AB 1196: Peace officers: use of force.
- Session Year: 2019-2020
- House: Assembly
- Latest Version Date: 2020-09-30
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Sep 30, 2020 | Chaptered by Secretary of State - Chapter 324, Statutes of 2020. |
| Sep 30, 2020 | Approved by the Governor. |
| Sep 14, 2020 | Enrolled and presented to the Governor at 4 p.m. |
| Aug 31, 2020 | Action rescinded whereby the bill was re-referred to Com. on PUB. S. pursuant to Assembly Rule 77.2. |
| Aug 30, 2020 | In Assembly. Concurrence in Senate amendments pending. |
| Aug 30, 2020 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Assembly. (Ayes 33. Noes 1.). |
| Aug 25, 2020 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| Aug 24, 2020 | Read third time and amended. Ordered to second reading. |
| Aug 20, 2020 | From committee: Do pass. (Ayes 5. Noes 1.) (August 20). |
| Aug 17, 2020 | In committee: Referred to APPR. suspense file. |
| Aug 8, 2020 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 6. Noes 1.) (August 7). Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Jul 9, 2020 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to committee. Read second time, amended, and re-referred to Com. on PUB. S. |
| Jul 1, 2020 | Re-referred to Com. on PUB. S. |
| Jun 18, 2020 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to committee. Read second time, amended, and re-referred to Com. on RLS. |
| Jun 17, 2020 | Referred to Com. on RLS. |
| Jan 30, 2020 | In Senate. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. |
| Jan 30, 2020 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Senate. (Ayes 61. Noes 12. Page 3941.) |
| Jan 28, 2020 | From inactive file. |
| Jan 27, 2020 | Notice of intention to remove from inactive file given by Assembly Member Gipson. |
| May 22, 2019 | Ordered to inactive file at the request of Assembly Member Gipson. |
| May 20, 2019 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| May 16, 2019 | From committee: Do pass. (Ayes 13. Noes 4.) (May 16). |
| May 8, 2019 | In committee: Set, first hearing. Referred to APPR. suspense file. |
| Apr 30, 2019 | Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Apr 29, 2019 | Read second time and amended. |
| Apr 25, 2019 | From committee: Amend, and do pass as amended and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 5. Noes 2.) (April 24). |
| Mar 27, 2019 | Re-referred to Com. on ED. |
| Mar 26, 2019 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to Com. on ED. Read second time and amended. |
| Mar 25, 2019 | Referred to Com. on ED. |
| Feb 22, 2019 | From printer. May be heard in committee March 24. |
| Feb 21, 2019 | Read first time. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Aug 31, 2020 | AB 1196 GIPSON Concurrence in Senate Amendments | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| Aug 30, 2020 | Assembly 3rd Reading AB1196 Gipson et al. By Durazo | Senate Floor |
Passed |
|
| Aug 20, 2020 | Do pass | Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Aug 17, 2020 | Placed on suspense file | Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Aug 7, 2020 | Do pass, but first be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Senate Standing Committee on Public Safety |
Passed |
|
| Jan 30, 2020 | AB 1196 Gipson Assembly Third Reading | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| May 16, 2019 | Do pass. | Assembly Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Apr 24, 2019 | Do pass as amended and be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Assembly Standing Committee on Education |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
CONCURRENCE IN SENATE AMENDMENTS
CSA1 Bill Id:AB 1196
Author:(Gipson, et al.)
As Amended Ver:August 24, 2020
Majority vote
SUMMARY:
Prohibits law enforcement agencies from authorizing carotid restraint holds and choke holds.
The Senate Amendments
Delete the assembly version of this bill and instead:
- Prohibit a law enforcement agency from authorizing the use of a carotid restraint hold or a choke hold as defined.
- Define "carotid restraint" as a vascular neck restraint or any similar restraint, hold, or other defensive tactic in which pressure is applied to the sides of a person's neck that involves a substantial risk of restricting blood flow and may render the person unconscious in order to subdue or control the person.
- Define "choke hold" means any defensive tactic or force option in which direct pressure is applied to a person's trachea or windpipe.
COMMENTS:
According to the Author:
AB 1196 seeks to eliminate the use of chokeholds, carotid restraints, and techniques or transport methods with a high risk of positional asphyxia by law enforcement.
The carotid restraint is one of the most commonly used strangleholds. To perform this hold, a peace officer applies pressure on either side of the windpipe—but not on the windpipe itself—to slow or stop the flow of blood to the brain via the carotid arteries. While designed to render subjects unconscious, this hold can go wrong in two main ways: either when improperly applied, or when a subjects' physical disposition—if they suffers from coronary artery disease, for example—makes the hold dangerous or lethal. Simply maintaining restricted blood flow for one minute after the suspect is rendered unconscious can lead to irreversible brain damage.
In the Eric Garner case, NY Commissioner James O'Neill said that the officer's failure to relax his grip while subduing him triggered a fatal asthma attack. With the high profile death of George Floyd in Minneapolis, where a peace officer used his knee to subdue and detain him, it is clear that similar methods of restraining suspects are incredibly risky and should no longer be allowed.
Police Departments in cities such as San Francisco, Los Angeles, and San Diego have already taken steps to prohibit their use but statewide policies regarding neck restraints vary, which results in a lack of accountability for officers who use them. AB 1196 will create a uniform statewide policy on carotid restraints and similar techniques to ensure that these procedures can no longer be improperly applied on Californians.
Argument in Support:
According to the National Action Network:
"It is imperative peace officers remain vigilant protecting the community and serving the public with integrity. For too long we have witnessed law enforcement abuse their power with overzealous individuals using the color of law to inflict terror among its citizens. California State National Action Network (CA State NAN) recognizes there are many tactics to de-escalate and subdue a person suspected of committing a crime. We do not believe any of the tactics include killing the suspect if the officer recognizes it is not necessary to take his or her life. For this reason, CA State NAN is pleased to sponsor AB 1196, which seeks to eliminate the use of the carotid restraint statewide by law enforcement. The carotid restraint is a tactic commonly used to render suspects unconscious; however, police officers are aware this restraint can be deadly. Simply maintaining restricted blood flow for one minute after the suspect is rendered unconscious can lead to irreversible brain damage or death. For nearly twenty years as leader of NAN, our founder Rev. Al Sharpton has led efforts across the nation to recognize egregious acts of abuse by law enforcement and demands for justice and civil rights. Over the years one thing we know remains to be true; changing laws will not change the heart and mind of a racist but we pray before our God these laws deter peace officers from abusing their power and committing fatal crimes against the citizenry they are sworn to protect. For these reasons, CA State NAN is pleased to sponsor AB 1196."
Argument in Opposition:
According to the Association of Los Angeles Deputy Sheriffs:
"As currently drafted, AB 1196 would prohibit law enforcement agencies from authorizing the use of a carotid restraint and techniques or transport methods that involve a substantial risk of positional asphyxia. We certainly appreciate the author's intent, and condemn the tragic death of George Floyd in Minneapolis, MN. However, the language as drafted does not provide law enforcement officers the ability to use these trained techniques when their own life, or any other person, is at risk. It is for this reason that we request language be added to specify an officer can use these restraints if they reasonably fear they, or any other person, is in danger of great bodily injury or death. Further, to ensure the safety of a person put into carotid restraint, we suggest including language that requires a law enforcement officer to put the person into a recovery position to monitor them for signs of positional asphyxia and provide medical attention when feasible and necessary."
FISCAL COMMENTS:
According to the Senate Appropriations Committee:
- Officer retraining & transportation modifications: Unknown costs, potentially in the millions of dollars. Costs to each law enforcement agency to train their officers in accordance with a policy consistent with this measure would vary based on a number of factors, including the number of peace officers employed by the agency, salaries of the officers, overtime costs to backfill officers who are attending training, and how similar the agency's current policy (and therefore training) is to the requirements of this measure. If an agency's policy currently is in alignment with AB 1196, there would be no associated training costs. (General Fund, special funds, local funds)
By way of example, it would have cost the California Highway Patrol $4.1 million for all of its uniformed personnel—868 sergeants and 6,236 officers—to attend a four-hour training in 2019. Using those same figures, it would cost the department over $500,000 for all of its officers to attend a 30-minute training. For context, there are approximately 90,000 peace officers in the state.
This measure also may lead to additional unknown, potentially-major one-time costs for agencies to test, evaluate, and develop a new method of transporting combative individuals that could result in the purchase of new equipment and the modification of patrol cars.
- Policy revision: Unknown, potentially-significant one-time costs ranging from the tens of thousands to the hundreds of thousands in the aggregate for all state and local law enforcement agencies to update their policies in accordance with AB 1196. Some agencies employ a contract service to ensure their policies reflect recent changes in statutory and case law. This measure may require more attention to revise policies than other prohibitions on practices to the extent agencies would have to consider which alternatives are appropriate for that specific agency to adopt, particularly with respect to transporting an individual. Alternatively, some agencies, such as the University of California system, would incur no to minimal costs, as their policies generally are in alignment with this bill.
Local costs to comply with this measure would be subject to reimbursement by the state to the extent that the Commission on State Mandates determines that this bill imposes a state-mandated local program. Considering that there are over 500 local law enforcement agencies across the state, costs to implement this measure could reach into the hundreds of thousands of dollars. (General Fund, special funds, local funds)
VOTES:
ASM EDUCATION: 5-2-0
YES: O'Donnell, Kalra, McCarty, Smith, Weber
NO: Kiley, Voepel
ASM APPROPRIATIONS: 13-4-1
YES: Gonzalez, Bloom, Bonta, Calderon, Carrillo, Chau, Eggman, Gabriel, Eduardo Garcia, Maienschein, Petrie-Norris, Quirk, Robert Rivas
NO: Bigelow, Brough, Fong, Obernolte
ABS, ABST OR NV: Diep
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 61-12-7
YES: Aguiar-Curry, Arambula, Bauer-Kahan, Berman, Bloom, Boerner Horvath, Bonta, Brough, Burke, Calderon, Carrillo, Chau, Chiu, Chu, Cooley, Cooper, Daly, Eggman, Frazier, Friedman, Gabriel, Cristina Garcia, Eduardo Garcia, Gipson, Gloria, Gonzalez, Grayson, Holden, Irwin, Jones-Sawyer, Kalra, Kamlager, Levine, Limón, Low, Maienschein, Mayes, McCarty, Medina, Mullin, Muratsuchi, Nazarian, O'Donnell, Petrie-Norris, Quirk, Quirk-Silva, Ramos, Reyes, Luz Rivas, Robert Rivas, Rodriguez, Blanca Rubio, Salas, Santiago, Smith, Mark Stone, Ting, Waldron, Weber, Wicks, Wood
NO: Bigelow, Chen, Choi, Cunningham, Megan Dahle, Fong, Kiley, Lackey, Mathis, Melendez, Obernolte, Voepel
ABS, ABST OR NV: Cervantes, Diep, Flora, Gallagher, Gray, Patterson, Rendon
SENATE FLOOR: 33-1-6
YES: Allen, Archuleta, Atkins, Beall, Bradford, Caballero, Chang, Dodd, Durazo, Galgiani, Glazer, Lena Gonzalez, Grove, Hertzberg, Hill, Hueso, Hurtado, Jackson, Leyva, McGuire, Mitchell, Monning, Moorlach, Pan, Portantino, Roth, Rubio, Skinner, Stern, Umberg, Wieckowski, Wiener, Wilk
NO: Nielsen
ABS, ABST OR NV: Bates, Borgeas, Dahle, Jones, Melendez, Morrell
UPDATED:
VERSION: August 24, 2020
CONSULTANT: Matthew Fleming / PUB. S. / (916) 319-3744 FN: 0003541
SENATE RULES COMMITTEE Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | AB 1196 |
THIRD READING
Bill No: AB 1196
Author: Gipson (D), Carrillo (D), Chiu (D), Grayson (D), Santiago (D) and Weber (D), et al.
