AB 2108: Judgeships.
- Session Year: 2019-2020
- House: Assembly
- Latest Version Date: 2020-02-06
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Jun 3, 2020 | In committee: Held under submission. |
| Jun 2, 2020 | In committee: Set, first hearing. Referred to APPR. suspense file. |
| Mar 10, 2020 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on APPR. with recommendation: To Consent Calendar. (Ayes 11. Noes 0.) (March 10). Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Feb 20, 2020 | Referred to Com. on JUD. |
| Feb 7, 2020 | From printer. May be heard in committee March 8. |
| Feb 6, 2020 | Read first time. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Mar 10, 2020 | Do pass and be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] with recommendation: To Consent Calendar | Assembly Standing Committee on Judiciary |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
Date of Hearing: June 2, 2020
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Lorena Gonzalez, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 2108
Author:(Obernolte) – As Introduced Ver:February 6, 2020
Policy Committee: | Judiciary | Vote: | 11 - 0 |
|
| ||
|
|
Urgency: No State Mandated Local Program: No Reimbursable: No
SUMMARY:
This bill authorizes, upon appropriation in the 2021-2022 fiscal year, 50 additional judgeships to be allocated through the state budget to county superior courts.
FISCAL EFFECT:
Cost pressure (GF) of approximately $13 million dollars annually for 50 new judges. Previous appropriations for additional judges has also included allocations for additional staff and interpreters at an estimated cost of $3.5 million dollars. The 2019-2020 Budget Act allocated $36.5 million dollars annually for 25 new judgeships.
COMMENTS:
- Purpose. According to the author:
The current severe judicial shortfall that exists in California directly affects the ability for people to have timely access to justice, which is unquestionably one of the fundamental responsibilities of government.
- Existing Unfunded Judgeships. The Legislature approved 100 new judgeships in 2007 but to date, only 76 judgeships were funded, including the 25 new judgeships funded last year. Judicial Council notes that the overall statewide need for judges grew by nearly 50 positions in 2019. The shortage of judgeships is particularly acute in California’s growing inland counties. In fact, the Judicial Council noted that in 2019 the counties of Kern, Riverside, and San Bernardino were jointly understaffed by approximately 102 judges. Despite the deficit of judges in these counties, following the funding of 25 judicial positions statewide in the 2019-2020 Budget Act, funding is provided for 1,981 judges despite an estimated need of only 1,975 positions. The imbalance in judicial positions is not related to funding, but to the overall allocation of judges across the state. For example, Los Angeles, San Diego, and San Francisco counties combine to account for approximately 101 more judges than necessary to handle existing caseloads, nearly the same size surplus as of the deficit facing some of the largest inland counties.
- Prior Legislation.
- AB 1313 (Donnelly), of the 2013-2014 Legislative Session would have required allocation of additional judges to courts with the greatest disparity between their current judicial allocation and their assessed judicial need. AB 1313 failed passage in the Assembly Judiciary Committee.
- SB 1190 (Jackson), of the 2013-2014 Legislative Session would have appropriated an unspecified sum from the General Fund to the judicial branch to fund the cost of a previously authorized set of 50 judges and accompanying staff. SB 1190 was held in the Senate Appropriations Committee.
- SB 229 (Roth) of the 2015-2016 Legislative Session would have appropriated $5 million from the General Fund for the purpose of funding 12 new superior court judgeships, and accompanying staff. SB 229 was vetoed by Governor Brown.
- AB 2446 (Obernolte) of the 2017-2018 Legislative Session would have appropriate $16.015 million from the General Fund to pay for one additional appellate court justice in the San Bernardino/Riverside area and ten additional judges and supporting staff statewide. AB 2446 was held on this Committee’s Suspense File.
