AB 1667: Electronic wills.
- Session Year: 2019-2020
- House: Assembly
- Latest Version Date: 2020-08-10
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Aug 20, 2020 | In committee: Held under submission. |
| Aug 19, 2020 | In committee: Referred to APPR. suspense file. |
| Aug 13, 2020 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on APPR. with recommendation: To Consent Calendar. (Ayes 9. Noes 0.) (August 13). Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Aug 10, 2020 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to committee. Read second time, amended, and re-referred to Com. on JUD. |
| Jun 25, 2020 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to committee. Read second time, amended, and re-referred to Com. on JUD. |
| Apr 24, 2020 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to committee. Read second time, amended, and re-referred to Com. on JUD. |
| Jul 1, 2019 | In committee: Set, first hearing. Hearing canceled at the request of author. |
| Jun 28, 2019 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to committee. Read second time, amended, and re-referred to Com. on JUD. |
| May 22, 2019 | Referred to Com. on JUD. |
| May 9, 2019 | In Senate. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. |
| May 9, 2019 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Senate. |
| May 2, 2019 | Read second time. Ordered to Consent Calendar. |
| May 1, 2019 | From committee: Do pass. To Consent Calendar. (Ayes 18. Noes 0.) (May 1). |
| Apr 25, 2019 | Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Apr 24, 2019 | Read second time and amended. |
| Apr 23, 2019 | From committee: Amend, and do pass as amended and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 12. Noes 0.) (April 23). |
| Mar 19, 2019 | Re-referred to Com. on JUD. |
| Mar 18, 2019 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to Com. on JUD. Read second time and amended. |
| Mar 18, 2019 | Referred to Com. on JUD. |
| Feb 25, 2019 | Read first time. |
| Feb 23, 2019 | From printer. May be heard in committee March 25. |
| Feb 22, 2019 | Introduced. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Aug 19, 2020 | Placed on suspense file | Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Aug 13, 2020 | Do pass, but first be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] with the recommendation: To Consent Calendar | Senate Standing Committee on Judiciary |
Passed |
|
| May 9, 2019 | AB 1667 Santiago Consent Calendar Second Day Regular Session | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| May 1, 2019 | Do pass. To Consent Calendar. | Assembly Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Apr 23, 2019 | Do pass as amended and be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Assembly Standing Committee on Judiciary |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
SENATE COMMITTEE ON
Senator Anthony Portantino, Chair
2019 - 2020 Regular Session
AB 1667 (Santiago) - Electronic wills
Version: | Policy Vote: |
Urgency: | Mandate: |
Hearing Date: | Consultant: |
Bill Summary:
AB 1667 would require the California Law Revision Commission (CLRC) to study the feasibility of electronic wills.
Fiscal Impact:
A study of this nature and scope, with the associated time restriction, would require the commitment of 1.0 Staff Counsel per year for the duration of the study. The cost of 1.0 Staff Counsel, including wages and benefits, is approximately $150,000. The commission has indicated that it currently has sufficient resources to complete the study by the required deadline; however, work on other legislative requests would by postponed or pushed back by prioritizing this study. (General Fund)
Background:
The California Law Revision Commission has the responsibility to make a continuing substantive review of California statutory and case law, to recommend legislation to make needed reforms, and to make recommendations to the Governor and Legislature for revision of the law on major topics (as assigned by the Legislature) that require detailed study and cannot easily be handled in the ordinary legislative process. In 2019, the Legislature established a new committee within CLRC called the Committee on Revision of the Penal Code, effective January 1, 2020, to study and make recommendations on revision of the Penal Code to achieve certain objectives, including simplifying and rationalizing the substance of criminal law and establishing alternatives to incarceration. The committee is required to prepare an annual report that describes its work in the prior calendar year and its expected work for the subsequent calendar year.
Existing law provides than an individual age 18 or older who is of sound mind, or an authorized conservator, may make a will. For a will to be valid, it must be (i) in writing, as defined; (ii) signed by the testator or on their behalf by another person in the testator’s presence and by their direction, or by an authorized conservator, and (iii) signed by two witnesses, during the testator’s lifetime, in each other’s presence, who witnessed either the signing of the will or the testator’s acknowledgment of the signature or of the will and understand that the instrument they sign is the testator’s will. If the witnessing requirement was not executed properly, existing law nonetheless upholds the validity of the will if the proponent of the will establishes by clear and convincing evidence that, at the time the testator signed the will, the testator intended it to constitute their will. Additionally, California recognizes as valid “holographic” wills, regardless of if it is witnessed, if the signature and material provisions are in the testator’s handwriting. Existing law specifies methods for the testator to revoke all or part of a will.
Within 30 days of learning of the testator’s death, the custodian of a will must deliver the will to the clerk of the superior court in the county in which the estate may be administered, as well as a copy to the executor of the estate. Existing law establishes default rules for the distribution of an estate that is not effectively disposed of by will.
Proposed Law:
This bill would require CLRC to deliver to the Legislature a study regarding the feasibility of electronic wills by September 30, 2022. At a minimum, the study must include a discussion of all of the following:
- How electronic wills are treated by the Uniform Law Commission and by other states and countries.
