AB 1281: Privacy: California Consumer Privacy Act of 2018.
- Session Year: 2019-2020
- House: Assembly
- Latest Version Date: 2020-09-29
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Sep 29, 2020 | Chaptered by Secretary of State - Chapter 268, Statutes of 2020. |
| Sep 29, 2020 | Approved by the Governor. |
| Sep 8, 2020 | Enrolled and presented to the Governor at 4:30 p.m. |
| Aug 30, 2020 | Senate amendments concurred in. To Engrossing and Enrolling. (Ayes 75. Noes 0. Page 5320.). |
| Aug 28, 2020 | In Assembly. Concurrence in Senate amendments pending. |
| Aug 28, 2020 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Assembly. (Ayes 39. Noes 0. Page 4379.). |
| Aug 20, 2020 | Read second time. Ordered to Consent Calendar. |
| Aug 19, 2020 | From committee: Be ordered to second reading file pursuant to Senate Rule 28.8 and ordered to Consent Calendar. |
| Aug 13, 2020 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on APPR. with recommendation: To Consent Calendar. (Ayes 9. Noes 0.) (August 13). Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Jul 1, 2020 | Re-referred to Com. on JUD. |
| Jun 26, 2020 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| Jun 25, 2020 | From inactive file. |
| Sep 10, 2019 | Ordered to inactive file at the request of Senator Wieckowski. |
| Aug 30, 2019 | From committee: Do pass. (Ayes 5. Noes 2.) (August 30). |
| Aug 12, 2019 | In committee: Referred to APPR. suspense file. |
| Jul 5, 2019 | Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Jul 3, 2019 | From committee: Amend, and do pass as amended and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 7. Noes 2.) (July 2). |
| Jun 27, 2019 | In committee: Set, first hearing. Hearing canceled at the request of author. |
| Jun 21, 2019 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to committee. Read second time, amended, and re-referred to Com. on JUD. |
| May 8, 2019 | Referred to Coms. on JUD. and APPR. |
| Apr 25, 2019 | In Senate. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. |
| Apr 25, 2019 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Senate. |
| Apr 23, 2019 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| Apr 22, 2019 | Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Apr 12, 2019 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to Com. on APPR. Read second time and amended. |
| Apr 11, 2019 | Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Apr 10, 2019 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to Com. on APPR. Read second time and amended. |
| Apr 3, 2019 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| Apr 2, 2019 | Read second time and amended. Ordered returned to second reading. |
| Apr 1, 2019 | From committee: Amend, and do pass as amended. (Ayes 8. Noes 3.) (March 26). |
| Mar 11, 2019 | Referred to Com. on P. & C.P. |
| Feb 22, 2019 | From printer. May be heard in committee March 24. |
| Feb 21, 2019 | Read first time. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Aug 30, 2020 | AB 1281 Chau Concurrence in Senate Amendments | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| Aug 28, 2020 | Consent Calendar AB1281 | Senate Floor |
Passed |
|
| Aug 13, 2020 | Do pass, but first be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] with the recommendation: To Consent Calendar | Senate Standing Committee on Judiciary |
Passed |
|
| Aug 30, 2019 | Do pass | Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Aug 12, 2019 | Placed on suspense file | Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Jul 2, 2019 | Do pass as amended, but first amend, and re-refer to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Senate Standing Committee on Judiciary |
Passed |
|
| Apr 25, 2019 | AB 1281 Chau Assembly Third Reading | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| Mar 26, 2019 | Do pass as amended. | Assembly Standing Committee on Privacy and Consumer Protection |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
CONCURRENCE IN SENATE AMENDMENTS
CSA1 Bill Id:AB 1281
Author:(Chau)
As Amended Ver:June 25, 2020
Majority vote
SUMMARY:
Extends, contingent on the voters not approving a specified ballot proposition at the November 3, 2020, statewide general election, the sunset dates by one year on two exemptions in the California Consumer Privacy Act (CCPA) for certain personal information (PI) collected by employers and collected in connection with business transactions and communications.
The Senate Amendments:
Removed the prior contents of this bill regulating facial recognition technology and inserted the sunset extensions described above.
COMMENTS:
The CCPA, until January 1, 2021, exempts from its provisions certain information collected by a business about a natural person in the course of the natural person acting as a job applicant, employee, owner, director, officer, medical staff member, or contractor of a business, as specified. It also, until January 1, 2021, exempts from specified provisions PI reflecting a written or verbal communication or a transaction between the business and a natural person who is acting as an employee, owner, director, officer, or contractor of a company, partnership, sole proprietorship, nonprofit, or government agency, and whose communications or transaction with the business occur solely within the context of the business conducting due diligence regarding, or providing or receiving a product or service to or from that company, partnership, sole proprietorship, nonprofit, or government agency. These exemptions were enacted with unanimous support by the Legislature last year by way of AB 25 (Chau), Chapter 763, Statutes of 2019) and AB 1355 (Chau), Chapter 757, Statutes of 2019).
On the ballot this November is Proposition 24 which, if enacted, would amend the CCPA in various ways. Relevant to the bill at hand, Proposition 24 would extend the sunsets that are the subject of this bill by two years, giving industry, labor, and other relevant stakeholders additional time to contemplate whether the CCPA should apply to specified business transactions and how to most appropriately protect employee privacy. Contingent on that Proposition not passing in November, this bill would extend those exemptions by one year, thereby ensuring that stakeholders are given the time necessary to discuss these important policies regardless of the outcome of Proposition 24.
According to the Author:
Both sunset dates were intended to provide a one-year delay to give stakeholders time to negotiate an appropriate solution with respect to employee privacy rights and business-to-business communications. Since then, the uncertainty surrounding the COVID-19 pandemic has resulted in the Legislature shifting its focus to how to best serve the immediate needs of the State, while at a time navigating an increasingly complicated legislative process.
As a result of the complications experienced because of the pandemic, more time is needed to work on developing a comprehensive framework in law that deals with business-to-business communications and transactions and the collection of certain personal information by employers.
Arguments in Support:
A coalition of business groups in support of this bill write:
The agreement called for stakeholders to come together and develop a solution in 2020, but the COVID-19 crisis denied stakeholders the opportunity to engage on this issue. And though the California Privacy Rights Act of 2020 (CPRA) would itself extend the sunset date at issue if it passes in the November election; no allowance has been made to account for the possibility that CPRA does not pass in November. Accordingly, AB 1281 extends this sunset for the CCPA exemptions until January 1, 2022 but will not take effect if CPRA passes in the November election.
Also writing in support, SEIU California writes:
Last year we worked with Assemblymember Chau and other stakeholders to reach agreement on the sunset provisions in AB 25. The intent of all parties involved was to work on a policy that accounts for the multifaceted privacy issues in the workplace this year. However, those conversations have been put on hold due to the current pandemic.
We believe AB 1281 keeps with the spirit of last year’s agreement on AB 25. For that reason, we write to support and ask that you vote Aye when it is before your committee.
Arguments in Opposition:
None on file.
FISCAL COMMENTS:
According to the Senate Appropriations Committee, pursuant to Senate Rule 28.8, any additional state costs are not significant, and do not and will not require the appropriation of additional state funds, and the bill will cause no significant reduction in revenues.
VOTES:
ASM PRIVACY AND CONSUMER PROTECTION: 8-3-0
YES: Chau, Bauer-Kahan, Berman, Weber, Mullin, Irwin, Smith, Wicks
NO: Gallagher, Fong, Obernolte
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 61-13-6
YES: Aguiar-Curry, Bauer-Kahan, Berman, Bloom, Boerner Horvath, Bonta, Burke, Calderon, Carrillo, Cervantes, Chau, Chiu, Chu, Cooley, Cooper, Cunningham, Daly, Diep, Frazier, Friedman, Gabriel, Cristina Garcia, Gipson, Gloria, Gonzalez, Grayson, Holden, Irwin, Jones‑Sawyer, Kalra, Kamlager-Dove, Levine, Limón, Low, Maienschein, Mayes, McCarty, Medina, Mullin, Muratsuchi, Nazarian, O'Donnell, Petrie-Norris, Quirk, Quirk-Silva, Ramos, Reyes, Luz Rivas, Robert Rivas, Rodriguez, Blanca Rubio, Salas, Santiago, Smith, Mark Stone, Ting, Waldron, Weber, Wicks, Wood, Rendon
NO: Bigelow, Brough, Choi, Dahle, Flora, Fong, Gallagher, Kiley, Lackey, Mathis, Obernolte, Patterson, Voepel
ABS, ABST OR NV: Arambula, Chen, Eggman, Eduardo Garcia, Gray, Melendez
SENATE FLOOR: 39-0-1
YES: Allen, Archuleta, Atkins, Bates, Beall, Borgeas, Bradford, Caballero, Chang, Dahle, Dodd, Durazo, Galgiani, Glazer, Lena Gonzalez, Grove, Hertzberg, Hill, Hueso, Hurtado, Jackson, Leyva, McGuire, Melendez, Mitchell, Monning, Moorlach, Morrell, Nielsen, Pan, Portantino, Roth, Rubio, Skinner, Stern, Umberg, Wieckowski, Wiener, Wilk
ABS, ABST OR NV: Jones
UPDATED:
VERSION: June 25, 2020
CONSULTANT: Nichole Rocha / P. & C.P. / (916) 319-2200 FN: 0003587
SENATE RULES COMMITTEE Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | AB 1281 |
CONSENT
Bill No: AB 1281
Author: Chau (D)
Amended: 6/25/20 in Senate
Vote: 21
PRIOR VOTES NOT RELEVANT
SENATE JUDICIARY COMMITTEE: 9-0, 8/13/20 (Pursuant to Senate Rule 29.10)
AYES: Jackson, Borgeas, Durazo, Lena Gonzalez, Melendez, Monning, Stern, Umberg, Wieckowski
SENATE APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE: Senate Rule 28.8
SUBJECT: Privacy: California Consumer Privacy Act of 2018
SOURCE: Author
DIGEST:
This bill extends the sunset dates on exemptions in the California Consumer Privacy Act (CCPA) for certain personal information collected by employers and collected in connection with business transactions and communications.
ANALYSIS:
Existing law:
- Establishes the CCPA, which grants consumers certain rights with regard to their personal information, including enhanced notice, access, and disclosure; the right to deletion; the right to restrict the sale of information; and protection from discrimination for exercising these rights. It places attendant obligations on businesses to respect those rights. (Civ. Code § 1798.100 et seq.)
- Provides consumers the right to request that a business that collects a consumer’s personal information disclose to that consumer the categories and specific pieces of personal information the business has collected. A business must provide the information upon receipt of a verifiable consumer request. (Civ. Code § 1798.100(a), (c).)
- Requires a business that collects a consumer’s personal information to, at or before the point of collection, inform consumers as to the categories of personal information to be collected and the purposes for which the categories of personal information shall be used. A business shall not collect additional categories of personal information or use personal information collected for additional purposes without providing the consumer with notice, as specified. (Civ. Code § 1798.100(b).)
- Provides consumers the right to request that a business delete any personal information about the consumer which the business has collected from the consumer. (Civ. Code § 1798.105(a).)
- Provides consumers the right to request that a business that collects personal information about the consumer, or that sells that information, to disclose to the consumer certain specified details. (Civ. Code § 1798.110(a), 1798.115(a).)
- Provides a consumer the right, at any time, to direct a business that sells personal information about the consumer to third parties not to sell the consumer’s personal information. (Civ. Code § 1798.120.)
