AB 1030: Pelvic examinations: informational pamphlet.
- Session Year: 2019-2020
- House: Assembly
- Latest Version Date: 2019-08-13
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Sep 14, 2019 | Ordered to inactive file at the request of Senator Bradford. |
| Aug 27, 2019 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| Aug 26, 2019 | From committee: Be ordered to second reading pursuant to Senate Rule 28.8. |
| Aug 15, 2019 | In committee: Hearing postponed by committee. |
| Aug 13, 2019 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to committee. Read second time, amended, and re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Aug 12, 2019 | In committee: Set, first hearing. Hearing canceled at the request of author. |
| Jul 3, 2019 | Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Jul 2, 2019 | From committee: Amend, and do pass as amended and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 5. Noes 0.) (June 24). |
| Jun 6, 2019 | In committee: Hearing postponed by committee. |
| Jun 3, 2019 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to committee. Read second time, amended, and re-referred to Com. on B., P. & E.D. |
| May 23, 2019 | In committee: Hearing postponed by committee. |
| May 8, 2019 | Referred to Com. on B., P. & E.D. |
| Apr 29, 2019 | In Senate. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. |
| Apr 29, 2019 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Senate. |
| Apr 25, 2019 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| Apr 24, 2019 | From committee: Do pass. (Ayes 17. Noes 0.) (April 24). |
| Apr 10, 2019 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 15. Noes 0.) (April 9). Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Mar 27, 2019 | Re-referred to Com. on HEALTH. |
| Mar 26, 2019 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to Com. on HEALTH. Read second time and amended. |
| Mar 7, 2019 | Referred to Com. on HEALTH. |
| Feb 22, 2019 | From printer. May be heard in committee March 24. |
| Feb 21, 2019 | Read first time. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Jun 24, 2019 | Do pass as amended, but first amend, and re-refer to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Senate Standing Committee on Business, Professions and Economic Development |
Passed |
|
| Apr 29, 2019 | AB 1030 Calderon Assembly Third Reading | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| Apr 24, 2019 | Do pass. | Assembly Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Apr 9, 2019 | Do pass and be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Assembly Standing Committee on Health |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | AB 1030 |
THIRD READING
Bill No: AB 1030
Author: Calderon (D) and Petrie-Norris (D)
Amended: 8/13/19 in Senate
SENATE BUS., PROF. & ECON. DEV. COMMITTEE: 5-0, 6/24/19
AYES: Glazer, Archuleta, Dodd, Hill, Wilk
NO VOTE RECORDED: Chang, Galgiani, Leyva, Pan
SENATE APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE: Senate Rule 28.8
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 73-0, 4/29/19 - See last page for vote
SUBJECT: Pelvic examinations: informational pamphlet
DIGEST:
This bill requires health professionals who are licensed, certified, registered, or otherwise subject to regulation who, acting within the scope of their practice in accordance with standardized protocols where they exist and in conformity with the standard of care for their profession, are authorized to perform pelvic examinations, to provide patients with a pamphlet, created by the Medical Board of California (MBC) in coordination with specified stakeholders, about appropriate pelvic exams prior to their first pelvic exam with that health professional.
Existing law:
- Requires physicians and surgeons, osteopathic physicians and surgeons, podiatrists, acupuncturists, chiropractors and naturopathic doctors to notify patients of their probationary status and provide information about the licensee's probationary status, he length of the probation and the end date, all practice restrictions placed on the licensee by the licensing board, the board's phone number, and an explanation of how the patient can find further information on the licensee's probation on the licensee's profile page on the board's online license information site. Requires licensees to obtain a signed copy of the disclosure outlined above from the patient or the patient's guardian or health surrogate.
- Requires the State Department of Health Services (now known as the Department of Health Care Services) to approve and send an updated copy of a standardized written summary on alternative methods of treatment for prostate cancer (concerning the advantages, disadvantages, risks, and descriptions, of procedures with regard to medically viable and efficacious alternative methods of treatment of prostate cancer) to the MBC every time the summary is modified and requires MBC to make the updated summary available to its licensees. Specifies that the summary be in layman’s language and in a language understood by patients. Urges physicians and surgeons to make the summary available to patients when appropriate. (Business and Professions Code (BPC) § 2248.5)
- Requires a physician and surgeon primarily responsible for providing a patient an annual gynecological examination to provide that patient, during the annual examination, a standardized summary containing a description of the symptoms and appropriate methods of diagnoses for gynecological cancers. The summary must be in layperson’s language and in a language understood by the patient. States that a physician and surgeon who violates this requirement may be cited and assessed an administrative fine upon the second and subsequent complaints against a physician and surgeon for not providing the summary. (BPC § 2249)
- Requires a prescriber, for minor patients, prior to directly dispensing or issuing a prescription for a controlled substance containing an opioid, to discuss information, including the risks of addiction and overdose associated with the use of opioids, the increased risk of addiction to an individual who is suffering from both mental and substance abuse disorders, and the danger of taking an opioid with a benzodiazepine, alcohol, or another central nervous system depressant. (HSC Section 11158.1)
- Requires a physician and surgeon, upon a diagnosis of breast cancer, to give a patient a standardized written summary in layperson’s language and in a language understood by the patient, developed by the Department of Health Care Services (DHCS), with the recommendations of the DHCS Cancer Advisory Council, informing the patient of the advantages, disadvantages, risks, and descriptions of the procedures with regard to medically viable and efficacious alternative methods of treatment for breast cancer. Requires a physician and surgeon to note on the patient’s chart that they have given the patient the written summary. Authorizes a physician and surgeon to choose to provide the summary prior to a screening or biopsy for breast cancer upon a patient’s request, or at the discretion of the physician and surgeon in appropriate cases, including, but not limited to, instances when a patient has demonstrated risk factors, has a family history of breast cancer, or is otherwise susceptible. Specifies that failure to provide the summary constitutes unprofessional conduct. (HSC § 109275)
- Requires, until January 1, 2025, health facilities where mammography is performed, if a patient is categorized by the facility as having dense breasts, as specified, to provide a notice informing the patient that they have dense breasts. (HSC § 123222.3)
This bill:
- Requires health professionals who are licensed, certified, registered, or otherwise subject to regulation who, acting within the scope of their practice in accordance with standardized protocols where they exist and in conformity with the standard of care for their profession, are authorized to perform pelvic examinations, to provide patients with a pamphlet about appropriate pelvic exams prior to their first pelvic exam with that health professional. Requires a signed acknowledgment of receipt of the pamphlet from the patient to be obtained and maintained as part of the patient's medical record.
- Specifies that MBC, on or before July 1, 2020, in coordination with the American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists (ACOG), the California Medical Association (CMA), and the California Academy of Family Physicians (CAFP) must develop a pamphlet that includes, but is not limited to: what a pelvic exam is and how it is properly performed; if applicable, a description of other relevant exams; privacy expectations, including that privacy should be provided for the patient both when undressing and dressing and that a gown or a drape should be provided; an explanation of what a speculum is and how it should be properly used during an examination; that gloves should be worn by the practitioner during the examination and; a telephone number for MBC where a patient may report any misconduct that the patient feels may have occurred.
