AB 1507: Charter schools: location: resource center.
- Session Year: 2019-2020
- House: Assembly
- Latest Version Date: 2019-10-03
(1)Existing law authorizes a charter school that is unable to locate within the jurisdiction or geographic boundaries of the chartering school district to establish one site outside the boundaries of the school district, but within the county in which that school district is located, if the school district where the charter school proposes to operate is notified in advance of the charter petition approval, the county superintendent of schools is notified of the location of the charter school before it commences operations, and either the charter school has attempted to locate a single site or facility to house the entire program, but a site or facility is unavailable in the area in which the school chooses to locate, or the site is needed for temporary use during a construction or expansion project.
This bill would delete the authority of a charter school to locate outside the jurisdiction or geographic boundaries of the chartering school district because the charter school has attempted to locate a single site or facility to house the entire program, but a site or facility is unavailable in the area in which the charter school chooses to locate, or the site is needed for temporary use during a construction or expansion project. The bill would authorize a charter school that established one site outside the boundaries of the school district, but within the county in which that school district is located before January 1, 2020, to continue to operate that site until the charter school submits a request for the renewal of its charter petition, and would authorize a charter school to continue operating that site if, before submitting the request for the renewal of the charter petition, the charter school first obtains written approval from the school district where the site is operating. The bill would authorize a charter school to relocate for not more than 5 years a site located within an area subject to a Presidential declaration of a major disaster or emergency, issued in accordance with federal law, to an area outside the area subject to the Presidential declaration, as specified. The bill would require a charter school to be allowed to return to its original campus location in perpetuity if that charter school was relocated from December 31, 2016, through December 31, 2019, due to a Presidential declaration of a major disaster or emergency in accordance with federal law. The bill would exempt from the above-described charter school location provisions a charter school located on a federally recognized California Indian reservation or rancheria and or operated by a federally recognized California Indian tribe. The bill would require the State Department of Education to regard a charter school approved pursuant to the above-described provisions as a continuing charter school for all purposes.
(2)Existing law authorizes a charter school to establish a resource center, meeting space, or other satellite facility located in a county adjacent to the county in which the charter school is authorized if specified conditions are met.
This bill instead would authorize a charter school to establish one resource center, meeting space, or other satellite facility within the jurisdiction of the school district where the charter school is physically located if specified conditions are met, except as specified. The bill would require a charter school to notify the charter schools chartering authority of the name and physical location of any resource center, meeting space, or satellite facility operated utilized by the charter school. The bill would prohibit the State Board of Education from waiving those restrictions on the establishment of a resource center, meeting space, or satellite facility.
This bill would authorize a charter school or a countywide charter school that was operating a resource center, meeting space, or other satellite facility outside the jurisdiction of the school district or county, respectively, where the charter school is physically located before January 1, 2020, to continue to operate that resource center, meeting space, or other satellite facility until the charter school submits a request for the renewal of its charter petition, and would authorize a charter school to continue operating that resource center, meeting space, or other satellite facility if, before submitting the request for the renewal of the charter petition, the charter school first obtains written approval from the school district or the county office of education, as appropriate, where the resource center, meeting space, or other satellite facility is operating. The bill would authorize a charter school to relocate for not more than 5 years a resource center, meeting space, or other satellite facility located within an area subject to a Presidential declaration of a major disaster or emergency, issued in accordance with federal law, to an area outside the area subject to the Presidential declaration, as specified. The bill would authorize a charter school to establish additional resource centers, meetings spaces, or other satellite facilities within the jurisdiction of the charter schools chartering authority if specified conditions are met.
This bill would make a conforming change.
(a)(1)Except as set forth in paragraph (2), a petition for the establishment of a charter school within a school district may be circulated by one or more persons seeking to establish the charter school. A petition for the establishment of a charter school shall identify a single charter school that will operate within the geographic boundaries of that school district. A charter school may propose to operate at multiple sites within the school district if each location is identified in the charter school petition. The petition may be submitted to the governing board of the school district for review after either of the following conditions is met:
(A)The petition is signed by a number of parents or legal guardians of pupils that is equivalent to at least one-half of the number of pupils that the charter school estimates will enroll in the charter school for its first year of operation.
(B)The petition is signed by a number of teachers that is equivalent to at least one-half of the number of teachers that the charter school estimates will be employed at the charter school during its first year of operation.
(2)A petition that proposes to convert an existing public school to a charter school that would not be eligible for a loan pursuant to subdivision (c) of Section 41365 may be circulated by one or more persons seeking to establish the charter school. The petition may be submitted to the governing board of the school district for review after the petition is signed by not less than 50 percent of the permanent status teachers currently employed at the public school to be converted.
(3)A petition shall include a prominent statement that a signature on the petition means that the parent or legal guardian is meaningfully interested in having their child or ward attend the charter school, or in the case of a teachers signature, means that the teacher is meaningfully interested in teaching at the charter school. The proposed charter shall be attached to the petition.
(4)After receiving approval of its petition, a charter school that proposes to establish operations at one or more additional sites shall request a material revision to its charter and shall notify the authority that granted its charter of those additional locations. The authority that granted its charter shall consider whether to approve those additional locations at an open, public meeting. If the additional locations are approved, they shall be a material revision to the charter schools charter.
(5)(A)A charter school that established one site outside the boundaries of the school district, but within the county in which that school district is located before January 1, 2020, may continue to operate that site until the charter school submits a request for the renewal of its charter petition. To continue operating the site, the charter school, before submitting the request for the renewal of the charter petition, shall first obtain approval in writing from the school district where the site is operating.
(B)If a Presidential declaration of a major disaster or emergency is issued in accordance with the federal Robert T. Stafford Disaster Relief and Emergency Assistance Act (42 U.S.C. Sec. 5121 et seq.) for an area in which a charter schoolsite is located and operating, the charter school, for not more than five years, may relocate that site outside the area subject to the Presidential declaration if the charter school first obtains the written approval of the school district where the site is being relocated to.
(C)Notwithstanding subparagraph (A), if a charter school was relocated from December 31, 2016, to December 31, 2019, inclusive, due to a Presidential declaration of a major disaster or emergency in accordance with the federal Robert T. Stafford Disaster Relief and Emergency Assistance Act (42 U.S.C. Sec. 5121 et seq.), that charter school shall be allowed to return to its original campus location in perpetuity.
(D)A charter school located on a federally recognized California Indian reservation or rancheria and or operated by a federally recognized California Indian tribe shall be exempt from the provisions of this paragraph.
(E)The department shall regard a charter school approved pursuant to this paragraph as a continuing charter school for all purposes.
(6)Commencing January 1, 2003, a petition to establish a charter school shall not be approved to serve pupils in a grade level that is not served by the school district of the governing board considering the petition, unless the petition proposes to serve pupils in all of the grade levels served by that school district.
(b)No later than 30 days after receiving a petition, in accordance with subdivision (a), the governing board of the school district shall hold a public hearing on the provisions of the charter, at which time the governing board of the school district shall consider the level of support for the petition by teachers employed by the school district, other employees of the school district, and parents. Following review of the petition and the public hearing, the governing board of the school district shall either grant or deny the charter within 60 days of receipt of the petition, provided, however, that the date may be extended by an additional 30 days if both parties agree to the extension. In reviewing petitions for the establishment of charter schools pursuant to this section, the chartering authority shall be guided by the intent of the Legislature that charter schools are and should become an integral part of the California educational system and that the establishment of charter schools should be encouraged. The governing board of the school district shall grant a charter for the operation of a school under this part if it is satisfied that granting the charter is consistent with sound educational practice. The governing board of the school district shall not deny a petition for the establishment of a charter school unless it makes written factual findings, specific to the particular petition, setting forth specific facts to support one or more of the following findings:
(1)The charter school presents an unsound educational program for the pupils to be enrolled in the charter school.
(2)The petitioners are demonstrably unlikely to successfully implement the program set forth in the petition.
(3)The petition does not contain the number of signatures required by subdivision (a).
(4)The petition does not contain an affirmation of each of the conditions described in subdivision (d).
(5)The petition does not contain reasonably comprehensive descriptions of all of the following:
(A)(i)The educational program of the charter school, designed, among other things, to identify those whom the charter school is attempting to educate, what it means to be an educated person in the 21st century, and how learning best occurs. The goals identified in that program shall include the objective of enabling pupils to become self-motivated, competent, and lifelong learners.
(ii)The annual goals for the charter school for all pupils and for each subgroup of pupils identified pursuant to Section 52052, to be achieved in the state priorities, as described in paragraphs (2) to (8), inclusive, of subdivision (d) of Section 52060, that apply for the grade levels served by the charter school, and specific annual actions to achieve those goals. A charter petition may identify additional school priorities, the goals for the school priorities, and the specific annual actions to achieve those goals.
(iii)If the proposed charter school will serve high school pupils, the manner in which the charter school will inform parents about the transferability of courses to other public high schools and the eligibility of courses to meet college entrance requirements. Courses offered by the charter school that are accredited by the Western Association of Schools and Colleges may be considered transferable and courses approved by the University of California or the California State University as creditable under the A to G admissions criteria may be considered to meet college entrance requirements.
(B)The measurable pupil outcomes identified for use by the charter school. Pupil outcomes, for purposes of this part, means the extent to which all pupils of the charter school demonstrate that they have attained the skills, knowledge, and attitudes specified as goals in the charter schools educational program. Pupil outcomes shall include outcomes that address increases in pupil academic achievement both schoolwide and for all groups of pupils served by the charter school, as that term is defined in subparagraph (B) of paragraph (3) of subdivision (a) of Section 47607. The pupil outcomes shall align with the state priorities, as described in paragraphs (2) to (8), inclusive, of subdivision (d) of Section 52060, that apply for the grade levels served by the charter school.
(C)The method by which pupil progress in meeting those pupil outcomes is to be measured. To the extent practicable, the method for measuring pupil outcomes for state priorities shall be consistent with the way information is reported on a school accountability report card.
(D)The governance structure of the charter school, including, but not limited to, the process to be followed by the charter school to ensure parental involvement.
(E)The qualifications to be met by individuals to be employed by the charter school.
(F)The procedures that the charter school will follow to ensure the health and safety of pupils and staff. These procedures shall require all of the following:
(i)That each employee of the charter school furnish the charter school with a criminal record summary as described in Section 44237.
(ii)The development of a school safety plan, which shall include the safety topics listed in subparagraphs (A) to (H), inclusive, of paragraph (2) of subdivision (a) of Section 32282 and procedures for conducting tactical responses to criminal incidents.
(iii)That the school safety plan be reviewed and updated by March 1 of every year by the charter school.
(G)The means by which the charter school will achieve a racial and ethnic balance among its pupils that is reflective of the general population residing within the territorial jurisdiction of the school district to which the charter petition is submitted.
(H)Admission policies and procedures, consistent with subdivision (d).
(I)The manner in which annual, independent financial audits shall be conducted, which shall employ generally accepted accounting principles, and the manner in which audit exceptions and deficiencies shall be resolved to the satisfaction of the chartering authority.
(J)The procedures by which pupils can be suspended or expelled from the charter school for disciplinary reasons or otherwise involuntarily removed from the charter school for any reason. These procedures, at a minimum, shall include an explanation of how the charter school will comply with federal and state constitutional procedural and substantive due process requirements that is consistent with all of the following:
(i)For suspensions of fewer than 10 days, provide oral or written notice of the charges against the pupil and, if the pupil denies the charges, an explanation of the evidence that supports the charges and an opportunity for the pupil to present the pupils side of the story.
(ii)For suspensions of 10 days or more and all other expulsions for disciplinary reasons, both of the following:
(I)Provide timely, written notice of the charges against the pupil and an explanation of the pupils basic rights.
(II)Provide a hearing adjudicated by a neutral officer within a reasonable number of days at which the pupil has a fair opportunity to present testimony, evidence, and witnesses and confront and cross-examine adverse witnesses, and at which the pupil has the right to bring legal counsel or an advocate.
(iii)Contain a clear statement that no pupil shall be involuntarily removed by the charter school for any reason unless the parent or guardian of the pupil has been provided written notice of intent to remove the pupil no less than five schooldays before the effective date of the action. The written notice shall be in the native language of the pupil or the pupils parent or guardian or, if the pupil is a foster child or youth or a homeless child or youth, the pupils educational rights holder, and shall inform the pupil, the pupils parent or guardian, or the pupils educational rights holder of the right to initiate the procedures specified in clause (ii) before the effective date of the action. If the pupils parent, guardian, or educational rights holder initiates the procedures specified in clause (ii), the pupil shall remain enrolled and shall not be removed until the charter school issues a final decision. For purposes of this clause, involuntarily removed includes disenrolled, dismissed, transferred, or terminated, but does not include suspensions specified in clauses (i) and (ii).
(K)The manner by which staff members of the charter schools will be covered by the State Teachers Retirement System, the Public Employees Retirement System, or federal social security.
(L)The public school attendance alternatives for pupils residing within the school district who choose not to attend charter schools.
(M)The rights of an employee of the school district upon leaving the employment of the school district to work in a charter school, and of any rights of return to the school district after employment at a charter school.
(N)The procedures to be followed by the charter school and the chartering authority to resolve disputes relating to provisions of the charter.
(O)The procedures to be used if the charter school closes. The procedures shall ensure a final audit of the charter school to determine the disposition of all assets and liabilities of the charter school, including plans for disposing of any net assets and for the maintenance and transfer of pupil records.
(6)The petition does not contain a declaration of whether or not the charter school shall be deemed the exclusive public employer of the employees of the charter school for purposes of Chapter 10.7 (commencing with Section 3540) of Division 4 of Title 1 of the Government Code.
(c)(1)Charter schools shall meet all statewide standards and conduct the pupil assessments required pursuant to Section 60605 and any other statewide standards authorized in statute or pupil assessments applicable to pupils in noncharter public schools.
(2)Charter schools shall, on a regular basis, consult with their parents, legal guardians, and teachers regarding the charter schools educational programs.
(d)(1)In addition to any other requirement imposed under this part, a charter school shall be nonsectarian in its programs, admission policies, employment practices, and all other operations, shall not charge tuition, and shall not discriminate against a pupil on the basis of the characteristics listed in Section 220. Except as provided in paragraph (2), admission to a charter school shall not be determined according to the place of residence of the pupil, or of the pupils parent or legal guardian, within this state, except that an existing public school converting partially or entirely to a charter school under this part shall adopt and maintain a policy giving admission preference to pupils who reside within the former attendance area of that public school.
(2)(A)A charter school shall admit all pupils who wish to attend the charter school.
(B)If the number of pupils who wish to attend the charter school exceeds the charter schools capacity, attendance, except for existing pupils of the charter school, shall be determined by a public random drawing. Preference shall be extended to pupils currently attending the charter school and pupils who reside in the school district except as provided for in Section 47614.5. Preferences, including, but not limited to, siblings of pupils admitted or attending the charter school and children of the charter schools teachers, staff, and founders identified in the initial charter, may also be permitted by the chartering authority on an individual charter school basis. Priority order for any preference shall be determined in the charter petition in accordance with all of the following:
(i)Each type of preference shall be approved by the chartering authority at a public hearing.
(ii)Preferences shall be consistent with federal law, the California Constitution, and Section 200.
(iii)Preferences shall not result in limiting enrollment access for pupils with disabilities, academically low-achieving pupils, English learners, neglected or delinquent pupils, homeless pupils, or pupils who are economically disadvantaged, as determined by eligibility for any free or reduced-price meal program, foster youth, or pupils based on nationality, race, ethnicity, or sexual orientation.
(iv)In accordance with Section 49011, preferences shall not require mandatory parental volunteer hours as a criterion for admission or continued enrollment.
(C)In the event of a drawing, the chartering authority shall make reasonable efforts to accommodate the growth of the charter school and shall not take any action to impede the charter school from expanding enrollment to meet pupil demand.
(3)If a pupil is expelled or leaves the charter school without graduating or completing the school year for any reason, the charter school shall notify the superintendent of the school district of the pupils last known address within 30 days, and shall, upon request, provide that school district with a copy of the cumulative record of the pupil, including report cards or a transcript of grades, and health information. If the pupil is subsequently expelled or leaves the school district without graduating or completing the school year for any reason, the school district shall provide this information to the charter school within 30 days if the charter school demonstrates that the pupil had been enrolled in the charter school. This paragraph applies only to pupils subject to compulsory full-time education pursuant to Section 48200.
(4)(A)A charter school shall not discourage a pupil from enrolling or seeking to enroll in the charter school for any reason, including, but not limited to, academic performance of the pupil or because the pupil exhibits any of the characteristics described in clause (iii) of subparagraph (B) of paragraph (2).
(B)A charter school shall not request a pupils records or require a parent, guardian, or pupil to submit the pupils records to the charter school before enrollment.
(C)A charter school shall not encourage a pupil currently attending the charter school to disenroll from the charter school or transfer to another school for any reason, including, but not limited to, academic performance of the pupil or because the pupil exhibits any of the characteristics described in clause (iii) of subparagraph (B) of paragraph (2). This subparagraph shall not apply to actions taken by a charter school pursuant to the procedures described in subparagraph (J) of paragraph (5) of subdivision (b).
(D)The department shall develop a notice of the requirements of this paragraph. This notice shall be posted on a charter schools internet website. A charter school shall provide a parent or guardian, or a pupil if the pupil is 18 years of age or older, a copy of this notice at all of the following times:
(i)When a parent, guardian, or pupil inquires about enrollment.
(ii)Before conducting an enrollment lottery.
(iii)Before disenrollment of a pupil.
(E)(i)A person who suspects that a charter school has violated this paragraph may file a complaint with the chartering authority.
(ii)The department shall develop a template to be used for filing complaints pursuant to clause (i).
(5)Notwithstanding any other law, a charter school in operation as of July 1, 2019, that operates in partnership with the California National Guard may dismiss a pupil from the charter school for failing to maintain the minimum standards of conduct required by the Military Department.
(e)The governing board of a school district shall not require an employee of the school district to be employed in a charter school.
