SB 999: Barbering and cosmetology.
- Session Year: 2017-2018
- House: Senate
- Latest Version Date: 2018-05-25
Existing law, the Barbering and Cosmetology Act, provides for the licensure and regulation of the practice of barbering and cosmetology, which include, among other things, shampooing, arranging, dressing, curling, waiving, waving, and applying hair tonics to, the hair of any person, by the State Board of Barbering and Cosmetology. The act specifies that the practice of cosmetology also includes the practice of cleansing or beautifying the hair of any person and that the practice of barbering also includes the practice of hairstyling all textures of hair by standard methods that are current at the time of the hairstyling. The act makes it unlawful for any person to engage in barbering or cosmetology for compensation or to operate an establishment where barbering or cosmetology is practiced, without a license, and specifies that a violation of this requirement is subject to an administrative fine and may be subject to a misdemeanor. The act also makes it a misdemeanor, punishable as prescribed, for any person, firm, association or corporation to violate the act if no specific penalty is otherwise provided.
This bill would remove the practices of shampooing, arranging, dressing, curling, and waving the hair of any person from the practice of barbering and cosmetology. The bill would remove the practice of hairstyling of all textures of hair by standard methods that are current at the time of the hairstyling from the practice of barbering. The bill would also remove the practice of cleansing or beautifying the hair of any person from the practice of cosmetology. The bill would require a person who engages in practices of arranging, beautifying, cleansing, curling, dressing, shampooing, or waving the hair of any person at an establishment to provide notice to consumers of his or her licensure status. Because the bill would create a new crime, the bill would impose a state-mandated local program.
The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.
This bill would provide that no reimbursement is required by this act for a specified reason.
Existing law, the Barbering and Cosmetology Act, provides for the licensure and regulation of the practice of barbering and cosmetology, which include, among other things, shampooing, arranging, dressing, curling, waiving, and applying hair tonics to, the hair of any person, by the State Board of Barbering and Cosmetology. The act specifies that the practice of cosmetology also includes the practice of cleansing or beautifying the hair of any person and that the practice of barbering also includes the practice of hairstyling all textures of hair by standard methods that are current at the time of the hairstyling. The act makes it unlawful for any person to engage in barbering or cosmetology for compensation or to operate an establishment where barbering or cosmetology is practiced, without a license, and specifies that a violation of this requirement is subject to an administrative fine and may be subject to a misdemeanor.
This bill would remove the practices of shampooing, arranging, dressing, curling, and waving the hair of any person from the practice of barbering and cosmetology. The bill would remove the practice of hairstyling of all textures of hair by standard methods that are current at the time of the hairstyling from the practice of barbering. The bill would also remove the practice of cleansing or beautifying the hair of any person from the practice of cosmetology.
Existing law, the Barbering and Cosmetology Act, provides for the licensure and regulation of the practice of barbering and cosmetology, which include, among other things, shampooing, arranging, dressing, curling, waiving, and applying hair tonics to, the hair of any person, by the State Board of Barbering and Cosmetology. Existing law The act specifies that the practice of cosmetology also includes the practice of cleansing or beautifying the hair of any person. The act makes it unlawful for any person to engage in barbering or cosmetology for compensation or to operate an establishment where barbering or cosmetology is practiced, without a license, and specifies that a violation of this requirement is subject to an administrative fine and may be subject to a misdemeanor.
This bill would remove shampooing the practices of shampooing, arranging, dressing, curling, and waving the hair of any person from the practice of barbering and cosmetology. The bill would also remove the practice of cleansing or beautifying the hair of any person from the practice of cosmetology.
Existing law, the Barbering and Cosmetology Act, provides for the licensure and regulation of the practice of barbering and cosmetology, which include, among other things, shampooing, dressing, and applying hair tonics to, the hair of any person, by the State Board of Barbering and Cosmetology. Existing law makes it unlawful for any person to engage in barbering or cosmetology for compensation or to operate an establishment where barbering or cosmetology is practiced, without a license, and specifies that a violation of this requirement is subject to an administrative fine and may be subject to a misdemeanor.
This bill would remove shampooing from the practice of barbering and cosmetology.
(a)The practice of barbering is all or any combination of the following practices:
(1)Shaving or trimming the beard or cutting the hair.
(2)Giving facial and scalp massages or treatments with oils, creams, lotions, or other preparations either by hand or mechanical appliances.
(3)Singeing, chemical waving, hair relaxing, or dyeing the hair or applying hair tonics.
(4)Applying cosmetic preparations, antiseptics, powders, oils, clays, or lotions to scalp, face, or neck.
(b)The practice of cosmetology is all or any combination of the following practices:
(1)Machineless permanent waving, permanent waving, cutting, relaxing, singeing, bleaching, tinting, coloring, straightening, dyeing, applying hair tonics to, or otherwise treating by any means, the hair of any person.
(2)Massaging, cleaning, or stimulating the scalp, face, neck, arms, or upper part of the human body, by means of the hands, devices, apparatus or appliances, with or without the use of cosmetic preparations, antiseptics, tonics, lotions, or creams.
(3)Beautifying the face, neck, arms, or upper part of the human body, by use of cosmetic preparations, antiseptics, tonics, lotions, or creams.
(4)Removing superfluous hair from the body of any person by the use of depilatories or by the use of tweezers, chemicals, or preparations or by the use of devices or appliances of any kind or description, except by the use of light waves, commonly known as rays.
(5)Cutting, trimming, polishing, tinting, coloring, cleansing, or manicuring the nails of any person.
(6)Massaging, cleansing, treating, or beautifying the hands or feet of any person.
(c)Within the practice of cosmetology cosmetology, there exist the specialty branches of skin care and nail care.
(1)Skin care is any one or more of the following practices:
(A)Giving facials, applying makeup, giving skin care, removing superfluous hair from the body of any person by the use of depilatories, tweezers or waxing, or applying eyelashes to any person.
(B)Beautifying the face, neck, arms, or upper part of the human body, by use of cosmetic preparations, antiseptics, tonics, lotions, or creams.
(C)Massaging, cleaning, or stimulating the face, neck, arms, or upper part of the human body, by means of the hands, devices, apparatus, or appliances, with the use of cosmetic preparations, antiseptics, tonics, lotions, or creams.
(2)Nail care is the practice of cutting, trimming, polishing, coloring, tinting, cleansing, manicuring, or pedicuring the nails of any person or massaging, cleansing, or beautifying from the elbow to the fingertips or the knee to the toes of any person.
(d)The practice of barbering and the practice of cosmetology do not include any of the following:
(1)The mere sale, fitting, or styling of wigs or hairpieces.
(2)Natural hair braiding. Natural hair braiding is a service that results in tension on hair strands or roots by twisting, wrapping, weaving, extending, locking, or braiding by hand or mechanical device, provided that the service does not include haircutting or the application of dyes, reactive chemicals, or other preparations to alter the color of the hair or to straighten, curl, or alter the structure of the hair.
(3)Threading. Threading is a technique that results in removing hair by twisting thread around unwanted hair and pulling it from the skin and the incidental trimming of eyebrow hair.
(4)(A)The practices of arranging, beautifying, cleansing, curling, dressing, shampooing, or waving the hair of any person.
(B)A person who engages in the practices specified in subparagraph (A) at an establishment shall provide notice to consumers of his or her licensure status.
(e)Notwithstanding paragraph (2) of subdivision (d), a person who engages in natural hairstyling, which is defined as the provision of natural hair braiding services together with any of the services or procedures defined within the regulated practices of barbering or cosmetology, is subject to regulation pursuant to this chapter and shall obtain and maintain a barbering or cosmetology license as applicable to the services respectively offered or performed.
(f)Electrolysis is the practice of removing hair from, or destroying hair on, the human body by the use of an electric needle only.
Electrolysis as used in this chapter includes electrolysis or thermolysis.
SEC. 2.No reimbursement is required by this act pursuant to Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution because the only costs that may be incurred by a local agency or school district will be incurred because this act creates a new crime or infraction, eliminates a crime or infraction, or changes the penalty for a crime or infraction, within the meaning of Section 17556 of the Government Code, or changes the definition of a crime within the meaning of Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution.
(a)The practice of barbering is all or any combination of the following practices:
(1)Shaving or trimming the beard or cutting the hair.
(2)Giving facial and scalp massages or treatments with oils, creams, lotions, or other preparations either by hand or mechanical appliances.
(3)Singeing, chemical waving, hair relaxing, or dyeing the hair or applying hair tonics.
(4)Applying cosmetic preparations, antiseptics, powders, oils, clays, or lotions to scalp, face, or neck.
(5)Hairstyling of all textures of hair by standard methods that are current at the time of the hairstyling.(b)The practice of cosmetology is all or any combination of the following practices:
(1)Machineless permanent waving, permanent waving, cutting, relaxing, singeing, bleaching, tinting, coloring, straightening, dyeing, applying hair tonics to, or otherwise treating by any means, the hair of any person.
(2)Massaging, cleaning, or stimulating the scalp, face, neck, arms, or upper part of the human body, by means of the hands, devices, apparatus or appliances, with or without the use of cosmetic preparations, antiseptics, tonics, lotions, or creams.
(3)Beautifying the face, neck, arms, or upper part of the human body, by use of cosmetic preparations, antiseptics, tonics, lotions, or creams.
(4)Removing superfluous hair from the body of any person by the use of depilatories or by the use of tweezers, chemicals, or preparations or by the use of devices or appliances of any kind or description, except by the use of light waves, commonly known as rays.
(5)Cutting, trimming, polishing, tinting, coloring, cleansing, or manicuring the nails of any person.
(6)Massaging, cleansing, treating, or beautifying the hands or feet of any person.
(c)Within the practice of cosmetology there exist the specialty branches of skin care and nail care.
(1)Skin care is any one or more of the following practices:
(A)Giving facials, applying makeup, giving skin care, removing superfluous hair from the body of any person by the use of depilatories, tweezers or waxing, or applying eyelashes to any person.
(B)Beautifying the face, neck, arms, or upper part of the human body, by use of cosmetic preparations, antiseptics, tonics, lotions, or creams.
(C)Massaging, cleaning, or stimulating the face, neck, arms, or upper part of the human body, by means of the hands, devices, apparatus, or appliances, with the use of cosmetic preparations, antiseptics, tonics, lotions, or creams.
