SB 948: California Environmental Quality Act community plans.
- Session Year: 2017-2018
- House: Senate
- Latest Version Date: 2018-04-30
The California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) requires a lead agency, as defined, to prepare, or cause to be prepared, and certify the completion of, an environmental impact report on a project that it proposes to carry out or approve that may have a significant effect on the environment or to adopt a negative declaration if it finds that the project will not have that effect. CEQA also requires a lead agency to prepare a mitigated negative declaration for a project that may have a significant effect on the environment if revisions in the project would avoid or mitigate that effect and there is no substantial evidence that the project, as revised, would have a significant effect on the environment.
The Jobs and Economic Improvement Through Environmental Leadership Act of 2011 authorizes the Governor, until January 1, 2021, to certify environmental leadership development projects that meet certain requirements for CEQA streamlining benefits provided by that act. The act defines environmental leadership development project to include certain kinds of projects, including residential, retail, commercial, sports, cultural, entertainment, or recreational use projects that meet specified requirements. The act authorizes the Governor to certify a project as an environmental leadership development project if the project meets certain conditions, including, among other things, that the project will result in a minimum investment of $100,000,000 in California upon completion of construction and the project will not result in any net additional emissions of greenhouse gases. The act requires a lead agency to prepare the record of proceedings for a certified project concurrent with the preparation of certain environmental documents.
This bill would specify that a authorize the Governor to certify updates to a community plan and the accompanying ordinances meeting specified requirements are a certified environmental leadership development project qualifying for as being eligible for the CEQA streamlining benefits provided by the Jobs and Economic Improvement Through Environmental Leadership Act of 2011.
The California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) requires a lead agency, as defined, to prepare, or cause to be prepared, and certify the completion of, an environmental impact report on a project that it proposes to carry out or approve that may have a significant effect on the environment or to adopt a negative declaration if it finds that the project will not have that effect. CEQA also requires a lead agency to prepare a mitigated negative declaration for a project that may have a significant effect on the environment if revisions in the project would avoid or mitigate that effect and there is no substantial evidence that the project, as revised, would have a significant effect on the environment.
The Jobs and Economic Improvement Through Environmental Leadership Act of 2011 authorizes the Governor, until January 1, 2021, to certify environmental leadership development projects that meet certain requirements for CEQA streamlining benefits provided by that act. The act defines environmental leadership development project to include certain kinds of projects, including residential, retail, commercial, sports, cultural, entertainment, or recreational use projects that meet specified requirements. The act authorizes the Governor to certify a project as an environmental leadership development project if the project meets certain conditions, including, among other things, that the project will result in a minimum investment of $100,000,000 in California upon completion of construction and the project will not result in any net additional emissions of greenhouse gases. The act requires a lead agency to prepare the record of proceedings for a certified project concurrent with the preparation of certain environmental documents.
This bill would specify that a community plan and the accompanying ordinances meeting specified requirements are a certified environmental leadership development project qualifying for CEQA streamlining benefits provided by the Jobs and Economic Improvement Through Environmental Leadership Act of 2011.
Under existing law, a conservation easement is a limitation in a recorded instrument designed to retain land predominantly in its natural, scenic, historical, agricultural, forested, on open-space condition. Existing law requires the Secretary of the Natural Resources Agency to establish a central public registry of all conservation easements held or required by the state, or purchased with state grant funds provided by an agency, department, or division of the state on or after January 1, 2000, as prescribed. Existing law requires the registry to be updated biennially.This bill would require the registry to be updated biennially or more frequently at the discretion of the secretary.Under existing law, a conservation easement is a limitation in a recorded instrument designed to retain land predominantly in its natural, scenic, historical, agricultural, forested, on open-space condition. Existing law requires the Secretary of the Natural Resources Agency to establish a central public registry of all conservation easements held or required by the state, or purchased with state grant funds provided by an agency, department, or division of the state on or after January 1, 2000, as prescribed. Existing law requires the registry to be updated biennially.
This bill would require the registry to be updated biennially or more frequently at the discretion of the secretary.
The Legislature finds and declares all of the following:
(a)The California Environmental Quality Act (Division 13 (commencing with Section 21000) of the Public Resources Code) requires that the environmental impacts, if any, of updated community plans be identified and mitigated. The act also guarantees the public an opportunity to review and comment on the environmental impacts of a project and to participate meaningfully in the development of mitigation measures for potentially significant environmental impacts.
(b)In many parts of the state, the city or countywide general plans cover so much geographic territory that local jurisdictions also adopt community plans. These community plans allow for tailored and responsive land use planning at the neighborhood level.
(c)While most jurisdictions update the land use element of their general plan as part of their general plan update, those with multiple community plan areas update these documents individually, requiring community plans to be reviewed through separate reviews pursuant to the act. In some jurisdictions with multiple community plans, these plans have not been updated in recent years to reflect changing local priorities as well as efforts to improve air quality, reduce climate pollution, increase transit ridership, reduce vehicle miles traveled, and provide more affordable housing.
(d)One significant obstacle to updating these plans is the uncertainty that results if the environmental review document prepared pursuant to the act for the community plan update is challenged in a court. During the litigation process, it is unclear whether the community plan or the update will be in effect, causing developers and planners great uncertainty and potentially delaying all development in that community.
(e)Expediting the judicial review process for community plan updates that further the states climate, air quality, housing, and land use goals is the best way to ensure a thorough environmental review of community plan updates while minimizing the time the community is in limbo.
SEC. 2.Section 21184.7 is added to the Public Resources Code, to read:21184.7.(a)For purposes of this section, qualified community plan update means an update of a community plan, as defined in subdivision in subdivision (e) of Section 21083.3, and the accompanying ordinances.
(b)The Governor may certify a qualified community plan update as being subject to requirements of Section 21186 and the rule of court established pursuant to Section 21185 if the qualified community plan update meets all of the following requirements:
(1)Includes two or more transit priority areas, as defined in Section 21099.
(2)Is for a jurisdiction with a general plan that includes a circulation or mobility element adopted on or after January 1, 2015.
(3)Is consistent with a sustainable communities strategy or an alternative planning strategy adopted by an applicable metropolitan planning organization and certified by the State Air Resources Board as achieving the required reduction in the emissions of greenhouse gases pursuant to Section 65080 of the Government Code.
(4)Complies with the state ambient air quality standards established by the State Air Resources Board.
(5)Includes housing capacity to sufficiently accommodate regional housing needs projects as set forth in Section 65584.01 of the Government Code.
(6)Is consistent with applicable regional plans to protect environmentally sensitive habitat areas, agricultural land, parks, flood zones, and high fire areas.
(7)Includes projects and strategies designed to reduce vehicle miles traveled and does not result in any net additional emissions of greenhouse gases, including greenhouse gas emissions from employee transportation, as determined by the State Air Resources Board.
(8)Has begun an environmental review for the update on or after January 1, 2017.
(c)The governing board of the jurisdiction proposing a qualified community plan update may apply to the Governor for certification pursuant to subdivision (b) by supplying evidence and materials sufficient to show to the Governor that the requirements set forth in subdivision (b) are met.
(d)A qualified community plan update certified by the Governor pursuant to subdivision (b) is subject to the requirements of Section 21186 and the rules of court adopted pursuant to Section 21185.
(e)This section does not affect or alter the obligation of a project that is consistent with an approved qualified community plan update to comply with this division or the eligibility of such a project for certification pursuant to Section 21183.
SECTION 1.Section 21184.7 is added to the Public Resources Code, to read:21184.7.(a)For purposes of this section, community plan project means a community plan, as defined in subdivision (e) of Section 21083.3, and the accompanying ordinances that meets all of the following requirements:(1)Include two or more transit priority areas, as defined in Section 21099.(2)Are for a jurisdiction with a general plan that includes a circulation or mobility element adopted on or after January 1, 2015.(3)Are consistent with a sustainable communities strategy or an alternative planning strategy adopted by an applicable metropolitan planning organization and certified by the State Air Resources Board as achieving the required reduction in the emissions of greenhouse gases pursuant to Section 65080 of the Government Code.(4)Comply with the regional clean air standards established by the State Air Resources Board.(5)Include housing capacity to sufficiently accommodate regional housing needs projects as set forth in Section 65584.01 of the Government Code.(6)Are consistent with applicable regional plans to protect environmentally sensitive habitat areas, agricultural land, parks, flood zones, and high fire areas.(7)Include projects and strategies designed to reduce vehicle miles traveled.(8)Receive final approval after January 1, 2017.(b)A community plan project is a leadership project that shall be deemed to be certified by the Governor and is subject to this chapter.(a)For purposes of this section, community plan project means a community plan, as defined in subdivision (e) of Section 21083.3, and the accompanying ordinances that meets all of the following requirements:
(1)Include two or more transit priority areas, as defined in Section 21099.
