AB 2234: Classified school and community college employees: personnel commission: legal counsel.
- Session Year: 2019-2020
- House: Assembly
- Latest Version Date: 2020-09-09
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Sep 9, 2020 | Chaptered by Secretary of State - Chapter 48, Statutes of 2020. |
| Sep 9, 2020 | Approved by the Governor. |
| Sep 4, 2020 | Enrolled and presented to the Governor at 2 p.m. |
| Aug 28, 2020 | In Assembly. Ordered to Engrossing and Enrolling. |
| Aug 28, 2020 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Assembly. (Ayes 39. Noes 0. Page 4374.). |
| Aug 7, 2020 | Read second time. Ordered to Consent Calendar. |
| Aug 6, 2020 | From committee: Do pass. To Consent Calendar. (Ayes 5. Noes 0.) (August 5). |
| Jun 23, 2020 | Referred to Com. on L., P.E. & R. |
| Jun 9, 2020 | In Senate. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. |
| Jun 8, 2020 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Senate. (Ayes 77. Noes 0. Page 4674.) |
| May 6, 2020 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| May 5, 2020 | From committee: Do pass. (Ayes 7. Noes 0.) (May 5). |
| Mar 16, 2020 | Re-referred to Com. on P.E. & R. |
| Mar 12, 2020 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to Com. on P.E. & R. Read second time and amended. |
| Mar 2, 2020 | Referred to Coms. on P.E. & R. and HIGHER ED. |
| Feb 14, 2020 | From printer. May be heard in committee March 15. |
| Feb 13, 2020 | Read first time. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Aug 28, 2020 | Consent Calendar AB2234 | Senate Floor |
Passed |
|
| Aug 5, 2020 | Do pass and be ordered to the Consent Calendar | Senate Standing Committee on Labor, Public Employment and Retirement |
Passed |
|
| Jun 8, 2020 | AB 2234 Chau Assembly Third Reading | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| May 5, 2020 | Do pass. | Assembly Standing Committee on Public Employment and Retirement |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
SENATE RULES COMMITTEE Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | AB 2234 |
CONSENT
Bill No: AB 2234
Author: Chau (D)
Amended: 3/12/20 in Assembly
Vote: 21
SENATE LABOR, PUB. EMP. & RET. COMMITTEE: 5-0, 8/5/20
AYES: Hill, Morrell, Jackson, Mitchell, Pan
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 77-0, 6/8/20 - See last page for vote
SUBJECT: Classified school and community college employees: personnel commission: legal counsel
SOURCE: California School Employees Association
DIGEST:
- This bill authorizes a merit based school or community college district’s personnel commission to select its own attorney rather than having to use the district’s attorney if a majority of the commission declares that a conflict of interest exists between the commission and the district or the district’s governing board.
ANALYSIS:
Existing law:
- Authorizes school and community college districts to adopt, as specified, a civil service merit system to regulate personnel through a three-member personnel commission (college districts may have five members) and a personnel director (Education Code § 45221 et seq. and Education Code § 88051 et seq.).
- Requires, where a district adopts a merit system, the personnel commission to classify all employees and positions within the district’s jurisdiction and designate them as the classified service. However, specified employees, including certificated employees, are exempt from the classified service (Education Code § 45256 and § 88076).
- Requires the commission to prepare an annual budget which is subject, as specified, to approval by the county superintendent of schools and creates a process to resolve budget issues where the superintendent fails to approve the budget (Education Code § 45253 and § 88073).
- Requires the district board’s legal counsel to aid and represent the commission in all legal matters. If counsel does not respond to the commission’s request for aid within 15 days the commission may employ its own attorney and charge the cost against the district’s general fund. Existing law also requires the district board’s counsel to refuse to represent the commission where counsel knows or has reason to know that a conflict of interest exists between the interests of the commission and the interests of the governing board or the district (Education Code § 45313 and § 88132).
This bill:
- Authorizes a member of the commission to declare that a conflict exists between the interests of the commission and the interests of the governing board or the school district. However, this bill requires that a majority of the commission must approve the declaration for a conflict to exist.
- Provides that if the commission finds that a conflict exists, the commission may employ its own attorney, and the reasonable cost thereof shall constitute a legal charge against the general funds of the district.
