AB 1253: Personal income taxes: additional tax.
- Session Year: 2019-2020
- House: Assembly
- Latest Version Date: 2020-07-27
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Aug 3, 2020 | In committee: Hearing for testimony only. |
| Jul 27, 2020 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to committee. Read second time, amended, and re-referred to Com. on GOV. & F. |
| Jun 18, 2019 | In committee: Set, first hearing. Hearing canceled at the request of author. |
| Jun 6, 2019 | Referred to Coms. on GOV. & F. and N.R. & W. |
| May 24, 2019 | In Senate. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. |
| May 23, 2019 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Senate. |
| May 20, 2019 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| May 16, 2019 | From committee: Do pass. (Ayes 13. Noes 4.) (May 16). |
| Apr 3, 2019 | In committee: Set, first hearing. Referred to APPR. suspense file. |
| Mar 28, 2019 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 6. Noes 2.) (March 27). Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Mar 11, 2019 | Referred to Com. on L. GOV. |
| Feb 22, 2019 | From printer. May be heard in committee March 24. |
| Feb 21, 2019 | Read first time. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| May 23, 2019 | AB 1253 Robert Rivas Assembly Third Reading | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| May 16, 2019 | Do pass. | Assembly Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Mar 27, 2019 | Do pass and be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Assembly Standing Committee on Local Government |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
SENATE COMMITTEE ON GOVERNANCE AND FINANCE
Senator Mike McGuire, Chair
2019 - 2020 Regular
Bill No: | AB 1253 | Hearing Date: | 8/3/20 |
Author: | Santiago | Tax Levy: | Yes |
Version: | 7/27/20 | Fiscal: | Yes |
Consultant: | Deitchman | ||
Personal income taxes: additional tax
Imposes an additional tax on higher-income taxpayers.
Background
All income earned in or sourced to California must be reported and filed on an income tax return. Residents of California must file an individual (or joint if married or registered domestic partners) return. Non-residents can either file a non-resident return, or elect to be included in a group return.
Tax Rates. All California Personal Income Taxpayers (PIT) pay a graduated tax rate between 1 percent and 12.3 percent, depending on the taxpayer’s adjusted taxable income and filing type for that year. In November 2012, voters approved Proposition 30, which added Section 36 to Article XIII of the California Constitution, which temporarily increases the top tax rates for taxable years beginning in 2012, and ending in 2019. In November, 2016, voters extended these tax rate increases through the 2030 taxable year (Proposition 55). The current 2019 tax tables are:
Filing Type : Single or Married Filing Separately | ||
Income Over | But not over | Calculation of tax |
$0 | $8,809 | 1% |
$8,809 | $20,883 | 2% |
$20,883 | $32,960 | 4% |
$32,690 | $45,753 | 6% |
$45,753 | $57,824 | 8% |
$57,824 | $295,373 | 9.3% |
$295,373 | $354,445 | 10.3% |
$354,445 | $590,742 | 11.3% |
$590,742 | And over | 12.3% |
Filing Type : Married/RDP Filing Jointly or Qualifying Widow | ||
Income Over | But not over | Calculation of tax |
$0 | $17,618 | 1% |
$17,618 | $41,766 | 2 % |
$41,766 | $65,920 | 4% |
$65,920 | $91,506 | 6% |
$91,506 | $115,648 | 8 % |
$115,648 | $590,746 | $9.3% |
$590,746 | $708,890 | $10.3% |
$708,890 | $1,181,484 | 11.3% |
$1,181,484 | And over | 12.3% |
Filing Type : Head of Household | ||
Income Over | But not over | Calculation of tax |
$0 | $17,629 | 1% |
$17,629 | $41,768 | 2% |
$41,768 | $53,843 | 4% |
$53,843 | $66,636 | 6% |
$66,636 | $78,710 | 8% |
$78,710 | $401,705 | 9.3% |
$401,705 | $482,047 | 10.3% |
$482,047 | $803,410 | 11.3% |
$803,410 | And over | 12.3% |
According to the Department of Finance, the Personal Income Tax generated almost $100 Billion for the 2020-21 fiscal year.
Mental Health Services Tax. In November of 2004, voters approved Proposition 63 (2004) known as the “Mental Health Services Act,” which imposes an additional 1 percent tax on taxpayers with taxable income of $1 million or more, adjusted for inflation, currently set at $1,181,484. Funds from this tax are used to better serve individuals and their families who are at risk of serious mental health issues. Specifically, the measure focuses on prevention, early intervention, and service needs and the necessary infrastructure, technology, and training elements that effectively support the public behavioral health system. The program is currently overseen by the Mental Health Services Oversight and Accountability Commission and the Department of Health Care Services. According to the data from the Franchise Tax Board, collection of this tax totals about $1.9 billion each year and is included on 80,000 to 90,000 tax returns annually.
The author wants to add an additional graduated, fixed tax rate on those taxpayers with income above $1 million to provide additional funds for state government services.
Proposed Law
AB 1253 imposes an additional tax for those Personal Income California taxpayers with income above the current Proposition 63 inflation-adjusted threshold of $1 million. The additional tax would be structured as follows:
Income Over | But not over | Additional tax |
$1 million | $2 million | 1% of the amount over $1 million |
$2 million | $5 million | 2% of the amount over $2 million |
$5 million | And over | 3.5% of the amount over $5 million |
The bill applies its additional rates to all filing types for taxable years beginning on or after January 1, 2020 and directs the Franchise Tax Board (FTB) to adjust these income thresholds annually. The measure provides that its tax shall be treated as if it were imposed under the Personal Income Tax.
State Revenue Impact
Pending.
Comments
- Purpose of the bill. According to the author, “Millions of Californians are jobless and struggling to put food on the table during this crisis, while the rich just seem to get richer. This crisis has put a spotlight on enduring inequities, which will only worsen if we rely on the same failed playbooks of the past without asking nothing of those with great wealth. I have personally seen how hard this crisis has hit my district - at one food bank in L.A., between 3,000 and 4,000 people came to pick up food for their families in just one weekend. Even before the pandemic, 70% of Californians agreed that it’s time for millionaires to pay their fair share, and AB 1253 will ensure just that. This is a modest proposal that leads with justice, equity, and inclusion in mind. By progressively taxing the wealthy, we will bring in billions per year to help California address the recession brought on by COVID-19.”
