AB 1638: Search warrants: vehicle recording devices.
- Session Year: 2019-2020
- House: Assembly
- Latest Version Date: 2019-08-30
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Aug 30, 2019 | Chaptered by Secretary of State - Chapter 196, Statutes of 2019. |
| Aug 30, 2019 | Approved by the Governor. |
| Aug 23, 2019 | Enrolled and presented to the Governor at 3:30 p.m. |
| Aug 19, 2019 | Senate amendments concurred in. To Engrossing and Enrolling. |
| Aug 15, 2019 | In Assembly. Concurrence in Senate amendments pending. May be considered on or after August 17 pursuant to Assembly Rule 77. |
| Aug 15, 2019 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Assembly. |
| Jul 8, 2019 | Read second time and amended. Ordered to third reading. |
| Jul 5, 2019 | From committee: Amend, and do pass as amended. (Ayes 4. Noes 0.) (July 2). |
| May 22, 2019 | Referred to Com. on PUB. S. |
| May 9, 2019 | In Senate. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. |
| May 9, 2019 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Senate. |
| May 2, 2019 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| May 1, 2019 | From committee: Do pass. (Ayes 9. Noes 0.) (April 30). |
| Apr 22, 2019 | Re-referred to Com. on P. & C.P. |
| Apr 11, 2019 | Read second time and amended. |
| Apr 10, 2019 | From committee: Amend, and do pass as amended and re-refer to Com. on P. & C.P. (Ayes 5. Noes 0.) (April 9). |
| Mar 18, 2019 | Referred to Coms. on PUB. S. and P. & C.P. |
| Feb 25, 2019 | Read first time. |
| Feb 23, 2019 | From printer. May be heard in committee March 25. |
| Feb 22, 2019 | Introduced. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Aug 19, 2019 | AB 1638 Obernolte Concurrence in Senate Amendments | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| Aug 15, 2019 | Assembly 3rd Reading AB1638 Obernolte By Wiener | Senate Floor |
Passed |
|
| Jul 2, 2019 | Do pass as amended | Senate Standing Committee on Public Safety |
Passed |
|
| May 9, 2019 | AB 1638 Obernolte Assembly Third Reading | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| Apr 30, 2019 | Do pass. | Assembly Standing Committee on Privacy and Consumer Protection |
Passed |
|
| Apr 9, 2019 | Do pass as amended and be re-referred to the Committee on [Privacy and Consumer Protection] | Assembly Standing Committee on Public Safety |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
CONCURRENCE IN SENATE AMENDMENTS
CSA1 Bill Id:AB 1638
Author:(Obernolte)
As Amended Ver:July 8, 2019
Majority vote
SUMMARY:
Expands authorization for the issuance of a search warrant to obtain information from a motor vehicle's software that "tends to show the commission of a felony or misdemeanor offense involving a motor vehicle, resulting in death or serious bodily injury."
The Senate Amendments:
Exclude infractions from the offenses for which law enforcement has the right to obtain a warrant for driver data to investigate a vehicle accident.
COMMENTS:
According to the Author:
"This bill would give law enforcement statutory authority to obtain a search warrant in order to access [event data recorders] (EDR) data in limited cases when an accident results in death or serious bodily injury. EDR technology is installed in most newer motor vehicle models and generally captures data from a period of approximately five seconds before until one second after a collision. This data can include information regarding the vehicle's braking, steering, airbag deployment, seat belt use, seat belt pre-tensioners, speed, engine throttle, time between crash events, and other pertinent factors, which is crucial in aiding an officer during an accident investigation. Current law does not allow law enforcement to obtain EDR data for any motor vehicle manufactured on or after July 1, 2004 without a court order or the consent of the vehicle owner. Unfortunately, in solo accidents the driver may be deceased or critically injured and, therefore, unable to give consent. This bill will give law enforcement the statutory authority for a search warrant to in order to access the most crucial and scientifically reliable evidence regarding the cause of an accident."
Arguments in Support:
According to the California Association of Highway Patrolmen, "Current law specifies the grounds upon which a search warrant may be issued, including, among other grounds, when the property or things to be seized constitute evidence showing that a felony has been committed. This bill would authorize a search warrant to be issued on the grounds that the property or things to be seized are data, from a recording device, as defined, installed by the manufacturer of a motor vehicle, that constitutes evidence that tends to show the commission of a public offense involving a motor vehicle, resulting in death or serious bodily injury, as defined, to any person."
Arguments in Opposition:
According to American Civil Liberties Union of California, "In accordance with fundamental constitutional principles, California's search warrant statute operates to curb governmental overreach, and to protect the privacy and personal security of those within our state. In order to balance these privacy concerns with the legitimate public safety concerns, our existing law is designed to permit the issuance of a search warrant only under narrow circumstances, for the most serious offenses, and only when governmental needs have been determined to outweigh those of private individuals.
"Privacy concerns are heightened when it is electronic information that is sought. Because the electronic information routinely collected by our phones, devices and cars is so extensive and contains such a wealth of highly private information, California's Electronic Communications Privacy Act puts in place additional protections when the government seeks access to this type of information. The kinds of information available from a motor vehicle recording device provide a good example of why additional protection is needed for electronic information: the data may include records of where the vehicle has been and the speeds at which it has been driven as well as steering and braking information and other information.
"AB 1638 would contravene the carefully crafted balance of our search warrant statute by allowing the issuance of a warrant for the extensive data available from a motor vehicle recording device when the crime under investigation is a misdemeanor. The bill would allow the privacy rights of the individual to be violated when the governmental interest, in investing a less-serious offense, does not warrant that violation."
FISCAL COMMENTS:
Unknown. This bill is keyed non-fiscal by the Legislative Counsel.
VOTES:
ASM PUBLIC SAFETY: 5-0-3
YES: Lackey, Bauer-Kahan, Diep, Quirk, Santiago
ABS, ABST OR NV: Jones-Sawyer, Kamlager-Dove, Wicks
ASM PRIVACY AND CONSUMER PROTECTION: 9-0-2
YES: Chau, Bauer-Kahan, Berman, Calderon, Gabriel, Gallagher, Irwin, Obernolte, Smith
ABS, ABST OR NV: Kiley, Wicks
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 60-7-13
YES: Aguiar-Curry, Bauer-Kahan, Berman, Bigelow, Bloom, Boerner Horvath, Brough, Burke, Calderon, Carrillo, Cervantes, Chiu, Choi, Chu, Cooley, Cooper, Cunningham, Daly, Diep, Flora, Fong, Frazier, Gabriel, Gallagher, Eduardo Garcia, Gipson, Grayson, Holden, Irwin, Kiley, Lackey, Levine, Limón, Low, Maienschein, Mathis, Mayes, McCarty, Medina, Melendez, Mullin, Muratsuchi, Nazarian, O'Donnell, Obernolte, Patterson, Petrie-Norris, Quirk, Quirk‑Silva, Ramos, Robert Rivas, Rodriguez, Blanca Rubio, Salas, Santiago, Smith, Voepel, Waldron, Wood, Rendon
NO: Friedman, Gray, Kalra, Kamlager-Dove, Mark Stone, Ting, Wicks
ABS, ABST OR NV: Arambula, Bonta, Chau, Chen, Dahle, Eggman, Cristina Garcia, Gloria, Gonzalez, Jones-Sawyer, Reyes, Luz Rivas, Weber
SENATE FLOOR: 32-4-4
YES: Allen, Atkins, Bates, Beall, Borgeas, Bradford, Caballero, Chang, Dahle, Dodd, Durazo, Galgiani, Glazer, Grove, Hertzberg, Hill, Hurtado, Jones, Leyva, McGuire, Moorlach, Morrell, Nielsen, Pan, Roth, Rubio, Skinner, Stern, Stone, Umberg, Wiener, Wilk
NO: Jackson, Mitchell, Monning, Wieckowski
ABS, ABST OR NV: Archuleta, Lena Gonzalez, Hueso, Portantino
UPDATED:
VERSION: July 8, 2019
CONSULTANT: Nikki Moore (Counsel) / PUB. S. / (916) 319-3744 FN: 0001372
Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | AB 1638 |
THIRD READING
Bill No: AB 1638
Amended: 7/8/19 in Senate
SENATE PUBLIC SAFETY COMMITTEE: 4-0, 7/2/19
AYES: Skinner, Moorlach, Morrell, Wiener
NO VOTE RECORDED: Bradford, Jackson, Mitchell
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 60-7, 5/9/19 - See last page for vote
SUBJECT: Search warrants: vehicle recording devices
DIGEST:
This bill authorizes the issuance of a search warrant from a recording device installed by the manufacturer of a motor vehicle that constitutes evidence that tends to show the commission of a felony or misdemeanor offense involving a motor vehicle resulting in death or “serious bodily injury” as defined.
Existing law:
- Provides, pursuant to the U.S. Constitution, that “the right of the people to be secure in their persons, houses, papers, and effects, against unreasonable searches and seizures, shall not be violated, and no Warrants shall issue, but upon probable cause, supported by Oath or affirmation, and particularly describing the place to be searched an the persons or things to be seized.” (U.S. Const., Fourth Amend; see also Cal. Const. art. 1, Sec. 13.)
- Governs search warrants, including the grounds upon which a search warrant may be issued. (Pen. Code, § 1523 et seq.)
- Defines a “search warrant” as a written order in the name of the people, signed by a magistrate, directed to a peace officer, commanding him or her to search for a person or persons, a thing or things, or personal property, and, in the case of a thing or things or personal property, bring the same before the magistrate. (Pen. Code, § 1523.)
- Authorizes a search warrant to be issued upon any of the following grounds:
- When the property was stolen or embezzled.
- When the property or things were used as the means of committing a felony.