- Specifies that the pamphlet must be posted as a printable file on MBC’s Web site, made available for order as a printed deliverable, or both. Requires the pamphlet to be written in layperson’s language and made available in both English and Spanish.
- Provides that a licensee who violates the requirements related to the pamphlet may be cited and assessed an administrative fine by the appropriate licensing board. A citation shall not be issued and a fine shall not be assessed upon the first complaint against a licensee who violates this section. Upon the second and subsequent complaints against a licensee who violates this section, a citation may be issued and an administrative fine may be assessed by the appropriate licensing board.
Background
In 2018, the Senate Committee on Business, Professions and Economic Development held a hearing, Sexual Misconduct Reporting in the Medical Profession: Missed Opportunities to Protect Patients, to explore whether licensed health professionals who fail to meet established standards are discovered, reviewed and disciplined, if necessary, in a timely manner.
Discussion at the hearing centered on recent events at the University of Southern California (USC) where a physician employed by USC’s student health clinic was accused of sexual misconduct. According to information provided by USC, In June 2016, their Office of Equity and Diversity received a complaint from a student health center staff member about Dr. George Tyndall, a gynecologist at the health center. Dr. Tyndall was placed on administrative leave while an investigation was conducted. During that investigation, outside medical reviewers concluded that the manner in which Dr. Tyndall performed physical exams did not meet current practice standards and that he made inappropriate remarks to patients, in some cases during the examination process. The investigation also brought to light complaints about Dr. Tyndall that had been received in prior years but were managed independently by the director of the student health center. USC filed a complaint with MBC about Dr. Tyndall in 2017.
At the time, the student health center was organized under USC’s university operations, rather than as an extension of its hospitals and medical schools. Complaints against Dr. Tyndall were treated as employment matters and followed an investigation process that did not include peer review, given that the student health center did not have a peer review body. In turn, MBC was not made aware of action taken against Dr. Tyndall by USC through one of the mandatory reporting requirements contained in BPC Sections 805 or 805.01.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: Yes Local: No
California Health Coalition Advocacy
Consumer Attorneys of California
Medical Board of California
OPPOSITION: (Verified 8/29/19)
American College of Physicians California Services Chapter
American Congress of Obstetricians & Gynecologists - District IX
California Academy of Family Physicians
California Medical Association
Maternal and Child Health Access
Planned Parenthood Affiliates of California
One individual, a former patient of Dr. Tyndall
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: Supporters write that “Given the more invasive nature of pelvic examinations, and recent horrific tales of abuse during these exams, it has become apparent that patients would benefit from advance information about what to expect during a pelvic exam. AB 1030 will ensure that female patients receive the information they need to in order to identify, and hopefully prevent, instances of severe misconduct.”
The Medical Board of California writes that the requirement in the bill for a physician to provide information may help to prevent sexual misconduct and ensure that instances of misconduct are reported to the Board.
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION: The American Congress of Obstetricians & Gynecologists - District IX (ACOG) and California Academy of Family Physicians of are opposed to this bill unless it is amended. The groups write that “while we appreciate the author’s intent and willingness to amend the bill to address some of our concerns, AB 1030 still contains problematic language that compels our opposition. We agree that women should be properly informed of what to expect during a pelvic examination and absolutely encourage dialogue between a physician and the patient. However, requiring that such information be verified by a signature and placed in the patient’s medical record is both burdensome and unnecessary when the goal is to ensure the patient is properly informed. We continue to believe there are more effective approaches to providing women with this information. These approaches include incorporating the information into students’ comprehensive sexual health education curriculum and/or giving the information to health plans to distribute to their enrollees with adequate time prior to the first exam so the enrollee may research and develop thoughtful questions. Providing the information immediately before the exam at the clinic will not adequately prepare the patient and will only serve to cause anxiety and increase unnecessary tension between the patient and physician. However, if a pamphlet must be required, we ask that it not include the additional burden of collecting a signature and requiring it be placed in the medical record. Increasingly, physicians feel burdened by administrative tasks that do not appear to add value to patient care and are unrelated to the reasons they chose their professions. This disconnect between their passion for patient care and their daily tasks has been identified as a key contributor to distress — leading to alienation, isolation, depersonalization, cynicism, emotional, exhaustion and burnout. These problems are real and despite even the most well intended legislation, they cannot be ignored. Therefore, we are asking for an amendment to remove the signature and medical record registration requirement from the bill.”
The California Medical Association (CMA) advises that while the organization appreciates the author’s intent to ensure that information is shared with each patient regarding pelvic examinations, “we strongly believe the signature requirement is inconsistent with other policy related to information sharing between a patient and physician and would have unintended consequences.” According to CMA, “this bill forces patients to consent that they have understood the information that is shared in the pamphlet prior to a pelvic exam being conducted. This is problematic for the physician but more importantly it could be problematic to the patient. If a patient has been forced to consent, through the signing of an informational pamphlet, they may be less likely to speak out if something makes them feel uncomfortable. Furthermore, if they choose not to sign the pamphlet, presumably they would be denied the exam. Pelvic and gynecological exams are extremely important to women’s health and this pamphlet puts patients in a position of being forced to sign and consent that they understand how an exam should be conducted. This is unnecessary and burdensome. Informational pamphlets are important, but they should be used to provide information, not trap patients into consenting to receive important medical care.”
One individual, a former patient of Dr. Tyndall who is now a physician, believes that the signature requirement should be removed from this bill, noting how difficult it was to come forward about her experience. She is concerned about the signature requirement in this bill which will “make it even more onerous for victims to come forward; it adds yet another thing we as young women become responsible for. If I had signed a piece of paper stating that I knew the components of a normal pelvic exam – whether I had actually read the document or not – and the same thing had happened despite my signing the form, it would be near impossible to keep from blaming myself for letting it happen anyway. It would be impossible not to think of how anyone defending a rapist or assaulter would point to this paper and say ‘Well, look, she signed this paper saying she knew what was normal, why didn’t she stop him or step forward sooner?’”
Planned Parenthood is concerned that the bill “creates additional barriers for patients to access reproductive health care…For many, coming into a Planned Parenthood is the first touch to the health care system, whether it’s for a pap smear, an STI test, or a pregnancy test and consultation. This bill will require any patient coming in for their first pelvic exam to be given an informational pamphlet and sign upon receipt. Based on the number of gynecological exams Planned Parenthood conducts, we believe this requirement will increase the length of patient visits and thus unintentionally cause patient volume to decrease. Planned Parenthood Orange and San Bernardino Counties estimates that this requirement would add 280,000 minutes to patient visits a year, which would equal about 18,700 patients a year who would not be able to be seen at a Planned Parenthood health center because of the additional time added to pelvic exam visits, and this represents just 1/7 of the Planned Parenthood Affiliates in California.
Planned Parenthood believes that by requiring a patient’s signature, medical providers will be putting the onus on the patient as the responsible party for knowing what it is right and wrong in the health care setting, which simply shouldn’t be the case. Appropriate medical practices are the responsibility of the institution and the clinicians, these medical professionals are responsible for ensuring there is no abuse taking place. In the specific case that this bill stems from, the Doctor in question had complaints filed against them with their institution since the 1980s, the institution chose not to pursue intermediary action.