- How high is too high? California’s personal income tax rates are already the highest in the nation. This bill would raise the tax rate by 3.5 percent for California’s wealthiest taxpayers. AB 1253’s opponents argue that this additional tax may cause those individuals to move out of the state, especially when other states do not impose personal income taxes at all. Opponents add that AB 1253 would negatively affect California’s economy, further compounding the adverse effects of the COVID-19 pandemic.
- Marriage Penalty. AB 1253’s additional tax applies to all taxpayers with adjusted gross income above specified thresholds, regardless of filing status. As a result, two unmarried individuals (or married individuals filing separate returns) with annual income of $750,000 would pay no additional tax under this proposal, but would if they were married and filed a joint return. The committee may wish to consider whether to provide an increased threshold for married individuals.
- What about withholding? The bill imposes its additional tax in the current taxable year, and states that this additional tax shall be treated as if it were calculated under the existing PIT tax rates. These rates are used to calculate a taxpayers withholding throughout the year to avoid underpayment and the additional of penalties and/or interest. As a result, most withholding for the year would have already been completed and those with income over $1 million are unlikely to have withheld enough tax to cover this additional tax. Individuals subject to the bill’s additional tax may face a large unexpected tax bill due. The committee may wish to consider whether a 2021 start date may be more appropriate to ease the burden on taxpayers by giving them an additional year to prepare.
- It’s not deductible. In December of 2017, President Trump signed HR 1, which enacted fundamental changes to the federal income tax. Among them, HR 1 limited the deduction from income for state and local taxes paid by individuals to $10,000 per taxable year, not indexed for inflation. Part of the federal income tax since its inception, the deduction for state and local income taxes paid permit taxpayers who itemize deductions on their federal income tax to deduct certain taxes paid to state and local governments for federal tax purposes. Taxpayers may deduct their property taxes in addition to their state income or sales taxes, but not both. However, the deduction can be limited by the federal Alternative Minimum Tax. In 2015, more than five million Californians deducted more than $80 billion in state and local taxes from their federal returns, according to the Internal Revenue Services (IRS). Proponents of the deduction argue that it prevents both the federal government and the state from taxing the same income twice, while critics assert that it primarily benefits higher-income individuals. HR 1 capped the deductions at $10,000 per year, and provided a significantly higher standard deduction, which reduced the number of filers who itemize. The Tax Policy Center states that residents of high-tax states, such as New York, California, and New Jersey, face the biggest tax increases resulting from this new limit on the deduction for state and local income taxes.
According to data released by the FTB, Californians that make over $1 million have consistently paid nearly 40 percent of the California’s total PIT revenue. The committee my wish to consider the impact of this additional tax on this population of taxpayers now that it will no longer be deductible for federal purposes.
- Last legislative change to tax rates. The Legislature has not modified the PIT rates since 2009 (ABx3 3, Evans) which increased each marginal rate by 0.125 percent.
Assembly Actions
Not relevant to this version of the bill.
Support and Opposition
(7/31/2020)
Support: Advancement Project California; American Civil Liberties Union of California; American Federation of State, County & Municipal Employees; American Friends Service Committee, Los Angeles; Alliance for Boys and Men of Coalition; Alliance of Californians for Community Empowerment; Asian Resources, Inc.; Asian Pacific Environmental Network; Build Affordable Housing Faster; California Environmental Justice Alliance; California Faculty Association; California Federation of Teachers; California Food Policy Advocates; California Health Professional Student Alliance; California League of Conservation Voters; California Pan-Ethnic Health Network, California Physicians Alliance;, California Tax Reform Association; California Teachers Association , California Policy Immigrant Center; Center on Policy Initiatives, San Diego; Central Coast Alliance United for Sustainable Economy; Children’s Defense Fund-California; Clergy and Laity United for Economic Justice; Coalition for Humane Immigrant Rights; Community Health Initiative of Orange County; Community Health Councils; East Bay Alliance for a Sustainable Economy; Empowering Pacific Islander Communities; Financial Capability Investment; Friends Committee on Legislation of California; Graton Day Labor Center; Having Our Say Coalition,; Health Access California; Inland Equity Partnership; Korean Community Center of the East Bay; Latino Coalition for a Healthy California; Leadership Counsel for Justice & Accountability; Long Beach Immigrant Rights; Los Angeles Alliance for New Economy; Los Angeles Trust for Children’s Health; MyPath; National Association of Social Workers, California Chapter; Orange County Communities Organized for Responsible Economy; Partnership for Working Families; Patriotic Millionaires; PICO California; PolicyLink; Power California; Prevention Institute; Safety Net for All; San Francisco Senior and Disability Action; Service Employees International Union California; Sierra Club California; South Asian Network; UDWAFSCME Local 3930, Warehouse Worker Resource Center, Inland Empire; Western Center of Law and Poverty; West Valley People’s Alliance; Women’s Foundation of California; Women’s Policy Institute; Women Organizing Resources, Knowledge and Services; Working Partnership USA; Working Partnership USA, Silicon Valley; City Council of Daly City
Opposition: Cal Chamber, Greater Riverside Chambers of Commerce
-- END --
SENATE COMMITTEE ON GOVERNANCE AND FINANCE
Senator Mike McGuire, Chair
2019 - 2020 Regular
Bill No: | AB 1253 | Hearing Date: | 6/19/19 |
Author: | Robert Rivas | Tax Levy: | No |
Version: | 2/21/19 | Fiscal: | Yes |
Consultant: | Favorini-Csorba | ||
Local agency formation commissions: grant program
Establishes a grant program for local agency formation commissions that perform specified actions until July 31, 2025.
