AB 1974: Horse racing: welfare and safety of racehorses and jockeys.
- Session Year: 2019-2020
- House: Assembly
- Latest Version Date: 2020-09-29
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Sep 29, 2020 | Chaptered by Secretary of State - Chapter 251, Statutes of 2020. |
| Sep 29, 2020 | Approved by the Governor. |
| Sep 10, 2020 | Enrolled and presented to the Governor at 2:30 p.m. |
| Aug 30, 2020 | In Assembly. Concurrence in Senate amendments pending. |
| Aug 30, 2020 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Assembly. (Ayes 39. Noes 0.). |
| Aug 25, 2020 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| Aug 24, 2020 | Read third time and amended. Ordered to second reading. |
| Aug 20, 2020 | From committee: Do pass. (Ayes 7. Noes 0.) (August 20). |
| Aug 19, 2020 | In committee: Referred to APPR. suspense file. |
| Aug 14, 2020 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 16. Noes 0.) (August 14). Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Aug 7, 2020 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to committee. Read second time, amended, and re-referred to Com. on G.O. |
| Jul 1, 2020 | Referred to Com. on G.O. |
| Jun 11, 2020 | In Senate. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. |
| Jun 10, 2020 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Senate. (Ayes 78. Noes 0. Page 4782.) |
| Jun 8, 2020 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| Jun 4, 2020 | Read second time and amended. Ordered returned to second reading. |
| Jun 3, 2020 | From committee: Amend, and do pass as amended. (Ayes 18. Noes 0.) (June 3). |
| Jun 2, 2020 | In committee: Set, first hearing. Referred to APPR. suspense file. |
| May 13, 2020 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 19. Noes 0.) (May 12). Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| May 5, 2020 | Re-referred to Com. on G.O. |
| May 4, 2020 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to Com. on G.O. Read second time and amended. |
| Apr 24, 2020 | Referred to Com. on G.O. |
| Jan 23, 2020 | From printer. May be heard in committee February 22. |
| Jan 22, 2020 | Read first time. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Aug 30, 2020 | AB 1974 Gray Concurrence in Senate Amendments | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| Aug 30, 2020 | Assembly 3rd Reading AB1974 Gray et al. By Dodd | Senate Floor |
Passed |
|
| Aug 20, 2020 | Do pass | Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Aug 19, 2020 | Placed on suspense file | Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Aug 14, 2020 | Do pass, but first be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Senate Standing Committee on Governmental Organization |
Passed |
|
| Jun 10, 2020 | AB 1974 Gray Assembly Third Reading | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| Jun 3, 2020 | Do pass as amended. | Assembly Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| May 12, 2020 | Do pass and be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Assembly Standing Committee on Governmental Organization |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
CONCURRENCE IN SENATE AMENDMENTS
CSA1 Bill Id:AB 1974
Author:(Gray and Chau)
As Amended Ver:August 24, 2020
2/3 vote
SUMMARY:
This bill makes various changes to the Horse Racing Law by imposing new and additional horse racing health and safety requirements to be enforced by the California Horse Racing Board (CHRB), and codifies with certain modifications existing horse racing health and safety standards and regulations.
The Senate Amendments:
- Require the CHRB to establish and maintain a whistleblower program through which an owner, trainer, jockey, or stable-area employee may call designated persons under strict confidentiality to report questionable activity or concerns relating to the health and safety of humans or horses under existing law.
- Prohibit a trainer from applying to a horse's feet on racing day any type of topical medication designed to alleviate pain, soreness, or tenderness of a horse's feet.
- Authorize, at the discretion of track stewards, the video surveillance of horses that ship in on racing days for purposes of monitoring compliance with the Horse Racing Law.
- Clarify that horses at a licensed quarter horse race meet will be subject to veterinary monitoring during morning training, as specified.
- Clarify that it is responsibility of the official veterinarian or the equine medical director's designee to ensure a racehorse is fit to race, as specified.
- Reposition the Horse and Jockey Safety and Welfare Account within the State Treasury.
- Add joint author and coauthors.
COMMENTS:
Horse racing in California. Horse racing has been taking place in California since the 1800s, but horse racing as we now know it – under the pari-mutuel wagering system – was not made possible until the electorate passed a constitutional amendment in 1933. To regulate and carryout the stated objectives in Horse Racing Law, the constitutional amendment established the CHRB. The stated mission of the CHRB is to ensure the integrity, viability, and safety of the California horse racing industry by, among other things, fostering safe racing through the development and enforcement of track safety standards and regulations for the health and welfare of all participants. There are over 17,000 licensed jobs tied to the horse racing industry in California, and according to the CHRB's Annual Report 2018-2019, the pari-mutuel handle totaled over $2.9 billion.
There are currently four privately operated racetracks, five racing fairs, and one training-only facility licensed and operating in California. Additionally, there are 28 non-track satellite-wagering facilities located throughout the state in tribal casinos, sports bars, restaurants, card clubs, and other businesses. All locations, except for the training-only facility and the Humboldt County Fair are open to the public during their off-seasons for simulcast wagering, which is the process of transmitting the audio and video signal of a live racing performance from one facility to a satellite for re-transmission to other locations or venues where pari-mutual wagering is permitted. Horse racing in California can generally be broken into four categories: Thoroughbred race meets; Quarter Horse race meets; harness race meets; and, State and county fair race meets.
The CHRB monitors equine safety measures and protocols within licensed facilities through official veterinarians, safety stewards, the Equine Medical Director (EMD), and the CHRB/University of California, Davis (UC Davis) postmortem program. Under existing law, the CHRB is required to among other things, establish safety standards governing the uniformity and content of the track base and racing surface, inner and outer rails, gates and gaps, turf, access and egress to the track, lighting for night racing, equipment for horse and rider, drainage, communications, veterinary services, medical and ambulance services, and other track facilities to improve the safety of horses, riders, and workers at the racetrack.
An unusual increase in equine fatalities occurred in the winter and spring 2018-2019 season at Santa Anita Park, which increased focus on animal protection in California and made national headlines. A number of critics blamed the racing surfaces at Santa Anita, which had endured heavier than normal rainfall which created maintenance problems. Experts were brought in to study and do work on the main track to ensure that it was as safe as possible for racing and training. This required a series of closures that temporarily halted racing and training.
Management also introduced new safety measures. Governor Newsom also directed the CHRB to create a panel of CHRB veterinarians and stewards to review the medical, training, and racing histories of each horse entered in a race, empowered to recommend to the stewards that they reject horses deemed unfit to run. In addition, SB 469 (Dodd, Chapter 22, Statutes of 2019) was signed into law by Governor Newsom and took immediate effect in June 2019. The bill authorized the CHRB to immediately suspend a license to conduct a horse racing meeting when necessary to protect the health and safety of horses and riders and the board adopted emergency regulations to implement the measure. The above-mentioned safety measures and protocols resulted in a reduction but not the total elimination of horse fatalities.
California's Racing Safety Program. The CHRB initiated the Racing Safety Program (CHRB RSP) in July 2010 to address the requirements of the Business and Professions Code and to reduce the incidence of debilitating and fatal injuries at California race tracks and training facilities. The CHRB RSP focuses on: 1) Continuing education for trainers; 2) Implementation of the Microchip Program; 3) The Track Safety Standards Program; 4) Medication Rules and Regulations Reform; 5) The UC Davis California Animal Health and Food Safety Laboratory System Postmortem Program; 6) Fatality investigations and necropsy reviews; and, 7) Governor's Panel for review of race entries.
The CHRB assigns Safety Stewards to each racetrack to enforce rules and procedures designed to ensure the health and safety of racehorses. This responsibility requires them to spend considerable time in stable areas and racetrack monitoring environmental safety and proper treatment of horses.
According to the CHRB, "FY 2018-19 had the second-lowest number of total fatalities since 1990 when comprehensive records of all fatalities became available. The reduction in racing and training fatalities was the culmination of years of effort, making the tragic cluster of fatalities in January and February especially disheartening."
The CHRB's Annual Report 2018-2019 included a statement from the Board's Chairman Dr. Gregory Ferraro, which stated, "The numerous fatalities at Santa Anita have been especially disheartening because up until last winter we had made significant strides in reducing equine fatalities—reduced by nearly 60 percent over the previous 13 years, we had hoped the declining trend would continue. But the stark reality is that we still have much more to do in order to protect horses and riders."
This bill makes various changes to the Horse Racing Law by imposing new and additional horse racing health and safety requirements to be enforced by the CHRB, and codifies various existing horse racing health and safety regulations.
According to the Author:
According to the author's office, "Horse racing in California has a long and storied history. The industry provides billions of dollars to California's economy, and supports tens of thousands of direct and indirect jobs throughout the state. California has continually led the nation in adoption of health and safety standards, and is home to the world's premier equine chemistry laboratory, the Maddy Lab at the University of California, Davis. The last 18 months have been extremely challenging for California's horse racing industry from the unusual increase in equine fatalities that occurred in early 2019 to the recent economic hardship caused by the current pandemic. But in both cases, the industry faced these challenges head-on with determination and resolve by adopting comprehensive changes and protocols that advanced the safety and welfare of horse and rider.
The author notes "that in response to the recent equine safety crisis, California's racing industry and the CHRB adopted stringent rules, regulations, and protocols from medication reform, advanced veterinarian screening, track maintenance—including special measures during rain or extreme weather conditions, and the use of high-tech diagnostic equipment, including PET and MRI machines. These wide-ranging changes and protocols have led to safer racing after the spike in fatal breakdowns at Santa Anita during the 2019 race meet. It should be noted though that these efforts resulted in a reduction but not the total elimination of horse fatalities."
The author believes that "California's horse racing industry, like many industries, must be willing to accept and adopt forward-thinking solutions to address long-standing issues and debates, as the health and welfare of the sport's human and equine athletes are paramount to the future of this agribusiness. AB 1974 will further strengthen California's Horse Racing Law with proactive measures which will allow for the safest environment for human and equine participants and be a model for other states to follow."
Arguments in Support:
In support of this bill, the California Authority of Racing Fairs (CARF) writes that the "Fair racing circuit has always taken pride in its record of horse safety and places a high priority on the welfare of these animals. AB 1974 strengthens the state's commitment to horse welfare by requiring veterinary monitoring during morning training sessions. This along with the other provisions of the bill aligns with CARF's mission to offer the safest forum for horseracing in the country."
Arguments in Opposition:
In opposition to this bill, Social Compassion in Legislation (SCL) writes "the provisions in AB 1974 are not strong enough to ensure the welfare and safety that leads to saving horses' lives. First and foremost, trainers who continually over medicate their horses must be properly held accountable and there must be a requirement for equipment that will expose preexisting conditions that are precursors to breakdowns and ultimately euthanasia.
FISCAL COMMENTS:
According to the Senate Appropriation Committee analysis, the CHRB reports an annual shift of $800,000 to $1.16 million from the General Fund to the newly created Horse and Jockey Safety and Welfare Account. The CHRB receives approximately $200,000 to $260,000 in penalties revenue. Additionally, the CHRB receives approximately $800,000 to $900,000 per year in occupational license fee revenue.
VOTES:
ASM GOVERNMENTAL ORGANIZATION: 19-0-2
YES: Gray, Bigelow, Aguiar-Curry, Berman, Bonta, Brough, Cooley, Daly, Gallagher, Eduardo Garcia, Gipson, Jones-Sawyer, Lackey, Low, Mathis, Melendez, Robert Rivas, Blanca Rubio, Salas
ABS, ABST OR NV: Cooper, Quirk-Silva
ASM APPROPRIATIONS: 18-0-0
YES: Gonzalez, Bigelow, Bauer-Kahan, Bloom, Bonta, Calderon, Carrillo, Chau, Megan Dahle, Diep, Eggman, Fong, Gabriel, Eduardo Garcia, Petrie-Norris, McCarty, Robert Rivas, Voepel
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 78-0-1
YES: Aguiar-Curry, Arambula, Bauer-Kahan, Berman, Bigelow, Bloom, Boerner Horvath, Bonta, Brough, Burke, Calderon, Carrillo, Cervantes, Chau, Chen, Chiu, Choi, Chu, Cooley, Cooper, Cunningham, Megan Dahle, Daly, Diep, Eggman, Flora, Fong, Frazier, Friedman, Gabriel, Gallagher, Cristina Garcia, Eduardo Garcia, Gipson, Gloria, Gonzalez, Gray, Grayson, Holden, Irwin, Jones-Sawyer, Kalra, Kamlager, Kiley, Lackey, Levine, Limón, Low, Maienschein, Mathis, Mayes, McCarty, Medina, Mullin, Muratsuchi, Nazarian, O'Donnell, Obernolte, Patterson, Petrie-Norris, Quirk-Silva, Ramos, Reyes, Luz Rivas, Robert Rivas, Rodriguez, Blanca Rubio, Salas, Santiago, Smith, Mark Stone, Ting, Voepel, Waldron, Weber, Wicks, Wood, Rendon
ABS, ABST OR NV: Quirk
SENATE FLOOR: 39-0-1
YES: Allen, Archuleta, Atkins, Bates, Beall, Borgeas, Bradford, Caballero, Chang, Dahle, Dodd, Durazo, Galgiani, Glazer, Lena Gonzalez, Grove, Hertzberg, Hill, Hueso, Hurtado, Jackson, Leyva, McGuire, Melendez, Mitchell, Monning, Moorlach, Morrell, Nielsen, Pan, Portantino, Roth, Rubio, Skinner, Stern, Umberg, Wieckowski, Wiener, Wilk
ABS, ABST OR NV: Jones
UPDATED:
VERSION: August 24, 2020
CONSULTANT: Eric Johnson / G.O. / (916) 319-2531 FN: 0003503
SENATE RULES COMMITTEE Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | AB 1974 |
THIRD READING
Bill No: AB 1974
Author: Gray (D), Chau (D), et al.
Amended: 8/24/20 in Senate
Vote: 27
SENATE GOVERNMENTAL ORG. COMMITTEE: 16-0, 8/14/20
AYES: Dodd, Wilk, Allen, Archuleta, Borgeas, Bradford, Chang, Galgiani, Glazer, Hill, Hueso, Jones, Nielsen, Portantino, Rubio, Wiener
SENATE APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE: 7-0, 8/20/20
AYES: Portantino, Bates, Bradford, Hill, Jones, Leyva, Wieckowski
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 78-0, 6/10/20 - See last page for vote
SUBJECT: Horse racing: welfare and safety of racehorses and jockeys
SOURCE: Author
DIGEST:
This bill makes various changes to the Horse Racing Law by imposing new and additional horse racing health and safety requirements to be enforced by the California Horse Racing Board (CHRB), and codifies various existing horse racing health and safety regulations.
