AB 1963: Common interest developments: construction defects.
- Session Year: 2015-2016
- House: Assembly
- Latest Version Date: 2016-07-22
Existing law, the Davis-Stirling Common Interest Development Act, requires, until July 1, 2017, specified conditions to be met before an association may file a complaint for damages against a builder, developer, or general contractor of a common interest development based upon a claim for defects in the design or construction of the common interest development.
This bill would delete the inoperative and repeal dates and would, instead, make these provisions inoperative on July 1, 2024, and would repeal these provisions as of January 1, 2025, as specified.
Existing law, the Davis-Stirling Common Interest Development Act, requires, until July 1, 2017, specified conditions to be met before an association may file a complaint for damages against a builder, developer, or general contractor of a common interest development based upon a claim for defects in the design or construction of the common interest development.
This bill would delete the inoperative and repeal dates and would, instead, make these provisions inoperative on July 1, 2024, and would repeal these provisions as of January 1, 2025, as specified.
Existing law, the Davis-Stirling Common Interest Development Act, requires, until July 1, 2017, specified conditions to be met before an association may file a complaint for damages against a builder, developer, or general contractor of a common interest development based upon a claim for defects in the design or construction of the common interest development.
This bill would delete the inoperative and repeal dates of the above described requirement. and would, instead, make these provisions inoperative on July 1, 2024, and would repeal these provisions as of January 1, 2025, as specified.
Existing law, the Davis-Stirling Common Interest Development Act, requires, until July 1, 2017, specified conditions to be met before an association may file a complaint for damages against a builder, developer, or general contractor of a common interest development based upon a claim for defects in the design or construction of the common interest development.
This bill would delete the inoperative and repeal dates of the above described requirement.
(a)Before an association files a complaint for damages against a builder, developer, or general contractor (respondent) of a common interest development based upon a claim for defects in the design or construction of the common interest development, all of the requirements of this section shall be satisfied with respect to the builder, developer, or general contractor.
(b)The association shall serve upon the respondent a Notice of Commencement of Legal Proceedings. The notice shall be served by certified mail to the registered agent of the respondent, or if there is no registered agent, then to any officer of the respondent. If there are no current officers of the respondent, service shall be upon the person or entity otherwise authorized by law to receive service of process. Service upon the general contractor shall be sufficient to initiate the process set forth in this section with regard to any builder or developer, if the builder or developer is not amenable to service of process by the foregoing methods. This notice shall toll all applicable statutes of limitation and repose, whether contractual or statutory, by and against all potentially responsible parties, regardless of whether they were named in the notice, including claims for indemnity applicable to the claim for the period set forth in subdivision (c). The notice shall include all of the following:
(1)The name and location of the project.
(2)An initial list of defects sufficient to apprise the respondent of the general nature of the defects at issue.
(3)A description of the results of the defects, if known.
(4)A summary of the results of a survey or questionnaire distributed to homeowners to determine the nature and extent of defects, if a survey has been conducted or a questionnaire has been distributed.
(5)Either a summary of the results of testing conducted to determine the nature and extent of defects or the actual test results, if that testing has been conducted.
(c)Service of the notice shall commence a period, not to exceed 180 days, during which the association, the respondent, and all other participating parties shall try to resolve the dispute through the processes set forth in this section. This 180-day period may be extended for one additional period, not to exceed 180 days, only upon the mutual agreement of the association, the respondent, and any parties not deemed peripheral pursuant to paragraph (3) of subdivision (e). Any extensions beyond the first extension shall require the agreement of all participating parties. Unless extended, the dispute resolution process prescribed by this section shall be deemed completed. All extensions shall continue the tolling period described in subdivision (b).
(d)Within 25 days of the date the association serves the Notice of Commencement of Legal Proceedings, the respondent may request in writing to meet and confer with the board. Unless the respondent and the association otherwise agree, there shall be not more than one meeting, which shall take place no later than 10 days from the date of the respondents written request, at a mutually agreeable time and place. The meeting shall be subject to subdivision (a) of Section 4925 and subdivisions (a) and (b) of Section 4935. The discussions at the meeting are privileged communications and are not admissible in evidence in any civil action, unless the association and the respondent consent in writing to their admission.
(e)Upon receipt of the notice, the respondent shall, within 60 days, comply with the following:
(1)The respondent shall provide the association with access to, for inspection and copying of, all plans and specifications, subcontracts, and other construction files for the project that are reasonably calculated to lead to the discovery of admissible evidence regarding the defects claimed. The association shall provide the respondent with access to, for inspection and copying of, all files reasonably calculated to lead to the discovery of admissible evidence regarding the defects claimed, including all reserve studies, maintenance records and any survey questionnaires, or results of testing to determine the nature and extent of defects. To the extent any of the above documents are withheld based on privilege, a privilege log shall be prepared and submitted to all other parties. All other potentially responsible parties shall have the same rights as the respondent regarding the production of documents upon receipt of written notice of the claim, and shall produce all relevant documents within 60 days of receipt of the notice of the claim.
(2)The respondent shall provide written notice by certified mail to all subcontractors, design professionals, their insurers, and the insurers of any additional insured whose identities are known to the respondent or readily ascertainable by review of the project files or other similar sources and whose potential responsibility appears on the face of the notice. This notice to subcontractors, design professionals, and insurers shall include a copy of the Notice of Commencement of Legal Proceedings, and shall specify the date and manner by which the parties shall meet and confer to select a dispute resolution facilitator pursuant to paragraph (1) of subdivision (f), advise the recipient of its obligation to participate in the meet and confer or serve a written acknowledgment of receipt regarding this notice, advise the recipient that it will waive any challenge to selection of the dispute resolution facilitator if it elects not to participate in the meet and confer, advise the recipient that it may seek the assistance of an attorney, and advise the recipient that it should contact its insurer, if any. Any subcontractor or design professional, or insurer for that subcontractor, design professional, or additional insured, who receives written notice from the respondent regarding the meet and confer shall, prior to the meet and confer, serve on the respondent a written acknowledgment of receipt. That subcontractor or design professional shall, within 10 days of service of the written acknowledgment of receipt, provide to the association and the respondent a Statement of Insurance that includes both of the following:
(A)The names, addresses, and contact persons, if known, of all insurance carriers, whether primary or excess and regardless of whether a deductible or self-insured retention applies, whose policies were in effect from the commencement of construction of the subject project to the present and which potentially cover the subject claims.
(B)The applicable policy numbers for each policy of insurance provided.
(3)Any subcontractor or design professional, or insurer for that subcontractor, design professional, or additional insured, who so chooses, may, at any time, make a written request to the dispute resolution facilitator for designation as a peripheral party. That request shall be served contemporaneously on the association and the respondent. If no objection to that designation is received within 15 days, or upon rejection of that objection, the dispute resolution facilitator shall designate that subcontractor or design professional as a peripheral party, and shall thereafter seek to limit the attendance of that subcontractor or design professional only to those dispute resolution sessions deemed peripheral party sessions or to those sessions during which the dispute resolution facilitator believes settlement as to peripheral parties may be finalized. Nothing in this subdivision shall preclude a party who has been designated a peripheral party from being reclassified as a nonperipheral party, nor shall this subdivision preclude a party designated as a nonperipheral party from being reclassified as a peripheral party after notice to all parties and an opportunity to object. For purposes of this subdivision, a peripheral party is a party having total claimed exposure of less than twenty-five thousand dollars ($25,000).
(f)(1)Within 20 days of sending the notice set forth in paragraph (2) of subdivision (e), the association, respondent, subcontractors, design professionals, and their insurers who have been sent a notice as described in paragraph (2) of subdivision (e) shall meet and confer in an effort to select a dispute resolution facilitator to preside over the mandatory dispute resolution process prescribed by this section. Any subcontractor or design professional who has been given timely notice of this meeting but who does not participate, waives any challenge he or she may have as to the selection of the dispute resolution facilitator. The role of the dispute resolution facilitator is to attempt to resolve the conflict in a fair manner. The dispute resolution facilitator shall be sufficiently knowledgeable in the subject matter and be able to devote sufficient time to the case. The dispute resolution facilitator shall not be required to reside in or have an office in the county in which the project is located. The dispute resolution facilitator and the participating parties shall agree to a date, time, and location to hold a case management meeting of all parties and the dispute resolution facilitator, to discuss the claims being asserted and the scheduling of events under this section. The case management meeting with the dispute resolution facilitator shall be held within 100 days of service of the Notice of Commencement of Legal Proceedings at a location in the county where the project is located. Written notice of the case management meeting with the dispute resolution facilitator shall be sent by the respondent to the association, subcontractors and design professionals, and their insurers who are known to the respondent to be on notice of the claim, no later than 10 days prior to the case management meeting, and shall specify its date, time, and location. The dispute resolution facilitator in consultation with the respondent shall maintain a contact list of the participating parties.
(2)No later than 10 days prior to the case management meeting, the dispute resolution facilitator shall disclose to the parties all matters that could cause a person aware of the facts to reasonably entertain a doubt that the proposed dispute resolution facilitator would be able to resolve the conflict in a fair manner. The facilitators disclosure shall include the existence of any ground specified in Section 170.1 of the Code of Civil Procedure for disqualification of a judge, any attorney-client relationship the facilitator has or had with any party or lawyer for a party to the dispute resolution process, and any professional or significant personal relationship the facilitator or his or her spouse or minor child living in the household has or had with any party to the dispute resolution process. The disclosure shall also be provided to any subsequently noticed subcontractor or design professional within 10 days of the notice.
(3)A dispute resolution facilitator shall be disqualified by the court if he or she fails to comply with this subdivision and any party to the dispute resolution process serves a notice of disqualification prior to the case management meeting. If the dispute resolution facilitator complies with this subdivision, he or she shall be disqualified by the court on the basis of the disclosure if any party to the dispute resolution process serves a notice of disqualification prior to the case management meeting.
(4)If the parties cannot mutually agree to a dispute resolution facilitator, then each party shall submit a list of three dispute resolution facilitators. Each party may then strike one nominee from the other parties list, and petition the court, pursuant to the procedure described in subdivisions (n) and (o), for final selection of the dispute resolution facilitator. The court may issue an order for final selection of the dispute resolution facilitator pursuant to this paragraph.
(5)Any subcontractor or design professional who receives notice of the associations claim without having previously received timely notice of the meet and confer to select the dispute resolution facilitator shall be notified by the respondent regarding the name, address, and telephone number of the dispute resolution facilitator. Any such subcontractor or design professional may serve upon the parties and the dispute resolution facilitator a written objection to the dispute resolution facilitator within 15 days of receiving notice of the claim. Within seven days after service of this objection, the subcontractor or design professional may petition the superior court to replace the dispute resolution facilitator. The court may replace the dispute resolution facilitator only upon a showing of good cause, liberally construed. Failure to satisfy the deadlines set forth in this subdivision shall constitute a waiver of the right to challenge the dispute resolution facilitator.
(6)The costs of the dispute resolution facilitator shall be apportioned in the following manner: one-third to be paid by the association; one-third to be paid by the respondent; and one-third to be paid by the subcontractors and design professionals, as allocated among them by the dispute resolution facilitator. The costs of the dispute resolution facilitator shall be recoverable by the prevailing party in any subsequent litigation pursuant to Section 1032 of the Code of Civil Procedure, provided however that any nonsettling party may, prior to the filing of the complaint, petition the facilitator to reallocate the costs of the dispute resolution facilitator as they apply to any nonsettling party. The determination of the dispute resolution facilitator with respect to the allocation of these costs shall be binding in any subsequent litigation. The dispute resolution facilitator shall take into account all relevant factors and equities between all parties in the dispute resolution process when reallocating costs.
(7)In the event the dispute resolution facilitator is replaced at any time, the case management statement created pursuant to subdivision (h) shall remain in full force and effect.
(8)The dispute resolution facilitator shall be empowered to enforce all provisions of this section.
(g)(1)No later than the case management meeting, the parties shall begin to generate a data compilation showing the following information regarding the alleged defects at issue:
(A)The scope of the work performed by each potentially responsible subcontractor.
(B)The tract or phase number in which each subcontractor provided goods or services, or both.
(C)The units, either by address, unit number, or lot number, at which each subcontractor provided goods or services, or both.
(2)This data compilation shall be updated as needed to reflect additional information. Each party attending the case management meeting, and any subsequent meeting pursuant to this section, shall provide all information available to that party relevant to this data compilation.
(h)At the case management meeting, the parties shall, with the assistance of the dispute resolution facilitator, reach agreement on a case management statement, which shall set forth all of the elements set forth in paragraphs (1) to (8), inclusive, except that the parties may dispense with one or more of these elements if they agree that it is appropriate to do so. The case management statement shall provide that the following elements shall take place in the following order:
(1)Establishment of a document depository, located in the county where the project is located, for deposit of documents, defect lists, demands, and other information provided for under this section. All documents exchanged by the parties and all documents created pursuant to this subdivision shall be deposited in the document depository, which shall be available to all parties throughout the prefiling dispute resolution process and in any subsequent litigation. When any document is deposited in the document depository, the party depositing the document shall provide written notice identifying the document to all other parties. The costs of maintaining the document depository shall be apportioned among the parties in the same manner as the costs of the dispute resolution facilitator.
(2)Provision of a more detailed list of defects by the association to the respondent after the association completes a visual inspection of the project. This list of defects shall provide sufficient detail for the respondent to ensure that all potentially responsible subcontractors and design professionals are provided with notice of the dispute resolution process. If not already completed prior to the case management meeting, the Notice of Commencement of Legal Proceedings shall be served by the respondent on all additional subcontractors and design professionals whose potential responsibility appears on the face of the more detailed list of defects within seven days of receipt of the more detailed list. The respondent shall serve a copy of the case management statement, including the name, address, and telephone number of the dispute resolution facilitator, to all the potentially responsible subcontractors and design professionals at the same time.
(3)Nonintrusive visual inspection of the project by the respondent, subcontractors, and design professionals.
(4)Invasive testing conducted by the association, if the association deems appropriate. All parties may observe and photograph any testing conducted by the association pursuant to this paragraph, but may not take samples or direct testing unless, by mutual agreement, costs of testing are shared by the parties.
(5)Provision by the association of a comprehensive demand which provides sufficient detail for the parties to engage in meaningful dispute resolution as contemplated under this section.
(6)Invasive testing conducted by the respondent, subcontractors, and design professionals, if they deem appropriate.
