AB 1101: Pupil school enrollment: residency requirements: policy on investigations.
- Session Year: 2015-2016
- House: Assembly
- Latest Version Date: 2015-08-11
Existing law requires each person between 6 and 18 years of age not otherwise exempted to attend the public full-time day school or continuation school or classes in the school district where the residency of the persons parent or legal guardian is located. Existing law provides that a pupil is deemed to have complied with the residency requirements for school attendance in a school district if the pupil satisfies one of specified requirements. Existing law also specifies a nonexhaustive list of reasonable evidence that a school district is required to accept from a parent or legal guardian of a pupil as proof that the pupil satisfies the residency requirements for attendance in the school district. Existing law authorizes a school district to make reasonable efforts to determine that a pupil actually meets the residency requirements, as specified, if an employee of the school district reasonably believes that the parent or legal guardian of the pupil has provided false or unreliable evidence of residency.
This bill would, if a school district elects to undertake an investigation, as specified, require the governing board of the school district to adopt a policy regarding the investigation of a pupil to determine whether the pupil meets the residency requirements for school attendance in the school district before investigating any pupils. The bill would require the policy to, among other things, identify the circumstances upon which the school district may initiate an investigation, describe the investigatory methods that may be used, including whether the school district will be employing the services of a private investigator, prohibit the surreptitious photographing or video-recording of pupils who are being investigated, as provided, and provide for an appeal process, as specified. The bill would require the policy to be adopted at a public meeting of the governing board of the school district.
Existing law requires each person between 6 and 18 years of age not otherwise exempted to attend the public full-time day school or continuation school or classes in the school district where the residency of the persons parent or legal guardian is located. Existing law provides that a pupil is deemed to have complied with the residency requirements for school attendance in a school district if the pupil satisfies one of specified requirements. Existing law also specifies a nonexhaustive list of reasonable evidence that a school district is required to accept from a parent or legal guardian of a pupil as proof that the pupil satisfies the residency requirements for attendance in the school district. Existing law authorizes a school district to make reasonable efforts to determine that a pupil actually meets the residency requirements, as specified, if an employee of the school district reasonably believes that the parent or legal guardian of the pupil has provided false or unreliable evidence of residency.
This bill would, if a school district elects to undertake an investigation, as specified, require the governing board of the school district to adopt a policy regarding the investigation of a pupil to determine whether the pupil meets the residency requirements for school attendance in the school district before investigating any pupils. The bill would require the policy to, among other things, identify the circumstances upon which the school district may initiate an investigation, describe the investigatory methods that may be used, including whether the school district will be employing the services of a private investigator, prohibit the surreptitious photographing or video-recording of pupils who are being investigated, as provided, and provide for an appeal process, as specified. The bill would require the policy to be adopted at a public meeting of the governing board of the school district.
Existing law requires each person between 6 and 18 years of age not otherwise exempted to attend the public full-time day school or continuation school or classes in the school district where the persons parent or legal guardian is located. Existing law provides that a pupil is deemed to have complied with the residency requirements for school attendance in a school district if the pupil satisfies one of specified requirements. Existing law also specifies a nonexhaustive list of reasonable evidence that a school district is required to accept from a parent or legal guardian of a pupil as proof that the pupil satisfies the residency requirements for attendance in the school district. Existing law authorizes a school district to make reasonable efforts to determine that a pupil actually meets the residency requirements, as specified, if an employee of the school district reasonably believes that the parent or legal guardian of the pupil has provided false or unreliable evidence of residency.
This bill would, if a school district elects to undertake an investigation, as specified, require the governing board of the school district to adopt a policy regarding the investigation of a pupil to determine whether the pupil meets the residency requirements for school attendance in the school district before investigating any pupils. The bill would require the policy to, among other things, identify the circumstances upon which the school district may initiate an investigation, describe the investigatory methods that may be used, including whether the school district will be employing the services of a private investigator, prohibit the surreptitious photographing or video-recording of pupils who are being investigated, as provided, and provide for an appeal process, as specified. The bill would require the policy to be adopted at a public meeting of the governing board of the school district.
Existing law requires each person between 6 and 18 years of age not otherwise exempted to attend the public full-time day school or continuation school or classes in the school district where the persons parent or legal guardian is located. Existing law provides that a pupil is deemed to have complied with the residency requirements for school attendance in a school district if the pupil satisfies one of specified requirements. Existing law also specifies a nonexhaustive list of reasonable evidence that a school district is required to accept from a parent or legal guardian of a pupil as proof that the pupil satisfies the residency requirements for attendance in the school district. Existing law authorizes a school district to make reasonable efforts to determine that a pupil actually meets the residency requirements, as specified, if an employee of the school district reasonably believes that the parent or legal guardian of the pupil has provided false or unreliable evidence of residency.
This bill would, if a school district elects to undertake an investigation, as specified, require the governing board of the school district to adopt a policy, containing specified information, policy regarding the investigation of a pupil to determine whether the pupil meets the residency requirements for school attendance in the school district before investigating any pupils. The bill also would require the policy to to, among other things, identify the circumstances upon which the school district may initiate an investigation, describe the investigatory methods that may be used, including whether the school district will be employing the services of a private investigator, prohibit the surreptitious photographing of pupils who are being investigated. investigated, and provide for an appeal process, as specified. The bill would require the policy to be adopted at a public meeting of the governing board of the school district.
Existing law requires each person between 6 and 18 years of age not otherwise exempted to attend the public full-time day school or continuation school or classes in the school district where the persons parent or legal guardian is located. Existing law provides that a pupil is deemed to have complied with the residency requirements for school attendance in a school district if the pupil satisfies one of specified requirements. Existing law also specifies a nonexhaustive list of reasonable evidence that a school district is required to accept from a parent or legal guardian of a pupil as proof that the pupil satisfies the residency requirements for attendance in the school district. Existing law authorizes a school district to make reasonable efforts to determine that a pupil actually meets the residency requirements, as specified, if an employee of the school district reasonably believes that the parent or legal guardian of the pupil has provided false or unreliable evidence of residency.
This bill would, if a school district elects to undertake an investigation, as specified, require the governing board of the school district to adopt a policy, containing specified information, regarding the investigation of a pupil to determine whether the pupil meets the residency requirements for school attendance in the school district before investigating any pupils. The bill also would require the policy to prohibit the surreptitious photographing of pupils who are being investigated. The bill would require the policy to be adopted at a public meeting of the governing board of the school district.
Existing law requires each person between 6 and 18 years of age not otherwise exempted to attend the public full-time day school or continuation school or classes in the school district where the persons parent or legal guardian is located. Existing law provides that a pupil is deemed to have complied with the residency requirements for school attendance in a school district if the pupil satisfies one of specified requirements. Existing law also specifies a nonexhaustive list of reasonable evidence that a school district is required to accept from a parent or legal guardian of a pupil as proof that the pupil satisfies the residency requirements for attendance in the school district. Existing law authorizes a school district to make reasonable efforts to determine that a pupil actually meets the residency requirements, as specified, if an employee of the school district reasonably believes that the parent or legal guardian of the pupil has provided false or unreliable evidence of residency.