Senate Floor Amendments of 8/24/20 clarify that it is responsibility of the official veterinarian or the equine medical director to ensure a racehorse is fit to race, as specified; move the Horse and Jockey Safety and Welfare Account to the State Treasury; and, add coauthors.
ANALYSIS:
Existing law:
- Provides, under Article IV, Section 19(b) of the Constitution of the State of California, that the Legislature may provide for the regulation of horse races and horse race meetings, and wagering on the results; and, grants the CHRB all powers necessary and proper to enable it to carry out fully and effectually the purposes of the Horse Racing Law.
- Requires the CHRB to adopt regulations to establish policies, guidelines, and penalties relating to equine medication in order to preserve and enhance the integrity of horse racing in the state.
This bill:
- Adds to the CHRB’s existing responsibilities that the board adopt rules and regulations that protect and advance the health, safety, welfare, and aftercare of racehorses.
- Provides that, at the discretion of track stewards, horses that ship in on racing days may be subject to video surveillance for purposes of monitoring compliance with existing law.
- Provides that horses that are unsound or lame be subject to immediate placement on the Veterinarian’s List with criteria for removal that may include diagnostic imaging, examination of blood, and counsel with attending veterinarians. A horse placed on the Veterinarian’s List as unsound or lame shall be removed from the list only after having established or demonstrated to the satisfaction of the official veterinarian that the horse is then raceably sound and in fit physical condition to exert its best effort in a race.
- Prohibits a horse placed on the Veterinarian’s List from being unsound or lame from working out for seven days after being placed on the list without the permission of the official veterinarian. The official veterinarian shall require any horse placed on the Veterinarian’s List to undergo a veterinary examination that may include diagnostic imaging before resuming training at any facility under the jurisdiction of the CHRB.
- Provides that a horse placed on the Veterinarian’s List as unsound or lame shall stay on the list for a specified minimum number of days before the horse is eligible to be removed from the list.
- Provides that a thoroughbred or quarter horse that is four years of age or older that has not competed in a race or has previously raced but has not raced in the preceding 365 days shall not be allowed to race, unless the horse has passed an examination and a postwork official blood test or tests required by the official veterinarian or the equine medical director, administered by the official veterinarian or the equine medical director’s designee. The horse shall race within 30 days after meeting these requirements.
- Provides that a thoroughbred or quarter horse that has not raced within 120 days but has raced within 365 days shall have an examination performed by the official veterinarian or the equine medical director’s designee within 14 days before entry. Based upon that examination, the official veterinarian or the equine medical director’s designee may require the horse to work before being allowed to enter in a race. If the horse is required to work, it shall meet the same requirements as a horse that is working to be taken off the Veterinarian’s List, as specified.
- Requires all horses at a licenses thoroughbred, fair, or quarter horse race meet be subject to veterinary monitoring during morning training. A licensed trainer and their staff shall be required to cooperate fully with all requests made by board-licensed veterinarians and outriders. All examining veterinarians at a race meet conducting live racing shall be under the direct supervision of the official veterinarian or the equine medical director.
- Prohibits a trainer from administering, directly or indirectly, or otherwise permitting to be administered, any medication to a horse under the trainer’s care that is racing or training at a board-approved racetrack, unless the medication is prescribed for that specific horse and administered strictly in accordance with board regulations.
- Prohibits a trainer from applying to a horse’s feet on racing day any type of topical medication designed to alleviate pain, soreness, or tenderness of a horse’s feet.
- Requires the use of diagnostic imaging to be an accepted component of prerace examinations by an examining veterinarian. The official veterinarian may order the diagnostic imaging if they believe that the use is warranted. In addition, video footage may be used and maintained by the official veterinarian for the purpose of comparison when a horse is removed from the Veterinarian’s List.
- Requires a racing association to provide a location within the inclosure where a horse can be observed jogging in a circle in both directions by the official veterinarian or the equine medical director’s designee, if needed, as part of the prerace examination process.
- Requires the CHRB to establish and maintain a whistleblower program through which an owner, trainer, jockey, or stable-area employee may call designated persons under strict confidentiality to report questionable activity or concerns relating to the health and safety of humans or horses under existing law.
- Creates the Horse and Jockey Safety and Welfare Account in the State Treasury for the deposit of specified moneys from license fees to be continuously appropriated to the CHRB for equine safety measures to improve the integrity and safety of horse racing.
- Requires all money from penalties or fines imposed by the stewards of a horse racing meeting be collected by the licensee of the meeting and paid to the CHRB within 10 business days after its close, for deposit in the Horse and Jockey Safety and Welfare Account established by this bill, as specified.
- Requires the CHRB to publicly disclose on its Internet website the horse welfare and safety measures it funds with the moneys in the Horse and Jockey Safety and Welfare Account, as specified.
Comments
Purpose of the bill. According to the author’s office, “horse racing in California has a long and storied history. The industry provides billions of dollars to California's economy, and supports tens of thousands of direct and indirect jobs throughout the state. California has continually led the nation in adoption of health and safety standards, and is home to the world's premier equine chemistry laboratory, the Maddy Lab at the University of California, Davis. The last 16 months have been extremely challenging for California’s horse racing industry from the unusual increase in equine fatalities that occurred in early 2019 to the recent economic hardship caused by the current pandemic. But in both cases, the industry faced these challenges head-on with determination and resolve by adopting comprehensive changes and protocols that not only advanced the safety and welfare of horses but jockeys and those that care for them as well.”
Horse racing in California. Horse racing has been taking place in California since the 1800s, but horse racing as we now know it – under the pari-mutuel wagering system – was not made possible until the electorate passed a constitutional amendment in 1933. To regulate and carryout the stated objectives in Horse Racing Law, the constitutional amendment established the CHRB. The stated mission of the CHRB is to ensure the integrity, viability, and safety of the California horse racing industry by, among other things, fostering safe racing through the development and enforcement of track safety standards and regulations for the health and welfare of all participants. There are over 17,000 licensed jobs tied to the horse racing industry in California, and according to the CHRB’s Annual Report 2018-2019, the pari-mutuel handle totaled over $2.9 billion.
There are currently four privately operated racetracks, five racing fairs, and one training-only facility licensed and operating in California. Additionally, there are 28 non-track satellite-wagering facilities located throughout the state in tribal casinos, sports bars, restaurants, card clubs, and other businesses. All locations, except for the training-only facility and the Humboldt County Fair are open to the public during their off-seasons for simulcast wagering, which is the process of transmitting the audio and video signal of a live racing performance from one facility to a satellite for re-transmission to other locations or venues where pari-mutual wagering is permitted. Horse racing in California can generally be broken into four categories: Thoroughbred race meets; Quarter Horse race meets; harness race meets; and, State and county fair race meets.
The CHRB monitors equine safety measures and protocols within licensed facilities through official veterinarians, safety stewards, the Equine Medical Director (EMD), and the CHRB/University of California, Davis (UC Davis) postmortem program. Under existing law, the CHRB is required to among other things, establish safety standards governing the uniformity and content of the track base and racing surface, inner and outer rails, gates and gaps, turf, access and egress to the track, lighting for night racing, equipment for horse and rider, drainage, communications, veterinary services, medical and ambulance services, and other track facilities to improve the safety of horses, riders, and workers at the racetrack.
An unusual increase in equine fatalities occurred in the winter and spring 2018-2019 season at Santa Anita Park, which increased focus on animal protection in California and made national headlines. A number of critics blamed the racing surfaces at Santa Anita, which had endured heavier than normal rainfall which created maintenance problems. Experts were brought in to study and do work on the main track to ensure that it was as safe as possible for racing and training. This required a series of closures that temporarily halted racing and training.
Management also introduced new safety measures. Additionally, Governor Newsom directed the CHRB to create a panel of CHRB veterinarians and stewards to review the medical, training, and racing histories of each horse entered in a race, empowered to recommend to the stewards that they reject horses deemed unfit to run. Those efforts resulted in a reduction but not the total elimination of horse deaths.
California’s Racing Safety Program. The CHRB initiated the Racing Safety Program (CHRB RSP) in July 2010 to address the requirements of the Business and Professions Code and to reduce the incidence of debilitating and fatal injuries at California race tracks and training facilities. The CHRB RSP focuses on: (1) Continuing education for trainers; (2) Implementation of the Microchip Program; (3) The Track Safety Standards Program; (4) Medication Rules and Regulations Reform; (5) The UC Davis California Animal Health and Food Safety Laboratory System Postmortem Program; (6) Fatality investigations and necropsy reviews; and, (7) Governor’s Panel for review of race entries.
The CHRB assigns Safety Stewards to each racetrack to enforce rules and procedures designed to ensure the health and safety of racehorses. This responsibility requires them to spend considerable time in stable areas and racetrack monitoring environmental safety and proper treatment of horses.
This bill makes various changes to the Horse Racing Law by imposing new and additional horse racing health and safety requirements to be enforced by the CHRB, and codifies various existing horse racing health and safety regulations.
Related/Prior Legislation
SB 800 (Dodd, 2020) authorizes veterinarians to make available the entire medical records of racehorses to specified parties involved in horse racing; requires the CHRB to publish on a weekly basis all horse fatalities that occur within a licensed facility, as specified; and requires the CHRB to post results of nonconfidential official racehorse drug test samples within five business days of the confirmed negative split sample test result, as specified. (Pending on the Assembly Floor)
AB 2177 (Kalra, 2020) would have, among other things, (1) required the CHRB to adopt rules and regulations for the welfare and safety of racehorses, as specified; (2) required specified licensed track operators to provide computerized tomography scanning equipment to detect potential horse injuries that shall be available onsite; (3) established an onsite central pharmacy; (4) prohibited training or races at least seven days after any sealing or reinforcement of the track, as specified; (5) authorized the CHRB to require racetracks to transition to high-quality synthetic surfaces, as specified; and (6) required the executive director of the CHRB to make drug test results publicly available. (Never heard in the Assembly Governmental Organization Committee)
AB 2615 (Chau, 2020) would have codified existing regulations requiring that, if a horse suffers a fatal injury on a racetrack in training or in competition, or dies or is euthanized within an area under the jurisdiction of the CHRB, the horse undergo a postmortem examination at a diagnostic laboratory that is under contract with the CHRB, as specified. (Never heard in the Assembly Governmental Organization Committee)
SB 469 (Dodd, Chapter 22, Statutes of 2019) authorized the CHRB to immediately suspend a license to conduct a horse racing meeting when necessary to protect the health and safety of horses and riders, as specified.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: Yes Fiscal Com.: Yes Local: Yes
According to the Senate Appropriations Committee, the CHRB reports an annual shift of $800,000 to $1.16 million from the General Fund to the newly created Horse and Jockey Safety and Welfare Account.
The CHRB receives approximately $200,000 to $260,000 in penalties revenue. Additionally, the CHRB receives approximately $800,000 to $900,000 per year in occupational license fee revenue.
SUPPORT: (Verified 8/24/20)
California Authority of Racing Fairs
California Teamsters Public Affairs Council
California Thoroughbred Breeders Association
Golden Bear Racing
SEIU California
OPPOSITION: (Verified 8/24/20)
Social Compassion in Legislation
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: In support of this bill, the California Authority of Racing Fairs (CARF) writes that the “Fair racing circuit has always taken pride in its record of horse safety and places a high priority on the welfare of these animals. AB 1974 strengthens the state’s commitment to horse welfare by requiring veterinary monitoring during morning training sessions. This along with the other provisions of the bill aligns with CARF’s mission to offer the safest forum for horseracing in the country.”
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION: In opposition to this bill, Social Compassion in Legislation (SCL) writes “the provisions in AB 1974 are not strong enough to ensure the welfare and safety that leads to saving horses’ lives. First and foremost, trainers who continually over medicate their horses must be properly held accountable and there must be a requirement for equipment that will expose preexisting conditions that are precursors to breakdowns and ultimately euthanasia. Recent polling by Probolsky Research showed that over 74% of California (83.4% of Democrats) support stronger regulations to protect the lives of racehorses. AB 1974 does not even leave the gate.”
Further, SCL states that, “AB 1974 has provisions the authors might consider reform, such as directing revenues towards horse welfare and safety measures, requiring all horses at board-approved tracks or training facilities be subject to veterinary monitoring during workouts and requiring space for a horse to move in a circle for examining veterinarians, to name a few. However, these provisions on their own will not make the difference that is needed unless coupled with the following: 1) Include quarter horses and Standardbreds; 2) Administration of drugs should only be allowed by veterinarians, not trainers; 3) Mandated and Defined Checklist for Removal from Veterinarians List; 4) Mandated pre-race CT Scan requirements; 5) Mandate Central Pharmacy for dispensing all medications; 6) Increase fines for medication violations and require the CHRB to suspend or revoke licenses for repeat offenders; 7) Installation of synthetic surfaces.”
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 78-0, 6/10/20
AYES: Aguiar-Curry, Arambula, Bauer-Kahan, Berman, Bigelow, Bloom, Boerner Horvath, Bonta, Brough, Burke, Calderon, Carrillo, Cervantes, Chau, Chen, Chiu, Choi, Chu, Cooley, Cooper, Cunningham, Megan Dahle, Daly, Diep, Eggman, Flora, Fong, Frazier, Friedman, Gabriel, Gallagher, Cristina Garcia, Eduardo Garcia, Gipson, Gloria, Gonzalez, Gray, Grayson, Holden, Irwin, Jones-Sawyer, Kalra, Kamlager, Kiley, Lackey, Levine, Limón, Low, Maienschein, Mathis, Mayes, McCarty, Medina, Mullin, Muratsuchi, Nazarian, Obernolte, O'Donnell, Patterson, Petrie-Norris, Quirk-Silva, Ramos, Reyes, Luz Rivas, Robert Rivas, Rodriguez, Blanca Rubio, Salas, Santiago, Smith, Mark Stone, Ting, Voepel, Waldron, Weber, Wicks, Wood, Rendon
NO VOTE RECORDED: Quirk
Prepared by: Brian Duke / G.O. / (916) 651-1530
8/25/20 15:24:47
**** END ****
SENATE RULES COMMITTEE Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | AB 1974 |
THIRD READING
Bill No: AB 1974
Author: Gray (D)
Amended: 8/7/20 in Senate
Vote: 27
SENATE GOVERNMENTAL ORG. COMMITTEE: 16-0, 8/14/20
AYES: Dodd, Wilk, Allen, Archuleta, Borgeas, Bradford, Chang, Galgiani, Glazer, Hill, Hueso, Jones, Nielsen, Portantino, Rubio, Wiener
SENATE APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE: 7-0, 8/20/20
AYES: Portantino, Bates, Bradford, Hill, Jones, Leyva, Wieckowski
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 78-0, 6/10/20 - See last page for vote
SUBJECT: Horse racing: welfare and safety of racehorses and jockeys
SOURCE: Author
DIGEST:
This bill makes various changes to the Horse Racing Law by imposing new and additional horse racing health and safety requirements to be enforced by the California Horse Racing Board (CHRB), and codifies various existing horse racing health and safety regulations.
