AB 199: California Online Notary Act of 2019.
- Session Year: 2019-2020
- House: Assembly
- Latest Version Date: 2019-01-10
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Feb 3, 2020 | From committee: Filed with the Chief Clerk pursuant to Joint Rule 56. |
| Jan 31, 2020 | Died pursuant to Art. IV, Sec. 10(c) of the Constitution. |
| Apr 22, 2019 | In committee: Set, first hearing. Hearing canceled at the request of author. |
| Apr 9, 2019 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on JUD. (Ayes 19. Noes 0.) (April 9). Re-referred to Com. on JUD. |
| Feb 4, 2019 | Referred to Com. on B. & P. |
| Jan 11, 2019 | From printer. May be heard in committee February 10. |
| Jan 10, 2019 | Read first time. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Apr 9, 2019 | Do pass and be re-referred to the Committee on [Judiciary] | Assembly Standing Committee on Business and Professions |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
Date of Hearing: April 23, 2019
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON JUDICIARY
Mark Stone, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 199
Author:(Calderon) – As Introduced Ver:January 10, 2019
SUBJECT: California Online Notary Act of 2019
KEY ISSUE: SHOULD CALIFORNIA LEGALIZE REMOTE ONLINE NOTARIZATION WITHOUT addressing ISSUES OF DATA PRESERVATION, EVIDENTIARY ACCESSIBILITY and RELIABILITY, USER PRIVACY, LIABILITY, INSURANCE, AND SECURITY, AND IN SO DOING, potentially THREATEN THE INTEGRITY OF A KEY ANTI-FRAUD MECHANISM IN OUR LEGAL SYSTEM?
SYNOPSIS
This bill would authorize California notaries public to provide remote online notary services over the Internet. It provides only a skeletal framework for online notarization in legislation, instead delegating the responsibility for critical rulemaking to the Secretary of State.
Documents notarized in traditional fashion in-person have robust evidentiary value. Rather than providing similar assurances of evidentiary reliability for online notarization, this bill leaves serious issues of long-term data retention, liability, security, insurance, evidentiary reliability and accessibility, and data privacy unaddressed. Ultimately, without tackling these crucial issues, this bill may endanger the integrity of document authentication and retention practices by prioritizing short-term convenience and embracing the allure of new technology.
This bill is supported by a national notary group, a remote online notary provider, and trade associations for realtors, credit unions, escrow agents, and mortgage bankers. The bill is opposed by an electronic privacy organization, a legal services organization, a coalition of notaries public, a notary business, and a trade association of licensed escrow agents.
SUMMARY: Enacts the California Online Notary Act of 2019 (Act), authorizing remote online notarization of documents within the state. Specifically, this bill:
- Defines the following terms:
- “Online notary public” means a notary public who has registered with the Secretary of State to perform online notarizations.
- “Online notarization” means a notarial act performed by an online notary public by means of audio-video communication technology that meets designated statutory and regulatory standards.
- “Identity proofing” means a process or service through which a third person affirms an individual’s identity based on personal information available from public and proprietary sources.
- “Credential” means a record which evidences an individual’s identity and meets designated statutory standards.
- “Credential analysis” means a process or service through which a third person affirms a credential’s validity based on personal information available from public and proprietary sources.
- “Electronic seal” means information within a notarized electronic record that corresponds to information in notary seals used on paper records.
- “Electronic signature” means an electronic sound, symbol, or process that is attached to an electronic record and is executed or adopted by a person intending to sign the electronic record.
- “Electronic online notarial certificate” means an attachment to an electronic record that is completed by an online notary public, and contains that notary’s electronic seal, electronic signature, and any facts that the notary attests to in the particular notarized transaction.
- Permits a notary public to apply to register with the Secretary of State as an online notary public.
- Authorizes an online notary public physically located in California to perform online notarization for an individual located in California, in another state, or outside the United States if the notary has no actual knowledge that the act is prohibited in the jurisdiction in which the individual is physically located.
- Requires audio-visual communications with an online notary public to consist of continuous, synchronous audio and video feeds with adequate clarity such that all participants can be clearly seen and understood at all times. Grants online notaries public discretion to terminate a session if, in their judgment, this standard is not met.
- Requires online notaries public to keep one or more secure electronic journals to record each online notarial act that they perform.
- Clarifies that the electronic journal is in addition to and apart from any copies of notarized electronic records that are in the online notary public’s possession.
- Establishes standards for what information must be contained in an electronic journal, including, but not limited to:
- The date, time, and type of the act being notarized.
- The physical location of each individual obtaining notary services, as represented to the online notary public at the time of the online notarial act.
- The character of the electronic records being sworn to, affirmed, acknowledged, or proved.
- The electronic signatures of the individuals obtaining online notary services.
- A notation of the type of identification credential provided to the online notary public for credential analysis, and a record of the identity proofing.
- Requires the online notary public to maintain a recording of the online notarization and a notation of the type of credential presented, to be kept in addition and apart from the electronic journal. The online notary public must take reasonable steps to protect the recording from unauthorized use.
- Requires an online notary public who resigns, is disqualified, is removed from office, or allows their registration to expire to deliver their electronic journal to the clerk of the county in which the notary’s oath of office is on file. Also requires that notary to destroy the hardware or password that enables electronic affixation of their electronic signature and seal.
- Establishes requirements for the contents of an electronic seal (which may accompany the notary’s electronic signature on certain documents) and requires an online notary public to ensure that their seal is current.
- Requires the online notary public to keep the notary’s electronic journal, electronic signature, and electronic seal in a secure manner under the notary’s direct and exclusive control. Permits the notary’s electronic journal, electronic signature, and electronic seal to be maintained on a storage device that is accessed with a password or other secure means of authentication. Requires the online notary public to maintain a backup of the journal.
- Mandates that an online notary public notify appropriate law enforcement agencies and the Secretary of State of the loss, compromise, theft, vandalism, or use by another person of the notary’s electronic journal, electronic signature, or electronic seal.
- Provides that failure by the online notary public to secure the electronic signature and electronic seal is cause for public administrative action against the notary by the Secretary of State.
- Requires the online notary public to affix their electronic signature and seal in a manner that is capable of independent verification and which makes evident any tampering or subsequent change or modification of an electronic record that is being notarized.
- Defines the standard of “satisfactory evidence” for an online notary public to verify the identity of an individual seeking notary services.
- Sets forth the form of an online notarial certificate.
- Establishes a maximum $25 fee for online notarial acts.
- Requires the Secretary of State to adopt rules necessary to implement the Act before January 1, 2021.
EXISTING LAW:
- Authorizes the Secretary of State to appoint and commission notaries public and authorizes notaries public to act as such in any part of the state. (Government Code Section 8200.)
- Requires every person appointed as a notary public to meet the following requirements:
- Be a legal resident of the state (with specified exceptions);
- Be not less than 18 years of age;
- After July 1, 2005, have completed a six-hour course of study approved by the Secretary of State; and
- Have satisfactorily completed a written examination prescribed by the Secretary of State. (Government Code Section 8201.)
- Requires the Secretary of State to determine if the applicant possesses the required honesty, credibility, truthfulness, and integrity to fulfill the responsibility of the position and requires the applicant to complete a criminal background check. (Government Code Section 8201.1.)
- When executing a jurat (a notarial act in which the signer is swearing to the content of the document), requires a notary to administer an oath or affirmation and requires the affiant to sign the document in the presence of the notary. (Government Code Section 8202.)
- Establishes the term of office for a notary public of four years. (Government Code Section 8204.)
