AB 1341: Private postsecondary education: California Private Postsecondary Education Act of 2009.
- Session Year: 2019-2020
- House: Assembly
- Latest Version Date: 2019-06-27
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Aug 30, 2019 | In committee: Held under submission. |
| Aug 12, 2019 | In committee: Referred to APPR. suspense file. |
| Jul 10, 2019 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 6. Noes 0.) (July 10). Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Jul 1, 2019 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on ED. (Ayes 7. Noes 0.) (July 1). Re-referred to Com. on ED. |
| Jun 27, 2019 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to committee. Read second time, amended, and re-referred to Com. on B., P. & E.D. |
| Jun 17, 2019 | In committee: Set, first hearing. Hearing canceled at the request of author. |
| May 29, 2019 | Referred to Coms. on B., P. & E.D. and ED. |
| May 23, 2019 | In Senate. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. |
| May 22, 2019 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Senate. |
| May 20, 2019 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| May 16, 2019 | From committee: Do pass. (Ayes 18. Noes 0.) (May 16). |
| May 16, 2019 | Joint Rule 62(a), file notice suspended. |
| May 15, 2019 | In committee: Set, first hearing. Referred to APPR. suspense file. |
| May 13, 2019 | Joint Rule 62(a), file notice suspended. (Page 1609.) |
| Apr 24, 2019 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 20. Noes 0.) (April 23). Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Apr 10, 2019 | Coauthors revised. |
| Mar 14, 2019 | Referred to Com. on HIGHER ED. |
| Feb 25, 2019 | Read first time. |
| Feb 23, 2019 | From printer. May be heard in committee March 25. |
| Feb 22, 2019 | Introduced. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Aug 12, 2019 | Placed on suspense file | Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Jul 10, 2019 | Do pass, but first be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Senate Standing Committee on Education |
Passed |
|
| Jul 1, 2019 | Do pass, but first be re-referred to the Committee on [Education] | Senate Standing Committee on Business, Professions and Economic Development |
Passed |
|
| May 22, 2019 | AB 1341 Berman Assembly Third Reading | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| May 16, 2019 | Do pass. | Assembly Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Apr 23, 2019 | Do pass and be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Assembly Standing Committee on Business and Professions |
Passed |
|
| Apr 9, 2019 | Do pass and be re-referred to the Committee on [Business and Professions] | Assembly Standing Committee on Higher Education |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
SENATE COMMITTEE ON
Senator Anthony Portantino, Chair
2019 - 2020 Regular Session
AB 1341 (Berman) - Private postsecondary education: California Private Postsecondary Education Act of 2009
Version: | Policy Vote: |
Urgency: | Mandate: |
Hearing Date: | Consultant: |
Bill Summary:
Assembly Bill 1341 would prohibit the Bureau for Private Postsecondary Education (Bureau or BPPE) from verifying the exemption from its oversight, or contracting to handle complaints for, a nonprofit institution that operated as a for-profit institution during any period on or after January 1, 2010, unless the Attorney General makes certain determinations.
Fiscal Impact:
- Department of Justice. $295,000 General Fund in FY 2019-20 and $512,000 General Fund in FY 2020-21, and ongoing, for 1.0 Investigative Auditor, 1.0 Deputy Attorney General, and 1.0 Legal Secretary for the Attorney General to investigate whether the institution meets the definition of a non-profit corporation to ensure that institutions are independently run, have not engaged in questionable activities, and does not compensate staff on an equity or revenue basis.
- BPPE. No anticipated fiscal impact to the Bureau. Because the bill would amend the definition of a nonprofit corporation and a public institution of higher education, there may be an increase in pre-authorization time. The Bureau would coordinate with the Attorney General’s Office to obtain verification of applicable institutions but does not anticipate the increase in processing times to be significant.
Background:
The BPPE is responsible for protecting students against fraud, misrepresentation, or other business practices at private postsecondary institutions; and for establishing and enforcing business and instructional quality standards. Under the California Private Postsecondary Act of 2009 (AB 48, Portantino, Chapter 310, Statutes of 2009), the Bureau must oversee private postsecondary institutions and can take formal actions, including closure, against an institution/school. The Bureau must also administer the Student Tuition Recovery Fund (STRF), which provides refunds to students affected by the possible closure of an institution/school, by the institutions' failure to refund or reimburse loan proceeds, or by the institutions' failure to pay students' restitution award. The BPPE also enables institutions to receive public funds through the federal Title IV financial aid programs.
Nonprofit status for colleges provides several benefits, including federal income tax exemptions, access to public dollars, and reputational advantages. However, there is recent evidence of formerly for-profit colleges that flow money through publically-traded affiliates. For example, Purdue University Global claims “public” college through its affiliation with Indiana’s public Purdue University, however Purdue University Global is a limited liability corporation and is exempt from state public records laws, state audit requirements, and is jointly operated by Kaplan Higher Education, which is traded on the New York Stock Exchange.
Proposed Law:
AB 1341 would prohibit the Bureau from verifying the exemption from Bureau oversight, or contract for the complaint handling for, a nonprofit institution that operated as a for-profit institution during any period on or after January 1, 2010, unless the Attorney General determines all of the following:
- The institution acquired the institution’s assets for no more than the value of the assets.
- The institution has not executed agreements for goods or services exceeding the value of the goods or services.
- All core functions of the institution are conducted by, under the control of, or subject to significant direction by the institution, rather than a person or entity that a public institution of higher education or a nonprofit corporation.
- The institution has not committed a substantial share of the institution’s assets to a joint venture with a person or entity, unless the joint venture is with an entity that is a public institution of higher education or nonprofit corporation, and all core functions of the venture are conducted by, under the control of, or subject to significant direction from that entity.
The bill also would define several terms, including “nonprofit corporation”, “public institution of higher education”, and “value.”
Related Legislation:
- AB 1340 (Chiu) would require the Bureau of Private Postsecondary Education (BPPE) to collect specified data on graduates of private postsecondary institutions, and to publish program- and institution-based aggregate debt-to-income information on the Bureau’s website based on information matched with wage data provided by the Employment Development Division (EDD). The bill is pending in the Senate Appropriations Committee.
- AB 1342 (Bauer-Kahan, 2019) would require a nonprofit corporation that operates or controls a private postsecondary educational institution to obtain the Attorney General’s consent before entering into certain agreements or transactions. AB 1342 is pending on the Senate Appropriations Committee suspense file.
- AB 1343 (Eggman, 2019) would have, beginning January 1, 2023, prohibited new enrollments at a private postsecondary educational institution, unless the institution meets one of two specified scenarios about the institution’s tuition revenue composition. AB 1343 is in the Senate Business, Professions, and Economic Development Committee.
- AB 1344 (Bauer-Kahan, 2019) would, effective July 1, 2022, require an out-of-state private postsecondary educational institution to provide the Bureau with specified information regarding whether or not a specified entity, has been subject to certain adverse state or federal actions in the previous 5 years before seeking authorization to operate in California. AB 1344 is pending in the Senate Appropriations Committee.
- AB 1345 (McCarty, 2019) would revise existing restrictions on private postsecondary school enrollment recruitment compensation. The bill would exempt nonprofit, regionally accredited institutions that grant undergraduate or graduate degrees, or both, from the Act. AB 1345 is in the Senate Appropriations Committee.
- AB 1346 (Medina, 2019) expands the definition of “economic loss,” as it pertains to the Student Tuition Recovery Fund (STRF). AB 1346 is in the Senate Appropriations Committee.
-- END --
SENATE COMMITTEE ON EDUCATION
Senator Connie Leyva, Chair
2019 - 2020 Regular
Bill No: AB 1341 Hearing Date: July 10, 2019
Author: | |||
Version: | June 27, 2019 | ||
Urgency: | No | Fiscal: | Yes |
Consultant: | Olgalilia Ramirez | ||
Subject: Private postsecondary education: California Private Postsecondary Education Act of 2009.
SUMMARY
This bill prohibits the Bureau for Private For-Profit Postsecondary Education (bureau) from verifying an exemption from bureau oversight for a nonprofit that operated as a for-profit institution unless the Attorney General makes certain determinations.
BACKGROUND
Existing law:
- Establishes the California Private Postsecondary Act of 2009 and requires the bureau to, among other things, review, investigate and approve private postsecondary institutions, programs and courses of instruction and authorizes bureau to take formal actions against an institution/school to ensure compliance with the Act, including seeking closure of an institution/school if determined necessary. The Act also provides for specified disclosures and enrollment agreements for students, requirements for cancellations, withdrawals and refunds, and that bureau shall administer the STRF to provide refunds to students affected by the possible closure of an institution/school. Existing law repeals the act on January 1, 2021. (Education Code (EC) § 94800 et seq.)
2) Exempts the following from oversight by the Bureau:
a) An institution that offers solely avocational or recreational educational programs.
b) An institution offering educational programs sponsored by a bona fide trade, business, professional, or fraternal organization, solely for that organization's membership.
c) A bona fide organization, association or council that offers pre-apprenticeship training programs on behalf of one or more Division of Apprenticeship Standards-approved labor-management or apprenticeship programs that is not on the Eligible Training Provider List (ETPL) currently but has met requirements for placement on the list, that is on the ETPL and that has not been removed from the ETPL for failure to meet performance standards.
d) A postsecondary educational institution established, operated, and governed by the federal government or by this state or its political subdivisions.
e) An institution offering either test preparation for examinations required for admission to a postsecondary educational institution or continuing education or license examination preparation, if the institution or the program is approved, certified, or sponsored by a government agency, other than bureau, that licenses persons in a particular profession, occupation, trade, or career field, a state-recognized professional licensing body, such as the State Bar of California, that licenses persons in a particular profession, occupation, trade, or career field or a bona fide trade, business, or professional organization.
f) An institution owned, controlled, and operated and maintained by a religious organization lawfully operating as a nonprofit religious corporation whose instruction is limited to the principles of that religious organization and the diploma or degree granted is limited to evidence of completion of that education. The institution is only eligible to offer degrees and diplomas in the beliefs and practices of the church, religious denomination, or religious organization and shall not award degrees in any area of physical science. Any degree or diploma granted by an institution owned, controlled, and operated and maintained by a religious organization lawfully operating as a nonprofit religious corporation shall contain on its face, in the written description of the title of the degree being conferred, a reference to the theological or religious aspect of the degree's subject area. The degree must reflect the nature of the degree title, such as "associate of religious studies," "bachelor of religious studies," "master of divinity," or "doctor of divinity."
g) An institution that does not award degrees and that solely provides educational programs for total charges of two thousand five hundred dollars ($2,500) or less when no part of the total charges is paid from state or federal student financial aid programs.
h) A law school that is accredited by the Council of the Section of Legal Education and Admissions to the Bar of the American Bar Association or a law school or law study program that is subject to the approval, regulation, and oversight of the Committee of Bar Examiners.
i) A nonprofit public benefit corporation that is qualified under Section 501(c)(3) of the United States Internal Revenue Code, is organized specifically to provide workforce development or rehabilitation services and is accredited by an accrediting organization for workforce development or rehabilitation services recognized by the Department of Rehabilitation.
j) An institution that is accredited by the Accrediting Commission for Senior Colleges (ACSC) and Universities, Western Association of Schools and Colleges (WASC), or the Accrediting Commission for Community and Junior Colleges (ACCJC).
k) Flight instruction providers or programs that provide flight instruction pursuant to Federal Aviation Administration (FAA) regulations and do not require students to enter into written or oral contracts of indebtedness and do not require or accept prepayment of instruction-related costs in excess of $2,500.
L) An institution owned, controlled, operated, and maintained by a community-based organization, as specified. (EC § 94874)
3) Also provides an exemption from the California Private Postsecondary Education Act (Act) and oversight by bureau for an institution that is accredited by the ACSC and WASC, or ACCJC that meets all of the following:
a) Has been accredited by a United States Department of Education (USDE) recognized accrediting agency for at least 10 years and has not been placed on probation or on monitoring or sanctioned.
b) Is headquartered in California and has operated continuously for at least 25 years.
c) Is privately held and was previously granted an approval to operate by the bureau or the former bureau and has not changed ownership since its last approval.
d) Has not filed for bankruptcy protection.
e) Maintains an equity ratio composite score of at least 1.5.
f) Derives at least 12.5 percent of its revenues from sources other than state or federal student assistance like Title 38 and Cal Grant monies.
g) Does not have a cohort default rate over 13 percent for the most recent 3 years.
h) Has a graduation rate that exceeds 60 percent.
i) Has not been subject to any legal or regulatory actions by a state Attorney General that resulted in monetary settlement, fines or other documented violations.
j) Provides a pro-rata refund of unearned institutional charges to students who complete 75 percent or less of the period of attendance.
k) Complies with other reasonable criteria established by the California State Approving Agency for Veterans Education.
l) Verifies its exemption with the bureau. (EC § 94947)
4) Requires institutions exempt from the Act to still comply with laws relating to
school closure and laws relating to fraud, abuse, and false advertising. (EC § 94874.9)
ANALYSIS
This bill:
- Prohibits the bureau from verifying the exemption from the Act, or contract for the complaint handling for, a nonprofit institution that operated as a for-profit institution during any period on or after January 1, 2010, unless the Attorney General determines all of the following:
- The institution acquired the institution’s assets for no more than the value
of the assets.