ANALYSIS:
Existing law:
- Provides, under Article IV, Section 19(b) of the Constitution of the State of California, that the Legislature may provide for the regulation of horse races and horse race meetings, and wagering on the results; and, grants the CHRB all powers necessary and proper to enable it to carry out fully and effectually the purposes of the Horse Racing Law.
- Requires the CHRB to adopt regulations to establish policies, guidelines, and penalties relating to equine medication in order to preserve and enhance the integrity of horse racing in the state.
This bill:
- Adds, specifically, to the CHRB’s responsibilities that the board adopt rules and regulations that protect and advance the health, safety, welfare, and aftercare of racehorses.
- Provides that, at the discretion of track stewards, horses that ship in on racing days may be subject to video surveillance for purposes of monitoring compliance with existing law.
- Provides that horses that are unsound or lame are subject to immediate placement on the Veterinarian’s List with criteria for removal that may include diagnostic imaging, examination of blood, and counsel with attending veterinarians. A horse placed on the Veterinarian’s List as unsound or lame shall be removed from the list only after having established or demonstrated to the satisfaction of the official veterinarian that the horse is then raceably sound and in fit physical condition to exert its best effort in a race.
- Prohibits a horse placed on the Veterinarian’s List from being unsound or lame from working out for seven days after being placed on the list without the permission of the official veterinarian. The official veterinarian shall require any horse placed on the Veterinarian’s List to undergo a veterinary examination that may include diagnostic imaging before resuming training at any facility under the jurisdiction of the CHRB.
- Provides that a horse placed on the Veterinarian’s List as unsound or lame shall stay on the list for a specified minimum number of days before the horse is eligible to be removed from the list.
- Prohibits a trainer from entering into any race a thoroughbred or quarter horse that is four years of age or older that has not competed in a race or has not raced in the preceding 365 days, unless the horse has passed an examination by a board-licensed veterinarian and has successfully passed a postwork official blood test.
- Provides that a thoroughbred or quarter horse that has not raced within 120 days but has raced within 365 days shall have an examination performed by a board-licensed veterinarian within seven days before entry. Based upon that examination, the board-licensed veterinarian may require the horse to work before being allowed to enter in a race. If the horse is required to work, it shall meet the same requirements as a horse that is working to be taken off the Veterinarian’s List, as specified.
- Requires all horses at a licenses thoroughbred, fair, or quarter horse race meet be subject to veterinary monitoring during morning training. A licensed trainer and their staff shall be required to cooperate fully with all requests made by board-licensed veterinarians and outriders. All examining veterinarians at a race meet conducting live racing shall be under the direct supervision of the official veterinarian or the equine medical director.
- Prohibits a trainer from administering, directly or indirectly, or otherwise permitting to be administered, any medication to a horse under the trainer’s care that is racing or training at a board-approved racetrack, unless the medication is prescribed for that specific horse and administered strictly in accordance with board regulations.
- Prohibits a trainer from applying to a horse’s feet on racing day any type of topical medication designed to alleviate pain, soreness, or tenderness of a horse’s feet.
- Requires the use of diagnostic imaging to be an accepted component of prerace examinations by an examining veterinarian. The official veterinarian may order the diagnostic imaging if they believe that the use is warranted. In addition, video footage may be used and maintained by the official veterinarian for the purpose of comparison when a horse is removed from the Veterinarian’s List.
- Requires a racing association to provide a location within the inclosure where a horse can be observed jogging in a circle in both directions by an examining veterinarian, if needed, as part of the prerace examination process.
- Requires the CHRB to establish and maintain a whistleblower program through which an owner, trainer, jockey, or stable-area employee may call designated persons under strict confidentiality to report questionable activity or concerns relating to the health and safety of humans or horses under existing law.
- Creates the Horse and Jockey Safety and Welfare Account in the Fair and Exposition Fund for the deposit of specified moneys from license fees to be continuously appropriated to the CHRB for equine safety measures to improve the integrity and safety of horse racing.
- Requires all money from penalties or fines imposed by the stewards of a horse racing meeting be collected by the licensee of the meeting and paid to the CHRB within 10 business days after its close, for deposit in the Horse and Jockey Safety and Welfare Account established by this bill.
- Requires the CHRB to publicly disclose on its Internet website the horse welfare and safety measures it funds with the moneys in the Horse and Jockey Safety and Welfare Account, as specified.
Comments
Purpose of the bill. According to the author’s office, “horse racing in California has a long and storied history. The industry provides billions of dollars to California's economy, and supports tens of thousands of direct and indirect jobs throughout the state. California has continually led the nation in adoption of health and safety standards, and is home to the world's premier equine chemistry laboratory, the Maddy Lab at the University of California, Davis. The last 16 months have been extremely challenging for California’s horse racing industry from the unusual increase in equine fatalities that occurred in early 2019 to the recent economic hardship caused by the current pandemic. But in both cases, the industry faced these challenges head-on with determination and resolve by adopting comprehensive changes and protocols that not only advanced the safety and welfare of horses but jockeys and those that care for them as well.”
Horse racing in California. Horse racing has been taking place in California since the 1800s, but horse racing as we now know it – under the pari-mutuel wagering system – was not made possible until the electorate passed a constitutional amendment in 1933. To regulate and carryout the stated objectives in Horse Racing Law, the constitutional amendment established the CHRB. The stated mission of the CHRB is to ensure the integrity, viability, and safety of the California horse racing industry by, among other things, fostering safe racing through the development and enforcement of track safety standards and regulations for the health and welfare of all participants. There are over 17,000 licensed jobs tied to the horse racing industry in California, and according to the CHRB’s
Annual Report 2018-2019, the pari-mutuel handle totaled over $2.9 billion.
There are currently four privately operated racetracks, five racing fairs, and one training-only facility licensed and operating in California. Additionally, there are 28 non-track satellite-wagering facilities located throughout the state in tribal casinos, sports bars, restaurants, card clubs, and other businesses. All locations, except for the training-only facility and the Humboldt County Fair are open to the public during their off-seasons for simulcast wagering, which is the process of transmitting the audio and video signal of a live racing performance from one facility to a satellite for re-transmission to other locations or venues where pari-mutual wagering is permitted. Horse racing in California can generally be broken into four categories: Thoroughbred race meets; Quarter Horse race meets; harness race meets; and, State and county fair race meets.
The CHRB monitors equine safety measures and protocols within licensed facilities through official veterinarians, safety stewards, the Equine Medical Director (EMD), and the CHRB/University of California, Davis (UC Davis) postmortem program. Under existing law, the CHRB is required to among other things, establish safety standards governing the uniformity and content of the track base and racing surface, inner and outer rails, gates and gaps, turf, access and egress to the track, lighting for night racing, equipment for horse and rider, drainage, communications, veterinary services, medical and ambulance services, and other track facilities to improve the safety of horses, riders, and workers at the racetrack.
An unusual increase in equine fatalities occurred in the winter and spring 2018-2019 season at Santa Anita Park which increased focus on animal protection in California and made national headlines. A number of critics blamed the racing surfaces at Santa Anita which had endured heavier than normal rainfall which created maintenance problems. Experts were brought in to study and do work on the main track to ensure that it was as safe as possible for racing and training. This required a series of closures that temporarily halted racing and training.
Management also introduced new safety measures. Additionally, Governor Newsom directed the CHRB to create a panel of CHRB veterinarians and stewards to review the medical, training, and racing histories of each horse entered in a race, empowered to recommend to the stewards that they reject horses deemed unfit to run. Those efforts resulted in a reduction but not the total elimination of horse deaths.
California’s Racing Safety Program. The CHRB initiated the Racing Safety Program (CHRB RSP) in July 2010 to address the requirements of the Business and Professions Code and to reduce the incidence of debilitating and fatal injuries at California race tracks and training facilities. The CHRB RSP focuses on: (1) Continuing education for trainers; (2) Implementation of the Microchip Program; (3) The Track Safety Standards Program; (4) Medication Rules and Regulations Reform; (5) The UC Davis California Animal Health and Food Safety Laboratory System Postmortem Program; (6) Fatality investigations and necropsy reviews; and
(7) Governor’s Panel for review of race entries.
The CHRB assigns Safety Stewards to each racetrack to enforce rules and procedures designed to ensure the health and safety of racehorses. This responsibility requires them to spend considerable time in stable areas and race track monitoring environmental safety and proper treatment of horses.
This bill makes various changes to the Horse Racing Law by imposing new and additional horse racing health and safety requirements to be enforced by the CHRB, and codifies various existing horse racing health and safety regulations.
Related/Prior Legislation
SB 800 (Dodd, 2020) authorizes veterinarians to make available the entire medical records of racehorses to specified parties involved in horse racing; requires the CHRB to publish on a weekly basis all horse fatalities that occur within a licensed facility, as specified; and requires the CHRB to post results of nonconfidential official racehorse drug test samples within five business days of the confirmed negative split sample test result, as specified. (Pending on the Assembly Floor)
AB 2177 (Kalra, 2020) would have, among other things, (1) required the CHRB to adopt rules and regulations for the welfare and safety of racehorses, as specified; (2) required specified licensed track operators to provide computerized tomography scanning equipment to detect potential horse injuries that shall be available onsite; (3) established an onsite central pharmacy; (4) prohibited training or races at least seven days after any sealing or reinforcement of the track, as specified; (5) authorized the CHRB to require racetracks to transition to high-quality synthetic surfaces, as specified; and (6) required the executive director of the CHRB to make drug test results publicly available. (Never heard in the Assembly Governmental Organization Committee)
AB 2615 (Chau, 2020) would have codified existing regulations requiring that, if a horse suffers a fatal injury on a racetrack in training or in competition, or dies or is euthanized within an area under the jurisdiction of the CHRB, the horse undergo a postmortem examination at a diagnostic laboratory that is under contract with the CHRB, as specified. (Never heard in the Assembly Governmental Organization Committee)
SB 469 (Dodd, Chapter 22, Statutes of 2019) authorized the CHRB to immediately suspend a license to conduct a horse racing meeting when necessary to protect the health and safety of horses and riders, as specified.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: Yes Fiscal Com.: Yes Local: Yes
According to the Senate Appropriations Committee, the CHRB reports an annual shift of $800,000 to $1.16 million from the General Fund to the newly created Horse and Jockey Safety and Welfare Account.
The CHRB receives approximately $200,000 to $260,000 in penalties revenue. Additionally, the CHRB receives approximately $800,000 to $900,000 per year in occupational license fee revenue.
SUPPORT: (Verified 8/20/20)
California Authority of Racing Fairs
California Teamsters Public Affairs Council
California Thoroughbred Breeders Association
Golden Bear Racing
SEIU California
OPPOSITION: (Verified 8/20/20)
Social Compassion in Legislation
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: In support of this bill, the California Authority of Racing Fairs (CARF) writes that the “Fair racing circuit has always taken pride in its record of horse safety and places a high priority on the welfare of these animals. AB 1974 strengthens the state’s commitment to horse welfare by requiring veterinary monitoring during morning training sessions. This along with the other provisions of the bill aligns with CARF’s mission to offer the safest forum for horseracing in the country.”
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION: In opposition to this bill, Social Compassion in Legislation (SCL) writes “the provisions in AB 1974 are not strong enough to ensure the welfare and safety that leads to saving horses’ lives. First and foremost, trainers who continually over medicate their horses must be properly held accountable and there must be a requirement for equipment that will expose preexisting conditions that are precursors to breakdowns and ultimately euthanasia. Recent polling by Probolsky Research showed that over 74% of California (83.4% of Democrats) support stronger regulations to protect the lives of racehorses. AB 1974 does not even leave the gate.”
Further, SCL states that, “AB 1974 has provisions the authors might consider reform, such as directing revenues towards horse welfare and safety measures, requiring all horses at board-approved tracks or training facilities be subject to veterinary monitoring during workouts and requiring space for a horse to move in a circle for examining veterinarians, to name a few. However, these provisions on their own will not make the difference that is needed unless coupled with the following: 1) Include quarter horses and Standardbreds; 2) Administration of drugs should only be allowed by veterinarians, not trainers; 3) Mandated and Defined Checklist for Removal from Veterinarians List; 4) Mandated pre-race CT Scan requirements; 5) Mandate Central Pharmacy for dispensing all medications; 6) Increase fines for medication violations and require the CHRB to suspend or revoke licenses for repeat offenders; 7) Installation of synthetic surfaces.”
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 78-0, 6/10/20
AYES: Aguiar-Curry, Arambula, Bauer-Kahan, Berman, Bigelow, Bloom, Boerner Horvath, Bonta, Brough, Burke, Calderon, Carrillo, Cervantes, Chau, Chen, Chiu, Choi, Chu, Cooley, Cooper, Cunningham, Megan Dahle, Daly, Diep, Eggman, Flora, Fong, Frazier, Friedman, Gabriel, Gallagher, Cristina Garcia, Eduardo Garcia, Gipson, Gloria, Gonzalez, Gray, Grayson, Holden, Irwin, Jones-Sawyer, Kalra, Kamlager, Kiley, Lackey, Levine, Limón, Low, Maienschein, Mathis, Mayes, McCarty, Medina, Mullin, Muratsuchi, Nazarian, Obernolte, O'Donnell, Patterson, Petrie-Norris, Quirk-Silva, Ramos, Reyes, Luz Rivas, Robert Rivas, Rodriguez, Blanca Rubio, Salas, Santiago, Smith, Mark Stone, Ting, Voepel, Waldron, Weber, Wicks, Wood, Rendon
NO VOTE RECORDED: Quirk
Prepared by: Brian Duke / G.O. / (916) 651-1530
8/21/20 17:55:31
**** END ****
SENATE COMMITTEE ON
Senator Anthony Portantino, Chair
2019 - 2020 Regular Session
AB 1974 (Gray) - Horse racing: welfare and safety of racehorses and jockeys
Version: | Policy Vote: |
Urgency: | Mandate: |
Hearing Date: | Consultant: |
Bill Summary:
AB 1974 establishes new and additional horse racing health and safety requirements to be enforced by the California Horse Racing Bureau (CHRB) and establishes the Horse and Jockey Safety and Welfare Account in the Fair and Exposition Fund for equine safety measures and to improve horse racing safety.