Amended: 8/24/20 in Senate
Vote: 21
SENATE PUBLIC SAFETY COMMITTEE: 6-1, 8/7/20
AYES: Skinner, Moorlach, Bradford, Jackson, Mitchell, Wiener
NOES: Morrell
SENATE APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE: 5-1, 8/20/20
AYES: Portantino, Bradford, Hill, Leyva, Wieckowski
NOES: Jones
NO VOTE RECORDED: Bates
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 61-12, 1/30/20 - See last page for vote
SUBJECT: Peace officers: use of force
SOURCE: Author
DIGEST:
This bill prohibits law enforcement agencies from authorizing 1) carotid restraint holds; and 2) choke holds.
Senate Floor Amendments of 8/24/20 (1) remove the prohibition on allowing law enforcement agencies to authorize techniques for transport method that involve substantial risk of positional asphyxia; (2) remove the definition of positional asphyxia; and (3) remove the urgency provisions from the bill.
ANALYSIS:
Existing law:
- Defines “deadly force” as any use of force that creates a substantial risk of causing death or serious bodily injury. Deadly force includes, but is not limited to, the discharge of a firearm. (Gov. Code, § 7286, subd. (a)(1).)
- Defines “feasible” means reasonably capable of being done or carried out under the circumstances to successfully achieve the arrest or lawful objective without increasing risk to the officer or another person. (Gov. Code, § 7286, subd. (a)(2).)
- Requires that each law enforcement agency shall, by no later than January 1, 2021, maintain a policy that provides a minimum standard on the use of force. Each agency’s policy shall include all of the following: (Gov. Code, § 7286, subd. (b).)
- A requirement that officers utilize deescalation techniques, crisis intervention tactics, and other alternatives to force when feasible.
- A requirement that an officer may only use a level of force that they reasonably believe is proportional to the seriousness of the suspected offense or the reasonably perceived level of actual or threatened resistance.
- A requirement that officers report potential excessive force to a superior officer when present and observing another officer using force that the officer believes to be beyond that which is necessary, as determined by an objectively reasonable officer under the circumstances based upon the totality of information actually known to the officer.
- Clear and specific guidelines regarding situations in which officers may or may not draw a firearm or point a firearm at a person.
- A requirement that officers consider their surroundings and potential risks to bystanders, to the extent reasonable under the circumstances, before discharging a firearm.
- Procedures for disclosing public records in accordance with Section 832.7.
- Procedures for the filing, investigation, and reporting of citizen complaints regarding use of force incidents.
- A requirement that an officer intercede when present and observing another officer using force that is clearly beyond that which is necessary, as determined by an objectively reasonable officer under the circumstances, taking into account the possibility that other officers may have additional information regarding the threat posed by a subject.
- Comprehensive and specific guidelines regarding approved methods and devices available for the application of force.
- An explicitly stated requirement that officers carry out duties, including use of force, in a manner that is fair and unbiased.
- Comprehensive and specific guidelines for the application of deadly force.
- Comprehensive and detailed requirements for prompt internal reporting and notification regarding a use of force incident, including reporting use of force incidents to the Department of Justice in compliance with Section 12525.2.
- The role of supervisors in the review of use of force applications.
- A requirement that officers promptly provide, if properly trained, or otherwise promptly procure medical assistance for persons injured in a use of force incident, when reasonable and safe to do so.
- Training standards and requirements relating to demonstrated knowledge and understanding of the law enforcement agency’s use of force policy by officers, investigators, and supervisors.
- Training and guidelines regarding vulnerable populations, including, but not limited to, children, elderly persons, people who are pregnant, and people with physical, mental, and developmental disabilities.
- Comprehensive and specific guidelines under which the discharge of a firearm at or from a moving vehicle may or may not be permitted.
- Factors for evaluating and reviewing all use of force incidents.
- Minimum training and course titles required to meet the objectives in the use of force policy.
- A requirement for the regular review and updating of the policy to reflect developing practices and procedures.
- Requires that each law enforcement agency shall make their use of force policy adopted pursuant to this section accessible to the public. (Gov. Code, § 7286, subd. (c).)
- Mandates that the Commission on Peace Officers Standards and Training (POST) shall implement a course or courses of instruction for the regular and periodic training of law enforcement officers in the use of force and shall also develop uniform, minimum guidelines for adoption and promulgation by California law enforcement agencies for use of force. The guidelines and course of instruction shall stress that the use of force by law enforcement personnel is of important concern to the community and law enforcement and that law enforcement should safeguard life, dignity, and liberty of all persons, without prejudice to anyone. These guidelines shall be a resource for each agency executive to use in the creation of the use of force policy that the agency is required to adopt and promulgate pursuant to Section 7286 of the Government Code, and that reflects the needs of the agency, the jurisdiction it serves, and the law. The course or courses of the regular basic course for law enforcement officers and the guidelines shall include specified guidelines. (Penal Code, § 13519.10)
This bill:
- Prohibits a law enforcement agency from authorizing the use of:
- A carotid restraint hold.
- A choke hold.
- Techniques or transport methods that involve a substantial risk of positional asphyxia.
- A carotid restraint hold.
- Defines the following terms as follows:
- “Carotid restraint” means a vascular neck restraint or any similar restraint, hold, or other defensive tactic in which pressure is applied to the sides of a person’s neck that involves a substantial risk of restricting blood flow and may render the person unconscious in order to subdue or control the person.
- “Choke hold” means any defensive tactic or force option in which direct pressure is applied to a person’s trachea or windpipe.
- “Carotid restraint” means a vascular neck restraint or any similar restraint, hold, or other defensive tactic in which pressure is applied to the sides of a person’s neck that involves a substantial risk of restricting blood flow and may render the person unconscious in order to subdue or control the person.
Background
Choke holds have been effectively banned in California, but not expressly banned. The practice fell out of favor over many years due to serious injury and death caused by the usage of the technique. Over many years both federal and State of California courts have found the practice subjects municipalities, government entities, and law enforcement agencies that permit the usage liable for wrongful death and serious injury to persons who have been subjected to the use of a choke hold by law enforcement agencies. As a result of these findings of liability, the usage of choke holds fell out of favor and cities and agencies routinely banned their usage. Additionally, the Commission on Peace Officer Standards and Training (POST) ceased instruction on the technique. However, the practice has never been expressly banned in California statute and this bill seeks to make that clarification.
Carotid restraint is very similar to a choke hold. The practice involves the cutting-off of blood circulation to the head of the person upon which the hold is placed. This process can cause the person to lose consciousness. This technique has conventionally been taught to be less deadly than a traditional choke hold which can more easily collapse the wind pipe because it’s focused on the front of the neck. However, a slight deviation in the placement of the arm of the person implementing the hold can convert a carotid restraint into a choke hold. Additionally, cutting off blood flow to a person’s brain has its own dangers.
This bill prohibits both practices in the State of California by law enforcement. Additionally, this bill would make sure that law enforcement agencies need to transport detained persons and persons otherwise in the custody of law enforcement in a manner that will not result in asphyxiation.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: Yes Local: Yes
According to the Senate Appropriations Committee:
- Officer retraining & transportation modifications: Unknown costs, potentially in the millions of dollars. Costs to each law enforcement agency to train their officers in accordance with a policy consistent with this measure would vary based on a number of factors, including the number of peace officers employed by the agency, salaries of the officers, overtime costs to backfill officers who are attending training, and how similar the agency’s current policy (and therefore training) is to the requirements of this measure. If an agency’s policy currently is in alignment with AB 1196, there would be no associated training costs. (General Fund, special funds, local funds)
By way of example, it would have cost the California Highway Patrol $4.1 million for all of its uniformed personnel—868 sergeants and 6,236 officers—to attend a four-hour training in 2019. Using those same figures, it would cost the department over $500,000 for all of its officers to attend a 30-minute training. For context, there are approximately 90,000 peace officers in the state.
This measure also may lead to additional unknown, potentially-major one-time costs for agencies to test, evaluate, and develop a new method of transporting combative individuals that could result in the purchase of new equipment and the modification of patrol cars.
- Policy revision: Unknown, potentially-significant one-time costs ranging from the tens of thousands to the hundreds of thousands in the aggregate for all state and local law enforcement agencies to update their policies in accordance with AB 1196. Some agencies employ a contract service to ensure their policies reflect recent changes in statutory and case law. This measure may require more attention to revise policies than other prohibitions on practices to the extent agencies would have to consider which alternatives are appropriate for that specific agency to adopt, particularly with respect to transporting an individual. Alternatively, some agencies, such as the University of California system, would incur no to minimal costs, as their policies generally are in alignment with this bill.
Local costs to comply with this measure would be subject to reimbursement by the state to the extent that the Commission on State Mandates determines that this bill imposes a state-mandated local program. Considering that there are over 500 local law enforcement agencies across the state, costs to implement this measure could reach into the hundreds of thousands of dollars. (General Fund, special funds, local funds)
SUPPORT: (Verified 8/25/20)
Advancement Project
Alliance for Boys and Men of Color
Alliance San Diego
American Civil Liberties Union – California
Anti-Defamation League
Asian Americans Advancing Justice – California
Association of Black Women Physicians
Brady California United Against Gun Violence
California Academy of Family Physicians
California Association of Black Lawyers
California Attorneys for Criminal Justice
California Dental Association
California Department of Insurance
California Department of Justice
California Immigrant Policy Center
California Natural Gas Vehicle Coalition
California Nurses Association
California Pan-Ethnic Health Network
California Psychological Association
California Public Defenders Association
California State Council of Service Employees International Union
California State National Action Network
California Teachers Association
Californiahealth+ Advocates
City of Alameda
City of Lafayette
City of Long Beach
Communities United for Restorative Youth Justice
Community Clinic Association of Los Angeles County
Compass Family Services
Consumer Attorneys of California
Disability Rights California
Ella Baker Center for Human Rights
Empowering Pacific Islander Communities
Everytown for Gun Safety Action Fund
Fresno Barrios Unidos
Friends Committee on Legislation of California
Giffords Law Center
Having Our Say Coalition
Health Access California
Indivisible – Marin
Indivisible – Sausalito
Initiate Justice
John Burton Advocates for Youth
Latino Coalition for a Healthy California
Legal Services for Prisoners with Children
Los Angeles County
Los Angeles LGBT Center
Los Angeles Office of Education
Los Angeles Regional Reentry Partnership
Mid-City Community Advocacy Network
Momentum United
NARAL Pro-Choice California
National Action Network
National Association of Social Workers – California
Phi Beta Sigma Fraternity
Planned Parenthood – California
PolicyLink
Public Health Advocates
Rubicon Programs
Salesforce
Showing Up for Racial Justice – San Diego
Silicon Valley Leadership Group
Stop Coalition
SURJ – Marin
The Arc
Time for Change Foundation
UDW/AFSCME Local 3930
United Cerebral Palsy – California
W. Haywood Burns Institute
Youth Alive!