- When the property or things are in the possession of any person with the intent to use them as a means of committing a public offense, or in the possession of another to whom he or she may have delivered them for the purpose of concealing them or preventing them from being discovered.
- When the property or things to be seized consist of any item or constitute any evidence that tends to show a felony has been committed, or tends to show that a particular person has committed a felony.
- When the property or things to be seized consist of evidence that tends to show that sexual exploitation of a child, or possession of matter depicting sexual conduct of a person under the age of 18 years, has occurred or is occurring.
- When there is a warrant to arrest a person.
- When a provider of electronic communication service or remote computing service has records or evidence, showing that property was stolen or embezzled constituting a misdemeanor, or that property or things are in the possession of any person with the intent to use them as a means of committing a misdemeanor public offense, or in the possession of another to whom he or she may have delivered them for the purpose of concealing them or preventing their discovery.
- When a provider of electronic communication service or remote computing service has records or evidence showing that property was stolen or embezzled constituting a misdemeanor, or that property or things are in the possession of any person with the intent to use them as a means of committing a misdemeanor public offense, or in the possession of another to whom he or she may have delivered them for the purpose of concealing them or preventing their discovery.
- When the property or things to be seized include an item or any evidence that tends to show a violation of the Labor Code, as specified.
- When the property or things to be seized include a firearm or any other deadly weapon at the scene of, or at the premises occupied or under the control of the person arrested in connection with, a domestic violence incident involving a threat to human life or a physical assault.
- When the property or things to be seized include a firearm or any other deadly weapon that is owned by, or in the possession of, or in the custody or control of, a person described in subdivision (a) of Section 8102 of the Welfare and Institutions Code.
- When the property or things to be seized include a firearm that is owned by, or in the possession of, or in the custody or control of, a person who is subject to the prohibitions regarding firearms under specified provisions of the Family Code.
- When the information to be received from the use of a tracking device constitutes evidence that tends to show that either a felony or a misdemeanor violation of the Fish and Game Code, or a misdemeanor violation of the Public Resources Code.
- When a sample of the blood of a person constitutes evidence that tends to show a violation of misdemeanor driving under the influence and the person from whom the sample is being sought has refused an officer's request to submit to, or has failed to complete, a blood test.
- When the property or things to be seized are firearms or ammunition or both that are owned by, in the possession of, or in the custody or control of a person who is the subject of a gun violence re straining order. This final provision does not go into effect until January 1, 2016.
- When the property or things to be seized are controlled substances or a device, contrivance, instrument or paraphernalia used for unlawfully administering a controlled substance as provided.
- When the warrant is for a blood sample of a person that tends to show a violations related to the operation of a vessel, or manipulating water skis, an aquaplane, or a similar device, while under the influence of alcohol or drugs.
- When the property or things to be seized consist of evidence that tends to show that a violation of the crime of disorderly conduct related to invasion of privacy has occurred or is occurring. (Pen. Code, § 1524, subd. (a).)
- Provides that a search warrant cannot be issued but upon probable cause, supported by affidavit, naming or describing the person to be searched or searched for, and particularly describing the property, thing, or things and the place to be searched. (Pen. Code, § 1525.)
- Requires a magistrate to issue a search warrant if he or she is satisfied of the existence of the grounds of the application or that there is probable cause to believe their existence. (Pen. Code, § 1528, subd. (a).)
- Enacts the California Electronic Communications Privacy Act (CalECPA), which generally prohibits a government entity from compelling the production of or access to electronic communication information from a service provider or to electronic device information from any person or entity other than the authorized possessor of the device, absent a search warrant, wiretap order, order for electronic reader records, or subpoena issued pursuant to specified conditions, or pursuant to an order for a pen register or trap and trace device, as specified. CalECPA also generally specifies the only conditions under which a government entity may access electronic device information by means of physical interaction or electronic communication with the device, such as pursuant to a search warrant, wiretap order, consent of the owner of the device, or emergency situations, as specified. (Pen. Code, § 1546 et seq.)
- Defines “serious bodily injury” to mean a serious impairment of physical condition, including, but not limited to, the following: loss of consciousness; concussion; bone fracture; protracted loss or impairment of function of any bodily member or organ; a wound requiring extensive suturing; and serious disfigurement. (Pen. Code, § 243, subd. (f)(4).)
- Requires owner’s manuals to disclose to the owner when a car is installed with event data recorders (EDRs) or sensing and diagnostic modules and defines “recording device” for these purposes to mean a device that is installed by the manufacturer of the vehicle and does one or more of the following, for the purpose of retrieving data after an accident:
- records how fast and in which direction the motor vehicle is traveling;
- records a history of where the motor vehicle travels;
- records steering performance;
- records brake performance, including, but not limited to, whether brakes were applied before an accident;
- records the driver’s seatbelt status; and/or,
- has the ability to transmit information concerning an accident in which the motor vehicle has been involved to a central communications system when an accident occurs. (Veh. Code, § 9951, subd. (b).)
- Specifies that such data from a “recording device,” identified above, can only be accessed under certain circumstances, including where the registered owner of the motor vehicle consents to the retrieval of the information, or in response to an order of a court having jurisdiction to issue the order. (Veh. Code, § 9951, subd. (c).)
This bill:
- Expands the grounds for issuance of a search warrant to include when the property or things to be seized are data from an EDR that constitutes evidence that tends to show the commission of a felony or misdemeanor offense involving a motor vehicle, resulting in death or serious bodily injury to any person.
- States that the data accessed by a warrant pursuant to this paragraph shall not exceed the scope of the data that is directly related to the public offense for which the warrant is issued.
- Provides that the scope of the data accessible by a warrant pursuant to this paragraph shall be limited to the specified information listed in Vehicle Code section 9951, subdivision (b).
- Provides that “recording device” has the same meaning as defined in Vehicle Code Section 9951, subdivision (b).
- States that “serious bodily injury” has the same meaning as defined in Penal Code Section 243, subdivision (f)(4).
According to the author, “This bill would give law enforcement statutory authority to obtain a search warrant in order to access EDR data in limited cases when an accident results in death or serious bodily injury. EDR technology is installed in most newer motor vehicle models and generally captures data from a period of approximately five seconds before until one second after a collision. This data can include information regarding the vehicle’s braking, steering, airbag deployment, seat belt use, seat belt pre-tensioners, speed, engine
throttle, time between crash events, and other pertinent factors, which is crucial in aiding an officer during an accident investigation. However, EDR data cannot be legally obtained by law enforcement without a court order or the consent of the vehicle’s registered owner (VC 9951). Unfortunately, there are many solo vehicle accidents where the driver is deceased or has been critically injured and, therefore, is unable to give consent. In those cases, there is no statutory “court order” available to law enforcement, making it impossible for the officer to use the EDR data to help with the accident investigation. The statute authorizing courts to issue search warrants (Penal Code 1524) applies to EDR data only for felonies. While VC 9951 also allows EDR data to be downloaded with consent of the vehicle’s registered owner, it is not always possible in fatality accidents.”
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: No Local: No
California Association of Highway Patrolmen
California District Attorneys Association
Peace Officers Research Association of California
San Diego County District Attorney’s Office
American Civil Liberties Union of California
California Attorneys for Criminal Justice
California Public Defenders Association
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 60-7, 5/9/19
AYES: Aguiar-Curry, Bauer-Kahan, Berman, Bigelow, Bloom, Boerner Horvath, Brough, Burke, Calderon, Carrillo, Cervantes, Chiu, Choi, Chu, Cooley, Cooper, Cunningham, Daly, Diep, Flora, Fong, Frazier, Gabriel, Gallagher, Eduardo Garcia, Gipson, Grayson, Holden, Irwin, Kiley, Lackey, Levine, Limón, Low, Maienschein, Mathis, Mayes, McCarty, Medina, Melendez, Mullin, Muratsuchi, Nazarian, Obernolte, O'Donnell, Patterson, Petrie-Norris, Quirk, Quirk-Silva, Ramos, Robert Rivas, Rodriguez, Blanca Rubio, Salas, Santiago, Smith, Voepel, Waldron, Wood, Rendon
NOES: Friedman, Gray, Kalra, Kamlager-Dove, Mark Stone, Ting, Wicks
NO VOTE RECORDED: Arambula, Bonta, Chau, Chen, Dahle, Eggman, Cristina Garcia, Gloria, Gonzalez, Jones-Sawyer, Reyes, Luz Rivas, Weber
Prepared by: Stella Choe / PUB. S. /
7/10/19 14:51:14
**** END ****
SENATE COMMITTEE ON PUBLIC SAFETY
Senator Nancy Skinner, Chair
2019 - 2020 Regular
Bill No: AB 1638 Hearing Date: July 2, 2019
Author: | Obernolte | ||
Version: | April 11, 2019 | ||
Urgency: | No | Fiscal: | No |
Consultant: | SC | ||
Subject: Search Warrants: Vehicle Recording Devices
HISTORY
Source: Author
Prior Legislation: AB 539 (Acosta), Ch. 342, Stats. 2017
AB 1924 (Low), Ch. 511, Stats. 2016
SB 178 (Leno), Ch. 651, Stats. 2015
AB 929 (Chau), Ch. 204, Stats. 2015
AB 539 (Levine), Ch. 118, Stats. 2015
AB 1104 (Rodriguez), Ch. 124, Stats. 2015
SB 467 (Leno), 2013, vetoed
SB 1424 (Leno), 2012, vetoed
SB 914 (Leno), 2011, vetoed
Support: California Association of Highway Patrolmen; California District Attorneys Association; Peace Officers Research Association of California; San Diego County District Attorney’s Office
Opposition: American Civil Liberties Union of California; California Attorneys for Criminal Justice
Assembly Floor Vote: 60 - 7
PURPOSE
The purpose of this bill is to authorize the issuance of a search warrant from a recording device installed by the manufacturer of a motor vehicle that constitutes evidence that tends to show the commission of a public offense involving a motor vehicle resulting in death or “serious bodily injury” as defined.
