AB 1270: False Claims Act.
- Session Year: 2019-2020
- House: Assembly
- Latest Version Date: 2019-08-13
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Aug 30, 2019 | In committee: Held under submission. |
| Aug 19, 2019 | In committee: Referred to APPR. suspense file. |
| Aug 13, 2019 | Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Aug 12, 2019 | From committee: Amend, and do pass as amended and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 5. Noes 2.) (July 10). |
| Jul 3, 2019 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on GOV. & F. (Ayes 7. Noes 2.) (July 2). Re-referred to Com. on GOV. & F. |
| Jun 24, 2019 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to committee. Read second time, amended, and re-referred to Com. on JUD. |
| Jun 6, 2019 | Referred to Coms. on JUD. and GOV. & F. |
| May 24, 2019 | In Senate. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. |
| May 23, 2019 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Senate. |
| May 20, 2019 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| May 16, 2019 | From committee: Do pass. (Ayes 13. Noes 5.) (May 16). |
| Apr 24, 2019 | In committee: Set, first hearing. Referred to APPR. suspense file. |
| Apr 11, 2019 | Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Apr 10, 2019 | Read second time and amended. |
| Apr 9, 2019 | From committee: Amend, and do pass as amended and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 9. Noes 3.) (April 9). |
| Mar 11, 2019 | Referred to Com. on JUD. |
| Feb 22, 2019 | From printer. May be heard in committee March 24. |
| Feb 21, 2019 | Read first time. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Aug 19, 2019 | Placed on suspense file | Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Jul 10, 2019 | Do pass as amended, but first amend, and re-refer to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Senate Standing Committee on Governance and Finance |
Passed |
|
| Jul 2, 2019 | Do pass, but first be re-referred to the Committee on [Governance and Finance] | Senate Standing Committee on Judiciary |
Passed |
|
| May 23, 2019 | AB 1270 Mark Stone Assembly Third Reading | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| May 16, 2019 | Do pass. | Assembly Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Apr 9, 2019 | Do pass as amended and be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Assembly Standing Committee on Judiciary |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
SENATE COMMITTEE ON
Senator Anthony Portantino, Chair
2019 - 2020 Regular Session
AB 1270 (Mark Stone) - False Claims Act
Version: | Policy Vote: |
Urgency: | Mandate: |
Hearing Date: | Consultant: |
Bill Summary:
AB 1270 would apply the California False Claims Act (CFCA) to cases of tax fraud, as specified. It also would clarify provisions of the act.
Fiscal Impact:
- Department of Justice: The department reports ongoing annual costs of $1.457 million for the following new positions and costs to meet anticipated workload demands resulting from this bill: 2.0 Deputy Attorneys General, 2.0 Senior Legal Analysts, 3.0 Legal Secretaries, and $300,000 for legal expert witness fees. (Special fund*)
- Courts: Unknown, potentially-significant workload cost pressures to the courts to adjudicate additional CFCA lawsuits filed resulting from this measure. While the superior courts are not funded on a workload basis, an increase in workload could result in delayed court services and would put pressure on the General Fund to fund additional staff and resources. For example, the Budget Act of 2019 appropriated $41.8 million from the General Fund to backfill continued reduction in fine and penalty revenue for trial court operations. (General Fund**)
- State revenue: This bill could result in the collection of additional tax revenue to the state and penalty revenue resulting from successful claims. (General Fund, various funds)
*False Claims Act Fund
**Trial Court Trust Fund
Background:
According to the analysis of this bill by the Senate Committee on Governance and Finance:
False claims statutes seek to uncover and prosecute fraudulent behavior. Congress enacted the first false claims statute in 1863 in response to illegal price-fixing and defective weaponry and supplies sold to the Union Army during the Civil War. The current Federal False Claims Act (Federal FCA) prohibits any person from knowingly presenting a false or fraudulent claim for payment or approval to the federal government. Any person found liable for violation of the Federal FCA is liable to the United States government for civil penalties and treble damages, or three times the amount of damages sustained by the government resulting from the act. Congress added the requirement for the false and fraudulent claim to be “knowing” in 1986, at which time it also added the “reverse false claim,” which prohibits persons from avoiding paying or transmitting money or property to the government.
The federal government provides a 10-percentage-point increase in their share of amounts from some cases for states that enact state statutes analogous to the Federal FCA that meet certain requirements. Currently, 29 states have their own false claims statutes, twenty of which qualify for the federal incentive, including California. The California False Claims Act (CFCA) is the California equivalent of the Federal FCA, which encourages employees, contractors, or agents to disclose false or fraudulent claims that their employers or others have made to the government, who are then protected from retaliation. The CFCA authorizes the Attorney General, or the prosecuting authority of a political subdivision, and any person acting as a qui tam plaintiff, similar to federal law, to bring a civil action in the name of the state or political subdivision. The CFCA establishes liability to the state for persons who commit certain enumerated acts relating to false claims submitted to the state, and allows for treble damages and civil penalties.
Under the CFCA, individuals who are aware of fraudulent activity consult an attorney, who then contacts the Attorney General or a County District Attorney, who investigate the allegations. The government may request additional time to investigate the matter, while the complaint remains under seal with any supporting affidavits or submissions made in camera. Generally, the seal is lifted once the government notifies the court that it intends to proceed with the action or, alternatively, once the government notifies the court that it declines to proceed and the qui tam plaintiff assumes responsibility for prosecuting the matter.
The CFCA has always expressly prohibited claims, records, or statements under the Revenue and Taxation Code. Instead, state law charges the Franchise Tax Board (FTB) with administering the Personal Income and Corporation Taxes, and the California Department of Tax and Fee Administration (CDTFA) with the Sales and Use Tax, among other tax and fee programs.
Proposed Law:
This bill would apply the CFCA to claims, records, or statements made under the Revenue and Taxation Code if specified conditions are met. Specifically, it would:
- Apply to instances in which the damages pleaded in an action under the act exceed $200,000 and that the claim, record, or statement was made on or after January 1, 2020.
- Require the Attorney General or prosecuting authority, as described, to consult with the taxing authorities to whom the claim was submitted prior to filing or intervening in any action under the CFCA that is based on the filing of false claims, records, or statements made under the Revenue and Taxation Code.
- Allow the Attorney General or the prosecuting authority, but not the qui tam plaintiff, to obtain otherwise confidential records relating to taxes, fees, or other obligations under the Revenue and Taxation Code. Such information would be required to be kept confidential, except as necessary to investigate and prosecute violations of these provisions.
- Prohibit the disclosure of federal tax information to the Attorney General or the prosecuting authority without authorization from the Internal Revenue Service.
- Would expand the whistleblower protections of the CFCA to any current or former employee, contractor, or agent.
- Require that the materiality test, with respect to if a false record or statement is material, focus on the potential effect of the false record or statement when it is made, not on the actual effect of the false statement when it is discovered. This bill would indicate that this change are declaratory of existing law.
- Specify that the amount of damages include consequential damages. This bill would indicate that this change are declaratory of existing law.