- Case studies involving electronic wills or other electronic testamentary instruments, to the extent that information is accessible and can be feasibly obtained.
- Common issues relating to electronic wills, including formation (including the requirement for electronic signatures) and witnessing (including remote online witnessing).
It also would require the study to recommend a specific legislative proposal for a comprehensive statutory scheme for recognizing electronic wills in California if CLRC determines that adopting a statutory scheme that recognizes electronic wills is prudent and does not pose unnecessary risks of fraud.
Related Legislation:
AB 3095 (Santiago, 2017-2018 Reg. Sess.) would have established a statutory scheme for electronic wills. AB 3095 was never heard in the Assembly Committee on Judiciary.
ACR 173 (Gallagher, 2019-2022 Reg. Sess.) would reauthorize and remove specified study topics for CLRC. ACR 173 is pending in this Committee.
SB 94 (Committee on Budget and Fiscal Review, Ch. 25, Stats. 2019) established a committee within CLRC to study and make recommendations on revision of the Penal Code, as specified.
AB 2248 (Spitzer, Ch. 53, Stats. 2008) added California’s variant of the harmless error rule.
-- END --
Senator Hannah-Beth Jackson, Chair
2019-2020 Regular Session
Bill No: AB 1667 (Author:Santiago)
Version: August 10, 2020
Hearing Date: August 13, 2020
Fiscal: Yes
Urgency: No
Consultant: JT
SUBJECT
Electronic wills
DIGEST
This bill would require the California Law Revision Commission (Commission), by September 30, 2022, to provide the Legislature a study on electronic wills, as specified.
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
In the span of a generation, our daily lives have become digitized in numerous ways, impacting how we communicate, interact, entertain ourselves, travel, consume media, and fall in love. Tangible books, newspapers, and maps are practically quaint anachronisms. Virtually every type of transaction can be done electronically: shopping, ordering food, banking, investing, paying bills, filing taxes, applying for a job, executing contracts, and purchasing real property. Even currency itself has been digitized. And the COVID-19 pandemic has accelerated this trend in areas such as remote work, telehealth, and judicial proceedings and records.
Wills are one of the few exceptions. For hundreds of years the same basic requirements have applied: they must be written, signed, and attested to. These formalities have endured because they protect against fraud, help testators appreciate the gravity of their decisions, and force them to delineate how they want their assets distributed.
This bill, which is sponsored by LegalZoom, is the product of years of intensive stakeholder discussions that resulted in an impasse as to whether, and how, to create a scheme in California that recognizes electronic wills. To help resolve the issue and provide a path forward, the bill was recently amended to require the Commission, by September 30, 2022, to study electronic wills and, if it finds that adopting a statutory scheme that recognizes electronic wills is prudent and does not pose unnecessary risks of fraud, to recommend a specific legislative proposal for a comprehensive statutory scheme for recognizing electronic wills. The bill has no registered opposition.
PROPOSED CHANGES TO THE LAW
Existing law:
- Provides than an individual 18 or more years of age who is of sound mind, or an authorized conservator, may make a will. (Prob. Code § 6100.)[1]
- For a will to be valid, requires that it be (1) in writing, (2) signed by the testator or on their behalf by another person in the testator’s presence and by their direction, or by an authorized conservator, and (3) signed by two witnesses, during the testator’s lifetime, in each other’s presence, who witnessed either the signing of the will or the testator’s acknowledgment of the signature or of the will and understand that the instrument they sign is the testator’s will. (§ 6110(a), (b).) However, if the witnessing requirement was not executed properly, existing law upholds the validity of the will if the proponent of the will establishes by clear and convincing evidence that, at the time the testator signed the will, the testator intended it to constitute their will. (Id. at (c).)
- Defines “writing” as handwriting, typewriting, printing, photostating, photographing, photocopying, transmitting by electronic mail or facsimile, and every other means of recording upon any tangible thing, any form of communication or representation, including letters, words, pictures, sounds, or symbols, or combinations thereof, and any record thereby created, regardless of the manner in which the record has been stored. (Evid. Code § 250.)
- Recognizes as valid “holographic” wills, whether or not witnessed, if the signature and material provisions are in the handwriting of the testator. (§ 6111(a).)
- Specifies methods for the testator to revoke all or part of a will. (§ 6120.)
- Requires the custodian of a will, within 30 days of learning of the testator’s death, to deliver the will to the clerk of the superior court in the county in which the estate may be administered, as well as a copy to the executor. (§ 8200)
- Establishes default rules for the distribution of an estate that is not effectively disposed of by will. (§ 6400 et seq.)
This bill:
- Declares the intent of the Legislature to evaluate the merits of electronic wills and whether the Legislature should adopt a statutory scheme that recognizes electronic wills.
- Requires the Commission, by September 30, 2022, to deliver to the Legislature a study regarding the feasibility of electronic wills that includes, at a minimum, a discussion of the following:
- How electronic wills are treated by the Uniform Law Commission, other states, and other countries.
