AB 1959: Property taxation: assessment appeals: deferral of tax payment.
- Session Year: 2019-2020
- House: Assembly
- Latest Version Date: 2020-02-14
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Mar 9, 2020 | In committee: Hearing for testimony only. |
| Feb 18, 2020 | Re-referred to Com. on REV. & TAX. |
| Feb 14, 2020 | Referred to Com. on REV. & TAX. |
| Jan 22, 2020 | From printer. May be heard in committee February 21. |
| Jan 21, 2020 | Read first time. To print. |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
Date of Hearing: March 9, 2020
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON REVENUE AND TAXATION
Autumn R. Burke, Chairwoman
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 1959 (
Author:Mayes) – As Amended Ver:February 14, 2020
FOR TESTIMONY ONLY
Majority vote. Fiscal committee.
SUBJECT: Property taxation: assessment appeals: deferral of tax payment
SUMMARY: Suspends the payment of property taxes in dispute if a taxpayer files an assessment appeal on their home's property assessment. Specifically, this bill:
- Tolls the due date of taxes on real property on the secured roll, limited to the disputed amount of the taxes, during the pendency of the assessment appeal.
- Starts the toll date when the taxpayer files an assessment appeal application with the county board of equalization or assessment appeals board (county board).
- Makes, after the county board's resolution of the assessment appeal, any formerly disputed taxes due and payable on the first November 1 or February 1, whichever occurs earlier.
- Establishes a 10% delinquency penalty if the disputed taxes due and payable on November 1 are unpaid on December 10, and for disputed taxes due and payable on February 1 on April 10, as applicable.
- Defines "resolution of the assessment appeal" to mean either:
- The county board has determined to not make any changes to the assessed value of the property or amount of taxes owed by the taxpayer, based on an assessment appeal application filed; or,
- The county board has determined to make changes to the assessed value of the property, or amount of taxes owed by the taxpayer, based on an assessment appeal application filed and the auditor has corrected the assessment roll with respect to that property in accordance with that decision, as specified.
- Limits the due date tolling provisions to an assessment appeal relating to real property the taxpayer both owns and occupies.
- Authorizes the Governor, by executive order, to suspend the tax payment tolling provisions when, in the Governor's judgment, economic conditions affecting the market in real property on a statewide basis warrant suspension.
- Makes conforming changes to county-optional provisions in law designed to discourage taxpayers from intentionally understating their opinion of value as stated on an assessment appeal application.
EXISTING LAW:
- Requires county tax collectors to mail annual property tax bills to taxpayers by November 1.
- Provides that the taxes are due in two equal installments on November 1 and February 1; imposes a delinquency penalty of 10%, and interest of 1-1/2% per month, on payments not received by December 10 and April 10, respectively.
- Establishes a process for taxpayers to appeal the assessed value of their property as determined by the assessor by filing an assessment appeal application with the county board by either September 15 or November 30 depending upon the county, as specified.
- Requires assessment appeal applicants to state their opinion of value on the application filed.
- Provides that if the county board fails to make a final determination on the appeal within two years of filing the application, then the applicant's opinion of value as stated on the application becomes the value upon which taxes are based for that tax year, as specified.
- Requires taxpayers to pay property taxes timely regardless of a pending appeal. Imposes delinquency penalties and interest charges regardless of the outcome of the appeal, should the taxpayer not pay their taxes by the delinquency deadlines.
- Provides taxpayers who appeal and are granted an assessment reduction by the county board a refund of taxes previously paid with interest.
- Allows the county auditor, with county board of supervisor approval, to impound the disputed revenues of any tax upon secured or unsecured property, levied and collected by the county or any revenue district, when a claim or action is filed for the return of revenues, as specified, or the auditor reasonably anticipates the tax may be refunded in whole or in part.[1]
FISCAL EFFECT: Unknown
COMMENTS:
- The author has provided the following statement in support of this bill:
In the 2017-2018 Fiscal Year there were 19,484 residential property tax appeals in California. A property tax appeal typically occurs when a property is sold, undergoes new construction, or when its market value declines significantly. If a taxpayer disagrees with this assessment, they may file an assessment appeal. However, the newly assessed property tax must still be paid by the taxpayer regardless of appeal. This bill would simply allow payment of a disputed amount to be postponed until the resolution of the appeal. California homeowners expect predictable property tax bills under Proposition 13 and this legislation would continue that predictability for owner-occupied homes.
- The California State Association of Counties, Rural County Representatives of California, and Urban Counties of California note the following in opposition to this bill:
AB 1959 would have serious consequences for local governments, which depend on property tax revenue to operate and deliver services, many of which are mandated by state law. Property taxes raise more than $55 billion annually for counties, cities, special districts, and schools. Assessment appeals boards, which already face high workloads in many counties, would see a sharp increase in the number of appeals filed, driven by those who simply wish to delay payment, thus increasing costs for, in many cases, no benefit.
The general principle for all taxes, from income to sales to property tax, is that they are due and payable until a taxpayer can prove otherwise. This balance helps guard against taxpayers manipulating the system for their own gain and the detriment of the community.
- The California Association of Clerks and Elections Officials (CACEO) opposes this bill and states:
Based on the potential misuse of the assessment appeals program we administer that AB 1959 would invite, and given the mechanics of the local property tax system and the numerous vulnerabilities that this policy change would create in the local property tax collection process, CACEO must oppose this proposal.