- Provides that the CCPA, except as provided, does not apply to the following:
- Personal information that is collected by a business about a natural person in the course of the natural person acting as a job applicant to, an employee of, owner of, director of, officer of, medical staff member of, or contractor of that business to the extent that the natural person’s personal information is collected and used by the business solely within the context of the natural person’s role or former role as a job applicant to, an employee of, owner of, director of, officer of, medical staff member of, or a contractor of that business;
- Personal information that is collected by a business that is emergency contact information of the natural person acting as a job applicant to, an employee of, owner of, director of, officer of, medical staff member of, or contractor of that business to the extent that the personal information is collected and used solely within the context of having an emergency contact on file; or
- Personal information that is necessary for the business to retain to administer benefits for another natural person relating to the natural person acting as a job applicant to, an employee of, owner of, director of, officer of, medical staff member of, or contractor of that business to the extent that the personal information is collected and used solely within the context of administering those benefits.
- Provides that the above exemption becomes inoperative on January 1, 2021.
- Provides that the CCPA, except as provided, does not apply to personal information reflecting a written or verbal communication or a transaction between the business and the consumer, where the consumer is a natural person who is acting as an employee, owner, director, officer, or contractor of a company, partnership, sole proprietorship, non-profit, or government agency and whose communications or transaction with the business occur solely within the context of the business conducting due diligence regarding, or providing or receiving a product or service to or from such company, partnership, sole proprietorship, non-profit, or government agency. This exemption becomes inoperative on January 1, 2021.
This bill extends the sunset dates on the exemptions for personal information of employees and certain business communications and transactions to January 1, 2022, contingent on the failed passage of any ballot propositions that amend Section 1798.145 of the Civil Code.
Background
Executive Summary
The CCPA provides consumers a number of rights with regard to businesses’ use of their personal information, as defined. Businesses that collect or sell a consumer’s personal information, or disclose it for a business purpose, must provide notice and certain disclosures upon request by the consumer. This includes disclosing the categories of information the business has collected or sold, the categories of sources from which the information is collected, and the specific pieces of information collected about the consumer. The CCPA also allows consumers who are 16 years of age or older to opt out of the sale of their personal information with younger consumers needing to opt in before a business can sell their information. Consumers can also request that a business delete certain personal information that has been collected by the business from the consumer.
However, there are also numerous exemptions and exceptions within the CCPA. For instance, the CCPA provides that its obligations do not restrict a business’ ability to comply with other laws or to collect, use, or sell deidentified or aggregate information. This bill extends the sunset dates on two exemptions in the CCPA, one for personal information collected by businesses in their role as employers and one regarding personal information collected in connection with certain business transactions and communications. This bill is author-sponsored and is supported by various business associations. There is no known opposition.
Comments
Personal information of employees
The CCPA grants a set of rights to consumers with regard to their personal information, including enhanced notice and disclosure rights regarding information collection and use practices, access to the information collected, the right to delete certain information, the right to restrict the sale of information, and protection from discrimination for exercising these rights.
Since the passage of the CCPA, representatives of business, tech, and other industry groups have called for various changes, clarifications, and carve outs from the CCPA. One change strongly lobbied for by these groups was an exemption that exempted the personal information of employees from the protections of the CCPA. AB 25 (Chau, Chapter 763, Statutes of 2019) provided that exemption, which held that the CCPA’s protections and controls do not apply to personal information that is:
- collected by a business about a person in the course of the person acting as a job applicant to, an employee of, owner of, director of, officer of, medical staff member of, or contractor of that business to the extent that the person’s personal information is collected and used by the business solely within the context of the person’s role or former role as a job applicant to, an employee of, owner of, director of, officer of, medical staff member of, or a contractor of that business;
- collected by a business that is emergency contact information of the natural person acting as a job applicant to, an employee of, owner of, director of, officer of, medical staff member of, or contractor of that business to the extent that the personal information is collected and used solely within the context of having an emergency contact on file; and
- necessary for the business to retain to administer benefits for another natural person relating to the natural person acting as a job applicant to, an employee of, owner of, director of, officer of, medical staff member of, or contractor of that business to the extent that the personal information is collected and used solely within the context of administering those benefits. (Civ. Code § 1798.145(h).)
It essentially excluded from most of the protections of the CCPA any information an employer business collects from an employee consumer in the employment context. In addition, the bill also provided an exemption for so called “business to business” information. That exemption held that the CCPA, except as specified, did not apply to “personal information reflecting a written or verbal communication or a transaction between the business and the consumer, where the consumer is a natural person who is acting as an employee, owner, director, officer, or contractor of a company, partnership, sole proprietorship, non-profit, or government agency,” as specified. (Civ. Code § 1798.145(n).)
Arguments in support of the exemptions warned of employees exploiting the CCPA or simply asserted that employees were not intended to be covered at all by the CCPA. However, a coalition of labor, privacy, and consumer groups wrote in opposition to AB 25. As the Senate Judiciary Committee’s analysis of the bill indicated, they felt the exemptions went too far in eroding the rights of employees, especially with the increasing prevalence of workplace monitoring. They argued:
Workers’ interest in data privacy is closely related to consumers’ interest, and many of the same technology is used to monitor both. . . . This use of data by employers does not just threaten employee privacy, but can also be used to discriminate against workers on prohibited bases. For example, Amazon experimented with an artificial intelligence hiring tool, but the company was forced to scrap the project when it downgraded graduates from all-women’s colleges and penalized resumes that included the word “women’s,” as in “women’s chess club captain.”
Given the legitimate concerns raised, the author agreed to place a one-year sunset on the exemptions provided by AB 25. The intent was to allow further negotiations to determine how the personal information of employees would be protected under the law, rather than simply carved out. These exemptions are set to expire on January 1, 2021. This bill extends the sunset dates for one year to January 1, 2022. However, it will not apply if a ballot initiative, Proposition 24, passes in November 2020. That initiative extends the exemptions even further.
The author argues:
Both sunset dates were intended to provide a one-year delay to give stakeholders time to negotiate an appropriate solution with respect to employee privacy rights and business-to-business communications. Since then, the uncertainty surrounding the COVID-19 pandemic has resulted in the Legislature shifting its focus to how to best serve the immediate needs of the State, while at a time navigating an increasingly complicated legislative process.
As a result of the complications experienced because of the pandemic, more time is needed to work on developing a comprehensive framework in law that deals with business-to-business communications and transactions and the collection of certain personal information by employers.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: Yes Local: No
SUPPORT: (Verified 8/19/20)
Advanced Medical Technology Association
Agricultural Council of California
Alliance for Automotive Innovation
American Benefits Council
American Council of Life Insurers
American Property Casualty Insurance Association
American Staffing Association
Association of California Life and Health Insurance Companies
Association of National Advertisers
Biocom
BSA the Software Alliance
California Apartment Association
California Association of Collectors, Inc.
California Association of Health Facilities
California Association of Licensed Investigators
California Association of Realtors
California Bankers Association
California Beer and Beverage Distributors
California Building Industry Association
California Business Properties Association
California Cable & Telecommunications Association
California Chamber of Commerce
California Credit Union League
California Hospital Association
California Hotel & Lodging Association
California Land Title Association
California League of Food Producers
California Life Sciences Association
California Manufacturers & Technology Association
California New Car Dealers Association
California Professional Association of Specialty Contractors
California Restaurant Association
California Retailers Association
California State Council of SHRM
California Trucking Association
Cemetery and Mortuary Association of California
Civil Justice Association of California
CompTIA
Consumer Technology Association
CTIA
Email Sender and Provider Coalition
Entertainment Software Association
Equifax
Honda North America, Inc.
Insights Association
Interactive Advertising Bureau
Internet Association
Internet Coalition
Motion Picture Association
MPA - the Association of Magazine Media
National Association of Mutual Insurance Companies
National Federation of Independent Business
National Payroll Reporting Consortium
Network Advertising Initiative
Orange County Business Council
Personal Insurance Federation of California
Plumbing Manufacturers International
Securities Industry and Financial Markets Association
Sempra Energy Utilities/SDG&E/SoCal Gas
Silicon Valley Leadership Group
Society for Human Resource Management
State Privacy and Security Coalition, INC.
Technet
The Spark Institute, Inc.
The Toy Association
OPPOSITION: (Verified 8/19/20)
None received
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: A coalition of business groups in support of this bill write: “The agreement called for stakeholders to come together and develop a solution in 2020, but the COVID-19 crisis denied stakeholders the opportunity to engage on this issue. And though the California Privacy Rights Act of 2020 (CPRA) would itself extend the sunset date at issue if it passes in the November election; no allowance has been made to account for the possibility that CPRA does not pass in November. Accordingly, AB 1281 extends this sunset for the CCPA exemptions until January 1, 2022 but will not take effect if CPRA passes in the November election.”
Prepared by: Christian Kurpiewski / JUD. / (916) 651-4113
8/21/20 18:10:53
Senator Hannah-Beth Jackson, Chair
2019-2020 Regular Session
Bill No: AB 1281 (Author:Chau)
Version: June 25, 2020
Hearing Date: August 13, 2020
Fiscal: Yes
Urgency: No
Consultant: CK
SUBJECT
Privacy: California Consumer Privacy Act of 2018
DIGEST
The bill extends the sunset dates on exemptions in the California Consumer Privacy Act (CCPA) for certain personal information collected by employers and collected in connection with business transactions and communications.
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
The CCPA provides consumers a number of rights with regard to businesses’ use of their personal information, as defined. Businesses that collect or sell a consumer’s personal information, or disclose it for a business purpose, must provide notice and certain disclosures upon request by the consumer. This includes disclosing the categories of information the business has collected or sold, the categories of sources from which the information is collected, and the specific pieces of information collected about the consumer. The CCPA also allows consumers who are 16 years of age or older to opt out of the sale of their personal information with younger consumers needing to opt in before a business can sell their information. Consumers can also request that a business delete certain personal information that has been collected by the business from the consumer.
However, there are also numerous exemptions and exceptions within the CCPA. For instance, the CCPA provides that its obligations do not restrict a business’ ability to comply with other laws or to collect, use, or sell deidentified or aggregate information. This bill extends the sunset dates on two exemptions in the CCPA, one for personal information collected by businesses in their role as employers and one regarding personal information collected in connection with certain business transactions and communications. This bill is author-sponsored and is supported by various business associations. There is no known opposition.
PROPOSED CHANGES TO THE LAW
Existing law:
- Establishes the CCPA, which grants consumers certain rights with regard to their personal information, including enhanced notice, access, and disclosure; the right to deletion; the right to restrict the sale of information; and protection from discrimination for exercising these rights. It places attendant obligations on businesses to respect those rights. (Civ. Code § 1798.100 et seq.)
- Provides consumers the right to request that a business that collects a consumer’s personal information disclose to that consumer the categories and specific pieces of personal information the business has collected. A business must provide the information upon receipt of a verifiable consumer request. (Civ. Code § 1798.100(a), (c).)
- Requires a business that collects a consumer’s personal information to, at or before the point of collection, inform consumers as to the categories of personal information to be collected and the purposes for which the categories of personal information shall be used. A business shall not collect additional categories of personal information or use personal information collected for additional purposes without providing the consumer with notice, as specified. (Civ. Code § 1798.100(b).)
- Provides consumers the right to request that a business delete any personal information about the consumer which the business has collected from the consumer. (Civ. Code § 1798.105(a).)
- Provides consumers the right to request that a business that collects personal information about the consumer, or that sells that information, to disclose to the consumer certain specified details. (Civ. Code § 1798.110(a), 1798.115(a).)
- Provides a consumer the right, at any time, to direct a business that sells personal information about the consumer to third parties not to sell the consumer’s personal information. (Civ. Code § 1798.120.)
