development recommended activities, including conducting annual counts of the unsheltered homeless population, raising nonfederal funding, and coordinating with other agencies.
(2)Better meet federal Housing and Urban Development requirements, including implementation of the Homeless Management Information System (HMIS) and entry systems. The state homeless council shall include among its considerations the establishment of a balance of state Continuum of Care areas to help alleviate the administrative burdens imposed on Continuum of Care lead agencies, especially in rural areas.
SECTION 1.Article 20 (commencing with Section 53997.5) is added to Chapter 4 of Part 1 of Division 2 of Title 5 of the Government Code, to read:20.Measure B Oversight Commission53997.5.For purposes of this article, the following definitions shall apply:(a)Commission means the Measure B Oversight Commission created pursuant to Section 53997.6.(b)Measure B means the special tax, levied on all improved parcels in the County of Los Angeles at a rate of three cents ($0.03) per square foot of structural improvements, approved by the voters of the County of Los Angeles on November 5, 2002, to provide funding for the Countywide System of Trauma Centers, Emergency Medical Services, and Bioterrorism Response.53997.6.(a)The County of Los Angeles shall establish a Measure B Oversight Commission. The commission shall consist of the following members:(1)A member appointed by each city in the County of Los Angeles with a trauma center. (2)A member appointed by the Southern California Chapter of the American College of Surgeons.(3)A member appointed by the Board of Supervisors of the County of Los Angeles.(4)A member appointed by the Emergency Medical Services Authority.(5)A member appointed by the Los Angeles County Department of Health Services.(6)A member appointed by the Los Angeles County Office of the Assessor.(7)Two members who are citizens appointed by the commission to represent underserved areas of the county.(b)The commission shall do all of the following:(1)On or before June 1, 2020, submit a report to the Legislature containing all of the following information:(A)An assessment of the solvency of the County of Los Angeles trauma network and recommendations to address deficiencies, if any, in the solvency of the network.(B)The need and feasibility of trauma center expansion in areas underserved by the County of Los Angeles trauma network.(C)The allocation, specifically and separately, of Measure B funds that includes all of the following:(i)The total amount of taxes collected under Measure B from the initial date of imposition of the tax.(ii)An accounting of all allocations of Measure B funds.(iii)Criteria used in determining the allocation of Measure B funds.(iv)The causes for, if any, the disparities between allocations to county operated trauma centers and noncounty operated trauma centers.(v)A recommendation of how Measure B funds should be allocated so as to most closely reflect the intent of the initial measure and to provide equitable allocation across the County of Los Angeles trauma network while ensuring that the needs of underserved populations and county regions are being met.(2)Following the submission of the report required pursuant to paragraph (1), continue to oversee and monitor the collection and expenditure of Measure B funds. On or before June 1, 2021, and on or before June 1 every other year thereafter, submit a report to the Legislature containing all of the following information:(A)Recommendations for continued improvements to the County of Los Angeles trauma network.(B)Information regarding whether recommendations made in prior reports of the commission required pursuant to this section were implemented.(C)An assessment of the allocation of Measure B funds for the previous year and information regarding whether these allocations were equitable throughout the County of Los Angeles trauma network. If the commission determines that these allocations were not equitable, a recommendation of how Measure B funds should be allocated equitably.(3)The reports required to be submitted pursuant to this subdivision shall be submitted in compliance with Section 9795.(c)The County of Los Angeles, in an effort to facilitate the duties of the commission and to ensure further and ongoing transparency, shall post in a clear and accessible location on the countys Internet Web site, both of the following:(1)On or before June 1, 2019, the total allocation of Measure B funds to each trauma center receiving those funds.(2)On or before June 1, 2020, and on or before June 1 each year thereafter, the allocation of Measure B funds to each trauma center receiving those funds in the prior year.SEC. 2.The Legislature finds and declares that a special statute is necessary and that a general statute cannot be made applicable within the meaning of Section 16 of Article IV of the California Constitution because of the particular need to assess the County of Los Angeles trauma network and the allocation of Measure B funds.SEC. 3.If the Commission on State Mandates determines that this act contains costs mandated by the state, reimbursement to local agencies and school districts for those costs shall be made pursuant to Part 7 (commencing with Section 17500) of Division 4 of Title 2 of the Government Code.For purposes of this article, the following definitions shall apply:
(a)Commission means the Measure B Oversight Commission created pursuant to Section 53997.6.
(b)Measure B means the special tax, levied on all improved parcels in the County of Los Angeles at a rate of three cents ($0.03) per square foot of structural improvements, approved by the voters of the County of Los Angeles on November 5, 2002, to provide funding for the Countywide System of Trauma Centers, Emergency Medical Services, and Bioterrorism Response.
53997.6.(a)The County of Los Angeles shall establish a Measure B Oversight Commission is hereby created. Commission. The commission shall consist of the following members:
(1)A member appointed by each city in the County of Los Angeles with a trauma center.
(2)A member appointed by the Southern California Chapter of the American College of Surgeons.
(3)A member appointed by the Board of Supervisors of the County of Los Angeles.
(4)A member appointed by the Emergency Medical Services Authority.
(5)A member appointed by the Los Angeles County Department of Health Services.
(6)A member appointed by the Los Angeles County Office of the Assessor.
(7)Two members who are citizens appointed by the commission to represent underserved areas of the county.
(b)The commission shall do all of the following:
(1)On or before June 1, 2020, submit a report to the Legislature containing all of the following information:
(A)An assessment of the solvency of the County of Los Angeles trauma network and recommendations to address deficiencies, if any, in the solvency of the network.
(B)The need and feasibility of trauma center expansion in areas underserved by the County of Los Angeles trauma network.
(C)The allocation, specifically and separately, of Measure B funds that includes all of the following:
(i)The total amount of taxes collected under Measure B from the initial date of imposition of the tax.
(ii)An accounting of all allocations of Measure B funds.
(iii)Criteria used in determining the allocation of Measure B funds.
(iv)The causes for, if any, the disparities between allocations to county operated trauma centers and noncounty operated trauma centers.
(v)A recommendation of how Measure B funds should be allocated so as to most closely reflect the intent of the initial measure and to provide equitable allocation across the County of Los Angeles trauma network while ensuring that the needs of underserved populations and county regions are being met.
(2)Following the submission of the report required pursuant to paragraph (1), continue to oversee and monitor the collection and expenditure of Measure B funds. On or before June 1, 2021, and on or before June 1 every other year thereafter, submit a report to the Legislature containing all of the following information:
(A)Recommendations for continued improvements to the County of Los Angeles trauma network.
(B)Information regarding whether recommendations made in prior reports of the commission required pursuant to this section were implemented.
(C)An assessment of the allocation of Measure B funds for the previous year and information regarding whether these allocations were equitable throughout the County of Los Angeles trauma network. If the commission determines that these allocations were not equitable, a recommendation of how Measure B funds should be allocated equitably.
(3)The reports required to be submitted pursuant to this subdivision shall be submitted in compliance with Section 9795.
(c)The County of Los Angeles, in an effort to facilitate the duties of the commission and to ensure further and ongoing transparency, shall post in a clear and accessible location on the countys Internet Web site, both of the following:
(1)On or before June 1, 2019, the total allocation of Measure B funds to each trauma center receiving those funds.
(2)On or before June 1, 2020, and on or before June 1 each year thereafter, the allocation of Measure B funds to each trauma center receiving those funds in the prior year.
SEC. 2.The Legislature finds and declares that a special statute is necessary and that a general statute cannot be made applicable within the meaning of Section 16 of Article IV of the California Constitution because of the particular need to assess the County of Los Angeles trauma network and the allocation of Measure B funds.
SEC. 3.If the Commission on State Mandates determines that this act contains costs mandated by the state, reimbursement to local agencies and school districts for those costs shall be made pursuant to Part 7 (commencing with Section 17500) of Division 4 of Title 2 of the Government Code.
For purposes of this article, the following definitions shall apply:
(a)Commission means the Measure B Oversight Commission created pursuant to Section 53997.6.
(b)Measure B means the special tax, levied on all improved parcels in the County of Los Angeles at a rate of three cents ($0.03) per square foot of structural improvements, approved by the voters of the County of Los Angeles on November 5, 2002, to provide funding for the Countywide System of Trauma Centers, Emergency Medical Services, and Bioterrorism Response.
53997.6.(a)The Measure B Oversight Commission is hereby created. The commission shall consist of the following members:
(1)A member appointed by each city in the County of Los Angeles with a trauma center.
(2)A member appointed by the Southern California Chapter of the American College of Surgeons.
(3)A member appointed by the Board of Supervisors of the County of Los Angeles.
(4)A member appointed by the Emergency Medical Services Authority.
(5)A member appointed by the Los Angeles County Department of Health Services.
(6)A member appointed by the Los Angeles County Office of the Assessor.
(7)Two members who are citizens appointed by the commission to represent underserved areas of the county.
(b)The commission shall do all of the following:
(1)On or before June 1, 2020, submit a report to the Legislature containing all of the following information:
(A)An assessment of the solvency of the County of Los Angeles trauma network and recommendations to address deficiencies, if any, in the solvency of the network.
(B)The need and feasibility of trauma center expansion in areas underserved by the County of Los Angeles trauma network.
(C)The allocation, specifically and separately, of Measure B funds that includes all of the following:
(i)The total amount of taxes collected under Measure B from the initial date of imposition of the tax.
(ii)An accounting of all allocations of Measure B funds.
(iii)Criteria used in determining the allocation of Measure B funds.
(iv)The causes for, if any, the disparities between allocations to county operated trauma centers and noncounty operated trauma centers.
(v)A recommendation of how Measure B funds should be allocated so as to most closely reflect the intent of the initial measure and to provide equitable allocation across the County of Los Angeles trauma network while ensuring that the needs of underserved populations and county regions are being met.
(2)Following the submission of the report required pursuant to paragraph (1), continue to oversee and monitor the collection and expenditure of Measure B funds. On or before June 1, 2021, and on or before June 1 every other year thereafter, submit a report to the Legislature containing all of the following information:
(A)Recommendations for continued improvements to the County of Los Angeles trauma network.
(B)Information regarding whether recommendations made in prior reports of the commission required pursuant to this section were implemented.
(C)An assessment of the allocation of Measure B funds for the previous year and information regarding whether these allocations were equitable throughout the County of Los Angeles trauma network. If the commission determines that these allocations were not equitable, a recommendation of how Measure B funds should be allocated equitably.
(3)The reports required to be submitted pursuant to this subdivision shall be submitted in compliance with Section 9795.
(c)The County of Los Angeles, in an effort to facilitate the duties of the commission and to ensure further and ongoing transparency, shall post in a clear and accessible location on the countys Internet Web site, both of the following:
(1)On or before June 1, 2019, the total allocation of Measure B funds to each trauma center receiving those funds.
(2)On or before June 1, 2020, and on or before June 1 each year thereafter, the allocation of Measure B funds to each trauma center receiving those funds in the prior year.
SEC. 2.The Legislature finds and declares that a special statute is necessary and that a general statute cannot be made applicable within the meaning of Section 16 of Article IV of the California Constitution because of the particular need to assess the County of Los Angeles trauma network and the allocation of Measure B funds.
SEC. 3.If the Commission on State Mandates determines that this act contains costs mandated by the state, reimbursement to local agencies and school districts for those costs shall be made pursuant to Part 7 (commencing with Section 17500) of Division 4 of Title 2 of the Government Code.