This bill would, if a school district elects to undertake an investigation, as specified, require the governing board of the school district to adopt a policy, containing specified information, regarding the investigation of a pupil to determine whether the pupil meets the residency requirements for school attendance in the school district. district before investigating any pupils. The bill also would require the policy to prohibit the surreptitious photographing of pupils who are being investigated. The bill would require the policy to be adopted at a public meeting of the governing board of the school district.
Existing law requires each person between 6 and 18 years of age not otherwise exempted to attend the public full-time day school or continuation school or classes in the school district where the persons parent or legal guardian is located. Existing law provides that a pupil is deemed to have complied with the residency requirements for school attendance in a school district if the pupil satisfies one of specified requirements. Existing law also specifies a nonexhaustive list of reasonable evidence that a school district is required to accept from a parent or legal guardian of a pupil as proof that the pupil satisfies the residency requirements for attendance in the school district. Existing law authorizes a school district to make reasonable efforts to determine that a pupil actually meets the residency requirements, as specified, if an employee of the school district reasonably believes that the parent or legal guardian of the pupil has provided false or unreliable evidence of residency.
This bill would, if a school district elects to undertake an investigation, as specified, require the governing board of the school district to adopt a policy, containing specified information, regarding the investigation of a pupil to determine whether the pupil meets the residency requirements for school attendance in the school district. The bill would require the policy to be adopted at a public meeting of the governing board of the school district.
(a)If a school district elects to undertake an investigation pursuant to subdivision (c) of Section 48204.1, the governing board of the school district shall adopt a policy regarding the investigation of a pupil to determine whether the pupil meets the residency requirements for school attendance in the school district before investigating any pupils.
(b)The policy shall do all of the following:
(1)Identify the circumstances upon which the school district may initiate an investigation, which shall, at a minimum, require the school district employee to be able to identify specific, articulable facts supporting the belief that the parent or legal guardian of the pupil has provided false or unreliable evidence of residency.
(2)(A)Describe the investigatory methods that may be used by the school district in the conduct of the investigation, including whether the school district will be employing the services of a private investigator.
(B)Before hiring a private investigator, the policy shall require the school district to make reasonable efforts to determine whether the pupil resides in the school district.
(3)Prohibit the surreptitious photographing or video-recording of pupils who are being investigated. For purposes of this paragraph, surreptitious photographing or video-recording means the covert collection of photographic or videographic images of person or places subject to an investigation. For purposes of this paragraph, the collection of images is not covert if the technology is used in open and public view.
(4)Require that employees and contractors of the school district engaged in the investigation must identify themselves truthfully as such to individuals contacted or interviewed during the course of the investigation.
(5)Provide a process whereby the determination of a school district as to whether a pupil meets the residency requirements for school attendance in the school district may be appealed, and shall specify the basis for that determination. If an appeal is made, the burden shall be on the appealing party to show why the decision of the school district should be overruled.
(c)The policy required pursuant to this section shall be adopted at a public meeting of the governing board of the school district.
(a)If a school district elects to undertake an investigation pursuant to subdivision (c) of Section 48204.1, the governing board of the school district shall adopt a policy regarding the investigation of a pupil to determine whether the pupil meets the residency requirements for school attendance in the school district before investigating any pupils.
(b)The policy shall do all of the following:
(1)Identify the circumstances upon which the school district may initiate an investigation, which shall, at a minimum, require the school district employee to be able to identify specific, articulable facts supporting the belief that the parent or legal guardian of the pupil has provided false or unreliable evidence of residency.
(2)(A)Describe the investigatory methods that may be used by the school district in the conduct of the investigation, including whether the school district will be employing the services of a private investigator.
(B)Before hiring a private investigator, the policy shall require the school district to make reasonable efforts to determine whether the pupil resides in the school district.
(3)Prohibit the surreptitious photographing or video-recording of pupils who are being investigated. For purposes of this paragraph, surreptitious photographing or video-recording means the covert collection of photographic or videographic images of person or places subject to an investigation. For purposes of this paragraph, the collection of images is not covert if the technology is used in open and public view.
(4)Require that employees and contractors of the school district engaged in the investigation must identify themselves truthfully as such to individuals contacted or interviewed during the course of the investigation.
(5)Provide a process whereby the determination of a school district as to whether a pupil meets the residency requirements for school attendance in the school district may be appealed, and shall specify the basis for that determination. If an appeal is made, the burden shall be on the appealing party to show why the decision of the school district should be overruled.
(c)The policy required pursuant to this section shall be adopted at a public meeting of the governing board of the school district.
(a)If a school district elects to undertake an investigation pursuant to subdivision (c) of Section 48204.1, the governing board of the school district shall adopt a policy regarding the investigation of a pupil to determine whether the pupil meets the residency requirements for school attendance in the school district before investigating any pupils.
(b)The policy shall do all of the following:
(1)Identify the circumstances upon which the school district may initiate an investigation, which shall, at a minimum, require the school district employee to be able to identify specific, articulable facts supporting the belief that the parent or legal guardian of the pupil has provided false or unreliable evidence of residency.
(2)(A)Describe the investigatory methods that may be used by the school district in the conduct of the investigation, including whether the school district will be employing the services of a private investigator.
(B)Before hiring a private investigator, the policy shall require the school district to make reasonable efforts to determine whether the pupil resides in the school district.
(3)Prohibit the surreptitious photographing of pupils who are being investigated.
(3)Prohibit the surreptitious photographing or video-recording of pupils who are being investigated. For purposes of this paragraph, surreptitious photographing or video-recording means the covert collection of photographic or videographic images of person or places subject to an investigation. For purposes of this paragraph, the collection of images is not covert if the technology is used in open and public view.
(4)Require that employees and contractors of the school district engaged in the investigation must identify themselves truthfully as such to individuals contacted or interviewed during the course of the investigation.
(5)Provide a process whereby the determination of a school district as to whether a pupil meets the residency requirements for school attendance in the school district may be appealed, and shall specify the basis for that determination. If an appeal is made, the burden shall be on the appealing party to show why the decision of the school district should be overruled.
(c)The policy required pursuant to this section shall be adopted at a public meeting of the governing board of the school district.
(a)If a school district elects to undertake an investigation pursuant to subdivision (c) of Section 48204.1, the governing board of the school district shall adopt a policy regarding the investigation of a pupil to determine whether the pupil meets the residency requirements for school attendance in the school district before investigating any pupils.
(b)The policy shall identify do all of the following:
(1)Identify the circumstances upon which the school district may initiate an investigation, which shall, at a minimum, require the school district employee to be able to identify specific, articulable facts supporting the belief that the parent or legal guardian of the pupil has provided false or unreliable evidence of residency. The policy shall describe
(2)(A)Describe the investigatory methods that may be used by the school district in the conduct of the investigation, including whether the school district will be employing the services of a private investigator. The policy shall prohibit
(B)Before hiring a private investigator, the policy shall require the school district to make reasonable efforts to determine whether the pupil resides in the school district.