- Provides that the CCPA, except as provided, does not apply to the following:
- personal information that is collected by a business about a natural person in the course of the natural person acting as a job applicant to, an employee of, owner of, director of, officer of, medical staff member of, or contractor of that business to the extent that the natural person’s personal information is collected and used by the business solely within the context of the natural person’s role or former role as a job applicant to, an employee of, owner of, director of, officer of, medical staff member of, or a contractor of that business;
- personal information that is collected by a business that is emergency contact information of the natural person acting as a job applicant to, an employee of, owner of, director of, officer of, medical staff member of, or contractor of that business to the extent that the personal information is collected and used solely within the context of having an emergency contact on file; or
- personal information that is necessary for the business to retain to administer benefits for another natural person relating to the natural person acting as a job applicant to, an employee of, owner of, director of, officer of, medical staff member of, or contractor of that business to the extent that the personal information is collected and used solely within the context of administering those benefits.
- Provides that the above exemption becomes inoperative on January 1, 2021.
- Provides that the CCPA, except as provided, does not apply to personal information reflecting a written or verbal communication or a transaction between the business and the consumer, where the consumer is a natural person who is acting as an employee, owner, director, officer, or contractor of a company, partnership, sole proprietorship, non-profit, or government agency and whose communications or transaction with the business occur solely within the context of the business conducting due diligence regarding, or providing or receiving a product or service to or from such company, partnership, sole proprietorship, non-profit, or government agency. This exemption becomes inoperative on January 1, 2021.
This bill extends the sunset dates on the exemptions for personal information of employees and certain business communications and transactions to January 1, 2022, contingent on the failed passage of any ballot propositions that amend Section 1798.145 of the Civil Code.
COMMENTS
- Personal information of employees
The CCPA grants a set of rights to consumers with regard to their personal information, including enhanced notice and disclosure rights regarding information collection and use practices, access to the information collected, the right to delete certain information, the right to restrict the sale of information, and protection from discrimination for exercising these rights.
Since the passage of the CCPA, representatives of business, tech, and other industry groups have called for various changes, clarifications, and carve outs from the CCPA. One change strongly lobbied for by these groups was an exemption that exempted the personal information of employees from the protections of the CCPA. AB 25 (Chau, Ch. 763, Stats. 2019) provided that exemption, which held that the CCPA’s protections and controls do not apply to personal information that is:
- collected by a business about a person in the course of the person acting as a job applicant to, an employee of, owner of, director of, officer of, medical staff member of, or contractor of that business to the extent that the person’s personal information is collected and used by the business solely within the context of the person’s role or former role as a job applicant to, an employee of, owner of, director of, officer of, medical staff member of, or a contractor of that business;
- collected by a business that is emergency contact information of the natural person acting as a job applicant to, an employee of, owner of, director of, officer of, medical staff member of, or contractor of that business to the extent that the personal information is collected and used solely within the context of having an emergency contact on file; and
- necessary for the business to retain to administer benefits for another natural person relating to the natural person acting as a job applicant to, an employee of, owner of, director of, officer of, medical staff member of, or contractor of that business to the extent that the personal information is collected and used solely within the context of administering those benefits. (Civ. Code § 1798.145(h).)
It essentially excluded from most of the protections of the CCPA any information an employer business collects from an employee consumer in the employment context. In addition, the bill also provided an exemption for so called “business to business” information. That exemption held that the CCPA, except as specified, did not apply to “personal information reflecting a written or verbal communication or a transaction between the business and the consumer, where the consumer is a natural person who is acting as an employee, owner, director, officer, or contractor of a company, partnership, sole proprietorship, non-profit, or government agency,” as specified. (Civ. Code § 1798.145(n).)
Arguments in support of the exemptions warned of employees exploiting the CCPA or simply asserted that employees were not intended to be covered at all by the CCPA. However, a coalition of labor, privacy, and consumer groups wrote in opposition to AB 25. As this Committee’s analysis of the bill indicated, they felt the exemptions went too far in eroding the rights of employees, especially with the increasing prevalence of workplace monitoring. They argued:
Workers’ interest in data privacy is closely related to consumers’ interest, and many of the same technology is used to monitor both. . . . This use of data by employers does not just threaten employee privacy, but can also be used to discriminate against workers on prohibited bases.[1] For example, Amazon experimented with an artificial intelligence hiring tool, but the company was forced to scrap the project when it downgraded graduates from all-women’s colleges and penalized resumes that included the word “women’s,” as in “women’s chess club captain.”[2]
Given the legitimate concerns raised, the author agreed to place a one-year sunset on the exemptions provided by AB 25. The intent was to allow further negotiations to determine how the personal information of employees would be protected under the law, rather than simply carved out. These exemptions are set to expire on January 1, 2021.
This bill extends the sunset dates for one year to January 1, 2022.
- Stakeholder positions
The author argues:
Both sunset dates were intended to provide a one-year delay to give stakeholders time to negotiate an appropriate solution with respect to employee privacy rights and business-to-business communications. Since then, the uncertainty surrounding the COVID-19 pandemic has resulted in the Legislature shifting its focus to how to best serve the immediate needs of the State, while at a time navigating an increasingly complicated legislative process. Additionally, an initiative recently qualified for the November 2020 ballot that provides an additional two-year extension, until January 1, 2023, to the exemptions for employee and business-to-business data currently in the CCPA.
As a result of the complications experienced because of the pandemic, more time is needed to work on developing a comprehensive framework in law that deals with business-to-business communications and transactions and the collection of certain personal information by employers.
A coalition of business groups in support of the measure write:
The agreement called for stakeholders to come together and develop a solution in 2020, but the COVID-19 crisis denied stakeholders the opportunity to engage on this issue. And though the California Privacy Rights Act of 2020 (CPRA) would itself extend the sunset date at issue if it passes in the November election; no allowance has been made to account for the possibility that CPRA does not pass in November. Accordingly, AB 1281 extends this sunset for the CCPA exemptions until January 1, 2022 but will not take effect if CPRA passes in the November election.
The extension is necessary because CCPA is broad enough to include employees and job applicants within its definition of “consumers.” But without a well-designed framework to deal specifically with employee data, the CCPA is ill-equipped to handle employee data and how that relates to workplace data.
As referenced, the bill’s sunset extensions will not apply should a ballot initiative, Proposition 24, pass in November 2020. That initiative would extend the exemptions even further.
SUPPORT
Advanced Medical Technology Association
Agricultural Council of California
Alliance for Automotive Innovation
American Benefits Council
American Council of Life Insurers
American Property Casualty Insurance Association
American Staffing Association
Association of California Life and Health Insurance Companies
Association of National Advertisers
Biocom
Bsa the Software Alliance
California Apartment Association
California Association of Collectors, Inc.
California Association of Health Facilities
California Association of Licensed Investigators
California Association of Realtors
California Bankers Association
California Beer and Beverage Distributors
California Building Industry Association
California Business Properties Association
California Cable & Telecommunications Association
California Chamber of Commerce
California Credit Union League
California Hospital Association
California Hotel & Lodging Association
California Land Title Association
California League of Food Producers
California Life Sciences Association
California Manufacturers & Technology Association
California New Car Dealers Association
California Professional Association of Specialty Contractors
California Restaurant Association
California Retailers Association
California State Council of SHRM
California Trucking Association
Cemetery and Mortuary Association of California
Civil Justice Association of California
CompTIA
Consumer Technology Association
CTIA
Email Sender and Provider Coalition
Entertainment Software Association
Equifax
Honda North America, Inc.
Insights Association
Interactive Advertising Bureau
Internet Association
Internet Coalition
Motion Picture Association
Mpa - the Association of Magazine Media
National Association of Mutual Insurance Companies
National Federation of Independent Business
National Payroll Reporting Consortium
Network Advertising Initiative
Orange County Business Council
Personal Insurance Federation of California
Plumbing Manufacturers International
Securities Industry and Financial Markets Association
Sempra Energy Utilities/SDG&E/SoCal Gas
Silicon Valley Leadership Group
Society for Human Resource Management
State Privacy and Security Coalition, INC.
Technet
The Spark Institute, Inc.
The Toy Association
OPPOSITION
None known
RELATED LEGISLATION
Pending Legislation: AB 713 (Mullin, 2020) creates additional exemptions in the CCPA, including for covered entities and business associates of covered entities. This bill is currently in the Senate Appropriations Committee.
Prior Legislation: AB 25 (Chau, Ch. 763, Stats. 2019) See Comment 1.
PRIOR VOTES:
This bill was gutted and amended into its current form on June 25, 2020. As such, all prior votes on the bill are irrelevant.
**************
Kim, Pauline, Data-Driven Discrimination at Work (April 19, 2017). William & Mary Law Review, Vol. 48, pp. 857-936 (2017); Washington University in St. Louis Legal Studies Research Paper No. 16-12-01, https://scholarship.law.wm.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=3680&context=wmlr. ↑
Jeffrey Dastin, Amazon scraps Secret AI Recruiting Tool that Showed Bias against Women (October 9, 2018) Reuters, https://www.reuters.com/article/us-amazon-com-jobs-automation-insight/amazon-scraps-secret-ai-recruiting-tool-that-showed-bias-against-women-idUSKCN1MK08G. ↑
Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | AB 1281 |
THIRD READING
Bill No: AB 1281
Amended: 7/5/19 in Senate
SENATE JUDICIARY COMMITTEE: 7-2, 7/2/19
AYES: Jackson, Durazo, Lena Gonzalez, Monning, Stern, Umberg, Wieckowski
NOES: Borgeas, Jones
SENATE APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE: 5-2, 8/30/19
AYES: Portantino, Bradford, Durazo, Hill, Wieckowski
NOES: Bates, Jones
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 61-13, 4/25/19 - See last page for vote
SUBJECT: Privacy: facial recognition technology: disclosure
DIGEST:
This bill requires businesses to disclose when they are using facial recognition technology.
Existing law:
- Provides, through the California Constitution, that all people are by nature free and independent and have inalienable rights. Among these are enjoying and defending life and liberty, acquiring, possessing, and protecting property, and pursuing and obtaining safety, happiness, and privacy. (Cal. Const, Art. I, § 1.)
- Establishes the Information Practices Act of 1977, which declares that the right to privacy is a personal and fundamental right protected by Section 1 of Article I of the Constitution of California and by the United States Constitution and that all individuals have a right of privacy in information pertaining to them. (Civ. Code § 1798 et seq.)
- Establishes the California Customer Records Act, which provides requirements for the maintenance and disposal of customer records and the personal information contained therein. (Civ. Code § 1798.80 et seq.) It further states it is the intent of the Legislature to ensure that personal information about California residents is protected and to encourage businesses that own, license, or maintain personal information about Californians to provide reasonable security for that information. (Civ. Code § 1798.81.5(a).)
- Requires a business that owns, licenses, or maintains personal information about a California resident to implement and maintain reasonable security procedures and practices appropriate to the nature of the information, to protect the personal information from unauthorized access, destruction, use, modification, or disclosure, and requires such businesses to contractually require third parties to which it discloses such personal information to similarly protect that information. (Civ. Code § 1798.81.5(b), (c).)
- Establishes the California Consumer Privacy Act of 2018 (CCPA), which grants consumers certain rights with regard to their personal information, including enhanced notice, access, and disclosure; the right to deletion; the right to restrict the sale of information; and protection from discrimination for exercising these rights. It places attendant obligations on businesses to respect those rights. (Civ. Code § 1798.100 et seq.)
- Requires that a business that collects a consumer’s personal information shall, at or before the point of collection, inform consumers as to the categories of personal information to be collected and the purposes for which the categories of personal information shall be used. (Civ. Code § 1798.100.)
- Provides consumers the right to request that a business that collects personal information about the consumer disclose to the consumer the following:
- the categories of personal information it has collected about that consumer;
- the categories of sources from which the personal information is collected;
- the business or commercial purpose for collecting or selling personal information;
- the categories of third parties with whom the business shares personal information; and
- the specific pieces of personal information it has collected about that consumer. (Civ. Code § 1798.110(a).)
