AB 1796: Domestic violence: restraining orders.
- Session Year: 2019-2020
- House: Assembly
- Latest Version Date: 2020-07-14
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Aug 20, 2020 | In committee: Held under submission. |
| Aug 13, 2020 | In committee: Referred to APPR. suspense file. |
| Jul 31, 2020 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on APPR. with recommendation: To Consent Calendar. (Ayes 9. Noes 0.) (July 30). Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Jul 14, 2020 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to committee. Read second time, amended, and re-referred to Com. on JUD. |
| Jul 1, 2020 | Re-referred to Com. on JUD. |
| Jun 24, 2020 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to committee. Read second time, amended, and re-referred to Com. on RLS. |
| Jun 17, 2020 | Referred to Com. on RLS. |
| Jan 28, 2020 | In Senate. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. |
| Jan 27, 2020 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Senate. (Ayes 72. Noes 0. Page 3910.) |
| Jan 23, 2020 | From committee: Do pass. (Ayes 18. Noes 0.) (January 23). |
| May 16, 2019 | In committee: Hearing postponed by committee. |
| May 8, 2019 | In committee: Set, first hearing. Referred to APPR. suspense file. |
| Apr 24, 2019 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 8. Noes 0.) (April 23). Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Apr 22, 2019 | Re-referred to Com. on HUM. S. |
| Apr 11, 2019 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to Com. on HUM. S. Read second time and amended. |
| Mar 18, 2019 | Referred to Com. on HUM. S. |
| Feb 25, 2019 | Read first time. |
| Feb 23, 2019 | From printer. May be heard in committee March 25. |
| Feb 22, 2019 | Introduced. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Aug 13, 2020 | Placed on suspense file | Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Jul 30, 2020 | Do pass, but first be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] with the recommendation: To Consent Calendar | Senate Standing Committee on Judiciary |
Passed |
|
| Jan 27, 2020 | AB 1796 Levine Assembly Third Reading | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| Jan 23, 2020 | Do pass. | Assembly Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Apr 23, 2019 | Do pass and be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Assembly Standing Committee on Human Services |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
SENATE COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Senator Anthony Portantino, Chair
2019 - 2020 Regular Session
AB 1796 (Levine) - Domestic violence: restraining orders
Version: July 14, 2020 | Policy Vote: JUD. 9 - 0 |
Urgency: No | Mandate: No |
Hearing Date: August 13, 2020 | Consultant: Shaun Naidu |
Bill Summary:
AB 1796 would require specified courts to provide a drop box, during and after business hours, for the submission of petitions for domestic violence restraining orders (DVROs).
Fiscal Impact:
Unknown, likely major one-time costs ranging from the mid hundreds of thousands of dollars to low millions of dollars to the courts to install drop boxes at each facility that receives petitions for DVROs. (Various funds (See Staff Comments.))
The Judicial Council reports that, for court facilities in Los Angeles County alone, estimated implementation costs would range from $188,000 to $192,000.
Background:
According to the analysis of this bill by the Senate Committee on Judiciary:
The [Domestic Violence Protetion Act (DVPA)] seeks to prevent acts of domestic violence, abuse, and sexual abuse, and to provide for a separation of persons involved in domestic violence for a period sufficient to enable them to seek a resolution. The DVPA’s “protective purpose is broad both in its stated intent and its breadth of persons protected.” (Caldwell v. Coppola (1990) 219 Cal.App.3d 859, 863.) The DVPA must be broadly construed in order to accomplish the statute’s purpose. (In re Marriage of Nadkarni (2009) 173 Cal.App.4th 1483, 1498.) The Act enables a party to seek a “protective order,” also known as a restraining order, which may be issued to protect a petitioner who presents “reasonable proof of a past act or acts of abuse.” ([Fam. Code,] § 6300; see § 6218.)
Petitioners who need immediate protection may seek a [temporary restraining order (TRO)], which becomes effective upon receiving a judge’s signature and being served on the respondent. TROs may be issued “ex parte” (Latin for “by or for one party”)—that is, without formal notice to, or the presence of, the respondent. (See § 241.) Because a restrained party would not have had the opportunity to defend their interests, TROs are of necessity short in duration. If a noticed hearing is not held within 21 days (or 25 if the court finds good cause), the TRO is no longer enforceable, unless a court grants a continuance. (§§ 242 & 245.) After a duly noticed hearing, however, the court is authorized to extend the original TRO into a “permanent” protective order (also known as orders after hearing) that may last up to five years. (§§ 6345, 6302.) [Footnote omitted.]
Proposed Law:
This bill would:
- Require any court or court facility that receives petitions for DVROs or domestic violence temporary restraining orders to permit such petitions to be submitted in a drop box located on the court premises, during and after normal business hours.
- Specify that the deadlines applicable to any action taken by the court with respect to a DVRO petition filed directly with the court also apply to any action taken with respect to a DVRO petition submitted in a drop box.
- Require the Judicial Council to develop rules and to assist courts in developing local rules or procedures necessary to effectuate this measure.
Related Legislation:
SB 1141 (Rubio, 2019-2020 Reg. Sess.) would provide that coercive control is a form of domestic abuse for purposes of the DVPA. SB 1141, at the time of this writing, is pending in the Assembly Committee on Judiciary.
AB 2517 (Gloria, 2019-2020 Reg. Sess.) would allow courts to make a finding in a DVRO issued after notice and a hearing that specific debts were incurred as a result of domestic violence. AB 2517 is pending in this Committee.