Background
Local government boundaries. The Legislature has the authority to create, dissolve, or otherwise modify the boundaries and services of local governments. Beginning in 1963, the Legislature delegated the ongoing responsibility to control the boundaries of cities, county service areas, and most special districts to local agency formation commissions (LAFCOs) in each county. The responsibilities and authority of LAFCOs have been modified in subsequent legislation, including a major revision of the LAFCO statutes in the Cortese-Knox-Hertzberg Local Government Reorganization Act of 2000 (AB 2838, Hertzberg).
The courts often refer to LAFCOs as the Legislature’s watchdog over boundary changes. To plan for the future boundaries and service areas of the cities and special districts, a LAFCO must adopt a policy document for each city and district called a sphere of influence. The LAFCO’s boundary decisions must be consistent with the spheres of influence of the affected cities or districts. Spheres must be reviewed and updated at least every five years.
Local governments can only exercise their powers and provide services where LAFCO allows them to: within their boundaries (which are set by LAFCO), within their spheres of influence but outside their boundaries (with authorization by LAFCO), and outside their spheres to address a major threat to public health if the extension is consistent with LAFCO’s policies. In 2015, the Legislature approved AB 402 (Dodd), which established a pilot program in Napa County and San Bernardino County that allowed the extension of services outside a local agency’s sphere of influence to support existing or planned uses under specified conditions. A local government that wants to expand its territory must ask LAFCO to annex new territory into the local government’s boundaries.
Most boundary changes begin when a city or special district applies to LAFCO, or when registered voters or landowners file petitions with a LAFCO. In limited circumstances, LAFCO can initiate some special district boundary changes: consolidations, dissolutions, mergers, subsidiary districts, or reorganizations. Boundary changes require four (sometimes five) steps:
- First, there must be a completed application to LAFCO, including a petition or resolution, an environmental review document, an agreement on how property taxes will be transferred, and a plan for services that describes what services will be provided at what level and how those services will be financed.
- Second, LAFCO must hold a noticed public hearing, take testimony, and may approve the proposed reorganization. The LAFCO may impose terms and conditions that spell out what happens to the assets and liabilities of affected local agencies. If LAFCO disapproves, the proposed reorganization stops.
- Third, LAFCO must hold another public hearing to count written protests in order to determine whether an election is needed. Although there are many exceptions, in most cases an election is required if 25 percent of the voters in a district, or voters representing 25 percent of the assessed value of land, submit written protests. However, the protest threshold is lowered to 10 percent in cases where the LAFCO initiates a change of organization—such as a dissolution or reorganization of a special district—instead of the local agency itself making the request. In nearly all cases, if a majority of voters or landowners protest, the reorganization also stops.
- Fourth, if an election is required, it occurs among the affected voters, requiring majority voter approval.
- Finally, LAFCO’s staff files formal documents to complete the reorganization.
Municipal service reviews and special studies. To determine spheres of influence, LAFCOs must conduct a “municipal service review” (MSR) to inform their decisions. When conducting an MSR, a LAFCO must comprehensively review all of the agencies that provide services within an area designated by the LAFCO. MSRs must analyze and make determinations about seven topics:
- Growth and population projections;
- Present and planned capacity of public facilities and adequacy of public services, including infrastructure needs or deficiencies, including the water, sewer, and fire protection needs of disadvantaged unincorporated communities;
- Agencies’ financial abilities to provide services;
- Opportunities for sharing facilities;
- Accountability for community service needs;
- The location and characteristics of any disadvantaged unincorporated communities; and
- Other matters relating to effective or efficient services.
An MSR may also assess various alternatives for improving efficiency and affordability of infrastructure and services in the area in and around a sphere of influence. Because spheres must be reviewed every five years, MSRs must also be conducted on that schedule. LAFCO law also allows LAFCOs to perform special studies of existing government agencies to determine their maximum service area and service capacities.
Commission makeup. Each LAFCO is governed by a commission comprising local elected officials and one or two members of the public. With few exceptions, every commission has either five or seven members, as follows: two members of the county board of supervisors, two members of city councils from cities within the county, and one member of the public, as well as two members of special district boards in the 30 counties where special districts have elected to be represented on LAFCOs. State law prescribes greater numbers of local officials to sit on the LAFCOs in Los Angeles, San Diego, and Kern counties, and counties with no cities—Alpine,
Mariposa, and Trinity—have three members of the board of supervisors and two public members. State law requires local officials that sit on LAFCOs to exercise independent judgment on behalf of the residents of the county as a whole, but also provides that those members do not have to recuse themselves on any matters and that this requirement does not create a right to sue.
Inactive districts. SB 448 (Wieckowski, 2017) requires the State Controller to publish a list of inactive special districts that have had no financial transactions, assets, debts, or liabilities in the past fiscal year. AB 448 also establishes a streamlined process for LAFCOs to dissolve those districts by requiring LAFCOs to initiate dissolution of inactive districts within 90 days of receiving the list from the Controller, holding only one public hearing, and exempting such a dissolution from the protest process.
Little Hoover Commission. The state’s Little Hoover Commission (LHC) issued a report in 2017 examining whether California taxpayers are well-served by special districts, and whether consolidation or dissolution of some special districts would improve local government operations and efficiency. As part of that review, LHC made recommendations regarding the role of LAFCOs. Among other recommendations, the LHC suggested that the Legislature provide one-time grant funding to pay for some LAFCO activities to encourage LAFCOs or smaller special districts to develop and implement dissolution or consolidation plans. The LHC noted that some participants in the LHC’s hearings suggested that the Strategic Growth Council (SGC) administer such a program. The California Association of Local Agency Formation Commissions (CALAFCO) wants the Legislature to implement this recommendation.
Proposed Law
Assembly Bill 1253 directs, until July 31, 2025, SGC to establish and administer a grant program for LAFCOs that perform specified actions, subject to appropriation by the Legislature. All LAFCOs are eligible for funding under the program. AB 1253 requires SGC to adopt guidelines and other administrative procedures for issuing grants after consulting with CALAFCO. SGC must give preference to applications from LAFCOs whose decisions are consistent with the goals of the applicable Sustainable Communities Strategy adopted under existing law. The bill also exempts the development of program regulations from the Administrative Procedures Act.