- Case studies involving electronic wills or other electronic testamentary instruments, to the extent that information is accessible and can be feasibly obtained.
- Common issues related to electronic wills, including formation, authentication, witnessing, storage, custodianship, delivery and presentation to the court, evidence, codicils, revocation, and any other aspect of the law of wills the Commission determines to be reasonable to study.
- Requires the Commission, if it determines that adopting a statutory scheme that recognizes electronic wills is prudent and does not pose unnecessary risks of fraud, to recommend a specific legislative proposal for a comprehensive statutory scheme for recognizing electronic wills in California.
COMMENTS
1. The allure and challenges of electronic wills
One of the few exceptions to the digital revolution is wills. Although the vast majority of wills are created on a computer, they must be printed out and signed in the physical presence of two witnesses. This practice traces to ancient Rome, where it was common for the wealthy to execute a will in a ceremony in which they solemnized their testamentary intentions in a written document, to which seven witnesses affixed their seal.[2] Vestiges of these laws survived despite the feudal law of primogeniture in the Middle Ages. The Statute of Wills in 1540 made land devisable by written will, the Statute of Frauds in 1677 required dispositions of any property to be in writing, and the Wills Act of 1837 also required dispositions to be signed by the testator in the presence of two or more witnesses.[3]
These formalities serve several purposes. They provide evidence of a testator’s wishes, force them to articulate these wishes in a standardized manner, impress upon them the solemnity and consequences of making a plan for the distribution of their property, and discourage improper influence, fraud, forgeries, and perjury.[4]
Strict adherence to these formalities occasionally led courts to invalidate wills on minor technicalities where the testator’s intent was clear. States began shifting toward a “substantial compliance” model to fulfill testator intent in such circumstances. In some states, this model has been replaced by the more liberal “harmless error” doctrine that enables courts to dispense with formalities and probate an improperly executed will so long as there is clear and convincing evidence of the testator’s intent.[5] In 2008, California adopted a variant of this rule that applies to the witnessing requirement. (§ 6110.)[6]
Additionally, no witness is required for so-called “holographic” wills that are handwritten and signed by the testator. (§ 6111.) “California has kept pace with reforms that are intended to simplify the process of creating a will, so that a person’s testamentary wishes are not thwarted by archaic requirements. It now is possible for a person to write a legally binding will on a cocktail napkin, provided that the person signs it with the intent to create a will.”[7]
For the better part of three years, the author of this bill has argued that California needs a statutory scheme that governs electronic wills—a testamentary device created, written, signed, and/or attested to on an electronic medium. The promise of electronic wills, the argument goes, is that they are convenient and efficient and will induce more people to execute wills. According to one survey, 64 percent of Gen-Xers and 78 percent of Millennials do not have a will.[8] Younger generations are marinated in a digital lifestyle and, whether or not California chooses to formally recognize them, electronic expressions of testamentary intent will become more common, forcing courts to eventually grapple with the issue. Additionally, vulnerable individuals could benefit from wills that can be witnessed and solemnized remotely.
Beneath that surface appeal lies a range of vexing problems relating to fraud, undue influence, safekeeping, and authentication of electronic documents. If stored improperly, electronic wills may be accessible to unscrupulous interested parties who may be able to manipulate the document. Departing from centuries of precedent to recognize an entirely new medium for expressing testamentary intent will usher in novel and challenging issues for courts. An inadequately drafted statutory scheme could open the litigation floodgates and result in the mass invalidation of wills.
Such concerns prompted a strong reaction from certain stakeholders, particularly groups that represent probate attorneys and judges. The bill’s predecessor, AB 3095 (Santiago, 2018) never received a hearing in the Assembly Judiciary Committee. This bill has undergone multiple makeovers, proposing various different schemes for recognizing electronic wills in California. Each new iteration led to multiple rounds of intensive and impassioned discussions. Although it appeared at various points that a product approximating consensus might emerge, disagreements among stakeholders, particularly with regard to the degree of formalities that should be prescribed for electronic wills, persisted and promise to remain intractable.
When the Legislature recently shut down because of the COVID-19 pandemic, time constraints forced the Houses to make difficult decisions to set aside some otherwise meritorious bills that were not of the highest urgency. This bill initially fell into that category. Nonetheless, because of the importance and relevance of the issue of electronic wills, a last-minute deal was struck to again remake the bill, this time in the form of a study.
2. California Law Revision Commission study on electronic wills
This bill, as recently amended, declares the intent of the Legislature to evaluate the merits of electronic wills and whether to adopt a statutory scheme that recognizes electronic wills. The bill requires the Commission, by September 30, 2022, to deliver to the Legislature a study regarding the feasibility of electronic wills that includes, at a minimum, a discussion of the following issues:
- How electronic wills are treated by the Uniform Law Commission, other states, and other countries
The Uniform Law Commission approved model legislation in July of 2019. A version of this bill was modeled after that law. Both were poorly received by stakeholders, particularly with regard to the issue of remote witnessing and the fact that they would have created standalone provisions rather than attempting to incorporate electronic wills into existing statutory schemes.[9]
Arizona, Florida, Indiana, and Nevada have legislative schemes that recognize electronic wills. Florida’s scheme, which generated significant controversy, was passed along party lines but vetoed in 2017, only to be signed into law in 2019 by a new Governor.[10] Florida’s legislation provides for remote witnessing and has extensive provisions governing custodianship, a process that has been criticized as advantaging incumbent electronic wills firms but that has also been recognized as having the potential to allay concerns over tampering and forgeries, making it easier to probate the will.