(2)Are for a jurisdiction with a general plan that includes a circulation or mobility element adopted on or after January 1, 2015.
(3)Are consistent with a sustainable communities strategy or an alternative planning strategy adopted by an applicable metropolitan planning organization and certified by the State Air Resources Board as achieving the required reduction in the emissions of greenhouse gases pursuant to Section 65080 of the Government Code.
(4)Comply with the regional clean air standards established by the State Air Resources Board.
(5)Include housing capacity to sufficiently accommodate regional housing needs projects as set forth in Section 65584.01 of the Government Code.
(6)Are consistent with applicable regional plans to protect environmentally sensitive habitat areas, agricultural land, parks, flood zones, and high fire areas.
(7)Include projects and strategies designed to reduce vehicle miles traveled.
(8)Receive final approval after January 1, 2017.
(b)A community plan project is a leadership project that shall be deemed to be certified by the Governor and is subject to this chapter.
SECTION 1.Section 5096.520 of the Public Resources Code is amended to read:5096.520.(a)The Secretary of the Natural Resources Agency shall establish a central public registry of all conservation easements held or required by the state, or purchased with state grant funds provided by an agency, department, or division of the state on or after January 1, 2000. In constructing the registry, the Natural Resources Agency shall draw upon the Department of General Services property inventory, and other information held by a state agency, department, division, or other sources.(b)For the purposes of this section, conservation easement means any limitation in a recorded instrument that contains an easement, restriction, covenant, condition, or offer to dedicate, that has been executed by or on behalf of the owner of the land that is subject to that limitation and is binding upon successive owners of the land, and the purpose of which is to retain land predominantly in its natural, scenic, historical, agricultural, forested, or open-space condition. Conservation easement includes a conservation easement as defined in Section 815.1 of the Civil Code, an open-space easement as defined in Section 51075 of the Government Code, and an agricultural conservation easement as defined in Section 10211.(c)The registry shall only include the following information on each conservation easement that is listed in the registry:(1)The assessors parcel numbers for the property covered by the easement.(2)The purpose of the easement.(3)The location of the easement, identified by county and nearest city.(4)The identity of the easementholder.(5)The size of the easement in acres.(6)The date the easement transaction was recorded.(7)The amount of funding provided by the agency, department, or division of the state holding or requiring the easement or providing state grant funds for the easement.(d)An agency, department, or division of the state with conservation easements that are held or required by the state or purchased with state grant funds shall enter and keep current the information specified in subdivision (c) for those easements in the registry established pursuant to this section.(e)The Secretary of the Natural Resources Agency shall make the registry available for use by the general public. Only the information relating to paragraphs (2) to (6), inclusive, of subdivision (c) regarding conservation easements held or required by the state, or purchased with state grant funds provided by an agency, department, or division of the state on or after January 1, 2006, shall be provided by the Secretary of the Natural Resources Agency on the Internet. Personal identifying information shall not be posted on the Internet. The registry shall be updated biennially or more frequently at the discretion of the secretary.(a)The Secretary of the Natural Resources Agency shall establish a central public registry of all conservation easements held or required by the state, or purchased with state grant funds provided by an agency, department, or division of the state on or after January 1, 2000. In constructing the registry, the Natural Resources Agency shall draw upon the Department of General Services property inventory, and other information held by a state agency, department, division, or other sources.
(b)For the purposes of this section, conservation easement means any limitation in a recorded instrument that contains an easement, restriction, covenant, condition, or offer to dedicate, that has been executed by or on behalf of the owner of the land that is subject to that limitation and is binding upon successive owners of the land, and the purpose of which is to retain land predominantly in its natural, scenic, historical, agricultural, forested, or open-space condition. Conservation easement includes a conservation easement as defined in Section 815.1 of the Civil Code, an open-space easement as defined in Section 51075 of the Government Code, and an agricultural conservation easement as defined in Section 10211.
(c)The registry shall only include the following information on each conservation easement that is listed in the registry:
(1)The assessors parcel numbers for the property covered by the easement.
(2)The purpose of the easement.
(3)The location of the easement, identified by county and nearest city.
(4)The identity of the easementholder.
(5)The size of the easement in acres.
(6)The date the easement transaction was recorded.
(7)The amount of funding provided by the agency, department, or division of the state holding or requiring the easement or providing state grant funds for the easement.
(d)An agency, department, or division of the state with conservation easements that are held or required by the state or purchased with state grant funds shall enter and keep current the information specified in subdivision (c) for those easements in the registry established pursuant to this section.
(e)On or before January 1, 2009, the The Secretary of the Natural Resources Agency shall make the registry available for use by the general public. Only the information pertaining relating to paragraphs (2) to (6), inclusive, of subdivision (c) regarding conservation easements held or required by the state, or purchased with state grant funds provided by an agency, department, or division of the state on or after January 1, 2006, shall be provided by the Secretary of the Natural Resources Agency on the Internet. Personal identifying information shall not be posted on the Internet. The registry shall be updated biennially biennially or more frequently at the discretion of the secretary.
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| May 8, 2018 | May 8 set for first hearing canceled at the request of author. |
| Apr 30, 2018 | From committee with author's amendments. Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on JUD. |
| Apr 25, 2018 | Set for hearing May 8. |
| Apr 19, 2018 | Re-referred to Coms. on JUD. and APPR. |
| Apr 18, 2018 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on RLS. (Ayes 4. Noes 3.) (April 18). Re-referred to Com. on RLS. |
| Mar 29, 2018 | Set for hearing April 18. |
| Mar 21, 2018 | Re-referred to Coms. on EQ. and APPR. |
| Mar 12, 2018 | From committee with author's amendments. Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on RLS. |
| Feb 8, 2018 | Referred to Com. on RLS. |
| Jan 31, 2018 | From printer. May be acted upon on or after March 2. |
| Jan 30, 2018 | Introduced. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Apr 18, 2018 | Do pass, but first be re-referred to the Committee on [Rules] | Senate Standing Committee on Environmental Quality |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
Senator Hannah-Beth Jackson, Chair
2017-2018 Regular Session
Bill No: SB 948 (Author:Allen)
Version: April 30, 2018
Hearing Date: May 8, 2018
Fiscal: Yes
Urgency: No
Consultant: CK
SUBJECT
California Environmental Quality Act community plans
DESCRIPTION
This bill would authorize the Governor to certify updates to a community plan and the accompanying ordinances meeting specified requirements as being eligible for the California Environmental Quality Act streamlining benefits provided by the Jobs and Economic Improvement Through Environmental Leadership Act of 2011.
BACKGROUND
Enacted in 1970, the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) requires state and local agencies (public agencies) to follow a set protocol to disclose and evaluate the significant environmental impacts of proposed projects and to adopt feasible measures to mitigate those impacts. CEQA itself applies to “projects” undertaken or requiring approval by public agencies, and, if more than one agency is involved, CEQA requires one of the agencies to be designated as the “lead agency.” The environmental review process required by CEQA consists of: (1) determining if the activity is a project; (2) determining if the project is exempt from CEQA; and (3) performing an initial study to identify the environmental impacts and, depending on the findings, prepare either a Negative Declaration (for projects with no significant impacts), a Mitigated Negative Declaration (for projects with significant impacts but that are revised in some form to avoid or mitigate those impacts), or an Environmental Impact Report (for projects with significant impacts).
An Environmental Impact Report (EIR) must accurately describe the proposed project, identify and analyze each significant environmental impact expected to result from the proposed project, identify mitigation measures to reduce those impacts to the extent feasible, and evaluate a range of reasonable alternatives to the proposed project. Prior to approving any project that has received environmental review, an agency must make certain findings pertaining to the project’s environmental impact and any associated mitigation measures. If mitigation measures are required or incorporated into a project, the public agency must adopt a reporting or monitoring program to ensure compliance with those measures. To enforce the requirements of CEQA, a civil action may be brought under several code sections to attack, review, set aside, void, or annul the acts or decisions of a public agency for noncompliance with the act.