By targeting only gynecological exams, this bill will further stigmatize reproductive health care and adds yet another barrier to accessing preventive health care services and could prevent a patient from receiving the care all together should they choose not to sign upon receipt of the pamphlet.”
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 73-0, 4/29/19
AYES: Aguiar-Curry, Bauer-Kahan, Berman, Bigelow, Bloom, Boerner Horvath, Bonta, Brough, Burke, Calderon, Carrillo, Cervantes, Chau, Chiu, Chu, Cooley, Cooper, Cunningham, Dahle, Daly, Diep, Eggman, Flora, Fong, Frazier, Friedman, Gabriel, Gallagher, Cristina Garcia, Eduardo Garcia, Gipson, Gloria, Gonzalez, Gray, Grayson, Holden, Irwin, Jones-Sawyer, Kalra, Kamlager-Dove, Lackey, Levine, Limón, Low, Mathis, Mayes, McCarty, Medina, Melendez, Mullin, Muratsuchi, Nazarian, O'Donnell, Patterson, Petrie-Norris, Quirk, Quirk-Silva, Ramos, Reyes, Luz Rivas, Robert Rivas, Rodriguez, Blanca Rubio, Salas, Santiago, Smith, Mark Stone, Ting, Voepel, Waldron, Wicks, Wood, Rendon
NO VOTE RECORDED: Arambula, Chen, Choi, Kiley, Maienschein, Obernolte, Weber
Prepared by: Sarah Mason / B., P. & E.D. /
8/29/19 14:23:13
**** END ****
SENATE COMMITTEE ON
BUSINESS, PROFESSIONS AND ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT
Senator Steven Glazer, Chair
2019 - 2020 Regular
Bill No: Hearing Date: June 24, 2019
Author: | |||
Version: | June 3, 2019 | ||
Urgency: | No | Fiscal: | Yes |
Consultant: | Sarah Mason | ||
Subject:
SUMMARY: Requires a physician to provide a patient with a pamphlet, created by the Medical Board of California (MBC) in coordination with specified stakeholders, about appropriate pelvic exams prior to their first pelvic exam with that physician. Requires a physician to obtain a patient’s signature on a form confirming that the patient received the informational pamphlet and understood the contents.
Existing law:
- Requires the State Department of Health Services (now known as the Department of Health Care Services) to approve and send an updated copy of a standardized written summary on alternative methods of treatment for prostate cancer (concerning the advantages, disadvantages, risks, and descriptions, of procedures with regard to medically viable and efficacious alternative methods of treatment of prostate cancer) to the Medical Board of California (MBC) every time the summary is modified and requires MBC to make the updated summary available to its licensees. Specifies that the summary be in layman’s language and in a language understood by patients. Urges physicians and surgeons to make the summary available to patients when appropriate. (Business and Professions Code (BPC) § 2248.5)
- Requires a physician and surgeon primarily responsible for providing a patient an annual gynecological examination to provide that patient, during the annual examination, a standardized summary containing a description of the symptoms and appropriate methods of diagnoses for gynecological cancers. The summary must be in layperson’s language and in a language understood by the patient. States that a physician and surgeon who violates this requirement may be cited and assessed an administrative fine upon the second and subsequent complaints against a physician and surgeon for not providing the summary. (BPC § 2249)
- Requires a prescriber, for minor patients, prior to directly dispensing or issuing a prescription for a controlled substance containing an opioid, to discuss information, including the risks of addiction and overdose associated with the use of opioids, the increased risk of addiction to an individual who is suffering from both mental and substance abuse disorders, and the danger of taking an opioid with a benzodiazepine, alcohol, or another central nervous system depressant. HSC Section 11158.1
- Requires a physician and surgeon, upon a diagnosis of breast cancer, to give a patient a standardized written summary in layperson’s language and in a language understood by the patient, developed by the Department of Health Care Services, with the recommendations of the DHCS Cancer Advisory Council, informing the patient of the advantages, disadvantages, risks, and descriptions of the procedures with regard to medically viable and efficacious alternative methods of treatment for breast cancer. Requires a physician and surgeon to note on the patient’s chart that they have given the patient the written summary. Authorizes a physician and surgeon to choose to provide the summary prior to a screening or biopsy for breast cancer upon a patient’s request, or at the discretion of the physician and surgeon in appropriate cases, including, but not limited to, instances when a patient has demonstrated risk factors, has a family history of breast cancer, or is otherwise susceptible. Specifies that failure to provide the summary constitutes unprofessional conduct. (HSC § 109275)
- Until January 1, 2025, requires health facilities where mammography is performed, if a patient is categorized by the facility as having dense breasts, as specified, to provide a notice informing the patient that they have dense breasts. (HSC § 123222.3)
This bill:
- Requires, effective one month after MBC creates a pamphlet containing information about pelvic exams, a physician primarily responsible for providing a patient an annual gynecological examination to provide a patient with the pamphlet prior to their first pelvic exam with that physician. Requires a physician to obtain a patient’s signature on a form that must be kept as part of the patient’s medical record confirming that the patient received the informational pamphlet and understood the contents.
- Specifies that MBC, on or before July 1, 2020, in coordination with the American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists (ACOG), the California Medical Association (CMA), and the California Academy of Family Physicians (CAFP) must develop a pamphlet that includes, but is not limited to: what a pelvic exam is and how it is properly performed; if applicable, a description of other relevant exams; privacy expectations, including that privacy should be provided for the patient both when undressing and dressing and that a gown or a drape should be provided; an explanation of what a speculum is and how it should be properly used during an examination; that gloves should be worn by the practitioner during the examination and; a telephone number for MBC where a patient may report any misconduct that the patient feels may have occurred.
- Specifies that the pamphlet must be posted as a printable file on MBC’s website, made available for order as a printed deliverable, or both.
FISCAL EFFECT: This bill is keyed fiscal by Legislative Counsel. According to the Assembly Committee on Appropriations analysis dated April 24, 2019, the bill will result in minor and absorbable costs to MBC to create the required pamphlet and minor and absorbable information technology costs to the Department of Consumer Affairs to track enforcement.
COMMENTS:
- Purpose. The Author is the Sponsor of this bill. According to the Author, “current law does not require any information be provided to patients prior to their first gynecological pelvic exam. Given the more invasive nature of pelvic examinations, and recent horrific tales of abuse during these exams, it has become apparent that patients would benefit from advance information about what to expect during a pelvic exam.”
The Author cites the example of recent events and allegations of misconduct by Dr. George Tyndall at the University of Southern California, noted below, in explaining the need for this bill. According to the Author, “though the Tyndall case garnered attention because of the educational setting and the astounding number of victims that have come forward, it is, unfortunately, not an isolated event. After reviewing the Medical Board of California’s disciplinary decisions from the last five years alone, there have been numerous other physicians who have had their licenses placed on probation or revoked entirely for sexual misconduct that occurred during a pelvic exam. AB 1030 will empower patients by giving them much needed information. AB 1030 will ensure that female patients receive the information they need to in order to identify, and hopefully prevent, instances of severe misconduct.”