Fiscal Impact:
The CHRB reports an annual shift of $800,000 to $1.16 million from the General Fund to the newly created Horse and Jockey Safety and Welfare Account.
The CHRB receives approximately $200,000 to $260,000 in penalties revenue. Additionally, the CHRB receives approximately $800,000 to $900,000 per year in occupational license fee revenue.
Background:
The CHRB monitors equine safety measures and protocols within licensed facilities through official veterinarians, safety stewards, the Equine Medical Director (EMD), and the CHRB/University of California, Davis (UC Davis) postmortem program. Under existing law, the CHRB is required to among other things, establish safety standards governing the uniformity and content of the track base and racing surface, inner and outer rails, gates and gaps, turf, access and egress to the track, lighting for night racing, equipment for horse and rider, drainage, communications, veterinary services, medical and ambulance services, and other track facilities to improve the safety of horses, riders, and workers at the racetrack.
The CHRB assigns Safety Stewards to each racetrack to enforce rules and procedures designed to ensure the health and safety of racehorses. This responsibility requires stewards to spend considerable time in stable areas and race tracks in order to monitor environmental safety and proper treatment of horses.
Proposed Law:
This bill:
- Authorizes track stewards to subject horses that ship in on racing days to video surveillance.
- Requires horses that are unsound or lame to be immediately placed on the Veterinarian’s List and establishes specified criteria around time periods when a horse must remain on the list.
- Authorizes the CHRB to adopt rules and regulations.
- Establishes criteria for examination of thoroughbreds and quarter horses to determine eligibility and appropriateness to enter a race.
- Requires all horses at licensed thoroughbred, fair, or quarter horse race meets to be subject to veterinary monitoring during morning training and establishes specified prohibitions on trainers for the application of medications.
- Requires a racing association to provide a location within the inclosure where a veterinarian can observe a horse jogging in a circle in both directions.
- Requires the CHRB to establish and maintain a whistleblower program.
- Establishes the Horse and Jockey Safety and Welfare Account in the Fair and Exposition Fund and authorizes money from license fees, fines, and penalities to be deposited into the account for the CHRB to enforce prescribed equine safety measures.
- Makes technical changes.
-- END --
SENATE COMMITTEE ON GOVERNMENTAL ORGANIZATION
Senator Bill Dodd
Chair
2019 - 2020 Regular
Bill No: AB Hearing Date: 8/14/2020
Author: | Gray | ||
Version: | Amended | ||
Urgency: | Fiscal: | ||
Consultant: | |||
SUBJECT:
DIGEST: This bill makes various changes to the Horse Racing Law by imposing new and additional horse racing health and safety requirements to be enforced by the California Horse Racing Board (CHRB), and codifies various existing horse racing health and safety regulations.
ANALYSIS:
Existing law:
- Article IV, Section 19(b) of the Constitution of the State of California provides that the Legislature may provide for the regulation of horse races and horse race meetings, and wagering on the results; and, grants the CHRB all powers necessary and proper to enable it to carry out fully and effectually the purposes of the Horse Racing Law.
- Requires the CHRB to adopt regulations to establish policies, guidelines, and penalties relating to equine medication in order to preserve and enhance the integrity of horse racing in the state.
- Requires every veterinarian who treats a horse within the inclosure to report, in writing, on a form prescribed by the CHRB, to the official veterinarian the name of the horse treated, the name of the trainer of the horse, the time of treatment, any medication administered to the horse, and any other information requested by the official veterinarian.
- Existing regulations require that horses that are injured, unsound, or lame are subject to immediate placement on the Veterinarian’s List with criteria for removal that may include diagnostic imaging, examination of blood, and counsel with attending veterinarians and that such a horse is prohibited from working out for 72 hours after being placed on the list without the permission of the official veterinarian.
- Existing regulations establish conditions for removal of a horse from the Veterinarian’s List and require that a horse determined to be unsound or lame for the first, second, third, or fourth time in a 365-day period is ineligible to be removed from the list for a specified period of time.
- Requires all money representing penalties or fines imposed by the stewards of a horse race meeting to be collected by the licensee of the meeting and paid to the CHRB, as specified, for deposit in the State Treasury to the credit of the General Fund.
This bill:
- Specifically adds to the CHRB’s responsibilities that the board adopt rules and regulations that protect and advance the health, safety, welfare, and aftercare of racehorses.
- Provides that, at the discretion of track stewards, horses that ship in on racing days may be subject to video surveillance for purposes of monitoring compliance with existing law.
- Provides that horses that are unsound or lame are subject to immediate placement on the Veterinarian’s List with criteria for removal that may include diagnostic imaging, examination of blood, and counsel with attending veterinarians. A horse placed on the Veterinarian’s List as unsound or lame shall be removed from the list only after having established or demonstrated to the satisfaction of the official veterinarian that the horse is then raceably sound and in fit physical condition to exert its best effort in a race.
- Prohibits a horse placed on the Veterinarian’s List from being unsound or lame from working out for seven days after being placed on the list without the permission of the official veterinarian. The official veterinarian shall require any horse placed on the Veterinarian’s List to undergo a veterinary examination that may include diagnostic imaging before resuming training at any facility under the jurisdiction of the CHRB.
- Provides that a horse placed on the Veterinarian’s List as unsound or lame shall stay on the list for a specified minimum number of days before the horse is eligible to be removed from the list.
- Prohibits a trainer from entering into any race a thoroughbred or quarter horse that is four years of age or older that has not competed in a race or has not raced in the preceding 365 days, unless the horse has passed an examination by a board-licensed veterinarian and has successfully passed a postwork official blood test.
- Provides that a thoroughbred or quarter horse that has not raced within 120 days but has raced within 365 days shall have an examination performed by a board-licensed veterinarian within seven days before entry. Based upon that examination, the board-licensed veterinarian may require the horse to work before being allowed to enter in a race. If the horse is required to work, it shall meet the same requirements as a horse that is working to be taken off the Veterinarian’s List, as specified.
- Requires all horses at a licenses thoroughbred, fair, or quarter horse race meet be subject to veterinary monitoring during morning training. A licensed trainer and their staff shall be required to cooperate fully with all requests made by board-licensed veterinarians and outriders. All examining veterinarians at a race meet conducting live racing shall be under the direct supervision of the official veterinarian or the equine medical director.
- Prohibits a trainer from administering, directly or indirectly, or otherwise permitting to be administered, any medication to a horse under the trainer’s care that is racing or training at a board-approved racetrack, unless the medication is prescribed for that specific horse and administered strictly in accordance with board regulations.
- Prohibits a trainer from applying to a horse’s feet on racing day any type of topical medication designed to alleviate pain, soreness, or tenderness of a horse’s feet.
- Requires the use of diagnostic imaging to be an accepted component of prerace examinations by an examining veterinarian. The official veterinarian may order the diagnostic imaging if they believe that the use is warranted. In addition, video footage may be used and maintained by the official veterinarian for the purpose of comparison when a horse is removed from the Veterinarian’s List.
- Requires a racing association to provide a location within the inclosure where a horse can be observed jogging in a circle in both directions by an examining veterinarian, if needed, as part of the prerace examination process.
- Requires the CHRB to establish and maintain a whistleblower program through which an owner, trainer, jockey, or stable-area employee may call designated persons under strict confidentiality to report questionable activity or concerns relating to the health and safety of humans or horses under existing law.
- Creates the Horse and Jockey Safety and Welfare Account in the Fair and Exposition Fund for the deposit of specified moneys from license fees to be continuously appropriated to the CHRB for equine safety measures to improve the integrity and safety of horse racing.
- Requires all money from penalties or fines imposed by the stewards of a horse racing meeting be collected by the licensee of the meeting and paid to the CHRB within 10 business days after its close, for deposit in the Horse and Jockey Safety and Welfare Account established by this bill.
- Requires the CHRB to publicly disclose on its internet website the horse welfare and safety measures it funds with the moneys in the Horse and Jockey Safety and Welfare Account, as specified.
Background
Purpose of the bill. According to the author’s office, “horse racing in California has a long and storied history. The industry provides billions of dollars to California's economy, and supports tens of thousands of direct and indirect jobs throughout the state. California has continually led the nation in adoption of health and safety standards, and is home to the world's premier equine chemistry laboratory, the Maddy Lab at the University of California, Davis. The last 16 months have been extremely challenging for California’s horse racing industry from the unusual increase in equine fatalities that occurred in early 2019 to the recent economic hardship caused by the current pandemic. But in both cases, the industry faced these challenges head-on with determination and resolve by adopting comprehensive changes and protocols that not only advanced the safety and welfare of horses but jockeys and those that care for them as well.”
Horse racing in California. Horse racing has been taking place in California since the 1800s, but horse racing as we now know it – under the pari-mutuel wagering system – was not made possible until the electorate passed a constitutional amendment in 1933. To regulate and carryout the stated objectives in Horse Racing Law, the constitutional amendment established the CHRB. The stated mission of the CHRB is to ensure the integrity, viability, and safety of the California horse racing industry by, among other things, fostering safe racing through the development and enforcement of track safety standards and regulations for the health and welfare of all participants. There are over 17,000 licensed jobs tied to the horse racing industry in California, and according to the CHRB’s
Annual Report 2018-2019, the pari-mutuel handle totaled over $2.9 billion.
There are currently four privately operated racetracks, five racing fairs, and one training-only facility licensed and operating in California. Additionally, there are 28 non-track satellite-wagering facilities located throughout the state in tribal casinos, sports bars, restaurants, card clubs, and other businesses. All locations, except for the training-only facility and the Humboldt County Fair are open to the public during their off-seasons for simulcast wagering, which is the process of transmitting the audio and video signal of a live racing performance from one facility to a satellite for re-transmission to other locations or venues where pari-mutual wagering is permitted. Horse racing in California can generally be broken into four categories: Thoroughbred race meets; Quarter Horse race meets; harness race meets; and, State and county fair race meets.
The CHRB monitors equine safety measures and protocols within licensed facilities through official veterinarians, safety stewards, the Equine Medical Director (EMD), and the CHRB/University of California, Davis (UC Davis) postmortem program. Under existing law, the CHRB is required to among other things, establish safety standards governing the uniformity and content of the track base and racing surface, inner and outer rails, gates and gaps, turf, access and egress to the track, lighting for night racing, equipment for horse and rider, drainage, communications, veterinary services, medical and ambulance services, and other track facilities to improve the safety of horses, riders, and workers at the racetrack.
An unusual increase in equine fatalities occurred in the winter and spring 2018-2019 season at Santa Anita Park which increased focus on animal protection in California and made national headlines. A number of critics blamed the racing surfaces at Santa Anita which had endured heavier than normal rainfall which created maintenance problems. Experts were brought in to study and do work on the main track to ensure that it was as safe as possible for racing and training. This required a series of closures that temporarily halted racing and training.
Management also introduced new safety measures. Additionally, Governor Newsom directed the CHRB to create a panel of CHRB veterinarians and stewards to review the medical, training, and racing histories of each horse entered in a race, empowered to recommend to the stewards that they reject horses deemed unfit to run. Those efforts resulted in a reduction but not the total elimination of horse deaths.
California’s Racing Safety Program. The CHRB initiated the Racing Safety Program (CHRB RSP) in July 2010 to address the requirements of the Business and Professions Code and to reduce the incidence of debilitating and fatal injuries at California race tracks and training facilities. The CHRB RSP focuses on: 1) Continuing education for trainers; 2) Implementation of the Microchip Program; 3) The Track Safety Standards Program; 4) Medication Rules and Regulations Reform; 5) The UC Davis California Animal Health and Food Safety Laboratory System Postmortem Program; 6) Fatality investigations and necropsy reviews; and 7) Governor’s Panel for review of race entries.
The CHRB assigns Safety Stewards to each racetrack to enforce rules and procedures designed to ensure the health and safety of racehorses. This responsibility requires them to spend considerable time in stable areas and race track monitoring environmental safety and proper treatment of horses.
CHRB and Los Angeles District Attorney’s Office investigations. Following the unusual increase in equine fatalities during Santa Anita’s 2018-2019 winter and spring meet, two separate reports were produced. The CHRB initiated an investigation into each of the 23 fatalities that occurred during the unusually rainy weather between December 30, 2018, and March 31, 2019. The Los Angeles District Attorney’s (LADA) office formed the Santa Anita Task Force (Task Force) to investigate and review the racing and training fatalities at Santa Anita Park for evidence of animal cruelty and criminal activity on 56 equine fatalities from July 8, 2018, to November 2, 2019.
The CHRB investigation into the initial 23 fatalities at Santa Anita looks back at the circumstances and causes of each fatality, and looks forward using its findings to make recommendations. Key findings of the CHRB investigation include: no illegal medications or procedures were uncovered; 21 horses had evidence of pre-existing pathology at the site of their fatal injury; a high majority (14 of 22) of the catastrophic musculoskeletal injuries (CMI) cases exhibited a high intensity exercise profile followed by a decline in activity in the month prior to CMI; and the data suggests that 39% of fatalities occurred on surfaces affected by wet weather.
The LADA Task Force concentrated its review on CHRB fatality reports and documents as well as statements from witnesses, industry stakeholders, and experts. The Task Force reviewed hundreds of documents including necropsies, veterinarian records, training records, and medication records related to the deaths and conducted numerous in-person interviews of current and former track maintenance experts, Santa Anita executives and employees, Jockey Guild and California Thoroughbred Trainers Association representatives, CHRB officials, jockeys, owners, trainers, and veterinarians.