This bill would authorize the Governor to certify updates to a community plan and the accompanying ordinances meeting specified requirements as being eligible for the California Environmental Quality Act streamlining benefits provided by the Jobs and Economic Improvement Through Environmental Leadership Act of 2011.
This bill passed out of the Senate Environmental Quality Committee on a 4-3 vote.
CHANGES TO EXISTING LAW
Existing law, the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA), requires a public agency to prepare, or cause to be prepared, and to certify the completion of, an environmental impact report (EIR) on a project that it proposes to carry out or approve that may have a significant effect on the environment or to adopt a negative declaration if it finds that the project will not have that effect. (Pub. Resources Code Sec. 21100 et seq.)
Existing law defines “project” to mean an activity which may cause either a direct physical change in the environment, or a reasonably foreseeable indirect physical change in the environment, and which is any of the following:
- an activity directly undertaken by any public agency;
- an activity undertaken by a person which is supported, in whole or in part, through contracts, grants, subsidies, loans, or other forms of assistance from one or more public agencies; or,
- an activity that involves the issuance to a person of a lease, permit, license, certificate, or other entitlement for use by one or more public agencies. (Pub. Resources Code Sec. 21065.)
Existing law provides that an action or proceeding to attack, review, set aside, void, or annul the acts or decisions of a public agency on the grounds of noncompliance with CEQA may be commenced when, among other things, it is alleged that:
- a public agency is carrying out or has approved a project that may have a significant effect on the environment without having determined whether the project may have a significant effect on the environment;
- a public agency has improperly determined whether a project may have a significant effect on the environment;
- an environmental impact report prepared by, or caused to be prepared by, a public agency does not comply with CEQA;
- a public agency has improperly determined that a project is not subject to CEQA; or
- another act or omission of a public agency does not comply with CEQA. (Pub. Resources Code Sec. 21167.)
Existing law requires a plaintiff or petitioner to file a request that the respondent public agency prepare the record of proceedings relating to the underlying subject of the action or proceeding to attack, review, set aside, void, or annul its acts or decisions on the grounds of noncompliance with CEQA. Such request must be served personally within 10 business days from the filing of the action or proceeding. The public agency is then required to prepare a record of proceedings relating to the subject of the action or proceeding. The public agency’s record of proceedings shall include, among other things, any transcript or minutes of the proceedings at which the decisionmaking body of the public agency heard testimony on, or considered any environmental document on, the project, and any transcript or minutes of proceedings before any advisory body to the public agency that were presented to the decisionmaking body prior to action on the environmental documents or on the project. (Pub. Resources Code Sec. 21167.6.)
Existing law states that an action or proceeding to attack, review, set aside, void, or annul the acts or decisions of a public agency on the grounds of noncompliance with CEQA shall not be brought unless the alleged grounds for noncompliance were presented to the public agency orally or in writing by any person during the public comment period provided by CEQA or prior to the close of the public hearing on the project before the issuance of the notice of determination. (Pub. Resources Code Sec. 21177(a).)
Existing law states that a person shall not maintain an action or proceeding to attack, review, set aside, void, or annul the acts or decisions of a public agency on the grounds of noncompliance with CEQA unless that person objected to the approval of the project orally or in writing during the public comment period provided by CEQA or prior to the close of the public hearing on the project before the filing of the notice of determination. (Pub. Resources Code Sec. 21177(b).)
Existing law does not preclude any organization formed after the approval of a project from maintaining an action or proceeding to attack, review, set aside, void, or annul the acts or decisions of a public agency on the grounds of noncompliance with CEQA if a member of that organization has complied with the above two provisions. Existing law provides that the grounds for noncompliance may have been presented directly by a member or by a member agreeing with or supporting the comments of another person. (Pub. Resources Code Sec. 21177(c).)
Existing law provides that if a parcel has been zoned to accommodate a particular density of development or has been designated in a community plan to accommodate a particular density of development and an environmental impact report was certified for that zoning or planning action, the application of CEQA to the approval of any subdivision map or other project that is consistent with the zoning or community plan shall be limited to effects upon the environment which are peculiar to the parcel or to the project and which were not addressed as significant effects in the prior environmental impact report, or which substantial new information shows will be more significant than described in the prior environmental impact report. (Pub. Resources Code Sec. 21083.3(a).)
Existing law provides that if a development project is consistent with the general plan of a local agency and an environmental impact report was certified with respect to that general plan, the application of CEQA to the approval of that development project shall be limited to effects on the environment which are peculiar to the parcel or to the project and which were not addressed as significant effects in the prior environmental impact report, or which substantial new information shows will be more significant than described in the prior environmental impact report. (Pub. Resources Code Sec. 21083.3(b).)
Existing law, the Jobs and Economic Improvement through Environmental Leadership Act of 2011, provides special processes for environmental leadership development projects, which are eligible for streamlining. A person proposing to construct such a project may apply to the Governor for certification. (Pub. Resources Code Sec. 211 et seq.)
Existing law provides that the Governor may certify a leadership project for streamlining pursuant to the Jobs and Economic Improvement through Environmental Leadership Act of 2011 if all the following conditions are met:
- the project will result in a minimum investment of one hundred million dollars ($100,000,000) in California upon completion of construction;
- the project creates high-wage, highly skilled jobs that pay prevailing wages and living wages and provide construction jobs and permanent jobs for Californians, and helps reduce unemployment;
- contractors and subcontractors shall pay to all construction workers employed in the execution of the project at least the general prevailing rate of per diem wages;
- the project does not result in any net additional emission of greenhouse gases, including greenhouse gas emissions from employee transportation, as determined by the State Air Resources Board pursuant to Division 25.5 (commencing with Section 38500) of the Health and Safety Code;
- the project applicant demonstrates compliance with the requirements of Chapters 12.8 (commencing with Section 42649) and 12.9 (commencing with Section 42649.8) of Part 3 of Division 30, as applicable;
- the project applicant has entered into a binding and enforceable agreement that all mitigation measures required pursuant to CEQA to certify the project shall be conditions of approval of the project, and those conditions will be fully enforceable by the lead agency or another agency designated by the lead agency. In the case of environmental mitigation measures, the applicant agrees, as an ongoing obligation, that those measures will be monitored and enforced by the lead agency for the life of the obligation;
- the project applicant agrees to pay the costs of the Court of Appeal in hearing and deciding any case, including payment of the costs for the appointment of a special master if deemed appropriate by the court, in a form and manner specified by the Judicial Council, as provided in the Rules of Court adopted by the Judicial Council pursuant to Section 21185; and
- the project applicant agrees to pay the costs of preparing the record of proceedings for the project concurrent with review and consideration of the project pursuant to this division, in a form and manner specified by the lead agency for the project. (Pub. Resources Code Sec. 21183.)
Existing law provides that the Judicial Council shall adopt a rule of court to establish procedures applicable to actions or proceedings brought to attack, review, set aside, void, or annul the certification of the environmental impact report for an environmental leadership development project certified by the Governor or the granting of any project approvals that require the actions or proceedings, including any potential appeals therefrom, be resolved, to the extent feasible, within 270 days of the filing of the certified record of proceedings with the court. (Pub. Resources Code Sec. 21185.)
Existing law provides that, notwithstanding any other law, the preparation and certification of the record of proceedings for a leadership project certified by the Governor shall be performed in the following manner:
- the lead agency for the project shall prepare the record of proceedings pursuant to this division concurrently with the administrative process;
- all documents and other materials placed in the record of proceedings shall be posted on, and be downloadable from, an Internet Web site maintained by the lead agency commencing with the date of the release of the draft environmental impact report;
- the lead agency shall make available to the public in a readily accessible electronic format the draft environmental impact report and all other documents submitted to, or relied on by, the lead agency in the preparation of the draft environmental impact report;
- a document prepared by the lead agency or submitted by the applicant after the date of the release of the draft environmental impact report that is a part of the record of the proceedings shall be made available to the public in a readily accessible electronic format within five business days after the document is released or received by the lead agency;
- the lead agency shall encourage written comments on the project to be submitted in a readily accessible electronic format, and shall make any comment available to the public in a readily accessible electronic format within five days of its receipt;
- within seven business days after the receipt of any comment that is not in an electronic format, the lead agency shall convert that comment into a readily accessible electronic format and make it available to the public in that format, except as provided;
- the lead agency shall certify the final record of proceedings within five days of its approval of the project;
- any dispute arising from the record of proceedings shall be resolved by the superior court. Unless the superior court directs otherwise, a party disputing the content of the record shall file a motion to augment the record at the time it files its initial brief; and
- the contents of the record of proceedings shall be as set forth in subdivision (e) of Section 21167.6 of the Public Resources Code. (Pub. Resources Code Sec. 21186.)