- The institution has not executed agreements for goods or services
exceeding the value of the goods or services.
- All core functions of the institution are conducted by, under the control of,
or subject to significant direction by the institution, rather than a person or entity that a public institution of higher education or a nonprofit corporation.
- The institution has not committed a substantial share of the institution’s
assets to a joint venture with a person or entity, unless the joint venture is with an entity that is a public institution of higher education or nonprofit corporation and all core functions of the venture are conducted by, under the control of, or subject to significant direction from that entity.
- Requires that “value,” which includes the value of any ongoing relationship, including any contract, agreement, lease, or other arrangement between the acquiring institution and the acquired institution or assets, as described, between the procuring institution and the procured goods or services, be demonstrated through one of the following:
- A third-party appraisal based on comparable assets acquired by, or
goods or services procured by, nonprofit corporations.
- Independent financing of the acquisition or procurement based upon the
assets acquired or goods or services procured.
- Full and open competition, as defined in federal regulations, in the
acquisition of the assets or procurement of the goods or services.
- Defines “public institution of higher education,” to mean any of the following:
- A campus, branch of the California Community Colleges, California State
University of the University of California.
- An institution operated by the United States government, a state or Indian
tribal government, as defined in federal law.
- An institution that is an instrumentality of a state or local government if it
meets all of the following:
- The institution’s employees are government employees.
- The institution’s liabilities are payable to the same degree as if they
were liabilities of the state or local government, as specified.
- The institution is subject to the same financial oversight and open
public records laws as the state or local government, as specified.
- Defines a nonprofit corporation to mean an institution to which contributions have been determined by the United States Internal Revenue Service to be tax-deductible and is subject to the limitations described in the bill.
- Specifies that only an institution of higher education meeting the act’s definition of nonprofit corporation or public institution of higher education is exempt from the requirements imposed on an out-of-state private postsecondary educational institution.
STAFF COMMENTS
- Need for the bill. According to the author, “Some for-profit colleges are using complicated financial schemes and shell corporations to covertly pose as nonprofit or public institutions, misleading students while dodging appropriate oversight.”
The author asserts, “This emerging problem is already affecting California students. For example:
Grand Canyon University. The CEO of Grand Canyon Education, Inc., a for-profit company traded on NASDAQ, also serves as the President of an affiliated nonprofit, Grand Canyon University, and about 60 percent of the tuition revenue that the “nonprofit” college receives flows through to the for-profit company. According to Georgetown Law Professor Brian Galle, an expert in nonprofit law, the nonprofit is essentially “a trustworthy-looking wrapper around a for-profit business.” Grand Canyon University reported more than 7,000 California enrollments in 2016-17.
Ashford University. Owned by Bridgepoint Education, Inc., and based in San Diego, Ashford University has been sued by the California Attorney General for misleading prospective students and has been called a “poster child for the ills of the for-profit college sector.” Meanwhile, the company announced in March 2018 that it would follow the Grand Canyon University approach to claiming nonprofit status. In fact, on February 15, 2019, Ashford University announced that it received determination from the Internal Revenue Service that it is exempt from federal income tax under Internal Revenue Code (IRC) Section 501 (c) (3). In 2016 Ashford University reported more than 16,000 online students. According to a June 19th article in the San Diego Union-Tribune, “Bridgepoint/Zovio is spinning off Ashford University into an independent, not-for-profit higher education institution. Ashford has agreed to contract with Bridgepoint/Zovio to provide online education technology tools.” State-specific figures are not available for Ashford University.
Purdue University Global. While claiming to be a “public” college because of its affiliation with Indiana’s public Purdue University, Purdue University Global (PUG) is actually a limited liability corporation for which the state refuses any financial responsibility, and which is exempt from state public records laws; exempt from state audit requirements; and exempt from state open meeting laws. The institution is jointly operated by Purdue and PUG, which was formerly owned by Kaplan Higher Education. Kaplan Higher Education, which is traded on the New York Stock Exchange, has formal roles in governing PUG and gets a share of profits. Kaplan Higher Education reported more than 2,000 California enrollments in 2016-17.
Others. Several smaller chains with ground campuses, including one in California (California College San Diego), are attempting to illicitly claim nonprofit status. Their tactics include disguising profits as rent and loan payments to former owners who take on governance roles in the nonprofit entity, and installing employees and business partners as nonprofit trustees.”
This bill aims to establish an oversight mechanism to verify nonprofit status prior to deeming an institution exempt from certain regulations designed to monitor educational quality and business practices of private colleges.
- Exemption from bureau oversight. The bureau has oversight of all of the non-exempt, private postsecondary institutions located in California. Current law contains exemptions to state-level oversight, including for avocational or recreational programs, educational programs offered for members of a business or professional association, pre-apprenticeship programs offered by specific types of organizations, test preparation providers, religious institutions, low-cost programs that do not receive public funds, WASC-accredited institutions, specified nationally accredited nonprofit institutions, and flight schools. An exempt institution is not regulated by the bureau. Students enrolled in exempt institutions are not protected by the Act, including access to the STRF, which provides reimbursement to students for bureau-regulated institutions that violate the law or closed abruptly. This measure specifies that prior to the bureau making the determination to exempt for its oversight a nonprofit institution that operated as a for-profit from, the AG’s office must first make certain determination.
- Why the Attorney General? Opponents have raised concerns, that while the Attorney General has the responsibility of supervising charities and charitable trust in the state, the office does not make the initial determination on exempt status. The opposition asserts that it is the California Franchise Tax Board (FTB) that must determine a charity or nonprofit organization’s status and that FTB has the expertise and review process already in place to make such a determination. However, the author asserts that the Attorney General is the appropriate arbiter for the situation outlined in the bill, as there are several circumstances under which California statutes call on the Attorney General to be the expert on what is appropriate for a nonprofit. Those circumstances include when a nonprofit wants to sell any assets (advance notice to the Attorney General is required, and the Attorney General may insist on an independent appraisal), dissolve (Attorney General review and approval required), or engage in certain types of conversions or mergers (Attorney General approval required).
Staff notes Since 1997, California law has required nonprofit health facilities that are subject to public benefit corporation law to obtain written consent from AG prior to entering into an agreement to sell, transfer, lease, exchange, option, convey, or otherwise dispose of assets, or transfer control or governance of assets. There is then a public review process in which the AG reviews the terms of the agreement, evaluates the potential impact the sale would have on the affected community, and decides whether to grant approval. Approved sales typically come with enforceable conditions to preserve standards of care and ensure that a commercial transaction involving charitably-funded assets does not occur to the detriment of the community. Arguably, it may also be appropriate to grant the AG the power to oversee transactions in which a private for-profit educational institution converts to a nonprofit, given its existing role in reviewing nonprofit status of other entities.
- Double-referral. This bill was previously heard by the Senate Business, Professions and Economic Development (BPED) Committee which has jurisdiction over bills relating to business and professional practices and periodically conducts sunset review of various boards and licensing agencies, including the Bureau. The BPED analysis raised questions regarding the need for greater clarity on the process for notifying the bureau and nonprofit of the AG’s determination that an institution complies with the required criteria. Senate Education Committee staff understands that the author’s office is working toward providing this clarification in the bill as it moves forward.
- Related legislation.
AB 1342 (Low, 2019) requires a nonprofit corporation that operates or controls a private postsecondary educational institution to obtain the Attorney General’s consent before entering into certain agreements or transactions, including an agreement or transaction to sell or convey its assets to, or to transfer control, responsibility, or governance of a material amount of its assets to, a for-profit corporation or mutual benefit corporation. This bill was approved by this committee on June 19 and is currently in the Senate Appropriations Committee.
AB 1344 (Bauer-Kahan, 2019) expands existing requirements that out-of-state private postsecondary educational institutions register with, and report information to, the bureau to include additional information regarding adverse actions and to authorize the bureau upon review to revoke an out-of-state school’s ability to enroll students in California, as specified. AB 1344 is also on the committee’s agenda today.
AB 1340 (Chiu, 2019) requires certain private postsecondary schools to report to the bureau information about their graduates and match that information with wage data from the Employment Development Department. It also requires the Bureau to make available on its website information regarding the earnings levels of graduates and student debt information. AB 1340 is also on the committee’s agenda today.
AB 1345 (McCarty, 2019) revises existing restrictions on private postsecondary school enrollment recruitment compensation to prohibit institutions from paying a person by means of a commission, bonus, quota, or other similar method contingent upon student recruitment, enrollment, admissions, attendance, financial aid, or sales of educational materials. AB 1345 is also on the committee’s agenda today.
AB 1346 (Medina, 2019) expands the definition of “economic loss,” as it pertains to the Student Tuition Recovery Fund (STRF), to include all amounts paid by a student to the institution, any amounts paid in connection with attending the institution, and all principal, interest, and charges of any kind for any loan incurred by the student to pay these amounts. AB 1346 is also on the committee’s agenda today.
AB 1342 (Bauer-Kahan, 2019) requires a nonprofit corporation that operates or controls a private postsecondary educational institution to obtain the Attorney General’s (AG) consent before entering into certain agreements or transactions, including an agreement or transaction to sell or convey its assets to, or to transfer control, responsibility, or governance of a material amount of its assets to, a for-profit corporation or mutual benefit corporation. AB 1342 was approved by this committee and is pending in Senate Appropriations Committee.
SUPPORT
California Conference of the American Association of University Professors
California Faculty Association
California Low-Income Consumer Coalition
Children’s Advocacy Institute Center for Public Interest Law
Consumer Federation of California
Consumer Reports Advocacy
Housing and Economic Rights Advocates
National Student Legal Defense Network
NextGen California
Public Advocates
Public Counsel
Public Law Center
SEIU California
The Century Foundation
The Institute for College Access and Success
Veterans Education Success
Veterans Legal Clinic
OPPOSITION
Zovio
-- END --
SENATE COMMITTEE ON
BUSINESS, PROFESSIONS AND ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT
Senator Steven Glazer, Chair
2019 - 2020 Regular
Bill No: Hearing Date: July 1, 2019
Author: | |||
Version: | June 27, 2019 | ||
Urgency: | No | Fiscal: | Yes |
Consultant: | Sarah Mason | ||
Subject:
SUMMARY: Prohibits the Bureau for Private Postsecondary Education (BPPE) from approving an exemption or handling complaints for a nonprofit institution that the Attorney General (AG) determines does not meet specified criteria of a nonprofit corporation.
NOTE:
This bill is referred, second, to the Senate Committee on Education.
Existing law:
- Establishes the California Private Postsecondary Education Act of 2009 (Act), until January 1, 2021, and requires the BPPE or Bureau within the Department of Consumer Affairs (DCA) to, among other things, review, investigate and approve private postsecondary institutions, programs and courses of instruction pursuant to the Act and authorizes BPPE to take formal actions against an institution/school to ensure compliance with the Act to include closure of an institution/school, if determined necessary. The Act provides for specified disclosures and enrollment agreements for students, requirements for cancellations, withdrawals and refunds, and the BPPE is required to administer the Student Tuition Recovery Fund (STRF) to provide refunds to students affected by the possible closure of an institution/school. (Education Code (EC) § 94800 et seq.)
