SB 897: Residential property insurance: wildfires.
- Session Year: 2017-2018
- House: Senate
- Latest Version Date: 2018-05-01
Existing law defines the measure of indemnity for a loss under a property insurance policy. Existing law requires an insurer, in the event of a loss under a residential insurance policy for which the insured has made a claim for additional living expenses, to provide the insured with a list of items that the insurer believes may be covered under the policy as additional living expenses. Additionally, existing law provides that, in the case of a loss related to a declared state of emergency, an insurer provide coverage for living expenses for a period of 24 months, subject to the limitations of the policy.
This bill would specify that additional living expense coverage shall include all reasonable expenses incurred by the insured in order to maintain a comparable standard of living and would provide a list of expenses that shall be covered. The bill would also authorize an insured to collect, in lieu of additional living expenses, the fair rental value, as defined, of the dwelling that has suffered a loss.
This bill would require, for losses related to a declared state of emergency, that the insurer provide an advance payment for living expenses and an advance payment for contents, the insurer to accept an inventory of contents in any reasonable form permit the grouping of certain items in an inventory of contents, and offer a payment of no less than 80% of the policy limit for contents without an itemized claim.
This bill would require an insurer to offer a 30-day grace period period, as specified, for payments of premiums for policies on property located within a declared state of emergency for a period of 30 days after the declaration of the emergency and would prohibit an insurer from canceling a policy for nonpayment or assessing a late fee during the grace period. emergency.
This bill would apply specified provisions retroactively to any applicable claim filed certain claims for losses incurred on or after July 1, 2017.
Existing law defines the measure of indemnity for a loss under a property insurance policy. Existing law requires an insurer, in the event of a loss under a residential insurance policy for which the insured has made a claim for additional living expenses, to provide the insured with a list of items that the insurer believes may be covered under the policy as additional living expenses. Additionally, existing law provides that, in the case of a loss related to a declared state of emergency, an insurer provide coverage for living expenses for a period of 24 months, subject to the limitations of the policy.
This bill would specify that additional living expense coverage shall include all reasonable expenses incurred by the insured in order to maintain a comparable standard of living and would provide a list of expenses that shall be covered. The bill would also authorize an insured to collect, in lieu of additional living expenses, the fair rental value, as defined, of the dwelling that has suffered a loss.
This bill would require, for losses related to a declared state of emergency, that the insurer provide an advance payment for living expenses and an advance payment for contents, the insurer to accept an inventory of contents in any reasonable form permit the grouping of certain items in an inventory of contents, and offer a settlement for payment of no less than 80% of the policy limit for contents in lieu of without an itemized claim.
This bill would require an insurer to offer a 30-day grace period for payments of premiums for policies on property located within a declared state of emergency for a period of 30 days after the declaration of the emergency and would prohibit an insurer from canceling a policy for nonpayment or assessing a late fee during the grace period.
This bill would apply specified provisions retroactively to any applicable claim filed on or after July 1, 2017.
Existing law defines the measure of indemnity for a loss under a property insurance policy. Existing law requires an insurer, in the event of a loss under a residential insurance policy for which the insured has made a claim for additional living expenses, to provide the insured with a list of items that the insurer believes may be covered under the policy as additional living expenses. Additionally, existing law provides that, in the case of a loss related to a declared state of emergency, an insurer provide coverage for living expenses for a period of 24 months, subject to the limitations of the policy.
This bill would specify that additional living expense coverage shall include all reasonable expenses incurred by the insured in order to maintain a comparable standard of living and would provide a list of expenses that shall be covered. The bill would also authorize an insured to collect, in lieu of additional living expenses, the fair rental value, as defined, of the dwelling that has suffered a loss.
This bill would require, for losses related to a declared state of emergency, that the insurer provide an advance payment for living expenses and an advance payment for contents, the insurer to accept an inventory of contents in any reasonable form permit the grouping of certain items in an inventory of contents, and offer a settlement for no less than 80% of the policy limit for contents in lieu of an itemized claim.
This bill would require an insurer to offer a 30-day grace period for payments of premiums for policies on property located within a declared state of emergency for a period of 30 days after the declaration of the emergency and would prohibit an insurer from canceling a policy for nonpayment or assessing a late fee during the grace period.
This bill would apply specified provisions retroactively to any applicable claim filed on or after July 1, 2017.
(a)In the event of a loss, as described in Section 675, under a residential property insurance policy, as defined in Section 10087, for which the insured has made a claim for additional living expenses, the insurer shall provide the insured with a list, in writing, of items that the insurer believes may be covered under the policy as additional living expenses. The list may include a statement that the list is not intended to include all items covered under the policy, but only those that are commonly claimed, if this is the case. If the department develops a list for use by insurers, the insurer may use that list.
(b)Additional living expense coverage under a residential property insurance policy shall include reimbursement for all reasonable additional expenses incurred by the insured in order to maintain a comparable standard of living following a covered loss. These additional costs shall include, but not be limited to, housing, furniture rental, food, transportation, storage, and boarding of pets and livestock. pets.