Related Legislation:
SB 387 (Jackson, Ch. 121, Stats. 2017) re-aligned the civil penalty provisions of CFCA with those of the federal False Claims Act and provided for automatic adjustments to the penalty range in accordance with federal law by indexing California’s penalties to the Federal Civil Penalties Inflation Adjustment Act of 1990.
AB 2492 (Blumenfield, Ch. 647, Stats. 2012) increased the penalty range for each violation to between $5,500 and $11,000.
Staff Comments:
The actual fiscal impact of AB 1270 to the courts will depend on many unknown factors, including the numbers of CFCA violations alleged to have occurred, if the Franchise Tax Board would have filed an action absent the changes proposed by this measure, if parties settle before the filing of an action, and the factors unique to each case. While it is unknown how many actions for alleged violations consumers would file ultimately, it generally costs about $7,644 to operate a courtroom for one day. Additionally, it costs the court about $12,750, on average, in personnel and resources to adjudicate an unlimited civil case. These costs takes into consideration the time from when a petition or complaint is received by the court, processing and calendaring by the clerks, any hearings presided over by a judicial officer, and the finalizing of the outcome by the clerk. Consequently, if alleged Revenue and Taxation Code violations of the CFCA lead to the filing of four or more new large cases or a few complex cases that took longer than six days to adjudicate, the cost pressures to the court would surpass the Suspense File threshold. As indicated above, while the court is not funded on a workload basis, an increase in workload could result in delayed court services and would put pressure on the General Fund to fund additional staff and resources.
The Department of Justice anticipates an increased workload resulting from this measure. Committee staff queries if the anticipated personnel and costs reported by the department accurately reflects how many new Revenue and Taxation Code claims would be pursued under the CFCA by the department, as it is not known how many tax fraud violations of the act actually would occur.
-- END --
SENATE COMMITTEE ON GOVERNANCE AND FINANCE
Senator Mike McGuire, Chair
2019 - 2020 Regular
Bill No: | AB 1270 | Hearing Date: | 7/10/19 |
Author: | Mark Stone | Tax Levy: | No |
Version: | 6/24/19 | Fiscal: | Yes |
Consultant: | Grinnell | ||
False Claims Act
Amends the California False Claims Act to apply to claims, records, or statements made under the Revenue and Taxation Code in specified circumstances.
Background
False Claims Acts. False claims statutes seek to uncover and prosecute fraudulent behavior. Congress enacted the first false claims statute in 1863 in response to illegal price-fixing and defective weaponry and supplies sold to the Union Army during the Civil War. The current Federal False Claims Act (Federal FCA) prohibits any person from knowingly presenting a false or fraudulent claim for payment or approval to the federal government. Any person found liable for violation of the Federal FCA is liable to the United States government for civil penalties and treble damages, or three times the amount of damages sustained by the government resulting from the act. Congress added the requirement for the false and fraudulent claim to be “knowing” in 1986, at which time it also added the “reverse false claim,” which prohibits persons from avoiding paying or transmitting money or property to the government.
The federal government provides a 10-percentage-point increase in their share of amounts from some cases for states that enact state statutes analogous to the Federal FCA that meet certain requirements. Currently, 29 states have their own false claims statutes, twenty of which qualify for the federal incentive, including California. The California False Claims Act (CFCA) is the California equivalent of the Federal FCA, which encourages employees, contractors, or agents to disclose false or fraudulent claims that their employers or others have made to the government, who are then protected from retaliation. The CFCA authorizes the Attorney General, or the prosecuting authority of a political subdivision, and any person acting as a qui tam plaintiff, similar to federal law, to bring a civil action in the name of the state or political subdivision. The CFCA establishes liability to the state for persons who commit certain enumerated acts relating to false claims submitted to the state, and allows for treble damages and civil penalties.
Under the CFCA, individuals who are aware of fraudulent activity consult an attorney, who then contacts the Attorney General or a County District Attorney, who investigate the allegations. The government may request additional time to investigate the matter, while the complaint remains under seal with any supporting affidavits or submissions made in camera. Generally, the seal is lifted once the government notifies the court that it intends to proceed with the action or, alternatively, once the government notifies the court that it declines to proceed and the qui tam plaintiff assumes responsibility for prosecuting the matter.
The CFCA has always expressly prohibited claims, records, or statements under the Revenue and Taxation Code. Instead, state law charges the Franchise Tax Board (FTB) with administering the Personal Income and Corporation Taxes, and the California Department of Tax and Fee Administration (CDTFA) with the Sales and Use Tax, among other tax and fee programs.
Tax Enforcement. FTB can impose penalties when a taxpayer fails to file a tax return on or before its due date, or fails to pay the tax due as shown on their tax return by the due date of the return. FTB can also apply penalties for failure to furnish information or maintain records, as well as accuracy related penalties attributable primarily to negligence or disregard of rules and regulations, among others. Additionally, the Legislature enacted the Large Corporate Understatement Penalty in 2008, which applies a penalty of 20% of any understatement that exceeds $1 million of the tax shown on an original return for taxpayers filing under the Corporation Tax. FTB can also impose a penalty for fraud upon clear and convincing evidence that shows the taxpayer's intent to evade tax that the taxpayer believed to have owed. FTB can also prosecute taxpayers for criminal violations in specified circumstances.
When FTB detects an underpayment of tax, failure to file a return, or other violation during an audit or examination, it sends a “notice of proposed assessment” (NPA) to a taxpayer. Except in the case of a false or fraudulent return, FTB must send the NPA to the taxpayer within four years after the return was filed, and cannot assess or collect for the year for which the return was filed unless the NPA is mailed within the four-year period. The law extends this period to eight years for gross negligence. Either the taxpayer or the Internal Revenue Service can extend the statute of limitations. Upon receipt, the taxpayer may protest the NPA. If the agency denies the protest, the taxpayer may file an appeal with the Office of Tax Appeals (OTA). Taxpayers may also appeal to the courts if OTA decides against them.
CDTFA can also impose penalties for failing to file a return, failure to pay tax, fraud or intent to evade the law, and negligence or intentional disregard for rules and regulations, among other violations. CDTFA must send a notice of deficiency determination within three years after the last day of the calendar month following the quarterly period for which the amount is proposed to be determined, or within three years after the return is filed. However, CDTFA can impose penalties for failure to make a return, up to eight years after the last day of the calendar month following the quarterly period for which the amount is proposed to be determined. Upon receipt, the taxpayer may protest the notice of deficiency determination. If the agency denies the protest, the taxpayer may file an appeal with the Office of Tax Appeals (OTA). Taxpayers may also appeal to the courts if OTA decides against them. CDTFA can also prosecute taxpayers for criminal violations in specified circumstances.
Whistleblower statutes. Since 1984, the Legislature has authorized FTB to administer a tax whistleblower program by issuing regulations to establish a reward program for information that identifies unreported or underreported information. The authorization caps the whistleblower’s reward to 10% of the taxes collected resulting from the information provided. Persons employed by or contracting with a tax agency are ineligible for rewards. A similar statute allows CDTFA to make similar payments from amounts appropriated by the Legislature. The Legislature has not appropriated amounts to pay tax whistleblowers, so neither agency has established its program.