(2)Nail care is the practice of cutting, trimming, polishing, coloring, tinting, cleansing, manicuring, or pedicuring the nails of any person or massaging, cleansing, or beautifying from the elbow to the fingertips or the knee to the toes of any person.
(d)The practice of barbering and the practice of cosmetology do not include any of the following:
(1)The mere sale, fitting, or styling of wigs or hairpieces.
(2)Natural hair braiding. Natural hair braiding is a service that results in tension on hair strands or roots by twisting, wrapping, weaving, extending, locking, or braiding by hand or mechanical device, provided that the service does not include haircutting or the application of dyes, reactive chemicals, or other preparations to alter the color of the hair or to straighten, curl, or alter the structure of the hair.
(3)Threading. Threading is a technique that results in removing hair by twisting thread around unwanted hair and pulling it from the skin and the incidental trimming of eyebrow hair.
(4)The practices of arranging, beautifying, cleansing, curling, dressing, shampooing, or waving the hair of any person.
(e)Notwithstanding paragraph (2) of subdivision (d), a person who engages in natural hairstyling, which is defined as the provision of natural hair braiding services together with any of the services or procedures defined within the regulated practices of barbering or cosmetology, is subject to regulation pursuant to this chapter and shall obtain and maintain a barbering or cosmetology license as applicable to the services respectively offered or performed.
(f)Electrolysis is the practice of removing hair from, or destroying hair on, the human body by the use of an electric needle only.
Electrolysis as used in this chapter includes electrolysis or thermolysis.
(a)The practice of barbering is all or any combination of the following practices:
(1)Shaving or trimming the beard or cutting the hair.
(2)Giving facial and scalp massages or treatments with oils, creams, lotions, or other preparations either by hand or mechanical appliances.
(3)Singeing, arranging, dressing, curling, waving, chemical waving, hair relaxing, or dyeing the hair or applying hair tonics.
(4)Applying cosmetic preparations, antiseptics, powders, oils, clays, or lotions to scalp, face, or neck.
(5)Hairstyling of all textures of hair by standard methods that are current at the time of the hairstyling.
(b)The practice of cosmetology is all or any combination of the following practices:
(1)Arranging, dressing, curling, waving, machineless Machineless permanent waving, permanent waving, cleansing, cutting, relaxing, singeing, bleaching, tinting, coloring, straightening, dyeing, applying hair tonics to, beautifying, or otherwise treating by any means, the hair of any person.
(2)Massaging, cleaning, or stimulating the scalp, face, neck, arms, or upper part of the human body, by means of the hands, devices, apparatus or appliances, with or without the use of cosmetic preparations, antiseptics, tonics, lotions, or creams.
(3)Beautifying the face, neck, arms, or upper part of the human body, by use of cosmetic preparations, antiseptics, tonics, lotions, or creams.
(4)Removing superfluous hair from the body of any person by the use of depilatories or by the use of tweezers, chemicals, or preparations or by the use of devices or appliances of any kind or description, except by the use of light waves, commonly known as rays.
(5)Cutting, trimming, polishing, tinting, coloring, cleansing, or manicuring the nails of any person.
(6)Massaging, cleansing, treating, or beautifying the hands or feet of any person.
(c)Within the practice of cosmetology there exist the specialty branches of skin care and nail care.
(1)Skin care is any one or more of the following practices:
(A)Giving facials, applying makeup, giving skin care, removing superfluous hair from the body of any person by the use of depilatories, tweezers or waxing, or applying eyelashes to any person.
(B)Beautifying the face, neck, arms, or upper part of the human body, by use of cosmetic preparations, antiseptics, tonics, lotions, or creams.
(C)Massaging, cleaning, or stimulating the face, neck, arms, or upper part of the human body, by means of the hands, devices, apparatus, or appliances, with the use of cosmetic preparations, antiseptics, tonics, lotions, or creams.
(2)Nail care is the practice of cutting, trimming, polishing, coloring, tinting, cleansing, manicuring, or pedicuring the nails of any person or massaging, cleansing, or beautifying from the elbow to the fingertips or the knee to the toes of any person.
(d)The practice of barbering and the practice of cosmetology do not include any of the following:
(1)The mere sale, fitting, or styling of wigs or hairpieces.
(2)Natural hair braiding. Natural hair braiding is a service that results in tension on hair strands or roots by twisting, wrapping, weaving, extending, locking, or braiding by hand or mechanical device, provided that the service does not include haircutting or the application of dyes, reactive chemicals, or other preparations to alter the color of the hair or to straighten, curl, or alter the structure of the hair.
(3)Threading. Threading is a technique that results in removing hair by twisting thread around unwanted hair and pulling it from the skin and the incidental trimming of eyebrow hair.
(4)The practices of arranging, beautifying, cleansing, curling, dressing, shampooing, or waving the hair of any person.
(e)Notwithstanding paragraph (2) of subdivision (d), a person who engages in natural hairstyling, which is defined as the provision of natural hair braiding services together with any of the services or procedures defined within the regulated practices of barbering or cosmetology, is subject to regulation pursuant to this chapter and shall obtain and maintain a barbering or cosmetology license as applicable to the services respectively offered or performed.
(f)Electrolysis is the practice of removing hair from, or destroying hair on, the human body by the use of an electric needle only.
Electrolysis as used in this chapter includes electrolysis or thermolysis.
(a)The practice of barbering is all or any combination of the following practices:
(1)Shaving or trimming the beard or cutting the hair.
(2)Giving facial and scalp massages or treatments with oils, creams, lotions, or other preparations either by hand or mechanical appliances.
(3)Singeing, shampooing, arranging, dressing, curling, waving, chemical waving, hair relaxing, or dyeing the hair or applying hair tonics.
(4)Applying cosmetic preparations, antiseptics, powders, oils, clays, or lotions to scalp, face, or neck.
(5)Hairstyling of all textures of hair by standard methods that are current at the time of the hairstyling.
(b)The practice of cosmetology is all or any combination of the following practices:
(1)Arranging, dressing, curling, waving, machineless permanent waving, permanent waving, cleansing, cutting, shampooing, relaxing, singeing, bleaching, tinting, coloring, straightening, dyeing, applying hair tonics to, beautifying, or otherwise treating by any means, the hair of any person.
(2)Massaging, cleaning, or stimulating the scalp, face, neck, arms, or upper part of the human body, by means of the hands, devices, apparatus or appliances, with or without the use of cosmetic preparations, antiseptics, tonics, lotions, or creams.
(3)Beautifying the face, neck, arms, or upper part of the human body, by use of cosmetic preparations, antiseptics, tonics, lotions, or creams.
(4)Removing superfluous hair from the body of any person by the use of depilatories or by the use of tweezers, chemicals, or preparations or by the use of devices or appliances of any kind or description, except by the use of light waves, commonly known as rays.
(5)Cutting, trimming, polishing, tinting, coloring, cleansing, or manicuring the nails of any person.
(6)Massaging, cleansing, treating, or beautifying the hands or feet of any person.
(c)Within the practice of cosmetology there exist the specialty branches of skin care and nail care.
(1)Skin care is any one or more of the following practices:
(A)Giving facials, applying makeup, giving skin care, removing superfluous hair from the body of any person by the use of depilatories, tweezers or waxing, or applying eyelashes to any person.
(B)Beautifying the face, neck, arms, or upper part of the human body, by use of cosmetic preparations, antiseptics, tonics, lotions, or creams.
(C)Massaging, cleaning, or stimulating the face, neck, arms, or upper part of the human body, by means of the hands, devices, apparatus, or appliances, with the use of cosmetic preparations, antiseptics, tonics, lotions, or creams.
(2)Nail care is the practice of cutting, trimming, polishing, coloring, tinting, cleansing, manicuring, or pedicuring the nails of any person or massaging, cleansing, or beautifying from the elbow to the fingertips or the knee to the toes of any person.
(d)The practice of barbering and the practice of cosmetology do not include any of the following:
(1)The mere sale, fitting, or styling of wigs or hairpieces.
(2)Natural hair braiding. Natural hair braiding is a service that results in tension on hair strands or roots by twisting, wrapping, weaving, extending, locking, or braiding by hand or mechanical device, provided that the service does not include haircutting or the application of dyes, reactive chemicals, or other preparations to alter the color of the hair or to straighten, curl, or alter the structure of the hair.
(3)Threading. Threading is a technique that results in removing hair by twisting thread around unwanted hair and pulling it from the skin and the incidental trimming of eyebrow hair.
(e)Notwithstanding paragraph (2) of subdivision (d), a person who engages in natural hairstyling, which is defined as the provision of natural hair braiding services together with any of the services or procedures defined within the regulated practices of barbering or cosmetology, is subject to regulation pursuant to this chapter and shall obtain and maintain a barbering or cosmetology license as applicable to the services respectively offered or performed.
(f)Electrolysis is the practice of removing hair from, or destroying hair on, the human body by the use of an electric needle only.
Electrolysis as used in this chapter includes electrolysis or thermolysis.
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Jun 26, 2018 | June 26 set for first hearing. Failed passage in committee. (Ayes 3. Noes 14.) |
| Jun 7, 2018 | Referred to Com. on B. & P. |
| May 31, 2018 | In Assembly. Read first time. Held at Desk. |
| May 31, 2018 | Read third time. Passed. (Ayes 33. Noes 2.) Ordered to the Assembly. |
| May 29, 2018 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| May 25, 2018 | From committee: Do pass as amended. (Ayes 7. Noes 0.) (May 25). |
| May 18, 2018 | Set for hearing May 25. |
| May 14, 2018 | May 14 hearing: Placed on APPR. suspense file. |
| May 4, 2018 | Set for hearing May 14. |
| May 3, 2018 | May 7 hearing postponed by committee. |
| May 2, 2018 | Set for hearing May 7. |
| Apr 19, 2018 | Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Apr 18, 2018 | From committee: Do pass as amended and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 6. Noes 1.) (April 16). |
| Apr 3, 2018 | From committee with author's amendments. Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on B., P. & E.D. |
| Mar 20, 2018 | Set for hearing April 16. |
| Feb 14, 2018 | Referred to Com. on B., P. & E.D. |
| Feb 6, 2018 | From printer. May be acted upon on or after March 8. |
| Feb 5, 2018 | Introduced. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Jun 26, 2018 | Do pass and be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Assembly Standing Committee on Business and Professions |
Failed |
|
| May 31, 2018 | Senate 3rd Reading SB999 Morrell et al. | Senate Floor |
Passed |
|
| May 25, 2018 | Do pass as amended | Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| May 14, 2018 | Placed on suspense file | Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Apr 16, 2018 | Do pass as amended, but first amend, and re-refer to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Senate Standing Committee on Business, Professions and Economic Development |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
Date of Hearing: June 26, 2018
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON BUSINESS AND PROFESSIONS
Evan Low, Chair
SBPCA Bill Id:SB 999
Author:(Morrell) – As Amended Ver:May 25, 2018
SENATE VOTE: 34-2
SUBJECT: Barbering and cosmetology
SUMMARY: Removes the practices of shampooing, arranging, dressing, curling, and waving hair from the practices of barbering and cosmetology, allowing any individual to perform these services for compensation without training or licensure by the state.