(f)The governing board of a school district shall not require a pupil enrolled in the school district to attend a charter school.
(g)The governing board of a school district shall require that the petitioner or petitioners provide information regarding the proposed operation and potential effects of the charter school, including, but not limited to, the facilities to be used by the charter school, the manner in which administrative services of the charter school are to be provided, and potential civil liability effects, if any, upon the charter school and upon the school district. The description of the facilities to be used by the charter school shall specify where the charter school intends to locate. The petitioner or petitioners also shall be required to provide financial statements that include a proposed first-year operational budget, including startup costs, and cashflow and financial projections for the first three years of operation.
(h)In reviewing petitions for the establishment of charter schools within the school district, the governing board of the school district shall give preference to petitions that demonstrate the capability to provide comprehensive learning experiences to pupils identified by the petitioner or petitioners as academically low achieving pursuant to the standards established by the department under Section 54032, as that section read before July 19, 2006.
(i)Upon the approval of the petition by the governing board of the school district, the petitioner or petitioners shall provide written notice of that approval, including a copy of the petition, to the applicable county superintendent of schools, the department, and the state board.
(j)(1)If the governing board of a school district denies a petition, the petitioner may elect to submit the petition for the establishment of a charter school to the county board of education. The county board of education shall review the petition pursuant to subdivision (b). If the petitioner elects to submit a petition for establishment of a charter school to the county board of education and the county board of education denies the petition, the petitioner may file a petition for establishment of a charter school with the state board, and the state board may approve the petition, in accordance with subdivision (b). A charter school that receives approval of its petition from a county board of education or from the state board on appeal shall be subject to the same requirements concerning geographic location to which it would otherwise be subject if it received approval from the school district to which it originally submitted its petition. A charter petition that is submitted to either a county board of education or to the state board shall meet all otherwise applicable petition requirements, including the identification of the proposed site or sites where the charter school will operate.
(2)In assuming its role as a chartering authority, the state board shall develop criteria to be used for the review and approval of charter school petitions presented to the state board. The criteria shall address all elements required for charter approval, as identified in subdivision (b), and shall define reasonably comprehensive, as used in paragraph (5) of subdivision (b), in a way that is consistent with the intent of this part. Upon satisfactory completion of the criteria, the state board shall adopt the criteria on or before June 30, 2001.
(3)A charter school for which a charter is granted by either the county board of education or the state board based on an appeal pursuant to this subdivision shall qualify fully as a charter school for all funding and other purposes of this part.
(4)If either the county board of education or the state board fails to act on a petition within 120 days of receipt, the decision of the governing board of the school district to deny the petition shall be subject to judicial review.
(5)The state board shall adopt regulations implementing this subdivision.
(6)Upon the approval of the petition by the county board of education, the petitioner or petitioners shall provide written notice of that approval, including a copy of the petition, to the department and the state board.
(k)(1)The state board may, by mutual agreement, designate its supervisorial and oversight responsibilities for a charter school approved by the state board to any local educational agency in the county in which the charter school is located or to the governing board of the school district that first denied the petition.
(2)The designated local educational agency shall have all monitoring and supervising authority of a chartering authority, including, but not limited to, powers and duties set forth in Section 47607, except the power of revocation, which shall remain with the state board.
(3)A charter school that is granted its charter through an appeal to the state board and elects to seek renewal of its charter shall, before expiration of the charter, submit its petition for renewal to the governing board of the school district that initially denied the charter. If the governing board of the school district denies the charter schools petition for renewal, the charter school may petition the state board for renewal of its charter.
(l)Teachers in charter schools shall hold a Commission on Teacher Credentialing certificate, permit, or other document equivalent to that which a teacher in other public schools would be required to hold. These documents shall be maintained on file at the charter school and are subject to periodic inspection by the chartering authority. It is the intent of the Legislature that charter schools be given flexibility with regard to noncore, noncollege preparatory courses.
(m)A charter school shall transmit a copy of its annual, independent financial audit report for the preceding fiscal year, as described in subparagraph (I) of paragraph (5) of subdivision (b), to its chartering authority, the Controller, the county superintendent of schools of the county in which the charter school is sited, unless the county board of education of the county in which the charter school is sited is the chartering authority, and the department by December 15 of each year. This subdivision does not apply if the audit of the charter school is encompassed in the audit of the chartering authority pursuant to Section 41020.
(n)A charter school may encourage parental involvement, but shall notify the parents and guardians of applicant pupils and currently enrolled pupils that parental involvement is not a requirement for acceptance to, or continued enrollment at, the charter school.
SEC. 2.Section 47605.1 of the Education Code is amended to read:47605.1.(a)(1)Notwithstanding any other law, a charter school that is granted a charter from the governing board of a school district or county office of education after July 1, 2002, and commences providing educational services to pupils on or after July 1, 2002, shall locate in accordance with the geographic and site limitations of this part.
(2)Notwithstanding any other law, a charter school that is granted a charter by the state board after July 1, 2002, and commences providing educational services to pupils on or after July 1, 2002, based on the denial of a petition by the governing board of a school district or county board of education, as described in paragraphs (1) and (2) of subdivision (j) of Section 47605, may locate only within the geographic boundaries of the chartering entity that initially denied the petition for the charter.
(3)A charter school that receives approval of its charter from a governing board of a school district, a county office of education, or the state board before July 1, 2002, but does not commence operations until after January 1, 2003, shall be subject to the geographic limitations of this part, in accordance with subdivision (d).
(b)This section is not intended to affect the admission requirements contained in subdivision (d) of Section 47605.
(c)(1)A charter school may establish one resource center, meeting space, or other satellite facility within the jurisdiction of the school district where the charter school is physically located if the following conditions are met:
(A)The facility is used exclusively for the educational support of pupils who are enrolled in nonclassroom-based independent study of the charter school.
(B)The charter school provides its primary educational services in, and a majority of the pupils it serves are residents of, the county in which the charter school is authorized.
(2)Except as provided in paragraphs (5) to (8), (9), inclusive, a charter school shall not establish a resource center, meeting space, or other satellite facility in any other location than the one authorized in paragraph (1).
(3)A charter school shall notify the charter schools chartering authority of the name and physical location of any resource center, meeting space, or other satellite facility operated utilized by that charter school.
(4)Notwithstanding Section 33050 or any other law, the state board shall not waive the restrictions listed in this subdivision.
(5)A charter school that was operating a resource center, meeting space, or other satellite facility outside the jurisdiction of the school district where the charter school is physically located before January 1, 2020, may continue to operate the resource center, meeting space, or other satellite facility until the charter school submits a request for the renewal of its charter petition. To continue operating the resource center, meeting space, or other satellite facility, the charter school, before submitting the request to the charter schools chartering authority for the renewal of the charter petition, shall first obtain approval in writing from the school district where the resource center, meeting space, or other satellite facility is operating.
(6)A countywide charter school approved by a county office of education that is operating a resource center, meeting space, or other satellite facility in a county other than the county in which the countywide charter school is authorized before January 1, 2020, may continue to operate that resource center, meeting space, or other satellite facility until the countywide charter school submits a request for the renewal of its charter petition. To continue operating the resource center, meeting space, or other satellite facility, the countywide charter school, before submitting the request to the countywide charter schools chartering authority for the renewal of the charter petition, shall obtain approval in writing from the county office of education where the resource center, meeting space, or other satellite facility is operating.
(7)If a Presidential declaration of a major disaster or emergency is issued in accordance with the federal Robert T. Stafford Disaster Relief and Emergency Assistance Act (42 U.S.C. Sec. 5121 et seq.) for an area in which a charter school is operating a resource center, meeting space, or other satellite facility, the charter school, for not more than five years, may relocate the resource center, meeting space, or other satellite facility outside the area subject to the Presidential declaration if the charter school first obtains the written approval of the school district where the resource center, meeting space, or other satellite facility is being relocated to.
(8)A charter school may establish additional resource centers, meetings spaces, or other satellite facilities within the jurisdiction of the charter schools chartering authority only if both of the following are met:
(A)The charter school is physically located within the boundaries of the charter schools chartering authority.
(B)The charter school has obtained written approval from the charter schools chartering authority for each additional resource center, meeting space, or other satellite facility.
(9)(A)Notwithstanding paragraph (5), a charter school that operates a resource center located in a school district outside of the boundaries of the charter schools authorizing school district may continue to operate the existing resource center if all of the following conditions are met:
(i)The charter school operating the resource center is authorized by, and physically located in, a school district adjacent to a school district with enrollment of at least 500,000 pupils.
(ii)The charter school operating the resource center was established before January 1, 2009.
(iii)The resource center is physically located in a school district with enrollment of at least 500,000 pupils and was established before January 1, 2011.
(iv)The resource center serves a pupil population of which at least 50 percent of the pupils are currently or formerly on probation or were formerly incarcerated individuals.
(B)A charter school described in this paragraph shall not establish a new resource center outside of the boundaries of the charter schools authorizing school district.
(d)(1)For a charter school that was granted approval of its charter before July 1, 2002, and provided educational services to pupils before July 1, 2002, this section only applies to new educational services or schoolsites established or acquired by the charter school on or after July 1, 2002.
(2)For a charter school that was granted approval of its charter before July 1, 2002, but did not provide educational services to pupils before July 1, 2002, this section only applies upon the expiration of a charter that is in existence on January 1, 2003.
(3)Notwithstanding other implementation timelines in this section, by June 30, 2005, or upon the expiration of a charter that is in existence on January 1, 2003, whichever is later, all charter schools shall be required to comply with this section for schoolsites at which educational services are provided to pupils before or after July 1, 2002, regardless of whether the charter school initially received approval of its charter school petition before July 1, 2002. To achieve compliance with this section, a charter school shall be required to receive approval of a charter petition in accordance with this section and Section 47605.
(4)This section is not intended to affect the authority of a governmental entity to revoke a charter that is granted on or before the effective date of this section.
(e)A charter school that submits its petition directly to a county board of education, as authorized by Section 47605.5 or 47605.6, may establish charter school operations only within the geographical boundaries of the county in which that county board of education has jurisdiction.
(f)Notwithstanding any other law, the jurisdictional limitations set forth in this section do not apply to a charter school that provides instruction exclusively in partnership with any of the following:
(1)The federal Workforce Innovation and Opportunity Act (29 U.S.C. Sec. 3101 et seq.).
(2)Federally affiliated Youth Build programs.
(3)Federal job corps training or instruction provided pursuant to a memorandum of understanding with the federal provider.
(4)The California Conservation Corps or local conservation corps certified by the California Conservation Corps pursuant to Sections 14507.5 or 14406 of the Public Resources Code.
(5)Instruction provided to juvenile court school pupils pursuant to subdivision (b) of Section 42238.18 or pursuant to Section 1981 for individuals who are placed in a residential facility.
SEC. 3.Section 60640 of the Education Code is amended to read:60640.(a)There is hereby established the California Assessment of Student Performance and Progress, to be known as the CAASPP.
(b)Commencing with the 201314 school year, the CAASPP shall be composed of all of the following:
(1)(A)A consortium summative assessment in English language arts and mathematics for grades 3 to 8, inclusive, and grade 11 that measures content standards adopted by the state board.
(B)In the 201314 school year, the consortium summative assessment in English language arts and mathematics shall be a field test only, to enable the consortium to gauge the validity and reliability of these assessments and to conduct all necessary psychometric procedures and studies, including, but not necessarily limited to, achievement standard setting, and to allow the department to conduct studies regarding full implementation of the assessment system. These field tests and results shall not be used for any other purpose, including the calculation of any accountability measure.
(2)(A)Science grade level assessments in grades 5, 8, and 10 that measure content standards adopted pursuant to Section 60605, until a successor assessment is implemented pursuant to subparagraph (B).
(B)For science assessments, the Superintendent shall make a recommendation to the state board as soon as is feasible after the adoption of science content standards pursuant to former Section 60605.85, as that section read on June 30, 2014, regarding the assessment of the newly adopted standards. Before making recommendations, the Superintendent shall consult with stakeholders, including, but not necessarily limited to, California science teachers, individuals with expertise in assessing English learners and pupils with disabilities, parents, and measurement experts, regarding the grade level and type of assessment. The recommendations shall include cost estimates and a plan for implementation of at least one assessment in each of the following grade spans:
(i)Grades 3 to 5, inclusive.
(ii)Grades 6 to 9, inclusive.
(iii)Grades 10 to 12, inclusive.
(3)The California Alternate Performance Assessment in grades 2 to 11, inclusive, in English language arts and mathematics and science in grades 5, 8, and 10, which measures content standards adopted pursuant to Section 60605 until a successor assessment is implemented. The successor assessment shall be limited to the grades and subject areas assessed pursuant to paragraph (1) and subparagraph (B) of paragraph (2).
(4)The Early Assessment Program established by Chapter 6 (commencing with Section 99300) of Part 65 of Division 14 of Title 3.
(5)(A)A local educational agency may administer a primary language assessment aligned to the English language arts standards adopted pursuant to Section 60605, as it read on January 1, 2013, to pupils who are identified as limited English proficient and enrolled in any of grades 2 to 11, inclusive, until a subsequent primary language assessment aligned to the common core standards in English language arts adopted pursuant to Section 60605.8 is developed pursuant to subparagraph (E).
(B)If a local educational agency chooses to administer a primary language assessment to pupils identified as limited English proficient and enrolled in any of grades 2 to 11, inclusive, pursuant to subparagraph (A), it shall notify the department in a manner to be determined by the department and the costs shall be paid by the state and included as part of the testing contract, and the department shall provide the local educational agency a per pupil apportionment for administering the assessment pursuant to subdivision (l).
(C)The Superintendent shall consult with stakeholders, including assessment and English learner experts, to determine the content and purpose of a stand-alone language arts summative assessment in primary languages other than English that aligns with the English language arts content standards. The Superintendent shall consider the appropriate purpose for this assessment, including, but not necessarily limited to, support for the State Seal of Biliteracy and accountability. It is the intent of the Legislature that an assessment developed pursuant to this section be included in the state accountability system.
(D)The Superintendent shall report and make recommendations to the state board at a regularly scheduled public meeting no sooner than one year after the first full administration of the consortium computer-adaptive assessments in English language arts and mathematics summative assessments in grades 3 to 8, inclusive, and grade 11, regarding an implementation timeline and estimated costs of a stand-alone language arts summative assessment in primary languages other than English.
(E)The Superintendent shall develop, and the state board shall adopt, a primary language assessment. The Superintendent shall administer this assessment no later than the 201617 school year.
(F)This paragraph shall be operative only to the extent that funding is provided in the annual Budget Act or another statute for the purpose of this section.
(c)No later than March 1, 2016, the Superintendent shall submit to the state board recommendations on expanding the CAASPP to include additional assessments, for consideration at a regularly scheduled public meeting. The Superintendent shall also submit these recommendations to the appropriate policy and fiscal committees of the Legislature and to the Director of Finance in accordance with all of the following:
(1)In consultation with stakeholders, including, but not necessarily limited to, California teachers, individuals with expertise in assessing English learners and pupils with disabilities, parents, and measurement experts, the Superintendent shall make recommendations regarding assessments, including the grade level, content, and type of assessment. These recommendations shall take into consideration the assessments already administered or planned pursuant to subdivision (b). The Superintendent shall consider the use of consortium-developed assessments, various item types, computer-based testing, and a timeline for implementation.
(2)The recommendations shall consider assessments in subjects, including, but not necessarily limited to, history-social science, technology, visual and performing arts, and other subjects as appropriate, as well as English language arts, mathematics, and science assessments to augment the assessments required under subdivision (b), and the use of various assessment options, including, but not necessarily limited to, computer-based tests, locally scored performance tasks, and portfolios.
(3)The recommendations shall include the use of an assessment calendar that would schedule the assessments identified pursuant to paragraph (2) over several years, the use of matrix sampling, if appropriate, and the use of population sampling.
(4)The recommendations shall include a timeline for test development, and shall include cost estimates for subject areas, as appropriate.
(5)Upon approval by the state board and the appropriation of funding for this purpose, the Superintendent shall develop and administer approved assessments. The state board shall approve test blueprints, achievement level descriptors, testing periods, performance standards, and a reporting plan for each approved assessment.
(6)The Superintendent shall convene an advisory panel, consisting of, but not necessarily limited to, secondary teachers, school administrators, school board members, parents, a student chosen from among the two finalists who were not appointed by the Governor to serve as the student member on the state board pursuant to Section 33000.5, representatives of a dropout recovery charter school operating pursuant to subdivision (f) of Section 47605.1, measurement experts, and individuals with expertise in assessing English learners and pupils with disabilities, to provide recommendations to the Superintendent on the continuation of the high school exit examination, described in Chapter 9 (commencing with Section 60850), and on alternative pathways to satisfy the high school graduation requirements pursuant to Sections 51224.5 and 51225.3.
(d)For the 201314 and 201415 school years, the department shall make available to local educational agencies Standardized Testing and Reporting Program test forms no longer required by the CAASPP. The cost of implementing this subdivision, including, but not necessarily limited to, shipping, printing, scoring, and reporting per pupil shall be the same for all local educational agencies, and shall not exceed the marginal cost of the assessment, including any cost the department incurs to implement this section. A local educational agency that chooses to administer an assessment pursuant to this subdivision shall do so at its own expense, and shall enter into an agreement for that purpose with a contractor, subject to the approval of the department.
(e)The Superintendent shall make available a paper and pencil version of any computer-based CAASPP assessment for use by pupils who are unable to access the computer-based version of the assessment for a maximum of three years after a new operational test is first administered.
(f)(1)From the funds available for that purpose, each local educational agency shall administer assessments to each of its pupils pursuant to subdivision (b). As allowable by federal statute, recently arrived English learner pupils are exempted from taking the assessment in English language arts. The state board shall establish a testing period to provide that all schools administer these tests to pupils at approximately the same time during the instructional year. The testing period established by the state board shall take into consideration the need of local educational agencies to provide makeup days for pupils who were absent during testing, as well as the need to schedule testing on electronic computing devices.