Analysis Prepared by: Kimberly Horiuchi / APPR. / (916) 319-2081
Date of Hearing: March 10, 2020
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON JUDICIARY
Mark Stone, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 2108
Author:(Obernolte) – As Introduced Ver:February 6, 2020
PROPOSED CONSENT
SUBJECT: Judgeships
KEY ISSUE: SHOULD AN ADDITIONAL 50 JUDGESHIPS BE APPROVED AND, IF FUNDING IS AVAILABLE, ALLOCATED IN ACCORDANCE WITH THE JUDICIAL COUNCIL’S NEEDS ASSESSMENT?
SYNOPSIS
This non-controversial measure would provide for 50 new judicial positions to be allocated, upon appropriation, across California’s superior courts in accordance with the Judicial Council’s judicial needs study. This bill is yet another in a series of bills that this Committee has considered in recent years seeking to remedy the deficit of judges serving in courts located in California’s inland counties. As highlighted by the Judicial Council’s “Need for New Judgeships in the Superior Courts: 2019 Update of the Judicial Needs Assessment” the current level of funded judgeships statewide is sufficient to meet currently projected needs, however, the current allocation of judges to the various county courts results in some counties with significantly more judges than necessary to meet existing caseloads, while other county courts are woefully understaffed. This bill seeks to address this imbalance by allocating new judges to those counties with the greatest need.
If this bill were enacted and properly funded, a surplus in judges statewide would result. However, such surpluses may be wise to compensate for fluctuating case levels in the future. This bill is supported by the County of San Bernardino, which points out the need for more judges by highlighting that, despite the 2019 budget allocation for new judgeships, the county continues to suffer from an inadequate number of judicial officers when compared to its existing caseloads. The county rightfully suggests that the lack of judges significantly impacts county residents’ ability to access the justice system. This bill has no known opposition.
SUMMARY: Authorizes 50 additional judicial positions to be allocated to county superior courts. Specifically, this bill:
- Authorizes 50 new judicial positions to be allocated, upon appropriation, in the 2021-2022 fiscal year.
- Provides that the judicial positions authorized pursuant to 1), above, are to be allocated in accordance with the most recently released update of the Judicial Needs Study conducted by the Judicial Council of California.
EXISTING LAW:
- Provides that the Legislature is to prescribe the number of judges and provide for the officers and employees of each superior court. (California Constitution, Article VI, Section 4.)
- Provides that the Legislature may provide for the trial courts to appoint officers such as commissioners to perform subordinate judicial duties. (California Constitution, Article VI, Section 22.)
- Authorizes the courts to appoint subordinate judicial officers, and sets forth their duties and titles. (Government Code Section 71622.)
- Sets forth the specific number of trial court judges in each county. (Government Code Section 69580 et seq.)
- Provides that new superior court judges are to be allocated, in accordance with uniform standards for factually determining additional judicial need in each county, as approved by the Judicial Council, pursuant to the most recent update of the Judicial Council of California’s Judicial Needs Study, based on the following criteria:
- Court filings data averaged over a period of three years;
- Workload standards that represent the average amount of time of bench and nonbench work required to resolve each case type; and
- A ranking methodology that provides consideration for courts that have the greatest need relative to their current complement of judicial officers. (Government Code Section 69614 (b).)
- Provides that, upon appropriation, 100 judges are to be allocated to the various county superior courts in accordance with 5). (Government Code Section 69614.3 (a).)
- Provides that 25 judges are allocated for appointment in the 2019-2020 fiscal year. (Government Code Section 69614.3 (e).)
FISCAL EFFECT: As currently in print this bill is keyed fiscal.
