AB 2217: Income taxes: credit: capital gain: sale of qualified vacant site.
- Session Year: 2019-2020
- House: Assembly
- Latest Version Date: 2020-02-27
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Mar 16, 2020 | In committee: Hearing postponed by committee. |
| Mar 2, 2020 | Re-referred to Com. on REV. & TAX. |
| Feb 27, 2020 | Referred to Com. on REV. & TAX. |
| Feb 13, 2020 | From printer. May be heard in committee March 14. |
| Feb 12, 2020 | Read first time. To print. |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
Date of Hearing: March 16, 2020
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON REVENUE AND TAXATION
Autumn R. Burke, Chairwoman
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 2217 (
Author:Mathis) – As Amended Ver:February 27, 2020
FOR TESTIMONY ONLY
Majority vote. Tax levy. Fiscal committee.
SUBJECT: Income taxes: credit: capital gain: sale of qualified vacant site
SUMMARY: Allows a tax credit under both the Personal Income Tax (PIT) Law and the Corporation Tax (CT) Law available to taxpayers that sell a qualified vacant site and an additional tax credit if specified construction on that site commences within five years from the site's sale date. Specifically, this bill:
- Allows a tax credit, for each taxable year beginning on or after January 1, 2021, and before January 1, 2033, to a taxpayer that sells a "qualified vacant site" in an amount equal to the following:
- Fifty percent of the tax attributable to a capital gain from the sale of a qualified vacant site in the taxable year that it is sold; and,
- Fifty percent of the tax attributable to a capital gain from the sale of a qualified vacant site in the taxable year that the construction process begins to build housing or a mixed-use development on the qualified vacant site if construction begins no later than five years from the sale of the qualified vacant site.
- Defines a "qualified vacant site" as one that meets all of the following conditions:
- An undeveloped site or a site with a building that has been abandoned for three or more years;
- That is surrounded by development on two or more sides; and,
- That has the following unit per acre densities approved for development on the site:
- At least 15 units per acre for a city located in a nonmetropolitan county or for a nonmetropolitan county that has a micropolitan area within it;
- At least 10 units per acre for an unincorporated area in a nonmetropolitan county that is not a micropolitan area within the county;
- At least 20 units per acre for a suburban jurisdiction; or,
- At least 30 units per acre for a city located within a metropolitan county, or for a metropolitan county.
- Defines a "metropolitan" county, a "nonmetropolitan" county, a "micropolitan area", and a "suburban jurisdiction" by reference to Government Code Section 65583.2.
- Allocates the credit when more than one taxpayer owns the qualified vacant site among the taxpayers based on their percentage of ownership.
- Requires the county assessor, upon request of the taxpayer or the Franchise Tax Board (FTB), to provide a report relating to the use of the qualified vacant site.
- Allows credit carryover for the following taxable year and the succeeding seven years until the credit is exhausted.
- Authorizes the FTB to issue any regulations necessary or appropriate to implement this credit.
- Sunsets the credit provisions on December 1, 2033.
- Provides that, for purposes of complying with Revenue and Taxation Code (R&TC) Section 41, the Legislature finds and declares all of the following:
- The specific goals, purposes, and objectives that this credit will achieve is to encourage voluntary participation in the sale of vacant sites for the repurposing and construction of housing or mixed-use developments on the site.
- Detailed performance indicators for the Legislature to use in determining whether this credit meets the goals, purposes, and objectives listed above is the number of taxpayers taking the credit; and,
- To review this tax credit's effectiveness requires the Legislative Analyst's Office (LAO) to provide a report to the Legislature, on or before December 1, 2023, and every two years thereafter, until December 1, 2033. Requires the LAO's report to include information on the number of taxpayers claiming the credits and the total amount of the credits provided.
- To assist the Legislature in determining whether this tax credit meets the specific goals, purposes, and objectives listed above, allows the LAO to request information from the FTB and requires the FTB to provide any data so requested.
EXISTING LAW:
- Allows various tax credits under the PIT Law. These credits are generally designed to encourage socially beneficial behavior or to provide relief to taxpayers who incur specified expenses.
- Requires any bill authorizing a new credit to contain all of the following:
- Specific goals, purposes, and objectives that the tax credit will achieve;
- Detailed performance indicators for the Legislature to use when measuring whether the tax credit meets the goals, purposes, and objectives stated in the bill; and,
- Data collection requirements to enable the Legislature to determine whether the tax credit is meeting, failing to meet, or exceeding those specific goals, purposes, and objectives. The requirements shall include the specific data and baseline measurements to be collected and remitted in each year the credit is in effect, for the Legislature to measure the change in performance indicators, and the specific taxpayers, state agencies, or other entities required to collect and remit data. (R&TC Section 41.)