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Aug 16, 2018 | August 16 hearing: Held in committee and under submission. |
| Aug 8, 2018 | August 8 set for first hearing. Placed on suspense file. |
| Jul 3, 2018 | Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Jul 2, 2018 | From committee: Do pass as amended and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 7. Noes 0.) (June 27). |
| Jun 14, 2018 | From committee: Be re-referred to Com. on H. & C.D. (Ayes 7. Noes 0.) (June 14). Re-referred to Com. on H. & C.D. |
| May 30, 2018 | Re-referred to Com. on RLS. pursuant to Assembly Rule 96. |
| May 25, 2018 | From committee with author's amendments. Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on L. GOV. |
| Aug 28, 2017 | June 28 set for first hearing canceled at the request of author. |
| Jun 28, 2017 | June 28 set for first hearing canceled at the request of author. |
| Jun 15, 2017 | Referred to Coms. on L. GOV. and HEALTH. |
| Jun 1, 2017 | In Assembly. Read first time. Held at Desk. |
| May 31, 2017 | Read third time. Passed. (Ayes 39. Noes 0. Page 1336.) Ordered to the Assembly. |
| May 26, 2017 | Published May 26 at 10 a.m. |
| May 25, 2017 | From committee: Do pass as amended. (Ayes 7. Noes 0. Page 1190.) (May 25). |
| May 23, 2017 | Set for hearing May 25. |
| May 22, 2017 | May 22 hearing: Placed on APPR. suspense file. |
| May 16, 2017 | Set for hearing May 22. |
| May 15, 2017 | May 15 hearing postponed by committee. |
| May 4, 2017 | Set for hearing May 15. |
| Apr 27, 2017 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 7. Noes 0. Page 885.) (April 26). Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Apr 21, 2017 | Set for hearing April 26. |
| Apr 20, 2017 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on GOV. & F. (Ayes 8. Noes 0. Page 808.) (April 19). Re-referred to Com. on GOV. & F. |
| Apr 4, 2017 | Set for hearing April 19. |
| Mar 9, 2017 | Referred to Coms. on HEALTH and GOV. & F. |
| Feb 21, 2017 | From printer. May be acted upon on or after March 23. |
| Feb 17, 2017 | Introduced. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Jun 27, 2018 | Do pass as amended and be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Assembly Standing Committee on Housing and Community Development |
Passed |
|
| Jun 14, 2018 | Be re-referred to the Committee on [Housing and Community Development] | Assembly Standing Committee on Rules |
Passed |
|
| May 31, 2017 | Senate 3rd Reading SB792 Wilk et al. | Senate Floor |
Passed |
|
| May 25, 2017 | Do pass as amended | Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| May 22, 2017 | Placed on suspense file | Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Apr 26, 2017 | Do pass, but first be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Senate Standing Committee on Governance and Finance |
Passed |
|
| Apr 19, 2017 | Do pass, but first be re-referred to the Committee on [Governance and Finance] | Senate Standing Committee on Health |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
Date of Hearing: August 8, 2018
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Lorena Gonzalez Fletcher, Chair
SBPCA Bill Id:SB 792
Author:(Wilk) – As Amended Ver:July 3, 2018
Policy Committee: | Rules | Vote: | 7 - 0 |
Housing and Community Development | 7 - 0 | ||
|
|
Urgency: No State Mandated Local Program: No Reimbursable: No
SUMMARY:
This bill assigns additional duties to the Homeless Coordinating and Financing Council (Council), housed in the Business, Consumer Services, and Housing Agency (BCSH). Specifically, this bill requires the Council, by July 1, 2020, to:
- Develop and implement a statewide strategic plan (plan) for addressing homelessness in the state, as specified.
- Implement strategic plans to assist the federal Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD) Continuum of Care (CoC) lead agencies to better implement HUD recommended activities and better meet HUD requirements, including implementing Homeless Management Information Systems.
FISCAL EFFECT:
BCSH indicates first year costs of $366,000 (GF) and ongoing costs of $256,000 (GF) for one limited-term and two permanent positions for developing the strategic planning goals, identifying funding sources, and coordinating with the local CoCs.
COMMENTS:
- Purpose. This bill seeks to better address the statewide issue of homeless by implementing recommendations of the state auditor to, among other goals, improve California’s competitiveness for federal funding.
- Background. SB 1380 (Mitchell), Chapter 847, statutes of 2016, created the Homeless Coordinating and Financing Council (Council) to coordinate the state's response to homelessness and requires all state agencies or departments that operate programs providing housing or housing-related services to people experiencing homelessness, or who are at risk of homelessness, to adopt guidelines and regulations to include Housing First policies. This year's budget moved the Council under the BCSH, authorized the creation of an executive director and added several staff members. Among its duties, the Council is responsible for distributing approximately $500 million in this year’s budget to local CoCs to address homelessness.
Lead agencies in each of the state’s 43 CoC areas are responsible for planning the administration of homeless services. In April of this year, the state auditor released “Homelessness in California: State Government and the Los Angeles Homeless Services Authority Need to Strengthen Their Efforts to Address Homelessness” and made several recommendations to improve the state's response to homelessness.
During the audit, the CoC lead agencies indicated a need for additional resources and direction from the state. Specifically, lead agencies reported that they lacked funding, staff, and other resources to implement HUD‑recommended activities such as conducting annual counts of unsheltered homeless, raising funds from nonfederal sources, and coordinating with other homeless service agencies. Rural CoC lead agencies also reported difficulties in implementing HUD requirements related to developing a coordinated entry system (entry system) and administering their Homeless Management Information Systems (HMIS).
In response, this bill proposes the creation of a “balance-of-state CoC area.” According to the audit:
At the moment, lead agencies for each CoC area are responsible for planning and administering homeless services within their geographic area. In contrast to this structure, more than 30 states have a “balance‑of‑state CoC area,” which can consist of multiple rural counties, and thus can maximize the funding potential and take advantage of economies of scale for large geographic areas.
As noted earlier, HUD considers information about the CoC’s planning body, governance structure, overall performance, and strategic planning process to determine the order in which CoC areas across the nation are funded. Helping rural CoC areas improve these factors could increase their competitiveness in HUD’s CoC grant program competition for funding.
- Related Legislation.
AB 2162 (Chiu), of this legislative session, requires the Department of Housing and Community Development to create a statewide homeless integrated data warehouse in coordination with the Council. That bill is pending with the Senate Committee on Appropriations.
SB 918 (Weiner), of this legislative session, requires the Council to take on additional related responsibilities, including the creation and administration of grant programs to house and serve California’s homeless youth and the collection of and reporting of pertinent data, among other duties. That bill is pending with this committee.
Analysis Prepared by: Jennifer Swenson / APPR. / (916) 319-2081
Date of Hearing: June 27, 2018
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON HOUSING AND COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT
David Chiu, Chair
SBPCA Bill Id:SB 792
Author:(Wilk) – As Amended Ver:May 25, 2018
SENATE VOTE: Not relevant
SUBJECT: Homeless Coordinating and Financing Council
SUMMARY: Assigns additional duties to the Homeless Coordinating and Financing Council (Council). Specifically, this bill:
- Requires the Council, by July 1, 2019, to develop and implement a statewide strategic plan (plan) for addressing homeless in the state.
- Requires the plan to include goals and objectives, timelines for achieving them, and metrics for measuring achievements.
- Requires the Council to identify additional funding sources that the state and local agencies can use to better address homelessness issues in the state.
- Requires the Council, by January 1, 2020 to implement strategic plans to assist the federal Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD) Continuum of Care (CoC) lead agencies to do either or both of the following:
- Better implement HUD recommended activities including conducting annual counts of the unsheltered homeless population, opportunities to raise nonfederal funding, and coordinating with other agencies.
- Better meet HUD requirements including implementing Homeless Management Information Systems.
- Require the Council to include among its considerations the establishment of a balance of state CoC to help alleviate the administrative burdens imposed on CoC lead agencies especially in rural areas.
EXISTING LAW:
- Defines, in federal statute, the word “homeless” for the purpose of housing assistance, to mean an individual or family who lacks a fixed, regular, and adequate nighttime residence, as specified.
- Defines “Housing First” as the evidence-based model that uses housing as a tool, rather than a reward for recovery. It connects homeless people to housing as quickly as possible and does not make housing contingent on participation in services. Housing First includes time-limited rental or services assistance, so long as the housing and service provider assists the recipient in accessing permanent housing and in securing longer-term rental assistance, income assistance, or employment.
- Defines “supportive housing” as housing with no limit on length of stay, that is occupied by a target population, as defined, and that is linked to onsite or offsite services that assist the supportive housing resident in retaining the housing, improving his or her health status, and maximizing his or her ability to live and, when possible, work in the community.
- Creates the Homeless Coordinating and Financing Council (Council), with the goals of:
- Identifying mainstream resources, benefits, and services that can be assessed to prevent and end homelessness in California;
- Creating partnerships among state agencies and departments, local government agencies, participants in the U.S Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD) Continuum of Care Program, federal agencies, the U.S. Interagency Council on Homelessness (US ICH), nonprofit entities working to end homelessness, and the private sector, for purposes of arriving at specific strategies to end homelessness;
- Promoting systems integration to increase efficiency and effectiveness;
- Coordinating existing funding and applications for competitive funding. Any action taken shall not restructure or change any existing allocations or allocation formula;
- Making policy and procedural recommendations to legislators and other government entities;
- Identifying and seek funding opportunities for state entities that have programs to end homelessness and facilitate and coordinate those state entities’ efforts to obtain funding;
- Brokering agreements between state agencies, departments and local jurisdictions to align and coordinate resources, reduce administrative burdens of accessing existing resources, and foster common applications to services, operating, and capital funding;
- Serving as a statewide homelessness planning and policy development resource;
- Reporting to the Governor, federal Cabinet members, and the Legislature on homelessness and work to reduce homelessness; and
- Ensuring accountability and results in meeting the strategies and goals of the council.
Requires the Governor, within 180 days of enacting this bill, to appoint up to 15 members to the Coordinating Council as follows:
- A representative from the Department of Housing and Community Development (HCD);
- A representative of the Department of Social Services;
- A representative of the California Housing Finance Agency;
- A representative of the Department of Health Care Services;
- A representative of the Department of Veterans Affairs;
- A representative of the Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation;
- A representative of the Tax Credit Allocation Committee in the State Treasurer’s office;
- A formerly homeless person who lives in California to the extent funding is available to pay for travel;
- Two representatives of local agencies or organizations that participate in the HUD Continuum of Care Program;
- State advocates or other members of the public or state agencies, according to the Governor's discretion.
- Two representatives from different stakeholder groups. One selected by the Senate Committee on Rules and the other by the Speaker of the Assembly; and
- The council may, at its discretion, invite stakeholders, individuals who have experienced homelessness, members of philanthropic communities, and experts to participate in meetings or provide information to the council.
FISCAL EFFECT: Unknown.
COMMENTS:
Homelessness in California: California is facing an affordable housing and homelessness crisis. In 2017, based on local point in time counts (PIT), 134,000 people are homeless in California on any given night. Already home to the largest homeless population in the country, from 2016 to 2017, California experienced the largest increase in the number of residents experiencing homelessness nationwide – over 16,000 individuals. California accounted for nearly half of all unsheltered people in the country in 2017 (49% or 91,642 people). The City and County of Los Angeles have the highest number of homeless people in the state with 55,188 people. Nearly one of every four people experiencing homelessness did so in New York City or Los Angeles. Of those experiencing homelessness in Los Angeles, only 25% were sheltered in 2017.