Existing law provides, pursuant to the U.S. Constitution, that “the right of the people to be secure in their persons, houses, papers, and effects, against unreasonable searches and seizures, shall not be violated, and no Warrants shall issue, but upon probable cause, supported by Oath or affirmation, and particularly describing the place to be searched an the persons or things to be seized.” (U.S. Const., Fourth Amend; see also Cal. Const. art. 1, Sec. 13.)
Existing law governs search warrants, including the grounds upon which a search warrant may be issued. (Pen. Code, § 1523 et seq.)
Existing law defines a “search warrant” as a written order in the name of the people, signed by a magistrate, directed to a peace officer, commanding him or her to search for a person or persons, a thing or things, or personal property, and, in the case of a thing or things or personal property, bring the same before the magistrate. (Pen. Code, § 1523.)
Existing law authorizes a search warrant to be issued upon any of the following grounds:
- When the property was stolen or embezzled.
- When the property or things were used as the means of committing a felony.
- When the property or things are in the possession of any person with the intent to use them as a means of committing a public offense, or in the possession of another to whom he or she may have delivered them for the purpose of concealing them or preventing them from being discovered.
- When the property or things to be seized consist of any item or constitute any evidence that tends to show a felony has been committed, or tends to show that a particular person has committed a felony.
- When the property or things to be seized consist of evidence that tends to show that sexual exploitation of a child, or possession of matter depicting sexual conduct of a person under the age of 18 years, has occurred or is occurring.
- When there is a warrant to arrest a person.
- When a provider of electronic communication service or remote computing service has records or evidence, showing that property was stolen or embezzled constituting a misdemeanor, or that property or things are in the possession of any person with the intent to use them as a means of committing a misdemeanor public offense, or in the possession of another to whom he or she may have delivered them for the purpose of concealing them or preventing their discovery.
- When a provider of electronic communication service or remote computing service has records or evidence showing that property was stolen or embezzled constituting a misdemeanor, or that property or things are in the possession of any person with the intent to use them as a means of committing a misdemeanor public offense, or in the possession of another to whom he or she may have delivered them for the purpose of concealing them or preventing their discovery.
- When the property or things to be seized include an item or any evidence that tends to show a violation of the Labor Code, as specified.
- When the property or things to be seized include a firearm or any other deadly weapon at the scene of, or at the premises occupied or under the control of the person arrested in connection with, a domestic violence incident involving a threat to human life or a physical assault.
- When the property or things to be seized include a firearm or any other deadly weapon that is owned by, or in the possession of, or in the custody or control of, a person described in subdivision (a) of Section 8102 of the Welfare and Institutions Code.
- When the property or things to be seized include a firearm that is owned by, or in the possession of, or in the custody or control of, a person who is subject to the prohibitions regarding firearms under specified provisions of the Family Code.
- When the information to be received from the use of a tracking device constitutes evidence that tends to show that either a felony or a misdemeanor violation of the Fish and Game Code, or a misdemeanor violation of the Public Resources Code.
- When a sample of the blood of a person constitutes evidence that tends to show a violation of misdemeanor driving under the influence and the person from whom the sample is being sought has refused an officer's request to submit to, or has failed to complete, a blood test.
- When the property or things to be seized are firearms or ammunition or both that are owned by, in the possession of, or in the custody or control of a person who is the subject of a gun violence re straining order. This final provision does not go into effect until January 1, 2016;
- When the property or things to be seized are controlled substances or a device, contrivance, instrument or paraphernalia used for unlawfully administering a controlled substance as provided.
- When the warrant is for a blood sample of a person that tends to show a violations related to the operation of a vessel, or manipulating water skis, an aquaplane, or a similar device, while under the influence of alcohol or drugs.
- When the property or things to be seized consist of evidence that tends to show that a violation of the crime of disorderly conduct related to invasion of privacy has occurred or is occurring.
(Pen. Code, § 1524, subd. (a).)
Existing law provides that a search warrant cannot be issued but upon probable cause, supported by affidavit, naming or describing the person to be searched or searched for, and particularly describing the property, thing, or things and the place to be searched. (Pen. Code, § 1525.)
Existing law requires a magistrate to issue a search warrant if he or she is satisfied of the existence of the grounds of the application or that there is probable cause to believe their existence. (Pen. Code, § 1528, subd. (a).)
Existing law enacts the California Electronic Communications Privacy Act (CalECPA), which generally prohibits a government entity from compelling the production of or access to electronic communication information from a service provider or to electronic device information from any person or entity other than the authorized possessor of the device, absent a search warrant, wiretap order, order for electronic reader records, or subpoena issued pursuant to specified conditions, or pursuant to an order for a pen register or trap and trace device, as specified. CalECPA also generally specifies the only conditions under which a government entity may access electronic device information by means of physical interaction or electronic communication with the device, such as pursuant to a search warrant, wiretap order, consent of the owner of the device, or emergency situations, as specified. (Pen. Code, § 1546 et seq.)
Existing law defines “serious bodily injury” to mean a serious impairment of physical condition, including, but not limited to, the following: loss of consciousness; concussion; bone fracture; protracted loss or impairment of function of any bodily member or organ; a wound requiring extensive suturing; and serious disfigurement. (Pen. Code, § 243, subd. (f)(4).)
Existing law requires owner’s manuals to disclose to the owner when a car is installed with event data recorders (EDRs) or sensing and diagnostic modules and defines “recording device” for these purposes to mean a device that is installed by the manufacturer of the vehicle and does one or more of the following, for the purpose of retrieving data after an accident:
- records how fast and in which direction the motor vehicle is traveling;
- records a history of where the motor vehicle travels;
- records steering performance;
- records brake performance, including, but not limited to, whether brakes were applied before an accident;
- records the driver’s seatbelt status; and/or,
- has the ability to transmit information concerning an accident in which the motor vehicle has been involved to a central communications system when an accident occurs. (Veh. Code, § 9951, subd. (b).)
Existing law specifies that such data from a “recording device,” identified above, can only be accessed under certain circumstances, including where the registered owner of the motor vehicle consents to the retrieval of the information, or in response to an order of a court having jurisdiction to issue the order. (Veh. Code, § 9951, subd. (c).)
This bill expands the grounds for issuance of a search warrant to include when the property or things to be seized are data from an EDR that constitutes evidence that tends to show the commission of a public offense involving a motor vehicle, resulting in death or serious bodily injury to any person.
This bill states that the data accessed by a warrant pursuant to this paragraph shall not exceed the scope of the data that is directly related to the public offense for which the warrant is issued.
This bill provides that the scope of the data accessible by a warrant pursuant to this paragraph shall be limited to the specified information listed in Vehicle Code section 9951, subdivision (b).
This bill provides that “recording device” has the same meaning as defined in Vehicle Code Section 9951, subdivision (b).
This bill states that “serious bodily injury” has the same meaning as defined in Penal Code Section 243, subdivision (f)(4).
COMMENTS
- Need for This Bill
According to the author of this bill:
This bill would give law enforcement statutory authority to obtain a search warrant in order to access EDR data in limited cases when an accident results in death or serious bodily injury. EDR technology is installed in most newer motor vehicle models and generally captures data from a period of approximately five seconds before until one second after a collision. This data can include information regarding the vehicle’s braking, steering, airbag deployment, seat belt use, seat belt pre-tensioners, speed, engine throttle, time between crash events, and other pertinent factors, which is crucial in aiding an officer during an accident investigation. However, EDR data cannot be legally obtained by law enforcement without a court order or the consent of the vehicle’s registered owner (VC 9951). Unfortunately, there are many solo vehicle accidents where the driver is deceased or has been critically injured and, therefore, is unable to give consent. In those cases, there is no statutory “court order” available to law enforcement, making it impossible for the officer to use the EDR data to help with the accident investigation. The statute authorizing courts to issue search warrants (Penal Code 1524) applies to EDR data only for felonies. While VC 9951 also allows EDR data to be downloaded with consent of the vehicle’s registered owner, it is not always possible in fatality accidents.
- Background on Event Data Recorders
An EDR is defined by the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA) “a device installed in a motor vehicle to record technical vehicle and occupant information for a brief period of time (seconds, not minutes) before, during and after a crash. For instance, EDRs may record (1) pre-crash vehicle dynamics and system status, (2) driver inputs, (3) vehicle crash signature, (4) restraint usage/deployment status, and (5) post-crash data such as the activation of an automatic collision notification (ACN) system.” (NHTSA, Event Data Recorder <https://www.nhtsa.gov/research-data/event-data-recorder> [as of June 24, 2019].)
NHTSA determined that for model year 2017, 99.6 percent of new “light vehicles” sold were equipped with EDRs. “Light vehicles” includes passenger cars, multipurpose passenger vehicles, trucks, and buses with a gross vehicle weight rating (GVWR) of 8,500 pounds or less and an unloaded vehicle weight of 5,500 pounds or less, except for walk-in van-type trucks or vehicles designed to be sold exclusively to the U.S. Postal Service. (Federal Motor Vehicle Safety Standards; Event Data Recorders <https://www.federalregister.gov/documents/2019/02/08/2019-01651/federal-motor-vehicle-safety-standards-event-data-recorders> [as of June 24, 2019].)
According to Edmunds.com, an online automobile resource:
Event data recorders aren't actually black boxes but tiny microcomputer chip sets. In most vehicles, they're part of the airbag control module, and originally were included to ensure airbags deployed when they were supposed to.
Over the years, as electronics got cheaper, smaller and smarter, event data recorders became capable of doing more than simply monitoring airbags. Automakers realized the devices could be used to provide information about the seriousness of an accident, and if a car was being operated properly when a crash occurred. Based on a separate NHTSA regulation passed in 2012, if a vehicle today does have an event data recorder, it must track 15 specific data points, including speed, steering, braking, acceleration, seatbelt use, and, in the event of a crash, force of impact and whether airbags deployed.