- Establishes the duties of a notary public, which include taking the acknowledgment or proof of advance health care directives, powers of attorney, mortgages, deeds, grants, transfers, and other instruments of writing executed by any person, and to give a certificate of that proof or acknowledgment, endorsed on or attached to the instrument. (Government Code Section 8205.)
- Requires a notary public to keep one active sequential journal at a time, of all official acts performed as a notary public, with specified information that must be included relating to the identity of the person signing, the fee charged, the document notarized and other information. (Government Code Section 8206.)
- Requires a notary public to provide and keep an official seal, with specified requirements. (Government Code Section 8207.)
- Requires every person appointed a notary public to execute an official bond in the sum of $15,000 in the form of a bond executed by an admitted surety insurer. (Government Code Section 8212.)
- Authorizes the proof or acknowledgement of an instrument to be made outside of the state, but within the United States, before a notary public, a justice, judge, court clerk, or any other officer authorized to take proof of acknowledgment. (Civil Code Section 1182.)
- Provides that any certificate or acknowledgement taken in another place shall be sufficient in this state if it is taken in accordance with the laws of the place where the acknowledgement is made. (Civil Code Section 1189 (b).)
- Defines “satisfactory evidence” as the absence of information, evidence, or other circumstances that would lead a reasonable person to believe that the person making the acknowledgment is not who that person claims to be, and certain other criteria. These criteria include the requirement that if the document to be notarized is a deed, quitclaim deed, deed of trust, or other document affecting real property or a power of attorney document, the notary public shall obtain the signing party to place a thumbprint in the notary’s journal. (Civil Code Section 1185 (b).)
- Requires a notary public not to acknowledge an instrument unless the notary has satisfactory evidence that the person making the acknowledgment is the individual who is described in and who executed the instrument. (Civil Code Section 1185 (a).)
- Provides that a seal is presumed to be genuine and its use authorized if it purports to be the seal of a notary public within any state of the United States. (Evidence Code Section 1452.)
- Provides that in civil and criminal actions, a signature is presumed to be genuine and authorized if it purports to be the signature, affixed in the signer’s official capacity, of a notary public within any state of the United States. (Evidence Code Section 1453.)
FISCAL EFFECT: As currently in print this bill is keyed fiscal.
COMMENTS: AB 199 would authorize a person registered with the California Secretary of State as an online notary public to perform remote online notarizations. In other words, a California online notary could notarize an individual’s signature without ever having the individual personally appear before the notary, as required for notarization under current law.
The bill’s author writes:
Online notarization allows a signer to personally appear before an online notary using audio-visual technology over the internet instead of being physically present in the same room. From a consumer perspective, [remote online notarization] offers a convenient way to allow documents to be notarized on demand anytime and anywhere. Consumers can already safely and securely apply for mortgages online, provide documentation through web portals or smart phones, and check the status of their application all over the internet. But when it comes time to closing, Californians are required to personally meet a notary or invite a mobile notary into their home. This can slow down the mortgage process and be a burden for some Californians, including first-time homebuyers, parents and active duty military.
The key virtue of remote online notarization, something that the author’s statement highlights, is convenience. This point is echoed by the bill’s supporters:
- “In California, when it comes time to close a real estate transaction, the involved parties are still required to personally meet a notary for a physical signing. In today’s fast paced society, finding time for all the parties to sit down together slows down the homebuying process and adds another layer of hassle to an already stressful process.” (Source: California Association of Realtors.)
- “AB 199 would allow a signer to appear before a California notary by way of an online process via a real-time audio-video process. The measure seeks to enact a statutory framework that combines the convenience of an online service with the security of significant additional processes to reliably verify the identity of signers and complete the notarial process.” (Source: California Escrow Association.)
It is undoubtedly inconvenient to use an in-person notary. In-person notarization often requires traveling to a physical location outside of one’s home or office, usually during work hours, and it requires that one remember to bring the proper documentation or identification. In our fast-paced, networked world, there is no doubt that in-person notarization reduces the ease and efficiency of transactions.
But the purpose of the notary system is not efficiency. Its purpose is to help ensure the validity of signatures used to document certain vital, life-altering transactions and events, such as real estate sales and purchases, the granting of powers of attorney, and the creation of advance health care directives. These events and transactions occur relatively rarely in most people’s lives. And lawsuits challenging the legality of these transactions and events regularly turn on proof that a signature was, or was not, validly notarized. To make significant changes in California’s notary laws would have significant implications for California’s civil justice system, and should therefore be undertaken with caution and the utmost care.
This bill—in its present form—may undermine an evidentiary bulwark of California’s legal system. California courts have repeatedly recognized the “important function notaries serve in our society….” (McComber v. Wells (1999) 72 Cal. App. 4th 512, 518.)
The Legislature has also historically recognized the important anti-fraud value of notarial acts. An epidemic of falsified loan documents led to the enactment of a pilot program in Los Angeles County, beginning in 1993, requiring notaries public to obtain the thumb prints of parties signing real estate deeds. (See SB 1842 (Watson) Chap. 815, Stats. 1992.) The program proved so successful at deterring fraud that these requirements were made statewide beginning in 1996. (See AB 1828 (Bustamante) Chap. 569, Stats. 1995.)
Notarized documents have a unique status in California courts, in that a notary public’s seal and signature are both presumed to be authentic. (California Evidence Code Sections 1452, 1453.)
Here is a random sampling of the many California cases in which notarized documents proved significant and the how validity of notarized signatures affected the outcome of legal disputes:
- During a divorce proceeding, a wife sought to demonstrate that she had not signed documents authorizing certain real estate sales, from which her husband had profited. She did so by requesting copies of pages from a notary journal, which in turn revealed that there were no fingerprints in the journal for pertinent sale documents on which fingerprints were required to be obtained. (In re Stone (2010) No. G042002, 2010 WL 1679989, 2010 Cal. App. Unpub. LEXIS 3037.)
- An individual tried to show that a grant deed transferring title to his home, which he supposedly signed when he was in prison, was fraudulent. But the pertinent notary journal entry showed that the notary had met him in prison to notarize his signature. The trial court found that the grant deed was valid and enforceable, relying in part on expert testimony regarding his signature and fingerprint found in the notary journal. (Cardenas v. Fremont Reorganizing Corp. (2012) No. B221963, 2012 Cal. App. Unpub. LEXIS 9307.)
- A man died; a woman claimed his estate on the basis that they were married. However, the private marriage service business which had conducted their wedding years earlier had neglected to register their marriage license. But a page in a notary journal which notarized their signatures on a marriage license, was deemed “sufficient to conclude that the parties believed a valid marriage took place.” (Estate of Jie Chen (2006) No. B182317, 2006 WL 1545714, 2006 Cal. App. Unpub. LEXIS 4900 at *9.)
- A husband forged his wife’s signature on a trust deed securing a loan and then found a notary who would notarize these signatures, despite his wife’s absence. The couple later separated, and the home was foreclosed on when the wife was unable to pay the loan that the husband had fraudulently obtained. The wife discovered her forged signature on the notarized trust deed when it was produced at deposition. (McComber, supra, 72 Cal. App. 4th at 514, 522.)
These are all cases involving ordinary people dealing with rather commonplace life events-- marriage, divorce, death, and (sadly) incarceration—which had a significant effect on their personal and financial circumstances (i.e. whether they were married and therefore entitled to community property, or whether they were responsible for the repayment of loans). There is nothing especially remarkable about the parties or their circumstances. Yet in every case, various features of in-person notarization ensured that essential facts about the challenged transactions were captured: whether or not signatures were forged, whether or not fingerprints were taken, and/or where signatures took place.
