AB 1032: Ticket sellers: equitable ticket buying process: use or sale of services.
- Session Year: 2019-2020
- House: Assembly
- Latest Version Date: 2019-07-12
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Jul 12, 2019 | Chaptered by Secretary of State - Chapter 105, Statutes of 2019. |
| Jul 12, 2019 | Approved by the Governor. |
| Jul 8, 2019 | Enrolled and presented to the Governor at 3:30 p.m. |
| Jul 1, 2019 | In Assembly. Ordered to Engrossing and Enrolling. |
| Jul 1, 2019 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Assembly. |
| Jun 25, 2019 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| Jun 24, 2019 | From committee: Be ordered to second reading pursuant to Senate Rule 28.8. |
| Jun 3, 2019 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 9. Noes 0.) (June 3). Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| May 22, 2019 | Referred to Com. on B., P. & E.D. |
| May 9, 2019 | In Senate. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. |
| May 9, 2019 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Senate. |
| May 2, 2019 | Read second time. Ordered to Consent Calendar. |
| May 1, 2019 | From committee: Do pass. To Consent Calendar. (Ayes 18. Noes 0.) (May 1). |
| Apr 24, 2019 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 11. Noes 0.) (April 23). Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Apr 10, 2019 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on P. & C.P. (Ayes 7. Noes 0.) (April 10). Re-referred to Com. on P. & C.P. |
| Apr 4, 2019 | Re-referred to Com. on A.,E.,S.,T., & I.M. |
| Apr 3, 2019 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to Com. on A.,E.,S.,T., & I.M. Read second time and amended. |
| Mar 7, 2019 | Referred to Coms. on A.,E.,S.,T., & I.M. and P. & C.P. |
| Feb 22, 2019 | From printer. May be heard in committee March 24. |
| Feb 21, 2019 | Read first time. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Jul 1, 2019 | Assembly 3rd Reading AB1032 Quirk By Pan | Senate Floor |
Passed |
|
| Jun 3, 2019 | Do pass, but first be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Senate Standing Committee on Business, Professions and Economic Development |
Passed |
|
| May 9, 2019 | AB 1032 Quirk Consent Calendar Second Day Regular Session | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| May 1, 2019 | Do pass. To Consent Calendar. | Assembly Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Apr 23, 2019 | Do pass and be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Assembly Standing Committee on Privacy and Consumer Protection |
Passed |
|
| Apr 10, 2019 | Do pass and be re-referred to the Committee on [Privacy and Consumer Protection] | Assembly Standing Committee on Arts, Entertainment, Sports, Tourism, and Internet Media |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | AB 1032 |
THIRD READING
Bill No: AB 1032
Amended: 4/3/19 in Assembly
SENATE BUS., PROF. & ECON. DEV. COMMITTEE: 9-0, 6/3/19
AYES: Glazer, Chang, Archuleta, Dodd, Galgiani, Hill, Leyva, Pan, Wilk
SENATE APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE: Senate Rule 28.8
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 76-0, 5/9/19 (Consent) - See last page for vote
SUBJECT: Ticket sellers: equitable ticket buying process: use or sale of services
DIGEST:
This bill clarifies existing prohibitions under the Ticket Sellers Act that are to benefit ticket buyers who are intended “event attendees,” as defined, and expands prohibited conduct to include the use or sale of services to circumvent security measures, access control systems or other control or measures, as specified.
Existing law:
- Regulates ticket sellers (defined as any person who for compensation, commission, or otherwise sells admission tickets to sporting, musical, theatre, or any other entertainment event) including establishing requirements for records of sales and disclosures of seat location, and establishing penalties for violating requirements and prohibitions on certain ticket selling practices. (Business and Professions Code (BPC) § 22500 et. seq.)
- Prohibits the using or selling of software to circumvent a security measure, access control system, or other control or measure that is used to ensure an equitable ticket buying process, as specified. (BPC § 22505.5)
This bill:
- Expands the prohibition in 2) above to include services that may be used to circumvent efforts to ensure an equitable ticket buying process for event attendees.
- Defines “event attendee” as a person who purchases one or more tickets with the intent to attend the event for which the ticket or tickets are purchased.
- States that “a control or measure that is used to ensure an equitable ticket buying process” includes limits on the number of tickets that a person can purchase.
Background
“Bots” and Attempts to Curb Their Use. “Bots” are robotic ticket buying software programs that allow users to quickly buy tickets online. Typically, these are used by unscrupulous actors like ticket scalpers to buy tickets, then turn around and sell the same tickets at increasingly higher prices. Over the past several years, numerous high profile concert ticket sales have been impacted by the presumed use of “bots” in that individuals wait online to purchase tickets while software programs allow their users to jump to the front of the line and purchase large numbers of tickets at one time. This scenario often leads to concerts and other high profile events selling out in a matter of minutes, leaving fans ticketless and forcing them to spend more money to attend an event.
The ticket industry has attempted to combat problems caused by “bots” by employing other technological means, such as “Completely Automated Public Turing tests to tell Computers and Humans Apart” (CAPTCHA), which include phrases and picture tests at the point of sale during the online transaction to differentiate between a human purchaser and a likely computer program. CAPTCHA tests, such as typing characters into a box, are designed to prevent the use of “bots” because the requested task is typically one that can be completed by a person but would be difficult for a robotic software program to accurately perform.