Nationwide, the number of people experiencing homelessness increased in major cities and decreased elsewhere between 2016 and 2017. The number of people experiencing homelessness in major cities increased by just over 5% between 2016 and 2017, driving the increase in homelessness nationwide. More specifically, increases in unsheltered homelessness in major cities drove the national increase with 17,139 more unsheltered people.
Housing First and the Homeless Coordinating and Financing Council: Housing First approaches homelessness by providing permanent, affordable housing for families and individuals, and then providing supportive services in order to help people avoid returning to homelessness. Housing First is premised on the idea that housing should not be denied to anyone, even if they are abusing alcohol or other substances. Under Housing First, supportive services are offered to maximize housing stability and prevent returns to homelessness, as opposed to addressing predetermined treatment goals prior to providing housing. Housing First has been shown to reduce the overall local costs incurred when localities provide social services to people where they are, rather than allowing them to continue to cycle through emergency rooms, jails, and treatment centers.
The federal government has moved to a Housing First model over the last decade that prioritizes permanent supportive housing. Chronic homelessness in the nation decreased by 27% between 2010-2016 after our federal response adopted the Housing First model. California embraced a Housing First model in 2015. SB 1380 (Mitchell), Chapter 847, which created the Homeless Coordinating and Financing Council (Council) to coordinate the state's response to homelessness, requires all state agencies or departments that operate programs that provide housing or housing-related services to people experiencing homelessness or at risk of homelessness to adopt guidelines and regulations to include Housing First policies. The Council was tasked with a list of goals including:
This year's budget moved the Council under the Business, Consumer Services, and Housing Agency, authorized the creation of an Executive Director to oversee the Council as well as several staff members. The Council is also responsible for distributing approximately $500 million to local CoCs to address homelessness that was included in this year's budget.
State Auditor report: In April of this year, the State Auditor released Homelessness in California: State Government and the Los Angeles Homeless Services Authority Need to Strengthen Their Efforts to Address Homelessness and made several recommendations to improve the state's response to homelessness. Recommendations include:
- Provide statewide leadership to agencies at all levels to improve coordination of efforts to address homelessness and provide funding for CoCs and the state homeless council.
- Require the state homeless council to implement a statewide strategic plan, and implement steps to assist CoC lead agencies to meet federal requirements and recommended activities.
Purpose of this bill: This bill would implement the recommendations of the State Auditor and would require the Council to develop a strategic plan and determine if the state should develop a balance of state CoC.
Balance of state CoC: To address homelessness at a local level, California currently has 43 CoC areas that cover the entire state. The auditor surveyed the lead agencies for the CoC areas to obtain some perspective related to best practices of homeless services across the State. Lead agencies in each CoC area are responsible for planning the administration of homeless services. The CoC lead agencies indicated a need for additional resources and direction from the State. Specifically, lead agencies reported that they lacked funding, staff, and other resources to implement HUD‑recommended activities such as conducting annual counts of unsheltered homeless, raising funds from nonfederal sources, and coordinating with other homeless service agencies. Rural CoC lead agencies also reported difficulties in implementing HUD requirements related to developing a coordinated entry system (entry system) and administering their Homeless Management Information Systems (HMIS).
This bill proposes the creation of a balance of state CoC. According to the audit, "at the moment, lead agencies for each CoC area are responsible for planning and administering homeless services within their geographic area. In contrast to this structure, more than 30 states have a balance‑of‑state CoC area, which can consist of multiple rural counties, and thus can maximize the funding potential and take advantage of economies of scale for large geographic areas. For instance, Nevada has a balance‑of‑state CoC area for those parts of the state outside of the Las Vegas/Clark County and Reno/Sparks/Washoe County CoC areas. For 2016 HUD awarded the Nevada balance‑of‑state CoC area about $575,000, or $2,861 per homeless person in its area. In contrast, 13 of California’s 17 rural CoC areas received HUD awards amounting to less than $1,000 per homeless person, and two of these received no HUD CoC awards. For the other 11 California rural CoC areas the average HUD award per homeless person was about $533. As noted earlier, HUD considers information about the CoC’s planning body, governance structure, overall performance, and strategic planning process to determine the order in which CoC areas across the nation are funded. Helping rural CoC areas improve these factors could increase their competitiveness in HUD’s CoC grant program competition for funding."
Committee amendments:
The committee may wish to consider extending the date by which the strategic plan must be complete by a year, to July 1, 2020. Although the Council will now have dedicated staff it is also responsible for distributing funds allocated in this budget to locals CoCs to address homelessness.
Related legislation:
AB 2162 (Chiu) would requires the Department of Housing and Community Development (HCD) to create a statewide homeless integrated data warehouse (data warehouse) in coordination with the Homeless Coordinating and Financing Council (Council).
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
None on file
Opposition
None on file
Analysis Prepared by: Lisa Engel / H. & C.D. / (916) 319-2085
Date of Hearing: June 28, 2017
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON LOCAL GOVERNMENT
Cecilia Aguiar-Curry, Chair
SBPCA Bill Id:SB 792
Author:(Wilk) – As Amended Ver:May 26, 2017
SENATE VOTE: 39-0
SUBJECT: Local government: Measure B Oversight Commission: County of Los Angeles.
SUMMARY: Requires Los Angeles County to establish an oversight commission to review and report on how the County allocates funds from Measure B, a parcel tax that voters approved to support the County's trauma system. Specifically, this bill:
- Requires Los Angeles County (LA County) to establish a Measure B Oversight Commission (Commission), consisting of the following members:
- A member appointed by each city in LA County with a trauma center;
- A member appointed by the Southern California Chapter of the American College of Surgeons;
- A member appointed by the LA County Board of Supervisors (Board);
- A member appointed by the Emergency Medical Services Authority (EMSA);
- A member appointed by the LA County Department of Health Services;
- A member appointed by the LA County Office of the Assessor; and,
- Two members who are citizens appointed by the Commission to represent underserved areas of LA County.
- Requires the Commission to submit a report to the Legislature by June 1, 2020, containing an assessment of the solvency of the LA County trauma network and recommendations to address deficiencies, the need and feasibility of trauma center expansion in underserved areas, and the allocation, specifically and separately, of Measure B funds that includes all of the following:
- The total amount of taxes collected under Measure B from the initial date of imposition of the tax;
- An accounting of all allocations of Measure B funds;
- Criteria used in determining the allocation of Measure B funds;
- The causes for, if any, disparities between allocations to LA County operated trauma centers and non-county operated trauma centers; and,
- A recommendation of how Measure B funds should be allocated so as to most closely reflect the intent of the initial measure and to provide equitable allocation across the LA County trauma network while ensuring that the needs of underserved populations and regions are being met.
- Requires the Commission, following the submission of the report to the Legislature, to continue to oversee and monitor the collection and expenditure of Measure B funds, and to submit a report to the Legislature on June 1 of each year containing all of the following information:
- Recommendations for continued improvements to the LA County trauma network;
- Information regarding whether recommendations made in prior reports of the Commission were implemented; and,
- An assessment of the allocation of Measure B funds for the previous year and information regarding whether these allocations were equitable throughout the LA County trauma network. If the Commission determines that these allocations were not equitable, it must make a recommendation of how Measure B funds should be allocated equitably.
- Requires the reports submitted pursuant to this bill to be submitted in compliance with provisions of law governing the manner in which reports must be submitted to the Legislature.
- Requires LA County, in an effort to facilitate the duties of the Commission and to ensure further and ongoing transparency, to post in a clear and accessible location on the County’s Internet Web site (website), both of the following:
- On or before June 1, 2019, the total allocation of Measure B funds to each trauma center receiving those funds;
- On or before June 1, 2020, and by each June 1 thereafter, the allocation of Measure B funds to each trauma center receiving those funds in the prior year.
- Finds and declares that a special statute is necessary and that a general statute cannot be made applicable within the meaning of Section 16 of Article IV of the California Constitution because of the particular need to assess LA County's trauma network and the allocation of Measure B funds.
- Provides that, if the Commission on State Mandates determines that this bill contains costs mandated by the state, reimbursement to local agencies and school districts for those costs shall be made pursuant to current law governing state mandated local costs.
EXISTING LAW:
- Allows general acute care hospitals, in addition to the basic services all hospitals are required to offer, to be approved by the Department of Public Health (DPH) to offer special services, including, but not limited to, a radiation therapy department, a burn center, an emergency center, a hemodialysis center or unit, psychiatric services, intensive care newborn nursery, cardiac surgery, cardiac catheterization laboratory, and renal transplant.
- Establishes EMSA, headed by a physician who has experience in the practice of emergency medicine and appointed by the Governor. Among other responsibilities, EMSA is required to develop planning and implementation guidelines for emergency medical services (EMS) systems.
- Requires each county that has developed an EMS system to designate a local EMS agency (LEMSA), which is required to be the county health department, an agency established and operated by the county, an entity with which the county contracts for purposes of local EMS administration, or a joint powers agency created for the administration of EMS between counties. LEMSAs are required to have physician directors, and are responsible for planning, implementing, and evaluating an EMS system, among other duties.
- Requires EMSA to draft regulations specifying minimum standards for the implementation of trauma care systems, as specified. A LEMSA may implement a trauma care system if the system meets minimum standards established by EMSA and may designate trauma facilities, as defined, as part of their trauma system.
FISCAL EFFECT: According to the Senate Appropriations Committee:
- Likely ongoing reimbursable mandate costs of about $300,000 per year for staff support of the Commission and administrative costs to support the Commission (General Fund).
- No significant state reimbursable mandate costs are anticipated due to the requirement in the bill that LA County post specified information on its website.
COMMENTS:
- Bill Summary. This bill requires Los Angeles County to establish a Measure B Oversight Commission to review and report on how the County allocates funds from Measure B, a parcel tax that voters approved to support the County's trauma system. The bill specifies the composition of the Commission, and requires it to provide specified reports to the Legislature and to provide ongoing oversight and monitoring of the allocation of Measure B funds. This bill is sponsored by the author.
- Author's Statement. According to the author, "In 2002 residents of Los Angeles County passed Measure B; a special use tax of 3-cents per square foot on property improvements to rescue LA County’s failing trauma network. In good faith, the people of L.A. County entrusted the Board of Supervisors to exert its discretion on the use of these funds in such a way that they would serve the entire region most effectively by increasing and improving trauma service countywide. Unfortunately, the Board has failed to carry out this task.
"The county collects $250 million annually from the tax. On average, over 76 percent of those funds are distributed to just three hospitals, none of which are located in areas designated, by the County’s own standards, as underserved. Further, these three beneficiaries are the only three hospitals operated by the County itself, with the 12 non-county operated trauma centers sharing just 15 percent of the funds.
"A 2014 report from the State Auditor uncovered a host of problems with the administration of the funds. The report offered a list of six recommendations to the L.A. County Board of Supervisors in order to remedy these issues, including a recommendation for a Measure B oversight commission which this bill would create, codifying the Auditor’s recommendation."
- Background. Emergency departments are responsible for providing medical and surgical care to patients arriving at a hospital in need of immediate care. Trauma centers maintain a higher level of service. Trauma centers are designated according to levels. Level I centers offer the greatest level of service, while Level IV offers the lowest level of service. All of California’s trauma centers are at least Level III. There are also pediatric-specific trauma centers, either Level I or Level II. Some hospitals are designated as both a regular trauma center, and a pediatric trauma center. Level I and Level II are similar, with the primary difference being that Level I facilities are also teaching hospitals. Level III and IV trauma centers generally only provide initial stabilization, though Level III has greater surgical capabilities than Level IV.
