AB 1320: Public employee retirement systems: prohibited investments: Turkey.
- Session Year: 2019-2020
- House: Assembly
- Latest Version Date: 2019-10-02
The California Constitution grants the retirement board of a public employee retirement system plenary authority and fiduciary responsibility for investment of moneys and administration of the retirement fund and system. The California Constitution qualifies this grant of powers by reserving to the Legislature the authority to prohibit investments if it is in the public interest and the prohibition satisfies standards of fiduciary care and loyalty required of a retirement board. Existing law prohibits the boards of administration of the Public Employees Retirement System and the State Teachers Retirement System from making investments in certain countries and in thermal coal companies, as specified, subject to the boards plenary authority and fiduciary responsibility for investment of moneys and administration of the systems.
This bill, upon the passage of a federal law that imposes sanctions on the government of Turkey for failure to officially acknowledge its responsibility for the Armenian Genocide, would prohibit the boards of administration of the Public Employees Retirement System and the State Teachers Retirement System from making additional or new investments, or renewing existing investments, of public employee retirement funds in an investment vehicle in the government of Turkey that is issued by the government of Turkey or that is owned by the government of Turkey. The bill would require the boards to liquidate existing investments in the government of Turkey within 18 months of the passage of the above-described federal law. The bill would require these boards to make specified reports to the Legislature and the Governor regarding these actions within one year of the passage of a federal law imposing those sanctions on the government of Turkey and on or before January 1, 2024. The bill would specify that its provisions do not require a board to take any action that the board determines in good faith is inconsistent with its constitutional fiduciary responsibilities to the retirement system. The bill would indemnify from the General Fund and hold harmless the present, former, and future board members, officers, and employees of, and investment managers under contract with, the boards, in connection with actions relating to these investments. The bill would repeal the above-described prohibited investment and reporting provisions on January 1, 2025, or if a determination is made by the board, the Department of State, the Congress of the United States, or another appropriate federal agency, agency that the government of Turkey has officially acknowledged its responsibility for the Armenian Genocide, whichever occurs first.
The Legislature finds and declares the following:
(a)The State of California has officially recognized the Armenian Genocide each year for decades and has repeatedly urged the Republic of Turkey to acknowledge the facts of the Armenian Genocide and work toward a just resolution, honor its obligations under international treaties and human rights laws, end all forms of religious discrimination and persecution, and return Christian church properties to their rightful owners.
(b)Genocide is defined by the United Nations as an act committed with intent to destroy, in whole or in part, a national, ethnical, racial or religious group.
(c)Genocide denial is widely viewed as among the final stages of genocide and serves to perpetuate the effects of genocide even after the active phases of extermination, massacres, forced marches, and deportation have ended.
(d)The government of Turkey has engaged and continues to engage in an ongoing campaign of genocide denial and historical revisionism by refusing to acknowledge its responsibility for the Armenian Genocide, refusing to compensate its victims, and actively pursuing a well-funded political lobbying campaign throughout the United States, including in California, to rewrite history and defeat legislation recognizing the Armenian Genocide.
(e)The government of Turkey has engaged, and continues to engage, in efforts to effect Armenian cultural erasure since the founding of the Republic of Turkey, including, but not limited to, ethnic cleansings and the destruction of sacred Armenian religious sites.
(f)A reference in Turkey by any scholar, journalist, or other person to the massacre and deportation of Armenians in 1915 to 1923, inclusive, as genocide can be criminally prosecuted under Article 301 of the Turkish Penal Code.
(g)The State of California is home to the largest Armenian American population in the United States, and Armenians living in California, most of whom are direct descendants of the survivors of the Armenian Genocide, have enriched our state through their leadership and contributions in business, agriculture, academia, government, and the arts, yet continue to suffer the effects of the continued denial campaign by the government of Turkey.
(h)The State of California, as the worlds fifth largest economy as of February 2019, and in accordance with principles of human rights and justice, has taken the lead in adopting legislation to divest from South Africa for its policy of apartheid, Sudan for its genocide in Darfur, and Iran for its support of international terrorism, imposing economic consequences upon regimes that engage in conduct and policy that violate human rights or constitute crimes against humanity.
(i)It is the government of Turkey, not the people of Turkey, that is responsible for Turkeys continued egregious violations of human rights and active pursuit of genocide denial, cultural erasure, and historical revisionism.
(j)Investment in the Republic of Turkey enables its government to continue to deny justice to the Armenian people.
(k)Divesting funds held in trust by the Public Employees Retirement System and the State Teachers Retirement System to pay for public employees retirement benefits would ensure that the State of California is in no way complicit in the continued denial of the Armenian Genocide by the government of Turkey and would encourage said government to acknowledge the Armenian Genocide and to reach a fair and just resolution of reparations for the survivors of the Armenian Genocide.
SEC. 2.Section 7513.74 is added to the Government Code, to read:7513.74.(a)As used in this section, the following terms have the following meanings:
(1)Board means the Board of Administration of the Public Employees Retirement System or the Teachers Retirement Board of the State Teachers Retirement System, as applicable.
(2)Government of Turkey means the government of Turkey or its instrumentalities or political subdivisions.
(3)Public employee retirement funds means the Public Employees Retirement Fund described in Section 20062 and the Teachers Retirement Fund described in Section 22167 of the Education Code.
(4)Turkey means the Republic of Turkey.
(b)Upon passage of a federal law by both the United States House of Representatives and the United States Senate, and signed by the President of the United States, imposing sanctions on the government of Turkey for failure to officially acknowledge its responsibility for the Armenian Genocide, the board shall not make additional or new investments or renew existing investments of public employee retirement funds in any investment vehicle in the government of Turkey that meets either of the following criteria:
(1)The investment vehicle is issued by the government of Turkey.
(2)The investment vehicle is owned by the government of Turkey.
(c)The board shall liquidate investments as described in subdivision (b), within 18 months of the passage of a federal law, pursuant to subdivision (b), that imposes sanctions on the government of Turkey for failure to officially acknowledge its responsibility for the Armenian Genocide.
(d)Within one year of the passage of a federal law pursuant to subdivision (b) imposing sanctions on the government of Turkey for failure to officially acknowledge its responsibility for the Armenian Genocide, the board shall file a report with the Legislature, in compliance with Section 9795, and with the Governor, that shall include the following:
(1)A list of investment vehicles in the government of Turkey of which the board has liquidated its investments pursuant to subdivision (c).
(2)A list of investment vehicles in the government of Turkey of which the board has not liquidated its investments as a result of a determination made pursuant to subdivision (e) that a sale or transfer of investments is inconsistent with the fiduciary responsibilities of the board as described in Section 17 of Article XVI of the California Constitution and the boards findings adopted in support of that determination.
(e)Nothing in this section shall require a board to take action as described in this section unless the board determines in good faith that the action described in this section is consistent with the fiduciary responsibilities of the board described in Section 17 of Article XVI of the California Constitution.
(f)(1)Before an extension of the operation of this section, the board shall, using methods or processes as determined by the board, reevaluate the merit of continuing the prescribed divestment action, including, but not limited to, the financial effects of the divestment action on the fiduciary responsibilities of the board pursuant to Section 17 of Article XVI of the California Constitution.
(2)On or before January 1, 2024, the board shall submit a report to the Legislature with the information described in paragraph (1) on the merit of continuing the prescribed divestment action.
(3)A report submitted pursuant to this subdivision shall be submitted in compliance with Section 9795.
(g)This section shall be repealed on the earlier of the following dates:
(1)Upon a determination by the board, the Department of State, the Congress of the United States, or other appropriate federal agency, that the government of Turkey has officially acknowledged its responsibility for the Armenian Genocide.
(2)January 1, 2025.
SEC. 3.Section 16642 of the Government Code is amended to read:16642.(a)Present, future, and former board members of the Public Employees Retirement System or the State Teachers Retirement System, jointly and individually, state officers and employees, research firms described in subdivision (d) of Section 7513.6, and investment managers under contract with the Public Employees Retirement System or the State Teachers Retirement System shall be indemnified from the General Fund and held harmless by the State of California from all claims, demands, suits, actions, damages, judgments, costs, charges, and expenses, including court costs and attorneys fees, and against all liability, losses, and damages of any nature whatsoever that these present, future, or former board members, officers, employees, research firms as described in subdivision (d) of Section 7513.6, or contract investment managers shall or may at any time sustain by reason of any decision to restrict, reduce, or eliminate investments pursuant to Sections 7513.6, 7513.7, 7513.74, and 7513.75.
(b)This section shall remain in effect only until Section 7513.74 is repealed, and as of that date is repealed.
SEC. 4.Section 16642 is added to the Government Code, to read:16642.(a)Present, future, and former board members of the Public Employees Retirement System or the State Teachers Retirement System, jointly and individually, state officers and employees, research firms described in subdivision (d) of Section 7513.6, and investment managers under contract with the Public Employees Retirement System or the State Teachers Retirement System shall be indemnified from the General Fund and held harmless by the State of California from all claims, demands, suits, actions, damages, judgments, costs, charges, and expenses, including court costs and attorneys fees, and against all liability, losses, and damages of any nature whatsoever that these present, future, or former board members, officers, employees, research firms as described in subdivision (d) of Section 7513.6, or contract investment managers shall or may at any time sustain by reason of any decision to restrict, reduce, or eliminate investments pursuant to Sections 7513.6, 7513.7, and 7513.75.
(b)This section shall become operative upon the repeal of Section 7513.74.
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Oct 2, 2019 | Chaptered by Secretary of State - Chapter 459, Statutes of 2019. |
| Oct 2, 2019 | Approved by the Governor. |
| Sep 25, 2019 | Enrolled and presented to the Governor at 3:30 p.m. |
| Sep 13, 2019 | Senate amendments concurred in. To Engrossing and Enrolling. |
| Sep 11, 2019 | In Assembly. Concurrence in Senate amendments pending. |
| Sep 11, 2019 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Assembly. |
| Sep 3, 2019 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| Aug 30, 2019 | From committee: Amend, and do pass as amended. (Ayes 7. Noes 0.) (August 30). |
| Aug 12, 2019 | In committee: Referred to APPR. suspense file. |
| Jul 3, 2019 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 8. Noes 0.) (July 2). Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Jun 27, 2019 | Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on JUD. |
| Jun 26, 2019 | From committee: Amend, and do pass as amended and re-refer to Com. on JUD. (Ayes 5. Noes 0.) (June 26). |
| Jun 6, 2019 | Referred to Coms. on L., P.E. & R. and JUD. |
| May 24, 2019 | In Senate. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. |
| May 23, 2019 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Senate. |
| May 20, 2019 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| May 16, 2019 | Coauthors revised. |
| Apr 24, 2019 | In committee: Set, first hearing. Referred to APPR. suspense file. |
| Apr 8, 2019 | Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Apr 4, 2019 | Read second time and amended. |
| Apr 3, 2019 | From committee: Amend, and do pass as amended and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 4. Noes 2.) (April 3). |
| Mar 27, 2019 | In committee: Set, first hearing. Hearing canceled at the request of author. |
| Mar 19, 2019 | Re-referred to Com. on P.E. & R. |
| Mar 18, 2019 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to Com. on P.E. & R. Read second time and amended. |
| Mar 14, 2019 | Referred to Com. on P.E. & R. |
| Feb 25, 2019 | Read first time. |
| Feb 23, 2019 | From printer. May be heard in committee March 25. |
| Feb 22, 2019 | Introduced. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sep 13, 2019 | AB 1320 Nazarian Concurrence in Senate Amendments | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| Sep 11, 2019 | Assembly 3rd Reading AB1320 Nazarian et al. By Borgeas | Senate Floor |
Passed |
|
| Aug 30, 2019 | Do pass as amended | Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Aug 12, 2019 | Placed on suspense file | Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Jul 2, 2019 | Do pass, but first be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Senate Standing Committee on Judiciary |
Passed |
|
| Jun 26, 2019 | Do pass as amended, but first amend, and re-refer to the Committee on [Judiciary] | Senate Standing Committee on Labor, Public Employment and Retirement |
Passed |
|
| May 23, 2019 | AB 1320 Nazarian Assembly Third Reading | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| May 16, 2019 | Do pass. | Assembly Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Apr 3, 2019 | Do pass as amended and be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Assembly Standing Committee on Public Employment and Retirement |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
CONCURRENCE IN SENATE AMENDMENTS
CSA1 Bill Id:AB 1320
Author:(Nazarian, et al.)
As Amended Ver:August 30, 2019
Majority vote
SUMMARY:
Prohibits the California Public Employees' Retirement System (CalPERS) and the California State Teachers' Retirement System (CalSTRS) from investing in an investment vehicle issued or owned by the government of Turkey, if the federal government of the United States (U.S.) imposes sanctions on the government of Turkey for failing to officially acknowledge its responsibility for the Armenian Genocide, among other provisions.
The Senate Amendments:
- Make changes to the legislative findings and declarations for these purposes.
- Modify the definition of the "government of Turkey" to specifically mean the government of Turkey or its instrumentalities or political subdivisions, and the definition of "Turkey" to specifically mean the Republic of Turkey.
- Clarify that divestment only applies to investment vehicles issued or owned by the government of Turkey.
- Include the CalPERS and CalSTRS boards among the entities that can make a determination that the government of Turkey has officially acknowledged its responsibility for the Armenian Genocide relating to repeal of its provisions.
- Make minor, clarifying and technical changes.
COMMENTS:
Please see the policy committee analysis for a full discussion of this bill.
According to the Author:
"The purpose of this bill is to achieve a policy objective of not financially rewarding and investing in governments which routinely violate human rights or which promote policies contrary to our own. Enactment of this bill would make it clear that California will stand on principle and make our state's investment choices consistent with our values and policies, such as Armenian Genocide recognition."
Arguments in Support:
Generally, supporters express sentiments similar to those of the author.
Arguments in Opposition:
CalPERS states that divestment invariably harms investment performance such as by causing transaction costs, compromising investment strategies and reducing portfolio. Instead, CalPERS prefers constructive engagement as a means of effecting change.
CalSTRS states that restrictions on investments could impair the board's ability to exercise its fiduciary obligation to act exclusively for the benefit of its members and beneficiaries because it reduces diversification and alters the investment strategy adopted by the board, which is especially concerning as investment returns affect CalSTRS' trajectory toward full funding.
Opponents representing local governments generally express that divestment will harm the investment performance of CalPERS which is currently underfunded in relation to paying promised retirement benefits, and that costs of negative investment performance, such as divestment, are passed on to public employers that are already financially burdened.
