AB 142: Lead-acid batteries.
- Session Year: 2019-2020
- House: Assembly
- Latest Version Date: 2019-10-13
The Lead-Acid Battery Recycling Act of 2016 prohibits a person from disposing, or attempting to dispose, of a lead-acid battery at a solid waste facility or on or in any land, surface waters, watercourses, or marine waters, but authorizes a person to dispose of a lead-acid battery at certain locations. The act requires, until March 31, 2022, a manufacturer battery fee of $1 to be imposed on a manufacturer of lead-acid batteries for each lead-acid battery it sells at retail to a person in California, or that it sells to a dealer, wholesaler, distributor, or other person for retail sale in California. The act requires the manufacturer battery fee to be paid to the California Department of Tax and Fee Administration and requires dealers and manufacturers of lead-acid batteries to register with the department. The act defines manufacturer for these purposes.
This bill would increase the amount of the manufacturer battery fee to $2 and would provide that the fee would continue indefinitely. The bill would authorize a person who manufactures a lead-acid battery and is not subject to the jurisdiction of the state to agree in writing with the importer, as defined, of that lead-acid battery to pay the manufacturer battery fee on behalf of the importer. The bill would exempt an importer who has an agreement of this type with a manufacturer, and who meets other specified requirements, from the requirement to register with the department. The bill would require the department, on or before January 1, 2020, to submit to the Legislature a report that includes, among other things, any regulations or policies adopted by the department for purposes of ensuring compliance with the registration, returns, reporting, payments, audits, refunds, or collection requirements related to the manufacturer battery fee.
The act requires manufacturer battery fees remitted pursuant to these provisions to be credited against amounts owed by the manufacturer to the state under a judgment or determination of liability under specific hazardous materials provisions or any other law for removal, remediation, or other response costs relating to a release of a hazardous substance from a lead-acid battery recycling facility.
This bill would additionally require that manufacturer battery fees remitted pursuant to these provisions be credited to the account of the manufacturer remitting those fees. The bill would require that a person who agrees in writing to pay the manufacturer battery fee on behalf of an importer be credited for a payment of the manufacturer battery fee only if certain conditions are met, including that the person provide to the purchaser of a lead-acid battery a statement that includes specified information on the invoice, contract, or other record documenting the transaction. The bill would relieve a purchaser of a lead-acid battery who receives that statement in a timely manner, and any subsequent purchaser of that battery, from liability for the manufacturer battery fee that would otherwise be imposed on the sale of that battery, provided that the manufacturer remits payment of the manufacturer battery fee to the state for the sale of that battery. The bill would authorize an importer who has paid the manufacturer battery fee and who receives an untimely statement that the fee has been paid for that battery to file a claim for a refund of any overpaid fees.
The bill would authorize the department to disclose the name, address, account number, and account status of a person registered with the department to pay the manufacturer battery fee. The bill would provide that account status does not include the amount of the manufacturer battery fee paid by any person.
The act requires a specified portion of moneys from the manufacturer battery fee to be deposited into the Lead-Acid Battery Cleanup Fund and provides that moneys in the fund are available upon appropriation by the Legislature to the Department of Toxic Substances Control for specified activities, including the repayment of specified loans.
This bill would authorize expenditure of moneys from the Lead-Acid Battery Cleanup Fund for the repayment of those loans only after the other specified activities have been fully funded.
The act imposes a California battery fee on a person for specified types of replacement lead-acid batteries purchased from a dealer.
This bill would provide, if a new motor vehicle dealer sells or leases to a person a used vehicle into which the new motor vehicle dealer has incorporated a replacement lead-acid battery, that the California battery fee does not apply to the person with regard to that replacement lead-acid battery.
This bill would declare that it is to take effect immediately as an urgency statute.
For purposes of this article, the following definitions shall apply:
(a)Board means State Board of Equalization. the California Department of Tax and Fee Administration.
(b)Business means any person, as defined in subdivision (j), (k), except a natural person or a city, county, city and county, district, commission, the state, or any department, agency, or political subdivision of any of those, or an interstate body or, to the extent permitted by law, the United States and its agencies and instrumentalities.
(c)California battery fee means the fee imposed pursuant to Section 25215.25.
(d)Dealer means every a person who engages in the retail sale of replacement lead-acid batteries directly to persons in California. Dealer includes a manufacturer of a new lead-acid battery that sells at retail that lead-acid battery directly to a person through any means, including, but not limited to, a transaction conducted through a sales outlet, catalog, or Internet Web site or any other similar electronic means.
(e)Importer means a person described in paragraph (2) of subdivision (h).
(e)(f)Lead-acid battery means any a battery weighing over five kilograms that is primarily composed of both lead and sulfuric acid, whether sulfuric acid is in liquid, solid, or gel state, with a capacity of six volts or more that is used for any of the following purposes:
(1)As a starting battery that is designed to deliver a high burst of energy to an internal combustion engine until it starts.
(2)As a motive power battery that is designed to provide the source of power for propulsion or operation of a vehicle, including a watercraft.
(3)As a stationary storage or standby battery that is designed to be used in systems where the battery acts as either electrical storage for electricity generation equipment or a source of emergency power, or otherwise serves as a backup in case of failure or interruption in the flow of power from the primary source.
(4)As a source of auxiliary power to support the electrical systems in a vehicle, as defined in Section 670 of the Vehicle Code, including a vehicle as defined in Section 36000 of the Vehicle Code, or an aircraft.
(f)(g)Lead-acid battery recycling facility means any a site at which lead-acid batteries are or have been disassembled for the purpose of making components available for reclamation to produce elemental lead or lead alloys or at which lead-acid batteries or their components, or both, are or have been reclaimed to produce elemental lead or lead alloys.
(g)(h)Manufacturer means either of the following:
(1)The person who manufactures the lead-acid battery and who sells, offers for sale, or distributes the lead-acid battery in the state.
(2)(A)If there is no person described in paragraph (1) that is subject to the jurisdiction of the state, the manufacturer is the person who imports the lead-acid battery into the state for sale or distribution.
(B)For purposes of this article, a person is subject to the jurisdiction of the state with respect to a lead-acid battery if the person is engaged in business in this state. For purposes of this subparagraph, a person shall be considered to be engaged in business in this state if the person is a retailer engaged in business in this state, as defined in subdivision (c) of Section 6203 of the Revenue and Taxation Code, with respect to that lead-acid battery, or if the person has a substantial nexus with this state for purposes of the commerce clause of the United States Constitution.
(h)(i)Manufacturer battery fee means the fee imposed pursuant to Section 25215.35.
(i)(j)Owner or operator has the same meaning given in Section 9601(20) of Title 42 of the United States Code and any person that previously met that definition or is the legal successor to a person that meets the definition or previously met the definition.
(j)(k)Person means an individual, trust, firm, joint stock company, business concern, corporation, including, but not limited to, a government corporation, partnership, limited liability company, or association. Person also includes any city, county, city and county, district, commission, the state, or any department, agency, or political subdivision of any of those, interstate body, and the United States and its agencies and instrumentalities to the extent permitted by law.
(k)(l)Remedial action has the same meaning as in Section 25322.
(l)(m)Removal has the same meaning as in Section 25323.
(m)(n)Replacement lead-acid battery means a new lead-acid battery that is sold at retail subsequent to the original sale or lease of the equipment or vehicle in which the lead-acid battery is intended to be used. Replacement lead-acid battery does not include a spent, discarded, refurbished, reconditioned, rebuilt, or reused lead-acid battery.
(n)(o)Response action has the same meaning as in Section 25323.3.
(o)(p)(1)A retail sale or a sale at retail has the same meaning as defined in Section 6007 of the Revenue and Taxation Code.
(2)Retail The following shall not be considered a retail sale does not include any or a sale at retail for purposes of the following: this article:
(A)The sale of a battery for which a California battery fee has previously been paid.
(B)The sale of a replacement lead-acid battery that is temporarily stored or used in California for the sole purpose of preparing the replacement lead-acid battery for use thereafter solely outside of the state and that is subsequently transported outside the state and thereafter used solely outside of the state.
(C)The sale of a battery for incorporation into new equipment for subsequent resale.
(D)The replacement of a lead-acid battery pursuant to a warranty or a vehicle service contract described under Section 12800 of the Insurance Code.
(E)The sale of any battery intended for use with or contained within a medical device, as defined in the federal Federal Food, Drug, and Cosmetic Act (21 U.S.C. Sec. 321(h)) as that definition may be amended.
(p)(q)Used lead-acid battery means a lead-acid battery no longer fully capable of providing the power for which it was designed or that a person no longer wants for any other reason.
(q)(r)Wholesaler means any a person who purchases a lead-acid battery from a manufacturer for the purpose of selling the lead-acid battery to a dealer, high-volume customer, or to a person for incorporation into new equipment for resale.
SEC. 2.Section 25215.2 of the Health and Safety Code is amended to read:25215.2.(a)A dealer shall accept from persons a person at the point of transfer a used lead-acid battery of a type listed in paragraph (1), (2), or (4) of subdivision (e) (f) of Section 25215.1, but shall not be required to accept from any person more than six used lead-acid batteries per day. A dealer shall not charge any a fee to receive a used lead-acid battery.
(b)On and after April 1, 2017, a dealer shall charge to each a person who purchases a replacement lead-acid battery of a type listed in paragraph (1), (2), or (4) of subdivision (e) (f) of Section 25215.1 and who does not simultaneously provide the dealer with a used lead-acid battery of the same type and size a refundable deposit for each such battery purchased. The dealer shall display the amount of the deposit separately on the receipt provided to the purchaser. The dealer shall refund the deposit to that person if, within 45 days of the sale of the replacement lead-acid battery, the person presents to the dealer a used lead-acid battery of the same type and size. A dealer may require the person to provide a receipt documenting the payment of the deposit before refunding any deposit. A dealer may keep any lead-acid battery deposit moneys that are not properly claimed within 45 days after the date of sale of the replacement lead-acid battery, not including any sales tax reimbursement charged to the consumer. Sales tax reimbursement charged to the consumer on the amount of the deposit shall be remitted to the board. California Department of Tax and Fee Administration.
(c)A dealer shall post a written notice that is clearly visible in the public sales area of the establishment, or include on the purchasers receipt, the following language:
This dealer is required by law to charge a nonrefundable $1 California battery fee and a refundable deposit for each lead-acid battery purchased. A credit of the same amount as the refundable deposit will be issued if a used lead-acid battery is returned at the time of purchase or up to 45 days later along with this dealers receipt. |
(d)The department shall provide notice of an alleged violation of subdivision (c) to any person alleged to be in violation of that subdivision no less than 60 days before the issuance of an order or filing an action imposing a civil penalty pursuant to subdivision (b) of Section 25189.2. If the person corrects the alleged violation before the order is issued or the action is filed the department shall not impose the civil penalty.
(e)Subdivision (c) does not apply to any of the following:
(1)A person whose ordinary course of business does not include the sale of lead-acid batteries.
(2)A person that does not sell lead-acid batteries directly to consumers, such as over-the-counter, but instead removes nonfunctional or damaged batteries and installs new lead-acid batteries as a part of an automotive repair dealer service.
(3)A business that removes lead-acid batteries and installs new lead-acid batteries as a part of roadside services. Roadside services, for purposes of this paragraph, means the services performed upon a motor vehicle for the purpose of transporting the vehicle or to permit it to be operated under its own power, by or on behalf of a motor club holding a certificate of authority pursuant to Chapter 2 (commencing with Section 12160) of Part 5 of Division 2 of the Insurance Code.
(f)Except as authorized by this article, a dealer shall not collect a refundable deposit for a lead-acid battery from a person.
SEC. 3.Section 25215.25 of the Health and Safety Code is amended to read:25215.25.(a)(1)On and after April 1, 2017, until March 31, 2022, a A California battery fee of one dollar ($1) shall be imposed on a person for each replacement lead-acid battery of a type listed in paragraph (1), (2), or (4) of subdivision (e) (f) of Section 25215.1 purchased from a dealer. dealer, except as specified in subdivision (c). On and after April 1, 2017, until March 31, 2022, the amount of the fee shall be one dollar ($1). On and after April 1, 2022, the amount of the fee shall be two dollars ($2).
(2)Except for sales to businesses, the dealer shall charge a person the amount of the California battery fee as a charge that is separate from, and not included in, any other fee, charge, or other amount paid by the person.
(3)The dealer shall collect the California battery fee at the time of sale and may retain 11/2 percent of the fee as reimbursement for any costs associated with the collection of the fee. The remainder of the California battery fee collected by the dealer shall be paid to the board California Department of Tax and Fee Administration in a manner and form prescribed by the board California Department of Tax Fee Administration and at the time the return is required to be filed, as specified in Section 25215.47.
(4)All moneys collected or required to be collected by a dealer pursuant to this section that are not properly remitted to the board California Department of Tax and Fee Administration pursuant to paragraph (3) shall be deemed to be a debt owed to the state by the dealer.
(5)A person who purchases a replacement lead-acid battery in this state is liable for the California battery fee until that fee has been paid to the board, California Department of Tax and Fee Administration, except that payment to a dealer registered under this article is sufficient to relieve the person from further liability of the fee.
(6)All moneys remitted to the board California Department of Tax and Fee Administration pursuant to this subdivision shall be expended in accordance with Section 25215.5.
(b)(1)Except for sales to businesses, the California battery fee imposed pursuant to subdivision (a) shall be separately stated by the dealer on the invoice given to a person at the time of sale. Any other fee charged by the dealer related to the lead-acid battery purchase, including any deposit charged, credited, or both, pursuant to Section 25215.2, shall be identified separately from the California battery fee.
(2)If a person purchases more than one lead-acid battery in a single transaction, and is therefore imposed more than one California lead-acid battery fee in that transaction, the dealer shall not be required to individually list on the invoice each California lead-acid battery fee imposed, but may instead condense the fees to a single-line item.
(c)If a new motor vehicle dealer sells or leases to a person a used vehicle into which the new motor vehicle dealer has incorporated a replacement lead-acid battery, the California battery fee imposed by paragraph (1) of subdivision (a) shall not apply to the person with regard to that replacement lead-acid battery. For purposes of this subdivision, new motor vehicle dealer has the same meaning as is specified in Section 426 of the Vehicle Code, and used vehicle has the same meaning as is specified in Section 665 of the Vehicle Code.
SEC. 4.Section 25215.3 is added to the Health and Safety Code, to read:25215.3.(a)A person who manufactures a lead-acid battery and is not subject to the jurisdiction of the state may agree in writing with the importer of that lead-acid battery to pay the manufacturer battery fee imposed pursuant to Section 25215.35 on behalf of the importer.
(b)A person who pays the manufacturer battery fee on behalf of an importer pursuant to subdivision (a) shall be credited, pursuant to Section 25215.56, for that payment, if the person does all of the following:
(1)The person submits to the jurisdiction of the state for purposes of the fees imposed under this article and registers with the California Department of Tax and Fee Administration to pay and remit the manufacturer battery fee.
(2)The person provides to the purchaser a statement on the invoice, contract, or other record documenting the transaction that includes the following information:
(A)The persons manufacturer account number with the California Department of Tax and Fee Administration.
(B)An identification of the lead-acid battery or batteries sold that will be subject to the manufacturer battery fee.
(C)A statement that the person will pay the manufacturer battery fee to the state on behalf of the importer.
(3)The person retains records sufficient to document that the lead-acid battery for which the person has agreed to pay the manufacturer battery fee was delivered for retail sale in California, the identity of the purchaser of that battery, and that the statement required by paragraph (2) was provided to the purchaser of the battery in a timely manner pursuant to subdivision (c). The person shall retain these records for a period of no less than four years and shall make the records reasonably available to the California Department of Tax and Fee Administration upon request.
(c)(1)A purchaser of a lead-acid battery who receives a timely statement from a manufacturer pursuant to paragraph (2) of subdivision (b), and any subsequent purchaser of that battery, shall be relieved from any obligation imposed pursuant to Section 25215.35 on the sale of that battery, provided that the manufacturer remits payment of the manufacturer battery fee to the state for the sale of that battery. A statement shall be considered timely if it is issued before the manufacturer bills the purchaser for the lead-acid battery, within the manufacturers normal billing and payment cycle, before delivery of the battery to the purchaser, or before the date on which a return would be due pursuant to Section 25215.47.
(2)An importer who has paid the manufacturer battery fee for a lead-acid battery and who subsequently receives an untimely statement that the fee has been paid for that battery may file a claim for a refund for any overpaid fees as provided in Article 3 (commencing with Section 55081) of Chapter 3 of, and Article 1 (commencing with Section 55221) of Chapter 5 of, Part 30 of Division 2 of the Revenue and Taxation Code.
(d)(1)On or before January 1, 2021, the California Department of Tax and Fee Administration shall submit to the Legislature a report relating to persons who have paid the manufacturer battery fee on behalf of an importer pursuant to subdivision (a). The report shall include, but is not limited to, all of the following information:
(A)Any regulations or policies adopted by the California Department of Tax and Fee Administration for purposes of ensuring compliance with the registration, returns, reporting, payments, audits, refunds, or collection requirements related to the manufacturer battery fee.
(B)The revenue impact as determined by the revenues paid or collected compared to the estimated revenue amount calculated by the Senate Committee on Appropriations in its analysis of the fiscal impact of Assembly Bill 2153 (Chapter 666 of the Statutes of 2016), adjusted as deemed appropriate by the California Department of Tax and Fee Administration to account for differences in reporting periods and to account for exemptions or exclusions that were not previously accounted for in that analysis or that were enacted after January 1, 2018.
(C)The fiscal impact of the manufacturer battery fee, including costs required to ensure compliance, costs related to audits, refunds, and administering regulations, and estimated cost savings.