Outside of the United States, some countries such as Canada and Australia recognize wills that do not comply with the traditional formalities, provided that there is sufficient evidence of testamentary intent. Australian courts have probated files labeled as wills in smartphones or created on Microsoft Word.[11]
The experience in these jurisdictions may offer useful guidance as the Commission conducts its study. Additionally, California may soon be forced to probate electronic wills executed in other states if the testator then moves to and dies in California.
- Case studies involving electronic wills
Some courts have begun to grapple with electronic expressions of testamentary intent.
A court in Tennessee deemed valid a will that a testator drafted on his computer and signed with a computer-generated cursive font in the presence of two witnesses. (Taylor v. Holt (Tenn. Ct. App. 2003) 134 S.W.3d 830.) In re Estate of Castro (Ohio Ct. Com. Pl. Prob. Div. June 19, 2013)[12] was a case in which the testator, who had a month to live, drafted a will on a tablet computer using a stylus pen. He and the witnesses signed it as he lay in the hospital. Finally, a recent Michigan case addressed a disposition of property that was contained in a suicide note created on a smartphone. Before dying, the decedent wrote a handwritten note with instructions for accessing the document on his phone. The court held the document was valid because clear and convincing evidence showed that the decedent intended the document to be his will. (Guardianship & Alternatives, Inc. v. Jones (In re Estate of Horton) (2018) 325 Mich.App. 325, 336.) A thorough examination of such precedents will help identify potential issues and principles for resolving them.
- Common issues related to electronic wills
This bill would additionally require the Commission to address a wide range of complex issues that have generated significant controversy and divergent viewpoints. These issues include the following:
- Formation—A key threshold question is whether electronic wills must be in writing. Could electronic wills also include audio or video recordings? And what form must written electronic wills take? Could electronic wills be created on text messages, emails, or social media posts? Traditional wills are not required to be on paper: courts have upheld wills inscribed on all sorts of surfaces: skin, wood, a tractor fender, a petticoat.[13] There was a time when typewritten wills were considered controversial.[14] A key distinction, however, is the relative permanence of tangible media, and the perceived lack thereof when the surface is a computer screen.
- Authentication—Existing law recognizes electronic signatures but these provisions do not apply to wills. In recent years, electronic signatures have gained widespread acceptance for a range of major transactions. The prior version of this bill attempted to adapt those provisions to the context of electronic wills. Concerns have been raised that this definition does not showcase the testator’s assent to the will’s terms in the way that a wet signature does. Other questions remain about the wisdom of recognizing less formal versions of a signature—for example, a handwritten signature on a tablet, an email byline, username, or Twitter handle.
- Witnessing—Remote witnessing presents a major challenge but also could make electronic wills far more useful. The challenges surrounding this issue dovetail with many of the challenges surrounding the issue of remote online notarization, itself a potentially beneficial, but controversial, matter in California, with precedents in other states. This bill would require the Commission to examine both.
- Storage—Storage in cyberspace rather than physical space will present a number of challenges. If, for instance, the will is stored on the family computer that others in the household have access to, should the will be probated?
- Custodianship—Existing law requires a custodian of a will, within 30 days of learning of the testator’s death, to deliver the will to the executor and the superior court of the county in which the estate of the decedent may be administered. (§ 8200.) The prior version of this bill would have required the custodian of an electronic will to deliver a certified copy of the will to the clerk and to the executor along with a declaration under penalty of perjury that the copy is a complete, true, and accurate copy of the original will as entrusted to the custodian. As described above, some advocate a more rigorous set of requirements to ensure the integrity of the will. This eases the burden on courts, though it may not be as useful to testators. But businesses come and go. An alternative, more stable option that may be explored is the creation of government repository of electronic wills. Twenty-eight states (but not California) enable testators to deposit their will with the probate court for safekeeping.[15]
- Delivery and presentation to the court—The prior version of the bill would have required a custodian to deliver a printed version of the bill along with a declaration of its authenticity. If informal electronic wills are permitted, particularly if they are in audio or visual form, questions may arise as to the manner of delivery and presentation to the court.
- Evidence—While courts may be accustomed to scrutinizing paper wills for interlineations or considering the opinion of a forensic handwriting expert, electronic wills could create a novel set of evidentiary challenges. Depending on the type of drafting program used, metadata may reveal that the document was changed but might not reveal who did it or what was changed. The prior version of this bill would have required electronic signatures that, among other things, are linked to data in such a manner that if the data are changed the digital signature is invalidated.