AB 1253 requires SGC to award grants to local agencies to pay the costs of:
- Initiating dissolution of an inactive special district;
- Conducting special studies to identify efficiencies and alternatives for improving the efficiency and affordability of infrastructure and service delivery to a disadvantaged community;
- Initiating a change of organization for a service provider that serves a disadvantaged community, based on determinations found in a special study that has been approved by the commission;
- Developing and implementing reorganization plans with timelines for expected outcomes; and
- Incentivizing service providers to work with LAFCO to develop and implement reorganization plans.
AB 1253 requires LAFCOs to supplement, not supplant, existing funding and staffing levels with the grant funds and prohibits the use of grant funds for conducting MSRs.
Inactive districts. In order to receive a grant for initiating a dissolution of an inactive special district, the LAFCO must submit to SGC an application requesting reimbursement for the costs of the dissolution proceedings. The application must include at least:
- The notification provided to the commission by the Controller of the inactive district(s) and the requirement to initiate dissolution proceedings;
- A full budget accounting for costs of the dissolution; and
- All reports and documents pertaining to the final dissolution action.
If all of the required documentation is in order, SGC must review and issue reimbursement within 60 days of receiving the application.
Special studies. In order to receive a grant to conduct a special study, the LAFCO must submit an application that includes at least:
- A resolution adopted by the LAFCO authorizing submission of the grant application and a commitment to review and consider the recommendations and potential actions contained in the study;
- A full budget accounting for estimated costs of the study to be performed;
- A full explanation of the reason for the study;
- The most recent completed MSR or study in which determinations were made by the LAFCO indicating the agency to be studied is a candidate for a change of organization or reorganization; and
- An identification of the disadvantaged community that is expected to benefit from the study.
The SGC must review the applications and select LAFCOs to receive funding based on criteria that further the purposes of the bill. The SGC must then notify selected program participants within two months of receiving the application and issue funds to the LAFCO within 60 days of the notification. A LAFCO that receives funding for a study must start the study within 30 days and must complete it within two years; otherwise the LAFCO must return the grant to SGC. After the LAFCO completes its study, it must provide the SGC:
- The full study conducted;
- The resolution making determinations as adopted by the local agency formation commission;
- A full budget accounting report of the funds used;
- A reimbursement of any unexpended funds;
- The local agency formation commission’s plan for future action based on the study’s conclusions; and
- Any other information requested by the SGC.
Other changes of organization. In order to receive funding to initiate other changes of organization, develop reorganization plans, or incentivize reorganization, a LAFCO must submit an application to SGC that contains:
- A resolution adopted by the LAFCO defining the purposes of the grant;
- Change of organization or reorganization plans with timelines for expected outcomes;
- A full budget accounting for estimated costs of the action to be performed;
- The most recent completed study, including an MSR or similar study that is less than five years old, in which the LAFCO made determinations that the agency should be reorganized or dissolved; and
- An identification of the disadvantaged community that is expected to benefit from the action.
The SGC must review the applications and select program participants based on criteria that further the purposes of the bill. The SGC must then notify selected program participants within two months of receiving the application and issue funds to the LAFCO within 60 days of the notification. A LAFCO that receives funding to initiate other changes of organization, develop reorganization plans, or incentivize reorganization must take the action within 30 days.
AB 1253 also changes the protest threshold for a change of organization that is funded by an SGC grant. Specifically, under current law, if a LAFCO initiates a change of organization that does not implement a prior determination by the LAFCO in an MSR or special study, the LAFCO must hold an election on the proposal if more than 10 percent of voters or landowners protest. AB 1253 instead establishes a different protest threshold for such an action if it is funded by a grant from the SGC. This threshold matches the requirements for signatures needed to put a recall on the ballot, specifically:
- Thirty percent if voter registration is less than 1,000;
- Twenty-five percent if the registration is less than 10,000 but at least 1,000;
- Twenty percent if the registration is less than 50,000 but at least 10,000;
- Fifteen percent if the registration is less than 100,000 but at least 50,000;
- Ten percent if the registration is 100,000 or above; or
- In the case of a landowner voting district, signatures of voters owning at least 10 percent of the assessed value of land.
Once the LAFCO takes the action, it must provide the SGC:
- The final action taken by the LAFCO;
- If proceedings were terminated as a result of protest, information necessary to support that fact;
- All reports and documents pertaining to the final action or protest action;
- A full accounting of the funds used;
- The reimbursement of any unexpended funds; and
- Any other information requested by the SGC.
AB 1253 defines its terms and includes findings and declarations to support its purposes, including that the bill shall not be interpreted to affect the independence or discretion exercised by a LAFCO in carrying out an actions funded under the bill.
AB 1253 repeals its provisions on December 31, 2025.
State Revenue Impact
No estimate.
Comments
1. Purpose of the bill. According to the author, “Consistent with a recommendation made in the 2017 Little Hoover Commission report, AB 1253 would provide LAFCOs, or Local Agency Formation Commissions, with a one-time small infusion of grant-like monies to focus efforts on streamlining local government and improving efficiency in service delivery. There is a need for LAFCOs to conduct more in-depth studies of local agency service providers that could result in more options for greater efficiencies, the elimination of non-functioning organizations, or reorganization actions. AB 1253 would establish a grant-like funding program, administered by the Strategic Growth Council, to provide LAFCOs with funding to conduct studies and analyses of local government agencies and services for the purpose of streamlining the delivery of local government services. Through AB 1253, LAFCOs would be able to address known service and governance concerns that could potentially save California taxpayers money. Grant funds will be used specifically to conduct special studies to identify and support opportunities to create greater efficiencies in the provision of municipal services, and to potentially initiate actions based on those studies that remove or reduce local costs thus incentivizing local agencies to work with the LAFCO in developing and implementing reorganization plans. The grant program would sunset on December 31, 2025.”