(2)For the 201314 school year, each local educational agency shall administer the field tests in a manner described by the department in consultation with the president or executive director of the state board. Additional participants in the field test beyond the representative sample may be approved by the department, and the department shall use existing contract savings to fund local educational agency participation in one or more tests per participant. Funds for this purpose shall be used to allow for maximum participation in the field tests across the state. To the extent savings in the current contract are not available to fully fund this participation, the department shall prorate available funds by test. Local educational agencies shall bear any additional costs to administer these assessments that are in excess of the contracted amount. With the approval of the state board and the Director of Finance, the department shall amend the existing assessment contract to accommodate field testing beyond the representative sample, and to allow for special studies using information collected from the field tests.
(g)From the funds available for that purpose, each local educational agency shall administer assessments as determined by the state board pursuant to paragraph (5) of subdivision (c).
(h)As feasible, the CAASPP field tests shall be conducted in a manner that will minimize the testing burden on individual schools. The CAASPP field tests shall not produce individual pupil scores unless it is determined that these scores are valid and reliable.
(i)The governing board of a school district may administer achievement tests in grades other than those required by this section as it deems appropriate.
(j)Subject to the approval of the state board, the department may make available to local educational agencies a primary language assessment aligned to the English language arts standards adopted pursuant to Section 60605, as it read on January 1, 2013, for assessing pupils who are enrolled in a dual language immersion program that includes the primary language of the assessment and who are either nonlimited English proficient or redesignated fluent English proficient until a subsequent primary language assessment aligned to the common core standards in English language arts adopted pursuant to Section 60605.8 is developed pursuant to paragraph (5) of subdivision (b). The cost for the assessment shall be the same for all local educational agencies and shall not exceed the marginal cost of the assessment, including any cost the department incurs to implement this section. A local educational agency that elects to administer a primary language assessment pursuant to this subdivision shall do so at its own expense and shall enter into an agreement for that purpose with the state testing contractor, subject to the approval of the department.
(k)Pursuant to Section 1412(a)(16) of Title 20 of the United States Code, individuals with exceptional needs, as defined in Section 56026, shall be included in the testing requirement of subdivision (b) with appropriate accommodations in administration, where necessary, and the individuals with exceptional needs who are unable to participate in the testing, even with accommodations, shall be given an alternate assessment.
(l)(1)The Superintendent shall apportion funds appropriated for these purposes to local educational agencies to enable them to meet the requirements of subdivisions (b) and (c).
(A)For the CAASPP field tests administered in the 201314 school year or later school years, the Superintendent shall apportion funds to local educational agencies if funds are specifically provided for this purpose in the annual Budget Act.
(B)The Superintendent shall apportion funds to local educational agencies to enable them to administer assessments used to satisfy the voluntary Early Assessment Program in the 201314 school year pursuant to paragraph (4) of subdivision (b).
(2)The state board annually shall establish the amount of funding to be apportioned to local educational agencies for each test administered and annually shall establish the amount that each contractor shall be paid for each test administered under the contracts required pursuant to Section 60643. The amounts to be paid to the contractors shall be determined by considering the cost estimates submitted by each contractor each September and the amount included in the annual Budget Act, and by making allowance for the estimated costs to local educational agencies for compliance with the requirements of subdivisions (b) and (c). The state board shall take into account changes to local educational agency test administration activities under the CAASPP, including, but not limited to, the number and type of tests administered and changes in computerized test registration and administration procedures, when establishing the amount of funding to be apportioned to local educational agencies for each test administered.
(3)An adjustment to the amount of funding to be apportioned per test shall not be valid without the approval of the Director of Finance. A request for approval of an adjustment to the amount of funding to be apportioned per test shall be submitted in writing to the Director of Finance and the chairpersons of the fiscal committees of both houses of the Legislature with accompanying material justifying the proposed adjustment. The Director of Finance is authorized to approve only those adjustments related to activities required by statute. The Director of Finance shall approve or disapprove the amount within 30 days of receipt of the request and shall notify the chairpersons of the fiscal committees of both houses of the Legislature of the decision.
(m)For purposes of making the computations required by Section 8 of Article XVI of the California Constitution, the appropriation for the apportionments made pursuant to paragraph (1) of subdivision (l), and the payments made to the contractors under the contracts required pursuant to Section 60643 or subparagraph (C) of paragraph (1) of subdivision (a) of Section 60605 between the department and the contractor, are General Fund revenues appropriated for school districts, as defined in subdivision (c) of Section 41202, for the applicable fiscal year, and included within the total allocations to school districts and community college districts from General Fund proceeds of taxes appropriated pursuant to Article XIIIB, as defined in subdivision (e) of Section 41202, for that fiscal year.
(n)As a condition to receiving an apportionment pursuant to subdivision (l), a local educational agency shall report to the Superintendent all of the following:
(1)The pupils enrolled in the local educational agency in the grades in which assessments were administered pursuant to subdivisions (b) and (c).
(2)The pupils to whom an achievement test was administered pursuant to subdivisions (b) and (c) in the local educational agency.
(3)The pupils in paragraph (1) who were exempted from the test pursuant to this section.
(o)The Superintendent and the state board are authorized and encouraged to assist postsecondary educational institutions to use the assessment results of the CAASPP, including, but not necessarily limited to, the grade 11 consortium summative assessments in English language arts and mathematics, for academic credit, placement, or admissions processes.
(p)Subject to the availability of funds in the annual Budget Act for this purpose, and exclusive of the consortium assessments, the Superintendent, with the approval of the state board, annually shall release to the public test items from the achievement tests pursuant to Section 60642.5 administered in previous years. Where feasible and practicable, the minimum number of test items released per year shall be equal to 25 percent of the total number of test items on the test administered in the previous year.
(q)On or before July 1, 2014, Sections 850 to 868, inclusive, of Title 5 of the California Code of Regulations shall be revised by the state board to conform to the changes made to this section in the first year of the 201314 Regular Session. The state board shall adopt initial regulations as emergency regulations to immediately implement the CAASPP assessments, including, but not necessarily limited to, the administration, scoring, and reporting of the tests, as the adoption of emergency regulations is necessary for the immediate preservation of the public peace, health, safety, or general welfare within the meaning of Section 11346.1 of the Government Code. The emergency regulations shall be followed by the adoption of permanent regulations, in accordance with the Administrative Procedure Act (Chapter 3.5 (commencing with Section 11340) of Part 1 of Division 3 of Title 2 of the Government Code).
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Oct 3, 2019 | Chaptered by Secretary of State - Chapter 487, Statutes of 2019. |
| Oct 3, 2019 | Approved by the Governor. |
| Sep 25, 2019 | Enrolled and presented to the Governor at 3:30 p.m. |
| Sep 12, 2019 | Senate amendments concurred in. To Engrossing and Enrolling. |
| Sep 11, 2019 | In Assembly. Concurrence in Senate amendments pending. |
| Sep 11, 2019 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Assembly. |
| Sep 6, 2019 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| Sep 5, 2019 | Read third time and amended. Ordered to second reading. |
| Sep 3, 2019 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| Aug 30, 2019 | From committee: Amend, and do pass as amended. (Ayes 5. Noes 2.) (August 30). |
| Aug 22, 2019 | Measure version as amended on August 13 corrected. |
| Aug 19, 2019 | In committee: Referred to APPR. suspense file. |
| Aug 13, 2019 | Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Aug 12, 2019 | From committee: Amend, and do pass as amended and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 4. Noes 3.) (July 10). |
| Jul 1, 2019 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to committee. Read second time, amended, and re-referred to Com. on ED. |
| May 22, 2019 | Referred to Coms. on ED. and APPR. |
| May 14, 2019 | In Senate. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. |
| May 13, 2019 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Senate. |
| May 9, 2019 | Read third time and amended. Ordered to third reading. |
| Apr 23, 2019 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| Apr 22, 2019 | Read second time and amended. Ordered returned to second reading. |
| Apr 11, 2019 | From committee: Amend, and do pass as amended. (Ayes 4. Noes 1.) (April 10). |
| Mar 27, 2019 | Re-referred to Com. on ED. |
| Mar 26, 2019 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to Com. on ED. Read second time and amended. |
| Mar 14, 2019 | Referred to Com. on ED. |
| Feb 25, 2019 | Read first time. |
| Feb 23, 2019 | From printer. May be heard in committee March 25. |
| Feb 22, 2019 | Introduced. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sep 12, 2019 | AB 1507 Smith Concurrence in Senate Amendments | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| Sep 11, 2019 | Assembly 3rd Reading AB1507 Smith et al. By Leyva | Senate Floor |
Passed |
|
| Aug 30, 2019 | Do pass as amended | Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Aug 19, 2019 | Placed on suspense file | Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Jul 10, 2019 | Do pass as amended, but first amend, and re-refer to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Senate Standing Committee on Education |
Passed |
|
| May 13, 2019 | AB 1507 Smith Assembly Third Reading | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| Apr 10, 2019 | Do pass as amended. | Assembly Standing Committee on Education |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
CONCURRENCE IN SENATE AMENDMENTS
CSA1 Bill Id:AB 1507
Author:(Smith, et al.)
As Amended Ver:September 5, 2019
Majority vote
SUMMARY:
Eliminates the ability to authorize a charter school located outside the boundaries of the authorizing school district or county, and allows a nonclassroom-based charter school to establish one or more resource centers within the jurisdiction of the school district where the charter school is located, as specified.
The Senate Amendments:
- Authorize a charter school that established one site outside the boundaries of the chartering school district, but within the county, before January 1, 2020, to continue to operate the site until the charter school submits a request for the renewal of its charter petition, and requires approval in writing from the school district where the site is operating prior to submitting the renewal.
- Authorize a charter school operating in an area subject to a presidential declaration of a major disaster to relocate the charter school outside of the area for no more than five years, subject to approval in writing from the school district where the site is operating.
- Specify that if a charter school was relocated from December 31, 2016, to December 31, 2019, inclusive, due to a Presidential declaration of a major disaster or emergency, that charter school shall be allowed to return to its original campus location in perpetuity.
- Exempt a charter school located on federally recognized California Indian reservation or rancheria operated by a federally recognized California Indian tribe from the provisions of the measure.
- Authorize a countywide charter school approved by a county office of education that is operating a resource center, meeting space, or other satellite facility in a county other than the county in which the countywide charter school is authorized before January 1, 2020, to continue to operate that resource center, meeting space, or other satellite facility until the countywide charter school submits a request for the renewal of its charter petition, at which time the charter school shall have approval in writing from the county office of education where the resource center, meeting space, or other satellite facility is operating.
- Authorize a charter school to establish additional resource centers, meeting spaces, or other satellite facilities within the jurisdiction of the charter school's chartering authority only under specified conditions.
- Provide that a charter school that operates a resource center located in a school district outside of the boundaries of the charter school's authorizing district may continue to operate the existing resource center if the charter school is authorized by, and physically located in, a district adjacent to a school district with enrollment of at least 500,000 pupils; the charter school operating the resource center was established before January 1, 2009; the resource center is physically located in a school district with enrollment of at least 500,000 pupils and was established before January 1, 2011; and, the resource center serves a pupil population of which at least 50% of the pupils are currently or formerly on probation or formerly incarcerated individuals.
COMMENTS:
California law gives school districts and county offices the authority to authorize and oversee charter schools operating within their boundaries. In most cases, charter schools are located within the boundaries of the local educational agency that authorized the school. However, current law allows a charter school to locate a facility in a school district other than the one it is authorized by under a limited number of circumstances. There have been a number of high-profile cases in which school districts have authorized charter schools outside of the district in order to generate revenue through "oversight fees." In the Santa Clarita area, the Acton-Agua Dulce Unified School District authorized a charter school that was subsequently located in another school district that had previously denied the school. In return, the school then paid a 3.5% oversight fee to the school district. Other school districts have had charter schools located within their boundaries through authorization by other school districts.
According to the Author:
"I am authoring AB 1507 to continue to address charter transparency goals that have been set forth by Governor Newsom and the Legislature. This bill eliminates loopholes in current law which allow charter schools to operate outside of their authorizing district. This bill restores the right of individual districts to have oversight of schools located within their boundaries. In my tenure as a school board member, neighboring school districts abused this loophole and authorization privilege, and families were impacted because of this. The bill clarifies the jurisdictional sovereignty of the duly elected school boards and their role in charter authorization. In this bill, it is my intent that the term "resource centers" include any meeting location where students gather on a routine basis. It is further my intent that a resource center operated by a charter school includes all meeting locations that are owned, leased, or used in accordance with a memorandum of understanding or other contract by a charter school and utilized by the students of the charter school."
Arguments in Support:
According to the School Employers Association of California, "State and local entities have little authority to enforce the law. Charter schools in various parts of the state have abused this lack of enforcement authority by taking advantage of the narrow circumstances under which a charter school is able to locate outside of the authorizing district. Once the charter school has set up operations in a neighboring district, it often stays. No government entity, except the authorizing district, has the practical ability to require the charter school comply with current law. This clearly violates the sovereign ability of each school district to determine which charter schools meet the statutory requirements for approval."
Arguments in Opposition:
According to the Charter Schools Development Center, "Previously, a charter school that was unable to locate a facility within the boundaries of its authorizing district, could locate in a facility within the same county. Deleting this provision from law will likely increase charter pressure on the authorizing district to find existing district buildings for new and growing charter schools and it even means sharing facilities and co-locating on traditional district public school sites."
FISCAL COMMENTS:
According to the Senate Appropriations Committee, this bill could result in unknown but significant local costs, potentially in the millions of dollars, for charter schools that are forced to shut down or relocate existing resource centers. A precise amount would depend on a variety of factors that are difficult to quantify, including the number of schools that would be affected. These costs would not be eligible for mandate reimbursement; however, charter schools may receive funding through the K12 Mandate Block Grant.
VOTES:
ASM EDUCATION: 4-1-1
YES: O'Donnell, Kalra, McCarty, Smith
NO: Kiley
ABS, ABST OR NV: Weber
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 54-18-8
YES: Aguiar-Curry, Bauer-Kahan, Berman, Bloom, Boerner Horvath, Bonta, Calderon, Carrillo, Cervantes, Chau, Chiu, Chu, Daly, Eggman, Friedman, Gabriel, Cristina Garcia, Eduardo Garcia, Gipson, Gloria, Gonzalez, Gray, Grayson, Holden, Irwin, Jones-Sawyer, Kalra, Kamlager-Dove, Levine, Limón, Low, Maienschein, McCarty, Medina, Mullin, Muratsuchi, Nazarian, O'Donnell, Petrie-Norris, Quirk, Quirk-Silva, Ramos, Reyes, Luz Rivas, Robert Rivas, Rodriguez, Salas, Santiago, Smith, Mark Stone, Ting, Wicks, Wood, Rendon
NO: Bigelow, Chen, Choi, Cooley, Cunningham, Dahle, Flora, Fong, Gallagher, Kiley, Lackey, Mathis, Mayes, Melendez, Obernolte, Patterson, Voepel, Waldron
ABS, ABST OR NV: Arambula, Brough, Burke, Cooper, Diep, Frazier, Blanca Rubio, Weber
SENATE FLOOR: 25-12-3
YES: Allen, Archuleta, Atkins, Beall, Bradford, Dodd, Durazo, Lena Gonzalez, Hertzberg, Hill, Hueso, Jackson, Leyva, McGuire, Mitchell, Monning, Pan, Portantino, Roth, Rubio, Skinner, Stern, Umberg, Wieckowski, Wiener
NO: Bates, Borgeas, Chang, Dahle, Glazer, Grove, Jones, Moorlach, Morrell, Nielsen, Stone, Wilk
ABS, ABST OR NV: Caballero, Galgiani, Hurtado
UPDATED:
VERSION: September 5, 2019
CONSULTANT: Chelsea Kelley / ED. / (916) 319-2087 FN: 0002173
Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | AB 1507 |
THIRD READING
Bill No: AB 1507
Author: Smith (D), McCarty (D) and O'Donnell (D), et al.
Amended: 9/5/19 in Senate
SENATE EDUCATION COMMITTEE: 4-3, 7/10/19
AYES: Leyva, Durazo, McGuire, Pan
NOES: Wilk, Chang, Glazer
SENATE APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE: 5-2, 8/30/19
AYES: Portantino, Bradford, Durazo, Hill, Wieckowski
NOES: Bates, Jones
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 54-18, 5/13/19 - See last page for vote
SUBJECT: Charter schools: location: resource center
DIGEST:
This bill eliminates the authorization for a charter school to be located outside the boundaries of their authorizer and allows a nonclassroom-based charter school to establish one resource center within the jurisdiction of the school district where the charter school is located, as specified.
Senate Floor Amendments of 9/5/19 (1) address chaptering issues with AB 1505 (O’Donnell); (2) clarify that a charter school seeking authorization from the district in which it is located must obtain approval from the district in writing and submit a request for renewal of the charter petition to that district, and (3) direct the California Department of Education to regard a charter school that changes its authorizer as a result of this bill as a continuing charter school for funding and data purposes.
Existing law:
- Authorizes a charter school that is unable to locate within the jurisdiction of the chartering school district to establish one site outside the boundaries of the authorizer, but within the county in which that school district is located, if the school district within the jurisdiction of which the charter school proposes to operate is notified in advance of the charter petition approval, the county superintendent of schools and the Superintendent of Public Instruction (SPI) are notified of the location of the charter school before it commences operations, and either of the following circumstances exists:
- The school has attempted to locate a single site or facility to house the entire program, but a site or facility is unavailable in the area in which the school chooses to locate.
- The site is needed for temporary use during a construction or expansion project.
- Authorizes a charter school to establish a resource center, meeting space, or other satellite facility located in a county adjacent to that in which the charter school is authorized if the following conditions are met:
- The facility is used exclusively for the educational support of pupils who are enrolled in nonclassroom-based independent study of the charter school; and
- The charter school provides its primary educational services in, and a majority of the pupils it serves are residents of, the county in which the charter school is authorized.
This bill:
- Deletes the authorization for a charter school that is unable to locate within the geographic boundaries of the chartering school district to establish one site outside the boundaries of the school district, but within the county.