(c)Under a residential property insurance policy for which the insured has made a claim for additional living expenses, the insured may, at his or her option and in lieu of itemized expenses, choose to collect the monthly fair rental value of the dwelling for the duration of the time it is not inhabitable due to the covered loss, up to the limits of the policy. For purposes of this section, the fair rental value is the amount the insured dwelling could have demanded for rental in furnished condition at the time the claim is filed.SEC. 2.Section 2061 is added to the Insurance Code, to read:2061.In the event of a covered loss relating to a state of emergency, as defined in Section 8558 of the Government Code, the following special provisions shall apply:
(a)If an insured has made a claim for living expenses related to a total loss, an insurer shall, upon request by an insured, render an advance payment of no less than four months of living expenses or fair rental value. Insurers shall adopt a standard four-month additional living expense or fair rental payment amount. expenses. Additional payment for additional living expenses or fair rental value shall be payable upon proper proof following the advance period.
(b)If an insured has made a claim for contents related to a total loss of a primary residence, an insurer shall render an initial advance payment of no less than 25 percent of the policy limit for contents without the completion of an inventory. Additional payment for contents shall be payable upon request with proper proof.
(c)If an insured has made a claim for contents related to a total loss of a primary residence, an insurer shall not require that the insured use a company-specific inventory form if the insured can provide an inventory using a form that contains substantially the same information. Nothing in this subdivision limits the authority of an insurer to seek additional information from an insured upon receipt of an inventory form submitted by an insured.
(d)If an insured has made a claim for contents related to a total loss of a primary residence, an insurer shall accept an inventory that includes groupings of categories of personal property, including, but not limited to, clothing, shoes, books, food items, CDs, DVDs, or other categories of items for which it would be impractical to separately list each individual item claimed.
(e)If an insured has made a claim for contents related to a total loss of a primary residence, the insurer shall offer no less than 80 percent of the policy limit for contents without requiring the insured to file an itemized claim. The insurer shall notify the insured that the insured retains the option to recover additional benefits if the insured subsequently completes a full inventory.
SEC. 3.Section 2062 is added to the Insurance Code, to read:2062.In the event of a state of emergency, as defined in Section 8558 of the Government Code, an insurer shall grant a 30-day grace period for payment of premiums for residential property insurance policies covering a property located within the affected area defined in the state of emergency for a period of 30 days after the emergency. During the grace period, a policy may not be canceled for nonpayment of a premium and a late fee shall not be assessed. This section does not require any change to insurer billing practices regarding billing, automatic payment, or cancellation for nonpayment if the insurer reinstates, without a lapse in coverage or late fees, any policy subject to this section that was canceled for nonpayment of premiums, if requested by the insured and upon reasonably timely payment of all premiums due.
SEC. 4.The provisions of this bill are severable. If any provision of this bill or its application is held invalid, that invalidity shall not affect other provisions or applications that can be given effect without the invalid provision or application.
SEC. 5.Subdivisions (c), (d), and (e) of Section 2061 of the Insurance Code as added by Section 2 of this bill, and the amendatory provisions of Section 1 of this bill, act shall be applied retroactively to any applicable claim filed claim for contents related to a loss incurred on or after July 1, 2017. 2017, and which has not been submitted as of January 1, 2019.
(a)In the event of a loss loss, as described in Section 675, under a residential property insurance policy policy, as defined in Section 10087, for which the insured has made a claim for additional living expenses, the insurer shall provide the insured with a list, in writing, of items that the insurer believes may be covered under the policy as additional living expenses. The list may include a statement that the list is not intended to include all items covered under the policy, but only those that are commonly claimed, if this is the case. If the department develops a list for use by insurers, the insurer may use that list.
(b)Additional living expense coverage under a residential property insurance policy shall include reimbursement for all reasonable additional expenses incurred by the insured in order to maintain a comparable standard of living following a covered loss. These additional costs shall include, but not be limited to, housing, furniture rental, food, transportation, storage, and boarding of pets and livestock.
(c)Under a residential property insurance policy for which the insured has made a claim for additional living expenses, the insured may, at his or her option and in lieu of itemized expenses, choose to collect the monthly fair rental value of the dwelling for the duration of the time it is not inhabitable due to the covered loss, up to the limits of the policy. For purposes of this section, the fair rental value is the amount the insured dwelling could have demanded for rental in furnished condition at the time the claim is filed.
SEC. 2.Section 2061 is added to the Insurance Code, to read:2061.In the event of a covered loss relating to a state of emergency, as defined in Section 8558 of the Government Code, the following special provisions shall apply:
(a)If an insured has made a claim for living expenses related to a total loss, an insurer shall, upon request by an insured, render an advance payment of no less than four months of living expenses or fair rental value. Insurers shall adopt a standard four-month additional living expense or fair rental payment amount. Additional payment for additional living expenses or fair rental value shall be payable upon proper proof following the advance period.
(b)If an insured has made a claim for contents related to a total loss of a primary residence, an insurer shall render an initial advance payment of no less than 25 percent of the policy limit for contents without the completion of an inventory. Additional payment for contents shall be payable upon request with proper proof.
(c)If an insured has made a claim for contents related to a total loss of a primary residence, an insurer shall not require that the insured use a company-specific inventory form if the insured can provide an inventory using a form that contains substantially the same information. Nothing in this subdivision limits the authority of an insurer to seek additional information from an insured upon receipt of an inventory form submitted by an insured.