2. With great power comes great responsibility. The Legislature delegated its authority to create and abolish local governments and adjust their boundaries to LAFCOs through the Cortese-Knox-Hertzberg Act. In doing so, the Legislature granted local officials much greater leeway in setting their own boundaries by establishing commissions comprising local officials. This is an important responsibility—they are tasked with ensuring that local services are provided efficiently, and are supposed to set aside their roles as local elected officials. However, it is unclear whether LAFCOs are living up to this responsibility. Specifically, the Legislature has enacted several measures in recent years to direct LAFCOs to take specific actions. While some bills sidestepping LAFCOs have done so because supporters think it’s easier than going through LAFCOs, other bills have emerged because constituents are concerned—and the Legislature has agreed—that LAFCOs have been falling down on the job. For example, the Legislature enacted SB 88 (Committee on Budget and Fiscal Review, 2015) to allow the State Water Resources Control Board to force consolidations of water agencies in part because LAFCOs weren’t taking as aggressive action as the Legislature wanted in cases of chronically unsafe drinking water.
Supporters of AB 1253 argue that this bill provides an opportunity for LAFCOs to show that they can do more of the types of activities the Legislature wants to see if they are provided the funding. But other obstacles to LAFCOs fulfilling the Legislature’s vision of LAFCOs may persist, including whether local officials can successfully set aside their prior convictions when they sit on LAFCOs and take action to consolidate or dissolve local agencies that may put fellow local officials out of a job. AB 1253 raises questions about LAFCOs’ responsibilities and how they carry them out. A larger conversation may need to be had about the role for LAFCOs and the Legislature’s expectations of them.
3. Show me the money. Many LAFCOs do not receive adequate funding to carry out the full range of actions that the Legislature has directed LAFCOs to perform. For example, a 2015 survey by CALAFCO found that just over half of LAFCOs felt they were adequately funded to perform their activities. However, LAFCOs already possess a powerful mechanism for securing funding: after a LAFCO adopts a budget, it forwards that budget to the county auditor to be apportioned among cities, counties, and, in those counties with special district representation on LAFCO, special districts. If those entities do not provide their share of funding, the auditor can appropriate property tax or other revenue to the LAFCO. Accordingly, the underfunding of LAFCOs may be due to a lack of political will on the part of the commissions themselves. AB 1253 provides state funding to commissions populated with local representatives that are given the authority to take actions that affect local agencies. The Committee may wish to consider whether this bill strikes the appropriate balance between state and local responsibilities over boundaries, and if the level of local control afforded to LAFCOs is appropriate if the state is providing funding. Moreover, AB 1253 establishes a grant program to be funded by SGC, but the source of funds for the program is currently unknown. The 2019-20 Budget recently adopted by the Legislature does not contain funding for such a purpose. The Committee may wish to consider whether this bill will achieve its intended goals without a state funding source, particularly when LAFCOs already possess the ability to fund their operations from local sources at whatever level the LAFCO approves. Other changes to the LAFCO statute to enhance local contributions to LAFCOs—such as providing clearer statutory direction to the commissions themselves on the level of funding they should be requesting from local agencies—may be a more appropriate solution to LAFCOs current lack of funding.
4. Where to draw the line. AB 1253 raises the threshold for consolidations and other changes of organizations that have not been identified in a previous MSR or special study, from 10 percent to a percentage that varies based on the voter registration in the affected area. Representatives of water districts cite the protest requirement as necessary to prevent LAFCOs from taking actions to dissolve or consolidate agencies against the will of local residents. They note that protests are relatively rare, and further argue that the source of funding should not change what threshold applies. However, LAFCOs often cite the specter of a protest and subsequent election—which a LAFCO would have to fund—as one reason that they do not initiate more actions of their own volition. LAFCOs also argue that a higher protest threshold is needed to ensure that state funds are not wasted on a process that is ultimately stalled by a small portion of the population. More generally, LAFCO law contains approximately 20 different combinations of actions that require varying protest thresholds. The sponsors of this measure, CALAFCO, convened a working group with stakeholders to see if a comprehensive revision to protest thresholds is achievable. AB 1253’s provisions may serve as a model for future discussions around protest thresholds.
5. Double referral. The Senate Rules Committee has ordered a double-referral of AB 1253—first to the Senate Governance & Finance Committee, which has jurisdiction over bills relating to LAFCOs, and then to the Senate Natural Resources and Water Committee, to hear issues related to the Strategic Growth Council.
6. Let’s get technical. The Committee may wish to consider the following technical amendment:
- On page 8, in line 1, strike out “effect” and insert “affect.”
7. Do it again. AB 1253 is almost identical to AB 2258 (Caballero, 2018), but with a sunset date of one year later. AB 2258 was vetoed by Governor Brown, with the following message:
“I am returning Assembly Bill 2258 without my signature. Subject to an appropriation in the annual Budget Act, this bill requires the Strategic Growth Council to establish and administer a grant program to fund various activities performed by Local Agency Formation Commissions. This new spending proposal should be evaluated in the annual budget process where it can be weighed together with the state's other spending priorities.”
Assembly Actions
Assembly Local Government Committee: 6-2
Assembly Appropriations Committee: 13-4
Assembly Floor: 59-17
Support and Opposition
(6/14/19)
Support: CALAFCO (Sponsor); Alameda Lafco; Amador Lafco; Association of California Healthcare Districts, And Affiliated Entity Alpha Fund; Butte Lafco; Calaveras Lafco; California Special Districts Association; California State Association of Counties; Colusa Lafco; Contra Costa Lafco; El Dorado Lafco; Glenn Lafco; Kern Local Agency Formation Commission (Kern Lafco); League of California Cities; Local Agency Formation Commission for The County Of Los Angeles; Local Agency Formation Commission of Merced County; Local Agency Formation Commission of San Benito County; Marin Local Agency Formation Commission; Mendocino Lafco; County of Monterey; Napa Lafco; Nevada County Local Agency Formation Commission (Lafco); Orange County Local Agency Formation Commission; Rural County Representatives of California; San Diego Lafco; San Mateo Local Agency Formation Commission; Santa Cruz Lafco; Sutter Lafco; Yolo Lafco
Opposition: Association of California Water Agencies.