Guiding principle: any online notary system should be at least as evidentiarily robust as our present system. Nothing in this analysis should be construed as arguing that California’s present notarial system is perfect or that a system of online notarization is impossible to implement. As shown by the cases described above, notaries sometimes behave negligently or are even complicitly in fraud. And it may be that remote online notarization will reduce some negligence and fraud—for example, elder abuse may be easier to prove if the recording of a notarization shows that a signer was not lucid—if it is done properly, and does not do away with the evidentiary virtues of in-person notarization.
The fundamental premise underlying this analysis is that California should act cautiously in order to ensure and require that the evidentiary reliability of online notarization is at least equal to, if not better than, traditional in-person notarization.
Concern: AB 199 leaves many key points unspecified, leaving (perhaps unwilling) regulators to fill in details. This bill delegates significant authority to the Secretary of State to issue crucial regulations for online notarization. These include:
- Establishing criteria for identity proofing by third parties
- Establishing criteria for credential verification by third parties
- Setting standards for audio-video communication technology
- Adopting rules governing how a notarized electronic record should correspond to the information in notary seals used on paper records
- Establishing form and content requirements for an online notary’s electronic journal
AB 199 only gives the Secretary of State until January 1, 2021 to promulgate these complex and crucial regulations.
It is fair to ask whether the Secretary of State has the expertise to properly specify all of these standards and ensure that they are fraud-proof. While the bill specifies that the Secretary of State “may confer with other departments or agencies on matters relating to equipment, security, and technological aspects of the online notarization standards” (Proposed Government Code Section 8231.3), it is not clear that our state government has the necessary knowledge or experience to fulfill this task. By contrast, consider last year’s AB 2658 (Calderon, Chap. 875, Stats. 2018), by the same author, which established a working group to evaluate the uses, risks, benefits, legal implications, and best practices associated with blockchain technology. The blockchain working group consists of the following participants:
(1) Three appointees from the technology industry.
(2) Three appointees from nontechnology-related industries.
(3) Three appointees with a background in law chosen in consultation with the Judicial Council.
(4) Two appointees representing privacy organizations.
(5) Two appointees representing consumer organizations.
(6) The State Chief Information Officer, or his or her designee.
(7) The Director of Finance, or his or her designee.
(8) The chief information officers of three other state agencies, departments, or commissions. (Government Code Section 11546.9 (b).)
Given the importance of notarial acts to our legal system, it seems reasonable to require a similar assemblage of expertise to be assembled in order to resolve technical issues and assist in rulemaking around AB 199.
Another issue of concern is that the rulemaking process is so much less transparent than the legislative process. Electronic Frontier Foundation, an opponent of the bill, echoes this concern, writing:
[V]irtually every aspect of the privacy and security of remote online notarization, from identity proofing and credential analysis to evaluating potential technology providers, is left to the Secretary of State, which means that the bill provides almost no guidance on these complex issues and that the public will have few details about these technologies or their vendors.
Finally, the Secretary of State’s office appears to be fully cognizant of issues and implementation problems with this bill. In a letter to the author dated June 18, 2018, regarding the virtually-identical AB 2368 (Calderon, 2018), the Secretary of State wrote the following:
[The bill] does not provide clear and complete electronic seal requirements, or ensure that the seal requirements applicable to all other notaries public will match. […] [The bill] eliminates the physical personal appearance of the principal, which is a current requirement for performance of a notarial act, and instead permits a remote appearance by a principal through audio visual communication. However, the bill does not address technology or other requirements surrounding the remote appearance or requirements for presentation of identification presented to the notary public….
This bill seems to suffer from the same deficiencies that were of concern in AB 2368 to the Secretary of State. There is no indication that the author has worked with the Secretary of State to address these issues. Therefore, this Committee may wish to consider whether it is wise and prudent to endorse a measure requiring the Secretary of State to establish the standards above when the Secretary himself decried the absence of legislative guidance on these same points less than one year ago and there is no evidence of any change in circumstances since that time.
Concern—what happens to notarized data if a notary platform were to go out of business without first securing or transferring data; if data were corrupted, or if data were lost? This bill, in its present form, would apparently place responsibility for maintaining records of the online notary system in the hands of platform companies. What happens if one of these companies goes out of business?
Committee staff was informed that Notarize, one of the leading platforms and a supporter of this bill, runs its remote online notary service on Amazon Web Services (AWS). AWS provides robust backup services and is a popular option for many leading Internet companies. But what would happen if Notarize ran out of money and was unable to pay its AWS bills? Would the records of the notarizations that it facilitated disappear for good? What would litigants do if they needed records of one of these notarizations?
Likewise, what would happen if AWS were hacked and data were corrupted or stolen? And what if online notary services used systems that had less robust backup services and simply abandoned their businesses?
Note that these scenarios are not arguments against private provision of notary services. Our present system relies on thousands of private notaries public to safeguard and maintain their journals. But a single lost notary journal imperils the records of, at most, a few hundred transactions. How many records could be lost if one of the platform companies failed? How many transactions could that imperil? Hundreds of thousands? Millions?
As East Bay Community Law Center, an opponent of the bill in its present form, writes:
It seems that at the very least we need a non-networked, well-organized, disaster-proof public repository of all recordings, in a reliable medium of preservation, for at least the duration of all applicable statutes of limitations.
The bill makes no provision for such a repository, beyond requiring notaries to deliver their electronic journals to the county clerk at the end of their commissions. (Proposed Government Code Section 8231.6 (h).) AB 199 does not even specify how online journals are to be transmitted to county clerks, how clerks are to store these journals, or how clerks are to produce records from these journals if they are sought by litigants, let alone how records could be authenticated in the event they could be accessed.
Concern—the bill appears designed to insulate the online notary platforms from liability, does not adequately address security, and makes no provision for insurance. Another item of substantial concern is that AB 199 makes little reference to the platform companies that will be facilitating the provision of remote online notary services. Instead, the onus is placed on the individual notary public to:
- Maintain the “recording of an online notarization that is the basis for evidence of identity….” (Proposed Gov’t Code Section 8231.6 (d).)
- “[T]ake reasonable steps to ensure that the audio-video communication used in an online notarization is secure from unauthorized interception.” (Proposed Gov’t Code Section 8231.8 (b).)
- “[K]eep the online notary public’s electronic signature and electronic seal in a secure manner under the direct and exclusive control of the online notary public….” (Proposed Gov’t Code Section 8231.7 (d))
Indeed, the wording of this bill appears geared towards the goal of insulating platform companies from all liability. If data stored by platform companies were stolen, corrupted or intercepted, these companies would be able to point at the text of AB 199 and disclaim all responsibility for their errors, placing the blame (statutorily) on the individual notaries, who are likely far the less sophisticated of the two parties and who are also less likely to have the resources to pay any judgments that were issued against them.
Such an insulation from liability is undesirable, given that it is the platform companies who have the resources and technological expertise to invest in the necessary security measures to safeguard the pertinent data. Note that it is not appropriate to absolve individual notaries, either, of responsibility or liability: of course they should use encrypted communications, devise highly-secure passwords that they change regularly and keep private, and the like. But to make notaries themselves the only responsible party identified in statute is undesirable and potentially harmful to consumers.
One can envision a number of quite realistic security risks presented by remote online notarization:
- Information regarding individuals’ most personal financial, familial, and medical affairs, gleaned from documents such as wills and advance directives, might be available to hackers. As noted above, at least one platform company uses AWS to operate its service. Data security on AWS is by no means guaranteed. (See Frier et al., Millions of Facebook Records Found on Amazon Cloud Servers (Apr. 3, 2019) Bloomberg, available at https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2019-04-03/millions-of-facebook-records-found-on-amazon-cloud-servers [quoting one expert as saying, “Not enough care is being put into the security side of big data.”].)