FISCAL EFFECT: The FTB estimates that this bill would result in revenue losses of $31 million in fiscal year (FY) 2020-21, and $75 million in FY 2021-22 and FY 2022-23.
COMMENTS:
- The author has provided the following statement in support of this bill:
In order to combat our state's housing crisis, creative steps must be taken in order to incentivize development of housing units. One resource that can be readily utilized is the repurposing of unused lots or abandoned sites. AB 2217 provides this pathway by granting a tax credit worth 100% of the tax attributable to the capital gains from the sale of the qualified vacant site; the site must be utilized for the repurposing and construction of housing or mixed-use developments. While the state's housing crisis will not be easily solved, the credit found in AB 2217 will help to maximize the potential of land otherwise sitting idle or abandoned.
- The California Tax Reform Association is in opposition to this bill on the basis that it is a costly tax bill.
- The Franchise Tax Board has identified the following implementation and policy concerns in its analysis of this bill:
- "This bill uses the undefined phrases, ‘sale,’ and ‘construction process begins.’ The absence of a definition to clarify these terms could lead to disputes with taxpayers and would complicate the administration of this bill. For example, would the sale date be the date sales documents are signed? The date escrow closes? Would the construction process begin as of the sales date? The date project estimates are begun? The date all plans and permits are approved? For clarity and ease of administration, it is recommended that the bill be amended."
- "The bill is silent on how the ‘tax attributable to a capital gain’ would be determined for purposes of calculating the credit. For example, would the taxpayer's tax rate be applied to the capital gain exclusive of any offsetting losses? Would there be a ‘tax attributable to a capital gain’ if a taxpayer had no tax liability for the taxable year? To ensure consistency with the author's intent and eliminate disputes between taxpayers and the department, this bill should be amended."
- "It is unclear whether the ‘qualified vacant site’ must be located in California. To ensure consistency with the author's intent and eliminate disputes between taxpayers and the department, this bill should be amended."
- "The FTB lacks the expertise to determine that a site is a qualified vacant site and it is unclear how the FTB and the taxpayer would determine the date the construction process begins. Typically, credits involving areas for which the department lacks expertise are certified by another agency or agencies that possess the relevant expertise. The certification language would specify the responsibilities of both the certifying agency and the taxpayer. It is recommended that this bill be amended to include a certifying agency."
- "It is unclear whether for purposes of eligibility for the second half of the credit a site must be a ‘qualified vacant site’ as of the date the construction process begins. To ensure consistency with the author's intent and to avoid disputes between taxpayers and the department, this bill should be amended."
- "Because the bill fails to specify otherwise, the FTB would be subject to the rulemaking procedures required under the Administrative Procedures Act (APA), Government Code section 11340 et seq. Following these procedures may delay the immediate implementation of this bill. To prevent any delay, it is recommended that the author add a provision exempting the FTB from the APA when the FTB is prescribing rules, guidelines, or procedures to carry out the bill's purpose."
- "If requested, this bill could require the FTB to provide confidential taxpayer information to the LAO. However, the bill fails to prohibit the LAO from further disclosure of confidential taxpayer information. It is recommended that the bill be amended to apply the appropriate disclosure restrictions to the LAO."
- "One half of the credit would be allowed in the taxable year the qualified vacant site is sold regardless of any subsequent activity to build housing or a mixed-use development on the site. The second half of the credit would be allowed if the construction process is begun within five year of the sale, regardless of whether a housing or mixed use development on the qualified vacant site is completed and certified for occupancy. A recapture provision would resolve these issues."
- "Additionally, because the bill fails to specify otherwise any subsequent sale of the same property that remains a qualified vacant site would be eligible for the credit."
- "This bill fails to limit the amount of the credit that may be taken. Credits that could potentially be quite costly are sometimes limited to a specified aggregate amount per taxable year, or on a per-project or per-taxpayer basis."
- Committee Staff Comments:
- California's housing shortage: According to a recent LAO report, California's home prices and rental prices are higher than just about anywhere else in the country[1]. The average home price in California is $440,000 or about 2.5 times more expensive than the national average and the average monthly rent in California is about $1,240 or about 50% higher than the national average. Though several factors have led to California's high housing costs, the main driving force is a lack of new housing[2]. In general, cities across the state, and particularly along the coast, are building fewer homes than people want. In order to mitigate the state's problem with housing affordability, the LAO estimates that California will have to at least double the number of units currently being built to prevent home prices from growing at a rate faster than the rest of the country. If California home and rental prices continue on this trend, those at the margin (i.e., those who currently earn just enough to purchase a home or rent an apartment within a desired location) will likely be pushed out of the market.