(d)If an insured has made a claim for contents related to a total loss of a primary residence, an insurer shall accept an inventory that includes groupings of categories of personal property, including, but not limited to, clothing, shoes, books, food items, CDs, DVDs, or other categories of items for which it would be impractical to separately list each individual item claimed.
(e)If an insured has made a claim for contents related to a total loss of a primary residence, the insurer shall, upon the request of the insured, offer a settlement for shall offer no less than 80 percent of the policy limit for contents in lieu of without requiring the insured to file an itemized claim. A settlement made pursuant to this subdivision shall release the insurer from any further indemnity for loss of contents related to the claim. The insurer shall notify the insured that the insured retains the option to recover additional benefits if the insured subsequently completes a full inventory.
SEC. 3.Section 2062 is added to the Insurance Code, to read:2062.In the event of a state of emergency, as defined in Section 8558 of the Government Code, an insurer shall grant a 30-day grace period for payment of premiums for residential property insurance policies covering a property located within the affected area defined in the state of emergency for a period of 30 days after the emergency. During the grace period, a policy may not be canceled for nonpayment of a premium and a late fee shall not be assessed.
SEC. 4.The provisions of this bill are severable. If any provision of this bill or its application is held invalid, that invalidity shall not affect other provisions or applications that can be given effect without the invalid provision or application.
SEC. 5.Section 2 of this bill, and the amendatory provisions of Section 1 of this bill, shall be applied retroactively to any applicable claim filed on or after July 1, 2017.
(a)In the event of a loss under a homeowners residential property insurance policy for which the insured has made a claim for additional living expenses, the insurer shall provide the insured with a list list, in writing, of items that the insurer believes may be covered under the policy as additional living expenses. The list may include a statement that the list is not intended to include all items covered under the policy, but only those that are commonly claimed, if this is the case. If the department develops a list for use by insurers, the insurer may use that list.
(b)Additional living expense coverage under a residential property insurance policy shall include reimbursement for all reasonable additional expenses incurred by the insured in order to maintain a comparable standard of living following a covered loss. These additional costs shall include, but not be limited to, housing, furniture rental, food, transportation, storage, and boarding of pets and livestock.
(c)Under a residential property insurance policy for which the insured has made a claim for additional living expenses, the insured may, at his or her option and in lieu of itemized expenses, choose to collect the monthly fair rental value of the dwelling for the duration of the time it is not inhabitable due to the covered loss, up to the limits of the policy. For purposes of this section, the fair rental value is the amount the insured dwelling could have demanded for rental in furnished condition at the time the claim is filed.
SEC. 2.Section 2061 is added to the Insurance Code, to read:2061.In the event of a covered loss relating to a state of emergency, as defined in Section 8558 of the Government Code, the following special provisions shall apply:
(a)If an insured has made a claim for living expenses related to a total loss, an insurer shall, upon request by an insured, render an advance payment of no less than four months of living expenses or fair rental value. Insurers shall adopt a standard four-month additional living expense or fair rental payment amount. Additional payment for additional living expenses or fair rental value shall be payable upon proper proof following the advance period.
(b)If an insured has made a claim related to a total loss of a primary residence, an insurer shall render an advance payment of no less than 25 percent of the policy limit for contents without the completion of an inventory. Additional payment for contents shall be payable upon request with proper proof.
(c)If an insured has made a claim for contents related to a total loss of a primary residence, an insurer shall not require that the insured use a company-specific inventory form if the insured can provide an inventory using a form that contains substantially the same information. Nothing in this subdivision limits the authority of an insurer to seek additional information from an insured upon receipt of an inventory form submitted by an insured.
(d)If an insured has made a claim for contents related to a total loss of a primary residence, an insurer shall accept an inventory that includes groupings of categories of personal property, including, but not limited to, clothing, shoes, books, food items, CDs, DVDs, or other categories of items for which it would be impractical to separately list each individual item claimed.
(e)If an insured has made a claim related to a total loss of a primary residence, the insurer shall, upon the request of the insured, offer a settlement for no less than 80 percent of the policy limit for contents in lieu of requiring the insured to file an itemized claim. A settlement made pursuant to this subdivision shall release the insurer from any further indemnity for loss of contents related to the claim.
SEC. 3.Section 2062 is added to the Insurance Code, to read:2062.In the event of a state of emergency, as defined in Section 8558 of the Government Code, an insurer shall grant a 30-day grace period for payment of premiums for residential property insurance policies covering a property located within the affected area defined in the state of emergency for a period of 30 days after the emergency. During the grace period, a policy may not be canceled for nonpayment of a premium and a late fee shall not be assessed.
SEC. 4.The provisions of this bill are severable. If any provision of this bill or its application is held invalid, that invalidity shall not affect other provisions or applications that can be given effect without the invalid provision or application.
SEC. 5.Section 2 of this bill, and the amendatory provisions of Section 1 of this bill, shall be applied retroactively to any applicable claim filed on or after July 1, 2017.