FISCAL COMMENTS:
According to the Senate Appropriations Committee, CalSTRS indicates that it would incur minor costs to monitor whether federal sanctions have been enacted. If this happens, CalSTRS would incur first-year costs of $100,000, and $43,200 annually thereafter, resulting from 1) transaction costs for liquidating securities; and, 2) additional costs for research services. CalPERS would also incur minor costs to monitor whether federal sanctions have been enacted. If federal sanctions are enacted, CalPERS indicates that its one-time divestment costs would depend on the number of its holdings that meet the bill's criteria, and could extend into the millions of dollars.
The bill would result in an unknown impact on public retirement system portfolios if federal sanctions against Turkey are enacted. CalSTRS and CalPERS may incur opportunity costs if alternative investments do not generate greater investment returns than divested securities would have generated. All of the fiscal impacts described above would only occur upon passage of a federal law imposing sanctions on Turkey for failure to acknowledge the Armenian Genocide. Those fiscal impacts would cease upon a federal determination that the Government of Turkey has officially acknowledged its responsibility for the Armenian Genocide.
VOTES:
ASM PUBLIC EMPLOYMENT AND RETIREMENT: 4-2-1
YES: Rodriguez, Voepel, Cervantes, Cooley
NO: Cooper, O'Donnell
ABS, ABST OR NV: Fong
ASM APPROPRIATIONS: 14-0-4
YES: Gonzalez, Bloom, Bonta, Brough, Calderon, Carrillo, Chau, Eggman, Gabriel, Eduardo Garcia, Maienschein, Petrie-Norris, Quirk, Robert Rivas
ABS, ABST OR NV: Bigelow, Diep, Fong, Obernolte
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 63-0-17
YES: Aguiar-Curry, Arambula, Berman, Bloom, Boerner Horvath, Bonta, Brough, Burke, Calderon, Carrillo, Cervantes, Chau, Chen, Chiu, Chu, Cunningham, Diep, Eggman, Flora, Frazier, Friedman, Gabriel, Gallagher, Cristina Garcia, Gipson, Gloria, Gonzalez, Gray, Holden, Irwin, Jones-Sawyer, Kalra, Kamlager-Dove, Lackey, Levine, Limón, Low, Maienschein, Mayes, McCarty, Medina, Mullin, Muratsuchi, Nazarian, Patterson, Petrie-Norris, Quirk, Quirk‑Silva, Ramos, Reyes, Luz Rivas, Robert Rivas, Blanca Rubio, Salas, Santiago, Mark Stone, Ting, Voepel, Waldron, Weber, Wicks, Wood, Rendon
ABS, ABST OR NV: Bauer-Kahan, Bigelow, Choi, Cooley, Cooper, Dahle, Daly, Fong, Eduardo Garcia, Grayson, Kiley, Mathis, Melendez, O'Donnell, Obernolte, Rodriguez, Smith
SENATE FLOOR: 33-0-7
YES: Allen, Archuleta, Atkins, Bates, Beall, Borgeas, Bradford, Chang, Dahle, Dodd, Durazo, Galgiani, Glazer, Lena Gonzalez, Grove, Hill, Hueso, Hurtado, Jones, Leyva, McGuire, Mitchell, Monning, Morrell, Nielsen, Pan, Portantino, Rubio, Skinner, Stern, Umberg, Wiener, Wilk
ABS, ABST OR NV: Caballero, Hertzberg, Jackson, Moorlach, Roth, Stone, Wieckowski
UPDATED:
VERSION: August 30, 2019
CONSULTANT: Michael Bolden / P.E. & R. / (916) 319-3957 FN: 0002412
Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | AB 1320 |
THIRD READING
Bill No: AB 1320
Author: Nazarian (D), Friedman (D) and Gabriel (D), et al.
Amended: 8/30/19 in Senate
SENATE LABOR, PUB. EMP. & RET. COMMITTEE: 5-0, 6/26/19
AYES: Hill, Morrell, Jackson, Mitchell, Pan
SENATE JUDICIARY COMMITTEE: 8-0, 7/2/19
AYES: Jackson, Borgeas, Durazo, Lena Gonzalez, Jones, Monning, Stern, Umberg
NO VOTE RECORDED: Wieckowski
SENATE APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE: 7-0, 8/30/19
AYES: Portantino, Bates, Bradford, Durazo, Hill, Jones, Wieckowski
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 63-0, 5/23/19 - See last page for vote
SUBJECT: Public employee retirement systems: prohibited investments: Turkey
DIGEST:
This bill prohibits, upon passage of a federal law imposing sanctions on the government of Turkey for failure to officially acknowledge its responsibility for the Armenian Genocide, the California Public Employees' Retirement System (CalPERS) and the California State Teachers' Retirement System (CalSTRS) from making or renewing investments in any investment vehicle owned or issued by the government of Turkey and requires the two pension systems to liquidate those specified investments within 18 months of the federal law’s passage.
Existing law:
- Provides, pursuant to California Constitution, that the boards of California's public retirement systems have "plenary authority and fiduciary responsibility for [the] investment of monies and administration of the system." (Cal. Const., art. XVI, § 17)
- Provides under the California Constitution that "the members of the retirement board of a public pension or retirement system shall discharge their duties with respect to the system solely in the interest of, and for the exclusive purposes of providing benefits to, participants and their beneficiaries, minimizing employer contributions thereto, and defraying reasonable expenses of administrating the system…[and] the board shall diversify the investments of the system so as to minimize the risk of loss and to maximize the rate of return unless under the circumstances it is clearly prudent to do so." (Cal. Const., art. XVI, § 17)
- Provides that the Legislature retains its authority to, by statute, "continue to prohibit certain investments by a retirement board where it is in the public interest to do so, and provided that the prohibition satisfies the standards of fiduciary care and loyalty required of a retirement board pursuant to this section." (Cal. Const., art. XVI, § 17)
- Prohibits CalPERS and CalSTRS, under previous legislative mandates, from making or holding certain investments in Iran, Sudan, in businesses discriminating against Israel related to the Arab Boycott of Israel, and in thermal coal companies. (Government Code §7513.6 et seq.)
This bill:
- Makes several findings and declarations related to the Armenian Genocide, Turkey’s ongoing efforts to erase Armenian culture, the number of Armenian Americans who are California residents, and other related findings and declarations.
- Provides that the Legislature finds and declares that divesting funds held in trust by CalPERS and CalSTRS to pay for public employees’ retirement benefits would ensure that the State of California is in no way complicit in the continued denial of the Armenian Genocide.
- Defines the following terms as follows:
- “Board” means the Board of Administration of CalPERS or CalSTRS, as applicable;
- “Government of Turkey” means the government of Turkey or its instrumentalities or political subdivisions;
- “Public employee retirement funds” means the Public Employees’ Retirement Fund described in Section 20062 of the Government Code and the Teachers’ Retirement Fund described in Section 22167 of the Education Code; and
- “Turkey” means the Republic of Turkey.
- Provides that upon passage of a federal law by both the United States House of Representatives and the United States Senate, and signed by the President of the Unites States, imposing sanctions on the government of Turkey for failure to officially acknowledge its responsibility for the Armenian Genocide, the board shall not make additional or new investments or renew existing investments of public employee retirement funds in any investment vehicle in Turkey that meets either of the following criteria:
- The investment vehicle is issued by the government of Turkey; or
- The investment vehicle is owned by the government of Turkey.
- Provides that the board shall liquidate investments, as specified within 18 months of the passage of the federal law described above, that imposes sanctions on the government of Turkey for failure to officially acknowledge its responsibility for the Armenian Genocide.
- Requires the board to, within one year of the passage of the federal law described above, file a report with the Legislature that includes: a list of investment vehicles in the government of Turkey of which the board has liquidated its investments; and a list of investment vehicles in the government of Turkey of which the board has not liquidated its investments, as specified.
- Provides that a board is not required to take action unless the board determines in good faith that the action is consistent with the fiduciary responsibilities of the board described in Section 17 of Article XVI of the California Constitution.
- Provides that before an extension of the operation of this section, the board shall, using methods or process as determined by the board, reevaluate the merit of continuing the prescribed divestment action, including, but not limited to, the financial effects of the divestment action on the fiduciary responsibilities of the board pursuant to Section 17 of Article XVI of the California Constitution. On or before January 1, 2024, the board shall submit a report to the Legislature with this information and submit it, as specified.
- States that shall be repealed on the earlier of the following dates: January 1, 2025; or upon a determination by either the Department of State or the Congress of the United States, or other appropriate federal agency, that the government of Turkey has officially acknowledged its responsibility for the Armenian Genocide.
- Provides that present, future, and former board members of CalPERS or CalSTRS, jointly and individually, state officers and employees, research firms described in subdivision (d) of Section 7513.6, and investment managers under contract with CALPERS or the CALSTRS shall be indemnified from the General Fund and held harmless by the State of California from all claims, demands, suits, actions, damages, judgments, costs, charges, and expenses, including court costs and attorney’s fees, and against all liability, losses, and damages of any nature whatsoever that these present, future, or former board members, officers, employees, research firms as described in subdivision (d) of Section 7513.6, or contract investment managers shall or may at any time sustain by reason of any decision to restrict, reduce, or eliminate investments pursuant to the above provisions regarding divestment from Turkey.
- Repeals, for consistency, this bill’s indemnity provision (see #10 above) upon repeal of the bill’s divestment provisions. This bill’s indemnity provision adds the Turkish investment divestment mandate to the existing indemnity provision for other, current divestment mandates.
- Restores existing law’s indemnity provision for current divestment mandates upon repeal of this bill’s divestment mandate.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: Yes Local: No
According to the Senate Appropriations Committee:
- CalSTRS indicates that it would incur minor costs to monitor whether federal sanctions have been enacted. If this happens, CalSTRS would incur first-year costs of $100,000, and $43,200 annually thereafter, resulting from (1) transaction costs for liquidating securities, and (2) additional costs for research services.
- CalPERS would also incur minor costs to monitor whether federal sanctions have been enacted. If federal sanctions are enacted, CalPERS indicates that its one-time divestment costs would depend on the number of its holdings that meet the bill’s criteria, and could extend into the millions of dollars.
- This bill would result in an unknown impact on public retirement system portfolios if federal sanctions against Turkey are enacted. CalSTRS and CalPERS may incur opportunity costs if alternative investments do not generate greater investment returns than divested securities would have generated.
- All of the fiscal impacts described above would only occur upon passage of a federal law imposing sanctions on Turkey for failure to acknowledge the Armenian Genocide. Those fiscal impacts would cease upon a federal determination that the Government of Turkey has officially acknowledged its responsibility for the Armenian Genocide.
Armenian Assembly of America
Armenian Catholic Eparchy of Our Lady of Nareg in the USA and Canada
Armenian Democratic Liberal Party
Armenian Evangelical Union of North America
Armenian National Committee of America – Western Region
Armenian Rights Council of America
Los Angeles City Councilmember, Paul Krekorian
Open Wounds
OPPOSITION: (Verified 8/30/19)
Association of Turkish Americans of Southern California
California Police Chiefs Association
California Public Employees’ Retirement System
California Retired Teachers Association
California Special Districts Association
California State Association of Counties
California State Teachers’ Retirement System
City of Rancho Cucamonga
League of California Cities
Peace Officers’ Research Association of California
Republic of Turkey
School Employers Association of California
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: According to the Armenian Assembly of America, “The purpose of AB 1320 is to craft a sensible policy, which refrains from financially rewarding and investing in foreign governments that undermine democracy and trample upon basic human and civil rights of its citizens. The approval of this bill would send a clear signal to residents of the Golden State that California values investment options that are in accordance with its legislative polices and principles in protecting and upholding universal human and civil rights, the rule of law, and the freedom of expression within the state and throughout the globe.”
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION: According to a coalition of the California Special Districts Association, the California State Association of Counties, and the League of California Cities, ‘CalPERS staff has previously noted in their analysis of divestment legislation that “every dollar in investment returns that is foregone, or expended in unnecessary transaction costs and fees, must be made up for in employer and employee contributions.’ Therefore, AB 1320 could be expected to contribute to an increased burden on employees and employers through increased contribution rates, and potentially impair CalPERS’ ability to deliver promised benefit payments. Given the significant rate increases our districts are currently facing, it would be extremely detrimental to add any unnecessary additional financial burdens on them at this time.”
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 63-0, 5/23/19
AYES: Aguiar-Curry, Arambula, Berman, Bloom, Boerner Horvath, Bonta, Brough, Burke, Calderon, Carrillo, Cervantes, Chau, Chen, Chiu, Chu, Cunningham, Diep, Eggman, Flora, Frazier, Friedman, Gabriel, Gallagher, Cristina Garcia, Gipson, Gloria, Gonzalez, Gray, Holden, Irwin, Jones-Sawyer, Kalra, Kamlager-Dove, Lackey, Levine, Limón, Low, Maienschein, Mayes, McCarty, Medina, Mullin, Muratsuchi, Nazarian, Patterson, Petrie-Norris, Quirk, Quirk-Silva, Ramos, Reyes, Luz Rivas, Robert Rivas, Blanca Rubio, Salas, Santiago, Mark Stone, Ting, Voepel, Waldron, Weber, Wicks, Wood, Rendon
NO VOTE RECORDED: Bauer-Kahan, Bigelow, Choi, Cooley, Cooper, Dahle, Daly, Fong, Eduardo Garcia, Grayson, Kiley, Mathis, Melendez, Obernolte, O'Donnell, Rodriguez, Smith
Prepared by: Glenn Miles / L., P.E. & R. / (916) 651-1556
9/3/19 11:30:51
**** END ****
SENATE COMMITTEE ON
Senator Anthony Portantino, Chair
2019 - 2020 Regular Session
AB 1320 (Nazarian) - Public employee retirement systems: prohibited investments: Turkey
Version: | Policy Vote: |
Urgency: | Mandate: |
Hearing Date: | Consultant: |
Bill Summary:
AB 1320 would (1) prohibit the California Public Employees Retirement System (CalPERS) and the State Teachers’ Retirement System (STRS) from making additional, new investments, or renew existing investments of public employee retirement funds in any investment issued, owned, controlled, or managed by the government of Turkey, and (2) require the pension funds to divest from Turkish government investments upon passage of a Federal Law sanctioning Turkey for failing to acknowledge the Armenian Genocide.