Staff Comments:
The funds that can be used for the installation of the drop boxes required by this bill vary by the type of installation needed at each court facility. As such, the Judicial Council believes that the fund source to pay for installation of these drop boxes also will vary. For instance, if the drop box is a stand-alone style, courts could pay for this cost from their allocations for court operations out of the Trial Court Trust Fund (TCTF). If the installation requires an exterior building modification, the cost could be paid out of the State Court Facilities Construction Fund (SCFCF) or the Immediate and Critical Needs Account (ICNA) as a facilities modification project with the court paying for the drop box itself. There are, however, challenges with these fund sources. If the courts were required to pay for these costs from their TCTF allocation, it would reduce funds available to pay for court operations costs. In the 2020-2021 fiscal year, courts already have been required to absorb a $167.8 million ongoing cut in their court operations allocations. Additionally, if SCFCF or ICNA were used to pay for these costs, the expense would hasten the insolvency of both funds. Currently, SCFCF is projected to go insolvent in the 2021-2022 fiscal year and ICNA in the 2026-2027 fiscal year. Insolvencies of special funds would lead to General Fund cost pressures to backfill any shortages. For example, the Budget Act of 2020 appropriated $273.8 million from the General Fund to backfill continued reduction in fine and fee revenue for trial court operations.
If enacted, AB 1796 would require the drop boxes to be set up by January 1, 2021. While the judicial branch likely would be able to install drop boxes at most affected court facilities located on state-owned property in time, the Judicial Council is unsure if it could comply with the mandate by the beginning of 2021 for non-state controlled court facilities due to several factors, such as diversity of MOUs, contracts for shared facilities, and potential delays in obtaining local approval caused by typical issues and/or the COVID-19 pandemic. Consequently, the author may wish to consider if a delayed implementation is warranted.
-- END --
Senator Hannah-Beth Jackson, Chair
2019-2020 Regular Session
Bill No: AB 1796 (Author:Levine)
Version: July 14, 2020
Hearing Date: July 30, 2020
Fiscal: Yes
Urgency: No
Consultant: JT
SUBJECT
Domestic violence: restraining orders
DIGEST
This bill requires courts to provide a drop box, during and after business hours, for the filing of petitions for domestic violence restraining orders.
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
Changes to everyday life associated with the COVID-19 pandemic have led to increased rates of domestic violence. Shelter-in-place orders, jobs losses, and school closures deteriorate strained relationships and keep victims confined with abusers. Many victims find it more difficult to seek help, escape to a safe location, report abuse to law enforcement, or go to court to get a restraining order. To help ensure victims of domestic violence continue to have access to courts during the pandemic, the Judicial Council has adopted emergency rules that extend the duration of restraining orders, provide for remote proceedings, and require that courts provide a means for the filing of requests for restraining orders, whether by physical location, drop box, or, if feasible, through electronic means.
This bill would require courts to allow for the submission of domestic violence restraining orders by drop boxes located on court premises, during and after normal business hours. The bill would provide that deadlines applicable to such petitions would apply to petitions submitted by drop box, and would require the Judicial Council to develop rules and assist courts in developing local rules or procedures necessary to effectuate the bill’s requirements.
The bill is supported by Change for Justice, California Partnership to End Domestic Violence, Jewish Family Services of Los Angeles, and the California Chapter of the National Association of Social Workers. It has no opposition.
PROPOSED CHANGES TO THE LAW
Existing law:
- Provides for the issuance of a “temporary restraining order” (TRO). (Fam. Code § 240 et seq.)[1]
- Provides that, with specified exceptions, a TRO may be granted without notice to the respondent if it is alleged that irreparable injury would result to the petitioner before the matter can be heard on notice. (§ 241.)
- If the TRO is granted without notice, requires a hearing to be held on the petition within 21 days of the date the TRO is granted, or 25 days if the court finds good cause. (§ 242(a).)
- If the hearing is heard after that timeframe, provides that the TRO is unenforceable, unless the court grants a continuance for a reasonable period. (§§ 242(b) & 245.)
- Establishes the Domestic Violence Protection Act ([DVPA] § 6200 et seq.), which sets forth procedural and substantive requirements for the issuance of a protective order to enjoin, among other things, specified acts of abuse (§§ 6318; 6320).
- Defines “protective order,” for purposes of the DVPA and 1), above, as a restraining order, whether issued ex parte, after notice and hearing, or in a judgment, that is an order enjoining specified acts of abuse, excluding a person from a dwelling, or enjoining other specified behavior. (§ 6218.)
- Defines “domestic violence” as abuse perpetrated against a spouse, cohabitant, a person the abuser dates, a person who has a child with the abuser, a child, and immediate relatives. (§ 6211.)
- Defines “abuse” as any of the following:
- Intentionally or recklessly causing or attempting to cause bodily injury.
- Sexual assault.
- Placing a person in reasonable apprehension of imminent serious bodily injury to that person or to another.
- Engaging in enumerated harmful behaviors, including disturbing the peace of the other party. (§§ 6203(a); 6320.)
- Requires that an ex parte order be issued or denied the same day the application is submitted to the court, unless the application is filed too late in the day to permit effective review, in which case the order must be issued or denied on the next day of judicial business, as specified. (§ 6326.)
- Requires courts that are closed during business hours on a court day to provide a drop box for depositing documents to be filed with the clerk. Provides that a document so deposited is deemed filed that day unless filed after 4:00pm or on a judicial holiday, in which case it is deemed deposited for filing on the next court day. (Ca. Rule Ct. 2.210.)
- Provides for the extension of the duration of restraining orders, provides for remote proceedings, and requires that courts provide a means for the filing of ex parte requests for temporary restraining orders and requests to renew restraining orders, whether by physical location, drop box, or, if feasible, through electronic means. (Emergency Rules Ct, Rules 3, 8.)