- Codicils—Section 88 provides that the term “will” includes a codicil, or amendment, which itself is subject to will formalities. Complications may arise when an electronic will is amended by a printed codicil or a printed will is amended by an electronic codicil.
- Revocation—Under existing law, a will may be revoked by a subsequent will or by the testator’s physical act that burns, tears, cancels, obliterates, or destroys it. The prior version of this bill would have provided that an electronic will may be revoked by a subsequent will or the testator’s physical act performed on a copy of the will stored in an electronic record or on a printed copy of an electronic will, provided there is clear and convincing evidence of the testator’s intent. Unlike existing law, this provision does not specify which acts are sufficient to constitute revocation. Is dragging and dropping a file into a desktop’s trash a “physical act” for these purposes?
- Other aspects of the law of wills—The bill would additionally enable the Commission to study any other aspect of the law of wills it deems reasonable to study, including the following issues:
- Harmless error. A simple, elegant approach to the question of electronic wills is to embrace them through the harmless error rule, which allows courts to dispense with certain formalities when there is clear and convincing evidence of testator intent. This would arguably have the most utility for testators, but could create the most challenges for courts, which would have to wade through evidence and make considered judgements on a case-by-case basis. Alternatively, the harmless error rule could be used in limited situations, such as exigent circumstances when the person suddenly finds themselves in imminent peril of death. Many would bypass pen and paper in favor of the omnipresent smartphone to dash off a text message or record a video setting forth their posthumous wishes. Indeed, one scholar argues that such circumstances are the only instances in which an electronic will offers a true advantage.[16] Ceremonial formalities are of little value for deathbed bequests. Furthermore, “when an estate plan comes to fruition on the heels of death, less time remains for evidence to deteriorate or for would-be perpetrators to commit fraud.”[17] In this regard, fifteen states allow oral wills when a person’s life is in jeopardy.[18]
- Informal electronic wills. Existing law recognizes handwritten wills known as “holographic” wills as long as they are signed and there is evidence of testamentary intent. No witness is necessary. Text messages, emails, or videos arguably are electronic analogs to holographic wills. It may be prudent to adopt a statutory scheme to address these informal ways of memorializing one’s end-of-life wishes.
- Risk of fraud compared to traditional wills. The risk of fraud in electronic wills cannot be meaningfully evaluated unless it is addressed against the baseline prevalence of mischief in traditional wills.
Following an examination of these factors, this bill would require the Commission, if it determines that adopting a statutory scheme that recognizes electronic wills is prudent and does not pose unnecessary risks of fraud, to recommend a specific legislative proposal for a comprehensive statutory scheme for recognizing electronic wills in California. It is expected that the study’s recommendations will help break the impasse among stakeholders and forge a path forward.
The author writes:
AB 1667 is a step towards making electronic wills a reality in California. The COVID-19 pandemic has shed light on the real need for accessible forms of post-humous planning. Low-income and communities of color disproportionately lack formally recognized wills in California, which leaves the distribution of their most valuable assets at the hands of the state. The results of this study will not only guide productive conversation, but also inform the best path forward as we seek to increase accessibility, equity, and security in California.
SUPPORT
LegalZoom (sponsor)
OPPOSITION
None known
RELATED LEGISLATION
Pending Legislation: None known.
Prior Legislation:
AB 3095 (Santiago, 2018) would have established a statutory scheme for electronic wills. The bill was referred to the Assembly Judiciary Committee but was not heard.
AB 2248 (Spitzer, Ch. 53, Stats. 2008) added California’s variant of the harmless error rule.
PRIOR VOTES:
Assembly Floor (Ayes 76, Noes 0)
Assembly Appropriations Committee (Ayes 18, Noes 0)
Assembly Judiciary Committee (Ayes 12, Noes 0)
**************
All further section references are to the Probate Code unless otherwise specified. ↑
Banta, Natalie, Electronic Wills and Digital Assets: Reassessing Formality in the Digital Age (2019) 71 Baylor L. Rev. 547, 554-55. ↑
Id. at 555-56. ↑
Developments in the Law—More Data More Problems: Chapter Four: “What is an Electronic Will”? (Apr. 2018) 131 Harv. L. Rev. 1790, 1793. ↑
Id. at pp. 1794-95. ↑
Added by AB 2248 (Spitzer, Ch. 53, Stats. 2008). ↑
Hon. Julia Kelety, California Can Lead the Way on Electronic Wills (Apr. 15, 2019) Los Angeles Daily Journal at p. 6. ↑
Nick DiUlio, More than Half of U.S. Adults Don't Have a Will, New Survey Reveals (Feb. 17, 2017) HuffPost, https://www.huffpost.com/entry/more-than-half-of-us-adults-dont-have-a-will-new_b_58a6086ce4b0b0e1e0e2083a (as of Aug. 9, 2020). ↑
The ULC proposal has also been criticized for procedural irregularities, including the fact that it skipped over the question of whether to formulate legislation providing for electronic wills. It has also been noted that two members appointed to serve on the drafting committee have had an association with Willing, a firm that offers services related to electronic wills. (Hirsch, Adam, Technology Adrift: In Search of a Role for Electronic Wills (2020) 61 Boston Coll. L. Rev. 827, 869-70.) ↑
Hirsch, Technology Adrift: In Search of a Role for Electronic Wills, supra, note 9 at 869-70. ↑
Banta, Electronic Wills and Digital Assets: Reassessing Formality in the Digital Age, supra, note 2 at 581. ↑
Described in Hirsch, Technology Adrift: In Search of a Role for Electronic Wills, supra, note 9 at 852. ↑
Banta, Electronic Wills and Digital Assets: Reassessing Formality in the Digital Age, supra, note 2 at 580. ↑
Id. ↑
Hirsch, Technology Adrift: In Search of a Role for Electronic Wills, supra, note 9 at 864. ↑
Id. at 878. ↑
Id. ↑
Id. at 875. ↑
Date of Hearing: May 1, 2019
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Lorena Gonzalez, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 1667
Author:(Santiago) – As Amended Ver:April 24, 2019
Policy Committee: | Judiciary | Vote: | 12 - 0 |
|
| ||
|
|
Urgency: No State Mandated Local Program: No Reimbursable: No
SUMMARY:
This bill provides for the recognition of validly executed electronic wills if the will was executed in accordance with the laws of a state that permits electronic wills by a then-resident of that state.