- Provides consumers the right to request that a business that sells the consumer’s personal information, or that discloses it for a business purpose, disclose to the consumer specified information. (Civ. Code § 1798.115(a).)
This bill:
- Requires a business in California that uses facial recognition technology to disclose the usage of facial recognition technology in a clear and conspicuous, physical sign at the entrance of every location that uses the technology.
- Requires the sign to be displayed in a manner that ensures that an individual can read the sign before the business captures a digital image or video of the individual that can be analyzed using facial recognition technology.
- Requires the sign to include information about where an individual can find more information about the purposes for which the business uses facial recognition technology.
- Subjects businesses in violation to civil penalties of up to $75 per violation up to $7,500 per year. This penalty is to be assessed and recovered in a civil action brought in the name of the people of the State of California by the Attorney General, by a district attorney, county counsel, or city attorney, or by a city prosecutor in a city having a full-time city prosecutor, in a court of competent jurisdiction. If the action is brought by the Attorney General, one-half of the penalty collected shall be paid to the treasurer of the county in which the judgment was entered, and one-half to the General Fund. If the action is brought by a district attorney or county counsel, the penalty collected shall be paid to the treasurer of the county in which the judgment was entered. If the action is brought by a city attorney or city prosecutor, one-half of the penalty collected shall be paid to the treasurer of the city in which the judgment was entered, and one-half to the treasurer of the county in which the judgment was entered.
- Subjects businesses in violation to a penalty of up to $5,000 for knowing and willful violations.
- Defines “clear and conspicuous” to mean in larger type than the surrounding text, or in contrasting type, font, or color to the surrounding text of the same size, or set off from the surrounding text of the same size by symbols and other marks that call attention to the language. “Facial recognition technology” means a software application that analyzes facial features from a digital image or video for the purpose of automatically identifying a specific individual.
- Becomes operative on July 1, 2020.
Background
Executive Summary
Facial recognition technology allows for the identification of an individual based on a capture of features of the individual’s face. It is being put into use at an ever-increasing pace by both governmental entities and private businesses.[1] In addition to the troubling privacy concerns posed by the technology, there has been research showing that the technology frequently results in misidentification, especially with persons with darker skin tones.[2]
In order to address the growing privacy concerns[3] in connection with the use of such technology, this bill requires signage at business locations deploying the technology and subjects those in violation to modest civil penalties.
The bill is sponsored by the author and supported by Oakland Privacy. The ACLU of California, the Electronic Frontier Foundation, and Privacy Rights Clearinghouse oppose the bill. This bill comes among similar efforts at both the local level here in California and in other states.
NOTE: For a more thorough discussion of this bill, please see the Senate Judiciary Committee analysis.
Comments
According to the author:
Facial recognition technology (FRT) is becoming ever more present throughout businesses in California. It can be used to prevent retail crime, find missing persons, and even diagnose diseases. However, concerns about privacy and use of the information are increasing. Individuals are not currently informed of FRT being used on them, nor do they know how long the information is held or how it is used. AB 1281 would simply make consumers aware of which California businesses are using FRT by requiring each business to disclose the use of the technology with a physical sign at its entrance.
Responding to the widespread use of facial recognition technology
Specifically, facial recognition technology is one form of surveillance technology that has gained increased prominence, as it is being used in our electronic devices and smart home products. However, the widespread collection of data through this technology is troubling. A recent study found that there is more than a 50 percent chance that any adult is already included in a law enforcement facial recognition database.[4] This bill takes a modest approach to the issue by requiring businesses that use facial recognition technology to place a clear and conspicuous sign at the entrance of each location using the technology disclosing the fact that such technology is being used.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: Yes Local: No
According to the Senate Appropriations Committee:
- Department of Justice: Ongoing costs of $357,000 annually for 1.0 Deputy Attorney General and 1.0 Legal Secretary to enforce the requirements in AB 1281. (Special fund*, General Fund)
- Courts: Unknown, potentially-significant workload cost pressures to the courts to adjudicate whether businesses have violated the disclosure requirement when using facial recognition technology. While the superior courts are not funded on a workload basis, an increase in workload could result in delayed court services and would put pressure on the General Fund to fund additional staff and resources. For example, the Budget Act of 2019 appropriated $41.8 million from the General Fund to backfill continued reduction in fine and penalty revenue for trial court operations. (General Fund**)
* Consumer Privacy Fund—not yet established
** Trial Court Trust Fund
Oakland Privacy
OPPOSITION: (Verified 8/30/19)
American Civil Liberties Union of California
Electronic Frontier Foundation
Privacy Rights Clearinghouse
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: Writing in support, Oakland Privacy states:
“Californians who patronize brick and mortar businesses, whether to purchase items, window shop or meet up with friends generally assume that their identity remains private. Unless or until they engage in a non-cash transaction with the business or engage in some act of disruption, disturbance or criminality, in which case security camera footage may be made available to local law enforcement.
“Facial recognition technology violates this general compact or understanding by potentially allowing instant or automated identification of any individual whose image is captured on security camera still or video footage, absent suspected criminality and absent consent. Such a list of bookstore browsers has a plethora of possible uses, some more innocuous than others, but all consisting of consent-free and suspicion-free autoidentification based on biometric data, which once collected and analyzed, remains in the possession of the collector despite as casual a relationship as looking at a paperback on display for five minutes.
“As with other signage and transparency regulations, like Proposition 65, Assembly Bill 1281 provides a buyer beware option. It allows consumers to know that a business may connect their image to their identity and allows them to consider alternatives and whether, in fact, they consent.”
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION: The American Civil Liberties Union of California, the Electronic Frontier Foundation, and Privacy Rights Clearinghouse write in joint opposition to this bill urging stronger action:
“Businesses have already begun to deploy facial recognition algorithms. An Oregon gas station for example recently installed a system that limits access to the facility based on its identification of a consumer’s face with a sign that reads: ‘Look at camera for entry. Facial recognition in use.’ Anyone flagged by the company’s algorithm is unable to enter the store, despite concerns about inaccuracy and the potential that the information may be used to create an ongoing database or shared with other retailers.
“Meanwhile, facial-recognition technology is being marketed to retailers as a way to flag people who are suspected of having previously shoplifted or sought refunds for stolen merchandise, raising questions about the accuracy of such systems and how the data is used. Could merchants share data? Would one incident of teenage shoplifting lead to someone being barred from a store – or every store – for life? What process is available for an individual to be notified and allowed to challenge false identifications, what proof would be necessary, and who decides?
“The technology is also in use within the service industry where companies such as Servall Biometrics are scanning the ID's and faces of bargoers, including over 50,000 patrons in Sacramento in a five- month period. Bars, nightclubs and pubs have used the company’s PatronScan system to create a shared blacklist of 40,000+ customers who are on average banned for 19 years based on whatever allegation the company’s staff inputs. This information is also provided to law enforcement agencies upon request without a warrant or probable cause. A competing company, IDScan.net allows bars to install a camera system outside their doors that will capture, catalog, and identify customers by their biometric information, matching it to their scanned IDs.
“Your bill permits businesses in California to use facial recognition technology so long as they merely disclose the usage of facial recognition technology in a physical sign at the entrance of every location that uses facial recognition technology. Moreover, violation of even this negligible requirement could not be remedied by the person whose biometric information was taken; compliance could be enforced only if a public prosecutor had the willingness and wherewithal to seek a civil penalty. Even then, no recovery would go to the person whose rights were violated, contrary to the custom and tradition of every meaningful privacy and consumer protection law.
“Posting a sign is little or no protection against the use of this powerful and intrusive technology. Such signs would likely become as ubiquitous and ignored as Prop. 65 notices are now, particularly when consumers have no effective way to guard against the dangers. A physical sign – no matter how prominent – is no substitute for consent.”
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 61-13, 4/25/19
AYES: Aguiar-Curry, Bauer-Kahan, Berman, Bloom, Boerner Horvath, Bonta, Burke, Calderon, Carrillo, Cervantes, Chau, Chiu, Chu, Cooley, Cooper, Cunningham, Daly, Diep, Frazier, Friedman, Gabriel, Cristina Garcia, Gipson, Gloria, Gonzalez, Grayson, Holden, Irwin, Jones-Sawyer, Kalra, Kamlager-Dove, Levine, Limón, Low, Maienschein, Mayes, McCarty, Medina, Mullin, Muratsuchi, Nazarian, O'Donnell, Petrie-Norris, Quirk, Quirk-Silva, Ramos, Reyes, Luz Rivas, Robert Rivas, Rodriguez, Blanca Rubio, Salas, Santiago, Smith, Mark Stone, Ting, Waldron, Weber, Wicks, Wood, Rendon
NOES: Bigelow, Brough, Choi, Dahle, Flora, Fong, Gallagher, Kiley, Lackey, Mathis, Obernolte, Patterson, Voepel
NO VOTE RECORDED: Arambula, Chen, Eggman, Eduardo Garcia, Gray, Melendez
Prepared by: Christian Kurpiewski / JUD. / (916) 651-4113
9/1/19 14:18:49
**** END ****
Nick Tabor, Smile! The Secretive Business of Facial-Recognition Software in Retail Stores (Oct. 20, 2018) New York Magazine, http://nymag.com/intelligencer/2018/10/retailers-are-using-facial-recognition-technology-too.html. All internet citations are current as of August 30, 2019. ↑
Natasha Singer, Amazon’s Facial Recognition Wrongly Identifies 28 Lawmakers, A.C.L.U. Says (Jul. 26, 2018) New York Times, https://www.nytimes.com/2018/07/26/technology/amazon-aclu-facial-recognition-congress.html; Amanda Jackson, Facial-recognition technology flagged 26 California lawmakers as criminals. This bill to ban the tech is headed to the Senate (August 15, 2019) CNN, https://www.cnn.com/2019/08/13/tech/facial-recognition-body-cameras-bill-california-trnd/index.html. ↑
Peter O’Dowd, As Facial Recognition Technology Booms, So Do Privacy Concerns (Dec. 21, 2018) WBUR, https://www.wbur.org/hereandnow/2018/12/21/facial-recognition-privacy-concerns. ↑
Shannon Van Sant, San Francisco Approves Ban On Government's Use Of Facial Recognition Technology (May 14, 2019) NPR, https://www.npr.org/2019/05/14/723193785/san-francisco-considers-ban-on-governments-use-of-facial-recognition-technology. ↑
SENATE COMMITTEE ON
Senator Anthony Portantino, Chair
2019 - 2020 Regular Session
AB 1281 (Chau) - Privacy: facial recognition technology: disclosure
Version: | Policy Vote: |
Urgency: | Mandate: |
Hearing Date: | Consultant: |
Bill Summary:
AB 1281 would require businesses to disclose, as specified, when they are using facial recognition technology and would allow public prosecutors to seek penalties for violations of this requirement.
Fiscal Impact:
- Department of Justice (DOJ): Ongoing costs of $357,000 annually for 1.0 Deputy Attorney General and 1.0 Legal Secretary to enforce the requirements in AB 1281. (Special fund*, General Fund)
- Courts: Unknown, potentially-significant workload cost pressures to the courts to adjudicate whether businesses have violated the disclosure requirement when using facial recognition technology. While the superior courts are not funded on a workload basis, an increase in workload could result in delayed court services and would put pressure on the General Fund to fund additional staff and resources. For example, the Budget Act of 2019 appropriated $41.8 million from the General Fund to backfill continued reduction in fine and penalty revenue for trial court operations. (General Fund**)
*Consumer Privacy Fund—not yet established
**Trial Court Trust Fund
Background:
The California Constitution provides that all people are by nature free and independent and have inalienable rights, among them are enjoying and defending life and liberty, acquiring, possessing, and protecting property, and pursuing and obtaining safety, happiness, and privacy. Starting on January 1, 2020, the California Consumer Privacy Act of 2018 (CCPA) grants a consumer various rights with regard to personal information relating to that consumer that is held by a business. The act will require a business that collects personal information about a consumer to disclose the consumer’s right to delete personal information in a form that is reasonably accessible to consumers and in accordance with a specified process.
