AB 2123: Accessibility: internet website.
- Session Year: 2019-2020
- House: Assembly
- Latest Version Date: 2020-05-04
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| May 11, 2020 | In committee: Set, first hearing. Hearing canceled at the request of author. |
| May 5, 2020 | Re-referred to Com. on JUD. |
| May 4, 2020 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to Com. on JUD. Read second time and amended. |
| Mar 16, 2020 | In committee: Hearing postponed by committee. |
| Mar 11, 2020 | Re-referred to Com. on JUD. |
| Mar 10, 2020 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to Com. on JUD. Read second time and amended. |
| Mar 4, 2020 | In committee: Hearing postponed by committee. |
| Feb 20, 2020 | Referred to Com. on JUD. |
| Feb 7, 2020 | From printer. May be heard in committee March 8. |
| Feb 6, 2020 | Read first time. To print. |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
Date of Hearing: May 11, 2020
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON JUDICIARY
Mark Stone, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 2123
Author:(Chau) – As Amended Ver:May 4, 2020
As Proposed to be Amended
SUBJECT: ACCESSIBILITY: INTERNET WEBSITE
KEY ISSUE: SHOULD STATE LAW PRESUME THAT IF A WEBSITE OR MOBILE APPLICATION OF A BUSINESS WHICH IS REQUIRED TO MAKE ITS PREMISES AND OPERATIONS ACCESSIBLE TO THE PUBLIC COMPLIES WITH A SPECIFIED STANDARD OF ACCESSIBILITY, IT ALSO COMPLIES WITH THE UNRUH ACT AND THE DISABLED PERSONS ACT, STATE LAWS REQUIRING THE BUSINESS TO BE ACCESSIBLE?
SYNOPSIS
This bill has four main components. First, it clarifies the conditions under which damages and attorney fees may be awarded in a disability access claim. Second, the bill requires the local public agency that issues business licenses and building permits to provide additional information to applicants for such permits, specifically information that a business’ internet website is required to be accessible and provide equally effective communication to all members of the public and facilitate full and equal enjoyment of the entity’s goods and services. Third, the bill requires the California Commission on Disability Access (CCDA), at a frequency determined by the commission, to review the standards established by the bill to determine whether they are the most up-to-date standards for effective communication by means of an internet website and, within 30 days of determining that the standards are not up to date and should be revised, notify the Legislature of its determination. Finally, and most significantly, the bill creates a presumption in state law that a website of a business which is a public place or place of public accommodation (and thus required to comply with the ADA and state accessibility laws) that meets a specified standard (specifically WCAG 2.1 Level AA) complies with state accessibility requirements. The goal of these provisions is to increase the accessibility of websites of businesses that serve the public; reduce uncertainty about the standard of accessibility that is required for websites to be accessible; and ultimately reduce litigation about the accessibility of websites.
The U.S. Department of Justice (DOJ) issued a notice of proposed rulemaking to establish a compliance standard for website accessibility in 2010, but the Trump Administration withdrew the proposed rulemaking in 2017. This lack of a specific standard for website compliance has created uncertainty among both businesses and the public and is commonly blamed for the recent spike in litigation about website accessibility. This bill adopts WCAG 2.1 Level AA, which was published in 2018, and has been adopted by the State of California as the compliance standard for its websites. The bill, which is author-sponsored, is supported by Disability Rights California and the California Apartment Association. It is opposed by a large coalition of business groups, led by the Civil Justice Association of California, that argue its standard may be too high and its presumption may be too weak.
SUMMARY: Creates a presumption in state law that if the website or mobile application of a business which is a public place or a place of public accommodation meets a specified standard of accessibility, it complies with California’s Unruh Civil Rights Act and Disabled Persons Act. Specifically, this bill:
- Provides that statutory damages under subdivision (a) of either Section 52 or Section 54.3 of the Civil Code (requiring places of public accommodation and public places to be accessible to all persons, including persons with a disabilities, shall only be recovered against an entity based upon the inaccessibility of an internet website of that entity if the internet website fails to provide equally effective communication or facilitate full and equal enjoyment of the entity’s goods and services to the public, including any member of the public with a disability.
- Provides that to be entitled to statutory damages for internet website inaccessibility, a plaintiff must prove one of the following:
- That the plaintiff personally encountered a barrier that did both of the following:
- Interfered with their ability to access all or part of the entity’s internet website.
- Caused the plaintiff to experience a difference in their ability to access or use the website as compared to other users such that the plaintiff was unable to acquire the same information, engage in the same interactions, or enjoy the same services with substantially equivalent ease of use, or to have the same level of privacy and independence as other users who are not disabled.
- That the plaintiff was deterred from accessing all or part of the website because of the website’s failure to provide equally effective communication or to facilitate full and equal enjoyment of the entity’s goods and services to all members of the public.
- Establishes a presumption in law that an internet website provides equally effective communication if the internet website complies with the Web Content Accessibility Guidelines (WCAG) 2.1 Level AA standard for the accessibility of internet websites published by the World Wide Web Consortium (W3C) on June 5, 2018, or any more stringent subsequent update, revision, or replacement to WCAG published by the W3C.
- Provides that the presumption in 3), above, affects the plaintiff’s burden of proof and is rebuttable by evidence showing, by a preponderance of the evidence, the elements of one of the violations set forth in 2), above.
- Provides that the above provisions are not intended to do either of the following:
- Limit the rights and remedies available to persons with disabilities under federal law, or any other state law.
- Affect whether an entity is responsible under either Section 51 or Section 51.5 for making its premises accessible to all members of the public, including persons with disabilities and including by means of accessing the entity’s internet website.
- Defines the following terms:
- “Entity” means a business establishment that is open to the public, a public place, or a place of public accommodation that is subject to the disability access provisions of the Unruh Civil Rights Act (Commencing with Section 51), the California Disabled Person’s Act (Commencing with Section 54), or the federal Americans with Disabilities Act of 1990 (42 U.S.C. Sec. 12101 et seq.) and any federal regulations adopted pursuant thereto.
- “Internet website” includes all internet web-based technology, including, but not limited to, a mobile application or app that can be accessed by a mobile device.
- Requires an information sheet that each city, county, or city and county that issues business licenses, building permits for additions, alterations, and structural repairs to commercial property, or building permits for new construction of commercial property, is required to provide to applicants for such licenses and permits under existing law (Section 4469.5 of the Government Code), to also include an advisory that a business’ internet website is required to be accessible, and to provide equally effective communication and facilitate full and equal enjoyment of the entity’s goods and services, to the public, including any member of the public who is disabled.
- Requires the California Commission on Disability Access (CCDA) to, at a frequency determined by the commission, review the standards for website accessibility established pursuant to paragraph (1) of subdivision (d) of Section 55.565 of the Civil Code to determine whether they are the most up-to-date standards for effective communication by means of an internet website and, within 30 days of determining that the standards are not up to date and should be revised, notify the Speaker of the Assembly and President pro Tempore of the Senate and the Chairs of the Assembly and Senate Committees on Judiciary, of its determination.
EXISTING LAW:
- Pursuant to federal law, under the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA), provides that no individual shall be discriminated against on the basis of disability in the full and equal enjoyment of the goods, services, facilities, privileges, advantages, or accommodations of any place of public accommodation by any person who owns, leases, or leases to, or operates a place of public accommodation. (42 U.S.C. Section 12182.)