Depending on the automaker and car model, an event data recorder may capture many more functions, though car companies aren't required to disclose exactly what those are. The language many use to explain black boxes in owner's manuals also is purposely general to cover technology updates and to save space.
Put everything the devices do in an owner's guide and "instead of one paragraph, you'd have potentially another 20 or 30 pages. That really wouldn't be realistic," says Richard Ruth, a black box equipment trainer, expert witness and consultant who worked at Ford Motor Co. for 33 years, including a stint evaluating event data recorders and other safety equipment. "It's not going to change whether or not you're going to buy the car."
Most event data recorders are programmed to record data in a continuous loop, writing over information again and again until a vehicle is in a front-end collision or other crash. When an accident occurs, the device automatically saves up to 5 seconds of data from immediately before, during and after an incident.
(Rafter, Decoding What's in Your Car's Black Box: Who owns the data and who can tap it? (July 22, 2014) <https://www.edmunds.com/car-technology/car-black-box-recorders-capture-crash-data.html> [as of June 24, 2019].)
- Fourth Amendment and Search Warrant Requirements
Both the United States and the California constitution’s guarantee the right of all persons to be secure from unreasonable searches and seizures. (U.S. Const., amend. IV; Cal. Const., art. 1, sec. 13.) This protection applies to all unreasonable government intrusions into legitimate expectations of privacy. (United States v. Chadwick (1977) 433 U.S. 1, 7, overruled on other grounds by California v. Acevedo (1991) 500 U.S. 565.) In general, a search is not valid unless it is conducted pursuant to a warrant. A search warrant may not be issued without probable cause. "Reasonable and probable cause exists if a man of ordinary care and prudence would be led to conscientiously entertain an honest and strong suspicion that the accused is guilty." (People v. Alvarado (1967) 250 Cal.App.2d 584, 591.) The mere reasonableness of a search, assessed in light of the surrounding circumstances, is not a substitute for the warrant required by the Constitution. (Arkansas v. Sanders (1979) 442 U.S. 753, 758, overruled on other grounds by California v. Acevedo, supra.) There are exceptions to the warrant requirement, but the burden of establishing an exception is on the party seeking one. (Arkansas v. Sanders (1979) 442 U.S. 753, 760, overruled on other grounds by California v. Acevedo, supra.)
Penal Code section 1524 provides the statutory grounds for the issuance of warrants. Under these provisions, a search warrant may be issued for a variety of reasons, some being as broad as "[w]hen property or things were used as the means to commit a felony." (Pen. Code, § 1524, subd. (a)(2).) There are 18 specified grounds upon which a warrant may be issued under that section.
Existing law also contains specific procedures for accessing electronic communication and electronic device information under CalECPA (SB 178, Leno, Ch. 651, Stats. 2015). CalECPA requires the government to obtain a search warrant, subpoena, or wiretap order before accessing electronic information on a cell phone or similar electronic device and contains additional specified requirements for such warrants and the handling of electronic information obtained through the warrant including retention, sealing, and disclosure. Specifically, it requires a demonstration of probable cause to obtain electronic communications information from a third party service provider and verification by affidavit of the authenticity of electronic information produced. CalECPA provides specified ways for a government entity to access electronic communication information including when that entity has obtained a valid search warrant pursuant to the existing statutory authorization for search warrants (Pen. Code, § 1523 et seq.).
This bill would expand that statutory authority for search warrants by allowing law enforcement to obtain a search warrant on the grounds that data from a recording device installed by a vehicle manufacturer constitutes evidence that tends to show the commission of a public offense involving a motor vehicle that resulted in death or serious bodily injury. The bill defines “recording device” to have the same meaning as under Vehicle Code section 9951 which generally requires owner’s manuals to disclose to the owner when a car is installed with an EDR or sensing and diagnostic modules. Under that Vehicle Code definition, “recording device” means a device installed by a vehicle manufacturer that records or has the ability to transmit certain data for purposes of retrieving data after an accident. This includes recording information regarding, for example: (1) how fast and in which direction the motor vehicle is traveling; (2) a history of where the motor vehicle travels; (3) records steering performance; and (4) brake performance, including, but not limited to, whether brakes were applied before an accident, and the driver’s seatbelt status. This bill limits the information made accessible from an EDR under a warrant to the information listed in that Vehicle Code definition and the scope of information that may be obtained from the EDR to “data that is directly related to the public offense for which the warrant is issued.”
Under existing law, “public offense” includes felonies, misdemeanors and infractions. (Pen. Code, § 16.) An infraction is not punishable by imprisonment, thus a person is not entitled to a trial by jury or to be appointed a public defender. (Pen. Code, § 19.6.) Unless otherwise specified, an infraction is punishable by a maximum fine of $250. (Pen. Code, § 19.8.) Common examples of infractions are moving violations, such as speeding. (Veh. Code, §§ 22350, 40000.1.)
In order to meet the probable cause requirement for a search warrant, the officer must reasonably believe that a person is guilty of a crime and that the search would turn up evidence of the crime. The crimes that would qualify for the search warrant authority created by this bill could be any infraction, misdemeanor, or felony involving a motor vehicle that resulted in death or serious bodily injury. It is unclear whether an injury or death involving a motor vehicle in itself would be enough to establish probable cause that a crime occurred, but arguably depending on the damage to a vehicle or the impact to the person injured, an officer could opine that the driver was violating several laws enumerated in the Vehicle Code.
In light of the privacy interests that are implicated by the issuance of a search warrant and considering that infractions are minor offenses, should the bill’s application to infractions be removed from the bill?
- Argument in Support
According to San Diego County District Attorney’s Office:
When someone is killed or suffers serious bodily injury as the result of a vehicle crash, law enforcement traffic investigators are tasked with conducting an investigation to ascertain what happened and whether any laws were violated. EDR data is akin to the so-called “black box” used in commercial aviation disasters. In both airline crashes and serious vehicle crashes, trained investigators can retrieve and utilize scientific data which tells the investigator what was happening with the aircraft or vehicle, in the time leading up to and during a crash. The scientific data is analyzed and considered by the expert investigators, along with the physical evidence and any witness statements, to get answers to the critical questions: What happened; and why?
Traffic investigators need available vehicular EDR data to properly do their jobs in crashes resulting in death or serious bodily injury. However, current California law does not allow law enforcement to obtain the EDR data unless law enforcement has probable cause to believe a felony was committed (basis for a search warrant.) Lack of access to EDR data results in incomplete law enforcement investigations. Incomplete investigations lead to conclusions which, at best, cannot be considered as reliable as conclusions which are corroborated and verified by scientific data. AB 1638 will remedy this.
- Argument in Opposition
The American Civil Liberties Union of California opposes the bill:
In accordance with fundamental constitutional principles, California’s search warrant statute operates to curb governmental overreach, and to protect the privacy and personal security of those within our state. In order to balance these privacy concerns with the legitimate public safety concerns, our existing law is designed to permit the issuance of a search warrant only under narrow circumstances, for the most serious offenses, and only when governmental needs have been determined to outweigh those of private individuals.
Privacy concerns are heightened when it is electronic information that is sought. Because the electronic information routinely collected by our phones, devices and cars is so extensive and contains such a wealth of highly private information, California’s Electronic Communications Privacy Act puts in place additional protections when the government seeks access to this type of information. The kinds of information available from a motor vehicle recording device provide a good example of why additional protection is needed for electronic information: the data may include records of where the vehicle has been and the speeds at which it has been driven as well as steering and braking information and other information.
AB 1638 would contravene the carefully crafted balance of our search warrant statute by allowing the issuance of a warrant for the extensive data available from a motor vehicle recording device when the crime under investigation is a misdemeanor. The bill would allow the privacy rights of the individual to be violated when the governmental interest, in investing a less-serious offense, does not warrant that violation.”
-- END –
ASSEMBLY THIRD READING
ATR Bill Id:AB 1638
Author:(Obernolte)
As Amended Ver:April 11, 2019
Majority vote
SUMMARY:
Expands authorization for the issuance of a search warrant to obtain information from a motor vehicle's software that "tends to show the commission of a public offense involving a motor vehicle, resulting in death or serious bodily injury."
Major Provisions
- Authorizes the issuance of a search warrant when the property or things to be seized are data from a recording device installed by the manufacturer of a motor vehicle that constitutes evidence that tends to show the commission of a public offense involving a motor vehicle, resulting in death or serious bodily injury to any person.
- Defines "recording device" to mean a device that is installed by the manufacturer of the vehicle and does one or more of the following, for the purpose of retrieving data after an accident: 1) Records how fast and in which direction the motor vehicle is traveling; 2) Records a history of where the motor vehicle travels; 3) Records steering performance; 4) Records brake performance, including, but not limited to, whether brakes were applied before an accident; 5) Records the driver's seatbelt status; 6) Has the ability to transmit information concerning an accident in which the motor vehicle has been involved to a central communications system when an accident occurs.
- Defines "serious bodily injury" to mean "a serious impairment of physical condition, including, but not limited to, the following: loss of consciousness; concussion; bone fracture; protracted loss or impairment of function of any bodily member or organ; a wound requiring extensive suturing; and serious disfigurement."
COMMENTS:
According to the Author:
"This bill would give law enforcement statutory authority to obtain a search warrant in order to access [event data recorders] (EDR) data in limited cases when an accident results in death or serious bodily injury. EDR technology is installed in most newer motor vehicle models and generally captures data from a period of approximately five seconds before until one second after a collision. This data can include information regarding the vehicle's braking, steering, airbag deployment, seat belt use, seat belt pre-tensioners, speed, engine throttle, time between crash events, and other pertinent factors, which is crucial in aiding an officer during an accident investigation. Current law does not allow law enforcement to obtain EDR data for any motor vehicle manufactured on or after July 1, 2004 without a court order or the consent of the vehicle owner. Unfortunately, in solo accidents the driver may be deceased or critically injured and, therefore, unable to give consent. This bill will give law enforcement the statutory authority for a search warrant to in order to access the most crucial and scientifically reliable evidence regarding the cause of an accident."