(7)Allowance for modification of the demand by the association if new issues arise during the testing conducted by the respondent, subcontractor, or design professionals.
(8)Facilitated dispute resolution of the claim, with all parties, including peripheral parties, as appropriate, and insurers, if any, present and having settlement authority. The dispute resolution facilitators shall endeavor to set specific times for the attendance of specific parties at dispute resolution sessions. If the dispute resolution facilitator does not set specific times for the attendance of parties at dispute resolution sessions, the dispute resolution facilitator shall permit those parties to participate in dispute resolution sessions by telephone.
(i)In addition to the foregoing elements of the case management statement described in subdivision (h), upon mutual agreement of the parties, the dispute resolution facilitator may include any or all of the following elements in a case management statement: the exchange of consultant or expert photographs; expert presentations; expert meetings; or any other mechanism deemed appropriate by the parties in the interest of resolving the dispute.
(j)The dispute resolution facilitator, with the guidance of the parties, shall at the time the case management statement is established, set deadlines for the occurrence of each event set forth in the case management statement, taking into account such factors as the size and complexity of the case, and the requirement of this section that this dispute resolution process not exceed 180 days absent agreement of the parties to an extension of time.
(k)(1)At a time to be determined by the dispute resolution facilitator, the respondent may submit to the association all of the following:
(A)A request to meet with the board to discuss a written settlement offer.
(B)A written settlement offer, and a concise explanation of the reasons for the terms of the offer.
(C)A statement that the respondent has access to sufficient funds to satisfy the conditions of the settlement offer.
(D)A summary of the results of testing conducted for the purposes of determining the nature and extent of defects, if this testing has been conducted, unless the association provided the respondent with actual test results.
(2)If the respondent does not timely submit the items required by this subdivision, the association shall be relieved of any further obligation to satisfy the requirements of this subdivision only.
(3)No less than 10 days after the respondent submits the items required by this paragraph, the respondent and the board shall meet and confer about the respondents settlement offer.
(4)If the board rejects a settlement offer presented at the meeting held pursuant to this subdivision, the board shall hold a meeting open to each member of the association. The meeting shall be held no less than 15 days before the association commences an action for damages against the respondent.
(5)No less than 15 days before this meeting is held, a written notice shall be sent to each member of the association specifying all of the following:
(A)That a meeting will take place to discuss problems that may lead to the filing of a civil action, and the time and place of this meeting.
(B)The options that are available to address the problems, including the filing of a civil action and a statement of the various alternatives that are reasonably foreseeable by the association to pay for those options and whether these payments are expected to be made from the use of reserve account funds or the imposition of regular or special assessments, or emergency assessment increases.
(C)The complete text of any written settlement offer, and a concise explanation of the specific reasons for the terms of the offer submitted to the board at the meeting held pursuant to subdivision (d) that was received from the respondent.
(6)The respondent shall pay all expenses attributable to sending the settlement offer to all members of the association. The respondent shall also pay the expense of holding the meeting, not to exceed three dollars ($3) per association member.
(7)The discussions at the meeting and the contents of the notice and the items required to be specified in the notice pursuant to paragraph (5) are privileged communications and are not admissible in evidence in any civil action, unless the association consents to their admission.
(8)No more than one request to meet and discuss a written settlement offer may be made by the respondent pursuant to this subdivision.
(l)All defect lists and demands, communications, negotiations, and settlement offers made in the course of the prelitigation dispute resolution process provided by this section shall be inadmissible pursuant to Sections 1119 to 1124, inclusive, of the Evidence Code and all applicable decisional law. This inadmissibility shall not be extended to any other documents or communications which would not otherwise be deemed inadmissible.
(m)Any subcontractor or design professional may, at any time, petition the dispute resolution facilitator to release that party from the dispute resolution process upon a showing that the subcontractor or design professional is not potentially responsible for the defect claims at issue. The petition shall be served contemporaneously on all other parties, who shall have 15 days from the date of service to object. If a subcontractor or design professional is released, and it later appears to the dispute resolution facilitator that it may be a responsible party in light of the current defect list or demand, the respondent shall renotice the party as provided by paragraph (2) of subdivision (e), provide a copy of the current defect list or demand, and direct the party to attend a dispute resolution session at a stated time and location. A party who subsequently appears after having been released by the dispute resolution facilitator shall not be prejudiced by its absence from the dispute resolution process as the result of having been previously released by the dispute resolution facilitator.
(n)Any party may, at any time, petition the superior court in the county where the project is located, upon a showing of good cause, and the court may issue an order, for any of the following, or for appointment of a referee to resolve a dispute regarding any of the following:
(1)To take a deposition of any party to the process, or subpoena a third party for deposition or production of documents, which is necessary to further prelitigation resolution of the dispute.
(2)To resolve any disputes concerning inspection, testing, production of documents, or exchange of information provided for under this section.
(3)To resolve any disagreements relative to the timing or contents of the case management statement.
(4)To authorize internal extensions of timeframes set forth in the case management statement.
(5)To seek a determination that a settlement is a good faith settlement pursuant to Section 877.6 of the Code of Civil Procedure and all related authorities. The page limitations and meet and confer requirements specified in this section shall not apply to these motions, which may be made on shortened notice. Instead, these motions shall be subject to other applicable state law, rules of court, and local rules. A determination made by the court pursuant to this motion shall have the same force and effect as the determination of a postfiling application or motion for good faith settlement.
(6)To ensure compliance, on shortened notice, with the obligation to provide a Statement of Insurance pursuant to paragraph (2) of subdivision (e).
(7)For any other relief appropriate to the enforcement of the provisions of this section, including the ordering of parties, and insurers, if any, to the dispute resolution process with settlement authority.
(o)(1)A petition filed pursuant to subdivision (n) shall be filed in the superior court in the county in which the project is located. The court shall hear and decide the petition within 10 days after filing. The petitioning party shall serve the petition on all parties, including the date, time, and location of the hearing no later than five business days prior to the hearing. Any responsive papers shall be filed and served no later than three business days prior to the hearing. Any petition or response filed under this section shall be no more than three pages in length.
(2)All parties shall meet with the dispute resolution facilitator, if one has been appointed and confer in person or by telephone prior to the filing of that petition to attempt to resolve the matter without requiring court intervention.
(p)As used in this section:
(1)Association shall have the same meaning as defined in Section 4080.
(2)Builder means the declarant, as defined in Section 4130.
(3)Common interest development shall have the same meaning as in Section 4100, except that it shall not include developments or projects with less than 20 units.
(q)The alternative dispute resolution process and procedures described in this section shall have no application or legal effect other than as described in this section.
(r)This section shall become operative on July 1, 2002, however it shall not apply to any pending suit or claim for which notice has previously been given.
(s)This section shall become inoperative on July 1, 2024, and, as of January 1, 2025, is repealed, unless a later enacted statute, that becomes operative on or before January 1, 2025, deletes or extends the dates on which it becomes inoperative and is repealed.
(a)Before an association files a complaint for damages against a builder, developer, or general contractor (respondent) of a common interest development based upon a claim for defects in the design or construction of the common interest development, all of the requirements of this section shall be satisfied with respect to the builder, developer, or general contractor.
(b)The association shall serve upon the respondent a Notice of Commencement of Legal Proceedings. The notice shall be served by certified mail to the registered agent of the respondent, or if there is no registered agent, then to any officer of the respondent. If there are no current officers of the respondent, service shall be upon the person or entity otherwise authorized by law to receive service of process. Service upon the general contractor shall be sufficient to initiate the process set forth in this section with regard to any builder or developer, if the builder or developer is not amenable to service of process by the foregoing methods. This notice shall toll all applicable statutes of limitation and repose, whether contractual or statutory, by and against all potentially responsible parties, regardless of whether they were named in the notice, including claims for indemnity applicable to the claim for the period set forth in subdivision (c). The notice shall include all of the following:
(1)The name and location of the project.
(2)An initial list of defects sufficient to apprise the respondent of the general nature of the defects at issue.
(3)A description of the results of the defects, if known.
(4)A summary of the results of a survey or questionnaire distributed to homeowners to determine the nature and extent of defects, if a survey has been conducted or a questionnaire has been distributed.
(5)Either a summary of the results of testing conducted to determine the nature and extent of defects or the actual test results, if that testing has been conducted.
(c)Service of the notice shall commence a period, not to exceed 180 days, during which the association, the respondent, and all other participating parties shall try to resolve the dispute through the processes set forth in this section. This 180-day period may be extended for one additional period, not to exceed 180 days, only upon the mutual agreement of the association, the respondent, and any parties not deemed peripheral pursuant to paragraph (3) of subdivision (e). Any extensions beyond the first extension shall require the agreement of all participating parties. Unless extended, the dispute resolution process prescribed by this section shall be deemed completed. All extensions shall continue the tolling period described in subdivision (b).
(d)Within 25 days of the date the association serves the Notice of Commencement of Legal Proceedings, the respondent may request in writing to meet and confer with the board. Unless the respondent and the association otherwise agree, there shall be not more than one meeting, which shall take place no later than 10 days from the date of the respondents written request, at a mutually agreeable time and place. The meeting shall be subject to subdivision (a) of Section 4925 and subdivisions (a) and (b) of Section 4935. The discussions at the meeting are privileged communications and are not admissible in evidence in any civil action, unless the association and the respondent consent in writing to their admission.
(e)Upon receipt of the notice, the respondent shall, within 60 days, comply with the following:
(1)The respondent shall provide the association with access to, for inspection and copying of, all plans and specifications, subcontracts, and other construction files for the project that are reasonably calculated to lead to the discovery of admissible evidence regarding the defects claimed. The association shall provide the respondent with access to, for inspection and copying of, all files reasonably calculated to lead to the discovery of admissible evidence regarding the defects claimed, including all reserve studies, maintenance records and any survey questionnaires, or results of testing to determine the nature and extent of defects. To the extent any of the above documents are withheld based on privilege, a privilege log shall be prepared and submitted to all other parties. All other potentially responsible parties shall have the same rights as the respondent regarding the production of documents upon receipt of written notice of the claim, and shall produce all relevant documents within 60 days of receipt of the notice of the claim.
(2)The respondent shall provide written notice by certified mail to all subcontractors, design professionals, their insurers, and the insurers of any additional insured whose identities are known to the respondent or readily ascertainable by review of the project files or other similar sources and whose potential responsibility appears on the face of the notice. This notice to subcontractors, design professionals, and insurers shall include a copy of the Notice of Commencement of Legal Proceedings, and shall specify the date and manner by which the parties shall meet and confer to select a dispute resolution facilitator pursuant to paragraph (1) of subdivision (f), advise the recipient of its obligation to participate in the meet and confer or serve a written acknowledgment of receipt regarding this notice, advise the recipient that it will waive any challenge to selection of the dispute resolution facilitator if it elects not to participate in the meet and confer, advise the recipient that it may seek the assistance of an attorney, and advise the recipient that it should contact its insurer, if any. Any subcontractor or design professional, or insurer for that subcontractor, design professional, or additional insured, who receives written notice from the respondent regarding the meet and confer shall, prior to the meet and confer, serve on the respondent a written acknowledgment of receipt. That subcontractor or design professional shall, within 10 days of service of the written acknowledgment of receipt, provide to the association and the respondent a Statement of Insurance that includes both of the following:
(A)The names, addresses, and contact persons, if known, of all insurance carriers, whether primary or excess and regardless of whether a deductible or self-insured retention applies, whose policies were in effect from the commencement of construction of the subject project to the present and which potentially cover the subject claims.
(B)The applicable policy numbers for each policy of insurance provided.
(3)Any subcontractor or design professional, or insurer for that subcontractor, design professional, or additional insured, who so chooses, may, at any time, make a written request to the dispute resolution facilitator for designation as a peripheral party. That request shall be served contemporaneously on the association and the respondent. If no objection to that designation is received within 15 days, or upon rejection of that objection, the dispute resolution facilitator shall designate that subcontractor or design professional as a peripheral party, and shall thereafter seek to limit the attendance of that subcontractor or design professional only to those dispute resolution sessions deemed peripheral party sessions or to those sessions during which the dispute resolution facilitator believes settlement as to peripheral parties may be finalized. Nothing in this subdivision shall preclude a party who has been designated a peripheral party from being reclassified as a nonperipheral party, nor shall this subdivision preclude a party designated as a nonperipheral party from being reclassified as a peripheral party after notice to all parties and an opportunity to object. For purposes of this subdivision, a peripheral party is a party having total claimed exposure of less than twenty-five thousand dollars ($25,000).
(f)(1)Within 20 days of sending the notice set forth in paragraph (2) of subdivision (e), the association, respondent, subcontractors, design professionals, and their insurers who have been sent a notice as described in paragraph (2) of subdivision (e) shall meet and confer in an effort to select a dispute resolution facilitator to preside over the mandatory dispute resolution process prescribed by this section. Any subcontractor or design professional who has been given timely notice of this meeting but who does not participate, waives any challenge he or she may have as to the selection of the dispute resolution facilitator. The role of the dispute resolution facilitator is to attempt to resolve the conflict in a fair manner. The dispute resolution facilitator shall be sufficiently knowledgeable in the subject matter and be able to devote sufficient time to the case. The dispute resolution facilitator shall not be required to reside in or have an office in the county in which the project is located. The dispute resolution facilitator and the participating parties shall agree to a date, time, and location to hold a case management meeting of all parties and the dispute resolution facilitator, to discuss the claims being asserted and the scheduling of events under this section. The case management meeting with the dispute resolution facilitator shall be held within 100 days of service of the Notice of Commencement of Legal Proceedings at a location in the county where the project is located. Written notice of the case management meeting with the dispute resolution facilitator shall be sent by the respondent to the association, subcontractors and design professionals, and their insurers who are known to the respondent to be on notice of the claim, no later than 10 days prior to the case management meeting, and shall specify its date, time, and location. The dispute resolution facilitator in consultation with the respondent shall maintain a contact list of the participating parties.
(2)No later than 10 days prior to the case management meeting, the dispute resolution facilitator shall disclose to the parties all matters that could cause a person aware of the facts to reasonably entertain a doubt that the proposed dispute resolution facilitator would be able to resolve the conflict in a fair manner. The facilitators disclosure shall include the existence of any ground specified in Section 170.1 of the Code of Civil Procedure for disqualification of a judge, any attorney-client relationship the facilitator has or had with any party or lawyer for a party to the dispute resolution process, and any professional or significant personal relationship the facilitator or his or her spouse or minor child living in the household has or had with any party to the dispute resolution process. The disclosure shall also be provided to any subsequently noticed subcontractor or design professional within 10 days of the notice.