Existing law defines “community plan” as a part of the general plan of a city or county which (1) applies to a defined geographic portion of the total area included in the general plan, (2) complies with Article 5 (commencing with Section 65300) of Chapter 3 of Division 1 of Title 7 of the Government Code by including or referencing each of the mandatory elements specified in Section 65302 of the Government Code, and (3) contains specific development policies adopted for the area included in the community plan and identifies measures to implement those policies, so that the policies which will apply to each parcel can be determined. Where a community plan is the basis for application of CEQA, any rezoning action consistent with the community plan shall be a project subject to exemption in accordance with CEQA. (Pub. Resources Code Sec. 21083.3.)
This bill would define “qualified community plan update” to mean an update of a community plan, as defined in subdivision (e) of Section 21083.3, and the accompanying ordinances.
This bill would authorize the Governor to certify a qualified community plan update as being subject to the requirements of Section 21186 and the rule of court established pursuant to Section 21185 if the qualified community plan update meets all of the following requirements:
- includes two or more transit priority areas, as defined in Section 21099;
- is for a jurisdiction with a general plan that includes a circulation or mobility element adopted on or after January 1, 2015;
- is consistent with a sustainable communities strategy or an alternative planning strategy adopted by an applicable metropolitan planning organization and certified by the State Air Resources Board as achieving the required reduction in the emissions of greenhouse gases pursuant to Section 65080 of the Government Code;
- complies with the state ambient air quality standards established by the State Air Resources Board;
- includes housing capacity to sufficiently accommodate regional housing needs projects as set forth in Section 65584.01 of the Government Code;
- is consistent with applicable regional plans to protect environmentally sensitive habitat areas, agricultural land, parks, flood zones, and high fire areas;
- includes projects and strategies designed to reduce vehicle miles traveled and does not result in any net additional emissions of greenhouse gases, including greenhouse gas emissions from employee transportation, as determined by the State Air Resources Board; and
- has begun an environmental review for the update on or after January 1, 2017.
This bill would provide that the governing board of a jurisdiction proposing a qualified community plan update may apply to the Governor for certification by supplying evidence and materials sufficient to show to the Governor that the requirements are met. If the update is so certified, it would be subject to the requirements of Section 21186 and the rules of court adopted pursuant to Section 21185, providing expedited judicial review.
This bill would provide that it does not affect or alter the obligation of a project that is consistent with an approved qualified community plan update to comply with CEQA or the eligibility of such a project for certification pursuant to Section 21183.
COMMENT
1. Stated need for the bill
According to the author:
SB 948 will help local governments bring their Community Plans up to date to conform to California’s climate, clean air, land use, and transportation goals by allowing qualified plans to receive expedited judicial review under CEQA. Up to date Community Plans can help direct growth to priority areas along transit infrastructure while preserving established residential neighborhoods and maintaining the unique character of individual neighborhoods. In larger jurisdictions, Community Plans are critical to implementing the goals of the Housing Element and the Transportation Element of the General Plan at the local level. These plans create healthier, well-planned neighborhoods, provide increased housing opportunities for residents, promote economic development and job production in business districts, and identify and protect open spaces and recreational areas by directing future growth away from sensitive ecological areas. However, if these plans are not updated and instead still envision strip malls and widening freeways, these benefits will not be realized. By expediting the judicial review for CEQA documents for plans that meet stringent criteria, we can incentivize better plans and help those plans get adopted sooner.
2. Negative impacts on the courts and the operation of CEQA
This bill would allow local jurisdictions to update community plans, which, upon certification, are eligible for expedited judicial review, among other streamlining procedures. Each certified plan would be eligible for expedited review under the AB 900 schedule, Section 21178 et seq. of the Public Resources Code. Any actions or proceedings brought to attack, review, set aside, void, or annul the certification of the environmental impact report for one of these plans would have to be resolved, to the extent feasible, within 270 days of the filing of the certified record of proceedings with the court. By undercutting the normal process for reviewing and challenging such plans, a number of key issues present themselves.
First, such a requirement inherently prioritizes such cases over other critically important ones, further delaying justice for parties to those actions. Writing in opposition, the Judicial Council states:
[I]f SB 948 is enacted, its expedited judicial review requirements will likely have an adverse impact on other cases. Like other types of calendar preferences, which the Judicial Council has historically opposed, setting an extremely tight timeline for deciding these cases has the practical effect of pushing other cases on the courts’ dockets to the back of the line. This means that other cases, including cases that have statutorily mandated calendar preferences, such as juvenile cases, criminal cases, and civil cases in which a party is at risk of dying, will take longer to decide.
In addition, by expediting the resolution of these cases, this bill would inherently stack the deck in defendants’ favor. Plaintiffs would face a steep uphill battle to make their case against a proposed plan. Defendants will have the upper hand, since they will have controlled much of the information involved in a challenged EIR, and plaintiffs will be forced to play catch up on a short timeline. CEQA was not intended to be enforced on such a tilted playing field. Sierra Club California discusses this issue:
Limiting the amount of time that any litigation must commence can have bad impacts on these plans, and the environment. Litigation should not be rushed, and parties should be given the correct amount of time to address any issues that arise from these plans. This could have negative impacts on parties’ abilities to litigate, as courts may be more likely to reject good faith motions for more time as needed, or other unforeseen issues that may arise trying to rush the case.
In addition, as pointed out by the Judicial Council, this expedited judicial review undermines equal access: “The courts are charged with dispensing equal access to justice for each and every case on their dockets. Singling out this particular type of case for such preferential treatment appears at odds with how our justice system has historically functioned.”
Furthermore, this bill seeks to take existing streamlined processes for very specific projects and apply them to broad, and often complex, community plans. Under existing law, projects can be certified as “environmental leadership development projects” only when they meet all of the following conditions:
- the project will result in a minimum investment of one hundred million dollars ($100,000,000) in California upon completion of construction;
- the project creates high-wage, highly skilled jobs that pay prevailing wages and living wages and provides construction jobs and permanent jobs for Californians, and helps reduce unemployment;
- contractors and subcontractors shall pay to all construction workers employed in the execution of the project at least the general prevailing rate of per diem wages;
- the project does not result in any net additional emission of greenhouse gases, including greenhouse gas emissions from employee transportation, as determined by the State Air Resources Board pursuant to Division 25.5 (commencing with Section 38500) of the Health and Safety Code;
- the project applicant demonstrates compliance with the requirements of Chapters 12.8 (commencing with Section 42649) and 12.9 (commencing with Section 42649.8) of Part 3 of Division 30, as applicable;
- the project applicant has entered into a binding and enforceable agreement that all mitigation measures required pursuant to CEQA to certify the project shall be conditions of approval of the project, and those conditions will be fully enforceable by the lead agency or another agency designated by the lead agency. In the case of environmental mitigation measures, the applicant agrees, as an ongoing obligation, that those measures will be monitored and enforced by the lead agency for the life of the obligation;
- the project applicant agrees to pay the costs of the Court of Appeal in hearing and deciding any case, including payment of the costs for the appointment of a special master if deemed appropriate by the court, in a form and manner specified by the Judicial Council, as provided in the Rules of Court adopted by the Judicial Council pursuant to Section 21185; and
- the project applicant agrees to pay the costs of preparing the record of proceedings for the project concurrent with review and consideration of the project pursuant to this division, in a form and manner specified by the lead agency for the project. (Pub. Resources Code Sec. 21183.)
This bill would incongruously attempt to allow for similar certification for community plan updates. However, the plans would only be required to meet a handful of less rigorous conditions. The bar set for these plans is a far cry from the extremely high standards generally set for leadership projects. Sierra Club California writes in opposition, addressing this incompatibility issue:
Community plans are very different than the single projects that are currently eligible for Environmental Leadership Project certification, with much more complexity. Existing provisions to try to finalize litigation within 270 days are based on single projects, which are nowhere near the scope and size of potential community plans. Since projects can be exempted based on consistency, any issues missed during litigation could improperly allow for pollution to occur unmitigated in these communities on these exempted projects.
