AB 1776: Sales and use taxes: exemptions: newspapers.
- Session Year: 2019-2020
- House: Assembly
- Latest Version Date: 2019-04-30
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Feb 3, 2020 | From committee: Filed with the Chief Clerk pursuant to Joint Rule 56. |
| Jan 31, 2020 | Died pursuant to Art. IV, Sec. 10(c) of the Constitution. |
| May 16, 2019 | In committee: Held under submission. |
| May 16, 2019 | Joint Rule 62(a), file notice suspended. |
| May 15, 2019 | In committee: Set, first hearing. Referred to APPR. suspense file. |
| May 13, 2019 | Joint Rule 62(a), file notice suspended. (Page 1609.) |
| May 7, 2019 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 10. Noes 0.) (May 6). Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| May 1, 2019 | Re-referred to Com. on REV. & TAX. |
| Apr 30, 2019 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to Com. on REV. & TAX. Read second time and amended. |
| Apr 29, 2019 | In committee: Hearing for testimony only. |
| Apr 23, 2019 | Re-referred to Com. on REV. & TAX. |
| Apr 22, 2019 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to Com. on REV. & TAX. Read second time and amended. |
| Apr 11, 2019 | Re-referred to Com. on REV. & TAX. |
| Apr 10, 2019 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to Com. on REV. & TAX. Read second time and amended. |
| Apr 8, 2019 | In committee: Set, first hearing. Hearing canceled at the request of author. |
| Mar 18, 2019 | Referred to Com. on REV. & TAX. |
| Feb 25, 2019 | Read first time. |
| Feb 23, 2019 | From printer. May be heard in committee March 25. |
| Feb 22, 2019 | Introduced. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| May 6, 2019 | Do pass and be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Assembly Standing Committee on Revenue and Taxation |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
Date of Hearing: May 16, 2019
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Lorena Gonzalez, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 1776
Author:(Levine) – As Amended Ver:April 30, 2019
Policy Committee: | Revenue and Taxation | Vote: | 10 - 0 |
|
| ||
|
|
Urgency: No State Mandated Local Program: No Reimbursable: No
SUMMARY:
This bill exempts, from January 1, 2020, until January 1, 2025, from the sales and use tax (SUT) a newspaper, as defined, and any tangible personal property that becomes an ingredient or component part of a newspaper. This bill also exempts from the SUT a photograph reproduced in a newspaper, as specified. Finally, this bill requires the Legislative Analyst’s Office to evaluate the effectiveness of this SUT exemption.
FISCAL EFFECT:
- Annual General Fund revenue loss of $3.2 million in 2019-20 and $6.2 million each year thereafter.
- Modest costs, likely in the tens of thousands of dollars, for LAO to review the effectiveness of the proposed SUT exemption.
COMMENTS:
- Background. From 1945 until 1991, newspapers and periodicals were exempt from the SUT. AB 2181 (Vasconcellos), Chapter 85, Statutes of 1991, and SB 179 (Deddeh), Chapter 88, Statutes of 1991, repealed the exemption as part of a budget agreement. While selected portions of this exemption have since been reinstated, such as the exemption for subscription periodicals or nonprofit-distributed publications, the SUT still applies to most newspapers.
- Purpose. According to the author, this bill “affirms the essential role that a free and open press plays in the lives of Californians and all people in our democracy.” The author argues California’s sales tax still applies to daily newspapers while other content continues untaxed.
- Section 41 costs. Section 41 of the Revenue and Taxation Code calls for tax expenditure legislation to include the bill’s goals and measurements of success, which will allow the Legislature to evaluate a tax expenditure’s effectiveness in later years. As noted in this committee’s analysis of AB 263 (Burke), of the 2019-20 Legislative Session, these reporting and data collection requirements could end up costly if the requested data is not easily obtainable by the identified agency. For this bill, LAO must evaluate the effectiveness of the proposed SUT exemption, including its economic impact. This is a comprehensive and substantial reporting requirement that will generate costs for LAO.
Analysis Prepared by: Luke Reidenbach / APPR. / (916) 319-2081
Date of Hearing: May 6, 2019
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON REVENUE AND TAXATION
Autumn R. Burke, Chairwoman
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 1776 (
Author:Levine) – As Amended Ver:April 30, 2019
FOR VOTE ONLY
Majority vote. Tax levy. Fiscal committee.