Background
According to the Los Angeles Unified School District website:
In the early 1930's, political corruption was rampant throughout the City of Los Angeles. Cronyism and patronage were prevalent at all levels of local government. In the Los Angeles Unified School District, the situation resulted in the replacement of over 700 District employees by "friends" and supporters of local politicians. As a result, there was a reaction by concerned citizens who petitioned the State legislature for the establishment of an independent civil service commission for the District. The Personnel Commission came into existence on June 15, 1936, as the first legally sanctioned Personnel Commission in the country to administer a personnel program under a merit system for non-certificated employees of a school system. Its primary purposes were to ensure that employees are selected for employment and promotion solely on the basis of merit and removed for just cause. It also provided for an impartial body to adjudicate employee appeals of discipline, medical disqualification and examinations. Both employees and administrative representatives sponsored the merit system law when it was under consideration by the State Legislature and the Board of Education in a spirit of reform, formally adopted it.
Purpose of personnel commissions. According to the California State Personnel Commission Association:
The Personnel Commission has three core responsibilities as defined in the California Education Code. These are as follows:
- Oversee a personnel management program based on merit principles that ensure the selection and promotion of employees is based solely on qualifications through competitive examination.
- Develop and administer policies governing employment matters to ensure the fair and equitable treatment of employees within the classified service.
- Conduct appeal hearings on matters involving employee disciplinary action, employment examinations, and personnel policies and procedures.
Comments
Author’s concerns with current law regarding legal counsel. According to the author:
The problem with the law is that only school district lawyers can decide when conflicts of interest exist, and personnel commissions have no role in that process. This favors one client over the other and is a growing problem.
Personnel commissions are civil service systems intended to provide fairness for classified employees and to ensure that districts are hiring and promoting qualified employees through consistent and lawful testing and hiring practices. One of the major functions of a personnel commission is to hear and render decisions on employee appeals of the district’s disciplinary actions. The commission acts in a quasi-judicial capacity as a neutral decision maker.
In this hearing process, legal counsel of the district functions as the prosecutor, i.e., one of the parties litigating before the personnel commission. When the personnel commission needs legal advice, whether procedural or substantive, there is an inherent conflict of interest if the personnel commission must rely on the advice of the same attorney or law firm representing the district in the action.
When personnel commissions seek independent legal counsel, and a district’s attorney refuses to agree that a conflict of interest exists, it diminishes the commission’s ability to function and compromises the fairness of the entire hearing process. In addition, when district counsel blocks a commission from receiving independent counsel, it undermines the independence of the personnel commission.
AB 2234 ensures a fair process by giving commissioners and districts a role in determining when conflicts exist between them, so the process does not favor one side.
Committee comments. This bill establishes greater independence for the personnel commissions of school and community college districts that have adopted merit based personnel systems by allowing a majority of the personnel commission to decide when to hire outside counsel.
Senate Labor, Public Employment and Retirement Committee staff sees this bill as similar to current law that permits some state departments to hire outside counsel directly although the general rule is to use the Attorney General’s Office (AG) or to get permission from the AG before employing outside counsel. Those statutory authorizations were effectively policy choices to provide those departments more independence to conduct their legal work. Here too, this issue is a policy choice to ensure school personnel commissions’ independence in their mission to administer a merit based personnel system for classified school employees.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: No Local: No
SUPPORT: (Verified 8/7/20)
California School Employees Association (source)
California Federation of Teachers
California Labor Federation
California Professional Firefighters
California School Personnel Commissioners Association
California Teachers Association
Service Employees International Union – California
OPPOSITION: (Verified 8/7/20)
None received
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: According to the California School Employees Association (CSEA):
It is wrong to allow district legal counsel to be gatekeepers of whether commissions can secure their own counsel. CSEA is unaware of any other law that only allows lawyers to determine if a conflict exists between two clients and prevents clients from making such a determination.
AB 2234 remedies this problem by allowing personnel commissions, by majority vote, and district legal counsel, to determine if conflicts of interest exist, ensuring fairness for commissions, districts and classified employees.
According to the California Teachers Association:
Current law allows for the legal counsel of the governing board to represent the district personnel commission in all legal matters unless a conflict of interest exists between the commission and the governing board. This legislation would allow commissions to investigate conflicts with a majority vote of the commission and shifts power from the governing board and its legal counsel to the district personnel commission.
