AB 1416: Business: collection and disclosures of consumer personal information.
- Session Year: 2019-2020
- House: Assembly
- Latest Version Date: 2019-05-06
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Jul 9, 2019 | In committee: Set, first hearing. Hearing canceled at the request of author. |
| Jun 12, 2019 | Referred to Com. on JUD. |
| May 30, 2019 | In Senate. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. |
| May 29, 2019 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Senate. |
| May 7, 2019 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| May 6, 2019 | Read second time and amended. Ordered returned to second reading. |
| May 2, 2019 | From committee: Amend, and do pass as amended. (Ayes 9. Noes 0.) (April 30). |
| Mar 14, 2019 | Referred to Com. on P. & C.P. |
| Feb 25, 2019 | Read first time. |
| Feb 23, 2019 | From printer. May be heard in committee March 25. |
| Feb 22, 2019 | Introduced. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| May 29, 2019 | AB 1416 Cooley Assembly Third Reading By DALY | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| Apr 30, 2019 | Do pass as amended. | Assembly Standing Committee on Privacy and Consumer Protection |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
Senator Hannah-Beth Jackson, Chair
2019-2020 Regular Session
Bill No: AB 1416 (Author:Cooley)
Version: May 6, 2019
Hearing Date: July 9, 2019
Fiscal: Yes
Urgency: No
Consultant: CK
SUBJECT
Business: collection and disclosures of consumer personal information
DIGEST
This bill creates several new exemptions to the California Consumer Privacy Act (CCPA).
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
The CCPA provides consumers a number of rights with regard to businesses’ use of their personal information. Businesses that collect or sell a consumer’s personal information, or disclose it for a business purpose, must provide notice and certain disclosures upon request by the consumer. This includes disclosing the categories of information the business has collected or sold, the categories of sources from which the information is collected, and the specific pieces of information collected about the consumer. The CCPA also allows consumers who are 16 years of age or older to opt out of the sale of their personal information with younger consumers needing to opt in before a business can sell their information. Consumers can also request that certain personal information be deleted. The CCPA has a series of exemptions to prevent conflicting obligations.
This bill creates several new, broad exemptions to the CCPA that would dramatically erode the rights of consumers pursuant to the nascent law and allow businesses to disregard consumers’ choices to restrict the sale of their personal information or to delete it. The bill is sponsored by the California State Association of Counties (CSAC) and supported by various government and business organizations, who argue it is necessary for government programs and fraud detection.
Various consumer and privacy groups, including the co-sponsors of the CCPA, oppose the bill, arguing that its exemptions eviscerate the CCPA’s “main consumer rights by raising the false specter of government need.”
PROPOSED CHANGES TO THE LAW
Existing law:
- Establishes the CCPA, which grants consumers certain rights with regard to their personal information. (Civ. Code § 1798.100 et seq.)
- Requires a business that collects a consumer’s personal information to, at or before the point of collection, inform consumers as to the categories of personal information to be collected and the purposes for which the categories of personal information shall be used. (Civ. Code § 1798.100(b).)
- Provides consumers the right to request that a business that collects personal information about the consumer disclose to the consumer the following:
- the categories of personal information it has collected about that consumer;
- the categories of sources from which the personal information is collected;
- the business or commercial purpose for collecting or selling personal information;
- the categories of third parties with whom the business shares personal information; and
- the specific pieces of personal information it has collected about that consumer. (Civ. Code §§ 1798.100(a), (c), 1798.110(a).)
- Provides consumers the right to request that a business delete any personal information about the consumer which the business has collected from the consumer. (Civ. Code § 1798.105(a).)
- Provides consumers the right to request that a business that sells the consumer’s personal information, or that discloses it for a business purpose, disclose to the consumer the following:
- the categories of personal information that the business collected about the consumer;
- the categories of personal information that the business sold about the consumer and the categories of third parties to whom the personal information was sold, by category or categories of personal information for each third party to whom the personal information was sold; and
- the categories of personal information that the business disclosed about the consumer for a business purpose. (Civ. Code § 1798.115(a).)
- Provides a consumer the right, at any time, to direct a business that sells personal information about the consumer to third parties not to sell the consumer’s personal information. This right may be referred to as the right to opt out. (Civ. Code § 1798.120.) It further requires a business that sells consumers’ personal information to third parties to provide notice to consumers, as specified, that this information may be sold and that consumers have the right to opt out of the sale of their personal information. (Civ. Code § 1798.120.)
- Defines “sell,” “selling,” “sale,” or “sold,” to mean selling, renting, releasing, disclosing, disseminating, making available, transferring, or otherwise communicating orally, in writing, or by electronic or other means, a consumer’s personal information by the business to another business or a third party for monetary or other valuable consideration. (Civ. Code § 1798.140(t)(1).)
- Provides that “personal information” does not include publicly available information, which is information that is lawfully made available from federal, state, or local government records, as specified. (Civ. Code § 1798.140(o)(2).)
- Provides that the obligations imposed by the CCPA shall not restrict a business’s ability to:
- comply with federal, state, or local laws;
- comply with a civil, criminal, or regulatory inquiry, investigation, subpoena, or summons by federal, state, or local authorities;
- cooperate with law enforcement agencies concerning conduct or activity that the business, service provider, or third party reasonably and in good faith believes may violate federal, state, or local law;
- exercise or defend legal claims;
- collect, use, retain, sell, or disclose consumer information that is deidentified or in the aggregate consumer information; or
- collect or sell a consumer’s personal information if every aspect of that commercial conduct takes place wholly outside of California. (Civ. Code § 1798.145(a).)
- Provides that the CCPA does not apply to medical information governed by other specified privacy laws; providers of health care, as specified; information collected as part of clinical trials; personal information collected, processed, sold, or disclosed pursuant to the Gramm-Leach-Bliley Act, the California Financial Information Privacy Act, or the Driver’s Privacy Protection Act. (Civ. Code § 1798.145.)
This bill:
- Provides that the obligations imposed on businesses by the CCPA shall not restrict a business’s ability to comply with any rules or regulations adopted pursuant to and in furtherance of state or federal laws.
- Provides that the obligations imposed on businesses by the CCPA shall not restrict a business’s ability to provide a consumer’s personal information to a government agency solely for the purposes of carrying out a government program, including providing government services in furtherance of a government program, provided that all of the following requirements are met:
- the business does not sell the personal information of a consumer who has opted out of the sale of the consumer’s personal information for any purpose other than providing it to a government agency for purposes of, and in furtherance of, a government program;
- the business does not retain the personal information of a consumer who has requested deletion of the consumer’s personal information for any purpose other than providing it to a government agency for purposes of, and in furtherance of, a government program; and
- the government agency shall not further share or retain the information except for purposes of carrying out a government program.
- Provides that the obligations imposed on businesses by the CCPA shall not restrict a business’s ability to sell the personal information of a consumer who has opted-out of the sale of the consumer’s personal information to another person for the sole purpose of detecting security incidents, protecting against malicious, deceptive, fraudulent, or illegal activity, and prosecuting those responsible for that activity, provided that the business and the person shall not further sell that information for any other purpose.
- Sunsets these new exemptions on January 1, 2024
COMMENTS
- Protecting the fundamental right to privacy
Article I, Section 1 of the California Constitution provides: “All people are by nature free and independent and have inalienable rights. Among these are enjoying and defending life and liberty, acquiring, possessing, and protecting property, and pursuing and obtaining safety, happiness, and privacy.” Privacy is therefore not just a policy goal; it is a constitutional right of every Californian. However, it has been under increasing assault.
The phrase “and privacy” was added to the California Constitution as a result of Proposition 11 in 1972; it was known as the “Privacy Initiative.” The arguments in favor of the amendment were written by Assemblymember Kenneth Cory and Senator George Moscone. The ballot pamphlet stated, in relevant part:
At present there are no effective restraints on the information activities of government and business. This amendment creates a legal and enforceable right of privacy for every Californian. The right of privacy . . . prevents government and business interests from collecting and stockpiling unnecessary information about us and from misusing information gathered for one purpose in order to serve other purposes or to embarrass us. . . . The proliferation of government and business records over which we have no control limits our ability to control our personal lives. . . . Even more dangerous is the loss of control over the accuracy of government and business records on individuals. . . . Even if the existence of this information is known, few government agencies or private businesses permit individuals to review their files and correct errors. . . . Each time we apply for a credit card or a life insurance policy, file a tax return, interview for a job[,] or get a drivers' license, a dossier is opened and an informational profile is sketched.[1]
In 1977, the Legislature reaffirmed that the right of privacy is a “personal and fundamental right” and that “all individuals have a right of privacy in information pertaining to them.” (Civ. Code § 1798.1.) The Legislature further stated the following findings:
- “The right to privacy is being threatened by the indiscriminate collection, maintenance, and dissemination of personal information and the lack of effective laws and legal remedies.”
- “The increasing use of computers and other sophisticated information technology has greatly magnified the potential risk to individual privacy that can occur from the maintenance of personal information.”
- “In order to protect the privacy of individuals, it is necessary that the maintenance and dissemination of personal information be subject to strict limits.”