Supporters of efforts to restrict the use of “bots” assert that even these technological efforts are not completely successful because the problem of instant sellouts and increased resale prices for tickets continues to generate complaints from the ticket-buying public. California is one of a number of states to pass legislation imposing bans on “bots” and establishing penalties for those who use these systems.
AB 329 (Pan, Chapter 325, Statutes of 2013) made it a misdemeanor to intentionally use or sell software to circumvent a security measure, access control system, or other control or measure on a ticket seller’s Web site that is used to ensure an equitable ticket buying process. The bill was designed to prevent the use of bots from denying the general public access to the first release of tickets, which generally are sold at a much lower price than the same tickets yield on the secondary market.
TradeDesk. According to Ticketmaster, TradeDesk is the company’s version of an inventory management tool for professional ticket resellers (brokers). Other resellers also have tools to organize a broker’s ticket inventory so the tickets can be priced and listed for sale on various ticket marketplaces, such as StubHub’s product called Ticket Utils or Vivid Seat’s Skybox. These tools serve a legitimate purpose in the marketplace for brokers who may have several sources of tickets, for instance multiple season ticket holders who source team seats (with demand for different sports and each team multiplying the number of sports accounts), accounts with theater venues for plays, and they often use multiple sources for concerts. It is therefore not in-and-of-itself a problematic tool. However, it can be used to circumvent the law.
In the fall of 2018, journalists from the Canadian Broadcasting Corporation and the Toronto Star newspaper reported that TradeDesk assists professional scalpers to resell tickets. Two journalists went undercover with hidden cameras and posed as professional resellers in their interactions with TradeDesk at a trade convention. A TradeDesk sales representative told the journalists that the resellers he works with have multiple Ticketmaster.com accounts apiece (“literally a couple of hundred”), a violation of Ticketmaster's terms of use, through which the resellers can buy large numbers of tickets for resale without facing any repercussion from Ticketmaster. According to the investigation resold tickets are “particularly lucrative” for Ticketmaster because the company reportedly profits from two separate sets of charges collected from the same ticket. “For example,” they write, “if Ticketmaster collects $25.75 on a $209.50 ticket on the initial sale, when the owner posts it for resale for $400 on the site, the company stands to collect an additional $76 on the same ticket.”
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: Yes Local: Yes
California District Attorneys Association
OPPOSITION: (Verified 6/25/19)
None received
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 76-0, 5/9/19
AYES: Aguiar-Curry, Bauer-Kahan, Berman, Bigelow, Bloom, Boerner Horvath, Bonta, Brough, Burke, Calderon, Carrillo, Cervantes, Chau, Chiu, Choi, Chu, Cooley, Cooper, Cunningham, Daly, Diep, Eggman, Flora, Fong, Frazier, Friedman, Gabriel, Gallagher, Cristina Garcia, Eduardo Garcia, Gipson, Gloria, Gonzalez, Gray, Grayson, Holden, Irwin, Jones-Sawyer, Kalra, Kamlager-Dove, Kiley, Lackey, Levine, Limón, Low, Maienschein, Mathis, Mayes, McCarty, Medina, Melendez, Mullin, Muratsuchi, Nazarian, Obernolte, O'Donnell, Patterson, Petrie-Norris, Quirk, Quirk-Silva, Ramos, Reyes, Luz Rivas, Robert Rivas, Rodriguez, Blanca Rubio, Salas, Santiago, Smith, Mark Stone, Ting, Waldron, Weber, Wicks, Wood, Rendon
NO VOTE RECORDED: Arambula, Chen, Dahle, Voepel
Prepared by: Sarah Mason / B., P. & E.D. /
6/26/19 15:44:10
**** END ****
SENATE COMMITTEE ON
BUSINESS, PROFESSIONS AND ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT
Senator Steven Glazer, Chair
2019 - 2020 Regular
Bill No: AB 1032 Hearing Date: June 3, 2019
Author: | Quirk | ||
Version: | April 3, 2019 | ||
Urgency: | No | Fiscal: | Yes |
Consultant: | Sarah Mason | ||
Subject: Ticket sellers: equitable ticket buying process: use or sale of services.
SUMMARY: Clarifies existing prohibitions under the Ticket Sellers Act are to benefit ticket buyers who are intended “event attendees,” as defined, and expands prohibited conduct to include the use or sale of services to circumvent security measures, access control systems or other control or measures, as specified.
Existing law:
- Regulates ticket sellers (defined as any person who for compensation, commission, or otherwise sells admission tickets to sporting, musical, theatre, or any other entertainment event) including establishing requirements for records of sales and disclosures of seat location, and establishing penalties for violating requirements and prohibitions on certain ticket selling practices. (Business and Professions Code (BPC) § 22500 et. seq.)
- Prohibits the using or selling of software to circumvent a security measure, access control system, or other control or measure that is used to ensure an equitable ticket buying process, as specified. (BPC § 22505.5)
This bill:
- Expands the prohibition in 2) above to include services that may be used to circumvent efforts to ensure an equitable ticket buying process for event attendees.
