AB 1772: Theft: aggregation.
- Session Year: 2019-2020
- House: Assembly
- Latest Version Date: 2019-02-22
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Jun 4, 2019 | From committee: Without further action pursuant to Joint Rule 62(a). |
| Apr 23, 2019 | In committee: Set, first hearing. Failed passage. |
| Mar 18, 2019 | Referred to Com. on PUB. S. |
| Feb 25, 2019 | Read first time. |
| Feb 23, 2019 | From printer. May be heard in committee March 25. |
| Feb 22, 2019 | Introduced. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Apr 23, 2019 | Do pass. | Assembly Standing Committee on Public Safety |
Failed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
Date of Hearing: April 23, 2019
Counsel: David Billingsley
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON PUBLIC SAFETY
Reginald Byron Jones-Sawyer, Sr., Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 1772
Author:(Chau) – As Introduced Ver:February 22, 2019
SUMMARY:
Specifies that if the value of the property taken or intended to be taken exceeds $950 over the course of distinct but related acts, whether committed against one or more victims, the value of the property taken or intended to be taken may properly be aggregated to charge a count of grand theft, if the acts are motivated by one intention, one general impulse, and one plan.
EXISTING LAW:
- Divides theft into two degrees, petty theft and grand theft. (Pen. Code, § 486.)
- Defines grand theft as when the money, labor, or real or personal property taken is of a value exceeding $950 dollars, except as specified. (Pen. Code, § 487.)
- Defines petty theft as obtaining any property by theft where the value of the money, labor, real or personal property taken does not exceed $950 and makes it punishable as a misdemeanor, except in the case where a person has a prior super strike or registrable sex conviction and a prior theft conviction, as specified. (Pen. Code, § 490.2, subd. (a).) This provision does not apply to theft of a firearm. (Pen. Code, § 490.2, subd. (c).)
- Lists the theft-related offenses which qualify a defendant for enhanced status for the crime of petty theft with a prior theft conviction as:
- Petty theft;
- Grand theft;
- Theft, embezzlement, forgery, fraud, and identity theft committed against an elder or dependent adult;
- Auto theft;
- Burglary;
- Carjacking;
- Robbery; and,
- Receiving stolen property. (Pen. Code, § 666.)
- Petty theft;
- Defines shoplifting as entering a commercial establishment with intent to commit larceny while that establishment is open during regular business hours, where the value of the property that is taken or intended to be taken does not exceed $950 dollars, and makes it punishable as a misdemeanor, except where a person has a prior super strike or registrable sex conviction. Any act of shoplifting must be charged as shoplifting. (Pen. Code, § 459.5, subd. (a).)
- Requires generally that a person who is arrested for a misdemeanor be released upon his or her promise to appear in court at a later specified date, unless one of specified reasons exists for non-release, including a reasonable likelihood that the offense or offenses will continue or resume, or that the safety of persons or property would be imminently endangered by release of the arrested person. (Pen. Code, § 853.6.)
FISCAL EFFECT:
Unknown
COMMENTS:
- Author's Statement: According to the author, "Since the enactment of Proposition 47 in 2014, there has been an increase in theft crimes occurring in my district. In fact, if you analyze the data reported to the California Department of Justice, from the cities within the 49th Assembly District, you see a stark rise in crime. Between 2014, when Prop. 47 was passed, and 2016, the most recent year data that is available, property crimes are up 25.6% in AD 49. AB 3011 would try to bring some relief and clarity to this situation by allowing distinct, but related incidents of theft, whether committed against one or more victims, to be aggregated to a charge of grand theft.”
- Proposition 47 and Theft: Proposition 47, also known as the Safe Neighborhoods and Schools Act, was approved by the voters in November 2014. According to the California Secretary of State’s web site, 59.6 percent of voters approved Proposition 47. (See (http://elections.cdn.sos.ca.gov/sov/2014-general/pdf/2014-complete-sov.pdf)
Proposition 47 reduced the penalties for certain drug and property crimes and directed that the resulting state savings be directed to mental health and substance abuse treatment, truancy and dropout prevention, and victims’ services. Specifically, the initiative reduced the penalties for possession for personal use of most illegal drugs to misdemeanors. The initiative also reduced the penalties for theft valued at $950 or less from felonies to misdemeanors. However, the measure limited the reduced penalties to offenders who do not have designated prior convictions for specified serious or violent felonies (super strikes) and who are not required to register as sex offenders. (See Legislative Analyst's Office analysis of Proposition 47 (http://www.lao.ca.gov/ballot/2014/prop-47-110414.pdf)
Among the theft crimes made misdemeanors by Proposition 47, where the value of the property is $950 or less, are forgery (Pen. Code, § 473), making or delivering a check with insufficient funds (Pen. Code, § 476a), petty theft (Pen. Code, § 490.2), and receiving stolen property (Pen. Code, § 496). (See People v. Rivera (2015) 233 Cal.App.4th 1085, 1091.)