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| May 31, 2018 | Ordered to inactive file on request of Senator McGuire. |
| May 1, 2018 | Read second time and amended. Ordered to third reading. |
| Apr 30, 2018 | From committee: Do pass as amended. (Ayes 8. Noes 0.) (April 25). |
| Mar 23, 2018 | Set for hearing April 25. |
| Mar 15, 2018 | Re-referred to Com. on INS. |
| Mar 15, 2018 | Withdrawn from committee. |
| Feb 28, 2018 | From committee with author's amendments. Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on I., B. & F.I. |
| Jan 24, 2018 | Referred to Com. on I., B. & F.I. |
| Jan 16, 2018 | From printer. May be acted upon on or after February 15. |
| Jan 12, 2018 | Introduced. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Apr 25, 2018 | Do pass as amended | Senate Standing Committee on Insurance |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | SB |
THIRD READING
Bill No: SB 897
: 5
SENATE INSURANCE COMMITTEE: 8-0, 4/25/18
AYES: Glazer, Galgiani, Hernandez, Hueso, Lara, Mitchell, Portantino, Roth
NO VOTE RECORDED: Gaines, Berryhill, Moorlach, Morrell, Newman
SOURCE: California Department of Insurance
DIGEST:
This bill (1) requires additional living expense coverage (ALE) to include all reasonable expenses incurred by the insured to maintain a comparable standard of living following a covered loss; (2) requires, in the case of a total loss that is a result of a state of emergency, an insurer to provide an advance payment of no less than four months of ALE or fair rental value, to make an initial advance payment of no less than 25% of the policy limit for a claim for contents related to a total loss of a primary residence without completion of an inventory, to offer no less than 80% of the policy limits for contents without requiring the insured to file an itemized claim, and prohibits an insurer in the case of a claim for contents from requiring the use of a company-specific inventory form, as specified; (3) requires insurers, in the event of a state of emergency, to grant a 30-day grace period for payment of premiums for all homeowners’ policies covering properties within the affected area; and (4) makes specified provisions retroactive for any claim filed after July 1, 2017 but not submitted by January 1, 2019.
Existing law:
- Requires an insurer, if there has been a claim of loss under a homeowners’ insurance policy and the insured has made a claim for ALE, to provide the insured with a list of items the insurer believes may be covered as ALE under the policy, as specified.
- Provides that in the event of a covered loss relating to a state of emergency, as defined, coverage for ALE shall be for a period of 24 months, subject to other policy provisions, including policy limits.
- Establishes a standard form fire policy including requirements in case a loss occurs, and specifies the insured shall furnish a complete inventory of the destroyed, damaged and undamaged property, showing in detail quantities, costs, actual cash value and amount of loss claimed.
This bill:
- Requires ALE to include all reasonable expenses incurred by the insured to maintain a comparable standard of living following a covered loss, including but not limited to housing, furniture rental, food, transportation, storage and boarding of pets.
- Applies the following in the case of a total loss that is a result of a state of emergency:
- Upon request of the insured, requires the insurer to provide an advance payment of no less than four months of ALE, with additional payments upon proper proof following the advance period.
- Requires an insurer to make an initial advance payment of no less than 25% of the policy limit for a claim for contents related to a total loss of a primary residence without completion of an inventory, and make additional payments upon request with proper proof.
- Prohibits an insurer in the case of a claim for contents from requiring the use of a company-specific inventory form if the insured can provide an inventory using a form that contains substantially the same information, and requires the insurer to accept an inventory that includes grouping of categories, as specified.
- Requires an insurer to offer no less than 80% of the policy limits if an insured has made a claim for contents without requiring the insured to file an itemized claim, and requires the insurer to notify the insured that they retain the option to recover additional benefits if the insured subsequently completes a full inventory.
- Requires insurers, in the event of a state of emergency, to grant a 30-day grace period for payment of premiums for all homeowners’ policies covering properties within the affected area, and prohibits the cancellation of policies for non-payment of premium or assessing of late fees during that period, as specified.
- Provides the provisions of the bill are severable.
- Provides that the requirements in subparagraphs 2 (c) and (d) above are to be applied retroactively to claims for contents related to a total loss after July 1, 2017 that have not been submitted as of January 1, 2019.
Background
In 2017, California experienced the largest and most destructive wildfire season in its history. Nearly 9,000 wildfires tore through the state, burning 1.2 million acres of land, destroying more than 10,800 structures—more than the previous nine years combined--and killing at least 46 people. The Tubbs Fire in Sonoma and Napa counties in October 2017 alone destroyed more than 5,000 homes and produced losses that are almost double those of the previous most costly fire in state history. Total insurance claims to date exceed $12 billion, and in Northern California alone insurance claims could exceed $9 billion.
Under a standard policy of homeowners’ insurance, ALE is required to be offered to insureds that are displaced as a result of damage that makes the home uninhabitable or a total loss, for up to 12 months while the home is being repaired or rebuilt. Following massive fires in 2003 that destroyed more than 3000 structures, legislation was enacted that extended ALE after a state of emergency to at least 24 months in recognition that reconstruction is difficult following large scale disasters that put pressure on all aspects of the process, from debris removal, to obtaining permits, to finding an available contractor and necessary materials. Insurers were also required to provide insureds with a list of items that it believes may be covered under the policy as ALE. Current standard practice provides that in order for the insured to collect ALE, they must incur the expenses and show receipts for each expenditure.