Although written almost 50 years ago, these concerns seem strikingly prescient.
- Responding to the systematic collection of consumers’ personal information
Today, the world’s most valuable resource is no longer oil, but data. Companies regularly and systematically collect, analyze, share, and sell the personal information of consumers. While this data collection provides consumers various benefits, public fears about the widespread, unregulated amassing of personal information have only grown since privacy was made a part of the California Constitution. Consumers’ web browsing, online purchases, and involvement in loyalty programs create a treasure trove of information on consumers. Many applications on the smartphones that most consumers carry with them throughout the day can track consumers’ every movement. In addition, data brokers amass vast amounts of information through various public and private sources, and package it for other businesses to buy.
The collection of this data combined with advanced technologies and the use of sophisticated algorithms can create incredibly detailed and effective profiling and targeted marketing from this web of information. Acxiom, a major data broker, offers “the World’s Most Powerful Consumer Insights” with “comprehensive consumer data on approximately 250 million U.S. addressable consumers,” or approximately 75 percent of the country’s population.[2] The company provides a sketch of the data elements collected: individual demographics such as age, gender, ethnicity, education; number/ages of children; economic stability; marriage/divorce; birth of children; products bought; and behavioral details, including community involvement, causes, and gaming. Vigilant Solutions, one of the largest providers of automated license plate reader systems, indicates that it can offer access to its private database of “over 5 billion nationwide detections and over 150 million more added monthly.”[3] The company’s website specifically advertises its ability to run advanced analytics across the vast troves of data it maintains.
A recent report by the Federal Trade Commission (FTC) found that data brokers “collect and store a vast amount of data on almost every U.S. household and commercial transaction,” most of them “store all data indefinitely,” and that “many of the purposes for which data brokers collect and use data pose risks to consumers.”[4]
In response to this increased surveillance, collection of personal information, and profiling, consumers have expressed growing concern. A study by the Pew Research Center found that 68 percent of American Internet users believe existing law does not go far enough to protect individual online privacy, with only 24 percent believing current laws provide reasonable protections.[5]
- Responding to the systematic collection of consumers’ personal information
In response to growing concerns about the privacy and safety of consumers’ data, proponents of the CCPA, a statewide ballot initiative, began collecting signatures in order to qualify it for the November 2018 election. The goal was to empower consumers to find out what information businesses were collecting on them and give them the choice to tell businesses to stop selling their personal information. In response to the pending initiative, which was subsequently withdrawn, AB 375 (Chau, Ch. 55, Stats. 2018) was introduced, quickly shepherded through the legislative process, and signed into law. The outcome was the CCPA, Civil Code Section 1798.100 et seq.
The CCPA grants a set of rights to consumers with regard to their personal information, including enhanced notice and disclosure rights regarding information collection and use practices, access to the information collected, the right to delete certain information, the right to restrict the sale of information, and protection from discrimination for exercising these rights.
AB 375 stated it was the intent of the Legislature “to further Californians’ right to privacy by giving consumers an effective way to control their personal information” through the following rights:
(1) The right of Californians to know what personal information is being collected about them.
(2) The right of Californians to know whether their personal information is sold or disclosed and to whom.
(3) The right of Californians to say no to the sale of personal information.
(4) The right of Californians to access their personal information.
(5) The right of Californians to equal service and price, even if they exercise their privacy rights.
This bill provides sweeping exemptions to the CCPA that arguably undermine the purposes of the CCPA and the existing rights of consumers.
- Exemptions from the CCPA
Currently, the CCPA provides for fairly broad exemptions that ensure certain critical activities of the business are not restricted or hindered by the obligations imposed by the law. Specifically, the CCPA provides that nothing therein shall restrict a business’s ability to do any of the following:
- comply with federal, state, or local laws;
- comply with a civil, criminal, or regulatory inquiry, investigation, subpoena, or summons by federal, state, or local authorities;
- cooperate with law enforcement agencies concerning conduct or activity that the business, service provider, or third party reasonably and in good faith believes may violate federal, state, or local law;
- exercise or defend legal claims;
- collect, use, retain, sell, or disclose consumer information that is deidentified or in the aggregate consumer information; or
- collect or sell a consumer’s personal information if every aspect of that commercial conduct takes place wholly outside of California.
(Civ. Code § 1798.145(a).)
This bill adds several additional exemptions to this list. First, the bill provides that the CCPA shall not interfere with a business’ ability to comply with regulations or rules adopted pursuant to and in furtherance of state or federal laws. It is not clear that this addition is necessary as such rules and regulations would likely be considered state or federal laws. However, the clarification is of little consequence. The other two exemptions, however, are much broader, and raise serious concerns about their potential effect on the operation and utility of the CCPA.
- Broad loophole for businesses that supply data to the government
The second major exemption created by this bill provides that the CCPA shall not restrict a business’ ability to provide “a consumer’s personal information to a government agency solely for the purposes of carrying out a government program, including providing government services in furtherance of a government program.” The bill then lays out several “requirements” that need to be met:
- the business does not sell the personal information of a consumer who has opted out of the sale of the consumer’s personal information for any purpose other than providing it to a government agency for purposes of, and in furtherance of, a government program;
- the business does not retain the personal information of a consumer who has requested deletion of the consumer’s personal information for any purpose other than providing it to a government agency for purposes of, and in furtherance of, a government program; and
- the government agency shall not further share or retain the information except for purposes of carrying out a government program.
There are several issues that are presented by this exemption. The most prominent is the sheer scope. The bill limits the ability of the CCPA to restrict the sharing of data for any agency carrying out any program. The “requirements” only further outline how far this exemption goes. So long as the business is providing data to some government entity or providing some service to some government entity, the business can effectively ignore the obligations of the CCPA. The language provides that a business is not required to delete a consumer’s personal information despite a legitimate request to delete from a consumer. A business can sell the personal information of a consumer to any government entity even after the consumer has legally opted out of such sales. These loopholes fundamentally undermine the control over personal information that the CCPA currently provides consumers. Consumers that would have every right to assume their data has either been deleted or that its sale was prohibited, could have their personal information being retained and sold by these businesses without their knowledge. To further exacerbate these issues, the government agency in receipt of the data can retain and further sell it.
The author states that the bill furthers “long-established public policy objectives” by allowing government programs to continue to “rely on the use of data from private firms.” According to the author, California has a duty to its people to assist in the “administration of debt recovery,” assist “state and local law enforcement efforts,” and other critical services. The author asserts that “[w]ithout this bill, California’s efforts will be undermined and unable to fulfil their intended purpose.”
First, as stated, the CCPA already has broad exemptions to allow for businesses to comply with any legal requirements. To the extent the relevant information is needed for law enforcement investigations, the law already allows businesses to ignore opt-out requests. If the information is subpoenaed, the business can turn it over.
Second, while there is undeniably utility for government programs in having unfettered access to the data collected by private businesses, Californians have a fundamental right to privacy and the CCPA provides a set of tools to effectuate that right without interfering with legal duties or unduly limiting the sharing of personal information.
Supporters of the bill, including the California Alliance of Caregivers, point to programs that attempt to locate the relatives of children taken out of their homes for possible placement. It is true that the CCPA may limit the government’s access to certain information for these and other programs, however, nothing in the CCPA prohibits the sharing of this data with government agencies. When the CCPA takes effect, these programs will continue to be able to reach into these private databases in an attempt to track down certain people. However, what the CCPA provides, and this bill takes away, is a person’s choice. In passing the CCPA, the Legislature made a determination that Californians should be able to have more control over where their information goes and who can have access to it.
Furthermore, the bill does not limit its scope to the reunification of families. Rather, the bill could clear the path for private companies such as the data brokers and surveillance corporations discussed above, to collect, keep, and sell the personal information of Californians without giving them a meaningful choice in the matter. One example of the potential for this unimpeded government surveillance is illustrated by a recent Los Angeles Times article:
The collection of more than 1,000 pages of contracts, emails, manuals and other materials shows some California law enforcement departments have granted ICE unfettered access to the personal data of drivers and that federal officials are using it to track and locate immigrants in the country illegally who might not have criminal records and could be protected under the state’s sanctuary and privacy policies.
. . .
The documents obtained by the ACLU provide the deepest look yet into the database run by Vigilant Solutions, one of the largest suppliers of data analysis software and equipment for police and sheriff’s departments across the country. They show more than 9,000 ICE agents nationwide have access to the Vigilant system through a $6.1-million contract with Thomson Reuters Special Services that was signed in December 2017 and runs through September 2020.[6]
Although certain information sharing could assist in uniting family members, as this article reveals, allowing private companies to amass this data and share it for any government program could also lead to tearing families apart.[7]
In addition, this ability to ignore consumer requests to delete or restrict sales of their personal information will only feed the growing data broker industry discussed above. Opponents of this bill argue that it “would allow data brokers to continue to collect and sell consumer data in totally unregulated fashion, simply by stating their intention to sell that data to government agencies at some future point in time. Recent media reports demonstrate the extraordinary scope of data that is collected by data brokers.”[8]
A coalition of governmental associations, including CSAC, the League of California Cities, and the California Special Districts Association, write in support of this exemption:
Local agencies are concerned that, without AB 1416, a wide variety of local services that the public wants and expects will be harmed. The definitions in the CCPA do not allow for the type of relationship government entities have with businesses that help provide critical data. Although government entities are not considered “businesses” under the CCPA, they are still third parties with whom businesses can be blocked from sharing information.