- Defines “event attendee” as a person who purchases one or more tickets with the intent to attend the event for which the ticket or tickets are purchased
- States that “a control or measure that is used to ensure an equitable ticket buying process” includes limits on the number of tickets that a person can purchase.
FISCAL EFFECT: This bill is keyed fiscal by Legislative Counsel. According to the Assembly Committee on Appropriations analysis dated May 1, 2019, this bill will result in potential minor non-reimbursable costs to cities and counties for enforcement, offset to some extent by fine revenues.
COMMENTS:
- Purpose. The Author is the Sponsor of this bill. According to the Author, “AB 1032 aims to prohibit anti-consumer practices enabled by services such as Ticketmaster’s TradeDesk. A July 2018 investigative report found Ticketmaster employees advertising TradeDesk as a means to allow scalpers to circumvent consumer protections in the ticket marketplace, such as limits on the number of tickets purchased. AB 1032 makes it clear that services which can coordinate the actions of hundreds of online accounts are regulated by the Attorney General and District Attorneys, just like bots are.”
- Background.
“Bots” and Attempts to Curb Their Use. “Bots” are robotic ticket buying software programs that allow users to quickly buy tickets online. Typically, these are used by unscrupulous actors like ticket scalpers to buy tickets, then turn around and sell the same tickets at increasingly higher prices. Over the past several years, numerous high profile concert ticket sales have been impacted by the presumed use of “bots” in that individuals wait online to purchase tickets while software programs allow their users to jump to the front of the line and purchase large numbers of tickets at one time. This scenario often leads to concerts and other high profile events selling out in a matter of minutes, leaving fans ticketless and forcing them to spend more money to attend an event.
The ticket industry has attempted to combat problems caused by “bots” by employing other technological means, such as “Completely Automated Public Turing tests to tell Computers and Humans Apart” (CAPTCHA), which include phrases and picture tests at the point of sale during the online transaction to differentiate between a human purchaser and a likely computer program. CAPTCHA tests, such as typing characters into a box, are designed to prevent the use of “bots” because the requested task is typically one that can be completed by a person but would be difficult for a robotic software program to accurately perform.
Supporters of efforts to restrict the use of “bots” assert that even these technological efforts are not completely successful because the problem of instant sellouts and increased resale prices for tickets continues to generate complaints from the ticket-buying public. California is one of a number of states to pass legislation imposing bans on “bots” and establishing penalties for those who use these systems.
AB 329 (Pan, Chapter 325, Statutes of 2013) made it a misdemeanor to intentionally use or sell software to circumvent a security measure, access control system, or other control or measure on a ticket seller’s website that is used to ensure an equitable ticket buying process. The bill was designed to prevent the use of bots from denying the general public access to the first release of tickets, which generally are sold at a much lower price than the same tickets yield on the secondary market.
TradeDesk. According to Ticketmaster, TradeDesk is the company’s version of an inventory management tool for professional ticket resellers (brokers). Other resellers also have tools to organize a broker’s ticket inventory so the tickets can be priced and listed for sale on various ticket marketplaces, such as StubHub’s product called Ticket Utils or Vivid Seat’s Skybox. These tools serve a legitimate purpose in the marketplace for brokers who may have several sources of tickets, for instance multiple season ticket holders who source team seats (with demand for different sports and each team multiplying the number of sports accounts), accounts with theater venues for plays, and they often use multiple sources for concerts. It is therefore not in-and-of-itself a problematic tool. However, it can be used to circumvent the law.
In the fall of 2018, journalists from the Canadian Broadcasting Corporation (CBC) and the Toronto Star newspaper reported that TradeDesk assists professional scalpers to resell tickets. Two journalists went undercover with hidden cameras and posed as professional resellers in their interactions with TradeDesk at a trade convention. A TradeDesk sales representative told the journalists that the resellers he works with have multiple Ticketmaster.com accounts apiece (“literally a couple of hundred”), a violation of Ticketmaster's terms of use, through which the resellers can buy large numbers of tickets for resale without any facing any repercussion from Ticketmaster. According to the investigation resold tickets are “particularly lucrative” for Ticketmaster because the company reportedly profits from two separate sets of charges collected from the same ticket. “For example,” they write, “if Ticketmaster collects $25.75 on a $209.50 ticket on the initial sale, when the owner posts it for resale for $400 on the site, the company stands to collect an additional $76 on the same ticket.”
SUPPORT AND OPPOSITION:
Support:
California District Attorneys Association
Opposition:
None on file as of May 29, 2019.
-- END --
Date of Hearing: May 1, 2019
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Lorena Gonzalez, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 1032
Author:(Quirk) – As Amended Ver:April 3, 2019
Policy Committee: | Arts, Entertainment, Sports, Tourism, and Internet Media | Vote: | 7 - 0 |
Privacy and Consumer Protection | 11 - 0 | ||
|
|
Urgency: No State Mandated Local Program: Yes Reimbursable: No
SUMMARY:
This bill clarifies existing prohibitions intended to ensure an equitable ticket buying process under the Ticket Sellers Act are to benefit ticket buyers who are intended “event attendees,” as defined, and expands prohibited conduct to include the use or sale of services to circumvent security measures, access control systems or other control or measures, as specified.
FISCAL EFFECT:
Potential minor non-reimbursable costs to cities and counties for enforcement, offset to some extent by fine revenues.