According to the Service Employees International Union – California:
It fundamentally undermines justice to allow lawyers to determine if a conflict of interest exists between two clients and then bar only one client from making such a decision for their self. AB 2234 would ensure personnel commissions can, in fact, remain impartial by allowing them to have a role in determining if a conflict of interest exists between themselves and a school district.
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 77-0, 6/8/20
AYES: Aguiar-Curry, Arambula, Bauer-Kahan, Berman, Bigelow, Bloom, Boerner Horvath, Bonta, Brough, Burke, Calderon, Carrillo, Cervantes, Chau, Chen, Chiu, Choi, Chu, Cooley, Cooper, Cunningham, Megan Dahle, Daly, Diep, Eggman, Flora, Fong, Frazier, Friedman, Gabriel, Gallagher, Cristina Garcia, Eduardo Garcia, Gipson, Gloria, Gonzalez, Gray, Grayson, Holden, Irwin, Jones-Sawyer, Kalra, Kamlager, Kiley, Lackey, Levine, Limón, Low, Maienschein, Mathis, Mayes, McCarty, Medina, Mullin, Nazarian, Obernolte, O'Donnell, Patterson, Petrie-Norris, Quirk-Silva, Ramos, Reyes, Luz Rivas, Robert Rivas, Rodriguez, Blanca Rubio, Salas, Santiago, Smith, Mark Stone, Ting, Voepel, Waldron, Weber, Wicks, Wood, Rendon
NO VOTE RECORDED: Muratsuchi, Quirk
Prepared by: Glenn Miles / L., P.E. & R. / (916) 651-1556
8/7/20 15:19:33
**** END ****
SENATE COMMITTEE ON LABOR, PUBLIC EMPLOYMENT AND RETIREMENT
Senator Jerry Hill, Chair
2019 - 2020 Regular
Bill No: AB 2234 Hearing Date: August 5, 2020
Author: | Chau | ||
Version: | March 12, 2020 | ||
Urgency: | No | Fiscal: | No |
Consultant: | Glenn Miles | ||
SUBJECT: Classified school and community college employees: personnel commission: legal counsel.
KEY ISSUE
Should a school or community college district’s personnel commission be able to select its own attorney rather than having to use the district’s attorney if a majority of the commission declares that a conflict of interest exists between the commission and the district or the district’s governing board?
ANALYSIS
Existing law:
- Authorizes school and community college districts to adopt, as specified, a civil service merit system to regulate personnel through a 3-member personnel commission (college districts may have 5 members) and a personnel director (Education Code § 45221 et seq. and Education Code § 88051 et seq.).
- Where a district adopts a merit system, requires the personnel commission to classify all employees and positions within the district’s jurisdiction and designate them as the classified service. However, specified employees, including certificated employees, are exempt from the classified service (Education Code § 45256 and § 88076).
- Requires the commission to prepare an annual budget which is subject, as specified, to approval by the county superintendent of schools and creates a process to resolve budget issues where the superintendent fails to approve the budget (Education Code § 45253 and § 88073).
- Requires the district board’s legal counsel to aid and represent the commission in all legal matters. If counsel does not respond to the commission’s request for aid within 15 days the commission may employ its own attorney and charge the cost against the district’s general fund. Existing law also requires the district board’s counsel to refuse to represent the commission where counsel knows or has reason to know that a conflict of interest exists between the interests of the commission and the interests of the governing board or the district (Education Code § 45313 and § 88132).
This bill:
- Authorizes a member of the commission to declare that a conflict exists between the interests of the commission and the interests of the governing board or the school district. However, the bill requires that a majority of the commission must approve the declaration for a conflict to exist.
- Provides that if the commission finds that a conflict exists, the commission may employ its own attorney, and the reasonable cost thereof shall constitute a legal charge against the general funds of the district.