- Recent Events and Allegations of Misconduct. In 2018, the Senate Committee on Business, Professions and Economic Development held a hearing, Sexual Misconduct Reporting in the Medical Profession: Missed Opportunities to Protect Patients, to explore whether licensed health professionals who fail to meet established standards are discovered, reviewed and disciplined, if necessary, in a timely manner.
Discussion at the hearing centered on recent events at the University of Southern California (USC) where a physician employed by USC’s student health clinic was accused of sexual misconduct. According to information provided by USC, In June 2016, their Office of Equity and Diversity received a complaint from a student health center staff member about Dr. George Tyndall, a gynecologist at the health center. Dr. Tyndall was placed on administrative leave while an investigation was conducted. During that investigation, outside medical reviewers concluded that the manner in which Dr. Tyndall performed physical exams did not meet current practice standards and that he made inappropriate remarks to patients, in some cases during the examination process. The investigation also brought to light complaints about Dr. Tyndall that had been received in prior years but were managed independently by the director of the student health center. USC filed a complaint with MBC about Dr. Tyndall in 2017.
At the time, the student health center was organized under USC’s university operations, rather than as an extension of its hospitals and medical schools. Complaints against Dr. Tyndall were treated as employment matters and followed an investigation process that did not include peer review, given that the student health center did not have a peer review body. In turn, MBC was not made aware of action taken against Dr. Tyndall by USC through one of the mandatory reporting requirements contained in BPC Sections 805 or 805.01.
- Arguments in Support. Supporters write that “Given the more invasive nature of pelvic examinations, and recent horrific tales of abuse during these exams, it has become apparent that patients would benefit from advance information about what to expect during a pelvic exam. AB 1030 will ensure that female patients receive the information they need to in order to identify, and hopefully prevent, instances of severe misconduct.”
The Medical Board of California writes that the requirement in the bill for a physician to provide information may help to prevent sexual misconduct and ensure that instances of misconduct are reported to the Board.
- Arguments in Opposition. The American Congress of Obstetricians & Gynecologists - District IX (ACOG) and California Academy of Family Physicians of are opposed to this bill unless it is amended. The groups write that “while we appreciate the author’s intent and willingness to amend the bill to address some of our concerns, AB 1030 still contains problematic language that compels our opposition. We agree that women should be properly informed of what to expect during a pelvic examination and absolutely encourage dialogue between a physician and the patient. However, requiring that such information be verified by a signature and placed in the patient’s medical record is both burdensome and unnecessary when the goal is to ensure the patient is properly informed. We continue to believe there are more effective approaches to providing women with this information. These approaches include incorporating the information into students’ comprehensive sexual health education curriculum and/or giving the information to health plans to distribute to their enrollees with adequate time prior to the first exam so the enrollee may research and develop thoughtful questions. Providing the information immediately before the exam at the clinic will not adequately prepare the patient and will only serve to cause anxiety and increase unnecessary tension between the patient and physician. However, if a pamphlet must be required, we ask that it not include the additional burden of collecting a signature and requiring it be placed in the medical record. Increasingly, physicians feel burdened by administrative tasks that do not appear to add value to patient care and are unrelated to the reasons they chose their professions. This disconnect between their passion for patient care and their daily tasks has been identified as a key contributor to distress — leading to alienation, isolation, depersonalization, cynicism, emotional, exhaustion and burnout. These problems are real and despite even the most well intended legislation, they cannot be ignored. Therefore, we are asking for an amendment to remove the signature and medical record registration requirement from the bill.”
One individual, a former patient of Dr. Tyndall who is now a physician, believes that the signature requirement should be removed from this bill, noting how difficult it was to come forward about her experience. She is concerned about the signature requirement in this bill which will “make it even more onerous for victims to come forward; it adds yet another thing we as young women become responsible for. If I had signed a piece of paper stating that I knew the components of a normal pelvic exam – whether I had actually read the document or not – and the same thing had happened despite my signing the form, it would be near impossible to keep from blaming myself for letting it happen anyway. It would be impossible not to think of how anyone defending a rapist or assaulter would point to this paper and say ‘Well, look, she signed this paper saying she knew what was normal, why didn’t she stop him or step forward sooner?’”
- Drafting Questions, Policy Questions and Suggested Amendments.
Should the bill specify that information be provided in a language understood by the patient? United States Census Bureau data from 2017 found that more than 40 percent of Californians speak a language other than English at home and nearly one in five Californians age five and older are considered limited English proficient (LEP), meaning they speak English less than “very well.” California ranks first among all states in both of these categories.
The Dymally-Alatorre Bilingual Services Act (Dymally-Alatorre, Government Code Section 7290 et seq) ensures that all California residents, including those who are limited English proficient (LEP), have equal access to public services. Dymally-Alatorre requires every state and local agency to have a sufficient number of qualified bilingual staff and translated written materials so that the LEP population they serve are able to effectively access and communicate with government.
This bill is modeled after an existing provision of law, BPC § 2249, which requires physicians to provide information about gynecological cancers “in layperson’s language and in a language understood by the patient” yet does not include the same language that could further assist patients, including California’s significant LEP population, in understanding the information contained in the pamphlet. The Author may wish to ensure the pamphlet is written in layperson’s language and in a language understood by the patient at the very least.
Should the bill be limited to physicians and surgeons subject to the Medical Practice Act? This bill requires “A physician and surgeon primarily responsible for providing a patient an annual gynecological examination” to provide the information pamphlet about pelvic exams. Yet a number of other licensees, like nurse practitioners and certified nurse midwives provide these services, and are likely the individuals primarily responsible for providing annual gynecological examinations for millions of Californians. In order to reflect the practitioners providing gynecological services to women throughout the state, the Author may wish to specify that an individual licensed under Division 2 of the BPC, acting within their scope of practice, according to standardized protocols where they exist, and in conformity with the standard of care for the profession, is required to comply with the requirements established by this bill.
Should the provider be required to obtain a signature or is there another appropriate professional who can do this? How does one determine if a patient “understood” the information contained in the pamphlet, as this bill requires? This bill mandates that a physician and surgeon “shall…provide the patient with the informational pamphlet” and “shall have the patient sign and date a form confirming that the patient has received the informational pamphlet and understood the contents before the first pelvic examination”. Given the nature of health care delivery settings, within which various trained allied health personnel may play a role in providing information to patients, and in order to better reflect the reality of how patients receive the pamphlet, while also recognizing that the bill does not specify what the form should look like and how it should be developed, the bill should be amended to remove the requirement that the licensee provide the information and that the licensee have a patient sign and date a form confirming that they received information and understood that information.
Establishing a threshold that a provider has to meet in order to determine whether a patient understands the material presented, as this bill requires, particularly in light of the issue noted above related to language, is difficult to comply with and should be removed from the bill.
The bill should be amended according to the following:
On page 3, strike lines 35-40; on page 4, strike lines 1-6 and replace with:
(b) (1) Prior to their first pelvic examination, a patient shall be provided the informational pamphlet developed pursuant to Section 2248.9 and acknowledgment of receipt shall be signed and maintained as part of that patient’s medical record.