SUBJECT: Sales and use taxes: exemptions: newspapers
SUMMARY: Provides two separate sales and use tax (SUT) exemptions designed to benefit the newspaper industry. Specifically, this bill:
- Provides a complete SUT exemption, on and after January 1, 2020, for any newspaper regularly issued at average intervals not exceeding three months or any tangible personal property (TPP) that becomes an ingredient or component part of the newspaper.
- Provides a complete SUT exemption, on and after January 1, 2020, for a photograph, whether or not produced to special order, when the possession, but not the title, of the photograph is transferred for the purpose of being reproduced one time only in a newspaper described above.
- Provides that the exemption shall not apply to newspapers during the term of a prepaid subscription, if the subscription was entered into and paid for prior to January 1, 2020.
- Takes immediate effect as a tax levy.
- Sunsets these exemption provisions on January 1, 2025.
- Provides that notwithstanding existing law, the state shall not reimburse any local agency for SUT revenues lost as a result of this exemption.
- Contains the following legislative findings and declarations:
- The specific goals, purposes, and objectives of this bill are as follows:
- Californians' right to know is enshrined in the California Constitution, which states that the people have the right of access to information concerning the conduct of the people's business;
- Printed, published, and distributed California newspapers continue to employ journalists in local communities who gather and report news about local, regional, and state issues;
- California newspapers inform the public, thereby increasing civic literacy and public participation in self-government;
- Newspapers were exempted from the SUT from enactment of the SUT Law on TPP in the 1930s until 1991;
- In 1991, faced with an unprecedented $8 billion budget deficit, the Legislature adopted a budget proposed by Governor Pete Wilson that removed the SUT exemption for four products: bottled water, candy and snack foods, newspapers and periodicals, and bunker fuel (stored fuel);
- In 1992, the people voted to approve a ballot measure that restored SUT exemptions for bottled water and snack foods;
- Shortly after the SUT exemption was removed for, and the tax again imposed on, all newspapers, the Legislature passed, and the Governor signed, a bill to narrow the scope of the tax by exempting student and religious newspapers, freely distributed newspapers, and the distribution of most weekly newspapers, such as those distributed between 4 and 60 times a year and delivered by mail or common carrier;
- Recent regulatory changes have further limited application of the SUT laws to newspapers by clarifying that the digital part of a mixed digital and print subscription is not subject to SUT;
- The SUT laws continue to apply to a relatively small number of businesses engaged in activities protected by the First Amendment to the United States Constitution – all daily newspapers and certain weekly newspapers – while virtually every other content creator and aggregator competing for the same audiences and advertising dollars is untaxed, including broadcast television and radio and digital aggregators of information;
- Application of the SUT laws on newspapers penalizes news companies that employ journalists in California communities, who gather news, inform the public, and serve their communities, while that tax policy benefits businesses that aggregate and redistribute high quality content created by newspapers;
- Ironically, the SUT laws continue to be levied on the print products of the only business set out for special protection in the federal Bill of Rights: the press;
- Unlike the aggregators and redistributors of digital content, California newspapers are responsible for the content they create and publish. Newspapers and the journalists that work for them subscribe to journalistic principals and a code of ethics;
- When the Legislature placed a tax on newspapers nearly 30 years ago, no one could foresee the changes that would occur on the media landscape;
- It is the intent of the Legislature to do all of the following:
- Level the playing field for all competing media with regard to the SUT laws, no matter the method of distribution;
- Increase the ability of newspapers to employ journalists in California communities and serve the community's need for accurate local, regional, and statewide information; and,
- Prevent further erosion of local newsgathering caused by aggregators of information.
- Level the playing field for all competing media with regard to the SUT laws, no matter the method of distribution;
- Californians' right to know is enshrined in the California Constitution, which states that the people have the right of access to information concerning the conduct of the people's business;
- Mindful of the fact that many factors determine economic efficiency and individual business decisions, the performance indicators related to this bill are as follows: the number of printed, published, and distributed newspapers paying SUT as determined by the state upon the effective date of this bill as compared to that number on the date one year prior to the scheduled repeal of the exemption; and,
- The data collection requirements to enable the Legislature to determine whether the tax exemption is meeting, failing to meet, or exceeding its specified goals, purposes, and objectives are as follows:
- The Legislative Analyst's Office shall review the effectiveness of the tax exemption and may request information from the California Department of Tax and Fee Administration (CDTFA) and any state governmental entity with authority relating to the purchasing of newspapers; and,
- CDTFA and any state governmental entity with authority relating to the purchasing of newspapers shall provide to the Legislative Analyst's Office (LAO) any data requested.