EMSA provides statewide coordination of and leadership for trauma systems statewide, including the development of trauma care system regulations. LEMSAs are responsible for managing local trauma care systems, including designating trauma centers, and collecting trauma care data. Existing law requires EMSA to approve local plans for trauma systems to ensure that they meet minimum standards for care and service provision. EMSA's trauma system regulations include standards for:
- Triage and transportation of trauma cases;
- Flow patterns of trauma cases and geographic boundaries regarding trauma and non-trauma cases;
- The number and type of trauma cases necessary to assure that trauma facilities will provide quality care to trauma cases referred to them;
- The resources and equipment needed by trauma facilities;
- The availability and qualifications of the health care personnel, including physicians and surgeons;
- Data collection regarding system operation and patient outcome; and,
- Periodic performance evaluation of the trauma system and its components.
In developing a trauma plan, LEMSA's designate geographic areas where a given trauma center provides service. These areas are structured to ensure that all areas in a jurisdiction have access to a trauma center. Trauma plans that do not meet EMSA standards cannot be used to designate hospitals as trauma centers and are ineligible for state funding to support and improve care at those centers.
- LA County's Trauma System. LA County’s trauma system began operating in 1983, initially with eight designated trauma centers. By 1985, the system peaked with 22 designated trauma centers. However, 10 centers withdrew in 1990, often citing unacceptable levels of uncompensated care for trauma patients. The three areas of LA County that have been considered underserved in the trauma system are:
- The Malibu area, which does not have a trauma center within its geographic boundary;
- The Antelope Valley in northeastern LA County, which is a large geographic area served by a single trauma center; and,
- Until very recently, the eastern San Gabriel Valley. However, LA County’s newest designated trauma center, Pomona Valley Hospital Medical Center, began receiving trauma patients from the San Gabriel Valley on March 1, 2017. LA County contributed $4.5 million in Measure B funds in 2015 to help cover start-up costs for this new center, which has required more than $100 million in capital expenses to bring the facility up to the standards of a Level II trauma center.
- Measure B. In 2002, LA County’s Department of Health Services was facing a significant budget deficit, which was threatening the County's trauma system. To address this shortfall, the Board submitted Measure B to the voters in November of 2002, which 73% of the voters approved. Proponents of the measure indicated that Measure B would make it possible to provide trauma service in three underserved areas: Pomona, the eastern San Gabriel Valley, and the Antelope Valley. This parcel tax measure was initially set at $.03 per square foot on all structural improvements. The Board has increased the rate three times, most recently in 2012 to $.0424.
Following the passage of Measure B, LA County designated new trauma centers in Lancaster (Antelope Valley) and Pomona to enhance service to underserved parts of the county. Currently, LA County has two county-operated and 13 non-county-operated trauma centers, including: eight centers in the City of Los Angeles, two centers in the City of Long Beach, and one center each in the cities of Lancaster, Lynwood, Pasadena, Pomona, and Santa Clarita.
The collection and expenditure of funds that Measure B generates was not specified in the measure, but is governed by the resolution that the Board approved to place Measure B on the ballot. Measure B raises more than $250 million in revenue annually. The Measure B resolution requires the Board to set the tax rate by a majority vote, and permits the tax rate to be adjusted from the initial $.03 based on the medical component of the Consumer Price Index. The Measure B resolution specified the purposes for which Measure B funds may be spent, including paying for trauma centers, EMS, bioterrorism response, and defraying administrative expenses such as salaries and benefits for personnel in the LA County Department of Health Services.
The Measure B resolution did not specify an allocation methodology. Following passage of Measure B, the Board created an oversight committee, which was composed of representatives from LA County government, including the Auditor-Controller, chief executive office, Department of Health Services, county counsel, assessor, treasurer, and tax
collector. The Committee recommended distributing most of Measure B funds to pay for uncompensated trauma and emergency care at county hospitals, and for uncompensated trauma care at non-county hospitals. This oversight committee disbanded in 2004, shortly after making this recommendation.
- State Auditor Report. The State Auditor in January of 2014 released a report requested by the Legislature on LA County’s management of Measure B funds for fiscal years 2008-09 through 2011-12. According to the report, LA County had not reevaluated its allocation methodology since the passage of Measure B and had not conducted a comprehensive review of its trauma system. The report concluded that, without a comprehensive assessment of its trauma system, LA County cannot demonstrate that it has used Measure B funds to address the County's most pressing trauma needs and has fulfilled the intent of the measure by expanding trauma services countywide.
According to this report, more than a decade after voters approved Measure B, existing trauma centers remained far removed from certain areas within LA County despite Measure B’s stated intent. (However, as noted above, a trauma center was designated in the San Gabriel Valley since this report was published. The San Gabriel Valley was one of the areas identified in the report as an example of the lack of trauma center expansion despite Measure B.)
Although the LA County LEMSA, in conjunction with the American College of Surgeons, conducts periodic performance evaluations of individual trauma centers, the report argued that a comprehensive evaluation is needed to determine whether LA County's trauma system has developed to adequately meet the needs of all geographic areas and populations in the county. In addition, the report noted that the Board had not revisited its approach to allocating Measure B funds, hindering its ability to demonstrate to taxpayers that it distributes funds to address the most pressing trauma care needs.
According to the report, while the Board initially allocated $2.4 million in 2003 to fund helicopter services as an interim solution to locating trauma centers in underserved areas, this amount had grown over time and had appeared to become a permanent solution to providing trauma care access to underserved areas. The report argued that the data related to helicopter transports does not contain enough information to evaluate the effectiveness of helicopter services. In addition to recommending that the Board engage the American College of Surgeons to perform a comprehensive assessment, the report recommended reinstating a Measure B oversight committee, as well as collecting better data relating to helicopter transport.
- LA County Response. In its response to the report, the Board disagreed with many of the report's findings. The Board stated that it had assessed and evaluated its trauma and emergency care system and continued to do on a regular basis, resulting in a number of significant improvements to enhance trauma and emergency care in the County. The Board asserted that the allocation of Measure B funds had not changed, that funds were provided to offset uncompensated care, and that rates had been revised to meet the needs of the trauma hospitals. According to the Board, Measure B funding had been allocated to account for changes in the trauma network, such as the addition of California Hospital and Antelope
Valley Medical Center as new trauma hospitals, as well as the extra burden of uncompensated care taken on by St. Francis Medical Center when LA County’s Martin Luther King, Jr. Medical Center lost its trauma center designation.
LA County also noted that there are numerous processes to evaluate the performance of its trauma system, including: review and approval of the County’s trauma plan by EMSA; review of individual trauma centers by the American College of Surgeons; establishment of a County-wide trauma hospital advisory committee; and, review of complaint data, transport data (including ground and helicopter transport for individuals needing treatment in remote parts of the County), and mortality data. The response noted that mortality due to trauma was down County-wide and in the East San Gabriel Valley following the passage of Measure B, even though the rate of trauma incidents had increased.
- Antelope Valley Hospital Lawsuit. Measure B was opposed by Antelope Valley Hospital, which is one of the privately-operated trauma centers in the County’s trauma system. Following the State Auditor report, Antelope Valley Hospital sued the LA County Board of Supervisors in September 2015 over its Measure B funding allocations. The lawsuit alleged that the Board had allocated Measure B funds in a manner that was inconsistent with the intent of voters when they approved Measure B and that it had not used the funds to address the most pressing trauma needs in the county. In March 2017, the court ruled in favor of the Board because Measure B did not prescribe a specific manner of allocating funding.
- Policy Considerations. The Committee may wish to consider the following issues:
- Local Issue, Local Resolution. Local governments pass local taxes when approved by local voters, who are able to exercise oversight by evaluating the performance of their elected officials and removing them if they are dissatisfied with their performance. The Committee may wish to consider if this issue should remain in the hands of local officials and their electorate.
- Enough Oversight Today? State regulations already prescribe requirements that trauma centers must meet, and the LA County system of trauma centers undergoes additional evaluations as noted by the County in its response to the State Auditor's report. The Committee may wish to consider whether it is appropriate for the Legislature to exert additional influence over how LA County spends its local tax dollars when this spending already undergoes several levels of review.
- Court Decision. As noted above, LA County prevailed in the lawsuit with Antelope Valley Hospital over its allocation of Measure B funds. The Committee may wish to consider whether this bill creates an unnecessary review process for local decisions that have already been litigated.
- Commission Membership. This bill prescribes the membership of the proposed Commission to include one representative from each city that has a trauma center, although these cities have vastly differing populations and different numbers of trauma centers. In addition, the area that a trauma center serves can include multiple cities – not just the city in which the center is located. Providing a small number of individual cities with representation on the Commission might not result in an accurate representation of
the needs of LA County residents. This is especially true for any underserved areas, which would be excluded from being seated on the Commission because only cities that already have a trauma center have been given a seat on the Commission.
- Previous Legislation. AB 1975 (Hernández) of 2014 would have required LEMSAs to contract with the American College of Surgeons every five years to conduct a comprehensive assessment of their regional trauma systems. AB 1975 was held in the Assembly Appropriations Committee.
AB 1357 (Hernández) of 2013 would have required Measure B funds that were collected from properties within the San Gabriel Valley (SGV) to remain within that geographic region of LA County, and would have required the funds to be used for the purposes intended by the voter initiative within that geographic area to reduce ambulance diversion. The bill would have established a task force consisting of EMSA, DPH, the State Auditor, and a representative of a local hospital task force to be selected by the other members, and would have required the task force to study and audit the funds collected from properties in SGV to gain an understanding as to how the moneys have been allocated and to gauge what improvements, if any, have been made. AB 1357 was referred to the Assembly Health Committee but was never heard.
- State Mandate. This bill is keyed a state mandate, which means the state could be required to reimburse local agencies and school districts for implementing the bill's provisions if the Commission on State Mandates determines that the bill contains costs mandated by the state.
- Arguments in Support. The California Chapter of the American College of Emergency Physicians, in support, writes, "Unfortunately, not all of Los Angeles County's trauma centers have received their fair share of Measure B funding. A 2014 report by the State Auditor concluded that 75% of funds go to the three county-run public hospitals and only 16% of funds go to the non-county operated trauma centers. The Auditor could not prove that Los Angeles County was using the funds inappropriately because Measure B did not include a specific funding formula.
"Our members support SB 792 because it will provide much needed accountability of Measure B funds, including an accounting of fund allocations, criteria the County uses to allocate those funds, and causes for disparities in funding. Measure B was intended to expand the trauma system in Los Angeles County and this bill will ensure it is living up to its promise."
- Arguments in Opposition. The LA County Board of Supervisors, in opposition, states,
"SB 792 sets an unjustified precedent for local governments and all local voter-approved ballot measures. In fact, the County questions the Legislature's authority to mandate the County, or any local jurisdiction for that matter, to statutorily establish new parameters or requirements on local ballot measures approved by the local electorate, especially if the proposed statutory change goes beyond the language contained in the locally-approved measure.
"SB 792 is duplicative. There already are three County commissions or departments that provide oversight and/or recommendations on Measure B oversight and expenditures. These
entities include a broad group of stakeholders representing cities, law enforcement, emergency physicians and trauma surgeons. Further, the County's Auditor-Controller is mandated by law to annually publish a report on all Measure B revenues and expenditures. SB 792 is a reimbursable State-mandate and it does not make sense to expend State resources for a process that already exists."