Collecting child support, contacting people who have been exposed to infectious diseases, finding family members of foster children, determining eligibility for human services, and even collecting taxes and court judgements from those who refuse to pay what they owe are examples of the types of services that will be hurt unless AB 1416 passes.
We do not believe that consumers should be able to use the provisions of the CCPA to avoid paying taxes or child support and we also do not believe those who avail themselves of the new privileges should inadvertently harm others by spreading infectious diseases or remaining unaware that an extended family member is in the foster care system.
Common Sense Kids Action and Californians for Consumer Privacy, the cosponsors of AB 375, explain their grave concerns with this provision of the bill:
AB 1416 would allow government data access to supersede a Californian’s constitutional right to privacy.
While governments have come to rely on excessive and unregulated consumer data collection, there is no evidence to suggest that consumer rights established through the CCPA will undermine government program implementation. Under the CCPA and proposed to be clarified by AB 874 (Irwin), governments will be able to rely on the aggregation and use of government records made public lawfully through local, state and federal government sources. These data sources will allow the ongoing administration of public programs.
It is unclear why the sale of a consumer’s private data, such as browsing history, retail purchases, geolocation data or fitness app data are necessary for the administration of government programs directly or potentially in the future. In the last year, there have been several examples of unnecessary, and what many have identified as inappropriate, government data collection and use.
. . .
Again, this measure focuses on a consumer’s personal information, often collected without their knowledge, not government records that are lawfully made available to the public. As a result this measure poses a significant question, “Should a business be able to sell your internet search history, your geo-location data, your retail purchases, your fitness app data, your television viewing habits and the recordings from your in home smart device, among other data, to a government agency, even if you have told the business or data broker not to sell your personal data, for no reason other than that they are selling it to a “government program”?
We believe the answer to that question is no.
- Impairing privacy to protect against potential fraud
The third exemption provided for by the bill provides that nothing in the CCPA shall restrict a business’ ability to:
Sell the personal information of a consumer who has opted-out of the sale of the consumer’s personal information to another person for the sole purpose of detecting security incidents, protecting against malicious, deceptive, fraudulent, or illegal activity, and prosecuting those responsible for that activity, provided that the business and the person shall not further sell that information for any other purpose.
A coalition led by the California Chamber of Commerce writes in support of this exemption:
The CCPA also inadvertently undermines efforts by businesses to protect consumers from identity theft and to prevent other crimes, like money laundering and human trafficking, because it contains no exception to the right to opt-out for the prevention or investigation of fraud or other illegal activities. If not fixed, this would allow bad actors to opt out of services designed to prevent or investigate fraudulent or illegal behavior.
The CCPA already recognizes part of this problem in the deletion section of the law, which has an exemption stating that businesses need not delete data that is necessary to detect security incidents or to protect against malicious, deceptive, fraudulent, or illegal activity. AB 1416 merely ensures that this same type of exemption can be applied to the right to opt out of the sale of data for these limited purposes.
This exemption, similar to the previous one, allows businesses to ignore a consumer’s decision to opt out of the sale of the consumer’s personal information. In this exemption, so long as there is an ostensible security purpose, a business can sell personal information that a person would reasonably expect could not be sold to any other business. One of the fundamental concepts in the CCPA is that a consumer should be able to contain the flow of their own information in this broader data-driven ecosystem. This exemption removes this safety valve.
Refinitiv, a company owned by Blackstone Group LP and Thomson Reuters, explains its support of the exemption: “To combat financial crime, private sector corporations, financial institutions, governments, law enforcement agencies and regulators often need to screen both customers and suppliers. In many cases, as with banks, these checks on organizations are mandatory.” It argues the changes made by the bill “recognize the need for an exemption related to activities performed that serve the public welfare and facilitate public safety (e.g., combatting financial crime and human trafficking). The exercise of individual rights in connection with the enumerated activities would undermine the ability of organizations to combat the specified crimes.”
Exacerbating the privacy concerns, although the bill restricts the business that receives the data from further selling that information, the exemption does not restrict the business from using it for any other internal purpose, so long as it is not sold. Therefore, the massive databases discussed above could be systematically fed this data to create incredibly detailed profiles of consumers.
For instance, a company such as Refinitiv provides services to businesses to fight financial crime and therefore, businesses could sell consumers’ personal information to Refinitiv for those purposes despite a consumer’s decision to opt out. However, Refinitiv also provides investment and wealth management services and others its “strong analytic capabilities” to “extract further value” from the data it is given.[9] The bill would not restrict Refinitiv from keeping that data and using it for its other activities.
Supporters of the bill identify the combatting of various crimes and investigations of illegal activity. However, again, existing exemptions in the CCPA make clear that nothing therein restricts a business’ ability to cooperate with law enforcement concerning illegal activity or exercising legal claims. In addition, as pointed out by the coalition in support, the CCPA already allows companies to retain data to detect security incidents, protect against malicious, deceptive, fraudulent, or illegal activity; or prosecute those responsible for that activity.
A coalition of consumer and privacy groups, including the Campaign for a Commercial-Free Childhood, the American Civil Liberties Union of California, and the Electronic Frontier Foundation, write in opposition to this exemption:
AB 1416 would undermine the consumer control embedded in the CCPA by allowing the sale and even resale of information to “detect security incidents, protect against malicious, deceptive, fraudulent, or illegal activity, and prosecute those responsible for that activity” even if the consumer has opted out of the sale of her information. Given the breath of these categories, especially with the increasing use of machine learning and other data-driven algorithms, there is no practical limit on the kinds of data that might be sold for these purposes. It would even allow sales based on the purchaser’s asserted purpose, increasing the potential for abuse, much like the disclosure of millions of Facebook user records by Cambridge Analytica. And it would leave the consumer unaware of and unable to respond to the sale of her information, which she would rightly assume had been foreclosed by her decision to opt out. Moreover, other provisions of the CCPA and AB 1416 already give businesses the ability to cooperate with law enforcement investigations or exercise their own legal claims.
Common Sense Kids Action and Californians for Consumer Privacy write:
The expansion of Civil Code Section 1798.145 (a)(6) will authorize a business to significantly undermine a consumer’s right to opt-out of the sale of their information under the CCPA. The proponents of this measure point to those potentially committing fraud as an excuse for the need to ignore some of CCPA’s major consumer rights and undermine consumer protections for all Californians who are simply seeking to limit the sale of their information and protect their privacy. The logic is absurd: since all consumers could potentially commit fraudulent acts, businesses must be allowed to collect all consumers’ personal information, to not delete it on request, and be allowed to ignore consumer requests not to sell it, since you never know when the authorities will need to examine years and years of any citizen’s personal information.
We have heard the story before, and we reject it. Our society will not be safer if the government knows everything about everyone: that is the road to totalitarianism.
SUPPORT
California State Association of Counties (sponsor)
Alliance for Children’s Rights
Azusa Chamber of Commerce
Brawley Chamber of Commerce
California Alliance of Caregivers
California Asian Pacific Chamber of Commerce
California Association of County Treasurers and Tax Collectors
California Association of Licensed Investigators, Inc.
California Association of Realtors
California Attractions and Parks Association
California Bankers Association
California Chamber of Commerce
California Credit Union League
California Land Title Association
California Special Districts Association
Camarillo Chamber of Commerce
Child Support Directors Association of California
Children Now
Civil Justice Association of California
Computing Technology Industry Association
Consumer Data Industry Association
County Health Executives Association of California
County Welfare Directors Association of California
CTIA
Electronic Transactions Association
Encino Chamber of Commerce
Entertainment Software Association
Garden Grove Chamber of Commerce
Greater Conejo Valley Chamber of Commerce
ID Analytics
Internet Association
Jaguar Land Rover North America, LLC
League of California Cities
LifeLock
Long Beach Area Chamber of Commerce
Los Angeles Area Chamber of Commerce
Murrieta/Wildomar Chamber of Commerce
North Orange County Chamber
Orange County Business Council
Oxnard Chamber of Commerce
Pleasanton Chamber of Commerce
Rancho Cordova Chamber of Commerce
Rani's Voice
Refinitiv
San Gabriel Valley Economic Partnership
Santa Clarita Valley Chamber of Commerce
Santa Maria Valley Chamber
Securities Industry and Financial Markets Association
Simi Valley Chamber
Southwest California Legislative Council
Symantec
Tech Net
Tesla
The Silicon Valley Organization
Tulare Chamber
OPPOSITION
Access Humboldt
American Civil Liberties Union of California
California Civil Liberties Advocacy
Californians for Consumer Privacy
Campaign for a Commercial-Free Childhood
Common Sense Kids Action
Consumer Attorneys of California
Consumer Federation of America
Consumer Reports
Digital Privacy Alliance
Electronic Frontier Foundation
Media Alliance
Oakland Privacy
Privacy Rights Clearinghouse
Purism
Three individuals
RELATED LEGISLATION
Pending:
SB 561 (Jackson, 2019) amends the private and consumer enforcement mechanisms in the CCPA. The bill also authorizes the Attorney General to provide general guidance on compliance with the CCPA. This bill is currently pending consideration in the Senate Appropriations Committee.