Arguments in Support:
According to the California Association of Highway Patrolmen, "Current law specifies the grounds upon which a search warrant may be issued, including, among other grounds, when the property or things to be seized constitute evidence showing that a felony has been committed. This bill would authorize a search warrant to be issued on the grounds that the property or things to be seized are data, from a recording device, as defined, installed by the manufacturer of a motor vehicle, that constitutes evidence that tends to show the commission of a public offense involving a motor vehicle, resulting in death or serious bodily injury, as defined, to any person."
Arguments in Opposition:
According to American Civil Liberties Union of California, "In accordance with fundamental constitutional principles, California's search warrant statute operates to curb governmental overreach, and to protect the privacy and personal security of those within our state. In order to balance these privacy concerns with the legitimate public safety concerns, our existing law is designed to permit the issuance of a search warrant only under narrow circumstances, for the most serious offenses, and only when governmental needs have been determined to outweigh those of private individuals.
"Privacy concerns are heightened when it is electronic information that is sought. Because the electronic information routinely collected by our phones, devices and cars is so extensive and contains such a wealth of highly private information, California's Electronic Communications Privacy Act puts in place additional protections when the government seeks access to this type of information. The kinds of information available from a motor vehicle recording device provide a good example of why additional protection is needed for electronic information: the data may include records of where the vehicle has been and the speeds at which it has been driven as well as steering and braking information and other information.
"AB 1638 would contravene the carefully crafted balance of our search warrant statute by allowing the issuance of a warrant for the extensive data available from a motor vehicle recording device when the crime under investigation is a misdemeanor. The bill would allow the privacy rights of the individual to be violated when the governmental interest, in investing a less-serious offense, does not warrant that violation."
FISCAL COMMENTS:
Unknown. This bill is keyed non-fiscal by the Legislative Counsel.
Please see the policy committee analysis for a full discussion of this bill.
VOTES:
ASM PUBLIC SAFETY: 5-0-3
YES: Lackey, Bauer-Kahan, Diep, Quirk, Santiago
ABS, ABST OR NV: Jones-Sawyer, Kamlager-Dove, Wicks
ASM PRIVACY AND CONSUMER PROTECTION: 9-0-2
YES: Chau, Bauer-Kahan, Berman, Calderon, Gabriel, Gallagher, Irwin, Obernolte, Smith
ABS, ABST OR NV: Kiley, Wicks
UPDATED:
VERSION: April 11, 2019
CONSULTANT: Nikki Moore (Counsel) / PUB. S. / (916) 319-3744 FN: 0000338
Date of Hearing: April 30, 2019
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON PRIVACY AND CONSUMER PROTECTION
Ed Chau, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 1638 (
Author:Obernolte) – As Amended Ver:April 11, 2019
SUBJECT: Search warrants: vehicle recording devices
SUMMARY: This bill would authorize the issuance of a search warrant on the grounds that the property or things to be seized are data, from a recording device installed by the manufacturer of a motor vehicle, that constitutes evidence that tends to show the commission of a public offense involving a motor vehicle resulting in death or “serious bodily injury” as defined under the Penal Code. This bill would prohibit the data accessed by a warrant from exceeding the scope of the data that is directly related to the public offense for which the warrant is issued. This bill would define “recording device” to have the same meaning as provided to that term under the Vehicle Code, as specified, and would limit the scope of data accessible by a warrant issued pursuant to this bill to the information described in the Vehicle Code. This bill would make other non-substantive changes.
EXISTING LAW:
- Provides, pursuant to the U.S. Constitution, that “the right of the people to be secure in their persons, houses, papers, and effects, against unreasonable searches and seizures, shall not be violated, and no Warrants shall issue, but upon probable cause, supported by Oath or affirmation, and particularly describing the place to be searched an the persons or things to be seized.” (U.S. Const., Fourth Amend; see also Cal. Const. art. 1, Sec. 13.)
- Governs search warrants, including the grounds upon which a search warrant may be issued. (Pen. Code Sec. 1523 et seq.)
- Defines a “search warrant” as a written order in the name of the people, signed by a magistrate, directed to a peace officer, commanding him or her to search for a person or persons, a thing or things, or personal property, and, in the case of a thing or things or personal property, bring the same before the magistrate. (Pen. Code Sec. 1523.)
- Authorizes a search warrant to be issued upon any of the following grounds, among others:
- When the property or things are in the possession of any person with the intent to use them as a means of committing a public offense, or in the possession of another to whom he or she may have delivered them for the purpose of concealing them or preventing them from being discovered.
- When the property or things to be seized consist of any item or evidence that tends to show that a felony has been committed or that a particular person has committed a felony.
- When a provider of electronic communication or remote computing service has records or evidence showing that property was stolen or embezzled constituting a misdemeanor, or that property or things are in the possession of any person with the intent to use them as a means of committing a misdemeanor, or in the possession of another to whom he or she may have delivered them for the purpose of concealment.
- When the information to be received from the use of a tracking device, as defined, constitutes evidence that tends to show: (a) either a felony, a misdemeanor violation of the Fish and Game Code, or a misdemeanor violation of the Public Resources Code has been committed or is being committed; (b) that a particular person has committed or is committing a felony, a misdemeanor violation of the Fish and Game Code, or a misdemeanor violation of the Public Resources Code, or will assist in locating an individual who has committed or is committing a felony, a misdemeanor violation of the Fish and Game Code, or a misdemeanor violation of the Public Resources Code.
- When the property or things to be seized consists of evidence that tends to show that specified violations of privacy (by way of looking through a hole or opening by means of instrumentalities such as periscopes, telescopes, binoculars, and more; or by way of using a concealed camcorder, motion picture camera, or photographic camera of any type to secretly tape, film, photograph or record by electronic means another identifiable person, as specified) under the Penal Code, has occurred or is occurring. (Pen. Code Sec. 1524.)
- Provides that a search warrant cannot be issued but upon probable cause, supported by affidavit, naming or describing the person to be searched or searched for, and particularly describing the property, thing, or things and the place to be searched. (Pen. Code Sec. 1525.)
- Enacts the California Electronic Communications Privacy Act (CalECPA), which generally prohibits a government entity from compelling the production of or access to electronic communication information from a service provider or to electronic device information from any person or entity other than the authorized possessor of the device, absent a search warrant, wiretap order, order for electronic reader records, or subpoena issued pursuant to specified conditions, or pursuant to an order for a pen register or trap and trace device, as specified. CalECPA also generally specifies the only conditions under which a government entity may access electronic device information by means of physical interaction or electronic communication with the device, such as pursuant to a search warrant, wiretap order, consent of the owner of the device, or emergency situations, as specified. (Pen. Code Sec. 1546 et seq.)
- Defines “serious bodily injury” to mean a serious impairment of physical condition, including, but not limited to, the following: loss of consciousness; concussion; bone fracture; protracted loss or impairment of function of any bodily member or organ; a wound requiring extensive suturing; and serious disfigurement. (Pen. Code Sec. 243(f)(4).)
- Requires owner’s manuals to disclose to the owner when a car is installed with event data recorders (EDRs) or sensing and diagnostic modules and defines “recording device” for these purposes to mean a device that is installed by the manufacturer of the vehicle and does one or more of the following, for the purpose of retrieving data after an accident:
- records how fast and in which direction the motor vehicle is traveling;
- records a history of where the motor vehicle travels;
- records steering performance;
- records brake performance, including, but not limited to, whether brakes were applied before an accident; and,
- records the driver’s seatbelt status; and/or,
- has the ability to transmit information concerning an accident in which the motor vehicle has been involved to a central communications system when an accident occurs. (Veh. Code Sec. 9951(b).)
- Specifies that such data from a recording device, identified above, can only be accessed under certain circumstances, including where the registered owner of the motor vehicle consents to the retrieval of the information, or in response to an order of a court having jurisdiction to issue the order. (Veh. Code Sec. 9951(c).)
FISCAL EFFECT: None. This bill has been keyed nonfiscal by the Legislative Counsel.
COMMENTS:
- Purpose of this bill: This bill seeks provide law enforcement the ability to obtain a warrant to access certain vehicle data after automobile accidents resulting in serious bodily injury or death. This is an author-sponsored bill.
- Author’s statement: According to the author, “Event Data Recorders (EDR) have become increasingly prevalent in motor vehicles in recent years. However, EDR data cannot be legally obtained by law enforcement without a court order or the consent of the vehicle’s registered owner ([Vehicle Code Sec.] 9951). Unfortunately, there are many solo vehicle accidents where the driver is deceased or has been critically injured and, therefore, is unable to give consent. In those cases, there is no statutory “court order” available to law enforcement, making it impossible for the officer to use the EDR data to help with the accident investigation. The statute authorizing courts to issue search warrants (Penal Code 1524) applies to EDR data only for felonies. While [Vehicle Code Sec.] 9951 also allows EDR data to be downloaded with consent of the vehicle’s registered owner, it is not always possible in fatality accidents. Specifically, this bill has been narrowly drafted to give law enforcement the statutory authority to obtain a search warrant in order to get information from the vehicle’s EDR that is related to the commission of a public offense involving a motor vehicle accident that results in a person’s death or serious bodily injury.”