EXISTING LAW:
- Establishes the State Board of Barbering and Cosmetology (Board) under the jurisdiction of the Department of Consumer Affairs (DCA) to license and regulate barbers, cosmetologists, electrologists, estheticians, and manicurists pursuant to the Barbering and Cosmetology Act. (Business and Professions Code (BPC) §§ 7301 et seq.)
- Provides that protection of the public shall be the highest priority for the Board in exercising its licensing, regulatory, and disciplinary functions. (BPC § 7303.1)
- Defines the practice of barbering as all or any combination of the following:
- Shaving or trimming the beard or cutting the hair;
- Giving facial and scalp massages or treatments with oils, creams, lotions, or other preparations either by hand or mechanical appliances;
- Singeing, shampooing, arranging, dressing, curling, waving, chemical waving, hair relaxing, or dyeing the hair or applying hair tonics;
- Applying cosmetic preparations, antiseptics, powders, oils, clays, or lotions to scalp, face, or neck;
- Hairstyling of all textures of hair by standard methods that are current at the time.
(BPC § 7316(a))
- Defines the practice of cosmetology as all or any combination of the following:
- Arranging, dressing, curling, waving, machineless permanent waving, permanent waving, cleansing, cutting, shampooing, relaxing, singeing, bleaching, tinting, coloring, straightening, dyeing, applying hair tonics to, beautifying, or otherwise treating by any means, the hair of any person.
- Massaging, cleaning, or stimulating the scalp, face, neck, arms, or upper part of the human body, by means of the hands, devices, apparatus or appliances, with or without the use of cosmetic preparations, antiseptics, tonics, lotions, or creams.
- Beautifying the face, neck, arms, or upper part of the human body, by use of cosmetic preparations, antiseptics, tonics, lotions, or creams.
- Removing superfluous hair from the body of any person by the use of depilatories or by the use of tweezers, chemicals, or preparations or by the use of devices or appliances of any kind or description, except by the use of light waves, commonly known as rays.
- Cutting, trimming, polishing, tinting, coloring, cleansing, or manicuring the nails of any person.
- Massaging, cleansing, treating, or beautifying the hands or feet of any person.
- Exempts from the definition of barbering and cosmetology the practices of wig-fitting, natural hair braiding, and threading. (BPC § 7316(d)
- Makes it unlawful to engage in barbering and cosmetology for compensation without a valid, unexpired license issued by the Board, punishable by an administrative fine or a misdemeanor. (BPC § 7317)
- Allows a licensed barber or cosmetologist to perform services for compensation outside of a licensed establishment when necessary due to the illness or other physical or mental incapacitation of the recipient of the service. (BPC § 7318)
- Exempts from the licensure requirement for barbering and cosmetology all of the following:
- Individuals licensed to practice medicine, surgery, dentistry, pharmacy, osteopathic medicine, chiropractic, naturopathy, podiatry, or nursing and acting within the scope of practice for which they are licensed.
- Commissioned officers of the United States Army, Navy, Air Force, Marine Corps, members of the United States Public Health Service, and attendants attached to those services when engaged in the actual performance of their official duties.
- Persons employed in the course of and incidental to the business of employers engaged in the theatrical, radio, television, or motion picture production industry.
- Persons engaged in any practice without receiving compensation.
- Persons engaged in the administration of hair, skin, or nail products for the exclusive purpose of recommending, demonstrating, or selling those products.
- Persons who render barbering or cosmetology services in an institutional program during the course of and incidental to the incarceration or confinement of inmates, prisoners, or persons charged with a crime.
(BPC § 7319)
- Requires the Board to allow any person to take the barbering license examination who has submitted an application, paid the fee, is at least 17 years old, has completed the 10th grade, is not otherwise disqualified, and has completed either an approved barbering course, an approved apprenticeship program, or has specified equivalent experience. (BPC § 7321.5.)
- Requires applicants for licensure by the Board to complete both a practical demonstration and a written test. (BPC § 7338)
- Requires the Board to determine the required subjects of instruction to be completed in all approved courses, including the minimum hours of technical instruction and minimum numbers of practical operations for each subject, and determine how much training is required before a student begins performing services on paying patrons. (BPC § 7362)
- Requires the Board to promulgate regulations regarding the creation of a personal service permit (PSP) and issue a PSP to any individual who meets the criteria set forth in the regulations. (BPC § 7402.5)
- Prohibits persons who are not licensed as barbers or cosmologists in the state to represent themselves as barbers or cosmologists. (BPC § 7320.3, § 7320.4)
- Requires barbering and cosmetology licensees to display his or her license in a conspicuous place in his or her place of business or employment. (BPC § 7397)
THIS BILL:
- Deletes all of the following activities from the current practice of barbering and cosmetology, effectively allowing any person to provide these services for compensation without qualifying for and receiving a license from the Board: arranging, beautifying, cleansing, curling, dressing, shampooing, or waving the hair of any person, as well as hairstyling of all textures of hair.
- Requires a person who engages in the above practices at an establishment to provide notice to consumers of his or her licensure status.
COMMENTS:
Purpose. This bill is sponsored by the R Street Institute. According to the author:
In order to professionally arrange, dress, curl, wave, cleanse, shampoo, or beautify hair, individuals are required to have over 1500 hours of training, pass a written and practical examination, and pay up to $125 in fees. These occupations are unlicensed with no reportedly detrimental effects in other states, yet California continues to restrict entry into these fields with the claim that it is in the interest of public health and safety. SB 999 would repeal the unnecessary licensing requirement California requires for these occupations. This would increase employment opportunities in the cosmetology field, reduce restrictions on salon business owners, and set a positive precedent of deregulating occupations in the spirit of free enterprise.
Background. Criticisms of Occupational Licensing. A number of recent reports have called for reforms to California’s licensure scheme, criticizing the state’s regulation of occupations and professions as needlessly burdensome and complex. These reports tend to follow a libertarian philosophy in favor of smaller government, arguing that regulation should only exist in situations where clear consumer harm is likely absent government intervention. Barriers to entry such as licensing fees, education requirements, examinations, conviction disqualifications, and other prerequisites are all then presumed undesirable unless proven necessary for the public interest.
The Little Hoover Commission’s Jobs for Californians: Strategies to Ease Occupational Licensing Barriers refers to the boards and bureaus under the DCA as a “nearly impenetrable thicket of bureaucracy for Californians” and advocates for the state to “review its licensing requirements and determine whether those requirements are overly broad or burdensome to labor market entry or labor mobility.” A recent study by the Mercatus Center at George Mason University, Changes in Occupational Licensing Burdens across States, makes a claim that “California has decreased the burden of occupational licensing by 0% since 2012.” Other reports published by both public and private research institutions are less aggressively critical in tone, but offer similar assessments as to the possibility that California may arguably overregulate in its licensure of professions and occupations.
The Institute for Justice’s License to Work: A National Study of Burdens from Occupational Licensing, now in its second edition, ranks California as the “most burdensome state” when accounting for both the number of lower-income occupations licensed and the average burden of licensing requirements. The report frequently references barbering and cosmetology—two of only 10 total occupations found to be licensed by all 50 states and the District of Columbia—as among the more overburdened occupations. In a ranking of occupations ranked by average burden nationally, cosmetologist is ranked #30 and barber is ranked #34 out of 102 occupations. The report regards “shampooer” as a separate and distinct occupation regulated by 37 states and listed #45 on the ranking of average burdens.
In the Institute for Justice’s summary of California—which it regards as “the most broadly and onerously licensed state in the nation”—the report asserts that obtaining a license as a barber or cosmetologist requires $125 in fees, 350 “estimated calendar days lost,” 1,500 clock hours in education, and 2 examinations. As a point of reference, the report claims that obtaining a license as a tree trimmer requires $529 in fees, 1,460 calendar days lost, no education but 4 years of experience, and 2 examinations. Meanwhile, licensure as a dental assistant requires no fees, only 2 calendar days lost, 10 clock hours of education, and no examinations.
Board of Barbering and Cosmetology. The Board licenses and regulates over 550,000 licensees. Each profession has its own scope of practice, entry-level requirements, and professional settings, with some overlap in areas. The Board’s licensing population includes barbers, cosmetologists, electrologists, estheticians, manicurists, establishments, and mobile units. As a special fund entity, the Board receives no General Fund support, relying solely on fees set in statute and collected from licensing and renewal fees. In addition to licensing individuals, the Board approves schools. A barbering and cosmetology school must first be approved by the Board and subsequently approved by the Bureau for Private Postsecondary Education. Under existing law, a barbering course is required to be 1,500 hours of practical training and technical instruction; a cosmetologist course is required to be 1,600 hours. Licensees are not required to complete continuing education.
BPC § 7362 specifies that the Board is required to determine, by regulation, the subjects which must be completed in an educational program, the approved courses (what material must be taught), including the minimum hours of technical instruction and practical operations a student must complete for each subject, and how much training is required prior to a student performing work on a paid patron. For example, the curriculum for a barbering and cosmetology course requires 200 hours of technical instruction in health and safety (16 CCR § 950.1 and § 950.2). In 2017, AB 326 (Salas) was signed into law to require the health and safety course to additionally cover physical and sexual abuse awareness.