- Documents that are kept by the notary public, such as recordings of notarizations and the notary’s electronic journal, may be stolen by hackers (if kept online) or by ordinary thieves (if kept at home on a personal computer).
- Data, even in encrypted and anonymized form, may be intercepted as it is being transmitted over the Internet.
- The answers to identity proving questions may be given by close relatives who know the victim well.
- Credentials, such as driver’s licenses and passports, may be falsified, as distinctive characteristics of falsification are harder to detect over a camera.
Public key certificate. The bill does provide specific guidance regarding one form of credential that is acceptable: a “public key certificate that conforms with standards adopted by the Secretary of State by rule.” (Proposed Government Code Section 8231.8 (a)(3).) But even this specific standard begs the question: is current technology able to produce a non-hackable form of such a certificate?
This is not to say the technology should not be adopted or that an online notary system is impossible to implement. But adequate consideration must be given to questions of how to mitigate security risks. This is to say nothing of the fact that sensitive data will be in the hands of individual notaries, many of whom are relatively unsophisticated in managing technology.
Insurance coverage. Even if the bill were revised to adequately delineate responsibility and liability between platforms and individual notaries, it would also need to address questions of insurance coverage. Given that California law requires documentation of real estate transactions to be notarized, platform companies will potentially be facilitating transactions collectively worth hundreds of billions of dollars under the bill. The Committee may wish to consider what is the adequate level of insurance if documentation of these transactions were to be corrupted, lost, or stolen?
Concern—can online notarization provide signers with the same evidentiary indisputability as a fingerprint? If a document to be notarized is a power of attorney or a document that affects ownership of real property, then existing law requires each of the parties signing the document to place a thumbprint in the notary journal. At this point in time, it is not possible to falsify a thumbprint, as even identical twins’ fingerprints differ from one another. At the same time, it is certainly possible that a person’s electronic fingerprints may be accessed in electronic form. Therefore, obtaining an electronic fingerprint via remote means does not ensure identity in the same way that a physical fingerprint does.
It is critical to ensure that some aspect of the record of an online notarization, at least of these most sensitive documents, is indisputably unique, and cannot be faked. This is a significant technological challenge, since any digital data consists of a series of zeroes and ones, and presumably can be forged. It might be that this problem could be solved, for example, by requiring that the recording of a notarial transaction be copied in real-time into a designated repository. It is less likely that two different versions, rather than one, would be corrupted or hacked.
Proponents will likely assert that identity verification, credential verification, and recording of the transaction are enough to ensure that signers’ identities can be uniquely established. That may be the case. However, intimates often know the answers to identity-proofing questions, IDs can be falsified or forged, and people’s appearance and voices can change, whether due to age, accidents, illnesses, or surgery. As the examples mentioned above indicate, it is not impossible for spouses and close friends to attempt to defraud one another. The Legislature should be cautious to ensure that it does not facilitate a means to conduct such fraudulent activity.
The Committee may wish to consider whether decisions about how to ensure the absolute uniqueness of the record of an online transaction is a question that ought to be decided in consultation with a working group of technical experts.
Concern—will evidence of online notarization be as easy to obtain as evidence of traditional notarization? Obtaining evidence of in-person notarization in California is straightforward. Any member of the public can make a written request to a notary public for a copy of a transaction in the notary’s journal. The notary must respond within 15 business days of receipt of the request with either a photocopy of the corresponding line item(s) in the notary’s journal or with an acknowledgment that no such line item exists.
It is also relatively easy to enforce a subpoena compelling production of a California notary’s journal at trial or deposition.
The situation would be more complicated under AB 199 if notaries are unable to produce the requested documents. Crucial recordings and other evidence of notarial acts may be under the control of entities incorporated and headquartered outside of California. Enforcing out-of-state subpoenas is notoriously time-consuming and potentially expensive, despite California’s 2008 adoption of the Uniform Interstate Depositions and Discovery Act. (See Code of Civil Procedure Sections 2029.100-2029.900.) Litigants must generally determine the appropriate jurisdiction in which to seek the records and then seek issuance of a subpoena from an appropriate court in that jurisdiction. If the recipient of the subpoena ignores or disobeys the subpoena, litigation may be necessary in that out-of-state jurisdiction.
It would be desirable for AB 199 to address this problem head on, perhaps by placing records of online notarizations directly within the jurisdiction of California courts. The Committee may wish to consider whether it is important for platform companies to weigh in on potential costs or risks associated with such a requirement prior to codifying it.
Concern—will platform companies seek to mine and commercialize information recorded in notarized transactions? A group of notaries who call themselves Oppose AB 199 write:
[T]his bill contains no language that protects the principal document(s) or the notary’s journal information from being mined, shared, or sold by the handful of technology companies hosting the online platforms required by this bill. We feel that because the journal is the public record, special attributes are essential to protect this data.
When asked about this concern, the author’s office responded:
When the California Consumer Privacy Act becomes effective on January 1, 2020, California will lead the nation in standards for consent of data sales. Consumers will have the right to know ALL data collected by a business, twice a year, free of charge, right to say NO to the sale of your information, right to know the categories of third parties with whom your data is share[d], right to know the categories of sources of information from whom your data was acquired, right to know the business or commercial purpose of collecting your information. Enforcement is via a private right of action (consumer lawsuits) for data breaches, with the rest of the act subject to enforcement by the California Attorney General, at up to $2,500 per violation. Realistically, people who have trepidations about their data privacy will not use an online notary, much the same way someone who is uncomfortable would not use Facebook or Instagram.
This answer is disquieting. Many of the notarizations that will be performed online will relate to real estate transactions, where real estate agents will likely recommend a notarization platform, just as they recommend an escrow agent and title company. These recommendations are almost always accepted by buyers and sellers, who generally will not insist on an in-person notary. And for non-real estate transactions, many people will likely bring the same expectation of privacy to online notarization that they do to in-person notarization. The Committee may wish to consider whether the California Consumer Privacy Act provides sufficient safeguards for data privacy in online notarization, or whether more targeted protections, crafted with the input of privacy advocates and experts, is preferable.
As Electronic Frontier Foundation, an opponent of the bill, writes:
[R]emote online notarization via audiovisual recording creates significantly greater data privacy issues than traditional notarization, especially given public concerns about facial (both static and expressional) and voice biometrics. A remote online notary will have much more data than a traditional notary would. This bill should outline how that data should be safeguarded, and whether it can be sold or shared. AB 199 does not adequately address issues around how remote online notaries must protect the privacy and security of Californians’ data.
A cautionary tale: MERS, Texas, and the 2008 foreclosure crisis. There seems to be some fear among the bill’s proponents that California, as a technology leader, ought not to fall behind other states in authorizing remote online notarization. Accompanying this fear may be the Silicon Valley ethos to “move fast and break stuff.”
But remote online notarization is not just a disruptive technology that promises to shake up a moribund industry in order to do to notaries what Airbnb has done to hotels and Expedia had done to travel agents. As discussed above, notarization is also an evidentiary plank of our judicial system. In order to avoid foreseeable harms, caution should be taken before altering its fundamental structure.
Two examples from the years leading up to the 2008 foreclosure crisis may be instructive. The first is that of the Mortgage Electronic Registration System (MERS), a private online repository of real estate transaction data that was created in the mid-1990’s to circumvent cumbersome state and local recording requirements and fees:
Despite the lack of public debate or legislative approval, this database commandeered the land recording system for a substantial majority of mortgages in the United States. Instead of filing with county recording offices each time a mortgage transferred—and paying that fee—banks instead listed MERS as the “mortgagee of record” in the initial mortgage assignment. Then, for subsequent transfers, the parties would go to the MERS database and list trades on an electronic spreadsheet. Banks could make unlimited transactions inside MERS; the county recorder only knew about the original assignment. (Dayen, Chain of Title (2016) p. 47.)