- The Legislative Analyst's Office shall review the effectiveness of the tax exemption and may request information from the California Department of Tax and Fee Administration (CDTFA) and any state governmental entity with authority relating to the purchasing of newspapers; and,
- The specific goals, purposes, and objectives of this bill are as follows:
EXISTING LAW:
- Imposes a sales tax on retailers for the privilege of selling TPP, absent a specific exemption. The tax is based upon the retailer's gross receipts from TPP sales in this state.
- Imposes a complimentary use tax on the storage, use, or other consumption of TPP purchased out-of-state and brought into California. The use tax is imposed on the purchaser; and unless the purchaser pays the use tax to an out-of-state retailer registered to collect California's use tax, the purchaser remains liable for the tax. The use tax is set at the same rate as the state's sales tax and must generally be remitted to the CDTFA.
- Provides a SUT exemption for TPP that becomes an ingredient or component part of any newspaper or periodical that is distributed without charge and regularly issued at average intervals not exceeding three months, and any such newspaper or periodical. (Revenue and Taxation Code (R&TC) Section 6362.7(a).)
- Provides a SUT exemption for TPP that becomes an ingredient or a component part of any periodical regularly issued at average intervals not exceeding three months, and any such periodical, that is sold by subscription and delivered by mail or common carrier. (R&TC Section 6362.7(b).)
- Provides a SUT exemption for TPP that becomes an ingredient or component part of any newspaper or periodical regularly issued at average intervals not exceeding three months, or any such newspaper or periodical. (R&TC Section 6362.8) This exemption, however, only applies to the following:
- Any newspaper or periodical that is published or purchased by an organization that qualifies for tax exempt status under Internal Revenue Code (IRC) Section 501(c)(3) and is distributed to the members of the organization in consideration of payment of the organization's membership fee, or to the organization's contributors;
- Any newspaper or periodical that is published by an organization that qualifies for tax exempt status under IRC Section 501(c)(3) and does not receive revenue from, or accept, any commercial advertising; and,
- Any newspaper or periodical distributed by a nonprofit organization for which both of the following conditions apply:
- Distribution is to any member of the nonprofit organization in consideration, in whole or in part, of payment of the organization's membership fee; and,
- The amount paid or incurred by the nonprofit organization for the cost of printing the newspaper or periodical is less than 10% of the membership fee attributable to the period for which the newspaper or periodical is distributed.
- Distribution is to any member of the nonprofit organization in consideration, in whole or in part, of payment of the organization's membership fee; and,
- Any newspaper or periodical that is published or purchased by an organization that qualifies for tax exempt status under Internal Revenue Code (IRC) Section 501(c)(3) and is distributed to the members of the organization in consideration of payment of the organization's membership fee, or to the organization's contributors;
FISCAL EFFECT: Estimated annual revenue losses of $13.5 million.
COMMENTS:
- The author has provided the following statement in support of this bill:
At a time when the fundamental and constitutional rights of an open and free press are under attack at the highest level, we must not allow the voice of journalism to be silenced. Just as other essential consumer items are exempt from sales tax, AB 1776 affirms the essential role that a free and open press plays in the lives of Californians and all people in our democracy.
California's sales tax continues to be applied to daily newspapers while virtually every other content creator and aggregator of content competing for the same viewership and ad sponsorship continues untaxed.
- Committee Staff Comments:
- What is a "tax expenditure"? Existing law provides various credits, deductions, exclusions, and exemptions for particular taxpayer groups. In the late 1960s, U.S. Treasury officials began arguing that these features of the tax law should be referred to as "expenditures" since they are generally enacted to accomplish some governmental purpose and there is a determinable cost associated with each (in the form of foregone revenues).
- What is a "tax expenditure"? Existing law provides various credits, deductions, exclusions, and exemptions for particular taxpayer groups. In the late 1960s, U.S. Treasury officials began arguing that these features of the tax law should be referred to as "expenditures" since they are generally enacted to accomplish some governmental purpose and there is a determinable cost associated with each (in the form of foregone revenues).