COMMENTS: Due to the significant budget constraints that plagued California for much of the last decade, the appointment of new judges to California courts did not keep pace with the state’s growing population. This problem was especially acute in the faster growing inland areas of California. Last year, to begin addressing the issue, the Legislature funded 25 new judgeships. Although caseloads have decreased across many courts the author believes additional judges are still needed, especially in the Inland Empire. This bill would authorize 50 new positions. In support of the new judgeships the author states:
In order to address the critical need for additional judges in California and to ensure equal access to justice across the state, AB 2108 would authorize an additional 50 judgeships in California. The current severe judicial shortfall that exists in California directly affects the ability for people to have timely access to justice, which is unquestionably one of the fundamental responsibilities of government. A judicial workload study conducted in 2016 (and updated in 2019) concluded that California’s judicial system is severely overburdened. In fact, Judicial Council’s 2019 update estimated that California continues to urgently need more than 170 additional judges statewide to meet the current workload requirements of our state’s 58 Superior Courts. This severe judicial shortage is compounded by the increased population growth in some areas of the state. Furthermore, having an insufficient number of judges results in delays in hearing criminal cases and civil case processing. For example, trial Courts in Riverside and San Bernardino Counties are operating at only 60% of their judicial need, which has resulted in backlogs that affect all cases but are especially harmful to family law cases. Equal and timely access to justice is a fundamental right that all Californians deserve and we must do all that we can to ensure that is a reality. AB 2108 moves us closer to achieving an equitable judicial system for all.
Historically, Courts Were County-Funded Entities and Funding Levels Varied Enormously Across the State: Until the late 1990s, trial courts in California were county entities, funded by the counties. Accordingly, funding levels varied dramatically between counties resulting in different levels of court services across the State. While visiting all 58 county courts, then-Chief Justice Ronald George discovered that chronic under-funding of many courts in the county-based court system substantially impaired access to justice, including “woefully inadequate facilities, insufficient staff, unavailable interpreter services, and antiquated information processing systems.” In his first year as chief justice, Chief Justice George twice had to seek emergency funding from the Legislature in order to prevent the shutdown of some county trial court operations. In 1997, after significant problems came to light with the county-based court funding model, the Legislature passed the Lockyer-Isenberg Trial Court Funding Act, AB 233 (Escutia & Pringle, Chap. 850, Stats. 1997), requiring the state to assume responsibility for funding the courts and helping to ensure equal access to a quality judicial system statewide.
After the state took over funding, the courts received significant funding increases and the historically underfunded counties began to see infusions of new funding from the state. However, most of the state funding continued to be distributed based on the courts' historical allocations, so courts that had been better funded by their counties remained better funded by the state, and courts that had been underfunded by their counties still struggled to generate enough revenue to maintain full access to legal services.
Early success in providing judges to courts to address California’s growing population. Beginning in 2005, the Judicial Council began seeking legislative authorization and funding for additional trial court judges to address judicial shortfalls resulting from population growth. At that time, the Judicial Council reported that the state faced a "judicial gap" that portended a number of troubling long term consequences: a significant decrease in Californians' access to the courts; compromised public safety; an unstable business environment; and, in some courts, enormous backlogs that inhibit fair, timely, and equitable justice. According to the Judicial Council, that judicial gap arose because the number of trial court judges had not kept pace with population growth, and the resulting increased demand on the courts. At the time the Judicial Council noted that, between 1990 and 2000, for example, California's population grew by over 16 percent; yet at the time the number of new judgeships created by the Legislature grew by less than three percent.
At that time, the Judicial Council pointed out that its uniform and objective assessment criteria contained in its 2001 and 2004 Judicial Needs Studies identified a statewide need for 355 new trial court judgeships. However, in consideration of the state's ongoing budget woes, the Council initially suggested a need for 150 new judgeships over that next three years. In response to the need, the Legislature passed SB 56 (Dunn, Chap. 390, Stats. 2006), which authorized, upon appropriation, 50 new trial court judgeships. Funding for those positions was provided in the budget that year. The next 50 trial court judges were authorized in AB 159 (Jones), Chap. 722, Stats. 2007. However, the requisite funding for those 50 positions, not part of AB 159, was not included in that fiscal year’s budget.
Budget woes undercut numerous attempts to address the Judicial Branch’s staffing shortfalls. Shortly after the passage of AB 159, the financial markets crashed, the Great Recession took hold, and California’s budget woes became a full-blown crisis. Faced with billions of dollars of budget cuts, the funding of the 50 judicial positions authorized by AB 159, and the authorization and funding of the next 50 positions, became luxuries the state could not afford.
