SJR 3: Presidential elections: electoral college.
- Session Year: 2017-2018
- House: Senate
- Latest Version Date: 2017-07-07
This measure would urge the state legislature and governor of each state to ratify the Agreement Among the States to Elect the President by National Popular Vote so that the President and Vice President of the United States are directly elected by the popular vote of all eligible citizens of the United States.
This measure would urge the state legislature and governor of each state to ratify the Agreement Among the States to Elect the President by National Popular Vote so that the President and Vice President of the United States are directly elected by the popular vote of all eligible citizens of the United States.
This measure would urge the state legislature and governor of each state to ratify the Agreement Among the States to Elect the President by National Popular Vote so that the President and Vice President of the United States are directly elected by the popular vote of all eligible citizens of the United States.
WHEREAS, Fifty-four percent of Americans favor amending the United States Constitution to elect the President and Vice President of the United States by popular vote; and
WHEREAS, Fifty-seven percent of Californians think a national popular vote system should be used to determine the President and Vice President of the United States; and
WHEREAS, A majority of Americans have preferred a national popular vote system dating back to Ronald Reagans presidency; and
WHEREAS, Section 1 of Article II of the United States Constitution gives the states exclusive control over awarding their electoral votes: Each state shall appoint, in such manner as the legislature thereof may direct, a number of electors...; and
WHEREAS, Maine and Nebraska currently award electoral votes by congressional district, which is a reminder that the method of awarding electoral votes is a state decision; and
WHEREAS, Ten states and the District of Columbia have already adopted National Popular Vote legislation that commits them to an interstate compact to award electoral votes to the presidential slate that wins the most votes nationwide; and
WHEREAS, The states that have adopted National Popular Vote legislation are California (55 electoral votes), Hawaii (4), Illinois (20), Massachusetts (11), Maryland (10), New Jersey (14), New York (29), Rhode Island (4), Vermont (3), and Washington (12), totaling 165 electoral votes or 61 percent of the 270 electoral votes needed to select the President and Vice President of the United States; and
WHEREAS, California adopted National Popular Vote legislation in 2011 with the passage of Assembly Bill 459, authored by then-Assembly Member Jerry Hill; and
WHEREAS, Several states have not yet adopted National Popular Vote legislation, even though a majority of their voters in recent elections cast ballots for the presidential slate that received the most votes nationwide but lost the election because of the current electoral college system; and
WHEREAS, Those states include Colorado (9 electoral votes), Connecticut (7), Delaware (3), Maine (4), Minnesota (10), Nevada (6), New Hampshire (4), New Mexico (5), Michigan (16), Oregon (7), Pennsylvania (20), Virginia (13), and Wisconsin (10), totaling 114 electoral votes; and
WHEREAS, If the legislatures and governors of those states adopted National Popular Vote legislation, it would bring the total number of electoral votes subject to the Agreement Among the States to Elect the President by National Popular Vote to 279 electoral votes, surpassing the 270 electoral votes needed to guarantee that the presidential slate that wins the most votes nationwide is elected as the next President and Vice President of the United States; and
WHEREAS, According to nationalpopularvote.com, a federal constitutional amendment or action by Congress is not necessary to change the current method of electing the President and Vice President of the United States; and
WHEREAS, The United States Constitution gives the states the exclusive and plenary power to choose the method of awarding their electoral votes; and
WHEREAS, The shortcomings of the current system of electing the President and Vice President of the United States stem from winner-take-all statutes that award all of a states electoral votes to the presidential slate that receives the most popular votes within each separate state; and
WHEREAS, The state-by-state winner-take-all method of awarding electoral votes is not found in the United States Constitution, was not debated at the Constitutional Convention of 1787, and is not discussed in the Federalist Papers; and
WHEREAS, The winner-take-all method of awarding electoral votes was used by only three states in the nations first presidential election in 1789, and those states abandoned that method by 1800. The Founders were dead for decades before the winner-take-all method became the predominant method for awarding electoral votes; and
WHEREAS, The winner-take-all method of awarding electoral votes is used today in 48 of the 50 states because it was enacted as a state statute in those states, under the same provision of the United States Constitution that empowers the states to choose the method of awarding their electoral votes and is being used to enact National Popular Vote legislation; and
WHEREAS, Winner-take-all statutes may be repealed in the same way they were enacted; namely, through each states process for enacting and repealing state laws. Therefore, a federal constitutional amendment is not necessary to change the state-by-state, winner-take-all method of awarding electoral votes; and
WHEREAS, The United States current electoral college system is causing all but the battleground states to be ignored in presidential elections; and
WHEREAS, Two-thirds of the campaign events for the 2016 presidential general election, 273 campaign events out of 399 total campaign events, occurred in only six states: Florida, Michigan, North Carolina, Ohio, Pennsylvania, and Virginia; and
WHEREAS, Two-thirds of the campaign events for the 2012 presidential general election, 176 campaign events out of 253 total campaign events, occurred in only four states: Iowa, Florida, Ohio, and Virginia; and
WHEREAS, If a national popular vote system was used, candidates would be more likely to campaign in more states based on population centers; and
WHEREAS, The following list of top media markets based on population provides an idea of the states that would receive more attention if a national popular vote system were used: Arizona, California, Colorado, the District of Columbia, Florida, Georgia, Illinois, Indiana, Maryland, Massachusetts, Michigan, Minnesota, Missouri, New York, North Carolina, Ohio, Oregon, Pennsylvania, Tennessee, Texas, and Washington; and
WHEREAS, In recent presidential elections the individual receiving the most popular votes nationwide has not won the election due to the current state-by-state winner-take-all electoral college system. In the 2000 presidential general election, the winner of the electoral college received 543,895 fewer national popular votes than his opponent and in the 2016 presidential general election, the winner of the electoral college received over 2.8 million fewer national popular votes than his opponent; and
WHEREAS, Americans deserve an electoral college system that awards the Presidency and Vice Presidency to the candidates who receive the most votes nationwide, regardless of which state a voter lives in; and
WHEREAS, We are all Americans and each vote should matter equally. This represents the true meaning of democracy; now, therefore, be it
Resolved by the Senate and the Assembly of the State of California, jointly, That the Legislature of the State of California urges each state legislature and governor to ratify the Agreement Among the States to Elect the President by National Popular Vote; and be it further
Resolved, That the Secretary of the Senate transmit copies of this resolution to each majority and minority leader in each house of every state legislature and to each state Governor.