-- END --
ASSEMBLY THIRD READING
ATR Bill Id:AB 1253
Author:(Robert Rivas)
As Introduced Ver:February 21, 2019
Majority vote
SUMMARY:
Authorizes the Strategic Growth Council (SGC) to administer a grant program to finance certain local agency formation commission (LAFCO) activities.
Major Provisions
This bill requires the SGC to establish and maintain a grant program to fund LAFCO actions and studies. Individual LAFCOs can apply to the SGC for funding. This measure requires the SGC to adopt guidelines, timelines, and application and reporting criteria for development and implementation of the program after consulting with California LAFCO (CALAFCO).
COMMENTS:
Who Pays? Traditionally, the agency that initiates dissolution, consolidation, annexation, or other change of organization pays for the costs associated with completing the process. LAFCOs are funded by the cities, counties, and, in 30 counties, special districts. CALAFCO states that one third of the 58 LAFCOs have an annual budget of less than $100,000 and one-fifth have an annual budget of less than $50,000.
According to the Author:
According to the author, "Consistent with a recommendation made in the 2017 Little Hoover Commission report, AB 1253 would provide LAFCOs, or Local Agency Formation Commissions, with a one-time small infusion of grant-like monies to focus efforts on streamlining local government and improving efficiency in service delivery. There is a need for LAFCOs to conduct more in-depth studies of local agency service providers that could result in more options for greater efficiencies, the elimination of non-functioning organizations, or reorganization actions. AB 1253 would establish a grant-like funding program, administered by the Strategic Growth Council, to provide LAFCOs with funding to conduct analyses of local government agencies and services for the purpose of streamlining the delivery of local government services. Through AB 1253, LAFCOs would be able to address known service and governance concerns that could potentially save California taxpayers money. Grant funds will be used specifically to conduct special studies to identify and support opportunities to create greater efficiencies in the provision of municipal services and to potentially initiate actions based on those studies that remove or reduce local costs, thus incentivizing local agencies to work with the LAFCO in developing and implementing reorganization plans. The grant program would sunset on December 31, 2025."
Arguments in Support:
The sponsor, CALAFCO, argues that, "While many LAFCOs are initiating actions to create improved efficiencies in the delivery of local government services, the reality is that certain LAFCOs and smaller districts lack the resources to propose consolidations and dissolutions, especially those serving disadvantaged communities. A CALAFCO statewide survey in 2017 showed that lack of funding was one of the top reasons why LAFCOs do not initiate such actions. Through AB 1253, LAFCOs will be able to actively address known service and governance concerns that could potentially save California taxpayers additional money through the reorganization of local government agencies and improved efficiencies in service delivery."
Arguments in Opposition:
According to the Association of California Water Agencies (ACWA), "Current law provides that a LAFCO proposing to consolidate, dissolve, or initiate other types of reorganizations of a special district must hold an election to decide the fate of that district if at least 10 percent of residents in the affected territory protest the proposed action. This threshold reflects the right residents should have to participate in debates over who serves them, especially when LAFCOs commence involuntary actions, such as forced consolidation. Under this bill, the only difference between the LAFCO-initiated reorganizations at issue is that the reorganizations would be funded by the State, rather than the individual LAFCOs. The various protest thresholds in the Cortese-Knox-Hertzberg Local Government Reorganization Act of 2000 have never depended on the source of funding. Creating two thresholds for the same proceeding complicates existing law and only serves to make it more difficult for residents to voice their concerns about LAFCO-initiated actions. Existing law must be maintained for such proceedings, regardless of funding.
"ACWA is also seeking an amendment to allow the public to provide comment when CALAFCO and the Strategic Growth Council discuss guidelines, timelines, and application and reporting criteria for the grant program. ACWA believes the public would help identify local issues that would benefit from this grant. ACWA opposes AB 1253 unless it is amended to address the above concerns."
FISCAL COMMENTS:
According to the Assembly Appropriations Committee, this bill will have the following fiscal effect:
- Estimated costs to the SGC of $170,000 (General Fund (GF)) annually for five years for one additional staff to establish and administer the grant program.
- One-time cost pressure to the GF of $1.5 million over five years to fund the grant program. Typically 5% of the grant total would go to the administrating agency, in this case the SGC, to administer the grants.
VOTES:
ASM LOCAL GOVERNMENT: 6-2-0
YES: Aguiar-Curry, Bloom, Chiu, Ramos, Luz Rivas, Robert Rivas
NO: Lackey, Voepel
ASM APPROPRIATIONS: 13-4-1
YES: Gonzalez, Bloom, Bonta, Calderon, Carrillo, Chau, Eggman, Gabriel, Eduardo Garcia, Maienschein, Petrie-Norris, Quirk, Robert Rivas
NO: Bigelow, Brough, Fong, Obernolte
ABS, ABST OR NV: Diep
UPDATED:
VERSION: February 21, 2019
CONSULTANT: Jimmy MacDonald / L. GOV. / (916) 319-3958 FN: 0000524
Date of Hearing: April 3, 2019
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Lorena Gonzalez, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 1253
Author:(Robert Rivas) – As Introduced Ver:February 21, 2019
Policy Committee: | Local Government | Vote: | 8-0 |
|
| ||
|
|
Urgency: No State Mandated Local Program: No Reimbursable: No
SUMMARY:
This bill requires the Strategic Growth Council (SGC), until July 1, 2025, to establish and administer a local agency formation commission (LAFCO) grant program to fund the dissolution of inactive special districts, prepare special studies and initiate other actions in disadvantaged communities, as specified. The bill specifies that program funding is subject to appropriation in the annual budget act.
FISCAL EFFECT:
- Estimated costs to the SGC of $170,000 (GF) annually for five years for one additional staff to establish and administer the grant program.
- One-time cost pressure to the GF of $1.5 million over five years to fund the grant program. Typically 5% of the grant total would go to the administrating agency, in this case the SGC, to administer the grants.