(3)A dispute resolution facilitator shall be disqualified by the court if he or she fails to comply with this subdivision and any party to the dispute resolution process serves a notice of disqualification prior to the case management meeting. If the dispute resolution facilitator complies with this subdivision, he or she shall be disqualified by the court on the basis of the disclosure if any party to the dispute resolution process serves a notice of disqualification prior to the case management meeting.
(4)If the parties cannot mutually agree to a dispute resolution facilitator, then each party shall submit a list of three dispute resolution facilitators. Each party may then strike one nominee from the other parties list, and petition the court, pursuant to the procedure described in subdivisions (n) and (o), for final selection of the dispute resolution facilitator. The court may issue an order for final selection of the dispute resolution facilitator pursuant to this paragraph.
(5)Any subcontractor or design professional who receives notice of the associations claim without having previously received timely notice of the meet and confer to select the dispute resolution facilitator shall be notified by the respondent regarding the name, address, and telephone number of the dispute resolution facilitator. Any such subcontractor or design professional may serve upon the parties and the dispute resolution facilitator a written objection to the dispute resolution facilitator within 15 days of receiving notice of the claim. Within seven days after service of this objection, the subcontractor or design professional may petition the superior court to replace the dispute resolution facilitator. The court may replace the dispute resolution facilitator only upon a showing of good cause, liberally construed. Failure to satisfy the deadlines set forth in this subdivision shall constitute a waiver of the right to challenge the dispute resolution facilitator.
(6)The costs of the dispute resolution facilitator shall be apportioned in the following manner: one-third to be paid by the association; one-third to be paid by the respondent; and one-third to be paid by the subcontractors and design professionals, as allocated among them by the dispute resolution facilitator. The costs of the dispute resolution facilitator shall be recoverable by the prevailing party in any subsequent litigation pursuant to Section 1032 of the Code of Civil Procedure, provided however that any nonsettling party may, prior to the filing of the complaint, petition the facilitator to reallocate the costs of the dispute resolution facilitator as they apply to any nonsettling party. The determination of the dispute resolution facilitator with respect to the allocation of these costs shall be binding in any subsequent litigation. The dispute resolution facilitator shall take into account all relevant factors and equities between all parties in the dispute resolution process when reallocating costs.
(7)In the event the dispute resolution facilitator is replaced at any time, the case management statement created pursuant to subdivision (h) shall remain in full force and effect.
(8)The dispute resolution facilitator shall be empowered to enforce all provisions of this section.
(g)(1)No later than the case management meeting, the parties shall begin to generate a data compilation showing the following information regarding the alleged defects at issue:
(A)The scope of the work performed by each potentially responsible subcontractor.
(B)The tract or phase number in which each subcontractor provided goods or services, or both.
(C)The units, either by address, unit number, or lot number, at which each subcontractor provided goods or services, or both.
(2)This data compilation shall be updated as needed to reflect additional information. Each party attending the case management meeting, and any subsequent meeting pursuant to this section, shall provide all information available to that party relevant to this data compilation.
(h)At the case management meeting, the parties shall, with the assistance of the dispute resolution facilitator, reach agreement on a case management statement, which shall set forth all of the elements set forth in paragraphs (1) to (8), inclusive, except that the parties may dispense with one or more of these elements if they agree that it is appropriate to do so. The case management statement shall provide that the following elements shall take place in the following order:
(1)Establishment of a document depository, located in the county where the project is located, for deposit of documents, defect lists, demands, and other information provided for under this section. All documents exchanged by the parties and all documents created pursuant to this subdivision shall be deposited in the document depository, which shall be available to all parties throughout the prefiling dispute resolution process and in any subsequent litigation. When any document is deposited in the document depository, the party depositing the document shall provide written notice identifying the document to all other parties. The costs of maintaining the document depository shall be apportioned among the parties in the same manner as the costs of the dispute resolution facilitator.
(2)Provision of a more detailed list of defects by the association to the respondent after the association completes a visual inspection of the project. This list of defects shall provide sufficient detail for the respondent to ensure that all potentially responsible subcontractors and design professionals are provided with notice of the dispute resolution process. If not already completed prior to the case management meeting, the Notice of Commencement of Legal Proceedings shall be served by the respondent on all additional subcontractors and design professionals whose potential responsibility appears on the face of the more detailed list of defects within seven days of receipt of the more detailed list. The respondent shall serve a copy of the case management statement, including the name, address, and telephone number of the dispute resolution facilitator, to all the potentially responsible subcontractors and design professionals at the same time.
(3)Nonintrusive visual inspection of the project by the respondent, subcontractors, and design professionals.
(4)Invasive testing conducted by the association, if the association deems appropriate. All parties may observe and photograph any testing conducted by the association pursuant to this paragraph, but may not take samples or direct testing unless, by mutual agreement, costs of testing are shared by the parties.
(5)Provision by the association of a comprehensive demand which provides sufficient detail for the parties to engage in meaningful dispute resolution as contemplated under this section.
(6)Invasive testing conducted by the respondent, subcontractors, and design professionals, if they deem appropriate.
(7)Allowance for modification of the demand by the association if new issues arise during the testing conducted by the respondent, subcontractor, or design professionals.
(8)Facilitated dispute resolution of the claim, with all parties, including peripheral parties, as appropriate, and insurers, if any, present and having settlement authority. The dispute resolution facilitators shall endeavor to set specific times for the attendance of specific parties at dispute resolution sessions. If the dispute resolution facilitator does not set specific times for the attendance of parties at dispute resolution sessions, the dispute resolution facilitator shall permit those parties to participate in dispute resolution sessions by telephone.
(i)In addition to the foregoing elements of the case management statement described in subdivision (h), upon mutual agreement of the parties, the dispute resolution facilitator may include any or all of the following elements in a case management statement: the exchange of consultant or expert photographs; expert presentations; expert meetings; or any other mechanism deemed appropriate by the parties in the interest of resolving the dispute.
(j)The dispute resolution facilitator, with the guidance of the parties, shall at the time the case management statement is established, set deadlines for the occurrence of each event set forth in the case management statement, taking into account such factors as the size and complexity of the case, and the requirement of this section that this dispute resolution process not exceed 180 days absent agreement of the parties to an extension of time.
(k)(1)At a time to be determined by the dispute resolution facilitator, the respondent may submit to the association all of the following:
(A)A request to meet with the board to discuss a written settlement offer.
(B)A written settlement offer, and a concise explanation of the reasons for the terms of the offer.
(C)A statement that the respondent has access to sufficient funds to satisfy the conditions of the settlement offer.
(D)A summary of the results of testing conducted for the purposes of determining the nature and extent of defects, if this testing has been conducted, unless the association provided the respondent with actual test results.
(2)If the respondent does not timely submit the items required by this subdivision, the association shall be relieved of any further obligation to satisfy the requirements of this subdivision only.
(3)No less than 10 days after the respondent submits the items required by this paragraph, the respondent and the board shall meet and confer about the respondents settlement offer.
(4)If the board rejects a settlement offer presented at the meeting held pursuant to this subdivision, the board shall hold a meeting open to each member of the association. The meeting shall be held no less than 15 days before the association commences an action for damages against the respondent.
(5)No less than 15 days before this meeting is held, a written notice shall be sent to each member of the association specifying all of the following:
(A)That a meeting will take place to discuss problems that may lead to the filing of a civil action, and the time and place of this meeting.
(B)The options that are available to address the problems, including the filing of a civil action and a statement of the various alternatives that are reasonably foreseeable by the association to pay for those options and whether these payments are expected to be made from the use of reserve account funds or the imposition of regular or special assessments, or emergency assessment increases.
(C)The complete text of any written settlement offer, and a concise explanation of the specific reasons for the terms of the offer submitted to the board at the meeting held pursuant to subdivision (d) that was received from the respondent.
(6)The respondent shall pay all expenses attributable to sending the settlement offer to all members of the association. The respondent shall also pay the expense of holding the meeting, not to exceed three dollars ($3) per association member.
(7)The discussions at the meeting and the contents of the notice and the items required to be specified in the notice pursuant to paragraph (5) are privileged communications and are not admissible in evidence in any civil action, unless the association consents to their admission.
(8)No more than one request to meet and discuss a written settlement offer may be made by the respondent pursuant to this subdivision.
(l)All defect lists and demands, communications, negotiations, and settlement offers made in the course of the prelitigation dispute resolution process provided by this section shall be inadmissible pursuant to Sections 1119 to 1124, inclusive, of the Evidence Code and all applicable decisional law. This inadmissibility shall not be extended to any other documents or communications which would not otherwise be deemed inadmissible.
(m)Any subcontractor or design professional may, at any time, petition the dispute resolution facilitator to release that party from the dispute resolution process upon a showing that the subcontractor or design professional is not potentially responsible for the defect claims at issue. The petition shall be served contemporaneously on all other parties, who shall have 15 days from the date of service to object. If a subcontractor or design professional is released, and it later appears to the dispute resolution facilitator that it may be a responsible party in light of the current defect list or demand, the respondent shall renotice the party as provided by paragraph (2) of subdivision (e), provide a copy of the current defect list or demand, and direct the party to attend a dispute resolution session at a stated time and location. A party who subsequently appears after having been released by the dispute resolution facilitator shall not be prejudiced by its absence from the dispute resolution process as the result of having been previously released by the dispute resolution facilitator.
(n)Any party may, at any time, petition the superior court in the county where the project is located, upon a showing of good cause, and the court may issue an order, for any of the following, or for appointment of a referee to resolve a dispute regarding any of the following:
(1)To take a deposition of any party to the process, or subpoena a third party for deposition or production of documents, which is necessary to further prelitigation resolution of the dispute.
(2)To resolve any disputes concerning inspection, testing, production of documents, or exchange of information provided for under this section.
(3)To resolve any disagreements relative to the timing or contents of the case management statement.
(4)To authorize internal extensions of timeframes set forth in the case management statement.
(5)To seek a determination that a settlement is a good faith settlement pursuant to Section 877.6 of the Code of Civil Procedure and all related authorities. The page limitations and meet and confer requirements specified in this section shall not apply to these motions, which may be made on shortened notice. Instead, these motions shall be subject to other applicable state law, rules of court, and local rules. A determination made by the court pursuant to this motion shall have the same force and effect as the determination of a postfiling application or motion for good faith settlement.
(6)To ensure compliance, on shortened notice, with the obligation to provide a Statement of Insurance pursuant to paragraph (2) of subdivision (e).
(7)For any other relief appropriate to the enforcement of the provisions of this section, including the ordering of parties, and insurers, if any, to the dispute resolution process with settlement authority.
(o)(1)A petition filed pursuant to subdivision (n) shall be filed in the superior court in the county in which the project is located. The court shall hear and decide the petition within 10 days after filing. The petitioning party shall serve the petition on all parties, including the date, time, and location of the hearing no later than five business days prior to the hearing. Any responsive papers shall be filed and served no later than three business days prior to the hearing. Any petition or response filed under this section shall be no more than three pages in length.
(2)All parties shall meet with the dispute resolution facilitator, if one has been appointed and confer in person or by telephone prior to the filing of that petition to attempt to resolve the matter without requiring court intervention.
(p)As used in this section:
(1)Association shall have the same meaning as defined in Section 4080.
(2)Builder means the declarant, as defined in Section 4130.
(3)Common interest development shall have the same meaning as in Section 4100, except that it shall not include developments or projects with less than 20 units.
(q)The alternative dispute resolution process and procedures described in this section shall have no application or legal effect other than as described in this section.
(r)This section shall become operative on July 1, 2002, however it shall not apply to any pending suit or claim for which notice has previously been given.
(s)This section shall become inoperative on July 1, 2024, and, as of January 1, 2025, is repealed, unless a later enacted statute, that becomes operative on or before January 1, 2025, deletes or extends the dates on which it becomes inoperative and is repealed.
(a)Before an association files a complaint for damages against a builder, developer, or general contractor (respondent) of a common interest development based upon a claim for defects in the design or construction of the common interest development, all of the requirements of this section shall be satisfied with respect to the builder, developer, or general contractor.
(b)The association shall serve upon the respondent a Notice of Commencement of Legal Proceedings. The notice shall be served by certified mail to the registered agent of the respondent, or if there is no registered agent, then to any officer of the respondent. If there are no current officers of the respondent, service shall be upon the person or entity otherwise authorized by law to receive service of process. Service upon the general contractor shall be sufficient to initiate the process set forth in this section with regard to any builder or developer, if the builder or developer is not amenable to service of process by the foregoing methods. This notice shall toll all applicable statutes of limitation and repose, whether contractual or statutory, by and against all potentially responsible parties, regardless of whether they were named in the notice, including claims for indemnity applicable to the claim for the period set forth in subdivision (c). The notice shall include all of the following:
(1)The name and location of the project.
(2)An initial list of defects sufficient to apprise the respondent of the general nature of the defects at issue.
(3)A description of the results of the defects, if known.
(4)A summary of the results of a survey or questionnaire distributed to homeowners to determine the nature and extent of defects, if a survey has been conducted or a questionnaire has been distributed.
(5)Either a summary of the results of testing conducted to determine the nature and extent of defects or the actual test results, if that testing has been conducted.
(c)Service of the notice shall commence a period, not to exceed 180 days, during which the association, the respondent, and all other participating parties shall try to resolve the dispute through the processes set forth in this section. This 180-day period may be extended for one additional period, not to exceed 180 days, only upon the mutual agreement of the association, the respondent, and any parties not deemed peripheral pursuant to paragraph (3) of subdivision (e). Any extensions beyond the first extension shall require the agreement of all participating parties. Unless extended, the dispute resolution process prescribed by this section shall be deemed completed. All extensions shall continue the tolling period described in subdivision (b).
(d)Within 25 days of the date the association serves the Notice of Commencement of Legal Proceedings, the respondent may request in writing to meet and confer with the board. Unless the respondent and the association otherwise agree, there shall be not more than one meeting, which shall take place no later than 10 days from the date of the respondents written request, at a mutually agreeable time and place. The meeting shall be subject to subdivision (a) of Section 4925 and subdivisions (a) and (b) of Section 4935. The discussions at the meeting are privileged communications and are not admissible in evidence in any civil action, unless the association and the respondent consent in writing to their admission.
