AB 2442: Social media platforms: false information.
- Session Year: 2019-2020
- House: Assembly
- Latest Version Date: 2020-07-14
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Jul 14, 2020 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to committee. Read second time, amended, and re-referred to Com. on JUD. |
| Jul 1, 2020 | Referred to Com. on JUD. |
| Jun 11, 2020 | In Senate. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. |
| Jun 11, 2020 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Senate. (Ayes 56. Noes 17. Page 4820.) |
| Jun 1, 2020 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| May 28, 2020 | Read second time and amended. Ordered returned to second reading. |
| May 27, 2020 | From committee: Amend, and do pass as amended. (Ayes 7. Noes 2.) (May 27). |
| May 7, 2020 | In committee: Hearing postponed by committee. |
| May 5, 2020 | Re-referred to Com. on JUD. |
| May 4, 2020 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to Com. on JUD. Read second time and amended. |
| Mar 17, 2020 | In committee: Hearing postponed by committee. |
| Mar 2, 2020 | Referred to Coms. on JUD. and A.,E.,S.,T., & I.M. |
| Feb 20, 2020 | From printer. May be heard in committee March 21. |
| Feb 19, 2020 | Read first time. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Jun 11, 2020 | AB 2442 Chau Assembly Third Reading | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| May 27, 2020 | Do pass as amended. | Assembly Standing Committee on Judiciary |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
ASSEMBLY THIRD READING
ATR Bill Id:AB 2442
Author:(Chau)
As Amended Ver:May 28, 2020
Majority vote
SUMMARY:
Requires a person or entity [person] that operates a social media platform to disclose whether or not the social media platform has a policy to address the spread of misinformation.
Major Provisions
- Requires a person who operates a social media platform to disclose whether or not the social media platform has a policy to address the spread of misinformation with respect to, at a minimum, all of the following:
- Intentionally misleading or inaccurate content purported as fact.
- Coordinated and deceptive promotion or suppression of information.
- Practices intended to materially and substantially manipulate or disrupt the behavior of users on the social media platform.
- Requires a person who operates a social media platform to conspicuously make the disclosures in 1) above in both of the following ways:
- Upon initiation of use, or upon registration required for use, of the social media platform.
- In the terms of service maintained, and made publicly available on the social media platform, by the person.
- Provides that a person who operates a social media platform shall be in violation of this bill if the person, within 30 days of being notified in writing of noncompliance by any person, fails to comply.
- Defines "social media platform" for purposes of the above, to mean an internet platform through which users develop a persistent virtual network or community comprised of other users for the purposes of sharing information, ideas, news reports, and other content.
COMMENTS:
According to the author, this bill seeks to address a proliferation of "misinformation" in the age of social media which, according to the author, "came to a head in the 2016 Presidential election," apparently a reference to the reports that various groups posted false and divisive information on Facebook in an effort to affect the outcome of the election. As a more recent example, the author cites an "experiment" conducted by Consumer Reports (CR). CR set up an advertising account with Facebook under the name of a made-up organization called the "Self Preservation Society." The fake organization submitted seven paid advertisements to Facebook, all of which contained false and potentially dangerous misinformation about the coronavirus, claiming, for example, that coronavirus was a hoax, that social distancing did not stop the spread of the virus, or that persons under 30 years of age could not contract the COVID-19 disease, and so on. To CR's surprise, Facebook approved all seven of the ads for publication. (CR pulled the ads before they went public.) While CR conceded that its contrived "experiment" amounted only to anecdotal evidence, it nonetheless maintained that the experiment illustrated a serious problem. Not only is it apparently easy to post false and even dangerously misleading advertisements on Facebook, it is not clear what steps, if any, Facebook and other social media platforms take to identify false or malicious information or what, if any, steps it takes to prohibit or remove such information.