WHEREAS, Fifty-four percent of Americans favor amending the United States Constitution to elect the President and Vice President of the United States by popular vote; and
WHEREAS, Fifty-seven percent of Californians think a national popular vote system should be used to determine the President and Vice President of the United States; and
WHEREAS, A majority of Americans have preferred a national popular vote system dating back to Ronald Reagans presidency; and
WHEREAS, Section 1 of Article II of the United States Constitution gives the states exclusive control over awarding their electoral votes: Each state shall appoint, in such manner as the legislature thereof may direct, a number of electors...; and
WHEREAS, Maine and Nebraska currently award electoral votes by congressional district, which is a reminder that the method of awarding electoral votes is a state decision; and
WHEREAS, Ten states and the District of Columbia have already adopted National Popular Vote legislation that commits them to an interstate compact to award electoral votes to the presidential slate that wins the most votes nationwide; and
WHEREAS, The states that have adopted National Popular Vote legislation are California (55 electoral votes), Hawaii (4), Illinois (20), Massachusetts (11), Maryland (10), New Jersey (14), New York (29), Rhode Island (4), Vermont (3), and Washington (12), totaling 165 electoral votes or 61 percent of the 270 electoral votes needed to select the President and Vice President of the United States; and
WHEREAS, California adopted National Popular Vote legislation in 2011 with the passage of Assembly Bill 459, authored by then-Assembly Member Jerry Hill; and
WHEREAS, Several states have not yet adopted National Popular Vote legislation, even though a majority of their voters in recent elections cast ballots for the presidential slate that received the most votes nationwide but lost the election because of the current electoral college system; and
WHEREAS, Those states include Colorado (9 electoral votes), Connecticut (7), Delaware (3), Maine (4), Minnesota (10), Nevada (6), New Hampshire (4), New Mexico (5), Michigan (16), Oregon (7), Pennsylvania (20), Virginia (13), and Wisconsin (10), totaling 114 electoral votes; and
WHEREAS, If the legislatures and governors of those states adopted National Popular Vote legislation, it would bring the total number of electoral votes subject to the Agreement Among the States to Elect the President by National Popular Vote to 279 electoral votes, surpassing the 270 electoral votes needed to guarantee that the presidential slate that wins the most votes nationwide is elected as the next President and Vice President of the United States; and
WHEREAS, According to nationalpopularvote.com, a federal constitutional amendment or action by Congress is not necessary to change the current method of electing the President and Vice President of the United States; and
WHEREAS, The United States Constitution gives the states the exclusive and plenary power to choose the method of awarding their electoral votes; and
WHEREAS, The shortcomings of the current system of electing the President and Vice President of the United States stem from winner-take-all statutes that award all of a states electoral votes to the presidential slate that receives the most popular votes within each separate state; and
WHEREAS, The state-by-state winner-take-all method of awarding electoral votes is not found in the United States Constitution, was not debated at the Constitutional Convention of 1787, and is not discussed in the Federalist Papers; and
WHEREAS, The winner-take-all method of awarding electoral votes was used by only three states in the nations first presidential election in 1789, and those states abandoned that method by 1800. The Founders were dead for decades before the winner-take-all method became the predominant method for awarding electoral votes; and
WHEREAS, The winner-take-all method of awarding electoral votes is used today in 48 of the 50 states because it was enacted as a state statute in those states, under the same provision of the United States Constitution that empowers the states to choose the method of awarding their electoral votes and is being used to enact National Popular Vote legislation; and
WHEREAS, Winner-take-all statutes may be repealed in the same way they were enacted; namely, through each states process for enacting and repealing state laws. Therefore, a federal constitutional amendment is not necessary to change the state-by-state, winner-take-all method of awarding electoral votes; and
WHEREAS, The United States current electoral college system is causing all but the battleground states to be ignored in presidential elections; and
WHEREAS, Two-thirds of the campaign events for the 2016 presidential general election, 273 campaign events out of 399 total campaign events, occurred in only six states: Florida, Michigan, North Carolina, Ohio, Pennsylvania, and Virginia; and
WHEREAS, Two-thirds of the campaign events for the 2012 presidential general election, 176 campaign events out of 253 total campaign events, occurred in only four states: Iowa, Florida, Ohio, and Virginia; and
WHEREAS, If a national popular vote system was used, candidates would be more likely to campaign in more states based on population centers; and
WHEREAS, The following list of top media markets based on population provides an idea of the states that would receive more attention if a national popular vote system were used: Arizona, California, Colorado, the District of Columbia, Florida, Georgia, Illinois, Indiana, Maryland, Massachusetts, Michigan, Minnesota, Missouri, New York, North Carolina, Ohio, Oregon, Pennsylvania, Tennessee, Texas, and Washington; and
WHEREAS, In recent presidential elections the individual receiving the most popular votes nationwide has not won the election due to the current state-by-state winner-take-all electoral college system. In the 2000 presidential general election, the winner of the electoral college received 543,895 fewer national popular votes than his opponent and in the 2016 presidential general election, the winner of the electoral college received over 2.8 million fewer national popular votes than his opponent; and
WHEREAS, Americans deserve an electoral college system that awards the Presidency and Vice Presidency to the candidates who receive the most votes nationwide, regardless of which state a voter lives in; and
WHEREAS, We are all Americans and each vote should matter equally. This represents the true meaning of democracy; now, therefore, be it
Resolved by the Senate and the Assembly of the State of California, jointly, That the Legislature of the State of California urges each state legislature and governor to ratify the Agreement Among the States to Elect the President by National Popular Vote; and be it further
Resolved, That the Secretary of the Senate transmit copies of this resolution to each majority and minority leader in each house of every state legislature and to each state Governor.