Youth Justice Coalition
OPPOSITION: (Verified 8/25/20)
Association for Los Angeles Deputy Sheriffs
Association of Orange County Deputy Sheriffs
California Association of Highway Patrolmen
California Fraternal Order of Police
Peace Officers Research Association of California
Riverside Sheriffs’ Association
Sacramento County Deputy Sheriffs Association
San Bernardino County Safety Employees’ Benefit Association
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 61-12, 1/30/20
AYES: Aguiar-Curry, Arambula, Bauer-Kahan, Berman, Bloom, Boerner Horvath, Bonta, Brough, Burke, Calderon, Carrillo, Chau, Chiu, Chu, Cooley, Cooper, Daly, Eggman, Frazier, Friedman, Gabriel, Cristina Garcia, Eduardo Garcia, Gipson, Gloria, Gonzalez, Grayson, Holden, Irwin, Jones-Sawyer, Kalra, Kamlager, Levine, Limón, Low, Maienschein, Mayes, McCarty, Medina, Mullin, Muratsuchi, Nazarian, O'Donnell, Petrie-Norris, Quirk, Quirk-Silva, Ramos, Reyes, Luz Rivas, Robert Rivas, Rodriguez, Blanca Rubio, Salas, Santiago, Smith, Mark Stone, Ting, Waldron, Weber, Wicks, Wood
NOES: Bigelow, Chen, Choi, Cunningham, Megan Dahle, Fong, Kiley, Lackey, Mathis, Melendez, Obernolte, Voepel
NO VOTE RECORDED: Cervantes, Diep, Flora, Gallagher, Gray, Patterson, Rendon
Prepared by: Gabe Caswell / PUB. S. /
8/25/20 15:24:53
**** END ****
SENATE RULES COMMITTEE Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | AB 1196 |
THIRD READING
Bill No: AB 1196
Author: Gipson (D), Carrillo (D), Chiu (D), Grayson (D), Santiago (D) and Weber (D), et al.
Amended: 7/9/20 in Senate
Vote: 27 - Urgency
SENATE PUBLIC SAFETY COMMITTEE: 6-1, 8/7/20
AYES: Skinner, Moorlach, Bradford, Jackson, Mitchell, Wiener
NOES: Morrell
SENATE APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE: 5-1, 8/20/20
AYES: Portantino, Bradford, Hill, Leyva, Wieckowski
NOES: Jones
NO VOTE RECORDED: Bates
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 61-12, 1/30/20 - See last page for vote
SUBJECT: Peace officers: use of force
SOURCE: Author
DIGEST:
This bill prohibits law enforcement agencies from authorizing 1) carotid restraint holds; 2) choke holds; and 3) techniques or transport methods that involve a substantial risk of positional asphyxia.
ANALYSIS:
Existing law:
- Defines “deadly force” as any use of force that creates a substantial risk of causing death or serious bodily injury. Deadly force includes, but is not limited to, the discharge of a firearm. (Gov. Code, § 7286, subd. (a)(1).)
- Defines “feasible” means reasonably capable of being done or carried out under the circumstances to successfully achieve the arrest or lawful objective without increasing risk to the officer or another person. (Gov. Code, § 7286, subd. (a)(2).)
- Requires that each law enforcement agency shall, by no later than January 1, 2021, maintain a policy that provides a minimum standard on the use of force. Each agency’s policy shall include all of the following: (Gov. Code, § 7286, subd. (b).)
- A requirement that officers utilize deescalation techniques, crisis intervention tactics, and other alternatives to force when feasible.
- A requirement that an officer may only use a level of force that they reasonably believe is proportional to the seriousness of the suspected offense or the reasonably perceived level of actual or threatened resistance.
- A requirement that officers report potential excessive force to a superior officer when present and observing another officer using force that the officer believes to be beyond that which is necessary, as determined by an objectively reasonable officer under the circumstances based upon the totality of information actually known to the officer.
- Clear and specific guidelines regarding situations in which officers may or may not draw a firearm or point a firearm at a person.
- A requirement that officers consider their surroundings and potential risks to bystanders, to the extent reasonable under the circumstances, before discharging a firearm.
- Procedures for disclosing public records in accordance with Section 832.7.
- Procedures for the filing, investigation, and reporting of citizen complaints regarding use of force incidents.
- A requirement that an officer intercede when present and observing another officer using force that is clearly beyond that which is necessary, as determined by an objectively reasonable officer under the circumstances, taking into account the possibility that other officers may have additional information regarding the threat posed by a subject.
- Comprehensive and specific guidelines regarding approved methods and devices available for the application of force.
- An explicitly stated requirement that officers carry out duties, including use of force, in a manner that is fair and unbiased.
- Comprehensive and specific guidelines for the application of deadly force.
- Comprehensive and detailed requirements for prompt internal reporting and notification regarding a use of force incident, including reporting use of force incidents to the Department of Justice in compliance with Section 12525.2.
- The role of supervisors in the review of use of force applications.
- A requirement that officers promptly provide, if properly trained, or otherwise promptly procure medical assistance for persons injured in a use of force incident, when reasonable and safe to do so.
- Training standards and requirements relating to demonstrated knowledge and understanding of the law enforcement agency’s use of force policy by officers, investigators, and supervisors.
- Training and guidelines regarding vulnerable populations, including, but not limited to, children, elderly persons, people who are pregnant, and people with physical, mental, and developmental disabilities.
- Comprehensive and specific guidelines under which the discharge of a firearm at or from a moving vehicle may or may not be permitted.
- Factors for evaluating and reviewing all use of force incidents.
- Minimum training and course titles required to meet the objectives in the use of force policy.
- A requirement for the regular review and updating of the policy to reflect developing practices and procedures.
- Requires that each law enforcement agency shall make their use of force policy adopted pursuant to this section accessible to the public. (Gov. Code, § 7286, subd. (c).)
- Mandates that the Commission on Peace Officers Standards and Training (POST) shall implement a course or courses of instruction for the regular and periodic training of law enforcement officers in the use of force and shall also develop uniform, minimum guidelines for adoption and promulgation by California law enforcement agencies for use of force. The guidelines and course of instruction shall stress that the use of force by law enforcement personnel is of important concern to the community and law enforcement and that law enforcement should safeguard life, dignity, and liberty of all persons, without prejudice to anyone. These guidelines shall be a resource for each agency executive to use in the creation of the use of force policy that the agency is required to adopt and promulgate pursuant to Section 7286 of the Government Code, and that reflects the needs of the agency, the jurisdiction it serves, and the law. The course or courses of the regular basic course for law enforcement officers and the guidelines shall include specified guidelines. (Penal Code, § 13519.10)
This bill:
- Prohibits a law enforcement agency from authorizing the use of:
- A carotid restraint hold.
- A choke hold.
- Techniques or transport methods that involve a substantial risk of positional asphyxia.
- Defines the following terms as follows:
- “Carotid restraint” means a vascular neck restraint or any similar restraint, hold, or other defensive tactic in which pressure is applied to the sides of a person’s neck that involves a substantial risk of restricting blood flow and may render the person unconscious in order to subdue or control the person.
- “Choke hold” means any defensive tactic or force option in which direct pressure is applied to a person’s trachea or windpipe.
- “Positional asphyxia” means situating a person in a manner that compresses an individual’s airway and reduces the likelihood that an individual will be able to breathe. This includes but is not limited to techniques or positioning that restrain a subject’s hands and legs together, leave a subject in control restraints lying on their back or stomach, put weight on the subject’s back or neck for a prolonged period, or keep a subject waiting for transportation in a restrained position, as described in this paragraph, without proper monitoring for signs of asphyxia.
- “Carotid restraint” means a vascular neck restraint or any similar restraint, hold, or other defensive tactic in which pressure is applied to the sides of a person’s neck that involves a substantial risk of restricting blood flow and may render the person unconscious in order to subdue or control the person.
Background
Choke holds have been effectively banned in California, but not expressly banned. The practice fell out of favor over many years due to serious injury and death caused by the usage of the technique. Over many years both federal and State of California courts have found the practice subjects municipalities, government entities, and law enforcement agencies that permit the usage liable for wrongful death and serious injury to persons who have been subjected to the use of a choke hold by law enforcement agencies. As a result of these findings of liability, the usage of choke holds fell out of favor and cities and agencies routinely banned their usage. Additionally, the Commission on Peace Officer Standards and Training (POST) ceased instruction on the technique. However, the practice has never been expressly banned in California statute and this bill seeks to make that clarification.
Carotid restraint is very similar to a choke hold. The practice involves the cutting-off of blood circulation to the head of the person upon which the hold is placed. This process can cause the person to lose consciousness. This technique has conventionally been taught to be less deadly than a traditional choke hold which can more easily collapse the wind pipe because it’s focused on the front of the neck. However, a slight deviation in the placement of the arm of the person implementing the hold can convert a carotid restraint into a choke hold. Additionally, cutting off blood flow to a person’s brain has its own dangers.
This bill prohibits both practices in the State of California by law enforcement. Additionally, this bill makes sure that law enforcement agencies need to transport detained persons and persons otherwise in the custody of law enforcement in a manner that will not result in asphyxiation.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: Yes Local: Yes
According to the Senate Appropriations Committee:
- Officer retraining & transportation modifications: Unknown costs, potentially in the millions of dollars. Costs to each law enforcement agency to train their officers in accordance with a policy consistent with this measure would vary based on a number of factors, including the number of peace officers employed by the agency, salaries of the officers, overtime costs to backfill officers who are attending training, and how similar the agency’s current policy (and therefore training) is to the requirements of this measure. If an agency’s policy currently is in alignment with AB 1196, there would be no associated training costs. (General Fund, special funds, local funds)
By way of example, it would have cost the California Highway Patrol $4.1 million for all of its uniformed personnel—868 sergeants and 6,236 officers—to attend a four-hour training in 2019. Using those same figures, it would cost the department over $500,000 for all of its officers to attend a 30-minute training. For context, there are approximately 90,000 peace officers in the state.
This measure also may lead to additional unknown, potentially-major one-time costs for agencies to test, evaluate, and develop a new method of transporting combative individuals that could result in the purchase of new equipment and the modification of patrol cars.
- Policy revision: Unknown, potentially-significant one-time costs ranging from the tens of thousands to the hundreds of thousands in the aggregate for all state and local law enforcement agencies to update their policies in accordance with AB 1196. Some agencies employ a contract service to ensure their policies reflect recent changes in statutory and case law. This measure may require more attention to revise policies than other prohibitions on practices to the extent agencies would have to consider which alternatives are appropriate for that specific agency to adopt, particularly with respect to transporting an individual. Alternatively, some agencies, such as the University of California system, would incur no to minimal costs, as their policies generally are in alignment with this bill.