SB 753 (Stern, 2019) provides that a business does not sell personal information if the business, pursuant to a written contract, shares, discloses, or otherwise communicates to another business or third party a unique identifier only to the extent necessary to serve or audit a specific advertisement to the consumer. The bill requires the contract to prohibit the other business or third party from sharing, selling, or otherwise communicating the information except as necessary to serve or audit advertisement from the business. This bill is currently pending consideration in the Senate Judiciary Committee.
AB 25 (Chau, 2019) excludes from the definition of “consumer” in the CCPA a natural person whose personal information has been collected by a business in the course of a person acting as a job applicant or as an employee, contractor, or agent, on behalf of the business, to the extent their personal information is used for purposes compatible with the context of the person’s activities for the business as a job applicant, employee, contractor, or agent of the business. This bill is currently pending consideration in the Senate Judiciary Committee.
AB 288 (Cunningham, 2019) provides that when a user of a social networking service deactivates or deletes the user’s account, the service shall provide the user the option of having the user’s personally identifiable information permanently removed from any database controlled by the service, from the service’s records, and to prohibit the service from selling that information to, or exchanging that information with, a third party in the future. Consumers are authorized to bring civil actions for damages that occur as a result of violations of the bill, including attorney’s fees, pain and suffering, and punitive damages, as specified. This bill is currently pending consideration in the Assembly Privacy and Consumer Protection Committee.
AB 846 (Burke, 2019) authorizes a business to offer a different price, rate, level, or quality of goods or services to a consumer, including offering its goods or services for no fee, if either the offering is in connection with a loyalty or rewards program or the offering is for a specific good or service whose functionality is directly related to the collection, use, or sale of the consumer’s data. This bill is currently pending consideration in the Senate Judiciary Committee.
AB 873 (Irwin, 2019) loosens the definition of “deidentified” and narrows the definition of “personal information” in the CCPA. The bill thereby limits the personal information subject to the protections of the CCPA. This bill is currently pending consideration in the Senate Judiciary Committee.
AB 874 (Irwin, 2019) amends the definitions of “personal information” and “publicly available” in the CCPA. It removes the application of the CCPA to publicly available information that is used for a purpose that is not compatible with the purpose for which the data is maintained and made available in government records or for which it is publicly maintained. This bill is currently pending consideration in the Senate Judiciary Committee.
AB 981 (Daly, 2019) eliminates a consumer’s right to request a business delete or not sell the consumer’s personal information under the CCPA if it is necessary to retain or share the consumer’s personal information to complete an insurance transaction requested by the consumer. It also strengthens privacy protections for the information of insureds. This bill is currently pending consideration in the Senate Insurance Committee.
AB 1146 (Berman, 2019) exempts from the opt-out and deletion protections and provisions of the CCPA vehicle information, including ownership information, shared between a new motor vehicle dealer and the vehicle’s manufacturer, if the vehicle information is shared for the purpose of effectuating, or in anticipation of effectuating, a vehicle repair covered by a vehicle warranty or a recall and is not sold, shared, or used for any other purpose. This bill is currently pending consideration in the Senate Judiciary Committee.
AB 1355 (Chau, 2019) makes a series of technical changes to the CCPA and amends the definitions of “publicly available” and “personal information.” This bill is currently pending consideration in the Senate Judiciary Committee.
AB 1564 (Berman, 2019) reduces the methods a business must make available to consumers for submitting requests for information required to be disclosed pursuant to the CCPA. It removes the requirement that a business provide a toll-free telephone number for such purposes. This bill is currently pending consideration in the Senate Judiciary Committee.
AB 1760 (Wicks, 2019) strengthens various protections for consumers, including a change from opt-out consent for the sale of information to opt-in consent for the sharing of information. The bill also includes data minimization requirements and modifies various definitions. It also explicitly allows district attorneys, city attorneys, and county counsel to bring actions on behalf of the people for violations of the CCPA in addition to the Attorney General. It also removes the provision regarding the legal opinions of the Attorney General. This bill is currently pending consideration in the Assembly Privacy and Consumer Protection Committee.
Prior Legislation:
AB 375 (Chau, Ch. 55, Stats. 2018) See Comment 3.
SB 1121 (Dodd, Ch. 735, Stats. 2018) amended the CCPA to make technical fixes and to address various stakeholder concerns.
PRIOR VOTES:
Assembly Floor (Ayes 47, Noes 17)
Assembly Privacy and Consumer Protection Committee (Ayes 9, Noes 0)
**************
Hill v. National Collegiate Athletic Assn. (1994) 7 Cal.4th 1, 17, quoting the official ballot pamphlet for the Privacy Initiative. ↑
InfoBase®: The World’s Most Powerful Consumer Insights, Acxiom, https://www.acxiom.com/what-we-do/infobase/. ↑
See https://www.vigilantsolutions.com/products/license-plate-recognition-lpr/. ↑
FTC, Data Brokers: A Call for Transparency and Accountability (May 2014) https://www.ftc.gov/system/files/documents/reports/data-brokers-call-transparency-accountability-report-federal-trade-commission-may-2014/140527databrokerreport.pdf. ↑
Lee Rainie et al., Anonymity, Privacy, and Security Online (September 5, 2013) Pew Research Center, http://www.pewinternet.org/2013/09/05/anonymity-privacy-and-security-online/. ↑
Jazmine Ulloa, ICE is tracking immigrants with the help of California sanctuary cities, court records show (March 13, 2019) Los Angeles Times, https://www.latimes.com/politics/la-pol-ca-ice-license-plate-immigrants-20190313-story.html [as of Jul. 2, 2019]. ↑
Who’s Behind ICE? The Tech Companies Fueling Deportations (October 23, 2018) mijente, National Immigration Law Project & Immigrant Defense Project https://mijente.net/wp-content/uploads/2018/10/WHO%E2%80%99S-BEHIND-ICE_-The-Tech-and-Data-Companies-Fueling-Deportations-_v1.pdf [as of Jul. 2, 2019]. ↑
See Geoffrey A. Fowler, It’s the middle of the night. Do you know who your iPhone is talking to? (May 28, 2019) Washington Post, https://www.washingtonpost.com/technology/2019/05/28/its-middle-night-do-you-know-who-your-iphone-is-talking/?noredirect=on&utm_term=.e2912ac4769c [as of Jul. 2, 2019]. ↑
ASSEMBLY THIRD READING
ATR Bill Id:AB 1416
Author:(Cooley)
As Introduced Ver:May 6, 2019
Majority vote
SUMMARY:
This bill adds various exemptions to the California Consumer Privacy Act of 2018 (CCPA), as specified, subject to a four-year sunset.
Major Provisions
- Specifies that the obligations imposed on businesses by the CCPA shall not restrict a business's ability to comply with any rules or regulations adopted pursuant to and in furtherance of state or federal laws.
- Provides that the obligations imposed on businesses by the CCPA shall not restrict a business's ability to provide a consumer's personal information (PI) to a government agency solely for the purposes of carrying out a government program, including providing government services in furtherance of a government program, provided that certain requirements are met.
- Provides that the obligations imposed on businesses by the CCPA shall not restrict a business's ability to sell the PI of a consumer who has opted-out of the sale of the consumer's PI to another person for the sole purpose of detecting security incidents, protecting against malicious, deceptive, fraudulent, or illegal activity, and prosecuting those responsible for that activity, provided that the business and the person shall not further sell that information for any other purpose.
COMMENTS:
This bill was significantly narrowed in policy committee to address concerns that the bill was overly broad and could undermine the consumer protections in the CCPA. As indicated in the policy committee analysis, additional work may be necessary to ensure that the proponents' goals can be achieved without undermining the CCPA (see, pp. 11-12), and ultimately, "there remains a fundamental policy question as to whether, and when, government access interests outweigh the consumer's privacy interests. Relatedly, there also remains a public policy question as to whether there should be a limit to how many years the information may be retained for these purposes, once the consumer has opted-out or sought to delete the information. Arguably, the information loses a great deal of utility after a number of years, and a person's privacy interests should outweigh the interest in maintaining that information in the event that it might be useful five, 10, or even 20 years down the line" (see, p. 8).
According to the Author:
"AB 1416 will further long-established public policy objectives in that it allows California to continue to operate as expected, providing critical programs and social services when such essential services rely on the use of data from private firms. California's duty to its people includes assisting state and local law enforcement efforts and fraud prevention, administration of debt recovery, and prioritizing the placement of foster youth with blood-related family. Without this bill, California's efforts will be undermined and unable to fulfil their intended purpose."
