AB 1422: Hate crimes: homeless status.
- Session Year: 2019-2020
- House: Assembly
- Latest Version Date: 2019-02-22
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Feb 3, 2020 | From committee: Filed with the Chief Clerk pursuant to Joint Rule 56. |
| Jan 31, 2020 | Died pursuant to Art. IV, Sec. 10(c) of the Constitution. |
| Jan 14, 2020 | In committee: Set, second hearing. Hearing canceled at the request of author. |
| Apr 23, 2019 | In committee: Set, first hearing. Failed passage. Reconsideration granted. |
| Mar 14, 2019 | Referred to Com. on PUB. S. |
| Feb 25, 2019 | Read first time. |
| Feb 23, 2019 | From printer. May be heard in committee March 25. |
| Feb 22, 2019 | Introduced. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Apr 23, 2019 | Reconsideration. | Assembly Standing Committee on Public Safety |
Passed |
|
| Apr 23, 2019 | Do pass and be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Assembly Standing Committee on Public Safety |
Failed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
Date of Hearing: April 23, 2019
Counsel: Matthew Fleming
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON PUBLIC SAFETY
Reginald Byron Jones-Sawyer, Sr., Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 1422
Author:(Gipson) – As Introduced Ver:February 22, 2019
SUMMARY:
Makes it a hate crime if a crime was committed in whole or in part because of the victim’s actual or perceived “homeless status.” Specifically, this bill:
- Adds “homeless status” to the list of people covered by hate crimes laws.
- Defines “homeless status” to mean an individual’s lack of a fixed, regular, and adequate nighttime residence, or an individual’s use of a primary nighttime residence that is one of the following:
- A supervised shelter, either publicly or privately operated, that is designed to provide temporary living accommodations, including, but not limited to, welfare hotels, congregate shelters, and transitional housing for persons with a mental illness;
- An institution that provides a temporary residence for individuals who are intended to be institutionalized; or,
- A public or private place not designed for, or ordinarily used as, a regular sleeping accommodation for human beings.
- A supervised shelter, either publicly or privately operated, that is designed to provide temporary living accommodations, including, but not limited to, welfare hotels, congregate shelters, and transitional housing for persons with a mental illness;
- Specifies that “homeless status” does not include a person who is imprisoned or otherwise involuntarily detained pursuant to state or federal law.
EXISTING LAW:
- Defines "hate crime" as any criminal act committed, in whole or in part, because of one or more of the following actual or perceived characteristics of the victim:
- Disability;
- Gender;
- Nationality;
- Race or ethnicity;
- Religion;
- Sexual orientation; and,
- Association with a person or group with one or more of these actual or perceived characteristics. (Pen. Code, § 422.55, subd. (a).)
- Disability;
- Provides that it is a hate crime to violate or interfere with the exercise of civil rights, or knowingly deface, destroy, or damage property because of actual or perceived characteristics of the victim that fit the hate crime definition. (Pen. Code, § 422.6, subds. (a) and (b).)
- Provides that a conviction for violating or interfering with the civil rights of another of the basis of actual or perceived characteristics of the victim that fit the hate crime definition shall be punished by imprisonment in a county jail not to exceed one year, or by a fine not to exceed five thousand dollars ($5,000), or by both the above imprisonment and fine, and the court shall order the defendant to perform a minimum of community service, not to exceed 400 hours, to be performed over a period not to exceed 350 days, during a time other than his or her hours of employment or school attendance. (Pen. Code, § 422.6, subd. (c).)
- Provides that a person who commits a felony that is a hate crime by virtue of the fact it was committed in whole or in part because of actual or perceived characteristics that fit the hate crime definition, or attempts to do so, shall receive an additional term of one, two, or three years in the state prison, at the court's discretion. (Pen. Code, § 422.75, subd. (a).)
- Provides that a person who commits a felony that is a hate crime by virtue of the fact it was committed in whole or in part because of actual or perceived characteristics that fit the hate crime definition, or attempts to do so, except as specified, and who voluntarily acted in concert with another person in the commission of the crime shall receive an additional term of two, three, or four years in the state prison, at the court's discretion. (Pen. Code, § 422.75, subd. (b).)
- Provides that a person who commits first-degree murder that is a hate crime shall be punished by imprisonment in the state prison for life without the possibility of parole. (Pen. Code, § 190.03, subd. (a).)