According to the Task Force’s report, “[a]fter an exhaustive evidentiary investigation, the District Attorney Task Force determined there was insufficient evidence to prove criminal animal cruelty or other unlawful conduct under California law.” While the Task Force did not uncover sufficient evidence of animal cruelty on the part of Santa Anita Park or any individual trainer, owner, or jockey, the Task Force did identify several areas of concern and possible factors that may have contributed to deaths. The Task Force probed the following areas: medication, track conditions, running injured horses, and pressure to race. The report identified a number of recommended best practices derived from and supported by experts and stakeholders, to improve safety and reduce fatalities in horseracing.
Santa Anita officials have repeatedly insisted the track has implemented a wide array of safety measures at the track to protect horses. They state that the track boasts one of the best safety records in the industry, noting that horses raced or trained at the facility more than 420,000 times in 2019 with a 99.91% safety rate.
Pending Federal Legislation. The Horse Racing Integrity Act of 2019, H.R. 1754, introduced in March 2019, would create a private, independent, horse racing anti-doping authority responsible for developing and administering a nationwide anti-doping and medication control program. The program would be administered by the United States Anti-Doping Agency (HADA), the body responsible for administering anti-doping programs for human athletes including the U.S. Olympic teams.
The HADA board would include six individuals with horse racing expertise and seven individuals from USADA. It would create uniform drug and medication rules, including lists of permitted and prohibited substances and methods in line with international anti-doping standards and veterinarian ethical standards. The nationwide standards would replace the state-to-state regulation of these issues. The bill is pending in the House Subcommittee on Consumer Protection and Commerce.
Prior/Related Legislation
SB 800 (Dodd, 2020) would authorize veterinarians to make available the entire medical records of racehorses to specified parties involved in horse racing; requires the CHRB to publish on a weekly basis all horse fatalities that occur within a licensed facility, as specified; and requires the CHRB to post results of nonconfidential official racehorse drug test samples within five business days of the confirmed negative split sample test result, as specified. (Pending on the Assembly Floor)
AB 2177 (Kalra, 2020) would, among other things, require the CHRB to adopt rules and regulations for the welfare and safety of racehorses, as specified; require specified licensed track operators to provide computerized tomography scanning equipment to detect potential horse injuries that shall be available onsite; establish an onsite central pharmacy; prohibit training or races at least seven days after any sealing or reinforcement of the track, as specified; authorize the CHRB to require racetracks to transition to high-quality synthetic surfaces, as specified; and require the executive director of the CHRB to make drug test results publicly available. (Never heard in the Assembly Governmental Organization Committee)
AB 2615 (Chau, 2020) would codify existing regulations requiring that, if a horse suffers a fatal injury on a racetrack in training or in competition, or dies or is euthanized within an area under the jurisdiction of the CHRB, the horse undergo a postmortem examination at a diagnostic laboratory that is under contract with the CHRB, as specified. (Never heard in the Assembly Governmental Organization Committee)
SB 469 (Dodd, Chapter 22, Statutes of 2019) authorized the CHRB to immediately suspend a license to conduct a horse racing meeting when necessary to protect the health and safety of horses and riders, as specified.
AB 128 (Gloria, Chapter 765, Statutes of 2019) would make it unlawful for any person to possess, sell, buy, give away, hold, or accept any horse if that person knows or should know that the animal will be killed for any commercial purpose.
AB 482 (Quirk, 2019) would authorize the CHRB to allow for races previously scheduled for daytime hours to be run in the evening when the proposed start time temperatures present a serious risk to horses, jockeys, or other backstretch employees, as specified. (Never heard in the Assembly Governmental Organization Committee)
AB 771 (Rubio, 2019) would make it a felony for any person to directly or indirectly hold or conduct any for-profit horse racing meeting without the proper licenses or approval from the CHRB. (Never heard in the Assembly Governmental Organization Committee)
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: Yes Fiscal Com.: Yes Local: Yes
SUPPORT:
California Authority of Racing Fairs
California Teamsters Public Affairs Council
California Thoroughbred Breeders Association
Golden Bear Racing
SEIU California
OPPOSITION:
Social Compassion in Legislation
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: In support of the bill, the California Authority of Racing Fairs (CARF) writes that the “Fair racing circuit has always taken pride in its record of horse safety and places a high priority on the welfare of these animals. AB 1974 strengthens the state’s commitment to horse welfare by requiring veterinary monitoring during morning training sessions. This along with the other provisions of the bill aligns with CARF’s mission to offer the safest forum for horseracing in the country.”
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION: In opposition to the bill, Social Compassion in Legislation (SCL) writes “the provisions in AB 1974 are not strong enough to ensure the welfare and safety that leads to saving horses’ lives. First and foremost, trainers who continually over medicate their horses must be properly held accountable and there must be a requirement for equipment that will expose preexisting conditions that are precursors to breakdowns and ultimately euthanasia. Recent polling by Probolsky Research showed that over 74% of California (83.4% of Democrats) support stronger regulations to protect the lives of racehorses. AB 1974 does not even leave the gate.”
Further, SCL states that, “AB 1974 has provisions the authors might consider reform, such as directing revenues towards horse welfare and safety measures, requiring all horses at board-approved tracks or training facilities be subject to veterinary monitoring during workouts and requiring space for a horse to move in a circle for examining veterinarians, to name a few. However, these provisions on their own will not make the difference that is needed unless coupled with the following: 1) Include quarter horses and Standardbreds; 2) Administration of drugs should only be allowed by veterinarians, not trainers; 3) Mandated and Defined Checklist for Removal from Veterinarians List; 4) Mandated pre-race CT Scan requirements; 5) Mandate Central Pharmacy for dispensing all medications; 6) Increase fines for medication violations and require the CHRB to suspend or revoke licenses for repeat offenders; 7) Installation of synthetic surfaces.”
ASSEMBLY THIRD READING
ATR Bill Id:AB 1974
Author:(Gray)
As Amended Ver:June 4, 2020
2/3 vote
SUMMARY:
Makes various changes to Horse Racing by imposing new and additional horse racing health and safety requirements to be enforced by the California Horse Racing Board (CHRB).
Major Provisions
- Requires the CHRB to adopt rules and regulations that protect and advance the health, safety, welfare, and aftercare of racehorses.
- Prohibits a trainer from administering, directly or indirectly, or otherwise permitting to be administered, any medication to a thoroughbred horse under the trainer's care that is racing or training at a CHRB approved racetrack, unless the medication is prescribed for that specific horse and administered strictly in accordance with board regulations.
- Provides that in addition to any criteria set forth by a racing association, a trainer shall not enter into any race a Thoroughbred horse that is four years of age or older that has not competed in a race or has not raced in the preceding 365 days, unless the horse has passed an examination by a board-licensed veterinarian and has successfully passed a post-work official blood test.
- Requires a Thoroughbred horse that has not raced within 120 days but has raced within 365 days to have an examination performed by a board-licensed veterinarian within seven days before entry. Based upon that examination, the CHRB-licensed veterinarian may require the horse to work before being allowed to enter in a race. If the horse is required to work, it shall meet the same requirements as a horse that is working to be taken off the Official Veterinarian's List, as specified in current law or any regulation adopted by the CHRB.
- Requires that all horses at a CHRB-approved racetrack or training facility be subject to veterinary monitoring during morning training, as specified, and would require the use of diagnostic imaging as an accepted component of prerace examinations by an examining veterinarian, as specified.
- Provides that horses that are unsound or lame are subject to immediate placement on the Veterinarian's List with criteria for removal that may include diagnostic imaging, examination of blood, and counsel with attending veterinarians. This provision specifies that: a) A horse placed on the Veterinarian's List for being unsound or lame shall not workout for seven days after being placed on the list without the permission of the official veterinarian; b) The official veterinarian shall require any horse placed on the Veterinarian's List to undergo a veterinary examination that may include diagnostic imaging before resuming training at any facility under the jurisdiction of the board; and c) A horse placed on the Veterinarian's List as unsound or lame shall be removed from the list only after having established or demonstrated to the satisfaction of the official veterinarian that the horse is then raceably sound and in fit physical condition to exert its best effort in a race.
- Provides that a horse placed on the Veterinarian's List as unsound or lame for the first time within a 365-day period shall stay on the Veterinarian's List for a minimum of 15 days before the horse is eligible to be removed from the list. This provision specifies that: a) A horse placed on the Veterinarian's List as unsound or lame for the second time in 365 days shall stay on the Veterinarian's List for a minimum of 45 days before the horse is eligible to be removed from the list; b) A horse placed on the Veterinarian's List as unsound or lame for the third time in 365 days shall stay on the Veterinarian's List for a minimum of 75 days before the horse is eligible to be removed from the list; and c) A horse placed on the Veterinarian's List as unsound or lame for the fourth time in 365 days shall stay on the Veterinarian's List for a minimum of 180 days before the horse is eligible to be removed from the list.
- Provides that a trainer shall not administer, directly or indirectly, or otherwise permit to be administered, any medication to a thoroughbred horse under the trainer's care that is racing or training at a board-approved racetrack, unless the medication is prescribed for that specific horse and administered strictly in accordance with board regulations.
- Specifies that the use of diagnostic imaging shall be an accepted component of prerace examinations by an examining veterinarian. The official veterinarian may order the diagnostic imaging if they believe that the use is warranted. In addition, video footage may be utilized and maintained by the official veterinarian for the purpose of comparison when a horse is removed from the Veterinarian's List.
- Requires a racing association to provide a location within the inclosure where a horse can be observed jogging in a circle in both directions by an examining veterinarian, if needed, as part of the pre-race examination process.
- Creates the Horse and Jockey Safety and Welfare Account in the Fair and Exposition Fund. The bill would require that moneys from specified license fees from occupational licenses and all penalty revenues imposed pursuant to current law be deposited in that account and be continuously appropriated to the CHRB for equine safety measures to improve the integrity and safety of horse racing that include, among other things, contracting for additional state veterinarians, stewards, and infrastructure to directly improve the safety and welfare of horses and riders
COMMENTS:
BACKGROUND:
Horse racing in California. Horse racing has been taking place in California since the 1800s, but horse racing as we now know it – under the pari-mutuel wagering system – was not made possible until the electorate passed a constitutional amendment in 1933. The expressed intent of the Horse Racing Law is to allow pari-mutuel wagering on horse races and: 1) Assure protection of the public; 2) Encourage agriculture and the breeding of horses in this state; 3) Provide uniformity of regulation for each type of horse racing; 5) Provide for maximum expansion of horse-racing opportunities in the public interest. To accomplish these objectives, the constitutional amendment created the California Horse Racing Board.
Under existing law, the CHRB is required to among other things, establish safety standards governing the uniformity and content of the track base and racing surface, inner and outer rails, gates and gaps, turf, access and egress to the track, lighting for night racing, equipment for horse and rider, drainage, communications, veterinary services, medical and ambulance services, and other track facilities to improve the safety of horses, riders, and workers at the racetrack.
Background on Equine Fatalities in FY 2018/2019. An unusual increase in equine fatalities in the winter and spring 2018-2019 season at Santa Anita Park increased focus on animal protection in California and made national headlines for a so-called spike in racing and training fatalities. Santa Anita, known as the Great Race Place, in Arcadia, CA offers some of the prominent horse racing events in the United States during early fall, winter, and spring.
Some critics blamed the racing surfaces at Santa Anita which had endured heavier than normal rainfall which created maintenance problems. In early March 2019, all races were canceled indefinitely following the 21st fatality of the winter season; racing resumed late in the month.
During the period that racing and training was ceased, experts were brought in to study and do work on the main track to ensure that it was as safe as possible for racing and training, When racing resumed, the track's owners, The Stronach Group announced a series of new safety measures, including limiting the use of pain or anti-inflammatory medications, treatment for horses and improving early detection of preexisting health conditions, and continuing to consult with outside experts regularly to review its dirt and turf surfaces. Also, all races run on the famed hillside turf course were canceled.
In June 2019, SB 469 (Dodd), Chapter 22, Statutes of 2019) was chaptered into law by Governor Newsom and came into force upon signature. The bill authorized the CHRB to immediately suspend a license to conduct a horse racing meeting when necessary to protect the health and safety of horses and riders and the board adopted emergency regulations to implement the measure. Furthermore, Governor Newsom had the CHRB create a panel of CHRB veterinarians and stewards to review the medical, training, and racing histories of each horse entered in a race, and to recommend to the Board of Stewards that they scratch (remove from races) horses deemed unfit to run.
The above-mentioned safety measures and protocols resulted in a reduction but not the total elimination of horse fatalities. Veterinary experts state that despite advances in veterinary care, rehabilitating horses from fractures is rare because animals cannot be immobilized.
At the request of Governor Newsom in November 2019, the CHRB submitted an extensive list of recommendations, some of which require legislation. Some of the recommendations have already been implemented or are in the process of adoption. These actions include: 1) The CHRB acted to limit corticosteroid and anti-inflammatory medications at all racetracks, and authorized racing secretaries to impose medication restrictions as conditions of races; 2) Racetracks restricted intra-articular injections within 14 days of racing; 3) Required trainers to maintain records of veterinary treatment for their horses, while taking additional steps to make veterinary treatments more transparent; 4) The CHRB stepped up out-of-competition testing of horses before they are scheduled to run in order to discourage the use of prohibited long-acting drugs; 5) The CHRB prohibited the administration of bisphosphonates to horses at CHRB regulated facilities and prohibiting any horse from entering the grounds within six months of having been administered bisphosphonates; 6) The CHRB required trainers and other licensees to review postmortem reports with the Official Veterinarian as an educational opportunity to help them understand how injuries develop and occur, and continued the process of implementing a more comprehensive continuing education program for trainers; 7) The CHRB established a protocol for full investigations of horse fatalities conducted by CHRB Investigators (sworn police officers) and Official Veterinarians, utilizing the Board's subpoena power as necessary; and 8) The CHRB began the regulatory process and/or adopted limits for certain drug substances and medications for horses performing high-speed exercise.
According to the CHRB, "FY 2018-19 had the second-lowest number of total fatalities since 1990 when comprehensive records of all fatalities became available. The reduction in racing and training fatalities was the culmination of years of effort, making the tragic cluster of fatalities in January and February especially disheartening."
The CHRB's Annual Report 2018-2019 included a statement from the Board's new Chairman Dr. Gregory Ferraro, which stated, "The numerous fatalities at Santa Anita have been especially disheartening because up until last winter we had made significant strides in reducing equine fatalities—reduced by nearly 60 percent over the previous 13 years, we had hoped the declining trend would continue. But the stark reality is that we still have much more to do in order to protect horses and riders."