The State Building and Construction Trades Council also writes in opposition, focusing on these issues:
A “community plan” can be created in a city or county and has no limits on the area it can cover (other than not the total area of a city or county). Once a community plan is approved, CEQA streamlines and, in some cases, exempts future projects from review. SB 948 states that “community plan updates” may be deemed “environmental leadership projects” by the Governor. This means that compliance with leadership requirements are not reviewable by a court and any court challenge on other issues must be completed in 9 months.
SB 948 is inconsistent with state policy that relies on robust review of community plan updates as justification to streamline/exempt future projects in the plan area. As intended, the bill is written to further limit the public’s ability to ensure adequate analysis and mitigation for future projects.
3. The weight of the evidence undermines the perception that CEQA is a major
impediment to housing and other important projects in California
As indicated by the “findings” of the bill, underlying this piece of legislation is the proposition that CEQA challenges are a “significant obstacle” to updating community plans. The bill would state as one of its findings that the “litigation process” creates this problem, “causing developers and planners great uncertainty and potentially delaying all development in that community.” Writing in support of the bill, the California Building Industry Association and the California Chamber of Commerce echoes this sentiment:
Protracted litigation over community plans stifles housing development by creating uncertainty over which land use plans a proposed housing project must comply with. By facilitating the resolution of litigation within 270 days for a narrow class of community plans that meet heightened environmental criteria, SB 948 provides critical certainty in land use rules that are a prerequisite for housing development in the area covered by such eligible plans.
However, this fundamental premise is not supported by any concrete evidence. In 2016, BAE Urban Economics did a quantitative analysis of the effects of CEQA on California’s economy generally, including the specific effects on housing development. (BAE Urban Economics, CEQA in the 21st Century (August 2016) <https://rosefdn.org/ wp-content/uploads/2016/08/CEQA-in-the-21st-Century.pdf> [as of Apr. 30, 2018].) The report found “no evidence” to support the argument that CEQA represents a major barrier to development. To the contrary, the report found that only 0.7 percent of all CEQA projects undergoing environmental review were involved in litigation. The report indicated that California’s affordable housing production ranked ninth among the 50 states. In fact, the report concluded that “[t]he CEQA process also helped ensure that affordable housing is develop[ed] in a way that does not compromise the health and safety of an already vulnerable population.”
Another relevant report produced by the Senate Environmental Quality Committee was recently released that also undercuts the theory that CEQA is hampering development. (Senate Environmental Quality Committee, California Environmental Quality Act Survey (December 2017) <http://senv.senate.ca.gov/sites/senv.senate.ca.gov/files/ceqa_ survey_full_report_-_final_12-5-17.pdf> [as of Apr. 30, 2018].)
No evidence has been provided that CEQA is derailing updates to community plans. One specific example cited to is the community plan for Hollywood that was updated by the City of Los Angeles. The plan update was successfully challenged by local groups that argued the update did not properly consider its impacts and the needs of the community. The plan also inexplicably relied on population data that was nearly a decade old. Eventually, the City of Los Angeles released a new draft community plan that was recently approved. Rather than an example of how the process creates “uncertainty,” this example arguably provides a success story for the current CEQA review protocols for plan updates. There were serious flaws in the update to the plan and local groups were able to enforce CEQA’s protections. It is unclear whether they would have been able to successfully challenge such a plan update under the strained timelines that could be triggered under this bill.
Support: California Apartment Association; California Building Industry Association; California Chamber of Commerce; Central City Association of Los Angeles; East Hollywood Business Improvement District; Eric Garcetti, Los Angeles Mayor; Greater San Fernando Valley Chamber of Commerce; Hollywood Chamber of Commerce; Hollywood Community Housing Corporation; Los Angeles Area Chamber of Commerce; Los Angeles County Economic Development Corporation; Mitch O’Farell, Los Angeles City Councilmember; Paramount Contractors and Developers
Opposition: California League of Conservation Voters; Judicial Council of California; Sierra Club California; State Building and Construction Trades Council
HISTORY
Source: Author
Related Pending Legislation:
SB 922 (Nguyen, 2018) would have imposed limits on the court’s ability to issue injunctive relief in CEQA cases challenging specified affordable housing projects built upon former surplus state real property. It would have also imposed time limits on the courts for the resolution of such cases. This bill failed passage in the Senate Governmental Organization Committee.
SB 1052 (Bates, 2018) would have required detailed information on any plaintiffs bringing CEQA challenges to acts or decisions of a public agency, including the source and amount of all contributions to the action. This bill failed passage in the Senate Environmental Quality Committee.
SB 1340 (Glazer, 2018) would have required the Judicial Council to adopt a rule of court to establish procedures requiring courts to fully adjudicate California Environmental Quality Act actions and proceedings in connection with any housing projects within 270 days of certifying the record of proceedings, to the extent feasible. This bill would also have prohibited courts from staying or enjoining challenged projects with two narrow exceptions. This bill failed passage in the Senate Judiciary Committee.
SB 1341 (Glazer, 2018) would require detailed information on any plaintiffs bringing CEQA challenges to acts or decisions of a public agency, including the source and amount of all contributions to the action. This bill is currently in the Senate Environmental Quality Committee.
AB 1905 (Grayson, 2018) would impose limits on the court’s ability to issue injunctive relief in CEQA cases challenging specified transportation projects. This bill is currently in the Assembly Natural Resources Committee.
AB 2279 (Fong, 2018) would impose limits on the court’s ability to issue injunctive relief in CEQA cases challenging specified housing projects. This bill is currently in the Assembly Natural Resources Committee.
AB 2856 (Melendez, 2018) would impose limits on the court’s ability to issue injunctive relief in CEQA cases challenging specified housing projects. This bill failed passage in the Assembly Natural Resources Committee.
Prior Legislation:
SB 743 (Steinberg, Ch. 386, Stats. 2013) established specified administrative and judicial review procedures for review of the EIR and public agency approvals granted for a project related to the development of an entertainment and sports center in the City of Sacramento. Additionally, this bill provides that aesthetic and parking impacts of a residential, mixed-use residential, or employment center project on an infill site within a transit priority area shall not be considered significant impacts on the environment under CEQA, as specified.
SB 292 (Padilla, Ch. 353, Stats. 2011) established specified administrative and judicial review procedures for review of the EIR and public agency approvals granted for a project related to the development of a stadium in the City of Los Angeles.
AB 30 (Caballero, 2017) would have imposed limits on the court’s ability to issue injunctive relief in CEQA cases challenging specified strip mall conversion housing projects. This bill died in the Assembly Natural Resources Committee.
AB 900 (Buchanan, Ch. 354, Stats. 2011), the Jobs and Economic Improvement Through Environmental Leadership Act of 2011, established specified administrative and judicial review procedures for the review of the EIR and public agency approvals granted for designated residential, retail, commercial, sports, cultural, entertainment, or recreational use projects, or clean renewable energy or clean energy manufacturing projects.
Prior Vote: Senate Environmental Quality Committee (Ayes 4, Noes 3)
**************
SENATE COMMITTEE ON ENVIRONMENTAL QUALITY
Senator Wieckowski, Chair
2017 - 2018 Regular
Bill No: SB 948
Author: | Allen | ||
Version: | 3/12/2018 | Hearing Date: | 4/18/2018 |
Urgency: | No | Fiscal: | No |
Consultant: | Rachel Machi Wagoner | ||
SUBJECT: California Environmental Quality Act community plans
ANALYSIS:
Existing law:
- Requires each local government planning agency prepare and the legislative body of each county and city adopt a comprehensive, long-term general plan for the physical development of the county or city, and of any land outside its boundaries which in the planning agency’s judgment bears relation to its planning. Chartered cities shall adopt general plans which contain the mandatory elements: land use element, circulation element, housing element, conservation element, open space element, noise element and safety element as specified.
Under the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA):
- Requires lead agencies with the principal responsibility for carrying out or approving a proposed discretionary project to prepare a negative declaration, mitigated declaration, or environmental impact report (EIR) for this action, unless the project is exempt from CEQA (CEQA includes various statutory exemptions, as well as categorical exemptions in the CEQA guidelines). (Public Resources Code (PRC) §21000 et seq.).