- Authorizes a charter school that established one site outside the boundaries of the chartering school district, but within the county, before January 1, 2020, to continue to operate the site until the charter school submits a request for the renewal of its charter petition, and requires approval in writing from the school district where the site is operating prior to submitting the renewal.
- Authorizes a charter school operating in an area subject to a presidential declaration of a major disaster to relocate the charter school outside of the area for no more than five years, subject to the approval in writing from the school district where the site is operating.
- Specifies that if a charter school was relocated from December 31, 2016 to December 31, 2019, inclusive, due to a Presidential declaration of a major disaster or emergency, that charter school shall be allowed to return to its original campus location in perpetuity.
- Exempts a charter school located on federally recognized California Indian reservation or rancheria operated by a federally recognized California Indian tribe from its provisions.
- Specifies that a charter school may establish one resource center within the jurisdiction of the school district where the charter school is physically located.
- Authorizes a charter school that was operating a resource center, meeting space, or other satellite facility outside the jurisdiction of the school district where the charter school is physically located before January 1, 2020, to continue that facility until the charter submits a request for the renewal of the charter petition, and requires approval in writing from the school district where the facility is operating, prior to submitting the renewal.
- Authorizes a charter school operating a resource center, meeting space, or other satellite facility in an area subject to a presidential declaration of a major disaster, to continue to operate the site until the charter school submits a renewal request, with the written approval of the school district where the site is located.
- Authorizes a countywide charter school approved by a county office of education that is operating a resource center, meeting space, or other satellite facility in a county other than the county in which the countywide charter school is authorized before January 1, 2020, to continue to operate that resource center, meeting space, or other satellite facility until the countywide charter school submits a request for the renewal of its charter petition. To continue operating the resource center, meeting space, or other satellite facility, the countywide charter school, before submitting the request to the countywide charter school’s chartering authority for the renewal of the charter petition, shall obtain approval in writing from the county office of education where the resource center, meeting space, or other satellite facility is operating.
- Authorizes a charter school to establish additional resource centers, meeting spaces, or other satellite facilities within the jurisdiction of the charter school’s chartering authority only under specified conditions.
- Specifies that a charter school that operates a resource center located in a school district outside of the boundaries of the charter school’s authorizing school district may continue to operate the existing resource center if specified conditions are met.
Comments
- Need for the bill. According to the author, “I am authoring AB 1507 to continue to address charter transparency goals that have been set forth by Governor Newsom and the Legislature. This bill eliminates loopholes in current law which allow charter schools to operate outside of their authorizing district. This bill restores the right of individual districts to have oversight of schools located within their boundaries. In my tenure as a school board member, neighboring school districts abused this loophole and authorization privilege, and families were impacted because of this. The bill clarifies the jurisdictional sovereignty of the duly elected school boards and their role in charter authorization.”
- Charter school overview. Charter schools are public schools that provide instruction in any combination of grades kindergarten through 12. In 1992, the state enacted legislation allowing charter schools in California to offer parents an alternative to traditional public schools and encourage local leaders to experiment with new educational programs. Except where specifically noted otherwise, California law exempts charter schools from many of the statutes and regulations that apply to school districts. Generally, all charter schools must (1) provide nonsectarian instruction, (2) charge no tuition, and (3) admit all interested students up to school capacity. To both open and continue operating, a charter school must have an approved charter setting forth a comprehensive vision for the school.
Over the last decade, charter school enrollment has grown steadily. In 2006, 560 charter schools served about 200,000 students (3.5 percent of the state’s K-12 enrollment). By 2016, over 1,200 charter schools served about 580,000 students (almost 10 percent of the state’s K-12 enrollment). Most charter schools are small, compared to traditional public schools, and located in urban areas. The median charter school enrolls about 250 students, whereas the median traditional public school enrolls about 525 students. Together, nine Bay Area counties, Los Angeles County, and San Diego County account for more than 60 percent of all charter schools and charter school enrollment in the state.
Charter schools can be conversions of existing public schools or new startup schools. About 15 percent of charter schools are conversions, with the remaining 85 percent being startups. Of these, about 80 percent offer traditional, classroom-based instruction and 20 percent offer some form of independent study, such as distance learning or home study.
- Charter school oversight. A charter school must promptly respond to all reasonable inquiries from its chartering authority, the county office of education that has jurisdiction over the school’s chartering authority, or from the SPI. Each chartering authority is also required to: (a) identify at least one staff member as a contact person for the charter school, (b) visit each charter school annually, (c) ensure that each charter school complies with reporting requirements, (d) monitor the fiscal condition of each charter school under its authority, and (e) provide timely notification to the California Department of Education if an existing charter is renewed, revoked, or ceased. Charter schools must annually submit reports to its chartering authority and county superintendent of schools including budget information, interim financial reports, and audits. The chartering authority is tasked with using any financial information it obtains from the charter school to assess the fiscal condition of the charter school.
- When can a charter school locate outside the boundaries of its authorizer? A charter school that is unable to locate within the jurisdiction of the authorizing school district may establish one site outside the boundaries of the school district, but within the same county, if the following conditions are satisfied:
- The school district in which the charter school proposes to operate is notified in advance of the charter petition approval; and
- The county superintendent of schools and the SPI are notified of the location of the charter school before it commences operations; and either of the following circumstances exists:
- The charter school has attempted to locate a single site or facility to house the entire program, but a site or facility is unavailable in the area in which the charter school chooses to locate.
- The site is needed for temporary use during a construction or expansion project.
- Where can nonclassroom-based charter schools locate? Nonclassroom-based charter schools, those not operating in a traditional brick-and-mortar settings, may establish a resource center, meeting space, or other satellite facility in a county adjacent to the county in which the school was approved if the following apply:
- The facility is used exclusively for the educational support of pupils who are enrolled in nonclassroom-based independent study; and
- The charter school provides its primary educational services in, and a majority of the pupils it serves are residents of, the county in which the charter was authorized.
A 2016 court decision in Anderson Union High School District v. Shasta Secondary Home School upheld the geographic restrictions on the location of satellite facilities—specifically that a nonclassroom-based charter can locate a facility in a county that is adjacent to the county in which the authorizer is located, but not in another district within the same county as the authorizing district. This decision led numerous charter schools to apply for waivers from the State Board of Education (SBE), as the location of their resource centers were out of compliance with the law. In 2017, the SBE received 55 waivers that were approved on a one time basis, to give time for these resource centers to come into compliance with the law.
- Some districts have authorized charter schools operating in other districts to generate revenue. While existing law allows a charter school to locate a facility in a school district other than the one it is authorized by under a limited number of circumstances, there have been high-profile instances of school districts authorizing charter schools outside of the district in order to generate revenue through oversight fees. In the Santa Clarita area, the Acton-Agua Dulce Unified School District authorized a charter school that was subsequently located in another school district that had previously denied the school. In return, the school then paid a 3.5 percent oversight fee to the school district. Though the situation in Santa Clarita has brought more attention to this statewide problem, other school districts, including Los Angeles Unified, Culver City Unified, Beverly Hills Unified, Pomona Unified, and San Diego Unified have all had charter schools located within their boundaries by other school districts.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: No Local: No
According to the Senate Appropriations Committee, this bill could result in unknown but significant local costs, potentially in the millions of dollars, for charter schools that are forced to shut down or relocate existing resource centers. A precise amount would depend on a variety of factors that are difficult to quantify, including the number of schools that would be affected. These costs would not be eligible for mandate reimbursement; however, charter schools may receive funding through the K12 Mandates Block Grant.
American Federation of State, County and Municipal Employees
California Association of Suburban School Districts
California-Hawaii State Conference of the NAACP
California Labor Federation
California School Boards Association
California State Association of Electrical Workers
California State Pipe Trades Council
California State PTA
California Teachers Association
Democrats for Neighborhood Action
Sulphur Springs Union School District
Townsend Public Affairs
Western States Council Sheet Metal, Air, Rail and Transportation
Able Charter Schools
Academia Avance
Ace Charter Schools
AeroSTEM Academy
Afisha Media Group
Alder Grove Charter School
Alliance College-Ready Public Schools
Alma Fuerte Public School
Alpha Public Schools
Alta Public Schools
Anahuacalmecac World School
Apex Academy
Ari Community Services
Arts in Action Community Charter Schools
Aspire Public Schools
Audeo Charter School
Bach Viet Association
Baypoint Preparatory Academy
Bella Mente Montessori Academy
Barona Band of Mission Indians
Bright Star Schools
Bullis Charter School
Cahuilla Band of Mission Indians
California Black Chamber of Commerce Foundation
Caliber Schools
California Connections Academy
California Pacific Charter Schools
Camino Nuevo Charter Academy
Campo Band of Kumeyaay Indians
Champs Charter High School of the Arts
Charter Schools Development Center
Chemehuevi Indian Tribe
Chico Country Day School
Chime Institute
Citizens of the World Charter School
City Charter Schools
Collegiate Charter High School of Los Angeles
Community School for Creative Education
Core Charter School
Creative Arts Charter School
Da Vinci Connect
Da Vinci Schools
Desert Trails Preparatory Academy
Ednovate
Education for Change
Eel River Charter School
El Sol Science and Arts Academy
Elk Grove Charter School
Endeavor College Prep
Environmental Charter Schools
Envision Education
Epic Charter School
Escuela Popular
Ewiiaapaayp Band of Kumeyaay Indians
Excelencia Charter Academy
Excelsior Charter Schools
Extera Public Schools
Fenton Charter Public Schools
Forest Charter School
Gabriella Charter Schools
Gateway College and Career Academy
Gateway Community Charters
Girls Athletic Leadership Schools Los Angeles
Global Education Collaborative
Goals Academy
Gorman Learning Charter Network
Greater Bakersfield Chamber of Commerce
Green Dot Public Schools California
Grimmway Schools
Grossmont Secondary School
Growth Public Schools
Guajome Schools
Hawking Steam Charter School
Heritage Peak Charter School
High Tech Los Angeles
Highlands Community Charter School
Icef Public Schools
Iipay Nation of Santa Ysabel
Ilead California Charter Schools
Inaja-Cosmit Band of Indians
Ingenium Schools
Inspire Charter Schools
International School for Science and Culture
Isana Academies
Ivy Academia Entrepreneurial Charter School
James Jordan Middle School
Jamul Indian Village a Kumeyaay Nation
John Muir Charter Schools
Julian Charter School
Kairos Public Schools
Kavod Charter School
Kid Street Learning Center Charter School
Kinetic Academy
KIPP Bay Area Public Schools
KIPP Bayview Academy
KIPP Bayview Elementary
KIPP Bridge Academy
KIPP LA Public Schools
La Jolla Band of Luiseño Indians
La Posta Band of Mission Indians
La Verne Elementary Preparatory Academy
La Vida Charter School
Language Academy of Sacramento
Larchmont Charter School
Lashon Academy
Leadership Public Schools
League of California Cities
Learn4Life Assurance Learning Academy
Leonardo da Vinci Health Sciences Charter School
Libertas College Preparatory Charter School
Lighthouse Charter School
Lighthouse Community Public Schools
Literacy First Charter Schools
Los Angeles Academy of Arts and Enterprise
Los Angeles International Charter School
Los Angeles Leadership Academy
Los Coyotes Band of Cahuilla and Cupeño Indians
Los Feliz Charter School for the Arts
Magnolia Public Schools
Making Waves Academy
Manzanita Band of the Kumeyaay Nation
Mesa Grande Band of Mission Indians
Mirus Secondary School
Multicultural Learning Center
National Action Network
Navigator Schools
New Academy of Sciences and Arts
New Designs Charter School
New Horizons Charter Academy
New Los Angeles Charter Schools
New West Charter
Norton Science and Language Academy
Nova Academy Early College High School
Oakland Unity High School
Odyssey Charter Schools
Olive Grove Charter School
Orange County Academy of Sciences and Arts
Orange County Educational Arts Academy
Pacific Charter Institute
Pacific Community Charter School
Pacoima Charter School
Pala Band of Mission Indians
Palisades Charter High School
Partnerships to Uplift Communities Schools
Pauma Band of Luiseño Indians
Perseverance Prep
Pivot Charter Schools
Plumas Charter School
Public Safety Academy of San Bernardino
Puente Charter School
Redwood Academy of Ukiah
Redwood Preparatory Charter
Resolute Academy
Rex and Margaret Fortune School of Education
Rincon Band of Luiseño Indians
Rio Valley Charter School
Rocketship Public Schools
Rocklin Academy Family of Schools
Ross Valley Charter School
Sacramento Area League of Associated Muslims
Sacramento Black Chamber of Commerce
Sacramento Music Summit "The Creative Exchange"
Sacramento Valley Charter School
Samueli Academy
San Diego Cooperative Charter Schools
San Diego Global Vision Academy
San Jose Charter Academy
San Jose Conservation Corps & Charter School
San Pasqual Band of Mission Indians
Santa Rosa Academy
Santa Rosa Band of Cahuilla Indians
Scholarship Prep Charter School
Sebastopol Independent Charter
Shasta Charter Academy
Sherman Thomas Charter School
Slicon Schools Fund
Soar Charter Academy
Sol Aureus College Preparatory
Soleil Academy
Southern California Tribal Chairmen's Association
Springs Charter Schools
St. Hope Public Schools
Stem Prep Schools
Summit Leadership Academy High Desert
Summit Public Schools
Sutter Peak Charter Academy
Sweetwater Secondary School
Sycamore Academy of Science and Cultural Arts
Sycamore Creek Community Charter School
Sycuan Band of the Kumeyaay Nation
Taylion Academy
TEACH Public Schools
The Academies
The Charter School of San Diego
The Foundation for Hispanic Education
The New School of San Francisco
The Preuss School UCSD
Thrive Public Schools
Tree of Life Charter School
Twin Ridges Home Study Charter School
University High School
University Preparatory Academy
Urban Discovery Academy
Valley Charter School
Vaughn Next Century Learning Center
Ventura Charter School of Arts and Global Education
Viejas Band of Kumeyaay Indians
Village Charter Academy
Visions in Education
Vista Charter Public Schools
Voices College Bound Language Academies
Vox Collegiate of Los Angeles
Western Sierra Charter Schools
Westlake Charter School
Willits Charter School
Willow Creek Academy
Wish Charter Schools
Yes Charter Academy
Young, Minney & Corr, LLP
Youth Policy Institute Charter Schools
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 54-18, 5/13/19
AYES: Aguiar-Curry, Bauer-Kahan, Berman, Bloom, Boerner Horvath, Bonta, Calderon, Carrillo, Cervantes, Chau, Chiu, Chu, Daly, Eggman, Friedman, Gabriel, Cristina Garcia, Eduardo Garcia, Gipson, Gloria, Gonzalez, Gray, Grayson, Holden, Irwin, Jones-Sawyer, Kalra, Kamlager-Dove, Levine, Limón, Low, Maienschein, McCarty, Medina, Mullin, Muratsuchi, Nazarian, O'Donnell, Petrie-Norris, Quirk, Quirk-Silva, Ramos, Reyes, Luz Rivas, Robert Rivas, Rodriguez, Salas, Santiago, Smith, Mark Stone, Ting, Wicks, Wood, Rendon
NOES: Bigelow, Chen, Choi, Cooley, Cunningham, Dahle, Flora, Fong, Gallagher, Kiley, Lackey, Mathis, Mayes, Melendez, Obernolte, Patterson, Voepel, Waldron
NO VOTE RECORDED: Arambula, Brough, Burke, Cooper, Diep, Frazier, Blanca Rubio, Weber
Prepared by: Ian Johnson / ED. /
9/6/19 13:33:39
**** END ****
Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | AB 1507 |
THIRD READING
Bill No: AB 1507
Author: Smith (D), McCarty (D) and O'Donnell (D), et al.
Amended: 8/30/19 in Senate
SENATE EDUCATION COMMITTEE: 4-3, 7/10/19
AYES: Leyva, Durazo, McGuire, Pan
NOES: Wilk, Chang, Glazer
SENATE APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE: 5-2, 8/30/19
AYES: Portantino, Bradford, Durazo, Hill, Wieckowski
NOES: Bates, Jones
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 54-18, 5/13/19 - See last page for vote
SUBJECT: Charter schools: location: resource center
DIGEST:
This bill eliminates the authorization for a charter school to be located outside the boundaries of their authorizer and allows a nonclassroom-based charter school to establish one resource center within the jurisdiction of the school district where the charter school is located, as specified.
Existing law:
- Authorizes a charter school that is unable to locate within the jurisdiction of the chartering school district to establish one site outside the boundaries of the authorizer, but within the county in which that school district is located, if the school district within the jurisdiction of which the charter school proposes to operate is notified in advance of the charter petition approval, the county superintendent of schools and the Superintendent of Public Instruction (SPI) are notified of the location of the charter school before it commences operations, and either of the following circumstances exists:
- The school has attempted to locate a single site or facility to house the entire program, but a site or facility is unavailable in the area in which the school chooses to locate.
- The site is needed for temporary use during a construction or expansion project.
- Authorizes a charter school to establish a resource center, meeting space, or other satellite facility located in a county adjacent to that in which the charter school is authorized if the following conditions are met:
- The facility is used exclusively for the educational support of pupils who are enrolled in nonclassroom-based independent study of the charter school; and
- The charter school provides its primary educational services in, and a majority of the pupils it serves are residents of, the county in which the charter school is authorized.
This bill:
- Deletes the authorization for a charter school that is unable to locate within the geographic boundaries of the chartering school district to establish one site outside the boundaries of the school district, but within the county.
- Authorizes a charter school that established one site outside the boundaries of the chartering school district, but within the county, before January 1, 2020, to continue to operate the site until the charter school submits a request for the renewal of its charter petition, and requires approval in writing from the school district where the site is operating prior to submitting the renewal.
- Authorizes a charter school operating in an area subject to a presidential declaration of a major disaster to relocate the charter school outside of the area for no more than five years, subject to the approval in writing from the school district where the site is operating.
