SB 993: Sales and use taxes: service tax: qualified business.
- Session Year: 2017-2018
- House: Senate
- Latest Version Date: 2018-05-09
Existing sales and use tax laws impose a tax on retailers measured by the gross receipts from the sale of tangible personal property sold at retail in this state, or on the storage, use, or other consumption in this state of tangible personal property purchased from a retailer for storage, use, or other consumption in this state.
This bill would reduce the rate of tax imposed by the Sales and Use Tax Law incrementally every calendar year beginning on January 1, 2020, until January 1, 2022, at which time the rate would be reduced by a total of 2%. This bill would require the Director of Finance to estimate the amount of net revenue that will be derived for specified calendar years as a result of the changes made by this bill and would require the rate of tax imposed by the Sales and Use Tax Law to be reduced or increased by a specified percentage amount for specified calendar years depending on the amount of the estimated revenue gains or losses.
Existing law imposes various taxes, including taxes on the privilege of engaging in certain activities. The Fee Collection Procedures Law, the violation of which is a crime, provides procedures for the collection of certain fees and surcharges.
This bill, beginning on and after January 1, 2020, would impose a tax on the receipt of a benefit in this state of a service that is purchased by a qualified business from any retailer, as measured by a percentage of the sales price for the service. This bill would incrementally increase the rate of the tax every calendar year until January 1, 2022, at which time the rate would be 3%.
This bill would require every seller and retailer engaged in business in this state, as specified, and making sales of services whose benefit is received in this state, to, at the time of making the sales or if the receipt of the benefit is not then taxable hereunder at the time the receipt of the services becomes taxable, determine whether the purchaser is a qualified business, collect the tax from the qualified business purchasing the service, and give the qualified business a receipt, as specified. This bill would require those sellers and retailers to register with the California Department of Tax and Fee Administration. This bill would make any person that violates specified provisions relating to the collection of the tax, the advertisement of the tax, and the separate statement of price and tax guilty of a misdemeanor. By creating a new crime, this bill would impose a state-mandated local program.
This bill would require all amounts to be paid to the California Department of Tax and Fee Administration, and would require the department to transmit those amounts, less refunds, to the Treasurer to be deposited into the General Fund.
This bill would provide for the administration and collection of this tax pursuant to procedures set forth in the Fee Collection Procedures Law. By expanding the application of the Fee Collection Procedures Law, the violation of which is a crime, this bill imposes a state-mandated local program.
The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.
This bill would provide that no reimbursement is required by this act for a specified reason.
The Sales and Use Tax Law imposes a tax on retailers measured by the gross receipts from the sale of tangible personal property sold at retail in this state, or on the storage, use, or other consumption in this state of tangible personal property purchased from a retailer for storage, use, or other consumption in this state.This bill would, on and after January 1, 2019, expand the Sales and Use Tax Law to impose a tax on the purchase of services by businesses in California at a specified percentage of the sales price of the service. The bill would require the tax to be collected and remitted by the seller of the purchased services. The bill would exempt certain types of services, including health care services, from the tax and would exempt from the tax a business with gross receipts of less than $100,000 in the previous 4 quarters. The bill would require the tax to be paid to the California Department of Tax and Fee Administration and would require the department to transmit the payments, less refunds and cost of administration, to the Treasurer to be deposited into the Retail Sales Tax on Services Fund, which this bill would create in the State Treasury. The bill would state that the moneys in that fund are to be appropriated to provide tax relief to middle-income and low-income Californians and to assist in securing greater stability for Californias infrastructure, its workforce, and its education services, including higher education. The bill would also state various related findings and declarations.This bill would include a change in state statute that would result in a taxpayer paying a higher tax within the meaning of Section 3 of Article XIIIA of the California Constitution, and thus would require for passage the approval of 2/3 of the membership of each house of the Legislature.
This bill would take effect immediately as a tax levy.
The Sales and Use Tax Law imposes a tax on retailers measured by the gross receipts from the sale of tangible personal property sold at retail in this state, or on the storage, use, or other consumption in this state of tangible personal property purchased from a retailer for storage, use, or other consumption in this state.
This bill would, on and after January 1, 2019, expand the Sales and Use Tax Law to impose a tax on the purchase of services by businesses in California at a specified percentage of the sales price of the service. The bill would require the tax to be collected and remitted by the seller of the purchased services. The bill would exempt certain types of services, including health care services, from the tax and would exempt from the tax a business with gross receipts of less than $100,000 in the previous 4 quarters. The bill would require the tax to be paid to the California Department of Tax and Fee Administration and would require the department to transmit the payments, less refunds and cost of administration, to the Treasurer to be deposited into the Retail Sales Tax on Services Fund, which this bill would create in the State Treasury. The bill would state that the moneys in that fund are to be appropriated to provide tax relief to middle-income and low-income Californians and to assist in securing greater stability for Californias infrastructure, its workforce, and its education services, including higher education. The bill would also state various related findings and declarations.
This bill would include a change in state statute that would result in a taxpayer paying a higher tax within the meaning of Section 3 of Article XIIIA of the California Constitution, and thus would require for passage the approval of 2/3 of the membership of each house of the Legislature.
This bill would take effect immediately as a tax levy.
The Legislature finds and declares all of the following:
(a)Californias tax collections in recent years have been heavily dependent on the income of top earners. During the Great Recession, a 3.6 percent decline in Californias economy resulted in a 23 percent plunge in General Fund revenues a loss of over $20 billion. To begin to address this, California enacted new constitutional requirements requiring new levels of budget reserves to be maintained. Further efforts to modernize and restructure the states tax system are still needed.
(b)An underlying problem is that, while Californias economy has evolved, its tax system has failed to keep up with the times. Over the past 60 years, California has moved from an agriculture- and manufacturing-based economy to a service-based economy. As a result, state tax revenues have become less reliant on revenues derived from the Sales and Use Tax on goods and more reliant on revenues derived from the Personal Income Tax. In 1950, the Sales and Use Tax comprised 61 percent of state General Fund revenues; today, it accounts for about 30 percent. The Personal Income Tax accounted for 12 percent of the General Fund in 1950; today, it accounts for almost 70 percent.
(c)It is the intent of this act to:
(1)Realign the states outdated tax code with the realities of Californias 21st century economy.
(2)Ensure that out-of-state corporations that do business in California contribute their fair share to Californias economy.
(d)The intent of this act is to make two broad changes to the tax code:
(1)Broaden the tax base by imposing a modest sales tax on the purchase of services by businesses. These changes would more fairly apportion taxes between goods and services and would produce more stable revenues. Local jurisdictions would not be authorized to increase sales tax on services, as they now can do with the sales tax on goods. Health care services, education services, child care, rent, interest, and services provided by very small businesses would be exempted from the sales tax on services.
(2)Reduce the sales and use tax rate on goods so as to ensure that the imposition of the tax on services is offset by a reduction in the tax rate on goods in a manner that is revenue neutral.
SEC. 2.Section 6051 of the Revenue and Taxation Code is amended to read:6051.(a)For the privilege of selling tangible personal property at retail a tax is hereby imposed upon all retailers at the rate of 21/2 percent following rates of the gross receipts of any retailer from the sale of all tangible personal property sold at retail in this state on or after August 1, 1933, and to and including June 30, 1935, and at the rate of 3 percent thereafter, and at the rate of 21/2 percent on and after July 1, 1943, and to and including June 30, 1949, and at the rate of 3 percent on and after July 1, 1949, and to and including July 31, 1967, and at the rate of 4 percent on and after August 1, 1967, and to and including June 30, 1972, and at the rate of 33/4 percent on and after July 1, 1972, and to and including June 30, 1973, and at the rate of 43/4 percent on and after July 1, 1973, and to and including September 30, 1973, and at the rate of 33/4 percent on and after October 1, 1973, and to and including March 31, 1974, and at the rate of 43/4 percent thereafter. state:
(1)On and after April 1, 1974, and before January 1, 2020, 43/4 percent.
(2)On and after January 1, 2020, and before January 1, 2021, 41/4 percent.
(3)On and after January 1, 2021, and before January 1, 2022, 33/4 percent, subject to any adjustment specified in subdivision (b).
(4)On and after January 1, 2022, 23/4 percent, subject to any adjustment specified in subdivision (b).
(b)(1)On or before September 15, 2020, on or before September 15, 2021, and on or before September 15, 2022, the Director of Finance shall estimate the amount of net revenue that will be derived for the next calendar year as a result of the changes to the tax laws made by the act adding this subdivision.
(2)(A)If the Director of Finance estimates pursuant to paragraph (1) that the amount of net revenue that will be derived for the 2021 calendar year as a result of the changes to the tax laws made by the act adding this subdivision will exceed four hundred fifty million dollars ($450,000,000), the rates in paragraph (3) of subdivision (a) of this section and subdivision (c) of Section 6201 shall be reduced by one-eighth percent or a multiple thereof as necessary for the period beginning on January 1, 2021, and before January 1, 2022, to reduce the estimated excess net revenue for that calendar year to less than four hundred fifty million dollars ($450,000,000).