WHEREAS, Fifty-four percent of Americans favor amending the United States Constitution to elect the President and Vice President of the United States by popular vote; and
WHEREAS, Fifty-seven percent of Californians think a national popular vote system should be used to determine the President and Vice President of the United States; and
WHEREAS, A majority of Americans have preferred a national popular vote system dating back to Ronald Reagans presidency; and
WHEREAS, Section 1 of Article II of the United States Constitution gives the states exclusive control over awarding their electoral votes: Each state shall appoint, in such manner as the legislature thereof may direct, a number of electors...; and
WHEREAS, Maine and Nebraska currently award electoral votes by congressional district, which is a reminder that the method of awarding electoral votes is a state decision; and
WHEREAS, Ten states and the District of Columbia have already adopted National Popular Vote legislation that commits them to an interstate compact to award electoral votes to the presidential slate that wins the most votes nationwide; and
WHEREAS, The states that have adopted National Popular Vote legislation are California (55 electoral votes), Hawaii (4), Illinois (20), Massachusetts (11), Maryland (10), New Jersey (14), New York (29), Rhode Island (4), Vermont (3), and Washington (12), totaling 165 electoral votes or 61 percent of the 270 electoral votes needed to select the President and Vice President of the United States; and
WHEREAS, California adopted National Popular Vote legislation in 2011 with the passage of Assembly Bill 459, authored by then-Assembly Member Jerry Hill; and
WHEREAS, Several states have not yet adopted National Popular Vote legislation, even though a majority of their voters in recent elections cast ballots for the presidential slate that received the most votes nationwide but lost the election because of the current electoral college system; and
WHEREAS, Those states include Colorado (9 electoral votes), Connecticut (7), Delaware (3), Maine (4), Minnesota (10), Nevada (6), New Hampshire (4), New Mexico (5), Michigan (16), Oregon (7), Pennsylvania (20), Virginia (13), and Wisconsin (10), totaling 114 electoral votes; and
WHEREAS, If the legislatures and governors of those states adopted National Popular Vote legislation, it would bring the total number of electoral votes subject to the Agreement Among the States to Elect the President by National Popular Vote to 279 electoral votes, surpassing the 270 electoral votes needed to guarantee that the presidential slate that wins the most votes nationwide is elected as the next President and Vice President of the United States; and
WHEREAS, According to nationalpopularvote.com, a federal constitutional amendment or action by Congress is not necessary to change the current method of electing the President and Vice President of the United States; and
WHEREAS, The United States Constitution gives the states the exclusive and plenary power to choose the method of awarding their electoral votes; and
WHEREAS, The shortcomings of the current system of electing the President and Vice President of the United States stem from winner-take-all statutes that award all of a states electoral votes to the presidential slate that receives the most popular votes within each separate state; and
WHEREAS, The state-by-state winner-take-all method of awarding electoral votes is not found in the United States Constitution, was not debated at the Constitutional Convention of 1787, and is not discussed in the Federalist Papers; and
WHEREAS, The winner-take-all method of awarding electoral votes was used by only three states in the nations first presidential election in 1789, and those states abandoned that method by 1800. The Founders were dead for decades before the winner-take-all method became the predominant method for awarding electoral votes; and
WHEREAS, The winner-take-all method of awarding electoral votes is used today in 48 of the 50 states because it was enacted as a state statute in those states, under the same provision of the United States Constitution that empowers the states to choose the method of awarding their electoral votes and is being used to enact National Popular Vote legislation; and
WHEREAS, Winner-take-all statutes may be repealed in the same way they were enacted; namely, through each states process for enacting and repealing state laws. Therefore, a federal constitutional amendment is not necessary to change the state-by-state, winner-take-all method of awarding electoral votes; and
WHEREAS, The United States current electoral college system is causing all but the battleground states to be ignored in presidential elections; and
WHEREAS, Two-thirds of the campaign events for the 2016 presidential general election, 273 campaign events out of 399 total campaign events, occurred in only six states: Florida, Michigan, North Carolina, Ohio, Pennsylvania, and Virginia; and
WHEREAS, Two-thirds of the campaign events for the 2012 presidential general election, 176 campaign events out of 253 total campaign events, occurred in only four states: Iowa, Florida, Ohio, and Virginia; and
WHEREAS, If a national popular vote system was used, candidates would be more likely to campaign in more states based on population centers; and
WHEREAS, The following list of top media markets based on population provides an idea of the states that would receive more attention if a national popular vote system were used: Arizona, California, Colorado, the District of Columbia, Florida, Georgia, Illinois, Indiana, Maryland, Massachusetts, Michigan, Minnesota, Missouri, New York, North Carolina, Ohio, Oregon, Pennsylvania, Tennessee, Texas, and Washington; and
WHEREAS, In recent presidential elections the individual receiving the most popular votes nationwide has not won the election due to the current state-by-state winner-take-all electoral college system. In the 2000 presidential general election, the winner of the electoral college received 543,895 fewer national popular votes than his opponent and in the 2016 presidential general election, the winner of the electoral college received over 2.8 million fewer national popular votes than his opponent; and
WHEREAS, Americans deserve an electoral college system that awards the Presidency and Vice Presidency to the candidates who receive the most votes nationwide, regardless of which state a voter lives in; and
WHEREAS, We are all Americans and each vote should matter equally. This represents the true meaning of democracy; now, therefore, be it
Resolved by the Senate and the Assembly of the State of California, jointly, That the Legislature of the State of California urges each state legislature and governor to ratify the Agreement Among the States to Elect the President by National Popular Vote; and be it further
Resolved, That the Secretary of the Senate transmit copies of this resolution to each majority and minority leader in each house of every state legislature and to each state Governor.