- Holds, pursuant to case law, that the websites and apps of businesses that are public places or places of public accommodation are governed by the ADA, which "applies to the services of a place of public accommodation, not services in a place of public accommodation." (Nat'l Fed'n of the Blind v. Target Corp. (N.D. Cal. 2006) 452 F. Supp. 2d 946, 953.)
- Pursuant to the Unruh Civil Rights Act (Unruh), provides that all persons, regardless of sex, race, color, religion, ancestry, national origin, disability or medical condition, are entitled to the full and equal accommodations, advantages, facilities, privileges, or services in all business establishments of every kind; makes a violation of the ADA also constitutes a violation of Unruh; and subjects a person or entity in violation to actual damages incurred by an injured party, treble actual damages but not less than $4,000, and any attorney’s fees as the court may determine to be proper. (Civil Code Section 51 et seq. All further statutory references are to the California Civil Code, unless otherwise indicated.)
- Provides, pursuant to the Disabled Persons Act, that individuals with disabilities or medical conditions have the same right as the general public to the full and free use of the streets, highways, sidewalks, walkways, public buildings, medical facilities, including hospitals, clinics and physicians’ offices, public facilities and other public places, and also provides that a violation of an individual’s rights under the ADA constitutes a violation of state law. (Section 54.)
- Provides that individuals with disabilities shall be entitled to full and equal access to public accommodations, subject only to the conditions and limitations established by law, or state or federal regulation, and applicable alike to all persons. (Section 54.1.)
FISCAL EFFECT: As currently in print this bill is keyed fiscal.
COMMENTS: This bill, among other things, seeks to establish a presumption in state law that if businesses comply with a specific standard for making their websites accessible to all persons, including persons with disabilities, they are presumed to comply with state disability access laws. The goal of the bill, in establishing such a presumption, is to increase the accessibility of websites of businesses that serve the public; reduce uncertainty about the standard of accessibility that is required for websites to be accessible; and ultimately reduce litigation about the accessibility of websites. According to the author:
AB 2123 would help protect businesses against potential lawsuits that claim their websites are inaccessible to users with disabilities, if they meet the WCAG standards developed by the World Wide Web Consortium (W3C). It would also require municipalities to notify businesses of the obligation to make their websites accessible to people with disabilities when issuing business licenses or building permits.
By creating this rebuttable presumption, AB 2123 would reduce litigation over whether business’ websites are ADA-compliant. . . . Further, by extending notice to businesses about their ADA responsibilities, AB 2123 could benefit many businesses by informing them of their ADA responsibilities before they publicize websites that fail to meet the WCAG standard.
Lastly, AB 2123 requires the California Commission on Disability Access to review the WCAG standards and determine whether they are the most up-to-date standards for effective communication through websites. With this provision, the bill ensures that the rebuttable presumption will remain a reasonable bar for a business’ website to meet.
The bill. This bill has five main components. First, it clarifies the conditions under which damages and attorney fees may be awarded in a disability access claim. The bill’s language clarifying the conditions under which damages and attorney fees may be awarded in a disability access claim, requires that “the plaintiff personally encountered a barrier” that either interfered with their ability to access all or part of the entity’s internet website, or deterred them from doing so. This is similar to language in existing law, Section 55.56 (b), requiring a plaintiff to personally encounter a construction-related access barrier in order to recover damages for such a claim.
Second, the bill requires the local public agency that issues business licenses or building permits to provide additional information to applicants for such licenses and permits, specifically information that a business’ internet website is required to be accessible and provide equally effective communication and facilitate full and equal enjoyment of the entity’s goods and services.
Third, the bill adds another duty to those of the CCDA, the state office whose mission is “to promote disability access in California through dialogue and collaboration with stakeholders including, but not limited to, the disability and business communities as well as all levels of government.” CCDA also makes, “recommendations to promote compliance with federal, and state laws and regulations; and to provide uniform information about programmatic and architectural disability access requirements to the stakeholders.” (See 14985-14985.11.) The bill requires CCDA, at a frequency determined by the commission, to review the standards established by the bill to determine whether they are the most up-to-date standards for effective communication by means of an internet website and, within 30 days of determining that the standards are not up to date and should be revised, notify the Legislature of its determination.
Given the mission and expertise of CCDA, this determination certainly seems to be within its purview. The process will allow businesses to rely on that statutory standard until and unless it is updated by the Legislature. The fact that the bill allows businesses to obtain the presumption of compliance when their websites comply with WCAG 2.1 AA or “any more stringent subsequent update, revision, or replacement to WCAG published by the W3C” provides certainty about what the standard is until or unless it is updated in the future by the Legislature.
Finally, and most significantly, the bill creates a presumption in state law that a website of a business which is a public place or place of public accommodation (and thus required to comply with the ADA and state accessibility laws) that meets a specified standard (specifically WCAG 2.1 Level AA) complies with state accessibility requirements. This provision—and the rationale for the standard--is explained in more detail below.
Background – Federal ADA and State Civil Rights Laws Protect the Ability of All Persons to Access Public Accommodations. Under the twenty-seven year-old federal Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA), a business that constitutes a place of public accommodation (e.g., many places of lodging, entertainment, recreation, restaurants, bars, theaters, stores, health clubs, etc.) is prohibited from discriminating on the basis of disability if its operations affect interstate commerce. Prohibited discrimination can take a number of forms – e.g., denial of participation in the facility, or a service, benefit, or good of the business; denial of equal participation in a good, service, or facility; or provision of a different or separate facility, service or good (unless necessary to provide services and the like that are as effective as that provided to others). Government facilities are also covered by the access obligations of the ADA.
According to the California Supreme Court, “In 1992, shortly after passage of the ADA, the Legislature amended the state's disability protections ‘to strengthen California law in areas where it is weaker than the [ADA] and to retain California law when it provides more protection for individuals with disabilities than the [ADA].’ Two overlapping laws, the Unruh Civil Rights Act (§ 51) and the Disabled Persons Act (§§ 54–55.3), are the principal sources of state disability access protection.” (Jankey v. Lee (2012) 55 Cal.4th 1038, 1044 [Citation to internal quotation deleted].) As a result of incorporating the ADA into the state’s Unruh Civil Rights, a plaintiff who prevails in a construction-related accessibility claim, like all plaintiffs in other civil rights cases, is entitled to minimum statutory damages of $4,000 per violation.
Therefore, since 1992, public accommodations in California have been required to comply with not only the ADA, but also with the state’s Unruh Act and Disabled Persons Act, which incorporate the ADA into their provisions and make a violation of the ADA punishable as a violation of Unruh and the Disabled Persons Act. (Sections 51, 54.) All violations under the Disabled Persons Act are liable for the actual damages and an amount determined by a jury, or the court sitting without a jury, up to a maximum of three times the actual damages (there is a minimum fine of $1,000) and attorney’s fees. All violations of Unruh are subject to statutory damages of at least four thousand dollars per violation, except some cases where the violation is based on a construction-related accessibility claim, in which case lower damages (a minimum of one thousand or two thousand dollars, depending on the circumstances of the case) apply.
U.S. Department of Justice Regulations Regarding Website Accessibility, Including Proposed (and Later Abandoned) Specific Accessibility Compliance Standards. The United States Department of Justice (DOJ) is the agency responsible for enforcing federal civil rights laws, including the ADA. In that capacity, DOJ has promulgated regulations and technical advice to businesses that are public places and places of public accommodation about how to comply with the ADA. For example, DOJ regulations require that a public accommodation, in its communications to the public, “furnish appropriate auxiliary aids and services where necessary to ensure effective communication with individuals with disabilities.” (28 C.F.R. 36.303(c)(1) (emphasis added); see Bragdon v. Abbott (1998) 524 U.S. 624, 646 [holding that DOJ's administrative guidance on ADA compliance is entitled to deference].)