This bill seeks to address this lack of clarity by requiring the operator of a social media platform to disclose whether or not the platform has a policy to address the spread of misinformation. Specifically, the bill would require the disclosure to address, at a minimum, how the platform deals with intentionally misleading and inaccurate content, coordinated efforts to promote or suppress information, and efforts to "substantially and materially manipulate or disrupt the behavior of users" on the social media platform. Significantly, the bill does not require the social media platforms to adopt policies that address misinformation; rather, the bill merely requires social media platforms to disclose what, if anything, they do in this regard. For example, a social media platform could, in full compliance with this bill, disclose that it does nothing at all to remove misinformation and, instead, leaves it to users to discern and evaluate advertising and postings for themselves. The intent of this measure is, apparently, to promote transparency and provide users and, just as important, provide policymakers with a better understanding of what social media platforms do and do not do to address false information on their sites.
Disclosure requirement does not likely constitute "compelled speech." In its letter opposing this bill, the Electronic Frontier Foundation (EFF) contends that the bill's disclosure requirement raises "First Amendment 'compelled speech' concerns." This seems unlikely. While the First Amendment prevents the government from compelling speech just as certainly as it prevents the government from restraining speech, existing case law suggests that the First Amendment would not prohibit the state from mandating the kinds of disclosures required by this bill. Indeed, California has numerous statutes that require businesses to disclose information on their websites and elsewhere. For example, existing law has long required websites to post their privacy policy, and no court has held (in California or elsewhere) that this requirement constitutes compelled speech in violation of the First Amendment. Quite similarly, this bill would require a social media platform to post its policies in regard to its treatment of false or misleading content. The line of compelled speech cases have generally only invalidated requirements that force a person or entity to directly or indirectly endorse positions or ideas that the person or business objects to; that create a false or unwanted association with a group, movement, or set of ideas; or that force the person or entity to support a group or position with which it disagrees. (See West Virginia Board of Education v. Barnette (1943) 319 U.S. 624; Wooley v Maynard (1977) 430 U.S. 705; United States v. United Foods (2001); Boy Scouts of America v Dale (2000) 530 U.S. 533. See also Larry Alexander, Compelled Speech, 23 Constitutional Commentary 147 (2006) and Erwin Chemerinsky, Constitutional Law 3d Ed. (2006) 972-973.)
The requirement in First Amendment jurisprudence that a required disclosure must force association with a position or value that the regulated person or entity does not share is seen in the United States Supreme Court's recent decision in striking down the California FACT Act, which required "crisis pregnancy centers" to post notices about the availability of abortion services. While the state is free to require licensed businesses and services to disclose information to its customers, the Court found that the FACT Act was unconstitutional, as applied to the crisis pregnancy center, because it required them to advertise the availability of abortion services – "the very practice that the petitioners are devoted to opposing." (National Institute of Family Life Advocates v. Becerra (2018) 138 S. Ct. 2361.) There is nothing in this bill that compels a social media platform to associate itself with an idea, belief, opinion, or position with which it disagrees or does not want to be associated. If this bill required the social media platform to declare that information is false or misleading, this would arguably constitute compelled speech because it would force the platform to assert something with which it might not agree. However, this bill merely requires a platform to disclose the policy, if any, that they have freely adopted; it does not compel them to express or associate themselves with, a position, idea, or group with which they do not agree or prefer not be associated.
What duties do social media platforms owe to their users? While the bill in its present form does not require social media platforms to adopt policies to combat the spread of misinformation, it nonetheless raises several complex legal issues relating to the duty, or even the right, of social media platforms to police content. To the extent that advertisements placed on social media platforms are false, the person or entity that developed and paid for the ad is subject to existing laws prohibiting false and misleading advertising. (See Business & Professions Code Section 17500.) To the extent that postings – whether advertisements, news articles, or opinion pieces – tell falsehoods that harm a person's reputation, the person or entity making the posting would be liable for defamation, depending upon, among other things, whether the person defamed was a public or private person, and whether the subject matter was one of public concern. On the other hand, to the extent that social media platforms exercise their authority to police and remove postings, platforms have considerable (and some would say, troubling) power to control the flow of public discourse. To be sure, private social media companies, because they are not state actors, may control content without violating the First Amendment. However, the California Constitution, as interpreted by the courts, protects freedom of expression from private interference under certain conditions. (Pruneyard Shopping Center v. Robins, (1980) 447 U.S. 74.) Moreover, the state action required by the First Amendment would certainly be met if the Legislature, for example, required a social media platform to remove protected content. As noted, this bill does not go that far and, therefore, does not immediately raise these complex issues. Nonetheless, the subtext of the bill appears to be that "misinformation" on social media platforms is a "problem" which the Legislature has some obligation to address.