(e)Upon receipt of the notice, the respondent shall, within 60 days, comply with the following:
(1)The respondent shall provide the association with access to, for inspection and copying of, all plans and specifications, subcontracts, and other construction files for the project that are reasonably calculated to lead to the discovery of admissible evidence regarding the defects claimed. The association shall provide the respondent with access to, for inspection and copying of, all files reasonably calculated to lead to the discovery of admissible evidence regarding the defects claimed, including all reserve studies, maintenance records and any survey questionnaires, or results of testing to determine the nature and extent of defects. To the extent any of the above documents are withheld based on privilege, a privilege log shall be prepared and submitted to all other parties. All other potentially responsible parties shall have the same rights as the respondent regarding the production of documents upon receipt of written notice of the claim, and shall produce all relevant documents within 60 days of receipt of the notice of the claim.
(2)The respondent shall provide written notice by certified mail to all subcontractors, design professionals, their insurers, and the insurers of any additional insured whose identities are known to the respondent or readily ascertainable by review of the project files or other similar sources and whose potential responsibility appears on the face of the notice. This notice to subcontractors, design professionals, and insurers shall include a copy of the Notice of Commencement of Legal Proceedings, and shall specify the date and manner by which the parties shall meet and confer to select a dispute resolution facilitator pursuant to paragraph (1) of subdivision (f), advise the recipient of its obligation to participate in the meet and confer or serve a written acknowledgment of receipt regarding this notice, advise the recipient that it will waive any challenge to selection of the dispute resolution facilitator if it elects not to participate in the meet and confer, advise the recipient that it may seek the assistance of an attorney, and advise the recipient that it should contact its insurer, if any. Any subcontractor or design professional, or insurer for that subcontractor, design professional, or additional insured, who receives written notice from the respondent regarding the meet and confer shall, prior to the meet and confer, serve on the respondent a written acknowledgment of receipt. That subcontractor or design professional shall, within 10 days of service of the written acknowledgment of receipt, provide to the association and the respondent a Statement of Insurance that includes both of the following:
(A)The names, addresses, and contact persons, if known, of all insurance carriers, whether primary or excess and regardless of whether a deductible or self-insured retention applies, whose policies were in effect from the commencement of construction of the subject project to the present and which potentially cover the subject claims.
(B)The applicable policy numbers for each policy of insurance provided.
(3)Any subcontractor or design professional, or insurer for that subcontractor, design professional, or additional insured, who so chooses, may, at any time, make a written request to the dispute resolution facilitator for designation as a peripheral party. That request shall be served contemporaneously on the association and the respondent. If no objection to that designation is received within 15 days, or upon rejection of that objection, the dispute resolution facilitator shall designate that subcontractor or design professional as a peripheral party, and shall thereafter seek to limit the attendance of that subcontractor or design professional only to those dispute resolution sessions deemed peripheral party sessions or to those sessions during which the dispute resolution facilitator believes settlement as to peripheral parties may be finalized. Nothing in this subdivision shall preclude a party who has been designated a peripheral party from being reclassified as a nonperipheral party, nor shall this subdivision preclude a party designated as a nonperipheral party from being reclassified as a peripheral party after notice to all parties and an opportunity to object. For purposes of this subdivision, a peripheral party is a party having total claimed exposure of less than twenty-five thousand dollars ($25,000).
(f)(1)Within 20 days of sending the notice set forth in paragraph (2) of subdivision (e), the association, respondent, subcontractors, design professionals, and their insurers who have been sent a notice as described in paragraph (2) of subdivision (e) shall meet and confer in an effort to select a dispute resolution facilitator to preside over the mandatory dispute resolution process prescribed by this section. Any subcontractor or design professional who has been given timely notice of this meeting but who does not participate, waives any challenge he or she may have as to the selection of the dispute resolution facilitator. The role of the dispute resolution facilitator is to attempt to resolve the conflict in a fair manner. The dispute resolution facilitator shall be sufficiently knowledgeable in the subject matter and be able to devote sufficient time to the case. The dispute resolution facilitator shall not be required to reside in or have an office in the county in which the project is located. The dispute resolution facilitator and the participating parties shall agree to a date, time, and location to hold a case management meeting of all parties and the dispute resolution facilitator, to discuss the claims being asserted and the scheduling of events under this section. The case management meeting with the dispute resolution facilitator shall be held within 100 days of service of the Notice of Commencement of Legal Proceedings at a location in the county where the project is located. Written notice of the case management meeting with the dispute resolution facilitator shall be sent by the respondent to the association, subcontractors and design professionals, and their insurers who are known to the respondent to be on notice of the claim, no later than 10 days prior to the case management meeting, and shall specify its date, time, and location. The dispute resolution facilitator in consultation with the respondent shall maintain a contact list of the participating parties.
(2)No later than 10 days prior to the case management meeting, the dispute resolution facilitator shall disclose to the parties all matters that could cause a person aware of the facts to reasonably entertain a doubt that the proposed dispute resolution facilitator would be able to resolve the conflict in a fair manner. The facilitators disclosure shall include the existence of any ground specified in Section 170.1 of the Code of Civil Procedure for disqualification of a judge, any attorney-client relationship the facilitator has or had with any party or lawyer for a party to the dispute resolution process, and any professional or significant personal relationship the facilitator or his or her spouse or minor child living in the household has or had with any party to the dispute resolution process. The disclosure shall also be provided to any subsequently noticed subcontractor or design professional within 10 days of the notice.
(3)A dispute resolution facilitator shall be disqualified by the court if he or she fails to comply with this subdivision and any party to the dispute resolution process serves a notice of disqualification prior to the case management meeting. If the dispute resolution facilitator complies with this subdivision, he or she shall be disqualified by the court on the basis of the disclosure if any party to the dispute resolution process serves a notice of disqualification prior to the case management meeting.
(4)If the parties cannot mutually agree to a dispute resolution facilitator, then each party shall submit a list of three dispute resolution facilitators. Each party may then strike one nominee from the other parties list, and petition the court, pursuant to the procedure described in subdivisions (n) and (o), for final selection of the dispute resolution facilitator. The court may issue an order for final selection of the dispute resolution facilitator pursuant to this paragraph.
(5)Any subcontractor or design professional who receives notice of the associations claim without having previously received timely notice of the meet and confer to select the dispute resolution facilitator shall be notified by the respondent regarding the name, address, and telephone number of the dispute resolution facilitator. Any such subcontractor or design professional may serve upon the parties and the dispute resolution facilitator a written objection to the dispute resolution facilitator within 15 days of receiving notice of the claim. Within seven days after service of this objection, the subcontractor or design professional may petition the superior court to replace the dispute resolution facilitator. The court may replace the dispute resolution facilitator only upon a showing of good cause, liberally construed. Failure to satisfy the deadlines set forth in this subdivision shall constitute a waiver of the right to challenge the dispute resolution facilitator.
(6)The costs of the dispute resolution facilitator shall be apportioned in the following manner: one-third to be paid by the association; one-third to be paid by the respondent; and one-third to be paid by the subcontractors and design professionals, as allocated among them by the dispute resolution facilitator. The costs of the dispute resolution facilitator shall be recoverable by the prevailing party in any subsequent litigation pursuant to Section 1032 of the Code of Civil Procedure, provided however that any nonsettling party may, prior to the filing of the complaint, petition the facilitator to reallocate the costs of the dispute resolution facilitator as they apply to any nonsettling party. The determination of the dispute resolution facilitator with respect to the allocation of these costs shall be binding in any subsequent litigation. The dispute resolution facilitator shall take into account all relevant factors and equities between all parties in the dispute resolution process when reallocating costs.
(7)In the event the dispute resolution facilitator is replaced at any time, the case management statement created pursuant to subdivision (h) shall remain in full force and effect.
(8)The dispute resolution facilitator shall be empowered to enforce all provisions of this section.
(g)(1)No later than the case management meeting, the parties shall begin to generate a data compilation showing the following information regarding the alleged defects at issue:
(A)The scope of the work performed by each potentially responsible subcontractor.
(B)The tract or phase number in which each subcontractor provided goods or services, or both.
(C)The units, either by address, unit number, or lot number, at which each subcontractor provided goods or services, or both.
(2)This data compilation shall be updated as needed to reflect additional information. Each party attending the case management meeting, and any subsequent meeting pursuant to this section, shall provide all information available to that party relevant to this data compilation.
(h)At the case management meeting, the parties shall, with the assistance of the dispute resolution facilitator, reach agreement on a case management statement, which shall set forth all of the elements set forth in paragraphs (1) to (8), inclusive, except that the parties may dispense with one or more of these elements if they agree that it is appropriate to do so. The case management statement shall provide that the following elements shall take place in the following order:
(1)Establishment of a document depository, located in the county where the project is located, for deposit of documents, defect lists, demands, and other information provided for under this section. All documents exchanged by the parties and all documents created pursuant to this subdivision shall be deposited in the document depository, which shall be available to all parties throughout the prefiling dispute resolution process and in any subsequent litigation. When any document is deposited in the document depository, the party depositing the document shall provide written notice identifying the document to all other parties. The costs of maintaining the document depository shall be apportioned among the parties in the same manner as the costs of the dispute resolution facilitator.
(2)Provision of a more detailed list of defects by the association to the respondent after the association completes a visual inspection of the project. This list of defects shall provide sufficient detail for the respondent to ensure that all potentially responsible subcontractors and design professionals are provided with notice of the dispute resolution process. If not already completed prior to the case management meeting, the Notice of Commencement of Legal Proceedings shall be served by the respondent on all additional subcontractors and design professionals whose potential responsibility appears on the face of the more detailed list of defects within seven days of receipt of the more detailed list. The respondent shall serve a copy of the case management statement, including the name, address, and telephone number of the dispute resolution facilitator, to all the potentially responsible subcontractors and design professionals at the same time.
(3)Nonintrusive visual inspection of the project by the respondent, subcontractors, and design professionals.
(4)Invasive testing conducted by the association, if the association deems appropriate. All parties may observe and photograph any testing conducted by the association pursuant to this paragraph, but may not take samples or direct testing unless, by mutual agreement, costs of testing are shared by the parties.
(5)Provision by the association of a comprehensive demand which provides sufficient detail for the parties to engage in meaningful dispute resolution as contemplated under this section.
(6)Invasive testing conducted by the respondent, subcontractors, and design professionals, if they deem appropriate.
(7)Allowance for modification of the demand by the association if new issues arise during the testing conducted by the respondent, subcontractor, or design professionals.
(8)Facilitated dispute resolution of the claim, with all parties, including peripheral parties, as appropriate, and insurers, if any, present and having settlement authority. The dispute resolution facilitators shall endeavor to set specific times for the attendance of specific parties at dispute resolution sessions. If the dispute resolution facilitator does not set specific times for the attendance of parties at dispute resolution sessions, the dispute resolution facilitator shall permit those parties to participate in dispute resolution sessions by telephone.
(i)In addition to the foregoing elements of the case management statement described in subdivision (h), upon mutual agreement of the parties, the dispute resolution facilitator may include any or all of the following elements in a case management statement: the exchange of consultant or expert photographs; expert presentations; expert meetings; or any other mechanism deemed appropriate by the parties in the interest of resolving the dispute.
(j)The dispute resolution facilitator, with the guidance of the parties, shall at the time the case management statement is established, set deadlines for the occurrence of each event set forth in the case management statement, taking into account such factors as the size and complexity of the case, and the requirement of this section that this dispute resolution process not exceed 180 days absent agreement of the parties to an extension of time.
(k)(1)At a time to be determined by the dispute resolution facilitator, the respondent may submit to the association all of the following:
(A)A request to meet with the board to discuss a written settlement offer.
(B)A written settlement offer, and a concise explanation of the reasons for the terms of the offer.
(C)A statement that the respondent has access to sufficient funds to satisfy the conditions of the settlement offer.
(D)A summary of the results of testing conducted for the purposes of determining the nature and extent of defects, if this testing has been conducted, unless the association provided the respondent with actual test results.
(2)If the respondent does not timely submit the items required by this subdivision, the association shall be relieved of any further obligation to satisfy the requirements of this subdivision only.
(3)No less than 10 days after the respondent submits the items required by this paragraph, the respondent and the board shall meet and confer about the respondents settlement offer.
(4)If the board rejects a settlement offer presented at the meeting held pursuant to this subdivision, the board shall hold a meeting open to each member of the association. The meeting shall be held no less than 15 days before the association commences an action for damages against the respondent.
(5)No less than 15 days before this meeting is held, a written notice shall be sent to each member of the association specifying all of the following:
(A)That a meeting will take place to discuss problems that may lead to the filing of a civil action, and the time and place of this meeting.
(B)The options that are available to address the problems, including the filing of a civil action and a statement of the various alternatives that are reasonably foreseeable by the association to pay for those options and whether these payments are expected to be made from the use of reserve account funds or the imposition of regular or special assessments, or emergency assessment increases.
(C)The complete text of any written settlement offer, and a concise explanation of the specific reasons for the terms of the offer submitted to the board at the meeting held pursuant to subdivision (d) that was received from the respondent.
(6)The respondent shall pay all expenses attributable to sending the settlement offer to all members of the association. The respondent shall also pay the expense of holding the meeting, not to exceed three dollars ($3) per association member.
(7)The discussions at the meeting and the contents of the notice and the items required to be specified in the notice pursuant to subparagraph (E) paragraph (5) are privileged communications and are not admissible in evidence in any civil action, unless the association consents to their admission.
(8)No more than one request to meet and discuss a written settlement offer may be made by the respondent pursuant to this subdivision.
(l)All defect lists and demands, communications, negotiations, and settlement offers made in the course of the prelitigation dispute resolution process provided by this section shall be inadmissible pursuant to Sections 1119 to 1124, inclusive, of the Evidence Code and all applicable decisional law. This inadmissibility shall not be extended to any other documents or communications which would not otherwise be deemed inadmissible.
(m)Any subcontractor or design professional may, at any time, petition the dispute resolution facilitator to release that party from the dispute resolution process upon a showing that the subcontractor or design professional is not potentially responsible for the defect claims at issue. The petition shall be served contemporaneously on all other parties, who shall have 15 days from the date of service to object. If a subcontractor or design professional is released, and it later appears to the dispute resolution facilitator that it may be a responsible party in light of the current defect list or demand, the respondent shall renotice the party as provided by paragraph (2) of subdivision (e), provide a copy of the current defect list or demand, and direct the party to attend a dispute resolution session at a stated time and location. A party who subsequently appears after having been released by the dispute resolution facilitator shall not be prejudiced by its absence from the dispute resolution process as the result of having been previously released by the dispute resolution facilitator.