This bill:
- Requires any court or court facility that receives petitions for domestic violence restraining orders or temporary restraining orders to permit such petitions to be submitted in a drop box located on the court premises, during or after normal business hours.
- Provides that the deadlines applicable to any action taken by the court with respect to a petition filed directly with the court also apply to any action taken with respect to a petition submitted in a drop box.
- Requires the Judicial Council to develop rules and to assist courts in developing local rules or procedures necessary to effectuate the bill’s provisions.
COMMENTS
- Domestic violence restraining orders
The DVPA seeks to prevent acts of domestic violence, abuse, and sexual abuse, and to provide for a separation of persons involved in domestic violence for a period sufficient to enable them to seek a resolution. The DVPA’s “protective purpose is broad both in its stated intent and its breadth of persons protected.” (Caldwell v. Coppola (1990) 219 Cal.App.3d 859, 863.) The DVPA must be broadly construed in order to accomplish the statute’s purpose. (In re Marriage of Nadkarni (2009) 173 Cal.App.4th 1483, 1498.) The Act enables a party to seek a “protective order,” also known as a restraining order, which may be issued to protect a petitioner who presents “reasonable proof of a past act or acts of abuse.” (§ 6300; see § 6218.)
Petitioners who need immediate protection may seek a TRO, which becomes effective upon receiving a judge’s signature and being served on the respondent. TROs may be issued “ex parte” (Latin for “by or for one party”)—that is, without formal notice to, or the presence of, the respondent. (See § 241.)[2] Because a restrained party would not have had the opportunity to defend their interests, TROs are of necessity short in duration. If a noticed hearing is not held within 21 days (or 25 if the court finds good cause), the TRO is no longer enforceable, unless a court grants a continuance. (§§ 242 & 245.) After a duly noticed hearing, however, the court is authorized to extend the original TRO into a “permanent” protective order (also known as orders after hearing) that may last up to five years. (§§ 6345, 6302.)
- Requires courts to receive domestic violence restraining order petitions via drop box
Changes to everyday life associated with the COVID-19 pandemic have led to increased rates of domestic violence.[3] Shelter-in-place orders, jobs losses, and school closures deteriorate strained relationships and keep victims confined with abusers. Many victims find it more difficult to seek help, escape to a safe location, report abuse to law enforcement, or go to court to get a restraining order.
According to the author: “County shelter-in-place orders due to the coronavirus have impacted all aspects of life, but have been particularly difficult for victims of domestic violence.” The author and sponsors jointly add that “[f]or victims, the process to seek a temporary restraining order (TRO) or a domestic violence restraining order (DVRO) has been complicated by the closure of or limited access to the courts. Even during a pandemic, timely access to the courts is necessary to protect vulnerable individuals and prevent harm to victims of domestic violence.”
To help ensure victims of domestic violence continue to have access to courts during the pandemic, the Judicial Council has adopted emergency rules that extend the duration of restraining orders, provide for remote proceedings, and require that courts provide a means for the filing of requests for restraining orders, whether by physical location, drop box, or, if feasible, through electronic means. (Emergency Rules Ct, Rules 3, 8.) Additionally, Rule of Court 2.210 requires courts that are closed during business hours on a court day to provide a drop box for depositing documents to be filed with the clerk. The rule also provides that a document so deposited is deemed filed that day unless filed 4:00pm or on a judicial holiday, in which case it is deemed deposited for filing on the next court day. (Ca. Rule Ct. 2.210.)
This bill would require any court or court facility that receives petitions for domestic violence restraining orders or temporary restraining orders to permit such petitions to be submitted in a drop box located on the court premises, during or after normal business hours. The bill would provide that the deadlines applicable to any action taken by the court with respect to a petition filed directly with the court also apply to any action taken with respect to a petition submitted in a drop box. The bill would require the Judicial Council to develop rules and to assist courts in developing local rules or procedures necessary to effectuate this provision.
The author writes:
Currently, a victim’s available options to file a request for a TRO or DVRO are at the discretion of each court. In-person filing during business hours is required, but access to alternative methods of filing, such as physical drop boxes, are inconsistent at best and unavailable at worst. A requirement for all courts to provide drop box locations for TRO and DVRO filings during and after business hours can help bridge the equity gap through consistent access across the state and by increasing access to low-income victims that may not have availability to file during business hours. Without additional alternatives to file a TRO or a DVRO, victims of domestic violence will continue to be exposed to harm with limited opportunities to escape a dangerous cycle of violence.
Change for Justice, in support of the bill, adds:
Stay-at-home orders issued during the COVID-19 pandemic have led to an alarming spike in acts of domestic violence. For months, victims have been locked in with abusers with little ability to seek out resources. The ability for a victim to receive relief from the courts in the form of a restraining order could mean the difference between life and death for them. As courts continue to operate on a limited basis for the foreseeable future, it is integral that the system be allowed to adapt to the rapidly changing needs of the public during this pandemic, and especially of those in harm’s way.
SUPPORT
California Partnership to End Domestic Violence
Change for Justice
Jewish Family Services of Los Angeles
National Association of Social Workers, California Chapter
OPPOSITION
None known
RELATED LEGISLATION
Pending Legislation:
SB 1141 (Rubio, 2020) would provide that coercive control is a form of domestic abuse for purposes of the DVPA. The bill is pending in the Assembly Judiciary Committee.
AB 2517 (Gloria, 2020) would authorize courts to make a finding in a domestic violence restraining order issued after notice and a hearing that specific debts were incurred as a result of domestic violence. The bill will be heard in this Committee the same day as this bill.
Prior Legislation: None known.