- Specifies that if a charter school was relocated from December 31, 2016 to December 31, 2019, inclusive, due to a Presidential declaration of a major disaster or emergency, that charter school shall be allowed to return to its original campus location in perpetuity.
- Exempts a charter school located on federally recognized California Indian reservation or rancheria operated by a federally recognized California Indian tribe from its provisions.
- Specifies that a charter school may establish one resource center within the jurisdiction of the school district where the charter school is physically located.
- Authorizes a charter school that was operating a resource center, meeting space, or other satellite facility outside the jurisdiction of the school district where the charter school is physically located before January 1, 2020, to continue that facility until the charter submits a request for the renewal of the charter petition, and requires approval in writing from the school district where the facility is operating, prior to submitting the renewal.
- Authorizes a charter school operating a resource center, meeting space, or other satellite facility in an area subject to a presidential declaration of a major disaster, to continue to operate the site until the charter school submits a renewal request, with the written approval of the school district where the site is located.
- Authorizes a countywide charter school approved by a county office of education that is operating a resource center, meeting space, or other satellite facility in a county other than the county in which the countywide charter school is authorized before January 1, 2020, to continue to operate that resource center, meeting space, or other satellite facility until the countywide charter school submits a request for the renewal of its charter petition. To continue operating the resource center, meeting space, or other satellite facility, the countywide charter school, before submitting the request to the countywide charter school’s chartering authority for the renewal of the charter petition, shall obtain approval in writing from the county office of education where the resource center, meeting space, or other satellite facility is operating.
- Authorizes a charter school to establish additional resource centers, meeting spaces, or other satellite facilities within the jurisdiction of the charter school’s chartering authority only under specified conditions.
- Specifies that a charter school that operates a resource center located in a school district outside of the boundaries of the charter school’s authorizing school district may continue to operate the existing resource center if specified conditions are met.
Comments
- Need for the bill. According to the author, “I am authoring AB 1507 to continue to address charter transparency goals that have been set forth by Governor Newsom and the Legislature. This bill eliminates loopholes in current law which allow charter schools to operate outside of their authorizing district. This bill restores the right of individual districts to have oversight of schools located within their boundaries. In my tenure as a school board member, neighboring school districts abused this loophole and authorization privilege, and families were impacted because of this. The bill clarifies the jurisdictional sovereignty of the duly elected school boards and their role in charter authorization.”
- Charter school overview. Charter schools are public schools that provide instruction in any combination of grades kindergarten through 12. In 1992, the state enacted legislation allowing charter schools in California to offer parents an alternative to traditional public schools and encourage local leaders to experiment with new educational programs. Except where specifically noted otherwise, California law exempts charter schools from many of the statutes and regulations that apply to school districts. Generally, all charter schools must (1) provide nonsectarian instruction, (2) charge no tuition, and (3) admit all interested students up to school capacity. To both open and continue operating, a charter school must have an approved charter setting forth a comprehensive vision for the school.
Over the last decade, charter school enrollment has grown steadily. In 2006, 560 charter schools served about 200,000 students (3.5 percent of the state’s K-12 enrollment). By 2016, over 1,200 charter schools served about 580,000 students (almost 10 percent of the state’s K-12 enrollment). Most charter schools are small, compared to traditional public schools, and located in urban areas. The median charter school enrolls about 250 students, whereas the median traditional public school enrolls about 525 students. Together, nine Bay Area counties, Los Angeles County, and San Diego County account for more than 60 percent of all charter schools and charter school enrollment in the state.
Charter schools can be conversions of existing public schools or new startup schools. About 15 percent of charter schools are conversions, with the remaining 85 percent being startups. Of these, about 80 percent offer traditional, classroom-based instruction and 20 percent offer some form of independent study, such as distance learning or home study.
- Charter school oversight. A charter school must promptly respond to all reasonable inquiries from its chartering authority, the county office of education that has jurisdiction over the school’s chartering authority, or from the SPI. Each chartering authority is also required to: (a) identify at least one staff member as a contact person for the charter school, (b) visit each charter school annually, (c) ensure that each charter school complies with reporting requirements, (d) monitor the fiscal condition of each charter school under its authority, and (e) provide timely notification to the California Department of Education if an existing charter is renewed, revoked, or ceased. Charter schools must annually submit reports to its chartering authority and county superintendent of schools including budget information, interim financial reports, and audits. The chartering authority is tasked with using any financial information it obtains from the charter school to assess the fiscal condition of the charter school.
- When can a charter school locate outside the boundaries of its authorizer? A charter school that is unable to locate within the jurisdiction of the authorizing school district may establish one site outside the boundaries of the school district, but within the same county, if the following conditions are satisfied:
- The school district in which the charter school proposes to operate is notified in advance of the charter petition approval; and
- The county superintendent of schools and the SPI are notified of the location of the charter school before it commences operations; and either of the following circumstances exists:
- The charter school has attempted to locate a single site or facility to house the entire program, but a site or facility is unavailable in the area in which the charter school chooses to locate.
- The site is needed for temporary use during a construction or expansion project.
- Where can nonclassroom-based charter schools locate? Nonclassroom-based charter schools, those not operating in a traditional brick-and-mortar settings, may establish a resource center, meeting space, or other satellite facility in a county adjacent to the county in which the school was approved if the following apply:
- The facility is used exclusively for the educational support of pupils who are enrolled in nonclassroom-based independent study; and
- The charter school provides its primary educational services in, and a majority of the pupils it serves are residents of, the county in which the charter was authorized.
A 2016 court decision in Anderson Union High School District v. Shasta Secondary Home School upheld the geographic restrictions on the location of satellite facilities—specifically that a nonclassroom-based charter can locate a facility in a county that is adjacent to the county in which the authorizer is located, but not in another district within the same county as the authorizing district. This decision led numerous charter schools to apply for waivers from the State Board of Education (SBE), as the location of their resource centers were out of compliance with the law. In 2017, the SBE received 55 waivers that were approved on a one time basis, to give time for these resource centers to come into compliance with the law.
- Some districts have authorized charter schools operating in other districts to generate revenue. While existing law allows a charter school to locate a facility in a school district other than the one it is authorized by under a limited number of circumstances, there have been high-profile instances of school districts authorizing charter schools outside of the district in order to generate revenue through oversight fees. In the Santa Clarita area, the Acton-Agua Dulce Unified School District authorized a charter school that was subsequently located in another school district that had previously denied the school. In return, the school then paid a 3.5 percent oversight fee to the school district. Though the situation in Santa Clarita has brought more attention to this statewide problem, other school districts, including Los Angeles Unified, Culver City Unified, Beverly Hills Unified, Pomona Unified, and San Diego Unified have all had charter schools located within their boundaries by other school districts.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: No Local: No
According to the Senate Appropriations Committee, this bill could result in unknown but significant local costs, potentially in the millions of dollars, for charter schools that are forced to shut down or relocate existing resource centers. A precise amount would depend on a variety of factors that are difficult to quantify, including the number of schools that would be affected. These costs would not be eligible for mandate reimbursement; however, charter schools may receive funding through the K12 Mandates Block Grant.
American Federation of State, County and Municipal Employees
California Association of Suburban School Districts
California-Hawaii State Conference of the NAACP
California Labor Federation
California School Boards Association
California State Association of Electrical Workers
California State Pipe Trades Council
California State PTA
California Teachers Association
Democrats for Neighborhood Action
Sulphur Springs Union School District
Townsend Public Affairs
Western States Council Sheet Metal, Air, Rail and Transportation
OPPOSITION: (Verified 8/30/19)
Able Charter Schools
Academia Avance
Ace Charter Schools
AeroSTEM Academy
Afisha Media Group
Alder Grove Charter School
Alliance College-Ready Public Schools
Alma Fuerte Public School
Alpha Public Schools
Alta Public Schools
Anahuacalmecac World School
Apex Academy
Ari Community Services
Arts in Action Community Charter Schools
Aspire Public Schools
Audeo Charter School
Bach Viet Association
Baypoint Preparatory Academy
Bella Mente Montessori Academy
Barona Band of Mission Indians
Bright Star Schools
Bullis Charter School
Cahuilla Band of Mission Indians
California Black Chamber of Commerce Foundation
Caliber Schools
California Connections Academy
California Pacific Charter Schools
Camino Nuevo Charter Academy
Campo Band of Kumeyaay Indians
Champs Charter High School of the Arts
Charter Schools Development Center
Chemehuevi Indian Tribe
Chico Country Day School
Chime Institute
Citizens of the World Charter School
City Charter Schools
Collegiate Charter High School of Los Angeles
Community School for Creative Education
Core Charter School
Creative Arts Charter School
Da Vinci Connect
Da Vinci Schools
Desert Trails Preparatory Academy
Ednovate
Education for Change
Eel River Charter School
El Sol Science and Arts Academy
Elk Grove Charter School
Endeavor College Prep
Environmental Charter Schools
Envision Education
Epic Charter School
Escuela Popular
Ewiiaapaayp Band of Kumeyaay Indians
Excelencia Charter Academy
Excelsior Charter Schools
Extera Public Schools
Fenton Charter Public Schools
Forest Charter School
Gabriella Charter Schools
Gateway College and Career Academy
Gateway Community Charters
Girls Athletic Leadership Schools Los Angeles
Global Education Collaborative
Goals Academy
Gorman Learning Charter Network
Greater Bakersfield Chamber of Commerce
Green Dot Public Schools California
Grimmway Schools
Grossmont Secondary School
Growth Public Schools
Guajome Schools
Hawking Steam Charter School
Heritage Peak Charter School
High Tech Los Angeles
Highlands Community Charter School
Icef Public Schools
Iipay Nation of Santa Ysabel
Ilead California Charter Schools
Inaja-Cosmit Band of Indians
Ingenium Schools
Inspire Charter Schools
International School for Science and Culture
Isana Academies
Ivy Academia Entrepreneurial Charter School
James Jordan Middle School
Jamul Indian Village a Kumeyaay Nation
John Muir Charter Schools
Julian Charter School
Kairos Public Schools
Kavod Charter School
Kid Street Learning Center Charter School
Kinetic Academy
KIPP Bay Area Public Schools
KIPP Bayview Academy
KIPP Bayview Elementary
KIPP Bridge Academy
KIPP LA Public Schools
La Jolla Band of Luiseño Indians
La Posta Band of Mission Indians
La Verne Elementary Preparatory Academy
La Vida Charter School
Language Academy of Sacramento
Larchmont Charter School
Lashon Academy
Leadership Public Schools
League of California Cities
Learn4Life Assurance Learning Academy
Leonardo da Vinci Health Sciences Charter School
Libertas College Preparatory Charter School
Lighthouse Charter School
Lighthouse Community Public Schools
Literacy First Charter Schools
Los Angeles Academy of Arts and Enterprise
Los Angeles International Charter School
Los Angeles Leadership Academy
Los Coyotes Band of Cahuilla and Cupeño Indians
Los Feliz Charter School for the Arts
Magnolia Public Schools
Making Waves Academy
Manzanita Band of the Kumeyaay Nation
Mesa Grande Band of Mission Indians
Mirus Secondary School
Multicultural Learning Center
National Action Network
Navigator Schools
New Academy of Sciences and Arts
New Designs Charter School
New Horizons Charter Academy
New Los Angeles Charter Schools
New West Charter
Norton Science and Language Academy
Nova Academy Early College High School
Oakland Unity High School
Odyssey Charter Schools
Olive Grove Charter School
Orange County Academy of Sciences and Arts
Orange County Educational Arts Academy
Pacific Charter Institute
Pacific Community Charter School
Pacoima Charter School
Pala Band of Mission Indians
Palisades Charter High School
Partnerships to Uplift Communities Schools
Pauma Band of Luiseño Indians
Perseverance Prep
Pivot Charter Schools
Plumas Charter School
Public Safety Academy of San Bernardino
Puente Charter School
Redwood Academy of Ukiah
Redwood Preparatory Charter
Resolute Academy
Rex and Margaret Fortune School of Education
Rincon Band of Luiseño Indians
Rio Valley Charter School
Rocketship Public Schools
Rocklin Academy Family of Schools
Ross Valley Charter School
Sacramento Area League of Associated Muslims
Sacramento Black Chamber of Commerce
Sacramento Music Summit "The Creative Exchange"
Sacramento Valley Charter School
Samueli Academy
San Diego Cooperative Charter Schools
San Diego Global Vision Academy
San Jose Charter Academy
San Jose Conservation Corps & Charter School
San Pasqual Band of Mission Indians
Santa Rosa Academy
Santa Rosa Band of Cahuilla Indians
Scholarship Prep Charter School
Sebastopol Independent Charter
Shasta Charter Academy
Sherman Thomas Charter School
Slicon Schools Fund
Soar Charter Academy
Sol Aureus College Preparatory
Soleil Academy
Southern California Tribal Chairmen's Association
Springs Charter Schools
St. Hope Public Schools
Stem Prep Schools
Summit Leadership Academy High Desert
Summit Public Schools
Sutter Peak Charter Academy
Sweetwater Secondary School
Sycamore Academy of Science and Cultural Arts
Sycamore Creek Community Charter School
Sycuan Band of the Kumeyaay Nation
Taylion Academy
TEACH Public Schools
The Academies
The Charter School of San Diego
The Foundation for Hispanic Education
The New School of San Francisco
The Preuss School UCSD
Thrive Public Schools
Tree of Life Charter School
Twin Ridges Home Study Charter School
University High School
University Preparatory Academy
Urban Discovery Academy
Valley Charter School
Vaughn Next Century Learning Center
Ventura Charter School of Arts and Global Education
Viejas Band of Kumeyaay Indians
Village Charter Academy
Visions in Education
Vista Charter Public Schools
Voices College Bound Language Academies
Vox Collegiate of Los Angeles
Western Sierra Charter Schools
Westlake Charter School
Willits Charter School
Willow Creek Academy
Wish Charter Schools
Yes Charter Academy
Young, Minney & Corr, LLP
Youth Policy Institute Charter Schools
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 54-18, 5/13/19
AYES: Aguiar-Curry, Bauer-Kahan, Berman, Bloom, Boerner Horvath, Bonta, Calderon, Carrillo, Cervantes, Chau, Chiu, Chu, Daly, Eggman, Friedman, Gabriel, Cristina Garcia, Eduardo Garcia, Gipson, Gloria, Gonzalez, Gray, Grayson, Holden, Irwin, Jones-Sawyer, Kalra, Kamlager-Dove, Levine, Limón, Low, Maienschein, McCarty, Medina, Mullin, Muratsuchi, Nazarian, O'Donnell, Petrie-Norris, Quirk, Quirk-Silva, Ramos, Reyes, Luz Rivas, Robert Rivas, Rodriguez, Salas, Santiago, Smith, Mark Stone, Ting, Wicks, Wood, Rendon
NOES: Bigelow, Chen, Choi, Cooley, Cunningham, Dahle, Flora, Fong, Gallagher, Kiley, Lackey, Mathis, Mayes, Melendez, Obernolte, Patterson, Voepel, Waldron
NO VOTE RECORDED: Arambula, Brough, Burke, Cooper, Diep, Frazier, Blanca Rubio, Weber
Prepared by: Ian Johnson / ED. /
9/3/19 11:14:18
**** END ****
SENATE COMMITTEE ON
Senator Anthony Portantino, Chair
2019 - 2020 Regular Session
AB 1507 (Smith) - Charter schools: location: resource center
Version: | Policy Vote: |
Urgency: | Mandate: |
Hearing Date: | Consultant: |
Bill Summary:
This bill eliminates the authorization for a charter school to be located outside the boundaries of their authorizer and allows a nonclassroom-based charter school to establish one resource center within the jurisdiction of the school district where the charter school is located, as specified.
*********** ANALYSIS ADDENDUM – SUSPENSE FILE ***********
The following information is revised to reflect amendments
adopted by the committee on August 30, 2019
Fiscal Impact:
This bill could result in unknown but significant local costs, potentially in the millions of dollars, for charter schools that are forced to shut down or relocate existing resource centers. A precise amount would depend on a variety of factors that are difficult to quantify, including the number of schools that would be affected. These costs would not be eligible for mandate reimbursement; however, charter schools may receive funding through the K12 Mandate Block Grant.
Author Amendments:
Exempt charter schools located on a federally recognized California Indian reservation or Rancheria or operated by a federally recognized California Indian tribe and require the State Department of Education to regard a charter school approved, a specified, as a continuing charter school for all purposes.
Committee Amendments:
Provide that a charter school that operates a resource center located in a school district outside of the boundaries of the charter school’s authorizing district may continue to operate the existing resource center if all of the following conditions are met:
- The charter school is authorized by, and physically located in, a district adjacent to a school district with enrollment of at least 500,000 pupils.
- The charter school operating the resource center was established before January 1, 2009.
- The resource center is physically located in a school district with enrollment of at least 500,000 pupils and was established before January 1, 2011.
- The resource center serves a pupil population of which at least 50 percent of the pupils are currently or formerly on probation or formerly incarcerated individuals.
-- END --
SENATE COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Senator Anthony Portantino, Chair
2019 - 2020 Regular Session
AB 1507 (Smith) - Charter schools: location: resource center
Version: August 13, 2019 | Policy Vote: ED. 4 - 3 |
Urgency: No | Mandate: No |
Hearing Date: August 19, 2019 | Consultant: Lenin Del Castillo |
Bill Summary:
This bill eliminates the authorization for a charter school to be located outside the boundaries of their authorizer and allows a nonclassroom-based charter school to establish one resource center within the jurisdiction of the school district where the charter school is located, as specified.
Fiscal Impact:
This bill could result in unknown but significant local costs, potentially in the millions of dollars, for charter schools that are forced to shut down or relocate existing resource centers. A precise amount would depend on a variety of factors that are difficult to quantify, including the number of schools that would be affected. These costs would not be eligible for mandate reimbursement; however, charter schools may receive funding through the K12 Mandates Block Grant.