Arguments in Support:
Similar to other organizations' arguments about impacts on their programs, the California Alliance of Caregivers writes that without this bill, "services related to child welfare would be negatively impacted." Specifically, "[i]n order to achieve the goals of CCR [Continuum of Care Reform], it is imperative that agencies are able to locate family or extended family members who are able and willing to care for their relatives/friends suffering from abuse and neglect. Child Welfare agencies needs to locate potential caregivers quickly so that children do not suffer the additional trauma of moving from one temporary placement to another as the agency struggles to find able and willing family or friends of the child.
For thousands of children awaiting permanency in California, timely access to information could be life changing. If this fix is not made to personal data collection and privacy, the gains that the child welfare system has made to provide the best placements for children entering the child welfare system will be impeded. The definitions provided for in AB 375 [(Chau), Chapter 55, Statutes of 2018] do not accurately reflect the relationship between a government entity and the businesses that retain and disseminate critical data. Although government entities are not considered 'businesses' under AB 375, they are still third parties with whom businesses can be blocked from sharing information pursuant to a consumer opt-out. The consumer opt-out could mean dropping out of records needed for family finding in Child Welfare agencies."
Arguments in Opposition:
Californians for Consumer Privacy fundamentally disagrees with the proponents of this bill over the question of whether government data access should supersede consumer privacy rights: "We recognize that governments have come to rely on the data industry to enhance the administration of various programs. While there may be some areas where data use by government is warranted, authorizing the continued and unfettered operation of the data surveillance economy, even when a consumer has exercised their right to opt-out of the sale of their information, threatens the very essence of right to privacy guaranteed by the California Constitution, and enhanced by the CCPA. We are greatly concerned that AB 1416 would provide the right for data brokers and other businesses to continue the unchecked collection of consumer data if they are willing to provide it to a government agency. Unfortunately, we believe this type of allowance would greatly undermine the right for a consumer to opt-out of the sale of their data."
FISCAL COMMENTS:
Unknown
VOTES:
ASM PRIVACY AND CONSUMER PROTECTION: 9-0-2
YES: Kiley, Bauer-Kahan, Berman, Calderon, Gabriel, Gallagher, Irwin, Obernolte, Smith
ABS, ABST OR NV: Chau, Wicks
UPDATED:
VERSION: May 6, 2019
CONSULTANT: Ronak Daylami / P. & C.P. / (916) 319-2200 FN: 0000404
Date of Hearing: April 30, 2019
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON PRIVACY AND CONSUMER PROTECTION
Ed Chau, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 1416 (
Author:Cooley) – As Introduced Ver:February 22, 2019
SUBJECT: Business: collection and disclosures of Consumer personal information
SUMMARY: This bill would expand the exemptions to the California Consumer Privacy Act of 2018 (CCPA), as specified. Specifically, this bill would:
- Specify that the obligations imposed on businesses by the CCPA shall not restrict a business’s ability to comply with any rules or regulations.
- Expand the current exemption for exercising or defending legal claims to instead allow businesses to collect, use, retain, sell, authenticate, or disclose personal information (PI) in order to do any of the following:
- Exercise, defend, or protect against legal claims.
- Protect against or prevent fraud or unauthorized transactions.
- Protect against or prevent security incidents or other malicious, deceptive, or illegal activity.
- Investigate, report, or prosecute those responsible for any activity set forth in the preceding two paragraphs.
- Add a new exemption specifying that the obligations imposed on businesses by the CCPA shall not restrict a business’s ability to collect, use, retain, sell, authenticate, or disclose a consumer’s PI for the purpose of assisting another person or government agency to conduct any of the activities specified directly above.
EXISTING LAW:
- Establishes the CCPA and provides various rights to consumers pursuant to the act. Subject to various general exemptions, a consumer has, among other things:
- the right to know what PI a business collects about consumers, as specified, including the categories of third parties with whom the business shares PI, and the specific pieces of information collected about the consumer;
- the right to know what PI a business sells about consumers, as specified, including the categories of PI that the business sold about the consumer and the categories of third parties to whom the PI was sold, by category or categories of PI for each third party to whom the PI was sold;
- the right to access the specific pieces of information a business has collected about the consumer;
- the right to delete information that a business has collected from the consumer;
- the right to opt-out of the sale of the consumer’s PI if over 16 years of age, and the right to opt-in, as specified, if the consumer is a minor; and,
- the right to equal service and price, despite exercising any of these rights. (Civ. Code Sec. 1798.100 et seq.)
- Generally requires under the CCPA that a business subject to the CCPA do all of the following, among other things: comply with the above requirements, provide various notices to those ends, and execute various requests upon receipt of a VCR, as specified; and provide certain mechanisms for consumers to make their lawful requests, including a clear and conspicuous link titled “Do Not Sell My Personal Information” on the business’s internet homepage to enable consumers, or a person authorized by the consumer, to opt-out of the sale of the consumer’s PI. (Civ. Code Sec. 1798.100 et seq.)
- Provides that a consumer has the right to request that a business delete any PI about the consumer which the business has collected from the consumer, subject to specified exceptions. Specifically, a business or a service provider are not required to comply with a consumer’s request to delete the consumer’s PI if it is necessary for the business or service provider to maintain the consumer’s PI in order to, among other things:
- Complete the transaction for which the PI was collected, provide a good or service requested by the consumer, or reasonably anticipated within the context of a business’s ongoing business relationship with the consumer, or otherwise perform a contract between the business and the consumer.
- Detect security incidents, protect against malicious, deceptive, fraudulent, or illegal activity; or prosecute those responsible for that activity.
- Debug to identify and repair errors that impair existing intended functionality.
- Comply with the California Electronic Communications Privacy Act, as specified.
- Comply with a legal obligation. (Civ. Code Sec. 1798.105, “the right to delete.”)
- Grants all consumers over the age of 16 the right, at any time, to direct a business that sells PI about the consumer to third parties not to sell the consumer’s PI (the right to “opt-out”). For all consumers less than 16 years of age, prohibits businesses from selling PI unless the consumer (or in the case of consumers under 13 years of age, the consumer’s parent or guardian) has affirmatively authorized the sale of the consumer’s PI (the right to “opt-in”). (Civ. Code Sec. 1798.120.)
- Provides various exemptions under the CCPA. Specifically:
- Provides that the obligations imposed on businesses by the CCPA shall not restrict a business’s ability to do the following, among other things:
- Comply with federal, state, or local laws.
- Comply with a civil, criminal, or regulatory inquiry, investigation, subpoena, or summons by federal, state, or local authorities.
- Cooperate with law enforcement agencies concerning conduct or activity that the business, service provider, or third party reasonably and in good faith believes may violate federal, state, or local law.
- Exercise or defend legal claims. (Civ. Code Sec. 1798.145.)
- Provides that the CCPA shall not apply to, among other things:
- The sale of PI to or from a consumer reporting agency if that information is to be reported in, or used to generate, a consumer report as defined under specified federal regulations, and use of that information is limited by the federal Fair Credit Reporting Act (15 U.S.C. Sec. 1681 et seq.).
- PI collected, processed, sold or disclosed pursuant to the federal Gramm-Leach-Bliley Act (Public Law 106-102), or the California Financial Information Privacy Act (Fin. Code Sec. 4050 et seq.) (Civ. Code Sec. 1798.145.)
- Provides various definitions under the CCPA. The CCPA, of particular relevance for this bill, defines the following terms:
- “Business” means a sole proprietorship, partnership, limited liability company, corporation, association, or other legal entity that is organized or operated for the profit or financial benefit of its shareholders or other owners, that collects consumers’ PI, or on the behalf of which such information is collected and that alone, or jointly with others, determines the purposes and means of the processing of consumers’ PI, that does business in California, and that satisfies one or more of specified thresholds,
- “Third party” means a person who is not any one of the following:
- The business that collects the PI.
- A person to whom the business discloses a consumer’s PI for a business purpose, pursuant to a written contract that prohibits, among other things, the recipient from selling the PI, or retaining, using, or disclosing the PI outside the direct business relationship between the person and the business.
- “PI” means information that identifies, relates to, describes, is capable of being associated with, or could reasonably be linked, directly or indirectly, with a particular consumer or household. PI includes certain specific types of information, if that information identifies, relates to, describes, is capable of being associated with, or could be reasonably linked, directly or indirectly, with a particular consumer or household. These include, for example:
- Identifiers such as a real name, alias, postal address, unique personal identifier, online identifier, Internet Protocol address, email address, account name, social security number, driver’s license number, passport number, or other similar identifiers.
- Characteristics of protected classifications under California or federal law.
- Commercial information, as specified.
PI does not include publicly available information, as specified. Among other things specifies that for these purposes, “publicly available” means information that is lawfully made available from federal, state, or local government records, as specified. Information is not “publicly available” if that data is used for a purpose that is not compatible with the purpose for which the data is maintained and made available in the government records or for which it is publicly maintained.
