AB 2334: Subsurface installations: attorney’s fees and costs.
- Session Year: 2019-2020
- House: Assembly
- Latest Version Date: 2020-02-14
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Mar 16, 2020 | In committee: Hearing postponed by committee. |
| Mar 2, 2020 | Referred to Com. on JUD. |
| Feb 15, 2020 | From printer. May be heard in committee March 16. |
| Feb 14, 2020 | Read first time. To print. |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
Date of Hearing: March 17, 2020
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON JUDICIARY
Mark Stone, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 2334
Author:(Levine) – As Introduced Ver:February 14, 2020
As Proposed to be Amended
SUBJECT: Subsurface installations: attorney’s fees and costs
KEY ISSUE: SHOULD REASONABLE ATTORNEY’S FEES AND COSTS BE AWARDED TO AN EXCAVATOR THAT IS FOUND NOT LIABLE FOR DAMAGING SUBSURFACE INSTALLATIONS BECAUSE OF ERRORS OR OMISSIONS BY THE OPERATOR OF THE INSTALLATION?
SYNOPSIS
In 2018, the California Public Utilities Commission launched an investigation into the Pacific Gas & Electric Company’s field location and marking program. All utilities in California with subsurface infrastructure installations are required to participate in the Regional Notification Center System, whereby a party seeking to do underground excavation is required to notify proper authorities of their intent to dig, thus permitting utility companies to mark the location of their underground infrastructure prior to the commencement of construction. As a result of the California Public Utilities Commission’s investigation, significant deficiencies were identified in the Pacific Gas & Electric Company’s field location and marking program, including the failure to properly mark thousands of subsurface installations, forcing the company to settle with the Commission.
This bill seeks to protect excavators who are sued by a utility or other subsurface installation operator for damage to the installation in the event the damage was the result of the operator’s own errors. As proposed to be amended, this bill would provide reasonable attorney’s costs and fees to an excavator that prevails in a civil action when it is determined by a court that the subsurface installation operator’s own errors resulted in the damage to their infrastructure, thus reducing the cost burdens on excavators that are wrongfully alleged to have damaged a subsurface installation. The author notes that these fee provisions may be particularly useful to local governments and the heavy construction contractors they hire for public works projects the construction of which are frequently the impetus for this type of complex litigation. This bill is sponsored by the Southern California Contractor Association who highlight that the California Public Utility Commission’s investigation into the Pacific Gas & Electric company discovered more than 100 thousand instances of late or improperly marked subsurface installations. They believe that this bill will serve to reduce the cost of litigating legal disputes that result from operator error and relieve the expenses from their members. As currently in print, this bill is opposed by the Western States Petroleum Association who are seeking amendments to narrow the scope of the bill. While the proposed amendments discussed in this analysis are not the amendments proposed by the Western States Petroleum Association, the amendments do narrow the scope of the bill in a manner that would appear to satisfy some of the concerns expressed by the Association.
SUMMARY: Provides reasonable attorney’s costs and fees to a prevailing excavator who is found not liable for damaging a subsurface installation due to errors on the part of an operator. Specifically, this bill requires a court to award reasonable attorney’s fees and costs, including expert witness fees, to a prevailing excavator, if a court determines that an excavator is not liable for damages, replacement costs, or other expenses arising from damages to a subsurface installation due to an inaccurate field mark by an operator, or by a third party under contract to perform field marking for the operator.
EXISTING LAW:
- Defines the following:
- Excavator, generally, means any person, firm, contractor or subcontractor, owner, operator, utility, association, corporation, partnership, business trust, public agency, or other entity that, with their, or his or her, own employees or equipment performs any excavation;
- Excavation means any operation in which earth, rock, or other material in the ground is moved, removed, or otherwise displaced by means of tools, equipment, or explosives in any of the following ways: grading, trenching, digging, ditching, drilling, augering, tunneling, scraping, cable or pipe plowing and driving, or any other way;
- Operator means any person, corporation, partnership, business trust, public agency, or other entity that owns, operates, or maintains a subsurface installation;
- Regional notification center means a nonprofit association or other organization of operators of subsurface installations that provides advance warning of excavations or other work close to existing subsurface installations, for the purpose of protecting those installations from damage, removal, relocation, or repair;
- Subsurface installation means any underground pipeline, conduit, duct, wire, or other structure, except nonpressurized sewerlines, nonpressurized storm drains, or other nonpressurized drain lines; and
- Ticket means an excavation location request issued a number by the regional notification center. (Government Code Section 4216.)