- Sets requirements relating to preparation, review, comment, approval and certification of environmental documents, as well as procedures relating to an action or proceeding to attack, review, set aside, void, or annul various actions of a public agency on the grounds of noncompliance with CEQA.
- Requires courts to give CEQA-related actions or proceedings preference over all other civil actions so that the action or proceeding is quickly heard and determined. (PRC §21167.1).
- Requires the Court of Appeal must regulate briefing schedules such that, to the extent feasible, the appeal is heard within one year of filing. (Public Resources Code § 21167.1(a)).
- Requires counties with a population of over 200,000 must designate one or more judges to develop expertise concerning CEQA and related land- use and environmental matters, and then assign such matters to that judge or those judges. (Public Resources Code § 21167.1 (b)).
- Defines a “community plan” as “a part of the general plan of a city or county which (1) applies to a defined geographic portion of the total area included in the general plan, (2) complies with Article 5 (commencing with Section 65300) of Chapter 3 of Division 1 of Title 7 of the Government Code by including or referencing each of the mandatory elements specified in Section 65302 of the Government Code, and (3) contains specific development policies adopted for the area included in the community plan and identifies measures to implement those policies, so that the policies which will apply to each parcel can be determined.” (PRC §21083.3).
- Provides that if a parcel has been zoned to accommodate a particular density of development or has been designated in a community plan to accommodate a particular density of development and an EIR was certified for that zoning or planning action, the approval of any subdivision map or other project that is consistent with the zoning or community plan shall be limited to effects upon the environment which are peculiar to the parcel or to the project and which were not addressed as significant effects in the prior environmental impact report, or which substantial new information shows will be more significant than described in the prior environmental impact report. (PRC §21083.3(a)).
- Provides that where a community plan is the basis for application of CEQA, any rezoning action consistent with the community plan shall be a project subject to exemption in accordance with CEQA.
- Provides that if an environmental impact report was certified for a planning level decision of a city or county, the application of this division to the approval of an infill project shall be limited to the effects on the environment that (A) are specific to the project or to the project site and were not addressed as significant effects in the prior environmental impact report or (B) substantial new information shows the effects will be more significant than described in the prior environmental impact report. (PRC §21094.5).
- Under the Jobs and Economic Improvement Through Environmental Leadership Act of 2011 (AB 900, Buchanan, Gordon, Chapter 354, Statutes of 2011), which is part of CEQA, establishes CEQA administrative and judicial review procedures for an “environmental leadership development project.” Among the provisions of AB 900 (PRC §21178 et seq.):
- Establishes procedures for expedited judicial review (i.e., requiring the courts to resolve lawsuits within 270 days of the filing of the certified record of proceedings with the court to the extent feasible) for “environmental leadership” projects certified by the Governor and meeting specified conditions, including LEED gold-certified infill site projects, clean renewable energy projects, and clean energy manufacturing projects.
- Defines “environmental leadership” project as a CEQA project that is one of the following:
- A residential, retail, commercial, sports, cultural, entertainment, or recreational use project that is certified as LEED gold or better by the United States Green Building Council and, where applicable, that achieves a 15% greater standard for transportation efficiency than for comparable projects.
- Requires that these projects be located on an infill site.
- Requires the project applicant to demonstrate compliance with commercial and organic waste recycling, as applicable.
- Requires a project that is within a metropolitan planning organization for which a sustainable communities strategy (SCS) or alternative planning strategy (APS) is in effect, to be consistent with specified policies in either the SCS or APS, which, if implemented, would achieve greenhouse gas emission (GHG) reduction targets.
- Requires that these projects be located on an infill site.
- A clean renewable energy project that generates electricity exclusively through wind or solar, but not including waste incineration or conversion.
- A clean energy manufacturing project that manufactures products, equipment, or components used for renewable energy generation, energy efficiency, or for the production of clean alternative fuel vehicles.
- A residential, retail, commercial, sports, cultural, entertainment, or recreational use project that is certified as LEED gold or better by the United States Green Building Council and, where applicable, that achieves a 15% greater standard for transportation efficiency than for comparable projects.
- Allows a person proposing to construct a leadership project to apply to the Governor for certification that the leadership project is eligible for streamlining. Requires the person to supply evidence and materials that the Governor deems necessary to make a decision on the application. Requires any evidence or materials be made available to the public at least 15 days before the Governor certifies a project pursuant to AB 900.
- Authorizes the Governor to certify a leadership project if the Governor finds the project meets all of the following conditions:
- The project will result in a minimum investment of $100 million in California upon completion of construction.
- The project creates high-wage, highly skilled jobs that pay prevailing wages and living wages, provides construction jobs and permanent jobs for Californians, and helps reduce unemployment.
- The project does not result in any net additional GHG emissions, including emissions from employee transportation, as determined by the Air Resources Board pursuant to the California Global Warming Solutions Act of 2006.
- The project applicant has entered into a binding and enforceable agreement that all mitigation measures required under CEQA shall be conditions of approval of the project, and those conditions will be fully enforceable by the lead agency or another agency designated by the lead agency. In the case of environmental mitigation measures, the applicant agrees, as an ongoing obligation, that those measures will be monitored and enforced by the lead agency for the life of the obligation.
- The project applicant agrees to pay the costs of the Court of Appeal in hearing and deciding any case, including payment of the costs for the appointment of a special master if deemed appropriate by the court, in a form and manner specified by the Judicial Council.
- The project applicant agrees to pay the costs of preparing the administrative record for the project concurrent with review and consideration of the project pursuant to CEQA, in a form and manner specified by the lead agency for the project.
- The project will result in a minimum investment of $100 million in California upon completion of construction.
- Requires the Governor, prior to certifying a project, to make a determination that each of the conditions specified above has been met. These findings are not subject to judicial review.
- If the Governor determines that a leadership project is eligible for streamlining, requires the Governor to submit that determination, and any supporting information, to the Joint Legislative Budget Committee (JLBC) for review and concurrence or non-concurrence.
- Requires the JLBC to concur or non-concur in writing within 30 days of receiving the Governor’s determination.
- Deems the leadership project certified if the JLBC fails to concur or non-concur on a determination by the Governor within 30 days of the submittal.
- Authorizes the Governor to issue guidelines regarding application and certification of projects pursuant to AB 900. These guidelines are not subject to the rulemaking provisions of the Administrative Procedure Act.
- Requires the Judicial Council to adopt a rule of court to establish procedures that require resolution within 270 days, including any appeals, of a lawsuit challenging the certification of the EIR or any project approvals for a certified environmental leadership project.
- Prohibits AB 900 from applying to a leadership project if the applicant fails to notify a lead agency prior to the release of the draft EIR for public comment.
- Sets requirements for preparation and certification of the administrative record for a leadership project certified by the Governor.
- Requires the draft and final EIR to include a specified notice in no less than 12-point type regarding the draft and final EIR being subject to AB 900.
- Provides that provisions of AB 900 are severable.
- Provides that nothing in AB 900 affects the duty of any party to comply with CEQA, except as otherwise provided in AB 900.
- Prohibits AB 900 from applying to a leadership project if the Governor does not certify the project prior to January 1, 2020.
- Provides that certification of the leadership project expires and is no longer valid if the lead agency fails to approve the project prior to January 1, 2021.
- Requires the Judicial Council to report to the Legislature on or before January 1, 2017, on the effects of AB 900 on the administration of justice.
- Repeals the act on to January 1, 2021.
- Establishes procedures for expedited judicial review (i.e., requiring the courts to resolve lawsuits within 270 days of the filing of the certified record of proceedings with the court to the extent feasible) for “environmental leadership” projects certified by the Governor and meeting specified conditions, including LEED gold-certified infill site projects, clean renewable energy projects, and clean energy manufacturing projects.
This bill: specifies that a community plan and the accompanying ordinances meeting specified requirements are deemed a certified environmental leadership development project qualifying for CEQA streamlining benefits provided by the Jobs and Economic Improvement Through Environmental Leadership Act of 2011.