The consequences of making our title system more efficient through technology proved severe:
Thousands of low-level workers across the county who worked at mortgage servicers or their law firms became “vice presidents” and “assistant secretaries” of MERS…. Under [its] membership agreement, MERS empowered these “corporate officers” to execute whatever documents were necessary for loans in the MERS system. […] Three centuries of American land title operations had been outsourced to a shell company created by big banks so they could save a buck—and they were using it to circumvent established procedures and kick people out of their homes. […]
If evidence in a judicial proceeding can be faked and nobody challenges the fakeries, the legitimacy of the system breaks down. Anyone can be swept up and condemned to eviction based on false documents or inaccurate testimony. (Ibid., p. 49-50.)
In order to ensure that California does not embark down the same road with notarization that was taken with the title system, by seizing on the latest technology to eliminate a supposedly-inefficient system but in the process discarding its virtues and harming ordinary people in the process, the Legislature may need to resist the siren’s call to move fast and break stuff. Rather, a more conservative and old fashioned approach perhaps should be taken: if it’s not broke, don’t fix it.
The bill’s authors and supporters put great stock in the fact that 16 states have passed legislation authorizing remote online notarization. This number is a bit misleading. Virginia legalized remote online notarization in 2012, and Montana followed suit in 2015, albeit with many more restrictions than this bill proposes to adopt. Texas and Nevada’s laws went into effect in 2018, and Minnesota’s became effective at the beginning of 2019. While eleven other states have passed authorizing legislation, their laws are either not yet effective, or are awaiting rulemaking by their respective secretaries of state. (See Lewis, Remote Notarization: What You Need To Know (updated Apr. 2, 2019) available at https://www.nationalnotary.org/notary-bulletin/blog/2018/06/remote-notarization-what-you-need-to-know.)
In other words, remote online notarization has not been robustly tested by other states’ legal systems, so it is simply too soon to identify the virtues and failings of the laws they have adopted.
Again, an example from the financial crisis is instructive:
In Texas, the story was different. The Federal Housing Finance Agency house price index fell less than 1 percent in Texas from its peak in 2007 to its trough in 2011, while it plunged 20 percent nationally…. With relatively stable house prices in Texas, the incidence of underwater mortgages was a fraction of what occurred in hard-hit states such as California, Florida, Arizona and Nevada. Even among subprime borrowers—those constituting the greatest credit risk—Texas default rates remained well below the national average during the recession and subsequent tepid recovery. The Texas experience presents an important case study, in part because of a unique state law. Texas is the only state with a regulation limiting home equity borrowing. After purchase, mortgage debt along with any new borrowing—including home equity loans—cannot exceed 80 percent of a home’s market value unless the new debt funds home improvements. Consequently, the state has lower levels of “cash-outs”—owners taking money out of their houses during a refinancing. Through the boom, the rates of mortgage debt growth and consumer spending in response to house price appreciation were more restrained in Texas. (Kumar & Skelton, Did Home Equity Restrictions Help Keep Texas Mortgages From Going Underwater? (3rd Q 2013) Federal Reserve Bank of Dallas Southwest Economy, p. 3.)
In the late 1990s and early 2000s, both state and federal governments raced to deregulate financial institutions and dismantle prudential lending standards, viewing them as an old-fashioned impediment to commerce. Millions ultimately suffered, losing their life savings and their homes. Texas stayed steadfast, perhaps due to memories of the savings & loan crisis of the early 1990s and managed to protect its residents. There is a lesson to be learned here for California. Our Legislature has the responsibility to maintain the virtues of our existing notary system even as it considers how to implement online notarization before moving forward.
Conclusion: the most sensible approach to addressing the concerns raised would be to provide adequate time for comprehensive discussions by stakeholders. AB 199’s author and supporters are confident that the issues flagged above will be addressed as the bill winds its way through the Legislature. But it is unclear at what stage relevant stakeholders and experts will be brought to the table to work through the relevant issues. The author’s office claims to have engaged with stakeholders regarding the Committee’s expressed concerns. But when pressed, they have been unable to identify any consumer protection, electronic privacy, or legal services organizations with whom they have consulted on this bill; nor have they demonstrated that the concerns raised by the Secretary of State about last year’s been have been addressed.
It is vital to deal with the issues raised above in a comprehensive manner, because drafting decisions made in one area may negatively impact other areas. For example, when asked about AB 199’s silence on the issue of platform liability, the author’s office suggested incorporating provisions of the National Notary Association’s model legislation (available at https://www.nationalnotary.org/file%20library/nna/reference-library/model-enotarization-act.pdf) which define and/or utilize the terms “electronic notarization system” and “electronic notarization system provider” and address the interplay between notary and provider liability. This an excellent suggestion that ought to be considered—but this suggestion should be considered in the context of the many questions raised above about the role of providers in obtaining insurance, in maintaining data even in the event of their insolvency, in responding to subpoenas, and so on.
AB 199’s nearly-identical predecessor, AB 2368 (Calderon, 2018), received unanimous support in the California Assembly last year. But that bill was not referred to this Committee, and therefore was not analyzed for its impact on our legal system, or the liability of persons participating in an online notary program.
Ultimately, the Committee may wish to consider whether the present notary system is so broken that California cannot take a year to ensure that this legislation implements a robust, reliable online system for the decades to come.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
California Association of Realtors
California Credit Union League
California Escrow Association
California Mortgage Bankers Association
National Notary Association
Notarize
Support if Amended
California Land Title Association
Oppose Unless Amended
East Bay Community Law Center
Escrow Institute of California
Opposition
Beverly Enterprises, LLC
Electronic Frontier Foundation
Oppose AB 199
Analysis Prepared by: Jith Meganathan / JUD. / (916) 319-2334
Date of Hearing:
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON BUSINESS AND PROFESSIONS
Evan Low, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 199
Author:(Calderon) – As Introduced Ver:January 10, 2019
SUBJECT: California Online Notary Act of 2019.
SUMMARY: Allows a notary public or an applicant for appointment as a notary public to register with the Secretary of State to be an online notary public by submitting an application for registration that meets certain requirements.
EXISTING LAW:
- Authorizes the Secretary of State to appoint and commission notaries public and authorizes notaries public to act as such in any part of the state. (Government Code § 8200)
- Requires every person appointed as a notary public to meet the following requirements:
- Be a legal resident of the state (with specified exceptions);
- Be not less than 18 years of age;
- After July 1, 2005, have completed a six-hour course of study approved by the Secretary of State;
- Have satisfactorily completed a written examination prescribed by the Secretary of State.