Local costs to comply with this measure would be subject to reimbursement by the state to the extent that the Commission on State Mandates determines that this bill imposes a state-mandated local program. Considering that there are over 500 local law enforcement agencies across the state, costs to implement this measure could reach into the hundreds of thousands of dollars. (General Fund, special funds, local funds)
SUPPORT: (Verified 8/20/20)
Advancement Project
Alliance for Boys and Men of Color
Alliance San Diego
American Civil Liberties Union – California
Anti-Defamation League
Asian Americans Advancing Justice – California
Association of Black Women Physicians
Brady California United Against Gun Violence
California Academy of Family Physicians
California Association of Black Lawyers
California Attorneys for Criminal Justice
California Dental Association
California Department of Insurance
California Department of Justice
California Immigrant Policy Center
California Natural Gas Vehicle Coalition
California Nurses Association
California Pan-Ethnic Health Network
California Psychological Association
California Public Defenders Association
California State Council of Service Employees International Union
California State National Action Network
California Teachers Association
Californiahealth+ Advocates
City of Alameda
City of Lafayette
City of Long Beach
Communities United for Restorative Youth Justice
Community Clinic Association of Los Angeles County
Compass Family Services
Consumer Attorneys of California
Disability Rights California
Ella Baker Center for Human Rights
Empowering Pacific Islander Communities
Everytown for Gun Safety Action Fund
Fresno Barrios Unidos
Friends Committee on Legislation of California
Giffords Law Center
Having Our Say Coalition
Health Access California
Indivisible – Marin
Indivisible – Sausalito
Initiate Justice
John Burton Advocates for Youth
Latino Coalition for a Healthy California
Legal Services for Prisoners with Children
Los Angeles County
Los Angeles LGBT Center
Los Angeles Office of Education
Los Angeles Regional Reentry Partnership
Mid-City Community Advocacy Network
Momentum United
NARAL Pro-Choice California
National Action Network
National Association of Social Workers – California
Phi Beta Sigma Fraternity
Planned Parenthood – California
PolicyLink
Public Health Advocates; Rubicon Programs
Showing Up for Racial Justice – San Diego
Silicon Valley Leadership Group
Stop Coalition
SURJ – Marin
The Arc
Time for Change Foundation
UDW/AFSCME Local 3930
United Cerebral Palsy – California
W. Haywood Burns Institute
Youth Alive!
Youth Justice Coalition
OPPOSITION: (Verified 8/20/20)
Association for Los Angeles Deputy Sheriffs
Association of Orange County Deputy Sheriffs
California Association of Highway Patrolmen
California Fraternal Order of Police
Peace Officers Research Association of California
Riverside Sheriffs’ Association
Sacramento County Deputy Sheriffs Association
San Bernardino County Safety Employees’ Benefit Association
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 61-12, 1/30/20
AYES: Aguiar-Curry, Arambula, Bauer-Kahan, Berman, Bloom, Boerner Horvath, Bonta, Brough, Burke, Calderon, Carrillo, Chau, Chiu, Chu, Cooley, Cooper, Daly, Eggman, Frazier, Friedman, Gabriel, Cristina Garcia, Eduardo Garcia, Gipson, Gloria, Gonzalez, Grayson, Holden, Irwin, Jones-Sawyer, Kalra, Kamlager, Levine, Limón, Low, Maienschein, Mayes, McCarty, Medina, Mullin, Muratsuchi, Nazarian, O'Donnell, Petrie-Norris, Quirk, Quirk-Silva, Ramos, Reyes, Luz Rivas, Robert Rivas, Rodriguez, Blanca Rubio, Salas, Santiago, Smith, Mark Stone, Ting, Waldron, Weber, Wicks, Wood
NOES: Bigelow, Chen, Choi, Cunningham, Megan Dahle, Fong, Kiley, Lackey, Mathis, Melendez, Obernolte, Voepel
NO VOTE RECORDED: Cervantes, Diep, Flora, Gallagher, Gray, Patterson, Rendon
Prepared by: Gabe Caswell / PUB. S. /
8/21/20 17:34:03
**** END ****
SENATE COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Senator Anthony Portantino, Chair
2019 - 2020 Regular Session
AB 1196 (Gipson) - Peace officers: use of force
Version: July 9, 2020 | Policy Vote: PUB. S. 6 - 1 |
Urgency: Yes | Mandate: Yes |
Hearing Date: August 17, 2020 | Consultant: Shaun Naidu |
Bill Summary:
AB 1196, an urgency measure, would prohibit law enforcement agencies from authorizing the use of a carotid restraint or choke hold by peace officers and techniques or transport methods that involve a substantial risk of positional asphyxia.
Fiscal Impact:
- Officer retraining & transportation modifications: Unknown costs, potentially in the millions of dollars. Costs to each law enforcement agency to train their officers in accordance with a policy consistent with this measure would vary based on a number of factors, including the number of peace officers employed by the agency, salaries of the officers, overtime costs to backfill officers who are attending training, and how similar the agency’s current policy (and therefore training) is to the requirements of this measure. If an agency’s policy currently is in alignment with AB 1196, there would be no associated training costs. (General Fund, special funds, local funds)
By way of example, it would have cost the California Highway Patrol $4.1 million for all of its uniformed personnel—868 sergeants and 6,236 officers—to attend a four-hour training in 2019. Using those same figures, it would cost the department over $500,000 for all of its officers to attend a 30-minute training. For context, there are approximately 90,000 peace officers in the state.
This measure also may lead to additional unknown, potentially-major one-time costs for agencies to test, evaluate, and develop a new method of transporting combative individuals that could result in the purchase of new equipment and the modification of patrol cars.
- Policy revision: Unknown, potentially-significant one-time costs ranging from the tens of thousands to the hundreds of thousands in the aggregate for all state and local law enforcement agencies to update their policies in accordance with AB 1196. Some agencies employ a contract service to ensure their policies reflect recent changes in statutory and case law. This measure may require more attention to revise policies than other prohibitions on practices to the extent agencies would have to consider which alternatives are appropriate for that specific agency to adopt, particularly with respect to transporting an individual. Alternatively, some agencies, such as the University of California system, would incur no to minimal costs, as their policies generally are in alignment with this bill.
Local costs to comply with this measure would be subject to reimbursement by the state to the extent that the Commission on State Mandates determines that this bill imposes a state-mandated local program. Considering that there are over 500 local law enforcement agencies across the state, costs to implement this measure could reach into the hundreds of thousands of dollars. (General Fund, special funds, local funds)
Background:
Existing law provides peace officers the authority to use objectively reasonable force to effect an arrest, prevent escape, or overcome resistance when the officer has reasonable cause to believe that the person to be arrested has committed a public offense.
Notwithstanding this authority, a peace officer is justified in using deadly force on another person only when the officer reasonably believes, based on the totality of the circumstances, that such force is necessary to either (i) defend against an imminent threat of death or serious bodily injury to the officer or to another person or (ii) apprehend a fleeing person for any felony that threatened or resulted in death or serious bodily injury, if the officer reasonably believes that the person will cause death or serious bodily injury to another unless immediately apprehended. Where feasible, the officer, before the use of force, must make reasonable efforts to identify themselves as a peace officer and to warn that deadly force may be used, unless the officer has objectively reasonable grounds to believe the person is aware of those facts. A death resulting from a peace officer’s use of force in compliance with these provisions is a justifiable homicide.
Additionally, a peace officer has no obligation to retreat or desist in the officer’s efforts because of resistance or the threat of resistance. Moreover, the officer is not deemed the aggressor and does not lose the right of self defense by the use of objectively reasonable force in accordance with the law to effect an arrest, prevent escape, or overcome resistance.
On June 10, 2020, the chair of the Board of State and Community Corrections (BSCC) issued a memo notifying correctional agencies of the suspension of the certification of training on the carotid hold. The action impacted 72 courses for local corrections officers. On August 13, 2020, BSCC voted to no longer certify training on the use of the carotid hold by local correctional officers, making the suspension permanent.
Proposed Law:
This bill would:
- Prohibit a law enforcement agency from authorizing the use of a carotid restraint or choke hold by any peace officer employed by that agency.
- Prohibit a law enforcement agency from authorizing techniques or transport methods that involve a substantial risk of positional asphyxia.
- Define “carotid restraint” as a vascular neck restraint or any similar restraint, hold, or other defensive tactic in which pressure is applied to the sides of a person’s neck that involves a substantial risk of restricting blood flow and may render the person unconscious in order to subdue or control the person.
- Define “positional asphyxia” as situating a person in a manner that compresses an individual’s airway and reduces the likelihood that an individual will be able to breathe. It would include techniques or positioning that:
- Restrain a subject’s hands and legs together.
- Leave a subject in control restraints lying on their back or stomach.
- Put weight on the subject’s back or neck for a prolonged period.
- Keep a subject waiting for transportation in a restrained position, as described above, without proper monitoring for signs of asphyxia.
Related Legislation:
AB 392 (Weber, Ch. 170, Stats. 2019) revised the standards for use of deadly force by peace officers.
SB 230 (Caballero, Ch. 285, Stats. 2019) required law enforcement agencies to maintain a policy that provides guidelines on the use of force, using deescalation techniques and other alternatives to force when feasible, specific guidelines for the application of deadly force, and factors for evaluating and reviewing all use of force incidents, among other things.
-- END --
SENATE COMMITTEE ON PUBLIC SAFETY
Senator Nancy Skinner, Chair
2019 - 2020 Regular
Bill No: AB 1196 Hearing Date: August 7, 2020
Author: | Gipson | ||
Version: | July 9, 2020 | ||
Urgency: | Yes | Fiscal: | Yes |
Consultant: | GC | ||
Subject: Peace Officers: Use of Force
HISTORY
Source: Alliance of Boys and Men of Color; National Action Network; PolicyLink
Prior Legislation: AB 392 (Weber), Ch. 170, Stats. of 2019
SB 230 (Caballero), Ch. 285, Stats. of 2019
Support: Advancement Project; The Arc; Alliance for Boys and Men of Color; Alliance San Diego; American Civil Liberties Union – California; Anti-Defamation League; Asian Americans Advancing Justice – California; Association of Black Women Physicians; California Association of Black Lawyers; Brady California United Against Gun Violence; California Academy of Family Physicians; California Association of Black Lawyers; California Attorneys for Criminal Justice; California Dental Association; California Department of Insurance; California Department of Justice; California Immigrant Policy Center; California Natural Gas Vehicle Coalition; California Nurses Association; California Pan-Ethnic Health Network; California Psychological Association; California Public Defenders Association, California State Council of Service Employees International Union; California State National Action Network; California Teachers Association; Californiahealth+ Advocates; City of Alameda; City of Lafayette; City of Long Beach; Communities United for Restorative Youth Justice; Community Clinic Association of Los Angeles County; Compass Family Services; Consumer Attorneys of California; Disability Rights California; Ella Baker Center for Human Rights; Empowering Pacific Islander Communities; Everytown for Gun Safety Action Fund; Fresno Barrios Unidos; Friends Committee on Legislation of California; Giffords Law Center; Having Our Say Coalition; Health Access California; Indivisible – Marin; Indivisible – Sausalito; Initiate Justice; John Burton Advocates for Youth; Latino Coalition for a Healthy California; Legal Services for Prisoners with Children; Los Angeles County; Los Angeles LGBT Center; Los Angeles Office of Education; Los Angeles Regional Reentry Partnership; Mid-City Community Advocacy Network; Momentum United; NARAL Pro-Choice California; National Action Network; National Association of Social Workers – California; Phi Beta Sigma Fraternity; Planned Parenthood – California; Public Health Advocates; Rubicon Programs; Showing Up for Racial Justice – San Diego; Silicon Valley Leadership Group; Stop Coalition; SURJ – Marin; Time for Change Foundation; UDW/AFSCME Local 3930; United Cerebral Palsy – California, W. Haywood Burns Institute; Youth Alive!; Youth Justice Coalition
Opposition: Association for Los Angeles Deputy Sheriffs; Association of Orange County Deputy Sheriffs; California Association of Highway Patrolmen; California Fraternal Order of Police; Peace Officers Research Association of California (PORAC); Riverside Sheriffs’ Association; Sacramento County Deputy Sheriffs Association; San Bernardino County Safety Employees’ Benefit Association
Assembly Floor Vote: Not relevant
PURPOSE
The purpose of this legislation is to prohibit law enforcement agencies from authorizing 1) carotid restraint holds; 2) choke holds, and 3) techniques or transport methods that involve a substantial risk of positional asphyxia.