- Establishes an Office of Student Assistance and Relief (Office) for the purpose of advancing and promoting the rights of prospective students, current students, or past students of private postsecondary educational institutions. Tasks the Office with: conducting outreach and providing information and assistance to students who have been affected by the unlawful activities or closure of an institution; serving as a primary point of contact to address the needs of private postsecondary education students and working in consultation with state and federal agencies, including, but not limited to, CSAC, the Office of the Chancellor of the California Community Colleges, the Department of Veterans Affairs, the federal Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, and the United States Department of Education. Authorizes the Office to provide outreach to students and prospective students to provide them with, among other information, information on making informed decisions in selecting postsecondary educational institutions, student rights regarding school performance disclosures, enrollment agreements, and cancellation and refund policies, how to contact the office and the bureau for assistance, student loan rights and assistance, and free nonprofit community based resources. (EC §§ 94949.7 - 94949.73)
- Defines “out-of-state private postsecondary educational institution” as a private entity without a physical presence in this state that offers distance education to California students for an institutional charge, regardless of whether the institution has affiliated institutions or institutional locations in California. (EC § 94850.5)
- Requires an out-of-state private postsecondary educational institution (other than a nonpublic higher education institution that grants undergraduate degrees, graduate degrees, or both, formed as nonprofit corporation and accredited by an agency recognized by the United States Department of Education) to register with the BPPE, pay a fee and provide evidence of accreditation; evidence that the institution is approved to operate in the state where the institution maintains its main administrative location and; a copy of the institution’s catalog and sample enrollment agreement. Requires these institutions to comply with STRF requirements and disclosures. Prohibits an institution from operating in California for failure to comply with the registration requirements. Establishes the validity of a BPPE registration for two years. (EC § 94801.5)
- Exempts the following from oversight by the Bureau: (EC § 94874)
- An institution that offers solely avocational or recreational educational programs.
- An institution offering educational programs sponsored by a bona fide trade, business, professional, or fraternal organization, solely for that organization's membership.
- A bona fide organization, association or council that offers preapprenticeship training programs on behalf of one or more Division of Apprenticeship Standards-approved labor-management or apprenticeship programs that is not on the Eligible Training Provider List (ETPL) currently but has met requirements for placement on the list, that is on the ETPL and that has not been removed from the ETPL for failure to meet performance standards.
- A postsecondary educational institution established, operated, and governed by the federal government or by this state or its political subdivisions.
- An institution offering either test preparation for examinations required for admission to a postsecondary educational institution or continuing education or license examination preparation, if the institution or the program is approved, certified, or sponsored by a government agency, other than BPPE, that licenses persons in a particular profession, occupation, trade, or career field, a state-recognized professional licensing body, such as the State Bar of California, that licenses persons in a particular profession, occupation, trade, or career field or a bona fide trade, business, or professional organization
- An institution owned, controlled, and operated and maintained by a religious organization lawfully operating as a nonprofit religious corporation whose instruction is limited to the principles of that religious organization and the diploma or degree granted is limited to evidence of completion of that education. The institution is only eligible to offer degrees and diplomas in the beliefs and practices of the church, religious denomination, or religious organization and shall not award degrees in any area of physical science. Any degree or diploma granted by an institution owned, controlled, and operated and maintained by a religious organization lawfully operating as a nonprofit religious corporation shall contain on its face, in the written description of the title of the degree being conferred, a reference to the theological or religious aspect of the degree's subject area. The degree must reflect the nature of the degree title, such as "associate of religious studies," "bachelor of religious studies," "master of divinity," or "doctor of divinity."
- An institution that does not award degrees and that solely provides educational programs for total charges of two thousand five hundred dollars ($2,500) or less when no part of the total charges is paid from state or federal student financial aid programs.
- A law school that is accredited by the Council of the Section of Legal Education and Admissions to the Bar of the American Bar Association or a law school or law study program that is subject to the approval, regulation, and oversight of the Committee of Bar Examiners.
- A nonprofit public benefit corporation that is qualified under Section 501(c)(3) of the United States Internal Revenue Code, is organized specifically to provide workforce development or rehabilitation services and is accredited by an accrediting organization for workforce development or rehabilitation services recognized by the Department of Rehabilitation.
- An institution that is accredited by the Accrediting Commission for Senior Colleges (ACSC) and Universities, WASC, or the Accrediting Commission for Community and Junior Colleges (ACCJC).
- Flight instruction providers or programs that provide flight instruction pursuant to Federal Aviation Administration (FAA) regulations and do not require students to enter into written or oral contracts of indebtedness and do not require or accept prepayment of instruction-related costs in excess of $2,500.
- An institution owned, controlled, operated, and maintained by a community-based organization, that has programs on, or is applying for some or all of their programs to be on the ETPL, that is registered as a nonprofit entity, does not offer degrees or educational programs designed to lead to a specific job requiring licensure if BPPE approval is required for the student to be eligible for licensure; the institution would otherwise be exempt from BPPE oversight if not for the fact that it receives funding under the federal Workforce Innovation and Opportunity Act (WIOA). Requires an institution exempt pursuant to these requirements to provide the Employment Development Department (EDD) information and data necessary to comply with performance reporting requirements pursuant to WIOA and cannot charge participants.
- Also provides an exemption from the Act and oversight by BPPE for one school located in Sacramento which meets the following requirements: the institution is accredited by the ACSC and WASC, or ACCJC and has been accredited by a USDE recognized accrediting agency for at least 10 years and has not been placed on probation or on monitoring or sanctioned; is headquartered in California and has operated continuously for at least 25 years; is privately held and was previously granted an approval to operate by the BPPE or the former Bureau and has not changed ownership since its last approval; has not filed for bankruptcy protection; maintains an equity ratio composite score of at least 1.5; derives at least 12.5 percent of its revenues from sources other than state or federal student assistance like veterans GI bill monies (Title 38) and state loan monies (CalGrant); does not have a cohort default rate over 13 percent for the most recent 3 years; has a graduation rate that exceeds 60 percent; has not been subject to any legal or regulatory actions by a state AG that resulted in monetary settlement, fines or other documented violations; provides a pro rata refund of unearned institutional charges to students who complete 75 percent or less of the period of attendance; complies with other reasonable criteria established by the California State Approving Agency for Veterans Education (CSAAVE); and verifies its exemption with BPPE. (EC § 94947)
- Requires a nonprofit corporation that operates or controls a health facility to provide written notice to, and obtain the written consent of, the AG prior to selling or otherwise disposing of a material amount of its assets to a for-profit corporation or entity, a mutual benefit corporation, or to another nonprofit corporation, regardless of whether it is currently operating or providing health care services or has a suspended or canceled license. (Corporations Code (CC) § 5914(a)(1).)
- Provides the AG discretion to consent to, give conditional consent to, or not consent to any agreement or transaction regarding the sale or disposal of a nonprofit health facility’s assets. Requires the AG to notify the nonprofit corporation in writing of the decision to consent to, give conditional consent to, or not consent to the agreement or transaction. In making this determination, requires the AG to consider any factors the AG deems relevant, including, but not limited to, whether any of the following apply:
- the terms and conditions of the agreement or transaction are fair and reasonable to the nonprofit corporation;
- the proposed agreement or transaction is in the public interest; and
- the agreement or transaction may create a significant effect on the availability or accessibility of health care services to the affected community. (CC §§ 5917 and 5921)
- Specifies that the Uniform Supervision of Trustees for Charitable Purposes Act applies to all charitable corporations, unincorporated associations, trustees, and other legal entities holding property for charitable purposes, commercial fundraisers for charitable purposes, fundraising counsel for charitable purposes, and commercial coventurers, over which the state or the AG has enforcement or supervisory powers. Exempts a charitable corporation or unincorporated association organized primarily as an educational institution from the filing, registration, and reporting provisions of this act. (Government Code §§ 12580-12599.8)
This bill:
- Defines “nonprofit corporation” as an institution to which contributions have been determined by the United States Internal Revenue Service to be tax-deductible pursuant to 501(c)(3) of the Internal Revenue Code, subject to the limitations described in this bill.
- Defines “public institution of higher education” as:
- An institution that meets the existing definition of higher public education, including a district or campus of the California Community Colleges.
- An institution operated by the United States government, a state, or Indian tribal government.
- An institution that is an instrumentality of a state or local government if its employees are government employees, if its liabilities are payable to the same degree as if they were liabilities of the state or local government, in the state or local government jurisdiction where the institution is formed, and if it is subject to the same financial oversight and open public records laws as the state or local government, in the state or local government jurisdiction where the institution is formed.
- Prohibits BPPE from verifying the exemption of, or contracting for the complaint handling for, a nonprofit institution that operated as a for-profit institution during any period on or after January 1, 2010, unless the AG determines all of the following:
- The institution acquired the institution’s assets for no more than the value of the assets.
- The institution has not executed agreements for goods or services exceeding the value of the goods or services.
- All core functions of the institution are conducted by, under the control of, or subject to significant direction by the institution, rather than a person or entity that a public institution of higher education or a nonprofit corporation.
- The institution has not committed a substantial share of the institution’s assets to a joint venture with a person or entity, unless the joint venture is with an entity that is a public institution of higher education or nonprofit corporation, and all core functions of the venture are conducted by, under the control of, or subject to significant direction from that entity.
- Defines “value” to include the value of any ongoing relationship, including any contract, agreement, lease, or other arrangement between the acquiring institution and the acquired institution or asset, or between the procuring institution and the procured goods or services, demonstrated through one of the following:
- A third-party appraisal based on comparable assets acquired by, or goods or services procured by, nonprofit corporations.
- Independent financing of the acquisition or procurement based upon the asset acquired or goods or services procured.
- Full and open competition in the acquisition of the assets or procurement of the goods and services, as defined in federal regulations, as it read on January 1, 2020.
FISCAL EFFECT:
Unknown. This bill is keyed fiscal by Legislative Counsel.
COMMENTS:
- Purpose. The Author is the Sponsor of this bill. According to the Author:
“Rampant deceptive or unfair treatment of students is rare at legitimate nonprofit and public colleges because financial restrictions make it difficult for school leaders to profit from bad behavior. Being a nonprofit has traditionally required an institution to both:
- devote all of its revenues to its educational purpose, and
- prohibit any form of profit-taking, so that those in control are not tempted to take advantage of students or the public.
These restrictions have been so effective in protecting students that state and federal laws frequently provide funding only to nonprofit and public institutions, or apply stricter guidelines if for-profit colleges seek access to taxpayer funds.
Some for-profit colleges, however, are starting to use a ‘nonprofit’ or ‘public’ label to attract students who are suspicious of for-profit colleges, and to escape regulatory oversight.
A decline in enforcement of nonprofit status by the federal Internal Revenue Service is allowing some for-profit colleges to get away with using complicated financial schemes and shell corporations to lay claim to nonprofit status, but without adopting the restrictions that actually protect students.
This emerging problem is already affecting California students. For example:
Grand Canyon University. The CEO of Grand Canyon Education, Inc., a for-profit company traded on NASDAQ, also serves as the President of an affiliated nonprofit, Grand Canyon University, and about 60% of the tuition revenue that the “nonprofit” college receives flows through to the for-profit company. According to Georgetown Law Professor Brian Galle, an expert in nonprofit law, the nonprofit is essentially “a trustworthy-looking wrapper around a for-profit business.” Grand Canyon University reported more than 7,000 California enrollments in 2016-17.
Ashford University. Owned by Bridgepoint Education, Inc., and based in San Diego, Ashford University has been sued by the California Attorney General for misleading prospective students and has been called a “poster child for the ills of the for-profit college sector.” Meanwhile, the company announced in March 2018 that it would follow the Grand Canyon University approach to claiming nonprofit status. In fact, on February 15, 2019, Ashford University announced that it received determination from the Internal Revenue Service that it is exempt from federal income tax under Internal Revenue Code (IRC) Section 501 (c) (3). In 2016 Ashford University reported more than 16,000 online students. According to a June 19th article in the San Diego Union-Tribune, “Bridgepoint/Zovio is spinning off Ashford University into an independent, not-for-profit higher education institution. Ashford has agreed to contract with Bridgepoint/Zovio to provide online education technology tools.” State-specific figures are not available for Ashford University.
Purdue University Global. While claiming to be a “public” college because of its affiliation with Indiana’s public Purdue University, Purdue University Global (PUG) is actually a limited liability corporation for which the state refuses any financial responsibility, and which is exempt from state public records laws; exempt from state audit requirements; and exempt from state open meeting laws. The institution is jointly operated by Purdue and PUG, which was formerly owned by Kaplan Higher Education. Kaplan Higher Education, which is traded on the New York Stock Exchange, has formal roles in governing PUG and gets a share of profits. Kaplan Higher Education reported more than 2,000 California enrollments in 2016-17.
Others. Several smaller chains with ground campuses, including one in California (California College San Diego), are attempting to illicitly claim nonprofit status. Their tactics include disguising profits as rent and loan payments to former owners who take on governance roles in the nonprofit entity, and installing employees and business partners as nonprofit trustees.