(2)A report required to be submitted pursuant to this subdivision shall be submitted in compliance with Section 9795 of the Government Code.
(3)Pursuant to Section 10231.5 of the Government Code, the requirement for submitting a report pursuant to this subdivision is inoperative on January 1, 2025.
SEC. 5.Section 25215.35 of the Health and Safety Code is amended to read:25215.35.(a)On and after April 1, 2017, a A manufacturer battery fee of one dollar ($1) two dollars ($2) shall be imposed on a manufacturer of lead-acid batteries for each lead-acid battery it sells at retail to a person in California or that it sells to a dealer, wholesaler, distributor, or other person for retail sale in California.
(b)Manufacturer battery fees shall be paid to the board California Department of Tax and Fee Administration in a manner and form as prescribed by the board California Department of Tax and Fee Administration and at the time the return is required to be filed, as specified in Section 25215.47.
(c)This section shall become inoperative on April 1, 2022, and, as of January 1, 2023, is repealed, unless a later enacted statute, that becomes operative on or before January 1, 2023, deletes or extends the dates on which it becomes inoperative and is repealed.SEC. 6.Section 25215.45 of the Health and Safety Code is amended to read:25215.45.(a)(1)Except as provided in paragraph (2), the lead-acid battery fees imposed pursuant to Sections 25215.25 and 25215.35 shall be collected by the board California Department of Tax and Fee Administration in accordance with the Fee Collection Procedures Law (Part 30 (commencing with Section 55001) of Division 2 of the Revenue and Taxation Code). For the purposes of this section, the reference to feepayer shall include a dealer and manufacturer.
(2)Notwithstanding the petition for redetermination and claim for refund provisions of the Fee Collection Procedures Law (Article 3 (commencing with Section 55081) of Chapter 3 of, and Article 1 (commencing with Section 55221) of Chapter 5 of, Part 30 of Division 2 of the Revenue and Taxation Code), the board California Department of Tax and Fee Administration shall not do either of the following:
(A)Accept or consider any petition for redetermination of fees determined under this article if the petition is founded upon the grounds that a battery is or is not a lead-acid battery, as defined in Section 25215.1. The board California Department of Tax and Fee Administration shall forward to the department any petition for redetermination that is based on those grounds.
(B)Accept or consider a claim for refund of fees paid pursuant to this article, if the claim for refund is founded upon the grounds that a battery is or is not a lead-acid battery, as defined in Section 25215.1. The board California Department of Tax and Fee Administration shall forward to the department any claim for refund that is based on these grounds.
(b)The following persons shall register with the board: California Department of Tax and Fee Administration:
(1)A dealer of lead-acid batteries.
(2)(A)A manufacturer of lead-acid batteries. batteries, unless subparagraph (B) applies.
(B)A person is not required to register with the California Department of Tax and Fee Administration as a manufacturer of lead-acid batteries if the person has an agreement or agreements pursuant to Section 25215.3 with a manufacturer or manufacturers of lead-acid batteries pursuant to which the manufacturer or manufacturers agree to pay the manufacturer battery fee on behalf of the person and the agreement or agreements apply to all lead-acid batteries sold by the person. A person exempt from registration pursuant to this subparagraph shall comply with any other applicable requirements that may be prescribed by the California Department of Tax and Fee Administration.
SEC. 7.Section 25215.48 is added to the Health and Safety Code, to read:25215.48.Notwithstanding subdivision (b) of Section 55381 of the Revenue and Taxation Code, the California Department of Tax and Fee Administration may disclose the name, address, account number, and account status of a person registered with the California Department of Tax and Fee Administration to pay the manufacturer battery fee. Account status shall not include the amount of the manufacturer battery fee paid by any person.
SEC. 8.Section 25215.5 of the Health and Safety Code is amended to read:25215.5.(a)Lead-acid battery fees collected pursuant to this article shall be managed as follows:
(1)The board shall retain moneys necessary for the payment of refunds and reimbursement of the board for expenses in the collection of the fees.
(2)The remaining moneys shall be deposited into the Lead-Acid Battery Cleanup Fund, which is hereby created in the State Treasury, and is available upon appropriation by the Legislature to the department for the purposes specified in this section.
(b)(1)Moneys in the Lead-Acid Battery Cleanup Fund shall be expended for the following activities:
(A)Investigation, site evaluation, cleanup, remedial action, removal, monitoring, or other response actions at any area of the state that is reasonably suspected to have been contaminated by the operation of a lead-acid battery recycling facility.
(B)Administration of the Lead-Acid Battery Cleanup Fund and the departments administration and implementation of this article.
(C)Repayment of a loan described in Section 25215.59 that was made before the effective date of the act which added this section, or any other loan made for purposes set forth in subparagraph (A). Moneys shall be expended for purposes of this subparagraph only after the activities specified in subparagraphs (A) and (B) have been fully funded.
(2)Moneys in the Lead-Acid Battery Cleanup Fund shall not be used to implement Article 14 (commencing with Section 25251) with respect to lead-acid batteries or to loan moneys to any other program.
(c)The department shall report to the Legislature by February 1, 2018, and annually thereafter, on the status of the Lead-Acid Battery Cleanup Fund and on the departments progress implementing this article, including, but not limited to, the sites at which actions were performed using moneys from the fund, the status of cleanup at those sites, including total anticipated costs of cleanup at those sites, the balance of the fund, the amount of fees remitted to the fund, the amount spent by the fund and the purposes for which those amounts were spent, the amounts reimbursed to the board pursuant to paragraph (1) of subdivision (a), and any other information requested by the Legislature.
SEC. 9.Section 25215.56 of the Health and Safety Code is amended to read:25215.56.(a)Any manufacturer battery fees paid remitted pursuant to this article shall, subject to subdivision (b) of Section 25215.3, be credited to the account of the manufacturer remitting those fees to the California Department of Tax and Fee Administration and shall be credited against amounts owed by the manufacturer to the state pursuant to a judgment or determination of liability under Chapter 6.8 (commencing with Section 25300) or any other law for removal, remediation, or other response costs relating to a release of a hazardous substance from a lead-acid battery recycling facility. A manufacturer shall not seek more than one credit for the same fee amount. This subdivision does not apply to any manufacturer who is also an owner or operator of a lead-acid battery recycling facility in California.
(b)The amount paid by a manufacturer for a manufacturer battery fee shall be considered to reduce the manufacturers share of liability in the allocation or apportionment of costs among potentially responsible parties in a contribution action brought by a private party related to a release of hazardous substances from a lead-acid battery recycling facility. This subdivision does not apply to any manufacturer who is also an owner or operator or a former owner or operator of a lead-acid battery recycling facility in California where a release occurred.
(c)This article does not create a private cause of action. Nothing in this article shall be construed to affect, expand, alter, or limit any requirements, duties, rights, or remedies under other law, or limit the state or any other party from bringing any cause of action that may exist under any law.
SEC. 10.This act is an urgency statute necessary for the immediate preservation of the public peace, health, or safety within the meaning of Article IV of the California Constitution and shall go into immediate effect. The facts constituting the necessity are:
In order to increase the cleanup of toxic materials and to prevent additional toxic pollution at the earliest possible time, it is necessary that this act take effect immediately.
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Oct 13, 2019 | Chaptered by Secretary of State - Chapter 860, Statutes of 2019. |
| Oct 13, 2019 | Approved by the Governor. |
| Sep 12, 2019 | Enrolled and presented to the Governor at 3:30 p.m. |
| Sep 9, 2019 | Senate amendments concurred in. To Engrossing and Enrolling. (Ayes 55. Noes 19.). |
| Sep 5, 2019 | In Assembly. Concurrence in Senate amendments pending. May be considered on or after September 7 pursuant to Assembly Rule 77. |
| Sep 4, 2019 | Read third time. Urgency clause adopted. Passed. Ordered to the Assembly. |
| Aug 30, 2019 | From committee: Do pass. (Ayes 5. Noes 2.) (August 30). |
| Aug 19, 2019 | In committee: Referred to APPR. suspense file. |
| Aug 13, 2019 | Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Aug 12, 2019 | From committee: Amend, and do pass as amended and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 5. Noes 0.) (July 10). |
| Jun 26, 2019 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to committee. Read second time, amended, and re-referred to Com. on GOV. & F. |
| Jun 24, 2019 | Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on GOV. & F. |
| Jun 20, 2019 | From committee: Amend, and do pass as amended and re-refer to Com. on GOV. & F. (Ayes 5. Noes 0.) (June 19). |
| Jun 6, 2019 | Referred to Coms. on EQ. and GOV. & F. |
| May 24, 2019 | In Senate. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. |
| May 24, 2019 | Read third time. Urgency clause adopted. Passed. Ordered to the Senate. |
| May 22, 2019 | Read third time and amended. Ordered to third reading. |
| May 20, 2019 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| May 16, 2019 | From committee: Amend, and do pass as amended. (Ayes 11. Noes 6.) (May 16). |
| Mar 20, 2019 | In committee: Set, first hearing. Referred to suspense file. |
| Mar 12, 2019 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 5. Noes 2.) (March 12). Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Feb 26, 2019 | Re-referred to Com. on E.S. & T.M. |
| Feb 25, 2019 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to Com. on E.S. & T.M. Read second time and amended. |
| Jan 24, 2019 | Referred to Com. on E.S. & T.M. |
| Jan 7, 2019 | Read first time. |
| Dec 14, 2018 | From printer. May be heard in committee January 13. |
| Dec 13, 2018 | Introduced. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sep 9, 2019 | AB 142 Cristina Garcia Concurrence in Senate Amendments | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| Sep 4, 2019 | Assembly 3rd Reading AB142 Cristina Garcia By Durazo Urgency Clause | Senate Floor |
Passed |
|
| Aug 30, 2019 | Do pass | Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Aug 19, 2019 | Placed on suspense file | Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Jul 10, 2019 | Do pass as amended, but first amend, and re-refer to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Senate Standing Committee on Governance and Finance |
Passed |
|
| Jun 19, 2019 | Do pass as amended, but first amend, and re-refer to the Committee on [Governance and Finance] | Senate Standing Committee on Environmental Quality |
Passed |
|
| May 24, 2019 | AB 142 Cristina Garcia Third Reading Urgency | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| May 16, 2019 | Do pass as amended. | Assembly Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Mar 12, 2019 | Do pass and be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Assembly Standing Committee on Environmental Safety and Toxic Materials |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
CONCURRENCE IN SENATE AMENDMENTS
CSA1 Bill Id:AB 142
Author:(Cristina Garcia)
As Amended Ver:August 13, 2019
2/3 vote. Urgency
SUMMARY:
Amends the Lead-Acid Battery Recycling Act (Act) of 2016 to delete the sunset on the $1 Manufacturer Battery Fee and increase the fee to $2 in perpetuity effective April 1, 2022; allow an out-of-state lead-acid battery manufacturer, not subject to the Manufacturer Battery Fee, to pay the fee on behalf of an importer and claim the associated credits to offset potential hazardous waste liability; exempt, effective January 1, 2020, new motor vehicle dealers that sell or lease a used vehicle containing a lead-acid battery from the California Battery Fee; require the California Department of Tax and Fee Administration (CDTFA) to report to the Legislature by January 1, 2022, relating to out-of-state manufacturers who opted to pay the Manufacturer Battery fee; specify that the repayment of the $176.6 million General Fund (GF) loan or any other loan provided to the Department of Toxic Substance Control (DTSC) to clean up the Exide Technologies (Exide) remediation site will not be paid back until the cleanup of Exide and all other areas of the state contaminated by lead-acid batteries is completed; and, provide that these changes take effect immediately as an urgency statute.
The Senate Amendments:
- Require a manufacturer or a dealer, if a lead-acid battery is not subject to the Manufacturer Battery Fee, to obtain written documentation, not a written exclusion certificate, from the purchaser. Make a purchaser who subsequently sells or uses the lead-acid battery liable for the payment of any applicable fees.
- Provide that moneys in the Lead-Acid Battery Cleanup Fund shall be expended to perform cleanup, remedial action, removal, monitoring, or other response actions to address contamination directly attributable to releases from a facility known to have been a lead-acid battery recycling facility at any area of the state that was contaminated by releases from that facility.
- Provide that DTSC, pursuant to the Lead-Acid Battery Recycling Facility Investigation and Cleanup Program (LABRIC Program), shall provide notice and an opportunity for comment on the proposed designation of a site as determined with reasonable certainty to have been contaminated by releases from the operation of a facility known to have been a lead-acid battery recycling facility. Require any proposed designation of a site by DTSC to additionally include an explanation of the basis for DTSC's designation.
- Provide that, if, within two years of the public notice, DTSC is unable to designate a site as determined with reasonable certainty to have been contaminated by releases from the operation of a facility known to have been a lead-acid battery recycling facility, the public notice shall be deemed to have been withdrawn and expenditure for purposes of further investigation or evaluation for the site shall no longer be authorized. Authorize DTSC, less than 30 days before the aforementioned two year deadline, to extend the deadline for the completion of an investigation.
- Delete provisions requiring a qualified battery association to implement a lead-acid battery recycling awareness plan. Delete the $500,000 grant program for qualified industry associations.
- Provide that CDTFA may disclose to an importer the amount of the Manufacturer Battery Fee paid or not paid on behalf of that importer by a person with which the importer has entered into an agreement.
COMMENTS:
Lead-Acid Battery Recycling Act (Act): Under the Act, both consumers and manufacturers are required to pay a $1 fee on a lead-acid battery until April 2022. The California Battery Fee (consumer fee) increases to $2 in April 2022 and the Manufacturer Battery Fee (manufacturer fee) sunsets. AB 142 strikes the 2022 sunset date for the Manufacturer Battery Fee and increases the fees to $2 in perpetuity. Establishing the Manufacturer Battery Fee at $2 creates equity with what consumers will be paying. The current Lead-Acid Battery Fund balance is not enough to pay back the current $176.6 million loan and the Governor's proposed $75 million additional loans for Fiscal Year 2019-2020. In addition, there are at least 39 other former lead smelter sites, which may require future remediation. The additional $2 fee would increase the Fund’s revenues. This will make a dent in the loan repayments, but is insufficient to do lead remediation at the prioritized four sites, let alone 39, additional lead smelter sites.
According to the Author:
"Exide and the other communities with historic lead-acid battery manufacturing plants have a great need for ongoing funding and [AB 142] will ensure that the battery fee money can only be used for its intended purpose. AB 142 addresses technical issues, will adjust the fees, and only allow the repayment of the $176.6 million dollar loan once the clean-up of Exide and other areas of the state that may be contaminated by lead acid batteries has been completed."
Arguments in Support:
The Los Angeles County Board of Supervisors states, "The increased revenue from AB 142 would increase the funds available for clean-up efforts at contaminated sites across the State. The County's Department of Public Health indicates that contaminated sites create a health equity issue, because at-risk communities at risk of lead exposure are predominantly communities of color, and those residents experience underlying health inequities and contend with exposure to multiple environmental hazards."
Arguments in Opposition:
The Howard Jarvis Taxpayers Association writes, "Not every legitimate health and safety issue requires increasing taxes. There are alternative funding mechanisms which may include legitimate regulatory fees under existing constitutional authority. In addition, the necessary funds already exist in California’s $22 billion surplus. Instead, battery manufacturers who may have had little role in contaminating communities are being targeted. The same goes for consumers who live hundreds of miles away from impacted areas. If eighteen sites need mitigation, this is a matter of statewide concern that should be funded out of the General Fund."
FISCAL COMMENTS:
According to the Senate Appropriations Committee, enactment of this bill would result in one-time administrative costs for CDTFA of $112,200 (Battery Cleanup Fund) to process returns filed by out-of-state manufacturers that enter into agreements with California importers to pay the Manufacturer Battery Fees on their behalf, and ongoing costs for DTSC of up to $350,000 annually (Battery Cleanup Fund) to comply with this bill. CDTFA estimates this bill would increase revenues from Manufacturer Battery Fees by $21.4 million in the first full fiscal year 2022-23 (Battery Cleanup Fund) and CDTFA estimates initial annual revenue losses of $80,000 until fiscal year 2022-23, then annual revenue losses of $160,000 from the California Battery Fee exemption for used car dealers (Battery Cleanup Fund). Delays for an unknown amount are expected in the repayment of General Fund loans for cleanup due to lead-acid battery contamination. Loan payback is an allowed expense for the Battery Cleanup Fund but is not an obligation.
VOTES:
ASM ENVIRONMENTAL SAFETY AND TOXIC MATERIALS: 5-2-2
YES: Quirk, Bauer-Kahan, Cristina Garcia, Holden, Muratsuchi
NO: Dahle, Mathis
ABS, ABST OR NV: Melendez, Arambula
ASM APPROPRIATIONS: 11-6-1
YES: Gonzalez, Bloom, Bonta, Calderon, Carrillo, Chau, Eggman, Gabriel, Eduardo Garcia, Quirk, Robert Rivas
NO: Bigelow, Brough, Diep, Fong, Obernolte, Petrie-Norris
ABS, ABST OR NV: Maienschein
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 54-17-9
YES: Aguiar-Curry, Arambula, Bauer-Kahan, Berman, Bloom, Boerner Horvath, Bonta, Burke, Calderon, Carrillo, Chau, Chiu, Chu, Cooper, Cunningham, Daly, Eggman, Friedman, Gabriel, Cristina Garcia, Gipson, Gloria, Gonzalez, Grayson, Holden, Irwin, Jones-Sawyer, Kalra, Kamlager-Dove, Levine, Limón, Low, Mayes, McCarty, Medina, Mullin, Muratsuchi, Nazarian, O'Donnell, Quirk, Reyes, Luz Rivas, Robert Rivas, Rodriguez, Blanca Rubio, Salas, Santiago, Smith, Mark Stone, Ting, Weber, Wicks, Wood, Rendon
NO: Bigelow, Brough, Cervantes, Choi, Dahle, Flora, Fong, Gallagher, Kiley, Lackey, Mathis, Melendez, Obernolte, Patterson, Petrie-Norris, Voepel, Waldron
ABS, ABST OR NV: Chen, Cooley, Diep, Frazier, Eduardo Garcia, Gray, Maienschein, Quirk‑Silva, Ramos
UPDATED:
VERSION: August 13, 2019
CONSULTANT: Paige Brokaw / E.S. & T.M. / (916) 319-3965 FN: 0001922
Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | AB 142 |
THIRD READING
Bill No: AB 142
Author: Cristina Garcia (D), et al.