DOJ has adopted regulations to define “auxiliary aids and services” to include “accessible electronic and information technology” or “other effective methods of making visually delivered materials available to individuals who are blind or have low vision” in 28 C.F.R. 36.303(b)(2). (Robles v. Domino's Pizza, LLC (9th Cir. 2019) 913 F.3d 898, 904-905.) And DOJ has repeatedly affirmed the application of the ADA to the websites and apps of public accommodations. (See 75 Fed. Reg. 43460-01, 43464 (July 26, 2010); Robles, supra, 913 F.3d at pp. 906-907.) Thus, the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals has held that the ADA applies to a restaurant’s website and app, which connect customers to the goods and services of the restaurants. (Robles, supra, at pp. 905 – 06.)
However, DOJ has not adopted a regulation setting a standard for what specifically the ADA requires businesses to do in order to make their websites accessible. (See Robles, supra, at p. 908.) Although DOJ issued a notice of proposed rulemaking to establish such a standard in 2010 (75 Fed. Reg. 43460-01 (July 26, 2010)), the Trump Administration withdrew the proposed rulemaking in 2017 (82 Fed. Reg. 60932-01 (Dec. 26, 2017).) While this lack of a specific standard for website compliance does not violate the due process rights of businesses or make the ADA unenforceable given that “[c]ourts are perfectly capable of interpreting the meaning of ‘equal’ and ‘effective’” (Robles, supra, at p. 911), it does create uncertainty among both businesses and the public; also, the lack of a specific standard may be related to a recent reported increase in litigation, or at least threatened litigation, regarding the accessibility of websites.
WCAG Standards, Including Versions and Levels of Compliance. In the absence of a specific standard for website compliance, courts and government entities sometimes rely on private standards developed by technology and accessibility experts, including the World Wide Web Consortium (W3C), the main international standards organization for the Internet. As part of their Web Accessibility Initiative, W3C has promulgated a series of web accessibility guidelines, including the Web Content Accessibility Guidelines (WCAG). WCAG standards are a set of recommendations for making Web content more accessible, particularly for people with disabilities. The first set of accessibility guidelines, called WCAG 1.0 became a W3C recommendation in May of 1999. The guidelines have been updated since then. WCAG 2.0 was published in December 2008 and became an ISO standard in October 2012. WCAG 2.1 became a W3C Recommendation in June of 2018.
WCAG 2.1 retains WCAG 2.0 in its entirety, but adds 17 additional success criteria to the 2.0 standard. The new success criteria are intended to address viewing of content on mobile devices and provide additional success criteria to improve the experience of individuals with low vision and cognitive impairments. W3C’s overview of the additional success criteria in version 2.1 can be accessed at the WCAG website: https://www.w3.org/WAI/standards-guidelines/wcag/new-in-21/. Regarding the level of compliance within each version of the standard, “Level A is a subset of Level AA. There are 25 criteria that you have to meet to reach Level A. To reach Level AA you have to meet 13 more criteria in addition to the 25 for Level A.” (https://myaccessible.website/blog/wcaglevels/wcag-levels-a-aa-aaa-difference)
Courts and government entities have relied upon WCAG standards in addressing accessibility issues and compliance, particularly in settlement agreements and consent decrees. For example:
- In 2013, DOJ entered into a settlement agreement with Louisiana Tech University that encompassed not only the University’s website, but also all electronic and information technology, instructional materials and online courses. (See Settlement Agreement with Louisiana Tech University, DJ #204-33-116 (July 22, 2013), available at https://www.ada.gov/louisiana-tech.htm.)
- In 2014, the National Federal of the Blind and DOJ entered into a consent decree with HRB Digital LLC and HRB Tax Group, Inc., agreeing that H&R Block’s website and apps would comply with the WCAG 2.0 AA standards by January 1, 2016. (National Federation of the Blind, et al v. HRB Digital LLC and HRB Tax Group, Inc., Civil Action No. 1:13-cv-10799-GAO, United States District Court for the State of Massachusetts, Boston Division, Consent Decree – available at https://www.ada.gov/hrb-cd.htm.)
- In August of 2016, DOJ notified the University of California, Berkeley, that large segments of its free, publicly available audio and video content (including its YouTube channel, iTunes U platform, and Open Online Courses) were not accessible to individuals with hearing, vision, or manual disabilities. The letter observed that, “While the University of California’s Information Technology Accessibility Policy adopts the WCAG 2.0 AA technical standard, which provides clear parameters for ensuring online content is accessible to individuals with disabilities, UC Berkeley has not ensured compliance with its policy.” (See Letter dated August 30, 2016 to University of California, Berkeley, available at https://www.ada.gov/briefs/uc_berkley_lof.pdf.)
- In November of 2018, the National Federation of the Blind announced a settlement agreement with Alameda County, California, in which the county agreed to utilize WCAG 2.1 AA in making its election website accessible. (See https://www.nfb.org/about-us/press-room/alameda-county-will-make-voting-more-accessible-blind.)
- In January of 2019, the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals observed in Robles that “the district court can order compliance with WCAG 2.0 as an equitable remedy if, after discovery, the website and app fail to satisfy the ADA.” (Robles, supra, 913 F.3d at p. 907.)
Significantly, the State of California also uses WCAG 2.1 AA as the benchmark for its agencies to comply with accessibility requirements. State law—specifically Government Code Section 11135--requires that all electronic and information technology developed or purchased by the State of California Government is accessible to people with disabilities. Furthermore, the State specifically requires that all agencies, and any contractors working for them, ensure that their public websites are accessible to the general public, and are aligned with WCAG 2.1 Level AA Standards.
This bill creates a presumption in state law that a website of a business which is a public place or place of public accommodation (and thus required to comply with the ADA and state accessibility laws) that meets WCAG 2.1 Level A and AA standards complies with state accessibility requirements. The bill sensibly adopts that same standard for the accessibility of websites of private businesses that are required to comply with state and federal accessibility laws.
Opposition groups argue that WCAG 2.1 is too high and too new of a standard. As recounted in more detail below, a coalition of business groups, led by the Civil Justice Association of California, is opposed to the bill, unless it is amended to enact WCAG 2.0 AA, rather than WCAG 2.1 AA as the compliance standard for websites. They opine, without presenting any evidence of cost or difficulty, that the bill would give “businesses who have coded their websites to WCAG 2.0 no time to upgrade to 2.1 standards. Particularly for small businesses, web development can be a very costly and lengthy process.” They suggest that, “AB 2123 should be amended to allow websites that have coded to substantially conform with WCAG 2.0 Level AA and above as of December 31, 2020 to be eligible for the rebuttable presumption.”
The WCAG 2.0 standard promoted by the opponents is more than ten years old. It was published in December 2008 and adopted as an ISO standard in October 2012. Technology has significantly changed and advanced since then. Adopting WCAG 2.0 as the bill’s performance standard could give businesses the impression that they were fully compliant with access laws and protected from liability, but this impression could turn out to be mistaken if a court found that the business could and should have complied with WCAG 2.1. This lack of clarity would undermine the main purposes of the bill and paradoxically could expose businesses to liability for non-compliance with state disability laws. It therefore likely does not make sense for the author to adopt an outdated and incomplete standard as the benchmark for website compliance in this bill.