The offenses made misdemeanors by Proposition 47 also include: the new offense of commercial burglary where the value of the property taken or intended to be taken is $950 or less (Pen. Code, § 459.5; People v. Sherow (2015) 239 Cal.App.4th 875, 879); and petty theft with a prior theft conviction. (Pen. Code, § 666; People v. Rivera, supra, 233 Cal.App.4th at p. 1091.) Specifically, Proposition 47 eliminated the penalties formerly associated with the “petty theft with a prior” statute except for a narrow category of sex offenders, persons with qualifying “super strikes,” and those persons convicted of theft from elders or dependent adults. Those persons are still eligible for felony punishment in state prison sentence. (Pen. Code, § 666.)
“One of Proposition 47’s primary purposes is to reduce the number of nonviolent offenders in state prisons, thereby saving money and focusing prison on offenders considered more serious under the terms of the initiative.” (Harris v. Superior Court (2016) 1 Cal.5th 984, 992, citing Voter Information Guide, Gen. Elec. (Nov. 4, 2014) text of Prop. 47, § 2, p. 70.) These policies are supported by a liberal construction clause in Proposition 47, sections 15 and 18. (http://vig.cdn.sos.ca.gov/2014/general/pdf/text-of-proposed-laws1.pdf#prop47)
- Aggregation and Theft Offenses Committed as Part of One Intention, Impulse and Plan: In 1961, the Supreme Court in People v. Bailey, found that a single misrepresentation resulting in multiple thefts could be aggregated and prosecuted as one felony grand theft if they were conducted pursuant to one intention, one general impulse, and one plan. (See People v. Bailey (1961) 55 Cal.2d 514, 518-519.) The defendant in Bailey made a single fraudulent misrepresentation about her household income that caused her to receive a stream of welfare payments. (Id. at pp. 515–516.) While each individual payment fell below the felony threshold, the aggregated total constituted grand theft. (Id. at p. 518.) The Supreme Court concluded that the payments could be aggregated because “the evidence established that there was only one intention, one general impulse, and one plan.” (Id. at p. 519; see also CALCRIM No. 1802 [Theft: As Part of Overall Plan].)
The California Supreme Court addressed the Bailey rule in People v. Whitmer (2014) 59 Cal.4th 733. In Whitmer, the defendant arranged for the fraudulent sale of 20 motorcycles, motorized dirt bikes, all-terrain vehicles, and similar recreational vehicles. The defendant was convicted of multiple thefts. The defendant appealed arguing that under Bailey he should have been convicted of a single theft. The Supreme Court distinguished the facts in Whitmer from what occurred in Bailey, and found that multiple theft convictions were appropriate because each count of theft was based on a separate and distinct fraudulent act. (Id. at 740.) The court in Whitmer pointed out that Bailey concerned a single fraudulent act followed by a series of payments. Concurring opinions were written by Justices Werdegar and Liu. Justice Liu distinguished acts committed with a common scheme from acts committed as part of a single impulse. (Id. at 748, concur. opn. J. Liu.) Justice Liu went on to state that “. . ., separate and distinct takings do not fall under Bailey's aggregation rule simply because, as here, they were all done the same way. But neither does the mere fact that multiple takings are separate and distinct entail a finding of multiple thefts in every case. If the takings were committed pursuant to a single intention, impulse, and plan, then under Bailey they amount to only one theft.”
Where multiple victims are involved, courts disagree about applying the Bailey rule and cumulating the charges even if a single plan or intent is demonstrated. In People v. Columbia Research Corp. (1980) 103 Cal.App.3d Supp. 33, the court applied Bailey and approved aggregation where the defendant was charged with grand theft based on a series of petty thefts that occurred over a 10-month period, pursuant to a single plan and intent, and involved different victims. (Id. at p. 40.) In People v. Garcia (1990) 224 Cal.App.3d 297, the defendant filed fraudulent bonds at different times involving different victims. The court found multiple convictions proper. (Id. at pp. 308-309.)
This bill states that the amendments to existing statute made by this bill do not constitute a change in, but are declaratory of, existing law. However, the language of this bill states: “if the value of the property taken or intended to be taken exceeds $950 over the course of distinct but related acts, whether committed against one or more victims, the value of the property taken or intended to be taken may properly be aggregated to charge a count of grand theft, if the acts are motivated by one intention, one general impulse, and one plan.” It is unclear whether the language of this bill is declaratory of existing law.
- Argument in Support: According to the Los Angeles County Sheriff’s Department, “Since the enactment of Proposition 47, numerous communities throughout Los Angeles County and the state have expressed concern over an increase in shoplifting and petty theft crimes. These crimes are being committed by individuals who are taking advantage of the system by attempting to keep their thefts under the $950 threshold established by the proposition. An article by the Los Angeles Times. (http://www.latimes.com/local/crime/la-me-prop47-anniversary.20151106-story.html) recently identified the unintended consequences of Proposition 47. It interviewed a serial thief who admitted to using the contents of Proposition 47 as a way to commit theft and stay out of jail. According to the article, the thief was very content with the passage of Proposition 47 and “didn’t start stealing bicycles until the proposition raised the threshold for a felony theft to $950.” Additionally, the thief bragged about being cited and released by law enforcement, so long as the thefts were left under the Proposition 47 threshold.