The Board has also established a Health and Safety Advisory Committee. This committee is comprised of both industry representatives and public members including a scientist, a medical professional, a physical/sexual abuse awareness specialist, an educational consultant, and representatives of the Department of Public Health and the Department of Industrial Relations. The Board is also authorized in statute to promote awareness of physical and sexual abuse by means of mail, television, radio, motion picture, newspaper, book, Internet, or other electronic communication, which includes, but is not limited to, domestic violence, sexual assault, human trafficking, and elder abuse.
The Board currently uses licensing examinations developed by the National Interstate Council of State Boards. Other states that use these exams often have a form of reciprocity with California for barbers and cosmetologists seeking licensure in another state. The cosmetology examination currently includes blowdrying, fingerwaving, shampooing, and other practices that would no longer be part of the Board’s licensing program if this bill were to be implemented. It is possible that this could result in the need for a new licensing examination in California.
In addition to qualifying applicants for licensure, the Board is requirements to routinely inspect barbering and cosmetology establishments to ensure compliance with the Barbering and Cosmetology Act, health and safety requirements, and applicable labor laws. In 2017, the Board issued 1,187 citations to barbers and 3,048 citations to cosmetologists for violations identified through an inspection. Many of these citations are issued following a consumer complaint submitted to the Board. According to the Board, 164 consumer harm allegations were received by the Board in 2017, of which 50 were for overprocessed hair, 32 were for scalp burns, 16 were for facial burns, 15 were for facial cuts, and 7 were for skin burns, among other complaints.
Narrowing the Practices of Barbering and Cosmetology. This bill would, in essence, remove from the definitions of barbering and cosmetology the majority of hair-related services that do not involve cutting or treating hair with products like dyes, creams, lotions, or tonics. Shampooing, blowdrying, curling, and generally styling or beautifying without chemicals would become services that may be offered for compensation with no license requirement or specific occupational regulation enforceable by the Board.
In recent years there has been a rise in popularity for salon services specializing in the kinds of practices that would be removed from the Board’s licensing programs by this bill. The “blowout” trend involves the shampooing, blowdrying, and brushing of hair to beautify a client without cutting or dying the hair. For example, the company Drybar, founded in California in 2010, expressly advertises: No Cuts. No Color. Just Blowouts! The mobile application Glamsquad also focuses its hair services on blowouts and other practices that do not involve cuts or color.
Within the limitations of other laws generally governing businesses, this bill would allow any person to advertise and sell these services in any location without training or oversight by a licensing board. The elimination of shampooing from state licensing requirements aligns with a national trend in which Tennessee, Florida and Texas have repealed their shampooing license. Each of the practices included in the bill, by way of their involvement of neither harsher chemicals or blades, are characterized by the bill’s author and supporters as presenting a relatively minor risk of public harm and therefore in less need of occupational regulation than other barbering and cosmetology services.
Current Related Legislation. AB 2134 (Rubio) would expand the Board’s externship program by authorizing a student enrolled in a course in cosmetology offered by a public institution and a student enrolled in an approved barbering program to work unpaid in a licensed establishment. That bill is pending in the Senate Business, Professions and Economic Development Committee.
Prior Related Legislation. SB 247 (Moorlach) would have eliminated a wide array of occupational licensing requirements, including the entire license requirement for barbering. That bill failed passage in the Senate Business, Professions and Economic Development Committee.
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT:
The R Street Institute, which describes itself as “a Washington, D.C.-based think tank” that promotes “practical, market-oriented solutions” to licensing reform, is the sponsor of this bill. The R Street Institute argues that occupational regulations “often are out of proportion to the task at hand” and may “harm job prospects for low-income Californians.” The R Street Institute suggests that one of the primary outcomes of the bill would be the ability for salons to hire employees whose sole purpose would be providing newly unlicensed activities like shampooing and blowdrying. The R Street Institute argues that the bill is “a simple way to remove an obstacle for people who want to climb the financial ladder.”
TechNet, which describes itself as “the voice of the innovation economy,” supports the bill. TechNet refers to “outmoded regulatory hurdles” that are faced by its member companies and argues that “it is critical that any legal or regulatory requirements should be tailored to the new product, directly tied to an identified harm, limited to gaps in existing coverage, focused on bad actors, and narrowly tailored to avoid conflicts or discrepancies in the law and unintended consequences.” Calling this bill a “shining example of this problem and solution,” TechNet believes that allowing for unlicensed shampooing and hairstyling would let new technology companies innovate in the salon space without being burdened by traditional pre-internet regulations.
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION:
The Board of Barbering and Cosmetology has taken a formal oppose position on the bill. At its May 20, 2018 meeting, the Board expressed concerns that “if shampooing and hairstyling are removed from the scopes of practice, there will likely be decline in health and safety procedures substantially increasing the threat to consumers” since licensees are currently educated on scalp and skin disorders and skin and hair analysis in order to “identify possible health and safety concerns prior to services being performed.” The Board expressed further concern that “there is a possibility that there may be an increase in the abuse of workers’ rights with in the industry as the deregulated shampoo/hairstylists technicians will not be required to receive education in basic California labor laws as currently required by Board licensees and will most likely be hired in entry level positions.” The Board also believes that “California will no longer qualify to use the National Interstate Council of State Boards licensing examinations for Barbering and Cosmetology (including manicuring and esthetics)” since the deregulated services are considered core services within that examination, which “may limit California licensees from exercising reciprocity with other states.” The Board also believes it would face a significant fiscal impact.
The Professional Beauty Association (PBA), “the only national organization with members representing salons and spas, distributors, manufacturers, and beauty professionals,” opposes the bill. Dozens of individual PBA members in California submitted letters of opposition to the bill. In its letter of opposition, PBA argues that while occupational licensing reform may be needed, this bill “would be detrimental to the California beauty industry.” PBA argues that this bill “would remove accountability established by the license, leaving consumers without a complaint process and at risk.” PBA states that “if SB 999 were enacted, Californians harmed by unlicensed service providers would have no recourse beyond filing a lawsuit.” PBA also believes the bill would hurt the ability of a Californian cosmetologist to cross state lines and would negatively impact California’s beauty industry overall.
The California Labor Federation (Labor Fed) is in opposition to this bill. Labor Fed argues that the bill “would weaken training requirements for workers in the barbering and cosmetology industries,” which it claims “have ensured that consumers seeking such services receive quality products from a knowledgeable, competent professional.” Labor Fed explains that “the more training and experience a worker has, the higher their wages tend to be.” Labor Fed argues that “eliminating training requirements not only lowers the bar but floods the market with new, less qualified entrants—directly attacking workers’ bargaining power and almost certainly reducing wages.”
POLICY ISSUES:
Removal of Training for Professionals. As drafted, this bill would simply strike a number of services from the practices of barbering and cosmetology. While these services could theoretically be obtained from an unlicensed individual at a potentially lower price, they would still presumably be services offered by licensees who engage in other practices that would remain licensed. In these settings, where a license is prominently displayed, the average consumer would likely have a certain expectation of competence for all services offered. However, because the bill simply eliminates the specified services from the enumerated practices of barbering and cosmetology, and because under statute the only services included in the license education and examination requirements are those listed as barbering and cosmetology practices, licensees would not be trained in these services even if they obtain a license from the Board. In addition to the Board’s concerns that this could result in California’s ineligibility to use the National Interstate Council of State Boards licensing examinations, there may be certain complexities to the newly unlicensed services that licensees would not be taught were this bill to chapter, including those related to health and safety.
Potential Public Harm. The underlying argument for this bill is that the eliminated practices present a relatively low risk of harm to the public. However, while this may appear reasonable on the surface, data offered by the Board suggests that the deletion of curling and blowdrying could result in a rise in harm to consumers. In 2017, roughly one-third of all consumer harm allegations involved burns. It is also possible that certain types of shampooing and cleansing can be unsafe; for example, the federal Food and Drug Administration (FDA) has announced investigations into certain cleansing conditioner products reported to result in hair loss, hair breakage, balding, itching, and rash. The practices impacted by this bill could also be unsafe when performed by an unlicensed individual in tandem with other salon services provided by licensees; for example, hair products containing formaldehyde can release toxic gas when heated with a blowdryer or curler, and the bill would allow untrained individuals to shampoo hair previously treated with chemicals and dyes not technically applied by the shampooer. While these possible threats of consumer harm may be alleviated with care, it is important to note that the presumed innocence of the practices included in this bill may be deceptive.
Workforce Impact. The bill’s author and sponsor argue that by eliminating certain practices from the state’s license requirements, economic opportunity would be expanded for primarily low-income workers who would no longer have to invest in expensive education and license fees. However, by removing virtually all regulatory barriers to the performance of these services, the bill arguably converts portions of a paid profession into a low-wage task. This would conceivably devalue the license currently possessed by barbers and cosmetologists. Additionally, the bill would potentially disrupt hierarchical salon environments in which newer licensees entering the profession are charged with easier tasks while receiving onsite training from experienced stylists; instead, many of these tasks would be assigned to untrained workers at a lower wage. This could make it harder for new barbers and cosmetologists to enter the industry.
Enforcement Challenges. Currently, the Board is mandated by statute to regularly inspect establishments and identify violations of law or the presence of unlicensed activity. This bill could potentially pose a problem with these activities in the event that unlicensed salon employees who are in fact performing services requiring a license identify themselves as shampooers or blowdryers. This could pose a challenge to the Board as it carries out its enforcement activities.
Timeliness. The Board’s sunset review is currently scheduled to occur in 2019. The sunset process provides a regular forum for discussion around the successes and challenges of various programs and the consideration of proposed changes to laws governing the regulation of professionals. In light of the many policy issues in need of resolution with this bill and the potential to work on these potential challenges within a broader conversation regarding the regulation of barbering and cosmetology more comprehensively, it may make sense to defer the reforms in this bill a year to allow the discussion to continue as part of the sunset process.