Background:
Existing law authorizes a charter school that is unable to locate within the jurisdiction of the chartering school district to establish one site outside the boundaries of the authorizer, but within the county in which that school district is located, if the school district within the jurisdiction of which the charter school proposes to operate is notified in advance of the charter petition approval, the county superintendent of schools and the Superintendent of Public Instruction (SPI) are notified of the location of the charter school before it commences operations, and either of the following circumstances exists:
- The school has attempted to locate a single site or facility to house the entire program, but a site or facility is unavailable in the area in which the school chooses to locate.
- The site is needed for temporary use during a construction or expansion project.
Existing law authorizes a charter school to establish a resource center, meeting space, or other satellite facility located in a county adjacent to that in which the charter school is authorized if the following conditions are met:
- The facility is used exclusively for the educational support of pupils who are enrolled in nonclassroom-based independent study of the charter school; and
- The charter school provides its primary educational services in, and a majority of the pupils it serves are residents of, the county in which the charter school is authorized.
Charter schools are public schools that provide instruction in any combination of grades kindergarten through 12. In 1992, the state enacted legislation allowing charter schools in California to offer parents an alternative to traditional public schools and encourage local leaders to experiment with new educational programs. Except where specifically noted otherwise, California law exempts charter schools from many of the statutes and regulations that apply to school districts. Generally, all charter schools must (1) provide nonsectarian instruction, (2) charge no tuition, and (3) admit all interested students up to school capacity. To both open and continue operating, a charter school must have an approved charter setting forth a comprehensive vision for the school.
Over the last decade, charter school enrollment has grown steadily. In 2006, 560 charter schools served about 200,000 students (3.5 percent of the state’s K-12 enrollment). By 2016, over 1,200 charter schools served about 580,000 students (almost 10 percent of the state’s K-12 enrollment). Most charter schools are small, compared to traditional public schools, and located in urban areas. The median charter school enrolls about 250 students, whereas the median traditional public school enrolls about 525 students. Together, nine Bay Area counties, Los Angeles County, and San Diego County account for more than 60 percent of all charter schools and charter school enrollment in the state.
Charter schools can be conversions of existing public schools or new startup schools. About 15 percent of charter schools are conversions, with the remaining 85 percent being startups. Of these, about 80 percent offer traditional, classroom-based instruction and 20 percent offer some form of independent study, such as distance learning or home study.
Proposed Law:
This bill deletes the authorization for a charter school that is unable to locate within the geographic boundaries of the chartering school district to establish one site outside the boundaries of the school district, but within the county.
This bill authorizes a charter school that established one site outside the boundaries of the chartering school district, but within the county, before January 1, 2020, to continue to operate the site until the charter school submits a request for the renewal of its charter petition, and requires approval in writing from the school district where the site is operating prior to submitting the renewal.
This bill authorizes a charter school operating in an area subject to a presidential declaration of a major disaster to relocate the charter school outside of the area for no more than five years, subject to the approval in writing from the school district where the site is operating, and specifies that if a charter school was relocated from December 31, 2016 to December 31, 2019, inclusive, due to a Presidential declaration of a major disaster or emergency, that charter school shall be allowed to return to its original campus location in perpetuity.
This bill exempt a charter schools located on federally recognized California Indian reservation or rancheria operated by a federally recognized California Indian tribe from its provisions.
This bill specifies that a charter school may establish additional resource centers, meetings spaces, or other satellite facilities within the jurisdiction of its authorizing school district only if the charter school is physically located within the jurisdiction of its authorizing school district and after obtaining approval in writing from its authorizing school district for each resource center, meeting space, or other satellite facility.
This bill authorizes a charter school that was operating a resource center, meeting space, or other satellite facility outside the jurisdiction of the school district where the charter school is physically located before January 1, 2020, to continue that facility until the charter submits a request for the renewal of the charter petition, and requires approval in writing from the school district where the facility is operating, prior to submitting the renewal.
This bill authorizes a charter school operating a resource center, meeting space, or other satellite facility in an area subject to a presidential declaration of a major disaster, to continue to operate the site until the charter school submits a renewal request, with the written approval of the school district where the site is located.
This bill authorizes a countywide charter school approved by a county office of education that is operating a resource center, meeting space, or other satellite facility in a county other than the county in which the countywide charter school is authorized before January 1, 2020, to continue to operate that resource center, meeting space, or other satellite facility until the countywide charter school submits a request for the renewal of its charter petition. To continue operating the resource center, meeting space, or other satellite facility, the countywide charter school, before submitting the request to the countywide charter school’s chartering authority for the renewal of the charter petition, shall obtain approval in writing from the county office of education where the resource center, meeting space, or other satellite facility is operating.
Related Legislation:
AB 1505 (O’Donnell) makes various reforms to the charter school authorization, renewal, and appeals process. This bill is scheduled to be heard by this Committee on August 19, 2019.
Staff Comments:
By requiring a charter school that has a site located outside of the boundaries of their authorizing school district to obtain approval from the school district where the site is physically operating, this bill could potentially result in certain charter schools being forced to close down. They could then submit a new petition with the district in which they are physically located and go through the same administrative processes required of new schools. The number of charter schools that could be affected is unknown. Assuming just 10 percent or 100 charters statewide would either close all together or need to relocate at least one of their existing resource centers, the bill would result in significant local costs for these schools. These costs could include the administrative expenses related to submitting a new petition, establishing new facilities or lease agreements, terminating existing leases, moving expenses, and hiring new staff. Additionally, because several state and federal funding sources are allocated based on prior year attendance figures—the state Mandates Block Grant, College Readiness Block Grant, Educator Effectiveness Grant, and Lottery, these charter schools that would not receive those funds in their first year of operation.
To the extent that the bill leads to permanent school closures and students must transfer to a traditional public school, there may be a local fiscal impact which will vary depending on the type of district, the number of students that transfer, and whether those students qualify for supplemental or concentration grant funding (unduplicated students) under the Local Control Funding Formula (LCFF). For example, a district would generate additional LCFF base grants if additional students transfer to that district. Further, to the extent these are unduplicated students that are transferring, the school district is not currently receiving concentration grant funding, and the transfer of these students now makes them eligible, this could trigger additional LCFF funds for that district. Conversely, if a single or small group of students transfer from one large district to another, those students are unlikely to change the LCFF amount at the new district (outside of the additional base grants for their ADA).
-- END --
SENATE COMMITTEE ON EDUCATION
Senator Connie Leyva, Chair
2019 - 2020 Regular
Bill No: Hearing Date: July 10, 2019
Author: | Smith | ||
Version: |
| ||
Urgency: | Fiscal: | ||
Consultant: | |||
Subject: .
NOTE: This bill has been referred to the Committees on Education and Appropriations. A "do pass" motion should include referral to the Committee on Appropriations.
SUMMARY
This bill eliminates the authorization for a charter school to be located outside the boundaries of their authorizer and allows a nonclassroom-based charter school to establish one resource center within the jurisdiction of the school district where the charter school is located, as specified.
BACKGROUND
Existing law:
- Authorizes a charter school that is unable to locate within the jurisdiction of the chartering school district to establish one site outside the boundaries of the authorizer, but within the county in which that school district is located, if the school district within the jurisdiction of which the charter school proposes to operate is notified in advance of the charter petition approval, the county superintendent of schools and the Superintendent of Public Instruction (SPI) are notified of the location of the charter school before it commences operations, and either of the following circumstances exists:
- The school has attempted to locate a single site or facility to house the entire program, but a site or facility is unavailable in the area in which the school chooses to locate.
- The site is needed for temporary use during a construction or expansion project.
- Authorizes a charter school to establish a resource center, meeting space, or other satellite facility located in a county adjacent to that in which the charter school is authorized if the following conditions are met:
- The facility is used exclusively for the educational support of pupils who are enrolled in nonclassroom-based independent study of the charter school; and
- The charter school provides its primary educational services in, and a majority of the pupils it serves are residents of, the county in which the charter school is authorized.
ANALYSIS
This bill:
- Deletes the authorization for a charter school that is unable to locate within the geographic boundaries of the chartering school district to establish one site outside the boundaries of the school district, but within the county.
- Authorizes a charter school that established one site outside the boundaries of the chartering school district, but within the county, before January 1, 2020, to continue to operate the site until the charter school submits a request for the renewal of its charter petition, and requires approval in writing from the school district where the site is operating prior to submitting the renewal.
- Authorizes a charter school operating in an area subject to a presidential declaration of a major disaster to relocate the charter school outside of the area for no more than five years, subject to the approval in writing from the school district where the site is operating.
- Specifies that if a charter school was relocated from December 31, 2016 to December 31, 2019, inclusive, due to a Presidential declaration of a major disaster or emergency, that charter school shall be allowed to return to its original campus location in perpetuity.
- Exempt a charter schools located on federally recognized California Indian reservation or rancheria operated by a federally recognized California Indian tribe from its provisions.
- Specifies that a charter school may establish one resource center within the jurisdiction of the school district where the charter school is physically located.
- Authorizes a charter school that was operating a resource center, meeting space, or other satellite facility outside the jurisdiction of the school district where the charter school is physically located before January 1, 2020, to continue that facility until the charter submits a request for the renewal of the charter petition, and requires approval in writing from the school district where the facility is operating, prior to submitting the renewal.
- Authorizes a charter school operating a resource center, meeting space, or other satellite facility in an area subject to a presidential declaration of a major disaster, to continue to operate the site until the charter school submits a renewal request, with the written approval of the school district where the site is located.
- Authorizes a countywide charter school approved by a county office of education that is operating a resource center, meeting space, or other satellite facility in a county other than the county in which the countywide charter school is authorized before January 1, 2020, to continue to operate that resource center, meeting space, or other satellite facility until the countywide charter school submits a request for the renewal of its charter petition. To continue operating the resource center, meeting space, or other satellite facility, the countywide charter school, before submitting the request to the countywide charter school’s chartering authority for the renewal of the charter petition, shall obtain approval in writing from the county office of education where the resource center, meeting space, or other satellite facility is operating.
STAFF COMMENTS
- Need for the bill. According to the author, “I am authoring AB 1507 to continue to address charter transparency goals that have been set forth by Governor Newsom and the Legislature. This bill eliminates loopholes in current law which allow charter schools to operate outside of their authorizing district. This bill restores the right of individual districts to have oversight of schools located within their boundaries. In my tenure as a school board member, neighboring school districts abused this loophole and authorization privilege, and families were impacted because of this. The bill clarifies the jurisdictional sovereignty of the duly elected school boards and their role in charter authorization.”
- Charter school overview. Charter schools are public schools that provide instruction in any combination of grades kindergarten through 12. In 1992, the state enacted legislation allowing charter schools in California to offer parents an alternative to traditional public schools and encourage local leaders to experiment with new educational programs. Except where specifically noted otherwise, California law exempts charter schools from many of the statutes and regulations that apply to school districts. Generally, all charter schools must (1) provide nonsectarian instruction, (2) charge no tuition, and (3) admit all interested students up to school capacity. To both open and continue operating, a charter school must have an approved charter setting forth a comprehensive vision for the school.
Over the last decade, charter school enrollment has grown steadily. In 2006, 560 charter schools served about 200,000 students (3.5 percent of the state’s K-12 enrollment). By 2016, over 1,200 charter schools served about 580,000 students (almost 10 percent of the state’s K-12 enrollment). Most charter schools are small, compared to traditional public schools, and located in urban areas. The median charter school enrolls about 250 students, whereas the median traditional public school enrolls about 525 students. Together, nine Bay Area counties, Los Angeles County, and San Diego County account for more than 60 percent of all charter schools and charter school enrollment in the state.
Charter schools can be conversions of existing public schools or new startup schools. About 15 percent of charter schools are conversions, with the remaining 85 percent being startups. Of these, about 80 percent offer traditional, classroom-based instruction and 20 percent offer some form of independent study, such as distance learning or home study.
- Charter school oversight. A charter school must promptly respond to all reasonable inquiries from its chartering authority, the county office of education that has jurisdiction over the school’s chartering authority, or from the SPI. Each chartering authority is also required to: (1) identify at least one staff member as a contact person for the charter school, (2) visit each charter school annually, (3) ensure that each charter school complies with reporting requirements, (4) monitor the fiscal condition of each charter school under its authority, and (5) provide timely notification to the California Department of Education (CDE) if an existing charter is renewed, revoked, or ceased. Charter schools must annually submit reports to its chartering authority and county superintendent of schools including budget information, interim financial reports, and audits. The chartering authority is tasked with using any financial information it obtains from the charter school to assess the fiscal condition of the charter school.
- When can a charter school locate outside the boundaries of its authorizer? A charter school that is unable to locate within the jurisdiction of the authorizing school district may establish one site outside the boundaries of the school district, but within the same county, if the following conditions are satisfied:
- The school district in which the charter school proposes to operate is notified in advance of the charter petition approval;
- The county superintendent of schools and the SPI are notified of the location of the charter school before it commences operations; and either of the following circumstances exists:
- The charter school has attempted to locate a single site or facility to house the entire program, but a site or facility is unavailable in the area in which the charter school chooses to locate.
- The site is needed for temporary use during a construction or expansion project.
- Where can nonclassroom-based charter schools locate? Nonclassroom-based charter schools, those not operating in a traditional brick-and-mortar settings, may establish a resource center, meeting space, or other satellite facility in a county adjacent to the county in which the school was approved if the following apply:
- The facility is used exclusively for the educational support of pupils who are enrolled in nonclassroom-based independent study; and
- The charter school provides its primary educational services in, and a majority of the pupils it serves are residents of, the county in which the charter was authorized.
A 2016 court decision in Anderson Union High School District v. Shasta Secondary Home School upheld the geographic restrictions on the location of satellite facilities—specifically that a nonclassroom-based charter can locate a facility in a county that is adjacent to the county in which the authorizer is located, but not in another district within the same county as the authorizing district. This decision led numerous charter schools to apply for waivers from the State Board of Education (SBE), as the location of their resource centers were out of compliance with the law. In 2017, the SBE received 55 waivers that were approved on a one time basis, to give time for these resource centers to come into compliance with the law.
- Some districts have authorized charter schools operating in other districts to generate revenue. While existing law allows a charter school to locate a facility in a school district other than the one it is authorized by under a limited number of circumstances, there have been high-profile instances of school districts authorizing charter schools outside of the district in order to generate revenue through oversight fees. In the Santa Clarita area, the Acton-Agua Dulce Unified School District authorized a charter school that was subsequently located in another school district that had previously denied the school. In return, the school then paid a 3.5 percent oversight fee to the school district. Though the situation in Santa Clarita has brought more attention to this statewide problem, other school districts, including Los Angeles Unified, Culver City Unified, Beverly Hills Unified, Pomona Unified, and San Diego Unified have all had charter schools located within their boundaries by other school districts.
- State Auditor report found that existing laws are ineffective. A 2017 report by the State Auditor found:
- “Requirements related to districts’ authorizations of charter schools outside their geographical boundaries are vague and ineffective.
- Districts we visited authorized charter schools outside of their districts that, in effect, expanded the districts’ reach into neighboring communities.
- Districts that authorize out‑of‑district charter schools are not accountable to the communities in which the schools are located (host districts) because residents in host districts cannot vote for an authorizing district’s school board.
- Authorizing districts can significantly increase their enrollments and revenue by authorizing out‑of‑district schools.
- The State is unable to determine how many out-of-district charter school locations exist. We found that over 10 percent of the State’s charter schools have at least one school outside of the authorizing district’s boundaries.
- We identified oversight issues at the three districts we visited.
- None had formal procedures for evaluating their charter schools’ financial information so as to respond to indicators of financial distress.
- The level of financial and academic oversight conducted by each district varied significantly due to vague state laws.
- The three districts could not demonstrate that they consistently monitored the academic performance of their charter schools, even though they performed below the average of comparable schools.”
- “Requirements related to districts’ authorizations of charter schools outside their geographical boundaries are vague and ineffective.
- Charter School Task Force report. The Governor has previously stated that rising charter school enrollments in some urban districts are having real impacts on those districts’ ability to provide essential support and services for their students. The Governor requested the SPI to convene a group of experts to closely examine the impact of charter school growth on district budgets and to provide a report and recommendations by July 1, 2019. The task force included 11 individuals—5 representing school labor or administrator groups, 4 representing charter schools, and 2 local education agency (LEA) superintendents.
On June 6, 2019, the SPI submitted the California Charter School Policy Task Force Report to the Governor. The report includes the following recommendations for which there was unanimous support:
- Extend the timeline to approve or deny a new charter school petition an additional 30 days.
- Create a statewide entity to develop standards for providing oversight to charter schools and provide training for authorizers.
- Include students transferring to charters schools in the average daily attendance “hold harmless” calculation for school districts.
- Provide additional discretion when considering a new charter school authorization and amend the role of CDE in oversight.
The report also includes the following recommendations for which there was majority support:
- Enact a one-year moratorium on the establishment of virtual charter schools.
- Remove the California State Board of Education from hearing appeals of charter petition denials.
- Limit the authorization of new charter schools to local districts with an appeals process that takes place at the County Board of Education only when there was an error by the district governing board.
- Prohibit districts from authorizing charter schools located outside of district boundaries.
- Allow authorizers to consider fiscal impact as part of the authorization process.
- Establish clear guidelines for use by authorizers and by charter applicants for new charter petitions.
- Update Education Code requirements to reflect current state accountability.
The report also notes that amending current law such that school districts “may” approve charter petitions instead of school districts “shall” approve charter schools, as specified, was not supported by the majority.
- How would a charter school that is forced to petition the district in which they are located be affected by this bill? By requiring a charter school that has a site located outside of the boundaries of their authorizing school district to obtain approval in writing from the school district where the site is operating, this bill could result in certain charter schools being forced to close down and submit a new charter petition with the district in which they are physically located (rather than just submit a petition for renewal with their current out-of-district authorizer). While the charter school itself would not be new, it would still have to go through the same administrative processes required of new schools. These processes alone can be costly. Moreover, because several state and federal funding sources are allocated based on prior year attendance figures—the state Mandates Block Grant, College Readiness Block Grant, Educator Effectiveness Grant, Lottery, and certain federal block grants—new charter schools would not receive these funds in their first year of operation.