(3)Prohibit the surreptitious photographing of pupils who are being investigated.
(c)The policy shall require
(4)Require that employees and contractors of the school district engaged in the investigation must identify themselves truthfully as such to individuals contacted or interviewed during the course of the investigation.
(d)The policy shall provide
(5)Provide a process whereby the determination of a school district as to whether a pupil meets the residency requirements for school attendance in the school district may be appealed, and shall specify the basis for that determination. If an appeal is made, the burden shall be on the appealing party to show why the decision of the school district should be overruled.
(e)
(c)The policy required pursuant to this section shall be adopted at a public meeting of the governing board of the school district.
(a)If a school district elects to undertake an investigation pursuant to subdivision (c) of Section 48204.1, the governing board of the school district shall adopt a policy regarding the investigation of a pupil to determine whether the pupil meets the residency requirements for school attendance in the school district before investigating any pupils.
(b)The policy shall identify the circumstances upon which the school district may initiate an investigation, which shall, at a minimum, require the school district employee to be able to identify specific, articulable facts supporting the belief that the parent or legal guardian of the pupil has provided false or unreliable evidence of residency. The policy shall provide for written notification of a pupils parent or legal guardian when a pupil is identified as being subject to investigation under this section and shall provide that such notification specify the basis for the reasonable belief supporting the need for the investigation. The policy shall provide that notification of a pupils parent or legal guardian shall occur at least five business days before the start of the investigation, and the policy shall describe the investigatory methods that may be used by the school district in the conduct of the investigation. investigation, including whether the school district will be employing the services of a private investigator. The policy shall prohibit the surreptitious photographing of pupils who are being investigated.
(c)The written notice shall include the school districts contact information, which a pupils parent or legal guardian may use to request information from or provide information to the school district regarding the investigation.
(d)
(c)The policy shall require that employees and contractors of the school district engaged in the investigation must identify themselves truthfully as such to individuals contacted or interviewed during the course of the investigation.
(e)
(d)The policy shall provide a process whereby the determination of a school district as to whether a pupil meets the residency requirements for school attendance in the school district may be appealed, and shall specify the basis for that determination. If an appeal is made, the burden shall be on the appealing party to show why the decision of the school district should be overruled.
(f)
(e)The policy required pursuant to this section shall be adopted at a public meeting of the governing board of the school district.
(a)If a school district elects to undertake an investigation pursuant to subdivision (c) of Section 48204.1, the governing board of the school district shall adopt a policy regarding the investigation of a pupil to determine whether the pupil meets the residency requirements for school attendance in the school district. district before investigating any pupils.
(b)The policy shall identify the circumstances upon which the school district may initiate an investigation, which shall, at a minimum, require the school district employee to be able to identify specific, articulable facts supporting the belief that the parent or legal guardian of the pupil has provided false or unreliable evidence of residency. The policy shall provide for written notification of a pupils parent or legal guardian when a pupil is identified as being subject to investigation under this section. section and shall provide that such notification specify the basis for the reasonable belief supporting the need for the investigation. The policy shall provide that notification of a pupils parent or legal guardian shall occur at least five business days before the start of the investigation, and the policy shall describe the investigatory methods that may be used by the school district in the conduct of the investigation. The policy shall prohibit the surreptitious photographing of pupils who are being investigated.
(c)The written notice shall include school district the school districts contact information, which a pupils parent or legal guardian may use to request information from or provide information to the school district regarding the investigation.
(d)The policy shall require that employees and contractors of the school district engaged in the investigation must identify themselves truthfully as such to individuals contacted or interviewed during the course of the investigation.
(e)The policy shall provide a process whereby the determination of a school district as to whether a pupil meets the residency requirements for school attendance in the school district may be appealed. appealed, and shall specify the basis for that determination. If an appeal is made, the burden shall be on the appealing party to show why the decision of the school district should be overruled.
(f)The policy required pursuant to this section shall be adopted at a public meeting of the governing board of the school district.
(a)If a school district elects to undertake an investigation pursuant to subdivision (c) of Section 48204.1, the governing board of the school district shall adopt a policy regarding the investigation of a pupil to determine whether the pupil meets the residency requirements for school attendance in the school district.
(b)The policy shall provide for written notification of a pupils parent or legal guardian when a pupil is identified as being subject to investigation under this section. The policy shall provide that notification of a pupils parent or legal guardian shall occur at least five business days before the start of the investigation, and shall describe the investigatory methods that may be used by the school district in the conduct of the investigation.
(c)The notice shall include school district contact information, which a pupils parent or legal guardian may use to request information from or provide information to the school district regarding the investigation.
(d)The policy shall require that employees and contractors of the school district engaged in the investigation must identify themselves truthfully as such to individuals contacted or interviewed during the course of the investigation.
(e)The policy shall provide a process whereby the determination of a school district as to whether a pupil meets the residency requirements for school attendance in the school district may be appealed. If an appeal is made, the burden shall be on the appealing party to show why the decision of the school district should be overruled.
(f)The policy required pursuant to this section shall be adopted at a public meeting of the governing board of the school district.
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Aug 11, 2015 | Chaptered by Secretary of State - Chapter 170, Statutes of 2015. |
| Aug 11, 2015 | Approved by the Governor. |
| Aug 3, 2015 | Enrolled and presented to the Governor at 3 p.m. |
| Jul 16, 2015 | Senate amendments concurred in. To Engrossing and Enrolling. (Ayes 79. Noes 0. Page 2417.). |
| Jul 16, 2015 | Senate amendments concurred in. To Engrossing and Enrolling. |
| Jul 13, 2015 | In Assembly. Concurrence in Senate amendments pending. May be considered on or after July 15 pursuant to Assembly Rule 77. |
| Jul 13, 2015 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Assembly. (Ayes 35. Noes 0. Page 1906.). |
| Jul 13, 2015 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Assembly. |
| Jul 1, 2015 | Read second time and amended. Ordered to third reading. |
| Jun 30, 2015 | From committee: Amend, and do pass as amended. (Ayes 9. Noes 0.) (June 24). |
| Jun 17, 2015 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to committee. Read second time, amended, and re-referred to Com. on ED. |
| Jun 15, 2015 | In committee: Set, first hearing. Hearing canceled at the request of author. |
| Jun 4, 2015 | Referred to Com. on ED. |
| May 22, 2015 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Senate. (Ayes 74. Noes 0. Page 1555.) |
| May 22, 2015 | In Senate. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. |
| May 21, 2015 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| May 20, 2015 | Read second time and amended. Ordered returned to second reading. |
| May 19, 2015 | From committee: Amend, and do pass as amended. (Ayes 7. Noes 0.) (May 13). |
| May 6, 2015 | Re-referred to Com. on ED. |
| May 5, 2015 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to Com. on ED. Read second time and amended. |
| Mar 19, 2015 | Referred to Com. on ED. |
| Mar 2, 2015 | Read first time. |
| Mar 1, 2015 | From printer. May be heard in committee March 31. |
| Feb 27, 2015 | Introduced. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Jul 16, 2015 | AB 1101 BONILLA Concurrence in Senate Amendments | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| Jul 13, 2015 | Assembly 3rd Reading AB1101 Bonilla By Lara | Senate Floor |
Passed |
|
| Jun 24, 2015 | Do pass as amended | Senate Standing Committee on Education |
Passed |
|
| May 22, 2015 | AB 1101 BONILLA Assembly Third Reading | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| May 13, 2015 | Do pass as amended. | Assembly Standing Committee on Education |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
AB 1101
Page 3
CONCURRENCE IN SENATE AMENDMENTS
AB 1101
(Bonilla)
As Amended July 1, 2015
Majority vote
ASSEMBLY: |
74-0 |
(May 22, 2015) |
SENATE: |
35-0 |
(July 13, 2015) |
Original Committee Reference: ED.