- “Sell,” “selling,” “sale,” or “sold,” means selling, renting, releasing, disclosing, disseminating, making available, transferring, or otherwise communicating orally, in writing, or by electronic or other means, a consumer’s PI by the business to another business or a third party for monetary or other valuable consideration. For purposes of the CCPA, a business does not “sell” PI when, among other things:
- A consumer uses or directs the business to intentionally disclose, as specified, PI or uses the business to intentionally interact with a third party, provided the third party does not also sell the PI, unless that disclosure would be consistent with this bill.
- The business uses or shares an identifier for a consumer who has opted out of the sale of the consumer’s PI for the purposes of alerting third parties that the consumer has opted out of the sale of the consumer’s PI.
- The business uses or shares with a service provider PI of a consumer that is necessary to perform a business purpose if both of the following conditions are met: (i) the business has provided notice that information being used or shared in its terms and conditions, as otherwise specified under the bill; and (ii) the service provider does not further collect, sell, or use the PI of the consumer except as necessary to perform the business purpose. (Civ. Code Sec. 1798.140.)
FISCAL EFFECT: None. This bill has been keyed nonfiscal by the Legislative Counsel.
COMMENTS:
- Purpose of this bill: This bill seeks to ensure that public entities can receive data necessary for various programs, services, or purposes after the CCPA takes effect. This is sponsored by the California State Association of Counties.
- Author’s statement: According to the author, “AB 1416 will further long-established public policy objectives in that it allows California to continue to operate as expected, providing critical programs and social services when such essential services rely on the use of data from private firms. California’s duty to its people includes assisting state and local law enforcement efforts and fraud prevention, administration of debt recovery, and prioritizing the placement of foster youth with blood-related family. Without this bill, California’s efforts will be undermined and unable to fulfil their intended purpose.”
- Impact of CCPA on government entities at debate in this bill: Last year, the Legislature enacted the CCPA (AB 375, Chau, Ch. 55, Stats. 2018), which gives consumers certain rights regarding their PI, such as: (1) the right to know what PI that is collected and sold about them; (2) the right to request the categories and specific pieces of PI the business collects about them; (3) the right to delete PI collected from them; and, (4) the right to opt-out of the sale of their PI, or opt-in in the case of minors under 16 years of age.
The author argues that, “[a]s a consequence of the CCPA, California’s government agencies fall under the same restrictions as non-government agencies, and businesses will be prevented from sharing collected personal information with a legitimate government program if a consumer opts-out of their data sharing. AB 1416 remedies the CCPA by removing restrictions preventing businesses from sharing personal information of opted-out consumers with government agencies, and removes restrictions preventing the business from doing so in order to comply with state, federal, or local laws and regulations. Additionally, permitting government agencies to access personal data will allow the government to continue operating mandated programs, such as combating identity theft, assisting law enforcement apprehend criminals, and prioritizing the placement of foster youth with blood relatives.”
Under the CCPA, a business is a “sole proprietorship, partnership, limited liability company, corporation, association, or other legal entity that is organized or operated for the profit or financial benefit of its shareholders or other owners, that collects consumers’ PI, or on the behalf of which such information is collected and that alone, or jointly with others, determines the purposes and means of the processing of consumers’ PI, that does business in California, and that satisfies one or more” of three possible thresholds relating to: (1) the business’s gross revenue; (2) the number of consumers, households, or devices, alone or in combination, from which the business, alone or in combination, annually buys, receives for the business’s commercial purposes, sells, or shares for commercial purposes, PI; or, (3) the percentage of their annual revenues that they derive from the sale of consumers’ PI.
A third party is a “person” who is not: (1) the business that collects the PI; or, (2) a person to whom the business discloses a consumer’s PI for a business purpose, pursuant to a written contract that prohibits, among other things, the recipient from selling the PI, or retaining, using, or disclosing the PI outside the direct business relationship between the person and the business. “Person” in turn, means an individual, proprietorship, firm, partnership, […] and any other organization or group of persons acting in concert.
Government entities are clearly not “businesses.” The question then becomes if they can be a “person” who can then be considered a “third party” for purposes of the CCPA. Arguably, to the extent a state agency, department, or office could be considered “any other organization or group of persons acting in concert,” a government entity could be considered a “person” for purposes of the CCPA’s “third person” definition. In support, the California Alliance of Caregivers also writes that without this bill, “services related to child welfare would be negatively impacted.” Specifically:
In order to achieve the goals of CCR [Continuum of Care Reform], it is imperative that agencies are able to locate family or extended family members who are able and willing to care for their relatives/friends suffering from abuse and neglect. Child Welfare agencies needs to locate potential caregivers quickly so that children do not suffer the additional trauma of moving from one temporary placement to another as the agency struggles to find able and willing family or friends of the child.
For thousands of children awaiting permanency in California, timely access to information could be life changing. If this fix is not made to personal data collection and privacy, the gains that the child welfare system has made to provide the best placements for children entering the child welfare system will be impeded. The definitions provided for in AB 375 do not accurately reflect the relationship between a government entity and the businesses that retain and disseminate critical data. Although government entities are not considered “businesses” under AB 375, they are still third parties with whom businesses can be blocked from sharing information pursuant to a consumer opt-out. The consumer opt-out could mean dropping out of records needed for family finding in Child Welfare agencies.
While locating family and non-related extended family members is indeed critical to the child welfare system, staff notes that the CCPA does not limit information available by way of the California Public Records Act, which is a resource available to all persons, public and private, to obtain government records. Additionally, companies in the business of aggregating information in the provision of government services would be able to share that information with government entities.
That being said, if the concern is to ensure that government programs are not unduly compromised by stifling the flow of information from businesses and data aggregators to government entities, a question is raised as to why the bill does not simply reflect a narrow exemption for governmental entities to obtain information for purposes of governmental programs. Indeed, this bill, instead, seeks to add new exemptions to the CCPA that apply not only to businesses that interact with government entities to provide them with vital data for purposes of government programs, but also to businesses that have no interaction whatsoever with government entities.
- Exemptions offered by this bill apply much more expansively than necessary to address the author’s intent: As noted above, this bill is largely premised on concerns about the unintended consequences that the CCPA may have on government agencies carrying forth their government programs, but the solution is not tailored as such. In addition to expanding the CCPA exemptions to specify that the act does not restrict a business’s ability comply with “any rules or regulations” (see Comment 6 for more), this bill would expand the CCPA’s existing exemptions to specify that the act does not restrict a business’s ability to collect, use, retain, sell, authenticate, or disclose PI for any of the following:
- in order to exercise, defend, or protect against legal claims (the CCPA already has an exemption for exercising or defending legal claims);
- in order to protect against or prevent fraud or unauthorized transactions;
- in order to protect against or prevent security incidents or other malicious, deceptive, or illegal activity;
- in order to investigate, report, or prosecute those responsible for protecting against fraud, unauthorized transactions, and preventing security incidents or other specified activities; or,
- for the purpose of assisting another person or government agency to conduct the aforementioned activities.
Again, nothing within the express language of the above exemptions is limited to facilitating necessary data exchanges between businesses and government entities in furtherance of the latter’s legitimate governmental programs or services. Rather, the provisions also apply to businesses who have no interaction with government entities to provide businesses exemptions both within the context of their own internal non-governmental activities, as well when assisting another person to conduct such non-governmental activities. Compare this to another bill this Committee considered very recently, AB 1564 (Berman), which included a limited exemption from the CCPA to enable vehicle manufacturers and car dealers to be able to retain and share data between them, and only them, if that data is necessary for warranty or recall purposes pursuant to federal law.
Here, a business having no interaction with a government agency, could now claim under the proposed changes to this exemptions section, that they need to retain a consumer’s PI or share it with other companies in order to “protect against” legal claims or investigate malicious activity, and so forth. (See Proposed Section 1798.145(a)(4) and (7).) Such general exemptions to the CCPA are arguably unnecessary and overly broad. For example, protecting against legal claims is a much different standard that exercising or defending legal claims – both of which are appropriately included in the existing CCPA exemptions. (Civ. Code Sec. 1798.140(a)(4).) Put another way, any action that a business takes as a reasonable actor, could be couched as avoiding or “protecting against” legal claims. In opposition, the Californians for Consumer Privacy (CCP) writes:
The expansion of Civil Code Section 1798.145 (a)(4) will authorize a business to take away nearly every consumer right established under the CCPA. The inclusion of the following language would introduce new and broad vagueness within the CCPA, allowing a business to collect, use, retain, sell or disclose a consumer’s data for virtually any purpose[…].
The inclusion of terms such as “protect against” and “investigate” provide ultimate discretion for a business not to comply with the provisions of the CCPA. As written, this language represents a significant erosion of brand-new consumer rights. In addition, many of the situations raised in AB 1416’s new language are already addressed elsewhere in the law. For example, the CCPA already provides exceptions to the title where there could reasonably be a concern regarding legal claims, fraud, security incidents, etc.
Subdivisions (1) through (3) [of the existing CCPA exemptions] provide all the required authority necessary for a business to provide data to law enforcement with respect to potential violations of the law. Subdivision (4) provides all the authority necessary to defend against legal claims. AB 1416’s proposed allowance of the collection and sale of personal information simply to, for example, ‘protect against...legal claims’ or to ‘investigate...malicious activity’ could theoretically allow the almost unlimited collection and sale of personal information, on the grounds that a business was taking preemptive steps to prepare for a bad outcome.