The standard form for fire insurance policies in California requires the insured to furnish a complete inventory of the destroyed, damaged and undamaged property, showing in detail quantities, costs, actual cash value and amount of loss claimed. After destructive wildfires, however, policyholders often find many of the things the insurance company needs to process their claim are missing or were destroyed in the fire, such as home inventories, receipts, bills of sale, and vehicle ownership papers. Preparing such an inventory often requires many hours or days for already emotionally distraught homeowners who have just lost everything. Providing an inventory of all of the contents of a home would be daunting in the best of circumstances, let alone providing valuation data and receipts of purchase.
Generally speaking, contents limits are set as a percentage of the primary dwelling coverage and do not necessarily reflect the actual contents of the home. The policy will cover up to that amount to the extent the homeowner can demonstrate they have a proven claim. Different insurers use different percentages for contents coverage. One may use 50% of the replacement cost of the primary dwelling, while another might use 75%. One homeowner might have expensive antiques and art while another has a sparsely furnished home with only basic furnishings.
The Insurance Commissioner (IC), on October 14, 2017, issued a notice to insurers asking them to agree to expedited claims handling procedures for wildfire damage claims in order to help fire victims recover more quickly. Those voluntary expedited procedures included a four month advance on ALE upon request of the insured, an advance payment of at least 25% of policy limits for contents after a total loss, a 30 day grace period for billing leniency, and a less burdensome itemization of contents in wildfire total losses, including grouping of items into categories. Most of the major homeowners’ insurers in the state agreed to the expedited processing for claimants, and some agreed to offer up to 75%-80% of contents coverage without requiring an inventory. According to the California Department of Insurance (CDI), a few companies offered 100% of contents coverage to their insureds who suffered a total loss. This bill would codify the IC’s voluntary expedited claims procedures for all insurers following a declaration of a state of emergency.
Despite its good intentions, the provisions of the bill regarding guaranteed payment of contents coverage may have unintended consequences on homeowners’ insurance policies statewide, including prompting insurers to reduce the contents coverage offered to homeowners, increasing its cost, or both.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: Fiscal Com.: Local:
California Department of Insurance (source)
California Professional Firefighters
California State Association of Counties
California State Association of Electrical Workers
City of Clearlake
City of Santa Rosa
Coalition of California Utility Employees
Consumer Attorneys of California
County of Lake Board of Supervisors
County of Mendocino Board of Supervisors
Legal Aid of Sonoma County
Mayors’ & Councilmembers’ Association of Sonoma County
Napa County Board of Supervisors
National Association of Consumer Advocates
North Bay Labor Council
Redwood Valley Municipal Advisory Council
Rural County Representatives of California
Sonoma County Board of Supervisors
United Policyholders
Working Families for Affordable Insurance
9 individuals affected by the fires
American Insurance Association
National Association of Mutual Insurance Companies
Pacific Association of Domestic Insurance Companies
Personal Insurance Federation of California
Property Casualty Insurers Association of America
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: The CDI has sponsored this bill to help alleviate the burden on as many wildfire survivors as possible. The IC argues that this bill simply codifies best practices that many insurers already have complied with as a result of his call on them to adopt a voluntary expedited claims process. The IC believes SB 897 creates a fair and reasonable compromise for homeowners by creating standards that would allow survivors to start rebuilding their lives and homes more quickly after a Governor-declared disaster.
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION: The leading insurance trade organizations in the state oppose SB 897 unless it is amended because in its current form it will negatively impact both price and coverage of insurance by mandating unnecessary
requirements that will jeopardize insurers’ flexibility to offer California
homeowners choice in coverages and increase premiums for all homeowners across the state.
5/2/18 15:11:05
**** END ****
SENATE COMMITTEE ON
Senator Steven Glazer, Chair
2017 - 2018 Regular
Bill No: Hearing Date: April 25, 2018
Author: | |||
Version: |
| ||
Urgency: | Fiscal: | ||
Consultant: | |||
Subject:
SUMMARY
Requires additional living expense coverage (ALE) to include all reasonable expenses incurred by the insured to maintain a comparable standard of living following a covered loss; Allows an insured to choose, at his or her option, to choose to collect the monthly fair rental value of the dwelling as ALE in lieu of itemized expenses; in the case of a total loss that is a result of a state of emergency, requires an insurer to provide an advance payment of no less than four months of ALE or fair rental value, to adopt a standard four month or fair rental payment amount, to make an initial advance payment of no less than 25% of the policy limit for a claim for contents related to a total loss of a primary residence without completion of an inventory, to offer no less than 80% of the policy limits if an insured has made a claim for contents without requiring the insured to file an itemized claim, and prohibits an insurer in the case of a claim for contents from requiring the use of a company-specific inventory form, as specified; requires insurers, in the event of a state of emergency, to grant a 30-day grace period for payment of premiums for all homeowners’ policies covering properties within the affected area; and makes specified provisions retroactive for any claim filed after July 1, 2017.
DIGEST
Existing law
- Requires an insurer, if there has been a claim of loss under a homeowners’ insurance policy and the insured has made a claim for ALE, to provide the insured with a list of items the insurer believes may be covered as ALE under the policy, as specified.
- Provides that in the event of a covered loss relating to a state of emergency, as defined, coverage for ALE shall be for a period of 24 months, subject to other policy provisions, including policy limits.
- Establishes a standard form fire policy including requirements in case a loss occurs, and specifies the insured shall furnish a complete inventory of the destroyed, damaged and undamaged property, showing in detail quantities, costs, actual cash value and amount of loss claimed.