Confidentiality of taxpayer information. State law prohibits the disclosure of any taxpayer information, with some exceptions. Generally, FTB and CDTFA can disclose confidential information to other state tax agencies, federal tax agencies, and the Multistate Tax Commission solely for tax administration purposes, as well as to courts, law enforcement agencies, and the Department of Justice. State law bars unauthorized disclosure of state tax information, and provides unauthorized disclosure of federal tax information is a misdemeanor and felony.
Seeking to further reduce the tax gap, or the difference between tax amounts due under law and amounts actually collected, Attorney General Xavier Becerra wants to allow the CFCA to apply to claims made under the Revenue and Taxation Code.
Proposed Law
Assembly Bill 1270 amends the CFCA to apply to claims, records, or statements made under the Revenue and Taxation Code in specified circumstances. The Act applies when:
- Damages pleaded in such action exceed $200,000,
- The person who made the false claim has taxable income under the Personal Income Tax, net income under the Corporation Tax, or sales under the Sales and Use Tax, of more than $500,000.
The Attorney General or prosecuting authority of a political subdivision, which includes a county counsel, city attorney, other local government official, or counsel retained by a political subdivision, must consult with the taxing authorities to whom the claim, record, or statement was submitted before filing or intervening in any action. The Attorney General or prosecuting authority, but not the qui tam plaintiff, can obtain confidential taxpayer information from FTB, CDTFA, or local taxing authorities, needed to investigate or prosecute suspected violations. The bill authorizes these entities to make such disclosures. The bill prohibits any entity from providing federal tax information without authorization from the Internal Revenue Service. AB 1270 requires any information provided as a result of the bill to be kept confidential except as necessary to investigate and prosecute suspected violations.
The measure also makes other changes to the CFCA, including:
- Specifies that the materiality test with respect to whether a false record or statement is material must focus on the potential effect of the false record or statement when it is made, not on the actual effect of the false statement when it is discovered, and states that this change is declaratory of existing law.
- Specifies that the amount of damages include consequential damages and that these changes are declaratory of existing law.
- Clarifies that the person entitled to all relief necessary to be made whole is a current or former employee, contractor, or agent.
- Clarifies that a “lawful act” done by the employee, contractor, agent, or associated other includes obtaining or transmitting to the state, a political subdivision, a qui tam plaintiff, or private counsel employed to investigate, potentially file, or file a course of action under the CFCA, documents, data, correspondence, electronic mail, or any other information, even though that act may violate a contract, employment term, or duty owed to the employer or contractor.
- Provides that the above provision shall not be interpreted to prevent any law enforcement authority from bringing a civil or criminal action against any person for violating any provision of law, and clarifies that the person is entitled to all relief necessary to be made whole also if they are harmed or penalized by an employer or contractor.
The bill also makes a legislative finding regarding preserving the confidentiality of tax records.
State Revenue Impact
FTB states that AB 1270 does not affect state revenues.
Comments
1. Purpose of the bill. According to the author, “AB 1270 is an important bill that will strengthen tax enforcement efforts and protect public dollars against fraud. AB 1270 not only strengthens provisions to protect whistleblowers from civil law suits, it also ensures that the government will be able to recover what it is owed from damages caused by fraud. The measure also codifies the definition of materiality, providing statutory clarification and resolving uncertainty caused by a number of conflicting court cases on the issue. Furthermore, the tax gap in California – the difference between what taxpayers owe and what the state takes in – amounts to over $20 billion, thus, it is clearly in the state’s best interests to be more vigilant about protecting public money from all types of fraud. By including tax fraud under the California False Claims Act, whistleblowers will be incentivized to report fraud without the fear of retaliation and legal action looming over them.”
2. Tax enforcement. Few say that FTB and CDTFA’s current tax enforcement efforts are less than robust. However, each agency’s charge is to verify the amount of tax paid by the taxpayer is correct for the time period in question, so it is possible that neither can fully ascertain fraudulent activity beyond what the taxpayer has chosen to reflect on the return; many famous abusive tax avoidance deals resembled simple transactions on corporate tax returns. Only whistleblowers can illuminate tax-motivated transactions that revenue agents may not detect. By allowing the CFCA to apply to claims made under the Revenue and Taxation Code, AB 1270 adds a powerful tool to California’s tax enforcement regime by allowing authorities to pursue false claims actions based on information received from whistleblowers. However, some taxpayers are concerned that the measure places them in a position of having to defend false claims actions for merely taking a potentially aggressive, but legitimate and defensible, position on a tax return. While it is possible that agencies pursuing a CFCA action could interpret a tax statute differently than FTB or CDTFA, and proceed with a whistleblower claim where the tax agency would have declined, prosecutors are reluctant to pursue cases unless they are confident of success. Also, AB 1270 requires the Attorney General or other prosecuting authority to consult with the state’s tax agencies before proceeding with the action. Additionally, the Department of Justice argues that the CFCA only applies to claims or statements which are knowingly false, or made in reckless disregard or deliberate ignorance of the truth, so taxpayer making good faith mistakes need not worry. With that said, it is possible that some clarification could be beneficial to ensure that AB 1270’s expansion does not apply to legitimate but aggressive positions on tax returns. The Committee may wish to consider amending AB 1270 to clarify that the measure’s expansion does not apply to credible claims taxpayers make as part of taking a position on their returns.
3. Empire state of mind. In 2010, New York became the first state to explicitly allow its false claims act to apply to tax cases. As a result, Attorney General Eric Schneiderman created the Taxpayer Protection Bureau within his office to process and investigate whistleblower submissions. In 2012, the state of New York sued telecommunications provider Sprint Nextel based on a whistleblower’s information. According to the State’s complaint, Sprint “illegally avoided its New York sales tax obligations” by failing to collect sales taxes on its “flat-rate” calling plans and knowingly filed false tax returns, actions for which New York sought damages exceeding $300 million. In June 2013, a New York Supreme Court denied Sprint’s motion to dismiss the case after concluding that New York had sufficiently alleged violations of the state’s tax laws, a decision unanimously affirmed by the Supreme Court’s Appellate Division. Attorney General Barbara Underwood recently announced a $330 million settlement with the firm. AG Underwood also recently announce a $40 million settlement against Alabama-based investment firm Harbert Management, over state income taxes that Harbert paid to its home state of Alabama, instead of paying in the higher taxing rate state of New York. However, Starbucks recently won a recent case brought by a qui tam prosecutor where the AG declined to bring an action. In this case, the New York State Supreme Court granted Starbucks’ motion to dismiss claims that it had failed to collect more than $10 million of sales tax at its New York store.