*********** ANALYSIS ADDENDUM – SUSPENSE FILE ***********
The following information is revised to reflect amendments
adopted by the committee on August 30, 2019
Fiscal Impact:
- CalSTRS indicates that it would incur minor costs to monitor whether federal sanctions have been enacted. If this happens, CalSTRS would incur first-year costs of $100,000, and $43,200 annually thereafter, resulting from (1) transaction costs for liquidating securities, and (2) additional costs for research services.
- CalPERS would also incur minor costs to monitor whether federal sanctions have been enacted. If federal sanctions are enacted, CalPERS indicates that its one-time divestment costs would depend on the number of its holdings that meet the bill’s criteria, and could extend into the millions of dollars.
- The bill would result in an unknown impact on public retirement system portfolios if federal sanctions against Turkey are enacted. CalSTRS and CalPERS may incur opportunity costs if alternative investments do not generate greater investment returns than divested securities would have generated.
- All of the fiscal impacts described above would only occur upon passage of a federal law imposing sanctions on Turkey for failure to acknowledge the Armenian Genocide. Those fiscal impacts would cease upon a federal determination that the Government of Turkey has officially acknowledged its responsibility for the Armenian Genocide.
Committee Amendments:
Add a coauthor and make technical changes.
-- END --
SENATE COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Senator Anthony Portantino, Chair
2019 - 2020 Regular Session
AB 1320 (Nazarian) - Public employee retirement systems: prohibited investments: Turkey
Version: June 27, 2019 | Policy Vote: L., P.E. & R. 5 - 0, JUD. 8 - 0 |
Urgency: No | Mandate: No |
Hearing Date: August 12, 2019 | Consultant: Robert Ingenito |
Bill Summary:
AB 1320 would (1) prohibit the California Public Employees Retirement System (CalPERS) and the State Teachers’ Retirement System (STRS) from making additional, new investments, or renew existing investments of public employee retirement funds in any investment issued, owned, controlled, or managed by the government of Turkey, and (2) require the pension funds to divest from Turkish government investments upon passage of a Federal Law sanctioning Turkey for failing to acknowledge the Armenian Genocide.
Fiscal Impact:
- CalSTRS indicates that it would incur minor costs to monitor whether federal sanctions have been enacted. If this happens, CalSTRS would incur first-year costs of $100,000, and $43,200 annually thereafter, resulting from (1) transaction costs for liquidating securities, and (2) additional costs for research services.
- CalPERS would also incur minor costs to monitor whether federal sanctions have been enacted. If federal sanctions are enacted, CalPERS indicates that its one-time divestment costs would depend on the number of its holdings that meet the bill’s criteria, and could extend into the millions of dollars.
- The bill would result in an unknown impact on public retirement system portfolios if federal sanctions against Turkey are enacted. CalSTRS and CalPERS may incur opportunity costs if alternative investments do not generate greater investment returns than divested securities would have generated.
- All of the fiscal impacts described above would only occur upon passage of a federal law imposing sanctions on Turkey for failure to acknowledge the Armenian Genocide. Those fiscal impacts would cease upon a federal determination that the Government of Turkey has officially acknowledged its responsibility for the Armenian Genocide
Background:
Under existing provisions of Section 17 of Article XVI of the California Constitution, as amended by Proposition 162 of 1992, the CalSTRS board and CalPERS board have plenary authority and fiduciary responsibility over the investment of retirement plan assets and are required to discharge their duties solely in the interests of the members and beneficiaries for the exclusive purpose of providing benefits. The boards must invest the assets of the plan with care, skill and diligence of a prudent person engaged in a similar enterprise so as to maximize the investments and minimize the risk of loss. The Constitution does allow the Legislature by statute to prohibit certain investments by a retirement board when it is in the public interest to do so and provided the prohibition satisfies the standards of fiduciary care and loyalty required of the retirement board.
Other measures have been enacted by the Legislature to prohibit certain investments by public pension funds. For instance, AB 221 (Anderson, Chapter 671, Statutes of 2007) prohibits CalPERS and CalSTRS from investing in companies that have specified energy or defense-related operations in Iran, AB 2941 (Koretz, Chapter 442, Statutes of 2006) prohibits CalPERS and CalSTRS from investing public employee retirement funds in a company with business operations in the Sudan, as specified, and SB 185 (De Leon, Chapter 605, Statutes of 2015) prohibits CalPERS and CalSTRS from investing public employee retirement funds in thermal coal companies.
Proposed Law:
This bill would, among other things, do the following:
- Provide that upon passage of a federal law by both the United States House of Representatives and the United States Senate, and signed by the President of the Unites States, imposing sanctions on the government of Turkey for failure to officially acknowledge its responsibility for the Armenian Genocide, CalPERS and STRS shall not make additional or new investments or renew existing investments of public employee retirement funds in any investment vehicle in Turkey that meets either of the following criteria: (1) the investment vehicle is issued by the government of Turkey, (2) or the investment vehicle is owned by the government of Turkey.
- Provide that the CalPERS and STRS shall liquidate investments, as specified within 18 months of the passage of the federal law described above, that imposes sanctions on the government of Turkey for failure to officially acknowledge its responsibility for the Armenian Genocide.
- Require CalPERS and STRS to, within one year of the passage of the federal law described above, file a report with the Legislature that includes specified information.
- Provide that CalPERS and STRS are not required to take action unless the board determines in good faith that the action is consistent with the fiduciary responsibilities of the board described in Section 17 of Article XVI of the California Constitution.
- Provide that its provisions shall be repealed on the earlier of the following dates: January 1, 2025; or upon a determination by either the Department of State or the Congress of the United States, or other appropriate federal agency, that the government of Turkey has officially acknowledged its responsibility for the Armenian Genocide.
- Indemnify from the state General Fund and hold harmless by the state, present, future, and former board members, jointly and individually, and their respective agents from personal liability for losses sustained as a result of any decision to restrict, reduce, or eliminate investments.
Related Legislation:
AB 1597 (Nazarian, 2017) was substantially similar to this bill. It was vetoed by the Governor.
Staff Comments:
CalSTRS currently has $0.12 million invested in debt securities issued by the government of Turkey; additionally, its global equities and currency investments subject to possible divestment have a potential combined market value of up to $2.4 million. CalPERS data indicates that its holdings of Turkish government-controlled securities amount to between $77 million and $350 million.
Both CalPERS and CalSTRS may incur opportunity costs as a result of this bill if suitable alternative investments are unavailable, or if such alternative investments do not provide an investment return that meets or exceeds those of the divested securities. Under these scenarios, the potential result would be (1) an increase the pension systems’ unfunded liabilities, and (2) an increase in the state pension contributions. A 2015 analysis by Wilshire Associates found that previous divestment efforts have collectively reduced the present value of the CalPERS portfolio by up to an estimated $8.3 billion.
-- END --
Senator Hannah-Beth Jackson, Chair
2019-2020 Regular Session
Bill No: AB 1320 (Author:Nazarian)
Version: June 27, 2019
Hearing Date: July 2, 2019
Fiscal: Yes
Urgency: No
Consultant: MEC
SUBJECT
Public employee retirement systems: prohibited investments: Turkey
DIGEST
This bill provides that the California Public Employees’ Retirement System (PERS) and State Teachers’ Retirement System (STRS) shall not make additional or new investments or renew existing investments of public employee retirement funds in any investment vehicle in the government of Turkey, that meets specified criteria, upon passage of a federal law imposing sanctions on the government of Turkey for failure to officially acknowledge its responsibility for the Armenian Genocide.
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
California recognizes the Armenian Genocide and provides that April 24 of each year shall be the California Day of Remembrance of the Armenian Genocide. The period beginning on the Sunday before that day through the following Sunday shall be the days of remembrance in this state, and shall annually be so proclaimed by the Governor. The recognition is in memory of the 1.5 million victims who were subjected to torture, starvation, and murder, including death marches into the Syrian Desert, by the rulers of the Ottoman Empire and the exile of more than 500,000 innocent people during the period from 1915 to 1923 and in honor of the survivors of those crimes against humanity. (Govt. Code § 6720.) As of 2019, 31 national governments as well as 49 of 50 U.S. state governments recognize the Armenian Genocide.
The Legislature has passed bills to require PERS and STRS to divest from South Africa during Apartheid, from Sudan, from Iran, and from coal. This bill makes various findings and declarations including that the government of Turkey has engaged and continues to engage in an ongoing campaign of genocide denial and historical revisionism by refusing to acknowledge its responsibility for the Armenian Genocide, refusing to compensate its victims, and actively pursuing a well-funded political lobbying campaign throughout the United States, including in California, to rewrite history and defeat legislation recognizing the Armenian Genocide.
The aim of this legislation is to ensure that California’s investment priorities match California’s longstanding position of encouraging Turkey to recognize the Armenian Genocide and work towards justice for the victims. The bill accomplishes this by establishing a path whereby California public pension plans cease investing in the government of Turkey and liquidate investments in the government of Turkey after a federal law is passed imposing sanctions on the government of Turkey for failure to officially acknowledge its responsibility for the Armenian Genocide.
This bill passed out of the Senate Labor, Public Employment and Retirement Committee on a vote of 5 to 0.
PROPOSED CHANGES TO THE LAW
Existing law:
- Provides that the Legislature encourages all state and local professional development activities to provide teachers with content background and resources to assist them in teaching about civil rights, human rights violations, genocide, slavery, the Armenian Genocide, and the Holocaust. (Educ. Code § 51226.3(c).)
- Provides, for purposes of the above, “Armenian Genocide” means the torture, starvation, and murder of 1,500,000 Armenians, which included death marches into the Syrian Desert, by the rulers of the Ottoman Turkish Empire and the exile of more than 500,000 innocent people during the period from 1915 to 1923. (Educ. Code § 51226.3(i).)
- Provides that April 24 of each year shall be the “California Day of Remembrance of the Armenian Genocide,” and the period beginning on the Sunday before that day through the following Sunday shall be the days of remembrance in this state, and shall annually be so proclaimed by the Governor, in memory of the 1.5 million victims who were subjected to torture, starvation, and murder, including death marches into the Syrian Desert, by the rulers of the Ottoman Turkish Empire and the exile of more than 500,000 innocent people during the period from 1915 to 1923, inclusive, and in honor of the survivors of those crimes against humanity. (Gov. Code § 6720.)
- Grants the retirement board of a public employee retirement system plenary authority and fiduciary responsibility for investment of moneys and administration of the retirement fund and system. (Cal. Const., art. XVI, § 17.)
- Provides that the Legislature may by statute continue to prohibit certain investments by a retirement board where it is in the public interest to do so, and provided that the prohibition satisfies the standards of fiduciary care and loyalty required of a retirement board pursuant to the Constitution. (Cal. Const., art. XVI, § 17 (g).)
- Prohibits the retirement boards from making investments in certain countries, such as Sudan and Iran, and in thermal coal companies, as specified, subject to the boards’ plenary authority and fiduciary responsibility for investment of moneys and administration of the systems. (Gov. Code § 7513.6, § 7513.7, § 7513.75.)
This bill:
- Provides that the Legislature finds and declares that the State of California has officially recognized the Armenian Genocide each year for decades and has repeatedly urged the Republic of Turkey to acknowledge the facts of the Armenian Genocide and work toward a just resolution, honor its obligations under international treaties and human rights laws, end all forms of religious discrimination and persecution, and return Christian church properties to their rightful owners.
- Provides that the Legislature finds and declares that genocide is defined by the United Nations as an act “committed with intent to destroy, in whole or in part, a national, ethnical, racial or religious group.”
- Provides that the Legislature finds and declares that genocide denial is widely viewed as among the final stages of genocide and serves to perpetuate the effects of genocide even after the active phases of extermination, massacres, forced marches, and deportation have ended.
- Provides that the Legislature finds and declares that the government of Turkey has engaged and continues to engage in an ongoing campaign of genocide denial and historical revisionism by refusing to acknowledge its responsibility for the Armenian Genocide, refusing to compensate its victims, and actively pursuing a well-funded political lobbying campaign throughout the United States, including in California, to rewrite history and defeat legislation recognizing the Armenian Genocide.
- Provides that the Legislature finds and declares that the government of Turkey has engaged, and continues to engage, in efforts to effect Armenian cultural erasure since the founding of the Republic of Turkey, including, but not limited to, ethnic cleansings and the destruction of sacred Armenian religious sites.
- Provides that the Legislature finds and declares that reference in Turkey by any scholar, journalist, or other person to the massacre and deportation of Armenians in 1915 to 1923, inclusive, as genocide can be criminally prosecuted under Article 301 of the Turkish Penal Code.
- Provides that the Legislature finds and declares that the State of California is home to the largest Armenian American population in the United States, and Armenians living in California, most of whom are direct descendants of the survivors of the Armenian Genocide, have enriched our state through their leadership and contributions in business, agriculture, academia, government, and the arts, yet continue to suffer the effects of the continued denial campaign by the government of Turkey.
- Provides that the Legislature finds and declares that the State of California, as the world’s fifth largest economy as of February 2019, and in accordance with principles of human rights and justice, has taken the lead in adopting legislation to divest from South Africa for its policy of apartheid, Sudan for its genocide in Darfur, and Iran for its support of international terrorism, imposing economic consequences upon regimes that engage in conduct and policy that violate human rights or constitute crimes against humanity.
- Provides that the Legislature finds and declares that it is the government of Turkey, not the people of Turkey, that is responsible for Turkey’s continued egregious violations of human rights and active pursuit of genocide denial, cultural erasure, and historical revisionism.
- Provides that the Legislature finds and declares that investment in the Republic of Turkey enables its government to continue to deny justice to the Armenian people.
- Provides that the Legislature finds and declares that divesting funds held in trust by PERS and the STRS to pay for public employees’ retirement benefits would ensure that the State of California is in no way complicit in the continued denial of the Armenian Genocide by the government of Turkey and would encourage said government to acknowledge the Armenian Genocide and to reach a fair and just resolution of reparations for the survivors of the Armenian Genocide.
- Defines the following terms as follows:
- “Board” means the Board of Administration of PERS or the STRS Teachers’ Retirement Board, as applicable;
- “Government of Turkey” means the government of Turkey or its instrumentalities or political subdivisions;
- “Public employee retirement funds” means the Public Employees’ Retirement Fund described in Section 20062 and the Teachers’ Retirement Fund described in Section 22167 of the Education Code; and
- “Turkey” means the Republic of Turkey.