This bill
- Requires ALE to include all reasonable expenses incurred by the insured to maintain a comparable standard of living following a covered loss, including but not limited to housing, furniture rental, food, transportation, storage and boarding of pets and livestock.
- Allows an insured to choose, at his or her option, to choose to collect the monthly fair rental value of the dwelling as ALE in lieu of itemized expenses, up to the policy limits.
- Requires the following to apply in the case of a total loss that is a result of a state of emergency:
- Upon request of the insured, the insurer to provide an advance payment of no less than four months of ALE or fair rental value, with additional payments upon proper proof following the advance period.
- Requires insurers to adopt a standard four month or fair rental payment amount.
- Requires an insurer to make an initial advance payment of no less than 25% of the policy limit for a claim for contents related to a total loss of a primary residence without completion of an inventory, and make additional payments upon request with proper proof.
- Prohibits an insurer in the case of a claim for contents from requiring the use of a company-specific inventory form if the insured can provide an inventory using a form that contains substantially the same information, and requires the insurer to accept an inventory that includes grouping of categories, as specified.
- Requires an insurer to offer no less than 80% of the policy limits if an insured has made a claim for contents without requiring the insured to file an itemized claim, and requires the insurer to notify the insured that they retain the option to recover additional benefits if the insured subsequently completes a full inventory.
- Requires insurers, in the event of a state of emergency, to grant a 30-day grace period for payment of premiums for all homeowners’ policies covering properties within the affected area, and prohibits the cancellation of policies for non-payment of premium or assessing of late fees during that period, as specified.
- Provides the provisions of the bill are severable.
- Makes the provisions regarding ALE in paragraphs 1, 2 and 3 above retroactive to any claim filed on or after July 1, 2017.
COMMENTS
- Purpose of the bill To create a fair and reasonable compromise for homeowners and renters by creating standards to expedite residential insurance claims after a Governor-declared disaster, allowing survivors to start rebuilding their lives and homes.
- Background In 2017, California experienced the largest and most destructive wildfire season in its history. Nearly 9,000 wildfires tore through the state, burning 1.2 million acres of land, destroying more than 10,800 structures—more than the previous nine years combined--and killing at least 46 people. The Tubbs Fire in Sonoma and Napa counties in October 2017 alone destroyed more than 5,000 homes and produced losses that are almost double those of the previous most costly fire in state history. Total insurance claims to date exceed $12 billion, and in Northern California alone insurance claims could exceed $9 billion.
Under a standard policy of homeowners’ insurance, ALE is required to be offered to insureds that are displaced as a result of damage that makes the home uninhabitable or a total loss, for up to 12 months while the home is being repaired or rebuilt. Following massive fires in 2003 that destroyed more than 3000 structures, legislation was enacted that extended ALE after a state of emergency to at least 24 months in recognition that reconstruction is difficult following large scale disasters that put pressure on all aspects of the process, from debris removal, to obtaining permits, to finding an available contractor and necessary materials. Insurers were also required to provide insureds with a list of items that it believes may be covered under the policy as ALE.
Current standard practice provides that in order for the insured to collect ALE, they must incur the expenses and show receipts for each expenditure. The policies of some, but not all insurers already offer the insured the option to not have to show receipt and instead collect the fair rental value of the home on a monthly basis. For example, if the insured’s home could rent in a furnished condition for $3,000 per month at the time of the claim, the insured could collect this amount instead of ALE (for the period of time the home is inhabitable) without having to show receipts. Proponents of the bill argue all policies should have this option.
By statute, the standard form for fire insurance policies in California requires the insured to furnish a complete inventory of the destroyed, damaged and undamaged property, showing in detail quantities, costs, actual cash value and amount of loss claimed. After destructive wildfires, however, policyholders often find many of the things the insurance company needs to process their claim are missing or were destroyed in the fire, such as home inventories, receipts, bills of sale, and vehicle ownership papers. Preparing such an inventory often requires many hours or days for already emotionally distraught homeowners who have just lost everything. Providing an inventory of all of the contents of a home would be daunting in the best of circumstances, let alone providing valuation data and receipts of purchase.
The Insurance Commissioner (IC), on October 14, 2017, issued a notice to insurers asking them to agree to expedited claims handling procedures for wildfire damage claims in order to help fire victims recover more quickly. Those voluntary expedited procedures included a four month advance on ALE upon request of the insured, an advance payment of at least 25% of policy limits for contents after a total loss, a 30 day grace period for billing leniency, and a less burdensome itemization of contents in wildfire total losses, including grouping of items into categories. Most of the major homeowners’ insurers in the state agreed to the expedited processing for claimants, and some agreed to offer up to 75%-80% of contents coverage without requiring an inventory. According to the California Department of Insurance (CDI), a few companies offered 100% of contents coverage to their insureds who suffered a total loss. On December 21, 2017, the IC sent another notice to insurers calling on them to provide up to 100% of contents coverage limits to victims of the wildfires without requiring claimants to complete a detailed inventory. This bill would codify the IC’s voluntary expedited claims procedures for all insurers following a declaration of a state of emergency.