SUPPORT AND OPPOSITION:
Support:
California Health Coalition Advocacy
Consumer Attorneys of California
Medical Board of California
Opposition:
American Congress of Obstetricians & Gynecologists - District IX
California Academy of Family Physicians
One individual, a former patient of Dr. Tyndall
-- END --
SENATE COMMITTEE ON
BUSINESS, PROFESSIONS AND ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT
Senator Steven Glazer, Chair
2019 - 2020 Regular
Bill No: AB 1030 Hearing Date: June 24, 2019
Author: | Calderon | ||
Version: |
| ||
Urgency: | Fiscal: | ||
Consultant: | |||
Subject: Pelvic examinations: informational pamphlet
SUMMARY: Requires a physician to provide a patient with a pamphlet, created by the Medical Board of California (MBC) in coordination with specified stakeholders, about appropriate pelvic exams prior to their first pelvic exam with that physician. Requires a physician to obtain a patient’s signature on a form confirming that the patient received the informational pamphlet and understood the contents.
Existing law:
- Requires the State Department of Health Services (now known as the Department of Health Care Services) to approve and send an updated copy of a standardized written summary on alternative methods of treatment for prostate cancer (concerning the advantages, disadvantages, risks, and descriptions, of procedures with regard to medically viable and efficacious alternative methods of treatment of prostate cancer) to the Medical Board of California (MBC) every time the summary is modified and requires MBC to make the updated summary available to its licensees. Specifies that the summary be in layman’s language and in a language understood by patients. Urges physicians and surgeons to make the summary available to patients when appropriate. (Business and Professions Code (BPC) § 2248.5)
- Requires a physician and surgeon primarily responsible for providing a patient an annual gynecological examination to provide that patient, during the annual examination, a standardized summary containing a description of the symptoms and appropriate methods of diagnoses for gynecological cancers. The summary must be in layperson’s language and in a language understood by the patient. States that a physician and surgeon who violates this requirement may be cited and assessed an administrative fine upon the second and subsequent complaints against a physician and surgeon for not providing the summary. (BPC § 2249)
- Requires a prescriber, for minor patients, prior to directly dispensing or issuing a prescription for a controlled substance containing an opioid, to discuss information, including the risks of addiction and overdose associated with the use of opioids, the increased risk of addiction to an individual who is suffering from both mental and substance abuse disorders, and the danger of taking an opioid with a benzodiazepine, alcohol, or another central nervous system depressant. HSC Section 11158.1
- Requires a physician and surgeon, upon a diagnosis of breast cancer, to give a patient a standardized written summary in layperson’s language and in a language understood by the patient, developed by the Department of Health Care Services, with the recommendations of the DHCS Cancer Advisory Council, informing the patient of the advantages, disadvantages, risks, and descriptions of the procedures with regard to medically viable and efficacious alternative methods of treatment for breast cancer. Requires a physician and surgeon to note on the patient’s chart that they have given the patient the written summary. Authorizes a physician and surgeon to choose to provide the summary prior to a screening or biopsy for breast cancer upon a patient’s request, or at the discretion of the physician and surgeon in appropriate cases, including, but not limited to, instances when a patient has demonstrated risk factors, has a family history of breast cancer, or is otherwise susceptible. Specifies that failure to provide the summary constitutes unprofessional conduct. (HSC § 109275)
- Until January 1, 2025, requires health facilities where mammography is performed, if a patient is categorized by the facility as having dense breasts, as specified, to provide a notice informing the patient that they have dense breasts. (HSC § 123222.3)
This bill:
- Requires, effective one month after MBC creates a pamphlet containing information about pelvic exams, a physician primarily responsible for providing a patient an annual gynecological examination to provide a patient with the pamphlet prior to their first pelvic exam with that physician. Requires a physician to obtain a patient’s signature on a form that must be kept as part of the patient’s medical record confirming that the patient received the informational pamphlet and understood the contents.
- Specifies that MBC, on or before July 1, 2020, in coordination with the American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists (ACOG), the California Medical Association (CMA), and the California Academy of Family Physicians (CAFP) must develop a pamphlet that includes, but is not limited to: what a pelvic exam is and how it is properly performed; if applicable, a description of other relevant exams; privacy expectations, including that privacy should be provided for the patient both when undressing and dressing and that a gown or a drape should be provided; an explanation of what a speculum is and how it should be properly used during an examination; that gloves should be worn by the practitioner during the examination and; a telephone number for MBC where a patient may report any misconduct that the patient feels may have occurred.
- Specifies that the pamphlet must be posted as a printable file on MBC’s website, made available for order as a printed deliverable, or both.
FISCAL EFFECT: This bill is keyed fiscal by Legislative Counsel. According to the Assembly Committee on Appropriations analysis dated April 24, 2019, the bill will result in minor and absorbable costs to MBC to create the required pamphlet and minor and absorbable information technology costs to the Department of Consumer Affairs to track enforcement.
COMMENTS:
- Purpose. The Author is the Sponsor of this bill. According to the Author, “current law does not require any information be provided to patients prior to their first gynecological pelvic exam. Given the more invasive nature of pelvic examinations, and recent horrific tales of abuse during these exams, it has become apparent that patients would benefit from advance information about what to expect during a pelvic exam.”
The Author cites the example of recent events and allegations of misconduct by Dr. George Tyndall at the University of Southern California, noted below, in explaining the need for this bill. According to the Author, “though the Tyndall case garnered attention because of the educational setting and the astounding number of victims that have come forward, it is, unfortunately, not an isolated event. After reviewing the Medical Board of California’s disciplinary decisions from the last five years alone, there have been numerous other physicians who have had their licenses placed on probation or revoked entirely for sexual misconduct that occurred during a pelvic exam. AB 1030 will empower patients by giving them much needed information. AB 1030 will ensure that female patients receive the information they need to in order to identify, and hopefully prevent, instances of severe misconduct.”
- Recent Events and Allegations of Misconduct. In 2018, the Senate Committee on Business, Professions and Economic Development held a hearing, Sexual Misconduct Reporting in the Medical Profession: Missed Opportunities to Protect Patients, to explore whether licensed health professionals who fail to meet established standards are discovered, reviewed and disciplined, if necessary, in a timely manner.
Discussion at the hearing centered on recent events at the University of Southern California (USC) where a physician employed by USC’s student health clinic was accused of sexual misconduct. According to information provided by USC, In June 2016, their Office of Equity and Diversity received a complaint from a student health center staff member about Dr. George Tyndall, a gynecologist at the health center. Dr. Tyndall was placed on administrative leave while an investigation was conducted. During that investigation, outside medical reviewers concluded that the manner in which Dr. Tyndall performed physical exams did not meet current practice standards and that he made inappropriate remarks to patients, in some cases during the examination process. The investigation also brought to light complaints about Dr. Tyndall that had been received in prior years but were managed independently by the director of the student health center. USC filed a complaint with MBC about Dr. Tyndall in 2017.
At the time, the student health center was organized under USC’s university operations, rather than as an extension of its hospitals and medical schools. Complaints against Dr. Tyndall were treated as employment matters and followed an investigation process that did not include peer review, given that the student health center did not have a peer review body. In turn, MBC was not made aware of action taken against Dr. Tyndall by USC through one of the mandatory reporting requirements contained in BPC Sections 805 or 805.01.