Definition of "social media platform." The author's office has informed the Committee that it used the term "social media platform" – as opposed to "social media" or "Internet website" – and defined it as they did in order to "narrow" the bill's application to those platforms which allow a group or community of users or members to share information and content, and therefore cover the most popular sources of news and content sharing, such as Facebook and Twitter.
According to the Author:
According to the author, this bill seeks to address a proliferation of "misinformation" in the age of social media which, according to the author, "came to a head in the 2016 Presidential election," apparently a reference to the reports that various groups posted false and divisive information on Facebook in an effort to affect the outcome of the election.
Arguments in Support:
None on file
Arguments in Opposition:
The Electronic Frontier Foundation (EFF) opposes AB 2442 "because it raises serious legal issues and may be unconstitutional . . . In addition to raising First Amendment 'compelled speech concerns' concerns, key terms in the bill are undefined, vague, or overbroad." EFF contends that the definition of "social media platform" is too broad and that the scope of platforms regulated under this bill "is unlikely to advance any legitimate legislative purpose." Similarly, EFF finds the term "misinformation" and related terms vague and "quite subjective." Finally, EFF concludes that "the First Amendment demands more clarity from bills that seek to regulate speech."
FISCAL COMMENTS:
None
VOTES:
ASM JUDICIARY: 7-2-2
YES: Mark Stone, Chau, Chiu, Gonzalez, Holden, Kalra, Reyes
NO: Kiley, Obernolte
ABS, ABST OR NV: Gallagher, Maienschein
UPDATED:
VERSION: May 28, 2020
CONSULTANT: Thomas Clark / JUD. / (916) 319-2334 FN: 0002791
Date of Hearing: May 27, 2020
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON JUDICIARY
Mark Stone, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 2442
Author:(Chau) – As Amended Ver:May 4, 2020
As Proposed to be Amended
SUBJECT: Social media platforms: false information
KEY ISSUE: Should a person who operates a social media platform be required to disclose whether or not the social media platform has a policy to address the spread of misinformation?
SYNOPSIS
“Misinformation,” the author contends, has “proliferated in the age of social media and came to a head in the 2016 Presidential elections.” Studies suggest an interesting paradox: Americans report that they are suspicious about the information available to them online, yet they also report that they obtain most of their news online, especially from news or advertisements posted on social media platforms like Facebook and Twitter. In an effort to combat the negative impact of false information on Internet-based social media, AB 2442 would require a person who operates a social media platform, as defined, to disclose to what extent, if any, the platform has a policy to address the spread of false information. The bill requires the platforms to conspicuously make these disclosures upon initial use, or upon any registration required to use the social platform. In addition, the social media platform must disclose its policy for addressing the spread of misinformation, if any, in its terms of service. A person would be in violation of the bill if, within 30 days of being notified in writing of noncompliance by any person, they fail to comply with the requirements of the bill. This author-sponsored bill is opposed by the Electronic Frontier Foundation on the grounds that it may unconstitutionally compel speech and because the broad definition of “social media platform” makes the scope of its application unclear. The author will take amendments in this Committee, reflected in the summary below. The amendments, however, will not likely remove the opposition.
SUMMARY: Requires a person or entity [person] that operates a social media platform to disclose whether or not the social media platform has a policy to address the spread of misinformation. Specifically, this bill:
- Requires a person who operates a social media platform to disclose whether or not the social media platform has a policy to address the spread of misinformation with respect to, at a minimum, all of the following:
- Intentionally misleading or inaccurate content purported as fact.
- Coordinated and deceptive promotion or suppression of information.
- Practices intended to materially and substantially manipulate or disrupt the behavior of users on the social media platform.
- Requires a person who operates a social media platform to conspicuously make the disclosures in 1) above in both of the following ways:
- Upon initiation of use, or upon registration required for use, of the social media platform.
- In the terms of service maintained, and made publicly available on the social media platform, by the person.