- Opposition groups would prefer a conclusive rule, or irrefutable presumption, rather than a presumption that can be overcome with evidence. The coalition’s second objection is that “The rebuttable presumption in AB 2123 does not provide businesses with meaningful protection or promote coding to WCAG standards,” and the group would prefer a conclusive/irrefutable presumption of compliance, rather than a rebuttable one.
As currently written, the presumption can be easily overcome – plaintiffs need only show they personally encountered a barrier that interfered and created a difference with website access, or they were deterred.
For a presumption to be effective, it needs to provide businesses with certainty. If they take steps to meet the requisite standards, they need assurances they have made their websites accessible and reduced their chances of getting sued. Under AB 2123, businesses who code to WCAG standards get no certainty because they are still fully subject to statutory damages once the presumption is easily rebutted.
This opposition argument seems to make a presumption of its own: that because the presumption of compliance with state disability access, in theory, could be overcome, that it easily would be overcome. The opposition presents no evidence for this assertion. They also minimize the power of a presumption affecting the burden of producing evidence, such as the one proposed by this bill. “A presumption meant to establish or implement some public policy other than facilitation of the particular action in which it applies is a presumption affecting the burden of proof.” (People v. Dubon (2001) 90 Cal.App.4th 944, 953; see also Evid. Code, Section 605.) A presumption of a fact does “not disappear in the face of evidence as to the nonexistence of the presumed fact.” (Bay Guardian Co. v. New Times Media LLC (2010) 187 Cal.App.4th 438, 464-465 [Citations omitted].) Although the party who is disadvantaged by a presumption may offer rebuttal evidence, they cannot overcome or negate the presumption without “conclusive proof.” (Id. at p. 465.)
Finally, the opposition seems to argue that the compliance standard established by the bill is too high, too futuristic, and too impractical, writing that, “AB 2123 sets a higher bar for compliance than existing law, under which courts have viewed compliance with WCAG standards as the equitable remedy for an inaccessible website.”
While it is true that some [federal] courts have looked to compliance with WCAG 2.0 as a factor in a multi-pronged evaluation of whether a business’s website was accessible (See Robles, supra, at pp. 905 – 06) and many [federal] agencies have ordered businesses to comply with WCAG 2.0 (Id. at p. 902, fn. 1). But it is also true, as explained above, that some agencies and settlement agreements have ordered entities to comply with WCAG 2.1 Level AA. Also, the State of California specifically requires all agencies, and any contractors doing business with the state, to ensure that their public websites are accessible to the general public, and are aligned with WCAG 2.1 Level AA. Therefore, any business affected by this bill that contracts with the State of California is already required to comply with the standard established for the presumption in this bill.
The only significant difference between WCAG 2.0 Level AA and WCAG 2.1 Level AA is the fact that the latter standard addresses newer technology, such as mobile applications, that are not addressed in the former. So while the opposition emphasizes the differences in the standards, it is important to note that in most ways, the standards are identical. So if a business just had a website and complied with WCAG 2.0 Level AA, the business would be in compliance with WCAG 2.1 Level AA. On the other hand, if the business offered a mobile application for accessing its website on mobile devices, the business could not be in compliance with WCAG 2.0 Level AA because such mobile applications are not addressed in that standard. On the other hand, a court would likely look to WCAG 2.1 Level AA to evaluate whether the application provided equal access to the website, because WCAG 2.1 Level AA addresses the issue, whereas WCAG 2.0 Level AA does not.
Reported Recent Uptick in Litigation (Almost Exclusively Outside of California) Regarding Website Compliance. The number of website accessibility lawsuits being reportedly is rising, at least in the nation’s federal courts. According to the Los Angeles Times, “lawsuits alleging website accessibility violations totaled 1,053 in the first six months [of 2018], a number that is projected to rise to 2,000 by year’s end, up 90% from 2017. (Martin, Hugo. “Lawsuits targeting business websites over ADA violations are on the rise (Nov. 11, 2018) Los Angeles Times, available at https://www.latimes.com/business/la-fi-hotels-ada-compliance-20181111-story.html.) Seyfarth Shaw LLP, a civil defense firm that publishes a blog devoted to ADA compliance lawsuits found that “lawsuits alleging inaccessible websites and mobile apps accounted for at least a fifth of the total number of ADA Title III lawsuits filed” last year and—along with hotel accessibility information on reservation websites—such types of claims were one of the “hot trends” of 2019. (Vu, Minh, Review and Hot Trends for 2020 (January 2, 2020), available at https://www.adatitleiii.com/2020/01/ada-title-iii-litigation-a-2019-review-and-hot-trends-for-2020/.). Interestingly, the Seyfarth Shaw report found that in 2019, only ten website accessibility lawsuits were filed in California’s federal courts.
There seems to be general agreement that DOJ’s withdrawal of its proposed rulemakings prompted the increased incidence of litigation regarding website compliance. “The Trump administration’s decision to stop drafting rules for website ADA compliance is widely seen as opening the floodgates to legal action.” (Martin, supra.) And these trends have caught the attention of Congress. For example, U.S. Representative Ted Budd (R-NC), joined by more than 100 members of Congress, urged then-Attorney General Jeff Sessions to address the situation. (Martin, supra.) In its response letter dated September 25, 2018, DOJ set forth its current views on the issue of website accessibility. DOJ reiterated its position that the ADA applies to public accommodations’ websites, which it first articulated over 20 years ago, and that absence of regulations specifically addressing websites does not provide a basis for noncompliance with the ADA’s requirements.
Author’s Amendments. Concerns have been raised to the author and Committee about whether the bill expands liability under existing law to entities beyond those which are required by existing state law to make their premises accessible to the public. Given that the bill articulates a limitation on the ability to recover damages and establishes a presumption against an entity’s liability, but does not create a new cause of action, this interpretation may not be reasonable. The bill should only apply in circumstances where state law already establishes liability. But in an abundance of caution, the author has agreed to add the following clarifying language to the definition of “entity”
On Page 4, at line 26, add the following at the end of the sentence:
that is subject to the disability access provisions of state law, including the Unruh Civil Rights Act (Commencing with Section 51) and Section 53 et seq., or the federal Americans with Disabilities Act of 1990 (42 U.S.C. Sec. 12101 et seq.) and any federal regulations adopted pursuant thereto.
The author has also agreed to make minor technical amendments to, among other things, replace the phrases “disabled person” and “the disabled” with “person with a disability”:
On Page 4, at line 8: strike out “established by the World Wide Web Consortium (W3C) Accessibility Guidelines Working Group” and insert “published by the World Wide Web Consortium (W3C)”
On Page 4, at line 18: strike out “disabled persons” and insert “persons with disabilities”
On Page 4, at line 22: strike out “the disabled” and insert “persons with disabilities”
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: Disability Rights California writes that, it supports the bill for a number of reasons, including the following:
AB 2123 will help ensure that websites are accessible to persons with disabilities by clearly providing that an internet website is presumed to be accessible if the internet website complies with the Web Content Accessibility Guidelines (WCAG) 2.1 Level AA standard for accessibility of internet websites established by the World Wide Web Consortium (W3C) Accessibility Guidelines Working Group or any subsequent updates. . . .This presumption, along with the articulation of a clear nationally-recognized compliance standard, the WCAG 2.1 AA standard, provides guidance to businesses of their compliance obligations. . . . AB 2123 provides appropriate liability protections for ensuring accessible websites, and provides a clear standard for being in compliance. This should result in greater accessibility of websites throughout the state.