Existing law defines “deadly force” as any use of force that creates a substantial risk of causing death or serious bodily injury. Deadly force includes, but is not limited to, the discharge of a firearm. (Gov. Code, § 7286, subd. (a)(1).)
Existing law defines “feasible” means reasonably capable of being done or carried out under the circumstances to successfully achieve the arrest or lawful objective without increasing risk to the officer or another person. (Gov. Code, § 7286, subd. (a)(2).)
Existing law requires that each law enforcement agency shall, by no later than January 1, 2021, maintain a policy that provides a minimum standard on the use of force. Each agency’s policy shall include all of the following: (Gov. Code, § 7286, subd. (b).)
- A requirement that officers utilize deescalation techniques, crisis intervention tactics, and other alternatives to force when feasible.
- A requirement that an officer may only use a level of force that they reasonably believe is proportional to the seriousness of the suspected offense or the reasonably perceived level of actual or threatened resistance.
- A requirement that officers report potential excessive force to a superior officer when present and observing another officer using force that the officer believes to be beyond that which is necessary, as determined by an objectively reasonable officer under the circumstances based upon the totality of information actually known to the officer.
- Clear and specific guidelines regarding situations in which officers may or may not draw a firearm or point a firearm at a person.
- A requirement that officers consider their surroundings and potential risks to bystanders, to the extent reasonable under the circumstances, before discharging a firearm.
- Procedures for disclosing public records in accordance with Section 832.7.
- Procedures for the filing, investigation, and reporting of citizen complaints regarding use of force incidents.
- A requirement that an officer intercede when present and observing another officer using force that is clearly beyond that which is necessary, as determined by an objectively reasonable officer under the circumstances, taking into account the possibility that other officers may have additional information regarding the threat posed by a subject.
- Comprehensive and specific guidelines regarding approved methods and devices available for the application of force.
- An explicitly stated requirement that officers carry out duties, including use of force, in a manner that is fair and unbiased.
- Comprehensive and specific guidelines for the application of deadly force.
- Comprehensive and detailed requirements for prompt internal reporting and notification regarding a use of force incident, including reporting use of force incidents to the Department of Justice in compliance with Section 12525.2.
- The role of supervisors in the review of use of force applications.
- A requirement that officers promptly provide, if properly trained, or otherwise promptly procure medical assistance for persons injured in a use of force incident, when reasonable and safe to do so.
- Training standards and requirements relating to demonstrated knowledge and understanding of the law enforcement agency’s use of force policy by officers, investigators, and supervisors.
- Training and guidelines regarding vulnerable populations, including, but not limited to, children, elderly persons, people who are pregnant, and people with physical, mental, and developmental disabilities.
- Comprehensive and specific guidelines under which the discharge of a firearm at or from a moving vehicle may or may not be permitted.
- Factors for evaluating and reviewing all use of force incidents.
- Minimum training and course titles required to meet the objectives in the use of force policy.
- A requirement for the regular review and updating of the policy to reflect developing practices and procedures.
Existing law requires that each law enforcement agency shall make their use of force policy adopted pursuant to this section accessible to the public. (Gov. Code, § 7286, subd. (c).)
Existing law mandates that the Commission on Peace Officers Standards and Training (POST) shall implement a course or courses of instruction for the regular and periodic training of law enforcement officers in the use of force and shall also develop uniform, minimum guidelines for adoption and promulgation by California law enforcement agencies for use of force. The guidelines and course of instruction shall stress that the use of force by law enforcement personnel is of important concern to the community and law enforcement and that law enforcement should safeguard life, dignity, and liberty of all persons, without prejudice to anyone. These guidelines shall be a resource for each agency executive to use in the creation of the use of force policy that the agency is required to adopt and promulgate pursuant to Section 7286 of the Government Code, and that reflects the needs of the agency, the jurisdiction it serves, and the law. The course or courses of the regular basic course for law enforcement officers and the guidelines shall include all of the following: (Penal Code, § 13519.10)
- Legal standards for use of force.
- Duty to intercede.
- The use of objectively reasonable force.
- Supervisory responsibilities.
- Use of force review and analysis.
- Guidelines for the use of deadly force.
- State required reporting.
- Deescalation and interpersonal communication training, including tactical methods that use time, distance, cover, and concealment, to avoid escalating situations that lead to violence.
- Implicit and explicit bias and cultural competency.
- Skills including deescalation techniques to effectively, safely, and respectfully interact with people with disabilities or behavioral health issues.
- Use of force scenario training including simulations of low-frequency, high-risk situations and calls for service, shoot-or-don’t-shoot situations, and real-time force option decision-making.
- Alternatives to the use of deadly force and physical force, so that deescalation tactics and less lethal alternatives are, where reasonably feasible, part of the decision-making process leading up to the consideration of deadly force.
- Mental health and policing, including bias and stigma and;
- Using public service, including the rendering of first aid, to provide a positive point of contact between law enforcement officers and community members to increase trust and reduce conflicts.
This bill prohibits a law enforcement agency from authorizing the use of:
- A carotid restraint hold.
- A choke hold.
- Techniques or transport methods that involve a substantial risk of positional asphyxia.
This bill defines the following terms as follows:
- “Carotid restraint” means a vascular neck restraint or any similar restraint, hold, or other defensive tactic in which pressure is applied to the sides of a person’s neck that involves a substantial risk of restricting blood flow and may render the person unconscious in order to subdue or control the person.
- “Choke hold” means any defensive tactic or force option in which direct pressure is applied to a person’s trachea or windpipe.
- “Positional asphyxia” means situating a person in a manner that compresses an individual’s airway and reduces the likelihood that an individual will be able to breathe. This includes but is not limited to techniques or positioning that restrain a subject’s hands and legs together, leave a subject in control restraints lying on their back or stomach, put weight on the subject’s back or neck for a prolonged period, or keep a subject waiting for transportation in a restrained position, as described in this paragraph, without proper monitoring for signs of asphyxia.
COMMENTS
1. Need for This Bill
AB 1196 seeks to eliminate the use of chokeholds, carotid restraints, and techniques or transport methods with a high risk of positional asphyxia by law enforcement.
The carotid restraint is one of the most commonly used strangleholds. To perform this hold, a peace officer applies pressure on either side of the windpipe—but not on the windpipe itself—to slow or stop the flow of blood to the brain via the carotid arteries. While designed to render subjects unconscious, this hold can go wrong in two main ways: either when improperly applied, or when a subjects' physical disposition—if they suffers from coronary artery disease, for example—makes the hold dangerous or lethal. Simply maintaining restricted blood flow for one minute after the suspect is rendered unconscious can lead to irreversible brain damage.
In the Eric Garner case, NY Commissioner James O’Neill said that the officer’s failure to relax his grip while subduing him triggered a fatal asthma attack. With the high profile death of George Floyd in Minneapolis, where a peace officer used his knee to subdue and detain him, it is clear that similar methods of restraining suspects are incredibly risky and should no longer be allowed.
Police Departments in cities such as San Francisco, Los Angeles, and San Diego have already taken steps to prohibit their use but statewide policies regarding neck restraints vary, which results in a lack of accountability for officers who use them. AB 1196 will create a uniform statewide policy on carotid restraints and similar techniques to ensure that these procedures can no longer be improperly applied on Californians.
2. California and the Use of Choke Holds and Carotid Restraint
Choke holds have been effectively banned in California, but not expressly banned. The practice fell out of favor over many years due to serious injury and death caused by the usage of the technique. Over many years both federal and State of California courts have found the practice subjects municipalities, government entities, and law enforcement agencies that permit the usage liable for wrongful death and serious injury to persons who have been subjected to the use of a choke hold by law enforcement agencies. As a result of these findings of liability, the usage of choke holds fell out of favor and cities and agencies routinely banned their usage. Additionally, the Commission on Peace Officer Standards and Training (POST) ceased instruction on the technique. However, the practice has never been expressly banned in California statute and this bill seeks to make that clarification.
Carotid restraint is very similar to a choke hold. The practice involves the cutting-off of blood circulation to the head of the person upon which the hold is placed. This process can cause the person to lose consciousness. This technique has conventionally been taught to be less deadly than a traditional choke hold which can more easily collapse the wind pipe because it’s focused on the front of the neck. However, a slight deviation in the placement of the arm of the person implementing the hold can convert a carotid restraint into a choke hold. Additionally, cutting off blood flow to a person’s brain has its own dangers.
This bill would prohibit both practices in the State of California by law enforcement. Additionally, this bill would make sure that law enforcement agencies need to transport detained persons and persons otherwise in the custody of law enforcement in a manner that will not result in asphyxiation.
3. Argument in Support
According to the National Action Network:
It is imperative peace officers remain vigilant protecting the community and serving the public with integrity. For too long we have witnessed law enforcement abuse their power with overzealous individuals using the color of law to inflict terror among its citizens. California State National Action Network (CA State NAN) recognizes there are many tactics to de-escalate and subdue a person suspected of committing a crime. We do not believe any of the tactics include killing the suspect if the officer recognizes it is not necessary to take his or her life. For this reason, CA State NAN is pleased to sponsor AB 1196, which seeks to eliminate the use of the carotid restraint statewide by law enforcement. The carotid restraint is a tactic commonly used to render suspects unconscious; however, police officers are aware this restraint can be deadly. Simply maintaining restricted blood flow for one minute after the suspect is rendered unconscious can lead to irreversible brain damage or death. For nearly twenty years as leader of NAN, our founder Rev. Al Sharpton has led efforts across the nation to recognize egregious acts of abuse by law enforcement and demands for justice and civil rights. Over the years one thing we know remains to be true; changing laws will not change the heart and mind of a racist but we pray before our God these laws deter peace officers from abusing their power and committing fatal crimes against the citizenry they are sworn to protect. For these reasons, CA State NAN is pleased to sponsor AB 1196.