SUMMARY: Requires a school district that elects to undertake an investigation to determine whether a pupil meets residency requirements to adopt a policy regarding the investigation of a pupil before investigating any pupils. Specifically, this bill:
Requires the policy to do the following:
Identify the circumstances upon which the school district may initiate an investigation, which shall, at a minimum, require the school district employee to be able to identify specific, articulable facts supporting the belief that the parent or legal guardian of the pupil has provided false or unreliable evidence of residency.
Describe the investigatory methods that may be used by the school district in the conduct of the investigation, including whether the district will be employing the services of a private investigator.
Require the school district to make reasonable efforts to determine whether the pupil resides in the school district before hiring a private investigator.
Prohibit the surreptitious photographing or video-recording of pupils who are being investigated. Defines "surreptitious photographing or video-recording" as the covert collection of photographic or videographic images of person or places subject to an investigation. Specifies that for purposes of this bill, the collection of images is not covert if the technology is used in open and public view.
Require employees and contractors of the school district engaged in the investigation to identify themselves truthfully as such to individuals contacted or interviewed during the course of the investigation.
Provide a process whereby the determination of a school district as to whether a pupil meets the residency requirements for school attendance in the school district may be appealed, and specify the basis for that determination. Specifies that if an appeal is made, the burden shall be on the appealing party to show why the decision of the school district should be overruled.
Requires the policy required pursuant to this bill to be adopted at a public meeting of the governing board of the school district.
The Senate amendments add the provisions requiring a school district to make reasonable efforts to determine whether the pupil resides in the school district and prohibiting the video-recording of pupils who are being investigated. The amendments also establish a definition for "surreptitious photographing or video-recording."
FISCAL EFFECT: None
COMMENTS: Under current law, compulsory education begins at age six until age 18. Any person subject to compulsory education found away from home without a valid excuse for not attending school can be arrested by school officials or peace or probation officers. A pupil is required to attend school in the district in which the residency of either the parent or legal guardian is located. Documentation of residency includes property tax payment receipts; rental property contract, lease, or payment receipts; utility service contract, statement, or payment receipts; pay stubs; voter registration; correspondence from a government agency; or declaration of residency executed by the parent or legal guardian. If an employee of a school district reasonably believes that the parent or legal guardian of a pupil has provided false or unreliable evidence of residency, the school district is authorized to make reasonable efforts to determine whether the pupil meets residency requirements.
What does this bill do? This bill requires a school district that elects to investigate a pupil's residency to adopt a policy regarding such investigations. This bill requires the policy to be adopted at a governing board meeting and to contain specified requirements, including indicating whether the district will be employing the services of a private investigator, prohibiting the photographing and video-recording of pupils, requiring employees and contractors to identify themselves truthfully, and establishing an appeals process. Amendments adopted in the Senate require a school district to make reasonable efforts to determine whether the pupil resides in the school district prior to hiring a private investigator and prohibit the video-recording of pupils.
Purpose of this bill. The author states, "Schools should have tools available to investigate residency issues, but we need to ensure safeguards are in place to protect those students being investigated especially elementary school-aged children." The author cites, as an example, a Contra Costa Times report of the investigatory tactics undertaken by investigators hired by the Orinda Union School District to investigate a seven-year-old girl the school district disenrolled last fall. According to the article, the investigator told the mother of the child named Vivian and neighbors at the family's old neighborhood that he was a car insurance investigator. The school district later reversed the decision to remove the child from the school district when it learned that the mother was a live-in nanny for a couple residing in the Orinda Union School District that was her primary residence. The little girl was in the other neighborhood spending time with her great-grandmother, who was ill. The article reports that hiring investigators to investigate residency issues is not uncommon, especially for smaller school districts that are unable to dedicate staff for this purpose. Investigators interviewed in the article acknowledge that they do hide their identity in hopes that people will "rat the kids out" unwittingly.
Current law simply says that a school district may make "reasonable efforts" to determine a pupil's residency. The law does not specify how that is to be done. It is unclear how many districts hire private investigators to conduct residency checks.
Arguments in support. The author states, "AB 1101 protects student safety and privacy by requiring school boards to adopt a policy when a private investigator is hired to conduct an investigation to determine whether a student resides within the school district boundaries. AB 1101 protects children, like Vivian, from questionable investigatory techniques such as lying to family members and neighbors and taking surreptitious photos of young students. This bill creates more transparency and disclosure in student residency investigations and provides for due process in challenging a student's home residency."
Arguments in opposition. The California School Boards Association states that this bill "enables those looking to evade a school district's efforts to implement statutory residency criteria by requiring governing boards to adopt board policies containing details about the procedures and parameters of these investigations. The requirement that districts' identify specific, articulable facts' supporting their findings could force districts to compromise the confidentiality of those who provide information in connection to investigations. The latter would have a detrimental effect on the willingness of school district employees and community members to provide true and accurate information to investigators."
Analysis Prepared by: Sophia Kwong Kim / ED. / (916) 319-2087 FN: 0001196
AB 1101
Page 5
|
Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 |
THIRD READING
Bill No: AB 1101
Amended: 7/1/15 in Senate
SENATE EDUCATION COMMITTEE: 9-0, 6/24/15
AYES: Liu, Runner, Block, Hancock, Leyva, Mendoza, Monning, Pan, Vidak
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 74-0, 5/22/15 - See last page for vote
SUBJECT: Pupil school enrollment: residency requirements: policy on investigations
DIGEST: This bill requires a school district that elects to investigate the residency of a student to first adopt a policy regarding such investigations.
Existing law:
Requires students to attend the public full-time day school or continuation school or classes in which the residency of either the parent or legal guardian is located. (Education Code § 48200)
Provides that a student complies with the residency requirements for school attendance in a school district if the student:
Is placed within the boundaries of the school district in a licensed children’s institution, licensed foster home, or a foster family home.
If a foster child who remains in his or her school of origin.
Has been approved for interdistrict attendance.
Resides within the boundaries of the school districts and whose parent or legal guardian is relieved of responsibility, control, and authority through emancipation.
Lives in the home of a caregiving adult that is located within the boundaries of that school district.