PRIOR VOTES:
This bill was amended June 24, 2020, to delete and replace its contents with provisions relating to a new subject. All prior votes on the bill occurred before these amendments and thus are not relevant.
**************
All further statutory references are to the Family Code, unless otherwise specified. ↑
A TRO is distinct from an “emergency protective order,” which is an order specifically requested by a law enforcement official and that a judicial officer finds necessary to prevent the occurrence or recurrence of domestic violence, child abuse, child abduction, or abuse of an elder or dependent adult. (§§ 6250, 6250.3, 6251.) An emergency protective order is not subject to the provisions governing TROs. (See § 240.) ↑
Newberry, Laura & Santa Cruz, Nicole, Domestic abuse victims in ‘worst-case scenario’ during outbreak, providers say (March 24, 2020) Los Angeles Times, available at https://www.latimes.com/california/story/2020-03-24/womens-shelters-brace-for-surge-in-domestic-violence-as-coronavirus-quarantines-isolate-survivors (as of May 16, 2020). ↑
ASSEMBLY THIRD READING
ATR Bill Id:AB 1796
Author:(Levine)
As Amended Ver:April 11, 2019
Majority vote
SUMMARY:
Repeals the ability of the California Department of Social Services (CDSS) to issue a license to operate or provide direct care services in a community care facility when an applicant meets all other conditions for licensure, except for receipt of pending Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI) criminal offender record information, and the individual has signed and submitted a statement that they have never been convicted of a crime in the United States, and instead prohibits CDSS from granting a criminal record clearance or exemption until it receives an individual's complete state and federal criminal record.
Major Provisions
- Deletes the ability of CDSS to issue a license to operate or provide direct care services in a community care facility to an applicant who, except for receipt of the FBI's criminal offender record information search response, meets all of the conditions for licensure and has signed and submitted a statement that they have never been convicted of a crime in the United States, other than a traffic violation, as defined in current law.
- Deletes the ability of CDSS to revoke the license, or require a foster family agency to revoke the certificate of approval, if, after licensure or the issuance of a certificate of approval to a certified family home by a foster family agency, CDSS determines that an individual, as specified, has a criminal record.
- Deletes the ability of CDSS to suspend a license or require a foster family agency to suspend a certificate of approval pending an administrative hearing, as defined in current law.
- Prohibits CDSS from granting a criminal record clearance or from granting an exemption, as specified in current law, until it receives an individual's complete state and federal criminal history information from the Department of Justice.
- Repeals certain provisions of statute enacted by SB 80 (Committee on Budget and Fiscal Review), Chapter 27, Statutes of 2019 and AB 819 (Stone), Chapter 777, Statutes of 2019 related to the criminal background check procedure.
- Makes technical changes.
COMMENTS:
Criminal background checks: Applicants, licensees, adult residents, certain volunteers, and employees of community care facilities who have contact with clients are required by law to undergo a background check and obtain a criminal record clearance or exemption, if applicable. In the event that an individual has a criminal history, Department of Justice (DOJ) sends a record transcript to CDSS, detailing the person's arrests and convictions. If the crimes meet the criteria necessary to qualify for an exemption, pursuant to current law, CDSS sends an exemption notification letter to the applicant or licensee and to the individual. Individuals who are awaiting an exemption may not be present in a facility until an exemption is granted by CDSS. An exemption is required when an individual has been convicted of any crime other than a minor traffic violation, and current law prohibits CDSS from granting exemptions to individuals who commit certain crimes (referred to as non-exemptible crimes), including convictions for murder, kidnapping, possession of child pornography, sexual exploitation of a child, elder or dependent abuse, and arson, among others.
California State Auditor report: Audit Report 2016-126, released in March 2017, examined the timeliness and quality of CDSS background procedures for individuals who have contact with clients in community care facilities. The report made a number of findings, and, in response to these findings, made a number of recommendations, among which was the recommendation that state law be changed to prohibit CBCB from allowing an individual to be present in a licensed facility until it receives information from the FBI about out-of-state convictions. Current law allows for an individual to be present in a licensed facility in instances where the individual meets all other conditions for licensure and has submitted a self-disclosure form stating that they have never been convicted of a crime in the United States, but the CBCB has not received the person's federal criminal history from the FBI.
Staff comments: Certain provisions of this bill repeal statutory changes related to the criminal background check process as they were enacted by SB 80 (Committee on Budget and Fiscal Review), Chapter 27, Statutes of 2019 and AB 819 (Stone), Chapter 777, Statutes of 2019. Should this bill move forward, the author may wish to make amendments to the provisions of this bill to ensure conformity with previously enacted legislation.
According to the Author:
According to the author, "In 2016 a report released by the California State Auditor's Office stated that in some cases, CDSS failed to obtain self-disclosure forms for individuals and allowed them access to facilities in advance of receiving their federal criminal history…Allowing unauthorized individuals to access licensed facilities exposes clients to unnecessary and potentially dangerous situations."
Arguments in Support:
Writing in support of this bill, the County of San Diego states, "By prohibiting CDSS from issuing a community care facility license until it receives complete state and federal criminal history information on the applicant, [this bill] further protects the health and safety of the vulnerable individuals who utilize community care facilities."
Arguments in Opposition:
Writing in opposition to the bill, 6Beds, Inc. writes "[This bill] will create delays of several days to weeks (in the case of federal government shutdown) in filling vacancies by requiring licensees to wait for the FBI criminal clearance even after receiving state DOJ background clearance."
FISCAL COMMENTS:
According to the Assembly Appropriations Committee:
- Estimated one-time costs of $500,000 (General Fund) to CDSS for two 12-month contracts to implement the necessary automation changes; and,
- Unknown, one-time costs to CDSS for increased workload to update necessary forms and procedures and to disseminate information regarding the changes to counties.