Background
- Brief background on CEQA. CEQA provides a process for evaluating the environmental effects of a project, and includes statutory exemptions, as well as categorical exemptions in the CEQA guidelines. If a project is not exempt from CEQA, an initial study is prepared to determine whether a project may have a significant effect on the environment. If the initial study shows that there would not be a significant effect on the environment, the lead agency must prepare a negative declaration. If the initial study shows that the project may have a significant effect on the environment, the lead agency must prepare an EIR.
Generally, an EIR must accurately describe the proposed project, identify and analyze each significant environmental impact expected to result from the proposed project, identify mitigation measures to reduce those impacts to the extent feasible, and evaluate a range of reasonable alternatives to the proposed project. Prior to approving any project that has received environmental review, an agency must make certain findings. If mitigation measures are required or incorporated into a project, the agency must adopt a reporting or monitoring program to ensure compliance with those measures.
If a mitigation measure would cause one or more significant effects in addition to those that would be caused by the proposed project, the effects of the mitigation measure must be discussed but in less detail than the significant effects of the proposed project. - CEQA judicial review. CEQA is enforced through judicial review. CEQA actions taken by public agencies can be challenged in Superior Court once the agency approves or determines to carry out the project. CEQA appeals are subject to unusually short statutes of limitations. Under current law, court challenges of CEQA decisions generally must be filed within 30 to35 days, depending on the type of decision. The courts are required to give CEQA actions preference over all other civil actions. The petitioner must request a hearing within 90 days of filing the petition and, generally, briefing must be completed within 90 days of the request for hearing. There is no deadline specified for the court to render a decision.
- Community Plans. The General Plan provides a vision, core values and policy guidance. Community plans address specific geographic areas of the City and build upon the more general citywide policies established in the General Plan with policy recommendations that apply at the community and neighborhood level. Community plans provide the level of information and community-specific detail that is needed in order to review and assess proposed public and private development projects. However, it is important to emphasize that community plans are policy documents that do not contain regulatory information. While the community plan addresses community needs, its policies and recommendations must be consistent with the General Plan, other community and resource plans, and citywide policies. Community plans also address other aspects of land use planning that are unique to their areas, such as mobility, community facilities, and urban design features and guidelines. Both General Plans and community plans require EIRs be completed and certified on the part of the local government.
Comments
- Purpose of bill. According to the author, “SB 948 will help local governments bring their Community Plans up to date to conform to California’s climate, clean air, land use, and transportation goals by allowing qualified plans to receive expedited judicial review under CEQA. Up to date community plans can help direct growth to priority areas along transit infrastructure while preserving established residential neighborhoods and maintaining the unique character of individual neighborhoods. In larger jurisdictions, Community Plans are critical to implementing the goals of the Housing Element and the Transportation Element of the General Plan at the local level. These plans create healthier, well-planned neighborhoods, provide increased housing opportunities for residents, promote economic development and job production in business districts, and identify and protect open spaces and recreational areas by directing future growth away from sensitive ecological areas. However, if these plans are not updated and instead still envision strip malls and widening freeways, these benefits will not be realized. By expediting the judicial review for CEQA documents for plans that meet stringent criteria, we can incentivize better plans and help those plans get adopted sooner.”
- One bite at the apple. Expedited CEQA litigation for the community plan may expedite projects potentially without project specific CEQA review and therefore without project specific opportunity to sue under CEQA. There are currently several statutory exemptions provided under CEQA for infill development and rezoning for which the projects developed out of the Hollywood Community Plan will likely qualify.
- A Community Plan is Not a Leadership Project. AB 900 was enacted very specifically to leverage an extremely high standard of project that is to build highly sustainable structures (LEED gold certified) and infuses new jobs and revenue into an economy in exchange for an expedited judicial review of the EIR for THAT SPECIFIC PROJECT. This does not work for community plans for several very important reasons:
- According to the intent of the Jobs and Economic Improvement Through Environmental Leadership Act of 2011, AB 900 “provides streamlining benefits under CEQA for a limited period of time to put people to work as soon as possible” and these projects “present an unprecedented opportunity to implement nation-leading innovative measures that will significantly reduce traffic, air quality, and other significant environmental impacts, and fully mitigate the greenhouse gas emissions resulting from passenger vehicle trips attributed to the project.”
In order to be considered for leadership project status a project must meet extraordinary, measurable sustainability standards, provide demonstrable and significant jobs and investment and benefits to the members of the community. (i.e. no net greenhouse gas emission increases, achieve at least 15 percent greater transportation efficiency, located on an infill site, if the project is a multifamily residential project, evidence that (1) private vehicle parking spaces are priced and rented or purchased separately from dwelling units; or (2) the dwelling units are subject to affordability restrictions that prescribe rent or sale prices, and the cost of parking spaces cannot be unbundled from the cost of dwelling units, information establishing that the project entails a minimum investment of $100 million in California through the time of completion of construction, information establishing that the prevailing and living wage requirements of the Public Resources Code 21183(b) will be satisfied, information establishing that the project will not result in any net additional greenhouse gas emissions, information establishing that the project will comply with requirement for commercial and organic waste recycling.)
While a community plan unto itself cannot meet these specific requirements because it is the planning document and not a project, it can create a high bar to ensure environmental and community benefit and that
- According to the intent of the Jobs and Economic Improvement Through Environmental Leadership Act of 2011, AB 900 “provides streamlining benefits under CEQA for a limited period of time to put people to work as soon as possible” and these projects “present an unprecedented opportunity to implement nation-leading innovative measures that will significantly reduce traffic, air quality, and other significant environmental impacts, and fully mitigate the greenhouse gas emissions resulting from passenger vehicle trips attributed to the project.”
the projects developed pursuant to the community plan meet these high standards.
This bill has specified, vague environmental criteria that a community plan must meet (e.g. a strategy for reducing VMT, consistent with regional plans for protecting environmentally sensitive habitat…., include housing capacity to sufficiently accommodate regional housing needs, include two or more transit priority areas, comply with statutorily required clean air standards, and are consistent with a sustainable communities strategy or an alternative planning strategy…). It would be extremely difficult for a plaintiff to establish much less prove that these vague criteria were not met in order to receive the expedited judicial review.
Further none of these criteria allude to the projects that would be developed pursuant to the community plan coming close to meeting the Leader Project Criteria either.
- Leadership Projects are certified by the governor and concurred in by the Legislature. This bill provides that community plans that meet these vague criteria are deemed Leadership Projects without any verification or certification that they even the minimal criteria are met.
- Leadership Projects are certified by the governor and concurred in by the Legislature. This bill provides that community plans that meet these vague criteria are deemed Leadership Projects without any verification or certification that they even the minimal criteria are met.
- How does expedited judicial review help? Expedited judicial review tips the scales to the defendants of the lawsuit who prepared the EIR and will have the advantage because they had all of the time, resources and information that went into the EIR document and will be ready to litigate well before the plaintiff(s) will have ever seen a draft, much less had time to review and prepare their case. Therefore, the defendant (city) will have the upper hand for any case filed.
- Hollywood Community Plan. In 2012 the City of Los Angeles released an updated community plan for Hollywood that would clear the way for denser development and taller buildings. A group of local Hollywood residents and neighborhood organizations concerned about increased traffic successfully sued the City of Los Angeles. In his ruling, Los Angeles Superior Court Judge Allan J. Goodman said the 2012 Hollywood Community Plan was based on outdated population estimates from 2004 and 2005 and does not properly address an increased need for city services. He ordered the city to rescind the plan and to stop issuing permits for projects that were based on the community plan.
In February, 2014 Judge Goodman ordered the City to rescind its new Hollywood Community Plan.
The City did rescind the new plan and reenact the old plan. However, in the guise of complying with the Judge’s order, the City voted on April 2nd, 2014 to modify the General Plan Framework to make community plan monitoring and reporting discretionary. The City Council even went so far in the Resolution they adopted to deal with the stern admonition from the Court to state that the intent of their action was to “overrule and supersede” the writ and judgment of the Court.
In June 2014, the community groups went back to Judge Goodman’s court to challenge what the City did in response to being ordered by the Court to rescind the plan.
Judge Goodman stated that the Resolution the City adopted was demonstrably arbitrary, capricious and without basis in law, that no reasonable person could conclude that adoption of the April 2nd Resolution made the General Plan of the City of Los Angeles internally consistent but that the contrary was the case. Further he stated that the City’s actions constitute a misstatement and misapplication of the City Charter, state law and his February 11, 2014 Judgment.