Additionally, as alluded to in Comment 3, above, even if the bill were to be limited to the context of information sharing between businesses and government agencies, the CCPA allows for government agencies to obtain a wealth of information from businesses that may be instrumental to their governmental activities – for example, information aggregated from federal, state, or local public records, particularly as proposed to be amended by AB 874 (Irwin), would not constitute PI and would not be subject to sharing restrictions under the CCPA.
Accordingly, if this Committee were to approve this bill, it may wish to strike the new exemptions specified above (under proposed paragraphs (a)(4) and (7)) to, instead, create a narrow exemption that would allow a business to provide a consumer’s PI to a public entity for purposes of government programs, consistent with the author’s intent. To this end, the following amendments would enable a business to share data in its possession with government entities for purposes of their government programs, even if a consumer opts-out or requests to have their PI deleted by that business, but not for any other purpose. They also ensure that the government agency does not further share or retain the PI for non-programmatic related purposes. Lastly, these amendments would also reinstate the CCPA’s existing exemption for a business to “exercise or defend legal claims.”
Suggested amendment:
On page 2, strike lines 15-23 and insert: “(4) Exercise or defend legal claims.
(5) Provide a consumer’s personal information to a government agency solely for the purposes of carrying out a government program, including providing government services in furtherance of a government program, provided that all of the following requirements are met:
(A) the business does not sell the personal information of a consumer who has opted out of the sale of the consumer’s personal information for any purpose other than providing it to a government agency for purposes of, and in furtherance of, a government program;
(B) the business does not retain the personal information of a consumer who has requested deletion of the consumer’s personal information for any purpose other than providing it to a government agency for purposes of, and in furtherance of, a government program; and
(C) the government agency shall not further share or retain the information except for purposes of carrying out a government program.”
On page 3, strike lines 6-10, inclusive.
That being said, there remains a fundamental policy question as to whether, and when, government access interests outweigh the consumer’s privacy interests. Relatedly, there also remains a public policy question as to whether there should be a limit to how many years the information may be retained for these purposes, once the consumer has opted-out or sought to delete the information. Arguably, the information loses a great deal of utility after a number of years, and a person’s privacy interests should outweigh the interest in maintaining that information in the event that it might be useful five, 10, or even 20 years down the line.
- Exemption for businesses to share information with other businesses to prevent fraud or security incidents: As noted above, as introduced, this bill not only seeks to allow for businesses to share PI with government agencies to protect against or prevent fraud or security incidents and other malicious, deceptive, or illegal activities (or investigate such activities), but also to share a consumer’s PI with other non-governmental persons for those same purposes. Staff notes that the primary concern stated by the author relates only to government agencies. The amendment in Comment 3, above, achieves those purposes.
That said, many proponents have indicated that security and fraud exemptions are necessary, lest the CCPA allow fraudsters, hackers and other criminals to use the CCPA to opt-out of inclusion of their PI in products offered by fraud and cybersecurity companies. These proponents also argue that fraud prevention is specifically mentioned under the General Data Protection Regulation of the European Union (the EU equivalent to the CCPA). Staff notes that the CCPA already includes provisions specific to fraud and security concerns. Indeed, as noted by the CCP’s opposition in Comment 3, under the existing CCPA, non-public entities and persons have the ability to retain information pursuant to an express exemption in the right of deletion. Specifically, the right of deletion specifies that a business or a service provider shall not be required to comply with a consumer’s request to delete the consumer’s PI if it is necessary for the business or service provider to maintain the consumer’s PI in order to “detect security incidents, protect against malicious, deceptive, fraudulent, or illegal activity; or prosecute those responsible for that activity.” Further, under the CCPA, businesses have the right to use PI for business purposes that expressly include, again, “detecting security incidents, protecting against malicious, deceptive, fraudulent, or illegal activity, and prosecuting those responsible for that activity.” As further noted by CCP in opposition to the bill:
[…] the CCPA contemplated situations where information would need to be shared by a business, even if a consumer elected to exercise their right to opt-out. Under Civil Code Section 1798.140 (d), law defines a “business purpose” which defines situations in which a business may need to share information for an operational purpose. Specifically, that provision reads as follows [in relevant part]:
Civil Code Section 1798.140 (d) “Business purpose” means the use of personal information for the business’s or a service provider’s operational purposes, or other notified purposes, provided that the use of personal information shall be reasonably necessary and proportionate to achieve the operational purpose for which the personal information was collected or processed or for another operational purpose that is compatible with the context in which the personal information was collected. Business purposes are:
(1) Auditing related to a current interaction with the consumer and concurrent transactions, including, but not limited to, counting ad impressions to unique visitors, verifying positioning and quality of ad impressions, and auditing compliance with this specification and other standards.
(2) Detecting security incidents, protecting against malicious, deceptive, fraudulent, or illegal activity, and prosecuting those responsible for that activity.
Thus, we see that as with deletion, Civil Code Section 1798.140 (d) already provides solutions to the problems that AB 1416 proposes to ‘fix,’ especially in subsection (2) above. The CCPA was constructed in a way to provide consumers the right to have control of their data in a world where data increasingly proliferates through the economy without consumers’ consent or control. The law already has important safeguards to prevent fraudulent activity and defend against legal claims. [Emphases in original.]
As such, it is unclear as to why any further exemption is needed here when the CCPA already addresses fraud prevent and security. In fact, expanding the CCPA exemptions in the manner proposed by this bill could very well present a potential loophole in the law, however unintentional. That being said, in support of this bill, a coalition business groups led by the California Chamber of Commerce (CalChamber) insist that:
The CCPA’s opt-out provision also undermines legal compliance activities and efforts by businesses to protect consumers from identity theft and to prevent other crimes, like money laundering and human trafficking, because it contains no exception for the prevention or investigation of fraud or other illegal activities. If not fixed, this would allow bad actors to opt out of services designed to prevent or investigate fraudulent or illegal behavior. […]
The CCPA already recognizes part of this problem in the deletion section of the law, which has an exemption stating that businesses need not delete data that is necessary to detect security incidents or to protect against malicious, deceptive, fraudulent, or illegal activity. AB 1416 ensures that this same type of exemption can be applied to the right to opt out of the sale of data for these limited purposes.
This fix is necessary because other provisions of the CCPA do not address this concern. Although the definition of business purpose in the CCPA contains an exemption for “detecting security incidents, protecting against malicious, deceptive, fraudulent, or illegal activity, and prosecuting those responsible for that activity,” there is no provision stating that by having a statutorily defined “business purpose” a business may refuse to honor an opt-out request.
Further, as discussed in the example above, provisions that exempt some data exchanges between a “Business” and a “Service Provider” from the definition of “sale” do not address the problem either. Companies providing fraud or crime prevention/investigation data services to businesses and governments are not “Service Providers” to those customers under the CCPA. A “Service Provider” is an entity that receives data from a Business and processes it solely for the Business. Instead, companies providing fraud or crime prevention/investigation services are selling data they control to another business or government agency; they are not only processing the data of the business or government agency.
If the Committee and author desire to eliminate remaining confusion on this matter, then the exemption should be limited to mirror the same language provided in the “right of deletion” and the “business purposes” definition, given the concerns that the bill’s proposed exemptions are unnecessarily broad and could create loopholes where none exist in the CCPA currently. Any amendment should be narrowly drawn to authorize a business to share with a person the PI of a consumer who has opted-out of the sale of the consumer’s PI for the sole purpose of (mirroring those provisions) “detecting security incidents, protecting against malicious, deceptive, fraudulent, or illegal activity, and prosecuting those responsible for that activity,” provided that the business and the person shall not further sell that information for any other purpose. Such a narrow exemption would be tailored to the actual complaint of the CalChamber coalition: that the existing provisions in the right of deletion and business purposes definition for detecting security incidents, protecting against malicious, deceptive, fraudulent, or illegal activity, and prosecuting those responsible for that activity do not apply to situations where the consumer has opted-out of the sale of their PI. Otherwise, this Committee should, as suggested in Comment 4, above, repeal these provisions in their entirety and focus on the author’s concern regarding governmental entities and recognition for “rules and regulations,” as discussed in Comment 6, below.
- Exemption for necessary compliance with federal, state, or local laws: As noted above, among the various exemptions sought by this bill is the addition of an exemption which provides that the obligations of the CCPA shall not restrict a business’s ability to comply with any rules or regulations. Currently the CCPA simply states it does not restrict a business’s ability to comply with federal, state, or local laws.
In support, Tesla writes “[c]urrently, while the CCPA provides that the Act shall not restrict a business’s ability to comply with federal, state, or local laws, it is silent with respect rules or regulations. […] For example, the California Air Resources Board (CARB) adopted regulations that will authorize electric vehicle (EV) manufacturers, EV charging equipment developers, and load serving entities (electric utilities and Community Choice Aggregators) to earn credits via the Low Carbon Fuel Standard (LCFS) when customers charge their EVs. However, CARB’s regulations will require these parties to obtain and report VIN-level data from EV owners for verification purposes, potentially triggering CCPA’s requirements to disclose this information as a “sale” of a customer’s personal information. This will unfortunately create an onerous and unintended compliance obligation that may frustrate the intent of the LCFS and limit the amount of data available to CARB to audit compliance with the regulation.”