4. Argument in Opposition
According to the Association of Los Angeles Deputy Sheriffs:
As currently drafted, AB 1196 would prohibit law enforcement agencies from authorizing the use of a carotid restraint and techniques or transport methods that involve a substantial risk of positional asphyxia. We certainly appreciate the author’s intent, and condemn the tragic death of George Floyd in
Minneapolis, MN. However, the language as drafted does not provide law enforcement officers the ability to use these trained techniques when their own life, or any other person, is at risk. It is for this reason that we request language be added to specify an officer can use these restraints if they reasonably fear they, or any other person, is in danger of great bodily injury or death. Further, to ensure the safety of a person put into carotid restraint, we suggest including language that requires a law enforcement officer to put the person into a recovery position to monitor them for signs of positional asphyxia and provide medical attention when feasible and necessary.
-- END –
ASSEMBLY THIRD READING
ATR Bill Id:AB 1196
Author:(Gipson)
As Amended Ver:April 29, 2019
Majority vote
SUMMARY:
Establishes a grant program to support the planning of, and operation of community schools, subject to an appropriation for this purpose.
Major Provisions
- Defines a community school as a school that includes an engaging curriculum; has an emphasis on high-quality teaching; provides wraparound supports such as health care, eye care, and social and emotional services throughout the year; an emphasis on positive discipline practices; parent and community engagement; and leadership committed to making the community school integral to the school's educational mandate.
- Makes an undefined one-time appropriation to create a three-year grant program for schools to plan and operate "community schools," to be administered the California Department of Education (CDE). Community schools integrate academics, health and social services, youth and community development, and community engagement at school.
- Requires the CDE to solicit grant applications and then award grants to schools based on student enrollment. In addition, grantees must provide a 20% local match to grant funds awarded. In the first year of funding, the grantee is required to conduct a needs-and-assets assessment of its school and then submit to the CDE a locally developed and approved plan to address these needs. The bill requires grantees to use grant funds to hire a community school coordinator, fund new employees to fulfill the strategic plan's needs, implement support services, provide professional development to school staff and develop funding strategies for the long-term sustainability of the program. This bill requires grantees to annually report certain information and the CDE to submit a final evaluation of the program to the Legislature.
COMMENTS:
According to the Coalition for Community Schools, "a community school is both a place and a set of partnerships between the school and other community resources. Its integrated focus on academics, health and social services, youth and community development, and community engagement leads to improved student learning, stronger families, and healthier communities. Community schools offer a curriculum that emphasizes real-world learning and community problem-solving. Schools become centers of the community and are open to everyone – all day, every day, evenings, and weekends."
According to the Public Policy Institute of California, 21% of children in California lived in families without enough resources to make ends meet in 2015, up from 17% in 2007. Additionally, 5% of California's children were in deep poverty. The rates of child poverty vary by region and by ethnicity. The poverty rate for Latino children (31%) was more than double that of Asian American (13%) and white (12%) children in California in 2014.
The achievement gap between low-income children and youth and their higher-income peers has been well-documented. This gap is present when children enter school and often widens as the child progresses through the education system. Research has shown that children living in poverty are five times more likely to drop out of high school than their higher-income peers, and only 9% will obtain a college degree. Children living in poverty often fail to receive adequate medical care. Lack of preventative care and treatment for chronic conditions such as asthma or diabetes leads to frequent absences from school. Chronic absenteeism in the early school years has been proven to be a strong indicator of failure to graduate from high school or to attend college.
According to the Author:
"Existing community schools effectively work toward becoming centers of the community and provide a role for everyone to participate in the academic achievement and social health of students and families within the community. In California and across the nation, the education system has time and time again had serious challenges with effectively educating poor and minority communities. The key to the issue is that the challenges often lie outside of the classroom, and are direct reflections of the environments and communities that youth come from. Many of these youth are exposed to gang violence, street crime, domestic abuse, drug abuse, poor health and a number of ills that become impediments to achievement in the classroom. These factors suggest that in order to effectively educate a child, one must bring together a holistic community-based solution. AB 1196 supports the community schools model in its mission aimed to improve outcomes for disadvantaged youth and their families."
Arguments in Support:
According to the State Superintendent of Public Instruction, the sponsor of the bill, "We know that many students are facing challenges and obstacles that require a deliberative and targeted approach to assist them in reaching their academic goals and full potential. We also know that safe and positive school environments, coupled with integrated and easily accessible systems of support have a direct and multiplying impact on a student's likelihood of success. We believe community schools are a part of the solution. AB 1196 aims to assist local education agencies to create community schools to significantly enhance our students' ability to succeed."
Arguments in Opposition:
None
FISCAL COMMENTS:
According to the Assembly Appropriations Committee:
- Unknown one-time Proposition 98 General Fund costs to provide community school grants, contingent on appropriation.
- Unknown, potential one-time Proposition 98 General Fund cost pressures for schools to provide one-time local matching funds.
- One-time General Fund costs of about $1 million over the three-year grant period, of $350,000 annually, to CDE.
VOTES:
ASM EDUCATION: 5-2-0
YES: O'Donnell, Kalra, McCarty, Smith, Weber
NO: Kiley, Voepel
ASM APPROPRIATIONS: 13-4-1
YES: Gonzalez, Bloom, Bonta, Calderon, Carrillo, Chau, Eggman, Gabriel, Eduardo Garcia, Maienschein, Petrie-Norris, Quirk, Robert Rivas
NO: Bigelow, Brough, Fong, Obernolte
ABS, ABST OR NV: Diep
UPDATED:
VERSION: April 29, 2019
CONSULTANT: Debbie Look / ED. / (916) 319-2087 FN: 0000698
Date of Hearing: May 8, 2019
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Lorena Gonzalez, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 1196
Author:(Gipson) – As Amended Ver:April 29, 2019
Policy Committee: | Education | Vote: | 5 - 2 |
|
| ||
|
|
Urgency: No State Mandated Local Program: No Reimbursable: No
SUMMARY:
This bill makes an undefined one-time appropriation to create a three-year grant program for schools to plan and operate “community schools,” to be administered the California Department of Education (CDE). Community schools integrate academics, health and social services, youth and community development, and community engagement at school.
Specifically, this bill requires the CDE to solicit grant applications and then award grants to schools based on student enrollment. In addition, grantees must provide a 20% local match to grant funds awarded. In the first year of funding, the grantee is required to conduct a needs-and-assets assessment of its school and then submit to CDE a locally developed and approved plan to address these needs. The grantee’s continued funding depends on CDE approving its plan. The bill requires grantees to use grant funds to hire a community school coordinator, fund new employees to fulfill the strategic plan’s needs, implement support services, provide professional development to school staff and develop funding strategies for the long-term sustainability of the program. The bill requires grantees to annually report certain information and the CDE to submit a final evaluation of the program to the Legislature.
FISCAL EFFECT:
- Unknown one-time Proposition 98 General Fund costs to provide community school grants, contingent on appropriation.
- Unknown, potential one-time Proposition 98 General Fund cost pressures for schools to provide one-time local matching funds equal to 20% of grant funds received. Potential ongoing Proposition 98 General Fund cost pressures for schools to sustain the program in the longer term.
- One-time General Fund costs of about $1 million over the three-year grant period, of $350,000 annually, for CDE to implement the program and provide required reporting. Costs would support three and one-half staff.
COMMENTS:
- Purpose. According to the author:
In California and across the nation, the education system has time and time again had serious challenges with effectively educating poor and minority communities. The key to the issue is that the challenges often lie outside of the classroom, and are direct reflections of the environments and communities that youth come from. Many of these youth are exposed to gang violence, street crime, domestic abuse, drug abuse, poor health and a number of ills that become impediments to achievement in the classroom. These factors suggest that in order to effectively educate a child, one must bring together a holistic community-based solution. AB 1196 supports the community schools model in its mission aimed to improve outcomes for disadvantaged youth and their families.
The bill is sponsored by the Superintendent of Public Instruction.
- Prior Legislation. AB 842 (Gipson), of the 2017-18 Legislative Session, would have required the CDE, contingent upon an appropriation, to establish an Office of Community Schools and to allocate planning and five-year operational grants to local educational agencies to plan and operate community schools. The bill would have specified the elements of a community school plan as well as the composition of the community school leadership team. It would have required annual reporting by the community schools, as well as by the CDE on a statewide basis. The bill was held on this committee’s Suspense File.
Analysis Prepared by: Natasha Collins / APPR. / (916) 319-2081
Date of Hearing: April 24, 2019
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON EDUCATION
Patrick O'Donnell, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 1196 (
Author:Gipson) – As Amended Ver:March 26, 2019
SUBJECT: Community schools: California Community Schools Act
SUMMARY: Establishes a grant program to support the planning of, and operation of community schools, subject to an appropriation for this purpose. Specifically, this bill:
- Establishes the California Community Schools Act.
- Codifies findings and declarations regarding the effectiveness of community schools in addressing academic outcomes, the well-being of children, as well as other societal outcomes.
- Defines a community school as a school that includes all of the following elements:
- A curriculum that is engaging, culturally relevant, and challenging, including a robust selection of classes and after school programs in the arts, languages, ethnic studies, advanced placement and honors courses, as well as services to support English learners and special education pupils, GED preparation, career technical education, and job training.
- An emphasis on high-quality teaching and not on high-stakes testing. Assessments are used to help teachers meet the needs of pupils, and educators have a real voice in professional development.
- Wraparound supports such as health care, eye care, and social and emotional services that support academics that are available before, during, and after school, year-round, to the community with providers who are accountable and culturally competent.
- An emphasis on positive discipline practices, such as restorative justice and social and emotional learning supports, so each pupil can grow and contribute to the school and community. Suspensions and harsh punishments are eliminated or greatly reduced.
- Promotion of parent and community engagement so the community actively participates in planning and decision-making. This process recognizes the link between the success of the school and the development of the community as a whole.
- Leadership that is committed to making the community school integral to the school’s educational mandate and functioning and ensure that the community school coordinator is part of the leadership team.
- Defines the following terms for the purposes of this act:
- “Applicant” means a school maintained by a school district that applies to plan and operate a community school.
- “Classified staff” means nonsupervisory employees of a school, excluding teachers.
- “Community organization” means a nonprofit organization that has been in existence for three years or more and has a verifiable track record of working with the community surrounding the covered schoolsite on education and other issues.
- “Community partner” means a community stakeholder, including, but not limited to, parents and parent organizations, pupils and pupil organizations, early learning programs, the business community, health care providers, civil rights organizations, civic engagement organizations, advocacy groups, local civic and community-based organizations, local governmental agencies, local school employee organizations, and postsecondary educational institutions.
- “Covered schoolsite” means a schoolsite at which a school has proposed to operate a community school.
- “Participating school” means a school that has received a community school operational grant and is participating in the community schools grant program.
- “Planning grant recipient” means a school that has been awarded a community school planning grant, under this program.
- “Program” means the community schools grant program established by this act.