- Provides that a tolerance zone is 24 inches on each side of the field marking placed by the operator in one of the following ways:
- Twenty-four inches from each side of a single marking, assumed to be the centerline of the subsurface installation;
- Twenty-four inches plus one-half the specified size on each side of a single marking with the size of installation specified; and
- Twenty-four inches from each outside marking that graphically shows the width of the outside surface of the subsurface installation on a horizontal plane. (Government Code Section 4216 (u).)
- Provides that an excavator, as defined in 1), does not include any of the following:
- An owner of real property who contracts for an excavation project, not requiring a permit issued by a state or local agency, with a licensed contractor or subcontractor;
- An owner of residential real property, not engaged as a contractor or subcontractor, who as part of improving his or her principal residence or appurtenances thereto is performing or having performed excavation work not requiring a permit issued by a state or local agency; and
- Any person or private entity that leases or rents power operated or power-driven excavating or boring equipment, regardless of whether an equipment operator is provided for that piece of equipment or not, to a contractor or subcontractor if the signed rental agreement between the person or private entity and the contractor or subcontractor contains a liability waiver, as specified. (Government Code Section 4216.8.)
- Requires every operator of a subsurface installation, except the Department of Transportation, to become a member of, participate in, and share in the costs of, a regional notification center. Operators of subsurface installations who are members of, participate in, and share in, the costs of a regional notification center, including, but not limited to, the Underground Service Alert—Northern California or the Underground Service Alert—Southern California are deemed to be in compliance with the law. (Government Code Section 4216.1.)
- Requires an excavator planning to conduct an excavation to notify the appropriate regional notification center of the excavator’s intent to excavate at least two working days, and not more than 14 calendar days, before beginning that excavation. States that the date of the notification does not count as part of the two-working-day notice and provides that if an excavator gives less notice than the legal excavation start date and time and the excavation is not an emergency, the regional notification center will take the information and provide a ticket, but an operator has until the legal excavation start date and time to respond. (Government Code Section 4216.2.)
- Provides that an operator must do one of the following prior to the legal excavation start date and time:
- Locate and field mark within the area delineated for excavation and, where multiple subsurface installations of the same type are known to exist together, mark the number of subsurface installations;
- To the extent and degree of accuracy that the information is available, provide information to an excavator where the operator’s active or inactive subsurface installations are located; or
- Advise the excavator it operates no subsurface installations in the area delineated for excavation. (Government Code Section 4216.3 (a).)
- Requires an excavator, if the field marks are no longer reasonably visible, to renotify the regional notification center with a request for remarks that can be visible for all or a portion of the excavation. Excavation shall cease in the area to be remarked. If the delineation markings are no longer reasonably visible, the excavator shall redelineate the area to be remarked. If remarks are requested, the operator shall have two working days, not including the date of request, to remark the subsurface installation. If the area to be remarked is not the full extent of the original excavation, the excavator shall delineate the portion to be remarked and provide a description of the area requested to be remarked on the ticket. The excavator shall provide a description for the area to be remarked that falls within the area of the original location request. (Government Code Section 4216.3 (b).)
- Provides that if an excavation is within the tolerance zone of a subsurface installation, the excavator must determine the exact location of the subsurface installations in conflict with the excavation using hand tools before using any power-driven excavation or boring equipment within the tolerance zone of the subsurface installations and provides that in all cases the excavator shall use reasonable care to prevent damaging subsurface installations. (Government Code Section 4216.4 (a).)
- Provides that if the exact location of the subsurface installation cannot be determined by hand excavating in accordance with 8), the excavator must request the operator to provide additional information to the excavator, to the extent that information is available to the operator, to enable the excavator to determine the exact location of the installation. (Government Code Section 4216.4 (b).)
- Provides that any operator or excavator determined to have negligently violated the law is subject to a civil penalty in an amount not to exceed ten thousand dollars ($10,000), and if an action was knowing or willful, the excavator or operator is liable for a civil penalty not to exceed fifty thousand dollars ($50,000). (Government Code Section 4216.6 (a).)
- Provides that the penalties in 10) may be sought by the Attorney General, the district attorney, or the local or state agency that issued the permit to excavate, for the enforcement of the civil penalty pursuant to this section in a civil action brought in the name of the people of the State of California. If penalties are collected as a result of a civil suit brought by a state or local agency for collection of those civil penalties, the penalties imposed shall be paid to the general fund of the agency. (Government Code Section 4216.6 (b).)