- Arguments in Support. Supporters write that “Given the more invasive nature of pelvic examinations, and recent horrific tales of abuse during these exams, it has become apparent that patients would benefit from advance information about what to expect during a pelvic exam. AB 1030 will ensure that female patients receive the information they need to in order to identify, and hopefully prevent, instances of severe misconduct.”
The Medical Board of California writes that the requirement in the bill for a physician to provide information may help to prevent sexual misconduct and ensure that instances of misconduct are reported to the Board.
- Arguments in Opposition. The American Congress of Obstetricians & Gynecologists - District IX (ACOG) and California Academy of Family Physicians of are opposed to this bill unless it is amended. The groups write that “while we appreciate the author’s intent and willingness to amend the bill to address some of our concerns, AB 1030 still contains problematic language that compels our opposition. We agree that women should be properly informed of what to expect during a pelvic examination and absolutely encourage dialogue between a physician and the patient. However, requiring that such information be verified by a signature and placed in the patient’s medical record is both burdensome and unnecessary when the goal is to ensure the patient is properly informed. We continue to believe there are more effective approaches to providing women with this information. These approaches include incorporating the information into students’ comprehensive sexual health education curriculum and/or giving the information to health plans to distribute to their enrollees with adequate time prior to the first exam so the enrollee may research and develop thoughtful questions. Providing the information immediately before the exam at the clinic will not adequately prepare the patient and will only serve to cause anxiety and increase unnecessary tension between the patient and physician. However, if a pamphlet must be required, we ask that it not include the additional burden of collecting a signature and requiring it be placed in the medical record. Increasingly, physicians feel burdened by administrative tasks that do not appear to add value to patient care and are unrelated to the reasons they chose their professions. This disconnect between their passion for patient care and their daily tasks has been identified as a key contributor to distress — leading to alienation, isolation, depersonalization, cynicism, emotional, exhaustion and burnout. These problems are real and despite even the most well intended legislation, they cannot be ignored. Therefore, we are asking for an amendment to remove the signature and medical record registration requirement from the bill.”
The California Medical Association (CMA) advises that while the organization appreciates the Author’s intent to ensure that information is shared with each patient regarding pelvic examinations, “we strongly believe the signature requirement is inconsistent with other policy related to information sharing between a patient and physician and would have unintended consequences.” According to CMA, “this bill forces patients to consent that they have understood the information that is shared in the pamphlet prior to a pelvic exam being conducted. This is problematic for the physician but more importantly it could be problematic to the patient. If a patient has been forced to consent, through the signing of an informational pamphlet, they may be less likely to speak out if something makes them feel uncomfortable. Furthermore, if they choose not to sign the pamphlet, presumably they would be denied the exam. Pelvic and gynecological exams are extremely important to women’s health and this pamphlet puts patients in a position of being forced to sign and consent that they understand how an exam should be conducted. This is unnecessary and burdensome. Informational pamphlets are important, but they should be used to provide information, not trap patients into consenting to receive important medical care.”
One individual, a former patient of Dr. Tyndall who is now a physician, believes that the signature requirement should be removed from this bill, noting how difficult it was to come forward about her experience. She is concerned about the signature requirement in this bill which will “make it even more onerous for victims to come forward; it adds yet another thing we as young women become responsible for. If I had signed a piece of paper stating that I knew the components of a normal pelvic exam – whether I had actually read the document or not – and the same thing had happened despite my signing the form, it would be near impossible to keep from blaming myself for letting it happen anyway. It would be impossible not to think of how anyone defending a rapist or assaulter would point to this paper and say ‘Well, look, she signed this paper saying she knew what was normal, why didn’t she stop him or step forward sooner?’”
- Drafting Questions, Policy Questions and Suggested Amendments.
Should the bill specify that information be provided in a language understood by the patient? United States Census Bureau data from 2017 found that more than 40 percent of Californians speak a language other than English at home and nearly one in five Californians age five and older are considered limited English proficient (LEP), meaning they speak English less than “very well.” California ranks first among all states in both of these categories.
The Dymally-Alatorre Bilingual Services Act (Dymally-Alatorre, Government Code Section 7290 et seq) ensures that all California residents, including those who are limited English proficient (LEP), have equal access to public services. Dymally-Alatorre requires every state and local agency to have a sufficient number of qualified bilingual staff and translated written materials so that the LEP population they serve are able to effectively access and communicate with government.
This bill is modeled after an existing provision of law, BPC § 2249, which requires physicians to provide information about gynecological cancers “in layperson’s language and in a language understood by the patient” yet does not include the same language that could further assist patients, including California’s significant LEP population, in understanding the information contained in the pamphlet. The Author may wish to ensure the pamphlet is written in layperson’s language and in a language understood by the patient at the very least.
Should the bill be limited to physicians and surgeons subject to the Medical Practice Act? This bill requires “A physician and surgeon primarily responsible for providing a patient an annual gynecological examination” to provide the information pamphlet about pelvic exams. Yet a number of other licensees, like nurse practitioners and certified nurse midwives provide these services, and are likely the individuals primarily responsible for providing annual gynecological examinations for millions of Californians. In order to reflect the practitioners providing gynecological services to women throughout the state, the Author may wish to specify that an individual licensed under Division 2 of the BPC, acting within their scope of practice, according to standardized protocols where they exist, and in conformity with the standard of care for the profession, is required to comply with the requirements established by this bill.
Should the provider be required to obtain a signature or is there another appropriate professional who can do this? How does one determine if a patient “understood” the information contained in the pamphlet, as this bill requires? This bill mandates that a physician and surgeon “shall…provide the patient with the informational pamphlet” and “shall have the patient sign and date a form confirming that the patient has received the informational pamphlet and understood the contents before the first pelvic examination”. Given the nature of health care delivery settings, within which various trained allied health personnel may play a role in providing information to patients, and in order to better reflect the reality of how patients receive the pamphlet, while also recognizing that the bill does not specify what the form should look like and how it should be developed, the bill should be amended to remove the requirement that the licensee provide the information and that the licensee have a patient sign and date a form confirming that they received information and understood that information.
Establishing a threshold that a provider has to meet in order to determine whether a patient understands the material presented, as this bill requires, particularly in light of the issue noted above related to language, is difficult to comply with and should be removed from the bill.
The bill should be amended according to the following:
On page 3, strike lines 35-40; on page 4, strike lines 1-6 and replace with:
(b) (1) Prior to their first pelvic examination, a patient shall be provided the informational pamphlet developed pursuant to Section 2248.9 and acknowledgment of receipt shall be signed and maintained as part of that patient’s medical record.
SUPPORT AND OPPOSITION:
Support:
California Health Coalition Advocacy
Consumer Attorneys of California
Medical Board of California
Opposition:
American Congress of Obstetricians & Gynecologists - District IX
California Academy of Family Physicians
California Medical Association
One individual, a former patient of Dr. Tyndall
-- END --
ASSEMBLY THIRD READING
ATR Bill Id:AB 1030
Author:(Calderon and Petrie-Norris)
As Amended Ver:March 26, 2019
Majority vote
SUMMARY:
Requires the Medical Board of California (MBC), on or before July 1, 2020, in coordination with the American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists (ACOG), to develop an informational pamphlet, as specified, that must be given to patients undergoing gynecological examinations. Requires a doctor to require their patient to sign and date a form attesting that the patient has received the informational pamphlet and understood the contents before the first gynecological examination with that doctor.