COMMENTS:
Background and Purpose. AB 329 (Pan), Chapter 325, Statutes of 2013, attempted to address the unregulated use of robotic ticket buying software (or bots), which allow scalpers to unfairly create instant sellouts of events before the average fan has a chance to buy tickets. These persons subsequently sell tickets they purchased through bots at highly marked-up prices, forcing fans to pay more for tickets when they have not had any fair opportunity to purchase a face-value ticket directly from the ticket issuer or event organizer.
Subsequent legislation has refined these consumer protections. This author-sponsored bill seeks to further ensure that individuals are able to purchase tickets for events at fair prices by expanding the Ticket Sellers Act to also prohibit services (not just software) designed to circumvent measures that are used to ensure an equitable ticket buying process. Specifically, the author indicates this bill is designed to apply to services like Ticketmaster’s TradeDesk platform, which allows brokers to network hundreds of Ticketmaster.com accounts, buy thousands of tickets, and instantly relist those tickets at inflated prices on Stubhub, Vivid Seats or Ticketmaster’s own resale platform.
Analysis Prepared by: Lisa Murawski / APPR. / (916) 319-2081
Date of Hearing: April 23, 2019
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON PRIVACY AND CONSUMER PROTECTION
Ed Chau, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 1032 (
Author:Quirk) – As Amended Ver:April 3, 2019
SUBJECT: Ticket sellers: equitable ticket buying process: use or sale of services.
SUMMARY: This bill would clarify that existing prohibitions intended to ensure an equitable ticket buying process under the Ticket Sellers Act are to benefit ticket buyers who are intended event attendees, as defined, and would the expand prohibited conduct to include the use or sale of services to circumvent security measures, access control systems, or other control or measures, as specified. Specifically, this bill would:
- Provide that it shall be unlawful for a person to intentionally use or sell services to circumvent a security measure, access control system, or other control or measure that is used to ensure an equitable ticket buying process.
- Define a “control measure that is used to ensure an equitable ticket buying process” to include limits on the number of tickets that a person can purchase.
- Define “event attendee” to mean a person who purchases one or more tickets with the intent to attend the event for which the ticket or tickets are purchased, and clarify that an event attendee does not include a ticket seller.
EXISTING LAW:
- Provides that a “ticket seller” is any person who for compensation, commission, or otherwise sells admission tickets to sporting, musical, theatre, or any other entertainment event. (Bus. & Prof. Code Sec. 22503.)
- Provides that a “primary contractor” is the person or organization that is responsible for the event for which tickets are being sold. (Bus. & Prof. Code Sec. 22503.5.)
- Makes it unlawful for a ticket seller to contract for the sale of tickets or accept consideration for the sale of tickets unless the ticket seller meets one or more of the following requirements:
- The ticket seller has the ticket in their possession.
- The ticket seller has a written contract to obtain the offered ticket, as specified.
- The ticket seller informs the purchaser that the seller may not be able to supply the ticket at the contracted price or range of prices, as specified. (Bus. & Prof. Code Sec. 22502.1(a)-(c).)
- Allows acceptance of a deposit from a prospective purchaser as part of an agreement that the ticket seller will make best efforts to obtain a ticket at a specified price or price range and within a specified time. (Bus. & Prof. Code Sec. 22502.1.)
- Makes failure to deliver the tickets within a reasonable time or by a contracted time, at or below the price stated or within the range of prices stated, punishable as a misdemeanor. (Bus. & Prof. Code Sec. 22505.)
- Provides that in addition to other remedies, a ticket seller who fails to supply a ticket at or below a contracted price or within a contracted price range shall be civilly liable to the ticket purchaser for two times the contracted price of the ticket, in addition to any sum expended by the purchaser in nonrefundable expenses for attending or attempting to attend the event in good faith reliance on seat or space availability, and reasonable attorneys’ fees and court costs. (Bus. & Prof. Code Sec. 22502.3.)
- Provides that ticket price of any event which is canceled, postponed, or rescheduled shall be fully refunded to the purchaser by the ticket seller upon request. (Bus. & Prof. Code Sec. 22507.)
- Declares that any deposit on a future event for which tickets are not available shall be refundable. (Bus. & Prof. Code Sec. 22506.)
- Requires that a ticket seller disclose any service charges assessed, as provided. (Bus. & Prof. Code Sec. 22508.)
- Requires that any ticket seller who includes tickets to an event in conjunction with the sale of a tour or event package, as defined, disclose in any advertisements or promotional materials the price charged or allotted for the tickets. (Bus. & Prof. Code Sec. 22509.)
- Allows local agencies to impose local fees or taxes. (Bus. & Prof. Code Sec. 22510.)
- Exempts certain persons, including:
- Any primary contractor or seller of tickets for the primary contractor, as specified (Bus. & Prof. Code Sec. 22503.5);
- Persons who sell six tickets or less to any one single event, provided the tickets are sold off the premises (Bus. & Prof. Code Sec. 22504.);
- Any nonprofit charitable tax-exempt organization selling tickets to an event sponsored by the organization. (Bus. & Prof. Code Sec. 22511.)