COMMENTS
1. Historical Background.
According to the Los Angeles Unified School District website,
In the early 1930's, political corruption was rampant throughout the City of Los Angeles. Cronyism and patronage were prevalent at all levels of local government. In the Los Angeles Unified School District, the situation resulted in the replacement of over 700 District employees by "friends" and supporters of local politicians. As a result, there was a reaction by concerned citizens who petitioned the State legislature for the establishment of an independent civil service commission for the District. The Personnel Commission came into existence on June 15, 1936, as the first legally sanctioned Personnel Commission in the country to administer a personnel program under a merit system for non-certificated employees of a school system. Its primary purposes were to ensure that employees are selected for employment and promotion solely on the basis of merit and removed for just cause. It also provided for an impartial body to adjudicate employee appeals of discipline, medical disqualification and examinations. Both employees and administrative representatives sponsored the merit system law when it was under consideration by the State Legislature and the Board of Education in a spirit of reform, formally adopted it.
2. Purpose of Personnel Commissions.
According to the California State Personnel Commission Association,
The Personnel Commission has three core responsibilities as defined in the California Education Code. These are as follows:
Oversee a personnel management program based on merit principles that ensure the selection and promotion of employees is based solely on qualifications through competitive examination.
Develop and administer policies governing employment matters to ensure the fair and equitable treatment of employees within the classified service.
Conduct appeal hearings on matters involving employee disciplinary action, employment examinations, and personnel policies and procedures.
3. Author’s Concerns with Current Law Regarding Legal Counsel.
According to the author,
The problem with the law is that only school district lawyers can decide when conflicts of interest exist, and personnel commissions have no role in that process. This favors one client over the other and is a growing problem.
Personnel commissions are civil service systems intended to provide fairness for classified employees and to ensure that districts are hiring and promoting qualified employees through consistent and lawful testing and hiring practices. One of the major functions of a personnel commission is to hear and render decisions on employee appeals of the district’s disciplinary actions. The commission acts in a quasi-judicial capacity as a neutral decision maker.
In this hearing process, legal counsel of the district functions as the prosecutor, i.e., one of the parties litigating before the personnel commission. When the personnel commission needs legal advice, whether procedural or substantive, there is an inherent conflict of interest if the personnel commission must rely on the advice of the same attorney or law firm representing the district in the action.
When personnel commissions seek independent legal counsel, and a district’s attorney refuses to agree that a conflict of interest exists, it diminishes the commission’s ability to function and compromises the fairness of the entire hearing process. In addition, when district counsel blocks a commission from receiving independent counsel, it undermines the independence of the personnel commission.
AB 2234 ensures a fair process by giving commissioners and districts a role in determining when conflicts exist between them, so the process does not favor one side.
4. Committee Comments.
Merit Based School Personnel Commissions’ Independence From School Districts
This bill establishes greater independence for the personnel commissions of school and community college districts that have adopted merit based personnel systems by allowing a majority of the personnel commission to decide when to hire outside counsel.
The Los Angeles Community College District (LACCD) and the Los Angeles Unified School District (LAUSD) expressed concerns to committee staff that the bill does not define “conflict of interest” and recommended defining the term by referencing the State Bar’s Rules of Professional Conduct. These proposed amendments are unnecessary and ineffective. Therefore, the committee staff does not recommend the committee adopt them.
After consultation with Senate Judiciary Committee staff, SLPER committee staff believes that the bill is not really about legal conflicts. Rather the bill is an effort to preserve school personnel commission independence from district counsel misinterpretation or contravention of existing statute.
Current law already requires the district counsel to refuse to provide legal services if counsel finds there is a conflict or should reasonably believe there is a conflict. Upon such a refusal, the commission can then hire outside counsel and expense reasonable costs against the district’s general fund. If counsel violates this provision by refusing to step down in face of what counsel should reasonably know is a conflict, counsel could be subject to sanctions by the State Bar under a violation of the California Supreme Court’s Rules of Professional Conduct. Because school districts’ counsel are already required to recuse themselves if they should reasonably know there is a conflict and because all California licensed attorneys are already required to assess conflicts under the Rules of Professional Conduct and act accordingly, the issue of conflicts appears to be secondary.
The bill gives the decision to determine a conflict to a majority vote of the personnel commission. The proposed amendments do not aid in the bill’s goals. The commissioners are not (generally) attorneys and have no current obligation to follow the Rules of Professional Conduct. Thus, the proposed amendment from LACCD and LAUSD could limit the personnel commission’s independence. In any case, it is unclear how the commissioners could determine a conflict under the Rules of Professional Conduct without resorting to legal counsel since the Rules are not exactly a short, precise, dictionary definition but rather a complex balancing test requiring legal training and judgment.