The California Apartment Association writes that it supports the bill because it provides clarity to businesses about their responsibilities and obligations:
As you know, the United States Department of Justice issued proposed regulations to establish a compliance standard for website accessibility in 2010, but the Trump Administration withdrew that proposed rulemaking in 2017. This lack of a clear standard has created uncertainty for businesses and has contributed to a recent spike in litigation on website accessibility, particularly in California where statutory damages are available. AB 2123 would require businesses to comply with industry best practice standards developed by technology and accessibility experts, adding much-needed clarity to this area for businesses seeking to comply with the law.
Finally, the California Special Districts Association writes on behalf of over 1,000 special districts and affiliate organizations throughout the state that it is “pleased to support Assembly Bill 2123 (Chau), which will provide clear direction on website compliance with the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA).”
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION: A coalition of business groups, led by the Civil Justice Association of California, is opposed to the bill, unless it is amended, to address two concerns. The coalition describes the first concern as “AB 2123 needs to include those who have already adopted widely recognized WCAG 2.0 standards.”
AB 2123 should also account for those businesses that are already coding their websites to substantially conform to WCAG 2.0 Level AA and above rather than 2.1, as 2.0 Level AA is still widely recognized, including by the California Legislature and courts. Delaying the application of the presumption by one year, as proposed in the committee’s amendments, will not be helpful as that will mean no businesses will get the benefit of a presumption of compliance another year.
- . . . If enacted, AB 2123 would take effect January 1, 2021, leaving businesses who have coded their websites to WCAG 2.0 no time to upgrade to 2.1 standards. Particularly for small businesses, web development can be a very costly and lengthy process. Therefore, AB 2123 should be amended to allow websites that have coded to substantially conform with WCAG 2.0 Level AA and above as of December 31, 2020 to be eligible for the rebuttable presumption.
- The coalition’s second objection is that, “The rebuttable presumption in AB 2123 does not provide businesses with meaningful protection or promote coding to WCAG standards,” and the group would prefer a conclusive presumption of compliance, rather than a rebuttable one.
The presumption in AB 2123 should be revised to encourage businesses to adopt WCAG standards. As currently written, the presumption can be easily overcome – plaintiffs need only show they personally encountered a barrier that interfered and created a difference with website access, or they were deterred.
For a presumption to be effective, it needs to provide businesses with certainty. If they take steps to meet the requisite standards, they need assurances they have made their websites accessible and reduced their chances of getting sued. Under AB 2123, businesses who code to WCAG standards get no certainty because they are still fully subject to statutory damages once the presumption is easily rebutted. As a result, AB 2123 sets a higher bar for compliance than existing law, under which courts have viewed compliance with WCAG standards as the equitable remedy for an inaccessible website.
Pending /Prior Related Legislation: SB 937 (Hill, 2020) would authorize a state agency to temporarily remove public documents from digital access if a justifiable impediment exists and the Director of Technology verifies the impediment prohibits full compliance and the state agency complies with certain requirements. Any file or document removed after October 14, 2017 would be subject to these requirements.
AB 3002 (Stats. 2018, Ch. 680, Gray) requires local jurisdictions that issue building permits for commercial construction or business licenses to make available a notice containing specified information regarding disability access, as well as an information notice to applicants.
AB 434 (Stats. 2017, Ch. 780, Baker) requires the director of each state agency or entity and the chief information officer of that state agency or entity to post on the home page of the agency’s or entity’s website a signed certification that the website is in compliance with specified accessibility standards. The bill would require the director to create a standard form that each state agency’s or state entity’s chief information officer would be required to use to determine whether the state agency’s or state entity’s Internet Web site is in compliance with the specified accessibility standards.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
California Apartment Association
California Special Districts Association
Disability Rights California
Opposition (unless amended)
Civil Justice Association of California
American Property Casualty Insurance Association
California Association of Realtors
California Business Properties Association
California Chamber of Commerce
California Restaurant Association
California Retailers Association
Citizens Against Lawsuit Abuse
Computing Technology Industry Association (CompTIA)
Greater Coachella Valley Chamber of Commerce
Internet Association
National Federation of Independent Business
Personal Insurance Federation of California
Pleasanton Chamber of Commerce
San Gabriel Valley Economic Partnership
TechNet
Tulare Chamber of Commerce
Valley Industry and Commerce Association
Analysis Prepared by: Alison Merrilees / JUD. / (916) 319-2334
Date of Hearing: March 17, 2020
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON JUDICIARY
Mark Stone, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 2123
Author:(Chau) – As Amended Ver:March 10, 2020
As Proposed to be Amended
SUBJECT: ACCESSIBILITY: INTERNET WEBSITES: COMPLIANCE STANDARD
KEY ISSUE: SHOULD STATE LAW PRESUME THAT IF A WEBSITE OR MOBILE APPLICATION OF A BUSINESS WHICH IS REQUIRED TO MAKE ITS PREMISES AND OPERATIONS ACCESSIBLE TO THE PUBLIC COMPLIES WITH A SPECIFIED STANDARD OF ACCESSIBILITY, IT ALSO COMPLIES WITH THE UNRUH ACT AND THE DISABLED PERSONS ACT, STATE LAWS REQUIRING SUCH BUSINESSES TO BE ACCESSIBLE?
SYNOPSIS
This bill has four main components. First, it clarifies the conditions under which damages and attorney fees may be awarded in a disability access claim. Second, the bill requires the local public agency that issues business licenses and building permits to provide additional information to applicants for such permits, specifically information that a business’ internet website is required to be accessible and provide equally effective communication to all members of the public and facilitate full and equal enjoyment of the entity’s goods and services. Third, the bill requires the California Commission on Disability Access (CCDA), at a frequency determined by the commission, to review the standards established by the bill to determine whether they are the most up-to-date standards for effective communication by means of an internet website and, within 30 days of determining that the standards are not up to date and should be revised, notify the Legislature of its determination. Finally, and most significantly, the bill creates a presumption in state law that a website of a business which is a public place or place of public accommodation (and thus required to comply with the ADA and state accessibility laws) that meets a specified standard (specifically WCAG 2.1 Level AA) complies with state accessibility requirements. The goal of these provisions is to increase the accessibility of websites of businesses that serve the public; reduce uncertainty about the standard of accessibility that is required for websites to be accessible; and ultimately reduce litigation about the accessibility of websites.
The U.S. Department of Justice (DOJ) issued a notice of proposed rulemaking to establish a compliance standard for website accessibility in 2010, but the Trump Administration withdrew the proposed rulemaking in 2017. This lack of a specific standard for website compliance has created uncertainty among both businesses and the public and is commonly blamed for the recent spike in litigation about website accessibility. This bill adopts WCAG 2.1 Level AA, which was published in 2018, and has been adopted by the State of California as the compliance standard for its websites. The bill, which is author-sponsored, is supported by Disability Rights California and has no opposition on file.
SUMMARY: Creates a presumption in state law that if the website or mobile application of a business which is a public place or a place of public accommodation meets a specified standard of accessibility, it complies with California’s Unruh Civil Rights Act and Disabled Persons Act. Specifically, this bill:
- Provides that statutory damages under subdivision (a) of either Section 52 or Section 54.3 of the Civil Code (requiring places of public accommodation and public places to be accessible to all persons, including disabled persons, shall only be recovered against an entity based upon the inaccessibility of an internet website of that entity if the internet website fails to provide equally effective communication and facilitate full and equal enjoyment of the entity’s goods and services to the public, including any member of the public who is disabled.