(The bill’s author submitted a legislative budget request for a one-time $1.5 million appropriation specifically to fund this bill. The request has not been heard in the budget subcommittee.)
COMMENTS:
- Purpose. This bill intends to implement a recommendation of the Little Hoover Commission to provide LAFCOs with a one-time infusion of funds to help them better meet their statutory directive to maintain orderly boundaries and seek greater efficiencies in delivering local services. According to the author, in some communities, this directive cannot be regularly met with current funding mechanisms, resulting in delays in or lack of important activities.
- Background. Existing law, The Cortese-Knox-Hertzberg Act of 2000, controls how local officials change the boundaries of cities and special districts and designates a LAFCO in each county to oversee boundary changes. Besides their more common annexation activities, LAFCOs also control district formations, consolidations and dissolutions, as well as city incorporations, consolidations and disincorporations.
Generally, the entity that initiates a dissolution, consolidation, annexation or other change of organization (the applicant) is required to pay for any costs associated with the process. Existing law, as enacted by SB 448 (Wieckowski) Chapter 336, Statutes of 2018, requires LAFCOs to dissolve inactive districts pursuant to an abbreviated process and to initiate dissolution proceedings for specified idle special districts. The costs for the latter are extensive and the process requires the applicant (LAFCO) to pay for a municipal service review and to hold hearings, protest hearings and, potentially, an election for voters to determine whether the district should be dissolved.
According to the California Association of Local Agency Formation Commissions (CALAFCO), simple proceedings can require up to six months of staff analysis time and up to $50,000.
LAFCOs are funded by cities, counties and, in 30 counties, special districts. CALAFCO indicates that one-third of the 58 LAFCOs have an annual budget of less than $100,000 and one-fifth have an annual budget of less than $50,000. After a LAFCO adopts a budget, it forwards the budget to the county auditor and costs are apportioned among the cities, counties and special districts with representation on the LAFCO. If those entities do not provide their share of funding, the auditor may appropriate property taxes or other revenues to the LAFCO to fully fund its budget.
- Little Hoover Commission Recommendation. The Little Hoover Commission issued a report in 2017 examining whether taxpayers are well-served by special districts and whether consolidation or dissolution of some special districts would improve local government operations and efficiency. Among the recommendations in the report, the commission suggested that the Legislature provide one-time grant funding of $1 million to $3 million to pay for some LAFCO activities to encourage LAFCOs or smaller special districts to develop and implement dissolution or consolidation plans. The commission noted that participants in its hearings on the issue suggested that the SGC administer such a program. This bill would implement that recommendation.
- Prior Legislation. AB 2258 (Caballero), of the 2017-18 Legislative Session, was nearly identical to this bill. That bill was vetoed by Governor Brown. In his veto message the governor stated, “This new spending proposal should be evaluated in the annual budget process where it can be weighed together with the state's other spending priorities.”
Analysis Prepared by: Jennifer Swenson / APPR. / (916) 319-2081
Date of Hearing: March 27, 2019
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON LOCAL GOVERNMENT
Cecilia Aguiar-Curry, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 1253 (
Author:Robert Rivas) – As Introduced Ver:February 21, 2019
SUBJECT: Local agency formation commissions: grant program.
SUMMARY: Authorizes the Strategic Growth Council (SGC) to administer a grant program to finance certain local agency formation commission (LAFCO) activities. Specifically, this bill:
- Requires the SGC to establish and administer a LAFCO grant program, including adopting guidelines, timelines, and application and reporting criteria for development and implementation of the program.
- Specifies that program funding is subject to appropriation in the annual budget.
- Provides that program funds awarded to participating LAFCOs shall be used to supplement, and not supplant, existing funding and staffing levels.
- Mandates that funds shall not be used to conduct municipal service reviews (MSRs).
- Requires the SGC, in granting funds under this program, to give preference to a LAFCO whose decisions are consistent with the goals of an adopted sustainable communities strategy.
- Specifies the types of studies and LAFCO actions the program is authorized to finance.
- Provides that a LAFCO shall repay the entire amount of the grant awarded by the SGC to the SGC if an eligible study is not completed within two years of the receipt of the grant funds. The LAFCO shall make repayment within 30 days from the two-year anniversary of receipt of the grant funds.
- Specifies the process that the LAFCO must follow for a change of organization funded by this program, including holding a public hearing and subsequent protest proceedings, and reporting requirements following the completion of the LAFCO action.
- Defines “disadvantaged community” as a community with an annual median household income that is less than 80% of the statewide annual median household income.
- Includes findings and declarations.
- Provides that this program shall become inoperative on July 31, 2025, and, as of January 1, 2026, is repealed.
EXISTING LAW:
- Enacts the Cortese-Knox-Hertzberg Local Government Reorganization Act of 2000 (CKH Act), which:
- Controls how local officials change the boundaries of cities and special districts, putting LAFCOs in charge of the proceedings; and,
- Directs LAFCOs to ensure that services are effectively and efficiently delivered, and local governments can only exercise their powers and provide services where allowed to by LAFCO, including the formation of new cities and special districts, modifications of existing boundaries, and dissolutions of unsustainable special districts.
- Controls how local officials change the boundaries of cities and special districts, putting LAFCOs in charge of the proceedings; and,
- Defines "inactive district" to mean a special district that meets all of the following:
- The special district, as defined in LAFCO law, to mean an agency of the state, formed pursuant to general law or special act, for the local performance of governmental or proprietary functions within limited boundaries, as specified;
- The special district has had no financial transactions in the previous fiscal year;
- The special district has no assets and liabilities; and,
- The special district has no outstanding debts, judgments, litigation, contracts, liens,
or claims.
- Requires the State Controller to notify the LAFCO in the county or counties in which the inactive district is located, if the State Controller has included the district on the list of inactive districts.
- Requires the LAFCO to initiate dissolution of inactive districts by resolution within 90 days of receiving notification from the State Controller, unless the LAFCO determines that the district does not meet the specified criteria.