(B)If the Director of Finance estimates pursuant to paragraph (1) that for the 2021 calendar year the changes to the tax laws made by the act adding this subdivision will result in a net revenue loss of more than four hundred fifty million dollars ($450,000,000), the rates in paragraph (3) of subdivision (a) of this section and subdivision (c) of Section 6201 shall be increased by one-eighth percent or a multiple thereof as necessary for the period beginning on January 1, 2021, and before January 1, 2022, to reduce the estimated net revenue loss for that calendar year to less than four hundred fifty million dollars ($450,000,000).
(3)(A)If the Director of Finance estimates pursuant to paragraph (1) that the amount of net revenue that will be derived for the 2022 calendar year as a result of the changes to the tax laws made by the act adding this subdivision will exceed four hundred sixty million dollars ($460,000,000), the rates in paragraph (4) of subdivision (a) of this section and subdivision (d) of Section 6201 shall be reduced by one-eighth percent or a multiple thereof as necessary for the period beginning on January 1, 2022, and before January 1, 2023, to reduce the estimated excess net revenue for that calendar year to less than four hundred sixty million dollars ($460,000,000).
(B)If the Director of Finance estimates pursuant to paragraph (1) that for the 2022 calendar year as a result of the changes to the tax laws made by the act adding this subdivision will result in a net revenue loss of more than four hundred sixty million dollars ($460,000,000), the rates in paragraph (4) of subdivision (a) of this section and subdivision (d) of Section 6201 shall be increased by one-eighth percent or a multiple thereof as necessary for the period beginning on January 1, 2022, and before January 1, 2023, to reduce the estimated net revenue loss for that calendar year to less than four hundred sixty million dollars ($460,000,000).
(4)(A)If the Director of Finance estimates pursuant to paragraph (1) that the amount of net revenue that will be derived for the 2023 calendar year as a result of the changes to the tax laws made by the act adding this subdivision will exceed four hundred seventy million dollars ($470,000,000), the rates in paragraph (4) of subdivision (a) of this section and subdivision (d) of Section 6201 shall be reduced by one-eighth percent or a multiple thereof as necessary to reduce the estimated excess net revenue for the 2023 calendar year to less than four hundred seventy million dollars ($470,000,000), and those rates shall be applicable beginning on and after January 1, 2023.
(B)If the Director of Finance estimates pursuant to paragraph (1) that for the 2023 calendar year the changes to the tax laws made by the act adding this subdivision will result in a net revenue loss of more than four hundred seventy million dollars ($470,000,000), the rates in paragraph (4) of subdivision (a) of this section and subdivision (d) of Section 6201 shall be increased by one-eighth percent or a multiple thereof as necessary to reduce the estimated net revenue loss for the 2023 calendar year to less than four hundred seventy million dollars ($470,000,000), and those rates shall be applicable beginning on and after January 1, 2023.
(c)The Director of Finance shall notify the California Department of Tax and Fee Administration and the Chairperson of the Joint Legislative Budget Committee within five days of making a determination pursuant to subdivision (b) that results in a change in the tax rates imposed by this section, Section 6201, or Section 7196.
SEC. 3.Section 6201 of the Revenue and Taxation Code is amended to read:6201.An excise tax is hereby imposed on the storage, use, or other consumption in this state of tangible personal property purchased from any retailer on or after July 1, 1935, for storage, use, or other consumption in this state at the rate of 3 percent following rates of the sales price of the property, and at the rate of 21/2 percent on and after July 1, 1943, and to and including June 30, 1949, and at the rate of 3 percent on and after July 1, 1949, and to and including July 31, 1967, and at the rate of 4 percent on and after August 1, 1967, and to and including June 30, 1972, and at the rate of 33/4 percent on and after July 1, 1972, and to and including June 30, 1973, and at the rate of 43/4 percent on and after July 1, 1973, and to and including September 30, 1973, and at the rate of 33/4 percent on and after October 1, 1973, and to and including March 31, 1974, and at the rate of 43/4 percent thereafter. property:
(a)On and after April 1, 1974, and before January 1, 2020, 43/4 percent.
(b)On and after January 1, 2020, and before January 1, 2021, 41/4 percent.
(c)On and after January 1, 2021, and before January 1, 2022, 33/4 percent, subject to any adjustment specified in subdivision (b) in Section 6051.
(d)On and after January 1, 2022, 23/4 percent, subject to any adjustment specified in subdivision (b) in Section 6051.
SEC. 4.Part 1.4 (commencing with Section 7195) is added to Division 2 of the Revenue and Taxation Code, to read:1.4.Service Tax Law1.General Provisions and Definitions7195.(a)This part is known and may be cited as the Service Tax Law.
(b)Services tax means the tax imposed by this part.
7195.1.Except where the context otherwise requires, the definitions given in this chapter govern the construction of this part.
7195.3.Business includes any activity engaged in by any person or caused to be engaged in by the person with the object of gain, benefit, or advantage, either direct or indirect.
7195.4.Department means the California Department of Tax and Fee Administration.
7195.5.In this state means within the exterior limits of the State of California and includes all territory within these limits owned by or ceded to the United States of America.
7195.7.Occasional sale means a sale of services not held or used by a seller in the course of activities for which the seller is required to register with the department or would be required to register with the department if the activities were conducted in this state, provided that the sale is not one of a series of sales sufficient in number, scope, and character to constitute an activity for which the seller is required to register with the department or would be required to register with the department if the activity were conducted in this state.
7195.9.Person means an individual, trust, firm, joint stock company, business concern, corporation, including, but not limited to, a government corporation, partnership, limited liability company, and association. Person also includes any city, county, city and county, district, commission, the state or any department, agency, or political subdivision thereof, any interstate body, and the United States and its agencies and instrumentalities to the extent permitted by law.
7195.11.Purchase means and includes any provision, exchange, or barter, conditional or otherwise, in any manner or by any means whatsoever, of service for a consideration.
7195.12.Qualified business means a person, including, but not limited to, a corporation, partnership, sole proprietorship, limited liability company, and limited liability partnership, engaged in business to provide a product or service for the purpose of producing income that is taxable under federal income tax law.
7195.13.Receipt of the benefit of a service means the receipt of services for any purpose other than resale of those services in the regular course of business.
7195.15.Retail sale or sale at retail means a sale for any purpose other than resale in the regular course of business in the form of services.
7195.17.(a)Retailer includes every seller who makes any retail sale or sales of a service.
(b)Every person making more than two retail sales of services during any 12-month period shall be considered a retailer within the provisions of this part.
7195.19.(a)Retailer engaged in business in this state means any retailer that has substantial nexus with this state for purposes of the commerce clause of the United States Constitution and any retailer upon whom federal law permits this state to impose a use tax collection duty. Retailer engaged in business in this state specifically includes, but is not limited to, any of the following:
(1)Any retailer maintaining, occupying, or using, permanently or temporarily, directly or indirectly, or through a subsidiary, or agent, by whatever name called, an office, place of distribution, sales or sample room or place, warehouse or storage place, or other place of business.
(2)Any retailer having any representative, agent, salesperson, canvasser, independent contractor, or solicitor operating in this state under the authority of the retailer or its subsidiary for the purpose of selling, providing, or the taking of orders for any services.
(3)Any retailer that is a member of a commonly controlled group, as defined in Section 25105, and is a member of a combined reporting group, as defined in paragraph (3) of subdivision (b) of Section 25106.5 of Title 18 of the California Code of Regulations, that includes another member of the retailers commonly controlled group that, pursuant to an agreement with or in cooperation with the retailer, performs services in this state in connection with services to be sold by the retailer, including, but not limited to, design and development of services sold by the retailer, or the solicitation of sales of services on behalf of the retailer.
(4)(A)Any retailer entering into an agreement or agreements under which a person or persons in this state, for a commission or other consideration, directly or indirectly refer potential purchasers of services to the retailer, whether by an Internet-based link or an Internet Web site, or otherwise, provided that both of the following conditions are met:
(i)The total cumulative sales price from all of the retailers sales, within the preceding 12 months, of services to purchasers in this state that are referred pursuant to all of those agreements with a person or persons in this state, is in excess of ten thousand dollars ($10,000).
(ii)The retailer, within the preceding 12 months, has total cumulative sales of services to purchasers in this state in excess of one million dollars ($1,000,000).
(B)An agreement under which a retailer purchases advertisements from a person or persons in this state, to be delivered on television, radio, in print, on the Internet, or by any other medium, is not an agreement described in subparagraph (A), unless the advertisement revenue paid to the person or persons in this state consists of commissions or other consideration that is based upon sales of services.
(C)Notwithstanding subparagraph (B), an agreement under which a retailer engages a person in this state to place an advertisement on an Internet Web site operated by that person, or operated by another person in this state, is not an agreement described in subparagraph (A), unless the person entering the agreement with the retailer also directly or indirectly solicits potential customers in this state through use of flyers, newsletters, telephone calls, electronic mail, blogs, microblogs, social networking sites, or other means of direct or indirect solicitation specifically targeted at potential customers in this state.
(D)For purposes of this paragraph, retailer includes an entity affiliated with a retailer within the meaning of Section 1504 of the Internal Revenue Code.
(E)This paragraph shall not apply if the retailer can demonstrate that the person in this state with whom the retailer has an agreement did not engage in referrals in the state on behalf of the retailer that would satisfy the requirements of the commerce clause of the United States Constitution.