As California’s economy and budget improved new attempts funding judicial positions began. Since 2011, several bills have attempted to fund or authorize additional judicial positions including, AB 1313 (Donnelly, 2013), SB 1190 (Jackson, 2014), SB 229 (Roth, 2015), and, most recently, AB 2446 (Obernolte, 2018). All of those measures either failed in the Legislature or were vetoed by the Governor due to cost or failure to adhere to the Judicial Council’s needs assessment process.
Recent budgets have reinvested in trial court judges despite caseloads falling overall. In recent years the Legislature and the Governor refocused budget spending to addressing the judicial shortfall impacting California courts. In 2019, as a part of the 2019-2020 budget the Legislature funded 25 new judgeships when it approved AB 74 (Ting) Chap. 23, Stats. 2019, and in adopting SB 95 (Committee on Budget and Fiscal Review) Chap. 36, Stats. 2019, a companion trailer bill, directed the newly funded positions to be allocated in accordance with the Judicial Council’s Judicial Needs Study. Although the 25 new judges were welcomed by the court, the Judicial Council notes that the overall statewide need for judges grew by nearly 50 positions in 2019. (Judicial Council of California, The Need for New Judgeships in the Superior Courts: 2019 Update of the Judicial Needs Assessment (Nov. 2019), at p. 3)
Judicial staffing imbalance is exacerbating the shortage of judges in some counties. As noted above, the shortage of judgeships is particularly acute in California’s growing inland counties. In fact, the Judicial Council noted that in 2019 the counties of Kern, Riverside, and San Bernardino were jointly understaffed by approximately 102 judges. (Judicial Council of California, The Need for New Judgeships in the Superior Courts: 2019 Update of the Judicial Needs Assessment, supra, at p. 7.) Despite the deficit of judges in these counties, following the funding of 25 judicial positions statewide in the 2019-2020 Budget, funding is provided for 1,981 judges despite an estimated need of only 1,975 positions. (Id. at 3.) The imbalance in judicial positions is thus not related to funding, but to the overall allocation of judges across the state. For example, the counties of Los Angeles, San Diego, and San Francisco combine to have approximately 101 more judges than necessary to handle existing caseloads, nearly the same size of the deficit facing some of the largest inland counties. (Id. at 7.) Although fluctuating caseloads justify some counties maintaining a surplus of judges, the author may wish to consider amendments to this bill that reallocate some of the existing judicial positions rather than seeking new, and arguably unnecessary, judicial positions.
Approving and funding judicial positions are two different acts. This bill proposes to authorize 50 new judgeships subject to funding approval. Without funding, an approved judgeship cannot be filled. Presently, there are 23 judicial positions that have been approved by the Legislature and not subsequently funded. (Government Code Section 69614.3 (e).) As currently in print, the bill appears to make the authorization of the judgeship contingent on an appropriation. However, if amended to remove such a contingency (potentially to reduce cost pressures), the bill may simply increase the statewide number of unfunded judgeships to 73. Rather than increasing the number of approved judicial positions awaiting funding, the author may wish to consider amending the bill to fund the already approved, but unfunded, judicial positions.
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: This bill is supported by the County of San Bernardino. According to the Judicial Council, that county is currently experiencing the largest deficit of trial court judges. In support the county writes:
In 2018, two highly impacted courts, San Bernardino and Riverside Counties, received two judgeships each. The California Budget Act of 2019 authorized and funded 25 new trial court judgeships upon adoption of the Judicial Council’s Judicial Needs Assessment that allocated 6 judgeships to San Bernardino County. As one of the state’s fastest growing counties, San Bernardino County Superior Court is one of the most underfunded, under judged and staffed courts in the state, which handles some of the highest caseloads statewide, resulting in a critical shortage of judges to hear the cases of our most vulnerable citizens.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
County of San Bernardino
Opposition
None on file
Analysis Prepared by: Nicholas Liedtke / JUD. / (916) 319-2334
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):