REGISTERED SUPPORT:
The R Street Institute (Sponsor)
TechNet
REGISTERED OPPOSITION:
Board of Barbering and Cosmetology
California Association of Private Postsecondary Schools
California Cosmetic Association
California Labor Federation
Make-Up Artists and Hair Stylists Guild Local 706
Professional Beauty Association
Professional Beauty Federation of California
Numerous individual salons, schools, and industry members including:
Academy for Salon Professionals
Adora Salon
Adrians Beauty College of Tracy
American Beauty Academy
American Made Beauty
Arnold’s
Atelier Salons
Beautiful People
Beauty Collective Company
Beauty Bar Lounge Watsonville
Bellflower Beauty College of Lakewood
Bellus Academy
Bidwell Hair Cottage
Body, Soul and Spirit Salon
Bombshell
Career Academy of Beauty
Chorine Clymens
Cleo Hair Salon
Del Mar Lash
Dinair
Ergo
Federico Beauty Institute
Framework Salon
Future Vanity
Great Clips (Tambry Ventures Franchise)
Hair Goals
Hairroin Salon
Hush Beauty Lounge
Krimson Hair Studio
Lytle’s Beauty College
Main Street Salon
McKay Services
North Adrian’s College of Beauty
Paul Mitchell The School Fresno
Paul Mitchell The School Sacramento
Paul Mitchell The School San Jose
Primarily Hair Salon
Reframe Salon
Regis Corporation (Seal Beach)
ROIL
Salon Brio
Salon Success Academy
Sherry Mesa Salon
Stainless Salon
Thomas Edward Salon & Dry Bar
Yota Batsaras
1329 Salon and Spa
Numerous individuals.
Analysis Prepared by: Robert Sumner / B. & P. / (916) 319-3301
Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | SB |
THIRD READING
Bill No: SB 999
: 5/25/18
SENATE BUS., PROF. & ECON. DEV. COMMITTEE: 6-1, 4/16/18
AYES: Hill, Fuller, Dodd, Galgiani, Glazer, Wilk
NOES: Newman
NO VOTE RECORDED: Hernandez, Pan
SENATE APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE: 7-0, 5/25/18
AYES: Lara, Bates, Beall, Bradford, Hill, Nielsen, Wiener
SUBJECT: Barbering and cosmetology
DIGEST:
This bill removes certain hair beautification services from the definition of the practice of barbering and cosmetology.
Existing law:
- Provides for licensure of cosmetologists by the Board of Barbering and Cosmetology (BBC) to practice cosmetology and requires applicants to be over the age of 17, complete 10th grade in a public California school or equivalent, not subject to a denial and have either completed a course in cosmetology from a BBC approved school, or practiced cosmetology in another state for a period of time equivalent to the study and training of a BBC approved course, or holds a license as a barber and completed a cosmetology crossover course or completed an apprenticeship program in cosmetology. (BPC § 7321)
- Provides for licensure of barbers by BBC to practice barbering and requires applicants to be over the age of 17, complete 10th grade in a public California school or equivalent, not subject to a denial and have either completed a course in barbering from a BBC approved school, or practiced barbering in another state for a period of time equivalent to the study and training of a BBC approved course, or holds a license as a cosmetologist and completed a barbering crossover course, or completed an apprenticeship program in barbering, or completed comparable military training. (BPC § 7321.5)
- Requires applicants for licensure to complete both a practical demonstration and a written test that embrace the subjects typically taught in BBC approved program. (BPC § 7338)
- Requires BBC to issue regulations regarding a personal service permit (PSP). Authorizes BBC to issue PSP to an individual who meets the criteria set forth in the regulations. (BPC § 7402.5)
This bill:
- Deletes certain hair beautification services that do not utilize instruments or chemicals from the definition of the practice of barbering and cosmetology. Specifically, this bill deletes shampooing, arranging, dressing, curling, and waving hair from barbering and arranging, dressing, curling, waving, cleansing, shampooing, and beautifying hair from cosmetology.
- Specifies that the practices of barbering and cosmetology do not include arranging, beautifying, cleansing, curling, dressing, shampooing, or waving the hair of any person. Requires a person who engages in these practices at an establishment to provide notice to consumers of his or her licensure status.
Background
Requirements for licensure as a barber and cosmetologist and recent focus on occupational licensing. To become a licensed barber, an applicant must submit proof of completion to BBC of 1500 training hours covering all practices of a barber. To become a licensed cosmetologist, an applicant must submit proof of completion to BBC of 1,600 training hours covering all practices of a cosmetologist. Currently in California, all BBC-regulated beautification services are required to be obtained within a BBC licensed establishment. BCP Section 7317 specifically states that it is unlawful for any person, firm, or corporation to engage in barbering, cosmetology or electrolysis practices, for compensation, in an establishment or mobile unit which is not licensed by the BBC (other than incidental services provided by individuals employed to provide services in the theater, radio, television or motion picture production industry or services performed on a client who is ill or has a physical or mental incapacitation and the appointment is made through a licensed establishment.) Legally, those BBC-licensed establishments or the 21 licensed mobile units are the only facilities where consumers can access services of licensed professionals regulated by the BBC. Currently, a cosmetologist styling the hair of a bride at a hotel or other venue is guilty of unlicensed activity because they are operating outside of a BBC-licensed establishment.
Recent studies and reports have focused on the impacts of licensing requirements for employment and on individuals seeking to become employed. In October 2016, the Little Hoover Commission released a report entitled Jobs for Californians: Strategies to Ease Occupational Licensing Barriers. The report noted that one out of every five Californians must receive permission from the government to work, and for millions of Californians that means contending with the hurdles of becoming licensed. The study found that occupational licensing hurts those at the bottom of the economic ladder twice: first by imposing significant costs on them should they try to enter a licensed occupation and second by pricing the services provided by licensed professionals out of reach. The report found that California compares poorly to the rest of the nation in the amount of licensing it requires for occupations traditionally entered into by people of modest means.
Legislative focus on BBC licensure burdens. The 1,600-hour education requirement for cosmetology licensure has been a discussion point for the Legislature during previous sunset review oversight of the BBC. The Senate Business, Professions and Economic Development Committee staff raised the issue of appropriate licensing categories in the 2012-13 review, noting the need for BBC to evaluate adding specialized certificates or licensure in certain practices. The review asked whether many of the beautification services offered by BBC licensees require the mandatory schooling and training hours necessary for a cosmetologist or esthetician and noted that, while there may be significant health concerns related to some practices, there may also not be a need for an individual performing specialized services to invest in a whole training program.
During the 2014-15 sunset review oversight, BBC reported that current trends in the beautification industry show that consumers are beginning to seek services outside the walls of a traditional brick and mortar establishment such as homes, hotels, businesses, and other non-traditional locations. In its 2014 sunset report to the Legislature, the BBC provided information on other states that offer a more flexible license or registration. In response to the questions of whether more people are seeking beautification services outside of a traditional salon establishment and whether BBC needs to update current establishment requirements to meet consumer demands, AB 181 (Bonilla, Chapter 430, Statutes of 2013) required BBC to establish regulations to issue a PSP. BBC was required to hold at least two stakeholder meetings and was authorized to issue a PSP to individuals who meet the requirements set forth in the regulation. PSP holders would be able to perform services outside of a licensed establishment but would still be required to obey existing health and safety requirements. AB 181 prohibited BBC from requiring a PSP holder to be employed by an establishment unless BBC determines it would be necessary in order to maintain consumer safety. The regulations also authorized BBC to require a PSP applicant to have proof of liability insurance and pass a criminal background clearance.
In the BBC’s report to the Legislature providing an update on the progress of the PSP regulation, BBC summarized the various viewpoints of stakeholder meeting attendees, including that not all services should be authorized under a PSP, liability insurance should be required, and licensees should be in good standing. BBC’s Licensing and Examination Committee determined a number of requirements for a proposed PSP, including:
- The PSP will be limited to cutting and styling hair
- The PSP will be tied to a licensed, working, brick-and-mortar establishment.
- The number of PSP holders per establishment will be limited.
- A criminal background check will be part of the PSP process.
The BBC’s report also noted additional requests from industry representatives to require PSP holders to demonstrate, while at the licensed establishment, protocols used when in someone's home or place of business; to require minimum liability insurance of $1 million; to limit the geographical boundary of a PSP holder so that person can only practice a certain distance from the licensed establishment and; to make PSP holders employees of the establishment they are tied to.
While the BBC has not promulgated a PSP, limitations on the types of services offered by a PSP holder and requirements to remain affiliated with a licensed establishment appear counter to the intention of flexibility and allowing BBC to better recognize trends in the beautification services industry.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: Fiscal Com.: Local: Yes
According to the Senate Appropriations Committee:
- The Department of Consumer Affairs (DCA) anticipates fee revenue losses of about $343,000 per year (Barbering and Cosmetology Contingent Fund). This estimate assumes that approximately four percent of individuals may choose to pursue the option of being an unlicensed shampoo or stylist technician as opposed to pursuing a barber or cosmetology license.
- By removing shampooing and styling from the barbering and cosmetology scope of practice, the DCA estimates a significant cost increase to BBC. This assumes that a new license examination would need to be developed because the existing national exam that is utilized contains questions related to shampooing and styling. However, it is not clear that a new exam is necessary and therefore, these costs may not materialize.
- $31,000 in additional costs to the BBC for various information technology related expenses. Any costs for the promulgation of regulations are expected to be minor and absorbable within existing resources. (Barbering and Cosmetology Contingent Fund)
- The DCA indicates there could be tuition losses for local barber and cosmetology schools resulting from students that no longer enroll in a Barber, Cosmetology or apprentice program. Assuming four percent of the number of initial license applications and apprentice license applications submitted each year, DCA estimates that tuition losses would be approximately $4.8 million each year.
R Street Institute (source)
TechNet
OPPOSITION: (Verified 5/25/18)
Professional Beauty Federation of California
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: Supporters believe this bill will reduce some of California’s onerous occupational licensing requirements for people who would like to be involved in basic hair-care work such as shampooing, arranging, dressing, curling, and waving. Supporters also believe that it is critical that any legal or regulatory requirements should be tailored to the new product, directly tied to an identified harm, limited to gaps in existing coverage, focused on bad actors, and narrowly tailored to avoid conflicts or discrepancies in the law and unintended consequences. Supporters believe beautification services is a field ripe for innovation to create more work opportunities while also providing consumers more services and also believe in making room for innovation and opportunity which this bill will do by removing unnecessary barriers for a very narrow range of activities.