Resides in a state hospital located within the boundaries of the school district. (EC § 48204)
Authorizes, until July 1, 2017, school districts to deem a student to have complied with the residency requirements for school attendance in a school district if at least one parent or the legal guardian is physically employed within the boundaries of that district for a minimum of 10 hours during the school week.
School districts are not required to admit a student with at least one parent or legal guardian who is physically employed in the district.
A school district may prohibit the transfer of a student if the district determines that the transfer would negatively impact the court-ordered or voluntary desegregation plan of the district, or if the district determines that the additional cost of educating the student would exceed the amount of additional state aid received as a result of the transfer. (EC § 48204)
Requires school districts to accept from the parent or legal guardian reasonable evidence that the student meets the residency requirements for school attendance in the district. Existing law requires reasonable evidence of residency to be established by documentation showing the name and address of the parent or legal guardian within the school district, including but not limited to the following:
Property tax payment receipts.
Rental property contract, lease, or payment receipts.
Utility service contract, statement, or payment receipts.
Pay stubs.
Voter registration.
Correspondence from a government agency.
Declaration of residency executed by the parent or legal guardian.
(EC § 48204.1)
Authorizes school districts to make reasonable efforts to determine that the student actually meets the residency requirements if an employee of the district reasonably believes that the parent or legal guardian has provided false or unreliable evidence of residency. (EC § 48204.1)
This bill requires a school district that elects to investigate the residency of a student to first adopt a policy regarding such investigations. Specifically, this bill:
Requires the governing board of a school district, if the district elects to undertake an investigation to determine if a student meets residency requirements, to adopt a policy regarding the investigation of a student to determine residency for school attendance before investigating any students.
Requires the policy to do all of the following:
Identify the circumstances upon which the school district may initiate an investigation, which must, at a minimum, require the school district employee to be able to identify specific, articulable facts supporting the belief that the parent or legal guardian has provided false or unreliable evidence of residency.
Describe the investigatory methods that may be used by the school district in the conduct of the investigation, including whether the school district will be employing the services of a private investigator.
Require the school district to make reasonable efforts to determine whether the student resides in the school district before hiring a private investigator.
Prohibit the surreptitious photographing or video-recording of students who are being investigated, provides that “surreptitious photographing or video-recording” means the covert collection of photographic or videographic images of people or places subject to an investigation, and provides that the collection of images is not covert if the technology is used in open and public view.
Require that employees and contractors of the school district engaged in the investigation identify themselves truthfully as such to individuals contacted or interviewed during the course of the investigation.
Provide a process whereby the determination of a school district as to whether a student meets residency requirements may be appealed, and specify the basis for that determination. Provide that the burden is on the appealing party to show why the decision of the school district should be overruled.
Requires the policy to be adopted at a public meeting of the school district governing board.
Comments
Investigative
tools. Existing law authorizes school districts to make
reasonable efforts to determine that the student actually meets the
residency requirements if an employee of the district reasonably
believes that the parent or legal guardian has provided false or
unreliable evidence of residency. Statutes do not define “reasonable
efforts” nor provide examples of what constitutes reasonable
efforts. This bill requires school districts’ policies to require
schools to make reasonable efforts to determine whether a student
resides in the district before hiring a private investigator. It
appears that reasonable efforts may range from a discussion with
parents about the belief that false or unreliable evidence of
residency was provided, to hiring a private investigator.
This
bill requires school districts’ policies to prohibit the
surreptitious photographing or video-recording of students, and
provides some guidance as to what is considered “surreptitious.”
This bill does not prohibit all photographing or video-recording of
students.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: No Local: No
California Federation of Teachers
California State PTA
California Teachers Association
Pittsburg Unified School District
Public Advocates
OPPOSITION: (Verified 6/30/15)
California Association of Licensed Investigators, Inc.
California School Boards Association
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: According to Public Advocates, “if districts believe the documentation is false, current law authorizes them to make reasonable efforts to determine whether a student has met the district residency requirement. This bill will provide notice to the public that investigations may occur and how they will be conducted. It will also require investigators to identify themselves when interviewing or making contact and specifically prohibit surreptitious photography of students being investigated.”
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION: According to the California School Boards Association, “the requirement that districts ‘identify specific, articulable facts’ supporting their findings could force districts to compromise the confidentiality of those who provide information in connection to investigations. It is unclear what the rationale is for the prohibition against the use of photography. There is no harm to children by the use of photography in these investigations, and photos are not distributed. Photography provides a great level of detail without requiring investigators to come into direct contact with children.”
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 74-0, 5/22/15
AYES: Achadjian, Travis Allen, Baker, Bigelow, Bloom, Bonilla, Bonta, Brough, Brown, Burke, Calderon, Campos, Chang, Chau, Chávez, Chiu, Chu, Cooley, Cooper, Dababneh, Dahle, Daly, Dodd, Eggman, Frazier, Beth Gaines, Gallagher, Cristina Garcia, Eduardo Garcia, Gatto, Gipson, Gomez, Gonzalez, Gordon, Gray, Grove, Harper, Roger Hernández, Holden, Irwin, Jones, Jones-Sawyer, Kim, Lackey, Levine, Linder, Lopez, Low, Maienschein, Mathis, Mayes, McCarty, Medina, Melendez, Mullin, Nazarian, Obernolte, Patterson, Perea, Quirk, Rendon, Ridley-Thomas, Rodriguez, Salas, Santiago, Steinorth, Mark Stone, Thurmond, Ting, Wagner, Wilk, Williams, Wood, Atkins
NO VOTE RECORDED: Alejo, Hadley, O'Donnell, Olsen, Waldron, Weber
Prepared by: Lynn Lorber / ED. / (916) 651-4105
7/1/15 14:55:58
**** END ****
AB 1101 (Bonilla) Page 4 of 4
SENATE COMMITTEE ON EDUCATION
Senator Carol Liu, Chair
2015 - 2016 Regular
Bill No: AB 1101
Author: |
Bonilla |
||
Version: |
June 17, 2015 Hearing Date: June 24, 2015 |
||
Urgency: |
No |
Fiscal: |
No |
Consultant: |
Lynn Lorber |
||
Subject: Pupil school enrollment: residency requirements: policy on investigations
SUMMARY
This bill requires a school district that elects to investigate the residency of a student to first adopt a policy regarding such investigations.
BACKGROUND
Existing law:
Requires students to attend the public full-time day school or continuation school or classes in which the residency of either the parent or legal guardian is located. (Education Code § 48200)
Provides that a student complies with the residency requirements for school attendance in a school district if the student:
Is placed within the boundaries of the school district in a licensed children’s institution, licensed foster home, or a foster family home.
If a foster child who remains in his or her school of origin.
Has been approved for interdistrict attendance.
Resides within the boundaries of the school districts and whose parent or legal guardian is relieved of responsibility, control, and authority through emancipation.
Lives in the home of a caregiving adult that is located within the boundaries of that school district.
Resides in a state hospital located within the boundaries of the school district. (EC § 48204)
Until July 1, 2017, authorizes school districts to deem a student to have complied with the residency requirements for school attendance in a school district if at least one parent or the legal guardian is physically employed within the boundaries of that district for a minimum of 10 hours during the school week.