As the Department of Finance notes in its annual Tax Expenditure Report, there are several key differences between tax expenditures and direct expenditures. First, tax expenditures are reviewed less frequently than direct expenditures. Second, there is generally no control over the amount of revenue losses associated with any given tax expenditure. Finally, it should also be noted that, once enacted, it takes a two-thirds vote to rescind an existing tax expenditure absent a sunset date. This effectively results in a "one-way ratchet" whereby tax expenditures can be conferred by majority vote, but cannot be rescinded, irrespective of their efficacy or cost, without a supermajority vote.
- An overview of the SUT Law: The SUT represents the state's second largest source of General Fund (GF) revenues. Nevertheless, the past 70 years have seen a dramatic reduction in the state's reliance on the SUT and a corresponding increase in its reliance on personal income tax revenues. In FY 2019-20, SUT revenues are estimated to comprise only 19% of the state's GF revenues, down from nearly 60% in FY 1950-51.
- What accounts for the state's reduced reliance on SUT revenues? The SUT Law was enacted in a very different era. In the 1930s, California's economy was largely dominated by manufacturing, and residents mostly bought and sold tangible goods. Thus, in establishing the base for a new consumption tax, it made sense to impose the tax on sales of TPP, defined as personal property that may be "seen, weighed, measured, felt, or touched." Over the past 80 years, however, California's economy has seen dramatic growth in the service and information sectors, resulting in a significant erosion of the SUT base. For example, the Commission on the 21st Century Economy noted that spending on taxable goods represented 34.6% of personal income in 2008, down from 55.4% in 1980. As a result, tax experts and economists from across the political spectrum argue that California should expand its SUT base.
It could be argued that, while well-intentioned, additional SUT exemptions further erode an already shrinking SUT base. This, in turn, increases fiscal pressures to maintain or even increase California's relatively high SUT rate. High rates arguably promote non-compliance and encourage out-of-state purchases, placing California retailers at a competitive disadvantage. High rates also risk impacting consumer decision-making, which runs counter to widely accepted principles of sound tax policy.
- The current taxation of newspapers: In general, sales of newspapers and periodicals are subject to tax. As noted above, however, there are exceptions. General guidance with respect to the application of tax is provided via Regulation 1590, Newspapers and Periodicals. Specifically:
- Distributions without charge: Tax does not apply to the sale or use of TPP that becomes an ingredient or component part of any newspaper or periodical distributed without charge and regularly issued at average intervals not exceeding three months, nor does tax apply to such distribution.
- Certain subscriptions: Tax does not apply to the sale or use of any periodical, as defined, regularly issued at average intervals not exceeding three months that is sold by subscription and delivered by mail or common carrier. The law defines a "periodical" to mean, in part, any publication that appears at stated intervals at least four times per year, but not more than 60 times per year.
- Non-profit organizations: Tax does not apply to the sale or use of any newspaper or periodical that is published or purchased by an organization that qualifies for tax-exempt status under IRC Section 501(c)(3) and is distributed to the members of the organization in consideration of payment of the organization's membership fee, or to the organization's contributors.
- General background: From 1945 until July 15, 1991, newspapers and periodicals, their ingredients and component parts, and photographs whose possession (but not title) was transferred to be reproduced for one time only in those publications were exempt from SUT. This exemption was repealed as part of a budget compromise to address the large revenue shortfalls that existed at the time. In the years since, selected portions of the newspaper and periodical exemptions have been reinstated. Moreover, in 2016, Regulation 1590 was revised to clarify the application of tax to mixed newspaper subscriptions by establishing that 53% of the charge is presumed to be for the nontaxable sale of the right to access digital content. Taxpayers may rebut the presumption by producing documentation establishing that the nontaxable allocation is greater than 53%.
- Policy arguments: Proponents of this bill advance a number of arguments for providing a complete and comprehensive SUT exemption for newspaper sales:
- First, proponents note that print papers currently face a competitive disadvantage vis-à-vis their electronic competitors. This is because digital platforms – like online news sites and aggregators – do not sell TPP and therefore can sell their services without tax. This is undoubtedly true, but speaks to a larger issue with the SUT base. Specifically, the base has not kept pace with the advent of digital services and products. Products that were once consumed almost exclusively in tangible form, like music CDs, are now purchased as electronic downloads not subject to tax. The same can be said for a wide range of products.