FISCAL EFFECT:
Minor and absorbable costs (Trial Court Trust Fund/GF) for trial courts to draft and implement regulations pertaining to the adjudication of electronic wills.
COMMENTS:
- Purpose. According to the author:
This bill will increase access to inexpensive and convenient methods for executing valid wills, provide decedents’ families more certainty in property succession, encourage more testators to make their wills and engage in other end of life planning activities, make the benefits of the legal system more accessible to vulnerable populations, and provide clear guidance to the courts regarding electronic wills thus avoiding estate disputes, saving time and conserving tax money.
- Background. Existing law permits an individual 18 or more years of age who is of sound mind to make a will. A will must be witnessed, during the testator’s lifetime, by at least two persons each of whom are present at the same time, witnessed either the signing of the will or the testator’s acknowledgment of the signature on the will and understand that the instrument they sign is the testator’s will. Recognizing the emergence of electronic wills across the country, and the work of the Uniform Law Commission to provide for a standardized electronic wills statute. This bill would require California courts to recognize electronic wills so long as they are validly executed in accordance with the laws of the state in which the testator lived at the time the will was executed.
Analysis Prepared by: Kimberly Horiuchi / APPR. / (916) 319-2081
Date of Hearing: April 23, 2019
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON JUDICIARY
Mark Stone, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 1667
Author:(Santiago) – As Amended Ver:March 18, 2019
As Proposed to be Amended
SUBJECT: Electronic wills
KEY ISSUE: SHOULD ELECTRONIC WILLS THAT ARE PROPERLY EXECUTED IN ACCORDANCE WITH THE LAW OF ANOTHER STATE, BY THEN-RESIDENTS OF THAT STATE, BE RECOGNIZED BY CALIFORNIA COURTS?
SYNOPSIS
Recognizing that many Californians do not have a valid will, this bill seeks to serve as a vehicle for ultimately enacting an electronic wills statute in California. Currently, the Uniform Law Commission is working to develop a uniform electronic wills statute. However, the Uniform Law Commission’s recommendations are not set to be finalized until July and, even then, any recommendations would need to be analyzed as applied to California. That has not stopped other states from proceeding with their own electronic wills statutes. Several states, including California’s neighbors Arizona and Nevada, have already enacted their own electronic wills statutes. Should a person execute an electronic will in those jurisdictions, move to California and subsequently die, California courts would be forced to grapple with that electronic will. Accordingly, as proposed to be amended, this bill would explicitly recognize those wills under California law, thus permitting them to be probated in California without undue complications.
Beyond recognizing the validity of electronic wills executed out-of-state, the author and sponsor of this measure hope that this bill can serve as a vehicle for a broader discussion about electronic wills in California. Several stakeholders, including the Judicial Council of California, California Judges Association, and California Lawyers Association have all engaged with the author on discussions of what a California electronic wills statute would entail. The stakeholders have agreed to continue these discussions as this bill proceeds and in the anticipation of the Uniform Law Commission releasing its final recommendations this summer. As proposed to be amended, the parties have agreed to permit this bill to advance in the legislative process and to work in good faith with the goal of ultimately drafting a workable electronic wills statute for California. This Committee will continue to monitor this bill as it advances through the legislative process, and should amendments be adopted to implement an electronic wills statute, this Committee reserves the right to hear this bill again in its final form and render its ultimate judgment on the merits of an electronic will statute for California. As proposed to be amended, this bill is supported by online legal service provider LegalZoom.com, and has no known opposition as the above-mentioned stakeholders have agreed to engage in good faith discussions as the measure moves forward.
SUMMARY: Provides for the recognition of validly executed electronic wills if the will was executed in accordance with the laws of a state that permits electronic wills by a then-resident of that state. Specifically, this bill:
- Provides that a written or electronic will is validly executed if its execution complies with any of the following:
- The execution of the will complies with the law at the time of execution of the place where the will is executed.