School districts are not required to admit a student with at least one parent or legal guardian who is physically employed in the district.
A school district may prohibit the transfer of a student if the district determines that the transfer would negatively impact the court-ordered or voluntary desegregation plan of the district, or if the district determines that the additional cost of educating the student would exceed the amount of additional state aid received as a result of the transfer. (EC § 48204)
Requires school districts to accept from the parent or legal guardian reasonable evidence that the student meets the residency requirements for school attendance in the district. Current law requires reasonable evidence of residency to be established by documentation showing the name and address of the parent or legal guardian within the school district, including but not limited to the following:
Property tax payment receipts.
Rental property contract, lease, or payment receipts.
Utility service contract, statement, or payment receipts.
Pay stubs.
Voter registration.
Correspondence from a government agency.
Declaration of residency executed by the parent or legal guardian.
(EC § 48204.1)
Authorizes school districts to make reasonable efforts to determine that the student actually meets the residency requirements if an employee of the district reasonably believes that the parent or legal guardian has provided false or unreliable evidence of residency. (EC § 48204.1)
ANALYSIS
This bill requires a school district that elects to investigate the residency of a student to first adopt a policy regarding such investigations. Specifically, this bill:
Requires the governing board of a school district, if the district elects to undertake an investigation to determine if a student meets residency requirements, to adopt a policy regarding the investigation of a student to determine residency for school attendance before investigating any students.
Requires the policy to do all of the following:
Identify the circumstances upon which the school district may initiate an investigation, which must, at a minimum, require the school district employee to be able to identify specific, articulable facts supporting the belief that the parent or legal guardian has provided false or unreliable evidence of residency.
Describe the investigatory methods that may be used by the school district in the conduct of the investigation, including whether the school district will be employing the services of a private investigator.
Require the school district to make reasonable efforts to determine whether the student resides in the school district before hiring a private investigator.
Prohibit the surreptitious photographing of students who are being investigated.
Require that employees and contractors of the school district engaged in the investigation identify themselves truthfully as such to individuals contacted or interviewed during the course of the investigation.
Provide a process whereby the determination of a school district as to whether a student meets residency requirements may be appealed, and specify the basis for that determination. Provides that the burden is on the appealing party to show why the decision of the school district should be overruled.
Requires the policy to be adopted at a public meeting of the school district governing board.
STAFF
COMMENTS
Need for the bill. According to the author, “In November 2014, the Orinda Union School District hired a private investigator to determine whether or not seven year old Vivian met the residency requirements to attend second grade in the school district. The investigator visited Vivian’s old neighborhood where he lied to neighbors and Vivian’s mother, Maria. He claimed he was a car insurance reviewer looking into an auto accident involving Maria’s car. The investigator was unaware that Maria filed a domestic violence restraining order against her ex-husband. Maria took these actions to keep her and her daughter’s real residence hidden. Through these duplicitous investigatory techniques, the investigator incorrectly determined that Vivian lived outside of the school district. The family received a letter from the school district explaining that Vivian was dismissed from attending school in the district. The Orinda Union School District did not provide the family with any evidence or reasons as to why they initiated the investigation.”
Investigative tools. Existing law authorizes school districts to make reasonable efforts to determine that the student actually meets the residency requirements if an employee of the district reasonably believes that the parent or legal guardian has provided false or unreliable evidence of residency. Statutes do not define “reasonable efforts” nor provide examples of what constitutes reasonable efforts. This bill requires school districts’ policies to require schools to make reasonable efforts to determine whether a student resides in the district before hiring a private investigator. It appears that reasonable efforts may range from a discussion with parents about the belief that false or unreliable evidence of residency was provided, to hiring a private investigator.
This bill requires school districts’ policies to prohibit the surreptitious photographing of students. It is not clear that this bill prohibits all photographing of students. Does it depend on whether a student has a reasonable expectation of privacy? May an investigator take photos of a student in a public setting? Is photographing students a necessary investigative tool? The author may wish to include a definition of “surreptitious” for the purposes of this bill.
Fiscal impact. This bill is flagged as being non-fiscal.
Related and prior legislation.
RELATED LEGISLATION
SB 200 (Lara, 2015) provides that a student meets residency requirements for school attendance if the student’s parent or legal guardian is employed and lives at the place of employment within the boundaries of the school district for at least three days during the school week. SB 200 is pending in the Assembly Appropriations Committee.
PRIOR LEGISLATION
AB 207 (Ammiano, Ch. 435, 2011) required school districts to accept reasonable evidence that the student meets residency requirements, and requires reasonable evidence to be established by documentation showing the name and address of the parent within the school district. AB 207 further specified that such documentation includes, but is not limited to, property tax payment receipts; rental property contract, lease or payment receipts; utility service contract, statement, or payment receipts; pay stubs; voter registration; correspondence from a government agency; and, declaration of residency executed by the parent or legal guardian.
SUPPORT
California Federation of Teachers
California State PTA
Public Advocates
OPPOSITION
California School Boards Association
-- END --
AB 1101
Page 3
ASSEMBLY THIRD READING
AB 1101
(Bonilla)
As Amended May 20, 2015
Majority vote
Committee |
Votes |
Ayes |
Noes |
Education |
7-0 |
O'Donnell, Chávez, Kim, McCarty, Santiago, Thurmond, Weber |
|
SUMMARY: Requires a school district that elects to undertake an investigation to determine whether a pupil meets residency requirements to adopt a policy regarding the investigation of a pupil before investigating any pupils. Specifically, this bill:
Requires the policy to identify the circumstances upon which the school district may initiate an investigation, which shall, at a minimum, require the school district employee to be able to identify specific, articulable facts supporting the belief that the parent or legal guardian of the pupil has provided false or unreliable evidence of residency.
Requires the policy to describe the investigatory methods that may be used by the school district in the conduct of the investigation, including whether the district will be employing the services of a private investigator.
Requires the policy to prohibit the surreptitious photographing of pupils who are being investigated.
Specifies that the policy shall require that employees and contractors of the school district engaged in the investigation must identify themselves truthfully as such to individuals contacted or interviewed during the course of the investigation.
Requires the policy to provide a process whereby the determination of a school district as to whether a pupil meets the residency requirements for school attendance in the school district may be appealed, and specify the basis for that determination. Specifies that if an appeal is made, the burden shall be on the appealing party to show why the decision of the school district should be overruled.
Requires the policy required pursuant to this bill to be adopted at a public meeting of the governing board of the school district.
FISCAL EFFECT: None
COMMENTS: Under current law, compulsory education begins at age six until age 18. Any person subject to compulsory education found away from home without a valid excuse for not attending school can be arrested by school officials or peace or probation officers. A pupil is required to attend school in the district in which the residency of either the parent or legal guardian is located. Documentation of residency includes property tax payment receipts; rental property contract, lease, or payment receipts; utility service contract, statement, or payment receipts; pay stubs; voter registration; correspondence from a government agency; or declaration of residency executed by the parent or legal guardian. If an employee of a school district reasonably believes that the parent or legal guardian of a pupil has provided false or unreliable evidence of residency, the school district is authorized to make reasonable efforts to determine whether the pupil meets residency requirements.