Amended: 8/13/19 in Senate
SENATE ENVIRONMENTAL QUALITY COMMITTEE: 5-0, 6/19/19
AYES: Allen, Hill, Skinner, Stern, Wieckowski
NO VOTE RECORDED: Bates, Dahle
SENATE GOVERNANCE & FIN. COMMITTEE: 5-0, 7/10/19
AYES: McGuire, Beall, Hertzberg, Hurtado, Wiener
NO VOTE RECORDED: Moorlach, Nielsen
SENATE APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE: 5-2, 8/30/19
AYES: Portantino, Bradford, Durazo, Hill, Wieckowski
NOES: Bates, Jones
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 54-17, 5/24/19 - See last page for vote
DIGEST:
This bill increases the Manufacturer Battery Fee and makes other changes to the Lead-Acid Battery Recycling Act of 2016 (Act).
Existing law, pursuant to the Act (Health & Safety Code (HSC) § 25215, et seq):
- Requires, on and after April 1, 2017, until March 31, 2022, a California Battery Fee (Fee) of $1 to be imposed on a person for each replacement lead-acid battery purchased from a dealer. Requires, on and after April 1, 2022, the amount of the Fee to increase to $2. (HSC § 25215.25)
- Requires each manufacturer to remit to the California Department of Tax and Fee Administration (CDTFA) a $1 Manufacturer Battery Fee for each lead-acid battery sold at retail to a person in California. Sunsets the Manufacturer Battery Fee on April 1, 2022. (HSC § 25215.35)
- Requires all Fee and Manufacturer Battery Fee revenues be remitted to the CDTFA for administration of the fee and the remainder to be deposited into the Lead-Acid Battery Fund (Fund). (HSC § 25215.5)
This bill:
- Allows out-of-state manufacturers not otherwise subject to the $1 Manufacturer Battery Fee to pay the fee on behalf of a California importer, and claim the associated credits to offset potential hazardous waste liability.
- Removes the sunset provision on the Manufacturer Battery Fee of April 1, 2022, and increases it to $2 per battery after that date.
- Exempts new motor vehicle dealers that sell or lease a used vehicle containing a replacement lead-acid battery from the $1 California Battery Fee.
- Requires, on or before January 1, 2022, CDTFA to submit a report to the Legislature relating to out-of-state manufacturers who opted to pay the Manufacturer Battery Fee on behalf of an importer, as specified.
- Reconfigures how moneys from the Fund shall be expended. Specifies funding for:
- Cleanup, remedial action, removal, monitoring, or other response actions at any area of the state that the Department of Toxic Substances Control (DTSC) determines with reasonable certainty to have been contaminated by the operation of a lead-acid battery recycling facility; and
- Repayment of the $176.6 million General Fund loan or any other loan provided to DTSC to clean up the Exide Technologies (Exide) remediation site only after the other authorized activities have been fully funded in a given fiscal year.
- Authorizes CDTFA to disclose the name, address, account number, and account status of a person registered with CDTFA required to pay the Manufacturer Battery Fee. Prohibits the account status from including the amount of the Manufacturer Battery Fee paid by any person.
- Requires DTSC to establish a Lead-Acid Battery Recycling Facility Investigation and Cleanup Program (LABRIC) to identify areas of the state that are eligible for moneys from the Fund.
- Requires the program to provide public notice of the initiation of the investigation or site evaluation of any area reasonably suspected to have been contaminated by the operation of a lead-acid battery recycling facility.
- Requires DTSC, upon completion of an investigation or site evaluation, to provide notice and an opportunity for comment on the proposed designation of a site as known to have been contaminated by the operation of a lead-acid battery recycling facility.
- Provides that further investigation or evaluation for a site is no longer authorized if, within two years of a public notice of the initiation of the investigation or evaluation, DTSC is unable to designate a site as known to have been contaminated by the operation of a lead-acid battery recycling facility.
- Makes technical changes to update the Board of Equalization’s name to CDTFA.
Background
- Lead-acid batteries. Lead-acid batteries are rechargeable batteries made of lead plates situated in sulfuric acid within a plastic casing. They are used globally for a wide range of purposes, most commonly in vehicles like automobiles, boats, trucks, and industrial vehicles. According to the U.S. Geological Survey, the lead-acid battery industry accounted for about 90% of reported U.S. lead consumption during 2015. The average battery contains 17.5 pounds of lead and 1.5 gallons of sulfuric acid.
The demand for lead is high and as such lead is a highly valued commodity that makes recycling highly profitable.
- Lead-Acid Battery Recycling Act. The Lead-Acid Battery Recycling Facility Investigation and Cleanup Program was established pursuant to AB 2153 (C. Garcia, Chapter 666, Statutes of 2016), which became the Lead-Acid Battery Recycling Act of 2016 (Act).
The Manufacturer Battery Fee and Fee on lead-acid batteries sold in the state are deposited into the Fund created by the Act. The Fund is a dedicated source to pay for cleanup of the Exide battery recycling site in Vernon, California, and at other contaminated sites. The Act also provides that manufacturers paying the fee receive a one-time credit equal to the amount each has paid against any future judgement of legal responsibility for a share of those cleanup costs.
Beginning on and after April 1, 2017, and until April 1, 2022, a $1 fee is imposed on a manufacturer for each lead-acid battery sold at retail to a person in California, or that is sold to a dealer, wholesaler, distributor, or other person for retail sale in California. The manufacturer is required to remit the fees to the CDTFA at the time the return is required to be filed.
- Exide Technologies. The Exide battery recycling facility in Vernon, California, recycled lead from used automotive batteries and other sources. The facility could process about 25,000 automotive and industrial batteries a day, providing a source of lead for new batteries. Over the course of decades of operation, the facility polluted the soil beneath it with high levels of lead, arsenic, cadmium, and other toxic metals. It also contaminated groundwater, released battery acid onto roads, and contaminated homes and yards in surrounding communities with lead emissions. In March, 2015, Exide was forced to close the facility.
Properties up to 1.3 and 1.7 miles away from the facility are impacted by Exide's lead contamination, which amounts to upwards of 10,000 properties. According to DTSC, cleaning each home costs about $60,000 (an increase from the previously $45,000 anticipated cost per property). DTSC has sampled 8,527 properties to-date; 7,733 properties have exceeded the screening level of 80 parts per million (ppm), meaning about 90% of all properties tested for lead will require remediation. Removing lead-contaminated soil from thousands of homes surrounding Exide could result in the most extensive cleanup of its kind in California and will be among the largest cleanup ever conducted in the nation.
On April 20, 2016, Governor Jerry Brown signed AB 118 (Santiago, Chapter 10, Statutes of 2016) and SB 93 (De Léon, Chapter 9, Statutes of 2016), appropriating a $176.6 million loan from the General Fund to the Toxic Substances Control Account (TSCA) to enable DTSC to test properties, schools, daycare centers, and parks in the 1.7 mile radius and remove contaminated soil at the properties that have the highest lead levels and greatest potential exposure to residents.
Cleanup costs initially incurred by the state will ultimately be sought from the parties responsible for the lead contamination (Exide). DTSC will need funds to pay for the work while it seeks additional money from Exide and other responsible parties.
After the $176.6 million is expended, DTSC will need additional funds for a complete and thorough cleanup. AB 2153 authorized use of the fee revenues in the Fund to fill that gap and repay the state loan while providing an ongoing source of funds to address lead contamination from lead-acid batteries.
Governor Newsom, in his proposed Fiscal Year (FY) 2019-2020 Budget, included an additional $75 million General Fund one-time loans to accelerate the cleanup of additional properties within a 1.7-mile radius of the facility over the next two years. Of that, $50 million would allow DTSC to clean up approximately 700 additional high-risk properties in which lead contamination exceeds the state standard of 80 parts per million, and $25 million would be used to continue cleaning up previously identified sites contaminated by Exide facility.
- Use of the Fund revenues to-date. The Legislature has appropriated funds to DTSC to set up and administer the Act, which includes development of a framework for implementation of the Act, and funds to CDTFA to set up and administer the Fund, including outreach to and registration of fee payees- battery manufacturers, importers, and dealers.
Additionally, between the FY 2017-2018 and FY 2018-2019 Budget Acts, the Legislature appropriated $26.7 million from the Fund to repay the General Fund Exide loan. The Governor's proposed FY 2019-2020 Budget would appropriate $16 million in loan repayment to the General Fund.
Comments
Purpose of bill. According to the author, "AB 2153 in 2016 reallocated a fee already imposed on all car batteries to fund the cleanup of contamination caused by lead-acid batteries throughout the state. Under current law, at the point of sale, $1 from the consumers’ deposit will go to the cleanup fund. Manufacturers also pay a $1 fee on all batteries sold in the state. Starting on April 1 2022, the consumer fee increases to $2, and the manufacture fee sunsets. This bill simply raises the manufacture fee to $2 as well to keep the fund equitable; consumers alone shouldn’t bare this burden.
“The fund will facilitate clean-up efforts for Exide and up to 39 similar sites across the state from Oakland, Los Angles, West Sacramento, Inglewood, Fresno, and San Francisco so remediation won’t be delayed based on an inability to get funding from the companies that created the situation in the first place, or relay on the general fund. This fund has been bringing relief to these affected communities and ensures solutions to a major long-term problem. Since starting in 2017 the fund has raised $30million dollars. Unfortunately the cleanup of just the homes surrounding Exide is estimated to cost $540-$720million dollars. If we don’t increase the manufacture fee it will take over 30 years to fund the clean-up. That is not acceptable.”
Related/Prior Legislation
AB 1663 (C. Garcia, 2017) would have amended the Act to clarify provisions related to an out-of-state lead-acid battery manufacturer's financial responsibilities. Specifically, would have authorized a person who manufacturers a lead-acid battery and is not subject to the jurisdiction of the state and who agrees in writing with the importer of that lead-acid battery to pay the Manufacturer Battery Fee imposed on behalf of the importer. The bill was later amended with unrelated content.
AB 2153 (C. Garcia, Chapter 666, Statutes of 2016) enacted the Act.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: Yes Local: No
According to the Senate Appropriations Committee, CDTFA estimates one-time administrative costs of $112,200 (Battery Cleanup Fund) to process returns filed by out-of-state manufacturers that enter into agreements with California importers to pay the manufacturer fees on their behalf. DTSC estimates ongoing costs of up to $350,000 annually (Battery Cleanup Fund) to comply with this bill. CDTFA estimates this bill would increase revenues from manufacturer fees by $21.4 million in the first full fiscal year 2022-23 (Battery Cleanup Fund). CDTFA estimates initial annual revenue losses of $80,000 until fiscal year 2022-23, then annual revenue losses of $160,000 from the California Battery Fee exemption for used car dealers (Battery Cleanup Fund). Delays for an unknown amount in the repayment of General Fund loans for cleanup due to lead-acid battery contamination. Loan payback is an allowed expense for the Battery Cleanup Fund but is not an obligation.
Battery Council International
Breast Cancer Prevention Partners
California Association of Environmental Health Administrators
California Communities Against Toxics
California New Car Dealers Association
California Safe Schools
City of Los Angeles
City of Torrance
Clean Water Action
Coalition For A Safe Environment
Coalition for Clean Air
Communities for a Better Environment
Consumer Attorneys of California
Desert Citizens Against Pollution
East Yard Communities for Environmental Justice
Environmental Working Group
Los Angeles County Board of Supervisors
Los Angeles Solid Waste Management Committee/Integrated Waste Management Task Force
Mothers o East Los Angeles
Northern California Recycling Association
PROUNO
Sierra Club
South Coast Air Quality Management District
OPPOSITION: (Verified 8/30/19)
Howard Jarvis Taxpayers Association
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 54-17, 5/24/19
AYES: Aguiar-Curry, Arambula, Bauer-Kahan, Berman, Bloom, Boerner Horvath, Bonta, Burke, Calderon, Carrillo, Chau, Chiu, Chu, Cooper, Cunningham, Daly, Eggman, Friedman, Gabriel, Cristina Garcia, Gipson, Gloria, Gonzalez, Grayson, Holden, Irwin, Jones-Sawyer, Kalra, Kamlager-Dove, Levine, Limón, Low, Mayes, McCarty, Medina, Mullin, Muratsuchi, Nazarian, O'Donnell, Quirk, Reyes, Luz Rivas, Robert Rivas, Rodriguez, Blanca Rubio, Salas, Santiago, Smith, Mark Stone, Ting, Weber, Wicks, Wood, Rendon
NOES: Bigelow, Brough, Cervantes, Choi, Dahle, Flora, Fong, Gallagher, Kiley, Lackey, Mathis, Melendez, Obernolte, Patterson, Petrie-Norris, Voepel, Waldron
NO VOTE RECORDED: Chen, Cooley, Diep, Frazier, Eduardo Garcia, Gray, Maienschein, Quirk-Silva, Ramos
Prepared by: Gabrielle Meindl / E.Q. / (916) 651-4108
9/1/19 10:50:13
**** END ****
SENATE COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Senator Anthony Portantino, Chair
2019 - 2020 Regular Session
AB 142 (Cristina Garcia) - Lead-acid batteries
Version: August 13, 2019 | Policy Vote: E.Q. 5 - 0, GOV. & F. 5 - 0 |
Urgency: Yes | Mandate: No |
Hearing Date: August 19, 2019 | Consultant: Ashley Ames |
Bill Summary:
This bill would increase the Manufacturer Battery Fee and make other changes to the Lead-Acid Battery Recycling Act of 2016.
Fiscal Impact:
- The California Department of Tax and Fee Administration (CDTFA) estimates one-time administrative costs of $112,200 (Battery Cleanup Fund) to process returns filed by out-of-state manufacturers that enter into agreements with California importers to pay the manufacturer fees on their behalf.
- The Department of Toxic Substances Control (DTSC) estimates ongoing costs of up to $350,000 annually (Battery Cleanup Fund) to comply with this bill.
- CDTFA estimates this bill would increase revenues from manufacturer fees by $21.4 million in the first full fiscal year 2022-23 (Battery Cleanup Fund).
- CDTFA estimates initial annual revenue losses of $80,000 until fiscal year 2022-23, then annual revenue losses of $160,000 from the California Battery Fee exemption for used car dealers (Battery Cleanup Fund).
- Delays for an unknown amount in the repayment of General Fund loans for cleanup due to lead-acid battery contamination. Loan payback is an allowed expense for the Battery Cleanup Fund but is not an obligation.
Background:
Lead-acid batteries. Lead-acid batteries are rechargeable batteries made of lead plates situated in sulfuric acid within a plastic casing. They are used globally for a wide range of purposes, most commonly in vehicles like automobiles, boats, trucks, and industrial vehicles. According to the U.S. Geological Survey, the lead-acid battery industry accounted for about 90% of reported U.S. lead consumption during 2015. The average battery contains 17.5 pounds of lead and 1.5 gallons of sulfuric acid.
The demand for lead is high and as such lead is a highly valued commodity that makes recycling highly profitable.
The Lead-Acid Battery Recycling Act. The Lead-Acid Battery Recycling Facility Investigation and Cleanup Program was established pursuant to Assembly Bill 2153 (C. Garcia, Chapter 666, Statutes of 2016), which became the Lead-Acid Battery Recycling Act of 2016 (Act).
The Manufacturer Battery Fee and Fee on lead-acid batteries sold in the state are deposited into the Fund created by the Act. The Fund is a dedicated source to pay for cleanup of the Exide battery recycling site in Vernon, California, and at other contaminated sites. The Act also provides that manufacturers paying the fee receive a one-time credit equal to the amount each has paid against any future judgement of legal responsibility for a share of those cleanup costs.
Beginning on and after April 1, 2017, and until April 1, 2022, a $1 fee is imposed on a manufacturer for each lead-acid battery sold at retail to a person in California, or that is sold to a dealer, wholesaler, distributor, or other person for retail sale in California. The manufacturer is required to remit the fees to the CDTFA at the time the return is required to be filed.
The United States and California have increased regulations over smelting operations (the process through which lead is retrieved) to decrease potential environmental and public health exposures to smelting emissions and contamination. However, some smelters in California, like the Exide facility, have pollution resulting from operations prior to the air, soil and water regulations of today.
CDTFA. CDTFA administers the Sales and Use Tax Law, Use Fuel Tax Law, Alcoholic Beverage Tax Law, Energy Resources Surcharge Law, Emergency Telephone Users Surcharge Law, Hazardous Substances Tax Law, Integrated Waste Management Fee Law, Oil Spill Response, Prevention, and Administration Fees Law, Underground Storage Tank Maintenance Fee Law, and Diesel Fuel Tax Law. In addition, CDTFA also operates other fee programs such as the Ballast Water, California Tire, Covered Electronic Waste Recycling, Fire Prevention, Marine Invasive Species, and Water Rights Fees, as well as the Natural Gas Surcharge, which are governed by the Fee
Proposed Law:
AB 142 would make three changes to the Lead-Acid Battery Fee:
- Allow out-of-state manufacturers not otherwise subject to the $1 manufacturer battery fee to pay the fee on behalf of a California importer, and claim the associated credits to offset potential hazardous waste liability.