- Provides that a violation of any of these provisions constitutes a misdemeanor, and in addition authorizes a civil penalty not to exceed $2,500 for each violation, which may be assessed and recovered in a civil action brought in the name of the people, as specified. (Bus. & Prof. Code Sec. 22500(c).)
- Provides that any person who, without the written permission of the owner or operator of the property on which an entertainment event is to be held or is being held, sells a ticket of admission to the entertainment event, which was obtained for the purpose of resale, at any price which is in excess of the price that is printed or endorsed upon the ticket, while on the grounds of or in the stadium, arena, theater, or other place where an event for which admission tickets are sold is to be held or is being held, is guilty of a misdemeanor. (Pen. Code Sec. 346.)
- Provides that, notwithstanding specified provisions above, it shall be unlawful for a person to intentionally use or sell software to circumvent a security measure, access control system, or other control or measure that is used to ensure an equitable ticket buying process. (Pen. Code Sec. 346.)
FISCAL EFFECT: Unknown
COMMENTS:
- Purpose of the bill: This bill seeks to further ensure that individuals are able to purchase tickets for events at fair prices by expanding the Ticket Sellers Act to also prohibit services (not just software) designed to circumvent measures that are used to ensure an equitable ticket buying process. This bill is author-sponsored.
- Author’s Statement: According to the author:
Illegal bots are limiting Californians ability to attend the events they want. Ticket brokers use bots to rapidly purchase tickets in bulk in order to raise the prices and charge additional fees, pricing out average consumers. However, as the State of California has moved to limit the influence of bots in manipulating the event ticket marketplace, a first-party platform has emerged which circumvents the law. Ticketmaster’s TradeDesk platform allows brokers to network hundreds of Ticketmaster.com accounts, buy thousands of tickets, and instantly relist those tickets at inflated prices on Stubhub, Vivid Seats, or Ticketmaster’s own resale platform. While it looks and acts like what we would consider a bot, the distinction may be drawn that TradeDesk is actually a service, which allows a ticket scalper to more effectively skirt the law against use of bots to circumvent the equitable ticket buying process for those fans who intend to attend sporting and entertainment events.
California’s laws preventing this type of practice were written with third-party bots in mind, and not first-party platforms. AB 1032 establishes parity between these ticket selling tools and services, thereby ensuring that hard fought protections for consumers remain effective.
- Prior legislative efforts to regulate ticket sales in California: In 2014, California specifically prohibited the use of “bots” (i.e., software able to execute the purchasing process without human involvement) to purchase tickets to entertainment events. (AB 1832 (Calderon, Ch. 158, Stats. 2014) AB 1832 was intended to prevent ticket resellers (commonly known as “scalpers”) from simply purchasing many, if not all, of the tickets to an event before event attendees had the opportunity, thus forcing the event attendees to pay ticket resellers amounts significantly above the ticket’s face value. At the time, several major news agencies chronicled the “bots” stranglehold on the ticket industry and the legislature responded by specifically prohibiting that activity. (Kolber, The Man Who Broke Ticketmaster, Motherboard, (Feb. 10, 2017) <https://motherboard.vice.com/en_us /article/mgxqb8/the-man-who-broke-ticketmaster> [as of Apr. 11, 2019].) Violations of these prohibitions constitute a misdemeanor, resulting in a fine of up to $2,500, or not more than six months in county jail, and civil liability of up to $2,500 per violation. (Bus. & Prof. Code Sec. 22500(b)-(c).)
- This bill represents a small step to curb anti-consumer practices in the ticket resale market, which persists despite past legislative efforts: Since 2014, some ticket sellers have arguably turned a blind eye to prohibited practices related to the resale of tickets by offering new services to individuals and brokers trying to manage their ticket subscriptions.
For example, Ticketmaster’s TradeDesk gives individuals (or brokers) a tool to pool all of the tickets they have bought from various sellers in one place (including tickets purchased from Ticketmaster), and to list those tickets for sale on the secondary market. Ticketmaster has received sharp criticism for failing to apply Ticketmaster’s terms of use to its own product, TradeDesk. In other words, while Ticketmaster has specific ticket-purchasing limits listed in its terms and conditions, it apparently has not been policing the number of tickets held by brokers (in excess of those limits) on its TradeDesk platform. (Cribb & Chown Oved, We went undercover as ticket scalpers — and Ticketmaster offered to help us do business, Toronto Star, (Sep. 19, 2018) <https://www. thestar.com/news/investigations /2018/09/19/ we-went-undercover-as-ticket-scalpers-and-ticketmaster-offered-to-help-us-do-business.html> [as of Apr. 11, 2019].)
Ticketmaster’s President, Jared Smith, responded to these allegations last year on the company’s blog:
TradeDesk is Ticketmaster’s version of an inventory management tool for professional ticket resellers (brokers). It is neither secret nor unique to Ticketmaster. Like StubHub’s product called Ticket Utils or Vivid Seat’s Skybox, TradeDesk is used by brokers to manage tickets they already have. All of these tools organize a broker’s ticket inventory so the tickets can be priced and listed for sale on various ticket marketplaces, not just on Ticketmaster as was suggested. These tickets could have come from Ticketmaster, from other ticketing systems or could have been purchased directly from a team, a venue or another reseller. TradeDesk is overwhelmingly used to manage season tickets for sporting events.