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION: Opponents believe that this bill and similar scope of practice exemption bills in recent years are inappropriate means of reforming California’s current approach to ensuring consumer protections via licensure and statewide regulation. Opponents state that the beautification services industry is already plagued by unlicensed activity, often by those holding BBC licenses, creating an unlevel field of competition between legitimate businesses who honor state regulations and those who do not. According to opponents, inviting additional unlicensed services into this marketplace will generate even more consumer confusion and unethical competitive practices.
5/29/18 8:45:47
**** END ****
SENATE COMMITTEE ON
Senator Ricardo Lara, Chair
2017 - 2018 Regular Session
SB 999 (Morrell) - Barbering and cosmetology
Version: | Policy Vote: |
Urgency: | Mandate: |
Hearing Date: | Consultant: |
Bill Summary:
This bill removes certain hair beautification services from the definition of the practice of barbering and cosmetology.
*********** ANALYSIS ADDENDUM – SUSPENSE FILE ***********
The following information is revised to reflect amendments
adopted by the committee on May 25, 2018
Fiscal Impact:
- The Department of Consumer Affairs (DCA) anticipates fee revenue losses of about $343,000 per year (Barbering and Cosmetology Contingent Fund). This estimate assumes that approximately four percent of individuals may choose to pursue the option of being an unlicensed shampoo or stylist technician as opposed to pursuing a barber or cosmetology license.
- By removing shampooing and styling from the barbering and cosmetology scope of practice, the DCA estimates a significant cost increase to the State Board of Barbering and Cosmetology (BBC). This assumes that a new license examination would need to be developed because the existing national exam that is utilized contains questions related to shampooing and styling. However, it is not clear that a new exam is necessary and therefore, these costs may not materialize.
- $31,000 in additional costs to the BBC for various information technology related expenses. Any costs for the promulgation of regulations are expected to be minor and absorbable within existing resources. (Barbering and Cosmetology Contingent Fund)
- The DCA indicates there could be tuition losses for local barber and cosmetology schools resulting from students that no longer enroll in a Barber, Cosmetology or apprentice program. Assuming four percent of the number of initial license applications and apprentice license applications submitted each year, DCA estimates that tuition losses would be approximately $4.8 million each year.
Author Amendments: Make technical changes and add coauthors.
Committee Amendments:
Require individuals performing the hair beautification services to provide notification to consumers of his or her licensure status.
-- END --
SENATE COMMITTEE ON
Senator Ricardo Lara, Chair
2017 - 2018 Regular Session
SB 999 (Morrell) - Barbering and cosmetology
Version: | Policy Vote: |
Urgency: | Mandate: |
Hearing Date: | Consultant: |
This bill meets the criteria for referral to the Suspense File.
Bill Summary:
This bill removes certain hair beautification services from the definition of the practice of barbering and cosmetology.
Fiscal Impact:
- The Department of Consumer Affairs (DCA) anticipates fee revenue losses of about $343,000 per year (Barbering and Cosmetology Contingent Fund). This estimate assumes that approximately four percent of individuals may choose to pursue the option of being an unlicensed shampoo or stylist technician as opposed to pursuing a barber or cosmetology license.
- By removing shampooing and styling from the barbering and cosmetology scope of practice, the DCA estimates a significant cost increase to the State Board of Barbering and Cosmetology (BBC). This assumes that a new license examination would need to be developed because the existing national exam that is utilized contains questions related to shampooing and styling. However, it is not clear that a new exam is necessary and therefore, these costs may not materialize.
- $31,000 in additional costs are anticipated to the BBC for various information technology related expenses. Any costs for the promulgation of regulations are expected to be minor and absorbable within existing resources. (Barbering and Cosmetology Contingent Fund)
- Unknown savings due to workload decreases in the enforcement of licensing requirements and the processing of applications and renewals (Barbering and Cosmetology Contingent Fund).
- The DCA indicates there could be tuition losses for local barber and cosmetology schools resulting from students that no longer enroll in a Barber, Cosmetology or apprentice program. Assuming four percent of the number of initial license applications and apprentice license applications submitted each year, DCA estimates that tuition losses would be approximately $4.8 million each year.
Background:
Under current law, the practice of barbering, cosmetology, and electrolysis are licensed and regulated by the BBC.
Existing law defines the practice of barbering as all or any combination of certain beautification practices (other than selling, fitting, or styling wigs or hairpieces; natural hair braiding or; threading) including: shaving or trimming beards or cutting hair; giving facial and scalp massages or treatments with oils, creams, lotions, or other preparations either by hand or mechanical appliances; singeing, shampooing, arranging, dressing, curling, waving, chemical waving, hair relaxing, or dyeing the hair or applying hair tonics; applying cosmetic preparations, antiseptics, powders, oils, clays, or lotions to the scalp, face, or neck and; hairstyling.
Existing law defines the practice of cosmetology as all or any combination of all or any combination of certain beautification practices (other than selling, fitting, or styling wigs or hairpieces; natural hair braiding or; threading) including: arranging, dressing, curling, waving, machine-less permanent waving, permanent waving, cleansing, cutting, shampooing, relaxing, singeing, bleaching, tinting, coloring, straightening, dyeing, applying hair tonics to, beautifying, or otherwise treating hair; massaging, cleaning, or stimulating the scalp, face, neck, arms, or upper part of the human body with hands, devices, apparatus or appliances, with or without the use of cosmetic preparations, antiseptics, tonics, lotions, or creams; beautifying the face, neck, arms, or upper part of the human body by use of cosmetic preparations, antiseptics, tonics, lotions, or creams; removing superfluous hair from a person by using depilatories or tweezers, chemicals, preparations, devices, or appliances; cutting, trimming, polishing, tinting, coloring, cleansing, or manicuring a person’s nails; and massaging, cleansing, treating, or beautifying a person’s hands or feet.
Existing law provides for licensure of cosmetologists by BBC to practice cosmetology and requires applicants to be over the age of 17, complete 10th grade in a public California school or equivalent, not subject to a denial and have either completed a course in cosmetology from a BBC approved school, or practiced cosmetology in another state for a period of time equivalent to the study and training of a BBC approved course, or holds a license as a barber and completed a cosmetology crossover course or completed an apprenticeship program in cosmetology.
Existing law provides for licensure of barbers by BBC to practice barbering and requires applicants to be over the age of 17, complete 10th grade in a public California school or equivalent, not subject to a denial and have either completed a course in barbering from a BBC approved school, or practiced barbering in another state for a period of time equivalent to the study and training of a BBC approved course, or holds a license as a cosmetologist and completed a barbering crossover course, or completed an apprenticeship program in barbering, or completed comparable military training.
Proposed Law:
This bill deletes certain hair beautification services that do not utilize instruments or chemicals from the definition of the practice of barbering and cosmetology. Specifically, the bill deletes shampooing, arranging, dressing, curling, waving hair, and hairstyling of all textures of hair by standard methods that are current from barbering and arranging, dressing, curling, waving, cleansing, shampooing, and beautifying hair from cosmetology.
This bill also specifies that the practices of barbering and cosmetology do not include arranging, beautifying, cleansing, curling, dressing, shampooing, or waving the hair of any person.
Related Legislation:
AB 181 (Bonilla, Chapter 430, Statutes of 2015) required the BBC to conduct a study and review of the 1600-hour training requirements for cosmetologists, conduct an occupational analysis of the cosmetology profession, and conduct a review of the national written examinations for cosmetologists and of the California practical examination, in order to evaluate whether both examinations assess critical competencies for California cosmetologists and meet professional testing standards.
-- END --
SENATE COMMITTEE ON
BUSINESS, PROFESSIONS AND ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT
Senator Jerry Hill, Chair
2017 - 2018 Regular
Bill No: Hearing Date: April 16, 2018
Author: | |||
Version: | April 3, 2018 | ||
Urgency: | No | Fiscal: | Yes |
Consultant: | Sarah Mason | ||
Subject:
SUMMARY: Removes certain hair beautification services from the definition of the practice of barbering and cosmetology.
Existing law:
- Provides for the licensure regulation of the practice of barbering, cosmetology, and electrolysis under the Barbering and Cosmetology Act (Act) by the BBC. (Business and Professions Code (BPC) § 7303)
- Defines the practice of barbering as all or any combination of certain beautification practices (other than selling, fitting, or styling wigs or hairpieces; natural hair braiding or; threading) including: shaving or trimming beards or cutting hair; giving facial and scalp massages or treatments with oils, creams, lotions, or other preparations either by hand or mechanical appliances; singeing, shampooing, arranging, dressing, curling, waving, chemical waving, hair relaxing, or dyeing the hair or applying hair tonics; applying cosmetic preparations, antiseptics, powders, oils, clays, or lotions to the scalp, face, or neck and; hairstyling. (BPC § 7316 (a))
- Defines the practice of cosmetology as all or any combination of all or any combination of certain beautification practices (other than selling, fitting, or styling wigs or hairpieces; natural hair braiding or; threading) including: arranging, dressing, curling, waving, machine-less permanent waving, permanent waving, cleansing, cutting, shampooing, relaxing, singeing, bleaching, tinting, coloring, straightening, dyeing, applying hair tonics to, beautifying, or otherwise treating hair; massaging, cleaning, or stimulating the scalp, face, neck, arms, or upper part of the human body with hands, devices, apparatus or appliances, with or without the use of cosmetic preparations, antiseptics, tonics, lotions, or creams; beautifying the face, neck, arms, or upper part of the human body by use of cosmetic preparations, antiseptics, tonics, lotions, or creams; removing superfluous hair from a person by using depilatories or tweezers, chemicals, preparations, devices, or appliances; cutting, trimming, polishing, tinting, coloring, cleansing, or manicuring a person’s nails; and massaging, cleansing, treating, or beautifying a person’s hands or feet. (BPC § 7316 (b)).
- Provides for licensure of cosmetologists by BBC to practice cosmetology and requires applicants to be over the age of 17, complete 10th grade in a public California school or equivalent, not subject to a denial and have either completed a course in cosmetology from a BBC approved school, or practiced cosmetology in another state for a period of time equivalent to the study and training of a BBC approved course, or holds a license as a barber and completed a cosmetology crossover course or completed an apprenticeship program in cosmetology.