Unfortunately, California cannot rely on the U.S. Department of Education to solve this problem. Despite the poor record of some federally-funded for-profit colleges and scandals that have plagued the for-profit industry, the federal government refuses to admit that investor control of colleges is hazardous to students and taxpayers and require greater oversight and scrutiny. Therefore, California must step up and step in to protect our students and ensure that appropriate oversight remains.”
- Background.
BPPE. BPPE is generally responsible for protecting consumers and students against fraud, misrepresentation, or other business practices at private postsecondary institutions that may lead to loss of students’ tuition and related educational funds; establishing and enforcing minimum standards for ethical business practices and the health and safety and fiscal integrity of postsecondary education institutions; and establishing and enforcing minimum standards for instructional quality and institutional stability for all students in all types of private postsecondary educational and vocational institutions.
The United States Department of Education (USDE) establishes that states are responsible for providing primary protection of consumers and students attending postsecondary educational institutions. BPPE approval not only authorizes institutions to operate and serve students in California but also enables institutions to receive public funds through the federal Title IV financial aid programs.
The BPPE is responsible for oversight of private postsecondary educational institutions operating with a physical presence in California. Established by AB 48 (Portantino, Chapter 310, Statutes of 2009) after numerous legislative attempts to remedy the laws and structure governing regulation of private postsecondary institutions, the bill took effect January 1, 2010, to make many substantive changes that created a foundation for oversight and gave the BPPE enforcement tools to ensure schools comply with the law.
AB 48 established BPPE’s authority to regulate private postsecondary institutions and enforce the provisions of the new Act and to respond to the major problems with the former laws governing the industry in California. The Act provides for prohibitions on false advertising and inappropriate recruiting and requires disclosure of critical information to students such as program outlines, graduation and job placement rates, and license examination information, and ensures colleges justify those figures. The Act also provides BPPE with enforcement powers necessary to protect consumers. The Act directs BPPE to:
- Create a structure that provides an appropriate level of oversight, including approval of private postsecondary educational institutions and programs;
- Establish minimum operating standards for California private postsecondary educational institutions to ensure quality education for students;
- Provide students a meaningful opportunity to have their complaints resolved;
- Ensure that private postsecondary educational institutions offer accurate information to prospective students on school and student performance; and,
- Ensure that all stakeholders have a voice and are heard in the operations and rulemaking process of BPPE.
BPPE is also tasked with actively investigating and combatting unlicensed activity, administering the STRF, and conducting outreach and education activities for students and private postsecondary educational institutions within the state. The STRF is an important tool to assist harmed students. STRF exists to relieve or mitigate economic loss suffered by students enrolled at non-exempt private postsecondary education institutions due to the institutions' closure, the institutions' failure to pay refunds or reimburse loan proceeds, or the institutions' failure to pay students' restitution award for a violation of the Act.
Private postsecondary institutions play an important role in ensuring access to higher educational opportunities for California’s students. The landscape of schools that are now regulated under BPPE, and that have become central in California’s discussion of private postsecondary education, has evolved significantly in recent decades. The smaller, independent for-profit institutions that made up the bulk of the former-Bureau’s licensee population have shifted. Today, a large number of California students are being served by multi-campus, publicly-traded institutions with a national presence. These institutions also receive significant public funds; under federal law, up to 90 percent of revenues can come from the Title IV financial aid program and at least 10 percent of revenues must come from non-Title IV sources ("90/10 rule"); however, this can include state aid, veteran's aid, and private loans (among other sources). High-profile state and federal investigations have revealed deceptive and illegal practices by some institutions within the sector. Federal regulators responded by increasing student outcome and institutional accountability measures. Specifically, in California, BPPE’s approval can enable these institutions to access the Title IV program; USDE relies on the Bureau to provide oversight and student protection.
Students, the public, and quality private postsecondary educational institutions are best served by a well-functioning regulatory entity that effectively enforces the Act. BPPE has faced significant difficulties in implementing the law. It is important that California’s approval and oversight of an institution assures minimum quality and student protections.
AG review of conversions. Since 1997, California law has required nonprofit health facilities that are subject to public benefit corporation law to obtain written consent from AG prior to entering into an agreement to sell, transfer, lease, exchange, option, convey, or otherwise dispose of assets, or transfer control or governance of assets. Additionally, the AG is required to conduct at least one public meeting in the county where the health facility is located before issuing a written opinion making the determination whether to consent to, give conditional consent to, or not consent to any elimination or reduction of emergency medical services. The AG has also had the ability to contract with experts regarding information needed to make this determination and obtain reimbursement for the costs of this contract from the health facilities being reviewed since 1997.
- Related Legislation This Year. AB 1340 (Chiu) would require institutions regulated by the BPPE to report identifying, program enrollment, and loan debt information to BPPE. Authorizes BPPE to match student information with wage data provided by the EDD. Requires BPPE to make information available on its website when the Director of the DCA certifies that an updated information technology system is capable of processing data. (Status: This measure is currently pending in this Committee.)
AB 1342 (Low) would require the state AG to review and approve any sale of a nonprofit educational institution to a for-profit entity. (Status: This measure is currently pending in the Senate Committee on Appropriations.)
AB 1343 (Eggman) would prohibit a private postsecondary educational institution, beginning January 1, 2023, from enrolling residents of California who are not already enrolled as of that date, unless the institution meets one of two requirements: either no more than 85 percent of the institution's tuition revenue is derived from federal monies or the institution does not spend less than 50 percent of revenue on student instruction. (Status: This measure is currently pending in this Committee.)
AB 1344 (Bauer-Kahan) beginning July 1, 2021, would replace current requirements for the information out-of-state institutions are required to provide the Bureau if they enroll California students in online programs, with the same and expanded information requirements, specifically adding adverse actions to the list of information that has to be provided. It would also authorize the BPPE to place these out-of-state private postsecondary institutions on a probationary status and revoke authorization to enroll California students. (Status: This measure is currently pending in this Committee.)
AB 1345 (McCarty) prohibits a private postsecondary institution from directly or indirectly compensating, conditioning a contract or any benefit under a contract with, or conditioning the employment of, any person involved in certain activities on the basis of financial incentives that are contingent upon recruitment, enrollment, continued enrollment, admissions, attendance, financial aid, or sales of education materials to a student. (Status: This measure is currently pending in this Committee.)
AB 1346 (Medina) would expand the definition of economic loss to include all amounts paid by a student to the institution, any amounts paid in connection with attending the institution, and all principal, interest, and charges of any kind for any loan incurred by the student to pay these amounts and would expand STRF eligibility to expands eligibility to students residing in California and attending a campus of a Corinthian Colleges, Inc. (CCI), institution on or after January 1, 2010. (Status: This measure is currently pending in this Committee.)
- Arguments in Support. Supporters state the same information as contained in the Author’s purpose above.
- Arguments in Opposition. According to Ashford University, “Unfortunately, at a pivotal point in its history, Ashford’s ability to serve California students and employers is threatened by [this legislation]…Ashford seeks to return to its roots as an independent, nonprofit university to focus more exclusively on helping students develop the knowledge and skills employers need. This return to nonprofit status will open the way for additional partnerships with employers; make available additional money for scholarships and student/faculty collaboration and, perhaps most importantly, allow for a longer time horizon to judge the effects of investments and innovations without having to take into account the quarterly financial cycles of a for-profit company.
Ashford objects to the role of the AG determining what constitutes a nonprofit, “complicating and delaying the process.” Ashford believes that role should rest with the Franchise Tax Board and states that the bill should “permit institutions to seek direct approval from courts, similar to the current process for review by the AG of other substantive changes by [nonprofits] such as sale of substantially all assests.”
Ashford also believes current nonprofits should be grandfathered thus not captured by the provisions of this measure.
Zovio writes that “Critics contend that for-profit institutions wish to convert to nonprofit stats to avoid compliance with federal gainful employment rules. This may be the case for some institutions, but not all of them. In fact, Zovio is currently affiliated with Ashford University. Under the gainful employment rule last year, Ashford had no programs ascertained to “fail” this regulation. Evading gainful employment requirements would simply not be a motivation for Ashford to consider restructuring as a nonprofit…While the AG has the responsibility of supervising charities and charitable trusts in the state, the office does not make the determination on exempt status…[the Franchise Tax Board] has the expertise and a review process already in place to make such a determination.”
Zovio also suggests an amendment to change “core function” to “inherently academic function” in the bill, a change the organization states would “ensure academic functions are maintained by the nonprofit. Other functions, such as IT services, do not compromise the quality of a program and should not be considered “core functions.”
- Policy Question and Suggested Clarification.
How are BPPE and nonprofit corporations made aware when the AG has made a determination? While the bill requires tasks the AG with making a determination that a nonprofit institution has met specified criteria, it is not clear how either BPPE or the institution will be made aware of that determination. Corporations Code Section 5915 specifies that the AG must notify a nonprofit of their consent to a transaction within a specified timeframe. As such, the Author should clarify how the AG provides notice to an institution and BPPE of the determination that an institution complies with the required criteria.
SUPPORT AND OPPOSITION:
Support:
Ca-AAUP
California Faculty Association
California Low-Income Consumer Coalition
Center For Public Interest Law
Century Foundation
Children's Advocacy Institute
Consumer Federation of California
Consumer Reports Advocacy
Housing and Economic Rights Advocates
Legal Aid Foundation of Los Angeles
National Student Legal Defense Network
NextGen California
Public Advocates, Inc.
Public Counsel
Public Law Center
SEIU California
The Century Foundation
The Institute For College Access And Success
Veterans Education Success
Veterans Legal Clinic
Opposition:
Ashford University
Zovio
2 former Ashford students
-- END --
ASSEMBLY THIRD READING
ATR Bill Id:AB 1341
Author:(Berman, et al.)
As Introduced Ver:February 22, 2019
Majority vote
SUMMARY:
Prohibits the Bureau of Private Postsecondary Education (BPPE) from approving an institution, exempting an institution from its oversight or handling a complaint by an institution not previously approved to operate until 1) it provides the public with a notice of the application request for approval, exemption or complaint handling and 2) the Attorney General (AG) determines the institution meets the definition of a nonprofit institution or public institution..
Major Provisions
Please refer to the Assembly Committee on Higher Education policy analysis for further discussion.
COMMENTS:
The BPPE was created in 2009 under the Department of Consumer Affairs to oversee most of the state's private postsecondary schools, including nationally accredited schools, unaccredited schools, and various specialized schools. The BPPE was charged with ensuring minimum educational quality standards, providing students with an effective complaint resolution process and preventing public deception associated with fraudulent or substandard degrees.
Research indicates the some national for-profit colleges have granted nonprofit status by the Internal Revenue Service or are in the process of pursuing a nonprofit status. Nonprofit status for colleges can have various benefits, such as federal income tax exemptions, more access to some public dollars and reputational advantages. However, there is evidence some of these formerly for-profit colleges continue to flow money to publically traded affiliates and engage in other profit-seeking behavior.
According to the Author:
According to the author, "Rampant deceptive or unfair treatment of students is rare at legitimate nonprofit and public colleges because financial restrictions make it difficult for school leaders to profit from bad behavior. Being a nonprofit has traditionally required an institution to devote all of its revenues to its educational purpose, and prohibit any form of profit-taking, so that those in control are not tempted to take advantage of students or the public."
"Despite the poor record of some federally-funded for-profit colleges and scandals that have plagued the for-profit industry, Secretary of Education Betsy DeVos and the Trump administration refuse to admit that investor control of colleges is hazardous to students and taxpayers and require greater oversight and scrutiny. Therefore, California must step up and step in to protect our students and ensure that appropriate oversight remains. Legislation is necessary to protect Californians from for-profit colleges that are deceiving and misleading their students."
Arguments in Support:
A coalition of student, veteran, civil rights, and higher education advocates jointly wrote to the committee, noting that "…leaders of nonprofit institutions are required to devote schools' revenues to its educational purpose, and they are prohibited from taking a profit. Rampant deceptive or unfair treatment of students has been rare at legitimate nonprofit and public colleges because the financial restrictions placed on nonprofits are designed to make it difficult for school leaders to profit from bad behavior… The federal government's failure to recognize that investor control of colleges requires greater oversight and scrutiny puts Californians at risk. AB 1341 would prevent these covert for-profit institutions from evading state oversight and deceiving students."