FISCAL EFFECT:
Unknown
COMMENTS:
- Author's Statement: According to the author, “Across California, there have been increasing cases of which the homeless have been victims of crimes such as: aggravated assault, robbery, rape and homicide. This has become a common, unacceptable tone of hate for our state’s most vulnerable community. We allow those with property an amount of protection for that very property, yet for our homeless brothers and sisters, while they already struggle to find safe places to rest day-to-day, there are basic inefficiencies in providing them with the security that is awarded to those who are more fortunate. They’re left vulnerable to deplorable acts of abuse by those deliberately targeting them due to circumstances shared by more and more of those in our communities across the state do to its high cost of living. We need to lead the way to maintain a fixed focus on elevating the most vulnerable, not on excluding those who are most in need of solutions to provide them reasonable protection against those who specifically prey on them.”
- Crimes Against the Homeless: The National Coalition for the Homeless (NCH) has documented 1,769 acts of violence against homeless individuals by housed perpetrators over nearly 20 years. (NCH, Vulnerable to Hate, Dec., 2018, https://nationalhomeless.org/wp-content/uploads/2019/01/hate-crimes-2016-17-final_for-web2.pdf.) According to that organization, these crimes are believed to have been motivated by the perpetrators’ biases against people experiencing homelessness or by their ability to target homeless people with relative ease. (Id. at 4.) Over a period of 18 years the NCH found that 1,758 acts of violence were committed against the homeless, resulting in 476 victims losing their lives. (Ibid.) The NCH found that perpetrators of these attacks were generally male and under the age of 30. (Ibid.) The report provides further detail on state-by-state basis noting that California had 26 such lethal attacks and 11 non-lethal. (Id. at 41.)
- Hate Crime Laws: Hate crimes, referred to in some jurisdictions as “bias crimes,” are generally defined as crimes that are “committed not out of animosity toward the victim as an individual, but out of hostility toward the group to which the victim belongs.” (Pendo, Recognizing Violence Against Women: Gender and the Hate Crimes Statistics Act (1994) 17 Harv. Women's L.J. 157, 159.) Looking at a more specific definition, a hate crime is defined as "a crime in which the defendant intentionally selects a victim because of the actual or perceived race, color, religion, national origin, ethnicity, gender, disability, or sexual orientation of any person." (Violent Crime Control and Law Enforcement Act of 1994, Pub. L. 103-322, 108 Stat. 1796 Section 280003 (1994) emphasis added (codified in part at 28 U.S.C. Section 994 (1994).)
According to the California State Auditor (CSA), hate crimes in California increased by more than 20 percent from 2014 to 2016, from 758 to 931. (CSA, Hate Crimes in California, May, 2018, available at: https://www.auditor.ca.gov/pdfs/reports/2017-131.pdf, [as of Apr. 18, 2019].) More than half of the reported hate crimes were on the basis of race, with crimes against persons on account of their sexual orientation or religion made up most of the other half, with bias crimes due to gender and disability accounting for 2 percent. (Id. at 10.) It must be noted, that the CSA report was based upon all reported hate crimes, not only violent offenses like the NCH Report.
California’s hate crime laws work to protect against the targeting of individuals on account of their actual or perceived belonging to a specific group in two important ways. As an initial matter, it is a misdemeanor offense to interfere with the free exercise of a person’s civil rights on account of their belonging to a protected group. For example, if an employer allows all of his or her Christian workers to vote on Election Day, but denies Jewish workers the same ability, the employer would likely be guilty of interfering with the free exercise of his Jewish worker’s right to vote. It is also a misdemeanor offense to destroy property or use force to accomplish that same sort of interference.
In addition, if a person commits a felony offense against a person in a protected class, and the prosecutor is able to prove that the felony was committed on account of the fact that victim was part of that class, the felon will be subjected to additional punishment. On top of applying the applicable penalty for the underlying felony, there will be an additional one, two, or three year prison term. If the defendant acted in concert with someone else to commit a felony hate crime, the additional punishment is two, three, or four years in state prison. - Immutability: Hate crime perpetrators target their victims based on discrimination against immutable characteristics such as age, disability, gender, national origin, race, sex, and sexual orientation. Immutability can be characterized in one of two ways. Some characteristics, such as age, disability, and race, cannot be altered by an individual's voluntary act. However, other characteristics, such as religion and gender, can only be altered with substantial cost or difficulty to the individual. Although not literally immutable, scholars contend that "the power of a constructed category can be so overwhelming, and its terms, assumptions, and normative social requirements so deeply ingrained into the members of society, that it is experienced at the individual level as immutable." [Marcosson, Constructive Immutability (2001) 3 U. Pa. J. Const. L. 646, 650.] This implies that some characteristics that are entirely possible for individuals to change, such as religion, have such a powerful impact on the construction of individual identity that they effectively operate as if they were unchangeable.