As a result of this action, the City has reverted, by operation of law, to the 1988 Hollywood Community Plan and the zoning regulations that existed prior.
In 2016 the City of Los Angeles released a draft new community plan for Hollywood and it received final approval in June 2017. The new plan uses updated population estimates and puts greater emphasis on historic preservation and building height limits. - Not faster but guaranteed fastest. Current law already provides that CEQA lawsuits get priority over other lawsuits and that in large jurisdictions there are designated judges for CEQA. That alone should expedite this process. By utilizing the AB 900 schedule you not only guarantee expedited judicial review but guarantee expedited completion of the case.
A question arises when reviewing a case like the litigation on the Hollywood Community Plan as to who stands to benefit? In this case, it appears that members of the Hollywood community who were concerned about how outdated population data would ultimately impact their neighborhood pursued a suit under CEQA and prevailed ultimately requiring the City of Los Angeles to use accurate data.
However, would they have succeeded if the suit had been subject the fast-tracked times specified in this bill?
Who is the community plan for – the members of the community or just the City at large?
The author argues that expedited judicial review will result in more community plan updates that reflect today’s environmental and community priorities, but could those be at the expense of the necessary balance that the plans should reflect between the cities’ goals and the priorities of the residents of that community. Expedited judicial review as provided in AB 900 makes it much more difficult for the plaintiffs to construct their case and succeed, thereby risking community plans that in fact hurt the residents they aim to benefit.
Perhaps rather than compromising individuals’ rights to CEQA protections and enforcement, a better incentive for updated plans would be to provide prioritized funding for infill projects that meet exceptional environmental standards.
DOUBLE REFERRAL: SB 948 is also referred to the Senate Committee on Rules. If this bill is approved by the committee, the motion shall be a do pass as amended to the Senate Rules Committee.
Related/Prior Legislation
SB 922 (Nguyen, 2018) – Would require the JC to adopt a rule of court by July 1, 2019, to establish procedures governing CEQA actions challenging specified affordable student housing projects that requires the actions and any appeals therefrom to be resolved, to the extent feasible, within 365 days of the lodging with the court of the certified record of proceedings. Also, seeks to impose the limits on the court’s ability to issue injunctive relief that were contained in SB 292/SB 743. Failed passage in the Government Organization Committee.
SB 1340 (Glazer, 2018), as introduced February 16, 2018 – Would require the Judicial Council to adopt a rule of court by July 1, 2019, to establish procedures governing CEQA actions challenging housing projects that requires the actions and any appeals therefrom to be resolved, to the extent feasible, within 270 days of the certification of the administrative record. Also, seeks to impose the limits on the court’s ability to issue injunctive relief that were contained in SB 292/SB 743. Failed passage in Senate Judiciary Committee.
SB 789 (Bradford), as amended September 8, 2017 – Would require the Judicial Council to adopt a rule of court by July 1, 2018, to establish procedures governing CEQA actions challenging a specified Inglewood sports and entertainment project that requires the actions and any appeals therefrom to be resolved, to the extent feasible, within 270 days of the certification of the administrative record. Also, seeks to impose the limits on the court’s ability to issue injunctive relief that were contained in SB 292/SB 743. Failed passage in Assembly Natural Resources Committee.
AB 246 (Santiago,Chapter 522, Statutes of 2017) – Extends for two years AB 900 sunset and its expedited judicial review provisions. [Note: This bill also modified AB 900 by requiring the courts to resolve CEQA lawsuits on AB 900 projects within 270 days to the extent feasible from the date the certified record of proceedings is filed with the court.]
SB 699 (Galgiani, 2017) – Would extend for two years AB 900 sunset and its expedited judicial review provisions. In the Assembly Rules Committee awaiting referral.
SB 836 (Committee on Budget, Chapter 31, Statutes of 2016) – Requires the Judicial Council to adopt rules, on or before July 1, 2017, that implement the expedited judicial review procedures for resolution of CEQA challenges to specified Capitol Building Annex projects within 270 days from the date of certification of the administrative record.
AB 734 (Galgiani, Chapter 210, Statutes of 2016) – Extends for two years AB 900 sunset and its expedited judicial review provisions.
AB 1473 (Salas, 2016) – Sought to extend for four years AB 900 sunset and its expedited judicial review provisions. Died without a hearing in Assembly Natural Resources Committee.
SB 1440 (Cannella, 2016) – Would have required the Judicial Council to adopt a rule of court by July 1, 2017, to establish procedures governing CEQA actions challenging specified water projects that require the actions and any appeals therefrom to be resolved, to the extent feasible, within 370 (vs. 270 under AB 900) days of the certification of the record. Also, sought to impose SB 292/SB 743 limits on the court’s ability to issue injunctive relief. Died without a hearing in Senate Environmental Quality Committee.
AB 1298 (Gipson, 2015) – Sought to apply AB 900/SB 743’s expedited judicial review provisions and impose SB 292/SB 743 limits on the court’s ability to issue injunctive relief in CEQA actions challenging a specified sports stadium project in the City of Carson. The above provisions were subsequently removed by the author when the bill was pending in the Assembly Natural Resources Committee.
AB 641 (Mayes, 2015) – Sought to apply AB 900/SB 743’s expedited judicial review provisions and impose SB 292/SB 743 limits on the court’s ability to issue injunctive relief in CEQA actions challenging specified housing development project. Failed passage in Assembly Natural Resources Committee.
AB 311 (Gallagher, 2015) – Would have required the Judicial Council to adopt rule of court by July 1, 2017, to establish procedures governing CEQA actions challenging specified water projects that require the actions and any appeals therefrom to be resolved, to the extent feasible, within 370 (vs. 270 under AB 900) days of the certification of the record. Also, sought to impose SB 292/SB 743 limits on the court’s ability to issue injunctive relief. Failed passage in Assembly Natural Resources Committee.
AB 455 (Bigelow, 2015) - Sought to apply AB 900/SB 743’s expedited judicial review provisions and impose SB 292’s/SB 743’s limits on the court’s ability to issue injunctive relief in CEQA actions challenging certain water projects. Died without a hearing in Assembly Water, Parks and Wildlife Committee.
SB 127 (Vidak, 2015) – Sought to apply AB 900/SB 743’s expedited judicial review provisions and impose SB 292’s/SB 743’s limits on the court’s ability to issue injunctive relief in CEQA actions challenging specified water projects. The above provisions were subsequently removed by the author when the bill was pending in the Senate Environmental Quality Committee.
SB 743 (Steinberg, Chapter 386, Statutes of 2013) - Applies expedited judicial review provisions from AB 900, as modified, and imposes SB 292’s limits on the court’s ability to issue injunctive relief in CEQA actions challenging a specified downtown sports and entertainment complex in the City of Sacramento.
Status: Signed into law by Governor (Stats. 2013, ch. 386)
AB 756 (Melendez, 2013) – Sought to apply AB 900’s original expedited judicial review provisions to specified public works projects. Status: Died without a hearing in Assembly Judiciary Committee.
AB 515 (Dickinson, 2013) - Would have mandated the creation of six (6) new CEQA compliance divisions of the superior court in specified counties. The above provisions were subsequently removed by the author when the bill was pending in the Assembly Judiciary Committee.
SB 123 (Corbett, 2012) - Would have required the presiding judge of each superior court to establish an environmental and land use division within the court to process CEQA cases and other specified subject areas (including air quality, biological resources, climate change, hazards and hazardous materials, land use planning, and water quality). As amended May 2, 2013: Among other things, would have mandated the creation of an environmental and land use division within two (2) or more superior courts within each of the appellate districts (i.e., a minimum of 12 new divisions) to handle CEQA and related environmental and land use actions. Died on suspense in Senate Appropriations Committee.
AB 1444 (Feuer, 2012) – Declared intent of the legislature to expand AB 900’s original expedited judicial review provisions to public rail transit projects. The above provision was subsequently removed by the author when the bill was pending in the Assembly Natural Resources Committee.
AB 2163 (Knight, 2012) - Sought to expand AB 900’s original expedited judicial review provisions to specified commercial and residential development projects. Failed passage in Assembly Natural Resources Committee.
SOURCE:
Author
SUPPORT:
California Apartment Association
California Building Industry Association
OPPOSITION:
Sierra Club
Judicial Council of California
-- END --
Discussed in Hearing
Senate Standing Committee on Environmental Quality
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):