Arguments in Opposition:
Ashford University wrote in opposition, noting that "…institutions work to change their status to become non-profit institutions for a variety of reasons. For example, students, faculty and staff that wish to participate in academic and co-curricular opportunities with other institutions are penalized because of the institution's tax status. Other benefits of becoming a non-profit institution include the elimination of shareholder profits on the P&L, the ability to receive tax deductible support for student tuition, and better opportunities for student transfer of credit. As such, converting to non-profit status expands educational opportunities for both our faculty and our students. Moreover, nonprofit status may lead to more affordable tuition for students."
FISCAL COMMENTS:
The Assembly Committee on Appropriations noted minor and absorbable costs to BPPE, and ongoing General Fund costs, potentially in the hundreds of thousands of dollars annually, to the AG.
VOTES:
ASM HIGHER EDUCATION: 11-0-1
YES: Medina, Choi, Gloria, Bloom, Gabriel, Irwin, Kiley, Gonzalez, Low, Santiago, Weber
ABS, ABST OR NV: Patterson
ASM BUSINESS AND PROFESSIONS: 20-0-0
YES: Low, Brough, Bloom, Chen, Chiu, Cunningham, Dahle, Eggman, Fong, Gipson, Gloria, Grayson, Holden, Irwin, McCarty, Medina, Mullin, Obernolte, Quirk-Silva, Ting
ASM APPROPRIATIONS: 18-0-0
YES: Gonzalez, Bigelow, Bloom, Bonta, Brough, Calderon, Carrillo, Chau, Diep, Eggman, Fong, Gabriel, Eduardo Garcia, Maienschein, Obernolte, Petrie-Norris, Quirk, Robert Rivas
UPDATED:
VERSION: February 22, 2019
CONSULTANT: Kevin J. Powers / HIGHER ED. / (916) 319-3960 FN: 0000755
Date of Hearing: May 16, 2019
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Lorena Gonzalez, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 1341
Author:(Berman) – As Introduced Ver:February 22, 2019
Policy Committee: | Higher Education | Vote: | 11 - 0 |
Business and Professions | 20 - 0 | ||
|
|
Urgency: No State Mandated Local Program: Yes Reimbursable: No
SUMMARY:
This bill prohibits the Bureau of Private Postsecondary Education (BPPE) from approving an institution, exempting an institution from its oversight or handling a complaint by an institution not previously approved to operate until (a) it provides the public with a notice of the application request for approval, exemption or complaint handling and (b) the Attorney General (AG) determines the institution meets the definition of a nonprofit institution or public institution. The bill states that an institution shall not meet the definition of a nonprofit institution if they engage in various profit-seeking behaviors.
FISCAL EFFECT:
- Minor and absorbable costs to BPPE. Some processing times might be impacted while awaiting AG approval and verification, but would not result in significant cost to BPPE.
- Ongoing General Fund costs, potentially in the hundreds of thousands of dollars annually, for the AG to determine whether an institution meets the definition of a nonprofit or public institution and, to the extent this statute is violated, bring enforcement actions against violators.
COMMENTS:
- Purpose. According to the author:
Rampant deceptive or unfair treatment of students is rare at legitimate nonprofit and public colleges because financial restrictions make it difficult for school leaders to profit from bad behavior. Being a nonprofit has traditionally required an institution to devote all of its revenues to its educational purpose, and prohibit any form of profit-taking…These restrictions have been so effective in protecting students that state and federal laws frequently provide funding only to nonprofit and public institutions, or apply stricter guidelines if for-profit colleges seek access to taxpayer funds. Some for-profit colleges, however, are starting to use a “nonprofit” or “public” label to attract students who are suspicious of for-profit colleges, and to escape regulatory oversight.
- Background. The BPPE was created in 2009 under the Department of Consumer Affairs to oversee most of the state’s private postsecondary schools, including nationally accredited schools, unaccredited schools, and various specialized schools. The BPPE was charged with ensuring minimum educational quality standards, providing students with an effective complaint resolution process and preventing public deception associated with fraudulent or substandard degrees.
Research indicates the some national for-profit colleges have granted nonprofit status by the Internal Revenue Service or are in the process of pursuing a nonprofit status. Nonprofit status for colleges can have various benefits, such as federal income tax exemptions, more access to some public dollars and reputational advantages. However, there is evidence some of these formerly for-profit colleges continue to flow money to publically traded affiliates and engage in other profit-seeking behavior.
- Private Postsecondary Bill Package. This bills is a part of an Assembly bill package designed to provide more accountability and state oversight of private postsecondary institutions.
AB 1340 (Chiu) would recodify in state law the federal Gainful Employment rule so that it may be enforced by the BPPE. The bill is pending in this committee.
AB 1342 (Low) would require the attorney general’s review and approval for any sale of a nonprofit educational institution to a for-profit entity. The bill is pending in this committee.
AB 1343 (Eggman) would prohibit a private postsecondary educational institution from enrolling residents of California, unless the institution meets either the requirement that no more than 85% of the institution’s tuition revenue is derived from student financial aid and loans, or not less than 50% of the institution’s tuition revenue is dedicated to student instruction. The bill is pending in this committee.
AB 1344 (Bauer-Kahan) would increase the BPPE’s oversight over out-of-state private postsecondary educational institutions operating online. The bill is pending in this committee.
AB 1345 (McCarty) would prohibit a private postsecondary school from providing financial incentives or compensation to their employees, directly or directly, for student recruitment, enrollment, admissions, attendance, financial aid or sales of educational materials. The bill passed out of this committee on May 1, 2019.
AB 1346 (Medina) would expand the definition of economic loss, as it pertains to the Student Tuition Recovery Fund. The bill is pending in this committee.
Analysis Prepared by: Natasha Collins / APPR. / (916) 319-2081
Date of Hearing:
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON BUSINESS AND PROFESSIONS
Evan Low, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 1341
Author:(Berman) – As Introduced Ver:February 22, 2019
SUBJECT: Private postsecondary education: California Private Postsecondary Education Act of 2009.
SUMMARY: Clarifies the definitions of a nonprofit corporation and a public institution of higher education for purposes of an institution’s exemption from the California Private Postsecondary Education Act of 2009.
EXISTING LAW:
- Enacts the California Private Postsecondary Education Act to provide for the regulation and oversight of private postsecondary schools. (Education Code (EDC) §§ 94800 et al.)
- Establishes the Bureau for Private Postsecondary Education (BPPE) in the Department of Consumer Affairs to regulate private postsecondary educational institutions under the California Private Postsecondary Education Act. (EDC § 94820)
- Exempts the following institutions from the California Private Postsecondary Education Act:
- An institution offering programs solely for the purpose of personal entertainment, pleasure, or enjoyment.
- An institution offering educational programs sponsored by a bona fide trade, business, professional, or fraternal organization, solely for that organization’s membership.
- A postsecondary educational institution established, operated, and governed by the federal government or by the government in California.
- An institution offering either test preparation for postsecondary education admissions examinations, or continuing education or license examination preparation.
- An institution owned, controlled, and operated and maintained by a religious organization lawfully operating as a nonprofit religious corporation, limited to education relevant to the beliefs and practices of the church, religious denomination, or religious organization.
- An institution that does not award degrees and that solely provides educational programs for total charges of $2,500 or less when no part of the total charges is paid from state or federal student financial aid programs.
- A law school that is accredited by the Council of the Section of Legal Education and Admissions to the Bar of the American Bar Association or that is subject to the approval, regulation, and oversight of the Committee of Bar Examiners.
- A nonprofit school organized specifically to provide workforce development or rehabilitation services that is accredited by the Department of Rehabilitation.
- An institution that is accredited by the Accrediting Commission for Senior Colleges and Universities, Western Association of Schools and Colleges, or the Accrediting Commission for Community and Junior Colleges, Western Association of Schools and Colleges.
- Flight instruction providers or programs that provide flight instruction pursuant to Federal Aviation Administration regulations.
- An institution owned by a nonprofit community-based organization that does not award degrees and does not offer educational programs designed to lead to licensure, and that would not have been subject to oversight if it did not receive funding under the federal Workforce Innovation and Opportunity Act.
(EDC §94874)
- States that as of January 1, 2016, an institution that is approved to participate in veterans’ financial aid programs that is not an independent institution of higher education shall not be exempt from the California Private Postsecondary Education Act. (EDC § 94874.2)
- Requires institutions exempt from the California Private Postsecondary Education Act to still comply with laws relating to school closure and laws relating to fraud, abuse, and false advertising. (EDC § 94874.9)
- Makes various findings and declarations regarding private postsecondary schools, including a finding that numerous reports and studies have concluded that California’s regulation of private postsecondary schools has consistently failed to ensure student protections or provide effective oversight of private postsecondary schools. (EDC § 94801)
- Defines “postsecondary education” as a formal institutional educational program whose curriculum is designed primarily for students who have completed or terminated their secondary education or are beyond the compulsory age of secondary education, including programs whose purpose is academic, vocational, or continuing professional education. (EDC § 94857)
- Defines “private postsecondary educational institution” as a private entity with a physical presence in the state that offers postsecondary education to the public for an institutional charge. (EDC § 94858)
- Defines “out-of-state private postsecondary educational institution” as a private entity without a physical presence in this state that offers distance education to California students for an institutional charge, regardless of whether the institution has affiliated institutions or institutional locations in California.
- Includes in the definition of “public higher education” the California Community Colleges, the California State University, and the University of California; defines “independent institutions of higher education” as nonpublic higher education institutions that grant undergraduate degrees or graduate degrees and are accredited by an agency recognized by the United States Department of Education. (EDC § 66010)
- Requires the BPPE to adopt regulations establishing minimum operating standards for a private postsecondary educational institution that ensures all of the following:
- The content of each educational program can achieve its stated objective.
- The institution maintains specific written standards for student admissions for each educational program and those standards are related to the particular program.
- The facilities, instructional equipment, and materials are sufficient to enable students to achieve the educational program’s goals.
- The institution maintains a withdrawal policy and provides refunds.
- The directors, administrators, and faculty are properly qualified.
- The institution is financially sound and capable of fulfilling its commitments to students.
- That, upon satisfactory completion of an educational program, the institution gives students a document signifying the degree or diploma awarded.
- Adequate records and standard transcripts are maintained and are available to students.
- The institution is maintained and operated in compliance with all applicable laws.
(EDC § 94885)
- Authorizes the BPPE to grant approval to operate only after an applicant has presented sufficient evidence to the bureau, and the bureau has independently verified the information provided by the applicant through site visits or other methods deemed appropriate by the bureau, that the applicant has the capacity to satisfy the minimum operating standards; requires the BPPE to deny an application for an approval to operate if the application does not satisfy those standards. (EDC § 94887)
- Provides that a standard approval to operate shall be valid for five years. (EDC § 94888)
- Requires the BPPE to grant an institution that is accredited an approval to operate by means of its accreditation. (EDC § 94890)
- Requires an institution to seek approval from the BPPE if it intends to make a substantive change to its approval to operate, such as changes in its education objectives, the addition of a new degree program, a change in ownership, or a change in name. (EDC § 94893)
- States that an institution is prohibited from doing any of the following:
- Use of the Great Seal of the State of California on a diploma.
- Promise or guarantee employment, or overstate the availability of jobs upon graduation.
- Advertise concerning job availability, degree of skill, or length of time required to learn a trade or skill unless the information is accurate and not misleading.
- Advertise, or indicate in promotional material, without including the fact that the educational programs are delivered by means of distance education.
- Advertise, or indicate in promotional material, that the institution is accredited if it is not.
- Solicit students for enrollment by causing an advertisement to be published in “help wanted” columns in a magazine, newspaper, or publication, or use “blind” advertising that fails to identify the institution.
- Offer to compensate a student to act as an agent of the institution with regard to the solicitation, referral, or recruitment of any person for enrollment in the institution.
- Pay any consideration to a person to induce that person to sign an enrollment agreement.
- Use a name in any manner improperly implying that the school is affiliated with a government agency, is a public institution, or grants degrees if it does not.
- In any manner make an untrue or misleading statement related to a test score, grade or record of grades, attendance record, record indicating student completion, placement, employment, salaries, or financial information.
- Willfully falsify, destroy, or conceal any document of record.
- Use the terms such as “approval” without stating clearly and conspicuously that approval to operate means compliance with state standards.
- Direct any individual to perform an unlawful act, to refrain from reporting unlawful conduct to the BPPE, or to engage in any unfair act to persuade a student not to complain.