(5)The retailer, within the preceding 12 months, has total cumulative sales of services in this state that exceed five hundred thousand dollars ($500,000). For purposes of this paragraph, sales of the retailer include sales by an agent or independent contractor of the taxpayer. For purposes of this paragraph, sales in this state shall be determined using the rules for assigning sales under Sections 25135 and 25136 and the regulations thereunder, as modified by regulations under Section 25137.
(b)Except as provided in this subdivision, a retailer is not a retailer engaged in business in this state under paragraph (2) of subdivision (a) if that retailers sole physical presence in this state is to engage in convention and trade show activities as described in Section 513(d)(3)(A) of the Internal Revenue Code, and if the retailer, including any of his or her representatives, agents, salespersons, canvassers, independent contractors, or solicitors, does not engage in those convention and trade show activities for more than 15 days, in whole or in part, in this state during any 12-month period and did not derive more than one hundred thousand dollars ($100,000) of net income from those activities in this state during the prior calendar year. Notwithstanding the preceding sentence, a retailer engaging in convention and trade show activities, as described in Section 513(d)(3)(A) of the Internal Revenue Code, is a retailer engaged in business in this state, and is liable for collection of the service tax, with respect to the receipt of the benefit of any services occurring at the convention and trade show activities and with respect to the receipt of the benefit of any services made pursuant to an order taken at or during those convention and trade show activities.
(c)Any limitations created by this section upon the definition of retailer engaged in business in this state shall only apply for purposes of tax liability under this part. Nothing in this section is intended to affect or limit, in any way, civil liability or jurisdiction under Section 410.10 of the Code of Civil Procedure.
7195.21.Sale means and includes any provision, exchange, or barter, conditional or otherwise, in any manner or by any means whatsoever, of a service for a consideration.
7195.23.(a)Sales price means the total amount for which a service is sold, valued in money, whether paid in money or otherwise, without any deduction on account of the cost of any expenses.
(b)Notwithstanding subdivision (a), sales price does not include cash discounts allowed and taken on sales.
7195.25.(a)Seller includes every person engaged in the business of selling services of a kind the sales price from the retail sale of which is required to be included in the measure of the services tax.
(b)For the purposes of this section, the phrase services of a kind the sales price from the retail sale of which are required to be included in the measure of the services tax includes all services of a kind the sales price from the retail sale of which is, or would be, required to be included in the measure of the services tax if sold at retail, whether or not the service is ever sold at retail or is suitable for sale at retail.
7195.27.(a)Service means a commodity consisting of activities engaged in by a person for another person for consideration.
(b)Services does not include any of the following:
(1)Activities performed by a person who is not in a regular trade or business offering its services to the public.
(2)(A)Intercompany services rendered, furnished, or performed by and to members of an affiliated group of companies.
(B)For the purposes of this section, an affiliated group would consist of any of the following:
(i)Corporations that are members of a commonly controlled group as defined by subdivision (b) of Section 25105, as that section read on the effective date of the act adding this section.
(ii)Entities considered as a single unit for purposes of Section 28 of Article XIII of the California Constitution.
(3)Services rendered, furnished, or performed by an individual for an employer that pays the individual wages subject to Division 6 (commencing with Section 13000) of the Unemployment Insurance Code.
2.Imposition of Tax7196.(a)An excise tax is hereby imposed on the receipt of the benefit of a service in this state that is purchased by a qualified business from any retailer at the following rates of the sales price of the services:
(1)On and after January 1, 2020, and before January 1, 2021, 3/4 percent.
(2)On and after January 1, 2021, and before January 1, 2022, 11/2 percent.
(3)On and after January 1, 2022, 3 percent.
(b)The place in which the benefit of a service is received is the location where the qualified business that has purchased the service has either directly or indirectly received value from delivery of that service.
7196.1.Every qualified business receiving a benefit from a service in this state purchased from a retailer is liable for the tax. The liability of the qualified business is not extinguished until the tax has been paid to this state except that a receipt from a retailer engaged in business in this state or from a retailer who is authorized by the department, under the rules and regulations as it may prescribe, to collect the tax and who is, for the purposes of this chapter relating to the tax, regarded as a retailer engaged in business in this state, given to the qualified business pursuant to Section 7196.2, is sufficient to relieve the qualified business from further liability for the tax to which the receipt refers.
7196.2.Every retailer engaged in business in this state and making sales of services whose benefit is received in this state, not exempted under Article 1 (commencing with Section 7196.60) of Chapter 4, shall, at the time of making the sales or, if the receipt of the benefit is not then taxable hereunder, at the time the receipt of the services becomes taxable, determine whether the purchaser is a qualified business, collect the tax from the qualified business purchasing the service, and give to the qualified business a receipt therefor in the manner and form prescribed by the department.
7196.3.The department, in consultation with the Franchise Tax Board, shall adopt regulations to implement the taxes imposed pursuant to this part that establish an apportionment methodology with respect to the receipt of the benefit of a service by a qualified business of a service that is engaged in business in this state and outside this state or is a part of an affiliated group of businesses as defined in Article 1 (commencing with Section 25101) of Chapter 17 of Part 11 that are engaged in business in this state and outside this state.
7196.4.Section 6203.5, regarding worthless and charged-off accounts, shall apply to this part. Except where the context otherwise requires, for purposes of this part the references in that section to tangible personal property shall include services.
7196.5.(a)The tax required to be collected by the retailer and any amount unreturned to the purchaser which is not tax but was collected from the purchaser under the representation by the retailer that it was tax constitutes debts owed by the retailer to this state.
(b)It is unlawful for any retailer to advertise or hold out or state to the public or to any purchaser, directly or indirectly, that the tax or any part thereof will be assumed or absorbed by the retailer or that it will not be added to the selling price of the property sold or that if added it or any part thereof will be refunded.
(c)The tax required to be collected by the retailer from the purchaser shall be displayed separately from the list price, the price advertised in the premises, the marked price, or other price on the sales check or other proof of sales.
(d)Any person violating Section 7196.2 and subdivision (b) or (c) is guilty of a misdemeanor.
3.Permits and Registration, Presumptions, and Resale Certificates 7196.50.(a)Every person desiring to engage in or conduct business as a seller within this state, or a retailer engaged in business in this state, selling services whose benefit is received in this state shall register with the department on a form prescribed by the department, providing information as the department may require.
(b)An application filed pursuant to this section may be filed using electronic media as prescribed by the department.
(c)Electronic media includes, but is not limited to, computer modem, magnetic media, optical disk, facsimile machine, or telephone.
7196.51.(a)For the purpose of the proper administration of this part and to prevent evasion of the service tax and the duty to collect the service tax, if a service is purchased from a seller or a retailer engaged in business in this state, then it shall be presumed that the receipt of the benefit of that service is in this state until the contrary is established. The burden of proving the contrary is upon the person who makes the sale unless the person takes from the purchaser a certificate to the effect that the service is purchased for resale.
(b)The certificate relieves the person selling the service from the duty of collecting the service tax only if taken in good faith from a person who is engaged in the business of selling services and who holds the permit provided for by Section 7296.50.
(c)(1)The certificate shall be signed by and bear the name and address of the purchaser, shall indicate the number of the permit issued to the purchaser, and shall indicate the general character of the service sold by the purchaser in the regular course of business. The certificate shall be substantially in such form as the department may prescribe.
(2)If the purchaser is a contractor of services that purchases services from a subcontractor of services for resale, the contractor may provide the subcontractor with a certificate that complies with this section.
(d)If a purchaser who gives a resale certificate or purchases services for the purpose of reselling receives the benefit of that service purchased in this state, that receipt of the benefit of that service is taxable as of that time of receipt.
7196.52.The department, whenever it deems necessary to ensure compliance with this part, may require any person subject to this part to place with it any security that the department determines to be reasonable, taking into account the circumstances of that person. The department may sell the security at public auction if it becomes necessary to do so in order to recover any fee or any amount required to be collected, including any interest or penalty due. Notice of the sale shall be served upon the person who placed the security personally or by mail.
If service is made by mail, the notice shall be addressed to the person at his or her address as it appears in the records of the department. Service shall be made at least 30 days prior to the sale in the case of personal service, and at least 40 days prior to the sale in the case of service by mail. Upon any sale, any surplus above the amounts due shall be returned to the person who placed the security.
4.Exemptions 1.Exemptions for Service Tax7196.60.There are exempt from the taxes imposed by this part the receipt of the benefit of, in this state of, all of the following:
(a)Services, the receipt of the benefit of which this state is prohibited from taxing under the Constitution or laws of the United States or under the Constitution of this state.
(b)Services provided by a person engaged in a line of business described in Subsector 611 of the North American Industry Classification System (NAICS) published by the United States Office of Management and Budget, 2012 edition, but limited only to those services that directly involve the providing of education or training.
(c)(1)Services provided by a person engaged in those lines of business described in Subsectors 621 to 623, inclusive, of the North American Industry Classification System (NAICS) published by the United States Office of Management and Budget, 2012 edition, but limited only to those services that directly involve the providing of health care and assisted living.
(2)The exemption provided by this section from the taxes imposed by this chapter for services provided by a managed care organization shall not be interpreted to exempt managed care organizations from taxes imposed by other provisions of law.
(d)Services provided by a person engaged in those lines of business described in Subsector 624410 of the North American Industry Classification System (NAICS) published by the United States Office of Management and Budget (OMB), 2012 edition, but limited only to those services that directly involve the providing of child care.