- Exempt new motor vehicle dealers that sell or lease a used vehicle containing a replacement lead-acid battery from the $1 California battery fee. Dealers must obtain written documentation from purchasers certifying that the battery will be used in a manner or for a purpose qualifying for the exemption. The purchaser is liable for paying the fee if the battery is subsequently used in a manner or purpose that does not qualify for the exemption.
- Remove the sunset provision on the manufacturer fee of April 1, 2022, and increases it to $2 per battery after that date.
This bill would also:
- Require, on or before January 1, 2022, CDTFA to submit a report to the Legislature relating to out-of-state manufacturers who opted to pay the Manufacturer Battery Fee on behalf of an importer. Requires the report to include all of the following information:
- Any regulations or policies adopted by CDTFA for the purposes of ensuring compliance with the registration, returns, reporting, payments, audits, refunds, or collection requirements related to the manufacturer battery fee;
- The revenue impact as determined by the revenues paid or collected compared to the estimated revenue amount calculated by the Senate Committee on Appropriations in its analysis of the fiscal impact of Assembly Bill 2153 (C. Garcia, Chapter 666, Statutes of 2016); and
- The fiscal impact of the Manufacturer Battery Fee, including costs required to ensure compliance, costs related to audits, refunds, and administering regulations, and estimated cost savings.
- Reconfigures how moneys from the Fund shall be expended as follows:
- Specifies funding for:
- Cleanup, remedial action, removal, monitoring, or other response actions at any area of the state that DTSC determines with reasonable certainty to have been contaminated by the operation of a lead-acid battery recycling facility;
- Grants to fund qualified industry association lead-acid battery recycling awareness plans;
- Repayment of the $176.6 million General Fund loan or any other loan provided to DTSC to clean up the Exide Technologies (Exide) remediation site only after the other authorized activities have been fully funded in a given fiscal year.
- Specifies funding for:
- Authorize CDTFA to disclose the name, address, account number, and account status of a person registered with CDTFA required to pay the Manufacturer Battery Fee. Prohibits the account status from including the amount of the Manufacturer Battery Fee paid by any person.
- Require DTSC to establish a Lead-Acid Battery Recycling Facility Investigation and Cleanup Program (LABRIC) to identify areas of the state that are eligible for moneys from the Fund.
- Requires the program to provide public notice of the initiation of the investigation or site evaluation of any area reasonably suspected to have been contaminated by the operation of a lead-acid battery recycling facility.
- Requires DTSC, upon completion of an investigation or site evaluation, to provide notice and an opportunity for comment on the proposed designation of a site as known to have been contaminated by the operation of a lead-acid battery recycling facility.
- Provides that further investigation or evaluation for a site is no longer authorized if, within 2 years of a public notice of the initiation of the investigation or evaluation, DTSC is unable to designate a site as known to have been contaminated by the operation of a lead-acid battery recycling facility.
- Make technical changes to update the Board of Equalization’s name to CDTFA.
- Take effect immediately as an urgency statute.
Staff Comments:
This bill increases from $1 to $2 and makes permanent the manufacturer battery fee beginning April 1, 2022, increasing revenues to $21.4 million in the first full fiscal year (FY) 2022-23.
This bill also adds an exemption from the $1 consumer battery fee for new car dealers that use a replacement lead-acid battery in the sale or lease of a used car, which reduces California battery fee revenue by an estimated $80,000 in the first full fiscal year 2020-21. Starting FY 2022-23, the fee revenue reduction would be an estimated $160,000.
CDTFA staff analyzed the first full FY data (i.e. FY 2017-18); total fees collected was $17.3 million. The following is a breakdown:
FY 2017-18 Manufacturer Battery Fee $10.3 million
FY 2017-18 California Battery Fee $ 7.0 million
Total Fees Collected $17.3 million
Manufacturer Fee Increase Impact
According to IBISWorld, a global business intelligence leader specializing in industry market research, the battery manufacturing industry will see an annual growth of 0.8% in the period 2018 to 2023 (December 2018 publication). Based on this growth, staff estimates manufacturer fee revenues to be $21.4 million in the first full fiscal year (FY 2022-23).
California Battery Fee Impact
Regarding the proposed California battery fee exemption, which exempts battery replacement in used car lease or sale by new car dealerships, the CNCDA previously indicated that an estimated ten percent (10%) of the used cars sold by new car dealers receive battery replacement. Based on the 2017 and 2018 CNCDA Economic Impact Report, staff estimated 802,000 used cars sold by new car dealerships in FY 2016-17. Applying the 10% ratio results in an estimated 80,000 used cars that need battery replacement (10% × 802,000 used cars = 80,000 used cars battery replacement). Staff estimates California battery fee revenue reduction by $80,000 per FY (80,000 used cars x $1 = $80,000). Commencing with the FY 2022-23, when the California battery fee is increased to $2, the fee revenue reduction is estimated to be $160,000 (80,000 used cars x $2 = $160,000).
DTSC. According to DTSC, the costs for DTSC to implement the procedures mandated in AB 142 could cost an additional $350,000 to further investigate suspected sites to meet the demonstration requirements, research site conditions and historical operations, conduct additional analyses to attempt to attribute lead contamination identified at sites to sources of that contamination, as well as for legal counsel to support the new procedural requirements and to respond to legal challenges, and for litigation support for the Attorney General’s Office to represent DTSC in legal proceedings.
-- END --
SENATE COMMITTEE ON GOVERNANCE AND FINANCE
Senator Mike McGuire, Chair
2019 - 2020 Regular
Bill No: | AB 142 | Hearing Date: | 7/10/19 |
Author: | Cristina Garcia | Tax Levy: | No |
Version: | 6/26/19 | Fiscal: | Yes |
Consultant: | Grinnell | ||
Lead-acid batteries
Makes three changes to the Lead-Acid Battery Fee.
Background
The California Department of Tax and Fee Administration (CDTFA) administers the Sales and Use Tax Law, Use Fuel Tax Law, Alcoholic Beverage Tax Law, Energy Resources Surcharge Law, Emergency Telephone Users Surcharge Law, Hazardous Substances Tax Law, Integrated Waste Management Fee Law, Oil Spill Response, Prevention, and Administration Fees Law, Underground Storage Tank Maintenance Fee Law, and Diesel Fuel Tax Law. In addition, CDTFA also operates other fee programs such as the Ballast Water, California Tire, Covered Electronic Waste Recycling, Fire Prevention, Marine Invasive Species, and Water Rights Fees, as well as the Natural Gas Surcharge, which are governed by the Fee Procedures Collections Law.
The Lead-Acid Battery Recycling Act of 2016. Lead is a toxic metal that does not break down in the environment and accumulates in the human body. Exposures can lead to behavioral problems, learning disabilities, joint and muscle weakness, anemia, organ failure, and even death. Lead has been listed under California's Proposition 65 since 1987 as a substance that can cause reproductive damage and birth defects and has been on the list of chemicals known to cause cancer since 1992.
The Exide battery recycling facility in Vernon, California, recycled lead from used automotive batteries and other sources. The facility could process about 25,000 automotive and industrial batteries a day, providing a source of lead for new batteries. Over decades of operation, the facility polluted the soil beneath it with high levels of lead, arsenic, cadmium, and other toxic metals. It also contaminated groundwater, released battery acid onto roads, and contaminated homes and yards in surrounding communities with lead emissions. In March 2015, Exide closed the facility. Exide's lead contamination impacted more than 10,000 properties around the facility, and cleaning each home costs about $60,000.
In 2016, Governor Brown signed AB 118 (Santiago) and SB 93 (De Léon), which appropriated a $176.6 million loan from the General Fund to the Department of Toxic Substances Control (DTSC) to test impacted properties and remove contaminated soil at the properties with the highest lead levels and greatest potential exposure to residents. The state will ultimately seek recovery of these cleanup costs from the parties responsible for the lead contamination, which can include Exide. However, DTSC needed funds in the interim period to immediately pursue cleanup efforts. In response, the Legislature enacted the Lead-Acid Battery Recycling Act of 2016 (AB 2153, C. Garcia, 2016). Among other provisions, AB 2153 imposed two new fees, which began on April 1, 2017:
- A $1 California battery fee for each purchase of a replacement lead-acid battery from a retail dealer. On and after April 1, 2022, the California battery fee increases to $2.
- A $1 fee on manufacturers for each lead-acid battery sold at retail to a person in California, or sold to a dealer, wholesaler, distributor, or other person for retail sale in California. AB 2153 defined “manufacturer” to mean:
- The person who manufactures the lead-acid battery and who sells, offers for sale, or distributes the lead-acid battery in the state.
- If no person, as described above, is subject to the state’s jurisdiction, the manufacturer is the person who imports the lead-acid battery into the state for sale or distribution.
After deducting its administrative costs, CDTFA deposits fee proceeds into the Lead-Acid Battery Fund (Fund), also created by AB 2153. The Fund is a dedicated source to pay for cleanup of the Exide battery recycling site, and at other contaminated sites. AB 2153 also provides that manufacturers paying the fee receive a one-time credit equal to the amount each has paid against any future judgement of legal responsibility for a share of those cleanup costs. CDTFA collected $17.3 million in fees in the 2017-18 fiscal year, of which $10.3 million were manufacturer fees, and $7 million were purchaser fees. Fees totaled $19.6 million in 2018-2019, and the Department of Finance projects $19.6 million in 2019-2020.
Nexus. The United States Constitution grants the power to Congress to “regulate Commerce with foreign nations, and among the several states, and with the Indian Tribes;” a provision widely known as the Commerce Clause (Article I, Section 8). If Congress fails to regulate interstate commerce wholly or in part, the United States Supreme Court has asserted that the Constitution still precludes states from doing so, known as the “dormant” or “negative” Commerce Clause. The United States Supreme Court has issued several decisions interpreting these parts of the Constitution to guide states seeking to tax firms engaged in multistate commerce. Under the foundational Complete Auto Transit v. Brady, 430 U.S. 274, 97 S.Ct. 1076 (1977), states may tax interstate business when the taxpayer’s activity has substantial nexus in the taxing state, meaning that it avails itself of the privilege of carrying on business in that state, among other requirements.
Earlier this year, the Legislature conformed its sales and use tax statutes to implement the United States Supreme Court’s decision in Wayfair v. South Dakota, 585 U.S. ___ (2018), in which the Court reversed previous precedent prohibiting states from compelling retailers to collect and remit sales and use taxes unless they have physical presence (AB 147, Burke). AB 147 requires retailers and persons related to the retailer with total combined sales of property of more than $500,000 in the previous or current calendar year, to register with CDTFA and commence collecting use taxes effective April 1, 2019. Additionally, taxpayers doing business in the state, and those with sales in this state that exceed the lesser of $500,000 or 25 percent of the taxpayer's total sales, have nexus for income tax purposes.
The author wants to increase fee amounts to produce additional revenue to help clean up environmental damage caused by lead acid batteries, and make other changes to clarify provisions in AB 2153.
Proposed Law
Assembly Bill 142 makes three changes to the Lead-Acid Battery Fee:
- Allows out-of-state manufacturers not otherwise subject to the $1 manufacturer battery fee to pay the fee on behalf of a California importer, and claim the associated credits to offset potential hazardous waste liability. The manufacturer must register with CDTFA to pay and remit the fee, and provide the importer with an invoice, contract, or other record documenting that includes:
- Their CDTFA account number,
- The specific batteries sold subject to the fee, and
- A statement that they will pay the fee on behalf of the importer.
- Exempts new motor vehicle dealers that sell or lease a used vehicle containing a replacement lead-acid battery from the $1 California battery fee. Dealers must obtain written documentation from purchasers certifying that the battery will be used in a manner or for a purpose qualifying for the exemption. The purchaser is liable for paying the fee if the battery is subsequently used in a manner or purpose that does not qualify for the exemption.
- Removes the sunset provision on the manufacturer fee of April 1, 2022, and increases it to $2 per battery after that date.
The bill requires manufacturers paying the fee on behalf of importers to retain records for four years, available to inspection by CDTFA, sufficient to document that they paid the fee on behalf of the importer, the identity of the purchaser, and that they provided the required statement. The measure relieves any purchasers who receive timely filed statements for a battery from the obligation to pay the fee, as well as any of its subsequent purchasers, if the manufacturer remits payment for that battery. AB 142 also allows an importer who paid the fee but subsequently receives an untimely statement that the manufacturer paid the fee to file a claim for a refund for any overpaid fees. The bill also states that persons are not required to register with CDTFA if they have an agreement with the manufacturer who agrees to pay the fee for all batteries sold. CDTFA can disclose the name, address, account number, and account status of a person registered to pay the manufacturer battery fee, but not the amount of the fee paid by any person.
AB 142 also modifies how funding is available for specified actions to address contamination directly attributable to releases from a facility known to have been a lead-acid battery recycling facility at any area of the state that DTSC determines with reasonable certainty. The bill also requires DTSC to establish a Lead-Acid Battery Recycling Facility Investigation and Cleanup Program (LABRIC) to identify areas of the state that are eligible for moneys from the Fund. LABRIC must provide public notice of the initiation of the investigation or site evaluation of any area reasonably suspected to have been contaminated by the operation of a lead-acid battery recycling facility. Upon completion of the investigation or evaluation, DTSC must provide notice and an opportunity for comment on the proposed designation of a site as known to have been contaminated by the operation of a lead-acid battery recycling facility. The bill allows further investigation or evaluation for a site that is no longer operating if DTSC is unable to designate a site as known to have been contaminated by the operation of a lead-acid battery recycling facility within two years of a public notice of the initiation of the investigation or evaluation.
Additionally, the bill requires CDTFA to submit a report to the Legislature relating to out-of-state manufacturers who opted to pay the Manufacturer Battery Fee on behalf of an importer. The bill requires the report to include:
- Any regulations or policies adopted by CDTFA for the purposes of ensuring compliance with the registration, returns, reporting, payments, audits, refunds, or collection requirements related to the manufacturer battery fee;
- The revenue impact as determined by the revenues paid or collected compared to the estimated revenue amount calculated by the Senate Committee on Appropriations in its analysis of the fiscal impact of AB 2153; and
- The fiscal impact of the Manufacturer Battery Fee, including costs required to ensure compliance, costs related to audits, refunds, and administering regulations, and estimated cost savings.
The bill also makes technical and conforming changes, including to add a definition of “importer.” The measure also make legislative findings and declarations supporting its purposes.
State Revenue Impact
For the May 16 version of AB 142, CDTFA estimates that the bill’s increase in the manufacturer fee will result in additional fee revenues of $21.4 million in the first full fiscal year (FY 2022-23). CDTFA’s estimates for the measure’s exemption for new car dealers installing reused batteries results in revenue losses of $80,000 per fiscal year until 2022-23, after which losses increase to $160,000 per year because of the fee increase.
Comments
1. Purpose of the bill. According to the author, “AB 2153 in 2016 reallocated a fee already imposed on all car batteries to fund the cleanup of contamination caused by lead-acid batteries throughout the state. Under current law, at the point of sale, $1 from the consumers’ deposit will go to the cleanup fund. Manufacturers also pay a $1 fee on all batteries sold in the state. Starting on April 1 2022, the consumer fee increases to $2, and the manufacture fee sunsets. This bill simply raises the manufacture fee to $2 as well to keep the fund equitable; consumers alone shouldn’t bear this burden. The fund will facilitate clean-up efforts for Exide and up to 39 similar sites across the state from Oakland, Los Angles, West Sacramento, Inglewood, Fresno, and San Francisco so remediation won’t be delayed based on an inability to get funding from the companies that created the situation in the first place, or rely on the general fund. This fund has been bringing relief to these affected communities and ensures solutions to a major long-term problem. Since starting in 2017 the fund has raised $30 million dollars. Unfortunately the cleanup of just the homes surrounding Exide is estimated to cost $540-$720million dollars. If we don’t increase the manufacture fee it will take over 30 years to fund the clean-up. That is not acceptable.”
2. Outside the reach? Some out-of-state battery manufacturers sell directly to distributors in California, thereby obtaining nexus for tax purposes, and remit the manufacturers’ fee directly to CDTFA. However, others sell to distributors outside California, who then resell batteries to a California distributor or wholesaler, so they do not obtain nexus. AB 2153 imposes the fee on
the manufacturer, but if the manufacturer does not have nexus, the importer then becomes responsible for the fee. AB 142 allows an out-of-state manufacturer engaged in business in this state to register and remit the manufacturer battery fee on behalf of the importer, but any sales that wholly occur outside this state are beyond the state’s reach for purposes of tax enforcement. As a result, CDTFA could not pursue collection of fees from the out-of-state manufacturer if there is a discrepancy or disagreement between the manufacturer and the importer regarding who paid how much in fees on which batteries. CDTFA will ultimately pursue the importer for any unpaid fees because they have taxable nexus. In two cases, state law allows CDTFA to allow another person to pay the tax or fee on behalf of the person upon whom the law imposes the fee. First, retailers can pay fees on behalf of consumers, who normally must pay the Covered Electronic Waste Recycling (eWaste) fee. The Underground Storage Tank fee program allows an operator/lessee of a gas station to pay the Underground Storage Tank fee for the owner of the tanks. However, in both cases, the person assuming the obligation has nexus for state tax purposes. While AB 142 could result in easing the burden on importers, and provide additional clean-up funds, it may complicate tax administration, and create disagreements between CDTFA, manufacturers, and importers. The Committee may wish to consider whether AB 142’s benefits are offset by its potential complications for tax administration.