- Provides that upon passage of a federal law by both the United States House of Representatives and the United States Senate, and signed by the President of the Unites States, imposing sanctions on the government of Turkey for failure to officially acknowledge its responsibility for the Armenian Genocide, the board shall not make additional or new investments or renew existing investments of public employee retirement funds in any investment vehicle in Turkey that meets either of the following criteria:
- the investment vehicle is issued by the government of Turkey; or
- the investment vehicle is owned by the government of Turkey.
- Provides that the board shall liquidate investments, as specified within 18 months of the passage of the federal law described above, that imposes sanctions on the government of Turkey for failure to officially acknowledge its responsibility for the Armenian Genocide.
- Requires the board to, within one year of the passage of the federal law described above, file a report with the Legislature that includes: a list of investment vehicles in the government of Turkey of which the board has liquidated its investments; and a list of investment vehicles in the government of Turkey of which the board has not liquidated its investments, as specified.
- Provides that a board is not required to take action unless the board determines in good faith that the action is consistent with the fiduciary responsibilities of the board described in Section 17 of Article XVI of the California Constitution.
- Provides that before an extension of the operation of this section, the board shall, using methods or process as determined by the board, reevaluate the merit of continuing the prescribed divestment action, including, but not limited to, the financial effects of the divestment action on the fiduciary responsibilities of the board pursuant to Section 17 of Article XVI of the California Constitution. On or before January 1, 2024, the board shall submit a report to the Legislature with this information and submit it, as specified.
- Shall be repealed on the earlier of the following dates: January 1, 2025; or upon a determination by either the Department of State or the Congress of the United States, or other appropriate federal agency, that the government of Turkey has officially acknowledged its responsibility for the Armenian Genocide.
- Provides that present, future, and former board members of PERS or STRS, jointly and individually, state officers and employees, research firms described in subdivision (d) of Section 7513.6, and investment managers under contract with PERS or the STRS shall be indemnified from the General Fund and held harmless by the State of California from all claims, demands, suits, actions, damages, judgments, costs, charges, and expenses, including court costs and attorney’s fees, and against all liability, losses, and damages of any nature whatsoever that these present, future, or former board members, officers, employees, research firms as described in subdivision (d) of Section 7513.6, or contract investment managers shall or may at any time sustain by reason of any decision to restrict, reduce, or eliminate investments pursuant to the above provisions regarding divestment from Turkey.
COMMENTS
- Stated need for the bill
According to the author:
California has a clear policy of Armenian Genocide recognition, as demonstrated by decades of legislative resolutions and gubernatorial proclamations. Contrary to our state’s policy, the Turkish government fosters the teaching of genocide denial in its public schools, and continues to discriminate against Armenians and other minorities. Despite these facts, our state’s pension systems – CalPERS and CalSTRS – have invested in Turkish government holdings, thereby indirectly subsidizing Turkish denial of the Genocide.
The purpose of this bill is to achieve a policy objective of not financially rewarding and investing in governments which routinely violate human rights or which promote policies contrary to our own. Enactment of this bill would make it clear that California will stand on principle and make our state’s investment choices consistent with our values and policies, such as Armenian Genocide recognition.
The Armenian Assembly of America, in support of the bill, highlights the following with regard to California’s history of commemorating the Armenian Genocide and divestment:
Throughout the past five decades, California has been an exemplar to fellow states with respect to the adoption of resolutions and proclamations commemorating the Armenian Genocide, in addition to the passage of legislation mandating the teaching of the genocide in statewide public schools, alongside the Holocaust and other modern-era mass atrocities.
[ . . . ]
California demonstrates an exemplary historical record of leading the way in the adoption of divestment legislation. The solid precedential record includes the California State Legislature’s divestment from South Africa, spearheaded by then Governor George Deukmejian and signed slightly prior to the United States Congress’ own divestment legislation vis-à-vis South Africa for the latter’s policy of apartheid. There are also the notable precedents of the California State Legislature divesting from Sudan for its state-sponsored genocide in Darfur, and from Iran for its support to international terrorist organizations.
In support, the Armenian National Committee of America – Western Region writes:
The policy objective of AB 1320 is to prevent financially rewarding and encouraging the government of Turkey, which is notorious for human rights violations. Enactment of this bill would ensure that if sanctions are placed against the government of Turkey by the U.S. federal government, then the State of California will follow suit in taking a principled stance to ensure that our investment choices align with our human rights policies and values. We cannot allow the State of California to indirectly subsidize the Turkish government’s ongoing denial of the Armenian Genocide by enabling it to use our funds to finance its denialist propaganda campaign.
[ . . . ]
California has already been in the forefront of fighting injustices globally by setting the precedent of divesting from South Africa in 1986 in response to the government’s oppressive and discriminatory Apartheid policy, leading the way for our federal government to follow suit. More recently, California divested from Sudan due to the government’s role in the genocide in Darfur.
2. The bill does not run afoul of the California Constitution
The California Constitution provides that the Legislature may by statute continue to prohibit certain investments by a retirement board where it is in the public interest to do so, and provided that the prohibition satisfies the standards of fiduciary care and loyalty required of a retirement board pursuant to the Constitution. (Cal. Const., art. XVI, § 17 (g)). While this bill does authorize the termination of investments of public employee retirement funds in any investment vehicle in the government of Turkey and the divestment from Turkey, this bill also contains a provision that provides that nothing in the bill shall require a board to divest in Turkey unless the board determines in good faith that divesting is consistent with the fiduciary responsibilities of the board described in Section 17 Article XVI of the California Constitution.
3. Opposition
The California State Teachers’ Retirement System, in opposition, writes:
The board’s policy is to oppose legislation that restricts its ability to invest in specific areas because, as described in its divestment policy, such restrictions could impair the board’s ability to exercise its fiduciary obligation to act exclusively for the benefit of the retirement plan members and beneficiaries. Divestment carries the risk of adversely affecting the CalSTRS investment portfolio by reducing diversification and altering the investment strategy adopted by the board. This is especially concerning as investment returns affect the CalSTRS […] on a trajectory toward full funding.
The League of California Cities, California State Association of Counties, and California Special Districts Association write the following in opposition:
As of January 22, 2019, the CalPERS fund stood at a projected 65 percent funded—that means that for every dollar owed to an active or retired employee, the average public agency has approximately 65 cents on hand.
[. . . ]
Due to the financial cost to local agencies and their employees, our agencies oppose any efforts to divert CalPERS from its duty to its members, including divestment of CalPERS assets to achieve political objectives if the divestment would have a negative impact on the overall health of the fund. Divestment harms investment performance and increases transaction costs.
The California Public Employees’ Retirement System (CalPERS) writes the following in opposition:
Generally, CalPERS prefers constructive engagement to divesting as a means of affecting change. Divesting appears to almost invariably harm investment performance, such as by causing transaction costs (e.g., the cost of selling assets and reinvesting the proceeds), compromising investment strategies, and reducing portfolio diversification.
CalPERS invests pension assets for the exclusive purpose of paying benefits to the plan participants. It is our experience that limiting investment opportunities results in lower than expected investment returns which leads to higher employer contribution rates.
The opposition arguments center around concerns that the pension funds will suffer losses and those losses will be passed on to the PERS/STRS employer.
4. Last year’s bill and veto
Last year, this Committee passed AB 1597 (Nazarian), a bill that was substantially similar to this bill. The bill was vetoed by the Governor. In his veto message, Govern Brown explained:
This bill, which only goes into effect if the Federal Government imposes sanctions on Turkey, would require our pension funds to sell all bonds or investment vehicles issued by the Turkish government.
The horror of the Armenian Genocide is something no Californian should ever forget. To that end, our school curriculum requires the study of the Armenian Genocide and this year I proclaimed April 24, 2018, as "Day of Remembrance of the Armenian Genocide". In addition, the state extended the statutory deadline for genocide victims or their heirs to seek legal redress.
While this subject is profoundly important, the bill as written is mostly symbolic. Moreover, I am reluctant to force yet another disinvestment measure on our already stressed pension systems.
SUPPORT
Armenian Assembly of America
Armenian Catholic Eparchy of Our Lady of Nareg in the USA and Canada
Armenian Democratic Liberal Party
Armenian Evangelical Union of North America
Armenian National Committee of America – Western Region
Armenian Rights Council of America
Open Wounds
Los Angeles City Councilmember, Paul Krekorian
OPPOSITION
California Police Chiefs Association
California Public Employees’ Retirement System
California Retired Teachers Association
California Special Districts Association
California State Association of Counties
California State Teachers’ Retirement System
City of Rancho Cucamonga
League of California Cities
Peace Officers’ Research Association of California
School Employers Association of California
Turkey
RELATED LEGISLATION
Pending Legislation: AB 33 (Bonta, (2018)) requires PERS and STRS to divest from private prison companies, from making new or renewing existing investments in such companies, and to constructively engage with private prison companies to establish whether the companies are transitioning their business model to another industry, among other provisions. This bill is currently pending in the Assembly Public Employment and Retirement Committee.
Prior Legislation:
AB 1597 (Nazarian, 2018) See comment 4.
AB 20 (Kalra, Ch. 575, Stats. 2017) requires CalPERS and CalSTRS to submit a report to the Legislature and Governor regarding investments in, and engagement activities with, companies constructing, or funding, the construction of the Dakota Access Pipeline.
AB 946 (Garcia, 2017) would have prohibited PERS and STRS from investing public employee retirement funds in companies engaged in business related to the border wall proposed by the Trump Administration. This bill is died without a hearing in the Assembly Public Employees, Retirement, and Social Security Committee.
AB 1410 (Nazarian, 2015) would have prohibited CalPERS and CalSTRS from investing public employee retirement funds in specified investments issued by, owned, controlled, or managed by the government of Turkey. This bill was held on suspense in the Assembly Appropriations Committee.
AB 1551 (Allen, 2015) would have required public retirement funds, on or after January 1, 2017, to make no additional investments or renew existing investments in business firms or financial institutions that engage in business practices in furtherance of the boycott of Israel, among other provisions. This bill was held in the Assembly.
AB 2283 (Calderon, 2015) would have required PERS and STRS to evaluate their investments in securitized home rental properties and ensure certain requirements were met, as specified, prior to investing or reinvesting in securitized home rental properties, among other provisions. This bill was held in the Assembly Public Employee, Retirement, and Social Security Committee.
AB 2650 (Nazarian, 2015) would have prohibited PERS and STRS from investing public employee retirement funds in specified investments issued by, owned, controlled, or managed by the government of Turkey. This bill was held in the Assembly Appropriations Committee.
SB 185 (De León, Ch. 605, Stats. 2015) prohibits PERS and STRS from investing public employee retirement funds in thermal coal companies, as specified.
AB 761 (Dickinson, 2013) would have prohibited PERS and STRS from investing in companies that manufacture firearms or ammunition for a recipient other than the U.S. military, subject to a process specified in the bill and consistent with previous divestment legislation, but subject to the board's fiduciary duties. This bill was held in the Assembly Appropriations Committee.
SR 18 (Leno, 2013) encouraged PERS and STRS, whenever feasible and consistent with their fiduciary responsibilities, to cease making direct investments in Russia and to encourage companies in which employee retirement funds are invested and that are doing business in Russia not to take actions that promote or otherwise enable human rights violations in Russia. The resolution was adopted.
AB 1151 (Feuer, Ch. 441, Stats. 2011) clarifies that PERS and STRS must divest pension funds, as specified, unless to do so would fail to satisfy their fiduciary responsibility. The law also modifies the types of companies that fall within the Act’s scope and requires certain findings and determinations be made in noticed public hearings.
SB 903 (Anderson, 2011) would have amended the California Public Divest From Iran Act to clarify the criteria and process that the boards of PERS and STRS must use to invest in Iran. This bill was held in the Senate Appropriations Committee.
AB 2337 (Ammiano, 2010) would have prohibited PERS and STRS from participating in predatory real estate investment practices related to rent-regulated housing that results in excessive rent increases, the displacement of tenants, or conversion of rent-regulated housing to market rate units. This bill was held in Senate Public Employment and Retirement Committee.
AB 221 (Anderson, Ch. 671, Stats. 2007) prohibits PERS and STRS from investing in companies that have specified energy or defense-related operations in Iran.
AB 2941 (Koretz, Ch. 442, Stats. 2006) prohibits PERS and STRS from investing public employee retirement funds in a company with business operations in Sudan, as specified.
SB 424, (Poochigian, Ch. 9, Stats. 2005) established April 24 of each year as the California Day of Remembrance of the Armenian Genocide and the period beginning on the Sunday before that day through the following Sunday as the days of remembrance of the Armenian Genocide.
SJR 2 (Speier, Ch. 22) designated April 24, 2005, as the California Day of Remembrance for the Armenian Genocide of 1915-1923 and also memorialized the United States Congress to act likewise to commemorate the Armenian Genocide.
AB 107 (Knox, 2000) would have prohibited new or additional investments in tobacco companies by PERS and STRS on and after January 1, 2001, and would have required divestment from existing investments by July 1, 2002. This bill was held on concurrence in the Assembly.
AB 2251, (Margolin, Ch. 1351, Stats. 1992) prohibits state trust fund and state money investments in business firms or financial institutions that engage in discriminatory business practices after January 1, 1994, relating to the Arab League’s economic boycott of Israel.
AB 134 (Waters, Ch. 1254, Stats. 1986) prohibits the use of state trust funds or state monies to make additional or new investments, or renew existing investments in firms doing business with or in South Africa, as of January 1, 1987.
PRIOR VOTES:
Senate Labor, Public Employment and Retirement Committee (Ayes 5, Noes 0)
Assembly Floor (Ayes 63, Noes 0)
Assembly Appropriations Committee (Ayes 14, Noes 0)
Assembly Public Employment and Retirement Committee (Ayes 4, Noes 2)
**************
SENATE COMMITTEE ON LABOR, PUBLIC EMPLOYMENT AND RETIREMENT
Senator Jerry Hill, Chair
2019 - 2020 Regular
Bill No: AB 1320 Hearing Date: June 26, 2019
Author: | Nazarian | ||
Version: | April 4, 2019 | ||
Urgency: | No | Fiscal: | Yes |
Consultant: | Glenn Miles | ||
SUBJECT: Public employee retirement systems: prohibited investments: Turkey
KEY ISSUE
Should the state prohibit CalPERS and CalSTRS from making additional, new investments, or renew existing investments of public employee retirement funds in any investment issued, owned, controlled, or managed by the government of Turkey and require the pension funds to divest from Turkish government investments upon passage of a Federal Law sanctioning Turkey for failing to acknowledge the Armenian Genocide?