- Compensate an employee involved in recruitment, enrollment, admissions, student attendance, or sales of educational materials to students on the basis of a commission, commission draw, bonus, quota, or other similar method related to the recruitment, enrollment, admissions, student attendance, or sales of educational materials to students.
- Require a prospective student to provide personal contact information in order to obtain, from the institution’s website, educational program information that is required to be contained in the school catalog.
- Offer an associate, baccalaureate, master’s, or doctoral degree without disclosing to prospective students prior to enrollment whether the institution or the degree program is unaccredited and any known limitation of the degree.
(EDC § 94897)
- Requires an institution that offers an educational program in a profession, occupation, trade, or career field that requires state licensure to have an educational program approval from the appropriate state licensing agency to conduct that educational program in order that a student who completes the educational program is eligible to sit for any required licensure examination. (EDC § 94899)
- Requires an institution’s recruiters to be its employees. (EDC § 94901)
- Requires an enrollment agreement to be written in language that is easily understood. (EDC § 94905)
- Requires an institution to provide a prospective student with a school catalog containing various program information and policies. (EDC § 94909)
- Requires an institution to provide a prospective student with a School Performance Fact Sheet containing information including but not limited to completion rates, placement rates for each program, license examination passage rates, starting salary or wage information, and information about how to contact the BPPE. (EDC § 94910)
- Requires an institution to post its school catalog, School Performance Fact Sheet, and student brochures on its website. (EDC § 94913)
- Establishes the Student Tuition Recovery Fund (STRF) to relieve or mitigate economic loss suffered by a student while enrolled in an institution at the time that institution, location, or program was closed or discontinued. (EDC § 94923)
- Requires an institution to annually report to the BPPE, as part of an annual report, and publish in its School Performance Fact Sheet, all of the following:
- The job placement rate for each program that is either designed, or advertised, to lead to a particular career, or advertised or promoted with any claim regarding job placement.
- The license examination passage rates for the immediately preceding two years for programs leading to employment requiring passage of a state licensing examination.
- Salary and wage information, consisting of the total number of graduates employed in the field and the annual wages or salaries of those graduates stated in increments of $5,000.
- If applicable, the most recent official three-year cohort default rate reported by the United States Department of Education for the institution and the percentage of enrolled students receiving federal student loans.
(EDC § 94929.5)
- Requires the Director of Consumer Affairs to provide written updates to the Legislature describing the BPPE’s progress in protecting consumers and enforcing the provisions of the California Private Postsecondary Education Act. (EDC § 94948)
- Establishes the Office of Student Assistance and Relief for the purpose of advancing and promoting the rights of prospective students, current students, or past students of private postsecondary educational institutions. (EDC § 94949.7)
- Subjects the BPPE to legislative oversight through the sunset review process, which provides for the California Private Postsecondary Education Act and the authority of the BPPE to be automatically repealed as of January 1, 2021 unless a later enacted statute deletes or extends that date. (EDC § 94950)
THIS BILL:
- Defines “nonprofit corporation” as an institution to which contributions have been determined by the United States Internal Revenue Service to be tax-deductible pursuant to Section 501(c) of the Internal Revenue Code, unless the Attorney General determines that the institution does not meet the definition of a nonprofit corporation.
- Defines “public institution of higher education” as any of the following:
- The California Community Colleges, the California State University, and the University of California;
- An institution operated by the United States government, a state, a local government, or Indian tribal government; or
- An institution that is an instrumentality of a state or local government if its employees are government employees, its liabilities are payable to the same degree as if they were liabilities of the state or local government, and it is subject to the same financial oversight and open public records laws as the state or local government.
- Directs that the BPPE shall not approve, exempt, or contract for the complaint handling of an institution not previously either approved to operate by the BPPE or verified by the Attorney General either as a nonprofit corporation or as a public institution of higher education until both of the following requirements occur:
- The BPPE provides the public with notice of the application or request for approval, exemption, or complaint handling, which must be posted on the BPPE’s internet website and included as an item listed on the agenda prepared for an advisory meeting.
- The Attorney General determines that the institution meets the definition of a nonprofit corporation or a public institution of higher education, unless the Attorney General determines the institution has engaged in an activity in which the net earnings of the institution benefit any person; the institution acquired assets for more than their value; one or more of the core functions of the institution are directed by a person or entity that is not a public institution of higher education or a nonprofit corporation; or a substantial share of the assets of the institution are committed to a joint venture with a person or entity that is not a public institution of higher education or a nonprofit corporation.
- Clarifies that the requirement for an out-of-state private postsecondary educational institution to register with the BPPE does not apply to a higher education institution that grants undergraduate degrees, graduate degrees, or both, and that is either formed as a nonprofit corporation and is accredited by an agency recognized by the United States Department of Education or is a public institution of higher education.
FISCAL EFFECT: Unknown; this bill is keyed fiscal by the Legislative Counsel.
COMMENTS:
Purpose. This bill is sponsored by the author. According to the author:
Rampant deceptive or unfair treatment of students is rare at legitimate nonprofit and public colleges because financial restrictions make it difficult for school leaders to profit from bad behavior. Being a nonprofit has traditionally required an institution to devote all of its revenues to its educational purpose, and prohibit any form of profit-taking, so that those in control are not tempted to take advantage of students or the public. These restrictions have been so effective in protecting students that state and federal laws frequently provide funding only to nonprofit and public institutions, or apply stricter guidelines if for-profit colleges seek access to taxpayer funds. Some for-profit colleges, however, are starting to use a “nonprofit” or “public” label to attract students who are suspicious of for-profit colleges, and to escape regulatory oversight. AB 1341 would prevent these covert for-profit colleges from evading state oversight by requiring the Attorney General to determine whether an institution that claims to be a nonprofit college or a public college actually meets the definition of a nonprofit corporation or public institution of higher education. Despite the poor record of some federally-funded for-profit colleges and scandals that have plagued the for-profit industry, the federal government refuses to admit that investor control of colleges is detrimental to students and taxpayers. Therefore, California must step up and step in to protect our students and ensure that appropriate oversight remains.
Background.
History of Regulation of Private Postsecondary Educational Institutions. The modern iteration of the BPPE was established on January 1, 2010 through AB 48 (Portantino, Chapter 310, Statutes of 2009). Prior to the current BPPE, the state made multiple other attempts to regulate for-profit colleges and other private postsecondary schools; many of these efforts are regarded as having been largely unsuccessful. In the BPPE’s 2014 sunset review, statute was enacted stating that “the Legislature advises future policymakers to continually and carefully evaluate” the BPPE and its regulatory authority.
Private postsecondary schools were previously regulated by a division within the California Department of Education; however, by the end of the 1980s, the state had purportedly become regarded as the “diploma mill capital of the world.” This led to the enactment of the Private Postsecondary and Vocational Education Reform Act of 1989 (Reform Act), which was intended to “promote the effective integration of private postsecondary education into all aspects of California's educational system and to foster and improve the educational programs and services of these institutions while protecting the citizens of the state from fraudulent or substandard operations.” That year, the Legislature also enacted Maxine Waters School Reform and Student Protection Act, which first set a threshold for minimum job placement and graduation rates.
These two reforms, which were ultimately merged, created a new regulatory entity established as the Council on Private Postsecondary and Vocational Education (CPPVE). The CPPVE was given authority to approve and disapprove private postsecondary schools, and it used this power aggressively and at times controversially. In 1996, Columbia Pacific University engaged in litigation against the CPPVE for denying its application for approval. The CPPVE ultimately prevailed in this litigation, but the CPPVE was left with a public perception that it was overly belligerent in its regulation of educational institutions.
A review by the California Postsecondary Education Commission recommended that both the CPPVE and the Reform Act be permanently extended beyond their June 30, 1997 sunset date. However, the bill to extend that sunset date by five years (AB 2960, Firestone and Campbell) was vetoed by Governor Pete Wilson. The Governor’s veto message stated that he believed “many of the bad operators have left the state or gone out of business” and that the remaining schools “have described a pattern of reprisals and vindictiveness in dealing with the Council staff.” Governor Wilson wrote that he “would like to have more assurances that we are not making it impossible or unreasonably difficult for many small businesses to operate before I extend the life of the Council.”
Urgency legislation was introduced in 1997 (AB 71, Wright) to extend the Reform Act and respond to the Governor’s veto message by making numerous changes to how its provisions were carried out. In support of the bill, the California Postsecondary Education Commission stated that the Reform Act had “become a model for federal standards and other states, its regulation of private postsecondary education is a major improvement over the conditions that existed prior to its creation.” The bill was opposed by numerous schools that had been regulated by the CPPVE and who believed the Reform Act simply resulted in “costly overregulation over private institutions” that “discourages new schools from investing in California.”
AB 71 was signed into law extending the provisions of the Reform Act; however, the bill allowed the CPPVE to be repealed on its sunset date. In its place, the bill established a new Bureau for Private Postsecondary and Vocational Education (BPPVE) created within the Department of Consumer Affairs. The extension of the Reform Act transferred all of the CPPVE’s responsibilities for its implementation to the new BPPVE.
The creation of a new bureau, however, did not rectify concerns that the state was not appropriately overseeing private postsecondary schools. A 2000 audit of the Department of Consumer Affairs found that the BPPVE’s licensing process was “not prompt or consistent” and that its complaint resolution procedures were inadequate. Following a review by the recently established Joint Legislative Sunset Review Committee in 2002, the BPPVE was tasked with streamlining the Reform Act, making its regulatory processes more efficient, and improving its data collection and reporting systems.
In 2004, SB 1544 (Figueroa) was enacted to provide the BPPVE with an Enforcement Monitor to examine the bureau’s operations. The Enforcement Monitor’s resulting report stated that there had been a “twenty-year record of repeatedly identified, fundamental problems in every one of the Bureau’s key operations.” That year, Governor Arnold Schwarzenegger vetoed AB 711 (Correa), which would have added additional exempted schools to the Reform Act; in his veto message, the Governor stated that it “fell short of its objective to streamline functions of the Bureau.” In 2006, SB 1473 (Figueroa) was introduced to replace the Reform Act with new provisions within the Business and Professions Code and to recast the BPPVE; however, this bill was subsequently held on suspense.
That same year, legislation to extend the sunset on the Reform Act and the BPPVE was once again vetoed by the Governor. In his veto message, Governor Arnold Schwarzenegger commented that he “supported meaningful protections for students of California’s private postsecondary and vocational institutions” but that because SB 1473 failed to pass the Legislature, extending the sunset date on the BPPVE “does nothing to enhance protections for students, allows problems that have been well documented to continue to exist, and merely allows mediocrity for California’s students.” A second bill to extend the state’s regulation of private postsecondary schools through a modernization of the Reform Act, SB 823 (Perata), was also vetoed, and the Governor directed the Department of Consumer Affairs to take on the bureau’s oversight responsibilities while a better replacement for the Reform Act was negotiated.
Following the Governor’s vetoes, the Reform Act became inoperative on July 1, 2007 and the bureau was subjected to repealed. AB 1525 (Cook) was chaptered in 2007 to provide for a transition plan for business still pending before the BPPVE, and to give the Director of Consumer Affairs clear authority to take on the bureau’s responsibilities. That bill also created the Student Tuition Recovery Fund. Later bills extended some of AB 1525’s provisions.
In the years following the sunsetting of the BPPVE and the Reform Act, private postsecondary schools were subject to little or no oversight by the state. Finally, AB 48 (Portantino) was chaptered in 2009 to revive the state’s regulation of private postsecondary institutions. That bill reinstated the authority of the BPPVE, rebranded and recast as the BPPE, and established the California Private Postsecondary Education Act of 2009. The bill sought to institute a more efficient and effective oversight entity to carry out implementation of a stronger consumer protection act. The BPPE was ultimately restored full funding in late 2010.
The BPPE continues to be subject to significant scrutiny by the Legislature and advocates. SB 1247 (Lieu) was chaptered in 2014 to provide the BPPE with only a two year sunset extension before further review while making a number of reforms to the California Private Postsecondary Education Act. In the BPPE’s 2016 sunset review, staff outlined a number of ongoing issues relating to the operation of the bureau, ultimately providing no immediate recommendation as to whether the BPPE’s sunset should be extended and stating that “the Bureau has faced significant difficulties in implementing the law. It is important that California’s approval and oversight of an institution assures minimum quality and student protections.”