Major Provisions
COMMENTS:
For nearly 30 years, the University of Southern California student health clinic had one full-time gynecologist: Dr. George Tyndall. He treated tens of thousands of female students, many of them teenagers seeing a gynecologist for the first time. Complaints regarding his behavior began in the 1990s, when co-workers alleged he was improperly photographing students' genitals. In the years that followed, patients and nursing staff accused him repeatedly of "creepy" behavior, including touching women inappropriately during pelvic exams and making sexually suggestive remarks about their bodies. Still, Tyndall was allowed to continue practicing. It was not until 2016, when a nurse went to the campus rape crisis center, that he was suspended.
Since then, approximately 500 current and former students have accused Tyndall of misconduct. Several lawsuits have been filed at the state and federal level, going into graphic detail about Tyndall's alleged practices, such as fully nude exams that were not medically necessary and digital penetration that did not resemble a routine gynecological exam.
According to the Author:
This bill will empower patients by giving them much needed information. The author states this bill will ensure that female patients receive the information they need to in order to identify, and hopefully prevent, instances of severe misconduct. The author notes that this bill requires the MBC and the ACOG to develop an informational pamphlet for patients undergoing a gynecological pelvic examination, with basic information regarding how the procedure should be properly performed, privacy and sanitary expectations, and contact information in order to report any instances of misconduct.
Arguments in Support:
California Health Coalition Advocacy supports this bill and states that given the invasive nature of pelvic examinations, and recent horrific tales of abuse during these exams, it has become apparent that patients would benefit from advance information about what to expect during a pelvic exam. This bill will ensure that female patients receive the information they need to in order to identify, and, hopefully, prevent, instances of severe misconduct.
Arguments in Opposition:
California Right to Life Committee, Inc. is opposed to this bill, contending it inadvertently benefits Planned Parenthood.
FISCAL COMMENTS:
According to the Assembly Appropriations Committee, minor and absorbable costs to the MBC to create the required pamphlet (Medical Board Contingent Fund), and minor and absorbable information technology costs to the Department of Consumer Affairs to track enforcement (Medical Board Contingent Fund; Osteopathic Medical Board Contingent Fund).
VOTES:
ASM HEALTH: 15-0-0
YES: Wood, Mayes, Aguiar-Curry, Bigelow, Bonta, Burke, Wicks, Flora, Limón, McCarty, Nazarian, Ramos, Rodriguez, Santiago, Waldron
ASM APPROPRIATIONS: 17-0-1
YES: Gonzalez, Bigelow, Bloom, Bonta, Brough, Calderon, Carrillo, Chau, Diep, Eggman, Fong, Gabriel, Jones-Sawyer, Maienschein, Petrie-Norris, Quirk, Robert Rivas
ABS, ABST OR NV: Obernolte
UPDATED:
VERSION: March 26, 2019
CONSULTANT: Lara Flynn / HEALTH / (916) 319-2097 FN: 0000284
Date of Hearing: April 24, 2019
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Lorena Gonzalez, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 1030
Author:(Calderon) – As Amended Ver:March 26, 2019
Policy Committee: | Health | Vote: | 15 - 0 |
Urgency: No State Mandated Local Program: No Reimbursable: No
SUMMARY:
This bill requires the Medical Board of California (MBC), on or before July 1, 2020, in coordination with the American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists (ACOG), to develop an informational pamphlet, as specified, that must be given to patients undergoing gynecological examinations.
It also requires a doctor to require their patient to sign and date a form attesting that the patient has received the informational pamphlet and understood the contents before the first gynecological examination with that doctor.
FISCAL EFFECT:
- Minor and absorbable costs to the Medical Board of California to create the required pamphlet (Medical Board Contingent Fund).
- Minor and absorbable information technology costs to the Department of Consumer Affairs to track enforcement (Medical Board Contingent Fund; Osteopathic Medical Board Contingent Fund).
COMMENTS:
- Purpose. The author states this bill will ensure female patients receive the information they need to in order to identify and prevent instances of severe misconduct. In arguing for this bill’s necessity, the author cites a recent case at of a gynecologist at the University of Southern California (USC) student health clinic, Dr. George Tyndall, who is alleged to have sexually abused hundreds of young women for decades under the guise of routine gynecological exams.
- Background. According the MBC, 70 physicians were disciplined for sexual misconduct with a patient during treatment or examination between 2013 and 2018.
Current law requires doctors to provide patients, during annual exams, a standardized summary containing a description of the symptoms and appropriate methods of diagnoses for gynecological cancers. This bill would expand upon that existing informational requirement.
- Support. The Consumer Attorneys of California (CAOC) and California Health Coalition Advocacy (CHCA) support this bill. CHCA states this bill will ensure that female patients receive the information they need to in order to identify and, hopefully, prevent, instances of severe misconduct.
- Opposition (Unless Amended). ACOG is opposed to this bill unless it is amended and states that it recommends the initial gynecological visit for screening take place between the ages of 13 and 15 years. ACOG notes this initial visit provides an excellent opportunity for the OB-GYN to start a patient-physician relationship, build trust, and counsel patients and parents regarding healthy behavior while dispelling myths and fears. ACOG contends that codifying a specific list of information a physician must provide in a pamphlet to the patient immediately prior to the exam is problematic and fails to consider the uniqueness of each patient and the evolution of medicine.
- Opposition. California Right to Life Committee, Inc. (CRLC) is opposed to this bill, contending it inadvertently benefits Planned Parenthood.
Analysis Prepared by: Lisa Murawski / APPR. / (916) 319-2081
Date of Hearing: April 9, 2019
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON HEALTH
Jim Wood, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 1030
Author:Calderon – As Amended Ver:March 26, 2019
SUBJECT: Gynecological examinations: informational pamphlet.
SUMMARY: Requires the Medical Board of California (MBC), on or before July 1, 2020, in coordination with the American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists (ACOG), to develop an informational pamphlet for patients undergoing gynecological examinations. Specifically, this bill:
- Requires the information in the pamphlet to include, but is not limited to, all of the following:
- What a Pap smear is and how it is properly performed;
- The recommended age for a patient receiving a pelvic exam and/or a Pap smear and how often a pelvic exam and/or Pap smear should be performed;
- Privacy expectations, including that privacy should be provide for the patient both when undressing and dressing and that a gown should be worn during the entire examination;
- An explanation of what a speculum is and how it should be properly used during an examination;
- That gloves should be worn by the practitioner during the examination;
- The duration of a pelvic exam and Pap smear; and,
- A telephone number for the MBC at which a patient may report any misconduct that the patient feels may have occurred.
- Requires a physician and surgeon primarily responsible for providing a patient an annual gynecological examination to, prior to a patient’s first gynecological pelvic examination, provide the patient with the informational pamphlet described in 1) above, and have the patient sign and date a form attesting that the patient has received the informational pamphlet and understood the contents.
- Requires the forms showing receipt of the information to be kept as part of the patient’s medical record.