4. Thresholds. AB 1270 applies the CFCA to a person who has taxable income under the Personal Income Tax, net income under the Corporation Tax, or sales under the Sales and Use Tax, of more than $500,000. This definition could potentially excluded a person who has no net income in a current taxable year and whose sales are not subject to the sales and use tax, such as services, intangibles, or excluded items. The Committee may wish to consider amending AB 1270 to substitute the reference to net income for the Corporation tax to instead refer to gross receipts, less returns and allowances reportable to this state.
5. Effective dates. The measure’s application of the CFCA to claims under the Revenue and Taxation Code does not have an explicit effective date. The Committee may wish to consider amending AB 1270 to state that its change applies to claims made after the effective date of the bill.
6. Incoming! The Senate Judiciary Committee approved AB 1270 by a vote of 7 to 2 on July 3rd. The Committee on Governance and Finance is considering the bill as the committee of second reference.
Assembly Actions
Assembly Judiciary Committee: 9-3
Assembly Appropriations Committee: 13-5
Assembly Floor: 56-19
Support and Opposition
(7/5/19)
Support: Attorney General Xavier Becerra, California District Attorneys Association, California Labor Federation, Constantine Cannon LLP, Consumer Attorneys of California
Opposition: Associated General Contractors of California, California Bankers Association, California Chamber of Commerce, California Retailers Association, California Society of CPAs, California Taxpayers Association, Cellular Telecommunications and Internet Association, Civil Justice Association of California, Computing Technology Industry Association, Council on State Taxation, Family Business Association of California, Motion Picture Association of America, National Federation of Independent Business, Tracfone Wireless.
- END --
Senator Hannah-Beth Jackson, Chair
2019-2020 Regular Session
Bill No: AB 1270 (Author:Mark Stone)
Version: June 24, 2019
Hearing Date: July 2, 2019
Fiscal: Yes
Urgency: No
Consultant: MEC
SUBJECT
False Claims Act
DIGEST
This bill applies the California False Claims Act (CFCA) to cases of tax fraud, as specified, and clarifies provisions of the CFCA.
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
The CFCA is a whistleblower statute designed to protect public funds. The CFCA establishes liability to the state for persons who commit certain enumerated acts relating to false claims submitted to the state. It provides for treble damages and civil penalties, contains a qui tam provision, and whistleblower protections.
This bill clarifies existing law with regard to the CFCA and expands the provisions of the CFCA to claims, records, or statements made under the Revenue and Taxation Code if specified conditions are met.
This bill is sponsored by the California Attorney General. Opposition is from the California Retailers Association, California Chamber of Commerce, and other business organizations.
PROPOSED CHANGES TO THE LAW
Existing law:
- Provides that a person who submits a false claim to the state, or to a political subdivision of the state, is liable for three times the amount of damages that the state or political subdivision sustains because of the false claim. (Gov. Code § 12651 (a))
- Allows recovery of costs and imposes a civil penalty ranging from $5,500 to $11,000 for each claim. For purposes of the CFCA, submitting a false claim consists of committing any one of several enumerated acts, including, but not limited to, knowingly making a false or fraudulent claim or statement to the state or political subdivision in order to obtain money, services, or some other benefit. (Gov. Code § 12651 (a))
- Requires the Attorney General or the prosecuting authority of a political subdivision to investigate diligently any false claim involving public funds, and authorizes the Attorney General or the prosecuting authority to bring a civil action on behalf of the state or political subdivision against a person who violates the CFCA. Gov. Code § 12652 (a)-(b).)
- Provides that, in cases where the state or political subdivision has elected not to proceed with the action, a person may bring an action in the name of the state or political subdivision as a qui tam plaintiff. Specifies that the qui tam plaintiff shall have the same right to conduct the action as the Attorney General or prosecuting authority would have had if it had chosen to proceed. (Gov. Code § 12662 (c) and (f).)
- Provides that if the state, a political subdivision, or the qui tam plaintiff proceeds with the action, the court may award to the prevailing defendant its reasonable attorneys' fees and expenses against the party that proceeded with the action only if the court finds that the claim was clearly frivolous, vexatious, or brought for purposes of harassment. (Gov. Code § 12652 (g)(9).)
- Provides that any employee, contractor, or agent shall be entitled to all relief necessary to make that employee, contractor, or agent whole, if that employee, contractor, or agent is discharged, demoted, suspended, threatened, harassed, or in any other manner discriminated against in the terms and conditions of their employment because of lawful acts done by the employee, contractor, agent, or associated others in furtherance of an action under this section or other efforts to stop one or more violations of the CFCA. Specifies that relief shall include reinstatement, two times the amount of back pay, interest on back pay, compensation for any special damages sustained, and, where appropriate, punitive damages. Provides that the defendant shall also be required to pay litigation costs and reasonable attorneys’ fees. (Gov. Code § 12653.)
This bill:
- Provides that the CFCA applies to claims, records, or statements made under the Revenue and Taxation Code if specified conditions are met, including if damages pleaded in an action under the CFCA exceed $200,000 and as specified.
- Requires the Attorney General or prosecuting authority, as described, to consult with the taxing authorities to whom the claim was submitted prior to filing or intervening in any action under the CFCA that is based on the filing of false claims, records, or statements made under the Revenue and Taxation Code.
- Authorizes the Attorney General or the prosecuting authority, but not the qui tam plaintiff, to obtain otherwise confidential records relating to taxes, fees, or other obligations under the Revenue and Taxation Code.
- Requires any information received pursuant to (2) and (3) above shall be kept confidential except as necessary to investigate and prosecute violations of these provisions.
- Specifies, with respect to whether a false record or statement is material, that the materiality test shall focus on the potential effect of the false record or statement when it is made, not on the actual effect of the false statement when it is discovered, and states that this change is declaratory of existing law.
- Specifies that the amount of damages include consequential damages and that these changes are declaratory of existing law.
- Clarifies that the person entitled to all relief necessary to be made whole is a current or former employee, contractor, or agent. Clarifies that a “lawful act” done by the employee, contractor, agent, or associated other shall include, but not be limited to, obtaining or transmitting to the state, a political subdivision, a qui tam plaintiff, or private counsel employed to investigate, potentially file, or file a course of action under the CFCA, documents, data, correspondence, electronic mail, or any other information, even though that act may violate a contract, employment term, or duty owed to the employer or contractor. Also provides that this shall not be interpreted to prevent any law enforcement authority from bringing a civil or criminal action against any person for violating any provision of law. Makes clear that the person is entitled to all relief necessary to be made whole also if they are harmed or penalized by an employer or contractor.
- Includes a finding and declaration regarding preserving the confidentiality of tax records.
COMMENTS
- Stated need for the bill
According to the author:
AB 1270 is an important bill that will strengthen tax enforcement efforts and protect public dollars against fraud. AB 1270 not only strengthens provisions to protect whistleblowers from civil law suits, it also ensures that the government will be able to recover what it is owed from damages caused by fraud. The measure also codifies the definition of materiality, providing statutory clarification and resolving uncertainty caused by a number of conflicting court cases on the issue.