(e)Services provided by a person engaged in those lines of business described in Sector 22 of the North American Industry Classification System (NAICS) published by the United States Office of Management and Budget, 2017 edition.
(f)Services provided by a person engaged in those lines of business described in Code 2361 of the North American Industry Classification System (NAICS) published by the United States Office of Management and Budget, 2017 edition, but limited only to those services that directly involve residential building construction.
(g)Services provided by a person engaged in those lines of business described in Sector 42 of the North American Industry Classification System (NAICS) published by the United States Office of Management and Budget, 2017 edition.
(h)Services provided by a person engaged in those lines of business described in Subsector 491 of the North American Industry Classification System (NAICS) published by the United States Office of Management and Budget, 2017 edition.
(i)Services provided by a person engaged in those lines of business described in Code 4413 of the North American Industry Classification System (NAICS) published by the United States Office of Management and Budget, 2017 edition.
(j)Services provided by a person engaged in those lines of business described in Sector 71 of the North American Industry Classification System (NAICS) published by the United States Office of Management and Budget, 2017 edition.
(k)Services provided by a person engaged in those lines of business described in Subsector 722 of the North American Industry Classification System (NAICS) published by the United States Office of Management and Budget, 2017 edition.
(l)Services provided by a person engaged in those lines of business described in Code 721199 of the North American Industry Classification System (NAICS) published by the United States Office of Management and Budget, 2017 edition.
(m)Services provided by a person engaged in those lines of business described in Sector 81 of the North American Industry Classification System (NAICS) published by the United States Office of Management and Budget, 2017 edition.
(n)Services provided by a person with gross receipts that are subject to tax pursuant to this chapter from that business of less than one hundred thousand dollars ($100,000) in the previous four quarters.
(o)Services subject to any tax imposed pursuant to Part 7 (commencing with Section 12001).
(p)Interest.
7196.62.There are exempted from the taxes imposed by this part the receipt of the benefit of services in this state, the transfer of which to the purchaser is an occasional sale.
7196.64.There are exempted from the taxes imposed by this part the receipt of the benefit of services by a tenant from the rental, lease, or provision of real property for personal or commercial use.
7196.66.There are exempted from the taxes imposed by this part the receipt of the benefit of services that the retailer or purchaser establishes to the satisfaction of the department that the sales price was included in the measure of tax imposed by Chapter 2 (commencing with Section 6051) or Chapter 3 (commencing with Section 6201) of Part 1, or would have been included in the measure of tax imposed by Chapter 2 (commencing with Section 6051) or Chapter 3 (commencing with Section 6201) of Part 1 but was exempted by Chapter 4 (commencing with Section 6351) of Part 1.
7196.68.(a)There are exempted from the taxes imposed by this part an amount equal to an amount that is attributable to the rate of tax imposed by this chapter with respect to the sales price of services whose benefit is received in this state if the retailer is obligated to provide, or the purchaser is obligated to purchase, the services for a fixed price pursuant to a contract entered into prior to January 1, 2017.
(b)For purposes of this section, services shall not be deemed obligated pursuant to a contract for any period of time for which any party to the contract has the right to terminate the contract upon notice, whether or not the right is exercised.
7196.70.There are exempted from the taxes imposed by this part the receipt of the benefits of services by:
(a)The United States, its unincorporated agencies and instrumentalities.
(b)Any incorporated agency or instrumentality of the United States wholly owned by the United States or by a corporation wholly owned by the United States.
(c)The American National Red Cross, its chapters and branches.
7196.72.There are exempted from the taxes imposed by this part the receipt of the benefit of municipal services in this state provided by a city, county, city and county, or special district, or the receipt of the benefit of municipal services in this state by an entity with which the city, county, city and county, or special district has entered into a contract to provide those services.
7196.74.A credit shall be allowed against, but shall not exceed, the taxes imposed on any person by this part by reason of the receipt of the benefit of services in this state to the extent that the person has paid a retail sales or use tax, or reimbursement therefor, imposed with respect to that service by any other state, political subdivision thereof, or the District of Columbia prior to the receipt of the benefit of that service in this state. The credit shall be apportioned to the taxes against which it is allowed in proportion to the amounts of those taxes.
2.Exemption Certificates7196.90.A purchaser may certify in writing that the receipt of the benefit of the service in this state purchased from a seller or a retailer engaged in business in this state will be exempt from the service tax. The certificate shall relieve the seller from the obligation to collect the service tax only if it is taken in good faith.
5.Determinations7197.Except where the context otherwise requires, Chapter 3 (commencing with Section 55040) of Part 30, regarding determinations, shall apply to this part. For purposes of this part, any references to fees in Chapter 3 (commencing with Section 55040) of Part 30 shall include the tax imposed by this part and any reference to feepayer in that chapter shall include a person liable for the payment of the tax imposed by this part.
6.Collection of Tax7197.5.Except where the context otherwise requires, Chapter 4 (commencing with Section 55121) of Part 30, regarding collection of fees, shall apply to this part. For purposes of this part, any references to fees in Chapter 4 (commencing with Section 55121) of Part 30 shall include the tax imposed by this part, and any reference to feepayer in that chapter shall include a person liable for the payment of the tax imposed by this part.
7.Overpayments and Refunds7197.10.Except where the context otherwise requires, Chapter 5 (commencing with Section 55221) of Part 30, regarding overpayments and refunds, shall apply to this part. For purposes of this part, any references to fees in Chapter 5 (commencing with Section 55221) of Part 30 shall include the tax imposed by this part and any reference to feepayer in that chapter shall include a person liable for the payment of the tax imposed by this part.
8.Administration and Taxpayers Bill of Rights7197.20.Except where the context otherwise requires, Chapter 6 (commencing with Section 55301) of Part 30, regarding administration and taxpayers bill of rights, shall apply to this part, and any reference to feepayer in that chapter shall include a person liable for the payment of the tax imposed by this part.
9.Disposition of Proceeds7197.30.All amounts of tax required to be paid to the state under this chapter shall be paid to the California Department of Tax and Fee Administration in the form of remittances payable to the department. The department shall transmit the payments, less refunds, to the Treasurer to be deposited into the General Fund.
10.Violations 7197.40.Chapter 7 (commencing with Section 55361) of Part 30, regarding violations, shall apply to this part. For purposes of this part, any references to fees in Chapter 10 (commencing with Section 7152) shall include the taxes imposed by this part.
11.Res Judicata 7197.50.In the determination of any case arising under this part the rule of res judicata is applicable only if the liability involved is for the same quarterly period as was involved in another case previously determined.
12.No Authorization of Local Tax7197.60.This part does not authorize a city, county, city and county, governmental subdivision, district, public and quasi-public corporation, or municipal corporation, whether or not incorporated or chartered, to levy or collect or cause to be levied or collected any tax on the receipts from the sale of, or the receipt of the benefit in this state of, services. A state agency shall not agree to administer any such tax for the benefit of any local agency.
SEC. 5.No reimbursement is required by this act pursuant to Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution because the only costs that may be incurred by a local agency or school district will be incurred because this act creates a new crime or infraction, eliminates a crime or infraction, or changes the penalty for a crime or infraction, within the meaning of Section 17556 of the Government Code, or changes the definition of a crime within the meaning of Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution.
SEC. 6.This act provides for a tax levy within the meaning of Article IV of the California Constitution and shall go into immediate effect.
SECTION 1.(a)The Legislature finds and declares all of the following:(1)In order to mitigate the negative impacts in California of the recently enacted federal tax bill (Public Law 115-97), California needs to reform the states tax system to more equitably share responsibility for supporting critical public programs.(2)Under the new federal tax law (Public Law 115-97), over 6 million Californians who itemize their taxes could lose on average over $8,000 in deductions. This is because the deduction for state and local income and property taxes would be capped at $10,000 by the new federal law (Public Law 115-97).(3)The federal tax changes, coupled with potential reductions to federal programs, pose a risk to Californias economy, California families, and state government.(4)While Californias economy has evolved, its tax system has failed to keep up with the times. Over the past 60 years, California has moved from an agriculture-based and manufacturing-based economy to a service-based economy. In California, goods are subject to sales or use tax while services generally are not. (5)As a result, state tax revenues have become less reliant on revenues derived from the sales and use tax on goods and more reliant on revenues derived from the personal income tax. In 1950, the sales and use taxes comprised 61 percent of the state General Fund; however, today they account for about 30 percent. The personal income tax accounted for 12 percent of the General Fund in 1950; however, today it accounts for almost 70 percent.(b)It is the intent of this act to do all of the following:(1)Provide tax relief to middle-income and low-income Californians to make up in part for tax increases and reductions to federal programs recently enacted or proposed by the federal government.(2)Ensure that out-of-state corporations that do business in California contribute their fair share to Californias economy.(3)Realign a portion of the states outdated tax code with the realities of Californias 21st century service-based economy.(4)Broaden the tax base by imposing a modest sales tax on services used by businesses in California:(A)This tax would offset a portion of the significant financial benefits provided to businesses under the new federal law. However, businesses would still be able to deduct from their federal taxes the state sales and use tax imposed on the services they use, which would mean most businesses will still pay lower taxes than before the federal changes.(B)Health care services, education services, child care, and interest and insurance payments subject to the state gross premiums tax would be exempt from the sales tax on services.(C)These changes would more fairly apportion taxes between goods and services and would produce more stable revenues.SEC. 2.Chapter 3.8 (commencing with Section 6305) is added to Part 1 of Division 2 of the Revenue and Taxation Code, to read:3.8.Services6305.(a)On and after January 1, 2019, in addition to the other taxes imposed by this part, a sales tax is hereby imposed the purchase of services by businesses in California at the rate of ____ percent of the sales price of the service.(b)The tax shall be collected and remitted by the seller of the service purchased by a business for benefit or use in California. In cases where the service benefits or is used by a purchasers California and non-California operations, an appropriate share of the services shall be apportioned to California for purposes of determining the tax.(c)The following are exempt from the tax imposed by this section:(1)Health care, education, and child care services, and interest and insurance payments subject to the gross premiums tax.(2)A business with gross receipts of less than one hundred thousand dollars ($100,000) in the previous four quarters.6307.(a)The Retail Sales Tax on Services Fund is hereby created in the State Treasury.(b)All amounts of tax required to be paid to the state under this chapter shall be paid to the California Department of Tax and Fee Administration in the form of remittances payable to the California Department of Tax and Fee Administration. The California Department of Tax and Fee Administration shall transmit the payments, less refunds and cost of administration, to the Treasurer to be deposited into the Retail Sales Tax on Services Fund. (c)Moneys in the fund shall be appropriated for the following purposes:(1)Providing tax relief to middle-income and low-income Californians negatively affected by recent changes to federal tax law as well as other changes to federal programs.(2)Assisting in securing greater stability for Californias infrastructure, its workforce, and its education systems, including higher education.SEC. 3.This act provides for a tax levy within the meaning of Article IV of the California Constitution and shall go into immediate effect.(a)The Legislature finds and declares all of the following:
(1)In order to mitigate the negative impacts in California of the recently enacted federal tax bill (Public Law 115-97), California needs to reform the states tax system to more equitably share responsibility for supporting critical public programs.