- The current taxation of newspapers: In general, sales of newspapers and periodicals are subject to tax. As noted above, however, there are exceptions. General guidance with respect to the application of tax is provided via Regulation 1590, Newspapers and Periodicals. Specifically:
Moreover, it should be noted that tax parity can be accomplished in one of two ways: (i) either the Legislature can exempt individual items of TPP from taxation to try to level the playing field, or (ii) the Legislature can reform the SUT base to encompass a broader range of services and products in a manner that does not discriminate based on the medium of delivery.
- Second, proponents note that newspapers provide a valuable public service by disseminating accurate and timely information to the public. This service, however, is often provided at a financial loss. Newspapers argue that this bill's SUT exemption would enable them to shore up their financial position and potentially retain on hire additional staff. It is not entirely clear to Committee staff, however, how much of a difference this exemption would provide given the relatively small amount at issue – roughly $13.5 million annually. In addition, it is not clear to Committee staff whether newspapers receiving the exemption would reduce consumer prices to attract more customers, or keep prices level and use the additional amounts to shore up their bottom line.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
None on file
Opposition
None on file
Analysis Prepared by: M. David Ruff / REV. & TAX. / (916) 319-2098
Date of Hearing: April 29, 2019
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON REVENUE AND TAXATION
Autumn R. Burke, Chairwoman
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 1776 (
Author:Levine) – As Amended Ver:April 22, 2019
FOR TESTIMONY ONLY
Majority vote. Tax levy. Fiscal committee.
SUBJECT: Sales and use taxes: exemptions: newspapers
SUMMARY: Provides two separate sales and use tax (SUT) exemptions designed to benefit the newspaper industry. Specifically, this bill:
- Provides a complete SUT exemption, on and after January 1, 2020, for any newspaper regularly issued at average intervals not exceeding three months or any tangible personal property (TPP) that becomes an ingredient or component part of the newspaper.
- Provides a complete SUT exemption, on and after January 1, 2020, for a photograph, whether or not produced to special order, when the possession, but not the title, of the photograph is transferred for the purpose of being reproduced one time only in a newspaper described above.
- Takes immediate effect as a tax levy.
- Sunsets these exemption provisions on January 1, 2025.
- Provides that notwithstanding existing law, the state shall not reimburse any local agency for SUT revenues lost as a result of this exemption.
- Contains the following legislative findings and declarations:
- The specific goals, purposes, and objectives of this bill are as follows:
- Californians' right to know is enshrined in the California Constitution, which states that the people have the right of access to information concerning the conduct of the people's business;
- Printed, published, and distributed California newspapers continue to employ journalists in local communities who gather and report news about local, regional, and state issues;
- California newspapers inform the public, thereby increasing civic literacy and public participation in self-government;
- Newspapers were exempted from the SUT from enactment of the SUT Law on TPP in the 1930s until 1991;
- In 1991, faced with an unprecedented $8 billion budget deficit, the Legislature adopted a budget proposed by Governor Pete Wilson that removed the SUT exemption for four products: bottled water, candy and snack foods, newspapers and periodicals, and bunker fuel (stored fuel);
- In 1992, the people voted to approve a ballot measure that restored SUT exemptions for bottled water and snack foods;
- Shortly after the SUT exemption was removed for, and the tax again imposed on, all newspapers, the Legislature passed, and the Governor signed, a bill to narrow the scope of the tax by exempting student and religious newspapers, freely distributed newspapers, and the distribution of most weekly newspapers, such as those distributed between 4 and 60 times a year and delivered by mail or common carrier;
- Recent regulatory changes have further limited application of the SUT laws to newspapers by clarifying that the digital part of a mixed digital and print subscription is not subject to SUT;
- The SUT laws continue to apply to a relatively small number of businesses engaged in activities protected by the First Amendment to the United States Constitution – all daily newspapers and certain weekly newspapers – while virtually every other content creator and aggregator competing for the same audiences and advertising dollars is untaxed, including broadcast television and radio and digital aggregators of information;
- Application of the SUT laws on newspapers penalizes news companies that employ journalists in California communities, who gather news, inform the public, and serve their communities, while that tax policy benefits businesses that aggregate and redistribute high quality content created by newspapers;
- Ironically, the SUT laws continue to be levied on the print products of the only business set out for special protection in the federal Bill of Rights: the press;
- Unlike the aggregators and redistributors of digital content, California newspapers are responsible for the content they create and publish. Newspapers and the journalists that work for them subscribe to journalistic principals and a code of ethics;
- When the Legislature placed a tax on newspapers nearly 30 years ago, no one could foresee the changes that would occur on the media landscape;
- It is the intent of the Legislature to do all of the following:
- Level the playing field for all competing media with regard to the SUT laws, no matter the method of distribution;
- Increase the ability of newspapers to employ journalists in California communities and serve the community's need for accurate local, regional, and statewide information; and,
- Prevent further erosion of local newsgathering caused by aggregators of information.