In 2016, the BPPE’s sunset date was again extended until January 1, 2021, with numerous reforms made in response to recent high-profile litigation and school closures. SB 1192 (Hill) established an Office of Student Assistance and Relief “for the purpose of advancing and promoting the rights of prospective students, current students, or past students of private postsecondary educational institutions.” The bill also expanded the BPPE’s authority to oversee out-of-state private postsecondary schools serving students in California, requiring registration and basic approval standards. Finally, the bill required approved institutions under investigation by entities other than the BPPE to report that investigation and its nature within 30 days.
The BPPE will next undergo sunset review in 2020. It is anticipated that the success of the new Office of Student Assistance and Relief and the effects of recent changes in management will be discussed, and the BPPE will be expected to demonstrate how it has improved its operates sufficiently to be a strong regulator on behalf of California students. Until then, the framework that has been put into place through careful oversight by the Legislature is cause for optimism that the BPPE is well-equipped to exercise its current responsibilities and expand into new opportunities for safeguarding the interests of Californians.
Criticism of For-Profit Colleges. Many educational programs run by for-profit entities offer coursework preparing students for careers not well served by nonprofit or public institutions. However the inherent profit motive behind these institutions’ stewardship of the societal values of higher education has long resulted in concern. This general apprehension about the capacity for certain private postsecondary schools to profit through the exploitation of vulnerable students has been the root purpose for regulation by the BPPE and its predecessors. The public prosecution and closure of various high-profile “bad actor” schools over the years has contributed substantially to the cause for furthering regulatory vigilance.
In 2016, California Attorney General Kamala D. Harris announced that a $1.1 billion judgment had at last been obtained against the long-vilified Corinthian Colleges, Inc. – which by that time had long closed down its campuses and filed for bankruptcy. The Attorney General’s complaint publicized how Corinthian, through its Everest, Heald, and Wyotech campuses, had for years made fraudulent statements to prospective students about job placement rates, available programs, and affiliation with the United States military.
The Attorney General’s complaint revealed that Corinthian had described its target demographic as “isolated,” “impatient,” individuals with “low self-esteem,” who have “few people in their lives who care about them” and who are “stuck” and “unable to see and plan well for future.” The average the average tuition for an associate’s degree at a Corinthian school was $40,000. Following the closure of Corinthian’s campuses, thousands of students were left with crippling debt without having received a quality education.
Corinthian is not regarded as being a rare exception in the world of for-profit education. In 2015, Marinello Schools of Beauty abruptly closed down campuses throughout California after the United States Department of Education cut off the institution’s access to federal student aid for “knowingly requesting federal aid for students based on invalid high-school diplomas, underawarding Title IV aid to students, charging students for excessive overtime.” In late 2018, another abrupt closure was announced by the Education Corporation of America (ECA) and its Brightwood College campuses following federal student aid restrictions and a notice from its accreditor that recognition for its campuses would be suspended.
Rollback of Federal Protections. During President Barack Obama’s second term, the White House announced that it was taking bold steps to increase federal oversight of for-profit colleges and protect students from predatory institutions. One such rule was the Department of Education’s “Gainful Employment” rule, which required colleges to track their students’ performance in the workforce after graduation. Under the Gainful Employment rule, career training programs that fail to adequately place graduates in jobs would be cut off from federal funding. This rule was intended to prevent for-profit colleges from overpromising job opportunities to students in exchange for saddling them with debt that they are subsequently unable to pay back.
By the end of President Obama’s second term, the Department of Education was robustly exercising its oversight and enforcement authority over the for-profit college sector. The Gainful Employment rule was challenged in court and was ultimately upheld in 2015, and the Department of Education ramped up its investigations into potentially problematic educational programs. However, in 2017, the Trump Administration took over the White House, and almost immediately began to reverse the progress that the Obama Administration was considered to have made.
According to recent reporting by the New York Times, an active investigation by the Department of Education into a large chain of private postsecondary schools was essentially halted after President Trump’s Secretary of Education, Betsy DeVos, named a former dean of that school as supervisor of the investigation team. Other individuals with prior affiliations with for-profit schools have also been appointed to senior positions within the Department. Reports indicate that the for-profit college investigation team has been curtailed from approximately a dozen attorneys and investigators to just three.
In addition to scaling back of investigations, Secretary DeVos announced the Department of Education’s intention to roll back several Obama-era regulations impacting higher education. In October 2017, Attorney General Xavier Becerra signed onto a multistate against the Department of Education for illegally delaying the implementation of the Gainful Employment Rule, in violation of the Administrative Procedure Act. In August 2018, a Notice of Proposed Rulemaking was announced to formally rescind the Gainful Employment rule.
An October 2018 CalMatters article titled California’s for-profit college watchdog fails to police as feds back down stated that “as the Trump administration pulls back from regulating the sector, consumer advocates argue, the states’ role becomes even more critical.” The article identifies the BPPE as the entity best suited to take on the oversight responsibilities that Secretary DeVos has taken steps to abdicate. The article does recognize that BPPE’s historical shortcomings—including its complaint backlogs—represent a challenge to effectuating new requirements. However, recent displays of progress with the BPPE showcase a bureau whose leadership is up to the task of regulating institutions through a student-centered approach, and inheriting responsibility for the Obama Administration’s protections in California may be an ideal fit.
“Covert For-Profits.” A report published by the Century Foundation titled The Covert For-Profit in September 2015 discusses how some institutions have attempted to circumvent the growing scrutiny around for-profit educational institutions by cloaking themselves in the garb of a nonprofit or public university. According to the Century Foundation, “the owners of some for-profit institutions have sought to switch their schools to nonprofit status, freeing them from the regulatory burdens of for-profit colleges, while continuing to reap the personal financial benefits of for-profit ownership.” The report also alleges that some for-profits have found ways to be identified as public institutions while in actuality remaining private, for-profits.
The report examined several specific examples of colleges that converted from for-profit to nonprofit, purportedly to evade regulations such as the Gainful Employment rule and other restrictions on for-profit actors. This includes:
Grand Canyon University. The CEO of Grand Canyon Education, Inc., a for-profit company traded on NASDAQ, also serves as the President of an affiliated nonprofit, Grand Canyon University, and about 60% of the tuition revenue that the “nonprofit” college receives flows through to the for-profit company. Grand Canyon University reported more than 7,000 California enrollments in 2016-17.
Ashford University. Owned by Bridgepoint Education, Inc., and based in San Diego, Ashford University has been sued by the California Attorney General for misleading prospective students. Meanwhile, the company announced in March 2018 that it would follow the Grand Canyon University approach to claiming nonprofit status. In fact, on February 15, 2019, Ashford University announced that it received determination from the Internal Revenue Service that it is exempt from federal income tax under Internal Revenue Code (IRC) Section 501 (c) (3). In 2018 Ashford University reported more than 35,000 students. State-specific figures are not available for Ashford University.
Purdue University Global. While claiming to be a “public” college because of its affiliation with Indiana’s public Purdue University, Purdue University Global (PUG) is actually a limited liability corporation for which the state refuses any financial responsibility, and which is exempt from state public records laws; exempt from state audit requirements; and exempt from state open meeting laws. The institution is jointly operated by Purdue and PUG, which was formerly owned by Kaplan Higher Education. Kaplan Higher Education, which is traded on the New York Stock Exchange, has formal roles in governing PUG and gets a share of profits. Kaplan Higher Education reported more than 2,000 California enrollments in 2016-17.
By requiring the Attorney General to make a determination about whether an institution is actually a nonprofit or public institution of higher education, the author believes that for-profit schools will be unable to shield themselves in technicality to avoid regulation by the BPPE.
Current Related Legislation. AB 1340 (Chiu) would recodify in state law the federal Gainful Employment rule so that it may be enforced by the BPPE. This bill is pending in the Assembly Business and Professions Committee.
AB 1342 (Low) would require the Attorney General’s review and approval for any sale of a nonprofit educational institution to a for-profit entity. This bill is pending in the Assembly Judiciary Committee.
AB 1343 (Eggman) would prohibit a private postsecondary educational institution from enrolling residents of California, unless the institution meets either the requirement that no more than 85 percent of the institution’s tuition revenue is derived from student financial aid and loans, or not less than 50% of the institution’s tuition revenue is dedicated to student instruction. This bill is pending in the Assembly Business and Professions Committee.
AB 1344 (Bauer-Kahan) would increase the BPPE’s oversight over out-of-state private postsecondary educational institutions operating online. This bill is pending in the Assembly Business and Professions Committee.
AB 1345 (McCarty) would prohibit an institution from providing certain financial incentives to any person, including a student, involved in student recruitment, enrollment, continued enrollment, admission, or attendance, or involved in awarding of financial aid based on the enrollment of a student. This bill is pending in the Assembly Business and Professions Committee.
AB 1346 (Medina) would expand the definition of economic loss, as it pertains to the Student Tuition Recovery Fund. This bill is pending in the Assembly Appropriations Committee.
Prior Related Legislation. SB 1192 (Hill, Chapter 593, Statutes of 2016) extended the operation of the BPPE and established the Office of Student Assistance and Relief.
AB 1619 (Berman) of 2017 would have required the BPPE to prohibit institutions from enrolling new students in an educational program that receives a fail rating for two out of three consecutive years, or receives a combination of zone or fail ratings for four consecutive years, based on the federal debt-to-earnings rates. The provisions in this bill were ultimately replaced with provisions dealing with a different topic.
AB 1611 (McCarty) of 2017 would have required certain debt-dependent programs to submit information to the BPPE upon the repeal or suspension of specified federal regulations. This bill was held under submission on the Assembly Appropriations Committee’s suspense file.
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT:
The Century Foundation (TCF) supports this bill. The TCF writes that “in a nutshell, the problem solved by AB 1341 is that for-profit colleges are trying to fool consumers and regulators by laying claim -- illicitly -- to the ‘nonprofit’ and ‘public’ labels, capitalizing on, but ultimately destroying, the good reputation of public and nonprofit schools.” The TCF argues that “by enacting AB 1341, California lawmakers will be taking a leading role nationally to protect the integrity of nonprofit and public status.”
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION:
Ashford University opposes this bill. Ashford University states that “institutions work to change their status to become non-profit institutions for a variety of reasons.” Ashford University argues that “institutions with existing relationships with entities that are uniquely positioned to provide desired services should have the opportunity to pursue services from those entities, particularly if they have an agreement that is consistent with market norms than if they were forced to go out to bid for the same services.”
REGISTERED SUPPORT:
California Conference of the American Association of University Professors
California Low-Income Consumer Coalition
Campaign for College Opportunity
Center for Public Interest Law
The Century Foundation
Children’s Advocacy Institute
Consumer Action
Consumer Federation of California
Consumer Reports
Housing and Economic Rights Advocates
The Institute for College Access and Success
Public Advocates
Public Counsel
Public Law Center
Service Employees International Union
Veterans Education Success
Veterans Legal Clinic
Youth Leadership Institute
REGISTERED OPPOSITION:
Ashford University
Analysis Prepared by: Robert Sumner / B. & P. / (916) 319-3301
Date of Hearing: April 9, 2019
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON HIGHER EDUCATION
Jose Medina, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 1341 (
Author:Berman) – As Introduced Ver:February 22, 2019
[Note: This bill is doubled referred to the Assembly Committee on Business and Professions and will be heard by that Committee as it relates to issues under its jurisdiction.]
SUBJECT: Private postsecondary education: California Private Postsecondary Education Act of 2009
SUMMARY: Specifies that only an institution of higher education meeting the definition of nonprofit corporation or public institution of higher education, as specified, is exempt from the requirements imposed on an out-of-state private postsecondary educational institution. Specifically, this bill:
- Clarifies that the requirement for an out-of-state private postsecondary educational institution to register with the Bureau for Private Postsecondary Education (BPPE) and follow specified requirement does not apply to a higher education institution that grants undergraduate degrees, graduate degrees, or both, and that is either formed as a nonprofit corporation and is accredited by an agency recognized by the United States Department of Education (USDE), or is a public institution of higher education.
- Defines a “Nonprofit corporation” to mean an institution to which contributions have been determined by the United States Internal Revenue Service (IRS) to be tax-deductible pursuant to Section 501(c) of the Internal Revenue Code (IRC), unless the Attorney General determines that the institution does not meet the definition of a nonprofit corporation.