(2)Under the new federal tax law (Public Law 115-97), over 6 million Californians who itemize their taxes could lose on average over $8,000 in deductions. This is because the deduction for state and local income and property taxes would be capped at $10,000 by the new federal law (Public Law 115-97).
(3)The federal tax changes, coupled with potential reductions to federal programs, pose a risk to Californias economy, California families, and state government.
(4)While Californias economy has evolved, its tax system has failed to keep up with the times. Over the past 60 years, California has moved from an agriculture-based and manufacturing-based economy to a service-based economy. In California, goods are subject to sales or use tax while services generally are not.
(5)As a result, state tax revenues have become less reliant on revenues derived from the sales and use tax on goods and more reliant on revenues derived from the personal income tax. In 1950, the sales and use taxes comprised 61 percent of the state General Fund; however, today they account for about 30 percent. The personal income tax accounted for 12 percent of the General Fund in 1950; however, today it accounts for almost 70 percent.
(b)It is the intent of this act to do all of the following:
(1)Provide tax relief to middle-income and low-income Californians to make up in part for tax increases and reductions to federal programs recently enacted or proposed by the federal government.
(2)Ensure that out-of-state corporations that do business in California contribute their fair share to Californias economy.
(3)Realign a portion of the states outdated tax code with the realities of Californias 21st century service-based economy.
(4)Broaden the tax base by imposing a modest sales tax on services used by businesses in California:
(A)This tax would offset a portion of the significant financial benefits provided to businesses under the new federal law. However, businesses would still be able to deduct from their federal taxes the state sales and use tax imposed on the services they use, which would mean most businesses will still pay lower taxes than before the federal changes.
(B)Health care services, education services, child care, and interest and insurance payments subject to the state gross premiums tax would be exempt from the sales tax on services.
(C)These changes would more fairly apportion taxes between goods and services and would produce more stable revenues.
SEC. 2.Chapter 3.8 (commencing with Section 6305) is added to Part 1 of Division 2 of the Revenue and Taxation Code, to read:3.8.Services6305.(a)On and after January 1, 2019, in addition to the other taxes imposed by this part, a sales tax is hereby imposed the purchase of services by businesses in California at the rate of ____ percent of the sales price of the service.
(b)The tax shall be collected and remitted by the seller of the service purchased by a business for benefit or use in California. In cases where the service benefits or is used by a purchasers California and non-California operations, an appropriate share of the services shall be apportioned to California for purposes of determining the tax.
(c)The following are exempt from the tax imposed by this section:
(1)Health care, education, and child care services, and interest and insurance payments subject to the gross premiums tax.
(2)A business with gross receipts of less than one hundred thousand dollars ($100,000) in the previous four quarters.
6307.(a)The Retail Sales Tax on Services Fund is hereby created in the State Treasury.
(b)All amounts of tax required to be paid to the state under this chapter shall be paid to the California Department of Tax and Fee Administration in the form of remittances payable to the California Department of Tax and Fee Administration. The California Department of Tax and Fee Administration shall transmit the payments, less refunds and cost of administration, to the Treasurer to be deposited into the Retail Sales Tax on Services Fund.
(c)Moneys in the fund shall be appropriated for the following purposes:
(1)Providing tax relief to middle-income and low-income Californians negatively affected by recent changes to federal tax law as well as other changes to federal programs.
(2)Assisting in securing greater stability for Californias infrastructure, its workforce, and its education systems, including higher education.
SEC. 3.This act provides for a tax levy within the meaning of Article IV of the California Constitution and shall go into immediate effect.
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| May 16, 2018 | May 16 hearing: Heard for testimony only. |
| May 9, 2018 | From committee with author's amendments. Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on GOV. & F. |
| May 8, 2018 | Set for hearing May 16. |
| Feb 14, 2018 | Referred to Com. on GOV. & F. |
| Feb 6, 2018 | From printer. May be acted upon on or after March 8. |
| Feb 5, 2018 | Introduced. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. To print. |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
SENATE COMMITTEE ON GOVERNANCE AND FINANCE
Senator Mike McGuire, Chair
2017 - 2018 Regular
Bill No: | SB 993 | Hearing Date: | 5/16/18 |
Author: | Hertzberg | Tax Levy: | Yes |
Version: | 5/9/18 | Fiscal: | Yes |
Consultant: | Grinnell | ||
Sales tax: services
Enacts the Service Tax Law, which imposes an excise tax on the receipt of the benefit of a service by a business in California, and reduces the current sales and use tax rate on transfers of tangible personal property.
Background
Sales and use tax. State law imposes the sales tax on every retailer engaged in business in this state that sells tangible personal property, and requires them to collect the appropriate tax from the purchaser, and remit the amount to the California Department of Tax and Fee Administration (CDTFA), which assumed the duties of collecting the sales and use tax from the Board of Equalization (BOE) in 2017. The sales and use tax neither applies to intangible products, such as downloaded software, nor to services.
Sales tax applies whenever a retail sale is made, which is basically any sale other than one for resale in the regular course of business. Unless the person pays the sales tax to the retailer, he or she is liable for the use tax, which is imposed on any person consuming tangible personal property in the state. The use tax rate is the same rate as the sales tax rate, and must be remitted on or before the last day of the month following the quarterly period in which the person made the purchase. The current rate is 7.25% as shown in the table below.
Rate | Jurisdiction | Purpose/Authority | |
|---|---|---|---|
3.9375% | State (General Fund) | State general purposes | |
1.0625% |
| Local governments to fund local public safety services | |
0.50% | State (1991 Realignment) | Local governments to fund health and welfare programs | |
0.50% | State (1993) | Local governments to fund public safety services | |
1.25% | Local (City/County) 1.00% City and County | City and county general operations. Dedicated to county transportation purposes | |
7.25% | Total Statewide Rate |
State law also allows cities, counties, and special districts to impose their own transactions and use tax within its jurisdiction subject to voter approval, known as “local add-ons” or “district taxes,” so long as they relied on the same base and procedures as the sales and use tax.
Services. In recent years, consumers have shifted their spending patterns from property, which are taxable, to intangibles and services, which are not. The Legislative Analyst’s Office (LAO) estimates that consumer spending on taxable items peaked in 1979, when consumers spent 53 cents of each dollar on taxable items. Since then, the sales tax base has grown at 1.3%, well below growth in the general economy and personal income. LAO states that the trend is primarily because taxable items have become less expensive relative to nontaxable items, resulting in more discretionary income that can be spent elsewhere. Spending on services such as entertainment, leisure, and recreation increases as income grows, and consumer demand has grown despite consistent increases in service prices that are four times the growth in prices for taxable items. LAO estimates that if consumption patterns had remained the same since 1979, the sales and use tax rate could be more than 3% lower and generate the same amount of revenue, and adds that this trend is likely to continue. The National Conference on State Legislatures notes that the diminishing sales tax base affects other states too: in 2015, NCSL stated that 22 states reported that general sales tax revenues fell below estimates, or that revenue targets had been lowered.
Pointing to approximately $644 billion in currently nontaxable business-to-business sales of services, the author wants to impose a tax on business purchases of services, and reduce the current sales and use tax rate that applies to tangible property.
Proposed Law
Senate Bill 993 enacts the Service Tax Law, which imposes an excise tax on the receipt of the benefit of a service by a business in California. The measure also reduces the base sales and use tax rate (General Fund) according to a schedule set forth in the bill.