Furthermore, the tax gap in California – the difference between what taxpayers owe and what the state takes in – amounts to over $20 billion, thus, it is clearly in the state’s best interests to be more vigilant about protecting public money from all types of fraud. By including tax fraud under the California False Claims Act, whistleblowers will be incentivized to report fraud without the fear of retaliation and legal action looming over them.
According to the sponsor, the California Attorney General:
Since 1987, the CFCA has been an effective tool in revealing, deterring, and punishing those who defraud our government of public funds. Under the CFCA, it is unlawful to make false claims against the government. The CFCA has two notable components: (1) it encourages private citizens (whistleblowers) to report fraud by providing them with a right to share in any recovery of money; and (2) it imposes treble damages on violators. A typical example of a case initiated under the CFCA involves a whistleblower alleging that a contractor for the government is overcharging a state or local agency for goods or services, thus defrauding the government of public funds.
The years and billions of taxpayer dollars recovered since the passage of the CFCA have proven the value of this anti-corruption law. They have also pointed to its shortcomings in keeping pace with the evolving schemes of corruption that violators employ against our government. The reforms to the CFCA proposed by AB 1270 expand its application to the most egregious cases of tax fraud. They clarify issues identified by our courts which, if left unaddressed, could be costly to taxpayers. They send a strong signal to whistleblowers that we appreciate and need their courage in stepping forward to uncover large-scale fraud committed by unscrupulous cheaters.
2. The False Claims Act
The Federal False Claims Act (Federal FCA) was enacted to combat fraud against the federal government and its myriad programs. It prohibits any person from “knowingly” presenting “a false or fraudulent claim for payment or approval” to the federal government. Any person found liable for violation of the Federal FCA is liable to the United States government for civil penalties and treble damages, or three times the amount of damages sustained by the government as a result of the act. (31 U.S.C. § 3729(a)(1).) The Federal FCA also contains a qui tam provision, allowing certain private persons to bring suit on behalf of themselves and the United States government. Such private persons may be eligible for a certain percentage of the proceeds awarded as a result of the actions. (31 U.S.C. § 3730.) The Federal FCA is widely hailed as the most effective and potent tool to detect, deter, and punish government fraud. The federal Department of Justice obtained more than $4.7 billion in settlements and judgments from civil cases involving fraud and false claims against the government in fiscal year 2016.
The federal government provides an incentive for states to enact state statutes analogous to the Federal FCA that meet certain requirements. The CFCA is the whistleblower statute analogous to the Federal FCA. It is designed to protect public funds by encouraging employees, contractors, or agents to disclose false or fraudulent claims that their employers or others have made to the government. The CFCA protects informants from retaliation. The CFCA authorizes the Attorney General, the prosecuting authority of a political subdivision, or any person acting as a qui tam plaintiff to bring a civil action in the name of the state or political subdivision. The CFCA establishes liability to the state for persons who commit certain enumerated acts relating to false claims submitted to the state. It provides for treble damages and civil penalties and also contains a qui tam provision. The CFCA largely tracks the prohibitions of the Federal FCA. (Gov. Code § 12650 et seq.)
The California Attorney General is sponsoring AB 1270 to expand the provisions of the CFCA to claims, records, or statements made under the Revenue and Taxation Code if specified conditions are met. The bill also clarifies provisions currently within the CFCA. Specifically, the bill clarifies that: “damages” includes consequential damage; protections apply to current and former employees; the materiality test for purposes of false claims violations shall focus on the potential effect of the false record or statement when it is made and not on the actual effect of the false record or statement when it is discovered; and “prosecuting authority” includes counsel retained by a political subdivision to act on its behalf for purposes of the Act.
The CFCA also provides that any employee, contractor, or agent shall be entitled to all relief necessary to make that employee, contractor, or agent whole, if that employee, contractor, or agent is discharged, demoted, suspended, threatened, harassed, or in any other manner discriminated against in the terms and conditions of their employment because of lawful acts done by the employee, contractor, agent, or associated others in furtherance of an action under this section or other efforts to stop one or more violations of the CFCA.
This bill further clarifies that: the person entitled to all relief necessary to be made whole is a current or former employee, contractor, or agent; and a “lawful act” done by the employee, contractor, agent, or associated other shall include, but not be limited to, obtaining or transmitting to the state, a political subdivision, a qui tam plaintiff, or private counsel employed to investigate, potentially file, or file a course of action under the CFCA, documents, data, correspondence, electronic mail, or any other information, even though that act may violate a contract, employment term, or duty owed to the employer or contractor. However, the bill also provides that this shall not be interpreted to prevent any law enforcement authority from bringing a civil or criminal action against any person for violating any provision of law. The bill also makes clear that the person is entitled to all relief necessary to be made whole also if they are harmed or penalized by an employer or contractor.
3. Codifying materiality standard
This bill codifies the California court interpretation of “materiality.” The California Retailers Association, in opposition to this codification, writes:
In changing the definition of “materiality”, the proposed legislation introduces subjectivity in deciding whether a false record or statement is considered “material’. Rather than defining materiality as the actual effects of a statement, this bill defines materiality as potential effects of a statement. “Potential effects” are more subjective and broader than “actual effects”. The consequence of such subjectivity is potential additional litigation. Costs of such additional litigation may come at the expense of the state.
In response, the California Attorney General explains:
First, the definition of materiality is actually not a change, but just a confirmation of the leading California court decision on this issue. In that decision, the court held that materiality is determined at the time the false claim is made, so the government’s later decision to pay the claim is not dispositive. (San Francisco Unified School Dist. ex rel. Contreras First Student, Inc. (2014) 224 Cal. App.4th 627.) Codifying the Contreras decision in statute will help avoid confusion.
Second, the law always has been that materiality is about the potential effects, not the actual effects, of a false claim or statement, because it focuses on the defendant’s intent at the time the false claim or statement was made, and whether the defendant was trying to get money from the government when making the false claim or statement. If the defendant tries to cheat the government and for some reason is fortunate enough that the government pays, the cheating still happened, and the defendant should not be immunized from liability for fraud.
Furthermore, there are many good reasons the government may need to continue paying a contractor even knowing or suspecting that, for example, the amount of an invoice is questionable, such as the need to avoid tipping off a contractor or to avoid interruption of essential services. The fact of the payment should not prevent the government from later pursuing recovery through a false claims action. As the Contreras court correctly noted, focusing on the government’s payment of false or fraudulent claims “would immunize certain instances of significant fraud and weaken the CFCA’s effectiveness at ‘policing the integrity of the government’s dealings with those to whom it pays money.’” (224 Cal.App.4th at 643.)
SUPPORT
California Attorney General (sponsor)
California District Attorneys Association
Constantine Cannon LLP
Consumer Attorneys of California
OPPOSITION
Associated General Contractors of California
California Bankers Association
California Chamber of Commerce
California Retailers Association
California Society of CPAs
California Taxpayers Association
Civil Justice Association of California
Computing Technology Industry Association
Council on State Taxation
Family Business Association of California
Motion Picture Association of America
National Federation of America
RELATED LEGISLATION
Pending Legislation: None known
Prior Legislation:
SB 387 (Jackson, Ch. 121, Stats. 2017) Re-aligned the civil penalty provisions of CFCA with those of the Federal FCA. This re-alignment allows California to continue collecting a 10 percent federal incentive bonus for Medicaid-related false claim recoveries. This bill further provided for automatic adjustments to the penalty range in accordance with federal law by indexing California’s penalties to the Federal Civil Penalties Inflation Adjustment Act of 1990.