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Jul 7, 2017 | Chaptered by Secretary of State. Res. Chapter 100, Statutes of 2017. |
| Jul 7, 2017 | Enrolled and filed with the Secretary of State at 2:15 p.m. |
| Jul 3, 2017 | In Senate. Ordered to engrossing and enrolling. |
| Jun 29, 2017 | Coauthors revised. |
| Jun 14, 2017 | From committee: Be adopted. Ordered to third reading. (Ayes 4. Noes 2.) (June 14). |
| Apr 3, 2017 | Referred to Com. on E. & R. |
| Mar 27, 2017 | In Assembly. Held at Desk. |
| Mar 27, 2017 | Read. Adopted. (Ayes 25. Noes 12. Page 481.) Ordered to the Assembly. |
| Mar 21, 2017 | From committee: Be adopted. Ordered to third reading. (Ayes 4. Noes 1. Page 428.) (March 21). |
| Mar 8, 2017 | Set for hearing March 21. |
| Jan 12, 2017 | Re-referred to Com. on E. & C.A. |
| Dec 21, 2016 | Introduced. Referred to Com. on RLS. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Jun 29, 2017 | SJR 3 Hill Senate Third Reading By LOW | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| Jun 14, 2017 | Be adopted. To third reading. | Assembly Standing Committee on Elections and Redistricting |
Passed |
|
| Mar 27, 2017 | Senate 3rd Reading SJR3 Hill et al. | Senate Floor |
Passed |
|
| Mar 21, 2017 | Be adopted. Ordered to third reading | Senate Standing Committee on Elections and Constitutional Amendments |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
Date of Hearing: June 14, 2017
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON ELECTIONS AND REDISTRICTING
Marc Berman, Chair
SBPCA Bill Id:SJR 3
Author:(Hill) – As Introduced Ver:December 21, 2016
SENATE VOTE: 25-12
SUBJECT: Presidential elections: electoral college
SUMMARY: Urges other states to participate in the National Popular Vote interstate compact in which each member state agrees to award its electoral votes to the Presidential ticket that receives the most votes nationwide.
EXISTING LAW provides that the Presidential ticket that receives the greatest number of votes in the state will receive all of California's electoral votes. Once the National Popular Vote agreement among the states goes into effect, the Presidential ticket that receives the greatest number of votes nationally will receive all of California's electoral votes.
FISCAL EFFECT: None. This resolution is keyed non-fiscal by the Legislative Counsel.
COMMENTS:
- Purpose of the Resolution: According to the author:
Regardless of how the Electoral College came to be, ranging from a slave state compromise, to founders being afraid of tyranny of the majority, to representation between big states and small states, to balance between states and the federal government and the branches of federal government, it’s time for states to award their electoral votes to the presidential slate that wins the most votes nationwide so that every American vote is treated equally.
The current Electoral College system creates a system where not all votes are equal. For California voters to be represented like Wyoming voters in the Electoral College, California would need 197 votes, not 55. The underrepresentation of large states in the Electoral College dilutes the representation of minority voters who live in diverse urban areas.
We’ve already corrected mistakes made by the founders who banned women and slaves from voting. We also changed the way US Senators are elected. They used to be appointed by state legislatures and now we allow for popular vote in each state. National Popular Vote is another correction we need to make to guarantee that each vote Americans cast in a presidential election counts equally.
- National Popular Vote Interstate Compact: The National Popular Vote is an interstate compact in which each member state agrees to award its electoral votes to the Presidential ticket that receives the most votes nationwide. It would effectively allow the President to be selected by the popular vote without amending the U.S. Constitution. According to their website:
The National Popular Vote interstate compact would guarantee the Presidency to the candidate who receives the most popular votes in all 50 states and the District of Columbia. Under the compact, the national popular vote winner would be the candidate who received the most popular votes from all 50 states (and DC) on Election Day. When the Electoral College meets in mid-December, the national popular vote winner would receive all of the electoral votes of the enacting states.
The National Popular Vote bill has been enacted by 11 jurisdictions possessing 165 electoral votes—61% of the 270 electoral votes necessary to activate it, including four small jurisdictions (RI, VT, HI, DC), three medium- size states (MD, MA, WA), and four big states (NJ, IL, NY, CA). The National Popular Vote interstate compact would not take effect until enacted by states possessing a majority of the electoral votes—that is, enough to elect a President (270 of 538).
The National Popular Vote interstate compact contains the following provisions:
a) Allows any state of the United States and the District of Columbia to become a member of the compact.
b) Requires each member of the compact to conduct a statewide popular election for President and Vice President.
c) Requires the chief election official of each member state to determine the number of votes cast for each presidential slate in each state of the United States and in the District of Columbia in which votes have been cast in a statewide popular election and to add such votes together to produce a “national popular vote total” for each presidential slate.
d) Requires the presidential elector certifying official of each member state to certify the appointment of the elector slate nominated in that state in association with the presidential slate that had the largest national popular vote total.
e) Requires, at least six days before the day fixed by law for the meeting and voting by presidential electors, each member state to make a final determination of the number of popular votes cast in the state for each presidential slate and to communicate an official statement of such results to the chief election officer of every other state. Requires the chief election official of each member state to treat any such statement received from another state as conclusive.
f) Provides that, in the event of a tie for the national popular vote winner, the presidential elector certifying official of each member state shall certify the appointment in that official’s own state of the elector slate nominated in association with the presidential slate receiving the largest number of popular votes within that official’s state.
g) Provides that if the number of presidential electors nominated in a member state in association with the national popular vote winner is less than or greater than that state’s number of electoral votes, the presidential candidate on the presidential slate that had the largest national popular vote total shall have the power to nominate the presidential electors for that state and that state’s presidential elector certifying official shall certify the appointment of such nominees.
h) Provides that this compact will govern the appointment of presidential electors in each member state in any year in which the agreement is in effect in states cumulatively possesses a majority of electoral votes as of July 20 of that year (six months prior to the beginning of the next presidential term).
i) Provides that the compact shall take effect when states cumulatively possessing a majority of the electoral votes have enacted the compact in substantially the same form and the enactments in such states have taken effect in each state.
j) Permits any member state to withdraw from the agreement, except that a withdrawal occurring six months or less before the end of a President’s term shall not become effective until a President and Vice President have been qualified to serve the next term.
k) Requires the Governor (or the Mayor in the case of the District of Columbia) of each member state to notify the Governor (Mayor) of all other states when the compact has been enacted and has taken effect in that official’s state, when the state has withdrawn from the compact, and when the compact takes effect generally.
l) Provides that the compact shall terminate if the Electoral College is abolished.
m) Defines various terms for the purposes of the compact.
n) Provides that if any provision of the compact is held invalid, the remaining provisions shall not be affected.