- The execution of the will complies with the law of the place where at the time of execution or at the time of death the testator is domiciled, has a place of abode, or is a national.
EXISTING LAW:
- Permits an individual 18 or more years of age who is of sound mind to make a will, and permits a conservator to make a will for the conservatee if the conservator has been authorized to do so by a court order. (Probate Code Section 6100. All further statutory references are to that code unless stated otherwise.)
- Provides that a will may dispose of the following property:
- The testator’s separate property.
- The one-half of the community property that belongs to the testator.
- The one-half of the testator’s quasi-community property that belongs to the testator. (Section 6101.)
- Provides that the execution or revocation of a will or a part of a will is ineffective to the extent the execution or revocation was procured by duress, menace, fraud, or undue influence. (Section 6103.)
- Provides that a will shall be in writing and shall be signed by one of the following:
- The testator.
- In the testator’s name by some other person in the testator’s presence and by the testator’s direction.
- A conservator pursuant to a court order. (Section 6110 (b).)
- Provides that the will shall be witnessed by being signed, during the testator’s lifetime, by at least two persons each of whom being present at the same time, witnessed either the signing of the will or the testator’s acknowledgment of the signature on the will and understand that the instrument they sign is the testator’s will. (Section 6110 (c)(1).)
- Provides that a will that does not comply with 4) and 5) above is valid as a holographic will, whether or not witnessed, if the signature and the material provisions are in the handwriting of the testator. (Section 6111.)
- Provides that a written will is validly executed if its execution complies with any of the following:
- The will is executed in compliance with 4) and 5) or 6).
- The execution of the will complies with the law at the time of execution of the place where the will is executed.
- The execution of the will complies with the law of the place where at the time of execution or at the time of death the testator is domiciled, has a place of abode, or is a national. (Section 6113.)
- Provides that if a will was not executed in compliance with 4) and 5), the will shall be treated as if it was executed in compliance with 4) and 5) if the proponent of the will establishes by clear and convincing evidence that, at the time the testator signed the will, the testator intended the will to constitute the testator’s will. (Probate Code Section 6110 (c)(2).)
- Provides for a statutory form will in California. (Section 6240.)
- Provides that a will is valid as regards form, irrespective particularly of the place where it is made, of the location of the assets, and of the nationality, domicile, or residence of the testator, if it is made in the form of an international will complying with specified requirements. (Section 6381.)
- Provides that the part of an estate that does not pass to the surviving spouse or registered domestic partner or, the entire estate, if there is no surviving spouse or registered domestic partner, passes:
- To the decedent's issue, as provided;
- If no surviving issue, to the decedent's parents equally;
- If no surviving issue or parent, to the parents’ issue, as provided;
- If no surviving issue, or parent or issue of the parents, to the grandparents or their issue, as provided;
- If no surviving issue, parent or parents’ issue, or grandparent or grandparents’ issue, to the issue of a predeceased spouse or registered domestic partner, as provided;
- If no surviving issue, parent or parents’ issue, grandparent or grandparents’ issue, or issue of a predeceased spouse or registered domestic partner, to the next of kin, a provided;
- If no surviving kin or issue of a predeceased spouse or registered domestic partner, to the parents of a predeceased spouse or registered domestic partner or their issue, as provided. (Section 6402.)
- Provides that if there is no taker of an intestate estate, the estate escheats to the state. (Section 6404.)
FISCAL EFFECT: As currently in print this bill is keyed fiscal.
COMMENTS: Recognizing the emergence of electronic wills across the country, and the work of the Uniform Law Commission to provide for a standardized electronic wills statute, this bill would require California courts to recognize electronic wills so long as they are validly executed in accordance with the laws of the state in which the testator lived at the time the will was executed. In support of this bill the author states:
According to the American Bar Association, 55% of Americans die without a will or estate plan. A person who dies without a will does not exercise choice regarding who receives her or his probate property, who administers her or his estate or who will care for her or his minor children. Instead the decedent’s probate passes to default takers under applicable “intestacy laws”. The intestacy laws, which are standard, one size fits all schemes, typically give the decedent’s property to the next of kin.
This bill will increase access to inexpensive and convenient methods for executing valid wills, provide decedents’ families more certainty in property succession, encourage more testators to make their wills and engage in other end of life planning activities, make the benefits of the legal system more accessible to vulnerable populations, and provide clear guidance to the courts regarding electronic wills thus avoiding estate disputes, saving time and conserving tax money.
To reduce the risk of fraud, California law requires the execution of a will to be witnessed. Recognizing that wills can be highly contested and fraught with opportunities for fraud or undue influence, California law requires that two witnesses be present at the signing of a will. California courts have held that these formalities exist to prevent fraud and ensure that there can be candor when reviewing a will. (In re Estate of Eugene (2002) 104 Cal.App.4th 907.) Ensuring that a testator’s true intent is critical in reviewing will, as unlike typical contracts, the main signatory to the document is no longer available to provide testimony regarding their intent.