Proposed Law:
This bill would:
- Require a business in California that uses facial recognition technology, starting on July 1, 2020, to disclose that usage in a physical sign that is clear and conspicuous at the entrance of every location that uses facial recognition technology.
- Define “facial recognition technology” as a software application that analyzes facial features from a digital image or video for the purpose of automatically identifying a specific individual.
- Require the sign be displayed in a specified manner and to include information about where an individual can find more information about the purposes for which the business uses facial recognition technology.
- Subject a business that violates the disclosure requirement to civil penalties.
- Allow the Attorney General, a district attorney, a county counsel, a city attorney, or a city prosecutor to bring a civil action to collect these penalties. If the action is brought by the Attorney General, half of the penalties collected would be paid to the county in which the judgment was entered and half to the General Fund.
Related Legislation:
AB 1130 (Levine, 2019) would expand the definition of personal information in various statutes, including the data breach notification statutes, to include certain additional information that is particularly sensitive but not currently explicitly included therein, including biometric data and certain identification numbers. AB 1130 is pending in this Committee.
AB 1215 (Ting, 2019) would prohibit law enforcement agencies or officials from installing, activating, or using a biometric surveillance system in connection with an agency’s body-worn camera or any other camera worn or carried. AB 1215 is pending on the Senate floor.
SB 1186 (Hill, 2018) would have required specified law enforcement agencies to have a policy, approved by their governing bodies, in place before the use of surveillance technology, including facial recognition technology. SB 1186 was held on the Suspense File of the Assembly Committee on Appropriations.
SB 21 (Hill, 2017) would have required law enforcement agencies to adopt a surveillance use policy, approved by its governing body, and cease the use of each surveillance technology if the plan is not adopted, as specified. SB 21 was held on the Suspense File of the Assembly Committee on Appropriations.
Staff Comments:
Starting January 1, 2020, the Consumer Privacy Fund will be established pursuant to the CCPA. As the fund is yet to be established and it has no money currently, there would need to be the appropriation of General Fund moneys to pay for the initial costs to implement the provisions of this measure, or DOJ would be required to absorb expenses associated with this measure.
The actual fiscal impact of AB 1281 to the courts will depend on many unknown factors, including the numbers of violations alleged to have occurred, if the Attorney General or local prosecutors settle with businesses before the filing of an action, and the factors unique to each case. While it is unknown how many actions for alleged violations would be filed ultimately, it generally costs about $7,644 to operate a courtroom for one day. Additionally, it costs the court almost $2,900, on average, in personnel and resources to adjudicate a limited civil case. These costs takes into consideration the time from when a petition or complaint is received by the court, processing and calendaring by the clerks, any hearings presided over by a judicial officer, and the finalizing of the outcome by the clerk. Consequently, if alleged violations of AB 1281 led to the filing of eighteen or more cases, the cost pressures to the court would surpass the Suspense File threshold.
-- END --
Senator Hannah-Beth Jackson, Chair
2019-2020 Regular Session
Bill No: AB 1281 (Author:Chau)
Version: June 21, 2019
Hearing Date: July 2, 2019
Fiscal: Yes
Urgency: No
Consultant: CK
SUBJECT
Privacy: facial recognition technology: disclosure
DIGEST
This bill requires businesses to disclose when they are using facial recognition technology.
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
Facial recognition technology allows for the identification of an individual based on a capture of features of the individual’s face. It is being put into use at an ever-increasing pace by both governmental entities and private businesses.
In order to address the growing privacy concerns in connection with the use of such technology, this bill requires signage at business locations deploying the technology and subjects those in violation to modest civil penalties.
The bill is sponsored by the author and supported by Oakland Privacy. The American Civil Liberties Union of California, the Electronic Frontier Foundation, and Privacy Rights Clearinghouse oppose the bill.
PROPOSED CHANGES TO THE LAW
Existing law:
- Provides, through the California Constitution, that all people are by nature free and independent and have inalienable rights. Among these are enjoying and defending life and liberty, acquiring, possessing, and protecting property, and pursuing and obtaining safety, happiness, and privacy. (Cal. Const, art. I, § 1.)
- Establishes the Information Practices Act of 1977, which declares that the right to privacy is a personal and fundamental right protected by Section 1 of Article I of the Constitution of California and by the United States Constitution and that all individuals have a right of privacy in information pertaining to them. It further states the following legislative findings:
- the right to privacy is being threatened by the indiscriminate collection, maintenance, and dissemination of personal information and the lack of effective laws and legal remedies;
- the increasing use of computers and other sophisticated information technology has greatly magnified the potential risk to individual privacy that can occur from the maintenance of personal information; and
- in order to protect the privacy of individuals, it is necessary that the maintenance and dissemination of personal information be subject to strict limits. (Civ. Code § 1798 et seq.)
- Establishes the California Customer Records Act, which provides requirements for the maintenance and disposal of customer records and the personal information contained therein. (Civ. Code § 1798.80 et seq.) It further states it is the intent of the Legislature to ensure that personal information about California residents is protected and to encourage businesses that own, license, or maintain personal information about Californians to provide reasonable security for that information. (Civ. Code § 1798.81.5(a).)
- Requires a business that owns, licenses, or maintains personal information about a California resident to implement and maintain reasonable security procedures and practices appropriate to the nature of the information, to protect the personal information from unauthorized access, destruction, use, modification, or disclosure, and requires such businesses to contractually require nonaffiliated third parties to which it discloses such personal information to similarly protect that information. (Civ. Code § 1798.81.5(b), (c).)
- Establishes the California Consumer Privacy Act of 2018 (CCPA), which grants consumers certain rights with regard to their personal information, including enhanced notice, access, and disclosure; the right to deletion; the right to restrict the sale of information; and protection from discrimination for exercising these rights. It places attendant obligations on businesses to respect those rights. (Civ. Code § 1798.100 et seq.)
- Requires that a business that collects a consumer’s personal information shall, at or before the point of collection, inform consumers as to the categories of personal information to be collected and the purposes for which the categories of personal information shall be used. (Civ. Code § 1798.100.)
- Provides consumers the right to request that a business that collects personal information about the consumer disclose to the consumer the following:
- the categories of personal information it has collected about that consumer;
- the categories of sources from which the personal information is collected;
- the business or commercial purpose for collecting or selling personal information;
- the categories of third parties with whom the business shares personal information; and
- the specific pieces of personal information it has collected about that consumer. (Civ. Code § 1798.110(a).)
- Provides consumers the right to request that a business that sells the consumer’s personal information, or that discloses it for a business purpose, disclose to the consumer the following:
- the categories of personal information that the business collected about the consumer;
- the categories of personal information that the business sold about the consumer and the categories of third parties to whom the personal information was sold, by category or categories of personal information for each third party to whom the personal information was sold; and
- the categories of personal information that the business disclosed about the consumer for a business purpose. (Civ. Code § 1798.115(a).)
This bill:
- Requires a business in California that uses facial recognition technology to disclose the usage of facial recognition technology in a clear and conspicuous, physical sign at the entrance of every location that uses the technology.
- Subjects businesses in violation to civil penalties of up to $75 per violation up to $7,500 per year. This penalty is to be assessed and recovered in a civil action brought in the name of the people of the State of California by the Attorney General, by a district attorney, county counsel, or city attorney, or by a city prosecutor in a city having a full-time city prosecutor, in a court of competent jurisdiction. If the action is brought by the Attorney General, one-half of the penalty collected shall be paid to the treasurer of the county in which the judgment was entered, and one-half to the General Fund. If the action is brought by a district attorney or county counsel, the penalty collected shall be paid to the treasurer of the county in which the judgment was entered. If the action is brought by a city attorney or city prosecutor, one-half of the penalty collected shall be paid to the treasurer of the city in which the judgment was entered, and one-half to the treasurer of the county in which the judgment was entered.
- Subjects businesses in violation to a penalty of up to $5,000 for knowing and willful violations.
- Defines “clear and conspicuous” to mean in larger type than the surrounding text, or in contrasting type, font, or color to the surrounding text of the same size, or set off from the surrounding text of the same size by symbols and other marks that call attention to the language. “Facial recognition technology” means a software application that analyzes facial features from a digital image or video for the purpose of automatically identifying a specific individual.
- Becomes operative on July 1, 2020.
COMMENTS
- Stated intent of the bill
According to the author:
Facial recognition technology (FRT) is becoming ever more present throughout businesses in California. It can be used to prevent retail crime, find missing persons, and even diagnose diseases. However, concerns about privacy and use of the information are increasing. Individuals are not currently informed of FRT being used on them, nor do they know how long the information is held or how it is used. AB 1281 would simply make consumers aware of which California businesses are using FRT by requiring each business to disclose the use of the technology with a physical sign at its entrance.
- Responding to the widespread use of facial recognition technology
Article I, Section 1 of the California Constitution provides: “All people are by nature free and independent and have inalienable rights. Among these are enjoying and defending life and liberty, acquiring, possessing, and protecting property, and pursuing and obtaining safety, happiness, and privacy.” Privacy is therefore not just a policy goal; it is a constitutional right of every Californian. However, it has been under increasing assault. The increasing use of various forms of surveillance, while providing myriad benefits, raises troubling concerns about the systematic invasion of Californian’s privacy.
Specifically, facial recognition technology is one form of surveillance technology that has gained increased prominence, as it is being used in our electronic devices and smart home products. However, the widespread collection of data through this technology is troubling. A recent study found that there is more than a 50 percent chance that any adult is already included in a law enforcement facial recognition database.[1]
A researcher at the Center for a New American Security has described the privacy concerns with such ubiquitous and powerful technology:
If you just walk down the street in Boston, in New York, in London, you are going to be recorded by many many security cameras. Some of them [in] the possession of the local police force, most of them in possession of private companies who just have a security camera. So in society, we have really gotten used to the idea of being photographed constantly. What's new in facial recognition technology is that we're losing the anonymity that used to be associated with being recorded. So it's not just that you walk past a 7-Eleven, and the security camera notes that you're there. There's the possibility that the 7-Eleven will know that you specifically, as an individual, are there, and they know how many times you have passed by in the past few weeks. That's what's really changing in recent years is the ability to analyze this data and correlate it and draw insights from it. It really does raise a whole host of new privacy concerns.[2]
The use by private businesses has exploded in recent years:
Facial-recognition software, which has been in development since the 1960s and has been gaining popularity with police for more than a decade, has taken off with retailers and event spaces during the last couple of years, consultants say. It’s marketed to them as an unparalleled tool for cutting down on shoplifting, and sold to the public as a security tool — helping identify would-be terrorists at sports games, for instance, or protecting consumers against identity theft by making sure that they are who they say they are. It’s also almost completely unregulated.[3]
This bill takes a modest approach to the issue by requiring businesses that use facial recognition technology to place a clear and conspicuous sign at the entrance of each location using the technology disclosing the fact that such technology is being used. The bill defines “facial recognition technology” as “a software application that analyzes facial features from a digital image or video for the purpose of automatically identifying a specific individual.” A coalition of groups in opposition to the bill argue the definition is inadequate. They argue for the following definition:
“Facial recognition” means either of the following, alone or in combination: (A) An automated or semiautomated process that captures biometric data of an individual. (B) An automated or semiautomated process that assists in identifying an individual or generating surveillance information about an individual based on biometric data.
To encourage compliance, the bill subjects businesses in violation to modest civil penalties of up to $75 per violation up to $7,500. These penalties can only be recovered in civil actions brought by specified public entities. However, an additional $5,000 penalty is available for knowing and willful violations of the signage requirement. Businesses must come into compliance by July 1, 2020.