- Provides that to be entitled to statutory damages for internet website inaccessibility, a plaintiff must prove one of the following:
- That the plaintiff personally encountered a barrier that did both of the following:
- Interfered with their ability to access all or part of the entity’s internet website.
- Caused the plaintiff to experience a difference in their ability to access or use the website as compared to other users such that the plaintiff was unable to acquire the same information, engage in the same interactions, or enjoy the same services with substantially equivalent ease of use, or to have the same level of privacy and independence as other users who are not disabled.
- That the plaintiff was deterred from accessing all or part of the website because of the website’s failure to provide equally effective communication or to facilitate full and equal enjoyment of the entity’s goods and services to all members of the public.
- Establishes a presumption in law that an internet website provides equally effective communication if the internet website complies with the Web Content Accessibility Guidelines (WCAG) 2.1 Level AA standard for the accessibility of internet websites established by the World Wide Web Consortium (W3C) Accessibility Guidelines Working Group on June 5, 2018, or any more stringent subsequent update, revision, or replacement to WCAG published by the W3C.
- Provides that the presumption in 3), above, affects the plaintiff’s burden of proof and is rebuttable by evidence showing, by a preponderance of the evidence, the elements of one of the violations set forth in 2), above.
- Provides that the above provisions are not intended to limit the rights and remedies available to disabled persons under federal law, or any other state law.
- Defines the following terms:
- “Entity” means a business establishment that is open to the public, a public place, or a place of public accommodation.
- “Internet website” includes all internet web-based technology, including, but not limited to, a mobile application or app that can be accessed by a mobile device.
- Requires an information sheet that each city, county, or city and county that issues business licenses, building permits for additions, alterations, and structural repairs to commercial property, or building permits for new construction of commercial property, is required to provide to applicants for such licenses and permits under existing law (Section 4469.5 of the Government Code), to also include an advisory that a business’ internet website is required to be accessible, and to provide equally effective communication or facilitate full and equal enjoyment of the entity’s goods and services, to the public, including any member of the public who is disabled.
- Requires the California Commission on Disability Access (CCDA) to, at a frequency determined by the commission, review the standards for website accessibility established pursuant to paragraph (1) of subdivision (d) of Section 55.565 of the Civil Code to determine whether they are the most up-to-date standards for effective communication by means of an internet website and, within 30 days of determining that the standards are not up to date and should be revised, notify the Speaker of the Assembly and President pro Tempore of the Senate and the Chairs of the Assembly and Senate Committees on Judiciary, of its determination.
EXISTING LAW:
- Pursuant to federal law, under the Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA), provides that no individual shall be discriminated against on the basis of disability in the full and equal enjoyment of the goods, services, facilities, privileges, advantages, or accommodations of any place of public accommodation by any person who owns, leases, or leases to, or operates a place of public accommodation. (42 U.S.C. Section 12182.)
- Holds, pursuant to case law, that the websites and apps of businesses that are public places or places of public accommodation are governed by the ADA, which "applies to the services of a place of public accommodation, not services in a place of public accommodation." (Nat'l Fed'n of the Blind v. Target Corp. (N.D. Cal. 2006) 452 F. Supp. 2d 946, 953.)
- Pursuant to the Unruh Civil Rights Act (Unruh), provides that all persons, regardless of sex, race, color, religion, ancestry, national origin, disability or medical condition, are entitled to the full and equal accommodations, advantages, facilities, privileges, or services in all business establishments of every kind; makes a violation of the ADA also constitutes a violation of Unruh; and subjects a person or entity in violation to actual damages incurred by an injured party, treble actual damages but not less than $4,000, and any attorney’s fees as the court may determine to be proper. (Civil Code Section 51 et seq. All further statutory references are to the California Civil Code, unless otherwise indicated.)
- Provides, pursuant to the Disabled Persons Act, that individuals with disabilities or medical conditions have the same right as the general public to the full and free use of the streets, highways, sidewalks, walkways, public buildings, medical facilities, including hospitals, clinics and physicians’ offices, public facilities and other public places, and also provides that a violation of an individual’s rights under the ADA constitutes a violation of state law. (Section 54.)
- Provides that individuals with disabilities shall be entitled to full and equal access to public accommodations, subject only to the conditions and limitations established by law, or state or federal regulation, and applicable alike to all persons. (Section 54.1.)
FISCAL EFFECT: As currently in print this bill is keyed fiscal.
COMMENTS: This bill, among other things, seeks to establish a presumption in state law that if businesses comply with a specific standard for making their websites accessible to all persons, including the disabled, they are presumed to comply with state disability access laws. The goal of the bill, in establishing such a presumption, is to increase the accessibility of websites of businesses that serve the public; reduce uncertainty about the standard of accessibility that is required for websites to be accessible; and ultimately reduce litigation about the accessibility of websites. According to the author:
AB 2123 would help protect businesses against potential lawsuits that claim their websites are inaccessible to users with disabilities, if they meet the WCAG standards developed by the World Wide Web Consortium (W3C). It would also require municipalities to notify businesses of the obligation to make their websites accessible to people with disabilities when issuing business licenses or building permits.
By creating this rebuttable presumption, AB 2123 would reduce litigation over whether business’ websites are ADA-compliant. . . . Further, by extending notice to businesses about their ADA responsibilities, AB 2123 could benefit many businesses by informing them of their ADA responsibilities before they publicize websites that fail to meet the WCAG standard.
Lastly, AB 2123 requires the California Commission on Disability Access to review the WCAG standards and determine whether they are the most up-to-date standards for effective communication through websites. With this provision, the bill ensures that the rebuttable presumption will remain a reasonable bar for a business’ website to meet.
The bill. This bill has five main components. First, it clarifies the conditions under which damages and attorney fees may be awarded in a disability access claim. The bill’s language clarifying the conditions under which damages and attorney fees may be awarded in a disability access claim, requires that “the plaintiff personally encountered a barrier” that either interfered with their ability to access all or part of the entity’s internet website, or deterred them from doing so. This is similar to language in existing law, Section 55.56 (b), requiring a plaintiff to personally encounter a construction-related access barrier in order to recover damages for such a claim.
Second, the bill requires the local public agency that issues business licenses or building permits to provide additional information to applicants for such licenses and permits, specifically information that a business’ internet website is required to be accessible and provide equally effective communication and facilitate full and equal enjoyment of the entity’s goods and services.
Third, the bill adds another duty to those of the CCDA, the state office whose mission is “to promote disability access in California through dialogue and collaboration with stakeholders including, but not limited to, the disability and business communities as well as all levels of government.” CCDA also makes, “recommendations to promote compliance with federal, and state laws and regulations; and to provide uniform information about programmatic and architectural disability access requirements to the stakeholders.” (See 14985-14985.11.) The bill requires CCDA, at a frequency determined by the commission, to review the standards established by the bill to determine whether they are the most up-to-date standards for effective communication by means of an internet website and, within 30 days of determining that the standards are not up to date and should be revised, notify the Legislature of its determination.
Given the mission and expertise of CCDA, this determination certainly seems to be within its purview. The process will allow businesses to rely on that statutory standard until and unless it is updated by the Legislature. The fact that the bill allows businesses to obtain the presumption of compliance when their websites comply with WCAG 2.1 AA or “any more stringent subsequent update, revision, or replacement to WCAG published by the W3C” provides certainty about what the standard is until or unless it is updated in the future by the Legislature.