3. Need. The Senate Environmental Quality Committee notes:
“The current Fund balance is not enough to pay back the current $176.6 million loan and proposed $75 million additional loans. As it relates to the Governor's proposed $75 million in loans for Exide cleanup, the Legislative Analysist's Office recommends the Legislature require a report to discuss any plans to use the Fund to repay these proposed loans, and what Exide's repayment could mean for the Fund. Based on rough math, it would take the Fund more than 12 years to accrue enough revenue to pay the three General Fund loans back in full, and an additional 25 years to fund total cleanup (should DTSC not be able to have cost recovery from Exide as the responsible party for the pollution before cleanup is finished). Notwithstanding Exide and the future loan repayments for those cleanup costs, there are at least 39 other former lead smelter sites, which may require future remediation. Of the four sites that DTSC prioritized from the list of 39, the estimated sampling and removal action costs are $30 million. The additional $2 fee would theoretically double the Fund's revenues. This will make a dent in the loan repayments, but is insufficient to do lead remediation at the prioritized four sites, let alone 39, additional lead smelter sites.”
4. Incoming! The Senate Environmental Quality Committee approved AB 142 by a vote of 5 to 0 on June 19th. The Committee on Governance and Finance is considering the bill as the committee of second reference.
5. Urgency. As an urgency statute, AB 142 must be approved by 2/3 vote of each house of the Legislature. Regular legislation takes effect on the January 1 following its passage, but urgency bills take effect as soon as they are passed, signed, and chaptered.
6. Technicals. CDTFA and Committee Staff recommend the following technical amendments:
- Continue to require importers that enter into agreements with out-of-state manufacturers to register with CDTFA.
- Clarify that the invoice statement issued by the out-of-state manufacturer, pursuant to Section 25215.3, should be provided to the CA importer, not the “purchaser.”
- Allow disclosure of account status, including manufacturer battery fees paid, to the importer that enters into agreement with the out-of-state manufacturer, pursuant to Section 25215.3.
Assembly Actions
Assembly Environmental Safety and Toxic Materials Committee: 5-2
Assembly Appropriations Committee: 11-6
Assembly Floor: 54-17
Support and Opposition
(7/5/19)
Support: Breast Cancer Prevention Partners, California Association of Environmental Health Administrators, California Communities Against Toxics, California League Of Conservation Voters, California New Car Dealers Association, City of Los Angeles, Coalition for a Safe Environment, Consumer Attorneys of California, Desert Citizens Against Pollution, East Yard Communities for Environmental Justice, Environmental Working Group, Los Angeles County Board Of Supervisors, Los Angeles County Solid Waste Management Committee/Integrated Waste Management Task Force, Mothers of East Los Angeles, Prouno, South Coast Air Quality Management District, City of Torrance.
Opposition: Howard Jarvis Taxpayers Association.
-- END --
SENATE COMMITTEE ON ENVIRONMENTAL QUALITY
Senator Allen, Chair
2019 - 2020 Regular
Bill No: AB 142
Author: | Cristina Garcia | ||
Version: | 5/22/2019 | Hearing Date: | 6/19/2019 |
Urgency: | Yes | Fiscal: | Yes |
Consultant: | Gabrielle Meindl | ||
SUBJECT: Lead-acid batteries
DIGEST: This bill increases the Manufacturer Battery Fee and makes other changes to the Lead-Acid Battery Recycling Act (Act) of 2016.
ANALYSIS:
Existing law:
Pursuant to the Act of 2016 (Health & Safety Code (HSC) § 25215, et seq):
- Requires, on and after April 1, 2017, until March 31, 2022, a California Battery Fee (Fee) of $1 to be imposed on a person for each replacement lead-acid battery purchased from a dealer. Requires, on and after April 1, 2022, the amount of the Fee to increase to $2. (HSC § 25215.25)
- Requires each manufacturer to remit to the California Department of Tax and Fee Administration (CDTFA) a $1 Manufacturer Battery Fee for each lead-acid battery sold at retail to a person in California. Sunsets the Manufacturer Battery Fee on April 1, 2022. (HSC § 25215.35)
- Requires all Fee and Manufacturer Battery Fee revenues be remitted to the CDTFA for administration of the fee and the remainder to be deposited into the Lead-Acid Battery Fund (Fund). (HSC § 25215.5)
This bill:
- Deletes the sunset on the $1 Manufacturer Battery Fee and increases the fee to $2 in perpetuity effective April 1, 2022.
- Revises the definition of "manufacturer" to state that a person who manufactures a lead-acid battery is subject to the jurisdiction of the state with respect to a lead-acid battery if the person is engaged in business in this state, including a "retailer engaged in business in this state," as defined.
- Allows an out-of-state lead-acid battery manufacturer, not subject to the Manufacturer Battery Fee, beginning January 1, 2020, to pay the fee on behalf of an importer and claim the associated credits to offset potential hazardous waste liability. Exempts an importer who has an agreement of this type with a manufacturer from the requirement to register with the CDTFA, as specified.
- Requires a person who pays the Manufacturer Battery Fee on behalf of an importer to be credited for that payment, if the person does all of the following:
- Submits to the jurisdiction of the state for purposes of the fees imposed under the Act and registers with CDTFA to pay and remit the manufacturer battery fee;
- Provides to the purchaser a statement on the invoice, contract, or other record documenting the transaction, as specified;
- Retains records sufficient to document that the lead-acid battery for which the person has agreed to pay the manufacturer battery fee was delivered for retail sale in California, the identity of the purchaser of that battery, and that the statement was provided to the purchaser of the battery in a timely manner; and,
- Requires the person to retain these records for a period of no less than four years and to make the records reasonably available to CDTFA upon request.
- Requires a purchaser of a lead-acid battery who receives a timely statement from a manufacturer to be relieved from any obligation related to the Manufacturer Battery Fee, provided that the manufacturer remits payment to the state for the sale of that battery.
- Authorizes an importer who has paid the Manufacturer Battery Fee for a lead-acid battery and who subsequently receives an untimely statement that the fee has been paid to file a claim for a refund for any overpaid fees.
- Exempts, effective January 1, 2020, new motor vehicle dealers that sell or lease a used vehicle, into which the new dealer has incorporated a replacement lead-acid battery, from the Fee.
- Requires a dealer or a manufacturer to obtain a written exclusion certificate from a purchaser if the battery will be sold or used in a manner entitling the dealer or manufacturer to regard the purchase as not subject to the Fee or the Manufacture Battery Fee, as specified. Relieves a dealer or manufacturer that accepts an exclusion certificate in good faith from the fee collection responsibility.
- Requires, on or before January 1, 2022, CDTFA to submit a report to the Legislature relating to out-of-state manufacturers who opted to pay the Manufacturer Battery Fee on behalf of an importer. Requires the report to include all of the following information:
- Any regulations or policies adopted by CDTFA for the purposes of ensuring compliance with the registration, returns, reporting, payments, audits, refunds, or collection requirements related to the manufacturer battery fee;
- The revenue impact as determined by the revenues paid or collected compared to the estimated revenue amount calculated by the Senate Committee on Appropriations in its analysis of the fiscal impact of Assembly Bill 2153 (C. Garcia, Chapter 666, Statutes of 2016); and
- The fiscal impact of the Manufacturer Battery Fee, including costs required to ensure compliance, costs related to audits, refunds, and administering regulations, and estimated cost savings.
- Reconfigures how moneys from the Fund shall be expended as follows:
- Specifies funding for:
- Cleanup, remedial action, removal, monitoring, or other response actions at any area of the state that DTSC determines is known to have been contaminated by the operation of a lead-acid battery recycling facility;
- Grants to fund qualified industry association lead-acid battery recycling awareness plans;
- Repayment of the $176.6 million General Fund (GF) loan or any other loan provided to DTSC to clean up the Exide Technologies (Exide) remediation site only after the other authorized activities have been fully funded in a given fiscal year.
- Specifies funding for:
- Authorizes CDTFA to disclose the name, address, account number, and account status of a person registered with CDTFA required to pay the Manufacturer Battery Fee. Prohibits the account status from including the amount of the Manufacturer Battery Fee paid by any person.
- Requires DTSC to establish a Lead-Acid Battery Recycling Facility Investigation and Cleanup Program (LABRIC) to identify areas of the state that are eligible for moneys from the Fund.
- Requires the program to provide public notice of the initiation of the investigation or site evaluation of any area reasonably suspected to have been contaminated by the operation of a lead-acid battery recycling facility.
- Requires DTSC, upon completion of an investigation or site evaluation, to provide notice and an opportunity for comment on the proposed designation of a site as known to have been contaminated by the operation of a lead-acid battery recycling facility.
- Provides that further investigation or evaluation for a site is no longer authorized if, within 2 years of a public notice of the initiation of the investigation or evaluation, DTSC is unable to designate a site as known to have been contaminated by the operation of a lead-acid battery recycling facility.
- Requires a qualified industry association (Battery Council International) to implement a lead-acid battery recycling awareness plan and specifies required components of the awareness plan.
- Creates a grant program that would provide funding to qualified industry associations, for the implementation of a lead-acid battery recycling awareness plan. Specifies the plan include a public education program to inform consumers regarding the availability of lead-acid battery recycling, promote the safe and environmentally sound collection of lead-acid batteries by retailers in the state, and promote the safe and environmentally sound recycling of lead-acid batteries collected by retailers and others in the state.
- Requires the Department of Resources Recycling and Recovery (CalRecycle) to approve a grant proposal that meets certain requirements. Appropriates $500,000 for the 2019–20 fiscal year from the Fund to CalRecycle for purposes of funding the grant program.
- States the intent of the Legislature to appropriate $500,000 annually from the Fund to CalRecycle to fund qualified industry association grants to implement their lead-acid battery recycling awareness plans.
- Makes technical changes to update the Board of Equalization’s name to CDTFA.
- Takes effect immediately as an urgency statute.
Background
- Health impacts associated with lead: Lead is a toxic metal that does not break down in the environment and accumulates in the human body. Exposures to lead can lead to a number of health problems, including: behavioral problems, learning disabilities, joint and muscle weakness, anemia, organ failure, and even death. Lead has been listed under California's Proposition 65 since 1987 as a substance that can cause reproductive damage and birth defects and has been on the list of chemicals known to cause cancer since 1992.
Children 6 years old and under are most at risk because their bodies are growing quickly. According to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention there is no safe blood level in children. Lead is a leading environmental threat to children’s health in the United States. When children are exposed to lead it has lifelong adverse effects, such as lowered IQ scores, hearing disabilities, difficulty paying attention, hyperactivity, and disrupted postnatal growth.
- Lead-acid batteries. Lead-acid batteries are rechargeable batteries made of lead plates situated in sulfuric acid within a plastic casing. They are used globally for a wide range of purposes, most commonly in vehicles like automobiles, boats, trucks, and industrial vehicles. According to the U.S. Geological Survey, the lead-acid battery industry accounted for about 90% of reported U.S. lead consumption during 2015. The average battery contains 17.5 pounds of lead and 1.5 gallons of sulfuric acid.
The demand for lead is high and as such lead is a highly valued commodity that makes recycling highly profitable.
The United States and California have increased regulations over smelting operations (the process through which lead is retrieved) to decrease potential environmental and public health exposures to smelting emissions and contamination. However, some smelters in California, like the Exide facility, have pollution resulting from operations prior to the air, soil and water regulations of today.
- Inception of the Act. The Lead-Acid Battery Recycling Facility Investigation and Cleanup Program was established pursuant to Assembly Bill 2153 (C. Garcia, Chapter 666, Statutes of 2016), which became the Lead-Acid Battery Recycling Act of 2016 (Act).
The Manufacturer Battery Fee and Fee on lead-acid batteries sold in the state are deposited into the Fund created by the Act. The Fund is a dedicated source to pay for cleanup of the Exide battery recycling site in Vernon, California, and at other contaminated sites. The Act also provides that manufacturers paying the fee receive a one-time credit equal to the amount each has paid against any future judgement of legal responsibility for a share of those cleanup costs.
Beginning on and after April 1, 2017, and until April 1, 2022, a $1 fee is imposed on a manufacturer for each lead-acid battery sold at retail to a person in California, or that is sold to a dealer, wholesaler, distributor, or other person for retail sale in California. The manufacturer is required to remit the fees to the CDTFA at the time the return is required to be filed.
- Exide Technologies. The Exide battery recycling facility in Vernon, California, recycled lead from used automotive batteries and other sources. The facility could process about 25,000 automotive and industrial batteries a day, providing a source of lead for new batteries. Over the course of decades of operation, the facility polluted the soil beneath it with high levels of lead, arsenic, cadmium, and other toxic metals. It also contaminated groundwater, released battery acid onto roads, and contaminated homes and yards in surrounding communities with lead emissions. In March, 2015, Exide was forced to close the facility.
Properties up to 1.3 and 1.7 miles away from the facility are impacted by Exide's lead contamination, which amounts to upwards of 10,000 properties. According to DTSC, cleaning each home costs about $60,000 (an increase from the previously $45,000 anticipated cost per property). DTSC has sampled 8,527 properties to-date; 7,733 properties have exceeded the screening level of 80 parts per million (ppm), meaning about 90% of all properties tested for lead will require remediation. Removing lead-contaminated soil from thousands of homes surrounding Exide could result in the most extensive cleanup of its kind in California and will be among the largest cleanup ever conducted in the nation.
On April 20, 2016, Governor Jerry Brown signed AB 118 (Santiago, Chapter 10, Statutes of 2016) and SB 93 (De Léon, Chapter 9, Statutes of 2016), appropriating a $176.6 million loan from the General Fund to the Toxic Substances Control Account (TSCA) to enable DTSC to test properties, schools, daycare centers, and parks in the 1.7 mile radius and remove contaminated soil at the properties that have the highest lead levels and greatest potential exposure to residents.
Cleanup costs initially incurred by the state will ultimately be sought from the parties responsible for the lead contamination (Exide). DTSC will need funds to pay for the work while it seeks additional money from Exide and other responsible parties.
After the $176.6 million is expended, DTSC will need additional funds for a complete and thorough cleanup. AB 2153 authorized use of the fee revenues in the Fund to fill that gap and repay the state loan while providing an ongoing source of funds to address lead contamination from lead-acid batteries.
Governor Newsom, in his proposed Fiscal Year (FY) 2019-2020 Budget, included an additional $75 million General Fund one-time loans to accelerate the cleanup of additional properties within a 1.7-mile radius of the facility over the next two years. Of that, $50 million would allow DTSC to clean up approximately 700 additional high-risk properties in which lead contamination exceeds the state standard of 80 parts per million, and $25 million would be used to continue cleaning up previously identified sites contaminated by Exide facility.
- Areas potentially contaminated by lead-acid battery recycling. AB 2153 requires DTSC to annually report to the Legislature on the status of DTSC's progress on implementing the Act and how it plans to spend revenues from the Fund on site remediation at other lead smelter sites.
In DTSC's first report from February 2018, DTSC describes its collaboration with the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency Region 9 (EPA Region 9) to evaluate previous and current lead-acid battery recycling facilities in California. This evaluation focused on 39 former lead smelter sites identified from a comprehensive review of site investigation and cleanup records maintained by both EPA Region 9 and DTSC, including DTSC's EnviroStor database.
Based on an initial review of the 39 sites, DTSC selected 18 potentially contaminated sites for a more thorough assessment, using available information to determine if further investigation, cleanup, or other appropriate actions are needed to protect public health. DTSC also evaluated areas around these sites to assess potential health impacts to schools, parks, and residential properties. Based on the assessment of the potential threat to public health and the environment, DTSC prioritized four of the 18 sites for investigation and potential remedial action in FY 2018-2019.
These other facilities may have operated and closed before environmental regulatory programs were established. DTSC has noted that although these secondary lead smelters may not precisely meet the definition of lead-acid battery recycling facility pursuant to AB 2153, it is possible that some or all of these historical smelters do meet the facility definition in the Act.
DTSC is researching the historical smelting facilities and gathering additional information on each of these facilities to ascertain the scope and nature of their operations and their impact on the surrounding communities. If any of these facilities meet the definition of a lead-acid battery recycling facility, they would be subject to investigation and cleanup by DTSC. The Fund created by AB 2153 would bear the initial cost of this effort if the Legislature appropriates funds for these activities.
- Statutorily authorized uses of the Fund revenues. Under current law, CDTFA collects all fees and retains sufficient funds necessary to cover its administrative costs to collect the fee. Once those costs are deducted, the remaining fees are deposited into the Fund, which are then available upon appropriation by the Legislature.
AB 2153 specified that monies from the Fund shall be expended for the following activities:
- Investigation, site evaluation, cleanup, remedial action, removal, monitoring, or other response actions at any area of the state that is reasonably suspected to have been contaminated by the operation of a lead-acid battery recycling facility;
- State administrative costs; and,
- Repayment of the $176.6 million General Fund loan to cleanup Exide.
- A symbolic gesture to fee payers. This bill includes language that states that revenues from the Fund can only be used for repayment of a loan to clean up Exide after the other eligible expenses for this Fund (e.g., investigation and site cleanup, administration of the Act), are initially paid.
Though the law specifies eligible expenditures of the fee revenues, AB 2153 was approved by a 2/3 vote of the Legislature due to an urgency clause in the bill. However, that vote threshold effectively rendered the fee a tax, which loosens the restraints for what the fee revenues can be spent.
This language is intended to clarify legislative intent and restrict spending for non-lead-acid battery pollution related expenditures, even if it can be overridden by future legislatures.