- Double-Referral. This bill is double-referred to the Health Committee.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
Antelope Valley Board of Trade
Antelope Valley Community Clinic
Antelope Valley Union High School District
California Chapter of the American College of Emergency Physicians
California Newspaper Publishers Association
City of Palmdale
Ellison John Transitional Care Center
Grace Resource Center
High Desert Medical Group
League of California Cities Desert Mountain Division
Mental Health America of Los Angeles, Antelope Valley Services
Palmdale Chamber of Commerce
One individual
Opposition
California State Association of Counties
Healthy African American Families
Los Angeles County Board of Supervisors
Urban Counties of California
Analysis Prepared by: Angela Mapp / L. GOV. / (916) 319-3958
Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | SB |
THIRD READING
Bill No: SB 792
Amended: 5/26/17
SENATE HEALTH COMMITTEE: 8-0, 4/19/17
AYES: Hernandez, Nguyen, Atkins, Leyva, Monning, Newman, Nielsen, Roth
NO VOTE RECORDED: Mitchell
SENATE GOVERNANCE & FIN. COMMITTEE: 7-0, 4/26/17
AYES: McGuire, Nguyen, Beall, Hernandez, Hertzberg, Lara, Moorlach
SENATE APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE: 7-0, 5/25/17
AYES: Lara, Bates, Beall, Bradford, Hill, Nielsen, Wiener
DIGEST:
This bill requires Los Angeles County to establish an oversight commission to review and report on how Los Angeles County uses the funds from a parcel tax measure approved by Los Angeles County voters in 2002, which provides funding for the county trauma system.
Existing law:
- Permits general acute care hospitals, in addition to the basic services all hospitals are required to offer, to be approved by the Department of Public Health (DPH) to offer special services, including, but not limited to, a radiation therapy department, a burn center, an emergency center, a hemodialysis center or unit, psychiatric services, intensive care newborn nursery, cardiac surgery, cardiac catheterization laboratory, and renal transplant.
- Establishes the Emergency Medical Services Authority (EMSA), headed by a physician who has experience in the practice of emergency medicine and appointed by the Governor. Among other responsibilities, EMSA is required to develop planning and implementation guidelines for emergency medical services (EMS) systems.
- Requires each county that has developed an EMS system to designate a local EMS agency (LEMSA), which is required to be the county health department, an agency established and operated by the county, an entity with which the county contracts for purposes of local EMS administration, or a joint powers agency created for the administration of EMS between counties. LEMSAs are required to have physician directors, and are responsible for planning, implementing, and evaluating an EMS system, among other duties.
- Requires EMSA to draft regulations specifying minimum standards for the implementation of trauma care systems, as specified. Permits LEMSAs to implement a trauma care system if the system meets minimum standards established by EMSA. Permits LEMSAs to designate trauma facilities, as defined, as part of their trauma system.
This bill:
- Requires the Los Angeles County (LA County) to establish a Measure B Oversight Commission (Commission), consisting of the following members:
- A member appointed by each city in LA County with a trauma center (currently, there are 9 cities with a trauma center);
- A member appointed by the Southern California Chapter of the American College of Surgeons;
- A member appointed by the Board of Supervisors (Board) of LA County;
- A member appointed by the Emergency Medical Services Authority;
- A member appointed by the LA County Department of Health Services;
- A member appointed by the LA County Office of the Assessor; and,
- Two members who are citizens appointed by the commission to represent underserved areas of LA County.
- Requires the Commission to submit a report to the Legislature by June 1, 2020, containing an assessment of the solvency of the LA County trauma network and recommendations to address deficiencies, the need and feasibility of trauma center expansion in underserved areas, and the allocation, specifically and separately, of Measure B funds that includes all of the following:
- The total amount of taxes collected under Measure B from the initial date of imposition of the tax;
- An accounting of all allocations of Measure B funds;
- Criteria used in determining the allocation of Measure B funds;
- The causes for, if any, disparities between allocations to LA County operated trauma centers and noncounty operated trauma centers; and,
- A recommendation of how Measure B funds should be allocated so as to most closely reflect the intent of the initial measure and to provide equitable allocation across the LA County trauma network while ensuring that the needs of underserved populations and regions are being met.
- Requires the Commission, following the submission of the report required by 2020, to continue to oversee and monitor the collection and expenditure of Measure B funds, and to submit a report to the Legislature on June 1 of each year containing all of the following information:
- Recommendations for continued improvements to the LA County trauma network;
- Information regarding whether recommendations made in prior reports of the Commission were implemented; and,
- An assessment of the allocation of Measure B funds for the previous year and information regarding whether these allocations were equitable throughout the LA County trauma network. Requires the Commission, if it determines that these allocations were not equitable, to make a recommendation of how Measure B funds should be allocated equitably.
- Requires the reports submitted pursuant to this bill to be submitted in compliance with provisions of law governing reports to the Legislature.
- Requires LA County, in an effort to facilitate the duties of the Commission and to ensure further and ongoing transparency, to post in a clear and accessible location on the County’s Internet Web site, both of the following:
- On or before June 1, 2019, the total allocation of Measure B funds to each trauma center receiving those funds;
- On or before June 1, 2020, and by each June 1 thereafter, the allocation of Measure B funds to each trauma center receiving those funds in the prior year.
Comments
- Author’s statement. According to the author, in 2002 residents of LA County passed Measure B; a special use tax of three cents per square foot on property improvements to rescue LA County’s failing trauma network. In good faith, the people of LA County entrusted the Board to exert its discretion on the use of these funds in such a way that they would serve the entire region most effectively by increasing and improving trauma service countywide. Unfortunately, the Board has failed to carry out this task. The county collects $250 million annually from the tax. On average, over 76% of those funds are distributed to just three hospitals, none of which are located in areas designated, by the County’s own standards, as underserved. Further, these three beneficiaries are the only three hospitals operated by the County itself, with the 12 non-county operated trauma centers sharing just 15% of the funds. A 2014 report from the State Auditor uncovered a host of problems with the administration of the funds. The report offered a list of six recommendations to the LA County Board in order to remedy these issues, including a recommendation for a Measure B oversight commission which this bill creates.
- Background on trauma centers. Trauma is defined as a potentially severe physical injury caused by an external source (fall, auto crash, farm or industrial accident, knife or gunshot wound, etc.) that requires emergency medical intervention to prevent loss of life or limb or substantial, permanent physical impairment. It does not include moderate or minor injuries; heart attacks, strokes, or other internal conditions; chronic, contagious or infectious diseases; or mental illness not caused by a severe physical injury. Trauma is the primary cause of death for people ages 1 to 44, regardless of gender, race, or economic status. Literature indicates that survival of trauma patients is greatly increased if they are brought to definitive surgical intervention within what has become known as “The Golden Hour” – the one hour time period from injury to specialized trauma care.
While an emergency department is responsible for providing medical and surgical care to patients arriving at the hospital in need of immediate care, trauma centers maintain a higher level of service. EMSA provides statewide coordination and leadership trauma systems statewide, including development of trauma care system regulations, while LEMSAs are responsible for managing local trauma care systems, including designating trauma centers, and collecting trauma care data.
Trauma centers are designated according to levels (Level I is the highest, Level IV is the lowest, although all of California’s trauma centers are at least Level III). There are also pediatric specific trauma centers, either Level I or Level II. Some hospitals are designated as both a regular trauma center, and a pediatric trauma center. Level I and Level II are similar, with the primary difference being that Level I facilities are also teaching hospitals. Level III and IV trauma centers generally only provide initial stabilization, though Level III has greater surgical capabilities than Level IV. - LA County trauma system. LA County’s trauma system began operating in 1983 with an initial eight designated trauma centers. By 1985, the system peaked with 22 designated trauma centers, but by 1990, ten withdrew, often citing unacceptable levels of uncompensated care for trauma patients. The three areas of LA County that have been considered underserved in the trauma system are the Malibu area, which does not have a trauma center within its geographic boundary; the Antelope Valley in northeastern LA County, which is a large geographic area served by a single trauma center; and until very recently, the eastern San Gabriel Valley. However, LA County’s newest designated trauma center, Pomona Valley Hospital Medical Center, began receiving trauma patients from the San Gabriel Valley on March 1, 2017. LA County contributed $4.5 million in Measure B funds in 2015 to help cover start-up costs of what ended up being more than $100 million in capital expenses to bring the facility up to the standards of a Level II trauma center.
- Background on Measure B. In 2002, LA County’s Department of Health Services was facing a significant budget deficit, which was threatening their trauma system. To address this, the Board submitted a parcel tax measure to the voters in November of 2002, which was approved by 73% of voters. The initial parcel tax was $.03 per square foot on all structural improvements, although the Board has voted to increase the tax rate three times, most recently to $.0424 in 2012. The resolution that the Board voted on to place the measure on the ballot governs the collection and expenditure of funds that Measure B brings in more than $250 million in revenue annually. The Measure B resolution requires the Board to set the tax rate by a majority vote, and permits the tax rate to be adjusted from the initial $.03 based on the medical component of the Consumer Price Index. The Measure B resolution specified the purposes for which Measure B funds may be spent, including paying for trauma centers, EMS, bioterrorism response, and defraying administrative expenses such as salaries and benefits for personnel in the LA County Department of Health Services. However, the Measure B resolution did not specify an allocation methodology. Instead, an initial Board-created oversight committee that was formed following the passage of Measure B recommended distributing most of the funds to pay for uncompensated trauma and emergency care at county hospitals, and for uncompensated trauma care at non-county hospitals. This oversight committee disbanded shortly after making this recommendation.
- State Auditor report. In January of 2014, the State Auditor released a report on LA County’s management of Measure B funds (report), concluding that without a comprehensive assessment of its trauma system, LA County cannot demonstrate that it has used Measure B funds to address the most pressing trauma needs and has fulfilled the intent of the measure by expanding trauma services countywide. According to this report, more than a decade after voters approved Measure B, existing trauma centers remain far removed from certain areas with LA County despite Measure B’s stated intent. (As noted above, since this report was published, a trauma center was designated in the San Gabriel Valley, which is one of the areas called out by the State Auditor as an example of the lack of expansion by Measure B.) The report argues that while the LA County LEMSA, in conjunction with the American College of Surgeons, conducts periodic performance evaluations of individual trauma centers, a comprehensive evaluation is needed to determine whether the trauma system LA County has developed is adequately meeting the needs of all geographic areas and populations in the county. Additionally, the report notes that the Board has not revisited its approach to allocating Measure B funds, hindering its ability to demonstrate to taxpayers that it distributes funds to address the most pressing trauma care needs. According to the report, while the Board initially allocated $2.4 million in 2003 to fund helicopter services as an interim solution to locating trauma centers in underserved areas, this amount has grown over time and that it appears that this has become a permanent solution to providing trauma care access to underserved areas. The report argues that the data related to helicopter transports does not contain enough information to evaluate the effectiveness of helicopter services. In addition to recommending that the Board engage the American College of Surgeons to perform a comprehensive assessment, the report recommends reinstating a Measure B oversight committee, and collecting better data relating to helicopter transport.