“AB 1772 would specify that if the value of the money, labor, real property, or personal property taken, or intended to be taken, exceeds $950 over the course of distinct but related acts, whether committed against one or more victims, the value may properly be aggregated to charge a count of grand theft if the acts are motivated by one intention, one general impulse, and one plan.” - Argument in Opposition: According to the American Civil Liberties Union of California “This bill states that ‘[i]t is not the intent of the Legislature to alter the scope or effect of Proposition 47’ and issues a legislative finding and declaration ‘that it was not the intent of the voters in enacting the Safe Neighborhoods and Schools Act, enacted as an initiative statute by Proposition 47, at the November 4, 2014, statewide general election to abrogate [the holdings in several pre-Proposition 47 cases related to aggregation] to the benefit of persons committing theft of property exceeding $950 in value over the course of successive but related acts.’ However, contrary to these findings and declarations, the bill does alter the scope and effect of Proposition 47. Moreover, it inappropriately substitutes the intent of the Legislature for that of the voters. Importantly, California voters already had the opportunity to make a decision on the issue addressed by this bill and on November 4, 2014, in our statewide general election, they overwhelmingly decided to approve Proposition 47.
“Current law already provides courts with sufficient power to punish multiple thefts of property. Under current law, as established by Proposition 47, the court may impose a sanction of up to one year in county jail for any petty theft. Thus, a person who commits multiple theft offenses in a short amount of time can already be punished with significant jail time; further expansion of the grand theft statute is unnecessary.
“Petty theft offenses are often crimes of poverty, even when they are committed on more than one occasion by the same person. Decades of experience in California shows that increasing the penal consequences for petty offenses to include a felony conviction will not lead to less recidivism; it will only make it more difficult for people to get their lives back on track and will waste taxpayer dollars. It is exactly this punitive approach to low-level, non-violent offenses that the voters rejected when they approved Proposition 47. Recent research has shown that counties that invest in rehabilitation services and programs and innovative approaches show better outcomes than those that focused on ‘old-fashioned enforcement’. Indeed an extensive study of the impact of realignment concluded that ‘[c]ounties that invested in offender reentry in the aftermath of realignment had better performance in terms of recidivism than counties that focused resources on enforcement.’”
- Related Legislation:
- AB 1476 (Ramos), would amend Proposition 47 to allow a person to be charged with a felony for petty theft, if the person has specified prior convictions, without regard to whether the person is required to register as a sex offender or has been convicted of specified violent or serious felonies. AB 1476 is awaiting hearing in the Assembly Public Safety Committee.
- AB 1210 (Low), would make it an alternate felony/misdemeanor to enter the property adjacent to a dwelling with the intent to steal a package that has been shipped to the dwelling. AB 1210 is set for hearing in the Assembly Public Safety Committee on April 23, 2019.
- AB 1476 (Ramos), would amend Proposition 47 to allow a person to be charged with a felony for petty theft, if the person has specified prior convictions, without regard to whether the person is required to register as a sex offender or has been convicted of specified violent or serious felonies. AB 1476 is awaiting hearing in the Assembly Public Safety Committee.
- Prior Legislation:
- AB 1065 (Jones-Sawyer), Chapter 803, Statutes of 2018, created the new crime of organized retail theft and specifies the penalties for violations of the new provisions. AB 1065 is awaiting hearing in the Senate Appropriations Committee.
- AB 3011 (Chau), contained the same provisions as this bill. AB 3011 was never heard in the Assembly Public Safety Committee.
- Proposition 47 of the November 2014 general election, the Safe Neighborhoods and Schools Act, reduced the penalties for certain drug and property crimes, including reducing petty theft with a prior theft conviction to a misdemeanor, except in the case where the person has a prior super strike conviction or a conviction for a specified theft-related offense against an elder or dependent adult.
- AB 2372 (Ammiano), Chapter 693, Statutes of 2010, increased the threshold amount that constitutes grand theft from $400 to $950.
- AB 1844 (Fletcher), Chapter 219, Statutes of 2010, amended petty theft with a prior to require three prior theft-related convictions.
- AB 1065 (Jones-Sawyer), Chapter 803, Statutes of 2018, created the new crime of organized retail theft and specifies the penalties for violations of the new provisions. AB 1065 is awaiting hearing in the Senate Appropriations Committee.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
City of Rosemead
Los Angeles County Sheriff's Department
Riverside Sheriffs' Association
1 private individual
Oppose
American Civil Liberties Union of California
California Public Defenders Association
Analysis Prepared by:
David Billingsley / PUB. S. / (916) 319-3744
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):