- Revenue projections and need. Since 2017 when the fees went into effect, the Fund accrued $17.2 million in FY 2017-2018, $19.6 million in FY 2018-2019, and, according to the Department of Finance, another $19.6 million is projected for FY 2019-2020.
To keep track of who is paying what and how much, AB 142 requires CDTFA to report to the Legislature by January 1, 2022, and outline the revenue impact determined by revenues collected compared against the revenue estimate from the August 11, 2016, Senate Appropriations Committee analysis for AB 2153, which predicted the Fund would generate "up to $32 million in revenue from the fee assessment" -- a far cry from the current $19 million projections.
Projections are important so DTSC can project revenue needs for implementing the Act.
DTSC has yet to release its annual report to the Legislature, as required by AB 2153, which was due in March, 2019. The report is expected to provide more information on DTSC's planned implementation efforts to identify and clean up lead pollution from lead-acid battery smelting. The report will also include information on the sites at which actions were performed using moneys from the Fund, the status of cleanup at those sites, including total anticipated costs of cleanup at those sites, the balance of the Fund, the amount of fees remitted to the Fund, the amount spent by the Fund and the purposes for which those amounts were spent, and the amounts reimbursed to CDTFA.
The report should shine a light on DTSC's resource needs from the Fund for lead contamination cleanup.
- Use of the Fund revenues to-date. The Legislature has appropriated funds to DTSC to set up and administer the Act, which includes development of a framework for implementation of the Act, and funds to CDTFA to set up and administer the Fund, including outreach to and registration of fee payees- battery manufacturers, importers, and dealers.
Additionally, between the FY 2017-2018 and FY 2018-2019 Budget Acts, the Legislature appropriated $26.7 million from the Fund to repay the General Fund Exide loan. The Governor's proposed FY 2019-2020 Budget would appropriate $16 million in loan repayment to the General Fund.
- Safer Consumer Products Work Plan. In 2016, Governor Brown and the California Legislature required that DTSC include lead-acid batteries in its 2015-2017 Safer Consumer Products Work Plan for consideration as a potential Priority Product. DTSC began research on exposures and hazards associated with lead-acid batteries in 2017 and will continue that work under this Work Plan. As part of its preliminary research, DTSC held a public workshop to gather stakeholder input on November 6, 2017. DTSC continues to actively evaluate whether lead-acid batteries should be designated a Priority Product.
Lead-acid batteries contain three Candidate Chemicals: lead, arsenic, and sulfuric acid. Lead exposures to workers and neighboring areas may occur during recycling and manufacturing operations. Inclusion of this category in the Work Plan allows DTSC to finalize evaluation of lead-acid batteries as a potential Priority Product.
Comments
- Purpose of Bill. According to the author, "AB 2153 in 2016 reallocated a fee already imposed on all car batteries to fund the cleanup of contamination caused by lead-acid batteries throughout the state. Under current law, at the point of sale, $1 from the consumers’ deposit will go to the cleanup fund. Manufacturers also pay a $1 fee on all batteries sold in the state. Starting on April 1 2022, the consumer fee increases to $2, and the manufacture fee sunsets. This bill simply raises the manufacture fee to $2 as well to keep the fund equitable; consumers alone shouldn’t bare this burden.
“The fund will facilitate clean-up efforts for Exide and up to 39 similar sites across the state from Oakland, Los Angles, West Sacramento, Inglewood, Fresno, and San Francisco so remediation won’t be delayed based on an inability to get funding from the companies that created the situation in the first place, or relay on the general fund. This fund has been bringing relief to these affected communities and ensures solutions to a major long-term problem. Since starting in 2017 the fund has raised $30million dollars. Unfortunately the cleanup of just the homes surrounding Exide is estimated to cost $540-$720million dollars. If we don’t increase the manufacture fee it will take over 30 years to fund the clean-up. That is not acceptable.”
- Increasing the manufacturer fee to $2 creates equity and begins to address ongoing funding need. Current law requires both consumers and manufacturers to pay a $1 fee until April 2022. The California Battery Fee then goes up to $2 in April 2022 and the Manufacturer Battery Fee sunsets. AB 142 strikes the 2022 sunset date for the Manufacturer Battery Fee and increases the fees to $2 in perpetuity. Establishing the Manufacturer Battery Fee at $2 creates equity with what consumers will be paying.
It is undisputed that ongoing costs to clean up lead pollution from lead-acid battery operations will be increasing and ongoing.
The current Fund balance is not enough to pay back the current $176.6 million loan and proposed $75 million additional loans. As it relates to the Governor's proposed $75 million in loans for Exide cleanup, the Legislative Analysist's Office recommends the Legislature require a report to discuss any plans to use the Fund to repay these proposed loans, and what Exide's repayment could mean for the Fund.
Based on rough math, it would take the Fund more than 12 years to accrue enough revenue to pay the three General Fund loans back in full, and an additional 25 years to fund total cleanup (should DTSC not be able to have cost recovery from Exide as the responsible party for the pollution before cleanup is finished).
Notwithstanding Exide and the future loan repayments for those cleanup costs, there are at least 39 other former lead smelter sites, which may require future remediation. Of the four sites that DTSC prioritized from the list of 39, the estimated sampling and removal action costs are $30 million.
The additional $2 fee would theoretically double the Fund's revenues. This will make a dent in the loan repayments, but is insufficient to do lead remediation at the prioritized four sites, let alone 39, additional lead smelter sites.
- Limitation on use of Funds. Existing statute allows DTSC to use Fund money for the investigation, site evaluation, cleanup, remedial action, removal, monitoring, or other response actions at any area of the state that is reasonably suspected to have been contaminated by the operation of a lead-acid battery recycling facility. AB 142 would require a higher threshold for the use of Fund money for cleanup, remedial action, removal, monitoring, or other response actions. The bill stipulates that DTSC must now determine a site is known to have been contaminated by the operation of a lead-acid battery facility before monies can be used for these activities. This new, higher standard could make it difficult for DTSC to use monies from the Fund to remediate lead contaminated properties adjacent to or near former lead battery recycling facilities.
Further, the bill narrows the definition of what is a lead-acid battery recycling facility to exclude facilities that conducted activities other than lead-acid battery recycling. Thus, if a facility did not exclusively conduct recycling activities, the cleanup of the site would not be eligible for Fund monies.
The Committee may wish to consider amending the bill to:
- Ensure that DTSC can access the Fund for a lead-acid battery recycling facility which also engaged in incidental processing of other lead bearing material; and
- Clarify that the “known” standard only applies to the alleged lead battery recycling facility;
- Specify that all other sites would be subject to a “reasonable certainty” standard, which does not require DTSC to prove that a lead-acid battery facility was the only contributor to lead contamination at the site, but it does require that there is information establishing a direct contribution.
- Tight time limit for DTSC investigations. The bill requires DTSC to establish a LABRIC program to identify areas of the state that are eligible for monies from the Fund. The bill further requires that the program provide public notice of the initiation of the investigation or site evaluation of any area reasonably suspected to have been contaminated by the operation of a lead-acid battery recycling facility and upon completion of an investigation, requires DTSC to provide notice and an opportunity for comment on the proposed designation of a site as known to have been contaminated by the operation of a lead-acid battery recycling facility.
AB 142 stipulates that, if after two years, DTSC is unable to designate a site as known to have been contaminated by the operation of a lead-acid battery recycling facility, “the public notice shall be deemed to have been withdrawn and further investigation or evaluation for the site shall no longer be authorized.” While two years seems like a reasonable timeframe, there might be circumstance that arise that make it difficult or impossible for DTSC to complete its analysis within two years (e.g., waiting for soil sampling results from a third party laboratory).
The Committee may wish to consider amending the bill to allow for a 90-day extension of the two-year site designation deadline for good cause without having to re-start the public notice process.
- Value of new exemption? AB 142 provides an exemption for new car dealers that sell or lease a used vehicle into which the dealer has incorporated a replacement lead-acid battery from the Fee. The author’s office describe this as a clarification of the existing exemption for new car dealers. However, staff notes that any exemption creates loss of revenue to the Fund and, consequently, reduces available monies to implement the Act.
- Value of new grant program? The bill establishes a new grant program that would provide $500,000 (Fund) in 2019-20 fiscal year to CalRecycle for a qualified industry association (Battery Council International) to implement a lead-acid battery recycling awareness plan. The plan shall include the creation of a program to develop and implement a public education program to inform consumers regarding the availability of lead-acid battery recycling, promote the safe and environmentally sound collection of lead-acid batteries by retailers in the state, and promote the safe and environmentally sound recycling of lead-acid batteries collected by retailers and others in the state. The bill also states legislative intent to appropriate $500,000 annually from the Fund for this purpose.
Staff notes that lead-acid batteries are the most recycled product in the state, with a nationwide recycling rate exceeding 99%.
The Committee may wish to consider amending the bill to instead authorize DTSC to expend up to $500,000 per year to issue grants to a qualified industry association for projects that improve lead acid battery technology, consistent with any recommendations that may result from its evaluation of lead acid batteries under the Safer Consumer Products program. DTSC’s recommendations may call for lead battery technology innovation in areas that will help prevent future environmental and public health impacts.
- Does this bill complicate tax administration? This bill creates a mechanism that allows an out-of-state manufacturer to agree to pay the manufacturer battery fee on behalf of the California importer, even though the out-of-state manufacturer is not otherwise subject to the state's taxing jurisdiction. If the out-of-state manufacturer fails to abide by its agreement with the California importer, the importer ultimately is responsible for paying the manufacturer battery fee and will be held liable for underpayments. This is so, even though the importer's agreement with the manufacturer relieves the importer of the requirement to register with CDTFA. Moreover, if CDTFA bills the importer, the billing may be the first indication that the out-of-state manufacturer failed to pay the fee, as the importer is not privy to the amount of fees the manufacturer actually paid. Although the bill allows account status to be disclosed to the California importer, it specifically excludes disclosure of the manufacturer fees paid.
The bill also allows a California importer to request a refund of fees that are overpaid because the out-of-state manufacturer issued an untimely statement that it had paid the fees on the importer's behalf. This would necessitate CDTFA to audit both the California importer and out-of-state manufacturer to verify the returns filed by the out-of-state manufacturer. Auditing both parties increases complexity in auditing the refund request.
Out-of-State Manufacturers: Fee Enforcement. On April 25, 2019, California passed AB 147 (Ch. 5, Stats. 2019). AB 147 requires retailers located outside of California (remote sellers) to register with CDTFA and collect California use tax if, during the preceding or current calendar year, the total combined sales of tangible personal property for delivery in California by the retailer and all persons related to the retailer exceed $500,000. The new collection requirement is operative April 1, 2019, and supersedes prior CDTFA direction regarding the use tax collection requirements for out-of-state retailers.
Lead-acid battery industry representatives explain that out-of-state manufacturers sell directly to distributors in California and sell to distributors outside California who subsequently resell the batteries to a California distributor or wholesaler. Currently, the manufacturer is the person who manufactures the lead-acid battery and who sells, offers for sale, or distributes the lead-acid battery in the state, or the importer is the "manufacturer" and liable for the manufacturer battery fee.
This bill expands the "manufacturer" definition to include a person "engaged in business in this state." Therefore, an out-of-state manufacturer engaged in business in this state would register and remit the manufacturer battery fee, which is currently remitted by an importer.
However, out-of-state manufacturers with sales that wholly occur outside this state are not be subject to California's taxing jurisdiction or enforcement. Therefore, if such a manufacturer does not remit manufacturer battery fees or claims bankruptcy, the CDTFA has no authority to pursue collection of those fees from the out-of-state manufacturer.
The primary benefit of allowing an out-of-state manufacturer to pay the manufacturer battery fee on behalf of an in-state importer appears to be that the manufacturer paying the fee can claim credit to offset future hazardous waste liability. Collecting fees from out-of-state manufactures and giving liability credit for those fees is complicated and problematic. Should this bill pass out of this Committee, it will be heard next by the Governance and Finance Committee, which will appropriately vet these tax administration and fee enforcement issues further.
Double Referral
If this measure is approved by the Senate Environmental Quality Committee, the do pass motion must include the action to re-refer the bill to the Senate Governance and Finance Committee.
Related/Prior Legislation
AB 1663 (C. Garcia, 2017). Would have amended the Act to clarify provisions related to an out-of-state lead-acid battery manufacturer's financial responsibilities. Specifically, would have authorized a person who manufacturers a lead-acid battery and is not subject to the jurisdiction of the state and who agrees in writing with the importer of that lead-acid battery to pay the Manufacturer Battery Fee imposed on behalf of the importer. The bill was later amended with unrelated content.
AB 2153 (C. Garcia, Chapter 666, Statutes of 2016). Enacted the Act.
SOURCE:
Author
SUPPORT:
Breast Cancer Prevention Partners
California Communities Against Toxics
California New Car Dealers Association
California Safe Schools
City Of Los Angeles
City Of Torrance
Coalition For A Safe Environment
Desert Citizens Against Pollution
Mothers Of East Los Angeles
PROUNO
Communities for a Better Environment
South Coast Air Quality Management District
Consumer Attorneys of California
East Yard Communities for Environmental Justice
Environmental Working Group
Los Angeles County Board of Supervisors
OPPOSITION:
Howard Jarvis Taxpayers Association
-- END --
ASSEMBLY THIRD READING
ATR Bill Id:AB 142
Author:(Cristina Garcia)
As Amended Ver:May 22, 2019
2/3 vote. Urgency
SUMMARY:
Increases the Manufacturer Battery Fee and makes other changes to the Lead-Acid Battery Recycling Act (Act) of 2016.
Major Provisions
- Deletes the sunset on the $1 Manufacturer Battery Fee and increases the fee to $2 in perpetuity effective April 1, 2022.
- Allows an out-of-state lead-acid battery manufacturer, not subject to the Manufacturer Battery Fee, to pay the fee on behalf of an importer and claim the associated credits to offset potential hazardous waste liability.
- Exempts, effective January 1, 2020, new motor vehicle dealers that sell or lease a used vehicle containing a lead-acid battery from the California Battery Fee.
- Requires the California Department of Tax and Fee Administration (CDTFA) to report to the Legislature by January 1, 2022, relating to out-of-state manufacturers who opted to pay the Manufacturer Battery fee.
- Specifies the repayment of the $176.6 million General Fund (GF) loan or any other loan provided to the Department of Toxic Substance Control (DTSC) to clean up the Exide Technologies (Exide) remediation site will not be paid back until the cleanup of Exide and all other areas of the state contaminated by lead-acid batteries is completed.
- Requires DTSC to establish a Lead-Acid Battery Recycling Facility Investigation and Cleanup Program (LABRIC) to identify areas of the state that are eligible for moneys from the Lead-Acid Battery Fund (Fund). Specifies public notification and public comment requirements for the LABRIC program.
- Requires a qualified industry association (Battery Council International) to implement a lead-acid battery recycling awareness plan and specifies required components of the awareness plan.
- States the intent of the Legislature to appropriate $500,000 annually from the Fund to the Department of Resources Recycling and Recovery to fund qualified industry association grants to implement their lead-acid battery recycling awareness plans.
- Takes effect immediately as an urgency statute.
COMMENTS:
Lead-Acid Battery Recycling Act (Act): Under the Act, both consumers and manufacturers are required to pay a $1 fee on a lead-acid battery until April 2022. The California Battery Fee (consumer fee) increases to $2 in April 2022 and the Manufacturer Battery Fee (manufacturer fee) sunsets. AB 142 strikes the 2022 sunset date for the Manufacturer Battery Fee and increases the fees to $2 in perpetuity. Establishing the Manufacturer Battery Fee at $2 creates equity with what consumers will be paying.
The current Fund balance is not enough to pay back the current $176.6 million loan and the Governor's proposed $75 million additional loans for Fiscal Year 2019-2020. Notwithstanding Exide and the future loan repayments for those cleanup costs, there are at least 39 other former lead smelter sites, which may require future remediation. Of the four sites that DTSC prioritized from the list of 39, the estimated sampling and removal action costs are $30 million.
The additional $2 fee would theoretically double the Fund's revenues. This will make a dent in the loan repayments, but is insufficient to do lead remediation at the prioritized four sites, let alone 39, additional lead smelter sites.
According to the Author:
"Exide and the other communities with historic lead-acid battery manufacturing plants have a great need for ongoing funding and [AB 142] will ensure that the battery fee money can only be used for its intended purpose."
Arguments in Support:
The Los Angeles County Board of Supervisors states, "The County's Department of Public Health (DPH) notes that the County is home to two of the largest battery recycling facilities in California: Exide in the City of Vernon and Quemetco, Inc. in the City of Industry. The increased revenue from AB 142 would increase the funds available for clean-up efforts at contaminated sites across the State. DPH indicates that contaminated sites create a health equity issue, because at-risk communities at risk of lead exposure are predominantly communities of color, and those residents experience underlying health inequities and contend with exposure to multiple environmental hazards."
Arguments in Opposition:
The Howard Jarvis Taxpayers Association states, "Not every legitimate health and safety issue requires increasing taxes. There are alternative funding mechanisms which may include legitimate regulatory fees under existing constitutional authority. In addition, the necessary funds already exist in California’s $22 billion surplus. Instead, battery manufacturers who may have had little role in contaminating communities are being targeted. The same goes for consumers who live hundreds of miles away from impacted areas. If eighteen sites need mitigation, this is a matter of statewide concern that should be funded out of the General Fund."
FISCAL COMMENTS:
According to the Assembly Appropriations Committee, enactment of this bill could result in: 1) Delays for an unknown amount in the repayment of GF loans for cleanup due to lead-acid battery contamination (loan payback is an allowed expense for the Fund but is not an obligation); 2) Increased annual revenues of $21.4 million, beginning April 1, 2022, resulting from the increase and extension of the Manufacturers Battery Fee; 3) One-time increased administrative costs of approximately $115,000 for CDTFA to collect information from out-of-state manufacturers and prepare the report to the Legislature; and, 4) Initial annual revenue losses of $80,000 until Fiscal Year 2022-23, then annual revenue losses of $160,000 from the California Battery Fee exemption for used car dealers.