- Requires the CDE to make planning grants of an unspecified amount available to applicants; to use a request for proposal process; and to evaluate proposals on the basis of criteria established by each school district, consistent with this program.
- Specifies that a proposal may be submitted by a school to the school district in whose geographic boundary the school is located for a covered schoolsite that is either of the following:
- A high-needs school that would benefit from the community school program, as determined by the school district.
- A school that serves a higher than average share of high-needs pupils relative to the school district average of high-needs pupils served per schoolsite.
- Requires the CDE to establish and enforce a policy prohibiting discrimination on the basis of race, national origin, religion, sex, disability, sexual orientation, gender expression or identity, housing status, or immigration status in the development and administration of community school programming.
- Requires the CDE to establish an Office of Community Schools to oversee the program.
- Requires the CDE to provide technical assistance, including, but not limited to, grant writing and support for the design of nondiscriminatory community school programming. Technical assistance may be provided by the department directly or by a nonprofit organization with demonstrated experience with community schools planning in partnership with community organizations or civic engagement organizations funded by the department through a request for proposal process to provide technical assistance. Specifies that an unspecified amount is to be allocated to the CDE to provide assistance to grantees, subject to appropriation by the Legislature for this purpose.
- Requires a planning grant recipient to hire a community school coordinator as a full-time member of the schoolsite staff to coordinate the planning process. Specifies that the coordinator must be a non-administrative certificated employee, and that the coordinator must be a bargaining unit member covered by a collective bargaining agreement with the school district, if applicable.
- Requires a community school coordinator to work collaboratively with school leadership and the community school leadership team to identify and arrange for the provision of services and programs that meet school and community needs and priorities. Specifies that the role of the coordinator is to be limited to work related to fulfilling the priorities for the schoolsite as described in the community school plan.
- Authorizes planning grant recipients to use community school planning grant funds for up to one year of planning, and at the end of this period, requires the recipient to submit a community school plan to the governing board of the school district, and if approved, to the CDE, as specified.
- Requires a planning grant recipient to establish a community school leadership team responsible for developing school-specific programming goals, assessing program needs, and overseeing the process of implementing expanded programming at each covered schoolsite. Authorizes an existing schoolsite leadership body to assume the roles and responsibilities of a community school leadership team if it includes the community school coordinator as a voting member, and meets other specified requirements.
- Requires the community school leadership team to include at least 12 people, but no more than 16 people, with at least three parents, three classroom teachers, one non-administrative certificated employee working outside of the classroom, one classified employee, and one principal, and include at least one representative from the following stakeholder groups:
- The school principal must be a voting member, but may not serve as the chairperson, of the community school leadership team.
- Community partners, selected by the leadership team.
- Parents and residents elected annually.
- Classroom teachers and other non-administrative certificated employees, as elected by an annual majority vote of the relevant employee organization, if applicable, or by a majority vote of the non-administrative certificated employees assigned to the school.
- Classified employees as elected by members of the relevant employee organization if applicable, or by a majority of the classified employees assigned to the school.
- Requires the community school leadership team to appoint two representatives from the community who are not parents, teachers, classified staff, or pupils to serve on the community leadership team; and to select a chairperson to guide the team’s work.
- Requires that the community school leadership team for a high school to be between 13 and 16 members, including two pupils, elected by the student body, to serve as voting members.
- Requires the community school coordinator and leadership team to oversee the baseline analyses required and to monitor the development and implementation of community school operations and programming, and to issue recommendations to school leadership, the school district, and community partners, on a regular basis, and to summarize the recommendations in an annual report, which is to be made available at the schoolsite as well as on the school’s website.
- Requires the community school coordinator, in collaboration with the community school leadership team and relevant experts, to conduct a baseline analysis of assets and needs at the schoolsite, including all of the following elements:
- Development of qualitative and quantitative needs/asset assessment surveys for each of the following stakeholder groups: pupils; parents and guardians; school staff; and community members and partners; as well as at least three forums with all stakeholders, and at least two focus groups with each stakeholder group. Requires that at least 75 percent of pupils, and parents/guardians, and all of school staff take part in the survey, and at least 45 percent take part in the forums and focus groups.
- A needs/asset assessment that identifies the challenges facing the school and identifies school assets.
- An analysis of the student body, including the enrollment of, retention rates, and specific needs of each of the following sub-groups: pupils with disabilities, English learners, foster youth, homeless pupils, and pupils eligible for free or reduced-price meals.
- An analysis of suspension and expulsion data, and justification for disciplinary actions and the degree to which particular sub-groups are represented.
- An analysis of school achievement data disaggregated by major demographic categories, including, race, ethnicity, English learner status, disability status, and eligibility for free or reduced-price meals.
- An analysis of current parent engagement strategies and their success.
- Evaluation of the need for, and availability of, wraparound services, including those to meet pupils’ social, emotional, and physical health needs; strategies to create safe and secure school environments, and improve school climate; implementing a positive behavior support system; and anti-bullying efforts.
- An analysis of the breadth and depth of community and school support for the school curriculum, and for changes to the school curriculum.
- A baseline analysis of community assets and a strategic plan for using and aligning identified assets, including a list of individuals, faith-based organizations, community and neighborhood associations, postsecondary educational institutions, hospitals, libraries, businesses, and social service agencies that may be able to provide support and resources.
- A baseline analysis of the needs in the community surrounding the school for: high-quality, full-day childcare and early childhood education programs; physical and mental health care services for children and adults; job training and other adult education programming; before and after school programs and summer learning programs.
- Requires that each planning grant recipient demonstrate, in their community school plan, how the school plans to support each of the following elements, and to provide measureable data at the beginning and end of each school year for each element:
- Positive disciplinary practices, such as restorative justice.
- Curricula that is engaging, culturally and socially relevant, and academically rigorous.
- Wraparound supports including physical and mental health services, social services, and academic enrichment programs.
- An emphasis on high-quality teaching, not on high-stakes testing.
- Parent and community engagement in an active decision making process.
- Inclusive school leadership committed to making the community school program an integral part of the school’s mandate and functioning.
- Requires the community school plan to address all of the following:
- Maintenance of attendance records in all programming components.
- Collection and reporting of measureable data demonstrating annual participation and the impact of programming on participating children and adults, subject to privacy restrictions.
- Documentation of meaningful and sustained collaboration between the school and community stakeholders, as specified.
- Ensuring compliance with nondiscrimination policy.
- How the school will sustain the continuation of the community school after the expiration of the grant funding period.
- Requires the CDE to make community school operational grants of an unspecified amount available to planning grant recipients for a period of five years, which may be renewed at the discretion of the CDE.
- Requires the planning grant recipient to submit its community school plan to the governing board of the school district for approval, and requires the governing board to approve or deny the plan within 45 days.
- Requires, upon approval by the governing board of the school district, the community school plan to be submitted to the CDE, who is required to approve or deny the plan within 45 days, and if approved to award a community school operational grant to the school; or if the plan is incomplete or inadequate, the CDE is required to notify the school and provide support so that the school is able to reach approval within 90 days of notice.
- Authorizes the use of community school operational grant funds to support the following activities:
- Hiring a community school coordinator, or a program director for multiple schoolsites.
- Hiring additional staff to fulfill needs identified in the needs assessment process.
- Funding for nonprofit partner organizations to increase parent and community engagement.
- Ongoing collaborations with institutional and community partners.
- General coordination of programs within and between covered schoolsites.
- Professional development for school staff.
- Ongoing monitoring of the impact on participating children and adults.
- Development of alternative funding strategies to guarantee the long-term sustainability of the community school.
- Ongoing operation of the community school leadership team.
- Other activities that assist in the implementation of the community school plan.
- Requires the community school coordinator, in consultation with the community school leadership team, to report to the CDE annually during the grant period, and make available publicly, a report which includes an assessment of all of the following:
- The effectiveness of the school in implementing the community school plan.
- Problems encountered in the design and execution of the plan, including the identification of any regulatory barriers.
- The operation of the community school team and its contribution to the successful execution of the plan.
- Recommendations for improving delivery of community school programming to pupils.
- The level of increases in access to services, and the number and percentage of pupils, and other community members, receiving community school programming who had not previously received services.
- Any improvements in school retention, and academic achievement among pupils receiving community school programming.
- Any changes in pupils’ readiness to enter school, or their active involvement in school, their community; and their health.
- Anticipated budget savings resulting from the implementation of the program.
- Any improvements in the frequency or depth of family involvement with their children’s education.
- Community stakeholder and institutional partner satisfaction.
- The ability of the school and community partners to sustain services beyond the availability of grant funding for this purpose.
- The degree of increased collaboration among participating agencies and private partners.
- Requires the CDE to develop criteria and evaluate each report submitted by a participating school based upon the factors listed above in (24).
- Requires the CDE to submit a report to the Governor and the Legislature annually by August 30th, following the first full year of operation of the community school program, on the impact of the community school program, based upon specified metrics. The report is to be made available publicly and is to be posted on the CDE website. Requires the report to include analyses and recommendations on best practices for community schools, as well as a calculation or estimate of cost savings at the state, local, and federal levels, in the areas of public health, public safety, and public education resulting from investment in community school programming.
- Specifies that this program will be implemented only if funds are appropriated for this purpose by the Legislature in the annual Budget Act or another statute.
EXISTING LAW:
- Establishes the Learning Communities for School Success Program to implement the K–12 education portion of the Safe Neighborhoods and Schools Act (Proposition 47) as approved by the voters at the November 4, 2014 statewide general election. Requires the CDE to administer grants and coordinate assistance to LEAs in identifying and implementing evidence-based, non-punitive programs and practices designed to keep the most vulnerable pupils in school. (EC 33430 - 33436)
- Federal law establishes the Full Services Community Schools Act of 2014, which encourages coordination of academic, social, and health services through partnerships among public elementary and secondary schools, LEAs, and community-based organizations, non-profit organizations, and other public or private entities. (H.R. 5168 of the 113th Congress)
- Federal law, the Elementary and Secondary Education Act (ESEA) of 1965, as amended, Title V, Part D, Subpart 1, authorizes the Fund for the Improvement of Education. Under this authority the U.S. Department of Education has established the Promise Neighborhoods, as a competitive grant program.
FISCAL EFFECT: The Office of Legislative Counsel has keyed this bill as a possible state-mandated local program.
COMMENTS:
Need for the bill. According to the author, “Existing community schools effectively work toward becoming centers of the community and provide a role for everyone to participate in the academic achievement and social health of students and families within the community. In California and across the nation, the education system has time and time again had serious challenges with effectively educating poor and minority communities. The key to the issue is that the challenges often lie outside of the classroom, and are direct reflections of the environments and communities that youth come from. Many of these youth are exposed to gang violence, street crime, domestic abuse, drug abuse, poor health and a number of ills that become impediments to achievement in the classroom. These factors suggest that in order to effectively educate a child, one must bring together a holistic community-based solution. AB 1196 supports the community schools model in its mission aimed to improve outcomes for disadvantaged youth and their families.”