(n)Any party may, at any time, petition the superior court in the county where the project is located, upon a showing of good cause, and the court may issue an order, for any of the following, or for appointment of a referee to resolve a dispute regarding any of the following:
(1)To take a deposition of any party to the process, or subpoena a third party for deposition or production of documents, which is necessary to further prelitigation resolution of the dispute.
(2)To resolve any disputes concerning inspection, testing, production of documents, or exchange of information provided for under this section.
(3)To resolve any disagreements relative to the timing or contents of the case management statement.
(4)To authorize internal extensions of timeframes set forth in the case management statement.
(5)To seek a determination that a settlement is a good faith settlement pursuant to Section 877.6 of the Code of Civil Procedure and all related authorities. The page limitations and meet and confer requirements specified in this section shall not apply to these motions, which may be made on shortened notice. Instead, these motions shall be subject to other applicable state law, rules of court, and local rules. A determination made by the court pursuant to this motion shall have the same force and effect as the determination of a postfiling application or motion for good faith settlement.
(6)To ensure compliance, on shortened notice, with the obligation to provide a Statement of Insurance pursuant to paragraph (2) of subdivision (e).
(7)For any other relief appropriate to the enforcement of the provisions of this section, including the ordering of parties, and insurers, if any, to the dispute resolution process with settlement authority.
(o)(1)A petition filed pursuant to subdivision (n) shall be filed in the superior court in the county in which the project is located. The court shall hear and decide the petition within 10 days after filing. The petitioning party shall serve the petition on all parties, including the date, time, and location of the hearing no later than five business days prior to the hearing. Any responsive papers shall be filed and served no later than three business days prior to the hearing. Any petition or response filed under this section shall be no more than three pages in length.
(2)All parties shall meet with the dispute resolution facilitator, if one has been appointed and confer in person or by telephone prior to the filing of that petition to attempt to resolve the matter without requiring court intervention.
(p)As used in this section:
(1)Association shall have the same meaning as defined in Section 4080.
(2)Builder means the declarant, as defined in Section 4130.
(3)Common interest development shall have the same meaning as in Section 4100, except that it shall not include developments or projects with less than 20 units.
(q)The alternative dispute resolution process and procedures described in this section shall have no application or legal effect other than as described in this section.
(r)This section shall become operative on July 1, 2002, however it shall not apply to any pending suit or claim for which notice has previously been given.
(s)This section shall become inoperative on July 1, 2024, and, as of January 1, 2025, is repealed, unless a later enacted statute, that becomes operative on or before January 1, 2025, deletes or extends the dates on which it becomes inoperative and is repealed.
(a)Before an association files a complaint for damages against a builder, developer, or general contractor (respondent) of a common interest development based upon a claim for defects in the design or construction of the common interest development, all of the requirements of this section shall be satisfied with respect to the builder, developer, or general contractor.
(b)The association shall serve upon the respondent a Notice of Commencement of Legal Proceedings. The notice shall be served by certified mail to the registered agent of the respondent, or if there is no registered agent, then to any officer of the respondent. If there are no current officers of the respondent, service shall be upon the person or entity otherwise authorized by law to receive service of process. Service upon the general contractor shall be sufficient to initiate the process set forth in this section with regard to any builder or developer, if the builder or developer is not amenable to service of process by the foregoing methods. This notice shall toll all applicable statutes of limitation and repose, whether contractual or statutory, by and against all potentially responsible parties, regardless of whether they were named in the notice, including claims for indemnity applicable to the claim for the period set forth in subdivision (c). The notice shall include all of the following:
(1)The name and location of the project.
(2)An initial list of defects sufficient to apprise the respondent of the general nature of the defects at issue.
(3)A description of the results of the defects, if known.
(4)A summary of the results of a survey or questionnaire distributed to homeowners to determine the nature and extent of defects, if a survey has been conducted or a questionnaire has been distributed.
(5)Either a summary of the results of testing conducted to determine the nature and extent of defects or the actual test results, if that testing has been conducted.
(c)Service of the notice shall commence a period, not to exceed 180 days, during which the association, the respondent, and all other participating parties shall try to resolve the dispute through the processes set forth in this section. This 180-day period may be extended for one additional period, not to exceed 180 days, only upon the mutual agreement of the association, the respondent, and any parties not deemed peripheral pursuant to paragraph (3) of subdivision (e). Any extensions beyond the first extension shall require the agreement of all participating parties. Unless extended, the dispute resolution process prescribed by this section shall be deemed completed. All extensions shall continue the tolling period described in subdivision (b).
(d)Within 25 days of the date the association serves the Notice of Commencement of Legal Proceedings, the respondent may request in writing to meet and confer with the board. Unless the respondent and the association otherwise agree, there shall be not more than one meeting, which shall take place no later than 10 days from the date of the respondents written request, at a mutually agreeable time and place. The meeting shall be subject to subdivision (a) of Section 4925 and subdivisions (a) and (b) of Section 4935. The discussions at the meeting are privileged communications and are not admissible in evidence in any civil action, unless the association and the respondent consent in writing to their admission.
(e)Upon receipt of the notice, the respondent shall, within 60 days, comply with the following:
(1)The respondent shall provide the association with access to, for inspection and copying of, all plans and specifications, subcontracts, and other construction files for the project that are reasonably calculated to lead to the discovery of admissible evidence regarding the defects claimed. The association shall provide the respondent with access to, for inspection and copying of, all files reasonably calculated to lead to the discovery of admissible evidence regarding the defects claimed, including all reserve studies, maintenance records and any survey questionnaires, or results of testing to determine the nature and extent of defects. To the extent any of the above documents are withheld based on privilege, a privilege log shall be prepared and submitted to all other parties. All other potentially responsible parties shall have the same rights as the respondent regarding the production of documents upon receipt of written notice of the claim, and shall produce all relevant documents within 60 days of receipt of the notice of the claim.
(2)The respondent shall provide written notice by certified mail to all subcontractors, design professionals, their insurers, and the insurers of any additional insured whose identities are known to the respondent or readily ascertainable by review of the project files or other similar sources and whose potential responsibility appears on the face of the notice. This notice to subcontractors, design professionals, and insurers shall include a copy of the Notice of Commencement of Legal Proceedings, and shall specify the date and manner by which the parties shall meet and confer to select a dispute resolution facilitator pursuant to paragraph (1) of subdivision (f), advise the recipient of its obligation to participate in the meet and confer or serve a written acknowledgment of receipt regarding this notice, advise the recipient that it will waive any challenge to selection of the dispute resolution facilitator if it elects not to participate in the meet and confer, advise the recipient that it may seek the assistance of an attorney, and advise the recipient that it should contact its insurer, if any. Any subcontractor or design professional, or insurer for that subcontractor, design professional, or additional insured, who receives written notice from the respondent regarding the meet and confer shall, prior to the meet and confer, serve on the respondent a written acknowledgment of receipt. That subcontractor or design professional shall, within 10 days of service of the written acknowledgment of receipt, provide to the association and the respondent a Statement of Insurance that includes both of the following:
(A)The names, addresses, and contact persons, if known, of all insurance carriers, whether primary or excess and regardless of whether a deductible or self-insured retention applies, whose policies were in effect from the commencement of construction of the subject project to the present and which potentially cover the subject claims.
(B)The applicable policy numbers for each policy of insurance provided.
(3)Any subcontractor or design professional, or insurer for that subcontractor, design professional, or additional insured, who so chooses, may, at any time, make a written request to the dispute resolution facilitator for designation as a peripheral party. That request shall be served contemporaneously on the association and the respondent. If no objection to that designation is received within 15 days, or upon rejection of that objection, the dispute resolution facilitator shall designate that subcontractor or design professional as a peripheral party, and shall thereafter seek to limit the attendance of that subcontractor or design professional only to those dispute resolution sessions deemed peripheral party sessions or to those sessions during which the dispute resolution facilitator believes settlement as to peripheral parties may be finalized. Nothing in this subdivision shall preclude a party who has been designated a peripheral party from being reclassified as a nonperipheral party, nor shall this subdivision preclude a party designated as a nonperipheral party from being reclassified as a peripheral party after notice to all parties and an opportunity to object. For purposes of this subdivision, a peripheral party is a party having total claimed exposure of less than twenty-five thousand dollars ($25,000).
(f)(1)Within 20 days of sending the notice set forth in paragraph (2) of subdivision (e), the association, respondent, subcontractors, design professionals, and their insurers who have been sent a notice as described in paragraph (2) of subdivision (e) shall meet and confer in an effort to select a dispute resolution facilitator to preside over the mandatory dispute resolution process prescribed by this section. Any subcontractor or design professional who has been given timely notice of this meeting but who does not participate, waives any challenge he or she may have as to the selection of the dispute resolution facilitator. The role of the dispute resolution facilitator is to attempt to resolve the conflict in a fair manner. The dispute resolution facilitator shall be sufficiently knowledgeable in the subject matter and be able to devote sufficient time to the case. The dispute resolution facilitator shall not be required to reside in or have an office in the county in which the project is located. The dispute resolution facilitator and the participating parties shall agree to a date, time, and location to hold a case management meeting of all parties and the dispute resolution facilitator, to discuss the claims being asserted and the scheduling of events under this section. The case management meeting with the dispute resolution facilitator shall be held within 100 days of service of the Notice of Commencement of Legal Proceedings at a location in the county where the project is located. Written notice of the case management meeting with the dispute resolution facilitator shall be sent by the respondent to the association, subcontractors and design professionals, and their insurers who are known to the respondent to be on notice of the claim, no later than 10 days prior to the case management meeting, and shall specify its date, time, and location. The dispute resolution facilitator in consultation with the respondent shall maintain a contact list of the participating parties.
(2)No later than 10 days prior to the case management meeting, the dispute resolution facilitator shall disclose to the parties all matters that could cause a person aware of the facts to reasonably entertain a doubt that the proposed dispute resolution facilitator would be able to resolve the conflict in a fair manner. The facilitators disclosure shall include the existence of any ground specified in Section 170.1 of the Code of Civil Procedure for disqualification of a judge, any attorney-client relationship the facilitator has or had with any party or lawyer for a party to the dispute resolution process, and any professional or significant personal relationship the facilitator or his or her spouse or minor child living in the household has or had with any party to the dispute resolution process. The disclosure shall also be provided to any subsequently noticed subcontractor or design professional within 10 days of the notice.
(3)A dispute resolution facilitator shall be disqualified by the court if he or she fails to comply with this subdivision and any party to the dispute resolution process serves a notice of disqualification prior to the case management meeting. If the dispute resolution facilitator complies with this subdivision, he or she shall be disqualified by the court on the basis of the disclosure if any party to the dispute resolution process serves a notice of disqualification prior to the case management meeting.
(4)If the parties cannot mutually agree to a dispute resolution facilitator, then each party shall submit a list of three dispute resolution facilitators. Each party may then strike one nominee from the other parties list, and petition the court, pursuant to the procedure described in subdivisions (n) and (o), for final selection of the dispute resolution facilitator. The court may issue an order for final selection of the dispute resolution facilitator pursuant to this paragraph.
(5)Any subcontractor or design professional who receives notice of the associations claim without having previously received timely notice of the meet and confer to select the dispute resolution facilitator shall be notified by the respondent regarding the name, address, and telephone number of the dispute resolution facilitator. Any such subcontractor or design professional may serve upon the parties and the dispute resolution facilitator a written objection to the dispute resolution facilitator within 15 days of receiving notice of the claim. Within seven days after service of this objection, the subcontractor or design professional may petition the superior court to replace the dispute resolution facilitator. The court may replace the dispute resolution facilitator only upon a showing of good cause, liberally construed. Failure to satisfy the deadlines set forth in this subdivision shall constitute a waiver of the right to challenge the dispute resolution facilitator.
(6)The costs of the dispute resolution facilitator shall be apportioned in the following manner: one-third to be paid by the association; one-third to be paid by the respondent; and one-third to be paid by the subcontractors and design professionals, as allocated among them by the dispute resolution facilitator. The costs of the dispute resolution facilitator shall be recoverable by the prevailing party in any subsequent litigation pursuant to Section 1032 of the Code of Civil Procedure, provided however that any nonsettling party may, prior to the filing of the complaint, petition the facilitator to reallocate the costs of the dispute resolution facilitator as they apply to any nonsettling party. The determination of the dispute resolution facilitator with respect to the allocation of these costs shall be binding in any subsequent litigation. The dispute resolution facilitator shall take into account all relevant factors and equities between all parties in the dispute resolution process when reallocating costs.
(7)In the event the dispute resolution facilitator is replaced at any time, the case management statement created pursuant to subdivision (h) shall remain in full force and effect.
(8)The dispute resolution facilitator shall be empowered to enforce all provisions of this section.
(g)(1)No later than the case management meeting, the parties shall begin to generate a data compilation showing the following information regarding the alleged defects at issue:
(A)The scope of the work performed by each potentially responsible subcontractor.
(B)The tract or phase number in which each subcontractor provided goods or services, or both.
(C)The units, either by address, unit number, or lot number, at which each subcontractor provided goods or services, or both.
(2)This data compilation shall be updated as needed to reflect additional information. Each party attending the case management meeting, and any subsequent meeting pursuant to this section, shall provide all information available to that party relevant to this data compilation.
(h)At the case management meeting, the parties shall, with the assistance of the dispute resolution facilitator, reach agreement on a case management statement, which shall set forth all of the elements set forth in paragraphs (1) to (8), inclusive, except that the parties may dispense with one or more of these elements if they agree that it is appropriate to do so. The case management statement shall provide that the following elements shall take place in the following order:
(1)Establishment of a document depository, located in the county where the project is located, for deposit of documents, defect lists, demands, and other information provided for under this section. All documents exchanged by the parties and all documents created pursuant to this subdivision shall be deposited in the document depository, which shall be available to all parties throughout the prefiling dispute resolution process and in any subsequent litigation. When any document is deposited in the document depository, the party depositing the document shall provide written notice identifying the document to all other parties. The costs of maintaining the document depository shall be apportioned among the parties in the same manner as the costs of the dispute resolution facilitator.