- Level the playing field for all competing media with regard to the SUT laws, no matter the method of distribution;
- Californians' right to know is enshrined in the California Constitution, which states that the people have the right of access to information concerning the conduct of the people's business;
- Mindful of the fact that many factors determine economic efficiency and individual business decisions, the performance indicators related to this bill are as follows: the number of printed, published, and distributed newspapers paying SUT as determined by the state upon the effective date of this bill as compared to that number on the date one year prior to the scheduled repeal of the exemption; and,
- The data collection requirements to enable the Legislature to determine whether the tax exemption is meeting, failing to meet, or exceeding its specified goals, purposes, and objectives are as follows:
- The Legislative Analyst's Office shall review the effectiveness of the tax exemption and may request information from the California Department of Tax and Fee Administration (CDTFA) and any state governmental entity with authority relating to the purchasing of newspapers; and,
- CDTFA and any state governmental entity with authority relating to the purchasing of newspapers shall provide to the Legislative Analyst's Office (LAO) any data requested.
- The Legislative Analyst's Office shall review the effectiveness of the tax exemption and may request information from the California Department of Tax and Fee Administration (CDTFA) and any state governmental entity with authority relating to the purchasing of newspapers; and,
- The specific goals, purposes, and objectives of this bill are as follows:
EXISTING LAW:
- Imposes a sales tax on retailers for the privilege of selling TPP, absent a specific exemption. The tax is based upon the retailer's gross receipts from TPP sales in this state.
- Imposes a complimentary use tax on the storage, use, or other consumption of TPP purchased out-of-state and brought into California. The use tax is imposed on the purchaser; and unless the purchaser pays the use tax to an out-of-state retailer registered to collect California's use tax, the purchaser remains liable for the tax. The use tax is set at the same rate as the state's sales tax and must generally be remitted to the CDTFA.
- Provides a SUT exemption for TPP that becomes an ingredient or component part of any newspaper or periodical that is distributed without charge and regularly issued at average intervals not exceeding three months, and any such newspaper or periodical. (Revenue and Taxation Code (R&TC) Section 6362.7(a).)
- Provides a SUT exemption for TPP that becomes an ingredient or a component part of any periodical regularly issued at average intervals not exceeding three months, and any such periodical, that is sold by subscription and delivered by mail or common carrier. (R&TC Section 6362.7(b).)
- Provides a SUT exemption for TPP that becomes an ingredient or component part of any newspaper or periodical regularly issued at average intervals not exceeding three months, or any such newspaper or periodical. (R&TC Section 6362.8) This exemption, however, only applies to the following:
- Any newspaper or periodical that is published or purchased by an organization that qualifies for tax exempt status under Internal Revenue Code (IRC) Section 501(c)(3) and is distributed to the members of the organization in consideration of payment of the organization's membership fee, or to the organization's contributors;
- Any newspaper or periodical that is published by an organization that qualifies for tax exempt status under IRC Section 501(c)(3) and does not receive revenue from, or accept, any commercial advertising; and,
- Any newspaper or periodical distributed by a nonprofit organization for which both of the following conditions apply:
- Distribution is to any member of the nonprofit organization in consideration, in whole or in part, of payment of the organization's membership fee; and,
- The amount paid or incurred by the nonprofit organization for the cost of printing the newspaper or periodical is less than 10% of the membership fee attributable to the period for which the newspaper or periodical is distributed.
- Distribution is to any member of the nonprofit organization in consideration, in whole or in part, of payment of the organization's membership fee; and,
- Any newspaper or periodical that is published or purchased by an organization that qualifies for tax exempt status under Internal Revenue Code (IRC) Section 501(c)(3) and is distributed to the members of the organization in consideration of payment of the organization's membership fee, or to the organization's contributors;
FISCAL EFFECT: Estimated annual revenue losses of $13.5 million.