CHRB Report on 2018/19 Santa Anita Fatalities. In March 2020, the CHRB released a 77-page report on the initial 23 fatalities that occurred during the Santa Anita race meet between December 26, 2018 and March 31, 2019. The report was compiled by veterinarians and scientists, CHRB investigators, safety stewards, and CHRB staff. The report examined in depth each of the fatalities, published key findings and recommendations in various areas, including track maintenance; management of the racing office; training practices; private veterinary practitioners and practices; horse safety and welfare; regulatory veterinary procedures and practices at the CHRB level. The report did not include the seven horses that died at Santa Anita from April 1 through June 23, 2019.
Key findings of the CHRB investigation include: no illegal medications or procedures were uncovered; 21 horses had evidence of preexisting pathology at the site of their fatal injury; a high majority (14 of 22) of the catastrophic musculoskeletal injuries (CMI) cases exhibited a high-intensity exercise profile followed by a decline in activity in the month before CMI; the data suggests that 39% of fatalities occurred on surfaces affected by wet weather. The investigations found no evidence of animal welfare violations, but investigators found 10 alleged violations of rules, mostly for failing to turn over daily veterinary reports, but also for allegations of training without the proper license.
Los Angeles District Attorney's Office Investigative Report. The Los Angeles District Attorney's (LADA) office formed the Santa Anita Task Force (Task Force) to investigate and review the racing and training fatalities at Santa Anita Park for evidence of animal cruelty and criminal activity on 56 equine fatalities from July 1, 2018 to November 30, 2019.
The LADA Task Force concentrated its review on CHRB fatality reports and documents as well as statements from witnesses, industry stakeholders, and experts. The Task Force reviewed hundreds of documents including necropsies, veterinarian records, training records, and medication records related to the deaths and conducted numerous in-person interviews of current and former track maintenance experts, Santa Anita executives and employees, Jockey Guild and California Thoroughbred Trainers Association representatives, CHRB officials, jockeys, owners, trainers, and veterinarians.
According to the Task Force's 19-page report, "[a]fter a thorough investigation and review of the evidence, the District Attorney's Task Force did not find evidence of criminal animal cruelty or unlawful conduct relating to the equine fatalities at Santa Anita Park." According to the report, the number of horse deaths at Santa Anita over the past decade has ranged from a high of 71 in fiscal year (FY) 2011-12 to a low of 37 in FY 2010-11. There were 49 horse deaths in FY 2018-19.
While the Task Force did not uncover sufficient evidence of animal cruelty on the part of Santa Anita Park or any individual trainer, owner, or jockey, the Task Force did identify several areas of concern and possible factors that may have contributed to deaths. The Task Force probed the following areas: medication, track conditions, running injured horses, and pressure to race. The report identified several recommended best practices derived from and supported by experts and stakeholders, to improve safety and reduce fatalities at Santa Anita Park and other racetracks in California. These recommendations include: 1) Urging the CHRB to prepare an annual racing fatality report that includes all equine fatalities at California racetracks and identifies contributing factors; 2) Mandating that all racing and training fatalities undergo thorough investigations conducted by sworn CHRB investigators that includes obtaining necropsy, training and veterinary records as well as interviewing people associated with the training, treatment, and care of the fatally injured horse; 3) Evaluating the need to enhance penalties for CHRB violations of rules and regulations to reflect the severity of some violations and to serve as an effective future deterrent; and 4) Establishing a tip line to encourage the reporting of suspected animal cruelty, horses at risk or illegal practices.
The report further stated, "Horse racing has inherent risks but is a legally sanctioned sport in California," District Attorney Jackie Lacey said. "Greater precautions are needed to enhance safety and protect both horses and their riders."
The Postmortem Examination Program. CHRB Rule 1846.5, Postmortem Examination, requires a necropsy for all horses dying within a CHRB facility. The Postmortem Examination Program has been in operation since February 1990, and has performed examinations on 7,061 horses, as of June 30, 2018. The Program has three primary objectives: 1) to determine the nature of injuries occurring in racehorses, 2) to determine the reasons for these injuries, and 3) to develop injury prevention strategies. To accomplish this, a broad, cooperative approach was organized involving the development of a contract with the California Animal Health and Food Safety Laboratory System at the UC Davis School of Veterinary Medicine to perform a necropsy on every horse that died spontaneously or was euthanized on racetracks or at training facilities under the jurisdiction of the CHRB. This visionary partnership has become a national and international model for the racing industry to improve the safety and welfare of racehorses.
In January 2020, the CHRB began publishing weekly updates on equine fatalities including the horse's name, breed, the activity the horse was performing, the trainer of the horse, the track surface, the weather at the time of the injury, and the last time the horse had run in a race, among other things.
The Practice of Racehorse Drug Testing in California. The CHRB requires analysis of blood and urine samples from horses in competition. The Kenneth L. Maddy Equine Analytical Chemistry Laboratory at UC Davis is widely recognized as one of the premier testing facilities in the world and provides the CHRB with an effective drug testing program. The lab routinely adds new drugs and analytical tests as new information becomes available. Funded by wagering revenues, the Maddy Lab analyzed 52,333 samples in FY 2018-19. The Maddy Lab analyzed 19,436 post-race urine and blood samples, including in-depth testing of 11,760 for anabolic steroids, 16,635 bicarbonate (TCO2) loading blood samples, 1,786 cobalt blood samples, 1,946 out-of-competition (OOC) blood samples, 583 OOC and post-race hair samples, 46 evidence submissions, and 118 other samples for various purposes in FY 2018-19. The cost to perform these services was $3,187,250.
The Jockey Club's Equine Injury Database. The Jockey Club's Equine Injury Database (EID) focuses on horse fatalities during racing starts to allow for comparison from track to track and from year to year throughout North America. The 2019 national rate of fatal injury was the lowest number since the EID started collecting data in 2009. The overall drop in the risk of fatal injury from 2009 to 2019 was 23.5%. The rate of fatal injury for Thoroughbreds dropped to 1.53 per 1,000 starts from a rate of 1.68 in 2018. Racetracks accredited by the National Thoroughbred Racing Association Safety and Integrity Alliance had a lower incidence of fatality per 1,000 starts versus non-accredited tracks across all surfaces (1.46 vs. 1.59).
In California, the Fresno District Fair had a 0.00 rate, the California State Fair had a 0.00 rate, the Alameda County Fair had a 1.34 rate, the Del Mar Thoroughbred Club which had seen declines in three straight years reported a 0.62 rate while Golden Gate Fields finished with a 0.64 rate in 2019.
Santa Anita Park numbers reflect the problems they faced in 2019. The numbers were up to 3.01 per 1,000 starts after a 2018 season of 2.04 per 1,000 starts. After Santa Anita ceased racing to address the rash of fatalities at the winter/spring meet and reopened, the catastrophic injury rate was 2.16, less than half the rate at the beginning of the meet.
Public Outcry by Interested Parties. The number of horse fatalities during Santa Anita's 2018/19 meet increased heightened scrutiny of horse racing not just at that racetrack but live racing facilities across California and the country. Some activists have called for the elimination of horse racing in California, staging frequent protests and mock funerals outside of California's racetracks on race days. Other groups have advocated changes to horse racing, including medication reform such as the use of performance-enhancing and injury-masking drugs, training practices for young horses, and the use of a riding crop, among others.
According to the Author:
According to the author's office, "Horse racing in California has a long and storied history. The industry provides billions of dollars to California's economy, and supports tens of thousands of direct and indirect jobs throughout the state. California has continually led the nation in adoption of health and safety standards, and is home to the world's premier equine chemistry laboratory, the Maddy Lab at the University of California, Davis. The last 16 months have been extremely challenging for California's horse racing industry from the unusual increase in equine fatalities that occurred in early 2019 to the recent economic hardship caused by the current pandemic. But in both cases, the industry faced these challenges head-on with determination and resolve by adopting comprehensive changes and protocols that advanced the safety and welfare of horse and rider.
The author notes "that in response to the recent equine safety crisis, California's racing industry and the CHRB adopted stringent rules, regulations, and protocols from medication reform, advanced veterinarian screening, track maintenance—including special measures during rain or extreme weather conditions, and the use of high-tech diagnostic equipment, including PET and MRI machines. These wide-ranging changes and protocols have led to safer racing after the spike in fatal breakdowns at Santa Anita during the 2019 race meet. It should be noted though that these efforts resulted in a reduction but not the total elimination of horse fatalities."
The author believes that "California's horse racing industry, like many industries, must be willing to accept and adopt forward-thinking solutions to address long-standing issues and debates, as the health and welfare of the sport's human and equine athletes are paramount to the future of this agribusiness. AB 1974 will further strengthen California's Horse Racing Law with proactive measures which will allow for the safest environment for human and equine participants and be a model for other states to follow."
Arguments in Support:
Supporters note that this bill strengthens the state's commitment to horse welfare by requiring veterinary monitoring during morning training sessions. This along with the other provisions of the bill moves forward the goal to offer the safest forum for horse racing in the country.
Arguments in Opposition:
None on file
FISCAL COMMENTS:
According to the Assembly Appropriations Committee,
- An annual shift of approximately $1.16 million from the General Fund to the Account as a result of reallocating specified occupational penalty and license fee revenue.
- Additional new costs in the hundreds of thousands of dollars to implement the horse racing safety provisions of this bill. New CHRB costs include approximately $600,000 for new veterinarians and unknown additional costs related to CHRB support of racetrack infrastructure investments.
VOTES:
ASM GOVERNMENTAL ORGANIZATION: 19-0-2
YES: Gray, Bigelow, Aguiar-Curry, Berman, Bonta, Brough, Cooley, Daly, Gallagher, Eduardo Garcia, Gipson, Jones-Sawyer, Lackey, Low, Mathis, Melendez, Robert Rivas, Blanca Rubio, Salas
ABS, ABST OR NV: Cooper, Quirk-Silva
ASM APPROPRIATIONS: 18-0-0
YES: Gonzalez, Bigelow, Bauer-Kahan, Bloom, Bonta, Calderon, Carrillo, Chau, Megan Dahle, Diep, Eggman, Fong, Gabriel, Eduardo Garcia, Petrie-Norris, McCarty, Robert Rivas, Voepel
UPDATED:
VERSION: June 4, 2020
CONSULTANT: Eric Johnson / G.O. / (916) 319-2531 FN: 0002991
Date of Hearing: June 2, 2020
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Lorena Gonzalez, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 1974
Author:(Gray) – As Amended Ver:May 4, 2020
Policy Committee: | Governmental Organization | Vote: | 19 - 0 |
|
| ||
|
|
Urgency: No State Mandated Local Program: Yes Reimbursable: No
SUMMARY:
This bill imposes new horse racing health and safety requirements to be enforced by the California Horse Racing Board (CHRB). Specifically, this bill:
- Creates the Horse and Jockey Safety and Welfare Account (Account) within the Fair and Exposition Fund. The Account will be funded through license fees and penalty revenues and used for equine safety measures and to improve the integrity and safety of horse racing.
- Creates rules and processes around when horses are placed on the “Veterinarian’s List” and when they are allowed to race. For example, a horse placed on the Veterinarian’s List as unsound or lame can only be removed from the list if it can be established or demonstrated to the satisfaction of the official veterinarian that the horse is sound and in fit physical condition. The more often the horse is put on the list, the longer the horse is suspended .
- Restricts the use of a thoroughbred racehorse that is four years of age or older unless the horse has met specified requirements, such as passing a veterinarian examination. These requirements vary depending on how long it has been since the horse last raced.
- Requires all horses at a CHRB-approved racetrack or training facility to be subject to veterinary monitoring during morning training and requires all examining veterinarians at a live race to be under direct supervision of an official veterinarian or equine medical director. A trainer is not allowed to administer any medication to a thoroughbred horse unless the medication is prescribed for that horse and is administered in accordance with regulations.
FISCAL EFFECT:
- An annual shift in the range of $800,000 to $1.16 million from the General Fund to the Account as a result of reallocating specified occupational penalty and license fee revenue. This includes:
- Penalty revenue of an unknown amount from medication-related penalties. CHRB does not differentiate penalty revenue based on the nature of the penalty. In total, CHRB collects between $200,000 and $260,000 in penalty revenue each year, so reallocated medication-related penalty revenues would be less than this amount each year.
- Occupational license fee revenue between $800,000 and $900,000 per year.
- Additional new costs in the hundreds of thousands of dollars to implement the horse racing safety provisions of this bill. New CHRB costs include approximately $600,000 for new veterinarians and unknown additional costs related to CHRB support of racetrack infrastructure investments. The revenues described above from penalties and license fees are expected to cover this bill’s costs.
- Additional costs to develop a system to differentiate the medication-related penalty new costs to develop a system to differentiate the medication-related penalty revenue described above. It is this committee’s understanding the intent is to redirect all penalty revenue, and not just medication-related penalties. Following a technical amendment, these new costs would be eliminated.
COMMENTS:
- Background. The 2018-19 horse racing season saw an uptick in horse fatalities that garnered significant public attention. Between December 26, 2018 and March 31, 2019, 23 horses died at Santa Anita Park. In response to the deaths, Santa Anita and CHRB announced various safety measures, such as granting independent veterinarians the power to prevent horses from racing if they seem unfit in the pre-race process. Notably, at one point in March 2019, CHRB asked Santa Anita to suspense racing for the rest of the season, which Santa Anita rejected.
In June 2019, the governor signed SB 469 (Dodd), Chapter 22, Statutes of 2019, which authorized CHRB to immediately suspend a license to conduct horse racing if necessary to protect the health and safety of horses and riders. Subsequently, a number of expert-led panels along with CHRB developed a range of recommendations and procedures to improve safety at the racetrack. As the policy committee analysis notes, these new measurers and protocols resulted in a reduction, but not elimination, of fatalities.
- Purpose. According to the author, AB 1974 will strengthen California’s horse racing industry “with proactive measurers which will allow for the safest environment for human and equine participants.”
- Budget proposal. The Governor’s May revision of the 2020-21 budget includes $1.3 million to support new CHRB safety measures. The proposal assumes six new veterinarians, three horse racing stewards, and three new CHRB investigators. This proposal, if approved, would cover the costs associated with this bill.