Writing in support, Oakland Privacy states:
Californians who patronize brick and mortar businesses, whether to purchase items, window shop or meet up with friends generally assume that their identity remains private. Unless or until they engage in a non-cash transaction with the business or engage in some act of disruption, disturbance or criminality, in which case security camera footage may be made available to local law enforcement.
Facial recognition technology violates this general compact or understanding by potentially allowing instant or automated identification of any individual whose image is captured on security camera still or video footage, absent suspected criminality and absent consent. Such a list of bookstore browsers has a plethora of possible uses, some more innocuous than others, but all consisting of consent-free and suspicion-free autoidentification based on biometric data, which once collected and analyzed, remains in the possession of the collector despite as casual a relationship as looking at a paperback on display for five minutes.
As with other signage and transparency regulations, like Proposition 65, Assembly Bill 1281 provides a buyer beware option. It allows consumers to know that a business may connect their image to their identity and allows them to consider alternatives and whether, in fact, they consent.
It should be noted that in addition the troubling privacy concerns posed by the technology, there has been research showing that the technology frequently results in misidentification, especially with persons with darker skin tones. A recent test of certain facial recognition technology was conducted:
The errors emerged as part of a larger test in which the civil liberties group used Amazon’s facial software to compare the photos of all federal lawmakers against a database of 25,000 publicly available mug shots. In the test, the Amazon technology incorrectly matched 28 members of Congress with people who had been arrested, amounting to a 5 percent error rate among legislators.
The test disproportionally misidentified African-American and Latino members of Congress as the people in mug shots.[4]
Jacob Snow with the American Civil Liberties Union of Northern California stated that the test confirmed that “facial recognition is flawed, biased, and dangerous.”
- Other efforts to address facial recognition technology
This bill comes among similar efforts at both the local level here in California and in other states.
In 2008, Illinois enacted the Biometric Information Privacy Act, which provides:
No private entity may collect, capture, purchase, receive through trade, or otherwise obtain a person’s or a customer’s biometric identifier or biometric information, unless it first:
(1) informs the subject or the subject’s legally authorized representative in writing that a biometric identifier or biometric information is being collected or stored;
(2) informs the subject or the subject’s legally authorized representative in writing of the specific purpose and length of term for which a biometric identifier or biometric information is being collected, stored, and used; and
(3) receives a written release executed by the subject of the biometric identifier or biometric information or the subject’s legally authorized representative.
(2007 ILL. ALS 994.) The law provides an enforcement mechanism for persons aggrieved by violations and makes available liquidated or actual damages, attorneys’ fees and costs, and other relief, including injunction.
Senator Cynthia Creem, a state senator in Massachusetts, is carrying a bill, Senate Bill 1385, “to establish a moratorium on face recognition and other remote biometric surveillance systems.”[5] The bill makes it unlawful for the government and its officials “to acquire, possess, access, or use any biometric surveillance system, or acquire, possess, access, or use information derived from a biometric surveillance system operated by another entity” absent express statutory authorization. New York City has also seen a bill aimed at this practice that would “require businesses to start telling the public if they’re using facial recognition, how long they’re storing it, and who they’re sharing it with.”[6]
Recently, the San Francisco Board of Supervisors made the city the first in the United States to ban the use of facial recognition technology by police and city agencies. It does not affect private use of the technology. Aaron Peskin, the city supervisor who sponsored the bill, stated: “I think part of San Francisco being the real and perceived headquarters for all things tech also comes with a responsibility for its local legislators. We have an outsize responsibility to regulate the excesses of technology precisely because they are headquartered here.”[7] Another issue identified with the technology was its use at local homeless shelters, where biometric finger scans and photos were being used to track shelter usage. There was evidence the practice was driving undocumented residents away from the shelters. Oakland and Somerville, Massachusetts are also considering similar legislation.
- Interaction with the CCPA
The CCPA grants consumers certain rights with regard to their personal information, including enhanced notice, access, and disclosure; the right to deletion; the right to restrict the sale of information; and protection from discrimination for exercising these rights. It places attendant obligations on businesses to respect those rights. (Civ. Code § 1798.100 et seq.) “Business” for the purposes of the CCPA is defined as:
A sole proprietorship, partnership, limited liability company, corporation, association, or other legal entity that is organized or operated for the profit or financial benefit of its shareholders or other owners, that collects consumers’ personal information, or on the behalf of which such information is collected and that alone, or jointly with others, determines the purposes and means of the processing of consumers’ personal information, that does business in the State of California, and that satisfies one or more of the following thresholds:
(A) Has annual gross revenues in excess of twenty-five million dollars ($25,000,000), as adjusted pursuant to paragraph (5) of subdivision (a) of Section 1798.185.
(B) Alone or in combination, annually buys, receives for the business’s commercial purposes, sells, or shares for commercial purposes, alone or in combination, the personal information of 50,000 or more consumers, households, or devices.
(C) Derives 50 percent or more of its annual revenues from selling consumers’ personal information.
(Civ. Code § 1798.140.)
Businesses that are subject to the CCPA and that collect personal information, are required to, at or before the point of collection, inform consumers as to the categories of personal information to be collected and the purposes for which the categories of personal information shall be used. (Civ. Code § 1798.100.) “Personal information,” for purposes of the CCPA, includes visual information and biometric information that “identifies, relates to, describes, is capable of being associated with, or could be reasonably linked, directly or indirectly, with a particular consumer.” Certainly, the use of technology that, by definition, “analyzes facial features from a digital image or video for the purpose of automatically identifying a specific individual” would be considered the collection of personal information.
Therefore, it is likely many businesses using such technology will already be required to inform consumers before using facial recognition technology at their stores and to further inform those consumers as to the categories of personal information to be collected and the purposes for which the personal information will be used.
However, the bill does provide for civil penalties for violations, which would be in addition to any penalties that could be enforced pursuant to the CCPA. Although, it should be noted that recent amendments to the bill have removed the ability of consumers to collect the base civil penalties, and instead requires such penalties to be collected in an action brought by the Attorney General, by a district attorney, county counsel, or city attorney, or by a city prosecutor in a city having a full-time city prosecutor. Penalties collected in actions brought by these public agencies would be paid into various public funds, as specified. In addition, penalties of up to $5,000 per location in violation can be recovered for knowing and willful violations.
- Strengthening the consumer protections provided
Given more robust approaches in other jurisdictions, arguably stronger regulatory action is warranted to counteract the very serious privacy implications of the use of this technology at such a massive scale. It is certainly true that better education of the public about the use of this technology is an important first step. As argued by Oakland Privacy in its letter of support “more public awareness is an essential element in the public dialogue about this technology. Public awareness requires disclosure.”
However, even when alerted to the fact that such technology is in use, there is no meaningful way to opt out of the collection of this information or the intrusive surveillance likely actively taking place when the individual reads the signage. Simply requiring notice that the technology is being used also does not impart additional, but critical, information about the purposes for its use and the third parties with whom these businesses share the collected information. This is problematic for those businesses that may not be subject to the CCPA, which requires more information to be provided than required by this bill. To strengthen the protections provided, the author has agreed to add the following provisions to this bill:
- “The positioning of the sign shall ensure a consumer can read it before the business captures a digital image or video of the individual that can be analyzed using facial recognition technology.”
- “The sign shall include information about where a consumer can go to find out more information about the purposes for which the business uses the technology.”
However, given the magnitude of the issue, the author may wish to consider further amendments to more adequately respond to the issues at hand. Indeed, the American Civil Liberties Union of California, the Electronic Frontier Foundation, and Privacy Rights Clearinghouse write in joint opposition to the bill urging stronger action:
Businesses have already begun to deploy facial recognition algorithms. An Oregon gas station for example recently installed a system that limits access to the facility based on its identification of a consumer’s face with a sign that reads: “Look at camera for entry. Facial recognition in use.” Anyone flagged by the company’s algorithm is unable to enter the store, despite concerns about inaccuracy and the potential that the information may be used to create an ongoing database or shared with other retailers.
Meanwhile, facial-recognition technology is being marketed to retailers as a way to flag people who are suspected of having previously shoplifted or sought refunds for stolen merchandise, raising questions about the accuracy of such systems and how the data is used. Could merchants share data? Would one incident of teenage shoplifting lead to someone being barred from a store – or every store – for life? What process is available for an individual to be notified and allowed to challenge false identifications, what proof would be necessary, and who decides?
The technology is also in use within the service industry where companies such as Servall Biometrics are scanning the ID's and faces of bargoers, including over 50,000 patrons in Sacramento in a five- month period. Bars, nightclubs and pubs have used the company’s PatronScan system to create a shared blacklist of 40,000+ customers who are on average banned for 19 years based on whatever allegation the company’s staff inputs. This information is also provided to law enforcement agencies upon request without a warrant or probable cause. A competing company, IDScan.net allows bars to install a camera system outside their doors that will capture, catalog, and identify customers by their biometric information, matching it to their scanned IDs.
Your bill permits businesses in California to use facial recognition technology so long as they merely disclose the usage of facial recognition technology in a physical sign at the entrance of every location that uses facial recognition technology. Moreover, violation of even this negligible requirement could not be remedied by the person whose biometric information was taken; compliance could be enforced only if a public prosecutor had the willingness and wherewithal to seek a civil penalty. Even then, no recovery would go to the person whose rights were violated, contrary to the custom and tradition of every meaningful privacy and consumer protection law.
Posting a sign is little or no protection against the use of this powerful and intrusive technology. Such signs would likely become as ubiquitous and ignored as Prop. 65 notices are now, particularly when consumers have no effective way to guard against the dangers. A physical sign – no matter how prominent – is no substitute for consent.
SUPPORT
Oakland Privacy
OPPOSITION
American Civil Liberties Union of California
Electronic Frontier Foundation
Privacy Rights Clearinghouse
RELATED LEGISLATION
Pending Legislation:
AB 1130 (Levine, 2019) expands the definition of personal information in various statutes, including the data breach notification statutes, to include certain additional information that is particularly sensitive but not currently explicitly included therein, including biometric data and certain identification numbers. This bill is currently in the Senate Judiciary Committee.
AB 1215 (Ting, 2019) prohibits law enforcement from installing, activating, or using a biometric surveillance system in connection with a law enforcement agency’s body-worn camera or any other camera worn or carried. This bill is currently on the Senate Floor.
Prior Legislation:
SB 1121 (Dodd, Ch. 735, Stats. 2018) amended the CCPA to make technical fixes and to address various stakeholder concerns.
SB 1186 (Hill, 2018) would have required specified law enforcement agencies to have a policy, approved by their governing bodies, in place before the use of surveillance technology, including facial recognition technology. The bill was held in the Assembly Appropriations Committee.
AB 375 (Chau, Ch. 55, Stats. 2018) created the CCPA.