(2)Provision of a more detailed list of defects by the association to the respondent after the association completes a visual inspection of the project. This list of defects shall provide sufficient detail for the respondent to ensure that all potentially responsible subcontractors and design professionals are provided with notice of the dispute resolution process. If not already completed prior to the case management meeting, the Notice of Commencement of Legal Proceedings shall be served by the respondent on all additional subcontractors and design professionals whose potential responsibility appears on the face of the more detailed list of defects within seven days of receipt of the more detailed list. The respondent shall serve a copy of the case management statement, including the name, address, and telephone number of the dispute resolution facilitator, to all the potentially responsible subcontractors and design professionals at the same time.
(3)Nonintrusive visual inspection of the project by the respondent, subcontractors, and design professionals.
(4)Invasive testing conducted by the association, if the association deems appropriate. All parties may observe and photograph any testing conducted by the association pursuant to this paragraph, but may not take samples or direct testing unless, by mutual agreement, costs of testing are shared by the parties.
(5)Provision by the association of a comprehensive demand which provides sufficient detail for the parties to engage in meaningful dispute resolution as contemplated under this section.
(6)Invasive testing conducted by the respondent, subcontractors, and design professionals, if they deem appropriate.
(7)Allowance for modification of the demand by the association if new issues arise during the testing conducted by the respondent, subcontractor, or design professionals.
(8)Facilitated dispute resolution of the claim, with all parties, including peripheral parties, as appropriate, and insurers, if any, present and having settlement authority. The dispute resolution facilitators shall endeavor to set specific times for the attendance of specific parties at dispute resolution sessions. If the dispute resolution facilitator does not set specific times for the attendance of parties at dispute resolution sessions, the dispute resolution facilitator shall permit those parties to participate in dispute resolution sessions by telephone.
(i)In addition to the foregoing elements of the case management statement described in subdivision (h), upon mutual agreement of the parties, the dispute resolution facilitator may include any or all of the following elements in a case management statement: the exchange of consultant or expert photographs; expert presentations; expert meetings; or any other mechanism deemed appropriate by the parties in the interest of resolving the dispute.
(j)The dispute resolution facilitator, with the guidance of the parties, shall at the time the case management statement is established, set deadlines for the occurrence of each event set forth in the case management statement, taking into account such factors as the size and complexity of the case, and the requirement of this section that this dispute resolution process not exceed 180 days absent agreement of the parties to an extension of time.
(k)(1)(A)At a time to be determined by the dispute resolution facilitator, the respondent may submit to the association all of the following:
(i)
(A)A request to meet with the board to discuss a written settlement offer.
(ii)
(B)A written settlement offer, and a concise explanation of the reasons for the terms of the offer.
(iii)
(C)A statement that the respondent has access to sufficient funds to satisfy the conditions of the settlement offer.
(iv)
(D)A summary of the results of testing conducted for the purposes of determining the nature and extent of defects, if this testing has been conducted, unless the association provided the respondent with actual test results.
(B)
(2)If the respondent does not timely submit the items required by this subdivision, the association shall be relieved of any further obligation to satisfy the requirements of this subdivision only.
(C)
(3)No less than 10 days after the respondent submits the items required by this paragraph, the respondent and the board shall meet and confer about the respondents settlement offer.
(D)
(4)If the board rejects a settlement offer presented at the meeting held pursuant to this subdivision, the board shall hold a meeting open to each member of the association. The meeting shall be held no less than 15 days before the association commences an action for damages against the respondent.
(E)
(5)No less than 15 days before this meeting is held, a written notice shall be sent to each member of the association specifying all of the following:
(i)
(A)That a meeting will take place to discuss problems that may lead to the filing of a civil action, and the time and place of this meeting.
(ii)
(B)The options that are available to address the problems, including the filing of a civil action and a statement of the various alternatives that are reasonably foreseeable by the association to pay for those options and whether these payments are expected to be made from the use of reserve account funds or the imposition of regular or special assessments, or emergency assessment increases.
(iii)
(C)The complete text of any written settlement offer, and a concise explanation of the specific reasons for the terms of the offer submitted to the board at the meeting held pursuant to subdivision (d) that was received from the respondent.
(F)
(6)The respondent shall pay all expenses attributable to sending the settlement offer to all members of the association. The respondent shall also pay the expense of holding the meeting, not to exceed three dollars ($3) per association member.
(G)
(7)The discussions at the meeting and the contents of the notice and the items required to be specified in the notice pursuant to subparagraph (E) are privileged communications and are not admissible in evidence in any civil action, unless the association consents to their admission.
(H)
(8)No more than one request to meet and discuss a written settlement offer may be made by the respondent pursuant to this subdivision.
(l)All defect lists and demands, communications, negotiations, and settlement offers made in the course of the prelitigation dispute resolution process provided by this section shall be inadmissible pursuant to Sections 1119 to 1124, inclusive, of the Evidence Code and all applicable decisional law. This inadmissibility shall not be extended to any other documents or communications which would not otherwise be deemed inadmissible.
(m)Any subcontractor or design professional may, at any time, petition the dispute resolution facilitator to release that party from the dispute resolution process upon a showing that the subcontractor or design professional is not potentially responsible for the defect claims at issue. The petition shall be served contemporaneously on all other parties, who shall have 15 days from the date of service to object. If a subcontractor or design professional is released, and it later appears to the dispute resolution facilitator that it may be a responsible party in light of the current defect list or demand, the respondent shall renotice the party as provided by paragraph (2) of subdivision (e), provide a copy of the current defect list or demand, and direct the party to attend a dispute resolution session at a stated time and location. A party who subsequently appears after having been released by the dispute resolution facilitator shall not be prejudiced by its absence from the dispute resolution process as the result of having been previously released by the dispute resolution facilitator.
(n)Any party may, at any time, petition the superior court in the county where the project is located, upon a showing of good cause, and the court may issue an order, for any of the following, or for appointment of a referee to resolve a dispute regarding any of the following:
(1)To take a deposition of any party to the process, or subpoena a third party for deposition or production of documents, which is necessary to further prelitigation resolution of the dispute.
(2)To resolve any disputes concerning inspection, testing, production of documents, or exchange of information provided for under this section.
(3)To resolve any disagreements relative to the timing or contents of the case management statement.
(4)To authorize internal extensions of timeframes set forth in the case management statement.
(5)To seek a determination that a settlement is a good faith settlement pursuant to Section 877.6 of the Code of Civil Procedure and all related authorities. The page limitations and meet and confer requirements specified in this section shall not apply to these motions, which may be made on shortened notice. Instead, these motions shall be subject to other applicable state law, rules of court, and local rules. A determination made by the court pursuant to this motion shall have the same force and effect as the determination of a postfiling application or motion for good faith settlement.
(6)To ensure compliance, on shortened notice, with the obligation to provide a Statement of Insurance pursuant to paragraph (2) of subdivision (e).
(7)For any other relief appropriate to the enforcement of the provisions of this section, including the ordering of parties, and insurers, if any, to the dispute resolution process with settlement authority.
(o)(1)A petition filed pursuant to subdivision (n) shall be filed in the superior court in the county in which the project is located. The court shall hear and decide the petition within 10 days after filing. The petitioning party shall serve the petition on all parties, including the date, time, and location of the hearing no later than five business days prior to the hearing. Any responsive papers shall be filed and served no later than three business days prior to the hearing. Any petition or response filed under this section shall be no more than three pages in length.
(2)All parties shall meet with the dispute resolution facilitator, if one has been appointed and confer in person or by telephone prior to the filing of that petition to attempt to resolve the matter without requiring court intervention.
(p)As used in this section:
(1)Association shall have the same meaning as defined in Section 4080.
(2)Builder means the declarant, as defined in Section 4130.
(3)Common interest development shall have the same meaning as in Section 4100, except that it shall not include developments or projects with less than 20 units.
(q)The alternative dispute resolution process and procedures described in this section shall have no application or legal effect other than as described in this section.
(r)This section shall become operative on July 1, 2002, however it shall not apply to any pending suit or claim for which notice has previously been given.
(s)This section shall become inoperative on July 1, 2017, and, as of January 1, 2018, is repealed, unless a later enacted statute, that becomes operative on or before January 1, 2018, deletes or extends the dates on which it becomes inoperative and is repealed.
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Jul 22, 2016 | Chaptered by Secretary of State - Chapter 71, Statutes of 2016. |
| Jul 22, 2016 | Approved by the Governor. |
| Jul 11, 2016 | Enrolled and presented to the Governor at 4:30 p.m. |
| Jun 30, 2016 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Assembly. (Ayes 37. Noes 0. Page 4646.). |
| Jun 30, 2016 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Assembly. |
| Jun 30, 2016 | In Assembly. Ordered to Engrossing and Enrolling. |
| Jun 16, 2016 | Read second time. Ordered to Consent Calendar. |
| Jun 15, 2016 | From committee: Do pass. To Consent Calendar. (Ayes 7. Noes 0.) (June 14). |
| Apr 28, 2016 | Referred to Com. on JUD. |
| Apr 7, 2016 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Senate. (Ayes 77. Noes 0. Page 4231.) |
| Apr 7, 2016 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Senate. |
| Apr 7, 2016 | In Senate. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. |
| Apr 5, 2016 | Read second time. Ordered to Consent Calendar. |
| Apr 4, 2016 | Read second time and amended. Ordered returned to second reading. |
| Mar 31, 2016 | From committee: Amend, and do pass as amended. To Consent Calendar. (Ayes 10. Noes 0.) (March 29). |
| Feb 25, 2016 | Referred to Com. on JUD. |
| Feb 16, 2016 | From printer. May be heard in committee March 17. |
| Feb 12, 2016 | Read first time. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Jun 30, 2016 | Consent Calendar 2nd AB1963 Calderon | Senate Floor |
Passed |
|
| Jun 14, 2016 | Do pass and be ordered to the Consent Calendar | Senate Standing Committee on Judiciary |
Passed |
|
| Apr 7, 2016 | AB 1963 CALDERON Consent Calendar Second Day Regular Session | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| Mar 29, 2016 | Do pass as amended. To Consent Calendar. | Assembly Standing Committee on Judiciary |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | AB |
CONSENT
Bill No: AB 1963
:
SENATE JUDICIARY COMMITTEE: 7-0, 6/14/16
AYES: Jackson, Moorlach, Anderson, Hertzberg, Leno, Monning, Wieckowski
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 77-0, 4/7/16 (Consent) - See last page for vote
SOURCE: California Building Industry Association
DIGEST: This bill extends, until July 1, 2024, a requirement that a homeowner association in a common interest development of more than 20 units follow a pre-litigation dispute resolution procedure before commencing a design or construction defect action against a builder, developer, or general contractor.
Existing law:
- Defines, in the Davis-Stirling Common Interest Development Act (Davis-Stirling Act), and regulates residential common interest developments (CIDs), including the ability of an association to levy regular and special assessments sufficient to perform its obligations. (Civ. Code Sec. 4000 et seq.)
- Requires, before an association files a complaint for damages against a builder, developer, or general contractor (respondent) of a CID based upon a claim for defects in the design or construction of the CID, certain specified requirements to be satisfied. (Civ. Code Sec. 6000 et seq.)
- Requires an association to serve upon the respondent a “Notice of Commencement of Legal Proceedings,” indicating the name and location of the project, an initial list of defects sufficient to apprise the respondent of the general nature of the defects at issue, a description of the results of the defects, if known, a summary of the results of a survey or questionnaire distributed to homeowners to determine the nature and extent of defects, if a survey has been conducted or a questionnaire has been distributed, and either a summary of the results of testing conducted to determine the nature and extent of defects or the actual test results, if that testing has been conducted. (Civ. Code Sec. 6000(b).)
- Specifies that service of the notice shall commence a period, not to exceed 180 days, during which the association, the respondent, and all other participating parties shall try to resolve the dispute through a specified process, and states that service of the notice shall toll all applicable statutes of limitation and repose, whether contractual or statutory, by and against all potentially responsible parties, regardless of whether they were named in the notice, including claims for indemnity. (Civ. Code Sec. 6000(b), (c).)
- States that upon receipt of the notice, the respondent shall provide the association with access to specified information for the project reasonably calculated to lead to the discovery of admissible evidence regarding the defects claimed within 60 days. (Civ. Code Sec. 6000(e).)
- States that within 20 days of sending the notice, the association, respondent, subcontractors, design professionals, and their insurers shall meet and confer in an effort to select a dispute resolution facilitator to preside over the specified mandatory dispute resolution process. (Civ. Code Sec. 6000(f).)
- Provides, among other things, that the respondent may submit to the association a request to meet with the association’s board of directors to discuss a written settlement offer. If the board rejects a settlement offer presented at the meeting, the board shall hold a meeting open to each member of the association no less than 15 days before the association commences an action for damages against the respondent. No less than 15 days before this meeting is held, a written notice shall be sent to each member of the association specifying all of the following:
- That a meeting will take place to discuss problems that may lead to the filing of a civil action, and the time and place of this meeting;
- The options that are available to address the problems, including the filing of a civil action and a statement of the various alternatives that are reasonably foreseeable by the association to pay for those options and whether these payments are expected to be made from the use of reserve account funds or the imposition of regular or special assessments, or emergency assessment increases; and
- The complete text of any written settlement offer, and a concise explanation of the specific reasons for the terms of the offer received from the respondent. (Civ. Code Sec. 6000(k).)
- States that all defect lists and demands, communications, negotiations, and settlement offers made in the course of the pre-litigation dispute resolution process shall be inadmissible, as specified. (Civ. Code Sec. 6000(l).)
- States that any party may at any time petition the superior court in the county where the project is located, upon a showing of good cause, to resolve a dispute or make a determination, as specified. (Civ. Code Sec. 6000(n).)
- States that the pre-litigation dispute resolution process shall become inoperative on July 1, 2017, and, as of January 1, 2018, is repealed, unless a later enacted statute, that becomes operative on or before January 1, 2018, deletes or extends the dates on which it becomes inoperative and is repealed. (Civ. Code Sec. 6000(s).)
This bill extends the above sunset date by seven years, stating that the pre-litigation dispute resolution process shall become inoperative on July 1, 2024, and, as of January 1, 2025, is repealed, unless a later enacted statute, that becomes operative on or before January 1, 2025, deletes or extends the dates on which it becomes inoperative and is repealed.