- Authorizing warrants to be issued for EDR data: Generally speaking, the Fourth Amendment to the United States Constitution (and art. I, Sec. 13 of the California Constitution) generally provides the right of people to be secure from unreasonable searches and seizures of their person or property, and a requirement that search warrants be specific and based on probable cause (with some exceptions). A search occurs when the government impinges on an individual's “reasonable expectation of privacy.” The rule is enforced in part by excluding evidence from trial that was obtained in violation of these requirements.
In 2015, out of concern that the law had not been adequately updated to protect all forms of electronic communications and their metadata, AB 178 (Leno, Ch. Stats. 2015) was adopted to codify and strengthen privacy protections under the California Constitution in a number of ways. For example, it required a demonstration of probable cause to obtain electronic communications information from a third party service provider, responding to a high percentage of legally inadequate requests from law enforcement. It also applied the probable cause requirement to past electronic communications, regardless of their age, which was an improvement over federal law. SB 178 also guaranteed that geolocation information is protected by the same standard, which codifies protections established in case law, and also protects some forms of “metadata.” The author’s end goal with SB 178, according to the Assembly Floor analysis, was to create a “clear, uniform warrant rule for California law enforcement access to electronic information.”
As noted in this Committee’s analysis of SB 178 at the time that bill was heard, generally CalECPA’s requirement for a search warrant or probable cause order for electronic communications information is protective of personal privacy and in keeping with the California Constitution’s explicit protection of an individual’s right of privacy, but does provide for the traditional exceptions in limited circumstances (i.e., volunteered information, lost devices, emergency situations, and so forth). Moreover, CalECPA’s requirements explicitly limit the searches to necessary information, ensure judicial oversight of information obtained without a warrant or order, and mandate deletion of unneeded information. Specifically, and of relevance to this bill, it specifies that any information unrelated to the objective of the warrant shall be sealed and not subject to further review, use, or disclosure without a court order.
This bill seeks to allow law enforcement to obtain a warrant on the grounds that data from a recording device installed by a vehicle manufacturer constitutes evidence that tends to show the commission of a public offense involving a motor vehicle that resulted in death or serious bodily injury. The bill defines “recording device” to have the same meaning as under a specific provision of the Vehicle Code (Veh. Code Sec. 9951) which generally requires owner’s manuals to disclose to the owner when a car is installed with event data recorders (EDRs) or sensing and diagnostic modules. Under that Vehicle Code definition, “recording device” means a device installed by a vehicle manufacturer that records or has the ability to transmit certain data for purposes of retrieving data after an accident. This includes recording information regarding, for example: (1) how fast and in which direction the motor vehicle is traveling; (2) a history of where the motor vehicle travels; (3) records steering performance; and (4) brake performance, including, but not limited to, whether brakes were applied before an accident, and the driver’s seatbelt status.
As amended in the Assembly Public Safety Committee, the bill limits the information made accessible from an EDR under a warrant to the information listed in that Vehicle Code definition. The recent amendments to the bill also limit the scope of information that may be obtained from the EDR to “data that is directly related to the public offense for which the warrant is issued.” According to the Assembly Public Safety Committee analysis, in practice, this means that EDR information related to a deadly accident may be released to the extent that the data sought is relevant to the accident, but a warrant would not be issued for wide-ranging access to the driver’s data for long periods of time, for example, over the week prior to the accident.
- CalECPA addresses need for a warrant to obtain electronic communications information and electronic device information: Of particular relevance to this bill, CalECPA not only protects against the unreasonable search and seizure of “electronic communications information,” but also “electronic device information.” Electronic device information means any information stored on or generated through the operation of an electronic device, including the current and prior locations of the device. Relatedly, electronic device generally means a device that stores, generates, or transmits information in electronic form.
As discussed in Comment 3, above, to protect the privacy interests that is held in electronic information, CalECPA expressly excludes government entities from compelling the production of or access to electronic communication information from a service provider, absent. The exceptions to this are where the government entity obtains: (1) a warrant that has been issued pursuant to the Penal Code as specified, subject to additional heightened requirements for warrants pursuant to CalECPA; (2) a wiretap order; (4) an order for electronic reader records; (4) a subpoena (provided that the information is not sought for the purpose of investigating or prosecuting a criminal offense); or, (5) an order for a pen register or trap and trace device, or both. Similarly, CalECPA also prohibits government entities from compelling the production of or accessing electronic device information from any person or entity other than the authorized possessor of that device in the absence of a warrant or such orders enumerated above.
Accordingly, to the extent that this bill seeks to authorize law enforcement to access a car’s black box data, it appears somewhat redundant of CalECPA, which requires that law enforcement either obtain a warrant in criminal investigations or prosecutions or subpoena in non-criminal investigations or prosecutions in order to compel or otherwise access the data off an electronic device from any person or entity (such as the manufacturer) other than the vehicle owner. Indeed, even if this bill expressly authorizes a warrant specifically be issued for this type of data, it does not relieve law enforcement of their obligation to meet the CalECPA standards for a warrant. Specifically, under CalECPA, a warrant for electronic information must comply with the following requirement:
- The warrant must describe with particularity the information to be seized by specifying, as appropriate, the time periods covered, the target individuals or accounts, the applications or services covered, and the types of information sought, except as specified.
- The warrant must require that any information sought through the execution of the warrant that is unrelated to the objective of the warrant are sealed and not subject to further review, use, or disclosure except pursuant to a court order requiring probable cause or to comply with discover, as specified.
- The warrant must comply with all other provisions of California or federal law, including any provisions prohibiting, limiting, or imposing additional requirements on the use of search warrants. (See Pen. Code Sec. 1546.1(d).)
Thus, the key difference between existing law and this bill appears to relate to the cases in which a warrant could be authorized under this bill as opposed to CalECPA. This bill would now allow for warrants to be issued in cases where law enforcement seeks information off of a car’s black box, not just in cases of felonies, but misdemeanors and other public offenses.
Currently, CalECPA recognizes the ability of law enforcement to seek a warrant for electronic device information pursuant to the Penal Code chapter governing the issuance of warrants (“search warrants chapter”), subject to the CalECPA warrant requirements above. The search warrants chapter, in turn, only expressly authorizes the issuance of a warrant in connection with misdemeanor violations in two areas. First, it permits a warrant to be issued when the information to be received from the use of a “tracking device” constitutes evidence that tends to show that either a felony, or a misdemeanor under the Fish and Game Code or Public Resources Code, has been committed or is being committed; tends to show that a particular person has committed or is committing a felony or such misdemeanor violations; or will assist in locating an individual who has committed or is committing a felony or such misdemeanor violations. (Pen. Code Sec. 1524(a)(12).) Second, it permits a warrant to be issued when a provider of electronic communication service or remote computing service has records or evidence, as specified, showing that property was stolen or embezzled constituting a misdemeanor, or that property or things are in the possession of any person with the intent to use them as a means of committing a misdemeanor public offense. (Pen. Code Sec. 1524(a)(7).) Similarly, the search warrants chapter authorizes warrants to be issued in two instances involving “public offenses”- one of which refers specifically to “misdemeanor public offense,” and the other which references “public offense” more generally. In that case, a warrant can be issued on the grounds that the property or things are in the possession of any person with the intent to use them as a means of committing a public offense, or in the possession of another to whom he or she may have delivered them for the purpose of concealing them or preventing them from being discovered. (Pen. Code Sec. 1524(a)(3).)
Arguably, given the sensitivity of and significant privacy implications involved with electronic information, a question arises as to whether law enforcement should be able to obtain that information in cases that do not involve a felony, particularly when given that subpoenas may be granted in non-criminal cases involving accidents. (See Comment 5 for more.)
- Unclear that a public offense is sufficient to warrant such an invasion of privacy involving electronic information: Despite recent amendments in the prior policy committee to narrow the bill, it remains unclear as to what constitutes a “public offense” sufficient for a warrant under this bill, other than it must involve death or serious bodily injury. Presumably, it includes misdemeanors and not just felonies, but it could also include infractions that involved death or serious bodily injury. This has potentially critical privacy implications for individuals to whom this car black box data pertains.
In its opposition to the introduced version of this bill, the American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU) highlighted this issue, raising concerns about the privacy concerns implicated when electronic information is sought by government entities. As stated in by ACLU:
In accordance with fundamental constitutional principles, California’s search warrant statute operates to curb governmental overreach, and to protect the privacy and personal security of those within our state. In order to balance these privacy concerns with the legitimate public safety concerns, our existing law is designed to permit the issuance of a search warrant only under narrow circumstances, for the most serious offenses, and only when governmental needs have been determined to outweigh those of private individuals.
Privacy concerns are heightened when it is electronic information that is sought. Because the electronic information routinely collected by our phones, devices and cars is so extensive and contains such a wealth of highly private information, California’s Electronic Communications Privacy Act puts in place additional protections when the government seeks access to this type of information. The kinds of information available from a motor vehicle recording device provide a good example of why additional protection is needed for electronic information: the data may include records of where the vehicle has been and the speeds at which it has been driven as well as steering and braking information and other information.
AB 1638 would contravene the carefully crafted balance of our search warrant statute by allowing the issuance of a warrant for the extensive data available from a motor vehicle recording device when the crime under investigation is a misdemeanor. The bill would allow the privacy rights of the individual to be violated when the governmental interest, in investigating a less-serious offense, does not warrant that violation.
The author responds that this bill “is very narrowly crafted to only allow law enforcement to access this information from the vehicle’s EDR that is related to the commission of a public offense involving a motor vehicle accident that results in a person’s death or serious bodily injury. In these circumstances the law enforcement officer would need a judge to issue a search warrant and then the officer would only be able to access information that is related to the accident in order to aid with the accident investigation. No personal information from the driver would be able to be obtained under this bill.”
- Related legislation: AB 904 (Chau) would prohibit a court from granting a search warrant to conduct real-time surveillance of a person through an electronic device possessed by that person, except in extraordinary circumstances. AB 904 is currently in the Assembly Public Safety Committee.