- Next steps. As noted in the fiscal analysis, this bill’s provisions redirecting certain penalty revenues for medication violations to fund horse racing safety measures may present administrative challenges for CHRB. After speaking to policy committee staff, the committee recommends a technical amendment that references Business and Professions Code Section 19640 instead of Section 19582. This would redirect all penalty revenue, as intended by the author, and ease CHRB’s implementation concerns.
Moreover, as the bill moves through the legislative process, the author may want to align the bill with the Governor’s CHRB proposal. If the enacted 2020-21 budget includes this proposal, then the costs of CHRB’s new duties under this bill would likely be absorbable.
Analysis Prepare by: Luke Reidenbach / APPR. / (916) 319-2081
Date of Hearing: May 12, 2020
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON GOVERNMENTAL ORGANIZATION
Adam Gray, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 1974 (
Author:Gray) – As Amended Ver:May 4, 2020
SUBJECT: Horse racing: welfare and safety of racehorses and jockeys
SUMMARY: Makes various changes to Horse Racing Law to further protect and advance the health, safety, welfare, and aftercare of racehorses in California. Specifically, this bill:
1) Adds as a California Horse Racing Board (CHRB) responsibility the adoption of rules and regulations that protect and advance the health, safety, welfare, and aftercare of racehorses.
2) Prohibits a trainer from administering, directly or indirectly, or otherwise permitting to be administered, any medication to a thoroughbred horse under the trainer’s care that is racing or training at a CHRB approved racetrack, unless the medication is prescribed for that specific horse and administered strictly in accordance with board regulations.
3) Requires that all penalty revenues imposed pursuant to current law be redirected to improve and enhance horse welfare and safety measures within the industry. The CHRB shall publicly disclose those measures on their internet website. The new welfare and safety measures shall include all of the following:
a) Contracting for additional state veterinarians.
b) Adding additional safety stewards.
c) Improving or adding race track infrastructure to directly improve the safety and welfare of horses and riders.
4) Provides that in addition to any criteria set forth by a racing association, a trainer shall not enter into any race a Thoroughbred horse that is four years of age or older that has not competed in a race or has not raced in the preceding 365 days, unless the horse has passed an examination by a board-licensed veterinarian and has successfully passed a post-work official blood test.
5) Requires a Thoroughbred horse that has not raced within 120 days but has raced within 365 days to have an examination performed by a board-licensed veterinarian within seven days before entry. Based upon that examination, the CHRB-licensed veterinarian may require the horse to work before being allowed to enter in a race. If the horse is required to work, it shall meet the same requirements as a horse that is working to be taken off the Official Veterinarian’s List, as specified in current law or any regulation adopted by the CHRB.
6) Requires that all horses at a board-approved racetrack or training facility be subject to veterinary monitoring during morning training, as specified, and would require the use of diagnostic imaging as an accepted component of prerace examinations by an examining veterinarian, as specified.
7) Provides that horses that are unsound or lame are subject to immediate placement on the Veterinarian’s List with criteria for removal that may include diagnostic imaging, examination of blood, and counsel with attending veterinarians.
This bill further specifies that:
a) A horse placed on the Veterinarian’s List for being unsound or lame shall not workout for seven days after being placed on the list without the permission of the official veterinarian.
b) The official veterinarian shall require any horse placed on the Veterinarian’s List to undergo a veterinary examination that may include diagnostic imaging before resuming training at any facility under the jurisdiction of the board.
c) A horse placed on the Veterinarian’s List as unsound or lame shall be removed from the list only after having established or demonstrated to the satisfaction of the official veterinarian that the horse is then raceably sound and in fit physical condition to exert its best effort in a race.
8) Provides that a horse placed on the Veterinarian’s List as unsound or lame for the first time within a 365-day period shall stay on the Veterinarian’s List for a minimum of 15 days before the horse is eligible to be removed from the list.
This bill further specifies that:
a) A horse placed on the Veterinarian’s List as unsound or lame for the second time in 365 days shall stay on the Veterinarian’s List for a minimum of 45 days before the horse is eligible to be removed from the list.
b) A horse placed on the Veterinarian’s List as unsound or lame for the third time in 365 days shall stay on the Veterinarian’s List for a minimum of 75 days before the horse is eligible to be removed from the list.
c) A horse placed on the Veterinarian’s List as unsound or lame for the fourth time in 365 days shall stay on the Veterinarian’s List for a minimum of 180 days before the horse is eligible to be removed from the list.
9) Provides that a trainer shall not administer, directly or indirectly, or otherwise permit to be administered, any medication to a thoroughbred horse under the trainer’s care that is racing or training at a board-approved racetrack, unless the medication is prescribed for that specific horse and administered strictly in accordance with board regulations.
10) Specifies that the use of diagnostic imaging shall be an accepted component of prerace examinations by an examining veterinarian. The official veterinarian may order the diagnostic imaging if they believe that the use is warranted. In addition, video footage may be utilized and maintained by the official veterinarian for the purpose of comparison when a horse is removed from the Veterinarian’s List.
11) Requires a racing association to provide a location within the inclosure where a horse can be observed jogging in a circle in both directions by an examining veterinarian, if needed, as part of the pre-race examination process.
12) Creates the Horse and Jockey Safety and Welfare Account in the Fair and Exposition Fund. The bill would require that moneys from specified license fees from occupational licenses imposed pursuant to the Horse Racing Law be deposited in that account and be continuously appropriated to the CHRB for equine safety measures to improve the integrity and safety of horse racing that include, among other things, contracting for additional state veterinarians, safety stewards, and infrastructure support related to the safety and welfare of racehorses and jockeys.
EXISTING LAW:
1) Provides, in Article IV, Section 19(b) of the Constitution of the State of California, that the Legislature may provide for the regulation of horse race meetings; and, grants the CHRB all powers necessary and proper to enable it to carry out the law and makes the board responsible for, among other things, adopting rules and regulations for the protection of the public and the control of horse racing and pari-mutuel wagering and administration and enforcement of all laws, rules, and regulations affecting horse racing and pari-mutuel wagering.
2) Requires the CHRB to adopt regulations to establish policies, guidelines, and penalties relating to equine medication in order to preserve and enhance the integrity of horse racing in the state. That law requires that those policies, guidelines, and penalties include, at a minimum, provisions that prohibit, among other things, a substance of any kind from being administered by any means to a horse after it has been entered to race in a horse race, unless the CHRB has, by regulation, specifically authorized the use of the substance and its quantity and composition. That law provides that violations of this provision, as determined by the CHRB, are punishable as set forth in regulations adopted by the board.
3) Authorizes the CHRB to, at any time, suspend a license to conduct a horse racing meeting when necessary to protect the health and safety of horses or riders, as specified.
4) Requires the CHRB to establish safety standards to improve the safety of horses, riders, and workers at the racetrack. Current law requires stewards to prepare a report identifying circumstances and likely causes for on-track accidents. Current law also establishes the qualifications for licensing and the duties of trainers and veterinarians.
5) Existing regulations of the CHRB require that, if a horse suffers a fatal injury on a racetrack in training or in competition, or dies or is euthanized within an area under the jurisdiction of the board, the horse undergo a postmortem examination at a diagnostic laboratory that is under contract with the board to determine the injury or sickness that resulted in euthanasia or natural death, as provided. Those regulations also provide for additional necropsy examinations requested by the owner or trainer, require the diagnostic laboratory to file a written report with the executive director of the CHRB, the equine medical director, and the official veterinarian upon completion of the postmortem examination, and require that each owner and trainer accept responsibility for the postmortem examination as a requisite for maintaining their occupational license.
FISCAL EFFECT: Unknown
COMMENTS:
Purpose of the bill. According to the author's office, "Horse racing in California has a long and storied history. The industry provides billions of dollars to California's economy, and supports tens of thousands of direct and indirect jobs throughout the state. California has continually led the nation in adoption of health and safety standards, and is home to the world's premier equine chemistry laboratory, the Maddy Lab at the University of California, Davis.”
The author’s office states, “The last 16 months have been extremely challenging for California’s horse racing industry from the unusual increase in equine fatalities that occurred in early 2019 to the recent economic hardship caused by the current pandemic. But in both cases, the industry faced these challenges head-on with determination and resolve by adopting comprehensive changes and protocols that not only advanced the safety and welfare of horses but jockeys and those that care for them as well.”
In response to the recent equine safety crisis, California's racing industry and the CHRB adopted stringent rules, regulations, and protocols from medication reform, advanced veterinarian screening, track maintenance—including special measures during rain or extreme weather conditions, and the use of high-tech diagnostic equipment, including PET and MRI machines.
The author states that “these wide-ranging changes and protocols have led to safer racing after the spike in fatal breakdowns at Santa Anita during the 2019 race meet. It should be noted though that these efforts resulted in a reduction but not the total elimination of horse fatalities.”
The author states that “Senate G.O. Chair Bill Dodd and I are both authoring bills this year to build on last year's legislative efforts to ensure that California is the safest racing jurisdiction in the nation, and continues as the gold-standard for other states to follow.”
The author believes that “California's horse racing industry, like many industries, must be willing to accept and adopt forward-thinking solutions to address long-standing issues and debates, as the health and welfare of the sport's human and equine athletes are paramount to the future of this agribusiness. AB 1974 will further strengthen California’s Horse Racing Law with proactive measures which will allow for the safest environment for human and equine participants.”
Background:
Horse racing in California. Horse racing has been taking place in California since the 1800s, but horse racing as we now know it – under the pari-mutuel wagering system – was not made possible until the electorate passed a constitutional amendment in 1933. The expressed intent of the Horse Racing Law is to allow pari-mutuel wagering on horse races and: 1) Assure protection of the public; 2) Encourage agriculture and the breeding of horses in this state; 3) Provide uniformity of regulation for each type of horse racing; 5) Provide for maximum expansion of horse-racing opportunities in the public interest. To accomplish these objectives, the constitutional amendment created the California Horse Racing Board.
Over the years, California’s laws have been modified, amended, and enhanced to provide for regulation and oversight of live racing, off-track wagering, interstate and international wagering, and online account wagering, known as Advance Deposit Wagering.
According to the CHRB’s Annual Report 2018-2019, “California customers and other fans of California horse racing wagered more than $2.9 billion in the last fiscal year. Of the total wagered, more than $2.3 billion was returned to winning ticket holders and $13,547,000 was remitted to fund CHRB operations. A total of $126,813,852 was distributed in the form of purses while racetracks and fairs that conduct live racing programs collected a total of $109,467,590 in commissions. Much of the gross revenue generated for racetracks went toward the cost of operations, such as rent, mortgages, salaries for track employees, track and backside maintenance, and pari-mutuel clerks who are members of SEIU Local 280. Also, more than $3.8 million was directed towards equine research, retirement, and welfare. There are over 17,000 licensed jobs tied to the horse racing industry in California.
There are currently four privately operated racetracks, five racing fairs, and one training-only facility licensed and operating in California. Additionally, there are 28 non-track satellite-wagering facilities located throughout the state in tribal casinos, sports bars, restaurants, card clubs, and other businesses. All locations, except for the training-only facility and the Humboldt County Fair are open to the public during their off-seasons for simulcast wagering, which is the process of transmitting the audio and video signal of a live racing performance from one facility to a satellite for re-transmission to other locations or venues where pari-mutuel wagering is permitted. Horse racing in California can generally be broken into four categories: Thoroughbred race meets; Quarter Horse race meets; harness race meets; and, State and county fair race meets.
The CHRB monitors equine safety measures and protocols within licensed facilities through official veterinarians, safety stewards, the Equine Medical Director (EMD), and the CHRB/University of California, Davis (UC Davis) postmortem program.
Under existing law, the CHRB is required to among other things, establish safety standards governing the uniformity and content of the track base and racing surface, inner and outer rails, gates and gaps, turf, access and egress to the track, lighting for night racing, equipment for horse and rider, drainage, communications, veterinary services, medical and ambulance services, and other track facilities to improve the safety of horses, riders, and workers at the racetrack.
Background on Equine Fatalities in FY 2018/2019. An unusual increase in equine fatalities in the winter and spring 2018-2019 season at Santa Anita Park increased focus on animal protection in California and made national headlines for a so-called spike in racing and training fatalities. Santa Anita, known as the Great Race Place, in Arcadia, CA offers some of the prominent horse racing events in the United States during early fall, winter, and spring.
Some critics blamed the racing surfaces at Santa Anita which had endured heavier than normal rainfall which created maintenance problems. In early March 2019, all races were canceled indefinitely following the 21st fatality of the winter season; racing resumed late in the month. During the period that racing and training was ceased, experts were brought in to study and do work on the main track to ensure that it was as safe as possible for racing and training, When racing resumed, the track’s owners, The Stronach Group announced a series of new safety measures, including limiting the use of pain or anti-inflammatory medications, treatment for horses and improving early detection of preexisting health conditions, and continuing to consult with outside experts regularly to review its dirt and turf surfaces. Also, all races run on the famed hillside turf course were canceled.
In June 2019, SB 469 (Dodd, Chapter 22, Statutes of 2019) was chaptered into law by Governor Newsom and came into force upon signature. The bill authorized the CHRB to immediately suspend a license to conduct a horse racing meeting when necessary to protect the health and safety of horses and riders and the board adopted emergency regulations to implement the measure. Furthermore, Governor Newsom had the CHRB create a panel of CHRB veterinarians and stewards to review the medical, training, and racing histories of each horse entered in a race, and to recommend to the Board of Stewards that they scratch (remove from races) horses deemed unfit to run.
The above-mentioned safety measures and protocols resulted in a reduction but not the total elimination of horse fatalities. Veterinary experts state that despite advances in veterinary care, rehabilitating horses from fractures is rare because animals cannot be immobilized.
At the request of Governor Newsom in November 2019, the CHRB submitted an extensive list of recommendations, some of which require legislation. Some of the recommendations have already been implemented or are in the process of adoption. These actions include: 1) The CHRB acted to limit corticosteroid and anti-inflammatory medications at all racetracks, and authorized racing secretaries to impose medication restrictions as conditions of races; 2) Racetracks restricted intra-articular injections within 14 days of racing; 3) Required trainers to maintain records of veterinary treatment for their horses, while taking additional steps to make veterinary treatments more transparent; 4) The CHRB stepped up out-of-competition testing of horses before they are scheduled to run in order to discourage the use of prohibited long-acting drugs; 5) The CHRB prohibited the administration of bisphosphonates to horses at CHRB regulated facilities and prohibiting any horse from entering the grounds within six months of having been administered bisphosphonates; 6) The CHRB required trainers and other licensees to review postmortem reports with the Official Veterinarian as an educational opportunity to help them understand how injuries develop and occur, and continued the process of implementing a more comprehensive continuing education program for trainers; 7) The CHRB established a protocol for full investigations of horse fatalities conducted by CHRB Investigators (sworn police officers) and Official Veterinarians, utilizing the Board’s subpoena power as necessary; and 8) The CHRB began the regulatory process and/or adopted limits for certain drug substances and medications for horses performing high-speed exercise.