Imposition. Beginning on January 1, 2020, SB 993 imposes the tax on a “qualified business,” defined as “a person, corporation, partnership, sole proprietorship, limited liability company and limited liability partnership engaged in business to provide a product or service for the purpose of producing income taxable under federal income tax law.” The bill assigns the benefit of the service to the location where the business either directly or indirectly receives value from the delivery of the service. Under the bill, the business becomes liable for the tax whenever they receive a benefit of a service in California, which is not extinguished until the tax is paid unless and until they are given a receipt from the retailer of the service. Businesses pay taxes to CDTFA, who deposits proceeds in the General Fund. SB 993’s tax is measured as a percentage of the sales price of the service, using the following rates by calendar year:
- For 2020, .75%,
- For 2021, 1.5%, and
- For 2022 and each year thereafter, 3%.
Retailers. Any service retailer must register with CDTFA, collect the tax from the purchaser at the time of sale, or when the services become taxable, and give the qualified business a receipt in a form and manner designed by CDTFA. SB 993 uses the current definition for retailer in the sales and use tax law, including the Legislature’s additions of certain remote sellers to the definition of retailer for use tax collection purposes (AB 155, Calderon, 2011). The measure also considers retailers those with cumulative sales of services that exceed $500,000 within the preceding 12 months using the same definition used by the Legislature when applying this “economic nexus” standard for the Corporation Tax (ABx3 15, Krekorian, and SBx3 15, Calderon, 2009).
Retailers are not liable for the tax when accounts are deemed worthless and charged off for income tax purposes, similar to the sales and use tax. Any tax amount collected by the retailer plus any other funds that are not taxes but are not returned to the purchaser constitute a debt owed to the state. The bill provides that retailers are guilty of misdemeanors for:
- Advertising, holding out, or stating to the public that it will assume, absorb, or refund the tax.
- Failing to display the tax separately from the list price, price advertised on the premises, the marked prices, or other price on the sales check.
Services subject to tax. The bill defines “service” as a “commodity consisting of activities engaged in by a person for another person for consideration.” The measure’s definition specifically excludes:
- Activities performed by a person not in a regular trade or business offering its services to the public,
- Services rendered, furnished, or performed by and within a corporation’s commonly controlled group, or within the same insurance company, and
- Services provided by an employee to whom the retailer pays wages.
Exemptions. The measure exempts from the tax services:
- Where the state is prohibited from taxing it by the U.S. or California Constitutions, or federal law.
- Where the retailer or purchaser can demonstrate to CDTFA that the service is currently subject to the Sales and Use Tax.
- Provided as part of an occasional sale, using the current definition in the Sales and Use tax.
- Provided by a person whose gross receipts subject to SB 993’s tax are less than $100,000 in the previous four quarters.
- Subject to the Gross Premiums Tax, which is the state’s sole means of taxing most insurance companies.
- Where the beneficiary of the service is a tenant from the rental, lease, or provision of real property for personal or commercial use.
- Where the purchaser was obligated to purchase the service pursuant to a fixed price contract entered into prior to January 1, 2017, unless any party to the contract has a right to terminate the contract upon notice.
- Purchased by:
- The United States Government, its unincorporated agencies and instrumentalities,
- Any incorporated agency or instrumentality of the United States wholly owned by the United States or by a corporation wholly owned by the United States, or
- The American Red Cross.
- Delivered as a municipal service by a city, county, or city and county, or special district, or by an entity contracted to provide a municipal service.
SB 993 also exempts services provided by businesses engaged in the following lines of business, using North American Industrial Classification System Code (NAICS) subsections from the 2012 or 2017 edition:
- Education Services, that directly involve providing education and training, delivered by:
- Elementary and Secondary Schools;
- Junior Colleges;
- Colleges, Universities, and Professional Schools;
- Business Schools and Computer and Management Training;
- Technical and Trade Schools;
- Other Schools and Instruction; and
- Educational Support Services.
- Ambulatory Health Services, Hospitals, and Nursing and Residential Care Facilities, that directly involve providing health care and assisted living, delivered by:
- Offices of Physicians;
- Offices of Dentists;
- Offices of Other Health Practitioners;
- Outpatient Care Centers;
- Medical and Diagnostic Laboratories;
- Home Health Care Services;
- Other Ambulatory Health Care Services;
- General Medical and Surgical Hospitals;
- Psychiatric and Substance Abuse Hospitals;
- Specialty (except Psychiatric and Substance Abuse) Hospitals;
- Nursing Care Facilities;
- Residential Mental Retardation, Mental Health and Substance Abuse Facilities;
- Community Care Facilities for the Elderly; or
- Other Residential Care Facilities.
- Child Day Care Services, that directly involve providing child care.
- Utilities, including:
- Electric Power Generation, Transmission and Distribution;
- Natural Gas Distribution; or
- Water, Sewage and Other Systems.
- Residential Building Construction.
- Wholesalers of durable and nondurable goods, and wholesale electronic markets and agents and brokers.
- The Postal Service.
- Automotive Parts, Accessories, and Tire Stores.
- Arts, entertainment, and recreation, including:
- Performing Arts, Spectator Sports, and Related Industries,
- Museums, Historical Sites, and Similar Institutions, or
- Amusement, Gambling, and Recreation Industries.
- Food Services and Drinking Places, including:
- Full-Service Restaurants,
- Limited-Service Eating Places,
- Special Food Services, or
- Drinking Places (Alcoholic Beverages).
- Other Services (except Public Administration), including:
- Repair and Maintenance;
- Personal and Laundry Services;
- Religious, Grantmaking, Civic, Professional, and Similar Organizations; or
- Private Households.
- Interest.
For any of the above exemptions, the purchaser may certify in writing that the receipt of the benefit of the service is exempt. The certificate then relieves the seller from the obligation if taken in good faith.
Sales for resale. The bill presumes that if a service is purchased from a retailer engaged in business in California, then the benefit of the service is in California. However, a person making the sale can establish the contrary. The burden of proving the contrary is upon the seller unless he or she takes a resale certificate from the purchaser. The certificate relieves the seller from the duty of collecting the tax if taken in good faith from a person who is engaged in the business of selling services, and has obtained a retail service seller’s permit under the bill. The measure requires the certificate to contain specified contents prescribed by CDTFA. Any contractor of services, defined as a person that purchases services from a subcontractor of services for resale, may provide the subcontractor with a certificate that complies with the bill. The bill imposes the tax on a contractor or a person holding a resale certificate if they receive the benefit of the service in the tax.
Tax Rates and adjustments. SB 993 reduces the current base sales and use tax rate allocated to the state General Fund according to a specified schedule, and contains an adjustment mechanism that can alter the rate upward or downward by .0125% (1/8th of a percentage point) in 2021, 2022, and 2023.
The bill alters the base General Fund sales and use tax rate as follows:
- In the 2020 calendar year, the rate is reduced by .5%,
- In the 2021 calendar year, the rate is reduced by another .5%, for an aggregate 1% reduction, plus or minus a possible adjustment,
- In the 2022 calendar year, the rate is additionally reduced by 1%, for an aggregate 2% reduction, plus or minus a possible adjustment,
- In the 2023 calendar year, the 2% aggregate reduction is maintained, plus or minus a possible adjustment, and
- In the 2024 calendar year and thereafter, the 2% aggregate reduction is maintained.
The bill requires the Director of Finance to estimate the amount of net revenue that will be derived for the next calendar year as a result of the imposition of the services tax, and the reduction in the base sales and use tax General Fund rate on or before September 15, 2020, and again by the same date in 2021 and 2022. Under the measure:
- If the Director of Finance estimates in 2020 that net revenue gain derived from SB 993 will exceed $450 million in 2021, the sales and use tax rate is reduced by 0.125% for the 2021 calendar year,
- However, if the Director of Finance estimates in 2020 that the net revenue loss derived from SB 993 will exceed $450 million in 2021, the sales and use tax rate is increased by 0.125% for the 2021 calendar year,
- If the Director of Finance estimates in 2021 that net revenue gain derived from SB 993 will exceed $460 million in 2022, the sales and use tax rate is reduced by 0.125% for the 2022 calendar year,
- However, if the Director of Finance estimates in 2021 that the net revenue loss derived from SB 993 will exceed $460 million in 2022, the sales and use tax rate is increased by 0.125% for the 2022 calendar year,
- If the Director of Finance estimates in 2022 that net revenue gain derived from SB 993 will exceed $470 million in 2023, the sales and use tax rate is reduced by 0.125% for the 2023 calendar year,
- However, if the Director of Finance estimates in 2022 that the net revenue loss derived from SB 993 will exceed $470 million in 2023, the sales and use tax rate is increased by 0.125% for the 2023 calendar year.
The bill requires the Director of Finance to notify CDTFA and the chair of the Joint Legislative Budget Committee within five days of making a determination that results in a change in the rate.
Other provisions. SB 993 also:
- Directs CDFTA, in consultation with the Franchise Tax Board, to adopt regulations to establish an apportionment methodology for multistate businesses.
- Allows CDFTA to require persons subject to the tax to place with it any reasonable security necessary to ensure compliance. CDTFA may sell the security at a public auction if necessary to recover any fee or amount required to be collected, interest, or penalty. CDTFA must serve notice of the sale to the person by mail or in person. The bill sets forth specified procedures for notifying the person.