As currently in print this bill seeks to adopt a draft of the Uniform Law Commission’s standardized electronic wills statute. The current language, among other provisions, provides for remote attestation of wills, whereby witnesses would use video conferencing to attest to the signing of the will. The remote attestation provisions are one of several areas of the Uniform Law Commission’s draft to raise significant concerns with stakeholders. Accordingly, the author is proposing to amend the bill to delete all of the existing language of the bill to provide parties time to discuss electronic wills broadly without any of the controversial language in the bill.
This bill, as proposed to be amended, provides for recognition of out-of-state electronic wills. Although there is significant discussion about what a California electronic wills statute would entail, as proposed to be amended, this bill recognizes that other states are beginning to adopt their own electronic wills statutes. The author notes that legislation is currently pending before the legislatures of Texas and Florida that would adopt electronic wills. Accordingly, the author is proposing amendments to this bill to ensure that California recognizes these out of state wills. Those amendments would delete the contents of the bill and add a provision that revises Section 6113 of the Probate Code to read as follows:
6113.
A written or electronic will is validly executed if its execution complies with any of the following:
(a) The will is executed in compliance with Section 6110 or 6111 or Chapter 6 (commencing with Section 6200) (California statutory will) or Chapter 11 (commencing with Section 6380) (Uniform International Wills Act).
(b) The execution of the will complies with the law at the time of execution of the place where the will is executed.
(c) The execution of the will complies with the law of the place where at the time of execution or at the time of death the testator is domiciled, has a place of abode, or is a national.
Existing California law requires that a will created by a California resident be in writing (Probate Code Section 6010) or be filled out on a paper form provided by the state. (Probate Code Section 6200 et seq.) Nothing in this bill, as proposed to be amended, would change that. Notwithstanding the inclusion of the word “electronic” in the execution provisions of Probate Code Section 6113, any will not executed in writing would not otherwise be executed in compliance with California law, and thus not be recognized. However, by including “electronic” in these provisions, this bill is designed to permit California courts to recognize wills executed by non-California residents, in a state permitting electronic wills, who subsequently move to California, die, and thus require their estate to be sent to probate in a California court. The author hopes that this simple amendment will reduce confusion in California courts should electronic wills begin to appear in California probate courts.
The Uniform Law Commission seeks to provide a national standard for electronic wills. Recognizing that many Americans are seeking to utilize electronic technology, the Uniform Law Commission started examining how to provide for electronic wills in 2017. The Commission noted that as early as 2013 courts were being forced to grapple with wills signed on electronic devices. The drafting committee cites examples of courts being forced to evaluate the legality of wills being signed on tablets as justification for seeking to create a uniform statute for electronic wills. Currently, the Uniform Law Commission is anticipating finishing its work on a uniform electronic wills statute this summer.
The limited scope of this bill seeks to promote ongoing discussions regarding the creation of an electronic wills statute for California. As noted the author is proposing to amend the bill to delete its existing contents to better facilitate stakeholder discussions regarding electronic wills and the Uniform Law Commission’s forthcoming final draft statute. As proposed to be amended, this bill provides helpful changes to California law in recognition that other states are likely to quickly enact the Uniform Law Commission’s proposal or their own electronic wills statutes without significant debate.
However, several stakeholders have contacted the author and this Committee to weigh in on the Uniform Law Commission’s draft. These stakeholders include the Judicial Council of California, the California Judges Association, and the California Lawyers Association, all critical parties in the probate process. These parties have raised several concerns regarding definitions in the Uniform Law Commission’s draft, the remote attestation provisions, provisions regarding revocation of wills, and data security. Although the parties, mostly, agree that the Uniform Law Commission’s draft can serve as a starting point for discussions, they also agree additional negotiations around any electronic will statute in California are needed. Accordingly, should those discussions prove fruitful, this bill may serve as a vehicle to enact an ultimate compromise between the stakeholders. To that end, should this bill be approved by this Committee, the author and sponsor of this measure are committing to working with stakeholders to develop an electronic wills statute that can be implemented in California. As proposed to be amended, none of the stakeholders are taking a formal position on the bill in order to foster good faith discussions of the Uniform Law Commission’s proposal.
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: This bill is sponsored by LegalZoom.com, the online legal services provider. In support of this bill, LegalZoom.com highlights the successful passage of electronic wills statutes in other states and argues:
People want to be able to execute wills electronically, and several states have enacted electronic wills statutes or are actively considering them. Nevada Assembly Bill 413 was enacted in 2017. Arizona House Bill 2656 and Indiana House Bill 1303 were enacted in 2018.
LegalZoom encourages all of our customers to seek the advice of an attorney and many of our estate planning document customers avail themselves of these legal plans. We are informed that those customers also desire the option to electronically sign their estate planning documents. It makes the process simpler for both the attorney and their clients.
AB 1667 will add electronic wills to the statute to expressly recognize valid out-of-state electronic wills.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
LegalZoom.com
Opposition
None on file
Analysis Prepared by: Nicholas Liedtke / JUD. / (916) 319-2334
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):