- Provides that in lieu of the notification and locate and field mark requirements of 5), 6), and 7), an excavator is permitted to contact a regional notification center to request a continual excavation ticket for an area of continual excavation. Requires the regional notification center to provide a ticket to the person who contacts the center pursuant to this section and shall notify any member, if known, who has a subsurface installation in the area of continual excavation. The ticket provided to the excavator must include the contact information for notified operators. (Government Code Section 4216.10.)
- Provides that if a subsurface installation is damaged by an excavator as a result of failing to comply with the provisions of 5), 7), 8), 9), or 12) or as a result of failing to comply with the operator’s requests to protect the subsurface installation as specified by the operator before the start of excavation, the excavator shall be liable to the operator of the subsurface installation for resulting damages, costs, and expenses to the extent the damages, costs, and expenses were proximately caused by the excavator’s failure to comply. (Government Code Section 4216.7 (a).)
- Provides that if an operator of a subsurface installation without a reasonable basis, as determined by a court of competent jurisdiction, has failed to comply with the provisions of 6) and 7) the operator shall be liable for damages to the excavator who has complied with Section 4216.2, subdivisions (b) and (d) of Section 4216.3, and Section 4216.4, including liquidated damages, liability, losses, costs, and expenses, actually incurred by the excavator, resulting from the operator’s failure to comply with these specified requirements to the extent the damages, costs, and expenses were proximately caused by the operator’s failure to comply. (Government Code Section 4216.7 (c).)
- Provides that an excavator who damages a subsurface installation due to an inaccurate field mark by an operator, or by a third party under contract to perform field marking for the operator, shall not be liable for damages, replacement costs, or other expenses arising from damages to the subsurface installation if the excavator complied with the requirements specified in 5), 8), 9), and 12).
- Defines “inaccurate field mark” to mean a mark, or set of markings that did not correctly indicate the approximate location of a subsurface installation affected by an excavation and includes the actual physical location of a subsurface installation affected by an excavation that should have been marked pursuant to but was not. (Government Code Section 4216.7 (e).)
FISCAL EFFECT: As currently in print this bill is keyed fiscal.
COMMENTS: Seeking to protect excavators, typically large public works contractors who dig around utility infrastructure, from mistakes made by a utility operator, this bill proposes to grant excavators reasonable attorney’s fees and costs if the excavator is deemed to not be liable for damaging subsurface infrastructure installations as a result of the operator’s delayed or mismarked utility infrastructure. The author notes that excavators are frequently local governments and other entities conducting critical public infrastructure projects. The author notes that even if a local government is ultimately found not liable for damaging infrastructure due to the error of a utility operator, the existing law still requires that government to expend significant costs to defend itself in court. Accordingly, in support of the bill, the author states:
AB 2334 authorizes attorney fees and costs to the prevailing party for claims arising from damaged underground infrastructure. It will increase the safety in excavation practices by providing downward pressure from utility company management to those individuals in the field locating and marking underground utility. This is accomplished by potentially increasing litigation costs for the parties. With the potential to pay for another party’s attorney fees at risk, parties involved in all aspects of underground excavation will increase their diligence when locating and marking underground utilities and how they excavate around them. This heightened level of excavation also increases the public’s safety.
Existing utility marking protocols are designed to protect infrastructure and keep the public safe. Significant portions of California’s critical utility infrastructure are located underground, frequently along public rights-of-way. This infrastructure, referred to as subsurface installations, includes underground pipelines, conduits, ducts, and wires. If damaged, this infrastructure can cause disruptions to utility service, are costly to replace, and pose significant risks to public safety. Accordingly, California’s Regional Notification Center System was created to ensure that construction work that would require digging could be properly apprised of the location of critical infrastructure. Accordingly, excavators (those performing the work) must contact the local Regional Notification Center between two and 14 days prior to beginning work. Once the excavator notifies the Regional Notification Center, the operator is then tasked with going to the construction site to locate and field mark the location of all subsurface installations.
Due to the significant need to protect infrastructure and public safety, the existing law requires excavators to continuously request new markings if a project goes on for a prolonged period of time. Similarly, if the markings are not properly visible an excavator is required to cease work and notify the Regional Notification Center and request new markings. Reflecting the serious need to all excavators to follow the procedures, the state imposes civil penalties of $10 thousand to $50 thousand for a violation.