What does this bill do? This bill requires a school district that elects to investigate a pupil's residency to adopt a policy regarding such investigations. This bill requires the policy to be adopted at a governing board meeting and to contain the following:
Identify the circumstances upon which the school district may initiate an investigation, which shall, at a minimum, require the school district employee to be able to identify specific, articulable facts supporting the belief that the parent or legal guardian of the pupil has provided false or unreliable evidence of residency. The policy must also describe the investigatory method to be used by the school district to conduct the investigation, including whether the district will be hiring private investigators.
Prohibit photographing of a pupil involved in the investigation.
Require that employees and contractors of the school district must identify themselves truthfully when contacting or interviewing individuals during the investigation.
Provide an appeals process. If a parent or legal guardian appeals the decision of a school district, the burden for showing why the decision should be overruled falls on the appealing party.
Purpose of this bill. The author states, "Schools should have tools available to investigate residency issues, but we need to ensure safeguards are in place to protect those students being investigated especially elementary school-aged children." The author cites, as an example, a Contra Costa Times report of the investigatory tactics undertaken by investigators hired by the Orinda Union School District to investigate a seven-year-old girl the school district disenrolled last fall. According to the article, the investigator told the mother of the child named Vivian and neighbors at the family's old neighborhood that he was a car insurance investigator. The school district later reversed the decision to remove the child from the school district when it learned that the mother was a live-in nanny for a couple residing in the Orinda Union School District that was her primary residence. The little girl was in the other neighborhood spending time with her great-grandmother, who was ill. The article reports that hiring investigators to investigate residency issues is not uncommon, especially for smaller school districts that are unable to dedicate staff for this purpose. Investigators interviewed in the article acknowledge that they do hide their identity in hopes that people will "rat the kids out" unwittingly.
Current law simply says that a school district may make "reasonable efforts" to determine a pupil's residency. The law does not specify how that is to be done.
It is unclear how many districts hire private investigators to conduct residency checks. School districts are funded through the Local Control Funding Formula (LCFF) based on an average daily attendance basis. Increasing enrollment increases funding for schools, except for those deemed basic aid districts. Basic aid districts do not receive or receive minimal LCFF because their local property taxes provide higher levels of funding than they would receive through LCFF. These districts would not benefit from increased enrollment. A basic aid status can fluctuate from year to year. In 2014 to 2015, there were 144 basic aid districts in the state.
The author may wish to consider requiring a school district to make an attempt to reconcile any questions or problems (e.g., two documents containing two different addresses) prior to hiring an investigator. A parent or legal guardian may be able to clear up any discrepancy or the parent or legal guardian may tell the truth, which could avoid the employment of a private investigator.
Arguments in support. The author states, "AB 1101 protects student safety and privacy by requiring school boards to adopt a policy when a private investigator is hired to conduct an investigation to determine whether a student resides within the school district boundaries. AB 1101 protects children, like Vivian, from questionable investigatory techniques such as lying to family members and neighbors and taking surreptitious photos of young students. This bill creates more transparency and disclosure in student residency investigations and provides for due process in challenging a student's home residency."
Arguments in opposition. The California School Boards Association states that this bill "enables those looking to evade a school district's efforts to implement statutory residency criteria by requiring governing boards to adopt board policies containing details about the procedures and parameters of these investigations. The requirement that districts' identify specific, articulable facts' supporting their findings could force districts to compromise the confidentiality of those who provide information in connection to investigations. The latter would have a detrimental effect on the willingness of school district employees and community members to provide true and accurate information to investigators."
Analysis Prepared by: Sophia Kwong Kim / ED. / (916) 319-2087 FN: 0000485
AB 1101
Page 5
Date of Hearing: May 13, 2015
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON EDUCATION
Patrick O'Donnell, Chair
AB 1101
(Bonilla) – As Amended May 5, 2015
SUBJECT: Pupil school enrollment: residency requirements: investigation
SUMMARY: Requires a school district that elects to undertake an investigation to determine whether a pupil meets residency requirements to adopt a policy regarding the investigation of the pupil before investigating any pupils. Specifically, this bill:
Requires the policy to identify the circumstances upon which the school district may initiate an investigation, which shall, at a minimum, require the school district employee to be able to identify specific, articulable facts supporting the belief that the parent or legal guardian of the pupil has provided false or unreliable evidence of residency.
Requires the policy to provide for written notification of a pupil’s parent or legal guardian when a pupil is identified as being subject to investigation under this bill. Specifies that the policy shall provide that notification of a pupil’s parent or legal guardian shall occur at least five business days before the start of the investigation, and shall describe the investigatory methods that may be used by the school district in the conduct of the investigation.
Requires the written notice to include school district's contact information, which a pupil’s parent or legal guardian may use to request information from or provide information to the school district regarding the investigation.
Requires the policy to prohibit the surreptitious photographing of pupils who are being investigated.
Specifies that the policy shall require that employees and contractors of the school district engaged in the investigation must identify themselves truthfully as such to individuals contacted or interviewed during the course of the investigation.
Requires the policy to provide a process whereby the determination of a school district as to whether a pupil meets the residency requirements for school attendance in the school district may be appealed, and specify the basis for that determination. Specifies that if an appeal is made, the burden shall be on the appealing party to show why the decision of the school district should be overruled.
Requires the policy required pursuant to this bill to be adopted at a public meeting of the governing board of the school district.
EXISTING LAW:
Specifies that each person between the ages of 6 and 18 years, unless otherwise exempted, is subject to compulsory full-time education. Requires each person subject to compulsory full-time education and each person subject to compulsory continuation education to attend the public full-time day school or continuation school or classes and for the full time designated as the length of the schoolday by the governing board of the school district in which the residency of either the parent or legal guardian is located, and requires each parent, guardian, or other person having control or charge of the pupil to send the pupil to the public full-time day school or continuation school or classes and for the full time designated as the length of the schoolday by the governing board of the school district in which the residence of either the parent or legal guardian is located. (Education Code (EC) Section 48200)
Provides that a student complies with the residency requirements for school attendance in a school district if the student:
Is placed within the boundaries of the school district in a licensed children’s institution, licensed foster home, or a foster family home.
Is a foster child who remains in his or her school of origin.
Has been approved for interdistrict attendance.
Resides within the boundaries of the school districts and whose parent or legal guardian is relieved of responsibility, control, and authority through emancipation.
Lives in the home of a caregiving adult that is located within the boundaries of that school district.
Resides in a state hospital located within the boundaries of the school district. (EC Section 48204)
Authorizes, until July 1, 2017, school districts to deem a student to have complied with the residency requirements for school attendance in a school district if at least one parent or the legal guardian is physically employed within the boundaries of that district for a minimum of 10 hours during the school week. (EC Section 48204)
Requires a school district to accept from the parent or legal guardian reasonable evidence that the student meets the residency requirements for school attendance in the district. Requires reasonable evidence of residency to be established by documentation showing the name and address of the parent or legal guardian within the school district, including but not limited to, the following:
Property tax payment receipts.