AB 2492 (Blumenfield, Ch. 647, Stats. 2012) increased the penalty range for each violation to $5500-11,000.
PRIOR VOTES:
Assembly Floor (Ayes 56, Noes 19)
Assembly Appropriations Committee (Ayes 13, Noes 5)
Assembly Judiciary Committee (Ayes 9, Noes 3)
**************
ASSEMBLY THIRD READING
ATR Bill Id:AB 1270
Author:(Mark Stone)
As Amended Ver:April 10, 2019
Majority vote
SUMMARY:
Expands the California False Claims Act (CFCA) to apply to cases of tax fraud and makes clarifying changes to existing law.
Major Provisions
- Provides that "materiality," for purposes of false claims violations, is determined by the potential effect of the false record or statement when it is made, not on the actual effect of the false record or statement when it is discovered.
- Defines "prosecuting authority" to include counsel retained by a political subdivision to act on its behalf for purposes of the CFCA.
- Specifies that the damages awardable under CFCA include consequential damages.
- Provides that CFCA shall apply to claims, records, or statements made under the Revenue and Taxation Code, but only if the damages pleaded exceed $200,000 and the taxable income of the person or corporation who commits a violation exceeds $500,000
- Provides that the Attorney General or prosecuting authority, but not the qui tam plaintiff, may obtain from state and local taxing authorities otherwise confidential records relating to taxes, fees, surcharges, or other obligations under the Revenue & Taxation Code if they are needed to investigate or prosecute violations.
COMMENTS:
The California False Claims Act (CFCA) is a whistleblower statute designed to protect public funds by encouraging employees, contractors, or agents to disclose to the government information about any false or fraudulent claims made by their employers or others. CFCA also protects informants from retaliation. CFCA authorizes the Attorney General, the prosecuting authority of a political subdivision, or any person acting as a qui tam plaintiff to bring a civil action in the name of the state or political subdivision. Under CFCA, a person who knowingly submits a false or fraudulent claim for money, services, or benefits to the state or a political subdivision is liable for three times the amount of damages suffered by the state or political subdivision, the costs of bringing the action, and a civil penalty of not less than $5,000 and not more than $11,000. The CFCA requires the Attorney General and the prosecuting authority to investigate and prosecute false claims involving public funds. However, if the state or political subdivision does not act, then the law also allows an individual – as a qui tam plaintiff acting in the name of the state or political subdivision – to bring a civil action against a person or business that violates the CFCA. The role of the qui tam plaintiff is to supplement governmental efforts to identify and prosecute false claims by authorizing private parties to act on behalf of the state or local public entity.
This bill, sponsored by the California Attorney General, makes several changes designed to increase the effectiveness of the CFCA. First, and most notably, this bill would expand the application of the False Claims Act to cases of tax fraud where the amount of damages claimed exceeds $200,000 and the annual income of the person that made the false claim exceeds $500,000 for any taxable year. In other words, the bill would extend the CFCA only to the most egregious false claims of wealthy fraudsters. In addition, AB 1270 will make three important clarifying changes to existing law. First, it will clarify that recoverable damages include consequential damages. Second, it will specify that whistleblower provisions under CFCA apply to both former and current employees. Third, the bill will codify recent case law to define "materiality" as the potential effect of the false record or statement when made, not on the actual effect of the false record or statement when discovered.
According to the Author:
AB 1270 is an important bill that will strengthen tax enforcement efforts and protect public dollars against fraud. AB 1270 not only strengthens provisions to protect whistleblowers from civil law suits, it also ensures that the government will be able to recover what it is owed from damages caused by fraud." The author believes that extending this bill to cases of tax fraud is important because "the tax gap in California – the difference between what taxpayers owe and what the state takes in – amounts to over $20 billion, thus, it is clearly in the state's best interests to be more vigilant about protecting public money from all types of fraud." Finally, the author notes that this measure usefully "codifies the definition of materiality, providing statutory clarification and resolving uncertainty caused by a number of conflicting court cases on the issue.
Arguments in Support:
The California Attorney General's Office (AGO), the bill's sponsor, writes that AB 1270 will protect the government and people of California by expanding the CFCA to tax fraud cases, providing additional protection to whistleblowers who step forward to expose fraud, and clarify "that fraudsters are liable for consequential damages under the CFCA." The AGO claims that, "CFCA has been an effective tool in revealing, deterring, and punishing those who defraud our government of public funds" by encouraging and protecting private whistleblowers and imposing treble damages on violators. However, the AGO also notes that the CFCA has certain "shortcomings," including that it does not apply to tax fraud, one of the most costly forms of fraud. AB 1270 will usefully "expand [the CFCA] to the most egregious cases of tax fraud." The AGO concludes, "for the sake of California taxpayers who expect our government to operate effectively, we must utilize every tool at our disposal to protect our state's programs and services against fraudulent actors."
Arguments in Opposition:
Contractor associations oppose this bill because they believe changing the definition of "materiality" from "actual effect" at time of discovery to "potential effect" at the time of the statement will introduce a "subjective" element that will lead to additional litigation.
FISCAL COMMENTS:
According to the Assembly Appropriations analysis, costs (False Claims Act Fund/GF) of approximately $300,000 annually in increased workload to the Department of Justice (DOJ). DOJ estimates it would need two additional deputy attorney generals, two senior legal analysts and three legal secretaries to investigate and file suit against persons or businesses for possible tax fraud in excess of $200,000 and to consult with the taxing authorities prior to filing or intervening on cases and obtain confidential tax records.
VOTES:
ASM JUDICIARY: 9-3-0
YES: Mark Stone, Chau, Chiu, Gonzalez, Holden, Kalra, Maienschein, Petrie-Norris, Reyes
NO: Gallagher, Kiley, Obernolte
ASM APPROPRIATIONS: 13-5-0
YES: Gonzalez, Bloom, Bonta, Calderon, Carrillo, Chau, Eggman, Gabriel, Eduardo Garcia, Maienschein, Petrie-Norris, Quirk, Robert Rivas
NO: Bigelow, Brough, Diep, Fong, Obernolte
UPDATED:
VERSION: April 10, 2019
CONSULTANT: Thomas Clark / JUD. / (916) 319-2334 FN: 0000515
Date of Hearing: April 24, 2019
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Lorena Gonzalez, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 1270
Author:(Mark Stone) – As Amended Ver:April 10, 2019
Policy Committee: | Judiciary | Vote: | 9 - 3 |
|
| ||
|
|
Urgency: No State Mandated Local Program: No Reimbursable: No
SUMMARY:
This bill expands the California False Claims Act (CFCA) to apply to cases of tax fraud and makes clarifying changes to existing law. Specifically, this bill:
- Provides “materiality,” for purposes of false claims violations, is determined by the potential effect of the false record or statement when it is made, not on the actual effect of the false record or statement when it is discovered.