ANALYSIS
Existing law:
- Provides, pursuant to California Constitution, that the boards of California's public retirement systems have "plenary authority and fiduciary responsibility for [the] investment of monies and administration of the system." (Cal. Const., art. XVI, § 17)
- Provides under the California Constitution that "the members of the retirement board of a public pension or retirement system shall discharge their duties with respect to the system solely in the interest of, and for the exclusive purposes of providing benefits to, participants and their beneficiaries, minimizing employer contributions thereto, and defraying reasonable expenses of administrating the system…[and] the board shall diversify the investments of the system so as to minimize the risk of loss and to maximize the rate of return unless under the circumstances it is clearly prudent to do so." (Cal. Const., art. XVI, § 17)
- Provides that the Legislature retains its authority to, by statute, "continue to prohibit certain investments by a retirement board where it is in the public interest to do so, and provided that the prohibition satisfies the standards of fiduciary care and loyalty required of a retirement board pursuant to this section." (Cal. Const., art. XVI, § 17)
- Prohibits CalPERS and CalSTRS, under previous legislative mandates, from making or holding certain investments in Iran, Sudan, in businesses discriminating against Israel related to the Arab Boycott of Israel, and in thermal coal companies. (Government Code §7513.6 et seq.)
This bill:
- Prohibits CalPERS and CalSTRS, immediately upon passage of a federal law imposing sanctions on Turkey for failure to acknowledge the Armenian Genocide, from making additional, new investments, or renewing existing investments of public employee retirement funds in any investment issued, owned, controlled, or managed by the government of Turkey.
- Requires CalPERS and CalSTRS to liquidate all investments issued by, owned, controlled, or managed by the government of Turkey within six months of the passage of a federal law imposing sanctions on Turkey for failure to acknowledge the Armenian Genocide.
- Requires CalPERS and CalSTRS, within one year of the passage of federal law imposing sanctions on Turkey for failure to acknowledge the Armenian Genocide, to file a report with the following information to the Legislature and Governor:
- A list of investments in Turkey of which the board, as defined, has liquidated.
- A list of investments in Turkey of which the board has not liquidated as a result of a determination by the board that divestment would be inconsistent with its fiduciary duties pursuant to California Constitution Article XVI Section 17, and the board's findings adopted in support of that determination.
- Specifies that nothing in this bill requires CalPERS or CalSTRS to take action unless they determine in good faith that the action is consistent with their fiduciary duties, as specified.
- Provides that the required mandate shall be repealed upon a determination by either the Department of State or the Congress of the United States, or other appropriate federal agency that the government of Turkey has officially acknowledged its responsibility for the Armenian Genocide.
- Indemnifies from the state General Fund and holds harmless by the state, present, future, and former board members, jointly and individually, and their respective agents from personal liability for losses sustained as a result of any decision to restrict, reduce, or eliminate investments.
- Makes legislative findings and declarations regarding the government of Turkey and the Armenian Genocide in support of its operative provisions.
- Defines, for these purposes, the following terms:
- “Board” to mean the boards of CalPERS and CalSTRS, respectively, and as applicable.
- “Government of Turkey” to mean, the government of Turkey or its instrumentalities or political subdivisions, including any investment vehicle, government bond, or financial institution and entity owned, controlled, or operated by the government of Turkey.
- “Public employee retirement funds” to mean CalPERS and CalSTRS, as provided.
- “Turkey” to mean the Republic of Turkey or any territory under the administration or control of Turkey.
COMMENTS
1. Need for this bill?
According to the author,
California has a clear policy of Armenian Genocide recognition, as demonstrated by decades of legislative resolutions and gubernatorial proclamations. Contrary to our state’s policy, the Turkish government fosters the teaching of genocide denial in its public schools, and continues to discriminate against Armenians and other minorities. Despite these facts, our state’s pension systems – CalPERS and CalSTRS – have invested in Turkish government holdings, thereby indirectly subsidizing Turkish denial of the Genocide.
The purpose of this bill is to achieve a policy objective of not financially rewarding and investing in governments which routinely violate human rights or which promote policies contrary to our own. Enactment of this bill would make it clear that California will stand on principle and make our state’s investment choices consistent with our values and policies, such as Armenian Genocide recognition. In addition, in April 2018, then candidate for Governor, Gavin Newsom, called for CalPERS and the UC to divest from Turkey.
2. Committee Comments
AB 1320 (Nazarian, 2019) and AB 1597 (Nazarian, 2017)
This bill is substantially the same as AB 1597 (Nazarian, 2017), which was vetoed by the Governor. This analysis incorporates by reference the Senate Policy Analysis of AB 1597.
Recommended Amendments
The bill language continues to use vague terms and definitions related to what investments the bill prohibits. Committee staff recommends amendments that would clarify the prohibited class of investments and clearly identify the Government of Turkey as the political state understood by common reference and not vague, overly broad terms as “investment vehicles”, “financial institutions”, and “entities”. Staff also recommend minor, technical amendments characterizing public pension funds as funds held in trust.
3. Proponent Arguments
According to the Armenian Assembly of America,
The purpose of AB 1320 is to craft a sensible policy, which refrains from financially rewarding and investing in foreign governments that undermine democracy and trample upon basic human and civil rights of its citizens. The approval of this bill would send a clear signal to residents of the Golden State that California values investment options that are in accordance with its legislative polices and principles in protecting and upholding universal human and civil rights, the rule of law, and the freedom of expression within the state and throughout the globe.
According to the Armenian Catholic Eparchy of Our Lady Nareg in the United States and Canada,
CalPERS and CalSTRS both have investment holdings in bonds directly issued by the Republic of Turkey. California's investments indirectly subsidize Turkish denial of the Genocide. This bill aims to address the issue of the Republic of Turkey’s unwillingness to cease teaching genocide denial in its public schools continues the pattern of discrimination against Armenians, and minorities.
4. Opponent Arguments:
According to the Association of Turkish Americans of Southern California
We are writing to register our opposition to AB-1320, which is another iteration of previous divestment bills targeting Turkey. Like its previous versions, this bill is also driven by a political agenda rather than an economic and financial rationale.
It undermines the fiduciary duties of PERS and STRS by calling upon the California legislature to divest from Turkey based on political, rather than investment related or economic considerations.
According to a coalition of the California Special Districts Association, the California State Association of Counties, and the League of California Cities,
CalPERS staff has previously noted in their analysis of divestment legislation that “every dollar in investment returns that is foregone, or expended in unnecessary transaction costs and fees, must be made up for in employer and employee contributions.” Therefore, AB 1320 could be expected to contribute to an increased burden on employees and employers through increased contribution rates, and potentially impair CalPERS’ ability to deliver promised benefit payments. Given the significant rate increases our districts are currently facing, it would be extremely detrimental to add any unnecessary additional financial burdens on them at this time.
According to the California State Teachers Retirement System,
Divestment carries the risk of adversely affecting the Ca1STRS investment portfolio by reducing diversification and altering the investment strategy adopted by the board. This is especially concerning as investment returns affect the Ca1STRS Funding Plan (AB 1469 - Bonta), which placed Ca1STRS on a trajectory toward full funding.
The School Employers Association of California (SEAC) states the following:
SEAC believes that the sustainability and integrity of the CalPERS and CalSTRS pension funds must be prioritized over any divestment policies and mandates that are inconsistent with the pension systems’ efforts to maximize risk-adjusted investment returns, control employer and employee contribution rates, and provide the retirement benefits promised to their members.
5. Double Referral:
This bill is double referred and, if passed out of this committee, will be heard in the Senate Judiciary Committee.
6. Prior Legislation:
2019: Assembly Bill 33 (Bonta) requires CalPERS and CalSTRS to divest from private prison companies, from making new or renewing existing investments in such companies, and to constructively engage with private prison companies to establish whether the companies are transitioning their business model to another industry, among other provisions. This bill is currently pending in the Assembly Public Employment and Retirement Committee.
2018: Senate Bill 459 (Portantino) would have required CalPERS to adopt an investment policy for retailers or wholesalers of banned weapons; engage those sellers; exercise proxy votes if engagement is unsuccessful; and, divest from those companies if engagement and the exercise of proxy votes are unsuccessful, among other provisions. This bill was withdrawn by the author while pending in the Assembly Public Employees, Retirement, and Social Security Committee.
2017: Chapter 575, Statutes of 2017 (AB 20, Kalra) requires CalPERS and CalSTRS to report to the Legislature and the Governor, on or before April 1, 2018, information regarding investments in, and engagement with, companies constructing or funding the construction of the Dakota Access Pipeline.
Assembly Bill 946 (Ting) would have prohibited CalPERS and CalSTRS from investing public employee retirement funds in companies engaged in business related to the ‘border wall’ proposed by the Trump Administration. This bill was withdrawn by the author while pending in the Assembly Public Employees, Retirement and Social Security Committee.
Assembly Bill 1597 (Nazarian) would have prohibited CalPERS and CalSTRS from investing in any investment vehicle issued, owned, controlled, or managed by the government of Turkey. The Governor vetoed this bill stating that:
This bill, which only goes into effect if the Federal Government imposes sanctions on Turkey, would require our pension funds to sell all bonds or investment vehicles issued by the Turkish government.
The horror of the Armenian Genocide is something no Californian should ever forget. To that end, our school curriculum requires the study of the Armenian Genocide and this year I proclaimed April 24, 2018, as “Day of Remembrance of the Armenian Genocide.” In addition, the state extended the statutory deadline for genocide victims or their heirs to seek legal redress.
While this subject is profoundly important, the bill as written is mostly symbolic. Moreover, I am reluctant to force yet another disinvestment measure on our already stressed pension systems.
2016: Assembly Bill 1410 (Nazarian) would have prohibited CalPERS and CalSTRS from investing public employee retirement funds in specified investments issued by, owned, controlled, or managed by the government of Turkey. This bill was held in the Assembly Appropriations Committee.
Assembly Bill 1551 (Allen) would have required public retirement funds, on or after January 1, 2017, to make no additional investments or renew existing investments in business firms or financial institutions that engage in business practices in furtherance of the boycott of Israel, among other provisions. This bill was held in the Assembly.
Assembly Bill 2283 (Calderon) would have required CalPERS and CalSTRS to evaluate their investments in securitized home rental properties and ensure certain requirements were met, as specified, prior to investing or reinvesting in securitized home rental properties, among other provisions. This bill was held in the Assembly Public Employees, Retirement, and Social Security Committee.
Assembly Bill 2650 (Nazarian) would have prohibited CalPERS and CalSTRS from investing public employee retirement funds in specified investments issued by, owned, controlled, or managed by the government of Turkey. This bill was held in the Assembly Appropriations Committee.
2015: Chapter 605 (Senate Bill 185, De Leon) prohibits CalPERS and CalSTRS from investing public employee retirement funds in thermal coal companies, as specified, and among other provisions.
2013: Assembly Bill 761 (Dickinson) would have prohibited CalPERS and CalSTRS from investing in companies that manufacture firearms or ammunition for a recipient other than the U.S. military, subject to a process specified in the bill and consistent with previous divestment legislation, but subject to the board's fiduciary duties. This bill was held in the Assembly Appropriations Committee.
Senate Resolution 18 (Leno) encouraged CalPERS and CalSTRS, whenever feasible and consistent with their fiduciary responsibilities, to cease making direct investments in Russia and to encourage companies in which employee retirement funds are invested and that are doing business in Russia not to take actions that promote or otherwise enable human rights violations in Russia. This resolution was adopted.
2011: Chapter 411 (AB 1151, Feuer) amended the California Public Divest from Iran Act to, among other things, clarify that the boards of CalPERS and CalSTRS must divest pension funds, unless to do so would breach a fiduciary duty, among other provisions.
Senate Bill 903 (Anderson) would have amended the California Public Divest from Iran Act to clarify the criteria and process that the boards of CalPERS and CalSTRS must use to invest in Iran. This bill was held in the Senate Appropriations Committee.
2010: Assembly Bill 2337 (Ammiano) would have prohibited CalPERS and CalSTRS from participating in predatory real estate investment practices related to rent-regulated housing that results in excessive rent increases, the displacement of tenants, or conversion of rent-regulated housing to market rate units. This bill was held in Senate Public Employment and Retirement Committee.
2007: Chapter 671 (AB 221, Anderson) prohibits CalPERS and CalSTRS from investing in companies that have specified energy or defense-related operations in Iran.
2006: Chapter 442 (AB 2941, Koretz) prohibits CalPERS and CalSTRS from investing public employee retirement funds in a company with business operations in Sudan, as specified.
SUPPORT
Armenian Assembly of America
Armenian Catholic Eparchy of Our Lady Nareg in the United States and Canada
Armenian Evangelical Union of the North America
Armenian Democratic Liberal Party, Western District Committee
Armenian National Committee of America – Western Region
Paul Krekorian, Los Angeles City Councilmember
Open Wounds
OPPOSITION
Association of Turkish Americans of Southern California
California Police Chiefs Association
California Public Employees’ Retirement System
California Retired Teachers’ Association
California Special Districts Association
California State Association of Counties
California State Teachers’ Retirement System
City of Rancho Cucamonga
Consul General of Turkey
League of California Cities
School Employers Association of California
-- END --
ASSEMBLY THIRD READING
ATR Bill Id:AB 1320
Author:(Nazarian, et al.)
As Amended Ver:April 4, 2019
Majority vote
SUMMARY:
Prohibits the California Public Employees' Retirement System (CalPERS) and the California State Teachers' Retirement System (CalSTRS) from investing in the government of Turkey and certain financial instruments thereof, if the federal government of the United States (U.S.) imposes sanctions on the government of Turkey for failing to officially acknowledge its responsibility for the Armenian Genocide, among other provisions.
Major Provisions
- Prohibits CalPERS and CalSTRS, immediately upon passage by the United States (U.S.) Congress and the President signing a federal law imposing sanctions on Turkey for failure to acknowledge its responsibility for the Armenian Genocide, from making additional, new investments, or renew existing investments of public employee retirement funds in any investment issued, owned, controlled, or managed by the government of Turkey.
- Requires CalPERS and CalSTRS to liquidate all investments issued by, owned, controlled, or managed by the government of Turkey within 18 months of the U.S. Congress passing, and the President signing a federal law imposing sanctions on the government of Turkey for failure to acknowledge its responsibility for the Armenian Genocide.