This bill would add “homeless status” to the list of classes that have been identified as being immutable for purposes of California’s hate crimes laws. While being homeless is undoubtedly a challenging and complex problem, it is arguably different from the classes that are currently protected by hate crimes laws. Unlike race, religion, gender, etc., the state, local governments, and community-based organizations are actively attempting to address homelessness by providing food, shelter and services to the homeless population. The City of Sacramento, for example, invests over $3 million in housing and services to help people experiencing homelessness. (http://www.cityofsacramento.org/City-Manager/Divisions-Programs/Homeless-Coordination/What-The-City-is-Doing.) Each session, the Legislature hears dozens of bills that are directed at getting homeless persons off of the street. By contrast, there are no state or local programs dedicated to changing the race, religion, or sexual orientation of California residents, and any such program would likely run afoul of the First Amendment to the United States Constitution. The Legislature has previously rejected attempts to include homeless status, peace officers, and political affiliation in the hate crimes statute. - Prison Overcrowding: In January 2010, a three-judge panel issued a ruling ordering the State of California to reduce its prison population to 137.5% of design capacity because overcrowding was the primary reason that CDCR was unable to provide inmates with constitutionally adequate healthcare. (Coleman/Plata vs. Schwarzenegger (2010) No. Civ S-90-0520 LKK JFM P/NO. C01-1351 THE.) The United State Supreme Court upheld the decision, declaring that “without a reduction in overcrowding, there will be no efficacious remedy for the unconstitutional care of the sick and mentally ill” inmates in California’s prisons. (Brown v. Plata (2011) 131 S.Ct. 1910, 1939; 179 L.Ed.2d 969, 999.)
After continued litigation, on February 10, 2014, the federal court ordered California to reduce its in-state adult institution population to 137.5% of design capacity by February 28, 2016, as follows: 143% of design bed capacity by June 30, 2014; 141.5% of design bed capacity by February 28, 2015; and, 137.5% of design bed capacity by February 28, 2016.
CDCR’s February 2019 monthly report on the prison population notes that the in-state adult institution population is currently 113,656 inmates, which amounts to 133.6% of design capacity. Additionally, there are still 1,463 prisoners being housed out of state. (https://www.cdcr.ca.gov/Reports_Research/Offender_Information_Services_Branch/Monthly/TPOP1A/TPOP1Ad1902.pdf)
The Governor’s January proposed budget for 2019-2020 anticipates that “The average daily adult inmate population is now projected to be 128,334, an increase of 1.1 percent over spring projections. However, current projections show the adult inmate population is trending downward and is expected to decrease by approximately 1,360 offenders between 2018-19 and 2019-20. Proposition 57, the Public Safety and Rehabilitation Act of 2016, established a durable solution to end federal court oversight and create more incentives for inmates to participate in rehabilitative programs. Proposition 57 is currently estimated to reduce the average daily adult inmate population by approximately 6,300 in 2019-20, growing to an inmate reduction of approximately 10,500 in 2021-22. The estimated impact of Proposition 57 has been incorporated into the aforementioned total population projections.” (http://www.ebudget.ca.gov/2019-20/pdf/BudgetSummary/PublicSafety.pdf.)
Thus, while CDCR is currently in compliance with the three-judge panel’s order on the prison population, the state needs to maintain a “durable solution” to prison overcrowding “consistently demanded” by the court. (Opinion Re: Order Granting in Part and Denying in Part Defendants’ Request For Extension of December 31, 2013 Deadline, NO. 2:90-cv-0520 LKK DAD (PC), 3-Judge Court, Coleman v. Brown, Plata v. Brown (2-10-14).)
As mentioned above, one of the effects of adding a protected class to the hate crimes list is that any felony hate crime can be subjected to additional punishment in the state prison. Specifically, a felony hate crime is punishable by an additional term of up to two, three, or four years in the state prison. Unfortunately, many felonies are committed against people who are homeless. Therefore, this bill has the potential to exacerbate California’s prison overcrowding issues. - Argument in Support: According to Disability Rights California, “ Existing law makes specified criminal acts punishable as a hate crime if it is committed in whole or in part because of one or more actual or perceived designated characteristics of the victim, including disability, gender, nationality, race or ethnicity, religion, or sexual orientation. This bill would add “homeless status,” as defined, to the list of hate crime categories.