In its response to the report, the Board stated that it disagrees with many of the assertions contained in the report. In particular, the Board states that it has and continues to regularly assess and evaluate its trauma and emergency care system, which has led to the development of a number of significant improvements to enhance trauma and emergency care. The Board states it is not the case that allocation of Measure B funds has not changed, and states that funds are provided to offset uncompensated care and rates have been revised to meet the needs of the trauma hospitals. According to the Board, Measure B funding has been allocated to account for changes in the trauma network, such as the addition of California Hospital and Antelope Valley Medical Center as new trauma hospitals, and the extra burden of uncompensated care taken on by St. Francis Medical Center when LA County’s Martin Luther King, Jr. Medical Center lost its trauma center designation.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: Fiscal Com.: Local:
According to the Senate Committee on Appropriations:
- Likely ongoing costs reimbursable mandate costs of about $300,000 per year for staff support of the commission and administrative costs to support the commission (General Fund).
- No significant state reimbursable mandate costs are anticipated due to the requirement in the bill that LA County post specified information on its Web site.
Antelope Valley Community Clinic
Antelope Valley Hospital
California Chapter of the American College of Emergency Physicians
City of Palmdale
Palmdale Chamber of Commerce
OPPOSITION: (Verified 5/25/17)
Los Angeles County Board of Supervisors
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: The California Chapter of the American College of Emergency Physicians (California ACEP) states in support that not all of LA County’s trauma centers have received their fair share of Measure B funding. California ACEP supports this bill because it will provide much needed accountability of Measure B funds, including an accounting of fund allocations, criteria LA County uses to allocate those funds, and causes for disparities in funding. California ACEP states that Measure B was intended to expand the trauma system in LA County, and this bill will ensure it is living up to its promise. Antelope Valley Community Clinic states in support that it strongly supports that it works closely with Antelope Valley Hospital, and supports legislation that will help support the trauma unit. The Palmdale Chamber of Commerce states in support that the Antelope Valley Hospital has been shortchanged, and this bill will help ensure Measure B funds will be distributed with greater fairness and transparency to the benefit of Antelope Valley residents, and all residents served by underfunded trauma hospitals in LA County.
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION: The Board opposes this bill, stating that since the passage of Measure B, the Board has approved the expansion of LA County’s trauma system by adding California Hospital, Antelope Valley Hospital, and most recently Pomona Valley Medical Center. The Board states that it has also allocated Measure B funds among the non-County trauma hospitals in proportion to the value of trauma-related care for uninsured patients and to reimburse trauma hospitals for costs associated with serving as a base hospital in LA County’s EMS system. The Board states that this bill is unnecessary because LA County continues to work with non-County hospitals to develop a new allocation method for Measure B funds. Further, the Board states that LA County’s Trauma Hospital Advisory Committee, which includes representatives from the American College of Surgeons and the EMS Commission, routinely monitors the use of Measure B funds and makes recommendations regarding deficiencies and improvements to the Board. The Board states that this bill would remove local control over Measure B funds from LA County by requiring the Commission’s report to the Legislature to make a recommendation based on the “equitable allocation” across LA County’s trauma network. The Board asserts that there is no such restriction in Measure B, and that this bill would set a bad precedent by allowing an outside Commission and the State to control or to participate in the distribution of not only Measure B funds, but potentially any and all locally-approved taxes and revenues. The Board states that Measure B is a locally-approved measure, and therefore oversight of those locally-derived dollars should be retained at the local level.
5/27/17 15:28:45
SENATE COMMITTEE ON
Senator Ricardo Lara, Chair
2017 - 2018 Regular Session
SB 792 (Wilk) - Local government: Measure B Oversight Commission: County of Los Angeles
Version: | Policy Vote: |
Urgency: | Mandate: |
Hearing Date: | Consultant: |
*********** ANALYSIS ADDENDUM – SUSPENSE FILE ***********
The following information is revised to reflect amendments
adopted by the committee on May 25, 2017
Bill Summary:
SB 792 would establish an oversight commission to review and report on the use of parcel tax funds for support of the trauma system in Los Angeles County.
Fiscal Impact:
- Likely ongoing costs reimbursable mandate costs of about $300,000 per year for staff support of the commission and administrative costs to support the commission (General Fund).
- No significant state reimbursable mandate costs are anticipated due to the requirement in the bill that Los Angeles County post specified information on its website.
Committee Amendments:
Specify that Los Angeles County is required to establish the Commission.
-- END --
SENATE COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Senator Ricardo Lara, Chair
2017 - 2018 Regular Session
SB 792 (Wilk) - Local government: Measure B Oversight Commission: County of Los Angeles
Version: February 17, 2017 | Policy Vote: HEALTH 8 - 0, GOV. & F. 7 - 0 |
Urgency: No | Mandate: Yes |
Hearing Date: May 22, 2017 | Consultant: Brendan McCarthy |
This bill meets the criteria for referral to the Suspense File.
Bill Summary:
SB 792 would establish an oversight commission to review and report on the use of parcel tax funds for support of the trauma system in Los Angeles County.
Fiscal Impact:
- Likely ongoing costs of about $300,000 per year for staff support of the commission and administrative costs to support the commission (General Fund).
- No significant state reimbursable mandate costs are anticipated due to the requirement in the bill that Los Angeles County post specified information on its website.
Background:
In 2002, the voters of Los Angeles County enacted Measure B, which created a parcel tax to provide funding to support the trauma system in the county. Currently, Measure B generates about $250 million per year. Measure B does not specify how revenues should be allocated within the trauma system.
The majority of the funding generated by Measure B is provided to trauma center hospitals in the county. In recent years, about 75% of Measure B funding has gone to three county-operated trauma centers and about 15% has gone go 12 non-county-operated trauma centers. Concerns have been raised for several years that the bulk of Measure B funding is going to three county-operated trauma centers and that some outlying areas of the county remain underserved by trauma centers. (However, a hospital in one of those areas – the eastern San Gabriel Valley – has recently been upgraded to a Level II trauma center, with some assistance from Measure B funding.)
Proposed Law:
SB 792 would establish an oversight commission to review and report on the use of parcel tax funds for support of the trauma system in Los Angeles County.
Specific provisions of the bill would:
- Establish the Measure B Oversight Commission;
- Provide for the Commission’s membership, including members appointed by cities in Los Angeles County with trauma centers, members appointed by the Los Angeles County Board of Supervisors, members appointed by several other appointing entities, and two public members appointed by the commission;
- Require the Commission to report to the Legislature on specific issues relating to the Los Angeles County trauma system, the use of Measure B funding, and recommendations for future allocations of Measure B funding;
- Require the Commission to continue to oversee Measure B spending and to report annually to the Legislature;
- Require Los Angeles County to post specified information regarding the allocation of Measure B funding on its website.
Staff Comments:
The bill does not specify whether the Commission is intended to be a state entity or a part of Los Angeles County government. In either case, the costs to provide support staff to the Commission would most likely be a state responsibility. If the Commission were established by the state (for example, with administrative support from the Emergency Medical Services Authority) the state would be directly responsible for the anticipated costs to provide staff support to the Commission. Alternatively, if the Commission were established under the administrative control of Los Angeles County, the county would be eligible for state reimbursement for the costs of supporting the commission.
Recommended Amendments:
The author should clarify whether the Commission is intended to be a state entity or a part of Los Angeles County government. Also, the bill as drafted, puts the new code sections into the Harbors and Navigation Code. The bill should be amended to place the bill’s contents in the Government Code or Health and Safety Code, as those codes are more relevant to the subject matter of the bill.
-- END --
SENATE COMMITTEE ON GOVERNANCE AND FINANCE
Senator Mike McGuire, Chair
2017 - 2018 Regular
Bill No: | SB 792 | Hearing Date: | 4/26/17 |
Author: | Wilk | Tax Levy: | No |
Version: | 2/17/17 | Fiscal: | Yes |
Consultant: | Favorini-Csorba | ||
Local government: Measure B Oversight Commission: County of Los Angeles
Establishes the Measure B Oversight Commission in Los Angeles County.
Background
Emergency Medical Services Authority. The Emergency Medical Services (EMS) Authority is a state agency that coordinates and regulates the planning, development, and implementation of local EMS systems. California has 33 local EMS systems that provide emergency medical services for California's 58 counties. Seven regional EMS systems comprised of thirty-three counties and twenty-six single county agencies provide the services. Regional systems are usually comprised of small, more rural, less-populated counties and single-county systems generally exist in the larger and more urban counties. County and regional EMS systems include “trauma centers” to better treat critical, life-threatening injuries due to motor vehicle crashes, falls, drownings, gunshots, burns, stabbings, or other grave physical harms.
The Health and Safety Code requires the EMS Authority to approve local plans for trauma systems to ensure that they meet minimum standards for care and service provision. The EMS Authority’s trauma system regulations include standards for:
- Triage and transportation of trauma cases.
- Flow patterns of trauma cases and geographic boundaries regarding trauma and nontrauma cases.
- The number and type of trauma cases necessary to assure that trauma facilities will provide quality care to trauma cases referred to them.
- The resources and equipment needed by trauma facilities.
- The availability and qualifications of the health care personnel, including physicians and surgeons.
- Data collection regarding system operation and patient outcome.
- Periodic performance evaluation of the trauma system and its components.
In developing a trauma plan, local EMS systems designate geographic areas where a given trauma center provides service. These areas are structured to ensure that everywhere in the jurisdiction has access to a trauma center. Trauma plans that do not meet EMS Authority standards cannot be used to designate hospitals as trauma centers and are ineligible for state funding to support and improve care at those centers.
Measure B. Los Angeles County developed a system of trauma centers in the early 1980s. By 1985, the county had 22 trauma centers, some operated by the county and some operated privately. However, shortly after Los Angeles’s trauma system reached this peak, trauma centers began to withdraw from the system, citing the costs of uncompensated care—for patients who are unable to pay for their care and have no third‑party insurance coverage—as the reason for their withdrawal. This left some areas in Los Angeles without a trauma center. By 2002 Los Angeles’s Department of Health Services faced a significant budget deficit, which threatened the already weakened trauma system.
At the November 5, 2002, election, Los Angeles voters approved Measure B, which authorized the county to levy a parcel tax of three cents per square foot on all parcels in the county to maintain and expand the county’s trauma system, ensure the continued availability of emergency medical services, and respond effectively to biological terrorism. Proponents of the measure indicated that Measure B would make it possible to provide trauma service in three underserved areas: Pomona, the eastern San Gabriel Valley, and the Antelope Valley. Measure B did not specify how funds would be allocated. Instead, the Board of Supervisors for Los Angeles County allocates these funds primarily to reimburse the trauma centers within Los Angeles’s trauma system for treatment of patients who are unable to pay for their care and who have no third‑party insurance coverage.
Following the passage of Measure B, LA County designated new trauma centers in Lancaster (Antelope Valley) and Pomona to enhance service to underserved parts of the county. Currently, LA County has two county‑operated and 13 non‑county‑operated trauma centers, including: 8 centers in the City of Los Angeles, 2 centers in the City of Long Beach, and 1 center each in the cities of Lancaster, Lynwood, Pasadena, Pomona, and Santa Clarita.
State Audit of Measure B Allocations. In 2013, at the request of the Legislature, the California State Auditor released an audit on LA County’s management of Measure B funds for fiscal years 2008–09 through 2011–12. The audit examined Los Angeles’s policies and procedures for allocating Measure B funds, including how Measure B funds were used to provide trauma services to “underserved areas.”
The audit noted that shortly after the passage of Measure B, the board established a Measure B oversight commission to guide allocation of the funds. The commission was composed of the representatives from the LA County government, including the Auditor-Controller, chief executive office, Department of Health Services, county counsel, assessor, treasurer, and tax collector. This commission was disbanded in 2004. According to the audit, LA County had not reevaluated its allocation methodology since the passage of Measure B and had not conducted a comprehensive review of its trauma system. The audit therefore concluded that the county could not demonstrate that it was spending Measure B funds to address the most pressing trauma needs in the county.