- What does this bill do? This bill offers a tax credit to a taxpayer that sells a qualified vacant site in an amount equal to the tax attributed to a capital gain from the sale. California generally follows federal law for determining the amount of gain or loss from the sale of a capital asset, such as land. However, under state law, capital gains are taxed at the same rate as ordinary income. The amount of the tax credit this bill proposes to provide would be equal to:
- 50% of the tax attributable to a capital gain from the sale of a qualified vacant site in the taxable year that it is sold; and,
- 50% of the tax attributable to a capital gain from the sale of a qualified vacant site in the taxable year that the construction process begins to build housing or a mixed-use development on the qualified vacant site, if construction begins no later than five years from the sale of the qualified vacant site.
- No requirement that any units actually be built: This bill does not require that any housing actually be constructed. The credit is not predicated on the sale of the site to a developer ready to build. Nor is the credit predicated on the type of housing built, such as a credit designed to encourage affordable housing production. Additionally, the tax credit is not targeted to those areas in California where underproduction is impacting housing affordability. If no housing construction begins within the five-year period after the sale of the site, then the taxpayer remains eligible for a 50% credit on the tax attributable to the capital gain.
- Land availability for housing construction: Recently, several actions have been taken to make state and local public lands available for affordable housing development. For instance, Governor Newsom issued Executive Order N-06-19 to make excess state and local land available for affordable housing and legislation has been enacted to connect affordable housing developers to local surplus land[3] and to require cities and counties to inventory and report excess public lands to the state.[4] In 2018, voters in the City of Oakland approved a $6,000 annual special tax that is applicable to undeveloped property within the city. Measures such as Oakland's special tax increase the holding costs associated with owning undeveloped property and may prompt impacted property owners to sell their undeveloped land. These property owners would benefit from this bill's tax credit.
- Incentive or windfall? It is often difficult to determine with any accuracy whether any credit will serve as a true incentive for taxpayers to undertake socially useful action, such as selling a vacant site that ultimately results in more housing, or whether the credit simply serves to reward taxpayers for actions they would have taken in the absence of a tax expenditure program because it is in their best interest to do so. This Committee may wish to consider whether this tax credit would result in a windfall to property owners, who for a myriad of reasons, may find it is an opportune time to sell their property.
- Tax credit amount: The tax credit amount is based on the tax liability incurred by a taxpayer for the realized gain. As such, a taxpayer may receive a larger credit because the value of the land today is worth substantially more than it was when the land was first purchased. In situations where the land was inherited, the taxpayer would likely have very little tax liability because of the step-up in basis. In these situations, the taxpayer may receive a very small amount of credit, even if the sale of the land results in the eventual production of housing units.
- No statewide overall cap: This bill does not limit the amount of the credit that taxpayers may claim either for a specific property site or on an overall statewide basis. Consequently, this bill lacks any backstop as to its possible revenue implications. Credits such as these, which could be quite costly, generally include a cap to limit the potential revenue loss.
- 100% tax credit: For some taxpayers, this bill could provide a taxpayer with a 100% tax credit, which would be unprecedented in California's income tax laws.
- R&TC Section 41 and Committee sunset date policy: Both R&TC Section 41 and this Committee's policy require that all new or extended tax expenditures include a statement of the policy being advanced by the expenditure as well as a plan for measuring the expenditure's future success with data. This Committee's policy also requires that all tax expenditure proposals contain a five-year sunset provision. This bill contains a twelve year sunset provision. Bills that fail to comply with this policy will be ineligible for a vote in this Committee. As such, the author may wish to amend this bill following its hearing to shorten its sunset provisions.
- Related legislation: AB 2058 (Gabriel) would create a $500 million program to provide tax credits to taxpayers who sell their housing properties to qualified developers to maintain as affordable housing units. The tax credit amount would be the lesser of $1 million or, the sum of 50% of the federal capital gains taxes and 50% of the state income taxes recognized for the sale of the property. AB 2058 was heard for testimony only by this Committee on March 9, 2020.
- Prior legislation: AB 201 (Steinorth), of the 2017-18 Legislative Session, was substantially similar to this bill. AB 201 was never heard by this Committee and returned to the Chief Clerk's office.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
None on file
Opposition
California Tax Reform Association
Analysis Prepared by: Rose Marie Kinnee / REV. & TAX. / (916) 319-2098
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):