- Provides a credit against the tax equal to the amount of tax paid to any other state. SB 993 directs that the credit must be apportioned to taxes against which it is allowed in proportion to the amount of those taxes.
- Imports provisions from the Fee Collections Procedures Law for determinations, collections, overpayments, refunds, administration, the Taxpayer Bill of Rights, and violations.
- States that its provisions do not authorize a city, county, or city and county, to impose a similar tax on services. The measure bars the state from collecting such a tax on behalf of local agencies.
The bill defines many of its terms, using several definitions from the sales and use tax law, and makes legislative findings and declarations supporting its purposes.
State Revenue Impact
Pending.
Comments
1. Purpose of the bill. According to the author, “Senate Bill 993 updates California’s tax system to reflect modern economic activities. Our economy has shifted from an agricultural based economy in the 1950’s to a service based economy, but we haven’t updated our tax code to reflect this shift. Sales and use taxes accounted for 61% of the General Fund revenues in 1950 and today it accounts for about 20%. This bill broadens our tax base gradually, reaching 3% for service, by 2023. This proposal is also revenue neutral and will synchronize a reduction in sales taxes on goods by 2%. The established service tax will focus on business to business transactions while exempting businesses whose gross receipts don’t reach $100,000 in four quarters. This tax reform will help California deal with volatility and provides working families with tax relief.”
2. Something new. SB 993 enacts a new tax in the hopes of capturing transactions that escape California’s current sales and use tax base, enacted in the 1930s, while cutting base sales and use tax rates. As a result, lower-income Californians who spend more of their dispensable income on taxable property should pay less tax, while firms that consume services will pay more. In theory, the bill’s low rate structure and reduced sales and use tax rate on property should result in fewer distortions, where taxpayers alter transaction or business structures to avoid taxes, and solidify the state’s revenue base.
However, implementing SB 993 will not be easy either for taxpayers or the state. While some sellers of services currently collect and remit sales and use taxes to CDTFA, many do not, and will be required by the bill to collect a tax that measures its purchaser’s benefit of the use of a service. Firms that consume services may have difficulty passing along the tax in prices, especially in competitive markets where margins are small. Service providers will have to determine when services are exempt, whether a resale certificate applies, demonstrating when necessary that the purchaser is not receiving the benefit of the service in California, and applying apportionment regulations when the purchaser received the benefit of the service in more than one state. CDTFA can impose penalties if service providers do not implement the bill correctly.
In 2015, the Board of Equalization issued a fact sheet, revenue estimate, and other information regarding a sales tax on consumer services. While SB 993 does not enact a sales tax on consumer services, BOE stated that a consumer services tax would have a substantial impact on its administrative processes, including increased costs to create a new collections and enforcement infrastructure; enact new regulations and guidance; hire, house, and train staff; identify and register affected businesses; make programmatic changes; respond to taxpayer inquiries; provide outreach to taxpayers; perform audit and collection functions; establish effective refund and appeals programs, and perform other administrative duties. It’s likely that the issues identified by BOE above would also apply to CDTFA implementing SB 993, which would have to accomplish all of these tasks for service providers to be able to collect the tax under the bill’s effective date of January 1, 2020, and would do so concomitantly with the launch of its new information technology system, the Centralized Revenue Opportunity System. California has recent experience implementing an ambitious vision on a short deadline with the Adult Use of Marijuana Act’s regulatory and tax requirements (Proposition 64, 2016); however, implementation efforts have not assuaged significant turmoil the initiatives has caused for many cannabis businesses. Additionally, cannabis tax revenues in its first quarter of the first year of implementation fell significantly short of estimates. The Committee may wish to consider whether CDTFA can implement SB 993 by January 1, 2020.
In particular, determining the benefit of the use of a service for a multistate business will be complex. The bill requires any seller of a non-exempt service to a multistate company to determine at the time of sale whether the purchaser receives a benefit of the use in California of the service sold, the share of the benefit in California compared to its benefit received in other states, charge the tax measured as a percentage of the sales price, and collect and remit the appropriate tax when not exempt. The bill envisions CDTFA regulations apportioning the benefit to California, but the bill’s tax is measured as a percentage of its sales price before any apportionment. Additionally, the benefit of any service could change as quickly as the company’s supply chain does, with potentially different benefits for any given service. For example, a person using YouTube to sell instructional videos will have to determine whether her customers are benefitting from the information provided in the videos in California, and if so, how much of their benefit is received in California compared to their benefit in other states. If the person sold videos to a business, she would have to determine whether and how much the businesses used the benefits provided by her instructional videos in California compared to other states.
FTB developed regulations that source a sale according to the purchaser’s receipt of the benefit of a service for corporate income tax purposes, implementing the state’s shift to “market-based sourcing,” that became effective in the 2011 taxable year. While these regulations have been in place for years, and have not been overturned by courts, they serve only to source a sale, not directly measure their customer’s benefit of a service receive, which is the base of SB 993’s tax. FTB continues to refine these regulations, with additional regulatory proceedings to further define terms and add examples occurring this year. Additionally, corporation taxpayers have time between the time when they make a sale and file their return to collect information to reasonably approximate the state in which the benefit of a service is received, but SB 993 would require the seller of instructional videos to calculate this benefit when charging for access to view the instructional videos, unless the purchaser pays the tax instead.
It is also difficult to forecast SB 993’s economic effects. Economists consistently recommend lower tax rates and broader tax bases, and a reduction in the sales and use tax rates will directly lower taxes for any Californian making a taxable purchase. However, opponents argue that SB 993’s tax duplicates income taxes, especially in light of California’s requirement that most multistate businesses must apportion income for corporation tax purposes solely using its sales factor (its sales in California as a percentage of its total sales). Opponents add that while SB 993’s are solely payable by businesses, these taxes will be passed on to consumers in the form of higher costs, and places them at a competitive disadvantage to firms in other states.
3. Tax Reform in California. SB 993 is likely the most ambitious change to the state’s tax system since Proposition 13 (1978), which fundamentally altered the property tax. While the state’s revenue system has performed well in recent years, its tax structure is volatile, resulting in unanticipated budget shortfalls which then necessitate cuts to key public services. The Top 1% of taxpayers pay half of the personal income tax, which comprises about 70% of general fund revenues. As a result, changes in state revenues usually over or understate changes in the economy, and rise and fall according to the fortunes of Californians with the highest incomes. The recession in the early 2000s led to over $80 billion in revenue losses, and LAO states that a moderate recession could lead to a $40 billion budget problem, and a mild one with a $20 billion one. While the state has enacted and funded the Proposition 2 (2014) rainy day reserve, a moderate recession would quickly exhaust the Governor’s proposed reserve of $15 billion, and would compel roughly $25 billion in actions to address a budget problem, including spending cuts, revenue increases, and cost shifts.
Advocates for tax reform have proposed to apply the sales tax to services, and use the revenue to counteract the slow growth in the current sales tax base, reduce the overall rate, or shrink other taxes. The revenue potential for a sales tax on services is immense: the Board of Equalization estimated annual revenue of $122.6 billion in by taxing all currently nontaxable services, $57.6 billion of which would flow to the General Fund, with the remainder going to local governments and special districts. Advocates also state that the current sales and use tax is regressive, resulting in lower-income taxpayers bearing more of the incidence of the tax, and expanding the sales tax to services would capture currently untaxed business consumption.
In recent years, California has seen several efforts to reform its taxes to reduce volatility, among them:
- The Commission on Tax Policy in the New Economy, created by the Legislature (SB 1933, Vasconcellos, 2000), recommended in its 2003 report, among others, to:
- Improve collection of the use tax,
- Broaden the sales tax base to include selected services, while lowering the state rate to retain revenue neutrality, and
- Eliminate selected sales and use tax exemptions or exclusions.
- The Commission on the 21st Century Economy, created by Governor Schwarzenegger, recommended in its 2010 report, among others, to:
- Reduce the personal income tax for every taxpayer,
- Eliminate the corporation tax and minimum tax,
- Eliminate the state general purpose sales tax, and
- Establish a business net receipts tax, a new tax, not to exceed 4 percent, applied to the net receipts of businesses.
- The Think Long Committee for California, a bipartisan committee of prominent Californians, issued a report entitled a “Blueprint to Renew California,” which contained several tax reform proposals, including to:
- Enact a floating rate sales tax based on revenues on all services with exceptions for medical and education, phased in over time,
- Reduce the sales and use tax rate on tangible personal property,
- Provide a rebate for low-income households,
- Revise personal income taxes into system with two rates: 2% for income under $25,000 single/$50,000 joint, and 7.5% above that,
- Increase the standard deduction, but eliminate other credits and deductions,
- Reduce the corporation tax rate from 8.84% to 7%, and
- Double the homeowners’ exemption, which triggers increase in renter’s credit.
SB 993 differs from these proposals by taxing the consumption of business services, not consumer services. Many states tax some services, and California taxes a few, most notably service charges in connection with the delivery of tangible personal property; however, none have tried a tax similar to this measure.