- Electoral College System: The Electoral College is a unique method for indirectly electing the president and vice-president of the United States. The Electoral College consists of a total of 538 members, one for each U.S. senator and representative, and three additional electors representing the District of Columbia. Each state has a number of electoral votes equal to the combined total of its congressional delegation, and each state legislature is free to determine the method it will use to select its own electors.
- Origins of the Electoral College: The indirect election of the US president through a “college of electors” was devised in 1787 by the framers of the Constitution. It was established by Article II, Section 1, Clause 2 of the U.S. Constitution, and has only been modified twice since, through the adoption of the 12th and 23rd Amendments.
The framers of the Constitution debated many options for choosing the nation’s highest office during the Constitutional Convention of 1787. Some wanted popular elections, while others wanted Congress to make the choice without public input. The Electoral College was a compromise made to fall between these two options. During the time of this debate, the country had only 13 states, which until 1776 had been separate colonies, and communications and travel across the country of 4 million people was difficult. Delegates feared that if the people were allowed to vote directly for president there would be too many candidates and that citizens of one state would not know much about the candidates from other states. There was concern that the public would vote for the “regional” candidate from their state, and the president would then likely be chosen from a state with a large population.
Another idea put in front of the delegates was to allow Congress to choose the president. This was criticized since such a system would lead away from checks and balances, and there was a chance that political deals would be struck between congressmen and the future president. Delegates were left with the option to create a separate institution composed of a distinct group of individuals to elect the president– an Electoral College. It was decided that the group of electors would meet only once in each respective state to vote for president, and the states would decide how to select their electors. The delegates reasoned that keeping the electors decentralized and temporary would make them less likely to be influenced by each other in their votes. Furthermore, since the electors were not a permanent sitting political body, it would be difficult for a presidential candidate to promise them something beyond the election.
- States Decide: The constitution gives state legislatures the power to decide how to appoint their electors. Forty-eight states and the District of Columbia currently award electoral votes through a winner-take-all system based on the popular vote in their state. Two states, Maine and Nebraska, have chosen to award one electoral vote to the Presidential ticket that receives the greatest number of votes in each Congressional district in the state, and two electoral votes to the Presidential ticket that receives the greatest number of votes in the state. Maine has used this system of electoral vote allocation since 1972, while Nebraska adopted this method in 1996. While the “winner take all” method of awarding electoral votes used in California and the district-based method of awarding electoral votes that is used in Maine and Nebraska are the only two methods that states currently use to award electoral votes, the states are not limited to these two options. Rather, the United States Constitution gives the state legislatures complete authority to determine how presidential electors are appointed.
- Candidate Spending & Battleground States: According to the author, our current electoral college system is causing all but the battleground states to be ignored in presidential elections. Due to the winner-take-all rule, modern presidential campaigns ignore any state where one candidate is comfortably ahead and instead focus only on a small number of closely contested battleground states. “Campaign events,” defined as public events in which a candidate is soliciting the state’s voters, are concentrated in a handful of states. According to America Goes to the Polls, a report by Nonprofit VOTE and US Elections Project, in 2016, the presidential campaigns dedicated 99% of their ad spending and 95% of campaign visits to the 14 battleground states, with well over half going to just four states – Florida, North Carolina, Ohio, and Pennsylvania. According to information compiled by the advocacy organization FairVote, between July and November 2016, California had no Democratic campaign events and only one Republican campaign event. This is in stark contrast to states like Florida with 71, North Carolina with 55, Pennsylvania with 54, and Ohio with 48 campaign events. Effectively, 65% of the electorate – 147 million voters living in the 36 non-battlegrounds states – were left on the sidelines of the presidential election.
- Representation of Minority Populations: In support of this resolution, the author argues that the "underrepresentation of large states in the Electoral College dilutes the representation of minority voters who live in diverse urban areas." According to America Goes to the Polls, the report discussed in the previous comment, “In 2016, the electoral college disproportionately impacted minority communities by effectively disenfranchising 75% of the Latino and 81% of the Asian American voters in the nation who did not live in a battleground state.”
- Popular Opinion: A national Gallup poll in December 2016 found that 49% of Americans say they want to amend the Constitution to allow for a popular vote for president. In California, a report published by the Public Policy Institute of California in 2008 found that 70% of residents and likely voters support electing the president by direct popular vote.
- Previous Legislation: AB 459 (Hill), Chapter 188, Statutes of 2011, ratified an interstate compact whereby the state agrees to award its electoral votes to the Presidential ticket that received the most popular votes nationwide.
SB 37 (Migden) of 2007, and AB 2948 (Umberg) of 2006, would have ratified an interstate compact whereby the state agrees to award its electoral votes to the Presidential ticket that received the most popular votes nationwide if certain conditions are met. Both bills were vetoed by the Governor.
AB 45 (Maze) of 2005, provided for California's electoral votes to be divided proportionately among presidential tickets based on each ticket's share of the popular vote in the state. AB 45 failed passage in this committee by a vote of 3-2.
AB 2003 (Longville) of 2004, would have provided that voters shall vote directly for Presidential electors, rather than voting for candidates for President and Vice President at the general election. AB 2003 was held on the Assembly Appropriations Committee's suspense file.
AB 45 (Strickland) of 2001, would have allocated presidential electors based on the winner of each congressional district, instead of the winner of the statewide vote. AB 45 failed passage in this committee.
- Related Legislation: AJR 1 (Low) requests the United States Congress to propose and send to the states for ratification a constitutional amendment to abolish the Electoral College, and provide for the direct election of the President and Vice President of the United States by the popular vote of all eligible citizens of the United States. AJR 1 was approved by this committee on a 5-2 vote, and is pending on the Senate Floor.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
California Teachers Association
Opposition
None on file.