In its official response to the audit, LA County noted that there are numerous processes to evaluate the performance of its trauma system, including: review and approval of the county’s trauma plan by the state EMS Authority; review of individual trauma centers by the American College of Surgeons; establishment of a county-wide trauma hospital advisory committee; and review of complaint data, transport data (including ground and helicopter transport for individuals needing treatment in far-flung parts of the county), and mortality data. The response noted that mortality due to trauma was down county-wide and in the East San Gabriel Valley following the passage of Measure B, even though the rate of trauma incidents had increased.
Antelope Valley Hospital Lawsuit. Measure B was opposed by Antelope Valley Hospital, which is one of the privately-operated trauma centers in the county’s trauma system. Following the State Auditor report, Antelope Valley Hospital sued the Los Angeles County Board of Supervisors in September 2015 over its Measure B funding allocations. The lawsuit alleged that the board had allocated Measure B funds in a manner that was inconsistent with the intent of voters when they approved Measure B and that it had not used the funds to address the most pressing trauma needs in the county. In March 2017, the court ruled in favor of the board because Measure B did not prescribe a specific manner of allocating funding.
Responding to concerns over the allocation of Measure B funds, the author wants to establish a commission to evaluate LA County’s expenditure of those funds.
Proposed Law
Senate Bill 792 establishes a Measure B Oversight Commission and assigns it certain duties. The membership of the commission includes:
- A member appointed by each city in the County of Los Angeles with a trauma center (for a total of 7 members)
- A member appointed by the Southern California Chapter of the American College of Surgeons.
- A member appointed by the Board of Supervisors of the County of Los Angeles.
- A member appointed by the Emergency Medical Services Authority.
- A member appointed by the Los Angeles County Department of Health Services.
- A member appointed by the Los Angeles County Office of the Assessor.
- Two members who are citizens appointed by the commission to represent underserved areas of the county.
SB 792 tasks the commission with submitting to the Legislature a report by June 1, 2020, on the performance of the Los Angeles County trauma network that contains:
- An assessment of the solvency of the county’s trauma network and recommendations to address deficiencies.
- The need and feasibility of trauma center expansion in areas underserved by the network.
- The allocation of Measure B funds, including: the total amount of taxes collected under Measure B to date; an accounting of all allocations of Measure B funds; criteria used in determining that allocation; and the causes for any disparities between allocations to county operated trauma centers and noncounty operated trauma centers.
- A recommendation of how Measure B funds should be allocated so as to most closely reflect the intent of the initial measure and to provide equitable allocation across the County of Los Angeles trauma network while ensuring that the needs of underserved populations and county regions are being met.
The commission must also continue to oversee the collection and spending of Measure B funds and report to the Legislature by June 1, 2021, and every other year thereafter, on whether funding allocations for the previous year were equitable, recommendations for continued improvements and improved equity, and information on whether previous recommendations were implemented.
SB 792 also directs LA County to post on its website the total allocation of Measure B funds to each trauma center by June 1, 2019, and the allocation of Measure B funds to each trauma center in the prior year annually by June 1, beginning in 2020.
State Revenue Impact
No estimate.
Comments
1. Purpose of the bill. Los Angeles County voters approved Measure B in 2002 with the expectation that it would provide underserved areas of LA County with trauma centers to meet their needs. Yet as the State Auditor notes, there is currently only one trauma center in the expansive Antelope Valley: the Antelope Valley Hospital. In 2015, that hospital saw 12.4% of Los Angeles County trauma and ER visits, but got only 2.9 percent of Measure B funds (among the non-county hospitals). In addition, county-operated trauma centers have gotten substantially more funding from Measure B than non-county-operated centers. These disparities have thwarted the intent of the voters to improve trauma service county-wide and instead have resulted in parts of the county being left behind. SB 792 sets up a process to evaluate whether the allocation methodology used by the county is fair and equitable by establishing a Measure B Oversight Commission. This puts another set of eyes on the funding allocation process and provides those underserved areas with representation by giving all cities with trauma centers a seat at the table. SB 792 also ensures that voters have access to the information they need to make sure Measure B fulfills its promise.
2. Overprescribing. Local governments pass local taxes, approved by local voters. Voters have the ability to exercise oversight by evaluating the performance of their elected officials and removing them if they are found wanting. Measure B leaves it up to the LA County Board of Supervisors to allocate its funds to improve its trauma network. If local voters are unhappy with how these funds have been allocated, they have a way to express it. State regulations already prescribe requirements that trauma centers must meet, and the LA County system of trauma centers undergoes additional evaluations as noted by the county in its response to the audit. Furthermore, Los Angeles County prevailed in the lawsuit with Antelope Valley Hospital over its usage of the funds. SB 792 creates an unnecessary review process for local decisions in an effort to re-litigate past battles. Is it appropriate for the Legislature to exert additional influence over how LA County spends its local tax dollars, when this spending already undergoes several levels of review?
3. Commission composition. Residents—and the associated need for trauma services—are not evenly distributed throughout Los Angeles County. At over 4 million people, the City of Los Angeles has more than 8 times as many people as the next largest city (the City of Long Beach, with roughly 485,000 residents), and it has 8 trauma centers within its boundaries. But SB 792 creates an oversight commission that gives the City of Los Angeles the same number of seats as the City of Lynwood (which has 73,000 residents), regardless of the number of people, geographic coverage, or number of trauma centers in each jurisdiction. In addition, the area that a trauma center serves can cross multiple cities—not just the city in which the center is located. Providing a small number of individual cities with representation on the commission may not result in an accurate representation of the needs of LA County residents . This is especially true for any underserved areas, which would be excluded from being seated on the commission created by SB 792 because it only includes those cities that already have a trauma center. Finally, the proposed composition of the board results in an even number of commissioners, which can create deadlock on the commission. The Committee may wish to consider amending SB 792 to specify a different board composition that would better reflect the needs of all LA County residents, such as by eliminating the city representatives and instead allowing each LA County Supervisor to appoint a representative.
4. Technical amendments. SB 792 adds Article 19 to Chapter 4 of Part 1 of Division 2 of Title 5 of the Harbors and Navigation Code on p. 2, lines 1-3. However, the bill’s title adds Article 19 to the Government Code, which is the correct code. Nonetheless, Article 19 of this chapter of the Government Code already exists. The Committee may wish to consider technical amendments to SB 792 that add the correct article to the correct code throughout the bill.
5. Mandate. The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local governments for the costs of new or expanded state mandated local programs. Because SB 792 imposes additional duties on the County of Los Angeles, Legislative Counsel says that it imposes a new state mandate. SB 792 requires the state to reimburse local agencies if the Commission on State Mandates determines that the bill imposes a reimbursable mandate.
6. Special legislation. The California Constitution prohibits special legislation when a general law can apply (Article IV, §16). SB 792 contains findings and declarations explaining the need for legislation that applies only to the Los Angeles County trauma network.
7. Incoming! The Senate Health Committee passed approved SB 792 on a vote of eight to one on April 19, 2017.
Support and Opposition
(4/21/17)
Support: Antelope Valley Community Clinic; Antelope Valley Hospital; California Chapter of the American College of Emergency Physicians; City of Palmdale; Palmdale Chamber of Commerce; Purse Health, LLC.
Opposition: California State Association of Counties; County of Los Angeles.
-- END --
SENATE COMMITTEE ON HEALTH
Senator Ed Hernandez, O.D., Chair
BILL NO: SB 792
AUTHOR: | Wilk | ||
VERSION: | February 17, 2017 | ||
HEARING DATE: | April 19, 2017 | ||
CONSULTANT: | Vince Marchand | ||
SUBJECT: Local government: Measure B Oversight Commission: County of Los Angeles
SUMMARY:
Establishes an oversight commission to review and report on how Los Angeles County uses the funds from a parcel tax measure approved by Los Angeles County voters in 2002, which provides funding for the county trauma system.
Existing law:
- Licenses general acute care hospitals under the Department of Public Health (DPH). Defines general acute care hospitals as hospitals that provide 24-hour inpatient care, including the following basic services: medical, nursing, surgical, anesthesia, laboratory, radiology, pharmacy, and dietary services.
- Permits general acute care hospitals, in addition to the basic services all hospitals are required to offer, to be approved by DPH to offer special services, including, but not limited to, a radiation therapy department, a burn center, an emergency center, a hemodialysis center or unit, psychiatric services, intensive care newborn nursery, cardiac surgery, cardiac catheterization laboratory, and renal transplant.
- Establishes the Emergency Medical Services Authority (EMSA), headed by a physician who has experience in the practice of emergency medicine and appointed by the Governor. Among other responsibilities, EMSA is required to develop planning and implementation guidelines for emergency medical services (EMS) systems.
- Requires each county that has developed an EMS system to designate a local EMS agency (LEMSA), which is required to be the county health department, an agency established and operated by the county, an entity with which the county contracts for purposes of local EMS administration, or a joint powers agency created for the administration of EMS between counties. LEMSAs are required to have physician directors, and are responsible for planning, implementing, and evaluating an EMS system, among other duties.
- Requires EMSA to draft regulations specifying minimum standards for the implementation of trauma care systems, as specified. Permits LEMSAs to implement a trauma care system if the system meets minimum standards established by EMSA. Permits LEMSAs to designate trauma facilities, as defined, as part of their trauma system.
This bill:
- Establishes the Measure B Oversight Commission (Commission), consisting of the following members:
- A member appointed by each city in Los Angeles County (LA County) with a trauma center (currently, there are 9 cities with a trauma center);
- A member appointed by the Southern California Chapter of the American College of Surgeons;
- A member appointed by the Board of Supervisors (Board) of LA County;
- A member appointed by the Emergency Medical Services Authority;
- A member appointed by the LA County Department of Health Services;
- A member appointed by the LA County Office of the Assessor; and,
- Two members who are citizens appointed by the commission to represent underserved areas of LA County.
- Requires the Commission to submit a report to the Legislature by June 1, 2020, containing an assessment of the solvency of the LA County trauma network and recommendations to address deficiencies, the need and feasibility of trauma center expansion in underserved areas, and the allocation, specifically and separately, of Measure B funds that includes all of the following:
- The total amount of taxes collected under Measure B from the initial date of imposition of the tax;
- An accounting of all allocations of Measure B funds;
- Criteria used in determining the allocation of Measure B funds;
- The causes for, if any, disparities between allocations to LA County operated trauma centers and noncounty operated trauma centers; and,
- A recommendation of how Measure B funds should be allocated so as to most closely reflect the intent of the initial measure and to provide equitable allocation across the LA County trauma network while ensuring that the needs of underserved populations and regions are being met.
- Requires the Commission, following the submission of the report required by 2020, to continue to oversee and monitor the collection and expenditure of Measure B funds, and to submit a report to the Legislature on June 1 of each year containing all of the following information:
- Recommendations for continued improvements to the LA County trauma network;
- Information regarding whether recommendations made in prior reports of the Commission were implemented; and,
- An assessment of the allocation of Measure B funds for the previous year and information regarding whether these allocations were equitable throughout the LA County trauma network. Requires the Commission, if it determines that these allocations were not equitable, to make a recommendation of how Measure B funds should be allocated equitably.
- Requires the reports submitted pursuant to this bill to be submitted in compliance with provisions of law governing reports to the Legislature.