- Support The CDI has sponsored this bill to help alleviate the burden on as many wildfire survivors as possible. The IC argues that this bill simply codifies best practices that many insurers already have complied with as a result of his call on them to adopt a voluntary expedited claims process. The IC believes SB 897 creates a fair and reasonable compromise for homeowners by creating standards that would allow survivors to start rebuilding their lives and homes more quickly after a Governor-declared disaster.
According to the California State Association of Counties, the post-disaster process can pose significant challenges to impacted residents, including finding temporary housing after a residence has been damaged or destroyed and the arduous process of making detailed insurance claims. Insurance companies often require paper work and documents from a claimant which in many cases could have been completely destroyed by wildfire or other major disaster. By allowing residents in Governor-declared disaster areas some relief and flexibility in complying with claim requirements, this bill creates a fair and reasonable process for homeowners and insurance companies.
United Policyholders supports SB 897 because it reflects the reality on the ground in hard-hit areas and acknowledges the plight of survivors. Most homeowners’ insurance policies are written in such a way that an insurance company can require the policyholder to prepare a detailed inventory in order make a payment for personal property/contents. However, this anti-fraud measure is really more suited for a routine burglary claim or kitchen fire, not a total loss due to wildfire.
According to a homeowner affected by the Tubbs Fire, losing a home is one of the worst life experiences a person can live through. The loss takes a significant emotional toll on a family. The massive amount of paperwork and unrelenting details that insurance companies require residents to go through for recouping their losses puts an unreasonable burden and hardship on disaster victims who must also deal with everything from finding a new place to live to keeping up with their jobs, bills and other living expenses.
- Opposition The leading insurance trade organizations in the state oppose SB 897 unless it is amended because in its current form it will negatively impact both price and coverage of insurance by mandating unnecessary requirements that will jeopardize insurers’ flexibility to offer California homeowners choice in coverages and increase premiums for all homeowners across the state.
- Questions
- The bill on page 3, line 12 requires insurers to adopt a standard for ALE or fair rental payment amount. How would an insurer do this? Is it a standard amount for all properties in the state of emergency area, including those not similarly situated? Is it intended to apply to each individual insured? Could this amount change if market conditions change as recovery progresses? The bill also requires the insurer to cover all living expenses for the insured to maintain a comparable standard of living, or at the insured’s option, collect the fair market rental value of the insured residence had it been intact at the time the claim is made. Doesn’t maintaining a comparable standard of living accomplish the same goal? How would the insured and insurer agree on the rental value of a home that has been destroyed in a market already disrupted by the destruction of hundreds or thousands of homes? The bill also requires the insurer to include the boarding of livestock in the calculation of reasonable ALE. Livestock, as opposed to pets, would generally be considered a commercial activity. Should livestock be included here as an ALE expense? What if you have a horse—would an insurer consider that a pet?
- This bill requires insurers to pay at least 80% of policy contents limits without completion of an itemized inventory by the insured. Generally speaking, contents limits are set as a percentage of the primary dwelling coverage and do not necessarily reflect the actual contents of the home. The policy will cover up to that amount to the extent the homeowner can demonstrate they have a proven claim. Different insurers use different percentages for contents coverage. One may use 50% of the replacement cost of the primary dwelling, while another might use 75%. One homeowner might have expensive antiques and art while another has a sparsely furnished home with only basic furnishings. Should the latter homeowner get a windfall without proof that they actually suffered such a loss? Will this drive up premiums for all homeowners or will insurers alternatively opt to lower coverage for contents? At the same time, completing a detailed inventory can be a traumatic requirement for homeowners who have lost their home and all of their possessions. Should the percentage for automatic payment without any inventory be lowered, leaving homeowners the ability to collect more with completion of an inventory? What is a fair number? What about in cases of true hardship, such as if the home’s residents have died or been incapacitated and are unable to complete an inventory?
- Insurers have asked for technical changes to the 30 day grace period and to limit the provision to only those who have had a total loss and been displaced from their homes rather than all households in the state of emergency area. Is it unreasonable for the 30-day grace period for payment to include all homes in the disaster area?
- Should the provisions regarding ALE and contents claims be applied retroactively? How would this affect claims that have already been settled between the insured and the insurer? By the time this bill takes effect, more than 15 months will have passed since the Tubbs fire in Napa and Sonoma and a year since the Thomas Fire was contained. Would the insurer now have to provide a list of items likely covered by ALE? If the insurer had not provided 40% of advance ALE initially, would it have to do so when the bill takes effect? What if they have already paid at least 40% of ALE? Would they now have to pay an additional 25% of contents as an advance if they have already made payments toward contents claims? If the homeowner has already submitted proof of contents claims that exceed the advance payment, how would this provision be applied? Would these requirements cause insurers to stop the voluntary expedited claims process and instead only do what is required by this bill? What if they were more generous with ALE or were waiving the contents itemization requirement altogether?
- Suggested Amendments
- On pages 2, line 19, DELETE “livestock.” On pages 2-3, DELETE subparagraph (c) lines 20-24 and lines 1-4 regarding fair rental value of the destroyed residence. On page 3 lines 12-13 DELETE “or fair rental value. Insurers shall adopt a standard four-month additional living expense or fair rental payment amount.”