Committee staff sees this bill as similar to current law that permits some state departments to hire outside counsel directly although the general rule is to use the Attorney General’s office (AG) or to get permission from the AG before employing outside counsel. Those statutory authorizations were effectively policy choices to provide those departments more independence to conduct their legal work. Here too, this issue is a policy choice to ensure school personnel commissions’ independence in their mission to administer a merit based personnel system for classified school employees.
The bill mitigates any cost concerns since providing the commission more independence to seek external counsel should serve as a check on school district counsel from trying to represent the commission in cases from which legal counsel should recuse itself. On the other side of the ledger, requiring a majority of the commission to authorize external counsel over school district counsel should serve as a check on abusing the use of external counsel over school district counsel.
5. Proponent Arguments
According to the California School Employees Association,
It is wrong to allow district legal counsel to be gatekeepers of whether commissions can secure their own counsel. CSEA is unaware of any other law that only allows lawyers to determine if a conflict exists between two clients and prevents clients from making such a determination.
AB 2234 remedies this problem by allowing personnel commissions, by majority vote, and district legal counsel, to determine if conflicts of interest exist, ensuring fairness for commissions, districts and classified employees
According to the California Teachers Association,
Current law allows for the legal counsel of the governing board to represent the district personnel commission in all legal matters unless a conflict of interest exists between the commission and the governing board. This legislation would allow commissions to investigate conflicts with a majority vote of the commission and shifts power from the governing board and its legal counsel to the district personnel commission.
According to SEIU – California,
It fundamentally undermines justice to allow lawyers to determine if a conflict of interest exists between two clients and then bar only one client from making such a decision for their self. AB 2234 would ensure personnel commissions can, in fact, remain impartial by allowing them to have a role in determining if a conflict of interest exists between themselves and a school district.
3. Opponent Arguments:
None on file.
4. Prior Legislation:
None found.
SUPPORT
California School Employees Association (Sponsor)
California Federation of Teachers
California Labor Federation
California Professional Firefighters
California School Personnel Commissioners Association
California Teachers Association
Service Employees International Union – California
OPPOSITION
None received.
-- END --
ASSEMBLY THIRD READING
ATR Bill Id:AB 2234
Author:(Chau)
As Amended Ver:March 12, 2020
Majority vote
SUMMARY:
Makes changes relating to legal counsel and representation of a personnel commission.
Major Provisions
- Authorizes a member of the personnel commission (commission) to declare a conflict exists between the interests if the commission and the interests of the governing board or the district.
- Provides that a conflict must not be found, unless approved by a majority vote of the members of the commission.
COMMENTS:
- Brief History of the Personnel Commissions and California Public Schools
Also commonly referred to as "merit systems" or "civil service systems" relating to public education in California, there are over 100 of these systems which are independent of the school or community college district's governing board to administer classified school employee hiring and retention through a statutory framework authorized by the Education Code.
These systems derive from the late 19th and early 20th century civil service movement that sought to curtail "spoils" of the system whereby elected political candidates rewarded their supporters with government positions. These systems arose out of a particularly egregious school board decision to discharge over 700 classified employees in the 1930s upon the new board's election. This history strongly suggest that the Legislature intended the merit system framework as a means to protect classified employees from local political mistreatment at a time prior to public sector collective bargaining.
- Obligations of Lawyers Relating to Conflicts of Interest Under the Model Rules of Professional Conduct, Generally
Generally, the Model Rules of Professional Conduct for Lawyers (Model Rules) establish the standards of ethics and professional conduct for lawyers, to which a lawyer must abide. The Model Rules serve to ensure the integrity of officers of the legal system who have a special responsibility for the quality of justice and establish the principles that include the lawyer's obligation to zealously protect and pursue the legitimate interests of the client within the bounds of the law. A lawyer's violation of these standards may result in sanctions or the lawyer being disbarred by the applicable State Bar – both damaging to the reputation of a lawyer. Thus, it goes to follow that a lawyer is held to a very high standard of professional and ethical conduct and there potentially could be a very high price to pay for violating the Model Rules.