Rental property contract, lease, or payment receipts.
Utility service contract, statement, or payment receipts.
Pay stubs.
Voter registration.
Correspondence from a government agency.
Declaration of residency executed by the parent or legal guardian. (EC Section 48204.1)
Authorizes a school district to make reasonable efforts to determine that the student actually meets the residency requirements if an employee of the district reasonably believes that the parent or legal guardian has provided false or unreliable evidence of residency. (EC Section 48204.1)
FISCAL EFFECT: None. This bill is keyed non-fiscal by the Legislative Counsel.
COMMENTS: Under current law, compulsory education begins at age 6 until age 18. Any person subject to compulsory education found away from home without a valid excuse for not attending school can be arrested by school officials or peace or probation officers. A pupil is required to attend school in the district in which the residency of either the parent or legal guardian is located. Documentation or residency includes property tax payment receipts; rental property contract, lease, or payment receipts; utility service contract, statement, or payment receipts; pay stubs; voter registration; correspondence from a government agency; or declaration of residency executed by the parent or legal guardian. If an employee of a school district reasonably believes that the parent or legal guardian of a pupil has provided false or unreliable evidence of residency, the school district is authorized to make reasonable efforts to determine whether the pupil meets residency requirements.
What does this bill do? This bill requires a school district that elects to investigate a pupil's residency to adopt a policy regarding such investigations. The bill requires the policy to be adopted at a governing board meeting and to contain the following:
Identify the circumstances upon which the school district may initiate an investigation, which shall, at a minimum, require the school district employee to be able to identify specific, articulable facts supporting the belief that the parent or legal guardian of the pupil has provided false or unreliable evidence of residency. The policy must also describe the investigatory method to be used by the school district to conduct the investigation.
Provide a written notification at least five days before the start of an investigation to the pupil's parent or legal guardian. The notification must also provide school district contact information that the parent or legal guardian may use to request or to provide information regarding the investigation.
Prohibit photographing of a pupil involved in the investigation.
Require that employees and contractors of the school district must identify themselves truthfully when contacting or interviewing individuals during the investigation.
Provide an appeals process. If a parent or legal guardian appeals the decision of a school district, the burden for showing why the decision should be overruled falls on the appealing party.
Purpose of the bill. The author states, "Schools should have tools available to investigate residency issues, but we need to ensure safeguards are in place to protect those students being investigated especially elementary school-aged children." The author cites, as an example, a Contra Costa Times report of the investigatory tactics undertaken by investigators hired by the Orinda Union School District to investigate a seven-year-old girl the school district disenrolled last fall. According to the article, the investigator told the mother of the child named Vivian and neighbors at the family's old neighborhood that he was a car insurance investigator. The school district later reversed the decision to remove the child from the school district when it learned that the mother was a live-in nanny for a couple residing in the Orinda Union School District that was her primary residence. The little girl was in the other neighborhood spending time with her great-grandmother, who was ill. The article reports that hiring investigators to investigate residency issues is not uncommon, especially for smaller school districts that are unable to dedicate staff for this purpose. Investigators interviewed acknowledge that they do hide their identity in hopes that people will "rat the kids out" unwittingly.
Current law simply says that a school district may make "reasonable efforts" to determine a pupil's residency. The law does not specify how that is to be done.
It is unclear how many districts hire private investigators to conduct residency checks. School districts are funded through the Local Control Funding Formula (LCFF) based on an average daily attendance basis. Increasing enrollment increases funding for schools, except for those deemed basic aid districts. Basic aid districts do not receive LCFF because their local property taxes provide higher levels of funding than they would receive through LCFF. These districts would not benefit from increased enrollment. A basic aid status can fluctuate from year to year. In 2014-15, there were 144 basic aid districts in the state.
Issues to consider:
Should districts be required to notify parents or legal guardians? This bill requires a school district to provide written notification to a parent or a legal guardian five business days prior to starting an investigation and provide the basis for the reasonable belief supporting the need for the investigation. The notice must also include school district contact information. The author states that in the Orinda Union School District case, the parent was never informed of the reason the pupil was being investigated. The California School Boards Association (CSBA) opposes the bill and expresses concerns that this provision of the bill undermines the investigatory process. If parents or legal guardians are aware of a pending investigation, they may change their behavior and take actions that will prevent a school district from getting an accurate portrayal of the situation. Staff recommends striking this provision of the bill.
Alternatively, the Committee may wish to consider requiring a school district to make an attempt to reconcile any questions or problems (e.g., two documents containing two different addresses), prior to hiring an investigator. A parent or legal guardian may be able to clear up any discrepancy, or the parent or legal guardian may tell the truth, which could avoid the employment of a private investigator.
Should photographing of pupils be prohibited? Photographing of pupils raises privacy concerns. The American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU) supports the bill and states, "The ACLU is deeply concerned about the surveillance of young children and the potentiality that investigations of student residency may be inappropriately motivated and inadequately conducted." School districts will argue that photographs are an effective way of documenting where pupils may reside. The CSBA states that "photography provides a great level of detail without requiring investigators to come into direct contact with children. Absent this tool, district investigators may need to approach and speak with students instead."
Arguments in support. The author states, "AB 1101 protects student safety and privacy by requiring school boards to adopt a policy when a private investigator is hired to conduct an investigation to determine whether a student resides within the school district boundaries. AB 1101 protects children, like Vivian, from questionable investigatory techniques such as lying to family members and neighbors and taking surreptitious photos of young students. This bill creates more transparency and disclosure in student residency investigations and provides for due process in challenging a student’s home residency."
Arguments in opposition. The California School Boards Association states that the bill "enables those looking to evade a school district’s efforts to implement statutory residency criteria by requiring governing boards to adopt board policies containing details about the procedures and parameters of these investigations. The requirement that districts 'identify specific, articulable facts' supporting their findings could force districts to compromise the confidentiality of those who provide information in connection to investigations. The latter would have a detrimental effect on the willingness of school district employees and community members to provide true and accurate information to investigators."
Related legislation. SB 200 (Lara), pending in the Assembly, provides that a student meets residency requirements for school attendance if the student’s parent or legal guardian is employed and lives with the student at the place of employment within the boundaries of the school district for at least three days during the school week.
SB 445 (Liu), pending in the Senate, extends to homeless youth the right to remain in the school of origin, as is currently provided to foster youth.
Prior related legislation. AB 207 (Ammiano), Chapter 435, Statutes of 2011, requires school districts to accept reasonable evidence that a pupil meets residency requirements for school attendance within the district; and, specifies certain types of documents that shall be considered reasonable evidence for a pupil living with his or her parent or legal guardian.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
American Civil Liberties Union
California Immigrant Policy Center
California Teachers Association
Common Sense Kids Action
Pleasanton Unified School District
Social Justice Learning Institute
Opposition
California School Boards Association
Analysis Prepared by: Sophia Kwong Kim / ED. / (916) 319-2087
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):