- On page 3, line 17, DELET “initial”. On page 3, line 37, DELETE “80 percent” and ADD “50 percent of the policy limit for contents without requiring the insured to file an itemized claim. On page 4, line 3, ADD after “full inventory.” “If the insured resident of the dwelling has died or otherwise been incapacitated and is unable to complete an inventory of the dwelling, the insurer shall offer the legal representative of the insured no less than 80 percent of the policy limit without requiring an itemized claim. A settlement of the claim under this provision with the legal representative shall release the insurer from any further indemnity for loss of contents related to the policy.“
- On page 4, line 10 after “the emergency.” ADD: “ This section shall not be construed to require any change to insurer billing practices regarding billing, automatic payment or cancellation for nonpayment if the insurer reinstates, without a lapse in coverage or late fee, any policy subject to this section that was canceled for nonpayment of premium, if requested by the insured and upon reasonably timely payment of all premiums due.”
- Delete retroactivity for section 1, and section 2 subparagraphs (a) and (b). Qualify retroactivity for section 2 subparagraphs (c), (d) and (e) to only those claims that have not been submitted, settled or paid at the time the bill takes effect.
- Technical and conforming changes, as necessary.
- Prior and Related Legislation
SB 824 (Lara) Prohibits an insurer from canceling, refusing to renew, or including a surcharge or an increase in the premium of a homeowners’ insurance policy for one year from the date of a declaration of a state of emergency; requires an insurer that intends to reduce, within 12 months of a declared disaster, the total number of homeowners’ policies in the disaster area by 20% or more, to submit a plan to the IC, 60 days prior to implementing that action; and directs the CDI to conduct a data call on wild fire and fire loss experience from insurers writing homeowners’ insurance.
SB 894 (Dodd) Extends the mandatory one year renewal of a homeowners’ insurance policy after a total loss in a disaster to at least two years, requires the insurer to report to the IC if the policy is non-renewed after the second renewal, increases ALE coverage from at least 24 to at least 36 months following a state of emergency, allows insureds to combine the policy limits for dwelling, other structures, contents and ALE for any covered purposes, and makes these changes retroactive to July 1, 2017.
SB 917 (Jackson) Provides that if loss or damage results from a combination of perils, one of which is a landslide, coverage shall be provided if an insured peril is the efficient proximate cause of the loss or damage, and specifies it is declaratory of existing law.
AB 1722 (Aguiar-Curry) Extends the minimum time to rebuild or replace after a declared disaster from 24 to 36 months.
AB 1797 (Levine) Requires insurers to provide an annual estimate of replacement costs to the insured, and makes the insurer liable for any replacement cost in excess of policy value if it fails to do so.
AB 1799 (Levine) Requires an insurer to provide a full copy of an insurance policy upon request after a covered loss.
AB 1800 (Levine) Explicitly allows an insured to claim extended replacement coverage even if they rebuild at a different location.
AB 1875 (Wood) Requires a homeowners’ insurer to offer extended replacement cost coverage of at least 50% when issuing or renewing a policy, and disclose the premium for that coverage.
AB 1923 (Limon) Establishes a consolidated debris removal program following a declaration of a state of emergency, and requires insurers to participate in that program.
AB 2229 (Wood) Requires changes to the standard homeowners’ insurance form including requiring specific information on features of the insured property that may contribute to increased or decreased risk as compared to similar properties.
AB 2594 (Friedman) Revises the standard form policy and extends the period in which to bring suit from 12 to 24 months after inception of the loss if the loss was related to a state of emergency.
AB 3166 (Burke) Requires insurers who do not use brokers, upon non-renewal of a homeowners’ insurance policy, to inform the homeowners about other brokers who may be able to help them obtain insurance, surplus line brokers, and information about the FAIR Plan.
AB 2199 (Kehoe, Chap. 311 Stat. of 2004) Allowed an insured to be granted a time extension to of 24 month to rebuild, repair, or replace the insured property and allowed the insured to rebuild, repair, or replace the property at a location other than the original insured premises.
SB 2 (Speier, Chap. 447, Statutes of 2005) Required insurers to provide a list of items that could be covered by ALE and extended ALE to 24 months. Although the provision was deleted in the Assembly, the bill as passed by the Senate in 2005 proposed requiring that policy limits for personal property be paid at 85% of the policy limits without requiring an inventory in the event of a fire that causes a total loss of a primary residence after a state of emergency, as an offer of final settlement.
POSITIONS
Support
California Department of Insurance (Sponsor)
California Professional Firefighters
California State Association of Counties
California State Association of Electrical Workers
City of Clearlake
City of Santa Rosa
Coalition of California Utility Employees
Consumer Attorneys of California
County of Lake Board of Supervisors
County of Mendocino Board of Supervisors
Legal Aid of Sonoma County
Mayors’ & Councilmembers’ Association of Sonoma County
Napa County Board of Supervisors
National Association of Consumer Advocates
North Bay Labor Council
Redwood Valley Municipal Advisory Council
Rural County Representatives of California
Sonoma County Board of Supervisors
POSITIONS
Support
United Policyholders
Working Families for Affordable Insurance
9 individuals affected by the fires
Oppose Unless Amended
American Insurance Association
National Association of Mutual Insurance Companies
Pacific Association of Domestic Insurance Companies
Personal Insurance Federation of California
Property Casualty Insurers Association of America
-- END --
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):