Permitting a taxpayer to withhold payment of property taxes while an assessment appeal relating to the subject property [is ongoing] will certainly invite the filing of frivolous or meritless applications for appeal by taxpayers who are either unable or unwilling to pay their taxes. [T]his in turn would create greater backlogs of pending appeals, delaying hearings for all applicants.
The assessment appeal process is consistent with a long-standing principle in California that protects the state and local taxing authorities against precollection litigation that could severely restrict or cut off the sources of government revenue. [E]nactment of AB 1959 would be the first step of this very slippery slope.
- Committee Staff Comments:
- What does this bill do? This bill would allow a homeowner who has filed an assessment appeal with their county appeals board to defer payment of their disputed taxes until the appeal is resolved. After the county appeals board issues a decision on the appeal, the homeowner would owe the outstanding amount, if any, in accordance with the county board's decision.
- Anti-injunction policy: California has long had a well-recognized public policy prohibiting the issuance of an injunction or other legal process to prevent the collection of a tax. This policy is reflected in Section 32 of Article XIII of the California Constitution. Although the provisions of Section 32 are limited to proceedings against the State or an officer thereof and are not applicable to local tax officials, essentially the same prohibition is found in R&TC Section 4807. That section provides that no "injunction or writ of mandate or other legal or equitable process shall issue in any suit or action or proceeding in any court against any county … or any officer thereof, to prevent or enjoin the collection of property taxes sought to be collected." The vitality of this fundamental tax policy has been repeatedly affirmed by the California courts. The underlying policy theory is that it protects government against pre-collection litigation that could tie or cut off government's source of revenue.
- A long-standing public policy: The principle of paying taxes levied while an assessment is in dispute is to allow revenue collection to continue during the appeals process so essential public services dependent on those funds are not unnecessarily interrupted. Additionally, this policy allows governmental entities to engage in fiscal planning based on expected revenues. Cities, counties, special districts, and schools depend on the property tax revenue proceeds with a reasonable amount of certainty. As previously noted, the "pay first, litigate after" principle is a long-standing public policy that runs through all state and local tax and fee programs. This bill would set a precedent of creating an exception to this process that other taxpayers would seek in both the property tax arena and other tax and fee programs.
- Administrative complexities: This bill does not define the phrase "disputed amount of taxes." County appeals boards determine assessed values and not "taxes." Property owners appeal assessed values, which, in turn, serve as the basis of the ad valorem portion of the property tax bill. However, many other payments are collected via the annual property tax bill, such as special assessments and parcel taxes, which are not based on the assessed value. These amounts are generally fixed and are not appealable to the county appeals board. Additionally, some loan payments such as Property Assessed Clean Energy (PACE) loans are collected through a homeowner's property tax bill. Many homeowners have an impound account with their mortgage managed by a mortgage servicer to pay their annual property taxes on their behalf. Given the compressed time between the appeals deadline (September 15 or November 30) and the tax bill delinquency date (December 10), it would be difficult for a new tax bill to be prepared and issued in time for the property owner (or mortgage servicer) to timely pay the "undisputed" portion of the tax bill. How would the homeowner calculate their partial payment to avoid a delinquency penalty on the undisputed portion? Counties would need to coordinate between the clerk of the county board who processes the appeal application on behalf of the county board, the county auditor who must calculate the new amounts due on the "non-disputed" amount, and the county tax collector who collects the taxes.
- Existing property taxpayer protections: To ensure the timely resolution of property tax appeals, the law provides that if the county board does not issue a determination on the taxpayer's assessment appeal within two years, the taxpayer effectively wins the appeal for that tax year. Specifically, the property taxes for that year will be based on the taxpayer's opinion of value as stated on the assessment appeal application filed. Additionally, the law provides that a taxpayer who ultimately receives a property tax reduction from the county appeals board will receive a refund with interest.
- Limited to owner-occupied homes: These provisions are limited to property the taxpayer "owns and occupies." For clarity, it would be preferable to instead reference property that is the taxpayer's principal place of residence and eligible for the homeowners' exemption. Statewide, about five million property owners are granted the homeowners' exemption.
- Lump sum payment if taxpayer does not prevail: Should a homeowner lose the appeal, this bill requires all previously disputed amounts to be due in one payment by the next November 1 or February 1, whichever comes first. If the final appeal decision covers multiple tax years, this could be a sizable tax liability and could create a financial hardship for the homeowner.
- Previous legislation: SB 494 (Maddy) and SB 1903 (Maddy), of the 1995-96 Legislative Session, proposed adding a provision of law to allow a taxpayer to elect not to pay the disputed portion of a property tax assessment under appeal until after the county board issues a final decision on the appeal of the assessed value if the taxpayer pays at least the amount of property tax assessed on the subject property for the immediately preceding fiscal year. The provision was deleted from SB 1903 by June 12, 1996 amendments and amended into SB 494 on July 10, 1996. SB 494 was then referred to the Assembly Revenue and Taxation Committee; the bill was not heard.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
None on file
Opposition
California Association of Clerks and Elections Officials
California State Association of Counties
California Tax Reform Association
Rural County Representatives of California
Santa Clara County Assessor
Urban Counties of California
Analysis Prepared by: Rose Marie Kinnee / REV. & TAX. / (916) 319-2098
Government Code Section 26906.1. ↑
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):