- Requires the Secretary of State to determine the applicant possesses the required honesty, credibility, truthfulness, and integrity to fulfill the responsibility of the position and requires the applicant to complete a criminal background check. (Government Code § 8201.1)
- When exciting a jurat (a notarial act in which the signer is swearing to the content of the document), requires a notary to administer an oath or affirmation and requires the affiant to sign the document in the presence of the notary. (Government Code § 8202)
- Establishes the term of office for a notary public of four years. (Government Code § 8204)
- Establishes the duty of a notary public, when requested:
- To demand acceptance and payment of foreign and inland bills of exchange, or promissory notes, to protest them for nonacceptance and nonpayment, and, with regard only to the nonacceptance or nonpayment of bills and notes, to exercise any other powers and duties that by the law of nations and according to commercial usages, or by the laws of any other state, government, or country, may be performed by a notary. This paragraph applies only to a notary public employed by a financial institution, during the course and scope of the notary’s employment with the financial institution;
- To take the acknowledgment or proof of advance health care directives, powers of attorney, mortgages, deeds, grants, transfers, and other instruments of writing executed by any person, and to give a certificate of that proof or acknowledgment, endorsed on or attached to the instrument. The certificate shall be signed by the notary public in the notary public’s own handwriting. A notary public may not accept any acknowledgment or proof of any instrument that is incomplete;
- To take deposits and affidavits, and administer oaths and affirmations, in all matters incident to the duties of the office, or to be used before any court, judge, officer, or board;
- To certify copies of powers of attorney;
- To furnish to the Secretary of State certified copies of the notary’s journal. (Government Code § 8205)
- Requires a notary public to keep one active sequential journal at a time, of all official acts performed as a notary public, with specified information that must be included relating to the identity of the person signing, the fee charged, the document notarized and other information. (Government Code § 8206)
- Requires a notary public to provide and keep an official seal, with specified requirements. (Government Code § 8207)
- Establishes the maximum fees that a notary public may charge, including $15 for taking an acknowledgement or proof of a deed, $15 for administering an oath or affirmation, $30 for all services rendered in connection with the taking of any deposition (including $7 for administering the oath to the witness and $7 for the certificate). (Government Code § 8211)
- Requires every person appointed a notary public to execute an official bond in the sum of $15,000 in the form of a bond executed by an admitted surety insurer. (Government Code § 8212)
- Authorizes the proof or acknowledgement of an instrument to be made outside of the state, but within the United States, before a notary public, a justice, judge, court clerk, or any other officer authorized to take proof of acknowledgment. (Civil Code § 1182)
- Provides that any certificate or acknowledgement taken in another place shall be sufficient in this state if it is taken in accordance with the laws of the place where the acknowledgement is made. (Civil Code § 1189(b))
THIS BILL:
- Authorizes remote online notarization (RON) in California by permitting an online notary public, approved by the Secretary of State, to take the acknowledgement or oath of a signer who personally appears before the notary by a secure two-way interactive audio and video communication.
- Reflects the recommendations of National Association of Secretaries of State (NASS) and would not replace or impact existing laws relating to paper notarization or current electronic notarization based on physical appearance before the notary. Consumers would still have the option of personally appearing before a notary, if it is their preference.
- Requires the use of a secure, tamper proof technology, approved by the Secretary of State, to digitally record the notarial act between the notary and signer. A multilayer identity verification of the signer would be required including: presentation of a photo ID, credential analysis, and identity proofing. The bill would also require disclosure in the online notary public’s acknowledgment evidencing the fact that the notarization was performed online, and an online notary will be required to keep a secure electronic journal with each notarial act performed.
- Would become operative on January 1, 2021.
FISCAL EFFECT: Unknown. This bill is keyed fiscal by Legislative Counsel.
COMMENTS:
Purpose. This bill is Author sponsored. According to the Author, “Technology and the internet have simplified electronic transactions including mortgages. Consumers can already safely and securely apply for mortgages online, provide documentation through web portals or smart phones, and check the status of their application all over the internet. But when it comes time to closing, Californians are required to personally meet a notary or invite a mobile notary into their home. This can slow down the mortgage process and be a burden for some Californians, including first-time homebuyers, parents and active duty military. As other states move toward remote online notarization, California needs to keep up with this 21st Century innovation and implement this new technology in a safe, secure, consumer-friendly way that ensures the California Secretary of State maintains regulatory control.”
Background. The Secretary of State is authorized to appoint and commission notaries, who have met specified education, examination, and ethical background requirements. Notary appointments are good for four years. All applicants for appointment must complete the Notary Public Application form prescribed by the Secretary each time they apply for a commission, whether they currently hold a commission as a notary public, a previous commission has expired, or they are applying for the first time. Notaries public who wish to renew their appointments must apply, complete a refresher course, and pass an exam before the expiration of their first appointment if they wish to avoid a break in notary public commission terms. A notary public’s jurisdiction is not limited to the county in which the notary public’s oath and bond are filed, but a California notary public cannot perform notarial acts outside of state borders.
The most common services provided by notaries public include acknowledgments, oaths and affirmations, witness signatures, and certified copies of documents that are not public or vital records. Notaries public are required to purchase a notarial seal from an approved vendor and to keep that seal secure in their own possession. Notaries public also have a responsibility to maintain a journal detailing all of their acknowledgements, and to keep that journal safely secured. California law does not set a minimum fee, but currently caps the maximum fee that a notary public may charge at $15 per signature for most notarial acts.
A notary public must obtain a bond from a California admitted surety insurer in the amount of $15,000. The bond must be filed with the county clerk of the county in which the notary public’s principal place of business is located. The bond is to provide a limited fund to reimburse members of the public who are damaged by notarial misconduct. However, the notary public and the surety named on the notary public’s official bond are liable in a civil action for all the damages sustained from a notary public’s misconduct or neglect. Since there may be personal liability for the notary public to the surety for the amount paid on the bond as damages and if the damages exceed the amount of the bond, the Secretary advises notary publics to consider purchasing errors and omissions insurance, or some other type of liability insurance, to cover damages that may occur in the course of performing their notarial duties.
In-person versus online notarization. Under current law, notarizations are performed face-to-face with a notary public. This allows the notary public to verify the principal’s identity for the notarization. As technology has evolved and the public has become accustomed to engaging in more transactions online, there has been consideration given to the feasibility of providing online notary services.
To date, twelve states have considered authorizing online notarization. Virginia currently allows electronic notarial acts. Notaries performing electronic notarial acts are authorized to use an electronic signature and seal to record electronic documents. Allowed electronic notarial acts include taking acknowledgements, administering oaths, certifying affidavits, and other acts. Electronic notarization in Virginia can be performed in person or through audio-video conference technology.
Two states, Texas and Nevada, have authorized online notarization in statute, but have not yet implemented it. Currently, both states are in the process of developing the regulations for online notarization and in both cases such services are authorized in law to begin in July 2018.
Security of online notarization. In order for entities that commonly receive notarized documents, such as banks and title companies, to know that the documents are equally reliable as those notarized in person, the standards for online notarization will need to ensure reliability and security.
This bill would require the Secretary of State to adopt rules necessary to implement the bill, including standards for remote presentation, credential analysis, and identify proofing. Rather than put complex technical requirements into statute, the bill gives the Secretary broad authority to set the technological standards necessary to implement online notarization. Given the rapid pace of technological evolution, it seems appropriate to leave the development of technical specifications and requirements to the regulatory process.
National Standards. The National Association of Secretaries of State (NASS) has been considering the use of advanced technology for electronic notarization since 2006. Initially, NASS considered and adopted standards for in person electronic notarization (i.e. notarization of an electronic document after a face to face meeting with the principal). Subsequent amendments to those standards address remote notarization. Those amendments were adopted in 2018. The standards adopted by NASS are general in concept and technology neutral. Similar to this bill, the standards address key issues and requirements, but do not provide detailed technical requirements.
Interstate recognition. Under current law and practice, California recognizes notarizations that are performed in other states, provided that they are performed according to the laws in that state. Similarly, other states recognize notarizations performed in California. Presumably, this authority would extend to online notarizations authorized in other states.
It is yet not clear how the burgeoning practice of online notarization will be recognized by the states. As noted above, the standards for performing notarizations do not vary considerably between the states and reciprocity between the states is observed. As online notarization develops, it is not clear whether the standards adopted by different states will be as similar as the standards for in-person notarization. If standards vary widely between the states, California may need to consider whether it is appropriate to continue to recognize online notarizations performed in other states.