VOTES:
ASM ENVIRONMENTAL SAFETY AND TOXIC MATERIALS: 5-2-2
YES: Quirk, Bauer-Kahan, Cristina Garcia, Holden, Muratsuchi
NO: Dahle, Mathis
ABS, ABST OR NV: Melendez, Arambula
ASM APPROPRIATIONS: 11-6-1
YES: Gonzalez, Bloom, Bonta, Calderon, Carrillo, Chau, Eggman, Gabriel, Eduardo Garcia, Quirk, Robert Rivas
NO: Bigelow, Brough, Diep, Fong, Obernolte, Petrie-Norris
ABS, ABST OR NV: Maienschein
UPDATED:
VERSION: May 22, 2019
CONSULTANT: Paige Brokaw / E.S. & T.M. / (916) 319-3965 FN: 0001015
ASSEMBLY THIRD READING
ATR Bill Id:AB 142
Author:(Cristina Garcia)
As Amended Ver:May 16, 2019
2/3 vote. Urgency
SUMMARY:
Increases the Manufacturer Battery Fee and makes other changes to the Lead-Acid Battery Recycling Act (Act) of 2016.
Major Provisions
- Deletes the sunset on the $1 Manufacturer Battery Fee and increases the fee to $2 in perpetuity effective April 1, 2022.
- Allows an out-of-state lead-acid battery manufacturer, not subject to the Manufacturer Battery Fee, to pay the fee on behalf of an importer and claim the associated credits to offset potential hazardous waste liability.
- Exempts, effective January 1, 2020, new motor vehicle dealers that sell or lease a used vehicle containing a lead-acid battery from the California Battery Fee.
- Requires the California Department of Tax and Fee Administration (CDTFA) to report to the Legislature by January 1, 2022, relating to out-of-state manufacturers who opted to pay the Manufacturer Battery fee.
- Specifies the repayment of the $176.6 million General Fund (GF) loan or any other loan provided to the Department of Toxic Substance Control (DTSC) to clean up the Exide Technologies (Exide) remediation site will not be paid back until the cleanup of Exide and all other areas of the state contaminated by lead-acid batteries is completed.
- Takes effect immediately as an urgency statute.
COMMENTS:
Lead-Acid Battery Recycling Act (Act): Under the Act, both consumers and manufacturers are required to pay a $1 fee on a lead-acid battery until April 2022. The California Battery Fee (consumer fee) increases to $2 in April 2022 and the Manufacturer Battery Fee (manufacturer fee) sunsets. AB 142 strikes the 2022 sunset date for the Manufacturer Battery Fee and increases the fees to $2 in perpetuity. Establishing the Manufacturer Battery Fee at $2 creates equity with what consumers will be paying.
The current Lead-Acid Battery Fund (Fund) balance is not enough to pay back the current $176.6 million loan and the Governor's proposed $75 million additional loans for Fiscal Year 2019-2020. Notwithstanding Exide and the future loan repayments for those cleanup costs, there are at least 39 other former lead smelter sites, which may require future remediation. Of the four sites that DTSC prioritized from the list of 39, the estimated sampling and removal action costs are $30 million.
The additional $2 fee would theoretically double the Fund’s revenues. This will make a dent in the loan repayments, but is insufficient to do lead remediation at the prioritized four sites, let alone 39, additional lead smelter sites.
According to the Author:
Exide and the other communities with historic lead-acid battery manufacturing plants have a great need for ongoing funding and [AB 142] will ensure that the battery fee money can only be used for its intended purpose. AB 142 addresses three technical issues: 1) It will clarify that out of state manufacturers can elect to register with the CDTFA to pay a $1 fee on all batteries sold in the state; 2) It will allow the CDTFA to post who is a registered manufacture on their webpage; and, 3) It will clarify that the consumer fee shall not apply to any person when a replacement lead-acid battery is included in any used vehicle sold or leased by a new motor vehicle dealer. This bill also will remove the April 1, 2022, sunset from the Manufacturer Battery Fee, and increase the Manufacturer Battery Fee from $1 to $2 to match the consumer fee, and only allow the repayment of the $176.6 million dollar loan once the clean-up of Exide and other areas of the state that may be contaminated by lead acid batteries has been completed.
Arguments in Support:
The Los Angeles County Board of Supervisors states, "The County's Department of Public Health (DPH) notes that the County is home to two of the largest battery recycling facilities in California: Exide in the City of Vernon and Quemetco, Inc. in the City of Industry. The increased revenue from AB 142 would increase the funds available for clean-up efforts at contaminated sites across the State. DPH indicates that contaminated sites create a health equity issue, because at-risk communities at risk of lead exposure are predominantly communities of color, and those residents experience underlying health inequities and contend with exposure to multiple environmental hazards."
Arguments in Opposition:
Battery Council International states that it "opposes the passage of AB 142 as an urgency measure unless amended because it proposes to double the fee imposed upon battery manufacturers before the full revenue potential is established. It is premature to increase the existing fee level before CDTFA establishes if its current implementation efforts are resulting in under-collection of fee revenues and DTSC develops a spending plan consistent with the purposes of the statute."
FISCAL COMMENTS:
According to the Assembly Appropriations Committee, enactment of this bill could result in: 1) Delays for an unknown amount in the repayment of GF loans for cleanup due to lead-acid battery contamination (loan payback is an allowed expense for the Fund but is not an obligation); 2) Increased annual revenues of $21.4 million, beginning April 1, 2022, resulting from the increase and extension of the Manufacturers Battery Fee; 3) One-time increased administrative costs of approximately $115,000 for CDTFA to collect information from out-of-state manufacturers and prepare the report to the Legislature; and, 4) Initial annual revenue losses of $80,000 until Fiscal Year 2022-23, then annual revenue losses of $160,000 from the California Battery Fee exemption for used car dealers.
VOTES:
ASM ENVIRONMENTAL SAFETY AND TOXIC MATERIALS: 5-2-2
YES: Quirk, Bauer-Kahan, Cristina Garcia, Holden, Muratsuchi
NO: Dahle, Mathis
ABS, ABST OR NV: Melendez, Arambula
ASM APPROPRIATIONS: 11-6-1
YES: Gonzalez, Bloom, Bonta, Calderon, Carrillo, Chau, Eggman, Gabriel, Eduardo Garcia, Quirk, Robert Rivas
NO: Bigelow, Brough, Diep, Fong, Obernolte, Petrie-Norris
ABS, ABST OR NV: Maienschein
UPDATED:
VERSION: May 16, 2019
CONSULTANT: Paige Brokaw / E.S. & T.M. / (916) 319-3965 FN: 0000880
Date of Hearing: March 20, 2019
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Lorena Gonzalez, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 142
Author:(Cristina Garcia) – As Amended Ver:February 25, 2019
Policy Committee: | Environmental Safety and Toxic Materials | Vote: | 5 - 2 |
|
| ||
|
|
Urgency: Yes State Mandated Local Program: No Reimbursable: No
SUMMARY:
This bill extends the Manufacturer Battery Fee indefinitely and increases the fee from $1 to $2 on April 1, 2022. Additionally this bill:
- Allows an out-of-state lead-acid battery manufacturer, not subject to the Manufacturer Battery Fee, to pay the fee on behalf of an importer and claim the associated credits to offset potential hazardous waste liability.
- Exempts new motor vehicle dealers that sell or lease a used vehicle containing a lead-acid battery from the California Battery Fee.
- Requires the California Department of Tax and Fee Administration (CDTFA) to report to the Legislature by January 1, 2021, relating to out-of-state manufacturers who opted to pay the Manufacturer Battery fee.
- Specifies the repayment of the $176.6 million GF loan or any other loan provided to the Department of Toxic Substance Control (DTSC) to cleanup the Exide remediation site will not be paid back until the cleanup of Exide and all other areas of the state contaminated by lead-acid batteries is completed.
- Takes effect immediately as an urgency statute.
FISCAL EFFECT:
- Delays for an unknown amount in the repayment of GF loans for cleanup due to lead-acid battery contamination. Loan payback is an allowed expense for the Battery Cleanup Fund but is not an obligation.
- Increased annual revenues of $21.4 million, beginning April 1, 2022, resulting from the increase and extension of the Manufacturers Battery Fee (Battery Cleanup Fund).
- One-time increased administrative costs of approximately $115,000 for CDTFA to collect information from out-of-state manufacturers and prepare the report to the Legislature (Battery Cleanup Fund).
- Initial annual revenue losses of $80,000 until FY 2022-23, then annual revenue losses of $160,000 from the California Battery Fee exemption for used car dealers (Battery Cleanup Fund).
COMMENTS:
- Purpose. According to the author, “Exide and the other communities with historic lead-acid battery manufacturing plants have a great need for ongoing funding and to ensure that the battery fee money can only be used for its intended purpose.” This bill provides ongoing and increased Manufacturer Battery Fee revenues and a mechanism for out-of-state lead-acid battery manufacturers to pay the fees on behalf of in-state importers so that the manufacturers can offset the fee payments against any potential hazardous waste liability.
In response to claims that the California Battery Fee is too burdensome to administer, this bill exempts new car dealers who sell or lease used cars with replacement batteries. In order to ensure funds are used for contamination cleanup as long as funds are necessary, this bill allows loan payback only after Exide and other contaminated sites throughout the state are remediated.
This bill also provides various technical clarifications and administrative modifications.
- Background. Existing law imposes a $1 California Battery Fee on a consumer for each purchase of a replacement lead-acid battery from a retailer. Except for sales to businesses, the retail dealer must separately state the California Battery Fee on the customer’s invoice at the time of sale. On April 1, 2022, the California Battery Fee will increase to $2.
From April 1, 2017 until April 1, 2022, a $1 fee is imposed on a manufacturer for each lead-acid battery sold at retail in California. The manufacturer is required to remit the fees to the CDTFA at the time the return is required to be filed. A manufacturer is the person who manufactures the lead-acid battery and who sells, offers for sale, or distributes the lead-acid battery in the state. If no person, as described above, is subject to the state’s jurisdiction, the manufacturer is the person who imports the lead-acid battery into the state for sale or distribution.
Any Manufacturer Battery Fee paid is credited against amounts owed to the state pursuant to a judgment or determination of liability or any other law for removal, remediation or other response costs related to a lead-acid battery recycling facility hazardous waste release. Manufacturers are limited to one credit for the same fee amount.
The vast majority of lead-acid battery manufacturers are located out of state. There are four lead-acid battery manufacturers in California, while roughly 85% of all lead-acid batteries are made outside California.
Funds from both fees are used by DTSC for the investigation, site evaluation, cleanup, removal, monitoring or other response actions at any area in the state that may have been contaminated by the operation of a lead-acid battery recycling facility.
- Prior Legislation. AB 1663 (C. Garcia), of the 2017-18 Legislative Session, would have allowed an out-of-state lead-acid battery manufacturer, not subject to the $1 battery fee, to pay the fee on behalf of an importer and claim the associated credits to offset potential hazardous waste liability. The bill was later amended with unrelated content and referred to the Senate Rules Committee without further action.
Analysis Prepared by: Jennifer Galehouse / APPR. / (916) 319-2081
Date of Hearing: March 12, 2019
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON ENVIRONMENTAL SAFETY AND TOXIC MATERIALS
Bill Quirk, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 142 (
Author:Cristina Garcia) – As Amended Ver:February 25, 2019
SUBJECT: Lead-acid batteries
SUMMARY: Increases the Manufacturer Battery Fee and makes other changes to the Lead-Acid Battery Recycling Act (Act) of 2016. Specifically, this bill:
- Revises the definition of "manufacturer" to state that a person who manufactures a lead-acid battery is subject to the jurisdiction of the state with respect to a lead-acid battery if the person is engaged in business in this state, including a "retailer engaged in business in this state," as defined, with respect to that lead-acid battery.
- States that if a new car dealer sells or leases to a person a used vehicle into which the new car dealer has incorporated a replacement lead-acid battery, the California Battery Fee shall not apply to the person with regard to that replacement lead-acid battery.
- Authorizes a person who manufactures a lead-acid battery and who is not subject to the jurisdiction of the state to agree in writing with the importer of that lead-acid battery to pay the Manufacturer Battery Fee on behalf of the importer.
- Requires a person who pays the Manufacturer Battery Fee on behalf of an importer to be credited for that payment, if the person does all of the following:
- Submits to the jurisdiction of the state for purposes of the fees imposed under the Act and registers with the California Department of Tax and Fee Administration (CDTFA) to pay and remit the manufacturer battery fee;
- Provides to the purchaser a statement on the invoice, contract, or other record documenting the transaction that includes the following information:
- The person’s manufacturer account number with CDTFA;
- An identification of the lead-acid battery or batteries sold that will be subject to the manufacturer battery fee; and,
- A statement that the person will pay the manufacturer battery fee to the state on behalf of the importer;
- Retains records sufficient to document that the lead-acid battery for which the person has agreed to pay the manufacturer battery fee was delivered for retail sale in California, the identity of the purchaser of that battery, and that the statement was provided to the purchaser of the battery in a timely manner; and,
- Requires the person to retain these records for a period of no less than four years and to make the records reasonably available to CDTFA upon request.
- Requires a purchaser of a lead-acid battery who receives a timely statement from a manufacturer, and any subsequent purchaser of that battery, to be relieved from any obligation related to the Manufacturer Battery Fee on the sale of that battery, provided that the manufacturer remits payment of the Manufacturer Battery Fee to the state for the sale of that battery. Requires that a statement shall be considered timely if it is issued before the manufacturer bills the purchaser for the lead-acid battery, within the manufacturer’s normal billing and payment cycle, before delivery of the battery to the purchaser, or before the date on which a return would be due.
- Authorizes an importer who has paid the Manufacturer Battery Fee for a lead-acid battery and who subsequently receives an untimely statement that the fee has been paid for that battery to file a claim for a refund for any overpaid fees.
- Requires, on or before January 1, 2021, CDTFA to submit to the Legislature a report relating to persons who have paid the Manufacturer Battery Fee on behalf of an importer. Requires the report to include, but not be limited to, all of the following information:
- Any regulations or policies adopted by CDTFA for the purposes of ensuring compliance with the registration, returns, reporting, payments, audits, refunds, or collection requirements related to the manufacturer battery fee;
- The revenue impact as determined by the revenues paid or collected compared to the estimated revenue amount calculated by the Senate Committee on Appropriations in its analysis of the fiscal impact of Assembly Bill 2153 (C. Garcia, Chapter 666, Statutes of 2016), adjusted as deemed appropriate by the CDTFA to account for differences in reporting periods and to account for exemptions or exclusions that were not previously accounted for in that analysis or that were enacted after January 1, 2018; and,
- The fiscal impact of the Manufacturer Battery Fee, including costs required to ensure compliance, costs related to audits, refunds, and administering regulations, and estimated cost savings.
- Deletes the sunset on the $1 Manufacturer Battery Fee and increases the fee to $2 in perpetuity effective April 1, 2022.
- States that a person is not required to register as a manufacturer of lead-acid batteries if the person has an agreement or agreements with a manufacturer or manufacturers of lead-acid batteries pursuant to which the manufacturer or manufacturers agree to pay the Manufacturer Battery Fee on behalf of the person and the agreement or agreements apply to all lead-acid batteries sold by the person.
- Authorizes CDTFA to disclose the name, address, account number, and account status of a person registered with CDTFA required to pay the Manufacturer Battery Fee. Prohibits the account status from including the amount of the Manufacturer Battery Fee paid by any person.
- States that funds from the Lead-Acid Battery Cleanup Fund (Fund) can only be used for repayment of a loan to clean up the Exide Technologies (Exide) remediation site after the other eligible expenses for the Fund are paid first.
- Makes technical changes to update the Board of Equalization’s name to CDTFA.
- Establishes these statutory changes as an urgency act in order to increase the cleanup of toxic materials and to prevent additional toxic pollution at the earliest possible time. Provides that it is necessary that these provisions take effect immediately.
EXISTING LAW:
Pursuant to the Lead-Acid Battery Recycling Act of 2016 (Health & Safety Code (HSC) § 25215, et seq):
- Requires, on and after April 1, 2017, until March 31, 2022, a California Battery Fee of $1 to be imposed on a person for each replacement lead-acid battery purchased from a dealer. Requires, on and after April 1, 2022, the amount of the California Battery Fee to increase to $2. (HSC § 25215.25)
- Requires each manufacturer to remit to the CDTFA a $1 Manufacturer Battery Fee for each lead-acid battery sold at retail to a person in California. Sunsets the Manufacturer Battery Fee on April 1, 2022. (HSC § 25215.35)
- Requires all California Battery Fee and Manufacturer Battery Fee revenues be remitted to the CDTFA for administration of the fee and the remainder to be deposited into the Fund. (HSC § 25215.5)
FISCAL EFFECT: Unknown.
COMMENTS:
Need for the bill: According to the author,
"Since the [AB 2153] was signed into law, the Board of Equalization (BOE), now the California Department of Tax and Fee Administration (CDTFA), has been working on regulations to implement the fee collection and technical problems have been identified. Exide and the other communities with historic lead-acid battery manufacturing plants have a great need for ongoing funding and to ensure that the battery fee money can only be used for its intended purpose.