EXISTING LAW:
- Establishes the MBC within the Department of Consumer Affairs to enforce the licensing and regulatory provisions relating to physicians and surgeons.
- Requires a physician primarily responsible for providing a patient an annual gynecological examination to provide, during the annual examination, a standardized summary containing a description of the symptoms and appropriate methods of diagnoses for gynecological cancers. Requires the information to be provided in a layperson’s language and in a language understood by the patient.
- Allows the requirements in 2) above to be met using existing publication or pamphlets developed by nationally recognize cancer organizations or by the State Department of Health Care Services.
- Authorizes an administrative fine upon the second and subsequent complaints against a physician who fails to provide the pamphlet described in 2) above.
- Requires MBC to investigate complaints from the public, other licensees, health care facilities or from others as specified.
- Requires MBC to prioritize its investigative and prosecutorial resources to ensure that physicians and surgeons representing the greatest threat of harm are identified and disciplined expeditiously.
- Sets forth what the MBC may do in disciplining a physician (e.g., revoke or suspend a license, place a physician on probation, etc.); further states that a licensee can "Have any other action taken in relation to discipline as part of an order as the board or administrative law judge may deem proper."
FISCAL EFFECT: This bill has not yet been analyzed by a fiscal committee.
COMMENTS:
- PURPOSE OF THIS BILL. According to the author, this bill will empower patients by giving them much needed information. The author states this bill will ensure that female patients receive the information they need to in order to identify, and hopefully prevent, instances of severe misconduct. The author notes that this bill requires the MBC and the ACOG to develop an informational pamphlet for patients undergoing a gynecological pelvic examination, with basic information regarding how the procedure should be properly performed, privacy and sanitary expectations, and contact information in order to report any instances of misconduct.
- BACKGROUND.
- Recent events. For nearly 30 years, the University of Southern California (USC) student health clinic had one full-time gynecologist: Dr. George Tyndall. He treated tens of thousands of female students, many of them teenagers seeing a gynecologist for the first time. Complaints regarding his behavior began in the 1990s, when co-workers alleged he was improperly photographing students’ genitals. In the years that followed, patients and nursing staff accused him repeatedly of “creepy” behavior, including touching women inappropriately during pelvic exams and making sexually suggestive remarks about their bodies. Still, Tyndall was allowed to continue practicing. It was not until 2016, when a nurse went to the campus rape crisis center, that he was suspended.
Since then, approximately 500 current and former students have accused Tyndall of misconduct. Several lawsuits have been filed at the state and federal level, going into graphic detail about Tyndall’s alleged practices, such as fully nude exams that were not medically necessary and digital penetration that did not resemble a routine gynecological exam.
While no criminal charges have yet been filed against Tyndall, prosecutors in the Los Angeles County district attorney's sex crimes division are currently reviewing dozens of cases for possible sex-crimes charges. According to press reports, a grand jury is currently hearing evidence against Dr. Tyndall. USC recently reached a $215 million settlement in principle on a class-action lawsuit with victims of Tyndall in October of last year.
- MBC disciplinary actions. According the MBC, 70 physicians were disciplined for sexual misconduct with a patient during treatment or examination between 2013 and 2018.
- Existing resources for patients prior to a pelvic exam. Many organizations have developed informational brochures or provide information on their website regarding what to expect during a first gynecologic visit including the Centers for Disease Control, Planned Parenthood, and ACOG. ACOG’s teen-specific information answers the following questions:
- When should I have my first gynecologic visit?
- Is it normal to be nervous before the first visit?
- What should I expect at the first gynecologic visit?
- What exams are performed?
- What happens during a general physical exam?
- What happens during an eternal genital exam?
- What are the pelvic exam and Pap test?
- What are vaccinations?
- What special concerns can be discussed with my ob-gyn? and,
- What can I do to stay healthy?
The document also provides a glossary of terms, and includes the information that the physician should be wearing gloves. The only information required by this bill, that is not already included on the document is the information regarding privacy expectations and the telephone number for the MBC.
- SUPPORT. California Health Coalition Advocacy supports this bill and states that given the invasive nature of pelvic examinations, and recent horrific tales of abuse during these exams, it has become apparent that patients would benefit from advance information about what to
expect during a pelvic exam. This bill will ensure that female patients receive the information they need to in order to identify, and, hopefully, prevent, instances of severe misconduct.
The Consumer Attorneys of California (CAOC) support this bill noting that in May of 2018, the Los Angeles Times broke the story of a cover up by USC regarding sexual misconduct of student patients by Dr. George Tyndall, the sole full-time gynecologist employed by the USC Student Health Center since 1989. Despite decades of complaints by former patients, USC consistently and pathologically ignored red flags and only belatedly conducted an investigation in 2016. Afterwards, Tyndall was simply and quietly asked to resign. CAOC states that in recent months hundreds of women have come forward to recount their sexual assaults – some dating back to 1989 – Tyndall. Many victims were either very young, foreign-born, or women of color. Most of these women did not fully comprehend that Dr. Tyndall’s conduct was not “treatment” but instead was sexual assault, or did not understand that their emotional injuries were caused by Dr. Tyndall’s misconduct.
- OPPOSITION. The California Right to Life Committee, Inc. (CRLC) is opposed to this bill and states that this bill purports to provide areas of health care for women in an informational pamphlet, whereas, in reality, it is promoting the work of ACOG, which works in conjunction with Planned Parenthood. CRLC notes that it would appear that this is another attempt to benefit Planned Parenthood with indirect advertising and that public monies should not be used in this manner.
- OPPOSE UNLESS AMENDED. ACOG is opposed to this bill unless it is amended and states that they recommend that the initial gynecological visit for screening should take place between the ages of 13 and 15 years. ACOG notes that this initial visit provides an excellent opportunity for the OB-GYN to start a patient-physician relationship, build trust, and counsel patients and parents regarding healthy behavior while dispelling myths and fears. ACOG contends that codifying a specific list of information that a physician must provide in a pamphlet to the patient immediately prior to the exam is problematic and fails to take into account the uniqueness of each patient and the evolution of medicine. ACOG states that requiring the pamphlet to be given by a physician to a patient, and signed by the patient, at the start of their first visit interferes with the patient-physician relationship and does nothing to properly prepare the patient on the exam itself.
- PREVIOUS LEGISLATION.
- SB 1080 (Bowen), Chapter 730, Statutes of 2007, authorized an administrative fine upon the second and subsequent complaints against a physician who fails to provide a pamphlet with a standardized summary containing a description of the symptoms and appropriate methods of diagnoses for gynecological cancers.
- AB 833 (Ortiz), Chapter 754, Statutes of 1997, required the medical care provider responsible for providing a patient an annual gynecological examination to provide, during the annual examination, a standardized summary containing a description of the symptoms and appropriate methods of diagnoses for gynecological cancers.
7) SUGGESTED AMENDEMENTS. As this bill moves forward, the authors may wish to amend this bill to require the pamphlets be provided in the preferred language of the patient.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
California Health Coalition Advocacy
Consumer Attorneys of California
Opposition
California Right to Life Committee, Inc.
Analysis Prepared by: Lara Flynn / HEALTH / (916) 319-2097
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):