- Prior legislation: AB 1924 (Low, Ch. 511, Stats. 2016) provided an exemption from CalECPA for pen registers and trap and trace devices to permit authorization for the devices to be used for 60 days.
SB 178 (Leno, Ch. 651, Stats. 2015) enacted CalECPA, which generally requires law enforcement entities to obtain a search warrant before accessing data on an electronic device or from an online service provider.
AB 929 (Chau, Ch. 204, Stats. 2015) authorized state and local law enforcement to use pen register and trap and trace devices under state law, and permitted the issuance of emergency pen registers and trap and trace devices. The authorization for the use of a trap and trace device or a pen register was for 60 days from the date of issuance, with extensions of up to 60 days. However, the governor signed AB 929 prior to signing the ECPA and as a result the authorization was chaptered out by the ECPA’s 10-day authorizations.
SB 467 (Leno, 2013) would have required a search warrant when a governmental agency is seeking the contents of a wire or electronic communication that is stored, held or maintained by a provider. SB 467 was vetoed by Governor Brown, who wrote: “The bill, however, imposes new notice requirements that go beyond those required by federal law and could impede ongoing criminal investigations. I do not think that is wise.”
SB 1434 (Leno, 2012) would have required a government entity to get a search warrant in order to obtain the location information of an electronic device. SB 1434 was vetoed by Governor Brown, who wrote: “It may be that legislative action is needed to keep the law current in our rapidly evolving electronic age. But I am not convinced that this bill strikes the right balance between the operational needs of law enforcement and individual expectations of privacy.”
SB 914 (Leno, 2011) would have required a search warrant to search the contents of a portable electronic device that is found during a search incident to an arrest. SB 914 was vetoed by Governor Brown, who wrote: “This measure would overturn a California Supreme Court decision that held that police officers can lawfully search the cell phones of people who they arrest. The courts are better suited to resolve the complex and case-specific issues relating to constitutional search-and-seizures protections.”
- Double-referral: This bill was double-referred to the Assembly Public Safety Committee where it was heard on April 9, 2019, and passed on a 5-0 vote.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
California District Attorneys Association
Opposition
American Civil Liberties Union
Analysis Prepared by: Ronak Daylami / P. & C.P. / (916) 319-2200
Date of Hearing: April 9, 2019
Counsel: Nikki Moore
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON PUBLIC SAFETY
Reginald Byron Jones-Sawyer, Sr., Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 1638
Author:(Obernolte) – As Introduced Ver:February 22, 2019
As Proposed to be Amended
SUMMARY:
Expands authorization for the issuance of a search warrant to obtain information from a motor vehicle’s software that “tends to show the commission of a public offense involving a motor vehicle, resulting in death or serious bodily injury.” Specifically, this bill:
- Authorizes the issuance of a search warrant when the property or things to be seized are data, from a recording device installed by the manufacturer of a motor vehicle, that constitutes evidence that tends to show the commission of a public offense involving a motor vehicle, resulting in death or serious bodily injury to any person.
- Defines “recording device” to mean a device that is installed by the manufacturer of the vehicle and does one or more of the following, for the purpose of retrieving data after an accident: (1) Records how fast and in which direction the motor vehicle is traveling; (2) Records a history of where the motor vehicle travels; (3) Records steering performance; (4) Records brake performance, including, but not limited to, whether brakes were applied before an accident; (5) Records the driver’s seatbelt status; (6) Has the ability to transmit information concerning an accident in which the motor vehicle has been involved to a central communications system when an accident occurs.
- Defines “serious bodily injury” to mean “a serious impairment of physical condition, including, but not limited to, the following: loss of consciousness; concussion; bone fracture; protracted loss or impairment of function of any bodily member or organ; a wound requiring extensive suturing; and serious disfigurement.”
EXISTING LAW:
- Provides that the right of the people to be secure in their persons, houses, papers, and effects, against unreasonable searches and seizures, shall not be violated, and no warrants shall issue, but upon probable cause, supported by oath or affirmation, and particularly describing the place to be searched and the persons or things to be seized. (U.S. Const., 4th Amend.; Cal. Const., art. I, § 13.)
- Defines a “search warrant” as a written order in the name of the people, signed by a magistrate, directed to a peace officer, commanding him or her to search for a person or persons, a thing or things, or personal property, and, in the case of a thing or things or personal property, bring the same before the magistrate. (Pen. Code, § 1523.)
- Provides that a search warrant may be issued upon any of the following grounds: (Pen. Code, § 1524):
- When the property was stolen or embezzled;
- When the property or things were used as the means of committing a felony;
- When the property or things are in the possession of any person with the intent to use them as a means of committing a public offense, or in the possession of another to whom he or she may have delivered them for the purpose of concealing them or preventing them from being discovered;
- When the property or things to be seized consist of any item or evidence that tends to show that a felony has been committed or that a particular person has committed a felony;
- When the property or things to be seized consist of evidence that tends to show sexual exploitation of a child or possession of child pornography;
- When there is a warrant to arrest a person;
- When a provider of electronic communication or remote computing service has records or evidence showing that property was stolen or embezzled constituting a misdemeanor, or that property or things are in the possession of any person with the intent to use them as a means of committing a misdemeanor, or in the possession of another to whom he or she may have delivered them for the purpose of concealment;
- When the things to be seized include evidence showing failure to secure workers compensation;
- When the property includes a firearm or deadly weapon and specified circumstances related to domestic violence, the examination of a person's mental condition, and protective orders, as specified;
- When the information to be received from the use of a tracking device tends to show a felony or misdemeanor violation of the Fish and Game Code, or a misdemeanor violation of the Public Resources Code;
- For purposes of obtaining a sample of the blood of a person in a driving under the influence matter when the person has refused to submit or complete, a blood test as required, as limited and specified;
- The property or things to be seized are firearms or ammunition or both that are owned by, in the possession of, or in the custody or control of a person who is the subject of a gun violence restraining order, as specified;
- When the property or things to be seized include a firearm that is owned by, or in the possession of, or in the custody or control of, a person who is subject to the prohibitions regarding firearms pursuant to Section 29800 or 29805, and the court has made a finding pursuant to subdivision (c) of Section 29810 that the person has failed to relinquish the firearm as required by law;
- When the property or things to be seized are controlled substances or a device, contrivance, instrument, or paraphernalia used for unlawfully using or administering a controlled substance pursuant to the authority described in Section 11472 of the Health and Safety Code;
- When all of the following apply: (1) a blood sample constitutes evidence that tends to show a violation of specified sections of the Harbors and Navigation Code relating to the operation of a marine vessel while under the influence of drugs or alcohol; (2) the person from whom the sample is being sought has refused an officer’s request to submit to, or has failed to complete, a blood test; and (3) the sample will be drawn from the person in a reasonable, medically approved manner. This provision is not intended to abrogate a court’s mandate to determine the propriety of the issuance of a search warrant on a case- by-case basis.
- When the property or things to be seized consists of evidence that tends to show that a violation privacy, as specified, that has occurred or is occurring.
- When the property was stolen or embezzled;
- The property, things, person, or persons described in the foregoing provisions may be taken on the warrant from any place, or from any person in whose possession the property or things may be. (Pen. Code, § 1524, subd. (b).)
- Provides that a search warrant cannot be issued but upon probable cause, supported by affidavit, naming or describing the person to be searched or searched for, and particularly describing the property, thing, or things and the place to be searched. (Pen. Code, § 1525.)
- Requires a magistrate to issue a search warrant if he or she is satisfied of the existence of the grounds of the application or that there is probable cause to believe their existence. (Pen. Code, § 1528, subd. (a).)
- Enacts CalECPA, which generally prohibits a government entity from compelling the production of or access to electronic communication information or electronic device information without a search warrant, wiretap order, order for electronic reader records, or subpoena issued pursuant to specified conditions, except for emergency situations. (Pen. Code, §§ 1546-1546.4.)
- Provides that a government entity may access electronic device information by means of a physical interaction or electronic communication device only: pursuant to a warrant; wiretap; with authorization of the possessor of the device; with consent of the owner of the device; in an emergency; and if seized from an inmate. (Pen. Code, § 1546.1, subd. (b).)
- Specifies the conditions under which a government entity may access electronic device information by means of physical interaction or electronic communication with the device, such as pursuant to a search warrant, wiretap order, or consent of the owner of the device. (Pen. Code, § 1546.1, subd. (c).)
- Allows a service provider to voluntarily disclose electronic communication information or subscriber information, when the disclosure is not otherwise prohibited under state or federal law. (Pen. Code, § 1546.1, subd. (f).)
- Provides that if a government entity receives electronic communication voluntarily it shall destroy that information within 90 days except under specified circumstances. (Pen. Code, § 1546.1, subd. (g).)
- Provides for notice to the target of a warrant or an emergency obtaining electronic information to be provided either contemporaneously with the service of the warrant or within three days in an emergency situation. (Pen. Code, § 1546.2, subd. (a).)
- Allows a person in a trial, hearing, or proceeding to move to suppress any electronic information obtained or retained in violation of the Fourth Amendment or the CalECPA. (Pen. Code, § 1546.4, subd. (a).)
- Defines “serious bodily injury” to mean a “serious impairment of physical condition, including, but not limited to, the following: loss of consciousness; concussion; bone fracture; protracted loss or impairment of function of any bodily member or organ; a wound requiring extensive suturing; and serious disfigurement.” (Pen. Code, § 24, subd. (f).)
- Requires that when an “event data recorders (EDR)” or “sensing and diagnostic modules (SDM),” is installed into a car, the owner’s manual for the vehicle shall disclose that fact. Defines “recording device” to mean a device that is installed by the manufacturer of the vehicle and does one or more of the following, for the purpose of retrieving data after an accident:
- Records how fast and in which direction the motor vehicle is traveling;
- Records a history of where the motor vehicle travels;
- Records steering performance;
- Records brake performance, including, but not limited to, whether brakes were applied before an accident; and,
- Records the driver’s seatbelt status.