PRIOR VOTES:
Assembly Floor (Ayes 61, Noes 13)
Assembly Privacy and Consumer Protection Committee (Ayes 8, Noes 3)
**************
Shannon Van Sant, San Francisco Approves Ban On Government's Use Of Facial Recognition Technology (May 14, 2019) NPR, https://www.npr.org/2019/05/14/723193785/san-francisco-considers-ban-on-governments-use-of-facial-recognition-technology [as of Jun. 18, 2019]. ↑
Peter O’Dowd, As Facial Recognition Technology Booms, So Do Privacy Concerns (Dec. 21, 2018) WBUR, https://www.wbur.org/hereandnow/2018/12/21/facial-recognition-privacy-concerns [as of Jun. 26, 2019]. ↑
Nick Tabor, Smile! The Secretive Business of Facial-Recognition Software in Retail Stores (Oct. 20, 2018) New York Magazine, http://nymag.com/intelligencer/2018/10/retailers-are-using-facial-recognition-technology-too.html [as of Jun. 26, 2019]. ↑
Natasha Singer, Amazon’s Facial Recognition Wrongly Identifies 28 Lawmakers, A.C.L.U. Says (Jul. 26, 2018) New York Times, https://www.nytimes.com/2018/07/26/technology/amazon-aclu-facial-recognition-congress.html [as of Jun. 26, 2019]. ↑
Nick Tabor, Smile! The Secretive Business of Facial-Recognition Software in Retail Stores (Oct. 20, 2018) New York Magazine, http://nymag.com/intelligencer/2018/10/retailers-are-using-facial-recognition-technology-too.html [as of Jun. 18, 2019]. ↑
Kate Conger, Richard Fausset, and Serge F. Kovaleski, San Francisco Bans Facial Recognition Technology (May 14, 2019) New York Times, https://www.nytimes.com/2019/05/14/us/facial-recognition-ban-san-francisco.html [as of Jun. 26, 2019]. ↑
ASSEMBLY THIRD READING
ATR Bill Id:AB 1281
Author:(Chau)
As Amended Ver:April 12, 2019
Majority vote
SUMMARY:
This bill requires a business in California that uses facial recognition technology (FRT), as defined, to disclose that usage in a physical sign that is clear and conspicuous at the entrance of every location that uses FRT.
Major Provisions
- Require that any business that utilizes FRT to disclose that usage in a physical sign at the entrance of every location that uses facial recognition technology.
- Define "clear and conspicuous" to mean in larger type than the surrounding text, or in contrasting type, font, or color to the surrounding text of the same size, or set off from the surrounding text of the same size by symbols and other marks that call attention to the language.
- Define "FRT" to mean a software application used to automatically identify individuals from a digital image or video frames.
- Provide that violators of the statute shall be liable for a civil penalty of up to $75 per violation, not to exceed $7,500 annually. Notwithstanding these penalties, an additional penalty of up to $5,000 per location annually may be assessed for knowing and willful violations.
- Delay implementation until July 1, 2020.
COMMENTS:
FRT is passive and universal, meaning that by simply walking into range of an FRT system (camera), a person's biometric information is captured. Thus, it is not necessary to complete a transaction or to otherwise actively engage with a business in order to have your personal information stored and used by that business.
That is not to say, however, that FRT does not present potential utility for its adopters and the public as whole. Operationalizing FRT in the sphere of public safety can offer a tremendous decrease in the cost of security oversight and in enforcement accuracy. FRT also allows users to unlock their phones without a password, alerts individuals when a friend uploads their picture to social media, and allows business to identify and address repeat customers and offer them better service. In the future, FRT could be used to increase businesses' advertising efficiency, help law enforcement find missing persons, or even allow consumers to skip the checkout line at the grocery store. Thus, whether it is law enforcement, schools, or business, FRT has the potential to lead to noticeable improvements.
That being said, FRT also has the potential to undermine an individual's right to privacy at the same time that it offers the promise of utility to entities employing it. Defining the appropriate balance between privacy interests and competing public policies can be difficult to define. Californians have enshrined the right to privacy in the state Constitution and as a state, California has consistently been an example to other states through its prioritization of its residents' right to privacy. Specifically, since the right to privacy was expressly provided in the state Constitution in 1972, the Legislature has continued to flesh out how this fundamental right is protected. The Confidentiality of Medical Information Act limits the disclosure of patients' medical information absent their consent. The Computer Spyware Act prohibits an unauthorized person from knowingly installing or providing software on another's computer, as specified. (Civil Code Section 56 et seq. and Business & Professions Code Section 22947 et seq.) California also has specific privacy protections for victims of domestic violence, elder and dependent adult abuse, stalking, and human trafficking, and similarly provides address confidentiality for elected and public officials despite the public's interest in transparency. (Government Code Section (Gov.) 6205 et seq. and Gov. 6254.21.) The California Consumer Privacy Act, enacted in 2018 to protect the privacy of consumers' personal information (PI) when in the possession of businesses, represents the most recent example of a long and pioneering history of placing privacy above all but the most serious concerns.
However, while there are a host of laws that protect the PI of Californians, including some that cover biometric information which would necessarily include certain applications of FRT, there are currently no statutes in place that directly govern the use of FRT more broadly in California. By requiring every business that uses FRT in California to disclose that usage to consumers, regardless of the business's size, this bill arguably increases consumer awareness substantially with minimal impact on the business themselves. In turn, by having awareness, consumers can make more informed choices about where they shop, and have a better appreciation that their biometric information is being collected and potentially used by businesses.
According to the Author:
"Facial recognition technology (FRT) is becoming ever more present throughout businesses in California. It can be used to prevent retail crime, find missing persons, and even diagnose diseases. However, concerns about privacy and use of the information are increasing. Individuals are not currently informed [when] FRT being used on them, nor do they know how long the information is held or how it is used. AB 1281 would simply make consumers aware of which California businesses are using FRT by requiring each business to disclose the use of the technology with a physical sign at its entrance."
Arguments in Support:
Oakland Privacy, in support, writes, "Californians who patronize brick and mortar businesses, whether to purse items, window shop or meet up with friends generally assume that their identity remains private. […] Facial recognition technology violates this general compact or understanding by potentially allowing instant or automated identification of any individual whose image is captured on security camera still or video footage. […] As with other signage and transparency regulations, like Proposition 65, Assembly Bill 1281 simply provides a buyer beware option. It allows consumers to know that a business may connect their image to their identity and allows them to consider alternatives and whether, in fact, they consent."
Arguments in Opposition:
The California Retailers Association removed their opposition based on the April 12, 2019 amendments.
FISCAL COMMENTS:
This bill is keyed non-fiscal by the Legislative Counsel
VOTES:
ASM PRIVACY AND CONSUMER PROTECTION: 8-3-0
YES: Chau, Bauer-Kahan, Berman, Weber, Mullin, Irwin, Smith, Wicks
NO: Gallagher, Fong, Obernolte
UPDATED:
VERSION: April 12, 2019
CONSULTANT: David Watson / P. & C.P. / (916) 319-2200 FN: 0000231
Date of Hearing: March 26, 2019
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON PRIVACY AND CONSUMER PROTECTION
Ed Chau, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 1281 (
Author:Chau) – As Introduced Ver:February 21, 2019
SUBJECT: Privacy: facial recognition technology: disclosure.
SUMMARY: This bill would require a business in California that uses facial recognition technology (FRT), as defined, to disclose that usage in a physical sign that is clear and conspicuous at the entrance of every location that uses FRT. Specifically, this bill would:
- Require that any business that utilizes FRT to disclose that usage in a physical sign at the entrance of every location that uses FRT.
- Define “clear and conspicuous” to mean in larger type than the surrounding text, or in contrasting type, font, or color to the surrounding text of the same size, or set off from the surrounding text of the same size by symbols and other marks that call attention to the language.
- Define “FRT” to mean a software application used to automatically identify individuals from a digital image or video frames.
- Provide that a violation of the bill shall be considered unfair competition pursuant to existing law, and that one violation shall occur for each day the required disclosure is not made.
EXISTING LAW:
- Provides, under the California Constitution, that all people have inalienable rights, including the right to pursue and obtain privacy. (Cal. Const. art. I, Sec. 1.)
- Provides, pursuant to the California Consumer Privacy Act (CCPA), effective January 1, 2020, that a business that collects personal information (PI) must inform the consumer at or before the time of collection, the category and purpose of the PI that is to be collected. (Civ. Code. Sec. 1798.100(b).)
- Defines various terms for purposes of the CCPA, including the following, among others:
- “PI” means information that identifies, relates to, describes, is capable of being associated with, or could reasonably be linked, directly or indirectly, with a particular consumer or household. Specifies that PI includes, but is not limited to, certain types of information if it identifies, relates to, describes, is capable of being associated with, or could be reasonably linked, directly or indirectly, with a particular consumer or household. Among these is “biometric information.” (Civ. Code. Sec. 1798.140(o)(1)(E).)
- “Biometric information” means an individual’s physiological, biological or behavioral characteristics, including an individual’s deoxyribonucleic acid (DNA), that can be used, singly or in combination with each other or with other identifying data, to establish individual identity. Biometric information includes, but is not limited to, imagery of the iris, retina, fingerprint, face, hand, palm, vein patterns, and voice recordings, from which an identifier template, such as a faceprint, a minutiae template, or a voiceprint, can be extracted, and keystroke patterns or rhythms, gait patterns or rhythms, and sleep, health, or exercise data that contain identifying information. (Civ. Code. Sec. 1798.140(b).)
- Generally protects consumers from unlawful, unfair and fraudulent business practices under California’s Unfair Competition Law (UCL). (Bus. & Prof. Code Sec. 17200, et seq.)
- Provides, pursuant to the UCL, that a business that fails to comply with the provisions of the act be subject to fines not to exceed $2,500 for each violation. (Bus. & Prof. Code. Sec. 17206.)
FISCAL EFFECT: This bill has been keyed nonfiscal by the Legislative Counsel.
COMMENTS:
- Purpose of the bill: This bill seeks to enhance consumer choice by requiring businesses that use FRT notify consumers of this usage prior to a consumer entering a commercial establishment. This is an author-sponsored bill.
- Author’s Statement: According to the author, “[f]acial recognition technology (FRT) is becoming ever more present throughout businesses in California. It can be used to prevent retail crime, find missing persons, and even diagnose diseases. However, concerns about privacy and use of the information are increasing. Individuals are not currently informed [when] FRT being used on them, nor do they know how long the information is held or how it is used. AB 1281 would simply make consumers aware of which California businesses are using FRT by requiring each business to disclose the use of the technology with a physical sign at its entrance.”
- The widespread use of FRT: FRT is passive and universal, meaning that by simply walking into range of an FRT system (camera), a person’s biometric information is captured. Thus, it is not necessary to complete a transaction or to otherwise actively engage with a business in order to have your personal information stored and used by that business.
That is not to say, however, that FRT does not present potential utility for its adopters and the public as whole. Operationalizing FRT in the sphere of public safety can offer a tremendous decrease in the cost of security oversight and in enforcement accuracy (though the utility is arguably limited by identified bias, discussed more in Comment 4, below). FRT also allows users to unlock their phones without a password, alerts individuals when a friend uploads their picture to social media, and allows business to identify and address repeat customers and offer them better service. In the future, FRT could be used to increase businesses’ advertising efficiency, help law enforcement find missing persons, or even allow consumers to skip the checkout line at the grocery store. Thus, whether it is law enforcement, schools, or business, FRT has the potential to lead to noticeable improvements.
That being said, FRT also has the potential to undermine an individual’s right to privacy at the same time that it offers the promise of utility to entities employing it. Defining the appropriate balance between privacy interests and competing public policies can be difficult to define. Californians have enshrined the right to privacy in the state Constitution and as a state, California has consistently been an example to other states through its prioritization of its residents’ right to privacy. Specifically, since the right to privacy was expressly provided in the state Constitution in 1972, the Legislature has continued to flesh out how this fundamental right is protected. The Confidentiality of Medical Information Act limits the disclosure of patients’ medical information absent their consent. The Computer Spyware Act prohibits an unauthorized person from knowingly installing or providing software on another’s computer, as specified. (Civ. Code Sec. 56 et seq. and Bus. & Prof. Code Sec. 22947 et seq.) California also has specific privacy protections for victims of domestic violence, elder and dependent adult abuse, stalking, and human trafficking, and similarly provides address confidentiality for elected and public officials despite the public’s interest in transparency. (Gov. Code Sec. 6205 et seq. and Gov. Code Sec. 6254.21.) The CCPA, enacted in 2018 to protect the privacy of consumers’ PI when in the possession of businesses, represents the most recent example of a long and pioneering history of placing privacy above all but the most serious concerns.