CCP argues in opposition that, “it is unclear why the current language in Civil Code Section 1798.145 (a)(1) does not provide sufficient clarity to businesses to ensure that the CCPA will not restrict a business’s ability to comply with current law. We have great concerns that the blanket inclusion of rules and regulations, as proposed in AB 1416, will be a vector for nefarious actors to avoid some of CCPA’s key consumer protections. We believe this inclusion is expansive and ambiguous, will create confusion and will provide a significant loophole.”
Staff notes that adding “any rules or regulations” could undermine the CCPA if, for example, a federal agency or commission were to adopt rules or regulations with the specific intent to undermine the CCPA. While Congress, too, could seek to enact legislation that would preempt the CCPA, passing federal legislation arguably entails greater checks and balances than a commission quietly passing regulations. Furthermore, there is a question as to whether local rules or regulations should ever effectively preempt state law. That being said, the bill actually goes even further than allowing for an exemption for federal, state, or local rules or regulations. It creates an exemption for any rules or regulations. In other words, if a company adopted rules or regulations, they could exempt themselves from the CCPA. Such an outcome is untenable.
If this Committee were to approve this bill, the author should continue to work with stakeholders and Committee to ensure that this provision can be narrowed in a manner that can achieve the stated goal of proponents, without undermining the CCPA. At the very least, the bill should arguably be narrowed to state that the obligations of the CCPA shall not restrict a business’s ability to retain or share information as necessary to comply with requirements of federal or state rules or regulations adopted in furtherance of federal or state laws, as follows:
Suggested amendment:
On page 2, lines 5-6, after “or any rules or regulations” insert “adopted pursuant to and in furtherance of state or federal laws.”
- Other arguments in support: The California Association of County Treasurers and Tax Collectors writes in support that “[t]ax collectors contract with some private entities to research delinquent or defaulted taxpayers, or to conduct other critical work in furtherance of their operations. These contracts produce data needed to successfully implement valuable debt offset and recovery programs in partnership with the California Franchise Tax Board. Private data helps ensure that local agencies are not only notifying the correct resident when multiple residents have the same name, but also ensures that the correct resident has his or her payment accounted for. Absent the passage of AB 1416, collection efforts would be harmed.”
The Alliance for Children’s Rights supports AB 1416, “to ensure access to information databases by county child welfare workers when seeking emergency placements with relatives to support children removed from their homes as a result of allegations of abuse or neglect. County child welfare workers also utilize such data when undertaking family finding and engagement activities in their diligent efforts to identify, locate and engage appropriate relatives to support children in foster care.” Specifically, the Alliance writes, “[f]amily finding and engagement may be compromised as a result of an unintended consequence of the “consumer opt-out” provision enacted in the Consumer Privacy Act of 2018 (Civil Code 1798.105.(a) by interfering with continued appropriate use of complete information databases by child welfare workers when undertaking required efforts to find and engage family members to support children in foster care.”
Staff notes that, arguably, the alternative solution offered in Comment 3, above, would address the proponents concerns of the impact the CCPA will have on their programs.
- Other arguments in opposition: In opposition, the CCP fundamentally disagrees with the proponents of this legislation over the question of whether government data access should supersede consumer privacy rights.
We recognize that governments have come to rely on the data industry to enhance the administration of various programs. While there may be some areas where data use by government is warranted, authorizing the continued and unfettered operation of the data surveillance economy, even when a consumer has exercised their right to opt-out of the sale of their information, threatens the very essence of right to privacy guaranteed by the California Constitution, and enhanced by the CCPA.
We are greatly concerned that AB 1416 would provide the right for data brokers and other businesses to continue the unchecked collection of consumer data if they are willing to provide it to a government agency. Unfortunately, we believe this type of allowance would greatly undermine the right for a consumer to opt-out of the sale of their data.
- Related legislation: AB 25 (Chau) seeks to clarify the CCPA’s definition of consumer and how businesses may comply with a consumer’s request for specific pieces of information in a privacy protective manner under the CCPA. This bill is pending hearing in the Assembly Appropriations Committee.
AB 288 (Cunningham) seeks to establish laws governing “social media privacy” separately from the CCPA’s existing requirements for such companies that meet the “business” definition thresholds identified in the CCPA. Specifically, the bill would require a social networking service, as defined, to provide users that close their accounts the option to have the user’s “personally identifiable information” permanently removed from the company’s database and records and to prohibit the service from selling that information to, or exchanging that information with, a third party in the future, subject to specified exceptions. The bill would authorize consumers to bring private right of action for a violation of these provisions, as specified. This bill has been referred to this Committee.
AB 523 (Irwin) seeks to protect Californians’ privacy with respect to the sale of their geolocation information by telephone corporations. This bill is pending hearing in this Committee.
AB 846 (Burke) seeks to replace “financial incentive programs” provisions in the non-discrimination statute of the CCPA with an authorization for offerings that include, among other things, gift cards or certificates, discounts, payments to consumers, or other benefits associated with a loyalty or rewards program, as specified. This bill is pending hearing in the Assembly Appropriations Committee.
AB 873 (Irwin) seeks to revise the CCPA’s definitions of “PI” and “deidentified” and to revise the CCPA’s existing provision that prohibits the act from being construed to require a business to reidentify or otherwise link information that is not maintained in a manner that would be considered PI. This bill is pending hearing in the Assembly Appropriations Committee.
AB 874 (Irwin) seeks to revise the definition of “publicly available” for purposes of the PI definition, which excludes such information. The bill would also correct a drafting error in the definition of “PI” to clarify that PI does not include deidentified or aggregate consumer information. This bill is pending hearing in the Assembly Appropriations Committee.
AB 981 (Daly) would add numerous privacy protections to the Insurance Information and Privacy Protection Act (IIPPA), to reflect the CCPA. The bill would exempt entities subject to the IIPPA, as specified, from the CCPA, with the exception of the CCPA’s data breach section. This bill is pending hearing in the Assembly Appropriations Committee.
AB 1035 (Mayes) seeks to require, under the Data Breach Notification Law, a person or business, as defined, that owns or licenses computerized data that includes PI to disclose any breach of the security of the system within 72 hours following discovery or notification of the breach, subject to the legitimate needs of law enforcement, as provided. This bill is pending hearing in this Committee.
AB 1138 (Gallagher) seeks to prohibit a person or business that conducts business in California, and that operates a social media website or application, from allowing a person under 13 years of age to create an account with the website or application unless the website or application obtains the consent of the person’s parent or guardian before creating the account. This bill is pending hearing in the Assembly Appropriations Committee.
AB 1146 (Berman) seeks to expand the CCPA exemptions to expressly exclude from the CCPA vehicle information shared between a new motor vehicle dealer and the vehicle’s manufacturer, if the information is shared pursuant to, or in anticipation of, a vehicle repair relating to warranty work or a recall, as specified. This bill is pending hearing in the Assembly Appropriations Committee.
AB 1355 (Chau) seeks to address a drafting error in the definition of PI to clarify that it does not include deidentified or aggregate consumer information. This bill is pending hearing in the Assembly Appropriations Committee.
AB 1395 (Cunningham) seeks to prohibit a smart speaker device, as defined, or a specified manufacturer of that device, from saving or storing recordings of verbal commands or requests given to the device, or verbal conversations heard by the device, as specified. This bill is pending hearing in this Committee.
AB 1564 (Berman) would revise a CCPA requirement that businesses make available to consumers “two or more designated methods” for submitting requests for information to be disclosed pursuant to specified provisions of the CCPA, including a toll-free telephone number. This bill is pending hearing in the Assembly Appropriations Committee.
AB 1760 (Wicks) would restate the CCPA rights using similar terminology, expand those existing CCPA rights to include new rights, and replace the “opt-out” rights of consumers 16 years and older with an “opt-in” right, among other things. This bill has been referred to this Committee.
- Prior legislation: AB 375 (Chau, Ch. 55, Stats. 2018) See Comment 3.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
California State Association of Counties (sponsor)
Alliance for Children’s Rights
California Alliance of Caregivers
California Association of County Treasurers & Tax Collectors
California Attractions and Parks Association
California Bankers Association
California Chamber of Commerce
California Credit Union League
California Land Title Association
Child Support Directors Association of California
Civil Justice Association of California
Computing Technology Industry Association
Consumer Data Industry Association
CTIA-The Wireless Association
Electronic Transactions Association
Entertainment Software Association
Internet Association
League of California Cities
Securities Industry and Financial Markets Association
Symantec
Technet
Tesla
Thomson Reuters (Markets) LLC, D/B/A Refinitiv
Opposition
Californians for Consumer Privacy
Analysis Prepared by: Ronak Daylami / P. & C.P. / (916) 319-2200
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):