Finally, and most significantly, the bill creates a presumption in state law that a website of a business which is a public place or place of public accommodation (and thus required to comply with the ADA and state accessibility laws) that meets a specified standard (specifically WCAG 2.1 Level AA) complies with state accessibility requirements. This provision—and the rationale for the standard--is explained in more detail below.
Background – Federal ADA and State Civil Rights Laws Protect the Ability of All Persons to Access Public Accommodations. Under the twenty-seven year-old federal Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA), a business that constitutes a place of public accommodation (e.g., many places of lodging, entertainment, recreation, restaurants, bars, theaters, stores, health clubs, etc.) is prohibited from discriminating on the basis of disability if its operations affect interstate commerce. Prohibited discrimination can take a number of forms – e.g., denial of participation in the facility, or a service, benefit, or good of the business; denial of equal participation in a good, service, or facility; or provision of a different or separate facility, service or good (unless necessary to provide services and the like that are as effective as that provided to others). Government facilities are also covered by the access obligations of the ADA.
According to the California Supreme Court, “In 1992, shortly after passage of the ADA, the Legislature amended the state's disability protections ‘to strengthen California law in areas where it is weaker than the [ADA] and to retain California law when it provides more protection for individuals with disabilities than the [ADA].’ Two overlapping laws, the Unruh Civil Rights Act (§ 51) and the Disabled Persons Act (§§ 54–55.3), are the principal sources of state disability access protection.” (Jankey v. Lee (2012) 55 Cal.4th 1038, 1044 [Citation to internal quotation deleted].) As a result of incorporating the ADA into the state’s Unruh Civil Rights, a plaintiff who prevails in a construction-related accessibility claim, like all plaintiffs in other civil rights cases, is entitled to minimum statutory damages of $4,000 per violation.
Therefore, since 1992, public accommodations in California have been required to comply with not only the ADA, but also with the state’s Unruh Act and Disabled Persons Act, which incorporate the ADA into their provisions and make a violation of the ADA punishable as a violation of Unruh and the Disabled Persons Act. (Sections 51, 54.) All violations under the Disabled Persons Act are liable for the actual damages and an amount determined by a jury, or the court sitting without a jury, up to a maximum of three times the actual damages (there is a minimum fine of $1,000) and attorney’s fees. All violations of Unruh are subject to statutory damages of at least four thousand dollars per violation, except some cases where the violation is based on a construction-related accessibility claim, in which case lower damages (a minimum of one thousand or two thousand dollars, depending on the circumstances of the case) apply.
U.S. Department of Justice Regulations Regarding Website Accessibility, Including Proposed (and Later Abandoned) Specific Accessibility Compliance Standards. The United States Department of Justice (DOJ) is the agency responsible for enforcing federal civil rights laws, including the ADA. In that capacity, DOJ has promulgated regulations and technical advice to businesses that are public places and places of public accommodation about how to comply with the ADA. For example, DOJ regulations require that a public accommodation, in its communications to the public, “furnish appropriate auxiliary aids and services where necessary to ensure effective communication with individuals with disabilities.” (28 C.F.R. 36.303(c)(1) (emphasis added); see Bragdon v. Abbott (1998) 524 U.S. 624, 646 [holding that DOJ's administrative guidance on ADA compliance is entitled to deference].)
DOJ has adopted regulations to define “auxiliary aids and services” to include “accessible electronic and information technology” or “other effective methods of making visually delivered materials available to individuals who are blind or have low vision” in 28 C.F.R. 36.303(b)(2). (Robles v. Domino's Pizza, LLC (9th Cir. 2019) 913 F.3d 898, 904-905.) And DOJ has repeatedly affirmed the application of the ADA to the websites and apps of public accommodations. (See 75 Fed. Reg. 43460-01, 43464 (July 26, 2010); Robles, supra, 913 F.3d at pp. 906-907.) Thus, the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals has held that the ADA applies to a restaurant’s website and app, which connect customers to the goods and services of the restaurants. (Robles, supra, at pp. 905 – 06.)
However, DOJ has not adopted a regulation setting a standard for what specifically the ADA requires businesses to do in order to make their websites accessible. (See Robles, supra, at p. 908.) Although DOJ issued a notice of proposed rulemaking to establish such a standard in 2010 (75 Fed. Reg. 43460-01 (July 26, 2010)), the Trump Administration withdrew the proposed rulemaking in 2017 (82 Fed. Reg. 60932-01 (Dec. 26, 2017).) While this lack of a specific standard for website compliance does not violate the due process rights of businesses or make the ADA unenforceable given that “[c]ourts are perfectly capable of interpreting the meaning of ‘equal’ and ‘effective’” (Id. at p. 911), it does create uncertainty among both businesses and the public; also, the lack of a specific standard may be related to a recent reported increase in litigation, or at least threatened litigation, regarding the accessibility of websites.
WCAG Standards, Including Versions and Levels of Compliance. In the absence of a specific standard for website compliance, courts and government entities sometimes rely on private standards developed by technology and accessibility experts, including the World Wide Web Consortium (W3C), the main international standards organization for the Internet. As part of their Web Accessibility Initiative, W3C has promulgated a series of web accessibility guidelines, including the Web Content Accessibility Guidelines (WCAG). WCAG standards are a set of recommendations for making Web content more accessible, particularly for people with disabilities. The first set of accessibility guidelines, called WCAG 1.0 became a W3C recommendation in May of 1999. The guidelines have been updated since then. WCAG 2.0 was published in December 2008 and became an ISO standard in October 2012. WCAG 2.1 became a W3C Recommendation in June of 2018.
WCAG 2.1 retains WCAG 2.0 in its entirety, but adds 17 additional success criteria to the 2.0 standard. The new success criteria are intended to address viewing of content on mobile devices and provide additional success criteria to improve the experience of individuals with low vision and cognitive impairments. W3C’s overview of the additional success criteria in version 2.1 can be accessed at the WCAG website: https://www.w3.org/WAI/standards-guidelines/wcag/new-in-21/. Regarding the level of compliance within each version of the standard, “Level A is a subset of Level AA. There are 25 criteria that you have to meet to reach Level A. To reach Level AA you have to meet 13 more criteria in addition to the 25 for Level A.” (https://myaccessible.website/blog/wcaglevels/wcag-levels-a-aa-aaa-difference)
Courts and government entities have relied upon WCAG standards in addressing accessibility issues and compliance, particularly in settlement agreements and consent decrees. For example:
- In 2013, DOJ entered into a settlement agreement with Louisiana Tech University that encompassed not only the University’s website, but also all electronic and information technology, instructional materials and online courses. (See Settlement Agreement with Louisiana Tech University, DJ #204-33-116 (July 22, 2013), available at https://www.ada.gov/louisiana-tech.htm.)
- In 2014, the National Federal of the Blind and DOJ entered into a consent decree with HRB Digital LLC and HRB Tax Group, Inc., agreeing that H&R Block’s website and apps would comply with the WCAG 2.0 AA standards by January 1, 2016. (National Federation of the Blind, et al v. HRB Digital LLC and HRB Tax Group, Inc., Civil Action No. 1:13-cv-10799-GAO, United States District Court for the State of Massachusetts, Boston Division, Consent Decree – available at https://www.ada.gov/hrb-cd.htm.)