VOTES:
ASM HUMAN SERVICES: 8-0-0
YES: Reyes, Mathis, Luz Rivas, Choi, Friedman, Gipson, Maienschein, Mark Stone
ASM APPROPRIATIONS: 18-0-0
YES: Gonzalez, Bigelow, Bloom, Bonta, Brough, Calderon, Carrillo, Chau, Megan Dahle, Diep, Eggman, Fong, Gabriel, Eduardo Garcia, Maienschein, Petrie-Norris, Quirk, Robert Rivas
UPDATED:
VERSION: April 11, 2019
CONSULTANT: Kelsy Castillo / HUM. S. / (916) 319-2089 FN: 0002653
Date of Hearing: May 8, 2019
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Lorena Gonzalez, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 1796
Author:(Levine) – As Amended Ver:April 11, 2019
Policy Committee: | Human Services | Vote: | 8 - 0 |
|
| ||
|
|
Urgency: No State Mandated Local Program: No Reimbursable: No
SUMMARY:
This bill prohibits the Department of Social Services (DSS) from granting a criminal record clearance or from granting an exemption, as specified in current law, until it receives an individual’s complete state and federal criminal history information from the Department of Justice (DOJ). Specifically, this bill:
- Repeals the ability of DSS to issue a license to operate or provide direct care services in a community care facility when an applicant meets all other conditions for licensure, except for receipt of pending Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI) criminal offender record information, and the individual has signed and submitted a statement that they have never been convicted of a crime in the United States.
- Instead, prohibits DSS from granting a criminal record clearance or exemption until it receives an individual’s complete state and federal criminal record.
FISCAL EFFECT:
- Estimated one-time costs of $500,000 (GF) to DSS for two 12-month contracts to implement the necessary automation changes.
- Unknown, one-time costs to DSS for increased workload to update necessary forms and procedures and to disseminate information regarding the changes to counties.
COMMENTS:
- Purpose. This bill seeks to further provide for the health and safety of individuals placed in certain community care facilities by removing the ability of CDSS to license an individual to be present in a facility before the federal criminal history is received. According to the author:
DSS is tasked with protecting the health and safety of vulnerable populations. Through CCLD, DSS is responsible for licensing and regulating more than 70,000 community care facilities throughout the state. These include child care facilities, foster family homes, and care facilities for the elderly. In 2016 a report released by the California State Auditor’s Office stated that in some cases, DSS failed to obtain self-disclosure forms for individuals and allowed them access to facilities in advance of receiving their federal criminal history. This failure to review an individual’s complete criminal history creates a situation whereby dangerous or unauthorized individuals can be granted access to facilities that house or provide services to vulnerable populations.
- Background. The Community Care Licensing Division (CCLD) within DSS provides licenses and investigates complaints against facilities within its jurisdiction, which includes RCFEs and child care facilities, among others, in order to provide for the health and safety of the vulnerable populations in those facilities. These facilities typically provide non-medical care and supervision for children and adults in need, which includes families needing early childhood education (child care), children in foster care and at-risk youth needing shelter services, seniors needing residential care and individuals with disabilities.
- Criminal Background Checks. Existing law requires DSS to perform background checks on applicants, licensees, adult residents, employees and certain volunteers in community care facilities who come into contact with clients. In January 1992, DSS created the Caregiver Background Check Bureau (CBCB) within CCLD in order to help protect children and vulnerable individuals receiving care. An individual seeking clearance must submit fingerprints that allow the DOJ to conduct a criminal history check. If the individual has no criminal history, a clearance notice is sent to the individual and the CBCB. If, however, the individual has a criminal record, DOJ sends a criminal record transcript to the CBCB, which then reviews the history and determines if the convictions are for crimes that may be exempted under current law.
Existing law prohibits DSS from offering exemptions to individuals who have been convicted of certain serious crimes, including convictions for murder, kidnapping and incest, and cannot allow individuals convicted of committing these crimes to be in a licensed facility. Additional non-exemptible crimes include convictions for possession of child pornography, sexual exploitation of a child, elder or dependent abuse, and arson.
- Related Legislation.
AB 367 (Flora), of this legislative session, includes certain instances of spousal rape, pandering (not of a minor), pimping (not of a minor) and identity theft among the crimes for which a criminal background check exemption may not be granted. AB 367 has not yet been heard the Assembly Human Services Committee.
AB 447 (Patterson), of this legislative session, creates a process by which licensees of certain community care facilities can transfer current criminal record clearances of an individual associated with a facility to multiple facilities of the same facility type operated by the same licensee. AB 447 is pending on the Assembly Floor
AB 1809 (Holden), of this legislative session, prohibits DSS requiring an applicant for a license to operate a community to self-disclose their criminal history information, requires CDSS to annually post on its internet website certain data related to criminal record clearance and exemption approvals and denials, and requires CDSS to create a process to grant simplified criminal record exemptions to applicants for a license or special permit to operate or manage a community care facility. AB 1809 is pending hearing in this committee.
- Prior Legislation.
AB 1914 (Flora), Chapter 708, Statutes of 2018, as introduced, would have expanded the list of non-exemptible crimes per a recommendation in the State Auditor’s report. AB 1914 was amended to an unrelated topic.
AB 3039 (Holden), of the 2017-18 Legislative Session, would have made numerous certain changes to the criminal background check process for certain community care facilities, home care aide registry applicants, and home care organizations. AB 3039 was held on this committee’s Suspense File.