Given the stated goal of this measure, a one-time reduction in state and federal revenues for certain charter schools that need to reclassify their school for authorizer compliance purposes appears to be an unintended consequence. The author should consider adding a hold harmless funding mechanism for these charter schools, if not also a one-time authorizer transition process of some kind.
- Committee amendment. As currently drafted, this bill would limit the number of resource centers, meetings spaces, or other satellite facilities that can be located within the jurisdiction of the school district where a charter school is physically located to one. This limitation appears to be modeled after the current limit of allowing charter schools to establish a (one) resource center located in an adjacent county, under specified circumstances. Given that this bill would limit the location of resource centers to the boundaries of the school district where the charter is operating, it is unclear why capping the number of resource centers under any and all circumstances at one is necessary. For example, students that reside in a geographically large district attending a nonclassroom-based charter school may have better access to tutoring if more than one resource center can be established.
If it is the desire of the Committee to pass this measure, staff recommends amending the bill to allow a charter school to establish additional resource centers, meetings spaces, or other satellite facilities within the jurisdiction of its authorizing school district only if the charter school is physically located within the jurisdiction of its authorizing school district and after obtaining approval in writing from its authorizing school district for each resource center, meeting space, or other satellite facility.
SUPPORT
American Federation of State, County and Municipal Employees
California Association of Suburban School Districts
California-Hawaii State Conference of the NAACP
California Labor Federation
California School Boards Association
California State Association of Electrical Workers
California State Pipe Trades Council
California State PTA
California Teachers Association
Democrats for Neighborhood Action
Sulphur Springs Union School District
Townsend Public Affairs
Western States Council Sheet Metal, Air, Rail and Transportation
OPPOSITION
Able Charter Schools
Academia Avance
Ace Charter Schools
AeroSTEM Academy
Afisha Media Group
Alder Grove Charter School
Alliance College-Ready Public Schools
Alma Fuerte Public School
Alpha Public Schools
Alta Public Schools
Anahuacalmecac World School
Apex Academy
Ari Community Services
Arts in Action Community Charter Schools
Aspire Public Schools
Audeo Charter School
Bach Viet Association
Baypoint Preparatory Academy
Bella Mente Montessori Academy
Barona Band of Mission Indians
Bright Star Schools
Bullis Charter School
Cahuilla Band of Mission Indians
California Black Chamber of Commerce Foundation
Caliber Schools
California Connections Academy
California Pacific Charter Schools
Camino Nuevo Charter Academy
Campo Band of Kumeyaay Indians
Champs Charter High School of the Arts
Charter Schools Development Center
Chemehuevi Indian Tribe
Chico Country Day School
Chime Institute
Citizens of the World Charter School
City Charter Schools
Collegiate Charter High School of Los Angeles
Community School for Creative Education
Core Charter School
Creative Arts Charter School
Da Vinci Connect
Da Vinci Schools
Desert Trails Preparatory Academy
Ednovate
Education for Change
Eel River Charter School
El Sol Science and Arts Academy
Elk Grove Charter School
Endeavor College Prep
Environmental Charter Schools
Envision Education
Epic Charter School
Escuela Popular
Ewiiaapaayp Band of Kumeyaay Indians
Excelencia Charter Academy
Excelsior Charter Schools
Extera Public Schools
Fenton Charter Public Schools
Forest Charter School
Gabriella Charter Schools
Gateway College and Career Academy
Gateway Community Charters
Girls Athletic Leadership Schools Los Angeles
Global Education Collaborative
Goals Academy
Gorman Learning Charter Network
Greater Bakersfield Chamber of Commerce
Green Dot Public Schools California
Grimmway Schools
Grossmont Secondary School
Growth Public Schools
Guajome Schools
Hawking Steam Charter School
Heritage Peak Charter School
High Tech Los Angeles
Highlands Community Charter School
Icef Public Schools
Iipay Nation of Santa Ysabel
Ilead California charter schools
Inaja-Cosmit Band of Indians
Ingenium schools
Inspire Charter Schools
International School for Science and Culture
Isana Academies
Ivy Academia Entrepreneurial Charter School
James Jordan Middle School
Jamul Indian Village a Kumeyaay Nation
John Muir Charter Schools
Julian Charter School
Kairos Public Schools
Kavod Charter School
Kid Street Learning Center Charter School
Kinetic Academy
KIPP Bay Area Public Schools
KIPP Bayview Academy
KIPP Bayview Elementary
KIPP Bridge Academy
KIPP LA Public Schools
La Jolla Band of Luiseño Indians
La Posta Band of Mission Indians
La Verne Elementary Preparatory Academy
La Vida Charter School
Language Academy of Sacramento
Larchmont Charter School
Lashon Academy
Leadership Public Schools
League of California Cities
Learn4Life Assurance Learning Academy
Leonardo da Vinci Health Sciences Charter School
Libertas College Preparatory Charter School
Lighthouse Charter School
Lighthouse Community Public Schools
Literacy First Charter Schools
Los Angeles Academy of Arts and Enterprise
Los Angeles International Charter School
Los Angeles Leadership Academy
Los Coyotes Band of Cahuilla and Cupeño Indians
Los Feliz Charter School for the Arts
Magnolia Public Schools
Making Waves Academy
Manzanita Band of the Kumeyaay Nation
Mesa Grande Band of Mission Indians
Mirus Secondary School
Multicultural Learning Center
National Action Network
Navigator Schools
New Academy of Sciences and Arts
New Designs Charter School
New Horizons Charter Academy
New Los Angeles Charter Schools
New West Charter
Norton Science and Language Academy
Nova Academy Early College High School
Oakland Unity High School
Odyssey Charter Schools
Olive Grove Charter School
Orange County Academy of Sciences and Arts
Orange County Educational Arts Academy
Pacific Charter Institute
Pacific Community Charter School
Pacoima Charter School
Pala Band of Mission Indians
Palisades Charter High School
Partnerships to Uplift Communities Schools
Pauma Band of Luiseño Indians
Perseverance Prep
Pivot Charter Schools
Plumas Charter School
Public Safety Academy of San Bernardino
Puente Charter School
Redwood Academy of Ukiah
Redwood Preparatory Charter
Resolute Academy
Rex and Margaret Fortune School of Education
Rincon Band of Luiseño Indians
Rio Valley Charter School
Rocketship Public Schools
Rocklin Academy Family of Schools
Ross Valley Charter School
Sacramento Area League of Associated Muslims
Sacramento Black Chamber of Commerce
Sacramento Music Summit "The Creative Exchange"
Sacramento Valley Charter School
Samueli Academy
San Diego Cooperative Charter Schools
San Diego Global Vision Academy
San Jose Charter Academy
San Jose Conservation Corps & Charter School
San Pasqual Band of Mission Indians
Santa Rosa Academy
Santa Rosa Band of Cahuilla Indians
Scholarship Prep Charter School
Sebastopol Independent Charter
Shasta Charter Academy
Sherman Thomas Charter School
Slicon Schools Fund
Soar Charter Academy
Sol Aureus College Preparatory
Soleil Academy
Southern California Tribal Chairmen's Association
Springs Charter School
Springs Charter Schools
St Hope Public Schools
Stem Prep Schools
Summit Leadership Academy High Desert
Summit Public Schools
Sutter Peak Charter Academy
Sweetwater Secondary School
Sycamore Academy of Science and Cultural Arts
Sycamore Creek Community Charter School
Sycuan Band of the Kumeyaay Nation
Taylion Academy
TEACH Public Schools
The Academies
The Charter School of San Diego
The Foundation for Hispanic Education
The New School of San Francisco
The Preuss School UCSD
Thrive Public Schools
Tree of Life Charter School
Twin Ridges Home Study Charter School
University High School
University Preparatory Academy
Urban Discovery Academy
Valley Charter School
Vaughn Next Century Learning Center
Ventura Charter School of Arts and Global Education
Viejas Band of Kumeyaay Indians
Village Charter Academy
Visions in Education
Vista Charter Public Schools
Voices College Bound Language Academies
Vox Collegiate of Los Angeles
Western Sierra Charter Schools
Westlake Charter School
Willits Charter School
Willow Creek Academy
Wish Charter Schools
Yes Charter Academy
Young, Minney & Corr, LLP
Youth Policy Institute Charter Schools
-- END --
ASSEMBLY THIRD READING
ATR Bill Id:AB 1507
Author:(Smith, et al.)
As Amended Ver:May 9, 2019
Majority vote
SUMMARY:
Eliminates the authorization for a charter school to be located outside the boundaries of their authorizer in specified instances; and, authorizes a nonclassroom-based charter school to establish one resource center within the jurisdiction of the school district where the charter school is located, subject to specified conditions for currently operating schools and specified facilities.
Major Provisions
- Deletes the authorization for a charter school that is unable to locate within the geographic boundaries of the chartering school district to establish one site outside the boundaries of the school district, but within the county.
- Authorizes a charter school that established one site outside the boundaries of the school district, but within the county, before January 1, 2020, to continue to operate the site until the charter school submits a request for the renewal of its charter petition, and requires approval in writing from the school district where the site is operating prior to submitting the renewal.
- Authorizes a charter school operating in an area subject to a presidential declaration of a major disaster to relocate the charter school outside of the area for no more than five years, subject to the approval in writing from the school district where the site is operating.
- Specifies that a charter school may establish one resource center within the jurisdiction of the school district where the charter school is physically located.
- Authorizes a charter school that was operating a resource center, meeting space, or other satellite facility outside the jurisdiction of the school district where the charter school is physically located before January 1, 2020, to continue that facility until the charter submits a request for the renewal of the charter petition, and requires approval in writing from the school district where the facility is operating, prior to submitting the renewal.
- Authorizes a charter school operating a resource center, meeting space, or other satellite facility in an area subject to a presidential declaration of a major disaster, to continue to operate the site until the charter school submits a renewal request, with the written approval of the school district where the site is located.
COMMENTS:
History of Charters Sited Outside their Authorizing Agency: California law gives school districts and county offices the authority to authorize and oversee charter schools operating within their boundaries. In most cases, charter schools are located within the boundaries of the local educational agency that authorized the school. However, current law allows a charter school to locate a facility in a school district other than the one it is authorized by under a limited number of circumstances. There have been a number of high-profile cases in which school districts have authorized charter schools outside of the district in order to generate revenue through "oversight fees." In the Santa Clarita area, the Acton-Agua Dulce Unified School District authorized a charter school that was subsequently located in another school district that had previously denied the school. In return, the school then paid a 3.5% oversight fee to the school district. Other school districts have had charter schools located within their boundaries by other school districts
According to the Author:
I am authoring this bill to address charter transparency goals that have been set forth by Governor Newsom and the Legislature. This bill eliminates loopholes in current law which allow charter schools to operate outside of their authorizing district. This bill restores the right of individual districts to have oversight of schools located within their boundaries. In my tenure as a school board member, neighboring school districts abused this loophole and authorization privilege, and families were impacted because of this. The bill clarifies the jurisdictional sovereignty of the duly elected school boards and their role in charter authorization.
Arguments in Support:
According to the School Employers Association of California, "State and local entities have little authority to enforce the law. Charter schools in various parts of the state have abused this lack of enforcement authority by taking advantage of the narrow circumstances under which a charter school to locate outside of the authorizing district. Once the charter school has set up operations in a neighboring district, it often stays. No government entity, except the authorizing district, has the practical ability to require the charter school comply with current law. This clearly violates the sovereign ability of each school district to determine which charter schools meet the statutory requirements for approval. In fact, despite school board votes to deny a particular charter school, the same charter school has attempted to locate in those districts."
Arguments in Opposition:
According to the Charter Schools Development Center, "This measure deletes the authority in current law that allows charter schools to locate outside of the charter-granting district's boundaries when facilities are either 1) unavailable inside district boundaries or 2) during a temporary construction or expansion project. Previously, a charter school that was unable to locate a facility within the boundaries of its authorizing district, could locate in a facility within the same county. This common sense rule allowed new or growing charters some flexibility and was welcomed by both charters and by authorizing districts that were unable or unwilling to make taxpayer-funded district space available as the law requires. Deleting this provision from law will likely increase charter pressure on the authorizing district to find existing district buildings for new and growing charter schools and it even means sharing facilities and co-locating on traditional district public school sites."
FISCAL COMMENTS:
The Office of Legislative Counsel has keyed this bill as non-fiscal.
VOTES:
ASM EDUCATION: 4-1-1
YES: O'Donnell, Kalra, McCarty, Smith
NO: Kiley
ABS, ABST OR NV: Weber
UPDATED:
VERSION: May 9, 2019
CONSULTANT: Chelsea Kelley / ED. / (916) 319-2087 FN: 0000405
ASSEMBLY THIRD READING
ATR Bill Id:AB 1507
Author:(Smith, et al.)
As Amended Ver:April 22, 2019
Majority vote
SUMMARY:
Eliminates the authorization for a charter school to be located outside the boundaries of their authorizer in specified instances; and, authorizes a nonclassroom-based charter school to establish one resource center within the jurisdiction of the school district where the charter school is located.
Major Provisions
- Deletes the authorization for a charter school that is unable to locate within the geographic boundaries of the chartering school district to establish one site outside the boundaries of the school district, but within the county.
- Specifies that, notwithstanding any other law, a charter school may establish one resource
center within the jurisdiction of the school district where the charter school is physically located.
COMMENTS:
This bill deletes the current authorization for a charter school to locate outside the jurisdiction of the chartering school district, when a site is unavailable within the jurisdiction of the chartering school district. Further, the bill authorizes a nonclassroom-based charter school to establish one resource center within the jurisdiction of the school district where the school is located.
Background on Charter Schools: According to the California Department of Education (CDE), in the 2018-19 academic year there were 1,317 charter schools in California, with an enrollment of over 630,000 students. Some charter schools are new, while others are conversions from existing public schools. Charter schools are part of the state's public education system and are funded by public dollars. A charter school is usually created or organized by a group of teachers, parents and community leaders, a community-based organization, or an education management organization. Charter schools are authorized by school district boards, county boards of education or the State Board of Education. A charter school is generally exempt from most laws governing school districts, except where specifically noted in the law. Specific goals and operating procedures for the charter school are detailed in an agreement (or "charter") between the sponsoring board and charter organizers.
History of Charters Sited Outside their Authorizing Agency: California law gives school districts and county offices of education the authority to authorize and oversee charter schools operating within their boundaries. In most cases, charter schools are located within the boundaries of the local educational agency that authorized the school. However, current law allows a charter school to locate a facility in a school district other than the one it is authorized by under a limited number of circumstances.
There have been a number of high-profile cases in which school districts have authorized charter schools outside of the district in order to generate revenue through "oversight fees." In the Santa Clarita area, the Acton-Agua Dulce Unified School District authorized a charter school that was subsequently located in another school district that had previously denied the school. In return, the school then paid a 3.5% oversight fee to the school district. Though the situation in Santa Clarita has brought more attention to this statewide problem, other school districts, including Los Angeles Unified, Culver City Unified, Beverly Hills Unified, Pomona Unified, and San Diego Unified have all had charter schools located within their boundaries by other school districts.
According to the Author:
I am authoring AB 1507 to continue to address charter transparency goals that have been set forth by Governor Newsom and the Legislature. This bill eliminates loopholes in current law which allow charter schools to operate outside of their authorizing district. This bill restores the right of individual districts to have oversight of schools located within their boundaries. In my tenure as a school board member, neighboring school districts abused this loophole and authorization privilege, and families were impacted because of this. The bill clarifies the jurisdictional sovereignty of the duly elected school boards and their role in charter authorization.
Arguments in Support:
According to the School Employers Association of California, "State and local entities have little authority to enforce the law. Charter schools in various parts of the state have abused this lack of enforcement authority by taking advantage of the narrow circumstances under which a charter school to locate outside of the authorizing district. Once the charter school has set up operations in a neighboring district, it often stays. No government entity, except the authorizing district, has the practical ability to require the charter school comply with current law. This clearly violates the sovereign ability of each school district to determine which charter schools meet the statutory requirements for approval. In fact, despite school board votes to deny a particular charter school, the same charter school has attempted to locate in those districts."
Arguments in Opposition:
According to the Charter Schools Development Center, "This measure deletes the authority in current law that allows charter schools to locate outside of the charter-granting district's boundaries when facilities are either 1) unavailable inside district boundaries or 2) during a temporary construction or expansion project. Previously, a charter school that was unable to locate a facility within the boundaries of its authorizing district, could locate in a facility within the same county. This common sense rule allowed new or growing charters some flexibility and was welcomed by both charters and by authorizing districts that were unable or unwilling to make taxpayer-funded district space available as the law requires. Deleting this provision from law will likely increase charter pressure on the authorizing district to find existing district buildings for new and growing charter schools and it even means sharing facilities and co-locating on traditional district public school sites."
FISCAL COMMENTS:
This bill is keyed non-fiscal by the Legislative Counsel.
VOTES:
ASM EDUCATION: 4-1-1
YES: O'Donnell, Kalra, McCarty, Smith
NO: Kiley
ABS, ABST OR NV: Weber
UPDATED:
VERSION: April 22, 2019
CONSULTANT: Chelsea Kelley / ED. / (916) 319-2087 FN: 0000214
Date of Hearing: April 10, 2019
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON EDUCATION
Patrick O'Donnell, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 1507 (
Author:Smith, McCarty and O’Donnell) – As Amended Ver:March 26, 2019
SUBJECT: Charter schools: location: resource center
SUMMARY: Eliminates the authorization for a charter school to be located outside the boundaries of their authorizer in specified instances; and, authorizes a nonclassroom-based charter school to establish one resource center within the jurisdiction of the school district where the charter school is located. Specifically, this bill:
- Deletes the authorization for a charter school that is unable to locate within the geographic boundaries of the chartering school district to establish one site outside the boundaries of the school district, but within the county, if the school district in which the charter school proposes to operate is notified in advance of the charter petition approval, the county superintendent of schools is notified of the location of the charter school before it commences operations, and either of the following circumstances exist:
- The charter school has attempted to locate a single site or facility to house the entire program, but such a facility or site is unavailable in the area in which the charter school chooses to locate.