In the practice of law, conflicting responsibilities are encountered and generally, the majority of difficult ethical problems arise from conduct between a lawyer's responsibilities to the client, the legal system, and the lawyer's own interests. The principles of the Model Rules regarding conflicts of interests for lawyers derive from a basic underlying principle: one may not serve two masters who have opposite interests.
There are a number of potential opportunities in which a lawyer may become subject to a conflict of interest when representing a client. Although there are nuances to each particular matter involving such conflicts or potential conflicts, at minimum, a lawyer has an obligation to the client to disclose the conflict (including any potential conflict), and at most, recuse himself or herself from representation, especially if the conflict cannot be avoided.
- Conflicting Interests of Legal Representation Relative to Governing Boards of School Districts or Community College Districts and Commissions
The legal counsel of a governing board of a school or community college district is required to represent the commission in all legal matters, and to declare a conflict of interest in matters pending before a commission.
The commission servers as the neutral, objective, and independent body that must decide the merits of an employment matter between a classified school employee and his or her school or community college district employer. Nevertheless, under existing law, the matters before a commission and its decision in a matter may be compromised if legal counsel does not declare that a conflict of interest exists, and if a conflict (or appearance of a conflict) exists as viewed by the Personnel Commission, proceeds with representation. As such, the commission is at substantial neutral, objective, and independent disadvantage in deciding a matter.
What typically may exist as a classic and possible continuing example of conflicts of interest in this employment arena are that the legal counsel represents the governing board of the school or community college district (i.e., the employer). However, the commission (i.e., the neutral, independent, and objective body over employment matters) must depend on representation from the same counsel during employment-related proceedings between an employee of the school or community college district, and his or her employer (again, whom the legal counsel represents), unless the legal counsel declares that a conflict of interest exists, or legal counsel refuses to respond to a written request, as provided, for aid and representation from the commission.
Naturally, the aforementioned example demonstrates an inherent contradiction to the ideals of fair representation, the duty of zealous representation of a client by a lawyer, disclosure of conflicts of interest, and the objectivity, neutrality, and independence of the Personnel Commission. As previously stated, one may not serve two masters who have opposite interests; however, it appears that existing law allows it to occur. Here, only upon a lawyer dedicated to upholding the principles of the Model Rules by disclosing and refusing to represent conflicting interests would a conflict be avoided.
- This Bill Proposes Parity and Flexibility to a Personnel Commission
It is quite likely that the Legislature did not intend existing law to operate in a manner that essentially tilts the scales of equity.
With respect to affording parity, flexibility and maintaining the independence, neutrality, and objectivity of a commission in employment-related matters, this bill would align the principles of the obligations of a lawyer, zealous representation of a client, and the purposes for which independent, objective, and neutral commissions exist.
According to the Author:
"[This bill] amends existing law to protect the independence of personnel commissions. More specifically, it ensures that personnel commissioners have a role in determining if conflicts of interest exist between them and their districts, just like the school board's legal counsel. Thus, commissions will be able to secure independent legal counsel when they find it appropriate, which the current law fails to do. This bill is about ensuring parity to both the district and the commission.
"Assembly Bill 2234 also provides fairness to classified employees. It helps restore their trust that commissions are neutral bodies that will treat them fairly. Commissioners should be able to retain independent legal counsel even if the district's legal counsel refuses to declare a conflict of interest. Otherwise, the fairness of commission hearings – which serve the important role of reviewing the districts' disciplinary actions – can be compromised."
Arguments in Support:
The California School Employees Association states in part that, "The deficiency in law is that only district lawyers have the authority to decide if a conflict of interest exists, weighting the decision in favor of the district. The current statute prevents commissions from choosing their own legal counsel when they believe a conflict of interest exists. The problem is particularly troubling because commissions are independent bodies that provide fairness to classified employees in hiring, promoting and rendering impartial disciplinary decisions on appeal. Their ability to remain neutral decision-makers is compromised when they must use district counsel when a conflict exists.
"Classified employees are hurt when commissioners are denied their right to independent legal counsel. Their jobs hang in the balance. If a commission believes there is a conflict on a personnel matter… [they should be permitted] to do their jobs as neutral, independent bodies."
Arguments in Opposition:
None on file
FISCAL COMMENTS:
None. This bill is keyed nonfiscal by Legislative Counsel.