TradeDesk is not a scheme to help Ticketmaster sell tickets twice. In fact, less than 4% of the concert tickets we sell each year are listed and sold again on Ticketmaster. What does make TradeDesk unique, however, is that it offers an integration with Ticketmaster for validating tickets that are uploaded to it. As a result, our integrated marketplace is fundamentally different than all the others – safer, more transparent, and where each resale ticket is clearly identified and required to be 100% verified before ever being listed for sale. (Ticketmaster, Setting the Record Straight on TradeDesk and Ticketmaster Resale, (Sept. 24, 2018) https://blog.ticketmaster.com/jared-smith-statement-tradedesk-resale/ [as of Apr. 13, 2019].)
It is important to note that this bill does not seek to regulate the secondary market directly. Instead, this bill seeks to clarify that existing protections (requiring an equitable ticket buying process) are intended to benefit event attendees, and not brokers. By clarifying that the use of services (in addition to software) to circumvent measures that are used to ensure equitable ticket buying processes for event attendees is prohibited, this bill may arguably help ensure that existing statutory protections extend to the type of business relationships facilitated by Ticketmaster’s TradeDesk and similar business models.
Furthermore, by specifying that event attendees are the persons the law is designed to protect, and not brokers, this bill should help ensure that natural persons are able to enjoy the protections and benefits the law intended.
- Privacy benefits of major secondary market websites: While the economic impact of secondary market ticket sales on event attendees is arguably negative, the ticketing industry’s envelopment of the secondary ticket market does present potential privacy and consumer protection benefits. Specifically, by centralizing the secondary market, these businesses provide consumers with a buffer between themselves and ticket resellers. That buffer seemingly provides consumers with a single entity though which they can enforce their consumer privacy rights under various California laws, including, among others, the Data Breach Notification law, the California Consumer Protection Act, and Shine the Light.
- Prior legislation: AB 1832 (Calderon, Ch. 158, Stats. 2014) made it unlawful for a person to intentionally use or sell software to circumvent a security measure, access control system, or other control or measure that is used to ensure an equitable ticket buying process.
AB 329 (Pan, Ch. 325, Stats. 2013) made it a misdemeanor to intentionally use or sell software to circumvent a security measure, access control system or other control or measure on a ticket seller’s Web site that is used to ensure an equitable ticket buying process.
SB 1602 (Battin, 2006), would have expanded the definition of scalping under the Penal Code, to extend the prohibition against selling event tickets purchased for resale above market value on the event premises, to any purchase of tickets for resale in an amount over the limitation on the maximum number of tickets allowed by the original ticket seller and for any amount of profit. The bill also would have criminalized the use of automated computer purchases of event tickets in order to accomplish the purchase above the seller's limit, by defining the practice as “criminal interference” with the seller’s website. The bill was placed in the inactive file on the Senate Floor.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
California District Attorneys’ Association
Opposition
None on file
Analysis Prepared by: David Watson / P. & C.P. / (916) 319-2200
Date of Hearing: April 10, 2019
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON ARTS, ENTERTAINMENT, SPORTS, TOURISM, AND INTERNET MEDIA
Kansen Chu, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 1032 (
Author:Quirk) – As Amended Ver:April 3, 2019
SUBJECT: Ticket sellers: equitable ticket buying process: use or sale of services.
SUMMARY: Would narrow the scope of existing protections against use or sale of software to circumvent security measures under the Ticket Sellers Act, to benefit of ticket buyers who are intended event attendees, as defined in the bill, and expand the prohibited conduct to include use or sale of services to circumvent ticket seller’s security measures. Specifically, this bill:
- Adds “services” to circumvent a security measure, access control system, or other control or measure that is used to ensure an equitable ticket buying process to the prohibition against intentional use or sale of software to circumvent equitable ticket buying processes.
- Narrows the scope of the equitable buying process protections to purchasers who are intended event attendees, and offers as an example the limitation on the number of tickets each purchaser could buy.
- Would define “event attendee” to mean a person who purchases one or more tickets with the intent to attend the event for which the ticket or tickets are purchased.
Clarifies that an event attendee does not include a ticket seller.
- States that for purposes of this section, “a control measure that is used to ensure an equitable ticket buying process” includes limits on the number of tickets that a person can purchase.
EXISTING LAW:
- Provides a broad regulatory scheme in the Business and Professions Code for the conduct of the business of "Ticket Seller." (Business and Professions Code [BPC] § 22505, et. seq.)
- Defines a ticket seller, as “any person who for compensation, commission, or otherwise sells admission tickets to sporting, musical, theatre, or any other entertainment event.” (BPC § 22503)
- States that, “this chapter does not apply to any person who sells six tickets or less to any one single event, provided the tickets are sold off the premises where the event is to take place, including, but not limited to, designated parking areas and points of entry to the event.” (BPC § 22504)
- Prohibits the using or selling of software to circumvent a security measure, access control system, or other control or measure that is used to ensure an equitable ticket buying process, as specified. (BPC § 22505.5)
FISCAL EFFECT: Unknown. This measure has been keyed fiscal by the Legislative Counsel.