However, while there are a host of laws that protect the PI of Californians, including some that cover biometric information which would necessarily include certain applications of FRT, there are currently no statutes in place that directly govern the use of FRT more broadly in California. By requiring every business that uses FRT in California to disclose that usage to consumers, regardless of the business’s size, this bill arguably increases consumer awareness substantially with minimal impact on the business themselves. In turn, by having awareness, consumers can make more informed choices about where they shop, and have a better appreciation that their biometric information is being collected and potentially used by businesses.
As highlighted in a recent article by national American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU) privacy and policy experts, Are Stores You Shop at Secretly Using Face Recognition on You?, a recent ACLU survey directly asked 20 of the largest brick and mortar store operators in the United States if they currently utilized FRT. Only one affirmatively denied using it and one verified they in fact did use FRT, claiming they use it specifically to prevent theft and identify shoplifters. The other 18 stores refused to answer the question at all. (Bitar & Stanley, Are Stores You Shop at Secretly Using Face Recognition on You?, ACLU (Mar. 26, 2018) <https://www.aclu.org/blog /privacy-technology/surveillance-technologies/are-stores-you-shop-secretly-using-face> [as of Mar. 19, 2019].) As stated by the ACLU experts:
At this point, customers may understand intellectually that their movements in stores are captured on video — although most stores place them in domes made of smoked glass for no reason other than to hide the cameras from customers (who might find the swiveling, zooming lenses therein to be spooky and actually gain a realistic sense of the extent to which they are being watched). Most customers also probably expect that most camera feeds, most of the time, are not being monitored — and that if they are, nothing is done with the video footage that is collected, so long as nothing dramatic is captured.
But I think [it is] fair to say that most customers do not think that they are being subject to a perpetual lineup, scrutinized by face recognition technology to see if they resemble anyone that a company security service has decided to put on a watch list. They do not expect that their faces are being captured, retained, connected to their real-world identity (for example when they use a credit card at checkout), and combined with information about their income, education, demographics, and other data. They do not expect that their every footstep, hand motion, and gaze will be analyzed by computers and filed away to give insight into their shopping habits, patterns, and preferences, and shared among different companies, data brokers, and advertisers. They do not expect that they are subject to the risk of being misidentified as someone in a database of suspected criminals, fugitives, terrorists, or whatever other blacklists stores may be using or begin using in the future. They [do not] expect that all these intimate details about their behavior will become accessible to government agencies through legal demands or voluntary sharing.
And if those things are happening, I think most customers would want to know about it. (Id.)
As stated by the ACLU in response to the reported implementation of FRT by Ohio state officials without any debate, FRT raises “difficult issues, but the first steps are clear. We need to shine more and brighter lights in all the shadowy corners of state surveillance. We probably won’t like what we find, but we can’t fix a problem we don’t know exists.” (Crockford, Ready, fire, aim: Ohio officials implement statewide face recognition program without a whiff of public debate, ACLU (Sep. 3, 2013) < https://www.aclu.org/blog/national-security/privacy-and-surveillance/ready-fire-aim-ohio-officials-implement-statewide> [as of Mar. 19, 2019].) While this bill applies to private businesses, the same can arguably be said about shining a light on business practices so Californians can be informed at the places they visit.
- Second order issues with FRT: While FRT may present great potential in terms of utility, these benefits do not come without risk. There are a number of concerns as to how it is currently operationalized, which stand to undermine the benefit of the technology’s utility if not addressed. A recent New York Times article cites specific issues with Amazon’s[1] FRT system that shows it consistently underperforms when used to accurately identify people with darker completions and of different genders. (Harwell, Amazon facial-identification software used by police falls short on tests for accuracy and bias, new research finds, The Washington Post, (Jan. 25, 2019) <https://www.washingtonpost.com/technology/2019/01/25/amazon-facial-identification-software-used-by-police-falls-short-tests-accuracy-bias-new-research-finds/?utm_term=.0c266b980812 > [as of Mar. 20. 2019].) This is an example of how, despite the pervasiveness of this technology, it is still in its developmental infancy. FRT systems are learning systems that are only as good as their programing. In other words, the technology generally improves as it is given more information. As data sets get larger, the technology will improve and hopefully become more accurate, reducing concerns related to bias. This is all the more reason for people to make an informed choice before ever exposing themselves to systems that collect and potentially retain their biometric information for unknown purposes.
- Bill would allow for more effective implementation of obligations and rights under the CCPA: The CCPA requires that businesses inform consumers about the type of PI a business collects about them, and defines PI to include biometric information. In turn, the CCPA defines “biometric information” to include, among other things, “imagery of the iris, retina, fingerprint, [and] face[.]” (Civ. Code Sec. 1798.140 (b) and (o).) As such, this information clearly encompasses data collected by FRT.
The CCPA separately defines “business” as a legal entity, as specified, that is organized or operated for profit, that collects consumers’ PI, and that satisfies one or more specified thresholds:
- having an annual gross revenue in excess of $25,000,000; or,
- alone or in combination, annually buying, receiving for the business’s commercial purposes, selling, or sharing for commercial purposes, alone or in combination, the PI of 50,000 or more consumers, households, or devices; or,
- deriving 50 percent or more of its annual revenues from selling consumers’ personal information. (Civ. Code Sec. 1798.140(c).)
Notably, this definition does not distinguish between businesses that operate online and those that are a traditional brick and mortar type-establishment. Since FRT enables the collection of biometric information, a plain reading of the relevant statutes would require both types of businesses (if they satisfy the criteria established by the CCPA) that use FRT, to disclose that information to consumers once CCPA becomes operative, on January 1, 2020. For businesses that operate online, this disclosure could be made on their internet website. However, the mechanism by which brick and mortar stores notify consumers may not be as apparent to the consumer on the outset of their visit to the brick and mortar store. By requiring this disclosure to be made at the entrance of brick and mortar stores, this bill would remove any ambiguity for both the brick and mortar store collecting such personal (biometric) information and for the consumer, thereby helping ensure that the store complies with the CCPA’s notice requirements, and protecting consumers from unwittingly participating in the use of FRT.
Regarding the mandatory disclosure under this bill, the California Retailers Association (CRA) argues for a delayed implementation of “September 1, 2020, which would provide a year’s notice for the industry to become aware of the new law, and to have the signs printed and posted. Without such an amendment, the effective date will be January 1, 2020, providing only [three] months notice if the Governor signs the bill.”
To ensure clarity and ease any confusion for any businesses subject to the overlapping requirements of this bill and the CCPA, the author offers the following amendment that would delay the effective date of this bill to July 1, 2020. This, as opposed to the September date suggested by CRA, would better coincide with the CCPA, which prohibits the Attorney General from bringing any enforcement actions under that act until six months after its final regulations are published, or July 1, 2020 (whichever date is sooner). .
Author’s amendment:
Delay implementation of AB 1281 until July 1, 2020.
- Small business usage of FRT: This bill would require all businesses that use FRT to disclose that usage to customers, regardless of size. As noted in Comment 5, above, the CCPA only applies to businesses of a certain size or that otherwise cross specific PI collection thresholds. However, with FRT use becoming more widespread as the barriers to entry become smaller, coupled with the apparent utility in FRT systems, its inevitable adoption by smaller businesses becomes more of an immediate reality.
Californians are entitled to privacy under the state constitution, and the concern of FRT undermining that privacy right exists regardless of the business’s size. Recognizing this, this bill correctly keeps that fundamental right in mind while balancing the costs associated with compliance for small businesses. Arguably, this bill places a very small obligation on business possible: simple notification. That obligation, however, should help Californians better exercise their rights and make informed choices.
- Potential issues of enforceability: As drafted, failure to comply with the requirements of this bill would constitute an unfair business practice, which would subject a business of a civil penalty of up to $2,500 under the state’s Unfair Competition Law (UCL). (Bus. & Prof. Code Secs. 17200 et seq. and 17206.) CRA, in opposition, argues that mandated signage grows every year and that the enforcement mechanism in this bill should be saved for more serious offensives. CRA writes:
Prop 65 warnings, beverage recycling locations, return policies, hours of operation alcoholic beverage applications, solicitation policies – all appear on store entrances. We respectfully suggest that enforcement of a new sign positing requirement should not be through Section 17200 of the Business and Profession Code. The Unfair Business Practices Act [the UCL] should be reserved for more serious violations such as weights and measures overcharges, anti-competitive acts, scanning violations, etc. The inadvertent absence of a sign at one location, whether by oversight, or accidental falling down of the sign, or a customer removing the sign, even if a sign remains posted at other entrances, should be a lesser violation.
[CRA suggests] the following alternative: “The first and second violations shall result in a notice of violation, and any subsequent violation shall constitute an infraction punishable by a fine of twenty-five dollars ($25) for each day the business i[s] in violation, but not to exceed three-hundred dollars ($300) annually.” This is the enforcement approach used in the straws-upon-request bill enacted last year by the Legislature, and also found in AB 161 this year.
Estimating the impact on business to comply with this bill is difficult in the abstract. The costs associated with designing and displaying a sign will surely vary from business to business based on their preferences and structure. However, as CRA points out in their letter, these same businesses have been routinely asked to prominently place signage advising patrons of their various rights and of specific safety concerns mandated by Proposition 65. Thus, it is likely that most businesses will be familiar with the process of complying with the requirements of this bill and already have mechanism in place to do so. That being said, a civil penalty of up $2,500 per violation under the UCL may not provide courts with enough flexibility to fairly address violations of small businesses in comparison to violations of larger businesses. At the same time, the proposed $25 per day violation suggested by CRA may not be sufficient to incentivize compliance, particularly by larger businesses.
Accordingly, the author offers the following amendment that would limit the penalty to up to $75 per day, but never to exceed $7,500 annually or one percent of the business’s net income. Arguably, this should create a penalty structure that, while not being overly punitive, still incentivizes businesses big and small to comply with the provisions of the bill. Staff also notes that this proposal, allowing for prosecution by public attorneys and providing for the distribution of the judgments, are consistent with various statutes under existing law. (See e.g., Civ. Code Sec. 1745.5.)
Author’s amendment:
On page 2, strike lines 20-23 and insert the following:
- (1) Any person who fails to comply with subdivision (a) shall be liable for a civil penalty up to seventy five dollars ($75) for each violation, not to exceed seventy five hundred dollars ($7,500) annually or one percent (1%) of the business’s net income, whichever is higher, which shall be assessed and recovered in a civil action brought in the name of the people of the State of California by the Attorney General, by any district attorney, county counsel, city attorney, or by a city prosecutor in any city having a full-time city prosecutor, in any court of competent jurisdiction.
(2) If the action is brought by the Attorney General, one-half of the penalty collected shall be paid to the treasurer of the county in which the judgment was entered, and one-half to the General Fund. If the action is brought by a district attorney, the penalty collected shall be paid to the treasurer of the county in which the judgment was entered. If the action is brought by a city attorney or city prosecutor, one-half of the penalty shall be paid to the treasurer of the city in which the judgment was entered, and one-half to the treasurer of the county in which the judgment was entered.
- Prior legislation: AB 375 (Chau, Ch. 55, Stats. 2018) enacted the CCPA to ensure the privacy of Californians’ PI through various consumer rights.
SB 1121 (Dodd, Ch. 735, Stats. 2018) ensured that a private right applied only to the CCPA’s section on data breach and not to any other section of the CCPA, as specified, corrected numerous drafting errors, made non-controversial clarifying amendments, and addressed several policy suggestions made by the AG in a preliminary clean-up bill after the passage of AB 375.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
None on file
Opposition
California Retailers Association
Analysis Prepared by: David Watson / P. & C.P. / (916) 319-2200
These types of bias issues have been identified in other proprietary FRT systems. Amazon just happens to be one of the most successful businesses in the field and thus open to more direct scrutiny. ↑
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):