VOTES:
ASM PUBLIC EMPLOYMENT AND RETIREMENT: 7-0-0
YES: Rodriguez, Voepel, Cooley, Cooper, Fong, O'Donnell, Reyes
UPDATED:
VERSION: March 12, 2020
CONSULTANT: Michael Bolden / P.E. & R. / (916) 319-3957 FN: 0002747
Date of Hearing: May 5, 2020
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON PUBLIC EMPLOYMENT AND RETIREMENT
Freddie Rodriguez, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 2234 (
Author:Chau) – As Amended Ver:March 12, 2020
SUBJECT: Classified school and community college employees: personnel commission: legal counsel
SUMMARY: Makes changes relating to legal counsel and representation of a personnel commission. Specifically, this bill:
- Authorizes a member of the personnel commission (commission) to declare a conflict exists between the interests if the commission and the interests of the governing board or the district.
- Provides that a conflict must not be found, as specified, unless approved by a majority vote of the members of the commission.
- Makes technical and conforming changes for these purposes.
EXISTING LAW:
- Authorizes a school district or community college district to adopt a merit system that establishes a process for the employment and retention of classified employees of the district.
- Requires a district that adopts the merit system to appoint a commission that consists of either three or five members, and requires the commission to classify employees and positions within the jurisdiction of the governing board of a school district or community college district, or of the commission.
- Requires, for K-12 school districts and community college districts:
- Legal counsel of a governing board (of a school or community college district) to aid and represent the commission on all legal matters. If the legal counsel does not respond to a written request by the commission for aid or representation within 15 working days of receipt of the written request, the counsel is deemed to have refused aid or to represent the commission in that matter.
- Legal counsel to refuse to represent the commission in circumstances in which the counsel knows, or has reason to know, that at the time the request is made, a conflict exists between the interests of the commission and those of the governing board or district.
- Authorizes the commission to employ its own attorney if the legal counsel refuses to aid or represent the commission in a legal matter. The reasonable costs of the commission’s own attorney must constitute a legal charge against the funds of the district.
FISCAL EFFECT: None. This bill is keyed nonfiscal by Legislative Counsel.
COMMENT: According to the author, “[This bill] amends existing law to protect the independence of personnel commissions. More specifically, it ensures that personnel commissioners have a role in determining if conflicts of interest exist between them and their districts, just like the school board’s legal counsel. Thus, commissions will be able to secure independent legal counsel when they find it appropriate, which the current law fails to do. This bill is about ensuring parity to both the district and the commission.
“Assembly Bill 2234 also provides fairness to classified employees. It helps restore their trust that commissions are neutral bodies that will treat them fairly. Commissioners should be able to retain independent legal counsel even if the district’s legal counsel refuses to declare a conflict of interest. Otherwise, the fairness of commission hearings – which serve the important role of reviewing the districts’ disciplinary actions – can be compromised.”
- Brief History of the Personnel Commissions and California Public Schools
Also commonly referred to as “merit systems” or “civil service systems” relating to public education in California, there are over 100 of these systems which are independent of the school or community college district’s governing board to administer classified school employee hiring and retention through a statutory framework authorized by the Education Code.
These systems derive from the late 19th and early 20th century civil service movement that sought to curtail “spoils” of the system whereby elected political candidates rewarded their supporters with government positions. These systems arose out of a particularly egregious school board decision to discharge over 700 classified employees in the 1930s upon the new board’s election.
This history strongly suggest that the Legislature intended the merit system framework as a means to protect classified employees from local political mistreatment at a time prior to public sector collective bargaining.
- Obligations of Lawyers Relating to Conflicts of Interest Under the Model Rules of Professional Conduct, Generally
Generally, the Model Rules of Professional Conduct for Lawyers (Model Rules) establish the standards of ethics and professional conduct for lawyers, to which a lawyer must abide. The Model Rules serve to ensure the integrity of officers of the legal system who have a special responsibility for the quality of justice and establish the principles that include the lawyer’s obligation to zealously protect and pursue the legitimate interests of the client within the bounds of the law. A lawyer’s violation of these standards may result in sanctions or the lawyer being disbarred by the applicable State Bar – both damaging to the reputation of a lawyer. Thus, it goes to follow that a lawyer is held to a very high standard of professional and ethical conduct and there potentially could be a very high price to pay for violating the Model Rules.