Prior Related Legislation.
AB 2368 (Calderon, 2018), from Senate Committee without further action
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT:
According to, Notarize, “[t]his bill contains key provisions and protections that will enable the
California program to be robust, safe and secure, while also letting technology thrive. Notarize argues that this bill is consistent with the uniform models and principles established by the National Association of Secretaries of State as well as the Mortgage Bankers Association/American Land Title Association.”
California Credit Union League and California Mortgage Bankers Association believe this new technology has many consumer and business benefits including making the notary process more efficient and secure for Californians. We believe AB 199 puts important safeguards around online notarizations while also providing regulatory flexibility for the Secretary of State, who commissions and oversees notaries in California.
In agreement is the California Escrow Association, who argues, “[u]nder current law, a California notary may only notarize a signer who appears physically before them. AB 199 would allow a signer to appear before a California notary by way of an online process via a real-time audio-video process. The measure seeks to enact a statutory framework that combines the convenience of an online service with the security of significant additional processes to reliably verify the identity of signers and complete the notarial process.”
California Association of Realtors additionally argues that, “[this bill] would make real estate transaction faster and more convenient for homebuyers and sellers.”
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION:
According to Escrow Institute of California, this bill lacks:
- Adequate security measures;
- Necessary protections to safeguard against excessive liabilities;
- A universal database that is properly monitored by state agencies; and
- A uniform process for security and storage.
POLICY ISSUE(S) FOR CONSIDERATION:
The bill authorizes an online notary public located in California to provide an online notarization to a person inside or outside of the state. Thus, California online notaries could provide notarization services to individuals in other states. Presumably, others states could grant the same authority to notary publics in their state. Over time, this may lead to a nationwide market for notary public services, as consumers in California (and other states) could have their need for notarization services met by notary publics in any state that allows notarization services to be provided to individuals outside their state.
As this system evolves, the Secretary of State and the Legislature will need to consider whether the needs of consumers and those entities that rely on notarized documents are being met in a secure and reliable manner.
Amendments are anticipated to address concerns about ensuring notarial acts are able to be used in court proceedings. Standards for quality of recordings and storage and security may be necessary. Further amendments are anticipated to address concerns surrounding the use of new technologies that allow for remote real time signatures, including remote signatures made in ink.
IMPLEMENTATION ISSUES:
The bill gives the Secretary of State the responsibility to adopt rules to implement the bill and defers many of the detailed requirements needed to facilitate online notarization to those rules.
The development of those rules by the Secretary of State is likely to require significant effort. The Secretary will need to consider both the evolving technologies that can facilitate online notarization and technologies that could be used to subvert the process.
REGISTERED SUPPORT:
California Association of Realtors
California Credit Union League
California Escrow Association
California Mortgage Bankers Association
National Notary Association
Notarize
REGISTERED OPPOSITION:
Escrow Institute of California
Analysis Prepared by: Danielle Sires / B. & P. / (916) 319-3301
Date of Hearing:
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON BUSINESS AND PROFESSIONS
Evan Low, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 199
Author:(Calderon) – As Introduced Ver:January 10, 2019
SUBJECT: California Online Notary Act of 2019.
SUMMARY: Allows a notary public or an applicant for appointment as a notary public to register with the Secretary of State to be an online notary public by submitting an application for registration that meets certain requirements.
EXISTING LAW:
- Authorizes the Secretary of State to appoint and commission notaries public and authorizes notaries public to act as such in any part of the state. (Government Code § 8200)
- Requires every person appointed as a notary public to meet the following requirements:
- Be a legal resident of the state (with specified exceptions);
- Be not less than 18 years of age;
- After July 1, 2005, have completed a six-hour course of study approved by the Secretary of State;
- Have satisfactorily completed a written examination prescribed by the Secretary of State.
- Requires the Secretary of State to determine the applicant possesses the required honesty, credibility, truthfulness, and integrity to fulfill the responsibility of the position and requires the applicant to complete a criminal background check. (Government Code § 8201.1)
- When exciting a jurat (a notarial act in which the signer is swearing to the content of the document), requires a notary to administer an oath or affirmation and requires the affiant to sign the document in the presence of the notary. (Government Code § 8202)
- Establishes the term of office for a notary public of four years. (Government Code § 8204)
- Establishes the duty of a notary public, when requested:
- To demand acceptance and payment of foreign and inland bills of exchange, or promissory notes, to protest them for nonacceptance and nonpayment, and, with regard only to the nonacceptance or nonpayment of bills and notes, to exercise any other powers and duties that by the law of nations and according to commercial usages, or by the laws of any other state, government, or country, may be performed by a notary. This paragraph applies only to a notary public employed by a financial institution, during the course and scope of the notary’s employment with the financial institution;
- To take the acknowledgment or proof of advance health care directives, powers of attorney, mortgages, deeds, grants, transfers, and other instruments of writing executed by any person, and to give a certificate of that proof or acknowledgment, endorsed on or attached to the instrument. The certificate shall be signed by the notary public in the notary public’s own handwriting. A notary public may not accept any acknowledgment or proof of any instrument that is incomplete;
- To take deposits and affidavits, and administer oaths and affirmations, in all matters incident to the duties of the office, or to be used before any court, judge, officer, or board;
- To certify copies of powers of attorney;
- To furnish to the Secretary of State certified copies of the notary’s journal. (Government Code § 8205)
- Requires a notary public to keep one active sequential journal at a time, of all official acts performed as a notary public, with specified information that must be included relating to the identity of the person signing, the fee charged, the document notarized and other information. (Government Code § 8206)
- Requires a notary public to provide and keep an official seal, with specified requirements. (Government Code § 8207)
- Establishes the maximum fees that a notary public may charge, including $15 for taking an acknowledgement or proof of a deed, $15 for administering an oath or affirmation, $30 for all services rendered in connection with the taking of any deposition (including $7 for administering the oath to the witness and $7 for the certificate). (Government Code § 8211)
- Requires every person appointed a notary public to execute an official bond in the sum of $15,000 in the form of a bond executed by an admitted surety insurer. (Government Code § 8212)
- Authorizes the proof or acknowledgement of an instrument to be made outside of the state, but within the United States, before a notary public, a justice, judge, court clerk, or any other officer authorized to take proof of acknowledgment. (Civil Code § 1182)
- Provides that any certificate or acknowledgement taken in another place shall be sufficient in this state if it is taken in accordance with the laws of the place where the acknowledgement is made. (Civil Code § 1189(b))
THIS BILL:
- Authorizes remote online notarization (RON) in California by permitting an online notary public, approved by the Secretary of State, to take the acknowledgement or oath of a signer who personally appears before the notary by a secure two-way interactive audio and video communication.
- Reflects the recommendations of National Association of Secretaries of State (NASS) and would not replace or impact existing laws relating to paper notarization or current electronic notarization based on physical appearance before the notary. Consumers would still have the option of personally appearing before a notary, if it is their preference.
- Requires the use of a secure, tamper proof technology, approved by the Secretary of State, to digitally record the notarial act between the notary and signer. A multilayer identity verification of the signer would be required including: presentation of a photo ID, credential analysis, and identity proofing. The bill would also require disclosure in the online notary public’s acknowledgment evidencing the fact that the notarization was performed online, and an online notary will be required to keep a secure electronic journal with each notarial act performed.
- Would become operative on January 1, 2021.
FISCAL EFFECT: Unknown. This bill is keyed fiscal by Legislative Counsel.