- Requires the County of Los Angeles, in an effort to facilitate the duties of the Commission and to ensure further and ongoing transparency, to post in a clear and accessible location on the County’s Internet Web site, both of the following:
- On or before June 1, 2019, the total allocation of Measure B funds to each trauma center receiving those funds;
- On or before June 1, 2020, and by each June 1 thereafter, the allocation of Measure B funds to each trauma center receiving those funds in the prior year.
FISCAL EFFECT:
This bill has not been analyzed by a fiscal committee.
COMMENTS:
- Author’s statement. According to the author, in 2002 residents of LA County passed Measure B; a special use tax of three cents per square foot on property improvements to rescue LA County’s failing trauma network. In good faith, the people of LA County entrusted the Board to exert its discretion on the use of these funds in such a way that they would serve the entire region most effectively by increasing and improving trauma service countywide. Unfortunately, the Board has failed to carry out this task. The county collects $250 million annually from the tax. On average, over 76% of those funds are distributed to just three hospitals, none of which are located in areas designated, by the County’s own standards, as underserved. Further, these three beneficiaries are the only three hospitals operated by the County itself, with the 12 non-county operated trauma centers sharing just 15% of the funds. A 2014 report from the State Auditor uncovered a host of problems with the administration of the funds. The report offered a list of six recommendations to the LA County Board in order to remedy these issues, including a recommendation for a Measure B oversight commission which this bill would create.
- Background on trauma centers. Trauma is defined as a potentially severe physical injury caused by an external source (fall, auto crash, farm or industrial accident, knife or gunshot wound, etc.) that requires emergency medical intervention to prevent loss of life or limb or substantial, permanent physical impairment. It does not include moderate or minor injuries; heart attacks, strokes, or other internal conditions; chronic, contagious or infectious diseases; or mental illness not caused by a severe physical injury. Trauma is the primary cause of death for people ages 1 to 44, regardless of gender, race, or economic status. Literature indicates that survival of trauma patients is greatly increased if they are brought to definitive surgical intervention within what has become known as “The Golden Hour” – the one hour time period from injury to specialized trauma care.
While an emergency department is responsible for providing medical and surgical care to patients arriving at the hospital in need of immediate care, trauma centers maintain a higher level of service. EMSA provides statewide coordination and leadership trauma systems statewide, including development of trauma care system regulations, while LEMSAs are responsible for managing local trauma care systems, including designating trauma centers, and collecting trauma care data.
Trauma centers are designated according to levels (Level I is the highest, Level IV is the lowest, although all of California’s trauma centers are at least Level III). There are also pediatric specific trauma centers, either Level I or Level II. Some hospitals are designated as both a regular trauma center, and a pediatric trauma center. Level I and Level II are similar, with the primary difference being that Level I facilities are also teaching hospitals. Level III and IV trauma centers generally only provide initial stabilization, though Level III has greater surgical capabilities than Level IV. - LA County trauma system. LA County’s trauma system began operating in 1983 with an initial eight designated trauma centers. By 1985, the system peaked with 22 designated trauma centers, but by 1990, ten withdrew, often citing unacceptable levels of uncompensated care for trauma patients. The three areas of LA County that have been considered underserved in the trauma system are the Malibu area, which does not have a trauma center within its geographic boundary; the Antelope Valley in northeastern LA County, which is a large geographic area served by a single trauma center; and until very recently, the eastern San Gabriel Valley. However, LA County’s newest designated trauma center, Pomona Valley Hospital Medical Center, began receiving trauma patients from the San Gabriel Valley on March 1, 2017. LA County contributed $4.5 million in Measure B funds in 2015 to help cover start-up costs of what ended up being more than $100 million in capital expenses to bring the facility up to the standards of a Level II trauma center.
- Background on Measure B. In 2002, LA County’s Department of Health Services was facing a significant budget deficit, which was threatening their trauma system. To address this, the Board submitted a parcel tax measure to the voters in November of 2002, which was approved by 73% of voters. The initial parcel tax was $.03 per square foot on all structural improvements, although the Board has voted to increase the tax rate three times, most recently to $.0424 in 2012. The ballot language that voters saw was as follows:
PRESERVATION OF TRAUMA CENTERS AND EMERGENCY MEDICAL SERVICES; BIOTERRORISM RESPONSE. To avoid the life-threatening shutdown of Los Angeles County’s trauma network, maintain and expand the trauma network countywide, ensure more timely response to critical and urgent medical emergencies and respond effectively to biological or chemical terrorism, shall all property owners pay an annual tax of three cents per square foot of improvements (buildings) on developed property?
The resolution that the Board voted on to place the measure on the ballot governs the collection and expenditure of funds that Measure B brings in more than $250 million in revenue annually. The Measure B resolution requires the Board to set the tax rate by a majority vote, and permits the tax rate to be adjusted from the initial $.03 based on the medical component of the Consumer Price Index. The Measure B resolution specified the purposes for which Measure B funds may be spent, including paying for trauma centers, EMS, bioterrorism response, and defraying administrative expenses such as salaries and benefits for personnel in the LA County Department of Health Services. However, the Measure B resolution did not specify an allocation methodology. Instead, an initial Board-created oversight committee that was formed following the passage of Measure B recommended distributing most of the funds to pay for uncompensated trauma and emergency care at county hospitals, and for uncompensated trauma care at non-county hospitals. This oversight committee disbanded shortly after making this recommendation.
On the following page is a chart showing the allocation of Measure B funds in 2011/12, and table showing the reimbursements that each hospital with a trauma center received from 2008/09 to 2011/12. These are copied from the State Auditor report that is described in comment 5).
- State Auditor report. In January of 2014, the State Auditor released a report on LA County’s management of Measure B funds (report), concluding that without a comprehensive assessment of its trauma system, LA County cannot demonstrate that it has used Measure B funds to address the most pressing trauma needs and has fulfilled the intent of the measure by expanding trauma services countywide. According to this report, more than a decade after voters approved Measure B, existing trauma centers remain far removed from certain areas with LA County despite Measure B’s stated intent. (As noted above, since this report was published, a trauma center was designated in the San Gabriel Valley, which is one of the areas called out by the State Auditor as an example of the lack of expansion by Measure B.) The report argues that while the LA County LEMSA, in conjunction with the American College of Surgeons, conducts periodic performance evaluations of individual trauma centers, a comprehensive evaluation is needed to determine whether the trauma system LA County has developed is adequately meeting the needs of all geographic areas and populations in the county. Additionally, the report notes that the Board has not revisited its approach to allocating Measure B funds, hindering its ability to demonstrate to taxpayers that it distributes funds to address the most pressing trauma care needs. According to the report, while the Board initially allocated $2.4 million in 2003 to fund helicopter services as an interim solution to locating trauma centers in underserved areas, this amount has grown over time and that it appears that this has become a permanent solution to providing trauma care access to underserved areas. The report argues that the data collected related to helicopter transports does not contain enough information to evaluate the effectiveness of helicopter services. In addition to recommending that the Board engage the American College of Surgeons to perform a comprehensive assessment, the report recommends reinstating a Measure B oversight committee, and collecting better data relating to helicopter transport.
In its response to the report, the Board stated that it disagrees with many of the assertions contained in the report. In particular, the Board states that it has and continues to regularly assess and evaluate its trauma and emergency care system, which has led to the development of a number of significant improvements to enhance trauma and emergency care. The Board states it is not the case that allocation of Measure B funds has not changed, and states that funds are provided to offset uncompensated care and rates have been revised to meet the needs of the trauma hospitals. According to the Board, Measure B funding has been allocated to account for changes in the trauma network, such as the addition of California Hospital and Antelope Valley Medical Center as new trauma hospitals, and the extra burden of uncompensated care taken on by St. Francis Medical Center when LA County’s Martin Luther King, Jr. Medical Center lost its trauma center designation. - Double referral. This bill is double-referred. Should it pass out of this committee, it will be referred to the Senate Governance and Finance Committee.
- Prior legislation. AB 1357 (Hernandez of 2013) would have required Measure B funds that were collected from properties within the San Gabriel Valley (SGV) to remain within that geographic region of LA County. Would have required the funds to be used for the purposes intended by the voter initiative, within that geographic area, to reduce ambulance diversion. Would have established a task force consisting of EMSA, DPH, the California State Auditor, and a representative of a local hospital task force to be selected by the other members, and required the task force to study and audit the funds collected from properties in SGV since the passage of the local voter initiative to gain an understanding as to how the moneys have been allocated and to gauge what improvements, if any, have been made. AB 1357 was referred to but did not have a hearing in Assembly Health Committee.
AB 1975 (Hernandez of 2014) would have required LEMSAs to contract with the American College of Surgeons every five years to conduct a comprehensive assessment of their regional trauma system. AB 1975 was held on suspense in Assembly Appropriations Committee. - Support. The California Chapter of the American College of Emergency Physicians (California ACEP) states in support that not all of LA County’s trauma centers have received their fair share of Measure B funding. California ACEP supports this bill because it will provide much needed accountability of Measure B funds, including an accounting of fund allocations, criteria LA County uses to allocate those funds, and causes for disparities in funding. California ACEP states that Measure B was intended to expand the trauma system in LA County, and this bill will ensure it is living up to its promise. Antelope Valley Community Clinic states in support that it strongly supports that it works closely with Antelope Valley Hospital, and supports legislation that will help support the trauma unit. The Palmdale Chamber of Commerce states in support that the Antelope Valley Hospital has been shortchanged, and this bill will help ensure Measure B funds will be distributed with greater fairness and transparency to the benefit of Antelope Valley residents, and all residents served by underfunded trauma hospitals in LA County.
- Opposition. The Board opposes this bill, stating that since the passage of Measure B, the Board has approved the expansion of LA County’s trauma system by adding California Hospital, Antelope Valley Hospital, and most recently Pomona Valley Medical Center. The Board states that it has also allocated Measure B funds among the non-County trauma hospitals in proportion to the value of trauma-related care for uninsured patients and to reimburse trauma hospitals for costs associated with serving as a base hospital in LA County’s EMS system. The Board states that this bill is unnecessary because LA County continues to work with non-County hospitals to develop a new allocation method for Measure B funds. Further, the Board states that LA County’s Trauma Hospital Advisory Committee, which includes representatives from the American College of Surgeons and the EMS Commission, routinely monitors the use of Measure B funds and makes recommendations regarding deficiencies and improvements to the Board. The Board states that this bill would remove local control over Measure B funds from LA County by requiring the Commission’s report to the Legislature to make a recommendation based on the “equitable allocation” across LA County’s trauma network. The Board asserts that there is no such restriction in Measure B, and that this bill would set a bad precedent by allowing an outside Commission and the State to control or to participate in the distribution of not only Measure B funds, but potentially any and all locally-approved taxes and revenues. The Board states that Measure B is a locally-approved measure, and therefore oversight of those locally-derived dollars should be retained at the local level.
- Policy comment. This bill requires the Commission to submit reports to the Legislature. However, given that this is a local tax that is controlled by LA County, it may be more appropriate to require the Commission to report to the Board, and require the Board to publish these reports on its web site.
SUPPORT AND OPPOSITION:
Support: Antelope Valley Community Clinic
Antelope Valley Hospital
California Chapter of the American College of Emergency Physicians
City of Palmdale
Palmdale Chamber of Commerce
Oppose: Los Angeles County Board of Supervisors
-- END --
Discussed in Hearing
Assembly Standing Committee on Appropriations
Assembly Standing Committee on Local Government
Senate Floor
Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations
Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations
Senate Standing Committee on Governance and Finance
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):