- Requires CalPERS and CalSTRS, within one year of the passage of federal law imposing sanctions on Turkey for failure to acknowledge the Armenian Genocide, to file a report with the following information to the Legislature and Governor regarding divestiture and remaining asset holdings that if divested, would be inconsistent with their fiduciary duties pursuant to the California Constitution.
- Specifies that nothing in this bill requires CalPERS or CalSTRS to take action unless they determine in good faith that the action is consistent with their fiduciary duties, as specified.
- Provides that the required divestment must be repealed upon a determination by either the U.S. Department of State or the U.S. Congress, or other appropriate federal agency that the government of Turkey has officially acknowledged its responsibility for the Armenian Genocide, or January 1, 2025, whichever occurs first.
COMMENTS:
Please see the policy committee analysis for a full discussion of this bill.
According to the Author:
"California has a clear policy of Armenian Genocide recognition, as demonstrated by decades of legislative resolutions and gubernatorial proclamations. Contrary to our state's policy, the Turkish government fosters the teaching of genocide denial in its public schools, and continues to discriminate against Armenians and other minorities. Despite these facts, our state's pension systems – CalPERS and CalSTRS – have invested in Turkish government holdings; thereby, indirectly subsidizing Turkish denial of the Genocide."
Arguments in Support:
Generally, supporters state the policy objective of this bill is to prevent financially rewarding and encouraging the government of Turkey which continues to engage in human rights violations.
Arguments in Opposition:
The Consul General of Turkey states in part that, "Assembly Bill 1320 undermines the fiduciary duties of [CalPERS and CalSTRS] by calling upon the Legislature to divest from Turkey based on political, rather than investment-related or economic considerations."
Opponents representing local governments express that, divestment harms investment performance and increases transaction costs because every investment dollar that is foregone, or expended in unnecessary transactions costs and fees, must be made up for increases in employer and employee contributions. This bill could be expected to potentially impair CalPERS' ability to deliver promised benefit payments, and rate increases resulting from this bill that add further unnecessary burdens that would be extremely detrimental.
FISCAL COMMENTS:
According the Assembly Appropriations Committee, this bill would result in:
- Unknown long-term impacts on retirement system portfolios of the CalPERS and CalSTRS systems. CalPERS and CalSTRS may incur opportunity costs if alternative investments do not generate greater investment returns than divested securities would have generated. Holdings affected by this bill total in at least the tens of millions – and possibly in the hundreds of millions – of dollars.
- Minor costs for CalPERS and CalSTRS to monitor federal actions, and significant initial costs exceeding $200,000 for CalPERS and CalSTRS to start liquidating securities if federal sanctions have been enacted. Costs could be much greater if the systems need to hire an external firm to determine which holdings meet the bill's criteria. There will also be significant ongoing costs for the public retirement systems, possibly in the hundreds of thousands of dollars annually, related to transaction costs and research services.
VOTES:
ASM PUBLIC EMPLOYMENT AND RETIREMENT: 4-2-1
YES: Rodriguez, Voepel, Cervantes, Cooley
NO: Cooper, O'Donnell
ABS, ABST OR NV: Fong
ASM APPROPRIATIONS: 14-0-4
YES: Gonzalez, Bloom, Bonta, Brough, Calderon, Carrillo, Chau, Eggman, Gabriel, Eduardo Garcia, Maienschein, Petrie-Norris, Quirk, Robert Rivas
ABS, ABST OR NV: Bigelow, Diep, Fong, Obernolte
UPDATED:
VERSION: April 4, 2019
CONSULTANT: Michael Bolden / P.E. & R. / (916) 319-3957 FN: 0000492
Date of Hearing: April 24, 2019
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Lorena Gonzalez, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 1320
Author:(Nazarian) – As Amended Ver:April 4, 2019
Policy Committee: | Public Employment and Retirement | Vote: | 4 - 2 |
|
| ||
|
|
Urgency: No State Mandated Local Program: No Reimbursable: No
SUMMARY:
This bill prohibits, under specified circumstances, the California Public Employees’ Retirement System (CalPERS) and the California State Teachers’ Retirement System (CalSTRS) from making or renewing investments in vehicles issued, owned, controlled or managed by the government of Turkey. This divestment policy is operative only when there are federal sanctions on Turkey for failure to acknowledge its responsibility for the Armenian Genocide, and this policy sunsets on the earlier of January 1, 2025, or when the Turkish government officially acknowledges its responsibility for the Armenian Genocide.
FISCAL EFFECT:
- Unknown long-term impact on retirement system portfolios of the CalPERS and CalSTRS systems. CalPERS and CalSTRS may incur opportunity costs if alternative investments do not generate greater investment returns than divested securities would have generated. Holdings affected by this bill total in at least the tens of millions – and possibly in the hundreds of millions – of dollars.
- Minor costs for CalPERS and CalSTRS to monitor federal actions, and significant initial costs exceeding $200,000 for CalPERS and CalSTRS to start liquidating securities if federal sanctions have been enacted. Costs could be much greater if the systems need to hire an external firm to determine which holdings meet AB 1320’s criteria. There will also be significant ongoing costs for the public retirement systems, possibly in the hundreds of thousands of dollars annually, related to transaction costs and research services.
COMMENTS:
- Purpose. According to the author, AB 1320 will make it clear that California will make its investment choices consistent with values such as a recognition of the Armenian Genocide. The author notes that California has a longstanding tradition of recognizing the Armenian Genocide, as indicated by legislative resolutions and executive branch proclamations. Despite this, CalPERS and CalSTRS still have investments in Turkish government holdings, which the author argues subsidizes Turkish denial of this genocide.
- Impact of divestment on CalPERS portfolio. A 2015 analysis by Wilshire Associates found that previous divestment efforts have collectively reduced the present value of the CalPERS portfolio by a range of $3.8 to $8.3 billion. Divestment targets that were included in this study were South African securities, tobacco-related securities, California Iran and Sudan Act lists, and firearm-related companies. The largest driver of this reduction in value was the divestment from tobacco, which Wilshire Associates found to have reduced the CalPERS portfolio by an estimated $2 billion to $3 billion.
Given the potential long-term costs associated with divestment proposals, public retirement systems and policymakers have pushed alternative strategies to promote positive social outcomes. For instance, current CalSTRS policy first prioritizes engagement with corporations, which consists of meeting with shareowners and senior managers. Under this policy, CalSTRS will consider divestment only after all engagement efforts have failed and when a corporation presents serious environmental, social or governance risk.
The Legislature has also been critical of past divestment proposals. Over the last few years, many divestment proposals have failed passage (see Comment #4). In addition, SB 783 (Pan), of the 2017-18 Legislative Session, would have appropriated $2 million GF for the University of California to review the fiscal and social impact of divestment proposals introduced in the Legislature. SB 783 was held on this committee’s Suspense File.
- Recent legislation. This bill is the fourth legislative attempt to develop a divestment strategy around Turkey and its recognition of the Armenian Genocide. Prior bills include AB 1597 (Nazarian), of the 2017-18 Legislative Session, which was vetoed by the governor, and AB 2650 (Nazarian) and AB 1410 (Nazarian), both of the 2015-16 Legislative Session, which were held on this committee’s Suspense File.
- Other divestment proposals. In recent years, a number of other proposals requesting or requiring CalPERS and CalSTRS to divest or modify investment strategies have been introduced. They include:
- A number of divestment-related proposals in the 2017-18 Legislative Session that died in the Assembly Committee on Public Employees & Retirement. Those proposals were SJR 24 (Jackson), which would have asked CalPERS to engage with companies that produce or sell firearms to determine a reasonable method for those companies to withdraw from the production and sale of firearms or to produce a plan to divest from those companies; SB 459 (Portantino), which would have required CalPERS and CalSTRS to divest from retailers or wholesalers of banned weapons if certain engagement efforts are unsuccessful; and, AB 946 (Ting), which would have required CalPERS and CalSTRS to divest from companies that contracts or subcontracts to build, maintain,\ or provide material for President Trump’s Border Wall.
- Other proposals in the 2015-16 Legislative Session for the most part failed passage. Legislation that failed to reach the governor’s desk include AB 1551 (Allen), which would have prohibited public retirement funds from making investments in businesses that engage in the boycott of Israel, and AB 2283 (Calderon), which would have required CalPERS and CalSTRS to evaluate their investments in securitized home rental properties and ensure certain requirements were met prior to investing in securitized home rental properties. One proposal did get signed into law: SB 185 (De Leon), Chapter 605, Statutes of 2016, which prohibits CalPERS and CalSTRS from investing public employee retirement funds in thermal coal companies.
Analysis Prepared by: Luke Reidenbach / APPR. / (916) 319-2081
Date of Hearing: April 3, 2019
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON PUBLIC EMPLOYMENT AND RETIREMENT
Freddie Rodriguez, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 1320 (
Author:Nazarian) – As Amended Ver:March 18, 2019
SUBJECT: Public employee retirement systems: prohibited investments: Turkey
SUMMARY: Prohibits the California Public Employees' Retirement System (CalPERS) and the California State Teachers' Retirement System (CalSTRS) from investing in the government of Turkey and certain financial instruments of the sovereign state, if the federal government of the United States (U.S.), as provided, imposes sanctions on Turkey for failing to acknowledge the Armenian Genocide, among other provisions. Specifically, this bill:
- Prohibits CalPERS and CalSTRS, immediately upon passage of a federal law imposing sanctions on Turkey for failure to acknowledge the Armenian Genocide, from making additional, new investments, or renew existing investments of public employee retirement funds in any investment issued, owned, controlled, or managed by the government of Turkey.
- Requires CalPERS and CalSTRS to liquidate all investments issued by, owned, controlled, or managed by the government of Turkey within six months of the passage of a federal law imposing sanctions on Turkey for failure to acknowledge the Armenian Genocide.
- Requires CalPERS and CalSTRS, within one year of the passage of federal law imposing sanctions on Turkey for failure to acknowledge the Armenian Genocide, to file a report with the following information to the Legislature and Governor:
- A list of investments in Turkey of which the board, as defined, has liquidated.
- A list of investments in Turkey of which the board has not liquidated as a result of a determination by the board that divestment would be inconsistent with its fiduciary duties pursuant to California Constitution Article XVI Section 17, and the board's findings adopted in support of that determination.
- Specifies that nothing in this bill requires CalPERS or CalSTRS to take action unless they determine in good faith that the action is consistent with their fiduciary duties, as specified.
- Provides that the required mandate shall be repealed upon a determination by either the Department of State or the Congress of the United States, or other appropriate federal agency that the government of Turkey has officially acknowledged its responsibility for the Armenian Genocide.
- Indemnifies from the state General Fund and holds harmless by the state, present, future, and former board members, jointly and individually, and their respective agents from personal liability for losses sustained as a result of any decision to restrict, reduce, or eliminate investments.
- Makes legislative findings and declarations regarding the government of Turkey and the Armenian Genocide in support of its operative provisions.
- Defines, for these purposes, the following terms:
- “Board” to mean the boards of CalPERS and CalSTRS, respectively, and as applicable.
- “Government of Turkey” to mean, the government of Turkey or its instrumentalities or political subdivisions, including any investment vehicle, government bond, or financial institution and entity owned, controlled, or operated by the government of Turkey.
- “Public employee retirement funds” to mean CalPERS and CalSTRS, as provided.
- “Turkey” to mean the Republic of Turkey or any territory under the administration or control of Turkey.
EXISTING LAW:
- Provides, pursuant to California Constitution Article XVI, Section 17, that the boards of California's public retirement systems have "plenary authority and fiduciary responsibility for [the] investment of monies and administration of the system."
- Provides under the California Constitution that "the members of the retirement board of a public pension or retirement system shall discharge their duties with respect to the system solely in the interest of, and for the exclusive purposes of providing benefits to, participants and their beneficiaries, minimizing employer contributions thereto, and defraying reasonable expenses of administrating the system…[and] the board shall diversify the investments of the system so as to minimize the risk of loss and to maximize the rate of return unless under the circumstances it is clearly prudent to do so."
- Provides under the California Constitution that the Legislature retains its authority to, by statute, "continue to prohibit certain investments by a retirement board where it is in the public interest to do so, and provided that the prohibition satisfies the standards of fiduciary care and loyalty required of a retirement board pursuant to this section."
- Prohibits CalPERS and CalSTRS, under previous legislative mandates, from making or holding certain investments in Iran, Sudan, in businesses discriminating against Israel related to the Arab Boycott of Israel, and in thermal coal companies.
FISCAL EFFECT: Unknown. This bill is flagged as fiscal by Legislative Counsel.
COMMENTS: According to the author, “California has a clear policy of Armenian Genocide recognition, as demonstrated by decades of legislative resolutions and gubernatorial proclamations. Contrary to our state’s policy, the Turkish government fosters the teaching of genocide denial in its public schools, and continues to discriminate against Armenians and other minorities. Despite these facts, our state’s pension systems – CalPERS and CalSTRS – have invested in Turkish government holdings; thereby, indirectly subsidizing Turkish denial of the Genocide.
‘The purpose of this bill is to achieve a policy objective of not financially rewarding and investing in governments which routinely violate human rights or which promote policies contrary to investing in governments which routinely violate human rights or which promote policies contrary to our own. Enactment of this bill would make it clear that California will stand on principle and make our state’s investment choices consistent with our values and policies, such as Armenian Genocide recognition.”
- Effects of Divestment: General Overview
CalPERS and CalSTRS have certain authority pursuant to the California Constitution and are governed by other existing laws. Decisions relating to the administration of each system are the responsibility of their respective independently elected and ex-officio board members who have plenary authority for their administration.
Public policies affecting the investments of CalPERS and CalSTRS have, and continue to have, ongoing negative financial impacts to each. Given the current funded status of CalPERS and CalSTRS, respectively, each system continues to prudently invest the monies of their respective participants to provide the benefits promised by the employers of these employees, and to preserve their financial security in retirement. In addition, alternative investing methods are being considered by each to remain competitive as a result of ever-changing dynamics in the investment market.
Continued and additional burdens on investments that limit the available investment opportunities horizon to maximize returns and minimize risks, coupled with contraction of the investment market and economy, each inhibit growth and threaten the financial security of these funds; thereby, placing financial strain on public employers, present and future retirees, and the state budget.
- Unknown Negative and Multiplier Effects of Legislative Divestment
During the last decade, CalPERS and CalSTRS have made strides to recover from over $100 billion in losses as a result of global and national economic uncertainty during the Great Recession. As each continue their trajectories of recovery, several legislative and budgetary actions have been established to assist in their continued financial stability, provision of retirement benefits and, therefore, retirement security to their respective members.