COMMENTS:
Purpose. This bill is Author sponsored. According to the Author, “Technology and the internet have simplified electronic transactions including mortgages. Consumers can already safely and securely apply for mortgages online, provide documentation through web portals or smart phones, and check the status of their application all over the internet. But when it comes time to closing, Californians are required to personally meet a notary or invite a mobile notary into their home. This can slow down the mortgage process and be a burden for some Californians, including first-time homebuyers, parents and active duty military. As other states move toward remote online notarization, California needs to keep up with this 21st Century innovation and implement this new technology in a safe, secure, consumer-friendly way that ensures the California Secretary of State maintains regulatory control.”
Background. The Secretary of State is authorized to appoint and commission notaries, who have met specified education, examination, and ethical background requirements. Notary appointments are good for four years. All applicants for appointment must complete the Notary Public Application form prescribed by the Secretary each time they apply for a commission, whether they currently hold a commission as a notary public, a previous commission has expired, or they are applying for the first time. Notaries public who wish to renew their appointments must apply, complete a refresher course, and pass an exam before the expiration of their first appointment if they wish to avoid a break in notary public commission terms. A notary public’s jurisdiction is not limited to the county in which the notary public’s oath and bond are filed, but a California notary public cannot perform notarial acts outside of state borders.
The most common services provided by notaries public include acknowledgments, oaths and affirmations, witness signatures, and certified copies of documents that are not public or vital records. Notaries public are required to purchase a notarial seal from an approved vendor and to keep that seal secure in their own possession. Notaries public also have a responsibility to maintain a journal detailing all of their acknowledgements, and to keep that journal safely secured. California law does not set a minimum fee, but currently caps the maximum fee that a notary public may charge at $15 per signature for most notarial acts.
A notary public must obtain a bond from a California admitted surety insurer in the amount of $15,000. The bond must be filed with the county clerk of the county in which the notary public’s principal place of business is located. The bond is to provide a limited fund to reimburse members of the public who are damaged by notarial misconduct. However, the notary public and the surety named on the notary public’s official bond are liable in a civil action for all the damages sustained from a notary public’s misconduct or neglect. Since there may be personal liability for the notary public to the surety for the amount paid on the bond as damages and if the damages exceed the amount of the bond, the Secretary advises notary publics to consider purchasing errors and omissions insurance, or some other type of liability insurance, to cover damages that may occur in the course of performing their notarial duties.
In-person versus online notarization. Under current law, notarizations are performed face-to-face with a notary public. This allows the notary public to verify the principal’s identity for the notarization. As technology has evolved and the public has become accustomed to engaging in more transactions online, there has been consideration given to the feasibility of providing online notary services.
To date, twelve states have considered authorizing online notarization. Virginia currently allows electronic notarial acts. Notaries performing electronic notarial acts are authorized to use an electronic signature and seal to record electronic documents. Allowed electronic notarial acts include taking acknowledgements, administering oaths, certifying affidavits, and other acts. Electronic notarization in Virginia can be performed in person or through audio-video conference technology.
Two states, Texas and Nevada, have authorized online notarization in statute, but have not yet implemented it. Currently, both states are in the process of developing the regulations for online notarization and in both cases such services are authorized in law to begin in July 2018.
Security of online notarization. In order for entities that commonly receive notarized documents, such as banks and title companies, to know that the documents are equally reliable as those notarized in person, the standards for online notarization will need to ensure reliability and security.
This bill would require the Secretary of State to adopt rules necessary to implement the bill, including standards for remote presentation, credential analysis, and identify proofing. Rather than put complex technical requirements into statute, the bill gives the Secretary broad authority to set the technological standards necessary to implement online notarization. Given the rapid pace of technological evolution, it seems appropriate to leave the development of technical specifications and requirements to the regulatory process.
National Standards. The National Association of Secretaries of State (NASS) has been considering the use of advanced technology for electronic notarization since 2006. Initially, NASS considered and adopted standards for in person electronic notarization (i.e. notarization of an electronic document after a face to face meeting with the principal). Subsequent amendments to those standards address remote notarization. Those amendments were adopted in 2018. The standards adopted by NASS are general in concept and technology neutral. Similar to this bill, the standards address key issues and requirements, but do not provide detailed technical requirements.
Interstate recognition. Under current law and practice, California recognizes notarizations that are performed in other states, provided that they are performed according to the laws in that state. Similarly, other states recognize notarizations performed in California. Presumably, this authority would extend to online notarizations authorized in other states.
It is yet not clear how the burgeoning practice of online notarization will be recognized by the states. As noted above, the standards for performing notarizations do not vary considerably between the states and reciprocity between the states is observed. As online notarization develops, it is not clear whether the standards adopted by different states will be as similar as the standards for in-person notarization. If standards vary widely between the states, California may need to consider whether it is appropriate to continue to recognize online notarizations performed in other states.
Prior Related Legislation.
AB 2368 (Calderon, 2018), from Senate Committee without further action
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT:
According to, Notarize, “[t]his bill contains key provisions and protections that will enable the
California program to be robust, safe and secure, while also letting technology thrive. Notarize argues that this bill is consistent with the uniform models and principles established by the National Association of Secretaries of State as well as the Mortgage Bankers Association/American Land Title Association.”
California Credit Union League and California Mortgage Bankers Association believe this new technology has many consumer and business benefits including making the notary process more efficient and secure for Californians. We believe AB 199 puts important safeguards around online notarizations while also providing regulatory flexibility for the Secretary of State, who commissions and oversees notaries in California.
In agreement is the California Escrow Association, who argues, “[u]nder current law, a California notary may only notarize a signer who appears physically before them. AB 199 would allow a signer to appear before a California notary by way of an online process via a real-time audio-video process. The measure seeks to enact a statutory framework that combines the convenience of an online service with the security of significant additional processes to reliably verify the identity of signers and complete the notarial process.”
California Association of Realtors additionally argues that, “[this bill] would make real estate transaction faster and more convenient for homebuyers and sellers.”
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION:
According to Escrow Institute of California, this bill lacks:
- Adequate security measures;
- Necessary protections to safeguard against excessive liabilities;
- A universal database that is properly monitored by state agencies; and
- A uniform process for security and storage.
POLICY ISSUE(S) FOR CONSIDERATION:
The bill authorizes an online notary public located in California to provide an online notarization to a person inside or outside of the state. Thus, California online notaries could provide notarization services to individuals in other states. Presumably, others states could grant the same authority to notary publics in their state. Over time, this may lead to a nationwide market for notary public services, as consumers in California (and other states) could have their need for notarization services met by notary publics in any state that allows notarization services to be provided to individuals outside their state.
As this system evolves, the Secretary of State and the Legislature will need to consider whether the needs of consumers and those entities that rely on notarized documents are being met in a secure and reliable manner.
IMPLEMENTATION ISSUES:
The bill gives the Secretary of State the responsibility to adopt rules to implement the bill and defers many of the detailed requirements needed to facilitate online notarization to those rules.
The development of those rules by the Secretary of State is likely to require significant effort. The Secretary will need to consider both the evolving technologies that can facilitate online notarization and technologies that could be used to subvert the process.
AMENDMENTS:
Amendments are anticipated to address concerns about ensuring notarial acts are able to be used in court proceedings. Standards for quality of recordings and storage and security may be necessary.
REGISTERED SUPPORT:
California Association of Realtors
California Credit Union League
California Escrow Association
California Mortgage Bankers Association
National Notary Association
Notarize
REGISTERED OPPOSITION:
Escrow Institute of California
Analysis Prepared by: Danielle Sires / B. & P. / (916) 319-3301
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):