(BPC § 7321) - Provides for licensure of barbers by BBC to practice barbering and requires applicants to be over the age of 17, complete 10th grade in a public California school or equivalent, not subject to a denial and have either completed a course in barbering from a BBC approved school, or practiced barbering in another state for a period of time equivalent to the study and training of a BBC approved course, or holds a license as a cosmetologist and completed a barbering crossover course, or completed an apprenticeship program in barbering, or completed comparable military training. (BPC § 7321.5)
- Requires applicants for licensure to complete both a practical demonstration and a written test that embrace the subjects typically taught in BBC approved program. (BPC § 7338)
- Requires BBC to issue regulations regarding a personal service permit (PSP). Authorizes BBC to issue PSP to an individual who meets the criteria set forth in the regulations. (BPC § 7402.5)
This bill:
- Deletes certain hair beautification services that do not utilize instruments or chemicals from the definition of the practice of barbering and cosmetology. Specifically, the bill deletes shampooing, arranging, dressing, curling, and waving hair from barbering and arranging, dressing, curling, waving, cleansing, shampooing, and beautifying hair from cosmetology.
- Specifies that the practices of barbering and cosmetology do not include arranging, beautifying, cleansing, curling, dressing, shampooing, or waving the hair of any person.
FISCAL EFFECT: Unknown. This bill is keyed “fiscal” by Legislative Counsel.
COMMENTS:
- Purpose. This bill is sponsored by the R Street Institute. According to the Author, “The average amount spent on licensing fees in California is $486, with an average education requirement of 827 days, and two examinations. Included in the list of occupations licensed are questionable jobs that reasonably should not require a license. However, thanks to the influence of industry lobbyists and powerful boards that have monopolized their respective industries via licensing requirements, attempts to reform ridiculous license requirements continue to fail.” The Author states that “An ideal example of California’s unnecessary occupational licensing is the requirement for shampooing. Currently classified under the barbering license, in order to professionally shampoo, individuals are required to have over 1500 hours of training, pass a written and practical examination, and pay up to $125 in fees. This occupation is unlicensed with no reportedly detrimental effects in other states, yet California continues to restrict entry into this field with the claim that it is in the interest of public health and safety. In reality, this license requirement disproportionately effects low to middle-income entrepreneurs and labor market newcomers. They are forced to navigate an expensive and unnecessary occupational licensing process in order to be employed or to work as a shampooer.”
According to the Author, “existing laws regarding shampoo licensure in other states are becoming much less stringent. While a majority of the 37 states that license Barbering and Cosmetology include shampooing within these requirements, an increasing number of states over the last five years have carved out or out rightly exempted shampooing. Since 2012, three states (Nevada, South Carolina and West Virginia) have specifically removed shampooing from their Barbering and Cosmetology code sections and have created separate licensure requirements. Cumulatively, six states have created licenses exclusively for shampooing. One state, Tennessee, even eliminated its shampooing licensure requirement following a lawsuit that the requirement limited competition and violated the Tennessee Constitution's ban on monopolies. The case for the lawsuit was made easier considering Tennessee’s onerous requirements: 300 hours of shampooing training with a tuition cost approaching $3,000.”
The Author states that “A recent wave of deregulation regarding the shampooing license requirement has swept across the country. Along with Tennessee, Florida and Texas have repealed the shampooing license requirement. Arizona’s legislature is also working on a bill that would achieve the same goal, and it has successfully passed through committee and will hopefully be enacted this session.”
- Background on BBC. The BBC licenses and regulates over 550,000 licensees. Each profession has its own scope of practice, entry-level requirements, and professional settings, with some overlap in areas. The BBC's licensing population includes: Barbers; Barber Apprentices; Cosmetology Apprentices; Cosmetologists; Electrologists; Estheticians; Manicurists; Establishments; and, Mobile Units.
The Act specifies the regulations and requirements for licensure and BBC regulations outline specific curriculum applicants are required to complete. For applicants who have received training from a BBC-approved school, the BBC provides the schools a Proof of Training document (POT) that is completed by the school administration. The POT verifies how many hours of training were completed. In order to verify submitted POT documents, a representative from the school is required to sign, under the penalty of perjury, that the information is true and correct. The BBC requires individuals seeking licensure as a barber, cosmetologist, esthetician, electrologists, or a manicurist to take and pass both a written examination and a practical examination.
BBC’s Enforcement Program opens cases based on complaints or issues submitted internally by staff, consumers, agencies, or any outside entity. To ensure the health and safety of consumers, all cases are investigated. Investigations may include an inspection of the establishment, requests for additional information from the consumer or licensee, assistance from the Division of Investigation (DOI) within the DCA, or an evaluation by an expert. Complaint cases are closed after the investigation has revealed insufficient evidence to proceed, compliance with the BBC’s rules and regulations has been demonstrated, or disciplinary action has been taken against the licensee. To ensure compliance with the BBC's health and safety and licensing regulations, random and targeted inspections of establishments are conducted.
Unlicensed activity violations are considered a high priority by both the DCA and the BBC. As the result of an inspection, owners who are operating unlicensed establishments and owners who employ unlicensed individuals are fined up to $1,000. Each unlicensed individual is also cited and fined $1,000. Cases involving licensed owners who have been repeatedly cited for employing unlicensed individuals are forwarded to the AG for discipline including, license suspension, probation, or revocation.
BBC currently licenses 29,554 barbers and 314,552 cosmetologists.
- Requirements for Licensure as a Barber and Cosmetologist.
To become a licensed barber, an applicant must submit proof of completion to BBC of 1500 training hours covering all practices of a barber, according to the following:
- 1100 hours of technical instruction and practical training in hair dressing –
65 hours of hairstyling including hair analysis, shampooing, finger waving, pin curling, comb outs, straightening, waving, curling with hot combs and hot curling irons and blower styling; 40 hours of permanent waving and chemical straightening including hair analysis, acid and alkaline permanent waving, chemical straightening including the use of sodium hydroxide and other base solutions and; 60 hours of bleaching including the use of semi-permanent, demi-permanent and temporary colors, hair analysis, predisposition and strand tests, safety precautions, formula mixing, tinting, bleaching, high and low lights, and the use of dye removers; 20 hours of hair cutting including the use of scissors, razor (shaper), electrical clippers/trimmers, and thinning (tapering) shears for wet and dry cutting. - 200 hours of technical instruction and practical training in shaving – The subject of Preparation and Performance shall include, but is not limited to the following techniques and procedures: Preparing the client's hair for shaving, assessing the condition of the client's skin, performing shaving techniques, applying after-shave antiseptic following facial services, massaging the client's face, rolling cream massages
- 200 hours of technical instruction in health and safety – 20 hours on the Act and BBC regulations; 45 hours on health and safety/hazardous substances including training in chemicals and health in establishments, material safety data sheets, protection from hazardous chemicals and preventing chemical injuries, health and safety laws and agencies, bacteriology and preventing communicable diseases including HIV/AIDS and Hepatitis B; 20 hours in disinfection and sanitation including proper procedures to protect the health and safety of the consumer as well as the technician and proper disinfection procedures for equipment used in establishments and; 15 hours in the subjects of anatomy and physiology.
- BBC also recommends that schools provide training in communication skills that includes professional ethics, salesmanship, decorum, record-keeping, client service record cards, and basic tax responsibilities related to independent contractors, booth renters, employees, and employers.
To become a licensed cosmetologist, an applicant must submit proof of completion to BBC of 1600 training hours covering all practices of a cosmetologist, according to the following:
- 1100 hours of technical instruction and practical training in hair dressing –
65 hours of hairstyling including hair analysis, shampooing, finger waving, pin curling, comb outs, straightening, waving, curling with hot combs and hot curling irons and blower styling; 40 hours of permanent waving and chemical straightening including hair analysis, acid and alkaline permanent waving, chemical straightening including the use of sodium hydroxide and other base solutions; 60 hours of hair coloring and bleaching including hair analysis, predisposition and strand tests, safety precautions, formula mixing, tinting, bleaching, high and low lights, and the use of dye removers and; 20 hours of hair cutting including the use of scissors, razor (shaper), electrical clippers/trimmers, and thinning (tapering) shears for wet and dry cutting. - 200 hours of technical instruction in health and safety – 20 hours on the Act and BBC regulations; 45 hours on health and safety/hazardous substances including cosmetology chemistry like the chemical composition and purpose of cosmetic, nail, hair and skin care preparations, elementary chemical makeup, chemical skin peels and chemical and physical changes of matter, hazardous substances chemicals and health in establishments, protection from hazardous chemicals and preventing chemical injuries, ergonomics, theory of electricity in cosmetology, bacteriology, communicable diseases, including HIV/AIDS, Hepatitis B, and staph and Material Safety Data Sheets; Disinfection and Sanitation (20 hours of Technical Instruction); 20 hours in disinfection and sanitation including proper procedures to protect the health and safety of the consumer as well as the technician and proper disinfection procedures for equipment used in establishments and; 15 hours in the subjects of anatomy and physiology.
- 200 hours of technical instruction and practical training in esthetics – 25 hours in manual, electrical and chemical facials including cleansing, scientific manipulations, packs, and masks, electrical facials using electrical modalities, dermal lights and electrical apparatus, chemical skin peels, packs, masks and scrubs; 25 hours in eyebrow beautification and makeup including eyebrow arching and hair removal, the use of wax, tweezers, electric or manual, and depilatories for the removal of superfluous hair, skin analysis, complete and corrective makeup, the application of false eyelashes, and lash and brow tinting, if a product exists that is not disapproved, prohibited or banned by the U.S. Food and Drug Administration, the Occupational Safety and Health Administration, or the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency.
- 100 hours of technical instruction and practical training in manicuring and pedicuring – 10 hours of manicuring and pedicuring including water and oil manicure, including nail analysis, and hand/foot and arm/ankle massage; 25 hours of artificial nails and wraps including acrylic, liquid and powder brush-ons, artificial nail tips and nail wraps and repairs.
- BBC also recommends that schools provide training in communication skills that includes professional ethics, salesmanship, decorum, record-keeping, client service record cards, and basic tax responsibilities related to independent contractors, booth renters, employees, and employers.