COMMENTS:
- Author’s statement. According to the author, “Illegal bots are limiting Californians ability to attend the events they want. Ticket brokers use bots to rapidly purchase tickets in bulk in order to raise the prices and charge additional fees, pricing out average consumers. However, as the State of California has moved to limit the influence of bots in manipulating the event ticket marketplace, a first-party platform has emerged which circumvents the law. Ticketmaster’s Trade Desk platform allows brokers to network hundreds of Ticketmaster.com accounts, buy thousands of tickets, and instantly relist those tickets at inflated prices on Stubhub, Vivid Seats, or Ticketmaster’s own resale platform. While it looks and acts like what we would consider a bot, the distinction may be drawn that TradeDesk is actually a service, which allows a ticket scalper to more effectively skirt the law against use of bots to circumvent the equitable ticket buying process for those fans who intend to attend sporting and entertainment events.
“California’s laws preventing this type of practice were written with third-party bots in mind, and not first-party platforms. AB 1032 establishes parity between these ticket selling tools and services, thereby ensuring that hard fought protections for consumers remain effective.”
- Background:
- “Bots” and Attempts to Curb Their Use. California law defines “Bot” as an automated online account where all or substantially all of the actions or posts of that account are not the result of a person. BCP§17940(a). This includes bots that are ticket buying software programs which allow users to quickly buy tickets online, thwarting average consumers who are unable to compete with the speed of the automated purchase programs. Typically, these bots are used by unscrupulous actors like ticket scalpers to buy tickets, then turn around and sell the same tickets at increasingly higher prices. Over the past several years, numerous high profile concert ticket sales have been impacted by the presumed use of “bots” in that individuals wait online to purchase tickets while software programs allow their users to jump to the front of the line and purchase large numbers of tickets at one time. This scenario often leads to concerts and other high profile events selling out in a matter of minutes, leaving fans ticketless and forcing them to spend more money to attend an event.
The ticket industry has attempted to combat problems caused by “bots” by employing other technological means, such as “Completely Automated Public Turing tests to tell Computers and Humans Apart” (CAPTCHA), which include phrases and picture tests at the point of sale during the online transaction to differentiate between a human purchaser and a likely computer program. CAPTCHA tests, such as typing characters into a box, are designed to prevent the use of “bots” because the requested task is typically one that can be completed by a person but would be difficult for a robotic software program to accurately perform.
Supporters of efforts to restrict the use of “bots” assert that even these technological efforts are not completely successful because the problem of instant sellouts and increased resale prices for tickets continues to generate complaints from the ticket-buying public. California is one of a number of states including Tennessee, Michigan, New Jersey, New York, Connecticut and Minnesota that have waded into the debate and considered or passed legislation imposing bans on “bots” and establishing stiff penalties to those who use these systems.
- Ticketmaster is accused of aiding scalpers with their TradeDesk platform. The author states that, “The TradeDesk service offered by Ticketmaster can be used to coordinate the actions of Ticketmaster accounts to purchase tickets, and resale accounts, either on Ticketmaster itself or other resale platforms like Stubhub or Vivid Seats. According to the Toronto Star, Ticketmaster employees have advertised TradeDesk in a way that is functionally indistinguishable from bots: with one saying, ‘I have brokers that have literally a couple of hundred Ticketmaster accounts,” admitting, “They have to because if you want to get a good show and the ticket limit is six or eight [seats], you’re not going to make a living on eight tickets.’”
TradeDesk is Ticketmaster’s version of an inventory management tool for professional ticket resellers (brokers). Other resellers also have tools to organize a broker’s ticket inventory so the tickets can be priced and listed for sale on various ticket marketplaces, such as StubHub’s product called Ticket Utils or Vivid Seat’s Skybox. These tools serve a legitimate purpose in the marketplace for brokers who may have several sources of tickets, for instance multiple season ticket holders who source team seats (with demand for different sports and each team multiplying the number of sports accounts), accounts with theater venues for plays, and they often use multiple sources for concerts. It is therefore not in-and-of-itself a problematic tool. However, it can be used to circumvent the law.
The author adds, “California law limits the number of tickets someone can resell to six before they are classified as a ticket seller and additional restrictions apply, such as having a permanent business address. Not only does TradeDesk allow users to circumvent internal purchasing policy, but by making it easy for brokers to resale tickets in bulk, TradeDesk allows its users to circumvent state law. California has taken steps to prevent third-party bots from manipulating the ticket market place, increasing the cost of tickets and pricing out average consumers. These policies are undermined however, if first-party ticket issues develop and market tools that offer the same functionality.”
The author has pointed to the activities of TradeDesk in particular, based upon a series of articles in the Toronto Star where reporters went undercover at a ticket broker convention in Las Vegas in July 2018. Undercover reporters asked TradeDesk sales representatives if they could use multiple Ticketmaster accounts — a violation of Ticketmaster’s rules — they were told TradeDesk does not monitor or care how their users obtain their tickets. “We don’t spend any time looking at your Ticketmaster.com account. ... When asked about limitations on the number of tickets one could purchase, they replied, “The policing of bots, going after those types of things, falls completely on the primary side. We have no input on it, no involvement with it …” he said. “I have a gentleman who’s got over 200 Ticketmaster.com accounts right into the point of sale, who syncs his tickets in every day. … If you’ve got 100 Ticketmaster.com accounts and you’re out there buying inventory, the system is automatically going to sync them and move them over to create the (resale) listing,” said the TradeDesk sales executive in Las Vegas.