- Requires the LAFCO to notify the State Controller, if the LAFCO determines that a district does not meet the criteria for an inactive district.
- Requires the LAFCO to hold one public hearing, within 90 days of the adoption of the resolution initiating dissolution, on the dissolution of an inactive district.
- Prohibits the dissolution of an inactive district from being subject to protest and election requirements or determinations by the LAFCO.
- Prohibits the dissolution process for inactive districts in this bill from applying to a special district formed by special legislation during the period of time in which the district is authorized to obtain funding.
FISCAL EFFECT: This bill is keyed fiscal.
COMMENTS:
- Bill Summary. This bill requires the SGC to establish and maintain a grant program to fund LAFCO actions and studies. Individual LAFCOs can apply to the SGC for funding. This measure requires the SGC to adopt guidelines, timelines, and application and reporting criteria for development and implementation of the program after consulting with CALAFCO.
This bill is sponsored by CALAFCO.
- Little Hoover Commission. The Little Hoover Commission serves as California’s independent oversight agency by investigating government operations. Through reports and legislative proposals, it makes recommendations to the Governor and Legislature to promote economy, efficiency, and improved service in state operations. The Commission released the report “Special Districts: Improving Oversight and Transparency” in August 2017, making 20 different recommendations to improve the accountability and operation of special districts.
In the report, the Little Hoover Commission suggested that, “The Commission in its 2000 report and again in this study heard that certain LAFCOs and smaller districts lack the resources to propose consolidations and dissolutions. As part of the August 2016 hearing and June 2017 advisory committee meeting, the Commission was told a small one-time infusion of $1 million to $3 million in grant funding could save California taxpayers money if local government is streamlined and efficiency is improved. This funding could provide an incentive for LAFCOs or smaller districts to start a dissolution or consolidation process. Participants in the Commission’s public process suggested the Strategic Growth Council or Department of Conservation could administer this one-time funding. The Legislature should provide one-time grant funding to pay for specified LAFCO activities, particularly to incentivize LAFCOs or smaller special districts to develop and implement dissolution or consolidation plans with timelines for expected outcomes. Funding should be tied to process completion and results, including enforcement authority for corrective action and consolidation.” - Author’s Statement. According to the author, “Consistent with a recommendation made in the 2017 Little Hoover Commission report, AB 1253 would provide LAFCOs, or Local Agency Formation Commissions, with a one-time small infusion of grant-like monies to focus efforts on streamlining local government and improving efficiency in service delivery. There is a need for LAFCOs to conduct more in-depth studies of local agency service providers that could result in more options for greater efficiencies, the elimination of non-functioning organizations, or reorganization actions. AB 1253 would establish a grant-like funding program, administered by the Strategic Growth Council, to provide LAFCOs with funding to conduct analyses of local government agencies and services for the purpose of streamlining the delivery of local government services. Through AB 1253, LAFCOs would be able to address known service and governance concerns that could potentially save California taxpayers money. Grant funds will be used specifically to conduct special studies to identify and support opportunities to create greater efficiencies in the provision of municipal services and to potentially initiate actions based on those studies that remove or reduce local costs, thus incentivizing local agencies to work with the LAFCO in developing and implementing reorganization plans. The grant program would sunset on December 31, 2025.”
- Who Pays? Traditionally, the agency that initiates dissolution, consolidation, annexation, or other change of organization pays for the costs associated with completing the process. LAFCOs are funded by the cities, counties, and, in 30 counties, special districts. CALAFCO states that one third of the 58 LAFCOs have an annual budget of less than $100,000 and one-fifth have an annual budget of less than $50,000.
- Governor’s Veto. AB 2258 (Caballero, 2018) was identical to AB 1253 and was passed by the Legislature. However, the Governor vetoed AB 2258 stating, “I am returning Assembly Bill 2258 without my signature. Subject to an appropriation in the annual Budget Act, this bill requires the Strategic Growth Council to establish and administer a grant program to fund various activities performed by Local Agency Formation Commissions. This new spending proposal should be evaluated in the annual budget process where it can be weighed together with the state's other spending priorities.”
- Arguments in Support. The sponsor argues that, “While many LAFCOs are initiating actions to create improved efficiencies in the delivery of local government services, the reality is that certain LAFCOs and smaller districts lack the resources to propose consolidations and dissolutions, especially those serving disadvantaged communities.
A CALAFCO statewide survey in 2017 showed that lack of funding was one of the top reasons why LAFCOs do not initiate such actions. Through AB 1253, LAFCOs will be able to actively address known service and governance concerns that could potentially save California taxpayers additional money through the reorganization of local government agencies and improved efficiencies in service delivery.” - Arguments in Opposition. According to the opposition, “Current law provides that a LAFCO proposing to consolidate, dissolve, or initiate other types of reorganizations of a special district must hold an election to decide the fate of that district if at least 10 percent of residents in the affected territory protest the proposed action. This threshold reflects the right residents should have to participate in debates over who serves them, especially when LAFCOs commence involuntary actions, such as forced consolidation. Under this bill, the only difference between the LAFCO-initiated reorganizations at issue is that the reorganizations would be funded by the State, rather than the individual LAFCOs. The various protest thresholds in the Cortese-Knox-Hertzberg Local Government Reorganization Act of 2000 have never depended on the source of funding. Creating two thresholds for the same proceeding complicates existing law and only serves to make it more difficult for residents to voice their concerns about LAFCO-initiated actions. Existing law must be maintained for such proceedings, regardless of funding.”
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
CALAFCO [SPONSOR]
Association of California Healthcare Agencies
California Special Districts Association
LAFCOs of: Alameda, Butte, Contra Costa, El Dorado, Glenn, Los Angeles, Mendocino, Merced, Napa, Nevada, San Benito, San Mateo, Santa Cruz, and Yolo
League of California Cities
Rural County Representatives of California
Opposition
Association of California Water Agencies (as amended)
Analysis Prepared by: Jimmy MacDonald / L. GOV. / (916) 319-3958
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):