- Provides that a person who operates a social media platform shall be in violation of this bill if the person, within 30 days of being notified in writing of noncompliance by any person, fails to comply.
- Defines “social media platform” for purposes of the above, to mean an internet platform through which users develop a persistent virtual network or community comprised of other users for the purposes of sharing information, ideas, news reports, and other content.
EXISTING LAW:
- Prohibits a person from making or disseminating in any advertising, or in any manner or means whatever, including over the Internet, any statement concerning real or personal property or services that is untrue or misleading. (Business and Professions Code Section 17500.)
- Defines “libel” as a false and unprivileged publication, including by writing, printing, or picture, that exposes any person to hatred, contempt, and ridicule. (Civil Code Section 45.)
FISCAL EFFECT: As currently in print this bill is keyed non-fiscal.
COMMENTS: According to the author, this bill seeks to address a proliferation of “misinformation” in the age of social media which, according to the author, “came to a head in the 2016 Presidential election,” apparently a reference to the reports that various groups posted false and divisive information on Facebook in an effort to affect the outcome of the election. As a more recent example, the author cites an “experiment” conducted by Consumer Reports (CR). CR set up an advertising account with Facebook under the name of a made-up organization called the “Self Preservation Society.” The fake organization submitted seven paid advertisements to Facebook, all of which contained false and potentially dangerous misinformation about the coronavirus, claiming, for example, that coronavirus was a hoax, that social distancing did not stop the spread of the virus, or that persons under 30 years of age could not contract the COVID-19 disease, and so on. To CR’s surprise, Facebook approved all seven of the ads for publication. (CR pulled the ads before they went public.) While CR conceded that its contrived “experiment” amounted only to anecdotal evidence, it nonetheless maintained that the experiment illustrated a serious problem. Not only is it apparently easy to post false and even dangerously misleading advertisements on Facebook, it is not clear what steps, if any, Facebook and other social media platforms take to identify false or malicious information or what, if any, steps it takes to prohibit or remove such information.
The lack of clarity about Facebook’s policies emerged during an exchange about political advertising between New York Representative Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez and Facebook founder and CEO, Mark Zuckerberg, during hearings before the House Financial Services Committee last October. When asked if Facebook would remove an ad that targeted predominantly African American zip codes and contained an incorrect election date, Zuckerberg suggested that Facebook would prohibit or remove such an ad because it contributes to voter suppression. However, when asked if Facebook would prohibit an ad that falsely claimed that certain Republicans supported the Green New Deal, Zuckerberg responded that such an ad, even if clearly a lie, would not be banned or removed by Facebook. While there may be any number of justifications for treating the political ads differently, Zuckerberg did not explain what policy justified removing one ad, but not the other.
This bill seeks to address this lack of clarity by requiring the operator of a social media platform to disclose whether or not the platform has a policy to address the spread of misinformation. Specifically, the bill would require the disclosure to address, at a minimum, how the platform deals with intentionally misleading and inaccurate content, coordinated efforts to promote or suppress information, and efforts to “substantially and materially manipulate or disrupt the behavior of users” on the social media platform. Significantly, the bill does not require the social media platforms to adopt policies that address misinformation; rather, the bill merely requires social media platforms to disclose what, if anything, they do in this regard. For example, a social media platform could, in full compliance with this bill, disclose that it does nothing at all to remove misinformation and, instead, leaves it to users to discern and evaluate advertising and postings for themselves. The intent of this measure is, apparently, to promote transparency and provide users and, just as important, provide policymakers with a better understanding of what social media platforms do and do not do to address false information on their sites.