In addition to making it easier to operate multiple accounts and obtain tickets in excess of statutory limits using bots with impunity, “Ticketmaster rewards mass sales with discounts on its commission for scalpers who reach $500,000 and $1 million in sales.” (Ticketmaster’s Tradedesk scalper tool explained, infra.)
In an article headlined, Ticketmaster Issues Statement on Scalper-Collusion Accusations, published in Variety, Ticketmaster responded saying, “We do not condone the statements made by the employee as the conduct described clearly violates our terms of service. …Ticketmaster’s Seller Code of Conduct specifically prohibits resellers from purchasing tickets that exceed the posted ticket limit for an event. In addition, our policy also prohibits the creation of fictitious user accounts for the purpose of circumventing ticket limit detection in order to amass tickets intended for resale.” Variety, (Sept. 20, 2018) https://variety.com/2018/biz/news/ticketmaster-issues-statement-on-scalper-collusion-accusations-1202950272/
However, In an interview with Billboard magazine published shortly thereafter, (September 24, 2018), “Ticketmaster boss Jared Smith conceded his company isn’t effectively policing its TradeDesk platform, where scalpers with multiple Ticketmaster accounts can upload and resell industrial-scale inventories of seats to major sports and concert events — in breach of the company’s own rules (Setting the Record Straight on TradeDesk and Ticketmaster Resale,” The Star (Sept. 24, 2018) https://www.thestar.com/news/investigations/2018/09/25/ticketmasters-tradedesk-scalper-tool-explained.html)
Ticketmaster has since stated the following, in response to a US Senate inquiry into the Star articles (Ticketmaster’s TradeDesk scalper tool explained, id): Ticketmaster is rigorous about limiting box office sales to ensure fans get a fair shot at seeing the sports teams and artists they love. “Ticketmaster’s general terms of use prohibit customers from buying a number of tickets for an event that exceeds the stated limit for that event. That limit, posted when tickets go on sale, is typically six or eight seats per buyer. If we identify breaches of these limits … we reserve the right to cancel any such orders ... Use of automated means to purchase tickets is strictly prohibited.” In the past, Ticketmaster has said it blocked more than five billion purchase attempts by bots in 2016.
As for whether Ticketmaster’s ticket-purchasing limits and associated detection practices apply to users of its online program, TradeDesk, Ticketmaster admitted, “We probably don’t do enough to look into TradeDesk,” Ticketmaster’s president of North American operations said, “The reality is, yeah, (TradeDesk users) could have more than their ticket limit” and acknowledged, “the company needs to be more vigilant about ensuring TradeDesk clients aren’t gaming the system.”
- Committee comment. As was noted above, Ticketmaster’s TradeDesk service is not unique, however their experience serves as a cautionary tale for the industry as it moves to a resale dominated field - other resellers also have tools to organize a broker’s ticket inventory so the tickets can be priced and listed for sale on various ticket marketplaces, such as StubHub’s product called Ticket Utils or Vivid Seat’s Skybox.
This bill does not address the issue of whether the resale platforms and the services which assist them in managing their clients’ ticket sales must find ways to assure the clients and accounts they are managing have obtained their inventory in conformity with the law. That is another bill for another day. However, AB 1032 does add another tool in the arsenal of enforcement by prohibiting brokers from using services to circumvent a security measure, access control system, or other control or measure that is used by the ticket sellers to ensure an equitable ticket buying process.
- Double-referral. Should this bill pass out of this committee, it will be re-referred to the Assembly Committee on Privacy and Consumer Protection.
- Prior Related Legislation.
- AB 1832 (Calderon), Chapter 158, Statutes of 2014, made technical changes to existing law prohibiting software from circumventing ticket sellers’ equitable ticket buying process to ensure the prohibition is not only limited to Internet Web sites.
- AB 329 (Pan), Chapter 325, Statutes of 2013, made it a misdemeanor to intentionally use or sell software to circumvent a security measure, access control system or other control or measure on a ticket seller’s Web site that is used to ensure an equitable ticket buying process.
- AB 2612 (Plescia), of 2008, was a spot bill to amend the ticket seller's provisions of the Business and Professions Code. (Status: The bill was held in the Assembly Committee on Rules without referral.)
- SB 1022 (Campbell), of 2006, would have included Licensed Ticket Sellers, and other businesses, eligible to organize as Limited Liability Corporations (LLC). (Status: The bill was not ever heard in a Senate policy committee.)
- SB 1602 (Battin), of 2006, would have expanded the definition of scalping under the Penal Code, to extend the prohibition against selling event tickets purchased for resale above market value on the event premises, to any purchase of tickets for resale in an amount over the limitation on the maximum number of tickets allowed by the original ticket seller and for any amount of profit. The bill also would have criminalized the use of automated computer purchases of event tickets in order to accomplish the purchase above the seller's limit, by defining the practice as "criminal interference" with the seller's Web site. (Status: The bill was not heard on the Senate Floor at the request of the Author.)
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
California District Attorneys Association
Opposition
There is no opposition on file.
Analysis Prepared by: Dana Mitchell / A.,E.,S.,T., & I.M. / (916) 319-3450
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):