Analysis Prepared by: Bish Paul / E. & R. / (916) 319-2094
Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | SJR |
THIRD READING
Bill No: SJR 3
:
SENATE ELECTIONS & C.A. COMMITTEE: 4-1, 3/21/17
AYES: Stern, Allen, Hertzberg, Leyva
NOES: Anderson
DIGEST: This resolution urges other states to participate in the National Popular Vote interstate compact.
Existing law:
- Requires all of the following regarding the Electoral College per federal law:
- Each state shall appoint, in a manner that the Legislature of the state directs, a number of electors of President and Vice President equal to the number of Senators and Representatives to which the state is entitled in Congress.
- The electors of President and Vice President shall be appointed in each state on the first Tuesday after the first Monday in November in every fourth year succeeding every election of a President and Vice President.
- The electors of President and Vice President of each state shall meet and give their votes on the first Monday after the second Wednesday in December following the presidential election.
- Provides, pursuant to state law, that the Presidential ticket that receives the greatest number of votes in the state will receive all of California’s electoral votes and requires each political party to select its slate of electors in accordance with established party procedures. The Secretary of State must certify the electors receiving the highest number of votes statewide in a general presidential election.
- Provides that California is a participant in the Agreement Among the States to Elect the President by National Popular Vote, an interstate compact that contains the following provisions:
- Allows any state of the United States and the District of Columbia to become a member of the compact.
- Requires each member of the compact to conduct a statewide popular election for President and Vice President.
- Requires the chief election official of each member state to determine the number of votes cast for each presidential slate in each state of the United States and in the District of Columbia in which votes have been cast in a statewide popular election and to add such votes together to produce a “national popular vote total” for each presidential slate.
- Requires the presidential elector certifying official of each member state to certify the appointment of the elector slate nominated in that state in association with the presidential slate that had the largest national popular vote total.
- Requires, at least six days before the day fixed by law for the meeting and voting by presidential electors, each member state to make a final determination of the number of popular votes cast in the state for each presidential slate and to communicate an official statement of such results to the chief election officer of every other state. Requires the chief election official of each member state to treat any such statement received from another state as conclusive.
- Provides that, in the event of a tie for the national popular vote winner, the presidential elector certifying official of each member state shall certify the appointment in that official’s own state of the elector slate nominated in association with the presidential slate receiving the largest number of popular votes within that official’s state.
- Provides that if the number of presidential electors nominated in a member state in association with the national popular vote winner is less than or greater than that state’s number of electoral votes, the presidential candidate on the presidential slate that had the largest national popular vote total shall have the power to nominate the presidential electors for that state and that state’s presidential elector certifying official shall certify the appointment of such nominees.
- Provides that this compact will govern the appointment of presidential electors in each member state in any year in which the agreement is in effect in states cumulatively possessing a majority of electoral votes as of July 20 of that year (six months prior to the beginning of the next presidential term).
- Provides that the compact shall take effect when states cumulatively possessing a majority of the electoral votes have enacted the compact in substantially the same form and the enactments in such states have taken effect in each state.
- Permits any member state to withdraw from the agreement, except that a withdrawal occurring six months or less before the end of a President’s term shall not become effective until a President and Vice President have been qualified to serve the next term.
- Requires the Governor (or the Mayor in the case of the District of Columbia) of each member state to notify the Governor (Mayor) of all other states when the compact has been enacted and has taken effect in that official’s state, when the state has withdrawn from the compact, and when the compact takes effect generally.
- Provides that the compact shall terminate if the Electoral College is abolished.
- Defines various terms for the purposes of the compact.
- Provides that if any provision of the compact is held invalid, the remaining provisions shall not be affected.
This resolution:
- Urges each state legislature and Governor to ratify the Agreement Among the States to Elect the President by National Popular Vote and requires the Secretary of the Senate to transmit copies of this resolution to each majority and minority leader in each house of every state legislature and to each state Governor.
- Makes findings related to the electoral college and the compact including, among others, all of the following:
- In two recent presidential elections the individual receiving the most popular votes nationwide has not won the election due to the current state-by-state winner-take-all electoral college system. In 2000, the winner of the electoral college received 543,895 fewer national popular votes than his opponent and in 2016, the winner of the electoral college received over 2.8 million fewer national popular votes than his opponent.
- Americans deserve an electoral college system that awards the Presidency and Vice Presidency to the candidates who receive the most votes nationwide, regardless of which state a voter lives in.
- A majority of Americans prefer a national popular vote system.
- Ten states and the District of Columbia have already adopted National Popular Vote legislation that commits them to an interstate compact to award electoral votes to the presidential slate that wins the most votes nationwide.
- The states that have adopted National Popular Vote legislation are California (55 electoral votes), Hawaii (4), Illinois (20), Massachusetts (11), Maryland (10), New Jersey (14), New York (29), Rhode Island (4), Vermont (3), and Washington (12), totaling 165 electoral votes or 61 percent of the 270 electoral votes needed to select the President and Vice President of the United States.
- Several states have not yet adopted National Popular Vote legislation, even though a majority of their voters in recent elections cast ballots for the presidential slate that received the most votes nationwide but lost the election because of the current electoral college system. Those states include Colorado (9 electoral votes), Connecticut (7), Delaware (3), Maine (4), Minnesota (10), Nevada (6), New Hampshire (4), New Mexico (5), Michigan (16), Oregon (7), Pennsylvania (20), Virginia (13), and Wisconsin (10), totaling 114 electoral votes.
- If the legislatures and governors of those states adopted National Popular Vote legislation, it would bring the total number of electoral votes subject to the Agreement Among the States to Elect the President by National Popular Vote to 279 electoral votes, surpassing the 270 electoral votes needed to guarantee that the presidential slate that wins the most votes nationwide is elected as the next President and Vice President of the United States.
- Winner-take-all statutes may be repealed in the same way they were enacted; namely, through each state’s process for enacting and repealing state laws. Therefore, a federal constitutional amendment is not necessary to change the state-by-state, winner-take-all method of awarding electoral votes.