AB 142 addresses three technical problems that were identified: 1) Will clarify that out of state Manufacturers can elect to register with the CDTFA to pay a $1 fee on all batteries sold in the state; 2) This bill will also allow the CDTFA to post who is a registered manufacture on their webpage, this is similar to other fee programs that the CDTFA administers; and, 3) It also clarifies that the consumer fee shall not apply to any person when a replacement lead-acid battery is included in any used vehicle sold or leased by a new motor vehicle dealer.
This bill also addresses two other key issues. It will remove the April 1, 2022, sunset from the manufacturer battery fee, and increase the manufacturer battery fee from $1 to $2 to match the consumer fee, and only allow the repayment of the $176.6 million dollar loan once the clean-up of Exide and other areas of the state that may be contaminated by lead acid batteries has been completed."
Lead: Lead is a toxic metal that does not break down in the environment and accumulates in the human body. Exposures to lead can lead to a number of health problems, including: behavioral problems, learning disabilities, joint and muscle weakness, anemia, organ failure, and even death. Lead has been listed under California's Proposition 65 since 1987 as a substance that can cause reproductive damage and birth defects and has been on the list of chemicals known to cause cancer since 1992.
Lead-acid batteries: State and federal governments have passed laws and regulations to reduce human exposure to lead. As a result of these changes in statute, leaded gasoline in automobiles has been phased out; lead solder in cans has been eliminated; lead-based paint for consumer uses, such as housing, has been banned; lead-based paint abatement activities in housing and other buildings is required; and, people are encouraged to recycle batteries, including lead-acid batteries.
Lead-acid batteries constitute an important contributor to lead in the environment. Statute prohibits the disposal of lead-acid batteries at a solid waste facility, or on or in any land, surface waters, watercourses, or marine waters (HSC § 25215.2). It also requires retailers to accept the trade-in of a spent lead-acid battery by a consumer upon purchase of a new one (HSC § 25215.3).
Lead-acid battery recycling facilities, or secondary lead smelters, bring with them the potential for threats to public health from lead poisoning. The recycling process includes: crushing the batteries, draining the sulfuric acid, and smelting the remaining lead material in large furnaces. The furnaces require extensive air pollution control systems to meet current air pollution control requirements. However, some of these secondary lead smelters have been operating for more than 50 years, before any air pollution control requirements existed, and without controls. DTSC estimates that each of these older smelters emitted one ton of lead particles into the air each hour. The particles would land on nearby residential properties, potentially mixing with lead dust from automobile exhaust, lead based paint residues, and lead from other industrial operations.
As a result, there is historical pollution from lead-acid battery smelters all around California that needs to be cleaned up to protect the public from the known and irreparable dangers of lead.
Inception of the Act: The Lead-Acid Battery Recycling Facility Investigation and Cleanup Program was established pursuant to Assembly Bill 2153 (C. Garcia, Chapter 666, Statutes of 2016), which became the Lead-Acid Battery Recycling Act of 2016 (Act).
The Manufacturer Battery Fee and California Battery Fee on lead-acid batteries sold in the state are deposited into the Fund created by the Act. The Fund is a dedicated source to pay for cleanup of the Exide battery recycling site in Vernon, California, and at other contaminated sites. The Act also provides that manufacturers paying the fee receive a one-time credit equal to the amount each has paid against any future judgement of legal responsibility for a share of those cleanup costs.
Beginning on and after April 1, 2017, and until April 1, 2022, a $1 fee is imposed on a manufacturer for each lead-acid battery sold at retail to a person in California, or that is sold to a dealer, wholesaler, distributor, or other person for retail sale in California. The manufacturer is required to remit the fees to the CDTFA at the time the return is required to be filed.
Exide Technologies: The Exide battery recycling facility in Vernon, California, recycled lead from used automotive batteries and other sources. The facility could process about 25,000 automotive and industrial batteries a day, providing a source of lead for new batteries. Over the course of decades of operation, the facility polluted the soil beneath it with high levels of lead, arsenic, cadmium, and other toxic metals. It also contaminated groundwater, released battery acid onto roads, and contaminated homes and yards in surrounding communities with lead emissions. In March, 2015, Exide was forced to close the facility.
Properties up to 1.3 and 1.7 miles away from the facility are impacted by Exide's lead contamination, which amounts to upwards of 10,000 properties. According to DTSC, cleaning each home costs about $60,000 (an increase from the previously $45,000 anticipated cost per property). DTSC has sampled 8,527 properties to-date; 7,733 properties have exceeded the screening level of 80 parts per million (ppm), meaning about 90% of all properties tested for lead will require remediation. Removing lead-contaminated soil from thousands of homes surrounding Exide could result in the most extensive cleanup of its kind in California and will be among the largest cleanup ever conducted in the nation.
On April 20, 2016, Governor Jerry Brown signed AB 118 (Santiago, Chapter 10, Statutes of 2016) and SB 93 (De Léon, Chapter 9, Statutes of 2016), appropriating a $176.6 million loan from the General Fund to the Toxic Substances Control Account (TSCA) to enable DTSC to test properties, schools, daycare centers, and parks in the 1.7 mile radius and remove contaminated soil at the properties that have the highest lead levels and greatest potential exposure to residents.
Cleanup costs initially incurred by the state will ultimately be sought from the parties responsible for the lead contamination (Exide). DTSC will need funds to pay for the work while it seeks additional money from Exide and other responsible parties.
After the $176.6 million is expended, DTSC will need additional funds for a complete and thorough cleanup. AB 2153 authorized use of the fee revenues in the Fund to fill that gap and repay the state loan (HSC § 25215.59) while providing an ongoing source of funds to address lead contamination from lead-acid batteries.
Governor Newsom, in his proposed Fiscal Year (FY) 2019-2020 Budget, included an additional $75 million General Fund one-time loans to accelerate the cleanup of additional properties within a 1.7-mile radius of the facility over the next two years. Of that, $50 million would allow DTSC to clean up approximately 700 additional high-risk properties in which lead contamination exceeds the state standard of 80 parts per million, and $25 million would be used to continue cleaning up previously identified sites contaminated by Exide facility.
Areas potentially contaminated by lead-acid battery recycling: AB 2153 requires DTSC to annually report to the Legislature on the status of DTSC’s progress on implementing the Act and how it plans to spend revenues from the Fund on site remediation at other lead smelter sites.
In DTSC’s first report from February 2018, DTSC describes its collaboration with the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency Region 9 (EPA Region 9) to evaluate previous and current lead-acid battery recycling facilities in California. This evaluation focused on 39 former lead smelter sites identified from a comprehensive review of site investigation and cleanup records maintained by both EPA Region 9 and DTSC, including DTSC’s EnviroStor database.
Based on an initial review of the 39 sites, DTSC selected 18 potentially contaminated sites for a more thorough assessment, using available information to determine if further investigation, cleanup, or other appropriate actions are needed to protect public health. DTSC also evaluated areas around these sites to assess potential health impacts to schools, parks, and residential properties. Based on the assessment of the potential threat to public health and the environment, DTSC prioritized four of the 18 sites for investigation and potential remedial action in FY 2018-2019.
These other facilities may have operated and closed before environmental regulatory programs were established. DTSC has noted that although these secondary lead smelters may not precisely meet the definition of lead-acid battery recycling facility pursuant to AB 2153, it is possible that some or all of these historical smelters do meet the facility definition in the Act.
DTSC is researching the historical smelting facilities and gathering additional information on each of these facilities to ascertain the scope and nature of their operations and their impact on the surrounding communities. If any of these facilities meet the definition of a lead-acid battery recycling facility, they would be subject to investigation and cleanup by DTSC. The Fund created by AB 2153 would bear the initial cost of this effort if the Legislature appropriates funds for these activities.
Statutorily authorized uses of the Fund revenues: Under current law, CDTFA collects all fees and retains sufficient funds necessary to cover its administrative costs to collect the fee. Once those costs are deducted, the remaining fees are deposited into the Fund, which are then available upon appropriation by the Legislature.
AB 2153 specified that monies from the Fund shall be expended for the following activities:
- Investigation, site evaluation, cleanup, remedial action, removal, monitoring, or other response actions at any area of the state that is reasonably suspected to have been contaminated by the operation of a lead-acid battery recycling facility;
- State administrative costs; and,
- Repayment of the $176.6 million General Fund loan to cleanup Exide.
A symbolic gesture to fee payers: This bill includes language that states that revenues from the Fund can only be used for repayment of a loan to clean up Exide after the other eligible expenses for this Fund (investigation and site cleanup, administration of the Act), are initially paid.
Though the law specifies eligible expenditures of the fee revenues, AB 2153 was approved by a 2/3 vote of the Legislature due to an urgency clause in the bill. However, that vote threshold effectively rendered the fee a tax, which loosens the restraints for what the fee revenues can be spent.
This language is intended to clarify legislative intent and restrict spending for non-lead-acid battery pollution related expenditures, even if it can be overridden by future legislatures.
Revenue projections and need: Since 2017 when the fees went into effect, the Fund accrued $17.2 million in FY 2017-2018, $19.6 million in FY 2018-2019, and, according to the Department of Finance, another $19.6 million is projected for FY 2019-2020.
To keep track of who is paying what and how much, AB 142 requires CDTFA to report to the Legislature by January 1, 2021, and outline the revenue impact determined by revenues collected compared against the revenue estimate from the August 11, 2016, Senate Appropriations Committee analysis for AB 2153, which predicted the Fund would generate "up to $32 million in revenue from the fee assessment" -- a far cry from the current $19 million projections.
Projections are important so DTSC can project revenue needs for implementing the Act.
DTSC is expected to release its next annual report to the Legislature, as required by AB 2153, in March, 2019, which will provide more information on DTSC’s planned implementation efforts to identify and clean up lead pollution from lead-acid battery smelting. The report will also include information on the sites at which actions were performed using moneys from the Fund, the status of cleanup at those sites, including total anticipated costs of cleanup at those sites, the balance of the Fund, the amount of fees remitted to the Fund, the amount spent by the Fund and the purposes for which those amounts were spent, and the amounts reimbursed to CDTFA.
The report should shine a light on DTSC’s resource needs from the Fund for lead contamination cleanup.
Variability in fee collections: The Act requires manufacturers (or an importer on a manufacturer’s behalf) and dealers (retailers who collect and remit the consumer’s California Battery Fee) to collect and remit a $1 fee ($2 in aggregate) on each lead-acid battery sold in California.
Despite the fact a $1 fee is being collected by two entities for the same battery, the remitted amounts vary. For instance, according to CDTFA data, the state is collecting more Manufacturer Battery Fee revenues than California Battery Fee revenues. In Quarter 4 for 2017, $2.75 million in Manufacturer Battery Fees were remitted, while only $1.85 million in the California Battery Fee were remitted. This discrepancy can be attributed to manufacturers paying the fee for every lead-acid battery sold in the state, yet not all lead-acid batteries sold in the state are required to have a consumer fee collected. Pursuant to HSC § 25215.1 (o)(2)(A-E), replacement lead-acid batteries, lead-acid batteries for incorporation into new equipment for subsequent resale, replacement of a lead-acid battery pursuant to a warranty or a vehicle service contract, and the sale of any battery intended for use with or contained within a medical device are all excluded from the fee. In addition, dealers can retain 1.5% of the California Battery Fee to cover their administrative costs (HSC 25215.25 (a)(3)). Therefore, fewer California Battery Fee revenues are collected per battery.
Use of the Fund revenues to-date: The Legislature has appropriated funds to DTSC to set up and administer the Act, which includes development of a framework for implementation of the Act, and funds to CDTFA to set up and administer the Fund, including outreach to and registration of fee payees— battery manufacturers, importers, and dealers.
Additionally, between the FY 2017-2018 and FY 2018-2019 Budget Acts, the Legislature appropriated $26.7 million from the Fund to repay the General Fund Exide loan (as authorized per HSC § 25215.5 (b)(1)(C)). The Governor’s proposed FY 2019-2020 Budget would appropriate $16 million in loan repayment to the General Fund.
There are strong concerns over use of the revenues from the Fund. Loans have been provided to other state accounts unrelated to lead-acid battery clean up, and DTSC has indicated that both of its primary funding accounts (Hazardous Waste Control Account (HWCA) and Toxic Substances Control Account (TSCA)) have large, growing structural deficits.
TSCA provides funds to DTSC to do cleanup at Superfund and state orphan sites (hazardous waste sites without a billable responsible party). DTSC estimates the demand for funding those sites to be $15 - $20 million annually for the next few years from TSCA, though the account only has approximately $10 million in revenues annually. These structural deficits put pressure on the Fund to float funds to those accounts via appropriated loans.
Why increase the fee to $2?: Current law requires both consumers and manufacturers to pay a $1 fee until April 2022. The California Battery Fee then goes up to $2 in April 2022 and the Manufacturer Battery Fee sunsets. AB 142 strikes the 2022 sunset date for the Manufacturer Battery Fee and increases the fees to $2 in perpetuity. Establishing the Manufacturer Battery Fee at $2 creates equity with what consumers will be paying.
Despite concerns over use of the Fund, it is undisputed that ongoing costs to clean up lead pollution from lead-acid battery operations will be ever increasing and ongoing.
The current Fund balance is not enough to pay back the current $176.6 million loan and proposed $75 million additional loans. As it relates to the Governor’s proposed $75 million in loans for Exide cleanup, the Legislative Analysist’s Office recommends the Legislature require a report to discuss any plans to use the Fund to repay these proposed loans, and what Exide’s repayment could mean for the Fund.
Based on rough math, it would take the Fund more than 12 years to accrue enough revenue to pay the three General Fund loans back in full, and an additional 25 years to fund total cleanup (should DTSC not be able to have cost recovery from Exide as the responsible party for the pollution before cleanup is finished).
Notwithstanding Exide and the future loan repayments for those cleanup costs, there are at least 39 other former lead smelter sites, which may require future remediation. Of the four sites that DTSC prioritized from the list of 39, the estimated sampling and removal action costs are $30 million.
The additional $2 fee would theoretically double the Fund’s revenues. This will make a dent in the loan repayments, but is insufficient to do lead remediation at the prioritized four sites, let alone 39, additional lead smelter sites.
Level playing field: AB 142 seeks to address the issue of out-of-state manufacturers paying the Manufacturer’s Battery Fee. The bill allows a lead-acid battery manufacturer not subject to the jurisdiction of the state to enter into a written agreement with the California importer of that lead-acid battery to pay the manufacturer battery fee on behalf of the importer. That out-of-state manufacturer that enters into a written agreement with the importer and who pays the manufacturer battery fee on behalf of the importer will be credited against amounts owed to the state pursuant to a judgment or determination of liability, or any other law for removal, remediation, or other response costs related to hazardous substance release from a lead-acid battery recycling facility. The out-of-state manufacturer will then be credited for that payment if specified conditions are met.
Since an out-of-state manufacturer conducting transactions wholly outside this state would not be subject to this state’s taxing authority, AB 142 creates a mechanism that allows the California importer to agree in writing with the out-of-state manufacturer to pay the Manufacturer Battery Fee for those batteries imported in this state on behalf of the importer. The bill keeps intact the manufacturer and importer’s ultimate responsibility for registration, reporting, and payment of the Manufacturer Battery Fee.
The vast majority of lead-acid battery manufacturers are located out-of-state. There are four lead-acid battery manufacturers in California, while roughly 85% of all lead-acid batteries are made outside California.
AB 142 will ensure the Manufacturer Battery Fee is paid for each lead-acid battery sold in California, but it also gives out-of-state manufacturers a way to 'buy in' credits for their legal liability should they be found liable for remediation costs.
Allowing another person to pay a tax or fee for another person is not unique: CDTFA administers more than 30 different tax and fee programs and has experienced unique industry compliance issues that have necessitated allowing another person the ability to pay the tax or fee for another person. There have been other instances in which a clear policy issue has required a change in statute or regulation to allow another person to pay a tax or fee for another.
Arguments in support: The Los Angeles County Board of Supervisors states, "The County's Department of Public Health (DPH) notes that the County is home to two of the largest battery recycling facilities in California: Exide in the City of Vernon and Quemetco, Inc. in the City of Industry. The increased revenue from AB 142 would increase the funds available for clean-up efforts at contaminated sites across the State. DPH indicates that contaminated sites create a health equity issue, because at-risk communities at risk of lead exposure are predominantly communities of color, and those residents experience underlying health inequities and contend with exposure to multiple environmental hazards."
Arguments in opposition: Battery Council International states that it, "opposes the passage of AB 142 as an urgency measure unless amended because it proposes to double the fee imposed upon battery manufacturers before the full revenue potential is established. It is premature to increase the existing fee level before CDTFA establishes if its current implementation efforts are resulting in under-collection of fee revenues and DTSC develops a spending plan consistent with the purposes of the statute."
Related legislation:
- AB 1663 (C. Garcia, 2017). Would have amended the Act to clarify provisions related to an out-of-state lead-acid battery manufacturer's financial responsibilities. Specifically, would have authorized a person who manufacturers a lead-acid battery and is not subject to the jurisdiction of the state and who agrees in writing with the importer of that lead-acid battery to pay the Manufacturer Battery Fee imposed on behalf of the importer. The bill was later amended with unrelated content.
- AB 2153 (C. Garcia, Chapter 666, Statutes of 2016). Enacted the Act.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
California Communities Against Toxics
California New Car Dealers Association
California Safe Schools
Coalition for a Safe Environment
Desert Citizens Against Pollution
Los Angeles County Board of Supervisors
Mothers of East Los Angeles
PROUNO
South Coast Air Quality Management District
Opposition
AutoCare Association
Battery Council International
California Automotive Wholesalers' Association
California Retailers Association
Motor and Equipment Manufacturers Association
National Marine Manufacturers Association
Analysis Prepared by: Paige Brokaw / E.S. & T.M. /
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):