High rate of childhood poverty in California. According to the Public Policy Institute of California, 21 percent of children in California lived in families without enough resources to make ends meet in 2015, up from 17 percent in 2007. Additionally, 5 percent of California’s children were in deep poverty as they lived in families with less than half of the resources needed to make ends meet. The rates of child poverty vary by region and by ethnicity. The poverty rate for Latino children (31 percent) was more than double that of Asian American (13 percent) and white (12 percent) children in California in 2014.
The achievement gap between low-income children and youth and their higher-income peers has been well-documented. This gap is present when children enter school and often widens as the child progresses through the education system. Research has shown that children living in poverty are five times more likely to drop out of high school than their higher-income peers, and only 9 percent will obtain a college degree. A 2012 study, by the Annie Casey Foundation, noted “children who spend a year or more in poverty account for 38 percent of all children, but they account for 70 percent of all children who do not graduate from high school.”
Children living in poverty often fail to receive adequate medical care. Lack of preventative care and treatment for chronic conditions such as asthma or diabetes leads to frequent absences from school. Chronic absenteeism in the early school years has been proven to be a strong indicator of failure to graduate from high school or to attend college.
Students living in poverty may also lack access to enrichment opportunities through after-school programs or summer learning, further widening the achievement gap.
What is a community school? According to the Coalition for Community Schools, “a community school is both a place and a set of partnerships between the school and other community resources. Its integrated focus on academics, health and social services, youth and community development, and community engagement leads to improved student learning, stronger families, and healthier communities. Community schools offer a curriculum that emphasizes real-world learning and community problem-solving. Schools become centers of the community and are open to everyone – all day, every day, evenings, and weekends.”
The “Community Schools Playbook” authored by the Partnership for the Future of Learning, identifies four key pillars of community schools that create the conditions necessary for students to thrive:
- Integrated student supports:
- Mental and physical health services to support student success.
- A dedicated staff member to coordinate support programs to address out-of-school learning barriers for students and families.
- Expanded and enriched learning time and opportunities:
- After-school, weekend, and summer programs which provide academic instruction and individualized support.
- Enrichment activities which emphasize real-world learning and community problem solving.
- Active family and community engagement:
- Promotion of interaction among families, administration, and teachers to help families be more involved in the decisions about their children’s education.
- The school functions as a neighborhood hub with educational opportunities for adults and family members to promote student success.
- Collaborative leadership and practices:
- Parents, students, teachers, principals, and community partners build a culture of professional learning, collective trust, and shared responsibility using strategies such as site-based leadership teams and professional learning communities.
Positive impacts of community schools. The Coalition for Community Schools identifies research showing that students attending community schools:
- Enter school more fully prepared to learn as a result of participation in high quality early care and education programs;
- Have improved work habits, efforts and attitudes toward learning through participation in extended learning opportunities and other support services;
- Experience improved grades and test scores, and are more likely to graduate from high school, due in part, to access to tutoring, mentoring, and after school activities;
- Are healthier due to access to health services including nurses, dentists, and mental health practitioners at school;
- Have families who are more engaged with the school and their children’s education;
- Are less likely to be absent from school;
- Face fewer discipline referrals and are less likely to be suspended from school.
The Community Schools Playbook identifies further benefits of community schools:
- Community schools are a vital component of an equity strategy. They create the conditions necessary for students to thrive by focusing attention, time, and resources on a shared vision for student and school success. They also help make society more fair by investing in communities that have been marginalized by historic disinvestment.
- In community schools, educators work with local companies, nonprofits, and higher education institutions to offer students real-world projects that make learning more relevant and engaging. They build connections that can open the door to future opportunities.
- Community schools are a time-tested, century-old strategy for connecting students to the services and supports they need to thrive.
- Community schools are efficient and cost-effective. They coordinate the delivery of services to avoid duplication and maximize student supports. Studies find that every $1 invested in a community schools strategy results in up to a $15 return to the community.
- Community schools qualify as an evidence-based approach to improving chronically low-performing schools under the Every Student Succeeds Act (ESSA).
Federal funding for community schools. The U.S. Department of Education has two programs offering funding to schools and communities to establish partnerships to deliver integrated services to children and families.
- The Full-Service Community Schools program has provided $72.5 million in funding since 2009 to encourage coordination of academic, social, and health services through partnerships among LEAs, and community-based organizations, nonprofit organizations, and other public or private entities.
$17.5 million was available in 2018 and seven LEAs and community organizations in California received grants, including the Lost Hills Elementary School District, the Los Angeles Education Partnership (2 grants, one for East L.A. Community Schools and one for South L.A. Community Schools), YMCA Long Beach, Oakland Unified School District, Youth Policy Institute (L.A.), and Green Dot Public Schools. All of these grantees, with the exception of Green Dot, received an initial allocation of $500,000 with expected funding of $2.5 million each over the five year life of the grant. The Green Dot charter school organization received an initial allocation of $102,800 with an expected allocation of $1.85 million over five years. The application period for 2019 grants closed on April 15, 2019.
- In 2010, the Obama Administration launched the Promise Neighborhood Initiative, which is modeled after the Harlem Children’s Zone. In the first year, the Promise Neighborhoods program awarded one-year grants to support the development of a plan to implement a Promise Neighborhood in 21 communities across the country. At the conclusion of the planning grant period, grantees were expected to have a feasible plan to implement a continuum of solutions that will significantly improve results for children in the community being served. The number of grant awards has declined significantly from 21 in 2010 to 3 in 2018.
California received two of the three grants awarded in 2018: the Chula Vista Promise Neighborhood received a one-time grant of $6 million, and the Mission Promise Neighborhood in San Francisco also received $6 million. In 2017, the CSU East Bay Foundation received $6 million in initial funds and an expectation of $30 million over five years on behalf of the Hayward Promise Neighborhood. In 2017, the Youth Policy Institute also received $6 million initial and $30 million total funds for the L.A. Promise Neighborhood.
State funding for community schools. At this time, there is no dedicated education funding stream specifically designated for community schools. School districts have the discretion to use their Local Control Funding Formula (LCFF), including supplemental and concentration funds, to serve the best interests of students, particularly high-needs students, and this could include the establishment of community schools.
California voters passed Proposition 47, the Safe Neighborhood and Schools Act (SNSA), in November 2014. The SNSA reduced the penalties for certain non-violent, non-serious drug and property crimes. Twenty five percent of the funds available through criminal justice system savings are to be allocated to the CDE for administration of a grant program to reduce truancy and support pupils who are at risk of dropping out of school or who are victims of crime. The CDE administers the “Learning Communities for School Success Program”. The grants are to be annually awarded using continuously appropriated funds arising out of the annual savings resulting from Proposition 47. According to the CDE, the first three cohorts have been funded for three year grants as follows:
- Cohort 1 for 2017 through 2020: $37 million to 35 LEAs
- Cohort 2 for 2018 through 2021: $13.6 million to 17 LEAs
- Cohort 3 for 2019 through 2022: $18.1 million to 14 LEAs
Existing law further specifies that an LEA that receives a grant through this program must use the grant funds for planning, implementation, and evaluation of activities in support of evidence-based, non-punitive programs and practices to keep the state’s most vulnerable pupils in school, and that this may include the establishment of a community school.
Recommended amendments. Staff recommend the bill be amended as follows:
- Uncodify the findings and declarations.
- Clarify the elements of a community school.
- Clarify that the applicant for a grant under this program be an LEA, on behalf of one or more eligible schools within its jurisdiction, and defines an LEA as a school district, county office of education, or charter school.
- Define an eligible school as a school that is identified for differentiated assistance under the State’s accountability system.
- Specify that grants are to be based upon pupil enrollment and that funded applicants may receive up to an unspecified amount per pupil enrolled for a three-year grant period, with minimum and maximum grant awards to be established by the CDE.
- Require that recipients provide a local match of at least 20 percent of the grant award.
- Authorize the CDE to retain up to one percent of total grant funds to support implementation of the program, including the provision of technical assistance.
- Specify the timeline and requirements for the needs and asset assessment, and the development of the community school plan by the grantee.
- Specify allowable expenditures for funds received under this program.
- Specify reporting requirements and timelines for grantees as well as for the department upon conclusion of the three-year grant period.
Similar and prior legislation. AB 875 (Wicks) of this Session updates the Healthy Start Support Services for Children Grant Program, previously administered by CDE, and identifies potential funding sources for the program. This bill is pending before this Committee.
AB 258 (Jones-Sawyer) of this Session, establishes the School-Based Pupil Support Services Program Act, to provide grants to local educational agencies for increasing the presence of school health professionals at schoolsites and providing programs that prevent and reduce substance abuse among pupils. The source of the state funding for the grants awarded under the program would be an appropriation from the Youth Education, Prevention, Early Intervention and Treatment Account established pursuant to the Control, Regulate and Tax Adult Use of Marijuana Act (Proposition 64). This bill is pending before the Assembly Health Committee.
AB 8 (Chu) of this Session, requires schools to have one mental health professional for every 400 pupils accessible on campus during school hours, and for schools of less than 400 pupils, to employ at least one mental health professional for one or more schools or enter into an agreement with a county agency or community-based organization to provide mental health services to pupils. This bill is pending before the Assembly Health Committee.
AB 842 (Gipson) of the 2017-18 Session would have required the CDE, contingent upon an appropriation for this purpose, to establish an Office of Community Schools, and to allocate planning and five-year operational grants to local educational agencies to plan and operate community schools. Specified the elements of a community school plan as well as the composition of the community school leadership team, and requires annual reporting by the community schools, as well as by the CDE on a statewide basis. This bill was held in the Assembly Appropriations Committee.
AB 1014 (Thurmond) Chapter 397 and SB 527 (Liu), Chapter 533, Statutes of 2016, establish a grant program to implement the Proposition 47 (2016) requirement to direct 25 percent of the funds to K-12 schools to reduce truancy and support students who are at risk of dropping out of school or are victims of crime. LEAs are eligible to apply for three years of grant funding for planning, implementation, and evaluation of activities in support of evidence-based, non-punitive programs and practices to keep students in school, consistent with the LEA's goals established in their local control and accountability plan. Authorizes funds to be used to establish a community school, implement activities or programs to improve attendance and reduce chronic absenteeism, implement restorative justice models to keep students in school and reduce referrals to law enforcement agencies, implement activities that promote social-emotional and positive learning environments, establishing partnerships with community-based organizations to support implementation of evidence-based, non-punitive approaches, and adding or increasing staff whose primary purpose is to address attendance issues.
SB 403 (Liu) of the 2015-16 Session would have authorized a LEA or schools, in collaboration with community partners, to form a community consortium to establish a California community school to coordinate academic, social, and health services for students, families, and community members. The bill would also have required the SPI to make grants available to fund community schools, to the extent that funds were allocated for this purpose. This bill was held in the Senate Appropriations Committee.
AB 2555 (Bocanegra) of the 2013-14 Session would have required the SPI, in collaboration with various other state agencies and private organizations, to develop a five-year plan for expanding cradle-to-career initiatives in California including full-service community schools, promise neighborhoods, wraparound programs, wellness centers, and healthy communities efforts. This bill was held in the Assembly Appropriations committee.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
California Federation of Teachers
Opposition
None on file
Analysis Prepared by: Debbie Look / ED. / (916) 319-2087
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):