Disclosure requirement does not likely constitute “compelled speech.” In its letter opposing this bill, the Electronic Frontier Foundation (EFF) contends that the bill’s disclosure requirement raises “First Amendment ‘compelled speech’ concerns.” This seems unlikely. While the First Amendment prevents the government from compelling speech just as certainly as it prevents the government from restraining speech, existing case law suggests that the First Amendment would not prohibit the state from mandating the kinds of disclosures required by this bill. Indeed, California has numerous statutes that require businesses to disclose information on their websites and elsewhere. For example, existing law has long required websites to post their privacy policy, and no court has held (in California or elsewhere) that this requirement constitutes compelled speech in violation of the First Amendment. Quite similarly, this bill would require a social media platform to post its policies in regard to its treatment of false or misleading content. The line of compelled speech cases have generally only invalidated requirements that force a person or entity to directly or indirectly endorse positions or ideas that the person or business objects to; that create a false or unwanted association with a group, movement, or set of ideas; or that force the person or entity to support a group or position with which it disagrees. (See West Virginia Board of Education v. Barnette (1943) 319 U.S. 624; Woolley v Maryland (1977) 430 U.S. 795; United States v. United Foods (2001); Boy Scouts of American v Dale (2000) 530 U.S. 533. See also Larry Alexander, Compelled Speech, 23 Constitutional Commentary 147 (2006) and Erwin Chemerinsky, Constitutional Law 3d Ed. (2006) 972-973.)
The requirement in First Amendment jurisprudence that a required disclosure must force association with a position or value that the regulated person or entity does not share is seen in the U.S. Supreme Court’s recent decision in striking down the California FACT Act, which required “crisis pregnancy centers” to post notices about the availability of abortion services. While the state is free to require licensed businesses and services to disclose information to its customers, the Court found that the FACT Act was unconstitutional, as applied to the crisis pregnancy center, because it required them to advertise the availability of abortion services – “the very practice that the petitioners are devoted to opposing.” (National Institute of Family Life Advocates v. Becerra (2018) 138 S. Ct. 2361.) There is nothing in this bill that compels a social media platform to associate itself with an idea, belief, opinion, or position with which it disagrees or does not want to be associated. If this bill required the social media platform to declare that information is false or misleading, this would arguably constitute compelled speech because it would force the platform to assert something with which it might not agree. However, this bill merely requires a platform to disclose the policy, if any, that they have freely adopted; it does not compel them to express or associate themselves with, a position, idea, or group with which they do not agree or prefer not be associated.
What duties do social media platforms owe to their users? While the bill in its present form does not require social media platforms to adopt policies to combat the spread of misinformation, it nonetheless raises several complex legal issues relating to the duty, or even the right, of social media platforms to police content. To the extent that advertisements placed on social media platforms are false, the person or entity that developed and paid for the ad is subject to existing laws prohibiting false and misleading advertising. (See Business & Professions Code Section 17500.) To the extent that postings – whether advertisements, news articles, or opinion pieces – tell falsehoods that harm a person’s reputation, the person or entity making the posting would be liable for defamation, depending upon, among other things, whether the person defamed was a public or private person, and whether the subject matter was one of public concern. On the other hand, to the extent that social media platforms exercise their authority to police and remove postings, platforms have considerable (and some would say, troubling) power to control the flow of public discourse. To be sure, private social media companies, because they are not state actors, may control content without violating the First Amendment. However, the California Constitution, as interpreted by the courts, protects freedom of expression from private interference under certain conditions. (Pruneyard Shopping Center v. Robins, (1980) 447 U.S. 74.) Moreover, the state action required by the First Amendment would certainly be met if the Legislature, for example, required a social media platform to remove protected content. As noted, this bill does not go that far and, therefore, does not immediately raise these complex issues. Nonetheless, the subtext of the bill appears to be that “misinformation” on social media platforms is a “problem” which the Legislature has some obligation to address.
If the bill moves out of this Committee, the author may wish to clarify the bill’s penalty provisions. The bill, as proposed to be amended, states that a social media platform violates the bill’s provisions if it fails to comply within 30 days after being informed by any person in writing, of its noncompliance. In short, the bill provides social media platforms with an opportunity to cure. However, the bill does not, in its present form or as proposed to be amended, create any penalty for continued noncompliance. Rather, by placing the bill in the Business and Professions Code, the author apparently assumes that a violation of its provisions would authorize any person affected by the violation and who notified the platform of the violation, to bring an action for injunctive relief under Business & Professions Code Section 17200, which defines any “unlawful” business act or practice as a form of “unfair competition.” An act of unfair competition generally allows for only two remedies: injunctive relief and recovery of actual economic damages. Since it seems unlikely that a failure of a social media platform to disclose its misinformation policy, if any, would lead to quantifiable economic damages, any relief provided under Section 17200 would merely take the form of a court-ordered injunction that the platform comply with the bill’s disclosure requirement, providing little incentive for the platform to comply with the bill in the first place.