- Has the ability to transmit information concerning an accident in which the motor vehicle has been involved to a central communications system when an accident occurs. (Veh. Code, § 9951.)
FISCAL EFFECT:
Unknown
COMMENTS:
- Author's Statement: According to the author, “This bill would give law enforcement statutory authority to obtain a search warrant in order to access EDR data in limited cases when an accident results in death or serious bodily injury. EDR technology is installed in most newer motor vehicle models and generally captures data from a period of approximately five seconds before until one second after a collision. This data can include information regarding the vehicle’s braking, steering, airbag deployment, seat belt use, seat belt pre-tensioners, speed, engine throttle, time between crash events, and other pertinent factors, which is crucial in aiding an officer during an accident investigation. Current law does not allow law enforcement to obtain EDR data for any motor vehicle manufactured on or after July 1, 2004 without a court order or the consent of the vehicle owner. Unfortunately, in solo accidents the driver may be deceased or critically injured and, therefore, unable to give consent. This bill will give law enforcement the statutory authority for a search warrant to in order to access the most crucial and scientifically reliable evidence regarding the cause of an accident.”
- The Fourth Amendment: Both the United States and the California constitutions guarantee the right of all persons to be secure from unreasonable searches and seizures. (U.S. Const., amend. IV; Cal. Const., art. 1, sec. 13.) This protection applies to all unreasonable government intrusions into legitimate expectations of privacy. (United States v. Chadwick (1977) 433 U.S. 1, 7, overruled on other grounds by California v. Acevedo (1991) 500 U.S. 565.) In general, a search is not valid unless it is conducted pursuant to a warrant. A search warrant may not be issued without probable cause. “Reasonable and probable cause exists if a man of ordinary care and prudence would be led to conscientiously entertain an honest and strong suspicion that the accused is guilty.” (People v. Alvarado (1967) 250 Cal.App.2d 584, 591, citations and quotations omitted.) The mere reasonableness of a search, assessed in light of the surrounding circumstances, is not a substitute for the warrant required by the Constitution. (Arkansas v. Sanders (1979) 442 U.S. 753, 758, overruled on other grounds by California v. Acevedo, supra.) There are exceptions to the warrant requirement, but the burden of establishing an exception is on the party seeking one. (Arkansas v. Sanders, 442 U.S. at 760.)
Fourth Amendment jurisprudence has developed to permit a government entity to access information held by a third party, in some cases with a warrant and in some, without. The third-party doctrine is grounded in the idea that an individual has a reduced expectation of privacy when knowingly sharing information with another. For example, the United States Supreme Court held that a person does not have a reasonable expectation of privacy in bank records, which may be subpoenaed by law enforcement with reasonable suspicion that those records will reveal that a crime has been committed. The court has, on the other hand, said that location information obtained from a third party which is transmitted through a cellphone likely requires a warrant to access, except in exigent circumstances.
- The California Electronic Communications Privacy Act (CalECPA): Federal law establishes a minimum floor to protect fundamental rights; a state may confer a greater protection of rights than its federal counterpart. In 2015, California did so when it passed SB 178 (Leno), Chapter 651, Statutes of 2015, which established CalECPA. SB 178 requires law enforcement officials to obtain a warrant before “searching” a person’s electronic records when they are held by a third party. In doing so, California has outstripped the Supreme Court in making it clear that warrant is required for an intrusion into a person’s electronic records and devices even if a third party has access to them.
Any California court issuing a warrant must decide whether to grant that warrant on a case by case basis. Under CalECPA, a law enforcement agency must have probable cause to search electronic records held by a third party. The law limits the reach of any warrant to information described with particularity, under specific time periods, identifying the “target individuals or accounts, the applications or services covered, and the types of information sought.”[1] The law also specifies that any information unrelated to the objective of the warrant shall be sealed and not subject to further review, use, or disclosure without a court order.[2]
- Warrant to Access Data on an Event Data Recorder: Many cars are sold equipped with one or more recording devices commonly referred to as “event data recorders (EDR)” or “sensing and diagnostic modules (SDM).”
A car’s black box is analogous to other electronic storage devices for which courts have recognized a reasonable expectation of privacy. CalECPA requires a law enforcement agency to obtain a warrant in order to access the data held on an EDR if it seeks the data from a third party. The author explains that in some cases, solo vehicle accidents that result in death may not result in criminal investigations, but law enforcement still investigates the accident to determine the cause. This bill seeks to give law enforcement the right to obtain information held in an EDR even if there is no criminal prosecution being sought.
It is unclear why the existing ability to subpoena information from a third party is not sufficient to address the author’s concerns. CalECPA recognizes that a subpoena may be issued to a third party holding electronic information, permitting a third party to disclose information “[p]ursuant to a subpoena issued pursuant to existing state law, provided that the information is not sought for the purpose of investigating or prosecuting a criminal offense, and compelling the production of or access to the information via the subpoena is not otherwise prohibited by state or federal law.” (Pen. Code, § 1546.1, subd. (b)(4).)
- Proposed Amendments Limit the Information that Can Be Obtained through a Warrant: Committee amendments limit the information that may be obtained from an EDR to the information articulated in Vehicle Code section 9951. That includes information regarding: 1) how fast and in which direction the motor vehicle is traveling, 2) a history of where the motor vehicle travels, 3) Records steering performance, 4) brake performance, including, but not limited to, whether brakes were applied before an accident, and the driver’s seatbelt status.
The amendments also limit the scope of information that may be obtained from the EDR to “data that is directly related to the public offense for which the warrant is issued.” In practice, this means that EDR information related to a deadly accident may be released to the extent that the data sought is relevant to the accident, but a warrant would not be issued for wide-ranging access to the driver’s data for long periods of time, for example, over the week prior to the accident.
The opposition objects that this bill expands the ability for law enforcement to obtain a warrant in misdemeanor cases. While this may be true, the Legislature has previously authorized specific misdemeanor offenses that will justify the issuance of a warrant, for example, in certain misdemeanor invasion of privacy actions. AB 1638 may authorize the issuance of a warrant in a misdemeanor case which law enforcement is not currently authorized to obtain under the law. However, this bill only authorizes a warrant if the offense suspected to be committed resulted in serious bodily injury or death.
- Argument in Support: None submitted.
- Argument in Opposition: According to American Civil Liberties Union of California, “In accordance with fundamental constitutional principles, California’s search warrant statute operates to curb governmental overreach, and to protect the privacy and personal security of those within our state. In order to balance these privacy concerns with the legitimate public safety concerns, our existing law is designed to permit the issuance of a search warrant only under narrow circumstances, for the most serious offenses, and only when governmental needs have been determined to outweigh those of private individuals.
“Privacy concerns are heightened when it is electronic information that is sought. Because the electronic information routinely collected by our phones, devices and cars is so extensive and contains such a wealth of highly private information, California’s Electronic Communications Privacy Act puts in place additional protections when the government seeks access to this type of information. The kinds of information available from a motor vehicle recording device provide a good example of why additional protection is needed for electronic information: the data may include records of where the vehicle has been and the speeds at which it has been driven as well as steering and braking information and other information.
“AB 1638 would contravene the carefully crafted balance of our search warrant statute by allowing the issuance of a warrant for the extensive data available from a motor vehicle recording device when the crime under investigation is a misdemeanor. The bill would allow the privacy rights of the individual to be violated when the governmental interest, in investing a less-serious offense, does not warrant that violation.” - Related Legislation: AB 904 (Chau) would prohibit a court from granting a search warrant to conduct real-time surveillance of a person through an electronic device possessed by that person, except in extraordinary circumstances. AB 904 is currently pending before this committee.
- Prior Legislation:
- SB 178 (Leno) Chapter 651, Statutes of 2015, established CalECPA, which prohibited a government entity from compelling the production of, or access to, electronic-communication information or electronic-device information without a search warrant or wiretap order, except under specified emergency situations.
- AB 1924 (Low), Chapter 511, Statutes of 2016, requires an order or extension order authorizing or approving the installation and use of a pen register or a trap and trace device direct that the order be sealed until the order, including any extensions, expires, and would require that the order or extension direct that the person owning or leasing the line to which the pen register or trap and trace device is attached not disclose the existence of the pen register or trap and trace device or the existence of the investigation to the listed subscriber or to any other person.
- AB 929 (Chau), Chapter 204, Statutes of 2015, authorized state and local law enforcement to use pen register and trap and trace devices under state law, and permits the issuance of emergency pen registers and trap and trace devices.
- AB 1104 (Rodriguez), Chapter 124, Statutes of 2015, authorizes the issuance of a search warrant when the property or things to be seized are controlled substances or any device, contrivance, instrument, or paraphernalia used for unlawfully using or administering a controlled substance.
- AB 1310 (Gatto), Chapter 643, Statutes of 2015, expanded a governmental entity’s authority to gather specified records from a provider of electronic communication service or a remote computing service by search warrant to include contents of communications originated by or addressed to the service provider.
- AB 1014 (Skinner), Chapter 872, Statutes of 2014, provided, in pertinent part, that a search warrant may be issued when the property or things to be seized are firearms or ammunition that are in the custody or control of, or is owned or possessed by, a person who is the subject of a gun violence restraining order.
- SB 178 (Leno) Chapter 651, Statutes of 2015, established CalECPA, which prohibited a government entity from compelling the production of, or access to, electronic-communication information or electronic-device information without a search warrant or wiretap order, except under specified emergency situations.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
California District Attorneys Association
Oppose
American Civil Liberties Union of California
Analysis Prepared by:
Nikki Moore / PUB. S. / (916) 319-3744
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):