Analysis Prepared by: Jennifer Swenson / APPR. / (916) 319-2081
Date of Hearing: April 23, 2019
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON HUMAN SERVICES
Eloise Gómez Reyes, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 1796 (
Author:Levine) – As Amended Ver:April 11, 2019
SUBJECT: Community care facilities: criminal background checks
SUMMARY: Repeals the ability of the California Department of Social Services (CDSS) to issue a license to operate or provide direct care services in a community care facility when an applicant meets all other conditions for licensure, except for receipt of pending Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI) criminal offender record information, and the individual has signed and submitted a statement that they have never been convicted of a crime in the United States, and instead prohibits CDSS from granting a criminal record clearance or exemption until it receives an individual’s complete state and federal criminal record. Specifically, this bill:
- Deletes the ability of CDSS to issue a license to operate or provide direct care services in a community care facility to an applicant who, except for receipt of the FBI’s criminal offender record information search response, meets all of the conditions for licensure and has signed and submitted a statement that they have never been convicted of a crime in the United States, other than a traffic violation, as defined in current law.
- Deletes the ability of CDSS to revoke the license, or require a foster family agency to revoke the certificate of approval, if, after licensure or the issuance of a certificate of approval to a certified family home by a foster family agency, CDSS determines that an individual, as specified, has a criminal record.
- Deletes the ability of CDSS to suspend a license or require a foster family agency to suspend a certificate of approval pending an administrative hearing, as defined in current law.
- Prohibits CDSS from granting a criminal record clearance or from granting an exemption, as specified in current law, until it receives an individual’s complete state and federal criminal history information from the Department of Justice.
- Makes technical changes.
EXISTING LAW:
- Establishes the “Community Care Facilities Act”, which allows for the licensure and oversight of out of home placements for abused and neglected children by CDSS. (Health and Safety Code [HSC] Section 1500 et seq.)
- Establishes the “Community Care Licensing Division” (CCLD) within CDSS and requires CDSS to license group care facilities, private foster family agencies, and foster family homes in order to place children who are in the child welfare system. Further requires, prior to licensure, a foster home provider to undergo a criminal background check, as specified. (HSC 1502 and 1522)
- Defines a “community care facility” as any facility, place, or building that is maintained and operated to provide nonmedical residential care, day treatment, adult day care, or foster family agency services for children, adults, or children and adults, including, but not limited to, the physically handicapped, mentally impaired, incompetent persons, and abused or neglected children, and includes: residential facilities, adult day programs, foster family agencies, group homes, and children’s crisis residential programs, among others. (HSC 1502 et seq.)
- Requires CDSS to notify a licensee, upon service of an order of temporary license suspension, of the licensee’s right to an interim hearing on the order. (HSC 1550.5(a)(1))
- Defines “residential care facility” as a residential care facility for persons with chronic, life-threatening illness who are 18 years of age or older or are emancipated minors. (HSC 1568.01(j))
- Defines “residential care facility for the elderly” (RCFE) as a housing arrangement chosen voluntarily by persons 60 years of age or over, or their authorized representative, where varying levels and intensities of care and supervision, protective supervision, or personal care are provided, based upon their varying needs, as determined in order to be admitted and to remain in the facility. (HSC 1569.2(o)(1))
- Defines “child day care facility” as a facility that provides nonmedical care to children under 18 years of age in need of personal services, supervision, or assistance essential for sustaining the activities of daily living or for the protection of the individual on less than a 24-hour basis, and may include day care centers, employer-sponsored child care centers, and family day care homes. (HSC 1596.750)
- Requires individuals in community care facilities, including adults responsible for administration or direct supervision of staff, any person, other than a client, residing in the facility, and any staff person, volunteer, or employee who has contact with clients, among others, to obtain either a criminal record clearance or a criminal record exemption from CDSS before his or her initial presence in a community care facility or certified family home. (HSC 1522(a))
- Allows CDSS to issue a license to certain individuals who meet all of the conditions for licensure, except receipt of the Federal Bureau of Investigation’s criminal offender record information search response, if the individual has signed and submitted a statement that they have never been convicted of a crime in the United States, other than a traffic infraction, as specified. Further, allows CDSS to revoke a license if it is determined that the licensee has a criminal record. (HSC 1522(a)(1)(E))
- Requires CDSS to deny the applications of certain applicants if the applicant has been convicted of a crime other than a minor traffic violation, unless the department has granted an exemption pursuant to the exemption requirements specified in HSC 1522 (g), if the individual is awaiting trial for a crime other than a minor traffic violation, or it is discovered by CDSS after licensure that an individual has been convicted of a crime other than a minor traffic violation. (HSC 1522(a)(4))
- Prohibits a criminal records exemption from being granted for an applicant to work, reside, or volunteer in certain facilities (including residential care facilities for the elderly, residential care facilities for the chronically ill, child day care facilities, and community care facilities) if the applicant has a conviction for certain offenses, as specified, including an offense specified in Penal Code [PEN] Section 290(c), which pertains to crime for which registration as a sex offender is required. (HSC 1522(g)(1)(A), HSC 1569.17(f), HSC 1568.09(f), HSC 1596.871)
- Allows the Department of Justice (DOJ) to provide subsequent state or federal arrest or disposition notification to any entity authorized by state or federal law to receive state or federal summary criminal history information to assist in fulfilling employment, licensing, certification duties, or the duties of approving relative caregivers, nonrelative extended family members, and resource families upon the arrest or disposition of any person whose fingerprints are maintained on file at the DOJ or the Federal Bureau of Investigation as the result of an application for licensing, employment, certification, or approval. (PEN 11105.2(a))
- Requires DOJ to, within 14 calendar days, notify CDSS of the criminal record information, and, if no criminal information has been recorded, provide a statement of that fact. (HSC 1522(c)(2))
FISCAL EFFECT: Unknown
COMMENTS:
Community Care Licensing Division (CCLD): Within CDSS is CCLD, which is responsible for licensing and investigating complaints against facilities that fall within its jurisdiction, such as RCFEs, child care facilities, and out-of-home placements for foster youth, among others. Typically, these facilities provide non-medical care and supervision for adults and youth in need by providing adult care services, early childhood education (child care), foster care and shelter services for youth, and residential care for seniors or individuals with developmental disabilities. CCLD is also responsible for ensuring these facilities comply with all applicable laws and regulations, including criminal background checks, as well was overseeing any necessary corrective actions in the event of noncompliance.