- Defines “prosecuting authority” to include counsel retained by a political subdivision to act on its behalf for purposes of the CFCA.
- Specifies that the damages awardable under CFCA include consequential damages.
- Provides the CFCA shall apply to claims, records or statements made under the Revenue and Taxation Code, but only if the damages pleaded exceed $200,000 and the taxable income of the person or corporation who commits a violation exceeds $500,000.
- Provides the attorney general or prosecuting authority, but not a qui tam plaintiff, may obtain from state and local taxing authorities otherwise confidential records relating to taxes, fees, surcharges or other obligations under the Revenue & Taxation Code if they are needed to investigate or prosecute violations.
FISCAL EFFECT:
Costs (False Claims Act Fund/GF) of approximately $300,000 annually in increased workload to the Department of Justice (DOJ). DOJ estimates it would need two additional deputy attorney generals, two senior legal analysts and three legal secretaries to investigate and file suit against persons or businesses for possible tax fraud in excess of $200,000 and to consult with the taxing authorities prior to filing or intervening on cases and obtain confidential tax records.
COMMENTS:
- Purpose and Background. The CFCA is a whistleblower statute designed to protect public funds by encouraging employees, contractors, or agents to disclose to the government information about any false or fraudulent claims made by their employers or others. CFCA also protects informants from retaliation. CFCA authorizes DOJ, the prosecuting authority of a political subdivision or any person acting as a qui tam plaintiff to bring a civil action in the name of the state or political subdivision. Under CFCA, a person who knowingly submits a false or fraudulent claim for money, services or benefits to the state or a political subdivision is liable for three times the amount of damages suffered by the state or political subdivision, the costs of bringing the action and a civil penalty of not less than $5,000 and not more than $11,000. The CFCA requires the attorney general and the prosecuting authority to investigate and prosecute false claims involving public funds. However, if the state or political subdivision does not act, the law allows an individual – as a qui tam plaintiff acting in the name of the state or political subdivision – to bring a civil action against a person or business that violates the CFCA. The role of the qui tam plaintiff is to supplement governmental efforts to identify and prosecute false claims by authorizing private parties to act on behalf of the state or local public entity.
- Support. According to Attorney General Xavier Becerra:
AB 1270 will protect the government and people of California by expanding the CFCA to tax fraud cases, providing additional protection to whistleblowers who step forward to expose fraud, and clarify that fraudsters are liable for consequential damages under the CFCA.
Analysis Prepared by: Kimberly Horiuchi / APPR. / (916) 319-2081
Date of Hearing: April 9, 2019
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON JUDICIARY
Mark Stone, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 1270
Author:(Mark Stone) – As Introduced Ver:February 21, 2019
As Proposed to be Amended
SUBJECT: False Claims Act
KEY ISSUES:
- should the California False Claims Act extend to cases of tax fraud?
- Should the California False Claims Act expressly provide that recoverable damages include consequential damages; that the act’s whistleblower protection provisions apply to both current and former employers; and that “Materiality” is determined by the potential effect of the false record or statement when it was made?
SYNOPSIS
The California False Claims Act (CFCA) is a whistleblower statute designed to protect public funds by encouraging employees, contractors, or agents to disclose false or fraudulent claims that their employers or others have made to the government. CFCA also protects informants from retaliation. CFCA authorizes the Attorney General, the prosecuting authority of a political subdivision, or any person acting as a qui tam plaintiff to bring a civil action in the name of the state or political subdivision. Sponsored by the California Attorney General’s Office, this bill makes several changes designed to increase the effectiveness of the CFCA. First, and most notably, this bill would expand the application of the False Claims Act to cases of tax fraud where the amount of damages claimed exceeds $200,000 and the annual income of the person that made the false claim exceeds $500,000 for any taxable year. In other words, the bill would extend the CFCA only to the most egregious false claims of wealthy fraudsters. In addition, AB 1270 will make three important clarifying changes to existing law. First, it will clarify that recoverable damages include consequential damages. Second, it will specify that whistleblower provisions under CFCA apply to both former and current employees. Third, the bill will codify recent case law to define “materiality” as the potential effect of the false record or statement when made, not on the actual effect of the false record or statement when discovered. The author will take amendments (reflected in the summary and analysis below) that address concerns raised by the Tax Franchise Board, mostly about access to confidential tax records by qui tam plaintiffs. There is no known opposition to the bill.
SUMMARY: Expands the California False Claims Act (CFCA) to apply to cases of tax fraud and makes clarifying changes to existing law. Specifically, this bill:
- Provides that “materiality,” for purposes of false claims violations, is determined by the potential effect of the false record or statement when it is made, not on the actual effect of the false record or statement when it is discovered.
- Defines “prosecuting authority” to include counsel retained by a political subdivision to act on its behalf for purposes of the CFCA.
- Specifies that the damages awardable under CFCA include consequential damages.
- Provides that CFCA shall apply to claims, records, or statements made under the Revenue and Taxation Code, but only if the damages pleaded exceed $200,000 and the taxable income of the person or corporation who commits a violation exceeds $500,000
- Provides that the Attorney General or prosecuting authority, but not the qui tam plaintiff, may obtain from state and local taxing authorities otherwise confidential records relating to taxes, fees, surcharges, or other obligations under the Revenue & Taxation Code if they are needed to investigate or prosecute violations.
EXISTING LAW:
- Makes a person who submits a false claim to the state, or to a political subdivision of the state, liable for three times the amount of damages that the state or political subdivision sustains because of the false claim. It also allows recovery costs and imposes a civil penalty ranging from $5,000 to $10,000 for each claim. For purposes of the CFCA, submitting a false claim consists of committing any one of several enumerated acts, including, but not limited to, knowingly making a false or fraudulent claim or statement to the state or political subdivision in order to obtain money, services, or some other benefit. (Government Code Section 12651 (a). All further statutory references are to this code, unless otherwise indicated.)
- Requires the Attorney General or the prosecuting authority of a political subdivision to investigate diligently any false claim involving public funds and authorizes the Attorney General or the prosecuting authority to bring a civil action on behalf of the state or political subdivision against a person who violates the CFCA. (Section 12652 (a)-(b).)
- Provides that, in cases where the state or political subdivision has elected not to proceed with the action, a person may bring an action in the name of the state or political subdivision as a qui tam plaintiff. Specifies that the qui tam plaintiff shall have the same right to conduct the action as the Attorney General or prosecuting authority would have had if it had chosen to proceed. (Section 12662 (c) and (f).)
- Provides that if the state, a political subdivision, or the qui tam plaintiff proceeds with the action, the court may award to the prevailing defendant its reasonable attorneys' fees and expenses against the party that proceeded with the action only if the court finds that the claim was clearly frivolous, vexatious, or brought for purposes of harassment. (Section 12652 (g)(9).)