California’s largest utility was recently reprimanded for failing to accurately mark utility infrastructure. In order for critical construction projects to proceed in a timely manner, the utility companies that operate subsurface installations play a critical role in the notification system. The operators are required to quickly and accurately mark the infrastructure on a site. Nonetheless, in 2018, the California Public Utilities Commission (CPUC) was forced to take action against the Pacific Gas & Electric Company (PG&E) for late and inaccurate markings of more than 150 thousand subsurface installations. (CPUC Investigation 18-12-007, Issued Dec. 14, 2018.) Furthermore, the investigation found that some within the company falsified records related to completed locate and mark work tickets. (Ibid.) As a part of the settlement with the CPUC, PG&E agreed to significantly increase staffing, strengthening training programs for staff assigned to the location and marking program, and require PG&E to conduct causal root cause analysis after any instance of damage to a subsurface installation to better understand the factors that contributed to it so that PG&E can work to address them. (Ibid.)
The existing law provides that in the event an excavator damages a utility operator’s infrastructure, it is liable for damages, unless damage occurred as the result of inaccurate markings. The author notes that when the utility company fails to mark their infrastructure properly and it is damaged as a result, the operator can still seek damages from the excavator and place the burden for legal costs of disproving the damages on the excavator.
This bill. Recognizing that excavators are forced to pay their own costs and fees in defending against a lawsuit instituted by an operator that mismarked the location of critical infrastructure, this bill will instruct courts to award reasonable costs and fees to a prevailing excavator if they are found not liable on account of improperly marked infrastructure. The bill explicitly includes the ability to recover expert witness fees, one of the larger potential costs in complex litigation related to the location of underground facilities and the conduct of an excavator. It should be noted that the bill only applies to prevailing defendants.
Proposed amendments narrow the focus the bill on protecting excavators. As currently in print, this bill would have awarded fees and costs to either party to a lawsuit and applied the bill to arbitration. In order to focus the bill on the issue of excavators that were sued despite the failures of an operator, the proposed amendments only award costs and fees to the prevailing excavator. Furthermore, in response to concerns raised by the Western States Petroleum Association, and the reality that many of these cases are outside the scope of a contractual agreement, the author is proposing to limit the bill to court cases only. It should be noted that in the event an arbitration agreement does not contain fee and cost sharing provisions, this bill would likely control the actions of an arbitrator. It is unclear if the amendments fully remove opposition, but the proposed amendments do appear to address most of the concerns expressed to this Committee. The proposed amendments will delete the subdivision (g) proposed in the bill as currently in print and replace that section with a new subdivision that would read as follows:
If a court determines that an excavator is not liable for damages, replacement costs, or other expenses arising from damages to a subsurface installation pursuant to subdivision (d), the court shall award reasonable attorney’s fees and costs, including expert witness fees, to a prevailing excavator.
Finally, the code section that this bill is proposing to amend is slated to take effect on July 1, 2020. The provision declaring the enactment date of this section is proposed to be deleted by the bill in print. Based on the guidance of the Office of Legislative Counsel, the proposed amendments will reinsert the enacting provisions.
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: This bill is sponsored by the Southern California Contractors Association, a group of contractors specialized in heavy construction. They highlight the issues that arose with PG&E, and in support of the bill state:
The bill arose from contractor experiences in excavating around underground utilities and the California Public Utility Commission’s investigation into one investor owned utility company that found it had recorded and reported 135,137 requests to mark underground utility infrastructure as “on-time” but were actually late and in violation of the law.
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION: As noted the Western States Petroleum Association opposes the bill in print and seeks amendments to narrow the bill. Although the proposed amendments appear to address many of the Association’s concerns, it is unclear if they will fully address their trepidations with this measure. Regarding the bill as it is currently in print, the Association writes:
AB 2334 unnecessarily limits the court’s discretion in determining remedies related to cases involving damage incurred to subsurface installations during excavation activities. The bill also lacks reasonable boundaries related to the amount of attorney’s fees a party may be mandated to pay and improperly mandates the outcome of arbitration proceedings in these types of matters.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
Southern California Contractors Association
Opposition
Western States Petroleum Association (unless amended)
Analysis Prepared by: Nicholas Liedtke / JUD. / (916) 319-2334
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):