COMMENTS:
- The author has provided the following statement in support of this bill:
At a time when the fundamental and constitutional rights of an open and free press are under attack at the highest level, we must not allow the voice of journalism to be silenced. Just as other essential consumer items are exempt from sales tax, AB 1776 affirms the essential role that a free and open press plays in the lives of Californians and all people in our democracy.
California's sales tax continues to be applied to daily newspapers while virtually every other content creator and aggregator of content competing for the same viewership and ad sponsorship continues untaxed.
- This bill is sponsored by the California News Publishers Association, which notes the following:
Faced with an unprecedented $8 billion budget deficit, the legislature in 1990 adopted a budget proposed by then-Gov. Pete Wilson that imposed a sales tax on four previously exempt products: bottled water, candy and snack foods, newspapers and periodicals, and bunker fuel (stored fuel). Newspapers found themselves subject to California sales tax for the first time since the sales tax was created in the 1930s.
By 1992, the bottled water and snack industries had used the initiative process to easily reclaim their exemptions. Meanwhile, CNPA and the magazine industry succeeded in making important changes on the application of the tax to newspapers and magazines. In 1991 the legislature acted quickly to repeal the tax on freely distributed newspapers – a harmful tax on printing costs which could not be passed on to readers since they receive the newspaper for free. That measure also repealed the tax on student, nonprofit and religious publications. In 1992 the legislature repealed the tax on mailed periodicals, which resulted (by regulatory changes) in also repealing the tax on the sales of most weekly newspapers (i.e., those distributed between four and sixty times a year, sold by subscription and delivered by mail or common carrier.)
The last tax change occurred just a few years ago when CNPA worked with the State Board of Equalization to adjust the regulations to clarify that the digital part of a mixed digital/ print subscription was not subject to tax. Since most newspapers offer mixed print and digital subscriptions, this change radically reduces the amount of tax collected by the state but does nothing to lift the tax burden on newspapers.
What remains today is a tax on the print distribution of all daily newspapers and single copy sales of weekly newspapers. At this moment, CNPA does not know the total amount collected on this tax, but asserts it is not a meaningful percentage of the state's tax revenue.
- Committee Staff Comments:
- What is a "tax expenditure"? Existing law provides various credits, deductions, exclusions, and exemptions for particular taxpayer groups. In the late 1960s, U.S. Treasury officials began arguing that these features of the tax law should be referred to as "expenditures" since they are generally enacted to accomplish some governmental purpose and there is a determinable cost associated with each (in the form of foregone revenues).
- What is a "tax expenditure"? Existing law provides various credits, deductions, exclusions, and exemptions for particular taxpayer groups. In the late 1960s, U.S. Treasury officials began arguing that these features of the tax law should be referred to as "expenditures" since they are generally enacted to accomplish some governmental purpose and there is a determinable cost associated with each (in the form of foregone revenues).
As the Department of Finance notes in its annual Tax Expenditure Report, there are several key differences between tax expenditures and direct expenditures. First, tax expenditures are reviewed less frequently than direct expenditures. Second, there is generally no control over the amount of revenue losses associated with any given tax expenditure. Finally, it should also be noted that, once enacted, it takes a two-thirds vote to rescind an existing tax expenditure absent a sunset date. This effectively results in a "one-way ratchet" whereby tax expenditures can be conferred by majority vote, but cannot be rescinded, irrespective of their efficacy or cost, without a supermajority vote.
- An overview of the SUT Law: The SUT represents the state's second largest source of General Fund (GF) revenues. Nevertheless, the past 70 years have seen a dramatic reduction in the state's reliance on the SUT and a corresponding increase in its reliance on personal income tax revenues. In FY 2019-20, SUT revenues are estimated to comprise only 19% of the state's GF revenues, down from nearly 60% in FY 1950-51.