Definition of “social media platform.” The author’s office has informed the Committee that it used the term “social media platform” – as opposed to “social media” or “Internet website” – and defined it as they did in order to “narrow” the bill’s application to those platforms which allow a group or community of users or members to share information and content, and therefore cover the most popular sources of news and content sharing, such as Facebook and Twitter. However, while the author sought a narrower definition, the Electronic Frontier Foundation (EFF), in its opposition letter, claims that “social media platform” is “defined very broadly,” and could encompass services beyond Facebook and Twitter, to include email and group communication tools such as Slack.
In fairness to the author, definitions of “social media” in existing law are hardly models of clarity and precision, when they are defined at all. A keyword search of the codes produces scores of uses of the term “social media,” but only a handful that provide a definition. The most common definition of “social media” states that it means some variation of “an electronic service or account, or electronic content, including, but not limited to, videos or still photographs, blogs, video blogs, podcasts, instant and text messages, email, online services or accounts, or Internet Web site profiles or locations.” (Education Code Sections 99120 and 49073.6; Labor Code Section 980; and Penal Code Section 632.01.) The only definition to reference “platforms” defines “social media” in a somewhat circular manner to mean “a service, platform, application, or site where users communicate and share media, such as pictures, videos, music, and blogs, with other users.” (Business & Professions Code Section 23353.3.) An “online platform” is defined to mean some variation of “any public-facing Internet Web site, Web application, or digital application, including a social network or publication.” In order to limit the scope of application, some definitions in the code restrict the definition by requiring a certain number of users. (See Business and Professions Code Section 17949, Government Code Section 84504.6.) The author may wish to consider such a limitation in order to reach the most popular social media, which appears to be the author’s primary concern, without having the overbroad effect about which the opposition cautions. Conversely, the author could define “social media platform” negatively – that is, to expressly exempt forms of social media, such as email or small group communication, that do not contribute to the problem that the author wishes to resolve.
Proposed Author Amendments: The author wishes to take the following amendments in this Committee. Although the amendments strike the content of the bill in print, the amendments are not as extensive as they appear, as the author is moving the substantive language, with some minor changes, into a new code section.
- Delete the contents of the bill in print.
- Add Section 22588 to the Business and Professions Code to read as follows:
22588. (a) A person that operates a social media platform shall disclose whether or not that social media platform has a policy to address the spread of misinformation with respect to, at a minimum, all of the following:
(1) Intentionally misleading or inaccurate content purported as fact.
(2) Coordinated and deceptive promotion or suppression of information.
(3) Practices intended to materially and substantially manipulate or disrupt the behavior of users on the social media platform.
(b) A person that operates a social media platform shall conspicuously make the disclosure required by subdivision (a) in both of the following ways:
(1) Upon initiation of use, or upon registration required for use, of the social media platform.
(2) In the terms of service maintained, and made publicly available on the social media platform, by the person.
(c) A person that operates a social media platform shall be in violation of this section if the person, within 30 days of being notified in writing of noncompliance by any person, fails to comply with the provisions of this section.
(d) For purposes of this section:
(1) “Person” means a natural person or a legal entity.
(2) “Social media platform” means an internet platform through which users develop a persistent virtual network or community comprised of other users for the purpose of sharing information, ideas, news reports, and other content.
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION: The Electronic Frontier Foundation (EFF) opposes AB 2442 “because it raises serious legal issues and may be unconstitutional . . . In addition to raising First Amendment ‘compelled speech concerns’ concerns, key terms in the bill are undefined, vague, or overbroad.” EFF contends that the definition of “social media platform” is too broad and that the scope of platforms regulated under this bill “is unlikely to advance any legitimate legislative purpose.” Similarly, EFF finds the term “misinformation” and related terms vague and “quite subjective.” Finally, EFF concludes that “the First Amendment demands more clarity from bills that seek to regulate speech.”
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
None on file
Opposition
Electronic Frontier Foundation
Analysis Prepared by: Thomas Clark / JUD. / (916) 319-2334
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):