- Defines “public institution of higher education” to mean any of the following:
- An institution that meets the definition of Section 66010 of the Education Code (described in “Existing Law”), including a district or campus of the California Community Colleges;
- An institution operated by the United States government, a state, a local government, or Indian tribal government, as defined; and,
- An institution that is an instrumentality of a state or local government if it meets all of the following:
- Its employees are government employees;
- Its liabilities are payable to the same degree as if they were liabilities of the state or local government, in the state or local government jurisdiction where the institution is formed; and,
- It is subject to the same financial oversight and open public records laws as the state or local government, in the state or local government jurisdiction where the institution is formed.
- Requires BPPE to not approve, verify an exemption, or contract for the complaint handling of an institution not previously either approved to operate by the bureau or verified by the Attorney General either as a nonprofit corporation or as a public institution of higher education until both of the following requirements occur:
- The BPPE provides the public with notice of the application or request for approval, exemption, or complaint handling. The notice shall be posted on the bureau’s internet website and included as an item listed on the agenda prepared for an advisory meeting of the bureau.
- The Attorney General determines that the institution meets the definition of a nonprofit corporation or of a public institution of higher education. However, an institution shall not meet the definition of a nonprofit corporation if any of the following applies:
- The Attorney General determines the institution has engaged in an activity in which the net earnings of the institution benefit any person. The Attorney General shall presume the institution has engaged in such an activity if it has engaged in a reportable incident, unless the Attorney General determines otherwise. A reportable incident is the reporting of any item under the following categories on United States IRS Form 990, Return of Organization Exempt from Income Tax, or a successor form:
- An excess benefit transaction.
- A transaction with a disqualified individual.
- A prohibited shelter transaction.
- An equity-based compensation arrangement.
- Compensation based on revenues.
- The institution has either acquired assets from another entity or has previously operated as a for-profit institution, and the Attorney General determines that the assets, or a significant portion of the assets, were acquired for more than the value of the assets. Value, which shall include the value of any ongoing relationship, including any contract, agreement, lease, or other arrangement between the acquiring institution and the acquired institution or asset, as described in the Code of Federal Regulations, as specified, shall be demonstrated through one of the following:
- A third-party valuation.
- Independent financing of the acquisition based upon the asset acquired.
- Full and open competition in the procurement of services or assets, as defined.
- One or more of the core functions of the institution are conducted by, under the control of, or subject to significant direction from, a person or entity that is not a public institution of higher education and is not a nonprofit corporation. For these purposes, there shall be a conclusive presumption that a person or entity exercises significant direction if one or more of its employees or owners serves as an officer, member of the board, or person holding similar authority for the institution; and,
- A substantial share of the assets of the institution are committed to a joint venture with a person or entity that is not a public institution of higher education and is not a nonprofit corporation, and the core functions of the venture are conducted by, under the control of, or subject to significant direction from that person or entity.
- Specifies that, for the purposes of determining tax exempt status for this chapter, the BPPE and the Attorney General may consider the tax exempt status of an institution of higher education as determined pursuant to Section 501(c)(3) of the Internal Revenue Code. However, that status shall not be the sole factor for determining whether an entity is a nonprofit corporation.
EXISTING LAW:
- Establishes the California Private Postsecondary Education Act of 2009 (Act) until January 1, 2021, and requires BPPE, within the Department of Consumer Affairs (DCA) to, in part, review, investigate and approve private postsecondary institutions (or institutions), programs and courses of instruction pursuant to the Act and authorizes BPPE to take formal actions against an institution/school to ensure compliance with the Act and even seek closure of an institution/school if determined necessary. The Act requires unaccredited degree granting institutions to be accredited by an accrediting agency recognized by the USDE by 2020. The Act also provides for specified disclosures and enrollment agreements for students, requirements for cancellations, withdrawals and refunds, and that the BPPE shall administer the STRF to provide refunds to students affected by the possible closure of an institution/school. (Education Code (EDC) Section 94800 et. seq.)
- Requires an out-of-state private postsecondary educational institution to comply with specified requirements, including providing the bureau evidence of the institution’s accreditation (EDC Section 94801.5)
- Establishes that public higher education consists of the California Community Colleges, the California State University, and each campus, branch, and function thereof, and each campus, branch, and function of the University of California (EDC Section 66010)
FISCAL EFFECT: Unknown.
COMMENTS: Need for the bill. According to the author, “Rampant deceptive or unfair treatment of students is rare at legitimate nonprofit and public colleges because financial restrictions make it difficult for school leaders to profit from bad behavior. Being a nonprofit has traditionally required an institution to devote all of its revenues to its educational purpose, and prohibit any form of profit-taking, so that those in control are not tempted to take advantage of students or the public.”
“These restrictions have been so effective in protecting students that state and federal laws frequently provide funding only to nonprofit and public institutions, or apply stricter guidelines if for-profit colleges seek access to taxpayer funds. Some for-profit colleges, however, are starting to use a “nonprofit” or “public” label to attract students who are suspicious of for-profit colleges, and to escape regulatory oversight.”
“Despite the poor record of some federally-funded for-profit colleges and scandals that have plagued the for-profit industry, Secretary of Education Betsy DeVos and the Trump administration refuse to admit that investor control of colleges is hazardous to students and taxpayers and require greater oversight and scrutiny. Therefore, California must step up and step in to protect our students and ensure that appropriate oversight remains. Legislation is necessary to protect Californians from for-profit colleges that are deceiving and misleading their students.”
Background. The Century Foundation published a report in September of 2015 titled “The Covert For-Profit.” Prompted by news of several conversions of for-profit colleges into nonprofits, The Century Foundation obtained IRS and USDE records and communications that called into question the legitimacy of some of these conversions. The Century Foundation wrote that “…through four case studies, based on hundreds of pages of documents obtained from government agencies, the examination reveals a dangerous regulatory blind spot, with the two federal agencies each assuming, wrongly, that the other is monitoring the integrity of the “nonprofit” claims of these colleges.”
Since “The Covert For-Profit” was released, several large national for-profit colleges that serve California students have transitioned, or begun the transition, to a nonprofit status. These colleges are:
- Grand Canyon University. The CEO of Grand Canyon Education, Inc., a for-profit company traded on NASDAQ, also serves as the President of an affiliated nonprofit, Grand Canyon University, and about 60% of the tuition revenue that the “nonprofit” college receives flows through to the for-profit company. Grand Canyon University reported more than 7,000 California enrollments in 2016-17.
- Ashford University. Owned by Bridgepoint Education, Inc., and based in San Diego, Ashford University has been sued by the California Attorney General for misleading prospective students. Meanwhile, the company announced in March 2018 that it would follow the Grand Canyon University approach to claiming nonprofit status. In fact, on February 15, 2019, Ashford University announced that it received determination from the Internal Revenue Service that it is exempt from federal income tax under Internal Revenue Code (IRC) Section 501 (c) (3). In 2018 Ashford University reported more than 35,000 students. State-specific figures are not available for Ashford University.
- Purdue University Global. While claiming to be a “public” college because of its affiliation with Indiana’s public Purdue University, Purdue University Global (PUG) is actually a limited liability corporation for which the state refuses any financial responsibility, and which is exempt from state public records laws; exempt from state audit requirements; and exempt from state open meeting laws. The institution is jointly operated by Purdue and PUG, which was formerly owned by Kaplan Higher Education. Kaplan Higher Education, which is traded on the New York Stock Exchange, has formal roles in governing PUG and gets a share of profits. Kaplan Higher Education reported more than 2,000 California enrollments in 2016-17.
AB 1341 triggers the Attorney General to determine whether an institution meets the definition of a nonprofit corporation or public institution of higher education, and explicitly specifies that an institution does not meet the definition of a nonprofit corporation if any of the following applies:
- The Attorney General determines the institution has engaged in an activity in which the net earnings of the institution benefit any person.
- The institution has either acquired assets from another entity or has previously operated as a for-profit institution, and the Attorney General determines that the assets, or a significant portion of the assets, were acquired for more than the value of the assets.
- One or more of the core functions of the institution are conducted by, under the control of, or subject to significant direction from, a person or entity that is not a public institution of higher education and is not a nonprofit corporation.
- A substantial share of the assets of the institution are committed to a joint venture with a person or entity that is not a public institution of higher education and is not a nonprofit corporation, and the core functions of the venture are conducted by, under the control of, or subject to significant direction from that person or entity.
Nonprofit status. The vast majority of public and private universities and colleges are tax-exempt entities as defined by IRC Section 501(c)(3) because of their educational purposes—purposes that the federal government has long recognized as fundamental to fostering the productive and civic capacity of its citizens—and/or the fact that they are state governmental entities. In turn, states generally grant tax-exempt status to organizations, including universities and colleges, which qualify as tax-exempt entities under federal law.
Income from activities that are substantially related to the purpose of an institution’s tax exemption, charitable contributions received, and investment income are not subject to federal income tax. The federal tax code classifies tax-exempt colleges and universities and their foundations as public charities. Consequently, they have historically not been subject to tax on investment income, payout requirements, or other rules that apply to private foundations.
The IRS requires all private universities and public charitable foundations that support public universities to submit an IRS Form 990 each year. Institutions are required to report on their mission, revenues, expenditures, endowments, salaries and benefits of top officials, charitable gifts, lobbying activities, and more. This information is made available to the public.
Arguments in support. The Century Foundation wrote in support of this bill, noting that, “…the problem solved by AB 1341 is that for-profit colleges are trying to fool consumers and regulators by laying claim -- illicitly -- to the “nonprofit” and “public” labels, capitalizing on, but ultimately destroying, the good reputation of public and nonprofit schools. It is unfortunate that state action is necessary to stop this abuse. But the failure of oversight at the federal level, combined with some cynically opportunistic for-profit school owners and executives who have taken advantage of the situation, has made state action essential.”
“Students enrolling at nonprofit colleges on average are more likely to graduate or transfer, more likely to get a job, and typically earn more than students enrolling at for-profit colleges. They are twice as likely to make progress in repaying their student loans, and are far less likely to default, especially the longer you track: twelve years after college, more than half of for-profit students have defaulted, triple the rate of nonprofit borrowers… AB 1341 would ensure that colleges that hold themselves out as nonprofit or public actually are holding themselves to the standards that consumers and taxpayers expect of nonprofit or public entities.”
A coalition of student, veteran, civil rights, and higher education advocates jointly wrote to the committee, noting that “…leaders of nonprofit institutions are required to devote schools’ revenues to its educational purpose, and they are prohibited from taking a profit. Rampant deceptive or unfair treatment of students has been rare at legitimate nonprofit and public colleges because the financial restrictions placed on nonprofits are designed to make it difficult for school leaders to profit from bad behavior… The federal government’s failure to recognize that investor control of colleges requires greater oversight and scrutiny puts Californians at risk. AB 1341 would prevent these covert for-profit institutions from evading state oversight and deceiving students.”
Arguments in opposition. Ashford University wrote to the committee in opposition, noting that “…institutions work to change their status to become non-profit institutions for a variety of reasons. For example, students, faculty and staff that wish to participate in academic and co-curricular opportunities with other institutions are penalized because of the institution’s tax status. Other benefits of becoming a non-profit institution include the elimination of shareholder profits on the P&L, the ability to receive tax deductible support for student tuition, and better opportunities for student transfer of credit. As such, converting to non-profit status expands educational opportunities for both our faculty and our students. Moreover, nonprofit status may lead to more affordable tuition for students.”
“Critics contend that for-profit institutions wish to convert to nonprofit status to avoid compliance with federal regulations such as Gainful Employment rules. This may be the case with some institutions, but not for all. Ashford is currently in compliance with all federal regulations. Under the Gainful Employment rule last year, for example, Ashford had no programs determined to “fail” this regulation. Evading Gainful Employment requirements, or any other current regulation, would simply not be a motivation for Ashford to consider restructuring as a nonprofit.”
“[This] measure places additional requirements around newly formed nonprofit institutions, such as requiring the institution to pursue a competitive procurement process for services or assets. Institutions with existing relationships with entities that are uniquely positioned to provide desired services should have the opportunity to pursue services from those entities, particularly if they have an agreement that is consistent with market norms than if they were force to go out and bid for the same services.”
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
California Conference of the American Association of University Professors
California Low-Income Consumer Coalition
Center for Public Interest Law
Children's Advocacy Institute
Consumer Federation of California
Consumer Reports Advocacy
Housing and Economic Rights Advocates
Public Advocates, Inc.
Public Counsel
Public Law Center
SEIU California
The Century Foundation
The Institute for College Access and Success
Veterans Education Success
Veterans Legal Clinic
Opposition
Ashford University
Analysis Prepared by: Kevin J. Powers / HIGHER ED. / (916) 319-3960
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):