4. Nexus and apportionment. The United States Constitution grants the power to Congress to “regulate Commerce with foreign nations, and among the several states” a provision widely known as the Commerce Clause (Article I, Section 8). If Congress fails to regulate interstate commerce wholly or in part, the United States Supreme Court has asserted consistently that the Constitution still precludes states from doing so, known as the “dormant” or “negative” Commerce Clause. Additionally, the due process clause (Amendment XIV, Sec. 1.) can also limit state taxation of interstate commerce. For many years, the Court held that a tax on the privilege of engaging in an activity in a State could not be applied to an activity that is part of interstate commerce. However, beginning in 1959, the Court started to uphold taxes upon taxpayers with activities that have nexus in the state, are fairly apportioned, non-discriminatory, and that have a fair relationship between the tax and the services provided must exist in Northwestern States Portland Cement Co. v. Minnesota. In 1977, the Court enshrined this four part test in Complete Auto Transit v. Brady, 430 U.S. 274, 97 S.Ct. 1076.
In 1992, the Court distinguished taxes based on the sales of tangible personal property, holding that a state could not require a seller without physical nexus in a state to collect and remit the state’s sales and use tax in Quill Corp. v. North Dakota, 504. U.S. 278. The Court stated that such a tax did not violate the due process clause, but did impair the commerce clause because it unduly burdened interstate commerce. The Quill decision prohibits states from compelling remote sellers from collecting sales and use taxes; however, the United States Supreme Court heard oral arguments on April 17th in South Dakota v. Wayfair, which could overturn Quill, and allow states to compel out-of-state retailers to collect the tax.
As mentioned above, SB 993 enacts a new tax on business to business services that no state has tried, using an economic nexus standard that requires retailers of services without physical presence in the state to collect and remit its tax. While Quill is specific to sales and use taxes, and SB 993 is imposed on the benefit of the use of a service, taxpayers without a physical presence may argue that Quill applies to taxes measured as a percentage of a sales price, imposed at the time of purchase, and implemented using terms and definitions for the sales and use tax. SB 993 shifts the payment obligation to the purchaser by maintaining a business’s liability for the tax if the retailer does not provide them a receipt for tax paid, which functions like the use tax obligation that currently applies when retailers lack nexus in California. While California has attempted for many years to effectively collect use taxes from individual consumers, SB 993 should be more effective because businesses have the additional incentives of deducting them from federal taxes, and generally maintain better records than consumers, which should help CDTFA effectively collect the tax.
Even if SB 993’s service tax isn’t considered a sales tax for nexus purposes, taxpayers may argue that it is not fairly apportioned. SB 993 assigns the benefit of the service to the location where the business directly or indirectly received value from the delivery of the service, and directs CDTFA in consultation with FTB to enact regulations that establish an apportionment methodology for multistate businesses. Apportionment rules for state income taxes may not be easily applied to a service tax. Regulations will have to be carefully constructed to ensure that SB 993’s taxes don’t pass an unfair share of the tax burden onto interstate commerce.
5. Odds and ends. SB 993 would benefit from refinement in the following areas:
- The seller is responsible for collecting the tax, either at the time of sale or when the service becomes taxable, but only the purchaser will know how to apportion the receipt of the benefit of the service between states. It will be difficult for retailers selling to multistate business or when exemptions aren’t clear to correctly calculate the amount of tax for a service that is yet to be used, especially for less sophisticated sellers unused to collecting and remitting taxes to CDTFA.
- Specifying the applicability of the tax when a person uses his or business to purchase a service, or when an employee purchases a service paid for by the business. For example, would a service provider collect the tax if a taxpayer paid using the credit card or checkbook for their business, but not if they use a personal credit card or check?
- Clarifying the requirement for apportionment for multistate business when any benefit received in California triggers the tax, and the measure of tax using a percentage of its sales price.
- The measure’s provisions regarding resale certificates are unclear. Many service providers will meet the bill’s definition of “qualified business” when procuring other services as part of services provided to non-business consumers. For example, a realtor meets the definition, and is therefore subject to SB 993’s tax, when purchasing home inspection, title insurance, and pest control services, which are then passed on to the homebuyer as part of a the realtor’s compensation. However, the bill’s procedures for resale certificates would appear to allow the realtor to be exempt from the tax by using a resale certificate: first, the measure relieves a person from the duty of collecting the tax when a resale certificate is presented by a person who is engaged in the business of selling services, and further provides that a purchaser who is a contactor of services that purchases services from a subcontractor for resale can present the resale certificate to the subcontractor.
- Some of the exemptions defined using NAICS codes are limited to specific services provided, whereas others only require a person be engaged in the specified lines of business. As a result, services that should be included in a broad-based, business-to-business services tax could be avoided. For example, an accounting firm could purchase a restaurant, and therefore be engaged in those lines of business as described in NAICS Subsector 722/7225, so exempt from the tax. The bill may benefit from instead requiring the person be “primarily engaged” in the specified line of business, similar to the sales and use tax exemption for manufacturing equipment, among others.
- Whether interest should be considered a service for purpose of the exemption, as interest is generally compensation paid for the use of funds, not a service provided.
- The exemption for the benefit of services provided by a tenant from the rental, lease, or provision of real property isn’t limited to rent paid, and could be interpreted to include other services provided by property owners to tenants incorporated in rents or other charges, such as security or janitorial services, which would be taxable under the bill when separately purchased.
- Altering the date for which a fixed price contract must be entered into for the exemption to apply from January 1, 2017, to January 1, 2019.
- The definition for qualified business only includes a person or entity engaged in business to provide a product or service the purposes of which is to produce income taxable under federal law. This definition excludes any entity that is tax-exempt for federal income tax purposes, but not a trust that generates unrelated business taxable income under federal law.
- The American Red Cross exemption duplicates the exemption for a tax exempt non-profit.
- It’s unclear whether the exclusion from the definition of seller for “activities performed by a person who is not in a regular trade or business offering its services to the public” would apply to boutique and custom services such as asset management, private security, consulting, and others, sold to specific individuals and not marketed to the general public.
- Accounting for intercompany transactions within the unitary group for purposes of the exemption from the exclusion from the definition of seller to account when a corporate structure changes during the taxable year.
- Exemption for NAICS code for postal service duplicates exemption for U.S Government and its unincorporated agencies and instrumentalities.
Support and Opposition
(5/11/18)
Support: Unknown
Opposition: Almond Alliance of California; American Council of Engineering Companies; American Institute of Architects, California Council; Anschutz Entertainment Group; Apartment Association, California Southern Cities; Apartment Association of Orange County; Association of California Egg Farmers; Association of California Life and Health Insurance Companies; Automotive Service Councils of California; Biocom; Building Owners and Managers Association of California; Calaveras County Taxpayers Association; California Apartment Association; California Asian Pacific Islander Chamber of Commerce; California Association of Collectors; California Association of Health Underwriters; California Association of Realtors; California Association of Wheat Growers California Autobody Association; California Automotive Business Association; California Bankers Association; California Bean Shippers Association; California Beer and Beverage Distributors; California Business Properties Association; California Cable and Telecommunications Association; California Chamber of Commerce; California Coalition of Travel Organizations; California Defense Counsel; California Escrow Association; California Farm Bureau Federation; California Grain and Feed Association; California Hotel and Lodging Association; California Land Title Association; California Life Sciences Association; California Manufacturers & Technology Association; California Mortgage Association; California New Car Dealers Association; California News Publishers Association; California Pear Growers Association; California Pool and Spa Association; California Railroads; California Real Estate Inspection Association; California Restaurant Association; California Retailers Association; California Seed Association; California Society of Certified Professional Accountants; California Society of Enrolled Agents; California State Club Association; California State Floral Association; California Tank Lines Inc.; California Taxpayers Association; California Tire Dealers Association; California Travel Association; California Trucking Association; California Warehouse Association; Camarillo Chamber of Commerce; Chamber of Commerce Alliance of Ventura and Santa Barbara Counties; Chemical Transfer Co.; CompTIA; Council on State Taxation; East Bay Rental Housing Association; Family Business Association of California; Folsom Chamber of Commerce; Fullerton Association of Concerned Taxpayers; Greater Conejo Valley Chamber of Commerce; Greater Irvine Chamber of Commerce; Greater San Fernando Valley Chamber of Commerce; Howard Jarvis Taxpayers Association; Independent Insurance Agents and Brokers of California; Insights Association; International Automotive Professionals Association; International Council of Shopping Centers; Investment Company Institute; Kern County Taxpayers Association; National Association for Industrial and Office Parks; National Association of Insurance and Financial Advisors of California; National Federation of Independent Business; National Notary Association; North Orange County Chamber of Commerce; North Valley Property Owners Association; Orange County Business Council; Orange County Taxpayers Association; Pacific Coast Rendering Association; Pacific Egg & Poultry Association; Plumbing-Heating-Cooling Contractors Association; Property Casualty Insurers Association of America; Professional Fiduciary Association of California; Retail Industry Leaders Association; San Diego County Apartment Association; San Gabriel Valley Economic Partnership; Securities Industry and Financial Markets Association; Silicon Valley Leadership Group; Silicon Valley Taxpayers Association; Solano County Taxpayers Association Spidell Publishing, Inc.; Structural Engineers Association of California; Superior Tank Wash Inc.; Sutter County Taxpayers Association ; Taxicab Paratransit Association of California; UPS; Valley Industry & Commerce Association; West Coast Leasing, LLC; West Coast Lumber and Building Material Association; Western Electrical Contractors Association Inc.; Western Manufactured Housing Communities Association; Western States Petroleum Association; Wine Institute
-- END --
Discussed in Hearing
Senate Standing Committee on Governance and Finance
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):