- Little Hoover Commission Report on Occupational Licensing. Recent studies and reports have focused on the impacts of licensing requirements for employment and on individuals seeking to become employed. According to a July 2015 report on occupational licensing released by the White House, strict licensing creates barriers to mobility for licensed workers, citing several groups of people particularly vulnerable to occupational licensing laws, including former offenders, military spouses, veterans and immigrants.
In October 2016, the Little Hoover Commission released a report entitled Jobs for Californians: Strategies to Ease Occupational Licensing Barriers. The report noted that one out of every five Californians must receive permission from the government to work, and for millions of Californians that means contending with the hurdles of becoming licensed. The report noted that many of the goals to professionalize occupations, standardize services, guarantee quality and limit competition among practitioners, while well intended, have had a larger impact of preventing Californians from working, particularly harder-to-employ groups such as former offenders and those trained or educated outside of California, including veterans, military spouses and foreign-trained workers. The study found that occupational licensing hurts those at the bottom of the economic ladder twice: first by imposing significant costs on them should they try to enter a licensed occupation and second by pricing the services provided by licensed professionals out of reach.
The report found that California compares poorly to the rest of the nation in the amount of licensing it requires for occupations traditionally entered into by people of modest means. According to the report, researchers from the Institute for Justice selected 102 lower-income occupations, defined by the Bureau of Labor Statistics as making less than the national average income, ranging from manicurist to pest control applicator. Of the 102 occupations selected, California required licensure for 62, or 61 percent of them. According to the report, California ranked third most restrictive among 50 states and the District of Columbia, following only Louisiana and Arizona. California ranked seventh of 51 when measuring the burden imposed on entrants into these lower- and moderate-income occupations: on average, California applicants must pay $300 in licensing fees, spend 549 days in education and/or training and pass one exam.
- Legislative Focus on BBC Licensure Burdens. The 1600 hour education requirement for cosmetology licensure has been a discussion point for the Legislature during previous sunset review oversight of the BBC. During the 2012-13 sunset review oversight, Committee staff raised the issue of appropriate licensing categories, noting the need for BBC to evaluate adding specialized certificates or licensure in certain practices. The review asked whether many of the beautification services offered by BBC licensees require the mandatory schooling and training hours necessary for a cosmetologist or esthetician and noted that while there may be significant health concerns related to some practices, there may also not be a need for an individual performing specialized services to invest in a whole training program. The review found that training for many of the beautification services provided by BBC licensees is provided directly from manufacturers and likely not even reflected in BBC-approved curriculum and at BBC-approved schools. Staff noted that many entrepreneurial individuals throughout the state, including a large number of women and minorities, have become successful small business owners focused on providing one specialized service. In a background paper prepared by Committee staff during the 2012-13 review of BBC, staff recommended BBC explore balancing the consumer health, safety and harm from certain services with the desire to keep people employed throughout the state offering limited services and required BBC to review the issue of recognizing specialized service providers and provide a report by January 1, 2014 on this issue.
In 2013, the BBC submitted a report back to the Legislature on this issue titled Appropriate Licensing of Subcategories in which BBC expressed concern over licensing any subcategories of practice that are already captured by the broader license for a cosmetologist, such as a waxing-only specialist or make-up artist, as these practice areas are covered under the scope of practice of a cosmetologist and esthetician. The report further cited BBC concerns that offering a sub-license may diminish the existing scope of practice for licensees and could significantly increase the BBC's workload.
To help address concerns of individuals who seek to practice a subspecialty of a license, the BBC proposed creating a BBC-approved industry certification. Essentially, a cosmetologist interested in a hair coloring specialty certification would take an unknown number of courses from a BBC-approved provider, at an unknown cost to the individual, in order to obtain an industry certification in that specialty. This effort, however, does not address the issue of an individual desiring to only practice one beautification service and does not assist nor meet the current needs of individuals seeking to obtain a single practice license that may alleviate the burden from having to complete a full cosmetology or esthetics program.
The 2014-15 sunset review oversight of the BBC further examined the issue of the required curriculum and connection to practice. AB 181 (Bonilla, Chapter 430, Statutes of 2013), the bill stemming from the comprehensive review of BBC, required BBC to conduct a study and review of the 1600-hour training requirement for cosmetologists, conduct an occupational analysis of the cosmetology profession in California, and conduct a review of the national written examination for cosmetologists and of the California practical examination, in order to evaluate whether both examinations assess critical competencies for California cosmetologists and meet professional testing standards.
Currently in California, all BBC-regulated beautification services are required to be obtained within a BBC licensed establishment. BCP § 7317 specifically states that it is unlawful for any person, firm, or corporation to engage in barbering, cosmetology or electrolysis practices, for compensation, in an establishment or mobile unit which is not licensed by the BBC (other than incidental services provided by individuals employed to provide services in the theater, radio, television or motion picture production industry or services performed on a client who is ill or has a physical or mental incapacitation and the appointment is made through a licensed establishment.) Legally, those BBC-licensed establishments or the twenty-one licensed mobile units are the only facilities where consumers can access services of licensed professionals regulated by the BBC. Currently, a cosmetologist styling the hair of a bride at a hotel or other venue is guilty of unlicensed activity because they are operating outside of a BBC-licensed establishment.
During the 2014-15 sunset review oversight, BBC reported that current trends in the beautification industry show that consumers are beginning to seek services outside the walls of a traditional brick and mortar establishment such as homes, hotels, businesses, and other non-traditional locations. In its 2014 sunset report to the Legislature, the BBC provided information on other states that offer a more flexible license or registration. Washington offers a personal service license and Oregon offers a freelance authorization, both of which allow consumers to access services outside of a licensed establishment. Ohio offers a temporary special event permit which temporarily allows for cosmetology services to be provided in a location not licensed by the regulatory entity. In addition, New York authorizes licensees to practice in remote locations as long as the applicable requirements are followed. Individuals are receiving services at business offices, hotels, or other sites not traditionally common to industry practices in California.
In response to the questions of whether more people are seeking beautification services outside of a traditional salon establishment and whether BBC needs to update current establishment requirements to meet consumer demands, AB 181 also required BBC to establish regulations to issue a PSP. BBC was required to hold at least two stakeholder meetings and was authorized to issue a PSP to individuals who meet the requirements set forth in the regulation. PSP holders would be able to perform services outside of a licensed establishment but would still be required to obey existing health and safety requirements. AB 181 prohibited BBC from requiring a PSP holder to be employed by an establishment unless BBC determines it would be necessary in order to maintain consumer safety. The regulations also authorized BBC to require a PSP applicant to have proof of liability insurance and pass a criminal background clearance.
In the BBC’s report to the Legislature providing an update on the progress of the PSP regulation, BBC summarized the various viewpoints of stakeholder meeting attendees, including that not all services should be authorized under a PSP, liability insurance should be required, and licensees should be in good standing. BBC’s Licensing and Examination Committee determined the following for a proposed PSP:
- The PSP will be limited to cutting and styling hair
- The PSP will be tied to a licensed, working, brick-and-mortar establishment.
- The licensed establishment and PSP holder will provide proof of liability insurance.
- The number of PSP holders per establishment will be limited.
- A criminal background check will be part of the PSP process.
- The regulations will stipulate how tools will be disinfected and transported. The clean, closed container language can be used and the PSP holder will also be required to carry a soiled container to bring back to the establishment to disinfect later.
- Spray-on disinfectants and wipes will be permitted in the field.
- The PSP holder will post their PSP and establishment licenses on any advertisement.
- A notice will be posted on the website to direct consumers to check license numbers online and verify the connection to an establishment.
- The PSP holder will be required to have a photo I.D. to show that they match the license number advertised.
The BBC’s report also noted additional requests from industry representatives to require PSP holders to demonstrate, while at the licensed establishment, protocols used when in someone's home or place of business; to require minimum liability insurance of $1 million; to limit the geographical boundary of a PSP holder so that person can only practice a certain distance from the licensed establishment and; to make PSP holders employees of the establishment they are tied to.
While the BBC has not promulgated a PSP, limitations on the types of services offered by a PSP holder and requirements to remain affiliated with a licensed establishment appear counter to the intention of flexibility and allowing BBC to better recognize trends in the beautification services industry.
- Arguments in Support. The R Street Institute, sponsor of this bill, believes that
SB 999 will reduce some of California’s onerous occupational licensing requirements for people who would like to be involved in basic hair-care work such as shampooing, arranging, dressing, curling, and waving. R Street Institute writes “we understand the need for licensing in some fields, but California’s basic hair-care licensing requirements are out of proportion to the task at hand. In this case, the regulations harm job prospects for low-income Californians and mainly serve to limit competition.” According to R Street Institute, the bill “could help salon owners and workers. There are no safety issues here. Indeed washing and preparing hair is something all of us do virtually every day. The bill can also encourage the expansion of a new, entrepreneurial web-based industry of at-home hair care, something that is particularly beneficial to elderly and infirm people.” The Sponsor calls this bill a simple solution that will remove an obstacle for people who want to climb the financial ladder.
TechNet writes in support of this bill, noting that member companies face outmoded regulatory hurdles that stall productivitiy and maintain a status quo, without providing an actual benefit. TechNet believes that “it is critical that any legal or regulatory requirements should be tailored to the new product, directly tied to an identified harm, limited to gaps in existing coverage, focused on bad actors, and narrowly tailored to avoid conflicts or discrepancies in the law and unintended consequences. TechNet believes that this is a “field ripe for innovation to create more work opportunities while also providing consumers more services” and also believes in making room for innovation and opportunity which this bill will do by removing unnecessary barriers for a very narrow range of activities.
- Proposed Author’s Amendment. The Author has proposed expanding the list of services that are not included in the practice of barbering to include “Hairstyling of all textures of hair by standard methods that are current at the time of the hairstyling.”
On page 2, strike lines 13-14
(5) Hairstyling of all textures of hair by standard methods that
are current at the time of the hairstyling.
SUPPORT AND OPPOSITION:
Support:
R Street Institute (Sponsor)
TechNet
Opposition:
None on file as of April 10, 2018.
-- END --
Discussed in Hearing
Senate Floor
Senate Standing Committee on Business, Professions and Economic Development
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):