- The site is needed for temporary use during a construction or expansion project.
- Specifies that, notwithstanding any other law, a charter school may establish one resource
center within the jurisdiction of the school district where the charter school is physically located if the following conditions are met:- The facility is used exclusively for the educational support of pupils who are enrolled in nonclassroom-based independent study of the charter school.
- The charter school provides its primary educational services in, and a majority of the pupils it serves are residents of, the county in which the charter school is authorized.
EXISTING LAW:
- Authorizes a charter school that is unable to locate within the jurisdiction of the chartering school district to establish one site outside the boundaries of the authorizer, but within the county in which that school district is located, if the school district within the jurisdiction of which the charter school proposes to operate is notified in advance of the charter petition approval, the county superintendent of schools and the Superintendent of Public Instruction are notified of the location of the charter school before it commences operations, and either of the following circumstances exists:
- The school has attempted to locate a single site or facility to house the entire program, but a site or facility is unavailable in the area in which the school chooses to locate.
- The site is needed for temporary use during a construction or expansion project. (Education Code 47605 and 47605.1)
- Authorizes a charter school to establish a resource center, meeting space, or other satellite facility located in a county adjacent to that in which the charter school is authorized if the following conditions are met:
- The facility is used exclusively for the educational support of pupils who are enrolled in nonclassroom-based independent study of the charter school; and
- The charter school provides its primary educational services in, and a majority of the pupils it serves are residents of, the county in which the charter school is authorized.
FISCAL EFFECT: This bill is keyed non-fiscal by the office of Legislative Counsel.
COMMENTS: This bill deletes the current authorization for a charter school to locate outside the jurisdiction of the chartering school district, when a site is unavailable within the jurisdiction of the chartering school district. Further, the bill authorizes a nonclassroom-based charter school to establish one resource center within the jurisdiction of the school district where the school is located.
Background on Charter Schools: According to the California Department of Education (CDE), in the 2018-19 academic year there were 1,317 charter schools in California, with an enrollment of over 630,000 students. Some charter schools are new, while others are conversions from existing public schools. Charter schools are part of the state's public education system and are funded by public dollars. A charter school is usually created or organized by a group of teachers, parents and community leaders, a community-based organization, or an education management organization. Charter schools are authorized by school district boards, county boards of education or the State Board of Education. A charter school is generally exempt from most laws governing school districts, except where specifically noted in the law. Specific goals and operating procedures for the charter school are detailed in an agreement (or "charter") between the sponsoring board and charter organizers.
According to the Author: “I am authoring AB 1507 to continue to address charter transparency goals that have been set forth by Governor Newsom and the Legislature. This bill eliminates loopholes in current law which allow charter schools to operate outside of their authorizing district. This bill restores the right of individual districts to have oversight of schools located within their boundaries. In my tenure as a school board member, neighboring school districts abused this loophole and authorization privilege, and families were impacted because of this. The bill clarifies the jurisdictional sovereignty of the duly elected school boards and their role in charter authorization.”
Location of Charter Schools. In general, brick-and-mortar charter schools must be located within the boundaries of the chartering authority. However, a charter school may locate outside of the boundaries of the chartering authority, but within the same county, if either of the following conditions occurs:
- A site or facility is not available in the area in which the school chooses to locate; or
- The site is needed for temporary use during a construction or expansion project.
History of Charters Sited Outside their Authorizing Agency: California law gives school districts and county offices of education the authority to authorize and oversee charter schools operating within their boundaries. In most cases, charter schools are located within the boundaries of the local educational agency that authorized the school. However, current law allows a charter school to locate a facility in a school district other than the one it is authorized by under a limited number of circumstances.
There have been a number of high-profile cases in which school districts have authorized charter schools outside of the district in order to generate revenue through “oversight fees.” In the Santa Clarita area, the Acton-Agua Dulce Unified School District authorized a charter school that was subsequently located in another school district that had previously denied the school. In return, the school then paid a 3.5% oversight fee to the school district. Though the situation in Santa Clarita has brought more attention to this statewide problem, other school districts, including Los Angeles Unified, Culver City Unified, Beverly Hills Unified, Pomona Unified, and San Diego Unified have all had charter schools located within their boundaries by other school districts.
State Audit Report: A 2017 report by the State Auditor found:
- “Requirements related to districts’ authorizations of charter schools outside their geographical boundaries are vague and ineffective.
- Districts we visited authorized charter schools outside of their districts that, in effect, expanded the districts’ reach into neighboring communities.
- Districts that authorize out‑of‑district charter schools are not accountable to the communities in which the schools are located (host districts) because residents in host districts cannot vote for an authorizing district’s school board.
- Authorizing districts can significantly increase their enrollments and revenue by authorizing out‑of‑district schools.
- The State is unable to determine how many out-of-district charter school locations exist. We found that over 10 percent of the State’s charter schools have at least one school outside of the authorizing district’s boundaries.
- We identified oversight issues at the three districts we visited.
- None had formal procedures for evaluating their charter schools’ financial information so as to respond to indicators of financial distress.
- The level of financial and academic oversight conducted by each district varied significantly due to vague state laws.
- The three districts could not demonstrate that they consistently monitored the academic performance of their charter schools, even though they performed below the average of comparable schools.”
What is Nonclassroom-based Instruction? Existing law defines charter school nonclassroom-based instruction as instruction that does not meet the requirements of classroom-based instruction. Those requirements are:
- Charter school pupils are engaged in required educational activities and are under the immediate supervision and control of a certificated teacher;
- At least 80% of the instructional time offered by the charter school is at the schoolsite (defined as a facility that is used primarily for classroom instruction); and
- Pupil attendance at the schoolsite is required for at least 80% of the minimum instructional time.
Existing law specifies that nonclassroom-based instruction includes, but is not limited to, independent study, home study, work study, and distance and computer-based education.
The rules for the location of facilities for nonclassroom-based charter schools are different. A nonclassroom-based charter school may establish a resource center, meeting space, or other satellite facility in a county adjacent to the county in which the school was approved if the following apply:
- The facility is used exclusively for the educational support of pupils who are enrolled in nonclassroom-based independent study; and
- The charter school provides its primary educational services in, and a majority of the pupils it serves are residents of, the county in which the charter was authorized.
These geographic restrictions were enacted in 2002 by AB 1994 (Reyes), Chapter 1058, Statutes of 2002, partly in response to the activities of the Gateway Academy Charter School, which was approved by the Fresno Unified School District. After receiving its charter, Gateway established "satellite" facilities (actually, additional schools) in other areas of the state, including Oakland (where it claimed state funding for private school enrollment) and Sunnyvale (where it allegedly provided sectarian instruction and charged tuition). The school's charter was eventually revoked by Fresno and its founder was sentenced to 14 years in prison for financial fraud associated with the operation of the charter school. In the meantime, Fresno claimed that it was difficult to exercise its oversight role over schools that were located so far outside its jurisdiction. AB 2002 addressed this problem by restricting the location of charter school facilities to only adjacent counties and only under specific circumstances.
Anderson Case. A 2016 court decision in Anderson Union High School District v. Shasta Secondary Home School, upheld the geographic restrictions on the location of satellite facilities. The specific issue was the provision in existing law whereby a nonclassroom-based charter can locate a facility in a county that is adjacent to the county in which the authorizer is located, but not in another district within the same county as the authorizing district. This decision led numerous charter schools to apply for waivers from the SBE, as the location of their resource centers were out of compliance with the law. In 2017, the SBE received 55 waivers that were approved on a one time basis, to give time for these resource centers to come into compliance with the law.
The committee may wish to consider the impact of this bill on existing schools that are located outside their authorizer’s jurisdiction and resource centers that will be out of compliance with this bill. It is unclear whether existing schools and resource centers will be grandfathered in, or whether these schools and resource centers will need to seek authorization from their local school district in the future.
Ineffective Instruction at Virtual Schools: The ability to enroll pupils and locate satellite facilities anywhere in the state is especially beneficial to virtual schools, which offer instruction online. However, numerous studies indicate online instruction is not as effective as regular classroom instruction:
- A 2011 study of charter school performance in Pennsylvania by the Center for Research on Education Outcomes (CREDO) at Stanford University found that each of that state's 8 online charter schools ("cyber schools") significantly underperformed brick and mortar schools and regular (non-virtual) charter schools in reading and math.
- Another CREDO study in 2015 concluded that the learning deficit of virtual schools is equivalent to receiving 180 fewer days of math instruction and 72 fewer days of reading instruction. The study's author said that the learning in math was so small that it was "literally as though the student did not go to school for the entire year."
- A review of virtual schools in Wisconsin by the Gannett Wisconsin Media Investigative Team found that students receiving online instruction "often struggle to complete their degrees and repeat grades four times as often as their brick-and-mortar counterparts," and they "trail traditional students in every subject but reading."
- A 2011 report from the Office of the Legislative Auditor in Minnesota reported that full-time online students were more likely to completely drop out of school and made less progress on state standardized math tests than students in traditional schools.
- A 2011 report from the Ohio Department of Education rated only three of Ohio's 27 virtual schools as "effective" or "excellent."
- A 2006 performance audit by the Colorado Department of Education of that state's virtual schools found that, "in the aggregate, online students performed poorly on the CSAP (Colorado State Assessment Program) exams and had higher repeater, attrition, and dropout rates."
- The Florida Virtual Academy, a statewide virtual school, reports that 81% of its students who complete their courses receive a passing grade. However, the Tampa Bay Times reports that the Virtual Academy's records show that two-thirds of students who enroll in a course don't finish it. When dropouts are included, the actual pass rate is 28%. The Times was unable to get Virtual School Florida Comprehensive Assessment Test scores from either the Virtual School or the Florida Department of Education.
A report by “In the Public Interest” ("Virtual Public Education in California," 2015) focused specifically on California Virtual Academy (CAVA) schools, and concluded that "students at CAVA are at risk of low quality educational outcomes, and some are falling through the cracks entirely, in a poorly resourced and troubled educational environment." Among the concerns identified by the report are the following:
- In every year since it began graduating students, except 2013, CAVA has had more dropouts than graduates.
- Students are eligible to be counted as having attended with as little as one minute of log in time each day.
- K12 California (the California subsidiary of K-12, Inc.) pays itself for services out of CAVA school bank accounts that it (K12 California) manages.
- Competitive bidding is prohibited: K12 California contractually prohibits CAVA schools from seeking another vendor for services that K12 California is willing and able to perform.
- CAVA teachers report that the "vast majority" of the work they do is clerical, preventing them from spending sufficient time teaching.
- Limited local control: individual CAVA location governing boards operate under contract to K12 California and do not "have much leeway in terms of budget, program and contracting decisions independent from K12 California."
- K12, Inc. charges CAVA schools more than they can reasonably pay for administrative and technology services. The shortfall is covered by "budget credits" that are extended by K12, Inc., which results in a "perpetual debt" relationship between CAVA schools and K12, Inc.
- CAVA students have lower academic achievement, higher dropout rates, and higher turnover than students enrolled in brick-and-mortar schools.
Many virtual schools in California use a curriculum provided by K12, Inc., a private, for-profit company headquartered in Virginia. In 2014, the NCAA recently announced that it will stop accepting coursework at any Division I or Division II college or university from 24 schools nationwide (13 in California) that use the K12, Inc. curriculum, because "their courses were found to not comply with the NCAA's nontraditional course requirements." Other K12, Inc. schools are currently being evaluated by the NCAA for compliance with its "core course and nontraditional course requirements." A 2012 report by the National Education Policy Center ("Understanding and Improving Full-Time Virtual Schools: A Study of Student Characteristics, School Finance, and School Performance in Schools Operated by K12, Inc.") found that students in K12, Inc. schools have lower academic achievement, higher dropout rates, and higher turnover than students in brick-and-mortar schools.
On every measure of student performance, virtual schools have been shown to consistently underperform brick-and-mortar schools by wide margins. At the same time, pursuant to legislative direction, California has invested heavily in policies to improve student outcomes, including the adoption of rigorous academic content standards, assessments aligned to those standards, and the use of evaluation rubrics (the "Dashboard") to monitor school and district performance and identify districts for targeted assistance.
Arguments in Support: According to the School Employers Association of California, “State and local entities have little authority to enforce the law. Charter schools in various parts of the state have abused this lack of enforcement authority by taking advantage of the narrow circumstances under which a charter school to locate outside of the authorizing district. Once the charter school has set up operations in a neighboring district, it often stays. No government entity, except the authorizing district, has the practical ability to require the charter school comply with current law. This clearly violates the sovereign ability of each school district to determine which charter schools meet the statutory requirements for approval. In fact, despite school board votes to deny a particular charter school, the same charter school has attempted to locate in those districts.”
Arguments in Opposition: According to the Charter Schools Development Center, “This measure deletes the authority in current law that allows charter schools to locate outside of the charter-granting district’s boundaries when facilities are either (1) unavailable inside district boundaries or (2) during a temporary construction or expansion project. Previously, a charter school that was unable to locate a facility within the boundaries of its authorizing district, could locate in a facility within the same county. This common sense rule allowed new or growing charters some flexibility and was welcomed by both charters and by authorizing districts that were unable or unwilling to make taxpayer-funded district space available as the law requires. Deleting this provision from law will likely increase charter pressure on the authorizing district to find existing district buildings for new and growing charter schools and it even means sharing facilities and co-locating on traditional district public school sites.”
Committee Amendments: Staff recommends the bill be amended to:
- Clarify that a nonclassroom-based charter school may not open any other type of meeting space or satellite facility in any other location.
- Require non classroom based charter schools to notify their authorizer of the name and physical location of any resource centers, meeting spaces, or satellite facilities they operate.
- Prohibit the requirements in this bill from being waived by the SBE.
Prior Legislation: AB 2011 (Kiley), from 2018, which failed passage in this committee, would have authorized nonclassroom-based charter schools to enroll students anywhere in the state by exempting them from existing geographical restrictions.
SB 808 (Mendoza) from 2017, which was held in the Senate Education Committee, would have required all charter school petitions to be approved by the governing board of the school district in which the charter school is located, prohibited a charter school from locating outside of its authorizer’s district boundaries, and limited the current charter appeal process to claims of procedural violations. Further, the bill specified that charter schools previously approved by a county board or the state board, and charter schools operating outside of their authorizer’s district boundaries may continue to operate until the charter is required to be renewed.
SB 739 (Pavley) from 2015, which was vetoed by the Governor, would have prohibited the governing board of a school district to authorize new charter schools located outside the boundaries of the school district if the school district is assigned a negative budget certification. Governor’s veto message:
This bill would prohibit a school district that has a negative budget certification from authorizing a charter school to operate outside of their attendance boundaries. This bill attempts to address an issue, currently being reviewed by the State Auditor, whereby school districts authorize multiple charter schools outside of district boundaries to collect oversight fees. Let's review the audit when it's released next spring to better determine the scope of the issue and what, if any, policy changes are necessary.
SB 1263 (Pavley) from 2014, which was vetoed by the Governor, would have authorized a charter school to locate outside the jurisdiction of the chartering school district with written approval from the school district within the jurisdiction of which the charter school chooses to operate and for purposes of construction, as specified; authorized existing charter schools that are located outside the jurisdiction of the chartering school district to continue operation if they were approved prior to April 1, 2013, and are in operation with students enrolled and attending before September 15, 2014; and, prohibited a school district with a negative certification from authorizing new charter schools located outside of their jurisdiction. Governor's veto message:
This bill seeks to reverse the application of a limited exemption in law that allows a charter school petitioner to locate a single school site outside of its authorizing school district, under specific circumstances. This bill would instead require the charter school to first get permission from the host district where it intends to locate.
Unfortunately, it appears that some districts and charter schools have gone against the spirit of the law and the exemption has instead become the rule. This has led to litigation and strained relationships among districts and charter schools.
While this bill attempts to solve a real problem, I am not comfortable with the retroactive language that could force existing charter schools to change locations.
I have assembled a team to examine this situation and come back with solutions that minimize disruption to students and parents.
AB 2954 (Liu) from 2006, which was vetoed by Governor Schwarzenegger, would have added "negative fiscal impact" as a reason for a school district to deny a charter school petition and authorizes a condition for approval of a petition as it relates to providing free and reduced priced meals. Governor's veto message:
While I understand the plight of school districts faced with fiscal challenges of declining enrollment and other management issues, I cannot condone allowing them to deny parents and students their rights to petition for the establishment of a charter school. In essence, this bill would grant school districts the authority to punish charter petitioners because of problems caused by their own fiscal management issues or their unwillingness to make tough decisions, or both.
In addition, allowing school districts to require, as a condition of approval, that the petition describe how the charter school will provide free and reduced-priced meals to eligible pupils would simply provide districts with another pretext on which to deny a charter. Charter schools are generally exempt from most laws and regulations governing school districts and they should continue to be exempt from this one.
In sum, this bill runs counter to the intent of charter schools, which is to provide parents and students with other options within the public school system and to stimulate competition that improves the quality not only of charter schools, but of non-charter schools as well.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
American Federation Of State, County And Municipal Employees, Afl-Cio
California Association Of School Business Officials (Casbo)
California Association Of Suburban School Districts
California Federation Of Teachers
California Labor Federation, Afl-Cio
California School Boards Association
California School Employees Association
California State Association Of Electrical Workers
California State Pipe Trades Council
California State Pta
California Teachers Association
Educators For Democratic Schools
Fresno Unified School District
Newhall School District
Oakland Unified School District
Placer County Superintendent of Schools
San Francisco Unified School District
Santa Barbara Unified School District
School Employers Association Of California
Western States Council Sheet Metal, Air, Rail And Transportation
Individual
Opposition
Aplus+
California Charter Schools Association
Charter Schools Development Center
Core Charter School
Edvoice
Forest Charter School
Hickman Community Charter District
Individual Citizen
Pathways Charter School
Phoenix Charter Academy
Twin Ridges Home Study Charter School
Individuals
Analysis Prepared by: Chelsea Kelley / ED. / (916) 319-2087
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):