- Provides that any employee, contractor, or agent that is discharged, demoted, suspended, threatened, harassed, or otherwise discriminated against for disclosing information of unlawful conduct or doing anything in furtherance of a false claim action shall be entitled to all necessary relief. Specifies that relief shall include reinstatement, two times the amount of back pay, interest on back pay, compensation for any special damages sustained, and, where appropriate, punitive damages. Provides that the defendant shall also be required to pay litigation costs and reasonable attorneys’ fees. (Section 12653.)
FISCAL EFFECT: As currently in print the bill is keyed fiscal.
COMMENTS: The California False Claims Act (CFCA) is a whistleblower statute designed to protect public funds by encouraging employees, contractors, or agents to disclose to the government information about any false or fraudulent claims made by their employers or others. CFCA also protects informants from retaliation. CFCA authorizes the Attorney General, the prosecuting authority of a political subdivision, or any person acting as a qui tam plaintiff to bring a civil action in the name of the state or political subdivision. Under CFCA, a person who knowingly submits a false or fraudulent claim for money, services, or benefits to the state or a political subdivision is liable for three times the amount of damages suffered by the state or political subdivision, the costs of bringing the action, and a civil penalty of not less than $5,000 and not more than $11,000. The CFCA requires the Attorney General and the prosecuting authority to investigate and prosecute false claims involving public funds. However, if the state or political subdivision does not act, then the law also allows an individual – as a qui tam plaintiff acting in the name of the state or political subdivision – to bring a civil action against a person or business that violates the CFCA. The role of the qui tam plaintiff is to supplement governmental efforts to identify and prosecute false claims by authorizing private parties to act on behalf of the state or local public entity. (See State Ex. Rel. Bowen v. Bank of American Corp. (2005) 126 Cal. App. 4th 225.)
Application of the CFCA to Largest Cases of Tax Fraud: While courts advocate construing the CFCA broadly in order to give the statute the widest possible coverage and effect (Contreras v. First Student, Inc. (2014) 224 Cal. App. 4th 627), the statute is nonetheless limited in various ways. Most notably for purposes of this bill, existing law expressly states that the CFCA “does not apply to claims, records, or statements made under the Revenue and Taxation Code.” (Government Code Section 12651 (f).) This bill proposes to strike that limitation and expressly extend CFCA to claims under the Revenue and Taxation Code, but only if both of the following are true: (1) the damages pleaded exceed $200,000; and (2) the annual taxable income of the person who made the false claim exceeds $500,000. In other words, AB 1270 seeks only to capture the most egregious cases of tax fraud committed by wealthy persons or businesses. AB 1270 does not seek to capture individuals or small businesses that make mistakes or commit relatively minor violations.
Amendments Will Address Concerns Raised by Franchise Tax Board: Although the Franchise Tax Board (FTB) does not oppose or take any position on this bill, it raised questions with the author and sponsor and suggested possible amendments to the bill. While the FTB had no objection to extending the CFCA to cases of tax fraud, it nonetheless expressed concern that private qui tam plaintiffs could gain access to tax records that are otherwise confidential. The author will amend the bill in this Committee to provide that, while the Attorney General and local prosecuting authorities will have access to records needed to conduct an investigation and prosecution, qui tam plaintiffs will not. It is possible that qui tam plaintiffs could gain access to those records by some other lawful means – such as subpoena or court order – but unlike the Attorney General and prosecuting authorities, they would not have statutory authority to access those records under the CFCA.
Clarifying Amendments to Existing Law: While the extension of the CFCA to tax fraud cases constitutes a significant change in the law, the other provisions of AB 1270 arguably just clarify existing law. First, while existing law states that a person who violates the CFCA is liable for “all damages” suffered by the state or political subdivision, this bill specifies that this would include consequential damages. One could argue that “all” damages already includes consequential damages; moreover, the other provisions of the CFCA suggest that consequential damages are consistent with the overall purpose and aim of the law. For example, the CFCA provides for punitive damages to an employee who suffers retaliation for providing information or otherwise further a false claim action, suggesting the seriousness with which the Legislature views false claims against the government. Second, this bill clarifies that the whistleblower protections of the CFCA apply to both current and former employees of the violator. This too seems consistent with other whistleblower statutes and common sense, as both current and former employees have valuable inside information about the unlawful acts that the CFCA seeks to prevent. Finally, this bill amends the definition of “materiality” to reflect recent case law on the matter. Some federal case law suggests that a false claim could not have been “material” in influencing the government’s decision if the government continued paying the claim despite knowing its falsity. California case law, on the other hand, holds that materiality is determined when the false claim is made, so that a government’s decision to pay the claim after knowing the claim is false does not negate the materiality of the false claim. (San Francisco Unified School Dist. ex. rel. Contreras v. First Student, Inc. (2014) 224 Cal. App. 4th 627.) As the Attorney General’s Office has explained to the Committee, there are many good reasons why a government will continue to pay a claim, such as not wanting to tip off the claimant or to avoid disrupting essential services. Under the reasoning of the federal courts, however, materiality would be determined at the point of discovery, meaning that the state could not claim damages for any payment made after discovery. This bill codifies the reasoning of the California courts, thereby taking account of the valid reasons a public entity might continue to make payments after discovery.
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: According to the author, “AB 1270 is an important bill that will strengthen tax enforcement efforts and protect public dollars against fraud. AB 1270 not only strengthens provisions to protect whistleblowers from civil law suits, it also ensures that the government will be able to recover what it is owed from damages caused by fraud.” The author believes that extending this bill to cases of tax fraud is important because “the tax gap in California – the difference between what taxpayers owe and what the state takes in – amounts to over $20 billion, thus, it is clearly in the state’s best interests to be more vigilant about protecting public money from all types of fraud.” Finally, the author notes that this measure usefully “codifies the definition of materiality, providing statutory clarification and resolving uncertainty caused by a number of conflicting court cases on the issue.”
The California Attorney General’s Office (AGO), the bill’s sponsor, writes that AB 1270 will protect the government and people of California by expanding the CFCA to tax fraud cases, providing additional protection to whistleblowers who step forward to expose fraud, and clarify “that fraudsters are liable for consequential damages under the CFCA.” The AGO claims that, “CFCA has been an effective tool in revealing, deterring, and punishing those who defraud our government of public funds” by encouraging and protecting private whistleblowers and imposing treble damages on violators. However, the AGO also notes that the CFCA has certain “shortcomings,” including that it does not apply to tax fraud, one of the most costly forms of fraud. AB 1270 will usefully “expand [the CFCA] to the most egregious cases of tax fraud.” The AGO concludes, “for the sake of California taxpayers who expect our government to operate effectively, we must utilize every tool at our disposal to protect our state’s programs and services against fraudulent actors.”
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
California Attorney General’s Office (sponsor)
California District Attorneys Association
Opposition
None on file
Analysis Prepared by: Thomas Clark / JUD. / (916) 319-2334
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):