Criminal background checks: Applicants, licensees, adult residents, certain volunteers, and employees of community care facilities who have contact with clients are required by law to undergo a background check and obtain a criminal record clearance or exemption, if applicable. The background check requires these individuals to submit fingerprints which are used by DOJ to search for any criminal record history. For individuals without a criminal history, DOJ forwards a clearance notice to the applicant or licensee, and to the Caregiver Background Check Bureau (CBCB) of CCLD. In the event that the individual does have a criminal history, DOJ sends a record transcript to CBCB, detailing the person’s arrests and convictions. If the crimes meet the criteria necessary to qualify for an exemption, pursuant to current law, CBCB sends an exemption notification letter to the applicant or licensee and to the individual. Individuals who are awaiting an exemption may not be present in a facility until an exemption is granted by CBCB. An exemption is required when an individual has been convicted of any crime other than a minor traffic violation, and current law prohibits CDSS from granting exemptions to individuals who commit certain crimes (referred to as non-exemptible crimes), including convictions for murder, kidnapping, possession of child pornography, sexual exploitation of a child, elder or dependent abuse, and arson, among others.
California State Auditor report: Audit Report 2016-126, released in March 2017, examined the timeliness and quality of CDSS background procedures for individuals who have contact with clients in community care facilities. The report made a number of findings including:
The DOJ does not send CDSS certain necessary information: State law does not explicitly require DOJ to send information related to sentencing; in 2016, DOJ stopped providing that information to CDSS. Pursuant to current law, DOJ is required to provide certain information to CDSS, including every criminal conviction of an individual, every arrest for which an individual is awaiting trial, and every arrest for certain crimes, including murder, elder abuse and assault, and sex offender status, but not information related to any arrest that was later determined to be a detention only or that resulted in the successful completion of a diversion program or exoneration. CDSS, therefore, issues clearance and exemption decisions based upon incomplete criminal record histories due to DOJ lacking the explicit authority to provide sentencing information; still, state regulations require CDSS to consider whether an applicant is on probation or parole, as well as the length of time that has elapsed since the end of parole, probation, or incarceration.
CDSS does not always obtain or review all pertinent information: The report also found that CBCB clears individuals to be present in licensed facilities without first reviewing convictions for infractions, which are relatively minor crimes and often punishable by a fine imposed by courts; infractions include theft, leaving a child under six years old in a vehicle without supervision, and selling liquor to a minor. While current law requires a criminal records exemption be obtained for convictions of any crimes with the exception of a nonminor traffic violation, background check procedures dictate CDSS staff to review only convictions for misdemeanors or felonies, and not convictions of infractions, as CDSS interprets “minor traffic violation” as inclusive of all infractions, be they traffic-related or otherwise. Current law also allows individuals to be present in a licensed facility based on their in-state criminal history received by DOJ, but prior to the receipt of the federal record of arrests and prosecutions (RAP) sheet if the individual has submitted a self-disclosure form attesting that they have never been convicted of a crime in the United States (other than a traffic violation). The audit report found that CDSS, contrary to state law, allowed individuals who did not submit a self-disclosure form to be present in licensed facilities.
Delays at DOJ and CDSS cause further delays in the issuance of exemption decisions: While DOJ is currently required to provide CDSS with criminal record histories within 14 days of receiving a person’s fingerprints, the State Auditor found that, in some instances, the average amount of time it took DOJ to send information to CDSS was between 30 and 66 days after fingerprinting, which can further delay the date by which CDSS can initiate and complete background checks. It was also determined that the information contained in the DOJ materials affects the timeliness during which CDSS issues a decision on a criminal record exemption. During Fiscal Years 2013-14 and 2015-16, upon receipt of information from DOJ, CBCB took an average of 149 and 170 days – approximately five to six months – to decide whether to grant or deny a standard exemption. The exemption process took an average of about four months, as state regulations allow 45 days for an individual or facility to submit exemption request documents to CDSS.
Auditor’s recommendations: In response to these findings, the audit made a number of recommendations, including, but not limited to:
- Amend state law to clearly direct DOJ to transmit all convictions it receives;
- Establish timeframes by which CDSS must notify individuals and facilities that criminal history exemptions are required, and for evaluating and issuing exemption decisions;
- Require DOJ to obtain and transmit subsequent federal RAP sheets and to report to the Legislature periodically about its implementation efforts; and,
- Expand the list of non-exemptible crimes to include eight crimes that are similar to crimes for which an exemption may not be granted, such as certain instances of spousal rape, pandering (not of a minor), pimping (not of a minor), and identity theft.