- The current electoral college system is causing all but the battleground states to be ignored in presidential elections.
Background
Electoral Votes. Section 1 of Article II of the United States Constitution provides, in part, that “each State shall appoint, in such Manner as the Legislature thereof may direct, a Number of Electors, equal to the whole Number of Senators and Representatives to which the State may be entitled in Congress.” In accordance with that authority granted to the state legislatures, California and 47 other states (along with the District of Columbia) have chosen to award all electoral votes to the Presidential ticket that receives the greatest number of votes in the state (or in the District).
Two states, Maine and Nebraska, have chosen to award one electoral vote to the Presidential ticket that receives the greatest number of votes in each Congressional district in the state, and two electoral votes to the Presidential ticket that receives the greatest number of votes in the state. Maine has used this system of electoral vote allocation since 1972, while Nebraska adopted this method in 1996.
While the “winner take all” method of awarding electoral votes used in California and the district-based method of awarding electoral votes that is used in Maine and Nebraska are the only two methods that states currently use to award electoral votes, the states are not limited to these two options. Rather, the United States Constitution gives the state legislatures complete authority to determine how presidential electors are appointed. The California Legislature has previously considered bills to adopt the district-based method, to award electoral votes proportionately to the Presidential tickets based on the share of the vote that each ticket received, and to provide that voters shall vote directly for Presidential electors, rather than voting for candidates for President and Vice President at the general election.
Legislation in Other States. According to information from National Popular Vote, the organization that is the source of this effort, the interstate compact has been ratified by 10 states (California, Hawaii, Illinois, Maryland, Massachusetts, New Jersey, New York, Rhode Island, Vermont, and Washington) and by the District of Columbia representing 165 electoral votes. The compact will take effect when enacted into law by states possessing 270 electoral votes (a majority of the 538 total electoral votes).
Comments
- According to the author, regardless of how the Electoral College came to be, ranging from a slave state compromise, to founders being afraid of tyranny of the majority, to representation between big states and small states, to balance between states and the federal government and the branches of federal government, it’s time for states to award their electoral votes to the presidential slate that wins the most votes nationwide so that every American vote is treated equally.
The current Electoral College system creates a system where not all votes are equal. For California voters to be represented like Wyoming voters in the Electoral College, California would need 197 votes, not 55. The underrepresentation of large states in the Electoral College dilutes the representation of minority voters who live in diverse urban areas.
We’ve already corrected mistakes made by the founders who banned women and slaves from voting. We also changed the way US Senators are elected. They used to be appointed by state legislatures and now we allow for popular vote in each state. National Popular Vote is another correction we need to make to guarantee that each vote Americans cast in a presidential election counts equally.
Related/Prior Legislation
AB 459 (Hill, Chapter 188, Statutes of 2011) made California a participant in the National Popular Vote interstate compact.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: No Local: No
None received
OPPOSITION: (Verified 3/21/17)
None received
3/22/17 14:29:02
**** END ****
SENATE COMMITTEE ON
ELECTIONS AND CONSTITUTIONAL AMENDMENTS
Senator Henry Stern, Chair
2017 - 2018 Regular
Bill No: 3 Hearing Date: 3/21/17
Author: | Hill & Allen | ||
Version: |
| ||
Urgency: | No | Fiscal: | |
Consultant: | |||
Subject:
DIGEST
This measure urges other states to participate in the National Popular Vote interstate compact.
ANALYSIS
Existing law:
- Requires all of the following regarding the Electoral College per federal law:
- Each state shall appoint, in a manner that the Legislature of the state directs, a number of electors of President and Vice President equal to the number of Senators and Representatives to which the state is entitled in Congress.
- The electors of President and Vice President shall be appointed in each state on the first Tuesday after the first Monday in November in every fourth year succeeding every election of a President and Vice President.
- The electors of President and Vice President of each state shall meet and give their votes on the first Monday after the second Wednesday in December following the presidential election.
- Provides, pursuant to state law, that the Presidential ticket that receives the greatest number of votes in the state will receive all of California’s electoral votes and requires each political party to select its slate of electors in accordance with established party procedures. The Secretary of State must certify the electors receiving the highest number of votes statewide in a general presidential election.
- Provides that California is a participant in the Agreement Among the States to Elect the President by National Popular Vote, an interstate compact that contains the following provisions:
- Allows any state of the United States and the District of Columbia to become a member of the compact.
- Requires each member of the compact to conduct a statewide popular election for President and Vice President.
- Requires the chief election official of each member state to determine the number of votes cast for each presidential slate in each state of the United States and in the District of Columbia in which votes have been cast in a statewide popular election and to add such votes together to produce a “national popular vote total” for each presidential slate.
- Requires the presidential elector certifying official of each member state to certify the appointment of the elector slate nominated in that state in association with the presidential slate that had the largest national popular vote total.
- Requires, at least six days before the day fixed by law for the meeting and voting by presidential electors, each member state to make a final determination of the number of popular votes cast in the state for each presidential slate and to communicate an official statement of such results to the chief election officer of every other state. Requires the chief election official of each member state to treat any such statement received from another state as conclusive.
- Provides that, in the event of a tie for the national popular vote winner, the presidential elector certifying official of each member state shall certify the appointment in that official’s own state of the elector slate nominated in association with the presidential slate receiving the largest number of popular votes within that official’s state.
- Provides that if the number of presidential electors nominated in a member state in association with the national popular vote winner is less than or greater than that state’s number of electoral votes, the presidential candidate on the presidential slate that had the largest national popular vote total shall have the power to nominate the presidential electors for that state and that state’s presidential elector certifying official shall certify the appointment of such nominees.
- Provides that this compact will govern the appointment of presidential electors in each member state in any year in which the agreement is in effect in states cumulatively possesses a majority of electoral votes as of July 20 of that year (six months prior to the beginning of the next presidential term).
- Provides that the compact shall take effect when states cumulatively possessing a majority of the electoral votes have enacted the compact in substantially the same form and the enactments in such states have taken effect in each state.