Background
In California, residential CIDs are governed by the Davis-Stirling Act. Owners of separate property in a CID have an undivided interest in the common property of the development and are subject to the CID’s covenants, conditions, and restrictions. Residential CIDs are governed by a homeowner association, which is run by volunteer directors that may or may not have prior experience managing an association.
In 1995, the Davis-Stirling Act was amended to require homeowner associations to take part in specified pre-litigation dispute resolution procedures before commencing a design or construction defect action against the builder, developer, or general contractor of the CID. (See SB 1029, Calderon, Chapter 864, Statutes of 1995; Civ. Code Sec. 6000.) According to the Senate Judiciary Committee analysis of that bill:
The author has introduced [SB 1029] because in many instances, expensive and time-consuming litigation alleging defects in the design or construction of common interest developments are commenced before the parties have a reasonable opportunity to discuss the merits of the claim, or to consider alternative proposals to resolve the claim. The author believes that the initiation of such litigation prior to a meaningful opportunity for the parties to meet and confer is detrimental because of the substantial costs to both parties, and to the courts, of complex construction defect litigation which in many instances could be avoided. (Sen. Com. on Judiciary, Analysis of Sen. Bill No. 1029 (1995–1996 Reg. Sess.) as amended Mar. 29, 1995, p. 7 [for hearing on May 9, 1995].)
In 2001, the Act was further amended to require an association to serve a “Notice of Commencement of Legal Proceedings” on the respondent builder, developer, or general contractor, including an initial list of defects sufficient to apprise the respondent of the general nature of the defects at issue, and also specified timelines and procedures for parties to follow during the pre-litigation dispute resolution process. (See AB 1700, Steinberg, Chapter 824, Statutes of 2001.) AB 1700 included a sunset provision that would have rendered the CID pre-litigation dispute resolution requirement inoperative on July 1, 2010. In 2009, AB 927 (Calderon, Chapter 7, Statutes of 2009) extended the effective date of the CID pre-litigation dispute resolution requirement to July 1, 2017, and repeals the requirement on January 1, 2018, unless a later enacted statute deletes or extends these dates.
This bill extends until July 1, 2024, the requirement that homeowner associations take part in the pre-litigation dispute resolution process, and repeals this requirement on January 1, 2025, unless a later enacted statute deletes or extends these dates.
Comments
According to the author:
Before a homeowner’s association may file a complaint for damages against a builder, developer, or general contractor of a [common interest development] based upon a claim for defects in the design or construction of the development, the association must first engage in the extensive pre-litigation process specified by Civil Code Section 6000, under the Davis-Stirling Act. This process was initially established by the Legislature in 1995, and since then has been revised and reauthorized twice before for seven-year trial periods, the last one of which ends on July 1, 2017. This process is also referred to as the “Section 6000 process” and requires among other things:
- the plaintiff to provide notice;
- within 25 days, the respondent may request a meeting with the [association] board of directors within 10 days;
- the association and respondent to exchange information about the defect within 60 days of the notice;
- the respondent to provide notice to subcontractors, design professionals, and insurers within 60 days of the notice;
- within 20 days of the notice to subcontractors, that all parties meet to select a mediator and establish a procedure to request the court to select a mediator if they cannot agree; and
- mediation costs to be split equally.
AB 1963 would extend the sunset for the “Section 6000” pre-litigation process for an additional seven years. It encourages disputes about construction defects in common interest developments to be settled or sent to alternative dispute resolution before a lawsuit is filed. This process has worked for the last twenty years, by providing an avenue for dispute resolution prior to costly and time-consuming lawsuits. In an era of overcrowded court dockets, the Legislature should act to preserve a process that relieves some of this pressure on our already overburdened courts. AB 1963 will ensure that homeowners and builders are able to continue to resolve disagreements in a cost effective manner that is careful to preserve the legal options of those involved.
Prior Legislation
AB 927 (Calderon, Chapter 7, Statutes of 2009) See Background.
AB 1700 (Steinberg, Chapter 824, Statutes of 2001) See Background.
SB 1029 (Calderon, Chapter 864, Statutes of 1995) See Background.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: Fiscal Com.: Local:
California Building Industry Association (source)
American Subcontractors Association California, Inc.
California Land Surveyors Association
California Professional Association of Specialty Contractors
Community Associations Institute
Construction Employers’ Association
OPPOSITION: (Verified 6/14/16)
None received
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 77-0, 4/7/16
AYES: Achadjian, Alejo, Travis Allen, Atkins, Baker, Bigelow, Bloom, Bonilla, Bonta, Brough, Brown, Burke, Calderon, Chang, Chau, Chávez, Chiu, Chu, Cooley, Cooper, Dababneh, Dahle, Daly, Dodd, Eggman, Frazier, Beth Gaines, Gallagher, Cristina Garcia, Eduardo Garcia, Gatto, Gipson, Gomez, Gonzalez, Gordon, Gray, Grove, Hadley, Harper, Roger Hernández, Holden, Irwin, Jones, Jones-Sawyer, Kim, Lackey, Linder, Lopez, Low, Maienschein, Mathis, Mayes, McCarty, Medina, Melendez, Mullin, Nazarian, Obernolte, O'Donnell, Olsen, Patterson, Quirk, Ridley-Thomas, Rodriguez, Salas, Santiago, Steinorth, Mark Stone, Thurmond, Ting, Wagner, Waldron, Weber, Wilk, Williams, Wood, Rendon
NO VOTE RECORDED: Campos, Levine
6/17/16 15:03:41
**** END ****
Senator Hannah-Beth Jackson, Chair
2015-2016 Regular Session
Bill No: AB 1963 (Author:Calderon)
Version: April 4, 2016
Hearing Date: June 14, 2016
Fiscal: No
Urgency: No
Consultant: TH
SUBJECT
Common Interest Developments: Construction Defects
DESCRIPTION
Existing law requires, until July 1, 2017, a homeowner association in a common interest development of more than 20 units to follow a pre-litigation dispute resolution procedure before commencing a design or construction defect action against a builder, developer, or general contractor. This bill would extend the above sunset date to July 1, 2024.
BACKGROUND
In California, residential common interest developments (CIDs) are governed by the Davis-Stirling Common Interest Development Act (Davis-Stirling Act). Owners of separate property in a CID have an undivided interest in the common property of the development and are subject to the CID’s covenants, conditions, and restrictions. Residential CIDs are governed by a homeowner association, which is run by volunteer directors that may or may not have prior experience managing an association.
In 1995, the Davis-Stirling Act was amended to require homeowner associations to take part in specified pre-litigation dispute resolution procedures before commencing a design or construction defect action against the builder, developer, or general contractor of the CID. (See SB 1029, Calderon, Ch. 864, Stats. 1995; Civ. Code Sec. 6000.) According to the Senate Judiciary Committee analysis of that bill:
The author has introduced [SB 1029] because in many instances, expensive and time-consuming litigation alleging defects in the design or construction of common interest developments are commenced before the parties have a reasonable opportunity to discuss the merits of the claim, or to consider alternative proposals to resolve the claim. The author believes that the initiation of such litigation prior to a meaningful opportunity for the parties to meet and confer is detrimental because of the substantial costs to both parties, and to the courts, of complex construction defect litigation which in many instances could be avoided. (Sen. Com. on Judiciary, Analysis of Sen. Bill No. 1029 (1995–1996 Reg. Sess.) as amended Mar. 29, 1995, p. 7 [for hearing on May 9, 1995].)
In 2001, the Act was further amended to require an association to serve a “Notice of Commencement of Legal Proceedings” on the respondent builder, developer, or general contractor, including an initial list of defects sufficient to apprise the respondent of the general nature of the defects at issue, and also specified timelines and procedures for parties to follow during the pre-litigation dispute resolution process. (See AB 1700, Steinberg, Ch. 824, Stats. 2001.) AB 1700 included a sunset provision that would have rendered the CID pre-litigation dispute resolution requirement inoperative on July 1, 2010. In 2009, AB 927 (Calderon, Ch. 7, Stats. 2009) extended the effective date of the CID pre-litigation dispute resolution requirement to July 1, 2017, and repeals the requirement on January 1, 2018, unless a later enacted statute deletes or extends these dates.
This bill would extend until July 1, 2024, the requirement that homeowner associations take part in the pre-litigation dispute resolution process, and would repeal this requirement on January 1, 2025, unless a later enacted statute deletes or extends these dates.
CHANGES TO EXISTING LAW
Existing law, the Davis-Stirling Common Interest Development Act, defines and regulates residential common interest developments (CIDs), including the ability of the association to levy regular and special assessments sufficient to perform its obligations. (Civ. Code Sec. 4000 et seq.)
Existing law requires, before an association files a complaint for damages against a builder, developer, or general contractor (respondent) of a common interest development based upon a claim for defects in the design or construction of the common interest development, certain specified requirements to be satisfied. (Civ. Code Sec. 6000 et seq.)
Existing law requires an association to serve upon the respondent a “Notice of Commencement of Legal Proceedings,” indicating the name and location of the project, an initial list of defects sufficient to apprise the respondent of the general nature of the defects at issue, a description of the results of the defects, if known, a summary of the results of a survey or questionnaire distributed to homeowners to determine the nature and extent of defects, if a survey has been conducted or a questionnaire has been distributed, and either a summary of the results of testing conducted to determine the nature and extent of defects or the actual test results, if that testing has been conducted. (Civ. Code Sec. 6000(b).)
Existing law specifies that service of the notice shall commence a period, not to exceed 180 days, during which the association, the respondent, and all other participating parties shall try to resolve the dispute through a specified process, and states that service of the notice shall toll all applicable statutes of limitation and repose, whether contractual or statutory, by and against all potentially responsible parties, regardless of whether they were named in the notice, including claims for indemnity. (Civ. Code Sec. 6000(b), (c).)
Existing law states that, upon receipt of the notice, the respondent shall provide the association with access to specified information for the project reasonably calculated to lead to the discovery of admissible evidence regarding the defects claimed within 60 days. (Civ. Code Sec. 6000(e).)
Existing law states that within 20 days of sending the notice, the association, respondent, subcontractors, design professionals, and their insurers shall meet and confer in an effort to select a dispute resolution facilitator to preside over the specified mandatory dispute resolution process. (Civ. Code Sec. 6000(f).)
Existing law provides, among other things, that the respondent may submit to the association a request to meet with the board to discuss a written settlement offer. If the board rejects a settlement offer presented at the meeting, the board shall hold a meeting open to each member of the association no less than 15 days before the association commences an action for damages against the respondent. No less than 15 days before this meeting is held, a written notice shall be sent to each member of the association specifying all of the following:
- that a meeting will take place to discuss problems that may lead to the filing of a civil action, and the time and place of this meeting;
- the options that are available to address the problems, including the filing of a civil action and a statement of the various alternatives that are reasonably foreseeable by the association to pay for those options and whether these payments are expected to be made from the use of reserve account funds or the imposition of regular or special assessments, or emergency assessment increases; and
- the complete text of any written settlement offer, and a concise explanation of the specific reasons for the terms of the offer received from the respondent. (Civ. Code Sec. 6000(k).)
Existing law states that all defect lists and demands, communications, negotiations, and settlement offers made in the course of the pre-litigation dispute resolution process shall be inadmissible, as specified. (Civ. Code Sec. 6000(l).)
Existing law states that any party may at any time petition the superior court in the county where the project is located, upon a showing of good cause, to resolve a dispute or make a determination, as specified. (Civ. Code Sec. 6000(n).)
Existing law states that the pre-litigation dispute resolution process shall become inoperative on July 1, 2017, and, as of January 1, 2018, is repealed, unless a later enacted statute, that becomes operative on or before January 1, 2018, deletes or extends the dates on which it becomes inoperative and is repealed. (Civ. Code Sec. 6000(s).)
This bill extends the above sunset date by seven years, stating that the pre-litigation dispute resolution process shall become inoperative on July 1, 2024, and, as of January 1, 2025, is repealed, unless a later enacted statute, that becomes operative on or before January 1, 2025, deletes or extends the dates on which it becomes inoperative and is repealed.
COMMENT
- Stated need for the bill
According to the author:
Before a homeowner’s association may file a complaint for damages against a builder, developer, or general contractor of a [common interest development] based upon a claim for defects in the design or construction of the development, the association must first engage in the extensive pre-litigation process specified by Civil Code Section 6000, under the Davis-Stirling Act. This process was initially established by the Legislature in 1995, and since then has been revised and reauthorized twice before for seven-year trial periods, the last one of which ends on July 1, 2017. This process is also referred to as the “Section 6000 process” and requires among other things:
- the plaintiff to provide notice;
- within 25 days, the respondent may request a meeting with the [association] board of directors within 10 days;
- the association and respondent to exchange information about the defect within 60 days of the notice;
- the respondent to provide notice to subcontractors, design professionals, and insurers within 60 days of the notice;
- within 20 days of the notice to subcontractors, that all parties meet to select a mediator and establish a procedure to request the court to select a mediator if they cannot agree; and
- mediation costs to be split equally.
AB 1963 would extend the sunset for the “Section 6000” pre-litigation process for an additional seven years. It encourages disputes about construction defects in common interest developments to be settled or sent to alternative dispute resolution before a lawsuit is filed. This process has worked for the last twenty years, by providing an avenue for dispute resolution prior to costly and time-consuming lawsuits. In an era of overcrowded court dockets, the Legislature should act to preserve a process that relieves some of this pressure on our already overburdened courts. AB 1963 will ensure that homeowners and builders are able to continue to resolve disagreements in a cost effective manner that is careful to preserve the legal options of those involved.
- Pre-litigation Dispute Resolution Process
Existing law establishes a pre-litigation dispute resolution process that must be followed prior to an association filing a lawsuit against a builder, general contractor, or developer of a common interest development with 20 or more units regarding claims for defects in the design or construction of the development. While the dispute resolution process is ongoing, the statute of limitation on the association’s claim or claims is tolled, generally for a period of 180 days, unless the parties agree to extend the process beyond 180 days. The five general steps of this process are described below.
Step 1: Before filing suit, the association must give written notice to the builder. This notice, denoted a “Notice of Commencement of Legal Proceedings,” must include, among other things:
- an initial list of defects sufficient to apprise the respondent of the general nature of the defects at issue; and
- either a summary of the results of testing conducted to determine the nature and extent of defects or the actual test results, if that testing has been conducted.