In the practice of law, conflicting responsibilities are encountered and generally, the majority of difficult ethical problems arise from conduct between a lawyer’s responsibilities to the client, the legal system, and the lawyer’s own interests. The principles of the Model Rules regarding conflicts of interests for lawyers derive from a basic underlying principle: one may not serve two masters who have opposite interests.
There are a number of potential opportunities in which a lawyer may become subject to a conflict of interest when representing a client. Although there are nuances to each particular matter involving such conflicts or potential conflicts, at minimum, a lawyer has an obligation to the client to disclose the conflict (including any potential conflict), and at most, recuse himself or herself from representation, especially if the conflict cannot be avoided.
- Conflicting Interests of Legal Representation Relative to Governing Boards of School Districts or Community College Districts and Commissions
As previously stated under existing law, the legal counsel of a governing board of a school or community college district is required to represent the commission in all legal matters, and to declare a conflict of interest in matters pending before a commission. Therefore, existing law is consistent with the obligation of lawyers to disclose a conflict of interest to a client under the Model Rules. However, a commission is not afforded similar rights when – except where the legal counsel refuses to aid or represent the Personnel Commission in a legal matter – the lawyer does not declare that a conflict exists and there is either an appearance of conflict, or a conflict does, in fact, exist.
The commission servers as the neutral, objective, and independent body that must decide the merits of an employment matter between a classified school employee and his or her school or community college district employer. Nevertheless, under existing law, the matters before a commission and its decision in a matter may be compromised if legal counsel does not declare that a conflict of interest exists, and if a conflict (or appearance of a conflict) exists as viewed by the Personnel Commission, proceeds with representation. As such, the commission is at substantial neutral, objective, and independent disadvantage in deciding a matter.
What typically may exist as a classic and possible continuing example of conflicts of interest in this employment arena are that the legal counsel represents the governing board of the school or community college district (i.e., the employer). However, the commission (i.e., the neutral, independent, and objective body over employment matters) must depend on representation from the same counsel during employment-related proceedings between an employee of the school or community college district, and his or her employer (again, whom the legal counsel represents), unless the legal counsel declares that a conflict of interest exists, or legal counsel refuses to respond to a written request, as provided, for aid and representation from the commission.
Naturally, the aforementioned example demonstrates an inherent contradiction to the ideals of fair representation, the duty of zealous representation of a client by a lawyer, disclosure of conflicts of interest, and the objectivity, neutrality, and independence of the Personnel Commission. As previously stated, one may not serve two masters who have opposite interests; however, it appears that existing law allows it to occur.
Here, only upon a lawyer dedicated to upholding the principles of the Model Rules by disclosing and refusing to represent conflicting interests would a conflict be avoided.
- This Bill Proposes Parity and Flexibility to a Personnel Commission
It is quite likely that the Legislature did not intend existing law to operate in a manner that essentially tilts the scales of equity.
With respect to affording parity, flexibility and maintaining the independence, neutrality, and objectivity of a commission in employment-related matters, this bill would align the principles of the obligations of a lawyer, zealous representation of a client, and the purposes for which independent, objective, and neutral commissions exist.
- Comments by Supporters
The California School Employees Association states that, “Existing law recognizes that there will inevitably be conflicts of interests between commissions and districts. In these cases, the law affords commissions the ability to hire their own lawyers. The deficiency in law is that only district lawyers have the authority to decide if a conflict of interest exists, weighting the decision in favor of the district. The current statute prevents commissions from choosing their own legal counsel when they believe a conflict of interest exists.
“The problem is particularly troubling because commissions are independent bodies that provide fairness to classified employees in hiring, promoting and rendering impartial disciplinary decisions on appeal. Their ability to remain neutral decision-makers is compromised when they must use district counsel when a conflict exists.
“Classified employees are hurt when commissioners are denied their right to independent legal counsel. Their jobs hand in the balance. If a commission believes there is a conflict on a personnel matter… [they should be permitted] to do their jobs as neutral, independent bodies.”
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
California School Employees Association (Sponsor)
California Federation of Teachers
California Labor Federation, AFL-CIO
California School Personnel Commissioners Association
California State Council of Service Employees International Union
Opposition
None on file
Analysis Prepared by: Michael Bolden / P.E. & R. / (916) 319-3957
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):