These actions, as discussed infra, continue to have slow, yet positive results towards achieving their underlying respective goals. The boards, as fiduciaries of these systems, continue to make decisions regarding the present and future financial stability of these funds and do so with consideration of historical, currently available and prevailing investment market information towards ensuring that their decisions are prudent under the circumstances.
Public policies that run contrary to these actions and efforts can have substantial unknown and unintended consequences.
- Whether AB 1320 Presents a Potential Financial Setback When Considering Prior State Budgetary Action and Proposed State Budgetary Action
The 2018-19 State Budget Act, as signed by Governor Brown, included a $6 billion supplemental payment to CalPERS to reduce CalPERS’ unfunded liability, stabilize state contribution rates paid to the system, and provide increased savings of approximately $11 billion to the state over the long-term.
The Governor’s 2019-20 Budget proposes an additional $3 billion supplemental payment for similar purposes, and more than $3 billion to CalSTRS, including monies for local public education for purposes of financial relief relating to retirement contributions. In total, this amounts to over $12 billion to reduce the unfunded liability of CalPERS and CalSTRS, while providing relief to local public education.
Currently, CalPERS’ funded status is approximately 70 percent, and CalSTRS’ is approximately 62.6 percent; meaning, CalPERS has 70 cents for every dollar needed to pay promised retirement benefits, whereas, CalSTRS has just under 63 cents for every dollar needed. Given the current funded status of each, AB 1320 may present a financial setback to both systems, public employers (including local public education), present and future retirees, local public education, and the state General Fund.
Relating to this bill, among CalPERS and CalSTRS, approximately $400 million in assets are at risk because AB 1320 affects the investments and overall investment strategy and portfolios of CalPERS and CalSTRS. It should be expected that AB 1320 may result in a financial setback relating to prior budgetary action and those currently under consideration, which ultimately would result in required and unknown increases in contributions from participating employers, and likely, the necessity for additional payments from the state General Fund in the future.
- Potential Effects on the Progress of the Public Employee Pension Reform Act (PEPRA)
Chapter 296, Statues of 2012, established the PEPRA which made numerous major revisions to public retirement system laws. Among them, the PEPRA increased employer and employee retirement contributions; established certain caps relating to compensation and creditable compensation; and reduced retirement benefit formulas for, and increased the age for retirement of, new pension plan members, to name a few.
While existing pension fund members are impacted by some of the PEPRA’s provisions, new members of CalPERS are among those who are impacted the most by these changes. However, at its core, the purpose of the PEPRA is to reduce unfunded liabilities and ensure the integrity and financial stability of public employee retirement.
The provisions of AB 1320 relating to investments could be expected to hinder the progress of the PEPRA, and may require additional monetary contributions from public employers, employees and the state General Fund, as a result.
- Potential Effects on the CalSTRS Full Funding Plan
Enabling law, pursuant to Chapter 47, Statutes of 2014 (AB 1469, Bonta), established the CalSTRS Full Funding Plan which sets forth a plan to address the unfunded liability in CalSTRS’ Defined Benefit Program by increasing contribution rates of teachers, employers, and the state. The ultimate goal of this plan is for CalSTRS to be fully funded (i.e., 100 percent) by the year 2046, such that the financial solvency of the fund remains towards meeting its legal mandates to “exclusively provide retirement benefits to its members and beneficiaries.”
The CalSTRS Full Funding Plan continues to be lauded as a financially prudent action by the Governor and Legislature. As the plan continues to demonstrate its efficacy, investment gains and losses, changes in mortality and system maturity all have effects on the delicate balance of the Full Funding Plan. The provisions of AB 1320 will compound this delicate balance due its financial impacts, and raise questions as to whether the Full Funding Plan will need to be revised to account for any unforeseen resulting consequences.
As the Legislature continues to contemplate budgetary actions as proposed in the Governor’s Budget to address CalSTRS’ unfunded liability and provide relief to local public schools, these budgetary actions could accelerate the fulfillment of the Full Funding Plan. However, it could be expected that AB 1320 will negatively impact the progress of the Full Funding Plan that would ensure the financial solvency of the system and retirement security of CalSTRS’ members.
- Investing By Legislative Public Policy in the Absence of Financial Considerations
As previously stated, pursuant to the California Constitution, the Legislature retains certain authority relating to the investments of California’s retirement funds. However, the Legislature does not employ investment market advisors and managers for purposes of CalPERS and CalSTRS investments. Indeed, the CalPERS and CalSTRS boards rely on highly experienced and skilled internal and external investment market advisors and managers who are responsible for ensuring, in part, the sustainability and continuity of the systems and their ability to provide promised retirement benefits to, and for the exclusive benefit of, their respective members. In performing their duties, these advisors and managers must consider the totality of historical investment market trends, the latest investment market information and circumstances, including globally, when advancing options and recommendations to the board for consideration and making decisions in the best interests of the funds and the respective members. This includes considerations by the boards relating to self-directed divestment.
Every investment dollar that is lost by these funds as a result of legislative requirements on investments must be made up by an increase in employer and employee contributions, unless the returns on other investments can offset the losses or lost opportunity. When participating employers have to contribute more to CalPERS or CalSTRS for their employees, their budgets are negatively affected which can lead to reductions in services, position and employees.
Flexibility related to investment options coupled with successful investing helps to ease cost pressure that will be borne by the systems and ultimately, participating employers, present and future retirees, and the state budget.
The committee is informed that, notwithstanding any moral, political, or symbolic gesture and goals of AB 1320, legislative divestment proposals such as AB 1320 that continue to be introduced each year do not take into consideration the extent of potential financial impacts.
a) CalPERS and CalSTRS: Tools of the Legislature for Moral, Symbolic or Political Objectives? There Are Unknown, Unforeseen and Exponential Financial Consequences.
This committee has consistently been informed by CalPERS, CalSTRS and others that legislation that requires divestment or prohibitions on investments have negative financial impacts on the overall funded status of the systems, and their overall investment strategies and portfolios. Among these systems, legislation impacting investments have a substantial multiplier effect when considering the impacts to the participants of the systems (i.e., present and future retirees and employers) and the state General Fund, as previously discussed.
Legislation that prohibits certain investments and those that require divestment have a de minimus to no impact on the prospect of achieving a change from offending behavior or activity. Because the very nature of the investment market is opportunistic, there are numerous other investors who will seize an investment opportunity in which CalPERS or CalSTRS are unable to no longer invest. Thusly, the target of divestment or prohibited investment is unaffected by the loss of CalPERS or CalSTRS investments when there are numerous other investment alternatives waiting for an opportunity creating little to no impetus to change from offending behavior or activity. There may be consequences relating to failure to change from offending behavior or activity when CalPERS and CalSTRS divest, including losses to the funds and exponentially multiplied losses in other areas.
Requiring divestment or prohibiting investments are at times, more often than not, symbolic, moral or political gestures that are akin to cutting off one’s nose to spite the face. Permitting CalPERS and CalSTRS to remain at the investment “table” to leverage their investment holdings along with other likeminded institutional investors, generally can lead to success in achieving the desired outcome. Prohibiting investment or requiring divestment are less likely, if ever, to lead to success in achieving the desired outcome.
Notwithstanding AB 1320 as a moral, symbolic or political gesture, this bill, which affects CalPERS and CalSTRS investments, should be expected to have negative downstream financial effects that will be borne by the systems, participating employers, present and future retirees, and the state General Fund without necessarily achieving the desired outcome of effectuating change from offending behavior or activity.
4) Potential Substantial Legal Implications, Including Federal Preemption
Assembly Bill 1320 potentially has significant legal implications regarding California Constitutional authority and federal preemption of state intrusion upon international affairs, pursuant to existing federal and U.S. Constitutional laws, relevant state laws, and relevant legal decisions of courts of competent jurisdiction.
Assembly Bill 1320 may be unconstitutional pursuant to existing court prudential decisions under federal law because it attempts to affect foreign policy which is in the exclusive jurisdiction of the federal government.
In a class action case brought by Armenian Genocide victims against various insurers under a California Code of Civil Procedure provision extending the statute of limitation for such claims, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the 9th Circuit sitting en banc found that the California statute was preempted by the U.S. Constitution under the Foreign Affairs Doctrine. (See, Movsesian v. Victoria Versicherung AG, 670 F.3d 1067, 1071 (9th 3 Cir. 2012 [en banc]).
According to the court, the statute “has more than some incidental effect on foreign affairs (citation omitted). The statute expresses a distinct political point of view on a matter of foreign policy. It imposes the politically charged label of ‘genocide’ on the actions of the Ottoman Empire (and, consequently, present-day Turkey) and expresses sympathy for Armenian Genocide victims. The law establishes a particular foreign policy for California – one that decries the actions of the Ottoman Empire and seeks to provide redress for ‘Armenian Genocide victims’ by subjecting foreign insurance companies to lawsuits in California.”
The court cited U.S. Supreme Court case Zschernig v. Miller in noting that “even in the absence of any treaty, federal statute, or executive order, a state law may be unconstitutional if it disturbs foreign relations or establishes its own foreign policy.” The court further noted that the California statute “has a direct impact upon foreign relations and may well adversely affect the power of the central government to deal with those problems.”
Arguments attempting to distinguish AB 1320 from Movsesian because AB 1320 merely restricts the state from investing its own money in Turkey fundamentally misunderstands the nature of California’s pension funds, which are trust funds that hold the earned deferred compensation of system members. The monies cease to be monies of the state upon transfer from the state to the fund or from the local school or public agency to the funds (where in fact, the monies were not the state’s monies even before the transfer) just as they cease to be the state’s monies upon issuance of employee’s paychecks.
Moreover, federal law is clear that a state’s foreign company divestment statute is an unconstitutional intrusion in a field reserved for the federal government. (See, National Foreign Trade Council v. Giannoulias, 523 F Supp. 2d 731).
Assembly Bill 1320 impermissibly seeks to influence U.S. foreign policy by bringing economic pressure against the government of Turkey through a prohibition on CalPERS and CalSTRS investments, and presumably, a wider divestment campaign among public and university institutional funds.
Regardless of existing laws relating to divestment from South Africa and the Sudan for various specified purposes and reasons that have not yet been legally challenged, AB 1320 presents another opportunity that may establish an undesirable legal supreme court precedential decision in this area.
Assembly Bill 1320 may be subject to a legal cause of action by a potentially aggrieved party with standing who has a vested interest in the systems, including concerns regarding federal preemption.
5) Suggested Author’s Amendments by the Committee and Rationale for Each
This bill is substantially similar to AB 1597 (Nazarian, 2017) that was vetoed by Governor Brown last year, as discussed further below. Although there are provisions that some might deem to be “protections” in AB 1320 as carried over from AB 1597, these “protections” are substantially insufficient. Among these, other provisions are ambiguous, inconsistent and nonconforming, and there are no mechanisms to prevent the measure from being effective in perpetuity, nor financial impact reporting requirements that provide adequate assurance of the necessity of the measure in the future.
The committee is advised that each of these, which are explained, and the proposed amendments, should thoroughly be considered if this measure is to advance beyond this committee. However, regardless of existing laws relative to divestment from the sovereign states of South Africa, the Sudan, and Iran, etc., legal causes of action have not yet been brought forth by a potentially aggrieved party with standing.
In addition, the committee is advised that, even with inclusion of the proposed amendments, this bill does not resolve or mitigate potential legal, U.S. Constitutional and federal law questions regarding the legality of California laws that intrude upon federal preemption relating to foreign affairs, regardless of motive.
- Ambiguities and Nonconformities
- Ambiguities Subject to Interpretation Must Be Resolved to Mitigate Confusion
This measure requires divestment if “Congress passes” a law imposing sanctions on the government of Turkey, as specified.
Generally, “The Congress” refers to both the U.S. House of Representatives and the U.S. Senate. However, common parlance or vernacular among the general public may refer to “Congress” as only the U.S. House of Representatives - not inclusive of both chambers of “The Congress.” Therefore, AB 1320 could be construed to mean that only the U.S. House of Representatives needs to make the affirmative act for this bill to become effective.
In addition, the measure only requires Congress to “pass” a federal law imposing such sanctions. However, mere “passage” is insufficient. Here, a plain reading of this provision could be interpreted to mean that only the U.S. House of Representatives needs to “pass” said law to trigger divestment. The existing language in this bill is not a sufficient protection from permitting the federal government to unilaterally dictate by one congressional chamber, California pension fund investments that could have substantial implications on the funds, public employers, present and future retirees, and the state budget.
To address potential legal ambiguities and because language is an art form with respect to legal interpretation, this ambiguity must be resolved to mitigate ambiguity and confusion in effect, operation and purpose. To address this insufficiency, there must absolutely be affirmative and specific bicameral action, followed by affirmative action by the President of the United States to resolve this issue.
(1) Proposed Clarifying Amendment to Resolve Ambiguities
On page 5, beginning at line 5, amend to read: “Immediately upon Upon passage of a federal law imposing sanctions on Turkey for failure to acknowledge by both the United States House of Representatives and the United States Senate, and signed by the President of the United States, imposing sanctions on the government of Turkey for failure to officially acknowledge its responsibility for the Armenian Genocide, the board shall not make additional or new investments in any investment vehicle in the government of Turkey that meets either of the following criteria:”
b) Need to Minimize Potentially Sudden Financial Shock to Investment Strategies and Portfolios, and Addressing Nonconformities
- Potentially Sudden Financial Shock
This bill requires divestment “within 6 months” of the federal government imposing sanctions on the government of Turkey for specified purposes. However, this is an abundantly short period of time that may result in sudden financial shock to the systems relative to significant and unreasonable increased costs (for which the systems are legally mandated to guard against pursuant to the California Constitution), including, but not limited to, transaction fees paid to quickly unwind the investments within that period, losses on potential buyouts, immediate financial impacts to their overall respective investment strategies, and urgent need to rebalance the entirety of their respective investment portfolios (in part, due to the sum of investments) for purposes of their California constitutional and legal fiduciary mandates.
Regardless of the offending behavior or activity, divestment action and timing must not be imprudent, but always must be prudent under the totality of prevailing circumstances. Prudence requires, among other things, time, care, thoughtful consideration and deliberation by their boards consistent with, and pursuant to, their fiduciary duties.
The proposed amendment below relating to “Making Noncomformities, Conforming” would permit divestment, but provide for timely, careful vetting, informed, and deliberate consideration by the boards respecting their fiduciary duties by extending this period to 18 months.