Service of the notice commences a period, not to exceed 180 days unless extended by the parties, during which the association, the respondent, and all other participating parties try to resolve the dispute through the process.
Step 2: Within 25 days, the respondent may request in writing to meet and confer with the association, which meeting must take place 10 days after the request. Upon receipt of the notice, the respondent must, within 60 days, provide the association with specified information pertaining to the project that may lead to evidence concerning the defects claimed by the association. Likewise, the association must provide the respondent with specified information concerning the defects claimed by the association, such as reserve studies, maintenance records, and test results.
The respondent must also provide written notice by certified mail to all subcontractors, design professionals, their insurers, and the insurers of any additional insured whose identities are known to the respondent or are readily ascertainable and whose potential responsibility appears on the face of the notice. This notice must include a copy of the Notice of Commencement of Legal Proceedings, and must specify the date and manner by which the parties shall meet and confer to select a dispute resolution facilitator.
Step 3: Within 20 days of sending the above notice, the association, respondent, subcontractors, design professionals, and their insurers must meet and confer in an effort to select a dispute resolution facilitator to preside over a mandatory dispute resolution process. Once selected, the dispute resolution facilitator and the participating parties agree to a date, time, and location to hold a case management meeting of all parties to discuss the claims being asserted and the scheduling of events in the process.
The costs of the dispute resolution facilitator are apportioned among the parties as follows: one-third to be paid by the association; one-third to be paid by the respondent; and one-third to be paid by the subcontractors and design professionals, as allocated among them by the dispute resolution facilitator. The costs of the dispute resolution facilitator are recoverable by the prevailing party in any subsequent litigation.
Step 4: No later than the case management meeting, the parties must begin to generate data showing the following information regarding the alleged defects:
- the scope of the work performed by each potentially responsible subcontractor;
- the tract or phase number in which each subcontractor provided goods or services, or both; and
- the units, either by address, unit number, or lot number, at which each subcontractor provided goods or services, or both.
At the case management meeting, the parties must come to an agreement on several issues with regard to resolving the dispute, including:
- the provision of a detailed list of defects by the association to the respondent after the association completes a visual inspection of the project;
- invasive testing conducted by the association, respondent, or other party, if deemed appropriate;
- provision by the association of a comprehensive demand which provides sufficient detail for the parties to engage in meaningful dispute resolution; and
- facilitated dispute resolution of the claim, with all parties present and having settlement authority.
Step 5: After the selection of a dispute resolution facilitator, and at his or her determination, the respondent may submit to the association a request to meet with the board to discuss a written settlement offer. No less than 10 days after the respondent submits required settlement information to the association, the respondent and the board must meet and confer about the settlement offer. If the board rejects the settlement offer, the board must hold a meeting open to each member of the association no less than 15 days before the association commences an action for damages against the respondent. Fifteen days prior to that open meeting, the board must send the following to each member of the association:
- notice that an open meeting will take place to discuss problems that may lead to the filing of a civil action, and the time and place of the meeting;
- options available to address the problems identified, including the filing of a civil action and a statement of the various alternatives to pay for those options and whether these payments are expected to be made from the use of reserve account funds or the imposition of regular or special assessments, or emergency assessment increases; and
- the text of any written settlement offer, and a concise explanation of the specific reasons for the terms of the offer.
The respondent is obligated to pay all expenses attributable to sending the settlement offer to members of the association, and for the expense of holding the meeting, up to a specified limit.
At any point during the pre-litigation dispute resolution process, any party may petition the superior court to resolve a dispute concerning the process, including disagreements relative to the timing of specific events, or to the production of documents or the exchange of information.
- Extension of Sunset Date
Under current law, the pre-litigation dispute resolution process described in Comment 2 is scheduled to sunset on July 1, 2017. This bill would extend that sunset date by seven years, delaying its terminal date to July 1, 2024. The California Land Surveyors Association, writing in support, states:
The provisions of Section 6000 of the Civil Code set forth a balanced procedure whereby a land surveyor or other party is provided notice of intent to file construction defect litigation and provided an opportunity to present facts to a dispute resolution facilitator. This pre-litigation process not only results in the non-inclusion of a land surveyor in subsequently filed litigation, but also expedites the court time and expense necessary to try construction defect litigation. It is important for all parties to continue to use the pre-litigation process in Section 6000.
In the past, this Committee has raised concerns about imposing mandatory pre-litigation dispute resolution procedures. First, procedures that are too complex or too time-consuming could place an unfair obstacle in the path of a litigant – here, a homeowner association – who seeks to vindicate its rights. Second, mandatory pre-litigation procedures could be used as a tool by defendants to make procedural objections and prevent a court from ruling on the merits of a litigant’s claim. However, it does not appear that these concerns are warranted with respect to this particular pre-litigation dispute resolution process for several reasons. First, the process, by its terms, must be completed within 180 days, unless the parties agree to extend that period, and during that time all applicable statutes of limitation are tolled. Second, as described in Comment 2, the process does not appear to be overly complex or difficult to execute. Finally, as noted in the Background, this particular process has been in place, in varying forms, for at least 20 years, and during that time the Committee has not received any significant indication that the process acts to frustrate the vindication of rights, or that it has been abused by litigants for procedural advantage.
Support: American Subcontractors Association California, Inc.; California Land Surveyors Association; California Professional Association of Specialty Contractors; Community Associations Institute; Construction Employers’ Association
Opposition: None Known
HISTORY
Source: California Building Industry Association
Related Pending Legislation: None Known
Prior Legislation:
AB 927 (Calderon, Ch. 7, Stats. 2009) See Background.
AB 1700 (Steinberg, Ch. 824, Stats. 2001) See Background.
SB 1029 (Calderon, Ch. 864, Stats. 1995) See Background.
Prior Vote:
Assembly Floor (Ayes 77, Noes 0)
Assembly Judiciary Committee (Ayes 10, Noes 0)
**************
Date of Hearing:
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON
, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:
Author:() – As Ver:
PROPOSED CONSENT (As Proposed to be Amended)
SUBJECT:
KEY ISSUE: should THE SUNSET DATE for provisions establshing a pre-litigation process in construction defect cases involving common interest developments be extended for an additional seven years?
SYNOPSIS
Before a homeowner's association may file a complaint for damages against a builder, developer, or general contractor of a common interest development based upon a claim for defects in the design or construction of the development, the association must first engage in the extensive pre-litigation process specified by Civil Code Section 6000, under the Davis-Stirling Act. This process was initially established by the Legislature in 1995, and since then has been revised and reauthorized twice before for seven-year trial periods, the last one of which ends on July 1, 2017. As proposed to be amended, this bill seeks to extend the existing sunset date by seven years, until July 1, 2024, and retain existing law authorizing this pre-litigation process. According to the legislative history of this pre-litigation process (aka "the Calderon process"), was the product of extensive negotiations involving many stakeholders, including the California Building Industry Association (the sponsor of this bill), the Consumer Attorneys of California, and homeowners' associations. When contacted by the Committee, these stakeholders reported varying degrees of satisfaction with the process, including some comments that the process needs further examination or clarification in order to be effective. However, no group or organization expressed opposition to extending the sunset date an additional seven years, as proposed to be amended in this Committee. The bill is supported by the California Building Industry Association and the California Professional Association of Specialty Contractors, and has no registered opposition.
SUMMARY: Retains existing law, Civil Code Section 6000, establishing special pre-litigation procedures in construction defect disputes involving common interest developments. Specifically, this bill extends the existing sunset date for seven years, until July 1, 2024, for Civil Code Section 6000, and repeals these provisions as of January 1, 2025, unless a later enacted statute becomes operative on or before that date.
EXISTING LAW:
- Requires, until July 1, 2017, that the parties in a construction defect dispute involving a common interest development follow a specified pre-litigation process ("Section 6000 process"), including mandatory mediation, before a plaintiff homeowner association may file a complaint for damages against the builder and others based upon a claim for defects in the design or construction of the development. Among other things, the Section 6000 process:
- Requires the association to provide the builder, developer, or general contractor (respondent) with a written "Notice of Commencement of Legal Proceedings" which includes certain information regarding defects in the development. This notice tolls the statute of limitations on all construction defect claims for all potentially responsible parties for 180 days, which can be extended by another 180 days with the consent of all the parties. (Civil Code Section 6000 (b). Further references are to this code, unless otherwise stated.)
- Provides that within 25 days of the notice, the respondent may request to meet with the association's board of directors within 10 days. (Section 6000 (d).)
- Requires, within 60 days of the notice, that the association and the respondent exchange certain information regarding defects, and that the respondent provide written notice to all subcontractors, design professionals, and insurers known or reasonably ascertainable to the respondent whose potential responsibility appears on the face of the notice. (Section 6000 (e).)
- Requires, within 20 days of the above notice to subcontractors, that the association, respondent, and all noticed parties meet to select a special mediator to handle the dispute resolution, and establishes procedures to apply to the court to select the mediator if the parties cannot reach agreement. (Section 6000 (f)(1).)
- Provides that the costs of the mediator be apportioned equally between the association, the respondent, and any subcontractors, with cost allocations among the subcontractors made by the mediator. (Section 6000 (f)(6).)
- Establishes procedures to be followed during the mediation process for the collection and sharing of relevant information between the parties necessary to facilitate the mediation, requires preparation of a case management statement, and allows the mediator considerable discretion to set timelines and requirements for the mediation process. (Section 6000, subd. (h) to (j).)
- Permits the parties to petition the court, upon a showing of good cause, to issue an order or appoint a referee to resolve disputes involving various aspects of the mediation process, including, among other things, whether a deposition of any party should be taken, to resolve any dispute over inspection, testing or production of documents, and whether a settlement offer is in good faith. (Section 6000 (n).)
- Sunsets on July 1, 2017, and, as of January 1, 2018, is repealed, unless a later enacted statute, that becomes operative on or before January 1, 2018, deletes or extends the dates on which it becomes inoperative and is repealed. (Section 6000 (s).)
- Establishes a comprehensive procedural scheme for handling construction defect litigation generally (whether or not a common interest development is involved), as established by SB 800 (Burton), Ch. 770, Stats. 2012 (hereafter "SB 800 process"). Under the SB 800 process:
- Construction defects are defined to ensure specified performance standards. (Section 896.)
- Homeowners must follow a specified procedure before bringing suit against a builder, including providing written notice to the builder regarding alleged violations. (Section 910.)
- Builders are guaranteed an absolute right to repair alleged defects before a claimant may sue. (Sections 917 to 919.)
- Homeowners retain the right to sue and pursue remedies if the repair is not made or is inadequate. (Sections 941 to 945.5.)
FISCAL EFFECT: As currently in print this bill is keyed non-fiscal.
COMMENTS: Before a homeowners' association may file a complaint for damages against a builder, developer, or general contractor of a common interest development (CID) based upon a claim for defects in the design or construction of the development, the association must first engage in the extensive pre-litigation process specified by Civil Code Section 6000, part of the Davis-Stirling Act. Pursuant to Section 6000, the association must, among other things: (1) file a notice regarding the commencement of legal proceedings; (2) engage in a meet and confer process to exchange documents relevant to the defects claimed and to select a mediator; (3) prepare a case management statement; and (4) participate in a mandatory mediation process to seek resolution of the dispute, as provided.
Legislative history and background of these provisions. This pre-litigation dispute resolution process now contained in Section 6000 was initially established by AB 1029 (Charles Calderon) in 1995, and was later revised and expanded by AB 267 (Steinberg) and AB 1700 (Steinberg) in 2001, at which time it was also reauthorized until 2010. It should also be noted, however, that in 2002, after a year of negotiations between many of the same stakeholders, the Legislature approved and the Governor signed SB 800 ((Burton and Wesson), Ch. 722, Stats. 2002), a historic piece of legislation that established significant reforms in the area of construction defect litigation generally, including cases not involving community interest developments. The requirements enacted by SB 800, including pre-litigation notice of alleged violations and a builder's right to repair alleged defects before a claimant may sue, were not subject to any sunset date and remain current law that applies in CID-related cases, on top of the so-called "Calderon process" provisions under Section 6000.
In 2009, the Legislature approved and the Governor signed AB 927 (Charles Calderon) which again reauthorized the Section 6000 provisions, this time until July 1, 2017. As proposed to be amended, this bill would extend the sunset date for an additional seven years, retaining existing law in this area until July 1, 2024.
According to the legislative history of this pre-litigation process, the statute was the product of extensive negotiations involving many stakeholders, including the California Building Industry Association, the Consumer Attorneys of California, and homeowners' associations, among others. (Senate Judiciary Committee analysis of AB 267; August 28, 2001.) When this Committee revisited the question of whether to reauthorize the process in 2009, it found that "by all accounts, existing law appears to be working adequately." (Assembly Judiciary Committee analysis of AB 927; April 14, 2009.)
Evaluation of the existing Calderon process. According to the California Building Industry Association (CBIA), the sponsor of this bill and the original sponsor of AB 1029 (1995), the pre-litigation process "encourages disputes about construction defects in common interest developments to be settled or sent to alternative dispute resolution before a lawsuit is filed . . . (and) allows parties to discuss the claim while still preserving legal recourse. In the twenty years since its establishment, the process has worked well to avoid costly, time consuming litigation."
When contacted by the Committee, representatives of the Community Associations Institute, representing homeowners' associations, reported that they were unaware of any major problems with the law experienced by their members, and adopted a neutral position on the bill.
While not opposing the extension of the sunset date for another seven years, the Consumer Attorneys of California (CAOC) stated that they believe the Calderon process needs further examination or clarification because their members report that it is rarely used, overlaps with the SB 800 process (described above), and often creates additional delay for homeowners who need to get their homes repaired. CAOC expressed willingness to work with the sponsors as the bill moves forward to address these problems, and remains neutral on the bill as proposed to be amended.
Author's proposed amendment to extend the sunset date until July 1, 2024. As proposed to be amended, this bill simply seeks to extend the 2017 sunset date for these provisions for an additional seven years, until July 1 2024. The amendment is:
On page 13, line 25, insert:
(s) This section shall become inoperative on July 1, 2024, and, as of January 1, 2025, is repealed, unless a later enacted statute, that becomes operative on or before January 1, 2025, deletes or extends the dates on which it becomes inoperative and is repealed.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
California Building Industry Association (CBIA) (sponsor)
California Professional Association of Specialty Contractors
Opposition
None on file
Analysis Prepared by:
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):