- Permits any member state to withdraw from the agreement, except that a withdrawal occurring six months or less before the end of a President’s term shall not become effective until a President and Vice President have been qualified to serve the next term.
- Requires the Governor (or the Mayor in the case of the District of Columbia) of each member state to notify the Governor (Mayor) of all other states when the compact has been enacted and has taken effect in that official’s state, when the state has withdrawn from the compact, and when the compact takes effect generally.
- Provides that the compact shall terminate if the Electoral College is abolished.
- Defines various terms for the purposes of the compact.
- Provides that if any provision of the compact is held invalid, the remaining provisions shall not be affected.
This measure:
- Urges each state legislature and Governor to ratify the Agreement Among the States to Elect the President by National Popular Vote and requires the Secretary of the Senate to transmit copies of this resolution to each majority and minority leader in each house of every state legislature and to each state Governor.
- Makes findings related to the electoral college and the compact including, among others, all of the following:
- In two recent presidential elections the individual receiving the most popular votes nationwide has not won the election due to the current state-by-state winner-take-all electoral college system. In 2000, the winner of the electoral college received 543,895 fewer national popular votes than his opponent and in 2016, the winner of the electoral college received over 2.8 million fewer national popular votes than his opponent.
- Americans deserve an electoral college system that awards the Presidency and Vice Presidency to the candidates who receive the most votes nationwide, regardless of which state a voter lives in.
- A majority of Americans prefer a national popular vote system.
- Ten states and the District of Columbia have already adopted National Popular Vote legislation that commits them to an interstate compact to award electoral votes to the presidential slate that wins the most votes nationwide.
- The states that have adopted National Popular Vote legislation are California (55 electoral votes), Hawaii (4), Illinois (20), Massachusetts (11), Maryland (10), New Jersey (14), New York (29), Rhode Island (4), Vermont (3), and Washington (12), totaling 165 electoral votes or 61 percent of the 270 electoral votes needed to select the President and Vice President of the United States.
- Several states have not yet adopted National Popular Vote legislation, even though a majority of their voters in recent elections cast ballots for the presidential slate that received the most votes nationwide but lost the election because of the current electoral college system. Those states include Colorado (9 electoral votes), Connecticut (7), Delaware (3), Maine (4), Minnesota (10), Nevada (6), New Hampshire (4), New Mexico (5), Michigan (16), Oregon (7), Pennsylvania (20), Virginia (13), and Wisconsin (10), totaling 114 electoral votes.
- If the legislatures and governors of those states adopted National Popular Vote legislation, it would bring the total number of electoral votes subject to the Agreement Among the States to Elect the President by National Popular Vote to 279 electoral votes, surpassing the 270 electoral votes needed to guarantee that the presidential slate that wins the most votes nationwide is elected as the next President and Vice President of the United States.
- Winner-take-all statutes may be repealed in the same way they were enacted; namely, through each state’s process for enacting and repealing state laws. Therefore, a federal constitutional amendment is not necessary to change the state-by-state, winner-take-all method of awarding electoral votes.
- The current electoral college system is causing all but the battleground states to be ignored in presidential elections.
BACKGROUND
Electoral Votes. Section 1 of Article II of the United States Constitution provides, in part, that “each State shall appoint, in such Manner as the Legislature thereof may direct, a Number of Electors, equal to the whole Number of Senators and Representatives to which the State may be entitled in Congress.” In accordance with that authority granted to the state legislatures, California and 47 other states (along with the District of Columbia) have chosen to award all electoral votes to the Presidential ticket that receives the greatest number of votes in the state (or in the District).
Two states, Maine and Nebraska, have chosen to award one electoral vote to the Presidential ticket that receives the greatest number of votes in each Congressional district in the state, and two electoral votes to the Presidential ticket that receives the greatest number of votes in the state. Maine has used this system of electoral vote allocation since 1972, while Nebraska adopted this method in 1996.
While the “winner take all” method of awarding electoral votes used in California and the district-based method of awarding electoral votes that is used in Maine and Nebraska are the only two methods that states currently use to award electoral votes, the states are not limited to these two options. Rather, the United States Constitution gives the state legislatures complete authority to determine how presidential electors are appointed. The California Legislature has previously considered bills to adopt the district-based method, to award electoral votes proportionately to the Presidential tickets based on the share of the vote that each ticket received, and to provide that voters shall vote directly for Presidential electors, rather than voting for candidates for President and Vice President at the general election.
Legislation in Other States. According to information from National Popular Vote, the organization that is the source of this effort, the interstate compact has been ratified by 10 states (California, Hawaii, Illinois, Maryland, Massachusetts, New Jersey, New York, Rhode Island, Vermont, and Washington) and by the District of Columbia representing 165 electoral votes. The compact will take effect when enacted into law by states possessing 270 electoral votes (a majority of the 538 total electoral votes).
COMMENTS
- According to the Author: Regardless of how the Electoral College came to be, ranging from a slave state compromise, to founders being afraid of tyranny of the majority, to representation between big states and small states, to balance between states and the federal government and the branches of federal government, it’s time for states to award their electoral votes to the presidential slate that wins the most votes nationwide so that every American vote is treated equally.
The current Electoral College system creates a system where not all votes are equal. For California voters to be represented like Wyoming voters in the Electoral College, California would need 197 votes, not 55. The underrepresentation of large states in the Electoral College dilutes the representation of minority voters who live in diverse urban areas.
We’ve already corrected mistakes made by the founders who banned women and slaves from voting. We also changed the way US Senators are elected. They used to be appointed by state legislatures and now we allow for popular vote in each state. National Popular Vote is another correction we need to make to guarantee that each vote Americans cast in a presidential election counts equally.
RELATED/PRIOR LEGISLATION
AB 459 (Hill, Chapter 188, Statutes of 201), made California a participant in the National Popular Vote interstate compact.
POSITIONS
Sponsor: Author
Support: None received
Oppose: None received
-- END --
Discussed in Hearing
Assembly Floor
Assembly Standing Committee on Elections and Redistricting
Senate Floor
Senate Standing Committee on Elections and Constitutional Amendments
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):