- Making Nonconformities, Conforming
This bill requires divestment for the government of Turkey’s “failure to acknowledge the Armenian Genocide.” However, provisions that permit automatic repeal based on certain affirmative action by the government of Turkey relating to the Armenian Genocide permit repeal if “the government of Turkey has acknowledged its responsibility for the Armenian Genocide.” Thus, divestment is triggered for failure to acknowledge, but automatic repeal is triggered only if acknowledgment is based on the claiming of responsibility for the Armenian Genocide. These are wholly inconsistent and mean completely different things (i.e., acknowledging the existence of something vs. acknowledging responsibility for something) and must be resolved for purposes of conformity. As such, both provisions must mirror each other.
Further, in some instances, provisions throughout the legislative findings and declarations and the operative provisions of this measure specify “Turkey” instead of the “government of Turkey,” and use “officially” in some instances, but not others, as it pertains to the Armenian Genocide and acknowledging responsibility for the Armenian Genocide, etc.
Since the underlying basis and rationale of this measure relates to the “government of Turkey” and the Armenian Genocide, and “official” actions or inactions by the sovereign state thereto, the proposed amendments are necessary relative to the operative provisions of AB 1320 and for purposes of appropriate conformity.
- Proposed Amendments to Resolve Concern Relating to Sudden Financial Shock and Nonconformities
On page 5, beginning at line 14, amend to read: “The board shall liquidate investments in Turkey in an investment vehicle described in subdivision (b) within six months of the passage of a federal law that imposes sanction on the government of Turkey, as defined in paragraph (2) of subdivision (a), and as described pursuant to subdivision (b), within six months 18 months of the passage of a federal law, as provided in subdivision (b), that imposes sanctions on the government of Turkey for failure to acknowledge officially acknowledge its responsibility for the Armenian Genocide.”
- On page 5, beginning at line 18, amend to read: “Within one year of the passage of a federal law imposing sanctions on
Turkey for failure to acknowledgethe government of Turkey for failure to acknowledge its responsibility for the Armenian Genocide, the board shall file a report with the Legislature, in compliance with Section 9795, and with the Governor, that shall include the following:” - On page 5, beginning at line 23, amend to read: “(1) A list of investment vehicles in the government of Turkey of which the board has liquidated its investments pursuant to subdivision (c).”
- On page 5, beginning at line 25, amend to read: “(2) A list of investment vehicles in the government of Turkey of which the board has not liquated its investments as a result of a determination made pursuant to subdivision (e) that a sale or transfer of investments is inconsistent with the fiduciary responsibilities of the board as described in Section 17 of Article XVI of the California Constitution and the board’s findings adopted in support of that determination.
- Existing Repeal Provision is Insufficient. A Sunset Date is Also is Necessary, in Addition to Inclusion of Reporting Requirements Relating to Merit and Financial Impact
- A Sunset Date Also is Necessary
- Existing Repeal Provision is Insufficient. A Sunset Date is Also is Necessary, in Addition to Inclusion of Reporting Requirements Relating to Merit and Financial Impact
This bill provides for automatic repeal if the U.S. Department of State or the U.S. Congress, or other appropriate federal agency determines that the government of Turkey has officially acknowledged its responsibility for the Armenian Genocide.
However, this provision in and of itself is insufficient. Here, though an automatic repeal could happen, legislative proposals directing investment strategy such as AB 1320 that remain in effect in perpetuity result in contraction of available investment opportunities. Meaning, as the Legislature continues to introduce and consider proposals affecting pension fund investments, those who otherwise would value CalPERS or CalSTRS investment, in sum, are aware of these proposals and existing divestment or prohibitive investment laws, simply are disinterested in California’s potential pension fund investment requirements; to wit, results in a loss of available investment opportunities.
The committee is advised that further protective measures must be in place to ensure continuity of investment flexibility and respective of the fiduciary responsibilities and plenary authority of the boards.
To that end, a proposed amendment to include a sunset provision effective January 1, 2025, is suggested as mandatory in addition to the existing automatic repeal provisions, whichever occurs first.
- A Report to Determine Merit and Financial Impact Prior to Extending Divestment Action is Necessary
As discussed infra, the frequency and number of proposals that require divestment or prohibit investments have significantly increased in frequency over more than the past decade when compared to prior years. Because the values of society change from time to time, and currently, seemingly more frequently, California’s pensions funds and their respective assets are an attractive tool to use for moral, social, or political causes that ultimately increase financial risks, minimize opportunities, and present challenges relating to financial distress for public employers, present and future retirees, and the state General Fund.
As previously discussed, rarely, if ever, do such proposals achieve the desired outcome due to the opportunistic nature of the investment market, unless a number of likeminded institutional investors share the same underlying goals. Given these, and with the negative and substantial financial impacts that legislatively required divestment have on the systems absent financial consideration, the validity of these proposals, coupled with ever-changing global and international dynamics, including some of the existing statutory divestment requirements, should be called to question as to merit and necessity in the future. In comparison to the direct fiduciaries of the systems (i.e., the respective boards) the Legislature must invest in, and be informed as to, the financial impacts of these actions to determine their efficacy and whether they should be permitted to begin, or continue.
The committee is highly advised that further protective measures must be in place to ensure continuity of investment flexibility, financial stability, protection of promised existing benefits, and recognition of the fiduciary responsibilities and plenary authority of the boards are needed.
(1) Proposed Amendments that Include Additional Protections Relating to Divestment Repeal and Reporting Requirements
On page 6, beginning after line 36, insert: “(f) (1) Before an extension of the operation of this section, the board shall, using methods or processes as determined by the board, reevaluate the merit of continuing the prescribed divestment action, including, but not limited to, the financial effects of the divestment action on the fiduciary responsibilities of the board pursuant to Section 17 of Article XVI of the California Constitution.
‘(2) On or before January 1, 2024, the board shall submit a report to the Legislature with the information described in paragraph (1), on the merit of continuing the prescribed divestment action.
‘(3) A report submitted pursuant to paragraph (2) shall be submitted in compliance with Section 9795.”
‘(g) This section shall be repealed upon a determination by either the Department of State or the Congress of the United States, or other appropriate federal agency, that the government of Turkey has officially acknowledged its responsibility for the Armenian Genocide on the earlier of the following dates:
‘(1) Upon a determination by either the Department of State or the Congress of the United States, or other appropriate federal agency, that the government of Turkey has officially acknowledged its responsibility for the Armenian Genocide.
‘(2) January 1, 2025.
6) Legislative Counsel Conflict Notification
Subject to the wishes of the author, the author is informed that, should this measure advance beyond this committee, the Office of Legislative Counsel has issued a conflict notice relating to this measure. Should this measure be enacted without addressing the specified conflict, serious legal challenges could arise in the future that could have been avoided by only and specifically relevant and appropriate amendments.
7) Important Notice to the Committee and Author
Regardless of the social, moral, or political ambitions of this measure, AB 1320 may be subject to a legal cause of action by any aggrieved party that has legal standing. It should be expected that a legal cause of action will result in an unknown amount of monetary and human resource capital expenditures for the state to defend this measure, regardless of whether it is not beneficial. This measure may result in the expenditure of said capital; thereby, reducing existing state and local resources from other vital programs and services.
8) Comments by Opponents
The Consul General of Turkey states that, “[AB 1320] undermines the fiduciary duties of [CalPERS and CalSTRS] by calling upon the California Legislature to divest from Turkey based on political, rather than investment-related or economic considerations. The bill subordinates the vital financial interests of the public employees and pensioners of California to the agenda of a single constituency. In this respect, AB 1320 intends to send a political message….,” and “an attempt to level economic sanctions against Turkey - a North Atlantic Treaty Organization.” The Consul further states that,”[t]he passage of AB 1320 would set a dangerous precedent, paving the way for other ethnic or national interest groups to press for divestment from other countries.”
Opponents representing local governments express that, “[d]ivestment harms investment performance and increases transaction costs…,” and that, according to CalPERS staff, “...every investment dollar that is foregone, or expended in unnecessary transactions costs and fees, must be made up for in employer and employee contributions. Therefore, AB 1320 could be expected to contribute to an increased burden on employees and employers through increased contribution rates, and potentially impair CalPERS’ ability to deliver promised benefit payments.
These opponents further state that, “[g]iven the significant rate increases [that] our districts are currently facing, it would be extremely detrimental to add any unnecessary financial burdens on them at this time.” In addition, “[f]orcing divestment of California retirees’ funding ultimately transfers the ownership of the investments to another investor at great cost to the CalPERS fund, and removes the ability and influence of CalPERS, as shareowners.”
9) Prior and Related Legislation
2019: Assembly Bill 33 (Bonta) requires CalPERS and CalSTRS to divest from private prison companies, from making new or renewing existing investments in such companies, and to constructively engage with private prison companies to establish whether the companies are transitioning their business model to another industry, among other provisions. This bill is currently pending in the Assembly Public Employment and Retirement Committee.
2018: Senate Bill 459 (Portantino) would have required CalPERS to adopt an investment policy for retailers or wholesalers of banned weapons; engage those sellers; exercise proxy votes if engagement is unsuccessful; and, divest from those companies if engagement and the exercise of proxy votes are unsuccessful, among other provisions. This bill was withdrawn by the author while pending in the Assembly Public Employees, Retirement, and Social Security Committee.
2017: Chapter 575, Statutes of 2017 (AB 20, Kalra) requires CalPERS and CalSTRS to report to the Legislature and the Governor, on or before April 1, 2018, information regarding investments in, and engagement with, companies constructing or funding the construction of the Dakota Access Pipeline.
Assembly Bill 946 (Ting) would have prohibited CalPERS and CalSTRS from investing public employee retirement funds in companies engaged in business related to the ‘border wall’ proposed by the Trump Administration. This bill was withdrawn by the author while pending in the Assembly Public Employees, Retirement and Social Security Committee.
Assembly Bill 1597 (Nazarian) would have prohibited CalPERS and CalSTRS from investing in any investment vehicle issued, owned, controlled, or managed by the government of Turkey. The Governor vetoed this bill stating that:
“This bill, which only goes into effect if the Federal Government imposes sanctions on Turkey, would require our pension funds to sell all bonds or investment vehicles issued by the Turkish government.
‘The horror of the Armenian Genocide is something no Californian should ever forget. To that end, our school curriculum requires the study of the Armenian Genocide and this year I proclaimed April 24, 2018, as “Day of Remembrance of the Armenian Genocide.” In addition, the state extended the statutory deadline for genocide victims or their heirs to seek legal redress.
‘While this subject is profoundly important, the bill as written is mostly symbolic. Moreover, I am reluctant to force yet another disinvestment measure on our already stressed pension systems.”
2016: Assembly Bill 1410 (Nazarian) would have prohibited CalPERS and CalSTRS from investing public employee retirement funds in specified investments issued by, owned, controlled, or managed by the government of Turkey. This bill was held in the Assembly Appropriations Committee.
Assembly Bill 1551 (Allen) would have required public retirement funds, on or after January 1, 2017, to make no additional investments or renew existing investments in business firms or financial institutions that engage in business practices in furtherance of the boycott of Israel, among other provisions. This bill was held in the Assembly.
Assembly Bill 2283 (Calderon) would have required CalPERS and CalSTRS to evaluate their investments in securitized home rental properties and ensure certain requirements were met, as specified, prior to investing or reinvesting in securitized home rental properties, among other provisions. This bill was held in the Assembly Public Employees, Retirement, and Social Security Committee.
Assembly Bill 2650 (Nazarian) would have prohibited CalPERS and CalSTRS from investing public employee retirement funds in specified investments issued by, owned, controlled, or managed by the government of Turkey. This bill was held in the Assembly Appropriations Committee.
2015: Chapter 605 (Senate Bill 185, De Leon) prohibits CalPERS and CalSTRS from investing public employee retirement funds in thermal coal companies, as specified, and among other provisions.
2013: Assembly Bill 761 (Dickinson) would have prohibited CalPERS and CalSTRS from investing in companies that manufacture firearms or ammunition for a recipient other than the U.S. military, subject to a process specified in the bill and consistent with previous divestment legislation, but subject to the board's fiduciary duties. This bill was held in the Assembly Appropriations Committee.
Senate Resolution 18 (Leno) encouraged CalPERS and CalSTRS, whenever feasible and consistent with their fiduciary responsibilities, to cease making direct investments in Russia and to encourage companies in which employee retirement funds are invested and that are doing business in Russia not to take actions that promote or otherwise enable human rights violations in Russia. This resolution was adopted.
2011: Chapter 411 (AB 1151, Feuer) amended the California Public Divest from Iran Act to, among other things, clarify that the boards of CalPERS and CalSTRS must divest pension funds, unless to do so would breach a fiduciary duty, among other provisions.
Senate Bill 903 (Anderson) would have amended the California Public Divest from Iran Act to clarify the criteria and process that the boards of CalPERS and CalSTRS must use to invest in Iran. This bill was held in the Senate Appropriations Committee.
2010: Assembly Bill 2337 (Ammiano) would have prohibited CalPERS and CalSTRS from participating in predatory real estate investment practices related to rent-regulated housing that results in excessive rent increases, the displacement of tenants, or conversion of rent-regulated housing to market rate units. This bill was held in Senate Public Employment and Retirement Committee.
2007: Chapter 671 (AB 221, Anderson) prohibits CalPERS and CalSTRS from investing in companies that have specified energy or defense-related operations in Iran.
2006: Chapter 442 (AB 2941, Koretz) prohibits CalPERS and CalSTRS from investing public employee retirement funds in a company with business operations in Sudan, as specified.
2000: Assembly Bill 107 (Knox) would have prohibited new or additional investments in tobacco companies by CalPERS and CalSTRS on and after January 1, 2001, and would have required divestment from existing investments by July 1, 2002. This bill was held in the Assembly with concurrence pending.
1992: Chapter 1351 (AB 2251, Margolin) prohibits state trust fund and state money investments in business firms or financial institutions that engage in discriminatory business practices after January 1, 1994, relating to the Arab League’s economic boycott of Israel.
1986 Chapter 1254 (AB 134, Waters) prohibits the use of state trust funds or state monies to make additional or new investments, or renew existing investments in firms doing business with or in South Africa, as of January 1, 1987.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
None on file
Opposition
California Special Districts Association
California State Association of Counties
Consul General of Turkey
League of California Cities
Analysis Prepared by: Michael Bolden / P.E. & R. / (916) 319-3957
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):