The audit also recommended that state law be changed to prohibit CBCB from allowing an individual to be present in a licensed facility until it receives information from the FBI about out-of-state convictions. Current law allows for an individual to be present in a licensed facility in instances where the individual meets all other conditions for licensure and has submitted a self-disclosure form stating that they have never been convicted of a crime in the United States, but the CBCB has not received the person’s federal criminal history from the FBI. The auditor’s recommendation was based on the audit findings that CDSS did not consistently obtain and use self-disclosed conviction information. Specifically, the audit found that, contrary to state law, CDSS does not always obtain self-disclosure forms for all individuals it allows to access licensed facilities in advance of receiving their federal criminal history. The audit stated that:
“When the CBCB does not obtain self-disclosure forms before allowing individuals to be present in facilities, it may allow individuals with federal criminal histories into facilities prematurely…Therefore, a change to state law to require that CDSS receive both state and federal criminal history information before allowing individuals to be present in facilities would not unduly delay CDSS’ exemption process, and it would eliminate the risk of initially allowing individuals into facilities before learning of their entire criminal history.”
Need for this bill: The provisions of this bill seek to further provide for the health and safety of individuals placed in certain community care facilities by removing the ability of CDSS to license an individual to be present in a facility upon receipt of a state criminal history and a self-disclosure form attesting that the individual has not committed a crime in the United States, but before the federal criminal history is received. The bill would instead prohibit CDSS from issuing a license to operate or be present in a community care facility until both the state and federal criminal histories have been received, and the individual has received a criminal record clearance or exemption pursuant to the current exemption process.
According to the author, “CDSS is tasked with protecting the health and safety of vulnerable populations. Through CCLD, CDSS is responsible for licensing and regulating more than 70,000 community care facilities throughout the state. These include child care facilities, foster family homes, and care facilities for the elderly. In 2016 a report released by the California State Auditor’s Office stated that in some cases, CDSS failed to obtain self-disclosure forms for individuals and allowed them access to facilities in advance of receiving their federal criminal history. This failure to review an individual’s complete criminal history creates a situation whereby dangerous or unauthorized individuals can be granted access to facilities that house or provide services to vulnerable populations. Clients under the care of CDSS rely on a system that properly screens those who provide them care. Allowing unauthorized individuals to access licensed facilities exposes clients to unnecessary and potentially dangerous situations.”
Staff comments: The provisions of this bill seek to ensure greater health and safety for individuals placed in community care facilities by prohibiting CDSS from issuing licenses to applicants before receiving both a person’s state and federal criminal histories. By prohibiting this practice, the provisions of this bill would prevent individuals who do not have a criminal history in California, but have a criminal conviction for crimes in another state or states that require an exemption from having premature access to the vulnerable populations placed in community care facilities.
While the provisions of this bill may result in increased health and safety of residents, the Legislature has seen an increase in legislation in recent years related to health and safety in certain community care facilities, specifically as it pertains to the criminal background check process. Some proposals, including this one, have been introduced in response to the Auditor’s report and seek to increase the stringency of the existing criminal background check process, while others seek to reform the existing process to allow for greater flexibility in determining whether to issue exemptions to individuals who have committed a crime but have been rehabilitated. It is the role of the Legislature to protect the health and safety of individuals placed in community care facilities. It is also important to ensure that the criminal background check process is timely, efficient, and does not unduly pose barriers to individuals who wish to provide the much-needed care to residents placed in these facilities. Should this bill move forward, the author may wish to consider whether a comprehensive assessment of the existing background check process is necessary to determine if the existing criminal background check process is effective, timely, efficient, and provides for the needs of residents placed in facilities, without also establishing unnecessary barriers to individuals who wish to provide care to residents.
RELATED AND PRIOR LEGISLATION:
AB 367 (Flora) of 2019 includes certain instances of spousal rape, pandering (not of a minor), pimping (not of a minor), and identity theft among the crimes for which a criminal background check exemption may not be granted. AB 367 is scheduled to be heard in the Assembly Human Services Committee on April 23, 2019.
AB 447 (Patterson) of 2019 creates a process by which licenses of certain community care facilities can transfer current criminal record clearances of an individual associated with a facility to multiple facilities of the same facility type operated by the same licensee. AB 447 is awaiting hearing in the Assembly Appropriations Committee.
AB 1608 (Holden) of 2019 prohibits CDSS from requiring an applicant for a license to operate a community to self-disclose their criminal history information, requires CDSS to annually post on its internet website certain data related to criminal record clearance and exemption approvals and denials, requires CDSS to create a process to grant simplified criminal record exemptions to applicants for a license or special permit to operate or manage a community care facility, and instructs CDSS to consider granting a simplified criminal record exemption to individuals who meet certain criteria. AB 1608 is scheduled to be heard in the Assembly Human Services Committee on April 23, 2019.
AB 1914 (Flora), Chapter 708, Statutes of 2018, as introduced, would have expanded the list of non-exemptible crimes to include certain instances of spousal rape, pandering (not of a minor), pimping (not of a minor), and identity theft. AB 1914 was amended on June 25, 2018, to pertain to underground excavations and subsurface facilities.
AB 3039 (Holden) of 2018 would have made numerous certain changes to the criminal background check process for certain community care facilities, home care aide registry applicants, and home care organizations. AB 3039 was held on the Assembly Appropriations Committee’s suspense file.
AB 484 (Cunningham), Chapter 526, Statutes of 2017, made convictions for any crime listed in PEN 261, which pertains to crimes related to rape, abduction, carnal abuse of children, and seduction, a requirement for registering on the sex offender registry.
SB 384 (Wiener), Chapter 541, Statutes of 2017, created a tiered registry for sex offenses such that people are required to register for 10 years, 20 years, or lifetime depending on the offense for which the individual was convicted.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
California Continuing Care Residents Association
California Police Chiefs Association
Consumer Attorneys of California
County of San Diego
Opposition
None on file
Analysis Prepared by: Kelsy Castillo / HUM. S. / (916) 319-2089
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):