- In August of 2016, DOJ notified the University of California, Berkeley, that large segments of its free, publicly available audio and video content (including its YouTube channel, iTunes U platform, and Open Online Courses) were not accessible to individuals with hearing, vision, or manual disabilities. The letter observed that, “While the University of California’s Information Technology Accessibility Policy adopts the WCAG 2.0 AA technical standard, which provides clear parameters for ensuring online content is accessible to individuals with disabilities, UC Berkeley has not ensured compliance with its policy.” (See Letter dated August 30, 2016 to University of California, Berkeley, available at https://www.ada.gov/briefs/uc_berkley_lof.pdf.)
- In November of 2018, the National Federation of the Blind announced a settlement agreement with Alameda County, California, in which the county agreed to utilize WCAG 2.1 AA in making its election website accessible. (See https://www.nfb.org/about-us/press-room/alameda-county-will-make-voting-more-accessible-blind.)
- In January of 2019, the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals observed in Robles that “the district court can order compliance with WCAG 2.0 as an equitable remedy if, after discovery, the website and app fail to satisfy the ADA.” (Robles, supra, 913 F.3d at p. 907.)
Significantly, the State of California also uses WCAG 2.1 AA as the benchmark for its agencies to comply with accessibility requirements. State law—specifically Government Code Section 11135--requires that all electronic and information technology developed or purchased by the State of California Government is accessible to people with disabilities. Furthermore, the State specifically requires that all agencies, and any contractors working for them, ensure that their public websites are accessible to the general public, and are aligned with WCAG 2.1 Level AA Standards.
This bill creates a presumption in state law that a website of a business which is a public place or place of public accommodation (and thus required to comply with the ADA and state accessibility laws) that meets WCAG 2.1 Level A and AA standards complies with state accessibility requirements. The bill sensibly adopts that same standard for the accessibility of websites of private businesses that are required to comply with state and federal accessibility laws.
Reported Recent Uptick in Litigation (Almost Exclusively Outside of California) Regarding Website Compliance. The number of website accessibility lawsuits being reportedly is rising, at least in the nation’s federal courts. According to the Los Angeles Times, “lawsuits alleging website accessibility violations totaled 1,053 in the first six months [of 2018], a number that is projected to rise to 2,000 by year’s end, up 90% from 2017. (Martin, Hugo. “Lawsuits targeting business websites over ADA violations are on the rise (Nov. 11, 2018) Los Angeles Times, available at https://www.latimes.com/business/la-fi-hotels-ada-compliance-20181111-story.html.) Seyfarth Shaw LLP, a civil defense firm that publishes a blog devoted to ADA compliance lawsuits found that “lawsuits alleging inaccessible websites and mobile apps accounted for at least a fifth of the total number of ADA Title III lawsuits filed” last year and—along with hotel accessibility information on reservation websites—such types of claims were one of the “hot trends” of 2019. (Vu, Minh, Review and Hot Trends for 2020 (January 2, 2020), available at https://www.adatitleiii.com/2020/01/ada-title-iii-litigation-a-2019-review-and-hot-trends-for-2020/.). Interestingly, the Seyfarth Shaw report found that in 2019, only ten website accessibility lawsuits were filed in California’s federal courts.
There seems to be general agreement that DOJ’s withdrawal of its proposed rulemakings prompted the increased incidence of litigation regarding website compliance. “The Trump administration’s decision to stop drafting rules for website ADA compliance is widely seen as opening the floodgates to legal action.” (Martin, supra.) And these trends have caught the attention of Congress. For example, U.S. Representative Ted Budd (R-NC), joined by more than 100 members of Congress, urged then-Attorney General Jeff Sessions to address the situation. (Martin, supra.) In its response letter dated September 25, 2018, DOJ set forth its current views on the issue of website accessibility. DOJ reiterated its position that the ADA applies to public accommodations’ websites, which it first articulated over 20 years ago, and that absence of regulations specifically addressing websites does not provide a basis for noncompliance with the ADA’s requirements.
Author’s Amendments. Concerns have been raised to the author and Committee about whether the bill expands liability under existing law to entities beyond those which are required by existing state law to make their premises accessible to the public. Given that the bill articulates a limitation on the ability to recover damages and establishes a presumption against an entity’s liability, but does not create a new cause of action, this interpretation may not be reasonable. The bill should only apply in circumstances where state law already establishes liability. But in an abundance of caution, the author has agreed to add the following clarifying language to the bill (on Page Four, beginning at Line 33):
(d) This section is not intended to limit do either of the following:
(1) Limit the rights and remedies available to disabled persons under federal law, or any other state law.
(2) Affect whether an entity is responsible under either Section 51 or Section 51.5 for making its premises accessible to all members of the public, including the disabled and including by means of accessing the entity’s internet website.
In addition, the bill appears to include two typographical errors. For example, on Page 3, at line 14, the bill now states that statutory damages shall only be recovered against an entity based upon the inaccessibility of the entity’s website if the website fails to provide equally effective communication and facilitate full and equal enjoyment of the entity’s goods and services. In fact, damages are recoverable if the website fails to provide equally effective communication or facilitate full and equal enjoyment of the entity’s goods and services. Therefore, the author proposes a technical amendment to change the word “and” to “or.”
Similarly, on Page 5, beginning at line 20, that “a business’ internet website is required to be accessible, and to provide equally effective communication or facilitate full and equal enjoyment of the entity’s goods and services, to the public, including any member of the public who is disabled.” In fact the law requires a website to be accessible, and to provide equally effective communication and facilitate full and equal enjoyment of the entity’s goods and services, to the public, including any member of the public who is disabled. Therefore, the author proposes a technical amendment to change the word “or” to “and.”
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: Disability Rights California writes that, it supports the bill for a number of reasons, including the following:
AB 2123 will help ensure that websites are accessible to persons with disabilities by clearly providing that an internet website is presumed to be accessible if the internet website complies with the Web Content Accessibility Guidelines (WCAG) 2.1 Level AA standard for accessibility of internet websites established by the World Wide Web Consortium (W3C) Accessibility Guidelines Working Group or any subsequent updates. If an internet website meets WCAG standards it is deemed to be compliant with state law and provide a rebuttable safe harbor for a business sued for damages for noncompliance. This presumption, along with the articulation of a clear nationally-recognized compliance standard, the WCAG 2.1 AA standard, provides guidance to businesses of their compliance obligations.
. . .
AB 2123 provides appropriate liability protections for ensuring accessible websites, and provides a clear standard for being in compliance. This should result in greater accessibility of websites throughout the state.
Pending /Prior Related Legislation: SB 937 (Hill, 2020) would authorize a state agency to temporarily remove public documents from digital access if a justifiable impediment exists and the Director of Technology verifies the impediment prohibits full compliance and the state agency complies with certain requirements. Any file or document removed after October 14, 2017 would be subject to these requirements.
AB 3002 (Stats. 2018, Ch. 680, Gray) requires local jurisdictions that issue building permits for commercial construction or business licenses to make available a notice containing specified information regarding disability access, as well as an information notice to applicants.
AB 434 (Stats. 2017, Ch. 780, Baker) requires the director of each state agency or entity and the chief information officer of that state agency or entity to post on the home page of the agency’s or entity’s website a signed certification that the website is in compliance with specified accessibility standards. The bill would require the director to create a standard form that each state agency’s or state entity’s chief information officer would be required to use to determine whether the state agency’s or state entity’s Internet Web site is in compliance with the specified accessibility standards.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
Disability Rights California
Opposition
None on file
Analysis Prepared by: Alison Merrilees / JUD. / (916) 319-2334
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):