- What accounts for the state's reduced reliance on SUT revenues? The SUT Law was enacted in a very different era. In the 1930s, California's economy was largely dominated by manufacturing, and residents mostly bought and sold tangible goods. Thus, in establishing the base for a new consumption tax, it made sense to impose the tax on sales of TPP, defined as personal property that may be "seen, weighed, measured, felt, or touched." Over the past 80 years, however, California's economy has seen dramatic growth in the service and information sectors, resulting in a significant erosion of the SUT base. For example, the Commission on the 21st Century Economy noted that spending on taxable goods represented 34.6% of personal income in 2008, down from 55.4% in 1980. As a result, tax experts and economists from across the political spectrum argue that California should expand its SUT base.
It could be argued that, while well-intentioned, additional SUT exemptions further erode an already shrinking SUT base. This, in turn, increases fiscal pressures to maintain or even increase California's relatively high SUT rate. High rates arguably promote non-compliance and encourage out-of-state purchases, placing California retailers at a competitive disadvantage. High rates also risk impacting consumer decision-making, which runs counter to widely accepted principles of sound tax policy.
- The current taxation of newspapers: In general, sales of newspapers and periodicals are subject to tax. As noted above, however, there are exceptions. General guidance with respect to the application of tax is provided via Regulation 1590, Newspapers and Periodicals. Specifically:
- Distributions without charge: Tax does not apply to the sale or use of TPP that becomes an ingredient or component part of any newspaper or periodical distributed without charge and regularly issued at average intervals not exceeding three months, nor does tax apply to such distribution.
- Certain subscriptions: Tax does not apply to the sale or use of any periodical, as defined, regularly issued at average intervals not exceeding three months that is sold by subscription and delivered by mail or common carrier. The law defines a "periodical" to mean, in part, any publication that appears at stated intervals at least four times per year, but not more than 60 times per year.
- Non-profit organizations: Tax does not apply to the sale or use of any newspaper or periodical that is published or purchased by an organization that qualifies for tax-exempt status under IRC Section 501(c)(3) and is distributed to the members of the organization in consideration of payment of the organization's membership fee, or to the organization's contributors.
- General background: From 1945 until July 15, 1991, newspapers and periodicals, their ingredients and component parts, and photographs whose possession (but not title) was transferred to be reproduced for one time only in those publications were exempt from SUT. This exemption was repealed as part of a budget compromise to address the large revenue shortfalls that existed at the time. In the years since, selected portions of the newspaper and periodical exemptions have been reinstated. Moreover, in 2016, Regulation 1590 was revised to clarify the application of tax to mixed newspaper subscriptions by establishing that 53% of the charge is presumed to be for the nontaxable sale of the right to access digital content. Taxpayers may rebut the presumption by producing documentation establishing that the nontaxable allocation is greater than 53%.
- Policy arguments: Proponents of this bill advance a number of arguments for providing a complete and comprehensive SUT exemption for newspaper sales:
- First, proponents note that print papers currently face a competitive disadvantage vis-à-vis their electronic competitors. This is because digital platforms – like online news sites and aggregators – do not sell TPP and therefore can sell their services without tax. This is undoubtedly true, but speaks to a larger issue with the SUT base. Specifically, the base has not kept pace with the advent of digital services and products. Products that were once consumed almost exclusively in tangible form, like music CDs, are now purchased as electronic downloads not subject to tax. The same can be said for a wide range of products.
- The current taxation of newspapers: In general, sales of newspapers and periodicals are subject to tax. As noted above, however, there are exceptions. General guidance with respect to the application of tax is provided via Regulation 1590, Newspapers and Periodicals. Specifically:
Moreover, it should be noted that tax parity can be accomplished in one of two ways: (i) either the Legislature can exempt individual items of TPP from taxation to try to level the playing field, or (ii) the Legislature can reform the SUT base to encompass a broader range of services and products in a manner that does not discriminate based on the medium of delivery.
- Second, proponents note that newspapers provide a valuable public service by disseminating accurate and timely information to the public. This service, however, is often provided at a financial loss. Newspapers argue that this bill's SUT exemption would enable them to shore up their financial position and potentially retain on hire additional staff. It is not entirely clear to Committee staff, however, how much of a difference this exemption would provide given the relatively small amount at issue – roughly $13.5 million annually. In addition, it is not clear to Committee staff whether newspapers receiving the exemption would reduce consumer prices to attract more customers, or keep prices level and use the additional amounts to shore up their bottom line.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
California News Publishers Association (Sponsor)
Opposition
None on file
Analysis Prepared by: M. David Ruff / REV. & TAX. / (916) 319-2098
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):