According to the CHRB, “FY 2018-19 had the second-lowest number of total fatalities since 1990 when comprehensive records of all fatalities became available. The reduction in racing and training fatalities was the culmination of years of effort, making the tragic cluster of fatalities in January and February especially disheartening.”
The CHRB’s Annual Report 2018-2019 included a statement from the Board’s new Chairman Dr. Gregory Ferraro, which stated, “The numerous fatalities at Santa Anita have been especially disheartening because up until last winter we had made significant strides in reducing equine fatalities—reduced by nearly 60 percent over the previous 13 years, we had hoped the declining trend would continue. But the stark reality is that we still have much more to do in order to protect horses and riders.”
CHRB Report on 2018/19 Santa Anita Fatalities. In March 2020, the CHRB released a 77-page report on the initial 23 fatalities that occurred during the Santa Anita race meet between December 26, 2018 and March 31, 2019. The report was compiled by veterinarians and scientists, CHRB investigators, safety stewards, and CHRB staff. The report examined in depth each of the fatalities, published key findings and recommendations in various areas, including track maintenance; management of the racing office; training practices; private veterinary practitioners and practices; horse safety and welfare; regulatory veterinary procedures and practices at the CHRB level.
Key findings of the CHRB investigation include: no illegal medications or procedures were uncovered; 21 horses had evidence of preexisting pathology at the site of their fatal injury; a high majority (14 of 22) of the catastrophic musculoskeletal injuries (CMI) cases exhibited a high-intensity exercise profile followed by a decline in activity in the month before CMI; the data suggests that 39% of fatalities occurred on surfaces affected by wet weather.
The investigations found no evidence of animal welfare violations, but investigators found 10 alleged violations of rules, mostly for failing to turn over daily veterinary reports, but also for allegations of training without the proper license.
Santa Anita officials have repeatedly insisted the track has implemented a wide array of safety measures at the track to protect horses. They said the track boasts one of the best safety records in the industry, noting that horses raced or trained at the facility more than 420,000 times in 2019 with a 99.991% safety rate.
The report did not include the seven horses that died at Santa Anita from April 1 through June 23, 2019.
Los Angeles District Attorney’s Office Investigative Report. The Los Angeles District Attorney’s (LADA) office formed the Santa Anita Task Force (Task Force) to investigate and review the racing and training fatalities at Santa Anita Park for evidence of animal cruelty and criminal activity on 56 equine fatalities from July 1, 2018 to November 30, 2019.
The LADA Task Force concentrated its review on CHRB fatality reports and documents as well as statements from witnesses, industry stakeholders, and experts. The Task Force reviewed hundreds of documents including necropsies, veterinarian records, training records, and medication records related to the deaths and conducted numerous in-person interviews of current and former track maintenance experts, Santa Anita executives and employees, Jockey Guild and California Thoroughbred Trainers Association representatives, CHRB officials, jockeys, owners, trainers, and veterinarians.
According to the Task Force’s 19-page report, “[a]fter a thorough investigation and review of the evidence, the District Attorney's Task Force did not find evidence of criminal animal cruelty or unlawful conduct relating to the equine fatalities at Santa Anita Park.” According to the report, the number of horse deaths at Santa Anita over the past decade has ranged from a high of 71 in fiscal year (FY) 2011-12 to a low of 37 in FY 2010-11. There were 49 horse deaths in FY 2018-19.
While the Task Force did not uncover sufficient evidence of animal cruelty on the part of Santa Anita Park or any individual trainer, owner, or jockey, the Task Force did identify several areas of concern and possible factors that may have contributed to deaths. The Task Force probed the following areas: medication, track conditions, running injured horses, and pressure to race. The report identified several recommended best practices derived from and supported by experts and stakeholders, to improve safety and reduce fatalities at Santa Anita Park and other racetracks in California. These recommendations include: 1) Urging the CHRB to prepare an annual racing fatality report that includes all equine fatalities at California racetracks and identifies contributing factors; 2) Mandating that all racing and training fatalities undergo thorough investigations conducted by sworn CHRB investigators that includes obtaining necropsy, training and veterinary records as well as interviewing people associated with the training, treatment, and care of the fatally injured horse; 3) Evaluating the need to enhance penalties for CHRB violations of rules and regulations to reflect the severity of some violations and to serve as an effective future deterrent; and 4) Establishing a tip line to encourage the reporting of suspected animal cruelty, horses at risk or illegal practices.
The report further stated, “Horse racing has inherent risks but is a legally sanctioned sport in California,” District Attorney Jackie Lacey said. “Greater precautions are needed to enhance safety and protect both horses and their riders.”
The Task Force recommended that “the California horse racing industry and regulators coordinate their efforts to formalize strategic safety plans aimed at reducing equine fatalities.”
California’s Racing Safety Program. The California Horse Racing Board initiated the Racing Safety Program (CHRB RSP) in July 2010 to address the requirements of the Business and Professions Code and to reduce the incidence of debilitating and fatal injuries at California race tracks and training facilities. The CHRB RSP focuses on: 1) Continuing education for trainers; 2) Implementation of the Microchip Program; 3) The Track Safety Standards Program; 4) Medication Rules and Regulations Reform; 5) The UC Davis California Animal Health and Food Safety Laboratory System Postmortem Program; 6) Fatality investigations and necropsy reviews; and 7) Governor’s Panel for review of race entries.
The CHRB assigns Safety Stewards to each racetrack to enforce rules and procedures designed to ensure the health and safety of racehorses. This responsibility requires them to spend considerable time in the stable areas and race track monitoring environmental safety and proper treatment of horses.
The Postmortem Examination Program. CHRB Rule 1846.5, Postmortem Examination, requires a necropsy for all horses dying within a CHRB facility. The Postmortem Examination Program has been in operation since February 1990, and has performed examinations on 7,061 horses, as of June 30, 2018. The Program has three primary objectives: 1) to determine the nature of injuries occurring in racehorses, 2) to determine the reasons for these injuries, and 3) to develop injury prevention strategies. To accomplish this, a broad, cooperative approach was organized involving the development of a contract with the California Animal Health and Food Safety Laboratory System at the UC Davis School of Veterinary Medicine to perform a necropsy on every horse that died spontaneously or was euthanized on racetracks or at training facilities under the jurisdiction of the CHRB. This visionary partnership has become a national and international model for the racing industry to improve the safety and welfare of racehorses.
Musculoskeletal injuries are the most common cause of fatalities at CHRB facilities, consistently around 80 percent of all fatalities. 81 percent of deaths among the horses examined in the previous year were racing or training fatalities. CHRB categorizes horse deaths in one of three ways: Racing, training, or "other." Racing and training deaths are related to injuries sustained on the track. The "other" category refers to deaths that are not exercise-related (CHRB cites gastrointestinal diseases, respiratory disease, and neurological diseases as examples). Musculoskeletal specimens of special interest are forwarded to the J.D. Wheat Veterinary Orthopedic Research Laboratory at the School of Veterinary Medicine at UC Davis for in-depth analysis. Research findings are published in veterinary medical journals and presented at racing industry, veterinary medical, and other professional meetings available to the public. Postmortem reports by fiscal year are available on the CHRB website under the Veterinary lab.
In January 2020, the CHRB began publishing weekly updates on equine fatalities including the horse’s name, breed, the activity the horse was performing, the trainer of the horse, the track surface, the weather at the time of the injury, and the last time the horse had run in a race, among other things.
The Practice of Racehorse Drug Testing in California. The CHRB requires analysis of blood and urine samples from horses in competition. The Kenneth L. Maddy Equine Analytical Chemistry Laboratory at UC Davis is widely recognized as one of the premier testing facilities in the world and provides the CHRB with an effective drug testing program. The lab routinely adds new drugs and analytical tests as new information becomes available. The lab has a world-renowned equine pharmacology research program. Funded by wagering revenues, the Maddy Lab analyzed 52,333 samples in FY 2018-19. The Maddy Lab analyzed 19,436 post-race urine and blood samples, including in-depth testing of 11,760 for anabolic steroids, 16,635 bicarbonate (TCO2) loading blood samples, 1,786 cobalt blood samples, 1,946 out-of-competition (OOC) blood samples, 583 OOC and post-race hair samples, 46 evidence submissions, and 118 other samples for various purposes in FY 2018-19. The cost to perform these services was $3,187,250.
Public Outcry by Interested Parties. The number of horse fatalities during Santa Anita's 2018/19 meet increased heightened scrutiny of horse racing not just at that racetrack but live racing facilities across California and the country. Some activists have called for the elimination of horse racing in California, staging frequent protests and mock funerals outside of California’s racetracks on race days. Other groups have advocated changes to horse racing, including medication reform such as the use of performance-enhancing and injury-masking drugs, training practices for young horses, and the use of a riding crop, among others.
The Jockey Club’s Equine Injury Database. The Jockey Club’s Equine Injury Database (EID) focuses on horse fatalities during racing starts to allow for comparison from track to track and from year to year throughout North America. The 2019 national rate of fatal injury was the lowest number since the EID started collecting data in 2009. The overall drop in the risk of fatal injury from 2009 to 2019 was 23.5%. The rate of fatal injury for Thoroughbreds dropped to 1.53 per 1,000 starts from a rate of 1.68 in 2018. Racetracks accredited by the National Thoroughbred Racing Association Safety and Integrity Alliance had a lower incidence of fatality per 1,000 starts versus non-accredited tracks across all surfaces (1.46 vs. 1.59).
In California, the Fresno District Fair had a 0.00 rate, the California State Fair had a 0.00 rate, the Alameda County Fair had a 1.34 rate, the Del Mar Thoroughbred Club which had seen declines in three straight years reported a 0.62 rate while Golden Gate Fields finished with a 0.64 rate in 2019.
Santa Anita Park numbers reflect the problems they faced in 2019. The numbers were up to 3.01 per 1,000 starts after a 2018 season of 2.04 per 1,000 starts. After Santa Anita ceased racing to address the rash of fatalities at the winter/spring meet and reopened, the catastrophic injury rate was 2.16, less than half the rate at the beginning of the meet.
Pending Federal Legislation. The Horse Racing Integrity Act of 2019, H.B. 1754, introduced in March 2019, would create a private, independent, horse racing anti-doping authority responsible for developing and administering a nationwide anti-doping and medication control program. The program would be administered by the United States Anti-Doping Agency (HADA), the body responsible for administering anti-doping programs for human athletes including the U.S. Olympic teams. The HADA board would include six individuals with horse racing expertise and seven individuals from USADA. It would create uniform drug and medication rules, including lists of permitted and prohibited substances and methods in line with international anti-doping standards and veterinarian ethical standards. The nationwide standards would replace the state-to-state regulation of these issues. The bill is pending in the Subcommittee on Consumer Protection and Commerce.
Related legislation. SB 800 (Dodd) of 2020. Would allow veterinarians to make available the entire medical records of racehorses to specified parties involved in horse racing; requires the CHRB to publish weekly all horse fatalities that occur within a licensed facility, as specified; and requires the CHRB to post results of non-confidential official racehorse drug test samples within five business days of the confirmed negative split sample test result, as specified. (Pending in Senate Governmental Organization Committee)
AB 2177 (Kalra) of 2020. Would, among other things, require the CHRB to adopt rules and regulations for the welfare and safety of racehorses, as specified; require specified licensed track operators to provide computerized tomography scanning equipment to detect potential horse injuries that shall be available onsite; establish an onsite central pharmacy; prohibit training or races at least seven days after any sealing or reinforcement of the track, as specified; authorize the CHRB to require racetracks to transition to high-quality synthetic surfaces, as specified; and require the executive director of the CHRB to make drug test results publicly available. (Pending in the Assembly Governmental Organization Committee)
AB 2615 (Chau) of 2020. Would codify existing regulations requiring that, if a horse suffers a fatal injury on a racetrack in training or in competition, or dies or is euthanized within an area under the jurisdiction of the CHRB, the horse undergo a postmortem examination at a diagnostic laboratory that is under contract with the CHRB, as specified. (Pending in the Assembly Governmental Organization Committee)
Prior legislation. SB 469 (Dodd), Chapter 22, Statutes of 2019. The bill expanded the CHRB’s authority to call an emergency meeting to consider the suspension of a racing license in instances where the health or safety of the horse or rider warrants such action. Any action by the CHRB taken under this authority shall be reviewed by the Board within 10 calendar days. The bill additionally required the Board to adopt emergency regulations to implement this authority. Finally, SB 469 clarified the CHRB’s authority to change, limit, restrict, or reallocate race dates regardless of whether a license to run those dates had been granted.
AB 1723 (Committee on Governmental Organization), Chapter 420, Statues of 2017. Authorized, upon approval of the CHRB, moneys in the backstretch welfare fund to be used to provide treatment for, and support the health care needs of, licensees under the Horse Racing Law, employees of racing associations, and members of horsemen’s and horsewoman’s organizations and other racing-related charitable organizations representing or assisting backstretch personnel, if the need for the treatment and support is related to the person’s participation in the horse racing industry.
SB 317 (Denham), Chapter 77, Statues of 2007. Required applicants for license as an official veterinarian to pass both a written and oral examination, and established qualifications for persons to be admitted to the official veterinarian examination.
SB 921 (Vincent), Chapter 155, Statutes of 2007. Increased the monetary penalty to $100,000 for a violation for administering unauthorized drug substances to a horse entered in a horse race.
AB 52 (Horton), Chapter 179, Statutes of 2005. Required the CHRB to contract with the University of California to be the primary drug-testing laboratory for any required equine drug testing.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
California Authority of Racing Fairs
California Thoroughbred Breeders Association
Service Employees International Union (SEIU California)
Opposition
None on file
Analysis Prepared by: Eric Johnson / G.O. / (916) 319-2531
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):