“The number of attacks against persons experiencing homelessness nationwide has increased over the years, even though crimes against the homeless are reported at lower rates than other crimes. California has had serious and unaddressed problems of crime against homeless persons, including homeless persons with disabilities. In its 2016-17 annual report, for example, the National Coalition for the Homeless (NCH) documented 112 violent attacks against homeless individuals across 30 states, 48 of which resulted in death. NCH notes that “[a]n astonishing 33% of attacks reported in 2016-2017 took place in California.” Several jurisdictions including Florida, Maryland, Maine and Washington D.C., have enacted laws making attacks on homeless people a hate crime. It is time that California follow suit.”
- Argument in Opposition: According to the Anti-Defamation League, “Founded in 1913, ADL (Anti-Defamation League) is the nation’s leading anti-hate and human relations organization, combating anti-Semitism and all forms of bigotry, discrimination, and extremism. ADL drafted the nation’s first model hate crime statute in the early 1980s. To date, 45 states plus Washington DC have adopted hate crime laws, mostly based on ADL’s model, and we continue to advocate for effective legislation wherever needed. Federally, we led the multiyear coalition effort to achieve passage of the landmark Matthew Shepard and James Byrd, Jr., Hate Crimes Prevention Act in 2009. Today, ADL is the leading non-governmental organization training law enforcement in all aspects of hate crime, including investigations, reporting, and community engagement.
“Hate crime laws are designed to enhance penalties for crimes committed because of the victim’s immutable, or core, personal characteristic. As defined in Penal Code Section 422.56, they are disability, gender, nationality, race or ethnicity, religion, and sexual orientation. These are fundamental personal traits which an individual either cannot, or should not have to, change or hide to be free from targeted and violent bigotry. Homelessness, by contrast, is a status and a challenge that society needs to solve. Notably unlike the existing categories, it is not a core or immutable personal trait, and an individual’s homelessness status should indeed be changed. As such, crimes against homeless individuals are not what hate crime laws were designed to address.
“We are also concerned about the counterproductive impact that could result should the Legislature expand the hate crime law to include a mutable and, one hopes, short-lived status such as homelessness. To wit, hate crime convictions are notoriously challenging to attain because of the high burden of proof – prosecutors must prove the offender’s subjective bias motivation for selecting the victim beyond a reasonable doubt. This is far higher than a mere general intent standard, or the even higher specific intent standard, that the Penal Code usually demands.”
- Prior Legislation:
- AB 2 (Obernolte), of the 2017 - 2018 Legislative Session, would have made any crime, except the crime of resisting arrest, a hate crime if it was committed in whole or in part because of the victim’s status as a peace officer. AB 2 failed passage in the Assembly Public Safety Committee.
- AB 39 (Bocanegra), of the 2017 – 2018 Legislative Session, would have required local law enforcement agencies to forward a summary of any hate crime to the human relations commission in their jurisdiction. AB 39 died in the Assembly Appropriations Committee.
- AB 246 (Rodriguez), of the 2015 – 2016 Legislative Session, would have made the assassination, rape, and kidnap, as well as an attempt to commit these crimes, a hate crime when the crime is committed against a peace officer or an immediate family member and the crime was knowingly committed because of that status. AB 246 died in the Assembly Appropriations Committee.
- AB 1206 (Miller), of the 2008-2009 Legislative Session, would have added political affiliation to the list of classes in the hate crimes statute. AB 1206 was never heard in committee.
- SB 122 (Steinberg), of the 2007 – 2008 Legislative Session, was identical to this bill and would have made it a hate crime if a crime was committed in whole or in part because of the victim’s actual or perceived homeless status. SB 122 died in the Senate Public Safety Committee.
- AB 2 (Obernolte), of the 2017 - 2018 Legislative Session, would have made any crime, except the crime of resisting arrest, a hate crime if it was committed in whole or in part because of the victim’s status as a peace officer. AB 2 failed passage in the Assembly Public Safety Committee.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
AIDS Healthcare Foundation
California Association of Human Relations Organizations
Center for the Study of Hate & Extremism
Disability Rights California
Green Party of Sacramento County
National Coalition for the Homeless
Sacramento Regional Coalition to End Homelessness
Southern Poverty Law Center
Oppose
Anti-Defamation League
California Public Defenders Association
Santa Clara County District Attorney
Yolo County District Attorney
Analysis Prepared by:
Matthew Fleming / PUB. S. / (916) 319-3744
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):